Docstoc
EXCLUSIVE OFFER FOR DOCSTOC USERS
Try the all-new QuickBooks Online for FREE.  No credit card required.

Memorandum

Document Sample
Memorandum Powered By Docstoc
					MEMORANDUM

TO:            Mayor and Boise City Council

FROM:          Hal Simmons
               Planning Director
               Boise City Planning and Development Services

DATE:          May 26, 2009

RE:            ZOA09-00002 / City of Boise


City of Boise requests approval to modify various sections of Title 2, Chapter 18 including
the definition of change in use, pre-application meeting timing, addition of modifications and
findings for staff level demolition approvals.

The Historic Preservation Commission recommended approval of this application on April
27, 2009. There was no public opposition to the request.


TABLE OF CONTENTS
Page 2  Summary
Page 3  Recommendation
Page 4  Historic Preservation Minutes from April 27, 2009
Page 5  Historic Preservation Staff report
Page 16 Strike through zoning ordinance amendment
                                                                                    ZOA09-00002
                                                                                         Page 2


SUMMARY
City Council and the Historic Preservation Commission held a joint meeting on March 24,
2009. At the joint meeting the changes to the ordinance were discussed and generally found
to be in line with the goals of the city. The one area where some discussion took place was
the revised definition for change in use.

The change in use definition removes the Historic Preservation Commissions oversight of lot
line adjustments. State Code Section 67-4608 states:

   CERTIFICATE OF APPRORIATENESS. Except as provided in section 67-4607d.,
   Idaho Code, after the designation of a historic district, no exterior portion of any
   building or other structure (including walls, fences, light fixtures, steps and pavement,
   or other appurtenant features) nor above ground utility structure nor any type of
   outdoor advertising sign shall be erected, altered, restored, moved or demolished
   within such district until after an application for a certificate of appropriateness as to
   exterior features had been submitted to and approved by the historic preservation
   commission. The county of city shall require such a certificate to be issued by the
   commission prior to the issuance of a building permit or other permit granted for
   purposed of construction or altering structures. A certificate of appropriateness shall
   be required whether or not a building permit is require. For purposes of this chapter,
   “exterior features” shall include the architectural site, general design and general
   arrangement of the exterior of a building or other structure, including the color, the
   kind and texture of the building material and type and style of all windows, doors,
   light fixtures, signs, other appurtenant fixtures and natural features such as trees and
   shrubbery. In the case of outdoor advertising signs, “exterior features” shall be
   construed to mean the style, material, size and location of all such signs. The
   commission shall not consider interior arrangement and shall take no action under this
   section except for the purposed of preventing the construction, reconstruction
   alteration, restoration, moving of demolition of buildings, structures, appurtenant
   fixtures, outdoor advertising signs or natural features in the historic district which
   would be incongruous with the historical, architectural, archeological or cultural
   aspects of the district.

Additionally, State Code Section 67-4609 states:

   CHANGE IN USE. No change in use of any structure of property within a
   designated historic district shall be permitted until after an application for a certificate
   of appropriateness has been submitted to an approved by the historic preservation
   commission. The county or city shall require such a certificate to be issued by the
   commission prior to the approval of any change of zoning classification within the
   historic district.

Legal staff has stated they believe these sections to show the commission does not need to
approve a certificate of appropriateness prior to a record of survey or any other property line
adjustments as required under Title 9. The definition of change in use is proposed to state:
                                                                                 ZOA09-00002
                                                                                      Page 3

   A certificate of appropriateness shall be issued by the Historic Preservation
   Commission prior to the approval of any change of zoning classification within the
   historic district. A change of zoning classification refers to any application, for
   property located within a historic district, for a zone change or any application for
   addition, modification or deletion to an overlay district.

Much discussion has taken place on this issue. The main debate is whether the Historic
Preservation Commission should be issuing a certificate of appropriateness for lot line
changes.

Another item proposed for change in the Historic Preservation Ordinance is the timing of the
pre-application meeting. The wording is being changed to be consistent with the rest of the
planning applications. Currently applicants are having the pre-application meetings at the
time of submittal. They are not using the meetings to obtain input from staff and make
changes to an application for compliance with the ordinance and guidelines. The change in
language to this section will require the applicant to hold the meeting with staff a minimum
of one day prior to application submittal.

The last two items are to allow for staff level modifications of applications as well as staff
level demolition approvals. The staff level modification of an application provides findings
for staff to make for approval of an application. The staff level demolition requests would
require the Building Official to find that there is a life safety concern with the building and
immediate removal is necessary.

The Historic Preservation Commission recommended approval of the zoning ordinance
amendment on the consent agenda.

RECOMMENDATION
Staff recommends approval of the zoning ordinance amendment as presented.
Historic Preservation Commission
Hearing Minutes of April 27, 2009

Commission Members Christopher Pooser, Chair, Scott Chandler, Cathy Sewell, Barbara
Present            Dawson, Betsy McFadden, Steve Smith, Liz Edrich and Amy Pence-
                   Brown

Members Present          Sarah Schafer, Matt Halitsky, Robert Lockward (Legal) and Nicki
                         Heckenlively
___________________________________________________________


ZOA09-00002 / City of Boise
Requests approval to modify various sections in Title 2 Chapter 18.

NO COMMISSION DISCLOSURES.

NO PUBLIC TESTIMONY.

COMMISSIONER CHANDLER MOVED TO APPROVE ZOA09-00002, ZOA09-
00003, DRH09-00052, DRH09-00063, DRH09-00066, DRH09-00072 AND DRH09-
00073 ON THE CONSENT AGENDA.

COMMISSIONER SMITH SECONDED THE MOTION.

ROLL CALL VOTE 8:0. MOTION CARRIES.
                                                                                 4

Planning Division Staff Report
File Number           ZOA09-00002 / Ordinance Amendment to Title 2, Chapter 18
Applicant             Boise City
Public Hearing Date   April 20, 2009
Heard by              Boise City Historic Preservation Commission
Planning Analyst      Sarah Schafer
Planning Supervisor   Hal Simmons



Table of Contents

1. Executive Summary                                            2
2. Zoning Ordinance Amendment: 2-18                             2
3. Background and Analysis                                      9
4. Reasons for the Decision                                     10


Attachments
Underline/Strikeout version of amendment
                                                                         ZOA09-00002
                                       Historic Preservation Commission / April 20, 2009
                                                                                 2 of 11     4
1. Executive Summary
Boise City Planning and Development Services requests approval of an amendment to the
regulations associated with historic preservation (Chapter 2-18) of the Boise City ordinance.

The proposed changes to the Historic Preservation Ordinance will clarify sections of the
ordinance which was completely rewritten in 2006. Since the Commission has had a couple of
years to use the ordinance there are some changes which will aid the public and the Commission
in processing of applications. Changes are summarized below:

   •   Add “change in use” to the definition section and change the application of the term
       (Section 2-18-02)
   •   Clarify the local landmarks section in regards to state owned properties (Section 2-18-08)
   •   Modify the time of pre-application meetings with staff to be consistent with current
       planning requirements. (Section 2-18-10)
   •   Modify the language in regards to timing of the hearing to be consistent with current
       planning standards. (Section 2-18-10)
   •   Add modification findings (Section 2-18-11)
   •   Allow for staff level approval of demolitions when the Building Official deems the
       demolition necessary because of life safety. (Section 2-18-11.02)

Description of Applicant's Request:
Boise City Planning and Development Services requests approval of an amendment to the
regulations associated with historic preservation (Chapter 2-18) of the Boise City ordinance.

Staff Recommendation:
Staff recommends approval of ZOA09-00002.


2. Zoning Ordinance Changes
Section 2-18-02DEFINITIONS
For the purposes of this Chapter, the following terms, phrases and words shall have the meanings
given herein. Additional definitions may be found in the Design Guidelines for Residential
Historic Districts available in the Boise City Planning and Development Services Department.
In the event of a conflict the definitions in this ordinance shall take precedence.

                                              ***

CERTIFICATE OF APPROPRIATENESS:
The document issued by the Historic Preservation Commission for any and all alterations (not
including ordinary repairs per Section 2-18-12 herein) within a designated historic district.
                                                                            ZOA09-00002
                                          Historic Preservation Commission / April 20, 2009
                                                                                    3 of 11        4
CHANGE IN USE:
Any change in use affecting the land or structure where a Conditional Use Permit or
Administrative Review is required under Title 11, Chapter 4, B. C. C. (Zoning) or Record of
Survey required under Title 9, Chapter 20.

A certificate of appropriateness shall be issued by the Historic Preservation Commission prior to
the approval of any change of zoning classification within the historic district. A change of
zoning classification refers to any application, for property located within a historic district, for a
zone change or any application for an addition, modification or deletion to an overlay district.

CHARACTER DEFINING FAÇADE
Any elevation that contains features that helps to define a structure’s significance.

                                                 ***
Section 2-18-08 DESIGNATION OF HISTORIC LANDMARKS
Historic Landmarks shall be designated by ordinance and in accordance with the following
requirements:

       A.      The building, site, structure or object proposed for such designation shall meet
               one or more of the criteria required in Section 2-18-07 A. In addition, it must
               meet the criteria established for inclusion in the National Register of Historic
               Places as such criteria are applied to historic properties in the State by the Idaho
               Historic Sites Review Board.

       B.      The Commission, either on its own initiative, or upon the request of the City
               Council, or upon the request of the owner of the property proposed to be
               designated, may recommend the designation of an historic landmark. Prior to
               recommending the designation the Commission shall conduct studies, research
               and investigations based on the relevant criteria given in Section 2-18-08 A.
               Thereafter, the Commission shall prepare a report containing recommendations
               concerning the historic landmark proposed to be designated and a draft of the
               designating ordinance to the City Council. The report of the Commission shall
               include comments regarding the suitability of the historic landmark for
               preservation or restoration. In case there is a question of an adaptive or
               alternative use of the historic landmark, the report shall include a statement
               regarding the appropriateness of such adaptive or alternative use. The report shall
               also include a statement regarding the administrative and financial responsibility
               of the person or organization proposing to undertake all or a portion of the cost of
               acquisition, restoration, maintenance, operation or repair, or the cost of adaptive
               or alternative use of the property to the extent that any, such considerations apply
               to the property proposed for designation. If the owner of the property proposed
               for designation has not consented to such designation, the report of the
                                                                        ZOA09-00002
                                      Historic Preservation Commission / April 20, 2009
                                                                                4 of 11           4
           Commission shall also include a statement regarding the appraised value of the
           property.

     C.    For each designated historic landmark, the designating ordinance shall require the
           waiting period prescribed by Section 2-18-13 to be observed prior to its
           demolition, material alteration, remodeling or removal.           The designating
           ordinance shall also provide guidelines for a suitable sign or marker on or near the
           historic landmark indicating that the property has been so designated.


           1. For properties designated as a historic landmark and located within a local historic
           district, the portions of this ordinance pertaining to the districts, takes precedence over
           the 180 waiting period for demolition of the structure.


           2. For State or Federal properties which are designated as historic landmarks, the
           designation is an honorary effort and the City acknowledges that the repair, maintenance
           demolition or remodel of the structure is not within its jurisdiction.


     D.    The City Council shall hold a public hearing on the designating ordinance, after
           having given written notice to the owners and occupants of the property and the
           publication of such notice in the time and manner required by Section 2-18-07.

     E.    Following such public hearing, the Council may act on the designating ordinance.

     F.    Upon passage of the designating ordinance, the owners and occupants of each
           designated historic landmark shall be given written notification of said
           designation by the Council, and one copy of the designating ordinance shall be
           filed in the office of the County Recorder of Ada County, Idaho.

     G.    The Commission shall give notice of such designation to the Tax Assessor of
           Ada County, Idaho.

                                              ***

Section 2-18-10 APPLICATION REQUIREMENTS; NOTICE; ACTION; APPEAL FOR
COMMISSION AND STAFF LEVEL APPLICATIONS

     A.    Application Requirements

           An application for a Certificate of Appropriateness shall be submitted by the
           owner of the property, or by a representative of such person, on a form designated
           by the Commission and containing such information as required by the
           Commission.
                                                                ZOA09-00002
                              Historic Preservation Commission / April 20, 2009
                                                                        5 of 11       4

     1.     For applications that will be heard by the Historic Preservation
            Commission, the applicant is required to do the following prior to
            submittal of the application:

            a.     Not more than six (6) months, nor less than one day prior to
                   submittal of the application, hold a pre-application staff
                   conference(s) with the Planning Director and invited referral
                   agencies. The staff must complete a pre-application conference
                   verification form provided by the Director during the conference,
                   have the applicant sign it, obtain the Director’s signature, and the
                   applicant shall submit it with the application.

     2.     For all applications for projects located in an “H” or “HD” overlay zone
            that are also located within an adopted urban renewal district, such as, but
            not limited to, River Myrtle – Old Boise Urban Renewal District and
            Westside Downtown Urban Renewal District, the Capital City
            Development Corporation (CCDC) shall be provided with documentation
            two weeks prior to submittal for a Certificate of Appropriateness to allow
            for an opportunity to comment.

     3.     For any application seeking Demolition or Relocation the applicant shall
            provide the following:

            a.     A written statement as to why the building, site, structure or object
                   should be demolished.
            b.     Photographs of the building, site, structure or object to be
                   demolished, as well as of adjacent properties.
            c.     If the applicant wished to be considered for Finding D under
                   Section 2-18-11.02 Demolitions or Relocations – Findings they
                   shall provide the following additional information:
                   i.      Two (2) written reports, prepared by licensed design
                           professionals appropriate to the nature of the project, at
                           least one of which shall be disinterested, stating the
                           structural soundness of the building or structure proposed
                           for demolition and suitability for reuse.
                   ii.     An analysis of the cost to rehabilitate existing structure plus
                           construct the additional square footage and other goals of
                           the application. These costs shall be completed to the cost
                           of demolishing any existing structures and the equivalent
                           new construction by a licensed design professional
                           appropriate to the nature of the project.

B.   Hearings, Notification and Action for Commission Level Applications
                                                         ZOA09-00002
                       Historic Preservation Commission / April 20, 2009
                                                                 6 of 11     4

1.   Prior to approval or denial of a Certificate of Appropriateness, the
     Commission shall schedule a public hearing and fourteen (14) calendar
     days prior to the hearing, notice shall be mailed to the applicant, to the
     property owners and residents within 300 feet of the exterior boundary of
     the parcel under consideration and to the registered neighborhood
     association.

2.   The Planning Director shall post notice on the site in a location(s) that is
     visible from all adjacent public road right-of-ways or private streets not
     less than fourteen (14) calendar days prior to the hearing.

      a.    The size of the notice shall be 11” x 17”.
      b.    The notice shall contain the following information:
            i.     The nature of the application.
            ii.    The date, location and time of the hearing before the
                   Historic Preservation Commission.
            iii.   The contact person and phone number for inquiries
                   regarding the proposal.

3.   Action by the Commission

     The Commission shall make every effort to act on an application in
     accordance with the applicable findings cited in Section 2-18-11 within six
     weeks (42 days) after Staff has determined the required information has
     been submitted based upon published cut-off and hearing dates. An
     application shall be deemed to have been approved and a favorable
     Certificate of Appropriateness shall be issued by the Commission unless
     one of the following occurs on or before the 42nd day if;

     a.     A hearing cannot be held due to lack of a quorum;

     b.     If the Commission makes a specific finding at the public hearing
            that there is good cause to continue the application. Good cause
            includes, but is not limited too, lateness of the hour, or a
            determination by the Commission that the submitted materials are
            incomplete to make a well informed decision on the application.

     c.     Approvals - If the Commission determines the proposed request is
            appropriate, it shall approve such application with its reasons for
            the decision and any applicable Conditions of Approval and shall
            issue to the applicant a Certificate of Appropriateness.
                                                                ZOA09-00002
                              Historic Preservation Commission / April 20, 2009
                                                                        7 of 11      4
            d.      Denials - If the Commission determines that a Certificate of
                    Appropriateness should not be issued, it shall place upon its
                    records the reason for such determination and shall notify the
                    applicant in writing of its reasons and recommendations, if any, as
                    to what actions could be taken in order to obtain a certificate.

C.   Action and Notification for Staff Level Certificates

     1.     Within fourteen (14) calendar days after receipt of an application, the
            Planning Director shall investigate the request and shall either approve,
            modify or deny such application.

     2.     Notice: Within two (2) calendar days of the decision, the Planning
            Director shall notify, in writing, the applicant, property owners and
            residents adjacent to the parcel (including those properties across a street,
            alley, canal or other right-of-way) and the registered neighborhood
            association informing them of the action taken and their right to appeal.
            Notification shall be deemed complete on the date notice is provided to the
            U.S. Postal Service.

D.   Appeals

     1.     Appeal of Commission Level decisions:

            Any applicant or party of record aggrieved by a determination of the
            Commission may appeal to the City Council within ten (10) calendar days
            of the decision in accordance with Title 11, Chapter 3, Boise City Code.
            The decision is deemed to have been made on the date that the
            Commission adopts written findings of fact and conclusions of law. An
            appeal from the Council may be taken to a court of competent jurisdiction.

     2.     Appeal of Staff Level Decisions

            A decision of the Planning Director may be appealed to the Commission
            within ten (10) calendar days from the date the notice is mailed in
            accordance with Title 11, Chapter 3, Boise City Code. The applicant may
            request a waiver of the ten (10) day appeal period for staff level approvals
            if the request is made in writing and accompanied by the signatures of all
            adjacent property owners and residents and a representative of the
            registered neighborhood association indicating that they do not object to
            the waiver request. The Planning Director shall review all pertinent
            information and issue a decision on the request.
                                                                           ZOA09-00002
                                         Historic Preservation Commission / April 20, 2009
                                                                                   8 of 11      4
       E.      Term of Approval

               The term of approval for a Certificate of Appropriateness shall be eighteen (18)
               months from the date the approval was granted. In order for a Certificate of
               Appropriateness to remain valid, the holder of the Certificate of Appropriateness
               shall have either begun the work or use specified in the Certificate of
               Appropriateness or received a time extension for an unexpired permit from the
               Historic Preservation Commission or Staff for Staff Level approvals. A time
               extension may be granted up to one year at a time with a total of three such
               extensions.

                                               ***
Section 2-18-11FINDINGS FOR GRANTING A CERTIFICATE OF APPROPRIATENESS
The Commission shall review each application with the findings outlined below as pertain to the
request for a Certificate of Appropriateness. The Commission may attach Conditions of
Approval to the application to insure compliance with the findings. Modifications to the
applications may be submitted and will be considered at a staff level. In reviewing the
modification the Planning Director will utilize the original findings under which the application
was reviewed to ensure the project still complies with the requirements for a Certificate of
Appropriateness.

               Section 2-18-11.01 Alteration - Findings
               Section 2-18-11.02 Demolition or Relocation - Findings
               Section 2-18-11.03 Change in Zoning Classification or Change in Use - Findings
               Section 2-18-11.04 “HD” Overlay Zone - Findings

                                               ***

Section 2-18-11.02 DEMOLITIONS OR RELOCATIONS - FINDINGS

In order for the Commission to approve a demolition or relocation request at least three (3) out of
the five (5) following findings must be met:

       A.      That the building, site, structure or object is not classified as contributing within
               the district as stated on the survey form on file in the Planning and Development
               Services Department.

       B.      That the building, site, structure or object cannot reasonably meet National, State
               or Local criteria for designation as an historic property.

       C.       That demolition of the building, site, structure or object would not have an
               adverse impact on the character of the district and/or the adjacent properties.
                                                                            ZOA09-00002
                                          Historic Preservation Commission / April 20, 2009
                                                                                    9 of 11       4
       D.      That the owner has reasonably demonstrated that rehabilitation of the building,
               site, structure or object would not be economically practical, realistic or viable
               based on review of the information required in Section 2-18-10 A shall to be
               provided by the applicant at the time the request for a Certificate of
               Appropriateness is submitted.

       E.      That plans have been submitted to redevelop the property if the demolition
               proceeds and such plans will have a positive effect on the district and/or adjacent
               properties. The size, scale, use, materials and/or overall design of the project may
               be considered as qualities for producing a positive effect.

In some instances a Certificate of Appropriateness for demolition of a structure may be granted
at a staff level if the following findings can be made:

A. The Commission has granted a partial demolition, has approved the replacement structure
and the plans for the replacement structure remain the same; and
B. The Building Official deems in writing that a full demolition is necessary for life safety and
there are no other cost effective alternatives.

                                                 ***
3. Background and Analysis
Section 11-08-04.01 states:
   This Ordinance may be amended whenever the Council deems that amendment is required
   for the public convenience or necessity, or for the general welfare. Any amendment shall be
   enacted pursuant to this section and for purposes of this Section, includes any measure to
   change district boundaries, establish or disestablish districts, to change district regulations, to
   add, repeal or amend district regulations, and to add, repeal or amend any other provisions of
   this Section or the whole of this Ordinance.

Staff believes, for the reasons stated herein, this amendment is necessary for public convenience
and is in the best interests of the general welfare.

After processing applications through this ordinance for almost three years, staff, the public and
the Commission have found a couple of areas which needed further explanation or would
provide for a smoother process.

The first change to the ordinance will be to move the definition of “change in use” from the
section that provides the findings to the definition section. Additionally, we will be redefining
what a change in use is for historic preservation in order to be in compliance with state code.
The definition currently requires the Commission to make findings when and staff level
application is required per Title 11 Chapter 4 or a record of survey is required by the subdivision
ordinance. Current legal staff believes this may overstep our statutory authority. The proposed
definition more accurately reflects the language of state code which is,
                                                                          ZOA09-00002
                                        Historic Preservation Commission / April 20, 2009
                                                                                 10 of 11      4

   Change in use. No change in the use of any structure of property within a designated historic
   district shall be permitted until after an application for a certificate of appropriateness has
   been submitted to and approved by the historic preservation commission. The county or city
   shall require such a certificate to be issued by the commission prior to the approval of any
   change of zoning classification within the historic district. (State Code 67-4609)

Staff believes the proposed amendment changing the language to require a certificate of
appropriateness for a zone change or an addition, modification or deletion of an overlay zone
more accurately reflects the intent of state code.

The changes to the local landmark section of the ordinance include a clarification of the
requirements for a local landmark within a local historic district as well as the implications of
local landmark status on a state owned property. With receiving the Preserve America grant to
landmark up to 30 properties within the City, further clarification of the ordinance was needed in
order to direct staff and property owners on projects. The ordinance amendment for this section
states the local historic district requirements take precedence over the local landmark
requirements for demolition. The state owned properties are not governed by the ordinance but
need to be recognized as a landmark.

The changes to the ordinance requiring pre-application meetings to happen at least one day prior
to submittal will maintain consistency with the current planning submittal requirements. The
changes to the language regarding the timing of the hearings is for consistency with the zoning
ordinance.

There have been several application submitted over the last three years which could have
benefited from a modification application. Currently the historic preservation section does not
have a modification application. The addition of this section to the ordinance will allow for staff
to process some changes to applications without having to provide a completely new staff report
on an application. While incorporating this into the ordinance, the fees for the modification
application as well as for all of the historic preservation applications should be reviewed.

The last change to be incorporated with this ordinance amendment is the ability of staff to
process demolition applications at the staff level when the Building Official deems the removal
of the building necessary due to health and life safety issues. There have been a couple of
projects within the last three years which have required a full demolition but needed to halt
demolition, secure the components and return to the Historic Preservation Commission for
approval. This ordinance amendment will allow staff to take care of some demolition
application which may present a public hazard.


                                               ***
                                                                     ZOA09-00002
                                   Historic Preservation Commission / April 20, 2009
                                                                            11 of 11   4
4. Reasons for Decision
In accordance with the above discussion, Staff and Commission have found that the
proposed amendment will benefit the citizens of the City without having any detrimental
effect. The changes will provide clarification on processes more consistent with the
remainder of application submittals in Planning and Development Services and will allow
for quicker application processing on some demolitions with the Building Officials
signature.
                                          Boise Municipal Code


                                             Chapter 2-18

                            HISTORIC PRESERVATION COMMISSION
Sections:
2-18-01           PURPOSE
2-18-02           DEFINITIONS
2-18-03           HISTORIC PRESERVATION COMMISSION
2-18-04           ORGANIZATION; OFFICERS; RULES; MEETINGS
2-18-05           POWERS AND DUTIES OF COMMISSION
2-18-06           FUNDING
2-18-07           DESIGNATION OF HISTORICAL DISTRICTS, INCLUDING HISTORICAL
                  DISTRICTS - RESIDENTIAL
2-18-08           DESIGNATION OF HISTORIC LANDMARKS
2-18-09           CERTIFICATE OF APPROPRIATENESS REQUIRED FOR ALTERATION,
                  DEMOLITIONS OR RELOCATIONS, CHANGES IN ZONING
                  CLASSIFICATION OR CHANGES IN USE IN HISTORIC DISTRICTS OR
                  HISTORIC DISTRICTS-RESIDENTIAL
2-18-10           APPLICATION REQUIREMENTS; NOTICE; ACTION; APPEAL FOR
                  COMMISSION AND STAFF LEVEL APPLICATIONS
2-18-11           FINDINGS FOR GRANTING A CERTIFICATE OF APPROPRIATENESS
2-18-12           PROCEDURE FOR REMOVAL OF DESIGNATION FOR HISTORIC
                  DISTRICTS OR HISTORIC DISTRICTS-RESIDENTIAL OR PROPERTY
                  WITHIN SUCH DISTRICTS
2-18-13           PROCEDURE FOR DEMOLITION OR CHANGE IN USE OF HISTORIC
                  LANDMARK
2-18-14           ORDINARY REPAIRS; PUBLIC SAFETY
2-18-15           ACQUISITION OF PROPERTY
2-18-16           ACQUISITION OF HISTORIC EASEMENTS
2-18-17           MAINTENANCE AND REPAIR REQUIRED; DEMOLITION BY NEGLECT
2-18-18           EXEMPTION FROM FIRE OR BUILDING CODES
2-18-19           NOTICE OF CITY DEPARTMENTS AND OTHER AGENCIES; REGISTER OF
                  HISTORIC DISTRICTS AND LANDMARKS
2-18-20           SIGNS
2-18-21           PENALTIES

Section 2-18-01PURPOSE
The purpose of this Chapter is to promote the educational, cultural and economic welfare of the public of
the City by engaging in a comprehensive program of historic preservation to promote, preserve and
protect historic buildings, structures, sites, monuments, streets, squares and neighborhoods which serve as
visible reminders of the historical, archeological, architectural, educational and cultural heritage of the
City. It is the further purpose of this Chapter for the social, economic and environmental advantages of
the City to promote the use and conservation of such property, to stabilize and improve property values in
historic areas, and to encourage new buildings and developments that will be harmonious with the
existing historical, archeological, architectural, educational and cultural buildings, structures, sites,
streets, squares and neighborhoods.
(6602, Repealed & Replaced, 09/25/2007)




                                               Page 1 of 26
                                           Boise Municipal Code



Section 2-18-02DEFINITIONS
For the purposes of this Chapter, the following terms, phrases and words shall have the
meanings given herein. Additional definitions may be found in the Design Guidelines for Residential
Historic Districts available in the Boise City Planning and Development Services Department. In the
event of a conflict the definitions in this ordinance shall take precedence.

ACQUISITION:
The act or process of acquiring fee title or interest other than fee title of real property (including
acquisition of development rights or remainder interest).

ADDITION:
Any construction that increases the size of a building or structure in terms of site coverage, height, length,
width or gross floor area.

ALTERATIONS:
Any act or process that changes one (1) or more exterior features of a building or site. Construction,
replacement or erection of new buildings, structures, objects or improvements.

BUILDING (for purposes of designation):
A resource created principally to shelter any form of human activity.

CERTIFICATE OF APPROPRIATENESS:
The document issued by the Historic Preservation Commission for any and all alterations (not including
ordinary repairs per Section 2-18-12 herein) within a designated historic district.

CHANGE IN USE:
Any change in use affecting the land or structure where a Conditional Use Permit or Administrative
Review is required under Title 11, Chapter 4, B. C. C. (Zoning) or Record of Survey required under Title
9, Chapter 20.

A certificate of appropriateness shall be issued by the Historic Preservation Commission prior to the
approval of any change of zoning classification within the historic district. A change of zoning
classification refers to any application, for property located within a historic district, for a zone change or
any application for an addition, modification or deletion to an overlay district.

CHARACTER DEFINING FAÇADE
Any elevation that contains features that helps to define a structure’s significance.

COMMISSION:
Historic Preservation Commission

COMPREHENSIVE HISTORIC PRESERVATION PLANNING:
The organization into a logical sequence of preservation information pertaining to identification,
evaluation, registration and treatment of historic properties, and setting priorities for accomplishing
preservation activities.




                                                 Page 2 of 26
                                           Boise Municipal Code

CONTRIBUTING:
A contributing building, site, structure or object adds to the historic architectural qualities, historic
associations, or archeological values for which a property is significant because (a) it was present during
the period of significance, and possesses historic integrity reflecting its character at that time or is capable
of yielding important information about the period, or (b) it individually meets the National Register
eligibility criteria. For inventory purposes, “primary” shall be used synonymously with “contributing”.
This classification has been designated through a survey and a formal hearing process.

DEMOLITION:
Any act or process that permanently, substantially destroys or razes any building, site, structure or object
in whole or in part.

DEMOLITION BY NEGLECT:
Any act or omission that destroys or contributes to the destruction of a building.

EXTERIOR FEATURES:
The architecture, color, size, location, type, style, kind, texture, design, general arrangement and material
of a building, site, structure or object including, but not limited to, windows, doors, light fixtures, signs,
appurtenant fixtures, streets, streetscapes, sidewalks and landscaping.

HISTORIC DISTRICT (referred to as “HD” overlay):
Any area designated as such by ordinance which includes or encompasses such historic buildings, sites,
structures or objects as the Commission may determine to be appropriate for historic preservation. Such
designated district or districts need not be a single enclosed area nor do the areas or sites have to be
contiguous to constitute a district. A district may include contributing, non-contributing or undeveloped
properties.

HISTORIC DISTRICT – RESIDENTIAL (referred to as “H” overlay):
An historic district that is predominantly of a residential nature. Non-residential structures may be
included within, and be a component part of a Historic District - Residential.

HISTORIC EASEMENT:
Any easement, restriction, covenant or condition running with the land designed and designated to
preserve, maintain and enhance all or part of the existing state of places of historical, architectural,
archeological, educational or cultural significance.

HISTORIC LANDMARK:
A district, site, building, structure or object that possesses exceptional significance in history, architecture,
engineering, archeology or culture at the national, state, or local level and has been designated as a
historic landmark through the public hearing process.

HISTORIC PRESERVATION:
The research, protection, restoration and rehabilitation of buildings, sites, structures, objects or districts
significant in the history, architecture, archeology or culture of the state, its communities or the nation.

HISTORIC PROPERTY:
A district, site, building, structure or object that is eligible for or listed on the National Register of
Historic Places.




                                                 Page 3 of 26
                                           Boise Municipal Code

IMPROVEMENT:
A valuable addition made to property (usually real estate) or an amelioration in its condition, amounting
to more than mere repairs or replacement, costing labor or capital, and intended to enhance its value,
beauty or utility or to adapt it for new or further purposes. Generally, buildings, but may also include any
permanent structure or other development, such as a street, sidewalks, sewers, utilities etc.

INTEGRITY:
The ability of a property to convey its significance; includes the concepts of location, design, setting,
materials, workmanship, feeling and association.

INVENTORY:
A list of historic properties determined to meet specified criteria of significance.

NATIONAL REGISTER:
The National Register of Historic Places. A list established by the National Historic Preservation Act of
1966 (as amended) and codified in 36CFR60 (as amended) of buildings, sites, structures, objects and
districts having local, state or national historical, architectural or cultural significance and considered
worthy of preservation.

NATIONAL REGISTER CRITERIA:
The established criteria for evaluating the eligibility of properties for inclusion in the National Register of
Historic Places. For further information on the criteria refer to the National Park Service website,
National Register of Historic Places (http://www.cr.nps.gov/nr).

NEW CONSTRUCTION:
Construction of an entire structure.

NONCONTRIBUTING:
A noncontributing building, site, structure or object may possess characteristics that make it important to
the overall historic character of the district such as, but not limited to, mass, scale, streetscape features,
setbacks or proximity to contributing structures. A building, site, structure or object within a district may
be noncontributing because (a) it was not present during the period of significance, (b) due to alterations,
disturbances, additions, or other changes, it no longer possesses historic integrity reflecting its character at
that time or is incapable of yielding important information about the period, or (c) it does not individually
meet the National Register eligibility criteria. A noncontributing building, site, structure or object that is
within an historic district remains subject to the Historic Preservation Ordinance. For inventory purposes,
“secondary” shall be used synonymously with “noncontributing”. This classification has been designated
through a survey and a formal hearing process.

OBJECT (for purposes of designation):
A construction primarily artistic in nature or relatively small in scale and simply constructed, such as a
statue or milepost.

PERIOD OF SIGNIFICANCE:
The length of time when a property was associated with important events, activities, or persons, or
attained the characteristics which qualify it for National Register listing. Period of significance usually
begins with the date when significant activities or events began giving the property its historic
significance; this is often a date of construction. The period of significance for each historic district is
described in each district's Statement of Significance which is available for review at the Boise City
Planning and Development Services Department.

                                                 Page 4 of 26
                                          Boise Municipal Code

PERSON:
An individual, firm, corporation, association, municipal corporation, or any other governmental or quasi-
governmental agency, or group or combination thereof acting as a unit, except that nothing in this chapter
shall be construed to allow the designation, regulation, conditioning, restriction or acquisition of historic
buildings, structures, sites or areas, or other properties or facilities owned by the state or any of its
political subdivisions, agencies or instrumentalities.

PERSON IN CHARGE:
The person or persons possessed of the freehold, or a mortgagee or vendee in possession, assignee of
rents, receiver, executor, trustee, lessee, agent or any person directly or indirectly in control of a historic
property.

PLANNING DIRECTOR:
The Planning Director of the Boise City Planning Division of the Planning and Development Services
Department charged with the administration of the City’s planning and zoning documents, including
those pertaining to historic preservation. The Director serves as the Secretary to the Planning and Zoning
Commission and is directly responsible to the Director of the Planning and Development Services
Department. This definition includes the Planning Director’s designated representative, also referred to in
this ordinance as Planning Staff. This definition also includes references to the Planning Administrator,
Planning Official and other similar titles.

PRESERVATION:
The act or process of applying measures necessary to sustain the existing form, integrity and materials of
an historic property. Work, including preliminary measures to protect and stabilize the property,
generally focuses upon the ongoing maintenance and repair of historic materials and features rather than
extensive replacement and new construction. New exterior additions are not within the scope of this
treatment; however, the limited and sensitive upgrading of mechanical, electrical and plumbing systems
and other code-required work to make properties functional is appropriate within a preservation project.

PRIMARY FAÇADE:
The elevation that most characterizes a structure’s significance; usually the front elevation.

PROPERTY:
Land and that which is erected or affixed to the land. Real property extends to rights issuing out of,
annexed to and exercisable within or about land. Property includes historic property as defined herein.

RECONSTRUCTION:
The act or process of depicting, by means of new construction, the form, features and detailing of a non-
surviving building, site, structure or object for the purpose of replicating its appearance at a specific
period of time and in its historic location.

REHABILITATION:
The act or process of making possible a compatible use for a property through repair, alterations and
additions while preserving those portions or features which convey its historical, cultural or architectural
values.

RESTORATION:
The act or process of accurately depicting the form, features, and character of a property as it appeared at
a particular period of time by means of the removal of features from other periods in its history and
reconstruction of missing features from the restoration period. The limited and sensitive upgrading of
mechanical, electrical, and plumbing systems and other code-required work to make properties functional
is appropriate within a restoration project.
                                                Page 5 of 26
                                             Boise Municipal Code


SECRETARY OF THE INTERIOR’S STANDARDS FOR REHABILITATION: Standards that
were written pursuant to Federal Law to insure that work on historic buildings is done in such a manner
which preserves the historical integrity of the building. For further information refer to the Secretary of
the Interior’s Standards for the Treatment of Historic Properties with Guidelines for Preserving,
Rehabilitating, Restoring & Reconstructing Historic Buildings and the Boise City Residential Design
Guidelines both available in the Boise City Planning and Development Services Department.

SITE (for purposes of designation):
Location of a significant event, a prehistoric or historic occupation or activity, or a building or structure,
whether standing, ruined or vanished, where the location itself possesses historic, cultural or archeological
value regardless of the value of any existing structures.

SITE IMPROVEMENTS:
A modification to the grounds of a property not including the buildings or other significant structures
such as garages. Such improvements may include, but are not limited to: fences, walls, greenhouses,
storage sheds, light fixtures, hot tubs, swimming pools, fountains, barbeques, out-door fireplaces,
playground equipment, steps or pavement.

STRUCTURE (for purposes of designation):
A functional construction made for purposes other than creating shelter, such as, but not limited to, a
bridge, canal or dam.

STRUCTURE (for all other purposes):
Anything constructed or erected which requires permanent location on the ground or is attached to
something having location on the ground. Structures may include, but are not limited to buildings,
platforms, framework, antennas and prefabricated metal sheds.

SURVEY FORM:
A form that catalogues the age, style, contributing or noncontributing classification, address, location,
photograph, date of inventory, name of surveyor, building permit history and other relevant information
as may be required by the Planning Director or Historic Preservation Commission for a building, site,
structure or object.

TEMPORARY FEATURES:
Items that are erected or displayed for a limited amount of time, not to exceed 180 days at any one time
unless otherwise approved by the Planning Director, which may include, but are not limited to: sidewalk
café tables, chairs, fences, planters, umbrellas and bicycle racks.

TEMPORARY STRUCTURES:
A structure with or without a foundation that is erected for a limited amount of time, not to exceed 180
days at any one time unless otherwise approved by the Planning Director, which may include, but is not
limited to: playhouses and play equipment, mobile buildings and carport/canopy structures.
(6602, Repealed & Replaced, 09/25/2007; 5192, Amended, 10/03/1989)



Section 2-18-03HISTORIC PRESERVATION COMMISSION
There is hereby created and established an Historic Preservation Commission which shall consist of no
less than five (5) but up to nine (9) members who shall be appointed by the Mayor with the advice and
consent of the Council. Members of the Commission shall be appointed with due regard to the proper
representation of such fields as history, architecture, urban planning, archeology and law. In addition, one
                                                    Page 6 of 26
                                             Boise Municipal Code

(1) member may be, at the time of appointment, under eighteen (18) years of age. The youth member
shall be appointed to a term of up to one (1) year and may be reappointed to up to two (2) successive
terms. The remaining members of the Commission are eligible for reappointment as provided by Section
1-21-8 of the Boise City Code. If a vacancy occurs, the Mayor with the consent of the Council shall
appoint a member to fill the unexpired term. The members of the Commission shall serve without pay but
shall be reimbursed by the City for necessary expenses incurred in connection with their duties. A quorum
shall consist of five (5) or more members.
(6602, Repealed & Replaced, 09/25/2007; 6303, Amended, 02/03/2004; Ord. 5942, Amended, 09/28/1999; 5192, Amended,
10/03/1989)



Section 2-18-04ORGANIZATION; OFFICERS; RULES; MEETINGS
At their first meeting, the appointed Commissioners shall elect officers who shall serve for terms of one
(1) year. The Commission may establish any rules necessary for the orderly conduct of its business, and
all meetings of the Commission shall be open to the public. The Commission shall keep a record of its
resolutions, proceedings and actions.

The Commission shall provide public notice as outlined in the ordinance. A person may request notice
through electronic mail, and if so, it shall be in addition to the mailed notice through the U.S. Postal
Service.
(6602, Repealed & Replaced, 09/25/2007)



Section 2-18-05POWERS AND DUTIES OF COMMISSION
The Commission shall exercise to the fullest extent the authority granted under Title 67 (State
Government and State Affairs), Chapter 46 (Preservation of Historic Sites) of the Idaho State Code.
Duties shall include, but not be limited to the following:

         A.       Conduct a survey of local historic properties of the City;

         B.       Recommend the lease, sale, transfer or disposition of historic property subject to rights of
                  public access and other covenants and in a manner that will preserve the property;

         C.       Contract, with the approval of the local governing body, with the state or federal
                  government, or any agency of either, or with any other person, firm, corporation, or
                  organization, to accomplish the purposes of this Chapter;

         D.       Cooperate with the federal, state and local governments in the pursuit of the objectives of
                  historic preservation;

         E.       Participate in the conduct of land use, urban renewal and other planning processes
                  undertaken by the city or any other entity;

         F.       Recommend ordinances and otherwise provide information for the purposes of historic
                  preservation to the City;

         G.       Promote and conduct an educational and interpretative program on historic properties
                  within the jurisdiction of the City; and




                                                    Page 7 of 26
                                             Boise Municipal Code

         H.       Enter, solely in performance of its official duties and only at reasonable times, upon
                  private lands for examination or survey thereof. However, no member, employee or
                  agent of the commission may enter any private property, building or structure without the
                  express consent of the owner or occupant thereof.
(6602, Repealed & Replaced, 09/25/2007)



Section 2-18-06FUNDING
A.      For the purpose of providing funds for a Historic Preservation Commission, the Council may:

         1.       Provide funds from current revenues;

         2.       Receive and expend monies from any other available source or sources, or

         3.       Use any combination of the foregoing.

B.       Funds received for a Historic Preservation Commission may be accumulated from year to year
         and need not be expended during any one fiscal year, except that unexpended monies
         appropriated by the Council shall be deemed surplus to be budgeted and appropriated for the
         subsequent year as provided by law.
(6602, Repealed & Replaced, 09/25/2007)



Section 2-18-07DESIGNATION OF HISTORICAL DISTRICTS, INCLUDING HISTORICAL
DISTRICTS - RESIDENTIAL
Historic Districts shall be designated by ordinance and in accordance with the following
requirements:

         A.       Criteria for Designation

                  The buildings, sites, structures and objects of an historic district shall meet one of the
                  following three (3) criteria:

                  1.       Historical or Cultural Importance:

                           a.       Has significant character, interest or value, as part of the development,
                                    heritage or cultural characteristics of the city, state or nation; or is
                                    associated with the life of a person significant in the past; or

                           b.       Is the site of an historic event with a significant effect upon society; or

                           c.       Exemplifies the cultural, political, economic, social, educational or
                                    historic heritage of the community; or

                           d.       By being part of or related to a street, square, park or other distinctive
                                    area, should be developed or preserved according to a plan based on
                                    historic, cultural or architectural motif; or




                                                   Page 8 of 26
                              Boise Municipal Code

             e.      Owing to its unique location or singular physical characteristic,
                     represents an established and familiar visual feature of the neighborhood,
                     community or city; or

     2.      Architectural Importance:

             a.      Portrays the environment in an era of history characterized by a
                     distinctive architectural style; or

             b.      Embodies those distinguishing characteristics of an architectural-type or
                     engineering specimen; or

             c.      Is the work of a designer, architect or craftsman whose individual work
                     has significantly influenced the development of the city, state or nation;
                     or

             d.      Contains elements of design, detail, materials or craftsmanship which
                     represent a significant innovation; or

     3.      Archeological Importance:

             a.      Has yielded or may be likely to yield, information important in pre-
                     history or history.

             b.      Contains or is likely to contain physical remains, such as fossils, relics,
                     monuments, art or symbols, of past human life and activities.

B.   Commission Research and Report on Proposed District.

     The Commission, either on its own initiative, or upon the request of the City Council, or
     upon the request of one or more owners of property in the area of a proposed historic
     district, may recommend the designation of one or more historic districts. Prior to
     recommending designation the Commission shall conduct studies, research and
     investigations based on the relevant criteria given in Section 2-18-07 (A) regarding
     buildings, sites, structures and objects of such proposed historic district or districts.
     Thereafter, the Commission shall prepare a report containing recommendations
     concerning the area or areas to be included in the proposed historic district or districts.

C.   Transmittal of Report to Planning and Zoning Commission.

     Copies of the report shall be transmitted for review and recommendation to the Planning
     and Zoning Commission. Not less than sixty (60) days after the date of transmittal of
     such report to the Planning and Zoning Commission, the Historic Preservation
     Commission shall hold a public hearing regarding the proposed district.

D.   Notice Requirements for Historic Preservation Commission Public Hearing.

     1.      Notice of the time, place and purpose of such hearing shall be given at least
             fourteen (14) calendar days prior to the hearing by one publication in a
             newspaper of general circulation in the City; and


                                    Page 9 of 26
                                     Boise Municipal Code

          2.      Notice of the hearing shall be given to the owners of all properties to be included
                  in the district or districts and to the registered neighborhood association at least
                  fourteen (14) calendar days prior to the hearing.

     E.   Final Report to City Council

          After conducting the public hearing, the Commission may vote to proceed with the
          district, and shall submit a final report with its recommendations and a draft ordinance to
          the City Council.

     F.    Public Hearing by City Council.

          The City Council shall act upon the report and recommendation in accordance with the
          public hearing provisions of Title 11, Chapter 3, Boise City Code. Upon approval by the
          Council of the ordinance establishing the historic district, the zoning maps shall be
          changed to reflect the addition of the "H" historic overlay zone.

     G.   Notification of District

          1.      Upon passage of the ordinance, the owners of each property within the
                  designated historic district, and the registered neighborhood association shall be
                  given written notification of said designation by the Council.

          2.      The Commission shall notify City Departments and other agencies as required
                  under Section 2-18-19 of this ordinance.

          3.      One copy of the ordinance creating the district shall be filed in the office of the
                  County Recorder of Ada County, Idaho.

     H.   Register of Historic Districts

          The Commission shall maintain a register of historic districts as required under Section 2-
          18-19 of this ordinance.

     I.   Investigation or Report Updates

          The physical changes in the district that are approved by a Certificate of Appropriateness
          shall be added to the report/survey. Updates are not considered amendments to the
          historic district.

Section 2-18-07.01 PROCEDURE FOR RECLASSIFICATION OF BUILDINGS, SITES,
STUCTURES OR OBJECTS LOCATED WITHIN DESIGNATED HISTORIC DISTRICTS AND
HISTORIC DISTRICTS -RESIDENTIAL

     A.   Fifty (50) Year Time Passage: Any building, site, structure or object located within a
          designated historic district may on the Fiftieth (50th) anniversary of its original
          construction be deemed historic which may change the classification from a non-
          contributing property to a contributing property. Classification may be changed through
          a survey and public process as outlined below.



                                           Page 10 of 26
                                             Boise Municipal Code

         B.       Upon the motion of the Commission, or at the request of the Planning Staff, property
                  owner or applicant (with consent of the property owner if not the same), the Commission
                  may reclassify a building, site, structure or object within a designated historic district or
                  historic district - residential from non - contributing to contributing or from contributing
                  to non – contributing. Criteria for reviewing such changes in classification may include,
                  but are not limited to:

                  1.       Errors in Original Inventories - A building, site, structure or object may be
                           reclassified from non-contributing to contributing or from contributing to non-
                           contributing if the Commission determines that an error was made on the original
                           survey.

                  2.       Alterations/Additions/Restorations - A building, site, structure or object may be
                           reclassified from contributing to non-contributing or from non-contributing to
                           contributing if alterations, additions or restorations have been made so that the
                           classification prior to the change no longer reflects the proper classification after
                           the change.

         C.       Findings for Changes in Classification: The Commission shall approve a change in
                  classification based on the following findings:

                  1.       Whether or not the building, site, structure or object is eligible for the National
                           Register of Historic Places.

                  2.       Whether or not the building, site, structure or object contributes to the district.

         D.       Application Form: An application for a reclassification shall be submitted to the
                  Commission on a form designated by the Commission and containing such information
                  as required by the Commission.

         E.       Public Hearing/Notification: The Commission shall schedule a public hearing on any
                  reclassification under Subsection B. Notice of the time, place and purpose of such
                  hearing shall be mailed to all adjacent property owners and residents, and the registered
                  neighborhood association at least fourteen (14) calendar days prior to the hearing.

         F.       Any applicant or party of record aggrieved by a determination of the Commission may
                  appeal to the City Council as provided in Title 11, Chapter 3, Boise City Code.
(6602, Repealed & Replaced, 09/25/2007; 5660, Amended, 09/19/1995; 5192, Amended, 10/03/1989)



Section 2-18-08DESIGNATION OF HISTORIC LANDMARKS
Historic Landmarks shall be designated by ordinance and in accordance with the following requirements:

         A.       The building, site, structure or object proposed for such designation shall meet one or
                  more of the criteria required in Section 2-18-07 A. In addition, it must meet the criteria
                  established for inclusion in the National Register of Historic Places as such criteria are
                  applied to historic properties in the State by the Idaho Historic Sites Review Board.




                                                   Page 11 of 26
                                             Boise Municipal Code

         B.       The Commission, either on its own initiative, or upon the request of the City Council, or
                  upon the request of the owner of the property proposed to be designated, may recommend
                  the designation of an historic landmark. Prior to recommending the designation the
                  Commission shall conduct studies, research and investigations based on the relevant
                  criteria given in Section 2-18-08 A. Thereafter, the Commission shall prepare a report
                  containing recommendations concerning the historic landmark proposed to be designated
                  and a draft of the designating ordinance to the City Council. The report of the
                  Commission shall include comments regarding the suitability of the historic landmark for
                  preservation or restoration. In case there is a question of an adaptive or alternative use of
                  the historic landmark, the report shall include a statement regarding the appropriateness
                  of such adaptive or alternative use. The report shall also include a statement regarding the
                  administrative and financial responsibility of the person or organization proposing to
                  undertake all or a portion of the cost of acquisition, restoration, maintenance, operation or
                  repair, or the cost of adaptive or alternative use of the property to the extent that any,
                  such considerations apply to the property proposed for designation. If the owner of the
                  property proposed for designation has not consented to such designation, the report of the
                  Commission shall also include a statement regarding the appraised value of the property.

         C.       For each designated historic landmark, the designating ordinance shall require the waiting
                  period prescribed by Section 2-18-13 to be observed prior to its demolition, material
                  alteration, remodeling or removal. The designating ordinance shall also provide
                  guidelines for a suitable sign or marker on or near the historic landmark indicating that
                  the property has been so designated.

                  1. For properties designated as a historic landmark and located within a local historic
                  district, the portions of this ordinance pertaining to the districts, takes precedence over
                  the 180 waiting period for demolition of the structure.

                  2. For State or Federal properties which are designated as historic landmarks, the
                  designation is an honorary effort and the City acknowledges that the repair, maintenance
                  demolition or remodel of the structure is not within its jurisdiction.

         D.       The City Council shall hold a public hearing on the designating ordinance, after having
                  given written notice to the owners and occupants of the property and the publication of
                  such notice in the time and manner required by Section 2-18-07.

         E.       Following such public hearing, the Council may act on the designating ordinance.

         F.       Upon passage of the designating ordinance, the owners and occupants of each designated
                  historic landmark shall be given written notification of said designation by the Council,
                  and one copy of the designating ordinance shall be filed in the office of the County
                  Recorder of Ada County, Idaho.

         G.       The Commission shall give notice of such designation to the Tax Assessor of Ada
                  County, Idaho.
(6602, Repealed & Replaced, 09/25/2007; 5192, Amended, 10/03/1989)




                                                   Page 12 of 26
                                     Boise Municipal Code

Section 2-18-09CERTIFICATE OF APPROPRIATENESS REQUIRED FOR ALTERATION,
DEMOLITIONS OR RELOCATIONS, CHANGES IN ZONING CLASSIFICATION OR
CHANGES IN USE IN HISTORIC DISTRICTS OR HISTORIC DISTRICTS-RESIDENTIAL

     A.    Alterations in historic districts

           1.      General Rule:

                   a.       After the designation by ordinance of an historic district, no exterior
                            feature, as defined within this chapter, of any building, site, structure or
                            object (including, but not limited to, walls, pavement or other
                            appurtenant features), nor above ground utility structure nor any type of
                            outdoor advertising sign shall be erected, altered, restored, moved or
                            demolished within such district until after an application for a Certificate
                            of Appropriateness has been submitted and approved by the
                            Commission.

                   b.       A certificate will be required whether or not a Building Permit is
                            required, and a Certificate of Appropriateness must be granted in all
                            cases before an applicant can obtain any other permit.

                   c.       Confirmation of Classification - As part of the application process for a
                            Certificate of Appropriateness, the Planning Staff shall confirm the
                            contributing or non-contributing classification of the property based on
                            the criteria set forth in the definitions of Section 2-18-02. In the event
                            that the property's level of significance may have changed since the last
                            survey, staff shall prepare a report stating why the property should be
                            reclassified and provide a copy to the applicant. A change in
                            classification shall be subject to approval in accordance with Section 2-
                            18-07.01 by vote of the Commission prior to considering the applicant's
                            request for a Certificate of Appropriateness.

                   d.       The Commission may delegate to the Planning Director review of
                            Certificates of Appropriateness that are listed as “staff level” under the
                            Certificate of Appropriateness Matrix adopted by the Historic
                            Preservation Commission and are in compliance with the design
                            guidelines on file in the Planning and Development Services Department.

           2.      Exceptions: No Certificate of Appropriateness is required for the following
                   items:

                   a.       Interior arrangement of any building or structure.

                   b.       Temporary structures and features that do not remain in existence for a
                            time period greater than a total of forty-five (45) days in any consecutive
                            twelve (12) month period.

                   c.       A site or building improvement that does not require a certificate in the
                            Certificate of Appropriateness Matrix as adopted by resolution by the
                            Historic Preservation Commission and on file in the Planning and
                            Development Services Department.
                                           Page 13 of 26
                                             Boise Municipal Code


         B.       Demolition or relocation in historic districts or historic districts-residential

                  After the designation by ordinance of an historic district, or historic district - residential,
                  no building, site, structure or object which is a part of such district shall be demolished or
                  moved until after an application for a Certificate of Appropriateness relating to the
                  demolition or moving of such building, site, structure or object has been submitted to and
                  approved by the Commission. A certificate will be required whether or not a Building
                  Permit is required and a Certificate of Appropriateness must be granted in all cases before
                  an applicant can obtain any other permit required for the demolition or moving of any
                  building, site, structure or object which is part of an historic district or historic district -
                  residential.

         C.       Change in zoning classification or change in use in historic districts or historic districts-
                  residential.

                  Any change in zoning classification or change in use that requires a Conditional Use
                  Permit or Administrative Review as set forth in Title 11, Chapter 4, Boise City Code
                  (Zoning) or a Record of Survey as required by Title 9, Chapter 20 (Subdivision) within a
                  designated Historic District or Historic District - Residential shall first require approval
                  of a Certificate of Appropriateness.
(6602, Repealed & Replaced, 09/25/2007; 6602, Amended, 09/25/2007; 6447, Amended, 01/10/2006; 5802, Amended,
07/15/1997; 5192, Amended, 10/03/1989; 4443, Added, 09/04/1979)


Section 2-18-10 APPLICATION REQUIREMENTS; NOTICE; ACTION; APPEAL FOR
COMMISSION AND STAFF LEVEL APPLICATIONS

         A.       Application Requirements

                  An application for a Certificate of Appropriateness shall be submitted by the owner of the
                  property, or by a representative of such person, on a form designated by the Commission
                  and containing such information as required by the Commission.

                  1.       For applications that will be heard by the Historic Preservation Commission, the
                           applicant is required to do the following prior to submittal of the application:

                           a.       Not more than six (6) months, nor less than one day prior to submittal of
                                    the application, hold a pre-application staff conference(s) with the
                                    Planning Director and invited referral agencies. The staff must complete
                                    a pre-application conference verification form provided by the Director
                                    during the conference, have the applicant sign it, obtain the Director’s
                                    signature, and the applicant shall submit it with the application.

                  2.       For all applications for projects located in an “H” or “HD” overlay zone that are
                           also located within an adopted urban renewal district, such as, but not limited to,
                           River Myrtle – Old Boise Urban Renewal District and Westside Downtown
                           Urban Renewal District, the Capital City Development Corporation (CCDC)
                           shall be provided with documentation two weeks prior to submittal for a
                           Certificate of Appropriateness to allow for an opportunity to comment.



                                                   Page 14 of 26
                             Boise Municipal Code

     3.     For any application seeking Demolition or Relocation the applicant shall provide
            the following:

            a.       A written statement as to why the building, site, structure or object
                     should be demolished.
            b.       Photographs of the building, site, structure or object to be demolished, as
                     well as of adjacent properties.
            c.       If the applicant wished to be considered for Finding D under Section 2-
                     18-11.02 Demolitions or Relocations – Findings they shall provide the
                     following additional information:
                     i.       Two (2) written reports, prepared by licensed design
                              professionals appropriate to the nature of the project, at least one
                              of which shall be disinterested, stating the structural soundness
                              of the building or structure proposed for demolition and
                              suitability for reuse.
                     ii.      An analysis of the cost to rehabilitate existing structure plus
                              construct the additional square footage and other goals of the
                              application. These costs shall be completed to the cost of
                              demolishing any existing structures and the equivalent new
                              construction by a licensed design professional appropriate to the
                              nature of the project.

B.   Hearings, Notification and Action for Commission Level Applications

     1.     Prior to approval or denial of a Certificate of Appropriateness, the Commission
            shall schedule a public hearing and fourteen (14) calendar days prior to the
            hearing, notice shall be mailed to the applicant, to the property owners and
            residents within 300 feet of the exterior boundary of the parcel under
            consideration and to the registered neighborhood association.

     2.     The Planning Director shall post notice on the site in a location(s) that is visible
            from all adjacent public road right-of-ways or private streets not less than
            fourteen (14) calendar days prior to the hearing.

             a.      The size of the notice shall be 11” x 17”.
             b.      The notice shall contain the following information:
                     i.      The nature of the application.
                     ii.     The date, location and time of the hearing before the Historic
                             Preservation Commission.
                     iii.    The contact person and phone number for inquiries regarding the
                             proposal.

     3.     Action by the Commission

            The Commission shall make every effort to act on an application in accordance
            with the applicable findings cited in Section 2-18-11 within six weeks (42 days)
            after Staff has determined the required information has been submitted based
            upon published cut-off and hearing dates. An application shall be deemed to
            have been approved and a favorable Certificate of Appropriateness shall be
            issued by the Commission unless one of the following occurs on or before the
            42nd day if;
                                   Page 15 of 26
                             Boise Municipal Code


             a.      A hearing cannot be held due to lack of a quorum;

             b.      If the Commission makes a specific finding at the public hearing that
                     there is good cause to continue the application. Good cause includes, but
                     is not limited too, lateness of the hour, or a determination by the
                     Commission that the submitted materials are incomplete to make a well
                     informed decision on the application.

             c.      Approvals - If the Commission determines the proposed request is
                     appropriate, it shall approve such application with its reasons for the
                     decision and any applicable Conditions of Approval and shall issue to the
                     applicant a Certificate of Appropriateness.

             d.      Denials - If the Commission determines that a Certificate of
                     Appropriateness should not be issued, it shall place upon its records the
                     reason for such determination and shall notify the applicant in writing of
                     its reasons and recommendations, if any, as to what actions could be
                     taken in order to obtain a certificate.

C.   Action and Notification for Staff Level Certificates

     1.      Within fourteen (14) calendar days after receipt of an application, the Planning
             Director shall investigate the request and shall either approve, modify or deny
             such application.

     2.      Notice: Within two (2) calendar days of the decision, the Planning Director shall
             notify, in writing, the applicant, property owners and residents adjacent to the
             parcel (including those properties across a street, alley, canal or other right-of-
             way) and the registered neighborhood association informing them of the action
             taken and their right to appeal. Notification shall be deemed complete on the
             date notice is provided to the U.S. Postal Service.

D.   Appeals

     1.      Appeal of Commission Level decisions:

             Any applicant or party of record aggrieved by a determination of the Commission
             may appeal to the City Council within ten (10) calendar days of the decision in
             accordance with Title 11, Chapter 3, Boise City Code. The decision is deemed to
             have been made on the date that the Commission adopts written findings of fact
             and conclusions of law. An appeal from the Council may be taken to a court of
             competent jurisdiction.

     2.      Appeal of Staff Level Decisions

             A decision of the Planning Director may be appealed to the Commission within
             ten (10) calendar days from the date the notice is mailed in accordance with Title
             11, Chapter 3, Boise City Code. The applicant may request a waiver of the ten
             (10) day appeal period for staff level approvals if the request is made in writing
             and accompanied by the signatures of all adjacent property owners and residents

                                   Page 16 of 26
                                             Boise Municipal Code

                           and a representative of the registered neighborhood association indicating that
                           they do not object to the waiver request. The Planning Director shall review all
                           pertinent information and issue a decision on the request.

         E.       Term of Approval

                  The term of approval for a Certificate of Appropriateness shall be eighteen (18) months
                  from the date the approval was granted. In order for a Certificate of Appropriateness to
                  remain valid, the holder of the Certificate of Appropriateness shall have either begun the
                  work or use specified in the Certificate of Appropriateness or received a time extension
                  for an unexpired permit from the Historic Preservation Commission or Staff for Staff
                  Level approvals. A time extension may be granted up to one year at a time with a total of
                  three such extensions.
(6602, Repealed & Replaced, 09/25/2007; 6471, Amended, 05/23/2006; 5192, Amended, 10/03/1989)



Section 2-18-11FINDINGS FOR GRANTING A CERTIFICATE OF APPROPRIATENESS
The Commission shall review each application with the findings outlined below as pertain to the request
for a Certificate of Appropriateness. The Commission may attach Conditions of Approval to the
application to insure compliance with the findings. Modifications to the applications may be submitted
and will be considered at a staff level. In reviewing the modification the Planning Director will utilize the
original findings under which the application was reviewed to ensure the project still complies with the
requirements for a Certificate of Appropriateness.

                  Section 2-18-11.01 Alteration - Findings
                  Section 2-18-11.02 Demolition or Relocation - Findings
                  Section 2-18-11.03 Change in Zoning Classification or Change in Use - Findings
                  Section 2-18-11.04 “HD” Overlay Zone - Findings

The Commission shall find that the design of the project is consistent with the following plans and
             guidelines that apply to the property:

         A.       1993 Downtown Boise Plan

         B.       Urban Renewal Plans, including, but not limited to:

                  1.       River Myrtle – Old Boise Urban Renewal Plan
                  2.       Westside Downtown Urban Renewal Plan

         C.       Design Guidelines for Residential Historic Districts
         D.       Boise City Historic Preservation Plan (dated July 1979)
         E.       The Secretary of the Interior’s Standards for the Treatment of Historic Properties with
                  Guidelines for Preserving, Rehabilitating, Restoring & Reconstructing Historic Buildings
                  (The Secretary of the Interior’s Standards)
         F.       A Field Guide to American Houses by Virginia & Lee McAlester
         G.       American Vernacular Design 1870-1940 An Illustrated Glossary by Herbert Gottfried
                  and Jan Jennings




                                                   Page 17 of 26
                                         Boise Municipal Code

Section 2-18-11.01 ALTERATIONS - FINDINGS

The Commission’s decision in regard to Certificates of Appropriateness for alterations, as described in 2-
18-09 (A), shall be based on the following findings as applicable to that property:

        A.      That the request is consistent with the Design Guidelines for Boise City’s Historic
                Districts.

        B.      That the request is consistent with the Boise City Design Guidelines for Residential
                Historic Districts.

        C.      That the request is consistent with The Secretary of the Interior’s Standards for
                Rehabilitation, or other standards as applicable (preservation, restoration or
                reconstruction).

        D.      That the request supports the goals, objectives and policies of the Boise City
                Comprehensive Plan and the plans referenced therein.

        E.      That based on the adopted design guidelines the request will not be incongruous with the
                historical, architectural, archeological, educational or cultural aspects of the district.

        F.      That the request complies with the dimensional standards and other applicable
                requirements of Title XI (Zoning Ordinance) including, but not limited to, setbacks,
                height restrictions and parking requirements unless the Commission finds that modifying
                those standards is necessary to protect the overall characteristics of the district and to
                comply with the adopted design guidelines.

Section 2-18-11.02 DEMOLITIONS OR RELOCATIONS - FINDINGS

In order for the Commission to approve a demolition or relocation request at least three (3) out of the five
(5) following findings must be met:

        A.      That the building, site, structure or object is not classified as contributing within the
                district as stated on the survey form on file in the Planning and Development Services
                Department.

        B.      That the building, site, structure or object cannot reasonably meet National, State or
                Local criteria for designation as an historic property.

        C.       That demolition of the building, site, structure or object would not have an adverse
                impact on the character of the district and/or the adjacent properties.

        D.      That the owner has reasonably demonstrated that rehabilitation of the building, site,
                structure or object would not be economically practical, realistic or viable based on
                review of the information required in Section 2-18-10 A shall to be provided by the
                applicant at the time the request for a Certificate of Appropriateness is submitted.

        E.      That plans have been submitted to redevelop the property if the demolition proceeds and
                such plans will have a positive effect on the district and/or adjacent properties. The size,
                scale, use, materials and/or overall design of the project may be considered as qualities
                for producing a positive effect.
                                              Page 18 of 26
                                          Boise Municipal Code


In some instances a Certificate of Appropriateness for demolition of a structure may be granted at a staff
level if the following findings can be made:

A. The Commission has granted a partial demolition, has approved the replacement structure and the
plans for the replacement structure remain the same; and
B. The Building Official deems in writing that a full demolition is necessary for life safety and there are
no other cost effective alternatives.


Section 2-18-11.03 CHANGE IN ZONING CLASSIFICATION OR CHANGE IN USE -
FINDINGS

The Commission’s decision in regard to Certificates of Appropriateness for a change in zoning
classification or a change in use as described in 2-18-09 (C) above shall be based on the following
findings:

        A.      That the request supports the Boise City Comprehensive Plan goals, objectives and
                policies contained within Chapter 5/Parks, Recreation and Cultural Resources, and the
                applicable neighborhood plans.

        B.      That the request will be congruous with the historical, architectural, archeological,
                educational or cultural significance of the district.

Section 2-18-11.04 “HD” OVERLAY ZONE - FINDINGS

For projects within an “HD” overlay zone, the following objectives and findings, in addition to those
cited under Section 2-18-11.01, shall be considered where applicable to the proposal:

I. Objective - Site Design

The application shall be reviewed by the Commission to determine compatibility and impact both on and
adjacent to the site as it relates to access, parking lot design, landscaping, grading and storm drainage, and
other development of the site. To accomplish said objective, the Commission shall coordinate design
input and requirements from other agencies. The decision of the Commission with regards to site design
shall be based upon the following findings as they relate to historic preservation:

        A.      Finding: That the site design minimizes impact of traffic on adjacent streets and that the
                pedestrian and bicyclist have been provided for by requiring sidewalks, landscaping and
                safe parking lot design as appropriate.

                Considerations relative to Finding A:

                1.       The impact and effect of the site development plan on traffic conditions on
                         contiguous streets and adjoining properties or neighborhoods.

                2.       The layout of the site with respect to separation or integration of vehicular,
                         pedestrian and bicycle traffic patterns.

                3.       The design of off-street parking facilities as they relate to access points, building
                         location and total site development to prevent traffic conflict or congestion.
                                               Page 19 of 26
                                         Boise Municipal Code


                4.      The location, arrangement and dimensions of truck loading ramps, docks and
                        bays and vehicle service facilities.

                5.      The coordination of the site development with planned right-of-way alignments,
                        acquisitions and street improvements.

        B.      Finding: That the proposed landscaping enhances the historic district and neighborhood
                with attributes that include, but are not limited to, protection of desirable existing trees,
                provision of street trees and adequate screening methods where needed to buffer adjacent
                uses and unsightly areas or features.

                Considerations relative to Finding B:

                1.      The location, height and materials of walls, fences, hedges and screening
                        plantings to insure harmony with adjacent developments;

                2.      The planting of street trees and the unnecessary destruction of existing trees and
                        landscape features;

                3.      The provision of plantings or other screening methods reasonably required to
                        conceal outdoor storage areas, trash receptacles, exposed machinery installation,
                        service areas, truck loading areas, utility buildings and installations and similar
                        accessory areas or other unsightly developments;

        C.      Finding: That on-site grading and drainage have been designed so as to minimize off-site
                impact and provide for erosion control as required by the Boise City Public Works
                Department, Ada County Highway District and/or other jurisdictional agency.

        D.      Finding: That utility service systems and equipment do not detract from the building
                design or adjacent buildings, and the size and location of all service systems are
                appropriate and maintainable.

                Considerations relative to Finding D:

                1.      Electrical and telephone service systems shall be installed underground unless
                        deemed appropriate due to location or existing conditions.

                2.      The location, design and screening of transformers and mechanical and electrical
                        equipment does not detract from the design of the building or adjacent properties;

II. Objective - Structure Design

The design of all proposed buildings shall be reviewed in accordance with the Design Guidelines for
Boise City’s Historic Districts and/or Boise City Design Guidelines for Residential Historic Districts, as
well as the following findings:

        A.      Building Mass: The mass of the building shall be reviewed for its relationship to other
                buildings within the historic district and area, and with the use proposed by the applicant.



                                              Page 20 of 26
                                         Boise Municipal Code

        B.      Proportion of Building Facades: The height to width relationship shall be compatible and
                consistent with the predominant architectural character of the historic district.

        C.      Shadow Relief/Design Interest: The exterior of the building shall provide shadow relief
                and design interest compatible with the architectural character of the area.

        D.      Relationship of Exterior Materials: The appropriateness of materials and colors (paint
                colors are not reviewed for single-family residential structures) shall be reviewed as they
                relate to building mass, shadow relief and compatibility with other buildings within the
                historic district and area.

        E.      Multiple-family building (any building containing more than 2 residential units) must be
                designed to include features which add to the visual and aesthetic appearance of the
                structure and help prevent a sterile, box-like appearance. Such features may include the
                use of brick or stone, roof or facade modulation, planter boxes, bay windows, balconies,
                porches, etc. The commission must make a finding that specific design features have
                been added to enhance the physical appearance of such multiple-family residential
                structures.

        F.      Commercial/Industrial buildings adjacent to residential uses: That the building is
                designed to minimize impacts on adjoining (including across a street or alley) residential
                uses and/or residential zones.

                Considerations Relevant to Finding F:

                1.      Overhead doors for service and/or repair activities and loading activities are
                        located at the side of the building most opposite to any residential neighborhood/
                        dwelling or residential zone, unless it can be demonstrated that there are no other
                        viable options and there will be mitigation through use of walls, berms,
                        landscaping, etc.

                2.      Building walls that face residential uses or zones provide visual interest through
                        use of a variety of materials/compatible colors, fenestration (wall openings), roof
                        line variations, wall modulation and/or other architectural method that will
                        minimize blank walls.

                3.      Wall lights facing any residential use or zone are shielded to prevent glare or
                        light fall on the adjacent property. The Commission may require a reduction in
                        height of the lights on the building, or footcandles, if it is determined that the
                        proposed lights will have a negative impact on the adjoining properties.

                4.      Mechanical equipment on the roof, or adjacent to the building, shall be located in
                        areas that are furthest away from residential uses or zones, unless it can be
                        demonstrated that there will not be visual and/or noise impacts on the adjacent
                        properties due to screen walls, equipment design or other factors.

III. Objective - Adopted Plans and Design Guidelines

The Commission shall find that the design of the project is consistent with the plans and guidelines listed
in Section 2-18-11.


                                              Page 21 of 26
                                             Boise Municipal Code

(6602, Repealed & Replaced, 09/25/2007; 5192, Renumbered, 10/03/1989; 5192, Amended, 10/03/1989)



Section 2-18-12PROCEDURE FOR REMOVAL OF DESIGNATION FOR HISTORIC
DISTRICTS OR HISTORIC DISTRICTS-RESIDENTIAL OR PROPERTY WITHIN SUCH
DISTRICTS
After the designation by ordinance of an historic district, historic district – residential; or property within
such districts, such designation shall not be rescinded, except as hereinafter provided:

        A.       Application Form.

                 The owner or owner's representative shall submit an application for removal of
                 designation on a form designated by the Commission and containing such information as
                 required by the Commission, including, but not limited to, a detailed explanation as to
                 why the property (or properties) does not meet the criteria under which the district was
                 adopted as outlined under Section 2-18-07 A (1-3) of this ordinance. Nothing herein
                 shall prevent the Commission from initiating such removals as well.

        B.        Public Hearing by Commission and Noticing Requirements

                 Prior to approval or denial of the application for removal of designation, the Commission
                 shall schedule a public hearing on the request and notify, in writing, each property owner
                 within the affected District if for removal of the entire historic District or 300’ radius
                 from the property boundaries for an individual property removal within the district and
                 the registered neighborhood association at least fourteen (14) calendar days prior to the
                 hearing. Notice of the time, date, place and purpose of such hearing shall also be
                 published at least fourteen (14) calendar days prior to such hearing in a newspaper of
                 general circulation within the city.

        C.       Action by the Commission – Approval of the Request for Removal of Designation

                 If, in the judgment of the Commission, when any building, site, structure or object
                 included within a designated historic district, or designated as a historic landmark, has
                 ceased to comply with the designation criteria or no longer exhibits the characteristics
                 which qualified the property for inclusion within a historic district or for designation as
                 an historic landmark, such property or properties may be recommended for exclusion
                 from the boundary of such district, or if the district, as a whole, no longer complies with
                 such criteria, it may be recommended for rescission of its historic designation, or such
                 landmark may be recommended for rescission of its historic designation.

                 If the Commission determines the proposed removal of designation is appropriate, it shall
                 forthwith approve such application and shall prepare a report containing such
                 recommendation of removal of designation and a draft of a proposed ordinance removing
                 such designation to the City Council.

                 1.       Public Hearing by Council and Noticing Requirements

                          The City Council shall hold a public hearing on the proposed removal ordinance,
                          after having given written notice as outlined in 2-18-12 B above. The City
                          Council shall act on the report and recommendation in accordance with the
                          public hearing provisions of Title 11, Chapter 3, Boise City Code.
                                                   Page 22 of 26
                                             Boise Municipal Code


                  2.       Notification of Approval of the Removal Ordinance

                           Upon approval of the ordinance, the owners and occupants of the historic district,
                           historic district - residential or property within such district for which designation
                           was removed shall be given written notification of such removal by the Council,
                           and one copy of the ordinance shall be filed in the office of the County Recorder
                           of Ada County, Idaho. The Commission shall give notice of such removal of
                           designation to the Tax Assessor of Ada County, Idaho and to the Internal
                           Revenue Service, Boise office. The zoning maps shall be changed to reflect the
                           removal of the "H" historic overlay zone.

         D.       Action by the Commission - Denial of the Request for Removal of Designation

                  If the Commission determines that the application for removal of designation should not
                  be recommended, it shall place upon its records the reason for such determination and
                  shall forthwith notify the applicant of such determination and a copy of its reasons and its
                  recommendations, if any, as appearing in the records of said Commission.

                  1.       Appeal of Denial of the Request for Removal of Designation

                           Any applicant aggrieved by a determination of the Commission may appeal to
                           the City Council in accordance with the provisions of Title 11, Chapter 3, Boise
                           City Code.
(6602, Repealed & Replaced, 09/25/2007; 66602, Repealed & Replaced, 09/25/2007; 6602, Amended, 09/25/2007; 4443, Added,
09/04/1979)



Section 2-18-13PROCEDURE FOR DEMOLITION OR CHANGE IN USE OF HISTORIC
LANDMARK
An historic landmark designated by ordinance as herein provided which is not part of an historic district,
may be demolished, materially altered, remodeled, relocated or put to a different use only after one-
hundred-eighty (180) days written notice of the owner's proposed action has been given to the Historic
Preservation Commission in accordance with the following procedures:

         A.       During this period, the Commission may negotiate with the owner and with any other
                  parties in an effort to find a means of preserving the property. The Commission may enter
                  into negotiations with the owner for the acquisition by gift, purchase, or exchange of the
                  property or any interest therein during this 180 day period or any such action as is
                  reasonably necessary or appropriate for the continued preservation of the property.

         B.       The Commission may notify, in writing, property owners within a three-hundred foot
                  (300') radius of the historic landmark and the registered neighborhood association of the
                  request to demolish, alter, remodel, relocate or change the use of the historic landmark;
                  and may allow such owners and the registered neighborhood association to provide input
                  within the 180 day waiting period.

         C.       The Commission may reduce the waiting period required by this section in any case
                  where the owner would suffer extreme hardship unless a reduction in the required period
                  were allowed. The Commission shall have the discretionary authority to waive all or any
                  portion of the required waiting period, provided that the alteration, remodeling, relocation
                                                   Page 23 of 26
                                             Boise Municipal Code

                  or change of use is undertaken subject to conditions agreed to by the Commission
                  insuring the continued maintenance of the historical, architectural, archeological or
                  cultural integrity and character of the property.

         D.       At the end of the required waiting period, as reduced or waived if such be the case, the
                  designation of such historic landmark shall be rescinded and a draft of a proposed
                  ordinance removing such designation shall be prepared and submitted to the City Council
                  for approval.
(6602, Amended, 09/25/2007; 6602, Repealed, 09/25/2007; 6602, Repealed & Replaced, 09/25/2007; 4728, Amended,
06/27/1983)



Section 2-18-14ORDINARY REPAIRS; PUBLIC SAFETY
Nothing in this Chapter shall be construed to prevent the ordinary maintenance or repair of any exterior
feature in a historic district, or of any historic landmark which does not involve a change in design,
material or outer appearance thereof, nor to prevent the construction, reconstruction, alteration, restoration
or demolition of any such feature when the Building Official shall certify such is required for the public
safety because of an unsafe or dangerous condition.
(6602, Repealed & Replaced, 09/25/2007; 4443, Amended, 09/04/1979)



Section 2-18-15ACQUISITION OF PROPERTY

         A.       All lands, buildings, structures, sites or areas acquired by funds appropriated by the City
                  shall be acquired in the name of the City unless otherwise provided by the governing
                  board. So long as owned by the City, historic properties may be maintained by or under
                  the supervision and control of the City.

         B.       Nothing in this chapter shall be construed to allow the designation, regulation
                  conditioning, restriction or acquisition of historic buildings, structures, sites or areas, or
                  other properties or facilities owned by the state or any of its political subdivisions,
                  agencies or instrumentalities.
(6602, Amended, 09/25/2007; 6602, Repealed & Replaced, 09/25/2007)



Section 2-18-16ACQUISITION OF HISTORIC EASEMENTS
The City may acquire, by purchase or donation, historic easements in any area within the jurisdiction of
the City wherever and to the extent the Council determines that the acquisition will be in the public
interest. For the purpose of this section, “historic easement” means any easement, restriction, covenant or
condition running with the land, designated to preserve, maintain or enhance all or part of the existing
state of places of historical, architectural, archeological or cultural significance.

The City Council shall seek a recommendation from the Historic Preservation Commission regarding the
historic easement and proposed resolution.
(6602, Repealed & Replaced, 09/25/2007; 5192, Amended, 10/03/1989)




                                                   Page 24 of 26
                                             Boise Municipal Code

Section 2-18-17MAINTENANCE AND REPAIR REQUIRED; DEMOLITION BY NEGLECT
Any property located within an historic district, historic district – residential or designated as a landmark
shall be preserved by the owner, or such other person or persons as may have the legal custody or control
thereof, against decay and deterioration and free from unreasonable structural defects. The owner or
other person having legal custody and control thereof shall repair such resource if it is found to have one
or more of the following defects, or other defects that in the judgment of the Commission has a
detrimental effect on the historical characteristics of the property or district:

         A.       The deterioration of exterior walls or other vertical supports;

         B.       The deterioration of roofs or other horizontal members;

         C.       The deterioration of exterior chimneys;

         D.       The deterioration or removal of exterior finishes or fenestration;

         E.       The ineffective waterproofing of exterior walls, roofs and foundations including broken
                  windows or doors; and

         F.       The deterioration of any feature so as to create or permit the creation of any hazardous or
                  unsafe condition or conditions.

If the Commission makes a preliminary determination that a resource is being demolished by neglect, it
shall direct the Boise City Building Division to notify the owner(s) of the resource of this preliminary
determination, stating the reasons therefore, and shall give the owner of record twenty-eight (28) days
from the date of mailing of such notice to commence work to correct the specific defects as determined by
the Commission.

If the owner(s) fail to commence work within the time allotted as evidenced by a Building Permit, the
Commission shall notify the owner(s) in writing to appear at a public hearing before the Commission at a
date, time and place to be specified in said notice, which shall be mailed at least twenty-eight (28) days
before the said hearing. The Commission shall also notify in writing adjacent property owners and the
registered neighborhood association of such hearing. The Commission shall receive evidence on the issue
of whether the subject resource should be repaired and the owner(s) may present evidence in rebuttal
thereto. If, after such hearing, the Commission shall determine that the resource is being demolished by
neglect, it may direct the City Attorney to commence legal action against the owner(s) if the necessary
repairs are not completed within ninety (90) days or a time frame as specified by the Commission.
(6602, Repealed & Replaced, 09/25/2007)



Section 2-18-18EXEMPTION FROM FIRE OR BUILDING CODES
The Council, in order to promote the preservation and restoration of any historic landmark, or property
within a historic district may, upon the recommendation of the Commission, exempt an historic landmark
or property within a historic district from the application of the City Fire or Building Codes upon
compliance with the criteria for exemption set forth in said codes and upon a finding that non-exemption
would prevent or seriously hinder the preservation or restoration of said historic landmark or property in a
historic district. Upon rescission of a historic designation, any code exemption herein granted shall be
revoked effective the date of rescission.
(6602, Repealed & Replaced, 09/25/2007; 5192, Amended, 10/03/1989; 4728, Amended, 06/27/1983)



                                                   Page 25 of 26
                                              Boise Municipal Code

Section 2-18-19NOTICE OF CITY DEPARTMENTS AND OTHER AGENCIES; REGISTER OF
HISTORIC DISTRICTS AND LANDMARKS
In addition to all other transmittals and notices required by this Chapter, the Commission shall notify the
departments of Boise City and other agencies regarding the designation or removal of designation of
historic districts and landmarks, and shall maintain a register of such districts and landmarks.

         A.       Within seven (7) calendar days after the designation by ordinance of any historic district
                  or landmark, the Commission shall notify all departments of Boise City and other
                  governmental agencies having a regulatory or legally prescribed duty affecting such
                  district or landmark. The notice shall state the fact of such designation, identify the
                  boundary of the district, or the address of the landmark, and shall summarize the effect
                  such designation will have.

         B.       The Commission shall maintain a current register and map of all historic districts and
                  landmarks which have been designated by ordinance. Such register and map shall be
                  made public and available to the City departments, other governmental agencies and any
                  interested person.
(6602, Repealed & Replaced, 09/25/2007; 4443, Added, 09/04/1979)



Section 2-18-20SIGNS
In addition to a sign application, a staff level Certificate of Appropriateness shall be received for any sign
located within an Historic District. The following finding shall be made in order to issue the Certificate
of Appropriateness:

         A.       The sign shall be congruous with the building in design, materials, size and location.
(6602, Repealed & Replaced, 09/25/2007; 6602, Renumbered, 09/25/2007; 6602, Added, 09/25/2007)



Section 2-18-21PENALTIES
        A.     Any person who violates any provision of this Chapter shall be guilty of a misdemeanor
               and shall be punished by a fine of not more than one thousand dollars ($1000.00).

         B.       Any person who files with the Commission an application or request for a Certificate of
                  Appropriateness who willfully makes any false statement in such application or request,
                  or who, upon demand, willfully furnishes false information to the Commission, shall be
                  guilty of a misdemeanor and shall be punished by a fine of not more than one thousand
                  dollars ($1000.00).

         C.        For the purpose of this Chapter, each day during which there exists any violation of any
                  provision herein will constitute a separate violation.
(6602, Repealed & Replaced, 09/25/2007; 6602, Added, 09/25/2007)




                                                    Page 26 of 26

				
DOCUMENT INFO
Shared By:
Categories:
Tags:
Stats:
views:4
posted:10/11/2011
language:English
pages:41