16

					                    Content of the critical review
                                You will need to

       Include key academic theories

       Demonstrate current knowledge of the area

       Use clear referencing for the reader to find the original cited
        publications

       Acknowledge the research of others
CBEB2105                                                                  1
Business Research
                    Questions LR can answer
                                                        What are the key
                                                       theories, concepts
                                                          and ideas?           What are the
                                 What are the key                              epistemological &
                                   sources?                                    ontological
                                                                               grounds for the
                                                                               discipline?

                                                    Literature
                          What are the              search &                          What are the main
                                                                                         questions &
                         major issues &
                        debates about the
                             topic?
                                                    review of                         problems to have
                                                                                       been addressed

                                                    your topic
                                                                                          to-date?



                                                                            How is knowledge
                                   What are the                             on the topic
                                      political                             structured &
                                   standpoints?       What are the          organised?
                                                         origins &
                                                     definitions of the
                                                           topic?




        How have approaches to these questions increased our understanding &
        knowledge?
                                                           (Hart, 1998)
CBEB2105                                                                                                  2
Business Research
                    Is your LR critical?


       Complete the Checklists Box 3.2 and Box 3.3
            to evaluate your literature review!



                         Refer to Saunders et al. (2009, p. 64 - 65)



CBEB2105                                                           3
Business Research
                    Checklist 3.2 (coverage)

      •   Clearly relates to research questions & objectives?
      •   Most relevant & significant theories covered?
      •   Most relevant & significant literature?
      •   Up-to-date literature?
      •   Literature reference style?



CBEB2105                                                        4
Business Research
                    Example of literature review
                     reference writing styles…
    Globalization is an ongoing process that is bearing witness to unprecedented change.
    As Friedman (2007) explained, many forces are coming together to cause a flattening
    or leveling effect of the world’s workforce. This has allowed many skilled workers from
    emerging nations to enter the workplace and compete for jobs that were traditionally
    held by only a few wealthy industrial nations. Global communication, international
    workflow, and connected knowledge sharing and learning are converging to realign
    power, wealth, and work (Folkestad & Banning, 2008).

                                             *NOTE:
       If more than two authors are cited for example, Mohd-Any, Ennew and Winklhofer
    (2009), you can also write it as Mohd-Any et al. (2011). Et al. simply means ‘and others’


CBEB2105                                                                                5
Business Research
                                 Bibliography

    • Florida, R. L. (2003). The rise of the creative class: And how it’s transforming work,
      leisure, community and everyday life. Cambridge, MA: Basic Books.
    • Florida, R. L. (2005). The world is spiky. The Atlantic Monthly, 296(3), 48-51.
    • Folkestad, J. E., & Banning, J. (2008). Ecology of the computer lab. Journal of
      Educational Technology, 5, 38-48.
    • Friedman, T. L. (2007). The world is flat: A brief history of the twenty-first century.
      New York, NY: Picador.
    • Griffith, R., Huergo, E., & Peters, B. (2005). Innovation and productivity across four
      European countries. Oxford Review of Economic Policy, 22, 438-498.
    • Hamel, G. (2006). The why, what, and how of management innovation. Harvard
      Business Review, 84, 72-84.

CBEB2105                                                                                 6
Business Research
                    Example of literature review
                     reference writing styles…
    Innovation positively contribute to the survival of the firm in dynamic business
    environments [22]. Generally, firms with higher innovation rates sustain higher
    profitability over the long-term [59]. However, as Downs and Mohr [24] pointed out,
    there are two aspects of organizational innovation studies. The first dealt with
    phenomena related to the adoption and diffusion of new innovations; in the IT area,
    examples include Moore and Benbasat [50], Fichman [27], and Swanson and Ramiller
    [63].




CBEB2105                                                                            7
Business Research
                                 Bibliography

    • [22] E. Danneels, The dynamics of product innovation and firm competences,
      Strategic Management Journal 23, 2002, pp. 1095–1121.
    • [23] D.L. Deadrick, N. Bennett, C.J. Russell, Using hierarchical linear modeling to
      examine dynamic performance criteria over time, Journal of Management 23
      (November–December (6)), 1997, pp. 745–757.
    • [24] G.W. Downs Jr., L.B. Mohr, Conceptual issues in the study of innovation,
      Administrative Science Quarterly 21 (December), 1976, pp. 700–714.




CBEB2105                                                                               8
Business Research
                                Checklist 3.3

    • Previous research?
    • Strength weaknesses?
    • Objectivity?
    • Facts vs opinion?
    • Value & relevance?
    • Justify own ideas?
    • New insight is needed? Inconsistencies, bias/omission, further testing, lack of
      evidence, contradictory, limited
    • Referencing correctly published research?



CBEB2105                                                                                9
Business Research
                    Structure of the literature review

                      Three common structures

     A single chapter

     A series of chapters

     Throughout the report



CBEB2105
Business Research                                        10
            The key to a critical literature review
     Demonstrate that you have read, understood and evaluated
      your material

     Link the different ideas to form a cohesive and coherent
      argument

     Make clear connections to your research objectives and the
      subsequent empirical material

                                                 Saunders et al. (2009)
CBEB2105
Business Research                                                         11
               Categories of Literature Sources
     Primary (published and unpublished)

     Secondary

     Tertiary

                    Detailed in Tables 3.1 and 3.2 Saunders et al. (2009)




CBEB2105
Business Research                                                           12
                  Literature sources available




CBEB2105                                       Saunders et al. (2009)
     Figure 3.2 Literature sources available                       13
Business Research
                         Data sources
         Textbooks
         Academic and professional journals
         Theses
         Conference proceedings
         Unpublished manuscripts
         Reports of government departments and corporations
         Newspapers
         The Internet
CBEB2105
Business Research                                              14
                The literature search strategy (1)
                                 Write down
       parameters of your search
       key words and search terms to be used
       databases and search engines to be used
       criteria for selection of relevant and useful studies


                                     And
                    Discuss these with a tutor (if possible)


CBEB2105
Business Research                                               15
               The literature search strategy (2)
     Define the research parameters

     Generate key words

     Discuss your research

     Brainstorm ideas

     Construct Relevance trees - use computer software

CBEB2105
Business Research                                         16
              Conducting a literature search (1)
                     Approaches can include

     Searching tertiary literature sources

     Obtaining relevant literature

     Scanning and browsing secondary literature

     Searching using the Internet
CBEB2105
Business Research                                  17
              Conducting a literature search (2)
                    Searching using tertiary literature

     Ensure key words match controlled index language

     Search appropriate printed and database sources

     Note precise details used – including search strings

     Note the FULL reference of each search found
CBEB2105
Business Research                                            18
              Conducting a literature search (3)
     Printed sources

     Databases – use of Boolean logic and free text
      searching (Table 3.3)

     Scanning and browsing

     Searching the Internet (Tables 3.4 and 3.5)
                                             Saunders et al. (2009)

CBEB2105
Business Research                                                     19
            Conducting a literature search (4)
                            Searching the Internet




CBEB2105
                                                     Saunders et al. (2003)
     Figure 3.3 Searching the Internet                                   20
Business Research
            Conducting a literature search (5)
                           Searching the Internet




CBEB2105                                             Saunders et al. (2003)
     Figure 3.3 Searching the Internet (Continued)                       21
Business Research
                    Evaluating the literature

         Define the scope of your review

         Assess relevance and value

         Assess sufficiency




CBEB2105
Business Research                               22
                     Recording the literature
                    Make notes for each item you read

        Record –

         Biographic details

         Brief summary of content

         Supplementary information
                                                 Sharp et al. (2002)
CBEB2105
Business Research                                                      23
                                 Plagiarism
                            Four common forms

         Stealing material from another source

         Submitting material written by another

         Copying material without quotation marks

         Paraphrasing material without documentation

                    Adapted from Park (2003), cited in Easterby-Smith et al. (2008)
CBEB2105
Business Research                                                                     24

				
DOCUMENT INFO
Shared By:
Categories:
Tags:
Stats:
views:7
posted:9/29/2011
language:English
pages:24