“Remember! The first line on the envelope address shows your financial status”—ME
South Australian Government Superannuated Employees Association Inc. President: Ray Hickman, 24 Castle Street,
Modbury, SA 5092. Tel: (08) 8264 4146
trading as: e-mail: firstname.lastname@example.org
Treasurer: Michael Evans, 40 Esplanade,
Established 1927 Pt. Willunga, SA 5173. Tel: (08) 8557 8184
Secretary: Vic Potticary, 27 Torrens Street,
Torrensville, SA 5031. Tel: (08) 8352 6504
Membership: Willy Hajszan, 8 Eden Court,
Issue No. 21 Aberfoyle Pk., SA 5159. Tel (08) 8387 2076
January, 2008 e-mail: email@example.com
From the President
n many respects the Association is in good CPI Change: The Adelaide Consumer Price
I shape. Membership, at 1,700, is higher than
ever before and the organization has financial
Index increase for June 2007 – December 2007, was
1.75% and this same adjustment will be made to
reserves sufficient to meet any foreseeable Super SA pensions from the first pension payment
contingency. But there is another very date in April, 2008.
important respect in which we are struggling. I
am referring here to our dependence on
volunteer labour. Annual General Meeting
We are going to the 2008 AGM with four of the six Monday, 25 February, 2008, at 1 p.m.
committee positions vacant and without a guest Pilgrim Centre, 12 Flinders Street, Adelaide
speaker coordinator. The incumbent Treasurer,
Secretary and Membership Officer have all indicated Agenda:
their willingness to continue in 2008 but should any of 1. Apologies
these people not be able to, the place from where a 2. Minutes of the 2007 Annual General Meeting
replacement will come is difficult to see. 3. Annual Reports: President, Treasurer
4. Election of Officers and Committee for 2008
The State Pension scheme was closed to new ------
members in 1986 and so the reality is that the Guest Speaker:
Association has a declining constituency. There are Julie Pettett, Conservation Council of South
the Police and Electricity Industry Pension schemes, Australia
and the State Lump Sum scheme, that might be a
source of additional members but these were also
closed to new members long ago. The Southern State Speaker Program for General Meetings:
Superannuation scheme (SSS) is the ongoing
government scheme and this has about 100,000 active March-June, 2008
and preserved members. (Speakers and topics subject to change without notice)
The SSS is very different from the Pension scheme March 31: Meg Lees, CEO of the Multiple Sclerosis
but there are important, common interests as you will Society of SA and NT, Inc. Formerly Senator and
see when you read the item Transition to Retirement. Leader of the Australian Democrats.
Perhaps the Association is destined to evolve into an April 28: Major Andrew Craib Salvation Army.
organization representing the superannuation interests The work of the Salvation Army in S.A.
of all state government employees. May 26: Merry Branson Australian Bureau of
Another item that I urge you to read carefully is Statistics: The Consumer Price Index (CPI).
Tasmanian Pensions After 1-7-2007. June 30: Ian Mawby Hearing loss, hearing aids and
At the end of 2007 the Executive Committee wrote to all things hearing.
other organizations, similar to SA Superannuants,
seeking their views on the payment of a Universal Disclaimer: Readers should not act, or refrain from
Age Pension. We expect to hear back from these acting, solely on the basis of information in this
organizations in time to publish an item on this topic newsletter, but should consult the relevant authorities
in the May Newsletter. Universal Age Pension was or other advisers with expertise in the particular field.
the subject of a letter from Willy Hajszan published Neither SA Superannuants nor the editor accepts any
in the August 2005 Newsletter. responsibility for actions taken.
Change of Federal Government Senator Minchin, the then Minister for Finance, wrote
Indexation of Pensions: During the election to say that the 10% tax offset on untaxed source
campaign Labor gave an undertaking to appoint an pensions already compensated recipients of those
independent person to report to it on the indexation pensions for the fact that they had to pay more tax on
issue if it achieved government. This person is to have their superannuation income than recipients of taxed
particular regard to a change which would see the source pensions. This remarkable assertion was made
amount of a superannuation pension equal to the age without any explanation.
pension indexed to the better of CPI or wages, with The Labor Party sought to amend the original
the balance of the superannuation pension remaining ‘Simpler Super’ legislation to provide for separate
indexed to the CPI alone. taxation of superannuation and non-superannuation
Labor will now be under pressure from the income when it was in opposition and so we have high
organizations representing Commonwealth super- expectations of it doing so now that it is in
annuants to deliver quickly on this undertaking. The government.
position that these organizations are taking on the Senator Nick Sherry (Tasmania) is the Minister
suggestion that improved indexation might be applied responsible for superannuation in the new government
to just part of a superannuation pension is that this and the Association wrote to him soon after the
would be a first step towards improved indexation for election to say that we were expecting to hear the
the entire pension. government’s intentions on taxation of non-
If the Commonwealth agrees to improved indexation superannuation income in the very near future. RH
for its superannuation pensions it will not be
automatic for the state governments to follow suit. Agreement Reached on Unwelcome Regulation
The New South Wales government has still not agreed In the May 2007 issue of this newsletter an account
to twice-yearly indexation of its superannuation was given of the addition of a section 59 (1a) (d) to
pensions. the Superannuation Act, 1988. This section allows for
a regulation to be made which can cause any part of
Any improvement in the indexation of superannuation the Act to not apply.
pensions will be more costly than was the move from
once-yearly to twice-yearly CPI adjustments. Following representations made by the Association,
Furthermore it will be more costly for a state and by the Superannuation Federation, the State
government to do this than is the case for the Treasurer, Hon Kevin Foley, MP has indicated that,
Commonwealth. when the Act is next considered for amendment,
The Commonwealth will recover a substantial part of section 59 (1a) (d) will be changed to ensure that it
its cost for improved indexation in the form of does not apply to the State Pension Scheme or State
increased tax on the larger pension income and Lump Sum Scheme. These are the two main, and
reduced age pension outlays. For many people original, schemes covered by the Superannuation Act,
receiving an untaxed source pension, like a 1988 and section 59 (1a) (d) will be changed so that it
Commonwealth or Super SA pension, and some age applies only to other schemes recently brought into
pension, every dollar of additional superannuation the scope of the Act .
income received provides the Commonwealth with
21.5 cents additional tax revenue and reduces age Mr Foley has also given an undertaking to the
pension entitlement by 40 cents. Superannuation Federation that section 59 (1a) (d)
will not be used in connection with the Pension and
Once the new government has appointed its Lump Sum schemes during the period before it is
independent expert to report on indexation of changed. All this is very pleasing. RH
Commonwealth pensions it will be important for the
Association to have an input to the inquiry. Transition to Retirement (TtR)
Taxation of non-superannuation income: During The South Australian government has introduced
the election campaign the Association wrote to every legislation which, when passed by the Parliament, will
South Australian Senator and Member of the House of change the rules for access to superannuation for
Representatives (MHR) asking to be advised of members of the Pension, Lump Sum, and Southern
his/her position on the matter of taxation of non- State Superannuation (SSS) schemes. The changed
superannuation income. rules will allow a person access to at least part of
his/her accrued benefit without the requirement to
The responses obtained from Senators and MHRs retire fully from government service (as currently
were mostly to tell us that they had referred the matter applies).
to a Minister or Shadow Minister. Senator Cory
Bernardi was the only person to write and tell us that The proposed new arrangements are:
he personally supported the Senate Committee 1. the person must move to part-time, or lower
recommendation. paid, employment, and
2. after the change in employment status, of age and length of service, is 75% of salary. The
whatever fraction of income the person has relatively small increase after reaching age 60 makes
surrendered is the fraction of the accrued it unattractive for Pension Scheme members to
benefit he/she can begin to receive, and continue working past that age. In fact, a Pension
3. the person must have reached his/her Scheme member who wants to work past 60 is often
superannuation preservation age (55 better off retiring from government service and taking
increasing to 60 for people born after another job afterwards.
Although the South Australian proposals for early
Arrangements applying elsewhere in Australia: To access to the defined benefits are not as good as those
compare the transition to retirement arrangements provided in Queensland and West Australia they
proposed for South Australia with those already in should still be attractive to some members.
place elsewhere one must first distinguish between the
Lump Sum and Pension schemes, which are unfunded Consider the case of a pension scheme member who is
defined benefit schemes, and the SSS scheme which is aged 60, has a salary of $60,000 p.a. and has an
a fully funded, accumulation scheme. accrued benefit of 70% of salary. The table below
compares net income from full-time and half-time
Accumulation schemes and TtR: Members of
employment for this person under the government’s
private sector accumulation schemes and members of
proposed arrangements. The 10% tax offset has been
all other government accumulation schemes, including
taken into account.
the Commonwealth government scheme, have had full
access to their accrued benefits at preservation age Full-time work Half-time work
and, regardless of their work status, from as long ago Work Income $60,000 $30,000
as 1 July, 2005 when this first became permitted by Pension Income $0 $21,000
Federal legislation. Gross Income $60,000 $51,000
Defined benefit schemes and TtR: Queensland and Net Income $46,500 $42,435
West Australian defined benefit schemes are the only The net income for the person working half-time is
schemes of this type which currently permit any 91% of that for full-time work. For a person who
access to the defined benefit at preservation age wants to continue working for the government beyond
without a person also having to meet one of the age 60, but not full-time, this should be an incentive
additional requirements of retiring fully, or changing for doing so.
employer at age 60, or reaching age 65.
There is a hold-up with the passage of this legislation
The reason why early access to defined benefits is because the Superannuation Federation, with the full
uncommon, while early access to accumulation support of SA Superannuants, has successfully
benefits is more or less universal, is that Federal argued in the Legislative Council for amendments that
legislation gives an employer the right to instruct a allow SSS members access to their benefits without
superannuation fund in matters that involve an the need to go to lower paid employment. The main
increase in its contributions. elements of the Federation’s case are:
unlike the Pension Scheme, access to
Early access to a defined benefit, increases employer superannuation by SSS members who remain
cost of the benefit, particularly where it is unfunded, in full-time work after preservation age has
whereas allowing a person early access to a fully no cost implications for the government;
funded accumulation benefit has no implications for access to super after age 60, while still
employer costs. Consequently employers can instruct working, would allow SSS members an
funds over access to defined benefits but not opportunity to significantly increase their
accumulation benefits. superannuation savings in the years before
In Queensland and West Australia, where the state eventual retirement. Most SSS members have
economies are booming, governments have accepted small accrued benefits and so it is important
increased costs for their defined benefits as the price for them to have this opportunity.
of retaining older, and experienced, employees The government has not yet indicated whether it will
beyond age 58-60. This is the popular retirement age accept the amendments made in the Legislative
range for members of defined benefit schemes and, in Council and Parliament does not sit again until
particular, pension schemes. Neither the Common- February, 2008. RH
wealth government nor any other state government
has yet allowed TtR provisions for members of
Tasmanian Pensions After 1-7-2007
defined benefit schemes.
Until 1-7-2007 Tasmanian state superannuation
In South Australia, Pension Scheme members retiring pensions were untaxed source pensions taxed in the
at 58-60 commonly have a retirement benefit of about same way as Super SA pensions. Now, however,
70% of salary while the maximum benefit, regardless Tasmanian pensions are about 30% taxed source and
70% untaxed source pensions. The actual percentages
vary from superannuant to superannuant, according to 2007 Executive Committee
a person’s employment and contribution history, but President: Ray Hickman
the split is usually about 30/70. The taxed source Vice-President: Clive Brooks
component of the pension is that which has been Secretary: Vic Potticary
funded by the member’s personal contributions. Assistant Secretary: Christine Venning
What makes this Tasmanian development very Treasurer: Michael Evans
interesting is the fact that the total gross pension value Membership: Willy Hajszan
remains the same. This leads to an obvious question: Committee Members:
If Tasmania can pay the component of its pension Lawrie Bennett, John Reddaway, Maureen Goodwin,
funded by members as a taxed source pension Willy Hajszan, Bob Scott, Queenie Inshaw
without any reduction in the gross pension value,
why not South Australia? In October the From the Treasurer: Now that we are operating with
Association wrote to the State Treasurer asking for an a separate Treasurer and Membership Officer I request
answer to this question. that you direct all membership inquiries to Willy
Any part of a pension that is paid from a taxed source Hajszan in the first instance. The inquiries that come
is tax-free if the person receiving it is aged 60 or direct to me have usually had to be referred to Willy
more. If the person is aged between 55 and 60 he/she and so are better sent to him in the first place.
can claim a 15% tax offset on the taxed source
component of a pension. If a person is in receipt of an Payment of fees by electronic funds transfer is going
invalid pension he/she can claim a 15% tax offset quite well and I want to encourage members to use
against the part of the pension paid from the taxed this facility BUT please make sure you identify
source from the time the pension commences until age yourself whenever you make an electronic transfer
60 when this component becomes tax-free. to SA Superannuants’ account. If you are not
confident about doing this it will be better for you to
The effects of having a 30% pension component pay by the traditional method. ME
which is from a taxed source (the Tasmanian Our bank is Bank SA and other details are as follows:
situation) compared to a pension which is entirely
from an untaxed source (the South Australian
Account number 950313840,
situation) may be summarised as follows:
Account name SA Superannuants.
1. For people aged over 60 tax becomes payable on a
South Australian pension at about $31,000 p.a. For a Membership Form
Tasmanian pension, tax becomes payable at about
$44,000 p.a. The tax payable on a South Australian Cut here and post to:
pension of $44,000 p.a. is $3,210. SA SUPERANNUANTS
2. For people aged under 60, tax becomes payable on 8 Eden Court, Aberfoyle Park, 5159
a South Australian pension at $11,000 p.a. and on a Existing Life Members should ignore this section (unless
Tasmanian pension at $15,700 p.a. for those aged 55- notifying change of address). Membership inquiries should
59 (or those Tasmanians in receipt of invalid pensions be directed to Willy Hajszan, Tel 8387 2076.
who are less than 60).
Your membership category is on the envelope.
3. Where a person must pay the Medicare levy, a
Tasmanian pension recipient aged 60 will pay 70% of MEMBERSHIP 2008
the amount payable by a South Australian receiving Renewal 2008/New Application /Life Membership
(Delete as necessary)
the same total pension. So a Tasmanian, age 60, with
a $44,000 p.a. pension will pay no tax and a Medicare Please find enclosed the amount of $....……....OR
levy of $462. A South Australian, age 60, with a I have made an electronic payment of $…………
$44,000 p.a. pension will pay $3,210 in tax and a
Medicare levy of $660. For S.A. Superannuants Annual/Life Membership
4. Where a person receiving a Super SA pension is FULL NAME (please print) ........................................
already paying no tax on the super pension (e.g. a
ADDRESS (please print)……..………………………
single person aged 60 with a pension less than about
$31,000 p.a.) the only difference between the South …........................................…….......... Post Code.......
Australian and a Tasmanian receiving a pension of the Tel.:……………….….. Date of Birth....../…../19.…..
same value will be that the Tasmanian will pay less
Medicare levy. SIGNED.....................................………………....
All the above points have been made for the case of a DATE...…../……..../2008
person who is single. For people with partners the *Fees: Annual = $10. Life (once only fee) Under Age 60 =
difference between a South Australian and Tasmanian $200; Age 60-65 = $160; Over Age 65 = $110.
couple will usually be less, depending on the income
(Receipts will not be posted unless a stamped, self-
of the person’s partner. RH addressed envelope accompanies the application)