Docstoc

11-06-0717-38-000n-tgn-lb84-frame-format-adhoc-group

Document Sample
11-06-0717-38-000n-tgn-lb84-frame-format-adhoc-group Powered By Docstoc
					May 2006                                           Title                doc.: IEEE 802.11-06/0541r0

            IEEE P802.11 Wireless LANs
            Submission
Designator: doc.: IEEE 802.11-06/0717r37
Venue Date: Sept 2006
First Author:Peter Loc

Subject:     Resolution of comments received during IEEE 802.11 Letter Ballot 84
Full Date:   2006-09-27
Author(s):   Peter Loc
             Marvell




Abstract:    Letter Ballot 84 was a vote to submit the contents of document IEEE 802.11 TGn Draft 1.0 to Sponsor Ballot.

             This document contains the comments received during Letter Ballot 84, and their resolutions.

             Organisation of this document: The spreadsheet contains multiple tabs along the bottom. The green tabs contain
             responses to LB84. The "Editorial" tab includes unique editorial comments. The "Technical" tab includes uniqu
             The yellow tabs contain lookup tables used to help classify comments (preliminary, pending discussion at the Ma

             Also, see the Revision History tab.




             Notice: This document has been prepared to assist IEEE 802.11. It is offered
             as a basis for discussion and is not binding on the contributing individual(s)
             or organization(s). The material in this document is subject to change in
             form and content after further study. The contributor(s) reserve(s) the right
             to add, amend or withdraw material contained herein.

             Release: The contributor grants a free, irrevocable license to the IEEE to
             incorporate material contained in this contribution, and any modifications
             thereof, in the creation of an IEEE Standards publication; to copyright in the
             IEEE’s name any IEEE Standards publication even though it may include
             portions of this contribution; and at the IEEE’s sole discretion to permit
             others to reproduce in whole or in part the resulting IEEE Standards
             publication. The contributor also acknowledges and accepts that this
             contribution may be made public by IEEE 802.11.

             Patent Policy and Procedures: The contributor is familiar with the IEEE 802
             Patent Policy and Procedures <http:// ieee802.org/guides/bylaws/sb-

Submission                                            1                  Adrian Stephens, Intel Corporation
May 2006                                        Title              doc.: IEEE 802.11-06/0541r0
             Patent Policy and Procedures <http:// ieee802.org/guides/bylaws/sb-
             bylaws.pdf>, including the statement "IEEE standards may include the
             known use of patent(s), including patent applications, provided the IEEE
             receives assurance from the patent holder or applicant with respect to patents
             essential for compliance with both mandatory and optional portions of the
             standard." Early disclosure to the Working Group of patent information
             that might be relevant to the standard is essential to reduce the possibility for
             delays in the development process and increase the likelihood that the draft
             publication will be approved for publication. Please notify the Chair
             <stuart.kerry@philips.com> as early as possible, in written or electronic
             form, if patented technology (or technology under patent application) might
             be incorporated into a draft standard being developed within the IEEE
             802.11 Working Group. If you have questions, contact the IEEE Patent
             Committee Administrator at <patcom@ieee.org>.




Submission                                        2                 Adrian Stephens, Intel Corporation
              May 2006                                        Title           doc.: IEEE 802.11-06/0541r0




1 Letter Ballot 84




Gn Draft 1.0 to Sponsor Ballot.

eir resolutions.

he bottom. The green tabs contains the comments compiled from the commenter
The "Technical" tab includes unique technical comments.
nary, pending discussion at the May 13th meeting).




ght in the




EEE 802



              Submission                                        3             Adrian Stephens, Intel Corporation
              May 2006     Title   doc.: IEEE 802.11-06/0541r0



to patents


ibility for




              Submission    4      Adrian Stephens, Intel Corporation
Revision History

Revision           Date
r11                     7-Jul-06
r12                    12-Jul-06
r17                    15-Jul-06
r23                    24-Jul-06
r27                    7-Sep-06
r34                   16-Sep-06
r37                   27-Sep-06
Summary of Changes
Reconciled with other spreadsheets (Adrian Stephens)
Merged in updates from email from FRAME telecon
Transfers in/out
Reconciled with other spreadsheets (Adrian Stephens)
Reconciled with other spreadsheets (Adrian Stephens)
Reconciled with other spreadsheets (Adrian Stephens)
Reconciled with other spreadsheets (Adrian Stephens)
                  Type E/HE/T/ST/DT(Ed)
Count of Name of Commenter(Ed)
        CID
Resn Status       DT       HE       ST     T        (blank)   Grand Total
A                                              2                          2
C                        2               1                                3
D                      16                7     15                        38
R                        2               1      1                         4
T                                               1                         1
(blank)                11         2     23     27                        63
Grand Total            31         2     32     46                       111
             Clause




             Line(E



                                                              Clause



                                                                        Clause
CID



              Name




                                                                                            Duplic
                   )
               Type




                                                                                    Type
                  of




              Page(
                  C)
             Line(C


                  of

                 No

                 /N)
              Page(
              enter(




                  d)




                                                                   d)
                Ed)
             Comm




                                                                                             ate of
              Numb




             Part of




                                                                           (Ed)




                                                                                     (Ed)
             Vote(Y




                                                              Title(E




                                                                                  E/HE/T
                                                                                  /ST/DT
        32   Adachi,       7.4A.   80       T   Y   80                  7.4A.1    ST
        33   Tomoko
             Adachi,       1.2
                           7.4A.   80       T   Y   80                  .2
                                                                        7.4A.2    ST
       493   Tomoko
             Choudhu       2
                           7.4A.   78   Tab T   Y   78   15             7.4A.1    ST
       494   ry, Abhijit
             Choudhu       1
                           7.4A.   81   le E
                                        0       N   81    0             7.4A.2    T
       548   ry, Abhijit
             Conner,       2
                           7.2.2   31   3   T   Y   31    3             7.2.2.    T
       660   W.
             CYPHER        .1
                           7.4.7   61   2   T   Y   61    2             1
                                                                        7.4.7.    ST
       773   , DAVID
             Durand,       .4
                           7.4.1            T   Y   55                  4
                                                                        7.4.1.    ST
      1105   Roger
             Fischer,      .5
                           5.6     11   11 T    Y   11   11             5
                                                                        5.6       T
      1106   Matthew
             Fischer,      5.6     11   11 T    Y   11   11             5.6       T
      1109   Matthew
             Fischer,      7                T   Y   13                  7         T
      1127   Matthew
             Fischer,      7.1.3   20   16 T    Y   20   16             7.1.3.    T
      1178   Matthew
             Fischer,      .8
                           7.3.2            T   Y   40                  8
                                                                        7.3.2.    T
      1196   Matthew
             Fischer,      .30
                           7.3.2   53       T   Y   53                  30
                                                                        7.3.2.    DT
      1197   Matthew
             Fischer,      .47.8
                           7.3.2   53       T   Y   53                  48
                                                                        7.3.2.    T
      1201   Matthew
             Fischer,      .47.8
                           7.3.2   53       T   Y   53                  48
                                                                        7.3.2.    T
      1211   Matthew
             Fischer,      .47.8
                           7.4.7            T   Y   76                  48
                                                                        7.4.7.    T
      1235   Matthew
             Fischer,      .10
                           7.4.7   60       T   Y   60                  10
                                                                        7.4.7.    T
      1236   Matthew
             Fischer,      .4
                           7.4.7            T   Y   62                  4
                                                                        7.4.7.    T
      1238   Matthew
             Fischer,      .5
                           7.4.7            T   Y   63                  5
                                                                        7.4.7.    T
      1242   Matthew
             Fischer,      .6
                           7.4.7            T   Y   72                  6
                                                                        7.4.7.    T
      1247   Matthew
             Fischer,      .8
                           7.4A.            T   Y   80                  8
                                                                        7.4A.2    T
      1248   Matthew
             Fischer,      2
                           7.4A.            T   Y   80                  7.4A.2    T
      1553   Matthew
             Haisch,       2
                           7.2.1   22   9   T   Y   22   9              7.2.1     T
      1746   Fred
             Inoue,        7.3.2   53       T   Y   53                  7.3.2.    DT
      1747   Yasuhiko
             Inoue,        .48
                           7.4A    78   11- T   Y   78   11             48
                                                                        7.4A      T
      1909   Yasuhiko
             Ji,           7.1.3   15   12 T
                                        5       Y   15    5             7.1.3.    T
      1910   Lusheng
             Ji,           .1.2
                           7.1.3   15   5   T   Y   15    5             1.2
                                                                        7.1.3.    T
      1911   Lusheng
             Ji,           .1.2
                           7.1.3   15   8   T   Y   15    8             1.2
                                                                        7.1.3.    T
      2000   Lusheng
             Ji,           .1.5
                           7.1.3   31   14 T    Y   31   14             1.5
                                                                        7.1.3.    T
      2125   Lusheng
             Ji,           .1.2
                           7.3.2   41   17 T    Y   41   17             1.2
                                                                        7.3.2.    DT
      2142   Lusheng
             Ji,           .47.1
                           7.3.2   44   0   T   N   44    0             47.1
                                                                        7.3.2.    T
      2257   Lusheng
             Ji,           .47.2
                           7.4.7   60   4   T   Y   60    4             47.2
                                                                        7.4.7.    T
      2268   Lusheng
             Ji,           .4
                           7.4.7   63   1   T   Y   63    1             4
                                                                        7.4.7.    ST
      2274   Lusheng
             Ji,           .5
                           7.4.7   64   2   T   Y   64    2             5
                                                                        7.4.7.    ST
      2280   Lusheng
             Ji,           .6
                           7.4.7   64   6   T   Y   64    6             6
                                                                        7.4.7.    ST
      2327   Lusheng
             Ji,           .6
                           7.4.7   73   1   T   Y   73    1             6
                                                                        7.4.7.    ST
      3694   Lusheng
             Kandala,      .8
                           5.6     11   21 T    Y   11   21             8
                                                                        5.6       ST
      3715   Srinivas
             Kandala,      7.1.3   20       T   Y   20                  7.1.3.    T
      3753   Srinivas
             Kandala,      .8
                           7.3.2   43       T   Y   43                  8
                                                                        7.3.2.    DT
      3756   Srinivas
             Kandala,      .47.2
                           7.3.2   45       T   Y   45                  47.2
                                                                        7.3.2.    DT
      3758   Srinivas
             Kandala,      .47.4
                           7.3.2   46       T   Y   46                  47.4
                                                                        7.3.2.    DT
      3760   Srinivas
             Kandala,      .47.5
                           7.3.2   46       T   Y   46                  47.5
                                                                        7.3.2.    DT
             Srinivas      .47.5                                        47.5
3771   Kandala,    7.3.2   52            T   Y   52        7.3.2.   T
3778   Srinivas
       Kandala,    .48
                   7.3.2   53            T   Y   53        48
                                                           7.3.2.   DT
3781   Srinivas
       Kandala,    .48
                   7.3.2   54            T   Y   54        48
                                                           7.3.2.   T
3785   Srinivas
       Kandala,    .48
                   7.3.2   54/5          E   Y   54        48
                                                           7.3.2.   T
3810   Srinivas
       Kandala,    .48
                   7.4.7   5             T   Y   62        48
                                                           7.4.7.   T
3814   Srinivas
       Kandala,    .5
                   7.4.7                 T   Y   63        5
                                                           7.4.7.   T
3818   Srinivas
       Kandala,    .6
                   7.4A.   79            T   Y   79        6
                                                           7.4A.1   ST
3820   Srinivas
       Kandala,    1
                   7.5                   T   Y   81        7.5      T
3968   Srinivas
       Kasher,     7.1.3   20     15     T   N   20   15   7.1.3.   DT
4044   Assaf
       Kerry,      .8
                   5.6     11     10     T   Y   11   10   8
                                                           5.6      ST
4045   Stuart
       Kerry,      5.6     11     21     T   Y   11   21   5.6      T
4222   Stuart
       Kneckt,     7.4.7   61     Tab    T   Y   61    1   7.4.7.   ST
4349   Jarkko
       Lefkowitz   .4
                   Tabl    42     le
                                  3      T   Y   42    3   4
                                                           7.3.2.   ST
4501   , Martin
       Liu, Der-   e N-
                   7.4A.   80     7      T   Y   80    7   47.2
                                                           7.4A.1   ST
4603   Zheng
       Malinen,    1.2
                   7.1.3   15     16     T   Y   15   16   .2
                                                           7.1.3.   DT
4617   Jouni
       Malinen,    .1.10
                   7.4.1   55     12     T   Y   55   12   1.10
                                                           7.4.1.   T
5135   Jouni
       Meylan,     .5
                   7.1.3   20     tabl   T   Y   20   18   5
                                                           7.1.3.   T
5136   Arnaud
       Meylan,     .8
                   7.1.3   20     e
                                  tabl   T   Y   20   18   8
                                                           7.1.3.   T
6773   Arnaud
       Morioka,    .8
                   7.1.3   18     e
                                  12     T   Y   18   12   8
                                                           7.1.3.   DT
6887   Yuichi
       Nanda,      .8
                   7.1.3   15     16     E   N   15   16   8
                                                           7.1.3.   DT
6889   Sanjiv
       Nanda,      .1.10
                   7.1.3   15     8      T   N   15    8   1.10
                                                           7.1.3.   DT
7223   Sanjiv
       Raissinia   .1.5
                   7.1.3   15     17     T   Y   15   17   1.5
                                                           7.1.3.   DT
7232   , Ali
       Raissinia   .1.10
                   7.2.2   31     16     T   N   31   16   1.10
                                                           7.2.2.   DT
7236   , Ali
       Raissinia   .2
                   7.3.2   46     Tab    T   N   46    4   2
                                                           7.3.2.   ST
7240   , Ali
       Raissinia   .47.5
                   7.3.2   53     le
                                  Tab    T   N   53    1   47.5
                                                           7.3.2.   DT
7252   , Ali
       Raissinia   .48
                   7.4A.   79     le
                                  6      T   Y   79    6   48
                                                           7.4A.1   DT
7253   , Ali
       Raissinia   1
                   7.4A.   79            T   N   79        7.4A.1   ST
7254   , Ali
       Raissinia   1
                   7.4A.   80     Tab    T   Y   80   31   7.4A.2   DT
       , Ali       2              le
                                  n48




7299   Ramesh,     7.1.3   18     10, T      Y   18   10   7.1.3.   T
7305   Sridhar
       Ramesh,     .8
                   7.3.2   46     11 T
                                  Tab        Y   46    4   8
                                                           7.3.2.   DT
7356   Sridhar
       Scarpa,     .47.5
                   7.1.3   75     le T       Y   75        47.5
                                                           7.1.3.   T
7362   Vincenzo
       Scarpa,     .5.3
                   7.4A.   80         T      Y   80        5.3
                                                           7.4A.2   DT
7811   Vincenzo
       SURINE      2
                   7.2.1   22     9   E      N   22   9    7.2.1    HE
       NI,
 7813   SURINE      7.3.2   13         T   Y   13                 7.3.2.   DT
 7819   NI,
        SURINE      .47.1
                    7.4.7   61   1     T   Y   61     1           47.1
                                                                  7.4.7.   ST
 7820   NI,
        SURINE      .4
                    7.4.7   62   13    T   Y   62    13           4
                                                                  7.4.7.   DT
 7823   NI,
        SURINE      .5
                    7.4.7   64   6     T   Y   64     6           5
                                                                  7.4.7.   ST
 7826   NI,
        SURINE      .6
                    7.4.7   69   4     T   Y   69     4           6
                                                                  7.4.7.   ST
 7830   NI,
        SURINE      .7
                    7.4.7   73   2     T   Y   73     2           7
                                                                  7.4.7.   ST
 8060   NI,
        Trainin,    .8
                    7.1.3   75         T   Y   75                 8
                                                                  7.1.3.   DT
 8065   Solomon
        Trainin,    .5.3
                    7.2.2   30         T   Y   30                 5.3
                                                                  7.2.2    ST
 8066   Solomon
        Trainin,    7.3.2              T   Y   41                 7.3.2.   ST
 8075   Solomon
        Trainin,    .47.1
                    7.3.2              T   Y   51                 47.1
                                                                  7.3.2.   ST
 8080   Solomon
        Trainin,    .48
                    7.4A.              T   Y   80                 48
                                                                  7.4A.2   DT
 8108   Solomon
        Tsoulogi    2
                    7.1.3 15     8-9   T   Y   15     8           7.1.3.   DT
 9961   annis,
        Xhafa,      .1.5 21
                    7.1.4              T   Y   21                 1.5
                                                                  7.1.4    T
 9976   Ariton
        Xhafa,      7.3.2 46     Tab   T   Y   46     4           7.3.2.   ST
10070   Ariton
        Yamaura     .47.5 20
                    7.1.3        le
                                 18    T   Y   20    18           47.5
                                                                  7.1.3.   ST
10297   , Tomoya
        Hayes,      .8
                    7.2.2 30           T   N   30                 8
                                                                  7.2.2    ST
10298   Kevin
        Hayes,      7.4A.              T   N   80                 7.4A.2   ST
11021   Kevin
        Marshall,   2
                    7.1.3 31     14    T   Y   31    14           7.1.3.   T
11025   Bill
        Marshall,   .1.2 15
                    7.1.3        20    T   Y   15    20           1.2
                                                                  7.1.3.   T
11388   Bill
        Marshall,   .2
                    7.4.7 60     2     E   N   60     2           2
                                                                  7.4.7.   HE
12003   Bill
        Basson,     .4
                    9.9.1 90     8     T   N   90     8           4
                                                                  9.9.1.   T
12016   Gal
        Basson,     .2
                    7.1.3 20     15-   T   N   20    15           2
                                                                  7.1.3.   T
12219   Gal
        Cheng,      .8
                    7.4A. 80     17
                                 26    T   N   80    26           8
                                                                  7.4A.2   DT
 7255   Hong
        Raissinia   2
                    7.4A. 81     Tab   T   Y   81     1 A-MPDU 7.4A.2      DT
        , Ali       2            le                     Contents
                                 n49
                                 ,
9885 Xhafa,   11.1 151           n50 T
                                 18        Y   151   18 MPDU      11.14. ST
     Tsoulogi 4.2 15
8107 Ariton   7.1.3              17 T      Y    15   17 density
                                                        Order     2
                                                                  7.1.3. ST
     annis,   .1.10                                     field     1.10
     Tom

4634 Matsuo,        7.3.1 36           T   Y   36                 7.3.1. DT
     Ryoko          .9                                            9
7304 Ramesh, 7.3.2 45     Tab T+ Y   45   1   7.3.2. DT
     Sridhar .47.3        le E                47.3
             (MA          n17
             C HT
             para
             mete
             rs
             Info
             field)

3744 Kandala, 7.3.2 40       T   Y   40       7.3.2. DT
     Srinivas .29                             29




3768 Kandala, 7.3.2 52       T   Y   52       7.3.2. DT
     Srinivas .48                             48




3741 Kandala, 7.3.1          T   Y   35       7.3.1. ST
     Srinivas .7                              7
3414 Jokela,   7.3.2 51   Ge T   Y   51   0   7.3.2. ST
     Jari      .48        ner                 48
                          al
  28 Adachi, 7.3.2 42       T   Y   42       7.3.2. T
     Tomoko .47.2                            47.2




7352 Sanwalk 7.2.2 31   1   t   Y   31   1   7.2.2. T
     a, Anil .1                              1




1150 Fischer, 7.2.2         T   Y   31       7.2.2. T
     Matthew .2                              2




  20 Adachi, 7.1.3 16       T   N   16       7.1.3. T
     Tomoko .5                               5
Assign




                                                                                                    e
    ee
 Resn
Status


Submi




                                                                                                  sed
 ssion




                                                        Comm
                                                          ent




                                                                                                Propo

                                                                                                Chang
  TGn
            What is negotiated_MPDU_limit in Fig. n33?          Correct "negotiated_MPDU_limit" in Fig.
            Maximum Rx A-MPDU Factor is negotiated
            "Block-Ack policy" in Tables 48 and 49 is           n33 to other phrase "Data MPDUs sent
                                                                Change the word or actual value.
            Can an MPDU within if it is when aggregate
            confusing. It looks as an A-MPDUthe Ack             under the length of this fieldTables 48 and
                                                                Make Block-ACK policy" in consistent
            For QoS Data, in the comment column length
            contain an A-MSDU ? If yes, the MPDUspecify         with the size of the maximum A-MSDU
            that table rowone TID per aggregation
            For it is only with ToDS=1/FromDS=1,                Update the fields to match Table 7 in the
            Missing ExplicitAddress 4 are both B8-B11
            Address 3 and Feedback Format listed as             Add draft.
                                                                basemissing specification information
            missing detail                                      how is a channel switch implemented
            In subpart c) subpart 1) -- this is the list of     given STBC clients associated?the QOS
                                                                Add a new item v which covers
            DATAto accommodateto be sent as class 3
            Need frames allowed block ack function              NULL with Management Action body to
                                                                Add BA and BAR and all subvariants
D           what IBSS AC does a to add belong BAR
            withinTID or case. NeedTSPECBA and to?              class 1 control frame list. Add MA of
                                                                clarify
D           The use of the term "aggregated" is confusing       Change "Aggregated means feedback
D           What restrictive.
            and/oris the relationship between the MSDU          aggregated with any other response in the
                                                                Change the MSDU parameters to be
            size parameters and the size of an A-MPDU or
            MIXED mode setting in additional HT                 MPDU parameters to accommodate
                                                                Actually, the proposed language, "AP
            For the "operating mode" case "01" language
            information element - make specific in the          shall set the description ofmode when
                                                                Change mixed operating the bit
            In the first row of the table on this -- for the
            additional HT information elementpage, this         Move the cited of to operating mode
                                                                combination 01textthe an appropriate
            All of the "use" column describes behavior
            text inthe information fields in this MA frame      clause, such as 11, and add "shall" to the
                                                                Move the definitions of all information
            need to have definitions within 7.3.1 frame
            All of the information fields in this MA            fields the definitions of as new
                                                                Move of this MA Frameall information
            need to have definitions within 7.3.1 frame
            All of the information fields in this MA            Move the definitions of as new
                                                                fields of this MA Frameall information
            need to have definitions within 7.3.1 frame
            All of the information fields in this MA            Move of this MA Frameall information
                                                                fields the definitions of as new
            need to have definitions within 7.3.1 frame
            All of the information fields in this MA            fields of this MA Frameall information
                                                                Move the definitions of as new
            Row to have definitions within - what
            need 3 of the table - QOSNULL7.3.1 is               Please this MA coherent explanation of
                                                                fields ofprovide aFrame as new
            Row 3 of "can be - QOSNULL - block ack
            meant by the tablesent out of any too much          the description field for QOS NULL - I
                                                                Strike the sentence "This supports explicit
D           Isn't the HT control field included Same issue
            information in the comment field. in HT Control     feedback and channel
                                                                See Coment
            Frames. If so, this thisMode: to be refelected
            Table n19, Operating needs                          As suggested.
            A-MPDU sub-frame format: field determines
            Result of interpretation of this                    Clarify
D           QoS+Null is being re-defined here pattern
            (1) I do not understand why uniqueas a              Change entry in Table 1 in 7.1.3.1.2 row
D           Management Action frame
            Text below Table 1 no longer accurate               11-Data-1100 to indicate "QoS Null (no
                                                                Change text below Table 1 to remove the
D           Changes to 7.1.3.1.5 are confusing. Are             Please clarify 6 meaning this change
                                                                mention of bit the intent of"No Frame
            "frames exchanged between HT peers thatthe
            If the intent is to allow data in a frame with      Make change indicated in comment
D           "No Frame Body"excessive for listing these
            IE length of 26 is bit set, fix Table 1 in          Reduce the number of options. Reduce
D   Marc    capabilities. - "BSS does/does not…"
            STBC support                                        the number"device", remove conditional
                                                                Change to of bits needed to describe
    Shra    Definition of Explicit Feedback Format not in       Add to table n25, meaning isn't based
                                                                definition since itsor delete from Figure on
    van     Table n25
            Several fields of the Transmit beamforming          n22 are unused, state that the value
                                                                If they
            control field are not specified - Calibration
            MCMR Segment Sequence value unspecified             are reserved and set to and set to zero.
                                                                State that it is reserved zero
            No definition given for Explicit Channel            Mark that field as "Reserved", and set to
            Whether field
            feedback Transmit Beamforming Control field,        zero
                                                                Specify all the fields
            Some Matrices action field, not all of the
            or CSI of the HT Controlframes should be            Reconsider the classification of these
D   Adri    Table n6 - Spell Examples include more
            allowed in IBSS. the bit combinationthe             frames.
                                                                As suggested
D   an      This field which bit is necessary. If DS/CCK
            clearly (ie is clearly notmore significant etc      Delete the field
D   Srini   Given the large number do not include them
            rates are not supported, of optional frames, in     Move the Supported MCS set out of HT
D           This field is have a few bits set have its
            this field willa great candidate toto 1 (for own    Capability field into an Element. Create a
                                                                Make this Information IE
D   Srini   Group parameters danger of specifying too
            IE. There is no realbased on the functionality Move MCS feedback out of the Extended
            and put them in IEs to make the parsing of the HT Capability Info field
              Can a control channel's width can be anything     Clarify (in the draft) or delete "20 MHz"
              other than 20 MHz?for this particular restrction
              What is the reason                                from the description of "Control Channel"
                                                                Please clarify - preferably remove the
              (and perhaps not other type) "no APSD non-
              If you had a separate IE for STBC, you            sentence
                                                                Use a separate IE for STBC and delete
              The mixed mode field.
              wouldn’t need thisor non-GF mode appears to       the subfield "Secondary Beacon"
                                                                For both Operating mode, and Non-GF
              be based on association. But this is not
              What does a value of Unused (for Explicit         Devices Present, make the settings
                                                                Clarify
              What doesSequence)? How is (for MIMO CSI
              Feedback a value of Unused it indicated?          Clarify
              Matrices) mean? How is it indicated? How is it
              To ensure that the ordering of the encoded        As suggested.
              Update the frame usage a diagram with the
              bits is correct, please add                       As suggested
D             "Immediate Feeback SIFS after the PPDU that Add a sentence saying that in the case of
              contains Request" is Frames encapsulatedis        Add the immediate feedback follows the
              Management Action not useful when ZLF in ZLF,Management Action Frames
              QoS Null Data frames are missing.
              HT action frames                                  encapsulated in QoS Null Data frames to
                                                                These frames must not be a part of
              Format for Explicit Feedback Format field of      Managementrow in thissince they are sent
                                                                Add another Frames, table with Field
D             Figure n22 on page 60 needs to be defined in columnitbeing "Explicit Feedback Format"
              "Green Field preamble" is undefined Thus far Define in section 3
              What is negotiated_MPDU_limit in Fig. n33? Specify in detail.
D             Re-use of Order field for indicating whether      Consider using another mechanism for
                                     is included does
              the HT Control Field Channel Switch not
              The frame format of                               Consider whether a new Action Value
                                                                specifyingallocating HT Control Field is
D             Announcement is modified to include extra
              Why restrict feedback to immediate XOR            for the frame if the length of to 'Immediate
                                                                change the definition of '10' the frame is
D             unsolicited XOR aggregated
              Why restrict feedback to immediate XOR            feedback and unsolicited is allowed'
                                                                change the definition of '11' to 'Aggregate
D             unsolicited XOR aggregated                        feedback and unsolicited is allowed'
              Receiver shall honor TRQ, if it supports the Rx Add;
D                                        when the MPDU
              of Implicit TxBF, exceptmanagement frame
              Clarify that control and                          "Receiver shall honor TRQ,beit supports
                                                                "The HT Control Field may if included in
D             types may be +HTC                                 Restate as management or data frame
              Is Fragmentation between HT peers allowed? any control,"No fragmentation is allowed
D             Although order bit signaling to indicate the      Change the text to only allow HTC+can be
                                                                between HT Peers. Fragmentation frame
                          of HT control Null embedding of MA Modify the text to allow frames as well
              presence policy for QoSfield allows HT control for all Unicast QoS dataACK policies as
              The ACK
D   Tom       The transition time as identified in no-ACK.
              is suggested to be normal ACK or the table        Specify for
                                                                requiredit. aggregation/Block-ACK
    o         needs justify the reasons a known time for
              Pleaseto be referenced to for why the RIFS is Drop the word APSD from the text.
              To to be used only when APSD devices are
              not improve reliability the delimiter with length Make the modification.
              Be explicit about the instead ofof all bits used" Add a similar diagram as Fign55 with
              zero "shall be used" ordering "can be into the
D   Yuic      The comments on the add a diagram such as Change the details theinput/output.
              CRC-8 Gen. Perhaps first row, inclusion of        appropriate text in of table to "BlockAck
    hi        BlockAck in an A-MPDU states that BA may          SHALL be non-aggregate frame (see
              be aggregated. Note that statement in page- BlockAck explanation)". Alternatively,
              88 line 22-23 specifies that control frames use remove BA from this table and mandate
              non-HT basic rate according to sub clause         not to include BA in the A_MPDU
              9.6.2. and that is chosen primarily (amongst a aggregation even if it is delayed BA with
              few reasons) so that the legacy STAs and          no ACK.
              OBSS STAs can hear the legacy PPDU and
              set their NAV accordingly. If however the         Efficiency improvement can be achieved
              transmitter obeys the rate decision rule but      by RIFS/SIFS bursting instead.
              use A-MPDU aggregation this defeats the
              purpose.



D   Sanji   1 "When a responder is unable to provide an    "When a responder is unable to provide
D   v         Need more granularity/range and sets MFB
            4 immediate response to MRQ in specifying to   an immediate response to MRQ and sets
                                                           Use some reserved bits (B3-B5, say) to
              transition + HTC no ACK policy to SIFS/RIFS at
              Qos Null time. Could go down is legal        increase range & granularity. 6 replace
                                                           In the line of B5B6=00 of Table
                                                           Do not allow BAR data) frames, this is
              Control frames (including BAR and BA) should "For QoS Null (no and BA frames to bethe
              be always sent using legacy PPDU             Include a figure with aggregates. Indicate
              Add a figure that shows a +HTC control frame included in A-MPDU specified change
              (Control frame with HT control field)
D                  Supported MCS table for STBC is not defined.          Add a separate MCS table for STBC
                   Table n25 does not specify all of the fields in       All fields should be included. All zeros
                   Transmit Beamforming Control
                   Value should be specified for unused Explicit         values for Explicit Feedback Format and
                                                                         Specify all zeros value
                   Feedback Sequence field
                   All fields in CSI Matrices Control Field need to      Define Explicit Channel Feedback bit, and
                   All defined CSI Matrices Control Field need to
                   be fields in in Table n30, and values for             Define all zeros values Feedback fields.
                                                                         specify Explicit Channel in reservedbit, and
                   be fields in in Table n37, and values for
                   All defined CSI Matrices Control Field need to        Define all zeros values Feedback fields.
                                                                         specify Explicit Channel in reservedbit, and
                   Qos Null + HTC no n44, policy is legal
                   be defined in Table ACK and values for                In the line zeros values in reserved fields.
                                                                         specify all of B5B6=00 of Table 6 replace
                   define HT PPDU for the multicast frames               "For after “in whichdata) frames, this is the
                                                                         Add QoS Null (no case QSTAs use QoS
D   Solo           Separated supported MCS set for 20Mhz and             New frames.” All HT STAs use non HT
                                                                         data field
D   mon
    Solo           40Mhz
                   Separated basic MCS set for 20Mhz and                 New field
    mon            40Mhzaggregation of the multicast frames
                   define                                                Add Table n50a – Multicast MPDUs
D                  I believe this statement assumes the fact that        Aggregation MPDU that was added: "It
                                                                         Delete the sentence
                   The duration/ID field should also frames
                   clause 9 indicates that all Unicasttake into          is set to 0 in all frames LongNAV
                                                                         Change to accomdate exchanged
D                  consideration LongNAV mechanism, where is
                   How are the transition time fields defined? It        operation.
D                  a mystery to me.in HTC should not imply type
                   Bits themselves                                       How about this ?
                   of response, I the multicast frames is
                   HT PPDU for think.                                    Add after 10 – Immediate feedback" by
                                                                         Replace " “in which case QSTAs use QoS
    Amit           undefined of the multicast frames is
                   Aggregation                                           data Table n50a –HT STAs use non HT
                                                                         Add frames.” All Multicast MPDUs
                   undefined is to allow data in a frame with the
                   If the intent                                         AggregationMPDU
                                                                         As in comment
D           Am     "No Frame Body"MPDUs fix unclear in
                   duration value of bit set, is Table 1                 specify the value of duration
            it B   It seems the intent is to define a common             As in comment
D                  Zero TxOP extension of the sounding
                   frame format for manyfor ZLFManagement                Extend "followed by ZLF" to "or A-MSDU
D                  No more different requests                            Remove the sentence any ACK "The
                                                                         or A-MPDU along with started byor Block
                   No reason was provided for prohibiting                Feedback Request field contains position
                                                                         Include BAR in Table n48.
R                  Immediate BAR to be aggregated using A- but Remove the use of BA/MTBA and
                   Similar comment with respect to Table n48
                   this time it applies to both BA/MTBA and    BAR/MTBAR from A-MPDU aggregation.
                   BAR/MTBAR.

C                  Needs to specify what is the PHY-bit-rate used
                   for calculations. Is implies that you rate that the
                   The last sentence it the max PHY can only             Delete the last sentence on line 17, or
                   include the HT Control frame in MPDUs that            add text to describe why you can only
                   also include a QOS Control frame. Is this             include the HT Control Field in QoS
                   what was meant? It seems like this is a pretty        frames.
D   Srini          A status code that AP denies association              Add a status code for the HT AP to deny
                   when a STA does not meet the 802.11n                  association due to the requesting STA not
                   feature should be defined.                            supporting the 802.11n feature.
C           "the number of bytes between the start of two    "the time interval in us between the start
            consecutive MPDUs in A-MPDU shall be equal       of two consecutive MPDUs in an A-MPDU
            or greater than MPDU-density*PHY-bit-rate/8".    shall be greater than or equal to MPDU-
            Not required if MPDU density is 1 every 4 us     density.", OR delete that clause
            or 8us. Here, the GI will fill in some spaces.   altogether.
            Incidentally, the field would be more
            appropriately called "MPDU sparseness" since
            it is really the reciprocal of MPDU density.


C           The subclause number in Tgma Draft 3.2 is        Expand the Ack Policy to include
            7.3.2.30. Perhaps it makes sense to add the      compressed bit map (or at least clarify
            type of Block Ack that is being used as this     what the current encoding refers to)
            could be significant.

R           Define a new IE for MCS Set and use it for   As suggested
            Basic MCS Set - also allow variable size for
            the MCS set. Let us not just have long
            beacons and probe responses if we don’t hae
            to.




D   Srini   Surely there should be some new reason           Add a few reason codes
            codes for disassociation - such as not
R           switching the required mode etc. would be
            Additional HT Information Element                Consider adding Additional HT
            useful in Measurement Pilot Frames               Information Element to Measurement
                                                             Pilot Frames
R   The MIMO power save field in the HT                   Change the MIMO power save field in the
    Capabilities Info field overlaps with MIMO            HT Capabilities Info field from 2 bits to 1
    Power Save Management Action Frame                    bit where 0 indicating not support and 1
    defined in clause 7.4.7.2. Here in the HT             indicating support of MIMO power save.
    Capabilities Info field, only 1 bit, where 0 to not   Or, if it wants to be kept as 2 bits, change
    support and 1 to support MIMO power save,             the allocation as follows to have 00 the
    should be enough.                                     case with no restrictions and to be
    If it wants to be kept as 2 bits, 00 should be        consistent with those in the MIMO Power
    when MIMO enabled (no restrictions on what            Save Management Action Frame:
    may be sent to the STA).                                00 MIMO enabled (no restrictions on
                                                          what may be sent to the STA)
                                                            01 Reserved
                                                            10 Static MIMO power save mode (the
                                                          STA is not capable of receiving any MIMO
                                                          PPDU)
                                                            11 Dynamic MIMO power save mode
                                                          (the STA requires a non-MIMO wakeup
A   The receiver address is ambiguous.                    Change receiver address to Address 1
                                                          value.




T   Why not allow PSMP use of this frame?         Modify the text to allow any ack policy
                                                  setting for the QOS NULL + HTC + MA
                                                  frame. The use of no-ack policy for CSI
                                                  feedback in some cases should be noted
                                                  in the subclause which describes the
                                                  allowed behaviors in the feedback
A   There are QoS CF-Ack frames in Applicable     mechanism - clause frames from linesbut
                                                  Delete QoS CF-Ack 9.20.3.2, I think, 5
    Frame (sub) Types of lines 5 and 7 in Table 4 and 7 in Table 4.
    but actually, QoS CF-Ack frame is not used
    independently.
                                                                    order
                                      Resol


                                          in
                                     Edited




                                                  lookup
                                      ution


                                       draft




                                                            Group




                                                                      My
                                                    Topic

                                                            Topic
                                               A-MPDU       Fram
                                               A-MPDU       e
                                                            Fram
                                               A-MPDU       e
                                                            Fram
Ed: reclassified as technical                  A-MPDU       e
                                                            Fram
                                               A-MSDU       e
                                                            Fram
Transfer to Frame Format ad hoc                Beamfor      e
                                                            Fram
                                               ming
                                               Manage       e
                                                            Fram
Gen AdHoc: Transfer to Frame Format            ment
                                               General      e
                                                            Fram
Gen AdHoc: Transfer to Frame Format            General      e
                                                            Fram
The chair takes an action item to get          Frame        e
                                                            Fram
further clarification from the commenter
see CID 1131                                   Formats
                                               Frame        e
                                                            Fram
Requires a submission to further clarify       Formats
                                               TSPEC        e
                                                            Fram
the proposed relationship                      HT           e
                                                            Fram
                                               Element
                                               HT           e
                                                            Fram
                                               Element
                                               HT           e
                                                            Fram
PSMP: Transfer to Frames as they are           Element
                                               PSMP         e
                                                            Fram
Transfer all the MA frames definitions
handling to Frame Format ad hoc                Beamfor      e
                                                            Fram
Transfer to Frame Format ad hoc                ming
                                               Beamfor      e
                                                            Fram
Transfer to Frame Format ad hoc                ming
                                               Beamfor      e
                                                            Fram
Transfer to Frame Format ad hoc                ming
                                               Beamfor      e
                                                            Fram
                                               ming
                                               A-MPDU       e
                                                            Fram
                                               A-MPDU       e
                                                            Fram
Deferred until a decision is made on           Frame        e
                                                            Fram
which frame types can carry HTC fields.        Formats
                                               HT           e
                                                            Fram
                                               Element
                                               A-MPDU       e
                                                            Fram
Chair to get more clarification from the       Frame        e
                                                            Fram
commenter more clarification from the
Chair to get                                   Formats
                                               Frame        e
                                                            Fram
commenter this jointly with the MAC
Will discuss                                   Formats
                                               Frame        e
                                                            Fram
adhoc. This adhoc group believes that          Formats
                                               Frame        e
                                                            Fram
Srini will bring in a submission to further    Formats
                                               HT           e
                                                            Fram
support the requestsubmission tothe
Marc will provide a for reducing clarify       Element
                                               HT           e
                                                            Fram
Transfer to Frame Format of hoc
and clean up the definition ad various         Element
                                               Beamfor      e
                                                            Fram
Transfer to Frame Format ad hoc                ming
                                               Beamfor      e
                                                            Fram
Transfer to Frame Format ad hoc                ming
                                               Beamfor      e
                                                            Fram
Transfer to Frame Format ad hoc                ming
                                               Beamfor      e
                                                            Fram
Transfer to Frame Format ad hoc                ming
                                               Beamfor      e
                                                            Fram
Gen AdHoc: Transfer to FrameFormat             ming
                                               General      e
                                                            Fram
Adrian will bring a submission to              Frame        e
                                                            Fram
present a solution to the bit and the
The group had a straw poll numbering           Formats
                                               HT           e
                                                            Fram
Srini 3/3
resultwill bring in a submission               Element
                                               HT           e
                                                            Fram
Show benefit in adding another IE              Element
                                               HT           e
                                                            Fram
Show benefit in adding another IE              Element
                                               HT           e
                                                            Fram
                                               Element      e
                                              HT        Fram
                                              Element
                                              HT        e
                                                        Fram
                                              Element
                                              HT        e
                                                        Fram
Ed: reclassified as technical.                Element
                                              HT        e
                                                        Fram
Transfer to Frame Format ad hoc               Element
                                              Beamfor   e
                                                        Fram
Transfer to Frame Format ad hoc               ming
                                              Beamfor   e
                                                        Fram
                                              ming
                                              A-MPDU    e
                                                        Fram
                                              A-MPDU    e
                                                        Fram
see CID 1131                                  Frame     e
                                                        Fram
Gen AdHoc: Transfer to Frame Format           Formats
                                              General   e
                                                        Coexi
Gen AdHoc: Transfer to FrameFormat            General   stenc
                                                        Fram
Transfer to Frame Format ad hoc               Beamfor   e
                                                        Fram
Request a submission to define GF             ming
                                              HT        e
                                                        Fram
preamble, short GI, LDPC, MIMO                Element
                                              A-MPDU    e
                                                        Fram
Request submission from the                   Frame     e
                                                        Fram
commenter                                     Formats
                                              Manage    e
                                                        Fram
see CID 1131                                  ment
                                              Frame     e
                                                        Fram
see CID 1131                                  Formats
                                              Frame     e
                                                        Fram
Request more info from commenter              Formats
                                              Frame     e
                                                        Fram
                                              Formats
                                              Frame     e
                                                        Fram
                                              Formats
                                              Frame     e
                                                        Fram
                                              Formats
                                              Frame     e
                                                        Fram
Instruct the editor to add the following to   Formats
                                              Manage    e
                                                        Fram
the section "When a QoS Null a
Tomo will submit text to show                 ment
                                              HT        e
                                                        Fram
reference point for the transition time.      Element
                                              HT        e
                                                        Fram
                                              Element
                                              A-MPDU    e
                                                        Fram
                                              A-MPDU    e
                                                        Fram
It's agreed that a resolution is deferred     A-MPDU    e
                                                        Fram
until a submission (work in progress by                 e
Yuichi et all) is put forward to further                Form
clarify section 9.6                                     at




Edit Notes (D1.03) ER: <This resolution       Frame     Fram
commits TGn to accept an as-yet
Need a submission from the                    Formats
                                              HT        e
                                                        Fram
commenter to support more values for          Element
                                              Frame     e
                                                        Fram
                                              Formats
                                              A-MPDU    e
                                                        Fram
Ed AdHoc: Transfer to Gen AdHoc               Frame     e
Gen AdHoc: Transfer to Frame                  Formats
John K. will take the action item to         HT       Fram
clarify with the commenter ad hoc
Transfer to Frame Format                     Element
                                             Beamfor  e
                                                      Fram
Transfer to Frame Format ad hoc              ming
                                             Beamfor  e
                                                      Fram
Transfer to Frame Format ad hoc              ming
                                             Beamfor  e
                                                      Fram
Transfer to Frame Format ad hoc              ming
                                             Beamfor  e
                                                      Fram
Transfer to Frame Format ad hoc              ming
                                             Beamfor  e
                                                      Fram
                                             ming
                                             Frame    e
                                                      Fram
                                             Formats
                                             Frame    e
                                                      Fram
Agreed with the suggestion. A                Formats
                                             HT       e
                                                      Fram
submission is required to specify the
Submission required                          Element
                                             HT       e
                                                      Fram
Poll1: do we allow multicast in A-           Element
                                             A-MPDU   e
                                                      Fram
MPDU?
A vote was conducted to accept this          Frame    e
                                                      Fram
comment. The result was 5 yes and 3          Formats e
                                             Frame
The specified values for the transition      Formats Fram
                                             HT
time CID 1131
see were derived from numerous               Element e
                                             Frame    Fram
                                             Formats e
                                             Frame    Fram
Poll1: do we allow multicast in A-           Formats e
                                             A-MPDU Fram
MPDU? Yes/No/Abstain 8/0/0 Poll2:            Frame    e
                                                      Fram
Amit Bangal will provide a submission                 e
                                             Formats Fram
                                             Frame
to further define the duration value of
Ed: agree with the comment. Need a           Formats e
                                             Beamfor Fram
submission to tidy up all the related
MAC: transfer to frame                       ming
                                             MAC      e
                                                      Fram
Defer - U1131 CID 12001
see CID - see                                         e
                                             Operatio Fram
                                             Frame
Proposed reject. Aggregating BAR in A-       Formats e
                                             A-MPDU Fram
MPDU introduces a single point of
 reject. Presumably the comment              A-MPDU e Fram   283
relates to CID 7254. The same                         e
resolution applies here too.                          Form
                                                      at
 counter. It is the actual data rate.        A-MPDU Fram     237
 counter. The in sentence reads:
This is clarifiedlastthe resolution to CID   Frame    e
                                                      Fram   465
"The HT Control Field may be included        Formats e
in any frame except a non-QoS Data                    Form
frame." replace this with "The HT                     at
Since this CID is similar to approved        Manage Fram     387
CID 26                                       ment     e
                                             Frames Form
                                                      at
See resolution to CID 551 which has          HT      Fram    434
benn resolved in D1.05                       Element e
                                             s       Form
                                                     at




D1.05, Reference CID 64                      TSPEC    Fram   299
                                                      e
                                                      Form
                                                      at

Rejected. The grouping of fields under       HT      Fram    317
each IE have been carefully designed         Element e
and approved by TGn. Strawpoll is 19/8       s       Form
to approve the rejection.                            at




Srini will bring in a submission to          Manage   Fram   297
request additing of Association and          ment     e
Disassociation Information Element
The Additional codes. This does not          Frames
                                             HT       Form
                                                      Fram   271
also contains operating mode and             Element e
capability fields for optional features of   s       Form
11n.                                                 at
In addition, the purpose of a
measurement pilot frame is to indicate
the presence of the AP. If the station is
interested in the AP capabilities, it can
send send a probe request.
Rejected. The group does not feel that   HT      Fram    7
the existing encoding scheme has any     Element e
issue.                                   s       Form
                                                 at




Accepted                                 A-MSDU Fram    437
                                                e
                                                Form
                                                ats

Transferred to PSMP group per request    PSMP   PSM     100
of the PSMP chair (10/18/06).                   P

When a QoS Null embedding of
management action is included in a
PSMP, the only permitted ACK policy is
No Ack."
Accepted                                 Frame   Fram    3
                                         Formats e
                                                 Form
                                                 at
                   e




                                                                   Line(E
CID




              Name




              Claus




                                                )


                                                      Type
                  of




              Page(
                  C)


                                          Line(C
             enter(




                                                         of




                                                        No

                                                        /N)
                                                     Page(




                                                                       d)
             Comm




               er(C)




                                                       ent




                                                       Ed)
             Numb




                                                    Comm

                                                    Part of

                                                    Vote(Y
      3704   Kandala,   7.1.3.5.3    16             T   Y     16
      2007   Srinivas
             Ji,        7.2.3.1      32   15        T   Y     32            15
      4281   Lusheng
             Leach,     7.2.3.1      32   15        T   N     32            15
      2144   David
             Ji,        7.3.2.47.3   44   2         T   Y     44             2
      2145   Lusheng
             Ji,        7.3.2.47.3   44   3         T   Y     44             3
      2130   Lusheng
             Ji,        7.3.2.47.2   42   3         T   N     42             3
      1142   Lusheng
             Fischer,   7.2.2.1      31   8         T   Y     31             8
      1143   Matthew
             Fischer,   7.2.2.1      31   12        T   Y     31            12
      4756   Matthew
             McCann,    7.4A.1       79   0         T   Y     79             0
             Stephen
                                Assig




                                                                  e
              E/HE/




                                 nee
Claus




             Duplic




                        Resn
                       Status
               Type




                CID




                                        Submi




                                                 appro




                                                               sed
e(Ed)




              ate of




                                         ssion




                                                             Comm
                                                                ent
                                                             Propo

                                                             Chang
                                                   val
                                                  TGn
              T(Ed)
             T/ST/D




                                                                      hi
                                                                       s
                                                                      is
                                                                       T
7.1.3.5.3    DT        R                                 Table 6:     The
7.2.3.1      DT        R                                 ACK
                                                         Beacon       alternative
                                                                      Reduce
7.2.3.1      DT        R                                 bloat.do
                                                         Why          the
                                                                      Merge
7.3.2.47.3   DT        R                                 we have
                                                         Add N-       "Additional
                                                                      Make
7.3.2.47.3   DT        R                                 Delayed
                                                         Since        change
                                                                      Make
7.3.2.47.2   T         R                         14      these
                                                         in row       change to
                                                                      Change
7.2.2.1      T         R                         13      "MIMO
                                                         The note     "STA is
                                                                      Delete the
7.2.2.1      T         R                         13      has no
                                                         The note     text "Note
                                                                      Delete the
7.4A.1       T         R                                 has no the
                                                         Why is       text "Note
                                                                      Clarificatio
                                                         unique       n required
                                  order
 s Resol




        in




                    p




                    p
                looku
hi Edited




               Group
               Looku
is ution




is draft




                                    My
                Topic


                Topic
hi




 s




                                          hi
                                           s
                                          is
                         D
                         u
                         m
                         m
 T




 T




                                           T
similar       Frame      Frame     278
reason
The           Formats
              Managem    Format
                         Frame     199
distributio
The           ent
              Managem    Format
                         Frame     367
distributio
R-            ent
              HT         Format
                         Frame     229
Already
Rejected      Elements
              HT         Format
                         Frame     230
since the
Rejected.     Elements
              HT         Format
                         Frame
A STA in
Rejected.     Elements
              A-MSDU     Format
                         Frame
Edit Notes
Rejected.     A-MSDU     Format
                         Frame
Edit Notes
Propose       A-MPDU     Format
                         Frame     391
reject.                  Format
                                                      CID




                   5140 Y
                                                      Part of No Vote(Y/N)
                                                      Page(Ed)




                   43
                                                      Line(Ed)
                                                      Clause Title(Ed)




1 HT

  s Info field
                                                      Clause(Ed)




  Capabilitie .47.2
               7.3.2 T
                                                      Type E/HE/T/ST/DT(Ed)

                                                      Duplicate of CID

                   T                                  Resn Status

                               This is a dummy entry.
                               Please do not delete or
                               sort out of the top of
                               the sheet. This is a
                               dummy entry. Please
                               to not delete or sort out
        replace 'BSS' with




                               of the top of the
        "infrastructure BSS'




                               sheet.This is a dummy
                               entry. Please to not      Proposed Change
                                                                                                                                          This is a dummy entry.
                                                                                                                                          Please do not delete or
                                                                                                                                          sort out of the top of
                                                                                                                                          the sheet. This is a
                                                                                                                                          dummy entry. Please
                                                                                                                                          to not delete or sort out
                                                                                                                                          of the top of the
                                                                                                                                          sheet.This is a dummy
                                                                                                                                          entry. Please to not
                                                                                                                                          delete or sort out of the
                                                                                                                                          top of the sheet. This is
                                                                                                                                          a dummy entry. Please
                                                                                                                                          to not delete or sort out
                                                                                                                                          of the top of the
                                                                                                                                          sheet.This is a dummy




Set to 1 if the AP supports use of PSMP
                                                                                                                                          entry. Please to not
                                                                                                                                          delete or sort out of the
                                                                                                                                          top of the sheet. This is




Set to 0 if the AP does not support use of PSMP
                                                                                                                                          a dummy entry. Please



                                                             AP/non-AP distinction, which achieves the same effect:
                                                                                                                                          do not delete or sort
                                                                                                                                          out of the top of the
                                                                                                                                          sheet.This is a dummy
                                                                                                                                          entry. Please do not
                                                             to 0 for IBSS" creates an exception, which will generate negative



"In Beacon and Probe Response frames transmitted by an AP:                                                                                delete or sort out of the
                                                                                                                                          top of the sheet. This is
                                                             Accept the proposed change. Edit Notes (D1.03) EMR: <The change is


                                                             comments. Propose the following functionality based on frame type and
                                                             not sufficient. The list of conditions is based on frame type. Adding "Set




                                                                                                                                          a dummy entry. Please Resolution
                                                                                                                           D1.03




                                                                                                                                                                Edited in draft
                                                             s
                                                             El




                                                                                                                                          Dummy Entry           Topic lookup
                                                             HT


                                                             ent
                                                             em
Frame Format
                                       Topic Group Lookup




               This is a dummy entry.
               Please do not delete or
               sort out of the top of
               the sheet. This is a
               dummy entry. Please
               to not delete or sort out My order
                                              CID


                                              Name of
                                              Commente
                                              r(Ed)




10326 Kwak, Joe
                                              Clause
                                              Number(C)




                  2186 Ji, Lusheng 7.3.2.48




Annex A
                  53
                                              Page(C)




269
                  0
                                              Line(C)




HTM13
T
                  T
                                              Type of
                                              Comment




Y
                  Y
                                              Part of No
                                              Vote(Y/N)
                                              Page(Ed)




269
                  53
                                              Line(Ed)




  n
                                              Clause




  HT
  onal




  ents
  Infor


  Elem

0 PICS
                                              Title(Ed)




  matio
0 Additi
 8118 Tsoulogian 7.4A.2     80    28-29    T   Y   80 28 A-
      nis, Tom                                           MPD
                                                         U
                                                         Conte
                                                         nts




10330 Kwak, Joe   Annex A   271   HTP1.3   T   Y   271   0 PICS




 2367 Ji, Lusheng 7.4A      78    3        T   N   78    3 Aggre
                                                           gated
                                                           MPD
                                                           U
                                                           frame
                                                           s
3800 Kandala,   7.4.7.10     78           T   Y   78    PSM
     Srinivas                                           P




6843 Myles,     7.1.3.1.10   15   16-17   T   Y   15 16 Order
     Andrew                                             field




1483 Fischer,   General                   T   Y    0    Gener
     Matthew                                            al
7013 O'Hara,     7.4A     78   2    T   Y   78   2 Aggre
     Bob                                           gated
                                                   MPD
                                                   U
                                                   frame
                                                   s




2369 Ji, Lusheng 7.4A.1   78   11   T   Y   78 11 Aggre
                                                  gated
                                                  MPD
                                                  U
                                                  forma
                                                  t (A-
                                                  MPD
                                                  U)
2365 Ji, Lusheng 7.4A               78   1   T   Y   78   1 Aggre
                                                            gated
                                                            MPD
                                                            U
                                                            frame
                                                            s




 766 Durand,    7.2.2.1 and table            T   Y   30    Aggre
     Roger      n15                                        gated
                                                           MSD
                                                           U
                                                           Form
                                                           at (A-
                                                           MSD
                                                           U)
  809 Durand,     General             T   Y   0      Gener
      Roger                                          al




 2195 Ji, Lusheng 7.3.2.48   54   0   T   Y   54   0 Additi
                                                     onal
                                                     HT
                                                     Infor
                                                     matio
                                                     n
                                                     Elem
                                                     ents
12252 Kumar,      7.2.2      30   9   T   Y   30   9 Data
      Rajneesh                                       frame
                                                     s
2184 Ji, Lusheng 7.3.2.48   53   0   T   Y   53   0 Additi
                                                    onal
                                                    HT
                                                    Infor
                                                    matio
                                                    n
                                                    Elem
                                                    ents
2188 Ji, Lusheng 7.3.2.48   53   0   T   Y   53   0 Additi
                                                    onal
                                                    HT
                                                    Infor
                                                    matio
                                                    n
                                                    Elem
                                                    ents




2192 Ji, Lusheng 7.3.2.48   54   0   T   Y   54   0 Additi
                                                    onal
                                                    HT
                                                    Infor
                                                    matio
                                                    n
                                                    Elem
                                                    ents
1208 Fischer,    7.3.2.48   55       T   Y   55     Additi
     Matthew                                        onal
                                                    HT
                                                    Infor
                                                    matio
                                                    n
                                                    Elem
                                                    ents


4074 Kerry,      7.4A       78   3   T   N   78   3 Aggre
     Stuart                                         gated
                                                    MPD
                                                    U
                                                    frame
                                                    s
2193 Ji, Lusheng 7.3.2.48   54   0   T   Y   54   0 Additi
                                                    onal
                                                    HT
                                                    Infor
                                                    matio
                                                    n
                                                    Elem
                                                    ents


7818 SURINENI, 7.4.7.4      60   2   T   Y   60   2 MIMO
     SHRAVAN                                        Chan
                                                    nel
                                                    Meas
                                                    urem
                                                    ent
                                                    frame

8079 Trainin,    7.4A.2     80       T   Y   80     A-
     Solomon                                        MPD
                                                    U
                                                    Conte
                                                    nts




2231 Ji, Lusheng 7.4.7.1    58   4   E   N   58   4 Reco
                                                    mmen
                                                    ded
                                                    Trans
                                                    missi
                                                    on
                                                    Chan
                                                    nel
                                                    Width
                                                    Mana
                                                    geme
                                                    nt
                                                    Action
                                                    Fram
                                                    e
 2245 Ji, Lusheng 7.4.7.3    59   8         E   N   59   8 PCO
                                                           Phas
                                                           e
                                                           Requ
                                                           est
                                                           Mana
                                                           geme
                                                           nt
                                                           Action
                                                           Fram
                                                           e

 2176 Ji, Lusheng 7.3.2.48   52   3         E   N   52   3 Additi
                                                           onal
                                                           HT
                                                           Infor
                                                           matio
                                                           n
                                                           Elem
                                                           ents
 8145 Van Nee,    7.4A.1                    T   Y   78     Aggre
      Richard                                              gated
                                                           MPD
                                                           U
                                                           forma
                                                           t (A-
                                                           MPD
                                                           U)

12256 Kumar,      7.4A       78   General   T   Y   78   0 Aggre
      Rajneesh                                             gated
                                                           MPD
                                                           U
                                                           frame
                                                           s
 495 Choudhury, 7.4A1   78   3    T   Y   78   3 Aggre
     Abhijit                                     gated
                                                 MPD
                                                 U
                                                 forma
                                                 t (A-
                                                 MPD
                                                 U)




3695 Kandala,   7       14   22   T   Y   14 22 Fram
     Srinivas                                   e
                                                forma
                                                ts
 2233 Ji, Lusheng 7.4.7.1    58   4    T   Y   58   4 Reco
                                                      mmen
                                                      ded
                                                      Trans
                                                      missi
                                                      on
                                                      Chan
                                                      nel
                                                      Width
                                                      Mana
                                                      geme
                                                      nt
                                                      Action
                                                      Fram
                                                      e


 7882 Takagi,     7.2.2      29        T   Y   29     Data
      Masahiro                                        frame
                                                      s




 4282 Leach,      7.3.2.48   52   1        N   52   1 Additi
      David                                           onal
                                                      HT
                                                      Infor
                                                      matio
                                                      n
                                                      Elem
                                                      ents


12253 Kumar,      7.2.3      30   22   T   Y   30 22 Mana
      Rajneesh                                       geme
                                                     nt
                                                     frame
                                                     s
 652 CYPHER,     7.3.2.48   53   T   Y   53   Additi
     DAVID                                    onal
                                              HT
                                              Infor
                                              matio
                                              n
                                              Elem
                                              ents




7606 Stephens,   7.4A.2          T   N   80   A-
     Adrian                                   MPD
                                              U
                                              Conte
                                              nts




3713 Kandala,    7.1.3.8         T   Y   17   HT
     Srinivas                                 Contr
                                              ol
                                              Field
1231 Fischer,   7.4.7.2              T   Y   58   MIMO
     Matthew                                      Powe
                                                  r
                                                  Save
                                                  Mana
                                                  geme
                                                  nt
                                                  Action
                                                  Fram
                                                  e




 475 Chaplin,   7.3.2.48   54        T   Y   54   Additi
     Clint                                        onal
                                                  HT
                                                  Infor
                                                  matio
                                                  n
                                                  Elem
                                                  ents
 765 Durand,    7.2.1.2              T   Y   22   CTS
     Roger                                        frame
                                                  forma
                                                  t




7816 SURINENI, 7.4.7.10    76   13   E/T Y   76 13 PSM
     SHRAVAN                                       P
2029 Ji, Lusheng 7.2.3.7   34   11   T   Y   34 11 Reas
                                                   sociat
                                                   ion
                                                   Resp
                                                   onse
                                                   frame
                                                   forma
                                                   t



2020 Ji, Lusheng 7.2.3.5   33   17   T   N   33 17 Assoc
                                                   iation
                                                   Resp
                                                   onse
                                                   frame
                                                   forma
                                                   t




2246 Ji, Lusheng 7.4.7.3   59   8    T   Y   59   8 PCO
                                                    Phas
                                                    e
                                                    Requ
                                                    est
                                                    Mana
                                                    geme
                                                    nt
                                                    Action
                                                    Fram
                                                    e

7814 SURINENI, 7.3.2.48    54        T   N   54    Additi
     SHRAVAN                                       onal
                                                   HT
                                                   Infor
                                                   matio
                                                   n
                                                   Elem
                                                   ents
 2377 Ji, Lusheng 7.4A.2     80    30    T   Y    80 30 A-
                                                        MPD
                                                        U
                                                        Conte
                                                        nts




 1007 Fischer,    11.14.1    151   27    T   Y   151 27 PSD
      Matthew                                           U
                                                        Lengt
                                                        h
                                                        Limit
                                                        Rules

10100 Yee, James 7.3.2.48    53    n19   T   N    53   1 Additi
                                                         onal
                                                         HT
                                                         Infor
                                                         matio
                                                         n
                                                         Elem
                                                         ents




 2189 Ji, Lusheng 7.3.2.48   53    0     T   Y    53   0 Additi
                                                         onal
                                                         HT
                                                         Infor
                                                         matio
                                                         n
                                                         Elem
                                                         ents

 1009 Fischer,    11.14.1    152   13    T   Y   152 13 PSD
      Matthew                                           U
                                                        Lengt
                                                        h
                                                        Limit
                                                        Rules
 5134 Meylan,     7.1.3.8      18   11   T   Y   18 11 HT
      Arnaud                                           Contr
                                                       ol
                                                       Field




 1200 Fischer,    7.3.2.47.8   52   5    T   Y   52   5 Additi
      Matthew                                           onal
                                                        HT
                                                        Infor
                                                        matio
                                                        n
                                                        Elem
                                                        ents


 2180 Ji, Lusheng 7.3.2.48     52   5    T   Y   52   5 Additi
                                                        onal
                                                        HT
                                                        Infor
                                                        matio
                                                        n
                                                        Elem
                                                        ents
 6906 Nanda,      7.3.2.48     52   5    T   Y   52   5 Additi
      Sanjiv                                            onal
                                                        HT
                                                        Infor
                                                        matio
                                                        n
                                                        Elem
                                                        ents
10369 Engwer,     7.4A.1.2               T   Y   79     De-
      Darwin                                            aggre
                                                        gation
                                                        (Infor
                                                        mativ
                                                        e)



 1179 Fischer,    7.3.2.47.1   41   6    T   Y   41   6 HT
      Matthew                                           Capa
                                                        bility
                                                        eleme
                                                        nt
6774 Morioka,    7.3.2.48   53    Table n19    T   Y   53  1 Additi
     Yuichi                                                  onal
                                                             HT
                                                             Infor
                                                             matio
                                                             n
                                                             Elem
                                                             ents
1244 Fischer,    7.4.7.9                       T   Y   75    Anten
     Matthew                                                 na
                                                             Select
                                                             ion
                                                             Indice
                                                             s
                                                             Feed
                                                             back
                                                             Fram
                                                             e
2373 Ji, Lusheng 7.4A.1.2   79    22footnote   T   N   79 24 De-
                                                             aggre
                                                             gation
                                                             (Infor
                                                             mativ
                                                             e)

2828 Ji, Lusheng 11.14.1    151   8            T   Y   151   8 PSD
                                                               U
                                                               Lengt
                                                               h
                                                               Limit
                                                               Rules
   3 Adachi,     11.14.1    151   9-10         T   Y   151   9 PSD
     Tomoko                                                    U
                                                               Lengt
                                                               h
                                                               Limit
                                                               Rules
7480 Stephens,   11.14.1                       T   N   151     PSD
     Adrian                                                    U
                                                               Lengt
                                                               h
                                                               Limit
                                                               Rules
1008 Fischer,    11.14.1    152   1            T   Y   152   1 PSD
     Matthew                                                   U
                                                               Lengt
                                                               h
                                                               Limit
                                                               Rules
4014 Kerry,      11.14.1      151   10   T   Y   151 10 PSD
     Stuart                                             U
                                                        Lengt
                                                        h
                                                        Limit
                                                        Rules




2371 Ji, Lusheng 7.4A.1.1     79    13   T   Y    79 13 CRC




2036 Ji, Lusheng 7.2.3.9      34    23   T   Y    34 23 Probe
                                                        Resp
                                                        onse
                                                        frame
                                                        forma
                                                        t




1210 Fischer,    7.4.7.1      58    4    T   Y    58   4 Reco
     Matthew                                             mmen
                                                         ded
                                                         Trans
                                                         missi
                                                         on
                                                         Chan
                                                         nel
                                                         Width
                                                         Mana
                                                         geme
                                                         nt
                                                         Action
                                                         Fram
                                                         e


2139 Ji, Lusheng 7.3.2.47.2   43    0    T   Y    43   0 HT
                                                         Capa
                                                         bilities
                                                         Info
                                                         field
 665 CYPHER,    7.4A.2       80   30   T   Y   80 30 A-
     DAVID                                           MPD
                                                     U
                                                     Conte
                                                     nts
3716 Kandala,   7.1.3.8      20        T   Y   20    HT
     Srinivas                                        Contr
                                                     ol
                                                     Field




3717 Kandala,   7.1.3.8      21        T   Y   21    HT
     Srinivas                                        Contr
                                                     ol
                                                     Field




3772 Kandala,   7.3.2.48     52        T   Y   52    Additi
     Srinivas                                        onal
                                                     HT
                                                     Infor
                                                     matio
                                                     n
                                                     Elem
                                                     ents




3803 Kandala,   7.4.7.3                T   Y   59    PCO
     Srinivas                                        Phas
                                                     e
                                                     Requ
                                                     est
                                                     Mana
                                                     geme
                                                     nt
                                                     Action
                                                     Fram
                                                     e

3750 Kandala,   7.3.2.47.2   42        T   Y   42    HT
     Srinivas                                        Capa
                                                     bilities
                                                     Info
                                                     field
   4 Adachi,     11.14.1    151   12-13   T   Y   151 12 PSD
     Tomoko                                              U
                                                         Lengt
                                                         h
                                                         Limit
                                                         Rules
3789 Kandala,    7.4.7.1                  T   Y    57    Reco
     Srinivas                                            mmen
                                                         ded
                                                         Trans
                                                         missi
                                                         on
                                                         Chan
                                                         nel
                                                         Width
                                                         Mana
                                                         geme
                                                         nt
                                                         Action
                                                         Fram
                                                         e


2190 Ji, Lusheng 7.3.2.48   54    0       T   Y    54   0 Additi
                                                          onal
                                                          HT
                                                          Infor
                                                          matio
                                                          n
                                                          Elem
                                                          ents
6775 Morioka,    7.4A       78    3       E   Y    78   3 Aggre
     Yuichi                                               gated
                                                          MPD
                                                          U
                                                          frame
                                                          s

3775 Kandala,    7.3.2.48   53            T   Y    53   1 Additi
     Srinivas                                             onal
                                                          HT
                                                          Infor
                                                          matio
                                                          n
                                                          Elem
                                                          ents
3972 Kasher,     7.3.2.48   53    1       T   N    53   1 Additi
     Assaf                                                onal
                                                          HT
                                                          Infor
                                                          matio
                                                          n
                                                          Elem
                                                          ents
4520 Loc, Peter   7.3.2.48     53   5   T   Y   53   5 Additi
                                                       onal
                                                       HT
                                                       Infor
                                                       matio
                                                       n
                                                       Elem
                                                       ents
1195 Fischer,     7.3.2.47.8   53       T   Y   53     Additi
     Matthew                                           onal
                                                       HT
                                                       Infor
                                                       matio
                                                       n
                                                       Elem
                                                       ents
1205 Fischer,     7.3.2.48     53       T   Y   53     Additi
     Matthew                                           onal
                                                       HT
                                                       Infor
                                                       matio
                                                       n
                                                       Elem
                                                       ents
1249 Fischer,     7.4A.2                T   Y   80     A-
     Matthew                                           MPD
                                                       U
                                                       Conte
                                                       nts
3801 Kandala,     7.4.7.2               T   Y   58     MIMO
     Srinivas                                          Powe
                                                       r
                                                       Save
                                                       Mana
                                                       geme
                                                       nt
                                                       Action
                                                       Fram
                                                       e


3802 Kandala,     7.4.7.2               T   Y   58    MIMO
     Srinivas                                         Powe
                                                      r
                                                      Save
                                                      Mana
                                                      geme
                                                      nt
                                                      Action
                                                      Fram
                                                      e
10367 Engwer,     7.3.2.48   52    5           T   Y   52    5 Additi
      Darwin                                                   onal
                                                               HT
                                                               Infor
                                                               matio
                                                               n
                                                               Elem
                                                               ents
 1155 Fischer,    7.2.3.4    33                T   Y   33      Assoc
      Matthew                                                  iation
                                                               Requ
                                                               est
                                                               frame
                                                               forma
                                                               t




 1006 Fischer,    11.14.1    151               T   Y   151   PSD
      Matthew                                                U
                                                             Lengt
                                                             h
                                                             Limit
                                                             Rules
10165 Zaks, Artur 7.4.7.10   76    13          T       76 13 PSM
                                                             P


 1212 Fischer,    7.4.7.10                     T   Y   76      PSM
      Matthew                                                  P


 3777 Kandala,    7.3.2.48   53                T   Y   53      Additi
      Srinivas                                                 onal
                                                               HT
                                                               Infor
                                                               matio
                                                               n
                                                               Elem
                                                               ents
 4069 Kerry,      7.3.2.48   206   Table n19   T   N   52    5 Additi
      Stuart                                                   onal
                                                               HT
                                                               Infor
                                                               matio
                                                               n
                                                               Elem
                                                               ents
 1246 Fischer,    7.4A.2     80   31   T   Y    80 31 A-
      Matthew                                         MPD
                                                      U
                                                      Conte
                                                      nts




 3780 Kandala,    7.3.2.48   54        T   Y    54    Additi
      Srinivas                                        onal
                                                      HT
                                                      Infor
                                                      matio
                                                      n
                                                      Elem
                                                      ents
 2181 Ji, Lusheng 7.3.2.48   52   5    T   Y    52 5 Additi
                                                      onal
                                                      HT
                                                      Infor
                                                      matio
                                                      n
                                                      Elem
                                                      ents
 7481 Stephens,   11.14.1              T   N   151    PSD
      Adrian                                          U
                                                      Lengt
                                                      h
                                                      Limit
                                                      Rules
11882 Tsien, Chih 7.4A.1.2   79   22   E   Y    79 22 De-
                                                      aggre
                                                      gation
                                                      (Infor
                                                      mativ
                                                      e)
2232 Ji, Lusheng 7.4.7.1   58   4    T   Y   58   4 Reco
                                                    mmen
                                                    ded
                                                    Trans
                                                    missi
                                                    on
                                                    Chan
                                                    nel
                                                    Width
                                                    Mana
                                                    geme
                                                    nt
                                                    Action
                                                    Fram
                                                    e


2234 Ji, Lusheng 7.4.7.1   58   4    T   Y   58   4 Reco
                                                    mmen
                                                    ded
                                                    Trans
                                                    missi
                                                    on
                                                    Chan
                                                    nel
                                                    Width
                                                    Mana
                                                    geme
                                                    nt
                                                    Action
                                                    Fram
                                                    e


2239 Ji, Lusheng 7.4.7.2   58   13   T   Y   58 13 MIMO
                                                   Powe
                                                   r
                                                   Save
                                                   Mana
                                                   geme
                                                   nt
                                                   Action
                                                   Fram
                                                   e
2241 Ji, Lusheng 7.4.7.2   58   13   T   Y   58 13 MIMO
                                                   Powe
                                                   r
                                                   Save
                                                   Mana
                                                   geme
                                                   nt
                                                   Action
                                                   Fram
                                                   e


2242 Ji, Lusheng 7.4.7.2   58   13   T   Y   58 13 MIMO
                                                   Powe
                                                   r
                                                   Save
                                                   Mana
                                                   geme
                                                   nt
                                                   Action
                                                   Fram
                                                   e


2247 Ji, Lusheng 7.4.7.3   59   8    T   Y   59   8 PCO
                                                    Phas
                                                    e
                                                    Requ
                                                    est
                                                    Mana
                                                    geme
                                                    nt
                                                    Action
                                                    Fram
                                                    e

2248 Ji, Lusheng 7.4.7.3   59   8    T   Y   59   8 PCO
                                                    Phas
                                                    e
                                                    Requ
                                                    est
                                                    Mana
                                                    geme
                                                    nt
                                                    Action
                                                    Fram
                                                    e
 7479 Stephens,   11.14.1              T   Y   151    PSD
      Adrian                                          U
                                                      Lengt
                                                      h
                                                      Limit
                                                      Rules




11974 Qian, Luke 11.14.1    151   11   T   Y   151 11 PSD
                                                      U
                                                      Lengt
                                                      h
                                                      Limit
                                                      Rules
                                                                                                                                           Clause(Ed)




                                         7.3.2.48




             Annex A
                                                                                                                                           Type




             DT
                                         DT
                                                                                                                                           E/HE/T/ST/
                                                                                                                                           DT(Ed)

                                                                                                                                           Duplicate
                                                                                                                                           of CID




             R
                                         R
                                                                                                                                           Resn
                                                                                                                                           Status

                                                                                                                                           Assignee

                                                                                                                                           Submissio
                                                                                                                                           n
                                                                                                                                           TGn
                                                                                                                                           approval




                           clause 7
                                                        This is a dummy entry. Please do not delete or sort out of the top of the sheet.
                                                        This is a dummy entry. Please to not delete or sort out of the top of the sheet.This
                                                        is a dummy entry. Please to not delete or sort out of the top of the sheet. This is a
                                                        dummy entry. Please to not delete or sort out of the top of the sheet.This is a




Capability should be
                                                        dummy entry. Please to not delete or sort out of the top of the sheet. This is a
                                                        dummy entry. Please do not delete or sort out of the top of the sheet.This is a




mandatory for all STAs..
                                                        dummy entry. Please do not delete or sort out of the top of the sheet. This is a


                           Remove normative text from
                                                        dummy entry. Please do not delete or sort out of the top of the sheet.                Comment
7.4A.2    DT   R   The 2nd and 3rd statements
                   in this clause do not use the
                   word "shall".




Annex A   DT   R   Capability should be
                   mandatory for all STAs..



7.4A      DT   R   Note that 65535 may be
                   reduced to a value advertised
                   by the STA. Further, its not
                   clear where the 65535
                   limitation comes from.
7.4.7.10     DT   R   Is the pad really needed or it
                      was put in because someone
                      thought it is cool. The MSDU
                      can still be of any length and
                      the FCS needs to be added.
                      So, whatever supposed gains
                      we may have in decoding the
                      frame are offset by having to
                      determine and insert the pad -
                      both of them affect the data
                      path; one has the advantage
                      of making the frame slightly
                      longer. :)


7.1.3.1.10   DT   R   The text overloads the Order
                      bit to indicate a HT frame

                      However, overloading in
                      protocol is generally the start
                      of the slipperly slope to chaos


General      DT   R   Add a statement to note that
                      HT STA shall be able to
                      interpret the HTC field of
                      frames.
7.4A     DT   R   No justification of the use of
                  aggregated frames is
                  provided in the draft. No
                  mechanism to provide these
                  aggregated frames to the
                  MAC through the Data SAP is
                  provided. No means of
                  determining when a STA can
                  or should aggregate frames is
                  provided. No benefit is
                  shown from the use of
                  aggregated frames.




7.4A.1   DT   R   B0-B1 need to be
                  distinguished so that the MAC
                  can properly handle the A-
                  MPDU.
7.4A      DT   R   The A-MPDU would be much
                   better defined as a MAC-level
                   capability, rather than a PHY
                   capability. Then it can be
                   used by other (future) PHYs,
                   and can even be used by
                   existing PHYs in some
                   circumstances.




7.2.2.1   DT   R   Justify changes or eliminate
General    DT   R   I see only trouble using RIFS,
                    if no ack is needed then send
                    a max size frames/fragments.
                    But, at each frame you must
                    do a proper IFS spacing for
                    COS/QOS purposes
                    (IEEE802.11e) relative to
                    EDCF gaps given class of
                    service and proper sharing of
                    the medium. What happens
                    when you have overlapping
                    RF coverage areas trying to
                    use RIFS who goes first?
                    Without Acks! this is not a
                    good idea? Unlicensed
                    spectrum suffers interference.


7.3.2.48   DT   A   PCO phase not valid in Probe
                    Responses?




7.2.2      DT   A   TCP already does piggback
                    acks whenver possible. So
                    citing TCP acks as a strong
                    case doesn’t help here.
7.3.2.48   DT   A   Remove normative text from
                    clause 7




7.3.2.48   DT   A   Remove normative text from
                    clause 7




7.3.2.48   DT   A   Remove normative text from
                    clause 7




7.3.2.48   DT   C   Non-GF Devices Present row,
                    Use colum, is it "should"
                    recommended or "shall"
                    recquired?




7.4A       DT   C   "The A-MPDU maximum
                    length is 65535 bytes.".
                    Although this is correct, it is
                    confusing since a HT-STA
                    may support only 8, 16, or 32
                    kB.
7.3.2.48   DT   C   Secondary Beacon in probe
                    responses has normative text




7.4.7.4    DT   C   Value should be specified for
                    unused Explicit Feedback
                    Sequence field




7.4A.2     DT   C   BA aggregation in Reverse
                    Direction is mentioned but
                    contradicts the single TID
                    aggregation table (n48)




7.4.7.1    HE   R   The frame formats would be
                    much better shown as a
                    Figure than a table
7.4.7.3    HE   R   The frame formats would be
                    much better shown as a
                    Figure than a table




7.3.2.48   HE   R   Suggest that you reference
                    Table 26 for the Element ID,
                    rather than all the Editor's
                    Notes




7.4A.1     ST   R   It is not mentioned in what
                    MSB/LSB order the fields like
                    Length and Unique Pattern
                    are transmitted




7.4A       ST   R   It is not clear if A-MPDUs
                    from different Traffic streams
                    ( and hence Ups ) be munged
                    together ( I hope not ! )
7.4A.1   ST   R   Does the A-MPDU maximum
                  length of 64K bytes include
                  only the sum of the MPDU
                  lengths, sub-frame lengths,
                  pad bytes or it also includes
                  the minimum seperation
                  bytes calculated from the
                  MPDU density, PHY-bit-rate
                  given in the HT Capability
                  element(page 45)? The
                  aggregation parsing algorithm
                  does not mention this
                  minimum seperation at all.




7        ST   R   Given that an MPDU may not
                  necessarily be a frame,
                  several terms in this clause
                  need to change, starting with
                  the name of the clause.

                  At a minimum, we should
                  avoid terms such as "Frame
                  Body" - instead use "MSDU"
                  or "Protocol Data"
7.4.7.1    ST   R   Fram   As this format of frames is
                    e      used throughout the base
                    Form   spec, Channel Width should
                    at     be defined as either a fixed
                           field in 7.3.1 or as in
                           Information Element in 7.3.2




7.2.2      ST   A          A-MSDU length can exceed
                           the maximum MPDU length
                           which A-MPDU delimiter field
                           can specify.




7.3.2.48   ST   A          The "Additional HT
                           Information" element format
                           doesn't match up right with
                           the table n19 definitions of
                           what is in the element.




7.2.3      ST   A          "The MPDU containing the A-
                           MSDU is one of the qos data
                           subtypes"; the meaning of
                           this sentence is not clear --
                           what is it trying to convey
7.3.2.48   ST   A   The text, "present in
                    Beacon/Probe Response
                    frames …." is confusing. It
                    appears to be stating that
                    these bits are only present in
                    these frames, but not present
                    in other frames. If this is the
                    case how does one know to
                    parse these bits as present or
                    not and what happens to byte
                    alignments?

7.4A.2     ST   A   This section does not relate
                    to the PHY service interface




7.1.3.8    ST   A   For many fields it is not clear
                    how the fields should be
                    encoded. Would it be
                    possible to clearly mark how
                    the bit ordering is arranged so
                    that there are no isseues with
                    interoperability? (For
                    example, it is not clear
                    whether bit 3 is represented
                    first or last in table n3. Same
                    issue with bits 6 through 8
7.4.7.2    ST   A           Enable/Disable and Mode
                            fields need to be defined.




7.3.2.48   ST   A           "In probe responses, this field
                            shall not be interpreted and
                            set to 0." This sentence
                            makes no sense at all.
                            Something is missing, I think.



7.2.1.2    ST   C   Adria   missing section in CTS frame
                    n       format area




7.4.7.10   ST   C           Missing entries in table in
                            Figure n28
7.2.3.7    ST   C          Order numbers in frame are
                           incorrect




7.2.3.5    ST   C          Order numbers in frame are
                           incorrect




7.4.7.3    ST   C   Fram   As this format of frames is
                    e      used throughout the base
                    Form   spec, PCO Phase should be
                    at     defined as either a fixed field
                           in 7.3.1 or as in Information
                           Element in 7.3.2




7.3.2.48   T    R          Maximum allowable Service
                           Interval Granularity is 40 ms.
                           It should be specified that the
                           Service Interval Granularity
                           should be less than Beacon
                           Interval
7.4A.2     T   R   Why are the possible MPDUs
                   in an aggregate limited?




11.14.1    T   R   make normative




7.3.2.48   T   R   "Basic MCS Set" is defined
                   but not used any where.




7.3.2.48   T   R   Is "RIFS mode" about RIFS
                   or APSD?




11.14.1    T   R   extra words
7.1.3.8      T   A   Not finished to explain use of
                     MRS with delayed MFB




7.3.2.48     T   A   In the first row of the table,
                     the text "all broadcast and
                     nonaggregated control
                     frames are sent so that they
                     can be received…" appears -
                     this text describes behavior
                     which should appear in a
                     behavioral clause of the
                     draft/amendment - such as
                     11.
7.3.2.48     T   A   Extension Channel Offset
                     missing definition of 10




7.3.2.48     T   A   Operating Mode = 11 (Mixed).
                     There is no operating mode
                     defined where legacy STA
                     are assocaited and legacy
                     protection using duplicate non-
                     HT PPDUs is required.


7.4A.1.2     T   A   the syntax notation or
                     language for the pseudo code
                     is not cited




7.3.2.47.1   T   A   clumsy wording
7.3.2.48   T   A   Basic MCS set would be for
                   HT-devices.




7.4.7.9    T   A   All of the information fields in
                   this MA frame need to have
                   definitions within 7.3.1




7.4A.1.2   T   A   One chance in 2^n (n is
                   number of bits in MAC FCS).




11.14.1    T   A   Can't mandate that a STA
                   receive anything. Too many
                   unknowns, like signal
                   strength and interference


11.14.1    T   A   As the maximum A-MPDU
                   length is 65535 bytes, the
                   expression should be
                   2^(13+Maximum Rx A-MPDU
                   Factor) -1.

11.14.1    T   A   "The STA shall receive
                   PSDUs of length less than
                   the indicated limit" - if it's a
                   limit, the language should
                   allow PSDUs of the indicated
                   limit.
11.14.1    T   A   make normative
11.14.1      T   A          Rx A-MPDU Factor :
                            Clarification : Does this refer
                            to the total length with the
                            padding required to
                            accommodate the A-MPDU
                            density factor or does it only
                            refer the total length of the
                            aggregated A-MPDU's.




7.4A.1.1     T   A          Insert a cross ref to 7.1.1 for
                            encoding



7.2.3.9      T   A          Text in this paragraph
                            duplicates what is already
                            stated in the Notes in the
                            table.




7.4.7.1      T   A   Fram   Channel width information
                     e      field has not been defined
                     Form   elsewhere - this is normally
                     at     done for action frames - for
                            example, it is necessary to
                            somewhere (7.3.1.x), specify
                            the size of this field.




7.3.2.47.2   T   A          DSSS/CCK - The HT STA …
                            shall be not associated…"
7.4A.2       T   A           Tables n48, n49, and n50 are
                             not referenced, instead the
                             term, below is used.


7.1.3.8      T   A   Adria   Table n7 - Spell the bit
                     n       combination more clearly (ie
                             which bit is more significant
                             etc




7.1.3.8      T   A   Adria   Table n8 - Spell the bit
                     n       combination more clearly (ie
                             which bit is more significant
                             etc




7.3.2.48     T   A           Indicate the bit ordering for
                             the following subfields:
                             Extension Channel Offset,
                             Operating Mode, Service
                             Interval Granularity




7.4.7.3      T   A   Fram    What is the format of PCO
                     e       Phase? Is it an IE or a fixed
                     Form    field? If it is an IE, what are
                     at      the element ID and lenghts?
                             If it is a fixed field, what is the
                             length (1 byte, 2 bytes or 4-
                             bytes?) It appears that the
                             values that the field takes is
                             binary. So which bit of this
                             field/IE is used to indicate
                             this?

7.3.2.47.2   T   A           Do the fields indicate support
                             for GI for transmitting or
                             receiving? I think it is meant
                             to state for receiving.
11.14.1    T   A          As the maximum A-MPDU
                          length is 65535 bytes, the
                          expression should be
                          2^(13+Maximum Rx A-MPDU
                          Factor) -1.

7.4.7.1    T   A   Fram   What is the format of channel
                   e      width? Is it an IE or a fixed
                   Form   field? If it is an IE, what are
                   at     the element ID and lenghts?
                          If it is a fixed field, what is the
                          length (1 byte, 2 bytes or 4-
                          bytes?) It appears that the
                          values that the field takes is
                          binary. So which bit of this
                          field/IE is used to indicate
                          this?




7.3.2.48   T   A          Service Interval Granularity in
                          ms or us?




7.4A       T   A          Max. MPDU length is a STA
                          capability.




7.3.2.48   T   A          Not sure why the mode is
                          called "Mixed Mode" if there
                          are no non-HT STAs are
                          associated.:)




7.3.2.48   T   A          In the operating Mode field
                          description, the description of
                          the Mixed Mode includes the
                          sentence "no non-HT STA is
                          associated" this is incorrected
                          - it should be "non-HT STA is
                          associated"
7.3.2.48   T   A   Table n19 - There is an error
                   in the definition of the Mixed
                   Operating Mode (11)




7.3.2.48   T   A   additional HT information
                   element -- the mixed mode
                   description is incorrect - the
                   description should read that
                   there ARE SOME non-HT
                   STA associated!


7.3.2.48   T   A   In Operating Mode, For mixed
                   case, there seems to be an
                   extra "no"




7.4A.2     T   A   For each of the tables, it
                   would appear that any frame
                   which uses the No-ack policy
                   should be allowed to appear
                   in the A-MPDU.
7.4.7.2    T   A   What is the format of
                   Enable/Disable? Is it an IE or
                   a fixed field? If it is an IE,
                   what are the element ID and
                   lenghts? If it is a fixed field,
                   what is the length (1 byte, 2
                   bytes or 4-bytes?) It appears
                   that the values that the field
                   takes is binary. So which bit
                   of this field/IE is used to
                   indicate this?

7.4.7.2    T   A   What is the format of Mode?
                   Is it an IE or a fixed field? If it
                   is an IE, what are the element
                   ID and lenghts? If it is a fixed
                   field, what is the length (1
                   byte, 2 bytes or 4-bytes?) It
                   appears that the values that
                   the field takes is binary. So
                   which bit of this field/IE is
                   used to indicate this?
7.3.2.48   T   A   The name "control channel" is
                   technically misleading. It
                   indicates that that this
                   channel only conveys control
                   information and not data as
                   well.


7.2.3.4    T   A   Thou shalt not shall in clause
                   7.




11.14.1    T   A   need a description of TX
                   behavior




7.4.7.10   T   A   Define TBD in Figure n28



7.4.7.10   T   A   There is a TBD



7.3.2.48   T   A   Too much description of the
                   behavior for RIFS mode
                   subfield.




7.3.2.48   T   C   "000 – 5ms" etc.
7.4A.2     T   C   In the table, the first row,
                   there is a paranthetical
                   statement that says "See
                   blockack explanation" - but
                   the reference seems to point
                   nowhere. Furthermore, this
                   comment indicates that the
                   block ack frame may be a
                   non-aggregate - how can it be
                   a non-aggregate, if it is part of
                   an A-MPDU aggregate?

7.3.2.48   T   C   I do not see too much
                   description of how "Service
                   Interval Granularity" is used.
                   Who is requesting? why are
                   they requesting?



7.3.2.48   T   C   Third row says
                   "Recommended" in col 1, and
                   "may" in col 3




11.14.1    T   C   The actual limit should be in
                   the form of 2 to some power
                   less 1 byte, because this is
                   how the PHY works.


7.4A.1.2   T   C   Open ended statement
7.4.7.1   T   C   Fram   Size of "Channel Width" is
                  e      not specified. 1-bit, 8-bit, 16-
                  Form   bit, 32-bit?
                  at




7.4.7.1   T   C   Fram   encoding not given for
                  e      Channel Width
                  Form
                  at




7.4.7.2   T   C          Size of "Enable/Disable" is
                         not specified. 1-bit, 8-bit, 16-
                         bit, 32-bit?
7.4.7.2   T   C          Size of "Mode" is not
                         specified. 1-bit, 8-bit, 16-bit,
                         32-bit?




7.4.7.2   T   C          encoding not given for Mode




7.4.7.3   T   C   Fram   Size of "PCO Phase" is not
                  e      specified. 1-bit, 8-bit, 16-bit,
                  Form   32-bit?
                  at




7.4.7.3   T   C   Fram   encoding not given for PCO
                  e      Phase
                  Form
                  at
11.14.1   T   C   The language about receiving
                  the first part of a longer
                  PSDU was written to support
                  multi-receiver-aggregation.
                  Since this is no longer part of
                  the spec, it should be
                  removed.

                  In that case, a STA should
                  never need to worry about
                  receiving an over-long PSDU,
                  and could behave in an
                  implementation-defined way if
                  this exception ever occurred.




11.14.1   T   C   "that are intended to be
                  received by a particular STA"
                  is incosistent with the single
                  receiver assumption.
                                                                                 This is a dummy entry. Please do not delete or sort out of the top of the sheet.




                                                    is used…"
                                                                                 This is a dummy entry. Please to not delete or sort out of the top of the sheet.This




              accordingly.
                                                                                 is a dummy entry. Please to not delete or sort out of the top of the sheet. This is a
                                                                                 dummy entry. Please to not delete or sort out of the top of the sheet.This is a
                                                                                 dummy entry. Please to not delete or sort out of the top of the sheet. This is a




              Modify Status column
                                                                                 dummy entry. Please do not delete or sort out of the top of the sheet.This is a
                                                                                 dummy entry. Please do not delete or sort out of the top of the sheet. This is a      Proposed




                                                    "…to indicate the MCS that
                                                                                 dummy entry. Please do not delete or sort out of the top of the sheet.                Change


                                                                                 This is a dummy entry. Please do not delete or sort out of the top of the sheet.
                                                                                 This is a dummy entry. Please to not delete or sort out of the top of the sheet.This




                                           descriptive.
                                                                                 is a dummy entry. Please to not delete or sort out of the top of the sheet. This is a
                                                                                 dummy entry. Please to not delete or sort out of the top of the sheet.This is a
                                                                                 dummy entry. Please to not delete or sort out of the top of the sheet. This is a
                                                                                 dummy entry. Please do not delete or sort out of the top of the sheet.This is a




describe support for it.
                                                                                 dummy entry. Please do not delete or sort out of the top of the sheet. This is a




                                           is not normative text, but




are HT capability bits that
                                            reject. "That is used for"




is clearly optional as there
 reject. Antenna selection
                                                                                 dummy entry. Please do not delete or sort out of the top of the sheet.                Resolution




                                                                                                                                                                     Edited in
                                                                                                                                                                     draft
                                                                                                                                                                     Topic




                                     s
                                     El
                                                                                 Dummy Entry                                                                         lookup




                                     ent
                                     em




              CS
              PI Frame Format
                                     HT Frame Format
                                                                                                                                                                     Topic
                                                                                                                                                                     Group
                                                                                                                                                                     Lookup
Change wording as follows:      reject. There's a move to      A- Frame Format
"All the MPDUs within an A-    clean clause 7 of shalls.       M
MPDU shall be addressed to     Statements describing the       PD
the same receiver address."    contents of structures use      U
"The Duration fields in the    "is" and then appeal to the
MAC Headers of all MPDUs       statement at the top of
in an A-MPDU shall carry the   clause 7: "A STA shall be
same value."                   able properly to construct a
                               subset
                               of the frames specified in
                               this clause for
                               transmission" where
                               "properly construct" is
                               taken to mean according to
                               the various "is" statements.


Modify Status column            reject. Greenfield mode is     PI Frame Format
accordingly.                   clearly optional as there       CS
                               are HT capability bits that
                               describe support for it.

Change to state that the        reject. In D1.03 section       A- Frame Format
maximum length of an A-        9.7c.1, which reads "An HT      M
MPDU is advertised by the      STA shall form an A-            PD
receiving STA. Further, that   MPDU for transmission           U
a STA shall not send an A-     such that all the MPDUs
MPDU to a STA unless the       within the A-MPDU that are
receiving STA has              intended to be received by
advertised such a maximum      a particular STA shall be
size.                          within the first 2^(13 +
                               Maximum Rx A-MPDU
                               Factor)
                               octets of the PSDU, using
                               the limit declared by that
                               STA.", this constraint
                               already exists.

                               A STA cannot transmit an
                               A-MPDU to another STA
                               until it has determined that
                               that STA is a HT STA. It
                               simultaneously obtains the
                               Maximum Rx A-MPDU
                               factor, as it is contained in
                               the HT Capability element,
                               so the situation cannot
                               arise where it knows it can
                               transmit an A-MPDU but is
                               not aware of the receiver's
                               maximum length.
Delete the pad field.            reject. One purpose of the      PS Frame Format
                                pad field is to reduce by a      M
                                factor of 4 the amount of        P
                                computation required to
                                regain synchronization
                                after an error in an A-
                                MPDU subframe header.




Reconsider overloading          reject. See response to          Fr Frame Format
and/or justify overloading      CID 4603.                        am
                                                                 e
                                                                 Fo
                                                                 rm
                                                                 ats


not sure where to put the        Reject. Submission 11-          Ge Frame Format
statement, but somewhere        06/1026r1 was approved           ner
there needs to be a             by motion in TGn in July.        al
normative requirement that      This submission has the
an HT STA shall be capable      opposite effect, of explicitly
of interpreting received HT     making HTC optional and
control fields in +HTC frames   stating the requirements
                                for interpretation of a frame
                                containing HTC as a third
                                party that does not directly
                                support HTC.
Given the complete lack of        reject. The draft is not     A- Frame Format
specification of how to use      required to justify itself.   M
frame aggregation, any           Justification was required    PD
benefit shown of their use, or   during the down-selection     U
even a mechanism specified       process when the values of
to provide to the MAC            mechanisms was
aggregated frames, delete        considered and
frame aggregation.               mechanisms that offered
                                 inadequate performance
                                 benefit were removed.
                                 There is much
                                 documentation about the
                                 value of features and the
                                 reader is referred to the
                                 MAC and PHY
                                 presentations produced
                                 throughout this process for
                                 background information.
                                 (Look for "000n"
                                 documents with TGnSync,
                                 WWiSE and Joint Proposal
                                 in their title).

                                 Regarding "...even a
                                 mechanism to provide to
                                 the MAC aggregated
                                 frames...", TGn does not
                                 propose any change to the
                                 MAC data SAP.
                                 Aggregation takes place
                                 wholly within the MAC
                                 layer, and is not exposed
B0-B1 shall be "01"              above it.
                                  reject. The MAC "properly    A- Frame Format
                                 handles" the A-MPDU on        M
                                 the basis of the              PD
                                 RXVECTOR                      U
                                 AGGREGATION paramter.
                                 No additional signalling is
                                 necessary within the MAC.
Integrate the definition of A- reject. The purpose of         A- Frame Format
MPDU into 7.1.2, as part of requiring the PHY to              M
the general frame format.      transport an "aggregated"      PD
Define B0-B1 of the MPDU flag is so that it can do so         U
Delimiter to be value 01, so with increased reliability
that it appears as the         over signalling it at data
Protocol Version of a non-HT rates.
MAC header. Move the
remainder of the definition of
A-MPDU to be in 7.1.5.
Delete the restriction on
contents so that A-MPDU
can contain any current
(protocol version 0) MAC
frame or sequences of such
frames. Delete all the
complexity in 9.12 about
frame sequences that
contain +ampdu and +ampdu-
end.
This is in conflict with past   reject. The standard is not   A- Frame Formats
802.11 work and will cause internally required to justify     M
legacy problems, eliminate     itself - that happened         SD
changes                        during the selection           U
                               process. However, in reply
                               to the commenter, under A-
                               MSDU aggregation, the
                               DA and SA are carried in
                               the subframe header. Any
                               field in the MPDU header
                               that carries DA or SA is
                               redundant and could
                               potentially be removed.
                               However this is not
                               possible as the condition
                               for the presence of one of
                               the address fields would
                               depend on a value in the
                               QoS Control field that
                               follow it. So, given that
                               the address fields have to
                               be present, but cannot
                               contain their prior values
                               we are faced with two
                               choices: mark them as
                               reserved or fill them with a
                               well-defined value
                               (BSSID). Filling them with
                               a well-defined value is the
                               least likely to cause any
                               problems with 3rd party
                               STA compared to defining
                               them as reserved, in
Eliminate RIFS in all it's        Reject. The use of RIFS        Ge Frame Format
forms                            vs SIFS between PPDUs           ner
                                 after channel access has        al
                                 been gained does not
                                 affect 802.11e channel
                                 access, which depends on
                                 an IFS > SIFS (>> RIFS).
                                 RIFS is only used under
                                 conditions when SIFS
                                 would also be valid.




Change to "Beacon frames         accept.                         HT Frame Format
and Probe Responses."                                            El
                                                                 em
                                                                 ent
                                                                 s



I would like to see a more        accept. No change to the       Fr Frame Format
reasoning on how A-MSDUs         Draft is necessary because      am
help. Sure, since the phy        it is not required to justify   e
overhead is so large that it     itself. The commenter is        Fo
makes sense to send large        referred to: 11-05-1266-01-     rm
MSDU/MPDUs, but I would          000n-tgn-joint-proposal-        ats
like to see more evidence as     mac-results.doc which
to how does it help some         shows the effectiveness of
typical applications. Can this   the overall system,
be used for Real-time            including A-MSDU, which
applications ?                   simultaneously meets
                                 challenging real-time QoS
                                 constraints for VoIP and
                                 video traffic.
                                 The benefit of A-MSDU is
                                 easy enough to calculate -
                                 it permits 14B of overhead
                                 per MSDU compared to
                                 30B of overhead per
                                 MPDU - a saving of 16B.
                                 If the average MSDU size
                                 is 1500B, the performance
                                 gain is ~1%. However, for
                                 MSDUs of size 256B
                                 (which is more realistic of
                                 average MSDU sizes), the
                                 performance gain is 6%.
"Non-HT basic rates shall be accept. This has already           HT Frame Format
used…"                       been handled by resolution         El
                             to approved comment                em
                             1107 in D1.03.                     ent
                                                                s



Change to "The AP sets this accept. This has already            HT Frame Format
parameter to 1… otherwise been implemented in                   El
this parameter is set to 0." D1.03 (with slightly               em
                             different wording) to              ent
                             achieve the intended               s
                             result, thus: "Set to 0 if all
                             HT STAs that are
                             associated are
                             Greenfield capable
                             Set to 1 if one or more HT
                             STAs that are not
                             Greenfield capable are
                             associated"
Change to "…is requesting is accepted. D1.03 has                HT Frame Format
a multiple of this value…"   already moved this text to         El
                             clause 11 in response to           em
                             CID 1107.                          ent
                                                                s



clarify                            counter. According to CID    HT Frame Format
                                  1107, normative language      El
                                  has been removed from         em
                                  clause 7 where possible.      ent
                                  In D1.03, the description     s
                                  of field describes the
                                  meaning of the bit, but
                                  doesn't introduce any
                                  normative behaviour.

Add e.g. "A HT-STA may             counter. Add a new           A- Frame Format
signal that it supports a lower   sentence to the end of this   M
maximum A-MPDU length of          paragraph. "The length of     PD
8192, 16384, or 32768             an A-MPDU addressed to        U
bytes."                           a particular STA may be
                                  further constrained as
                                  described in <insert ref to
                                  9.7c.1 A-MPDU length limit
                                  rules>".
Change to "this field is        counter. D1.03 uses this      HT Frame Format
reserved and set to 0."        language: "Defined only in     El
                               a Beacon transmission.         em
                               Reserved otherwise."           ent
                               There is no need to            s
                               mention "0" because that is
                               covered by the definition of
                               "reserved" in the baseline.


Specify all zeros value         counter. In D1.03 it is       Be Frame Format
                               marked "reserved". This        am
                               defines it as zeroes by        for
                               convention.                    mi
                                                              ng



Change the "Comments"           counter. Remove the           A- Frame Format
with "Definition" in the third existing comment (Done in      M
column. Edit the first row as D1.03). Add the following       PD
follow: BlockAck may be non- to the comment for Block         U
aggregate frame. If the        Ack: "At most one
BlockAck is sent in the        BlockAck established
aggregation is shall be sent under HT-immediate BA
at first place.                Policy may be present, in
                               which case it occurs at the
                               start of the A-MPDU. Any
                               number of Block Ack
                               frames established under
                               HT-delayed BA Policy with
                               the BA Ack Policy field set
                               to 1 may be present."


Change to a Figure showing      reject. The baseline uses     Co Frame Format
sizes of each field, and a     a tabluar notation for         exi
short paragraph below with     description of certain         ste
the information currently in   action frames, and so our      nc
the "Value" column             usage is not inconsistent      e
                               with this.
Change to a Figure showing      reject. The baseline uses    PC Frame Format
sizes of each field, and a     a tabluar notation for        O
short paragraph below with     description of certain
the information currently in   action frames, and so our
the "Value" column             usage is not inconsistent
                               with this.




Change to "The Element ID       reject. The numbers have     HT Frame Format
field is set to the value      been obtained from the        El
shown in Table 26 for the HT   ANA and inserted in D1.03     em
Capability information         in implementation of          ent
element." Similar changes      resolution to CID 1181.       s
elsewhere these numbers
need to appear.

Mention for each field          reject. This is              A- Frame Format
whether LSB is first or last   unambiguously defined by      M
                               subclause 7.1 in the          PD
                               baseline.                     U




Please clarify that this can    reject. A-MPDU is a          A- Frame Format
not happen.                    frame aggregation             M
                               technique. The Data           PD
                               frames that can transmitted   U
                               are constrained by channel
                               access rules and by Block
                               Ack response rules.
                               These rules don't stop the
                               aggregation of Data of
                               different TIDs under
                               certain circumstances - for
                               example, during PSMP
                               operation.
                reject. In reply to the        A- Frame Format
               commenter:                      M
               1. the maximum length of        PD
               the A-MPDU is the               U
               maximum length of the
               structure called the A-
               MPDU shown in the figure
               just above this statement,
               rather that the maximum
               length of some subset of
               fields within it. No other
               interpretation is possible,
               and no further clarification
               is required.
               2. The parsing algorithm
               does not need to be
               modified. The MPDU
               density may be achieved in
               multiple ways, but the
               most obvious one is to
               include delimiters with a
               length field set to zero.
               This is explicitly called out
               as legal. Parsing of these
               delimiters is identical to
               those with a length field
               that is non-zero, and no
               accomodation is required
               in the parsing algorithm.


As suggested    reject. The terms MPDU         Fr Frame Format
               and frame are used as           am
               synonyms in the baseline,       e
               and the TGn ammendment          Fo
               does not change that.           rm
               "Frame body" is the name        ats
               of a field defined in the
               baseline. While accepting
               that an A-MPDU is not a
               frame, but contains
               frames, Clause 7 is still
               the best home for it.
Recommend changing frame       reject. While accepting       Co Frame Format
formats to a Figure instead   the original comment           exi
of a table. This comment      (which is addressed in CID     ste
applies throughout clause     1210), the change is           nc
7.4.7                         unrelated to that and          e
                              relates to CID 2231.




Need some restriction on       accept as in the resolution   Fr Frame Format
combined usages of A-         column.                        am
MSDU and A-MPDU.                                             e
                                                             Fo
                                                             rm
                                                             ats


1) Order the element table    accept.                        HT Frame Format
(n19) in the same order as                                   El
the element format.                                          em
2) Resolve the name for B7                                   ent
in octect 2. Dual STBC                                       s
Protection or Dual CTS
protection.
3) resolve name for b0-b6 in
octect 2. Basic STBC MCS
or STBC Basic MCS
Change the sentence to        accept. Replace the            Ma Frame Format
convey the intended          sentence: "The MPDU             na
meaning more accurately      containing the A-MSDU           ge
                             may be any of the QoS           me
                             data subtypes, excluding        nt
                             the no data subtypes." in       Fr
                             D1.03 with the following:       am
                             "The MPDU containing the        es
                             A-MSDU may be carried in
                             any of the following Data
                             subtypes: QoS Data, QoS
                             Data + CF-Ack, QoS Data
                             + CF-Poll, QoS Data + CF-
                             Ack + CF-Poll."
Change text to state that this     accept. Add "Otherwise         HT Frame Format
field is only processed and       reserved" in each field of      El
has the following meaning         the table that has a            em
when in these frames,             qualification about when it     ent
otherwise the field is ignored.   is present.                     s




Describe how an A-MPDU is accept. Add a new                       A- Frame Format
signalled through the PHY subclause in 9.7c (D1.03):              M
data sap interface.       "Transport of A-MPDU by                 PD
                          the PHY data service. An                U
                          A-MPDU is transmitted in a
                          PSDU associated with a
                          PHY-TXSTART.request
                          with the TXVECTOR
                          AGGREGATION
                          parameter set to 1. A
                          received PSDU is
                          determined to be an A-
                          MPDU when the
                          associated PHY-
                          RXSTART.indication
                          RXVECTOR
                          AGGREGATION
                          parameter is set to 1."

For each instance, clearly         accept. Document 11-06-        Fr Frame Format
spell out the bit ordering        0836-00-000n-tgn-               am
                                  representation-bitstring-       e
                                  literals-in-tgn-draft.doc       Fo
                                  defines bitstring literals in   rm
                                  D1.0 as msb on the left.        ats
                                  Additionally the editor
                                  should remove
                                  unnecessary use of
                                  bitstring literals where
                                  integers would more
                                  naturally be used in the
                                  baseline.
Define the Enable/Disable        accept. Merge the two           Po Frame Format
and Mode fields as new          fields into a single 8-bit       we
subclauses, 7.3.1.x and         field "SM Power Control",        r
7.3.1.y -- it might also be     give it a new subclause          Ma
handy to combine these into     heading in 7.3.1. Move the       na
one field of 8 bits instead,    current definition of the bits   ge
and some name which has a       within that field into the       me
bit more specificity could be   new subclause. Replace           nt
helpful.                        the existing fields by the
                                new field in frame format
                                and add references to the
                                new subclause where
                                appropriate.

Fix the sentence.                accept. See resolution to       HT Frame Format
                                2193.                            El
                                                                 em
                                                                 ent
                                                                 s



Missing CTS info for STBC        counter. After an email         Fr Frame Format
modes                           exchange with the                am
                                commenter, it appears            e
                                that adding a reference to       Fo
                                the dual CTS protection          rm
                                section would suffice, in        ats
                                the context of setting the
                                Duration/ID field.
Fill in missing entries for      counter. Although tables        PS Frame Format
name and value                  are used in the baseline         M
                                (e.g. the action frame           P
                                formats that came from
                                802.11e), we have
                                extended that with two
                                columns. These columns
                                are largely blank and give
                                rise to comments such as
                                this.

                                Instruct the editor to
                                remove the extra columns
                                and where they provide
                                definition that is not
                                duplicated in the text
                                below, the definition
                                should be moved to the
                                text that follows with
                                appropriate rewording.

                                For consistency, make this
                                change to all 7.1.7
                                subclauses.
P802.11REV-ma-D6.0 ends counter. D1.03 resolves               Ma Frame Format
with 6; 11k added 8-9 (7-8); this by removing the order       na
11r added 9-15. Change to numbers and modifying the           ge
16-17                        editor's instructions thus:      me
                             "insert the following … just     nt
                             before the Vendor Specific       Fr
                             IE and insert contiguous         am
                             numbering in the “Order”         es
                             column"


P802.11REV-ma-D6.0 ends counter. The following                Ma Frame Format
with 6; 11k added 8-9 (7-8); change made in D1.03             na
11r added 9-15. Change to should suffice: Remove              ge
16-17                        order numbers from the           me
                             table and modify the             nt
                             editing instructions to read:    Fr
                             "Insert the following two        am
                             additional rows (preserving      es
                             their order) in Table 11-
                             Association Response
                             frame body just before the
                             Vendor Specific IE and
                             insert contiguous
                             numbering in the “Order”
                             column:"
Recommend changing frame counter. See CID 3803.               PC Frame Format
formats to a Figure instead See also 2245.                    O
of a table. This comment
applies throughout clause
7.4.7




Add the sentence " STAs          reject. It is up to the AP   HT Frame Format
always use a service interval   to decide what granularity    El
granularity value less than     to offer based on its         em
the Beacon Interval"            implementation-defined        ent
                                scheduler. There is no        s
                                need to relate this to the
                                beacon because S-APSD
                                (and therefore S-PSMP)
                                can operate
                                asynchronously compared
                                to the beacon.
Please clarify, or remove this reject. The amendment is            A- Frame Format
restriction.                   not required to justify itself      M
                               internally.                         PD
                               However, in reply to the            U
                               commenter, it simplifies
                               both the implementation
                               and the protocol when
                               these constraints are
                               present.
change "declares" to "shall     reject. There is already a         A- Frame Format
declare"                       normative requirement for           M
                               the HT STA to include this          PD
                               element. The referenced             U
                               text is intended to be
                               descriptive.

Delete "Basic MCS Set"            reject. The following text       HT Frame Format
throughout this document.        appears in D1.03: "9.6.2          El
                                 HT Basic MCS Set                  em
                                 The Basic MCS Set field of        ent
                                 the HT Information                s
                                 element indicates which
                                 MCS values are supported
                                 by all
                                 STAs in a BSS. An AP
                                 shall refuse a
                                 (re)association request
                                 from a STA that does not
                                 support all the rates in
                                 the Basic MCS Set." This
                                 is clearly a use of the field -
                                 i.e. the AP is advertising
                                 which rates it requires all
                                 associated STA to support.

Make consistent in the            reject. The interpretation       HT Frame Format
definition. If there is a link   of the field in D1.03 is          El
between RIFS and APSD,           strictly whether RIFS may         em
that belongs in the              or may not be used. Only          ent
procedures section.              the AP needs to make the          s
                                 link with APSD, and that
                                 doesn't need to be
                                 exposed in the clause 7
                                 text.
remove "NOTE -"                   reject. This is the correct      A- Frame Format
                                 form for including                M
                                 informative text according        PD
                                 to IEEE-SA style guide            U
                                 rules.
Add after the last sentence    accept    Fr
(line 11). "that responder               am
may transmit the MFB at a                e
later point and include the              Fo
corresponding MFS"                       rm
                                         ats


Move the cited text to an      accept    HT Frame Format
appropriate clause, such as              El
11, and add "shall" to the               em
statement with an                        ent
appropriate qualifier.                   s




Note that 10 is reserved       accept    HT Frame Format
                                         El
                                         em
                                         ent
                                         s



Replace "no non-HT STA is      accept    HT Frame Format
associated" with "non-HT                 El
STA may be associated"                   em
                                         ent
                                         s



cite the syntax type for the accept      A- Frame Format
pseudo code, e.g. say "the               M
algorithm is expressed in                PD
Figure xx as a C                         U
Programming Language
code snippet". otherwise the
code could be interpreted in
different ways.

Change "not fixed to allow     accept.   HT Frame Format
extension" to "not fixed, so             El
as to allow extension"                   em
                                         ent
                                         s
Add "HT" between "all" and      accept.   HT Frame Format
"devices" within the "Use"                El
column for Basic MCS set.                 em
                                          ent
                                          s



Move the definitions of all     accept.   An Frame Format
information fields of this MA             ten
Frame as new subclauses                   na
beneath 7.3.1 and provide                 Se
definitions for those fields              lec
that lack one                             tio
                                          n



Change to "..will discard with accept.    A- Frame Format
high probability based…"                  M
                                          PD
                                          U



Change to "The STA shall be accept.       A- Frame Format
capable of receiving                      M
PSDUs…"                                   PD
                                          U


Correct it.                     accept.   A- Frame Format
                                          M
                                          PD
                                          U


Change to: "The STA shall       accept.   A- Frame Format
be able to receive PSDUs of               M
length up to the indicated                PD
limit".                                   U


change verb tense to            accept.   A- Frame Format
include "shall"                           M
                                          PD
                                          U
Clarification in the text would accept. Add the following      A- Frame Format
be preferred.                   note in this section:          M
                                "NOTE-the PSDU length          PD
                                limit applies to the           U
                                maximum length of the
                                PSDU that may be
                                received. If the A-MPDU
                                includes any padding
                                delimiters (i.e. delimiters
                                with the length field set to
                                0) in order to meet the
                                MPDU density
                                requirement, this padding
                                is included in this length
                                limit."
Make change indicated in         accept. Add the following:    A- Frame Format
comment                         "NOTE- the order of            M
                                transmission of bits within    PD
                                the CRC field is defined in    U
                                7.1.1."
delete this paragraph            accept. Already actioned      Ma Frame Format
                                in D1.03 for approved          na
                                comment 3733.                  ge
                                                               me
                                                               nt
                                                               Fr
                                                               am
                                                               es



Define the Channel Width          accept. Create a new         Co Frame Format
field as a new subclause         subclause in 7.3.1 and        exi
within 7.3.1 (i.e. as 7.3.1.x)   move the definition of the    ste
                                 channel width field there     nc
                                 from this clause. Add         e
                                 reference to the new
                                 subclause from the existing
                                 subclause where
                                 appropriate. Set the width
                                 of the field to 1 octet.




Move the normative                accept. D1.03 has action     HT Frame Format
procedure text to another        approved resolution to CID    El
appropriate clause               1107, which effects this      em
                                 change.                       ent
                                                               s
Remove the term, below and accept. D1.03 implements       A- Frame Format
and the explicit references this.                         M
                                                          PD
                                                          U

As suggested               accept. Document 11-06-        Fr Frame Format
                          0836-00-000n-tgn-               am
                          representation-bitstring-       e
                          literals-in-tgn-draft.doc       Fo
                          defines bitstring literals in   rm
                          D1.0 as msb on the left.        ats


As suggested               accept. Document 11-06-        Fr Frame Format
                          0836-00-000n-tgn-               am
                          representation-bitstring-       e
                          literals-in-tgn-draft.doc       Fo
                          defines bitstring literals in   rm
                          D1.0 as msb on the left.        ats


                           accept. Document 11-06-        HT Frame Format
                          0836-00-000n-tgn-               El
                          representation-bitstring-       em
                          literals-in-tgn-draft.doc       ent
                          defines bitstring literals in   s
                          D1.0 as msb on the left.
                          Additionally the editor
                          should remove
                          unnecessary use of
                          bitstring literals where
                          integers would more
                          naturally be used in the
                          baseline.
Clarify                    accept. Give the "PCO          PC Frame Format
                          Phase Control" field a new      O
                          subclause heading in
                          7.3.1. Move the current
                          definition of the field into
                          the new subclause.
                          Replace the existing field
                          by the new field in frame
                          format and add references
                          to the new subclause
                          where appropriate.

Clarify in the draft.      accept. Insert "for the        HT Frame Format
                          reception of" in and            El
                          appropriate place in            em
                          definition column for the       ent
                          two short GI fields.            s
Correct it.                    accept. Resolved in    A- Frame Format
                              resolution to 11974.    M
                                                      PD
                                                      U


Clarify                       accept. See CID 1210.   Co Frame Format
                                                      exi
                                                      ste
                                                      nc
                                                      e




Make consistent between       accept. See CID 4069.   HT Frame Format
description and use                                   El
                                                      em
                                                      ent
                                                      s



dependancy with STA           accept. See CID 4074.   A- Frame Format
capability need to be added                           M
                                                      PD
                                                      U



Examine the entry for Mixed accept. See CID 6906      HT Frame Format
Operating Mode and ichange                            El
it to what it should be.                              em
                                                      ent
                                                      s



change to "non-HT STA is      accept. See CID 6906    HT Frame Format
associated"                                           El
                                                      em
                                                      ent
                                                      s
change "no non-HT STA is       accept. See CID 6906         HT Frame Format
associated" to " there is at                                El
least a non-HT STA                                          em
associated"                                                 ent
                                                            s



Change "no Non-HT STA" to accept. See CID 6906              HT Frame Format
"some non-HT STA"                                           El
                                                            em
                                                            ent
                                                            s



"=Mixed: no non-HT STA" --     accept. See CID 6906         HT Frame Format
> "=Mixed: non-HT STA"                                      El
                                                            em
                                                            ent
                                                            s



Add a table entry to each    accept. See resolution of      A- Frame Format
table which allows no-ack    CID 33.                        M
policy frames to be included                                PD
in any a-mpdu aggregate.                                    U

Clarify                         accept. See resolution to   Po Frame Format
                               1231.                        we
                                                            r
                                                            Ma
                                                            na
                                                            ge
                                                            me
                                                            nt




Clarify                         accept. See resolution to   Po Frame Format
                               1231.                        we
                                                            r
                                                            Ma
                                                            na
                                                            ge
                                                            me
                                                            nt
Change "control channel" to accept. This change has         HT Frame Format
"primary channel" throughout already been implemented       El
the draft.                   by approved resolution in      em
                             D1.03.                         ent
                                                            s



Replace instances of "shall" accept. This has already       Ma Frame Format
with simple declarative forms been handled by prior         na
of the verb.                  comment in D1.03.             ge
                                                            me
                                                            nt
                                                            Fr
                                                            am
                                                            es



add a sentence which places accept. This is covered         A- Frame Format
a limit on transmitter      by resolution to CID 11974.     M
behavior with respect to                                    PD
obeying the advertised                                      U
PSDU limit of an intended
receiver
                             accept. This is resolved in    PS Frame Format
                            D1.03.                          M
                                                            P

Replace the TBD with a       accept. This is resolved in    PS Frame Format
category ID from ANA         D1.03.                         M
                                                            P

Move it to the appropriate    accept. D1.03 has moved       HT Frame Format
subclause                    normative text to clause 9     El
                             in resolution of CID 1107.     em
                                                            ent
                                                            s



These should be               counter. Periods of the       HT Frame Format
microseconds, not ms.        order of typical application   El
                             MSDU periodicities (i.e. 10    em
                             or 20ms for VoIP) are          ent
                             appropriate. In D1.03 the      s
                             "use column" has
                             disappeared and the "in
                             us" has been removed.
Please provide a proper             counter. Both sentences    A- Frame Format
reference for the information      referred to by the          M
missing from the comment in        commenter have been         PD
the first row of the table and     removed in D1.03.           U
make some sense out of the
other part of the comment.




Can you please state the use counter. D1.03 has added          HT Frame Format
more clearly?                a reference to 11.4.4b.2,         El
                             which describes its use.          em
                                                               ent
                                                               s



Make consistent. Is it              counter. D1.03 removes     HT Frame Format
recommended or optional?           the term "recommended"      El
Suggest "should" in col 3          and renames the field to    em
                                   STA Channel Width.          ent
                                                               s



add a (-1) whenever the             counter. Make this         A- Frame Format
2^(…) expression occurs.           adjustment wherever this    M
                                   relates to the Maximum Rx   PD
                                   A-MPDU Factor.              U


State the probability for false-    counter. Remove the        A- Frame Format
positive MPDU delimiter            following sentence: "The    M
recognition, e.g. based on         overall effect may be to    PD
CRC false-positive rate            lose one or more MPDUs      U
multiplied by either 1-in-256      from the aggregate very
for the 0x0E Unique Pattern        infrequently." from the
occurence probability or           footnote.
Unique Pattern probability
derived from general network
traffic textual analysis
Make change indicated in    counter. See CID 1210.    Co Frame Format
comment                                               exi
                                                      ste
                                                      nc
                                                      e




Reference 7.1.1 for encoding counter. See CID 1210.   Co Frame Format
conventions                                           exi
                                                      ste
                                                      nc
                                                      e




Make change indicated in    counter. See CID 1231.    Po Frame Format
comment                                               we
                                                      r
                                                      Ma
                                                      na
                                                      ge
                                                      me
                                                      nt
Make change indicated in    counter. See CID 1231.    Po Frame Format
comment                                               we
                                                      r
                                                      Ma
                                                      na
                                                      ge
                                                      me
                                                      nt




Reference 7.1.1 for encoding counter. See CID 1231.   Po Frame Format
conventions                                           we
                                                      r
                                                      Ma
                                                      na
                                                      ge
                                                      me
                                                      nt




Make change indicated in    Counter. See CID 3803.    PC Frame Format
comment                                               O




Reference 7.1.1 for encoding Counter. See CID 3803.   PC Frame Format
conventions                                           O
Remove: When it receives a counter. See resolution to           A- Frame Format
PSDU of length greater than CID 11974.                          M
the limit, it shall receive the                                 PD
first 2^(13 + Maximum Rx A-                                     U
MPDU Factor ) bytes and
discard any remainder.

Replace: "An HT STA shall
form an aggregate for
transmission such that all the
MPDUs within the aggregate
that are intended to be
received by a particular STA
shall be within the first 2^(13
+ Maximum Rx A-MPDU
Factor ) bytes of the PSDU,
using the limit declared by
that STA."
with:
"An HT STA shall not send a
PSDU that exceeds its
receiver's PSDU Length
capability."


Remove it.                         counter: "An HT STA shall    A- Frame Format
                                  not transmit an A-MPDU        M
                                  that is longer than 2^(13 +   PD
                                  Maximum Rx A-MPDU             U
                                  Factor)-1 octets, using the
                                  limit declared by the
                                  intended receiver."
            This is a dummy entry. Please do not delete or sort out of the top of the sheet.
            This is a dummy entry. Please to not delete or sort out of the top of the sheet.This
            is a dummy entry. Please to not delete or sort out of the top of the sheet. This is a
            dummy entry. Please to not delete or sort out of the top of the sheet.This is a
            dummy entry. Please to not delete or sort out of the top of the sheet. This is a
            dummy entry. Please do not delete or sort out of the top of the sheet.This is a       My order




211
      263
139




225




51
282




279




319
333




303
141




553
 2




329




242
402




322




341




378




129
137




150




331




66
509




140




324




243
16




46
47




48




49




56
464




494




361
138




362




147




326
207




244




452




479
544




246




248




249




250
251




253




254




450




204




481
252




545




524




527




136




39




321
369




551




40




385




539
398




538




540




541




399




542
543




448




239




      U




463




265
67




488




489




556




      U




261
22




330




428




404




      U




      U
412




505




241




262




235
260




57




272
69




247




397
537




496
                             Clause
CID




                   Ed)




                                       Page(C)




                                                                       Part of No
                Name of




                                                                                    Page(Ed)
             Commenter(




                          Number(C)




                                                 Line(C)




                                                             Type of
                                                           Comment




                                                                                                    Line(Ed)
                                                                       Vote(Y/N)
                                                              T/E(C)
      7588 Stephens, 7.3.2.48                              T           N                       51
           Adrian

      1185   Fischer,     7.3.2.47.3   45        1         T           Y                       45              1
      1186   Matthew
             Fischer,     7.3.2.47.3   45        1         T           Y                       45              1
      2147   Matthew
             Ji,          7.3.2.47.3   45        1         T           Y                       45              1
       471   Lusheng
             Chaplin,     7.3.2.47.4   45        3         T           Y                       45              3
      3757   Clint
             Kandala,     7.3.2.47.5   46                  T           Y                       46
      1198   Srinivas
             Fischer,     7.3.2.47.8   51        6         T           Y                       51              6
      3766   Matthew
             Kandala,     7.3.2.48     51        7 to 9    T           Y                       51              7
      7586   Srinivas
             Stephens,    7.3.2.48                         T           N                       51
      7587   Adrian
             Stephens,    7.3.2.48                         T           N                       51
      1199   Adrian
             Fischer,     7.3.2.47.8   52        3         T           Y                       52              3
             Matthew
                                                        Assignee
                    Type




                                   CID


                                          Resn Status




                                                                                                                             Change
Clause(Ed)




                                                                   Submission




                                                                                                                           Proposed
                           Duplicate of




                                                                                                   Comment
                                                                                approval
                                                                                    TGn
                   T(Ed)
             E/HE/T/ST/D




                                                                                                               entry.
                                                                                                             dummy


                                                                                                        not delete or
                                                                                                           Please do

                                                                                                          sort out of
                                                                                                           the top of
                                                                                                            This is a
7.3.2.48     ST                           E                                                Add
                                                                                           before
                                                                                           table n19
7.3.2.47.3   T                            E                                                incorrect         In the first row of
7.3.2.47.3   T                            E                                                prepositio
                                                                                           In                "Maximum the
                                                                                                             the table, inRx
7.3.2.47.3   T                            E                                                Maximum
                                                                                           Use of            PSDUFactor" -->
                                                                                                             Change "shall be
7.3.2.47.4   T                            E                                                "shall"
                                                                                           "B0 to            equal or greater
                                                                                                             Should be either,
7.3.2.47.5   T                            E                                                B76
                                                                                           Is there a        "B0 to B77
                                                                                                             As suggested
7.3.2.48     T                            E                                                polcy by
                                                                                           clumsy            Change "not fixed
7.3.2.48     T                            E                                                wording
                                                                                           Delete the        to allow
                                                                                                             Delete the
7.3.2.48     T                            E                                                pontificait
                                                                                           "In probe         sentence,
                                                                                                             Replace with:
7.3.2.48     T                            E                                                responses
                                                                                           PCO               "reserved in
7.3.2.48     T                            E                                                phase
                                                                                           There is a        Replace the TBD
                                                                                           TBD               with an element
                   Edited in




                                   lookup
      Resolution




                       draft




                                                           Lookup




                                                                      My order
                                     Topic




                                                 Dummy Topic Group
    entry.




    entry.




                                                                                     entry.
                                                   Entry
  dummy




  dummy




                                                                                   dummy
Please do




Please do




                                                                                 Please do
 This is a




 This is a




                                                                                  This is a
                               HT       Frame                        458
                               Elements Format

Suggeste                       HT            Frame                   127
d change
Suggeste                       Elements
                               HT            Format
                                             Frame                   128
d change
suggested                      Elements
                               HT            Format
                                             Frame                   231
Change is
change "0                      Elements
                               HT            Format
                                             Frame                    14
to 77" to                      Elements
                               HT            Format
                                             Frame                   310
                               Elements
                               HT            Format
                                             Frame                   132
                               Elements
                               HT            Format
                                             Frame                   316
                               Elements
                               HT            Format
                                             Frame                   456
                               Elements
                               HT            Format
                                             Frame                   457
                               Elements
                               HT            Format
                                             Frame                   133
                               Elements      Format
         yp
          P




          P




          P




          E
          a

          e

          a




          a


         Li




          e


         ar




          a


         Li
CI
D


          N




         Cl


         se
         m




          u




          g
         e(

          n
         e(




           t




          g
         e(

          n
         e(
         C)




         of




         of
          T
  7478   Stephens,   11.14                            E   N   151
  3700   Adrian
         Kandala,    7.1.2        14        22        T   Y    14   22
  4499   Srinivas
         Liu, Der-   7.3.2.47.3   45        1         T   Y    45    1
  5141   Zheng
         Meylan,     7.3.2.47.3   45        table n17 T   Y    45    1
  8067   Arnaud
         Trainin,    7.3.2.47.3   Table n17           T   Y    45    1
 10311   Solomon
         Kwak, Joe   7.3.2.47.4   45        5         T   N    45    5
  2154   Ji,         7.3.2.47.5   46        4         T   Y    46    4
  2156   Lusheng
         Ji,         7.3.2.47.5   46        4         T   Y    46    4
   473   Lusheng
         Chaplin,    7.3.2.48     51        6         T   Y    51    6
   852   Clint
         Emeott,     7.4A.2       81                  T   Y    81
         Stephen
     A
   yp




     S
     a




     e




   pl
    ic




     a




 T Pr
   Cl


   se




   E/
    D




    R
   es




   ss




    C
     u




     u




     n




   ig
     n

     u
     b
   m


     n


     o
   m
   m

hi o
 s p
is o
    G
   St
     T




     T
11.14        HE   A   These        Find a
7.1.2        ST   A   sections
                      The size     more
                                   Replace
7.3.2.47.3   T    A   of the the
                      Why is       2324 with
                                   Replaced
7.3.2.47.3   T    A   Maximum
                      inconsiste   by "The to
                                   change
7.3.2.47.3   T    A   ncy in
                      16us         'The 1/4
                                   001-
7.3.2.47.4   T    A   coverage
                      Where        μsec
                                   Add
7.3.2.47.5   T    A   value
                      "A PCO       sentence,
                                   Change to
7.3.2.47.5   T    A   capable
                      "specified   "A PCO
                                   Either
7.3.2.48     T    A   "The with
                      time         quantify
                                   Should be
7.4A.2       T    A   structure
                      In Table     "The the
                                   Make
                      n49, the     recomme
                                   y
 E
ol


di
te




pi
 c


pi
 c




                                  or
 R
es




 d

 o




 o




                                   d
ut




 T




 T




                                  M
hi
 s
is

hi
 s
is




                                         hi
                                          s
                                         is
                         D
                         u
                         m
                         m
 T




 T




                                          T
Propose       A-MPDU     Frame     449
accept.
Instruct      Frame      Format
                         Frame     276
the editor
Change        Formats
              HT         Format
                         Frame     374
the length
Change        Elements
              HT         Format
                         Frame     396
PSDU
Accepted      Elements
              HT         Format
                         Frame     477
Add a
after         Elements
              HT         Format
                         Frame     514
sentence,
In table      Elements
              HT         Format
                         Frame     233
n18, in the
Remove        Elements
              HT         Format
                         Frame     234
"with high
Change        Elements
              HT         Format
                         Frame      15
A- n20 to
FigAdd to     Elements
              A-MPDU     Format
                         Frame      65
table n49                Format
            yp
             P




             P




             P




             E
             a

             e

             a




             a


            Li




             e


            ar




             a


            Li
CI
D


             N




            Cl


            se
            m




             u




             g
            e(

             n
            e(




              t




             g
            e(

             n
            e(
            C)




            of




            of
             T
      551   Cooklev,     7.3.2.47.3                  T   N    44
     4519   Todor
            Loc, Peter   7.3.2.47.5   46   Table n18 T   Y    46    4
     7884   Takagi,      7.3.2.47.5   46   4         T   Y    46    4
     8275   Masahiro
            Wentink,     7.4A.1       78   11        T   Y    78   11
      550   Menzo
            Cooklev,     11.14.2                     T   N   151
     9973   Todor
            Xhafa,       7.3.2.47.3   45   Table n17 T   Y    45   1
     1125   Ariton
            Fischer,     7.1.3.8      18   5-11      T   Y    18   5
            Matthew
     A
   yp




     S
     a




     e




   pl
    ic




     a




 T Pr
   Cl


   se




   E/
    D




    R
   es




   ss




    C
     u




     u




     n




   ig
     n

     u
     b
   m


     n


     o
   m
   m

hi o
 s p
is o
    G
   St
     T




     T
7.3.2.47.3   DT   C        According    Replace
7.3.2.47.5   DT   C        to the n18
                           Table        the
                                        Change
7.3.2.47.5   DT   C        - The
                           If AP        transition
                                        Assign
7.4A.1       DT   C        sends
                           The          "00" to
                                        Extend
11.14.2      ST   C        MPDUas
                           same         the MPDU
                                        Replace
7.3.2.47.3   T    C        above
                           Definition   the a
                                        Addtext in
7.1.3.8      T    C   14   of MPDU
                           There are    sentence
                                        Reword
                           several      the
                                y
 E
ol


di
te




pi
 c


pi
 c




                               or
 R
es




 d

 o




 o




                                d
ut




 T




 T




                               M
hi
 s
is

hi
 s
is




                                      hi
                                       s
                                      is
                        D
                        u
                        m
                        m
 T




 T




                                       T
To reflect   HT       Frame      25
the true
Change       Elements
             HT       Format
                      Frame     377
the
See          Elements
             HT       Format
                      Frame     473
Resolution
Proposed     Elements
             A-MPDU   Format
                      Frame     493
counter.
Counter:     A-MPDU Format
                      Frame      24
After has
Text the     HT       Format
                      Frame     498
Accept is
change                Format
             Elements Frame
             Frame
proposed     Formats Format
                CID


         Name of
    Commenter(Ed)




 Clause Number(C)




            Page(C)



            Line(C)




  Type of Comment
              T/E(C)
Part of No Vote(Y/N)
          Page(Ed)

           Line(Ed)
   Clause Title (Ed)
         Clause(Ed)
Type E/HE/T/ST/DT(Ed)




      Duplicate of CID




          Resn Status
            Assignee




          Submission

        TGn approval




            Comment
    This is a dummy entry. Please do not delete or sort out of the top of the sheet.
This is a dummy entry. Please to not delete or sort out of the top of the sheet.This
is a dummy entry. Please to not delete or sort out of the top of the sheet. This is a
     dummy entry. Please to not delete or sort out of the top of the sheet.This is a
     dummy entry. Please to not delete or sort out of the top of the sheet. This is a
     dummy entry. Please do not delete or sort out of the top of the sheet.This is a
    dummy entry. Please do not delete or sort out of the top of the sheet. This is a
              dummy entry. Please do not delete or sort out of the top of the sheet.      Proposed Change



    This is a dummy entry. Please do not delete or sort out of the top of the sheet.
This is a dummy entry. Please to not delete or sort out of the top of the sheet.This
is a dummy entry. Please to not delete or sort out of the top of the sheet. This is a
     dummy entry. Please to not delete or sort out of the top of the sheet.This is a
     dummy entry. Please to not delete or sort out of the top of the sheet. This is a
     dummy entry. Please do not delete or sort out of the top of the sheet.This is a
    dummy entry. Please do not delete or sort out of the top of the sheet. This is a
              dummy entry. Please do not delete or sort out of the top of the sheet.            Resolution


    This is a dummy entry. Please do not delete or sort out of the top of the sheet.
This is a dummy entry. Please to not delete or sort out of the top of the sheet.This
is a dummy entry. Please to not delete or sort out of the top of the sheet. This is a
     dummy entry. Please to not delete or sort out of the top of the sheet.This is a
     dummy entry. Please to not delete or sort out of the top of the sheet. This is a
     dummy entry. Please do not delete or sort out of the top of the sheet.This is a
    dummy entry. Please do not delete or sort out of the top of the sheet. This is a
              dummy entry. Please do not delete or sort out of the top of the sheet.         Edited in draft




                                                                                              Topic lookup



                                                                      Dummy Entry       Topic Group Lookup
                                                                                        My order
    This is a dummy entry. Please do not delete or sort out of the top of the sheet.
This is a dummy entry. Please to not delete or sort out of the top of the sheet.This
is a dummy entry. Please to not delete or sort out of the top of the sheet. This is a
     dummy entry. Please to not delete or sort out of the top of the sheet.This is a
     dummy entry. Please to not delete or sort out of the top of the sheet. This is a
     dummy entry. Please do not delete or sort out of the top of the sheet.This is a
                            Clause Number(C)




                                                                   Type of Comment




                                                                                                                                  Clause Title(Ed)
            Commenter(Ed)




                                                                                     Part of No
                                                                                     Vote(Y/N)
                                                                                                  Page(Ed)


                                                                                                                  Line(Ed)
            Name of




                                               Page(C)




                                                         Line(C)




                                                                   T/E(C)
CID




            Sanwalka,                                                                                                             HT
       7353 Anil            7.3.2.47           all                 T                 Y                       0                    Capabilitie
            Fischer,                                                                                                              Frame
       1107 Matthew         7                                      T                 Y                       13                   formats
            Fischer,                                                                                                              MAC
       1110 Matthew         7.1                14        4         T                 Y                       14               4   frame
            Ji,                                                                                                                   MAC
       1899 Lusheng         7.1                14        4         T                 Y                       14               4   frame
            Fischer,                                                                                                              General
       1114 Matthew         7.1.2              14        22        T                 Y                       14              22   frame
            Kandala,                                                                                                              Frame
       3696 Srinivas        7                  14        27        T                 Y                       14              27   formats
            Kandala,                                                                                                              Frame
       3697 Srinivas        7                  14        29        T                 Y                       14              29   formats
            Fischer,                                                                                                              More
       1116 Matthew         7.1.3.1.5          15        9         T                 Y                       15               9   Fragment
            Kerry,                                                                                                                More
       4049 Stuart          7.1.3.1.5          15        9         T                                         15               9   Fragment
            Fischer,
       1115 Matthew         7.1.3.1.10 15                16        T                 Y                       15              16 Order field
            Xhafa,
       9955 Ariton          7.1.3.1.10 15                16        T                 Y                       15              16 Order field
            Kandala,                                                                                                            Frame
       3699 Srinivas        7                  15        20        T                 Y                       15              20 formats
            Fischer,                                                                                                            Duration/I
       1118 Matthew         7.1.3.2            15        20        T                 Y                       15              20 D field
            Fischer,                                                                                                            Duration/I
       1119 Matthew         7.1.3.2            15        20        T                 Y                       15              20 D field
            CYPHER,                                                                                                             QoS
        610 DAVID           7.1.3.5            15        25        T                 Y                       15              25 Control
            Tsoulogia                                                                                                           Ack Policy
       8109 nnis, Tom       7.1.3.5.3          16        6         T                 Y                       16               6 subfield
            Stephens,                                                                                                           Ack Policy
       7574 Adrian          7.1.3.5.3                              T                 N                       16                 subfield
            Fischer,                                                                                                            TXOP
       1122 Matthew         7.1.3.5.6          17        8-12      T                 Y                       17               8 Duration
            Raissinia,                                                                                                          TXOP
       7224 Ali             7.1.3.5.6          17        12        T                 N                       17              12 Duration
            CYPHER,                                                                                                             HT
        616 DAVID           7.1.3.8            17        16        T                 Y                       17              16 Control
            CYPHER,                                                                                                             HT
        612 DAVID           7.1.3.8            18        4-5       T                 Y                       18               4 Control
            CYPHER,                                                                                                             HT
        613 DAVID           7.1.3.8            18        4-5       T                 Y                       18               4 Control
            Ji,                                                                                                                 HT
       1927 Lusheng         7.1.3.8            18        4         T                 Y                       18               4 Control
            Ji,                                                                                                                 HT
       1928 Lusheng         7.1.3.8            18        4         T                 Y                       18               4 Control
            Tsoulogia                                                                                                           HT
       8112 nnis, Tom       7.1.3.8            18        4         T                 Y                       18               4 Control
            Hart,                                                                                                               HT
      12091 Brian           7.1.3.8            18        4         T                 Y                       18               4 Control
            Fischer,                                                                                                            HT
       1123 Matthew         7.1.3.8            18                  T                 Y                       18                 Control
            Fischer,                                                                                                            HT
       1126 Matthew         7.1.3.8            20        10-11     T                 Y                       20              10 Control
      Ji,                                                    HT
 1939 Lusheng      7.1.3.8    20   12        T   Y   20   12 Control
      Kumar,                                                 Aggregate
12255 Rajneesh     7.2.2.1    30   General   T   Y   30    0 d MSDU
      Fischer,                                               Data
 1135 Matthew      7.2.2      30   2         T   Y   30    2 frames
      Fischer,                                               Aggregate
 1144 Matthew      7.2.2.1    30   14        T   Y   30   14 d MSDU
      Fischer,                                               Aggregate
 1138 Matthew      7.2.2.1    30   23        T   Y   30   23 d MSDU
      Ji,                                                    Aggregate
 1991 Lusheng      7.2.2.1    30   24        T   Y   30   24 d MSDU
      Adachi,                                                Aggregate
   25 Tomoko       7.2.2.1                   T   Y   30      d MSDU
      Malinen,                                               Aggregate
 4606 Jouni        7.2.2.1    30             T   Y   30      d MSDU
      Ji,                                                    Aggregate
 1992 Lusheng      7.2.2.1    31   1         T   Y   31    1 d MSDU
      Dorsey,                                                Aggregate
  728 John         7.2.2.1    31   6         T   Y   31    6 d MSDU
      Fischer,                                               Aggregate
 1141 Matthew      7.2.2.1    31   6         T   Y   31    6 d MSDU
      Kandala,                                               Aggregate
 3729 Srinivas     7.2.2.1    31   6         T   Y   31    6 d MSDU
      Fischer,                                               Aggregate
 1142 Matthew      7.2.2.1    31   8         T   Y   31    8 d MSDU
      Fischer,                                               Aggregate
 1143 Matthew      7.2.2.1    31   12        T   Y   31   12 d MSDU
      Kandala,                                               Associatio
 3733 Srinivas     7.2.3.4                   T   Y   32      n Request
      Ji,                                                    Reassocia
 2022 Lusheng      7.2.3.6    33   22        T   Y   33   22 tion
      Fischer,                                               Associatio
 1157 Matthew      7.2.3.5    33             T   Y   33      n
      Fischer,                                               Reassocia
 1159 Matthew      7.2.3.6    33             T   Y   33      tion
      Ji,                                                    Reassocia
 2026 Lusheng      7.2.3.7    34   5         T   Y   34    5 tion
      Ji,                                                    Probe
 2031 Lusheng      7.2.3.8    34   16        T   Y   34   16 Request
      Kandala,                                               Reassocia
 3736 Srinivas     7.2.3.7                   T   Y   34      tion
      Fischer,                                               Probe
 1163 Matthew      7.2.3.8    34             T   Y   34      Request
      Kandala,                                               Probe
 3738 Srinivas     7.2.3.9                   T   Y   34      Response
      CYPHER,                                                New
  632 DAVID        7.3.2.20A 39    4-7       T   Y   39    4 Extension
      Raissinia,                                             TSPEC
 7235 Ali          7.3.2.29   40   11        T   Y   40   11 element
      Kandala,                                               TSPEC
 3745 Srinivas     7.3.2.29                  T   Y   40      element
      Fischer,                                               HT
 1182 Matthew      7.3.2.47.1 41   3         T   Y   41    3 Capability
      CYPHER,                                                HT
  633 DAVID        7.3.2.47.1 41   6 & 13-14 T   Y   41    6 Capability
      Jokela,                                                HT
 3411 Jari         7.3.2.47.1 41   10-11     T   Y   41   10 Capability
      Fischer,                                               HT
 1181 Matthew      7.3.2.47.1 41   17        T   Y   41   17 Capability
      CYPHER,                                                HT
  635 DAVID        7.3.2.47.2 41   20        T   Y   41   20 Capabilitie
      Jokela,                      Table                     HT
 3412 Jari         7.3.2.47.2 42   n16,      T   Y   42    3 Capabilitie
      Ji,                                                    HT
 2138 Lusheng      7.3.2.47.2 43   0         T   Y   43    0 Capabilitie
      Ji,                                                     HT
 2140 Lusheng      7.3.2.47.2 43    0         E   N   43    0 Capabilitie
      Jang,                                                   Ack Policy
 1759 KyungHun     7.1.3.5.3   6              T   N   6       subfield
      Ji,                                                     QoS
 1916 Lusheng      7.1.3.5     16   2         T   Y   16    2 Control
      Fischer,                                                Ack Policy
 1120 Matthew      7.1.3.5.3   16   6         T   Y   16    6 subfield
      Nanda,                                                  Ack Policy
 6891 Sanjiv       7.1.3.5.3   16   6         T   Y   16    6 subfield
      Kerry,                                                  TXOP
 4050 Stuart       7.1.3.5.6   17   8         T       17    8 Duration
      Chaplin,                                                HT
  464 Clint        7.1.3.8     18   2         T   Y   18    2 Control
      Ji,                                                     HT
 1925 Lusheng      7.1.3.8     18   4         T   Y   18    4 Control
      Yamaura,                                                HT
10069 Tomoya       7.1.3.8     18   4         T   Y   18    4 Control
      Fischer,                                                HT
 1125 Matthew      7.1.3.8     18   5-11      T   Y   18    5 Control
      Ramesh,      7.1.3.8                                    HT
 7299 Sridhar      (HT         18   10,11     T   Y   18   10 Control
      Lojko,                                                  HT
 4552 Peter        7.1.3.8     18   12        T   Y   18   12 Control
      Ji,                                                     HT
 1932 Lusheng      7.1.3.8     19   1         T   Y   19    1 Control
      Ji,                                                     HT
 1936 Lusheng      7.1.3.8     20   7         T   Y   20    7 Control
      Ji,                                                     HT
 1937 Lusheng      7.1.3.8     20   10        T   Y   20   10 Control
      Pirzada,                                                HT
 7188 Fahd         7.1.3.8     21   5         T   Y   21    5 Control
      Kandala,                                                Data
 3726 Srinivas     7.2.2       29   30        T   Y   29   30 frames
      Adachi,                                                 Data
   24 Tomoko       7.2.2       29             T   Y   29      frames
      Kandala,                                                Aggregate
 3727 Srinivas     7.2.2.1     30   7         T   Y   30    7 d MSDU
      Kuehnel,                                                Aggregate
 4261 Thomas       7.2.2.1     30   9         T   Y   30    9 d MSDU
      Yee,                                                    Aggregate
10097 James        7.2.2.1     30   9         T   N   30    9 d MSDU
      Ji,                                                     Aggregate
 1990 Lusheng      7.2.2.1     30   16        T   Y   30   16 d MSDU
      Fischer,                                                Aggregate
 1139 Matthew      7.2.2.1     30   22        T   Y   30   22 d MSDU
      Ji,                                                     QoS Null
 1999 Lusheng      7.2.2.2     31   15        T   Y   31   15 Embeddin
      Fischer,                                                QoS Null
 1146 Matthew      7.2.2.2     31   19        T   Y   31   19 Embeddin
      Kerry,                                                  QoS Null
 4056 Stuart       7.2.2.2     31   20        T   Y   31   20 Embeddin
      Choudhur                                                QoS Null
  491 y, Abhijit   7.2.2.2     31   21        T   Y   31   21 Embeddin
      Fischer,                                                QoS Null
 1149 Matthew      7.2.2.2                    T   Y   31      Embeddin
      Ji,                                                     QoS Null
 2002 Lusheng      7.2.2.2     32   0         T   Y   32    0 Embeddin
      Kerry,                                                  Beacon
 4057 Stuart       7.2.3.1     32   9         T   N   32    9 frame
      Kerry,                                                  Beacon
 4058 Stuart       7.2.3.1     32   Table 8   T   N   32   15 frame
      Inoue,                                                  Beacon
 1742 Yasuhiko     7.2.3.1     32             T   Y   32      frame
      Kerry,                                                  Associatio
 4059 Stuart       7.2.3.4     33   1         T   N   33    1 n Request
      Kerry,                                                    Associatio
 4060 Stuart       7.2.3.4      33   11         T   N   33   11 n Request
      Kerry,                                                    Associatio
 4061 Stuart       7.2.3.5      33   Table 11   T   N   33   17 n
      Kerry,                                                    Reassocia
 4062 Stuart       7.2.3.6      33   22         T   N   33   22 tion
      Kerry,                                                    Reassocia
 4063 Stuart       7.2.3.7      34   5          T   N   34    5 tion
      Kerry,                                                    Reassocia
 4064 Stuart       7.2.3.7      34   16         T   N   34   16 tion
      Kerry,                                                    Probe
 4065 Stuart       7.2.3.8      34   Table 14   T   N   34   19 Request
      Kerry,                                                    Probe
 4066 Stuart       7.2.3.8      34   23         T   N   34   23 Request
      Kerry,                                                    Probe
 4067 Stuart       7.2.3.9      35   Table 15   T   N   35    3 Response




      Adachi,                                                     Status
   26 Tomoko       7.3.1.9      36              T   Y   36        Code field
      Kandala,                                                    Status
 3742 Srinivas     7.3.1.9                      T   Y   36        Code field
      Stephens,                                                   HT
 7582 Adrian       7.3.2.47.1 41     2          T   Y   41    2   Capability
      Chaplin,                                                    HT
  470 Clint        7.3.2.41.1 41     3          T   Y   41    3   Capability
      Ji,                                                         HT
 2119 Lusheng      7.3.2.47.1 41     3          T   N   41    3   Capability
      Jokela,                                                     HT
 3410 Jari         7.3.2.47.1 41     3          T   Y   41    3   Capability
      Kandala,                                                    HT
 3746 Srinivas     7.3.2.47.1 41     3          T   Y   41    3   Capability
      Lefkowitz,                                                  HT
 4339 Martin       7.3.2.47.1 41     7          T   Y   41    7   Capability
      Fischer,                                                    HT
 1183 Matthew      7.3.2.47.1 41                T   Y   41        Capability
      Scarpa,                                                     HT
 7358 Vincenzo     7.3.2.47.1                   T       41        Capability
      Durand,                                                     HT
  771 Roger        7.3.2.47.2                   T   Y   41        Capabilitie
      Ji,                                                         HT
 2130 Lusheng      7.3.2.47.2 42     3          T   N   42    3   Capabilitie
      Lefkowitz,   Table N-                                       HT
 4348 Martin       16         42     3          T   Y   42    3   Capabilitie
      Meylan,                                                     HT
 5140 Arnaud       7.3.2.47.2 43     table n16 T    Y   43    1   Capabilitie
      Ramesh,      7.3.2.47.2                                     HT
 7303 Sridhar      (HT        43     Table n16 E    Y   43    1   Capabilitie
      Kandala,                                                    HT
 3754 Srinivas     7.3.2.47.2 43                T   Y   43        Capabilitie
      Kandala,                                                    MAC HT
 3755 Srinivas     7.3.2.47.3 43                T   Y   43        parameter
      Basson,                        Figure                       Extended
11993 Gal          7.3.2.47.5 46     n18        T   N   46    0   HT
      Jang,                                                       Ack Policy
 1758 KyungHun     7.1.3.5.3    6               T   N   6         subfield
      Godfrey,                                                    General
 1514 Tim          7.1.2        14   29         T   N   14   29   frame
      Inoue,
 1733 Yasuhiko     7.1.3.1.10 15     14         T   Y   15   14 Order field
      Hayes,
10301 Kevin        7.1.3.1.10 15     16         T   N   15   16 Order field
      Fischer,                                                  Duration/I
 1117 Matthew       7.1.3.2     15   20         T   Y   15   20 D field
      Kandala,                                                  QoS
 3703 Srinivas      7.1.3.5     15   25         T   Y   15   25 Control
      Fischer,                                                  Ack Policy
 1121 Matthew       7.1.3.5.3   16   6          T   Y   16    6 subfield
      Sanwalka,                                                 Ack Policy
 7351 Anil          7.1.3.5.3   16   6          t   Y   16    6 subfield
      Kerry,                                                    TXOP
 4051 Stuart        7.1.3.5.6   17   12         T       17   12 Duration
      Durand,                                                   TXOP
  764 Roger         7.1.3.5.6                   T   Y   17      Duration
      Fischer,                                                  HT
 1132 Matthew       7.1.3.8                     T   Y   17      Control
      Kandala,                                                  HT
 3714 Srinivas      7.1.3.8                     T   Y   17      Control
      Ji,                                                       HT
 1924 Lusheng       7.1.3.8     18   3          T   Y   18    3 Control
      Ji,                                                       HT
 1926 Lusheng       7.1.3.8     18   4          T   Y   18    4 Control
      Ji,                                                       HT
 1929 Lusheng       7.1.3.8     18   5          T   Y   18    5 Control
      Kasher,                                                   HT
 3910 Assaf         `           18              T   N   18      Control
      Wentink,                                                  HT
 8274 Menzo         7.1.3.8     18              T   Y   18      Control
      Basson,                                                   HT
11982 Gal           7.1.3.8     18              T   N   18      Control
      Ji,                                                       HT
 1933 Lusheng       7.1.3.8     19   1          T   Y   19    1 Control
      CYPHER,                                                   HT
  615 DAVID         7.1.3.8     19   2          T   Y   19    2 Control
      Ji,                                                       HT
 1934 Lusheng       7.1.3.8     20   2          T   Y   20    2 Control
      Ji,                                                       HT
 1935 Lusheng       7.1.3.8     20   6          T   Y   20    6 Control
      Ji,                                                       HT
 1938 Lusheng       7.1.3.8     20   10         T   Y   20   10 Control
      Basson,                                                   HT
12018 Gal           7.1.3.8     21   Table n8   T   N   21    0 Control
      Ji,                                                       Duration/I
 1946 Lusheng       7.1.4       22   2          T   Y   22    2 D field in
      Inoue,                                                    Duration/I
 1734 Yasuhiko      7.1.4       22   3          T   Y   22    3 D field in
      Ji,                                                       Data
 1986 Lusheng       7.2.2       29   30         T   Y   29   30 frames




        Inoue,                                                    Data
 1740   Yasuhiko    7.2.2       30   3-4        T   Y   30    3   frames
        Ji,                                                       Aggregate
 1987   Lusheng     7.2.2.1     30   6          T   Y   30    6   d MSDU
        Kuehnel,                                                  Aggregate
 4260   Thomas      7.2.2.1     30   7          T   Y   30    7   d MSDU
        Malinen,                                                  Aggregate
 4607   Jouni       7.2.2.1     30   21         T   Y   30   21   d MSDU
        Tsoulogia                                                 Aggregate
 8116   nnis, Tom   7.2.2.1     30   22         T   Y   30   22   d MSDU
        Jokela,                                                   Aggregate
 3409   Jari        7.2.2.1     30   25, 26     T   Y   30   25   d MSDU
     Dorsey,                                              Aggregate
 727 John         7.2.2.1    31   6       T   Y   31    6 d MSDU
     Ji,                                                  QoS Null
1997 Lusheng      7.2.2.2    31   14      T   Y   31   14 Embeddin
     Ji,                                                  QoS Null
1998 Lusheng      7.2.2.2    31   15      T   Y   31   15 Embeddin
     Kandala,                                             QoS Null
3731 Srinivas     7.2.2.2    31   21      T   Y   31   21 Embeddin
     Fischer,                                             QoS Null
1147 Matthew      7.2.2.2    32   2       T   Y   32    2 Embeddin
     SURINEN                                              Data
7812 I,           7.2.2      32   4       E   N   32    4 frames
     Tsoulogia                                            Beacon
8117 nnis, Tom    7.2.3.1    32   15      T   Y   32   15 frame
     Durand,      7.2.3.4                                 Associatio
 767 Roger        and                     T   Y   32      n Request
     Ji,                                                  Probe
2034 Lusheng      7.2.3.8    34   19      T   Y   34   19 Request
     Ji,                                                  Informatio
2117 Lusheng      7.3.2.37   40   17      T   Y   40   17 n
     Ji,                                                  HT
2133 Lusheng      7.3.2.47.2 42   3       T   Y   42    3 Capabilitie
     Mujtaba,                                             HT
6812 Syed Aon     7.3.2.47.2 42   3       T   N   42    3 Capabilitie
     Inoue,                                               HT
1744 Yasuhiko     7.3.2.47.2 42           T   Y   42      Capabilitie
     Matsuo,                                              HT
4635 Ryoko        7.3.2.47.2 42           T   Y   42      Capabilitie
     Scarpa,                                              HT
7360 Vincenzo     7.3.2.47.2 42           T       42      Capabilitie
     Ji,                                                  HT
2136 Lusheng      7.3.2.47.2 43   0       T   Y   43    0 Capabilitie
     Ji,                                                  HT
2137 Lusheng      73.2.47.2 43    0       T   N   43    0 Capabilitie
     Ji,                                                  HT
2141 Lusheng      7.3.2.47.2 43   0       T   N   43    0 Capabilitie
     Nanda,                                               HT
6902 Sanjiv       7.3.2.47.2 43   PSMP    T   Y   43    3 Capabilitie
     Petranovic                                           HT
7173 h, James     7.3.2.47.2 43           T   N   43    3 Capabilitie
     Choudhur                                             HT
 492 y, Abhijit   7.3.2.47.2 43   Row 4   T   Y   43    4 Capabilitie
                                                          HT
     Kandala,                                             Capabilitie
3751 Srinivas     7.3.2.47.2 43           T   Y   43      s Info field


                                                          HT
     Kandala,                                             Capabilitie
3752 Srinivas     7.3.2.47.2 43           T   Y   43      s Info field
                                                                                                                                                     Proposed Change
             E/HE/T/ST/DT(Ed)


                                Duplicate of CID




                                                                                         TGn approval
                                                   Resn Status



                                                                            Submission
Clause(Ed)




                                                                                                                                          Comment
                                                                 Assignee
             Type




                                                                                                        This section of the standard is      Remove
7.3.2.47     T                                     A                                     Motionx1       describing the elements.             heading.
                                                                                                                                             Replace
7            T                                     A                                     Motionx1       Thou shalt not shall in clause 7. instances
                                                                                                        The description of a MAC             Reword
7.1          T                                     A                                     Motionx1       header is not accurate. Some         the
                                                                                                        Paragraph doesn't show the           Show the
7.1          T                                     A                                     Motionx1       changes being made                   changes -
                                                                                                        Why do only some fields now          make
7.1.2        T                                     A                                     Motionx1       show "0 or" when other fields        consistent
                                                                                                        I am not sure what the sentence, Rephrase/
7            ST                                    A                                     Motionx1       "The format of an A-MPDU             remove
                                                                                                        What is the specific reason for Delete the
7            T                                     A                                     Motionx1       the special mention of HT            sentence
                                                                                                        what is meant by "HT peers"?         use
7.1.3.1.5    T                                     A                                     Motionx1       Not defined, Is it just "HT          consistent
                                                                                                                                             Replace
7.1.3.1.5    DT                                    A                                     Motionx1       …using Block Ack                     with ..
                                                                                                        There is no definition for an HT Delete the
7.1.3.1.10 T                                       A                                     Motionx1       PPDU.                                words
                                                                                                        "The presence of the HT control Change it
7.1.3.1.10 T                                       A                                     Motionx1       field in frames carried in an HT to: "The
                                                                                                        Rewrite the sentence without         As
7            ST                                    A                                     Motionx1       using the word "shall"               suggested
                                                                                                        "in an aggregate" is unclear.        clarify and
7.1.3.2      T                                     A                                     Motionx1       Should it be "in an A-MPDU"?         consistant
                                                                                                        "shall all carry the same value" -
7.1.3.2      T                                     A                                     Motionx1       What value should that be?           clarify
                                                                                                        The presence of an A-MSDU            Add "and
7.1.3.5      T                                     A                                     Motionx1       cannot be signaled by bit 7          set to
                                                                                                        In the first line of the 0-0 case in Reword
7.1.3.5.3    T                                     A                                     Motionx1       table 6 the phrase "or implicit      this
                                                                                                        "The addressed recipient returns Replace
7.1.3.5.3    DT                                    A                                     Motionx1       a BA MPDU or MTBA MPDU,              with: "The
                                                                                                        The text in this part of the draft Move the
7.1.3.5.6    T                                     A                                     Motionx1       describes behavior, not frame        text to an
                                                                                                        Add the phrase "or subsequent Include
7.1.3.5.6    DT                                    A                                     Motionx1       PSMP schedule" to the end of         the
                                                                                                                                             Change is
7.1.3.8      T                                     A                                     Motionx1       Too many verbs in sentence           to in
                                                                                                        Field names do not match those Add text
7.1.3.8      T                                     A                                     Motionx1       shown in Figure n2. The reuse to MRQ
                                                                                                        For MFS a See note is included Number
7.1.3.8      T                                     A                                     Motionx1       in the table but it is not clear     notes and
                                                                                                        Field MRS/ASI is not defined in Probably
7.1.3.8      T                                     A                                     Motionx1       table n3                             change
                                                                                                        Field MFB/ASC is not defined in Probably
7.1.3.8      T                                     A                                     Motionx1       table n3                             change
                                                                                                        Table n3 is very difficult to        Redo
7.1.3.8      ST                                    A                                     Motionx1       decipher. One reason is that         Table n3
                                                                                                        Value of MRS when MRQ = 0 is Define
7.1.3.8      ST                                    A                                     Motionx1       undefined.                           what MRS
                                                                                                        In table n3, there is the            Either
7.1.3.8      T                                     A                                     Motionx1       statement "see note" in the table make a
                                                                                                        The word "must" shall not            Change
7.1.3.8      T                                     A                                     Motionx1       appear here.                         "must be "
                                     Procedures don't belong in           Move the
7.1.3.8    T    A         Motionx1   clause 7                             procedure
                                     It is not clear if MSDU belonging    Please
7.2.2.1    ST   A         Motionx1   to different UP be munged into       clarify that
                                     What about the existing text that    Does it
7.2.2      T    A         Motionx1   starts with "The frame body          need a
                                     When setting the length to a
7.2.2.1    T    A         Motionx1   multiple of 4, does it include the   Clarify
                                                                          Change
7.2.2.1    T    A         Motionx1   ambiguous wording                    "is
                                     Is it the intent of 11n to prevent   Change
7.2.2.1    ST   A         Motionx1   any future data confidentiality      "encrypted
                                     As the A-MSDU length can be          Clarify
7.2.2.1    ST   A         Motionx1   longer than the delimiter of A-      that when
                                     A-MSDU description did not           Clarify use
7.2.2.1    DT   A         Motionx1   seem to place any limit on           of A-
                                     Since the SA and DA fields of        Please
7.2.2.1    T    A         Motionx1   the individual frames may be         clarify this
                                     Wouldn't an A-MSDU lifetime          Explain
7.2.2.1    ST   A         Motionx1   computed as the minimum of           why max
                                                                          Change
7.2.2.1    T    A         Motionx1   incorrect preposition                "defined
                                     Please move the behavior to          As
7.2.2.1    T    A         Motionx1   normative part of the draft (a       suggested
                                                                          Delete the
7.2.2.1    T    A         Motionx1   The note has no referant.            text "Note
                                                                          Delete the
7.2.2.1    T    A         Motionx1   The note has no referant.            text "Note
                                     The text above the table does        At least
7.2.3.4    T    A         Motionx1   not add anything. The rest of the    for the
                                     Text in this paragraph duplicates    delete this
7.2.3.6    T    A         Motionx1   what is already stated in the        paragraph
                                                                          Replace
7.2.3.5    T    A         Motionx1   Thou shalt not shall in clause 7.    instances
                                                                          Replace
7.2.3.6    T    A         Motionx1   Thou shalt not shall in clause 7.    instances
                                     Text in this paragraph duplicates    delete this
7.2.3.7    T    A         Motionx1   what is already stated in the        paragraph
                                     Text in this paragraph duplicates    delete this
7.2.3.8    T    A         Motionx1   what is already stated in the        paragraph
                                     The text above the table does        At least
7.2.3.7    T    A         Motionx1   not add anything. The rest of the    for the
                                                                          Replace
7.2.3.8    T    A         Motionx1   Thou shalt not shall in clause 7.    instances
                                     The text above the table does        At least
7.2.3.9    T    A         Motionx1   not add anything. The rest of the    for the
                    Fra              If a value of zero is no extension   Specify
7.3.2.20A ST    A   me    Motionx1   channel, a value ot 3 is below,      the
                                     The statement mandates the           Modify the
7.3.2.29   DT   A         Motionx1   use of MTBA BlockAck frame           text to
                                                                          As
7.3.2.29   T    A         Motionx1   Update Table 37 for HT PHY           suggested
                                     The shall sentence here is           Removed
7.3.2.47.1 T    A         Motionx1   covered by virtue of the inclusion   the
                                     If the length of this element is     Delete
7.3.2.47.1 ST   A         Motionx1   not fixed to allow extension, then   (26)
                                     It seem to be useful to add HT       Make it
7.3.2.47.1 ST   A         Motionx1   Capability element to                possible
                                                                          Change
7.3.2.47.1 ST   A         Motionx1   Instance of TBD                      TBD to
                                     Is it Delayed BlockAck or N-         Use one
7.3.2.47.2 T    A         Motionx1   Delayed BlockAck?                    term
                                                                          Add
7.3.2.47.2 T    A         Motionx1   What is MIMO PPDU?                   definition
                                     DSSS/CCK - "The AP shall not         Move the
7.3.2.47.2 T    A         Motionx1   include…"                            normative
                                      DSSS/CCK last line in table very   Reword
7.3.2.47.2 T     A         Motionx1   badly worded                       before
                                      I believe that the original        Cross out
7.1.3.5.3   ST   C         Motionx2   intention on the usage of MTBA     'MTBA
                                      Explain the change of "QAP" to     Clarify the
7.1.3.5     T    C         Motionx2   "AP" (twice in "Bits 8-15"         intent of
7.1.3.5.3   T    C         Motionx2   What does "this value" refer to? clarify
                                      For QoS Null (no data) frames Allow No
7.1.3.5.3   T    C         Motionx2   this is the only permissible value Ack policy
                                                                         Replace
7.1.3.5.6   T    C         Motionx2   HT STA                             with HT
                                      You have this spiffy figure n2     Either
7.1.3.8     T    C         Motionx2   here. However, I can find no       refer to
                                      The "QoS Null Data frame" has Delete the
7.1.3.8     DT   C         Motionx2   the bit set in the MAC header      notion of a
                                      TRQ itself in HTC doesn't imply Replace "
7.1.3.8     T    C         Motionx2   immediate response.                '1' =
                                      There are several occurrences Reword
7.1.3.8     T    C         Motionx2   of the word "shall" in this        the
                                      "When a responder is unable to "When a
7.1.3.8     T    C         Motionx2   provide an immediate response responder
                                      Both rows of Table n2 indicate Delete
7.1.3.8     T    C         Motionx2   the same values of MRQ and         second
                                      Table n4 seems to be redefining If so,
7.1.3.8     T    C         Motionx2   part of what was already defined merge
                                      Table n6 row for "Calibration      Move the
7.1.3.8     T    C         Motionx2   Sequence" is giving procedural procedure
                                                                         Make
7.1.3.8     T    C         Motionx2   Change the "must" to "shall"       change
                                      This section refers to             Define
7.1.3.8     ST   C         Motionx2   requirements for third party       third party
                                      Figure 35 - with the introduction Replace
7.2.2       T    C         Motionx2   of A-MSDU frames the               2324 with
                                      The maximum length of Frame Make
7.2.2       ST   C         Motionx2   Body is expressed as 2324, but consistent
                                      The entire paragraph appears to Move it to
7.2.2.1     T    C         Motionx2   be normative and I am not sure a more
                                      Whilst A-MSDUs may increase remove
7.2.2.1     DT   C         Motionx2   the MAC efficiency slightly, if at sentence:
                                      TCP acks is not a good             Delete
7.2.2.1     T    C         Motionx2   example. There are applications "such as
                                      "The DA and SA fields are          Please
7.2.2.1     T    C         Motionx2   interpreted as defined in Table clarify this
                                                                         Change
7.2.2.1     T    C         Motionx2   ambiguous wording                  "The
                                      Given the design with MA=1 and Please
7.2.2.2     T    C         Motionx2   "No Frame Body" both set, what clarify the
                                                                         Change
7.2.2.2     T    C         Motionx2   Thou shalt not shall in clause 7. "shall not
                                      "The sequence number is            e.g. "The
7.2.2.2     T    C         Motionx2   undefined." This should be         sequence
                                      Why is Management Action           Fix the
7.2.2.2     T    C         Motionx2   Body size 2-2318 and not 0-        figure.
                     Sol              Is there any restriction on the    Add a
7.2.2.2     ST   C   om    Motionx2   use of the QOS NULL + HTC + clarifying
                                      Depending on the Category          Fix Figure
7.2.2.2     T    C         Motionx2   value, the Action Value may not n12, or
                                      dot11HTCapabilityImplemented Replace
7.2.3.1     T    C         Motionx2   not defined in MIB                 with
                                      dot11HTCapabilityImplemented Replace
7.2.3.1     T    C         Motionx2   not defined in MIB                 with
                                      In Table 8, Order 32               As
7.2.3.1     ST   C         Motionx2   "New Extension Channel Offset suggested
                                      dot11HTCapabilityImplemented Replace
7.2.3.4     T    C         Motionx2   not defined in MIB                 with
                                dot11HTCapabilityImplemented         Replace
7.2.3.4     T    C   Motionx2   not defined in MIB                   with
                                dot11HTCapabilityImplemented         Replace
7.2.3.5     T    C   Motionx2   not defined in MIB                   with
                                dot11HTCapabilityImplemented         Replace
7.2.3.6     T    C   Motionx2   not defined in MIB                   with
                                dot11HTCapabilityImplemented         Replace
7.2.3.7     T    C   Motionx2   not defined in MIB                   with
                                dot11HTCapabilityImplemented         Replace
7.2.3.7     T    C   Motionx2   not defined in MIB                   with
                                dot11HTCapabilityImplemented         Replace
7.2.3.8     T    C   Motionx2   not defined in MIB                   with
                                dot11HTCapabilityImplemented         Replace
7.2.3.8     T    C   Motionx2   not defined in MIB                   with
                                dot11HTCapabilityImplemented         Replace
7.2.3.9     T    C   Motionx2   not defined in MIB                   with
                                                                     Add a
                                                                     status
                                A status code for denying            code for
                                association when a STA does          the HT AP
                                not meet the 802.11n feature(s)      to deny
                                that the AP requires should be       associatio
7.3.1.9     ST   C   Motionx2   defined.                             n due to
                                Surely there could be reasons        Add a few
7.3.1.9     ST   C   Motionx2   for not associating or not           status
                                All the features of the HTC are      Add a
7.3.2.47.1 ST    C   Motionx2   optional. It should therefore be     capability
                                "The HT Capabilities field shall     I believe it
7.3.2.47.1 T     C   Motionx2   be present in any frame              should be,
                                Use of "shall" inappropriate in      While this
7.3.2.47.1 T     C   Motionx2   clause 7                             sentence
                                802.11k Measurement Pilot            Make it
7.3.2.47.1 ST    C   Motionx2   Frame does not contain               possible
                                Clearly this element is not          Qualify
7.3.2.47.1 T     C   Motionx2   present with any of the currently    the
                                "The length of this element is       Remove
7.3.2.47.1 DT    C   Motionx2   not fixed to allow extension. The    "Additional
                                The length is specified as 26        Change
7.3.2.47.1 T     C   Motionx2   octets, but the text declares that   the length
                                HT Control field is used to          Add
7.3.2.47.1 DT    C   Motionx2   handle optional features and         support to
                                There is no such DSSS/CCK            B12 refers
7.3.2.47.2 DT    C   Motionx2   mode, do you mean something          to a
                                in row "MIMO power save", how        Change to
7.3.2.47.2 T     C   Motionx2   can a STA be operating in            "STA is
                                "advanced coding" is undefined       Define it in
7.3.2.47.2 ST    C   Motionx2   thus far                             section 3
                                BSS could mean infrastructure        replace
7.3.2.47.2 T     C   Motionx2   BSS or IBSS. PSMP is not             'BSS' with
                                "Indicates support for N-Delayed     "Indicates
7.3.2.47.2 T     C   Motionx2   Block ACK". Clarify if this is for   support
                                Clarify how DS/CCK, PSMP and         As
7.3.2.47.2 T     C   Motionx2   STBC control fields are              suggested
                                The field does not cover all         As
7.3.2.47.3 T     C   Motionx2   aspects of MAC HT. Rename it         suggested
                                                                     Use bit 10
7.3.2.47.5 T     C   Motionx2   Add capability of HTC support        in the
                                The case when this particular        Change
7.1.3.5.3   ST   R   Motionx3   setting of ACK policy bits will be   'Normal
                                The HT Control field is only         Clarify
7.1.2       ST   R   Motionx3   applicable to HT devices, but        when the
                                "All non-HT QSTAs set this           We can
7.1.3.1.10 DT    R   Motionx3   subfield to 0."                      use other
                                Unclear whether +HTC is              Add;
7.1.3.1.10 DT    R   Motionx3   allowed in legacy PPDU               "HT
                                The use of the term "shall" has      Strike the
7.1.3.2     T    R   Motionx3   been deemed inappropriate for        word
                                The presence of A-MSDU is            Use one
7.1.3.5     DT   R   Motionx3   identified by the use of bit-7 in    of the
                                                                     "BA"
7.1.3.5.3   T    R   Motionx3   "BA" not in Definitions section      needs to
                                Since an A-MPDU can                  Restrict all
7.1.3.5.3   DT   R   Motionx3   potentially have MPDUs with          MPDUs in
                                                                     Replace
7.1.3.5.6   T    R   Motionx3   HT AP                                with HT
                                                                     where is
7.1.3.5.6   ST   R   Motionx3   missing detail refernce              the details
                                Want to allow for the possibility
7.1.3.8     ST   R   Motionx3   of providing MCS feedback with
                                Can the link adaptation control      Clarify in
7.1.3.8     ST   R   Motionx3   have both a request and              the draft.
                                11k defined a structure for          Link
7.1.3.8     DT   R   Motionx3   measurement requests and             Adaption
                                Table n3 contains procedures to      Move the
7.1.3.8     T    R   Motionx3   be followed by STAs.                 procedure
                                Procedures don't belong in           Move the
7.1.3.8     T    R   Motionx3   clause 7                             procedure
                                Add two 2-bits fields allowing the
7.1.3.8     DT   R   Motionx3   requestor of the feed back to
                                The RDG/More PPDU bit is             Move the
7.1.3.8     DT   R   Motionx3   currently included in the HTC        RDG bit to
                                Add two 2-bits fields allowing the
7.1.3.8     ST   R   Motionx3   requestor of the feed back to
                                11k defined a structure for        Antenna
7.1.3.8     DT   R   Motionx3   measurement requests and           Selection
                                Table n5 does not show the         Add "are
7.1.3.8     T    R   Motionx3   structure of the subfield, but     coded as
                                Procedures don't belong in         Move the
7.1.3.8     T    R   Motionx3   clause 7                           procedure
                                11k defined a structure for        Calibratio
7.1.3.8     DT   R   Motionx3   measurement requests and           n Position
                                Procedures don't belong in         Move the
7.1.3.8     T    R   Motionx3   clause 7                           procedure
                                                                   00 – NA
7.1.3.8     DT   R   Motionx3   Change the Definition values       01 – CSI
                                Changing "minimum" to "either" Make the
7.1.4       T    R   Motionx3   means the transmitter algorithm sub-items
                                Do we need to change text for
7.1.4       T    R   Motionx3   HCCA TXOP?
                                Change in Figure 35 "0 or 6"       Add an
7.2.2       T    R   Motionx3   (was 6) and "0 or 2" (was 2)       explanatio
                                "The setting of the Order field
                                determines whether the HT
                                Control field is present, as
                                specified in 7.1.3.1.10. The HT Use other
                                Control field is defined in        bit in the
                                7.1.3.8."                          Frame
                                                                   Control
7.2.2       T    R   Motionx3   Do not use order bit to signal the field.
                                11n is defining both A-MSDU        Pick one
7.2.2.1     DT   R   Motionx3   and A-MPDU, as two different       and delete
                                The concept of aggregating         Remove
7.2.2.1     DT   R   Motionx3   small msdu's to fit into one       MSDU
                                Figure n10 (A-MSDU subframe Specify
7.2.2.1     ST   R   Motionx3   structure) does not specify byte the byte
                                This section indicates that the A- Add
7.2.2.1     ST   R   Motionx3   MSDU MPDU header must use details of
                                The need for seperate DA and Consider
7.2.2.1     DT   R   Motionx3   SA field is very limited           removing
                               Is there a tight upper bound on     Proof of
7.2.2.1   ST    R   Motionx3   the extent to which a constituent   the bound,
                               Setting "No Frame Body" in the      Please
7.2.2.2   T     R   Motionx3   MAC header means there is no        give a
                               If the length of the frame          Please
7.2.2.2   T     R   Motionx3   indicates that it isn't empty (in   clarify
                               Address 4 is used for a             Delete
7.2.2.2   T     R   Motionx3   destination (or source) over the    address 4
                                                                   Delete the
7.2.2.2   T     R   Motionx3   The note has no referant.           text "Note -
                               Add a figure to show a + HTC        Include a
7.2.2     T     R   Motionx3   management frame                    figure with
                               Is it really necessary to define
7.2.3.1   DT    R   Motionx3   separate elements for the
                                                                   what is
7.2.3.4   ST    R   Motionx3   complete the section                the details
                               Why is the HT Capabilities IE       Please
7.2.3.8   T     R   Motionx3   being added to Probe Requests.      clarify why
                               Extensions to the Neighbor          add fields
7.3.2     ST    R   Motionx3   report to indicate HT support is    to the
                               No reason to advertise the TX       Make
7.3.2.47.2 DT   R   Motionx3   capability for STBC, just           change
                               In table n16: Why is there          short GI,
7.3.2.47.2 T    R   Motionx3   separate indication of short GI     that
                               Table n16, Definition of MIMO       What is
7.3.2.47.2 ST   R   Motionx3   Power Save:                         necessary
                               The MIMO power save field in        Change
7.3.2.47.2 DT   R   Motionx3   the HT Capabilities Info field      the MIMO
                               A STA can choose to not             Use
7.3.2.47.2 DT   R   Motionx3   support MIMO Power Save.            reserved
                               N-Delayed Block Ack is a MAC        Move this
7.3.2.47.2 T    R   Motionx3   function, not PHY                   capability
                               DSSS/CCK - "BSS does/does           Change to
7.3.2.47.2 T    R   Motionx3   not allow…"                         "AP"
                               PSMP support - "BSS                 Change to
7.3.2.47.2 T    R   Motionx3   does/does not…"                     "device",
                               0 BSS does not support use of       Make AP
7.3.2.47.2 DT   R   Motionx3   PSMP. If station comes back         support of
                               DSS/CCK entry of table n16 is       clarify that
7.3.2.47.2 ST   R   Motionx3   not fully clear. The term HT        this
                               Maximum A-MSDU lengths of           The
7.3.2.47.2 ST   R   Motionx3   4K should not be mandated.          mandatory
                               Maximum A-MSDU length - I           Expand
                               like the mechanism of A-MSDU        the field to
                               as it not only increases            two bits -
7.3.2.47.2 DT   R   Motionx3   throughput on the channel but       allocate
                               Clarify why the encoding uses
                               unusual numbers such as 3893
                               and 7935; I am sure there is a
                               reason. I'd like to know why and    Clarify in
7.3.2.47.2 T    R   Motionx3   also other readers as well.         the draft.
                      Edited in draft




                                              Topic lookup


                                                                 Topic Group
         Resolution




                                                                                My order
                                                                 Lookup
Accepted                                HT                   Frame
with no                                 Elements             Format            438
Instruct                                Frame                Frame
the editor                              Formats              Format            70
Agree to                                Frame                Frame
add text                                Formats              Format            72
Instruct                                Frame                Frame
the editor                              Formats              Format            165
Instruct                                Frame                Frame
the editor                              Formats              Format            73
Instruct                                Frame                Frame
the editor                              Formats              Format            273
Editor                                  Frame                Frame
please                                  Formats              Format            274
Instruct                                Frame                Frame
the editor                              Formats              Format            75
as                                      Frame                Frame
suggested                               Formats              Format            343
As                                      Frame                Frame
suggested                               Formats              Format            74
Accept                                  Frame                Frame
the                                     Formats              Format            495
                                        Frame                Frame
Agree                                   Formats              Format            275
as                                      Frame                Frame
suggested                               Formats              Format            77
Add a                                   Frame                Frame
statement                               Formats              Format            78
Instruct                                Frame                Frame
the editor                              Formats              Format            26
Accept as                               Frame                Frame
suggested                               Formats              Format            483
as                                      Frame                Frame
suggested                               Formats              Format            453
Instruct                                Frame                Frame
the editor                              Formats              Format            81
Accept -                                Frame                Frame
as                                      Formats              Format            418
As                                      Frame                Frame
suggested                               Formats              Format            30
Instruct                                Frame                Frame
the editor                              Formats              Format            27
Instruct                                Frame                Frame
the editor                              Formats              Format            28
                                        Frame                Frame
Accept                                  Formats              Format            173
                                        Frame                Frame
Accept                                  Formats              Format            174
                                        Frame                Frame
Accept                                  Formats              Format            484
Instruct                                Frame                Frame
the editor                              Formats              Format            550
Accepted.                               Frame                Frame
Instruct                                Formats              Format            82
As                                      Frame                Frame
suggested                               Formats              Format            84
Move the     Frame       Frame
first        Formats     Format    183
The TID                  Frame
carried in   A-MSDU      Formats   555
Change       Frame       Frame
paragraph    Formats     Format    88
The editor               Frame
to add a     A-MSDU      Formats   95
Change                   Frame
text as      A-MSDU      Formats   89
Change                   Frame
text as      A-MSDU      Formats   188
Add the                  Frame
following    A-MSDU      Formats    5
 Add the
following    A-MSDU      MAC       381
 Add the
following:   A-MSDU                189
 Add a                   Frame
NOTE:        A-MSDU      Formats   54
Change                   Frame
text as      A-MSDU      Formats   92
Remove                   Frame
the          A-MSDU      Formats   287
Change                   Frame
text as      A-MSDU      Formats   93
Change                   Frame
text as      A-MSDU      Formats   94
Delete the   Managem     Frame
text         ent         Format    291
             Managem     Frame
See 3733     ent         Format    205
Change       Managem     Frame
"shall be"   ent         Format    106
             Managem     Frame
See 1157     ent         Format    108
             Managem     Frame
see 3733     ent         Format    206
             Managem     Frame
see 3733     ent         Format    208
             Managem     Frame
see 3733     ent         Format    294
             Managem     Frame
see 1157     ent         Format    112
             Managem     Frame
See 3733     ent         Format    296
 Add         Coexisten   Frame
"according   ce          Format    33
Delete                   Frame
text from    TSPEC       Format    421
Add to                   Frame
table 37     TSPEC       Format    300
delete the   HT          Frame
sentence     Elements    Format    124
             HT          Frame
             Elements    Format    34
Instruct     HT          Frame
the editor   Elements    Format    269
Instruct     HT          Frame
the editor   Elements    Format    123
Use N-       HT          Frame
Delayed      Elements    Format    35
Replace      HT          Frame
MIMO         Elements    Format    270
Instruct     HT          Frame
the editor   Elements    Format    224
Agree to      HT         Frame
reword the    Elements   Format    226
Accepted      Frame      Frame
to cross      Formats    Format    164
Replace       Frame      Frame
AP by         Formats    Format    169
Instruct      Frame      Frame
the editor    Formats    Format    79
Accept        Frame      Frame
the           Formats    Format    407
Instruct      Frame      Frame
the editor    Formats    Format    344
Instruct      Frame      Frame
the editor    Formats    Format    12
Make the      Frame      Frame
change in     Formats    Format    171
Instruct      Frame      Frame
the editor    Formats    Format    502
Instruc the   Frame      Frame
editor to     Formats    Format    83
Sanjiv will   Frame      Frame
submit the    Formats    Format    429
Instruct      Frame      Frame
the editor    Formats    Format    379
See CID       Frame      Frame
4552          Formats    Format    176
Move the      Frame      Frame
first         Formats    Format    180
See CID       Frame      Frame
1126          Formats    Format    181
Remove        Frame      Frame
whole         Formats    Format    416
add a note    Frame      Frame
to fig. 35    Formats    Format    284
add a note    Frame      Frame
to Fig 35     Formats    Format     4
Accept                   Frame
the           A-MSDU     Formats   285
See                      Frame
resolution    A-MSDU     Formats   365
See                      Frame
resolution    A-MSDU     Formats   504
 Change                  Frame
lines 24 to   A-MSDU     Formats   187
Accept                   Frame
the first     A-MSDU     Formats   90
If the        Managem    Frame
length is     ent        Format    195
Change        Managem    Frame
"shall not    ent        Format    97
See the       Managem    Frame
baseline      ent        Format    348
Change        Managem    Frame
the           ent        Format    18
Instruct      Managem    Frame
the           ent        Format    99
Delete Fig    Managem    Frame
n12 and       ent        Format    197
Replace       Managem    Frame
with          ent        Format    349
Replace       Managem    Frame
with          ent        Format    350
Instruct      Managem    Frame
the editor    ent        Format    158
Replace       Managem    Frame
with          ent        Format    351
Replace       Managem    Frame
with          ent        Format   352
Replace       Managem    Frame
with          ent        Format   353
Replace       Managem    Frame
with          ent        Format   354
Replace       Managem    Frame
with          ent        Format   355
Replace       Managem    Frame
with          ent        Format   356
Replace       Managem    Frame
with          ent        Format   357
Replace       Managem    Frame
with          ent        Format   358
Replace       Managem    Frame
with          ent        Format   359
Need to
reuse
existing
codes
since         Managem
legacy        ent        Frame
equipment     Frames     Format    6
              Managem    Frame
see 26        ent        Format   298
See           HT         Frame
resolution    Elements   Format   455
see           HT         Frame
resolution    Elements   Format   13
see           HT         Frame
resolution    Elements   Format   213
see           HT         Frame
resolution    Elements   Format   268
There are     HT         Frame
2             Elements   Format   301
Agree         HT         Frame
only to       Elements   Format   371
Remove        HT         Frame
(26) in the   Elements   Format   125
See           HT         Frame
resolution    Elements   Format   440
In table      HT         Frame
B12,          Elements   Format   60
Change is     HT         Frame
accepted      Elements   Format   218
Replace       HT         Frame
"advance      Elements   Format   372
Add "Set      HT         Frame
to 0 for      Elements   Format   395
Add a         HT         Frame
statement     Elements   Format   433
Add a         HT         Frame
note to       Elements   Format   307
Chane the     HT         Frame
field name    Elements   Format   308
See           HT         Frame
resolution    Elements   Format   547
Implicit      Frame      Frame
BA can        Formats    Format   163
Fig 19        Frame      Frame
shows all     Formats    Format   151
The           Frame      Frame
current       Formats    Format   154
The           Frame      Frame
comment       Formats    Format   512
It's good      Frame     Frame
informatio     Formats   Format    76
The group      Frame     Frame
voted 11       Formats   Format    277
BA has         Frame     Frame
already        Formats   Format    80
MPDUs          Frame     Frame
within         Formats   Format    436
Reject -       Frame     Frame
HT AP is       Formats   Format    345
Reject -                 Frame
see            Duplicate Format    55
Reject -       Frame     Frame
already        Formats Format      87
See            Frame     Frame
9.19.2         Formats Format      280
11k does       Frame     Frame
not define     Formats Format      170
The table      Frame     Frame
only           Formats Format      172
Rejected -     Frame     Frame
rthe           Formats Format      175
R - There      Frame     Frame
is no need     Formats Format      338
Rejected -     Frame     Frame
The order      Formats Format      492
Rejected -     Frame     Frame
see CID        Formats Format      546
Rejected -     Frame     Frame
11k            Formats Format      177
Rejected -     Frame     Frame
table n5       Formats Format      29
The            Frame     Frame
statement      Formats Format      178
See            Frame     Frame
reason for     Formats Format      179
See 1126 -     Frame     Frame
the            Formats Format      182
lack of        Frame     Frame
justificatio   Formats Format      549
Rejected -     Frame     Frame
this is an     Formats Format      184
Inadequat      Frame     Frame
e              Formats Format      155
Rejected -     Frame     Frame
The            Formats Format      185



Rejected -
inadequat
e
justificatio   Frame     Frame
n              Formats   Format    156
 see 4260      A-MSDU    General   186
 The                     Frame
simulation     A-MSDU    Formats   364
                         Frame
Subclause      A-MSDU    Formats   382
R - Detail               Frame
of what to     A-MSDU    Formats   486
 It is quite             Frame
common         A-MSDU    Formats   267
 This is                   Frame
dependent       A-MSDU     Formats   53
The             Managem    Frame
commen          ent        Format    193
The             Managem    Frame
length          ent        Format    194
There is        Managem    Frame
no reason       ent        Format    289
No              Managem    Frame
referant is     ent        Format    98
R - There       Frame      Frame
is no need      Formats    Format    461
The             Managem    Frame
distributio     ent        Format    487
Detail is in    Managem    Frame
7.3.2.47.       ent        Format    58
The HT          Managem    Frame
capabilitie     ent        Format    210
The             Managem    Frame
capabilitie     ent        Format    212
The             HT         Frame
reason for      Elements   Format    221
To allow        HT         Frame
devices to      Elements   Format    403
                HT         Frame
                Elements   Format    159
Devices         HT         Frame
equipped        Elements   Format    388
MIMO            HT         Frame
power           Elements   Format    442
N-delayed       HT         Frame
Block Ack       Elements   Format    222
BSS             HT         Frame
includes        Elements   Format    223
BSS is          HT         Frame
correct         Elements   Format    227
 PSMP is        HT         Frame
optional.       Elements   Format    408
If the bit is   HT         Frame
set to 0,       Elements   Format    414
Simulation      HT         Frame
results         Elements   Format    19
See
resolution
to CID          HT       Frame
492             Elements Format      304
The
numbers
are based
on (8191 -      HT       Frame
2^x) and        Elements Format      305
Description of Fields used on the Comments Tab

Field                     Description
                          Comment identifier. This is a unique integer that identifies a
                          comment whereever the need to cross-reference occurs.
                          There is no significance to the actual values or ordering of
CID                       values in this field.
Name of Commenter (Ed)    The name of the commenter
Clause Number (C)         The clause number indicated by the commenter
Page # (C)                The page number indicated by the commenter
Line # (C)                The line number indicated by the commenter
Type of Comment T/E (C)   The type of comment indicated by the commenter

Part of No Vote (Y/N)     Whether the comment forms part of the commenter's "no" vote
                          The page number, fixed up if necessary. Reasons to fix the
                          page number include providing the wrong value, providing no
                          value, or providing a value that was not a single integer. Where
                          the value of this field differs with the value provided by the
                          commenter, the field is shaded yellow as a flag. This is a
                          warning to the reader that the commenter may have provided
Page # (Ed)               additional information (e.g. a range of pages).
                          The line number, fixed up if necessary. Reasons to fix the line
                          number include providing the wrong value or providing a value
                          that was not a single integer. Where the value of this field
                          differs with the value provided by the commenter, the field is
                          shaded yellow as a flag. This is a warning to the reader that the
                          commenter may have provided additional information (e.g. a
Line # (Ed)               range of lines or table number).
                          This is the title of the clause, determined by table lookup in the
Clause Title (Ed)         "Headings" tab using the Clause (Ed) field.
                          The clause number, fixed up if necessary so that it is one of the
                          following forms: ("General", Annex A, 1.2.3.4). Where the value
                          of this field differs with the value provided by the commenter,
                          the field is shaded yellow as a flag. This is a warning to the
                          reader that the commenter may have provided additional
Clause (Ed)               information.
                      Comment classification for the purpose of managing the
                      comment resolution process. The initial value was a copy of the
                      commenter's value, with any values excepting T and E
                      replaced.
                      A (very) partial reclassification of editorials (to T, HE) has been
                      started.

                      Where the value of this field differs with the value provided by
                      the commenter, the field is shaded yellow as a flag. This is a
                      warning to the reader that the commenter may have provided
                      additional information.

                      The permitted values in this field are:
                      E - editorial (comment requires no technical change)
                      HE - Hard editorial (comment requires no technical change but
                      doesn't fully provide the solution and a submission is necessary
                      to resolve the comment)
                      T - Technical
                      HT - Hard Technical (comment requires a submission to
                      resolve)
Type E/HE/T/HT (Ed)   Other values in this field are TBD

                      A non-blank value indicates that the comment is an exact match
                      in the clause, comment and recommended change fields with
                      the referenced comment. Note, because of the way the
                      spreadsheet was sorted, where two commenters made a
                      matching comment, the commenter whose name is
Duplicate of CID      alphabetically later will be tagged with a duplicate reference.
                      Resolution status:
                      A - accepted
                      R - rejected
                      C - counter (provided in proposed change field)
                      D - Deferred
                      X - No consensus reached in the ad-hoc
Resn. Status          T - Pending Transfer to another ad-hoc

                      If non-blank, the person identified by this column has agreed to
Assignee              bring a submission to TGn in resolution of the comment.
                      If non-blank, identifies a document submission brought in
Submission            resolution of the comment.
                      Details TBD. Perhaps a motion reference and an outcome
                      affecting the approval of the motion. e.g. M12 implies approved
                      by motion 12, R implies rejected in TGn. However, to do this
                      requires a means of referencing TGn motions, which we don't
TGn approval ?        currently have.
                      The comment made by the commenter. Minor fixups were
Comment               made to remove embedded objects.
                      The comment made by the commenter. Minor fixups were
Proposed Change       made to remove embedded objects.
                      The resolution proposed by the comment resolution committee.
Resolution            May contain other notes.
                     The version number of the draft embodying changes. Working
                     versions of the draft (not published) are named yyyymmddrn
                     Dn.nn, example 20060503r0 D1.01 is the working version
                     revision 0 on 3 May 2006, which will become D1.01 when
                     published. This syntax may need to be extended to provide
                     coordination between any editing team and comment resolution
Edited in draft:     committee.
                     The result of the lookup of the clause (Ed) field in the Headings
                     table, topic column. This is used as an intermediate to get the
Topic lookup         Topic Group values.
                     The result of the lookup of the Topic Lookup in the Topic
                     Groupings column.
                     This is used to partition the comments into topic groups, with
                     the assumption as this is written that there is a mapping from
Topic Group Lookup   topic groups onto comment resolution ad-hocs.
Update Rules



Read only
Read only
Read only
Read only
Read only
Read only

Read only




Read write. Only update if it is
discovered to be in error.




Read write. Only update if it is
discovered to be in error.

Read only - calculated field




Read write. Only update if it is
discovered to be in error.
Read write.
Read write. The comment
identified by this field should
match in comment and
recommended change.
The comment identified in this
field should not itself be a
duplicate.




Read write


Read write

Read write




Read write

Read only

Read only

Read write
Read Write by editor, otherwise
read-only


Read only




Read write - only to transfer
HID         Clause        Title                                          Page
            0             General                                                 0
        1   1             Overview                                                2
      318   10            Layer management                                      131
      319   10.1          Overview of management model                          131
      320   10.2          Generic management primitives                         131
      321   10.3          MLME SAP interface                                    131
      343   10.3.10       Start                                                 136
      344   10.3.10.1     MLME-START.request                                    136
      345   10.3.10.1.2   Semantics of the service primitive                    136
      346   10.3.15       Channel switch                                        137
      347   10.3.15.1     MLME-CHANNELSWITCH.request                            137
      348   10.3.15.1.2   Semantics of the service primitive                    137
      349   10.3.15.1.3   When generated                                        138
      350   10.3.15.3     MLME-CHANNELSWITCH.indication                         138
      351   10.3.15.3.1   Function                                              138
      352   10.3.15.4     MLME-CHANNELSWITCH.response                           139
      353   10.3.15.4.2   Semantics of the service primitive                    139
      322   10.3.2        Scan                                                  132
      323   10.3.2.2      MLME-SCAN.confirm                                     132
      324   10.3.2.2.2    Semantics of the service primitive                    132
      325   10.3.6        Associate                                             132
      326   10.3.6.1      MLME-ASSOCIATE.request                                132
      327   10.3.6.1.2    Semantics of the service primitive                    132
      328   10.3.6.2      MLME-ASSOCIATE.confirm                                133
      329   10.3.6.2.2    Semantics of the service primitive                    133
      330   10.3.6.3      MLME-ASSOCIATE.indication                             133
      331   10.3.6.3.2    Semantics of the service primitive                    133
      332   10.3.6.4      MLME-ASSOCIATE.response                               134
      333   10.3.6.4.2    Semantics of the service primitive                    134
      334   10.3.7        Reassociate                                           134
      335   10.3.7.1      MLME-REASSOCIATE.request                              134
      336   10.3.7.1.2    Semantics of the service primitive                    134
      337   10.3.7.2      MLME-REASSOCIATE.confirm                              135
      338   10.3.7.2.2    Semantics of the service primitive                    135
      339   10.3.7.3      MLME-REASSOCIATE.indication                           135
      340   10.3.7.3.2    Semantics of the service primitive                    135
      341   10.3.7.4      MLME-REASSOCIATE.response                             136
      342   10.3.7.4.2    Semantics of the service primitive                    136
      354   10.4          PLME SAP interface                                    140
      355   10.4.3        PLME-CHARACTERISTICS.confirm                          140
      356   10.4.3.2      Semantics of the service primitive                    140
      357   11            MLME                                                  142
      358   11.1          Synchronization                                       142
      403   11.1          Radio Measurement Procedures                          150
      359   11.1.1        Basic Approach                                        142
      360   11.1.2        Maintaining Synchronization                           142
      361   11.1.2.1      Beacon generation in infrastructure networks          142
      362   11.1.2.1.1    Secondary Beacon Transmission                         142
      363   11.1.3        Acquiring synchronization, scanning                   142
      364   11.1.3.1      Passive scanning                                      142
      365   11.1.3.2      Active scanning                                       143
366   11.1.3.2.1   Sending a probe response                                   143
367   11.1.3.2.2   Active Scanning Procedure                                  143
404   11.11        Usage of the Neighbor Report                               150
405   11.12        Link Measurement                                           150
406   11.13        Measurement pilot frame generation and usage               151
407   11.14        A-MPDU operation                                           151
408   11.14.1      PSDU Length Limit Rules                                    151
409   11.14.2      MPDU density                                               151
410   11.15        40/20 MHz Operation                                        151
411   11.15.1      Basic functionality in BSS 40/20Mhz mode                   151
412   11.15.2      Operating Modes (Informative)                              152
413   11.15.3      STA Capabilities (Informative)                             155
414   11.16        Phased Coexistence Operation                               156
415   11.16.1      Rules for Operation at PCO AP                              157
416   11.16.2      Rules for Operation at the PCO non-AP STA                  158
368   11.2         Power management                                           143
369   11.2.1       Power management in an infrastructure network              143
370   11.2.1.1     Receive operation for non-AP QSTAs using APSD              143
371   11.2.1.3     TIM types                                                  143
372   11.2.1.5     AP operation during the CP                                 143
373   11.2.1.6     AP operation during the CFP                                144
374   11.2.1.7     STA operation during the CP                                144
375   11.2.1.8     STA operation during the CFP                               145
376   11.2.2       Power management in an IBSS                                145
377   11.2.3       MIMO Power Save Features                                   145
378   11.2.3.1     MIMO Power Save support                                    145
379   11.2.3.2     Reduced MIMO capability                                    145
380   11.3         Authentication and deauthentication                        146
381   11.4         TS operation                                               146
382   11.4.1       Introduction                                               146
383   11.4.2       TSPEC construction                                         146
384   11.4.3       TS lifecycle                                               146
385   11.4.4       TS Setup                                                   146
386   11.4.4A      Management of Scheduled PSMP                               146
387   11.4.4A.1    Introduction (Informative)                                 146
388   11.4.4A.2    Join PSMP                                                  147
389   11.4.4B      Management of Unscheduled PSMP                             148
390   11.5         Block Ack operation                                        149
391   11.5.2       Multi-TID Block Ack                                        149
392   11.5.2.1     Multiple TID Block Ack management under scheduled PSMP     149
393   11.5.2.2     Multiple TID Block Ack management under unscheduled PSMP   149
394   11.6         Higher layer timer synchronization                         149
395   11.7         DLS operation                                              149
396   11.8         TPC                                                        149
397   11.9         DFS                                                        149
398   11.9.4       Selecting and advertising a new channel                    149
399   11.9.5       Channel Selection Methods for 20/40 MHz Operation          149
400   11.9.5.1     Introduction                                               149
401   11.9.5.2     Rules                                                      150
402   11.9.5.3     Channel Management at the AP                               150
417   12           PHY service specification                                  158
418   12.3.4.4     Vector descriptions                                        158
419 13          PHY management                                        158
    17          OFDM PHY Spec for 5GHz
  2 19          ERP Specification                                       0
420 2           Normative references                                    2
421 20          High Throughput PHY specification                     159
422 20.1        Introduction                                          159
423 20.1.1      Scope                                                 159
424 20.1.2      High Throughput PHY functions                         160
425 20.1.2.1    High Throughput PLCP sublayer                         160
426 20.1.2.2    High Throughput PMD sublayer                          160
427 20.1.2.3    PHY management entity (PLME)                          160
428 20.1.2.4    Service specification method                          160
429 20.1.3      Operating Mode                                        160
430 20.2        High Throughput PHY specific service parameter list   161
431 20.2.1      Introduction                                          161
432 20.2.2      TXVECTOR parameters                                   161
441 20.2.2.1    TXVECTOR L_LENGTH                                     162
442 20.2.2.10   TXVECTOR SMOOTHING                                    164
443 20.2.2.11   TXVECTOR NOT_SOUNDING                                 164
444 20.2.2.12   TXVECTOR AGGREGATION                                  164
445 20.2.2.13   TXVECTOR STBC                                         164
446 20.2.2.14   TXVECTOR ADVANCED_CODING                              164
447 20.2.2.15   TXVECTOR SHORT_GI                                     164
448 20.2.2.16   TXVECTOR NUM_EXTEN_SS                                 164
449 20.2.2.17   TXVECTOR ANTENNA_SET                                  164
433 20.2.2.18   TXVECTOR EXPANSION_MAT                                165
434 20.2.2.2    TXVECTOR L_DATARATE                                   163
435 20.2.2.3    TXVECTOR SERVICE                                      163
436 20.2.2.4    TXVECTOR TXPWR_LEVEL                                  163
437 20.2.2.5    TXVECTOR FORMAT                                       163
438 20.2.2.6    TXVECTOR MCS                                          163
439 20.2.2.7    TXVECTOR BW                                           163
440 20.2.2.8    TXVECTOR CH_OFFSET                                    163
450 20.2.2.9    TXVECTOR LENGTH                                       164
451 20.2.3      RXVECTOR parameters                                   165
460 20.2.3.1    RXVECTOR L_LENGTH                                     166
461 20.2.3.10   RXVECTOR SMOOTHING                                    167
462 20.2.3.11   RXVECTOR NOT_SOUNDING                                 167
463 20.2.3.12   RXVECTOR AGGREGATION                                  167
464 20.2.3.13   RXVECTOR STBC                                         167
465 20.2.3.14   RXVECTOR SHORT_GI                                     167
466 20.2.3.15   RXVECTOR NUM_EXTEN_SS                                 167
452 20.2.3.16   RXVECTOR CHAN_MAT                                     168
453 20.2.3.2    RXVECTOR RSSI                                         166
454 20.2.3.3    RXVECTOR L-DATARATE                                   166
455 20.2.3.4    RXVECTOR SERVICE                                      166
456 20.2.3.5    RXVECTOR FORMAT                                       166
457 20.2.3.6    RXVECTOR MCS                                          166
458 20.2.3.7    RXVECTOR BW                                           166
459 20.2.3.8    RXVECTOR CH_OFFSET                                    167
467 20.2.3.9    RXVECTOR LENGTH                                       167
468 20.3        High Throughput PLCP sublayer                         168
538   20.3.1           Introduction                                                          168
539   20.3.10          Transmitter RF delay                                                  223
540   20.3.11          Slot time                                                             223
541   20.3.12          Transmit and receive port impedance                                   223
542   20.3.13          Transmit and receive operating temperature range                      223
543   20.3.14          PMD Tx specification                                                  224
544   20.3.14.1        Transmit Spectrum Mask                                                224
545   20.3.14.2        Spectral Flatness                                                     225
546   20.3.14.3        Transmit Power                                                        225
547   20.3.14.4        Transmit center frequency tolerance                                   225
548   20.3.14.5        Packet alignment                                                      225
549   20.3.14.6        Reduced Interframe Space (RIFS)                                       226
550   20.3.14.7        Symbol clock frequency tolerance                                      226
551   20.3.14.8        Modulation accuracy                                                   226
552   20.3.14.8.1      Transmit center frequency leakage                                     226
553   20.3.14.8.2      Transmitter constellation error                                       226
554   20.3.14.8.3      Transmitter modulation accuracy (EVM) test                            227
555   20.3.15          High Throughput PMD receiver specification                            228
556   20.3.15.1        Receiver minimum input sensitivity                                    228
557   20.3.15.2        Adjacent channel rejection                                            228
558   20.3.15.3        Non-adjacent channel rejection                                        229
559   20.3.15.4        Receiver maximum input level                                          229
560   20.3.15.5        Clear channel assessment (CCA) sensitivity                            229
561   20.3.15.6        Received Channel Power Indicator (RCPI) Measurement                   229
562   20.3.16          PLCP transmit procedure                                               230
469   20.3.17          PLCP receive procedure                                                233
470   20.3.2           PLCP frame format                                                     168
471   20.3.2.1         Transmitter Block Diagram (informative)                               170
472   20.3.2.2         Overview of the PPDU encoding process                                 171
473   20.3.2.3         Modulation and Coding Scheme (MCS)                                    174
474   20.3.2.4         Timing related parameters                                             174
475   20.3.2.5         Mathematical description of signals                                   176
476   20.3.2.6         Transmission in the upper/lower 20MHz of a 40MHz channel              179
477   20.3.3           High Throughput Preamble                                              179
478   20.3.3.1         Introduction                                                          179
479   20.3.3.2         Mixed Mode preamble and header fields                                 179
480   20.3.3.2.1       Non-HT portion of mixed mode preamble                                 180
481   20.3.3.2.1.1     Cyclic shift definition for the non-HT fields.                        180
482   20.3.3.2.1.2     Non-HT Short Training Field                                           181
483   20.3.3.2.1.3     Non-HT Long Training Field                                            182
484   20.3.3.2.1.4     The Non-HT Signal Field                                               183
485   20.3.3.2.2       The High Throughput portion of mixed mode preamble                    184
486   20.3.3.2.2.1     Cyclic shift for the High Throughput portion of Mixed Mode preamble   184
487   20.3.3.2.2.2     The High Throughput Signal Field                                      185
488   20.3.3.2.2.2.1   CRC calculation                                                       189
489   20.3.3.2.2.3     The HT STF training symbol                                            190
490   20.3.3.2.2.4     The HT-LTF long training Field                                        191
491   20.3.3.3         Greenfield preamble and header fields                                 195
492   20.3.3.3.1       Cyclic shift for the Green Field preamble and header fields           195
493   20.3.3.3.2       Short training field                                                  195
494   20.3.3.3.3       Signal field                                                          195
495   20.3.3.3.3.1     Signal Field for 20 MHz operation                                     196
496   20.3.3.3.3.2   Signal Field for 40 MHz operation                                   196
497   20.3.3.3.4     Long training field                                                 197
498   20.3.4         The Data Field                                                      197
499   20.3.4.1       The service field                                                   197
500   20.3.4.2       Scrambler                                                           197
501   20.3.4.3       Coding                                                              198
502   20.3.4.3.1     Encoder Parsing operation                                           198
503   20.3.4.3.2     Coding and puncturing                                               198
504   20.3.4.3.3     Low density parity check codes (optional ECC)                       199
505   20.3.4.3.3.1   LDPCC Code Rates and Codeword Block Lengths                         199
506   20.3.4.3.3.2   LDPCC Encoder                                                       200
507   20.3.4.3.3.3   Parity check matrices                                               200
508   20.3.4.3.3.4   LDPCC PPDU encoding process                                         201
509   20.3.4.3.3.5   LDPC Parser                                                         203
510   20.3.4.4       Data Interleaver                                                    203
511   20.3.4.4.1     Overview                                                            203
512   20.3.4.4.2     Stream Parser                                                       204
513   20.3.4.4.3     Frequency interleaver                                               204
514   20.3.4.5       QAM Mapping                                                         206
515   20.3.4.5.1     Space-Time-Block-Coding (STBC)                                      206
516   20.3.4.6       Pilot Subcarriers                                                   207
517   20.3.4.7       OFDM Modulation                                                     209
518   20.3.4.7.1     Spatial Mapping                                                     209
519   20.3.4.7.2     20MHz HT transmission                                               212
520   20.3.4.7.3     Transmission in 40MHz HT mode                                       213
521   20.3.4.7.4     Transmission in HT duplicate mode.                                  214
522   20.3.4.7.5     Transmission with a short guard interval                            214
523   20.3.4.8       Non-HT duplicate transmission                                       214
524   20.3.5         Beamforming                                                         215
525   20.3.5.1       Implicit Beamforming                                                216
526   20.3.5.2       Explicit Beamforming                                                216
527   20.3.5.2.1     CSI Matrices Feedback                                               216
528   20.3.5.2.2     Non Compressed Steering Matrix Feedback                             217
529   20.3.5.2.3     Compressed Steering Matrix Feedback                                 217
530   20.3.6         High Throughput Preamble Format for Sounding PPDUs                  220
531   20.3.6.1       Sounding with a zero length packet                                  220
532   20.3.6.2       Sounding PPDU for calibration                                       221
533   20.3.6.3       Sounding PPDU for channel quality assessment                        221
534   20.3.7         Regulatory Requirements                                             221
535   20.3.8         Channel Numbering and Channelization                                221
536   20.3.8.1       Channel Allocation in the 5 GHz Band                                222
537   20.3.8.2       Channel Allocation in the 2.4 GHz Band                              222
563   20.3.9         Transmit and receive in-band and out-of-band spurious transmissions 223
564   20.4           High Throughput PLME                                                237
565   20.4.1         PLME_SAP sublayer management primitives                             237
566   20.4.2         PHY management information base                                     238
567   20.4.3         TXTIME calculation                                                  240
568   20.4.4         PHY characteristics                                                 241
569   20.5           High Throughput PMD sublayer                                        242
570   20.5.1         Scope and field of application                                      242
571   20.5.2         Overview of service                                                 243
572   20.5.3         Overview of interactions                                            243
573   20.5.4        Basic service and options                         243
574   20.5.4.1      PMD_SAP peer-to-peer service primitives           244
575   20.5.4.2      PMD_SAP sublayer-to-sublayer service primitives   244
576   20.5.4.3      PMD_SAP service primitive parameters              244
577   20.5.5        PMD_SAP detailed service specification            246
578   20.5.5.1      PMD_DATA.request                                  246
579   20.5.5.1.1    Function                                          246
580   20.5.5.1.2    Semantic of the service primitive                 246
581   20.5.5.1.3    When generated                                    246
622   20.5.5.1.4    Effect of receipt                                 246
623   20.5.5.10     PMD_EXPANSIONS_MAT.request                        250
624   20.5.5.10.1   Function                                          251
625   20.5.5.10.2   Semantic of the service primitive                 251
626   20.5.5.10.3   When generated                                    251
627   20.5.5.10.4   Effect of receipt                                 251
628   20.5.5.11     PMD_BW_OFFSET.indicate                            251
629   20.5.5.11.1   Function                                          251
630   20.5.5.11.2   Semantic of the service primitive                 251
631   20.5.5.11.3   When generated                                    251
632   20.5.5.11.4   Effect of receipt                                 251
633   20.5.5.12     PMD_CHAN_MAT.indicate                             252
634   20.5.5.12.1   Function                                          252
635   20.5.5.12.2   Semantic of the service primitive                 252
636   20.5.5.12.3   When generated                                    252
637   20.5.5.12.4   Effect of receipt                                 252
638   20.5.5.13     PMD_FORMAT.indicate                               252
639   20.5.5.13.1   Function                                          252
640   20.5.5.13.2   Semantic of the service primitive                 252
641   20.5.5.13.3   When generated                                    252
582   20.5.5.13.4   Effect of receipt                                 252
583   20.5.5.2      PMD_DATA.indicate                                 247
584   20.5.5.2.1    Function                                          247
585   20.5.5.2.2    Semantic of the service primitive                 247
586   20.5.5.2.3    When generated                                    247
587   20.5.5.2.4    Effect of receipt                                 247
588   20.5.5.3      PMD_TXSTART.request                               247
589   20.5.5.3.1    Function                                          247
590   20.5.5.3.2    Semantic of the service primitive                 247
591   20.5.5.3.3    When generated                                    247
592   20.5.5.3.4    Effect of receipt                                 247
593   20.5.5.4      PMD_TXEND.request                                 247
594   20.5.5.4.1    Function                                          248
595   20.5.5.4.2    Semantic of the service primitive                 248
596   20.5.5.4.3    When generated                                    248
597   20.5.5.4.4    Effect of receipt                                 248
598   20.5.5.5      PMD_TXPWRLVL.request                              248
599   20.5.5.5.1    Function                                          248
600   20.5.5.5.2    Semantic of the service primitive                 248
601   20.5.5.5.3    When generated                                    248
602   20.5.5.5.4    Effect of receipt                                 248
603   20.5.5.6      PMD_RATE.request                                  248
604   20.5.5.6.1    Function                                          248
605   20.5.5.6.2   Semantic of the service primitive                               249
606   20.5.5.6.3   When generated                                                  249
607   20.5.5.6.4   Effect of receipt                                               249
608   20.5.5.7     PMD_RSSI.indicate                                               249
609   20.5.5.7.1   Function                                                        249
610   20.5.5.7.2   Semantic of the service primitive                               249
611   20.5.5.7.3   When generated                                                  249
612   20.5.5.7.4   Effect of receipt                                               249
613   20.5.5.8     PMD_RCPI.indicate                                               249
614   20.5.5.8.1   Function                                                        250
615   20.5.5.8.2   Semantics of the service primitive                              250
616   20.5.5.8.3   When generated                                                  250
617   20.5.5.8.4   Effect of receipt                                               250
618   20.5.5.9     PMD_TX_PARAMETERS.request                                       250
619   20.5.5.9.1   Function                                                        250
620   20.5.5.9.2   Semantic of the service primitive                               250
621   20.5.5.9.3   When generated                                                  250
642   20.5.5.9.4   Effect of receipt                                               250
643   20.6         Optional Features                                               253
  3   20.7                                                                         253
                   Rate Dependent Parameters for High Throughput Modulation and Coding Schemes (MCS)
  4   3            Definitions                                                       2
  5   4            Abbreviations and acronyms                                        3
  6   5            General description                                               6
  7   5.2.7        HT STA                                                            6
  8   5.2.7.1      PHY Enhancements Requiring MAC Signaling                          7
  9   5.2.7.2      General description of HT Features                                7
 10   5.2.8        HT STA                                                            8
 11   5.3          Logical Service Interfaces                                        8
 12   5.3.1        SS                                                                9
 13   5.3.2        DSS                                                               9
 14   5.4          Overview of the services                                         10
 15   5.4.9        Radio link management                                            10
 16   5.4.9.1      Link adaptation                                                  10
 17   5.4.9.2      Transmit beamforming                                             10
 18   5.4.9.3      Antenna selection                                                10
 19   5.6          Relationship between services                                    10
 20   6            MAC service definition                                           11
 21   6.1          Overview of MAC services                                         11
 22   6.1.1        Data service                                                     11
 23   6.1.2        Security services                                                11
 24   6.1.3        MSDU ordering                                                    11
 25   6.1.4        MSDU format                                                      11
 26   6.1.5        MAC data service architecture                                    11
 27   6.2          Detailed service specification                                   13
 28   6.2.1        MAC data services                                                13
 29   7            Frame formats                                                    13
 30   7.1          MAC frame formats                                                14
 31   7.1.1        Conventions                                                      14
 32   7.1.2        General frame format                                             14
 33   7.1.3        Frame fields                                                     15
 35   7.1.3.1      Frame Control field                                              15
 34   7.1.3.1.10   Order field                                                      15
36   7.1.3.1.2   Type and Subtype Fields                                      0
37   7.1.3.1.5   More Fragments field                                        15
38   7.1.3.2     Duration/ID field                                           15
39   7.1.3.3     Address Fields                                              15
40   7.1.3.4     Sequence Control Field                                      15
41   7.1.3.5     QoS Control Field                                           15
42   7.1.3.5.3   Ack Policy subfield                                         16
43   7.1.3.5.6   TXOP Duration Requested subfield                            17
44   7.1.3.6     Frame Body field                                            17
45   7.1.3.7     FCS field                                                   17
46   7.1.3.8     HT Control Field                                            17
47   7.1.4       Duration/ID field in data and management frames             21
48   7.2         Format of individual frame types                            22
49   7.2.1       Control frames                                              22
50   7.2.1.1     RTS frame format                                            22
51   7.2.1.2     CTS frame format                                            22
52   7.2.1.3     ACK frame format                                            22
53   7.2.1.4     PS-Poll frame format                                        22
54   7.2.1.5     CF-End frame format                                         22
55   7.2.1.6     CF-End+CF-Ack frame format                                  22
56   7.2.1.7     Block Ack Request (BlockAckReq) frame format                22
57   7.2.1.7.1   Simple Block Ack Request (Simple BlockAckReq)               23
58   7.2.1.7.2   Block Ack Request (BlockAckReq) frame format (compressed)   24
59   7.2.1.7.3   Multiple TID Block Acknowledgement Request                  24
60   7.2.1.8     Block Ack (BlockAck) frame format                           25
61   7.2.1.8.1   Simple Block Ack (Simple BlockAck)                          27
62   7.2.1.8.2   Block Ack (BlockAck) frame format (compressed)              27
63   7.2.1.8.3   Multiple TID Block Acknowledgement                          28
64   7.2.2       Data frames                                                 29
65   7.2.2.1     Aggregated MSDU Format (A-MSDU)                             30
66   7.2.2.2     QoS Null Embedding of Management Action                     31
75   7.2.3       Management frames                                           32
76   7.2.3.1     Beacon frame format                                         32
77   7.2.3.10    Authentication frame format                                 35
67   7.2.3.11    Deauthentication                                            35
68   7.2.3.12    Action frame format                                         35
69   7.2.3.2     IBSS ATIM frame format                                      32
70   7.2.3.3     Disassociation frame format                                 32
71   7.2.3.4     Association Request frame format                            32
72   7.2.3.5     Association Response frame format                           33
73   7.2.3.6     Reassociation Request frame format                          33
74   7.2.3.7     Reassociation Response frame format                         34
78   7.2.3.8     Probe Request frame format                                  34
79   7.2.3.9     Probe Response frame format                                 34
80   7.3         Management frame body components                            35
89   7.3.1       Fields that are not information elements                    35
90   7.3.1.1     Authentication Algorithm Number field                       35
91   7.3.1.10    Timestamp field                                             36
92   7.3.1.11    Action field                                                36
93   7.3.1.12    Dialog Token field                                          36
94   7.3.1.13    DLS Timeout Value field                                     36
95   7.3.1.14    Block Ack Parameter Set field                               36
 96   7.3.1.15     Block Ack Timeout Value field                      37
 81   7.3.1.16     DELBA Parameter Set field                          37
 82   7.3.1.17     QoS Info field                                     37
 83   7.3.1.2      Authentication Transaction Sequence Number field   35
 84   7.3.1.3      Beacon Interval field                              35
 85   7.3.1.4      Capability Information field                       35
 86   7.3.1.5      Current AP Address field                           35
 87   7.3.1.6      Listen Interval field                              35
 88   7.3.1.7      Reason Code field                                  35
 97   7.3.1.8      AID field                                          36
 98   7.3.1.9      Status Code field                                  36
107   7.3.2        Information elements                               37
108   7.3.2.1      SSID element                                       37
109   7.3.2.10     Hopping Pattern Parameters information element     38
110   7.3.2.11     Hopping Pattern Table information element          38
111   7.3.2.12     Request information element                        38
112   7.3.2.13     ERP Information element                            38
113   7.3.2.14     Extended Supported Rates element                   38
114   7.3.2.15     Power Constraint element                           38
115   7.3.2.16     Power Constraint element                           38
116   7.3.2.17     TPC Request element                                38
 99   7.3.2.18     TPC Report element                                 38
117   7.3.2.19     Supported Channels element                         38
118   7.3.2.2      Supported Rates element                            37
119   7.3.2.20     Channel Switch Announcement element                38
120   7.3.2.20A    New Extension Channel Offset element               38
121   7.3.2.21     Measurement Request element                        39
122   7.3.2.21.1   Basic request                                      39
123   7.3.2.21.2   CCA request                                        39
124   7.3.2.21.3   RPI histogram request                              39
125   7.3.2.22     Measurement Report element                         39
126   7.3.2.22.1   Basic report                                       39
127   7.3.2.22.2   CCA report                                         39
128   7.3.2.22.3   RPI histogram report                               39
129   7.3.2.23     Quiet element                                      39
130   7.3.2.24     IBSS DFS element                                   39
131   7.3.2.25     RSN information element                            39
132   7.3.2.25.1   Cipher suites                                      39
133   7.3.2.25.2   AKM suites                                         39
134   7.3.2.25.3   RSN capabilities                                   40
135   7.3.2.25.4   PMKID                                              40
136   7.3.2.26     Vendor Specific information element                40
137   7.3.2.27     QBSS Load element                                  40
100   7.3.2.28     EDCA Parameter Set element                         40
138   7.3.2.29     TSPEC element                                      40
139   7.3.2.3      FH Parameter Set element                           37
140   7.3.2.30     TCLAS element                                      40
141   7.3.2.31     TS Delay element                                   40
142   7.3.2.32     TCLAS Processing element                           40
101   7.3.2.33     Schedule element                                   40
143   7.3.2.34     QoS Capability element                             40
144   7.3.2.4      DS Parameter Set element                           37
145   7.3.2.46     Fast BSS transition EAPOL-Key information element (EAPKIE)   40
146   7.3.2.47     HT Capabilities                                              40
147   7.3.2.47.1   HT Capability element                                        41
148   7.3.2.47.2   HT Capabilities Info field                                   41
149   7.3.2.47.3   MAC HT parameters Info field                                 44
150   7.3.2.47.4   Supported MCS set field                                      45
151   7.3.2.47.5   Extended HT Capabilities Info field                          46
152   7.3.2.47.6   Transmit Beamforming Capability                              47
102   7.3.2.47.7   Antenna Selection Capability                                 50
103   7.3.2.48     Additional HT Information Elements                           51
104   7.3.2.5      CF Parameter Set element                                     37
105   7.3.2.6      TIM                                                          37
106   7.3.2.7      IBSS Parameter Set element                                   37
153   7.3.2.8      Challenge Text element                                       38
154   7.3.2.9      Country information element                                  38
155   7.4          Action frame format details                                  55
156   7.4.1        Spectrum management action details                           55
157   7.4.1.1      Measurement Request frame format                             55
158   7.4.1.2      Measurement Report frame format                              55
159   7.4.1.3      TPC Request frame format                                     55
160   7.4.1.4      TPC Report frame format                                      55
161   7.4.1.5      Channel Switch Announcement frame format                     55
162   7.4.2        QoS Action frame details                                     55
163   7.4.2.1      ADDTS Request frame format                                   56
164   7.4.2.2      ADDTS Response frame format                                  56
165   7.4.2.3      DELTS frame format                                           56
166   7.4.2.4      Schedule frame format                                        56
167   7.4.3        DLS Action frame details                                     56
168   7.4.3.1      DLS Request frame format                                     56
169   7.4.3.2      DLS Response frame format                                    56
170   7.4.3.3      DLS Teardown frame format                                    56
171   7.4.4        Block Ack Action frame details                               56
172   7.4.4.1      ADDBA Request frame format                                   57
173   7.4.4.2      ADDBA Response frame format                                  57
174   7.4.4.3      DELBA frame format                                           57
175   7.4.5        Radio Measurement action details                             57
176   7.4.6        Fast BSS transition action details                           57
185   7.4.7        HT Management Action Frames details                          57
177   7.4.7.1                                                                   57
                   Recommended Transmission Channel Width Management Action Frame
178   7.4.7.10     PSMP                                                         76
179   7.4.7.2      MIMO Power Save Management Action Frame                      58
180   7.4.7.3      PCO Phase Request Management Action Frame                    59
181   7.4.7.4      MIMO Channel Measurement frame                               59
182   7.4.7.5      Reciprocity Correction frame                                 62
183   7.4.7.6      MIMO CSI Matrices frame                                      63
184   7.4.7.7      MIMO Uncompressed Steering Matrices frame                    68
186   7.4.7.8      Compressed Steering Matrices Feedback frame                  72
187   7.4.7.9      Antenna Selection Indices Feedback Frame                     75
188   7.4A         Aggregated MPDU frames                                       78
189   7.4A.1       Aggregated MPDU format (A-MPDU)                              78
190   7.4A.1.1     CRC                                                          79
191   7.4A.1.2     De-aggregation (Informative)                                 79
192   7.4A.2     A-MPDU Contents                                             80
193   7.5        Frame usage                                                 81
194   8          Security                                                    81
195   8.1        Framework                                                   81
196   8.2        Pre-RSNA security methods                                   81
197   8.3        RSNA data confidentiality protocols                         82
198   8.4        RSNA security association management                        82
199   8.5        Keys and key distribution                                   82
200   8.6        Mapping EAPOL keys to IEEE 802.11 keys                      82
201   8.7        Per-frame pseudo-code                                       82
202   8.8        Security for HT STA                                         82
238   9          MAC sublayer functional description                         82
203   9.1        Block Acknowledgment (Block Ack)                            91
239   9.1        MAC architecture                                            82
240   9.1.5      Fragmentation/defragmentation overview                      82
241   9.10.1     Introduction                                                91
242   9.10.2     Setup and modification of the Block Ack parameters          91
243   9.10.3     Data and acknowledgement transfer                           92
244   9.10.4     Receive Buffer Operation                                    92
245   9.10.5     Teardown of the Block Ack mechanism                         92
246   9.10.6     Use of Compressed bitmap                                    92
247   9.10.7     N-Immediate BlockAck extensions                             92
248   9.10.7.1   BlockAck Extension Architecture                             93
249   9.10.7.2   Rx reordering buffer control                                93
250   9.10.7.3   Scoreboard context control in full state                    94
251   9.10.7.4   Scoreboard context control in partial state                 94
252   9.10.7.5   Scoreboard context control of BlockAck                      95
253   9.10.7.6   Scoreboard context control of BlockAckReq                   95
254   9.10.7.7   Originator's behavior                                       95
255   9.10.7.8   Maintaining the BlockAck state at the originator            95
256   9.10.7.9   Originator's support of Responder's partial state           96
257   9.10.8     N-Delayed BlockAck extensions                               96
258   9.10.8.1   N-Delayed BlockAck negotiation                              96
259   9.10.8.2   Operation of N-Delayed BlockAck                             96
260   9.11       No Acknowledgment (No Ack)                                  97
261   9.12       Frame exchange sequences                                    97
262   9.13       Protection mechanism for non-ERP receivers                 104
263   9.14       Protection mechanisms for different HT PHY options         105
264   9.14.1     RIFS Protection                                            105
265   9.14.2     Green Field Protection                                     105
266   9.15       L-SIG TXOP Protection                                      105
267   9.15.1     L-SIG TXOP Protection Rules at the Initiator               106
268   9.15.2     L-SIG TXOP Protection Rules at the Responder               106
269   9.15.3     L-SIG TXOP Protection Rules at Third Party HT              106
270   9.16       Protection mechanisms for Aggregation Exchange Sequences   107
271   9.16.1     Generally                                                  107
272   9.16.2     Long NAV                                                   107
273   9.16.3     Truncation of TXOP                                         108
274   9.17       Reverse direction                                          109
275   9.17.1     Reverse direction aggregation exchanges                    109
276   9.17.2     Bi-Directional Data Exchange Rules                         110
277   9.17.3     Constraints regarding responses                            111
278   9.18           PSMP                                               111
279   9.18.1         Scheduled PSMP                                     111
280   9.18.1.1       PSMP sequence                                      111
281   9.18.1.1.1     Down Link Transmission                             113
282   9.18.1.1.2     Up Link Transmission                               113
283   9.18.1.1.2.1   Scheduling of Up Link Transmissions                114
284   9.18.2         Multi-phase PSMP                                   114
285   9.18.2.1       PSMP Power management                              116
286   9.18.3         MTBA rules in scheduled PSMP sequence              116
287   9.18.3.1       ULT payload retransmission                         116
288   9.18.4         Unscheduled PSMP                                   117
289   9.19           Link Adaptation                                    117
290   9.19.1         Introduction (informative)                         117
291   9.19.2         Link Adaptation using the HT Control Field         118
204   9.19.3         Immediate Response Frame Exchange for HT Control   119
292   9.19.4         Fast Link Adaptation using explicit feedback       119
206   9.2            DCF                                                 82
207   9.2.3          IFS                                                 82
208   9.2.3.1        SIFS                                                83
209   9.2.3.2        PIFS                                                83
210   9.2.3.3        DIFS                                                83
211   9.2.3.4        AIFS                                                83
212   9.2.3.5        Extended IFS (EIFS)                                 83
214   9.2.3.6        RIFS                                                83
213   9.2.4          DCF access procedure                                83
215   9.2.5          DCF access procedure                                84
216   9.2.5.4        Setting and resetting the NAV                       83
217   9.2.5.4        Setting and resetting the NAV                       84
293   9.2.5.4.1      Dual CTS Protection                                 84
294   9.2.6          Directed MPDU transfer procedure                    84
205   9.20           Transmit Beamforming                               119
295   9.20.1         Introduction (Informative)                         119
296   9.20.2         Transmit Beamforming with Implicit Feedback        120
297   9.20.2.1       Calibration                                        121
298   9.20.2.1.1     Introduction (Informative)                         121
299   9.20.2.1.2     Procedure                                          122
300   9.20.3         Explicit feedback beamforming                      123
301   9.20.3.1       Introduction (informative)                         123
302   9.20.3.2       Feedback request and response rules                123
303   9.20.3.3       Transmit Beamforming with explicit Feedback        124
304   9.21           Antenna Selection                                  125
305   9.21.1         Introduction (Informative)                         125
306   9.21.2         Procedure                                          125
307   9.22           Zero Length Frame as sounding frame                128
308   9.22.1         Determination of ZLF destination                   128
309   9.22.2         Determination of ZLF source                        129
310   9.23           40/20 Functional description                       129
311   9.23.1         Rules for operation in 40/20Mhz BSS                129
312   9.23.2         STA CCA sensing 40/20MHz BSS                       129
313   9.23.3         AP CCA sensing in 40/20Mhz BSS                     130
314   9.23.4         NAV assertion in 40/20Mhz BSS                      130
315   9.23.5         Frame transmission in 40/20Mhz BSS                 130
316   9.23.6         Protection in 40/20MHz BSS                          130
317   9.23.7         CF-End in duplicated mode                           130
218   9.23.8         ACK and BlockAck in non-HT duplicated mode          131
219   9.23.9         STA switching from 40MHz to 20MHz in 40/20MHz BSS   131
220   9.3            PCF                                                  85
221   9.3.3          PCF transfer procedure                               85
222   9.3.3.3        CFPMaxDuration limit                                 85
223   9.4            Fragmentation                                        85
224   9.5            Defragmentation                                      86
225   9.6            Multirate support                                    87
226   9.6.1          Modulation classes                                   88
227   9.6.2          Non-HT Basic Rate calculation                        88
228   9.7            MSDU transmission restrictions                       89
229   9.8            Operation across regulatory domains                  89
230   9.9            HCF                                                  89
231   9.9.1          HCF contention-based channel access (EDCA)           89
232   9.9.1.1        Reference Implementation                             90
233   9.9.1.2        EDCA TXOPs                                           90
234   9.9.1.3        Obtaining an EDCA TXOP                               90
235   9.9.1.4        Multiple frame transmission in an EDCA TXOP          90
236   9.9.1.6        Retransmit procedures                                90
237   9.9.3          Admission Control at the HC                          90
645   9.9.3.2        Controlled-access admission control                  91
647   9.9.4          PSMP NAV operation                                   91
646   A.4            PICS proforma-IEEE Std 802.11, 2006 Edition9        265
648   A.4.15         Enhancements for Higher Throughput                  265
649   A.4.3          IUT configuration                                   265
644   A4.15.1        MAC Enhancements for Higher Throughput              265
650   A4.15.2        PHY Enhancements for Higher Throughput              271
652   Annex A        PICS                                                265
653   Annex C        Formal description of MAC operation                 275
651   Annex D        ASN.1 encoding of the MAC and PHY MIB               276
      Annex P        LDPC Matrix Definitions                             323
      Boilerplate    Boilerplate                                           0
      C.3            State machines for MAC stations                     275
      CA DOC         CA Document                                           0
      General        General                                               0
                     Table of Contents
      Table of Contents                                                    0
      Title          Title                                                 0
Topic
General
General
Interfaces
Interfaces
Interfaces
MLME
MLME
MLME
MLME
MLME
MLME
MLME
MLME
MLME
MLME
MLME
MLME
MLME
MLME
MLME
MLME
MLME
MLME
MLME
MLME
MLME
MLME
MLME
MLME
MLME
MLME
MLME
MLME
MLME
MLME
MLME
MLME
MLME
PLME
PLME
PLME
MAC Management
MAC Management
MAC Management
MAC Management
MAC Management
MAC Management
MAC Management
MAC Management
MAC Management
MAC Management
MAC Management
MAC Management
MAC Management
MAC Management
MAC Management
A-MPDU
A-MPDU
A-MPDU
Coexistence
Coexistence
Coexistence
Coexistence
PCO
PCO
PCO
Power Management
Power Management
Power Management
Power Management
Power Management
Power Management
Power Management
Power Management
Power Management
Power Management
Power Management
Power Management
Security
TSPEC
TSPEC
TSPEC
TSPEC
TSPEC
PSMP
PSMP
PSMP
PSMP
Block Ack
Block Ack
PSMP
PSMP
Synchronization
DLS
Coexistence
Coexistence
Coexistence
Coexistence
Coexistence
Coexistence
Coexistence
PHY Interface
PHY Interface
PHY Management
PHY General
PHY General
General
PHY General
PHY General
PHY General
PHY General
PHY General
PHY General
PHY General
PHY General
PHY General
PHY Interface
PHY Interface
PHY Interface
PHY Interface
PHY Interface
PHY Interface
PHY Interface
PHY Interface
PHY Interface
PHY Interface
PHY Interface
PHY Interface
PHY Interface
PHY Interface
PHY Interface
PHY Interface
PHY Interface
PHY Interface
PHY Interface
PHY Interface
PHY Interface
PHY Interface
PHY Interface
PHY Interface
PHY Interface
PHY Interface
PHY Interface
PHY Interface
PHY Interface
PHY Interface
PHY Interface
PHY Interface
PHY Interface
PHY Interface
PHY Interface
PHY Interface
PHY Interface
PHY Interface
PLCP
PLCP
PHY Characteristics
PHY Characteristics
PHY Characteristics
PHY Characteristics
PHY Characteristics
PHY Characteristics
PHY Characteristics
PHY Characteristics
PHY Characteristics
PHY Characteristics
RIFS
PHY Characteristics
PHY Characteristics
PHY Characteristics
PHY Characteristics
PHY Characteristics
PHY Characteristics
PHY Characteristics
PHY Characteristics
PHY Characteristics
PHY Characteristics
CCA
RCPI
PLCP
PLCP
PLCP Frame Format
PLCP
PLCP
PLCP MCS
PLCP
PLCP
PLCP
PLCP Preamble
PLCP Preamble
PLCP Preamble
PLCP Preamble
PLCP Preamble
PLCP Preamble
PLCP Preamble
PLCP Header
PLCP Preamble
PLCP Preamble
PLCP Header
PLCP Header
PLCP Preamble
PLCP Preamble
PLCP Greenfield
PLCP Greenfield
PLCP Greenfield
PLCP Header
PLCP Header
PLCP Header
PLCP Preamble
PLCP Data
PLCP Data
PLCP Data
PLCP Coding
PLCP Coding
PLCP Coding
PLCP Coding
PLCP Coding
PLCP Coding
PLCP Coding
PLCP Coding
PLCP Coding
PLCP Interleaver
PLCP Interleaver
PLCP Interleaver
PLCP Interleaver
PLCP OFDM
PLCP STBC
PLCP OFDM
PLCP OFDM
PLCP OFDM
PLCP OFDM
PLCP OFDM
PLCP OFDM
PLCP OFDM
Coexistence
PHY Beamforming
PHY Beamforming
PHY Beamforming
PHY Beamforming
PHY Beamforming
PHY Beamforming
PHY Sounding
PHY Sounding
PHY Sounding
PHY Sounding
PLCP Regulatory
PLCP Regulatory
PLCP Regulatory
PLCP Regulatory
PLCP Regulatory
PLME
PLME
PLME
PLME
PLME
PMD
PMD
PMD
PMD
PMD
PMD Interface
PMD Interface
PMD Interface
PMD Interface
PMD Interface
PMD Interface
PMD Interface
PMD Interface
PMD Interface
PMD Interface
PMD Interface
PMD Interface
PMD Interface
PMD Interface
PMD Interface
PMD Interface
PMD Interface
PMD Interface
PMD Interface
PMD Interface
PMD Interface
PMD Interface
PMD Interface
PMD Interface
PMD Interface
PMD Interface
PMD Interface
PMD Interface
PMD Interface
PMD Interface
PMD Interface
PMD Interface
PMD Interface
PMD Interface
PMD Interface
PMD Interface
PMD Interface
PMD Interface
PMD Interface
PMD Interface
PMD Interface
PMD Interface
PMD Interface
PMD Interface
PMD Interface
PMD Interface
PMD Interface
PMD Interface
PMD Interface
PMD Interface
PMD Interface
PMD Interface
PMD Interface
PMD Interface
PMD Interface
PMD Interface
PMD Interface
PMD Interface
PMD Interface
PMD Interface
PMD Interface
PMD Interface
PMD Interface
PMD Interface
PMD Interface
PMD Interface
PMD Interface
PMD Interface
PMD Interface
Features
MCS
General
General
General
Features
Features
Features
Features
Features


General
General
Link Adaptation
Beamforming
Antenna Selection
General
MAC Interface
MAC Interface
MAC Interface
MAC Interface
MAC Interface
MAC Interface
MAC Interface
MAC Interface
MAC Interface
Frame Formats
Frame Formats
Frame Formats
Frame Formats
Frame Formats
Frame Formats
Frame Formats
Frame Formats
Frame Formats
Frame Formats
Frame Formats
Frame Formats
Frame Formats
Frame Formats
Frame Formats
Frame Formats
Frame Formats
Frame Formats
Frame Formats
Frame Formats
Frame Formats
Frame Formats
Frame Formats
Frame Formats
Frame Formats
Frame Formats
Frame Formats
Block Ack
Block Ack
Block Ack
Block Ack
Block Ack
Block Ack
Block Ack
Block Ack
Frame Formats
A-MSDU
Management Frames
Management Frames
Management Frames
Management Frames
Management Frames
Management Frames
Management Frames
Management Frames
Management Frames
Management Frames
Management Frames
Management Frames
Management Frames
Management Frames
Management Frames
Management Frames
Management Frames
Management Frames
Management Frames
Management Frames
Management Frames
Block Ack
Block Ack
Block Ack
Management Frames
Management Frames
Management Frames
Management Frames
Management Frames
Management Frames
Management Frames
Management Frames
Management Frames
Management Frames
Management Frames
Management Frames
Management Frames
Management Frames
Management Frames
Management Frames
Coexistence
Coexistence
Coexistence
Coexistence
Coexistence
Coexistence
Coexistence
Coexistence
Management Frames
Management Frames
Management Frames
Management Frames
Management Frames
Management Frames
Management Frames
Management Frames
Management Frames
Management Frames
Security
Security
Security
Security
Security
Management Frames
Management Frames
Management Frames
TSPEC
Management Frames
TSPEC
TSPEC
TSPEC
TSPEC
Management Frames
Management Frames
Security
HT Elements
HT Elements
HT Elements
HT Elements
HT Elements
HT Elements
Beamforming
Antenna Selection
HT Elements
Management Frames
Management Frames
Management Frames
Management Frames
Management Frames
Management Frames
Management Frames
Management Frames
Management Frames
Management Frames
Management Frames
Management Frames
Management Frames
TSPEC
TSPEC
TSPEC
TSPEC
DLS
DLS
DLS
DLS
Block Ack
Block Ack
Block Ack
Block Ack
Management Frames
Management Frames
HT Action Frames
Coexistence
PSMP
Power Management
PCO
Beamforming
Beamforming
Beamforming
Beamforming
Beamforming
Antenna Selection
A-MPDU
A-MPDU
A-MPDU
A-MPDU
A-MPDU
A-MPDU
Security
Security
Security
Security
Security
Security
Security
Security
Security
MAC Operation
Block Ack
MAC Operation
MAC Operation
Block Ack
Block Ack
Block Ack
Block Ack
Block Ack
Block Ack
Block Ack
Block Ack
Block Ack
Block Ack
Block Ack
Block Ack
Block Ack
Block Ack
Block Ack
Block Ack
Block Ack
Block Ack
Block Ack
MAC Operation
MAC Operation
Protection Mechanisms
Protection Mechanisms
RIFS
Protection Mechanisms
Protection Mechanisms
Protection Mechanisms
Protection Mechanisms
Protection Mechanisms
Protection Mechanisms
Protection Mechanisms
Protection Mechanisms
Protection Mechanisms
MAC Operation
MAC Operation
MAC Operation
MAC Operation
PSMP
PSMP
PSMP
PSMP
PSMP
PSMP
PSMP
PSMP
PSMP
PSMP
PSMP
Link Adaptation
Link Adaptation
Link Adaptation
Link Adaptation
Link Adaptation
MAC Operation
MAC Operation
MAC Operation
MAC Operation
MAC Operation
MAC Operation
MAC Operation
RIFS
MAC Operation
MAC Operation
MAC Operation
MAC Operation
Protection Mechanisms
MAC Operation
Beamforming
Beamforming
Beamforming
Beamforming
Beamforming
Beamforming
Beamforming
Beamforming
Beamforming
Beamforming
Antenna Selection
Antenna Selection
Antenna Selection
ZLF
ZLF
ZLF
Coexistence
Coexistence
Coexistence
Coexistence
Coexistence
Coexistence
Coexistence
Coexistence
Coexistence
Coexistence
MAC Operation
MAC Operation
MAC Operation
MAC Operation
MAC Operation
MAC Operation
MAC Operation
Coexistence
MAC Operation
MAC Operation
MAC Operation
MAC Operation
MAC Operation
MAC Operation
MAC Operation
MAC Operation
MAC Operation
MAC Operation
MAC Operation
PSMP
PICS
PICS
PICS
PICS
PICS
PICS
MAC SDL
MIB
PLCP Coding
General
MAC SDL
CA DOC
General
General
General
Topic                     Grouping
                        0 General
A-MPDU                    Frame Format
A-MSDU                    Frame Format
Antenna Selection         Beamforming & Adaptation
Beamforming               Beamforming & Adaptation
Block Ack                 MAC
CA DOC                    CA DOC
CCA                       Coexistence
Coexistence               Coexistence
DLS                       MAC
Duplicate                 Duplicate
Features                  General
Frame Formats             Frame Format
General                   General
HT Action Frames          Frame Format
HT Elements               Frame Format
Interfaces                General
Link Adaptation           Beamforming & Adaptation
MAC Interface             MAC
MAC Management            MAC
MAC Operation             MAC
MAC SDL                   MAC
Management Frames         Frame Format
MCS                       PHY
MIB                       General
MLME                      MAC
PCO                       Coexistence
PHY Beamforming           Beamforming & Adaptation
PHY Characteristics       PHY
PHY General               PHY
PHY Interface             PHY
PHY Management            PHY
PHY Sounding              Beamforming & Adaptation
PICS                      General
PLCP                      PHY
PLCP Coding               PHY
PLCP Data                 PHY
PLCP Frame Format         PHY
PLCP Greenfield           PHY
PLCP Header               PHY
PLCP Interleaver          PHY
PLCP MCS                  PHY
PLCP OFDM                 PHY
PLCP Preamble             PHY
PLCP Regulatory           Coexistence
PLCP STBC                 PHY
PLME                      PHY
PMD                       PHY
PMD Interface             PHY
Power Management          MAC
Protection Mechanisms     Coexistence
PSMP              PSMP
RCPI              PHY
RIFS              Coexistence
Security          MAC
Synchronization   MAC
TSPEC             Frame Format
ZLF               Beamforming & Adaptation
                  General

				
DOCUMENT INFO
Shared By:
Categories:
Tags:
Stats:
views:8
posted:9/22/2011
language:English
pages:209