Docstoc

Introduction - Why Teenage Pregnancy Matters

Document Sample
Introduction - Why Teenage Pregnancy Matters Powered By Docstoc
					1. Introduction - Why Teenage Pregnancy Matters.

Teenage pregnancy is a significant public health and social exclusion issue. Having children at a young age places young women
and their children at risk of poor outcomes:

      Teenage Parents are less likely to finish their education and are more likely to bring up their children alone and in poverty.
      The infant mortality rate for babies born to teenage mother is 60% higher than for babies born to older mothers.
      Teenage mothers are more likely to smoke during pregnancy and less likely to breastfeed, both of which have negative
       health consequences for the child.
      Teenage mothers have three times the rate of postnatal depression of older mothers and a higher risk of poor mental health
       for three years after the birth.
      Children of teenage mothers are generally at increased risk of poverty, low education attainment, poor housing and poor
       health and have lower rates of economic activity in adult life.
      Rates of teenage pregnancy are highest among deprived communities, so the negative consequences of teenage pregnancy
       are disproportionately concentrated among those who are already disadvantaged.

(Teenage Pregnancy Next Steps: Guidance for Primary Care Trusts and Local Authorities on the Effective Delivery of Local
Strategies. DFES 2006)

In addition the financial cost of teenage pregnancies is high:

      The cost of teenage pregnancy to the NHS alone is estimated to be £63 million a year.
      Benefit payments to a teenage mother who does not enter employment in the three years following birth total between
       £19,000 and £25,000 over three years.
      Teenage mothers are much more likely than older mothers to require targeted support from a range of local services e.g. to
       help them re-engage with education, training or employment or to help them access supported housing.
      Broad estimates suggest that for every £1 spent on the strategy there is a saving of £4 to the public purse when assessed
       over a period of five years.




                                                                                                                                    1
(Teenage Pregnancy Next Steps: Guide for Local Authorities and Primary Care Trusts on Effective Delivery of Local Strategies
DfES 2006)

It has been reported that In Birmingham and Solihull the cost of teenage pregnancies to the NHS alone is estimated to be around
£1.5 million a year.

(Sex and the City- draft Sexual Health Needs Assessment for Birmingham and Solihull 2007)

Birmingham has an additional financial incentive to focus on reducing teenage conceptions. If we achieve our 2008 LPSA stretch
target we stand to receive a reward grant of £2.6 million in 2010.

2. 0 Outcome Analysis

The Teenage Pregnancy Strategy is subject to a number of national and local performance targets. Progress towards these targets
impacts on the Annual Performance Assessment and the Joint Area Review for Children‟s Services as well as the Healthcare
Commission PCT star ratings.

2.1 Targets

The Social Exclusion Unit's Report on Teenage Pregnancy, published in June 1999, set out two national targets: to halve the under
18 conception rate by 2010 (and establish a firm downward trend in the under 16 rate); and to increase the participation of teenage
parents in education, training or work, to reduce their risk of long-term social exclusion.

The Social Exclusion Unit Report also set a target that all under 18 teenage lone parents who cannot live with family or partner
should be placed in suitable supported accommodation by the end of 2003. This target has had a low profile since 2003 and is no
longer being used as a key performance indicator.

In 2002 a further target was announced to reduce the risk of long-term social exclusion by increasing the participation of teenage
mothers aged 16 to 19 in employment, education or training to 60% by 2010. Local Connexions Partnerships share this target, as
well as the target to halve the under 18 conception rate by 2010.



                                                                                                                                     2
There is also a commitment to reduce health inequalities with a target to 'achieve agreed local teenage conception reduction
targets while reducing the gap in rates between the worst fifth of wards and the average by at least a quarter in line with national
targets'. This target is measured at a national level.

Birmingham has two local targets in addition to the main PSA target of a 50% reduction in under 18 conceptions by 2010:

LPSA: Achieve an average rate of decline that is 4.8% better than the England rate of decline by 2008

LAA: No more than 7 Birmingham wards to be more than 25% higher than the Birmingham average by 2009.

We do not know yet whether the under 18 conception rate will be one of the locally selected targets for the new Local Area
Agreement.

2.2 Outcomes for Young People

In keeping with the move towards outcome-driven strategic planning, the following outcomes are suggested as the principal
outcomes for the Teenage Pregnancy Strategy. These are clear links between these and the Brighter Future Strategy Priority
Outcomes.

      Young people are able to make informed choices about their sexual health, sexual behaviour, personal relationships and
       parenthood. (Physical and Emotional Health)
      Young people are free from sexually transmitted infections, unplanned pregnancies and avoidable terminations. (Physical
       Health)
      Young people have the confidence and skills to ask for information, gain support and to access advice and sexual health
       services when needed. (Social Literacy)
      Young people are able to form healthy and fulfilling personal relationships, free from coercion and exploitation. (Emotional
       Health, Social Literacy, Behaviour)




                                                                                                                                       3
      Young people, including young parents, are able to fulfil their educational and economic potential. (Literacy and Numeracy,
       Job Skills)
      Young families have a safe place to live. (Physical and Emotional Health)
      Young parents and their children are healthy. (Physical and Emotional Health)
      Young people – including young parents -make a positive contribution. (Social Literacy)
      Young people become successful parents.(Behaviour, Emotional Health)

Work is continuing to identify how we can measure progress towards these outcomes using appropriate performance indicators.

2.3 Conception trends

Under 18s

Birmingham has seen a decrease in the under 18 conception rate between 1998 and 2005 of 13.4%. The England rate of decline
was 11.3% for the same period. Our best performing year was 2002, when our rate of decline was 15.5%, but this was followed by
a slight increase in 2003.




                                                                                                                                     4
     Under 18 conception rate per 1000
                                         70      1998 baseline                                     2010     Birmingham
                                                                                                   target   MCD
                                         60                                                                 England
                                         50
                                                                                                            West Midlands
                                         40
                                         30                                                                 LA 2004 target
                                         20
                                         10
                                          0




                                              p
                                            97

                                            98

                                            99

                                            00

                                            01

                                            02

                                            03

                                            04




                                            06

                                            07

                                            08

                                            09

                                            10
                                           05
                                          19

                                          19

                                          19

                                          20

                                          20

                                          20

                                          20

                                          20




                                          20

                                          20

                                          20

                                          20

                                          20
                                         20
                                                                      Year


Fig 1 source ONS.

In 2005 the under18 conception rate for Birmingham was 50.5 per 1000 young women aged 15-17, compared with the England
average of 41.1. We have the 45th highest rate out of 148 top-tier local authorities.

Birmingham has the best rate of decline of our statistical neighbour group as determined by the DfES.

 Table 1: Under-18 conception trends by DfES
 Statistical Neighbours
                                                                               Under-18 conception rate     % difference
                                                                 Deprivation
 LA code                                      LA                   score          1998          2005         1998-2005
 00CN                                         Birmingham MCD        37.6          58.3          50.5           -13.4

 00KA                                         Luton                 23.3          43.1           41.5           -3.7
 00CS                                         Sandwell              35.4          69.1           62.1          -10.1
 00CW                                         Wolverhampton         32.2          66.3           61.4           -7.5




                                                                                                                             5
 00FY         Nottingham City         41.8             74.7            69.3    -7.2
Fig 2 Source: ONS

Our rate of decline is better than Manchester, Leeds, Bristol, Sheffield, and Newcastle-Upon-Tyne, but not as good as Liverpool or
Leicester.

Despite some progress we are not on track to meet our PSA or LPSA target and will have to accelerate considerably to meet them.
To achieve the 50% reduction target by 2010 we need to prevent between 100 and 150 conceptions year on year.

To achieve the LPSA target we will need to have prevented approximately 40 additional conceptions a year in 2006, 2007 and
2008, assuming that the national rate of decline continues to follow its current trajectory

Conceptions Under 16

Figures for the under 16 population show a small but concerning rise in the number and rate of conceptions in the younger age
group in Birmingham since 2001, at a time when the England rate is declining

Under 16                  2001-                2002-                   2003-
conceptions               2003                  2004                    2005

                Number     Rates      Number   Rates      Number       Rates

England          22,360         7.9   22,132     7.8          22,201     7.7

Birmingham
MCD                 547         8.5      562     8.7            578      9.0
Fig 3 Source: ONS
Under 16 Rate = number of under 16 conceptions per 1000 young women aged 13-15




                                                                                                                                     6
Terminations

As this table and graph illustrate (Fig 4), our under 18 abortion rate has not declined significantly since the late 1990s, it is our
maternity rate which has reduced.

Repeat terminatons
Recent figures on the percentage of repeat abortions for under 19s by PCT show that in 2006 the national average for repeat
abortions was 10.7%. Heart of Birmingham PCT was better than the national average at 8.8%, but Birmingham East and North
PCT and South Birmingham PCT were worse at 11.4% and 12.3% respectively. Overall in Birmingham in 2006 there were 88
repeat abortions by young women under 19.

The rate of second and subsequent pregnancies among teenagers in Birmingham is not known.


                       Outcome of u18                                                                                  60
                      conception 1997-




                                                                                      Rate per 1000 girls aged 15-17
                       99 and 2003-05                                                                                  50


 Birmingham MCD           1997-99               2003-05           % change                                             40
         Under 18
       conceptions                  58.1                   52.1         -10.3                                                                              Births
                                                                                                                       30
      Abortion rate                 22.5                   22.3          -0.6
     Maternity rate                 35.6                   29.8         -16.4                                               Abortions
                                                                                                                       20

Fig 4 Source ONS                                                                                                       10


                                                                                                                       0
                                                                                                                                    1997-99           2003-05
                                                                                                                                              Years




                                                                                                                                                                    7
Ward Data

Data at ward level shows us that our under 18 conceptions in Birmingham are more concentrated in particular areas.

                                        U 18
                       No of u18                   No of u18        U 18          change
                                    conception
     WARD NAME        conceptions                 conceptions    conception    from 2001-3
                        2001-3       rate 2001-     2002-4      rate 2002-04     to 2002-4
                                         03
Hall Green                    37         30.68            42          23.45           7.23   decrease
Sutton Vesey                  37         36.63            45          25.04          11.59   decrease
Sutton Four Oaks              36         35.50            43          25.97           9.54   decrease
Moseley                       37         31.44            36          27.21           4.22   decrease
Sparkhill                     76         31.73            72          31.13           0.60   decrease
Sutton New Hall               49         36.08            58          31.64           4.44   decrease
Small Heath                  108         34.02            94          32.95           1.07   decrease
Sandwell                      64         34.56            73          33.66           0.90   decrease
Perry Barr                    38         34.39            46          34.85          -0.46   increase
Harborne                      42         37.91            38          38.50          -0.59   increase
Selly Oak                     54         56.25            50          38.58          17.67   decrease
Oscott                        63         64.68            60          41.84          22.84   decrease
Edgbaston                     36         33.27            41          42.84          -9.57   increase
Handsworth                   106         42.15            93          43.79          -1.64   increase
Quinton                       48         56.54            51          44.16          12.38   decrease
Nechells                     118         44.05            98          47.69          -3.64   increase
Northfield                    73         75.18            66          47.72          27.46   decrease
Bournville                    74         66.07            69          48.42          17.65   decrease
Brandwood                     62         52.41            69          48.42           3.99   decrease
Sparkbrook                   130         47.22           112          49.06          -1.84   increase
Washwood Heath               101         36.98           113          50.70         -13.71   increase
Acock's Green                 81         53.82            85          52.76           1.06   decrease
Sheldon                       58         65.24            61          56.64           8.60   decrease




                                                                                                                     8
Kingstanding                127       86.87       110        61.32       25.55   decrease
Yardley                      90       82.64        95        61.49       21.16   decrease
Longbridge                  108       64.94       122        61.52        3.42   decrease
Hodge Hill                   97       72.01       103        64.29        7.72   decrease
Bartley Green                83       73.98        86        65.60        8.38   decrease
Billesley                   112       92.26       129        65.85       26.41   decrease
Soho                        130       51.77       124        66.24      -14.47   increase
Weoley                      103      102.28       103        66.80       35.49   decrease
Aston                       151       53.99       145        70.15      -16.16   increase
Stockland Green             108       80.12       119        74.00        6.11   decrease
King's Norton               103       93.55        98        76.32       17.23   decrease
Kingsbury                    69       78.41        82        77.65        0.76   decrease
Fox Hollies                 123       87.92       133        77.91       10.01   decrease
Erdington                    98       77.96       110        79.37       -1.40   increase
Ladywood                     89       44.30       104        81.38      -37.08   increase
Shard End                   136      105.10       120        88.30       16.80   decrease
Fig 5 Source: ONS

As might be expected there is some correlation between wards with low educational attainment, high deprivation and under 18
conceptions, however two of our most deprived wards, Small Heath and Sparkhill have under 18 conception rates below the
national average. (Fig 6 and 7) This could possibly be explained by the ethnic make up of the population in those areas, with a high
proportion of young people from South Asian backgrounds. (See 2.4 below)




                                                                                                                                   9
                                                          u 18 concpetion rate vs % of boys with no GCSE passes
                                                                                by ward**

                            16

                                                                                                                                                                        Shard End
                            14
                                                                                                                                                       Kingsbury

                            12
                                                                                                                            Kingstanding
% boys achieving no GCSEs




                                                                                                         Washwood Heath
                                                                                                       Sparkbrook
                            10
                                                                                                                                                   Stockland Green
                                                                                                                                           Aston             Ladywood
                                                                         Sparkhill
                            8

                                                                                                     Nechells
                                                                                                Handsworth                                             Fox Hollies
                            6                                                                                                     Soho


                                                                           Small Heath
                            4



                            2



                            0
                             0.00   10.00         20.00          30.00               40.00          50.00           60.00          70.00              80.00          90.00          100.00

                   **Those named are in most deprived national quintile                      u 18 conception rate




                                                                                                                                                                                             10
                                                                  U 18 conception rate vs % of boys achieving 5+ GCSEs at A* to C
                                                                                            by ward**

                                    100


                                     90


                                     80
% boys achieving 5+ A* to C GCSEs




                                     70


                                     60


                                     50

                                                                                            Small Heath                                              Fox Hollies
                                     40
                                                                                         Sparkhill
                                                                                                                                    Soho
                                     30                                                                      Nechells
                                                                                                              Sparkbrook                                  Ladywood
                                                                                                                 Washwood Heath                 Stockland Green
                                                                                                  Handsworth                              Aston      Kingsbury
                                                                                                                             Kingstanding                          Shard End
                                     20


                                     10


                                      0
                                       0.00          10.00         20.00         30.00         40.00          50.00           60.00   70.00        80.00           90.00       100.00
                                                                                                       u 18 conception rate
                                    ** Those named are in most deprived national quintile




                                                                                                                                                                                        11
2.4 Risk factors for Teenage Pregnancy

Although local data about outcomes for risk groups is limited, research gives us an indication of which young people are most at
risk of teenage pregnancy.

Where young people experience multiple risk factors their likelihood of teenage parenthood increases significantly. Young women
experiencing five risk factors (daughter of a teenage mother; father‟s social class IV & V; conduct disorder; social housing at 10 and
poor reading ability at 10) have a 31% probability of becoming a mother under 20, compared with a 1% probability for someone
experiencing none of these risk factorsi. Similarly, young men experiencing the same five risk factors had a 23% probability of
becoming a young father (under age 23), compared to 2% for those not experiencing any of these risk factors.


Factors associated with high teenage pregnancy rates
Risk factor                                                            Evidence
Risky Behaviours
Early onset of  Girls having sex under-16 are three times more likely to become pregnant than those who first have sex over
sexual activity   16.ii
                 Around 60% of boys and 47% of girls leaving school at 16 with no qualifications had sex before 16,
                  compared with around 20% for both males and leaving school at 17 or over with qualifications.
                 Early onset of sexual activity is also associated with some ethnic groups (see below)
Poor             Around a quarter of boys and a third of girls who left school at 16 with no qualifications did not use
contraceptive     contraception at first sex, compared to only 6% of boys and 8% girls who left school at 17 or over, with
use               qualifications.
                 Survey data demonstrate variations in contraceptive use by ethnicity. Among 16-18 year olds surveyed in
                  London, non-use of contraception at first intercourse was most frequently reported among Black African
                  males (32%), Asian females (25%), Black African females (24%) and Black Caribbean males (23%). iii
Mental health /  A number of studies have suggested a link between mental health problems and teenage pregnancy. A
conduct           study of young women with conduct disorders showed that a third became pregnant before the age of 17 iv.
disorder/        Teenage boys and girls who had been in trouble with the police were twice as likely to become a teenage




                                                                                                                                    12
involvement in     parent, compared to those who had no contact with the police.v
crime
Alcohol and      Research among south London teenagers found regular smoking, drinking and experimenting with drugs
substance          increased the risk of starting sex under-16 for both young men and women. A study in Rochdale showed
misuse             that 20% of white young women report going further sexually than intended because they were drunk vi.
                   Other studies have found teenagers who report having sex under the influence of alcohol are less likely to
                   use contraception and more likely to regret the experience.vii
Teenage          A significant proportion of teenage mothers have more than one child when still a teenager. Around 20% of
motherhood         births conceived under-18 are second or subsequent births
Repeat           Around 7.5% of abortions under-18 follow either a previous abortion or pregnancy. Within London this
abortions          proportion increases to around 12% of under-18 abortions
Education-related factors
Low              The likelihood of teenage pregnancy is far higher among those with poor educational attainment, even after
educational        adjusting for the effects of deprivation. On average, deprived wards with poor levels of educational
attainment         attainment had an under-18 conception rate double that found in similarly deprived wards with better levels
                   of educational attainment. (80 per 1000 girls aged 15-17 compared with 40 per 1000)
Dis-             A survey of teenage mothers showed that disengagement from education often occurred prior to pregnancy,
engagement         with less than half attending school regularly at the point of conception. Dislike of school was also shown to
from school        have a strong independent effect on the risk of teenage pregnancy. viii
                 Poor attendance at school is also associated with higher teenage pregnancy rates. Among the most
                   deprived 20% of local authorities, areas with more than 8% of half days missed had, on average, an under-
                   18 conception rate 30% higher than areas where less than 8% of half days were missed.
Leaving          Overall, nearly 40% of teenage mothers leave school with no qualifications.ix
school at 16     Among girls leaving school at 16 with no qualifications, 29% will have a birth under 18, and 12% an abortion
with no            under 18, compared with 1% and 4% respectively for girls leaving at 17 or over.
qualifications  Leaving school at 16 is also associated with having sex under 16 and with poor contraceptive use at first sex
                   (see below).
Family / Background factors
Living in Care  Research has shown that by the age of 20 a quarter of children who had been in care were young parents,



                                                                                                                                    13
                   and 40% were mothersx.
                  The prevalence of teenage motherhood among looked after girls under-18 is around three times higher than
                   the prevalence among all girls under-18 in England.
Daughter of a     Research findings from the 1970 British Birth Cohort dataset showed being the daughter of a teenage
teenage            mother was the strongest predictor of teenage motherhood.
mother
Ethnicity       Data on mothers giving birth under age 19, identified from the 2001 Census, show rates of teenage
                 motherhood are significantly higher among mothers of „Mixed White and Black Caribbean‟, „Other Black‟ and
                 „Black Caribbean‟ ethnicity. „White British‟ mothers are also over-represented among teenage mothers,
                 while all Asian ethnic groups are under-represented
                A survey of adolescents in East Londonxi showed the proportion having first sex under-16 was far higher
                 among Black Caribbean men (56%), compared with 30% for Black African, 28% for White and 11% for
                 Indian and Pakistani men. For women, 30% of both White and Black Caribbean groups had sex under-16,
                 compared with 12% for Black African, and less than 3% for Indian and Pakistani women
                Poor contraceptive use has also been reported for some ethnic groups
Parental        Research shows that a mother with low educational aspirations for her daughter at age 10 is an important
aspirations      predictor of teenage motherhood
Teenage Pregnancy: Accelerating the Strategy to 2010. DfES 2006
I
 Berrington A, Diamond I, Ingham R, Stevenson J et al (2005) Consequences of teenage parenthood: pathways which minimise the long
term negative impacts of teenage childbearing’ University of Southampton
ii
   Wellings K, et al (2001) Sexual Health in Britain: early heterosexual experience. The Lancet vol.358: p1834-1850
iii
   Testa A and Coleman L (2006) Sexual Health Knowledge, Attitudes and Behaviours among Black and Minority Ethnic Youth in
London. Trust for the Study of Adolescence and Naz Project London
iv
   Maskey S, (1991) Teenage Pregnancy: doubts, uncertainties and psychiatric disorders Journal of Royal Society of Medicine
v
   Hobcraft J (1998) Intergenerational and life-course transmission of social exclusion: Influences of childhood poverty, family
disruption and contact with the police. CASE paper 15, LSE
vi
   Redgrave K, Limmer M (2005) ‘It makes you more up for it’. School aged young people’s perspectives on alcohol and sexual
health. Rochdale Teenage Pregnancy Strategy: Rochdale




                                                                                                                                   14
vii
   Alcohol Concern (2002) Alcohol & Teenage Pregnancy. London: Alcohol Concern
viii
    Hosie A, Dawson N (2005) the Education of Pregnant Young Women and Young Mothers in England. Bristol: University of
Newcastle and University of Bristol
ix
   National Statistics (2004) Census 2001 table: C0069 Mothers under 19 at birth (Commissioned by Teenage Pregnancy Unit,
DfES)
x
   Barn R, Andrew L, Mantovani N (2005) Life after care: the experiences of young people from different ethnic groups Joseph
Rowntree Foundation, London
xi
   Viner R, Roberts H (2004) Starting sex in East London: protective and risk factors for early sexual activity and contraception use
amongst Black and Minority Ethnicity adolescents in East London University College London, City University and Queen Mary,
University of London


Ethnicity
Data from our local hospitals and abortion service providers shows that young women who are Black or of mixed parentage are
over represented amongst young women under 18 who conceive in Birmingham, whereas South Asian groups are under
represented. (See Fig 8 Below)
However, data from the 2001 census shows that 21.7% of young mothers in Birmingham who had their first child below the age of
19 were of Pakistani origin. This suggests high birth rates for Pakistani young women at 18.

Further analysis of local data (see Fig 9 below) shows that among the youngest girls who conceive, Black young women are most
likely to continue with their pregnancy. At ages 15, 16 and 17 it is mixed parentage young women who are most likely to continue
their pregnancy (i.e. least likely to seek a termination)


The current systems for recording ethnicity do not give us a clear idea of conception patterns within newly arrived populations and
anecdotal reports are mixed.




                                                                                                                                    15
                 Teenage conceptions by ethnicity
                    April 2003 - October 2006



              2% 3%
                             15%




                                                    Black, Black British, African or Caribbean
                                       8%
                                                    Asian, British Asian, Pakistani, Indian or
                                                    Bangladeshi
                                                    Mixed parentage

                                                    White

                                                    Other

                                                    not specified
                                       15%

        57%




Fig 8



                                                                                                 16
                                Proportion of live births to teenage mothers by age and ethnicity
                                                       Apr 2003 -March 2007

                   100


                   90


                   80


                   70
  percentage (%)




                   60


                   50


                   40


                   30


                   20


                   10


                    0
                         < 15                        15                                 16          17
                                                                       age

                                                       White   Black    Asian   Mixed   All

Fig 9




                                                                                                         17
Looked After Children and Care Leavers


Rates of pregnancy are high among looked after children in Birmingham and exceptionally high among care leavers. These groups
are particularly vulnerable to a range of poor outcomes. It is not known to what extent these pregnancies are planned or unplanned.

In a sample of 100 16 -18 year old Care Leavers in Birmingham there was evidence that 19 of the 41 young women (46%) had
been pregnant at some point, with between 1 and 3 pregnancies each. (This is likely to be an underestimation as young people
may not tell professionals about pregnancies that do not result in a birth)There were 20 young parents (15 mothers and 5 fathers) in
the sample, with 23 children between them.

In a sample of 100 16-17 year old young people in care it appeared that 8 of the 36 females (22%) had been pregnant at some
point. (One young woman had been pregnant twice). There were 4 fathers and 8 mothers with 14 children between them.

(From the 16+ Care Leavers Needs Analysis January 2006, Birmingham CYPF Directorate)

Other Vulnerable Groups

Approximately 5% of young parents known to the Connexions Service have a learning disability or difficulty – the majority of these
having emotional or behavioural difficulties.

There is currently no system to collect information to monitor the number of young offenders who become young parents in
Birmingham.

Although there is no local data and limited UK research to compare, a number of large-scale population studies in the United States
have highlighted the vulnerability of gay, lesbian and bisexual young people.


   Massachusetts 1997 Youth Risk Behavior Survey: LGB youth were 2 times as likely as their peers to have been/or got someone
    pregnant (24% v. 12%)



                                                                                                                                 18
   Seattle 1995 Teen Health Risk Survey: LGB youth were 2 times as likely to be a teen parent (6.7% v. 3.5%)
   Minnesota 1987 Adolescent Health Survey: lesbian and bisexual young women were twice as likely as their heterosexual peers
    to report having ever been pregnant. (Only data for girls available (12.3% v. 6.1%)
   Vermont 1997 Youth Risk Behavior Survey: LGB youth were two or more times likely to have been pregnant or got someone
    pregnant (15% v. 2%).

(Massachusetts, 1997; Seattle 1995; Minnesota 1987; Vermont 1997: 83.000 -- Sexual Orientation (Safe Schools Coalition of WA)

Saewyc et al (1999) suggest the following as possible reasons to explain why lesbian and bisexual teenagers might have had
heterosexual experience:

1. Forced sexual contact as sexual abuse, incest and rape are more prevalent among lesbian and bisexual young women than
   heterosexual young women (Grundlach & Reiss, 1967; Simari & Baskin, 1982).
2. Many may have heterosexual sexual relationships before identifying as lesbian (Henderson, 1984; Sanford, 1989).
3. It may be a strategy employed during identity confusion stage of development. Troiden (1988) notes: "Some adolescents
   establish heterosexual involvement in hopes of 'curing' themselves of their homosexual interest....In some cases; an adolescent
   girl may purposely become pregnant to prove that she isn't lesbian. Researchers have also made this proposition based on
   their clinical experience and investigations (Rotheram-Borus & Fernandez, 1995).
4. Involvement in prostitution as a result of being made homeless due to family rejection on the grounds of their sexual orientation
   (Bidwell & Deisher, 1991).

(Bidwell, R.J. & Deisher, R.W. (1991) Adolescent sexuality: current issues, Pediatric Annals, Vol 20(6), 293-302).
(Grundlach, R.H. & Reiss, B.F. (1967) Birth order and sex of siblings in sample of lesbians and nonlesbians, Psychological Reports,
Vol 20(1), 61-62)
(Rotheram-Borus, M.J. & Fernandez, M.I. (1995) Sexual orientation and developmental challenges experienced by gay and lesbian
youths, Suicide and Life-Threatening Behavior, Vol 25(Supplement), 26-34)
(Saewyc EM., Bearinger, L.H., Blum, R.Wm., Resnick, M.D. (1999) Sexual Intercourse, Abuse and Pregnancy Among Adolescent
Women: Does Sexual Orientation Make a Difference? Family Planning Perspectives, Vol 31 (3), May/June)




                                                                                                                                  19
(Simari, C.G. & Baskin, D. (1982) Incestuous experiences within homosexual populations: a preliminary study, Archives of Sexual
Behavior, Vol 11(4), 329-343)
 (Troiden, R.R. (1988) Homosexual identity development, Journal of Adolescent Health Care, Vol 9(2), 105-113)

2.5 Relationships

Despite the obvious importance to young people of forming romantic, sexual and/or long-term relationships, and the significance of
healthy relationships for long-term emotional wellbeing, this is an area where we are not very good at measuring outcomes.

Early sexual activity increases the risk of teenage pregnancy. Research carried in 2001 showed that the earlier first intercourse
occurred the greater the likelihood that the respondent expressed regret relating to timing and reported being more or less (but not
equally) willing compared with their partner. Women were more likely than men to say they wished they had waited longer and to
report not having been equally willing.

(From Sexual Behaviour in Britain, Early Heterosexual Experience, Wellings, Johnson et al. The Lancet, December 1st 200)
.
A quarter of girls and nearly a third of boys have sex under 16 but the average age for both sexes is 16.
Research tells us that regret is a major issue for young people. 67% of young men and 84% young women who had sex aged 13
and 14 wished they had waited.

(2002 National Survey of Sexual Health Attitudes and Lifestyles (NATSAL) Johnson, Wellings et al)

Young women who lack emotional resilience are vulnerable not just to teenage pregnancy but also to abuse and exploitation. This
is particularly the case for Looked after Children and Care Leavers, for whom entering a sexual relationship or having a child may
be an attempt to meet an unmet need for affection and emotional security.

Teenage relationships often break down and teenage mothers are more likely to end up bringing up their children alone than older
mothers. According to the 2001 Census, 58% of teenage mothers under 19 in Birmingham were lone parents. However 23% of our
young mothers under 19 were married, one of the highest percentages in England. This could possibly be explained by the high
birth rate to 18 year old mothers from Pakistani families, who are more likely to marry and start a family at a younger age.



                                                                                                                                   20
Aspirations

Current mechanisms for measuring aspirations concentrate on academic achievement and employment, so as yet we do not have
a clear idea of the extent to which young people in Birmingham might see parenthood as the best „career option‟. However the
2001 census shows that 50% of our young mothers under 19 had no qualifications, one of the highest percentages in England (8th
worst out of 352 Local Authority districts).

Empowerment
Young people in Birmingham do not always have the information and the support they need to make informed choices. 40% of
young people in Birmingham who took part in the school-based ‟Tell Us 2‟ Survey would like more or better information and advice
on sex and relationships, more than any other topic surveyed.

The Tell Us 2 Survey suggests that Q30? of young people in the Birmingham sample worry about girlfriends/boyfriends/sex.

Not all young people are knowledgeable about the services that are there to help them. In a Birmingham survey of 175 socially
excluded young men, 50% did not have any knowledge of their local sexual health services. (Syconium 2006)

?% Young people simply do not have anyone they feel they can to turn to for advice and support Tell Us 2 Q 31a and 32

2.6 Health of Teenage Mothers and their Babies

2.7 Education and Economic well-being




                                                                                                                                21
3.0 Service Gap Analysis


3.1 What works to prevent Teenage Pregnancy?

Teenage pregnancy is a complex problem which requires a complex solution. The core business of local teenage pregnancy
Strategies has been to focus on ensuring young people have the means to avoid unintended pregnancies by improving knowledge,
skills and contraceptive use.

It is clear that wider actions to address the underlying causes of teenage pregnancy are also needed to give young people the
choice and motivation to aspire to further education and rewarding careers, leaving the decision to have children until later when
they are better equipped to deal with the demands of parenthood.


There is a growing body of evidence for effective interventions. What is clear is that in order to improve outcomes, local strategies
should have a multi-faceted approach including:

   -   Sex and relationships education (SRE) in schools and SRE training for professionals working with vulnerable young people
   -   Availability of well publicised, young people –centred contraceptive services.
   -   Well-resourced youth and career development programmes promoting academic, social skills, self esteem and entry to
       employment.
   -   Intensive structured parenting and family support for vulnerable families.
   -   Wider measures to reduce poverty and increase aspiration.

Teenage Pregnancy, an Overview of the Research Evidence. HDA 2004.
Teenage Pregnancy and Parenthood: A Review of Reviews. HDA 2003.
Teenage Pregnancy Next Steps: Guidance for Local Authorities and Primary Care Trusts on Effective Delivery of Local
Strategies.DfES 2006




                                                                                                                                     22
3.2 Personal, Social and Health education (PSHE)

Within Schools, Sex and Relationships Education (SRE) is usually taught under the umbrella of PSHE which covers a wider range
of issues such as drugs, alcohol and bullying.
School governors have a statutory responsibility for sex and relationships education (SRE) in their school.

The 1996 Education Act consolidates all relevant previous legislation. In summary:

–   The SRE elements of the National Curriculum Science Order across all key stages are mandatory for all pupils of primary and
    secondary age.
–   All schools must have an up to date policy that describes the content and organisation of SRE provided outside the National
    Curriculum Science Order. It is the school governors‟ responsibility to ensure that the policy is developed and made available
    to parents for inspection.
–   Primary schools should either have a policy statement that describes the SRE provided or give a statement of the decision not
    to provide SRE other than that provided within the National Curriculum Science Order.
–   Secondary schools are required to provide SRE, which includes (as a minimum) information about sexually transmitted
    infections (STIs) and HIV/AIDS.


Parents have the right to withdraw their children from all or part of sex education, except those areas that are included in the
national curriculum programme of study for science. Teachers are within their rights to refuse to teach SRE.
Information gathered over the last 18 months from pupils as part of the secondary SRE project has highlighted areas of the
curriculum which appear to be weakest. Schools seem to be good at covering the basics around conception, contraception and
relationships, however young people want more information and discussion about sex and the law, consent, STIs, where to go for
contraception, being a parent and negotiation in relationships.




                                                                                                                                   23
For the last two years we have focussed our strategy for Birmingham on improving the capacity of schools to deliver high quality
SRE by providing help with needs assessment, policy and curriculum planning and training. This in turn contributes to schools
achieving National Healthy School Status.
Considerable progress has been made in engaging schools with the Healthy Schools programme, with good coverage of schools.
Key for all maps
primary schools =   Secondary schools =       Special schools =
rate/1000 women aged 15-17
       75 and over         50-75        25-50        1-25




Fig 10 Schools with NHSS 2007



                                                                                                                                   24
Fig 11 Schools working towards NHSS




                                      25
Fig 12 Schools not engaged in NHSS




                                     26
SRE is most effective when delivered by people with specialist training. As part of a national programme, the Health Education
Service offers a specialist PSHE CPD Course for teachers and community nurses delivering PSHE. There has been a year on year
increase in uptake by teachers; however uptake by nurses has been low.




Fig 13 Schools that have or have had a certificated PSHE teacher


Only 32% of secondary schools with >20% free school meal entitlement have access to a PSHE certificated nurse.




                                                                                                                            27
Fig 14 Schools with a phase 5 teacher working towards certification


The Teenage Pregnancy Partnership has commissioned the Health Education Service and Birmingham Brook to work with
secondary schools in order to implement a complete review of their SRE provision with consultation with students, staff and
parents. Agreement is sought from School Governing Bodies for participation in the programme. Schools were prioritised initially
using a range of criteria including location in a high rate ward, educational attainment, attendance and reported pregnancies.




                                                                                                                                   28
             Secondary SRE Programme
             Schools approached                       40
             Schools involved                         25
             Schools expressed an interest            3
             Schools not responded to opportunity     8
             Schools not wishing to be involved       4
            (Figures correct as of 31.10.2007)


Steady progress is being made with the schools that are engaged. Barriers to schools getting involved include;

      Schools offended by the offer due to links to Teenage Pregnancy and the fear of upsetting parents.
      Lack of contactable person in schools due to Teaching and Learning Responsibility points issues. Some schools have
       abolished their PSHE post and have year heads organising the PSHE programme, this could mean that in one school for
       example you would have to meet with 5 people to discuss the programme and plan it across the year groups.
      PSHE provision is so inadequate that they are unable to contemplate the project at this time. Some schools had no
       recognisable programme and had to acknowledge that they had to firstly look at this issue before looking at provision within
       the programme.

Factors once recruited have also caused progress to stall in some schools:
      Lack of or out-of-date SRE policy that meant that no teaching or development could go on till Governors had given outline
       approval.
      Currently poor practice meant that the starting point was very low with very few teachers having any classroom experience
       upon which to build or associate to. One school involved in the programme admitted to not having taught any SRE for at
       least the last 8 years.
      Lack of motivation of teachers to teach SRE, some schools did have well organised programmes but teachers were not
       delivering on it and there was a lack of management integrity in the school that would normally be applied to the teaching of
       core curriculum subjects.
      Ignorance/ anxiety to ethnic/ cultural issues was a major factor schools cited as a reason not to develop their programme or
       why staff were hesitant to deliver it.



                                                                                                                                   29
      Some schools not willing to address certain topics in SRE such as sexuality and masturbation. Religious reasons are
       mainly cited for the topics exclusion, but a lot of school are stating Homophobic Bullying is a real problem in schools
       particularly among the Muslim pupils.
      Tutor lead programmes means that up to 70 staff could be delivering PSHE in the school and trying to get that many staff to
       deliver to the same level is a major challenge and a practice that QCA are trying to steer schools away from in favour of a
       discrete delivery team.
      Lack of Continued Professional Development (CPD) for teacher‟s means many had several years of service but no update or
       input based around SRE. Newly qualified teachers also felt that preparation for teaching this type of subject in their training
       was unsatisfactory. Schools who did have a teacher who had completed the DfES CPD PSHE certification were not
       necessarily better off as the one individual maybe did not have the status to bring about effective change in their school.

Greater availability of data on reported pregnancies over a four-year period has highlighted a further 20 schools where pregnancies
have occurred that would need to be targeted in the next phase.

Primary Schools
Birmingham Children‟s Fund has for six years supported the HES to work in partnership with the national charity „Positive
Parenting‟ on a primary SRE project. 70 primary schools have been involved with a further 12 starting this year.
The project worker works in a consultative way, speaking to pupils, parents, staff and governors to gain data that is particular to
those children in that locality and therefore “tailor-make” an SRE policy and scheme of work that meets the needs of those children.
The project is regularly evaluated and is locally and nationally recognised as a great success and a model of good practice. There
is now a long waiting list of additional schools that would like to take part in this project.



Input from Outside Agencies
There are a number of agencies which offer direct classroom input to complement SRE delivery in schools. These include School
Nurses; Youth Workers; Theatre Groups; Voluntary organisations such as Positive Parenting, Brook, and Space. This type of input
evaluates well by pupils and schools, however it is difficult to sustain and too dependent on either the willingness of schools to pay,




                                                                                                                                    30
the availability of short-term funding streams, or the capacity of front-line staff such as school nurses to make a contribution as part
of their core role. This means that external input is patchy and not always well-targeted.
As a result of feedback from young people‟s representatives, a Scrutiny Review of effective SRE is underway in the City, with a
final report due in October 2008.


Recommendations
  1. Aim to provide universal high quality SRE in schools. If SRE is seen as an entitlement for all pupils it should reduce
     the stigma associated with ‘being targeted’. We should however continue to target efforts at schools where the
     need is greatest.
  2. Further proactive work should be undertaken with governors and parents, particularly at schools were there is a
     strong religious emphasis.
  3. Provide examples of good practice in faith-sensitive SRE
  4. Support the Scrutiny process to ensure that good practice is recognised, young people’s views are given full
     consideration and further improvements are identified.


3.3 Targeted Work

Resources and effort have been targeted to reach young people at increased risk on both a geographical and „risk group‟ basis.

Geographical

Since 06/07 14 wards have been prioritised for prevention work. The City Council Youth Service along with voluntary sector
organisations have been commissioned to deliver Teenage Pregnancy Prevention programmes in these areas. The programmes
offer Sex and Relationships Education with an agreed set of learning outcomes, based on work that was being delivered at the
Maypole Youth Centre as a National Youth Development Pilot. Within the programmes there is an emphasis on relationships, the
realities of parenting and helping young people to think about their future life goals.




                                                                                                                                     31
       Youth Development Programmes
         Ward                                No. of           Forecast
                                             actual          No. of
                                             programmes      programmes
                                             Delivered       completed
                                             from April 05   by March 08
                                             to Sept 07
         1. Acocks Green                     1               3
         2. Aston                                            2
         3. Bartley Green                    1               3
         4. Erdington                        1               6
         5. Hodge Hill                       2               3
         6. Kings Norton                     2               4
         7. Kingstanding                     3               4
         8. Ladywood                         2               3
         9. Nechells                                         2
         10. Shard End                       4               6
         11. Stetchford and Yardley North    3               4
         12. Stockland Green                 2               4
         13. Tyburn                          3               6
         14. Weoley                          1               3

An average of 11 young people have taken part in each programme, of which 59% were young women.

91%of participants achieved a Youth service recorded outcome and 79% some sort of accreditation e.g. ASDAN.

BME Groups




                                                                                                              32
Monitoring data shows that 90% of the programme participants so far in 07/08 have been white, reflecting less delivery in Aston
and Nechells. This is not however the total picture of delivery in those areas as there have been a number of programmes funded
directly by Heart of Birmingham PCT, including Sisters with Voices (targeting Black and mixed parentage young women) and City
United (working with Black young men). The HYPe (Healthy Young People) project was set up in the SRB 6 area and works mainly
with young people from BME communities.

Looked After Children and Care Leavers.

For at least 5 years there has been a Sexual Health Development Officer post in place to support work with Looked After Children.
Until 2005/6 the focus of the work has been on workforce capacity-building i.e. policy development, training and action-planning
with staff in residential units, and to a limited extent, training foster carers and social workers. Although there has clearly been a
need to support front-line residential staff, it is clear that their role has been mainly reactive, providing information and signposting
and dealing with safeguarding issues such as inappropriate sexual behaviour and sexual exploitation. The Development Officer has
also coordinated input from external agencies, in particular working with Friction Arts on an annual performance project to raise
awareness of Sexual Health, and Positive Parenting who have run parenting awareness sessions in some of the Units. Since
2006/7 the Development Officer has also been required to do some direct delivery to young people and has recently delivered to a
group of unaccompanied minors by working in partnership with BUMP (Befriending Unaccompanied Minors Project). More
opportunities need to be found to deliver structured prevention programmes.

There is a small team of Looked After Children‟s Nurses employed by South Birmingham PCT. They have limited capacity for group
work…………….

For several years the 16+ Care Leavers Service ran an award-winning peer education programme. Care Leavers were recruited
and trained to deliver SRE to young people in Care, for which they received a BTEC qualification. This was mainstreamed and
integrated into a holistic „Preparation for Independence‟ programme. This has been on hold now for some time pending the
outcome of the current service review.

There needs to be more joined up working to promote emotional resilience and to raise aspirations among these most vulnerable
young people as this would help to prevent a wide range of poor outcomes




                                                                                                                                      33
Young Offenders

There have been a number of attempts to find the best way to deliver work via the Youth Offending Service, including „buying in‟
external facilitators, capacity-building of YOS staff and a specialist post within the inappropriate sexual behaviour team. The current
arrangement is to have a dedicated person who delivers education and advice on both an individual and small group basis as
regular input into each of the YOS area teams. Although this is a recent appointment the early indication is that this approach is
working well, with 16 referrals within the first month.

Homeless Young People

Some project work has been delivered by St Basil‟s in the past. This is not something that the Teenage Pregnancy Partnership is
funding at the moment but has the potential to be revisited. South Birmingham PCT fund prevention work at the South Birmingham.
Young Homeless Project.

Youth Inclusion Programmes (YIP)

Two of the current YIPs are in high rate Teenage Pregnancy Areas (Kingstanding and Shard End). The young people they work
with are identified and assessed as being at high risk of a range of poor outcomes that would also be risk factors for Teenage
Pregnancy. Kingstanding YIP has been delivering a specific teenage pregnancy prevention programme. The young people taking
part are tracked and so far there have been no pregnancies among what would be a high risk group. This approach to addressing
risky behaviour along with other cross-cutting risk factors such as poor educational engagement is very promising.

Underdeveloped areas of targeted work

The most obvious gaps in the targeted work at the moment are for work with NEET young people, work in the Pupil Referral Units
and for work with young people with mental health problems.




                                                                                                                                     34
Recommendations:

   1. Youth Development Programmes to be a resource for Extended Provision Clusters resulting in improved targeting
      and more joined up delivery.
   2. Improve early identification of vulnerability to teenage pregnancy through Pre-CAF and CAF processes.
   3. Integrate 1. and 2. above into design for Targeted Youth Support Service. In particular learning from the YIPs.
   4. More work to be commissioned with PRUs and NEET young people
   5. Link with specialist agencies working with Gay, Lesbian and Bisexual Young People to get a better understanding
      of what is currently being delivered and where there might be scope for addionality.
   6. Review work with Looked After Children and Care Leavers in order to maximise opportunities for delivery with a
      particular focus on resilience work.
   7. Drill-down conception rate analysis to identify hotspots within otherwise affluent wards.
   8. Clarify the role of the Sexual Health Promotion Service in supporting this area of work.



3.4 Parenting Support

Parentline Plus
Speakeasy
Local mapping for the parenting strategy

3.5 Contraceptive Services

Significance of contraceptive services to achieving targets :

Contraceptive services have a significant role to play in reducing teenage conceptions. Research conducted in the United States
has shown that approximately one quarter of the decline in US rates between 1988 and 1996 was attributable to abstinence and
three quarters to sexually active young people changing their behaviour. They found that there had been little change in the




                                                                                                                                  35
frequency of sex and only a slight increase in contraceptive use. However a significant proportion of teenagers had changed to
long-acting contraceptive methods (by 1998 13% of teenage contraceptive users were using long-acting methods).
Alan Guttmacher Institute 1999

In-depth reviews carried out by the Teenage Pregnancy Unit in 2005 identified the key factors for successful strategies to reduce
under 18 conceptions. The factor most frequently cited as having the biggest impact on conception rates was the provision of
young people-focused, contraceptive/sexual health services, trusted by teenagers and well-known by the professionals working
with them. Features of successful services included: easy accessibility in the right location with opening hours convenient to young
people; provision of the full range of contraceptive methods, including long-acting methods; a strong focus on sexual health
promotion, through for example, outreach work in schools; work with professionals to improve their ability to engage with young
people on sexual health issues; and through highly visible publicity. Effective services also had a strong focus on meeting the
needs of young men. All high- performing areas also had condom distribution schemes and/or access to EHC in non-clinical
settings.

Teenage Pregnancy Next Steps: Guidance for Local Authorities and Primary Care Trusts on Effective Delivery of Local Strategies.
DfES 2006


A detailed contraceptive service needs assessment has recently been carried out on behalf of the Birmingham and Solihull Sexual
Health Joint Commissioning Board. The main findings are summarised below:

Level and Distribution of Services in Birmingham

Only twelve of the 23 Birmingham Family Planning clinics are in areas with the highest rates of teenage pregnancy.

The service hosted by HOB tPCT has a large well- qualified team of 16 doctors [1 consultant, one associate specialist and 13
medical officers] and 19 nurses. 9 of the 16 medical staff are trained to insert and remove implants; 10 to insert and remove IUDs;
10 are DFFP trainers. 8 out of 19 nurses have a family planning certificate.




                                                                                                                                  36
                                                                             Rate/1000 women aged
                                                                             15-17
                                                                             75 and over
                                                                             50-74
                                                                             25-49
                                                                             1-24




Teenage Conception rate 2002-2004 by ward and location of family planning clinics (Source: ONS & Local Data)



The national contract for GP practices requires them to provide basic contraceptive services. Most provide this as part of a general
consultation, rather than through dedicated clinics.



                                                                                                                                 37
Almost all GP practices offer advice and prescription of the oral contraceptive pill; some offer contraceptive injection and IUD fitting;
few if any offer contraceptive implant fitting. Practices refer patients to FP clinics to supply services they do not deliver themselves.

There are major variations between PCTs in the amount and costs of contraception which GPs prescribe, which appears to be
unrelated to population size or need. For example, GPs in HOBtPCT prescribing spend is only one third that spent by other 2
PCTs.

Attempts to improve primary care based sexual health services through the Sexual Health In Practice [SHIP] scheme have had limited
success. For instance there is great variation in the amount of basic contraception prescribed by different practices ( Appendix Figures
D,E,F,G)

Many practices trained under this scheme do not actively provide sexual health services and deliver the objectives of this scheme. There is
little capacity within the SHIP team [1.2 wte] to follow up practices and ensure proper implementation.

Provision of enhanced sexual health services in GP practices is particularly poor in areas with the highest need, HOBtPCT and parts of BEN.
Table 1 – SHIP provision
Name of PCT       No of practices No who actively provide % of SHIP trained
                  with      SHIP additional sexual health practices in PCT
                  training         services      e.g.    free
                                   condoms,         Chlamydia
                                   testing
HOBtPCT           27               3                             31%
BEN               57               5                             89%
SBCT              45               9                             66%
Solihull          29                                             93%




                                                                                                                                          38
Birmingham Brook is the major provider of contraceptive services to young people under 25 years. This service sees around 12000
new clients per year in their City-Centre base, of who the majority are between the ages of 16 – 19 years of age.

                                 New Clients at Brook 2005/6 (Source: KT31)

               1800
               1600
               1400
               1200
      Number




               1000
                800
                600
                400
                200
                 0
                      <15   15      16      17      18       19     20-21     22-23   24   25-29
                                                     Age Group




Information, Advice and Basic Services




                                                                                                                            39
In Birmingham these services are provided in a range of young people‟s settings delivered by different agencies and funded
through various funding streams. Services are limited where there is no input from qualified contraceptive and sexual health nurses.

Young people have to be signposted to Brook, a GP or Family Planning Clinic to access more reliable forms of contraception. This
may involve an unacceptable distance to travel, a fear of recognition or approaching a venue perceived as unwelcoming.

 Service                       Ward/Area               Ward                  Funding               Comments
                                                       Conception Rate

 Here 4 You (BEN)              Erdington               Very High             BEN and Youth         751 contacts April 06-
 Provides weekly sessions      Hodge Hill              High                  Service provide       Feb 07
 offering advice and info,     Kingsbury (Castle       Very High             staffing – supplies
 condoms, pregnancy testing    Vale)                                         funded through        Main age range 14-16
 and Chlamydia Screening.      Shard End               Very High             TP Grant.             year olds
 Working towards EHC           Sutton New Hall         Low
 provision.                    (Falcon Lodge)                                                      57% of clients are young
                               Yardley                                                             men
                                                       High
                                                                                                   Falcon Lodge is a
                                                                                                   pocket of deprivation in
                                                                                                   an otherwise affluent
                                                                                                   ward.

 HYPe                          Aston (x2)              High                  Originally SRB 6.     Family Planning
 (HOB)                         Handsworth              Low                   HOB funding roll      qualified nurse is
 Provides holistic health      Sandwell (X2).          Low                   out                   available.
 advice, condoms,              Small Heath                                   £248,000
 pregnancy testing,            Soho (X2)               Low                                         Service is relatively new
 Chlamydia screening, EHC,                             High




                                                                                                                                 40
hormonal contraception.

Youth Information Shops
 Provide advice,
information, condoms,          Northfield              Low                  Youth Worker       Northfield Youth Shop is
pregnancy testing,                                                          staffing costs     on a main bus route and
Chlamydia Screening.           Kings Norton            High                 funded by the      attracts young people
Nurse available at Base KS                                                  Youth Service,     from a wide
and Northfield for one         Kingstanding/Oscott     High                 Condoms and        geographical area.
session per week.                                                           pregnancy tests
                                                                            by TP Grant.
                                                                            Northfield Nurse
                                                                            funded by NRF.

C-Card Condom                  Brandwood (Druids       Low                  Funded through     Now coordinated by
Distribution Scheme            Heath)                                       the TP Grant       Brook with scope for
                               Erdington                                    £27,000 (includes expansion 07/08
Condoms and advice             Fox Hollies             Very High            supplies for Youth
provided by trained staff in   Perry Barr              Very High            information
young people‟s settings.                               Low                  Shops)
                               (In addition to Youth
                               Information Shops)
Brook Satellite Sessions
                               City College:           Students travel in   Funded through     Uptake is low at some
Advice                                                 from a wide area.    TP Grant           sessions and very high
condoms, pregnancy             Handsworth,                                  £15,400 per        at others.
testing, Chlamydia             Newtown and Tysley                           annum
screening. Nurse-led
session at Handsworth




                                                                                                                          41
 offering hormonal
 contraception.



The following wards have high or very high under 18 conception rates and do not have any local advice services in young people‟s
settings:

Acocks Green –SBPCT
Billesley -SBPCT
Bartley Green - SBPCT
Ladywood - HOBtPCT
Longbridge - SBPCT
Stockland Green - BENPCT
Sheldon- BENPCT
Washwood Heath- BENPCT
Weoley-SBPCT

In all Birmingham PCTs the School Nursing Service offers generic drop-in advice sessions to secondary Schools but this offer isn‟t
always taken up.
South PCT have targeted their service to secondary schools in high rate areas (Bartley Green, Billesley, Acocks Green and
Quinton)
BEN and HOB PCTs have negotiated drop-in sessions on a school by school basis. The extent to which services are „open‟ access
rather than available via teacher referral varies. The school nursing service in these PCTS is stretched. Sessions are cancelled
when there is no sickness cover or additional demands such as immunisation.


Service Access




                                                                                                                               42
Up to date information is currently being collected about young people‟s perceptions of access to sexual health services.

Birmingham Brook is open 6 days a week I [10 –6 pm] including all day Saturdays and offers advice over the phone.
Postcode analysis to be added.

An analysis of service attendees indicate that In Birmingham the Family Planning Service is predominantly used by older women
(25 – 35 + ), the majority of whom are Pakistani , white British or Irish


                                                Female First Contacts 2005/6 & 2006/7 (Source: KT31)
                                              * No data available for the 3 Birmingham PCTs for 2006/7

            8000

            7000

            6000

            5000
   Number




                                                                                                                            2005/6
            4000                                                                                                            2006/7

            3000

            2000

            1000

               0
                   <16   16-19        20-24        25-34        35+         <16         16-19       20-24     25-34   35+
                                 Birmingham PCTs                                                   Solihull
                                                                      Age




                                                                                                                                     43
Brook has sees a much higher % of Black African Caribbean young people than GPs or FP clinics.

HOBtPCT manages FP clinics for the three Birmingham PCTs. Since July, because of high DNA (did not attend) rates, these clinics
are now provided on a walk-in basis. The mean number of patients seen per session is 10.8 [range 0.2 – 27].

6 clinics see less than six patients per session, namely Good Hope, Broadmeadow, Hillmeads, Sanctuary, Weoley Castle and
Yardley Wood.

Of the 51 FP clinic sessions held per week in Birmingham, 18 are specifically for young people, 6 are held in the evening and 4 on
a Saturday morning.
In most wards there are no evening FP services.

The BRASH service for young people and hosted by HOBtPCT provides an advice line weekdays only [9am to 4.30 pm.]

The FP services also offer specialised clinics as follows
   - pregnancy counselling
   - psychosexual clinics
   - complex family planning or medical needs
   - drugs or alcohol misuse
   - vasectomies

Both FP services undertake very few or no domiciliary (home) visits [n= 0 – 3 per year]. There is no targeted provision of
contraceptive services for Looked After Children or Care leavers

Hawthorn House and the Drake Unit also offer contraception as part of their wider sexual health services but the volume of activity
is not known.

Long Acting Reversable Contraception (LARC)



                                                                                                                                44
NICE guidance indicates that Long Acting Reversible Contraceptives i.e. IUDs and implants] are much more cost effective than
Combined Oral Contraceptive pill even 1 year after use - and that women should be given information and choice about such
methods.
In Birmingham and Solihull GP prescribing of Oral Contraception is nearly twice the “ideal” level. To achieve the “ideal “level of
LARCs will require EITHER a major investment in developing GP competency and financial incentives to provide these services
OR using the capacity of our FP services to improve access to LARC services

The way to target the “at risk” population for LARCs is to provide an enhanced contraceptive advisory service after termination or
requests for EHC.




                                                                                                                               45
                                                        Comparison between current profiles and ideal profile of contraception provision (adapted from
                                                       Armstrong N, Donaldson C. The Economics of Sexual Health. Family Planning Association 2005)


                                            70
   Percent of Prescribable Contraceptives




                                            60

                                            50                                                                                                    National GP
                                                                                                                                                  B&S GP Mean
                                            40                                                                                                    Ideal GP
                                                                                                                                                  National FP
                                            30
                                                                                                                                                  B&S FP Mean
                                                                                                                                                  Ideal FP
                                            20

                                            10

                                            0




                                                                                                                                      ap
                                                   P




                                                                                                        D
                                                                                           S
                                                                 P




                                                                                                                       t
                                                                                n




                                                                                                                   an
                                                                                io
                                                  C




                                                                                         IU
                                                               PO




                                                                                                      IU




                                                                                                                                    /C
                                                                              ct
                                                  O




                                                                                                                  pl



                                                                                                                                 gm
                                                                          je
                                                 C




                                                                                                                Im
                                                                         In




                                                                                                                               ra
                                                                                                                             ph
                                                                                                                            ia
                                                                                                                           D


Pregnancy Testing and Advice




                                                                                                                                                                46
Younger women are more likely to need additional support in the case of an unplanned pregnancy. Research carried out by
Southampton University in Birmingham showed that young women under 18 took a longer time on average to suspect a pregnancy
and to make a decision about whether or not to have an abortion. 48% of under 18s reported delaying a termination due to „fears
about how my parents would react‟.

Abortions at ten and more weeks in Birmingham, Roger Ingham and Steve Clements, Centre for Sexual Health Research,
University of Southampton.2007

Preventing Second Pregnancies

Around 20% of births to under 18s are to young women who are already teenage mothers.

Teenage Pregnancy:Accelerating the Strategy to 2010. DfES 2006

Teenage Pregnancy Midwives in each of the four Maternity Units in Birmingham are undertaking training which will qualify them as
reproductive and sexual health nurses and enable them to work under PGDs to provide contraception as part of the care pathway
for young parents.

Some health visitors have been trained to provide post natal contraceptive advice and supply condoms, however this is not
currently monitored.




   3.6 Service information and signposting

Information about the main local services is available in leaflets and posters produced by the City‟s Sexual Health Promotion
Service and the Teenage Pregnancy Partnership. The Sexual Health Promotion Service has a large database of agencies who are




                                                                                                                               47
encouraged to order materials for distribution. Distribution therefore has a tendency to be a bit patchy as it is dependent upon all
agencies taking a level of responsibility for getting information out to their clients.
Schools are encouraged to provide service information to young people as part of PSHE. However there is no capacity to audit the
extent to which this is actually happening.
Services are also promoted through other media as radio as part of occasional advertising campaigns or new service launches.
A number of NHS providers in Birmingham have recently developed separately branded services and websites aimed at young
people, namely e.g .HYPe, Here4you, BRASH, BStreetwise and Ship-Shape. The impact and costs of this brand proliferation is not
yet known, but has the potential to create confusion and not deliver value for money in terms of impact .
Commissioners have not contracted a single agency responsible for maintaining a comprehensive local service database, helpline
or leading a city wide marketing strategy

There is limited capacity within any of the clinical services for staff to get out into young people‟s settings to promote their service.
Brook is able to do this as part of their education and training work, but this has had to be separately funded from other sources
such as the Teenage Pregnancy Grant.

Front-line practitioners are encouraged through training to actively support and signpost sexually active young people to help them
access services. In some service areas more work needs to be done to clarify workers‟ roles and responsibilities in this area.

Recommendations

The city wide commissioning board should:-

   1. Ensure that all SLAs /contracts with providers of sexual health and reproductive services, [including independent
      contractors contracted through a LES ] include the DH ‘You’re Welcome’ Quality Standards for young people
   2. Monitor that these standards are being delivered in practice
   3. Commission a single agency to coordinate the marketing strategy for Birmingham and Solihull, develop a local
      service directory/ helpline and database of sexual health services.




                                                                                                                                      48
4. Ask each PCT to develop, with input from their PBC groups, an SLA specifying the location , type and volume of
    contraceptive services they wish to commission for young people n particular to specify a) which neighbourhoods
    will be served by practices already actively providing sexual health services for young people and how these
    practices will be commissioned to enhance their current provision to drop in /open access to that neighbourhood
    as a whole. b) which neighbourhoods will be served by sexual health /contraceptive services commissioned to
    operate in young people’s settings
5. A separate SLA on behalf of all PCTs should be developed for City centre based young people’s contraceptive
    services.
6. Develop separate service specifications for the FP service , Brook and Hawthorn House which clearly identify the
    particular contribution expected [ or not ] from each service in providing contraceptive services to young people [
    under 25s ]
7. Agree 3 year trajectory for changing the ratio of LARS to CORC prescribing
8. Include post-natal contraceptive provision into maternity and health visiting care pathways and service
    specifications.
9. Review and, if appropriate, improve the capacity and targeting of the SHIP scheme to deliver more effective and
    equitable distributed young people contraceptive services within primary care.
10. Highlight to the Children and Young Peoples Board those schools and neighbourhoods whose young people are
    least well served by contraceptive and sexual advice services.
11. Commission jointly with the TP Partnership, basic training to enable all front line workers working with young
    people and other groups at risk to signpost them to sexual health services.
12. Ensure that the service specification for specialist FP services requires that all the Doctors and nurses working in
    such services are appropriately trained to deliver specialist FP services, fit and remove LARCs.

Service provision

Organisations commissioned by their PCTs to provide contraceptive services for young people should:-

13. Actively promote their services in young peoples settings and include this promotion as part of their business
    plans
14. Develop the competence of the nursing workforce to offer contraceptive advice as part of their day to day role



                                                                                                                     49
15. Increase the number of qualified reproductive and sexual health nurses able to work flexibly in young people’s
    settings.
16. Rationalise, merge or cluster Family Planning /primary care services which are inefficient or lack resilience and
    consolidate provision in areas of highest need.
17. Ensure that all staff working in Specialist FP clinics are trained to deliver specialist FP care


3.8 Workforce training, policies and guidance
Delay




                                                                                                                  50
   5. Acknowledgements

Prepared by Sarah Farmer and Christiane Moron

With contributions from:

Angela Collard
Akhtar Chowdry
Richard Wilson
Dr Jacky Chambers
Dr Michael Caley
Niall Crawford
Andrew Cooper
Nicky Martin
Becky Crampton
Jan Norton
Mandy Tyler
Helen Davis
Suzanne King
West Midlands Perinatal Institute
Birmingham and Solihull Connexions




                                                51
52

				
DOCUMENT INFO
Shared By:
Categories:
Tags:
Stats:
views:16
posted:9/22/2011
language:English
pages:52