Docstoc

SUMMARY OF 193rd MEETING OF SRC NCTE th 198 Meeting

Document Sample
SUMMARY OF 193rd MEETING OF SRC NCTE th 198 Meeting Powered By Docstoc
					                                                                              th
                                                                         198 Meeting of SRC
                                                                         th h
                                                                      24 -26 November 2010




                 SOUTHERN REGIONAL COMMITTEE
                          BANGALORE

                  Minutes of the 198h Meeting of SRC held at the
       Conference Hall of NCTE, Bangalore from 24th-26th November, 2010



                          The following members attended the Meeting:-

            1.     Prof. C. Thangamuthu         -    Chairman

            2.     Prof. C.L. Anand             -    Member

            3.     Prof. C. Seshadri            -    Member

            4.     Prof. P.J. Poulose           -    Member

            5.     Prof.C.H.Vijayalakshmi       -    Member

            6.     Prof. Sudhakar.              -    Member

            7.     G.Arockiya Samy (TN)         -    Representative
                   Joint Director

            8.     Sri. Gangadharaiah           -    Convenor



                   The following members could not attend the Meeting :-


      Prof. Syeda Akthar, Member & Representatives of the State Governments of Karnataka,
      Andhra Pradesh, Kerala, and U.T‟s of Lakshadweep, Pondicherry & Andaman & NICO
      bar Islands




                                            1

  (Gangadharaiah)                                               (Prof. C. Thangamuthu)
Regional Director, SRC, NCTE                                    Chairman, SRC, NCTE
                                                                                                th
                                                                                            198 Meeting of SRC
                                                                                           th  h
                                                                                         24 -26 November 2010




      Sl.                      Brief Description                         Remarks of SRC
      No.
      1.        Confirmation of Minutes of 197th meeting                     Confirmed
                                   th   th
                      held on 13 -14 October 2010

      2.       Action Taken Report (ATR) on the Minutes                        Noted
                          th                         th   th
                of 196 Meeting of SRC held on 15 -16
                               September 2010


       Inspection Report –Shifting Cases:

Sl.           Code                                                 Remarks of SRC
No.          Course
           Name of the
            institution
              State
3.          APS02774             SRC-NCTE granted recognition on 28.10.2004 for D.T.Ed course with an
             D.T.Ed              intake of 100 students from the academic session 2005-2006 in respect of
                                 Venkateshwara Teacher Training Institute, 10-A, Maraimalai Adigal Salai,
       Venkateshwara             Pondicherry-600501.
      Teacher Training
                                 NCTE-Hqrs. has forwarded inspection report under Section 13 of the NCTE
             Institute,
                                 Act, inspection was caused in respect of Venkateshwara Teacher Training
            Puducherry           Institute on 20.4.2009. It is observed from the inspection report that the
                PO               institution shifted to its new premises without its inspection by the SRC and
                                 without payment of the requisite fee by the institution. Moreover, even in the
                                 new building the multipurpose hall is smaller in size. Further, the library is not
                                 equipped with books and seating capacity in accordance with the norms of the
                                 NCTE. It is also not clear whether salaries to the staff are being paid through
                                 bank. It is requested to issue show cause notice to the institution for violation
                                 of the regulations and norms of NCTE, under intimation to us.

                                 The Extract of the overall assessment of the institution is as follows:

                                 “The institution has been shifted to the present campus “Radhaboobalan
                                 Educational Campus, J.J. Nagar Extn. Moolakulam, Puducherry” in the
                                 beginning of the academic year 2009-2010 under intimation to the NCTE
                                                               2

         (Gangadharaiah)                                                          (Prof. C. Thangamuthu)
       Regional Director, SRC, NCTE                                               Chairman, SRC, NCTE
                                                                                      th
                                                                                  198 Meeting of SRC
                                                                                 th  h
                                                                               24 -26 November 2010

                      dated 4th July, 2008 (Lr. No. VETRI/TTI-074/2008 dated 04.7.2008). Two
                      institutions viz. Venkateswara College of Education and Venkateswara
                      Teacher Training Institute are functioning in the same campus. The college of
                      education is housed in the ground floor and the teacher training institute in the
                      first floor. Except the playground, all other facilities are available for the
                      institutions separately. The infrastructural facilities and academic facilities
                      available for the training institute are satisfactory. The institution is functioning
                      properly”.

                      The institution submitted inspection fee on 14.7.2008 for causing inspection for
                      shifting of premises. Thereafter on 26.5.2009 a letter was written to the
                      institution calling for land documents, FDRs. No reply has been received from
                      the institution so far.

                      SRC in its 184th meeting held on 26-27 October 2009 has decided to cause inspection
                      under Section 17 of NCTE Act, on submission of all related documents including filled
                      in Questionnaire.

                      Accordingly, inspection was carried out on 14.10.2010.

                      The Committee considered the VT Report and all the relevant documentary
                      evidences and it was decided to serve Show cause Notice Under Section 17 of
                      NCTE Act for the following -

                         The latest Building Completion Certificate from the competent Government
                          Engineer is not submitted.

                         Non- Encumbrance Certificate from the competent Government Authorised
                          person / Authorities to be submitted.

                          The Affidavit on Rs. 100/- stamp paper in the prescribed format with notary
                           attestation to be submitted.

                          Fixed deposits in joint names towards Endowment fund & Reserve fund
                           from a Nationalised Bank are to be produced.


                      In view of the above, the Committee decided to issue a Showcause Notice to
                      the institution as to why the recognition be not withdrawn and thereby
                      providing an opportunity to the institution to make a written representation
                      within 30 days from the date of issue of the Notice along with necessary
                      certificates/documents in order to take a final decision in the matter; failing
                      which action will be taken including the withdrawal, based on the records
                      available with no further notice.

4.    APS02936        Venkateswara Teacher Training Institute, Kalitheerthalkuppam, Mannadipet
                      Commune, Pondicherry-605107 had submitted an application to the Southern
         B.Ed
                      Regional Committee for grant of recognition for Elementary (D.T.Ed) course of Two
                                                  3

       (Gangadharaiah)                                                   (Prof. C. Thangamuthu)
     Regional Director, SRC, NCTE                                        Chairman, SRC, NCTE
                                                                                         th
                                                                                     198 Meeting of SRC
                                                                                    th  h
                                                                                  24 -26 November 2010

     Venkateshwara      years duration on 31.12.2003.
        College of
                        The institution has been granted recognition by SRC for offering D.T.Ed course with
       Education,       an intake of 50 students vide order dated 21.11.2005.
       Puducherry
                        The institution in its letter dated 01.10.2009 has submitted a proposal for shifting of
           PO           premises along with Rs.40000/- towards shifting fee.

                        Accordingly, inspection was carried out on 14.10.2010.

                        The Committee considered the VT Report, VCD and all the relevant
                        documentary evidences and it was decided to serve Showcause Notice Under
                        Section 17 of NCTE Act for the following -

                           The latest Building Completion Certificate for the new building from the
                            competent Government Engineer has not been submitted.

                           Non-Encumbrance Certificate from the competent Government Authorised
                            person / Authorities is to be submitted.

                            Fixed deposits in joint names towards Endowment fund & Reserve fund
                             from a Nationalised Bank are to be produced.


                        In view of the above, the Committee decided to issue a Showcause Notice to
                        the institution as to why the recognition be not withdrawn and thereby
                        providing an opportunity to the institution to make a written representation
                        within 30 days from the date of issue of the Notice along with necessary
                        certificates/documents in order to take a final decision in the matter; failing
                        which action will be taken including the withdrawal, based on the records
                        available, with no further notice.

5.     APS02963         Alpha College of Education, No. 4, Candappa Mudali Street, Pondicherry-1 has
                        submitted an application for seeking grant of recognition for B.Ed course on 3.2.2004.
          B.Ed
     Alpha College of   The application was processed, inspection was carried out and notices issued.
                        Finally SRC granted recognition for B.Ed course on 3.9.2005 with an intake of 100
       Education,
                        from the session 2005-06.
       Puducherry
                        SRC received a complaint dated 9.7.2009 from President Venkateswara Training
           PO
                        Institute of Vetri Coaching Centre, Raka Boobalan Educational Campus, J.J. Nagar
                        Extention, Moolakulam, Reddiarpalayam, Puducherry-605010 pertaining to Alpha
                        College of Education, Alpha Educational Campus, Bahour, Puducherry stating that
                        the B.Ed college is housed in a building where D.T.Ed course is also being run.
                        Alpha college through its advertisements(copy not enclosed by complainant) has
                        been giving different addresses as its permanent location.

                        The complainant, Venkateswara Training Institute of Vetri coaching centre preferred
                        writ petition no. 13153/2009 in the High court of Judicature at Chennai raising the
                                                     4

        (Gangadharaiah)                                                     (Prof. C. Thangamuthu)
      Regional Director, SRC, NCTE                                          Chairman, SRC, NCTE
                                                                                       th
                                                                                   198 Meeting of SRC
                                                                                  th  h
                                                                                24 -26 November 2010

                      same issues and also stating that Alpha College is also running the school in the
                      same building. The copy of writ petition is forwarded by our legal counsel. The
                      Venkateswara Training Institute is also parallely running D.T.Ed course and feels
                      adversely affected by misleading action of Alpha college.

                      The matter was placed before SRC in its 181st meeting held on 20-21st August, 2009
                      and SRC decided to call for the following documents for causing inspection for
                      shifting of premises.

                            Demand Draft of Rs. 40,000/- towards inspection fee in favour of “The
                             Member Secretary, NCTE” payable at Bangalore should be submitted.
                            Land documents of the new building/location for having own land in the name
                             of the institution/society/trust.
                            Building plan of the new building duly approved by the Government Authority.
                            Building completion certificate from the Government authorities in the
                             prescribed format.
                            Land usage certificate from concerned Government authorities stating that the
                             land is exclusively permitted/sanctioned for Educational purposes only should
                             be submitted.
                            Encumbrance certificate from the competent Government should be
                             submitted.
                            Fixed deposit of Rs. 5 lakhs towards Endowment fund and Rs. 3 lakhs
                             towards Reserve fund kept in joint account for a period of 5 years in original
                             should be submitted.
                            Certificate of Registration/bye-law of the society/trust should be submitted.
                            The affidavit in Rs. 100/- stamp paper in the prescribed format with notary
                             attestation should be submitted.

                      Accordingly, a letter was issued to the institution on 4.9.2009. The institution has
                      submitted reply on 16.9.2009.

                      The Committee considered the matter in its 185th meeting held on 26-27 November
                      2010 and decided to conduct inspection for shifting as well as for Complaint

                      According inspection was carried out on 15.10.2010.

                      The Committee considered the VT report,VCD of the institution, VCD and all
                      other related documents along with the original file of the institution for shifting
                      to new/permanent premises. The committee decided to permit for running B.Ed
                      programme in the new premises. And no further action is warranted on the
                      complaint.

6.    APS01340        Nehru Teacher Training College No.27, Gandhi Street, Kathirkamam, Pondicherry.
                      has submitted application for offering D.T.Ed course on 30.12.2003. The institution
      APS02964
                      has been granted recognition by SRC for offering D.T.Ed course with an intake of 100
       D.T.Ed
                      students vide order dated 21.11.2005
         B.Ed         The institution in its letter dated 12.06.2009 has submitted a proposal for shifting of
     Nehru Teacher    premises along with Rs.40,000/- towards shifting fee.
                      Accordingly, inspection was carried out on16th October 2010. The inspection report
                                                   5

       (Gangadharaiah)                                                    (Prof. C. Thangamuthu)
     Regional Director, SRC, NCTE                                         Chairman, SRC, NCTE
                                                                                          th
                                                                                      198 Meeting of SRC
                                                                                     th  h
                                                                                   24 -26 November 2010

     Training College,   has been received along with VCD.
       Puducherry
                         The Committee considered the VT Report, VCD and all the relevant
           PO            documentary evidences and it was decided to serve Show cause Notice Under
                         Section 17 of NCTE Act for the following :

                            The institute has not submitted the approved Building plan from a
                             competent Govt. authority.

                            The latest Building Completion Certificate for the new building from the
                             competent Government Engineer has not submitted.

                            Non-Encumberance Certificate from the competent Government Authorised
                             person / Authorities to be submitted.


                         In view of the above, the Committee decided to issue a Showcause Notice to
                         the institution as to why the recognition be not withdrawn and thereby
                         providing an opportunity to the institution to make a written representation
                         within 30 days from the date of issue of the Notice along with necessary
                         certificates/documents in order to take a final decision in the matter; failing
                         which action will be taken including the withdrawal, based on the records
                         available, with no further notice.

7.      APS01894         SDM Trust‟s B.Ed College, Jamkhandi, Terdal-587315, Karnataka has submitted
                         application for offering B.Ed course on 31.12.2003. The institution has been granted
           B.Ed
                         recognition by SRC for offering B.Ed course with an intake of 100 students vide order
     SDM Trust‟s B.Ed    dated 01.12.2004.
     College, Bagalkot   The institution in its letter dated 12.10.2007 has submitted a proposal for shifting of
                         premises along with Rs.40,000/- towards shifting fee.
            KA
                         Inspection was carried out on 16th October 2010. The inspection report has been
                         received along with VCD. The details of the visiting team report is attached:
                         The Committee considered the VT Report,VCD and all the relevant documentary
                         evidences and it was decided to serve Show cause Notice Under Section 17 of
                         NCTE Act for the following :

                             The management is running a Hospital in the ground floor and B.Ed
                             programme in the I & II floor of the same building, which is against the
                             NCTE norms. This serious violation of NCTE norms cannot be condoned,
                             even if the under-mentioned deficiencies are rectified.

                             The Survey Nos are not shown in the lease agreement for the new
                             premises.

                             The Affidavit in Rs.100/- stamp paper in the prescribed format with notary
                             attestation to be submitted.


                                                      6

        (Gangadharaiah)                                                      (Prof. C. Thangamuthu)
      Regional Director, SRC, NCTE                                           Chairman, SRC, NCTE
                                                                                                th
                                                                                           198 Meeting of SRC
                                                                                           th h
                                                                                        24 -26 November 2010

                                The institute has not submitted the Land useage certificate from a
                                competent Govt. authority

                               The latest Building Completion Certificate from the competent Government
                                Engineer has not been submitted.

                               Non-Encumbrance Certificate from the competent Government Authorised
                                person / Authorities to be submitted.

                               The facility for language learning lab is not available.

                            In view of the above, the Committee decided to issue a Showcause Notice to
                            the institution as to why the recognition be not withdrawn and thereby
                            providing an opportunity to the institution to make a written representation
                            within 30 days from the date of issue of the Notice along with necessary
                            certificates/documents in order to take a final decision in the matter; failing
                            which action will be taken including the withdrawal, based on the records
                            available, with no further notice.

8.       APS03745           Siddartha College of Education, Kale Complex, Bus Stand Road, Jamkhandi,
            B.Ed            Bagalkot District, Karnataka has submitted application for offering B.Ed course on
     Siddartha College of   30.12.2004. The institution has been granted recognition by SRC for offering D.Ed
     Education, Bagalkot    course with an intake of 100 students vide order dated 26.12.2005.
                            The institution in its letter dated 06.10.2009 has submitted a proposal for shifting of
             KA             premises along with Rs.40,000/- towards shifting fee.
                            The inspection was carried out on 17th October 2010. The inspection report has been
                            received along with VCD.

                            The Committee considered the VT Report, VCD and all the relevant
                            documentary evidences and it was decided to serve Show cause Notice Under
                            Section 17 of NCTE Act for the following :

                             The Institution was granted recognition in temporary premises to run B.Ed
                              course on 26.12.2005 with a condition that it should shift to its own
                              permanent premises in 3 years. i.e., on or before 25.12.2008. The Institution is
                              still running in temporary premises and not shifted to new premises even
                              after a lapse of stipulated 3 years i.e., after lapse of of more than 4 years and
                              11 months now.

                             As per VT report and VCD, the building is still in the initial stage of
                              construction only.

                             Land documents with survey Nos of the land where the institution is to be
                              shifted are not submitted.

                            In view of the above, the Committee decided to issue a Showcause Notice to
                            the institution as to why the recognition be not withdrawn and thereby
                                                          7

          (Gangadharaiah)                                                         (Prof. C. Thangamuthu)
        Regional Director, SRC, NCTE                                              Chairman, SRC, NCTE
                                                                                              th
                                                                                         198 Meeting of SRC
                                                                                         th h
                                                                                      24 -26 November 2010

                          providing an opportunity to the institution to make a written representation
                          within 30 days from the date of issue of the Notice along with necessary
                          certificates/documents in order to take a final decision in the matter; failing
                          which action will be taken including the withdrawal, based on the records
                          available, with no further notice.

9.       APS02409         Sri Sadashiva B.Ed College, Lokapura Road, Ballur-Muthod Taluk, Bagalkot District,
           B.Ed           Karnataka has submitted application for offering B.Ed course vide order dated
     Sri Sadashiva B.Ed   31.12.2003. The institution has been granted recognition by SRC for offering B.Ed
     College, Bagalkot    course with an intake of 100 students vide order dated 03.02.2006.
            KA            The institution in its letter dated 01.10.2009 has submitted a proposal for shifting of
                          premises along with Rs.40,000/- towards shifting fee.
                          Accordingly, inspection was carried out on 17th October 2010. The inspection report
                          has been received along with VCD

                          The Committee considered the VT Report, VCD and all the relevant
                          documentary evidences and it was decided to serve Show cause Notice Under
                          Section 17 of NCTE Act for the following:

                             The Institution was granted recognition in a temporary premises to run B.Ed
                              course on 03.02.2006 with a condition that it should shift to its own
                              permanent premises in 3 years. i.e., on or before 02.02.2009. The Institution
                              is still running in temporary premises and not shifted to new premises even
                              after a lapse of stipulated 3 years and i.e., after more than 4 years and 6
                              months now.

                             As per the VT report, VCD and all the relevant documents, it is clear that the
                              building is incomplete and The institution is running the B.Ed. programme
                              in a building which is partly roofed with asbestos sheets, which is against
                              the NCTE Norms.

                             The institution is situated in a prime centre of industrial area which is not
                              suitable to run the teacher educational programmes.

                              The institute has not submitted the Land useage certificate from a
                              competent Govt. approved authority

                             Non-Encumbrance Certificate from the competent Government Authorised
                              person / Authorities is to be submitted.

                             Certified copy of the registered land documents issued by the competent
                              authority is not submitted.

                          In view of the above, the Committee decided to issue a Showcause Notice to
                          the institution as to why the recognition be not withdrawn and thereby
                          providing an opportunity to the institution to make a written representation
                          within 30 days from the date of issue of the Notice along with necessary
                                                        8

         (Gangadharaiah)                                                        (Prof. C. Thangamuthu)
       Regional Director, SRC, NCTE                                             Chairman, SRC, NCTE
                                                                                        th
                                                                                    198 Meeting of SRC
                                                                                   th  h
                                                                                 24 -26 November 2010

                          certificates/documents in order to take a final decision in the matter; failing
                          which action will be taken including the withdrawal, based on the records
                          available, with no further notice.

10.      APS01128         PDR Vellachiammal College of Education, Dharmapuri submitted an
            B.Ed          application for grant of recognition for B.Ed course on 30.12.2002.
      PDR Vellachiammal   Recognition order to was issued to the institution on 09.09.2004 at PDR
          College of      Vellachiammal College of Education, Sekkampatti, Soriampatti-636902,
         Education,       Dharmapuri, Tamilnadu with the condition to shift to own premises within 3
                          years.
         Dharmapuri
             TN           The institution vide letter dated 29.10.2007 submitted Rs.40000/- the
                          institution in its reply has stated that they would like to continue in the present
                          premises which was used for the last three years as it fulfills the stipulation of
                          the new regulation, norms & standards.

                          The inspection was carried out on 18.10.2010.

                          The Committee considered the VT Report and all the relevant documentary
                          evidences and it was decided to serve Show cause Notice Under Section 17 of
                          NCTE Act for the following :

                             The management is running Two Teacher Training Institutions in the same
                              building, and no earmarked built up area for each of the course/programme.
                              The total built up area is 20621 sq.ft, which is inadequate for both B.Ed and
                              D.T.Ed Teacher Education Programmes as per NCTE norms. A total built up
                              area of 27,000 Sq.ft is required for both B.Ed and D.T.Ed.

                             No exclusive Land and Building has been exclusively earmarked for each
                              Teacher Education Programme and for other programmes.

                             No clear / exclusive earmarking of built up area there for each of the
                              programmes being run in the same premises. A School is also functioning
                              in the same building/premises, which is against the NCTE norms.


                             To submit the documents for having deposited the Endowment Fund and
                              Reserve fund of Rs. 5 lakhs and 3 lakhs respectively for each course
                              separately.

                             The latest Building Completion Certificate from the competent Government
                              Engineer has not been submitted in the proper format.

                          In view of the above, the Committee decided to issue a Showcause Notice to
                          the institution as to why the recognition be not withdrawn and thereby
                          providing an opportunity to the institution to make a written representation
                          within 30 days from the date of issue of the Notice along with necessary
                                                     9

          (Gangadharaiah)                                                  (Prof. C. Thangamuthu)
        Regional Director, SRC, NCTE                                       Chairman, SRC, NCTE
                                                                                               th
                                                                                          198 Meeting of SRC
                                                                                          th h
                                                                                       24 -26 November 2010

                           certificates/documents in order to take a final decision in the matter; failing
                           which action will be taken including the withdrawal, based on the records
                           available, with no further notice.

11.       APS01597         Anjuman Urdu D.Ed College, Alampur Peth-Ikal (PO), Hungund Taluk, Bagalkot
                           District, Karnataka has submitted application for offering D.Ed course on 26.12.2003.
             D.Ed
                           The institution has been granted recognition by SRC for offering D.Ed course with an
      Anjuman Urdu D.Ed    intake of 50 students vide order dated 30.11.2004.
       College, Bagalkot   The institution in its letter dated 11.10.2007 has submitted a proposal for shifting of
                           premises along with Rs.40,000/- towards shifting fee.
              KA
                           Accordingly, inspection was carried out on 19th October 2010. The inspection report
                           has been received along with VCD. The details of the visiting team report is attached:
                           The Committee considered the VT Report,VCD and all the relevant documentary
                           evidences and it was decided to serve Show cause Notice Under Section 17 of
                           NCTE Act for the following :
                              The Built up area as per VT report is only 5600 Sq.ft for D.Ed. (Urdu)
                               course, which is inadequate. As per the NCTE Norms, 11,000 Sq ft. built up
                               area is required.

                               The institute has not submitted the Land useage certificate from a
                               competent Govt. approved authority

                              The latest Building Completion Certificate from the competent Government
                               Engineer has not been submitted.

                              Non-Encumbrance Certificate from the competent Government Authorised
                               person / Authority. To be submitted.

                              Language learning lab is not available.

                              Affidavit on Rs. 100/- is to be submitted.

                              FDRs for Rs. 3.00 lakhs and 5.00 lakhs in joint names from a Natrionalised
                               Bank are to be produced.

                              Land documents in English version clearly mentioning the Address, Survey
                               Nos etc., are to be submitted.

                           In view of the above, the Committee decided to issue a Showcause Notice to
                           the institution as to why the recognition be not withdrawn and thereby
                           providing an opportunity to the institution to make a written representation
                           within 30 days from the date of issue of the Notice along with necessary
                           certificates/documents in order to take a final decision in the matter; failing
                           which action will be taken including the withdrawal, based on the records
                           available, with no further notice.


                                                        10

          (Gangadharaiah)                                                        (Prof. C. Thangamuthu)
        Regional Director, SRC, NCTE                                             Chairman, SRC, NCTE
                                                                                              th
                                                                                         198 Meeting of SRC
                                                                                         th h
                                                                                      24 -26 November 2010

12.      APS5006          Shree   Sakthi Teacher Training Institute, Dharmapuri submitted an
           D.T.Ed         application for grant of recognition for D.T.Ed course on 28.12.2005.
       Shree Shakthi      Recognition order was issued to the institution on 9/01/2007. Sri Shakthi
      Teacher Training    Teacher Training Institute, Nallanahalli Village, Kuppur Post, Dharmapuri-
          Institute,      636704, Tamilnadu with the condition to shift to own premises within 3 years.
        Dharmapuri        The institution vide letter dated 22.09.2009 submitted Rs.40000/- towards shifting
             TN           fee.

                          The inspection was carried out on 19.10.2010.

                          The Committee considered the VT Report,VCD and all the relevant documentary
                          evidences and it was decided to serve Show cause Notice Under Section 17 of
                          NCTE Act for the following.

                              As per the VT report, different building is located in different survey Nos in
                               locations other than the one originally proposed.

                              The management is running D.T.Ed programme along with D.T.Ed-Al
                              course. The total built up area as per VT report for both D.T.Ed & D.T.Ed-Al
                              programme is 10021 Sq.ft. which is inadequate. As per the NCTE norms,
                              16,000 Sq.ft. built up area is required for both D.T.Ed and D.T.Ed Additional
                              Units.

                              The latest Building Completion Certificate from the competent Government
                               Engineer has not been submitted.

                              Language learning lab is not available.

                          In view of the above, the Committee decided to issue a Showcause Notice to
                          the institution as to why the recognition be not withdrawn and thereby
                          providing an opportunity to the institution to make a written representation
                          within 30 days from the date of issue of the Notice along with necessary
                          certificates/documents in order to take a final decision in the matter; failing
                          which action will be taken including the withdrawal, based on the records
                          available, with no further notice.

13.      APS01911         Sri Kalidasa D.Ed College, Banasanakari Road, Badami- 587901, Bagalkot District,
                          Karnataka has submitted application for offering D.Ed course on 21.12.2003. The
            D.Ed
                          institution has been granted recognition by SRC for offering D.Ed course with an
      Sri Kalidasa D.Ed   intake of 50 students vide order dated 23.12.2004.
      College, Bagalkot   The institution in its letter dated 21.09.2007 has submitted a proposal for shifting of
                          premises along with Rs.40,000/- towards shifting fee.
             KA
                          Inspection was carried out on 18th October 2010. The inspection report has been
                          received along with VCD. The details of the visiting team report is attached:

                                                       11

         (Gangadharaiah)                                                        (Prof. C. Thangamuthu)
       Regional Director, SRC, NCTE                                             Chairman, SRC, NCTE
                                                                                               th
                                                                                          198 Meeting of SRC
                                                                                          th h
                                                                                       24 -26 November 2010

                           The Committee considered the VT Report, VCD and all the relevant
                           documentary evidences and it was decided to serve Show cause Notice Under
                           Section 17 of NCTE Act for the following.

                              Certified copy of the registered land documents in English issued by the
                               competent authority to be submitted.

                               The Affidavit in Rs.100/-stamp paper in the prescribed format with notary
                                attestation to be submitted.

                               Certificate of Registration / Bye-Laws of the Society are to be submitted by
                                the management.

                               Psychology lab, Language lab needs to be strengthen & Language
                                learning lab is not available.

                           In view of the above, the Committee decided to issue a Showcause Notice to
                           the institution as to why the recognition be not withdrawn and thereby
                           providing an opportunity to the institution to make a written representation
                           within 30 days from the date of issue of the Notice along with necessary
                           certificates/documents in order to take a final decision in the matter; failing
                           which action will be taken including the withdrawal, based on the records
                           available, with no further notice.

14.       APS03774         Sabari College of Education, 76/2 Madagadipet Main Road Kariamanickam,
                           Puducherry has submitted application for offering B.Ed course on 21.12.2004. The
             B.Ed
                           institution has been granted recognition by SRC for offering D.Ed course with an
       Sabari College of   intake of 100 students vide order dated 10.11.2005
          Education,
                           The institution in its letter dated 06.10.2009 has submitted a proposal for shifting of
         Puducherry
                           premises along with Rs.40,000/- towards shifting fee.
             PO
                           Accordingly, inspection was carried out on 20th October 2010. The inspection report
                           has been received along with VCD.

                           The Committee considered the VT report of the institution, VCD and other
                           related documents along with the original file of the institution for shifting to
                           new/permanent premises. The committee decided to permit shifting of B.Ed
                           course.

                           Shifting fee of Rs. 40,000/- to be paid by the management for shifting of M.Ed
                           programme to the new premises.

15.       APS04363         Annai Sonia Gandhi Teacher Training Institute had submitted an application to SRC-
                           NCTE for B.Ed course during 2005. The application was processed and the
             B.Ed
                           inspection was conducted on 19.8.2005. The visiting team report was placed before
      Annai Sonia Gandhi   SRC in its 100th meeting held on 23rd and 24th September, 2005. The Committee
                           decided to accord recognition to the institution from the academic session 2005-06
       Teacher Training
                           (15.10.200) with an intake of 50 students with some stipulated conditions. One of the
                                                        12

          (Gangadharaiah)                                                        (Prof. C. Thangamuthu)
        Regional Director, SRC, NCTE                                             Chairman, SRC, NCTE
                                                                                    th
                                                                                198 Meeting of SRC
                                                                               th  h
                                                                             24 -26 November 2010

  Institute,     condition is the institution will ensure that the permanent building is constructed within
                 a period of 3 years on the acquired land.
 Puducherry
     PO          The institution also submitted application for D.T.Ed-additional intake on 26.12.2005.
                 The application was processed and the inspection of the institution was carried out on
                 29.10.2006. The visiting team report, VCD and other essential documents were
                 placed before SRC in its 120th meeting held on 3rd and 4th November, 2006. The
                 committee decided to accord recognition for an additional intake of 50 students in the
                 existing D.T.Ed course thus making the total intake of 100 students. Accordingly, a
                 recognition order was issued to the institution on 8.11.2006.

                 The institution on their own submitted written representation dated 21.4.2009 with
                 regard to shifting of college premises from temporary to permanent building along
                 with D.D. of Rs. 40,000/-. The institution was asked to submit the following
                 documents:-
                     1. Land documents of the new building / location for having own land in the name
                        of the institution / Society / Trust.
                     2. Building plan of the new building duly approved by the Government authority.
                     3. Building Completion Certificate from the Government authorities in the
                        prescribed format (Format enclosed)
                     4. Land Usage Certificate from the concerned Government authorities stating
                        that the land is exclusively permitted / sanctioned for Educational Purposes
                        only should be submitted.
                     5. Encumbrance certificate from the competent Government should be
                        submitted.
                     6. Fixed Deposit Receipt of Rs.5 lakhs kept in JOINT ACCOUNT with SRC in
                        Nationalised Bank for a period of 5 years towards Endowment Fund in
                        ORIGINAL should be submitted.
                     7. Fixed Deposit Receipt of Rs.3 lakhs kept in JOINT ACCOUNT with SRC in
                        Nationalised Bank for a period of 5 years towards Reserve Fund in ORIGINAL
                        should be submitted.
                     8. Certificate of Registration / Bye-law of the Society / Trust should be submitted.
                     9. The Affidavit in Rs.100/- stamp paper in the prescribed format with Notary
                        attestation should be submitted. (FORMAT ENCLOSED)

                 Meantime, NCTE-Hqrs. has forwarded inspection report which was conducted on
                 21.4.2009 in respect of Annai Sonia Gandhi Teacher Training Institute, Palayam
                 Road, Nallur, Pondicherry.

                 The Council has noticed from the inspection report submitted by the inspection team
                 that the institution is not running the course in accordance with the existing norms and
                 standards of the NCTE. The Council, has, therefore, decided that the inspection
                 report may be forwarded to SRC, NCTE, Bangalore to initiate action against the
                 institution under Section 17 of the NCTE Act. The matter in the inspection report is
                 produced as follows;

                 “The institution run by Sri Venkateswara Education and Charitable Trust has been
                 shifted to the present address… Palayam Road, Nallur(via), Puducherry-605107 from
                 the previous address no. 5 Madukarai Main Road, Kakikalampakkam, Puducherry-
                                              13

  (Gangadharaiah)                                                      (Prof. C. Thangamuthu)
Regional Director, SRC, NCTE                                           Chairman, SRC, NCTE
                                                                                            th
                                                                                        198 Meeting of SRC
                                                                                       th  h
                                                                                     24 -26 November 2010

                       605007. The trust has not informed about the shifting of the institute to the SRC duly
                       and has not followed the regulatory formalities of change of premises as stipulated by
                       NCTE without getting the competition certificate from the Puducherry Planning
                       Authority, the trust has occupied the present premises and the admissions for the
                       current academic year 2009-2010 have been made and the classes started. About 10
                       percent of the civil works have not been completed as on date of visit. The following
                       incompletion of works have been observed:-
                        Compound walls/fence have not been erected,
                        The land is not leveled for playground and
                        Laboratory facilities are insufficient and ill-equipped”.

                       SRC considered the above matter in its 184th meeting and it has been decided to
                       cause inspection under Section 17 based on the report of inspection conducted under
                       Section 13 by the NCTE, HQ

                       Accordingly inspection was carried out on 20.10.2010.

                       The Committee considered the VT Report,VCD and all the relevant documentary
                       evidences and it was decided to serve Show cause Notice Under Section 17 of
                       NCTE Act for the following.


                          The total Built up area earmarked for both D.T.Ed and D.T.Ed-Al course is
                           only 655 Sq. mts. which is grossly inadequate. As per NCTE norms, a built
                           up area of 16,000 Sq.ft is required for both DTEd and DETd Additional Units.

                          Building plan is not submitted.

                          Building completion certificate from the authorized Government engineer is
                           not clear.

                          Educational Technology Lab, Library facilities and other Labs, Physical
                           education, facilities needs to be strengthened.

                          The institution has not got the prior permission for shifting to the
                           permanent premises and not paid the prescribed inspection fee of Rs.
                           40,000 for shifting.

                       In view of the above, the Committee decided to issue a Showcause Notice to
                       the institution as to why the recognition be not withdrawn and thereby
                       providing an opportunity to the institution to make a written representation
                       within 30 days from the date of issue of the Notice along with necessary
                       certificates/documents in order to take a final decision in the matter; failing
                       which action will be taken including the withdrawal, based on the records
                       available, with no further notice.

16.    APS01124        Vedasandur Rajathiammal & Rengaswamy Chettiar Trust, J.K. Teacher Training
                       Institute Dindigul, Tamilnadu was granted recognition for offering D.T.Ed course with

                                                    14

        (Gangadharaiah)                                                      (Prof. C. Thangamuthu)
      Regional Director, SRC, NCTE                                           Chairman, SRC, NCTE
                                                                                        th
                                                                                    198 Meeting of SRC
                                                                                   th  h
                                                                                 24 -26 November 2010

     D.T.Ed           an intake of 50 students on 24.10.2006 with the condition to shift to own premises
                      within 3 years and D.T.Ed-AI with an intake of 50 students on 22.06.2007.
  J.K. Teacher
Training Institute,   Recognition order to was issued to the institution at 4/360, J.K. Nagar, Dindigul-
                      624001, Tamilnadu.
     Dindigul
       TN             The institution vide letter dated 20.10.2008 submitted Rs. 40000/- towards shifting
                      fee.

                      As per decision of SRC in its 175th meeting held on 13th-14th May 2009, the office of
                      SRC has reviewed the files of the institution who have been granted recognition either
                      in a rented premises pending construction of own building or in lease premises. A list
                      of such institutions has been prepared and placed before SRC in its 181st meeting
                      held on 20th-21st August 2009 wherein, it was decided that the institution which have
                      not shifted to the permanent premises even after the expiry of three years time limit
                      be issued notice under Section 17 of NCTE Act for further action.

                      Accordingly a notice was issued to the institution on 23.07.2010. The institution
                      submitted its reply on 31.08.2010 alongwith photocopies of certain documents.
                      Details regarding infrastructure and instructional facilities submitted in proforma.

                      The SRC considered the reply in its 196th meeting held on 15th-16th September 2010
                      and decided to cause inspection for shifting.

                      The SRC also considered the reply dated 01.09.2010 to notice for B.Ed course of the
                      institution and decided to cause inspection of the institution for shifting. Recognition
                      was granted to the institution for B.Ed course vide order dated 27.07.2007.

                      The inspection was carried out on 20.10.2010.

                      The Committee considered the VT Report and all the relevant documentary
                      evidences and it was decided to serve Show cause Notice Under Section 17 of
                      NCTE Act for the following.

                         The total Built up area available and earmarked for D.T.Ed & D.T.Ed-Al is
                          23621.295 Sq.ft, B.Ed is 23621.295 Sq.ft and for M.Ed is 1082.41 Sq.ft. The
                          earmarked area for M.Ed programme is only 1082.41 Sq. ft. which is grossly
                          inadequate for M.Ed programme as sper NCTE norms. The same is also
                          corroborated by the management in the essential data. As per the norms
                          6000 Sq,ft of built up area is required for M.Ed programme.

                         The building proposed for shifting is incomplete even after the stipulated
                          time period of 3 years and after lapse of time period of more than 5 years.

                         Building completion certificate from the authorized Government engineer is
                          not submitted.

                         Language learning lab is not available.

                                                  15

   (Gangadharaiah)                                                        (Prof. C. Thangamuthu)
 Regional Director, SRC, NCTE                                             Chairman, SRC, NCTE
                                                                                              th
                                                                                          198 Meeting of SRC
                                                                                         th  h
                                                                                       24 -26 November 2010

                               FDRs of Rs. 5.00 Lakhs & 3.00 Lakhs in joint names for each course from a
                                Nationalized Bank is to be submitted.

                               Built up area is not mentioned in the affidavit.

                               The management has not paid Rs. 40000/- towards shifting fee for each
                                course being run.

                               The management has not paid the Inspection fees of Rs. 40,000/- towards
                                each course being run.

                            In view of the above, the Committee decided to issue a Showcause Notice to
                            the institution as to why the recognition be not withdrawn and thereby
                            providing an opportunity to the institution to make a written representation
                            within 30 days from the date of issue of the Notice along with necessary
                            certificates/documents in order to take a final decision in the matter; failing
                            which action will be taken including the withdrawal, based on the records
                            available, with no further notice.

17.      APS05144           Vedasandur Rajathiammal & Rengaswamy Chettiar Trust, J.K. Teacher Training
                            Institute Dindigul, Tamilnadu was granted recognition for offering D.T.Ed course with
          D.T.Ed-AI
                            an intake of 50 students on 20.01.2005 with the condition to shift to own premises
        J.K. Teacher        within 3 years and D.T.Ed-AI with an intake of 50 students on 22.06.2007.
      Training Institute,
                            Recognition order to was issued to the institution at 4/360, J.K. Nagar, Dindigul-
           Dindigul         624001, Tamilnadu.
             TN
                            The institution vide letter dated 20.10.2008 submitted Rs. 40000/- for a proposal for
                            change of premises

                            As per decision of SRC in its 175th meeting held on 13th-14th May 2009, the office of
                            SRC has reviewed the files of the institution who have been granted recognition either
                            in a rented premises pending construction of own building or in lease premises. A list
                            of such institutions has been prepared and placed before SRC in its 181st meeting
                            held on 20th-21st August 2009 wherein, it was decided that the institution which have
                            not shifted to the permanent premises even after the expiry of three years time limit
                            be issued notice under Section 17 of NCTE Act for further action.

                            Accordingly a notice was issued to the institution on 23.07.2010. The institution
                            submitted its reply on 31.08.2010 alongwith photocopies of certain documents.
                            Details regarding infrastructure and instructional facilities submitted in proforma.

                            The SRC considered the reply in its 196th meeting held on 15th-16th September 2010
                            and decided to cause inspection for shifting.

                            The SRC also considered the reply dated 01.09.2010 to notice for B.Ed course of the
                            institution and decided to cause inspection of the institution for shifting. Recognition
                            was granted to the institution for B.Ed course vide order dated 27.07.2007.

                                                        16

         (Gangadharaiah)                                                        (Prof. C. Thangamuthu)
       Regional Director, SRC, NCTE                                             Chairman, SRC, NCTE
                                                                                         th
                                                                                     198 Meeting of SRC
                                                                                    th  h
                                                                                  24 -26 November 2010

                         The inspection was carried on 20.10. 2010

                         The Committee considered the VT Report and all the relevant documentary
                         evidences and it was decided to serve Show cause Notice Under Section 17 of
                         NCTE Act for the following.
                            The total Built up area earmarked for D.T.Ed & D.T.Ed-Al is 23621.295 Sq.ft,
                             B.Ed is 23621.295 Sq.ft and for M.Ed is 1082.41 Sq.ft. The earmarked area
                             for M.Ed programme is only 1082.41 Sq. ft. which is grossly inadequate for
                             M.Ed programme as sper NCTE norms. The same is also corroborated by
                             the management in the essential data.

                            The building proposed for shifting is incomplete even after the stipulated
                             time period of 3 years and after lapse of time period of more than 5 years
                             and 01 month,

                            Building completion certificate from the authorized Government engineer is
                             not submitted.

                            Language learning lab is not available.

                            FDRs of Rs. 5.00 Lakhs & 3.00 Lakhs in joint names for each course from a
                             Nationalized Bank is to be submitted.

                            Built up area is not mentioned in the affidavit.

                            The management has not paid Rs. 40000/- towards shifting fee for each
                             course being run.

                         In view of the above, the Committee decided to issue a Showcause Notice to
                         the institution as to why the recognition be not withdrawn and thereby
                         providing an opportunity to the institution to make a written representation
                         within 30 days from the date of issue of the Notice along with necessary
                         certificates/documents in order to take a final decision in the matter; failing
                         which action will be taken including the withdrawal, based on the records
                         available, with no further notice.

18.     APS04658         Pachamuthu     Teacher     Training            Dharmapuri submitted
                                                                Institute,                                an
          D.T.Ed         application for grant of recognition for D.T.Ed course on 15.02.2005.
        Pachamuthu       Recognition order to was issued to the institution on 24.10.2006 at
      Teacher Training   Pachumuthu Teacher Training Institute, Salem Main Road, Virupatchipuram
         Institute,      Village, Dharmapuri-636705, Tamilnadu with the condition to shift to own
                         premises within 3 years.
        Dharmapuri
            TN           SRC in its 181st meeting held on 20th-21st August 2009 wherein, it was decided
                         that the institution which have not shifted to the permanent premises even
                         after the expiry of three years time limit be issued notice under Section 17 of
                         NCTE Act for further action. Accordingly a notice has been issued to the
                                                    17

         (Gangadharaiah)                                                     (Prof. C. Thangamuthu)
       Regional Director, SRC, NCTE                                          Chairman, SRC, NCTE
                                                                                          th
                                                                                      198 Meeting of SRC
                                                                                     th  h
                                                                                   24 -26 November 2010

                            institution on 11.09.2009.

                            The institution vide letter dated 01.10.2009 submitted Rs.40000/- towards
                            shifting fee.

                            The inspection was carried out on 20.10.2010

                            The Committee considered the VT Report,VCD and all the relevant documentary
                            evidences and it was decided to serve Show cause Notice Under Section 17 of
                            NCTE Act for the following.

                             As per VT report, the management is running B.Ed, D.T.Ed programmes and
                              also running a Higher Secondary School in the same building/premises,
                              which is not permissible as per NCTE norms.

                             On observation from the VCD submitted by the VT members the building
                              construction proposed for shifting is incomplete.

                             Shifting fee of Rs 40,000/- for each course is to be submitted.

                             The Faculty is inadequate for the programmes being run by the management.

                             The No. of Library books in Library is 2000, which is not sufficient.

                             Language learning lab is not available.

                            In view of the above, the Committee decided to issue a Showcause Notice to
                            the institution as to why the recognition be not withdrawn and thereby
                            providing an opportunity to the institution to make a written representation
                            within 30 days from the date of issue of the Notice along with necessary
                            certificates/documents in order to take a final decision in the matter; failing
                            which action will be taken including the withdrawal, based on the records
                            available, with no further notice.

19.      APS01464           Victory Teacher Training Institute, Kambilampatty, Dindigul was granted
           D.T.Ed           recognition to D.T.Ed course on 28.10.2004 for an intake of 50 intake.
      Victory Teacher
      Training Institute,
                            The institution submitted its proposal for shifting alongwith Rs.40000/-.
           Dindigul
                            Inspection of the institution for shifting of premises was conducted on
             TN
                            20.10.2010.
                            The Committee considered the VT Report,VCD and all the relevant documentary
                            evidences and it was decided to serve Show cause Notice Under Section 17 of
                            NCTE Act for the following.

                               Address of Land, certified copy of land use certificate in English is be
                                                         18

         (Gangadharaiah)                                                     (Prof. C. Thangamuthu)
       Regional Director, SRC, NCTE                                          Chairman, SRC, NCTE
                                                                                           th
                                                                                       198 Meeting of SRC
                                                                                      th  h
                                                                                    24 -26 November 2010

                                submitted.

                               The latest Building Completion Certificate from the competent Government
                                Engineer has not been submitted.

                               Non-Encumberance Certificate from the competent Government Authorised
                                person / Authoriies is to be submitted.

                               As per VT report, the management is running D.T.Ed and D.T.Ed-Al courses
                                and shifting fee of Rs. 40,000/- for each course is to be paid.

                            in view of the above, the Committee decided to issue a Showcause Notice to
                            the institution as to why the recognition be not withdrawn and thereby
                            providing an opportunity to the institution to make a written representation
                            within 30 days from the date of issue of the Notice along with necessary
                            certificates/documents in order to take a final decision in the matter; failing
                            which action will be taken including the withdrawal, based on the records
                            available, with no further notice.


20.       APS04653          Pachamuthu College of Education, Dharmapuri submitted an application for
             B.Ed           grant of recognition for B.Ed course on 21.12.2005.
         Pachamuthu         Recognition order to was issued to the institution on 06.10.2006 at
          College of        Pachumuthu College of Education, No.26-C, Salem Main Road,
      Education, Dindigul   Virupatchipuram Village, Dharmapuri-636705, Tamilnadu with the condition to
                            shift to own premises within 3 years.
              TN
                            SRC in its 181st meeting held on 20th-21st August 2009 wherein, it was decided
                            that the institution which have not shifted to the permanent premises even
                            after the expiry of three years time limit be issued notice under Section 17 of
                            NCTE Act for further action. Accordingly a notice has been issued to the
                            institution on 03.09.2009.

                            The institution vide letter dated 28.10.2009 submitted Rs.40000, for shifting to new
                            premises.
                            The inspection was carried out on 21.10.2010

                            The Committee considered the VT Report,VCD and all the relevant documentary
                            evidences and it was decided to serve Show cause Notice Under Section 17 of
                            NCTE Act for the following.

                             On observation from the VCD submitted by the VT members the building
                              construction proposed for shifting is incomplete.

                             As per VT report, the management is running B.Ed, D.T.Ed programmes and
                              also running a Higher Secondary School in the same building/premises,
                                                       19

          (Gangadharaiah)                                                     (Prof. C. Thangamuthu)
        Regional Director, SRC, NCTE                                          Chairman, SRC, NCTE
                                                                                             th
                                                                                         198 Meeting of SRC
                                                                                        th  h
                                                                                      24 -26 November 2010

                              which is not permissible as per NCTE norms.

                             Shifting fee of Rs 40,000/- for each course is to be submitted.

                             The Faculty is inadequate for the programmes being run by the management.

                             The No. of Library books in Library is 2000, which is not sufficient.

                             Language learning lab is not available.

                            in view of the above, the Committee decided to issue a Showcause Notice to
                            the institution as to why the recognition be not withdrawn and thereby
                            providing an opportunity to the institution to make a written representation
                            within 30 days from the date of issue of the Notice along with necessary
                            certificates/documents in order to take a final decision in the matter; failing
                            which action will be taken including the withdrawal, based on the records
                            available, with no further notice.

21.       APS06008          Mother Teresa Women‟s University B.Ed. College, Dindigul, Tamilnadu was accorded
                            recognition for B.Ed. course on 02.9.2006.
             B.Ed
        Mother Teresa       As per the recommendationunitu= of Sri. Sathyam Committee report and based on
                            the Directions of MHRD, re-inspection was conducted to all the institutions which
      Women‟s University
                            were granted recognition in 116th meeting of SRC.
          College of
                            The institution was re-inspected and the VT report along with all documents were
      Education, Dindigul
                            placed before 169th meeting of SRC held during 12-13 January, 2009 wherein it was
              TN            decided to issue Notice under Section 17 of NCTE Act. Accordingly, a Notice was
                            issued to the institution on 6.3.2009. The institution submitted its written
                            representation on 3.4.2009 along with supporting documents.

                            The Committee decided to issue showcause Notice under Section 17 of NCTE Act for
                            providing insufficient infrastructural and instructional facilities at the temporary
                            premises and also for not shifting to permanent / own premises before 29.8.2009.

                            Further, the Committee decided to call the following documents immediately for
                            shifting of premises and causing of inspection. Accordingly notice was issued to the
                            institution on 31.07.2009. The institution submitted its reply on 10.09.2009 along with
                            Rs.40000/-

                            The institution is also running M.Ed programme.

                            The inspection was carried out on 21.10.2010.

                            The Committee considered the VT Report,VCD and all the relevant documentary
                            evidences and it was decided to serve Show cause Notice Under Section 17 of
                            NCTE Act for the following.

                             The management is running the both B.Ed and M.Ed programmes in a tin
                                                        20

          (Gangadharaiah)                                                       (Prof. C. Thangamuthu)
        Regional Director, SRC, NCTE                                            Chairman, SRC, NCTE
                                                                                               th
                                                                                          198 Meeting of SRC
                                                                                          th h
                                                                                       24 -26 November 2010

                             sheet covered roofed building which is against the NCTE norms.

                            The total built up area including common area is 17278 sq.ft only, which is
                             very much inadequate for running both B.Ed and M.Ed courses. As per the
                             norms, 22,000 Sq.ft of built up area is required for both B.Ed & M.Ed.

                           In view of the above, the Committee decided to issue a Showcause Notice to
                           the institution as to why the recognition be not withdrawn and thereby
                           providing an opportunity to the institution to make a written representation
                           within 30 days from the date of issue of the Notice along with necessary
                           certificates/documents in order to take a final decision in the matter; failing
                           which action will be taken including the withdrawal, based on the records
                           available, with no further notice.

22.      APS01928          JSS Institute of Education, Huvina Hadagali, Holagundi Road, Bellary District-583219,
            B.Ed           Karnataka has submitted application for offering B.Ed course on 31.12.2003.The
       JSS Institute of    institution has been granted recognition by SRC for offering B.Ed course with an
      Education, Bellary   intake of 100 students vide order dated 01.12.2004.
             KA            The institution in its letter dated 01.10.2009 has submitted a proposal for shifting of
                           premises along with Rs.40,000/- towards shifting fee.
                           Accordingly, inspection was carried out on 21st October 2010.
                           The Committee considered the VT Report,VCD and all the relevant documentary
                           evidences and it was decided to serve Show cause Notice Under Section 17 of
                           NCTE Act for the following.

                              A public school is also being run in the same building where the B.Ed
                               programme is functioning. This is against the norms of NCTE

                              As per the VT report no exclusive separate building with land is available
                               for the B.Ed course.

                              The latest Building Completion Certificate from the competent Government
                               Engineer has not been submitted.

                              Non-Encumbrance Certificate from the competent Government Authorised
                               person / Authority to be submitted.

                              Certified copy of the registered land documents in English version issued
                               by the competent authority not submitted.

                               Bye-Laws of the Society are to be submitted by the management.

                           In view of the above, the Committee decided to issue a Showcause Notice to
                           the institution as to why the recognition be not withdrawn and thereby
                           providing an opportunity to the institution to make a written representation
                           within 30 days from the date of issue of the Notice along with necessary
                                                        21

          (Gangadharaiah)                                                        (Prof. C. Thangamuthu)
        Regional Director, SRC, NCTE                                             Chairman, SRC, NCTE
                                                                                                 th
                                                                                            198 Meeting of SRC
                                                                                            th h
                                                                                         24 -26 November 2010

                             certificates/documents in order to take a final decision in the matter; failing
                             which action will be taken including the withdrawal, based on the records
                             available, with no further notice.

23.       APS02986           Sabari Institute of Teacher Education ECR-Cuddalore Main Road, Kirumambakkam,
                             Puducherry has submitted application for offering D.T.Ed course on 28.01.2004. The
            D.T.Ed
                             institution has been granted recognition by SRC for offering D.T.Ed course with an
      Sabari Institute of    intake of 100 students vide order dated 02.03.2005
      Teacher Education,
                             The institution in its letter dated 01.10.2009 has submitted a proposal for shifting of
          Puducherry         premises along with Rs.40,000/- towards shifting fee.
              PO             Accordingly, inspection was carried out on 21st October 2010.

                             The Committee considered the VT Report,VCD and all the relevant documentary
                             evidences and it was decided to serve Show cause Notice Under Section 17 of
                             NCTE Act for the following.

                              The management is running the institution for D.T.Ed course and sharing
                              the building with some other programme in the same building, which is
                              against the NCTE norms.

                              Separately earmarked built-up area in an exclusive building for D.T.Ed to be
                              provided.

                              A Certificate from the Government Affiliating body to the effect that no other
                              programme is being run by the institution in the same building / Campus,
                              along with the existing Course D.T.Ed to be submitted.

                             In view of the above, the Committee decided to issue a Showcause Notice to
                             the institution as to why the recognition be not withdrawn and thereby
                             providing an opportunity to the institution to make a written representation
                             within 30 days from the date of issue of the Notice along with necessary
                             certificates/documents in order to take a final decision in the matter; failing
                             which action will be taken including the withdrawal, based on the records
                             available, with no further notice.

24.       APS01145           T.V.R Teacher Training Institute, Mathikrishnapuram, Manapet P.O, Bahour,
                             Commune, Puducherryhas submitted application for offering D.T.Ed course on
            D.T.Ed
                             31.12.2002. The institution has been granted recognition by SRC for offering D.T.Ed
        T.V.R. Teacher       course with an intake of 100 students vide order dated 29.10.2004
       Training Institute,
                             The institution in its letter dated 09.10.2009 has submitted a proposal for shifting of
          Puducherry         premises along with Rs.40,000/- towards shifting fee.
              PO             The institution is also running B.Ed programme in the same building/premises.
                             Accordingly, inspection was carried out on 21 October 2010. The inspection report
                             has been received along with VCD.

                                                          22

          (Gangadharaiah)                                                          (Prof. C. Thangamuthu)
        Regional Director, SRC, NCTE                                               Chairman, SRC, NCTE
                                                                                        th
                                                                                    198 Meeting of SRC
                                                                                   th  h
                                                                                 24 -26 November 2010

                            The Committee considered the VT Report VCD and all the relevant documentary
                            evidences and it was decided to serve Show cause Notice Under Section 17 of
                            NCTE Act for the following.

                             A Certificate from the Government Affiliating body to the effect that no other
                             programme is being run by the institution in the same building / Campus,
                             along with the existing Course D.T.Ed to be submitted.

                             The management has not exclusively earmarked the built up area for the
                             D.T.Ed programme which is being run. As per VT report the built up area
                             shown for D.T.Ed and B.Ed programme is only 3620 sq.ft which is grossly
                             inadequate. As per NCTE norms, a total built up area of 27,000 Sq.ft is
                             required for both B.Ed and D.T.Ed.

                             The latest Building Completion Certificate from the competent Government
                             Engineer has not been submitted.

                             The institute has not submitted the Land useage certificate from a competent
                              Govt. approved authority

                             Education technology lab and Physical education needs to be strengthened.

                            In view of the above, the Committee decided to issue a Showcause Notice to
                            the institution as to why the recognition be not withdrawn and thereby
                            providing an opportunity to the institution to make a written representation
                            within 30 days from the date of issue of the Notice along with necessary
                            certificates/documents in order to take a final decision in the matter; failing
                            which action will be taken including the withdrawal, based on the records
                            available, with no further notice.

25.      APS01422           Supa Teacher Training Institute, Dharmapuri submitted an application for
          D.T.Ed-AI         grant of recognition for D.T.Ed course on 29.12.2004.
       Supa Teacher         Recognition order to was issued to the institution on 25.08.2005 Supa Teacher
      Training Institute,   Training Institute, No.7-A, Venkata Sharma Road, Dharmapuri-636701,
         Dharampuri         Tamilnadu with the condition to shift to own premises within 3 years.
             TN             The institution vide letter dated 29.10.2008 submitted Rs.40000/- towards
                            shifting fee.

                            A letter was issued on 12.06.2009 to the institution calling for documents to
                            examine the proposal for shifting of premises. The institution submitted its
                            reply on 06.07.2009.

                            The inspection was carried out on 22.10.2010.

                            The Committee considered the VT Report, VCD and all the relevant

                                                     23

         (Gangadharaiah)                                                   (Prof. C. Thangamuthu)
       Regional Director, SRC, NCTE                                        Chairman, SRC, NCTE
                                                                                         th
                                                                                     198 Meeting of SRC
                                                                                    th  h
                                                                                  24 -26 November 2010

                            documentary evidences and it was decided to serve Show cause Notice Under
                            Section 17 of NCTE Act for the following.

                               The total Built up area available for both D.T.Ed. and D.T.Ed – Al is 10900
                                Sq.Ft. which is far less than the requirement to run both the courses as per
                                NCTE Norms. A total built up area of 16,000 Sq.ft is required as per the
                                norms.

                               The latest Building Completion Certificate from the competent Government
                                Engineer has not been submitted.

                               The building construction is incomplete and I floor is under construction.

                               The facilities in Science lab and Psychology lab are adequate for one unit of
                                D.Ed course.

                               Language learning lab is not available.

                            In view of the above, the Committee decided to issue a Showcause Notice to
                            the institution as to why the recognition be not withdrawn and thereby
                            providing an opportunity to the institution to make a written representation
                            within 30 days from the date of issue of the Notice along with necessary
                            certificates/documents in order to take a final decision in the matter; failing
                            which action will be taken including the withdrawal, based on the records
                            available, with no further notice.

26.      APS01180           Rev. Jacob Memorial Teacher Training Institute, Dindigul submitted an
           D.T.Ed           application for grant of recognition for D.T.Ed course.
         Rev. Jacob
                            Recognition order to was issued to the institution on 12.01.2005 at Rev. Jacob
      Memorial Teacher      Memorial Teacher Training Institute, No.1/33, Sukumar Complex,
      Training Institute,   Kallimandayam, Dindigul-624616, Tamilnadu with the condition to shift to own
                            premises within 3 years.
           Dindigul
             TN             In the meantime a letter was received from State Government of Tamilnadu
                            stating some lapses that prevailed in 54 D.T.Ed institutions in Tamilnadu. The
                            matter was considered by SRC in its 157th meeting held on 23rd-24th April 2008
                            and decided to issue show cause notice to the institutions.

                            Accordingly a show cause notice u/s 17 was issued to the institution on
                            17.06.2008. The institution submitted its reply on 14.07.2008. The written
                            representation was considered by SRC in its 166th meeting held on 18th-19th
                            October 2008 and cause inspection of the institution under Section 17 of
                            NCTE Act, to verify the veracity of the compliance as claimed by the institution
                            and also the structural modifications / improvement / shifting to new building
                            as claimed, on payment of re-inspection fee of Rs.40000/- by the institution.

                                                      24

         (Gangadharaiah)                                                    (Prof. C. Thangamuthu)
       Regional Director, SRC, NCTE                                         Chairman, SRC, NCTE
                                                                                              th
                                                                                          198 Meeting of SRC
                                                                                         th  h
                                                                                       24 -26 November 2010

                            Accordingly a letter was issued to the institution on 27.10.08. The institution
                            submitted its reply on 10.11.08. The reply of the institution was considered by
                            SRC in its 179th meeting held on 23rd July 09 and decided to cause inspection
                            under section 17.

                            The institution vide letter dated 13.09.2008 submitted for a proposal for shifting
                            to new premises alongwith Rs. 40000/-

                            A letter was issued to the institution for submission of requisite documents on
                            12.03.2009. The institution submitted its reply on 21.07.2009.

                            The inspection was carried out on 22.10.2010.

                            The Committee considered the VT Report,VCD and all the relevant documentary
                            evidences and it was decided to serve Show cause Notice Under Section 17 of
                            NCTE Act for the following.
                              As per the VT report D.T.Ed course is run in the permanent premises, but the
                               new building is partly covered with Asbestos sheet roof and the Ist floor is
                               still under construction.

                             The institution was given recognition on 12.01.2005 in a temporary premises
                              with a specific condition that the institution should move to a permanent
                              premise within a period of three years i.e., on or before 11.01.2008.

                             The built up area is inadequate and incomplete.

                             Language learning lab is not available.

                            In view of the above, the Committee decided to issue a Showcause Notice to
                            the institution as to why the recognition be not withdrawn and thereby
                            providing an opportunity to the institution to make a written representation
                            within 30 days from the date of issue of the Notice along with necessary
                            certificates/documents in order to take a final decision in the matter; failing
                            which action will be taken, including the withdrawal based on the records
                            available, with no further notice.

27.       APS04661          Vedasandur Rajathiammal & Rengaswamy Chettiar Trust, Dindigul, Tamilnadu
                            submitted application for grant of recognition to J.K. College of Education, J.K. Nagar,
             B.Ed
                            Dindigul, Tamilnadu for B.Ed course on 21.12.2005.
        J.K. College of
                            The application was processed as per the provisions contained in Rules and
      Education, Dindigul
                            Regulation, Norms and Standards prevalent at that point of time and the recognition
              TN            was granted to the institution vide order dated 27.07.2007 with certain stipulated
                            conditions.

                            As per decision of SRC in its 175th meeting held on 13th-14th May 2009, the office of
                            SRC has reviewed the files of the institution who have been granted recognition either
                            in a rented premises pending construction of own building or in lease premises. A list
                                                        25

          (Gangadharaiah)                                                       (Prof. C. Thangamuthu)
        Regional Director, SRC, NCTE                                            Chairman, SRC, NCTE
                                                                                       th
                                                                                   198 Meeting of SRC
                                                                                  th  h
                                                                                24 -26 November 2010

                       of such institutions has been prepared and placed before SRC in its 181st meeting
                       held on 20th-21st August 2009 wherein, it was decided that the institution which have
                       not shifted to the permanent premises even after the expiry of three years time limit
                       be issued notice under Section 17 of NCTE Act for further action.

                       Accordingly a notice was issued to the institution on 23.07.2010 to submit following
                       documents. The institution submitted its reply on 01.09.2010 alongwith photocopies of
                       certain documents. SRC considered the reply in its 196th meeting and decided to
                       cause inspection.

                       The inspection of the institution was conducted on 23.10.2010

                       The Committee considered the VT Report,VCD and all the relevant documentary
                       evidences and it was decided to serve Show cause Notice Under Section 17 of
                       NCTE Act for the following.

                          The total Built up area earmarked for D.T.Ed & D.T.Ed-Al is 23621.295 Sq.ft,
                           B.Ed is 23621.295 Sq.ft and for M.Ed is 1082.41 Sq.ft. The earmarked area
                           for M.Ed programme is only 1082.41 Sq. ft. which is grossly inadequate for
                           M.Ed programme as sper NCTE norms. The same is also corroborated by
                           the management in the essential data.

                          The building proposed for shifting is incomplete even after the stipulated
                           time period of 3 years and after lapse of time period of more than 4 years.

                          Building completion certificate from the authorized Government engineer is
                           not submitted.

                          Language learning lab is not available.

                          FDRs of Rs. 5.00 Lakhs & 3.00 Lakhs in joint names for each course from a
                           Nationalized Bank is to be submitted.

                          Built up area is not mentioned in the affidavit.

                          The management has not paid Rs. 40000/- towards shifting fee for each
                           course being run.

                       In view of the above, the Committee decided to issue a Showcause Notice to
                       the institution as to why the recognition be not withdrawn and thereby
                       providing an opportunity to the institution to make a written representation
                       within 30 days from the date of issue of the Notice along with necessary
                       certificates/documents in order to take a final decision in the matter; failing
                       which action will be taken including the withdrawal, based on the records
                       available, with no further notice.

28.    APS04712        Vijayalakshmi   Teacher Training Institute, Dharmapuri submitted                  an
         D.T.Ed        application for grant of recognition for D.T.Ed course on 30.12.2005.
                                                  26

        (Gangadharaiah)                                                   (Prof. C. Thangamuthu)
      Regional Director, SRC, NCTE                                        Chairman, SRC, NCTE
                                                                                            th
                                                                                        198 Meeting of SRC
                                                                                       th  h
                                                                                     24 -26 November 2010

        Vijayalakshmi       Recognition order to was issued to the institution on 09.01.2007 at
       Teacher Training     Vijayalakshmi Teacher Training Institute, D.No.1/270, Siva Salai, Collector
                            Bungalow Road, Devarasampatti, A. Jettihalli Post, Dharmapuri-636807,
           Institute,       Tamilnadu with the condition to shift to own premises within 3 years.
         Dharamapuri
                            The institution vide letter dated 30.12.2009 submitted Rs.40000/- towards inspectiong
              TN
                            fee.

                            The inspection of the institution was carried out on 23.102010.

                            The Committee considered the VT Report, VCD and all the relevant
                            documentary evidences and it was decided to serve Show cause Notice Under
                            Section 17 of NCTE Act for the following.

                                As per the VCD of the institution, the building is incomplete and flooring in
                                 the Ist floor is not done.

                               The latest Building Completion Certificate from the competent Government
                                Engineer has not been submitted.

                                The Affidavti in Rs.100/-stamp paper in the prescribed format with notary
                                 attestation to be submitted.

                                Language learning is not available.

                                ET lab and Psychology labs are adequate for one unit of D.T.Ed course.

                            In view of the above, the Committee decided to issue a Showcause Notice to
                            the institution as to why the recognition be not withdrawn and thereby
                            providing an opportunity to the institution to make a written representation
                            within 30 days from the date of issue of the Notice along with necessary
                            certificates/documents in order to take a final decision in the matter; failing
                            which action will be taken including the withdrawal, based on the records
                            available, with no further notice.

29.       APS03630          Amman Educational Trust, Dindigul submitted an application in the name and
             B.Ed           style of Amman College of Education for seeking grant of recognition for B.Ed
                            course on 30.12.2004.
      Amman College of
      Education, Dindigul   The application was processed and the inspection of the institution was carried
                            out on 21.11.2005. Recognition order to was issued to the institution on
              TN
                            04.01.2006 at Amman College of Education, VSKS Nagar, Bye-Pass Road,
                            Dindigul-625001, Tamilnadu with the condition to shift to own premises within
                            3 years.

                            The institution vide letter dated 02.03.2009 submitted Rs.40000/- information
                            about college shifted to own premises.

                                                       27

          (Gangadharaiah)                                                      (Prof. C. Thangamuthu)
        Regional Director, SRC, NCTE                                           Chairman, SRC, NCTE
                                                                                         th
                                                                                     198 Meeting of SRC
                                                                                    th  h
                                                                                  24 -26 November 2010



                        SRC in its 181st meeting held on 20th-21st August 2009 wherein, it was decided
                        that the institution which have not shifted to the permanent premises even
                        after the expiry of three years time limit be issued notice under Section 17 of
                        NCTE Act for further action. Accordingly a notice has been issued to the
                        institution on 16.09.2009.

                        The institution vide letter dated 01.10.2010 submitted Rs.40000/- towards
                        shifing fee.

                        The inspection of the institution was conducted on 23.10.2010.

                        The Committee considered the VT Report, VCD and all the relevant
                        documentary evidences and it was decided to serve Show cause Notice Under
                        Section 17 of NCTE Act for the following.

                           A School is being run in the same building where the B.Ed programme is
                            also conducted.

                           Different survey Nos of the land are given.

                           A Certificate from the Government Affiliating body to the effect that no
                            other programme is being run by the institution in the same building /
                            Campus, along with the existing B.Ed.course to be submitted.

                           The latest Building Completion Certificate from the competent Government
                            Engineer has not been submitted.

                           The earmarked built up area for each of the Teacher Educational
                            Programme is to be given.

                        In view of the above, the Committee decided to issue a Showcause Notice to
                        the institution as to why the recognition be not withdrawn and thereby
                        providing an opportunity to the institution to make a written representation
                        within 30 days from the date of issue of the Notice along with necessary
                        certificates/documents in order to take a final decision in the matter; failing
                        which action will be taken including the withdrawal, based on the records
                        available, with no further notice.

30.     APS02985        Yanam Educational Society, Pondicherry submitted an application for grant of
                        recognition for D.T.Ed course and recognition was granted to the institution vide SRC
          D.T.Ed
                        order dated 18.10.2005 for 100 seats.
      Yanam School of
                        A complaint was received on 25.05.2010 in the office of SRC against Yanam School
        Education,
                        of Education. The Committee considered the complaint in 194th meeting held on 21-
        Puducherry      22 July, 2010 and decided to call for remarks from the institution on the following :-
            PO
                         Land Use Certificate and building approval plan is to be submitted.
                                                    28

         (Gangadharaiah)                                                   (Prof. C. Thangamuthu)
       Regional Director, SRC, NCTE                                        Chairman, SRC, NCTE
                                                                                    th
                                                                                198 Meeting of SRC
                                                                               th  h
                                                                             24 -26 November 2010

                  Building Completion Certificate duly signed by the competent Engineer is to be
                   submitted.
                  To submit the documents for having deposited the Endowment Fund and Reserve
                   fund of Rs. 5 lakhs and 3 lakhs respectively for each course separately.
                  The details of the number of admissions made for the past three years is to be
                   submitted.
                  Details of the teaching staff, name, date of Birth, Designation, qualification, years of
                   experience duly approved by the competent affiliating authority along with
                   Certificates of Marks sheets and appointment orders are to be submitted.

                 As per the decision of SRC clarification letter was issued on 18.11.2010.

                 The institution in its letter dated 14.10.2009 has submitted a proposal for shifting of
                 premises along with Rs.40000/- towards shifting fee.

                 Accordingly, inspection was carried out on 23.10.2010. The inspection report
                 has been received along with VCD.

                 The Committee considered the VT Report, VCD and all the relevant
                 documentary evidences and it was decided to serve Show cause Notice Under
                 Section 17 of NCTE Act for the following.

                  The institution was given recognition on 18.10.2005 in a leased temporary
                   premises with a specific condition that the institution should move to a
                   permanent premise within a period of three years i.e., on or before 17.10.2008.
                   Even after a lapse of time period of 5 years 11 months, the management is yet
                   to start the construction of its own building/move to its own building.

                  The leased premises of the institution is also having a built-up area of 5910
                   sq.ft. It is inadequate as per the norms of NCTE for offering D.T.Ed course;
                   11,000 sq.ft. built up area is required as per the norms.

                  The management is running the institution in a residential building which is
                   not suitable for running an education programme.

                  All labs i.e., Science lab, Psychology lab, ET lab, other labs/Physical labs
                   needs to be strengthen.

                  The management has not submitted the aproved building plan from
                   Government Authorised Authority.

                  Building Completion Certificate duly signed by the competent Government
                   Engineer is to be submitted.

                 In view of the above, the Committee decided to issue a Showcause Notice to
                 the institution as to why the recognition be not withdrawn and thereby
                 providing an opportunity to the institution to make a written representation
                 within 30 days from the date of issue of the Notice along with necessary
                 certificates/documents in order to take a final decision in the matter; failing
                                              29

  (Gangadharaiah)                                                      (Prof. C. Thangamuthu)
Regional Director, SRC, NCTE                                           Chairman, SRC, NCTE
                                                                                                   th
                                                                                              198 Meeting of SRC
                                                                                              th h
                                                                                           24 -26 November 2010

                               which action will be taken including the withdrawal, based on the records
                               available, with no further notice.

31.        APS01674            Phool Bun Teacher Training Institute for Women, Jambunath Road, Hospet-583201,
              D.Ed             Bellary District, Karnataka has submitted application for offering D.Ed course on
      Phool Bun Teacher        29.12.2003.The institution has been granted recognition by SRC for offering D.Ed
      Training Institute for   course with an intake of 50 students vide order dated 02.12.2004.
        Women, Bellary         The institution in its letter dated 09.10.2007 has submitted a proposal for shifting of
                               premises along with Rs.40,000/- towards shifting fee.
               KA
                               Inspection was carried out on 25th October 2010. The inspection report has been
                               received along with VCD. The details of the visiting team report are attached:
                               The Committee considered the VT Report,VCD and all the relevant documentary
                               evidences and it was decided to serve Show cause Notice Under Section 17 of
                               NCTE Act for the following.

                                  A Certificate from the Government Affiliating body to the effect that other
                                   programme is being run/shared by the institution in the same building /
                                   Campus, along with the existing Course D.Ed to be submitted.

                                  The latest Building Completion Certificate from the competent Government
                                   Engineer has not been submitted.

                                  The institute has not submitted the Land useage certificate from a
                                   competent Govt. approved authority.

                                  Certificate of Registration/bye-law of the society/trust is to be submitted.

                                  Notarised land documents in English are requested to ascertain the actual
                                   position of the new premises.

                               In view of the above, the Committee decided to issue a Showcause Notice to
                               the institution as to why the recognition be not withdrawn and thereby
                               providing an opportunity to the institution to make a written representation
                               within 30 days from the date of issue of the Notice along with necessary
                               certificates/documents in order to take a final decision in the matter; failing
                               which action will be taken including the withdrawal, based on the records
                               available, with no further notice.

32.        APS01996            Sri.Nirvanaswamy College of Education, Sree Degula Math, Kanakapura - 562117,
              B.Ed             Bangalore Rural District, Karnataka has submitted application for offering B.Ed
      Sri Nirvanaswamy         course on 31.12.2003. The institution has been granted recognition by SRC for
           College of          offering B.Ed course with an intake of 100 students vide order dated 02.12.2004.
           Education,          The institution in its letter dated 17.10.2007 has submitted a proposal for shifting of

                                                            30

           (Gangadharaiah)                                                           (Prof. C. Thangamuthu)
         Regional Director, SRC, NCTE                                                Chairman, SRC, NCTE
                                                                                               th
                                                                                          198 Meeting of SRC
                                                                                          th h
                                                                                       24 -26 November 2010

      Bangalore Rural      premises along with Rs.40,000/- towards shifting fee.
             KA            Inspection was carried out on 25th October 2010. The inspection report has been
                           received along with VCD

                           The Committee considered the VT Report, VCD and all the relevant
                           documentary evidences and it was decided to serve Show cause Notice Under
                           Section 17 of NCTE Act for the following.

                              The total Built up area earmarked for the B.Ed programme is only 8788 Sq.
                               ft and for D.Ed programme is 5576 Sq.ft which is grossly inadequate for
                               both the Teacher Education Programmes as per NCTE norms. The same is
                               also corroborated by the management by affixing signature of the
                               management representative in the essential data.

                              The institute has not submitted the Land useage certificate                     from a
                               competent Govt. approved authority.

                           In view of the above, the Committee decided to issue a Showcause Notice to
                           the institution as to why the recognition be not withdrawn and thereby
                           providing an opportunity to the institution to make a written representation
                           within 30 days from the date of issue of the Notice along with necessary
                           certificates/documents in order to take a final decision in the matter; failing
                           which action will be taken including the withdrawal, based on the records
                           available, with no further notice.

33.      APS01718          Nethaji College of Education No.27, Arehalli, Ittamadu Main Road, Banashankari 3rd
            B.Ed           Stage, Bangalore – 560061, Karnataka has submitted application for offering B.Ed
      Nethaji College of   course on 30.12.2003.The institution has been granted recognition by SRC for
         Education,        offering B.Ed course with an intake of 100 students vide order dated 30.11.2004.
         Bangalore         The institution in its letter dated 08.10.2007 has submitted a proposal for shifting of
                           premises along with Rs.40,000/- towards shifting fee.
             KA
                           Inspection was carried out on 25th October 2010. The inspection report has been
                           received along with VCD. The details of the visiting team report is attached:

                           The Committee considered the VT Report,VCD and all the relevant documentary
                           evidences and it was decided to serve Show cause Notice Under Section 17 of
                           NCTE Act for the following.

                              A Certificate from the Government Affiliating body to the effect that no
                               other programme is being run/shared by the institution in the same building
                               / Campus, along with the existing Course B.Ed is to be submitted.

                              NCTE has never approved the name, location & change in the management
                               and as such the management has started to function in the new address
                               where the inspection is carried out.
                                                        31

         (Gangadharaiah)                                                         (Prof. C. Thangamuthu)
       Regional Director, SRC, NCTE                                              Chairman, SRC, NCTE
                                                                                                th
                                                                                           198 Meeting of SRC
                                                                                           th h
                                                                                        24 -26 November 2010

                               Building plan is not submitted, the management has shown only sketch of
                                the plan which is not approved by the competent authority.

                               The institute has not submitted the Land useage certificate from a
                                competent Govt. approved authority.

                               The FDRs of Rs. 5 Lakhs and 3 Lakhs are not in the joint account.
                                Photocopy of the FDRs are shown to VT members which is not clear.

                               ET lab needs to be strengthened.

                               Land area given in Affidavit is not adequate as per NCTE norms.

                            In view of the above, the Committee decided to issue a Showcause Notice to
                            the institution as to why the recognition be not withdrawn and thereby
                            providing an opportunity to the institution to make a written representation
                            within 30 days from the date of issue of the Notice along with necessary
                            certificates/documents in order to take a final decision in the matter; failing
                            which action will be taken including the withdrawal, based on the records
                            available, with no further notice.

34.       APS02320          Vijayanagar College of Education, Vijayanagar Educational Academy, 49, 6th Cross,
             B.Ed           1st Stage, 2nd Phase, Chandra Layout, Bangalore-560040, Karnataka has submitted
      Vijayanagar College   application for offering B.Ed course on 31.12.2003.The institution has been granted
         of Education,      recognition by SRC for offering B.Ed course with an intake of 100 students vide order
          Bangalore         dated 30.11.2004.
              KA            The institution in its letter dated 28.11.2007 has submitted a proposal for shifting of
                            premises along with Rs.40,000/- towards shifting fee.
                            The inspection was carried out on 26th October 2010. The inspection report has been
                            received along with VCD. The details of the visiting team report is attached:
                            The Committee considered the VT Report, VCD and all the relevant
                            documentary evidences and it was decided to serve Show cause Notice Under
                            Section 17 of NCTE Act for the following.

                             The management is running the institution in a FIVE storied residential
                              building, which is unsuited to run the academic programme. No vacant land
                              around the building as against the requirement of 2500 Sq.mts of land as per
                              norms. Playground is 300 meters away from the building and is being shared
                              with other school.

                             The institute has not submitted the Land useage certificate from a competent
                             Govt. approved authority.

                             The latest Building Completion Certificate from the competent Government
                              Engineer is not submitted.
                                                         32

          (Gangadharaiah)                                                         (Prof. C. Thangamuthu)
        Regional Director, SRC, NCTE                                              Chairman, SRC, NCTE
                                                                                                 th
                                                                                            198 Meeting of SRC
                                                                                            th h
                                                                                         24 -26 November 2010

                              Affidavit on Rs.100/- stamp paper is not submitted.

                              The building plan submitted is for different location other than the one
                               proposed earlier/initially.

                              The FDRs of Rs. 5 Lakhs and 3 Lakhs are taken for 2 years only and the
                               duration is already lapsed. (Date of issue of FDR both 5 lakhs and 3 lakhs is
                               13.09.2008). As per the NCTE norms it should be of 5 years duration.

                             In view of the above, the Committee decided to issue a Showcause Notice to
                             the institution as to why the recognition be not withdrawn and thereby
                             providing an opportunity to the institution to make a written representation
                             within 30 days from the date of issue of the Notice along with necessary
                             certificates/documents in order to take a final decision in the matter; failing
                             which action will be taken including the withdrawal, based on the records
                             available, with no further notice.

35.       APS01533           Vijayanagar College of Teachers Training, #1938, Sanjeevininagar, Moodalapalya,
             D.Ed            Vijayanagar west, Banglore-560072, Karnataka has submitted application for offering
      Vijaynagar College     D.Ed course on 22.12.2003.The institution has been granted recognition by SRC for
      of Teacher Training,   offering D.Ed course with an intake of 50 students vide order dated 30.11.2004.
          Bangalore          The institution in its letter dated 28.11.2007 has submitted a proposal for shifting of
                             premises along with Rs.40,000/- towards shifting fee. Further, the institution has
              KA
                             given consent for inspection on 19.06.2009.
                             Accordingly, inspection was not conducted on 26.10.2010. A letter is submitted by the
                             VT members by enclosing a letter from the management regarding unwillingness for
                             shifting the premises.
                             The institution is also running B.Ed course for which inspection has been conducted
                             on 26.10.2010.
                             As per land documents, the land address is Katha No.13, (Old Khanesumari
                             No.904/13-14) situated at Ward No.40, Attiguppe, 80 feet Road, Maruthi Nagar,
                             Nagarabhavi, Bangalore, in all measuring 2283.84 sq.ft but as per khatha extract,
                             2323.13 sq.ft comprising of Basement, Ground, First, Second and Third Floor and
                             composite super built up area of 6400 sq.ft of RCC roofed Red Oxide flooring, brick
                             wall and doors and windows of Jungle Wood.
                             The committee considered the written explanation to the notice and other
                             documents submitted by the institution and decided to cause inspection at the
                             same premises Under Section 17 of NCTE Act. The institution is directed to
                             submit the following with 30 days of the receipt of the notice. Demand Draft of
                             Rs.40,000/- towards inspection fee in favour of “The Member Secretary, NCTE”
                             payable at Bangalore should be submitted. Duly filled in Questionnaire along
                                                          33

           (Gangadharaiah)                                                         (Prof. C. Thangamuthu)
         Regional Director, SRC, NCTE                                              Chairman, SRC, NCTE
                                                                                            th
                                                                                       198 Meeting of SRC
                                                                                       th h
                                                                                    24 -26 November 2010

                        with all the necessary documents for land, building approval and completion
                        certificate from a competent Govt. Engineer and other relevant documents.
                        FDRs for Rs. 5 lakhs and 3 lakhs which was earlier drawn is of only 2 years
                        duration, which lapsed on 12.09.2010. New FDRs to be taken in joint account
                        with a duration of 5 years.

36.     APS01901        K.K.College of Education, K.K. Educational and Charitable Trust, Vasanthapura
           B.Ed         Road, Konanakunte Cross, Bangalore-560062, Karnataka has submitted application
      K.K. College of   for offering B.Ed course on 31.12.2003.The institution has been granted recognition
        Education,      by SRC for offering B.Ed course with an intake of 100 students vide order dated
        Bangalore       29.11.2004.
            KA          The institution in its letter dated 25.10.2007 has submitted a proposal for shifting of
                        premises along with Rs.40,000/- towards shifting fee.
                        The inspection was carried out on 27th October 2010. The inspection report has been
                        received along with VCD.

                        The Committee considered the VT Report, VCD and all the relevant
                        documentary evidences and it was decided to serve Show cause Notice Under
                        Section 17 of NCTE Act for the following.

                         The institution is functioning in a multistoried building which is being shared
                          for running management and Commerce Colleges. This is a gross violation of
                          norms on the part of the management to share with other colleges.

                         The affidavit is being signed by a different person and land area and Survey
                          Nos are different.

                         The land where the institution is functioning in the building is in the name of
                          an individual, it should be in the name of the trust or institution as per the
                          norms.

                         The latest Building Completion Certificate from the competent Government
                          Engineer has not been submitted.

                         Rs. 5 Lakhs FDR expired on 13.10.2010. Fresh FDR for Rs. 5 lakhs to be
                          submitted.
                        In view of the above, the Committee decided to issue a Showcause Notice to
                        the institution as to why the recognition be not withdrawn and thereby
                        providing an opportunity to the institution to make a written representation
                        within 30 days from the date of issue of the Notice along with necessary
                        certificates/documents in order to take a final decision in the matter; failing
                        which action will be taken including the withdrawal, based on the records
                        available, with no further notice.



                                                     34

        (Gangadharaiah)                                                       (Prof. C. Thangamuthu)
      Regional Director, SRC, NCTE                                            Chairman, SRC, NCTE
                                                                                                 th
                                                                                            198 Meeting of SRC
                                                                                            th h
                                                                                         24 -26 November 2010

37.       APS01615           V.V.Sanghas Teacher Training Institute, Vijayanagar College of Campus Amaravathi
             D.Ed            College Road, Hospet,       Bellary District, Pin 583201, Karnataka has submitted
        V.V. Sanghas         application for offering D.Ed course on 29.12.2003. The institution has been granted
       Teacher Training      recognition by SRC for offering D.Ed course with an intake of 50 students vide order
       Institute, Bellary    dated 24.12.2004.
              KA             The institution in its letter dated 24.09.2007 has submitted a proposal for shifting of
                             premises along with Rs.40,000/- towards shifting fee.
                             Inspection was carried out on 27th October 2010. The inspection report has been
                             received along with VCD.

                             The Committee considered the VT Report, VCD and all the relevant
                             documentary evidences and it was decided to serve Show cause Notice Under
                             Section 17 of NCTE Act for the following.

                                A Certificate from the Government Affiliating body to the effect that other
                                 programme being conducted by the institution in the same building /
                                 Campus, along with the existing Course D.Ed is to be submitted.

                                The institute has not submitted the Land useage certificate from a
                                 competent Govt. approved authority.

                                The latest Building Completion Certificate from the competent Government
                                 Engineer has not been submitted.

                             In view of the above, the Committee decided to issue a Showcause Notice to
                             the institution as to why the recognition be not withdrawn and thereby
                             providing an opportunity to the institution to make a written representation
                             within 30 days from the date of issue of the Notice along with necessary
                             certificates/documents in order to take a final decision in the matter; failing
                             which action will be taken including the withdrawal, based on the records
                             available, with no further notice.

38.       APS02422           Sri Kotturswamy Institute of Teacher Education, Sree Jagadguru Kotturswamy Math,
             D.Ed            Main Bazaar,Hospet-583201, Bellary District, Karnataka has submitted application for
       Sri Kotturswamy       offering D.Ed course on 31.12.2003. The institution has been granted recognition by
      Institute of Teacher   SRC for offering D.Ed course with an intake of 50 students vide order dated
      Education, Bellary     30.11.2004.
              KA             The institution in its letter dated 28.09.2007 has submitted a proposal for shifting of
                             premises along with Rs.40,000/- towards shifting fee.
                             Inspection was carried out on 27th October 2010. The inspection report has been
                             received along with VCD. The details of the visiting team report is attached:


                                                          35

          (Gangadharaiah)                                                          (Prof. C. Thangamuthu)
        Regional Director, SRC, NCTE                                               Chairman, SRC, NCTE
                                                                                            th
                                                                                       198 Meeting of SRC
                                                                                       th h
                                                                                    24 -26 November 2010

                        The Committee considered the VT Report,VCD and all the relevant documentary
                        evidences and it was decided to serve Show cause Notice Under Section 17 of
                        NCTE Act for the following.

                         The institution has shifted to new premises which is again a leased building.
                          As per the regulation of NCTE it is not permissible and the management has
                          to shift to its own permanent premises/building immediately.

                         The Affidavit in Rs.100/- stamp paper in the prescribed format with notary
                          attestation to be submitted.

                         The latest Building Completion Certificate from the competent Government
                          Engineer has not been submitted.

                         The institute has not submitted the Land useage certificate from a competent
                         Govt. approved authority.

                         Certificate of Registration / Bye-Laws of the Society are to be submitted by the
                          management.

                         Language learning lab is not available.

                        In view of the above, the Committee decided to issue a Showcause Notice to
                        the institution as to why the recognition be not withdrawn and thereby
                        providing an opportunity to the institution to make a written representation
                        within 30 days from the date of issue of the Notice along with necessary
                        certificates/documents in order to take a final decision in the matter; failing
                        which action will be taken including the withdrawal, based on the records
                        available, with no further notice.

39.     APS02125        Sri Markandeshwara D.Ed College, 90/A, Sadashiva Nagar, Ananthasayan Gudi,
           D.Ed         Hospet, Bellary district, Karnataka has submitted application for offering D.Ed course
            Sri         on 31.12.2003.The institution has been granted recognition by SRC for offering D.Ed
      Markandeshwara    course with an intake of 50 students vide order dated 29.11.2004.
       D.Ed College,    The institution in its letter dated 18.09.2007 has submitted a proposal for shifting of
                        premises along with Rs.40,000/- towards shifting fee.
          Bellary
                        Accordingly, inspection was carried out on 28th October 2010. The inspection report
            KA
                        has been received along with VCD.

                        The Committee considered the VT Report, VCD and all the relevant
                        documentary evidences and it was decided to serve Show cause Notice Under
                        Section 17 of NCTE Act for the following.

                         As per VT report, the management is running D.Ed programme and also
                          running a primary and higher secondary school in the same
                          building/premises, which is not permissible as per NCTE norms.

                                                     36

         (Gangadharaiah)                                                      (Prof. C. Thangamuthu)
       Regional Director, SRC, NCTE                                           Chairman, SRC, NCTE
                                                                                                th
                                                                                           198 Meeting of SRC
                                                                                           th h
                                                                                        24 -26 November 2010

                             As per the VT report, VCD and all the relevant documents, it is clear that the
                              building is incomplete and the institution is running the D.Ed. programme in a
                              building which is partly roofed with asbestos sheets, which is against the
                              NCTE Norms.

                             Original Affidavit of Rs. 100/- is not submitted.

                             FDRs of Rs. 5 lakhs and 3 lakhs in joint names from a Nationalized Bank for a
                              period of 5 years is to be submitted.

                             Non-encumbrance Certificate from the competent Government Authorised
                              person / Authority. To be submitted.

                             Lease documents of English version is to be submitted.

                            In view of the above, the Committee decided to issue a Showcause Notice to
                            the institution as to why the recognition be not withdrawn and thereby
                            providing an opportunity to the institution to make a written representation
                            within 30 days from the date of issue of the Notice along with necessary
                            certificates/documents in order to take a final decision in the matter; failing
                            which action will be taken including the withdrawal, based on the records
                            available, with no further notice.

40.      APS01711           Sonia Gandhi D.Ed Training Instiute, M/s Ghousia Educational Minority Institute
            D.Ed            Society, Near Police Quarters, Millerpet, Bellary Distirct, Karnataka has submitted
      Sonia Gandhi D.Ed     application for offering D.Ed course on 30.12.2003. The institution has been granted
      Training Institute,   recognition by SRC for offering D.Ed course with an intake of 50 students vide order
           Bellary          dated 10.12.2004.
             KA             The institution in its letter dated 03.10.2007 has submitted a proposal for shifting of
                            premises along with Rs.40,000/- towards shifting fee.
                            Inspection was carried out on 29th October 2010.

                            The Committee considered the VT Report,VCD and all the relevant documentary
                            evidences and it was decided to serve Show cause Notice Under Section 17 of
                            NCTE Act for the following.

                             As per VT report VCD the management is running D.Ed programme and also
                              running a primary school and High School in the same building/premises,
                              which is not permissible as per NCTE norms.

                             The latest Building Completion Certificate from the competent Government
                              Engineer has not been submitted.

                             The institute has not submitted the Land useage certificate from a competent
                             Govt. approved authority.

                                                         37

          (Gangadharaiah)                                                         (Prof. C. Thangamuthu)
        Regional Director, SRC, NCTE                                              Chairman, SRC, NCTE
                                                                                         th
                                                                                     198 Meeting of SRC
                                                                                    th  h
                                                                                  24 -26 November 2010

                             Rs. 5 lackhs FDR is expired on 24.01.2010. Fresh FDR of Rs. 5 lackhs is to be
                              submitted in a joint account with NCTE.

                            In view of the above, the Committee decided to issue a Showcause Notice to
                            the institution as to why the recognition be not withdrawn and thereby
                            providing an opportunity to the institution to make a written representation
                            within 30 days from the date of issue of the Notice along with necessary
                            certificates/documents in order to take a final decision in the matter; failing
                            which action will be taken including the withdrawal, based on the records
                            available, with no further notice.

41.      APS05344           Kovai Medical Centre Research & Educational Trust, Coimbatore submitted an
            D.T.Ed          application in the name and style of Dr. NGP Teacher Training Institute for
      Dr. N.G.P. Teacher    seeking grant of recognition for D.T.Ed course on 30.12.2005.
      Training Institute,   The application was processed and the inspection of the institution was carried
         Coimbatore         out on 10.09.2006. Recognition order to was issued to the institution on
                            28.09.2006 at Dr. NGP College of Education, Kalappatti Road, Coimbatore-
             TN
                            641035, Tamilnadu with the condition to shift to own premises within 3 years.

                            The institution vide letter dated 24.03.2009 submitted for a proposal for
                            change of premises alongwith Rs.40000/-:

                            A letter was issued on 12.06.2009 to the institution calling for documents to
                            examine the proposal for shifting of premises. The institution submitted its
                            reply on 27.07.2009.

                            The Committee considered the VT report of the institution, VCD and other
                            related documents along with the original file of the institution for shifting to
                            new/permanent premises and decided to permit shifting to permanent
                            Building/Premises.

42.      APS04303           Kovai Medical Centre Research & Educational Trust, Coimbatore submitted an
            B.Ed            application in the name and style of Dr. NGP College of Education for seeking
                            grant of recognition for B.Ed course on 02.11.2004.
      Dr. N.G.P. College    The application was processed and the inspection of the institution was carried
        of Education,       out on 22.05.2005. Recognition order to was issued to the institution on
                            13.07.2005 at Dr. NGP College of Education, Kovai Estate, Kalappatti Road,
         Coimbatore
                            Coimbatore-641035, Tamilnadu with the condition to shift to own premises
             TN             within 3 years.
                            The institution vide letter dated 03.01.2009 submitted for a proposal for
                            change of premises alongwith Rs.40000/-:
                            The Committee considered the VT report of the institution, VCD and other
                            related documents along with the original file of the institution for shifting to
                            new/permanent premises and decided to permit shifting to permanent
                            Building/Premises.

                                                      38

          (Gangadharaiah)                                                   (Prof. C. Thangamuthu)
        Regional Director, SRC, NCTE                                        Chairman, SRC, NCTE
                                                                                       th
                                                                                   198 Meeting of SRC
                                                                                  th  h
                                                                                24 -26 November 2010

43.     APS03798         KMG Charitable Trust, Coimbatore submitted an application in the name and
          D.T.Ed         style of Palaniammal Teacher Training Institute for seeking grant of
                         recognition for D.T.Ed course on 20.12.2004.
       Palaniammal
      Teacher Training   The application was processed and the inspection of the institution was carried
                         out on 28.09.2005. Recognition order to was issued to the institution on
         Institute,
                         08.12.2005 at Palaniammal Teacher Training Institute, V. Kaliapuram Post,
        Coimbatore       Vettaikaran Pudur Via, Pollachi, Coimbatore, Tamilnadu with the condition to
            TN           shift to own premises within 3 years.

                         The institution vide letter dated 10.06.2010 submitted for a proposal for shifting
                         to new premises alongwith Rs.40000/-
                         The Committee considered the VT Report,VCD and all the relevant documentary
                         evidences and it was decided to serve Show cause Notice Under Section 17 of
                         NCTE Act for the following.
                            The management is running two different Teacher Education Programme
                             with two different names in the same premises and has not clearly
                             earmarked land area, built up area etc for two different institutions.

                            A Certificate from the Government Affiliating body to the effect that no
                             other programme is being conducted by the institution in the same building
                             / Campus, along with the existing Course D.T.Ed is to be submitted.

                            The building plan shown to VT members is not approved by the
                             Government authority. The management has to submit the building plan
                             approved by the Government authority immediately.

                            The latest Building Completion Certificate from the competent Government
                             Engineer has not been submitted.

                            It is evident from VCD the building is in incomplete stage.

                            Land documents and Land use certificate are in Tamil version, English
                             version of the same is to be submitted.

                            There is a disparity in the land documents sale deed/gift deed in English
                             version is to be submitted and the land ownership address.
                            Language lab is not available.

                            No. of library books and seating capacity is not mentioned / given.

                         In view of the above, the Committee decided to issue a Showcause Notice to
                         the institution as to why the recognition be not withdrawn and thereby
                         providing an opportunity to the institution to make a written representation
                         within 30 days from the date of issue of the Notice along with necessary
                         certificates/documents in order to take a final decision in the matter; failing
                         which action will be taken including the withdrawal, based on the records
                         available, with no further notice.
                                                   39

         (Gangadharaiah)                                                  (Prof. C. Thangamuthu)
       Regional Director, SRC, NCTE                                       Chairman, SRC, NCTE
                                                                                        th
                                                                                    198 Meeting of SRC
                                                                                   th  h
                                                                                 24 -26 November 2010




44.      APS03680         KMG Charitable Trust, Coimbatore submitted an application in the name and
            B.Ed          style of KMG College of Education for seeking grant of recognition for B.Ed
                          course on 27.12.2004.
      K.M.G. College of
         Education,       The application was processed and the inspection of the institution was carried
                          out on 25.11.2005. Recognition order to was issued to the institution on
        Coimbatore
                          28.09.2006 at KMG College of Education, Vettaikkaran Pudur (Via), Pollachi
             TN           Taluk,, Coimbatore-642129, Tamilnadu with the condition to shift to own
                          premises within 3 years.

                          A letter was issued to the institution on 08.10.2009 calling for documents to
                          examine the proposal for shifting of premises. The institution vide letter dated
                          31.10.2009 submitted for a proposal for shifting to new premises alongwith
                          Rs.40000/-
                          The inspection was carried out on 13.11.2010.

                          The Committee considered the VT Report,VCD and all the relevant documentary
                          evidences and it was decided to serve Show cause Notice Under Section 17 of
                          NCTE Act for the following.


                             A Certificate from the Government Affiliating body to the effect that no
                              other programme being conducted by the institution in the same building /
                              Campus, along with the existing Course B.Ed is to be submitted.

                             The building plan shown to VT members is not approved by the
                              Government authority. The management has to submit the building plan
                              approved by the Government authority immediately.

                             The latest Building Completion Certificate from the competent Government
                              Engineer has not been submitted.

                             It is evident from VCD the building is in incomplete stage.

                             Land documents and Land use certificate are in Tamil version, English
                              version of the same is to be submitted.

                             There is a disparity in the land documents sale/gift deed in English version
                              is to be submitted and the land ownership address.

                             Language Learning lab is not available.

                             No. of library books and seating capacity is not mentioned / given.


                                                    40

         (Gangadharaiah)                                                   (Prof. C. Thangamuthu)
       Regional Director, SRC, NCTE                                        Chairman, SRC, NCTE
                                                                                          th
                                                                                      198 Meeting of SRC
                                                                                     th  h
                                                                                   24 -26 November 2010

                               The management is running two different Teacher Education Programme
                                with two different names in the same premises and has not clearly
                                earmarked land area, built up area etc for two different institutions.

                            In view of the above, the Committee decided to issue a Showcause Notice to
                            the institution as to why the recognition be not withdrawn and thereby
                            providing an opportunity to the institution to make a written representation
                            within 30 days from the date of issue of the Notice along with necessary
                            certificates/documents in order to take a final decision in the matter; failing
                            which action will be taken including the withdrawal, based on the records
                            available, with no further notice.


45.      APS01457           Royal Educational Trust, Coimbatore submitted an application in the name
           D.T.Ed           and style of St. Marks Teacher Training Institute for seeking grant of
                            recognition for D.T.Ed course on 31.12.2001.
      St. Marks Teacher
      Training Institute,   The application was processed and the inspection of the institution was carried
                            out on 12.10.2004. Recognition order to was issued to the institution on
         Coimbatore
                            20.01.2002 at St. Mark‟s Teacher Training Institute, Marappalam, Madukkarai,
             TN             Coimbatore-641105, Tamilnadu with the condition to shift to own premises
                            within 3 years.

                            The institution vide letter dated 23.10.2008 submitted for a proposal for shifting
                            to new premises alongwith Rs.40000/-

                            The inspection was carried out on 13.11.2010.

                            The Committee considered the VT Report,VCD and all the relevant documentary
                            evidences and it was decided to serve Show cause Notice Under Section 17 of
                            NCTE Act for the following.

                               Land details are not submitted to the VT members.

                               The latest Building Completion Certificate from the competent Government
                                Engineer has not been submitted.

                               The institute has not submitted the Land useage certificate from a
                                competent Govt. approved authority to be submitted.


                               Non-Encumbrance Certificate from the competent Government Authorised
                                person / Authority to be submitted.

                            In view of the above, the Committee decided to issue a Showcause Notice to
                            the institution as to why the recognition be not withdrawn and thereby
                            providing an opportunity to the institution to make a written representation
                            within 30 days from the date of issue of the Notice along with necessary
                                                      41

         (Gangadharaiah)                                                     (Prof. C. Thangamuthu)
       Regional Director, SRC, NCTE                                          Chairman, SRC, NCTE
                                                                                           th
                                                                                       198 Meeting of SRC
                                                                                      th  h
                                                                                    24 -26 November 2010

                             certificates/documents in order to take a final decision in the matter; failing
                             which action will be taken including the withdrawal, based on the records
                             available, with no further notice.

46.       APS05688           Sri Mahalakshmi Educational Trust, Coimbatore submitted an application in
            D.T.Ed           the name and style of Sri Mahalakshmi Teacher Training Institute for seeking
                             grant of recognition for D.T.Ed course on 02.01.2006.
       Sri Mahalakshmi
       Teacher Training      The application was processed and the inspection of the institution was carried
                             out on 10.10.2006. Recognition order to was issued to the institution on
      Institute for women,
                             13.11.2006 at Sri Mahalakshmi Teacher Training Institute for Women,
          Coimbatore         No.3/302, Mangalam, Palladam, Tirupur Taluk, Coimbatore, Tamilnadu with
              TN             the condition to shift to own premises within 3 years.

                             The institution vide letter dated 15.07.2008 submitted for a proposal for shifting
                             to new premises alongwith Rs.40000/-

                             A letter was issued to the institution on 12.06.2009 calling for documents to
                             examine the proposal for shifting of premises.

                             The inspection of the institution was carried out on 14.11.2010

                             The Committee considered the VT Report and all the relevant documentary
                             evidences and it was decided to serve Show cause Notice Under Section 17 of
                             NCTE Act for the following.

                                The management in their application Dt. 2.1.2006 has mentioned the
                                 address as “Sri Mahalakshmi Educational Trust for grant of recognition,
                                 but in the land documents changed the trust name as Sri Alagammai
                                 Charitable Aid Mission, without the approval of NCTE Bangalore.

                                Language learning lab is not available.

                                 In the library room the furniture is inadequate, it should be increased to
                                  accommodate the seating capacity as per the requirement of the students.
                                  Shifting of the furniture to other rooms will create inconvenience to the
                                  students.
                             In view of the above, the Committee decided to issue a Showcause Notice to
                             the institution as to why the recognition be not withdrawn and thereby
                             providing an opportunity to the institution to make a written representation
                             within 30 days from the date of issue of the Notice along with necessary
                             certificates/documents in order to take a final decision in the matter; failing
                             which action will be taken including the withdrawal, based on the records
                             available, with no further notice.

47.       APS01106           AVM Foundation, Coimbatore submitted an application in the name and style
            D.T.Ed           of AVMR Teacher Training Institute for seeking grant of recognition for D.T.Ed

                                                       42

          (Gangadharaiah)                                                     (Prof. C. Thangamuthu)
        Regional Director, SRC, NCTE                                          Chairman, SRC, NCTE
                                                                                   th
                                                                               198 Meeting of SRC
                                                                              th  h
                                                                            24 -26 November 2010

 AVMR Teacher         course on 31.12.2002.
Training Institute,
                      The application was processed and the inspection of the institution was carried
   Coimbatore         out on 11.12.2004. Recognition order to was issued to the institution on
       TN             20.01.2005 at AVMR Teacher Training Institute, SF.No.383/1, Near Codissa
                      Fair Grounds, Peelamedu, Coimbatore-641004, Tamilnadu with the condition
                      to shift to own premises within 3 years.

                      In the meantime, the State Govt. has informed that these institutions are not
                      maintaining norms and standards as prescribed by NCTE and deficiencies of
                      individual institutions were also submitted to this office. The SRC in its 157 th
                      meeting held on 23-24 April, 2008 considered the complaint and decided to
                      issue Notice to these institutions under Section 17 of NCTE Act, 1993.
                      Accordingly, Notice was issued on 17.6.2008. In reply the institution submitted
                      written representation on 14.07.2008.

                      The written representation was placed before 166th meeting of SRC held on
                      18-19 October, 2008 and SRC decided to cause inspection under Section 17
                      of NCTE Act, to verify the veracity of the compliance as claimed by the
                      institution and also the structural modifications / improvement / shifting to new
                      building as claimed, on payment of re-inspection fee of Rs.40000/- by the
                      institution.

                      A letter was issued to the institution on 27.10.2008. The institution vide letter
                      dated 01.03.2010 submitted for a proposal for shifting to newpremises
                      alongwith Rs.40000/-

                      The inspection of the institution was carried out on 16.11.2010

                      The Committee considered the VT Report,VCD and all the relevant documentary
                      evidences and it was decided to serve Show cause Notice Under Section 17 of
                      NCTE Act for the following.

                         On verification from the VCD the construction of the building is incomplete
                          in spite of the Building Completion Certificate issued by the competent
                          Government Engineer.

                         A Certificate from the Government Affiliating body to the effect that no
                          other programme is being conducted by the institution in the same building
                          / Campus, along with the existing Course D.T.Ed is to be submitted.



                         Non-Encumbrance Certificate from the competent Government Authorised
                          person / Authority to be submitted.

                         Land documents & details of its location etc in English version is to be
                                                43

   (Gangadharaiah)                                                    (Prof. C. Thangamuthu)
 Regional Director, SRC, NCTE                                         Chairman, SRC, NCTE
                                                                                           th
                                                                                       198 Meeting of SRC
                                                                                      th  h
                                                                                    24 -26 November 2010

                               submitted.

                              As per the address given in the questionnaire, the land documents are
                               being submitted.

                           In view of the above, the Committee decided to issue a Showcause Notice to
                           the institution as to why the recognition be not withdrawn and thereby
                           providing an opportunity to the institution to make a written representation
                           within 30 days from the date of issue of the Notice along with necessary
                           certificates/documents in order to take a final decision in the matter; failing
                           which action will be taken including the withdrawal, based on the records
                           available, with no further notice.


        Section 13 Inspection Report

48.      APS02398          Little Flower D.Ed College, No.6,16th „B‟ Main, HAL II Stage, Indiranagar, Bangalore-
         APS05830
                           560008, Karnataka submitted an application for grant of recognition on 02.01.2006.
           D.Ed
                           The institution was granted recognition for offering D.Ed with intake of 50students
            D.Ed-AI
      Little Flower D.Ed   vide order dated 29.11.2004 and D.Ed-AI course with an intake of 50 students vide
      College, Bangalore   order dated 30.03.2007.
             KA            In the mean time NCTE, Hqrs vide its letter dated 20.10.2010 has forwarded a
                           copy of the inspection report dated 21.04.2010 conducted Under Section 13 of
                           NCTE Act. As there are deficiencies pointed out in the inspection report,
                           NCTE, Hqrs has requested SRC to look into the matter to ascertain whether
                           the recognition to the institution still be continued and take appropriate action
                           against institution.
                           Inspection was carried out on 21.04.2010

                           The Committee considered the VT Report,VCD and all the relevant documentary
                           evidences and it was decided to serve Show cause Notice Under Section 17 of
                           NCTE Act for the following :

                            As per the VT report and other relevant documents produced by the visiting
                           members, that the institution is not functioning due to non-admission of
                           students since last two years and this was corroborated by the institution
                           authorities to the visiting members. No records were available to the VT
                           members for inspection. For the last two years no admission were made to the
                           D,Ed course, this was informed to the VT members by the representative of the
                           institution through phone. The management has continued non admission and
                           hence non functional status of the college to NCTE Hqts Vide letter dt.
                           26.01.2010

                                                      44

          (Gangadharaiah)                                                     (Prof. C. Thangamuthu)
        Regional Director, SRC, NCTE                                          Chairman, SRC, NCTE
                                                                                                 th
                                                                                             198 Meeting of SRC
                                                                                            th  h
                                                                                          24 -26 November 2010

                            In view of the above, the Committee decided to issue a Showcause Notice to
                            the institution as to why the recognition be not withdrawn and thereby
                            providing an opportunity to the institution to make a written representation
                            within 30 days from the date of issue of the Notice along with necessary
                            certificates/documents in order to take a final decision in the matter; failing
                            which action will be taken including the withdrawal, based on the records
                            available, with no further notice.

49.      APS02322           Nadaprabhu Kempegowda D.Ed College, Behind KTC & Canter Service Centre,
         APS02448
                            Bommanahally, Hosur Raod, Bangalore-560068, Karnataka submitted an application
           D.Ed
        (Tamil medium)      for grant of recognition on 31.12.2003. The institution was granted recognition for
         D.Ed (Telugu
           medium)          offering D.Ed course with an intake of 50 students vide order dated 24.12.2005.
         Nadaprabu          In the mean time NCTE, Hqrs vide its letter dated 20.10.2010 has forwarded a copy
      Kempegowda D.Ed       of the inspection report dated 23.04.2010 conducted Under Section 13 of NCTE Act.
      College, Bangalore    As there are deficiencies pointed out in the inspection report, NCTE, Hqrs has
             KA             requested SRC to look into the matter to ascertain whether the recognition to the
                            institution still be continued and take appropriate action against institution.
                            The Committee considered the VT Report and all the relevant documentary
                            evidences and it was decided to serve Show cause Notice Under Section 17 of
                            NCTE Act for the following :

                             As per the VT report the institution is not functioning since two years and no
                              admission were made to the present course D.Ed.

                             When the VT members visited the institution, they were informed by the
                              management that no admissions were made since two years and functioning
                              of the institution stopped.

                             The institution is non functional since last two years and the building is
                              under construction. The management is planning to restart the D.Ed course
                              after one / two years.

                            In view of the above, the Committee decided to issue a Showcause Notice to
                            the institution as to why the recognition be not withdrawn and thereby
                            providing an opportunity to the institution to make a written representation
                            within 30 days from the date of issue of the Notice along with necessary
                            certificates/documents in order to take a final decision in the matter; failing
                            which action will be taken including the withdrawal, based on the records
                            available, with no further notice.

50.      APS01841           Sarathi Teacher Training Institute, #171/2, Kothannur Village, J.P.Nagar, 8th Phase,
            D.Ed
                            2nd Block, Opp.to HM World City, Bangalore-560083, Karnataka submitted an
       Sarathi Teacher
                            application for grant of recognition on 31.12.2003. The institution was granted
      Training Institute,
                                                          45

          (Gangadharaiah)                                                          (Prof. C. Thangamuthu)
        Regional Director, SRC, NCTE                                               Chairman, SRC, NCTE
                                                                                               th
                                                                                           198 Meeting of SRC
                                                                                          th  h
                                                                                        24 -26 November 2010

         Bangalore        recognition for offering D.Ed course with an intake of 50 students vide order dated
             KA           25.11.2004.
                          In the mean time NCTE, Hqrs vide its letter dated 20.10.2010 has forwarded a copy
                          of the inspection report dated 03.05.2010 conducted Under Section 13 of NCTE Act.
                          As there are deficiencies pointed out in the inspection report, NCTE, Hqrs has
                          requested SRC to look into the matter to ascertain whether the recognition to the
                          institution still be continued and take appropriate action against institution.

                          The Committee considered the VT Report,VCD and all the relevant documentary
                          evidences and it was decided to serve Show cause Notice Under Section 17 of
                          NCTE Act for the following deficiencies:

                           As per the VT report the institution is not functioning since two years and no
                            admission were made to the present course D.Ed.

                           When the VT members visited the institution, they were informed by the
                            management that no admissions were made since two years and functioning
                            of the institution stopped.

                           The management has confirmed non-admission and hence non functional
                            status of the institution to NCTE Hqrts Vide letter dt. 01.04.2010

                          In view of the above, the Committee decided to issue a Showcause Notice to
                          the institution as to why the recognition be not withdrawn and thereby
                          providing an opportunity to the institution to make a written representation
                          within 30 days from the date of issue of the Notice along with necessary
                          certificates/documents in order to take a final decision in the matter; failing
                          which action will be taken including the withdrawal, based on the records
                          available, with no further notice.

51.      APS00583         Venkatesha T.C.H. Training College, Marathahalli, Bangalore-560037,Karnataka
         APS04349         submitted an application for grant of recognition on 16.01.1996. The institution was
           D.Ed
                          granted recognition for offering D.Ed course with an intake of 90 students vide order
          D.Ed-AI
                          dated 11.07.2000.
      Venkatesha T.C.H.
      Training College,
                          In the mean time NCTE, Hqrs vide its letter dated 20.10.2010 has forwarded a copy
         Bangalore
                          of the inspection report dated 04.05.2010 conducted Under Section 13 of NCTE Act.
             KA
                          As there are deficiencies pointed out in the inspection report, NCTE, Hqrs has
                          requested SRC to look into the matter to ascertain whether the recognition to the
                          institution still be continued and take appropriate action against institution
                          The Committee considered the VT Report,VCD and all the relevant documentary
                                                        46

          (Gangadharaiah)                                                        (Prof. C. Thangamuthu)
        Regional Director, SRC, NCTE                                             Chairman, SRC, NCTE
                                                                                         th
                                                                                     198 Meeting of SRC
                                                                                    th  h
                                                                                  24 -26 November 2010

                           evidences and it was decided to serve Show cause Notice Under Section 17 of
                           NCTE Act for the following :

                            As per the VT report the institution is not functioning since two years and no
                             admission were made to the present course D.Ed.

                            When the VT members visited the institution, they were informed by the
                             management that no admissions were made since two years and functioning
                             of the institution stopped.

                            The management has confirmed non-admission and hence non functional
                             status of the institution to NCTE Hqrts Vide letter dt. 04.05.2010

                           In view of the above, the Committee decided to issue a Showcause Notice to
                           the institution as to why the recognition be not withdrawn and thereby
                           providing an opportunity to the institution to make a written representation
                           within 30 days from the date of issue of the Notice along with necessary
                           certificates/documents in order to take a final decision in the matter; failing
                           which action will be taken including the withdrawal, based on the records
                           available, with no further notice.

52.      APS01732          Pramod D.Ed College, No.33, Challekere, Banasawadi Post, Bangalore-560043,
         APS05436
                           Karnataka submitted an application for grant of recognition on 30.12.2003. The
           D.Ed
          D.Ed-AI          institution was granted recognition for offering D.Ed course with an intake of 50
        Pramod D.Ed
                           students vide order dated 25.11.2004.
      College, Bangalore
                           In the mean time NCTE, Hqrs vide its letter dated 20.10.2010 has forwarded a copy
             KA            of the inspection report dated 06.05.2010 conducted Under Section 13 of NCTE Act.
                           As there are deficiencies pointed out in the inspection report, NCTE, Hqrs has
                           requested SRC to look into the matter to ascertain whether the recognition to the
                           institution still be continued and take appropriate action against institution

                           The Committee considered the VT Report and all the relevant documentary
                           evidences and it was decided to serve Show cause Notice Under Section 17 of
                           NCTE Act for the following deficiencies:

                            The management is running the institution for D.Ed &D.T.Ed-Al course and
                             sharing the building with a State Board School programme in the same
                             building, which is against the NCTE norms.

                            As per the VT report, the built up area available for each of the two courses is
                             only 3850 sq.ft.i.e.,for D.Ed & D.Ed-Al. programme. The built-up area is far
                             inadequate as per NCTE norms. As per the norms, 16,000 Sq.ft of built up
                             area is required for D.Ed and D.Ed Additional Units.

                            In the science lab, Psychology lab the equipments are not available.

                            Language learning lab is not available.
                                                      47

          (Gangadharaiah)                                                   (Prof. C. Thangamuthu)
        Regional Director, SRC, NCTE                                        Chairman, SRC, NCTE
                                                                                                th
                                                                                            198 Meeting of SRC
                                                                                           th  h
                                                                                         24 -26 November 2010


                            The management has failed to provide the summarized report on the library
                             to the VT members, only the bills of the books purchased are shown.

                            No proper information is provided to the VT members regarding the
                             disbursement of the salary through bank, payment of CPF/GPF contribution
                             to the staff.

                            Staff were not present for interaction on the date of inspection.

                            Admissions to the said programme is not done since two years and the
                             institution is not functioning.


                           In view of the above, the Committee decided to issue a Showcause Notice to
                           the institution as to why the recognition be not withdrawn and thereby
                           providing an opportunity to the institution to make a written representation
                           within 30 days from the date of issue of the Notice along with necessary
                           certificates/documents in order to take a final decision in the matter; failing
                           which action will be taken including the withdrawal, based on the records
                           available, with no further notice.

53.       APS00289         Jayendra D.Ed College, No.84, 1st, „C‟ Main, Jakkasandra, Koramangala, Bangalore-
          APS04347
                           560034, Karnataka submitted an application for grant of recognition on 31.12.2004.
            D.Ed
           D.Ed-AI         The institution was granted recognition for offering D.Ed-AI course with an intake of
        Jayendra D.Ed
                           60 students vide order dated 26.12.2005.
      College, Bangalore
             KA
                           In the mean time NCTE, Hqrs vide its letter dated 20.10.2010 has forwarded a copy
                           of the inspection report dated 06.05.2010 conducted Under Section 13 of NCTE Act.
                           As there are deficiencies pointed out in the inspection report, NCTE, Hqrs has
                           requested SRC to look into the matter to ascertain whether the recognition to the
                           institution still be continued and take appropriate action against institution.
                           The Committee considered the VT Report,VCD and all the relevant documentary
                           evidences and it was decided to serve Show cause Notice Under Section 17 of
                           NCTE Act for the following deficiencies:

                            The management has not admitted any students since two years.

                            When the VT members visited the institution, they were informed by the
                             management that no admissions were made since two years and functioning
                             of the institution stopped.

                           The management has confirmed non-admission and hence non functional
                           status of the institution to NCTE Hqrts Vide letter dt. 04/05/2010.

                                                         48

          (Gangadharaiah)                                                         (Prof. C. Thangamuthu)
        Regional Director, SRC, NCTE                                              Chairman, SRC, NCTE
                                                                                          th
                                                                                      198 Meeting of SRC
                                                                                     th  h
                                                                                   24 -26 November 2010



                         In view of the above, the Committee decided to issue a Showcause Notice to
                         the institution as to why the recognition be not withdrawn and thereby
                         providing an opportunity to the institution to make a written representation
                         within 30 days from the date of issue of the Notice along with necessary
                         certificates/documents in order to take a final decision in the matter; failing
                         which action will be taken including the withdrawal, based on the records
                         available, with no further notice.

54.      APS01580        Annapurneshwari Hukkeri D.Ed College, Borgaon Post, Chikodi Taluk, Belgaum
         APS04778
                         District, Karnataka (APS04778) submitted an application for grant of recognition on
           D.Ed
        D.Ed (Marathi    02.01.2006. The institution was granted recognition for offering D.Ed course with an
          Medium)
      Annapurneshwari    intake of 50 students vide order dated 31.10.2007.

        Hukkeri D.Ed     Another file by name Annapurneshwari Hukkeri D.Ed College, Borgaon – 591216,

      College, Belgaum   Chikodi, Belgaum District, Karnataka bearing code No.APS01580 was granted

             KA          recognition vide order dated 01.12.2004 with an intake of 50 students from the
                         session 2004-2005.
                         In the mean time NCTE, Hqrs vide its letter dated 27.10.2010 has forwarded a copy
                         of the inspection report dated 21.05.2010 conducted Under Section 13 of NCTE Act.
                         As there are deficiencies pointed out in the inspection report, NCTE, Hqrs has
                         requested SRC to initiate action against the institution Under Section 17 of the NCTE
                         Act immediately.
                         The Committee considered the VT Report,VCD and all the relevant documentary
                         evidences and it was decided to serve Show cause Notice Under Section 17 of
                         NCTE Act for the following.

                          The management is running I.T.I (Industrial Training Institute) programme in
                           the same building where Teacher Education Programme D.Ed. is run.

                          The earmarked built up area for each of the course/programme i.e., for D.Ed
                           is 6889 Sq.ft & for D.Ed (Marathi Medium) is 6792 Sq.ft, The total built up
                           area is 13681 sq.ft, which is inadequate for both Teacher Education
                           Programmes and not as per NCTE norms.

                          Staff salaries are paid in cash instead through bank and service benefits
                           CPF/GPF are not paid.
                         In view of the above, the Committee decided to issue a Showcause Notice to
                         the institution as to why the recognition be not withdrawn and thereby
                         providing an opportunity to the institution to make a written representation
                         within 30 days from the date of issue of the Notice along with necessary
                         certificates/documents in order to take a final decision in the matter; failing
                         which action will be taken including the withdrawal, based on the records

                                                    49

         (Gangadharaiah)                                                      (Prof. C. Thangamuthu)
       Regional Director, SRC, NCTE                                           Chairman, SRC, NCTE
                                                                                            th
                                                                                        198 Meeting of SRC
                                                                                       th  h
                                                                                     24 -26 November 2010

                            available, with no further notice.

55.     AOSO0493            Shreyas Teacher Training Institute, Ramakrishna Extension, Srinivasapura Taluk,
         APS03222
                            Kolar District-563135, Karnataka submitted an application for grant of recognition on
           D.Ed
          D.Ed-AI           31.12.2003 for D.Ed-AI course. The institution was granted recognition for offering
      Shreyas Teacher
                            D.Ed – AI with an existing intake of 90 students and and additional intake of 30
      Training Institute,
                            students thus making an annual intake of 120 students vide order dated 15.12.2004.
            Kolar
             KA
                            In the mean time NCTE, Hqrs vide its letter dated 19.11.2010 has forwarded a
                            copy of the inspection report dated 14.06.2010 conducted Under Section 13 of
                            NCTE Act. As there are deficiencies pointed out in the inspection report,
                            NCTE, Hqrs has decided that SRC, NCTE may look into the matter to
                            ascertain the adherence of norms and standards by the institution and
                            requested to take appropraiate action.
                            The Committee considered the VT Report,VCD and all the relevant documentary
                            evidences and it was decided to serve Show cause Notice Under Section 17 of
                            NCTE Act for the following deficiencies:

                             The management is running D.Ed programmes of 3 units.The Built area is
                              only 1466 Sq.mtrs, taking into account the overall measurement which is
                              grossly inadequate. As per NCTE Norms, 21,000 Sq.ft of built up area is
                              required for three units of D.Ed.

                             The management is paying the salaries to staff by cash, not through bank.

                             Service benefits CPF/GPF to staff member are not paid.

                             No. of books in the library is only 2355 and journals/periodicals are only four,
                              this is inadequate for three units of the programmes being run by the
                              institution.
                            In view of the above, the Committee decided to issue a Showcause Notice to
                            the institution as to why the recognition be not withdrawn and thereby
                            providing an opportunity to the institution to make a written representation
                            within 30 days from the date of issue of the Notice along with necessary
                            certificates/documents in order to take a final decision in the matter; failing
                            which action will be taken including the withdrawal, based on the records
                            available, with no further notice.




                                                       50

         (Gangadharaiah)                                                       (Prof. C. Thangamuthu)
       Regional Director, SRC, NCTE                                            Chairman, SRC, NCTE
                                                                                              th
                                                                                          198 Meeting of SRC
                                                                                         th  h
                                                                                       24 -26 November 2010



         Section 14 Inspection Report

56.          APS09586     Ballary Rudrappa Education Society,Ballary Rudrappa Education Society‟s B.Ed
                          College, Motebennur P.O, Byadgi Taluk, 84-2 & 82/b/2, Byadgi Road, Haveri District-
              B.Ed
                          581136, Karnataka has submitted application for offering B.Ed course on 27.08.2008.
      Ballary    Rudrappa The recognition has been refused to the institution vide order dated 29.05.2009.
      Education Society‟s
                             The institution preferred an appeal and the Appellate Authority, NCTE, New Delhi has
      B.Ed          College, confirmed the rejection order of SRC vide order dated 11.09.2009.
      Haveri
                              Aggrieved by the rejection order of the Appellate Authority, NCTE, New Delhi, the
               KA             institution has filed W.P.No.66762 / 2002 in the Hon'ble High Court of Karnataka,
                              Circuit Bench at Dharwad. The writ petition has been disposed of directing the
                              petitioners to make an application for inspection to the NCTE within one week with
                              requisite fees and was further pleased to direct the NCTE to inspect the institution
                              within 6 weeks from today in accordance with law, without waiting for the certified
                              copy.

                              In obedience to the court directions, the institution has submitted application along
                              with requisite fee on 13.07.2010.

                              The SRC in its 194th meeting held on 30-22 July 2010 considered the matter and
                              decided to call for documents/ clarification. Accordingly, a notice was issued to the
                              institution on 30.08.2010. The institution submitted the written representation on
                              13.09.2010. along with duly filed in Questionnaire.

                              The SRC in its 196th meeting held on 15-16 September 2010 considered the
                              representation and decided to cause inspection.

                              Accordingly, inspection was carried out on 20th October 2010.

                              The Committee considered the VT Report,VCD and all the relevant
                              documentary evidences and it was decided to serve Show cause Notice Under
                              Section 17 of NCTE Act for the following deficiencies:

                               The management has to submit a certificate from the concerned affiliating
                                body/university that no other courses is being run in the said
                                building/premises.

                               Building Completion Certificate from the competent Government Engineer is
                                to be submitted.

                               Non-Encumbrance Certificate from the competent Government Authorised
                                person / Authorities is to be submitted.

                               The land documents are in regional language Kannada, the management has
                                to furnish the same in English version.

                                                          51

           (Gangadharaiah)                                                       (Prof. C. Thangamuthu)
         Regional Director, SRC, NCTE                                            Chairman, SRC, NCTE
                                                                                                th
                                                                                           198 Meeting of SRC
                                                                                          th  h
                                                                                        24 -26 November 2010

                             Library books available in the library is only 663 and journals/periodicals are
                              5, these are to be provided as per the NCTE norms.

                            In view of the above, the Committee decided to issue a Showcause Notice to
                            the institution as to why application for grant of the recognition be rejected and
                            thereby providing an opportunity to the institution to make a written
                            representation within 30 days from the date of issue of the Notice along with
                            necessary certificates/documents in order to take a final decision in the matter;
                            failing which action will be taken including the refusal and rejection of
                            application, based on the records available, with no further notice.

57.       APS09751          Sri.Gullappa Upanal D.Ed College, 142/2, Muktimandir, Laxmeshwara, Sirahatti, Gadag

              D.Ed          – 582116, Karnataka was refused recognition on 10.08.2009.
      Sri Gullappa Upanal
                            The institution preferred appeal and the Appellate Authority in the order dated
      D.Ed College,         05.01.2010 has confirmed the refusal order of SRC.
      Gadag
                            Now, this office is in receipt of Court order vide judgement dated 21.09.2010 (copy
              KA
                            enclosed) in W.P.62506 of 2010 filed by The President, Shri.Jagadguru
                            Veeragangadhar Shivacharya Trikoti Shivalinga Trust‟s Sri.Gullappa Upanal D.Ed
                            College,    Gadag,        Karnataka   (APS09751)       in          the   Hon'ble    High
                            Court of Karnataka Circuit Bench at Dharwad and has disposed of the case. The
                            order reads as follows:

                            “……. it is open to the petitioner to inform the respondent-authorities and pay the
                            requisite fees whereupon the respondent-authorities shall arrange to make the
                            inspection to satisfy themselves regarding the compliance of the deficiencies. If the
                            deficiencies are complied with, the authorities are directed to take action in
                            accordance with law for grant of recognition for the subsequent year.”

                            A copy of the judgement has been forwarded to NCTE, Hqrs.

                            The SRC in its 197th meeting held on 13-14, october 2010 considered the court order
                            and decided to cause inspection.

                            Accordingly, inspection was carried out on 09-11.2010. The inspection report has
                            been received along with VCD.

                            The Committee considered the VT Report,VCD and all the relevant
                            documentary evidences and it was decided to serve Show cause Notice Under
                            Section 17 of NCTE Act for the following deficiencies:

                             The management has to submit a certificate from the concerned affiliating
                              body/university that no other courses is being run in the said
                              building/premises.

                                                         52

           (Gangadharaiah)                                                     (Prof. C. Thangamuthu)
         Regional Director, SRC, NCTE                                          Chairman, SRC, NCTE
                                                                                              th
                                                                                          198 Meeting of SRC
                                                                                         th  h
                                                                                       24 -26 November 2010



                           As per the VT and VCD reports the building of the institution is incomplete.

                           In new building Doors & Windows are yet to be fixed, conducting the classes
                            in a such a building is unsafe.

                           Internet facility is not available.

                          In view of the above, the Committee decided to issue a Showcause Notice to
                          the institution as to why application for grant of the recognition be rejected and
                          thereby providing an opportunity to the institution to make a written
                          representation within 30 days from the date of issue of the Notice along with
                          necessary certificates/documents in order to take a final decision in the matter;
                          failing which action will be taken including the refusal and rejection of
                          application based on the records available, with no further notice.



         Section 17 Inspection Report:

58.       APS03280        SRC-NCTE granted recognition to Ruben College of Education, Kanyakumari District,
                          Tamilnadu for B.Ed course vide order no. F.TN.SEC/SRO/NCTE/2005-2006/1591
            B.Ed
                          dated 7.7.2005 with an intake of 100 students from the academic session 2005-06.
      Ruben College of
      Education,          Meantime, NCTE-Hqrs. has forwarded W.P. No. 910 of 2006 filed by Shri. R. Jenson
                          Muthraj against Ruben College of Education, Kanyakumari District, Tamilnadu. In the
      Kanyakumari
                          writ petition the petitioner alleged that the institution claims to own 4 acres 95 cents of
              TN          land in the same location, a school having class 1 to XII is running.

                          In response to the above letter, it has been informed to NCTE-Hqrs. vide our letter
                          dated 3.1.2007 that surprise inspection will be conducted and the report will be
                          placed. But, no such inspection has been conducted and no further action has been
                          taken.

                          Meanwhile, a requisition letter has been received from the institution on 26.7.2010,
                          stated that they have started running the institution during the academic year 2005-
                          2006 in accordance to the reference. As per the prevailing norms that in that period
                          an extend of 5 acres of land was desirable for 4000 sq.mt of land, and requested to
                          issue the permission, that the excess land may be utilized for staring an other
                          institution.

                          The matter was considered by the Committee in its 195th meeting held on 17th-18th
                          August 2010 and it was decided to cause inspection of the institution for B.Ed.
                          Course, under Section 17 of NCTE Act, after payment of Rs. 40,000/- inspection fee
                          and on submission of filled in Questionnaire, along with relevant supporting
                          documents relating to building, land, including Building Completion Certificate from
                          the competent Government Engineer and Land Use Certificate, within four weeks
                          from the date of confirmation of the Minutes.


                                                       53

           (Gangadharaiah)                                                      (Prof. C. Thangamuthu)
         Regional Director, SRC, NCTE                                           Chairman, SRC, NCTE
                                                                                                 th
                                                                                            198 Meeting of SRC
                                                                                           th  h
                                                                                         24 -26 November 2010

                              Accordingly a letter has been issued to the institution on 22.09.2010 to submit the
                              D.D. of Rs.40000/- alongwith essential documents. The institution submitted its reply
                              on 18.10.2010 alongwith Rs.40000/-.

                              The inspection of the institution was carried out on 22.10.2010.

                              The Committee considered the VT Report,VCD and all the relevant
                              documentary evidences and it was decided to serve Show cause Notice Under
                              Section 17 of NCTE Act for the following deficiencies:

                               The management is running the institution for D.T.Ed, B.Ed & M.Ed
                                programmes and sharing the building with a School programme in the same
                                building, which is against the NCTE norms.

                               The management is running D.T.Ed, B.Ed programme along with M.Ed course
                                in the same premises. The total area earmarked for the course i.e, for B.Ed is
                                15300 sq.mts and for M.Ed is 38660 Sq.ft in the questionnaire, but as per VT
                                report built up area earmarked for the course B.Ed– 6455 Sq.ft, and M.Ed
                                sharing with B.Ed. The total Built up area for B.Ed and M.Ed is 16445 Sq.ft,
                                which is inadequate as per the NCTE norms. Only two rooms are earmarked
                                for M.Ed programme as per VT report, but the questionnaire data gives
                                38,660 Sq.ft for M.Ed programme. This discrepancy may be explained.

                               A Certificate from the Government Affiliating body to the effect that no other
                                programme is being conducted by the institution in the same building /
                                Campus, along with the existing Course is to be submitted.

                               Total area of the land, area of the site as per building plan & total built up
                                area as per building plan is not mentioned/given.

                               Psychology lab needs to be strengthened.

                               Language learning lab is not available.

                              In view of the above, the Committee decided to issue a Showcause Notice to
                              the institution as to why the recognition be not withdrawn and thereby
                              providing an opportunity to the institution to make a written representation
                              within 30 days from the date of issue of the Notice along with necessary
                              certificates/documents in order to take a final decision in the matter; failing
                              which action will be taken including the withdrawal, based on the records
                              available, with no further notice.

59.        APS04710           All Saints College of Education, Kanyakumari, Tamilnadu was granted recognition for
                              offering B.Ed course with an intake of 100 students on 05.09.2006 with the condition
               B.Ed
                              to shift to own premises within 3 years.
      All Saints College of
      Education,              Meantime, the Ministry of Human Resource Development (MHRD), Government of
                              India, based on the inquiry report submitted by Sri.Sathyam, IAS (Retd) has directed
      Kanyakumari
                              NCTE for taking action. In this regard, it has been envisaged that all the cases
                                                          54

           (Gangadharaiah)                                                        (Prof. C. Thangamuthu)
         Regional Director, SRC, NCTE                                             Chairman, SRC, NCTE
                                                                                 th
                                                                             198 Meeting of SRC
                                                                            th  h
                                                                          24 -26 November 2010

    TN           cleared by SRC in its 116th meeting held 22-23 August 2006 should be re-inspected
                 and the maintenance of Norms and Standards should be verified.

                 The above institution was one amongst 71 institutions which was granted recognition
                 in the 116th meeting. Based on the directions of MHRD, inspection under section 17
                 of the above institution was carried out on 18.12.2008. The VT report, VCD, original
                 application file along with other documents were placed before SRC in its 170th
                 meeting held on 16-17 February 2009. SRC decided to issue notice under section 17
                 of NCTE Act, for the deficiencies noted. Accordingly, notice was issued to the
                 institution on 02.04.2009. the institution submitted its reply on 15.04.2009.

                 SRC in its 178th meeting held on 13-14 July 2009 considered the reply wherein SRC
                 noted that the second floor of the building is completed after inspection. The
                 Committee decided to cause inspection to verify the built up space available after
                 completion of building after payment of Rs.40000/- for inspection fees.

                 Accordingly a letter was issued to the institution on 25.08.2009. The institution has
                 not submitted the required fee and documents.

                 Meanwhile, SRC in its 181st meeting held on 20-21st August 2009 where in it was
                 decided that the institution which have not shifted to the permanent premises even
                 after the expiry of three years time limit be issued notice under section 17 of NCTE
                 Act for further action. But the notice was not issued then. Hence the matter was
                 brought to the notice. As directed on 15.07.2010, a notice as decided in 181st SRC
                 meeting was issued on 23.7.2010. The institution has submitted its reply on
                 12.08.2010.

                 The matter was considered by the Committee in its 195th meeting held 17th-18th
                 August 2010 and it was decided to cause inspection of the institution for B.Ed.
                 Course, under Section 17 of NCTE Act, after payment of Rs.40,000/- inspection fee
                 and on submission of filled in Questionnaire, along with relevant supporting
                 documents relating to building, land, including Building Completion Certificate from
                 the competent Government Engineer and Land Use Certificate, within four weeks
                 from the date of confirmation of the Minutes.

                 Accordingly a letter has been issued to the institution to submit the above documents
                 on 22.09.2010. The institution submitted the documents with the VT members but not
                 submitted Rs.40000/-.

                 The inspection of the institution was conducted on 23.10.2010

                 The Committee considered the VT Report,VCD and all the relevant
                 documentary evidences and it was decided to serve Show cause Notice Under
                 Section 17 of NCTE Act for the following deficiencies:

                  A Certificate from the Government Affiliating body to the effect that no other
                   programme is being conducted by the institution in the same building /
                   Campus, along with the existing Course is to be submitted.

                                            55

  (Gangadharaiah)                                                   (Prof. C. Thangamuthu)
Regional Director, SRC, NCTE                                        Chairman, SRC, NCTE
                                                                                             th
                                                                                         198 Meeting of SRC
                                                                                        th  h
                                                                                      24 -26 November 2010

                             Psychology lab, ET and Science lab needs to be strengthened.

                             Language learning lab is not available.

                             Total built up area of the building is not clearly mentioned in the Building
                              plan.

                            In view of the above, the Committee decided to issue a Showcause Notice to
                            the institution as to why the recognition be not withdrawn and thereby
                            providing an opportunity to the institution to make a written representation
                            within 30 days from the date of issue of the Notice along with necessary
                            certificates/documents in order to take a final decision in the matter; failing
                            which action will be taken including the withdrawal, based on the records
                            available, with no further notice.

60.        APS09699         An application was submitted by Sri Shiridi Sai Educational Society, Kadapa, Andhra
                            Pradesh for grant of recognition to D.Ed course in the office of SRC-NCTE Bangalore
              D.Ed
                            vide dated 30.10.2008
      Sri Sai Teacher
      Training Institute,   The file was under process and in the meanwhile, in view of the recommendations of
                            the State Government of Andhra Pradesh vide letter dated 07.01.2009 not to further
      Kadapa
                            recognise/permit the institutions for conducting B.Ed,D.Ed, physical education,
               AP           Language Pandit course(s)

                            SRC in its 169th meeting held on 12-13th January,2009 having considered the letter
                            dated 07.01.2009 of state government of Andhra Pradesh and decided to give effect
                            to the decision of above decision of State Government of Andhra Pradesh as such,
                            with immediate effect.

                            A letter dated 07.02.2009 forwarded by Principal Secretary of Education requesting
                            not to accord further recognition/permission to the new colleges/private B.Ed, D.Ed,
                            Physical Education, Language pandit in the state of Andhra Pradesh as the above
                            colleges are exceeding in numbers than required.

                            A letter dated 17th March, 2009 has been received form NCTE Hqrs informing that the
                            “The recommendations of the Govt. of Andhra Pradesh not to grant
                            recognition/permission in respect of other Courses like B.Ed , D.Ed and Physical
                            Education courses have further been considered in NCTE and it has been decided
                            that no further recognition/Permission to any institution in the state of Andhra
                            Pradesh be considered by SRC for the academic session 2009-10 for B.Ed , D.Ed
                            and Physical Education courses also‟‟.

                            The state Government vide its letter dated 20.03.2009 informed that it has been
                            decided not to recommended the name of the institution.

                            The letter dated 07.01.2009, 07.02.2009 and 17.03.2009 were considered by SRC in
                            its 172nd meeting held on 25th-26th March 2009 and SRC decided to accept the
                            recommendation of the State government of Andhra Pradesh, not to grant recognition
                            to any of the Teacher Training Institution in the state of Andhra Pradesh for the year
                                                        56

           (Gangadharaiah)                                                     (Prof. C. Thangamuthu)
         Regional Director, SRC, NCTE                                          Chairman, SRC, NCTE
                                                                                     th
                                                                                 198 Meeting of SRC
                                                                                th  h
                                                                              24 -26 November 2010

                 2009-10 and decided to close the applications.

                 As per the direction of SRC a letter was issued to the institution on 18.04.2009.

                 The institution has approached to Hon‟ble High      court of Andhra Pradesh
                 W.P.11038/2009 without making appeal to appellate authority under section 18 of
                 NCTE Act.

                    Hon‟ble High court has passed order dated first day of June, two thousand and
                    ten. The operative part of order as under:-
                 These Writ Petitions raise common issues. Therefore, with the consent of the
                 learned counsel for the parties, they are taken up for hearing and disposal together.

                 In all these Writ petitions, the petitioners, which are educational Institutions, felt
                 aggrieved by non-consideration of their applications for grant of recognition to
                 D.Ed/B.Ed courses purportedly on the ground of the policy decision taken by the
                 Government not to permit establishment of new D.Ed/B.Ed Colleges.

                 At the hearing, Sri Andapalli Sanjeev Kumar, learned counsel appearing for the
                 petitioners in Writ petition Nos.11038, 11040, 11587 and 10965 of 2009, and Sri S.
                 Girimoji Rao, learned counsel for the petitioner in Writ petition No.11241 of 2009,
                 submitted that the petitioners filed their applications for recognition prior to the policy
                 decision taken by the State Government; and that in an identical Writ petition, this
                 Court, vide: order dated 16-12-2009 in writ petition No.6712 of 2009, held as under:

                 “It may be true the State Government as well the first respondent have reviewed the
                 situation as to the necessity or otherwise of according permission to establish new
                 colleges of education in the State in further and that the existing institutions are fond
                 to be adequate. However, the right that is accrued to the petitioners on the basis of
                 their application and the consideration there of by the first respondent cannot be
                 taken away on account of the change of policy. It is settled principle of law that
                 whenever an application is made, it must be considered and processed in
                 accordance with the provisions of law or the policy that existed as on the date of
                 presentation. Subsequent changes may apply to the applications that are made
                 thereafter.

                 Hence, the writ petition is disposed of directing the first respondent to take necessary
                 steps as contemplated in its communication dated 24-11-2009 and pass appropriate
                 orders.
                 There shall be no order as to coasts”.

                 The learned Standing Counsel representing respondents 2 and 3 has not disputed
                 the above position.

                 Since the issue raised in these Writ Petitions are squarely covered by the above
                 mentioned orders, these Writ petitions are disposed of in terms of the above
                 mentioned orders in writ petition No.6712 of 2009 with the direction that the directions
                 given in the said orders shall form part of this orders.

                                              57

  (Gangadharaiah)                                                      (Prof. C. Thangamuthu)
Regional Director, SRC, NCTE                                           Chairman, SRC, NCTE
                                                                                           th
                                                                                       198 Meeting of SRC
                                                                                      th  h
                                                                                    24 -26 November 2010

                          Prior to closure of the application a deficiency letter dated 05.11.2008 was issued to
                          the institution and institution vide letter dated 05.01.2009 has sought to rectify the
                          deficiencies.

                          The explanation, affidavit and BCC are placed in file. The fee submitted by the
                          institution is available with SRC as the same was not refunded earlier. The institution
                          has vide letter dated 05.07.2010 requested for necessary action in terms of court
                          orders.

                          However, BCC certificate in prescribed format and FDR of Rs.5 lakhs & Rs.3 lakhs
                          were required.
                          SRC considered the matter and directed the Management/institution to resubmit the
                          old application returned by SRC along with necessary documents as originally
                          submitted relating to land, building, FDR, Application fee, Building Completion
                          Certificate from competent Government Engineer/ authority and other relevant
                          aspects for processing and for necessary action.


                          As per direction of SRC a letter has been sent to the institution on 31.08.2010, in
                          response to this office letter dated 31.08.2010 the institution has submitted reply
                          letter dated 07.09.2010.

                          The matter was placed in 197th meeting held on 13-14 October 2010 the committee
                          considered the matter and decided to cause inspection.
                          The inspection was carried out on 26.10.2010.

                          On careful perusal of the VT Report, VCD and original file of the institution,
                          court order and other related documents, Act of NCTE, 1993, Regulations and
                          guidelines of NCTE published from time to time laid on the table, the Regional
                          Committee decided to issue Letter of Intent for grant of recognition to D.Ed
                          course of two years duration with an annual intake of 50(Fifty only)(one unit)
                          for the academic year 2010-11 subject to the appointment of qualified staff
                          through duly constituted selection committee as per the Norms of NCTE/State
                          Government/Affiliating University and be given            effect before the
                          commencement of the academic session.

61.       APS09523        An application was submitted by Deekshitha Telugu Training College, Takkol Village,
                          Sidhout Mandal, kadapa Distt, Andhra Pradesh for grant of recognition to TPT
             TPT
                          Course in the office of SRC-NCTE Bangalore vide dated 21.05.2008.
      Deekshitha TPT
      College, Kadapa     The file was under process and in the meanwhile, in view of the recommendations of
                          the State Govt of Andhra Pradesh not to further recognize/permit the institutions for
              AP
                          conducting Language pandit teacher training Course (S), a public notice was issued
                          on 01.10.2008 to this effect that application for Language pandit Courses from the
                          State of Andhra Pradesh will not be considered for the academic session 2009-2010
                          and all such applications shall be returned along with processing fees and
                          documents.

                                                      58

           (Gangadharaiah)                                                    (Prof. C. Thangamuthu)
         Regional Director, SRC, NCTE                                         Chairman, SRC, NCTE
                                                                                           th
                                                                                    198 Meeting of SRC
                                                                                       h
                                                                                      th
                                                                                 24 -26 November 2010

                 Another letter 07.01.2009 received from the Principal Secretary Department of
                 School Education, Govt of Andhra Pradesh and decision of the NCTE Hqrs vide letter
                 dated 20.01.2009 for not to accord further recognition‟s/permissions to the new
                 College, interalia for Language pandit training course. SRC in its 169th meeting held
                 on 12-13th January, 2009 having considered the letter dated 07.01.2009 of the State
                 Govt of Andhra pradesh and decided to give effect to the above decision of State
                 Govt of Andhra pradesh as such, with immediate effect. Therefore SRC returned the
                 application along with the processing fee of Rs. 40,000/- vide D.D bearing no
                 044460 dated 20.03.2009       with inform to the institution the Deekshitha Telugu
                 pandit Training College, Takkol Village, Sidhout Mandal, Kadapa Distt, Andhra
                 Pradesh here by closed and same returned in the SRC office due to Undelivered.

                 The institution ignored to approached the Appellate authority NCTE Head Quarters
                 and directly approached to Hon‟ble High Court in writ petition no 13153/2010
                 wherein the Hon‟ble High court passed an order as under:-

                 This writ petition is filed for the following substantive relief:-

                 “ to issue a writ, order or direction more particularly one in the nature of writ of
                 Mandamus to declare the policy decision of the 1st respondent not to permit any
                 recognition for further private B.Ed/D.Ed/Private Physical Education/Private
                 Language pandit training colleges, as communicated vide the impugned proceedings
                 in letter No. 22525/Trg./A1/2008 dated 07.01.2009 to the respondents 2 and 3 as
                 arbitrary illegal, and the consequential action of the 3rd respondent in rejecting the
                 application of the petitioner submitted on 03.05.2008 for grant of recognition to TPT
                 course vide impugned proceeding no.              F. SRC?NCTE/2008-09/10912 dated
                 20.03.2009 on account of the impugned policy of the respondent no. 1 as arbitrary,
                 illegal, contrary to the provisions of National Council for Teacher Education Act 1993
                 and regulations made thereunder and issue a consequential direction to the
                 respondents 2 and 3 to grant recognition to the TPT Course to the petitioner.”

                 At the hearing, it is agreed by the learned counsel appearing for the respective
                 parties that the issue in this writ petition is covered by order dated 01.06.2010
                 passed by this court in Writ petition nos. 11038 of 2009 and batch.

                 Following the said order, this writ petition is disposed of with the direction that the
                 said order forms part of this order.

                 As a sequel to disposal of the writ petition, WPMP.No. 16577 of 2010 filed by the
                 petitioner for interim relief is disposed of as infructuous.

                 Direction of Hon‟ble High Court in Writ Petition No. 11038/2009 is produced below:-

                 “ It May be true that the State Govt as well as the first respondent have reviewed the
                 situation as to the necessity or otherwise of according permission to establish new
                 colleges of education in the state in future and that the existing institutions are found
                 to be adequate. However the right that is accrued to the petitioners on the basis of
                 their application and the consideration thereof by the first respondent cannot be taken
                 away on account of the change of policy . It is settled principle of law that whenever
                                                59

  (Gangadharaiah)                                                         (Prof. C. Thangamuthu)
Regional Director, SRC, NCTE                                              Chairman, SRC, NCTE
                                                                                  th
                                                                              198 Meeting of SRC
                                                                             th  h
                                                                           24 -26 November 2010

                 an application is made, it must be considered and processed in accordance with the
                 provisions of law or the policy that existed as on the date of presentation. Subsequent
                 changes may apply to the applications that are made thereafter.

                 Hence, the writ petition is disposed of directing the first respondent state of Andhra
                 Pradesh to take necessary steps as contemplated in its communication dated
                 24.11.2009 and pass appropriate orders. There shall be no order as to costs.”

                 The learned Standing Counsel representing respondents 2 NCTE and 3 SRC, NCTE
                 has not disputed the above position.‟

                 Since the issues raised in these writ petitions are squarely covered by the above
                 mentioned order, these writ petitions are disposed of in terms of the above mentioned
                 order, in Writ petition no 6712 of 2009 with the direction that the directions given in
                 the said order shall form part of this order.”

                 Before closing the file SRC had issued a deficiency letter on 24.10.2008. The
                 institution had submitted its reply dated 17.11.2008.

                 The matter was considered by the Committee in its 194th meeting held on 21-22 July
                 2010 and it was decided to call for the following documents from the institution, for
                 further processing and action:-

                  Demand Draft of Rs.40,000/- in the name of Member Secretary, NCTE payable at
                   Bangalore.
                  Land documents of the new building/location for having own land in the name of
                   the institution/locality/Trust.
                  Building Plan for the new building duly approved by the Government authority in
                   the prescribed format.
                  Building Completion Certificate from the Government authority in the prescribed
                   format.
                  Land Usage Certificate from the Government authority.
                  Encumbrance Certificate from the Government authority.
                  Fixed Deposit of Rs.5 lakhs and Rs. 3 lakhs kept in joint account with SRC in the
                   Nationalized Bank for a period of 5 years towards Endowment Fund and Reserve
                   Fund in original.
                  Certificate of Registration/Bye-law of the Society/Trust.
                  The Affidavit in Rs.100/- stamp paper in the prescribed format with notary
                   attestation.

                 The institution submitted its written representation on 23.09.2010.
                 The matter was placed in 197th meeting held on 13-14 October 2010 the committee
                 considered the matter and decided to cause inspection.

                 The Committee considered the VT Report,VCD and all the relevant
                 documentary evidences and it was decided to serve Show cause Notice Under
                 Section 17 of NCTE Act for the following:


                                             60

  (Gangadharaiah)                                                    (Prof. C. Thangamuthu)
Regional Director, SRC, NCTE                                         Chairman, SRC, NCTE
                                                                                             th
                                                                                         198 Meeting of SRC
                                                                                        th  h
                                                                                      24 -26 November 2010

                             As per the Building completion certificate of the institution (APS09523), the
                              total built up area earmarked for the Telugu Pandit Training programme is
                              27776.26 Sq.ft, But in VT report the earmarked for the proposed course is
                              18169.8 Sq.ft. The discrepancy of the built up area between the BCC and VT
                              report may be explained.

                             The management has to submit a certificate from the concerned affiliating
                              body/university that no other courses is being run in the said
                              building/premises.

                            In view of the above, the Committee decided to issue a Showcause Notice to
                            the institution as to why application for grant of the recognition be rejected and
                            thereby providing an opportunity to the institution to make a written
                            representation within 30 days from the date of issue of the Notice along with
                            necessary certificates/documents in order to take a final decision in the matter;
                            failing which action will be taken including the refusal & rejection of application
                            based on the records available, with no further notice.

62.        APS09429         An application was submitted by Sri Sai Rural Educational Society, Srikakulam
                            District, Andhra Pradesh for grant of recognition to B.Ed course in the office of SRC-
              B.Ed
                            NCTE, vide dated 27.03.2008
      Sri Sai Educational
      Society, Srikakulam   The file was under process and in the meanwhile, in view of the recommendations of
                            the State Government of Andhra Pradesh vide letter dated 07.01.2009 not to further
              AP
                            recognise/permit the institutions for conducting B.Ed, D.Ed, Physical Education,
                            Language Pandit course(s). The SRC in its 169th Meeting held on 12-13 January,
                            2009 having considered the letter dated 07.01.2009 of State Government of Andhra
                            Pradesh and decided to give effect to the above decision of State Government of
                            Andhra Pradesh as such, with immediate effect.

                            A letter dated 07.02.2009 was also forwarded by Principal Secretary of Education
                            requesting not to accord further recognition/permission to the new colleges/private
                            B.Ed, D.Ed, Physical Education, Language Pandit in the State of Andhra Pradesh as
                            the above colleges are exceeding in numbers than required.

                            A letter dated 17.03.2009 has been received from NCTE, Hqrs informing that the
                            “The recommendations of the Govt. of Andhra Pradesh not to grant
                            recognition/permission in respect of other courses like B.Ed, D.Ed and Physical
                            Education courses have further been decided that no further Recognition/ Permission
                            to any institution in the State of Andhra Pradesh be considered by SRC for the
                            academic session 2009-2010 for B.Ed, D.Ed, and Physical Education courses also”.
                            The State Government vide its letter dated 20.03.2009 informed that it has been
                            decided not to recommend the name of this institution. The letters dated 07.01.2009,
                            07.02.2009, 17.03.2009 and 20.03.2009 were considered by SRC in its 172nd
                            Meeting held on 25-26 March, 2009 and SRC decided to accept the recommendation
                            of the State Government of Andhra Pradesh, not to grant recognition to any of the
                            Teacher Training Institutions in the State of Andhra Pradesh for the year 2009-2010
                            and decided to close the applications.

                                                        61

           (Gangadharaiah)                                                     (Prof. C. Thangamuthu)
         Regional Director, SRC, NCTE                                          Chairman, SRC, NCTE
                                                                                   th
                                                                               198 Meeting of SRC
                                                                              th  h
                                                                            24 -26 November 2010

                 As per the decision of SRC the application was closed on 28.04.2009

                 The Institute has approached to Hon‟ble High Court in W.P.No.14203/2010.

                 Now, the Hon‟ble High Court has passed an order on 02.06.2010 vide W.P.No.14203
                 of 2010 reads as hereunder:
                 “It may be true that the State Government as well as the first respondent have
                 reviewed the situation as to the necessary or otherwise of according permission to
                 establish new colleges of education in the State in future and that the existing
                 institutions are found to be adequate. However, the right that is accrued to the
                 petitioners on the basis of their application and the consideration thereof by the first
                 respondent cannot be taken away on account of the change of policy. It is settled
                 principle of law that whenever an application is made, it must be considered and
                 processed in accordance with the provisions of law that existed as on the date of
                 presentation. Subsequent changes may apply to the applications that are made
                 thereafter.
                 Hence, the writ petition is disposed of directing the first respondent to take necessary
                 steps as contemplated in its communication dated 24.11.2009 and pass appropriate
                 orders. There shall be no order as to costs.”
                  The file was closed at the stage where, BCC from competent authority was called
                 for.
                 The institution as per records has submitted BCC on 24.12.2008 as asked by this
                 office from Government Engineer.

                 The institution has now sent D.D No.4412091 dated 06.07.2010 for Rs.40000/- and
                 requested to cause inspection as per court order. While closing the institution‟s
                 application SRC had returned processing fee of Rs.40,000/- . Further the institution is
                 now required to submit FDRs of Rs.5 lakhs and Rs.3 lakhs in view of court order.

                 The matter was considered by the Committee and it was decided to Call for the
                 following documents from the institution, for further processing and action:-
                  Demand Draft of Rs.40,000/- in the name of Member Secretary, NCTE payable at
                   Bangalore.
                  Land documents of the new building/location for having own land in the name of
                   the institution/locality/Trust.
                  Building Plan, new building duly approved by the Government authority in the
                   prescribed format.
                  Building Completion Certificate from the Government authority in the prescribed
                   format.
                  Land Usage Certificate from the Government authority.
                  Encumbrance Certificate from the Government authority.
                  Fixed Deposit of Rs.5 lakhs and Rs. 3 lakhs kept in joint account with SRC in the
                   Nationalized Bank for a period of 5 years towards Endowment Fund and Reserve
                   Fund in original.
                  Certificate of Registration/Bye-law of the Society/Trust.

                  The Affidavit in Rs.100/- stamp paper in the prescribed format with notary
                   attestation.
                                              62

  (Gangadharaiah)                                                     (Prof. C. Thangamuthu)
Regional Director, SRC, NCTE                                          Chairman, SRC, NCTE
                                                                                              th
                                                                                          198 Meeting of SRC
                                                                                         th  h
                                                                                       24 -26 November 2010



                          As per direction of SRC a letter was issued to the institution on 31.08.2010 with
                          request to submit above documents. In response to this office letter dated 31.08.2010
                          the institution has submitted reply vide letter dated 17.09.20010.

                          The SRC considered the Hon‟ble court orders and all the relevant documents and
                          decided to take further action in the matter including the visit of the institution subject
                          to the fulfilment of all the requirements by the institution as per the norms and
                          regulations.

                          The institution submitted its written representation on 17.9.2010 along with Rs.
                          40.000/-

                          The inspection was done on 09.11.2010..
                          The Committee considered the VT Report,VCD and all the relevant
                          documentary evidences and it was decided to serve Show cause Notice Under
                          Section 17 of NCTE Act for the following deficiencies:

                           A Certificate from the Government Affiliating body to the effect that no other
                            programme is being run by the institution in the same building / Campus,
                            along with the existing Course B.Ed to be submitted.

                           The FDRs of Rs. 5 lakhs and 3 lakhs are to be submitted from a Nationalised
                            Bank.

                           The latest Building Completion Certificate from the competent Government
                            Engineer has not been submitted.

                          In view of the above, the Committee decided to issue a Showcause Notice to
                          the institution as to why the application for grant of the recognition be not
                          rejected and thereby providing an opportunity to the institution to make a
                          written representation within 30 days from the date of issue of the Notice along
                          with necessary certificates/documents in order to take a final decision in the
                          matter; failing which action will be taken including the refusal and rejection of
                          application. based on the records available, with no further notice.

63.       APS09331        An application was submitted by Arundhathi Educational society, Ranga Reddy Dist,
                          Andhra Pradesh for grant of recognition to D.Ed. course in the office of SRC-NCTE
             D.Ed
                          Bangalore vide dated 05.08.2008. The file was under process and in the meanwhile,
      S.V. Model D.Ed
                          in view of the recommendations of the State Government of Andhra Pradesh vide
      College,            letter dated 07.01.2009 not to further recognize/permit the institutions for conducting
                          B.Ed, D.Ed, physical Education, Language Pandit course (S).
      Rangareddy
                          The SRC in its 169th meeting held on 12-13th January, 2009 having considered the
                 AP
                          letter dated 07.01.2009 of State Government of Andhra Pradesh and decided to give
                          effect to the decision of above decision of State Government of Andhra Pradesh as
                          such, with immediate effect. A letter dated 07.02.2009 forwarded by Principal
                                                       63

           (Gangadharaiah)                                                      (Prof. C. Thangamuthu)
         Regional Director, SRC, NCTE                                           Chairman, SRC, NCTE
                                                                                    th
                                                                                198 Meeting of SRC
                                                                               th  h
                                                                             24 -26 November 2010

                 Secretary of Education requesting not to accord further recognition/permission to the
                 new colleges/private B.Ed, D.Ed, Physical Education, Language Pandit in the state of
                 Andhra Pradesh as the above colleges are exceeding in numbers than required. A
                 letter dated 17the March, 2009 was received from NCTE Hqrs informing that the
                 “The recommendations of the Govt. of Andhra Pradesh not to grant
                 recognition/permission in respect of other courses like B.Ed, D.Ed, and Physical
                 Education courses have further been considered in NCTE and it has been decided
                 that no further recognition/permission to any institution in the state Andhra Pradesh
                 be considered by SRC for the academic session 2009-10 for B.Ed, D.Ed. and
                 physical Education Courses also”. The State Government vide its letter dated
                 20.03.2009 informed that it has been decided not to recommend the name of the
                 institution.
                 The State Govt. letter dated 07.01.2009, 07.02.2009, 17.03.2009 and 20.03.2009
                 were considered by SRC in its 172nd meeting held on 25th-26th March 2009 and SRC
                 decided to accept the recommendation of the State Government of Andhra Pradesh,
                 not to grant recognition to any of the Teacher Institutions in the state of Andhra
                 Pradesh for the year 2009-10 and decided to close the applications.
                  As per direction of Southern Regional committee a letter was sent to correspondent
                 of the institution on 22.04.2010 with intimation that the application submitted by
                 Arundhathi Educational Society, Ranga Reddy Dist, Andhra Pradesh here by closed.
                 No further correspondence whatsoever will be entertained in this regard.
                 Institution has approached Hon‟ble High Court of Andhra Pradesh at Hyderabad in
                 W.P.No.25762 of 2010 in writ petition no. 20287/2010 without approaching
                 Appellate authority NCTE under section 18 of NCTE Act, 1993. The Court order
                 dated 31.12.209 states as under –


                 “ In the light of the order passed by this court in the similar writ petitions WP no.
                 6712/2009, WP no. 9360/2010 and WP no. 11078/2010, there shall be a direction to
                 the first respondent to consider the petitioner‟s application for starting D.Ed course in
                 accordance with law without reference to the State Govt. „s policy dated 17.10.2009.”
                 Institution had previously submitted processing fee of Rs 40,000/-which is deposited
                 into NCTE Account.
                 The matter was placed before 196th meeting of SRC held on 15th –16th September,
                 2010, the Regional Committee decided to process the application.
                 The institution has submitted original FDR of five and three lacks, BCC dated
                 07.09.10, Affidavit dated 08.09.10 and copy of land documents for sy no. 250 situated
                 at Dommar Poohampally village, Quthbullapur Mandal, Ranga Reddy Distt, Andhra
                 Pradesh. The building plan on the said land are available in the file. The SRC may
                 provide names of VT Member for causing inspection. The SRC had vide its letter
                 dated 19.09.2008 sought consent of inspection for causing inspection and in view of
                 state Govt‟s ban the file was closed.

                 The SRC considered the matter and all relevant documents and decided to cause
                 inspection to examine whether the institution fulfils all the requirements as per the
                 norms, for the proposed programme.

                                              64

  (Gangadharaiah)                                                     (Prof. C. Thangamuthu)
Regional Director, SRC, NCTE                                          Chairman, SRC, NCTE
                                                                                             th
                                                                                         198 Meeting of SRC
                                                                                        th  h
                                                                                      24 -26 November 2010



                           The institution submitted its written representation on 09.11.2010.
                           The Committee considered the VT Report,VCD and all the relevant
                           documentary evidences and it was decided to serve Show cause Notice Under
                           Section 17 of NCTE Act for the following deficiencies:

                            As per the VCD observation it is found that the top floor roof of the building
                             is covered with asbestos sheets as evident from VCD. This is against the
                             NCTE norms. The building completion certificate issued by the competent
                             authority has not made any remarks regarding this.


                           In view of the above, the Committee decided to issue a Showcause Notice to
                           the institution as to why the recognition be not withdrawn and thereby
                           providing an opportunity to the institution to make a written representation
                           within 30 days from the date of issue of the Notice along with necessary
                           certificates/documents in order to take a final decision in the matter; failing
                           which action will be taken including the withdrawal, based on the records
                           available, with no further notice.

64.       APS00409         The institution has submitted an application for seeking grant of recognition for B.Ed.
                           course on 2.7.2001. The application was processed and after the inspection,
             B.Ed
                           recognition granted for B.Ed. course on 22.8.2002 with an intake of 90 students from
      Sree Narayana
                           the session 2002-2003.
      College of Teacher
                           A complaint was received from Sri. K.Jayaprakash, Thrissur, Kerala on 19.07.2010 in
      Education,           the office of SRC and SRC had written a letter to the complainant on 09.08.2010 with
                           the request to submit affidavit of Rs.100/-. In response to this office letter dated
      Kozhikode
                           09.08.2010 the complainant has submitted affidavit on 27.09.2010 and has raised the
              KL           following points against Sree Narayana College of Teacher Education, Kozikode
                           District Kerala.

                           “Sree Narayana College of Teacher Education, Chelannur, Kozhikode Dist. Was
                           started in the academic year 2001-02. The college did not get NCTE recognition in
                           the year 2001-02. regarding the affiliation of the university of Calicut, the University
                           granted an order No. GAI/D3/3407/99(2), dated 25.06.2001 which specifies that
                           affiliation will be granted subject to ratification by the syndicate and subject to the
                           approval of the NCTE.
                           The minutes of the syndicate item No. 2001.509, dated 20.07.2001 specifies

                           that classes should be started only after obtaining sanction from NCTE. But without
                           taking this into consideration, the college started in the academic year 2001-02. Later
                           the affiliation of the college was withdrawn by the university of Calicut because there
                           was no NCTE recognition for the college during the year 2001-02.

                           It is learnt that the above said college has not given proper application form the
                           prescribed fee of Rs.5000/- was not remitted for the year 2001-02 for NCTE
                           recognition. There was no report of the Calicut University Syndicate for starting new
                           college(Syndicate inspection committee in the year 2001-02 without any sanction.

                                                        65

           (Gangadharaiah)                                                      (Prof. C. Thangamuthu)
         Regional Director, SRC, NCTE                                           Chairman, SRC, NCTE
                                                                                     th
                                                                                198 Meeting of SRC
                                                                                th h
                                                                             24 -26 November 2010

                 B.Ed examination was conducted and Degree certificates were awarded to the
                 students of the college, in the university of Calicut.

                 The college continued in the year 2002-03 without proper documents and affiliations.
                 It is the violation of Calicut University first statute 1977 chapter 20 affiliation of the
                 colleges. The college has not followed the procedure under section 1 to section12.

                 The college management has violated all the norms, rules and regulations of the
                 University of Calicut. The university has awarded B.Ed degree to the students of the
                 above said college in the year 2001-02, even without NCTE recognition. The
                 university is well aware that the NCTE recognition is necessary for granting affiliation.
                 The management is a powerful management in the state of Kerala.

                 When asked through RTI act for the list of students appeared for the examination
                 during the year 2001-02, the university has replied that, the principal of the college
                 has been directed to provide the details directly. But the college principal has not
                 given me the details. The admission register of the college should be examined and
                 enquiry should be conducted regarding the matter of awarding B.Ed degree to
                 students studying in college without NCTE recognition in the year 2001-02 (I am
                 submitting the photocopy of the application for M.Ed Degree course in which the
                 college principal has specified this fact) and the same may be marked as EX A1.

                 It is understood that the college is still working temporary building number. There is
                 no permanent building number for the college. The chelannur Grama panchayath in
                 which the college is situated has given a detail that Door No. 12/408A is temporary
                 building in which the college is functioning. So there is no permanent building number
                 for the college. As per the NCTE norms, the college should have permanent building
                 number. A college which is started in the year 2001 is still running without a
                 permanent building. It is the violation of the NCTE norms (copy of the document
                 received from the Chelannur Grama Panchayath is produced herewith the same may
                 be marked as EX A2).

                 Every appraisal report has been sent by the college to NCTE for granting recognition
                 for the next year along with details of teaching staff. But I would like to point out that
                 many of the teachers in the list have not been appointed by the college and this is
                 reflected from the attendance register of the teaching staff maintained in the college.
                 Since the professional tax has been paid to Chelannur Grama Panchayath. I have the
                 copy of professional tax assessment register in which the all the teachers in the
                 college has paid, but the remaining were not appointed by the college. The college
                 has been misleading the NCTE by giving false list of teachers. The list produced may
                 be marked as EX A3.

                 The college has been violating all NCTE norms and misleading the NCTE. The
                 college has admitted students in the year 2001-02 without NCTE recognition by
                 influencing the authorities of university of calicut. The university awarded B.Ed
                 degree to the students for the year 2001-02 and also mislead the NCTE by saying
                 that the college has permanent building number. The document maintained with
                 Chelannur Grama Panchayath, Kozhikode district, Kerala state shows that the
                 building is a temporary one.
                                              66

  (Gangadharaiah)                                                      (Prof. C. Thangamuthu)
Regional Director, SRC, NCTE                                           Chairman, SRC, NCTE
                                                                                               th
                                                                                           198 Meeting of SRC
                                                                                          th  h
                                                                                        24 -26 November 2010



                           Giving take list of teachers along with the appraisal list submitted by the college each
                           year, not following the students teacher ration which in the NCTE norms. Not giving
                           the proper salary and other benefits to the staff members of the colleges. It is
                           understood land of the college belong to the Sree Narayana Guru College,
                           Chelannur, in Kozhikode district. Since the college has been violating all NCTE
                           norms. A re-visit should be conducted in the college and all registers of the college
                           like the students admission register, attendance register of the staff, acquaintance
                           register showing salary details, documents like the registered document of the land,
                           permanent building number, NOC from Government of Kerala, University Syndicate
                           local enquiry committee report, etc from the year 2001-09 may be verified.

                           The college authority is misleading the NCTE authorities by giving false information.
                           So Stringent action should be taken. All the staff members should be given salary
                           and other benefits DA, EPF, ESI as per norms prescribed by affiliated
                           University/State Government. But the management rejected the claims. This is the
                           violation of the NCTE norms”.

                           The complainant has submitted supporting documents also.

                           The committee considered the complaints and also decided to cause inspection
                           under Sec.17 of the NCTE Act and call for duly filled in Questionnaire along with
                           Rs.40,000/- inspection fee along with necessary documents relating to land, building,
                           FDR, Building Completion Certificate from competent Government Engineer/authority
                           and other relevant aspects including the faculty details for necessary action.
                           The inspection of the institution was done on 15.11.2010

                           The Committee considered the VT report,VCD of the institution, VCD and all
                           other related documents along with the original file of the institution. The
                           committee decided to permit B.Ed programme to be continued.



        Court Cases/Appeal/Notice/Complaint/Shifting/Miscellaneous Cases:

65.       APS08149         K.I.E.T College of P.G & Research in Education, Bangalore-560029, Karnataka
            M.Ed
                           has been granted recognition for D.Ed, B.Ed and M.Ed courses by SRC, NCTE.
      KIET College of PG
        & Research in
                           A complaint has been received on 11.06.2009 from students of KIET College of
          Education,
          Bangalore        Education stating that there are no proper facilities, library and teachers. All the
                           courses are running like distance learning programmes along with Alagappa
             KA
                           University Distance programmes and it has also stated that the management has
                           enrolled students from Rajasthan/Bihar/Andaman and Nicobar by selling the seats for
                           huge sum by facilitating them to write final exam with mass copying.


                                                        67

          (Gangadharaiah)                                                        (Prof. C. Thangamuthu)
        Regional Director, SRC, NCTE                                             Chairman, SRC, NCTE
                                                                                        th
                                                                                    198 Meeting of SRC
                                                                                   th  h
                                                                                 24 -26 November 2010

                 SRC in its 177th Meeting held on 22-23 June, 2009 considered the complaint and
                 decided to issue showcause Notice under section 17 of NCTE, Act.

                 Accordingly, notice was issued to the institution on 25.08.2009 under section 17. The
                 institution has submitted its written representation on 10.09.2009.

                 Further, the reply was considered by SRC in its 183rd Meeting held on 22
                 September, 2009 and decided to conduct inspection under section 17 of NCTE Act
                 for verification of infrastructural and instructional facilities for all teacher education
                 courses. Accordingly, inspection has been carried out on 20.10.2009.

                 The inspection report was placed before SRC in its 184th meeting held on 26-27
                 October 2009 and decided to issue notice for withdrawal for all the courses.

                 In the meantime, a court order dated 20.10.2009 received on 30.10.2009 from the
                 Hon'ble High Court of Karnataka which reads as follows:

                 In the light of the grounds raised in the writ petition, it is ordered that while the

                 respondent is at liberty to conduct inspection as proposed vide impugned notice

                 dated 14.10.2009 – Annexure – F, further action to be taken in the matter shall await

                 orders of this court.

                 Post after two weeks. In the meantime, objections, if any, by the respondent.

                 Accordingly, Sri.Ashok Haranahalli, Counsel for NCTE has been forwarded affidavit .

                 SRC in its 185th meeting held on 26-27 November 2009 considered the matter and
                 decided to await disposal of the case and the NCTE Counsel be requested to get
                 necessary clearance from the Court. Several letters were written to the advocate
                 advocate to know the latest position of the case and the reply is awaited. As such
                 withdrawal notice as pr dcecision in 184th meeting of SRC is kept pending till disposal
                 of the case as per the court order dated 20.10.2009.
                 The institution has submitted now a letter dated 13.10.2010 and had sought for
                 enhancement of intake for M.Ed course as per NCTE Hqrs. vide their letter F.No.49-
                 4/2010/PT/NCTE(N&S)/ dated 30th July, 2010 which it has been informed that the
                 enhancement in the intake of one unit of M.Ed. course programme from 25 to 35 has


                                                68

  (Gangadharaiah)                                                         (Prof. C. Thangamuthu)
Regional Director, SRC, NCTE                                              Chairman, SRC, NCTE
                                                                                              th
                                                                                          198 Meeting of SRC
                                                                                         th  h
                                                                                       24 -26 November 2010

                           been notified vide National Council for Teacher Education Amendment Regulation,
                           2010 in the Gazette of India on 26th July 2010. The amendment stipulates that the
                           intake be increased from existing 25 to 35 students from the current session 2010-11,
                           without creation of any additional infrastructure and instructional facilities. NCTE Hqrs
                           has directed to intimate all the institutions of each region having approved M.Ed.
                           Programme of 25 students by issuing a letter that they may enhance it upto 35
                           students, accordingly. The institution was granted recognition for M.Ed. course with
                           an intake of 25 students vide-order       F.SRO/NCTE/M.Ed/2006-2007/18588 dated
                           06.03.2008.
                           The committee considered the request of the management and decided that in
                           case, the stay order of the Hon’ble Court is no more valid, the show cause
                           notice for withdrawal of all the programmes of the institution on the basis of
                           VT inspection (held on 29.10.2009) be issued immediately. During the
                           pendency of the follow up action on the basis of the above VT report and as the
                           main issue relating to the withdrawal of recognition of the institution is
                           subjudice, no further action be taken on the request of the institution for
                           enhancement of intake in M.Ed programme.

66.      APS09043          M.S.C. Educational Society, Mahabubnagar District, Andhra Pradesh had applied for
             HPT           grant of recognition to Amritha Akshitha College of Education, Metpalli Post and
      M.S.C. Educational   Mandal, Wanaparthy, Mahabubnagar District-509193, Andhra Pradesh for HPT
           Society,        Course of two year duration under Section 14(I) of the NCTE Act, 1993 to the
       Mahabubnagar        Southern Regional Committee, NCTE.

             AP            The competent authority had constituted a Visiting Team to visit the institution and
                           the visiting team had since submitted its report.

                           SRC in its 160th meeting held on 31st July & 1st August, 2008 the Southern Regional
                           Committee after considering the report of the visiting team as well as other relevant
                           materials furnished by the applicant institution, was satisfied that the applicant
                           institution did not fulfill the requirements and issued a notice on 08.08.2008 to the
                           applicant institution under proviso to Section 14/15 (3) (b) of the NCTE Act, 1993,
                           thereby giving an opportunity to the said applicant institution to make a written
                           representation for the following:

                              The built up space 13400 sq.ft. for existing B.Ed & 4300 sq.ft is not adequate for
                               the proposed HPT course & TPT courses.
                              The management has been running MBA & MCA courses in the same building. It
                               is not permitted as per Regulations & Act of NCTE.
                              The management has to submit a certificate from the concerned affiliating

                                                        69

          (Gangadharaiah)                                                       (Prof. C. Thangamuthu)
        Regional Director, SRC, NCTE                                            Chairman, SRC, NCTE
                                                                                    th
                                                                                198 Meeting of SRC
                                                                               th  h
                                                                             24 -26 November 2010

                     university that no other courses is being run in the said building, otherwise action
                     to be initiated for withdrawal of existing B.Ed course recognition as per section 17
                     of NCTE Act.
                    The books 1294 are not adequate for existing & proposed courses.
                    The lab equipment in psychology, ET, Science lab are not adequate for existing &
                     proposed courses.

                 The applicant institution had submitted its written representation dated 08.09.2008 to
                 SRC, NCTE. The said representation of the institution as well as other documents
                 and materials submitted by the institution along with VTR and videography were
                 again duly considered by the Southern Regional Committee on 164th meeting held on
                 20th September, 2008, which came to the conclusion that recognition/ permission to
                 the said institution be refused for the following reasons:
                      The built up space of 20,000 sq.ft as per approved building plan is not
                         adequate to run existing B.Ed course and proposed HPT course. The
                         earmarked building also not suitable to run HPT course as per VCD submitted
                         by the institution.
                      The books in the library are not adequate. In reply, also the management has
                         not submitted proofs about purchase of additional books for proposed course.
                 Accordingly, refusal order was issued to the institution on 23.09.2008. Aggrieved by
                 the refusal order of SRC, the institution preferred an appeal to NCTE-Hqrs. The
                 appellate authority in its order dated 19.12.2008 confirms the order appealed against.

                 The institution approached to the Hon‟ble High Court of Andhra Pradesh in
                 W.P.No.3966 of 2009 praying that the orders of refusal issued by the 2 nd respondent
                 and confirmed by the 1st respondent and quash the same and consequently direct the
                 respondents to consider the application of the petitioner to grant recognition for
                 starting HPT course taking into consideration the report submitted by the visiting
                 team dated 08.05.2008.

                 The Court has ordered interalia states “Since the impugned order of rejection, passed
                 by the 2nd respondent, as confirmed by the 1st respondent in appeal rejecting the
                 application of the petitioner for grant of permission to run Hindi Pandit Training
                 course, is without considering the important and relevant material, the same cannot
                 be sustained, and they are accordingly set aside, and the matter is remitted to the
                 respondents for consideration of the matter afresh.

                 Accordingly, the writ petition is allowed. The respondents are directed to consider the
                 application of the petitioner for grant of permission to run Hindi Pandit Course afresh
                 in the light of the materials placed before the court, particularly the building plan and
                 the inspection report of the visiting team, which inspected the premises of the
                 petitioner, pursuant to the application for grant of permission, and pass appropriate
                 orders thereon in accordance with law expeditiously. No costs.

                 The matter was placed before SRC in its 177th meeting held on 22-23 June, 2009, the
                 Committee considered Hon‟ble High Court of Judicature, Andhra Pradesh order in its
                 W.P.No.3966 of 2009, documents in original file, inspection report, video CD and
                 written representation of the institution dated 12.6.2009 and earlier decisions of the
                 Committee in respect of stopping recognitions of language pandit courses in the
                                              70

  (Gangadharaiah)                                                     (Prof. C. Thangamuthu)
Regional Director, SRC, NCTE                                          Chairman, SRC, NCTE
                                                                                  th
                                                                              198 Meeting of SRC
                                                                             th  h
                                                                           24 -26 November 2010

                 State of Andhra Pradesh and noted the following: -

                  SRC in its 169th meeting held on 12-13 January, 2009 considered the letter dated
                   07/01/2009 of State Government of Andhra Pradesh wherein Principal Secretary
                   of Education has requested NCTE “not to accord further recognition/permission to
                   the new colleges/private B.Ed, D.Ed, Physical Education, Language Pandit in the
                   State of Andhra Pradesh as above colleges are exceeding in numbers than
                   required”. The SRC decided to give effect to the decision of State Government of
                   Andhra Pradesh as such with immediate effect.
                  Further, the letter dated 17/03/2009 was received from NCTE-HQ informing that
                   the “The recommendations of the Govt. of Andhra Pradesh not to grant
                   recognition/permission in respect of other courses like B.Ed,D.Ed and Physical
                   Education courses have further been considered in NCTE and it has been
                   decided that no further recognition/Permission to any institution in the State of
                   Andhra Pradesh be considered by SRC for the academic session 2009-10 for
                   B.Ed, D.ED, and Physical Education courses also”.
                  It was noted that SRC in its 172nd meeting held on 25th-26th March 2009 decided
                   to accept the recommendation of the State Government of Andhra Pradesh, not
                   to grant recognition to any of the Teacher Training institutions in the State of
                   Andhra Pradesh for the year 2009-10.

                 In view of the decisions of Committee for stopping Language Pandit course
                 recognitions in Andhra Pradesh, as per the orders of the State Government, after
                 consideration of NCTE Act, regulations, policy decisions, Hon‟ble High Court order,
                 the Committee, decided to refuse recognition to the proposed course as per Section
                 14(3)(b) of NCTE Act.

                 As per the decision of SRC refusal order was issued to the institution on 13.07.2009.
                 The Institute has approached to Hon‟ble High Court in W.P.No.30506/2010.
                 Now, the Hon‟ble High Court has passed an order on 13.08.2010 as hereunder:

                 “In the light of he orders passed by this court in similar W.P.Nos.6712 of 2009,
                 9360and 11078 of 2010, there shall be a direction to the 1st respondent to consider
                 the petitioner’s application for starting H.P.T., institutions in accordance with law
                 without reference to the State Government’s policy dated 7.01.2009.
                 Post along with W.P.Nos6712 of 2009, 9360of 2010 and 11078 of 2010”.

                 SRC considered the matter and directed the Management/institution to resubmit the
                 old application returned by SRC along with necessary documents as originally
                 submitted relating to land, building, FDR, Application fee, Building Completion
                 Certificate from competent Government Engineer/ authority and other relevant
                 aspects for processing and for necessary action.
                 As per direction of Regional Committee a letter issued to the applicant institution
                 on 25.10.10 with request to submit the old application returned by SRC along with
                 necessary documents as originally submitted relating to land, building, FDR,
                 Application fee, Building Completion Certificate from competent Government
                 Engineer/ authority and other relevant aspects for processing and for necessary
                 action.

                                             71

  (Gangadharaiah)                                                     (Prof. C. Thangamuthu)
Regional Director, SRC, NCTE                                          Chairman, SRC, NCTE
                                                                                           th
                                                                                       198 Meeting of SRC
                                                                                      th  h
                                                                                    24 -26 November 2010



                            In response to SRC letter dated 25.10.2010 the institution has submitted reply
                            vide letter dated 15.11.2010.
                            In response to SRC letter dt. 25.10.2010 the institution has submitted reply vide
                            letter dt.15.11.2010 for the deficiencies called for, the following deficiencies are
                            still to be corrected:

                             Inspection of Rs. 40.000/- in the name of the Member Secretary, NCTE
                              payable at Bangalore.

                             Land documents are in Telugu version, needs English version to determine if
                              pertains to same land.

                             Building plan is not readable, fresh original copy of the building plan duly
                              approved by the government authority in the prescribe format to be
                              submitted.

                             Building completion certificate from the Government authority in the
                              prescribed format to be submitted.

                             The management has not submitted the originals of FDRs of Rs. 5 lakhs and
                              3 lakhs from a nationalized bank, to be submitted originals.

                             Original affidavit in Rs. 100/- stamp paper in the prescribed format with
                              notary attestation to be submitted.

                            In view of the above, the Committee decided to issue a Showcause Notice to
                            the institution as to why the application can’t be closed and thereby providing
                            an opportunity to the institution to make a written representation within 30
                            days from the date of issue of the Notice along with necessary
                            certificates/documents in order to take a final decision in the matter; failing
                            which action will be taken including the closure of application and rejection of
                            the application based on the records available, with no further notice.

67.      APS09727           An application was submitted by Al-Madina Educational Society, Nalgonda District,
             B.Ed           Andhra Pradesh for grant of recognition to B.Ed course in the office of SRC-NCTE,
         Al-Madina          vide dated 31.10.2008
      Eduational Society,
          Nalgonda          The file was under process and in the meanwhile, in view of the recommendations of
                            the State Government of Andhra Pradesh vide letter dated 07.01.2009 not to further
              AP            recognise/permit the institutions for conducting B.Ed, D.Ed, Physical Education,
                            Language Pandit course(s).

                            The SRC in its 169th Meeting held on 12-13 January, 2009 having considered the
                            letter dated 07.01.2009 of State Government of Andhra Pradesh and decided to give
                            effect to the above decision of State Government of Andhra Pradesh as such, with
                            immediate effect.

                                                       72

          (Gangadharaiah)                                                     (Prof. C. Thangamuthu)
        Regional Director, SRC, NCTE                                          Chairman, SRC, NCTE
                                                                                    th
                                                                                198 Meeting of SRC
                                                                               th  h
                                                                             24 -26 November 2010

                 A letter dated 07.02.2009 forwarded by Principal Secretary of Education requesting
                 not to accord further recognition/permission to the new colleges/private B.Ed, D.Ed,
                 Physical Education, Language Pandit in the State of Andhra Pradesh as the above
                 colleges are exceeding in numbers than required.

                 A letter dated 17.03.2009 was also received from NCTE, Hqrs informing that the “The
                 recommendations of the Govt. of Andhra Pradesh not to grant recognition/permission
                 in respect of other courses like B.Ed, D.Ed and Physical Education courses have
                 further been decided that no further Recognition/ Permission to any institution in the
                 State of Andhra Pradesh be considered by SRC for the academic session 2009-2010
                 for B.Ed, D.Ed, and Physical Education courses also”.

                 The State Government vide its letter dated 20.03.2009 informed that it has been
                 decided not to recommend the name of this institution. The letters dated 07.01.2009,
                 07.02.2009, 17.03.2009 and 20.03.2009 was considered by SRC in its 172nd
                 Meeting held on 25-26 March, 2009 and SRC decided to accept the recommendation
                 of the State Government of Andhra Pradesh, not to grant recognition to any of the
                 Teacher Training Institutions in the State of Andhra Pradesh for the year 2009-2010
                 and decided to close the applications.

                 As per the decision of SRC the application was closed on 28.04.2009

                 The Institute has approached to Hon‟ble High Court in W.P.No.13482/2010.
                 The Hon‟ble High Court has passed an order on 16.06.2010 vide W.P.No.13482 of
                 2010 reads as hereunder:-

                 “It may be true that the State Government as well as the first respondent have
                 reviewed the situation as to the necessary or otherwise of according permission to
                 establish new colleges of education in the State in future and that the existing
                 institutions are found to be adequate. However, the right that is accrued to the
                 petitioners on the basis of their application and the consideration thereof by the first
                 respondent cannot be taken away on account of the change of policy. It is settled
                 principle of law that whenever an application is made, it must be considered and
                 processed in accordance with the provisions of law that existed as on the date of
                 presentation. Subsequent changes may apply to the applications that are made
                 thereafter.

                 Hence, the writ petition is disposed of directing the first respondent to take necessary
                 steps as contemplated in its communication dated 24.11.2009 and pass appropriate
                 orders. There shall be no order as to costs.”

                 We had issued deficiency letter to institution on 25.11.2008 to which institution replied
                 with supporting documents on 26.12.2008. It was observed that the Building
                 Completion Certificate is signed by Private Engineer.

                 SRC considered in its 194th meeting held on 30st –22nd July, 2010 and the SRC
                 directed the Management to resubmit the old application returned by SRC along with
                 the documents as originally submitted relating to land, building, FDR, Application fee,
                 BCC from competent Government Engineer/ Authority and other relevant aspects for
                                              73

  (Gangadharaiah)                                                     (Prof. C. Thangamuthu)
Regional Director, SRC, NCTE                                          Chairman, SRC, NCTE
                                                                                               th
                                                                                           198 Meeting of SRC
                                                                                          th  h
                                                                                        24 -26 November 2010

                            processing and for necessary action.

                                    As per direction of Regional Committee a letter was issued on 19.08.2010. In
                            response to this office letter dated 19.08.2010 the institution has submitted reply vide
                            letter dated 24.08.2010.

                                    As per perusal of the file the institution has submitted following documents
                            vide letters dated 24.08.10 and 28.07.10 :-

                                   1.   Processing fee and application fee (40,000+1,000= 41,000/-)
                                   2.   Land documents
                                   3.   BCC Certificate
                                   4.   Land use Certificate
                                   5.   Approved Building Plan
                                   6.   Original FDR of 5 lakhs and 3 lakhs.

                            The Committee considered the matter and decided to process the application further
                            as per norms and to list deficiencies, if any, and to inform the institution to comply
                            with the deficiencies allowing a period of 60 days for rectification of deficiencies.

                            As per perusal of the file the institution has submitted above documents vide letter
                            dated 24.08.10 and 28.07.10.

                            The matter was considered by the Committee and it was decided to cause
                            inspection of the institution for considering recognition for B.Ed. Course.

68.      APS04545           Jairupa TTI, Erode Dt., Tamilnadu was granted recognition by SRC-NCTE for
          D.T.Ed-AI         conducting D.T.Ed-AI course with an annual intake of 100 students from the
      Jairupa Teacher       academic session 2006-2007 vide order dated 09th September 2006.
      Training Institute,
            Erode           Based on the Inquiry Report Submitted by Sri. Sathyam, IAS (Retd) the
             TN             inspection of the institution was carried out on 16.12.2008. The report was
                            considered by SRC in its 16th meeting held on 12th-13th January 2009 and
                            decided to issue show cause notice. Accordingly a Show Cause Notice u/s 17
                            was issued on the institution on 05.08.2009.

                            SRC considered the reply to the Show Cause Notice submitted by the
                            institution on 08.05.2009 in its 166th meeting held on 18th-19th October 2008.
                            SRC vide its letter dated.3.9.2009 decided to conduct inspection for shifting of
                            premises to permanent building after submission of the following documents
                            for shifting of Premises:

                            1. Demand Draft of Rs.40,000/- towards inspection fee in favour of “The
                               Member Secretary, NCTE” payable at Bangalore should be submitted.
                            2. Land documents of the new building/ location for having own land in the
                               name of the institution/ Society/ Trust.
                            3. Building Plan of the new building duly approved by the Government

                                                         74

         (Gangadharaiah)                                                         (Prof. C. Thangamuthu)
       Regional Director, SRC, NCTE                                              Chairman, SRC, NCTE
                                                                              th
                                                                          198 Meeting of SRC
                                                                         th  h
                                                                       24 -26 November 2010

                      authority.
                 4.   Building Completion Certificate from the Government authorities in the
                      prescribed format
                 5.   Land Usage Certificate from the concerned Government authorities stating
                      that the land is exclusively permitted/ sanctioned for Educational Purposes
                      only should be submitted.
                 6.   Encumbrance certificate from the competent Government authority
                      authority should be submitted.
                 7.   Fixed Deposit Receipt of Rs.5 lakhs towards Endowment Fund and Rs.3
                      lakhs towards Reserve Fund kept in JOINT ACCOUNT for a period of 5
                      years ORIGINAL should be submitted.
                 8.   Certificate of Registration/ Bye-law of the Society/ Trust should be
                      submitted.
                 9.   The Affidavit in Rs.100/- stamp paper in the prescribed format with Notary
                      attestation should be submitted.

                 Accordingly, as per the decision of SRC, a letter was issued on 08.09.2009.
                 The institution vide letter dated 22.09.2009 submitted a copy of order in W.P.
                 No. 19143 of 2009 and the Hon'ble High Court of Madras vide its order dated
                 17th September 09 made the following order: -

                 Interim Stay and Notice

                 The matter is placed before SRC along with a copy of the order passed by the
                 Hon'ble Court and also the copy of representation submitted by the institution
                 for perusal and direction.

                 SRC considered the above matter and it has been decided to get the stay
                 vacated and arrange for Inspection under Section 17 of NCTE Act, within four
                 weeks since the date of confirmation of the Minutes.

                 In obedience to the direction of SRC, a letter was issued to the advocate
                 requested to vacate the stay on 28.5.2010 followed by reminder on 27.7.2010.

                 A court order in W.P. no. 19143 of 2009 filed by Jairupa TTI has been
                 received from the Hon‟ble High Court of Madras on 15.11.2010.

                 The Hon‟ble court       has ordered as follows ”…The Southern Regional
                 Committee, NCTE,        Bangalore is empowered to cause re-inspection to
                 ascertain the details   made in the written representation of the institute. For
                 causing inspection,     necessarily, the institute has to bear the inspection
                 charges.”

                 The committee considered Hon’ble court order and it was decided to cause
                 inspection of the institution under Section 17 of NCTE Act, on payment of

                                             75

  (Gangadharaiah)                                                 (Prof. C. Thangamuthu)
Regional Director, SRC, NCTE                                      Chairman, SRC, NCTE
                                                                                                th
                                                                                            198 Meeting of SRC
                                                                                           th  h
                                                                                         24 -26 November 2010

                              Rs.40,000/- inspection fee and on submission of filled in Questionnaire, along
                              with relevant supporting documents relating to building, land, including
                              Building Completion Certificate from the competent Government Engineer,
                              Land Use Certificate, FDRs of Rs. 5 lakhs and 3 lakhs for a period of 5 years
                              from a Nationalised Bank, Certificate of Registration/Bye-laws of the
                              society/trust, Affidavit in Rs.100/- stamp paper in the prescribed format with
                              notary attestation etc., within four weeks from the date of confirmation of the
                              Minutes.

69.       APS07534            Kasturibai College of Education for women, Guntur District, Andhra Pradesh
              B.Ed
      Kasturibai College of   In terms of Section 14(1) of the NCTE Act, 1993 Acharya Educational Society, Guntur
         Education for        District Andhra Pradesh had submitted an application to the Southern Regional
        Women, Guntur         Committee of NCTE for grant of recognition to Kasturibai College of Education for
                              women, D.No.4-9-6, Patel Nagar, 1st line, Bapatla Guntur District-522101, Andhra
               AP             Pradesh for B.Ed Course of one year duration.

                              Southern Regional Committee in its 151st meeting held on 7-8 January 2008
                              considering the report of the visiting team as well as other relevant materials
                              furnished by the institution, is satisfied that the institution does not fulfill the
                              requirement and issued a notice on 21.01.2008 to the institution under provisio to
                              section 14(3)(b) of the NCTE Act, 1993, thereby giving an opportunity to the
                              institution to make a written representation in this behalf.

                              The institution has submitted its written representation dated 03.03.2008. The
                              representation of the institution as well as other documents and materials submitted
                              by the institution along with VTR and videography were again duly considered by the
                              Southern Regional Committee in 157th meeting held on 23-24 April 2008 which came
                              to the conclusion that recognition/permission to the said institution be refused for the
                              following reasons:

                                 The temporarily constructed asbestos sheet roofed sheds are not suitable for
                                  proposed B.Ed. course.
                                 The asbestos sheet roofed sheds and proposed permanent building are located
                                  in different places. It is not as per NCTE regulations.

                              As per the decision of SRC refusal order was issued to the institution on 15.05.2008

                              The Institute has approached to Hon‟ble High Court in W.P.No.23729 of 2010.
                              Now, the Hon‟ble High Court has passed an order on 29.09.2010 vide W.P.No.23729
                              of 2010 reads as hereunder:

                              “However, a prima facie case is made out that the writ petitioner society has
                              constructed the necessary buildings and provided the necessary infrastructure for
                              establishing a College of Education. Therefore, the respondents are directed to
                              undertake a fresh round of inspection within a maximum period of six weeks from the
                              date of receipt of this order”.

                              The order copy has been received on 26.10.2010
                                                          76

           (Gangadharaiah)                                                         (Prof. C. Thangamuthu)
         Regional Director, SRC, NCTE                                              Chairman, SRC, NCTE
                                                                                           th
                                                                                       198 Meeting of SRC
                                                                                      th  h
                                                                                    24 -26 November 2010



                         The institution has submitted an inspection fee of Rs. 40,000/- on 19.10.2010

                         The committee considered Hon’ble court order dt. 29.09.2010 and it was
                         decided to cause inspection of the institution for B.Ed. Course, on submission
                         of relevant supporting documents relating to building, land, including Building
                         Completion Certificate from the competent Government Engineer, Land Use
                         Certificate, FDRs of Rs. 5 lakhs and 3 lakhs for a period of 5 years from a
                         Nationalised Bank, Certificate of Registration/Bye-laws of the society/trust,
                         Affidavit in Rs.100/- stamp paper in the prescribed format with notary
                         attestation etc.,

70.      APS02800        Sub:- Ankala Reddy Memorial Teacher Training Course, Kurnool-518543, Andhra
            D.Ed         Pradesh has submitted application for D.Ed course on 30.01.2004.
       Ankala Reddy
      Memorial Teacher   Application was under process and meanwhile, the Government of Andhra Pradesh
      Training Course,   of Hyderabad filed a Writ Petition No.22866 of 2005 in the Hon‟ble High Court of
          Kurnool        Andhra Pradesh of Hyderabad challenging the Notification of NCTE with regard to the
                         dispensing with the requirement of NOC from the State Government. The writ
            AP           petition was allowed by the learned single judge with the directions that the rule
                         excluding the State Government is bad. Against said judgement a Writ Appeal
                         No.692 of 2006 was filed in the Division Bench of Hon‟ble High Court of Hyderabad.
                         Many discussions took place between the State Government of Andhra Pradesh and
                         SRC-NCTE. However, neither State Government withdrew the case filed by them nor
                         the stay has been vacated.

                         Some institutions went to the court and filed writ petitions individually seeking
                         directions for processing of their applications, in one of such Writ Petition No.8278 of
                         2008. The Hon‟ble High Court decided that the applications of the institutions shall be
                         processed as per the NCTE rules and regulations norms and standards existing as
                         on date.

                         As per the direction of Hon‟ble High Court and decision of SRC for processing of
                         pending D.Ed application as per new regulation of NCTE in its 164th meeting held on
                         20th September 2008, the SRC started to process the applications.

                         In view of the above decision, a reminder letter was issued to the institution vide
                         dated 02.01.2009. the institution submitted its reply on 10.01.2009 and file was under
                         process and in the meanwhile, in view of the recommendations of the State
                         Government of Andhra Pradesh vide letter dated 07.01.2009 not to further
                         recognize/permit the institutions for conducting B.Ed, D.Ed, Physical Education,
                         Language Pandit Course. SRC in its 169th meeting held on 12-13th January, 2009
                         having considered the letter dated 07.01.2009 of State Government of Andhra
                         Pradesh as such, with immediate effect.

                         A letter dated 07.02.2009 forwarded by Principal Secretary of Education requesting
                         not to accord further recognition/permission to the new colleges/private B.Ed, D.Ed,
                         Physical Education, Language Pandit in the state of Andhra Pradesh as the above
                         colleges are exceeding in numbers than required.
                                                     77

         (Gangadharaiah)                                                      (Prof. C. Thangamuthu)
       Regional Director, SRC, NCTE                                           Chairman, SRC, NCTE
                                                                                       th
                                                                                  198 Meeting of SRC
                                                                                  th h
                                                                               24 -26 November 2010



                 A letter dated 17th March, 2009 has been received from NCTE Hqrs. informing that
                 the “the recommendations of the Govt. of Andhra Pradesh not to grant
                 recognition/permission in respect of other courses like B.Ed, D.Ed and Physical
                 Education courses have further been considered in NCTE and it has been decided
                 that no further recognition/Permission to any institution in the State of Andhra
                 Pradesh be considered by SRC for the academic session 2009-10 for B.Ed, D.Ed
                 and Physical Education Courses also.

                 The State Government vide its letter dated 20.03.2009 informed that it has been
                 decided not to recommend the name of your institution.

                 The letters dated 07.01.2009, 07.02.2009, 17.03.2009 and 20.03.2009 were
                 considered by SRC in its 172nd meeting held on 25th – 26th March, 2009 and SRC
                 decided to accept the recommendation of the State Government of Andhra Pradesh,
                 not to grant recognition to any of the Teacher Training Institutions in the State of
                 Andhra Pradesh for the year 2009-2010 and decided to close the applications.

                 Accordingly, a closing letter was issued to the institution on 29.04.2009.

                 Further, the institution has approached Hon‟ble High Court of Andhra Pradesh in
                 W.P.No.17026 of 2010. The court has passed order dated 16.07.2010:
                 “in the light of the orders passed by this Court in the similar writ petitions W.P. No.
                 6712 of 2009, W.P. No.9360 of 2010 and W.P. No.11078 o 2010, there shall be a
                 direction to the first respondent to consider the petitioner‟s application for starting
                 D.Ed, course in accordance with law without reference to the State Government‟s
                 policy dated 07.01.2009.

                 The committee considered the matter and decided to process the application, on
                 receipt of Application fee and other relevant documents as per the court orders under
                 intimation to the institution. As per decision of Regional Committee a letter was sent
                 to the institution on 27.09.10 with request to submit documents. As per perusul of file
                 the institution has submitted following documents.


                  Affidavit of Rs. 100/- regarding land - submitted Dt. 22.10.2010.
                  FDR of Rs. 5 lakhs towards endowment fund – submitted.
                  FDR of Rs. 3 lakhs towards reserved fund – submitted.
                  Application fee of Rs. 40.000/- Not submitted.
                  Land documents, sale deed and building plan, BCC & LUC – Submitted, the total
                   extent of land is 3.33 + 3.33 = 6.66 (total 5.00 Acres).
                 Institution has submitted a letter dt. 17.11.2010, in this letter the institution has stated
                 that the application submitted on 30.01.2004 to NCTE and still to make decision in
                 SRC meeting after considering inspection report and hence the question of payment
                 of Rs. 40.000/- towards application form fees does not arise and there is no need of
                 any inspection since it is a old application.

                                               78

  (Gangadharaiah)                                                        (Prof. C. Thangamuthu)
Regional Director, SRC, NCTE                                             Chairman, SRC, NCTE
                                                                                          th
                                                                                      198 Meeting of SRC
                                                                                     th  h
                                                                                   24 -26 November 2010

                        The Committee considered the matter and decided to cause inspection subject
                        to the condition that the institution has submitted all the necessary documents
                        and the inspection fee and also has rectified the deficiencies, if any as per the
                        norms.
71.       APS09304      An application was submitted by Sri Raghavendra Educational Society, West
            D.Ed        Godavari, Andhra Pradesh for grant of recognition to Sri Raghavendra College of
      Sri Raghavendra   Education, Bhimavaram Taluk, West Godavari District Andhra Pradesh for D.Ed
          College of    course of Two year duration under section 15(1) of the NCTE Act, 1993 to the
      Education, West   Southern Regional Committee, NCTE on 19.02.2008.
           Godavari
                        The application was processed and a deficiency letter was issued on 06.03.2008.
            AP          The application submitted its reply vide dated 05.04.2008 which was received on
                        09.04.2008.The reply was scrutinized and a reminder letter was issued on
                        29.04.2008. The institution submitted its reply on 08.05.2008. The reply was further
                        scrutinized and 2nd reminder was issued on 18.07.2008, and also a copy of the
                        application was forwarded to the State Government for its recommendation on
                        07.08.2008.

                        The institution submitted its written representation for 2nd reminder on 28.08.2008. All
                        the documents were verified and it was found complete. Accordingly letter of consent
                        was issued to the institution on 09.09.2008. The institution submitted its consent for
                        inspection on 30.09.2008.

                        In the meanwhile, in view of the recommendations of the State Government of
                        Andhra Pradesh vide letter dated 07.01.2009 requested not to further
                        recognize/permit the institutions for conducting B.Ed, D.Ed, Physical Education,
                        Language Pandit Courses. SRC in its 169th Meeting held on 12-13 January, 2009
                        having considered the letter dated 07.01.2009 of State Government of Andhra
                        Pradesh and decided to give effect to the above decision of State Government of
                        Andhra Pradesh as such, with immediate effect.

                        A letter dated 07.02.2009 forwarded by Principal Secretary of education requesting
                        not to accord further recognition/permission to the new colleges/private B.Ed, D.Ed,
                        Physical Education, Language Pandit in the State of Andhra Pradesh as the above
                        colleges are exceeding in numbers than required, was also received.

                        A letter dated 17th March 2009 was also received from NCTE Hqrs informing that the
                        “The recommendations of the Government of Andhra Pradesh not to grant
                        recognition/permission in respect of other courses like B.Ed, D.Ed and Physical
                        Education courses have further been considered in NCTE and it has been decided
                        that no further recognition/permission to any institution in the state of Andhra Pradesh
                        be considered by SRC for the academic session 2009-10 for B.Ed, D.Ed and physical
                        Education courses also. The State Government vide its letter dated 20.03.2009
                        informed that it has been decided not to recommend the name of the institution. The
                        letters dated 07.01.2009, 07.02.2009, 17.03.2009 and 20.03.2009 were considered
                        by SRC in its 172nd meeting held on 25-26 March 2009 and SRC decided to accept
                        the recommendation of the State Government of Andhra Pradesh, not to grant
                        recognition to any of the Teacher Training Institutions in the state of Andhra Pradesh
                        for the year 2009-10 and decided to close the applications.
                                                    79

         (Gangadharaiah)                                                     (Prof. C. Thangamuthu)
       Regional Director, SRC, NCTE                                          Chairman, SRC, NCTE
                                                                                     th
                                                                                 198 Meeting of SRC
                                                                                th  h
                                                                              24 -26 November 2010



                 As per direction of SRC an order was issued to the applicant institution on
                 22.04.2009 with direction to no further correspondence will be entertained in this
                 regard.

                 The institution has approached to Hon‟ble High Court of Andhra Pradesh W.P.No
                 11587/09 without exhausting remedy of appeal to appellate authority under section
                 18 of NCTE Act.

                    Hon‟ble High court has passed order dated first day of June, two thousand and
                    ten. The operative part of order as under:-


                 “These Writ Petitions raise common issues. Therefore with the consent of the learned
                 counsel for the parties, they are taken up for hearing and disposal together.

                 In all these Writ petitions, the petitioners, which are educational Institutions, felt
                 aggrieved by non-consideration of their applications for grant of recognition to
                 D.Ed/B.Ed courses purportedly on the ground of the policy decision taken by the
                 Government not to permit establishment of new D.Ed/B.Ed Colleges.

                 At the hearing, Sri Andapalli Sanjeev Kumar, learned counsel appearing for the
                 petitioners in Writ Petition Nos.11038, 11040, 11587 and 10965 of 2009, and Sri S.
                 Girimoji Rao, learned counsel for the petitioner in Writ petition No.11241 of 2009,
                 submitted that the petitioners filed their applications for recognition prior to the policy
                 decision taken by the State Government; and that in an identical Writ petition, this
                 Court, vide: order dated 16-12-2009 in writ petition No.6712 of 2009, held as under:-

                 “It may be true the State Government as well the first respondent have reviewed the
                 situation as to the necessity or otherwise of according permission to establish new
                 colleges of education in the State any further and that the existing institutions are
                 found to be adequate. However, the right that is accrued to the petitioners on the
                 basis of their application and the consideration there of by the first respondent cannot
                 be taken away on account of the change of policy. It is settled principle of law that
                 whenever an application is made, it must be considered and processed in
                 accordance with the provisions of law or the policy that existed as on the date of
                 presentation. Subsequent changes may apply to the applications that are made
                 thereafter.

                 Hence, the writ petition is disposed of directing the first respondent to take necessary
                 steps as contemplated in its communication dated 24-11-2009 and pass appropriate
                 orders.
                 There shall be no order as to coasts”.

                 The learned Standing Counsel representing respondents 2 and 3 has not disputed
                 the above position.

                 Since the issue raised in these Writ Petitions are squarely covered by the above
                 mentioned orders, these Writ petitions are disposed of in terms of the above
                                              80

  (Gangadharaiah)                                                      (Prof. C. Thangamuthu)
Regional Director, SRC, NCTE                                           Chairman, SRC, NCTE
                                                                                                    th
                                                                                               198 Meeting of SRC
                                                                                               th h
                                                                                            24 -26 November 2010

                            mentioned orders in writ petition No.6712 of 2009 with the direction that the directions
                            given in the said orders shall form part of this orders.”

                            SRC in its 194th meeting held on 21-22 July 2010 considered the matter and directed
                            the Management/institution to resubmit the old application returned by SRC along
                            with necessary documents as originally submitted relating to land, building, FDR,
                            Application fee, Building Completion Certificate from competent Government Engineer/
                            authority and other relevant aspects for processing and for necessary action.

                            As per the decision of SRC a letter was issued to the institution on 07.09.2010.

                            In reply to the letter dated 07.09.2010 institution has submitted a copy of Building
                            completion certificate approved by Mandal Engineering Officer and FDRs of Rs.5
                            lakhs and Rs.3 lakhs from Karur Vysya Bank ltd.,

                            The SRC considered the matter and all relevant documents and decided to
                            cause inspection to examine whether the institution fulfils all the requirements
                            as per the norms, for the proposed programme, subject to the condition that
                            the deficiencies, if any, were duly rectified by the institution, as per the norms.

72.       APS09456          Sub:- Sree Sai College of Education, 22-49-B3, Opp Brahmgari Mattam,
            D.Ed            Pagidyala Road, 27 Block, Nandikotkur, Kurnool-518401.
      Sree Sai College of
      Education, Kurnool    An application was submitted by Sri Siddartha Educational Society, Kurnool Dt., A.P.
                            in the name of Sree Sai College of Education, Kurnool Dt., A.P. for grant of
              AP            recognition to D.Ed. course in the office of SRC, NCTE Bangalore on 8.4.2008.

                            The file was under process and in the meanwhile, in view of the recommendations of
                            the State Government of Andhra Pradesh vide letter dated 07.01.2009 not to further
                            recognize/permit the institutions for conducting B.Ed, D.Ed, Physical Education,
                            Language Pandit course(s), to this effect that application for B.Ed, D.Ed, Physical
                            Education, Language Pandit courses from the States of Andhra Pradesh will not be
                            considered for the academic session 2009-2010 and all such applications shall be
                            returned along with processing fees and documents.

                            The SRC in its 169th meeting held on 12-13th January, 2009 having considered the
                            letter dated 7.1.2009 of State Government of Andhra Pradesh and decided to give
                            effect to the decision of above decision of State Government of Andhra Pradesh as
                            such, with immediate effect.

                            Further, a letter dated 07.02.2009 forwarded by Principal Secretary of Education
                            requesting not to accord further recognition/permission to the new colleges/private
                            B.Ed , D.Ed, Physical Education, Language Pandit in the state of Andhra Pradesh as
                            the above colleges are exceeding in numbers than required.

                            Meanwhile, a letter dated 17.03.2009 has been received from NCTE Hqrs informing
                            that the “ The recommendations of the Govt. of Andhra Pradesh not to grant
                            recognition/ permission in respect of other courses like B.Ed , D.Ed and Physical
                            Education courses have further been considered in NCTE and it has been decided

                                                           81

          (Gangadharaiah)                                                            (Prof. C. Thangamuthu)
        Regional Director, SRC, NCTE                                                 Chairman, SRC, NCTE
                                                                                        th
                                                                                    198 Meeting of SRC
                                                                                   th  h
                                                                                 24 -26 November 2010

                        that no further recognition/Permission to any institution in the state of Andhra
                        Pradesh be considered by SRC for the academic session 2009-10 for B.Ed , D.Ed
                        and physical Education Courses also”.

                        Further the state Government vide its letter dated 20.03.2009 informed that it has
                        been decided not to recommend the name of this institution.

                        The letters dated 07.01.2009, 07.02.2009, 17.03.2009 and 20.03.2009 were
                        considered by SRC in its 172nd meeting held on 25th-26th March 2009 and SRC
                        decided to accept the recommendation of the State Government of Andhra Pradesh,
                        not to grant recognition to any of the Teacher Training Institutions in the state of
                        Andhra Pradesh for the year 2009-10 and decided to close the applications.

                        As per the decision of SRC the application was closed on 22.04.2009.

                        The Hon‟ble High Court has passed an order on 06.05.2010 vide W.P.No.11078 of
                        2010 to consider the application of the petitioner without making reference to the
                        recommendation of State Government policy dated 07.01.2009.

                        The Committee considered the matter and decided to process the application.

                        The matter was considered by the Committee in 195 SRC and it was decided to Call
                        for the following documents from the institution, for further processing and action:-
                         B.C.C Certificate in prescribed format.
                         FDR of 5 lakhs and 3 lakhs for Reserve fund and Endowment fund.
                         Affidavit of Rs.100/- in prescribed format in respect of land records and all other
                          necessary documents for processing the application; along with Rs.40,000/-
                          towards application fee.

                         AS per direction of SRC a letter was issued on 23.09.10. In response to this office
                         letter dated 23.09.10 the institution has submitted reply dated 15.11.2010.

                        The SRC considered the matter and all relevant documents and decided to
                        cause inspection to examine whether the institution fulfils all the requirements
                        as per the norms, for the proposed programme, subject to the condition that
                        the institution had rectified the deficiencies, if any, as per the norms.

73.      APS09674       Sri Vivekananda College of Elementary Education, Prabhu Educational Society, NO.
            D.Ed        590/1, 59/1/2, Mahabubabad, Edulapusapally Road, Warangal-506101, Andhra
      Sri Vivekananda   Pradesh.
          College of
        Elementary      An application was submitted by Prabu Educational Society, Warangal, Andhra
          Education     Pradesh for grant of recognition to D.Ed course in the office of SRC-NCTE,
                        Bangalore vide dated 30.10.2008.
            AP
                         The file was under process and in the meanwhile, in view of the recommendation of
                        the state Government of Andhra pradesh vide letter dated 07.01.2009 not to further
                        recognize/permit the institutions for conducting B.Ed, D.Ed, Physical Education,
                        Language Pandit Course(s).
                                                   82

         (Gangadharaiah)                                                   (Prof. C. Thangamuthu)
       Regional Director, SRC, NCTE                                        Chairman, SRC, NCTE
                                                                                   th
                                                                               198 Meeting of SRC
                                                                              th  h
                                                                            24 -26 November 2010



                  SRC in its 169th Meeting held on 12-13th January, 2009 meeting held on 12-13th
                 January, 2009 having considered the letter dated 07.01.2009 of state Government of
                 Andhra Pradesh and decided to give effect to the decision of above decision of state
                 Government of Andhra Pradesh as such, with immediate effect. A letter dated
                 07.02.2009 forwarded by Principal Secretary of Education requesting not to accord
                 further recognition/permission to the new colleges/private B.Ed, D.Ed, Physical
                 Education, Language Pandit in the state of Andhra Pradesh as the above colleges
                 are exceeding in numbers than required letter dated 17th March, 2009 has been
                 received from NCTE Hqrs informing that the “The recommendations of the Govt. of
                 Andhra Pradesh not to grant recognition/permission in respect of other courses like
                 B.Ed, D.Ed and Physical Education courses have further been considered in the
                 NCTE and it has been decided that no further recognition/permission to any
                 institution in the state of Andhra Pradesh be considered by SRC for the academic
                 session 2009-10 for B.Ed, D.Ed and Physical Education courses also”. The state
                 Government vide letter dated 20.03.2009 informed that it has been decided not to
                 recommend the name of your institution. The letters dated 07.01.2009, 07.02.2009,
                 17.03.2009 and 20.03.2009 was considered by SRC in its 172nd meeting held on 25th
                 – 26th March 2009 and SRC decided to accept the recommendation of the state
                 Government of Andhra Pradesh, not to grant recognition to any of the Teacher
                 Training Institutions in the state of Andhra Pradesh for the year 2009-10 and decided
                 to close the applications. As per decision of SRC the withdrawal order issued on
                 18.04.2009.

                 The Institution has approached to Honorable High Court in W.P 26814 of 2010. The
                 Honorable High Court has directed vide dared 29-10-2010. The Honorable High
                 Court has passed an order.

                 “It may be true that the state Government as well as the first respondent have
                 reviewed the situation as to the necessity or otherwise of according permission to
                 establish new colleges of education in the state in future and that the existing
                 institutions are found to be adequate. However , the right that is accrued to the
                 petitioners on the basis of their application and the consideration thereof by the first
                 respondent cannot be taken away on account of the change of policy. It is settled
                 principle of law that whenever an application is made, it must be considered and
                 processed in accordance with the provisions of law or the policy that existed as on
                 the date of presentation. Subsequent changes may apply to the applications that are
                 made there after‟.

                 Hence, this writ Petition is also disposed of reiterating the same directions as noticed
                 supra. No costs.”

                 SRC had issued a deficiency letter dated 30.10.2008. The institution had submitted
                 its reply dated 05.10.09.

                 The SRC considered the matter and all relevant documents and decided to
                 cause inspection to examine whether the institution fulfils all the requirements
                 as per the norms, for the proposed programme, subject to the condition that
                 the institution had rectified the deficiencies, if any, as per the norms.
                                             83

  (Gangadharaiah)                                                     (Prof. C. Thangamuthu)
Regional Director, SRC, NCTE                                          Chairman, SRC, NCTE
                                                                                             th
                                                                                         198 Meeting of SRC
                                                                                        th  h
                                                                                      24 -26 November 2010




74.      APS08730          An application was submitted by Gowthama Budda Educational Society, Krishna
            D.Ed
                           District, Andhra Pradesh for grant of recognition to D.Ed course in the office of SRC-
       Dr. D.S. Kothari
          College of       NCTE Bangalore vide dated 25.05.2007.
      Education, Krishna

             AP            The institution was issued a Deficiency letter dated 06.06.2007 giving a time of 90
                           days for submitting the compliance to the effect that all the deficiency communicated
                           have been removed. The period of 90 days have been expired but the applicant
                           institute didn‟t submit any reply. The matter of all such institutions was considered by
                           SRC in its 135th meeting held on 7th & 8th June 2007. The SRC decided to closed the
                           file and inform the institute about the decision .


                           As per the decision of SRC a letter was issued to the institution on 06.11.2007.


                           The Institute has approached to Hon‟ble High Court in W.P.No.19647 of 2010.

                           Now, the Hon‟ble High Court has passed an order on 11.08.2010 vide W.P.No.19647
                           of 2010 reads as hereunder:
                           “The writ petition is disposed of directing the National Council for Teacher Education
                           to consider the petitioner college‟s case for granting permission for commencing
                           D.Ed., course independently and pass appropriate orders as expeditiously as
                           possible. No order as to costs.” A copy of the order enclosed.
                           The Committee considered the matter and decided to process the application
                           on submission of original application and related supporting documents within
                           four Four weeks from the date of confirmation of the Minutes.

75.       APS02370         SRC-NCTE granted recognition on 5.11.2007 for B.Ed course with an intake of 100
             B.Ed          students in respect of Sri Venkateswara College of Education, No. 171/1/4/5,
      Sri Venkateshwara    Mandapathur Road, Thiruvettakudy, Kottucherry-609609, Karaikal District,
           College of      Pondicherry.
          Education,
          Puducherry       NCTE-Hqrs. has forwarded inspection report, which was conducted on 20.4.2009
                           under Section 13 of NCTE Act in respect of Sri Venkateswara College of Education,
             PO            Mandapathur Road, Thiruvettakuddy, Karaikal, Pondicherry.

                                                         84

          (Gangadharaiah)                                                       (Prof. C. Thangamuthu)
        Regional Director, SRC, NCTE                                            Chairman, SRC, NCTE
                                                                                     th
                                                                                198 Meeting of SRC
                                                                                th h
                                                                             24 -26 November 2010

                 The Council has noticed from the inspection report under section 13 submitted by the
                 inspection team that the institution is not running the course in accordance with the
                 norms and standards of the NCTE. The Council, has, therefore, decided that the
                 inspection report may be forwarded to SRC, NCTE, Bangalore to initiate action
                 against the institution under Section 17 of the NCTE Act.

                 The Extract of the overall assessment of the institution is as follows:

                 “At the time of team‟s visit the students were reported left after morning test. In-
                 complete construction, unfurnished, unset labs, in-adequate books of relevance to
                 the courses conducted, correction in FDRs nor hand attested although rubber
                 stamped by banks and not healthy but untidy premises including want of drinking
                 water, fire fighting facilities in this tsunami affected area obviate all other positive
                 features observed and noted in this report call for urgent remedies for conducting the
                 programmes”.

                 SRC in its 184th Meeting held on 26-27 October, 2009 has decided to cause
                 inspection under Section 17 of NCTE Act, on submission of all related documents
                 including filled in Questionnaire within four weeks since the date of confirmation of
                 the Minutes.

                 Accordingly, a letter was issued to the institution on 02.12.2009 seeking required
                 documents along with the filled questionnaire. The institution has not submitted its
                 reply even after expiry of stipulated period.

                 The Committee considered the matter and observed that the institution has not
                 replied to the Notice dated 2.12.2009. Hence, based on the gist of VT report,
                 inspected under Section 13 of NCTE Act by NCTE-HQ and also based on the
                 available records, the Committee considered the matter and decided to withdraw
                 recognition of B.Ed. course for the following :-

                  “At the time of team‟s visit the students were reported left after morning test.
                   Incomplete construction, unfurnished, unset labs, inadequate books of relevance to
                   the courses conducted, correction in FDRs nor hand attested although, rubber
                   stamped by banks and not healthy but untidy premises including want of drinking
                   water, fire fighting facilities in this tsunami affected area obviate all other positive
                   features observed and noted in this report call for urgent remedies for conducting
                   the programmes”.
                  The institution has not replied to the Notice of the institution dated 2.12.2009, even
                   after six months after the notice period. The institution is trying to avoid Section 17
                   inspection by not responding to the Notice implying that it has not remedied the
                   deficiencies.

                 Under the above grounds, the Committee decides to withdraw the recognition for B.
                 Ed. course.
                 Accordingly, withdrawal order was issued to the institution on 02.08.2010.

                 The institution has filed an appeal under Section 18 of NCTE Act, before the
                 Appellate Authority, NCTE, New Delhi against the withdrawal order of SRC.
                                              85

  (Gangadharaiah)                                                      (Prof. C. Thangamuthu)
Regional Director, SRC, NCTE                                           Chairman, SRC, NCTE
                                                                                              th
                                                                                         198 Meeting of SRC
                                                                                         th h
                                                                                      24 -26 November 2010



                          The Appellate authority vide its order dated 27.09.2010 reversed the case with
                          direction to the SRC to reconsider the case after examining the reply dated
                          02.01.2010.

                          The Committee in its 197th meeting held on 13-14 October 2010 considered the
                          appelleate authority order dated 27.09.2010 decided to consider the reply of the
                          institution.

                          The institution has forwarded their reply sent on 02.01.2010 to the SRC Notice vide
                          letter dated 05.10.2010.

                          The Committee considered the reply of the institution and other related
                          documents along with the original file of the institution and decided to continue
                          recognition accorded to the institution.

76.      APS05203         Pragathi D.Ed College, H.M.Nagar, Mudhol, Bagalkot-587313, Karnataka has been
            D.Ed          granted recognition for D.Ed course on 01.11.2007. The recognition was withdrawn
       Pragathi D.Ed      vide order dated 05.03.2010.
      College, Bagalkot
                          The Institution preferred appeal and the Appellate Authority has remanded back the
             KA           case to SRC vide order dated 19.07.2010 and has stated that the institution may be
                          allowed to shift to own premises by November 2010 and the appellant shall apply to
                          the SRC for inspection of permanent premises well in advance along with the
                          inspection fee and its requisite documents, so that shifting of the institution shall take
                          place within stipulated period of 3 years.

                          The SRC in its 195th meeting held on 17- 18 August, 2010 considered the appellate
                          authority order dated 19.7.2010 remanding the case to SRC for causing inspection of
                          permanent premises and it was decided to cause inspection of the institution for
                          B.Ed. Course, under Section 17 of NCTE Act, on payment of Rs.40,000/- inspection
                          fee and on submission of filled in Questionnaire, along with relevant supporting
                          documents relating to building, land, including Building Completion Certificate from
                          the competent Government Engineer and Land Use Certificate. Accordingly, a letter
                          was issued to the institution on 27.09.2010.

                          The institution has submitted written representation on 26.10.2010 and the details are
                          given below:
                          1. The institution has submitted duly filled up questionnaire.
                          2. Record of Rights (RTC) in Survey no.33 having 2 acres of land.
                          3. Approved Building plan – In the building plan the name and address of the
                              competent authority is not mentioned.
                          4. The institution has submitted original Affidavit in Survey no.33 having total area of
                              land 8095.65 sq.mts. and the built up area is not mentioned.
                          5. The institution has not submitted Building Completion Certificate from the
                              competent Government Engineer and Land Use Certificate.

                          Further, the institution has also not submitted Rs.40,000/- towards inspection fee and
                          has requested SRC to provide 3 months time for inspection.
                                                       86

         (Gangadharaiah)                                                        (Prof. C. Thangamuthu)
       Regional Director, SRC, NCTE                                             Chairman, SRC, NCTE
                                                                                                 th
                                                                                             198 Meeting of SRC
                                                                                            th  h
                                                                                          24 -26 November 2010

                             The Committee considered the matter and decided to cause inspection of the
                             institution for shifting to new premises after submission of Rs. 40000/- towards
                             inspection fee.

77.        APS03720          Mohammadi Institute of Diploma in Education, Gulbarga, Karnataka is granted
              D.Ed
                             recognition for D.Ed. course on 3.2.2006.
          Mohammadi
      Institute of Diploma   This is one of the teacher training institutes against which the State Government
         in Education,
                             Directorate has made specific complaints based on their inspection. As the State
            Gulbarga
                             Government made a specific complaint, the matter was placed before 178th meeting
              KA
                             of SRC      held on 13-14 July, 2009 and Notice was served to the institution on
                             18.8.2009 for the following reasons, as pointed out by the State Directorate:-
                                 The inspection team has reported that the institution is not functioning in the
                                  proposed address.
                             Reply to the Notice was submitted by the institution on 31.8.2009. FDR of Rs. 3
                             lakhs is not submitted.
                             The Committee considered the reply and decided to issue Notice for submission of
                             filled in Questionnaire along with supporting documents for all Teacher Education
                             course within 21 days from the date of receipt of this Notice, for taking further action
                             in the matter.
                             Accordingly, a Notice was sent to the institution on 31.10.2009. The institution has
                             submitted written representation on 16.12.2009.
                             The Committee considered the reply to the Notice and decided to Withdraw
                             Recognition of the institution for the following reasons:-
                             1. Building Completion Certificate issued from the Government authority on the
                                 prescribed format is not submitted.
                             2. The institution has not submitted original FDR for Rs.3 lakhs towards Reserve
                                 Fund kept in the Joint Account.
                             3. The Management has not made arrangement to run the D.Ed. course for the
                                 sessions 2007-08, 2008-09 and 2009-10.
                             The Committee considered the Appellate authority order dt. 31.08.2010 and
                             decided to continue recognition accorded to the institution.

78.       SRCAPP86           TNN Memorial Educational & Charitable Trust, TNN Memorial College of Teacher
             B.Ed            Education, No.439/1, Lakshmi Vilasam, Arumanai, Vilavancode, Kanyakumari-
        TNN Memorial         629151, Tamilnadu submitted its application for B.Ed course through on-line on
      College of Teacher     27.10.2009. Application of the above institution was received by SRC on 30.10.2009.
          Education,         The application was processed and deficiency letter was issued to the institution on
                                                           87

          (Gangadharaiah)                                                          (Prof. C. Thangamuthu)
        Regional Director, SRC, NCTE                                               Chairman, SRC, NCTE
                                                                                     th
                                                                                 198 Meeting of SRC
                                                                                th  h
                                                                              24 -26 November 2010

Kanyakumari       22.12.2009.

    TN            The institution submitted its written representation on 08.03.2010, which was
                  considered by SRC in its 190th meeting held on 29th-30th March, 2010 and the
                  Committee decided to reject the application on the following grounds:

                   The institution has not submitted valid Minority Status Certificate from the
                  Competent Authority.

                  Accordingly, the application was rejected vide order F.SRC/NCTE/B.Ed/2010/18625
                  dated. 30.04.2010.

                  Aggrieved by the rejection order, the institution preferred appeal u/s 18 of NCTE Act.

                  The Appellate Authority vide its order No.F.No.89-779/2010-Appeal dated 24.09.2010
                  reversed the order of the SRC dated 30.04.2010 with a direction to SRC to process
                  the application on merits. In case the institution get recognition on merit, they would
                  be required to submit a minority states certificate for the institution in due course and
                  would abide by their obligation as a minority institution, in order to enjoy continuous
                  recognition

                  SRC considered the appeal order in its 197th meeting held on 13th-14th October 2010
                  and decided to process the application.

                  Accordingly, the file was scrutinized and the following points were observed:

                   The land document in the form of Gift deed dated 30.9.2008 is in individual
                    capacity, namely in favour of N. Vijayakumar. This document shows that land is
                    not in favour of the society/institution.
                   As per Point No.3 in the affidavit, it is mentioned that land is on ownership basis
                    for a period of 30 years.
                   Building Completion Certificate submitted is not as per prescribed format.
                   As per land documents, total area of land is 2751.96 sq.mtrs but as per affidavit
                    total land area is 1499.97 sq.mtrs both are not matching.

                  The Committee considered Appellate Authority order and it was decided to
                  serve Notice Under Section 17 of NCTE Act for the following deficiencies:-

                   The land document in the form of Gift deed dated 30.9.2008 is in individual
                    capacity, namely in favour of N. Vijayakumar. This document shows that land
                    is not in favour of the society/institution, as per the norms.

                   As per Point No.3 in the affidavit, it is mentioned that land is on ownership
                    basis for a period of 30 years.How is it that the ownership of land is for a
                    limited future? How a permanent institution be started on such an uncertain
                    condition?

                   Buillding Completion Certificate submitted is not as per prescribed format.
                    Building should be permanent, complete and exclusive, in all respects, as per
                                               88

  (Gangadharaiah)                                                      (Prof. C. Thangamuthu)
Regional Director, SRC, NCTE                                           Chairman, SRC, NCTE
                                                                                                 th
                                                                                             198 Meeting of SRC
                                                                                            th  h
                                                                                          24 -26 November 2010

                               norms.

                              As per land documents, total area of land is 2751.96 sq.mtrs but as per
                               affidavit total land area is 1499.97 sq.mtrs. Both are conflicting and hence
                               lacking credibility.

                              The institute has not submitted the Land useage certificate                     from a
                               competent Govt. approved authority.

                             In view of the above, the Committee decided to issue Notice to the institution
                             and thereby providing an opportunity to the institution to make a written
                             representation within 30days from the date of issue of the Notice along with
                             necessary certificates/documents in order to take a final decision in the matter,
                             failing which action will be taken including the closure of the application and
                             rejection based on the records available, with no further notice.

79.      SRCAPP54            Don Bosco College of Education and Research Institute, Adhiyaman By Pass Road,
             B.Ed            Sogathur, Dharmapuri District-636809, Tamilnadu submitted its application for B.Ed
      Don Bosco College      course through on-line on 20.10.2009. Application of the above institution was
        of Education &       received by SRC on 27.10.2009. The application was processed and deficiency letter
      Research Institute,    was issued to the institution on 22.12.2009. The institution submitted its written
         Dharmapuri          representation on 19.02.2010.
                             The SRC considered the matter in its 189th meeting held on 25th-26th February 2010
              TN             and on careful perusal of the original file of the institution and other related
                             documents, Committee decided to cause inspection to the institution.
                             The inspection of the institution was conducted on 24.04.2010. The SRC in its 192nd
                             meeting held on 10th-11th May 2010 after considering the report of the visiting team as
                             well as other relevant materials furnished by the applicant institution, the Regional
                             Committee decided to refuse recognition to B.Ed course for the following grounds:-
                            The institution has not produced valid Minority Certificate issued by the competent
                            authority.
                              The visit was conducted inadvertently, before getting the proper clarification from the
                            State Government on the requirements of a legally valid Minority Certificate from a
                            competent authority.
                             The institution without valid Minority Certificate, as such, is not eligible to apply under
                             Minority category.
                             The institution has not produced valid Minority Certificate issued by the competent
                             authority.
                             Accordingly, the application was rejected vide order F.SRC/NCTE/B.Ed/2010/19160
                             dated. 28.05.2010.

                             Aggrieved by the rejection order, the institution preferred appeal u/s 18 of NCTE Act.

                             The Appellate Authority vide its order No.F.No.89-746/2010-Appeal dated 15.09.2010
                             reversed with the direction to the SRC for processing the case further on merit.

                             SRC considered the appeal order in its 197th meeting held on 13th-14th October 2010
                             and decided to process the application.

                                                           89

          (Gangadharaiah)                                                           (Prof. C. Thangamuthu)
        Regional Director, SRC, NCTE                                                Chairman, SRC, NCTE
                                                                                          th
                                                                                     198 Meeting of SRC
                                                                                     th h
                                                                                  24 -26 November 2010

                       The inspection of the institution was carried out on 24.04.2010

                        The Committee had not earlier considered the VTR and the other
                         documentary evidences, as the institution did not submit valid minority
                         certificate. Hence the same be processed and put up for consideration.

80.   SRCAPP141        Sri Ramanas College of Education, No.2/654, Chidambarapuram, Aruppukottai
          B.Ed         Taluk, Virudhunagar District-626134, Tamilnadu submitted its application for B.Ed
      Sri Ramanas      course through on-line on 30.10.2009. Application of the above institution was
       College of      received by SRC on 30.10.2009. The application was processed and deficiency letter
       Education,      was issued to the institution on 22.12.2009. The institution submitted its written
      Virudhunagar     representation on 25.01.2010.

          TN           The SRC considered the matter in its 189th meeting held on 25th-26th February 2010
                       and on careful perusal of the original file of the institution and other related
                       documents, Committee decided to cause inspection to the institution.

                       The inspection of the institution was conducted on 07.05.2010. The SRC in its 192nd
                       meeting held on 10th-11th May 2010 after considering the report of the visiting team as
                       well as other relevant materials furnished by the applicant institution, the Regional
                       Committee decided to refuse recognition to B.Ed course for the following grounds:-

                        The institution has not produced valid Minority Certificate issued by the competent
                         authority.
                        The visit was conducted inadvertently, before getting the proper clarification from
                         the State Government on the requirements of a legally valid Minority Certificate
                         from a competent authority.
                        The institution without valid Minority Certificate, as such, is not eligible to apply
                         under Minority category.
                       Accordingly, the application was rejected vide order F.SRC/NCTE/B.Ed/2010/19161
                       dated. 28.05.2010.

                       Aggrieved by the rejection order, the institution preferred appeal u/s 18 of NCTE Act.

                       .The Appellate Authority vide its order No.F.No.89-720/2010-Appeal dated
                       24.09.2010 reversed the order of the SRC dated 28.05.2010 with a direction to SRC
                       to process the application on merits. This would however subject to the condition
                       that a valid minority certificate would be obtained by the society for the institution in
                       due course and that the institution shall abide by their obligation as a minority
                       institution in order to enjoy continuos recognition.

                       SRC considered the appeal order in its 197th meeting held on 13th-14th October 2010
                       and decided to process the application.

                        The Committee had not earlier considered the VTR and the other
                         documentary evidences, as the institution did not submit valid minority
                         certificate. Hence the same be processed and put up for consideration.


                                                   90

        (Gangadharaiah)                                                     (Prof. C. Thangamuthu)
      Regional Director, SRC, NCTE                                          Chairman, SRC, NCTE
                                                                                             th
                                                                                         198 Meeting of SRC
                                                                                        th  h
                                                                                      24 -26 November 2010

81.       APS09050         Refusal order in respect of Rosammal Memorial Minority College of Education,
             B.Ed          Tuticorin, Tamilnadu for B.Ed course was issued on 13.4.2009.
      Rosammal Memorial
       Minority College,   Aggrieved by the refusal order of SRC, the institution preferred an appeal to NCTE-
           Tuticorin       Hqrs. The appellate authority in its order F.No.89-379/2009-Appeal/99399 dated
                           7.8.2009 confirms the order appealed against.
             TN
                           Meantime, a court notice was received in W.P. no. 24907 of 2009 filed by Rosammal
                           Memorial Minority College of Education enclosing a copy of writ petition filed by the
                           institution. In response to the writ petition a letter was issued on 14.12.2009 to Shri.
                           M.T. Arunan, Advocate enclosing a brief of the case and a copy of appeal order
                           dated 7.8.2009.

                           Shri. M.T. Arunan, Advocate has forwarded a court order on 23.12.2009 in W.P. No.
                           24907 of 2009 dated 18.12.2009 filed by the institution. The Hon‟ble court has
                           ordered as follows;
                           “This writ petition is filed for the issue of a writ of mandamus directing the first
                           respondent to pass orders on the petitioner‟s appeal dated 16.4.2009.

                           On notice, the Learned Counsel for the respondents 1 and 2 has submitted that
                           within a period of two weeks from the date of receipt of a copy of this order, the
                           petitioner‟s appeal dated 16.4.2009 will be disposed of.

                           Recording the above submission made by the Learned Counsel for the respondents
                           1 and 2, this writ petition is closed. No costs”.

                           Meantime, a copy of written representation addressed to the Member Secretary,
                           NCTE, New Delhi has been received from the institution on 29.12.2009 enclosing a
                           copy of court order in W.P. No. 24907 of 2009 and Lease Deed. A copy of the same
                           court order was received from the petitioner‟s advocate on 29.12.2009.

                           A letter dated 1.1.2010 was issued to the Member Secretary, NCTE, New Delhi
                           informing that the Hon‟ble High Court of Madras has passed a judgement on
                           18.12.2009 in the above writ petition directing the 1st respondent (Member Secretary,
                           NCTE-New Delhi) to pass orders on the petitioner‟s appeal dated 16.4.2009 within a
                           period of two weeks from the date of receipt of this order. A copy of the court order
                           has enclosed with the letter for direction in the matter. So far this office has not
                           received any reply from the NCTE-Hqrs., New Delhi.

                           Meantime, Petitioner‟s Counsel Shri. P. Munusamy forwarded a Contempt Petition
                           no. 193 of 2010 against W.P. No. 24907 of 2009 which was received on 3.3.2010
                           states that the matter is posted on 11.3.2010 for your appearance.

                           Shri. Arunan, Advocate has forwarded a copy of writ petition no. 4419 of 2010 filed by
                           Rosammal Memorial Minority College of Education against NCTE. The matter came
                           up on 3.3.2010 and the same is adjourned to 10.3.2010.

                           W.P.No. 4419 of 2010 filed by the above mentioned institution received on 12.3.2010
                           states that“……..it is humbly prayed that this Hon‟ble court may be pleased to issue a
                                                       91

          (Gangadharaiah)                                                       (Prof. C. Thangamuthu)
        Regional Director, SRC, NCTE                                            Chairman, SRC, NCTE
                                                                                     th
                                                                                 198 Meeting of SRC
                                                                                th  h
                                                                              24 -26 November 2010

                 Writ of Certiorarified Mandamus or any other Writ, order or direction in the nature of a
                 writ calling for the records from the first respondent relating to the impugned order in
                 F.No.89-379/2009-Appeal order dated 7.8.2009, quash the same and further direct
                 the first and second respondent to grant recognition to the petitioner institution to start
                 a one year B.Ed Degree course from the academic year 2010-2011 without insisting
                 on NOC from the 3rd Respondent and pass any other further or other orders this
                 Hon‟ble Court may deem fit and proper in the circumstances of the case and thus
                 render justice”.

                 A court order in W.P. No. 44815 of 2002 has been received on 15.3.2010. The court
                 order states as “……seeks permission to withdraw the writ petition. He has also made an
                 endorsement to that effect. Permission is granted, and the writ petition is dismissed as
                 withdrawn”.

                 Shri M.T. Arunan, advocate has forwarded a letter dated 11.3.2010 enclosing a copy
                 of additional affidavit of the petitioner in W.P. no. 4419 of 2010. In the affidavit the
                 petitioner states that has filed the afore said writ petition for Certiorarified Mandamus
                 calling for the records from the 1st Respondent in F.No.89/379/2009 appeal dated
                 7.8.2009, quash the same and further direct the first and second respondent to grant
                 recognition to the petitioner institution.

                 The petitioner humbly states that the only ground on which the Appellant Authority
                 rejected the appeal was that the petitioner has not submitted the land documents
                 before the original authority at the time of main application. The appellate authority
                 had taken a stand that the land documents were submitted subsequently.

                 The petitioner humbly states that he willing to re-submit a fresh application for
                 recognition within one week from today and this Hon‟ble Court may be pleased to
                 direct the 2nd Respondent to receive the applicant and pass orders within prescribed
                 time limit and thus render justice.

                 The above said institution has re-submitted the application in-triplicate for B.Ed
                 course on 17.3.2010 along with D.D. of Rs. 40,000/- and DD. Rs. 1000/- along with
                 court order in W.P.No. 4419 of 2010, which states as follows; “…….In view of the
                 said submissions, this writ petition is disposed of granting permission to the petitioner
                 to submit a fresh application for recognition within one weeks from the date of receipt
                 of a copy of this order and the second respondent is directed to receive the same and
                 pass necessary orders in accordance with law, within a period of eight weeks from
                 the date of receipt of the application from the petitioner”.

                 Accordingly the file was forwarded to NCTE-Hqrs for further consideration. The
                 appellate authority vide order dated 24.09.2010 reversed the order of the SRC dt.
                 04.05.2010 with the direction to process the fresh application on merits, by treating
                 the application for establishment of a minority educational institution of Christian
                 minority. The institution if recognized on merit, would obtain a minority status
                 certificate from the concerned authority of the State Government and would abide by
                 its obligation as a minority institution.

                 The institution vide letter dated 05.10.2010 submitted its written representation. The

                                              92

  (Gangadharaiah)                                                      (Prof. C. Thangamuthu)
Regional Director, SRC, NCTE                                           Chairman, SRC, NCTE
                                                                                 th
                                                                             198 Meeting of SRC
                                                                            th  h
                                                                          24 -26 November 2010

                 institution has submitted application for B.Ed course on 12.10.2010 but not submitted
                 in on-line mode.

                 SRC considered the appeal order in its 197th meeting held on 13th-14th October 2010
                 and decided to process the application.

                 Accordingly, the documents dated 05.10.2010 & 12.10.2010 was scrutinized and the
                 following deficiencies observed:

                  The institution has not submitted application on-line.

                  As per affidavit submitted on 12.10.2010, total area of land is 13680.774 sq.ft
                   which comes to 1270.91 sq.mtrs. As per NCTE norms regulations, total land
                   area required for B.Ed college is 2500 sq.mtrs.

                  As per affidavit, Plot No/ Khasra No, where the college is proposed to start is
                   not mentioned.

                  The institution has submitted two lease deeds (private) dt. 3.10.2007 &
                   21.04.2009 for a period of 35 years & 29 years in the name of Rosammal
                   Memorial Minority College of Education (Women), which is not acceptable as
                   per NCTE Regulation.

                  Land usage certificate is submitted in Tamil version, English version to be
                   submitted.

                  Copy of Building Plan submitted is not approved by Government Competent
                   Authority. As per Building Plan total built up space is 2647.04 sq.mtrs at
                   D.No.85/2C, Boopalarayerpuram in Sy.No.5842, Ward No.4, Block No.49,
                   Tuticorin. But Building Plan submitted with initial application is approved by
                   Government.

                  As per the norms, the institution should possess own land and own
                   permanent building complete in all respects, on the date of application.

                  FDR of Rs. 300000/- submitted towards reserve fund is of not joint account.
                   FDR of Rs. 500000/- towards endowment is not submitted.

                  Building Completion Certificate is not submitted.

                 As per the documentary evidences submitted dt. 5.10.2010 & Dt. 12.10.2010 and
                 the deficiencies as stated above, clarification should be submitted by the
                 institution.

                 The Committee also considered Appellate order Dt. 24.09.2010 and all the
                 relevant documentary evidences and it was decided to serve Showcause
                 Notice on the above.
                 In view of the above, the Committee decided to issue a Showcause Notice to
                 the institution as to why the application can’t not be closed and thereby
                                            93

  (Gangadharaiah)                                                   (Prof. C. Thangamuthu)
Regional Director, SRC, NCTE                                        Chairman, SRC, NCTE
                                                                                            th
                                                                                        198 Meeting of SRC
                                                                                       th  h
                                                                                     24 -26 November 2010

                          providing an opportunity to the institution to make a written representation
                          within 30 days from the date of issue of the Notice along with necessary
                          certificates/documents in order to take a final decision in the matter; failing
                          which action will be taken including the closure and rejection of the
                          application. based on the records available, with no further notice.

82.           ----        Processing of New Applications received for the session 2011-2012- clarification reg.
              ----
      Processing of New   New Regulation 2009 came into force on 31st August, 2009. Para 5(4) of Regulation
         Applications     state that:-
       received for the   “Duly completed applications in all respect may be submitted to the Regional
      session 2011-2012   Committee concerned during the period from the 1st day of September till 31st day
                          October of the preceding year to the academic session for which recognition has
             ---          been sought”

                          1. As per NCTE Hqrts, New Delhi Public Notice dated 29.7.2010 the application
                             should be submitted on-line between 1st Aug, 2010 to 30th Sep, 2010
                             subsequently this date was extended upto 1st October, 2010 by NCTE Hqrs vide
                             their letter dated 29.09.2010.

                          2. As per 7(1-A) of NCTE Regulation, 2009 the application submitted on-line but not
                             followed by dispatch, through registered post or by hand with the documents
                             mentioned at (i ) to (vii) of 7(1) of regulation, 2009 within 7 days shall be
                             summarily rejected with reasons recorded in writing and returned to the applicant
                             along with processing fee with in 30 days of receipt of application.

                          3. SRC has received 34 no of hard copies of the on-line application even beyond the
                             stipulated 7 days period i.e date 08.10.2010 from the date of on-line submission
                             i.e 01-10-2010 (list enclosed). In this regard a letter has been sent to NCTE Hqrs
                             on 25.10.2010 with request to kindly issue direction whether such hard copies of
                             on-line applications may be accepted by SRC or not. However the reply of the
                             same is still awaited. In view of non receipt of confirmation i.e reference to State
                             Government as well as issue of deficiency letters are kept in abeyance.

                          4.    Meanwhile, NCTE Hqrs vide letter dated 18.10.2010 advised Regional
                               Committee not to communicate the outcome of the scrutiny of applications
                               including issuance of deficiency letters before the notification of the amendments
                               to the Regulation in this regard. As per above instructions received from NCTE
                               Hqrs issue of deficiency letters to institutions are kept in abeyance.

                          5. As per proviso 5(5) to Regulation 2009 the applications received so far in
                             Regional Committees are to disposed of by 15th May 2011 succeeding year. In
                             view of the delay due to non-receiving of direction from the Hqrs in this regard,
                             the last date of conveying the outcome of application either recognition granted or
                             refused shall automatically be affected.

                          The following is the list of 34 no of hard copies of the on-line application
                          received even beyond the stipulated 7 days period i.e. from 08/2/2010 from the
                          date of on-line submission i.e, 01-10-2010.
                                                       94

          (Gangadharaiah)                                                     (Prof. C. Thangamuthu)
        Regional Director, SRC, NCTE                                          Chairman, SRC, NCTE
                                                                                            th
                                                                                       198 Meeting of SRC
                                                                                      th  h
                                                                                    24 -26 November 2010

                  Sl.   ID Code     Name of the trust/         Name of      course           Date of      Challan/
                  No                    Society              the College                   Submissio      D.D No &
                                                                                            n of hard     Amount.
                                                                                             copy in
                                                                                               SRC
                  01    SRCAP     Malla Reddy                CMR             D.Ed          18/.10.2010   D.D
                         P376     Educational Society        Institute of                                40000/-
                                  294, Comssary Bazar,       Elementary                                  D.D No-
                                  New Bowenpally,            Teacher                                     010393
                                  Secunderabad,              Education                                   D.D
                                  Hyderabad,                 S.No-563,                                   1000/-
                                  RangaReddy-500011,         Gundla                                      D.D No-
                                  Andhra Pradesh             Pochampall                                  010390
                                                             y, Dundigal,
                                                             Secunderab
                                                             ad,
                                                             RangaRedd
                                                             y-500055,
                                                             Andhra
                                                             Pradesh
                  02    SRCAP     Sri Sai Venkata            Sri Sai        H.P.T          14.10.2010    Challan
                         P383     Computer Educational       Venkata                                     40100/-
                                  Society                    Hindi Maha                                  Dt-
                                  898, Cherkupalli, Pundi,   Vidyalayam                                  01.10.2010
                                  Nandigam, Srikakulam-      86/5, 898,
                                  532218,                    Cherkupalli,
                                  AndhraPradesh              Pundi,
                                                             Nandigam,
                                                             Srikakulam-
                                                             532218,
                                                             Andhra
                                                             Pradesh
                  03    SRCAP     St Martins Educational     MR Institute    B.Ed          18.10.2010    D.D
                        P372+3    Society                    of Teacher                                  40000/-
                          75      294, Comssary Bazar,       Education                                   D.D No-
                                  New Bowenpally,            S.No-563,                                   010395
                                  Secunderabad,              Gundla                                      D.D
                                  Hyderabad,                 Pochampall                                  1000/-
                                  RangaReddy-500011,         y, Dundigal,                                D.D No-
                                  AndhraPradesh              Secunderab                                  010396
                                                             ad,
                                                             RangaRedd
                                                             y-500055,
                                                             Andhra
                                                             Pradesh
                  04    SRCAP     St Martins Educational     MR Institute    D.Ed          18.10.2010    D.D
                        P375+3    Society                    of                                          40000/-
                          72      294, Comssary Bazar,       Elementary                                  D.D No-
                                  New Bowenpally,            Teacher                                     010394
                                  Balanagar,                 Education                                   D.D
                                  Secunderabad,              563,                                        1000/-
                                  RangaReddy-500011,         Gundla                                      D.D No-
                                  Andhra Pradesh             Pochampall                                  010397
                                                             y, Dundigal,
                                                             Secunderab
                                                             ad,
                                                             RangaRedd
                                                             y-500055,
                                                             AndhraPrad
                                                             esh
                                                 95

  (Gangadharaiah)                                                           (Prof. C. Thangamuthu)
Regional Director, SRC, NCTE                                                Chairman, SRC, NCTE
                                                                                       th
                                                                                  198 Meeting of SRC
                                                                                 th  h
                                                                               24 -26 November 2010

                  05   SRCAP    Gods Foundation         Sri Balaji      M.Ed          18.10.2010   D.D
                        P389    Nursing Educational     College of                                 40000/-
                                Society                 Education                                  D.D No-
                                42, Doctors Colony, B   S.No-440-                                  244425
                                Camp Post Office,       3A&B,
                                Kurnool-518002,         Ponnutipaly
                                AndhraPradesh           am,
                                                        Madanapall
                                                        e, Chittoor-
                                                        517325,
                                                        AndhraPrad
                                                        esh
                  06   SRCAP    CVS Krishna Murthy      CVS             M.Ed          18.10.2010   D.D
                       P424+4   Theja Charities         Krishna                                    41000/-
                         44     131, Chadalawada        Theja                                      D.D No-
                                Nagar, Daminedu,        College of                                 027073
                                Settipalli, Tirupati,   Education
                                Chittoor-517506,        131, #1,
                                AndhraPradesh           Daminedu,
                                                        Settipalli,
                                                        Tirupati,
                                                        Chittoor-
                                                        517506,
                                                        AndhraPrad
                                                        esh
                  07   SRCAP    Malla Reddy             Malla           M.Ed          18.10.2010   D.D
                        P440    Educational Society     Reddy                                      40000/-
                                S.No-59, Jaya Nagar,    College Of                                 D.D No-
                                New Bowenpally,         Education                                  432410
                                Secunderabad,           1-238,                                     D.D
                                RangaReddy-500011,      Madhava                                    1000/-
                                AndhraPradesh.          Nagar,                                     D.D No-
                                                        Miyapur,                                   432409
                                                        Sherlingam
                                                        pally,
                                                        Hyderabad,
                                                        RangaRedd
                                                        y-500049,
                                                        AndhraPrad
                                                        esh.
                  08   SRCAP    CVS Krishna Murthy      CVS             D.Ed          18.10.2010   D.D
                       P444+4   Theja Charities         Krishna                                    41000/-
                         24     131, Chadalawada        Theja                                      D.D No-
                                Nagar, Daminedu,        College of                                 027074
                                Settipalli, Tirupati,   Education
                                Chittoor-517506,        131,
                                AndhraPradesh           3219/2000,
                                                        #2,
                                                        Daminedu,
                                                        Settipalli,
                                                        Tirupati,
                                                        Chittoor-
                                                        517506,
                                                        AndhraPrad
                                                        esh
                  09            Sri Bhadravathi         Sumourya       H.P.T          21.10.2010   D.D
                                Bhavana Rushi           HPT                                        1000/-
                       SRCAP
                                Charitable Trust        College                                    D.D No-
                        P280
                                P.No-180/1 ,180/2,      P.No-180/1                                 943582
                                Nandyal Road, VPO- B.   180/2, Nh-                                 D.D
                                               96

  (Gangadharaiah)                                                      (Prof. C. Thangamuthu)
Regional Director, SRC, NCTE                                           Chairman, SRC, NCTE
                                                                                         th
                                                                                    198 Meeting of SRC
                                                                                   th  h
                                                                                 24 -26 November 2010

                                Tandrapadu, Kallur        18, B,                                     40050/-
                                Taluka, Dist Kurnool-     Tandrapadu                                 D.D No-
                                518007, Andhra            Vill, P.O-                                 943583
                                Pradesh                   Nanur, Dist-
                                                          Kurnool-
                                                          518007,
                                                          Andhra
                                                          Pradesh
                  10                                      JMJ             B.Ed          22.10.2010   D.D
                                                          College of                                 40500/-
                                St Marys educational      Education,                                 D.D No-
                                Society                   P No-71,                                   002047
                                P No-1-40/1,              VPO-                                       D.D
                                Thimmaraopet, VPO-        Thimmarao                                  5000/-
                       SRCAP
                                Thimmaraopet, Taluka-     pet, Taluka-                               D.D No-
                        P351
                                Chennaraopet, City-       Chennarao                                  002048
                                Narsampet, Dist-          pet, Dist-
                                Warangal-506332,          Warangal-
                                Andhra Pradesh            506332,
                                                          Andhra
                                                          Pradesh
                  11                                      V. C .R         M.Ed          22.10.2010   D.D
                                                          College of                                 40100/-
                                                          Education                                  D.D No-
                                Smt Lakshmamma and        P.No-220/5,                                819816
                                Srinivasula Reddy         Mapakshi
                                Educational Society       Vill, P.O
                       SRCAP
                                P.No-19-277, Reddy‟s      Reddigunta,
                        P432
                                Colony, VPO-Chittoor,     Chittoor
                                Dist-Chittoor-517001,     Taluka, Dist
                                Andhra Pradesh            Chittoor-
                                                          517002,
                                                          Andhra
                                                          Pradesh
                  12   SRCAP    St. Xaviers Educational   St. Xaviers     D.Ed          11.10.2010    Challan
                       P266+3   Society                   College of                                  41000/-
                       20       92/1, LakshmiNagar,       Education                                      Dt-
                                Chinamushidavada,         92/1, 14-                                  28.09.2010
                                Pendurthy,                163,
                                Visakhapatnam-            Lakshmi
                                530051,                   Nagar,
                                Andhrapradesh             Chinamushi
                                                          davada,
                                                          Pendurthy,
                                                          Visakhapat
                                                          nam-
                                                          530051,
                                                          Andhraprad
                                                          esh
                  13   SRCAP    Musthafa Educational      Musthafa        B.Ed          11.10.2010    Challan
                       P297     Society                   College of                                  40100/-
                                No71, Amulya Colony,      Education                                      Dt-
                                Nalgonda-508001,          S.No.873,                                  29.09.2010
                                AndhraPradesh.            NLG.Road,
                                                          Narketpally,
                                                          Nalgonda-
                                                          508254,
                                                          AndhraPrad
                                                          esh

                                               97

  (Gangadharaiah)                                                        (Prof. C. Thangamuthu)
Regional Director, SRC, NCTE                                             Chairman, SRC, NCTE
                                                                                       th
                                                                                  198 Meeting of SRC
                                                                                 th  h
                                                                               24 -26 November 2010

                  14   SRCAP    Modern Educational      Modern          D.Ed          11.10.2010    Challan
                       P300     Society                 College of                                     Dt-
                                No 57, Sainagar         Elementary                                 29.09.2010
                                Colony, Nalgonda-       Education
                                508001,                 S.No.321,
                                AndhraPradesh           NLG Road,
                                                        Narketpally-
                                                        508254,
                                                        AndhraPrad
                                                        esh.
                  15                                    Kalaam                        11.10.2010     Challan
                                                        College of
                                Kalaam Educational
                                                        Education,
                                Society, No.2-1-222
                                                        S.No.436,
                       SRCAP    Chandrannakunta
                                                        Aklaigudem     D.El.Ed
                        P301    Bazar, Suryapet,
                                                        , Nalgonda-
                                Nalgonda-508213,
                                                        508001,
                                Andhra Pradesh
                                                        Andhra
                                                        Pradesh
                  16                                    Mohammad                      11.10.2010     Challan
                                                        ens College
                                                        of
                                                        Education
                                Mohammadens             for Women,
                                Educational & Welfare   No.369,
                       SRCAP    Society, No.369,        Vuppu
                       P306+3   Gazinagar,              Vagu,           B.Ed
                         11     Devarakonda,            Gazinagar,
                                Nalgonda-508248,        Devarakond
                                Andhra Pradesh          a,
                                                        Nalgonda-
                                                        508248,
                                                        Andhra
                                                        Pradesh
                  17   SRCAP    Mohammadens             Mohammde        D.Ed          11.10.2010   Challan
                       P311+3   Educational And         ns College                                 40100/-
                         06     Welfare Society         of                                         Dt-
                                S.No-369, Vuppuvagu,    Elementary                                 29.09.2010
                                Gazinagar,              Education
                                Devarakonda,            S.No-369,
                                Nalgonda-508248,        Vuppuvagu,
                                AndhraPradesh           Gazinagar,
                                                        Devarakond
                                                        a,
                                                        Nalgonda-
                                                        508248,
                                                        AndhraPrad
                                                        esh
                  18   SRCAP    Azeezia Educational     Azeezia         B.Ed          11.10.2010     Challan
                        P324    and Welfare Socirty     College of                                   40100/-
                        +336    5-8-75, Manyam          Education
                                Chalka, Nalgonda-       for Women
                                508001,                 S.No 337,
                                AndhraPradesh.          Manyamch
                                                        al,
                                                        Nalgonda-
                                                        508001,
                                                        AndhraPrad
                                                        esh.

                                              98

  (Gangadharaiah)                                                      (Prof. C. Thangamuthu)
Regional Director, SRC, NCTE                                           Chairman, SRC, NCTE
                                                                                      th
                                                                                 198 Meeting of SRC
                                                                                th  h
                                                                              24 -26 November 2010

                  19   SRCAP    Azeezia Educational     Azeezia       D.Ei.Ed        11.10.2010    Challan
                       P336+3   and Welfare Socirty     College of                                 40100/-
                         24     5-8-75, Manyam          Elementary                                    Dt-
                                Chalka, Nalgonda-       Education                                 29.09.2010
                                508001,                 S.No 337,
                                AndhraPradesh.          Manyamch
                                                        al,
                                                        Nalgonda-
                                                        508001,
                                                        AndhraPrad
                                                        esh.
                  20   SRCAP    Afsara Educational &    Afsara         B.Ed          11.10.2010    Challan
                       P337     Welfare Society         College of                                 40100/-
                                5-8-75, Manyamchalka,   education                                     Dt-
                                Nalgonda-508001,        337,                                      29.09.2010
                                AndhraPradesh           Manyamch
                                                        alka,
                                                        Nalgonda-
                                                        508001,
                                                        AndhraPrad
                                                        esh
                  21   SRCAP    Sri Shathavahana        Stella         B.Ed          11.10.2010   Challan
                       P339     Educational Society     College of                                40100/-
                                S.No.590, Behind Bus    Education                                 Dt-
                                Depot, Kodad,           S.No. 590,                                01.10.2010
                                Nalgonda-508206,        Sub
                                AndhraPradesh.          Station,
                                                        Akupamula,
                                                        Munagala,
                                                        Kodad,
                                                        Nalgonda-
                                                        508206,
                                                        AndhraPrad
                                                        esh
                  22                                    Stella                       11.10.2010     Challan
                                                        College of
                                                        Elementary
                                Sri Shathavaha
                                                        Education,
                                Educational Society,
                                                        S.No.746,
                       SRCAP    S.No.746, Behind Bus
                                                        Bus Depot,    D.El.Ed
                        P342    Depot, Kodad,
                                                        Kodad,
                                Nalgonda-508206,
                                                        Nalgonda-
                                Andhra Pradesh
                                                        508206,
                                                        Andhra
                                                        Pradesh
                  23                                    Srujana                      11.10.2010     Challan
                                                        College of
                                                        Elementary
                                Srjna Educational       Education,
                                Society, S.No.306,      S.No.306,
                       SRCAP    Penpahad Road,          Penpahad
                                                                      D.El.Ed
                        P343    Durajpally, Suryapet,   Road,
                                Nalgonda, Andhra        Durajpally,
                                Pradesh                 Suryapet,
                                                        Nalgonda,
                                                        Andhra
                                                        Pradesh
                  24            Kalaam Educational      Mina                         11.10.2010     Challan
                       SRCAP
                                Society, No.2-1-222,    College of     B.Ed
                        P346
                                Chandrannakunta         Education,
                                               99

  (Gangadharaiah)                                                     (Prof. C. Thangamuthu)
Regional Director, SRC, NCTE                                          Chairman, SRC, NCTE
                                                                                        th
                                                                                   198 Meeting of SRC
                                                                                  th  h
                                                                                24 -26 November 2010

                               Bazar, Suryapet,         H.No.1-8-
                               Nalgonda-508213,         115, Bhagat
                               Andhra Pradesh           NG,
                                                        Suryapet,
                                                        Nalgonda-
                                                        508213,
                                                        Andhra
                                                        Pradesh
                  25   SRCAP   Vyjayanthi Educational   Brindavan        M.Ed          11.10.2010     Challan
                       P459    Society                  Institute for                                 40050/-
                               Seriguda,                Teacher
                               Ibrahimpatnam,           Education
                               RangaReddy-501510,       1242, 373,
                               AndhraPradesh            374,
                                                        Seriguda,
                                                        Ibrahimpatn
                                                        am,
                                                        RangaRedd
                                                        y-501510,
                                                        AndhraPrad
                                                        esh
                  26   SRCAP   Penubala Association     Dr               B.Ed          11.10.2010      D.D
                       P461    for Social Service       Penubala                                     40050/-
                               5A, Tirumalesh           Penchalaia                                   D.D No-
                               Mansion, Maruthi         h College of                                 484433
                               Nagar, MR Palli,         Education
                               Tirupathi, Chittoor-     2177, RLY
                               517502,                  Koduru,
                               AndhraPradesh            Kadapa-
                                                        516101,
                                                        AndhraPrad
                                                        esh.
                  27   SRCAP   Sahaya Educational       Sahaya           B.Ed          11.10.2010      D.D
                       P462    Society                  Institute of                                 40050/-
                               6-1-11, Old Maternity    Advanced                                     D.D No-
                               Road, Tirupatti,         Studies in                                   484434
                               Chittoor-517501,         Education
                               AndhraPradesh            199/3,
                                                        Kotramang
                                                        alam,
                                                        Tiruchanoor
                                                        , Renigunta,
                                                        Tirupatti,
                                                        Chittoor-
                                                        517503,
                                                        AndhraPrad
                                                        esh
                  28   SRCAP   Vyjayanthi Educational   Sree Dattha      M.Ed          11.10.2010   Challan
                        P464   Society                  Brindavan                                   40050/-
                               54, Kavarampally         Institute of
                               Shivasingaram,           Teacher
                               Singaram, Narayanpet,    Education
                               Mahbubnagar-509210,      54,
                               AndhraPradesh            Kavarampal
                                                        ly
                                                        Shivasingar
                                                        am,
                                                        Singaram,
                                                        Narayanpet
                                                        ,
                                             100

  (Gangadharaiah)                                                       (Prof. C. Thangamuthu)
Regional Director, SRC, NCTE                                            Chairman, SRC, NCTE
                                                                                            th
                                                                                       198 Meeting of SRC
                                                                                      th  h
                                                                                    24 -26 November 2010

                                                           Mahbubnag
                                                           ar-509210,
                                                           AndhraPrad
                                                           esh
                  29   SRCAP    Sainatha Educational       YVSR              B.Ed          11.10.2010   D.D
                        P467    Society                    Memorial                                     40050/-
                                6/601-7C,                  College of                                   D.D No-
                                Sankarapuram,              Education                                    484430
                                Kadapa-516002,             219/A/3A,
                                AndhraPradesh              Chinnacho
                                                           wk,
                                                           Kadapa-
                                                           516002,
                                                           AndhraPrad
                                                           esh
                  30   SRCAP    StXaviersEducationaSo      St. Xaviers       B.Ed          12.10.2010     Challan
                       P320+2   ciety14163,LakshmiNag      College of                                     40100/-
                         66     ar, Chinamusidivada,       Education
                                Pendurthy,                 14-163,
                                Visakhapatnam-             Lakshminag
                                530051,                    ar,
                                Andhra Pradesh             Chinamusid
                                                           ivada,
                                                           Pendurthy,
                                                           Visakhapat
                                                           nam-
                                                           530051,
                                                           Andhra
                                                           Pradesh
                  31   SRCAP    Neo Royal Educational      Royal             B.Ed          12.10.2010   D.D
                        P330    Society,                   College                                      40100/-
                                54, Chevella,              ofEducation                                  D.D No-
                                RangaReddy-501503,         54,                                          727626
                                AndhraPradesh              Dammergid
                                                           da,
                                                           Chevella,
                                                           RangaRedd
                                                           y-501503,
                                                           AndhraPrad
                                                           esh
                  32   SRCAP    Little           Flower    Little Flower     B.Ed          12.10.2010     850059
                        P387    Educational Society        College of                                     40000/-
                                Suncity, Hydershakote,     Education                                      (Xerox)
                                Rajendra Nagar,            Suncity,
                                Hyderabad-500008,          Hydershako
                                Andhra Pradesh             te,
                                                           Rajendra
                                                           Nagar,
                                                           Hyderabad-
                                                           500008,
                                                           Andhra
                                                           Pradesh
                  33   SRCAP    S.Mohamed Mohideen,        Haji     SMS    B.Ed            13.10.2010   Challan for
                       P404     Haji     SMS      Shaik    Shaik                                        40100
                                Jalaludeen         B.Ed    Jalaludeen                                   dt.01.10.10
                                College,         No.11,    B.Ed
                                Carpenter        Street,   College,
                                Adirampattinam,            No.153,
                                Pattukkottai, Thanjavur-   Malavenirka
                                614701, Tamilnadu          du,
                                              101

  (Gangadharaiah)                                                           (Prof. C. Thangamuthu)
Regional Director, SRC, NCTE                                                Chairman, SRC, NCTE
                                                                                                           th
                                                                                                   198 Meeting of SRC
                                                                                                      h
                                                                                                     th
                                                                                                24 -26 November 2010

                                                                        Adirampatti
                                                                        nam,
                                                                        Pattukkottai
                                                                        , Tamilnadu
                              34    SRCA     Bidar Vidya Kendra         Shantinike     M.Ed               25.10.201       D.D
                                    PP413    Society, 209/1, Chidri     tan                               0            No.00963
                                             Road, Bidar -              College of                                         1
                                             585403, Karnataka          Education,                                     dated28.0
                                                                        Bidar                                          9.2010 for
                                                                        Vidya                                          Rs.40,000/
                                                                        Kendra                                             -
                                                                        Society,
                                                                        209/1,
                                                                        Chidri
                                                                        Road,
                                                                        Bidar -
                                                                        585403,
                                                                        Karnataka


                             The Committee considered the above and approved the list for necessary
                             action.

83.            ----          Sub:- Regarding new application received form Anddhra Pradesh for recognition to
               ----          TPT course for the session 2011-12.
      Application received
                             SRC has received many applications from State of Andhra Pradesh for Language
          from Andhra
                             Pandit Training Courses i.e. HPT,TPT etc. As on date NCTE has not developed
           Pradesh for
                             norms and standards for LPT course. NCTE Hqtrs may kindly guide SRC as to
       recognition to TPT
                             process these. We are also seeking a guidelines from State Govt in this regard as far
         Course for the
                             as norms and standards, faculty requirement, total land and built up area is
        session 2011-12
                             concerned. SRC has been considering applications for Language Pandit Training
                             Course previously and according recognition for the same also.
              AP
                             In this regard a clarification letter sent to NCTE hqtrs on 25.10.10 with request to
                             guide for what of their norms and standards being specified. The list of TPT
                             application as under:-
                              Sl.   ID        Name of the           Name of the        Date of On-          Date of    Challan/
                              No             trust/ Society           College             line            Submissio    D.D No & Amount.
                                    Code
                                                                                                           n of hard
                                                                                                            copy in
                                                                                                             SRC




                                                              102

           (Gangadharaiah)                                                               (Prof. C. Thangamuthu)
         Regional Director, SRC, NCTE                                                    Chairman, SRC, NCTE
                                                                                            th
                                                                                    198 Meeting of SRC
                                                                                       h
                                                                                      th
                                                                                 24 -26 November 2010

                  01                               Chaiyanya T.P.T       23.09.2010        28.09.2010   D.D
                               Chaitanya
                                                   College                                              40000/-
                               Educational
                                                   P.No-250/4, 250/1,                                   D.D N0-119759
                               Institution,
                                                   250/2, 250/3,
                               P.NO-250/4,
                                                   250/4,
                       SRCA    VPO-
                                                   Narasayyapeta Vill,
                       PP23    Chodavaram,
                                                   Chodavaram-P.O,
                         7     Chodavaram
                                                   Chodavaram-
                               Taluka, Dist-
                                                   Taluka, Dist-
                               Vishakhapatnam
                                                   Vishakhapatnam-
                               -531036, Andhra
                                                   531036, Andhra
                               Pradesh
                                                   Pradesh
                  02           Annapurna           Chaitanya Telugu      24.09.2010        29.09.2010   D.D
                               Educational         Pandit College                                       40000/-
                               Society             P.No-1A,                                             D.D No-904352
                               P.No-1A,            Chaitanya Nagar, P
                               Chaitanya           S Bonangi VPO,
                       SRCA
                               Nagar, P S          Parwada Mandal
                       PP24
                               Bonangi VPO,        Taluka,
                         1
                               Parwada Mandal      Vishakhapatnam
                               Taluka,             Dist-531021,
                               Vishakhapatnam      Andhra Pradesh
                               Dist-531021,
                               Andhra Pradesh
                  03           YSM                 Noble HPT College     24.09.2010        27.09.2010   D.D
                               Educational         P.No-13/341,                                         40000/-
                               Society             Kottapalle VPO,                                      D.D No-322100
                               P.No-13/341,        Proddatur Taluka,
                               Maduru road,        Kadapa Dist-
                       SRCA
                               Kottapalle          516361, Andhra
                       PP24
                               Village,            pradesh
                         4
                               Proddatur P.O,
                               Proddatur
                               Taluka, Kadapa
                               Dist-516361,
                               Andhra pradesh
                  04           Srinivasa           Srinivasa Hindi       29.09.2010        08.10.2010            Challan
                               Educational &       Pandit Training                                               40050/-
                               Rural               College, Ukkaypalli
                       SRCA
                               Development         VPO, Kadapa,
                       PP31
                               Society,            Taluka-Kadapa,
                         7
                               Ukkayapalli         Dist-Kadapa-
                               Village, Kadapa,    516002, Andhra
                               Andhra Pradesh      Pradesh
                  05   SRCA    All        Saints   St. Paul T P          29.09.2010        06.10.2010           Credit Card
                       PP32    Christian           College                                                 ICICI Transaction
                         9     Educational         Ziroithi,                                                No.12857805830
                               Society             Singannabanda,
                                 nd
                               2          Floor,   Tagarapuvalasa,
                               Dwarakanagar,       Visakhapatnam-
                               Visakhapatnam-      531162
                               530016,             Andhra Pradesh
                               Andhra Pradesh




                                               103

  (Gangadharaiah)                                                          (Prof. C. Thangamuthu)
Regional Director, SRC, NCTE                                               Chairman, SRC, NCTE
                                                                                             th
                                                                                     198 Meeting of SRC
                                                                                        h
                                                                                       th
                                                                                  24 -26 November 2010

                  06   SRCA    SK Faheema          Success Hindi          29.09.2010        30.09.2010   D.D
                       PP33    Educational         Pandit Training                                       40000/-
                         4     Society             College                                               D.D No-381069
                               44-19-1-1E,         36/A3, 4-218,                                         D.D
                               Nethajinagar,       Nidzuru, Kurnool-                                     1000/-
                               Sunkesula           518004,                                               D.D No-381068
                               Road, Kurnool-      AndhraPradesh
                               518004,
                               AndhraPradesh
                  07   SRCA    Rajavaram           Sri Vasavi Raja        30.09.2010        08.10.2010            Challan
                       PP37    Educational         Prathap Hindi                                                  40100/-
                         9     Society             Pandit Training                                             Dt-01.10.2010
                               1-10-85/3C,         College
                               Sheshadri           71/AA, 1-10-85/3C,
                               Nagar,              Christianpally,
                               Christianpally,     Mahbubnagar-
                               Mahbubnagar-        509001,
                               509001,             AndhraPradesh
                               AndhraPradesh
                  08   SRCA    Sri Sai Venkata     Sri Sai Venkata        30.09.2010        14.10.2010   Challan
                       PP38    Computer            Hindi Maha                                            40100/-
                         3     Educational         Vidyalayam                                            Dt-01.10.2010
                               Society             86/5, 898,
                               898, Cherkupalli,   Cherkupalli, Pundi,
                               Pundi,              Nandigam,
                               Nandigam,           Srikakulam-
                               Srikakulam-         532218,
                               532218,             AndhraPradesh
                               AndhraPradesh
                  09   SRCA    Raman               Vikas College of       30.09.2010        08.10.2010              D.D
                       PP39    Educational         Education                                                      41018/-
                       6       Society             78/4f, 78/4a, Main                                          D.D No-27558
                               1-10, Main          Road, Tatipaka
                               Road, Tatipaka      Village, Razole
                               Village, Razole     Taluka, East
                               Taluka, East        Godavari-533249,
                               Godavari-           AndhraPradesh
                               533249,
                               AndhraPradesh
                  10   SRCA    Sri                 Vamsadhara             01.10.2010        07.10.2010            000385
                       PP40    Kottammathalli      Telugu        Pandit                                          01.10.2010
                         5     Educational         Training College                                                1000/-
                               Society             5-5-225,
                               5-5-224,     Main   Kotabommali,                                                   Challan
                               Road,               Srikakulam-                                                    40100/-
                               Kotabommali,        532195,
                               Srikakulam-         Andhra Pradesh
                               532195,
                               Andhra Pradesh
                  11           Sri Balaji                                 01.10.2010        07.10.2010            Challan
                                                   Sri Balaji TPT
                               Educational
                                                   College, No.446,
                               Society, No.11-
                       SRCA                        Rajiv Road,
                               1-86/1,
                       PP40                        Duddeda,
                               Bharathnagar,
                         8                         Kondapak, Medak-
                               Siddipet, Medak-
                                                   502277, Andhra
                               502103, Andhra
                                                   Pradesh
                               Pradesh




                                               104

  (Gangadharaiah)                                                           (Prof. C. Thangamuthu)
Regional Director, SRC, NCTE                                                Chairman, SRC, NCTE
                                                                                              th
                                                                                      198 Meeting of SRC
                                                                                         h
                                                                                        th
                                                                                   24 -26 November 2010

                          12                           Vamsadhara Hindi    01.10.2010        07.10.2010    Challan-40100
                                      Sri
                                                       Pandit Training
                                      Kottammathalli
                                                       College,                                            DD. Rs.1000/-
                               SRCA   Educational
                                                       P.No.5.5.224,                                        No.000386
                               PP41   Society,
                                                       Kotabommali,
                                 0    Kotabommali,
                                                       Srikakulam-
                                      Srikakulam,
                                                       532195, Andhra
                                      Andhra Pradesh
                                                       Pradesh


                        In above cases state Govt reference letter not been sent to the concerned state
                        Govt.
                        The Committee considered the above list and approval for Language Pandit
                        Training Courses and the same matter is being referred to State Govt. in this
                        regard for norms and standards to be followed for the above courses is
                        awaited.

                        The Committee approved the above list for necessary action.

84.         ---         A letter has been received from University of Madras, Centenary Building, Chepauk,
            ---         Chennai-600005 on 15.11.2010 regarding Revival of B.Ed and M.Ed Degree Courses
       University of    through Distance Mode of Institute of Distance Education from the year 2011.
      Madras, Chennai
                        The Registrar in its letter dated 29.10.2010 stated that “the Institute of Distance
            TN          Education of University of Madras was offering the B.Ed and M.Ed Degree courses
                        from the year 1989 to 1999. They were suspended due to non-viability after this
                        period.

                        Presently many representations have been received from the practicing teachers
                        working in Elementary and Secondary schools in Tamilnadu requesting the Institute
                        of Distance Education, University of Madras to revive and to offer these courses
                        through distance mode. Hence the Syndicate of the University of Madras at its
                        meeting held on 22.10.2010 has resolved to offer these courses from the year 2011.

                        In this connection, the Government of Taminadu has issued “No Objection” for
                        Reintroduction of B.Ed and M.Ed Degree Courses from the Academic year 2010-
                        2011 through the Institute of Distance Education of this University vice its letter (1D)
                        No. 225, dated 8.10.2010.

                        Hence, the Registrar wish to bring to your kind notice that the University of Madras
                        reviving the B.Ed and M.Ed Degree courses through distance mode from the year
                        2010-2011 onwards”.

                        Note: The University of Madras, Chennai has not made application for recognition of
                        B.Ed and M.Ed Degree courses through Distance Mode so far.
                        The Committee considered the request of the Registrar, University of Madras
                        for “reviving” the B.Ed and M.Ed programmes under Distance Mode and
                        decided that the question of “revival” does not arise as these programmes
                        were never approved by NCTE in the first instance. The University is required
                        to make fresh application to NCTE after fulfilling all the norms/regulations of
                        NCTE and after the existing general ban against new B.Ed programme is lifted.
                                                    105

         (Gangadharaiah)                                                     (Prof. C. Thangamuthu)
       Regional Director, SRC, NCTE                                          Chairman, SRC, NCTE
                                                                                              th
                                                                                         198 Meeting of SRC
                                                                                         th h
                                                                                      24 -26 November 2010



85.          -----          NCTE-Hqrs vide letter dt. 18.10.2010 forwarded a complaint copy received from Shri,
             ------         Shanmugan against irregularities in admission of IGNOU courses in convergence
                            centre for B.Ed/M.Ed & Engg.programmes.
            Complaint
          forwarded by      NCTE-Hqrs asked that complaiant may please be confirmed from the complainant
      NCTE-Hqrs against     and get the evidences in the support of the complaint, if any and requsted to look into
        irregularities in   the facts of the complaint by placing it before the Regional Committee in the ensuing
          admission of      meeting and take action under the provision of the NCTE Act, 1993 and furnish the
      IGNOU courses in      action taken report to the headquarters at the earliest.
         Convergence
       centre for B.Ed &    Copy of the complaint is enclosed alongwith this note.
         M.Ed & Engg.
           Programme        The Committee considered the complaint and decided to call for Affidavit from
                            the complainant.

86.             ----        A complaint was received from Sri.Mallikarjuna Rao on 06.09.2010 in the oiffice of
                ----        SRC and SRC had written a letter to the complainant on 06.10.2010 with the request
       Complaint against    to submit affidavit on Rs. 100/- in response to this office letter dated 06.10.2010 the
        Teacher Training    complainant has submitted affidavit on 01.11.2010 and has raised the following
         Institute run by   points against Dakshin Bharatiya Hindi Sabha, Madras.
         Dakshin Bharat
      Hindi Prachar Sabha   “During the initial period of this course most of the students admitted for B.Ed class
                            were native of south Indian States. Later on, management started admitting the
              ---           students from North India. At present B.Ed College of DBHP Sabha in Karnataka has
                            100%, Kerala 90%, Tamilnadu 100% and Andhra Pradesh 75% students from Hindi
                            speaking States (North India). The city/town having B.Ed colleges in State of
                            Karnataka, Kerala and Andhra Pradesh do not have any Hindi Medium School, which
                            is highly essential for conducting teaching practive course to the students admitted to
                            B.Ed course. Further more, the admitted students from North India do not have any
                            awareness of the language of the respective south Indian State. It is highly shocking
                            to note that DBHP Sabha‟s B.Ed college do not arrange any teaching practice, which
                            is a pre-requisite for awarding B.Ed degree. These colleges are in habit of issuing
                            false teching practice certificate to the B.Ed students”.

                            The Committee considered the complaint and decided to call for remarks with
                            necessary documentary evidence from B.Ed College of DBHP sabhas of all the
                            Southern States (Tamil Nadu, Kerala, Karnataka and Andhra Pradesh) on the
                            alleged irregularities in admission of students from other Hindi speaking states
                            for courses in B.Ed colleges and details of Hindi Medium Schools, for
                            conducting teaching practice course to the students admitted to B.Ed course.

87.       APS07608          Narendar College of Education, Trichy, Tamilnadu has submitted an application for
            B.Ed            seeking grant of recognition for B.Ed course on 21.11.2006.
      Narendar College of
       Education, Trichy    The application was processed and recognition to the institution for B.Ed course was
                            granted on 31.01.2008 for annual intake of 100 students.

              TN            A complaint has been received from Shri. V.C. Ravi Chandran, No.40,
                                                        106

           (Gangadharaiah)                                                      (Prof. C. Thangamuthu)
         Regional Director, SRC, NCTE                                           Chairman, SRC, NCTE
                                                                                          th
                                                                                      198 Meeting of SRC
                                                                                     th  h
                                                                                   24 -26 November 2010

                        Kamarajarnagar, Chinnatirupathy, Salem-636008

                        , Tamilnadu regarding concealment and violation of rules and regulation by Narendar
                        College of Education.

                        SRC considered the complaint in its 195th meeting held on 17th-18th August 2010 and
                        decided to call for remarks with necessary documentary evidence on the specifics of
                        the complaint from the institution and to obtain an affidavit from the complainant.

                        Accordingly letters to complainant and institution was issued to submit the affidavit on
                        24.09.2010.

                        Reply from the complainant is received on 14.10.2010. The complainant has
                        submitted affidavit on Rs.10/- stamp paper along with encumbrance certificate.

                        Reply from the institution is not received so far.

                        The committee considered the complaint on the institution and decided to
                        cause inspection Under Section 17 of NCTE Act. The institution is directed to
                        submit the following within 30 days of the receipt of the notice. Demand Draft
                        of Rs.40,000/- towards inspection fee in favour of “The Member Secretary,
                        NCTE” payable at Bangalore should be submitted. Duly filled in Questionnaire
                        along with all the necessary documents for land, building approval and
                        building completion certificate from a competent Govt. Engineer and other
                        relevant documents should also be submitted within the stipulated notice
                        period of 30 days.

88.     APS03671        Star College of Education, Namakkal, Tamilnadu has submitted an application for
           B.Ed         seeking grant of recognition for B.Ed course on 24.12.2004.
      Star College of
        Education,      The application was processed and recognition to the institution for B.Ed course was
        Namakkal        granted on 24.10.2006 for annual intake of 100 students with the condition to shift to
                        own premises within 3 years.

           TN           An E-mail has been received from Sreenivasan against “Star College of Education,
                        Periyamanali Post, Namakkal District, Tamilnadu stating the above mentioned
                        college have no facilities regarding:

                        1.  psychology laboratory
                        2.  Eligible staff members
                        3.  Office staff
                        4.  Physical and Biological science laboratories
                        5.  Eligible principal
                        6.  Land availability
                        7.  In that campus one matric school and Teacher Training Institute are running
                            under one construction building.
                        8. Irregular students were admitted last year and this year also.
                        9. Principal in-charge Mr. R. Guruvaiah is proceed the every malpractise.
                        10. Computer facility (all are version or sleeping mode)
                                                     107

        (Gangadharaiah)                                                      (Prof. C. Thangamuthu)
      Regional Director, SRC, NCTE                                           Chairman, SRC, NCTE
                                                                                               th
                                                                                           198 Meeting of SRC
                                                                                          th  h
                                                                                        24 -26 November 2010

                            The same category is available in the following 7 colleges, attached by me,
                            previously star College of Education is under Mehendhira Group of Institutions. You
                            will visit surprisingly the 8 colleges simultaneously and you know about the demerits”.

                            Meanwhile NCTE-Hqrs vide letter dated 02.11.2010 forwarded the same E-mail copy
                            of complaint from Mr. Sreenivasan.

                            The Committee considered the complaint and decided to call for affidavit from
                            the complainant.

89.      APS07957           Jenney‟s Teacher Training Institute, Trichy, Tamilnadu was accorded recognition for
           D.T.Ed           D.T.Ed course on 26.11.2008.
      Jenny‟s Teacher
      Training Institute,   Meanwhile, a complaint was received from the Director, DTERT, and Government of
            Trichy          Tamilnadu mentioning the following deficiencies persisting in the institution: -

                             The Principal appointee Smt. J. Ruby Flora is not possessing five years
             TN               experience of teaching in an elementary teacher education institution as
                              prescribed in NCTE Regulations and Norms and Standards vide Appendix-2,
                              Para-4.1 (b) (I) (b).
                             Building License and Sanitary Certificate has not produced.

                            The SRC considered the matter in its 181st meeting held on 20th-21st August 2009
                            and decided to issue showcause notice to the institution under section 17 of NCTE
                            Act. The committee also decided to ask the institution to submit faculty list approved
                            by the affiliating body for all existing teacher education courses with details of each
                            faculty member in the prescribed format.

                            Accordingly, a notice was issued to the institution on 27.8.2009. The institution
                            submitted its reply on 1.10.2009. The written representation was considered by SRC
                            in its 185th meeting held on 26th-27th November 2009 and decided to allow the
                            institution to produce the approval of qualification from the competent authority within
                            one month‟s time.

                            Accordingly a letter was issued to the institution on 18.01.2010. The institution
                            submitted its reply on 01.03.2010 stating that “as per the letter I met the Secretary
                            Education Department Tamilnadu Government in person for getting the approval of
                            qualification of Principal. He informed that he had not received reply from Director
                            DTERT and D.O letter was written to him in this regard. So it is unable to produce the
                            approval of qualification of Principal within one-month time. Hence, request that the
                            time limit of one month may please be extended for further period and I assure that I
                            would send the approval letter as soon as I receive it from the Secretary Tamilnadu
                            Government”.

                            The reply of the institution was considered by SRC in its 190th meeting held on 29-
                            30th March 2010 and decided to issue notice for the following reason and to submit
                            the reply within 21 days:

                             Faculty list approved by the affiliating body for all existing teachers with details of
                                                        108

         (Gangadharaiah)                                                         (Prof. C. Thangamuthu)
       Regional Director, SRC, NCTE                                              Chairman, SRC, NCTE
                                                                                      th
                                                                                  198 Meeting of SRC
                                                                                 th  h
                                                                               24 -26 November 2010

                         qualifications and experience of each faculty member in the prescribed format is
                         not submitted till date.

                       The institution vide letter dated 28.05.2010 stating that “we have appealed to the
                       Government of Tamilnadu regarding the experience of the Principal appointee Smt. J.
                       Ruby Flora. We have sent reminders but we have not received proper reply till today.
                       Our appeal is that Smt. J.Ruby Flora is having five years of approved experience.

                               Though Smt. J. Ruby Flora, Principal appointee had been working as
                       Principal in that institution in the vacant post she had been continuing as science
                       teacher in the permanent science post. No science teacher was appointed in her
                       post. If her service as science teacher is taken, she is possessing more than five
                       years of approved service. This is our appeal. Since we have not received any reply
                       for our appeal, we are unable to send faculty list approved by the affiliating body.
                       Under this circumstance, we request you to kindly grant time to send faculty list.
                       Since the Government of Tamilnadu has not sent reply to our appeal.

                       SRC considered the reply in its 193rd meeting held on 21st-23rd June 2010 and
                       decided to address a letter to DTERT Chennai on the above points. Accordingly a
                       letter was issued to the DTERT on 28.7.2010.

                       Reply from DTERT is not received so far.

                       The Committee considered the Complaint from the Director, DTERT and
                       government of Tamilnadu and all the relevant documentary evidences and it
                       was decided to serve Show cause Notice Under Section 17 of NCTE Act for the
                       following :

                        The Principal appointee Smt. J. Ruby Flora is not possessing five years
                         experience of teaching in an elementary teacher education institution as
                         prescribed in NCTE Regulations, Norms and Standards Vide Appendix-2,
                         Para-4.1 (b) (1) (b).

                        Sufficient time ( now more than one year has lapsed since the first notice)
                         was given to the institution by NCTE to the institution for getting the
                         approval of qualification of Principal and also to produce the faculty list
                         approved by the affiliating body for all existing teachers with details of
                         qualifications and experience of each faculty members in the prescribed
                         format. But still the institution has not submitted till date.

                       In view of the above, the Committee decided to issue a Showcause Notice to
                       the institution as to why the recognition be not withdrawn and thereby
                       providing an opportunity to the institution to make a written representation
                       within 30 days from the date of issue of the Notice along with necessary
                       certificates/documents in order to take a final decision in the matter; failing
                       which action will be taken including the withdrawal, based on the records
                       available, with no further notice.

90.    APS03674        Auxilium College of Education, Pudukottai, Tamilnadu was granted recognition for
                                                  109

        (Gangadharaiah)                                                  (Prof. C. Thangamuthu)
      Regional Director, SRC, NCTE                                       Chairman, SRC, NCTE
                                                                                                th
                                                                                            198 Meeting of SRC
                                                                                           th  h
                                                                                         24 -26 November 2010

             B.Ed           offering B.Ed course with an intake of 100 students on 01.02.2006 with the condition
      Auxilium College of   to shift to own premises within 3 years.
          Education,
          Pudukottai        SRC in its 181st meeting held on 20-21st August 2009 where in it was decided that the
                            institution which have not shifted to the permanent premises even after the expiry of
                            three years time limit be issued notice under section 17 of NCTE Act for further
              TN            action.

                            Accordingly, notice was issued to the institution on 08.10.2009. The institution did not
                            submit its reply even after completion of stipulated period. As per the direction, the list
                            of such institution were published in the website on 20.7.2010 giving 10 days to
                            submit reply.

                            The stipulated period has been expired, the institution did not submit its reply, SRC
                            considered the matter in its 196th meeting held on 15th-16th September 2010 and
                            decided to issue show cause notice to institution as to why recognition be not
                            withdrawn.

                            Accordingly, notice was issued to the institution on 26.10.2010 to submit the following
                            documents. The institution submitted reply vide letter dated 08.11.2010.

                            The Committee considered the matter and decided to cause inspection of the
                            institution for shifting to new premises under section 17 of NCTE Act, after
                            submission of Rs. 40000/- towards inspection fee, filled in Questionnaire, Land
                            Useage Certificate from the concerned Government authorities, Building
                            Completion Certificate from Competent Government Engineer and other
                            relevant documents.

91.      APS05921           Radhaa College of Education, Dharmapuri, Tamilnadu was granted recognition for
           B.Ed             offering B.Ed course with an intake of 100 students on 13.11.2006 with the condition
      Radhaa College of     to shift to own premises within 3 years.
         Education,
        Dharmapuri          SRC in its 181st meeting held on 20-21st August 2009 where in it was decided that the
                            institution which have not shifted to the permanent premises even after the expiry of
                            three years time limit be issued notice under section 17 of NCTE Act for further
              TN            action.
                            Accordingly notice were issued to the institution on 11.09.2009. The same was
                            returned back undelivered on 18.09.2010

                            The list of institutions were notices were returned undelivered and reply not received
                            were published in the website on 16.7.2010 giving 10 days to submit reply. The
                            institution has submitted its reply on 06.08.2010. SRC considered the reply in its
                            195th meeting held on 17th-18th August 2010 and decided to serve Notice Under
                            Section 17 of NCTE Act for the following. The institution submitted its reply on
                            18.01.2010 along with Rs. 40,000/- towards shifting fee.

                            The Committee considered the written reply of the institution dt. 18.01.2010
                            and decided to cause inspection of the institution for shifting to new premises
                            under section 17 of NCTE Act.
                                                         110

          (Gangadharaiah)                                                         (Prof. C. Thangamuthu)
        Regional Director, SRC, NCTE                                              Chairman, SRC, NCTE
                                                                                            th
                                                                                        198 Meeting of SRC
                                                                                       th  h
                                                                                     24 -26 November 2010




92.      APS03614        Annai College of Education, Athanur Patti, Valapadi Taluk, Salem District-636115,
           B.Ed          Tamilnadu has submitted an application for seeking grant of recognition for B.Ed
      Annai College of   course on 19.08.2004.
      Education, Salem
                         The application was processed and the inspection of the institution was carried out on
                         21.5.2005. The visiting team report was placed before SRC in its 97th meeting held
            TN           on 27th July, 2005. The Committee considered the visiting team report and decided to
                         accord recognition to the institution from 2006-2007 with an intake of 100 with the
                         condition that the staff list duly approved by the affiliating university be submitted to
                         SRC immediately and in any case before the admissions. Accordingly, a recognition
                         order was issued to the institution on 3.9.2005.

                         In the meanwhile, some institutions who have been granted recognition for the
                         subsequent year based on belated endorsements preferred an appeal to NCTE-Hqrs.
                         and contended that a few institutions which have submitted belated endorsements
                         were granted recognition for the current academic year. SRC, in its comments to the
                         NCTE-Hqrs. explained that this has occurred due to oversight and would modify such
                         orders which have been wrongly issued. Pursuant to this, the NCTE-New Delhi vide
                         order no.F.No.89-156/2005-Appeal dated 28th September, 2005 remanded back the
                         cases to the SRC, Bangalore with a direction to reconsider the cases immediately for
                         granting recognition from 2005-2006 at par with other similar cases who have been
                         granted recognition for 2005-2006.

                         The matter was placed before SRC in its 103rd meeting held on 27th and 28th October,
                         2005 and SRC after obtaining a considered legal opinion in this regard, had taken
                         decision to review its recognition orders issued for the session 2006-2007 and to
                         grant recognition for the session 2005-06 to those institutions who have submitted
                         belated NOC‟s/Endorsements as one time exception.

                         Subsequently, SRC in its 104th meeting held on 9th November, 2005 decided to
                         extend this relaxation to the institutions which have submitted other essential
                         documents mentioned in Appendix 1B, belatedly. Accordingly, as per Public Notice of
                         SRC, a modified recognition order was issued to the institution on 22.11.2005 for
                         B.Ed course from the academic session 2005-06.

                         In the meantime, a complaint was received from the students of Annai College of
                         Education, Salem Dt. which was considered by SRC in its 190th meeting held on 29-
                         30th March 2010 and it was decided to issue Notice to the institution and accordingly,
                         Notice was issued to the institution on 06.05.2010. The institution submitted its reply
                         on 08.06.2010.

                         The SRC in its 193rd meeting held on 21st-22nd June 2010 decided to cause
                         inspection of the institution and accordingly inspection of Annai College of Education,
                         Athanur patti, Valapadi Taluk, Salem-636115, Tamilnadu was conducted on
                         09.07.2010.

                         The SRC in its 195th meeting held on 17th-18th August 2010 considered the report of
                                                     111

         (Gangadharaiah)                                                      (Prof. C. Thangamuthu)
       Regional Director, SRC, NCTE                                           Chairman, SRC, NCTE
                                                                                                th
                                                                                         198 Meeting of SRC
                                                                                            h
                                                                                           th
                                                                                      24 -26 November 2010

                           the institution and decided to serve Showcause Notice.

                           As per the decision of SRC, Notice was issued to the institution on 24.09.2010. The
                           institution submitted its reply on 18.10.2010.

                           The Committee considered the reply of the institution and decided to serve
                           Showcause Notice for the following as the replies were not specific, highly
                           misleading and evasive.

                            Annai Matriculation School running LKG to VII Standard is functioning in the
                             First and Second Floor of the above, partly constructed building, in front of
                             which, only the name board of the College of Education is placed. As per the
                             norms, the B.Ed College should have an exclusive campus and building and
                             not sharing with any other institution.

                            The new building is under construction at Umaiyalpuram which is about 10
                             kms from Athanurpatti.

                            Records were not available & were                      said        to   be   with   the
                             management/Correspondent of the College.


                            There are no basic amenities like drinking water, toilet etc.”

                           In view of the above, the Committee decided to issue a Showcause Notice to
                           the institution as to why the recognition be not withdrawn and thereby
                           providing an opportunity to the institution to make a written representation
                           within 30 days from the date of issue of the Notice along with necessary
                           certificates/documents in order to take a final decision in the matter; failing
                           which action will be taken including the withdrawal, based on the records
                           available, with no further notice.

93.        APS03254        Annai Fathima Teacher Training College for women, Erode, Tamilnadu has submitted
             B.Ed          an application for seeking grant of recognition for B.Ed course on 03.02.2004.
        Annai Fathima
       Teacher Training    The application was processed and recognition to the institution for B.Ed course was
      College for Women,   granted on 09.05.2005 for annual intake of 100 students from the academic session
             Erode         2005-2006.

             TN            A letter from the Registrar, Tamilnadu Teachers Education University was received
                           on 27.08.2010 informing disaffiliation of Annai Fathima Teacher Training College,
                           Dharapuram from the year 2010-2011.

                           SRC considered the matter in its 196th meeting held on 15th-16th September 2010 and
                           decided to serve notice on the following points. Accordingly notice was issued to the
                           institution on 26.10.2010. The institution submitted its reply on 08.11.2010.

                           The committee considered the matter and decided to await for decision of the
                           Court .
94.       APS04386         Jai Sai B.Ed College, Trichy, Tamilnadu was granted recognition for offering B.Ed
                                                      112

          (Gangadharaiah)                                                     (Prof. C. Thangamuthu)
        Regional Director, SRC, NCTE                                          Chairman, SRC, NCTE
                                                                                                 th
                                                                                             198 Meeting of SRC
                                                                                            th  h
                                                                                          24 -26 November 2010

             B.Ed           course with an intake of 100 students on 26.12.2005 with the condition to shift to own
         Jai Sai B.Ed       premises within 3 years.
        College, Trichy
                            SRC in its 181st meeting held on 20-21st August 2009 where in it was decided that the
                            institution which have not shifted to the permanent premises even after the expiry of
              TN            three years time limit be issued notice under section 17 of NCTE Act for further
                            action.

                            Accordingly, notice was issued to the institution on 16.09.2009. The institution did not
                            submit its reply even after completion of stipulated period. As per the direction, the list
                            of such institution were published in the website on 20.7.2010 giving 10 days to
                            submit reply.

                            The stipulated period has been expired, the institution did not submit its reply, SRC
                            considered the matter in its 196th meeting held on 15th-16th September 2010 and
                            decided to issue show cause notice to institution as to why recognition be not
                            withdrawn.

                            Accordingly, notice was issued to the institution on 26.10.2010 to submit the following
                            documents. The institution has however only submitted a letter dated 08.11.2010
                            stating as follows:

                            “Jai Sai Teacher Training Institute, Sri Sai Nagar, Airport (P.O), Trichy-620007 was
                            granted recognition by NCTE (SRC) in its Order F.SRO/NCTE/D.Ed/2006-2007/7218
                            dated 11.08.2006 Code : APS04388, since the institution has completed 3 years. As
                            per norms, our recognition has to be renewed. Hence we are humbly submitting our
                            application for renewal of recognition. We request you to kindly grant us renewal of
                            recognition and oblige”
                            .
                            The committee decided to cause inspection Under Section 17 of NCTE Act. The
                            institution is directed to submit the following within 30 days of the receipt of
                            the notice. Demand Draft of Rs.40,000/- towards inspection fee in favour of
                            “The Member Secretary, NCTE” payable at Bangalore should be submitted,
                            along with filled in Questionnaire, Land Useage Certificate from the concerned
                            Government authorities, Building Completion Certificate from Competent
                            Government Engineer, approved building plan and other relevant documents.

95.        APS03533         Padmavani College of Education, Salem, Tamilnadu was granted recognition for
             B.Ed           offering B.Ed course with an intake of 100 students on 28.09.2006 with the condition
      Padmavani College     to shift to own premises within 3 years.
      of Education, Salem
                            A letter was issued to the institution for submitting necessary documents for shifting.
                            Meanwhile SRC in its 181st meeting held on 20-21st August 2009 where in it was
              TN            decided that the institution which have not shifted to the permanent premises even
                            after the expiry of three years time limit be issued notice under section 17 of NCTE
                            Act for further action.

                            As letter was issued to the institution to the submitted the documents notice was not
                            issued to the institution. The institution did not submit its reply to the letter even after
                                                         113

           (Gangadharaiah)                                                         (Prof. C. Thangamuthu)
         Regional Director, SRC, NCTE                                              Chairman, SRC, NCTE
                                                                                            th
                                                                                        198 Meeting of SRC
                                                                                       th  h
                                                                                     24 -26 November 2010

                          completion of stipulated period. As per the direction, the list of such institution were
                          published in the website on 20.7.2010 giving 10 days to submit reply.

                          The stipulated period has been expired, the institution did not submit its reply, SRC
                          considered the matter in its 196th meeting held on 15th-16th September 2010 and
                          decided to issue show cause notice to institution as to why recognition be not
                          withdrawn.

                          Accordingly, notice was issued to the institution on 26.10.2010 to submit the following
                          documents. The institution submitted reply vide letter dated 10.11.2010.

                          The Committee considered written reply of the institution and all the relevant
                          documentary evidences and it was decided to serve Show cause Notice Under
                          Section 17 of NCTE Act for the following :

                           The institute has not submitted the approved Building plan from a competent
                            Govt. authority.

                           The Affidavit on Rs.100/- stamp paper in the prescribed format with notary
                            attestation to be submitted.

                           The institute has not submitted the Land useage certificate                  from a
                            competent Govt. authority


                          In view of the above The committee decided to cause inspection Under Section
                          17 of NCTE Act. The institution is directed to submit the following within 30
                          days of the receipt of the notice. Demand Draft of Rs.40,000/- towards
                          inspection fee in favour of “The Member Secretary, NCTE” payable at
                          Bangalore should be submitted, along with filled in Questionnaire, Land
                          Useage Certificate from the concerned Government authorities, Building
                          Completion Certificate from Competent Government Engineer, approved
                          building plan and other relevant documents including the affidavit on Rs. 100
                          stamp paper.

96.     APS04518          Kathir College of Education, Coimbatore, Tamilnadu has submitted an application for
            B.Ed          seeking grant of recognition for B.Ed course on 12.12.2005.
      Kathir College of
        Education,        The application was processed and recognition to the institution for B.Ed course was
        Coimbatore        granted on 24.10.2006 for annual intake of 100 students.

                          The institution has submitted letter dated 06.09.2010 requesting for change of
            TN            address from No.8, Balan Nagar, South Street, Peelamedu, Coimbatore to
                          S.F.No.806, Neelambur, Avinashi Road, Coimbatore, Tamilnadu. No documents are
                          submitted in support of the change of address.
                          The inspection was actually conducted in their existing building at No.8, Balan Nagar,
                          South Street, Peelamedu, Coimbatore. As per the VT report, VT members observed
                          that the construction work of new building is about to be completed. The recognition
                          order was issued to the above address.
                                                      114

         (Gangadharaiah)                                                       (Prof. C. Thangamuthu)
       Regional Director, SRC, NCTE                                            Chairman, SRC, NCTE
                                                                                             th
                                                                                        198 Meeting of SRC
                                                                                        th h
                                                                                     24 -26 November 2010


                         The matter was considered by SRC in its 196th meeting held on 15th-16th September
                         2010 and decided to issue notice to the institution. Accordingly notice was issued to
                         the institution on 26.10.2010 on the following. The institution submitted its reply on
                         15.11.2010.

                         The institution has not obtained permission for shifting from one Address i.e., No.8
                         Balan Nagar South Street, Peelamedu, Coimbatore – 04 to S.F. No. 806, Neelambur,
                         Avinashi Road, Coimbatore – 62.

                         The institution is required to obtain permission for shifting alongwith requisite shifting
                         fee & documents in support of proposal.

                         The committee decided to cause inspection Under Section 17 of NCTE Act. The
                         institution is directed to submit the following within 30 days of the receipt of
                         the notice. Demand Draft of Rs.40,000/- towards inspection fee in favour of
                         “The Member Secretary, NCTE” payable at Bangalore should be submitted,
                         Duly filled in Questionnaire along with all the necessary relevant documents for
                         Building completion certificate from a competent Govt. Engineer, the Land
                         useage certificate from a competent Govt. authority, Non-Encumbrance
                         Certificate from the competent Government Authorised person / Authorities is
                         to be submitted.

97.       APS07829       Sir Issac Newton Teacher Training Institute, Nagapattinam Disrict, Tamilnadu
          D.T.Ed-AI
                         submitted an application for grant of recognition to D.T.Ed-AI on 21.12.2006.
      Sri Issac Newton
      Teacher Training   Recognition to the institution was granted on 27.2.2008.
           Institute,
                         NCTE, Hqrs in its letter dated 27.04.2009 has forwarded the complaint against the
       Nagapattinam
                         above mentioned institution by the villagers of Papakovil and other aggrieved
            TN
                         persons/students of the institution.
                         The complainant has alleged that the institution has five courses of teacher education
                         and also running Polytechnic and Hotel Management courses. The overall building
                         available is 20,000 sq.ft. It has been stated that the infrastructural and instructional
                         facilities are not maintained as per norms.

                         SRC considered the matter in its 174th Meeting held on 1st May 2009 and SRC
                         decided to call the information through Questionnaire for all the recognized teacher
                         education courses and cause inspection under section 17 for all the courses.

                         Accordingly, a letter was issued to the institution on 22.10.2009. The institution has
                         submitted its reply on 20.11.2009 along with the filled questionnaire.

                         Meanwhile, SRC in its 185th meeting held on 26-27th November 2009 has decided
                         that Visiting Teams constituted for visiting all the Section 17 cases before
                         31.12.2009. A letter dated 18.02.2010 was issued to the institution informing to be
                         ready for inspection to be held shortly.
                                                      115

         (Gangadharaiah)                                                       (Prof. C. Thangamuthu)
       Regional Director, SRC, NCTE                                            Chairman, SRC, NCTE
                                                                                             th
                                                                                         198 Meeting of SRC
                                                                                        th  h
                                                                                      24 -26 November 2010



                          Accordingly inspection of the institution was conducted on 08.07.2010. The VT report
                          was considered by SRC in its 194th meeting held on 21st-22nd July 2010 and it has
                          decided to issue notice.

                          Accordingly, a notice was issued to the institution on 20.08.2010 to submit the reply
                          within 21 days. The reply from the institution has not been received. The notice
                          period of 21 days has expired. SRC considered the matter in its 196th meeting held
                          on 15th-16th September 2010 and decided to issue notice. Accordingly notice was
                          issued to the institution on 20.08.2010. The institution did not submit its reply within
                          stipulated period.

                          The matter was considered by SRC in its 196th meeting held on 15th-16th September
                          2010 and has decided to issue notice. Meanwhile the institution submitted its reply on
                          12.10.2010. Notice was also issued to the institution on 26.10.2010.

                          The institution submitted its reply on 15.11.2010 stating “submission of clarification to
                          all the points raised in the same letter dated 20.8.2010 has already sent on
                          12.10.2010”.

                          The committee decided to cause composite inspection for all the courses
                          Under Section 17 of NCTE Act. The institution is directed to submit the
                          following within 30 days of the receipt of the notice. Demand Draft of
                          Rs.40,000/- inspection fee towards each of the courses being run, in favour of
                          “The Member Secretary, NCTE” payable at Bangalore. Further committee
                          decided to submit earmarked built up area for each of P.E.P and filled in
                          questionnaire and other relevant documents to be submitted. Committee also
                          decided incase of no response, show cause notice of 30 days be issued.

98.      APS07266         A.R.R College of Education, No.156, ARR Road, Kumbakonam-612001, Thanjavur,
           M.Ed           Kumbakonam, Tamilnadu was accorded recognition for M.Ed course with an intake of
      A.R.R. College of   25 on 01.08.2006.
         Education,
       Kumbakonam         A.R.R TTI, Kumbakonam, Tamilnadu was accorded recognition for D.T.Ed course
                          with an intake of 50 on 2.9.2006. Based on the directions of MHRD, inspection under
                          section 17 of the above institution for D.T.Ed course was carried out on 17.12.2008.
             TN           The VT report, VCD, original application file along with other documents were placed
                          before SRC in its 169th meeting held on 12-13 January 2009. SRC decided to issue
                          notice under section 17 of NCTE Act for D.T.Ed course.

                          As per the decision of SRC, a notice under Section 17 notice was issued on
                          31.07.2009 for D.T.Ed course. In reply to the Notice, the institution has submitted
                          written representation on 26.08.2009. The Committee considered the matter in its
                          182nd meeting held on 31st August 2009 and decided to conduct inspection under
                          Section 17 of NCTE Act for shifting of premises to permanent building, after
                          submission of Encumbrance Certificate from the Competent Government authority
                          and other relevant documents.

                          A letter was issued to the institution on 07.10.2009 to submit the reply. The institution
                                                      116

         (Gangadharaiah)                                                       (Prof. C. Thangamuthu)
       Regional Director, SRC, NCTE                                            Chairman, SRC, NCTE
                                                                                    th
                                                                                198 Meeting of SRC
                                                                               th  h
                                                                             24 -26 November 2010

                 did not submit written representation even after the stipulated period. The Committee
                 in its 189th meeting of SRC considered the matter and decided to cause inspection to
                 the institution. Accordingly, a letter was issued to the institution on 2.3.2010.


                 Inspection under section 17 for D.T.Ed course was conducted on 29.05.2010 and the
                 report of the institution was considered by the Committee in its 193rd meeting held on
                 21st-22nd June 2010. The Committee decided to issue Notice to the institution for
                 D.T.Ed course. Further, the Committee has decided to withdraw M.Ed. course
                 (APS07266) due to shortage of space/ built-up area with immediate effect.

                 Accordingly, withdrawal order to M.Ed course was issued to the institution on
                 27.7.2010.

                 Meantime, the institution has approached to the Hon‟ble High Court of Madras in
                 W.P. No. 17330 of 2010 and the Hon‟ble Court has granted an interim stay order of
                 SRC-NCTE.

                 The court has ordered as follows: “According to the learned counsel for the petitioner,
                 the recognition granted by the National council for Teachers Education(NCTE) for an
                 institution to conduct is permanent and the same cannot be withdrawn without
                 following the procedure laid down under section 17 of the NCTE Act. The said
                 procedure contemplated in the Act has not been followed and the respondent has
                 conducted inspection only in respect of D.T.Ed courses and not for M.Ed courses and
                 no opportunity was given to the petitioner before passing the impugned order.

                 Therefore, the impugned order is in violation of the principals of natural justice and it
                 cannot be put against the petitioner, Hence, the impugned proceeding is vitiated.

                 2. Considering the submission and circumstances, there will be order of interim stay.
                 Issue notice to the respondent returnable in four weeks”.

                 The Committee considered the matter in its 195th meeting held on 15th-16th August
                 2010 and it was decided to serve Showcause Notice Under Section 17 of NCTE Act.
                 In the light of Court judgement to initiate separate fresh action for the ongoing M.Ed.
                 programme because of the following deficiencies.

                 Accordingly notice was issued to the institution on 22.9.2010 to submit the reply
                 within 21 days. But the institution submitted its reply only on 19.11.2010.

                 The committee decided to cause composite inspection of all the teacher
                 education programme under Section 17 of NCTE Act. The institution is directed
                 to submit the following within 30 days of the receipt of the notice. Demand
                 Draft of Rs.40,000/- inspection fee towards each of the courses being run, in
                 favour of “The Member Secretary, NCTE” payable at Bangalore, other relevant
                 documents to be submitted and to ascertain offering of other programmes in
                 the same building/premises along with the existing courses.


                                             117

  (Gangadharaiah)                                                     (Prof. C. Thangamuthu)
Regional Director, SRC, NCTE                                          Chairman, SRC, NCTE
                                                                                               th
                                                                                           198 Meeting of SRC
                                                                                          th  h
                                                                                        24 -26 November 2010

99.       APS01724          Goutham College of Education, No.258, 5th Main, 2nd Cross, Manjunatha Nagar,
          APS05385          Bangalore-560010, Karnataka has submitted application for D.Ed-AI course on
            D.Ed            30.12.2005 The institution has granted recognition with an annual intake of 100
           D.Ed-AI          students vide order dated 24.12.2005 which includes existing intake of 50 students
      Goutham College of    and additional intake of 50 students.
          Education,        NCTE, Hqrs vide its letter dated 22.06.2010 has forwarded a copy of the inspection
          Bangalore         report dated 22.04.2010 conducted under section 13 of NCTE Act for B.Ed and M.Ed
                            course. As there are deficiencies pointed out in the inspection report, NCTE, Hqrs
             KA             has requested SRC to initiate action against the institution under section 17 of the
                            NCTE Act immediately.

                            SRC in its 194th meeting held on 21-22 July 2010 considered the letter from NCTE,
                            Hqrs, VT report and original file of the institution and has decided to serve Notice for
                            both D.Ed., B.Ed. and M.Ed. courses. under Section 17 of NCTE Act for the following
                            deficiencies:-
                            As per the VT report, the built up area available for all the three courses is only 6000
                            sq.ft. and land area earmarked for all the three courses is 7200 sq.ft. only. The built-
                            up area and land area are far is inadequate as per NCTE norms.
                            The number of books available in the Library is only 1962. Endowment fund and
                            Reserve fund are not being maintained in joint account with NCTE.
                            A School is also being run in the same building and no sports facilities are available.

                            Accordingly, notice was issued to the institution on 31.08.2010. The institution has
                            submitted a letter on 19.11.2010 stating that the institution has being served a notice
                            by the inspecting committee citing inadequate infrastructure and now the trust has
                            discussed in length and came to a conculsion to discontinue the D.Ed course from
                            the present academic year.

                            The matter is placed before SRC for consideration and further directions.
                             APS01724-D.Ed
                                                                                              APS05385-D.Ed-AI
                            Goutham College of Education, No.258, 5th Main, 2nd Cross, Manjunatha Nagar,
                            Bangalore-560010, Karnataka has submitted application for D.Ed-AI course on
                            30.12.2005 The institution has granted recognition with an annual intake of 100
                            students vide order dated 24.12.2005 which includes existing intake of 50 students
                            and additional intake of 50 students.

                            NCTE, Hqrs vide its letter dated 22.06.2010 has forwarded a copy of the inspection
                            report dated 22.04.2010 conducted under section 13 of NCTE Act for B.Ed and M.Ed
                            course. As there are deficiencies pointed out in the inspection report, NCTE, Hqrs
                            has requested SRC to initiate action against the institution under section 17 of the
                            NCTE Act immediately.

                            SRC in its 194th meeting held on 21-22 July 2010 considered the letter from NCTE,
                            Hqrs, VT report and original file of the institution and has decided to serve Notice for
                            both D.Ed., B.Ed. and M.Ed. courses. under Section 17 of NCTE Act for the following
                            deficiencies:-
                            As per the VT report, the built up area available for all the three courses is only 6000
                            sq.ft. and land area earmarked for all the three courses is 7200 sq.ft. only. The built-
                                                         118

          (Gangadharaiah)                                                        (Prof. C. Thangamuthu)
        Regional Director, SRC, NCTE                                             Chairman, SRC, NCTE
                                                                                               th
                                                                                           198 Meeting of SRC
                                                                                          th  h
                                                                                        24 -26 November 2010

                             up area and land area are far is inadequate as per NCTE norms.
                            The number of books available in the Library is only 1962. Endowment fund and
                            Reserve fund are not being maintained in joint account with NCTE.
                             A School is also being run in the same building and no sports facilities are available.

                             Accordingly, notice was issued to the institution on 31.08.2010. The institution has
                             submitted a letter on 19.11.2010 staring that the institution has served a notice by the
                             inspecting committee citing inadequate infrastructure and now the trust has
                             discussed in length and came to a conculsion to discontinue the D.Ed course from
                             the present academic year. Further requested to cancel the recognition
                             accorded to the institution.

                             The Committee considered the Institutions request for closure of D.Ed & D.Ed-
                             Al course and decided to permit the closure by withdrawing the recognition for
                             (APS01724) D.Ed & (APS05385 D.Ed-Al) course with effect from 2012-2013, in
                             order to enable the ongoing batch of students in D.Ed course, if any, to
                             complete their final year course.

                             But it is made clear that the institution is debarred from making any further
                             admission subsequent to the date of issue of this order.

                             The Affiliating body / Examining board / body be informed accordingly.

                             Further decided to return Endowment funds and Reserve fund if deposited with
                             SRC NCTE, Bangalore.

100.       APS01725          Goutham M.Ed College, Goutham Institute of Medical Sciences, No.258, 5th Main, 2nd
           APS07399          Cross, West of Chord Road, Rajajinagar, Bangalore-560010, Karnataka has
              B.Ed           submitted application for
             M.Ed
        Goutham M.Ed         D.Ed course on 30.12.2003. The institution was granted recognition with an intake of
       College, Banaglore    50 students vide order dated 24.12.2005.

              KA
                             NCTE, Hqrs vide its letter dated 22.06.2010 has forwarded a copy of the inspection
                             report dated 22.04.2010 conducted under section 13 of NCTE Act for B.Ed and M.Ed
                             course. As there are deficiencies pointed out in the inspection report, NCTE, Hqrs
                             has requested SRC to initiate action against the institution under section 17 of the
                             NCTE Act immediately.
                             SRC in its 194th meeting held on 21-22 July 2010 considered the letter from NCTE,
                             Hqrs, VT report and original file of the institution and has decided to serve Notice for
                             both D.Ed., B.Ed. and M.Ed. courses.

                             Accordingly, notice was issued to the institution on 25.08.2010. The institution has
                             requested to close the file pertaining to D.Ed course and a separate agenda is
                             prepared in this regard. The institution has submitted its representation on
                             19.11.2010. The details of written representation is given below:



                                                         119

           (Gangadharaiah)                                                        (Prof. C. Thangamuthu)
         Regional Director, SRC, NCTE                                             Chairman, SRC, NCTE
                                                                                           th
                                                                                       198 Meeting of SRC
                                                                                      th  h
                                                                                    24 -26 November 2010

                           The Committee considered written reply of the institution and all the relevant
                           documentary evidences and it was decided to serve Show cause Notice Under
                           Section 17 of NCTE Act for the following :

                            The institution is functioning in an eight storyed residential building offering
                             B.Ed and M.Ed programmes. Running of Teacher Education Programmes in
                             a residential building is against the NCTE norms and the residential building
                             is not designed to conduct for any academic programme.

                            The building is not provided with lift facility for the students.

                            It is dangerous for the student community to go up and down in the eight
                             storyed building to attend to classes.

                            The   Building completion certificate            is   not     from   Government
                             approved/authorized Engineer.

                           In view of the above, the Committee decided to issue a Showcause Notice to
                           the institution as to why the recognition be not withdrawn and thereby
                           providing an opportunity to the institution to make a written representation
                           within 30 days from the date of issue of the Notice along with necessary
                           certificates/documents in order to take a final decision in the matter; failing
                           which action will be taken including the withdrawal, based on the records
                           available, with no further notice.

101.       APS00495        Sri.Bhavani D.Ed College, Bethamangala – 563116, Bangarpet Taluk, Kolar District,
           APS01647
                           Karnataka was granted recognition for offering D.Ed-AI course on 27.12.2004 with an
              D.Ed
             D.Ed-AI       intake of 200 students which includes existing intake of 120 students and additional
       Sri. Bhavani D.Ed
                           intake of 80 students.
        College, Kolar

              KA           NCTE, Hqrs vide its letter dated 10.08.2010 has forwarded a copy of the inspection
                           report dated 15.06.2010 conducted under section 13 of NCTE Act. As there are
                           deficiencies pointed out in the inspection report, NCTE, Hqrs has requested SRC to
                           initiate action against the institution under section 17 of the NCTE Act immediately.
                           The SRC in its 195th meeting held on 17-18 August 2010 considered the report and
                           decided to issue showcause Notice. Accordingly, Notice was issued to the institution
                           on 22.09.2010. The institution has submitted written representation on 18.10.2010.
                           The details are given below:-
                           The committee decided to cause inspection Under Section 17 of NCTE Act. The
                           institution is directed to submit the following within 30 days of the receipt of
                           the notice. Demand Draft of Rs.40,000/- inspection fee towards the course
                           being run, in favour of “The Member Secretary, NCTE” payable at Bangalore,
                           other relevant documents to be submitted and to ascertain infrastructural and
                           instructional facilities



                                                      120

          (Gangadharaiah)                                                     (Prof. C. Thangamuthu)
        Regional Director, SRC, NCTE                                          Chairman, SRC, NCTE
                                                                                              th
                                                                                          198 Meeting of SRC
                                                                                         th  h
                                                                                       24 -26 November 2010

102.       AOS00032           Al-Ameen Urdu Training Institute, 1st Cross, Azad Nagar, Belgaum District-590016,
           APS03122           Karnataka was granted recognition for offering D.Ed-AI course on 27.12.2004 with an
              D.Ed            intake of 200 students which includes existing intake of 120 students and additional
             D.Ed-AI          intake of 80 students.
         Al-Ameen Urdu
        Training Institute,   NCTE, Hqrs vide its letter dated 10.08.2010 has forwarded a copy of the inspection
            Belgaum           report dated 15.06.2010 conducted under section 13 of NCTE Act. As there are
                              deficiencies pointed out in the inspection report, NCTE, Hqrs has requested SRC to
                              initiate action against the institution under section 17 of the NCTE Act immediately.
               KA
                              The SRC in its 195rd meeting held on 17-18 August 2010 considered the report and
                              decided to issue showcause Notice. Accordingly, Notice was issued to the institution
                              on 22.09.2010. The institution has submitted written representation on 18.10.2010.

                              The Committee considered the VT Report and all the relevant documentary
                              evidences and it was decided to serve Show cause Notice Under Section 17 of
                              NCTE Act for the following :

                               The Institution was granted conditional recognition in temporary premises to
                                run D.Ed-Al course on 27.12.2004 with a condition that it should shift to its
                                own permanent premises in 3 years. i.e., on or before 26.12.2007. The
                                Institution is still running in temporary premises and not shifted to new
                                premises even after a lapse of stipulated 3 years i.e.,after lapse of time
                                period of more than six long years.

                               The institution was granted conditional permission on 27.12.2001 in a
                                temporary premises with condition for the basic unit of D.Ed and hence the
                                lapse of nine years now.

                               The above temporary premises where the management is running D.Ed
                                (AOS00032) and D.Ed-Al (APS03122) courses has a total built up area of
                                3000sq.ft, which is grossly inadequate as sper NCTE norms.

                               The same building is shared for PUC and High School, which is not as per
                                NCTE norms.

                               The institution has stated that the building is still under construction.

                              In view of the above, the Committee decided to issue a Showcause Notice to
                              the institution as to why the recognition be not withdrawn and thereby
                              providing an opportunity to the institution to make a written representation
                              within 30 days from the date of issue of the Notice along with necessary
                              certificates/documents in order to take a final decision in the matter; failing
                              which action will be taken including the withdrawal, based on the records
                              available, with no further notice.

103.       APS02046           Impact College of Education & Applied Sicence, Kodigehalli, Sahakarnagar South,
              B.Ed
                              Bangalore-560092, Karnataka has submitted application for B.Ed course on
        Impact College of
       Education & Applied
                                                         121

            (Gangadharaiah)                                                      (Prof. C. Thangamuthu)
          Regional Director, SRC, NCTE                                           Chairman, SRC, NCTE
                                                                                                  th
                                                                                              198 Meeting of SRC
                                                                                             th  h
                                                                                           24 -26 November 2010

       Science, Bangalore   31.12.2003. The institution has been granted recognition for B.Ed course with an
                            intake of 100 students on 03.02.2006.
              KA
                            As per the directions given in SRC in its 175th meeting held on 13-14 May 2009, the
                            office of SRC has reviewed the files of the institution who have been granted
                            recognition either in a rented premises pending construction of own building or in
                            lease premises pertaining to the B.Ed., course in the State of Karnataka.
                            A list of such institution has been prepared and placed before SRC in its 176th
                            meeting held on 27-28 May, 2009 wherein, it was decided that the institution which
                            have not shifted to the permanent premises even after the expiry of three years time
                            limit be issued notice under Section 17 of NCTE Act for further action. Accordingly,
                            notice was issued to the institution on dated 08.09.2009.

                            The SRC in its 196th meeting held on 15-16 september 2010 observed that the
                            institution did not care to respond to the Notice served on the institution, for their
                            failure to shift to permanent premises, even after the lapse of three years stipulated
                            period permitted in their conditional orders of recognition. Hence SRC decided to
                            issue Showcause Notice to the institution. Accordingly, notice was issued to the
                            institution on 27.10.2010. The institution submitted its written representation on
                            12.11.2010.

                            The Committee considered the written reply of the institution dt. 12.11.2010
                            which is not relevant and specific to deficiencies pointed and and decided to
                            cause inspection of the institution for shifting to new premises under section
                            17 of NCTE Act, in anticipation of Rs. 40000/- towards inspection fee and filled
                            in Questionnaire, Building Completion Certification, Building plan, Land
                            Useage Certificate, Non-encumbrance certificate, affidavits and all other
                            relevant documents.
104.      APS01998          Udupi College of Education, Karavali Hotel Complex, Adi Udupi, Udupi-576103 Karnataka has
             B.Ed           submitted application for B.Ed course on 31.12.2003.      The institution has been granted
        Udupi College of
        Education, Udupi    recognition for B.Ed course with an intake of 100 students on 01.12.2004.

                            As per the directions given in SRC in its 175th meeting held on 13-14 May 2009, the
              KA            office of SRC has reviewed the files of the institution who have been granted
                            recognition either in a rented premises pending construction of own building or in
                            lease premises pertaining to the B.Ed., course in the State of Karnataka.
                            A list of such institution has been prepared and placed before SRC in its 176th
                            meeting held on 27-28 May, 2009 wherein, it was decided that the institution which
                            have not shifted to the permanent premises even after the expiry of three years time
                            limit be issued notice under Section 17 of NCTE Act for further action. Accordingly,
                                                          122

           (Gangadharaiah)                                                          (Prof. C. Thangamuthu)
         Regional Director, SRC, NCTE                                               Chairman, SRC, NCTE
                                                                                       th
                                                                                   198 Meeting of SRC
                                                                                  th  h
                                                                                24 -26 November 2010

                 notice was issued to the institution on dated 08.09.2009.


                 The institution did not care to respond to the Notice served on the institution, for their
                 failure to shift to permanent premises, even after the lapse of three years stipulated
                 period permitted in their conditional orders of recognition.
                 The SRC in its 196th meeting held on 15-16 september 2010 considered the matter
                 and decided to issue Showcause Notice to the institution. Accordingly, notice was
                 issued to the institution on 27.10.2010. The institution submitted its written
                 representation on 12.11.2010

                 The Committee considered the written reply of the institution dt.12.11.2010 and
                 noted not replying to specific deficiencies pointed and decided to serve Show
                 cause Notice Under Section 17 of NCTE Act for the following :

                  The Institution was granted recognition in temporary premises to run B.Ed
                   course on 01.12.2004 with a condition that it should shift to its own
                   permanent premises in 3 years. i.e., on or before 30.11.2007. The Institution is
                   still running in temporary premises and not shifted to new premises even
                   after a lapse of stipulated 3 years i.e., after lapse of time period of more than
                   6 years.

                  Demand draft of Rs. 40000/- towards inspection fee not submitted.

                  Building completion certificate from the Competent Government authorities
                   in the prescribed format not submitted.

                  Land useage certificate from the concerned Government authorities not
                   submitted.

                  Non-Encumbrance certificate from the competent Government authority not
                   submitted.

                  Fixed Deposit Receipt of Rs. 5 lakhs and 3 lakhs in joint account with SRC in
                   a Nationalised Bank for a period of 5 years towards endowment fund in
                   original not submitted.

                  The Affidavit in Rs. 100/- stamp paper in the prescribed format with Notary
                   attestation should be submitted.


                 In view of the above, the Committee decided to issue a Showcause Notice to
                 the institution as to why the recognition be not withdrawn and thereby
                 providing an opportunity to the institution to make a written representation
                 within 30 days from the date of issue of the Notice along with necessary
                 certificates/documents in order to take a final decision in the matter; failing
                 which action will be taken including the withdrawal, based on the records
                 available, with no further notice.
                                              123

  (Gangadharaiah)                                                      (Prof. C. Thangamuthu)
Regional Director, SRC, NCTE                                           Chairman, SRC, NCTE
                                                                                            th
                                                                                        198 Meeting of SRC
                                                                                       th  h
                                                                                     24 -26 November 2010




105.      APS01881          Ravi D.Ed College, 2nd Cross, Gowripet, Kolar District, Pin – 563101, Karnataka was
          APS05544          granted recognition for offering D.Ed course on 12.04.2007 with an intake of 100
             D.Ed           students which includes existing intake of 50 students and additional intake of 50
            D.Ed-AI         students.
       Ravi D.Ed College,
             Kolar          NCTE, Hqrs vide its letter dated 19.07.2010 has forwarded a copy of the inspection
                            report dated 14.06.2010 conducted under section 13 of NCTE Act. As there are
                            deficiencies pointed out in the inspection report, NCTE, Hqrs has requested SRC to
              KA            initiate action against the institution under section 17 of the NCTE Act immediately

                            The SRC in its 195th meeting held on 17-18 August 2010 considered the report and
                            decided to issue showcause Notice. Accordingly, Notice was issued to the institution
                             on 28.09.2010. The institution has submitted written representation on 18.10.2010.

                            The Committee considered the written reply of the institution dt.18.10.2010 and
                            all the relevant documentary evidences and it was decided to serve Show
                            cause Notice Under Section 17 of NCTE Act for the following :

                             The institution was given recognition for D.Ed., D.Ed. - additional intake on
                              12.4.2007 in temporary/rented premises with a specific condition that the
                              institution should move to a permanent premise within a period of three
                              years i.e., on or before 11.4.2010. The Institution is still running in temporary
                              premises and not shifted to new premises even after a lapse of stipulated 3
                              years and after lapse of time period of more than 6 months.

                             It is also stated in the VTR that the College is working in a registered lease
                              building on 1.27 acres of land which is registered in the name of the Trust.
                              As per the VT report, the College is still functioning in a rented building for
                              which approval was granted.

                             Construction of the new building is yet to be completed.

                             The premises of the institution is having 9000 sq.ft. land area and a built-up
                              area of 8000 sq.ft. It is inadequate as per the norms of NCTE for offering
                              D.Ed. and D.Ed.-Addl. intake courses; 16,000 sq.ft. built up area is required
                              as per the norms.

                             The building plan submitted does not mention Survey Nos, total area and
                              built up area not mentioned and the figures given are on Sq.mts/Sq.fts is not
                              clear.


                             Staff salaries are being paid by cash instead of through Bank and Provident
                              fund contributions are not made or paid to the respective agency.”

                            In view of the above, the Committee decided to issue a Showcause Notice to
                            the institution as to why the recognition be not withdrawn and thereby
                                                       124

           (Gangadharaiah)                                                    (Prof. C. Thangamuthu)
         Regional Director, SRC, NCTE                                         Chairman, SRC, NCTE
                                                                                             th
                                                                                         198 Meeting of SRC
                                                                                        th  h
                                                                                      24 -26 November 2010

                             providing an opportunity to the institution to make a written representation
                             within 30 days from the date of issue of the Notice along with necessary
                             certificates/documents in order to take a final decision in the matter; failing
                             which action will be taken including the withdrawal, based on the records
                             available, with no further notice.

106.      APS02324           Pragathi Teacher Training Institute, No.10, M.G.Road, Chintamani – 563125, Kolar
          APS05427           District Karnataka was granted recognition for offering D.Ed-AI course on 14.05.2007
             D.Ed            with an intake of 100 students which includes existing intake of 50 students and
            D.Ed-AI          additional intake of 50 students.
       Pragathi Teacher
       Training Institute,   NCTE, Hqrs vide its letter dated 10.08.2010 has forwarded a copy of the inspection
             Kolar           report dated 16.06.2010 conducted under section 13 of NCTE Act. As there are
                             deficiencies pointed out in the inspection report, NCTE, Hqrs has requested SRC to
                             initiate action against the institution under section 17 of the NCTE Act immediately.
              KA
                             The SRC in its 195th meeting held on 17-18 August 2010 considered the report and
                             decided to issue showcause Notice. Accordingly, Notice was issued to the institution
                             on 22.09.2010. The institution has submitted written representation on 18.10.2010.
                             The Committee considered written reply of the institution and all the relevant
                             documentary evidences and it was decided to serve Show cause Notice Under
                             Section 17 of NCTE Act for the following :

                              The institution is functioning in an Five storied residential building for both
                               D.Ed and D.Ed-Al programmes. Firstly the running of the programmes in a
                               residential building is against the NCTE norms, secondly the residential
                               building is not designed for any academic programme to be conducted.

                              The building is not provided with any lift for the students.

                              It is dangerous for the student community to go up and down in the eight
                               storyed building to attend to classes.

                              Staff salaries are being paid by cash instead of through Bank and Provident
                               fund contributions are not made or paid to the respective agency.

                              The trust is also running other programmes in the same building. This is
                               against the norms of NCTE.

                             In view of the above, the Committee decided to issue a Showcause Notice to
                             the institution as to why the recognition be not withdrawn and thereby
                             providing an opportunity to the institution to make a written representation
                             within 30 days from the date of issue of the Notice along with necessary
                             certificates/documents in order to take a final decision in the matter; failing
                             which action will be taken including the withdrawal, based on the records
                             available, with no further notice.




                                                        125

          (Gangadharaiah)                                                       (Prof. C. Thangamuthu)
        Regional Director, SRC, NCTE                                            Chairman, SRC, NCTE
                                                                                             th
                                                                                         198 Meeting of SRC
                                                                                        th  h
                                                                                      24 -26 November 2010

107.      APS04766           Vikram D.Ed College, Near Railway Track, Chelur Road, Chintamani, Kolar District,
                             Karnataka was granted recognition for offering D.Ed (Kannada medium) course on
          APS05588           24.05.2007 and D.Ed (English Medium) course on 15.05.2007 with an intake of 50
       D.Ed(Kannada)         students each which comes to an annual intake of 100 students.
       D.Ed-AI(English)
         Vikram D.Ed         NCTE, Hqrs vide its letter dated 10.08.2010 has forwarded a copy of the inspection
        College, Kolar       report dated 17.06.2010 conducted under section 13 of NCTE Act. As there are
                             deficiencies pointed out in the inspection report, NCTE, Hqrs has requested SRC to
                             initiate action against the institution under section 17 of the NCTE Act immediately.
              KA
                             The SRC in its 195th meeting held on 17-18 August 2010 considered the report and
                             decided to issue showcause Notice. Accordingly, Notice was issued to the institution
                             on 22.09.2010. The institution has submitted written representation on 18.10.2010.

                             The committee considered the reply and decided to cause inspection Under
                             Section 17 of NCTE Act. The institution is directed to submit the following with
                             30 days of the receipt of the notice. Demand Draft of Rs.40,000/- inspection fee
                             towards the course being run, in favour of “The Member Secretary, NCTE”
                             payable at Bangalore, Building completion certificate from a competent Govt.
                             Engineer, other relevant documents           to be submitted and to ascertain
                             infrastructural and instructional facilities

108.      AOS00027           Annai Fathima Teacher Training Institute, Hirebidanur, Gauribidanur Taluk, Kolar
          APS03115           District-561208, Karnataka has submitted application for D.Ed course on 27.01.2004.
              D.Ed           The institution has been granted recognition for D.Ed-AI on 13.12.2004. with an
           D.Ed-AI           intake of 50 students which includes existing intake of 30 students and additional
        Annai Fathima        intake of 20 students.
       Teacher Training      NCTE, Hqrs vide its letter dated 10.08.2010 has forwarded a copy of the inspection
        Institute, Kolar     report dated 16.06.2010 conducted under section 13 of NCTE Act. As there are
                             deficiencies pointed out in the inspection report, NCTE, Hqrs has requested SRC to
              KA             initiate action against the institution under section 17 of the NCTE Act immediately.
                             The SRC in its 195th meeting held on 17-18 August 2010, considered the report of the
                             institution and decided to issue Showcause Notice.

                             Accordingly, showcause notice was issued to the institution on 27.09.2010. The
                             institution submitted its written representation on 25.10.2010.

                             The committee considered the reply and decided to cause inspection Under
                             Section 17 of NCTE Act. The institution is directed to submit the following
                             within 30 days of the receipt of the notice. Demand Draft of Rs.40,000/-
                             inspection fee towards the course being run, in favour of “The Member
                             Secretary, NCTE” payable at Bangalore, other relevant documents to be
                             submitted and to ascertain infrastructural and instructional facilities

109.      APS05244           Arni Teacher Training Institute, Thiruvannamalai, Tamilnadu submitted
          APS08846           application for granted of recognition to D.T.Ed course. Recognition was
            D.T.Ed           granted for offering D.T.Ed course with an intake of 50 students on
           D.T.Ed-AI         17.11.2006 and D.T.Ed-AI on 20.12.2007 at No.21 & 22, Arasu Gardens,
         Arni Teacher        Miller Road, Arni-623301, Thiruvannamalai, Tamilnadu with the condition to
       Training Institute,
                                                        126

          (Gangadharaiah)                                                       (Prof. C. Thangamuthu)
        Regional Director, SRC, NCTE                                            Chairman, SRC, NCTE
                                                                                              th
                                                                                          198 Meeting of SRC
                                                                                         th  h
                                                                                       24 -26 November 2010

       Thiruvannamalai       shift to own premises within 3 years.
              TN             The institution has submitted its written representation alongwith DD of
                             Rs.40000/- towards inspection fee on 20.10.2010 stating as follows :

                             “We have been running a Arni Teacher Training Institute (D.T.Ed course) since
                             November 2006 after getting due permission from Southern Regional Committee,
                             NCTE, Bangalore Vide Nos.F.SRO/NCTE/D.T.Ed/2006-2007/9341, dated 23.12.2006
                             and Tamilnadu State Government Approval No. RC.No.9883/C1/2007 dated
                             17.11.2006 for 50 Sseats & F.SRO/NCTE/D.T.Ed-AI/2006-07/16173 Dt.20.12.2007
                             for additional 50 seats in the following address:

                             Now we have shifted our Arni Teacher Training Institute to our own premises.

                             Hence, I have herewith enclosed a DD for Rs.40, 000/- (DD No.988180 dated
                             13.9.2010) towards inspection fees.

                             Hence, I kindly request you to make an inspection at an early date of your
                             convenience”.

                             The committee considered the written explanation to the notice and other
                             documents submitted by the institution and decided to cause inspection at the
                             new premises Under Section 17 of NCTE Act. The institution is directed to
                             submit the following within 30 days of the receipt of the notice, Duly filled in
                             Questionnaire along with all the necessary documents for land, building
                             approval and completion certificate from a competent Govt. Engineer, FDRs for
                             Rs. 5 lakhs and 3 lakhs and other relevant documents.

110.      APS04984           Thellar Teacher Training Institute, Thiruvannamalai, Tamilnadu submitted
            D.T.Ed           application for granted of recognition to D.T.Ed course on 02.01.2006.
        Thellar Teacher
       Training Institute,   The application was processed and recognition was granted for offering
       Thiruvannamalai       D.T.Ed course with an intake of 50 students on 23.12.2006 at Vandavasi
              TN             Taluk, Thellar, Thiruvannamalai, Tamilnadu with the condition to shift to own
                             premises within 3 years.

                             The institution has submitted its written representation alongwith DD of
                             Rs.40000/- towards inspection fee on 20.10.2010 stating as follows :

                             “we have been running a Teacher Training Institute (D.E.I.Ed course) since 2007
                             after getting due permission from NCTE and no objection certificate (NOC) from
                             Tamilnadu Government, then we started classes in a temporary building (NCTE
                             Approval No – F.SRC/NCTE/D.T.Ed/2006-2007/9719, dated 23.12.2006 and
                             Tamilnadu State Government Approval No. RC.No.9883/C1/2007 dated 20.6.2007)
                             herewith we are submitting the demand draft for Rs. 40000 in favour of the Director,
                             NCTE, SRC payable at Bangalore for the purpose of inspection processing fees for
                             shifting to our new our building”.

                                                        127

          (Gangadharaiah)                                                       (Prof. C. Thangamuthu)
        Regional Director, SRC, NCTE                                            Chairman, SRC, NCTE
                                                                                                th
                                                                                            198 Meeting of SRC
                                                                                           th  h
                                                                                         24 -26 November 2010

                              The committee considered the written explanation to the notice and other
                              documents submitted by the institution and decided to cause inspection at the
                              new premises Under Section 17 of NCTE Act. The institution is directed to
                              submit the following within 30 days of the receipt of the notice, Duly filled in
                              Questionnaire along with all the necessary documents for land, building
                              approval and completion certificate from a competent Govt. Engineer, FDRs for
                              Rs. 5 lakhs and 3 lakhs, and other relevant documents.

111.      APS03033            Nazerath College of Education for Women, Chennai, Tamilnadu submitted
             B.Ed             application for granted of recognition to B.Ed course. Recognition was granted
       Nazerath College of    for offering B.Ed course with an intake of 100 students on 22.11.2005 at
         Education for        Kovilpathagai Main Road, Kannadapalayam, Vellanoor Post, Avadi, Chennai,
        Women, Chennai        Tamilnadu with the condition to shift to own premises within 3 years.
               TN             The institution has submitted its written representation on 21.10.2010 stating as
                              follows :

                              With reference to the above, I would like to inform you that it has been stated in your
                              order that institution has made arrangement for conducting the course in the rented
                              premises.

                              In this connection I would like to inform that the course is now being conducted in the
                              permanent building exclusively meant for B.Ed since August 2008.

                              I request that the shifting of the building from the rented to permanent building in the
                              permanent site may kindly be approved.

                              The committee considered the written request and other documents submitted
                              by the institution and decided to cause inspection at the new premises Under
                              Section 17 of NCTE Act. The institution is directed to submit the following
                              within 30 days of the receipt of the notice, Duly filled in Questionnaire along
                              with all the necessary documents for land, building approval and completion
                              certificate from a competent Govt. Engineer, FDRs for Rs. 5 lakhs and 3 lakhs,
                              and other relevant documents along with Demand Draft of Rs.40,000/-
                              inspection fee towards the course being run, in favour of “The Member
                              Secretary, NCTE” payable at Bangalore,

112.       APS01032           Wisdom Teacher Training Institute, Thiruvannamalai, Tamilnadu submitted
           APS05171           application for granted of recognition to D.T.Ed course. Recognition was
             D.T.Ed           granted for offering D.T.Ed course with an intake of 50 students on
            D.T.Ed-AI         22.11.2005 & D.T.Ed-AI with an intake of 50 students on 13.11.2006 at
        Wisdom Teacher        Cheyyattraivenran Village & Post, Cheyyar Taluk, Thiruvannamalai-604401,
        Training Institute,
                              Tamilnadu with the condition to shift to own premises within 3 years.
        Thiruvannamalai

               TN             The institution has submitted its written representation on 20.10.2010 stating
                              as follows :

                              “We have been running a Teacher Training Institute (D.E.I.Ed course) since 2006
                                                          128

           (Gangadharaiah)                                                         (Prof. C. Thangamuthu)
         Regional Director, SRC, NCTE                                              Chairman, SRC, NCTE
                                                                                                th
                                                                                            198 Meeting of SRC
                                                                                           th  h
                                                                                         24 -26 November 2010

                             after getting due permission from NCTE and no objection certificate (NOC) from
                             Tamilnadu Government, then we started classes in a temporary building (NCTE
                             Approval No – F.TN/ElE/SRO/NCTE/D.T.Ed/2005-2006/4129, dated 22.11.2005,
                             F.SRO/NCTE/D.T.Ed-AI/2006-2007/9192 dated 13.11.2006 and Tamilnadu State
                             Government Approval No. RC.No.2846/C1/2007 dated 08.03.2007) Now we have
                             shifted the institute to our own new building. We have sent Rs.40000 through
                             Demand Draft No.078977 date 30.1.2010 (Extn date 02.08.2010) towards inspection
                             fee”.

                             The committee considered the written request and other documents submitted
                             by the institution and decided to cause composite inspection at the new
                             premises Under Section 17 of NCTE Act. The institution is directed to submit
                             the following within 30 days of the receipt of the notice, Duly filled in
                             Questionnaire along with all the necessary documents for land, building
                             approval and completion certificate from a competent Govt. Engineer, FDRs for
                             Rs. 5 lakhs and 3 lakhs and other relevant documents.

113.      APS04492           JSR Teacher Training Institute, Coimbatore, Tamilnadu has submitted an application
            D.T.Ed           for seeking grant of recognition for D.T.Ed course on 08.12.2005.
         JSR Teacher
       Training Institute,   The application was processed and recognition to the institution for D.T.Ed course
          Coimbatore         was granted on 20.06.2007 for annual intake of 50 students with the condition to shift
                             to own premises within 3 years.

              TN             The institution vide letter dated 02.11.2010 stated as follows:

                             “I am to state that our institution has shifted to permanent building and functioning at
                             the address as follows:

                             JSR Teacher Training Institute
                             Agraharakkannadiputhur Village
                             Madathukulam Taluk
                             Tiruppur District
                             Tamilnadu

                             Herewith I have enclosed a DD for Rs.40000/- towards obtaining permission for
                             shifting of the premises to the permanent building.

                             Kindly acknowledge the receipt of the same and do the needful at the earliest”.


                             Note: The institution is also running B.Ed course. Recognition to B.Ed course was
                             granted on 13.07.2005.

                             The committee considered the written request and other documents submitted
                             by the institution and decided to cause composite inspection at the new
                             premises Under Section 17 of NCTE Act. The institution is directed to submit
                             the following within 30 days of the receipt of the notice, Duly filled in
                             Questionnaire along with all the necessary documents for land, building
                                                         129

          (Gangadharaiah)                                                         (Prof. C. Thangamuthu)
        Regional Director, SRC, NCTE                                              Chairman, SRC, NCTE
                                                                                                        th
                                                                                                   198 Meeting of SRC
                                                                                                   th h
                                                                                                24 -26 November 2010

                               approval and completion certificate from a competent Govt. Engineer, FDRs for
                               Rs. 5 lakhs and 3 lakhs and other relevant documents.

114.        APS09430           Sri Balaji College of Education, Villupuram, Tamilnadu has submitted an application
               B.Ed            for seeking grant of recognition for B.Ed course on 11.03.2008.
       Sri Balaji College of
            Education,         The application was processed and recognition to the institution for B.Ed course was
           Virudhunagar        granted on 25.06.2009 for annual intake of 100 students.

                               The institution vide letter dated 01.11.2010 stated as follows:
               TN
                               “As per the resolution of our Trust we have shifted our institution to our own land and building.
                               Copy of the resolution is enclosed.

                               We have enclosed one DD for Rs.40000/- as inspection fee. So we humbly request you to
                               inspect our institution and issue favorable order”.

                               The institution has submitted the following:
                                DD of Rs. 40000/-
                                Copy of resolution
                                Copy of Trust deed
                                Copy of Land document – tamil version
                                Building Plan at Sy.No.8/2 at A. Vasadevanoor Village, Chinna Salem to Salem
                                  Main Road, Kallakurichi, Villupuram approved by Registered Engineer authorized
                                  by District Collectors of Cuddalore and Villupuram with total area of 127195.20
                                  sq.ft (11821.10 sq.mtrs) and built up space of 19346 sq.ft (1796 sq.mtrs)
                                Land usage certificate – tamil version
                                Encumbrance certificate
                                Building Completion Certificate approved by Junior Engineer PWD, Kallakurichi
                                  with built up space of 1796.90 sq.mtrs.
                                Affidavit on Rs.100/- stamp paper with total area of 3126.2 sq.mtrs

                               Note: The institution is also running D.T.Ed course (APS05682) on 08.11.2006.

                               The committee considered the written reply and other documents submitted
                               by the institution and decided to cause inspection at the new premises Under
                               Section 17 of NCTE Act. The institution is directed to submit the following
                               within 30 days of the receipt of the notice, Duly filled in Questionnaire along
                               with all the necessary documents for land, building approval and completion
                               certificate from a competent Govt. Engineer . FDRs for Rs. 5 lakhs and 3 lakhs,
                               and other relevant documents
115.       APS04442            SRET Teacher Training Institute, Namakkal, Tamilnadu submitted application
             D.T.Ed            for granted of recognition to D.T.Ed course on 03.11.2005. Recognition was
         SRET Teacher          granted for offering D.T.Ed course with an intake of 50 students on
        Training Institute,    06.10.2006 with the condition to shift to own premises within 3 years.
           Namakkal
                               The institution vide letter dated 05.10.2010 alongwith Rs. 40000/- stating as
               TN              follows:

                                                              130

            (Gangadharaiah)                                                              (Prof. C. Thangamuthu)
          Regional Director, SRC, NCTE                                                   Chairman, SRC, NCTE
                                                                                               th
                                                                                           198 Meeting of SRC
                                                                                          th  h
                                                                                        24 -26 November 2010

                          “Sri Rengaswamy Educational Trust, running D.T.Ed college in the name and style of
                          SRET Teacher Training Institute at Komarapalayam, Tamilnadu with an annual intake
                          of 100. We would like to shift our institution from the present site to permanent site at
                          Survey no. 368/8 at Pallakapalayam Village, Komarapalayam from the year 2010-
                          2011. Hence, we are submitting an application for shifting to permanent premises.
                          We are herewith enclosing the land documents and application from for your kind
                          perusal”.

                          Note : The institution is also running another D.T.Ed course in the name of SRET
                          Teacher Training Institute for women (APS04439) in the same campus granted by
                          SRC vide order dated 09.08.2008.

                          The committee considered the written reply and other documents submitted
                          by the institution and decided to cause composite inspection at the new
                          premises Under Section 17 of NCTE Act. The institution is directed to submit
                          the following within 30 days of the receipt of the notice, Duly filled in
                          Questionnaire along with all the necessary documents for land, building
                          approval and completion certificate from a competent Govt. Engineer and other
                          relevant documents along with Demand Draft of Rs.40,000/- inspection fee
                          towards the other Teacher Education programme i.e., D.T.Ed additional course
                          being run, in favour of “The Member Secretary, NCTE” payable at Bangalore,

116.     APS09574         An application was submitted by Siva Sankara Educational & Development Society, Kurnool,
            B.Ed          Andhra Pradesh for grant of recognition to B.Ed course in the office of SRC-NCTE, vide dated
        Siva Sankara      13.08.2008.
        Educational &
                          The file was under process and in the meanwhile, in view of the recommendations of the
        Development
                          State Government of Andhra Pradesh vide letter dated 07.01.2009 not to further
       Society, Kurnool   recognise/permit the institutions for conducting B.Ed, D.Ed, Physical Education, Language
                          Pandit course(s).
             AP
                          The SRC in its 169th Meeting held on 12-13 January, 2009 having considered the letter dated
                          07.01.2009 of State Government of Andhra Pradesh and decided to give effect to the above
                          decision of State Government of Andhra Pradesh as such, with immediate effect.

                          A letter dated 07.02.2009 forwarded by Principal Secretary of Education requesting not to
                          accord further recognition/permission to the new colleges/private B.Ed, D.Ed, Physical
                          Education, Language Pandit in the State of Andhra Pradesh as the above colleges are
                          exceeding in numbers than required.

                          A letter dated 17.03.2009 has been received from NCTE, Hqrs informing that the “The
                          recommendations of the Govt. of Andhra Pradesh not to grant recognition/permission in
                          respect of other courses like B.Ed, D.Ed and Physical Education courses have further been
                          decided that no further Recognition/ Permission to any institution in the State of Andhra
                          Pradesh be considered by SRC for the academic session 2009-2010 for B.Ed, D.Ed, and
                          Physical Education courses also”.

                          The letters dated 07.01.2009, 07.02.2009, 17.03.2009 and 20.03.2009 was
                          considered by SRC in its 172nd Meeting held on 25-26 March, 2009 and SRC
                          decided to accept the recommendation of the State Government of Andhra Pradesh,
                          not to grant recognition to any of the Teacher Training Institutions in the State of
                                                       131

          (Gangadharaiah)                                                        (Prof. C. Thangamuthu)
        Regional Director, SRC, NCTE                                             Chairman, SRC, NCTE
                                                                                      th
                                                                                  198 Meeting of SRC
                                                                                 th  h
                                                                               24 -26 November 2010

                 Andhra Pradesh for the year 2009-2010 and decided to return the applications.

                 As per the direction of SRC the documents along with processing fee returned to the
                 institution on 27.04.2009. The institution has approached to Hon‟ble High court of
                 Andhra pradesh without making appeal to appellate authority under section 18 of
                 NCTE Act.

                    Hon’ble High court has passed order dated first day of June, two thousand and ten. The
                    operative part of order as under:-
                 These Writ Petitions raise common issues. Therefore with the consent of the learned
                 counsel for the parties, they are taken up for hearing and disposal together.

                 In all these Writ petitions, the petitioners, which are educational Institutions, felt
                 aggrieved by non-consideration of their applications for grant of recognition to
                 D.Ed/B.Ed courses purportedly on the ground of the policy decision taken by the
                 Government not to permit establishment of new D.Ed/B.Ed Colleges.

                 At the hearing, Sri Andapalli Sanjeev Kumar, learned counsel appearing for the
                 petitioners in Writ petition Nos.11038, 11040, 11587 and 10965 of 2009, and Sri S.
                 Girimoji Rao, learned counsel for the petitioner in Writ petition No.11241 of 2009,
                 submitted that the petitioners filed their applications for recognition prior to the policy
                 decision taken by the State Government; and that in an identical Writ petition, this
                 Court, vide: order dated 16-12-2009 in writ petition No.6712 of 2009, held as under:

                 “It may be true the State Government as well the first respondent have reviewed the
                 situation as to the necessity or otherwise of according permission to establish new
                 colleges of education in the State in further and that the existing institutions are fond
                 to be adequate. However, the right that is accrued to the petitioners on the basis of
                 their application and the consideration there of by the first respondent cannot be
                 taken away on account of the change of policy. It is settled principle of law that
                 whenever an application is made, it must be considered and processed in
                 accordance with the provisions of law or the policy that existed as on the date of
                 presentation. Subsequent changes may apply to the applications that are made
                 thereafter.

                 Hence, the writ petition is disposed of directing the first respondent to take necessary
                 steps as contemplated in its communication dated 24-11-2009 and pass appropriate
                 orders.
                 There shall be no order as to coasts”.

                 The learned Standing Counsel representing respondents 2 and 3 has not disputed
                 the above position.

                 Since the issue raised in these Writ Petitions are squarely covered by the above
                 mentioned orders, these Writ petitions are disposed of in terms of the above
                 mentioned orders in writ petition No.6712 of 2009 with the direction that the directions
                 given in the said orders shall form part of this orders.

                 The institution has now submitted D.Ed of 40000/- for processing fee on 30.06.2010.
                                              132

  (Gangadharaiah)                                                       (Prof. C. Thangamuthu)
Regional Director, SRC, NCTE                                            Chairman, SRC, NCTE
                                                                                                      th
                                                                                                  198 Meeting of SRC
                                                                                                 th  h
                                                                                               24 -26 November 2010

                              All documents submitted as well as application appears to have been returned on
                              27.04.2009

                              SRC in its 194th meeting held on 21-22 July 2010 considered the matter and directed
                              the Management/institution to resubmit the old application returned by SRC along
                              with necessary documents as originally submitted relating to land, building, FDR,
                              Application fee, Building Completion Certificate from competent Government
                              Engineer/ authority and other relevant aspects for processing and for necessary
                              action.

                              As per direction of Regional Committee a letter was issued on 19.08.2010. In
                              response to this office letter dated 30.08.2010 the institution has submitted reply vide
                              letter dated 03.09.2010.

                              As per perusal of the file the institution has submitted following documents vide letters dated
                              03.09.10 :-
                              1. Processing fee and application fee (40,000+1,000= 41,000/-) Application fee of Rs.
                                  1,000/- submitted earlier too)
                              2. Land documents
                              3. BCC Certificate not in prescribed format from Panchyat Secretary
                              4. Land use Certificate by Tahsildar.
                              5. Approved Building Plan by panchyat Secretary
                              6. Original FDR of 5 lakhs and 3 lakhs not submitted.
                              7. Affidavit of Rs 100/- regarding land and building submitted in photocopy..

                              The committee considered the written explanation to the notice and other
                              documents submitted by the institution and decided to cause inspection of the
                              institution Under Section 14/15 of NCTE Act.

117.       SRCAPP72           Dr. Zakir Hussain College, Ilayanagudi, Paramakud Road, Sivagangai-630702,
              B.Ed            Tamilnadu submitted its application for B.Ed course through on-line on 29.10.2009.
       Dr. Zakir College of   Application of the above institution was received by SRC on 29.10.2009. The
            Education,        application was processed and deficiency letter was issued to the institution on
           Sivagangai         22.12.2009.

                              The institution submitted its written representation on 01.03.2010, which was
               TN             considered by SRC in its 190th meeting held on 29-30th March, 2010 and the
                              Committee decided to reject the application on the following grounds:

                              The institution has not submitted valid minority status certificate from the competent
                                 authority.

                              Accordingly, the application was rejected vide order F.SRC/NCTE/M.Ed/2010/18632
                              dated. 03.05.2010.

                              Aggrieved by the rejection order, the institution filed appeal under section 18 of NCTE
                              Act, before the Appellate Authority, NCTE, New Delhi. The Appellate Authority vide
                              order dated 19.07.2010 remanded back the case to SRC for necessary action.

                              SRC considered the appeal order in its 195th meeting held on 17th-18th August 2010
                                                             133

           (Gangadharaiah)                                                              (Prof. C. Thangamuthu)
         Regional Director, SRC, NCTE                                                   Chairman, SRC, NCTE
                                                                                              th
                                                                                          198 Meeting of SRC
                                                                                         th  h
                                                                                       24 -26 November 2010

                             and the committee decided to call for Minority Status Certificate in the name of the
                             proposed college from the Competent Authority in order to take a final decision in the
                             matter.

                             Accordingly a letter was issued to the institution on 22.09.2010 to submit the same.

                             The institution vide its letter dated 26.10.2010 has submitted declaration on Rs.20/-
                             stamp paper which is placed on file.

                             They have however not submitted minority status certificate in the name of proposed
                             college from the competent authority.

                             The committee considered the written explanation to the notice and other
                             documents submitted by the institution and decided to cause inspection of the
                             institution Under Section 14/15 of NCTE Act.


118.      APS03378           Municipal Teacher Training Institute, N.H.7, Chitravathi Extension, Chikballapur,
          APS03099
                             Kolar District – 562101, Karnataka was granted recognition by SRC for offering D.Ed-
             D.Ed
            D.Ed-AI          AI course with an existing intake of 60 students and additional intake of 20 students,
       Municipal Teacher
                             thus with an annual intake of 80 students vide order dated 29.12.2004.
       Training Institute,
         Chikballapur
                             The institution vide letter dated 04.10.2010 has stated that Municipal Teacher
              KA
                             Training Institute was under the control of City Municipal Council, Chickballapur for
                             the past 39 years. Now Karnataka Government has been taken over the institution
                             on 16.02.2010 vide Government order No.ED:121:PTI:2009/Bangalore Dated
                             16.10.2010. DSERT, Bangalore and CAC Bangalore has also issued letters to this
                             effect.
                             Hence, the institution has requested to change the name from “Municipal Teacher‟s
                             Training Institute” to “Government Teacher‟s Training Institute, Chickballapur” as per
                             Government order.
                             The committee considered the matter and decided that change of name from
                             “Municipal Teacher’s Training Institute” to “Government Teacher’s Training
                             Institute” is permitted.

119.       APS03844          Renuka College of Diploma Education, Ramanagara, Kudligi Road,
              D.Ed           Hagaribommanahalli Taluk, Bellary – 583212, Karnataka (APS03844) has been
       Renuka College of     granted recognition from the session 2005-2006 with an intake of 50 students vide
       Diploma Education,    order dated 03.02.2006.
             Bellary
                             The institution in its letter submitted on 28.05.2010 has requested for change of
              KA             management as per the directions of the Hon‟ble High Court, Dharwad as per the
                                                         134

           (Gangadharaiah)                                                       (Prof. C. Thangamuthu)
         Regional Director, SRC, NCTE                                            Chairman, SRC, NCTE
                                                                                                th
                                                                                            198 Meeting of SRC
                                                                                           th  h
                                                                                         24 -26 November 2010

                            judgement dated 08.03.2010 in W.P. 61250 of 2010 from Sri. Ranganathaswamy
                            Vidya Samsthe, Bapuji Public School, N.H.13, Chitradurga to Yedeyuryu
                            Sri.Siddalingeshwara Vidya Peetha, Renuka Vidya Mandira, Kudligi Road,
                            Ramanagara, Hagaribommanahalli – 583212, Bellary District, Karnataka.
                            From the perusal of the representation submitted by the institution, it is not known
                            whether the institution is also seeking shifting of premises and change of name.

                            The SRC in its 194th meeting held on 21-22 July 2010 considered the matter and
                            decided to call for clarification from the institution:-
                             on whether the Management is seeking change of Management and name of the
                              College OR for shifting the location of the institution, OR for both.
                            Any shifting of location of the institution is not permissible from one district to another
                            district on the following grounds:-
                             The NCTE recognition is for a particular Teacher Education programme in a
                               particular institution in a specific location.
                             As the NCTE recognition already granted is institution-specific and location-
                               specific, the same recognition order of NCTE cannot be used for starting a different
                               institution in a different location.
                             The NCTE recognized Teacher Education institution is not to be treated as a
                               commercial and speculative venture and as a mobile property to be shifted from
                               one place to another for better clientable and marketing, and purely for pecuniary
                               gains.
                             The question of shifting arises only in respect of such of those institutions which
                               were permitted to be started in temporary premises subject to the condition that
                               they shall shift within three year period to the permanent premises in a close
                               vicinity, which land should have been permitted already as per the NCTE norms.

                            The institution has submitted written representation on 28.09.2010 and has stated
                            that the management has sought only for change the management but not shifting
                            the college and its name. The institution has further stated that the college is existing
                            at the same location with building, staff and its name. Hence the management has
                            requesting to grant the recognition in favour of institution with anticipation.

                            The NCTE Regulations 2009 does not provide for change of management.

                            The committee considered the request of the management and all other related
                            documents and decided to permit the change of Management from “Sri
                            Ranganatha Swamy Vidya Samsthe” to “Yedeyuru Sri Siddalingeshwara Vidya
                            Peetha”,    Renuka       Vidya   Mandira,     Kudligi   Road,    Ramanagara,
                            Hagaribommanahalli – 583212, Bellary District, Karnataka, subject to the
                            condition that there is no change in location name of the college etc., Further,
                            the committee decided that change in management is permitted subject to
                            payment of Rs. 40000/-

120.       APS09521         Bhanwari Devi Parasmal Surana Prabhavati Jayaprakash Teacher Training Institute,
             D.T.Ed         Chennai, Tamilnadu has submitted an application for seeking grant of recognition for
         Jaya Prakash       D.T.Ed course on 22.05.2008.
       Teacher Training
       Institute, Chennai   The application was processed and recognition to the institution for D.T.Ed course
                                                         135

          (Gangadharaiah)                                                         (Prof. C. Thangamuthu)
        Regional Director, SRC, NCTE                                              Chairman, SRC, NCTE
                                                                                                th
                                                                                           198 Meeting of SRC
                                                                                           th h
                                                                                        24 -26 November 2010

                            was granted on 24.06.2009 for annual intake of 50 students.
              TN
                            The institution vide letter dated 01.11.2010 stated as follows:

                            “We write this inform your good self that due to very poor response for the admission
                            of students. Our trust has decided to defer the commencement of admission of
                            students from the year 2011.

                            We are enclosing the copy of the letter submitted to DTERT, Chennai in this regard.”

                            The committee considered the letter of the institution and decided to note the
                            decision of the management.

121.       APS01660         Aditya Teachers College, Aditya Educational Trust, #26/3, Maheshwari Temple Road,
              D.Ed
                            8th Cross, Malleshwaram, Bangalore-560003, Karnataka has submitted application
        Aditya Teachers
       College, Bangalore   for D.Ed course on 29.12.2003. The institution has granted recognition with an intake
                            of 50 students vide order dated 25.11.2004.
              KA
                            The institution in its letter dated 27.09.2007 has submitted a proposal for shifting of
                            premises along with Rs.40,000/- towards shifting fee. Accordingly, inspection was
                            scheduled on 24-26 November 2010.
                            Now, the institution has submitted a letter on 19.11.2010 and has stated that, since
                            the owner of the premises has asked the institution to vacate the building and NCTE
                            was not giving permission to shift to another rented building.           Unfortunately the
                            institution did not had own premises and the instituition had no other option but to
                            vacate the premises and the students were shifted to Shusruthi D.Ed college,
                            Peenya, Bangalore with the approval from DSERT & DIET(letter enclosed).

                            Therefore, the institution has requested to cancel the recognition of above institution
                            and the institution has also requested SRC, NCTE to return back FDRs of 5 & 3
                            lakhs.

                            The Committee considered the Institutions request for closure of D.Ed course
                            and decided to permit the closure by withdrawing the recognition for
                            (APS01660) with effect from 2012-2013, in order to enable the ongoing batch of
                            students in D.Ed, course, if any, to complete their final year course.

                            But it is made clear that the institution is debarred from making any further
                            admission subsequent to the date of issue of this order.

                            The Affiliating body / Examining board / body be informed accordingly.

                            Further decided to return Endowment funds and Reserve fund if deposited with
                            SRC NCTE, Bangalore.
                                                         136

           (Gangadharaiah)                                                        (Prof. C. Thangamuthu)
         Regional Director, SRC, NCTE                                             Chairman, SRC, NCTE
                                                                                              th
                                                                                          198 Meeting of SRC
                                                                                         th  h
                                                                                       24 -26 November 2010




122.        APS03820          Sri Lakshmi Teacher Training Institute, 5th Cros, Gautham Nagar, Robertsonpet,
               D.Ed
                              Kolar Gold Field, Kolar District, Karnataka submitted an application for grant of
       Sri Lakshmi Teacher
        Training Institute,   recognition on 31.12.2004. The institution was granted recognition for offering D.Ed
               Kolar
                              course with an intake of 50 students vide order dated 03.01.2006.
                              The institution has submitted a letter on 21.10.2010 and has stated that the above
               KA             trust in the meeting held on 22.09.2010, has unanimously decided to close Teachers
                              Training Course.since they are unable to secure admissions for the year 2009-10 and
                              2010-11. Further the institution has requested to withdraw or cancel the recognition
                              and return the Fixed Deposit Recepits

                              The Committee considered the Institutions request for closure of D.Ed course
                              and decided to permit the closure by withdrawing the recognition for
                              (APS03820) with effect from 2012-2013, in order to enable the ongoing batch of
                              students in D.Ed, course, if any, to complete their final year course.

                              But it is made clear that the institution is debarred from making any further
                              admission subsequent to the date of issue of this order.

                              The Affiliating body / Examining board / body be informed accordingly.

                              Further decided to return Endowment funds and Reserve fund if deposited with
                              SRC NCTE, Bangalore.

123.       AOS00352           Malnad College of Physical Education, Terrethahalli-577432, Shimoga District,
             C.P.Ed           Karnataka has been granted recognition by SRC for offering C.P.Ed vide order dated
        Malnad College of     15.07.1998.
       Physical Education,    A letter dated 18.11.2010 has been received from the Government of Karnataka and
            Shimoga           had stated that based on the report of the Director, DSERT, the Govenrment had
                              recommended that the recognition of Malnad College of Physical Education be
               KA             withdrawn immediately. The report is attached herewith, entire report is in Kannada

                              The committee considered the written communication from the institution and
                              The Director DSERT, 100 ft road, BSK III state, Hosakerehalli post, Bangalore-
                              80 and also letter from Govt. of Karnataka, The Principal Secretary, Department
                              of Education, Multistoryed Building Bangalore, recommending withdrawal of
                              Recognition to Maland College of Physical Education, Teerthahalli – 577432
                              Shimoga District, Karnataka and decided to cause inspection of the premises
                              Under Section 17 of NCTE Act. The institution is directed to submit the
                              following within 30 days of the receipt of the notice, Duly filled in Questionnaire
                              along with all the necessary documents for land, building approval and
                              completion certificate from a competent Govt. Engineer and other relevant
                              documents along with Demand Draft of Rs.40,000/- inspection fee towards the
                              C.P.Ed course being run, in favour of “The Member Secretary, NCTE” payable
                              at Bangalore,

                                                         137

            (Gangadharaiah)                                                      (Prof. C. Thangamuthu)
          Regional Director, SRC, NCTE                                           Chairman, SRC, NCTE
                                                                                             th
                                                                                         198 Meeting of SRC
                                                                                        th  h
                                                                                      24 -26 November 2010



124.       APS04132        Mother India D.Ed College, Wadi Junction, Chittapur Taluk, Gulbarga – 585225,
             D.Ed
                           Karnataka was granted recognition by SRC for offering D.Ed course with an intake of
       Mother India D.Ed
       College, Gulbarga   50 students vide order dated 21.02.2006.
                           Based on the compliant of the State Government of Karnataka, inspection of the
              KA           institution was conducted under section 17. The recognition of the institution was
                           withdrawn by SRC, NCTE and order of withdrawal was issued to the institution on
                           06.12.2007.
                           The institution preferred appeal before NCTE, New Delhi. The Appellate Authority in
                           its order dated 19.06.2008 reversed the decision of SRC and directed to restore
                           recognition of the institution immediately and allowing extension of time for shifting
                           the building to its own permanent premises / building upto 24.12.2008. Accordingly,
                           the recognition order was restored and the institution was informed to shift to new
                           premises before 24.12.2008.
                           The institution in its letter dated 07.01.2009 has informed that due to heavy rains
                           construction of the work could not be completed and the building will be ready by the
                           end of June 2009. The institution has requested to grant extension of time for shifting
                           the college to the new building.
                           The representation of the institution along with original application and other
                           documents available were considered by SRC in its 170th meeting held on 16-17
                           February 2009 and SRC decided to withdraw recognition of the institution for the
                           D.Ed course as there is no provision to extend the time for shifting the building to own
                           premises beyond three years.
                           Accordingly, order withdrawing recognition was issued to the institution on
                           22.04.2009. Again the institution preferred apeal before NCTE, New Delhi and the
                           Appellate Authority vide order dated 07.08.2009 confirmed the withdrawal orders of
                           SRC.
                           The institution approached Hon'ble High Court of Karnataka in W.P. No.82000-82001
                           of 2010 wherein, the order dated 10.08.2010 reads as follows:
                           “…. the writ petitions stands allowed. The petitioners are granted time upto October,
                           2011, to complete the construction in accordance with norms, the guidelines and the
                           sanctioned plan for construction of the building. Subject to the same, the petitions
                           stand allowed.”

                           The NCTE, Hqrs has advised this office to file a review petition as the judgement is
                                                       138

           (Gangadharaiah)                                                      (Prof. C. Thangamuthu)
         Regional Director, SRC, NCTE                                           Chairman, SRC, NCTE
                                                                                             th
                                                                                         198 Meeting of SRC
                                                                                        th  h
                                                                                      24 -26 November 2010

                          not in consonance with the provisions of the NCTE‟s Regulations. Accordingly, a
                          letter was written to the advocate to file Review Petition on 21.10.2010.
                          Simultaneously, the institution has submitted a letter dt.06.09.2010 and has
                          requested to restore the recognition as per the Court directions, wherein time upto
                          October 2011 has been granted to complete the building contruction.
                          Now, a letter dated 16.10.2010 has been received and has requested to restore
                          recognition and shift the building by October 2011. The institution has also requested
                          to revoke the recognition and give permission to take admission.

                          The Committee considered the request of the institution and took note of the
                          contents of the judgement of the Hon’ble High Court of Karnataka, Circuit
                          Bench at Gulberga; and it was decided, as per the directions of NCTE Head
                          quarters, to file a review petition as the above judgement is not in consonance
                          with the provisions of the NCTE’s Regulations.

125.     APS04399         Southern Regional Committee-NCTE has granted recognition to Nandha College of
       Nanda College of   Education, 29/4, Koorapalayam, Pirivu, Pituchandampalayam Post, Erode-638052,
          Education       Tamilnadu for B.Ed Course of one year duration with an annual intake of 100
                          students on 18.10.2005.
             TN
                          As per the direction of Ministry of Human Resource Development (MHRD), as per
                          recommendation of Sri. Sathyam Committee reports on all the institution, which were
                          granted recognition by SRC in its 116th meeting. The re-inspection for B.Ed course of
                          the institution was carried out on 18.12.2008.

                          The visiting team report was placed before SRC in its 170th meeting held on 16-17th
                          February 2009 and SRC decided to issue show cause notice under section 17 of
                          NCTE Act, accordingly a show cause notice was issued to the institution on
                          02.04.2009.

                          The institution did not submit its reply even after completion of stipulated period. The
                          matter was considered by SRC in its 191st meeting held 20-21st April 2010 and it was
                          decided to issue final notice to the institution to submit the reply within 21 days.
                          Accordingly, final Notice was issued on 1.6.2010 on the following deficiencies;

                             The built up space of 24,892 sq.ft. is not adequate for existing B.Ed, D.T.Ed,
                              Matriculation school and Arts and Science college.
                             The Management has to submit details of total built up space and earmarked
                              spaces for each of the teacher education institution, school, Arts and Colleges
                              and also details of land registered in the name of the education colleges, with
                              evidence.
                             The books in the library numbering 4632 are not adequate for existing B.Ed and
                              D.T.Ed courses.
                             The Management has to submit approved building plan and building completion
                              certificate for verification for built up space available to run B.Ed and D.T.Ed
                                                      139

          (Gangadharaiah)                                                      (Prof. C. Thangamuthu)
        Regional Director, SRC, NCTE                                           Chairman, SRC, NCTE
                                                                                   th
                                                                               198 Meeting of SRC
                                                                              th  h
                                                                            24 -26 November 2010

                     courses.
                    The management has to submit a certificate from affiliating university and
                     DTERT, Chennai stating that no other courses are being run in the building
                     except teacher education courses.
                    The institution has to submit faculty list approved by the affiliating body for all
                     existing teacher education courses with details of each faculty members in the
                     format prescribed.

                 This office did not receive any reply from the institution thus far. Hence, the
                 Committee considered the matter in its 194th meeting held on 21st-22nd July 2010 and
                 decided to withdraw recognition for the following reasons:-

                  The Management has not submitted its reply to the notice within stipulated period
                   nor before the SRC met and decided on the issue.
                  The Management has not submitted Certificate from the affiliating
                   University/DTERT, Chennai stating that no other courses are being run in the
                   building other than teacher education courses.
                  The Management has not submitted details of the built-up space and earmarked
                   space for each of the teacher education programmes.
                  In the land document submitted, the Management has not earmarked no land for
                   the Nanda College of Education whereas all the documents only show the land in
                   the name of the Society which is also running other programmes other than teacher
                   education programmes.
                  The Management has not submitted approved building plan certified from the
                   competent Government authority in the proper format. Whereas, the building
                   completion certificate submitted reference to Nanda Polytechnic and issued by the
                   private Engineering Construction agency.
                  The institution has not submitted latest faculty list approved by the affiliating body
                   along with the necessary details of the faculty in the prescribed format for each
                   course.
                  The built-up space of 24,892 sq.ft. is not adequate for existing D.T.Ed., B.Ed.,
                   Matriculation school and an Arts and Science College.

                 Accordingly, withdrawal of recognition order was issued to the institution on
                 20.8.2010.

                 Aggrieved by the withdrawal of SRC, the institution filed court case in W.P. no. 18549
                 of 2010. The court has orders as follows.

                 “The Learned Counsel appearing for the respondent has produced an order dated
                 20.8.2010 withdrawing recognition granted to the petitioner to conduct B.Ed course.
                 While the decision of the 194th meeting of the respondent was relating to other
                 institutions also, the order dated 20.8.2010 is relating to the petitioner alone. The
                 order nowhere considers the representation given by the petitioner in reply to the
                 show cause notice dated 1.6.2010. Hence, the impugned order was passed in
                 violation of principles of natural justice. Hence, the impugned order is quashed and
                 the respondent is directed to consider and pass a fresh order after considering the
                 explanation given by the petitioner referred to above within a period of eight weeks
                 from the date of receipt of copy of this order”.
                                             140

  (Gangadharaiah)                                                     (Prof. C. Thangamuthu)
Regional Director, SRC, NCTE                                          Chairman, SRC, NCTE
                                                                                   th
                                                                               198 Meeting of SRC
                                                                              th  h
                                                                            24 -26 November 2010



                 The court order was placed before SRC in its 196th meeting held on 15th and 16th
                 September, 2010. SRC considered the matter and decided to await for the
                 documentary evidence and clarifications from the institution.

                 Further, SRC has decided that on receipt of the necessary documents the application
                 be processed as per the usual procedure.

                 In response to the decision of SRC, the reply for final notice submitted by the
                 institution vide their letter dated 18.6.2010 was scrutinised and the following
                 deficiencies were pointed out;-

                 The Committee considered the written reply of the institution dt. 18.6.2010 and
                 all the relevant documentary evidences and         it was decided to serve
                 Showcause Notice Under Section 17 of NCTE Act for the following –

                  The institution has to submit faculty list approved by the affiliating body for
                   all the existing teacher education courses as per the format.

                  Teacher education college is located within the Polytechnic premises.

                  The built up space for the teacher education programme is inadequate. As
                   per the building plan approved the institution is having Ground floor-8000
                   Sq.ft (413.5 Sq.mts), First floor-7005 Sq.ft(651.0 Sq.mts) with total built up
                   space of 15005 Sq.ft (1394.5 Sq.mts). Second floor-7005 sq.ft(651.0 Sq mts),
                   Third floor-7005 Sq.ft (651.0 Sq.Mts), with total built up space of 14010 Sq.ft
                   (1302 Sq.Mts), total built up area comes to – 29015 Sq.ft (2696.5 Sq.mts).As
                   per NCTE regulation total land area required for D.T.Ed and B.Ed is 3000
                   Sq.mts and built up area required is 3000 Sq.mts (32293 Sq.ft). The built up
                   area of 29015 Sq.ft is inadequate as sper regulations.

                  Land to be in the name of Trust/institution, whereas in the land document
                   submitted, the management has not earmarked any land for the Nanda
                   College of Education. All the documents only show the land in the name of
                   the Soceity which is also running other programmes other than teacher
                   education prgrammes.

                  Building completion certificate from approved Government enginner is to be
                   submitted.

                  A Certificate from the Government Affiliating body to the effect that no other
                   programme is being run by the institution in the same building / Campus,
                   along with the existing Course B.Ed to be submitted .

                  The institution has not subscribed to any Journals

                  Website of the institution is not updated.

                  The dimensions of multipurpose Hall, Science Lab, Phychology Lab, ET lab,
                                             141

  (Gangadharaiah)                                                     (Prof. C. Thangamuthu)
Regional Director, SRC, NCTE                                          Chairman, SRC, NCTE
                                                                                           th
                                                                                       198 Meeting of SRC
                                                                                      th  h
                                                                                    24 -26 November 2010

                            Library cum reading room are not mentioned.

                          In view of the above, the Committee decided to issue a Showcause Notice to
                          the institution as to why the recognition be not withdrawn and thereby
                          providing an opportunity to the institution to make a written representation
                          within 30 days from the date of issue of the Notice along with necessary
                          certificates/documents in order to take a final decision in the matter; failing
                          which action will be taken including the withdrawal, based on the records
                          available, with no further notice.



126.       APS08525       Annamalai University, Directorate of Distance Education, Annamalai Nagar,
           Annamalai      Tamilnadu was granted recognition for offering B.Ed-DE course with an intake of 500
           University.    students on 09.04.2008.
           Annanagar
                          Meanwhile a letter dated 24.9.2010 has been received from Shr. Elangovadav,
               TN         Working President, Tamilnadu Samajwadi Party addressed to Chairman, NCTE, New
       B.Ed (DE)          Delhi.

                          The letter reads as follows: “We Tamilnadu Samajwadi Party Office Bearers want to meet
                                              th
                          you during October 6 2010 on Convocation at Annamalai University. We want to submit a
                          Memorandum in regarding Students Admission B.Ed course in Distance Education,
                          Annamalai University. Hence we want an appointment on the same date for the above
                          mentioned matter”.

                          As directed by, NCTE-Hqrs letter dated 5.10.2010 was issued to the Registrar,
                          Directorate of Distance Education, Annamalai University and Dean, Directorate of
                          Distance Education, Annamalai University seeking information about number of
                          students enrolled in the above programme during the year 2008, 2009 and 2010 and
                          also about the no of students appeared and passed the examination during the said
                          years. But the university has not submitted reply so far.

                          The committee considered the matter in its 197th meeting held on 13th-14th October
                          2010 and decided to cause inspection under section 17 of NCTE.

                          Again a reminder was issued to the university on 01.11.2010. Inspection of the
                          institution was conducted on 21st-22nd November 2010.

                          The Committee considered the VT report of the institution, VCD and other related
                          documents along with the original file of the institution and decided to seek
                          clarification regarding:

                           No. of students who were conferred B.Ed degrees during the last three
                            convocations of the University, with documentary support.

                           Rationale and the need for appointment of 52 faculty for both regular and DE
                            programme vis-à-vis the number of sanctioned students as per the NCTE norms
                            (of course, giving allowance for research and other related work)

                                                     142

           (Gangadharaiah)                                                   (Prof. C. Thangamuthu)
         Regional Director, SRC, NCTE                                        Chairman, SRC, NCTE
                                                                                     th
                                                                                 198 Meeting of SRC
                                                                                th  h
                                                                              24 -26 November 2010

                  Details of study centre and No. of students attached to each of the study centres in
                   the following format.

                               Sl.No      Name and Address              No. of Students
                               1
                               2
                               3
                               4
                               5

                  No. of Full-time regular faculty working in B.Ed Distance Education exclusively
                   along with their qualifications/designation/experience.

                  Details of faculty attached to each study centre.

                  Infra-structural facilities available in each of the study centres of B.Ed programme
                   Viz Name and address, land area, Built up area, lab facilities, Library facilities etc.,

                  As per the norms, the study centres for B.Ed (Distance Education) are to be
                   located in the NCTE recognized B.Ed colleges only. But, from the documents
                   provided by the University, there is no evidence of adhering to the norms of NCTE.
                   B.Ed students seem to be attached to general study centres where all the other
                   programmes also are offered.

                  No data on B.Ed (Distance Education) uploaded in the University Website; as per
                   the NCTE norms/regulations.

                  all the data need to be uploaded in the University Website and the relevant part of
                   webs to be updated / functional always.

                  Exclusive Laboratory/library facilities for B.Ed (Distance Education students)
                   students.

                  Circumstances under which the representatives of different political parties were
                   presented to the VT members.

                  Details of Schools (Centrewise) used for teaching practice and brief account of
                   teaching practice sessions.

                  Details of contact programmes conducted in academic years 2008-09 & 2009-2010
                   at each centre, giving the dates, total no. of hours of contact and the no, of faculty
                   involved.




                                              143

  (Gangadharaiah)                                                       (Prof. C. Thangamuthu)
Regional Director, SRC, NCTE                                            Chairman, SRC, NCTE
                                                                                             th
                                                                                         198 Meeting of SRC
                                                                                        th  h
                                                                                      24 -26 November 2010

          CR to UCR

127.       SRCAPP80         Instituion has submitted profile of teaching staff but not approved by concerned
              M.Ed          affiliating University.
       Government College
       Teacher Education.   The Committee considered the matter and it was decided to serve Notice Under
       Kozhikode            Section 17 of NCTE Act for the following-

              KL             The institution has not submitted the certificate from the affiliating university
                              regarding the list of the approved teaching staff.

                            In view of the above, the Committee decided to issue Notice to the institution
                            and thereby providing an opportunity to the institution to make a written
                            representation within 30days from the date of issue of the Notice along with
                            necessary certificates/documents in order to take a final decision in the matter,
                            failing which action will be taken including the refusal and rejection of the
                            application based on the records available, with no further notice.

128.        APS09817
               B.Ed        The Committee considered the matter and it was decided to serve Notice Under
       Shantini      Ketan Section 17 of NCTE Act for the following deficiencies:-
       College          of
       Education, Theni      Marks sheets and service certificate of Principal are not submitted to
                              ascertain qualification and experience.
                TN
                             Marks sheets of lecturers not submitted to ascertain the qualification.

                             Original FDRs of Rs. 5 lakhs and Rs. 3 Lakhs in joint names not submitted.

                             The institution has to submit the certificate from the affiliating University for
                              the approval of faculty list.

                            In view of the above, the Committee decided to issue Notice to the institution
                            and thereby providing an opportunity to the institution to make a written
                            representation within 30days from the date of issue of the Notice along with
                            necessary certificates/documents in order to take a final decision in the matter,
                            failing which action will be taken including the refusal and rejection of
                            application based on the records available, with no further notice.




                                                        144

            (Gangadharaiah)                                                     (Prof. C. Thangamuthu)
          Regional Director, SRC, NCTE                                          Chairman, SRC, NCTE

				
DOCUMENT INFO
Shared By:
Categories:
Tags:
Stats:
views:221
posted:7/27/2011
language:English
pages:144