TSP Sco Xxxx_07 Iss88.qxd

Shared by: fdh56iuoui
Categories
Tags
-
Stats
views:
22
posted:
7/19/2011
language:
English
pages:
24
Document Sample
scope of work template
							                                                                             Winter 2009 Issue 17
                                                                             Scotland Edition
                                                                                          SS48881



The Member Magazine for Qualified Paralegal Practitioners




Graduations
                                                                              PLUS –
                                                                       The Big Interview:
                                                                         Instruct Us Now
                                                                       Margo MacDonald:
                                                           “An idea whose time has come”

                                  Specialist Paralegal Training Programmes
                                  developed, accredited and presented by:




   Society of Specialist Paralegals
                                                     Our Training Courses
                                                   Delivered in your Office
                                                          Legal & Management Training
                                                            - tailored to suit your needs


                                                                                               FESSIO
                                                                                              O




                                                                                                      N
                                                                                         PR




                                                                                                       AL
 Bespoke training courses                                                                 T
                                                                                              R
                                                                                                  AINING
 Innovative management solutions         suit you                                www.clt-scotland.co.uk
 CPD compliant                           Unique access to expert tutors


                                                                                  “In-house training
                                                                                  has the advantage of
       Delivering tailored training solutions at your premises                    being offered in a more
                                                                                  relaxed environment (the
                                                                                  trainer comes to you)
Topics presented in our Public courses delivered directly to you                  where there is a greater
                                                                                  opportunity to discuss
Course content from our current range of public courses and conferences can be    real issues in-depth. The
                                                                                  increased interaction

                                                                                  the audience.”
                                                                                 David Gourlay, Partner,
                                                                                 McClure
                                                                                 For more Naismith
                                                                                 information,
                                                                                 contact
                                                                                 “Easy to arrange,
                                                                                 tailored to suit our
                                                                                 Fiona Cassidy,
                                                                                 needs, course content
                                                                                 In-House Training
                                                                                 and speaker excellent,
                                                                                 Manager
                                                                                 enjoyed by all staff.”
Bespoke training
                                                                                 Caroline Galloway,
                                                                                 Telephone:
                                                                                 Consumer Rights
                                                                                 0141 225 6705

                                                                                 Email:
                                                                                 Ayrshire Council
                                                                                 fcassidy@centlaw.com

                                                                                 www.clt-scotland.co.uk
In this issue...
Regulars

4            Editorial
             Winter of discontent?

4-7          News
             The latest legal news from around the United Kingdom

9            Illegally Blonde
             Diary of The Specialist Paralegal’s girl about town!

10-11        The Lowdown
             Latest news, Society information and contact details at your fingertips

14           The Big Interview                                                                                    GRADUATIONS 12
             With Kimberly Fyffe and Instruct Us Now

15           Career Clinic
             Lisa McGill from Search Legal answers your burning career questions.

16-17        Coffee Break
             Kaite Welsh’s Year of Living Gracefully

18-21        Professional Update
             The Gay Divorcé
             The Cumulative Nil Rate Band – the Future?
             Debt Recovery in Turbulent Times

22           Forthcoming Courses
             Course calendar



Features

8            An idea whose time has come
             Margo MacDonald MSP on her End of Life Choices (Scotland) Bill

12-13        Autumn Graduations                               COVER
             Newly qualified paralegals speak




         “ The Rolls Royce of Qualifications -
                                                                                                                  COFFEE BREAK 16
      the best not only in the UK but in Europe”




                                                                                          Published by the Society of Specialist Paralegals
     CONTACT US:                                                                          5th Floor, 80 St Vincent Street, Glasgow, G2 5UB
                                                                                                      Telephone: 0141 225 6700
     EDITOR: Lisa-Marie Ferla
     lferla@centlaw.com
     0141 225 6706
                                                                                                     Designed and printed by
     THANK YOU TO ALL OF OUR CONTRIBUTORS                                                             In Position Media Ltd,
                                                                                              426 Drumoyne Road, Glasgow, G51 4DA
     For details of advertising rates, please contact Lisa-Marie Ferla on 0141 225 6700             Telephone: 0141 810 9000



                                                                                           The Specialist Paralegal Winter 2009               3
                editorial
                                            The winter of discontent?
                                            With a new year comes new                  hurdle passed, and safe in the           University of Strathclyde, at the
                                            challenges. In my own case, the            knowledge that I have – kind of –        tail-end of 2008. Our Professional
                                            biggest challenge comes in the form        stuck to my resolutions (including       Update section features a topical
                                            of an expanded role at work. In            my scheduled three visits to the gym     look at the work of the debt
                                            December 2008, I became Paralegal          this week) things can only get           recovery paralegal, as well as a
                                            Training Manager for the University        better.                                  Private Client update and an
                                            of Strathclyde and the University of         Of course, the ongoing economic        examination of the substantive law
                                            the West of England programmes.            downturn continues to shape the          behind the sensationalist headlines
                                              It’s a busy role, but one I am           news and I know that, for some,          as the first celebrity “gay divorce”
                                            looking forward to getting my teeth        optimism is in short supply at the       goes to court. We also have an
                                            into fully. What it will hopefully         moment. Getting the housing              exclusive interview with Margo
                                            mean for you, as readers of this           market moving again remains a top        MacDonald MSP on assisted suicide
                                            magazine, is more relevant,                priority for our legislators as we       – another topical area, and one in
                                            interesting content as my daily            move into 2009; and as a highly          which the politician hopes to clarify
                                            contact with paralegals from all           skilled, cost effective, emerging        the law. Ms MacDonald is an
                                            walks of life and at all stages of their   profession, Specialist Paralegals        inspirational figure, and I’d like to
                                            studies shapes the editorial content.      would seem ideally placed to lead        thank her for taking the time to
                                            I am, as always, readily contactable       the legal profession out of recession    speak to me at length.
                                            via email and by telephone, so             when the market ultimately reasserts       Resolutions aren’t just for January:
                                            please don’t hesitate to get in touch      itself.                                  for Kaite Welsh, 2009 will be “The
                                            if you have any news or suggestions          On that note, I’d like to welcome      Year of Living Gracefully”.
Lisa-Marie Ferla LLB (Hons) MSc             for inclusion.                             Lisa McGill of Search Legal              Improving your life and the lives of
                                              As I write this, the month of            onboard as our new careers advisor.      those around you needn’t cost the
Paralegal Training Manager                  January is reaching its dark, cold         Turn to Career Clinic on P15 for her     earth – find out how on P16.
Editor, The Specialist Paralegal            conclusion. The first month of the         first column, and feel free to send        I hope you enjoy this issue, and I
                                            year is traditionally a depressing         your burning career questions            look forward to speaking to you
                                            one: poor weather and a hard slog          through for inclusion in our next        over the next few months.
                                            until that first post-Christmas            issue.
                                            payday make dragging oneself out             Elsewhere in this issue, we speak
                                            of bed in the morning that little bit      to newly-qualified paralegals who
                                            more difficult. But with that first        graduated at the Barony Hall, the




news
crime and justice
                                                       The latest legal
                                                       news from around
                                                       the United Kindom

                                                                                       legal profession

Age of criminal                                                                        Paralegal launches
responsibility to rise                                                                 HR consultancy
Scottish Ministers are considering        avoided… I have no wish as a chief
raising the age of criminal               prosecutor in this country to
responsibility from eight to at least     criminalise children unnecessarily.”
12.                                         A government consultation on the
  They were responding to a call          issue will not end until March, but
from the UN Committee on the              ministers appear to be “minded” to
Rights of the Child to raise the age at   move towards an age of 12. They
which children can be prosecuted in       point out that there were only six
the courts to 14.                         prosecutions of under 12s in the past
  Ministers discussed the issue at        five years, and that the Children’s
their regular cabinet meeting, but it     Hearing system in Scotland was
has been confirmed that they ruled        working well in dealing with young
out going as high as the UN               offenders.
recommendation.                             Meanwhile, new figures show a 22
  Scotland has one of the lowest ages     percent rise in Probation Orders
of criminal responsibility in Europe.     incorporating unpaid work, as an             An Employment Law paralegal has          handbooks.
In England it is 10, while some           alternative to prison.                       established      her     own      HR       Sam said: “Obviously having
Scandinavian countries go as high as        At a workshop in Dunfermline               consultancy, aimed at helping small      another qualification on top of my
15.                                       where offenders carry out such work,         businesses      with     their    HR     CIPD displays my commitment to
  Holyrood ministers accept that the      Justice Minister Kenny MacAskill             requirements.                            continuing               professional
change is necessary to bring              said: “I’m pleased the courts are              Sam Mott MSSP, who qualified as        development          and      further
Scotland into line with other             imposing        more     community           a Specialist Paralegal in January last   demonstrates my competence to
countries in its treatment of children,   sentences, particularly requiring            year, has launched Essex-based           clients.
with the intention of offering young      those placed on probation to do              Flexible HR Ltd with her friend and        “It is testing times for employers
offenders      help    rather     than    unpaid work to benefit communities.          business partner, Suzanne Bolwell-       and to launch a new business, but
punishment.                                 “This Government is determined to          Davies.                                  with our determination we are
  Lord Advocate Elish Angiolini has       ensure that Scotland has a coherent            The company offers external HR         confident of succeeding.”
already said she believed eight was       penal policy for the long term – one         advice to clients without their own
too young for criminal prosecution,       that protects the public, reduces            HR department, on issues such as         I Flexible HR can be contacted by
telling the Justice Committee: “My        reoffending and thereby offending,           disciplinaries,           grievances,    email on flexiblehr@tiscali.co.uk, or
policies are quite clear – I do not       and so builds safer, stronger                recruitment,           redundancies,     visit their website:
prosecute children where it can be        communities for all our people.”             contracts of employment and              www.flexiblehrltd.co.uk.

 4   The Specialist Paralegal Winter 2009
legal profession                                                                 legal profession

New legal department Alternative Business
for Denholm Associates Structures proposals
Marketing recruitment agency            the legal and support services           Proposals for alternative business         legal practice pass a “fit to own” test
Denholm Associates has expanded         market sectors.”                         structures (ABS) for the legal             and comply with an appropriate code
into the legal sector, with the           Denholm Associates has long-           profession in Scotland have been           of conduct; and
acquisition of Beaumont Legal.          standing experience in marketing,        published for consultation by the          • The governance of the Law Society
  Michelle Beaumont, founder of         sales, financial services and business   Scottish Government.                       will be reviewed and the regulatory
Beaumont Legal, joins Denholm as        support recruitment.                       Some of the main proposals for           arrangements for the Faculty of
a Managing Consultant and brings          John      Denholm,        Managing     inclusion in the forthcoming Legal         Advocates clarified.
with her an extensive background in     Director of Denholm, added: “The         Profession Bill include:                     Justice Secretary Kenny MacAskill
paralegal      and     fee     earner   merge with Beaumont Legal will           • Reform of the regulatory framework       said: “This is a once-in-a-generation
recruitment.                            add a new dimension to the               for legal services, and the removal of     opportunity to create a more flexible
  Ms Beaumont, who established          Denholm offering in a field we’ve        restrictions on the types of business      and modern regulatory framework for
her own agency almost four years        never acted in before, but with          models under which a solicitor can         Scotland’s legal services.
ago, commented on the decision to       Michelle’s expertise and reputation      offer such services – while allowing the     “I believe the proposals published
join forces: “I knew immediately        we will really be enhancing our          traditional business model to remain an    today for consultation will help the
that as companies we would fit          level and scope of service offering.     option for those who choose to carry       profession to remain successful and
together well. We have the same         At Denholm, we are continuously          on practising within that structure;       innovative in the face of increased
consultative approach, where client     listening to the needs and               • Regulation of ABS to apply to any        competition and in the difficult
and     candidate     are     equally   requirements of our clients and          other form of business where a legal       economic climate that we are all
important, and I know that I am         strive to deliver the best candidates    professional is involved in the            currently going through.”
joining a team that has an              for any roles they have within our       provision of legal services to third
entrepreneurial approach.               expanding areas of specialism.”          parties;                                   I Wider choice and better protection –
  “The trust and credibility that has                                            • ABS to be regulated by an approved       a consultation paper on the regulation
to be built up in your own business     I Find out more about                    regulator, who will be authorised to do    of legal services in Scotland is open
is not something I would transfer       Denholm Associates at                    so by Scottish Ministers with the          for responses until 3rd April 2009.
lightly; this is a great opportunity    www.denholmassociates.com, or            agreement of the Lord President;           Find out more at
for the new, stronger, combined         contact Michelle Beaumont at             • Outside ownership will be permitted      www.scotland.gov.uk/
agency to really make a mark within     michelle@denholmassociates.com.          where those holding an interest in a       Consultations/Current.

environment                                                                      property

Eco-award for                                                                    New home report
Scottish Courts                                                                  system introduced
The Scottish Court Service has            “I would like to thank all who         Home reports are now mandatory             death of the Scottish property
become one of the first                 have been involved over the last         for most house sales in Scotland.          market.”
organizations in Scotland to be         two to three years in bringing             The reports – which include a              The SLAS had called for the
publicly recognised for tackling        about the reduction in carbon            detailed survey containing the             introduction to be delayed for two
climate change and reducing carbon      emissions which has led to this          condition, valuation and energy            years, arguing the policy should
emissions at an award ceremony          recognition.”                            efficiency of the house – are              not be implemented during the
held in Edinburgh.                        Meanwhile, Climate Change              intended to prevent buyers having          economic downturn because it
  Alan Stevenson, sustainable           Minister Stewart Stevenson said          to commission several surveys              could lead to more repossessions.
development manager for SCS,            Scotland will be at the “forefront”      before bidding on a property.                The Law Society of Scotland is to
collected the Carbon Trust              of global action on climate change,        However, critics said the move           push for an early review of Home
Standard award from Richard             as he set out the key components of      would be disastrous for an already         Reports. At a Special General
Wakeford,          the       Scottish   the Scottish Climate Change Bill.        turbulent housing market.                  Meeting in September 2008, more
Government’s director general for         The Government said that by              The reports will cost between            than 2,000 solicitors called for the
the environment.                        including international aviation         £300 and £800 each, and will have          scheme to be postponed in light of
  SCS is one of only eight Scottish     and shipping, emissions from all six     to be made available to anyone             the property market downturn – in
organizations to be certified to the    greenhouse gases, and annual             interested in purchasing a property.       addition to long-held concerns
standard – the world’s first carbon     targets, Scotland will have the most       England and Wales introduced             about the viability of the single
certification initiative that shows     ambitious Bill to tackle climate         their own version – Home                   survey.
organizations have measured,            change anywhere in the world.            Information Packs (HIPs) – last              Meanwhile,        the      Scottish
managed and genuinely reduced             The proposals would see an 80%         December.                                  Government has responded to
their carbon footprint year-on-year     reduction in the country’s                 The Scottish Government said             pressure to support homeowners
rather than merely off-setting          greenhouse gas emissions by 2050.        that both buyers and sellers would         facing eviction for mortgage
emissions.                                Campaigning group Stop Climate         benefit from the new system and            default, by funding more legal
  The Scottish Court Service has        Chaos Scotland hailed the bill as        claimed it would encourage more            advice and representation for
incorporated a range of energy and      potentially “the most significant for    first-time buyers into the property        people taken to court.
carbon       emission      reduction    a generation”, but said there was        market.                                      £3 million will be provided over
strategies,                including    room for improvement.                      However, the Conservatives and           the next two years to enhance
recommissioning presence-sensing          Mr Stevenson said: “Achieving          the Scottish Law Agents Society            services such as the in-court advice
controlled lighting to reduce           these targets will be challenging,       (SLAS) raised concerns that                service in the sheriff courts, as well
unnecessary energy expenditure,         but I am confident that                  lenders would not accept the               as services provided by local
and holding regular staff awareness     government, business and the             valuations given in the reports in         solicitors, advice agencies or
events such as “Switch It Off”          people of Scotland are ready to rise     the current falling market.                solicitors employed by the Scottish
weekends.                               to the challenge of climate                SLAS spokesman Ian Ferguson,             Legal Aid Board.
  Alan Stevenson said: “Achieving       change.”                                 who reported on the proposals at             The Government had been
this Carbon Trust Award is in part        The Scottish Government will           length in the last issue of this           criticised for not supporting
down to the hard work of a team of      now be developing a range of             magazine, told the BBC that he             householders to the same extent as
people within the Property Service      short, medium and long-term              expected the reports to become as          in England and Wales, where free
Unit at Hayweight House and the         policy options to drive the changes      unpopular as the Poll Tax.                 legal advice is available and a pre-
support,      co-operation       and    needed to meet the targets. These          He added: “Today is Black                action protocol lays down
assistance of all staff across the      options will be published later this     Monday. It’s the birth of home             procedures to be followed before
Scottish Court Service organisation.    year.                                    reports but, quite possibly, the           lenders resort to court action.

                                                                                                                        The Specialist Paralegal Winter 2009    5
                                                                                         technology & ip
                         news
licensing                                                                                New email laws
Licensing proposals                                                                      “an attack on rights”
come under fire                                                                          New laws which will force internet
                                                                                         service providers to keep details of
                                                                                         every email sent in the UK have
                                                                                                                                         The new rules are due to come into
                                                                                                                                       force on 15th March as part of a
                                                                                                                                       European Commission directive,
Scottish Government proposals for             difficult to implement and enforce,        been slammed by human rights                  and could cost the government
restrictions on the sale of alcohol           it says, “as there would appear to be      groups and internet service                   between £25m and £70m in ISP set-
have come under challenge in a                no consensus within the licensed           providers.                                    up costs. The directive already
submission from the Law Society of            trade as to where problems arise”.           From March, ISPs will by law have           applies to telephone companies,
Scotland.                                       The committee does support               to keep information about every               which routinely hold much of the
  In a response submitted to the              action to reduce the size of               email sent or received in the UK for          data for billing.
Government,        the      Society’s         standard measures, imrove labeling         a year.                                         The firms will have to store the
Licensing Subcommittee has                    and control advertising – especially         The Home Office insists that the            information and make it available to
challenged both the enforceability            when directed at young people.             data, which does not include the              any public body which makes a
and – in certain respects – the                 In a separate campaign, retailers        content of emails, is vital for crime         lawful request, which could include
legality of the measures announced.           are preparing to take the Scottish         and terror investigations.                    police, local councils and health
  The      committee       questions          Government to court over the                 Some three billion emails are               authorities.
whether minimum retail pricing per            proposed minimum pricing policy            thought to be sent each day in the              The Home Office said the data
unit of alcohol – one of the most             on alcohol sales.                          UK alone.                                     was a vital tool for investigation and
controversial aspects of the                    A retailing insider told the               Shami Chakrabarti, director of              intelligence gathering.
Government’s plans – is in fact a             Scotland on Sunday in November:            human rights watchdog Liberty, said             A spokesperson added: “It will
licensing matter, or one relating to          “The advice we have given is that          ISPs already kept the information on          allow investigators to identify
the “regulation of the sale and               these proposals are, at best, a grey       a voluntary basis.                            suspects, examine their contacts,
supply of good and services to                legal area and I would be                    However, she cautioned: “The                establish relationships between
consumers” – a reserved matter                anticipating a legal challenge as          thing we have to worry about is               conspirators and place them in a
under the Scotland Act.                       soon as the SNP announce their             what happens next because the                 specific location at a certain time.”
  The committee also questions the            final proposals early next year.”          government is already mooting                   Reports have suggested the
basis for the minimum figure of 35p             At the SNP’s annual conference in        plans not just to leave this stuff with       government has even bigger plans
per unit of alcohol put forward by            Perth, Kenny MacAskill made no             the providers but to create a central         for data retention in the works. The
the Government, and highlights                apologies for wanting to tackle            government database where they                Interception           Modernisation
the problems likely to arise in               Scotland’s alcohol problem.                hold all the information.                     Programme could involve one
checking whether it is being                    He said: “We make no apology as            “I’m afraid we just don’t trust any         central database, gathering details
properly applied – especially to              a government for seeking to tackle         government or any organisation to             on every text sent, email sent,
mixed drinks.                                 this most major of social issues in        keep that much very sensitive                 phonecall made and website visited.
  The         proposed        “social         our lives. If it causes some               information about us all and to keep          Consultation on the plans is due to
responsibility fee” would also be             controversy – so be it.”                   it safe.”                                     begin later this year.




news in brief
 SOCIETY ELECTIONS                            force on 1st January 2005 and provides a   in Scotland. Principal solicitor Mike        FISCAL POWER
   The President and Vice President of        statutory right of access to information   Dailly said that work was already              Moves to hand full financial powers to
 the Law Society of Scotland for 2009/10      held by Scottish public authorities.       underway to tackle the area’s housing        the Scottish Parliament have been ruled
 have been elected by members of the                                                     problems.                                    out by the body considering reforms to
 body’s ruling Council. Ian Smart, current                                                                                            devolution. The Calman Commission
 Vice President, was elected President        SMOKED OUT                                                                              said giving Scotland full fiscal autonomy
 from May 2009 and Jamie Millar, current        The Scottish Government is to crack      MANDATORY FAIs                               would be inconsistent with the United
 Treasurer and a partner with Brodies in      down on the use of cigarette vending         Fatal accident inquiries could become      Kingdom. A number of areas have been
 Glasgow, will take the position of Vice      machines by under 18s, it has been         mandatory in more cases and their            flagged up for further consideration by
 President from that date. Mr Smart said:     confirmed. Legislation to be introduced    recommendations legally binding,             the Commission, including whether
 “It is exciting to be able to carry on the   later this year will include further       following a review by one of Scotland’s      issues including broadcasting, firearms,
 valuable work started by Richard             controls on the sale of tobacco from the   most senior legal figures. Former Lord       energy policy and the misuse of drugs
 Henderson, particularly during the           machines to restrict access by minors.     President Lord Cullen of Whitekirk KT        should be overseen by Westminster or
 Society’s 60th anniversary year.”            Tobacco manufacturers have said there      has announced the start of a                 Holyrood. Full findings will be published
                                              is no need for an outright ban on the      consultation as part of his Review of
                                              machines. The legal age for buying                                                      later this year.
                                                                                         Fatal Accident Inquiry Legislation. Lord
 INFORMATION                                  cigarettes in Scotland was raised from     Cullen will make his recommendations
                                              16 to 18 a year ago.                       later in 2009.
 EXTENSION
   The Scottish Government has issued a                                                  REGISTERED
 discussion paper proposing extending         GOVANHILL CENTRE                                                                        DISABLED PARKING
 the Freedom of Information (Scotland)          A new law centre offering free legal     PARALEGALS                                     Planned laws which would see people
 Act to more organisations. It proposes       advice to one of the poorest areas of        Discussions are still underway to          fined for wrongly parking in disabled
 covering contractors who provide             Glasgow has opened. The Govanhill Law      create a “Registered Paralegal” status in    bays has moved closer to reality. The
 services that are a public authority         Centre aims to work with the local         Scotland. The Law Society said the           plans, brought forward in a bill by
 function, registered social landlords and    community to root out slum landlords,      plans, mooted last year, had been            Labour MSP Jackie Baillie, were given
 local authority trusts or bodies. Minister   gangmasters and organised criminals.       affected by the economic uncertainty of      the go-ahead in principle from
 for Parliamentary Business Bruce             Govanhill has some of the most severe      the past few months but that it remained     Holyrood’s Local Government Committee
 Crawford has also announced that the         housing problems in the UK, with an        fully committed to the project and will      – although MSPs on the committee
 Government would be pro-actively             estimated 750 slum flats, and has an       review the situation in April jointly with   questioned the cost and timescale.
 publishing Ministerial car travel and        ethnically diverse population with the     the Scottish Paralegal Association. A        Currently, 85% of disabled parking bays
 diary information. The Act came into         biggest concentration of Roma families     new launch date will also be considered.     are not legally enforceable.


 6   The Specialist Paralegal Winter 2009
crime and justice
                                                                                                                      legal profession
New focus on                                                                                  Soul sistah Caroline
domestic abuse cases                                                                         An Edinburgh-based paralegal
                                                                                             enjoys a secret life behind the mic
A specialist domestic abuse court            acceptable and neither should                   as frontwoman for a soul covers
established in Glasgow should                domestic abuse. Tackling this                   band.
expand citywide in 2009.                     unacceptable behaviour – and that                 Caroline Roberts may use her
  Offenders from the south side,             is what it is – will always be a                debt recovery qualification for
city centre and west of Glasgow              priority for the Force.”                        Edinburgh City Council by day,
have been referred to the court                Strathclyde Police responded to               but by night she’s a soul diva for
since its launch in 2004,                    24,197 domestic incidents between               five-piece Soulussion.
established within the Glasgow               April 2007 and March 2008 –                       Formed in 2007, Soulussion
Sheriff Court to ensure a consistent         equating to one every 22 minutes.               describe themselves as “a mixture
approach.                                      Scotland’s Chief Statistician                 of disco, soul and funk with a wee
  All cases referred to the court are        recorded almost 50,000 incidents                splat of ‘you’d never expect them
assigned a date within six weeks of          of domestic abuse for the year                  to play that’ flung in for good            soulful voice – particularly during
being called to trial, and the vast          2007-08. Half of the incidents                  measure.        The       Specialist       a slowed-down and heartbreaking
majority of the accused plead                recorded led to the recording of a              Paralegal’s     top     team     of        version of Bob Dylan’s “Knockin’
guilty before or during the trial.           crime or offence, most commonly                 entertainment experts – also               On Heaven’s Door”.
  Scotland’s largest police force,           minor assault or breach of the                  known as its editor in music                 All in all, a top night out from
Strathclyde Police, has also set up a        peace.                                          blogging mode – were suitably              the self-proclaimed “soulussion to
specialist unit aimed at tackling              The Scottish Government has                   rocked at the band’s Halloween             all your problems!”
domestic abuse in the latest phase           announced funding of nearly                     show in Edinburgh.                           Soulussion are available to play
of     its   “Campaign       Against         £44million to address violence                    Although happy to play plenty            functions, nightclubs, weddings
Violence”.                                   against women and domestic abuse                of the “pub standards” – albeit            and corporate events, playing
  Chief Constable Stephen House              – more than double the investment               exceptionally well, and with a side        songs by Aretha Franklin, Otis
has appointed a domestic abuse co-           made between 2005-08.                           order of extra Stevie Wonder for           Redding, Wilson Pickett, Stevie
ordinator to oversee and support               A spokesman said: “Domestic                   good measure – Soulussion set              Wonder, Eddie Floyd, Sam
the force’s response to such                 abuse must not be tolerated in any              themselves apart from the typical          Cooke and more. They can also
incidents, who will head up a                form. We know the effects of                    pub covers band with a set that is         provide The Soul Time Disco to
specialist task force of sixteen             domestic abuse can be devastating,              anything but predictable. The              make your night complete. Call
centrally located officers.                  including on children and young                 band overall are tight and                 Cazz for further details on 07796
  He said: “Quite simply, domestic           people, and we are determined to                professional, and an excellent             393907, or listen to some tracks
abuse is violent crime in a domestic         tackle it – wherever and whenever               showcase for Caroline’s rich,              at www.myspace.com/soulussion.
context. Violent crime is not                it occurs.”




   l ow e r in g th e b a r
    The lighter side of the legal profession…
    Facebook suit                                            and medical laboratory technicians and above             forcing noise ordinance violators to sit in a room and
    Social networking site Facebook has been used to         computer programmers.                                    listen to music they don’t like has cut down on
    serve legal documents for what is believed to be the       Federal judges were ranked at 69th on the list,        repeat offenders – many of whom are teenagers
    first time. An Australian lawyer used the social         with lawyers way down the rankings at number 82.         whose parents ended up having to pay the fines they
    networking site to serve documents on a couple who         Lawyers and stockbrokers (84) both did so poorly       incurred from playing their music too loud.
    had defaulted on their $150,000 mortgage, and now        – and the reason, the lists editors say, is stress.
    a Supreme Court Judge in the Australia Capital           “Attorneys and stockbrokers may earn considerably        “Ebay barrister” jailed
    Territory (ACT) has ruled that the notice was            more than bookbinders or telephone repair                A man who posed as a barrister at a series of court
    binding.                                                 technicians, but these high-powered careers are          hearings after buying his robes and wig on eBay has
       Mark MacCormack, of Canberra law firm Meyer           hurt by anxiety, as both rank among the 20 most          been jailed for two years. Ian Clegg, described as
    Vandenberg, had been unable to find Carmel Corbo         stressful jobs on our list.”                             “very aggressive” on behalf of his clients, pretended
    and Gordon Poyser through traditional methods –            The top ten, ranked by combining income (and           to have set up his own law chambers and boasted to
    but managed to track them down on Facebook using         growth potential), stress, environment, employment       clients of “having enough qualifications to run rings
    the details they had provided on their mortgage          outlook and physical demands, were as follows:           around” their opponents. In reality, he was a
    application.                                                                                                      convicted fraudster whose training consisted of one
       However, it took some explaining before Supreme        Mathematician                                           year of a law degree at Teesside University. Staff at
    Court judge Master David Harper allowed papers to         Actuary                                                 the magistrates’ court in Guisborough, North
    be served through the site’s private messaging            Statistician                                            Yorkshire, became suspicious because Clegg did not
    system – as he didn’t have a Facebook account and         Biologist                                               seem to know court procedure.
    needed the site explained to him.                         Software engineer
       In more Facebook news, a juror who posted details      Computer systems analyst                                Bumper fines for national plates
    of a trial on the social networking site was lucky to     Historian                                               Motorists who display national flags on their
    escape prosecution. The woman was thrown off the          Sociologist                                             number plates are breaking the law and could face a
    jury after conducting a poll among her friends to see     Industrial designer                                     £60 fine, it has emerged. Thousands of motorists
    “which way she should go”. In the interests of a fair     Accountant                                              who choose to display the Saltire, cross of St
    trial, British jurors are forbidden from discussing                                                               George, Welsh dragon or even the Union flag could
    details of a case with even their closest family           And at the bottom of the rankings? Lumberjack,         be unwittingly breaking the law. Transport Minister
    members.                                                 taxi driver, seaman and dairy farmer.                    Jim Fitzpatrick told Westminster MPs that the only
                                                                                                                      symbol legally allowed on a licence plate is the EU
    Paralegal jobs “better than lawyers”                     Her name was Lola…                                       flag of 12 stars on a blue background, as per
    A US survey has vindicated the career aspirations of     A Colorado judge has come up with a novel                regulations that came into force in 2001. Bob Spink
    many paralegals, after citing the role as the best job   punishment for noise polluters – giving them a taste     of UK Independence Party raised the parliamentary
    in the legal profession. New job website                 of their own medicine in the form of the greatest hits   question after being contacted by drivers who had
    CareerCast.com ranked paralegal assistant as the         of Barry Manilow and Barney the Purple Dinosaur.         been hit with the fines. “No-one believed it,” he
    17th most desirable job – just below meteorologists      Judge Paul Sacco of Fort Lupton, Colorado, says that     said. “This is outrageous.”

                                                                                                                                    The Specialist Paralegal Winter 2009       7
An idea whose
time has come
                In the wake of several headline-grabbing cases, Margo MacDonald MSP
                talks to The Specialist Paralegal about her End of Life Choices Bill.

The old saying may tell us that              Safeguards                                that if things get too intolerable you   control over their own lives, that
nothing in life is certain but death           Scotland, of course, has a separate     can go to a doctor who knows you,        total dependency on other people
and taxes, but as a nation we Brits          criminal legal system to the rest of      knows your history and will take you     with no hope of that ever
don’t like to talk about that final          the UK, but recent news coverage          seriously.”                              mitigating,” she says. “And it’s not a
inevitability. Indeed many of us             has kickstarted the debate both             Basing her legislation on the          temporary thing; it’s not something
haven’t even made a will, let alone          north and south of the border and         autonomy of the individual, she is       that people go into a huff or a mood
considered the circumstances in              responses to the consultation aren’t      very clear that the capacity of that     about. And I’ve anticipated that this
which we might meet our end.                 limited to Scotland. “I’m going for       individual to make the decision to       might happen to me.”
   Despite this, even the most casual        physician assisted, not named person      end his or her own life be carefully       She does not shy away from the
observer couldn’t have helped but            assisted as in Debbie Purdy’s case,”      examined. It is clear that being able    passionate and vocal arguments
notice the number of stories in the          Ms McDonald says when asked how           to deal with a doctor who knows the      against the legalisation of physician
national press towards the end of            she would see the two jurisdictions       patient’s medical history has its        assisted suicide, but admits that she
2008 which raised legal and moral                                                                                               “doesn’t get” the so-called ‘slippery
questions about terminal illness and                                                                                            slope’ argument. “My bill all depends
the end of life. In September, 23-                                                                                              on autonomy – without the person
year-old Daniel James died at the                   The reason why this is such a challenging piece                             being able to say that they want to
Dignitas clinic in Switzerland after a            of legislation is that it is absolutely at the interface                      miss this last part out, it can’t work,”
rugby accident left him paralysed;                                                                                              she says. “Under my legislation, the
and in October, MS sufferer Debbie                         of public policy and private morality                                patient would have to in all cases
Purdy lost her High Court battle to                                                                                             activate the process, which is
clarify the law which could                                                                                                     arguably more protection than we
potentially see her husband jailed           interact should she ultimately be         advantages in this respect. “If you      currently have. Nobody could say
for fourteen years if he was to “assist”     successful. “I don’t know what the        are someone who has a mental             ‘we’ll just dehydrate and starve him,
her suicide by helping her make the          consultation will say though, and I’d     illness or depression, the doctor        just let him slip away…’
same journey. Meanwhile, Prime               be quite interested to find out if        dealing with you would have to             “The reason why this is such a
Minister Gordon Brown has publicly           there are people who would prefer it      know that you had the capability to      challenging piece of legislation is
stated that he is opposed to passing         to be named person.                       make that decision,” Ms MacDonald        that it is absolutely at the interface of
legislation that could “put pressure            “I suspect that, here in Scotland,     explains. “In that case, it would show   public policy and private morality.
on people to end their lives”.               people prefer the idea of doctors if      up in the patient’s record if the        But if a society can consider that sort
   For Scottish politician Margo             there are a sufficient number who are     doctor didn’t adhere to the              of thing calmly, and clearly, it’s good
MacDonald, however, the questions            willing, and suitable. But no doctor      appropriate guidelines that a            for them to grow.”
raised aren’t ones of public morals          can be forced, and not every doctor       psychiatrist has to be called in.          And perhaps now is the time for
but rather private autonomy. Last            will be suitable – and the possibility      “You have a duty of care towards       society to begin to ask these
year Ms MacDonald, 65, who suffers           of a register is something that I think   that person, to make sure that you at    questions. A close friend of Cardinal
from Parkinson’s disease, launched a         I’ll find out as I go through the         least give them the chance to try to     Keith O’Brien, head of the Catholic
consultation on a private members’           consultation process and speak with       tackle depression or mental illness.     Church in Scotland, who she
bill which she hopes will get her            different groups of doctors.”             But if at the end of it they still say   interviewed for the Panorama
colleagues debating some difficult              Although most of the details will      ‘no, I’ve had enough’ – and it is them   programme, Ms MacDonald has
questions.                                   be shaped as the consultation             that is saying ‘no’, and not a           stipulated that she has no intention
   “This consultation document is            process gets underway, Ms                 depressive illness – then they have      of attempting to change the minds of
really to let everyone see what I’m          McDonald has clearly given plenty         the same rights as anybody else.”        those whose belief systems preclude
proposing,         what      I’m     still   of thought to how the scheme will           Clearly not one to shy away from       the termination of life before its
questioning, what I’ve found out –           work in practice and what safeguards      difficult questions about the scheme,    natural end.
it’s to set the scene,” she explains. “At    will immediately be necessary.            Ms MacDonald also brings up the            “Why now?” she asks. “I think more
the end of the consultation period, I        “Regardless of the actual system we       subject of some kind of lower age        of us are living longer, and modern
will ask MSPs if they think the              end up with – whether it’s like in        limit bearing in mind the recent         news coverage has made people
contents of the proposal are worthy          Oregon where you are given a              decision allowing thirteen-year-old      more aware. And perhaps there is a
of debate – and I believe they have          prescription and the doctor stands        Hannah Jones, of Hereford, to refuse     metaphysical reason – perhaps the
to be debated.                               back, or whether it’s like in the         a potentially life-saving heart          time is now right. It’s possible that
   “I think by that time they will have      Netherlands, where the doctor             transplant. “I don’t feel that it        this is an idea that’s time has come.”
had so much communication from               might actually administer a fatal         diminishes the argument to discuss         And with a recent YouGov survey
their own constituents that a lot of         injection because you’ve asked for it     these things,” she says. “There’s no     in the Sunday Times showing that
them will agree to the debate, even          – a very small number of people           perfect, one size fits all approach,     more than two-thirds (69%) of 2,000
if they don’t agree with the                 ultimately ask for this,” she explains.   although ultimately one law has to       respondents supporting a change in
proposal.”                                   “While a higher propensity towards        apply       to    everybody.       The   the law on assisted suicide, perhaps
   Assuming that she gets the backing        a progressive condition – for             refinements, and how that law is         she is right.
of the eighteen MSPs needed to               example, a high concentration of MS       applied, will be difficult.”
draft a Bill, Ms MacDonald predicts          sufferers – might skew the figures                                                 I The proposed End of Life Choices
that the debate will continue until at       slightly, it won’t be in any way that     Loss of control                          (Scotland) Bill is open for consultation
least the end of this year. “During          can’t be explained.                         Late last year, Ms MacDonald           until 9th March 2009. Find out more at
that time I imagine it won’t be the             “Every patient has a record, and       fronted a Panorama programme for         www.scottish.parliament.uk/s3/bills/
frenzy it has been this last year, but       ultimately this will be another           the BBC on assisted suicide in which     MembersBills/index.htm
there will be other cases – of that I’m      record. I think people will eventually    she spoke to campaigners, sufferers,
absolutely sure,” she says. “So I think      realise that the main benefit to be       religious figures – and those left       Do you have any comments on this
the topic is not going to go away            derived from this proposed                behind after a family member had         article? Please send them through to
and we do have to, at the very least,        legislation for sufferers of a            committed suicide. “With everybody       specialist_paralegal_magazine
work out what our attitudes are and          progressive condition like mine is        I’ve spoken to, it’s not the pain that   @centlaw.com, and we will publish a
clarify the law.”                            that you have an insurance policy, so     they mention first – it’s the loss of    selection in our next edition.

 8    The Specialist Paralegal Winter 2009
                                                                                                                                                                    Image by Lyndsay Meager Sann www.lyndsaymeager.com
Illegally Blonde
Diary of The Specialist Paralegal’s girl about town!


Dear Diary,
Another year, another diet. After abusing my               she seems like a nice girl. When they are in his         Hubbie also came up trumps on the present
body over the festive period it was back to bread          room I can be found scurrying about upstairs in        front. It was the first time he had bought me
and water only. But at the first sign of stress – i.e.     the other rooms making as much noise as possible       something which I hadn’t had to take back or
first day back at work – I was back on the                 – just in case they are doing something they           which he hadn’t bought me previously. I had told
chocolates.                                                shouldn’t.                                             him not to buy me anything but he did. He is
  I must admit I was glad to get back to work after          However, she won her way into my heart when          learning fast.
the festive frolics but am missing one of my close         she bought me some chocolates for Christmas.             His favourite gift to me was a Still Game DVD
working colleagues who has started her battle to           She can’t be all that bad.                             – it must be as he has never stopped watching it!
fight cancer. She is a tough gal and has the right           My other son has just turned 14 and is doing           We have also been busy on the Wills and
mental attitude, but still it is a difficult time and I    well at school – particularly physics. His father is   Executries front as a number of our clients have
wish her a speedy recovery only to return to work          not very technically minded, so you know where         regretfully passed away in the early part of the
quickly and resume her title of “senior member” in         he gets the brains from.                               year. It certainly brings the worst out from some
our wee department!                                          My youngest is now taller than me, which             family members who are too eager to get their
  I have also taken up power walking, sometimes            means I am officially the smallest person in our       hands on some money – one family member
via the chip shop, in a bid to shed the pounds             family. Apart from my husband after I tell him off.    phoned to advise of his dad’s passing away nine
with my friend June. It’s a great way to lose                I have been thinking of getting a dog to replace     hours previously when he still hadn’t been
weight and we can also have a great laugh as well.         our pet cocker spaniel Isla, who died last year, but   pronounced dead.
And I don’t feel so guilty when I have a refreshing        the cat and dog home only seem to have                   It made me realise that this is one business
glass of wine (or two) afterwards.                         unwanted rottweilers. My husband says we               which always does well – in good times and bad
  My oldest son dropped a bombshell at the end             already have one in the house – me.                    times.
of last year. It is the moment all mums dread with           I had my father over on Christmas Day for his          The recession is now making people think
their sons: I have been replaced in his affections.        lunch, who is on his own – another reminder that       about their futures and more and more are making
He has a steady girlfriend.                                my dear mother passed away three years ago and         wills – are you?
  She comes up on a Sunday and they disappear              never a day goes by when I don’t think about her.
for hours on end to his bedroom to help her with           Christmas is a difficult time of year, but everyone    I Illegally Blonde is the pseudonym of a Wills,
her homework – or that is what he tells me. But            rallied around to make it a great day.                 Trusts and Executries-qualified paralegal.




                                      60 second interview
  with Legally Blonde – a high flying lawyer who also loves to cook to impress!
                                             Illegally Blonde: Okay, firstly I         mind. Then again, Hugh Jackman          Legally Blonde: Mmm… who
                                             have to confess to being addicted to      could pull me with one of his           could we have as dinner guests?
                                             Masterchef, and hope one day not          spectacular claws.                      Don’t know about you but I’m
                                             only to attract John Torode’s                                                     having Hugh, Bruce and John just to
                                             (Johnny to me) affections but also to     Illegally Blonde: What about the        make you jealous!
                                             offer new culinary delights to my         two of us applying to appear on
                                             family. And as you know, working          Saturday Kitchen? James Martin…         Illegally Blonde: I’ll do the dishes!
                                             with me at the moment, once I get         yum! Food heaven!                       Who would be your ideal dinner
                                             my teeth into something I’m like a                                                companion – apart from myself and
                                             Rottweiler and won’t let go! Who or       Legally Blonde: More like food          Mr Torode (don’t tell my long-
                                             what have you got your eye on when        hell – what about gorgeous bald         suffering hubbie about my “other
                                             you are watching Masterchef?              Simon Rimmer from Something for         man”)!
                                                                                       the Weekend??!                          Legally Blonde: Easy – my wee
                                             Legally Blonde: Woof woof, don’t                                                  boy. Easy to cook for, loveable,
                                             I know all too well about you and         Illegally Blonde: Okay, what            cuddly and appreciates good home
                                             your Rottweiler traits! But you force     about Come Dine With Me? That           cooking – even the brussell sprouts
                                             me to watch Masterchef not only by        would be easy for me – I would go to    found hiding under his plate!
                                             texting me to remind me but making        good old M&S and pick up a couple
                                             me sit through another episode            of those “two can dine for a tenner”    Illegally Blonde: Would you cook
                                             during my lunch on the BBC’s not so       meals, and hope not to be caught!       or go out? I once bought a curry deal
                                             friendly iPlayer! So in a nutshell John   Last time we had friends over for       from Asda and put everything into
                                             T and Greg W do nothing for me.           dinner, I made lasagne but during the   saucepans so I could pretend I had
                                                                                       cooking I couldn’t get my bolognaise    cooked it myself.
                                             Illegally Blonde: Okay, so John’s         sauce to thicken so thinking on my      Legally Blonde: Oh, I’d stay in!
                                             not your cup of tea – who is?             feet I added All Bran. Meal was great
                                                                                       – it was next day when friends          Illegally Blonde: So roll on
                                             Legally Blonde: Give me strength          started to query what they had          Masterchef and let’s hope I can
                                             to think – mmm, Gordon Ramsay,            eaten; Andrex was rapidly running       persuade a home visit from John…
                                             but if Bruce Springsteen was a chef       out! M&S is definitely the safer        “cooking doesn’t get tougher than
                                             then I may just have to change my         option.                                 this”.

                                                                                                                           The Specialist Paralegal Winter 2009     9
                                                                                                                LATEST NEWS, SOCIETY INFORMATION AND
                                                                                                                   CONTACT DETAILS AT YOUR FINGERTIPS


In this section, we plan to bring you the latest news
from CLT and the Universities, as well as providing you
with a handy reference for all things Society of Specialist         Dual qualify with Specialist                 Fellowship Status and CPD
                                                                    Paralegal Practitioner                         Some of you will be nearing the end of your
Paralegals and a peek at the latest happenings south of             Qualifications in association                CPD year which, for paralegals, runs
the border. Got any ideas for this section? Let us know             with the University of the West              concurrently with your year of membership. We
at specialist_paralegal_magazine@centlaw.com                        of England                                   have a great range of courses to fill out those
                                                                      In addition to the University of           outstanding hours, and remember – Society of
                                                                    Strathclyde programme, CLT has an            Specialist Paralegals members are entitled to
Book now!                                                           established range of Specialist              substantial discounts across a wide range of legal
  Bookings are now being taken for the Specialist     Paralegal Practitioner Qualifications south of the         update conferences and seminars! For more
Paralegal Practitioner Programme, providing the       border in association with the University of the           details, and a full timetable, visit our website at
legal secretary/paralegal or support staff with an    West of England, Bristol. The Law Faculty at               http://www.clt-scotland.co.uk.
in-depth understanding of their chosen area of        UWE is one of the UK's largest, and has been                 In the ever-changing world of the legal
law, together with a recognisable academic            engaged in the delivery of quality education since         profession, it is of vital importance that
qualification from the University of Strathclyde.     1969. It currently holds one of then highest               professionals keep up to date with the latest
The University was recently awarded 5A in the         research ratings for Law in the “new” university           developments and continually add to their skills
recent UK Research Assessment Exercise (RAE).         sector and has been rated “excellent for its               and knowledge. It is for this reason that we
This is the highest rating awarded to any Law         teaching” by the Higher Education Funding                  recommend that all Members of the Society of
School in Scotland and, in effect, means that         Council for England.                                       Specialist Paralegals undertake CPD amounting
Strathclyde Law School in rated ninth equal (out        Undertaking an additional Specialist Paralegal           to at least ten hours per annum.
of 60) Law Schools in the UK.                         Practitioner Qualification with UWE will enable              All Members of the Society of Specialist
  A Specialist Paralegal Practitioner Qualification   paralegals to “dual qualify”, giving them a unique         Paralegals are issued with a CPD record card at
from the University of Strathclyde is the most        perspective into the distinctive legal system south        the start of each membership year. We would
established, rigorous and cost-effective method       of the border. With many Scottish firms merging            urge members to fill these out accurately and
to meet the academic element required under the       with or expanding their operations into England            return them promptly at the end of each
“competency map” which will form part of the          and Wales, or developing a UK-wide client base,            membership year to the address shown on the
new Law Society of Scotland Registered Paralegal      dual qualification is an excellent way to develop          card.
scheme.                                               your career.                                                 In addition, two years of membership including
  The next intake of face to face tutorial courses             25% off all Specialist Paralegal                  the completion of CPD entitles a member to
will commence in April 2009. Please contact the                 Qualifications – book NOW!                       Fellowship Status and the use of the letters FSSP
Paralegal Training Department for further                                                                        after their name. Fellowship Status is conferred
information.                                          I For more information, or to book, please contact         automatically in the third year of membership
  Specialist Paralegal Practitioner Qualifications    Daniel Byrne, Paralegal Training Administrator, on 0141    providing all outstanding CPD cards have been
are also delivered by home study, enabling            225 6700 or via email at englishparalegal@centlaw.com.     returned. Please contact The Membership
delegates to combine the programme with other                                                                    Manager on 0141 225 6700 or via email at
commitments such as work or family. The home          Graduations                                                enquiries@specialistparalegals.co.uk for further
study course runs continuously throughout the           The next Specialist Paralegal Practitioner               information.
year, with a maximum of eighteen months given         Graduation ceremony will take place at the
to complete the course. Examination is by way of      Barony Hall, the University of Strathclyde in              Intimations
continuous assessments, followed by a final           Spring 2009, date TBC. Please contact the                    Please send us your announcements for our
written examination.                                  Paralegal Training Department for further                  intimations column and news section! Births,
  On successful completion of the course,             information.                                               marriages, promotions, new projects – drop us a
students will be awarded a Specialist Paralegal                                                                  couple of lines, and a photograph if possible, to
Practitioner Award at a graduation ceremony held      Website                                                    specialist_paralegal_magazine@centlaw.com.
at the University of Strathclyde, Glasgow.              Have you visited the Society of Specialist               Remember The Specialist Paralegal is your
Graduates of the programme will also be eligible      Paralegals' website recently?                              magazine, and we are always interested to hear
for full membership of the Society of Specialist      http://www.specialistparalegals.co.uk                      about what our members are up to.
Paralegals, and will be entitled to use the             The website is regularly updated with the latest
designation MSSP after their name in recognition      vacancies from some of Scotland's biggest legal              We are, of course, always looking for your
of their professional status.                         recruiters, and new content is being added all the         letters to the editor, whether on an issue you have
         25% off all Specialist Paralegal             time. Our members-only area contains links to              read about in this publication or something of
          Qualifications – book NOW!                  breaking news stories and details on forthcoming           wider legal interest, on working life or anything
                                                      courses, and you can even access back issues of            that takes your fancy – get it off your chest! We're
I For more information, or to book, please contact    The Specialist Paralegal magazine in electronic            keen to receive the latest news from your firm or
Daniel Byrne, Paralegal Training Administrator,       format! If you have misplaced your login details,          employer as well – don't worry about journalistic
on 0141 225 6700 or via email at                      please contact The Society of Specialist Paralegals        style, just get in touch with a few brief details and
scottishparalegal@centlaw.com.                        via email on enquiries@specialistparalegals.co.uk.         we'll do the rest.


  CONTACT US
  The general email addresses for enquiries regarding the                           In addition, delegates are reminded that the general
  Paralegal Practitioner Programmes are:                                            email inbox for enquiries relating to CLT courses is
                                                                                    scotenquiries@centlaw.com
  Scottish Paralegal Practitioner/
  University of Strathclyde Qualifications:                                         For enquiries relating to your membership of the
  scottishparalegal@centlaw.com                                                     Society of Specialist Paralegals, please contact:
  English Paralegal Practitioner/UWE Qualifications:                                Gary Anderson, Membership Manager
  englishparalegal@centlaw.com                                                      enquiries@specialistparalegals.co.uk
                                                                                    or 0141 225 6700.
  The Paralegal Training Department can be contacted by
  telephone on 0141 225 6700. Please contact Daniel Byrne                           The Society of Specialist Paralegals website is located at
  (Administrator) or Lisa-Marie Ferla (Manager).                                    http://www.specialistparalegals.co.uk

10   The Specialist Paralegal Winter 2009
                                                                                       Not yet a
                                                                                       member?
                                                                                       The Society of Specialist Paralegals is the alumni association for
                                                                                       the over 4,000 graduates of the Specialist Paralegal Practitioner
                                                                                       Programme – the only UK qualification backed by a prestigious
                                                                                       university. It aims to create a UK-wide network of University of
                                                                                       Strathclyde/University of the West of England alumi while
                                                                                       promoting the status of qualified Paralegal Practitioners.
                                                                                       Members are entitled to use the letters MSSP after their
                                                                                       names, to distinguish themselves as holders of a prestigious
                                                                                       academic qualification from a leading law school.




BENEFITS OF MEMBERSHIP
Current membership benefits include:

•    Professional recognition, with the right to use the letters MSSP (Member of the Society of Specialist Paralegals) after your name.
•    Fellowship status, attainable after two years’ membership or more.
•    Substantially reduced rates available to Society members across a wide range of CLT conferences and seminars.
•    A dedicated website, currently undergoing expansion and which will contain a discussion forum, online bulletins and a recruitment section as
     well as details of current CPD courses.
•    Your quarterly glossy magazine – the only way to guarantee your copy is as a Society of Specialist Paralegals member.

Membership runs annually for one year from the date of joining, for an annual subscription fee of £50.
                                                                                                                                                                                            Ê

    Name:
                                                                     APPLICATION FOR MEMBERSHIP
                                                                     The Society of Specialist Paralegals complies with the Data Protection Act in collecting and
                                                                     processing personal data held fairly and storing it securely. By signing this form, I agree to my
    Home address:                                                    details being held by the Society and its founding organisation, Central Law Training, for the
                                                                     purposes of organising and running the Society, of keeping its members informed of Society
                                                                     and related activities and matters of professional interest, and of obtaining feedback from
                                                                     members on relevant activities and interests.

    Home telephone:
                                                                     J      I am happy to receive information from organisations and companies which the
                                                                            Society believes would be of legitimate interest to members of the Society.
    Employer:
    Work address:
                                                                     J      I enclose a cheque for £50 made out to the Society of Specialist Paralegals
                                                                            for one year’s membership of the Society.




    Work telephone:                                                  Signed . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . .

    Contact email:
                                                                     Date . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . .
    Mailing preference: HOME/WORK

    When did you qualify?
                                                                                                 Please return forms to:
    Area of specialisation                                                                       The Membership Manager, The Society of Specialist Paralegals,
                                                                                                 5th Floor, 80 St Vincent Street, Glasgow, G2 5UB
    (e.g. civil court etc):                                                                                                          The Specialist Paralegal Summer 2008                   11
Graduations
AUTUMN 2008
 Sixty newly-qualified paralegals received their awards at a graduation ceremony at the Barony Hall, the
 University of Strathclyde, on Monday, 20th October 2008. Here, we talk to some of those paralegals about
 the challenges they faced in working towards their qualifications – and their plans for the future!


                                                      residential team. They
                                                      certainly are a hard-
                                                      working bunch and, like
                                                      Lindsays as a firm, put the
                                                      needs of our client first and
                                                      foremost and are always on
                                                      hand to help. I now no
                                                      longer type and my own
                                                      workload is growing – it’s
                                                      great!”
                                                        Her admiration for her
                                                      colleagues is even more
                                                      evident when asked about
                                                      role models in the
                                                      profession. “Susan Law is a
                                                      superb role model for
Kim Moffat, Lindsays                        youngsters starting out in the legal
Qualified in: Residential                   profession, having already achieved
Conveyancing                                Senior Associate status,” Kim says.
                                            “Susan was an NQ when she joined
                                            Lindsays and, like the firm, has
                                            grown from strength to strength. If
                                            I could achieve even a quarter of
Kim Moffat had been with central            what she has in her short career I
Scotland firm Lindsays for four             would be delighted! Natalie Barnes
years before undertaking the                too deserves a mention – she is also
paralegal course. “I actually fell into     a fab young property lawyer. Both
legal work by accident and had no           these hard-working girls were a big
formal experience or training               support to me throughout my
having previously worked in                 studying and showed me a lot of
insurance and in medical,” she says.        encouragement and I will
“I found the work interesting and           forever be indebted to their
there was always something new to           kindness.”
be learned.                                   But her praise isn’t just for her
  “After being with the firm for four       colleagues: “Last but not least, I
years I felt it was time to take things     have to give a big mention to                                                      be a good deal of job security as
up a gear, and felt by undertaking          my lovely mum, Nanette,                                                            people will more than likely always
the course I would be able to               without whom I would never                                                         have accidents!”
contribute so much more to the              have gotten this far,” she adds.                                                     After Irwin Mitchell merged with
firm. After approaching the head of           One aspect of the paralegal                                                      Golds in 2007, Fraser asked one of
department it was agreed that I             training experience which Kim                                                      the partners if the firm would put
would undertake the property                particularly enjoyed was the                                                       him through the paralegal course. “I
course and I had the full support of        graduation ceremony. “It was a                                                     thought I knew a lot about
the partners and staff in the               very special day for me as well                                                    reparation law and I deal with road
department to take that forward.”           as my family,” she explains. “I                                                    traffic accident claims on a daily
  Kim “thoroughly enjoyed” the              felt a real sense of achievement,                                                  basis,” he says. “It wasn’t until I
course, saying: “It was very                as I’m sure all the other graduates       Fraser Watson, Irwin Mitchell           started my paralegal course that I
interesting and informative and was         did. It really made all the hard work     Qualified in: Reparation Law            realised that there was still a fair bit
a good introduction into the                worthwhile and I am pleased that                                                  for me to learn.
workings of property law. I would           paralegals are now recognised as                                                    “I enjoyed the course and would
definitely recommend it, as having          having a professional qualification.”                                             recommend it to anyone that
this certificate under your belt is a         Kim is the single mother of                                                     currently deals with reparation.
good base to progress your career.          Christopher, who is nearly three.                                                   “I found it a lot easier to work on
  “As I studied the course by the           “Although he doesn’t know it yet,                                                 my assignments by staying behind
home study method, you really               he played a big part in me wanting          Fraser joined Irwin Mitchell, or      in the office after work. This way, I
need to be dedicated and set aside          to progress my career and undertake       Golds as it then was, in September      remained in work mode and was
time every day to study. Although,          this course – every mum wants their       2003. “When I started, I was            away from any distractions I may
having really enjoyed the course, I         child to be proud of them,” she says.     originally employed to answer           have at home – such as the
used to look forward to coming              “And in five years time I would           phones and get new instructions set     television and my Playstation 3!”
home in the evenings so I could get         certainly hope to be a fully-fledged,     up on the system,” he remembers. “I       Fraser enjoyed the graduation
into my books – there was no                multi-functional paralegal – or           then moved on to dealing with           ceremony, which he attended with
chance of my enthusiasm waning!             maybe more!                               claims before a court action was        his wife and family. “As I left school
  “My job has changed completely              “If someone had asked me five           raised, then I moved into the court     when I was sixteen years old and
since completing the course,” Kim           years ago where I expected to be          section where I am now.                 never went to college or university,
adds. “Although I am still part of the      today I wouldn’t have been able to          “I felt that a legal practice would   this was the first chance I have had
property group, I have moved over           tell them so who knows what the           be a fairly interesting place to work   to experience a graduation
from the commercial team to the             future has in store for me..!”            and, if I’m honest, that there would    ceremony,” he says. “I also enjoyed

12   The Specialist Paralegal Winter 2009
                                        Nadine McPike, Michael Lott              bit of a blur – I was in awe of the                               allow yourself some ‘reward’ time to
                                        Qualified in: Wills, Trusts and          Barony Hall which is so beautiful,                                unwind and forget about the course
                                        Executries                               and I think I was more concerned                                  for a little while – if I was spending
                                                                                 that my parents and grandfather                                   too many hours studying my mum
                                                                                 were enjoying the day rather than                                 would insist that I take a break and
                                                                                 how much I was enjoying it. My                                    maybe go shopping for a few
                                                                                 second graduation was fantastic – I                               hours.”
                                                                                 was much more relaxed, and I knew                                   Her favourite part of the job is
                                                                                 what to expect.”                                                  telling clients they can collect their
                                                                                   Despite her initial panic having                                keys. “That one sentence makes my
                                        Nadine McPike completed her first        been out of the way of studying for                               day!” she says. Although her role
                                        paralegal qualification – in Property    almost a decade, Nadine found she                                 hasn’t changed much since
                                        Law – in 2006, and “enjoyed that         enjoyed building up her study                                     completing the course, she adds, “I
                                        course so much” that she embarked        hours. “After a few weeks I found it                              am more confident in myself and I
                                        upon a second qualification in           less difficult and actually began to                              don’t question my decisions
                                        August 2007. Nadine credits her          enjoy learning more and more,” she                                anymore. I am much more efficient
                                        fascination with the law to the          says. “I would definitely recommend                               in my work too.”
                                        television programmes she enjoyed        a Paralegal course to anyone who                                    As for planning for the future,
                                        as a girl. “At a very early age I was    works in the legal profession, enjoys                             Nadine’s philosophy is: “I don’t. I
                                        addicted to LA Law, TJ Hooker and        their job and who wants to take the                               think if you look too far into the
                                        The Bill, and I became so obsessed       next step and further their career.”                              future and set yourself too many
                                        with the Police Force I even started       Nadine attributes her success to                                goals you only disappoint yourself. I
                                        school with a plastic gun and police     her friends and family, saying, “If I                             used to plan as far ahead as possible
                                        badge in my blazer pocket!” she          hadn’t had the support of my                                      but I never met any of my goals so
                                        recalls.                                 parents, I don’t think I would have                               now I’m fairly spontaneous in what I
                                          After leaving school, Nadine was       found the course as stress-free as I                              do and touch wood… my life is so
                                        determined to join Strathclyde           did.                                                              much more enjoyable and
                                        Police as soon as she was old              “I think it’s imperative that you                               rewarding!”
                                        enough – but fate was to deliver an
                                        unexpected turn. “I started work
                                        with Austin Lafferty in October
                                        2007 as an officer junior and left the
                                        company in June 2001 as a
                                        secretary,” she says. “I enjoyed the
                                        work so much that joining the
the drinks reception afterwards.”       police was put on the back burner.”
  His job has changed “quite a bit”       “I began working for Michael Lott
since completing the paralegal          Solicitors in June 2002 as a
course, he says, explaining: “I have    Secretary and can honestly say that
recently become a manager in my
department. I will now be able to
                                        my time there has passed too
                                        quickly. The light atmosphere and
                                                                                   Tip the scales in your favour
pass on my knowledge to the team I      relaxed relationships within the           Achieving your goals in 2009 means taking action now - so register
look after.”                            office makes the working day pass          for our essential LLB events to find out about developing your
  He enjoys his job, saying: “I don’t   pretty quickly.”                           career with a law degree.
really have a favourite part of my        Nadine had no formal legal
job in particular, but the least        qualifications before completing           • Part-time LLB (evening classes)
favourite part is dealing with any      her first paralegal course, which she        Information Evening: Wednesday 11 March - 6pm
complaints       that     come    in.   arranged herself and told her boss
Thankfully there are very few of        about once she had passed. “I had          • Graduate Entry LLB (two year course)
these, and the ones that we get are     two reasons for undertaking the              Information Afternoon: Wednesday 25 February - 1:30pm
usually easily resolved.”               course,” she says. “The first and
  Fraser has been married for just      main reason was to prove to myself         Why Strathclyde? Strathclyde is one of the top Law Schools in the
over two years, and says that if he     that I could do it without any             UK. For over 45 years it has established a reputation for the highest
was to cite one person as a role        assistance        financially       or     quality teaching and research in the UK. In the recent official
model it would be his father. “My       professionally from anyone else. I         assessment of the quality of staff expertise, most of the Law School’s
Dad worked hard to be able to           took great pride in saying that I had      output was officially graded ‘world-class’ or ‘internationally excellent’ –
provide a good standard of living       done all this work on my own and           in effect this ranks Strathclyde Law School as the seventh best in the
for myself and our family,” he          came out at the end of it all with a       UK (out of 67) and top in Scotland. This means that students are being
explains. “If I can provide the same    good pass mark.
standard of living for my family one      “My second was to make my                taught by among the very best legal experts in the UK.
day then I will be happy. Perhaps a     family proud. My parents have              Find out more by registering for the events/visit the
little stressed, but happy all the      worked hard to give me the best            course web pages to complete the online form.
same!”                                  lifestyle they could, and my
  In his spare time, Fraser enjoys      grandfather James has been a real          w: www.law.strath.ac.uk
watching Rangers play at Ibrox,         gem throughout my life too; so this        t: 0141 548 3738
listening to music and socialising      was my way of paying them back,            e: courses@law.strath.ac.uk
with his wife and friends. “In five     making them proud and giving
years time I see myself pretty much     them a fantastic day out at the            Please quote: PARA1/09
doing what I am just now,” he says.     Graduation Ceremony where they             The University of Strathclyde is a charitable body, registered in Scotland,
“The difference will be that I will     could see all their hard work and          number SC015263

have even more knowledge and            mine pay off.
experience in what I do.”                 “My first graduation passed by in a      The place of useful learning


                                                                                                                                           The Specialist Paralegal Winter 2009      13
                                                                                            KIMBERLY FYFFE and INSTRUCT US NOW

  Instruct Us Now is a unique service which
  organises counsel for Scottish solicitors – and
  paralegals! We talk to founder Gordon Stead
                                                                                       been extremely happy with the out-        young baby and begun working from
  about the company, and hear from client                                              come in cases where we have used          home for three days a week, being in
  paralegal Kimberly Fyffe.                                                            the service, and I would strongly rec-    the office two days per week. Home
                                                                                       ommend Instruct Us Now to any             study was particularly appealing
                                                                                                   solicitors who often          because it meant that I could still
Instruct Us Now was launched in                                                                    require     to     instruct   work full time and study in the
May 2008 by Gordon Stead, a                                                         Kimberly       Counsel in certain cases      evenings and weekends.
practicing solicitor who had been                                                      Fyffe       for whatever reason.            “Since I have completed this course
running a similar service with a                                                                   They present themselves       I feel I have learned so much, and am
business partner since May 2007. “As                                                               as very friendly and          so much more confident in my role. I
a solicitor for over ten years I was                                                               approachable, yet experi-     am frequently involved in many
very aware of the level of service                                                                 enced and professional        interesting and bizarre cases, which I
demanded by clients to secure their                                                                and they provide a great      think is why I enjoy my job so much.
work,” he explains. “I felt that                                                                   service.”                     I find the favourite part of my job is
solicitors did not receive a similar                                                                 Kimberly found herself      meeting with clients and handing
level of service from suppliers of                                                                 working for Boyles as an      over their settlement cheques to
services to them, and in particular                                                                office junior after leaving   them at the conclusion of an action
the provision of Advocacy services.                                                                school at sixteen. “To be     after many months of investigation
  “There are over 400 practicing                                                                   honest, I had not really      and hard work, which I personally
Advocates who all work, fee and                                                                    considered a career in law    find very satisfying.”
deliver advice in a different way. My                                                              at that particular time,”       Instruct Us Now organise all types
aim was to make the instruction of                                                                 she admits. “But due to       of civil litigation, pre-litigation and
Counsel easier for solicitors and to                                                               the limited staffing          in the Court of Session and Sheriff
introduce clear and consistent                                                                     within the company at         Courts. “Most members of the
service standards which apply                                                                      the time I found I was        profession, and in particular
regardless of which Counsel                                                                        basically thrown in at the    paralegals, do not necessarily know
completes the work.”                                                                                                             which Counsel would be suitable to
  The        company         guarantee                                                   Gordon                                  provide advice in relation to a
consistent, quality advice within five                                                   Stead                                   particular topic,” Gordon explains. “I
working days to firms who use the                                                                                                am able to assist in ensuring that
service, on a pre-agreed feeing basis                                                                                            only a Counsel with real relevant
and in a standardised format. “This                                                                                              experience will undertake work for
removes uncertainty and also                                                                                                     them.
unnecessary time spent locating a           being charged for Advocacy services                                                    “Having instructed Counsel for ten
suitable counsel and chasing                at that time,” Kimberly explains.                                                    years I am very aware of the
outstanding work,” Gordon explains.         “This was particularly inviting to us                                                importance of receiving clear advice
“In general terms I wanted to offer         because in a number of cases,                                                        which will help progress a client’s
the level of service to solicitors and      Advocates’ fees would not be met by                                                  case. My background also means
paralegals that they deserve, and           the opponents and would often                                                        that I can assist solicitors and
which will assist them in earning           require to be deducted from the                                                      paralegals by discussing their cases
fees.”                                      client’s award of compensation.                                                      with them – I’m often used as a
  One paralegal who has already               “Mr Stead had explained to me that                                                 sounding board, and whilst I do not
benefitted from the service is              he was an experienced Accident                                                       give any legal advice I can often give
Kimberly Fyffe of Boyles Solicitors,        Claims Solicitor, and although he          deep end, and had learn very              reassurance and a few pointers on
Dundee. Kimberly, a Member of the           would pass our requests to Counsel         quickly.” Kimberly worked her way         how best to proceed.
Society of Specialist Paralegals who        he was more than willing to offer          through the ranks, first as a junior        “Although the legal market can be
completed a qualification from the          what personal assistance and advice        then senior typist working in various     very conservative, I find that when I
University of Strathclyde in 2005, is       he could in cases – as part of the         departments in the firm.                  meet with people and discuss how I
a senior paralegal who is principally       service and without any additional           “I think around nine years ago I was    can help they are usually very
responsible for the running of the          charge. Through my time in dealing         working within our rapidly                receptive to trying out our service.
firm’s Accident Claims Department.          with him, I have often found that he       increasing reparation department,         I’m keen for as many people as
She deals with a fairly large caseload      would be more than happy to give           which dealt with accident claims,”        possible to try us out as I’m confident
of personal injury claims, criminal         me his opinion on certain cases            she remembers. “I enjoyed this work       it will make their life easier and make
injuries compensation claims and            without us having to formally              very much and became extremely            their working life easier which can
medical negligence claims.                  instruct Counsel.                          interested in this area of law. I         only be a good thing. I am always
  It was the firm’s senior partner who        “I find the service provided by          became involved in meeting with           happy to meet with people
first introduced Kimberly to Gordon         them to be very helpful, whether           clients and investigating claims,         throughout Scotland and if anyone
and his new service. “We had used           we’re looking for the drafting of          which was of particular interest to       fancies coffee or lunch call or email
Faculty Services for the instruction        pleadings in complication litigation       me, then learned through my               me to arrange!”
of Counsel, but Instruct Us Now             or to obtain a Note on Quantum in          employer        that     Strathclyde
were offering a very inviting service       an effort to persuade insurance            University were running Specialist        I To find out more about Instruct
which guaranteed a work turnaround          companies to increase offers in            Paralegal Courses through home            Us Now, call Gordon Stead on
of five working days and fees               particular cases.                          study. This was of particular interest    0844 567 66 99 or visit the website
somewhat less than the fees we were           “I have found that the clients have      to me at the time because I had a         on www.instructusnow.com.

14   The Specialist Paralegal Winter 2009
career clinic+                                                                                                                 Welcome to the Career
                                                                                                                               Clinic, where you have
                                                                                                                               the opportunity to ask
                                                                                                                               Lisa McGill from
NO SUPPORT                                                                                                                     Search Legal those
                                                                                                                               burning questions about
Q: I have been working with my                                                                                                 your paralegal career.
firm for over two years now and                                                                                                Please feel free to send
have been given no development                                                                                                 us your experiences that
since I started in terms of training                                                                                           relate to any of the
and guidance. I have not received                                                                                              questions, and we ll try
any appraisals and feel as though I
am drifting along without knowing
                                                                                                                               to print them in the next
how well I am performing or if I’m                                                                                             issue.
meeting my boss’ expectations. I
have never been told I am doing a
bad job, but would like to know for
sure. What should I do?

Career Clinic: This is an all-too
common           scenario,     where
employees are left in limbo not
knowing if their work performance
is satisfactory or not. Unfortunately,
it tends to be the case that a poor
work standard is recognised before
a good one. Given that no problems
with your work have been raised it
would seem all is ok, but this is not
ideal as you obviously want to know
for your own peace of mind and
development. I suggest you                                                                                                  would like a new challenge. I do
approach your boss and ask for a                                                                                            really enjoy working in law and feel
meeting where you can address this                                                                                          it would be a shame to throw my
and make him aware that you would                                                                                           experience away. One thing I have
like a more structured approach to                                                                                          considered is retraining as a
your development, which will                                                                                                solicitor, but I couldn’t afford to do
ideally include annual appraisals in                                                                                        it full time and I know fees are
order to raise any areas of weakness                                                                                        expensive. Do you know if firms
that need improved. I am sure your                                                                                          help paralegals training as
boss will appreciate this, and it may                                                                                       solicitors?
well be the case that he thinks
you’re happy with his informal                                                                                              Career Clinic: In my experience,
approach. Good luck!                                                                                                        firms tend to be supportive of
                                                                                                                            employees who want to further
                                                                                                                            their knowledge – especially when
                                                                                                                            it will be to their advantage. The
OVERLOOKED FOR                                                                                                              level of assistance does vary
PROMOTION                                                                                                                   however from firm to firm, for
                                                                                                                            example some firms will just be
Q: I work as a PI paralegal within a                                                                                        flexible with working hours and will
team of five and have been at my         would be a good idea to raise your     undertaking        the      Paralegal       accommodate time off for exams
firm for over eight years. I have        concerns with your boss and his/her    Certificate here, as that combined          etc, while others will actually pay
been overlooked for promotion to         explanation may put your mind at       with your extensive experience will         fees and offer traineeships at the
team leader twice in favour of less      rest. Of course, it may also be the    stand you in better stead in securing       end of the diploma. There are also
experienced colleagues. It is            case that your boss’ justification     employment. I would ensure that             various options for paralegals
affecting my confidence, even            means that you want to move onto       when applying for jobs you include          retraining as solicitors, so do some
though I always get good feedback        a firm where progression will be       in your covering letter that you            research to work out what would
from my boss. I feel like leaving but    achievable, and if that is the case    have the Scottish qualification,            suit you best. Then the best thing
I love my job and get on well with       please don’t hesitate to contact me!   which has given you knowledge of            you could do is broach the subject
my colleagues so I don’t know what                                              Scots law and you can apply that to         with your boss and take things from
to do. Do you have any advice?                                                  your practical experience. You              there depending on what support
                                                                                should also explain that you are            they are prepared to offer. Best of
Career Clinic: I can completely          RELOCATION WOES                        here permanently. Additionally, you         luck!
understand why you feel your                                                    could approach firms and ask if you
confidence has been knocked by           Q: I am an American paralegal who      could go in on a voluntary basis to         I Have you got a burning question for
this. I would say, however, that         has     relocated    to    Scotland    gain experience here, which would           our recruitment expert, or would you
there could be many reasons to           permanently, but I’m struggling to     help. Paralegals with foreign               like to share your experiences on the
explain why you haven’t been             find suitable employment. I worked     experience do manage to get                 above? Drop us a line at
promoted – your colleagues may           in Arizona as a Litigation paralegal   paralegal roles, so I would say your        specialist_paralegal_magazine@centl
have managerial experience from          for ten years where I had a high       perseverance and patience will pay          aw.com.
previous jobs, for example. The fact     volume caseload. I have completed      off.
you always get good feedback             the Paralegal Certificate in
would suggest you have nothing to        Reparation as I thought that would                                                     Career Clinic – brought to
worry about, and it may be your          help me get a job over here but I am                                                    you in association with
boss thinks you wouldn’t want a          not even getting any interviews. Is    SOLICITOR DREAMS
team leader role – which many            there anything else I can do?
paralegals don’t. It would seem a                                               Q: I have been working as a
shame to leave if you’re happy with      Career Clinic: Firstly, I would say    paralegal for fifteen years and am
every other aspect of your job, so it    that you’ve done the right thing by    beginning to feel stale at work and

                                                                                                                        The Specialist Paralegal Winter 2009   15
The Year of
Living Gracefully
If you didn’t make any resolutions               good deals by using their selling        can’t afford and will rarely use once     thehungersite.com let you raise
this year, skip this article – you’re            power to lower buying prices, so         the novelty has worn off. Jogging –       funds just be clicking on a button –
obviously perfect. But if you did                those lower down the food chain          or even walking – groups are              one click on their animal rescue
(and I’ve got a feeling that’s most of           have to get by on less and watch,        cropping up all over the country and      section lets you donate 0.6 bowls of
you) then tear up your list, you’re              while those above them get richer.       most of the time all you need to do       food to rescue animals, and
not going to need it anymore.                    And they’re often a lynchpin of the      is grab some suitable shoes (because      freerice.com is an online trivia
Resolutions are about thinking big,              local community – and in an              you can’t run in high heels, didn’t       game that donates 20 grains of rice
about change on a grand scale, and               increasingly cyber-driven age, who       that dash for the last bus on             to the UN World Food Program for
they don’t work. We’re in a recession            can afford to turn down the chance       Christmas Eve teach you anything?).       every right answer. And if you’re
– it’s time to downsize.                         of a flesh and blood connection?         You can meet new people, and              shopping online during your lunch
  I’ll lose weight. I’ll drink less. I’ll stop   When LGBT store Gay’s the Word           making friends is an excellent            break, don’t forget that you can
spending money I don’t have on things I          was threatened with closure,             incentive to come back. And you           often donate money to a good cause
don’t need. Sound familiar? They’re all          countless regulars spoke to the press    don’t need a membership, or even a        just by going via the website of your
good ideas – in practice. The                                                             workout outfit. The Hash House            favourite charity. Then you can
problem is that every resolution we                                                       Harriers are an international running     update your Facebook status and
make comes back to that one word:                                                         group whose website describes their       brag about your good deeds.
I. We spend January trying to                                                             activities as “a state of mind – a          We all know the drill by now – if
change ourselves, when we                                                                    friendship of kindred spirits          you can avoid driving, use public
should be spending the year                                                                    joined together for the sole         transport. Although we might
trying to change the world                                                                       purpose of reliving their          complain about it, Britain has great
around us. But doesn’t that                                                                       childhood, releasing the          public transportation. OK, so you
mean thinking big? Not                                                                             tensions of everyday life, and   might be swapping the dulcet tones
necessarily. Instead of                                                                             generally, acting a fool        of your favourite radio station for
thinking        about       self-                                                                   amongst others”. Beats the      the blaring hip-hop on the top deck
improvement, concentrate                                                                            treadmill any day.              of the bus, but you never know –
on looking outward for a                                                                              If you want to get out of     you might get off the bus with a
change – and you’ll see                                                                             the house but want to avoid     whole new appreciation for it. And
how even the slightest                                                                             working up a sweat, look into    even if you have to drive, don’t feel
alterations to your daily                                                                         volunteering. It gives you a      too guilty because there are still
routine can make a big                                                                           chance to make all those fuzzy     ways you can reduce that carbon
difference.                                                                                     resolutions – make new friends,     footprint. Again, it’s the little things
  Take shopping, for instance.                                                                give something back, find a new       that count – switch off your air
Even in the current economic                                                               social activity that doesn’t revolve     conditioning and keep your speed
climate, none of us are going to give                                                     around the pub – all part of your         below 70mph even on the
up completely. And yet, even in the                                                       weekly routine. And it couldn’t be        motorway, but remember that
melee that is the average high street,                                                    easier – http://do-it.org.uk is a         driving at less than 15mph is one of
we can still find a way to make a                with stories about how the shop had      great resource when it comes to           the biggest car-related causes of
difference. Take the road less                   changed – or in some cases, even         finding local activities that match       pollution. Even driving with your
travelled and investigate smaller,               saved – their lives. In smaller towns    your interests, or try getting            car windows up helps (apparently it
independent shops. Or shop online                and cities, small bookshops are often    monthly volunteering ideas emailed        reduces drag) and ensuring that you
– etsy.com is a great place for those            the main provider of books about         to you by TimeBank. We all have           have the correct type pressure can
hidden gems, selling a variety of                local history, creating a community      skills we can use to make the world       save you up to 10% on your fuel bill.
handmade objects such as purses,                 of writers and readers as well as        a better place, we all have               And in these dark days, who doesn’t
jewellery, bags, art and notebooks.              supporting small presses. If they go,    experiences to share and wisdom we        like a bargain? For more
For most people, these online stores             then the community that has been         can pass on.                              information,          just       Google
are a way of supplementing their                 built around them vanishes as well.        Charity may begin in the home,          “hypermiling”          or     go      to
income whilst doing something they               Whilst you’re there, pick up a book      but it doesn’t have to be confined to     www.eta.co.uk – a website chock
love.                                            that can give you more ideas on how      your life outside the office. Envisage    full of ideas for green driving.
  And rather than shop at the usual              to improve the world around you.         your average working day. Now               See how easy it is to make the
high street behemoths, try an                    Don’t forget that most shops now         think of how you spend your time          small things matter? Even if it’s just
independent bookshop instead.                    sell reusable carrier bags, so buy one   online – no, not the work-related         switching your morning cup of
They can’t afford to lower their                 and make sure you take it with you       stuff. The other stuff you do, when       coffee to a fair trade brand or
prices to meet or beat those of ther             on your next shopping spree.             your boss isn’t looking. Sneakily         making sure that if you have to use
competitors, they can’t give you a                                                        checking Facebook, ordering your          disposable crockery you buy the
free Toblerone with every purchase                  Lose weight, save the planet          weekly shop, forwarding that              biodegradable stuff, or printing on
– the most you’re likely to get is a             OK, so you want to make a                hilarious joke email… sound               both sides (again – take the time to
free bookmark advertising a book                 difference, but you still want to get    familiar? Unsurprisingly, there are       think if you really need a hard copy
you’ll probably never buy and                    fit. Fair enough – but there are         more        productive     ways      to   of that email), making the world a
wouldn’t read if you did. Don’t                  plenty of ways to do it without          procrastinate online – and some of        better place without even thinking
forget, the chains can only negotiate            getting a gym membership that you        them are even fun. Websites like          about it is a lot easier than it sounds.

16    The Specialist Paralegal Winter 2009
And about that cup of coffee – if you      difference to the level of medical
have to have that early morning            care you receive and you can amend
overpriced caffeine fix, at least buy a    or withdraw your registration at any
travel mug with a lid. A lot of places     time.
will give you a small discount or            There’s a new kind of activism
even a free refill, and you’ll be saving   that’s becoming increasingly
the planet in the process. Maybe           popular – grace activism.
you’ll just be cutting down on the         Jennifer Baumgardner
refuse we accumulate by one paper          and      Amy       Richardson
cup a day and saving yourself a few        coined the term in their 2005
pennies – but it’s a start. It’s one       book, Grassroots: a Field Guide to
small step from there, to bypassing        Feminist Activism. It’s about improving
Starbucks altogether and bringing          the quality of life in all those tiny
your coffee from home. Oh, and try         ways that most of us take for
skimmed milk and forget the sugar.         granted. For example, studies have
There’s no reason you can’t rescue         shown that nearly 8% of primary
the planet and your waistline, after       schoolchildren in the UK don’t have
all. Just make sure that when you do,      any books at home – but by starting
you only fill your kettle with the         a bookdrive or donating to the
water you need – if everyone did           Literacy Trust, you can help young
that, there would be enough                children improve their vocabulary,
electricity left over to power every       add to their education and fire their
street light in the country.               imagination. Then there’s the
                                           weekly shop – most supermarkets,
         Look to the future                especially ones in big cities, have
Mugs, t-shirts and posters with            tables or baskets where you can
kittens in adorable poses all tell us to   donate a few cans of pet food or
live each day as if it’s our last. Think   some toys to ease the pressure on
about that for a second. It doesn’t        animal shelters. If you can’t afford to
just mean making the most of every         take in a homeless mutt, you can at
second – a nice thought, but not so        least buy them a slap-up meal.
easy to put into practice – it also        Alternatively, rather than just
means planning for the future and          throwing your old clothes out or
making sure that the good work             simply donating them to the
you’re doing with all these non-           nearest charity shop, look for
resolutions carries on after you’re        your nearest branch of Dress for
gone. Make a will. That way you            Success and set up a clothing
and you alone get to choose what           drive. This international non-
happens to your assets after you die,      profit organisation provides
and make arrangements for children,        business         suits       for
pets or any other dependents.              disadvantaged women who
Wouldn’t we all sleep a little sounder     are entering the job
if we knew that if the worst did           market or who have just
happen, we could soften the blow           started work, and women
for our loved ones? Don’t forget that      for      whom          buying
unmarried couples can’t currently          themselves something
inherit if you die intestate – and         nice has always come way
don’t forget to leave a charitable         down the list of their
donation in your will, however             priorities but who need to
small.                                     look smart for the office.
  Sign up to the NHS organ donor           Maybe next time you hit
register and help someone live after       the sales for a bit of retail
your death. It takes five minutes out      therapy, you can pick up a
of your time to register by signing        few extra things for
up at www.uktransplant.org.uk              someone who really needs
and it can make all the difference –       them.
currently more than 9,000 people in          With small actions, we can
Britain are in need of a transplant,       change the world in hundreds
and yet only 3,000 operations are          of huge, irrevocable, wonderful
performed a year. Statistically you’re     ways. So offer the person
more likely to become a transplant         looming over you on the Tube
recipient than a donor, so make sure       your seat – they might not be old,
you not only sign up (informing            visibly pregnant or have an obvious
your next of kin), but spread the          disability, but they might just have
word to family or friends as well.         had a really bad day. It’s a small
Contrary to occasional media               gesture, but it can mean a lot.
scaremongering, being on the               Sometimes, all we have to rely on is
register makes absolutely no               the kindness of strangers.


              I Kaite Welsh is an author, activist and freelance journalist.
              She has written for The Guardian and her blog, Grandma
              Was A Sufragette (www.modernbluestocking.blogspot.com)
              has been quoted by Red magazine.

                                                                                     The Specialist Paralegal Winter 2009   17
professional update
The Gay Divorcé
                               It was not exactly Paul McCartney and Heather Mills in terms of its financial interest, but nevertheless
                               the recent “divorce” of Matt Lucas and Kevin McGee generated significant press coverage. Probably it
                               would have done so in any case, given the profile that Lucas and his stage partner David Walliams
                               currently enjoy, but there was unquestionably some added journalistic glee at the fact that the “only
                               gay in the village” had become the first (well-known, at any rate) gay divorcé.


Matt Lucas and Kevin McGee were joined                   and disadvantages arising from the relationship; a       in that case did not accept that Heather Mills’
together, not in holy matrimony but in civil             claim to share the costs of bringing up a child; a       earning capacity had been diminished by her
partnership, in December 2006, a year after the          claim to provide a three year cushion of support;        marriage. So the only real issue was in valuing the
coming into force of the Civil Partnership Act           and a claim to avoid serious financial hardship. The     assets earned by Paul McCartney during the course
2004; they had been together by then for four            aim is to provide, where possible, a clean break         of their (relatively short) marriage. As is well-
years. Their six year relationship was brought to its    between the parties, and continuing obligations of       known, Mills received a payment of 25 million
legal end in October 2008. Though in strictly legal      support are not encouraged. Though judges have           pounds, which was roughly half of the increase in
terms not “marriage” (which both English and Scots       some discretion (such as determining what is a “fair”    McCartney’s wealth during the period of the
law reserve to opposite-sex couples), civil              division of matrimonial/family property), their          marriage.
partnership is virtually indistinguishable from that     room for manoeuvre is deliberately restricted. In           Matt Lucas and Kevin McGee registered their
institution in terms of eligibility, consequences and    Scotland, a premium is put on predictability.            civil partnership at the height of the former’s fame,
procedures for bringing the relationship to an end         In England, the Matrimonial Causes Act 1973 is         and his income was particularly high during the
- divorce for marriage and dissolution for civil         very much looser in its drafting. Parliament gave        time after the civil partnership registration. So the
partnership. The non-availability of adultery as a       English judges a far wider discretion than that          expectation must be that McGee will receive a
ground for dissolution, while it remains a ground        granted to Scottish judges. Predictability is            payment of around half of Lucas’s earnings from
for divorce, makes little difference in practice                                                                  December 2006 until May 2008 (when they
because if one partner is unhappy about the sexual                                                                separated). Whether McGee is entitled to
exploits of the other then dissolution is likely to be                                                            anything else remains moot. He was a television
available on the ground of unreasonable behaviour               There is not the strong                           producer when the couple registered their
in any case.                                                                                                      partnership and there is little in the press reports to
  Of course few people worry today about the                encouragement that there is in                        indicate that his earning capacity has been reduced
ground for either divorce or dissolution, because         Scotland to ensure that whatever is                     by that partnership. If so, he can expect little else.
even if neither adultery nor unreasonable behaviour                                                                  Yet there is an inherent unfairness here in making
is available, the marriage or civil partnership can be     awarded is awarded as a one-off                        financial provision on dissolution of civil
brought to an end after one year of separation, or         payment or transfer of property,                       partnership exactly the same as financial provision
two years if the defender does not agree. The real                                                                on divorce, and the Lucas/McGee relationship
disputes in the vast majority of divorces today           and open-ended periodical support                       illustrates it well. The pair had lived together since
concern children and money. Lucas and McGee                  is more common in England.                           2002, but of course civil partnership was not
have no children, either together or separately. But                                                              available to them at that point. To define “family
it is unlikely to stop them arguing about money.                                                                  property” as property acquired only after entering
The press report Lucas’s wealth at around 10                                                                      the legal institution rather than after commencing
million pounds. The dissolution court has the                                                                     their relationship minimises the claims that can be
power to order a sharing of at least some of this        sacrificed for justice in the individual case. The       made. This benefits the wealthier of the two, as
wealth.                                                  legislation says little more than that the judge         illustrated by the Lucas/McGee partnership: Kevin
  Now, the Lucas/McGee dissolution is governed           should seek a fair outcome, taking into account          McGee would have been entitled to 50% of a far
by English law on this matter and this is one of         various factors. It has been left to the higher courts   larger portion of Matt Lucas’s wealth had civil
those areas that is very different from the              to give guidance as to how this fairness is to be        partnership been available in 2002. This is, of
equivalent Scottish law.            So just as the       achieved. The House of Lords has encouraged an           course, a diminishing problem as time goes by, but
McCartney/Mills financial settlement tells us            equal division of what they call “matrimonial            it will disadvantage some people in civil partnership
nothing north of the border, so too will the             property”, but the legislation does not provide any      for decades to come. Whether the courts adopt
Lucas/McGee settlement tell us nothing. But it is        definition. It is assumed that it means roughly what     imaginative techniques to minimise this unfairness,
nevertheless worth looking at the differences in         it means in Scotland, but there is still much scope      which might well be characterised as
approach between the two jurisdictions.                  for judicial disagreement in England (for example        discriminatory, remains to be seen.
  In Scotland, the Family Law (Scotland) Act 1985,       whether pensions are covered, or assets tied up in a        And of course the problem may be less severe
sections 8 – 14, govern the matter, and the Civil        business). And recently the House of Lords and the       than it would be in the heterosexual world. The
Partnership Act 2004 amended this Act to bring in        Court of Appeal have begun to recognise that             problem for courts in highly discretionary systems
civil partners whose relationship is being dissolved.    contributions to a relationship are not all financial.   like English law has been to design awards that
It sets out in some fine detail the orders that can be   Determined to push a gender-neutral agenda               minimise or neutralise gender differences in society.
made and the principles that justify the making of       (though using gender stereotypes to do so), these        Financial provision on divorce was designed for
the orders. The primary claim is one for a fair          courts have held that home-making contributions          couples where, systemically, one is likely to have
sharing of the “matrimonial” or (if the couple are       should be valued the same as bread-winning               less earning capacity than the other and where
civil partners) “family” property. A fair sharing is     contributions. So the stay-at-home spouse/civil          gender roles in society will, even today, strongly
presumed to be a 50-50 split, though it is possible      partner can expect some payment to recognise that        push one party to continue with a career and the
to argue that a different split would be fairer.         their own future earning capacity has been               other to become homemaker and child-minder. In
Matrimonial or family property is (very basically)       compromised. There is not the strong                     the gay community these disparities will exist but
that property which the parties or either of them        encouragement that there is in Scotland to ensure        they are far less noticeable, and while one party
acquired during the marriage or civil partnership -      that whatever is awarded is awarded as a one-off         may well decide to be home-maker rather than
from the date of the marriage/civil partnership until    payment or transfer of property, and open-ended          bread-winner, this will be driven by mutual choice
the date of final separation. This claim is one almost   periodical support is more common in England.            rather than social expectation. It will be interesting
of right and it takes a lot to persuade the court not      Now, the differences between Scotland and              to see the extent to which these social differences
to grant it. It is paid as a lump sum (though it may     England really only show up in “big-money cases”         between marriage and civil partnership are
be deferred or paid in instalments) or as a transfer     where there is a substantial surplus beyond what         reflected in financial awards in the future.
of property. Other claims might be made against          each party genuinely needs to live. One of the
all the property, whether matrimonial/family or          biggest of big money cases of recent years was of        I Kenneth McK. Norrie is a Professor of Law with
not: a claim to even out the economic advantages         course the McCartney/Mills divorce. But the judge        the University of Strathclyde

18 The Specialist Paralegal Winter 2009
                                                                                                                                      professional update
The Cumulative Nil Rate
Band – The Future?
                 On 9 October 2007, the Chancellor of the Exchequer stood up in the Houses of Parliament and announced – for the
                 first time ever – the concept of the cumulative or transferable Nil Rate Band. Prior to then, the Nil Rate Band had
                 been available on a “use it or lose it” basis. In effect, if one spouse had left his or her whole Estate to the other,
                 this was effectively giving back a tax exemption of a substantial amount to the Treasury.


Recognition of the foregoing meant         therefore that if the funds were put       this route out (to preserve the                 My own experience has been that,
that, for several years, our clients       into a Discretionary Trust (albeit         Cumulative Nil Rate Band) is to be            even after the implications of the
required us to devise methodologies        subject to the foregoing regime of         preserved.                                    cumulative NRB have been explained
by which Inheritance Tax could be          taxation to Inheritance Tax) as              At their Conference in September            to our clients, several have chosen
mitigated. In many ways, the most          opposed to passing absolutely to the       2007, the Conservative Party                  not to revert to simple Wills. Why
inexpensive way of seeking to              surviving spouse, there could be           indicated that, if they were elected          should this be?        The first and
achieve IHT mitigation was                 differential savings in IHT – if the       into power at the next General                perhaps simplest reason is that many
appropriate Will drafting. The reason      funds in question had passed solely to     Election, they would introduce a Nil          clients do not regard their Wills as
for this was that the Testator did not     the surviving spouse then on his or        Rate Band of £1m. The Conservatives           being simple “fiscal” devices i.e.
require to give away any of his or her     her death they would have been             did not “flesh out” that proposal but         intended to mitigate the maximum
Estate during their lifetime, but          charged at 40%. However, funds             the effect which it had on their              amount of IHT. Clients who feel that
rather could structure arrangements        remaining with a Discretionary Trust       position in the polls was incredible.         way very often take the view that,
on their death so as to seek to            set up on death of the first spouse are    This probably pushed the Chancellor           even although they appreciate the
achieve some degree of tax                 likely to suffer less taxation to IHT      into his announcement on 9 October            potentiality of the cumulative NRB,
mitigation. What were the principal        even if the Trust were to run for          2007.                                         they still wish their adult children to
methodologies? Obviously, under            several years.                                                                           receive a substantial benefit sooner
the pre-October 2007 regime, there           Some clients have decided to retain                                                    rather than later i.e. the children
would require to be some degree of         a Discretionary Nil Rate Band Trust            The announcement of                       should not require to wait until the
“first use” of the predecessor’s Nil       because of fears, for example, that                                                      death of the surviving spouse.
Rate Band. This evolved into two           one of their children may be verging            the cumulative NRB                       Another reason why clients have not
main approaches:-                          on bankruptcy.         Retention of the        caused panic amongst                      reverted to “simple Wills” is a fear of
                                           funds within the Trust will protect                                                      the potentiality of the survivor
• The first death legacy – this often      those funds for the child if                    the legal profession                     requiring to go into a Care Home.
  was stated to be for the full amount     bankruptcy occurs. Some clients                                                          Whilst I suspect that many of our
  of the relevant Nil Rate Band but        have also expressed concern that the                                                     clients have a misplaced view of the
  did not require to be so – anything      marriages of one or more of their            The announcement of the                     potential loss of inheritance of their
  passed to adult children on first        adult children are “rocky”. Again,         cumulative NRB caused panic                   children if the survivor requires to go
  death would reduce the size of the       they would prefer to see funds             amongst the legal profession – after          into a Care Home, nonetheless we
  Estate of the surviving spouse, with     protected until a reconciliation or        all, we had spent years trying to             have to respect clients’ feelings.
  a result that less IHT would be          divorce takes place. I am of course        devise schemes in terms of our                This particular viewpoint is relevant
  payable on the death of the              aware that inherited funds should not      clients’ Wills to mitigate IHT for            in respect of a client who has
  surviving spouse.                        fall within the parameters of              their families.          Most firms           incorporated a Discretionary Trust
                                           “matrimonial property” – however,          immediately revised their Wills’              Nil Rate Band legacy provision in his
• Incorporation of a Discretionary         there have already been cases where        Banks. The approach of each firm to           Will and wishes to retain the same
  Nil Rate Band Trust.                     inherited       funds     have     been    the introduction of the cumulative            notwithstanding the provisions of
                                           “converted”       and      have    been    NRB has differed.          Some have          the Finance Act 2008.              The
  These two strategies were quite          subsequently found by a Court to           indicated to clients, who had                 consideration here is that a fund can
different. In the first case, the          come within the “target area” of           incorporated         first       death        be kept separate i.e. not passed to the
legacies were absolute.         In the     matrimonial property.                      legacies/Discretionary Trust Nil Rate         surviving spouse, and therefore be
second case, however, the Trustees           Incorporation of a Cumulative Nil        Band provisions within their Wills,           (at least in the conception of the
could assess the position of the           Rate Band Discretionary Trust offers       that they should revert to simple             client) kept free from the predations
various beneficiaries. In particular, if   great flexibility. There should be no      Wills i.e. each spouse leaving their          (as clients would perceive it) of the
the surviving spouse was included as       immediate rush into eliding the same       respective Estates to each other.             Local Authority in the event of the
a beneficiary, then, provided this step    from our client’s Wills – why? Quite       Other firms have adopted a much               survivor requiring to go into a Care
was taken not earlier than three           simply the Inland Revenue have             more measured approach (which I               Home.
months after and within two years of       already indicated that, when an            favour).                                        Whilst such fears may in fact be
the relevant date of death, in terms of    individual dies leaving a Will               There can be no doubt but that the          misplaced, there is no doubt but that
Section 144 of the Inheritance Tax         containing such a Trust, then              introduction of the cumulative NRB            retention of a fund within a
Act 1984, the whole funds could be         provided the funds are appointed out       has, potentially, moved many families         Discretionary Trust Nil Rate Band
appointed       out     to     relevant    to the surviving spouse not earlier        out of anticipated IHT liability – that       provision would preserve the funds
beneficiaries, with no additional IHT      than three months after but within         liability arose simply because of the         within that Trust for adult children
being payable. Obviously, however,         two years of the relevant date of          huge increases in house prices seen           on death of the surviving spouse.
where the Trustees chose not to            death, the Revenue will not regard         (up until recently) over the past five        Regulation 51 of the Income Support
appoint out to the surviving spouse        this as first use of the Nil Rate Band -   to six years. In some cases, the              General Regulations 1987 states that
then there could still be achieved         the cumulative NRB will still remain       introduction of the cumulative NRB            the assessing authority should not
generational and differential savings      available to the surviving spouse.         will be a boon. However, we should            take into account the fact that the
to IHT. Bear in mind that where a          This very helpful approach allows a        not encourage our clients to rush into        benefit applicant is a beneficiary in a
capital disposal is made from a            family a period of adjustment and to       reverting to “simple Wills” (i.e. each        Discretionary Trust.
Discretionary Trust, the maximum           assess the financial position of the       spouse leaving their Estate to the              There are, however, other points
amount of IHT which can be charged         surviving spouse. One danger point –       other) without giving this matter due         which require to be considered in
is 6%. This also applies to the 10         the original Trust must include the        thought. There are traps for the
year charge. The consideration was         surviving spouse as a beneficiary if       unwary here.                                                   continued overleaf

                                                                                                                                The Specialist Paralegal Winter 2009   19
The Cumulative
Nil Rate Band
– The Future?                             Debt Recovery
continued

relation to the cumulative NRB.                         The “credit crunch” is real, it is here and it is now, and while the role of the
Firstly, Practitioners require to be                    paralegal has always been an important and busy one, for the Specialist
aware of important dates.                               Debt Recovery Paralegal, in times of economic uncertainty and the current
Although this will apply only in                        highly volatile financial market, it is even more crucial than ever.
a very limited number of cases
(and I have had to deal with
one), care has to be taken where          In simple terms, the present            and there was simply no excuse,         the firm reserving clients to
the predeceasing spouse died              situation is that there are those in-   apart from good old-fashioned           themselves when it comes to debt
prior to October 1972. Because            house debt recovery staff who will      inefficiency, for the debt having not   recovery as this is invariably a
of the fact that there was no             get paid on time; those who will get    been collected.                         recipe for disaster, and it can be
spouse exemption under the then           paid but have to wait and, most           If law firms have any sense at all    very difficult to lean on slow payers
Estate Duty Regime, the Inland            seriously, those who won’t be           they will have a very high regard for   personally on Monday morning
Revenue have made it clear that           getting paid at all.                    their debt recovery people at this      when you have been engaged in
the cumulative NRB will not be              There will doubtless be some of       present time and give them the          social activity (golf, squash, the
available to the Executors of the         you reading this article who would      equipment, staff and any other          pony-club and dinners etc) at the
surviving spouse.                         not agree with this, and think that     resources they need to make sure        weekend. So, firms need to use their
  There is also the nuance where          the legal profession is somehow                                                 in-house credit control and debt
the spouses have been married             immune to the normal sorts of                                                   recovery departments to full
previously, with the first                pressures that affect everyday                                                  advantage and, in particular, make
marriages ending through death            business in terms of not being paid           If law firms have                 use of the skills which the Specialist
of the first spouse. There is scope       at all, but if my own experience is         any sense at all they               Debt Recovery paralegal will have
for client will planning here.            anything to go by (and we are one                                               gained as a result of studying and
  Application and interpretation          of the leading firms of debt
                                                                                      will have a very high               passing their qualification with
of the cumulative NRB is                  collection trainers in the UK), then        regard for their debt               CLT. Now, more than ever, is the
therefore not as simple as it may         watch out! I have handled one case             recovery people                  time for debt recovery specialists to
appear.       There are numerous          in the last week where I had to fight                                           shine and show what they can do,
issues to be considered, and it           “tooth and nail” with a major bank                                              and they need encouragement and
may well be that in certain               to get a payment of just under                                                  support from the top of the
circumstances, it would be                £20,000 that was seven months late;     that the team are trained, motivated    organisation down if they are to
appropriate not to encourage              another case in the last month          and get results.                        succeed in this.
clients to amend their existing           where a debtor in the profession          So, what do we need to do to
Wills. This may largely depend            who owes my client nearly £50,000       maximise our chances of success in      Basic good sense
on the viewpoint of the client in         already nine months late needs to       debt recovery and make sure that it        There are a number of basic good
question but I have always made           pay it in three instalments between     is we who are the ones getting paid     sense things which anyone reading
it clear that my own personal             now and early April, and a case in      while others wait? First, we need to    this article ought to be doing. Make
view is that a Will should not be         the last three months where the         say what we mean and mean what          sure your terms of service are clear
made simply for fiscal (tax               debtor went into insolvent              we say, there should be very few        as to what the payment obligations
mitigation) considerations.               liquidation owing my client legal       examples of Partners                      are. Talk to the people who owe
  Clever Will drafting can allow          fees and work in progress (WIP)         or Fee Earners in                               you money instead of
use (in relation to the second            amounting to around £60,000. The                                                           emailing and writing to
marriage) of the Nil Rate Band            saddest thing about this last case is                                                         them. Where necessary,
on first death leaving the                that the debt was 20 months                                                                     invoke penalties and
survivor still with a Cumulative          overdue at the time the                                                                          sanctions for late
Nil Rate Band. Obviously, this is         client went bust                                                                                 payment (interest and
an area where you have to ask                                                                                                              late        payment
the “right questions” when taking                                                                                                         charges), and stand up
instructions from clients in such                                                                                                        for and be proud of
a second marriages.                                                                                                                   your payment terms. You
                                                                                                                                   are (surely) proud of the
                                                                                                                              work you have done, so why
I John Kerrigan is a Partner                                                                                              should a similar sense of pride in
with Maxwell Maclaurin’s                                                                                                  your entitlement to be paid on time
Private Client Department,                                                                                                be any different? Remember, if the
and can be contacted on                                                                                                   client fails to pay on time, the right
jkerrigan@maxwellmaclaurin.com                                                                                            or cause of action is not that they
                                                                                                                          failed to pay on time, but that of the
Mr Kerrigan will be delivering a                                                                                          “breach of contract” which occurred
paper at CLT’s End of Year Tax                                                                                            by reason of their failure to pay on
Planning Conference on                                                                                                    time. So, late payment is a far more
6th March 2009 in Edinburgh                                                                                               serious matter than you might at
– for more information, or to                                                                                             first have thought.
book a discounted place,                                                                                                     Remember one of the core basics
please visit our website at                                                                                               of the world of credit and debt,
www.clt-scotland.co.uk.                                                                                                   which is that the older and later a
                                                                                                                          debt becomes the greater your
                                                                                                                          exposure and risk are each and
                                                                                                                          every day that it remains
                                                                                                                          outstanding. Go back to the
                                                                                                                          example I gave you earlier of the
                                                                                                                          debtor who went into insolvent
                                                                                                                          liquidation when the debt was 20
                                                                                                                          months overdue. Who knows what
                                                                                                                          the client would have recovered (I

20 The Specialist Paralegal Winter 2009
                                                                                                                                professional update


suspect the entire debt), if they had    short-term cashflow problems or           balance. That’s good – exceptional         do it. Logic would dictate that if
been on the case much, much              longer term financial hardship or, in     – debt recovery.                           you don’t change anything then
earlier.                                 the worst case, are they Type 4, the        Finally, bear in mind that really        your collection rates will not
  When it comes to discussing            criminal and fraudulent debtor who        good debt recovery can be simply           improve and indeed in the present
payment, don’t be afraid to              never intended to pay in the first        summed up that when you do more            economic climate your bad debt
accelerate the call “up” an              place.                                    of the right things in the right way       write-off has the potential to be
organisation. So, if you are dealing                                               you will invariably achieve far            significantly higher than what it
with bought-ledger and they won’t        Early intervention                        better results. So, the challenge is       was last year. Decide what you are
respond to your calls or fail to           Perhaps adopting an “early              for you to look closely at your debt       going to do and get on with it so
cooperate, then speak to the Chief       intervention” policy would work for       recovery policies and procedures,          that, as stated earlier in this article,
Executive or Financial Director.         your firm. Under such a process,          see what needs to be changed,              it is you who is the one being paid
That may be a wiser course of            within five days of an invoice being      removed or implemented and then            while others wait.
action in any event because the          sent you contact the client to
Chief Exec or FD may be the one          establish that it has been received;
who has given the instruction for        that there are no queries and to                                                                  I Mike Connolly is
your debt to be delayed, but equally     confirm when (on which date) and                                                                  Senior Partner of The
be someone who has the seniority         how (by what method, i.e. cheque                                                                  Connolly Partnership
within the firm to authorise that        or BACS) the payment is going to                                                                  (Consultant
your cheque or BACS now be               be made. Such a policy can, at a                                                                  Credit/Debt Specialists
                                                                                                                                           and Freelance Law
                                                                                                                                           Lecturers) based in
                  When it comes to discussing                                                                                              Llangollen, North
                                                                                                                                           Wales. He can be
              payment, don’t be afraid to accelerate                                                                                       contacted by email:
                 the call “up” an organisation                                                                                             tcp@pastdue.co.uk, by
                                                                                                                                           telephone on 01978
                                                                                                                                           861616, or via the
                                                                                                                                           website at
released. Also, compared to bought-      stroke, deal with two of the oldest                                                               www.pastdue.co.uk.
ledger staff who tend to develop         excuses in the book when it comes
immunity to receiving debt-chasing       to chasing monies owed to a law
phone calls, those higher up the         firm: that of the client who, when
firm are often “pussy cats”.             the invoice is already 3/4/5/6
  Make sure you are fully prepared       months late, states that either they
for the call. Know who you intend        have never received the bill or that
to speak to, which number you are        there is a query on it. Early
going to ring and when. Think of         intervention is simple and
the questions you are going to ask       inexpensive to instigate, and pays
them and make a note of any              handsome dividends very quickly.
questions they might ask you. Have         You will need to ensure that you
full details of the matter(s) and        know your law and that you use it.
access to the outstanding invoices       If you have gained your Specialist
there and then when you are on the       Paralegal        Debt        Recovery                             DEBT RECOVERY & CREDIT CONTROL LAWYERS
phone.       Avoid      costly    and    qualification through CLT then
unnecessary delays in posting copy       there will be no excuse for not
invoices by having these in .pdf         knowing. A good grasp of the legal
format so you can email them to the      dos and don’t will have a significant          DEBT RECOVERY PARALEGAL
client at the same time as making        impact on your levels of personal
the call. Always – yes, always –         confidence when you speak to                  An opportunity has arisen for a Debt Recovery Paralegal
agree a date for any follow-up: so, if   people on the telephone, and that
the outcome of the call is a promise     confidence will impact in a big way                 to join our busy Debt Recovery Department.
to pay, then make sure that if the       on how seriously you are taken and            The preferred candidate should have experience of some
client says they are going to pay by     whether debtors follow through on
Monday, that they are very aware         their undertakings to pay you.
                                                                                          or all of the following aspects of Debt Recovery:-
that you will be back on (and you          If you arrive at the conclusion that            telephone recovery, letters before action, issuing,
must be), if the payment has not         a debtor might be a Type 3 cash-                 serving and minuting on Court actions, Inhibitions
arrived by Wednesday morning of          flow or financial hardship case then
the same week.                           it is vital that you set up an                               and enforcement of Decrees.
  Sort your debtors into “types” and     appropriate instalment agreement at
not just profiles. By “profile” we say   the earliest possible opportunity,              This position would suit somone interested in further
the client is a small or large firm, a   and the start point for this will be to            developing their Debt Recovery Paralegal skills.
council or government department         obtain detailed income and
or perhaps a member of the public,       expenditure information. Please                 Although experience of operating a case management
a pensioner or a young family. But       email us at the address at the end of            system would be advantageous, this is not essential.
this only tells us their profile when,   this article if you need an example
to deal with them accurately as a        of an income and expenditure form.                          Salary dependent on experience.
debtor, we need also to know their       Imagine your joy in dealing with
type. Are they Type 1 delayers, who      such a case if you are owed, say,
can afford to pay but know your          £15,000 and the client eventually                 PLEASE FORWARD YOUR CV TO:
system and are simply making you         goes into liquidation or is declared
wait? Are they Type 2, who have or       bankrupt and at the time your debt               Anne Rourke, Debt Recovery and Insolvency Manager
feel they have a genuine reason not      has reduced down to just £1,500 or               Yuill & Kyle, 79 West Regent Street, Glasgow G2 2AR
to pay? Perhaps the debtor is Type       £2,000 while other creditors are
3, and is unable to pay by reason of     taking “hits” for the full outstanding            Tel: 0141 572 4256 Email: AnneR@yuill-kyle.co.uk

                                                                                                                          The Specialist Paralegal Winter 2009    21
Forthcoming
    COURSES
Now
   BOOKING
A new year means a new range of full and half-day      through the most important issues that you need to        materials included.
courses to keep you up to speed no matter your         be aware of as well as some of the less well-known          For Employment Law practitioners, the annual CLT
area of professional practice, and CLT have a range    potential pitfalls.                                       Certificate in Employment Law in association with
of discounts and special offers to ensure that vital     Also on the Private Client side, the Aberdeen           Burness LLP (20th and 27th March, Glasgow)
training is affordable whatever your budget.           Private Client Conference (23rd February,                 returns in 2009. Recent years have continued to
  Top of the bill this month is our ever-popular       Aberdeen) will be of essential interest to private        produce a mass of domestic and European
Annual Licensing Conference (30th April,               client advisors. In the current economic climate, it      legislation and case law relating to this area, with
Edinburgh). With the commencement on 1st               has never been more important for clients to be           the “credit crunch” meaning a busy time for
September of the new licensing regime, there has       made fully aware of what they can do to ensure that       employment lawyers particularly in the related
never been a more challenging time for licensing       their assets are properly managed and their liability     fields of restructuring and redundancy. The aim of
practitioners. Now in its 15th year, our annual        to tax is minimised. Our panel of experienced             this course is to provide delegates with a strong
conference will consider the practical impact of       advisors will consider six key areas where the            foundation in the core areas of employment law
those issues causing most concern and will provide     advice that you give your clients can make a              practice, and on completion of the course delegates
delegates with the opportunity to raise their          significant difference.                                   will be awarded a “Certificate in Employment Law”.
concerns and experiences with the panel. This is the     Our two-day Private Client Conversion Course              It is suspected that from April 2009 the current
one event that all licensing practitioners cannot      (17-18th March, Edinburgh) is suitable for                statutory disciplinary and grievance procedure will
afford to miss.                                        paralegals in any field wishing to change                 be swept away, to be replaced by the new
  All of the major taxes will be considered in our     specialism. The course is designed to give                provisions contained in the proposed Employment
comprehensive End of Year Tax Planning                 delegates a sound grounding in the basics of              Act 2008. Our topical New ACAS Code – all you
Conference (6th March, Edinburgh) – allowing you       Private Client work, including an understanding of        need to know half-day seminar (10th March,
to look at what you need to know to enable you to      how to draft wills, administer estates, give advice to    Edinburgh and 16th March, Glasgow) will review
advise your clients fully ahead of April 2009. With    elderly clients and a knowledge of some of the tax        and discuss the new statutory regime, while
an extremely practical focus, an experience team of    issues involved. There will be practical exercises        providing a round-up of the caselaw and recent
lawyers, accountants and financial advisors –          and case studies where appropriate, and a                 developments under the current system that
chaired by Professor Alex McDougall – will take you    Resource Pack with forms, guidance and other              remains in force until next year.

Also
   BOOKING
 CIVIL LITIGATION & PI                                 Bankruptcy and Dilligence – coping with the              RESIDENTIAL PROPERTY
 The Personal Injury Conference 2009                   rise in debtors                                          Home Reports and the Sellers Survey:
 Edinburgh, 27th February                              Glasgow, 19th March                                      friend or foe?
                                                                                                                Glasgow, 24th February
 COMMERCIAL PROPERTY                                   EMPLOYMENT LAW
 English Commercial Leases                             Mediation in Employment Conference                       The A-Z of Residential Conveyancing
 Edinburgh, 12th March                                 Edinburgh, 26th February                                 Edinburgh, 26th February
 Acquiring and Disposing of Pubs, Hotels and                                                                    Property Litigation Remedies in Difficult
                                                       FAMILY LAW                                               Times
 Restaurants
                                                       Protecting Family Wealth on Marriage,                    Edinburgh, 27th February
 Glasgow, 27th March
                                                       Separation and Divorce                                   Acting for Purchasers in a Challenging
 COMPANY LAW                                           Edinburgh, 26th February                                 Market
 Directors’ Duties – Crucial Changes                   Child Law for Non-Lawyers Conference                     Edinburgh, 5th March // Glasgow, 11th March
 Edinburgh, 29th April                                 Edinburgh, 16th March                                    The Property Disputes Conference 2009
 CONSTRUCTION LAW                                      PRIVATE CLIENT                                           Glasgow, 30th March
 Construction in the Credit Crunch                     Variations After Death                                   Property Aspects of Insolvency
 Conference                                            Glasgow, 20th February                                   Edinburgh, 28th April
 Edinburgh, 27th February                              What should you be advising clients before               RURAL LAW
                                                       April 2009?                                              The Rural Law Conference 2009
 CRIMINAL LAW
                                                       Glasgow, 24th February // Edinburgh, 26th                Edinburgh, 26th March
 Practice and Procedure in the Sheriff Court
                                                       February
 Edinburgh, 30th April
                                                       Will Drafting – the essential workshop                   SKILLS AND MANAGEMENT
 DEBT RECOVERY                                         Glasgow, 5th March                                       Effective Business Development: when
 Extracting Payment from Unwilling Debtors             Advising the Older Client                                times are tough
 Edinburgh, 26th February                              Glasgow, 20th March                                      Edinburgh, 27th February



 Remember. . .
           SSP members are entitled to discounted rates across CLT’s full range of conferences, seminars
                   and certificated programmes. Just mention your membership when booking.
              For further details of our CPD programme, visit our website on www.clt-scotland.co.uk
                                            or call us on 0141 225 6700.


22 The Specialist Paralegal Winter 2009
Debt Recovery Paralegal
Glasgow
    Trust us with your most
   precious legal document.




  Choose whether your CV is visible or
  hidden at the specialist job website.

Now you can take more control of your next career move by choosing
whether you want to be noticed by the top legal recruiters. What’s
more, whatever position you’re interested in – from legal secretary or
paralegal to lawyer or solicitor – our advanced search technology
ensures the best candidate-to-vacancy matching in the legal sector.

Do your career justice at
www.legalprospects.com

						
Other docs by fdh56iuoui
Analogue Display
Views: 110  |  Downloads: 0
Binary to Decimal Conversion Worksheet
Views: 109  |  Downloads: 0
FRUIT BREEDING AND IMPROVEMENT AT SOFRI
Views: 71  |  Downloads: 0
4120 Attempt
Views: 112  |  Downloads: 0
The 2010 GRI Readers Choice Awards
Views: 43  |  Downloads: 0
Fit and Proper Policy
Views: 38  |  Downloads: 0