Docstoc

HISTORIC DISTRICT COMMISSION HISTORIC DISTRICT

Document Sample
HISTORIC DISTRICT COMMISSION HISTORIC DISTRICT Powered By Docstoc
					                                                   HISTORIC DISTRICT COMMISSION
                                                             37 Washington Street
                                                        Nantucket, Massachusetts 02554
                                            Telephone: 508.228.7231               Fax: 508.325.7572
                Commissioners: Dirk Roggeveen, Chair, Linda Williams, Vice Chair, Dawn Hill, Secretary, John McLaughlin, Va lerie Norton
          Associate Commissioners: Wendy McCrae, Diane Coombs, Brian Conroy Staff: Mark Voigt, Aaron Marcavitch, Erin Kerwin, Ann Medina

                                                         ~~ AGENDA ~~
                                            NOVEMBER 29, 2005 – OLD BUSINESS
                                           Cyrus Pierce Middle School Cafeteria – 5:00 pm

I. CONSENT

1. Yates, Dorinda #47263                    58 Kendrick Street                  Shed, 12 x 9                  76.4.3/61
2. Means, John #47264                       10 Farmview Drive                   Shed, 10 x 8                  66/183
3. Boyce, Alexander #47265                  16C Milestone Road                  Foundation                    54/130.2
4. Nietupski, David #47266                  42 Wigwam Road                      Roof change                   77/81
5. Gifford, Margaret #47267                 14 Derrymore Road                   Fence, 5 & 1                  41/240
6. Unruh, R. #47268                         14 Long Pond Road                   Outdoor Shower                59/22
7. Gifford Whitney Trust #47269             7 South Road – Sconset Ext.         Dormer Revisions              73.4.1/44
8. Savitt, Bob #47270                       68 Goldfinch Drive                  Clapboard                     68/683
9. Sherburne Commons #47271                 South Shore Road                    Temporary Fence               80/1
10. Chuplis, John #47272                    103 Main Street                     Clapboard, Trim Revision      42.3.3/153
11. Holdgate, Dawn #47273                   23 Madaket Road                     Roof change, red cedar        41/301
12. Greenberg, Mark #47274                  17 Pocomo Road                      Bulkhead/Cellar Sash          14/11.1
13. McGovern, Robert #47275                 32 Walsh Street                     Door/Window Revisions         29/109
14. Sea Shanty NT #47276                    9 New Street – SOHD                 Bulkhead/Window Revisions     73.4.2/13
15. Bousa, Edward #47277                    102 Cliff Road                      Shed, 9 x 13                  41/13
16. Town of Nantucket #47278                6 Backus Lane                       Move on                       55/628
17. King Air Realty Trust #47279            40 Tennessee Avenue – MAB           Window/Porch Revisions        59.4/255
18. Haddon, Bill #47280                     5 Huckleberry Lane                  Cornerboard Revisions         32/61
19. Ryan, Dave #47281                       70 Fairgrounds Road                 Reduction in size             67/171
20. Town of Nantucket #47282                293 Madaket Road – MAB              Wall Sign                     60.1.2/64
Sitting           Mr. McLaughlin, Mr. Roggeveen, Ms. Williams, Ms. Norton , Ms. Coombs
Alternates
Representing
Concerns
Motion            Ms. Coombs approve 9 (Ms. Williams recuse, Ms. Norton recuse)        2nd
                  Ms. Williams approve 1-8, 10, 12-20
                  Ms. Williams approve 11 (Mrs. Hill Holdgate recuse)
Vote              3-2 (Ms. Coombs, Ms. McCrae)                                         Certificate # 47263-47282
                  4-0 (Mr. McLaughlin abstain)
                  4-0 (Mr. Mclaughlin abstain)


II. SPECIAL BUSINESS

1. Nantucket Island Resorts                   Easton Street                          Commercial                           Various
Sitting          Mr. McLaughlin, Mr. Roggeveen, Ms. Williams, Mrs. Hill Holdgate, Ms. Coombs
Alternates
Representing     Melissa Philbrick, Brad Edgerley
Concerns         Not all sides of buildings shown, ¼ inch scale drawings, saltbox form
Motion           Ms. Williams hold for complete application                               2nd
Vote             5-0                                                                      Certificate #




                                            Please Turn off Cell Phones
                                                    Proposed Minutes for 11/29/05

III. OLD BUSINESS

1. Madison NT                               7 Wingspread Lane                  Pool/Fence                         27/17.4
Sitting       Ms. Williams, Ms. Coombs, Ms. McCrae
Alternates
Representing  David Troast
Concerns      Type II, natural, to meet pool code, visibility from Shawkemo Road, move to another part of site, should be tucked
              into site, planting plan to hide pool
Motion        Ms. Coombs hold for revisions                                           2nd
Vote          2-0 (Ms. McCrae abstain)                                                Certificate #

2. D’Agostino, Vincent                   10 Cottage Avenue - SOHD            Dormer/Skylight                               73.3.1/100
Sitting         Mr. McLaughlin, Mr. Roggeveen, Ms. Norton, Ms. Coombs, Mrs. Hill Holdgate
Alternates
Representing    Chris Holland
Concerns        Visible from Magnolia Lane, not appropriate
Motion          Ms. Norton approve without additional skylight                      2nd
Vote            5-0                                                                 Certificate #                47283

3. Dineen, Kevin                          106 Orange Street                    Addition                                    55/400
Sitting         Ms. Williams, Ms. Norton, Mrs. Hill Holdgate, Mr. McLaughlin, Mr. Roggeveen
Alternates
Representing    Kevin Dineen
Concerns        Garage door type, in OHD?, tdl windows
Motion          Ms. Williams approve with TDL windows and casing to match existing    2nd
Vote            5-0                                                                   Certificate #              47284

4. Hedgebury Lane LLC                       8 Madaket Road                            Addition                              41/595
Sitting        Mr. McLaughlin, Mr. Roggeveen, Ms. Williams, Ms. Norton, Ms. Coombs
Alternates     (Mrs. Hill Holdgate recuse)
Representing   Mark Cutone
Concerns       Ms. Norton: Simple agrarian structure is being lost, lower level “moat,” automobile access, stone chimney, cupola,
               stairway across “moat,” Ms. Williams: previously had indicated that barn was going to remain the same, original
               simplicity is being obliterated, completely visible, not part of larger field, no tie to agriculture, suspended stair, round
               doors, protecting gable, should stay a gambrel, ganged windows, tall eave lines, how much of original fabric will
               even remain, Mr. McLaughlin: eight foot retaining walls, too much stone, rocket shaped end, Ms. Coombs: “car
               museum” on south, simplicity of barn, Mr. Roggeveen: four doors might be appropriate, grade should be worked into
               building, not changing grade on Madaket and Winn Street side is more important than any other side
Motion         Ms. Williams hold for revisions                                                 2nd
Vote           5-0                                                                             Certificate #

5. Uzzi, Don                                    7 Maxey Pond Road                      As Built Wall                      40/104
Sitting            Mr. McLaughlin, Mr. Roggeveen, Ms. Norton, Ms. Williams, Mrs. Hill Holdgate
Alternates         Ms. Coombs, Ms. McCrae
Representing       Sally Uzzi (flat stone walls are typical), Nathan McMullen
Concerns           Not an appropriate stone, irregularly shaped, in combination, artificially creates yard, design and height, interior to
                   lot would be more appropriate, base of wall
Motion             Ms. Williams hold for revisions                                             2nd
Vote               5-0                                                                         Certificate #

6. Uzzi, Don                                    7 Maxey Pond Road                Retaining Walls                           40/104
Sitting            Mr. McLaughlin, Mr. Roggeveen, Ms. Norton, Ms. Williams, Mrs. Hill Holdgate
Alternates         Ms. Coombs, Ms. McCrae
Representing       Sally Uzzi (flat stone walls are typical), Nathan McMullen
Concerns           Type of stone, amount of retainage
Motion             Ms. Williams hold for revisions                                      2nd
Vote               5-0                                                                  Certificate #
                                                  Proposed Minutes for 11/29/05
7. Wisnewski/Collatos                   6 Saccacha Avenue                    Move/Demolition                           82/336
Sitting        Mr. McLaughlin, Mr. Roggeveen, Ms. Norton, Ms. Williams, Mrs. Hill Holdgate
Alternates     Ms. Coombs, Ms. McCrae
Representing   Bill Collatos, Nathan McMullen, Stephen Cohen (abutter)
Concerns
Motion         Ms. Williams hold                                                    2nd
Vote           5-0                                                                  Certificate #

8. Wisnewski/Collatos                       6 Saccacha Avenue                        New Dwelling                      82/336
Sitting        Mr. McLaughlin, Mr. Roggeveen, Ms. Norton, Ms. Williams, Mrs. Hill Holdgate
Alternates     Ms. Coombs, Ms. McCrae (recuse)
Representing   Bill Collatos, Nathan McMullen, Stephen Cohen (abutter) size of structure
Concerns       Length of roof, central shed dormer, roofwalk, round windows, curve in second floor deck, would not like to see
               white trim, east elevation second floor dormer intersecting dormer, arched latticework, curved decks, size of
               structure, trim size, 12 pitch on structure, post size, massing, grade changes, foundation height and overall height of
               structure, size of french doors, no additive massing, corner boards, out of proportion for neighborhood
Motion         Ms. Williams hold for revisions                                               2nd
Vote           5-0                                                                           Certificate #

9. Pilgrim, Gary                           66 Monomoy Road                     As Built Retaining Walls                43/109.2
Sitting          Mr. McLaughlin, Mr. Roggeveen, Ms. Norton, Ms. Williams, Mrs. Hill Holdgate
Alternates       Ms. Coombs, Ms. McCrae
Representing     Richard Glidden, Terry Kelly
Concerns
Motion           Ms. Williams approve                                                 2nd
Vote             4-0 (Ms. Norton abstain)                                             Certificate # 47285

10. Griswold, Jay                         14 Satchem Road                       Demolition                             30/240
Sitting           Mr. McLaughlin, Mr. Roggeveen, Ms. Norton, Ms. Williams, Mrs. Hill Holdgate
Alternates        Ms. Coombs, Ms. McCrae
Representing      Jeff Spoelker
Concerns          None
Motion            Ms. Williams approve                                                 2nd
Vote              4-1 (Ms. Norton)                                                     Certificate #         47286

11. Griswold, Jay                          14 Satchem Road                      Addition                               30/240
Sitting           Mr. McLaughlin, Mr. Roggeveen, Ms. Norton, Ms. Williams, Mrs. Hill Holdgate
Alternates        Ms. Coombs, Ms. McCrae
Representing      Jeff Spoelker
Concerns          Missing elevations
Motion            Ms. Williams hold for complete application                           2nd
Vote              5-0                                                                  Certificate #

12. Griswold, Jay                          14 Satchem Road                        Garage                               30/240
Sitting           Mr. McLaughlin, Mr. Roggeveen, Ms. Norton, Ms. Williams, Mrs. Hill Holdgate
Alternates        Ms. Coombs, Ms. McCrae
Representing      Jeff Spoelker
Concerns          Dormer setback, ganged windows, post size on porch,
Motion            Ms. Williams approve with smaller posts and separate ganged windows 2nd
                  on first floor
Vote              4-1 (Mr. McLaughlin)                                                   Certificate #       47287

13. Kloppenburg, Janet                       1 Tennis Court Road               Demolition                              29/158
Sitting          Mr. McLaughlin, Mr. Roggeveen, Ms. Norton, Ms. Williams, Mrs. Hill Holdgate
Alternates       Ms. Coombs, Ms. McCrae
Representing     Scott Hutton, Jeff Spoelker
Concerns
Motion           Ms. Williams hold for revisions                                      2nd
Vote             5-0                                                                  Certificate #
                                                  Proposed Minutes for 11/29/05
14. Kloppenburg, Janet                       1 Tennis Court Road               New Dwelling (Secondary)                 29/158
Sitting          Mr. McLaughlin, Mr. Roggeveen, Ms. Norton, Ms. Williams, Mrs. Hill Holdgate
Alternates       Ms. Coombs, Ms. McCrae
Representing     Scott Hutton, Jeff Spoelker
Concerns
Motion           Ms. Williams hold for revisions                                      2nd
Vote             5-0                                                                  Certificate #

15. Kloppenburg, Janet                       1 Tennis Court Road                      New Dwelling (Main)               29/158
Sitting          Mr. McLaughlin, Mr. Roggeveen, Ms. Norton, Ms. Williams, Mrs. Hill Holdgate
Alternates       Ms. Coombs, Ms. McCrae
Representing     Scott Hutton, Jeff Spoelker
Concerns         Too long, massive, short entry gable, meeting rails, too massive, too tall, ganged, whats inside screen porch, too
                 many ganged windows, too many gables projecting off large box, isn’t actually breaking up mass, not traditional
                 additive mass, tall french doors, rambling nature, actually has a central mass, round columns, more traditional simple
                 elements, porches, low eaves
Motion           Ms. Williams hold for revisions                                              2nd
Vote             5-0                                                                          Certificate #

16. Kloppenburg, Janet                       1 Tennis Court Road               Garage                                   29/158
Sitting          Mr. McLaughlin, Mr. Roggeveen, Ms. Norton, Ms. Williams, Mrs. Hill Holdgate
Alternates       Ms. Coombs, Ms. McCrae
Representing     Scott Hutton, Jeff Spoelker
Concerns
Motion           Ms. Williams hold for revisions                                      2nd
Vote             5-0                                                                  Certificate #

17. Bradbury Lyons LLC                      6 Capaum Pond Road                Pool Shed                                 40/114
Sitting         Mr. McLaughlin, Mr. Roggeveen, Ms. Norton, Ms. Williams, Mrs. Hill Holdgate
Alternates      Ms. Coombs, Ms. McCrae
Representing    Sue Ellen Ward
Concerns        Visible, should be a simple outbuilding, gable, columns
Motion          Mr. McLaughlin hold for revisions                                    2nd
Vote            5-0                                                                  Certificate #

18. Bradbury Lyons LLC                      6 Capaum Pond Road                Pool/Fence/Wall                           40/114
Sitting         Mr. McLaughlin, Mr. Roggeveen, Ms. Norton, Ms. Williams, Mrs. Hill Holdgate
Alternates      Ms. Coombs, Ms. McCrae
Representing    Sue Ellen Ward
Concerns        Planting plan, fence design is inappropriate
Motion          Ms. Williams hold for revisions, planting plan                       2nd
Vote            5-0                                                                  Certificate #

19. Armstrong, Chris                        8 Monomoy Road                           Gate                             54/49
Sitting          Mr. McLaughlin, Mr. Roggeveen, Ms. Norton, Ms. Williams, Mrs. Hill Holdgate
Alternates       Ms. Coombs, Ms. McCrae
Representing     None
Concerns         Too wide, too large, two on a small plot, could be set further in, remove lamps, policy has said to keep gates back
                 twenty feet back from road, no need to be bigger than 12 or 14 feet
Motion           Ms. Williams hold for revisions                                           2nd
Vote             5-0                                                                       Certificate #

20. Murphy, Kent                            43 Old South Road                        Commercial                        68/81
Sitting          Mr. McLaughlin, Mr. Roggeveen, Ms. Norton, Ms. Williams, Mrs. Hill Holdgate
Alternates       Ms. Coombs, Ms. McCrae
Representing     Joe Paul
Concerns         Style of architecture on Old South Road, size of structure, detailing is too formal, double transom, double columns,
                 simplify building, band boards, meeting rails, symmetrical, large center gable
Motion           Ms. Norton hold for revisions                                               2nd
Vote             5-0                                                                         Certificate #
                                                   Proposed Minutes for 11/29/05

21. Olbres, Jason                                 29 Wigwam Road                     Material Change                   77/7.7
Sitting             Mr. McLaughlin, Mr. Roggeveen, Ms. Norton, Ms. Williams, Mrs. Hill Holdgate
Alternates          Ms. Coombs, Ms. McCrae
Representing        None
Concerns            Cost of columns, existing columns on other buildings, no standard for synthetic materials, lower cost columns are
                    available from various companies, could change to square columns, Ms. Williams no concern about columns outside
                    of town, Mr. McLaughlin should set a rule and regulation, should start denying as-builts, Mr. Roggeveen current
                    literature states that material is specified
Motion              Ms. Williams hold for representation                                    2nd
                    Mr. McLaughlin hold for representation
                    Ms. Norton deny as architecturally inappropriate
Vote                1-4 (Ms. Norton, Mrs. Hill Holdgate, Mr. Roggeveen, Mr. McLaughlin) Certificate # 47288 (D)
                    2-3 (Ms. Norton, Mrs. Hill Holdgate, Mr. Roggeveen)
                    3-2 (Mr. McLaughlin, Ms. Williams)

22. Vareschi, William                         200 Eel Point Road                        Material Change               38/2
Sitting           Mr. McLaughlin, Mr. Roggeveen, Ms. Norton, Ms. Williams, Mrs. Hill Holdgate
Alternates        Ms. Coombs, Ms. McCrae
Representing      Lisa Botticelli
Concerns          Same concerns as before, signed off portions can not be changed, some circumstances have allowed to match, other
                  circumstances have required to conform, Ms. Norton: stick with policy, Mrs. Hill Holdgate: Stick with policy, snap-
                  ins were approved, not just signed off, our guidelines state, our application state our policy
Motion            Ms. Williams approve because they will match pre-existing, signed off 2nd
                  columns
                  Mr. McLaughlin hold to old business
Vote              2-3 (Ms. Norton, Mr. Roggeveen, Mrs. Hill Holdgate)                           Certificate #
                  5-0

23. Normandin, Ann                           7 Fawcett Way - SOHD                   Addition                         73.1.3/64.1
Sitting         Mr. McLaughlin, Mr. Roggeveen, Ms. McCrae, Ms. Williams, Ms. Norton
Alternates      Ms. Coombs, Mrs. Hill Holdgate (recuse)
Representing    Stefano Molinaro, Steven Cohen, Richard Langdon, Paul & Joanne Schold (abutter) concerned about privacy, Jeff
                Stetina (for Abutter Kristin Alexandre)
Concerns        Overall massing, doesn’t fit into neighborhood, appreciates height, window in side of dormer, north elevation
                window pan, recessed balcony, overall project, not a “historical renovation,” ridge height change, changing whole
                appearance of house, obliterating existing structure, too many changes, balcony on end over porch may not have
                precedent, may be able to raise portions of building not whole second floor, show what’s added on, what’s original
Motion          Ms. Williams hold for revisions                                             2nd
Vote            5-0                                                                         Certificate #

24. NHM Realty LLC (Point Breeze)           71 Easton Street                         Addition                            42.3.2/21.2
Sitting         Mr. McLaughlin, Mr. Roggeveen, Ms. Norton, Ms. Williams, Ms. Coombs
Alternates      Mrs. Hill Holdgate (recuse), Ms. McCrae
Representing    Ethan McMorrow, Ted Burnham, Matt MacEachern, Sarah Alger, Jeff Stetina (abutter for North Road and Cliff
                Road) height of structure
Concerns        Ms. Norton: likes project overall, deck across front of structure, better as porch with roof, roofwalk is inappropriate,
                return house element to original hotel design with door around corner, Ms. Williams: tower doesn’t seem to pop, no
                roofwalk, Ms. Coombs: height is well designed, Mr. McLaughlin: should be kept to 30 foot height limit, length of
                structure, Mr. Roggeveen: likes to see history in historic preservation and historic district commission, remove deck
                rather than use as porch, windows have to be TDL, material should not be synthetic, sign permit will be necessary for
                project
Motion          Ms. Williams approve with removal of roofwalk, remove door on south 2nd
                elevation of house (replace with window), remove deck on south
                elevation of main structure, replace doors with windows, with TDL
                windows, , with ongoing staff review of project
Vote            4-1 (Mr. McLaughlin)                                                          Certificate # 47289
                                                     Proposed Minutes for 11/29/05
25. Hathaway, Lawrence                       11 Woodbury Lane                         Roofwalk skirt                   41/55
Sitting         Mr. McLaughlin, Mr. Roggeveen, Ms. Norton, Ms. Williams, Mrs. Hill Holdgate
Alternates      Ms. Coombs, Ms. McCrae
Representing    None (Letter read)
Concerns        Some skirted, some not skirted, there are many skirted roofwalks today
Motion          Ms. Williams deny as architecturally inappropriate given the setting, 2nd
                proliferation of skirt, and type/style of structure the roofwalk is placed
                upon
Vote            5-0                                                                         Certificate #    47290

26. Nantucket Properties One LLC          40 Nobadeer Farm Road                      New Dwelling                      69/32
Sitting          Mr. McLaughlin, Ms. Williams, Ms. Norton, Ms. McCrae
Alternates
Representing     Dave Holcomb
Concerns         Removed snout, replaced with shed
Motion           Ms. Norton approve                                                         2nd
Vote             4-0                                                                        Certificate #    47291

27. Williams, Mark                            16 Williams Street              Color change                             55/372
Sitting          Mr. McLaughlin, Mr. Roggeveen, Ms. Norton, Ms. McCrae, Mrs. Hill Holdgate
Alternates       Ms. Williams (recuse)
Representing     Mark Williams
Concerns         Orange color of clear oil finish
Motion           Ms. McCrae approve unfinished cedar                                 2nd
Vote             5-0                                                                 Certificate #           47292

28. O’Brien, Edward                        9B Hussey Farm Road                     New Dwelling (Main)                 56/96.2
Sitting         Mr. Roggeveen, Ms. Norton, Ms. Williams, Ms. Coombs, Ms. Coombs, Ms. McCrae
Alternates
Representing    Edward O’ Brien
Concerns        East elevation complexity, wall plane without windows, odd spacing of windows, south elevation ganging, flush
                dormers, french doors, front door in secondary element, no additive massing, front entry should be better articulated,
                window too close to corner, north elevation wart window is historically correct, massing is appropriate
Motion          Ms. Williams hold for revisions                                            2nd
Vote            5-0                                                                        Certificate #

29. O’Brien, Edward                        9B Hussey Farm Road              New Dwelling (Secondary)                   56/96.2
Sitting         Mr. Roggeveen, Ms. Norton, Ms. Williams, Ms. Coombs, Ms. Coombs, Ms. McCrae
Alternates
Representing    Edward O’ Brien
Concerns        Dormer design, windows
Motion          Ms. Williams hold for revisions                                    2nd
Vote            5-0                                                                Certificate #

30. The Braes LLC                          25 Baxter Road – Sconset Ext.           New Dwelling                        492.3/11
Sitting         Mr. McLaughlin, Mr. Roggeveen, Ms. Norton, Ms. Williams, Mrs. Hill Holdgate
Alternates      Ms. Coombs, Ms. McCrae
Representing    Lisa Botticelli
Concerns        Ganged windows facing Baxter road, front door panel size, traditional four light, tdl windows
Motion          Ms. Williams approve with four light door on north elevation (larger 2nd
                panel), ungang triples on west elevation, tdl windows with double glaze
Vote            5-0                                                                        Certificate # 47293

31. Tsunami RT                             283 Hummock Pond Road              Dock                                     83/6
Sitting           Mr. Roggeveen, Ms. Williams, Ms. Norton, Ms. Coombs, Ms. McCrae
Alternates
Representing      Lisa Botticelli (clarified legal issues)
Concerns
Motion            Ms. Williams approve                                                      2nd
Vote              4-0 (Ms. McCrae abstain)                                                  Certificate #    47294
                                                Proposed Minutes for 11/29/05

32. McCausland, Peter                        13 Lincoln Avenue                  Retaining Walls                  30/135
Sitting         Ms. Williams, Mrs. Hill Holdgate, Ms. Coombs, Ms. McCrae
Alternates
Representing    Ray Pohl (return hedge after work)
Concerns        Return screening,
Motion          Mrs. Hill Holdgate approve with corrected drawings to not exceed 2 ½ 2nd
                feet, with plantings to be shown on drawings.
Vote            4-0                                                                    Certificate #     47295

Hold remaining applications until Thursday at 1pm

33. Hedge and Home LLC                   25B Washington Street                    Stairs/Balcony                 42.3.2/21
Sitting         Mr. McLaughlin, Mr. Roggeveen, Ms. Norton,
Alternates
Representing    Matt McEachern- representative waives board
Concerns
Motion          Ms. Norton approve                                                       2nd
Vote            3-0                                                                      Certificate #   47296

34. Johnson, David                            150 Polpis Road                       Dormer/Door                  27/14
Sitting          Mr. McLaughlin, Mr. Roggeveen, Ms. Norton,
Alternates
Representing     Fred Church
Concerns         Gable dormer feature too intrusive, might be more appropriate to have one long shed dormer, need 3 ft set back,
                 french door; should be door in between windows
Motion           Ms. Norton approve with east elevation three dormers change to single 2nd
                 shed dormer set 3 ft in, decrease pitch to what will work, doors; option
                 of single door or keep as is
Vote             3-0                                                                      Certificate # 47297
Ms. McCrae arrives at 1:10 pm , Ms. Williams arrives at 1:15 pm
35. Dupont, Rhett                            43 Warren’s Landing Road             New Dwelling                   38/49
Sitting           Mr. McLaughlin, Mr. Roggeveen, Ms. Norton, Ms. Williams
Alternates
Representing      None
Concerns
Motion            Ms. Williams hold for full board                                       2nd
Vote              4-0                                                                    Certificate #

36. Dupont, Rhett                            43 Warren’s Landing Road             Garage/Apartment               38/49
Sitting           Mr. McLaughlin, Mr. Roggeveen, Ms. Norton, Ms. Williams,
Alternates
Representing      None
Concerns
Motion            Ms. Williams hold for full board                                       2nd
Vote              4-0                                                                    Certificate #

37. Walsh Street NT                         17 Walsh Street                         New Dwelling                 42.4.1/13
Sitting           Ms. McCrae
Alternates
Representing      None – hold until beginning of next meeting due to lack of quorum
Concerns
Motion                                                                                   2nd
Vote                                                                                     Certificate #
                                                  Proposed Minutes for 11/29/05

38. Walsh Street NT                          17 Walsh Street                       Garage                                42.4.1/13
Sitting           Ms. McCrae
Alternates
Representing      None- hold until beginning of next meeting due to lack of quorum
Concerns
Motion                                                                                    2nd
Vote                                                                                      Certificate #

39. Oscar Squared Inc.                   68 Cato Lane                                 Major Revisions                    56/424
Sitting          Mr. McLaughlin, Mr. Roggeveen, Ms. Norton, Ms. Williams,
Alternates
Representing     Richard Federov
Concerns
Motion           Ms. Williams approve                                                        2nd
Vote             4-0                                                                         Certificate #    47298

40. Minahan, Betsy                         16 Somerset Road                    Dormers                                   66/3
Sitting          Mr. Roggeveen, Mr. McLaughlin, Ms. Williams, Ms. Norton, Ms. McCrae
Alternates
Representing     Val Oliver, Jerry Minahan – no quorum, applicant waives board
Concerns
Motion           Ms. Williams approve                                                2nd
Vote             5-0                                                                 Certificate #            47299

41. Smithson, Fred                        12 Galen Avenue                          Deck/Door Revisions                   39/116
Sitting          Mr. McLaughlin, Mr. Roggeveen, Ms. Norton, Ms. Williams, Ms. McCrae
Alternates
Representing     Val Oliver,
Concerns         Door should match window on east elevation
Motion           Ms. Williams approve with french door on east elevation to standard 15- 2nd
                 light
Vote             5-0                                                                     Certificate #        47300

42. Auer, Dave                            4 South Cambridge Street - MAB              Addition                           59.4/111
Sitting           Mr. McLaughlin, Mr. Roggeveen, Ms. Norton, Ms. Williams
Alternates
Representing      Val Oliver
Concerns          No shutters, sidelights are too formal, deck not drawn right, all doors should be french doors (south elevation), need
                  to have drawn in what is behind the screen
Motion            Ms. Williams approve with deck pushed back 1 ft on west elevation, 2nd
                  doors french, no shutters, change sidelights
Vote              4-0                                                                         Certificate # 47301

43. Schreiber, Patricia                   8 Lily Street                         Addition                                 42.3.4/8
Sitting           Mr. McLaughlin, Mr. Roggeveen, Ms. Norton, Ms. Williams, Ms. McCrae
Alternates
Representing      Val Oliver
Concerns
Motion            Mr. McLaughlin approve                                               2nd
Vote              5-0                                                                  Certificate #          47302

44. Van De Velde, Maxwell                 12 Coffin Street - SOHD             New Dwelling                               73.4.1/18
Sitting         Mr. McLaughlin, Mr. Roggeveen, Ms. Norton, Ms. Williams, Ms. McCrae
Alternates
Representing    None
Concerns        Not clouded- need to know what is changing
Motion          Ms. Williams hold for clouded drawings                              2nd
Vote            5-0                                                                 Certificate #
                                                    Proposed Minutes for 11/29/05

45. Sullivan, Dennis                          26 Appleton Road                        New Dwelling                        66/30
Sitting           Mr. McLaughlin, Mr. Roggeveen, Ms. Norton, Ms. Williams
Alternates
Representing      Mark Poor
Concerns          Structure in that corner/neighborhood is too large- should be more of a Cape style, too tall, too formal, eave lines too
                  high,
Motion            Ms. Williams hold for revisions                                            2nd
Vote              4-0                                                                        Certificate #

46. Halliwell, Jack                         2 Webster Road                         Pergola                          79/146
Sitting            Mr. McLaughlin, Mr. Roggeveen, Ms. Norton, Ms. Williams, Ms. McCrae
Alternates
Representing       Mark Poor
Concerns           Massive wood posts are going to outside of pergola- pergola should be natural and so should posts, with standard
                   8X8 posts
Motion             Ms. Williams approve with natual, 8X8 square posts                     2nd
Vote               5-0                                                                    Certificate # 47303

47. Boughrum, Richard                     23 Old Tom Nevers Road                   Roofwalk Skirt                         92.4/282
Sitting         Mr. McLaughlin, Mr. Roggeveen, Ms. Norton, Ms. Williams, Ms. McCrae
Alternates
Representing    Mark Poor
Concerns        Chimney needs to be added on to, needs clarification as to what was previously approved
Motion          Ms. Williams hold for previously approval                                 2nd
Vote            5-0                                                                       Certificate #

48. Gerstner, Louis                          10 Berkley Avenue                         Walls                              54/158
Sitting           Ms. Williams, Ms. McCrae
Alternates
Representing      Annie Gilson- hold until next meeting for quorum
Concerns
Motion                                                                                         2nd
Vote                                                                                           Certificate #

49. Gerstner, Louis                          10 Berkley Avenue                         Driveway                           54/158
Sitting           Ms. Williams, Ms. McCrae
Alternates
Representing      Annie Gilson, hold until next meeting for quorum
Concerns
Motion                                                                                         2nd
Vote                                                                                           Certificate #

50. Gerstner, Louis                          10 Berkley Avenue                         Gates                              54/158
Sitting           Ms. Williams Ms. McCrae
Alternates
Representing      Annie Gilson- hold until next meeting for quorum
Concerns
Motion                                                                                         2nd
Vote                                                                                           Certificate #

51. Cross, Carol                           20 India Street                      Arbor/Gate                                42.3.4/22
Sitting            Mr. McLaughlin, Mr. Roggeveen, Ms. Norton (recuse), Ms. McCrae , Ms. Williams
Alternates
Representing       Carol Cross
Concerns           Not Nantucket style, finials inappropriate,
Motion             Ms. Williams approve                                                        2nd
Vote               3-1 Mr. McLaughlin                                                          Certificate #    47304
                                                  Proposed Minutes for 11/29/05
52. Dorton, Patrick                           29 King Street – SOHD             Addition                              73.4.2/101
Sitting           Mr. McLaughlin, Mr. Roggeveen, Ms. Norton, Ms. Williams, Mrs. Hill Holdgate
Alternates        Ms. Coombs, Ms. McCrae
Representing      Pulled by applicant until next Old Business Meeting
Concerns
Motion                                                                                 2nd
Vote                                                                                   Certificate #

53. Conlon, Raymond                    63 South Shore Road                   New Dwelling                             80/306
Sitting         Mr. McLaughlin, Mr.Roggeveen, Ms. Williams, Ms. Norton, Ms. McCrae
Alternates
Representing    Raymond Conlon
Concerns
Motion          Ms. McCrae approve                                                 2nd
Vote            5-0                                                                Certificate #              47305

54. Toce, Margaret                           18 Pequot Street                            New Dwelling                 80/94
Sitting          Mr. McLaughlin, Mr. Roggeveen, Ms. Williams,
Alternates
Representing     Jerome Dixon, Jay McConnell
Concerns         Mass still needs to be broken, east elevation french doors, still too long,
Motion           Ms. Williams hold for revisions                                              2nd
Vote             3-0                                                                          Certificate #

55. Toce, Margaret                         18 Pequot Street                           Garage/Apartment                80/94
Sitting          Mr. McLaughlin, Mr. Roggeveen, Ms. Williams,
Alternates
Representing     Jerome Dixon, Jay McConnell
Concerns
Motion           Ms. Williams hold for new dwelling                                          2nd
Vote             3-0                                                                         Certificate #
Mr. Roggeveen leaves meeting at 2:15pm
56. 6 Eel Point Road Trust                  6 Eel Point Road                       Addition                         40/63
Sitting           Mr. McLaughlin, Ms. Norton, Ms. Williams, Ms. McCrae
Alternates
Representing      Greg Nichols applicant waives board
Concerns          View from Madaket road- too long, some masses should come out rather than added on to length, need up to date site
                  plan, photos from Mr. McLaughlin back up argument that structure would be seen from Madaket road.
Motion            Ms. McCrae hold for revisions                                           2nd
Vote              4-0                                                                     Certificate #


IV.     HDC BUSINESS
Review Minutes -    November 15
Approve Minutes -   October 25, November 1, November 8: November 1, November 8 th adopted by unanimous consent
60 Day Denials -    None
Announcements -     Discussion: Land Bank Meeting Dates
                    Discussion: 9 Capaum Pond Road
                    Discussion: 9 Milk Street
                    Other Business
 8 – OHD             5 - SOHD + 2 – Sconset Ext.                     3 – MAB

				
DOCUMENT INFO