Ppt on Realestate of India

Document Sample
Ppt on Realestate of India Powered By Docstoc
					                                                                                                                                                                         Updated: August 2008



Список аналитических ресурсов по реформе государственного управления в РФ /
List of Analytical Resources on Public Administration Reform in Russia
1. Организационно-структурное развитие / Organizational and structural development
1.1 Оптимизация структуры органов исполнительной власти / Optimization of Executive Authorities Structure
1.2 Экспертиза и оптимизация функций и регулирующих воздействий ОИВ /Assessment and Optimization of Functions and Regulatory Impact of Executive Authorities
1.3 Регламентация деятельности органов исполнительной власти / Regulation (Regulation/ Reglamentation ) of Executive Authorities Operations
2. Организационно-экономические механизмы / Organizational and economic mechanisms
2.1 Оплата служебной деятельности / Remuneration
2.2 Социальное обеспечение государственных служащих / Social security for civil servants
2.3 Планирование и оценка деятельности государственных органов, управление по результатам / Planning and Evaluation of Public Authorities Operations, Performance M anagement
2.4 Проектное управление в деятельности органов исполнительной власти / Project management in operations of Executive Authorities
2.5 Финансирование деятельности органов исполнительной власти, бюджетирование по результатам / Financing of Public Authorities Operations, Performance Budgeting
2.6. Системы аутсорсинга административно-управленческих процессов/Outsourcing of Administrative and M anagement Process
3. Формирование кадрового состава государственной службы / Human resources management in Public Service
3.1 Государственная кадровая политика / State personnel policy
3.2 Кадровые технологии на государственной службе / Human resources technologies in civil service
3.3 Этика государственной службы / Ethics in civil service
4. Подготовка, переподготовка и повышение квалификации / Professional education, in -service training and professional development of the civil servants
4.1 Образовательные программы и модели повышения квалификации / Educational models and programs of professional development
4.2 М еждународные отношения в области образования гражданских служащих / International relations for professional development of civil servants
5. Материально- техническое и информационное обеспечение/ Financial and technical resources
5.1 M атериально-техническое обеспечение деятельности / Financial and technical resources required for civil service operations
5.2 Управление материально-техническими ресурсами / M anagement of financial and technical resources
5.3 Информационное обеспечение деятельности ОИВ /IT Technologies in Executive Authorities
5.4. Повышение эффективности системы закупок для государственных нужд \Increasing Effectiveness of Government Procurement
6. Государственные услуги/ Pu blic S ervices
6.1. Стандарты государственных услуг./ Standards of Public Services
6.2 М ониторинг и оценка качества государственных услуг / M onitoring and Evaluation of Public Services Quality
6.3 Аутсорсинг государственных услуг / Outsourcing of Public Services
6.4. М ногофункциональные центры государственных и муниципальных услуг / M ultifunctional centers of public and municipal services
6.5. Использование информационно-коммуникационных технологий и системы электронного правительства в предоставлении государственных услуг / Use of information &
communication technologies and e-government in delivery of public services
7. Взаимодействие органов исполнительной власти и общества / S tate and S ociety Interaction
7.1. Информационная прозрачность органов исполнительной власти / Access to information and transparency of executive power
7.2 Антикоррупционные механиз мы / Anticorruption M echanisms
7.3 М еханиз мы досудебного обжалования / M echanisms of Pre-Court Appellations
8. Управление реформой государственной службы и административной реформой / Management of the Civil Service reform and Administrative reform
8.1 Нормативно-правовое обеспечение реформы / Normative and regulatory framework for reform implementation
8.2 Научно-методическое обеспечение реформы / Scientific and methodological support for reform implementation
8.3 Информационное сопровождение реформы / Information support for the reform

Prepa red by the WB/DFID Development Pa rtners Secreta ria t for Governance Reforms in Russia. You a re welcome to send informa tion on new resources to be i ncluded in this database to   1
Tumun Ts ydypov a t tts ydypov@worldbank.org / Подготовлено Секретариа том партнеров по ра звитию в обла сти реформы госуда рственного упра вления в России (Всемирный
Ба нк/Министерство Международного Ра звития Великобрита нии). Просим на правлять информацию о ма териа ла х для включения в ба зу да нных Тумуну Цыдыпову по а дресу
tts ydypov@worldbank.org
                                                                                                                                                                         Updated: August 2008


8.4 Вклад международных проектов в реформу / Impact of international projects
8.5 М ониторинг и оценка хода реформ / M onitoring and evaluation




Prepa red by the WB/DFID Development Pa rtners Secreta ria t for Governance Reforms in Russia. You a re welcome to send informa tion on new resources to be i ncluded in this database to   2
Tumun Ts ydypov a t tts ydypov@worldbank.org / Подготовлено Секретариа том партнеров по ра звитию в обла сти реформы госуда рственного упра вления в России (Всемирный
Ба нк/Министерство Международного Ра звития Великобрита нии). Просим на правлять информацию о ма териа ла х для включения в ба зу да нных Тумуну Цыдыпову по а дресу
tts ydypov@worldbank.org
                                                                                                                                                                            Updated: August 2008




                                                                                                                                                       Technical                Доступ к файлам / Access
Тема / Topic               Раздел/Sub-theme                                         Список ресурсов/List of resources                                  assistance               to the file
                                                                                                                                                       project/Source           Англ./ Eng.  Русский /
                                                                                                                                                                                             Russian
1. Организационно-         1.1 Оптимизация                  Modernization of the Federal Civil Service: Methodology for Functional                     World Ban k              Func_review     Func_revie
структурное                структуры органов                Reviews, Neil Parison and Nick Manning, 2002                                                                        s_eng.pdf       ws_rus.pdf
развитие /                 исполнительной власти /          International Public Ad min istration Reform: Imp lications for the Russian                                         Int. Public     Int. Public
Organizational and         Optimization of Executive        Federation, Neil Parison and Nick Manning, 2003                                            World Ban k              Admin_eng       Admin_rus
structural                 Authorities Structure
development

                                                            Determining Govern ment Structure and Functions: Program and Functional                    World Ban k              Determining_    Determining
                                                            Reviews, Neil Parison and Nick Manning, October 2004, Moscow, World Bank                                            the_structure   _the_structu
                                                                                                                                                                                _Parison_eng    re_Parison_r
                                                                                                                                                                                .doc            us.doc
                                                            I. Leksin, A. Shvetsov, Status of Delimitation of Authority and Interaction                CIDA Public                              CIDA_Repo
                                                            Between Federal Bodies of Govern ment and Bodies of Govern ment of RF                      Admin istration                          rtSocialRus.
                                                            Subjects in the Social Sphere, December 2003.                                              Reform pro ject                          doc




                                                            I. Leksin, A. Shvetsov, Status of Delimitation of Authority and Interaction                CIDA Public                              federal-
                                                            Between Federal Bodies of Govern ment and Bodies of Govern ment of RF                      Admin istration                          subject
                                                            Subjects in the Minerals Sector, December 2003.                                            Reform pro ject                          relations_ne
                                                                                                                                                                                                dropolzovan
                                                                                                                                                                                                ie.doc
                                                            Pierre Schreiber, Co mparative Chart “Main systems of civ il service in the EU             European                                 Co mparative
                                                            applying to municipalities”                                                                Co mmission,                             chart_munic
                                                                                                                                                       Public                                   ipal
                                                                                                                                                       Admin istration                          service_rus.
                                                                                                                                                       Reform in Russia                         doc




   Prepa red by the WB/DFID Development Pa rtners Secreta ria t for Governance Reforms in Russia. You a re welcome to send informa tion on new resources to be i ncluded in this database to    3
   Tumun Ts ydypov a t tts ydypov@worldbank.org / Подготовлено Секретариа том партнеров по ра звитию в обла сти реформы госуда рственного упра вления в России (Всемирный
   Ба нк/Министерство Международного Ра звития Великобрита нии). Просим на правлять информацию о ма териа ла х для включения в ба зу да нных Тумуну Цыдыпову по а дресу
   tts ydypov@worldbank.org
                                                                                                                                                                         Updated: August 2008


                                                         Ray mond Piganio l, Czech Republic Public Service And The Administrative                   European                                Chech
                                                         Framework Assessment, 2003                                                                 Co mmission,                            Republic_A
                                                                                                                                                    Public                                  ssessment of
                                                                                                                                                    Admin istration                         Public
                                                                                                                                                    Reform in Russia                        Service.doc
                                                         Ray mond Piganio l, Hungary Public Service and The Admin istrative Framework               European                                Hungary_Pu
                                                         Assessment, 2003                                                                           Co mmission,                            blic
                                                                                                                                                    Public                                  Service_Ass
                                                                                                                                                    Admin istration                         essment_20
                                                                                                                                                    Reform in Russia                        03
                                                         Ray mond Piganio l, Presentation: Which civil service in Europe?                           European                 Which civil
                                                                                                                                                    Co mmission,             service in
                                                                                                                                                    Public                   Europe.ppt
                                                                                                                                                    Admin istration
                                                                                                                                                    Reform in Russia
                                                         Jean-Loup PETIT, State Governance and Public Sector reform in France,                      European                                State
                                                         Presentation                                                                               Co mmission,                            reform_Fran
                                                                                                                                                    Public                                  ce_rus.doc
                                                                                                                                                    Admin istration
                                                                                                                                                    Reform in Russia
                                                         Zoran NERANDZIC, «Civ il Serv ice in Czech Republic», Presentation                         European                                State
                                                                                                                                                    Co mmission,                            Service_ Che
                                                                                                                                                    Public                                  ch
                                                                                                                                                    Admin istration                         Republic_ru
                                                                                                                                                    Reform in Russia                        s.ppt
                                                         Final Publication of the Tacis PAR p roject: «Materials of the roundtable on               European                                Functional
                                                         functional analysis in the Federal structures of executive power»                          Co mmission,                            analysis_rou
                                                                                                                                                    Public                                  ndtable.rtf
                                                                                                                                                    Admin istration
                                                                                                                                                    Reform in Russia




Prepa red by the WB/DFID Development Pa rtners Secreta ria t for Governance Reforms in Russia. You a re welcome to send informa tion on new resources to be i ncluded in this database to   4
Tumun Ts ydypov a t tts ydypov@worldbank.org / Подготовлено Секретариа том партнеров по ра звитию в обла сти реформы госуда рственного упра вления в России (Всемирный
Ба нк/Министерство Международного Ра звития Великобрита нии). Просим на правлять информацию о ма териа ла х для включения в ба зу да нных Тумуну Цыдыпову по а дресу
tts ydypov@worldbank.org
                                                                                                                                                                         Updated: August 2008


                                                         Shrin king Smart ly: Downsizing Options Simu lation Exercise (DOSE)                        World Ban k              http://web.wo
                                                                                                                                                                             rldbank.org/
                                                                                                                                                                             WBSITE/ EX
                                                                                                                                                                             TERNA L/EX
                                                                                                                                                                             TDEC/ EXTR
                                                                                                                                                                             ESEARCH/ E
                                                                                                                                                                             XTDECSHR
                                                                                                                                                                             SMA/0,,men
                                                                                                                                                                             uPK:1330305
                                                                                                                                                                             ~pagePK:641
                                                                                                                                                                             68427~piPK:
                                                                                                                                                                             64168435~th
                                                                                                                                                                             eSitePK:1330
                                                                                                                                                                             293,00.ht ml

                                                         Admin istrative reform. Executive Agencies: in itial issues for structural                 World Ban k                              Exec.
                                                         development. Analytical report prepared for the Govern ment of the RF.                                                              Agencies1.d
                                                         February 2002                                                                                                                       oc
                                                         Rob Laking, Ad min istrative reform. Executive Agencies: benefits and risks.                                                        Agencies
                                                         September 2002.                                                                                                                     Benefits and
                                                                                                                                                                                             Risks_rus2
                                                         Minimizing Negative Distributional Effects in Pub lic Sector Downsizing,                   World Ban k              http://www1.
                                                         PREM Note 84, World Ban k, April 2004                                                                               worldbank.or
                                                                                                                                                                             g/prem/PRE
                                                                                                                                                                             MNotes/prem
                                                                                                                                                                             note84.pdf
                                                         Executive Agencies in UK – study tour informat ion material                                DFID Public              Executive       Executive
                                                                                                                                                    Admin istration          Agencies in     Agencies in
                                                                                                                                                    Reform Project           UK_eng.doc      UK_rus.doc



                                                         Executive Review Process                                                                   DFID Public              Executive       Executive
                                                                                                                                                    Admin istration          Review          Review
                                                                                                                                                    Reform Project           Process_eng.    Process_rus.
                                                                                                                                                                             doc             doc



Prepa red by the WB/DFID Development Pa rtners Secreta ria t for Governance Reforms in Russia. You a re welcome to send informa tion on new resources to be i ncluded in this database to    5
Tumun Ts ydypov a t tts ydypov@worldbank.org / Подготовлено Секретариа том партнеров по ра звитию в обла сти реформы госуда рственного упра вления в России (Всемирный
Ба нк/Министерство Международного Ра звития Великобрита нии). Просим на правлять информацию о ма териа ла х для включения в ба зу да нных Тумуну Цыдыпову по а дресу
tts ydypov@worldbank.org
                                                                                                                                                                         Updated: August 2008


                                                         Independent Regulators and the UK Financial Services Authority (FSA) -                     DFID Public              Independent     Independent
                                                         Report                                                                                     Admin istration          regulators_re   regulators_r
                                                                                                                                                    Reform Project           port_eng.doc    eport_rus.do
                                                                                                                                                                                             c


                                                         Public Ad ministration Reform -Federalism: Intergovernmental Relations in                  CIDA Public              Elder_Sep04     Elder_Sep04
                                                         Canada, D. Elder - Presentation at the conference “State Governance Reform                 Admin istration          _eng.ppt        _rus.ppt
                                                         and Its Implementation at the Regional Level”, September 2004, Moscow                      Reform Project



                                                         Report of DFID Pro ject on Public Admin istration and Civil Serv ice Reform -              DFID Public              Report on       Report on
                                                         Phase 3. The Review of the Federal Executive Body                                          Admin istration          Phase 3 of      Phase 3 of
                                                                                                                                                    Reform Project           ERP_eng.doc     ERP_ rus.do
                                                                                                                                                                                             c


                                                         Rebuilding State Structures: Methods and Approaches, UNDP/ RBEC Po licy                    UNDP/ RBEC               State_Structu
                                                         Advocacy Papers, 2001                                                                                               res_UNDP_i
                                                                                                                                                                             ntro_eng.zip



                                                         Structure and Legal Framework of the Public Service in Germany, Joachim                    European                 Structure_SC    Structure_S
                                                         Vo llmuth, 2005                                                                            Co mmission,             _Germany_e      C_ Germany
                                                                                                                                                    Public                   ng.doc          _rus.doc
                                                                                                                                                    Admin istration
                                                                                                                                                    Reform in Russia
                                                         General Framework and Abstracts fro m the Federal Law on Organization of                   European                 Framework_      Framework_
                                                         Work of the German Federal M inistries, Joachim Vo llmuth, 2005                            Co mmission,             Germany_en      Germany_ru
                                                                                                                                                    Public                   g.doc           s.doc
                                                                                                                                                    Admin istration
                                                                                                                                                    Reform in Russia




Prepa red by the WB/DFID Development Pa rtners Secreta ria t for Governance Reforms in Russia. You a re welcome to send informa tion on new resources to be i ncluded in this database to    6
Tumun Ts ydypov a t tts ydypov@worldbank.org / Подготовлено Секретариа том партнеров по ра звитию в обла сти реформы госуда рственного упра вления в России (Всемирный
Ба нк/Министерство Международного Ра звития Великобрита нии). Просим на правлять информацию о ма териа ла х для включения в ба зу да нных Тумуну Цыдыпову по а дресу
tts ydypov@worldbank.org
                                                                                                                                                                         Updated: August 2008


                                                         Managing Intergovernmental Relations in Canada, D. Elder, R. Robinson,                     CIDA Public              Intergov_rel_   Intergov_rel
                                                         Canadian School of Public Ad min istration, January 2005                                   Admin istration          Canada_eng.     _Canada_ru
                                                                                                                                                    Reform pro ject          doc             s.doc



                                                         Priorit ies for Intergovernmental Cooperation: a Canadian Perspective, R.                  CIDA Public              Robinson_Uf     Robinson_U
                                                         Robinson, presentation at the conference on intergovernmental cooperation,                 Admin istration          a2005_eng.p     fa2005_rus.
                                                         Ufa, April 2005                                                                            Reform pro ject          pt              ppt



                                                         General Questions of Organization of Co-operation of State Authorities of the              CIDA Public                              Cooperation
                                                         RF and of Its Constituent Entities, Foundation for Legal Issues in Federalism              Admin istration                          _rus.doc
                                                         and Local Self-Governance, November 2004                                                   Reform pro ject



                                                         Structural and Organizat ional Refo rm: the Achilles‟ Heel of Admin istrative              World Ban k              Verheijen_fu    Verheijen_f
                                                         Reform, T. Verheijen, p resentation at the project launch seminar in Ko mi                                          nct_review_     unct_review
                                                         Republic, May 2005, World Ban k                                                                                     Ko mi_eng.pp    _Komi_rus.
                                                                                                                                                                             t               ppt


                                                         Ko mi Republic: Functional Rev iew in the Bodies of Executive Authorities, A.              World Ban k              Medvedev_K      Medvedev_
                                                         Medvedev, presentation in Ko mi Republic, May 2005, World Bank                                                      omi_eng.ppt     Ko mi_rus.p
                                                                                                                                                                                             pt



                                                         The Relationship Between Min istries/Agencies/Services, Discussion paper,                  DFID Public              Min_ag_serv     Min_ag_ser
                                                         June 2005                                                                                  Admin istration          _eng.doc        v_rus.doc
                                                                                                                                                    Reform Project




Prepa red by the WB/DFID Development Pa rtners Secreta ria t for Governance Reforms in Russia. You a re welcome to send informa tion on new resources to be i ncluded in this database to    7
Tumun Ts ydypov a t tts ydypov@worldbank.org / Подготовлено Секретариа том партнеров по ра звитию в обла сти реформы госуда рственного упра вления в России (Всемирный
Ба нк/Министерство Международного Ра звития Великобрита нии). Просим на правлять информацию о ма териа ла х для включения в ба зу да нных Тумуну Цыдыпову по а дресу
tts ydypov@worldbank.org
                                                                                                                                                                         Updated: August 2008


                                                         The Organization of General Directorates for Civil Serv ice in European                    European                 Europe_CSm     Europe_CS
                                                         Member States, R. Piganiol, June 2005                                                      Co mmission,             anagement_e    management
                                                                                                                                                    Public                   ng.doc         _rus.doc
                                                                                                                                                    Admin istration
                                                                                                                                                    Reform in Russia
                                                          Administrative Structure of a State, Workshop Materials, September 2004.                  European Union                          State_adm_s
                                                                                                                                                    Project “Siv il                         tructure_rus.
                                                                                                                                                    Service Reform”                         doc
                                                                                                                                                    (Administrative
                                                                                                                                                    Reform II)
                                                         .Administrative System of a State, Workshop Materials, September 2004.                     European Union                          State_adm_
                                                                                                                                                    Project “Siv il                         mechanis m_
                                                                                                                                                    Service Reform”                         rus.doc
                                                                                                                                                    (Administrative
                                                                                                                                                    Reform II)
                                                         .Public Civ il Service: principles and reforms, Workshop Materials, September              Проект                                  CS_principl
                                                         2004.                                                                                      Европейско го                           es&reforms
                                                                                                                                                    Союза «Реформа                          _rus.doc
                                                                                                                                                    государственной
                                                                                                                                                    службы»
                                                                                                                                                    (Административн
                                                                                                                                                    ая реформа-II)
                                                                                                                                                    European Union
                                                                                                                                                    Project “Siv il
                                                                                                                                                    Service Reform”
                                                                                                                                                    (Administrative
                                                                                                                                                    Reform II)
                                                         Functional and operational review of a public authority. Se minar " Realization            МЕDT-World                              Executive_
                                                         of the Concept of administrative reform in the Russian Federation in 2006 -                Bank                                    Authorities-
                                                         2008: coordination of actions at federal and reg ional levels ", December 15-16                                                    researchDec
                                                         2005, Moscow.                                                                                                                      2005_rus.pp
                                                                                                                                                                                            t




Prepa red by the WB/DFID Development Pa rtners Secreta ria t for Governance Reforms in Russia. You a re welcome to send informa tion on new resources to be i ncluded in this database to   8
Tumun Ts ydypov a t tts ydypov@worldbank.org / Подготовлено Секретариа том партнеров по ра звитию в обла сти реформы госуда рственного упра вления в России (Всемирный
Ба нк/Министерство Международного Ра звития Великобрита нии). Просим на правлять информацию о ма териа ла х для включения в ба зу да нных Тумуну Цыдыпову по а дресу
tts ydypov@worldbank.org
                                                                                                                                                                         Updated: August 2008


                                                         Functional analysis in public authorities. Seminar " Realization of the Concept            МЕDT-World                              Functional_
                                                         of administrative reform in the Russian Federation in 2006-2008: coordination              Bank                                    analysisDec
                                                         of actions at federal and regional levels ", December 15-16 2005, Moscow.                                                          2005-rus.ppt



                                                         «Functional Analysis of the Executive authorities‟ act ivities. Methodology ”.             World Ban k/DFID                        FA_method
                                                                                                                                                    Trust Fund                              ology_prese
                                                         Presentation by A. Medvedev, seminar “Introducing elements of performance
                                                         management at the regional level”, Saratov, Feb.28 – March 01, 2006                                                                ntation_rus.r
                                                                                                                                                                                            ar


                                                         «Methods of functional analysis in executive authorities”, A. Medvedev,                    World Ban k/DFID                        Draft
                                                                                                                                                    Trust Fund                              methodolog
                                                         seminar “Introducing elements of performance management at the regional
                                                         level”, Saratov, Feb.28 – March 01, 2006                                                                                           y_FA_Medv
                                                                                                                                                                                            edev_feb06_
                                                                                                                                                                                            rus.doc


                                                         Pilot optimizat ion of functions of an executive authority. Distributing functions         Russian Business                        2_repnikov_
                                                                                                                                                    Systems Auditing                        rus.ppt
                                                         according to management levels. Approaches to development of regulations of
                                                         administrative procedures. Pilot authorities: Min istry of Transport and Federal           and Consulting
                                                         Labor. Presentation by Mr. Repnikov at the conference «Implementation of the               Group
                                                         Concept on Administrative Reform in RF within the Framework of Institutional
                                                         and Regional Programmes: Imp lementation Mechanis ms and Support»,
                                                         February 17-18, 2006
                                                         Functional analysis at the regional level. Automatizat ion of FA in To msk                 Consultancy                             Automatizat
                                                         Region. Presentation by E. Moro zova at the training “Administrative Reform in             “Stavka”                                ion_Tomsk_
                                                         Russia: train ing course”, Pyatigorsk, September 2006                                                                              rus.ppt




Prepa red by the WB/DFID Development Pa rtners Secreta ria t for Governance Reforms in Russia. You a re welcome to send informa tion on new resources to be i ncluded in this database to   9
Tumun Ts ydypov a t tts ydypov@worldbank.org / Подготовлено Секретариа том партнеров по ра звитию в обла сти реформы госуда рственного упра вления в России (Всемирный
Ба нк/Министерство Международного Ра звития Великобрита нии). Просим на правлять информацию о ма териа ла х для включения в ба зу да нных Тумуну Цыдыпову по а дресу
tts ydypov@worldbank.org
                                                                                                                                                                         Updated: August 2008


                                                          Functional reviews in Slovakia – experiences and lessons. M. Beblavy,                     Slovak Governance        Slovakia_exp   Slovakia_ex
                                                         materials for the training “Administrative Reform in Russia: training course”,             Institute                erience_eng.   perience_rus
                                                         Pyatigorsk, September 2006                                                                                          doc            .doc




                                                                                                                                                    Slovak Governance        FA_how_to_     FA_how_to
                                                          Functional reviews – why, what and how? Presentation by Miroslav Beblavý,                 Institute                eng.ppt        _rus.ppt
                                                         for the train ing “Administrative Reform in Rus sia: training course”, Pyatigorsk,
                                                         September 2006




                        1.2 Экспер тиза и                Scheme of Executive Power Authorities in Regulation of Entrepreneurial                     EuropeAid/114008/                       Infrustaructu
                        оптимизация функций и            Activities, Deregulation and Administrative Barriers Removal. . Deregulat ion to           C/SV/ RU                                re_of_state_
                        регулирующих                     the Economy and Removal of Administrative Barriers, Russian Federation.                                                            bodies_rus.p
                        воздействий ОИВ                  October 2004.                                                                                                                      df
                        /Assessment and
                        Optimization of Functions
                        and Regulatory Impact of
                        Executive Authorities
                                                         Develop ment of Legal Regulat ion in Licensing. Deregulat ion to the Economy               EuropeAid/114008/                       Licensing_r
                                                         and Removal of Administrative Barriers, Russian Federation. October 2004.                  C/SV/ RU                                us.pdf




                                                         Description of Cert ification and Accreditation System in Certifying Agencies              EuropeAid/114008/                       Cert ification
                                                         and Testing Laboratories prior to enforcement of Federal Law “On Technical                 C/SV/ RU                                _accreditatio
                                                         Regulation”. Deregulation to the Economy and Removal of Ad ministrative                                                            n_systems_r
                                                         Barriers, Russian Federation. October 2004.                                                                                        u.pdf




Prepa red by the WB/DFID Development Pa rtners Secreta ria t for Governance Reforms in Russia. You a re welcome to send informa tion on new resources to be i ncluded in this database to   10
Tumun Ts ydypov a t tts ydypov@worldbank.org / Подготовлено Секретариа том партнеров по ра звитию в обла сти реформы госуда рственного упра вления в России (Всемирный
Ба нк/Министерство Международного Ра звития Великобрита нии). Просим на правлять информацию о ма териа ла х для включения в ба зу да нных Тумуну Цыдыпову по а дресу
tts ydypov@worldbank.org
                                                                                                                                                                         Updated: August 2008


                                                         Application of Appraisal Methods of Regulatory Impact on Accreditation                     EuropeAid/114008/                        Conformity_
                                                         Legislature. Deregulation to the Economy and Removal of Ad min istrative                   C/SV/ RU                                 assessment_
                                                         Barriers, Russian Federation. April 2005.                                                                                           in_accreditat
                                                                                                                                                                                             ion_rus.pdf


                                                         Proposals in Development of Legislature. Improving Effectiveness of Licensing              EuropeAid/114008/                        Licensing_o
                                                         of Entrepreneurial Activit ies. . Deregulat ion to the Economy and Removal of              C/SV/ RU                                 f-
                                                         Admin istrative Barriers, Russian Federation. October 2004.                                                                         enterpreneur
                                                                                                                                                                                             s._rus.pdf


                                                         Setting up of National Accreditation System. Deregulat ion to the Economy and              EuropeAid/114008/        Accreditation
                                                         Removal of Ad min istrative Barriers, Russian Federation. October 2004.                    C/SV/ RU                 _eu_experien
                                                                                                                                                                             ce_eng.pdf



                                                         State Quality System in Poland. Polish center of Accreditation. Deregulation to                                                     Polish_quali
                                                         the Economy and Removal of Administrative Barriers, Russian Federation.                                                             ty_system_r
                                                         October 2004.                                                                                                                       us.pdf



                                                         Assessment of Regulatory Impact of Govern ment Degree Project “Procedure of                EuropeAid/114008/                        State_regula
                                                         Accreditation of Certifying Bod ies and Testing laboratories ” .Deregulation to            C/SV/ RU                                 tion_accredit
                                                         the Economy and Removal of Administrative Barriers, Russian Federation.                                                             ation_rus.pd
                                                         October 2004.                                                                                                                       f


                                                         Regulatory Impact Valuation. EC Experiences. Ninneta Hannetu. Deregulation                 EuropeAid/114008/                        Regulatory_
                                                         to the Economy and Removal of Ad ministrative Barriers, Russian Federation.                C/SV/ RU                                 policies_pra
                                                         April 2005.                                                                                                                         ctices_eu_ru
                                                                                                                                                                                             s.pdf




Prepa red by the WB/DFID Development Pa rtners Secreta ria t for Governance Reforms in Russia. You a re welcome to send informa tion on new resources to be i ncluded in this database to    11
Tumun Ts ydypov a t tts ydypov@worldbank.org / Подготовлено Секретариа том партнеров по ра звитию в обла сти реформы госуда рственного упра вления в России (Всемирный
Ба нк/Министерство Международного Ра звития Великобрита нии). Просим на правлять информацию о ма териа ла х для включения в ба зу да нных Тумуну Цыдыпову по а дресу
tts ydypov@worldbank.org
                                                                                                                                                                         Updated: August 2008


                                                         Methods of Calculat ions of Individual Indicators of State Regulation of                   EuropeAid/114008/                       State_regula
                                                         Entrepreneurial Activ ities. Deregulation to the Econo my and Removal of                   C/SV/ RU                                tion_method
                                                         Admin istrative Barriers, Russian Federation. April 2005.                                                                          ology_indic
                                                                                                                                                                                            ators_rus.pd
                                                                                                                                                                                            f
                                                         Application of Methods of Regulatory Impact Assessment in Decisionmaking                   EuropeAid/114008/                       State_regula
                                                         in State regulation of Entrepreneurial Activit ies of . Deregulat ion to the               C/SV/ RU                                tion_method
                                                         Economy and Removal of Ad min istrative Barriers, Russian Federation. April                                                        ology_rus.p
                                                         2005.                                                                                                                              df


                                                         Admin istrative Barrier Assessment in four Regions (Sankt-Petersbourg,                     EuropeAid/114008/                       State_regula
                                                         Kaliningradskaya, Novgorodskaya, and Sverdlovskaya areas) . Deregulat ion to               C/SV/ RU                                tion_admin_
                                                         the Economy and Removal of Administrative Barriers, Russian Federation.                                                            barriers_rus.
                                                         April 2005.                                                                                                                        pdf


                                                         Appraisal of Survey of Cert ify ing Bodies and Testing Laboratories Executives.            EuropeAid/114008/                       State_regula
                                                         Deregulation to the Econo my and Removal of Ad ministrative Barriers, Russ ian             C/SV/ RU                                tion_certific
                                                         Federation. April 2005..                                                                                                           ation_rus.pd
                                                                                                                                                                                            f


                                                         Report on Interviewing of Federal Executive Authorities Representatives in                 EuropeAid/114008/                       State_regula
                                                         terms of State Policy towards Deregulat ion and Removal of Ad min istrative                C/SV/ RU                                tion_survey
                                                         Barriers. Deregulation to the Economy and Removal of Ad min istrative Barriers,                                                    _rus.pdf
                                                         Russian Federation. April 2005..


                                                         Develop ment of Policy towards Deregulation and Removal of Ad ministrative                 EuropeAid/114008/                       State_regula
                                                         Barriers at Local Municipals. Deregulation to the Economy and Removal of                   C/SV/ RU                                tion_deregul
                                                         Admin istrative Barriers, Russian Federation. April 2005..                                                                         ation_rus.pd
                                                                                                                                                                                            f




Prepa red by the WB/DFID Development Pa rtners Secreta ria t for Governance Reforms in Russia. You a re welcome to send informa tion on new resources to be i ncluded in this database to   12
Tumun Ts ydypov a t tts ydypov@worldbank.org / Подготовлено Секретариа том партнеров по ра звитию в обла сти реформы госуда рственного упра вления в России (Всемирный
Ба нк/Министерство Международного Ра звития Великобрита нии). Просим на правлять информацию о ма териа ла х для включения в ба зу да нных Тумуну Цыдыпову по а дресу
tts ydypov@worldbank.org
                                                                                                                                                                         Updated: August 2008


                                                         Analytical Report on State Policy towards Deregulat ion and Removal of                     EuropeAid/114008/                       State_policy
                                                         Admin istrative Barriers at Regional and Municipal Levels of North-West                    C/SV/ RU                                _on_deregul
                                                         Federal d istrict .Prepared by Elena Shkoda for Consulting Center “Business -                                                      ation_econo
                                                         Tezaurus” and Euroconsultants. Deregulation to the Econo my and Removal of                                                         my_rus.pdf
                                                         Admin istrative Barriers, Russian Federation. April 2005..
                                                         Appraisal of State Measures on Debureaucratizat ion of Economy and Removal                 EuropeAid/114008/                       State_regula
                                                         of Administrative Barriers. Deregulation to the Econo my and Removal of                    C/SV/ RU                                tion_econo
                                                         Admin istrative Barriers, Russian Federation. October 2004.                                                                        mics_rus.pdf



                                                         Quality system. EU experience.                                                             Europe Aid :                            Quality_syst
                                                                                                                                                    114008/ C/SV/ RU                        em_eu_pract
                                                                                                                                                                                            ices_rus.pdf



                                                         Improving the quality of decision-making in state regulation of business                                                           State_regula
                                                         activities. Regulatory Impact. October 2005.                                                                                       tion_quality
                                                                                                                                                                                            _rus.pdf



                                                         Introducing elements of performance auditing in executive authorities.                     CEFC/ Donor                             Audit_rus.p
                                                         Presentation by O. Alexandrov at the conference “Admin istrative reform at the             Secretariat for                         pt
                                                         regional level”, 2006                                                                      Admin istrative and
                                                                                                                                                    Civil Service
                                                                                                                                                    Reforms
                                                         REGULATORY REFORM IN GREECE. Efi Stefanopoulou. Presentation for                           Hellenic Ministry        Greek_Regul
                                                         the learning visit of the Russian delegation on KEPs, Ju ly 2008                           of Interior              atory_Refor
                                                                                                                                                                             m_eng.ppt




Prepa red by the WB/DFID Development Pa rtners Secreta ria t for Governance Reforms in Russia. You a re welcome to send informa tion on new resources to be i ncluded in this database to   13
Tumun Ts ydypov a t tts ydypov@worldbank.org / Подготовлено Секретариа том партнеров по ра звитию в обла сти реформы госуда рственного упра вления в России (Всемирный
Ба нк/Министерство Международного Ра звития Великобрита нии). Просим на правлять информацию о ма териа ла х для включения в ба зу да нных Тумуну Цыдыпову по а дресу
tts ydypov@worldbank.org
                                                                                                                                                                         Updated: August 2008


                                                         Presentations from the interreg ional seminar on Regulatory Impact Assessment.             WB                                      RIA_worksh
                                                         Krasnodar, May 2008                                                                                                                op_Krasnod
                                                                                                                                                                                            ar_2008_rus
                                                                                                                                                                                            .zip


                        1.3 Регламентация                Develop ment and Pilot Imp lementation of Regulat ions for Administrative                  MoEDT                                   1_parshin_r
                        деятельности органов             Procedures. Presentation by M. Parshin at the conference «Implementation of                                                        us.ppt
                        исполнительной власти /          the Concept on Admin istrative Reform in RF within the Framework of
                        Regulation (Regulat ion/         Institutional and Regional Programmes: Imp lementation Mechanisms and
                        Reglamentation ) of              Support», February 17-18, 2006
                        Executive Authorities
                        Operations
                                                         Proposals for Licensing Tele/Rad io Broadcasting. Presentation by Dr A xel G               EC pro ject “Public      PSIR_ Broadc   PSIR_ Broad
                                                         Koetz and Andrey Zhulin, seminar “Draft ing Administrative Regulations II”,                Sector Institutional     asting_eng.p   casting_rus.
                                                         2006                                                                                       Reform”                  pt             ppt


                                                         Introducing regulations of admin istrative procedures related to land registration         Mayorate of the                         Admin
                                                         services. Presentation by S. Ponamarenko, city mayor o f Shakhty, at the                   city of Shakhty                         reglament_S
                                                         seminar “Administrative reform at the regional level”, 2006                                                                        hakhty_rus.p
                                                                                                                                                                                            pt
                                                         Gu idelines and practice of developing regulations of administrative procedures.           HSE/ EC Pro ject                        Admin
                                                         Presentation by A. Klimenko and A. Zhulin at the seminar “Ad min istrative                 “Public Sector                          reglament_
                                                         reform at the regional level”, 2006                                                        Institutional                           Klimen ko_r
                                                                                                                                                    Reform”                                 us.ppt


                                                                                                                                                    “Pro-gramma”                            Admreglam
                                                                                                                                                    consultancy                             enty_Pyatig
                                                         Developing regulations for ad ministrative procedures related to public services
                                                                                                                                                                                            orsk_rus
                                                         and government functions. Presentation by A. Veretnov at the training
                                                                                                                                                                                            (folder)
                                                         “Admin istrative Reform in Russia: train ing course”, Pyatigorsk, September
                                                         2006




Prepa red by the WB/DFID Development Pa rtners Secreta ria t for Governance Reforms in Russia. You a re welcome to send informa tion on new resources to be i ncluded in this database to   14
Tumun Ts ydypov a t tts ydypov@worldbank.org / Подготовлено Секретариа том партнеров по ра звитию в обла сти реформы госуда рственного упра вления в России (Всемирный
Ба нк/Министерство Международного Ра звития Великобрита нии). Просим на правлять информацию о ма териа ла х для включения в ба зу да нных Тумуну Цыдыпову по а дресу
tts ydypov@worldbank.org
                                                                                                                                                                            Updated: August 2008


                                                            Regulation of ad ministrative procedure “Subsidies for paying housing costs”.              Depart ment for                         Subsidies_re
                                                            Presentation on a study tour to Tomsk region, November 2006                                Social Assistance,                      gulation_rus
                                                                                                                                                       Tomsk Reg ional                         .ppt



                                                            Standardization and Reglamentation of Public Services: Results and                         Donor                                   Elista Day
                                                            Reco mmendations fro m Pilot Pro jects. Presentations from the final seminar of            Secretaria/World                        2_rus.zip
                                                            Interregional pro ject “Introduction of Perfo rmance Management Elements at                Bank
                                                            Sub-National Level in the Russian Federation”, 2007

                                                            On activit ies of the Working Group on development of proposals of                         Higher School of                        Yakobson_
                                                            administrative regulations. Lev Yakobson. Presentation at the annual                       Economics                               WG_ad min_
                                                            “Admin istrative reform 2008” conference, March 2008                                                                               regulations_
                                                                                                                                                                                               2008_rus.pp
                                                                                                                                                                                               t
2. Организационно-         2.1 Оплата служебной             A. Klimenko, Ye. Berezdivina, N. Klisch, Study of the Public Payroll Planning              CIDA, Public                            CIDA_Klim
экономические              деятельности /                   Procedures and Methods Used in Russia as an Element of Justification of                    Admin istration                         enkoReport_
механизмы /                Remuneration                     Financial Needs of the Structures of Executive Power (Draft Version), March                Reform                                  rus
Organizational and                                          2004.
economic mechanisms




                                                            A. Klimenko, Н. Klisch, Use of Canadian Experience in Develop ment of                      CIDA, Public                            Klimen ko_R
                                                            Optimization Mechanisms for Budget Activities of Executive Authorities and                 Admin istration                         eport_June0
                                                            Public Payroll Systems in Russia, June 2004                                                Reform                                  4_rus.doc




                                                            Laurent Olleon, “Performance-related pay: International Experience”                        European                                Results
                                                                                                                                                       Co mmission,                            oriented
                                                                                                                                                       Public                                  payment_rus
                                                                                                                                                       Admin istration
                                                                                                                                                       Reform in Russia




   Prepa red by the WB/DFID Development Pa rtners Secreta ria t for Governance Reforms in Russia. You a re welcome to send informa tion on new resources to be i ncluded in this database to   15
   Tumun Ts ydypov a t tts ydypov@worldbank.org / Подготовлено Секретариа том партнеров по ра звитию в обла сти реформы госуда рственного упра вления в России (Всемирный
   Ба нк/Министерство Международного Ра звития Великобрита нии). Просим на правлять информацию о ма териа ла х для включения в ба зу да нных Тумуну Цыдыпову по а дресу
   tts ydypov@worldbank.org
                                                                                                                                                                         Updated: August 2008


                                                         Ray mond Piganio l, Eu ropean Best Practices In Performance Related Pay For                European                                 European
                                                         Public Serv ice Managers                                                                   Co mmission,                             practice_pay
                                                                                                                                                    Public                                   ment fo r
                                                                                                                                                    Admin istration                          state
                                                                                                                                                    Reform in Russia                         officials.doc
                                                         Pay and Emp loy ment in OECD countries (note), World Bank Russia Civil                     World Ban k                              Pay and
                                                         Service Reform Team, 2002                                                                                                           emp loyment
                                                                                                                                                                                             _OECD_rus
                                                         Pay and Emp loy ment Model for Federal Executive Authorities (2002)                        World Ban k                              Pay and
                                                                                                                                                                                             Emp loy ment
                                                                                                                                                                                             model.xls
                                                         Federal Civil Servant‟s Remuneration system in Russia: co mparative study of               DFID,                    Civil Service   Civil
                                                         pay rates and benefits in civil service and private sector, 2003 / Сравнительное           implemented by the       pay_eng         Service
                                                         изучение оплаты деятельности работников государственно го и частного                       State University –                       Pay_rus
                                                         секторов (только для госслужащих федеральных органов исполнительной                        Higher School of
                                                         власти), 2003                                                                              Economics
                                                         Available in English and in Russian

                                                         Outline Structure of Implementation for Work and Inco me – The Case of the                 DFID Public              Work and        Work and
                                                         Netherlands                                                                                Admin istration          Income_eng.     Income_rus.
                                                                                                                                                    Reform Project           doc             doc

                                                         Civil Service Pay in UK – Brief Information                                                DFID Public              Civil Service   Civil
                                                                                                                                                    Admin istration          Pay in          Service Pay
                                                                                                                                                    Reform Project           UK_eng.doc      in
                                                                                                                                                                                             UK_eng.doc
                                                         Senior civil service performance management and reward – Gu ide to the SCS                 DFID Public              Gu ide to SCS   Gu ide to
                                                         reward system                                                                              Admin istration          reward          SCS reward
                                                                                                                                                    Reform Project           system_eng.d    system_rus.
                                                                                                                                                                             oc              doc



                                                         Individual Perfo rmance Appraisal and Performance Related Pay. UK Approach,                European                 Performance     Performance
                                                         D. Richards - Presentation at the conference “State Governance Reform and Its              Co mmission,             _pay_eng.ppt    _pay_rus.ppt
                                                         Implementation at the Reg ional Level”, September 2004, Moscow                             Public
                                                                                                                                                    Admin istration
                                                                                                                                                    Reform in Russia


Prepa red by the WB/DFID Development Pa rtners Secreta ria t for Governance Reforms in Russia. You a re welcome to send informa tion on new resources to be i ncluded in this database to    16
Tumun Ts ydypov a t tts ydypov@worldbank.org / Подготовлено Секретариа том партнеров по ра звитию в обла сти реформы госуда рственного упра вления в России (Всемирный
Ба нк/Министерство Международного Ра звития Великобрита нии). Просим на правлять информацию о ма териа ла х для включения в ба зу да нных Тумуну Цыдыпову по а дресу
tts ydypov@worldbank.org
                                                                                                                                                                         Updated: August 2008


                                                         Implementation Principles of Performance-Related Pay and Bonuses for Civil                 Higher School of         Salary_Klisc    Salary_Klisc
                                                         Servants, N. Klisch - Presentation at the conference “State Governance Reform              Economics                h_eng.ppt       h_rus.ppt
                                                         and Its Implementation at the Regional Level”, September 2004, Moscow


                                                         Implementation of the Performance-related Pay: the Chuvash Republic                        Govern ment of           Chuvashiya_     Chuvashiya
                                                         Experience, L. Petrova - Presentation at the conference “State Governance                  Chuvash Republic         eng.ppt         _rus.ppt
                                                         Reform and Its Imp lementation at the Regional Level”, September 2004,
                                                         Moscow


                                                         Performance-Related Pay Po licies for Govern ment Employees: Main Trends in                OECD                     PRP_OECD_
                                                         OECD Countries, OECD, 2004                                                                                          eng.pdf


                                                         Individual Country Reports on Performance-Related Pay, OECD, 2004                          OECD                     OECD_PRP_       OECD_PRP
                                                                                                                                                                             country         _country_
                                                                                                                                                                             reports_eng.d   reports_rus.
                                                                                                                                                                             oc              doc
                                                         Performance Contract: An Instrument for Creat ing Co mpetit ion in Public                  World Ban k              Trivedi_eng.    Trivedi_rus.
                                                         Services – presentation, P. Trivedi, World Bank, January 2005                                                       ppt             ppt




                                                         Implementing Pay for Performance Po licy - fro m Pay for Performance: A Gu ide             IBM Center for the       Risher_eng.p
                                                         for Federal Managers, Howard Risher, Washington, IBM Center for the                        Business of              df
                                                         Business of Govern ment, 2004                                                              Govern ment

                                                         Implementation of Perfo rmance Related Pay, Ray mond Piganiol, December                    European                 PRP_Imp lem     PRP_Imp le
                                                         2004                                                                                       Co mmission,             entation_eng.   mentation_r
                                                                                                                                                    Public                   doc             us.doc
                                                                                                                                                    Admin istration
                                                                                                                                                    Reform in Russia




Prepa red by the WB/DFID Development Pa rtners Secreta ria t for Governance Reforms in Russia. You a re welcome to send informa tion on new resources to be i ncluded in this database to    17
Tumun Ts ydypov a t tts ydypov@worldbank.org / Подготовлено Секретариа том партнеров по ра звитию в обла сти реформы госуда рственного упра вления в России (Всемирный
Ба нк/Министерство Международного Ра звития Великобрита нии). Просим на правлять информацию о ма териа ла х для включения в ба зу да нных Тумуну Цыдыпову по а дресу
tts ydypov@worldbank.org
                                                                                                                                                                         Updated: August 2008


                                                         Performance Related Pay Mechanisms Applied in the German Civ il Serv ice,                  European                 PRP_ German    PRP_ Germa
                                                         Joachim Vo llmuth, 2005                                                                    Co mmission,             y_eng.doc      ny_rus.doc
                                                                                                                                                    Public
                                                                                                                                                    Admin istration
                                                                                                                                                    Reform in Russia
                                                         Civil Servants Pay in Russia, presentation at the conference of EC “Civ il                 European                                Go lov_rus.p
                                                         Service Reform (AR II)” Pro ject, March 2005                                               Co mmission Civ il                      pt
                                                                                                                                                    Service Reform
                                                                                                                                                    (AR II) Project
                                                         Paying for Performance: Policies for Govern ment Emp loyees, May 2005,                     OECD                     Paying_for_p
                                                         OECD                                                                                                                erformance_
                                                                                                                                                                             OECD_eng.p
                                                                                                                                                                             df
                                                         Criteria for Public Civil Servants Remuneration, Working Group Materials,                   Eu ropean Union                        Remuneratio
                                                         September, 2004.                                                                           Project “Siv il                         n_criteria_ru
                                                                                                                                                    Service Reform”                         s.doc
                                                                                                                                                    (Administrative
                                                                                                                                                    Reform II)
                                                         Principles for Public Civil Servants Remunerat ion, 2004.                                  ) European Union                        Remuneratio
                                                                                                                                                    Project “Siv il                         n_rus.doc
                                                                                                                                                    Service Reform”
                                                                                                                                                    (Administrative
                                                                                                                                                    Refor
                                                         Digest of recent Wage System Reform practices in ECA states. Discussion                    World Ban k              Wage           Wage_refor
                                                         Note.                                                                                                               reform_eng.d   m_ru.doc
                                                         March 2006                                                                                                          oc

                                                         Experience with Performance-Related Pay in Russia: Emerging Lessons.                       World Ban k              Dobrolyubov
                                                         Presentation by Y. Dobrolyubova, Expert Meeting on Performance-Based                                                a_hague_PR
                                                         Arrangements for Sen ior Civil Servants, The Hague, September 15, 2006                                              P_eng.pdf


                        2.2 Социальное                   State Social Policy for Civil Servants, R. Piganio l, June 2005                            European                                Package_soc
                        обеспечение                                                                                                                 Co mmission,                            ial_rus.doc
                        государственных                                                                                                             Public
                        служащих / Social                                                                                                           Admin istration
                        security for civil servants                                                                                                 Reform in Russia


Prepa red by the WB/DFID Development Pa rtners Secreta ria t for Governance Reforms in Russia. You a re welcome to send informa tion on new resources to be i ncluded in this database to   18
Tumun Ts ydypov a t tts ydypov@worldbank.org / Подготовлено Секретариа том партнеров по ра звитию в обла сти реформы госуда рственного упра вления в России (Всемирный
Ба нк/Министерство Международного Ра звития Великобрита нии). Просим на правлять информацию о ма териа ла х для включения в ба зу да нных Тумуну Цыдыпову по а дресу
tts ydypov@worldbank.org
                                                                                                                                                                         Updated: August 2008




                        2.3 Планирование и               Performance Management of Civil Servants in the Republic of Korea                          Republic o f Korea       http://www.c
                        оценка деятельности                                                                                                         Civil Service            sc.go.kr/eng/
                        государственных                                                                                                             Co mmission              csr/csr0108.a
                        органов, управление по                                                                                                                               sp
                        результатам / Planning           Philippe Mazuel, «Analysis of the concepts “achievements” or “performance                  European                                  Achievemen
                        and Evaluation of Public         outcomes” of state structures: international experience»                                   Co mmission,                              t and
                        Authorities Operations,                                                                                                     Public                                    erformance_
                        Performance Management                                                                                                      Admin istration                           international
                                                                                                                                                    Reform in Russia                          _rus
                                                         Value for Money Audit - Discussion Paper                                                   DFID Public              Value for        Value for
                                                                                                                                                    Admin istration          money            money
                                                                                                                                                    Reform Project           Audit_eng.do     Audit_rus.d
                                                                                                                                                                             c                oc
                                                         Doing right things and doing them right – Improving Evaluative Activity in the             State Services           http://www.s
                                                         New Zealand State Sector, State Serv ices Co mmission, New Zealand, 2003                   Co mmission of           sc.govt.nz/dis
                                                                                                                                                    New Zealand              play/docume
                                                                                                                                                                             nt.asp?DocID
                                                                                                                                                                             =3506


                                                         Outcomes Focused Management in New Zealand – A Background Paper, Chris
                                                         Ussher and Andrew Kibblewh ite, Treasury Working Paper 01/ 05, New Zealand                 The Treasury, New        http://www.tr
                                                                                                                                                    Zealand                  easury.govt.n
                                                                                                                                                                             z/workingpap
                                                                                                                                                                             ers/2001/twp
                                                                                                                                                                             01-5.pdf




Prepa red by the WB/DFID Development Pa rtners Secreta ria t for Governance Reforms in Russia. You a re welcome to send informa tion on new resources to be i ncluded in this database to     19
Tumun Ts ydypov a t tts ydypov@worldbank.org / Подготовлено Секретариа том партнеров по ра звитию в обла сти реформы госуда рственного упра вления в России (Всемирный
Ба нк/Министерство Международного Ра звития Великобрита нии). Просим на правлять информацию о ма териа ла х для включения в ба зу да нных Тумуну Цыдыпову по а дресу
tts ydypov@worldbank.org
                                                                                                                                                                         Updated: August 2008


                                                         Assessing country readiness for results -based monitoring and evaluation                   World Ban k              http://www1.
                                                         systems, PREM Note 87, World Bank, June 2004                                                                        worldbank.or
                                                                                                                                                                             g/prem/PRE
                                                                                                                                                                             MNotes/prem
                                                                                                                                                                             note87.pdf




                                                         Best Practice Guidelines for Evaluation. PUMA Policy Brief No.5. Public                    OECD                     http://www.o
                                                         Management Service, 1998                                                                                            ecd.org/datao
                                                                                                                                                                             ecd/11/56/19
                                                                                                                                                                             02965.pdf


                                                         Evaluation Feedback for Effect ive Learning and Accountability. OECD, 2001                 OECD                     http://www.o
                                                                                                                                                                             ecd.org/datao
                                                                                                                                                                             ecd/10/29/26
                                                                                                                                                                             67326.pdf



                                                          EC Pro ject “Budget Reform in Russia”                                                     European                 List of         List of
                                                          List of reports, prepared under the project for trainings in June 2004                    Co mmission State        reports on      reports on
                                                          “On Results and Key Areas of Activities for                                               Budget Reform in         budget          budget
                                                          Budget Planning Subjects in 2005”                                                         Russia, 2003-2004        reform in       reform in
                                                                                                                                                                             RF_en.doc       RF_ru.doc




Prepa red by the WB/DFID Development Pa rtners Secreta ria t for Governance Reforms in Russia. You a re welcome to send informa tion on new resources to be i ncluded in this database to    20
Tumun Ts ydypov a t tts ydypov@worldbank.org / Подготовлено Секретариа том партнеров по ра звитию в обла сти реформы госуда рственного упра вления в России (Всемирный
Ба нк/Министерство Международного Ра звития Великобрита нии). Просим на правлять информацию о ма териа ла х для включения в ба зу да нных Тумуну Цыдыпову по а дресу
tts ydypov@worldbank.org
                                                                                                                                                                         Updated: August 2008


                                                         Proposals on Planning, Budgeting and Performance Evaluation in the Reg ional               Admin istration of                      Taimyr_con
                                                         Pilots in Russia. Case of Taimy r, G. Ivanov – report at the conference “State             Dolgano-Nenetsky                        ference_Sep
                                                         Governance Reform and Its Implementation at the Regional Level”, September                 Autonomous                              04_rus.doc
                                                         2004, Moscow                                                                               District




                                                         Agenda for Change: Towards Performance Management in Central Govern ment                   SIDA Public              Murrey_eng.    Murrey_rus.
                                                         of Sweden, R. Murrey – Presentation at the conference “State Governance                    Admin istration          ppt            ppt
                                                         Reform and Its Imp lementation at the Regional Level”, September 2004,                     Reform Project
                                                         Moscow




                                                         Samara Oblast Programme for 2004 on Imp lementation of Experiments and                     Institute of                            Samara_rus.
                                                         Pilot Pro jects, V. Vittikh - Presentation at the conference “State Governance             Co mplex Systems                        ppt
                                                         Reform and Its Imp lementation at the Regional Level”, September 2004,                     Management,
                                                         Moscow                                                                                     Russian Academy
                                                                                                                                                    of Science




                                                         Govern ment St rategic Planning and Budgeting in Lithuania, R. Veckys -                    Ministry of              Lithuania_Se   Lithuania_S
                                                         Presentation at the conference “State Governance Reform and Its                            Finance, Lithuania       p04_eng.ppt    ep04_rus.ppt
                                                         Implementation at the Reg ional Level”, September 2004, Moscow




Prepa red by the WB/DFID Development Pa rtners Secreta ria t for Governance Reforms in Russia. You a re welcome to send informa tion on new resources to be i ncluded in this database to   21
Tumun Ts ydypov a t tts ydypov@worldbank.org / Подготовлено Секретариа том партнеров по ра звитию в обла сти реформы госуда рственного упра вления в России (Всемирный
Ба нк/Министерство Международного Ра звития Великобрита нии). Просим на правлять информацию о ма териа ла х для включения в ба зу да нных Тумуну Цыдыпову по а дресу
tts ydypov@worldbank.org
                                                                                                                                                                         Updated: August 2008


                                                         Performance Management Decelopment and Introduction in Bodies of                           RF Min istry of                         MoEDT_per
                                                         Executive Authorities, RF M inistry of Economic Develop ment and Trade -                   Economic                                formance_m
                                                         conference “State Governance Reform and Its Implementation at the Regional                 Develop ment and                        anagement_r
                                                         Level”, September 2004, Moscow                                                             Trade                                   us.ppt




                                                         On Raising Effectiveness of Public Admin istration in Perm Oblast, A. Silling -            Admin istration of                      Perm_rus.pp
                                                         Presentation at the conference “State Governance Reform and Its                            Perm Ob last                            t
                                                         Implementation at the Reg ional Level”, September 2004, Moscow




                                                         Delivering Results: the Brit ish Government‟s Approach, M. Barber –                        Prime M inister‟s        Barber_eng.p   Barber_rus.p
                                                         Presentation at the World Bank Seminar, September 2004, Moscow                             Delivery Unit            pt             pt




                                                         Performance Planning and Budgeting: the Case of New Zealand. Working paper                 Donor Secretariat                       NZ_note_ru
                                                         (prepared at the request of the RF Min istry of Cu lture and Mass                          for Civ il Service                      s.doc
                                                         Co mmunicat ions)                                                                          Reform in Russia




Prepa red by the WB/DFID Development Pa rtners Secreta ria t for Governance Reforms in Russia. You a re welcome to send informa tion on new resources to be i ncluded in this database to   22
Tumun Ts ydypov a t tts ydypov@worldbank.org / Подготовлено Секретариа том партнеров по ра звитию в обла сти реформы госуда рственного упра вления в России (Всемирный
Ба нк/Министерство Международного Ра звития Великобрита нии). Просим на правлять информацию о ма териа ла х для включения в ба зу да нных Тумуну Цыдыпову по а дресу
tts ydypov@worldbank.org
                                                                                                                                                                         Updated: August 2008


                                                         Develop ment of Goals and Performance Indicators in Law Enforcement                        Donor Secretariat                        Law_ Enforc
                                                         Agencies: Overview of International Experienec. Working paper (prepared at                 for Civ il Service                       ement_rus.d
                                                         the request of the RF Govern ment Co mmission on Raising Effectiveness of                  Reform in Russia                         oc
                                                         Budget Expenditures)




                                                         On Experiments and Pilot Pro jects to Apply New Approaches to Organization                 Institute of                             Samara_21
                                                         of Civil Serv ice in Samara Ob last, presentation at the conference “Reformat ion          Co mplex Systems                         Dec04_rus.p
                                                         of Civil Serv ice in the RF. Results and Future Prospects”, 21 December 2004,              Management of the                        pt
                                                         HSE                                                                                        Russian Academy
                                                                                                                                                    of Science




                                                         Results of Experiments to Apply New Approaches to Organizat ion of Civil                   Admin istration of                       Saratov_21
                                                         Service in Saratov Obl., presentation at the conference “Reformation of Civil              Saratov Oblast                           Dec04_rus.p
                                                         Service in the RF. Results and Future Prospects”, 21 December 2004, HSE                                                             pt




                                                         Presentations from international sy mposium “Strategic Planning and                        World Ban k              Ankara_Jan0
                                                         Performance Budgeting in the Context of Public Sector Reforms”,Ankara,                                              5_presentatio
                                                         January 2005                                                                                                        ns.zip




Prepa red by the WB/DFID Development Pa rtners Secreta ria t for Governance Reforms in Russia. You a re welcome to send informa tion on new resources to be i ncluded in this database to    23
Tumun Ts ydypov a t tts ydypov@worldbank.org / Подготовлено Секретариа том партнеров по ра звитию в обла сти реформы госуда рственного упра вления в России (Всемирный
Ба нк/Министерство Международного Ра звития Великобрита нии). Просим на правлять информацию о ма териа ла х для включения в ба зу да нных Тумуну Цыдыпову по а дресу
tts ydypov@worldbank.org
                                                                                                                                                                         Updated: August 2008


                                                         Performance-Oriented Public Sector Modernizat ion in Developing Countries:                 World Ban k              Performance
                                                         Meeting the Imp lementation Challenge, Gary Reid, Public Sector Management                                          _CSR_eng.d
                                                         Div ision, the World Bank, 1998 (fro m Course Pack “Rightsizing Public                                              oc
                                                         Organizations”)




                                                         Performance Management in the Public Service of Canada, presentation at the                CIDA Public              Performance    Performance
                                                         conference on intergovernmental cooperation, Ufa, April 2005                               Admin istration          _managemen     _manageme
                                                                                                                                                    Reform Project           t_Canada_en    nt_Canada_r
                                                                                                                                                                             g.ppt          us.ppt




                                                         Planning Systems in Govern mental Institutions – Relevance of UK Experience                DFID Public              Hollis_13Ma    Hollis_13M
                                                         to the Russian Federation, G. Hollis, presentation at the seminar on                       Admin istration          y2005_eng.p    ay2005_rus.
                                                         departmental perfo rmance reports for 2006-2008, 13-14 May 2005                            Reform Project           pt             ppt




                                                         Depart mental Targeted Programmes of the RF M inistry for Econo mic                        DFID Public                             Alexandrov
                                                         Develop ment and Trade, O. Alexandrov, presentation at the seminar on                      Admin istration                         _13May200
                                                         departmental perfo rmance reports for 2006-2008, 13-14 May 2005                            Reform Project                          5_rus.ppt




Prepa red by the WB/DFID Development Pa rtners Secreta ria t for Governance Reforms in Russia. You a re welcome to send informa tion on new resources to be i ncluded in this database to   24
Tumun Ts ydypov a t tts ydypov@worldbank.org / Подготовлено Секретариа том партнеров по ра звитию в обла сти реформы госуда рственного упра вления в России (Всемирный
Ба нк/Министерство Международного Ра звития Великобрита нии). Просим на правлять информацию о ма териа ла х для включения в ба зу да нных Тумуну Цыдыпову по а дресу
tts ydypov@worldbank.org
                                                                                                                                                                         Updated: August 2008


                                                         Performance Audit in Public Institutions, Institute for Economic and Social                DFID Public                              UNESP_ 13
                                                         Policy, presentation at the seminar on depart mental performance reports for               Admin istration                          May2005_ru
                                                         2006-2008, 13-14 May 2005                                                                  Reform Project                           s.ppt




                                                         Develop ment of Performance Report of the RF M inistry for Economic                        DFID Public                              Gabunia_13
                                                         Develop ment and Trade, G. Ph ilip, p resentation at the seminar on departmental           Admin istration                          May2005_ru
                                                         performance reports for 2006-2008, 13-14 May 2005                                          Reform Project                           s.ppt




                                                         Managing Government Performance: Tools and Techniques, (Canadian Federal                   World Ban k              Managing_go
                                                         Govern ment, Provincial Govern ment of Ontario, Govern ment of Lithuania, and                                       vernment_per
                                                         Govern ment of New Zealand), Go rd Evans, October 2004, Moscow, World                                               formance_Ev
                                                         Bank                                                                                                                ans_eng




                                                         Public Sector Modernisation: Modernising Accountability and Control, April                 OECD                     Accountabilit
                                                         2005, OECD                                                                                                          y_control_O
                                                                                                                                                                             ECD.pdf




Prepa red by the WB/DFID Development Pa rtners Secreta ria t for Governance Reforms in Russia. You a re welcome to send informa tion on new resources to be i ncluded in this database to    25
Tumun Ts ydypov a t tts ydypov@worldbank.org / Подготовлено Секретариа том партнеров по ра звитию в обла сти реформы госуда рственного упра вления в России (Всемирный
Ба нк/Министерство Международного Ра звития Великобрита нии). Просим на правлять информацию о ма териа ла х для включения в ба зу да нных Тумуну Цыдыпову по а дресу
tts ydypov@worldbank.org
                                                                                                                                                                         Updated: August 2008


                                                         Use of Performance Indicators to Measure Effectiveness of Bodies of Executive              World Ban k                              Pskov_Indic
                                                         Authorities: International Experience Y. Dobrolyubova, presentation at the                                                          ators_Dobro
                                                         seminar in Pskov, July 4, 2005                                                                                                      lyubova.ppt




                                                         Use of Performance Indicators to Measure Effectiveness of Bodies of Executive              World Ban k                              PerIndic_Ag
                                                         Authorities. Approach and Objectives, V. Agafonov, presentation at the seminar                                                      afonov_rus.
                                                         in Pskov, Ju ly 4, 2005                                                                                                             ppt




                                                         Beyond Economics: Developing Indicators of the Social Effects of Culture, D.               Depart ment of           Culture_socia   Culture_soci
                                                         Stanley, Proceedings of the International Symposiu m on Cu lture Statistics,               Canadian Heritage,       l_effects_eng   al_effects_ru
                                                         Depart ment of Canadian Heritage, Hull, Canada                                             Hull, Canada             .pdf            s.doc




                                                         The Relevance of the Balanced Scorecard Approach to the Russian Federation                 DFID Public              BSC_eng.doc     BSC_rus.do
                                                         Performance Management and Performance Measurement, Discussion paper,                      Admin istration                          c
                                                         June 2005                                                                                  Reform Project




                                                         Interfaces between ministries and agencies: international experience and                   ECORYS,                                  October_se
                                                         Russia‟s challenges. Prepared by Belyanova E.V. and Go rshenin, ECORYS,                    Research and                             minar_prese
                                                         Research and Consulting. Ministry of Culture and Mass Media of the Russian                 Consulting                               nt_EB_A G_
                                                         Federation. Moscow, October 2005                                                                                                    rus.ppt




Prepa red by the WB/DFID Development Pa rtners Secreta ria t for Governance Reforms in Russia. You a re welcome to send informa tion on new resources to be i ncluded in this database to    26
Tumun Ts ydypov a t tts ydypov@worldbank.org / Подготовлено Секретариа том партнеров по ра звитию в обла сти реформы госуда рственного упра вления в России (Всемирный
Ба нк/Министерство Международного Ра звития Великобрита нии). Просим на правлять информацию о ма териа ла х для включения в ба зу да нных Тумуну Цыдыпову по а дресу
tts ydypov@worldbank.org
                                                                                                                                                                         Updated: August 2008


                                                         Agreement on Results of Activities: How to Make Them Work?                                 ECORYS,                                 October-
                                                         ECORYS, Research and Consulting, Bannock Consulting. Ministry of Culture                   Research and                            seminar_pre
                                                         and Mass Media of the Russian Federation. Moscow, October 2005                             Consulting                              sent_PeterBr
                                                                                                                                                                                            ooke_rus_pp
                                                                                                                                                                                            t
                                                         Agreements between ministries and agencies. Practical experience of                        ECORYS,                                 October-
                                                         application. ECORYS, Research and Consulting, Bannock Consulting. Ministry                 Research and                            seminar_pre
                                                         of Cu lture and Mass Media of the Russian Federation. Moscow, October 2005                 Consulting                              sent_PeterBr
                                                                                                                                                                                            ooke_Perf_
                                                                                                                                                                                            Agreem_rus
                                                                                                                                                                                            _pp
                                                         Interfaces between ministries and agencies: practical imp lications. ECORYS,               ECORYS,                                 October_se
                                                         Research and Consulting, Bannock Consulting. Ministry of Culture and Mass                  Research and                            minar_prese
                                                         Media of the Russian Federation. Moscow, October 2005                                      Consulting                              nt-
                                                                                                                                                                                            chrisHiddin
                                                                                                                                                                                            k_PeterFair
                                                                                                                                                                                            man_ Rus.pp
                                                                                                                                                                                            t
                                                         Typical Agreement on interface between a min istry and an agency to achieve                ECORYS,                                 October-
                                                         goals and objectives of state policy in a g iven sphere of activity. Seminar               Research and                            seminar_pre
                                                         presentation prepared by Sidorenko S.V., Deputy Director of “Institute of                  Consulting                              sent_Sergey
                                                         economics and social policy” Fund. Moscow, October 2005.                                                                           _Sidorenko_
                                                                                                                                                                                            rus_ppt
                                                         Projects financed by the European Co mmission and approaches towards                       ECORYS,                                 October-
                                                         providing assistance . Ministry of Cu lture and Mass Media of the Russian                  Research and                            seminar_pre
                                                         Federation. Moscow, October 2005                                                           Consulting                              sent_Stefani
                                                                                                                                                                                            eHarter_rus_
                                                                                                                                                                                            ppt
                                                         Interfaces between ministries and agencies, agencies and spending units.                   ECORYS,                                 October_se
                                                         International experience and Russia‟s challenges. ECORYS, Research and                     Research and                            minar_Min C
                                                         Consulting. Min istry of Cu lture and Mass Media of the Russian Federation.                Consulting                              ult_rus.pdf
                                                         Moscow, October 2005




Prepa red by the WB/DFID Development Pa rtners Secreta ria t for Governance Reforms in Russia. You a re welcome to send informa tion on new resources to be i ncluded in this database to   27
Tumun Ts ydypov a t tts ydypov@worldbank.org / Подготовлено Секретариа том партнеров по ра звитию в обла сти реформы госуда рственного упра вления в России (Всемирный
Ба нк/Министерство Международного Ра звития Великобрита нии). Просим на правлять информацию о ма териа ла х для включения в ба зу да нных Тумуну Цыдыпову по а дресу
tts ydypov@worldbank.org
                                                                                                                                                                         Updated: August 2008


                                                         Structure of Performance Management, DFID. Seminar " Realization of the                    МЕDT-World                              Result_man
                                                         Concept of administrative reform in the Russian Federation in 2006-2008:                   Bank                                    agementDec
                                                         coordination of actions at federal and regional levels ", December 15-16 2005,                                                     2005_rus.pp
                                                         Moscow.                                                                                                                            t

                                                         Performance Management. Seminar " Realizat ion of the Concept of                           МЕDT-World                              Performance
                                                         administrative refo rm in the Russian Federation in 2006-2008: coordination of             Bank                                    _manageme
                                                         actions at federal and regional levels ", December 15-16 2005, Moscow.                                                             nt_Dec2005
                                                                                                                                                                                            _rus.ppt

                                                         Performance Management in the Min istry of Cu lture, prepared by Sidorenko                 МЕDT-World                              Performance
                                                         S.V., Institute of Economics and Social Po lit ics. Seminar " Realizat ion of the          Bank                                    _manageme
                                                         Concept of administrative reform in the Russian Federation in 2006-2008:                                                           nt_min istry_
                                                         coordination of actions at federal and regional levels ", December 15-16 2005,                                                     cultureDec2
                                                         Moscow.                                                                                                                            005_rus.ppt

                                                         Performance Management: Performance Budgeting. International Experience,                   МЕDT-World                              International
                                                         prepared by Alistar Pirie. Seminar " Realization of the Concept of                         Bank                                    _experience
                                                         administrative refo rm in the Russian Federation in 2006-2008: coordination of                                                     _pirie_dec2
                                                         actions at federal and regional levels ", December 15-16 2005, Moscow.                                                             005_rus.ppt

                                                         Methodology for developing goals, objectives, and performance indicators for               World Ban k/DFID                        Indicators_
                                                         executive authorities in RF; writing perfo rmance reports. Presentation by O.              Trust Fund                              Alexandrov
                                                         Alexandrov at the seminar “Introducing Elements of Performance Management                                                          _Saratov_28
                                                         at the Regional Level”, Saratov, Feb.28 – March 1, 2006                                                                            feb06_rus.d
                                                                                                                                                                                            oc

                                                         General Govern ment Sector External Audit. Presentation by I. Dubin ina at the             DFID PAR project                        1_dubinina_
                                                                                                                                                                                            rus.ppt
                                                         conference «Imp lementation of the Concept on Admin istrative Refo rm in RF
                                                         within the Framework of Institutional and Regional Programmes:
                                                         Implementation Mechanisms and Support», February 17-18, 2006




Prepa red by the WB/DFID Development Pa rtners Secreta ria t for Governance Reforms in Russia. You a re welcome to send informa tion on new resources to be i ncluded in this database to   28
Tumun Ts ydypov a t tts ydypov@worldbank.org / Подготовлено Секретариа том партнеров по ра звитию в обла сти реформы госуда рственного упра вления в России (Всемирный
Ба нк/Министерство Международного Ра звития Великобрита нии). Просим на правлять информацию о ма териа ла х для включения в ба зу да нных Тумуну Цыдыпову по а дресу
tts ydypov@worldbank.org
                                                                                                                                                                         Updated: August 2008


                                                         Improving the legal and regulatory framework in public ad min istration;                   World                                   Murmansk_r
                                                         development and implementation of performance management in executive                      Bank/Finnish Trust                      us.ppt
                                                         authorities (pilot authority – Depart ment for Economic Develop ment of                    Fund
                                                         Murmansk Region). Presentation within the framework of Finnish Trust Fund
                                                         Project on Public Ad ministration, 2006

                                                         Experience in preparation of performance reports of executive authorities.                 World Ban k/EU
                                                                                                                                                                                            DROND_Al
                                                         Presentation by O. Alexandrov, training “Strategic p lanning, program-based                Trust Fund
                                                                                                                                                                                            exandrov_ru
                                                         management, and policy impact assessment”, 2006
                                                                                                                                                                                            s.ppt


                                                         Policy Impact Assessment. Presentation package. training “Strategic planning,              World Ban k/EU                          Policy
                                                         program-based management, and policy impact assessment”, 2006                              Trust Fund                              impact
                                                                                                                                                                                            assessment.z
                                                                                                                                                                                            ip

                                                         Regional strategic planning. Training package. training “Strategic p lanning,              World Ban k/EU                          Strat_plan_c
                                                         program-based management, and policy impact assessment”, 2006                              Trust Fund                              ourse_rus.zi
                                                                                                                                                                                            p



                                                         Consolidated performance report of the RF Govern ment. Presentation by A.                  MoEDT                                   Consolidate
                                                         Mitkin, training “Strategic p lanning, program-based management, and policy                                                        d_DROND_
                                                         impact assessment”, 2006                                                                                                           rus.ppt



                                                         CAF works – better service for the cit izens by using CAF.                                 Austrian Federal         Caf_ works_e
                                                                                                                                                    Chancellery,             nglish.pdf
                                                                                                                                                    Directorate General
                                                                                                                                                    III – Civ il Serv ice
                                                                                                                                                    and Administrative
                                                                                                                                                    Reform




Prepa red by the WB/DFID Development Pa rtners Secreta ria t for Governance Reforms in Russia. You a re welcome to send informa tion on new resources to be i ncluded in this database to   29
Tumun Ts ydypov a t tts ydypov@worldbank.org / Подготовлено Секретариа том партнеров по ра звитию в обла сти реформы госуда рственного упра вления в России (Всемирный
Ба нк/Министерство Международного Ра звития Великобрита нии). Просим на правлять информацию о ма териа ла х для включения в ба зу да нных Тумуну Цыдыпову по а дресу
tts ydypov@worldbank.org
                                                                                                                                                                          Updated: August 2008


                                                         Performance management and performance-based budgeting in Latvia.                                                                  Latvian_exp
                                                         Presentation by V. Sturis training “Administrative Reform in Russia: training                                                      erience_rus.
                                                         course”, Pyatigorsk, September 2006                                                                                                ppt



                                                         Performance Management in the Australian Public Service                                    A u s tralian            Australia_P
                                                                                                                                                    Na t io n a l            M_eng.pdf
                                                                                                                                                    A u d it Of f i c e

                                                         Performance management in government agencies. Presentation by Messrs.                     French Embassy                          Scowron_ru
                                                         Skowron and Audianne, France, 2007                                                                                                 s.ppt

                                                         Gu idelines of program auditing, Interministerial Program Auditing Co mmittee              Intermin isterial                       Program_au
                                                         (CIAP), France, 2006                                                                       Program Auditing                        dit.rus
                                                                                                                                                    Co mmittee (CIAP),
                                                                                                                                                    France
                                                         Roundtable minutes “Performance management: progress assessment and                        Center of                               CSR_perfor
                                                                                                                                                    Economic and                            mance_ man
                                                         prospects”. Organized jointly by Center of Econo mic and Financial Consulting
                                                         and Center for Strategic Research, 23 June 2008, Moscow                                    Financial                               agement_se
                                                                                                                                                    Consulting and                          minar_June_
                                                                                                                                                    Center for Strategic                    2008_ minut
                                                                                                                                                    Research                                es_rus.doc
                                                         Efficiency assessment of budget investments at regional and municipal levels.              Institute for                           Effificiency
                                                         Ed.by V.Klimanov, “Public Finances” series, Moscow, 2008                                   Regional Public                         _public_inv
                                                                                                                                                    Finances                                estments_re
                                                                                                                                                                                            gional_and_
                                                                                                                                                                                            municipal_r
                                                                                                                                                                                            us.pdf
                                                         Materials of the international conference on performance management. Mexico,                                        Mexico_conf
                                                         June 2008                                                                                                           erence
                                                                                                                                                                             _performance
                                                                                                                                                                             _managemen
                                                                                                                                                                             t_June_2008
                                                                                                                                                                             _eng.zip




Prepa red by the WB/DFID Development Pa rtners Secreta ria t for Governance Reforms in Russia. You a re welcome to send informa tion on new resources to be i ncluded in this database to   30
Tumun Ts ydypov a t tts ydypov@worldbank.org / Подготовлено Секретариа том партнеров по ра звитию в обла сти реформы госуда рственного упра вления в России (Всемирный
Ба нк/Министерство Международного Ра звития Великобрита нии). Просим на правлять информацию о ма териа ла х для включения в ба зу да нных Тумуну Цыдыпову по а дресу
tts ydypov@worldbank.org
                                                                                                                                                                         Updated: August 2008


                                                         Support for Strengthening Performance Management in Russia – Experience,                   Russia Public            WB_regional     WB_regiona
                                                         Trends, Lessons. Presentation for the 2008 Annual Conference of the Min istry              Admin istration and      _performance    l_performan
                                                         of Economic Development and Trade of the Russian Federation                                Governance Team,         _managemen      ce_manage
                                                                                                                                                    WB                       t_evaluation_   ment_evalua
                                                                                                                                                                             2008_eng.ppt    tion_2008_r
                                                                                                                                                                                             us.ppt
                                                         Materials fro m inter-reg ional seminar on performance management, organized               Russia Public                            French_semi
                                                         by the World Bank PAR team and the French Embassy to Russia. March 2008,                   Admin istration and                      nar_PM
                                                         Vlad ikav kaz                                                                              Governance Team,                         1_rus.zip
                                                                                                                                                    WB and French
                                                                                                                                                    Embassy to Russia
                                                         Materials fro m inter-reg ional seminar on performance management, organized               Russia Public            French_semi     French_semi
                                                         by the World Bank PAR team and the French Embass y to Russia. June 2008,                   Admin istration and      nar_PM_2_e      nar_PM_2_r
                                                         Pyatigorsk                                                                                 Governance Team,         ng.zip          us.zip
                                                                                                                                                    WB and French
                                                                                                                                                    Embassy to Russia
                        2.4 Проектное                    Progress Towards The Common Object ives In Education And Train ing.                        Co mmission Of           Indicators
                        управление в                     Indicators And Benchmarks                                                                  The European             and
                        деятельности органов                                                                                                        Co mmunit ies            benchmarks_
                        исполнительной власти /                                                                                                                              eng.pdf
                        Project management in
                        operations of Executive
                        Authorities

                        2.5 Финансирование               Analysis of the system of budget planning in structures of executive power, А.             CIDA, Public                             CIDA_budg
                        деятельности органов             Klimen ko, N. Klisch, Е. Berezdivina, 2004                                                 Admin istration                          et
                        исполнительной власти,                                                                                                      Reform in Russia                         planning.doc
                        бюджетирование по
                        результатам / Financing of       Manual on Govern ment Finance Statistics                                                   IMF                      http://www.i    http://www.
                        Public Authorities                                                                                                                                   mf.org/exter    minfin.ru/p m
                        Operations, Perfo rmance                                                                                                                             nal/pubs/ft/g   fkrf/408372.p
                        Budgeting                                                                                                                                            fs/manual/in    df
                                                                                                                                                                             dex.htm




Prepa red by the WB/DFID Development Pa rtners Secreta ria t for Governance Reforms in Russia. You a re welcome to send informa tion on new resources to be i ncluded in this database to    31
Tumun Ts ydypov a t tts ydypov@worldbank.org / Подготовлено Секретариа том партнеров по ра звитию в обла сти реформы госуда рственного упра вления в России (Всемирный
Ба нк/Министерство Международного Ра звития Великобрита нии). Просим на правлять информацию о ма териа ла х для включения в ба зу да нных Тумуну Цыдыпову по а дресу
tts ydypov@worldbank.org
                                                                                                                                                                         Updated: August 2008


                                                         A Strategy Map for Results-based Budgeting: Moving fro m Theory to Practice,               The Finance              Fried man_ro
                                                         Mark Fried man, prepared fo r The Finance Pro ject, September 1996                         Project                  admap_eng.
                                                                                                                                                                             doc



                                                         Govern ment Internal Audit Standards: Good Practice Guidance. The Ro le of                 HM Treasury, UK          http://www.
                                                         Internal Audit – Resource Budgeting, December 2002                                                                  hm-
                                                                                                                                                                             treasury.gov
                                                                                                                                                                             .uk/ media/ B
                                                                                                                                                                             8033/pss_G
                                                                                                                                                                             PG_resource
                                                                                                                                                                             _080704.pdf
                                                         Mid-Term Performance Budgeting: Results and Prospects at the Federal Level,                European                                 Performance
                                                         A. Pirie - Presentation at the conference “State Governance Reform and Its                 Co mmission, State                       _budgeting_S
                                                         Implementation at the Reg ional Level”, September 2004, Moscow                             Budget Reform in                         ep04_rus.ppt
                                                                                                                                                    Russia, 2003-2004




                                                         Swedish Budget Reform, J. Bruno - Presentation at the conference “State                    Swedish-Russian                          Swedish_bud
                                                         Governance Reform and Its Implementation at the Regional Level”, September                 Cooperation                              g_ref_Sep04
                                                         2004, Moscow                                                                               Programme                                _rus.ppt




Prepa red by the WB/DFID Development Pa rtners Secreta ria t for Governance Reforms in Russia. You a re welcome to send informa tion on new resources to be i ncluded in this database to    32
Tumun Ts ydypov a t tts ydypov@worldbank.org / Подготовлено Секретариа том партнеров по ра звитию в обла сти реформы госуда рственного упра вления в России (Всемирный
Ба нк/Министерство Международного Ра звития Великобрита нии). Просим на правлять информацию о ма териа ла х для включения в ба зу да нных Тумуну Цыдыпову по а дресу
tts ydypov@worldbank.org
                                                                                                                                                                         Updated: August 2008


                                                         Methodological Reco mmendations on Increasing Effectiveness of Budget                      European                                PBB_ Chuvas
                                                         Expenditures in Executive Authorities of Chuvash Republic, presentation at the             Co mmission Civ il                      hiya_rus.ppt
                                                         conference of EC Project “Civ il Service Reform (AR II)”, March 2005                       Service Reform
                                                                                                                                                    (AR II) Project
                                                         Budget Process as an Instrument of Effective Management, Swed ish-Russian                  Swedish-Russian                         Budget_proc
                                                         Cooperation Program, Regeringskansliet, Stockholm, 2005                                    Cooperation                             ess_SIDA_ru
                                                                                                                                                    Program                                 s.pdf
                                                         Integration of Recurrent and Capital “Develop ment” Budgets: Issues, Problems,             World Ban k              Note_recurr
                                                         Country Experiences, and the Way Forward, Feridoun Saraff, Ju ly 2005                                               ent_capital_
                                                                                                                                                                             eng.pdf
                                                         Lessons from SBR in Financial Management, Monitoring, Evaluation and                       European                 EC_budget2     EC_budget2_
                                                         Audit, P. Boulding, p resentation at the kick-off seminar, Moscow, 6 September             Co mmission Public       _Boulding_e    Boulding_rus
                                                         2005                                                                                       Expenditure              ng.ppt         .ppt
                                                                                                                                                    Management
                                                                                                                                                    Project
                                                         Medium Term Performance Based Budgeting - Lessons Learned and Way                          European                 EC_budget2     EC_budget2_
                                                         Forward, presentation at the kick-o ff seminar, Moscow, 6 September 2005                   Co mmission Public       _Brooke_en     Brooke_rus.p
                                                                                                                                                    Expenditure              g.ppt          pt
                                                                                                                                                    Management
                                                                                                                                                    Project
                                                         Up-to-date Experience of Budget Reform Imp lementation in Russia, M.                       European                 EC_budget2     EC_budget2_
                                                         Klishina, presentation at the kick-o ff seminar, Moscow, 6 September 2005                  Co mmission Public       _Klishina_e    Klishina_rus.
                                                                                                                                                    Expenditure              ng.ppt         ppt
                                                                                                                                                    Management
                                                                                                                                                    Project
                                                         Starting point: the role of the «State Budget Reform» pro ject in reforming the            European                 EC_budget2     EC_budget2_
                                                         budget process in the Russian Federation, O. Yastrebova, presentation at the               Co mmission Public       _Yastrebova    Yastrebova_r
                                                         kick-o ff seminar, Moscow, 6 September 2005                                                Expenditure              _eng.ppt       us.ppt
                                                                                                                                                    Management
                                                                                                                                                    Project
                                                         Michael Ossel, Deputy Head of Budget Department, M inistry of Finance                      Swedish-Russian
                                                                                                                                                                                            Budget
                                                         “Budget Process – work for stabilization and effect iveness, Swedish reforms               cooperation
                                                                                                                                                                                            process_Swe
                                                         experience”                                                                                programme
                                                                                                                                                                                            desh
                                                                                                                                                                                            experience_r
                                                                                                                                                                                            u.doc



Prepa red by the WB/DFID Development Pa rtners Secreta ria t for Governance Reforms in Russia. You a re welcome to send informa tion on new resources to be i ncluded in this database to   33
Tumun Ts ydypov a t tts ydypov@worldbank.org / Подготовлено Секретариа том партнеров по ра звитию в обла сти реформы госуда рственного упра вления в России (Всемирный
Ба нк/Министерство Международного Ра звития Великобрита нии). Просим на правлять информацию о ма териа ла х для включения в ба зу да нных Тумуну Цыдыпову по а дресу
tts ydypov@worldbank.org
                                                                                                                                                                         Updated: August 2008


                                                         Pro memoria “Calculation of Assignations” Seminar with RF M inistry of                     Swedish-Russian
                                                                                                                                                                                            Prememo ria_
                                                         Finance, Stockholm, 5-7 November 2003.                                                     cooperation
                                                                                                                                                                                            seminar with
                                                                                                                                                    programme
                                                                                                                                                                                            Min of
                                                                                                                                                                                            Fin_Nov
                                                                                                                                                                                            2003_ru_doc


                                                         Experience and Perspectives of Budget Reform. Presentation made by Lavrov                  МЕDT-World
                                                                                                                                                                                            Experience_p
                                                         A.M. Seminar " Realization of the Concept of admin istrative reform in the                 Bank
                                                                                                                                                                                            erspectives_
                                                         Russian Federation in 2006-2008: coordination of actions at federal and
                                                                                                                                                                                            Dec2005_rus
                                                         regional levels ", December 15-16 2005, Moscow
                                                                                                                                                                                            .ppt

                                                         The Performing State. Reflect ion on an Idea Whose Time Has Co me but Whose                OECD_Asian               The_Perfor
                                                         Implementation Has Not, by Allen Schick, Brookings Institute. Bangkok,                     Senior Budget            ming_State_
                                                         Thailand, 15-16 December 2005.                                                             Officials                OECD_eng.
                                                                                                                                                                             pdf
                                                         Public Sector Budget Management Issues in Ch ina, by Ch ristine Wong,                      OECD_Asian               Public_secto
                                                         University of Washington, Seattle. Bangkok, Thailand, 15-16 December 2005.                 Senior Budget            r_Budget_M
                                                                                                                                                    Officials                gt_issues_in
                                                                                                                                                                             _China_OE
                                                                                                                                                                             CD_eng.pdf
                                                         Sustainable Budget Policy-Concepts and Approaches, by Allen Schick,                        OECD_Asian               Sustainable_
                                                         Brookings Institute. Bangkok, Thailand, 15-16 December 2005                                Senior Budget            Budget_Poli
                                                                                                                                                    Officials                cies_Concep
                                                                                                                                                                             ts_and-
                                                                                                                                                                             Approaches
                                                                                                                                                                             _OECD_eng
                                                                                                                                                                             .pd
                                                         Public Finance Management Reform Guidelines. March 2005                                    The                      Co mmonwe
                                                                                                                                                    Co mmonwealth            alth_PFM_
                                                                                                                                                    Secretariat              GUIDELIN
                                                                                                                                                                             ES_2005_en
                                                                                                                                                                             g.pdf
                                                         Overview of performance-based approach to budget formu lation. Presentation                The World Ban k          PBB_ De
                                                                                                                                                                                            PBB_ De
                                                         by M. De Silva at the train ing “Strategic planning, program-based management,             Institute                Silva_Do mb
                                                                                                                                                                                            Silva_Do mba
                                                         and policy impact assessment”, 2006                                                                                 ai_eng.ppt
                                                                                                                                                                                            i_rus.ppt


Prepa red by the WB/DFID Development Pa rtners Secreta ria t for Governance Reforms in Russia. You a re welcome to send informa tion on new resources to be i ncluded in this database to   34
Tumun Ts ydypov a t tts ydypov@worldbank.org / Подготовлено Секретариа том партнеров по ра звитию в обла сти реформы госуда рственного упра вления в России (Всемирный
Ба нк/Министерство Международного Ра звития Великобрита нии). Просим на правлять информацию о ма териа ла х для включения в ба зу да нных Тумуну Цыдыпову по а дресу
tts ydypov@worldbank.org
                                                                                                                                                                         Updated: August 2008


                                                         Relation between strategic planning and performance based budgeting.                       World Ban k/EC
                                                                                                                                                                                            Bogdanov_D
                                                         Presentation by L. Bogdanov at the training “Strategic planning, program-based             Trust Fund/Center
                                                                                                                                                                                            ombai_rus.pp
                                                         management, and policy impact assessment”, 2006                                            for Fiscal Policy
                                                                                                                                                                                            t

                                                         Introducing performance based budgeting. Presentation by E. Kislyakov at the               MoEDT
                                                                                                                                                                                            Kislyakov_P
                                                         training “Strategic p lanning, program-based management, and policy impact
                                                                                                                                                                                            BB_rus.ppt
                                                         assessment”, 2006

                                                         Experience in reforming public finance. Presentation by A. Barakhovsky at the              Center for                              Barakhovsky
                                                         kick-o ff seminar of EC project “Management of subnational finance”, 2006                  Interbudgetary                          _1June2006_
                                                                                                                                                    Relations Research                      rus.pdf
                                                         Experience, results, and perspectives of budget reforms in Russia. Presentation            Ministry of Finance                     Lavrov_1Jun
                                                         by A. Lavrov at the kick-off seminar of EC pro ject “Management of subnational                                                     e2006_rus.pd
                                                         finance”, 2006                                                                                                                     f
                                                         Application of program-based budget planning at the regional level: targeted               World Ban k/EU TF                       BOR_ Do mba
                                                         programs of executive authorities. Presentation of A. Sokhnev at the training                                                      i_rus.ppt
                                                         “Strategic planning, program-based management, and policy impact
                                                         assessment”, 2006
                                                         OECD country experiences in performance based budgeting. Report, D.Shand,                  World Ban k              OECD_PBB       OECD_PB_e
                                                         January 2007                                                                                                        _experiences   xperiences_r
                                                                                                                                                                             .eng           us.doc
                                                         Performance Budgeting and Performance Management in the U.S. Govern ment:                  U.S. Office o f          PART_eng.      PART_rus.pp
                                                         Lessons from the PART Init iative. Presentation by John Pfeiffer, U.S. Office of           Management and           ppt            t
                                                         Management and Budget, 2007                                                                Budget


                                                         Improving public finance management in Northern Caucasus regions.                          Center for Fiscal        CFP_North      CFP_North
                                                         Presentation, 2007                                                                         Policy                   Caucasus_Fi    Caucasus_Fi
                                                                                                                                                                             nance_rus.p    nance_eng.pp
                                                                                                                                                                             pt             t
                                                         Pilot Pro jects on Imp lementation of Program Approach in Budgeting and                    Donor                                   Elista_Day1_
                                                         Expenditure Management in Executive Bodies of Regional Ad ministrations:                   Secretariat/World                       rus.zip
                                                         Results and Lessons Learnt: Presentations, Final Seminar, Project “Introduction            Bank
                                                         of Performance Management Elements at Sub-National Level in the Russian
                                                         Federation”, 2007




Prepa red by the WB/DFID Development Pa rtners Secreta ria t for Governance Reforms in Russia. You a re welcome to send informa tion on new resources to be i ncluded in this database to   35
Tumun Ts ydypov a t tts ydypov@worldbank.org / Подготовлено Секретариа том партнеров по ра звитию в обла сти реформы госуда рственного упра вления в России (Всемирный
Ба нк/Министерство Международного Ра звития Великобрита нии). Просим на правлять информацию о ма териа ла х для включения в ба зу да нных Тумуну Цыдыпову по а дресу
tts ydypov@worldbank.org
                                                                                                                                                                          Updated: August 2008


                                                         Performance budgeting in OECD countries. 2007                                              OECD                     PBB in
                                                                                                                                                                             OECD
                                                                                                                                                                             2007_eng.pd
                                                                                                                                                                             f
                                                         Fiscal decentralization in t ransit economies . Ed. By V.Klimanov. Moscow,                 Institute of Public                     Fiscal_decent
                                                         2007                                                                                       finance Reforms                         ralisation_tra
                                                                                                                                                                                            nsit_countrie
                                                                                                                                                                                            s_rus.pdf
                                                         Long-term sustainability of public finances in Russia. Presentation of Zeljco              WB                                      FISCA L_SU
                                                         Bogetic at the seminar “Strategy of budget reforms until 2012”, Moscow, 4 Ju ly                                                    STAIN_ Boge
                                                         2008                                                                                                                               tic_WB_Pres
                                                                                                                                                                                            entation
                                                                                                                                                                                            _rus.ppt

                                                         Lessons of budget reforms in transit countries and recommendations for Russia              ECORYS-NEI                              FISCA L_SU
                                                         Presentation of O. Yastrebova at the seminar “Strategy of budget reforms until                                                     STAIN_ ECO
                                                         2012”, Moscow, 4 July 2008                                                                                                         RYS_ Budget
                                                                                                                                                                                            _reforms_tra
                                                                                                                                                                                            nsit_rus.ppt
                                                         Financial relations between levels of government. Chapter 6 of the Russian                 OECD                     FISCA L_S
                                                         Budget Review by Valentina Kostyleva-Mejdahl. Presentation at the seminar                                           USTAIN_K
                                                         “Strategy of budget reforms until 2012”, Moscow, 4 Ju ly 2008                                                       ostyleva_OE
                                                                                                                                                                             CD_intergo
                                                                                                                                                                             vernmental_
                                                                                                                                                                             relations_en
                                                                                                                                                                             g.ppt
                                                         Budget Formulation and Fiscal Rules: international and Russia‟s experience.                OECD                     FISCA L_S
                                                         Dirk-Jan Kraan. Presentation at the seminar “Strategy of budget reforms until                                       USTAIN_K
                                                         2012”, Moscow, 4 July 2008                                                                                          raan_Russia
                                                                                                                                                                             n Budget
                                                                                                                                                                             Review_OE
                                                                                                                                                                             CD_eng.ppt




Prepa red by the WB/DFID Development Pa rtners Secreta ria t for Governance Reforms in Russia. You a re welcome to send informa tion on new resources to be i ncluded in this database to   36
Tumun Ts ydypov a t tts ydypov@worldbank.org / Подготовлено Секретариа том партнеров по ра звитию в обла сти реформы госуда рственного упра вления в России (Всемирный
Ба нк/Министерство Международного Ра звития Великобрита нии). Просим на правлять информацию о ма териа ла х для включения в ба зу да нных Тумуну Цыдыпову по а дресу
tts ydypov@worldbank.org
                                                                                                                                                                         Updated: August 2008


                                                         Results, lessons and prospects of the budget reform in Russia. A. Lavrov.                  RF Min istry of                          FISCA L_SU
                                                         Presentation at the seminar “Strategy of budget reforms until 2012”, Moscow, 4             Finance                                  STAIN_ Lavr
                                                         July 2008                                                                                                                           ov_Budget_r
                                                                                                                                                                                             eform_results
                                                                                                                                                                                             _&_prospects
                                                                                                                                                                                             _rus.ppt
                                                         Budget reform in Kazakhstan. J. Litwack. Presentation at the seminar “Strategy             WB                                       FISCA L_SU
                                                         of budget reforms until 2012”, Moscow, 4 July 2008                                                                                  STAIN_ Litw
                                                                                                                                                                                             ack_Budget_
                                                                                                                                                                                             reform_ Kaza
                                                                                                                                                                                             khstan_rus.p
                                                                                                                                                                                             pt
                                                         Health challenges in Russia: outcomes, expenditures, reforms. Rifat Atun and               WB                       FISCA L_S
                                                         Patricio Marquez. Presentation at the seminar “Strategy of budget reforms until                                     USTAIN_M
                                                         2012”, Moscow, 4 July 2008                                                                                          arquez_WB
                                                                                                                                                                             _Health_eng
                                                                                                                                                                             .ppt
                                                         Introduction of mid-term performance budgeting: comparison of federal and                  RF Min istry of                          FISCA L_SU
                                                         regional experience. V.Sidorenko. Presentation at the seminar “Strategy of                 Finance                                  STAIN_M inf
                                                         budget reforms until 2012”, Moscow, 4 Ju ly 2008                                                                                    in_Mid-
                                                                                                                                                                                             term_perform
                                                                                                                                                                                             ance_budgeti
                                                                                                                                                                                             ng_rus.ppt
                                                         Budget reform in the Russian Federation: experience of the Fund for regional               WB                                       FISCA L_SU
                                                         and municipal finance reforms. V. Onischenko. Presentation at the seminar                                                           STAIN_ Onis
                                                         “Strategy of budget reforms until 2012”, Moscow, 4 Ju ly 2008                                                                       chenko_Regi
                                                                                                                                                                                             onal_Budget
                                                                                                                                                                                             _reform_rus.
                                                                                                                                                                                             ppt
                                                         The role of Parliament and Supreme Audit Institution in the scrutiny of public             German Technical         FISCA L_S
                                                         expenditure. Russias´s experiences and international trends. M.Witt.                       Cooperation              USTAIN_W
                                                         Presentation at the seminar “Strategy of budget reforms until 2012”, Moscow, 4                                      itt_effective
                                                         July 2008                                                                                                           external
                                                                                                                                                                             scrutiny_eng
                                                                                                                                                                             .ppt




Prepa red by the WB/DFID Development Pa rtners Secreta ria t for Governance Reforms in Russia. You a re welcome to send informa tion on new resources to be i ncluded in this database to    37
Tumun Ts ydypov a t tts ydypov@worldbank.org / Подготовлено Секретариа том партнеров по ра звитию в обла сти реформы госуда рственного упра вления в России (Всемирный
Ба нк/Министерство Международного Ра звития Великобрита нии). Просим на правлять информацию о ма териа ла х для включения в ба зу да нных Тумуну Цыдыпову по а дресу
tts ydypov@worldbank.org
                                                                                                                                                                          Updated: August 2008


                                                         Principles of efficient and responsible public finance management. RF Min istry            RF Min istry of                         Minfin_effici
                                                         of Finance report for G8 2006.                                                             Finance                                 ent_responci
                                                                                                                                                                                            ble_public_fi
                                                                                                                                                                                            nance_manag
                                                                                                                                                                                            ement_report
                                                                                                                                                                                            for G8
                                                                                                                                                                                            2006_eng.pdf
                                                         Materials of the RF M inistry of Finance on experiment on introduction of                  RF Min istry of                         Minfin_2007
                                                         performance budgeting in 2007                                                              Finance                                 _performance
                                                                                                                                                                                            _budgeting_e
                                                                                                                                                                                            xperiment_ru
                                                                                                                                                                                            s.zip
                                                         Regional public finance reforms strategy. V.Klimanov in Budget. 2007, No.9                 Institute of Public                     Regional_pu
                                                                                                                                                    Finance Reforms                         blic_finance_
                                                                                                                                                                                            reforms_strat
                                                                                                                                                                                            egy_rus.pdf
                                                         Urban public finance reforms. Ed ited by V.Klimanov. Moscow, 2008                          Institute of Public                     Urban_public
                                                                                                                                                    Finance Reforms                         _finance_refo
                                                                                                                                                                                            rsm_rus.pdf
                                                         Innovations in public sector management at the regional level. Edited by                   Institute for                           Regional_pu
                                                         V.Klimanov. Public Finance series. Moscow, 2006                                            Regional Public                         blic_sector_
                                                                                                                                                    Finances                                management
                                                                                                                                                                                            _innovations
                                                                                                                                                                                            _rus.pdf
                                                         Successful Health Reform in the Russian Federation: Evidence fro m Chuvash                 WB                       FISCA L_S
                                                         Republic and Vo ronezh Oblast. Presentation by Professor Rifat Atun and Dr                                          USTAIN_At
                                                         Patricio Marquez at the seminar “Strategy of budget reforms until 2012”                                             un_Russia
                                                         Moscow, 4 July 2008                                                                                                 Health
                                                                                                                                                                             reform 7-
                                                                                                                                                                             08_eng.ppt
                                                         Production and Quality of Informat ion for Perfo rmance. Budgeting: The                    WB                       Mexico_200
                                                         Australian Case. Lewis Hawke. Report at the International Conference on                                             8_PBB_Aus
                                                         Performance Budgeting. Mexico City, June 9 2008                                                                     tralia_eng.p
                                                                                                                                                                             df




Prepa red by the WB/DFID Development Pa rtners Secreta ria t for Governance Reforms in Russia. You a re welcome to send informa tion on new resources to be i ncluded in this database to   38
Tumun Ts ydypov a t tts ydypov@worldbank.org / Подготовлено Секретариа том партнеров по ра звитию в обла сти реформы госуда рственного упра вления в России (Всемирный
Ба нк/Министерство Международного Ра звития Великобрита нии). Просим на правлять информацию о ма териа ла х для включения в ба зу да нных Тумуну Цыдыпову по а дресу
tts ydypov@worldbank.org
                                                                                                                                                                         Updated: August 2008


                                                         Some Observations on the Concepts and the State of the Art in Performance                  Graham Scott,            Mexico_200
                                                         Budgeting. Graham Scott. Report at the International Conference on                         former secretary to      8_Concepts
                                                         Performance Budgeting. Mexico City, June 9 2008                                            the treasure, New        _PBB_eng.p
                                                                                                                                                    Zealand                  df
                                                         Getting Performance Budgeting to Perform. Allen Sch ick. Report at the                     WB                       Mexico_200
                                                         International Conference on Performance Budgeting. Mexico City, June 9 2008                                         8_ Getting_P
                                                                                                                                                                             BB_to_refor
                                                                                                                                                                             m_eng.pdf
                                                         Performance Budgeting: A Users Gu ide. Barry Anderson. Report at the                       OECD                     Mexico_200
                                                         International Conference on Performance Budgeting. Mexico City, June 9 2008                                         8_OECD_P
                                                                                                                                                                             BB_Usergui
                                                                                                                                                                             de_eng.pdf
                                                         Institutional Foundations for Performance Budgeting: The Case of the                       Results-based            Mexico_200
                                                         Govern ment of Canada. Lee McCormack. Report at the International                          Management               8_PBB_Can
                                                         Conference on Performance Budgeting. Mexico City, June 9 2008                              Treasury Board,          ada_eng.pdf
                                                                                                                                                    Canada

                                                         Performance Budgeting in France and Public Service Delivery. Frédéric Bobay.               Ministry of              Mexico_200
                                                         Report at the International Conference on Perfo rmance Budgeting. Mexico City,             Economy, France
                                                                                                                                                                             8_PBB_Fra
                                                         June 9 2008                                                                                                         nce_eng.pdf

                                                         Production and Quality of Informat ion for Perfo rmance Budgeting. Definit ion             International            Mexico_200
                                                         of Indicators and the use of Log-Frames. Marc Robinson. Report at the                      Monetary Fund
                                                                                                                                                                             8_PBB_IMF
                                                         International Conference on Performance Budgeting. Mexico City, June 9 2008                                         _Performanc
                                                                                                                                                                             e_informatio
                                                                                                                                                                             n_eng.pdf

                                                         Performance-Informed Budgeting in Lat in A merica: experiences and                         WB                       Mexico_200
                                                         opportunities. Nick Manning. Report at the International Conference on
                                                                                                                                                                             8_PBB_Lat i
                                                         Performance Budgeting. Mexico City, June 9 2008                                                                     n_America_
                                                                                                                                                                             eng.pdf

                                                         Program budgeting in the Netherlands. Raphael Debets and Helmer Vossers.                   Ministry of              Mexico_200
                                                         Report at the International Conference on Perfo rmance Budgeting. Mexico City,             Finance,                 8_PBB_NL
                                                         June 9 2008.                                                                               Netherlands              _eng.pdf




Prepa red by the WB/DFID Development Pa rtners Secreta ria t for Governance Reforms in Russia. You a re welcome to send informa tion on new resources to be i ncluded in this database to   39
Tumun Ts ydypov a t tts ydypov@worldbank.org / Подготовлено Секретариа том партнеров по ра звитию в обла сти реформы госуда рственного упра вления в России (Всемирный
Ба нк/Министерство Международного Ра звития Великобрита нии). Просим на правлять информацию о ма териа ла х для включения в ба зу да нных Тумуну Цыдыпову по а дресу
tts ydypov@worldbank.org
                                                                                                                                                                            Updated: August 2008


                                                            The Use of Performance Information by Cit izens. Miguel Braun. Report at the               Center for the           Mexico_200
                                                            International Conference on Performance Budgeting. Mexico City, June 9 2008.               Implementation of
                                                                                                                                                                                8_PBB_Perf
                                                                                                                                                       Public Policies          ormance_inf
                                                                                                                                                       (CIPPEC),
                                                                                                                                                                                ormat ion_fo
                                                                                                                                                       Argentina
                                                                                                                                                                                r_citizens_e
                                                                                                                                                                                ng.pdf

                                                            Performance Budgeting in Korea: Observations and Lessons. Nowook Park.                     Korea Institute of       Mexico_200
                                                            Report at the International Conference on Perfo rmance Budgeting. Mexico City,             Public Finance,          8_PBB_Sou
                                                            June 9 2008.                                                                               Korea
                                                                                                                                                                                th_Korea_en
                                                                                                                                                                                g.pdf

                                                            The Institutional Foundations for Performance Budgeting: The Nord ic Case.                 Agency for Public        Mexico_200
                                                            Knut Rexed. Report at the International Conference on Performance Budgeting.               Management,
                                                                                                                                                                                8_PBB_Swe
                                                            Mexico City, June 9 2008.                                                                  Sweden                   den_eng.pdf

                                                            Spending Reviews and performance budgeting in the UK. Richard Hughes.                      International            Mexico_200
                                                            Report at the International Conference on Perfo rmance Budgeting. Mexico City,             Monetary Fund
                                                                                                                                                                                8_PBB_UK
                                                            June 9 2008.                                                                                                        _eng.pdf

                           2.6. Системы аутсорсинга
                           административно-
                           управленческих
                           процессов/Outsourcing of
                           Admin istrative and
                           Management Process
3. Формирование            3.1 Государственная              Ray mond Piganio l, “Informat ion systems on Human resources management”:                  European                                Information
кад рового состава         кадровая по литика / State       case of France»                                                                            Co mmission,                            systems in
госуд арственной           personnel policy                                                                                                            Public                                  HR
службы / Human                                                                                                                                         Admin istration                         management
resources                                                                                                                                              Reform in Russia                        _rus
management in Public
Service
                                                            Tamás M. HORVATH, Presentation “The HR policy in the Hungarian civil                       European                                HR
                                                            service”                                                                                   Co mmission,                            policy_Hung
                                                                                                                                                       Public                                  ary.rus
                                                                                                                                                       Admin istration
                                                                                                                                                       Reform in Russia

   Prepa red by the WB/DFID Development Pa rtners Secreta ria t for Governance Reforms in Russia. You a re welcome to send informa tion on new resources to be i ncluded in this database to   40
   Tumun Ts ydypov a t tts ydypov@worldbank.org / Подготовлено Секретариа том партнеров по ра звитию в обла сти реформы госуда рственного упра вления в России (Всемирный
   Ба нк/Министерство Международного Ра звития Великобрита нии). Просим на правлять информацию о ма териа ла х для включения в ба зу да нных Тумуну Цыдыпову по а дресу
   tts ydypov@worldbank.org
                                                                                                                                                                         Updated: August 2008


                                                         Patricia Bairsto, Hu man Resources Management: Co mparative study, 3 June                  DFID Public                             HRM_compa
                                                         2004                                                                                       Admin istration                         rative
                                                                                                                                                    Reform pro ject                         study.pdf
                                                         Patricia Bairsto, Emp loy ment Agencies: experience of the United Kingdom                  DFID Public                             Emp loy ment
                                                                                                                                                    Admin istration                         Agencies.pdf
                                                                                                                                                    Reform pro ject
                                                         Defining HR Purpose and Roles – handout to the seminar, 28 April 2004                      DFID Public              Defining HR    Defining HR
                                                                                                                                                    Admin istration          purpose and    purpose and
                                                                                                                                                    Reform pro ject          roles_eng.do   roles_rus.doc
                                                                                                                                                                             c
                                                         Recru it ment and Career: General Council of Seine and Marne- Presentation                 European                                Recru it ment
                                                                                                                                                    Co mmission,                            and
                                                                                                                                                    Public                                  Career_Prese
                                                                                                                                                    Admin istration                         ntation_rus.d
                                                                                                                                                    Reform in Russia                        oc
                                                         Samples of French Regulat ions on appointment, career pro mot ion of civ il                European                                French
                                                         servants and other issues                                                                  Co mmission,                            Legislat ion.ra
                                                                                                                                                    Public                                  r
                                                                                                                                                    Admin istration
                                                                                                                                                    Reform in Russia
                                                         Central Personnel Un it in Ad ministration                                                 DFID Public              Central
                                                                                                                                                    Admin istration          Personnel
                                                                                                                                                    Reform Project           Unit in
                                                                                                                                                                             administrati
                                                                                                                                                                             on_eng.doc
                                                         Hu man Resource Management in the Russian Federation Federal Civil                     World Ban k                  HRM_Diag
                                                         Service : Diagnostic Study. Report prepared by Talaibek Ko ichumanov and                                            nostic_eng.r
                                                         Olha Lu kashenko and edited by Neil Parison, February 2004                                                          u




Prepa red by the WB/DFID Development Pa rtners Secreta ria t for Governance Reforms in Russia. You a re welcome to send informa tion on new resources to be i ncluded in this database to   41
Tumun Ts ydypov a t tts ydypov@worldbank.org / Подготовлено Секретариа том партнеров по ра звитию в обла сти реформы госуда рственного упра вления в России (Всемирный
Ба нк/Министерство Международного Ра звития Великобрита нии). Просим на правлять информацию о ма териа ла х для включения в ба зу да нных Тумуну Цыдыпову по а дресу
tts ydypov@worldbank.org
                                                                                                                                                                         Updated: August 2008


                                                         Work with Senio r Public Officials in the Un ited States, V. Lobanov, State            State Management                               Lobanov_US
                                                         Management University, Moscow 2003                                                     University, Moscow                             A_rus.doc




                                                         Career, Grad ing and Pay System in the German Civil Serv ice, Joachim                  European                     Career_ Ger       Career_ Germ
                                                         Vo llmuth, 2005                                                                        Co mmission, Public          many_eng.d        any_rus.doc
                                                                                                                                                Admin istration Reform       oc
                                                                                                                                                in Russia



                                                         Planning Career Develop ment, presentation at the conference of EC Project             European Co mmission                           Staff_reserve
                                                         “Civil Service Reform (AR II)”, March 2005                                             Civil Service Reform                           _rus.ppt
                                                                                                                                                (AR II) Project




                                                         Civil Service Co mmissioners‟ Recru it ment Code, 5th Ed ition – March 2004,           Office o f the Civil         http://www.
                                                         Office o f the Civil Serv ice Co mmissioners, UK                                       Service                      civilservicec
                                                                                                                                                Co mmissioners, UK           ommissioner
                                                                                                                                                                             s.gov.uk/pub
                                                                                                                                                                             licat ions_an
                                                                                                                                                                             d_forms/htm
                                                                                                                                                                             l/recru it ment
                                                                                                                                                                             _code/index.
                                                                                                                                                                             asp
                                                         Fast Track Career Development: co mparative Perspectives, T. Verheijen,                World Ban k                  Fast_Track_       Fast_Track_
                                                         presentation in Ko mi Republic, May 2005, World Ban k                                                               Career_Ko m       Career_Ko mi
                                                                                                                                                                             i_eng.ppt         _rus.ppt




Prepa red by the WB/DFID Development Pa rtners Secreta ria t for Governance Reforms in Russia. You a re welcome to send informa tion on new resources to be i ncluded in this database to      42
Tumun Ts ydypov a t tts ydypov@worldbank.org / Подготовлено Секретариа том партнеров по ра звитию в обла сти реформы госуда рственного упра вления в России (Всемирный
Ба нк/Министерство Международного Ра звития Великобрита нии). Просим на правлять информацию о ма териа ла х для включения в ба зу да нных Тумуну Цыдыпову по а дресу
tts ydypov@worldbank.org
                                                                                                                                                                         Updated: August 2008


                                                         Qualifications Required for the UK Civil Service, S.Catchpole, 2005                    European                     Qualificatio     Qualification
                                                                                                                                                Co mmission, Public          ns_UKCS_e        s_UKCS_ rus.
                                                                                                                                                Admin istration Reform       ng.doc           doc
                                                                                                                                                in Russia



                                                         Managing Senior Management: Senior Civil Serv ice Reform in OECD                       OECD                         http://appli1.
                                                         Member Countries. Backg round Note. 28th Session of the Public                                                      oecd.org/olis
                                                         Management Co mmittee, 13-14 November 2003, Paris                                                                   /2003doc.nsf
                                                                                                                                                                             /43bb6130e
                                                                                                                                                                             5e86e5fc125
                                                                                                                                                                             69fa005d00
                                                                                                                                                                             4c/481f49ba
                                                                                                                                                                             e23a5600c1
                                                                                                                                                                             256dcd0039
                                                                                                                                                                             122c/$FILE/
                                                                                                                                                                             JT00153050
                                                                                                                                                                             .PDF
                                                         Civil Service and Ad min istrative Reform: Co mments on the Concept of                 World Ban k                                   Admin regl
                                                         Federal Law « On Administrative Regulations in the Agencies of Executive                                                             comments_ru
                                                         Authority in the Russian Federation», Center for Strategic Studies, 27 April                                                         .doc
                                                         2004



                        3.2 Кадровые технологии          David Richards, “Career progression: Experience of the UK”                             European                                      Career
                        на государственной                                                                                                      Co mmission, Public                           development
                        службе / Hu man resources                                                                                               Admin istration Reform                        _UK
                        technologies in civil                                                                                                   in Russia
                        service


                                                         Pierre Schreiber, “Career development: French experience”                              European                                      Career
                                                                                                                                                Co mmission, Public                           development_
                                                                                                                                                Admin istration Reform                        France.doc
                                                                                                                                                in Russia



Prepa red by the WB/DFID Development Pa rtners Secreta ria t for Governance Reforms in Russia. You a re welcome to send informa tion on new resources to be i ncluded in this database to     43
Tumun Ts ydypov a t tts ydypov@worldbank.org / Подготовлено Секретариа том партнеров по ра звитию в обла сти реформы госуда рственного упра вления в России (Всемирный
Ба нк/Министерство Международного Ра звития Великобрита нии). Просим на правлять информацию о ма териа ла х для включения в ба зу да нных Тумуну Цыдыпову по а дресу
tts ydypov@worldbank.org
                                                                                                                                                                         Updated: August 2008


                                                         Ron Carr, “Performance appraisal – organizations: European Experience”                 European                                       Performance
                                                                                                                                                Co mmission, Public                            evaluation_or
                                                                                                                                                Admin istration Reform                         ganization_E
                                                                                                                                                in Russia                                      urope.doc



                                                         Philippe Mazuel, Presentation «Performance management: European                        European                                       Performance_
                                                         Experience»                                                                            Co mmission, Public                            European
                                                                                                                                                Admin istration Reform                         experience_ru
                                                                                                                                                in Russia                                      s
                                                         Irina Kotelevskaya, Performance Appraisal – Civil Servants                             European                                       Performance
                                                                                                                                                Co mmission, Public                            appraisal_Rus
                                                                                                                                                Admin istration Reform                         sia_rus
                                                                                                                                                in Russia

                                                         Pierre Schreiber, “Select ion and recruit ment of staff”                               European                                       Selection and
                                                                                                                                                Co mmission, Public                            recruit ment
                                                                                                                                                Admin istration Reform                         of
                                                                                                                                                in Russia                                      staff_France.
                                                                                                                                                                                               doc


                                                         A Western European Examp le of Recruit ment Procedures                                 DFID Public                  Example      of     Example of
                                                                                                                                                Admin istration Project      Recru it ment_e     Recru it men
                                                                                                                                                                             n.doc               t_ru.doc




Prepa red by the WB/DFID Development Pa rtners Secreta ria t for Governance Reforms in Russia. You a re welcome to send informa tion on new resources to be i ncluded in this database to      44
Tumun Ts ydypov a t tts ydypov@worldbank.org / Подготовлено Секретариа том партнеров по ра звитию в обла сти реформы госуда рственного упра вления в России (Всемирный
Ба нк/Министерство Международного Ра звития Великобрита нии). Просим на правлять информацию о ма териа ла х для включения в ба зу да нных Тумуну Цыдыпову по а дресу
tts ydypov@worldbank.org
                                                                                                                                                                         Updated: August 2008


                                                         HR Development Analysis for Federal M inistries and Agencies (Step One)                DFID Public                  HR Dev            HR Dev
                                                                                                                                                Admin istration Project      Analysis_eng.     Analysis_r
                                                                                                                                                                             doc               us.doc




                                                         Note on Problems of HR Services and Key Direct ions of Work to Solve                   DFID Public                  Problems of       Problems
                                                         Them                                                                                   Admin istration Project      HR_eng.doc        of
                                                                                                                                                                                               HR_rus.do
                                                                                                                                                                                               c




                                                         Recru iting in Eu rope – Brief In formation                                            DFID Public                  Recru iting in
                                                                                                                                                Admin istration Project      Europe_eng.d
                                                                                                                                                                             oc




                                                         Evaluation of Civ il Servants - Examp le                                               European                                       Evaluation
                                                         Criteria for Evaluation and Co mpilation of the Evaluation Sheet                       Co mmission, Public                            criteria_ru.
                                                                                                                                                Admin istration Reform                         doc
                                                                                                                                                in Russia




Prepa red by the WB/DFID Development Pa rtners Secreta ria t for Governance Reforms in Russia. You a re welcome to send informa tion on new resources to be i ncluded in this database to     45
Tumun Ts ydypov a t tts ydypov@worldbank.org / Подготовлено Секретариа том партнеров по ра звитию в обла сти реформы госуда рственного упра вления в России (Всемирный
Ба нк/Министерство Международного Ра звития Великобрита нии). Просим на правлять информацию о ма териа ла х для включения в ба зу да нных Тумуну Цыдыпову по а дресу
tts ydypov@worldbank.org
                                                                                                                                                                         Updated: August 2008


                                                         Samples of Public Agencies HR Depart ments Documents – French                          European                                      Samples of
                                                         experience                                                                             Co mmission, Public                           HR Dept
                                                                                                                                                Admin istration Reform                        Documents
                                                                                                                                                in Russia                                     .rar




                                                         Assessment and Development Centers (handout materials), D. Batt le,                    European                     AssessmentCe     Assessment
                                                         October 2004                                                                           Co mmission, Public          nters_eng.doc    Centers_ru
                                                                                                                                                Admin istration Reform                        s.doc
                                                                                                                                                in Russia




                                                         Job Regulation Development, presentation at the conference of EC P roject              European Co mmission                          Job_regulat
                                                         “Civil Service Reform (AR II)”, March 2005                                             Civil Service Reform                          ion_rus.ppt
                                                                                                                                                (AR II) Project




                                                         Making and Managing Public Appointments, a Gu ide for Depart ments,                    Cabinet Office, UK           Public_appt_g
                                                         Third Edit ion, Cabinet Office, UK, September 2004                                                                  uide_eng.pdf




Prepa red by the WB/DFID Development Pa rtners Secreta ria t for Governance Reforms in Russia. You a re welcome to send informa tion on new resources to be i ncluded in this database to    46
Tumun Ts ydypov a t tts ydypov@worldbank.org / Подготовлено Секретариа том партнеров по ра звитию в обла сти реформы госуда рственного упра вления в России (Всемирный
Ба нк/Министерство Международного Ра звития Великобрита нии). Просим на правлять информацию о ма териа ла х для включения в ба зу да нных Тумуну Цыдыпову по а дресу
tts ydypov@worldbank.org
                                                                                                                                                                         Updated: August 2008


                                                         A Handbook for Measuring Emp loyee Performance. A ligning Emp loyee                    Workforce                    http://www.op      Standards_
                                                         Performance Plans with Organizational Goals in the USA, Workforce                      Co mpensation and            m.gov/perfor       USA.zip
                                                         Co mpensation and Performance Serv ice, September 2001                                 Performance Serv ice,        m/WPPDF/20
                                                                                                                                                USA                          02/ HANDBO
                                                                                                                                                                             OK.PDF




                                                         Improving Performance Management: The Relevance of the Balanced                        DFID Public                  360_eng.zip        360_rus.zip
                                                         Scorecard Approach to the Russian Federation. Individual Appraisal – 360               Admin istration Reform
                                                         Degree Feedback, June 2005                                                             Project




                                                         Develop ment of Civ il Servant‟s Performance Contract, L. Tatarinova,                  World Ban k                                     PefContrac
                                                         presentation at the seminar, Pskov, July 4, 2005                                                                                       t_Tatarinov
                                                                                                                                                                                                a_rus.ppt




                                                         Co mparative analysis of EU practices in the field of „Job regulations‟,               European                     EUpractice_A       EUpractice
                                                         “Admin istrative reform-I” Project papers, 2005                                        Co mmission, Public          rticle_ 47_eng.    _Article_4
                                                                                                                                                Admin istration Reform       doc                7_rus.doc
                                                                                                                                                in Russia




Prepa red by the WB/DFID Development Pa rtners Secreta ria t for Governance Reforms in Russia. You a re welcome to send informa tion on new resources to be i ncluded in this database to      47
Tumun Ts ydypov a t tts ydypov@worldbank.org / Подготовлено Секретариа том партнеров по ра звитию в обла сти реформы госуда рственного упра вления в России (Всемирный
Ба нк/Министерство Международного Ра звития Великобрита нии). Просим на правлять информацию о ма териа ла х для включения в ба зу да нных Тумуну Цыдыпову по а дресу
tts ydypov@worldbank.org
                                                                                                                                                                         Updated: August 2008


                                                         Reco mmendations on the Structure and Contents of Generic Job Regulat ion,             European                     Generic_ job_r    Generic_ jo
                                                         EC Pro ject “Administrative Reform I”, 2005                                            Co mmission, Public          egulation_eng.    b_regulatio
                                                                                                                                                Admin istration Reform       doc               n_rus.doc
                                                                                                                                                in Russia




                                                         Sample Docu ments Related to Job Regulations of Senior Civ il Servants                 European                     SeniorCS_sam      SeniorCS_s
                                                         (based on international practice), S. Catchpole, EC Project “Ad ministrative           Co mmission, Public          ples_eng.zip      amp les_rus
                                                         Reform I”, 2005                                                                        Admin istration Reform                         .zip
                                                                                                                                                in Russia




                                                         Generic Job Regulat ion of Civ il Servants – samples, May 2005                         European                     Job_regulation    Job_regulat
                                                                                                                                                Co mmission, Public          s_samples_en      ions_sampl
                                                                                                                                                Admin istration Reform       g.zip             es_rus.zip
                                                                                                                                                in Russia




                                                         Implementation of methodologies for evaluation of civil servants‟                      World Ban k/DFID                               Interregion
                                                         performance and recruit ment-related assessment in Krasnoyarsk Krai.                   Trust Fund                                     al_Krasnoy
                                                         Presentation by L. Mitskevich at the seminar “Results of Pilot                                                                        arsk_rus.pp
                                                         Implementation of New Approaches to Performance Evaluation of Civ il                                                                  t
                                                         Servants at the Regional Level”, Vologda, March 20-21, 2006




Prepa red by the WB/DFID Development Pa rtners Secreta ria t for Governance Reforms in Russia. You a re welcome to send informa tion on new resources to be i ncluded in this database to     48
Tumun Ts ydypov a t tts ydypov@worldbank.org / Подготовлено Секретариа том партнеров по ра звитию в обла сти реформы госуда рственного упра вления в России (Всемирный
Ба нк/Министерство Международного Ра звития Великобрита нии). Просим на правлять информацию о ма териа ла х для включения в ба зу да нных Тумуну Цыдыпову по а дресу
tts ydypov@worldbank.org
                                                                                                                                                                         Updated: August 2008


                                                                                                                                                World Ban k                                  Assessment
                                                         Possible ways to improve the procedures for indiv idual evaluation in the                                                           _optimizat i
                                                         civil service. Presentation by Y. Dobro lyubova at the seminar “Results of                                                          on_rus.ppt
                                                         Pilot Imp lementation of New Approaches to Performance Evaluation of
                                                         Civil Servants at the Regional Level”, Vologda, March 20-21, 2006

                                                         Develop ment and Implementation of Methodologies for Co mpetit ive                     World Ban k/DFID                             Interregion
                                                         Selection and Performance Evaluation in the Civil Serv ice. Lessons and                Trust Fund                                   al_ Yu zhak
                                                         Opportunities of the Project. Presentation by V. Yu zhakov at the seminar                                                           ov_rus.ppt
                                                         “Results of Pilot Imp lementation of New Approaches to Performance
                                                         Evaluation of Civ il Servants at the Regional Level”, Vo logda, March 20-21,
                                                         2006

                                                         Experience in implementation of methods for planning and evaluating                    World Ban k/DFID                             Interregion
                                                         performance of an executive authority, it‟s structural unit, and indiv idual           Trust Fund                                   al_Morozo
                                                         civil servants. Examp le of Chuvashia republic. Presentation by E. Moro zova                                                        va_imp lem
                                                         at the seminar “Results of Pilot Imp lementation of New Approaches to                                                               entation_ru
                                                         Performance Evaluation of Civil Servants at the Regional Level”, Vologda,                                                           s.ppt
                                                         March 20-21, 2006

                                                                                                                                                World Ban k/DFID                             Interregion
                                                         The system of co mprehensive assessment and performance evaluation of                  Trust Fund                                   al_Morozo
                                                         civil servants: issues and perspectives (pilot authority: Ministry of Health                                                        va_system_
                                                         and Social Develop ment of Chuvashia republic). Presentation by E.                                                                  rus.ppt
                                                         Morozova at the seminar “Results of Pilot Imp lementation of New
                                                         Approaches to Performance Evaluation of Civ il Servants at the Regional
                                                         Level”, Vo logda, March 20-21, 2006

                                                         Draft model legislative act “On harmonization of procedures and results for            World Ban k/DFID                             Interregion
                                                         different forms of evaluation and assessment in the civ il service at the              Trust Fund                                   al_NPA_ru
                                                         regional level”. Presentation by V. Yu zhakov at the seminar “Results of                                                            s.ppt
                                                         Pilot Imp lementation of New Approaches to Performance Evaluation of
                                                         Civil Servants at the Regional Level”, Vologda, March 20-21, 2006




Prepa red by the WB/DFID Development Pa rtners Secreta ria t for Governance Reforms in Russia. You a re welcome to send informa tion on new resources to be i ncluded in this database to   49
Tumun Ts ydypov a t tts ydypov@worldbank.org / Подготовлено Секретариа том партнеров по ра звитию в обла сти реформы госуда рственного упра вления в России (Всемирный
Ба нк/Министерство Международного Ра звития Великобрита нии). Просим на правлять информацию о ма териа ла х для включения в ба зу да нных Тумуну Цыдыпову по а дресу
tts ydypov@worldbank.org
                                                                                                                                                                         Updated: August 2008


                                                         Develop ment and implementation of evaluation methods for civ il servants‟             World Ban k/DFID                               Interregion
                                                         performance in Irkutsk region. Presentation by L. Sokolova at the seminar              Trust Fund                                     al_Sokolov
                                                         “Results of Pilot Imp lementation of New Approaches to Performance                                                                    a_rus.ppt
                                                         Evaluation of Civ il Servants at the Regional Level”, Vo logda, March 20-21,
                                                         2006


                                                         Results of Pilot Imp lementation of Civ il Servants‟ Evaluation                        World Ban k/DFID                               Interregion
                                                         Methodologies at the Directorate for Education of Irkutsk Region.                      Trust Fund                                     al_Shamsut
                                                         Presentation by T. Shamsutdinova at the seminar “Results of Pilot                                                                     dinova_rus.
                                                         Implementation of New Approaches to Performance Evaluation of Civ il                                                                  ppt
                                                         Servants at the Regional Level”, Vologda, March 20-21, 2006


                                                         Results of Implementation of Performance Evaluation Methodology in the                 World Ban k/DFID                               Interregion
                                                         Pilot Executive Authority: Saratov Regional Min istry of Cu lture.                     Trust Fund                                     al_Maslenn
                                                         Presentation by E. Maslennikova, at the seminar “Results of Pilot                                                                     ikova_rus.p
                                                         Implementation of New Approaches to Performance Evaluation of Civ il                                                                  pt
                                                         Servants at the Regional Level”, Vologda, March 20-21, 2006

                                                         Individual performance indicators in the civil service. Presentation by N.             HSE                                            Individual
                                                         Klisch at the annual HSE conference, 2006.                                                                                            performanc
                                                                                                                                                                                               e
                                                                                                                                                                                               indicators_
                                                                                                                                                                                               Klisch_rus.
                                                                                                                                                                                               doc
                                                         Co mmercial Forms of Hu man Resource Management and Development.                       DFID PAR project             Pat‟s master      Pat‟s
                                                         Presentation by Pat Bairsto, October 2006                                                                           class             master
                                                                                                                                                                             presentation_e    class
                                                                                                                                                                             ng.ppt            presentatio
                                                                                                                                                                                               n_rus.ppt
                                                         Presentations from the seminar “New techniques of competit ive selection,              The Donor Secretariat                          Assessment
                                                         recruit ment, and assessment of civ il servants: Russian regional experience”.                                                        _Pyatigors
                                                         Pyatigorsk, November 2006                                                                                                             k_rus.zip




Prepa red by the WB/DFID Development Pa rtners Secreta ria t for Governance Reforms in Russia. You a re welcome to send informa tion on new resources to be i ncluded in this database to     50
Tumun Ts ydypov a t tts ydypov@worldbank.org / Подготовлено Секретариа том партнеров по ра звитию в обла сти реформы госуда рственного упра вления в России (Всемирный
Ба нк/Министерство Международного Ра звития Великобрита нии). Просим на правлять информацию о ма териа ла х для включения в ба зу да нных Тумуну Цыдыпову по а дресу
tts ydypov@worldbank.org
                                                                                                                                                                         Updated: August 2008


                        3.3 Э тика                       Obolonsky A., Ethical Aspects of Civil Service – one of the major                      CIDA, Public                                    CIDA_Eth i
                        государственной службы           components of civil service reform and ad min istrative reform as a whole ,            Admin istration Reform                          cal aspects
                        / Ethics in civil service        March 2004                                                                             in Russia                                       of the
                                                                                                                                                                                                reform_rus.
                                                                                                                                                                                                doc




                                                         Prof. A. Obolonsky, April 6, 2004, Eth ics Co mmissions: Reco mmendations              CIDA, Public                 Obolonsky_Et
                                                         on Organization and Structure.                                                         Admin istration Reform       hics
                                                                                                                                                in Russia                    Co mmissions_
                                                                                                                                                                             Reco m_eng.d
                                                                                                                                                                             oc




                                                         Conflict of Interests Review of Legislation                                            EC Policy Advice             Conflict of
                                                                                                                                                project, 2003                interest review
                                                                                                                                                                             of legislat ion
                                                         Enforcement and disciplinary issues, conflict of interest, Mike Stevens                World Ban k                  http://www1.
                                                                                                                                                                             worldbank.org
                                                                                                                                                                             /publicsector/c
                                                                                                                                                                             ivilservice/enf
                                                                                                                                                                             orcement.ht m
                                                         OECD Gu idelines on Managing Conflict of Interest, Countries: Stability                OECD, Stability Pact         Ссылка
                                                         Pact Anti - Corruption Initiat ive                                                     Anti - Corruption
                                                                                                                                                Initiat ive


                                                         Civil Service Reform: co mparative approaches to the conflict of interest: the         World Ban k                  Conflict of
                                                         United States, Canada, and the United Kingdom, K. Lalazarian, 2001                                                  interest_eng.zi
                                                                                                                                                                             p




Prepa red by the WB/DFID Development Pa rtners Secreta ria t for Governance Reforms in Russia. You a re welcome to send informa tion on new resources to be i ncluded in this database to      51
Tumun Ts ydypov a t tts ydypov@worldbank.org / Подготовлено Секретариа том партнеров по ра звитию в обла сти реформы госуда рственного упра вления в России (Всемирный
Ба нк/Министерство Международного Ра звития Великобрита нии). Просим на правлять информацию о ма териа ла х для включения в ба зу да нных Тумуну Цыдыпову по а дресу
tts ydypov@worldbank.org
                                                                                                                                                                         Updated: August 2008


                                                         “Managing Conflict o f Interest in Public Service: Selected Tools and                  OECD, Stability Pact        http://www.ant
                                                         Strategies”, Presentation by Mr. Howard Whitton, OECD                                  Anti - Corruption           icorruptionnet.
                                                                                                                                                Initiat ive                 org/acncgi/use
                                                                                                                                                                            r_side/projects
                                                                                                                                                                            .cgi?lang=en&
                                                                                                                                                                            site_type=grap
                                                                                                                                                                            hics&come_fr
                                                                                                                                                                            om=projects&
                                                                                                                                                                            search=1&cou
                                                                                                                                                                            ntry_id=110#
                                                         “Good Governance Project: Bridging the Gap”, Presentation by Mr. Janos                 OECD, Stability Pact        http://www.ant
                                                         Bertok, OECD                                                                           Anti - Corruption           icorruptionnet.
                                                                                                                                                Initiat ive                 org/acncgi/use
                                                                                                                                                                            r_side/projects
                                                                                                                                                                            .cgi?lang=en&
                                                                                                                                                                            site_type=grap
                                                                                                                                                                            hics&come_fr
                                                                                                                                                                            om=projects&
                                                                                                                                                                            search=1&cou
                                                                                                                                                                            ntry_id=110#




Prepa red by the WB/DFID Development Pa rtners Secreta ria t for Governance Reforms in Russia. You a re welcome to send informa tion on new resources to be i ncluded in this database to     52
Tumun Ts ydypov a t tts ydypov@worldbank.org / Подготовлено Секретариа том партнеров по ра звитию в обла сти реформы госуда рственного упра вления в России (Всемирный
Ба нк/Министерство Международного Ра звития Великобрита нии). Просим на правлять информацию о ма териа ла х для включения в ба зу да нных Тумуну Цыдыпову по а дресу
tts ydypov@worldbank.org
                                                                                                                                                                         Updated: August 2008


                                                         Backg round on Employ ment Structure – Background informat ion for Study               DFID Public                 Backg round       Backg roun
                                                         Tour in the Netherlands (May 9-12, 2004)                                               Admin istration Project     info_On           d info_On
                                                                                                                                                                            Emp loy ment      Emp loy me
                                                                                                                                                                            Structure_eng.    nt
                                                                                                                                                                            doc               Structure_r
                                                                                                                                                                                              us.doc
                                                         Fro m the Ground Up: Assessing the Record of Anticorruption Assistance in              Center for Po licy          WP-
                                                         Southeastern Europe. Center for Policy Studies, Central European                       Studies, Central            Anticorruption
                                                         University and Soros Foundation Network publication                                    European University         .report
                                                                                                                                                and Soros Foundation        SEE_engpdf.p
                                                                                                                                                                            df


                                                         Legal Framewo rks, Institutions and Management Systems Necessary to                    SIGMA                       http://www.sig
                                                         Pro mote Public Service Eth ics, Roger Errera, Conseil d‟Etat, France. Multi-                                      maweb.org/PD
                                                         country Seminar on Normative and Institutional Structures Supporting                                               F/SIGMA_ CS
                                                         Public Serv ice Ethics, Paris, 5 November 1997                                                                     _LEGA LFRA
                                                                                                                                                                            MEWORKS_ 0
                                                                                                                                                                            51197.pdf
                                                         Anticorruption Toolkit, UN Office on Drugs and Crime, Global                           UN Office on Drugs                            UNToolkit
                                                         Anticorruption Programme, edition 1, June 2001                                         and Crime                                     _2001_rus.
                                                                                                                                                                                              doc
                                                         Co mbating Corruption: A Co mparative Rev iew o f Selected Legal Aspects of            World Ban k                 Anti-
                                                         State Practice and Major International Init iatives, Ofosu-Amaah, W. Paat ii,                                      corruption_W
                                                         Soopramanien, Raj, Uprety, Kishor, 1999                                                                            B_eng.pdf
                                                         Mechanism to Increase Transparency of Administration: On-Line Open                     UN Depart ment of                             OPEN_rus.
                                                         System for Cit izens‟ Co mplains in Seoul Mayor House, UN Depart ment of               Economic and Social                           pdf
                                                         Economic and Social Affairs, Seoul Mayor House                                         Affairs, Seoul Mayor
                                                                                                                                                House
                                                         Anti-corruption in Transition: A Contribution to the Policy Debate, World              World Ban k                 Anti-
                                                         Bank, 2000                                                                                                         corruption_tra
                                                                                                                                                                            nsition_eng.pd
                                                                                                                                                                            f
                                                         Service Conduct and Conflict of Interests, presentation at the conference of           European Co mmission                          Conflict_of
                                                         EC Pro ject “Civil Serv ice Reform (A R II)”, March 2005                               Civil Service Reform                          _interest_r
                                                                                                                                                (AR II) Project                               us.ppt


Prepa red by the WB/DFID Development Pa rtners Secreta ria t for Governance Reforms in Russia. You a re welcome to send informa tion on new resources to be i ncluded in this database to    53
Tumun Ts ydypov a t tts ydypov@worldbank.org / Подготовлено Секретариа том партнеров по ра звитию в обла сти реформы госуда рственного упра вления в России (Всемирный
Ба нк/Министерство Международного Ра звития Великобрита нии). Просим на правлять информацию о ма териа ла х для включения в ба зу да нных Тумуну Цыдыпову по а дресу
tts ydypov@worldbank.org
                                                                                                                                                                               Updated: August 2008


                                                             Indicators in Ethics and Prevention of Corruption, EC Project                          European                      Indicators_corr    Indicators_
                                                             “Admin istrative Reform I”, 2004                                                       Co mmission, Public           uption_eng.do      corruption_
                                                                                                                                                    Admin istration               c                  rus.doc
                                                                                                                                                    Reform in Russia
                                                             Preventing conflict of interest in the civ il service: experience of Italy.            EC pro ject                                      Italian_sys
                                                             Appendix to the project report                                                         “Avoidance and                                   _conflict_o
                                                                                                                                                    Settlement of                                    f_interest_r
                                                                                                                                                    conflicts of Interest in                         us.doc
                                                                                                                                                    the Public Service:
                                                                                                                                                    Setting up a Non-
                                                                                                                                                    governmental
                                                                                                                                                    Monitoring System”
                                                             Public mon itoring of ad min istrative structures‟ activities: developing              EC pro ject                                      Public_ mo
                                                             openness, preventing corruption and conflict of interest. Appendix to the              “Avoidance and                                   nitoring_ru
                                                             project report.                                                                        Settlement of                                    s.doc
                                                                                                                                                    conflicts of Interest in
                                                                                                                                                    the Public Service:
                                                                                                                                                    Setting up a Non-
                                                                                                                                                    governmental
                                                                                                                                                    Monitoring System”
4. Подготовка,              4.1 Образовательные              Train ing Civil Servants for Internationalizat ion. Docu mentation Fro m a             SIGMA, OECD                   http://www.sig
переподготовка и            программы и модели               SIGMA Mu lti-Country Seminar Held In Budapest 22-23 May 1995, Sig ma                                                 maweb.org/pdf
повышение                   повышения                        Papers: No. 3                                                                                                        /SIGMA_SP03
квалификации /              квалификации /                                                                                                                                        _96E.pdf
Professional                Educational models and
education, in-service       programs of professional
training and                development
professional                                                 A. Campbell, Advanced Training for Civil Servants: Lessons fro m Canadian              CIDA Public                   Advanced
development of the                                           Experience – Discussion Paper, 2004                                                    Admin istration               Train ing_Cana
civil servants                                                                                                                                      Reform Project                da_eng.doc
                                                             Information on Interchange Scheme – UK Civil Service                                   DFID Public                   Interchange
                                                                                                                                                    Admin istration Project       scheme_eng.d
                                                                                                                                                                                  oc

                                                             Civil Service Training and the Context o f Public Ad ministration Reform: A            UNDP                          UNCivilServic
                                                             Co mparative Study of Selected Countries fro m Central and Eastern Europe,                                           eTrain ing_eng.
                                                             and the Former Soviet Union (1989 to 2003), June 2003                                                                pdf


    Prepa red by the WB/DFID Development Pa rtners Secreta ria t for Governance Reforms in Russia. You a re welcome to send informa tion on new resources to be i ncluded in this database to       54
    Tumun Ts ydypov a t tts ydypov@worldbank.org / Подготовлено Секретариа том партнеров по ра звитию в обла сти реформы госуда рственного упра вления в России (Всемирный
    Ба нк/Министерство Международного Ра звития Великобрита нии). Просим на правлять информацию о ма териа ла х для включения в ба зу да нных Тумуну Цыдыпову по а дресу
    tts ydypov@worldbank.org
                                                                                                                                                                         Updated: August 2008


                                                         Teaching Civil Servants to Respect, Value and Manage Diversity, United                 UN Depart ment of           ManagingDive
                                                         Nations, Depart ment of Economic and Social Affairs                                    Economic and Social         rsity_eng.pdf
                                                                                                                                                Affairs
                                                         International Experience on Civil Servants Training, presentation at the               European Co mmission                          Int_exp_tra
                                                         conference of EC Project “Civ il Service Reform (AR II)”, March 2005                   Civil Service Reform                          ining_rus.p
                                                                                                                                                (AR II) Project                               pt

                        4.2 Международные                The Governance Advisory and Exchange Program (GA EP) - a five-year                     CIDA                        http://www.ga     http://www
                        отношения в области              program funded by the Canadian International Develop ment Agency                                                   ep.ca/en/about    .gaep.ca/ru/
                        образования гражданских          (CIDA)                                                                                                             us.htm            ohac.htm
                        служащих / International
                        relations for professional
                        development of civ il
                        servants




Prepa red by the WB/DFID Development Pa rtners Secreta ria t for Governance Reforms in Russia. You a re welcome to send informa tion on new resources to be i ncluded in this database to    55
Tumun Ts ydypov a t tts ydypov@worldbank.org / Подготовлено Секретариа том партнеров по ра звитию в обла сти реформы госуда рственного упра вления в России (Всемирный
Ба нк/Министерство Международного Ра звития Великобрита нии). Просим на правлять информацию о ма териа ла х для включения в ба зу да нных Тумуну Цыдыпову по а дресу
tts ydypov@worldbank.org
                                                                                                                                                                               Updated: August 2008


5. Материально-             5.1 Mатериально-                 Material and Technical Support for Civil Servants, R. Piganiol, June 2005              European                      Material_eng.d    Material_ru
техническое и               техническое обеспечение                                                                                                 Co mmission, Public           oc                s.doc
информационное              деятельности / Financial                                                                                                Admin istration
обеспечение/                and technical resources                                                                                                 Reform in Russia
Financi al and              required for civ il service
technical resources         operations
                            5.2 Управление                   Principles of Ad ministrative Budget Expenditures of France, Informat ion              European Union
                            материально-                     Material, 2004.                                                                        Project “Siv il Serv ice
                            техническими ресурсами                                                                                                  Reform”
                            / Management of financial                                                                                               (Administrative
                            and technical resources                                                                                                 Reform)
                            5.3 Информационное               Improving ad min istrative processes using IT technologies. Presentation by            MoEDT                                           Tsereno
                            обеспечение деятельности         Mr. Tserenov at the conference «Implementation of the Concept on                                                                       v_repor
                            ОИВ / IT Technologies in                                                                                                                                                t_rus.do
                                                             Admin istrative Reform in RF within the Framework of Institutional and
                            Executive Authorities            Regional Programmes: Imp lementation Mechanisms and Support», February                                                                 c
                                                             17-18, 2006


                                                             The concept of legal and regulatory framework, methodological basis,                   Higher School of                                2_abdra
                                                             and IT support of executive authorities. Presentation by G.                            Economics                                       kh mano
                                                             Abdrakhmanova at the conference «Imp lementation of the Concept on                                                                     va_rus.
                                                             Admin istrative Reform in RF within the Framework of Institutional and                                                                 ppt
                                                             Regional Programmes: Imp lementation Mechanisms and Support»,
                                                             February 17-18, 2006
                                                             Economist Intelligence Un it e-readiness index 2005. Press-release, April 20,          The Econo mist                Economist
                                                             2005                                                                                                                 Intelligence
                                                                                                                                                                                  Unit e-
                                                                                                                                                                                  readiness
                                                                                                                                                                                  index
                                                                                                                                                                                  2005_eng.doc
                                                             Improving ad min istrative processes and introducing e-government,                                                                     Armen ia_e
                                                             experience of Armenia. Presentation by A.Mkrtchyan at the training                                                                     -
                                                             “Admin istrative Reform in Russia: train ing course”, Pyatigorsk, September                                                            govt_rus.pp
                                                             2006                                                                                                                                   t




    Prepa red by the WB/DFID Development Pa rtners Secreta ria t for Governance Reforms in Russia. You a re welcome to send informa tion on new resources to be i ncluded in this database to      56
    Tumun Ts ydypov a t tts ydypov@worldbank.org / Подготовлено Секретариа том партнеров по ра звитию в обла сти реформы госуда рственного упра вления в России (Всемирный
    Ба нк/Министерство Международного Ра звития Великобрита нии). Просим на правлять информацию о ма териа ла х для включения в ба зу да нных Тумуну Цыдыпову по а дресу
    tts ydypov@worldbank.org
                                                                                                                                                                            Updated: August 2008


                           5.4. Повышение                   Develop ment of State Procurement Systems. World Practice and Russia.                  World Ban k                 Goszakaz         Goszakaz
                           эффективности системы            Speech of Mr. Jesus Renzo li, Procurement Specialist at the World Bank                                             2006, speech,    2006,
                           закупок для                      Moscow Office, at the plenary of the fo ru m-exposition “Goszakaz-2006”,                                           English,         speech,
                           государственных нужд             Moscow, March 14-16, 2006                                                                                          March 14,        Russian,
                           \Increasing Effectiveness                                                                                                                           2006.doc         March 14,
                           of Govern ment                                                                                                                                                       2006.doc
                           Procurement
                                                            Public p rocurement at the regional and municipal levels: innovations and              Institute of Public                          Regional_
                                                            prospects. V.Klimanov and A.Altynysev. in Finances and Budget. No. 3,                  Finance reforms                              municipal_
                                                            2008                                                                                                                                procureme
                                                                                                                                                                                                nt_rus.pdf
6. Госуд арственные        6.1. Стандарты                   The Governance of Service Delivery: Strengthening ECAs Operational                     World Ban k                 WB_Service
услуги/ Public             государственных услуг./          Approach - Regional Study, ECA VP, World Bank, June 2004                                                           Delivery_eng.
Services                   Standards of Public                                                                                                                                 doc
                           Services
                                                            Citizens, Politicians and Providers: the Latin A merican Experience with               World Ban k                 Services_LA_
                                                            Service Delivery Reform, Latin A merica and the Caribbean Region, World                                            eng.pdf
                                                            Bank, 2004
                                                            Quality Serv ice Charter Handbook. Malta.                                                                                           Quality_ser
                                                                                                                                                                                                vice_charte
                                                                                                                                                                                                r_handboo
                                                                                                                                                                                                k_Malta_ru
                                                                                                                                                                                                s.pdf
                                                            Report on National Charters of Public Services in European Countries.                                                               Public_Ser
                                                                                                                                                                                                vice_Chart
                                                                                                                                                                                                ers_rus.doc
                                                            Consolidated Appraisal Report. Draft Law o f the Russian Federation On                                             Service_Stand    Service_St
                                                            Standards of Public services and Public Service Delivery. Prepared on the                                          ards_CoE_Co      andards_C
                                                            basis of comments by Jacek Czaputowicz, Deputy Head of the Civ il service,                                         mmenets_eng.     oE_Co mm
                                                            Poland and Eduard Liebermann, Honorary President of the Administrative                                             doc              enets_rus.d
                                                            Court of Karlsruhe, Germany. December 2004.                                                                                         oc
                                                            Project of Federal Law “On Standardization of Public Serv ices”, prepared by           МЕDT-World Bank                              Public_serv
                                                            V.N.Yu zhakov. Seminar " Realization of the Concept of administrative                                                               ices_stand
                                                            reform in the Russian Federation in 2006-2008: coord ination of actions at                                                          Dec2005_r
                                                            federal and reg ional levels ", December 15-16 2005, Moscow.                                                                        us.ppt



   Prepa red by the WB/DFID Development Pa rtners Secreta ria t for Governance Reforms in Russia. You a re welcome to send informa tion on new resources to be i ncluded in this database to   57
   Tumun Ts ydypov a t tts ydypov@worldbank.org / Подготовлено Секретариа том партнеров по ра звитию в обла сти реформы госуда рственного упра вления в России (Всемирный
   Ба нк/Министерство Международного Ра звития Великобрита нии). Просим на правлять информацию о ма териа ла х для включения в ба зу да нных Тумуну Цыдыпову по а дресу
   tts ydypov@worldbank.org
                                                                                                                                                                         Updated: August 2008


                                                         Standardization of Public Services in the Context of Ad min istrative                  МЕDT-World Bank                              Public_serv
                                                         Reform”, prepared by K. Golov zhinsky. Seminar " Realizat ion of the                                                                ices_standa
                                                         Concept of administrative reform in the Russian Federation in 2006-2008:                                                            rdsDec200
                                                         coordination of actions at federal and regional levels ", December 15-16                                                            5_rus.ppt
                                                         2005, Moscow.

                                                         Organization of Delivery o f Public Services , p repared by R.L. Safonov.              МЕDT-World Bank                              Budget_ser
                                                         Seminar " Realization of the Concept of administrative refo rm in the                                                               vicesDec20
                                                         Russian Federation in 2006-2008: coordination of actions at federal and                                                             05_rus.ppt
                                                         regional levels ", December 15-16 2005, Moscow.

                                                         Develop ment and Piloting of Public Service Standards in Federal Executive             МЕDT-World Bank                              Develop me
                                                         Bodies, prepared by Parshin M.V. Seminar " Realization of the Concept of                                                            nt_piloting
                                                         administrative refo rm in the Russian Federation in 2006-2008: coordination                                                         _ParshinDe
                                                         of actions at federal and regional levels ", December 15-16 2005, Moscow.                                                           c2005.rus.p
                                                                                                                                                                                             pt
                                                         Methodology for Develop ment and Implementation of Public Serv ices                    World Ban k/DFID                             Методика_
                                                         Standards. Presentation by S. Makovetskaya, seminar “Introducing Elements              Trust Fund                                   стандарты
                                                                                                                                                                                             _Маковецк
                                                         of Performance Management at the Reg ional Level”, Saratov, Feb. 28 –
                                                         March 1, 2006                                                                                                                       ая_v6_rus.
                                                                                                                                                                                             ppt
                                                         Overview of Practices of Developing Public Services Standards. Report by               World Ban k/DFID                             Report_Ma
                                                         S. Makovetskaya, seminar “Introducing Elements of Performance                          Trust Fund                                   kovetskaya
                                                         Management at the Regional Level”, Saratov, Feb. 28 – March 1, 2006                                                                 _v2_05020
                                                                                                                                                                                             6_rus.rar

                                                         Research of real estate and land transactions in the Russian Federation.               FIAS/ EC                                     Land_reale
                                                         November 2005. Public services were monitored with in this area.                                                                    state_surve
                                                                                                                                                                                             ry_FIAS_N
                                                                                                                                                                                             ov2005_rus
                                                                                                                                                                                             .pd
                                                         China. Deepening Public Service Unit Reform to Improve Service Delivery                World Ban k                 China PSU        China PSU
                                                                                                                                                                            reform_eng.pd    reform_rus.
                                                                                                                                                                            f                doc




Prepa red by the WB/DFID Development Pa rtners Secreta ria t for Governance Reforms in Russia. You a re welcome to send informa tion on new resources to be i ncluded in this database to   58
Tumun Ts ydypov a t tts ydypov@worldbank.org / Подготовлено Секретариа том партнеров по ра звитию в обла сти реформы госуда рственного упра вления в России (Всемирный
Ба нк/Министерство Международного Ра звития Великобрита нии). Просим на правлять информацию о ма териа ла х для включения в ба зу да нных Тумуну Цыдыпову по а дресу
tts ydypov@worldbank.org
                                                                                                                                                                         Updated: August 2008


                                                         Service Standards. Presentation by G. Hollis at the DFID PA R pro ject                 DFID PAR project            Service            Service
                                                         masterclass, Feb.2007                                                                                              Standards_GH       Standards_
                                                                                                                                                                            _eng.ppt           GH_rus.ppt
                                                         Regional register of public services. V.Klimanov, in Finances and Budget               Institute of Public                            Regional_p
                                                         No. 6, 2008                                                                            Finance reforms                                ublic_servi
                                                                                                                                                                                               ces_registe
                                                                                                                                                                                               rs_rus.pdf
                        6.2 Мониторинг и оценка
                        качества
                        государственных услуг /
                        Monitoring and Evaluation
                        of Public Services Quality
                                                         Citizen Sat isfaction Survey. Overv iew Report. Presentation to Parliamentary          OECD                        Trust_and_sati
                                                         Portfolio Co mmittee on Public Serv ice and Administration. 09 April 2003.                                         sfaction_indica
                                                                                                                                                                            tors_eng.pdf

                                                         Defining Quality in Public Ad ministration by Elke Loffler. Paper fo r the             OECD                        Unpan_quality
                                                         session on Quality in Public Ad min istration: Basic Concepts and                                                  _management_
                                                         Co mparative Perspective. May 10-13, Riga, Latvia.                                                                 eng.pdf

                                                         Co mparing Measures of Citizen Trust and User Satisfaction as Indicators of            OECD                        South_Africa_
                                                         “Good Governance”: Difficu lties in Linking Trust and Satisfaction                                                 presentation_o
                                                         Indicators, by Geert Bouckaert and Steven Van de Walle.                                                            f_survey_resul
                                                                                                                                                                            ts_eng.ppt
                                                         Enhancing Quality of Public Serv ices: International Approaches and Russian            World Ban k/Finnish                            Presentatio
                                                         Practices. Presentation by M. Gusarova, inception seminar within the                   Trust Fund                                     n_Gusarov
                                                         framework of the project on enhancing quality of public services, Pskov,                                                              a_rus.ppt
                                                         March 2006

                                                         International Rev iew of Ad min istrative Sciences. Using government                                               Govern ment_
                                                         performance management data to identify new business opportunities:                                                Business_USA
                                                         examples fro m government services outsourcing in the United States by                                             _eng.pdf
                                                         Lawrence L. Martin and Karun K. Singh, 2004.
                                                         Public Serv ices: Costs for Cit izens and Business. Presentation, October 2006         Institute for Urban         Presentation_      Presentatio
                                                                                                                                                Economics                   UrbanEcon_en       n_UrbanEc
                                                                                                                                                                            g.ppt              on_rus.ppt



Prepa red by the WB/DFID Development Pa rtners Secreta ria t for Governance Reforms in Russia. You a re welcome to send informa tion on new resources to be i ncluded in this database to     59
Tumun Ts ydypov a t tts ydypov@worldbank.org / Подготовлено Секретариа том партнеров по ра звитию в обла сти реформы госуда рственного упра вления в России (Всемирный
Ба нк/Министерство Международного Ра звития Великобрита нии). Просим на правлять информацию о ма териа ла х для включения в ба зу да нных Тумуну Цыдыпову по а дресу
tts ydypov@worldbank.org
                                                                                                                                                                         Updated: August 2008


                                                         Study of Public Serv ices Clients: Social Costs                                        Institute for               Public            Public
                                                                                                                                                Co mparative Labor          Services_eng.p    Services_ru
                                                                                                                                                Studies                     pt                s.ppt

                        6.3 Аутсорсинг
                        государственных услуг /
                        Outsourcing of Public
                        Services
                                                         Международный обзор административных наук. Испо льзование                                                          Govern ment_
                                                         данных управления по результатам для выявления новых                                                               Business_USA
                                                         коммерческих возможностей: примеры использования аутсорсинга                                                       _eng.pdf
                                                         государственных услуг в Соединенных Штатах. Лоренс Мартин и
                                                         Карун Синг, 2004.
                        6.4.
                        Многофункциональные
                        центры госу дарственных
                        и муниципальных услуг /
                        Multifunctional centers of
                        public and municipal
                        services
                                                         Presentations from the seminar “Imp lementation of ad ministrative reform at           Donors Secretariat /                          MFC_Ady
                                                         the regional level: MfSC”, Maykop 2007                                                 WB                                            gheya_200
                                                                                                                                                                                              7_rus

                                                         The Greek citizen‟s service centers: the way fo rward. Presentation of Efi             Hellenic Ministry of        Greek_KEPs_
                                                         Stefopoulou for the learning visit o f the Russian delegation on KEPs, July            the Interior                way_forward_
                                                         2008                                                                                                               eng.ppt


                                                         Public and municipal services in Brazil. Poupatempo program. Report of                 MoEDT                                         MoEDT_ re
                                                         MoEDT on results of the learning visit to Brazil. 2007                                                                               port_Public
                                                                                                                                                                                              _services_
                                                                                                                                                                                              Brazil_200
                                                                                                                                                                                              7_rus.pdf




Prepa red by the WB/DFID Development Pa rtners Secreta ria t for Governance Reforms in Russia. You a re welcome to send informa tion on new resources to be i ncluded in this database to    60
Tumun Ts ydypov a t tts ydypov@worldbank.org / Подготовлено Секретариа том партнеров по ра звитию в обла сти реформы госуда рственного упра вления в России (Всемирный
Ба нк/Министерство Международного Ра звития Великобрита нии). Просим на правлять информацию о ма териа ла х для включения в ба зу да нных Тумуну Цыдыпову по а дресу
tts ydypov@worldbank.org
                                                                                                                                                                         Updated: August 2008


                                                         Develop ment of Multifunctional Serv ice Centers (MfSC) in 2008. A.Sharov.             MoEDT                                           MoEDT_ S
                                                         Presentation at the annual “Administrative reform 2008” conference, March                                                              harov_MfS
                                                         2008                                                                                                                                   C_2008_ru
                                                                                                                                                                                                s.ppt
                                                         MfSC: upgrade of public and municipal services in Novosibirsk oblast.                  Admin istration of                              Novosibirs
                                                         V.Nikonov. Presentation at the annual “Admin istrative reform 2008”                    Novosibirsk oblast                              k_MfSC_2
                                                         conference, March 2008                                                                                                                 008_rus.ppt

                                                         MfSC: Administrative reform in Shakhty. S.Ponamarenko. Presentation at                 Admin istration of                              Shakhty_M
                                                         the annual “Administrative reform 2008” conference, March 2008                         Shakhty municipality                            fSC_2008_
                                                                                                                                                                                                rus.ppt

                                                         Citizen service centers (KEP): Greek approach to institutional service                 Develop ment Partners       WB_ Greek_K         WB_ Greek
                                                         delivery reforms and e-governance. Background note, July 2008                          Secretariat for             ep-                 _Kep-
                                                                                                                                                Governance Reforms          Final_eng.doc       Final_ rus.d
                                                                                                                                                in Russia                                       oc
                                                                                                                                                The World Ban k
                        6.5. Использование
                        информационно-
                        коммуникационных
                        технологий и системы
                        электронного
                        правительства в
                        предоставлении
                        государственных услуг /
                        Use of information &
                        communicat ion
                        technologies and e-
                        government in delivery of
                        public services
                                                         Process re-engineering at e-governance centers (centers of registration &              WB                          Rajneesh_E          Rajneesh_
                                                         licensing authority) of district Hamirpur through ISO 9001:2000                                                    govt for G2C        E govt for
                                                         certification “Making Public Systems Efficient” Rajneesh Ku mar, Hamirpur                                          (govt to            G2C (govt
                                                         (India)                                                                                                            citizen)            to citizen)
                                                                                                                                                                            Interface_ISO       Interface_I
                                                                                                                                                                            Cert ification_e    SO
                                                                                                                                                                            ng.doc              Cert ificatio
                                                                                                                                                                                                n_rus.doc


Prepa red by the WB/DFID Development Pa rtners Secreta ria t for Governance Reforms in Russia. You a re welcome to send informa tion on new resources to be i ncluded in this database to      61
Tumun Ts ydypov a t tts ydypov@worldbank.org / Подготовлено Секретариа том партнеров по ра звитию в обла сти реформы госуда рственного упра вления в России (Всемирный
Ба нк/Министерство Международного Ра звития Великобрита нии). Просим на правлять информацию о ма териа ла х для включения в ба зу да нных Тумуну Цыдыпову по а дресу
tts ydypov@worldbank.org
                                                                                                                                                                            Updated: August 2008


7.    Взаимодействие       7.1. Информационная              Admin istrative Reform: Civil Society Interests. Presentation of V.N.                  OECD                                          Yu zhakov_
органов                    прозрачность органов             Yu zhakov in Ekaterinbourg , 11 November 2005.                                                                                       Ekaterinbo
исполнительной             исполнительной власти /                                                                                                                                               urg_Nov11
власти и общества /        Access to information and                                                                                                                                             _rus.doc
State    and Society       transparency of executive
Interaction                power

                                                            Role of Non-Profit Organizations in Realization of the Administrative                  МЕDT-World Bank                               Non_Profit
                                                            Reform, by Y.M. Katsnelson. Seminar " Realizat ion of the Concept of                                                                 _organizati
                                                            administrative refo rm in the Russian Federation in 2006-2008: coordination                                                          onsDec200
                                                            of actions at federal and regional levels ", December 15-16 2005, Moscow.                                                            5_rus.doc

                                                            Draft Law On Access to Information (d raft fro m 02.2003)                              EC Policy Advice             EC_Po licy
                                                                                                                                                   Project on                   Advice_Acces
                                                                                                                                                   Admin istrative Reform       s to info.doc
                                                                                                                                                   in Russia, 2002-2003




   Prepa red by the WB/DFID Development Pa rtners Secreta ria t for Governance Reforms in Russia. You a re welcome to send informa tion on new resources to be i ncluded in this database to    62
   Tumun Ts ydypov a t tts ydypov@worldbank.org / Подготовлено Секретариа том партнеров по ра звитию в обла сти реформы госуда рственного упра вления в России (Всемирный
   Ба нк/Министерство Международного Ра звития Великобрита нии). Просим на правлять информацию о ма териа ла х для включения в ба зу да нных Тумуну Цыдыпову по а дресу
   tts ydypov@worldbank.org
                                                                                                                                                                         Updated: August 2008


                                                         I.Bachilo, Analytical report “Normative and legal regulation of hu man rights          CIDA Public                  Bachilo_final_    Bachilo_fin
                                                         for informat ion and informational transparency of the government”, 2004               Admin istration Project      eng.doc           al_rus.doc




                                                         J. Bartram, Access to Information: the Canadian Approach and Experience -              CIDA Public                  Bartram_ATI_      Bartram_A
                                                         a Review of the Access To Information Task Fo rce Report, Studies and                  Admin istration Project      eng.doc           TI_rus.doc
                                                         Documentation, 2004



                                                         О. Afanasieva, On Legislative Regulat ion of Public Access to Informat ion in          CIDA Public                                    Afanasieva
                                                         Russia – analytical note, 2004                                                         Admin istration Project                        _rus.doc




                                                         D. Elder, Expert Analysis of Draft Legislation. Policy and Pract ice of the            CIDA Public                  Elder_eng.doc     Elder_rus.d
                                                         Govern ment of Canada, April 2004                                                      Admin istration Reform                         oc
                                                                                                                                                Project



                                                         Disclosure of Info rmation on Inco me and Property of Civil Servants: Cases            DFID / WB Donor                                Shiro kova_
                                                         of USA and Canada, Background Paper, J. Shiro kova, December 2004                      Secretariat for Civil                          info_disclo
                                                                                                                                                Service Reform in                              sure_rus.do
                                                                                                                                                Russia                                         c

                                                         Increasing Government Transparency and Accountability: International                   DFID / WB Donor              Transparency_     Transparen
                                                         Experience, Ye. Dobrolyubova, J. Sh irokova, DFID / WB Donor Secretariat               Secretariat for Civil        eng.doc           cy_rus.doc
                                                         for Civ il Service and Ad min istrative Refo rm in Russia                              Service Reform in
                                                         Moscow, December 2004                                                                  Russia


                                                         Increasing Effectiveness of Govern ment‟s Interaction with Society:                    World Ban k                                    Transparen
                                                         International Experience, J. Sh iro kova, presentation in Yekaterinburg, May                                                          cy_Shiroko
                                                         2005, World Bank                                                                                                                      va_rus.ppt




Prepa red by the WB/DFID Development Pa rtners Secreta ria t for Governance Reforms in Russia. You a re welcome to send informa tion on new resources to be i ncluded in this database to     63
Tumun Ts ydypov a t tts ydypov@worldbank.org / Подготовлено Секретариа том партнеров по ра звитию в обла сти реформы госуда рственного упра вления в России (Всемирный
Ба нк/Министерство Международного Ра звития Великобрита нии). Просим на правлять информацию о ма териа ла х для включения в ба зу да нных Тумуну Цыдыпову по а дресу
tts ydypov@worldbank.org
                                                                                                                                                                         Updated: August 2008



                                                         «Increasing Transparency of Executive Authorities‟ Activities as one of the            World Ban k / Finnish                        Transparen
                                                                                                                                                Trust Fund                                   cy_Batchae
                                                         Main Direct ions for Administrative Reform in Russia in 2006-2008”,
                                                         Presentation by A. Batchaev                                                                                                         v_rus.ppt



                                                         "Participation of businesses and civil society in imp lementation of                   Center for Strategic                         CSR_ Busin
                                                         administrative refo rm: experience, p roblems, prospects.” Seminar minutes,            Research                                     ess_civil_s
                                                         Moscow, 26 December 2007                                                                                                            ociety_adm
                                                                                                                                                                                             in_reform_
                                                                                                                                                                                             workshop_
                                                                                                                                                                                             Dec_2007_
                                                                                                                                                                                             minues_rus
                                                                                                                                                                                             .doc
                                                         On participation of civ il society in the administrative reform. V.Korochkin.          OPORA Rossii (SM E                           OPORA_S
                                                         Presentation at the annual “Administrative reform 2008” conference, March              association)                                 MEs_admi
                                                         2008                                                                                                                                n_reform_2
                                                                                                                                                                                             008_rus.ppt

                        7.2 Антикоррупционные            Admin istrative and Regulatory Reform in the Russian-Federation: Fighting              МЕDT-World Bank                             Anti_corrupti
                        механизмы /                      Sources of Potential Corruption, prepared by Y. Sh iro kova, World Bank.                                                           on_Dec2005.
                        Anticorruption                   Seminar " Realization of the Concept of administrative refo rm in the                                                              rus.ppt
                        Mechanisms                       Russian Federation in 2006-2008: coordination of actions at federal and
                                                         regional levels ", December 15-16 2005, Moscow.


                                                         Draft methodology for analysis of corruption-prone aspects of regulations              Center for Strategic                        Draft_ meth_c
                                                         issued by executive authorities                                                        Research                                    orruptiogenn
                                                                                                                                                                                            ost_feb06_ru
                                                                                                                                                                                            s.doc

                                                         Methodology for analysis of corruption-prone aspects of legislation.                   Center for Strategic
                                                         Presentation by E. Talapina at the conference «Implementation of the                   Research
                                                         Concept on Administrative Reform in RF within the Framework of
                                                         Institutional and Regional Programmes: Imp lementation Mechanisms and
                                                         Support», February 17-18, 2006




Prepa red by the WB/DFID Development Pa rtners Secreta ria t for Governance Reforms in Russia. You a re welcome to send informa tion on new resources to be i ncluded in this database to   64
Tumun Ts ydypov a t tts ydypov@worldbank.org / Подготовлено Секретариа том партнеров по ра звитию в обла сти реформы госуда рственного упра вления в России (Всемирный
Ба нк/Министерство Международного Ра звития Великобрита нии). Просим на правлять информацию о ма териа ла х для включения в ба зу да нных Тумуну Цыдыпову по а дресу
tts ydypov@worldbank.org
                                                                                                                                                                         Updated: August 2008


                                                                                                                                                Transparency                Download
                                                         Global Corruption Report 2006. Co rruption and Health.                                 International               document


                                                         Strengthening anti-corruption services in south-eastern Europe. Results of a           SIDA/PA CO Impact           Impact_anti-
                                                         regional meet ing held in Skopje (31 March – 1 April 2005)                                                         corruption_s
                                                                                                                                                                            ervices_SE_
                                                                                                                                                                            Europe_eng.
                                                                                                                                                                            pdf
                                                         Anti-corruption Documents and Instruments: International and National                  IREX                                        Demidov_rus
                                                         Experience                                                                                                                         .doc
                                                         on Fight Against Corruption. Co mp iled by Boris Demidov, 2004
                                                         Convention against Corruption. UNODC presentation, February 2006                       UNODC                       Anticor_con
                                                                                                                                                                            vention_UN
                                                                                                                                                                            ODC_rus.pp
                                                                                                                                                                            t
                                                         Checklist of Actions required by UN Convention against Corruption                      UN                          Checklist of
                                                                                                                                                                            actions_eng.
                                                                                                                                                                            doc

                                                         Co mbating Corruption. The Finnish Experience. 2005                                    Ministry for Foreign        Co mbatingC
                                                                                                                                                Affairs of Finland          orruption05_
                                                                                                                                                                            Fin land_eng.
                                                                                                                                                                            pdf
                                                                                                                                                Govern ment of              Prevention      Prevention of
                                                                                                                                                Singapore                   of              corruption
                                                         Corruption Prevention Act, Singapore
                                                                                                                                                                            corruption_s    act_singapore
                                                                                                                                                                            ingapore_rus    _eng.doc
                                                                                                                                                                            .doc
                                                         Corruption and Democracy. OCTOPUS Conference Conclusions, November                     Council of Europe           Conference_     Conference_c
                                                         2006                                                                                                               conclus_eng.    onclus_rus.d
                                                                                                                                                                            pdf             oc
                                                         Information about Corruption Prevention Bureau, Singapore                              Singapore                                   Singapore_an
                                                                                                                                                Govern ment                                 ticor_CPIB_r
                                                                                                                                                                                            us.doc




Prepa red by the WB/DFID Development Pa rtners Secreta ria t for Governance Reforms in Russia. You a re welcome to send informa tion on new resources to be i ncluded in this database to   65
Tumun Ts ydypov a t tts ydypov@worldbank.org / Подготовлено Секретариа том партнеров по ра звитию в обла сти реформы госуда рственного упра вления в России (Всемирный
Ба нк/Министерство Международного Ра звития Великобрита нии). Просим на правлять информацию о ма териа ла х для включения в ба зу да нных Тумуну Цыдыпову по а дресу
tts ydypov@worldbank.org
                                                                                                                                                                             Updated: August 2008


                                                             Roundtable materials “Legislat ion on Anticorruption Assessment of Legal               Center for Strategic                        CSR_anticorr
                                                             Acts in Russia, Eastern Europe and Asia: Implementation and Develop ment               Research                                    uption_works
                                                             Prospects ” (Moscow, 24-25 June 2008)                                                                                              hop_June_20
                                                                                                                                                                                                08_rus.zip
                                                             Proposals to the National Anticorruption Plan. Presentation of V.Yu zhakov,            Center for Strategic                        CSR_ Nationa
                                                             16 June 2008                                                                           Research                                    l_anticorrupti
                                                                                                                                                                                                on_plan_prop
                                                                                                                                                                                                osals_2008_r
                                                                                                                                                                                                us.ppt
                            7.3 Механизмы                    Mechanisms of Pre-Court Appelation Related to Decisions of Goverment                   Center for Strategic                        1_uzhakov_r
                            досудебного                      Bodies andc Public Officials. Presentation by V. Yu zhakov at the conference           Research                                    us.ppt
                            обжалования /                    «Imp lementation of the Concept on Admin istrative Reform in RF within the
                            Mechanisms of Pre-Court          Framework of Institutional and Regional Programmes: Imp lementation
                            Appellations                     Mechanisms and Support», February 17-18, 2006

8. Управление               8.1 Нормативно-правовое          Implementation of the Law on the State Civil Service: Normat ive acts to be            European                    Norm_acts_      Norm_acts_r
реформой                    обеспечение реформы /            developed for this purpose, R. Piganio l, September 2004                               Co mmission, Public         eng.doc         us.doc
госуд арственной            Normative and regulatory                                                                                                Admin istration
службы и                    framework for reform                                                                                                    Reform in Russia
административной            implementation
реформой /
Management of the
Ci vil Service reform
and Administrati ve
reform

                                                             The Develop ment of Civ il Service Leg islation in the Russian Federation              World Ban k, Moscow         CSLeg islatio
                                                             V.A. Kozbanenko                                                                                                    n_eng.doc


                                                             Elvira Talapina, “ Co mparative analysis of legislation on Civ il Service in the       European                                    Co mparative
                                                             RF of 1995-2003 гг”                                                                    Co mmission, Public                         analysis_CS
                                                                                                                                                    Admin istration                             law.doc
                                                                                                                                                    Reform in Russia




    Prepa red by the WB/DFID Development Pa rtners Secreta ria t for Governance Reforms in Russia. You a re welcome to send informa tion on new resources to be i ncluded in this database to   66
    Tumun Ts ydypov a t tts ydypov@worldbank.org / Подготовлено Секретариа том партнеров по ра звитию в обла сти реформы госуда рственного упра вления в России (Всемирный
    Ба нк/Министерство Международного Ра звития Великобрита нии). Просим на правлять информацию о ма териа ла х для включения в ба зу да нных Тумуну Цыдыпову по а дресу
    tts ydypov@worldbank.org
                                                                                                                                                                         Updated: August 2008


                                                         Elvira Talapina, «Proposed amendments to the Draft Federal Law On                      European                                    Proposals_St
                                                         State Ci vil Service», Analytical note                                                 Co mmission, Public                         ate Civ il
                                                                                                                                                Admin istration                             Service
                                                                                                                                                Reform in Russia                            Law_rus.doc
                                                         Irina Kotelevskaya, «Su mmary on decisions of the Constitutional Court of              European                                    Constitutiona
                                                         the RF on issues of state and municipal service»                                       Co mmission, Public                         l Court
                                                                                                                                                Admin istration                             decisions_rus
                                                                                                                                                Reform in Russia



                                                         Expert Support in Improvement of Legislat ion on Public Service, HSE,                  HSE                                         Legislat ion_
                                                         presentation at the conference “Reformation of Civil Service in the RF.                                                            HSE_ 21Dec0
                                                         Results and Future Prospects”, 21 December 2004                                                                                    4_rus.ppt


                                                         Concept and Major Activities of Ad min istrative Reform Imp lementation in             Ministry of Economic        AR_concept      AR_concept_
                                                         Russia in 2005 – 2008, M. Parshin, presentation, June 2005                             Develop ment and            _MEDT_eng       MEDT_rus.p
                                                                                                                                                Trade of the RF             .ppt            pt
                                                         Reco mmendations for the application of the Article 50 on State Civ il Serv ice        European                    Article_50_e    Article_50_r
                                                         Law of the RF, EC Pro ject “Administrative Reform I”, March 2005                       Co mmission, Public         ng.doc          us.doc
                                                                                                                                                Admin istration
                                                                                                                                                Reform in Russia
                                                         Reco mmendations for the application of the Article 55 on State Civ il Serv ice        European                    Article_55_e    Article_55_r
                                                         Law of the RF, EC Pro ject “Administrative Reform I”, March 2005                       Co mmission, Public         ng.doc          us.doc
                                                                                                                                                Admin istration
                                                                                                                                                Reform in Russia
                                                         Article 66 of the Law on the State Civil Serv ice, recommendations about               European                    Article_66_e    Article_66_r
                                                         contents of normat ive documents that regulate the holding of experiments,             Co mmission, Public         ng.doc          us.doc
                                                         EC Pro ject “Administrative Reform I”, March 2005                                      Admin istration
                                                                                                                                                Reform in Russia
                                                         Implementation of the Law on the State Civil Service. Normative acts to be             European                    Implementat     Implementati
                                                         developed for this purpose, EC Project “Ad min istrative Reform I”, 2004               Co mmission, Public         ion_eng.doc     on_rus.doc
                                                                                                                                                Admin istration
                                                                                                                                                Reform in Russia




Prepa red by the WB/DFID Development Pa rtners Secreta ria t for Governance Reforms in Russia. You a re welcome to send informa tion on new resources to be i ncluded in this database to   67
Tumun Ts ydypov a t tts ydypov@worldbank.org / Подготовлено Секретариа том партнеров по ра звитию в обла сти реформы госуда рственного упра вления в России (Всемирный
Ба нк/Министерство Международного Ра звития Великобрита нии). Просим на правлять информацию о ма териа ла х для включения в ба зу да нных Тумуну Цыдыпову по а дресу
tts ydypov@worldbank.org
                                                                                                                                                                         Updated: August 2008


                                                         Civil Service Code of Great Britain (brief summary), S. Catchpole, 2005                European                    CS_ GB_ Cod     CS_ GB_ Cod
                                                                                                                                                Co mmission, Public         e_eng.doc       e_rus.doc
                                                                                                                                                Admin istration
                                                                                                                                                Reform in Russia
                                                         Legal, Regulatory, and Methodological Support of Administrative Reform in              MoEDT                                       SharonovThe
                                                         2006 – 2008. Presentation by A. Sharonov at the conference                                                                         sis_rus.doc
                                                         «Imp lementation of the Concept on Admin istrative Reform in RF within the
                                                         Framework of Institutional and Regional Programmes: Imp lementation
                                                         Mechanisms and Support», February 17-18, 2006

                                                         The concept of legal and regulatory framework, methodological basis,                   Higher School of                            2_abdrak
                                                         and IT support of executive authorities. Presentation by G.                            Economics                                   hmanova
                                                         Abdrakhmanova at the conference «Imp lementation of the Concept on                                                                 _rus.ppt
                                                         Admin istrative Reform in RF within the Framework of Institutional and
                                                         Regional Programmes: Imp lementation Mechanisms and Support»,
                                                         February 17-18, 2006
                                                         On co mpetition between admin is trative reform projects in 2008. M . Parshin.         Ministry of Economic                        MoEDT_ad m
                                                         Presentation at the annual “Administrative reform 2008” conference, March              Develop ment                                in_reform_co
                                                         2008                                                                                                                               mpetit ion_20
                                                                                                                                                                                            08_rus.ppt
                        8.2 Научно-методическое          Russian Civ il Serv ice Reform: History of Reform Attempts fro m 1992 to               WB / Moscow State           CSR in          CSR in
                        обеспечение реформы /            2000                                                                                   University                  Russia_1992     Russia_1992-
                        Scientific and                                                                                                                                      -2000           2000_rus
                        methodological support for                                                                                                                          edited_Eng.d
                        reform imp lementation                                                                                                                              oc
                                                         Civil Service Reform in Russia 1992 to 2003, Ed ited by Neil Parison                   WB / Moscow State           CSR_ in_Rus
                                                         (English version), World Bank CSR team, Moscow, October 2004                           University                  sia_1992-
                                                                                                                                                                            2003_eng.do
                                                                                                                                                                            c
                                                         Admin istrative and Civil Service Reform: Policy note prepared for Russian             World Ban k                 Policy          Policy
                                                         Federation Authorities, May 2004                                                                                   note_May        note_May
                                                                                                                                                                            2004_en.doc     2004_rus.doc




Prepa red by the WB/DFID Development Pa rtners Secreta ria t for Governance Reforms in Russia. You a re welcome to send informa tion on new resources to be i ncluded in this database to   68
Tumun Ts ydypov a t tts ydypov@worldbank.org / Подготовлено Секретариа том партнеров по ра звитию в обла сти реформы госуда рственного упра вления в России (Всемирный
Ба нк/Министерство Международного Ра звития Великобрита нии). Просим на правлять информацию о ма териа ла х для включения в ба зу да нных Тумуну Цыдыпову по а дресу
tts ydypov@worldbank.org
                                                                                                                                                                         Updated: August 2008


                                                         Main tendencies in modernizat ion of state governance                                  European                                    Rus_GUEST
                                                                                                                                                Co mmission, Public                         ION
                                                                                                                                                Admin istration                             PUBLIQUE.
                                                                                                                                                Reform in Russia                            ppt




Prepa red by the WB/DFID Development Pa rtners Secreta ria t for Governance Reforms in Russia. You a re welcome to send informa tion on new resources to be i ncluded in this database to   69
Tumun Ts ydypov a t tts ydypov@worldbank.org / Подготовлено Секретариа том партнеров по ра звитию в обла сти реформы госуда рственного упра вления в России (Всемирный
Ба нк/Министерство Международного Ра звития Великобрита нии). Просим на правлять информацию о ма териа ла х для включения в ба зу да нных Тумуну Цыдыпову по а дресу
tts ydypov@worldbank.org
                                                                                                                                                                         Updated: August 2008


                                                         Govern ment Restructuring and Public Ad min istration Reform.                          World Ban k                 Final June      Final June
                                                         Extract fro m World Ban k June 2004 Russian Economic Report                                                        2004            2004
                                                                                                                                                                            RER8_en.do      RER8_rus.do
                                                                                                                                                                            c               c
                                                         The concept of legal and regulatory framework, methodological basis,                   Higher School of                            2_abdrak
                                                         and IT support of executive authorities. Presentation by G.                            Economics                                   hmanova
                                                         Abdrakhmanova at the conference «Imp lementation of the Concept on                                                                 _rus.ppt
                                                         Admin istrative Reform in RF within the Framework of Institutional and
                                                         Regional Programmes: Imp lementation Mechanisms and Support»,
                                                         February 17-18, 2006
                                                         Why Civil Service Reforms Fail? Charles Polidano, Office of the Prime                  Institute for               http://idpm.
                                                         Mi nister, Malta, IDPM Public Policy and Management Working Paper                      Develop ment Policy         man.ac.u k/p
                                                         no. 16, March 2001                                                                     and Management              ublications/a
                                                                                                                                                                            rchive/ppm/
                                                                                                                                                                            ppm_wp16.s
                                                                                                                                                                            html
                                                                                                                                                Ministry of Public          Bulgaria_rep
                                                         Report on the State of the Public Admin istration in 2003, Republic o f                Admin istration in          ort2003_eng.
                                                         Bulgaria                                                                               Bulgaria                    zip



                                                         Priorit ies for Public Administration System Modernisation at the Levels of            World Ban k                                 Pirorit ies_NP
                                                         Subjects of the RF: International Perspective, N. Parison - сonference “State                                                      _Sep04_rus.p
                                                         Governance Reform and Its Implementation at the Regional Level”,                                                                   pt
                                                         September 2004, Moscow


                                                         State and Prospects for Develop ment of the Ukrainian Civil Service in 2005-           Head Civil Serv ice                         Ukraine_Sep
                                                         2010, V. Soro ko - Presentation at the conference “State Governance                    Directorate in the                          04_rus.ppt
                                                         Reform and Its Imp lementation at the Regional Level”, September 2004,                 Ukraine
                                                         Moscow
                                                         Report of the Chairman of the Agency of the Republic of Kazakhstan                     Agency of the               Kazakhstan_     Kazakhstan_
                                                         for Civ il Service Affairs for the Conference “Strategy of public                      Republic o f                Sep04_eng.d     Sep04_rus.do
                                                         administration reform in Russia and its imp lementation at the regional level”         Kazakhstan                  oc              c
                                                                                                                                                for Civ il Service
                                                                                                                                                Affairs


Prepa red by the WB/DFID Development Pa rtners Secreta ria t for Governance Reforms in Russia. You a re welcome to send informa tion on new resources to be i ncluded in this database to   70
Tumun Ts ydypov a t tts ydypov@worldbank.org / Подготовлено Секретариа том партнеров по ра звитию в обла сти реформы госуда рственного упра вления в России (Всемирный
Ба нк/Министерство Международного Ра звития Великобрита нии). Просим на правлять информацию о ма териа ла х для включения в ба зу да нных Тумуну Цыдыпову по а дресу
tts ydypov@worldbank.org
                                                                                                                                                                         Updated: August 2008


                                                         State Governance Reform in Russia: Looking fro m the Inside. Group of                  Higher School of                            Hard copy
                                                         authors (MoEDT), 2004. Institute of State and Municipal Governance, State              Economics
                                                         University – Higher School o f Economics
                                                         Modernizing Federal Administration, St rategy for Phase 2 of the                       Federal M inistry of        http://www.s
                                                         Govern ment Programme “Modern State – Modern Administration”, Federal                  Interior (Germany)          taat-
                                                         Ministry of Interior (Germany), June 2004                                                                          modern.de/A
                                                                                                                                                                            nlage/origina
                                                                                                                                                                            l_668763/M
                                                                                                                                                                            odernizing-
                                                                                                                                                                            the-Federal-
                                                                                                                                                                            Admin istrati
                                                                                                                                                                            on-Strategy-
                                                                                                                                                                            for-Phase-2-
                                                                                                                                                                            of-the-
                                                                                                                                                                            Govern ment
                                                                                                                                                                            -
                                                                                                                                                                            Programme.
                                                                                                                                                                            pdf
                                                         Delivery and Reform. Progress and Plans for the Future. Cabinet Office,                Cabinet Office, UK          http://www.c
                                                         UK, 2003                                                                                                           ivilservice.g
                                                                                                                                                                            ov.uk/impro
                                                                                                                                                                            ving_service
                                                                                                                                                                            s/delivery_a
                                                                                                                                                                            nd_reform/p
                                                                                                                                                                            ublications/p
                                                                                                                                                                            df/DRNarrat
                                                                                                                                                                            ive.pdf
                                                         Modernization of State Governance in Great Britain, V. Lobanov, State                  State Management                            Lobanov_UK
                                                         Management University, Moscow 2003                                                     University, Moscow                          _rus.doc
                                                         State Governance Reforms in Russia: Looking fro m the Inside (selected                 MoEDT - HSE                                 MoEDT_ HS
                                                         articles), Min istry of Economic Development and Trade of the RF – Higher                                                          E_SCRefo rm
                                                         School of Economics, 2004                                                                                                          ation_2004_r
                                                                                                                                                                                            us




Prepa red by the WB/DFID Development Pa rtners Secreta ria t for Governance Reforms in Russia. You a re welcome to send informa tion on new resources to be i ncluded in this database to   71
Tumun Ts ydypov a t tts ydypov@worldbank.org / Подготовлено Секретариа том партнеров по ра звитию в обла сти реформы госуда рственного упра вления в России (Всемирный
Ба нк/Министерство Международного Ра звития Великобрита нии). Просим на правлять информацию о ма териа ла х для включения в ба зу да нных Тумуну Цыдыпову по а дресу
tts ydypov@worldbank.org
                                                                                                                                                                         Updated: August 2008


                                                         Methodological and Legislative Support to Introduction of Contemporary                 PAKK Consulting and                         PAKK_ 21De
                                                         Methods of Planning, Financing, Appraisal and Motivation of Civil                      Audit                                       c04_rus.ppt
                                                         Servants, presentation, 21 December 2004, HSE


                                                         Governance: New Technologies – materials fro m international conference of             Moscow State                                MSU_rus.zip
                                                         25-28 May 2004, Moscow State University, Moscow, 2004                                  University,
                                                                                                                                                Depart ment of Public
                                                                                                                                                Admin istration
                                                         Lessons and Prospects of Admin istrative Refo rm in the Russian Federation,            State Management                            Lobanov_ad
                                                         V. Lobanov, Center for State Policy and Management Studies, State                      University, Moscow                          min_reform_
                                                         Management University, Moscow, 2004                                                                                                rus.doc

                                                         Civil Service Reform in Lat in A merica: Lessons from Experience, Gary J.              World Ban k                 SCR_ LatinA
                                                         Reid, Public Sector Management Division, the World Bank (materials fro m                                           merica_eng.
                                                         the Course Pack “Rightsizing Public Organizat ions”)                                                               doc

                                                         Admin istrative Reform and Russian Economics: Co mpatibility and                       National Institute of                       Adm_ref_nis
                                                         Develop ment Contradictions, analytical report, A. Shestoperov, National               Systemic                                    se_rus.doc
                                                         Institute of Systemic Entrepreneurship Studies, Moscow, 2005                           Entrepreneurship
                                                                                                                                                Studies
                                                         Increasing Govern ment Effectiveness: Approaches to Admin istrative                    World Ban k                 Increasing_     Increasing_G
                                                         Reform in the Russian Federation, Y. Dobrolyubova, N. Manning, N.                                                  Gov_ Effecti    ov_Effective
                                                         Parison, J. Shirokova, G. Evans, May 2005, World Bank                                                              veness_eng.     ness_rus.doc
                                                                                                                                                                            doc

                                                         State Governance Reform and Its Implementation at the Regional Level,                  DFID / WB Donor                             HSE_confere
                                                         Conference materials – 28-29 September and 21 December 2004                            Secretariat for Civil                       nce_rus.pdf
                                                                                                                                                Service Reform in
                                                                                                                                                Russia
                                                         How to speed up results of administrative refo rm. Presentation by N. Parison          Bannock Consulting                          1_parison_ru
                                                         at the conference «Implementation of the Concept on Administrative Reform                                                          s.ppt
                                                         in RF within the Framework of Institutional and Regional Programmes:
                                                         Implementation Mechanisms and Support», February 17-18, 2006




Prepa red by the WB/DFID Development Pa rtners Secreta ria t for Governance Reforms in Russia. You a re welcome to send informa tion on new resources to be i ncluded in this database to   72
Tumun Ts ydypov a t tts ydypov@worldbank.org / Подготовлено Секретариа том партнеров по ра звитию в обла сти реформы госуда рственного упра вления в России (Всемирный
Ба нк/Министерство Международного Ра звития Великобрита нии). Просим на правлять информацию о ма териа ла х для включения в ба зу да нных Тумуну Цыдыпову по а дресу
tts ydypov@worldbank.org
                                                                                                                                                                         Updated: August 2008


                                                         Public Civil Serv ice. Materials of a Seminar " Realizat ion of the Concept of         МЕDT-World Bank                             Concept_eve
                                                         administrative refo rm in the Russian Federation in 2006-2008: coordination                                                        nts_reform_r
                                                         of actions at federal and regional levels ", December 15-16 2005, Moscow.                                                          us.ppt

                                                         Admin istrative Reform within the Framework of Institutional Reforms in                Center for Strategic                        1_dmitriev_r
                                                         Russia. Presentation by M. Dmit riev, at the conference «Imp lementation of            Research                                    us.ppt
                                                         the Concept on Admin istrative Reform in RF within the Framework of
                                                         Institutional and Regional Programmes: Imp lementation Mechanisms and
                                                         Support», February 17-18, 2006




                                                         Legal, Regulatory, and Methodological Support of Administrative Reform in              MoEDT                                       SharonovThe
                                                         2006 – 2008. Presentation by A. Sharonov at the conference                                                                         sis_rus.doc
                                                         «Imp lementation of the Concept on Admin istrative Reform in RF within the
                                                         Framework of Institutional and Regional Programmes: Imp lementation
                                                         Mechanisms and Support», February 17-18, 2006

                                                         Assistance to Civil Service Reform in the Russian Federation                           EC “Ad ministrative                         707_ Reforma
                                                                                                                                                Reform 1” Project                           Gosslyzbi-
                                                                                                                                                                                            01_rus.pdf
                                                         Public Ad ministration Best Pract ices Dissemination Mechanisms.                       MoEDT                                       2_parshin_pr
                                                         Presentation by M. Parshin at the conference «Implementation of the                                                                aktika_rus.pp
                                                         Concept on Administrative Reform in RF within the Framework of                                                                     t
                                                         Institutional and Regional Programmes: Imp lementation Mechanisms and
                                                         Support», February 17-18, 2006

                                                         Mechanisms for Administrative Reform Implementation in RF in 2006 –                    MoEDT                                       1_sharov_rus
                                                         2008. Coordination and motivation of act ivities at the federal and regional                                                       .ppt
                                                         levels. Presentation by A. Sharov at the conference «Implementation of the
                                                         Concept on Administrative Reform in RF within the Framework of
                                                         Institutional and Regional Programmes: Imp lementation Mechanisms and
                                                         Support», February 17-18, 2006




Prepa red by the WB/DFID Development Pa rtners Secreta ria t for Governance Reforms in Russia. You a re welcome to send informa tion on new resources to be i ncluded in this database to   73
Tumun Ts ydypov a t tts ydypov@worldbank.org / Подготовлено Секретариа том партнеров по ра звитию в обла сти реформы госуда рственного упра вления в России (Всемирный
Ба нк/Министерство Международного Ра звития Великобрита нии). Просим на правлять информацию о ма териа ла х для включения в ба зу да нных Тумуну Цыдыпову по а дресу
tts ydypov@worldbank.org
                                                                                                                                                                         Updated: August 2008


                                                         Management of Civil Serv ice Reform in Central Europe. M iroslav Beblavy.              Open Society Institute      Civil Service   Civil
                                                         Chapter of the publication “MASTERING DECENTRALIZATION AND                                                         Reform_ OSI     Service_OSI
                                                         PUBLIC ADMINISTRATION REFORMS IN CENTRA L AND EASTERN                                                              _eng.pdf        _rus.doc
                                                         EUROPE”, OSI, 2003


                                                         Strategic planning, ad ministrative, and budget reforms at subnational level.          Leontieff Center                            Limonov_ind
                                                         Presentation by L. Limonov at an annual conference of the Higher School of                                                         icators_regio
                                                         Economics, 2006                                                                                                                    nal_rus.
                                                                                                                                                                                            doc
                                                         MASTERING DECENTRALIZATION AND PUBLIC                                                  Open Society Institute
                                                         ADMINISTRATION REFORMS IN CENTRAL AND EASTERN
                                                         EUROPE”, OSI, 2003

                                                         Improving governance quality and increasing Russia‟s competitiveness at                World Ban k                                 Quality of
                                                         the world market : results of international comparisons. Presentation by Y.                                                        Governance_
                                                         Dobrolybova at the conference “Admin istrative reform at the regional                                                              Dobrolyubov
                                                         level”, 2006                                                                                                                       a_rus.ppt

                                                         Increasing effectiveness of institutional reforms in Russia: domestic and              World Ban k                                 Institutional
                                                         international experience. Presentation by Y. Dobrolybova at the conference                                                         reform_ Dobr
                                                         “Admin istrative reform at the regional level”, 2006                                                                               olyubova_rus
                                                                                                                                                                                            .ppt

                                                         Uses and Abuses of Governance Indicators                                               OECD                        Governance
                                                                                                                                                                            indicators_e
                                                                                                                                                                            ng.pdf
                                                         Gu idelines for co mparative assessment of governance quality. Presentation            Center for Fiscal                           Governance_
                                                         by V. Dalin, October 2006                                                              Policy                                      CFP_rus.pps
                                                         Intergovernmental relations in Canada. Draft of analytical paper                        CIDA GA EP Project                         Intergovernm
                                                                                                                                                                                            ental
                                                                                                                                                                                            relations in
                                                                                                                                                                                            Canada_rus.d
                                                                                                                                                                                            oc
                                                         On Measuring Governance: Framing Issues for Debate                                     The World Ban k             On_measuri
                                                                                                                                                                            ng_governan
                                                                                                                                                                            ce_eng.pdf

Prepa red by the WB/DFID Development Pa rtners Secreta ria t for Governance Reforms in Russia. You a re welcome to send informa tion on new resources to be i ncluded in this database to   74
Tumun Ts ydypov a t tts ydypov@worldbank.org / Подготовлено Секретариа том партнеров по ра звитию в обла сти реформы госуда рственного упра вления в России (Всемирный
Ба нк/Министерство Международного Ра звития Великобрита нии). Просим на правлять информацию о ма териа ла х для включения в ба зу да нных Тумуну Цыдыпову по а дресу
tts ydypov@worldbank.org
                                                                                                                                                                         Updated: August 2008


                                                         On major directions of admin istrative reform in 2008-2010. A.Popova.                  Ministry of Economic                        MoEDT_ Pop
                                                         Presentation at the annual “Administrative reform 2008” conference, March              Develop ment                                ova_Admin_r
                                                         2008                                                                                                                               eform_2008_
                                                                                                                                                                                            rus.ppt
                        8.3 Информационное               Attitude to Public Officials and Admin istrative Refo rm, Public Opin ion              Public Opin ion                             FOM_21Dec
                        сопровождение реформы            Foundation, presentation at the conference “Reformation of Civ il Serv ice in          Foundation                                  04_rus.ppt
                        / Information support for        the RF. Results and Future Prospects”, 21 December 2004, HSE
                        the reform


                                                         Public Officials Surveys: International and Russian Experience, Y.                     World Ban k                                 Pskov_surve
                                                         Dobrolyubova, presentation at the seminar in Pskov, July 4, 2005                                                                   ys_Dobrolyu
                                                                                                                                                                                            bova.ppt
                                                         Federal Targeted Programs: Institutions based on IKT. Seminar "                        МЕDT-World Bank                             Federal_targe
                                                         Realization of the Concept of administrative reform in the Russian                                                                 ted_programs
                                                         Federation in 2006-2008: coordination of actions at federal and regional                                                           _institutions
                                                         levels ", December 15-16 2005, Moscow.                                                                                             Dec2005.rus.
                                                                                                                                                                                            ppt
                        8.4 Вклад                        Donor Matrix on Civ il Service Reform in Russia                                        WB/DFID Donor               Donor           Donor
                        международных                                                                                                           Secretariat for Civil       Matrix_eng.     Matrix_rus.d
                        проектов в реформу /                                                                                                    Service Reform in           doc             oc
                        Impact of international                                                                                                 Russia
                        projects                         Database of Analytical Resources on Civil Serv ice Reform                              WB/DFID Donor
                                                                                                                                                Secretariat for Civil
                                                                                                                                                Service Reform in
                                                                                                                                                Russia
                                                         Donor Matrix on Budget Reform in Russia (federal level)                                WB/DFID Donor               Budget
                                                                                                                                                Secretariat for Civil       reform
                                                                                                                                                Service Reform in           Matrix_eng.
                                                                                                                                                Russia                      doc
                                                         A. Lavrov, M inistry of Finance of the RF, «Pro ject contribution to reforming         European                                    http://www.n
                                                         budget process at the federal level», Project Kick-Off Meeting, Delegation             Co mmission, State                          ei.ru/rus/pdf/
                                                         of the European Co mmission in Russia, 19 March 2003                                   Budget Reform in                            A.Lavrov_Pr
                                                                                                                                                Russia, 2003-2004                           esentation-
                                                                                                                                                                                            Kick_off.zip




Prepa red by the WB/DFID Development Pa rtners Secreta ria t for Governance Reforms in Russia. You a re welcome to send informa tion on new resources to be i ncluded in this database to   75
Tumun Ts ydypov a t tts ydypov@worldbank.org / Подготовлено Секретариа том партнеров по ра звитию в обла сти реформы госуда рственного упра вления в России (Всемирный
Ба нк/Министерство Международного Ра звития Великобрита нии). Просим на правлять информацию о ма териа ла х для включения в ба зу да нных Тумуну Цыдыпову по а дресу
tts ydypov@worldbank.org
                                                                                                                                                                         Updated: August 2008


                                                         E. V. Belyanova «Project Impact on Russia's Reforms», Project Kick -Off                European                                    http://www.n
                                                         Meeting, Delegation of the European Co mmission in Russia, 19 March 2003               Co mmission, State                          ei.ru/rus/pdf/
                                                                                                                                                Budget Reform in                            Elena%20Bel
                                                                                                                                                Russia, 2003-2004                           yanova-kick-
                                                                                                                                                                                            off.pdf




                                                         A. Pirie «Pro ject approach and main expected results», Project Kick-Off               European                                    http://www.n
                                                         Meeting, Delegation of the European Co mmission in Russia, 19 March 2003               Co mmission, State                          ei.ru/rus/pdf/
                                                                                                                                                Budget Reform in                            Alistair%20Pi
                                                                                                                                                Russia, 2003-2004                           rie_ Rus.pdf

                                                         Matrix on Donor Projects in the Area of Public Administration Reform at                WB/DFID Donor               Matrix_PA R     Matrix_PA R_
                                                         the Regional Level in Russia                                                           Secretariat for Civil       _regions_en     regions_rus.x
                                                                                                                                                Service Reform in           g.xls           ls
                                                                                                                                                Russia




Prepa red by the WB/DFID Development Pa rtners Secreta ria t for Governance Reforms in Russia. You a re welcome to send informa tion on new resources to be i ncluded in this database to   76
Tumun Ts ydypov a t tts ydypov@worldbank.org / Подготовлено Секретариа том партнеров по ра звитию в обла сти реформы госуда рственного упра вления в России (Всемирный
Ба нк/Министерство Международного Ра звития Великобрита нии). Просим на правлять информацию о ма териа ла х для включения в ба зу да нных Тумуну Цыдыпову по а дресу
tts ydypov@worldbank.org
                                                                                                                                                                         Updated: August 2008


                                                         S. Zlobin «Outputs with respect of performance budgeting» Project Kick-                European                                    http://www.n
                                                         Off Meeting, Delegation of the European Co mmission in Russia, 19 March                Co mmission, State                          ei.ru/rus/pdf/
                                                         2003                                                                                   Budget Reform in                            Zlobin%20ki
                                                                                                                                                Russia, 2003-2004                           ckoff-Rus.pdf




                                                         Objectives, Approaches and Methods of the Project, K. Plo kker, Pro ject               European Co mmission                        ECPA R2_rus
                                                         Director, presentation at the conference of EC Project “Civil Service Reform           Civil Service Reform                        .ppt
                                                         (AR II)”, March 2005                                                                   (AR II) Project


                                                         Evaluating the Status and Developing Measures for Improvement of Hu man                World Ban k                 Project_Dob     Project_Dobr
                                                         Resources in Public Ad ministration and Municipal Service of Ko mi                                                 rolyubova_e     olyubova_rus
                                                         Republic: Goals and Object ives of the Project, Y. Dobrolyubova,                                                   ng.ppt          .ppt
                                                         presentation in Ko mi Republic, May 2005, World Ban k


                                                         Developing and introducing methods for competit ive selection of applicants            World Ban k                 Interregional   Interregional_
                                                         to fill vacant positions in the civil service and for evaluation of civ il                                         _YD_eng.pp      YD_rus.ppt
                                                         servants‟ performance: Interregional Project,Y. Dobrolyubova, presentation                                         t
                                                         in Irkutsk, June 2005, World Bank



                                                         Outline of AR II – PEM project and its key stakeholders, Y. Belyanova,                 European Co mmission        EC_budget2      EC_budget2_
                                                         presentation at kick-off seminar, Moscow, 6 September 2005                             Improvement of              _Belyanova      Belyanova_ru
                                                                                                                                                Public Expenditure          _rus_eng.ppt    s_eng.ppt
                                                                                                                                                Management Project
                                                         Improvement of Public Expenditure Management Pro ject -                                European Co mmission        EC_budget2      EC_budget2_
                                                         Plan of work until December 2006, A. Pirie, presentation at kick-off                   Improvement of              _Pirie_eng.p    Pirie_rus.ppt
                                                         seminar, Moscow, 6 September 2005                                                      Public Expenditure          pt
                                                                                                                                                Management Project




Prepa red by the WB/DFID Development Pa rtners Secreta ria t for Governance Reforms in Russia. You a re welcome to send informa tion on new resources to be i ncluded in this database to   77
Tumun Ts ydypov a t tts ydypov@worldbank.org / Подготовлено Секретариа том партнеров по ра звитию в обла сти реформы госуда рственного упра вления в России (Всемирный
Ба нк/Министерство Международного Ра звития Великобрита нии). Просим на правлять информацию о ма териа ла х для включения в ба зу да нных Тумуну Цыдыпову по а дресу
tts ydypov@worldbank.org
                                                                                                                                                                         Updated: August 2008


                                                         Bureaucracy and Authority in Contemporary Russia: attitude of population               Institute of                                Bureaucracy_
                                                         and expert appraisal. Analytical Report, prepared by the Institute of                  Sociology/Friedrich                         and_power_r
                                                         Sociology in collaboration with Fried rich Ebert Foundation in the Russian             Ebert Foundation                            us.present.do
                                                         Federation. Moscow, 2005.                                                                                                          c
                                                         Reform of Management Systems in the Cultural Sector: International                     ECORYS, Research                            October_semi
                                                         Experience and opportunities to apply it Russia. Ministry of Culture and               and Consulting                              nar_program
                                                         Mass Media of the Russian Federation.Moscow, October 2005.                                                                         me_ Rus25Oc
                                                                                                                                                                                            t.doc
                                                         Effectiveness of Donor Interactions in Implementation of Ad ministrative               МЕDT-World Bank                             Interfaces_do
                                                         Reform, by E.I. Dobrolyubova, World Bank. Seminar " Realizat ion of the                                                            nors_dec2005
                                                         Concept of administrative reform in the Russian Federation in 2006-2008:                                                           _rus.ppt
                                                         coordination of actions at federal and regional levels ", December 15-16
                                                         2005, Moscow.
                                                         Presentation of the ToR of the Pro ject “Provid ing Access and Enhancing               World Ban k/Finnish                         ToR_ Limono
                                                         quality of Public Services in Pskov Reg ion”                                           Trust Fund/Leontiev                         v_rus.ppt
                                                                                                                                                Center
                                                         “World Bank: Support to Public Ad ministration Reforms in Russia”.                     World Ban k                                 1_Dobrolyub
                                                         Presentation by Y. Dobrolyubova at the conference «Implementation of the                                                           ova_rus.ppt
                                                         Concept on Administrative Reform in RF within the Framework of
                                                         Institutional and Regional Programmes: Imp lementation Mechanisms an d
                                                         Support», February 17-18, 2006.

                                                         “Supporting Administrative Reform in RF within the Framework of the                    DFID PAR Project                            1_hollis_rus.
                                                         DFID PAR Project”. Presentation by G. Hollis at the conference                                                                     ppt
                                                         «Imp lementation of the Concept on Admin istrative Reform in RF within the
                                                         Framework of Institutional and Regional Programmes: Imp lementation
                                                         Mechanisms and Support», February 17-18, 2006.
                                                         The Donor Matrix on Performance-Based Budgeting at the Regional Level,                 World Ban k / DFID          Matrix_PBB      Matrix_PBB_
                                                         May 2006                                                                               Trust Fund                  _RFreg ions_    RFregions_M
                                                                                                                                                                            May06_eng.      ay06_rus.xls
                                                                                                                                                                            xls
                                                         Financial and economic analysis of projects: selected WB projects in Russia.           World Ban k                                 Project
                                                         Presentation by Y. Dobrolyubova at the training “Strategic planning,                                                               evaluation_D
                                                         program-based management, and policy impact assessment”, 2006                                                                      obrolyubova_
                                                                                                                                                                                            rus.ppt



Prepa red by the WB/DFID Development Pa rtners Secreta ria t for Governance Reforms in Russia. You a re welcome to send informa tion on new resources to be i ncluded in this database to   78
Tumun Ts ydypov a t tts ydypov@worldbank.org / Подготовлено Секретариа том партнеров по ра звитию в обла сти реформы госуда рственного упра вления в России (Всемирный
Ба нк/Министерство Международного Ра звития Великобрита нии). Просим на правлять информацию о ма териа ла х для включения в ба зу да нных Тумуну Цыдыпову по а дресу
tts ydypov@worldbank.org
                                                                                                                                                                         Updated: August 2008


                                                         Improving Governance Systems. UNDP Projects in the North Caucasus.                     UNDP                                        Projects_UN
                                                         Presentation, October 2006                                                                                                         DP_NCaucas
                                                                                                                                                                                            us_rus.ppt
                                                         FIAS efforts to reduce regulatory burdens on business and attract investment           FIAS                        FIAS_eng.p      FIAS_rus.ppt
                                                         to SFO regions. Presentation, 2007                                                                                 pt

                                                         The Operational Programme “Public Ad ministration Reform 2007 – 2013”.                 Hellenic Ministry of        Greek_Publi
                                                         Presentation of Yianna Papadaki for the learn ing visit of the Russian                 the Interior                c_Admnistra
                                                         delegation on KEPs, July 2008                                                                                      tion_Reform
                                                                                                                                                                            _2007-
                                                                                                                                                                            2013_eng.pp
                                                                                                                                                                            t
                        8.5 Мониторинг и оценка          Integral Governance Indicators. Reference material on international                    WB/DFID Donor               Indicators_     Indicators_G
                        хо да реформ / Monitoring        approaches. Prepared for the Govern ment of the Russian Federation, July               Secretariat for Civil       Gov             ov
                        and evaluation                   2004                                                                                   Service Reform in           reform_final    reform_final_
                                                                                                                                                Russia                      _eng.doc        rus.doc

                                                         Federal Civil Servant‟s Remuneration system in Russia: co mparative study              DFID, implemented           Civil           Civil Service
                                                         of pay rates and benefits in civil service and private sector, 2003                    by the HSE                  Service         Pay_rus
                                                                                                                                                                            pay_eng
                                                         Public Officials Survey, 2003                                                          DFID, implemented                           Public
                                                                                                                                                by the HSE                                  Officials
                                                                                                                                                                                            Survey_rus
                                                         Sociological study of state and municipal civ il servants in 6 regions of the           “Leontief Center”                          Russian:
                                                         RF to analyze approaches in management of state and municipal finance for                                                          http://www.p
                                                         social protection, 2000                                                                                                            areform.ru/ve
                                                                                                                                                                                            /reports/3.asp

                                                         Economic Issues of Admin istrative Refo rm, survey of 600 civil servants of            Expert Foundation for                       http://www.p
                                                         the Central Apparatus of the Federal Min istries (Min istry of Health, Min istry       Labor Research                              areform.ru/ve
                                                         of Education, Ministry of Labor and Social Develop ment, Min istry for                 «ELF» under the grant                       /reports/1.asp
                                                         Economic Develop ment and Trade) 2001                                                  of Moscow Public
                                                                                                                                                Scientific Foundation




Prepa red by the WB/DFID Development Pa rtners Secreta ria t for Governance Reforms in Russia. You a re welcome to send informa tion on new resources to be i ncluded in this database to   79
Tumun Ts ydypov a t tts ydypov@worldbank.org / Подготовлено Секретариа том партнеров по ра звитию в обла сти реформы госуда рственного упра вления в России (Всемирный
Ба нк/Министерство Международного Ра звития Великобрита нии). Просим на правлять информацию о ма териа ла х для включения в ба зу да нных Тумуну Цыдыпову по а дресу
tts ydypov@worldbank.org
                                                                                                                                                                         Updated: August 2008


                                                         “Young Specialists in Russian Civil Service” , 2003                                    Institute of Sociology                      Young civ il
                                                                                                                                                RAN, Un iversity of                         servants_regi
                                                                                                                                                Toronto, Canada, led                        onal
                                                                                                                                                by V.S. Margun and                          report.doc
                                                                                                                                                R. Brim
                                                         Toward More Operationally Relevant Indicators of Governance, PREM                      World Ban k                 http://www1
                                                         Note 49, World Bank, December 2000                                                                                 .worldbank.
                                                                                                                                                                            org/prem/PR
                                                                                                                                                                            EM Notes/pr
                                                                                                                                                                            emnote49.pd
                                                                                                                                                                            f
                                                         International Experience with Civ il Service Censuses, PREM Note 62,                   World Ban k                 http://www1
                                                         World Ban k, January 2004                                                                                          .worldbank.
                                                                                                                                                                            org/prem/PR
                                                                                                                                                                            EM Notes/pr
                                                                                                                                                                            emnote62.pd
                                                                                                                                                                            f
                                                         Evaluation in Finnish Public Management Reforms, K. Ho lkeri –                         Ministry of Fianance,       Holkery_en      Holkery_rus.
                                                         Presentation at the conference “State Governance Reform and Its                        Fin land                    g.ppt           ppt
                                                         Implementation at the Reg ional Level”, September 2004, Moscow

                                                         On the Measurement of Market-Oriented Reforms, N. Loyaza, R. Soto, 2003                World Ban k, Catholic       http://econ.
                                                                                                                                                University of Chile         worldbank.o
                                                                                                                                                                            rg/files/3770
                                                                                                                                                                            7_wps3371.
                                                                                                                                                                            pdf
                                                         The Public Sector Governance Reform Cycle: Available Diagnostic Tools,                 World Ban k                 http://www1
                                                         PREM Note 88, World Ban k, Ju ly 2004:                                                                             .worldbank.
                                                                                                                                                                            org/prem/PR
                                                                                                                                                                            EM Notes/pr
                                                                                                                                                                            emnote88.pd
                                                                                                                                                                            f
                                                         Linking Administrative Reform to Economic Gro wth Patterns: Review of                  World Ban k                 Indicators_a    Indicators_an
                                                         Methods and Findings, Discussion Paper, Poverty Reduction and Economic                                             nd_tracking     d_tracking_ru
                                                         Management Network, World Bank, 2005                                                                               _eng.doc        s.doc




Prepa red by the WB/DFID Development Pa rtners Secreta ria t for Governance Reforms in Russia. You a re welcome to send informa tion on new resources to be i ncluded in this database to   80
Tumun Ts ydypov a t tts ydypov@worldbank.org / Подготовлено Секретариа том партнеров по ра звитию в обла сти реформы госуда рственного упра вления в России (Всемирный
Ба нк/Министерство Международного Ра звития Великобрита нии). Просим на правлять информацию о ма териа ла х для включения в ба зу да нных Тумуну Цыдыпову по а дресу
tts ydypov@worldbank.org
                                                                                                                                                                         Updated: August 2008


                                                         Governance and Gro wth: Measurement and Evidence, S. Knack, Center for                 Center for Institutional    http://www.
                                                         Institutional Reforms and the Informal Sector, 2002                                    Reforms and the             dec.org/pdf_
                                                                                                                                                Informal Sector             docs/PNAC
                                                                                                                                                                            P769.pdf
                                                         Contemporary Tendencies in Regional Development, B. Zhkharev ich, L.                   World Ban k                 Leontieff_C     Leontieff_Ce
                                                         Limonov, presentation in Arkhangelsk, June 2005, World Bank / Leontieff                                            enter_eng.pp    nter_rus.ppt
                                                         Center                                                                                                             t

                                                         Govern ment Performance Monitoring and Evaluation: International                       World Ban k                 Governance      Governance_
                                                         Experience, Y. Dobrolyubova, presentation in Arkhangelsk, June 2005,                                               _YD_eng.pp      YD_rus.ppt
                                                         World Ban k                                                                                                        t

                                                         Quality of Governance in Russian Regions. Presentation by A. Klimenko                  HSE                                         HSE_governa
                                                         and K. Go lovshinsky at the seminar “Administrative Reform in the                                                                  nce_monitori
                                                         Regions”, 2006                                                                                                                     ng_rus.ppt

                                                         Monitoring Governance Quality in South Russia. Presentation by S. Sneider,             Working Group                               Governance_
                                                         October 2006                                                                           Secretariat, Rostov on                      SFO_ rus.pps
                                                                                                                                                Don
                                                         Implementation of ad ministrative reform programs, action plans, and                   MoEDT                       MoEDT_M         MoEDT_Mo
                                                         projects in 2006. Presentation by MoEDT, March 2007                                                                onitoring_A     nitoring_AR_
                                                                                                                                                                            R_2007_eng      2007_rus.doc
                                                                                                                                                                            .doc
                                                         Federal Employ ment Serv ice: result of ad ministrative refo rm in 2006-07 and         Federal Employ ment                         Fed_employ
                                                         activities in 2008. Presentation of Y. Gertsiy at the “Administrative Reform           Service                                     ment_service
                                                         2008” conference, Moscow 14 March 2008                                                                                             _admin_refo r
                                                                                                                                                                                            m_ 2007_rus.
                                                                                                                                                                                            ppt




Prepa red by the WB/DFID Development Pa rtners Secreta ria t for Governance Reforms in Russia. You a re welcome to send informa tion on new resources to be i ncluded in this database to   81
Tumun Ts ydypov a t tts ydypov@worldbank.org / Подготовлено Секретариа том партнеров по ра звитию в обла сти реформы госуда рственного упра вления в России (Всемирный
Ба нк/Министерство Международного Ра звития Великобрита нии). Просим на правлять информацию о ма териа ла х для включения в ба зу да нных Тумуну Цыдыпову по а дресу
tts ydypov@worldbank.org

				
DOCUMENT INFO
Description: Ppt on Realestate of India document sample