Grading Rubric for Journal Article Reviews

Document Sample
Grading Rubric for Journal Article Reviews Powered By Docstoc
					Grading Rubric for Journal Article Reviews

Excellent                                   Satisfactory                                Unsatisfactory
Follows all directions accurately           Follows most directions accurately          Follows some directions correctly
Selection of articles applies effectively   Selection of articles applies to writer’s   Selection of articles does not apply to
to writer’s future situation                future situation                            writer’s future situation
Demonstrates through writing                Demonstrates through writing                Does not demonstrate through writing
summary a thoughtful reading of the         summary a cursory reading of the            summary that the material was read
material                                    material                                    and understood
Demonstrates intellectual depth in          Demonstrates thought and reflection in      Does not demonstrate thought and
answering required analysis questions       answering required analysis questions       reflection in answering analysis