Torture in Egypt

Document Sample
Torture in Egypt Powered By Docstoc

                                                                                                                                 D O C U M E N TAT I O N

                                                    Torture in Egypt
                                                    Basma M. Abdel Aziz, M.Psych., M.Neur.*

                                                    Abstract                                               1990s) thousands of detainees have been
                                                    This article is concerned with the increasing prev-    subjected to torture and ill-treatment in
                                                    alence of torture in Egypt. Torture is a widespread    Egypt.1 In May 1996 the UN Committee
                                                    problem in Egypt, being practiced in the majority      against Torture stated that it had received
                                                    of police stations and state security places. It has
                                                                                                           information on torture allegations mainly
                                                    become a routine practice and is seen daily on a
                                                                                                           through reports of the UN special rappor-
                                                    systematic basis. The number of people who are
                                                                                                           teur on torture, AI, and the World Organiza-
                                                    subjected every month to torture is unimaginable.
                                                    In addition, there are deaths that occur as a result   tion against Torture (Organisation Mondial
                                                    of the torture. However, the Egyptian govern-          Contre Torture, OMCT). The committee
                                                    ment does not give clear answers about the issue.      further noted that its requests to conduct a
                                                    Everyone could be exposed to torture, and for          visit to Egypt had received no reply. A con-
                                                    different, illogic reasons. The case of Bany Mazar     clusion made by the UN special rapporteur
                                                    is a horribly clarifying one. The unclear political    is that “torture is systematically practiced by
                                                    situation and the absence of democracy play the        the security forces in Egypt, in particular the
                                                    main role in the highly increasing rate of torture     state security intelligence, since in spite of
                                                    in Egypt.
                                                                                                           denials of the government, the allegations of
                                                                                                           torture submitted by reliable, non govern-
                                                    Key words: torture methods, Egypt, El Shariaa,
                                                                                                           mental organizations consistently indicate
                                                    police, prison
                                                                                                           that reported cases of torture are seen to
                                                                                                           be habitual, widespread and deliberate in at
                                                                                                           least a considerable part of the country.”1-3
                                                    One of the Amnesty International reports is
                                                    concerned about torture practice in Egypt,
T O R T U R E Vo l um e 17 , N um b er 1 , 2 00 7

                                                                                                           Examining prevalence
                                                    issued on the 28th of February, 2001, notes
                                                                                                           of torture in Egypt
                                                    that over the two past decades (1980s,
                                                                                                           Over the last two decades, NGOs working in
                                                                                                           the field of human rights have documented
                                                                                                           thousands of torture cases in police stations,
                                                    *)                                                     prisons and state security headquarters (Ta-
                                                    48, Mohamed Farid St.                                  ble 1). Meanwhile the human rights center
                                                    Heliopolis                                             for the assistance of prisoners (HRCPA)
                                                    Egypt                                                  monitored 1124 torture cases in prisons (El


    The Legal Aid Center reported about              per week and approximately one live victim
100s case of torture between 1994 and                every one and a half days.9
1995.                                                     Discussing systematic torture in Egypt,
    The Egyptian organization for human              El Nadeem4 assumes that the exact number
rights has documented in its annual reports5-        of torture victims is in reality several times
  the continuation of torture and ill-treat-         more than what has been revealed as many
ment of prisoners being widespread in the            victims could not report on officials who
majority of the Egyptian prisons, especially         tortured them. The simplest of these reasons
that of El Wady el Gedid and Abou Za’abal.           is the fear of police threats to re-arrest and
    In addition to torture and ill-treatment,        torture them and their families all over again
the absence of adequate medical care and             if they dare to come forward. Sometimes
the bad conditions of prisons led, for ex-           if the victims try to put forth a complaint
ample, to the death of eight prisoners within        or report what happened, police authority
the year 1999.6                                      would frame them for crimes they did not
    In Table 2 the numbers of torture cases          commit.
and deaths in 2000-2004 can be seen.
    However, the report mentions that these          Review of torture methods
cases are only a limited sample chosen from          used in Egypt
hundreds of other cases. The other cases             Methods used to induce this suffering are ei-
the organization was informed about have             ther physical, like beating, or psychological,
not been documented for different technical          like threats. These methods are applied
    The Egyptian Association Against Tor-
                                                     Table 2. The reported torture cases and deaths.8
ture (EAAT) reported the death of seven
                                                     Year              Torture cases Death under torture
persons under torture, in addition to an-
other 38 persons who underwent torture in            2000              13   victims   10 victims
                                                     2001              14   victims    7 victims
different police stations and state security         2002              12   victims   12 victims
intelligence. All of these came to be victims        2003              45   victims   13 victims
within only 50 days, that is to say one death        2004 till April   24   victims    2 victims

Table 1. Deaths under torture as reported by El Nadeem Center between 1994 and 2000, could be sum-
marized as follows.4
Name                              Place of torture                                      Date of death
                                                                                                           T O R T U R E Vol u m e 1 7 , N um b er 1, 2 0 07

F. EB. AM.                        Helwan PS                                                  16/8/1994
R. A. M. A..                      Misr Qadima PS                                            31/10/1994
A. I. M.                                                                                     15/8/1995
A. AH. A,                         Mansoura PS                                                 6/6/1996
M. ED., M. ET. S. A. S. A.        Coast Guard PS., Port Said                                    6/1996
M. H. M.                          Police Patrol, Kafr Al Dawar                                  7/1996
M. I. O. A.Z.                     Mansoura PS                                                   7/1996
S. A. B.                          Al-Zawiah AL-Hamra PS                                      16/8/1996
M. S. AE.                         Helwan PS                                                  27/8/1996
A. M. M. T.                       Omranniya PS                                               31/7/1999
R. S.                             Fayoum PS                                                  14/2/1999
M. A. A.                          Giza PS                                                       3/2000
PS = police station.

                                                                                                                          D O C U M E N TAT I O N

                                                   through specific techniques, and aim at              – Almost all cases were subjected to
                                                   achieving and serving the torturer’s goals           blindfolding.
                                                   whatever they are.                                6) Humiliation: including verbal abuse, ridi-
                                                       According to the report of El Nadeem             culing the victim and her/his body, call-
                                                   Center,4 the methods used in incarceration           ing them humiliating names that violate
                                                   places as described by 272 victims who vis-          their dignity and their parents and fam-
                                                   ited the Center between 1993 and 2001 are:           ily.
                                                                                                        – Almost all victims were subjected to
                                                    1) Beating: constitutes the first reception         this kind of torture.
                                                       ritual awaiting the victims, it is usually    7) Electric shock: frequently electrodes are
                                                       called “reception party”.                        connected to genitals.
                                                       – Three victims died from beating on             – Thirty-six victims were subjected to
                                                       testicles while one victim had an abor-          the electric torture.
                                                       tion.                                         8) Unsanitary conditions: keeping large num-
                                                    2) Suspension: constitutes one of the com-          bers of people in very small rooms, which
                                                       monest methods used in police stations           are not well ventilated, dirty and dark.
                                                       and jails where the victim becomes to-           – Most victims have been subjected to
                                                       tally incapacitated.                             these conditions.
                                                       – Twenty-seven victims have been sub-         9) Threats of harming the victim’s family.
                                                       jected to suspension. Most of them have          – Twenty-four cases were subjected to
                                                       suffered partial or total tearing of the         these threats.
                                                       nervous plexuses with the resultant mo-          – In eight cases the threats were actual
                                                       tor and sensory deficits.                        carried out.
                                                    3) Spraying icy water on the body: ice logs     10) Watching torture of other victims: that
                                                       may also be placed on the victim’s chest.        might be a family member (spouse,
                                                       – Most victims were subjected to this            mother, father ...).
                                                       method.                                          – Eight cases were subjected to this
                                                    4) Sexual abuse, rape: used against both            method.
                                                       men and women, where the victim is           11) Dragging on the floor.
                                                       first forced to take off her/his clothes.        – Eight cases were subjected to this
                                                       Clothes and parts of the body are de-            method.
                                                       scribed with obscene words while touch-          – One of them was dragged from his
                                                       ing sensitive parts.                             home to the police station.
                                                       – Forty-three victims were subjected to      12) Forcing the hands into extremely hot water:
T O R T U R E Vol um e 17 , Nu m be r 1 , 2 00 7

                                                       this kind of torture.                            resulting in the skinning of hands
                                                       – Seven women among them were                    – One victim was exposed to this
                                                       stripped and abused by words and                 method.
                                                       touch.                                       13) Breacking bones:
                                                       – Seven have been threatened by rape.            – Four cases suffered broken bones as a
                                                       – One woman was actually raped.                  result of beating.
                                                       – One man was exposed to violently           14) Burning: by cigarettes or red hot metal
                                                       squeezing the scrotum.                           tool.
                                                    5) Deprivation: the most common way is to           – Nine victims were subjected to this
                                                       blindfold the victim.                            method.


    – Four among them had deep burns              confession, because of the marked contradic-
    complicated by infections.                    tions in the intelligence story. However, the
    – One victim was burnt by pouring             whole family is still suffering severe harass-
    kerosene on his body and setting him on       ment guided by the officers who tortured M.
    fire.4                                        and who apparently decided to revenge the
                                                  refusal of M.’s family to scarify their son.
M. Ali – 29/12/2005                                   The illogic horrible context M. had been
A young man who lived in one of the Egyp-         through prevented him from seeking psycho-
tian villages was working as a farmer. He         logical help immediately. He chose to be iso-
lived with his old parents and had two mar-       lated for a period of time. His first visit to El
ried sisters and two brothers.                    Nadeem Center was in 2000. Months after
     One day a horrible murder occurred in        the first interview he preferred to write his
the village, three families (ten persons) were    story rather than to verbally express it.
killed during sleep and their genitals were
cut. Each family lived in a separate house.       Discussion
     Nobody heard or witnessed anything           An understanding of why torture is prac-
around the houses, however M. Ali was ac-         ticed in Egypt may be obtained by the ideals
cused of this crime. He was detained and          of the Egyptian regime and what this ideol-
tortured to confess, but he did not confess       ogy is fighting for while torturing.
except when the officers brought his family            In this context we may observe that
and started to torture them ... they took first   Egypt is passing through a period of im-
his father and sister, who left an infant be-     balance and disturbance. The target is not
hind her, then they took his mother … start-      communism, nor socialism, nor liberalism,
ing to torture the family, M. Ali accepted        nor even the Islamic ideology. Egypt is
to say whatever they wanted him to say ...        hosting a mixture of many ideologies that
officers offered his father a “generous” offer:   reflect themselves in many aspects of life.
(on condition M. confesses, we will prove         One profound example is the presence of
that he is insane, admit him to a mental hos-     (Article 59) of the Egyptian Constitution,10
pital and then he will be discharged)…            which states that the protection, support and
     M. Ali confessed under both physical         maintenance of the “socialist” gains are a
and psychological torture and was trained by      national duty; and (Article 73), in which the
detectives how to jump and to play the role       President of the Republic is also expected
of an assassinator. He was then admitted to       to protect socialist gains. Those articles are
a mental hospital where he was tied to the        still present, while the actual state policy is
                                                                                                      T O R T U R E Volu m e 1 7, N um be r 1, 2 0 07

bed for about 100 days.                           clearly directed towards privatisation and
     Some activists knew about the story and      market economy.
a case of torture was raised up in front of            A further contradiction is the following:
the persecutor general.                           while the state confiscates books under pres-
     The medical report of the mental hospi-      sure of Islamists and maintains that Islam
tal proved that M. Ali is not insane; he has      is the “official” religion of the state and that
no mental illness at all.                         “El Shariaa” is the main source of legislat-
     At the beginning of September the court      ing laws (Article 2), we find the cover of a
started to look into the case and after a few     weekly “official” state-owned magazine car-
days M. Ali was judged innocent despite his       rying an advertisement for alcoholic drinks

                                                                                                                             D O C U M E N TAT I O N

                                                   in many successive volumes.11,12 In this         References
                                                   context, Egyptian prisons and detention cen-      1. Torture remains rife as cries for justice go un-
                                                                                                        heeded. Amnesty International, Egypt, 2001. AI
                                                   tres host 20,000 detainees, most of whom             index: MDE 12/001/2001.
                                                   are kept illegally under the pretext of being     2. No protection – systematic torture continues.
                                                   Islamists.13                                         Amnesty International, Egypt, 2002. AI index:
                                                       This mixture of ideologies leads in turn         MDE 12/031/2002.
                                                                                                     3. Report of the committee against torture, July
                                                   to a vague identification of the in-group            1996. United Nations, 1996. Supplement No.
                                                   and the out-group, i.e. the “enemy” and              44(A/51/44).
                                                   the “friend”. From this perspective, state        4. Torture in Egypt, facts and testimonies. El Na-
                                                                                                        deem Center for Psychological Management and
                                                   violence and torture are not restricted to
                                                                                                        Rehabilitation of Victims of Violence, 2003.
                                                   or directed toward certain groups, but,           5. Human rights state in Egypt. The Annual Report
                                                   as reported, Islamists are tortured as well          of 1998. The Egyptian Organization for Human
                                                   as communists, socialists, criminals, poor           Rights, 1999.
                                                                                                     6. Human rights state in Egypt. The Annual Report
                                                   people, human rights defenders, anti-war
                                                                                                        of 1999-2000. The Egyptian Organization for
                                                   people, and suspects, thus creating another          Human Rights, 2001.
                                                   heterogeneous mixture, this time composed         7. Human rights state in Egypt. The Annual report
                                                   of victims.                                          of 2002. The Egyptian Organization for Human
                                                                                                        Rights, 2003.
                                                       The enemy is considered to be anyone
                                                                                                     8. Torture in Egypt -- a phenomenon without re-
                                                   who is not clearly belonging to the system,          straint. The 12th report. The Egyptian Organiza-
                                                   who is not supported by the regime.                  tion for Human Rights, 2004.
                                                       This lack of “system” results in a confu-     9. Egyptian Association against Torture. Statement:
                                                                                                        stop torture now. El Nadeem Center, 2004.
                                                   sion regarding what one should or should         10. The Egyptian constitution. El Matabe El Amir-
                                                   not do to avoid becoming a victim. The               reya, 1971.
                                                   result is a people who appear as “passive” to    11. Rose El Yossef 2003 (a national Egyptian maga-
                                                   the outside observer.                                zine). No. 3915, No. 3916. Cover.
                                                                                                    12. Rose El Yossef 2004. No. 3956. No. 3964, No.
                                                       Power and authority pose two deeply dif-         3966, No. 3975. Cover.
                                                   ferent meanings. While power refers to the       13. The annual report of 2003. Human Rights
                                                   absolute illegitimate force, authority carries       Center for the Assistance of Prisoners, 2004.
                                                                                                    14. Maritain J. Man and the state. Chicago: Phoenix
                                                   the legitimate right to command others.14
                                                                                                        Books, 1966.
                                                   What in fact dominates the political life in
                                                   Egypt is certainly the absolute power and
                                                   not the authority, given that much of the
                                                   police practices are in violation of the Con-
                                                   stitution and the law.
T O R T U R E Vol um e 17 , Nu m be r 1 , 2 00 7