Documents
Resources
Learning Center
Upload
Plans & pricing Sign in
Sign Out

Minutes of 201st Meeting of SRC

VIEWS: 537 PAGES: 190

									                                                                                     st
                                                                          Minutes-201 Meeting of SRC
                                                                                   22-23 February 2011




                    SOUTHERN REGIONAL COMMITTEE
                             BANGALORE

                      Minutes of the 201st Meeting of SRC held at the
                Conference Hall of NCTE, Bangalore on 22-23 February, 2011



                           The following members attended the Meeting:-

            1.      Prof. C. Thangamuthu      -      Chairman

            2       Prof. C.L. Anand          -      Member

            3       Prof. P.J. Poulose        -      Member

            4.      Prof.C.H.Vijayalakshmi    -      Member

            5.      Prof. V.Sudhakar          -      Member

            6.      Fahmida Rahim (Karnataka) -      Representative
                    Deputy Director

             7      Arokiasamy
                    Jt. Director (TN)         -      Representative ( Attended on 22.02.2011)

             8.     Sri. Gangadharaiah        -      Convenor



                    The following members could not attend the Meeting :-


      Prof. Syeda Akthar, Member, Prof. C. Seshadri, Member & Representatives of          the Andhra
      Pradesh and U.T‟s of Lakshadweep, Pondicherry & Andaman & Nicobar Islands




     (Gangadharaiah)                                                   (Prof. C. Thangamuthu)
Regional Director, SRC, NCTE                                            Chairman, SRC, NCTE
                                              1
                                                                                        st
                                                                             Minutes-201 Meeting of SRC
                                                                                      22-23 February 2011
                        SOUTHERN REGIONAL COMMITTEE
               NATIONAL COUNCIL FOR TEACHER EDUCATION
                                         BANGALORE
 ---------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------
                   MINUTES OF 201st MEETING OF SRC, NCTE

Sl.                     Brief Description                              Remarks of SRC
No
 1.     Confirmation of Minutes of 200th meeting held on                  Confirmed
                       20-21 January 2011

 2.    Action Taken Report (ATR) on the Minutes of 199th                    Noted
             meeting held on 22-23 December 2010


Inspection Report – Section 13 Report:

Sl.           Code                                         Remarks of SRC
No          Course
      Name of the institution
              State
3.         APS01431             S.J.U.P D.Ed College, Harihar-577601, Davangere District,
           APS05963             Karnataka was granted recognition for offering D.Ed-AI course with
              D.Ed              an intake of 100 students vide order dated 26.09.2007 which
             D.Ed-AI            includes existing intake of 50 students and additional intake of 50
      S.J.U.P.D.Ed College,     students.
           Davangere
               KA               NCTE, Hqrs vide its letter dated 10.02.2011 has forwarded a copy of
                                the inspection report dated 28.06.2010 conducted Under Section 13
                                of NCTE Act. As there are deficiencies pointed out in the inspection
                                report, NCTE, Hqrs has requested SRC to look into the matter to
                                ascertain the adherence of relevant NCTE norms & standards by the
                                institution and take appropriate action against institution.

                                The Committee considered the reply of the institution, VT
                                Report and all the relevant documentary evidences and it was
                                decided to serve Show cause Notice Under Section 17 of NCTE
                                Act for the following :
                                 Built up areas earmarked for D.Ed, D.Ed-AI, B.Ed and M.Ed
                                   course are not mentioned.
                                 The management is also running a primary school,
                                   secondary school, PUC and Degree college along with D.Ed,
                                   B.Ed and M.Ed in the same building which is not permitted
                                   as per NCTE norms as the institution is running other
                                   courses in the same campus.




     (Gangadharaiah)                                                        (Prof. C. Thangamuthu)
Regional Director, SRC, NCTE                                                 Chairman, SRC, NCTE
                                                  2
                                                                                       st
                                                                            Minutes-201 Meeting of SRC
                                                                                     22-23 February 2011
                                Payment of CPF/EPF of staff members is not maintained.
                                Details of Endowment and Reserve Fund for B.Ed and M.Ed
                                 programmes are not not submitted.

                               In view of the above, the Committee decided to issue a Show
                               cause Notice to the institution as to why the recognition be not
                               withdrawn and thereby providing an opportunity to the
                               institution to make a written representation within 30 days from
                               the date of issue of the Notice along with necessary
                               certificates/documents in order to take a final decision in the
                               matter; failing which action will be taken including the
                               withdrawal of recognition, based on the records available, with
                               no further notice.

4.          APS01210           B.K.R. Teacher Training Institute, Chennai District, Tamilnadu
              D.T.Ed
      BKR Teacher Training     Sola Raju Dhanuskodi Raja Thai Ammal Memorial Education
        Institute, Chennai     Charitable Trust, B.K.R Teacher Training Institute, No. 45/22E,
                TN             Madras Bye Pass Road, Thiruttani-631209, Thiruvallur District,
                               Tamilnadu submitted an application to SRC for grant of recognition
                               for offering D.T.Ed course on 28.10.2002. The application was
                               processed and recognition to D.T.Ed course was granted with an
                               intake of 50 students on 13.09.2004.

                               SRC in its 192nd meeting held on 10th-11th May 2010 and decided to
                               withdraw recognition granted to the institution for B.Ed course.
                               Accordingly withdrawal order for B.Ed course was issued to the
                               institution on 01.07.2010.

                               Aggrieved by the withdrawal order, the institution preferred an
                               appeal to NCTE-Hqrs. The Appellate Authority in its order dt.
                               17.09.2010 reversed SRCs order dt. 01.07.2010 with the direction to
                               SRC for causing composite inspection of the own premises of the
                               institution for all the recognized Teacher Training Programe of
                               NCTE, after obtaining a payment of Rs. 40000/-from the institution
                               and for further decision thereafter within 30 days of issue of this
                               order and thereafter pass appropriate order.

                               The institution has submitted Rs. 40000/- towards inspection fees.
                               The committee considered the matter in its 197th meeting held on
                               13th-14th October 2010 and decided to cause composite inspection.

                               As per the decision of SRC in its 197th meeting held on 13th-14th
                               October 2010, composite inspection of the institution was conducted
                               on 24.11.2010. The Committee in its 199th meeting held on 22nd-23rd
                               December 2010 considered the VT Report, VCD and all the relevant
                               documentary evidences and it was decided to serve Showcause
                               Notice Under Section 17 of NCTE Act for the following:




     (Gangadharaiah)                                                      (Prof. C. Thangamuthu)
Regional Director, SRC, NCTE                                               Chairman, SRC, NCTE
                                                 3
                                                                                         st
                                                                              Minutes-201 Meeting of SRC
                                                                                       22-23 February 2011
                                The management is running in the same complex an Engineering
                                 college and Nursing college.
                                A Certificate from the Government Affiliating body to the effect that
                                 no other programme is being run/shared by the institution in the
                                 same building / Campus, along with the existing Course B.Ed,
                                 D.T.Ed, M.Ed & D.T.Ed – Al is to be submitted.
                                The latest Building Completion Certificate from the competent
                                 Government Engineer is not submitted.
                                The institute has not submitted the approved Building plan from a
                                 competent Govt. authority.
                                Non- encumbrance Certificate from the competent Government
                                 Authorized person / Authorities to be submitted.
                                Duly filled in Questionnaire along with all the necessary
                                 documents for land, building approval and completion certificate
                                 from a competent Govt. Engineer and others etc., is to be
                                 submitted.

                               Accordingly, show cause notice was issued to the institution on
                               01.02.2011 giving 30 days time to reply. The reply from the
                               institution is awaited.

                               In the mean time NCTE, Hqrs vide its letter dated 10.02.2011 has
                               forwarded a copy of the inspection report dated 22.11.2010
                               conducted Under Section 13 of NCTE Act and requested for further
                               necessary action.

                               The Committee considered the Section 13 Inspection report of
                               the institution, VT Report and all the relevant documentary
                               evidences and it was decided to await for the reply to the
                               Showcause Notice under section 17 of NCTE Act for final
                               decision.

Inspection Report – Appeal Case:

5.        SRCAPP65             Shadan College of Education, Hyderabad, Andhra Pradesh
            B.Ed-AI            An application was submitted by Shadan Educational Society, Plot
       Shadan College of       No-6-2-978.     village Khairatabad. Post-Khairatabad. Taluka –
      Education, Hyderabad     Khairatabad. Hyderabad, Andhra Pradesh had applied for grant of
               AP              recognition to Shadan College of Education. 6-2-978, Khairatabad,
                               Hyderabad, Andhra Pradesh, for B.Ed (Al) intake from 160 seats to
                               200 seats course.of one year duration under section 15(1) of the
                               NCTE Act, 1993 to the Southern Regional Committee, NCTE on
                               29.10.2009.

                               The application was processed and the deficiency letter was issued to
                               the institution on 22.12.2009. The institution submitted its written
                               representation on 08.02.2010.




     (Gangadharaiah)                                                        (Prof. C. Thangamuthu)
Regional Director, SRC, NCTE                                                 Chairman, SRC, NCTE
                                                 4
                                                                                            st
                                                                                 Minutes-201 Meeting of SRC
                                                                                          22-23 February 2011
                               The SRC considered the matter in its 190th meeting held on 29th-30th
                               March 2010 and on careful perusal of the original file of the institution
                               and other related documents. NCTE Act 1993, regulations and
                               guidelines from time to time laid on the table, written representation
                               from the institution, the regional committee decided to reject the
                               application on the following grounds:-
                                Minority Status Certificate submitted is not from the competent authority.

                               Accordingly, rejection order was issued to the applicant institution on
                               03.05.2010.as per direction of Regional Committee.

                               The Appellate Authority order dt. 23.08.2010 has remanded back the
                               case to SRC with a direction to process the case further on merit.

                               The SRC considered the Appellate Authority order and decided to
                               reprocess the application.

                               The institution has submitted the following in letter dt. 25.10.2010.
                               Minority Certificate dated.16.08.1999 issued by Secretary, Minorities
                               Welfare Department, Govt. of Andhra Pradesh. and Govt. of Andhra
                               Pradesh order dt. 23.03.1999, extracts of memorandum of
                               association and bye-laws is also for perusal in terms of observation in
                               Appellate order dt. 23.08.2010.Para 4.

                               The committee in its 199th meeting held on 23-24, December 2010
                               considered the written explanation to the notice and other relevant
                               documents submitted by the institution and decided to cause
                               inspection. The inspection was caused on 10.02.2011.

                               The Committee considered the Appellate authority order dt.
                               23.08.2010, VT Report, VCD and all the relevant documentary
                               evidences and it was decided to serve Showcause Notice Under
                               Section 17 of NCTE Act for the following:
                                The institution has to submit details of other programmes being
                                 run by the management in the same building/premises/in
                                 Multistoreyed building, along with documentary evidence from the
                                 relevant affiliating/approving authority.
                                The institution has to submit latest VCD of the Building where
                                 teacher education programme is currently being conducted.

                               In view of the above, the Committee decided to issue a
                               Showcause Notice to the institution as to why the recognition be
                               not withdrawn and thereby providing an opportunity to the
                               institution to make a written representation within 30 days from
                               the date of issue of the Notice along with necessary
                               certificates/documents in order to take a final decision in the
                               matter; failing which action will be taken including the
                               withdrawal of recognition, based on the records available, with
                               no further notice.




     (Gangadharaiah)                                                           (Prof. C. Thangamuthu)
Regional Director, SRC, NCTE                                                    Chairman, SRC, NCTE
                                                   5
                                                                                        st
                                                                             Minutes-201 Meeting of SRC
                                                                                      22-23 February 2011
Inspection Report –Court Cases:

6.          APS09674           Sri      Vivekananda        College      of      Education,Prabhu
               D.Ed            EducationalSociety,No.590/1, 59/1/2, Mahabubabad, Edulapussapally
     Sri Vivekananda College   Road, Warangal-506101, Andhra Pradesh
     of Education, Warangal    Sri Vivekananda College of Elementary Education, Prabhu
                AP             Educational Society, NO. 590/1, 59/1/2, Mahabubabad,
                               Edulapusapally Road, Warangal-506101, Andhra Pradesh.
                                An application was submitted by Prabhu Educational Society,
                               Warangal, Andhra Pradesh for grant of recognition to D.Ed course in
                               the office of SRC-NCTE, Bangalore vide dated 30.10.2008.
                                The file was under process and in the meanwhile, in view of the
                               recommendation of the state Government of Andhra pradesh vide
                               letter dated 07.01.2009 not to further recognize/permit the
                               institutions for conducting B.Ed, D.Ed, Physical Education,
                               Language Pandit Course(s).

                               SRC in its 169th Meeting held on 12-13th January, 2009 meeting
                               held on 12-13th January, 2009 having considered the letter dated
                               07.01.2009 of state Government of Andhra Pradesh and decided to
                               give effect to the decision of above decision of state Government of
                               Andhra Pradesh as such, with immediate effect. A letter dated
                               07.02.2009 forwarded by Principal Secretary of Education
                               requesting not to accord further recognition/permission to the new
                               colleges/private B.Ed, D.Ed, Physical Education, Language Pandit in
                               the state of Andhra Pradesh as the above colleges are exceeding in
                               numbers than required letter dated 17th March, 2009 has been
                               received from NCTE Hqrs informing that the “The recommendations
                               of the Govt. of Andhra Pradesh not to grant recognition/permission in
                               respect of other courses like B.Ed, D.Ed and Physical Education
                               courses have further been considered in the NCTE and it has been
                               decided that no further recognition/permission to any institution in
                               the state of Andhra Pradesh be considered by SRC for the academic
                               session 2009-10 for B.Ed, D.Ed and Physical Education courses
                               also”. The state Government vide letter dated 20.03.2009 informed
                               that it has been decided not to recommend the name of your
                               institution. The letters dated 07.01.2009, 07.02.2009, 17.03.2009
                               and 20.03.2009 was considered by SRC in its 172nd meeting held on
                               25th – 26th March 2009 and SRC decided to accept the
                               recommendation of the state Government of Andhra Pradesh, not to
                               grant recognition to any of the Teacher Training Institutions in the
                               state of Andhra Pradesh for the year 2009-10 and decided to close
                               the applications. As per decision of SRC the withdrawal order issued
                               on 18.04.2009.
                               The Institution has approached to Honorable High Court in W.P
                               26814 of 2010. The Honorable High Court has directed vide dared
                               29-10-2010. The Honorable High Court has passed an order.



     (Gangadharaiah)                                                       (Prof. C. Thangamuthu)
Regional Director, SRC, NCTE                                                Chairman, SRC, NCTE
                                                 6
                                                                                              st
                                                                                  Minutes-201 Meeting of SRC
                                                                                           22-23 February 2011
                               “It may be true that the state Government as well as the first respondent
                               have reviewed the situation as to the necessity or otherwise of according
                               permission to establish new colleges of education in the state in future and
                               that the existing institutions are found to be adequate. However , the right
                               that is accrued to the petitioners on the basis of their application and the
                               consideration thereof by the first respondent cannot be taken away on
                               account of the change of policy. It is settled principle of law that whenever
                               an application is made, it must be considered and processed in accordance
                               with the provisions of law or the policy that existed as on the date of
                               presentation. Subsequent changes may apply to the applications that are
                               made there after‟.

                               Hence, this writ Petition is also disposed of reiterating the same directions
                               as noticed supra. No costs.”

                               SRC had issued a deficiency letter dated 30.10.2008. The institution
                               had submitted its reply dated 05.10.09.

                               SRC in its 198th meeting held on 24th –26th November, 2010
                               considered the matter and all relevant documents and decided to
                               cause inspection to examine whether the institution fulfils all the
                               requirements as per the norms, for the proposed programme,
                               subject to the condition that the institution had rectified the
                               deficiencies, if any, as per the norms. Accordingly inspection of the
                               institution was carried out on 19.01.2011.

                               The Committee considered the VT Report, VCD and all the
                               relevant documentary evidences and it was decided to serve
                               Show cause Notice Under Section 17 of NCTE Act for the
                               following :
                                The institution has to submit details of other programmes
                                   being run by the management, along with documentary
                                   evidence from the relevant affiliating/approving authority.
                                The essential data entered in the inspection report have
                                   found been tampered by using white correction fluid.
                                As per VCD, it is clear that the Name board of the institution
                                   is of Flexi board instead of a permanent type, and reads that
                                   the course is approved by NCTE without formal approval.
                                As per VCD, entrance of each room, carries pasted paper
                                   which reads, as Class I, Class II, Class III, Class IV etc.,
                                   implying that a School is being run in the same building.
                                As per VCD, Electrical wiring is not concelead and open in
                                   most of the class rooms, there by expasing students to
                                   danger/Lack of Safety measures.
                                As per VCD, flooring in some rooms is yet to done.
                                Full view and frontage of the Building are not covered in the
                                   VCD.
                                Toilets are not clean and Hygenic.




     (Gangadharaiah)                                                             (Prof. C. Thangamuthu)
Regional Director, SRC, NCTE                                                      Chairman, SRC, NCTE
                                                   7
                                                                                       st
                                                                            Minutes-201 Meeting of SRC
                                                                                     22-23 February 2011
                               In view of the above, the Committee decided to issue a Show
                               cause Notice to the institution as to why the recognition be not
                               withdrawn and thereby providing an opportunity to the
                               institution to make a written representation within 30 days from
                               the date of issue of the Notice along with necessary
                               certificates/documents in order to take a final decision in the
                               matter; failing which action will be taken including the
                               withdrawal of recognition, based on the records available, with
                               no further notice.

7.        APS09727             Al-Madina College of Education,H.No.2-1/1, S.No.120, Kesharaj
             B.Ed              Pally, Thipparty Mandal, Nalgonda-508001, Andhra Pradesh.
      Al-Madina College of     Course- B.Ed. (Code no. APS09727)
      Education, Nalgonda
              AP               An application was submitted by Al-Madina Educational Society,
                               Nalgonda District, Andhra Pradesh for grant of recognition to B.Ed
                               course in the office of SRC-NCTE, vide dated 31.10.2008

                               The file was under proc ess and in the meanwhile, in view of the
                               recommendations of the State Government of Andhra Pradesh vide
                               letter dated 07.01.2009 not to further recognise/permit the
                               institutions for conducting   B.Ed, D.Ed, Physical Education,
                               Language Pandit course(s).

                               The SRC in its 169th Meeting held on 12-13 January, 2009 having
                               considered the letter dated 07.01.2009 of State Government of
                               Andhra Pradesh and decided to give effect to the above decision of
                               State Government of Andhra Pradesh as such, with immediate
                               effect.

                               A letter dated 07.02.2009 forwarded by Principal Secretary of
                               Education requesting not to accord further recognition/permission to
                               the new colleges/private B.Ed, D.Ed, Physical Education, Language
                               Pandit in the State of Andhra Pradesh as the above colleges are
                               exceeding in numbers than required.

                               A letter dated 17.03.2009 was also received from NCTE, Hqrs
                               informing that the “The recommendations of the Govt. of Andhra
                               Pradesh not to grant recognition/permission in respect of other
                               courses like B.Ed, D.Ed and Physical Education courses have
                               further been decided that no further Recognition/ Permission to any
                               institution in the State of Andhra Pradesh be considered by SRC for
                               the academic session 2009-2010 for B.Ed, D.Ed, and Physical
                               Education courses also”.




     (Gangadharaiah)                                                       (Prof. C. Thangamuthu)
Regional Director, SRC, NCTE                                                Chairman, SRC, NCTE
                                                 8
                                                                                           st
                                                                              Minutes-201 Meeting of SRC
                                                                                       22-23 February 2011
                               The State Government vide its letter dated 20.03.2009 informed that
                               it has been decided not to recommend the name of this institution.
                               The letters dated 07.01.2009, 07.02.2009, 17.03.2009 and
                               20.03.2009 was considered by SRC in its 172nd Meeting held on 25-
                               26 March, 2009 and SRC decided to accept the recommendation of
                               the State Government of Andhra Pradesh, not to grant recognition to
                               any of the Teacher Training Institutions in the State of Andhra
                               Pradesh for the year 2009-2010 and decided to close the
                               applications.

                               As per the decision of SRC the application was closed on
                               28.04.2009

                               The Institute has approached          to   Hon‟ble   High        Court   in
                               W.P.No.13482/2010.

                               The Hon‟ble High Court has passed an order on 16.06.2010 vide
                               W.P.No.13482 of 2010 reads as hereunder:-

                               “It may be true that the State Government as well as the first
                               respondent have reviewed the situation as to the necessary or
                               otherwise of according permission to establish new colleges of
                               education in the State in future and that the existing institutions are
                               found to be adequate. However, the right that is accrued to the
                               petitioners on the basis of their application and the consideration
                               thereof by the first respondent cannot be taken away on account of
                               the change of policy. It is settled principle of law that whenever an
                               application is made, it must be considered and processed in
                               accordance with the provisions of law that existed as on the date of
                               presentation. Subsequent changes may apply to the applications
                               that are made thereafter.

                               Hence, the writ petition is disposed of directing the first respondent
                               to take necessary steps as contemplated in its communication dated
                               24.11.2009 and pass appropriate orders. There shall be no order as
                               to costs.”

                               We had issued deficiency letter to institution on 25.11.2008 to which
                               institution replied with supporting documents on 26.12.2008. It was
                               observed that the Building Completion Certificate is signed by
                               Private Engineer.

                               SRC considered in its 194th meeting held on 30st –22nd July, 2010
                               and the SRC directed the Management to resubmit the old
                               application returned by SRC along with the documents as originally
                               submitted relating to land, building, FDR, Application fee, BCC from
                               competent Government Engineer/ Authority and other relevant
                               aspects for processing and for necessary action.




     (Gangadharaiah)                                                         (Prof. C. Thangamuthu)
Regional Director, SRC, NCTE                                                  Chairman, SRC, NCTE
                                                  9
                                                                                           st
                                                                                Minutes-201 Meeting of SRC
                                                                                         22-23 February 2011
                                        As per direction of Regional Committee a letter was issued
                               on 19.08.2010. In response to this office letter dated 19.08.2010 the
                               institution has submitted reply vide letter dated 24.08.2010.

                                       As per perusal of the file the institution has submitted
                               following documents vide letters dated 24.08.10 and 28.07.10 :-
                                      1.   Processing fee and application fee (40,000+1,000= 41,000/-)
                                      2.   Land documents
                                      3.   BCC Certificate
                                      4.   Land use Certificate
                                      5.   Approved Building Plan
                                      6.   Original FDR of 5 lakhs and 3 lakhs.

                               SRC in its 196th Meeting held on 15-16 September, 2010
                               considered the matter and decided to process the application further
                               as per norms and to list deficiencies, if any, and to inform the
                               institution to comply with the deficiencies allowing a period of 60
                               days for rectification of deficiencies.

                               As per perusal of the file the institution has submitted           above
                               documents vide letter dated 24.08.10 and 28.07.10.

                               SRC in its 198th meeting held on 24th –26th November, 2010
                               considered by the Committee and it was decided to cause inspection
                               of the institution for considering recognition for B.Ed. Course.

                               Accordingly inspection of the institution was carried out on
                               20.01.2011

                               The SRC considered the VT report, VCD, reply to the show
                               cause notice and all relevant documents and decided to issue
                               Letter of Intent for grant of recognition to B.Ed course of one
                               year duration with an annual intake of 100 (Hundred only)(one
                               unit) for the academic year 2011-12 subject to the appointment
                               of qualified staff through duly constituted selection committee
                               as per the Norms of NCTE/State Government/Affiliating
                               University and be given effect before the commencement of the
                               academic session.




     (Gangadharaiah)                                                           (Prof. C. Thangamuthu)
Regional Director, SRC, NCTE                                                    Chairman, SRC, NCTE
                                                  10
                                                                                              st
                                                                                  Minutes-201 Meeting of SRC
                                                                                           22-23 February 2011
8.         APS09456            Sree Sai College of Education, 22-49-B3, Opp Brahmgari Mattam,
             D.Ed              Pagidyala Road, 27 Block, Nandikotur, Kurnool-518401, Andhra
       Sree Sai College of     Pradesh.Course- D.Ed. (Code no. APS09456)
       Education, Kurnool
              AP               An application was submitted by Sri Siddartha Educational Society,
                               Kurnool Dt., A.P. in the name of Sree Sai College of Education,
                               Kurnool Dt., A.P. for grant of recognition to D.Ed. course in the office
                               of SRC, NCTE Bangalore on 8.4.2008.

                               The file was under process and in the meanwhile, in view of the
                               recommendations of the State Government of Andhra Pradesh vide
                               letter dated 07.01.2009 not to further recognize/permit the
                               institutions for conducting B.Ed, D.Ed, Physical Education,
                               Language Pandit course(s), to this effect that application for B.Ed,
                               D.Ed, Physical Education, Language Pandit courses from the States
                               of Andhra Pradesh will not be considered for the academic session
                               2009-2010 and all such applications shall be returned along with
                               processing fees and documents.

                               The SRC in its 169th meeting held on 12-13th January, 2009 having
                               considered the letter dated 7.1.2009 of State Government of Andhra
                               Pradesh and decided to give effect to the decision of above decision
                               of State Government of Andhra Pradesh as such, with immediate
                               effect.

                               Further, a letter dated 07.02.2009 forwarded by Principal Secretary
                               of Education requesting not to accord further recognition/permission
                               to the new colleges/private B.Ed , D.Ed, Physical Education,
                               Language Pandit in the state of Andhra Pradesh as the above
                               colleges are exceeding in numbers than required.

                               Meanwhile, a letter dated 17.03.2009 has been received from NCTE
                               Hqrs informing that the “ The recommendations of the Govt. of Andhra
                               Pradesh not to grant recognition/ permission in respect of other courses like
                               B.Ed , D.Ed and Physical Education courses have further been considered
                               in NCTE and it has been decided that no further recognition/Permission to
                               any institution in the state of Andhra Pradesh be considered by SRC for the
                               academic session 2009-10 for B.Ed , D.Ed and physical Education Courses
                               also”.
                               Further the state Government vide its letter dated 20.03.2009
                               informed that it has been decided not to recommend the name of this
                               institution.

                               The letters dated 07.01.2009, 07.02.2009, 17.03.2009 and
                               20.03.2009 were considered by SRC in its 172nd meeting held on
                               25th-26th March 2009 and SRC decided to accept the
                               recommendation of the State Government of Andhra Pradesh, not to
                               grant recognition to any of the Teacher Training Institutions in the
                               state of Andhra Pradesh for the year 2009-10 and decided to close
                               the applications.



     (Gangadharaiah)                                                             (Prof. C. Thangamuthu)
Regional Director, SRC, NCTE                                                      Chairman, SRC, NCTE
                                                   11
                                                                                              st
                                                                                  Minutes-201 Meeting of SRC
                                                                                           22-23 February 2011
                               As per the decision of SRC the application was closed on
                               22.04.2009.

                               The Hon‟ble High Court has passed an order on 06.05.2010 vide
                               W.P.No.11078 of 2010 to consider the application of the petitioner
                               without making reference to the recommendation of State
                               Government policy dated 07.01.2009.

                               The Committee considered the matter and decided to process the
                               application.

                               The matter was considered by the Committee in 195 SRC and it was
                               decided to Call for the following documents from the institution, for
                               further processing and action:-
                                  B.C.C Certificate in prescribed format.
                                  FDR of 5 lakhs and 3 lakhs for Reserve fund and Endowment fund.
                                  Affidavit of Rs.100/- in prescribed format in respect of land records and
                                   all other necessary documents for processing the application; along
                                   with Rs.40,000/- towards application fee.

                               As per direction of SRC a letter was issued on 23.09.10. In response
                               to this office letter dated 23.09.10 the institution has submitted reply
                               dated 15.11.2010.

                               SRC in its 198th meeting held on 24th –26th November, 2010
                               considered the matter and all relevant documents and decided to
                               cause inspection to examine whether the institution fulfils all the
                               requirements as per the norms, for the proposed programme,
                               subject to the condition that the institution had rectified the
                               deficiencies, if any, as per the norms.

                               Accordingly inspection of the institution was carried out on
                               21.01.2011.

                               The Committee considered the VT Report, VCD and all the
                               relevant documentary evidences and it was decided to serve
                               Show cause Notice Under Section 17 of NCTE Act for the
                               following :

                                As per VT report, the earmarked built up area for B.Ed is
                                 16511 sq.ft and for D.Ed is 6660 sq.ft. The total Built up area
                                 for both the courses is 23171 sq.ft. which is inadequate
                                 against NCTE requirement of 3000 sq.mts for both the
                                 courses.
                                As per VCD, it is clear that a school is being run in the same
                                 Building/premises.
                                As per VCD, entrance of each room carry pasted paper
                                 which reads as Class I, Class II, Class III etc. implying that a
                                 School is being run in the same building.




     (Gangadharaiah)                                                             (Prof. C. Thangamuthu)
Regional Director, SRC, NCTE                                                      Chairman, SRC, NCTE
                                                   12
                                                                                       st
                                                                            Minutes-201 Meeting of SRC
                                                                                     22-23 February 2011
                               In view of the above, the Committee decided to issue a Show
                               cause Notice to the institution as to why the recognition be not
                               withdrawn and thereby providing an opportunity to the
                               institution to make a written representation within 30 days from
                               the date of issue of the Notice along with necessary
                               certificates/documents in order to take a final decision in the
                               matter; failing which action will be taken including the
                               withdrawal of recognition, based on the records available, with
                               no further notice.

9.          APS09574           Siva Ranga College of Education, Siva Sankara Educational &
              B.Ed             Development Society, No.926, Koilkuntla, Kurnool-518134,
      Siva Ranga College of    Andhra Pradesh Course- B.Ed. (Code no. APS09574)
       Education, Kurnool
               AP              An application was submitted by Siva Sankara Educational &
                               Development Society, Kurnool, Andhra Pradesh for grant of
                               recognition to B.Ed course in the office of SRC-NCTE, vide dated
                               13.08.2008.

                               The file was under process and in the meanwhile, in view of the
                               recommendations of the State Government of Andhra Pradesh vide
                               letter dated 07.01.2009 not to further recognise/permit the
                               institutions for conducting B.Ed, D.Ed, Physical Education,
                               Language Pandit course(s).

                               The SRC in its 169th Meeting held on 12-13 January, 2009 having
                               considered the letter dated 07.01.2009 of State Government of
                               Andhra Pradesh and decided to give effect to the above decision of
                               State Government of Andhra Pradesh as such, with immediate
                               effect.

                               A letter dated 07.02.2009 forwarded by Principal Secretary of
                               Education requesting not to accord further recognition/permission to
                               the new colleges/private B.Ed, D.Ed, Physical Education, Language
                               Pandit in the State of Andhra Pradesh as the above colleges are
                               exceeding in numbers than required.

                               A letter dated 17.03.2009 has been received from NCTE, Hqrs
                               informing that the “The recommendations of the Govt. of Andhra
                               Pradesh not to grant recognition/permission in respect of other
                               courses like B.Ed, D.Ed and Physical Education courses have
                               further been decided that no further Recognition/ Permission to any
                               institution in the State of Andhra Pradesh be considered by SRC for
                               the academic session 2009-2010 for B.Ed, D.Ed, and Physical
                               Education courses also”.




     (Gangadharaiah)                                                       (Prof. C. Thangamuthu)
Regional Director, SRC, NCTE                                                Chairman, SRC, NCTE
                                                13
                                                                                           st
                                                                                Minutes-201 Meeting of SRC
                                                                                         22-23 February 2011
                               The letters dated 07.01.2009, 07.02.2009, 17.03.2009 and
                               20.03.2009 was considered by SRC in its 172nd Meeting held on 25-
                               26 March, 2009 and SRC decided to accept the recommendation of
                               the State Government of Andhra Pradesh, not to grant recognition to
                               any of the Teacher Training Institutions in the State of Andhra
                               Pradesh for the year 2009-2010 and decided to return the
                               applications.

                               As per the direction of SRC the documents along with processing fee
                               returned to the institution on 27.04.2009. The institution has
                               approached to Hon‟ble High court of Andhra pradesh without
                               making appeal to appellate authority under section 18 of NCTE Act.

                               Hon‟ble High court has passed order dated first day of June, two
                               thousand and ten. The operative part of order as under:-
                               These Writ Petitions raise common issues. Therefore with the
                               consent of the learned counsel for the parties, they are taken up for
                               hearing and disposal together.

                               In all these Writ petitions, the petitioners, which are educational
                               Institutions, felt aggrieved by non-consideration of their applications
                               for grant of recognition to D.Ed/B.Ed courses purportedly on the
                               ground of the policy decision taken by the Government not to permit
                               establishment of new D.Ed/B.Ed Colleges.

                               At the hearing, Sri Andapalli Sanjeev Kumar, learned counsel
                               appearing for the petitioners in Writ petition Nos.11038, 11040,
                               11587 and 10965 of 2009, and Sri S. Girimoji Rao, learned counsel
                               for the petitioner in Writ petition No.11241 of 2009, submitted that
                               the petitioners filed their applications for recognition prior to the
                               policy decision taken by the State Government; and that in an
                               identical Writ petition, this Court, vide: order dated 16-12-2009 in writ
                               petition No.6712 of 2009, held as under:

                               “It may be true the State Government as well the first respondent
                               have reviewed the situation as to the necessity or otherwise of
                               according permission to establish new colleges of education in the
                               State in further and that the existing institutions are fond to be
                               adequate. However, the right that is accrued to the petitioners on the
                               basis of their application and the consideration there of by the first
                               respondent cannot be taken away on account of the change of
                               policy. It is settled principle of law that whenever an application is
                               made, it must be considered and processed in accordance with the
                               provisions of law or the policy that existed as on the date of
                               presentation. Subsequent changes may apply to the applications
                               that are made thereafter.




     (Gangadharaiah)                                                          (Prof. C. Thangamuthu)
Regional Director, SRC, NCTE                                                   Chairman, SRC, NCTE
                                                  14
                                                                                         st
                                                                              Minutes-201 Meeting of SRC
                                                                                       22-23 February 2011
                               Hence, the writ petition is disposed of directing the first respondent
                               to take necessary steps as contemplated in its communication dated
                               24-11-2009 and pass appropriate orders.
                               There shall be no order as to coasts”.

                               The learned Standing Counsel representing respondents 2 and 3
                               has not disputed the above position.

                               Since the issue raised in these Writ Petitions are squarely covered
                               by the above mentioned orders, these Writ petitions are disposed of
                               in terms of the above mentioned orders in writ petition No.6712 of
                               2009 with the direction that the directions given in the said orders
                               shall form part of this orders.

                               The institution has now submitted D.Ed of 40000/- for processing fee
                               on 30.06.2010. All documents submitted as well as application
                               appears to have been returned on 27.04.2009

                               SRC in its 194th meeting held on 21-22 July 2010 considered the
                               matter and directed the Management/institution to resubmit the old
                               application returned by SRC along with necessary documents as
                               originally submitted relating to land, building, FDR, Application fee,
                               Building Completion Certificate from competent Government
                               Engineer/ authority and other relevant aspects for processing and for
                               necessary action.

                               As per direction of Regional Committee a letter was issued on
                               19.08.2010. In response to this office letter dated 30.08.2010 the
                               institution has submitted reply vide letter dated 03.09.2010.

                               As per perusal of the file the institution has submitted following
                               documents vide letters dated 03.09.10 :-
                               1. Processing fee and application fee (40,000+1,000= 41,000/-)
                                  Application fee of Rs. 1,000/- submitted earlier too)
                               2. Land documents
                               3. BCC Certificate not in prescribed format from Panchyat Secretary
                               4. Land use Certificate by Tahsildar.
                               5. Approved Building Plan by panchyat Secretary
                               6. Original FDR of 5 lakhs and 3 lakhs not submitted.
                               7. Affidavit of Rs 100/- regarding land and building submitted in
                                  photocopy..
                               SRC in its 198th meeting held on 24th –26th November, 2010
                               considered the written explanation to the notice and other
                               documents submitted by the institution and decided to cause
                               inspection of the institution Under Section 14/15 of NCTE Act.

                               Accordingly inspection of the institution was carried out on
                               22.01.2011




     (Gangadharaiah)                                                        (Prof. C. Thangamuthu)
Regional Director, SRC, NCTE                                                 Chairman, SRC, NCTE
                                                 15
                                                                                       st
                                                                            Minutes-201 Meeting of SRC
                                                                                     22-23 February 2011
                               The Committee considered the VT Report, VCD and all the
                               relevant documentary evidences and it was decided to serve
                               Show cause Notice Under Section 17 of NCTE Act for the
                               following :

                                Part of the building is Asbestos roofed in the 1st floor, which
                                 is against NCTE norms; in support of this as per VCD the
                                 hall is covered with false ceiling.
                                As per VCD, students benches/desks carry the marking as
                                 “SMDHS” and the nature and size of Black Boards in calss
                                 room etc., clearly indicate a School is being run in the same
                                 building/premises, which is not permitted as per NCTE
                                 norms.
                                The data sheet has not been filled in the prescribed format.
                                A temporary cloth banner name board is tied to the poles at
                                 the entrance
                                The institution has to submit Notarised Land Usage
                                 Certificate issued by the competent authority.

                               In view of the above, the Committee decided to issue a Show
                               cause Notice to the institution as to why the recognition be not
                               withdrawn and thereby providing an opportunity to the
                               institution to make a written representation within 30 days from
                               the date of issue of the Notice along with necessary
                               certificates/documents in order to take a final decision in the
                               matter; failing which action will be taken including the
                               withdrawal of recognition, based on the records available, with
                               no further notice.
10.        APS09669            An application was submitted by Ushodaya Residential School
             B.Ed              Committee, Guntur District, Andhra Pradesh for grant of recognition
       Palnadu College of      to B.Ed course in the office of SRC-NCTE, vide dated 30.10.2008
       Education, Guntur
              AP               The file was under process and in the meanwhile, in view of the
                               recommendations of the State Government of Andhra Pradesh vide
                               letter dated 07.01.2009 not to further recognise/permit the
                               institutions for conducting B.Ed, D.Ed, Physical Education,
                               Language Pandit course(s).

                               The SRC in its 169th Meeting held on 12-13 January, 2009 having
                               considered the letter dated 07.01.2009 of State Government of
                               Andhra Pradesh and decided to give effect to the above decision of
                               State Government of Andhra Pradesh as such, with immediate
                               effect.

                               A letter dated 07.02.2009 forwarded by Principal Secretary of
                               Education requesting not to accord further recognition/permission to
                               the new colleges/private B.Ed, D.Ed, Physical Education, Language
                               Pandit in the State of Andhra Pradesh as the above colleges are
                               exceeding in numbers than required.




     (Gangadharaiah)                                                       (Prof. C. Thangamuthu)
Regional Director, SRC, NCTE                                                Chairman, SRC, NCTE
                                                16
                                                                                               st
                                                                                   Minutes-201 Meeting of SRC
                                                                                            22-23 February 2011
                               A letter dated 17.03.2009 has been received from NCTE, Hqrs
                               informing that

                               “The recommendations of the Govt. of Andhra Pradesh not to grant
                               recognition/permission in respect of other courses like B.Ed, D.Ed and
                               Physical Education courses have further been decided that no further
                               Recognition/ Permission to any institution in the State of Andhra Pradesh
                               be considered by SRC for the academic session 2009-2010 for B.Ed, D.Ed,
                               and Physical Education courses also”.

                               The State Government vide its letter dated 20.03.2009 informed that
                               it has been decided not to recommend the name of this institution.
                               The letters dated 07.01.2009, 07.02.2009, 17.03.2009 and
                               20.03.2009 was considered by SRC in its 172nd Meeting held on 25-
                               26 March, 2009 and SRC decided to accept the recommendation of
                               the State Government of Andhra Pradesh, not to grant recognition to
                               any of the Teacher Training Institutions in the State of Andhra
                               Pradesh for the year 2009-2010 and decided to close the
                               applications.

                               As per the decision of SRC the application was closed on
                               27.04.2009 and original application and DD for Rs.40000/- to the
                               institution is returned.

                               The Institute has approached to Hon‟ble High Court in
                               W.P.No.21400/2010.
                               Now, the Hon‟ble High Court has passed an order on 27.08.2010 as
                               hereunder:
                               “In the light of he orders passed by this court in similar W.P.Nos.6714 of
                                                                                             st
                               2009, 9360 of 2010, there shall be a direction to the 1 respondent to
                               consider the petitioner‟s application for starting B.Ed., course in accordance
                               with law without reference to the State Government‟s policy dated
                               17.01.2009. Post along with W.P. Nos 6714 of 2009, 9360of 2010 and
                               11078 of 2010”.

                               SRC considered the matter in its 196th Meeting held on 15-16
                               September, 2010 Meeting held on 15-16 September, 2010 meeting
                               and directed the Management/institution to resubmit the old
                               application returned by SRC along with necessary documents as
                               originally submitted relating to land, building, FDR, Application fee,
                               Building Completion Certificate from competent Government
                               Engineer/authority and other relevant aspects for processing and for
                               necessary action.

                               As per direction of Regional Committee a letter was issued on
                               25.10.2010. In response to this office letter dated 25.10.2010 the
                               institution has submitted reply vide letter dated 27.11.2010.

                                       As per perusal of the file the institution has submitted
                               following documents vide letters dated 29.11.2010 :-




     (Gangadharaiah)                                                             (Prof. C. Thangamuthu)
Regional Director, SRC, NCTE                                                      Chairman, SRC, NCTE
                                                   17
                                                                                         st
                                                                              Minutes-201 Meeting of SRC
                                                                                       22-23 February 2011
                                  1. Processing fee and application fee (40,000+1,000= 41,000/-)
                                                                                                  th
                                  2. Land documents-The Deed of Sale is Executed on 25 of
                                      November 2006 for Sy No 158/9A, 158/10B1, 158/11A, 158/12B. in
                                      favour of Ushodaya Residential School Committee, Dachepalli.
                                  3. BCC Certificate from Assistant Engineer. dated 10-11-2008, for Sy
                                      No 158/9A, 158/10B1, 158/11A, 158/12B.Ed, Narayanapuram, Built
                                      up area-17553.5 Sq.ft.
                                  4. Land use Certificate by Tahsildar.
                                  5. Approved Building Plan by Assistant Engineer, for Sy No-158/9A,
                                      158/10B1, 158/11A, 158/12B.Ed, Land area-Ac.1-10guntas, Built
                                      up area-1632.5 Sq.mts.
                                  6. FDR submitted in photo copy original verified.
                                  7. Encumbrance Certificate
                                  8. Bye laws of Society Registration
                                  9. Copy of Affidavit of Rs 100/- Sy No-158/9A, 158/10B1, 158/11A,
                                      158/12B.Ed, Land area-Ac.1-10guntas, Built up area-1632.5
                                      Sq.mts.
                                  10. Copy of Original Application

                               The committee in its 199th meeting held on 23-24 December 2010
                               considered the written explanation to the notice and other
                               documents submitted by the institution and decided to cause
                               inspection. Inspection was conducted on 07.02.2011.

                               The Committee considered the VT Report, VCD and all the
                               relevant documentary evidences and it was decided to serve
                               Show cause Notice Under Section 17 of NCTE Act for the
                               following :

                                As per VCD, it is clear that the part of the building is
                                 Asbestos roofed in the 1st floor, which is against NCTE
                                 norms.
                                As per VCD, ladies toilets, Art & Music rooms are covered
                                 with asbestos roof which is not permitted as per NCTE
                                 norms.
                                As per VCD, plastering walls, internal rooms, front portion is
                                 incomplete.
                                As per VCD, all materials are dumped in the rooms.
                                As per VCD, entrance of ech rooms carry pasted papers
                                 which reads the purpose for which each room is assigned
                                 as temporary arrangement. This should be explained.

                               In view of the above, the Committee decided to issue a Show
                               cause Notice to the institution as to why the recognition be not
                               withdrawn and thereby providing an opportunity to the
                               institution to make a written representation within 30 days from
                               the date of issue of the Notice along with necessary
                               certificates/documents in order to take a final decision in the
                               matter; failing which action will be taken including the
                               withdrawal of recognition, based on the records available, with
                               no further notice.



     (Gangadharaiah)                                                        (Prof. C. Thangamuthu)
Regional Director, SRC, NCTE                                                 Chairman, SRC, NCTE
                                                18
                                                                                        st
                                                                             Minutes-201 Meeting of SRC
                                                                                      22-23 February 2011
11.         APS09473            Shanthinikethan College of Education, Miryalguda, Nalgonda
               D.Ed             District-508207 Andhra Pradesh
      Shanthinikethan College
      of Education, Nalgonda    An application was submitted by Shantinikethan Education Society
                AP              for Women, Nalgonda, A.P for grant of recognition to D.Ed course in
                                the office of SRC-NCTE, Bangalore vide dated 17.04.2008.

                                The file was under process and in the meanwhile, in view of the
                                recommendations of the State Government of Andhra Pradesh vide
                                letter dated 07.01.2009 not to further recognize/permit the
                                institutions for conducting B.Ed, D.Ed, Physical Education,
                                Language Pandit course(s), to this effect that application for B.Ed,
                                D.Ed, Physical Education, Language Pandit courses from the States
                                of Andhra Pradesh will not be considered for the academic session
                                2009-2010 and all such applications shall be returned along with
                                processing fees and documents.
                                The SRC in its 169th meeting held on 12-13th January, 2009 having
                                considered the letter dated 7.1.2009 of State Government of Andhra
                                Pradesh and decided to give effect to the decision of above decision
                                of State Government of Andhra Pradesh as such, with immediate
                                effect.

                                Further, a letter dated 07.02.2009 forwarded by Principal Secretary
                                of Education requesting not to accord further recognition/permission
                                to the new colleges/private B.Ed , D.Ed, Physical Education,
                                Language Pandit in the state of Andhra Pradesh as the above
                                colleges are exceeding in numbers than required.

                                Meanwhile, a letter dated 17.03.2009 has been received from NCTE
                                Hqrs informing that the “ The recommendations of the Govt. of
                                Andhra Pradesh not to grant recognition/ permission in respect of
                                other courses like B.Ed , D.Ed and Physical Education courses have
                                further been considered in NCTE and it has been decided that no
                                further recognition/Permission to any institution in the state of
                                Andhra Pradesh be considered by SRC for the academic session
                                2009-10 for B.Ed , D.Ed and physical Education Courses also”.

                                Further, the state Government vide its letter dated 20.03.2009
                                informed that it has been decided not to recommend the name of this
                                institution.

                                The letters dated 07.01.2009, 07.02.2009, 17.03.2009 and
                                20.03.2009 were considered by SRC in its 172nd meeting held on
                                25th-26th March 2009 and SRC decided to accept the
                                recommendation of the State Government of Andhra Pradesh, not to
                                grant recognition to any of the Teacher Training Institutions in the
                                state of Andhra Pradesh for the year 2009-10 and decided to close
                                the applications.




     (Gangadharaiah)                                                        (Prof. C. Thangamuthu)
Regional Director, SRC, NCTE                                                 Chairman, SRC, NCTE
                                                 19
                                                                                                st
                                                                                     Minutes-201 Meeting of SRC
                                                                                              22-23 February 2011
                               As per the decision of SRC the application was closed on
                               22.04.2009

                               The institution has approached the Hon‟ble High court of Andhra
                               Pradesh W.P.11038/2009 without making appeal to appellate
                               authority under section 18 of NCTE Act

                               The Hon‟ble High Court has passed an order on 23.09.2010 vide
                               W.P.M.P.No.30904 of 2010 in W.P. No. 24142/2010 as under:-
                                 “In the light of the orders passed by this court in the similar writ petitions
                               W.P.No. 6712/2009, W.P.no. 9360/2010 and W.P. no. 11078/2010 there
                               shall be a direction to the first respondent to consider the petitioner‟s
                               application for starting D.Ed course in accordance with law without
                               reference to the state Govt‟s Policy dated 07.01.2009.”

                               The SRC considered the Hon‟ble court orders and all the relevant
                               documents and decided to take further action in the matter, subject
                               to the fulfillment of all the requirements by the institution as per the
                               norms and regulations.

                               As per the decision of SRC a deficiency letter was issued to the
                               institution on 16.11.2010.

                               In reply to the letter dated 16.11.2010 institution submitted its written
                               representation on 30.11.2010.

                               The SRC in its 199th meeting held on 22-23 December 2010
                               considered the matter and all relevant documents and decided to
                               cause inspection to examine whether the institution fulfils all the
                               requirements as per the norms, for the proposed programme,
                               subject to the condition that the deficiencies, if any, were duly
                               rectified by the institution, as per the norms. The inspection was
                               conducted on 07.02.2011.

                               The Committee considered the VT Report, VCD and all the
                               relevant documentary evidences and it was decided to serve
                               Show cause Notice Under Section 17 of NCTE Act for the
                               following :

                                As per VT report, the earmarked Built up area for B.Ed is
                                 16250 sq.ft. forD.Ed is 16250 sq.ft and no earmarked built up
                                 areas for for HPT, TPT are given. The total built up area for
                                 all the four courses is inadequate as per NCTE norms.
                                The institution has to submit VCD with full view of the Front
                                 side of the Building and all the portions of the Bulding.
                                The number of books and journals in the Library are not
                                 sufficient.
                                The details of Fixed deposits for Endowment and Reserve
                                 Fund for B.Ed, TPT, HPT courses is to be provided.




     (Gangadharaiah)                                                               (Prof. C. Thangamuthu)
Regional Director, SRC, NCTE                                                        Chairman, SRC, NCTE
                                                   20
                                                                                       st
                                                                            Minutes-201 Meeting of SRC
                                                                                     22-23 February 2011
                               In view of the above, the Committee decided to issue a Show
                               cause Notice to the institution as to why the recognition be not
                               withdrawn and thereby providing an opportunity to the
                               institution to make a written representation within 30 days from
                               the date of issue of the Notice along with necessary
                               certificates/documents in order to take a final decision in the
                               matter; failing which action will be taken including the
                               withdrawal of recognition, based on the records available, with
                               no further notice.

12.        APS02555            Gayathri College of     Elementary          Teacher      Education,
             D.Ed              Mahabubnagar, Andhra Pradesh
       Gayathri College of
       Elementary Teacher      An application was submitted by Gayathri Educational Society,
           Education,          Mahabubnagar District, Andhra Pradesh for grant of recognition to
         Mahabubnagar          D.Ed course in the office of SRC-NCTE, vide dated 03.02.2004
              AP
                               The file was under process and in the meanwhile, in view of the
                               recommendations of the State Government of Andhra Pradesh vide
                               letter dated 07.01.2009 not to further recognise/permit the
                               institutions for conducting B.Ed, D.Ed, Physical Education,
                               Language Pandit course(s).

                               The SRC in its 169th Meeting held on 12-13 January, 2009 having
                               considered the letter dated 07.01.2009 of State Government of
                               Andhra Pradesh and decided to give effect to the above decision of
                               State Government of Andhra Pradesh as such, with immediate
                               effect.

                               A letter dated 07.02.2009 forwarded by Principal Secretary of
                               Education requesting not to accord further recognition/permission to
                               the new colleges/private B.Ed, D.Ed, Physical Education, Language
                               Pandit in the State of Andhra Pradesh as the above colleges are
                               exceeding in numbers than required.

                               A letter dated 17.03.2009 has been received from NCTE, Hqrs
                               informing that the “The recommendations of the Govt. of Andhra
                               Pradesh not to grant recognition/permission in respect of other
                               courses like B.Ed, D.Ed and Physical Education courses have
                               further been decided that no further Recognition/ Permission to any
                               institution in the State of Andhra Pradesh be considered by SRC for
                               the academic session 2009-2010 for B.Ed, D.Ed, and Physical
                               Education courses also”.




     (Gangadharaiah)                                                       (Prof. C. Thangamuthu)
Regional Director, SRC, NCTE                                                Chairman, SRC, NCTE
                                                21
                                                                                         st
                                                                              Minutes-201 Meeting of SRC
                                                                                       22-23 February 2011
                               The State Government vide its letter dated 20.03.2009 informed that
                               it has been decided not to recommend the name of this institution.
                               The letters dated 07.01.2009, 07.02.2009, 17.03.2009 and
                               20.03.2009 was considered by SRC in its 172nd Meeting held on 25-
                               26 March, 2009 and SRC decided to accept the recommendation of
                               the State Government of Andhra Pradesh, not to grant recognition to
                               any of the Teacher Training Institutions in the State of Andhra
                               Pradesh for the year 2009-2010 and decided to close the
                               applications.

                               As per the decision of SRC the application was closed on
                               29.04.2009

                               The Institute has approached to Hon‟ble High Court in
                               W.P.No.28641 of 2010 without approached to appellate authority.

                               Now, the Hon‟ble High Court has passed an order on 19.11.2010
                               vide W.P.No.28641 of 2010 reads as hereunder:

                               “It may be true that the State Government as well as the first
                               respondent have reviewed the situation as to the necessary or
                               otherwise of according permission to establish new colleges of
                               education in the State in future and that the existing institutions are
                               found to be adequate. However, the right that is accrued to the
                               petitioners on the basis of their application and the consideration
                               thereof by the first respondent cannot be taken away on account of
                               the change of policy. It is settled principle of law that whenever an
                               application is made, it must be considered and processed in
                               accordance with the provisions of law that existed as on the date of
                               presentation. Subsequent changes may apply to the applications
                               that are made thereafter.

                               Hence, the writ petition is also disposed of reiterating the same
                               directions as noticed supra. No costs.”

                               The institution was caused inspection by SRC on 29.04.2005. A
                               deficiency letter dated 01.10.2008 was also issued and the institution
                               replied on 20.01.2009.

                               Again a letter dated 09.01.2009 to institution was issued for
                               submitting the following documents, which were submitted on
                               28.01.2009.
                                  1. Affidavit dated 21.09.2009
                                  2. Copy of Building Completion certificate (26,000 Sq.ft signed by
                                     Government Engineer) for S.No. 261/2 Tadiparthy, Andhra
                                     Pradesh.
                                  3. Copy of Land usage certificate from Tasildhar.




     (Gangadharaiah)                                                         (Prof. C. Thangamuthu)
Regional Director, SRC, NCTE                                                  Chairman, SRC, NCTE
                                                 22
                                                                                          st
                                                                              Minutes-201 Meeting of SRC
                                                                                       22-23 February 2011
                               Apart from this the institution has submitted photo copies of FDR‟s of
                               Rs.5 lakhs and Rs.3 lakhs

                               In the mean while, in view of the recommendations of the State
                               Government of Andhra Pradesh vide letter dated 07.01.2009 not to
                               further recognize/permit the institutions for conducting B.Ed, D.Ed,
                               Physical Education, Language Pandit course(s) SRC decided to
                               close the file vide order dated 29.04.2009.

                               The SRC in its 199th meeting held on 22-23 December 2010
                               considered the Hon‟ble court orders and all the relevant documents
                               by the institution and decided to cause inspection at the premises as
                               the earlier visit was more than five year old dated 29.4.2005.The
                               institution is directed to submit the following within 30 days of the
                               receipt of the notice, all the necessary documents for land, building
                               approval and completion certificate from a competent Govt. Engineer
                               and other relevant documents along with Demand Draft of
                               Rs.40,000/- inspection fee towards the B.Ed course in favour of “The
                               Member Secretary, NCTE” payable at Bangalore, for due
                               consideration and necessary orders. The inspection was conducted
                               on 10.02.2011.

                               The management         is   running   B.Ed   course   in    the   same
                               building/premises.

                               The Committee considered the VT Report, VCD and all the
                               relevant documentary evidences and it was decided to serve
                               Show cause Notice Under Section 17 of NCTE Act for the
                               following :

                                The Building is incomplete, construction is in progress in II
                                 Floor.
                                The earmarked built up area for D.Ed is only 10,000 sq.ft
                                 which is inadequate. Built up area required as per NCTE
                                 norms is 1500 sq.mts.
                                The number of Journals subscribed is 02 which is not
                                 sufficient.
                                The Science Lab is to be strengthened.
                                Staff is paid consolidated pay instead of pay scale of
                                 Central/State Government/UGC guidelines.

                               In view of the above, the Committee decided to issue a Show
                               cause Notice to the institution as to why the recognition be not
                               withdrawn and thereby providing an opportunity to the
                               institution to make a written representation within 30 days from
                               the date of issue of the Notice along with necessary
                               certificates/documents in order to take a final decision in the
                               matter; failing which action will be taken including the
                               withdrawal of recognition, based on the records available, with
                               no further notice.



     (Gangadharaiah)                                                        (Prof. C. Thangamuthu)
Regional Director, SRC, NCTE                                                 Chairman, SRC, NCTE
                                                 23
                                                                                               st
                                                                                   Minutes-201 Meeting of SRC
                                                                                            22-23 February 2011
13.       APS03213             Navodaya College of Education, Near Housing Board,
            D.Ed               Nagarkurnool-109209,       Dist-Mahabubnagar, Andhra
      Navodaya College of      Pradesh.Course- D.Ed. (Code no. APS03213)
          Education,
        Mahabubnagar           Navodaya College of Education, Mahabubnagar District-509209,
             AP                Andhra Pradesh has submitted application for D.Ed on 30.01.2004.
                               The application was closed vide order dated 29.04.2009 in view of
                               State ban endorsed by NCTE, Hqrs.

                               The institution has moved to Hon‟ble High Court of Andhra Pradesh
                               in W.P.11930 of 2009 and judgement dated 14.12.2010 reads as
                               follows:
                                                                                               st
                               “It may be true that the State Government as well as the 1 respondent
                               have reviewed the situation as to the necessity or otherwise of according
                               permission to establish new colleges of education in the State in future and
                               that the existing institutions are found to be adequate. However, the right
                               that is accrued to the petitioners on the basis of their applications and the
                                                                   st
                               consideration therefore by the 1 respondent cannot be taken away on
                               account of the changes of policy. It is settled principal of law that whatever
                               an application is made, it must be considered and processed in accordance
                               with the provision of law or the policy that existed as on the date of
                               presentation. Subsequent changes may apply to the applications that are
                               made thereafter.

                               Hence, the writ petition is disposed of directing the first respondent to take
                               necessary steps as contemplated in its communication…… and pass
                               appropriate orders……….”

                               Now, the institution has submitted a letter dated 20.12.2010 along
                               with the following documents :
                               1.    Judgement in W.P. 11930 of l2010 dated 14.12.2010.
                               2.    Sale Deed along with notarized English version.
                               3.    Application Form
                               4.    Land Usage certificate
                               5.    Land Conversation certificate
                               6.    Building Completion Certificate
                               7.    Copy of FDR of 5+3 Lakhs
                               8.    Rejected order copy dated 29.01.2009.
                               9.    Building plan
                               10.   Affidavit
                               11.   Deficiency letter dated 09.01.2009
                               12.   Reply to Deficiency letter dt.17.01.2009

                               Hence, the institution has requested SRC, NCTE to issue
                               Recognition order for D.Ed course as per court order and directions.

                               SRC in its 199th meeting held on 22nd –23rd December 2010,
                               considered the written explanation to the notice and other
                               documents submitted by the institution and decided to cause
                               inspection. Accordingly, inspection of the institution was carried out
                               on VTR dated 09.02.2011.




     (Gangadharaiah)                                                             (Prof. C. Thangamuthu)
Regional Director, SRC, NCTE                                                      Chairman, SRC, NCTE
                                                   24
                                                                                       st
                                                                            Minutes-201 Meeting of SRC
                                                                                     22-23 February 2011
                               The management is running B.Ed course with an intake of 120
                               seats.

                               The Committee considered the VT Report, VCD and all the
                               relevant documentary evidences and it was decided to serve
                               Show cause Notice Under Section 17 of NCTE Act for the
                               following :

                                As per VCD, Building is incomplete and the construction is
                                 still going on.
                                As per VT report, the earmarked built up area for B.Ed is
                                 16140 sq.ft and for D.Ed is 12890 sq.ft. The total built up
                                 area is 29030 sq.sft. which is inadequate. The built up area
                                 of 32000 sq.ft is required as petitioner NCTE norms.
                                As per VCD, Classrooms, stairs, varanda’s and lobby area
                                 look very dirty and appears got damaged due to fire. This
                                 may be explained.
                                A fire safety certificate from competent Government
                                 authority should be produced.
                                Staff are paid consolidated pay instead of pay scale of
                                 Central/State Government/UGC guidelines.

                               In view of the above, the Committee decided to issue a Show
                               cause Notice to the institution as to why the recognition be not
                               withdrawn and thereby providing an opportunity to the
                               institution to make a written representation within 30 days from
                               the date of issue of the Notice along with necessary
                               certificates/documents in order to take a final decision in the
                               matter; failing which action will be taken including the
                               withdrawal of recognition, based on the records available, with
                               no further notice.

14.        APS09117            S.V.R College of Elementary Teacher Education, Bhargavi
              D.Ed             Educational Society, No.6-31/2, Madhira, Khammam-507203,
         SVR College of        Andhra Pradesh Course- D.Ed. (Code no. APS09117)
       Elementary Teacher
      Education, Khammam       An application was submitted by Bhargavi Educational Society,
               AP              Khammam, A.P for grant of recognition to D.Ed course in the office
                               of SRC-NCTE, Bangalore vide dated 19.11.2007. The consent letter
                               was issued to the institution as per NCTE Regulation 2007 vide
                               dated 26.09.2008 directing to give consent for inspection alongwith
                               as self attested copy of the completion certificate of building for
                               which affidavit, building plan and land documents were submitted.
                               The Institution submitted its reply consent letter dated 06.10.2008.




     (Gangadharaiah)                                                       (Prof. C. Thangamuthu)
Regional Director, SRC, NCTE                                                Chairman, SRC, NCTE
                                                25
                                                                                       st
                                                                            Minutes-201 Meeting of SRC
                                                                                     22-23 February 2011
                               The file was under process and in the meanwhile, in view of the
                               recommendations of the State Government of Andhra Pradesh vide
                               letter dated 07.01.2009 not to further recognize/permit the
                               institutions for conducting B.Ed, D.Ed, Physical Education,
                               Language Pandit course(s), to this effect that application for B.Ed,
                               D.Ed, Physical Education, Language Pandit courses from the States
                               of Andhra Pradesh will not be considered for the academic session
                               2009-2010 and all such applications shall be returned along with
                               processing fees and documents.

                               The SRC in its 169th meeting held on 12-13th January, 2009 having
                               considered the letter dated 7.1.2009 of State Government of Andhra
                               Pradesh and decided to give effect to the decision of above decision
                               of State Government of Andhra Pradesh as such, with immediate
                               effect.

                               Further, a letter dated 07.02.2009 forwarded by Principal Secretary
                               of Education requesting not to accord further recognition/permission
                               to the new colleges/private B.Ed , D.Ed, Physical Education,
                               Language Pandit in the state of Andhra Pradesh as the above
                               colleges are exceeding in numbers than required.

                               Meanwhile, a letter dated 17.03.2009 has been received from NCTE
                               Hqrs informing that the “ The recommendations of the Govt. of
                               Andhra Pradesh not to grant recognition/ permission in respect of
                               other courses like B.Ed , D.Ed and Physical Education courses have
                               further been considered in NCTE and it has been decided that no
                               further recognition/Permission to any institution in the state of
                               Andhra Pradesh be considered by SRC for the academic session
                               2009-10 for B.Ed , D.Ed and physical Education Courses also”.

                               Further, the state Government vide its letter dated 20.03.2009
                               informed that it has been decided not to recommend the name of this
                               institution.

                               The letters dated 07.01.2009, 07.02.2009, 17.03.2009 and
                               20.03.2009 were considered by SRC in its 172nd meeting held on
                               25th-26th March 2009 and SRC decided to accept the
                               recommendation of the State Government of Andhra Pradesh, not to
                               grant recognition to any of the Teacher Training Institutions in the
                               state of Andhra Pradesh for the year 2009-10 and decided to close
                               the applications.

                               As per the decision of SRC the application was closed on
                               17.05.2009

                               The institution has approached to Hon‟ble High court of Andhra
                               Pradesh W.P.31046/2010 in W.P. No. 24265/2010 without making
                               appeal to appellate authority under section 18 of NCTE Act




     (Gangadharaiah)                                                       (Prof. C. Thangamuthu)
Regional Director, SRC, NCTE                                                Chairman, SRC, NCTE
                                                26
                                                                                           st
                                                                                Minutes-201 Meeting of SRC
                                                                                         22-23 February 2011
                               The Hon‟ble High Court has passed an order on 29.09.2010 vide
                               W.P.M.P.No.31046 of 2010 in W.P. No. 24265/2010 as under:-

                                 “In the light to consider the order passed by this court in the similar
                               writ petitions w.p.No. 6712/2009, w.p.no. 9360/2010 and w.p. no.
                               11078/2010 there shall be a direction to the first respondent to
                               consider the petitioner‟s application for starting D.Ed course in
                               accordance with law without reference to the state Govt‟s Policy
                               dated 07.01.2009.”

                               The matter was placed in 197th meeting of SRC held on 13th – 14th
                               ocy, 2010, wherein the SRC decided to Re-submit the application for
                               continuation. As per direction of SRC a letter was sent to the
                               institution on 19.10.10 with request to submit original form alongwith
                               land use certificate, BCC, Application fee, land documents and other
                               relevant documents.

                               The SRC considered the Hon‟ble court orders and all the relevant
                               documents and decided to take further action in the matter, subject
                               to the fulfillment of all the requirements by the institution as per the
                               norms and regulations.

                               The following deficiencies has been submitted by the institution on
                               letter dated 01.12.2010.
                               1. FDR of Rs 5.00 lakh submitted in original
                               2. FDR of Rs 3.00 lakh submitted in original
                               3. BCC in the prescribed proforma duly signed by the local civil
                                    authority.
                               4. Further, the land use certificate Dt. 18.2.2009 is to be notarized.
                               5. Notarized English version copy of registered land document is to
                                    be submitted.

                               SRC in its 199th meeting held on 22nd –23rd December, 2010
                               considered the matter and all relevant documents and decided to
                               cause inspection to examine whether the institution fulfils all the
                               requirements as per the norms, for the proposed programme,
                               subject to the condition that the deficiencies, if any, were duly
                               rectified by the institution, as per the norms.

                               FDRs returned after the verification and attested English version of
                               land documents submitted with original Building Completion
                               Certificate.

                               Accordingly inspection of the institution was carried out on VTR
                               dated 10.02.2011




     (Gangadharaiah)                                                          (Prof. C. Thangamuthu)
Regional Director, SRC, NCTE                                                   Chairman, SRC, NCTE
                                                  27
                                                                                              st
                                                                                   Minutes-201 Meeting of SRC
                                                                                            22-23 February 2011
                                  The Committee considered the VT Report, VCD and all the
                                  relevant documentary evidences and it was decided to serve
                                  Show cause Notice Under Section 17 of NCTE Act for the
                                  following :

                                   A School is being run in the same building, in which teacher
                                    education programe is conducted, which is not permitted as
                                    per NCTE norms.
                                   The questionnaire submitted by the institution is incomplete
                                    and all the columns are to be filled up which are mandatory.
                                   Science Lab is to be strengthened.
                                   Management is not paying salaries as per Central/State
                                    Government/UGC guidelines.
                                   It is clear from VCD, that a part of the ceiling is covered with
                                    False Ceiling and partly asbestos roofed.
                                   The building consists of three floors and is still under
                                    construction.

                                  In view of the above, the Committee decided to issue a Show
                                  cause Notice to the institution as to why the recognition be not
                                  withdrawn and thereby providing an opportunity to the
                                  institution to make a written representation within 30 days from
                                  the date of issue of the Notice along with necessary
                                  certificates/documents in order to take a final decision in the
                                  matter; failing which action will be taken including the
                                  withdrawal of recognition, based on the records available, with
                                  no further notice.

15.          APS04545             Jairupa Teacher Training Institute, Erode Dt., Tamilnadu was
             D.T.Ed-AI            granted recognition by SRC-NCTE for conducting D.T.Ed-AI course
         Jai Rupa Teacher         with an annual intake of 100 students from the academic session
      Training Institute, Erode   2006-2007 vide order dated 09th September 2006.
                 TN
                                  Based on the Inquiry Report Submitted by Sri. Sathyam, IAS (Retd)
                                  the inspection of the institution was carried out on 16.12.2008. The
                                  report was considered by SRC in its 116th meeting held on 12th-13th
                                  January 2009 and decided to issue show cause notice. Accordingly
                                  a Show Cause Notice u/s 17 was issued on the institution on
                                  05.08.2009.

                                  SRC considered the reply to the Show Cause Notice submitted by
                                  the institution on 08.05.2009 in its 166th meeting held on 18th-19th
                                  October 2008. SRC vide its letter dated 3.9.2009 decided to conduct
                                  inspection for shifting of premises to permanent building after
                                  submission of the following documents for shifting of Premises:
                                  1. Demand Draft of Rs.40,000/- towards inspection fee in favour of “The
                                     Member Secretary, NCTE” payable at Bangalore should be submitted.
                                  2. Land documents of the new building/ location for having own land in the
                                     name of the institution/ Society/ Trust.




     (Gangadharaiah)                                                              (Prof. C. Thangamuthu)
Regional Director, SRC, NCTE                                                       Chairman, SRC, NCTE
                                                     28
                                                                                               st
                                                                                   Minutes-201 Meeting of SRC
                                                                                            22-23 February 2011
                               3. Building Plan of the new building duly approved by the Government
                                  authority.
                               4. Building Completion Certificate from the Government authorities in the
                                  prescribed format
                               5. Land Usage Certificate from the concerned Government authorities
                                  stating that the land is exclusively permitted/ sanctioned for Educational
                                  Purposes only should be submitted.
                               6. Encumbrance certificate from the competent Government authority
                                  authority should be submitted.
                               7. Fixed Deposit Receipt of Rs.5 lakhs towards Endowment Fund and
                                  Rs.3 lakhs towards Reserve Fund kept in JOINT ACCOUNT for a
                                  period of 5 years ORIGINAL should be submitted.
                               8. Certificate of Registration/ Bye-law of the Society/ Trust should be
                                  submitted.
                               9. The Affidavit in Rs.100/- stamp paper in the prescribed format with
                                  Notary attestation should be submitted.

                               Accordingly, as per the decision of SRC, a letter was issued on
                               08.09.2009. The institution vide letter dated 22.09.2009 submitted a
                               copy of order in W.P. No. 19143 of 2009 and the Hon'ble High Court
                               of Madras vide its order dated 17th September 09 made the following
                               order: -
                               “Interim Stay and Notice”.

                               The matter is placed before SRC along with a copy of the order
                               passed by the Hon'ble Court and also the copy of representation
                               submitted by the institution for perusal and direction.

                               SRC considered the above matter in its 184th meeting held on 26-
                               27th October 2009 and it has been decided to get the stay vacated
                               and arrange for Inspection under Section 17 of NCTE Act, within four
                               weeks since the date of confirmation of the Minutes.

                               In obedience to the direction of SRC, a letter was issued to the
                               advocate requested to vacate the stay on 28.5.2010 followed by
                               reminder on 27.7.2010.

                               A court order in W.P. no. 19143 of 2009 filed by Jairupa TTI has
                               been received from the Hon‟ble High Court of Madras on
                               15.11.2010.

                               The Hon‟ble court has ordered as follows ”…The Southern Regional
                               Committee, NCTE, Bangalore is empowered to cause re-inspection to
                               ascertain the details made in the written representation of the institute. For
                               causing inspection, necessarily, the institute has to bear the inspection
                               charges.”

                               The court order was placed before SRC in its 198th meeting held on
                               24th-26th November 2010 and it was decided to cause inspection of
                               the institution under section 17 of NCTE Act on payment of
                               Rs.40,000/- inspection fee and on submission of filled in
                               Questionnaire, along with relevant supporting documents relating to



     (Gangadharaiah)                                                             (Prof. C. Thangamuthu)
Regional Director, SRC, NCTE                                                      Chairman, SRC, NCTE
                                                   29
                                                                                         st
                                                                              Minutes-201 Meeting of SRC
                                                                                       22-23 February 2011
                               building, land, including Building Completion Certificate from the
                               competent Government Engineer, Land Use Certificate, FDRs of Rs.
                               5 lakhs and 3 lakhs for a period of 5 years from a Nationalised Bank,
                               Certificate of Registration/Bye-laws of the society/trust, Affidavit in
                               Rs.100/- stamp paper in the prescribed format with notary attestation
                               etc., within four weeks from the date of confirmation of the Minutes.

                               As per the decision of SRC, a letter was issued to the institution on
                               6.1.2011. The institution has instead of replying filed the present
                               Appeal in W.A.SR.No.5954/11(copy enclosed). They have requested
                               for postponement of the inspection till the disposal of the appeal.

                               The management is running D.T.Ed, B.Ed and M.Ed courses in the
                               same building.

                               Meanwhile the inspection of the institution was carried out on
                               15.02.2011 under section 17 of NCTE Act

                               The Committee considered the VT Report, VCD and all the
                               relevant documentary evidences and it was decided to serve
                               Show cause Notice Under Section 17 of NCTE Act for the
                               following :

                                The built up area as per Building Plan and Affidavit is 38518
                                 sq.ft and as per VT report the built up area is 49405 sq.ft.
                                 This discrepency in built up area may be explained.
                                Earmarked built up area for each of the programme is to be
                                 given, floorwise.
                                As per VCD, the first floor of the building is still under
                                 construction.
                                As pr VCD, multipurpose hall is temporarily converted into
                                 B.Ed class room II, which is against NCTE norms.
                                The number of non-teaching staff for the existing teacher
                                 education programme in position is four only, which is
                                 inadequate as per NCTE norms.
                                Details of Fixed Deposits of Endowment and Reserve Fund
                                 for each course should be given.

                               In view of the above, the Committee decided to issue a Show
                               cause Notice to the institution as to why the recognition be not
                               withdrawn and thereby providing an opportunity to the
                               institution to make a written representation within 30 days from
                               the date of issue of the Notice along with necessary
                               certificates/documents in order to take a final decision in the
                               matter; failing which action will be taken including the
                               withdrawal of recognition, based on the records available, with
                               no further notice.




     (Gangadharaiah)                                                         (Prof. C. Thangamuthu)
Regional Director, SRC, NCTE                                                  Chairman, SRC, NCTE
                                                 30
                                                                                           st
                                                                                Minutes-201 Meeting of SRC
                                                                                         22-23 February 2011
16.         APS02800           Ankala Reddy Memorial Teacher Training Course, Kurnool-518543,
              D.Ed             Andhra Pradesh has submitted application for D.Ed course on
      Ankala Reddy Memorial    30.01.2004.
         Teacher Training
         Course, Kurnool       Inspection was done on 30.05.2005 (file – page no.90).
               AP
                               Application was under process and meanwhile, the Government of
                               Andhra Pradesh of Hyderabad filed a Writ Petition No.22866 of 2005
                               in the Hon‟ble High Court of Andhra Pradesh of Hyderabad
                               challenging the Notification of NCTE with regard to the dispensing
                               with the requirement of NOC from the State Government. The writ
                               petition was allowed by the learned single judge with the directions
                               that the rule excluding the State Government is bad. Against said
                               judgment a Writ Appeal No.692 of 2006 was filed in the Division
                               Bench of Hon‟ble High Court of Hyderabad. Many discussions took
                               place between the State Government of Andhra Pradesh and SRC-
                               NCTE. However, neither State Government withdrew the case filed
                               by them nor the stay has been vacated.

                               Some institutions went to the court and filed writ petitions individually
                               seeking directions for processing of their applications, in one of such
                               Writ Petition No.8278 of 2008. The Hon‟ble High Court decided that
                               the applications of the institutions shall be processed as per the
                               NCTE rules and regulations norms and standards existing as on
                               date.

                               As per the direction of Hon‟ble High Court and decision of SRC for
                               processing of pending D.Ed application as per new regulation of
                               NCTE in its 164th meeting held on 20th September 2008, the SRC
                               started to process the applications.

                               In view of the above decision, a reminder letter was issued to the
                               institution vide dated 02.01.2009. the institution submitted its reply
                               on 10.01.2009 and file was under process and in the meanwhile, in
                               view of the recommendations of the State Government of Andhra
                               Pradesh vide letter dated 07.01.2009 not to further recognize/permit
                               the institutions for conducting B.Ed, D.Ed, Physical Education,
                               Language Pandit Course. SRC in its 169th meeting held on 12-13th
                               January, 2009 having considered the letter dated 07.01.2009 of
                               State Government of Andhra Pradesh as such, with immediate
                               effect.

                               A letter dated 07.02.2009 forwarded by Principal Secretary of
                               Education requesting not to accord further recognition/permission to
                               the new colleges/private B.Ed, D.Ed, Physical Education, Language
                               Pandit in the state of Andhra Pradesh as the above colleges are
                               exceeding in numbers than required.




     (Gangadharaiah)                                                          (Prof. C. Thangamuthu)
Regional Director, SRC, NCTE                                                   Chairman, SRC, NCTE
                                                  31
                                                                                          st
                                                                               Minutes-201 Meeting of SRC
                                                                                        22-23 February 2011
                               A letter dated 17th March, 2009 has been received from NCTE Hqrs.
                               informing that the “the recommendations of the Govt. of Andhra
                               Pradesh not to grant recognition/permission in respect of other
                               courses like B.Ed, D.Ed and Physical Education courses have
                               further been considered in NCTE and it has been decided that no
                               further recognition/Permission to any institution in the State of
                               Andhra Pradesh be considered by SRC for the academic session
                               2009-10 for B.Ed, D.Ed and Physical Education Courses also.

                               The State Government vide its letter dated 20.03.2009 informed that
                               it has been decided not to recommend the name of your institution.

                               The letters dated 07.01.2009, 07.02.2009, 17.03.2009 and
                               20.03.2009 were considered by SRC in its 172nd meeting held on
                               25th – 26th March, 2009 and SRC decided to accept the
                               recommendation of the State Government of Andhra Pradesh, not to
                               grant recognition to any of the Teacher Training Institutions in the
                               State of Andhra Pradesh for the year 2009-2010 and decided to
                               close the applications.

                               Accordingly, a closing letter was issued to the institution on
                               29.04.2009.

                               Further, the institution has approached Hon‟ble High Court of Andhra
                               Pradesh in W.P.No.17026 of 2010. The court has passed order
                               dated 16.07.2010:
                               “in the light of the orders passed by this Court in the similar writ
                               petitions W.P. No. 6712 of 2009, W.P. No.9360 of 2010 and W.P.
                               No.11078 o 2010, there shall be a direction to the first respondent to
                               consider the petitioner‟s application for starting D.Ed, course in
                               accordance with law without reference to the State Government‟s
                               policy dated 07.01.2009.

                               The committee considered the matter and decided to process the
                               application, on receipt of Application fee and other relevant
                               documents as per the court orders under intimation to the institution.
                               As per decision of Regional Committee a letter was sent to the
                               institution on 27.09.10 with request to submit documents. As per
                               perusal of file the institution has submitted following documents.
                                  Affidavit of Rs. 100/- regarding land - submitted Dt. 22.10.2010.
                                  FDR of Rs. 5 lakhs towards endowment fund – submitted.
                                  FDR of Rs. 3 lakhs towards reserved fund – submitted.
                                  Application fee of Rs. 40.000/- Not submitted.
                                  Land documents, sale deed and building plan, BCC & LUC – Submitted,
                                   the total extent of land is 3.33 + 3.33 = 6.66 (total 5.00 Acres).
                               Institution has submitted a letter dt. 17.11.2010, in this letter the
                               institution has stated that the application submitted on 30.01.2004 to
                               NCTE and still to make decision in SRC meeting after considering
                               inspection report and hence the question of payment of Rs. 40.000/-




     (Gangadharaiah)                                                         (Prof. C. Thangamuthu)
Regional Director, SRC, NCTE                                                  Chairman, SRC, NCTE
                                                  32
                                                                                          st
                                                                               Minutes-201 Meeting of SRC
                                                                                        22-23 February 2011
                               towards application form fees does not arise and there is no need of
                               any inspection since it is a old application.
                               The Committee in its 198th meeting held on 24-26 November 2010
                               considered the matter and decided to cause inspection subject to the
                               condition that the institution has submitted all the necessary
                               documents and the inspection fee and also has rectified the
                               deficiencies, if any as per the norms.

                               As per the decision of SRC inspection team reached the college on
                               24.01.2011.

                               Institution requested for cancellation of inspection and submitted a
                               letter on 03.01.2011 (copy enclosed)

                               The institution has informed that “the Hon‟ble High Court clearly
                               given its judgment stating that to consider petitioner‟s application for
                               starting D.Ed course. Even the NCTE letter vide reference at one
                               above asking the management to comply with fulfillment of
                               deficiencies under section 14 of the NCTE act.

                               The management has also requested to consider previous
                               inspection report and subsequent compliance reports regarding
                               fulfillment of all deficiencies and grant recognition to Ankala Reddy
                               D.Ed College Allagadda, Kurnool District, Andhra Pradesh without
                               any second inspection even though it is already very high time and
                               oblige.

                               The Committee considered the VT Report, VCD and all the
                               relevant documentary evidences and it was decided to cause
                               re-inspection as the request can be considered only after a
                               fresh visit, as the earlier visit was done more than six years
                               before. The visit is needed to know the present status of the
                               infrastructural & instructional facilities of the institution .

                                The institution is not within its right to seek exemption from
                                 inspection as the application is more than seven year old
                                 and that there is no guarantee that the same land/infra-
                                 structure would remain in the same condition during the last
                                 seven year period.
                                It is far-fetched for the institution to misinterpret the court
                                 orders as if the court was against the inspection of the
                                 seven-year old applicant-institution. The court only directed
                                 to consider the application “in accordance with law”.
                                It is impertiment on the part of the institution to have
                                 disallowed the VT (which had reached the institution), from
                                 discharging its official responsibilities of inspection.
                                The institution be required to remit another inspection fee of
                                 Rs.40,000/- to enable the SRC to consider the case, under
                                 the conditions explained above.




     (Gangadharaiah)                                                         (Prof. C. Thangamuthu)
Regional Director, SRC, NCTE                                                  Chairman, SRC, NCTE
                                                 33
                                                                                          st
                                                                               Minutes-201 Meeting of SRC
                                                                                        22-23 February 2011


Inspection Report – Shifting Cases:

17.          APS00664          St. Francis Assisi Teacher Training Institute, Arthunkal P.O.
                TTI            Cherthala, Alappuzha District-688530, Kerala has made an
        St. Francis Assisi     application for Elementary(TTI) course to Southern Regional
         Teacher Training      Committee, NCTE, Bangalore on 30.12.2002.
       Institute, Alappuzha
                 KL            The application was processed and after considering the report of
                               the Visiting Team as well as other relevant materials granted
                               recognition to the institution for offering TTI course with an intake of
                               50 students from the session 2004-2005 vide order No.4440 dated
                               02.07.2004.

                               The institution in its letter dated 07.09.2007 has submitted proposal
                               for shifting the TTC course to the new location along with inspection
                               fees of Rs.40,000/-. Accordingly, inspection was carried out on
                               25.01.2011.

                               The Committee considered the VT Report, VCD and all the
                               relevant documentary evidences and it was decided to serve
                               Show cause Notice for shifting of premises Under Section 17 of
                               NCTE Act for the following :

                                As per VCD, it is seen that Tin sheet / Asbestos sheets are
                                 used to roof the top floor of the building which is not
                                 permissible as per NCTE norms.
                                Affidavit on Rs.100/- not submitted.
                                Building     Completion     Certificate  from    competent
                                 Government Engineer in the prescribed format not
                                 submitted.
                                Land Use Certificate not submitted.
                                Encumbrnce Certificate from competent Government
                                 authority not submitted.
                                Byelaws of the Society/Registration copy of the society not
                                 submitted.

                               In view of the above, the Committee decided to issue a Show
                               cause Notice to the institution as to why the recognition be not
                               withdrawn and thereby providing an opportunity to the
                               institution to make a written representation within 30 days from
                               the date of issue of the Notice along with necessary
                               certificates/documents in order to take a final decision in the
                               matter; failing which action will be taken including the
                               withdrawal of recognition, based on the records available, with
                               no further notice.




     (Gangadharaiah)                                                         (Prof. C. Thangamuthu)
Regional Director, SRC, NCTE                                                  Chairman, SRC, NCTE
                                                 34
                                                                                          st
                                                                               Minutes-201 Meeting of SRC
                                                                                        22-23 February 2011
18.        APS01045            National Teacher Training Institute, 13/63, Iqbal Square, Vengola,
               TTI             Perumbavoor, Ernakulam-683554, Kerala has made an application
        National Teacher       for TTI course to Southern Regional Committee, NCTE, Bangalore
        Training Institute,    on 31.12.2002.
           Ernakulam
               KL              The application was processed and after considering the report of
                               the Visiting Team as well as other relevant materials granted
                               recognition to the institution for offering TTI course with an intake of
                               50 students from the session 2004-2005 vide order No.9233 dated
                               09.12.2004.

                               The institution in its letter dated NIL has submitted proposal for
                               shifting the TTC course to the new location along with inspection
                               fees of Rs.40,000/-. Accordingly, inspection was carried out on
                               25.01.2011.

                               The management is also runing B.Ed, M.Ed programmes in the
                               same building.

                               The Committee considered the VT Report, VCD and all the
                               relevant documentary evidences and it was decided to serve
                               Show cause Notice for shifting of premises Under Section 17 of
                               NCTE Act for the following :

                                As per VCD the building is still under construction and
                                 incomplete.
                                A School is being run in the same Building/campus in which
                                 teacher education programme is run, which is not
                                 permissible as per NCTE Regulations.
                                As per VT report the earmarked built up area for TTI course
                                 is 6199 sq.ft. which is far inadequate for running the course;
                                 as per NCTE norms, 16,000 sq.ft is required.

                               In view of the above, the Committee decided to issue a Show
                               cause Notice to the institution as to why the recognition be not
                               withdrawn and thereby providing an opportunity to the
                               institution to make a written representation within 30 days from
                               the date of issue of the Notice along with necessary
                               certificates/documents in order to take a final decision in the
                               matter; failing which action will be taken including the
                               withdrawal of recognition, based on the records available, with
                               no further notice.




     (Gangadharaiah)                                                         (Prof. C. Thangamuthu)
Regional Director, SRC, NCTE                                                  Chairman, SRC, NCTE
                                                 35
                                                                                          st
                                                                               Minutes-201 Meeting of SRC
                                                                                        22-23 February 2011
19.        APS01088            Valummel Teacher Training Institute, Sulthan Bathery, Moolankave
               TTI             Post, Wayanad District- 673592, Kerala has made an application for
       Valummel Teacher        TTI course to Southern Regional Committee, NCTE, Bangalore on
        Training Institute,    31.12.2002.
            Wayanad
               KL              The application was processed and after considering the report of
                               the Visiting Team as well as other relevant materials granted
                               recognition to the institution for offering TTI course with an intake of
                               50 students from the session 2004-2005 vide order No.4442 dated
                               02.07.2004.

                               The institution in its letter dated 18.09.2007 has submitted proposal
                               for shifting the TTC course to the new location along with inspection
                               fees of Rs.40,000/-. Accordingly, inspection was carried out on
                               27.01.2011.

                               The Committee considered the VT Report, VCD and all the
                               relevant documentary evidences and it was decided to serve
                               Show cause Notice for shifting of premises Under Section 17 of
                               NCTE Act for the following :

                                Land Usage Certificate from the competent authortity not
                                 submitted.
                                Fixed Deposit Receipts of Rs.5.00 lakhs towards
                                 Endowment Fund and Rs.3.00 lakhs towards Reserve Fund
                                 are from private Bank. The FDRs are to be deposited in the
                                 Nationalised Bank for a duration of 5 years in joint account.
                                Encumbrance Certificate from Government authorised
                                 authority not submitted.

                               In view of the above, the Committee decided to issue a Show
                               cause Notice to the institution as to why the recognition be not
                               withdrawn and thereby providing an opportunity to the
                               institution to make a written representation within 30 days from
                               the date of issue of the Notice along with necessary
                               certificates/documents in order to take a final decision in the
                               matter; failing which action will be taken including the
                               withdrawal of recognition, based on the records available, with
                               no further notice.




     (Gangadharaiah)                                                         (Prof. C. Thangamuthu)
Regional Director, SRC, NCTE                                                  Chairman, SRC, NCTE
                                                 36
                                                                                           st
                                                                                Minutes-201 Meeting of SRC
                                                                                         22-23 February 2011
20.         APS01393              St. Peters Teacher Training Institute, Dharmapuri District, TN
            APS03789
              D.T.Ed              St. Peter‟s Educational Trust, Salem submitted an application in the
             D.T.Ed-AI            name and style of St.Peter‟s Teacher Training Institute, Dharmapuri
        St. Peters Teacher        District, Tamilnadu for seeking grant of recognition for D.T.Ed-AI
        Training Institute,       course on 31.12.2004.
            Dharmapuri
                TN                The application was processed and the inspection of the institution
                                  was carried out on 25.10.2005. Recognition order was issued to the
                                  institution on 17.11.2005 at St. Peter‟s Teacher Training Institute,
                                  No.216, Salem Main Road, Bommidi, Dhramapuri District-635301,
                                  Tamilnadu with the condition to shift to own premises within 3 years.

                                  The institution vide letter dated 05.10.2007 submitted Rs.40000/- for
                                  change of address St. Peter‟s Teacher Training Institute, Mittapalli
                                  Village, Balinayanapalli Post, Krishnagiri-635108, Tamilnadu

                                  Accordingly, inspection for shifting of premises was carried out on
                                  07.02.2011.

                                  The Committee considered the VT report and Institution’s
                                  request for closure of D.T.Ed course and decided to permit the
                                  closure by withdrawing the recognition for D.T.Ed (APS01393)
                                  course and D.T.Ed – AI (APS03789) with effect from 2012-2013,
                                  in order to enable the ongoing batch of students in D.T.Ed,
                                  course, if any, to complete their final year course.

                                  But it is made clear that the institution is debarred from making
                                  any further admission subsequent to the date of issue of this
                                  order.

                                  The Affiliating body / Examining board / body be informed
                                  accordingly.

                                  Further decided to return Endowment funds and Reserve fund
                                  deposited with SRC NCTE, Bangalore if any.

21.          APS03531             Bharathiyar Teacher Training Institute, Salem District, TN
                B.Ed
        Bharathiyar Teacher       Sri Sakthi Educational Trust, Salem submitted an application in the
      Training Institute, Salem   name and style of Bharathiyar College of Education, Salem District,
                 TN               Tamilnadu for seeking grant of recognition for B.Ed course on
                                  28.09.2004.

                                  The application was processed and the inspection of the institution
                                  was carried out on 21.03.2005. Recognition order to was issued to
                                  the institution on 13.07.2005 at Bharathiyar College of Education,
                                  Ammampalaym Post, Attur Taluk, Salem District-636141, Tamilnadu
                                  with the condition to shift to own premises within 3 years.




     (Gangadharaiah)                                                          (Prof. C. Thangamuthu)
Regional Director, SRC, NCTE                                                   Chairman, SRC, NCTE
                                                    37
                                                                                         st
                                                                              Minutes-201 Meeting of SRC
                                                                                       22-23 February 2011
                               The institution vide letter dated 07.08.2008 submitted Rs.40000/- for
                               change of address at Bharathiyar Teacher Training Institute,
                               Deviyakurichi-636112, Attur Taluk, Salem District,Tamilnadu.
                               Accordingly inspection of the institution was fixed between 7th-11th
                               February 2011 and was intimated to the institution on 31.01.2011.
                               Accordingly inspection of the institution for shifting of premises was
                               conducted on 07.02.2011.

                               The management is also running D.T.Ed and D.T.Ed Additional
                               Intake course in the same building/premises

                               The Committee considered the VT Report, VCD and all the
                               relevant documentary evidences and it was decided to serve
                               Show cause Notice Under Section 17 of NCTE Act for the
                               following :
                                Discrepancy in built up area as given in Affidavit and
                                   Building plan may be explained.
                                The earmarked built up area for D.T.Ed and D.T.Ed – AI
                                   course is 12093 sq.ft only which is inadequate as per NCTE
                                   norms.
                                Building completion certificate issued by the competent
                                   Government authorised Engineer not submitted.
                                Building plan duly approved by the competent authority to
                                   be submitted.
                                Land Usage Certificate issued by competent authority not
                                   submitted.
                                Non-Encumbrance certificate issued by the competent
                                   Government authority not submitted.

                               In view of the above, the Committee decided to issue a Show
                               cause Notice to the institution as to why the recognition be not
                               withdrawn and thereby providing an opportunity to the
                               institution to make a written representation within 30 days from
                               the date of issue of the Notice along with necessary
                               certificates/documents in order to take a final decision in the
                               matter; failing which action will be taken including the
                               withdrawal of recognition, based on the records available, with
                               no further notice.

22.        APS01345            Bharathiyar Girls Teacher Training Institute, Salem District, TN
              D.T.Ed
            D.T.Ed-AI          Sri Sakthi Educational Trust, Salem submitted an application in the
        Bharathiyar Girls      name and style of Bharathiyar Girls Teacher Training Institute,
        Teacher Training       Salem District, Tamilnadu for seeking grant of recognition for D.T.Ed.
         Institute, Salem
                TN             The application was processed and the inspection of the institution
                               was carried out on 09.10.2004. Recognition order was issued to the
                               institution on 08.08.2004 with an intake of 50 and additional intake of




     (Gangadharaiah)                                                         (Prof. C. Thangamuthu)
Regional Director, SRC, NCTE                                                  Chairman, SRC, NCTE
                                                 38
                                                                                         st
                                                                              Minutes-201 Meeting of SRC
                                                                                       22-23 February 2011
                               50 on 13.12.2004 at Bharathiyar Girls Teacher Training Institute,
                               No.43/3, Deviyakurichi-636112, Thalaivasal, Attur Taluk, Salem
                               District, Tamilnadu with the condition to shift to own premises within
                               3 years.

                               The institution vide letter dated 13.09.2007 submitted Rs.40000/- &
                               22.06.2009 for change of address at Bharathiyar Teacher Training
                               Institute, No.43/3, Deviyakurichi-636112, Thalaivasal, Attur Taluk,
                               Salem District, Tamilnadu

                               Accordingly inspection of the institution was fixed between 7th-11th
                               February 2011 and was intimated to the institution on 31.01.2011.
                               Accordingly inspection of the institution for shifting of premises was
                               conducted on 08.02.2011.

                               The management is also running B.Ed course in the same building.

                               The Committee considered the VT Report, VCD and all the
                               relevant documentary evidences and it was decided to serve
                               Show cause Notice Under Section 17 of NCTE Act for the
                               following :

                                Discrepancy in built up area as given in Affidavit and
                                 Building plan may be explained.
                                The earmarked built up area for D.T.Ed and D.T.Ed – AI
                                 course is 12093 sq.ft only which is inadequate as per NCTE
                                 norms.
                                Building completion certificate issued by the competent
                                 Government authorised Engineer not submitted.
                                Building plan duly approved by the competent authority to
                                 be submitted.
                                Land Usage Certificate issued by competent authority not
                                 submitted.
                                Non-Encumbrance certificate issued by the competent
                                 Government authority not submitted.

                               In view of the above, the Committee decided to issue a Show
                               cause Notice to the institution as to why the recognition be not
                               withdrawn and thereby providing an opportunity to the
                               institution to make a written representation within 30 days from
                               the date of issue of the Notice along with necessary
                               certificates/documents in order to take a final decision in the
                               matter; failing which action will be taken including the
                               withdrawal of recognition, based on the records available, with
                               no further notice.




     (Gangadharaiah)                                                        (Prof. C. Thangamuthu)
Regional Director, SRC, NCTE                                                 Chairman, SRC, NCTE
                                                 39
                                                                                        st
                                                                             Minutes-201 Meeting of SRC
                                                                                      22-23 February 2011
23.        APS01360            Crescent Teacher Training Institute, Madurai District, Tamilnadu
             D.T.Ed
        Crescent Teacher       All India Islamic Foundation Trust, Madurai submitted an application
        Training Institute,    in the name and style of Crescent Teacher Training Institute,
            Maadurai           Madurai District, Tamilnadu for seeking grant of recognition for
               TN              D.T.Ed course on 28.08.2002.

                               The application was processed and the inspection of the institution
                               was carried out on 21.08.2004. Recognition order was issued to the
                               institution on 12.01.2005 at Crescent Teacher Training Institute,
                               Seethakathi Nagar, Kallampatti, Natham-Alagar Koil Link Road,
                               Chathrapatti Post, Madurai-625014, Tamilnadu with the condition to
                               shift to own premises within 3 years.

                               The institution vide its letter dated 24.09.2007 submitted Rs.40000/-
                               for change of address at Crescent Teacher Training Institute,
                               Seethakathi Nagar, Kallampatti, Natham-Alagar Koil Link
                               Road,Chathrapatti Post, Madurai-625014, Tamilnadu.

                               Accordingly inspection of the institution was fixed between 8th-12th
                               February 2011 and the same was intimated to the institution on
                               31.01.2011. Accordingly inspection of the institution for shifting of
                               premises was conducted on 08.02.2011.

                               The management is also running B.Ed course in the same
                               building/premises.

                               The Committee considered the VT Report, VCD and all the
                               relevant documentary evidences and it was decided to serve
                               Show cause Notice Under Section 17 of NCTE Act for the
                               following :
                                In Building plan, built-up area is not mentioned.
                                Sy.Nos in building plan, Building completion certificate and
                                   Affidavit are different.
                                Sale deed not submitted for Sy.No.482 and Sy.No.91/2 given
                                   in the Building Plan and Affidavit.
                                Land Usage Certificate issued by competent Government
                                   authority not submitted.
                                The institution is having inadequate teaching staff.
                               In view of the above, the Committee decided to issue a Show
                               cause Notice to the institution as to why the recognition be not
                               withdrawn and thereby providing an opportunity to the
                               institution to make a written representation within 30 days from
                               the date of issue of the Notice along with necessary
                               certificates/documents in order to take a final decision in the
                               matter; failing which action will be taken including the
                               withdrawal of recognition, based on the records available, with
                               no further notice.




     (Gangadharaiah)                                                       (Prof. C. Thangamuthu)
Regional Director, SRC, NCTE                                                Chairman, SRC, NCTE
                                                 40
                                                                                           st
                                                                                Minutes-201 Meeting of SRC
                                                                                         22-23 February 2011
24.          APS04951           K.M Teacher Training Institute, Krishnagiri District, Tamilnadu
               D.T.Ed
      K.M. Teacher Training     Lakshmi Educational & Research Institutional Trust, Salem
       Institute, Krishnagiri   submitted an application in the name and style of K.M Teacher
                 TN             Training Institute, Krishnagiri District, Tamilnadu for seeking grant of
                                recognition for D.T.Ed course on 29.12.2005.

                                The application was processed and the inspection of the institution
                                was carried out on 26.11.2006. Recognition order was issued to the
                                institution on 05.01.2007 at K.M Teacher Training Institute, No.117,
                                Krishnappa Layout, Co-operative Society, Krishnagiri-635001,
                                Tamilnadu with the condition to shift to own premises within 3 years.

                                The institution vide letter dated 05.05.2010 submitted Rs.40000/- for
                                change of address at K.M Teacher Training Institute, Sy.No.10/C &
                                11, Gudusalapalli Village, Melumalai Panchayat, Hosur Taluk,
                                Krishnagiri, Tamilnadu.

                                Accordingly inspection of the institution was fixed between 7th-9th
                                February 2011 and was intimated to the institution on 31.01.2011.
                                Accordingly inspection of the institution for shifting of premises was
                                conducted on 08.02.2011. The brief details of the VT report are
                                given below:

                                The management is also running B.Ed programme in the same
                                building.

                                Meanwhile the institution vide letter dated 04.02.2011 requested
                                extension of time to 1 ½ months for inspection of the institution.

                                The Committee considered the VT Report, VCD and all the
                                relevant documentary evidences and it was decided to serve
                                Show cause Notice Under Section 17 of NCTE Act for the
                                following :

                                 As per VCD, the Building is still under construction.
                                 Details of the land and address of land documents not
                                  given.
                                 Building completion certificate issued by the Government
                                  Engineer/competent authority not submitted.
                                 Land Usage Certificate issued by competent authority not
                                  submitted.
                                 Non-Encumbrance certificate issued by the competent
                                  Government authority not submitted.
                                 Bye-laws of the Society are not submitted.
                                 Psychology lab and Education Technology lab to be
                                  strengthened.
                                 Language Learning Lab need to be established/not
                                  available.




     (Gangadharaiah)                                                          (Prof. C. Thangamuthu)
Regional Director, SRC, NCTE                                                   Chairman, SRC, NCTE
                                                  41
                                                                                                st
                                                                                   Minutes-201 Meeting of SRC
                                                                                            22-23 February 2011
                                   The earmarked built up area for each course is to be given.
                                   The details of FDRs of Endowment and Reserve Fund for
                                    each course is to be given.

                                  In view of the above, the Committee decided to issue a Show
                                  cause Notice to the institution as to why the recognition be not
                                  withdrawn and thereby providing an opportunity to the
                                  institution to make a written representation within 30 days from
                                  the date of issue of the Notice along with necessary
                                  certificates/documents in order to take a final decision in the
                                  matter; failing which action will be taken including the
                                  withdrawal of recognition, based on the records available, with
                                  no further notice.

25.          APS08205             Vel College of Education, Dindigul District, Tamilnadu submitted an
                B.Ed              application for seeking grant of recognition for B.Ed course on
      Vel College of Education,   12.01.2007.
               Dindigul
                 TN               The application was processed and the recognition to the institution
                                  for B.Ed course was granted on 07.11.2007 for annual intake of 100
                                  students.

                                  The institution vide its letter dated 25.08.2010 submitted Rs.40000/-
                                  towards permanent affiliation. A letter was issued to the institution on
                                  03.09.2010 to clarify the purpose for which D.D of Rs.40000/-
                                  submitted.

                                  The institution submitted its reply stating that the D.D was send for
                                  the purpose of shifting of our college from rented building to our own
                                  premises for the purpose of permanent affiliation. Documents
                                  required in connection with shifting of premises relating to land etc
                                  are not sent.

                                  The committee considered the matter in its 197th meeting held on
                                  13th-14th October 2010 and decided to cause inspection. Inspection
                                  of the institution was fixed on 16-17th November 2010 but inspection
                                  of the institution could not be conducted as the institution vide its fax
                                  dated 29.10.2010 requested for postpone the inspection date for
                                  another four months.

                                  Accordingly inspection of the institution was fixed between 24th
                                  January 2011 and was intimated to the institution on 17.01.2011.
                                  Accordingly inspection of the institution for shifting of premises was
                                  conducted on 08.02.2011.

                                  The management          is   running   D.T.Ed   course   in        the   same
                                  building/premises.




     (Gangadharaiah)                                                              (Prof. C. Thangamuthu)
Regional Director, SRC, NCTE                                                       Chairman, SRC, NCTE
                                                     42
                                                                                            st
                                                                                 Minutes-201 Meeting of SRC
                                                                                          22-23 February 2011
                                  The Committee considered the VT Report, VCD and all the
                                  relevant documentary evidences and it was decided to serve
                                  Show cause Notice Under Section 17 of NCTE Act for the
                                  following :

                                   Building construction is incomplete.
                                   A School is being run in the same Building in which teacher
                                    education programmes are conducted.
                                   Building completion certificate not submitted from the
                                    Government authorised Engineer/competent authority.
                                   No full view of the building is shown in VCD.
                                   No drinking water facilities.
                                   Psychology Lab is not according to the NCTE norms
                                    prescribed for teacher education programme.
                                   Language Lab is not available.
                                   Science Lab is yet to be set up.
                                   Details of FDRs for Endowment and Reserve Fund for each
                                    course i.e. B.Ed and D.T.Ed couses is required.
                                   Land Use Certificate and Encumbrance Certificate is
                                    required.
                                   Built up area earmarked for each course is not given in
                                    affidavit.

                                  In view of the above, the Committee decided to issue a Show
                                  cause Notice to the institution as to why the recognition be not
                                  withdrawn and thereby providing an opportunity to the
                                  institution to make a written representation within 30 days from
                                  the date of issue of the Notice along with necessary
                                  certificates/documents in order to take a final decision in the
                                  matter; failing which action will be taken including the
                                  withdrawal of recognition, based on the records available, with
                                  no further notice.

26.          APS03891             Bharathiyar    Teacher     Training    Institute,   Salem      District,
               D.T.Ed             Tamilnadu
             APS06155
             D.T.Ed – AI          Sri Amman Educational & Women Development Trust, Salem
        Bharathiyar Teacher       submitted an application in the name and style of Bharathiyar
      Training Institute, Salem   Teacher Training Institute, Madurai District, Tamilnadu for seeking
                 TN               grant of recognition for D.T.Ed course on 30.12.2004.

                                  The application was processed and the inspection of the institution
                                  was carried out on 05.08.2005. Recognition order was issued to the
                                  institution on 29.12.2005 at Bharathiyar Teacher Training Institute,
                                  Attur-636102, Salem District, Tamilnadu with the condition to shift to
                                  own premises within 3 years.




     (Gangadharaiah)                                                           (Prof. C. Thangamuthu)
Regional Director, SRC, NCTE                                                    Chairman, SRC, NCTE
                                                    43
                                                                                             st
                                                                                  Minutes-201 Meeting of SRC
                                                                                           22-23 February 2011
                                  The institution vide its letter dated 06.10.2009 submitted Rs.40000/-
                                  for change of address at Bharathiyar Teacher Training Institute, Near
                                  Railway Station, Attur-636102, Salem District, Tamilnadu.
                                  Accordingly inspection of the institution was fixed between 7th-11th
                                  February 2011 and was intimated to the institution on 31.01.2011.
                                  Accordingly inspection of the institution for shifting of premises was
                                  conducted on 09.02.2011.

                                  The management is running D.T.Ed –AI course also (APS06155).

                                  The Committee considered the VT Report, VCD and all the
                                  relevant documentary evidences and it was decided to serve
                                  Show cause Notice Under Section 17 of NCTE Act for the
                                  following :

                                   Details of other programmes being run in the same
                                    building/campus, alongwith documentary vidence/certificate
                                    from the relevant affiliating/approving authority.
                                   There is no exclusive earmaked built up area for D.T.Ed and
                                    D.T.Ed-AI courses
                                   Affidavit in Rs.100/- stamp paper duly notarized not
                                    submitted.
                                   Land Usage Certificate from competent Government
                                    authority not submitted.
                                   Non-Encumbrance certificate from competent Government
                                    authority not submitted.
                                   Building completion certificate is not in the prescribed
                                    format.
                                   The total area and total built up area not mentioned.
                                   Language Learning Lab is not available.

                                  In view of the above, the Committee decided to issue a Show
                                  cause Notice to the institution as to why the recognition be not
                                  withdrawn and thereby providing an opportunity to the
                                  institution to make a written representation within 30 days from
                                  the date of issue of the Notice along with necessary
                                  certificates/documents in order to take a final decision in the
                                  matter; failing which action will be taken including the
                                  withdrawal of recognition, based on the records available, with
                                  no further notice.

27.            APS05017           Krishna Teacher        Training   Institute,    Krishnagiri     District,
                 D.T.Ed           Tamilnadu
      Krishna Teacher Training
         Institute, Krishnagiri   Bharat Educational Trust, Krishnagiri submitted an application in the
                   TN             name and style of Krishna Teacher Training Institute, Krishnagiri
                                  District, Tamilnadu for seeking grant of recognition for D.T.Ed course
                                  on 30.12.2005.




     (Gangadharaiah)                                                             (Prof. C. Thangamuthu)
Regional Director, SRC, NCTE                                                      Chairman, SRC, NCTE
                                                    44
                                                                                        st
                                                                             Minutes-201 Meeting of SRC
                                                                                      22-23 February 2011
                               The application was processed and the inspection of the institution
                               was carried out on 25.11.2006. Recognition order was issued to the
                               institution on 17.11.2005 at Krishna Teacher Training Institute,
                               Kattinayanapalli Post, Krishnagiri-635001, Tamilnadu with the
                               condition to shift to own premises within 3 years.

                               The institution vide letter dated 28.04.2010 submitted Rs.40000/- for
                               change of address at Krishna Teacher Training Institute,
                               Kattinayanapalli Post, Krishnagiri-635001, Tamilnadu.

                               Accordingly inspection of the institution was carried out on 9th
                               February 2011 and the VT report was received on 10.2.2011.

                               The management is running B.Ed and D.T.Ed –AI course in the
                               same building.

                               The Committee considered the VT Report, VCD and all the
                               relevant documentary evidences and it was decided to serve
                               Show cause Notice Under Section 17 of NCTE Act for the
                               following :

                                  Construction of Building is not yet completed.
                                  The details of the land, land address are not submitted.
                                  The survey no. in affidavit and building plan do not tally.
                                  The discrepancy in built up area in affidavit and building
                                   plan may be explainted.
                                  The earmarked built up area for each course i.e. B.Ed,
                                   D.T.Ed and D.T.Ed Additional intake should be given.
                                  Building completion certificate issued by the Government
                                   Engineer/competent authority not submitted.
                                  Land Usage Certificate issued by Govenremnt competent
                                   authority not submitted.
                                  Non-Encumbrance certificate not submitted issued by the
                                   Government competent authority.

                               In view of the above, the Committee decided to issue a Show
                               cause Notice to the institution as to why the recognition be not
                               withdrawn and thereby providing an opportunity to the
                               institution to make a written representation within 30 days from
                               the date of issue of the Notice along with necessary
                               certificates/documents in order to take a final decision in the
                               matter; failing which action will be taken including the
                               withdrawal of recognition, based on the records available, with
                               no further notice.




     (Gangadharaiah)                                                       (Prof. C. Thangamuthu)
Regional Director, SRC, NCTE                                                Chairman, SRC, NCTE
                                                 45
                                                                                               st
                                                                                 Minutes-201 Meeting of SRC
                                                                                          22-23 February 2011
28.       APS06128             Kapi College of Education, Madurai District, Tamilnadu
              B.Ed
        Kapi College of        Crescent Trust, Madurai submitted an application in the name and style of
       Education, Madurai      Kapi College of Education, Madurai District, Tamilnadu for seeking grant of
                               recognition for B.Ed course on 30.12.2005.
              TN
                               The application was processed and the inspection of the institution was
                               carried out on 30.10.2006. Recognition order was issued to the institution
                               on 23.12.2006 at Kapi College of Education, No.4/59, V.P. Sindan Nagar,
                               Theni Main Road, Nagamalai West, Madurai-625019, Tamilnadu with the
                               condition to shift to own premises within 3 years.

                               The institution vide its letter dated 15.10.2009 submitted Rs.40000/- for
                               change of address at Kapi College of Education, No.7/14A, Willington
                               Road, NGGO Colony, Nagamalai, Madurai-625019, Tamilnadu.

                               The management is running D.T.Ed and D.T.Ed-AI course in the same
                               building/campus.
                                                                                          th        th
                               Accordingly inspection of the institution was fixed between 8 -12 February
                               2011 and was intimated to the institution on 31.01.2011. Accordingly
                               inspection of the institution for shifting of premises was conducted on
                               09.02.2011.

                               The Committee considered the VT Report, VCD and all the
                               relevant documentary evidences and it was decided to serve
                               Show cause Notice Under Section 17 of NCTE Act for the
                               following :

                                The building is still under construction and incomplete.
                                The institution is running D.T.Ed, D.T.Ed-AI and B.Ed and
                                 earmarked built up area for each course should be given.
                                As per VT report, the earmarked built up area for B.Ed is
                                 15224 sq.ft and for D.T.Ed course is 14714 sq.ft and the total
                                 built up area is 29,938 sq.ft, which is inadequate. For B.Ed,
                                 D.T.Ed and D.T.Ed-AI courses required built up area is
                                 38,000 sq.ft as per NCTE norms
                                Non-Encumbrance certificate from Government/competent
                                 authority not submitted.
                                Language Learning Lab not established/not available.
                                Building completion certificate from authorised Government
                                 Engineer not submitted in the prescribed format.
                               In view of the above, the Committee decided to issue a Show
                               cause Notice to the institution as to why the recognition be not
                               withdrawn and thereby providing an opportunity to the
                               institution to make a written representation within 30 days from
                               the date of issue of the Notice along with necessary
                               certificates/documents in order to take a final decision in the
                               matter; failing which action will be taken including the
                               withdrawal of recognition, based on the records available, with
                               no further notice.



     (Gangadharaiah)                                                           (Prof. C. Thangamuthu)
Regional Director, SRC, NCTE                                                    Chairman, SRC, NCTE
                                                  46
                                                                                              st
                                                                                Minutes-201 Meeting of SRC
                                                                                         22-23 February 2011
29.        APS06130            Kapi Teacher Training Institute, Madurai District, Tamilnadu
              D.T.Ed
      Kapi Teacher Training    Crescent Trust, Madurai submitted an application in the name and style of
        Institute, Madurai     Kapi Teacher Training Institute, Madurai District, Tamilnadu for seeking
                TN             grant of recognition for D.T.Ed course on 30.12.2006.

                               The application was processed and the inspection of the institution was
                               carried out on 12.10.2006. Recognition order was issued to the institution
                               on 24.10.2006 at Kapi Teacher Training Institute, Plot No.408, No.7/14A,
                               Willington Road, NGGO Colony, Nagamalai, Madurai-625019, Tamilnadu
                               with the condition to shift to own premises within 3 years.

                               The institution vide letter dated 15.10.2009 & 26.02.2010 submitted
                               Rs.40000/- for change of address at Kapi Teacher Training Institute,
                               No.7/14A, Willington Road, NGGO Colony, Nagamalai, Madurai-625019,
                               Tamilnadu
                                                                                         th        th
                               Accordingly inspection of the institution was fixed between 8 -12 February
                               2011 and was intimated to the institution on 31.01.2011. Accordingly
                               inspection of the institution for shifting of premises was conducted on
                               08.02.2011.

                               The Committee considered the VT Report, VCD and all the
                               relevant documentary evidences and it was decided to serve
                               Show cause Notice Under Section 17 of NCTE Act for the
                               following :

                                The building is still under construction and incomplete.
                                The institution is running D.T.Ed, D.T.Ed-AI and B.Ed and
                                 earmarked built up area for each course should be given.
                                As per VT report, the earmarked built up area for B.Ed is
                                 15224 sq.ft and for D.T.Ed course is 14714 sq.ft and the total
                                 built up area is 29,938 sq.ft, which is inadequate. For B.Ed,
                                 D.T.Ed and D.T.Ed-AI courses required built up area is
                                 38,000 sq.ft as per NCTE norms
                                Non-Encumbrance certificate from Government/competent
                                 authority not submitted.
                                Language Learning Lab not established/not available.
                                Building completion certificate from authorised Government
                                 Engineer not submitted in the prescribed format.

                               In view of the above, the Committee decided to issue a Show
                               cause Notice to the institution as to why the recognition be not
                               withdrawn and thereby providing an opportunity to the
                               institution to make a written representation within 30 days from
                               the date of issue of the Notice along with necessary
                               certificates/documents in order to take a final decision in the
                               matter; failing which action will be taken including the
                               withdrawal of recognition, based on the records available, with
                               no further notice.




     (Gangadharaiah)                                                           (Prof. C. Thangamuthu)
Regional Director, SRC, NCTE                                                    Chairman, SRC, NCTE
                                                  47
                                                                                              st
                                                                                Minutes-201 Meeting of SRC
                                                                                         22-23 February 2011
30.         APS05711           Sri Balaji College of Education for Women, Madurai District, TN
               B.Ed
                               Annai Meenakshi Educational and Charitable Trust, Madurai submitted an
       Sri Balaji College of   application in the name and style of Sri Balaji College of Education for
      Education for Women,     Women, Madurai District, Tamilnadu for seeking grant of recognition for
             Madurai           B.Ed course on 02.01.2006.
                TN
                               The application was processed and the inspection of the institution was
                               carried out on 25.11.2006. Recognition order was issued to the institution
                               on 09.01.2007 at Sri Balaji College of Education for Women, Krishna
                               Bhavan, New No.15, Venkataraman Street, Cinna Chokkikulam, Maduari-
                               625002, Tamilnadu with the condition to shift to own premises within 3
                               years.

                               The institution vide letter dated 04.01.2010 submitted Rs.40000/- for
                               change of address at Sri Balaji College of Education for Women,
                               Sithalangudi Village, Ayyankottai Post, Nagari, Madurai-625221,
                               Tamilnadu.
                                                                                         th        th
                               Accordingly inspection of the institution was fixed between 8 -12 February
                               2011 and was intimated to the institution on 31.01.2011. Accordingly
                               inspection of the institution for shifting of premises was conducted on
                               10.02.2011

                               The institution vide letter dated 15.10.2009 & 26.02.2010 submitted
                               Rs.40000/- for change of address at Kapi Teacher Training Institute,
                               No.7/14A, Willington Road, NGGO Colony, Nagamalai, Madurai-625019,
                               Tamilnadu
                                                                                         th        th
                               Accordingly inspection of the institution was fixed between 8 -12 February
                               2011 and was intimated to the institution on 31.01.2011. Accordingly
                               inspection of the institution for shifting of premises was conducted on
                               08.02.2011.

                               The Committee considered the VT Report, VCD and all the
                               relevant documentary evidences and it was decided to serve
                               Show cause Notice Under Section 17 of NCTE Act for the
                               following :
                                The building is still under construction and incomplete and
                                   Stair case is not plastered.
                                Building completion certificate not submitted in the
                                   prescribed format issued by competent Government
                                   Engineer.

                               In view of the above, the Committee decided to issue a Show
                               cause Notice to the institution as to why the recognition be not
                               withdrawn and thereby providing an opportunity to the
                               institution to make a written representation within 30 days from
                               the date of issue of the Notice along with necessary
                               certificates/documents in order to take a final decision in the
                               matter; failing which action will be taken including the
                               withdrawal of recognition, based on the records available, with
                               no further notice.



     (Gangadharaiah)                                                           (Prof. C. Thangamuthu)
Regional Director, SRC, NCTE                                                    Chairman, SRC, NCTE
                                                  48
                                                                                         st
                                                                              Minutes-201 Meeting of SRC
                                                                                       22-23 February 2011
31.          APS06108           Raj College of Education, Madurai District, Tamilnadu
                B.Ed
      Raj College of Education, Bangaru Ammal Educational Trust, Madurai submitted an application
               Madurai          in the name and style of Raj College of Education, Madurai District,
                                Tamilnadu for seeking grant of recognition for B.Ed course on
                 TN             02.01.2006.

                                The application was processed and the inspection of the institution
                                was carried out on 31.08.2007. Recognition order was issued to the
                                institution on 02.11.2007 at Raj College of Education, No.385C,
                                Harveypatty,     Thirupparankumdram         Post,   Madurai-625005,
                                Tamilnadu with the condition to shift to own premises within 3 years.

                                The institution vide letter dated 30.04.2010 submitted Rs.40000/- for
                                change of address at Raj College of Education, No.72, Harveypatty,
                                Thirupparankumdram Post, Madurai-625005, Tamilnadu.

                                Accordingly inspection of the institution was fixed between 8th-12th
                                February 2011 and the same was intimated to the institution on
                                31.01.2011. Accordingly inspection of the institution for shifting of
                                premises was conducted on 11.02.2011.

                                The management is also running D.T.Ed and D.T.Ed-AI courses in
                                the same building.

                                The Committee considered the VT Report, VCD and all the
                                relevant documentary evidences and it was decided to serve
                                Show cause Notice Under Section 17 of NCTE Act for the
                                following :

                                 As per VT report, the total built up area for D.T.Ed, D.T.Ed-AI
                                  and B.Ed is 31,401 sq.ft which is inadequate. As per NCTE
                                  norms total built up area required is 38,000 sq.ft.
                                 Building Completion Certificate by competent Governmment
                                  Engineer not submitted in the prescribed format.
                                 Non-Encumbrance certificate issued by the competent
                                  authority not submitted.

                                In view of the above, the Committee decided to issue a Show
                                cause Notice to the institution as to why the recognition be not
                                withdrawn and thereby providing an opportunity to the
                                institution to make a written representation within 30 days from
                                the date of issue of the Notice along with necessary
                                certificates/documents in order to take a final decision in the
                                matter; failing which action will be taken including the
                                withdrawal of recognition, based on the records available, with
                                no further notice.




     (Gangadharaiah)                                                        (Prof. C. Thangamuthu)
Regional Director, SRC, NCTE                                                 Chairman, SRC, NCTE
                                                  49
                                                                                         st
                                                                              Minutes-201 Meeting of SRC
                                                                                       22-23 February 2011
32.        APS05753            Raj Teacher Training Institute, Madurai District, Tamilnadu
             D.T.Ed
      Raj Teacher Training     Bangaru Ammal Educational Trust, Madurai submitted an application
       Institute, Madurai      in the name and style of Raj Teacher Training Institute, Madurai
                               District, Tamilnadu for seeking grant of recognition for D.T.Ed course
              TN               on 02.01.2006.

                               The application was processed and the inspection of the institution
                               was carried out on 10.10.2006. Recognition order was issued to the
                               institution on 08.11.2006 at Raj Teacher Training Institute, No.385C,
                               Harveypatty,      Thirupparankumdram        Post,   Madurai-625005,
                               Tamilnadu with the condition to shift to own premises within 3 years.

                               The institution vide its letter dated 01.10.2009 submitted Rs.40000/-
                               for change of address at Raj Teacher Training Institute, No.72,
                               Harveypatty,      Thirupparankumdram         Post,  Madurai-625005,
                               Tamilnadu

                               Accordingly inspection of the institution was fixed between 8th-12th
                               February 2011 and the same was intimated to the institution on
                               31.01.2011.

                               The Committee considered the VT Report, VCD and all the
                               relevant documentary evidences and it was decided to serve
                               Show cause Notice Under Section 17 of NCTE Act for the
                               following :

                                As per VT report, the total built up area for D.T.Ed, D.T.Ed-AI
                                 and B.Ed is 31,401 sq.ft which is inadequate. As per NCTE
                                 norms total built up area required is 38,000 sq.ft.
                                Building Completion Certificate by competent Governmment
                                 Engineer not submitted in the prescribed format.
                                Non-Encumbrance certificate issued by the competent
                                 authority not submitted.

                               In view of the above, the Committee decided to issue a Show
                               cause Notice to the institution as to why the recognition be not
                               withdrawn and thereby providing an opportunity to the
                               institution to make a written representation within 30 days from
                               the date of issue of the Notice along with necessary
                               certificates/documents in order to take a final decision in the
                               matter; failing which action will be taken including the
                               withdrawal of recognition, based on the records available, with
                               no further notice.




     (Gangadharaiah)                                                        (Prof. C. Thangamuthu)
Regional Director, SRC, NCTE                                                 Chairman, SRC, NCTE
                                                 50
                                                                                         st
                                                                              Minutes-201 Meeting of SRC
                                                                                       22-23 February 2011
Appeal Cases:
33.        APS09517            Arul College of Education, Villupuram District, Tamilnadu has
              B.Ed             submitted an application for starting B.Ed course on 21.5.2008. The
         Arul College of       application was processed and refused recognition to the institution
      Education, Villupuram,   on 29.5.2009.
           Tamilnadu
               TN              Meantime, the institution filed court case in W.P. No. 12169 of 2009.
                               Accordingly, a letter was sent to the advocate on 20.7.2009.

                               This office has received court judgement dated 10.7.2009 and the
                               representation of the institution dated 4.6.2009 was placed before
                               SRC in its 180th meeting held on 29th July, 2009. The Committee
                               considered the High Court order in W.P. No. 12169 and decided to
                               cause inspection after submission of documents and re-inspection
                               fee for B.Ed course to verify the infrastructural and instructional
                               facilities. Further the Committee also decided to cause inspection for
                               shifting of premises of D.T.Ed course as the same has been shifted
                               to the same campus.

                               Accordingly, a letter was issued to the institution on 31.7.2009. The
                               institution has submitted a letter requested SRC-NCTE to cause
                               inspection without re-inspection fees of Rs. 40,000/-, which was
                               placed before SRC in its 181st meeting held on 20th and 21st August,
                               2009, wherein the Committee decided that the institution be asked to
                               pay Rs. 40,000/- for revisiting and verification of infrastructural and
                               instructional facilities provided for B.Ed course. Further, the
                               Committee viewed that the re-inspection decision has been taken on
                               the basis of Hon‟ble High Court of Madras orders in W.P. No. 12169
                               of 2009 and on the request of the institution in its letter dated
                               4.6.2009. Accordingly, a letter was issued to the institution on
                               28.8.2009.

                               The institution has submitted re-inspection fee of Rs. 40,000/- on
                               18.9.2009. Accordingly, an inspection of the institution was carried
                               out on 6.9.2009. The visiting team was considered by SRC in its
                               184th meeting held on 26th and 27th October, 2009 and decided to
                               issue notice. Accordingly, a notice was issued to the institution on
                               2.11.2009. The institution has submitted written representation on
                               24.12.2009, which was placed before SRC in its 188th meeting held
                               on 28th and 29th January, 2010. The Committee considered the
                               written representation and decided to refuse recognition.
                               Accordingly, a refusal order was issued to the institution on 2.3.2010.

                               Aggrieved by the refusal order of SRC, the institution preferred an
                               appeal to NCTE-Hqrs. and the appellate authority has confirmed the
                               refusal order of SRC vide order dated 21.01.2011.

                               The committee noted the Appellate authority order dt.21.01.2011
                               confirming the SRC’s order dt. 02.03.2010.



     (Gangadharaiah)                                                         (Prof. C. Thangamuthu)
Regional Director, SRC, NCTE                                                  Chairman, SRC, NCTE
                                                 51
                                                                                            st
                                                                                 Minutes-201 Meeting of SRC
                                                                                          22-23 February 2011
34.             ---            Haji SMS Shaik Jalaludeen B.Ed College, Thanjavur, Tamilnadu
               B.Ed
         Haji SMS Shaik     1.     Shaduli Family Pvt. Trust submitted an application dated
       Jalaludeen Teacher      24.10.2009 for B.Ed course in the name of Haji SMS Shaik
        Training Institute,    Jalaludeen B.Ed College, Thanjavur, Tamilnadu which was received
         Adirampattinam        on 26.10.2009.
                TN
                            2.     The application was returned back to the society on 29.10.2009
                               as the application was not submitted electronically through on-line
                               mode as per the new Regulation;

                                “As para 5 (3) of the NCTE Regulation, 2009 the application may be
                                essentially submitted electronically through on-line mode available
                                on the website of National Council for Teacher Education along with
                                the processing fee. However, while submitting the application
                                through on-line mode, the application and requisite documents in
                                triplicate shall have to be submitted or sent by registered post
                                separately to the office of the Regional Committee concerned,
                                immediately after on-line submission of the application. You have not
                                submitted your application in on-line mode”.

                                Further it is also informed that as per the Public Notice dated 28th
                                July, 2009, the NCTE had taken a policy decision not to
                                recognize/permit institutions for conduct of B.Ed course in the State
                                of Tamilnadu for the academic session 2010-2011. However, the
                                above restriction will not apply in case of minority institutions
                                established under Article 20 of the Constitution”.

                           3.       The institution again resubmitted the application on 16.11.2009,
                                the same was returned since the application was not submitted
                                through on-line mode and that too after the last date of submission
                                of application.

                           4.       Previously, the institution filed court case in W.P. No. 12809 of
                                2009 in the Hon‟ble Madurai Bench of Madras High Court, Madurai
                                District quashing SRC‟s letter no. F.SRC/NCTE/2009/16764 dated
                                20.11.2009.
                           5.
                           6.      Accordingly, the fact of the case was communicated to Shri. A.
                                Sivaji, Advocate, Madurain vide this office letter No.
                                F.CC/SRO/NCTE/2009-2010/17728 dated 10.2.2010.

                                The Hon‟ble High Court of Madras, Madurai Bench of Madurai in
                                their order dated 27.4.2010 in the W.P(M.D) No. 12809 and M.P. No.
                                1 of 2009 filed by the above institution has dismissed the writ
                                petition. The court has ordered as follows:
                                “The Learned Counsel appearing for the petitioner seeks permission of this
                                court to withdraw the writ petition and he has also made an endorsement to
                                that effect.




     (Gangadharaiah)                                                            (Prof. C. Thangamuthu)
Regional Director, SRC, NCTE                                                     Chairman, SRC, NCTE
                                                   52
                                                                                               st
                                                                                   Minutes-201 Meeting of SRC
                                                                                            22-23 February 2011
                               In view of the same, the writ petition is dismissed as withdrawn. No costs.
                               Consequently, connected miscellaneous petition is closed”.
                               This year also the same institution applied for B.Ed course through
                               on-line on 30.9.2010 but the hard copy received by this office on
                               13.10.2010 i.e after the last date of submission of application (as per
                               regulation 2009, the institution should apply through on-line followed
                               submission of hard copy within 7 days). The institution has submitted
                               5 days late. In this regard a general letter seeking clarification has
                               been sent to NCTE-Hqrs on 25.10.2010. The reply is awaited, hence
                               this application is kept in abeyance.

                               Now the institution has filed appeal Under Section 18 of NCTE Act,
                               before the Appellate Authority, NCTE, New Delhi against the
                               rejection order of SRC. The Appellate Authority refused to accept
                               the reasons for condonation of delay and admit the appeal vide
                               order dated 01.02.2011

                               The committee noted the Appellate authority order dt.
                               01.02.2011 confirming the SRC’s order dt.16.08.2009.

35.       SRCAPP393            Jayanthimala Educational Trust, J.P. College of Education, No.67/A,
              B.Ed             Bazaar Street, II Floor, Srimushnam-608703, Cuddalore, Tamilnadu
         J.P. College of
      Education, Cuddalore     Jayanthimala Educational Trust, J.P. College of Education, No.67/A,
                               Bazaar Street, II Floor, Srimushnam-608703, Cuddalore, Tamilnadu
               TN
                               submitted an application for B.Ed course through on-line on 30.09.2010.
                               Application of the above institution dated 09.10.2010 was received by SRC
                               on 12.10.2010.

                                        As per the new Regulation, 2009 “the application may be
                               essentially submitted electronically through on-line mode available on the
                               website of National Council for Teacher Education along with the
                               processing fee. However, while submitting the application through on-line
                               mode, the application and requisite documents in triplicate shall have to be
                               submitted or sent by registered post separately to the office of the Regional
                               Committee concerned, immediately after on-line submission of the
                               application”.

                                        Since, the institution did not submit hard copy of application and
                               requisite documents in triplicate and as per NCTE Regulations hard copy of
                               application should be submitted within 7 days after submission of same
                               application through online. Last date for submission of on-line application is
                                st
                               1 October 2010. Hence hard copy of application should have been
                               submitted on or before 8.10.2010.

                               Hence the application was rejected and returned along with the Demand
                               Draft of Rs. 40,000/- bearing No. 114174 dated. 10.07.2010 and Rs.1,000/-
                               bearing no. 115333 dated 27.09.2010 vide letter No. 22915 dated
                               02.11.2010.

                               The committee noted the Appellate authority order dt.
                               01.02.2011 confirming the SRC’s order dt. 02.11.2010.



     (Gangadharaiah)                                                             (Prof. C. Thangamuthu)
Regional Director, SRC, NCTE                                                      Chairman, SRC, NCTE
                                                   53
                                                                                         st
                                                                              Minutes-201 Meeting of SRC
                                                                                       22-23 February 2011
36.        APS09763            Shree Gokarnantheshwara College of Education, Gandhinagar,
              M.Ed             Mangalore-575003, Karnataka has submitted application for starting
             Shree             M.Ed course on 31.10.2008.
      Gokarnantheshwara
      College of Education,    On careful perusal of the original file of the institution, inspection
           Managalore          report, VCD, written representation from the institution and other
               KA              related documents, ACT of NCTE, 1993, Regulations and guidelines
                               from time to time laid on the table, written representation from the
                               institution, the SRC committed noted the following:

                               The institution has stated that Professor is having 11 years of
                               experience at PG level in Nova College of Education. But, Nova
                               College of Education got recognition from NCTE only on 09.07.2007.
                               Therefore the Professor Candidate‟s PG experience Certificate
                               issued by Nova College of Education is not vaild. The qualified
                               Professor is not appointed as per norms and standards of NCTE for
                               M.Ed course.

                               In the view of the above, the SRC in its 182nd meeting held on 31st
                               August, 2010 decided to refuse the recognition/withdraw the letter of
                               Intent or Conditional recognition accorded to the institution for the
                               proposed course. The refusal order was issued to the institution on
                               24.09.2009.

                               The institution preferred an appeal to NCTE, Hqrs and the appellate
                               authority has reversed the refusal order of SRC vide order dated
                               21.01.2011.

                               The committee considered the Appellate authority order dt.
                               21.01.2011 and decided to restore Letter of Intent and to await
                               for faculty information from the institution.

37.         APS02069           Sri. Krishna College of Education, Karnataka Yadava Educational
               B.Ed            Society, No.12/2, Yamuna Bai Road, Madhava Nagar, Bangalore-
      Sri Krishna College of   560001, Karnataka has submitted application for starting B.Ed
      Education, Bangalore     course on 31.12.2003. The institution was granted recognition on
                KA             25.11.2004
                               As per the decision of 175th meeting of SRC held on 13-14 May
                               2009, the institutions where recognition‟s were granted in temporary
                               premises with a condition shift to permanent premises within period
                               of three years time limit of grant recognition as per NCTE
                               Regulations, 2002 notified in 18.11.2002, were considered. It was
                               decided that institutions which have not shifted to the permanent
                               premises even after the expiry of three years time limit be issued
                               notice under section 17 of NCTE Act for further action.




     (Gangadharaiah)                                                        (Prof. C. Thangamuthu)
Regional Director, SRC, NCTE                                                 Chairman, SRC, NCTE
                                                 54
                                                                                       st
                                                                            Minutes-201 Meeting of SRC
                                                                                     22-23 February 2011
                               Accordingly, Notice was issued to the institution on 01.09.2009. The
                               institution has submitted its written representation on 30.09.2009.
                               SRC in its 187th meeting held on 29-30 December 2009 considered
                               the written representation and decided to cause inspection.
                               Accordingly inspection was carried out on 04.06.2010.

                               The SRC in its 193rd meeting held on 21-22 June 2010 considered
                               the VT report and other documents and decided to withdraw the
                               recognition. Accordingly withdrawal order was issued to the on
                               28.07.2010.

                               The institution preferred an appeal to NCTE, Hqrs and the appellate
                               authority vide order dated 21.01.2011 has reversed the Withdrawal
                               Order of SRC dated 28.07.2010 with the direction to the SRC for
                               issuance of Showcause Notice and for taking further action
                               thereafter.

                               The Committee considered the Appellate authority order dt.
                               21.01.2011, VT Report, VCD and all the relevant documentary
                               evidences and it was decided to serve Showcause Notice
                               Under Section 17 of NCTE Act for the following:

                               As per VT Report and as countersigned by the Management,
                                   D.Ed., B.Ed. and ITI courses in the same campus as per
                                     VT report.
                                   Built-up space on calculation comes to 6485 sq.ft. which
                                     is far inadequate, as per NCTE norms of 16,000 sq.ft.
                                   The Management is running ITI course in Ground floor
                                     which is not permitted as per the NCTE norms.
                                   First Floor of the building is earmarked for B.Ed. course.
                                     But, as per the VTR, the area earmarked for each course
                                     is not available; the labs. and other facilities like toilets,
                                     etc. were being shared by B.Ed., D.Ed. alongwith ITI
                                     students.
                                   Psychology lab. and E.T. Lab. need to be strengthened.
                                   Language learning lab. is not available.
                                   The seating capacity in Library and reading room are not
                                     sufficient.
                                   Website is not available.

                               In view of the above, the Committee decided to issue a
                               Showcause Notice to the institution as to why the recognition
                               be not withdrawn and thereby providing an opportunity to the
                               institution to make a written representation within 30 days from
                               the date of issue of the Notice along with necessary
                               certificates/documents in order to take a final decision in the
                               matter; failing which action will be taken including the
                               withdrawal of recognition, based on the records available, with
                               no further notice.




     (Gangadharaiah)                                                       (Prof. C. Thangamuthu)
Regional Director, SRC, NCTE                                                Chairman, SRC, NCTE
                                                55
                                                                                           st
                                                                                Minutes-201 Meeting of SRC
                                                                                         22-23 February 2011
38.         SRCAPP185           Sri.Konidela Venkat Rao Memorial College of Education, Krishna
                B.Ed            District, Andhra Pradesh has submitted application on 03.11.2009.
      Sri Konidela Venkat Rao   The institution was refused recognition due to non-reply to the
        Memorial College of     deficiency letter. Refusal order was issued on 30.04.2010.
         Education, Krishna
                 AP             The institution preferred appeal to NCTE, Hqrs and the Appellate
                                Authority has confirmed the refusal order of SRC vide order dated
                                21.01.2011.

                                The committee noted the Appellate authority order dt.21.01.2011
                                confirming the SRC’s order dt. 30.04.2010.

39.         APS02586            K.P. Education Society has submitted an application for seeking
              D.Ed              recognition for D.Ed course in the name and style of St. Thomas
      St. Thomas Institute of   Institute of Elementary Teacher Education Achanpally, Bodhan,
       Elementary Teacher       Nizamabad, Andhara Pradesh on 03.02.2004.
      Education, Nizamabad
               AP               In the meanwhile the Govt. of Andhra Pradesh of Hyderabad filed a
                                Writ Petition No.22866/2005 in Hon‟ble High court of Andhra
                                Pradesh at Hyderabad challenging the notification of NCTE with
                                regard to the dispensing with the requirement of NOC from the State
                                Govt. The writ petition was allowed by the learned single judge with
                                the directions that the rule excluding the State Govt. is bad.

                                Against the said Judgment a writ appeal No. 692/2006 was filed in
                                the Division Bench of Hon‟ble High Court of Hyderabad. Many
                                discussions took place between the State Govt. of Andhra Pradesh
                                and SRC-NCTE. However, neither the State Govt. withdrew the case
                                filed by them, nor the stay was vacated.

                                Thereafter, some institutions went to the court and filed petitions
                                individually seeking directions for processing of their applications, in
                                one of such writ petition No.8278/2008. The Hon‟ble High court of
                                Andhra Pradesh decided that the applications of the institutions shall
                                be processed as per the NCTE rules and regulation, norms and
                                standards existing as on date.

                                As per direction of Hon‟ble High court the matter was placed in 164th
                                meeting of SRC and the Committee considered the pending matters
                                of D.Ed institutions in the State of Andhra Pradesh and it was
                                decided to process these applications according to the new norms
                                and standards of NCTE as per direction of Hon‟ble High court of
                                Andhra Pradesh.

                                As per the directions of Regional Committee a deficiency letter was
                                issued to the applicant institution on 30.09.2009, with a request to
                                submit reply to the deficiency letter within 90 days as per section
                                7(1) of the NCTE Regulation 2007.




     (Gangadharaiah)                                                          (Prof. C. Thangamuthu)
Regional Director, SRC, NCTE                                                   Chairman, SRC, NCTE
                                                  56
                                                                                              st
                                                                                  Minutes-201 Meeting of SRC
                                                                                           22-23 February 2011
                               Earlier, SRC in its 135th meeting held on 7th–8th June, 2007 had
                               decided to treat the application which have not submitted
                               compliance as closed after the expiry of 90 days of time as per the
                               Regulation of NCTE, 2005. A letter dated 31.10.2008 was received
                               from NCTE Hqrs. clarifying that all such cases where letter of
                               deficiency was issued but no reply was received from the
                               concerned institution within 90 days may also be closed in terms of
                               section 7(1) of the NCTE Regulations.

                               The applicant institution had failed to submit the reply within 90 days
                               and hence it was decided to close the application and letter closing
                               the application was issued to the institution on 02.03.2009.

                               After that the applicant institution approached Hon‟ble High court of
                               Andhra Pradesh in writ petition No. 22786/2009. In this regard, a
                               suitable reply was forwarded to our legal counsel on 26.11.2009.
                               The Hon‟ble High passed an order dated 16.12.2009. However, the
                               operative part of order as under:-
                               “the writ petition is allowed and the impugned order is set aside. The
                               respondent is directed to pass appropriate orders taking into account the
                               compliance report by the petitioner to the deficiencies pointed out, in his
                               letter 30.09.2008. This exercise shall be completed within la period of four
                               (4) weeks from the date of receipt of a copy of this order. There shall be no
                               order as to costs”.

                               The court order is received in SRC office on 12.01.2010.
                               The institution has also submitted compliance report on 27.01.2010

                               The matter was placed before 188th meeting of SRC held on 28-29th
                               January, 2010 the Regional committee decided to cause Re-
                               Inspection. The inspection report dt. 30.04.2010 was considered by
                               SRC.

                               The Committee considered the Inspection Report and all the relevant
                               records and decided to refuse recognition. Accordingly, refusal
                               order was issued on 25.06.2010.

                               The institution has now sent letter dated 16.07.2010 enclosing a
                               copy of order dated 09.07.2010 in W.P.M.P. no. 17495/2010 in writ
                               petition no. 13905/2010 wherein the Hon‟ble High court has passed
                               the following order.

                               The operative part of order is reproduced as under:-
                               “If the Committee feels that the report submitted by the Visiting Team has
                               not reflecting the true picture, the Committee can record the reasons and
                               reject the same. The order impugned in the Writ Petition does not reflect
                               that they ignored the report submitted by the Visiting Team Members or the
                               report submitted by the visiting team member is contrary to any of the
                               information available with them.




     (Gangadharaiah)                                                             (Prof. C. Thangamuthu)
Regional Director, SRC, NCTE                                                      Chairman, SRC, NCTE
                                                   57
                                                                                               st
                                                                                   Minutes-201 Meeting of SRC
                                                                                            22-23 February 2011
                               “In view of the matter, there shall be interim direction to the respondent to
                               reconsider the application filed by the petitioner seeking permission for
                               commencement of the D.Ed course in its institution keeping in view the
                               report submitted by the Visiting Team Members, as expeditiously as
                               possible. I may also make it clear that if the committee feels that the report
                               of the visiting team members is contrary to any other material placed before
                               them, it is left open to the committee to disagree with the report submitted
                               by the visiting team members by recording the reasons”.

                               It is not clear from this what the impugned order is. A copy of the
                               WPMP No.17495/2010 as well as certified copy of the order dated
                               09.07.2010 called from the counsel in Andhra Pradesh.

                               The institution has also submitted BCC certificate along with Building
                               plan issued by Dy. Executive Engineer (R&B) Sub. Divn. Bodhan,
                               approved building plan and photos of the building along with letter
                               dated 16.07.2010.

                               Based carefully scrutinizing Visiting team report and related
                               evidence, and on the irrefutable VCD evidence on hand, the SRC
                               took a considered decision to reconfirm the earlier decision of
                               refusing the recognition for D.Ed. programme to the said institution.

                               The committee noted the Appellate authority order dt.21.01.2011
                               confirming the SRC’s order dt. 02.09.2010.

40.        APS08117            Pondicherry Society for Higher Education, Karaikal Disst, Pondicherry had
              M.Ed             submitted an application to southern regional committee of NCTE for grant
         Perunthalaivar        of recognition to Perunthalaivar Kamarajar College of Education, Nehru
       Kamarajar College of    Nagar, Karaikal-609605, Pondicherry for M.Ed Course of One year duration
                               on 02.01.2007.
      Education, Pondicherry
               PO              The SRC , after considering the report of the visiting team as well as other
                                                            th                             th   th
                               relevant materials in its 145 meeting of SRC held on 16 –18 october,
                               2007 and the decided to issue Conditional Recognition.

                               Accordingly conditional recognition was issued to the institution on
                               22.10.2007. The institution did not submit the reply to conditional
                               recognition. The matter was considered by SRC in its 175th Meeting held
                               on 13-14 May, 2009 meeting held on 13-14 may 2009 and decided to
                               withdraw the conditional recognition letter dated 22.10.2007 and refuse
                               recognition to the institution. Accordingly, refusal order was issued vide
                               order dt.01.06.2009.

                               The institution preferred an appeal to NCTE, Hqrs and the appellant
                               authority vide order dated 25.01.2011 has reversed the refusal order of
                               SRC with a direction to the SRC for giving three months more time for
                               appointing the qualified requisite faculty as per NCTE norms.

                               The committee considered the Appellate authority order dt.25.01.2011
                               and decided to restore Letter of Intent and to await for faculty
                               information from the institution within three months.




     (Gangadharaiah)                                                             (Prof. C. Thangamuthu)
Regional Director, SRC, NCTE                                                      Chairman, SRC, NCTE
                                                   58
                                                                                           st
                                                                                Minutes-201 Meeting of SRC
                                                                                         22-23 February 2011
41.          APS09612            Viswadarshini Charitable Society, Thiruvananthapuram, Kerala has
                B.Ed             submitted an application for seeking recognition for B.Ed course in
       Vishwadarshini College    the name and style of Viswadarshini College of Education on
      of Education, Trivandrum   24.09.2008.
                 KL
                                 The application was processed and a deficiency letter was issued to
                                 the institution on 08.10.08. The institution submitted reply on
                                 07.01.2009. The file was under process and in the meanwhile, in
                                 view of the recommendations of the State Govt of Kerala “not to
                                 further recognize/permit the institutions for conducting B.Ed course
                                 (s), a public notice was issued on 02.10.2008 to this effect that
                                 application for B.Ed courses from the State of Kerala will not be
                                 considered for the academic session 2009-2010 and all such
                                 application shall be returned along with processing fees and
                                 documents.”

                                 Accordingly, the application alongwith processing fee was returned
                                 to the applicant institution on 27.01.2009.

                                 The Institution approached the Hon‟ble High court of Kerala,
                                 through Writ Petition No.12971/2009. Shri V.M. Kurian, Advocate,
                                 in its letter dated 31.07.2009 forwarded a Certified copy of the
                                 judgement in respect of Writ Petition no. 12971/2009 filed by
                                 Vishwadarsini College of Education, Thiruvananthapuram, Kerala for
                                 B.Ed Course. The Hon‟ble High court has directed that “if the
                                 petitioner re-submit its application, pursuant to ext. P7, alongwith a
                                 copy of this Judgement, then it shall be processed and orders
                                 passed thereon by the 2nd Respondent within three months from the
                                 date of receipt of a copy of this judgement. Writ petition is disposed
                                 of as above.”

                                 In obedience to the court direction the institution has submitted
                                 application for B.Ed course alongwith processing fee of Rs 41,000/-
                                 on 06.08.2009.

                                 As per public Notice issued by NCTE-Hqrts in Times of India dated
                                 29.07.2009, a policy decision was taken by NCTE Head Quarters in
                                 consultation with the state Govt/UTs not to further recognize/permit
                                 institution for conduct of following teacher training courses for the
                                 academic session 2010-1011:-
                                 B.Ed, D.Ed, C.P.Ed, D.P.Ed, B.P.Ed, M.P.Ed

                                 The matter was placed in 181st meeting of SRC held on 21st August,
                                 2009 and the Committee decided to file an appeal against the order
                                 dated 16.07.2009 of Hon‟ble High court of Kerala. In this regard, a
                                 letter was issued to our advocate on 25.08.2009 and same was
                                 brought to the notice of NCTE -HQ also.




     (Gangadharaiah)                                                          (Prof. C. Thangamuthu)
Regional Director, SRC, NCTE                                                   Chairman, SRC, NCTE
                                                   59
                                                                                         st
                                                                              Minutes-201 Meeting of SRC
                                                                                       22-23 February 2011
                               In response to the office letter dt.25.8.2009, Shri. V.M. Kurian, legal
                               counsel for SRC has sent a letter received by this office on
                               31.08.2009 and has stated as under:-
                               “ In the Judgment, the Hon‟ble Court has only ordered the SRC to
                               process the application and to take a decision within a time frame.
                               In case the time fixed by the Hon‟ble court is inadequate or there
                               are other justifying reason, the time may be extended later. In view
                               of the Public notice, applications can be entertained for 2010-2011
                               session and processed. The court has not directed to grant
                               recognition.

                               Considered the above facts, there is no scope for filing appeal
                               against the judgment as the directions do not violate the NCTE Act,
                               Rules or Regulations under Article 226 of the constitution of India
                               High court are entitles to issue directions as above.”

                               Shri. Kurian has sent the order of Hon‟ble High court (Division
                               Bench) order dated 18.12.2009 which was received by this office
                               on 04.01.2010, wherein Hon‟ble High court has directed as under :
                               “The learned Single Judge has only directed the applicants to
                               process the application that may be resubmitted by respondent
                               No.1 and pass orders thereon irrespective of any cutoff date. In that
                               view of the matter, we do not find any reason to interfere with the
                               direction issued by the learned single judge.

                               Appellant No. 2 i.e. SRC shall process the application if it was
                               resubmitted by respondent No. 1 as directed by learned Single
                               Judge, and pass orders thereon in accordance with law. This shall
                               be done as expeditiously as possible, at any date, within one month
                               from the date of receipt of a copy of this judgement. “

                               The facts alongwith original file of the institution were placed before
                               188th meeting of SRC held on 28-29 January, 2010 wherein the
                               Regional Committee decided to cause inspection. The Committee
                               considered the matter and decided to cause inspection. The
                               Inspection   Report is considered by the Committee and the
                               Committee decided to refuse recongnition to the B.Ed. course.

                               The institution preferred appeal and the Appellate Authority vide
                               order dated21.01.2011 has confirmed the order of SRC.

                               The committee noted the Appellate authority order dt.21.01.2011
                               confirming the SRC’s order dt. 02.09.2010.




     (Gangadharaiah)                                                         (Prof. C. Thangamuthu)
Regional Director, SRC, NCTE                                                  Chairman, SRC, NCTE
                                                 60
                                                                                           st
                                                                                Minutes-201 Meeting of SRC
                                                                                         22-23 February 2011
42.         SRCAPP108            An application was submitted by Mahaboob Muslim Minority
                 B.Ed
                                 Educational Society, V.N. Nagar, VPO-Rayachoty, Dist-Kadapa,
      Vidyaniketan Educational
          Institute, Kadapa      Andhra Pradesh           had applied for grant of recognition to
                  AP
                                 Vidyanikethan Educational Institution, Street No-V.N. Nagar, VPO-
                                 Rayachoty, Dist-Kadapa, Andhra Pradesh-516269 for B.Ed course of
                                 one year duration under section 14(1) of the NCTE Act, 1993 to the
                                 SRC, NCTE on 30.10.2009.


                                 The application was processed and the deficiency letter was issued
                                 to the institution on 22.12.2009. the institution submitted its written
                                 representation on 22.02.2010.


                                 The SRC considered the matter in its 190th Meeting held on 29-30
                                 March, 2010 and on careful perusal of the original file of the
                                 institution   and   other   related   documents,   NCTE    Act   1993,
                                 Regulations and guidelines from time to time laid on the table,
                                 written representation from the institution, the regional committee
                                 decided to reject the application.


                                 Accordingly, rejection order was issued to the applicant institution on
                                 03.005.2010 as per Regional Committee.


                                 The institution preferred an appeal to NCTE, Hqrs and the appellant
                                 authority has reversed the order appealed against of SRC vide
                                 order dated 03.05.2010


                                 The committee considered the Appellate Authority order
                                 dt.01.02.2011 and decided to process the application.




     (Gangadharaiah)                                                           (Prof. C. Thangamuthu)
Regional Director, SRC, NCTE                                                    Chairman, SRC, NCTE
                                                     61
                                                                                                  st
                                                                                      Minutes-201 Meeting of SRC
                                                                                               22-23 February 2011
43.         APS00520             An application was submitted by Sree Vivekananda Teacher
               B.Ed              Education Centre Teacher Training Institute , Thrissur District,
       Vivekananda Teacher       Kerala for grant of recognition to B.Ed. course in the office of SRC-
      Education Centre, Kerala   NCTE, Bangalore. The application was processed as per the
                KL               provisions contained in Rules and Regulation, Norms and Standards
                                 in vogue at that point of time and the recognition was granted to the
                                 institution vide order dt 23.02.2005 with stipulated conditions.

                                 Subsequently an application for TTC was filed on 02.01.2006 and
                                 recognition order was issue on 16.11.2006 for conducting TTC with
                                 an intake of 50 from the year 2006.

                                 A complaint dated 05.05.2009 is received alleging lack of facilities as
                                 per NCTE norms and standards against Sree Vivekananda Teacher
                                 Education Center, Thrissur, Kerala which was placed before SRC in
                                 its 175th meeting held on 13-14 May, 2009. The Committee decided
                                 to issue showcause Notice under Section 17 of NCTE Act.
                                 Accordingly, Notice was issued to the institution on 4.6.2009
                                 followed by reminder on 27.8.2009 for the following reasons:-
                                  The Manager of the institution who is a retired Assistant Educational
                                   Officer is acting as Principal for the last six months. He is not qualified to
                                   be the Principal. All the academic activities are controlled by the
                                   Manager.
                                  The equipment‟s in the laboratories verified by the inspection team at the
                                   time giving recognition to the institution have been shifted. No additional
                                   books were purchased to the Library. Huge amount of fee is collected by
                                   the Management in the name of record fee, excursion fee, PTA fund and
                                   fee for uniform in addition to the special fee and tuition fee. The fee
                                   except tuition fee and special fee are collected without issuing receipt.
                                   PTA is not functioning in this institution even though the PTA fund is
                                   collected.

                                 The institution has submitted its reply on 10.9.2009.         SRC
                                 considered the reply of the institution and decided to cause
                                 inspection under Section 17 of NCTE Act after payment of fees of
                                 Rs.40,000/- for TTC and B.Ed. course. The institution has submitted
                                 payment of fees of Rs.40,000/- . Inspection under Section 17 was
                                 conducted to the institution on 22.3.2010.

                                 The Committee considered the visiting team report of the institution
                                 and all the relevant information available and decided to withdraw
                                 the approval for B.Ed. programme w.e.f. 2010-11 and to continue
                                 the TTC programme for which only the available built-up area is
                                 adequate.




     (Gangadharaiah)                                                                (Prof. C. Thangamuthu)
Regional Director, SRC, NCTE                                                         Chairman, SRC, NCTE
                                                     62
                                                                                               st
                                                                                   Minutes-201 Meeting of SRC
                                                                                            22-23 February 2011

                               The decision is based on the following grounds:-
                                As per the VT report, which had been admitted and duly countersigned
                                 by the Management, the built-up area available and earmarked for B.Ed.
                                 is only 10,400 sq.ft. as against the required built-up area of 16,000 sq.ft.
                                 as per the norms ; and the available and earmarked area for TTC is only
                                 4,300 sq.ft. as against the required built – up area as per norms of
                                 11,000 sq.ft. Thus, there is an aggregate shortage as high as 12,300
                                 sq.ft.; and the space as earmarked is inadequate for both the
                                 programmes. It was decided to continue the approval for TTC only, as
                                 there was no adequate space for B.Ed. though the latter was approved
                                 earlier.

                               The withdrawal of B.Ed. takes effect from 2010-11. No fresh
                               admission in B.Ed. can be made after the withdrawal orders.

                               While, the visiting team has given the actual data on built-up area, it
                               has made a wrong observation about its adequacy, for which
                               separate action is contemplated.

                               As the management itself has concurred with the VT report on built-
                               up area data,(through their counter signature), it was decided that
                               there was no need for any further notice to be sent. Already an
                               opportunity was given by the issue of Notice under Section 17 and
                               the institution‟s reply was duly considered. Now, the deficiencies
                               had been admitted by the Management itself.

                               As per the decision of SRC withdrawal order was issued on
                               04.05.2010.

                               As per the section 18 of NCTE Act, 1993 institution preferred an
                               appeal dated 12.05.2010. Appellate authority considered the appeal
                               and rejected it vide order dated 13.08.2010 and SRC‟s order dated
                               04.05.2010 was confirmed.

                               The appellate order is self speaking regarding the Regulations made
                               applicable.

                               The committee noted the Appellate authority                            order
                               dt.13.08.2010 confirming the SRC’s order dt. 04.05.2010.




     (Gangadharaiah)                                                             (Prof. C. Thangamuthu)
Regional Director, SRC, NCTE                                                      Chairman, SRC, NCTE
                                                  63
                                                                                          st
                                                                               Minutes-201 Meeting of SRC
                                                                                        22-23 February 2011
Court Cases/Appeal/Notice/Complaint/Shifting/Miscellaneous Cases:

44.           APS02200          Sri.Parshwanath College of Education for Women and
              APS02330          Sri.Parashwanath Teacher Training Institute for Women, Ajjihally
                 D.Ed           P.O. Channagiri, Davanagere – 577213, Karnataka granted
                 B.Ed           recognition by SRC for offering B.Ed and D.Ed course with an intake
      Sri Parshwanath College   of 100 and 50 students respectively. Recognition orders were
      of Education for Women    issued on 09.12.2004 & 30.11.2004.
        & Sri Parashwanath
          Teacher Training      Further, this office is in receipt of letter dated 18.09.2009 from
        Institute for Women,    NCTE, Hqrs and has forwarded a complaint received from the
             Davanagere         students of B.Ed and D.Ed course of Parshwanath College of
                  KA            Education regarding harassment by the management.

                                SRC in its 187th meeting held on 29-30 December 2009 considered
                                the matter and decided to call for remarks from the College for
                                further action. Accordingly, a letter seeking remarks was issued to
                                the institution on 09.02.2010. The institution has submitted its
                                remarks on 25.02.2010. SRC in its 189th meeting held on 25-26
                                February 2010 considered the remarks and decided to cause
                                inspection under section 17. Accordingly, inspection has been
                                carried out on 11.06.2010. SRC in its 193rd meeting held on 21-22
                                June 2010 considered the VT report and decided to withdraw
                                recognition. Accordingly, order withdrawing recognition was issued
                                on 03.08.2010.

                                The management is running D.Ed and B.Ed courses in the same
                                building/premises.

                                The institution approached the Hon'ble High Court of Karnataka in
                                W.P.2113 of 2010 and passed judgement on 19.01.2011 which
                                states as follows:
                                       “…The petitioner is permitted to file objections / explanation
                                       within a period of three weeks and if so done, the respondent-
                                       NCTE is directed to consider the same and pass orders, in
                                       accordance with law.”

                                As per the court directions, the institution has submitted its written
                                representation on 08.02.2011.

                                The Committee considered the reply of the institution, VT
                                Report and all the relevant documentary evidences and it was
                                decided to serve Final Show cause Notice Under Section 17 of
                                NCTE Act for the following :

                                 The total built-up-area earmarked for both B.Ed. & D.Ed.
                                  courses is only 9976 sq.ft against the requirement of toal
                                  32,000 sq.ft
                                 Website address is not available.




     (Gangadharaiah)                                                         (Prof. C. Thangamuthu)
Regional Director, SRC, NCTE                                                  Chairman, SRC, NCTE
                                                  64
                                                                                                  st
                                                                                     Minutes-201 Meeting of SRC
                                                                                              22-23 February 2011
                                Library can accommodate only 10 students and has only
                                 1500 books related to Education which is less than the
                                 required as per NCTE norms.
                                Equipment provided in the Science lab. is insufficient for
                                 two courses. The storage and display facilities are not
                                 available in the Science lab.
                                Equipment in E.T. lab. are inadequate.
                                Class rooms and lab. facilities are inadequate for organizing
                                 two teacher education programmes(B.Ed. and D.Ed.)
                                The staff appointed for teaching B.Ed. methodology are not
                                 qualified as per NCTE norms.

                               In view of the above, the Committee decided to issue a Final
                               Show cause Notice to the institution for unsatisfactory reply
                               submitted by the institution for Showcause Notice as to why the
                               recognition be not withdrawn and thereby providing an
                               opportunity to the institution to make a written representation
                               within 30 days from the date of issue of the Notice along with
                               necessary certificates/documents in order to take a final
                               decision in the matter; failing which action will be taken
                               including the withdrawal of recognition, based on the records
                               available, with no further notice.

45.          APS05618          AVS Teacher Training Institute, Gantekanive, N.H.206, B.H.Road,
                D.Ed           M.C.Halli Post, Tarikere Taluk, Chikmagalur District, Karnataka has
      AVS Teacher Training     submitted application to SRC for D.Ed course on 02.01.2006. The
      Institute, Chikmagalur   institution was refused recognition vide order dated 20.04.2007. The
                 KA            institution preferred appeal under section 18 of NCTE Act before
                               NCTE, New Delhi and the Appellate Authority has also confirmed the
                               orders of SRC.

                               The institution approached the Hon‟ble Court in W.P.7 of 2008 and
                               W.P.8 of 2008. Considering the writ petitions, the Hon‟ble High
                               Court of Karnataka in its judgement dated 25.08.2008 has passed
                               common judgement in both the petitions stating that:

                                      “In the instant case, it is seen from the Additional report filed, the
                                      structure existing is not said to be sufficient for the running the D.Ed
                                      course and in the circumstance it is for the petitioner to comply with
                                      the requirement of the space for running the course and also the
                                      other observations made as per the report and to comply with the
                                      same for seeking permission from the NCTE. The petitioner after
                                      such compliance would approach once again the respondent
                                      authority. The respondent authority shall consider the request of
                                      the petitioner in accordance with law at the earliest if it is found fit in
                                      accordance with law for the next academic year.”




     (Gangadharaiah)                                                               (Prof. C. Thangamuthu)
Regional Director, SRC, NCTE                                                        Chairman, SRC, NCTE
                                                  65
                                                                                           st
                                                                                Minutes-201 Meeting of SRC
                                                                                         22-23 February 2011
                               The institution in its letter dated 20.11.2008 has requested to re-
                               consider their application based on the directions of the Hon‟ble
                               court. As the directions of the Hon‟ble court was not clear, the
                               opinion from the Counsel of NCTE Sri.Ashok Haranahalli was
                               sought.

                               As per court directions and legal opinion of the advocate, a letter
                               was sent to the institution on 30.04.2009 seeking to submit duly filled
                               in questionnaire along with required documents on or before 07th
                               May 2009. The institution has submitted its written representation.
                               The same was considered by SRC in it 176th meeting held on 27-28
                               May 2009 and decided to cause re-inspection.

                               Accordingly, re-inspection of the institution was carried out on
                               08.07.2009. The re-inspection report was considered by SRC in its
                               176th meeting held on 13-14 July 2009 and decided to refuse
                               recognition.     Accordingly, order of refusal was issued to the
                               institution vide order dated 11.08.2009.

                               The institution preferred appeal and the Appellate Authority in its
                               order dated 07.06.2010 has stated as follows:

                                      “…..the appeal was accepted and set aside the order of the
                                      SRC’s order dt.11.08.2009 and remand the case to the SRC
                                      for issuance of letter of intent prior to grant of recognition
                                      under clause 7(9) of the NCTE Regulations. The final
                                      decision of the SRC, if it decides to grant recognition would,
                                      however, be made operative from the date of withdrawal of
                                      the ban on further recognition of D.Ed course in the State of
                                      Karnataka imposed by the NCTE and notified vide Public
                                      Notice dated 28.07.2009.”

                               The Appellate Authority order was placed before SRC in its 193rd
                               meeting held on 21-22 June 2010 and SRC decided as under:

                                      “The Committee noted the appellate authority order dated 7.6.2010
                                      remanding the case to the SRC and decided to issue letter of
                                      intent prior to grant of recognition under clause 7(9) of the NCTE
                                      regulations. The Committee also noted and decided that the final
                                      decision of grant recognition, if any, would, however, be made
                                      operative from the date of withdrawal of the ban of D.Ed. course in
                                      the state of Karnataka imposed by the NCTE and notified vide
                                      Public Notice dated 28.7.2009”.

                               Accordingly, a letter was issued to the institution on 10.08.2010.

                               The institution approached the Hon‟ble Court in W.P.25699 of 2010
                               and passed judgement on 18.01.2011 which reads as follows:




     (Gangadharaiah)                                                          (Prof. C. Thangamuthu)
Regional Director, SRC, NCTE                                                   Chairman, SRC, NCTE
                                                 66
                                                                                               st
                                                                                   Minutes-201 Meeting of SRC
                                                                                            22-23 February 2011
                                      The writ petition is allowed in part. The order dt.07.06.2010
                                                          st
                                      Annex.E, of the 1 respondent (NCTE, New Delhi) in so far it
                                      relates to the observation, “the final decision of SRC, if it decides to
                                      grant recognition would, however, be made operative from the date
                                      of withdrawal of the ban on further recognition of D.Ed course in the
                                      State of Karnataka imposed by the NCTE and notified vide Public
                                                                                     nd
                                      Notice dt.28.07.2009”, is quashed. The 2 respondent, SRC, is
                                      directed to comply with the order Annex.E forthwith..

                               On careful perusal of the original file of the institution, court
                               order, and other related documents, Act of NCTE, 1993,
                               Regulations and guidelines of NCTE published from time to
                               time laid on the table, the Regional Committee decided to issue
                               Letter of Intent for grant of recognition to D.Ed course of two
                               year duration with an annual intake of 50 (Fifty only)(one unit)
                               for the academic year 2011-12 subject to the appointment of
                               qualified staff through duly constituted selection committee as
                               per the Norms of NCTE/State Government/Affiliating University
                               and be given effect before the commencement of the academic
                               session.

46.       APS08069             ABR College of Education Prakasam District, Andhra Pradesh
              D.Ed
        ABR College of         ABR College of Education Prakasam District, Andhra Pradesh was
      Education, Prakasam      granted recognition for 2 year Elementary D.Ed course with 50
               AP              intake vide order dated 15.04.2008 and recognition for B.Ed with 100
                               intake from 2007-08 is given vide order dated 06.09.2007.

                               A complaint was received from Sri. G. Eswaraiah, General
                               Secretary, ALL INDIA YOUTH FEDERATION (AIYF) on 22.07.2010
                               in the office of SRC and SRC had written a letter to the complainant
                               on 09.08.2010 with the request to submit affidavit of Rs.100/-. In
                               response to this office letter dated 09.08.2010 the complainant has
                               submitted affidavit on 24.08.2010. and has raised the following
                               points against ABR College of Education, Prakasam, Andhra
                               Pradesh.

                               The committee in its 196th meeting held on 15-16 September 2010
                               considered the matter and decided to call for remarks from the
                               institution

                               As per the decision of SRC a letter was issued on 28.10.2010 and
                               Institution submitted its reply on 23.04.2010.

                               The committee considered the reply submitted by the institution
                               and has noted the contents.




     (Gangadharaiah)                                                             (Prof. C. Thangamuthu)
Regional Director, SRC, NCTE                                                      Chairman, SRC, NCTE
                                                  67
                                                                                            st
                                                                                 Minutes-201 Meeting of SRC
                                                                                          22-23 February 2011
47.       APS08525             Annamalai University, Directorate of Distance Education,
           B.Ed-DE             Annamalai Nagar, Tamilnadu.
      Annamalai University,
          Cuddalore            As per the decision of SRC in its 198th meeting held on 24th-26th
             TN                November 2010, clarification letter was issued to the university on
                               03.01.2011.

                               The university submitted its reply to clarification letter dated
                               03.01.2011 on 27.01.2011 & 31.01.2011.
                               Meanwhile, another complaint has been received from Peasant
                               Social Action Team on 27.12.2010 and the same has been
                               forwarded by NCTE-Hqrs 03.01.2011 regarding over strength of
                               students admitted in B.Ed, M.Ed and B.Ed-DE programme in
                               Annamalai University for action. SRc considered the complaint in its
                               200th meeting held on 20th-21st January 2011 and noted the
                               complaint and decided to call for affidavit from the complainant and
                               comments from the university on the complaint without waiting for
                               confirmation of minutes.

                               As per the decision of SRC in its 200th meeting held on 20th-21st
                               January 2011 a letter was issued seeking comments from the
                               university on complaint of Shri. V. Rajarathinam, Peasant Social
                               Action Forum, Chidambaram, Tamilnadu on 04.02.2011 and to
                               Complainant on 04.02.2011.

                               The university submitted its reply stating as follows:

                               “The complaint about admitting more number of students by Annamalai
                               university in B.Ed, M.Ed and B.Ed (DDE) are absolutely false. There are
                               some vested interest people who are against the growth of Annamalai
                               university are making such kind of representations.
                               The Annamalai university is running all the above mentioned courses as
                               per the norms of NCTE and the State Government. The inspection team
                               from SRC Bangalore and NCTE Head Quarters conducted surprise
                               inspection on 21, 22 November 2010 and 6.12.2010 respectively in the
                               Department of Education and Directorate of Distance Education, Annamalai
                               University. They made a physical verification of the instructional and
                               infrastructural facilities of the courses B.Ed, M.Ed, B.Ed(DDE) they were
                               very much pleased with the facilities and they have appreciated the way the
                               courses have been conducted. Further, based on the report of committees
                               the SRC, Bangalore sought some clarification on 03.01.2011. We gave
                               reply appropriately with necessary documents on 27.01.2011. Above all we
                               are very much shocked to see another letter from the NCTE seeking reply
                               for the same complaints.
                               We have ascertained to NCTE earlier through the records that we have
                               admitted 300 students in B.Ed and 70 students in M.Ed programme on
                               campus and 500 students for B.Ed programme under Distance Education.
                               This has also been verified by the NCTE visiting team members twice.
                               The complaint of the nature is being done repeatedly by some mischievous
                               elements. We request the NCTE in future may kindly ignore this kind of
                               representations.




     (Gangadharaiah)                                                           (Prof. C. Thangamuthu)
Regional Director, SRC, NCTE                                                    Chairman, SRC, NCTE
                                                  68
                                                                                             st
                                                                                  Minutes-201 Meeting of SRC
                                                                                           22-23 February 2011
                               There are some person with vested interest of his own exploiting and
                               harassing the university for their personal gain and tarnishing the name and
                               fame of the university by writing letters to various authorities in the
                               administrative.
                               We absolutely ascertain that we are strictly adhering to the norms of NCTE
                               and state Government in running the B.Ed, M.Ed on campus and B.Ed
                               (Distance Education) programme”.

                               The University is also running a regular B.Ed and M.Ed course.

                               Reply from the complainant is not received yet.

                               The committee considered the reply submitted by the University
                               and has noted the contents.

48.        APS02985            Yanam Educational Society‟s Yanam School of Education,
            D.T.Ed             Gandhinagar, Yanam, Pondicherry submitted an application for grant
        Yanam School of        of recognition for D.T.Ed course and recognition was granted to the
        Education, Yanam       institution vide SRC order dated 18.10.2005 for 100 seats.
               PO
                               A complaint was received on 25.05.2010 in the office of SRC against
                               Yanam School of Education. The Committee considered the
                               complaint in 194th meeting held on 21-22 July, 2010 and decided to
                               call for remarks from the institution.

                               As per the decision of SRC clarification letter was issued on
                               18.11.2010. Institution submitted reply on 27.12.2010. The institution
                               in its letter dated 14.10.2009 has submitted a proposal for shifting of
                               premises along with Rs.40000/- towards shifting fee. Accordingly,
                               inspection was carried out on 23.10.2010. The inspection report has
                               been received along with VCD.

                               The Committee in its 198th meeting held on 24-26 November 2010
                               considered the VT Report, VCD and all the relevant documentary
                               evidences and it was decided to serve Show cause Notice Under
                               Section 17.
                                Land Use Certificate and building approval plan is to be
                                   submitted.
                                Building Completion Certificate duly signed by the competent
                                   Engineer is to be submitted.
                                To submit the documents for having deposited the Endowment
                                   Fund and Reserve fund of Rs. 5 lakhs and 3 lakhs respectively
                                   for each course separately.
                                The details of the number of admissions made for the past three
                                   years is to be submitted.
                                Details of the teaching staff, name, date of Birth, Designation,
                                   qualification, years of experience duly approved by the
                                   competent affiliating authority along with Certificates of Marks
                                   sheets and appointment orders are to be submitted.




     (Gangadharaiah)                                                            (Prof. C. Thangamuthu)
Regional Director, SRC, NCTE                                                     Chairman, SRC, NCTE
                                                  69
                                                                                          st
                                                                               Minutes-201 Meeting of SRC
                                                                                        22-23 February 2011
                               Notice was issued on 19.01.2011. The institution submitted reply on
                               17.02.2011 and it was placed in 201st meeting held on 22-23
                               February 2011.

                               The committee considered the reply submitted by the institution
                               and as the reply was found to be unsatisfactory and
                               unconvincing, it was decided to withdraw recognition for D.T.Ed
                               course (APS02985) with effect from 2012-13, in order to enable
                               the ongoing batch of students in D.T.Ed course, if any, to
                               complete their course.

                               But it is made clear that the institution is debarred from making
                               any further admission subsequent to the date of issue of this
                               order.

                               The Affiliating body / Examining board / body be informed
                               accordingly.

                               Further decided to return Endowment funds and Reserve fund
                               deposited with SRC NCTE, Bangalore if any.

49.        APS07037            Residency College of Education, H No. 4/21 Main Road, Rajampet,
              B.Ed             Cuddapah-516115, Andhra Pradesh. was granted recognition for
      Residency College of     B.Ed Course with an annual intake of 100 students vide order dated
      Education, Cuddapah      28.09.2007
               AP
                               The SRC, NCTE, Bangalore received a written remarks on the
                               deficiencies pointed out by the Dean, Faculty of Education,
                               Sri.Venkateshwara University, Tirupati,A.P.

                               SRC in its 195th Meeting held on 17-18 August, 2010 considered the
                               letter received from S. V. University and decided to call for
                               clarification from the institution. Accordingly, a letter was issued to
                               the institution for seeking clarification on 27.09.2010. The institution
                               has submitted its clarification on 13.10.2010

                               SRC considered the reply submitted by the institution and has
                               noted the contents.




     (Gangadharaiah)                                                         (Prof. C. Thangamuthu)
Regional Director, SRC, NCTE                                                  Chairman, SRC, NCTE
                                                 70
                                                                                                  st
                                                                                      Minutes-201 Meeting of SRC
                                                                                               22-23 February 2011
50.          APS09043            M.S.C. Educational Society, Mahabubnagar District, Andhra Pradesh
                HPT              had applied for grant of recognition to Amritha Akshitha College of
      Amritha Akshitha College   Education, Metpalli Post and Mandal, Wanaparthy, Mahabubnagar
            of Education,        District-509193, Andhra Pradesh for HPT Course of two year
           Mahabubnagar          duration under Section 14(I) of the NCTE Act, 1993 to the Southern
                 AP              Regional Committee, NCTE.

                                 The competent authority had constituted a Visiting Team to visit the
                                 institution and the visiting team had since submitted its report.

                                 SRC in its 160th meeting held on 31st July & 1st August, 2008 the
                                 Southern Regional Committee after considering the report of the
                                 visiting team as well as other relevant materials furnished by the
                                 applicant institution, was satisfied that the applicant institution did not
                                 fulfill the requirements and issued a notice on 08.08.2008. The
                                 applicant institution had submitted its written representation dated
                                 08.09.2008 to SRC, NCTE. The said representation of the institution
                                 as well as other documents and materials submitted by the institution
                                 along with VTR and videography were again duly considered by the
                                 Southern Regional Committee on 164th meeting held on 20th
                                 September, 2008, and decided to refuse recognition.

                                 Accordingly, refusal order was issued to the institution on
                                 23.09.2008. Aggrieved by the refusal order of SRC, the institution
                                 preferred an appeal to NCTE-Hqrs. The appellate authority in its
                                 order dated 19.12.2008 confirms the order appealed against.

                                 The institution approached to the Hon‟ble High Court of Andhra
                                 Pradesh in W.P.No.3966 of 2009 praying that the orders of refusal
                                 issued by the 2nd respondent and confirmed by the 1st respondent
                                 and quash the same and consequently direct the respondents to
                                 consider the application of the petitioner to grant recognition for
                                 starting HPT course taking into consideration the report submitted by
                                 the visiting team dated 08.05.2008.

                                 The Court has ordered interalia states “Since the impugned order of
                                                           nd                                       st
                                 rejection, passed by the 2 respondent, as confirmed by the 1 respondent
                                 in appeal rejecting the application of the petitioner for grant of permission to
                                 run Hindi Pandit Training course, is without considering the important and
                                 relevant material, the same cannot be sustained, and they are accordingly
                                 set aside, and the matter is remitted to the respondents for consideration of
                                 the matter afresh.

                                 Accordingly, the writ petition is allowed. The respondents are directed to
                                 consider the application of the petitioner for grant of permission to run Hindi
                                 Pandit Course afresh in the light of the materials placed before the court,
                                 particularly the building plan and the inspection report of the visiting team,
                                 which inspected the premises of the petitioner, pursuant to the application
                                 for grant of permission, and pass appropriate orders thereon in accordance
                                 with law expeditiously. No costs.




     (Gangadharaiah)                                                                 (Prof. C. Thangamuthu)
Regional Director, SRC, NCTE                                                          Chairman, SRC, NCTE
                                                     71
                                                                                            st
                                                                                 Minutes-201 Meeting of SRC
                                                                                          22-23 February 2011
                               The matter was placed before SRC in its 177th meeting held on 22-
                               23 June, 2009, the Committee considered Hon‟ble High Court of
                               Judicature, Andhra Pradesh order in its W.P.No.3966 of 2009,
                               documents in original file, inspection report, video CD and written
                               representation of the institution dated 12.6.2009 and earlier
                               decisions of the Committee in respect of stopping recognitions of
                               language pandit courses in the State of Andhra Pradesh and noted
                               the following: -
                                                 th
                                SRC in its 169 meeting held on 12-13 January, 2009 considered the
                                 letter dated 07/01/2009 of State Government of Andhra Pradesh
                                 wherein Principal Secretary of Education has requested NCTE “not to
                                 accord further recognition/permission to the new colleges/private B.Ed,
                                 D.Ed, Physical Education, Language Pandit in the State of Andhra
                                 Pradesh as above colleges are exceeding in numbers than required”.
                                 The SRC decided to give effect to the decision of State Government of
                                 Andhra Pradesh as such with immediate effect.

                               Further, the letter dated 17/03/2009 was received from NCTE-HQ
                               informing that the “The recommendations of the Govt. of Andhra
                               Pradesh not to grant recognition/permission in respect of other
                               courses like B.Ed,D.Ed and Physical Education courses have further
                               been considered in NCTE and it has been decided that no further
                               recognition/Permission to any institution in the State of Andhra
                               Pradesh be considered by SRC for the academic session 2009-10
                               for B.Ed, D.ED, and Physical Education courses also”.

                               It was noted that SRC in its 172nd meeting held on 25th-26th March
                               2009 decided to accept the recommendation of the State
                               Government of Andhra Pradesh, not to grant recognition to any of
                               the Teacher Training institutions in the State of Andhra Pradesh for
                               the year 2009-10.

                               In view of the decisions of Committee for stopping Language Pandit
                               course recognitions in Andhra Pradesh, as per the orders of the
                               State Government, after consideration of NCTE Act, regulations,
                               policy decisions, Hon‟ble High Court order, the Committee, decided
                               to refuse recognition to the proposed course as per Section 14(3)(b)
                               of NCTE Act.

                               As per the decision of SRC refusal order was issued to the institution
                               on 13.07.2009. The Institute has approached to Hon‟ble High Court
                               in W.P.No.30506/2010.
                               Now, the Hon‟ble High Court has passed an order on 13.08.2010 as
                               hereunder:
                               “In the light of he orders passed by this court in similar W.P.Nos.6712 of
                                                                                                        st
                               2009, 9360and 11078 of 2010, there shall be a direction to the 1
                               respondent to consider the petitioner’s application for starting H.P.T.,
                               institutions in accordance with law without reference to the State
                               Government’s policy dated 7.01.2009.
                               Post along with W.P.Nos6712 of 2009, 9360of 2010 and 11078 of 2010”.




     (Gangadharaiah)                                                           (Prof. C. Thangamuthu)
Regional Director, SRC, NCTE                                                    Chairman, SRC, NCTE
                                                  72
                                                                                        st
                                                                             Minutes-201 Meeting of SRC
                                                                                      22-23 February 2011
                               SRC considered the matter and directed the Management/institution
                               to resubmit the old application returned by SRC along with
                               necessary documents as originally submitted relating to land,
                               building, FDR, Application fee, Building Completion Certificate from
                               competent Government Engineer/ authority and other relevant
                               aspects for processing and for necessary action.

                               In response to SRC letter dated 25.10.2010, the institution has
                               submitted reply vide letter dated 15.11.2010.

                               SRC in tis 198th meeting held on 24-26 November 2010 considered
                               the written representation and decided to issue Showcause Notice.
                               Accordingly, Showcause Notice was issued to the infrastructural &
                               instructional facilities for seeking clarification on 10.01.2011. the
                               institution has submitted its written representation on 20.01.2011.

                               The Committee considered the reply to Show Cause Notice, VT
                               Report, VCD and all the relevant documentary evidences and it
                               was decided to serve Final Showcause Notice Under Section 17
                               of NCTE Act for the following :

                                Building completion certificate in the prescribed format from
                                 the Government authorised Engineer is to be submitted.
                                Affidavit in Rs. 100/- stamp paper in the prescribed format
                                 with Notary attestation should be submitted.

                               In view of the above, the Committee decided to issue a Final
                               Showcause Notice to the institution as to why the recognition
                               be not withdrawn and thereby providing an opportunity to the
                               institution to make a written representation within 30 days from
                               the date of issue of the Notice along with necessary
                               certificates/documents in order to take a final decision in the
                               matter; failing which action will be taken including the
                               withdrawal of Recognition, based on the records available, with
                               no further notice.




     (Gangadharaiah)                                                       (Prof. C. Thangamuthu)
Regional Director, SRC, NCTE                                                Chairman, SRC, NCTE
                                                 73
                                                                                                    st
                                                                                       Minutes-201 Meeting of SRC
                                                                                                22-23 February 2011
51.         APS02774           Venkateshwara Teacher Training Institute, 10-A, Maraimalai Adigal
               B.Ed            Salai Pondicherry-600501. was granted recognition for B.Ed course
      Venkateshwara Teacher    with an intake of 100 students vide order dated 28.10.2004.
         Training Institute,
           Pondicherry         NCTE-Hqrs. has forwarded inspection report under Section 13 of the
                PO             NCTE Act, inspection was caused in respect of Venkateshwara
                               Teacher Training Institute on 20.4.2009. It is observed from the
                               inspection report that the institution shifted to its new premises
                               without its inspection by the SRC and without payment of the
                               requisite fee by the institution. Moreover, even in the new building
                               the multipurpose hall is smaller in size. Further, the library is not
                               equipped with books and seating capacity in accordance with the
                               norms of the NCTE. It is also not clear whether salaries to the staff
                               are being paid through bank. It is requested to issue show cause
                               notice to the institution for violation of the regulations and norms of
                               NCTE, under intimation to us.

                               The Extract of the overall assessment of the institution is as follows:

                               “The institution has been shifted to the present campus “Radhaboobalan
                               Educational Campus, J.J. Nagar Extn. Moolakulam, Puducherry” in the
                               beginning of the academic year 2009-2010 under intimation to the NCTE
                                         th
                               dated 4 July, 2008 (Lr. No. VETRI/TTI-074/2008 dated 04.7.2008). Two
                               institutions viz. Venkateswara College of Education and Venkateswara
                               Teacher Training Institute are functioning in the same campus. The college
                               of education is housed in the ground floor and the teacher training institute
                               in the first floor. Except the playground, all other facilities are available for
                               the institutions separately. The infrastructural facilities and academic
                               facilities available for the training institute are satisfactory. The institution is
                               functioning properly”.

                               The institution submitted inspection fee on 14.7.2008 for causing
                               inspection for shifting of premises. Thereafter on 26.5.2009 a letter
                               was written to the institution calling for land documents, FDRs. No
                               reply has been received from the institution so far.

                               SRC in its 184th meeting held on 26-27 October 2009 has decided to
                               cause inspection under Section 17 of NCTE Act, on submission of all
                               related documents including filled in Questionnaire.

                               Accordingly, inspection was carried out on 14.10.2010.

                               SRC in its 198th meeting held on 24th –26th November, 2010
                               considered the VT Report and all the relevant documentary
                               evidences and it was decided to issue Show cause Notice Under
                               Section 17 of NCTE Act . Accordingly, a show cause notice was
                               issued to the institution for seeking clarification on 17.01.2011. The
                               institution has submitted its written representation on 13.01.2011,
                               the institution has already obtained information from the Website,




     (Gangadharaiah)                                                                 (Prof. C. Thangamuthu)
Regional Director, SRC, NCTE                                                          Chairman, SRC, NCTE
                                                    74
                                                                                           st
                                                                                Minutes-201 Meeting of SRC
                                                                                         22-23 February 2011
                               The Committee considered the reply to Show Cause Notice, VT
                               Report, VCD and all the relevant documentary evidences and it
                               was decided to serve final Showcause Notice Under Section 17
                               of NCTE Act for the following :

                                Building completion certificate in the prescribed format
                                 issued by Government Engineer/competent authority is to
                                 be submitted.
                                Non-Encumbrance certificate issued by the competent
                                 authority is to be submitted.

                               In view of the above, the Committee decided to issue a final
                               Showcause Notice to the institution as to why the recognition
                               be not withdrawn and thereby providing an opportunity to the
                               institution to make a written representation within 30 days from
                               the date of issue of the Notice along with necessary
                               certificates/documents in order to take a final decision in the
                               matter; failing which action will be taken including the
                               withdrawal of Recognition, based on the records available, with
                               no further notice.

52.        APS07104            A.M Reddy College of Education, Petluvari Palem, Narasaraopet
              B.Ed             Mandal, Guntur District-522601, Andhra Pradesh has made an
      A.M. Reddy College of    application on 31.03.2006 for B.Ed course to SRC, NCTE,
        Education, Guntur      Bangalore.
               AP
                               The SRC after considering the report of the visiting team as well as
                               other relevant materials, granted recognition to the institution for
                               offering B.Ed course with an intake of 100 students from the session
                               2007-2008 vide order no. F.SRO/NCTE/B.Ed/2006-2007/3330 dated
                               26.05.2007.

                               The Government of Andhra Pradesh vide letter dated 06.03.2007
                               forwarded a list of institutions not recommending the name of
                               colleges with the specific reasons with a request to NCTE-SRC to
                               take necessary action against the institutions, this institution is one of
                               the institutions not recommended.

                               The matter was placed before the SRC in its 150th meeting held on
                               28th – 29th December, 2007. The SRC after careful consideration of
                               all aspects decided to conduct the inspection of the institution under
                               section 17. The inspection of the institution was conducted on
                               22.04.2008 and the report was received. The report was considered
                               by SRC in its 161st meeting held on 6th –7th August, 2008 and upon
                               consideration of all aspects it was decided to serve a showcause
                               notice to the institution under section 17 of NCTE Act 1993.




     (Gangadharaiah)                                                           (Prof. C. Thangamuthu)
Regional Director, SRC, NCTE                                                    Chairman, SRC, NCTE
                                                  75
                                                                                              st
                                                                                   Minutes-201 Meeting of SRC
                                                                                            22-23 February 2011
                               Accordingly, a showcause notice was served to the institution vide
                               dated 25.08.2008. the reply received vide dated 03.10.2008 was
                               placed before SRC in its 166th meeting held on 18th – 19th October,
                               2008. The SRC considered the points raised in the showcause
                               notice, the deficiencies pointed out in the report forwarded by State
                               Government, VCD, two visiting team reports under section 14 and
                               under section 17 of NCTE Act, 1993, and decided to withdraw the
                               recognition from the academic session 2008-2009.

                               Accordingly, a withdrawal of recognition order was issued to the
                               institution on 22.10.2008 for the proposed B.Ed course as per
                               section 15(3)(b) of NCTE Act.

                               The applicant institution preferred an appeal under Section 18 of
                               NCTE Act, before NCTE, New Delhi. The Appellate Authority
                               considering the appeal passed an order vide.F.No.89-360/2008
                               dated 09.02.2009 confirming the decision of SRC.

                               Further the institution has approached Hon‟ble High Court of Andhra
                               Pradesh in Writ Petition No.3609 of 2009. The court has passed an
                               order dated 02.08.2010 as under:
                                      1. The impugned orders dated 09.02.2009 22.10.2008 if
                                         respondent Nos.1 and 2 respectively are set aside.
                                      2. The petitioner shall complete the new building with all facilities
                                         necessary for running the college by the first week of October,
                                         2010. It shall pay the inspection and shifting fees to respondent
                                         No.2 within a period of four weeks from today. Respondent
                                         No.2 is entitled to depute an inspection team in the first week of
                                         October, 2010, by which time, the petitioner shall make the
                                         building ready for inspection.
                                      3. On the basis of the repot to be submitted by the inspection
                                         team respondent No.2 shall take a fresh decision and pending
                                         the decision the petitioner college shall be included in the list of
                                         the colleges eligible for admission of the students for the
                                         academic year 2010-2011. If an adverse report is submitted by
                                         the inspection team, respondent No.2 shall be free to pass
                                         appropriate orders in accordance with the provisions of the Act
                                         and the regulations made thereunder.
                               The institution has not submitted any fees and other relevant
                               documents as yet.

                               SRC in its 197th meeting held on 13th –14th October, 2010considered
                               the matter and all the relevant documents and it was decided to
                               issue Showcause Notice Under Section 17 of NCTE Act.
                               Accordingly, a show cause notice was issued to the institution for
                               seeking clarification on 01.12.2010. The institution has submitted its
                               written representation on 03.01.2011

                               The committee considered the written representation and
                               decided to cause inspection.




     (Gangadharaiah)                                                             (Prof. C. Thangamuthu)
Regional Director, SRC, NCTE                                                      Chairman, SRC, NCTE
                                                  76
                                                                                         st
                                                                              Minutes-201 Meeting of SRC
                                                                                       22-23 February 2011
53.        APS01696            Halappa Kote B.Ed College, Mailoor Road, Near Lidkar Office, Bidar
              B.Ed             District-585403, Karnataka was granted recognition for offering B.Ed
       Halappa Kote B.Ed       course with an annual intake of 100 students vide order dated
         College, Bidar        29.11.2004.
               KA
                               A clipping has appeared in Deccan Herald newspaper clipping dated
                               08.01.2011 pertaining to Halappa Kote B.Ed College, Mailoor Road,
                               Near Lidkar Office, Bidar District-585403, Karnataka (APS01696)
                               stating that “the Assistant Superintendent of Police Y. Ravi has
                               made a surprise visit to the college and found instances of mass
                               copying. The students who were found copying, were appearing for
                               B.Ed second semester Psychology paper.

                               It is alleged that the college authorities had connived with the
                               students that remained largely unnoticed, including in a college run
                               by Vidya Vikas Trust at Naubad.

                               The incident came to light when a few journalists visited the Kote
                               college to verify reports of mass copying. But the institution chairman
                               Bakappa kote abused the journalists for visiting the examination hall.

                               In the meantime, Deputy Commissioner made a surprise visit to the
                               examination rooms along with other officials. Students were frisked
                               and pieces of paper were found on students. Besides, the students
                               were allowed to have their mobile phones in the examination hall.
                               According to sources, a few institutions collected money from
                               students for copying. Examinations conducted on January 6th and 7th
                               2011 at the centres will be held again.

                               SRC in its 200th meeting held on 20-21 January 2011 considered
                               the complaint and decided to call remarks from the College and
                               University. Accordingly, a letter to the institution was issued on
                               19.01.2011. The institution has submitted its remarks on 07.02.2011
                               by enclosing a copy of the squad Report from the Registrar
                               (Evaluation), Gulbarga University, Gulbarga.

                               The Committee considered the remarks received from the
                               institution and has noted the contents.

54.        APS00391            Notre Dame Junior College of Education, No.70, Palace Road,
           APS03561            C/o.Sophia High School, Bangalore-560001, Karnataka has been
              D.Ed             granted recognition with an intake of 40 students (APS00391) on
            D.Ed-AI            25.02.2002 and additional intake of 10 students (APS03564) on
       Notre Dame Junior       30.01.2006 thus making annual intake of 50 students. The exams of
      College of Education,    the institution are being conducted by the Commissioner, Bureau of
           Bangalore           Government Examinations, Maharastra State, Shivaji Nagar, Pune-
               KA              05, Maharashtra.




     (Gangadharaiah)                                                         (Prof. C. Thangamuthu)
Regional Director, SRC, NCTE                                                  Chairman, SRC, NCTE
                                                 77
                                                                                          st
                                                                               Minutes-201 Meeting of SRC
                                                                                        22-23 February 2011
                               SRC, NCTE is in receipt of unsigned complaint on 02.06.2010 on
                               behalf of the guardians and parents from Tamilnadu, Kerala,
                               Karnataka. In complaint it has been stated that Notre Dame Jr.
                               College of Education is not recognised by any State Government.
                               The Maharastra Government is conducting the exam. But certificate
                               are being issued and who pass out from the college are finding it
                               difficult to get into job. The complainant has also stated that why the
                               NCTE‟s name is used.

                               The Maharashtra State (under Jurisdiction of WRC) Government‟s
                               circular dated 12.07.1976 has been annexed which allows students
                               of Notre Dame Junior College of Education to appear for the
                               “Trained Teacher‟s Certificate Exam” exclusively for Anglo- Indian
                               Schools. A marks sheet dated May 2009 issued by Maharashtra
                               Government Council of Exam, Pune is also attached to
                               representation which establishes that still the Maharashtra State
                               Council of Examinations, Pune is awarding Trained Teachers
                               Certificate (for Anglo- Indian Schools).

                               Government of Karnataka during 15.05.1975 have issued NOC for
                               conducting examination for Training Teachers Certificate for Anglo
                               Indian Schools conducted by the Government of Maharashtra.

                               A letter seeking clarification was sent to institution on 19.07.2010
                               with a copy to the concerned.          In response to the letter, the
                               institution has submitted its reply on 29.07.2010 and has stated that
                               the recognition has been granted by NCTE with an annual intake of
                               90 students. Further, a letter has been received from Maharasthra
                               State Council of Examination, Pune on 08.02.2011 and has stated
                               that, according to the Govt Resloution No TCM 2977/34506/2497
                               XXVII dated on 1st July 1978 the revised course for the Trained
                               Teacher‟s Certificate Examination formulated by the interstate Board
                               of Anglo Indian Education, New Delhi has been introduced with
                               effect from 1973. It was also recognised by State Government on
                               19th February 1981. The Notre Dame Junior College of Education,
                               Bangalore has already granted recognition by NCTE SRC on
                               25.02.2007.

                               The Maharashtra State Council of Examination has also stated that
                               as per the NCTE Act 1993, Chapter IV-6(A) when grants recognition
                               to institute, it is essential to conduct the examination of the students
                               admitted in such institute as the Maharasthra State Council of
                               Examination is a examining body. The council has requested SRC
                               to neglect the complaint against the institution.

                               The Committee considered the clarification letter received from
                               the Maharashtra State Counil of Examination and has noted the
                               contents.




     (Gangadharaiah)                                                         (Prof. C. Thangamuthu)
Regional Director, SRC, NCTE                                                  Chairman, SRC, NCTE
                                                 78
                                                                                         st
                                                                              Minutes-201 Meeting of SRC
                                                                                       22-23 February 2011
55.        APS00049            Hannamma Christian College of Education, Y.M.R. Colony,
              B.Ed             Proddatur, Cuddapah-516361, Andhra Pradesh was granted
      Hannamma Christian       recognition for B.Ed course from the academic session 2004-05 with
      College of Education,    annual intake of 120 students vide order dated 19.09.2004.
           Cuddapah
               AP              NCTE Hqrs. has forwarded copy of complaint dated 05.03.2006
                               received from Shri.B.S.Lambert, Correspondent of Vijay Vidyodaya
                               Samajam Proddatur-516361, Cuddapah (Dist.) Andhra Pradesh
                               alongwith its enclosures against Hannamma College of Education,
                               Proddatur-Kadapa, Dist., Andhra Pradesh with request to take
                               appropriate necessary action.

                               The complainant has raised grievances against the institution as
                               under:-

                                  Not having approved teaching & non teaching staff.
                                  They are managing with the Govt. Employees in running the
                                   college as teaching staff.
                                  Filling others certificates & photos to inspiring authority.
                                  Not having their own building registered in the name of college.

                               In as much as they do not have any infrastructure for the college it is
                               only proper to withdrawal the recognition.

                               The Government of Andhra Pradesh has already declared the trust
                               of this Hannamma College i.e., Douglas as “Bogus” and with this
                               stigma how the management can further continue to run the B.Ed.,
                               College.

                               The SRC in its 195th meeting held on 17-18 August, 2010 considered
                               the matter and decided to issue Notice Under Section 17 of NCTE.
                               Notice was issued to the institution on 18.11.2010. The institution
                               has submitted its written representation 21.12.2010.

                               The Committee considered the reply to Show Cause Notice, VT
                               Report, VCD and all the relevant documentary evidences and it
                               was decided to serve Final Showcause Notice Under Section 17
                               of NCTE Act for the following :

                                Building completion certificate issued by competent
                                 Government Engineer/authority to be submitted.
                                Land Usage Certificate issued by the Competent
                                 Government authority to be submitted for the land in which
                                 building is located along with survey nos.
                                Building plan duly approved by the competent authority
                                 showing the land area, built up area and survey nos. is to be
                                 submitted.




     (Gangadharaiah)                                                         (Prof. C. Thangamuthu)
Regional Director, SRC, NCTE                                                  Chairman, SRC, NCTE
                                                 79
                                                                                        st
                                                                             Minutes-201 Meeting of SRC
                                                                                      22-23 February 2011
                                FDR submitted by the institution is laminated and is not
                                 acceptable. Hence the institution has to submit original
                                 FDRs.
                                The authentication of the FDRs are to be certified by the
                                 Bank.

                               In view of the above, the Committee decided to issue a Final
                               Showcause Notice to the institution as to why the recognition
                               be not withdrawn and thereby providing an opportunity to the
                               institution to make a written representation within 30 days from
                               the date of issue of the Notice along with necessary
                               certificates/documents in order to take a final decision in the
                               matter; failing which action will be taken including the
                               withdrawal of Recognition, based on the records available, with
                               no further notice.

56.        APS00300            An application was submitted by Ramaraja Womens College of
              B.Ed             Education,Tirupati, Andhra Pradesh for grant of recognition to B.Ed.,
              D.Ed             & D.Ed course in the office of SRC-NCTE, Bangalore on 31.12.2001
       Ramaraja Women‟s
      College of Education,    The application was processed as per the provisions contained in
            Tirupathi          Rules and Regulation, Norms and Standards vogue at that point of
               AP              time and the recognition was granted to the institution vide order dt
                               04.04.2003 with stipulated conditions.

                               Shifting proposal was submitted by the institution on 20.09.2007.
                               Shifting inspection was conducted on 20.09.2010.

                               The SRC, NCTE, Bangalore received a written remarks on the
                               deficiencies pointed out by the Dean, Faculty of Education,
                               Sri.Venkateshwara University, Tirupati, A.P.
                               The Committee in its 195th Meeting held on 17-18 August 2010
                               considered the deficiencies pointed out in the staff list and decided
                               to call for clarification from the institution.

                               As per the decision of SRC notice was issued to the institution on
                               27.09.2010. Institution submitted reply on 25.10.2010.

                               The Visiting Team report was placed before SRC in its 197th meeting
                               held on 13th and 14th October, 2010 and decided to serve
                               Showcause Notice Under Section 17. As per the decision of SRC
                               show cause notice was issued on 03.12.2010. Institution submitted
                               reply on 07.01.2011.

                               The Committee considered the written representation from the
                               institution dt. 07.01.2011 to the show cause notice and all other
                               related documents along with the original file of the institution,
                               and decided shifting to new/permanent premises permitted.




     (Gangadharaiah)                                                       (Prof. C. Thangamuthu)
Regional Director, SRC, NCTE                                                Chairman, SRC, NCTE
                                                 80
                                                                                           st
                                                                                Minutes-201 Meeting of SRC
                                                                                         22-23 February 2011
57.       APS06034             Thorrur College of Education, Khammam District, Andhra Pradesh
              B.Ed             has made an application for B.Ed course to Southern Regional
       Thorrur College of      Committee, NCTE, Bangalore.
      Education, Khammam
               AP              The application was processed and after considering the report of
                               the Visiting Team as well as other relevant materials granted
                               recognition to the institution for offering B.Ed course with an intake of
                               100 students from the session 2002 -2003 vide order No.678 dated
                               12.04.2007.
                               The Registrar, Kakatiya University, Warangal vide letter
                               dt.14.03.2008 drawn the attention of Regional Director, SRC and
                               informed that in the process of granting temporary affiliation to the
                               institutions the university conducted inspection and observed that
                               the institution is located in a Commercial Complex. The ground floor
                               is full of shops, first floor is residential complex and second floor is
                               accommodated for temporary B.Ed. course.
                               The letter was placed before the SRC in its 157th meeting held on
                               23rd-24th April 2008. The SRC after careful consideration of all
                               aspects decided to issue show cause notice. Accordingly, a show
                               cause notice was issued on 28.05.2008 to the institution. In
                               response to the notice the applicant institution replied on 25.08.2008
                               as under” the construction of the building for permanent
                               accommodation to the Thorrur College of Education was completed
                               recently. Due to heavy rain it was delayed for few days. This college
                               will be shifted to the newly constructed premises on 10.09.2008 from
                               the existing temporary accommodation premise”. The reply was
                               placed before SRC in its 161st meeting held on 6th-7th August 2008.
                               The SRC has decided and resolved to cause inspection under
                               Section 17 to verify the infrastructural and instructional facilities.

                               The SRC-NCTE conducted an inspection of the institution under
                               section 17 of NCTE Act 1993 on 16.09.2008. The report received
                               from the visiting team informs as follows: That management is not
                               ready to face the inspection now on 16.09.2008 because of various
                               factors and asked for postponement of the inspection by three more
                               months. The institution not cooperated in carrying out inspection of
                               institution as per the Provisions of NCTE Act.
                               Therefore, the SRC-NCTE in its 165th meeting held on 27th-28th
                               September, 2008 on careful perusal of the original file of the
                               institution, two visiting team report under section 14 & 17, the letter
                               dated 14.03.2008 from the Registrar, Kakatiya University, Warangal
                               to the Regional Director, SRC and the reply dated.21.06.2008 to the
                               show cause notice issued to the institution and other related
                               documents, Act of NCTE 1993, Regulations and Guidelines issued
                               from time to time laid on the table, the Regional Committee noted the
                               following:-




     (Gangadharaiah)                                                          (Prof. C. Thangamuthu)
Regional Director, SRC, NCTE                                                   Chairman, SRC, NCTE
                                                  81
                                                                                           st
                                                                                Minutes-201 Meeting of SRC
                                                                                         22-23 February 2011
                                  The institution is Located in a Commercial Complex which is not
                                   in consonance with the NCTE Norms and Standards.
                                  The ground floor is full of shops, first floor is residential complex
                                   and second floor is accommodating temporary B.Ed. course.
                                  The institution in its application dated.29.12.2005 submitted
                                   SRC- NCTE informed in writing that the construction of own
                                   building shall be completed by December 2006. It failed to
                                   comply its on statement.
                                  The institution did not cooperate with the visiting team in carrying
                                   out inspection under section 17 on 16.09.2008. This is
                                   considered as an act of defiance and unbecoming of an
                                   educational institution.
                                  The institution violated the provisions contained under various
                                   sections of NCTE Act and regulations there under.
                                  Accordingly a withdrawal order was issued to the institution on
                               06.10.2008.

                               After that the institution has approached the Appellate Authority,
                               New Delhi wherein the appellate authority has directed as under:-
                                      “ After perusal of documents, memorandum of appeal, affidavit, VT
                                      report and after hearing oral arguments advanced during hearing,
                                      the Council reached the conclusion that there was no ground to
                                      accept the appeal and that it should be rejected. Accordingly, the
                                      appeal was rejected and SRC’s order dated 06.10.2008 was
                                      confirmed
                               In this regard, institution has approached the Hon‟ble High Court of
                               Andhra Pradesh at Hyderabad in W.P.No.29224 of 2009
                               An order dated 31.12.2009 in W.P.No.29224 of 2009 has been
                               received in the office of SRC on 25.01.2010, wherein the Hon‟ble
                               High court has directed as under:-
                               “There shall interim suspension of the impugned order dated
                               06.11.2009 passed 1st respondent in rejecting the appeal file by the
                               petitioner confirming the orders passed by the 2nd respondent vide
                               proceedings F.SRO/NCTE/Ref/2008-09/5464 dated 06.10.2008.
                               However, it is directed that the petitioner shall be entitled to run the
                               B.Ed college in the next academic year, only after the premises in
                               which the college is to be located is approved by the competent
                               authority.
                               Also an court order dated 18.01.2010 has been received in the office
                               of SRC as under:-
                               Interim order granted earlier is extended by four (4) weeks. Post
                               after two weeks.
                               The Judgment copy was placed along with original file before SRC in
                               its 189th held on 25th – 26th Feb, 2010, the Southern Regional
                               Committee decided to await for the court orders.




     (Gangadharaiah)                                                          (Prof. C. Thangamuthu)
Regional Director, SRC, NCTE                                                   Chairman, SRC, NCTE
                                                  82
                                                                                              st
                                                                                  Minutes-201 Meeting of SRC
                                                                                           22-23 February 2011
                               Further SRC has received another court order dated 19.07.2010 as
                               under :-
                                        “It is the case of the petitioner-college that it has rectified the
                               deficiencies pointed out during the earlier inspection in the year 2008 and
                               submitted an application with the requisite fee on 29.03.2010 seeking
                               inspection. As the order of this Court Dt:31-12-2009 required the petitioner-
                               college to be inspected and approved by the competent authority prior to its
                               operation in the next academic year 2010-2011, there shall be an interim
                               direction as prayed for”.
                               The matter was considered by the Committee and it was decided to
                               cause inspection of the institution for B.Ed. Course, under Section 17
                               of NCTE Act, on payment of Rs.40,000/- inspection fee and on
                               submission of filled in Questionnaire, along with relevant supporting
                               documents relating to building, land, including Building Completion
                               Certificate from the competent Government Engineer and Land Use
                               Certificate, within four weeks from the date of confirmation of the
                               Minutes.

                               Institution has submitted D.D of Rs. 40,000/- vide letter dated
                               21.07.2010, along with the data. The inspection was conducted on
                               15.09.2010.

                               The Committee in its 197th Meeting held on 13-14 October 2010
                               considered the VT Report Dt. 15.09.2010 and decided to issue
                               Showcause Notice. Accordingly, Showcause Notice was issued to
                               the institution on 01.12.2010. the institution has submitted its written
                               representation by fax on 18.12.2010

                               The Committee considered the reply to Show Cause Notice, VT
                               Report, VCD and all the relevant documentary evidences and it
                               was decided to serve Final Showcause Notice Under Section 17
                               of NCTE Act for the following :

                                The institution has to submit fresh and new VCD to show
                                 that the construction of the building is completed, in order
                                 to decide on re-inspection, if necessary.

                               In view of the above, the Committee decided to issue a Final
                               Showcause Notice to the institution as to why the recognition
                               be not withdrawn and thereby providing an opportunity to the
                               institution to make a written representation within 30 days from
                               the date of issue of the Notice along with necessary
                               certificates/documents in order to take a final decision in the
                               matter; failing which action will be taken including the
                               withdrawal of Recognition, based on the records available, with
                               no further notice.




     (Gangadharaiah)                                                             (Prof. C. Thangamuthu)
Regional Director, SRC, NCTE                                                      Chairman, SRC, NCTE
                                                   83
                                                                                       st
                                                                            Minutes-201 Meeting of SRC
                                                                                     22-23 February 2011
58.        APS03745            Siddartha College of Education, Kale Complex, Bus Stand Road,
              B.Ed             Jamkhandi, Bagalkot District, Karnataka has submitted application
       Siddartha College of    for offering B.Ed course on 30.12.2004. The institution has been
       Education, Bagalkot     granted recognition by SRC for offering D.Ed course with an intake
               KA              of 100 students vide order dated 26.12.2005.

                               The institution in its letter dated 06.10.2009 has submitted a
                               proposal for shifting of premises along with Rs.40,000/- towards
                               shifting fee. The inspection was carried out on 17th October 2010.
                               The inspection report has been received along with VCD.

                               The SRC in its 198th meeting held on 24-26 November 2010
                               considered the VT report and all relevant documentary evidences
                               and decided to issue Showcause Notice. Accordingly, Showcause
                               Notice was issued to the institution on 11.01.2011. The institution
                               has submitted its written representation on 10.02.2011.

                               The committee considered the written reply and other relevant
                               documents and decided to cause re-inspection. The institution
                               is directed to submit the following within 30 days of the receipt
                               of the notice, duly filled in Questionnaire along with all the
                               necessary documents for land, building approval and Building
                               Completion Certificate from a competent Govt. Engineer and
                               other relevant documents, along with inspection fee of
                               Rs.40,000/- in favour of “The Member Secretary, NCTE” payable
                               at Bangalore.


59.         APS01911           Sri Kalidasa D.Ed College, Banasanakari Road, Badami-587901,
              D.Ed             Bagalkot District, Karnataka for offering D.Ed course with an intake
        Sri Kalidasa D.Ed      of 50 students vide order dated 23.12.2004.
        College, Bagalkot
                KA             The institution in its letter dated 21.09.2007 has submitted a
                               proposal for shifting of premises along with Rs.40,000/- towards
                               shifting fee. Inspection was carried out on 27th October 2010. The
                               inspection report has been received along with VCD.

                               The SRC in its 198th meeting held on 24-26 November 2010
                               considered the VT report and all relevant documentary evidences
                               and decided to issue showcause notice. Accordingly, Showcause
                               Notice was issued to the institution on 10.01.2011. The institution
                               has submitted its written representation on 07.02.2011.

                               The Committee considered the written representation from the
                               institution dt. 07.02.2011 to the show cause notice and all other
                               related documents along with the original file of the institution,
                               and decided that shifting to new/permanent premises be
                               permitted.




     (Gangadharaiah)                                                       (Prof. C. Thangamuthu)
Regional Director, SRC, NCTE                                                Chairman, SRC, NCTE
                                                84
                                                                                          st
                                                                               Minutes-201 Meeting of SRC
                                                                                        22-23 February 2011
60.         APS01928             JSS Institute of Education, Huvina Hadagali, Holagundi Road,
               B.Ed              Bellary District-583219, Karnataka has submitted application for
          JSS Institute of       offering B.Ed course on 31.12.2003.The institution has been granted
         Education, Bellary      recognition by SRC for offering B.Ed course with an intake of 100
                KA               students vide order dated 01.12.2004.

                                 The institution in its letter dated 01.10.2009 has submitted a
                                 proposal for shifting of premises along with Rs.40,000/- towards
                                 shifting fee. Accoridngly, inspection was carried out on 21st October
                                 2010.

                                 The SRC in its 198th meeting held on 24-26 November, 2010
                                 considered the VT report and decided to issue Showcause Notice.
                                 Accordingly, showcause notice was issued on 03.01.2011. The
                                 institution has submitted written representation on 27.01.201.

                                 The Committee considered the reply to Show Cause Notice, VT
                                 Report, VCD and all the relevant documentary evidences and it
                                 was decided to serve final Showcause Notice Under Section 17
                                 of NCTE Act for the following :

                                  As per Building completion certificate, the built up area is
                                   14679.75 sq.ft which is inadequate. The required built up
                                   area is 16,000 sq.ft as per NCTE norms.
                                  Building completion certificate issued by the Government
                                   competent Engineer/authority to be submitted.

                                 In view of the above, the Committee decided to issue a Final
                                 Showcause Notice to the institution as to why the recognition
                                 be not withdrawn and thereby providing an opportunity to the
                                 institution to make a written representation within 30 days from
                                 the date of issue of the Notice along with necessary
                                 certificates/documents in order to take a final decision in the
                                 matter; failing which action will be taken including the
                                 withdrawal of Recognition, based on the records available, with
                                 no further notice.

61.          APS01881            Ravi D.Ed College, 2nd Cross, Gowripet, Kolar District-563101,
             APS05544            Karnataka has been granted recognition for offering D.Ed course on
               D.Ed              12.04.2007 with an intake of 100 students which includes existing
              D.Ed-AI            intake of 50 students and additional intake of 50 students.
      Ravi D.Ed College, Kolar
                KA               NCTE, Hqrs vide its letter dated 19.07.2010 has forwarded a copy of
                                 the inspection report dated 14.06.2010 conducted under section 13
                                 of NCTE Act. As there are deficiencies pointed out in the inspection
                                 report, NCTE Hqrs has requested SRC to initiate action against the
                                 institution under Section 17 of the NCTE Act immediately.




     (Gangadharaiah)                                                         (Prof. C. Thangamuthu)
Regional Director, SRC, NCTE                                                  Chairman, SRC, NCTE
                                                   85
                                                                                              st
                                                                                   Minutes-201 Meeting of SRC
                                                                                            22-23 February 2011
                                    The SRC in its 195th meeting held on 17-18 August 2010 considered
                                    the report and decided to issue Showcause notice. Accordingly,
                                    Showcause notice was issued to the institution on 28.09.2010. The
                                    institution has submitted written representation on 18.10.2010.

                                    The SRC in its 198th meeting held on 24-26 November 2010
                                    considered the written reply of the institution dt.18.10.2010 and all
                                    the relevant documentary evidences and it was decided to issue
                                    Showcause notice again. Accordingly, Showcause notice was issued
                                    to the institution on 03.01.2011. The institution has submitted written
                                    representation on 21.01.2011.

                                    The committee considered the reply submitted by the institution
                                    and decided to withdraw recognition for the following reasons:
                                     The institution has not shifted to new premises as
                                       recognition for the basic unit was granted in 2004 itself and
                                       now it is more than seven years since the recognition was
                                       granted.
                                     The institution, as per the condition stipulated should have
                                       shifted to permanent premises in 2007 itself.
                                    Hence, the committee decided to withdraw recognition for
                                    D.T.Ed (APS01881) and D.T.Ed – AI course (APS05544) with
                                    effect from 2012-13, in order to enable the ongoing batch of
                                    students in D.T.Ed course, if any, to complete their course.
                                    But it is made clear that the institution is debarred from making
                                    any further admission subsequent to the date of issue of this
                                    order.
                                    The Affiliating body / Examining board / body be informed
                                    accordingly.
                                    Further decided to return Endowment funds and Reserve fund
                                    deposited with SRC NCTE, Bangalore if any.
62.          APS01674               Phool Bun Teacher Training Institute for Women, Jambunath Road,
                D.Ed                Hospet-583201, Bellary District, Karnataka for offering D.Ed course
        Phool Bun Teacher           with an intake of 50 students vide order dated 02.12.2004.
      Training Institute, Bellary
                 KA                 The institution in its letter dated 09.10.2007 has submitted a
                                    proposal for shifting of premises along with Rs.40,000/- towards
                                    shifting fee. Inspection was carried out on 25th October 2010. The
                                    inspection report has been received along with VCD.

                                    The SRC in its 198th meeting held on 24-26 November 2010
                                    considered the VT report and all relevant documentary evidences
                                    and decided to issue showcause notice. Accordingly, Showcause
                                    Notice was issued to the institution on 10.01.2011. The institution
                                    has submitted its written representation on 07.02.2011.




     (Gangadharaiah)                                                              (Prof. C. Thangamuthu)
Regional Director, SRC, NCTE                                                       Chairman, SRC, NCTE
                                                      86
                                                                                                 st
                                                                                     Minutes-201 Meeting of SRC
                                                                                              22-23 February 2011
                                  The Committee considered the reply to Show Cause Notice, VT
                                  Report, VCD and all the relevant documentary evidences and it
                                  was decided to serve Final Showcause Notice Under Section 17
                                  of NCTE Act for the following :

                                   The institution is having inadequte built up area of only 8000
                                    sq.ft, as against requirement of 16,000 sq.ft. as per the
                                    norms.
                                   Land Usage Certificate from the competent Govenremnt
                                    authority to be submitted.

                                  In view of the above, the Committee decided to issue a Final
                                  Showcause Notice to the institution as to why the recognition
                                  be not withdrawn and thereby providing an opportunity to the
                                  institution to make a written representation within 30 days from
                                  the date of issue of the Notice along with necessary
                                  certificates/documents in order to take a final decision in the
                                  matter; failing which action will be taken including the
                                  withdrawal of Recognition, based on the records available, with
                                  no further notice.

63.         APS00493              Shreyas Teacher Training Institute, Ramakrishna Extension, Srinivasapura
            APS03222              Taluk, Kolar District-563135, Karnataka for offering D.Ed-AI with an existing
               D.Ed               intake of 90 students and additional intake of 30 students thus making an
              D.Ed-AI             annual intake of 120 students vide order dated 15.12.2004.
         Shreyas Teacher
                                  In the mean time NCTE, Hqrs vide its letter dated 19.11.2010 has
      Training Institute, Kolar   forwarded a copy of the inspection report dated 14.06.2010. As there are
                 KA               deficiencies pointed out in the inspection report, NCTE Hqrs has decided
                                  that SRC, NCTE may look into the matter to ascertain the adherence of
                                  norms and standards by the institution and requested to take appropriate
                                  action.
                                                     th
                                  The SRC in its 198 meeting held on 24-26 November 2010 considered the
                                  VT report and all the relevant documentary evidences and decided to issue
                                  showcause notice. Accordingly, Showcause Notice was issued to the
                                  institution on 11.01.2010. The institution has submitted its written
                                  representation on 03.02.2011.

                                  The committee considered the written representation and other
                                  relevant documents and found the reply unsatisfactory and
                                  unconvincing and hence decided that one Basic Unit of 50
                                  students only for D.Ed course (APS00493) is permitted to
                                  continue; as built up area is inadequate to run any additional
                                  intake, the D.Ed-Al intake (in excess of basic unit of 50)
                                  (APS03222) be withdrawn.

                                  The committee further decided to inform the Affiliating/
                                  Examining body for necessary action.




     (Gangadharaiah)                                                                (Prof. C. Thangamuthu)
Regional Director, SRC, NCTE                                                         Chairman, SRC, NCTE
                                                      87
                                                                                         st
                                                                              Minutes-201 Meeting of SRC
                                                                                       22-23 February 2011
64.         APS01996             Sri. Nirvanaswamy College of Education, Sree Degula Math,
               B.Ed              Kanakapur-562117, Bangalore Rural District, Karnataka for offering
        Sri Nirvanaswamy         B.Ed course with an intake of 100 students vide order dated
       College of Education,     02.12.2004.
      Bangalore Rural District
                KA               The institution in its letter dated 17.10.2007 has submitted a
                                 proposal for shifting of premises along with Rs.40,000/- towards
                                 shifting fee. Inspection was carried out on 25th October 2010. The
                                 inspection report has been received along with VCD.

                                 The SRC in its 198th meeting held on 24-26 November 2010
                                 considered the VT report and all relevant documentary evidences
                                 and decided to issue showcause notice. Accordingly, Showcause
                                 Notice was issued to the institution on 10.01.2011. The institution
                                 has submitted its written representation on 07.02.2011.

                                 The management is running B.Ed course also in the same building.

                                 The Committee considered the reply to Show Cause Notice, VT
                                 Report, VCD and all the relevant documentary evidences and it
                                 was decided to serve Final Showcause Notice Under Section 17
                                 of NCTE Act for the following :

                                  The institution has to submit details of built up area
                                   earmarked for both D.Ed and B.Ed courses.
                                  Building completion certificate from the authorised
                                   competent Governemnt Engineer in the prescribed format to
                                   be submitted.
                                  Land Usage Certificate from the competent Government
                                   authority to be submitted. Land Usage Certificate from the
                                   competent authority to be submitted.

                                 In view of the above, the Committee decided to issue a Final
                                 Showcause Notice to the institution as to why the recognition
                                 be not withdrawn and thereby providing an opportunity to the
                                 institution to make a written representation within 30 days from
                                 the date of issue of the Notice along with necessary
                                 certificates/documents in order to take a final decision in the
                                 matter; failing which action will be taken including the
                                 withdrawal of Recognition, based on the records available, with
                                 no further notice.




     (Gangadharaiah)                                                        (Prof. C. Thangamuthu)
Regional Director, SRC, NCTE                                                 Chairman, SRC, NCTE
                                                  88
                                                                                          st
                                                                               Minutes-201 Meeting of SRC
                                                                                        22-23 February 2011
65.          APS02422             Sri Kotturswamy Institute of Teacher Education, Sree Jagadguru
                D.Ed              Kotturswamy Math, Main Bazaar, Hospet-583201, Bellary Distirct,
      Sri Kotturswamy Institute   Karnataka has submitted application for offering D.Ed course on
       of Teacher Education,      31.12.2003. The institution has been granted recognition by SRC for
               Bellary            offering D.Ed course with an intake of 50 students vide order dated
                 KA               30.11.2004.

                                  The institution in its letter dated 28.09.2007 has submitted a
                                  proposal for shifting of premises along with Rs.40,000/- towards
                                  shifting fee. Inspection was carried out on 27th October 2010. The
                                  inspection report has been received along with VCD.

                                  The SRC in its 198th meeting held on 24-26 November 2010
                                  considered the VT report and all relevant documentary evidences
                                  and decided to issue showcause notice. Accordingly, Showcause
                                  Notice was issued to the institution on 11.01.2011. The institution
                                  has submitted its written representation on 03.02.2011.

                                  The Committee considered the reply to Show Cause Notice, VT
                                  Report, VCD and all the relevant documentary evidences and it
                                  was decided to serve Final Showcause Notice Under Section 17
                                  of NCTE Act for the following :

                                   The earmarked built up area povided for D.Ed course is only
                                    8550 sq.ft. which is inadequate as per NCTE norms. A
                                    16,000 sq.ft built up area is required as per NCTE norms.

                                  In view of the above, the Committee decided to issue a Final
                                  Showcause Notice to the institution as to why the recognition
                                  be not withdrawn and thereby providing an opportunity to the
                                  institution to make a written representation within 30 days from
                                  the date of issue of the Notice along with necessary
                                  certificates/documents in order to take a final decision in the
                                  matter; failing which action will be taken including the
                                  withdrawal of Recognition, based on the records available, with
                                  no further notice.




     (Gangadharaiah)                                                         (Prof. C. Thangamuthu)
Regional Director, SRC, NCTE                                                  Chairman, SRC, NCTE
                                                   89
                                                                                        st
                                                                             Minutes-201 Meeting of SRC
                                                                                      22-23 February 2011
66.         APS02409           Sri Sadashiva B.Ed College, Lokapur Road, Ballur, Muthod Taluk,
              B.Ed             Bagalkot District, Karnataka for offering B.Ed course with an intake
       Sri Sadashiva B.Ed      of 100 students vide order dated 03.02.2006.
        College, Bagalkot
               KA              The institution in its letter dated 01.10.2009 has submitted a
                               proposal for shifting of premises along with Rs.40,000/- towards
                               shifting fee. Accordingly, inspection was carried out on 17th October
                               2010.

                               The SRC in its 198th meeting held on 24-26 November 2010
                               considered the VT report and all the relevant documentary
                               evidences and it was decided to issue showcause notice.
                               Accordingly showcause notice was issued to the institution on
                               11.01.2011. The institution has submitted its written representation
                               on 11.02.2011.

                               The Committee considered the reply to Show Cause Notice, VT
                               Report, VCD and all the relevant documentary evidences and it
                               was decided to serve Final Showcause Notice Under Section 17
                               of NCTE Act for the following :

                                The institution has to submit fresh VCD of the building.
                                Building completion certificate form the Governemnt
                                 competent authorised Engineer to be submitted in the
                                 prescribed format showing built up area.
                                Non-Encumbrance certificate issued by the competent
                                 Government authority to be submitted.
                                Land documents in the name of the Society/Trust/Institution
                                 is to be submitted.

                               In view of the above, the Committee decided to issue a Final
                               Showcause Notice to the institution as to why the recognition
                               be not withdrawn and thereby providing an opportunity to the
                               institution to make a written representation within 30 days from
                               the date of issue of the Notice along with necessary
                               certificates/documents in order to take a final decision in the
                               matter; failing which action will be taken including the
                               withdrawal of Recognition, based on the records available, with
                               no further notice.




     (Gangadharaiah)                                                       (Prof. C. Thangamuthu)
Regional Director, SRC, NCTE                                                Chairman, SRC, NCTE
                                                 90
                                                                                        st
                                                                             Minutes-201 Meeting of SRC
                                                                                      22-23 February 2011
67.        APS01580            Annapurneshwari Hukkeri D.Ed College, Borgaon Post, Chikodi
           APS04778            Taluk, Belgaum District, Karnataka (APS04778) submitted an
              D.Ed             application for grant of recognition on 02.01.2006. The institution
          D.Ed(Marthi)         was granted recognition for offering D.Ed course with an intake of 50
        Annapurneshwari        students vide order dated 31.10.2007.
      Hukkeri D.Ed College,
            Belgaum            Another file by name Annapurneshwari Hukeri D.Ed College,
               KA              Borgaon-591216, Chikodi, Belgaum District, Karnataka bearing code
                               No. APS01580 was granted recognition vide order dated 01.12.2004
                               with an intake of 50 students from the session 2004-2005.

                               NCTE, Hqrs vide its letter dated 27.10.2010 has forwarded a copy of
                               the inspection report dated 21.05.2010. As there are deficiencies
                               pointed out in the inspection report NCTE, Hqrs has requested SRC
                               to initate action against institution.

                               The SRC in its 198th meeting held on 24-26 November 2010
                               considered the VT report and all relevant documentary evidences
                               and decided to issue showcause notice. Accordingly, Showcause
                               notice was issued to the institution on 03.01.2011. The institution
                               has submitted its written representation on 03.02.2011.

                               The Committee considered the reply to Show Cause Notice, VT
                               Report, VCD and all the relevant documentary evidences and it
                               was decided to serve Final Showcause Notice Under Section 17
                               of NCTE Act for the following :

                                The management/institution to submit an evidence from
                                 DIET/DSERT for having shifting of I.T.I course from D.Ed
                                 building.

                               In view of the above, the Committee decided to issue a Final
                               Showcause Notice to the institution as to why the recognition
                               be not withdrawn and thereby providing an opportunity to the
                               institution to make a written representation within 30 days from
                               the date of issue of the Notice along with necessary
                               certificates/documents in order to take a final decision in the
                               matter; failing which action will be taken including the
                               withdrawal of Recognition, based on the records available, with
                               no further notice.




     (Gangadharaiah)                                                       (Prof. C. Thangamuthu)
Regional Director, SRC, NCTE                                                Chairman, SRC, NCTE
                                                 91
                                                                                       st
                                                                            Minutes-201 Meeting of SRC
                                                                                     22-23 February 2011
68.        Aps01732            Pramod D.Ed College, No.33, Challekere, Banasawadi Post,
          APS05436             Bangalore-560043, Karnataka has submitted application for grant
             D.Ed              recognition on 30.12.2003. The institution was granted recognition
            D.Ed-AI            for offering D.Ed course with an intake of 50 students vide order
      Pramod D.Ed College,     dated 25.11.2004.
           Bangalore
              KA               In the mean time NCTE, Hqrs vide its letter dated 20.10.2010 has
                               forwarded a copy of the inspection report dated 06.05.2010. As there
                               are deficiencies pointed out in the inspection report NCTE, Hqrs has
                               requested SRC to initiate action against institution.

                               The SRC in its 198th meeting held on 24-26 November 2010
                               considered the VT report and all the relevant documentary and
                               decided to issue showcause notice. Accordingly showcause notice
                               was issued to the institution on 03.01.2011. The institution has
                               submitted its written representation on 04.02.2011.

                               The Committee considered the reply to Show Cause Notice, VT
                               Report, VCD and all the relevant documentary evidences and it
                               was decided to serve Final Showcause Notice Under Section 17
                               of NCTE Act for the following :

                                Building completion certificate is not in the prescribed
                                 format.

                                Building completion certificate from competent Govenrment
                                 Engineer is to be submitted.

                                Certificate from DSERT for shifting the School to some other
                                 building to be submitted.

                                Materials in lab need to be strengthened.

                                Books in the library need to be added.

                               In view of the above, the Committee decided to issue a Final
                               Showcause Notice to the institution as to why the recognition
                               be not withdrawn and thereby providing an opportunity to the
                               institution to make a written representation within 30 days from
                               the date of issue of the Notice along with necessary
                               certificates/documents in order to take a final decision in the
                               matter; failing which action will be taken including the
                               withdrawal of Recognition, based on the records available, with
                               no further notice.




     (Gangadharaiah)                                                       (Prof. C. Thangamuthu)
Regional Director, SRC, NCTE                                                Chairman, SRC, NCTE
                                                92
                                                                                        st
                                                                             Minutes-201 Meeting of SRC
                                                                                      22-23 February 2011
69.        APS01597            Anjuman Urdu D.Ed College, Alamour Peth- Ikal (PO), Hungund
              D.Ed             Taluk, Bagalkot District, Karnataka has been granted recognition for
       Anjuman Urdu D.Ed       offering D.Ed course with an intake of 50 students vide order dated
        College, Bagalkot      30.11.2004.
               KA
                               The institution in its letter dated 11.10.2007 has submitted a
                               proposal for shifting of premises along with Rs.40,000/- towards
                               shifting fee. Accordingly, inspection was carried out on 19th October
                               2010. The inspection report has been received along with VCD.

                               The SRC in its 196th meeting held on 24-26 November 2010
                               considered the VT report, VCD and all the relevant documentary
                               evidences and decided to issue showcause notice. Accordingly,
                               showcause notice was issued to the issued on 11.01.2010. The
                               institution has submitted its written representation on 31.01.2011.

                               The Committee considered the un-satisfactory reply to Show
                               Cause Notice, VT Report, VCD and all the relevant documentary
                               evidences and it was decided to serve Final Showcause Notice
                               Under Section 17 of NCTE Act for the following :

                                Building completion certificate is found tampered and not in
                                 the prescribed format.

                                There is discrepancy in the built up area shown in the
                                 affidavit and a fresh affidavit on Rs.100/- stamp paper duly
                                 notarised is to be submitted.

                                The latest non-encumbrance certificate upto date is to be
                                 submitted.

                                Notarised Land Usage Certificate is to be submitted.

                                Language Learning Lab is not available.

                                Fixed Deposit Receipt of Rs.3.00 lakhs is not from
                                 Nationalised Bank and not in Joint name as per NCTE
                                 norms.

                               In view of the above, the Committee decided to issue a Final
                               Showcause Notice to the institution as to why the recognition
                               be not withdrawn and thereby providing an opportunity to the
                               institution to make a written representation within 30 days from
                               the date of issue of the Notice along with necessary
                               certificates/documents in order to take a final decision in the
                               matter; failing which action will be taken including the
                               withdrawal of Recognition, based on the records available, with
                               no further notice.




     (Gangadharaiah)                                                       (Prof. C. Thangamuthu)
Regional Director, SRC, NCTE                                                Chairman, SRC, NCTE
                                                 93
                                                                                        st
                                                                             Minutes-201 Meeting of SRC
                                                                                      22-23 February 2011
70.        APS02059            Shrinidhi College of Education, No.93/2, Hommadevanahalli,
              B.Ed             C.K.palya Road, Bannerghatta Main Road, Bangalore-560083,
       Shrinidhi College of    Karnataka has been granted recognition for offering B.Ed course
      Education, Bangalore     with an intake of 100 students vide order dated 25.11.2004.
               KA
                               NCTE, Hqrs vide its letter dated 22.06.2010 has forwarded a copy of
                               the inspection report dated 04.05.2010 conducted under section 13
                               of NCTE Act . As there are deficiencies pointed out in the inspection
                               report, NCTE Hqrs has requested SRC to initiate action against the
                               institution immediately.

                               The SRC in its 194th meeting held on 21-22 July 2010 considered
                               the letter from the NCTE Hqrs, VT report and decided to issue
                               notice. Accordingly, Notice was issued to the on 31.08.2010. The
                               institution has submitted its written representation on 31.01.2011.

                               The Committee considered the VT Report, VCD and all the
                               relevant documentary evidences and it was decided to cause
                               re-inspection in anticipation of re-inspection fee of Rs.40,000/-.

71.       APS01901             K.K. College of Education, K.K.Educational and Charitable Trust,
              B.Ed             Vasanthapur Road, Konanakunte Cross, Bangalore-560062,
        K.K. College of        Karnataka has been granted recognition for offering B.Ed course
      Education, Bangalore     with an intake of 100 students vide order dated 29.11.2004.
               KA
                               The institution in its letter dated 25.10.2007 has submitted a
                               proposal for shifting of premises along with Rs.40,000/- towards
                               shifting fee. The inspection was carried out on 27th October 2010.
                               The inspection received on 29.10.2010 along with VCD.

                               The SRC in its 198th meeting held on 24-26 November 2010
                               considered the VT report and all the relevant documentary
                               evidences and it was decided to issue showcause notice.
                               Accordingly, Showcause notice was issued on 11.01.2011 for the
                               following raeasons:

                                The institution is functioning in a multistoried building
                                 which is being shared for running management and
                                 Commerce Colleges. This is a gross violation of norms on
                                 the part of the management to share with other colleges.

                                The affidavit is being signed by a different person and land
                                 area and Survey Nos are different.

                                The land where the institution is functioning in the building
                                 is in the name of an individual, it should be in the name of
                                 the trust or institution as per the norms.




     (Gangadharaiah)                                                       (Prof. C. Thangamuthu)
Regional Director, SRC, NCTE                                                Chairman, SRC, NCTE
                                                 94
                                                                                          st
                                                                               Minutes-201 Meeting of SRC
                                                                                        22-23 February 2011
                                The latest Building Completion Certificate from the
                                 competent Government Engineer has not been submitted.

                                Rs. 5 Lakhs FDR expired on 13.10.2010. Fresh FDR for Rs. 5
                                 lakhs to be submitted.

                               The institution   has   submitted   its   written   representation    on
                               28.01.2011.

                               The committee considered the reply submitted by the institution
                               and decided to withdraw recognition for D.Ed course
                               (APS01901) with effect from 2012-13, in order to enable the
                               ongoing batch of students in D.Ed course, if any, to complete
                               their course.
                               But it is made clear that the institution is debarred from making
                               any further admission subsequent to the date of issue of this
                               order.
                               The Affiliating body / Examining board / body be informed
                               accordingly.

                               Further decided to return Endowment funds and Reserve fund
                               deposited with SRC NCTE, Bangalore if any.

72.       APS01718             Nethaji College of Education No.27, Arehalli, Ittamadu Main Road,
              B.Ed             Banashankari 3rd Stage, Bangalore – 560061, Karnataka has
       Nethaji College of      submitted application for offering B.Ed course on 30.12.2003.The
      Education, Bangalore     institution has been granted recognition by SRC for offering B.Ed
               KA              course with an intake of 100 students vide order dated 30.11.2004.
                               The institution in its letter dated 08.10.2007 has submitted a
                               proposal for shifting of premises along with Rs.40,000/- towards
                               shifting fee. Inspection was carried out on 25th October 2010. The
                               inspection report has been received along with VCD.

                               The SRC in its 198th meeting held on 24-26 November 2010
                               considered the VT report and all the relevant documentary
                               evidences and it was decided to issue show cause notice.
                               Accordingly, showcause notice was issued to the institution on
                               19.01.2011. The institution has submitted its written representation
                               on 11.02.2011.

                               The Committee considered the written representation from the
                               institution dt. 11.02.2011 to the show cause notice and all other
                               related documents along with the original file of the institution,
                               and decided that shifting to new/permanent premises be
                               permitted.




     (Gangadharaiah)                                                         (Prof. C. Thangamuthu)
Regional Director, SRC, NCTE                                                  Chairman, SRC, NCTE
                                                 95
                                                                                           st
                                                                                Minutes-201 Meeting of SRC
                                                                                         22-23 February 2011
73.        APS01894            SDM Trust‟s B.Ed College, Jamkhandi, Terdal-587315, Karnataka
              B.Ed             has submitted application for offering B.Ed course on 31.12.2003.
        SDM Trust‟s B.Ed       The institution has been granted recognition by SRC for offering
        College, Bagalkot      B.Ed course with an intake of 100 students vide order dated
               KA              01.12.2004.

                               The institution in its letter dated 12.10.2007 has submitted a
                               proposal for shifting of premises along with Rs.40,000/- towards
                               shifting fee. Inspection was carried out on 16th October 2010. The
                               inspection report has been received along with VCD.

                               The SRC in its 198th meeting held on 24-26 November 2010
                               considered the VT report and all the relevant documentary
                               evidences and it was decided to issue show cause notice.
                               Accordingly, showcause notice was issued to the institution on
                               11.01.2011 for the following reasons:
                                The management is running a Hospital in the ground floor and B.Ed
                                 programme in the I & II floor of the same building, which is against the
                                 NCTE norms. This serious violation of NCTE norms cannot be
                                 condoned, even if the under-mentioned deficiencies are rectified.
                                The Survey Nos are not shown in the lease agreement for the new
                                 premises.
                                The Affidavit in Rs.100/- stamp paper in the prescribed format with
                                 notary attestation to be submitted.
                                The institute has not submitted the Land useage certificate from a
                                 competent Govt. authority
                                The latest Building Completion Certificate from the competent
                                 Government Engineer has not been submitted.
                                Non-Encumbrance Certificate from the competent Government
                                 Authorised person / Authorities to be submitted.
                                The facility for language learning lab is not available.

                               The institution has submitted its written representation on
                               14.02.2011.

                               The committee considered the reply submitted by the institution
                               and found the reply to be unsatisfactory and unconvencing and
                               decided to withdraw recognition for B.Ed course (APS01894)
                               with effect from 2012-13, in order to enable the ongoing batch of
                               students in B.Ed course, if any, to complete their course.

                               But it is made clear that the institution is debarred from making
                               any further admission subsequent to the date of issue of this
                               order.

                               The Affiliating body / Examining board / body be informed
                               accordingly.

                               Further decided to return Endowment funds and Reserve fund
                               deposited with SRC NCTE, Bangalore if any.




     (Gangadharaiah)                                                           (Prof. C. Thangamuthu)
Regional Director, SRC, NCTE                                                    Chairman, SRC, NCTE
                                                  96
                                                                                       st
                                                                            Minutes-201 Meeting of SRC
                                                                                     22-23 February 2011
74.          AOS00032          Al-Ameen Urdu Training Institute, 1st Cross, Azad Nagar, Belgaum
             APS03122          District-590016, Karnataka was granted recognition for offering
                 D.Ed          D.Ed-AI course on 27.12.2004 with an intake of 200 students which
               D.Ed-AI         includes existing intake of 120 students and additional intake of 80
      Al-Ameen Urdu Training   students.
         Institute, Belgaum
                  KA           NCTE, Hqrs vide its letter dated 10.08.2010 has forwarded a copy of
                               the inspection report dated 15.06.2010 conducted under section 13
                               of NCTE Act. As there are deficiencies pointed out in the inspection
                               report, NCTE, Hqrs has requested SRC to initiate action against the
                               institution under section 17 of the NCTE Act immediately.

                               The SRC in its 195rd meeting held on 17-18 August 2010 considered
                               the report and decided to issue showcause Notice. Accordingly,
                               Notice was issued to the institution on 22.09.2010. The institution
                               has submitted written representation on 18.10.2010.

                               The SRC in its 198th meeting held on 24-26 November 2010
                               considered the VT report and all relevant documentary evidences
                               and it was decided to issue Show cause notice for the following
                               reasons:

                                The institution was granted conditional permission on
                                 27.12.2001 in a temporary premises with condition that the
                                 basic unit of D.Ed shall be shifted to permanent premises
                                 within a period of three years i.e. on or before 26.12.2004.
                                 Now more than 10 years have lapsed.

                                The Institution was granted conditional recognition in
                                 temporary premises to run D.Ed-Al course on 27.12.2004
                                 with a condition that it should shift to its own permanent
                                 premises in three years. i.e., on or before 26.12.2007. The
                                 Institution is still running in temporary premises and not
                                 shifted to permanent premises even after a lapse of
                                 stipulated three years. Now there is a lapse of time period
                                 of more than four long         years, since the conditional
                                 recognition was granted.

                                The above temporary premises where the management is
                                 running D.Ed (AOS00032) and D.Ed-Al (APS03122) courses
                                 has a total built up area of 3000sq.ft, which is grossly
                                 inadequate as sper NCTE norms.

                                The same building is shared for PUC and High School,
                                 which is not as per NCTE norms.

                                The institution has stated that the building is still under
                                 construction.




     (Gangadharaiah)                                                       (Prof. C. Thangamuthu)
Regional Director, SRC, NCTE                                                Chairman, SRC, NCTE
                                                97
                                                                                         st
                                                                              Minutes-201 Meeting of SRC
                                                                                       22-23 February 2011
                               Accordingly, Showcause notice was issued to the institution on
                               11.02.2011. The institution has submitted its written representation
                               on 14.02.2011.

                               The committee considered the reply submitted by the institution
                               and found the reply to be unsatisfactory and convincing and
                               decided to withdraw recognition for D.Ed (AOS00032) and D.Ed-
                               AI (APS03122) with effect from 2012-13, in order to enable the
                               ongoing batch of students in D.Ed course, if any, to complete
                               their course.

                               But it is made clear that the institution is debarred from making
                               any further admission subsequent to the date of issue of this
                               order.

                               The Affiliating body / Examining board / body be informed
                               accordingly.

                               Further decided to return Endowment funds and Reserve fund
                               deposited with SRC NCTE, Bangalore if any.

75.        APS02125            Sri Markandeshwara D.Ed College, 90/A, Sadashiva Nagar,
             D.Ed              Ananthasayan Gudi, Hospet, Bellary District, Karnataka has been
      Sri Markandeshwara       granted recognition for offering D.Ed course with an intake of 50
      D.Ed College, Bellary    students vide order dated 29.11.2004.
              KA
                               The institution in its letter dated 18.09.2007 has submitted a
                               proposal for shifting of premises along with 40,000/- towards shifting
                               fee. Accordingly, inspection was carried out on 28th October 2010.
                               The inspection report has been received on 01.11.2010.

                               The SRC in its 198th meeting held on 24-26 November 2010
                               considered the VT report, VCD and other relevant documentary
                               evidences and decided to issue showcause notice for the following
                               reasons:

                                As per VT report, the management is running D.Ed
                                 programme and also running a primary and higher
                                 secondary school in the same building/premises, which is
                                 not permissible as per NCTE norms.

                                As per the VT report, VCD and all the relevant documents, it
                                 is clear that the building is incomplete and the institution is
                                 running the D.Ed. programme in a building which is partly
                                 roofed with asbestos sheets, which is against the NCTE
                                 Norms.




     (Gangadharaiah)                                                        (Prof. C. Thangamuthu)
Regional Director, SRC, NCTE                                                 Chairman, SRC, NCTE
                                                 98
                                                                                       st
                                                                            Minutes-201 Meeting of SRC
                                                                                     22-23 February 2011
                                Original Affidavit of Rs. 100/- is not submitted.

                                FDRs of Rs. 5 lakhs and 3 lakhs in joint names from a
                                 Nationalized Bank for a period of 5 years is to be submitted.

                                Non-encumbrance  Certificate from the   competent
                                 Government Authorised person / Authority. To be
                                 submitted.

                                Lease documents of English version is to be submitted.

                               Accordingly, Showcause notice was issued to the institution on
                               03.01.2011.The institution has submitted its written representation
                               on 27.01.2011.

                               The committee considered the reply submitted by the institution
                               and found the reply to be unsatisfactory and unconvincing and
                               decided to withdraw recognition for D.Ed (APS02125) course
                               with effect from 2012-13, in order to enable the ongoing batch of
                               students in D.Ed course, if any, to complete their course.

                               But it is made clear that the institution is debarred from making
                               any further admission subsequent to the date of issue of this
                               order.

                               The Affiliating body / Examining board / body be informed
                               accordingly.

                               Further decided to return Endowment funds and Reserve fund
                               deposited with SRC NCTE, Bangalore if any.

76.        APS01145            T.V.R Teacher Training Institute, Mathikrishnapuram, Manapet P.O,
              D.T.Ed           Bahour, Commune, Puducherry has submitted application for
      TVR Teacher Training     offering D.T.Ed course on 31.12.2002. The institution has been
        Institute, Bahour      granted recognition by SRC for offering D.T.Ed course with an intake
                PO             of 100 students vide order dated 29.10.2004

                               The institution in its letter dated 09.10.2009 has submitted a
                               proposal for shifting of premises along with Rs.40,000/- towards
                               shifting fee. The institution is also running B.Ed programme in the
                               same building/premises. Accordingly, inspection was carried out on
                               21st October 2010. The inspection report has been received along
                               with VCD.




     (Gangadharaiah)                                                       (Prof. C. Thangamuthu)
Regional Director, SRC, NCTE                                                Chairman, SRC, NCTE
                                                99
                                                                                         st
                                                                              Minutes-201 Meeting of SRC
                                                                                       22-23 February 2011
                               The Committee in 198h Meeting of SRC held on 24th - 26th November, 2010
                               considered the VT Report VCD and all the relevant documentary
                               evidences and it was decided to serve Show cause Notice Under
                               Section 17 of NCTE Act for the following. Accordingly show cause
                               notice APS01145 – D.T.Ed dtd 17.01.2011 was issued on
                               17.01.2011. The institution submitted its reply on 10.02.2011

                               The Committee considered the reply to Show Cause Notice, VT
                               Report, VCD and all the relevant documentary evidences and it
                               was decided to serve Final Showcause Notice Under Section 17
                               of NCTE Act for the following :

                                Building completion certificate from the competent
                                 Government Engineer/authority in the prescribed format is
                                 to be submitted.

                               In view of the above, the Committee decided to issue a Final
                               Showcause Notice to the institution as to why the recognition
                               be not withdrawn and thereby providing an opportunity to the
                               institution to make a written representation within 30 days from
                               the date of issue of the Notice along with necessary
                               certificates/documents in order to take a final decision in the
                               matter; failing which action will be taken including the
                               withdrawal of Recognition, based on the records available, with
                               no further notice.

77.        APS03614            Annai College of Education, Salem District, Tamilnadu
             B.Ed
        Annai College of       Annai College of Education, Athanur Patti, Valapadi Taluk, Salem
        Education, Salem       District-636115, Tamilnadu has submitted an application for seeking
               TN              grant of recognition for B.Ed course on 09.08.2004. The application
                               was processed and a recognition order was issued to the institution
                               on 3.9.2005.

                               In the meanwhile, some institutions who have been granted
                               recognition for the subsequent year based on belated endorsements
                               preferred an appeal to NCTE-Hqrs. and contended that a few
                               institutions which have submitted belated endorsements were
                               granted recognition for the current academic year. SRC, in its
                               comments to the NCTE-Hqrs. explained that this has occurred due
                               to oversight and would modify such orders which have been wrongly
                               issued. Pursuant to this, the NCTE-New Delhi vide order no.F.No.89-
                               156/2005-Appeal dated 28th September, 2005 remanded back the
                               cases to the SRC, Bangalore with a direction to reconsider the cases
                               immediately for granting recognition from 2005-2006 at par with
                               other similar cases who have been granted recognition for 2005-
                               2006.




     (Gangadharaiah)                                                         (Prof. C. Thangamuthu)
Regional Director, SRC, NCTE                                                  Chairman, SRC, NCTE
                                                 100
                                                                                          st
                                                                               Minutes-201 Meeting of SRC
                                                                                        22-23 February 2011
                               The matter was placed before SRC in its 103rd meeting held on 27th
                               and 28th October, 2005 and SRC after obtaining a considered legal
                               opinion in this regard, had taken decision to review its recognition
                               orders issued for the session 2006-2007 and to grant recognition for
                               the session 2005-06 to those institutions who have submitted
                               belated NOC‟s/Endorsements as one time exception.

                               SRC in its 104th meeting held on 9th November 2005 decided to
                               extend this relaxation to the institutions which have submitted other
                               essential documents mentioned in Appendix 1B, belatedly.
                               Accordingly, as per Public Notice of SRC, a modified recognition
                               order was issued to the institution on 22.11.2005 for B.Ed course
                               from the academic session 2005-06.

                               A complaint was received from the students of Annai College of
                               Education, Salem Dt. which was considered by SRC in its 190th
                               meeting held on 29-30th March 2010 and it was decided to issue
                               Notice to the institution and accordingly, Notice was issued to the
                               institution on 06.05.2010. The institution submitted its reply on
                               08.06.2010.

                               The SRC in its 193rd meeting held on 21st-22nd June 2010 decided to
                               cause inspection of the institution and accordingly inspection of
                               Annai College of Education, Athanur patti, Valapadi Taluk, Salem-
                               636115, Tamilnadu was conducted on 19.07.2010.

                               The SRC in its 195th meeting held on 17th-18th August 2010
                               considered the report of the institution and decided to serve
                               Showcause Notice. As per the decision of SRC, Notice was issued
                               to the institution on 24.09.2010. The institution submitted its reply on
                               18.10.2010.

                               The Committee in its 198th meeting held on 24th-26th November 2010
                               considered the reply of the institution and decided to serve
                               Showcause Notice for the following as the replies were not specific,
                               highly misleading and evasive.

                                Annai Matriculation School running LKG to VII Standard is
                                 functioning in the First and Second Floor of the above,
                                 partly constructed building, in front of which, only the name
                                 board of the College of Education is placed. As per the
                                 norms, the B.Ed College should have an exclusive campus
                                 and building and not sharing with any other institution.
                                The new building is under construction at Umaiyalpuram
                                 which is about 10 kms from Athanurpatti.
                                Records were not available & were said to be with the
                                 management/Correspondent of the College.
                                There are no basic amenities like drinking water, toilet etc.”




     (Gangadharaiah)                                                         (Prof. C. Thangamuthu)
Regional Director, SRC, NCTE                                                  Chairman, SRC, NCTE
                                                 101
                                                                                        st
                                                                             Minutes-201 Meeting of SRC
                                                                                      22-23 February 2011
                                Accordingly, notice was issued to the institution on 06.01.2011. The
                               institution submitted its reply on 07.02.2011.

                               The committee considered the reply submitted by the institution
                               and found the reply to be unsatisfactory and unconvincing and
                               decided to withdraw recognition for B.Ed (APS03614) course
                               with effect from 2012-13, in order to enable the ongoing batch of
                               students in B.Ed course, if any, to complete their course.

                               But it is made clear that the institution is debarred from making
                               any further admission subsequent to the date of issue of this
                               order.

                               The Affiliating body / Examining board / body be informed
                               accordingly.

                               Further decided to return Endowment funds and Reserve fund
                               deposited with SRC NCTE, Bangalore if any.

78.       APS04399             Nandha College of Education, 29/4, Koorapalayam, Pirivu,
            B.Ed               Pituchandampalayam Post, Erode-638052, Tamilnadu has been
       Nandha College of       granted recognition for B.Ed Course of one year duration with an
       Education, Erode        annual intake of 100 students on 31.08.2006.
             TN
                               As per the direction of Ministry of Human Resource Development
                               (MHRD), as per recommendation of Sri. Sathyam Committee reports
                               on all the institution, which were granted recognition by SRC in its
                               116th meeting. The re-inspection for B.Ed course of the institution
                               was carried out on 18.12.2008.

                               The visiting team report was placed before SRC in its 170th meeting
                               held on 16-17th February 2009 and SRC decided to issue show
                               cause notice under section 17 of NCTE Act, accordingly a show
                               cause notice was issued to the institution on 02.04.2009.

                               The institution did not submit its reply even after completion of
                               stipulated period. The matter was considered by SRC in its 191st
                               meeting held 20-21st April 2010 and it was decided to issue final
                               notice to the institution to submit the reply within 21 days.
                               Accordingly, final Notice was issued on 1.6.2010

                               The office did not receive any reply from the institution thus far.
                               Hence, the Committee considered the matter in its 194th meeting
                               held on 21st-22nd July 2010 and decided to withdraw recognition

                               Accordingly withdrawal of recognition order was issued to the
                               institution on 20.8.2010. Aggrieved by the withdrawal of SRC, the
                               institution filed court case in W.P. no. 18549 of 2010. The court has
                               orders as follows:




     (Gangadharaiah)                                                       (Prof. C. Thangamuthu)
Regional Director, SRC, NCTE                                                Chairman, SRC, NCTE
                                                102
                                                                                              st
                                                                                  Minutes-201 Meeting of SRC
                                                                                           22-23 February 2011
                               “The Learned Counsel appearing for the respondent has produced an order
                               dated 20.8.2010 withdrawing recognition granted to the petitioner to
                                                                                           th
                               conduct B.Ed course. While the decision of the 194 meeting of the
                               respondent was relating to other institutions also, the order dated 20.8.2010
                               is relating to the petitioner alone. The order nowhere considers the
                               representation given by the petitioner in reply to the show cause notice
                               dated 1.6.2010. Hence, the impugned order was passed in violation of
                               principles of natural justice. Hence, the impugned order is quashed and the
                               respondent is directed to consider and pass a fresh order after considering
                               the explanation given by the petitioner referred to above within a period of
                               eight weeks from the date of receipt of copy of this order”.

                               The court order was placed before SRC in its 196th meeting held on
                               15th and 16th September, 2010. SRC considered the matter and
                               decided to await for the documentary evidence and clarifications
                               from the institution. Further, SRC has decided that on receipt of the
                               necessary documents the application be processed as per the usual
                               procedure.

                               In response to the decision of SRC, the reply for final notice
                               submitted by the institution vide their letter dated 18.6.2010 was
                               scrutinized. The Committee in its 198th meeting held on 24th-26th
                               November 2010 considered the written reply of the institution dt.
                               18.6.2010 and all the relevant documentary evidences and it was
                               decided to serve Showcause Notice under Section 17 of NCTE Act
                               for the following. Accordingly, notice was issued to the institution on
                               05.01.2011. The institution submitted its reply on 27.01.2011 and
                               01.02.2011.

                               The Committee considered the reply to Show Cause Notice, VT
                               Report, VCD and all the relevant documentary evidences and it
                               was decided to serve Final Showcause Notice Under Section 17
                               of NCTE Act for the following :

                                The institution has to submit Building Completion
                                 Certificate from the authorised Government Engineer for the
                                 built up area.

                               In view of the above, the Committee decided to issue a Final
                               Showcause Notice to the institution as to why the recognition
                               be not withdrawn and thereby providing an opportunity to the
                               institution to make a written representation within 30 days from
                               the date of issue of the Notice along with necessary
                               certificates/documents in order to take a final decision in the
                               matter; failing which action will be taken including the
                               withdrawal of Recognition, based on the records available, with
                               no further notice.




     (Gangadharaiah)                                                             (Prof. C. Thangamuthu)
Regional Director, SRC, NCTE                                                      Chairman, SRC, NCTE
                                                  103
                                                                                          st
                                                                               Minutes-201 Meeting of SRC
                                                                                        22-23 February 2011
79.          APS04710           All Saints    College    of   Education,    Kanyakumari        District,
                B.Ed            Tamilnadu
        All Saints College of
      Education, Kanyakumari    All Saints College of Education, Kanyakumari, Tamilnadu was
                 TN             granted recognition for offering B.Ed course with an intake of 100
                                students on 05.09.2006 with the condition to shift to own premises
                                within 3 years.

                                The Ministry of Human Resource Development (MHRD),
                                Government of India, based on the inquiry report submitted by Sri.
                                Sathyam, IAS (Retd) has directed NCTE for taking action. In this
                                regard, it has been envisaged that all the cases cleared by SRC in
                                its 116th meeting held on 22-23 August 2006 should be re-inspected
                                and the maintenance of Norms and Standards should be verified.

                                The above institution was one amongst 71 institutions which was
                                granted recognition in the 116th meeting held on 22-23rd August
                                2006. Based on the directions of MHRD, inspection under section
                                17 of the above institution was carried out on 18.12.2008. The VT
                                report, VCD, original application file along with other documents
                                were placed before SRC in its 170th meeting held on 16-17 February
                                2009. SRC decided to issue notice under section 17 of NCTE Act,
                                for the deficiencies noted. Accordingly, notice was issued to the
                                institution on 02.04.2009. The institution submitted its reply on
                                15.04.2009.

                                SRC in its 178th meeting held on 13-14 July 2009 considered the
                                reply wherein SRC noted that the second floor of the building is
                                completed after inspection. The Committee decided to cause
                                inspection to verify the built up space available after completion of
                                building after payment of Rs.40000/- for inspection fees. Accordingly,
                                a letter was issued to the institution on 25.08.2009. The institution
                                has not submitted the required fee and documents.

                                SRC in its 181st meeting held on 20-21st August 2009 where in it was
                                decided that the institution which have not shifted to the permanent
                                premises even after the expiry of three years time limit be issued
                                notice under section 17 of NCTE Act for further action. But the notice
                                was not issued then. Hence the matter was brought to the notice. As
                                directed on 15.07.2010, a notice as decided in 181st SRC meeting
                                was issued on 23.7.2010. The institution has submitted its reply on
                                12.08.2010.

                                And whereas, the matter was considered by the Committee in its
                                195th meeting held on 17th-18th August 2010 and it was decided to
                                cause inspection of the institution for B.Ed. Course, under Section 17
                                of NCTE Act, after payment of Rs.40,000/- inspection fee and on
                                submission of filled in Questionnaire, along with relevant supporting
                                documents relating to building, land, including Building Completion




     (Gangadharaiah)                                                         (Prof. C. Thangamuthu)
Regional Director, SRC, NCTE                                                  Chairman, SRC, NCTE
                                                 104
                                                                                       st
                                                                            Minutes-201 Meeting of SRC
                                                                                     22-23 February 2011
                               Certificate from the competent Government Engineer and Land Use
                               Certificate, within four weeks from the date of confirmation of the
                               Minutes.

                               A letter has been issued to the institution to submit the above
                               documents on 22.09.2010. The institution submitted the documents
                               with the VT members but not submitted Rs.40000/-.

                               The inspection of the institution was conducted on 23.10.2010. The
                               Committee in its 198th meeting held on 24th-26th November 2010
                               considered the VT Report, VCD and all the relevant documentary
                               evidences and it was decided to serve Show cause Notice Under
                               Section 17 of NCTE Act for the following deficiencies. Accordingly a
                               notice was issued to the institution on 11.01.2011. The institution
                               submitted its reply on 10.02.2011.

                               The Committee considered the reply to Show Cause Notice, VT
                               Report, VCD and all the relevant documentary evidences and it
                               was decided to serve Final Showcause Notice Under Section 17
                               of NCTE Act for the following :


                                A Certificate from the Government affiliating body to the
                                  effect that no other programme is being conducted by the
                                  institution in the same building/campus, along with the
                                  existing course, is to be submitted.


                               In view of the above, the Committee decided to issue a Final
                               Showcause Notice to the institution as to why the recognition
                               be not withdrawn and thereby providing an opportunity to the
                               institution to make a written representation within 30 days from
                               the date of issue of the Notice along with necessary
                               certificates/documents in order to take a final decision in the
                               matter; failing which action will be taken including the
                               withdrawal of Recognition, based on the records available, with
                               no further notice.




     (Gangadharaiah)                                                       (Prof. C. Thangamuthu)
Regional Director, SRC, NCTE                                                Chairman, SRC, NCTE
                                                105
                                                                                               st
                                                                                   Minutes-201 Meeting of SRC
                                                                                            22-23 February 2011
80.         APS03280           SRC-NCTE granted recognition to Ruben College of Education,
               B.Ed            Kanyakumari District, Tamilnadu for B.Ed course vide order no.
         Ruben College of      F.TN.SEC/SRO/NCTE/2005-2006/1591 dated 7.7.2005 with an intake of
      Education, Kanyakumari   100 students from the academic session 2005-06.
                TN             NCTE-Hqrs. has forwarded W.P. No. 910 of 2006 filed by Shri. R. Jenson
                               Muthraj against Ruben College of Education, Kanyakumari District,
                               Tamilnadu. In the writ petition the petitioner alleged that the institution
                               claims to own 4 acres 95 cents of land in the same location, a school
                               having class 1 to XII is running. In response to the above letter, it has been
                               informed to NCTE-Hqrs. vide our letter dated 3.1.2007 that surprise
                               inspection will be conducted and the report will be placed. But, no such
                               inspection has been conducted and no further action has been taken.
                               A requisition letter has been received from the institution on 26.7.2010,
                               stated that they have started running the institution during the academic
                               year 2005-2006 in accordance to the reference. As per the prevailing norms
                               that in that period an extent of 5 acres of land was desirable for 4000 sq.mt
                               of land, and requested to issue the permission, that the excess land may be
                               utilized for starting an other institution.
                                                                                         th
                               The matter was considered by the Committee in its 195 meeting held on
                                  th    th
                               17 -18 August 2010 and it was decided to cause inspection of the
                               institution for B.Ed. Course, under Section 17 of NCTE Act, after payment
                               of Rs. 40,000/- inspection fee and on submission of filled in Questionnaire,
                               along with relevant supporting documents relating to building, land,
                               including Building Completion Certificate from the competent Government
                               Engineer and Land Use Certificate, within four weeks from the date of
                               confirmation of the Minutes.

                               A letter has been issued to the institution on 22.09.2010 to submit the D.D.
                               of Rs.40000/- alongwith essential documents. The institution submitted its
                               reply on 18.10.2010 alongwith Rs.40000/-. The inspection of the institution
                                                                                         th
                               was carried out on 22.10.2010. The Committee in its 198 meeting held on
                                  th   th
                               24 -26 November 2010 considered the VT Report, VCD and all the
                               relevant documentary evidences and it was decided to serve Show cause
                               Notice Under Section 17

                                Accordingly a notice was issued to the institution on 11.01.2011.
                               Meanwhile, a complaint has been received from DTERT, Chennai on
                               13.01.2011 regarding faculty members working in the Ruben Teacher
                               Training Institute who were also working in the Ruben B.Ed College. SRC
                               in its 200th meeting held on 20-21 January 2011 considerded the DTERT
                               report and decided to issue notice. Notice could not be issued and the
                               same was placed before SRC along with the written representation for
                               notice submitted by the institution on 08.02.2011.

                               The Committee considered the reply to Show Cause Notice,
                               Complaint of DTERT, Chennai, VT Report, VCD and all the
                               relevant documentary evidences and it was decided to serve
                               Final Showcause Notice Under Section 17 of NCTE Act for the
                               following :




     (Gangadharaiah)                                                             (Prof. C. Thangamuthu)
Regional Director, SRC, NCTE                                                      Chairman, SRC, NCTE
                                                  106
                                                                                       st
                                                                            Minutes-201 Meeting of SRC
                                                                                     22-23 February 2011
                                Certificate from the Government/affiliating body to the effect
                                 that no other programme is being conducted by the
                                 institution in the same building/campus, along with the
                                 existing course is to be submitted.
                                Building completion certificate issued by authorised
                                 Government Engineer/competent authority is to be
                                 submitted.
                                As per the DTERT report, the management has suppressed
                                 the fact that three faculty members namely Mr. J. Nirmal
                                 Thambi, Miss J. Ajitha & Mrs. T. Gayathri are working both in
                                 the Ruben Teacher Training institute and Ruben B.Ed
                                 College.
                                As per the enquiry conducted by the Joint Director
                                 (Administration), DTERT Chennai and as per the August-
                                 2010 attendance register of Ruben Teacher                Training
                                 Institute and Ruben B.Ed College, Miss. J. Ajitha name has
                                 been found in the both attendance registers.
                                One full time faculty member cannot be shown
                                 simultaneously in two institutions (both the Teacher
                                 Training Institute as well as B.Ed college at the same time).
                                This is a clear indication of suppressing the facts and trying
                                 to mislead NCTE and other various departments for getting
                                 recognition, affiliation and approval to the staff list.

                               In view of the above, the Committee decided to issue a Final
                               Showcause Notice to the institution as to why the recognition
                               be not withdrawn and thereby providing an opportunity to the
                               institution to make a written representation within 30 days from
                               the date of issue of the Notice along with necessary
                               certificates/documents in order to take a final decision in the
                               matter; failing which action will be taken including the
                               withdrawal of Recognition, based on the records available, with
                               no further notice.

81.        APS01128            PDR Vellachiammal College of Education, Dharmapuri submitted an
              B.Ed             application for grant of recognition for B.Ed course on 24.12.2002.
      PDR Vellachiammal
                               Recognition was granted to the institution on 09.09.2004 at PDR
      College of Education,
                               Vellachiammal College of Education, Sekkampatti, Soriampatti-
           Dharmapuri
                               636902, Dharmapuri, Tamilnadu with the condition to shift to own
               TN
                               premises within 3 years.
                               The institution vide letter dated 29.10.2007 submitted proposal for
                               shifting along with Rs.40000/-. The inspection was carried out on
                               18.10.2010. The Committee in its 198th meeting held on 24th-26th
                               November 2010 considered the VT Report and all the relevant
                               documentary evidences and it was decided to serve Show cause
                               Notice Under Section 17. Accordingly notice was issued to the
                               institution on 03.01.2011. The institution submitted its reply on
                               14.02.2011.




     (Gangadharaiah)                                                      (Prof. C. Thangamuthu)
Regional Director, SRC, NCTE                                               Chairman, SRC, NCTE
                                                107
                                                                                         st
                                                                              Minutes-201 Meeting of SRC
                                                                                       22-23 February 2011
                               The Committee considered the reply to Show Cause Notice, VT
                               Report, VCD and all the relevant documentary evidences and it
                               was decided to serve Final Showcause Notice Under Section 17
                               of NCTE Act for the following :

                                The latest Building Completion Certificate issued by
                                 authorised Government Engineer/competent authority is to
                                 be submitted.

                               In view of the above, the Committee decided to issue a Final
                               Showcause Notice to the institution as to why the recognition
                               be not withdrawn and thereby providing an opportunity to the
                               institution to make a written representation within 30 days from
                               the date of issue of the Notice along with necessary
                               certificates/documents in order to take a final decision in the
                               matter; failing which action will be taken including the
                               withdrawal of Recognition, based on the records available, with
                               no further notice.

82.        APS03798            Palaniammal Teacher Training Institute, Coimbatore District, TN
             D.T.Ed
      Palaniammal Teacher      KMG Charitable Trust, Coimbatore submitted an application in the
        Training Institute,    name and style of Palaniammal Teacher Training Institute for
           Coimbatore          seeking grant of recognition for D.T.Ed course on 20.12.2004.
               TN
                               The application was processed and recognition order to the
                               institution was issued to the institution on 08.12.2005 at
                               Palaniammal Teacher Training Institute, V. Kaliapuram Post,
                               Vettaikaran Pudur Via, Pollachi, Coimbatore, Tamilnadu with the
                               condition to shift to own premises within 3 years.

                               The institution vide its letter dated 01.06.2010 submitted proposal for
                               shifting to new premises alongwith Rs. 40000/-. The inspection of the
                               institution for shifting of premises was carried out on 13.11.2010.
                               The Committee in its 198th meeting held on 24th-26th November 2010
                               considered the VT Report,VCD and all the relevant documentary
                               evidences and it was decided to serve Show cause Notice Under
                               Section 17 of NCTE Act. Accordingly, notice was issued to the
                               institution on 06.01.2011. The institution submitted its reply on
                               07.02.2011.

                               The management is running a B.Ed programme in the same
                               building/premises/survey nos in the name of KMG Teacher Training
                               Institute, Coimbatore.

                               The Committee considered the reply to Show Cause Notice, VT
                               Report, VCD and all the relevant documentary evidences and it
                               was decided to serve Final Showcause Notice Under Section 17
                               of NCTE Act for the following :




     (Gangadharaiah)                                                         (Prof. C. Thangamuthu)
Regional Director, SRC, NCTE                                                  Chairman, SRC, NCTE
                                                 108
                                                                                           st
                                                                                Minutes-201 Meeting of SRC
                                                                                         22-23 February 2011
                                A certificate from the Government affiliating body i.e. DTERT
                                 to the effect that no other programme is being conducted by
                                 the institution in the same building/campus, along with the
                                 existing course D.T.Ed is to be submitted.
                                The management is also running a B.Ed programme in the
                                 name of KMG Teacher Training Institute at the same
                                 address/survey nos. and is misleading NCTE.
                                The institution has to submit fresh and new VCD to show
                                 that the construction of the building is completed.
                                The latest Building completion certificate from the
                                 competent Government Engineer/competent authority to be
                                 submitted.

                               In view of the above, the Committee decided to issue a Final
                               Showcause Notice to the institution as to why the recognition
                               be not withdrawn and thereby providing an opportunity to the
                               institution to make a written representation within 30 days from
                               the date of issue of the Notice along with necessary
                               certificates/documents in order to take a final decision in the
                               matter; failing which action will be taken including the
                               withdrawal of Recognition, based on the records available, with
                               no further notice.
83.         APS04712           Vijayalakshmi Teacher Training Institute, Dharmapuri District,
              D.T.Ed           Tamilnadu
      Vijayalakshmi Teacher
         Training Institute,   Vijayalakshmi Teacher Training Institute, Dharmapuri submitted an
           Dharmapuri          application for grant of recognition for D.T.Ed course on 30.12.2005.
                TN
                               The application was processed and the recognition order was issued
                               to the institution on 09.01.2007 at D.No.1/270, Siva Salai, Collector
                               Bungalow Road, Devarasampatti, A. Jettihalli Post, Dharmapuri-
                               636807, Tamilnadu with the condition to shift to own premises within
                               3 years.

                               The institution vide letter dated 14.12.2009 submitted Rs.40000/-
                               towards inspection fee. The inspection of the institution for shifting of
                               premises was carried out on 23.10.2010.

                               The Committee in its 198th meeting held on 24th-26th November 2010
                               considered the VT Report, VCD and all the relevant documentary
                               evidences and it was decided to serve Show cause Notice Under
                               Section 17 of NCTE Act for the following. Accordingly, notice was
                               issued to the institution on 03.01.2011. The institution submitted its
                               reply on 07.02.2011.

                               The Committee considered the VT Report, VCD and all the
                               relevant documentary evidences and it was decided to cause
                               re-inspection in anticipation of payment of re-inspection fee of
                               Rs.40,000/-.




     (Gangadharaiah)                                                          (Prof. C. Thangamuthu)
Regional Director, SRC, NCTE                                                   Chairman, SRC, NCTE
                                                 109
                                                                                              st
                                                                                  Minutes-201 Meeting of SRC
                                                                                           22-23 February 2011
84.          APS03680          KMG Teacher Training Institute, Coimbatore District, Tamilnadu
                B.Ed
                               KMG Charitable Trust, Coimbatore submitted an application in the name
      KMG Teacher Training     and style of KMG College of Education for seeking grant of recognition for
       Institute, Coimbatore   B.Ed course on 27.12.2004.
                  TN
                               The application was processed and the recognition order was issued to the
                               institution on 01.08.2006 at KMG College of Education, V. Kaliapuram Post,
                               Vettaikkaran, Pudur (Via), Pollachi Taluk, Coimbatore-642129, Tamilnadu
                               with the condition to shift to own premises within 3 years.

                               Notice was issued to the institution on 08.10.2009 calling for documents to
                               examine the proposal for shifting of premises. The institution vide letter
                               dated 28.10.2009 submitted a proposal for shifting to new premises
                               alongwith Rs.40000/-.

                               The management is also running D.T.Ed programme in the same
                               building/premises in the name of Palaniammal Teacher Training Institute,
                               Coimbatore (APS03798).

                               The inspection of the institution for shifting of premises was carried out on
                                                                       th                    th   th
                               13.11.2010. The Committee in its 198 meeting held on 24 -26 November
                               2010 considered the VT Report, VCD and all the relevant documentary
                               evidences and it was decided to serve Show cause Notice Under Section
                               17 of NCTE Act for the following. Accordingly, notice was issued to the
                               institution on 05.01.2011. The institution submitted its reply on 07.02.2011.

                               The Committee considered the reply to Show Cause Notice, VT
                               Report, VCD and all the relevant documentary evidences and it
                               was decided to serve Final Showcause Notice Under Section 17
                               of NCTE Act for the following :
                                Building completion certificate issued by authorised
                                   Government Engineer/authority is to be submitted.
                                A certificate from the Government affiliating body i.e. DTERT
                                   to the effect that no other programme being conducted by
                                   the institution in the same building / campus, along with the
                                   existing course B.Ed is to be submitted.
                                Latest VCD of the Building covering full view and all
                                   portions of the building should be submitted.
                                The management is also running D.T.Ed programme in the
                                   same building/premises in the name of Palaniammal
                                   Teacher Training Institute, Coimbatore (APS03798).

                               In view of the above, the Committee decided to issue a Final
                               Showcause Notice to the institution as to why the recognition
                               be not withdrawn and thereby providing an opportunity to the
                               institution to make a written representation within 30 days from
                               the date of issue of the Notice along with necessary
                               certificates/documents in order to take a final decision in the
                               matter; failing which action will be taken including the
                               withdrawal of Recognition, based on the records available, with
                               no further notice.



     (Gangadharaiah)                                                             (Prof. C. Thangamuthu)
Regional Director, SRC, NCTE                                                      Chairman, SRC, NCTE
                                                  110
                                                                                        st
                                                                             Minutes-201 Meeting of SRC
                                                                                      22-23 February 2011
85.         APS05688           Sri Mahalakshmi Teacher Training Institute, Coimbatore District,
              D.T.Ed           Tamilnadu
        Sri Mahalakshmi
        Teacher Training       Sri Mahalakshmi Educational Trust, Coimbatore submitted an
      Institute, Coimbatore    application in the name and style of Sri Mahalakshmi Teacher
                 TN            Training Institute for seeking grant of recognition for D.T.Ed course
                               on 02.01.2006.

                               The application was processed and recognition order was issued to
                               the institution on 13.11.2006 at Sri Mahalakshmi Teacher Training
                               Institute for Women, No.3/302, Mangalam, Palladam, Tirupur Taluk,
                               Coimbatore, Tamilnadu with the condition to shift to own premises
                               within 3 years.

                               The institution vide letter dated 15.07.2008 submitted for a proposal
                               for shifting to new premises alongwith Rs.40000/-. A letter was
                               issued to the institution on 12.06.2009 calling for documents to
                               examine the proposal for shifting of premises. The inspection of the
                               institution was carried out on 14.11.2010. The Committee in its 198th
                               meeting held on 24th-26th November 2010 considered the VT Report
                               and all the relevant documentary evidences and it was decided to
                               serve Show cause Notice Under Section 17 of NCTE Act.
                               Accordingly, notice was issued to the institution on 05.01.2011. The
                               institution submitted its reply on 04.02.2011.

                               The Committee considered the reply to Show Cause Notice, VT
                               Report, VCD and all the relevant documentary evidences and it
                               was decided to serve Final Showcause Notice Under Section 17
                               of NCTE Act for the following :

                                The management in their application dt.02.01.2006 has
                                 mentioned the address as “Sri.Mahalakshmi Educational
                                 Trust” for grant of recognition. But in the land documents,
                                 it has changed the trust name as Sri.Alagammal charitable
                                 Aid Mission, without the approval of NCTE, Bangalore.

                               In view of the above, the Committee decided to issue a Final
                               Showcause Notice to the institution as to why the recognition
                               be not withdrawn and thereby providing an opportunity to the
                               institution to make a written representation within 30 days from
                               the date of issue of the Notice along with necessary
                               certificates/documents in order to take a final decision in the
                               matter; failing which action will be taken including the
                               withdrawal of Recognition, based on the records available, with
                               no further notice.




     (Gangadharaiah)                                                       (Prof. C. Thangamuthu)
Regional Director, SRC, NCTE                                                Chairman, SRC, NCTE
                                                111
                                                                                         st
                                                                              Minutes-201 Meeting of SRC
                                                                                       22-23 February 2011
86.       APS03630             Amman College of Education, Dindigul District, Tamilnadu
              B.Ed
       Amman College of        Amman Educational Trust, Dindigul submitted an application in the
       Education, Dindigul     name and style of Amman College of Education for seeking grant of
               TN              recognition for B.Ed course on 30.12.2004.

                               The application was processed and the recognition order was issued
                               to the institution on 04.01.2006 at Amman College of Education,
                               VSKS Nagar, Bye-Pass Road, Dindigul-625001, Tamilnadu with the
                               condition to shift to own premises within 3 years.

                               The institution vide letter dated 02.03.2009 submitted Rs. 40000/-
                               information about college shifted to own premises. SRC in its 181st
                               meeting held on 20th-21st August 2009 wherein, it was decided that
                               the institution which have not shifted to the permanent premises
                               even after the expiry of three years time limit be issued notice under
                               Section 17 of NCTE Act for further action. Accordingly a notice has
                               been issued to the institution on 16.09.2009. The institution vide
                               letter dated 01.10.2009 submitted reply to notice.

                               The inspection of the institution for shifting of premises was
                               conducted on 23.10.2010. The Committee in its 198th meeting held
                               on 24th-26th November 2010 considered the VT Report, VCD and all
                               the relevant documentary evidences and it was decided to serve
                               Show cause Notice Under Section 17 of NCTE Act. Accordingly,
                               notice was issued to the institution on 11.01.2011. The institution
                               submitted its reply on 04.02.2011.

                               The Committee considered the reply to Show Cause Notice, VT
                               Report, VCD and all the relevant documentary evidences and it
                               was decided to serve Final Showcause Notice Under Section 17
                               of NCTE Act for the following :

                                The latest Building completion certificate from the
                                 competent Government Engineer to be submitted in the
                                 prescribed format.

                               In view of the above, the Committee decided to issue a Final
                               Showcause Notice to the institution as to why the recognition
                               be not withdrawn and thereby providing an opportunity to the
                               institution to make a written representation within 30 days from
                               the date of issue of the Notice along with necessary
                               certificates/documents in order to take a final decision in the
                               matter; failing which action will be taken including the
                               withdrawal of Recognition, based on the records available, with
                               no further notice.




     (Gangadharaiah)                                                        (Prof. C. Thangamuthu)
Regional Director, SRC, NCTE                                                 Chairman, SRC, NCTE
                                                112
                                                                                           st
                                                                                Minutes-201 Meeting of SRC
                                                                                         22-23 February 2011
87.          APS01464            Victory Teacher Training Institute, Kambilampatty, Dindigul
                D.T.Ed           District, Tamilnadu
      Victory Teacher Training
          Institute, Dindigul    Victory Teacher Training Institute, Kambilampatty, Dindigul was
                  TN             granted recognition to D.T.Ed course on 28.10.2004 with an intake
                                 of 50 students.

                                 The institution submitted its proposal for shifting alongwith
                                 Rs.40000/- on 11.09.2007. The inspection of the institution for
                                 shifting of premises was conducted on 20.10.2010.

                                 The Committee in its 198th meeting held on 24th-26th November 2010
                                 considered the VT Report,VCD and all the relevant documentary
                                 evidences and it was decided to serve Show cause Notice Under
                                 Section 17 of NCTE Act for the following. . Accordingly, notice was
                                 issued to the institution on 03.01.2011. The institution submitted its
                                 reply on 31.01.2011

                                 The Committee considered the reply to Show Cause Notice, VT
                                 Report, VCD and all the relevant documentary evidences and it
                                 was decided to serve Final Showcause Notice Under Section 17
                                 of NCTE Act for the following :

                                  Building completion certificate from the competent
                                   Government Engineer to be submitted in the prescribed
                                   format.

                                 In view of the above, the Committee decided to issue a Final
                                 Showcause Notice to the institution as to why the recognition
                                 be not withdrawn and thereby providing an opportunity to the
                                 institution to make a written representation within 30 days from
                                 the date of issue of the Notice along with necessary
                                 certificates/documents in order to take a final decision in the
                                 matter; failing which action will be taken including the
                                 withdrawal of Recognition, based on the records available, with
                                 no further notice.




     (Gangadharaiah)                                                          (Prof. C. Thangamuthu)
Regional Director, SRC, NCTE                                                   Chairman, SRC, NCTE
                                                  113
                                                                                           st
                                                                                Minutes-201 Meeting of SRC
                                                                                         22-23 February 2011
88.         APS06008           Mother Teresa Women‟s University B.Ed. College, Anandagiri 4th
               B.Ed            Street, Kodaikanal-624102, Dindigul District, Tamilnadu was
      Mother Teresa Women‟s    accorded recognition for B.Ed. course on 30.08.2006.
        University, Dindigul
                TN             As per the recommendation of Sri. Sathyam Committee reports and
                               based on the Directions of MHRD, re-inspection was conducted to all
                               the institutions which were granted recognition in 116th meeting of
                               SRC.

                               Inspection of the institution under Section 17 was conducted on
                               16.12.2008 and the VT report along with all documents were placed
                               before 169th meeting of SRC held during 12-13 January, 2009
                               wherein it was decided to issue Notice under Section 17 of NCTE
                               Act. Accordingly, a Notice was issued to the institution on 6.3.2009.
                               The institution submitted its written representation on 3.4.2009 along
                               with supporting documents.

                               The Committee in its 178th meeting held on 13th-14th July 2009
                               decided to issue showcause Notice under Section 17 of NCTE Act
                               for providing insufficient infrastructural and instructional facilities at
                               the temporary premises and also for not shifting to permanent / own
                               premises before 29.8.2009. Further, the Committee decided to call
                               for 10 documents immediately for shifting of premises and causing of
                               inspection. Accordingly notice was issued to the institution on
                               31.07.2009. The institution submitted its reply on 10.09.2009 along
                               with Rs.40000/-

                               The inspection of the institution for shifting of premises was carried
                               out on 21.10.2010. The Committee in its 198th meeting held on 24th-
                               26th November 2010 considered the VT Report, VCD and all the
                               relevant documentary evidences and it was decided to serve Show
                               cause Notice Under Section 17 of NCTE Act for the following.
                               Accordingly, notice was issued to the institution on 06.01.2011. The
                               institution submitted its reply on 24.01.2011.


                               The Committee considered the written representation from the
                               institution dt. 07.01.2011 to the show cause notice and all other
                               related documents along with the original file of the institution,
                               and decided to Continue Recognition and also shifting to
                               new/permanent premises be permitted.




     (Gangadharaiah)                                                           (Prof. C. Thangamuthu)
Regional Director, SRC, NCTE                                                    Chairman, SRC, NCTE
                                                 114
                                                                                             st
                                                                                Minutes-201 Meeting of SRC
                                                                                         22-23 February 2011
89.        APS04653            Pachamuthu College of Education, Dharmapuri, Tamilnadu
              B.Ed
      Pachamuthu College of    Pachamuthu College of Education, Dharmapuri submitted an
      Education, Dharmapuri    application for grant of recognition for B.Ed course on 21.12.2005.
               TN
                               Recognition order to was issued to the institution on 06.10.2006 at
                               Pachumuthu College of Education, No.26-C, Salem Main Road,
                               Virupatchipuram Village, Dharmapuri-636705, Tamilnadu with the
                               condition to shift to own premises within 3 years.

                               SRC in its 181st meeting held on 20th-21st August 2009 wherein, it
                               was decided that the institution which have not shifted to the
                               permanent premises even after the expiry of three years time limit be
                               issued notice under Section 17 of NCTE Act for further action.
                               Accordingly a notice has been issued to the institution on
                               03.09.2009. The institution vide letter dated 28.10.2009 submitted
                               Rs.40000, for shifting to new premises.

                               The inspection was carried out on 21.10.2010. The Committee in its
                               198th meeting held on 24th-26th November 2010 considered the VT
                               Report, VCD and all the relevant documentary evidences and it was
                               decided to serve Show cause Notice Under Section 17 of NCTE Act
                               for the following. Accordingly, notice was issued to the institution on
                               04.01.2011. The institution submitted its reply on 25.01.2011

                               The management          is   running   D.T.Ed   course   in        the   same
                               building/premies.

                               The Committee considered the reply to Show Cause Notice, VT
                               Report, VCD and all the relevant documentary evidences and it
                               was decided to serve Final Showcause Notice Under Section 17
                               of NCTE Act for the following :

                                Staff list duly approved by the affiliating authority is to be
                                 submitted.
                                Fresh VCD covering full view of the building and other
                                 portions of the Building is to be submitted.

                               In view of the above, the Committee decided to issue a Final
                               Showcause Notice to the institution as to why the recognition
                               be not withdrawn and thereby providing an opportunity to the
                               institution to make a written representation within 30 days from
                               the date of issue of the Notice along with necessary
                               certificates/documents in order to take a final decision in the
                               matter; failing which action will be taken including the
                               withdrawal of Recognition, based on the records available, with
                               no further notice.




     (Gangadharaiah)                                                           (Prof. C. Thangamuthu)
Regional Director, SRC, NCTE                                                    Chairman, SRC, NCTE
                                                 115
                                                                                         st
                                                                              Minutes-201 Meeting of SRC
                                                                                       22-23 February 2011
90.       APS04658             Pachamuthu Teacher Training Institute, Dharmapuri, Tamilnadu
            D.T.Ed
      Pachamuthu Teacher       Pachamuthu Teacher Training Institute, Dharmapuri submitted an
       Training Institute,     application for grant of recognition for D.T.Ed course on 15.02.2005.
          Dharmapuri
              TN               Recognition order was issued to the institution on 24.10.2006 at
                               Pachumuthu Teacher Training Institute, Salem Main Road,
                               Virupatchipuram Village, Dharmapuri-636705, Tamilnadu with the
                               condition to shift to own premises within 3 years.

                               SRC in its 181st meeting held on 20th-21st August 2009 wherein, it
                               was decided that the institution which have not shifted to the
                               permanent premises even after the expiry of three years time limit be
                               issued notice under Section 17 of NCTE Act for further action.
                               Accordingly a notice has been issued to the institution on
                               11.09.2009. The institution vide letter dated 01.10.2009 submitted
                               Rs.40000/- towards shifting fee.

                               The inspection of the institution for shifting of premises was carried
                               out on 20.10.2010. The Committee in its 198th meeting held on 24th-
                               26th November 2010 considered the VT Report, VCD and all the
                               relevant documentary evidences and it was decided to serve Show
                               cause Notice Under Section 17 of NCTE Act for the following.
                               Accordingly, notice was issued to the institution on 05.01.2011. The
                               institution submitted its reply on 25.01.2011.

                               The management is also funning B.Ed course in the same
                               building/campus.

                               The Committee considered the reply to Show Cause Notice, VT
                               Report, VCD and all the relevant documentary evidences and it
                               was decided to serve Final Showcause Notice Under Section 17
                               of NCTE Act for the following :

                                Staff list duly approved by the affiliating authority is to be
                                 submitted.
                                Fresh VCD covering full view of the building and other
                                 portions of the Building is to be submitted.

                               In view of the above, the Committee decided to issue a Final
                               Showcause Notice to the institution as to why the recognition
                               be not withdrawn and thereby providing an opportunity to the
                               institution to make a written representation within 30 days from
                               the date of issue of the Notice along with necessary
                               certificates/documents in order to take a final decision in the
                               matter; failing which action will be taken including the
                               withdrawal of Recognition, based on the records available, with
                               no further notice.




     (Gangadharaiah)                                                        (Prof. C. Thangamuthu)
Regional Director, SRC, NCTE                                                 Chairman, SRC, NCTE
                                                116
                                                                                         st
                                                                              Minutes-201 Meeting of SRC
                                                                                       22-23 February 2011
91.          APS01422          Supa Teacher Training Institute, Dharmapuri district, Tamilnadu
              D.T.Ed-AI
      Supa Teacher Training    Supa Teacher Training Institute, Dharmapuri submitted an
       Institute, Dharmapuri   application for grant of recognition for D.T.Ed-AI course on
                  TN           29.12.2004.

                               The application was processed and recognition order was issued to
                               the institution on 25.08.2005 at Supa Teacher Training Institute,
                               No.7-A, Venkata Sharma Road, Dharmapuri-636701, Tamilnadu with
                               the condition to shift to own premises within 3 years.

                               The institution vide letter dated 29.10.2008 submitted Rs.40000/-
                               towards shifting fee. A letter was issued on 12.06.2009 to the
                               institution calling for documents to examine the proposal for shifting
                               of premises. The institution submitted its reply on 06.07.2009.

                               The inspection of the institution for shifting of premises was carried
                               out on 22.10.2010. The Committee in its 198th meeting held on 24th-
                               26th November 2010 considered the VT Report, VCD and all the
                               relevant documentary evidences and it was decided to serve Show
                               cause Notice Under Section 17 of NCTE Act for the following.
                               Accordingly, notice was issued to the institution on 03.01.2011. The
                               institution submitted its reply on 25.01.2011

                               The committee considered the written reply and other relevant
                               documents and decided to cause composite re-inspection for
                               all courses, along with the payment of inspection fee of
                               Rs.40,000/- drawn in favour of “The Member Secretary, NCTE”
                               payable at Bangalore and submission of Building Completion
                               Certificate from competent Government Engineer in the
                               prescribed format.

92.        APS04882            Dr. Nagarathinam’s College of Education, Salem District,
              B.Ed             Tamilnadu
       Dr. Nagarathinam‟s
      College of Education,    Chandramohan Nagarathinam Educational Trust, Salem submitted
             Salem             an application in the name and style of Dr. Nagarathinam‟s College
               TN              of Education, Kosavampalli Kadu, Ananthagoundampalayam Village,
                               Via Vennandur, Minnakkal Post, Rasipuram Taluk, Namakal-637505,
                               Tamilnadu for seeking grant of recognition for B.Ed course on
                               28.12.2005.

                               Whereas the inspection of the institution was carried out on
                               10.10.2006 in Salem. Recognition order was issued to the institution
                               on    08.11.2006    at   No.52/7,     Seelanaickanpatti,    Salem-
                               636201,Tamilnadu with the condition to shift to own premises within
                               3 years.




     (Gangadharaiah)                                                        (Prof. C. Thangamuthu)
Regional Director, SRC, NCTE                                                 Chairman, SRC, NCTE
                                                117
                                                                                         st
                                                                              Minutes-201 Meeting of SRC
                                                                                       22-23 February 2011
                               The institution vide letter dated 09.11.2009 and 15.02.2010
                               submitted Rs.40000/- for change of address:

                               Dr. Nagarathinam‟s College of Education
                               Ananthagoundam Palaym
                               Namakkal District
                               Tamilnadu

                               Following are observed in the file:

                               1. The institution submitted application for recognition of the
                                  institution in Namakkal District only.
                               2. Whereas inspection was carried out at Salem District and
                                  recognition order also was issued to institution in Salem address.

                               The above discrepancy found while processing the file for inspection
                               of shifting of premises. Institution has also requested that they plan
                               to shift to new building at Namakkal district and submitted fee of
                               Rs.40000/- vide their letter dated 10.2.2010 but no inspection has
                               been conducted for shifting of premises.

                               This is a case of shifting from one district to another district. NCTE
                               regulations are silent about the permissibility of shifting to another
                               district.

                               The Committee considered the matter along with other relevant
                               documents and decided to process the application as there is
                               no change in the District and College is located at Nammakal
                               whereas only the administrative office is located at Salem.

93.         APS00845           St. Pauls Teacher Training Institute, Chennai, Tamilnadu was
             D.T.Ed            granted recognition for offering D.T.Ed course with an intake of 50
        St. Pauls Teacher      from the session 2004-05 on 12.01.2005 at No.50, 70 ft Road,
        Training Institute,    Periyar Nagar, Chennai-600082, Tamilnadu with the condition to
             Chennai           shift to own premises within 3 years.
               TN
                               The institution was issued letter dt. 21.05.2009 to submit the
                               following:

                               1. Demand Draft of Rs.40,000/- towards inspection fee in favour of
                                  “The Member Secretary, NCTE” payable at Bangalore should be
                                  submitted.
                               2. Land documents of the new building/ location for having own
                                  land in the name of the institution/ Society/ Trust.
                               3. Building Plan of the new building duly approved by the
                                  Government authority.




     (Gangadharaiah)                                                        (Prof. C. Thangamuthu)
Regional Director, SRC, NCTE                                                 Chairman, SRC, NCTE
                                                 118
                                                                                          st
                                                                               Minutes-201 Meeting of SRC
                                                                                        22-23 February 2011
                               4. Building Completion Certificate from the Government authorities
                                   in the prescribed format(Format enclosed)
                               5. Land Usage Certificate from the concerned Government
                                   authorities stating that the land is exclusively permitted/
                                   sanctioned for Educational Purposes only should be submitted.
                               6. Encumbrance certificate from the competent Government
                                   authority authority should be submitted.
                               7. Fixed Deposit Receipt of Rs.5 lakhs kept in JOINT ACCOUNT
                                   with SRC in Nationalised Bank for a period of 5 years towards
                                   Endowment Fund in ORGINAL should be submitted.
                               8. Fixed Deposit Receipt of Rs.3 lakhs kept in JOINT ACCOUNT
                                   with SRC in Nationalised Bank for a period of 5 years towards
                                   Reserve Fund in ORIGINAL should be submitted.
                               9. Certificate of Registration/ Bye-law of the Society/ Trust should
                                   be submitted.
                               10. The Affidavit in Rs.100/- stamp paper in the prescribed format
                                   with Notary attestation should be submitted.(FORMAT
                                   ENCLOSED)

                               The institution   has   submitted   its   written   representation    on
                               03.02.2011

                               The following documents as called for have not been submitted:
                               1. Land documents of the new building/ location for having own
                                  land in the name of the institution/ Society/ Trust.
                               2. Building Plan of the new building duly approved by the
                                  Government authority.
                               3. Building Completion Certificate from the Government authorities
                                  in the prescribed format(Format enclosed)
                               4. Land Usage Certificate from the concerned Government
                                  authorities stating that the land is exclusively permitted/
                                  sanctioned for Educational Purposes only should be submitted.
                               5. Encumbrance certificate from the competent Government
                                  authority authority should be submitted.
                               6. Certificate of Registration/ Bye-law of the Society/ Trust should
                                  be submitted.
                               7. The Affidavit in Rs.100/- stamp paper in the prescribed format
                                  with Notary attestation should be submitted.(FORMAT
                                  ENCLOSED)
                               8. Fixed Deposit Receipt of Rs.5 lakhs kept in JOINT ACCOUNT
                                  with SRC in Nationalised Bank for a period of 5 years towards
                                  Endowment Fund in ORGINAL should be submitted.
                               9. Fixed Deposit Receipt of Rs.3 lakhs kept in JOINT ACCOUNT
                                  with SRC in Nationalised Bank for a period of 5 years towards
                                  Reserve Fund in ORIGINAL should be submitted.




     (Gangadharaiah)                                                         (Prof. C. Thangamuthu)
Regional Director, SRC, NCTE                                                  Chairman, SRC, NCTE
                                                 119
                                                                                         st
                                                                              Minutes-201 Meeting of SRC
                                                                                       22-23 February 2011

                               Meanwhile a letter has been received from DTERT, Chennai on
                               17.2.2011 stated as follows:

                               “It is stated in the SRC-NCTE recognition order that the institution
                               shall shift to its own premises within three years from the date of
                               recognition. The Principal, DIET, Triplicane has visited the above
                               said Teacher Training Institute and submitted a visit report to the
                               Director of Teacher Education Research and Training, Chennai-
                               600006.

                               On perusal of the report, a challan Rs.40000/- was remitted to SRC-
                               NCTE drawn in favour of the NCTE, Bangalore. The management of
                               the institute has not produced the copy of the proposal sent to the
                               SRC-NCTE to DTERT for shifting the Teacher Training Institute. As
                               per the Principals report, constructed area of the building in the new
                               site is only 5541 sq.ft.

                               it is stated that 1000 sq.mtrs RCC building is mandatory for running
                               a Teacher Training Institute as per Regulations, Norms and
                               Standards of NCTE. Hence, it is stated that the management of the
                               institute has not shifted the Teacher Training Institute in the fully
                               equipped own RCC building within three years and thus violated the
                               order.

                                      In these circumstances, for the foregoing reasons, necessary
                               steps may be to taken to withdraw the recognition granted to the St.
                               Pauls Teacher Training Institute located at 6D, Narayana Street,
                               Ayanavaram, Chennai-600082”.

                               The Committee considered the reply and it was decided to issue
                               a Final Showcause Notice on the following:

                                Specific Remarks on the DTERT Report to be submitted.
                                 The DTERT report has stated that:

                                  “It is stated in the SRC-NCTE recognition order that the institution
                                  shall shift to its own premises within three years from the date of
                                  recognition. The Principal, DIET, Triplicane has visited the above
                                  said Teacher Training Institute and submitted a visit report to the
                                  Director of Teacher Education Research and Training, Chennai-
                                  600006.




     (Gangadharaiah)                                                        (Prof. C. Thangamuthu)
Regional Director, SRC, NCTE                                                 Chairman, SRC, NCTE
                                                120
                                                                                         st
                                                                              Minutes-201 Meeting of SRC
                                                                                       22-23 February 2011

                                  On perusal of the report, a challan Rs.40000/- was remitted to
                                  SRC-NCTE drawn in favour of the NCTE, Bangalore. The
                                  management of the institute has not produced the copy of the
                                  proposal sent to the SRC-NCTE to DTERT for shifting the
                                  Teacher Training Institute. As per the Principals report,
                                  constructed area of the building in the new site is only 5541 sq.ft.
                                  it is stated that 1000 sq.mtrs RCC building is mandatory for
                                  running a Teacher Training Institute as per Regulations, Norms
                                  and Standards of NCTE. Hence, it is stated that the management
                                  of the institute has not shifted the Teacher Training Institute in
                                  the fully equipped own RCC building within three years and thus
                                  violated the order.

                                  In these circumstances, for the foregoing reasons, necessary
                                  steps may be to taken to withdraw the recognition granted to the
                                  St. Pauls Teacher Training Institute located at 6D, Narayana
                                  Street, Ayanavaram, Chennai-600082”.

                                Non-response to SRC notice; the institution had not cared to
                                 send the specific documents as called for by SRC in its ref.
                                 Date 21.05.2009.

                                Non-shifting of the institution to a permanent premise even
                                 after a period of seven years is a serious violation of NCTE
                                 norms and the conditonal recognition.


                               In view of the above, the Committee decided to issue a Final
                               Showcause Notice to the institution as to why the recognition
                               be not withdrawn and thereby providing an opportunity to the
                               institution to make a written representation within 30 days from
                               the date of issue of the Notice along with necessary
                               certificates/documents in order to take a final decision in the
                               matter; failing which action will be taken including the
                               withdrawal of Recognition, based on the records available, with
                               no further notice.




     (Gangadharaiah)                                                        (Prof. C. Thangamuthu)
Regional Director, SRC, NCTE                                                 Chairman, SRC, NCTE
                                                121
                                                                                               st
                                                                                   Minutes-201 Meeting of SRC
                                                                                            22-23 February 2011
94.        APS07157            Janardhan Reddy College of Education, Huzurabad, Karimnagar
              B.Ed             District-505468, AndhraPradesh
       Janardhan Reddy
      College of Education,    Grama Nava Nirman Samithi, Karimnagar District, Andhra Pradesh
           Karimnagar          had submitted an application on 12.05.2006 to the Southern
               AP              Regional Committee of NCTE for grant of recognition to Janardhan
                               Reddy College of Education, H.No.4-2/A, Indiranagar, Saidapur
                               Road, Huzurabad, Karimnagar District-505468, AndhraPradesh for
                               B.Ed Course of One year duration.

                               And Whereas the Southern Regional Committee, after considering
                               the report of the visiting team as well as other relevant materials
                               granted recognition to the institution for offering B.Ed Course with an
                               intake of 100 students from the session 2007-2008 vide Order
                               No.783 dated 12.04.2007.

                               The Registrar, Kakatiya University, Warangal vide letter
                               dt.14.03.2008 drew the attention of Regional Director, SRC and
                               informed that in the process of granting temporary affiliation to the
                               institutions the university conducted inspection and observed that
                               Shabby accommodation and insufficient to run B.Ed. programme.
                               Land and building are at different places.

                               The letter was placed before the SRC in its 157th meeting held on
                               23rd-24th April 2008. The SRC after careful consideration of all
                               aspects decided to issue show cause notice. Accordingly, a show
                               cause notice was issued on 28.05.2008 to the institution. in
                               response to the notice the applicant institution replied on 14.06.2008
                               as under:

                               “with regard to insufficient accommodation, as per the advice of University
                               Authorities, we have started construction of two more big size lecture hall
                               and one seminar hall. At the time of second visit of university team, the
                               construction work was not completed totally and after going through the
                               progress of construction, the university has granted temporary affiliation for
                               the year 2007-08. Now, the accommodation is ready in every aspect”

                               The reply was placed before SRC in its 161st meeting held on 6th-7th
                               August 2008. The SRC has decided and resolved to cause
                               inspection under Section 17 to verify the infrastructural and
                               instructional facilities.

                               The SRC-NCTE conducted an inspection of the institution under
                               section 17 of NCTE Act 1993 on 17.09.2008. The report received
                               from the visiting team informs as follows:

                               “That management is not ready to face the inspection now on 17.09.2008
                               because of various factors and asked for postponement of the inspection by
                               three more months.”




     (Gangadharaiah)                                                             (Prof. C. Thangamuthu)
Regional Director, SRC, NCTE                                                      Chairman, SRC, NCTE
                                                  122
                                                                                                st
                                                                                    Minutes-201 Meeting of SRC
                                                                                             22-23 February 2011
                               The institution has not co-operated in carrying out inspection of
                               institution as per the Provisions of NCTE Act. Therefore, the SRC-
                               NCTE in its 165th meeting held on 27th-28th September, 2008 on
                               careful perusal of the original file of the institution, two visiting team
                               report under section 14 & 17, the letter dated 14.03.2008 from the
                               Registrar, Kakatiya University, Warangal to the Regional Director,
                               SRC and the reply dated.14.06.2008 to the show cause notice
                               issued to the institution and other related documents, Act of NCTE
                               1993, Regulations and Guidelines issued from time to time laid on
                               the table, the Regional Committee noted the following:-
                                  As per the inspection team report of the Kakatiya University, Warangal
                                   the land of the institution is situated at the place other than the location
                                   of the building.
                                  The institution in its communication to deficiency letter
                                   dated.09.10.2006 submitted the land document in the form of sale deed
                                   pertaining to Sy.No.242/B admeasuring 1089 sq.yards situated at
                                   Bornepelly Gram Panchayat, Huzurabad, Karimnagar District and
                                   whereas along with letter dt.14.06.2008 it has furnished a land
                                   document in the form of sale deed having the land at Sy.Nos.243. Plot
                                   (A) extent 1023.00 sq.yards, equivalent to this 859.32 sq.mts, (B)
                                   extent 224.77 sq.yards, equivalent to this 84.00 sq.mts, total plot extent
                                   (1347.77) sq.yards, equivalent to this (1132.12) sq.mts bounded by
                                   18.0 feets width road situated at Bornapelly Village in favor of
                                   Padmashali Seva Samithi, Karimnagar District which is neither the
                                   institution not the applicant society.
                                  The society changed its initial site of the land whose documents were
                                   submitted by it to NCTE with the undertaking that it will construct its
                                   building on the same land.
                               The institution at present constructing the building on the land is not
                               in the name of society nor in the name of institution and it is also not
                               clear as to whether the land purchased by it for running
                                  B.Ed course is still in possession of it or it is sold.
                                  The institution at present running its B.Ed course on the site seen by
                                   the team of the Kakatiya University is having shabby accommodation
                                   and insufficient to run the B.Ed course.
                                  The institution did not cooperate with the visiting team in carrying out
                                   inspection under section 17 on 17.09.2008. This is considered as an
                                   act of defiance and unbecoming of an educational institution.
                                  The institution violated the provisions contained under various sections
                                   of NCTE Act and regulations there under.
                               The SRC after careful consideration of all aspects decided to
                               withdraw the recognition of the institution from the academic session
                               2008-09. Further, the SRC also decided to inform the decision to the
                               State Government of Andhra Pradesh and Concerned University for
                               follow-up action immediately, including redistribution of students
                               admitted, if any.
                               As per direction of SRC withdrawal order was issued on 06.10.2008.
                               The institution was approached to Appellate Authority NCTE Head
                               Quarters wherein the Council confirms the order appealed against
                               with the modification that the said withdrawal of recognition order
                               would be effective form the academic session 2010-2011.



     (Gangadharaiah)                                                              (Prof. C. Thangamuthu)
Regional Director, SRC, NCTE                                                       Chairman, SRC, NCTE
                                                   123
                                                                                            st
                                                                                 Minutes-201 Meeting of SRC
                                                                                          22-23 February 2011
                               As per direction of Appellate Authority corrigendum order was issued
                               on 09.08.2010.

                               Now the institution has approach to Hon‟ble High court in W.P.M.P
                               no. 16528/2010 in writ petition no. 13130/2010 in the matter of
                               Janardhan Reddy College of Education, Indiranagar, Saidapur
                               Road, Huzurabad, Karimnagar Vs NCTE and others.

                               A letter alongwith following documents has been received form the
                               institution on 29.06.2010.

                               1. Court order dated 11.06.2010.
                               2. D.D of 40,000/- bearing no.461733.

                               In the court order the Hon‟ble High court has directed as under:-

                               “this is an application to direct the respondents to conduct an
                               inspection of the petitioner- college.

                               I have heard Sri A Sanjeev Kumar, learned counsel for the petitioner,
                               and Smt.G.Jhansi, learned counsel, representing Sri B.
                               Adinarayanana Rao, learned Standing Counsel for the respondents.
                               Having regard to interim order passed in WPMP no 16529/2010,
                               respondent no. 2 is directed to depute an inspection team on
                               payment of Rs.40,000/- which is stated to the required fees, by the
                               petitioner and submit subject the report to respondent no. 2 (SRC,
                               NCTE) within a period of eight weeks from today subject to the
                               above direction, the WPMP is disposed of. “

                               As per the direction of court case the institution has submitted D.D of
                               Rs. 40,000/- vide letter dated 12.07.2010.

                               The matter was considered by the Committee and it was decided to
                               cause inspection of the institution for B.Ed. Course, under Section 17
                               of NCTE Act, after payment of Rs.40,000/- inspection fee and on
                               submission of filled in Questionnaire, along with relevant supporting
                               documents relating to building, land, including Building Completion
                               Certificate from the competent Government Engineer and Land Use
                               Certificate, within four weeks from the date of confirmation of the
                               Minutes.
                               Meanwhile an court order dated 02.08.2010 an court order has been
                               received in the office of SRC on 17.08.2010 in W.P.M.P NO: 23751
                               & 23752 of 2010 in W.P.NO: 18762 of 2010. The Hon‟ble High Court
                               has passed an order as under:-

                               “ The Petitioner institution was directed to be inspected by the National
                               council for Teacher Education by interim order of this court dated
                               11.08.2010 in writ petition no 13130 of 2010. The said inspection is yet to
                               take place.




     (Gangadharaiah)                                                           (Prof. C. Thangamuthu)
Regional Director, SRC, NCTE                                                    Chairman, SRC, NCTE
                                                  124
                                                                                         st
                                                                              Minutes-201 Meeting of SRC
                                                                                       22-23 February 2011
                               However in the meanwhile counseling for admissions to B.Ed course
                               for the academic year 2010-2011 has already commenced.

                               In such view of the matter, if the petitioner institution is denied
                               affiliation by the Kakatiya University, respondent 3, it would stand to
                               lose the entire academic year, as it would not be included in the list
                               of colleges for counseling by the Andhra Pradesh State Council for
                               Higher Education, respondent 4. There shall accordingly be a
                               direction to the Kakatiya University to consider the case of the
                               petitioner College for affiliation for the academic year 2010-2011
                               without insisting upon the approval of the National Council for
                               Teacher Education based on its inspection. In the even the petitioner
                               college is found eligible in all other respects, the University shall
                               grant affiliation and thereupon the Andhra Pradesh State Council for
                               Higher Education shall include the petitioner College in the second
                               phase of counseling scheduled to be held in the later part of August,
                               2010 enabling it to make admission to B.Ed course for the academic
                               year 2010-2011.

                               The matter has been taken up with the Advocate to defend in the
                               interest of NCTE.

                               The inspection was caried out on 02.09.2010.

                               The Committee in its 196th meeting held on 15-16 September 2010
                               considered the VT report and all the relevant documentary
                               evidences and it was decided to serve Notice Under Section 17 for
                               the following reasons:

                                The Instructional facilities are generally inadequate            and
                                 housed in small rooms.

                                All the Laboratories required to be strengthened with
                                 additional materials / equipments.

                                FDRs are not in the Joint Names.

                                The staff list yet to be formally approved by the affiliating
                                 University.

                                Instructional space & facilities are inadequate for
                                 continuance of the B.Ed., programme as per the NCTE
                                 Norms.

                                Change of Land Use Certificate not obtained / not6available.

                                Science lab is about 300 sq.ft in size and it is rather small.

                                The size of classroom is only 450 sq.ft. as against 500 sq.ft
                                 or 10 sq.ft. per student as per NCTE norms.


     (Gangadharaiah)                                                         (Prof. C. Thangamuthu)
Regional Director, SRC, NCTE                                                  Chairman, SRC, NCTE
                                                 125
                                                                                          st
                                                                               Minutes-201 Meeting of SRC
                                                                                        22-23 February 2011
                                As per the decision of SRC Notice was issued on 25.10.2010. Till
                                date institution not submitted its written representation/documents.

                                The committee considered the not replying/non-response by
                                the institution to the Showcause Notice issued on 25.10.2010
                                and decided to withdraw recognition for B.Ed course
                                (APS07157) with effect from 2011-12, in order to enable the
                                ongoing batch of students in B.Ed course, if any, to complete
                                their course.

                                But it is made clear that the institution is debarred from making
                                any further admission subsequent to the date of issue of this
                                order.

                                The Affiliating body / Examining board / body be informed
                                accordingly.

                                Further decided to return Endowment funds and Reserve fund
                                deposited with SRC NCTE, Bangalore if any.

95.        APS00366             Jnanabharathi     College   of   Education,    Ananthpur,      Andhra
              B.Ed              Pradesh
      Jnanbharathi College of
      Education, Ananthapur     An application was submitted by Jnanabharathi College of
               AP               Education, Ananthpur, Andhra Pradesh for grant of recognition to
                                B.Ed course in the office of SRC-NCTE, Bangalore on 31.12.2001

                                The application was processed as per the provisions contained in
                                Rules and Regulation, Norms and Standards vogue at that point of
                                time and the recognition was granted to the institution vide order dt
                                03.03.2003 with stipulated conditions.

                                The Committee observed from records of the following institutions
                                that the institutions were accorded recognition in the rented premises
                                and they had not yet shifted to the permanent premises/building. In
                                view of non-shifting of Colleges to permanent building, the
                                Committee decided to issue showcause Notice under Section 17 of
                                NCTE Act and obtain shifting fees and other documents for causing
                                inspection for shifting. Inspection was conducted on 16.09.2010.

                                SRC in its 197th meeting held on 13th and 14th October, 2010
                                considered the VT Report and all the relevant documentary
                                evidences and decided to issue Showcause Notice Under Section
                                17 of NCTE Act for the following reasons:




     (Gangadharaiah)                                                          (Prof. C. Thangamuthu)
Regional Director, SRC, NCTE                                                   Chairman, SRC, NCTE
                                                 126
                                                                                            st
                                                                                 Minutes-201 Meeting of SRC
                                                                                          22-23 February 2011

                                 As per V.T. report Dt. 16.09.2010 the total Built up area is
                                  18273 Sq.Ft.

                                 The Primary School and Secondary School programmes are
                                  run in the same building which is not in accordance with the
                                  NCTE Norms.

                                As per the decision of SRC Notice was issued on 03.12.2010.

                                Till date institution not     submitted its written representation
                                /documents.

                                The committee considered the not replying/non-response by
                                the institution to the Showcause Notice issued by SRC dated
                                03.12.2010 and decided to withdraw recognition for B.Ed course
                                (APS07157) with effect from 2011-12, in order to enable the
                                ongoing batch of students in B.Ed course, if any, to complete
                                their course.

                                But it is made clear that the institution is debarred from making
                                any further admission subsequent to the date of issue of this
                                order.

                                The Affiliating body / Examining board / body be informed
                                accordingly.

                                Further decided to return Endowment funds and Reserve fund
                                deposited with SRC NCTE, Bangalore if any.

96.         APS02622            Ghulam Ahmed College of Education, Banjara Hills, Hyderabad,
             APS0191            Andhra Pradesh has submitted application for additional intake in
             APS0028            B.Ed course on 28.10.2009.
                D.Ed
                B.Ed            A deficiency letter was issued to the university on 22.12.2009. The
               M.Ed             institution submitted its written representation on 02.03.2010. The
      Ghulam Ahmed College      reply for deficiency letter was placed before SRC in its 190th
      of Education, Hyderabad   meeting held on 29-30 March 2010 and SRC decided to cause
                 AP             inspection. Accordingly, inspection was carried out to the institution
                                on 08.05.2010.

                                On careful perusal of the original file of the institution, Visiting Team
                                Report, Video CD, other related documents, Act of NCTE, 1993,
                                Regulations and guidelines of NCTE published from time to time laid
                                on the table, written representation from the institution, the Regional
                                Committee in its 192nd Meeting held on 10-11 May, 2010 decided to
                                refuse recognition to the B.Ed-AI course for the following reasons: -




     (Gangadharaiah)                                                           (Prof. C. Thangamuthu)
Regional Director, SRC, NCTE                                                    Chairman, SRC, NCTE
                                                  127
                                                                                        st
                                                                             Minutes-201 Meeting of SRC
                                                                                      22-23 February 2011
                                The institution is already having B.Ed. course, D.Ed. course and
                                 M.Ed. course. Total built-up area is 3804 sq. mtrs. As per
                                 norms of NCTE, 3500 sq.mtrs. is required for the existing
                                 courses and 500 sq.mtrs. additional built up area is required for
                                 the proposed course.

                                MBA, Law College, Junior College, Pharmacy College, a public
                                 school and Engineering College are all run in the same
                                 educational complex with no separate demarcation of land/
                                 building for the Teacher Education courses.

                               The Committee also decided to serve Notice under Section 17 of
                               NCTE Act, for the existing D.Ed., B.Ed. and M.Ed. course for non-
                               fulfilment of the infrastructural and instructional facilities as per
                               NCTE norms. Accordingly, notice was issued to the institution on
                               09.07.2010 for D.Ed course. The institution has submitted its written
                               representation on 23.07.2010.

                               The written representation was considered by the Committee in its
                               195th meeting held on 17-18 August, 2010 and it was decided to
                               cause inspection of the institution for M.Ed., B.Ed. and D.Ed.
                               Course, under Section 17 of NCTE Act, on payment of Rs.40,000/-
                               inspection fee for each course and on submission of filled in
                               Questionnaire, along with relevant supporting documents relating to
                               building, land, including Building Completion Certificate from the
                               competent Government Engineer and Land Use Certificate, within 21
                               days.

                               As per the decision of SRC the letter was sent on 22.09.2010. Till
                               date institution not submitted its written representation/documents
                               and Inspection fee.

                               The committee decided to cause composite inspection of the
                               institution for M.Ed., B.Ed. and D.Ed. Courses, under Section 17
                               of NCTE Act, in anticipation of payment of Rs.40,000/-
                               inspection fee for each course and on submission of filled in
                               Questionnaire, along with relevant supporting documents
                               relating to building, land, including Building Completion
                               Certificate from the competent Government Engineer and Land
                               Use Certificate, within 21 days.




     (Gangadharaiah)                                                       (Prof. C. Thangamuthu)
Regional Director, SRC, NCTE                                                Chairman, SRC, NCTE
                                                128
                                                                                          st
                                                                               Minutes-201 Meeting of SRC
                                                                                        22-23 February 2011
97.        APS09335            K.S.R Memorial Charitable Trust for Rural Development, Hyderabad,
              B.Ed             Andhra Pradesh has submitted an application in the name and style
         KBR College of        of K.B.R College of Education, H.No.2-1-68/A, Bazaar Street,
        Education, Nellore     Naidupeta, Nellore, Andhra Pradesh for B.Ed course on 31.01.2008.
               AP              The application was processed and the deficiency letter was issued
                               to the institution on 18.02.2008. The institution has submitted written
                               representation on 21.04.2008. the reply submitted by the institution
                               was scrutinized and a clarification letter was issued to the institution
                               on 27.06.2008. The institution has submitted its reply on 14.08.2008
                               which was examined and found that the institution is fulfilled all the
                               deficiencies. Hence a consent letter was issued to the institution on
                               12.09.2008.

                               The institution in its reply dated 18.09.2008 expressed their opinion
                               of consent for inspection. Again one more letter was received from
                               the institution on 22.10.2008.

                               Meantime, letters dated 07.01.2009, 07.02.2009 from the State
                               Government of Andhra Pradesh requesting not to accord further
                               recognition/permission to the new colleges/private B.Ed,
                               D.Ed/Physical Education/Language Pandit in the State of Andhra
                               Pradesh.

                               Further a letter dated 17.03.2009 has been received from NCTE-
                               Hqrs. informing that the recommendations of the Government of
                               Andhra Pradesh not to grant recognition/permission in respect of
                               other courses like B.Ed, D.Ed and Physical Education courses have
                               been considered in NCTE and it has been decided that no further
                               recognition/permission to any institution in the State of Andhra
                               Pradesh be considered by SRC for the academic session 2009-2010
                               for B.Ed, D.Ed and Physical Education courses also.

                               The letters dated 07.01.2009, 07.02.2009 and 17.03.2009 were
                               considered by SRC in its 172nd Meeting held on 25th and 26th March,
                               2009 and the Committee decided to accept the recommendation of
                               the State Government of Andhra Pradesh, not to grant recognition to
                               any of the teacher training institutions in the State of Andhra
                               Pradesh for the year 2009-10 and decided to return the applications.

                               As per the decision of SRC the application for B.Ed course in the
                               respect of K.B.R College was returned along with documents and
                               processing fee of Rs.40000/- on 28.04.2009.

                               Further the institution has approached Hon‟ble High Court of Andhra
                               Pradesh in W.P.No.10067 of 2009. The court has passed order
                               dated 13.07.2010:




     (Gangadharaiah)                                                         (Prof. C. Thangamuthu)
Regional Director, SRC, NCTE                                                  Chairman, SRC, NCTE
                                                 129
                                                                                         st
                                                                              Minutes-201 Meeting of SRC
                                                                                       22-23 February 2011
                               “With a direction to the first respondent to take necessary steps for
                               granting recognition to the petitioners College of Education at
                               Narsireddy Kandriga, Naidupeta, Nellore District in accordance with
                               the relevant rules. This recognition shall ensure to the benefit of the
                               present academic year has already commenced with the schedule of
                               counseling which is to begin from 02.08.2010. in the circumstances
                               of the case, there shall be no order as to costs”.

                               SRC in its 195th meeting held on 17-18 August 2010 considered the
                               matter and decided to direct the Management/institution to resubmit
                               the old application returned by SRC along with the documents as
                               originally submitted relating to land, building, FDR, Application fee,
                               BCC from competent Government Engineer and other relevant
                               aspects for processing and for necessary action.

                               As per the decision of SRC a letter was issued on 23.09.2010 and a
                               letter to revalidate the DD was issued on 07.10.2010. Till date
                               institution not submitted its written representation and revalidated
                               D.D.

                               The Committee considered the non-reply of the institution to
                               the SRC’s letters dated 23.09.2010 and 07.10.2010 and decided
                               to send a Showcause Notice

                                The Management/institution to resubmit the old application
                                 returned by SRC along with the documents as originally
                                 submitted relating to land, building, FDR, Application fee,
                                 BCC from competent Government Engineer and other
                                 relevant aspects for processing and for necessary action.

                                Revalidated Demand Draft of Rs.40,000/- drawn in favour of
                                 “The Member Secretary” payable at Bangalore.

                               In view of the above, the Committee decided to issue a Final
                               Showcause Notice to the institution as to why the recognition
                               be not withdrawn and thereby providing an opportunity to the
                               institution to make a written representation within 30 days from
                               the date of issue of the Notice along with necessary
                               certificates/documents in order to take a final decision in the
                               matter; failing which action will be taken including the
                               withdrawal of Recognition, based on the records available, with
                               no further notice.




     (Gangadharaiah)                                                         (Prof. C. Thangamuthu)
Regional Director, SRC, NCTE                                                  Chairman, SRC, NCTE
                                                 130
                                                                                                 st
                                                                                     Minutes-201 Meeting of SRC
                                                                                              22-23 February 2011
98.           APS02773           Little Flower Elementary Teacher Education for Girls,
                  D.Ed           Ananthpur Andhra Pradesh
      Little Flower Elementary   An application was submitted by Little Flower Elementary Teacher
       Teacher Education for     Education for Girls, Ananthpur Andhra Pradesh for grant of
           Girls, Anathapur      recognition to D.Ed course in the office of SRC-NCTE, Bangalore on
                   AP            03.02.2004

                                 The application was processed as per the provisions contained in
                                 Rules and Regulation, Norms and Standards vogue at that point of
                                 time and the recognition was granted to the institution vide order dt
                                 26.05.2005 with stipulated conditions.

                                 Shifting proposal was submitted by the institution on 17.07.2009.
                                 Shifting inspection was conducted on 17.09.2009.

                                 The Visiting Team report was placed before SRC in its 197th
                                 meeting held on 13th and 14th October, 2010.

                                 The Committee considered the VT Report and all the relevant
                                 documentary evidences and it was decided to serve Showcause
                                 Notice Under Section 17 of NCTE Act for the following -
                                  The Teacher Education Programme is being run in the same building in
                                   which Primary and Secondary classes of the School are also being run,
                                   this is against the norms of NCTE.
                                  Part of the land (50%) is in the name of the individual (Correspondent)
                                   and part of it, is in the name of the Little Flower, Montesery Primary &
                                   Secondary school, which is against the NCTE Norms. The land should
                                   be in the name of the Society/Institution offering Teacher Education
                                   Programme.
                                  The Journals in the library is not sufficient for the usage of the students.
                                  Original FDR‟s were not shown to V.T. Members.

                                 As per the decision of SRC Notice was issued on 03.12.2010. Till
                                 date institution not submitted its written representation/documents.

                                 The committee considered the non-response of the institution
                                 to the Showcause Notice dated 03.12.2010 and decided to
                                 withdraw recognition for D.Ed course (APS02773) with effect
                                 from 2012-13, in order to enable the ongoing batch of students
                                 in D.Ed course, if any, to complete their course.

                                 But it is made clear that the institution is debarred from making
                                 any further admission subsequent to the date of issue of this
                                 order.

                                 The Affiliating body / Examining board / body be informed
                                 accordingly.

                                 Further decided to return Endowment funds and Reserve fund
                                 deposited with SRC NCTE, Bangalore if any.



     (Gangadharaiah)                                                               (Prof. C. Thangamuthu)
Regional Director, SRC, NCTE                                                        Chairman, SRC, NCTE
                                                    131
                                                                                          st
                                                                               Minutes-201 Meeting of SRC
                                                                                        22-23 February 2011
99.          APS06013           Hardekar Manjappa D.Ed College, Alamatti Dam Site, Basavana
                D.Ed.           Bagewadi Taluk, Bijapur-586201, Karnataka for offering D.Ed course
      Hardekar Manjappa D.Ed    vide order dated 26.09.2007.
       College, Alamatti Dam
           Site, Basavana       A letter dated No.ED 122 PTI 2008 (B) dated 18.06.2009 was
      Bagewadi Taluk, Bijapur   received from the Principal Secretary, Primary and Higher
                  KA            Education, Education Department, Government of Karnataka and
                                has recommended SRC to withdraw the recognition granted to your
                                D.Ed college as the institution is not maintaining norms and
                                standards as prescribed by NCTE.

                                The matter was placed before SRC in its 178th meeting held on 13-
                                14 July 2009 and SRC considered the recommendation of the State
                                Government of Karnataka and decided to issue showcause notice.
                                Accordingly, Notice was issued to the institution on 12.08.2009. The
                                institution has submitted written representation on 10.09.2009. The
                                SRC in its 183rd meeting held on 22nd September 2009 considered
                                the written representation and decided to issue notice. Accordingly,
                                Notice was issued to the institution on 31.11.2009. The institution
                                has not submitted any written representation to the notice, the matter
                                was placed before SRC in its 189th meeting held on 25-26 February
                                2010 and SRC decided to issue final notice. Accordingly, Final
                                notice was issued to the institution on 12.04.2010.

                                The institution submitted its written representation on 03.05.2010.
                                The SRC in its 192nd meeting held on 10-11 May 2010 considered
                                the written representation and decided to cause inspection.
                                Accordingly, inspection was carried out on 04.06.2010. The matter
                                was considered in its 193rd meeting held on 21-22 June, 2010 and it
                                was decided to cause inspection and it was also decided payment
                                Rs.40,000/- towards re-inspection by the management. Accordingly,
                                inspection was conducted on 14.07.2010.

                                The SRC in its 197th meeting held on 13-14 October 2010
                                considered the VT report and other related documents and decided
                                to continue recognition. As the institution has not submitted
                                Rs.40,000/- towards re-inspection fee as decided in 193rd meeting
                                held on 21-22 June 2010 a letter seeking for re-inspection fee was
                                issued to the institution on 06.12.2010.

                                Till date, the institution has not submitted re-inspection fee of
                                Rs.40,000/- and hence letter for continuation of recognition could not
                                be issued.

                                The committee considered the matter and decided that a
                                Reminder notice be issued for payment of Rs.40,000/- within a
                                period of four weeks, failing which action will be taken with no
                                further notice.




     (Gangadharaiah)                                                         (Prof. C. Thangamuthu)
Regional Director, SRC, NCTE                                                  Chairman, SRC, NCTE
                                                 132
                                                                                                st
                                                                                     Minutes-201 Meeting of SRC
                                                                                              22-23 February 2011
100.         APS02432           St.Joseph College of Education, #55, Uttarahalli Main Road,
               B.Ed.            Uttarahalli Hobli, Bangalore-560061, Karnataka was granted
       St. Joseph College of    recognition for offering B.Ed course on 21.12.2005 with an intake of
          Education, # 55,      100 students.
       Uttarahalli Main Road,
          Uttarahalli Hobli,    As per decision of SRC in its 175th meeting the office of SRC has
             Bangalore          reviewed the files of the institution who have been granted
                 KA             recognition either in a rented premises pending construction of own
                                building or in lease premises.

                                A list of such institutions has been prepared and placed before SRC
                                in its 176th meeting held on 27-28 May 2009 wherein, it was decided
                                that the institution which have not shifted to the permanent premises
                                even after the expiry of three years time limit be issued notice under
                                section 17 of NCTE Act for further action. Notice was issued to the
                                institution on 08.09.2009.

                                The institution did not care to respond to the notice issued on the
                                institution even after lapse of 1 year 5 months.

                                The Committee considered the non-reply to Notice and it is
                                now decided to serve Final Showcause Notice Under Section 17
                                of NCTE Act for the following :

                                1. Demand Draft of Rs. 40,000/- towards inspection fee in favour of “The
                                    Member Secretary NCTE”Payable at Bangalore should be submitted.
                                2. Land documents of the new building/location for having own land in the
                                    name of the institution/Society/Trust.
                                3. Building Plan of the new building duly approved by th Government
                                    authority.
                                4. Building Completion Certificate from the Government authorities in the
                                    prescribed format(Format enclosed).
                                5. Land Usage Certificates from the concerned Government authorities
                                    stating that the land is exclusively permitted/ sanctioned for Educational
                                    Purposes only should be submitted.
                                6. Encumbrance certificate from the competent Government authority
                                    should submitted.
                                7. Fixed Deposit Receipt of Rs. 5 lakhs kept in JOINT ACCOUNT with
                                    SRC in Nationalised Bank for a period of 5 years towards Endowment
                                    Fund in ORIGINAL should be submitted.
                                8. Fixed Deposit Receipt of Rs. 3 lakhs kept in JOINT ACCOUNT with
                                    SRC in Nationalised Bank for a period of 5 years towards Endowment
                                    Fund in ORIGINAL should be submitted.
                                9. Certificates of Registration/ Bye-law of the Society/Trust should be
                                    submitted.
                                10. The Affidavit in Rs. 100/- stamp paper in the prescribed format with
                                    Notary attestation.
                                11. The institution has not shifted to its own building even after the lapse of
                                    over 6 years.




     (Gangadharaiah)                                                               (Prof. C. Thangamuthu)
Regional Director, SRC, NCTE                                                        Chairman, SRC, NCTE
                                                    133
                                                                                                  st
                                                                                      Minutes-201 Meeting of SRC
                                                                                               22-23 February 2011
                                  In view of the above, the Committee decided to issue a Final
                                  Showcause Notice to the institution as to why the recognition
                                  be not withdrawn and thereby providing an opportunity to the
                                  institution to make a written representation within 30 days from
                                  the date of issue of the Notice along with necessary
                                  certificates/documents in order to take a final decision in the
                                  matter; failing which action will be taken including the
                                  withdrawal of Recognition, based on the records available, with
                                  no further notice.

101.         APS04077             Vathsalya College of Education, Sri. Nataraja Prathishtanam, Sri.
                B.Ed              Hosamutt, No.140, Shankarmutt Road, Mysore-570004, Karnataka
        Vathsalya College of      was granted recognition for offering B.Ed course on 24.12.2005 with
       Education, Sri, Nataraja   an intake of 100 students.
          Prathishtana, Sri,
         Hosamutt, No, 140,       As per the directions given in SRC in its 175th meeting held on 13-14
         Shankarmutt Road,        May, 2009 the office of SRC has reviewed the files of the institution
             Mysore 04            who have been granted recognition either in a rented premises
                 KA               pending construction of own building or in lease premises pertaining
                                  to the B.Ed course in the State of Karnataka.

                                  A list of such institution has been prepared and placed before SRC
                                  in its 176th meeting held on 27-28 May, 2009 it was decided that the
                                  institution which have not shifted to the permanent premises even
                                  after the expiry of three years time limit be issued notice.

                                  As per the decision of SRC Notice was issued to the institution on
                                  08.09.2009 for the following reasons:
                                  1. Demand Draft of Rs. 40,000/- towards inspection fee in favour of “The
                                      Member Secretary NCTE”Payable at Bangalore should be submitted.
                                  2. Land documents of the new building/location for having own land in the
                                      name of the institution/Society/Trust.
                                  3. Building Plan of the new building duly approved by th Government
                                      authority.
                                  4. Building Completion Certificate from the Government authorities in the
                                      prescribed format(Format enclosed).
                                  5. Land Usage Certificates from the concerned Government authorities
                                      stating that the land is exclusively permitted/ sanctioned for Educational
                                      Purposes only should be submitted.
                                  6. Encumbrance certificate from the competent Government authority
                                      should submitted.
                                  7. Fixed Deposit Receipt of Rs. 5 lakhs kept in JOINT ACCOUNT with
                                      SRC in Nationalised Bank for a period of 5 years towards Endowment
                                      Fund in ORIGINAL should be submitted.
                                  8. Fixed Deposit Receipt of Rs. 3 lakhs kept in JOINT ACCOUNT with
                                      SRC in Nationalised Bank for a period of 5 years towards Endowment
                                      Fund in ORIGINAL should be submitted.
                                  9. Certificates of Resgistration/ Bye-law of the Society/Trust should be
                                      submitted.
                                  10. The Affidavit in Rs. 100/- stamp paper in the prescribed format with
                                      Notary attestation.




     (Gangadharaiah)                                                                (Prof. C. Thangamuthu)
Regional Director, SRC, NCTE                                                         Chairman, SRC, NCTE
                                                     134
                                                                                             st
                                                                                  Minutes-201 Meeting of SRC
                                                                                           22-23 February 2011
                                 As the institution did not care to respond to the notice issued on the
                                 institution, for their failure to shift to permanent premises, even after
                                 the lapse of three years stipulated period permitted in their
                                 conditional orders of recognition and the matter was placed before
                                 SRC. The SRC in its 196th meeting held on 15-16 September 2010
                                 considered the matter and decided to issue Showcause notice.
                                 Accordingly, Showcause notice was issued to the institution on
                                 25.10.2010.

                                 Again the institution did not care to respond to the showcause notice
                                 issued on the institution even after lapse of 4 months.

                                 The committee considered the non-response by the institution
                                 to the Showcause Notice dated 25.10.20410 and decided to
                                 withdraw recognition for D.Ed course (APS04077) with effect
                                 from 2012-13, in order to enable the ongoing batch of students
                                 in D.Ed course, if any, to complete their course.

                                 But it is made clear that the institution is debarred from making
                                 any further admission subsequent to the date of issue of this
                                 order.

                                 The Affiliating body / Examining board / body be informed
                                 accordingly.

                                 Further decided to return Endowment funds and Reserve fund
                                 deposited with SRC NCTE, Bangalore if any.

102.          APS02336           Shri.Nagappana Karjagi D.Ed College, Sree Beereshwara
              APS07035           Shikshana Samsthe, Behind Syrian Hospital, P.B.Road,
       D.Ed (Kannada Medium)     Sankeshwar-591313, Hukkeri Taluk, Belgaum District, Karnataka
       D.Ed (Marathi Medium)     was granted recognition for offering D.Ed course (Kannada Medium)
       Shri. Nagappana Karjagi   with an intake of 50 students from the session 2004-2005 vide order
         D.Ed College, Sree      dated 02.12.2004 bearing code No. APS02336. Further,
        Beereshwara Shikshna     Shri.Nagappana Karajagi D.Ed College, Sree Beereshwara
         Samsthe, Belgaum        Shikshana Samsthe, Behind Syrian Hospital, P.B.Road, Sankeshwar
                 KA              – 591313, Hukkeri Taluk, Belgaum District, Karnataka was also
                                 granted recognition for offering D.Ed course (English Medium) with
                                 an intake of 50 students vide order dated 26.04.2007 bearing code
                                 No.APS07035.

                                 NCTE, Hqrs vide its letter dated 11.10.2010 has forwarded a copy of
                                 the inspection report dated 21.05.2010 conducted Under Section 13
                                 of NCTE Act. As there are deficiencies pointed out in the inspection
                                 report, NCTE, Hqrs has requested SRC to initiate action against the
                                 institution Under Section 17 of the NCTE Act immediately.




     (Gangadharaiah)                                                            (Prof. C. Thangamuthu)
Regional Director, SRC, NCTE                                                     Chairman, SRC, NCTE
                                                   135
                                                                                      st
                                                                           Minutes-201 Meeting of SRC
                                                                                    22-23 February 2011
                               The SRC in its 197th meeting held on 13-14 October 2010
                               considered the VT report and decided to issue showcause notice for
                               the following reasons:

                                Certificate from the government affiliating body to the effect
                                 that no other programme is being run by the institution in
                                 the same building / Campus, along with the existing Course
                                 D.Ed.,(Kannada Medium) & D.Ed.(Marathi Medium),
                                 programmes to be submitted. The exclusively earmarked
                                 area for each of the Teacher Training Programmes to be
                                 submitted.

                                Staff salary is paid in cash instead of Bank payment.

                                The details of the existing teaching and Non-teaching staff /
                                 faculty along with their qualification and experience to be
                                 provided.

                               Accordingly, Showcause notice was issued to the institution on
                               13.12.2010 with the request to reply in 30days from the date of
                               receipt of notice.

                               The institution did not care to respond to the showcause notice
                               issued on the institution.

                               The committee considered the non-response of the institution
                               to the Showcause Notice dated 13.02.2010 and decided to
                               withdraw recognition for D.Ed (APS02336 – Kannada Medium)
                               and D.Ed (APS07035 – Marathi Medium) with effect from 2012-
                               13, in order to enable the ongoing batch of students in D.Ed
                               course, if any, to complete their course.

                               But it is made clear that the institution is debarred from making
                               any further admission subsequent to the date of issue of this
                               order.

                               The Affiliating body / Examining board / body be informed
                               accordingly.

                               Further decided to return Endowment funds and Reserve fund
                               deposited with SRC NCTE, Bangalore if any.




     (Gangadharaiah)                                                     (Prof. C. Thangamuthu)
Regional Director, SRC, NCTE                                              Chairman, SRC, NCTE
                                               136
                                                                                         st
                                                                              Minutes-201 Meeting of SRC
                                                                                       22-23 February 2011
103.        APS02248            Keshav College of Education, No.27/2, Chokkanahalli, Hegde Nagar
               B.Ed.            Main Road, Jakkur Post, Yelahanka Hobli, Bangalore-560064,
         Keshav College of      Karnataka was granted recognition for offering B.Ed course on
       Education, , Bangalore   04.01.2006 with an intake of 100 students.
                KA
                                As per the directions given in SRC in its 175th meeting held on 13-14
                                May, 2009 the office of SRC has reviewed the files of the institution
                                who have been granted recognition either in a rented premises
                                pending construction of own building or in lease premises pertaining
                                to the B.Ed course in the State of Karnataka.

                                A list of such institution has been prepared and placed before SRC
                                in its 176th meeting held on 27-28 May, 2009 it was decided that the
                                institution which have not shifted to the permanent premises even
                                after the expiry of three years time limit be issued notice.

                                As per the decision of SRC Notice was issued to the institution on
                                08.09.2009 for the following reasons:

                                1. Demand Draft of Rs. 40,000/- towards inspection fee in favour of
                                   “The Member Secretary NCTE”Payable at Bangalore should be
                                   submitted.
                                2. Land documents of the new building/location for having own land
                                   in the name of the institution/Society/Trust.Building Plan of the
                                   new building duly approved by th Government authority.
                                3. Building Completion Certificate from the Government authorities
                                   in the prescribed format(Format enclosed).
                                4. Land Usage Certificates from the concerned Government
                                   authorities stating that the land is exclusively permitted/
                                   sanctioned for Educational Purposes only should be submitted.
                                5. Encumbrance certificate from the competent Government
                                   authority should submitted.
                                6. Fixed Deposit Receipt of Rs. 5 lakhs kept in JOINT ACCOUNT
                                   with SRC in Nationalised Bank for a period of 5 years towards
                                   Endowment Fund in ORIGINAL should be submitted.
                                7. Fixed Deposit Receipt of Rs. 3 lakhs kept in JOINT ACCOUNT
                                   with SRC in Nationalised Bank for a period of 5 years towards
                                   Endowment Fund in ORIGINAL should be submitted.
                                8. Certificates of Resgistration/ Bye-law of the Society/Trust should
                                   be submitted.
                                9. The Affidavit in Rs. 100/- stamp paper in the prescribed format
                                   with Notary attestation.




     (Gangadharaiah)                                                        (Prof. C. Thangamuthu)
Regional Director, SRC, NCTE                                                 Chairman, SRC, NCTE
                                                 137
                                                                                           st
                                                                                Minutes-201 Meeting of SRC
                                                                                         22-23 February 2011
                               As the institution did not care to respond to the notice issued on the
                               institution, for their failure to shift to permanent premises, even after
                               the lapse of three years stipulated period permitted in their
                               conditional orders of recognition and the matter was placed before
                               SRC. The SRC in its 196th meeting held on 15-16 September 2010
                               considered the matter and decided to issue Showcause notice.
                               Accordingly, Showcause notice was issued to the institution on
                               27.10.2010. The institution did not care to respond to the showcause
                               notice issued on the institution even after lapse of 1 year 5 months.

                               The committee considered the non-response of the institution
                               to the Showcause Notice dated 27.10.2010 and decided to
                               withdraw recognition for B.Ed course (APS02248) with effect
                               from 2011-12, in order to enable the ongoing batch of students
                               in B.Ed course, if any, to complete their course.

                               But it is made clear that the institution is debarred from making
                               any further admission subsequent to the date of issue of this
                               order.

                               The Affiliating body / Examining board / body be informed
                               accordingly.

                               Further decided to return Endowment funds and Reserve fund
                               deposited with SRC NCTE, Bangalore if any.

104.       APS01873,           Krupanidhi College of Education, No.72/1, Ring Road, Bellandur,
              B.Ed.            Bangalore-560037, Karnataka was granted recognition for offering
       Krupanidhi College of   B.Ed course on 06.01.2005 with an intake of 100 students.
       Education, Bangalore
               KA              As per decision of SRC in its 175th meeting the office of SRC has
                               reviewed the files of the institution who have been granted
                               recognition either in a rented premises pending construction of own
                               building or in lease premises.

                               A list of such institutions has been prepared and placed before SRC
                               in its 176th meeting held on 27-28 May 2009 wherein, it was decided
                               that the institution which have not shifted to the permanent premises
                               even after the expiry of three years time limit be issued notice under
                               section 17 of NCTE Act for further action. Notice was issued to the
                               institution on 01.09.2009 for the following reasons:

                               1. Demand Draft of Rs. 40,000/- towards inspection fee in favour of
                                  “The Member Secretary NCTE”Payable at Bangalore should be
                                  submitted.
                               2. Land documents of the new building/location for having own land
                                  in the name of the institution/Society/Trust.




     (Gangadharaiah)                                                          (Prof. C. Thangamuthu)
Regional Director, SRC, NCTE                                                   Chairman, SRC, NCTE
                                                 138
                                                                                           st
                                                                                Minutes-201 Meeting of SRC
                                                                                         22-23 February 2011
                               3. Building Plan of the new building duly approved by th
                                   Government authority.
                               4. Building Completion Certificate from the Government authorities
                                   in the prescribed format(Format enclosed).
                               5. Land Usage Certificates from the concerned Government
                                   authorities stating that the land is exclusively permitted/
                                   sanctioned for Educational Purposes only should be submitted.
                               6. Encumbrance certificate from the competent Government
                                   authority should submitted.
                               7. Fixed Deposit Receipt of Rs. 5 lakhs kept in JOINT ACCOUNT
                                   with SRC in Nationalised Bank for a period of 5 years towards
                                   Endowment Fund in ORIGINAL should be submitted.
                               8. Fixed Deposit Receipt of Rs. 3 lakhs kept in JOINT ACCOUNT
                                   with SRC in Nationalised Bank for a period of 5 years towards
                                   Endowment Fund in ORIGINAL should be submitted.
                               9. Certificates of Resgistration/ Bye-law of the Society/Trust should
                                   be submitted.
                               10. The Affidavit in Rs. 100/- stamp paper in the prescribed format
                                   with Notary attestation.

                               As the institution did not care to respond to the notice issued on the
                               institution, for their failure to shift to permanent premises, even after
                               the lapse of three years stipulated period permitted in their
                               conditional orders of recognition and the matter was placed before
                               SRC. The SRC in its 196th meeting held on 15-16 September 2010
                               considered the matter and decided to issue Showcause notice.
                               Accordingly, Showcause notice was issued to the institution on
                               27.10.2010.

                               Again the institution did not care to respond to the showcause notice
                               issued on the institution even after lapse of 3 months.

                               The committee considered the non-response/reply submitted by
                               the institution and decided to withdraw recognition for B.Ed
                               course (APS01873) with effect from 2012-13, in order to enable
                               the ongoing batch of students in B.Ed course, if any, to
                               complete their course.

                               But it is made clear that the institution is debarred from making
                               any further admission subsequent to the date of issue of this
                               order.

                               The Affiliating body / Examining board / body be informed
                               accordingly.

                               Further decided to return Endowment funds and Reserve fund
                               deposited with SRC NCTE, Bangalore if any.




     (Gangadharaiah)                                                          (Prof. C. Thangamuthu)
Regional Director, SRC, NCTE                                                   Chairman, SRC, NCTE
                                                 139
                                                                                           st
                                                                                Minutes-201 Meeting of SRC
                                                                                         22-23 February 2011
105.         AOS00525           St. Anthony‟s D.P.Ed College, Honnavar, Pin-581334, Uttar
               D.P.Ed           Kannada District, Karnataka was granted recognition for offering
        St.Anthony‟s D.P.Ed     D.P.Ed course.
       College, Uttar Kannada
              District,         The State Government of Karnataka in its letter addressed to
                 KA             Ministry of HRD, Government of India, New Delhi and NCTE has
                                recommended withdrawal of some institutions in the state of
                                Karnataka as the institutions are lacking infrastructural, instructional
                                facilities and staff. The matter was placed before SRC in its 134th
                                meeting of SRC held during 29-31 May & 1st June, 2007 has decided
                                to cause inspection of the institutions recommended for withdrawal
                                of recognition by State Government of Karnataka under Section 17
                                of NCTE Act. Accordingly, inspection was carried out on 18.10.2007.

                                The SRC in its 161st meeting held on 06-07 August 2007 considered
                                the VT report and decided to issue notice for the following reasons:-
                                1. The D.P.Ed College is not functioning and closed since last two
                                    years.
                                2. The management also already sent the letter to Deputy D.P.I.
                                    stating that the institution is not going admit the students for the
                                    academic year 2007-08.

                                Accordingly, notice was issued to the institution on 26.08.2008.

                                The institution did not care to respond to the notice issued on the
                                institution even after lapse of two and half years.

                                The Committee considered the non-reply to the Notice, VT
                                Report, VCD and all the relevant documentary evidences and it
                                was decided to serve Final Showcause Notice Under Section 17
                                of NCTE Act for the following :

                                 The D.P.Ed College is not functioning and closed since last
                                  two years.
                                 The management also already sent a letter to Deputy D.P.I.
                                  stating that the institution is not going to admit the students
                                  from the academic year 2007-08.

                                In view of the above, the Committee decided to issue a Final
                                Showcause Notice to the institution as to why the recognition
                                be not withdrawn and thereby providing an opportunity to the
                                institution to make a written representation within 30 days from
                                the date of issue of the Notice along with necessary
                                certificates/documents in order to take a final decision in the
                                matter; failing which action will be taken including the
                                withdrawal of Recognition, based on the records available, with
                                no further notice.




     (Gangadharaiah)                                                          (Prof. C. Thangamuthu)
Regional Director, SRC, NCTE                                                   Chairman, SRC, NCTE
                                                  140
                                                                                               st
                                                                                    Minutes-201 Meeting of SRC
                                                                                             22-23 February 2011
106.         AOS00508              Sanjay D.P.Ed College, Gunahalli Road, Shahapur Village, Pin-
                D.P.Ed             585401, Bidar District, Karnataka was granted recognition for
       Sanjay D.P.Ed College,      offering D.P.Ed course. The State Government of Karnataka in its
       Bidar District, Karnataka   letter addressed to Ministry of HRD, Government of India, New Delhi
                  KA               and NCTE has recommended withdrawal of some institutions in the
                                   state of Karnataka as the institutions are lacking infrastructural,
                                   instructional facilities and staff.

                                   The matter was placed before SRC in its 134th meeting of SRC held
                                   during 29-31 May & 1st June, 2007 has decided to cause inspection
                                   of the institutions recommended for withdrawal of recognition by
                                   State Government of Karnataka under Section 17 of NCTE Act.
                                   Accordingly, inspection was carried out on 18.10.2007. The
                                   inspection report has received and placed before SRC.

                                   The SRC in its 161st meeting held on 06-07 August 2007 considered
                                   the report and decided that the institution prima facie, does not fulfill
                                   the requriments, the norms and standards laid down by the NCTE in
                                   accordance with the provisions of the NCTE Act 1993 detailed as
                                   below:
                                   1.   The management has not responded to inspection team.
                                   2.   The building in which the D.P.Ed course was functioning is closed.
                                   3.   The D.P.Ed college is not functioning in the same address.
                                   4.   The management running nightingale nursing school in the same
                                        building.

                                   As the institution did not care to respond to the notice dated
                                   26.08.2008 issued to the institution even after lapse of two and half
                                   years.

                                   The Committee considered the non-reply to the Notice, VT
                                   Report, VCD and all the relevant documentary evidences and it
                                   was decided to serve Final Showcause Notice Under Section 17
                                   of NCTE Act for the following :
                                    The management has not responded to inspection team.
                                    The building in which the D.P.Ed course was functioning is
                                       closed.
                                    The D.P.Ed college is not functioning in the same address.
                                    The management is running nightingale nursing school in
                                       the same building.

                                   In view of the above, the Committee decided to issue a Final
                                   Showcause Notice to the institution as to why the recognition
                                   be not withdrawn and thereby providing an opportunity to the
                                   institution to make a written representation within 30 days from
                                   the date of issue of the Notice along with necessary
                                   certificates/documents in order to take a final decision in the
                                   matter; failing which action will be taken including the
                                   withdrawal of Recognition, based on the records available, with
                                   no further notice.



     (Gangadharaiah)                                                              (Prof. C. Thangamuthu)
Regional Director, SRC, NCTE                                                       Chairman, SRC, NCTE
                                                     141
                                                                                            st
                                                                                 Minutes-201 Meeting of SRC
                                                                                          22-23 February 2011
107.          AOS00344            Mahatma Gandhi D.P.Ed College, Balegudi, Ankola Taluk, Pin-
                D.P.Ed            581314, Uttar Kannada District, Karnataka was granted recognition
       Mahatma Gandhi D.P.Ed      for offering D.P.Ed course. The State Government of Karnataka in its
       College, Uttara Kannada,   letter addressed to Ministry of HRD, Government of India, New Delhi
              Karnataka           and NCTE has recommended withdrawal of some institutions in the
                  KA              state of Karnataka as the institutions are lacking infrastructural,
                                  instructional facilities and staff.

                                  The matter was placed before SRC in its 134th meeting of SRC held
                                  during 29-31 May & 1st June, 2007 has decided to cause inspection
                                  of the institutions recommended for withdrawal of recognition by
                                  State Government of Karnataka under Section 17 of NCTE Act.
                                  Accordingly, inspection was carried out on 18.10.2007.

                                  The SRC in its 161st meeting held on 06-07 August 2007 considered
                                  the VT report and decided to issue notice for the following reasons:-
                                  1. The building is demolished and D.P.Ed college is not functional.
                                  2. The management stopped admissions and facilities are not
                                      available to run the course.

                                  Accordingly, notice was issued to the institution on 26.08.2008.

                                  The institution did not care to respond to the notice issued on the
                                  institution even after lapse of two and half years.

                                  The Committee considered the non-reply to the Notice, VT
                                  Report, VCD and all the relevant documentary evidences and it
                                  was decided to serve Final Showcause Notice Under Section 17
                                  of NCTE Act for the following :

                                   The building is demolished and D.P.Ed college is not
                                    functional.
                                   The management stopped admissions and facilities are not
                                    available to run the course.

                                  In view of the above, the Committee decided to issue a Final
                                  Showcause Notice to the institution as to why the recognition
                                  be not withdrawn and thereby providing an opportunity to the
                                  institution to make a written representation within 30 days from
                                  the date of issue of the Notice along with necessary
                                  certificates/documents in order to take a final decision in the
                                  matter; failing which action will be taken including the
                                  withdrawal of Recognition, based on the records available, with
                                  no further notice.




     (Gangadharaiah)                                                           (Prof. C. Thangamuthu)
Regional Director, SRC, NCTE                                                    Chairman, SRC, NCTE
                                                   142
                                                                                        st
                                                                             Minutes-201 Meeting of SRC
                                                                                      22-23 February 2011
108.         APS02297          Harshavardhana B.Ed College, Magadi Main Road, Vishwaneedam
               B.Ed            Post, Bangalore-560090, Karnataka was granted recognition for
       Harshavardhana B.Ed     offering B.Ed course on 03.05.2006 with an intake of 100 students.
        College, Bangalore,
             Karnataka         As per the directions given in SRC in its 175th meeting held on 13-14
                KA             May, 2009 the office of SRC has reviewed the files of the institution
                               who have been granted recognition either in a rented premises
                               pending construction of own building or in lease premises pertaining
                               to the B.Ed course in the State of Karnataka.

                               A list of such institution has been prepared and placed before SRC
                               in its 176th meeting held on 27-28 May, 2009 it was decided that the
                               institution which have not shifted to the permanent premises even
                               after the expiry of three years time limit be issued notice.

                               As per the decision of SRC Notice was issued to the institution on
                               01.09.2009 for the following reasons:

                               1. Demand Draft of Rs. 40,000/- towards inspection fee in favour of
                                   “The Member Secretary NCTE”Payable at Bangalore should be
                                   submitted.
                               2. Land documents of the new building/location for having own land
                                   in the name of the institution/Society/Trust.
                               3. Building Plan of the new building duly approved by th
                                   Government authority.
                               4. Building Completion Certificate from the Government authorities
                                   in the prescribed format(Format enclosed).
                               5. Land Usage Certificates from the concerned Government
                                   authorities stating that the land is exclusively permitted/
                                   sanctioned for Educational Purposes only should be submitted.
                               6. Encumbrance certificate from the competent Government
                                   authority should submitted.
                               7. Fixed Deposit Receipt of Rs. 5 lakhs kept in JOINT ACCOUNT
                                   with SRC in Nationalised Bank for a period of 5 years towards
                                   Endowment Fund in ORIGINAL should be submitted.
                               8. Fixed Deposit Receipt of Rs. 3 lakhs kept in JOINT ACCOUNT
                                   with SRC in Nationalised Bank for a period of 5 years towards
                                   Endowment Fund in ORIGINAL should be submitted.
                               9. Certificates of Resgistration/ Bye-law of the Society/Trust should
                                   be submitted.
                               10. The Affidavit in Rs. 100/- stamp paper in the prescribed format
                                   with Notary attestation.




     (Gangadharaiah)                                                       (Prof. C. Thangamuthu)
Regional Director, SRC, NCTE                                                Chairman, SRC, NCTE
                                                143
                                                                                           st
                                                                                Minutes-201 Meeting of SRC
                                                                                         22-23 February 2011
                               As the institution did not care to respond to the notice issued on the
                               institution, for their failure to shift to permanent premises, even after
                               the lapse of three years stipulated period permitted in their
                               conditional orders of recognition and the matter was placed before
                               SRC. The SRC in its 196th meeting held on 15-16 September 2010
                               considered the matter and decided to issue Showcause notice.
                               Accordingly, Showcause notice was issued to the institution on
                               25.10.2010.

                               Again the institution did not care to respond to the showcause notice
                               issued on the institution even after lapse of four months.

                               The committee considered the non-reponse of the institution to
                               the Showcause Notice and decided to withdraw recognition for
                               B.Ed course (APS02297) with effect from 2011-12, in order to
                               enable the ongoing batch of students in B.Ed course, if any, to
                               complete their course.


                               But it is made clear that the institution is debarred from making
                               any further admission subsequent to the date of issue of this
                               order.


                               The Affiliating body / Examining board / body be informed
                               accordingly.


                               Further decided to return Endowment funds and Reserve fund
                               deposited with SRC NCTE, Bangalore if any.




     (Gangadharaiah)                                                          (Prof. C. Thangamuthu)
Regional Director, SRC, NCTE                                                   Chairman, SRC, NCTE
                                                 144
                                                                                                 st
                                                                                     Minutes-201 Meeting of SRC
                                                                                              22-23 February 2011
109.          APS03810           Archana B.Ed College, Ullal Cross, Nagadevana Halli, 2nd Block,
                B.Ed             Gnanabharthi, Bangalore-560056, Karnataka was granted
       Archana B.Ed College,     recognition for offering B.Ed course on 24.12.2005 with an intake of
       Ullal Cross, Bangalore,   100 students.
              Karnataka
                 KA              As per the directions given in SRC in its 175th meeting held on 13-14
                                 May, 2009 the office of SRC has reviewed the files of the institution
                                 who have been granted recognition either in a rented premises
                                 pending construction of own building or in lease premises pertaining
                                 to the B.Ed course in the State of Karnataka.

                                 A list of such institution has been prepared and placed before SRC
                                 in its 176th meeting held on 27-28 May, 2009 it was decided that the
                                 institution which have not shifted to the permanent premises even
                                 after the expiry of three years time limit be issued notice.

                                 As per the decision of SRC Notice was issued to the institution on
                                 01.09.2009 for the following reasons:
                                 1. Demand Draft of Rs. 40,000/- towards inspection fee in favour of “The
                                     Member Secretary NCTE”Payable at Bangalore should be submitted.
                                 2. Land documents of the new building/location for having own land in the
                                     name of the institution/Society/Trust.
                                 3. Building Plan of the new building duly approved by th Government
                                     authority.
                                 4. Building Completion Certificate from the Government authorities in the
                                     prescribed format(Format enclosed).
                                 5. Land Usage Certificates from the concerned Government authorities
                                     stating that the land is exclusively permitted/ sanctioned for Educational
                                     Purposes only should be submitted.
                                 6. Encumbrance certificate from the competent Government authority
                                     should submitted.
                                 7. Fixed Deposit Receipt of Rs. 5 lakhs kept in JOINT ACCOUNT with
                                     SRC in Nationalised Bank for a period of 5 years towards Endowment
                                     Fund in ORIGINAL should be submitted.
                                 8. Fixed Deposit Receipt of Rs. 3 lakhs kept in JOINT ACCOUNT with
                                     SRC in Nationalised Bank for a period of 5 years towards Endowment
                                     Fund in ORIGINAL should be submitted.
                                 9. Certificates of Resgistration/ Bye-law of the Society/Trust should be
                                     submitted.
                                 10. The Affidavit in Rs. 100/- stamp paper in the prescribed format with
                                     Notary attestation.

                                 As the institution did not care to respond to the notice issued on the
                                 institution, for their failure to shift to permanent premises, even after
                                 the lapse of three years stipulated period permitted in their
                                 conditional orders of recognition and the matter was placed before
                                 SRC. The SRC in its 196th meeting held on 15-16 September 2010
                                 considered the matter and decided to issue Showcause notice.
                                 Accordingly, Showcause notice was issued to the institution on
                                 22.10.2010.




     (Gangadharaiah)                                                               (Prof. C. Thangamuthu)
Regional Director, SRC, NCTE                                                        Chairman, SRC, NCTE
                                                    145
                                                                                          st
                                                                               Minutes-201 Meeting of SRC
                                                                                        22-23 February 2011
                                 Again the institution did not care to respond to the showcause notice
                                 issued on the institution even after lapse of four months.

                                 The committee considered the non-response of the institution
                                 to the Showcause Notice and decided to withdraw recognition
                                 for B.Ed course (APS03810) with effect from 2011-12, in order to
                                 enable the ongoing batch of students in B.Ed course, if any, to
                                 complete their course.

                                 But it is made clear that the institution is debarred from making
                                 any further admission subsequent to the date of issue of this
                                 order.

                                 The Affiliating body / Examining board / body be informed
                                 accordingly.

                                 Further decided to return Endowment funds and Reserve fund
                                 deposited with SRC NCTE, Bangalore if any.

110.        APS02260             Ganga Kaveri College of Education, No. 1699 (43/1), Dr. Rajkumar
                B.Ed             Road, 3rd Stage, Rajajinagar, Bangalore-560010, Karnataka
       Ganga Kaveri College of
        Education, Bangalore,    Ganga Kaveri College of Education No. 1699 (43/1) Dr. Rajkumar
             Karnataka           Road, 3rd Stage, Rajajinagar, Bangalore-560010, Karnataka was
                 KA              granted recognition for offering B.Ed course on 24.12.2005 with an
                                 intake of 100 students.

                                 As per the directions given in SRC in its 175th meeting held on 13-14
                                 May, 2009 the office of SRC has reviewed the files of the institution
                                 who have been granted recognition either in a rented premises
                                 pending construction of own building or in lease premises pertaining
                                 to the B.Ed course in the State of Karnataka.

                                 A list of such institution has been prepared and placed before SRC
                                 in its 176th meeting held on 27-28 May, 2009 it was decided that the
                                 institution which have not shifted to the permanent premises even
                                 after the expiry of three years time limit be issued notice.

                                 As per the decision of SRC Notice was issued to the institution on
                                 01.09.2009 for the following reasons:
                                 1. Demand Draft of Rs. 40,000/- towards inspection fee in favour of
                                    “The Member Secretary NCTE”Payable at Bangalore should be
                                    submitted.
                                 2. Land documents of the new building/location for having own land
                                    in the name of the institution/Society/Trust.
                                 3. Building Plan of the new building duly approved by th
                                    Government authority.
                                 4. Building Completion Certificate from the Government authorities
                                    in the prescribed format(Format enclosed).




     (Gangadharaiah)                                                         (Prof. C. Thangamuthu)
Regional Director, SRC, NCTE                                                  Chairman, SRC, NCTE
                                                  146
                                                                                           st
                                                                                Minutes-201 Meeting of SRC
                                                                                         22-23 February 2011
                               5. Land Usage Certificates from the concerned Government
                                   authorities stating that the land is exclusively permitted/
                                   sanctioned for Educational Purposes only should be submitted.
                               6. Encumbrance certificate from the competent Government
                                   authority should submitted.
                               7. Fixed Deposit Receipt of Rs. 5 lakhs kept in JOINT ACCOUNT
                                   with SRC in Nationalised Bank for a period of 5 years towards
                                   Endowment Fund in ORIGINAL should be submitted.
                               8. Fixed Deposit Receipt of Rs. 3 lakhs kept in JOINT ACCOUNT
                                   with SRC in Nationalised Bank for a period of 5 years towards
                                   Endowment Fund in ORIGINAL should be submitted.
                               9. Certificates of Resgistration/ Bye-law of the Society/Trust should
                                   be submitted.
                               10. The Affidavit in Rs. 100/- stamp paper in the prescribed format
                                   with Notary attestation.

                               As the institution did not care to respond to the notice issued on the
                               institution, for their failure to shift to permanent premises, even after
                               the lapse of three years stipulated period permitted in their
                               conditional orders of recognition and the matter was placed before
                               SRC. The SRC in its 196th meeting held on 15-16 September 2010
                               considered the matter and decided to issue Showcause notice.
                               Accordingly, Showcause notice was issued to the institution on
                               27.10.2010.

                               Again the institution did not care to respond to the showcause notice
                               issued on the institution even after lapse of four months.

                               The committee considered the non-reply to Showcause Notice
                               by the institution and decided to withdraw recognition for B.Ed
                               course (APS02260) with effect from 2011-12, in order to enable
                               the ongoing batch of students in B.Ed course, if any, to
                               complete their course.

                               But it is made clear that the institution is debarred from making
                               any further admission subsequent to the date of issue of this
                               order.

                               The Affiliating body / Examining board / body be informed
                               accordingly.

                               Further decided to return Endowment funds and Reserve fund
                               deposited with SRC NCTE, Bangalore if any.




     (Gangadharaiah)                                                          (Prof. C. Thangamuthu)
Regional Director, SRC, NCTE                                                   Chairman, SRC, NCTE
                                                 147
                                                                                                st
                                                                                    Minutes-201 Meeting of SRC
                                                                                             22-23 February 2011
111.       APS02315            Aryan B.Ed College, No.147, Vidyanagar Colony, Opp. Basaveshwara
              B.Ed             Hospital, Sedam Road, Gulbarga-585105, Karnataka was granted
       Aryan B.Ed College,     recognition for offering B.Ed course on 05.01.2005 with an intake of 100
       Gulbarga Karnataka      students.
               KA                                                 th
                               As per decision of SRC in its 175 meeting the office of SRC has reviewed
                               the files of the institution who have been granted recognition either in a
                               rented premises pending construction of own building or in lease premises.

                               A list of such institutions has been prepared and placed before SRC in its
                                    th
                               176 meeting held on 27-28 May 2009 wherein, it was decided that the
                               institution which have not shifted to the permanent premises even after the
                               expiry of three years time limit be issued notice under section 17 of NCTE
                               Act for further action. Notice was issued to the institution on 08.09.2009.

                               The institution did not care to respond to the notice issued on the institution
                               even after lapse of one and half years.

                               The Committee considered the non-reply to the Notice, VT Report,
                               VCD and all the relevant documentary evidences and it was decided
                               to serve Final Showcause Notice Under Section 17 of NCTE Act for
                               the following :
                               1. Demand Draft of Rs. 40,000/- towards inspection fee in favour of “The
                                   Member Secretary NCTE”Payable at Bangalore should be submitted.
                               2. Land documents of the new building/location for having own land in the
                                   name of the institution/Society/Trust.
                               3. Building Plan of the new building duly approved by th Government
                                   authority.
                               4. Building Completion Certificate from the Government authorities in the
                                   prescribed format(Format enclosed).
                               5. Land Usage Certificates from the concerned Government authorities
                                   stating that the land is exclusively permitted/ sanctioned for Educational
                                   Purposes only should be submitted.
                               6. Encumbrance certificate from the competent Government authority
                                   should submitted.
                               7. Fixed Deposit Receipt of Rs. 5 lakhs kept in JOINT ACCOUNT with
                                   SRC in Nationalised Bank for a period of 5 years towards Endowment
                                   Fund in ORIGINAL should be submitted.
                               8. Fixed Deposit Receipt of Rs. 3 lakhs kept in JOINT ACCOUNT with
                                   SRC in Nationalised Bank for a period of 5 years towards Endowment
                                   Fund in ORIGINAL should be submitted.
                               9. Certificates of Resgistration/ Bye-law of the Society/Trust should be
                                   submitted.
                               10. The Affidavit in Rs. 100/- stamp paper in the prescribed format with
                                   Notary attestation.
                               In view of the above, the Committee decided to issue a Final
                               Showcause Notice to the institution as to why the recognition
                               be not withdrawn and thereby providing an opportunity to the
                               institution to make a written representation within 30 days from
                               the date of issue of the Notice along with necessary
                               certificates/documents in order to take a final decision in the
                               matter; failing which action will be taken including the
                               withdrawal of Recognition, based on the records available, with
                               no further notice.



     (Gangadharaiah)                                                              (Prof. C. Thangamuthu)
Regional Director, SRC, NCTE                                                       Chairman, SRC, NCTE
                                                   148
                                                                                        st
                                                                             Minutes-201 Meeting of SRC
                                                                                      22-23 February 2011
112.         APS07635           Sri. Siddarameshwar Education Trust‟s Chandragiri College of
                D.Ed            Education for Women, Kagwad Post, Athani Taluk, Belgaum District,
        Sri Siddarameshwar      Karnataka was granted recognition for offering D.Ed course on
         Education Trust‟s      26.06.2007 with an intake of 50 students.
       Chandragiri College of
       Education for Women,     NCTE, Hqrs vide its letter dated 09.07.2010 has forwarded a copy of
              Belgaum           the inspection report dated 20.05.2010 conducted under section 13
                 KA             of NCTE Act. As there are deficiencies pointed out in the inspection
                                report, NCTE Hqrs has requested SRC to initiate action against the
                                institution under section 17 of the NCTE Act immediately.

                                The SRC in its 194th meeting held on 21-22 July 2010 considered
                                the letter from NCTE, Hqrs VT report and original file of the
                                institution and decided to issue notice. Accordingly, Notice was
                                issued to the institution on 27.08.2010.

                                 The institution did not care to respond to the notice issued on the
                                institution even after lapse of six months.

                                The Committee considered the non-reply to the Notice, VT
                                Report, VCD and all the relevant documentary evidences and it
                                was decided to serve Final Showcause Notice Under Section 17
                                of NCTE Act for the following :

                                 Clarification for non-admission of the students and why
                                  recognition cannot be withdrawn.
                                 As per the Visiting team report, the College is not prepared
                                  to start the College this year also and expressed their
                                  inability due to do so for various reasons.

                                In view of the above, the Committee decided to issue a Final
                                Showcause Notice to the institution as to why the recognition
                                be not withdrawn and thereby providing an opportunity to the
                                institution to make a written representation within 30 days from
                                the date of issue of the Notice along with necessary
                                certificates/documents in order to take a final decision in the
                                matter; failing which action will be taken including the
                                withdrawal of Recognition, based on the records available, with
                                no further notice.




     (Gangadharaiah)                                                        (Prof. C. Thangamuthu)
Regional Director, SRC, NCTE                                                 Chairman, SRC, NCTE
                                                 149
                                                                                                st
                                                                                    Minutes-201 Meeting of SRC
                                                                                             22-23 February 2011
113.         APS03935            A.E.T. College of Education, Doddakannelli, Sarjapur Road,
               B.Ed              Carmelram Post, Bangalore-560035, Karnataka was granted
          A.E.T College of       recognition for offering B.Ed course on 03.05.2006 with an intake of
             Education,          100 students.
       Doddakannelli, Sarjapur
       Road, Carmelram Post,     As per the directions given in SRC in its 175th meeting held on 13-14
         Bangalore-560035,       May, 2009 the office of SRC has reviewed the files of the institution
             Karnataka           who have been granted recognition either in a rented premises
                KA               pending construction of own building or in lease premises pertaining
                                 to the B.Ed course in the State of Karnataka.

                                 A list of such institution has been prepared and placed before SRC
                                 in its 176th meeting held on 27-28 May, 2009 it was decided that the
                                 institution which have not shifted to the permanent premises even
                                 after the expiry of three years time limit be issued notice.

                                 As per the decision of SRC Notice was issued to the institution on
                                 01.09.2009.

                                 As the institution did not care to respond to the notice issued on the
                                 institution, for their failure to shift to permanent premises, even after
                                 the lapse of three years stipulated period permitted in their
                                 conditional orders of recognition and the matter was placed before
                                 SRC. The SRC in its 196th meeting held on 15-16 September 2010
                                 considered the matter and decided to issue Showcause notice.
                                 Accordingly, Showcause notice was issued to the institution on
                                 27.10.2010.

                                 Again the institution did not care to respond to the showcause notice
                                 issued on the institution even after lapse of four months.

                                 The Committee considered the non-reply to the Notice, VT
                                 Report, VCD and all the relevant documentary evidences and it
                                 was decided to serve Final Showcause Notice Under Section 17
                                 of NCTE Act for the following :
                                 1. Demand Draft of Rs. 40,000/- towards inspection fee in favour of “The
                                    Member Secretary NCTE”Payable at Bangalore should be submitted.
                                 2. Land documents of the new building/location for having own land in the
                                    name of the institution/Society/Trust.
                                 3. Building Plan of the new building duly approved by th Government
                                    authority.
                                 4. Building Completion Certificate from the Government authorities in the
                                    prescribed format(Format enclosed).
                                 5. Land Usage Certificates from the concerned Government authorities
                                    stating that the land is exclusively permitted/ sanctioned for Educational
                                    Purposes only should be submitted.
                                 6. Encumbrance certificate from the competent Government authority
                                    should submitted.
                                 7. Fixed Deposit Receipt of Rs. 5 lakhs kept in JOINT ACCOUNT with
                                    SRC in Nationalised Bank for a period of 5 years towards Endowment
                                    Fund in ORIGINAL should be submitted.



     (Gangadharaiah)                                                               (Prof. C. Thangamuthu)
Regional Director, SRC, NCTE                                                        Chairman, SRC, NCTE
                                                    150
                                                                                          st
                                                                               Minutes-201 Meeting of SRC
                                                                                        22-23 February 2011
                               8. Fixed Deposit Receipt of Rs. 3 lakhs kept in JOINT ACCOUNT with
                                   SRC in Nationalised Bank for a period of 5 years towards Endowment
                                   Fund in ORIGINAL should be submitted.
                               9. Certificates of Resgistration/ Bye-law of the Society/Trust should be
                                   submitted.
                               10. The Affidavit in Rs. 100/- stamp paper in the prescribed format with
                                   Notary attestation.

                               The committee considered the non-reply to Showcause Notice
                               by the institution and decided to withdraw recognition for B.Ed
                               course (APS03935) with effect from 2011-12, in order to enable
                               the ongoing batch of students in B.Ed course, if any, to
                               complete their course.

                               But it is made clear that the institution is debarred from making
                               any further admission subsequent to the date of issue of this
                               order.

                               The Affiliating body / Examining board / body be informed
                               accordingly.

                               Further decided to return Endowment funds and Reserve fund
                               deposited with SRC NCTE, Bangalore if any.

114.         APS0008
                D.Ed           Maulana Azad National Urdu University, Hyderabad, Andhra
        Maulana Azad Urdu      Pradesh (Central Govt. institution coming under MHRD, New Delhi)
       University, Hyderabad   has been granted recognition with an intake of 75 students for D.Ed
                 AP            course.Vide order dated 13/9/2001

                               The Government of India in its Central Education Institution
                               (Reservation in Admission) Act 2007, has made separate quota for
                               OBC‟s. The Central Government has decided to enhance the intake
                               of Government institutions for providing reservations under Act the
                               said Act to the OBCs. In this regard a letter dt.20.06.2008 was
                               received from NCTE, New Delhi stating that the applications
                               received for increase in intake for accommodating OBC‟s shall be
                               considered on priority in terms of provision of Central Education
                               Institution (Reservation in Admission) Act 2006.

                               The Maulana Azad National University Hyderabad, Andhra Pradesh
                               has made application on 2.4.2009 requesting for increase of intake
                               of 40 students for D.Ed. course.

                               The NCTE, New Delhi in its letter dated 20.6.2008 has informed to
                               consider on priority the applications received under the above
                               category for increase in intake.




     (Gangadharaiah)                                                         (Prof. C. Thangamuthu)
Regional Director, SRC, NCTE                                                  Chairman, SRC, NCTE
                                                 151
                                                                                           st
                                                                                Minutes-201 Meeting of SRC
                                                                                         22-23 February 2011
                               The application submitted by Maulana Azad National Urdu University
                               for increase in the intake from 75 to 115 was placed before SRC in
                               its 173rd meeting held on 20-22 April, 2009. The SRC considered
                               the matter and decided to enhance the intake of the institution from
                               75 to 115 subject to providing infrastructural and instructional
                               facilities as per NCTE norms and standards.

                               Accordingly, Conditional Recognition orders for D.Ed was issued on
                               20.05.2009 with a request to submit reply within 15 days from the
                               date of receipt of the letter. The institution did not submit the reply, a
                               reminder was sent on 07.07.2009. The institution did not submit any
                               reply.

                               SRC in its 182nd meeting held on 31st August 2009, decided to issue
                               Showcause Notice under Section 17 of NCTE Act for withdrawal of
                               Conditional Recognition/ Refusal of Recognition, for not fulfilling the
                               faculty norms of NCTE.

                               As per the decision of SRC notice u/s 17 was issued on 29.09.2009.
                               In reply to the notice institution has sent written representation
                               through fax on 19.10.2009

                               The inspection report of the above institution along with VCD and the
                               application was again considered by SRC as per Act of NCTE, 1993,
                               Regulations and guidelines from time to time laid on the table. The
                               Regional Committee noted the following deficiencies still persist in
                               the institution:-
                                  It has not specified as to who is the Principal for B.Ed. and D.Ed.
                                   course separately.
                                  It is not clear which faculty are teaching B.Ed. and D.Ed. courses
                                   separately.
                                  Teachers are inadequate, in numbers as per norms.
                                  As per practice the original affidavit of Rs 100/- by the management
                                   and Rs 10/- by each staff along with supporting document i.e marks
                                   sheets are required.

                               The institution may submit documentary proof duly certified by the
                               competent authority with respect to the deficiencies notified as above
                               along with an Affidavit and fresh VCD supporting removal of the
                               above deficiencies.

                               As per direction of SRC a SCN was issued on 25.11.2009. However
                               no reply has been received on till date.

                               The Committee in its 196th meeting held on 15-16 September 2010
                               considered the matter and it was decided to serve Showcause
                               Notice Under Section 17 of NCTE Act.
                                 For not responding to the Showcause Notice dated. 25.11.2009,
                                   evenafter a lapse of around 11 months.




     (Gangadharaiah)                                                           (Prof. C. Thangamuthu)
Regional Director, SRC, NCTE                                                    Chairman, SRC, NCTE
                                                 152
                                                                                        st
                                                                             Minutes-201 Meeting of SRC
                                                                                      22-23 February 2011
                                As per the decision of SRC Notice was issued on 29.10.2010. Till
                                date institution not submitted its written representation/documents
                                even after lapse of more than one year 2 months.

                                The Committee considered the non-reply to the Notice, VT
                                Report, VCD and all the relevant documentary evidences and it
                                was decided to serve Final Showcause Notice Under Section 17
                                of NCTE Act for the following :

                                 For not responding to the Showcause Notice dated.
                                  25.11.2009, evenafter a lapse of around one year two
                                  months.

                                In view of the above, the Committee decided to issue a Final
                                Showcause Notice to the institution as to why the recognition
                                be not withdrawn and thereby providing an opportunity to the
                                institution to make a written representation within 30 days from
                                the date of issue of the Notice along with necessary
                                certificates/documents in order to take a final decision in the
                                matter; failing which action will be taken including the
                                withdrawal of Recognition, based on the records available, with
                                no further notice.

115.         SRCAPP39           Chaithanya Educational Institution, 65/2, Kudloor, Kushalnagar,
                 B.Ed           Somwarpet, Kodagu District-571234, Karnataka had submitted an
       Chaithanya Educational   application seeking     grant of recognition for B.Ed course on
         Institution, Kodagu    06.11.2009. Application was processed and the deficiency letter
                   KA           was issued to the institution on 22.12.2009. The institution has
                                replied to the deficiency letter on 29.01.2010. The SRC in its 190th
                                meeting held on March 29-30 2010 considered the written
                                representation and decided to reject the application. Accordingly, a
                                refusal order was issued to the institution on 04.05.2010.

                                Further the institution preferred appeal and the appellate authority
                                has reversed the rejection order of SRC vide order dated
                                15.09.2010. The SRC in its 197th meeting held on 13-14 October
                                2010 considered the appellate authority order and decided to
                                process the application on merits. Accordingly, application has been
                                processed and Deficiency letter was issued to the institution on
                                10.01.2011. The institution has submitted its written representation
                                on 08.02.2011.

                                The committee considered the reply to deficiency letter and
                                decided to cause inspection and also decided to follow up the
                                deficiencies, if any.




     (Gangadharaiah)                                                        (Prof. C. Thangamuthu)
Regional Director, SRC, NCTE                                                 Chairman, SRC, NCTE
                                                 153
                                                                                                 st
                                                                                     Minutes-201 Meeting of SRC
                                                                                              22-23 February 2011
116.         SRCAPP99             The District Muslim Education Society D.Ed College, No.243/1,
                D.Ed              Gajbarwadi, Kukkeri Post, Hukkeri, Belgaum District-591309,
         The District Muslim      Karnataka had submitted an application seeking grant of recognition
       Educational Society D.Ed   for D.Ed course on 06.11.2009.
          College, Belgaum
                 KA               Application was processed and the deficiency letter was issued to
                                  the institution on 22.12.2009. The institution has replied to the
                                  deficiency letter on 18.02.2010.

                                  The SRC in its 190th meeting held on March 29-30 2010 considered
                                  the written representation and on careful perusal original file of the
                                  institution and decided to reject the application. Accordingly, a
                                  refusal order was issued to the institution on 28.04.2010.

                                  Further the institution preferred appeal and the appellate authority
                                  has reversed the rejection order of SRC vide order dated
                                  15.09.2010. The SRC in its 197th meeting held on 13-14 October
                                  2010 considered the appellate authority order and decided to
                                  process the application on merits. Accordingly, application has been
                                  processed and Deficiency letter was issued to the institution on
                                  11.01.2011. The institution has submitted its written representation
                                  on 11.02.2011.

                                  The committee considered the reply to deficiency letter and
                                  decided to cause inspection and also decided to follow up the
                                  deficiencies, if any.
117.         APS09203             PSR College of Education, Virudhunagar District, Tamilnadu
               B.Ed-AI
           PSR College of         P.S. Ramasamy Telugu Minority Educational & Charitable Trust,
       Education, Virudhunagar    Sivakasi submitted an application in the name and style of PSR
                 TN               College of Education, Sivakasai, Virudhunagar for seeking grant of
                                  recognition for B.Ed-AI course on 27.11.2007.

                                  The application was processed and recognition order to the
                                  institution was issued to the institution on 30.08.2008 with intake of
                                  200 students.

                                  The institution vide its letter dated 27.01.2011 stated as follows:
                                  “In the NCTE notification 2009, it has been ordered that the colleges
                                  running B.Ed course with an intake of 200 students exceeding the standard
                                  norms of 100 strength shall be allowed to continue the same strength from
                                  the academic year 2011-2012 subject to the condition that the course is
                                  accredited with “B-Grade”. Accordingly, the Tamilnadu Teacher Education
                                  University, Chennai has accorded affiliation to the PSR College of
                                  Education for the intake of 200 students for the academic year 2010-2011
                                  and the university has stipulated that the college should get accreditation
                                  with “B-Grade” from the NAAC, Bangalore for keeping the strength of 200
                                  for the ensuing academic year 2011-2012 as per the order of NCTE, New
                                  Delhi. Failure to get the accreditation from the NAAC, Bangalore will lead to
                                  reduce the intake from 200 to 100 for the academic year 2011-2012.




     (Gangadharaiah)                                                                (Prof. C. Thangamuthu)
Regional Director, SRC, NCTE                                                         Chairman, SRC, NCTE
                                                     154
                                                                                                       st
                                                                                          Minutes-201 Meeting of SRC
                                                                                                   22-23 February 2011
                                           In this connection, it is submitted that the PSR College of Education
                                   has been started in the year 2007-2008 with an intake of 100 students in
                                   the permanent RCC building with space area of 2808 sq.mts, library and
                                   laboratories are installed comfortably for the students.

                                   Considering the excess available space, proposal was submitted to the
                                   NCTE to increase the intake from 100 to 200 from the academic year 2008-
                                   2009. The NCTE was kind enough to sanction the intake of 200 accordingly
                                   form the academic year 2008-2009. Now the college stands in it fourth year
                                   in the permanent space structure for 200 students.

                                             The staff required for 200 students have been appointed from the
                                   year 2008-2009. They are continuing without break in service. All steps are
                                   being taken to develop the institution in all aspects so as to get the B.Ed
                                   course accredited from the academic year 2012-2013. As the institution is
                                   situated in backward rural area, it is experienced much difficulty to get
                                   scholars as Guest lecturers to impart research topics on recent trend in
                                   teaching methodology to our staff and students. Anyhow we will overcome
                                   the difficulties and achieve the goal accreditation from the year, 2012-2013.
                                   It is requested to extend the time for another one year i.e 2011-2012. So
                                   that we can have the intake of 200 for the said year which will safe guard
                                   the interest of staff as well as the utility value of the structure created for the
                                   institution. The graduated students community will also get the benefit of
                                   acquiring professional B.Ed course from rural areas. We pray for grant of
                                   permission to extend to accreditation time for the year 2011-2012 and allow
                                   us to admit 200 students during the year 2011-2012 only/’.

                                   The committee considered the matter and decided that the
                                   request for extension of time for accreditation be not complied
                                   with

118.          APS03759             Andavar Teacher Training Institute, Erode District, Tamilnadu
                D.T.Ed
          Andavar Teacher          Gobi Andavar Educational & Charitable Trust, Erode submitted an
       Training Institute, Erode   application in the name and style of Andavar Teacher Training
                  TN               Institute for seeking grant of recognition for D.T.Ed course on
                                   16.12.2004.

                                   The application was processed and recognition order to the
                                   institution was issued to the institution on 06.01.2006 at Andavar
                                   Teacher Training Institute, Sathy Main Karattadipalayam Pudur Post,
                                   Gobi Taluk-638453, Erode, Tamilnadu with the condition to shift to
                                   own premises within 3 years.

                                   The institution vide its letter dated 27.01.2011 stated as follows:

                                   “Our Teacher Training Institute situated at Karattadipalayam Pudhur Post,
                                   Gobi-638453, Erode, Tamilnadu had been granted recognition for D.T.Ed of
                                   two year course with respect to above order. As per the condition enforced




     (Gangadharaiah)                                                                    (Prof. C. Thangamuthu)
Regional Director, SRC, NCTE                                                             Chairman, SRC, NCTE
                                                        155
                                                                                                  st
                                                                                      Minutes-201 Meeting of SRC
                                                                                               22-23 February 2011
                                   by you for 3 years approval we are unable to run the institute due to lack of
                                   admission in the rural belt of Tamilnadu. Hence we had closed the
                                   admission permanently in the previous academic year 2009-2010 itself.
                                   This is for your kind information. Thanking you and looking forward to have
                                   co-operative at all times”.

                                   The committee considered the request and decided to permit
                                   the closure of the institution by withdrawing recognition for
                                   D.T.Ed course (APS03759) with effect from 2011-12, in order to
                                   enable the ongoing batch of students in D.T.Ed course, if any,
                                   to complete their course.

                                   But it is made clear that the institution is debarred from making
                                   any further admission subsequent to the date of issue of this
                                   order.

                                   The Affiliating body / Examining board / body be informed
                                   accordingly.

                                   Further decided to return Endowment funds and Reserve fund
                                   deposited with SRC NCTE, Bangalore if any.


119.          APS06235             Kongunaadu Teacher Training Institute, Bangalore Main Road,
              D.T.Ed-AI            Mamangam, Salem
        Kongunaadu Teacher
       Training Institute, Salem   Kongunaadu TTI, Salem, Tamilnadu has submitted an application for
                  TN               seeking grant of recognition for D.T.Ed-AI on 13.10.2005. The
                                   application was processed and the inspection of the institution was
                                   carried out on 5.7.2006 and finally SRC granted recognition to offer
                                   D.T.Ed-AI on 14.8.2006 of two years duration from the academic
                                   session 2006-2007 with an existing intake of 50 students and
                                   additional intake of 50 students.

                                   Meantime, a written representation from the institution has been
                                   received on 11.2.2011, which is stated as follows;

                                   “The Kongunaadu Educational Trust General Body meeting was held on
                                   6.2.1011 and in that meeting it has been unanimously resolved to surrender
                                   the recognition of Additional in take of 50 students only from the academic
                                   session 2006-2007 attached to the previously existing Kongunaadu
                                   Teacher         Training        Institute,      Mamamngam,           Salem-
                                   636302[Ref:FTN/SRO/NCTE/2005-2006/3367 dated 7.10.2005 Code
                                   APS03866] from the academic year 2010-2011 due to poor admission of
                                   the students”.




     (Gangadharaiah)                                                                 (Prof. C. Thangamuthu)
Regional Director, SRC, NCTE                                                          Chairman, SRC, NCTE
                                                      156
                                                                                          st
                                                                               Minutes-201 Meeting of SRC
                                                                                        22-23 February 2011
                                The committee considered the request and decided to permit
                                the closure of the institution by withdrawing recognition for
                                D.T.Ed Additional Intake course (APS06235) with effect from
                                2012-13, in order to enable the ongoing batch of students in
                                D.T.Ed – AI course, if any, to complete their course.

                                But it is made clear that the institution is debarred from making
                                any further admission subsequent to the date of issue of this
                                order.

                                The Affiliating body / Examining board / body be informed
                                accordingly.

                                Further decided to return Endowment funds and Reserve fund
                                deposited with SRC NCTE, Bangalore if any.

120.       APS09581             Merit College of Education, Tirunelveli District, Tamlinadu
               B.Ed
         Merit College of       Merit Educational and Charitable Trust, Tirunelveli Dt. Tamilnadu
       Education, Tirunelveli   has submitted an application in the name and style of Merit College
                TN              of Education, No. 222, Kadayam to Mukkudal Main Road, Idaikal
                                Village, Ambasamudram Taluk, Tirunelveli District, Tamilnadu for
                                seeking grant of recognition for B.Ed course on 20.8.2008.

                                A letter was sent to the to the State Government for their
                                recommendation on 4.9.2008.

                                The application was processed and the deficiency letter was sent to
                                the institution on 4.9.2008 for want of Land Usage Certificate for
                                educational purposes from concerned Government authorities.

                                The institution in its letter dated 23.10.2008 submitted a copy of land
                                use certificate approved by Tahsildar, Ambasamudram.

                                The matter was not placed in any of the SRC meetings. Reply from
                                the State Government has also not been received so far.

                                Meantime, after lapse of two years duration, the institution now filed
                                court case in W.P. no. 1459 of 2011 alleging that application filed by
                                the petitioner dated 20.8.2008 for one year year programme is not
                                considered and for a direction to NCTE to consider the said
                                application for the year 2011-2012 without reference to NOC from
                                the first respondent.

                                In this regard a letter to the advocate enclosing the brief of the case
                                is sent on 17.02.2011.

                                The committee considered the writ petition and decided to await
                                for the court orders.




     (Gangadharaiah)                                                          (Prof. C. Thangamuthu)
Regional Director, SRC, NCTE                                                   Chairman, SRC, NCTE
                                                  157
                                                                                         st
                                                                              Minutes-201 Meeting of SRC
                                                                                       22-23 February 2011
121.         APS05578            An application was submitted by St.Mark NTR Institute of
                D.Ed             Elementary Teacher Education, Guntur, A.P for grant of recognition
       St. Marks NTR Institute   to D.Ed course in the office of SRC-NCTE, Bangalore vide dated
       of Elemenatary Teacher    02.01.2006.
          Education, Guntur
                 AP              The file was under process and in the meanwhile, in view of the
                                 recommendations of the State Government of Andhra Pradesh vide
                                 letter dated 07.01.2009 not to further recognize/permit the
                                 institutions for conducting B.Ed, D.Ed, Physical Education,
                                 Language Pandit course(s), to this effect that application for B.Ed,
                                 D.Ed, Physical Education, Language Pandit courses from the States
                                 of Andhra Pradesh will not be considered for the academic session
                                 2009-2010 and all such applications shall be returned along with
                                 processing fees and documents.

                                 The SRC in its 169th meeting held on 12-13th January, 2009 having
                                 considered the letter dated 7.1.2009 of State Government of Andhra
                                 Pradesh and decided to give effect to the decision of above decision
                                 of State Government of Andhra Pradesh as such, with immediate
                                 effect.

                                 Further, a letter dated 07.02.2009 forwarded by Principal Secretary
                                 of Education requesting not to accord further recognition/permission
                                 to the new colleges/private B.Ed , D.Ed, Physical Education,
                                 Language Pandit in the state of Andhra Pradesh as the above
                                 colleges are exceeding in numbers than required.

                                 Meanwhile, a letter dated 17.03.2009 has been received from NCTE
                                 Hqrs informing that the “ The recommendations of the Govt. of
                                 Andhra Pradesh not to grant recognition/ permission in respect of
                                 other courses like B.Ed , D.Ed and Physical Education courses have
                                 further been considered in NCTE and it has been decided that no
                                 further recognition/Permission to any institution in the state of
                                 Andhra Pradesh be considered by SRC for the academic session
                                 2009-10 for B.Ed , D.Ed and physical Education Courses also”.

                                 Further, the state Government vide its letter dated 20.03.2009
                                 informed that it has been decided not to recommend the name of this
                                 institution.

                                 The letters dated 07.01.2009, 07.02.2009, 17.03.2009 and
                                 20.03.2009 were considered by SRC in its 172nd meeting held on
                                 25th-26th March 2009 and SRC decided to accept the
                                 recommendation of the State Government of Andhra Pradesh, not to
                                 grant recognition to any of the Teacher Training Institutions in the
                                 state of Andhra Pradesh for the year 2009-10 and decided to close
                                 the applications.




     (Gangadharaiah)                                                         (Prof. C. Thangamuthu)
Regional Director, SRC, NCTE                                                  Chairman, SRC, NCTE
                                                  158
                                                                                           st
                                                                                Minutes-201 Meeting of SRC
                                                                                         22-23 February 2011

                               As per the decision of SRC the application was closed on
                               29.04.2009.

                               The Hon‟ble High Court has passed an order on 23.04.2010 vide
                               W.P.No.9360 of 2010 to consider the application of the petitioner
                               without making reference to the recommendation of State
                               Government policy dated 07.01.2009.

                               Further, a letter has been received from NCTE, Hqrs vide letter
                               No.64-138/2010/NCTE/legal dated 02.06.2010 with the direction to
                               file Counter Affidavit in the matter incorporating the provision of filing
                               appeal under section 18 of NCTE Act and to defend the case
                               including on behalf of NCTE (HQ) under intimation to this office.

                               The Committee considered the matter and decided to process the
                               application.

                               As per decision of Regional Committee the file has been processed
                               and deficiency letter was issued on 17.08.2010. The institution is
                               having land and building on a lease of 30 years as per regulation
                               2006. As per questionnaire submitted by institution on 28.09.2010 it
                               is having land on ownership in Sr. NO. 522/2- total 1 Acres and the
                               building is constructed over it.

                               The institution is already running B.Ed course with 100 intake.

                               As per affidavit dated 03.04.07 it is showing that it has permanent
                               land in Sr. No. 48,60,61 of Kesanupalli, Village, Narasaraopet
                               Mandal, Guntur District to extent of 2.23 hectares. The sale Deed
                               dated 24.12.2005 states that the institution is having land of one acre
                               in Southern Regional Committee. NO. 48,60,61 in Kesanupalli
                               Village, Narasaraopet Mandal, Guntur, Andhra Pradesh.

                               The committee considered the matter and decided to cause
                               inspection.

122.        APS04084           Sivanthi Institute of Education has submitted an application for
               B.Ed            seeking grant of recognition for B.Ed course on 31.12.2004.
        Sivanthi College of
       Education, Kundrathur   As per the Court direction in W.P. No. 14411 & 1441/2055 inspection
                TN             of the institution was carried out on 26.9.2005. The inspection report
                               was placed before SRC in its 6th October, 2005. The SRC
                               considered the report of inspection team and other documents
                               submitted by the institution along with application and decided to
                               accord recognition to the institution for offering B.Ed course from the
                               session 2006-2007.




     (Gangadharaiah)                                                           (Prof. C. Thangamuthu)
Regional Director, SRC, NCTE                                                    Chairman, SRC, NCTE
                                                 159
                                                                                          st
                                                                               Minutes-201 Meeting of SRC
                                                                                        22-23 February 2011
                               Some of the institutions who have granted recognition for the
                               subsequent year have preferred appeal before NCTE, New Delhi to
                               consider their cases of grant of recognition for the session 2005-
                               2006 itself instead of 2006-07. The NCTE-New Delhi vide order no.
                               F.No. 89-156/2005/Appeal dated 28.9.2005 has remanded back the
                               case to SRC with a direction to reconsider these cases immediately
                               for grant of recognition for the session 2005-06.

                               SRC in its 104th meeting held on 9-10 November, 2005 has
                               considered the legal opinion obtained in this regard and has taken a
                               decision to grant recognition to the session 2005-06 to those
                               institutions who have submitted belated NOCs/Endorsements and
                               also the essential documents mentioned in Appendix-1B of NCTE
                               Regulations as one time exception.

                               Accordingly, recognition order was issued to the institution vide order
                               No.F.SRO/NCTE/B.Ed/2005-06/4075 dated 18.11.2005 at the
                               following address No.151/19, Arcot Road, Virugambakkam,
                               Chennai-600092, Tamlinadu.

                               After a period of 2 years the institution has submitted request for
                               correction of address in recognition order dated 18.11.2005 which
                               carries the Trust‟s address instead of college address which is as
                               follows;
                               151/19, Arcot road, Virugambakkam, Chennai-600092

                               The committee considered the matter and decided that the
                               address i.e. No.151/19, Arcot Road, Virugambakkam, Chennai-
                               600092, Tamlinadu instead of the Trust Address be corrected
                               according to the location of the institution.

123.      APS05519             MSES College of Education, Karur District-639005, Tamilnadu
             B.Ed
        MSES College of        MSES College of Education, 1st Floor, S.F.No. 721,
        Education, Karur       Thanthantrimalai, Karur District-639005, Tamilnadu has submitted
              TN               an application for seeking grant of recognition for B.Ed course on
                               02.01.2006. The application was processed and recognition to the
                               institution for B.Ed course was granted for annual intake of 100
                               students on 13.11.2006.

                               An RTI query from Shri. V.C. Ravi Chandran has been received
                               through NCTE-Hqrs on 02.09.2010 in which RTI applicant has
                               informed that the college run by the society MSES is running the
                               college without any own building and land and basic infrastructure
                               for more than four years and sought for action.

                               In view of the above, the application file of above institution has been
                               scrutinized and observed that recognition order has been issued on
                               13.11.2006 to the address as mentioned in rent deed.




     (Gangadharaiah)                                                         (Prof. C. Thangamuthu)
Regional Director, SRC, NCTE                                                  Chairman, SRC, NCTE
                                                 160
                                                                                              st
                                                                                  Minutes-201 Meeting of SRC
                                                                                           22-23 February 2011
                               Recognition has been granted subject to fulfillment of following
                               conditions among others, The institution shall shift to its own
                               premises or building within three years from the date of recognition
                               (if the course is started in rented premises). As per the rent deed
                               submitted by institution they have started institution in a rented
                               premises at S.F.No.721, No.13, 1st Floor, Thanthantrimalai, Karur.
                               But so far the institution has not informed about shifting to
                               permanent building and not submitted fee of Rs.40000/- for causing
                               inspection for shifting.

                               The Committee in its 197th meeting held on 13th-14th October 2010
                               considered all the relevant documentary evidences and decided to
                               serve Showcause Notice Under Section 17 of NCTE Act for the
                               following –

                                The institution was given recognition on 13.11.2006 in temporary rented
                                 premises and as per the NCTE Norms the institution should have shifted
                                 to the New building/premises within the stipulated period of 3 years
                                 i.e.,on or before 12.11.2009. But till now the institution has not informed
                                 to SRC-NCTE about the shifting schedule to new building / premises nor
                                 submitted fee of Rs. 40000/- for causing inspection for shifting.
                                The Management has not shifted to its own building / Premises even
                                 after the lapse of more than 4 years period.

                               Accordingly, show cause notice was issued to the institution on
                               08.12.2010 to submit reply within 30 days. The reply from the
                               institution has not been received so far. SRC considered the matter
                               in its 200th meeting held on 20th-21st January 2011 and decided to
                               issue final showcause notice.

                               Meanwhile the institution vide letter dated 06.01.2010 stated as
                               follows:

                               “I wish to inform you that in the aforesaid show cause notice, you
                               have informed us that one Sri V.C. Ravichandran has raised a query
                               through RTI on 02.09.2010 that our college, namely MSES College
                               of Education is running without building and land and basic
                               infrastructure.

                               I wish to inform you that the afore said allegation is totally incorrect
                               and false and I request you give me a copy of the complaint from Sri.
                               V.C. Ravichandran dt.2.9.2010. You have informed me that I should
                               give a reply within 30 days. I request you to give me a copy of the
                               complaint for me to give an effective reply to you and the copy is
                               necessary for giving you a reply in this regard.

                               The committee considered the matter and decided that the
                               request of the institution be complied with.




     (Gangadharaiah)                                                            (Prof. C. Thangamuthu)
Regional Director, SRC, NCTE                                                     Chairman, SRC, NCTE
                                                 161
                                                                                           st
                                                                                Minutes-201 Meeting of SRC
                                                                                         22-23 February 2011
124.        APS04037           Sree Narayana Educational Guidance Society,Pondicherry has
              D.T.Ed           submitted an application to Southern Regional Committee For grant
          Sree Narayana        of Recognition to Sree Narayana Teacher Training Institute Mahe-
       Educational Guidance    673310 Pondichery for D.T.Ed course of two years duration on
       Society, Pondicherry    30.12.2004. the Southern Regional Committee, after considering the
                PO             report of the Visiting team as well as other relevant materials
                               granted recognition to the Institution for offering D.T.Ed course with
                               an intake of 50 students vide order no.F.PN/ELE/SRO/NCTE/2005-
                               06/3492 dated 18.10.2005.

                               The office of SRC has received a complaint against the institution,
                               Which was placed before SRC in its 156th meeting held on 26th& 27th
                               march 2008. The committee after careful consideration of all aspects
                               decided to send the facts Finding committee. Accordingly an
                               inspection of the institution was carried out on 2.5.2008 by the fact
                               finding committee. The inspection report, VCD and other related
                               documents were placed before SRC in its 159th meeting held on 23rd
                               and 24th July 08. SRC decided to issue show cause notice under sec
                               17 of NCTE Act, 1993 on the following reasons:-
                                The Institution does not have land at one place. The management
                                 created play facilities little far away from the institution.
                                The Temporary accommodation wherein the teacher training institute
                                 permitted is not suitable for running the teacher education programme.
                                Technically he permanent building is not sufficient to run both B.Ed and
                                 D.Ed Programmes.
                                The new building constructed measuring 28 cents is less than 1500 sq.
                                 mtrs.
                                The society claims to have procured required land elsewhere in Mahe
                                 which is not suitable as per NCTE norms & standards.

                               A show cause notice was issued to the institution on 4.8.2008. The
                               Institution has not submitted reply, even after the stipulated period of
                               30 days Already over on 30.9.2008. The matter was placed before
                               SRC in its 165th meeting Held on 27th and 28th September 2008
                               wherein SRC decided to conduct inspection Under section 17 of
                               NCTE Act. 1993. The decision taken by SRC-NCTE the inspection of
                               the Institution under section 17 of NCTE Act was carried out on
                               31.10.2008 The visiting Team report was placed before SRC in its
                               168th meeting held on 15th December 2008.

                               The SRC after careful consideration of all aspects of all decided to
                               serve show cause Notice under section 17 of NCTE Act, 1993.

                               1. The society has procured land at different places stretched over at
                               different places as the following:

                                 . Rs. No.25/7-4 Cents
                                 . Rs. No. 8/2, SS 7-10, 1 acres 16 cents
                                 . Rs. No.25/7B, 25/6-24 Cents
                                 . Rs. No. 76.5-50 cents




     (Gangadharaiah)                                                          (Prof. C. Thangamuthu)
Regional Director, SRC, NCTE                                                   Chairman, SRC, NCTE
                                                 162
                                                                                             st
                                                                                  Minutes-201 Meeting of SRC
                                                                                           22-23 February 2011
                               2. Lease cum rental building –total land 1 acre 24 cents
                               3. The B.Ed. college has been running in own building and TTC in rented
                               building
                               4. The B.Ed. college is functioning in a building constructed on 28 cents of
                               land. The D.T.Ed course was recognized in 2005 and three years period
                               has lapsed. But, this course is being run in a lease cum rented building. As
                               per NCTE regulations.       The institution has to be shifted to permanent
                               premises within three years.
                               5. The Website of the institution is not functional.
                               6. The Furniture is not suitable for D.T.Ed course.

                               In this regard show cause notice was issued to the institution on
                               3.2.2009.The Institution has submitted reply on 3.3.2009. The written
                               representation was placed Before SRC in its 171st meeting held on
                               16th and 17th March 2009.The committee Decided to withdraw the
                               recognition for the following reasons:-

                                The D.T.Ed course was recognized on 18.10.2005 with a condition to
                                 ensure that the permanent building is constructed within a period of
                                 three years on the acquired land, whereas the institution even after
                                 expiry of three years, has not constructed any building for D.T.ED
                                 course and thus violated the conditions prescribed by NCTE .
                                The building is not adequate for the B.Ed and D.T.Ed course.
                                The institution has constructed the building in the site area of 28 cents.
                                 The land Area is less than 2500 sq.mts as per the norms & standards.
                                Adequate furniture were not found during the course of inspection.
                                Website of the institution is not created.

                               As per direction of Regional committee the recognition accorded to
                               Sree Narayana Teacher Training Institute, Mahe-673310,
                               Pondicherry to D.T.Ed course was Withdrawn.

                               The committee also decided to withdraw the recognition for B.Ed
                               course of the Institution from the academic session 2009-2010.
                               However, the ongoing batch of Students to complete their course
                               the (the students admitted in 2008-09 be allowed to continue and
                               pursue the course upto 2009-10 in order to complete the course)
                               and directed to not make any fresh admissions subsequent to the
                               withdrawal Order. The withdrawal order issued on 09.04.2009.

                               The institution approached to Appellate Authority, wherein the
                               appellate authority has passed order no 89-560/2009/Appeal dated
                               07.09.2009 as under:-

                               “After perusal of documents memorandum of appeal affidavit, VT Report
                               and after hearing oral argument advanced during hearing the council
                               reached the conclusion that there was no ground to accept the appeal and
                               that it should be rejected accordingly, the appeal was rejected and SRC’s
                               order dated 09.04.2009 was conformed.”




     (Gangadharaiah)                                                            (Prof. C. Thangamuthu)
Regional Director, SRC, NCTE                                                     Chairman, SRC, NCTE
                                                  163
                                                                                               st
                                                                                   Minutes-201 Meeting of SRC
                                                                                            22-23 February 2011
                               The institution approached to Hon‟ble High court of Judicature at
                               Madras wherein the High court passed order dated 05.10.2009. The
                               operative part of orders as under-
                               ”Even if reasons are not given as statutory appellate Authority, there must
                               be some inference from the reading of the order of the Appellate Authority
                               that it has applied its mind, taking note of the various grounds raised by the
                               appellant in the grounds of appeal. In the absence of such application of
                               mind certainly, it is open to this court to interfere to set right the wrong
                               committed by the statutory appellate Authority.

                               It is no doubt true that at the time of inspection the petitioner was having a
                               duty to prove that the conditions are complied with. But, in the present
                               case, when inspection was done within the period of three years there is no
                               possibility for the petitioner prove the same, because the petitioner had
                               still five more months time. When that issue was raised before the appellate
                               Authority, the Appellate Authority, in my considered view, ought to have
                               considered the said aspect along with inspection committee report dated
                               03.05.2008.

                               As such view of the matter, the impugned orders of the respondents are set
                               aside. The writ petition stands allowed, however with liberty to the second
                               respondent to conduct fresh inspection through its team and find out as to
                               whether the conditions imposed while granting recognition on 18.10.2005
                               have been complied with and pass appropriate orders after giving
                               opportunity to the petitioner.”

                               In this regard NCTE HQ has directed in letter no 64-
                               206/2009/NCTE/Legal/A52253 dated 3rd Nov, 2009 to implement the
                               directions of the Hon‟ble High Court. The matter was placed in 185th
                               meeting of SRC, which was held on 26-27th Nov, 2009 wherein the
                               Regional Committee decided to cause Re-inspection. As directed by
                               Regional Committee the re-inspection of the institution was
                               conducted on 15.12.2009.

                               The Committee considered the above facts as well as Court
                               directions in 188th meeting held on 28-29 January 2010 and decided
                               to call for Clarification from the institution on the following:-
                                   1. Original Registered document showing that the Land and Building
                                      are at the same place should be submitted for verification.
                                   2. Building Plan approved by the Competent authority/Civic agency is
                                      to be submitted.
                                   3. Building Completion Certificate(in the prescribed format) is to be
                                      submitted.
                                   4. Coursewise details of space allocation to be submitted.
                                   5. Lack of space of students in the Science Lab.
                                                                                           rd
                                   6. Specify the type of roof (whether asbestos) in the 3 floor which is
                                      used as Auditorium/Seminar Hall.

                               The institution has submitted clarification reply dated 23.03.2010.




     (Gangadharaiah)                                                             (Prof. C. Thangamuthu)
Regional Director, SRC, NCTE                                                      Chairman, SRC, NCTE
                                                  164
                                                                                            st
                                                                                 Minutes-201 Meeting of SRC
                                                                                          22-23 February 2011
                                The Committee in its 190th meeting held on 29-30 March 2010
                                considered the reply of the institution and decided to withdraw
                                recognition of the D.T.Ed. course on the following grounds:-
                                 Temporary structure in the top floor with PVC/Metal sheet which is a
                                  temporary structure which cannot be considered suitable/permanent for
                                  an educational programme as per NCTE norms.
                                 The remaining concrete structure as per Building Completion Certificate
                                  is 20,640.09 sq.ft. which is adequate only to offer B.Ed. programme and
                                  also B.Ed. Additional unit.
                                 The withdrawal of D.T.Ed. course takes effect from the end of academic
                                  session 2010-11, to enable the ongoing batch of students to complete
                                  their course (the students admitted in 2009-10 be allowed to continue
                                  and pursue the course upto 2010-11 in order to complete the course)
                                  and the institution is directed not to make any fresh admissions
                                  subsequent to the withdrawal Order.

                                Institution requested in its letter dated 01.02.2011 to return the
                                original documents submitted on 22.03.2010.

                                The committee considered the matter and decided that the
                                request of the institution be complied with and to keep a copy
                                of the document.

125.        SRCAPP241           Chaitanya Telgu Pandit College for recognition to the TPT Course
                TPT             for the academic year 2011-12 ..reg.
               M.Ed
       Chaitanya TPT College,   This office is in receipt of the application dated 29.09.10 and
          Visakhapatnam         01.11.10 submitted by the institution for starting TPT and M.Ed
                 AP             course for the session 2011-2012. It is ascertained that after
                                scrutiny of your application in accordance with clause 8 (2) and 8(3)
                                of NCTE Regulation 2009, that :-

                                “In the first instance an institution shall be considered for grant of
                                recognition of only one course for the basic unit as prescribed in the
                                norms and standards for the particular teacher education
                                programme”.

                                “An institution can apply for one basic unit only of an additional
                                course or for an additional unit of the existing recognised course
                                after completion of three academic session of the respective course,
                                for which the institution shall submit application before the cut of date
                                prescribed for submission of applications in the year succeeding the
                                completion of three academic sessions”.




     (Gangadharaiah)                                                           (Prof. C. Thangamuthu)
Regional Director, SRC, NCTE                                                    Chairman, SRC, NCTE
                                                  165
                                                                                          st
                                                                               Minutes-201 Meeting of SRC
                                                                                        22-23 February 2011

                               Institution has submitted two applications for TPT and M.Ed course
                               for the session 2011-2012. As per NCTE Regulation 2009
                               reproduced above, an institution shall be considered for grant of
                               recognition of only one course for the basic unit as prescribed in the
                               norms and standards for the particular teacher education
                               programme.

                               In this regard a letter was issued to the institution on 16.11.2010 with
                               requested      to immediately inform the name of course your
                               institution wants, to run immediately for further processing and
                               consideration. As per regulation 2009 (8 (2)) and 8 (3) an institution
                               cannot apply for more than one course at one time.

                               In response to this office letter dated 16.11.2010 the institution has
                               informed vide letter dated 18.11.2010 that to consider our application
                               for TPT only.

                               At the perusal of the file the institution has submitted photo copy of
                               processing fee of Rs. 40,000/-. SRC office was written a letter to the
                               applicant institution on 03.12.2010 with request to submit the
                               processing fee for Rs. 40,000/- immediately for further course of
                               action.

                               Institution not submitted application fee till 07.01.2011 after 34 days.
                               The office returned and reject the application to the applicant
                               institution on 10.01.2010 due to non submission of processing fee. A
                               letter was also issued on 24.01.2011 to applicant institution on
                               24.01.2011 with request to send the duplicate demand draft for the
                               same denomination immediately for the needful.

                               The institution has submitted draft of 40,000/- vide no. 9043532
                               dated 23.09.2010 alongwith application in response to SRC letter
                               dated 24.01.2011.
                                        ,
                                In the first instance the following deficiency are observed.

                               1. Building completion certificate:- The institution has not submitted
                                  building completion certificate. Hence the institution is required to
                                  submit Building completion certificate issued by local civil
                                  authority/Govt Engineer




     (Gangadharaiah)                                                         (Prof. C. Thangamuthu)
Regional Director, SRC, NCTE                                                  Chairman, SRC, NCTE
                                                 166
                                                                                          st
                                                                               Minutes-201 Meeting of SRC
                                                                                        22-23 February 2011
                               2. Notarized copy of Change of land use Certificate issued by the
                                  competent authority - The institution has not submitted land use
                                  certificate . Hence the institution is required to submit notarized
                                  copy of CLU (Agriculture lands -conversion of Non - Agricultural
                                  purpose) issued by Revenue Department.

                               3. Affidavit in the prescribed form on Rs 100/ stamp paper duly
                                  attested by oath commissioner or Notary public, stating the
                                  precise location of the land (village, district, state etc) the total
                                  area in possession, the permission of the competent authority to
                                  use the land for educational purpose and mode of possession
                                  i.e. ownership or lease :- The institution has submitted affidavit
                                  of Rs 100/- stamp paper duly attested by oath commissioner or
                                  Notary public but it not clear the land is own or lease basis.
                                  Hence the institution is required to submit affidavit of Rs 100/-
                                  stamp paper in all respect.

                               4. Certified copy of the registered land documents issued by the
                                  competent authority :- The institution has submitted certified copy
                                  of land document by sub-Registrar, Lankelapalem, Andhra
                                  pradesh. As per land records the sale deed in favour of
                                  Peesapati Suryanarayana Reddy, aged 43 years, son of
                                  Peesapati Venkata Reddy, Secretary, Annapurna Educational
                                  and Charitable Society, C/o Chaitanya Public School, Sector-11,
                                  Visakhapatnam-32. It seems the land is individual name.

                               As per MIS SRC has granted recognition for B.Ed Course to
                               Chaitanya College of Education for B.Ed course on 22.08.2008 for
                               100 student and as per online application courses commence from
                               24.09.2010 (CP-194/C in the file) . Now the institution has submitted
                               an application for TPT course for session 2011-12. The institution
                               has not completed three academic years at the time of making of
                               application for proposal of additional course i.e TPT which is against
                               the clause 8 (3) of Regulation 2009.

                               Hence the file is put up for further direction whether deficiency letter
                               to be issued or proposal be returned and rejected as above point no.
                               4 and 5. In the instant application state Govt. ref not sent to the
                               concerned state Govt.

                               The committee considered the matter and decided that the
                               institution is not eligible to apply and be rejected.




     (Gangadharaiah)                                                         (Prof. C. Thangamuthu)
Regional Director, SRC, NCTE                                                  Chairman, SRC, NCTE
                                                 167
                                                                                         st
                                                                              Minutes-201 Meeting of SRC
                                                                                       22-23 February 2011
126.           ----            Masters college of Education, R.S NO. 316/2, Plot. No. 8-252/5,
             M.Ed              Village – Tetali, Post- Tetali, West Godawari Distt, Andhrapradesh
        Master College of      Manged by Krishnaveni Educational Society, 402, Tirumala Towers,
        Education, West        Tanuka Vari Street , West Godavari - 534211 Andhra Pradesh for
           Godavari            the M.Ed Course for the academic year 2011-12.
               AP
                               Reference the application dated NIL received in SRC on 30.09.2010
                               for seeking recognition of M.Ed course for the session 2011-2012.

                               As per the new Regulation, 2009 the application may be essentially
                               submitted electronically through on-line mode available on the
                               website of National Council for Teacher Education along with the
                               processing fee. However, while submitting the application through
                               on-line mode, the application and requisite documents in triplicate
                               shall have to be submitted or sent by registered post separately to
                               the office of the Regional Committee concerned, immediately after
                               on-line    submission     of    the    application   along     with
                               acknowledgement/receipt of on line submission.

                               Since, the institution not submitted application through online, the
                               application submitted by the institution for M.Ed course was
                               returned herewith along with Demand Draft bearing Nos. 441433 &
                               441432 dated. 29.09.2010 for Rs. 1000/- & 40000/-. Respectively on
                               07.10.10.

                               The institution has approached to Hon‟ble High Court in Writ
                               Petition no. 34861/2010 in 27289/2010 without appeal to NCTE
                               Head Quarters in the matter of Krishnaveni Educational Society Vs
                               The Chairman NCTE Hq and Regional Director, SRC, NCTE. The
                               institution has submitted application for M.Ed course alongwith court
                               order. In this Writ petition the Hon‟ble High court has ordered as
                               under:-

                               “on instructions , it is submitted by the learned standing counsel that
                               the respondents have received the hard copy of the applications
                               from the petitioner, seeking permission to establish M.Ed College,
                               which is also acknowledged by the respondents on 30.09.2010
                               alongwith the requisite fee for processing the applications.

                               In that view of the matter, there shall be interim‟s directions as
                               prayed for.

                               As per perusal of the file in the    first instance the institution not
                               submitted NAAC certificate.

                               The Committee considered the matter along with other relevant
                               documents and decided to process the application as per court
                               directions, subject to fulfilment of norms of NCTE.




     (Gangadharaiah)                                                         (Prof. C. Thangamuthu)
Regional Director, SRC, NCTE                                                  Chairman, SRC, NCTE
                                                 168
                                                                                           st
                                                                                Minutes-201 Meeting of SRC
                                                                                         22-23 February 2011
127.        SRCAPP368            The following institutions have submitted application for seeking
            SRCAPP348            grant of recognition of B.El.Ed programe for the session 2011-12
               B.El.Ed
       Clarification regarding   1. Joseph Yuva College of Educaiton, Plot no. 413/e1, Village-
               B.El.Ed              Kapugallu, Post- kodad, Taluka- Kodad, Distt- Nalgonda,
       programme/Innovative         Andhara Pradesh.
                course
                  AP             2. The Cresent College of Education, Survey no. 524, Village-
                                    Gorrekuta, Post- Janpak, Taluka- Geesugonda, Distt- Warangal,
                                    Andhdra Pradesh

                                 On scrutiny of application of the above institutions with reference to
                                 NCTE Norms and Regulation 2009 it is observed that built up area
                                 and total area is not mentioned in the NCTE Norms and standard of
                                 2009..

                                        In this regard a letter was issued to the Member Secretary on
                                 11.11.10 and 13.12.2010 with request to inform the norms for the
                                 above course i.e B.ElEd for further processing of above applications
                                 and also matter may kindly be treated as urgent as processing of
                                 B.El.Ed programme would held up for want of above norms and
                                 standards.

                                        In response to this letter No. 49-1/2010/NCTE/N&S dated
                                 17.01.2011 NCTE Hq has directed that the Norms Committee has
                                 examined the issue of four year integrated courses and a sub
                                 Committee of experts who have worked in Regional Institute of
                                 Education has been constituted to develop the norms & Standards
                                 for the course within a considerable time. Further NCTE Head
                                 Quarters has requested to take action as per the norms for B.El.Ed
                                 course already notified in the NCTE Regulation, 2009.

                                           As per regulation 2009 stated in r/o Norms for Space as
                                 under:-
                                          “Where teacher education is provided through a
                                 Department/college as an integral part of a University/institution
                                 having several Faculties and Departments of Studies, all Central
                                 facilities/amenities are to be shared between the Department of
                                 Elementary Education and other Departments. In the case of
                                 laboratories and workshops, necessary additional provisions need
                                 be made so that the B.ElEd students can make use of them. Apart
                                 from the Central Library of the University/College, a Departmental
                                 Library may also be developed to cater to the special needs of the
                                 B.ElEd students. The Resource Laboratory should be equipped with
                                 adequate reading material alongwith equipment needed for
                                 Pedagogy-based practicum and other School Contract Programmes.
                                 Amenities such as Auditorium Hall, Conference Rooms, etc could be
                                 shared with other departments”.




     (Gangadharaiah)                                                          (Prof. C. Thangamuthu)
Regional Director, SRC, NCTE                                                   Chairman, SRC, NCTE
                                                    169
                                                                                         st
                                                                              Minutes-201 Meeting of SRC
                                                                                       22-23 February 2011
                               In the two applications received in SRC, the Institutions proposing to
                               start B.ElEd programme are new and no proof of running any other
                               programme is available. Hence no sharing of central
                               facilities/amenities, common space etc as specified in the Regulation
                               2009 for B.ElEd is possible.

                               Therefore a letter was also issued to NCTE Head Quarters on
                               28.01.2011 to guide us in the absence of specific norms for
                               infrastructure facilities like built up area space etc. SRC is not in a
                               position to process the applications further. However the reply of the
                               same is being awaited from HQtrs. As such no deficiency letter could
                               be issued for this application.

                               The committee considerd the matter and decided to await
                               guidelines from NCTE, Hqrs.

128.              ---          Letter from Higher Education (E1) Department regarding
                  ---          regulating growth of teacher education institutions
         Letter from Higher
          Educattion (E1)
       Department regarding    A letter dated 31.01.2011 has been received on 03.02.2011 from
        regulating growth of   higher Education Department informing in respect of starting of new
         teacher education     colleges of education, the State Government is of the view that no
             institutions      further College of Education need to be sanctioned in Tamilnadu for
                  TN           the year 2011-2012 and therefore, you are requested not to give
                               recognition for any new college of education.

                               In respect of B.P.Ed and M.P.Ed colleges, the state Government is
                               of the view that the new B.P.Ed and M.P.Ed colleges may be
                               granted approval for the year 2011-2012, since there are less
                               number of physical education colleges now functioning in the state.

                               However as per Public Notice dt 29.7.2010 issued by NCTE-Hqrs for
                               D.P.Ed and B.P.Ed it is stated that application will not be accepted
                               and further the application for 2011-12 are closed on 01.10.2010.

                               The committee considered the matter and decided to seek
                               clarification from State Government whether the lifting of ban is
                               for just one year i.e. 2011-12 or with effect from 2011-12.




     (Gangadharaiah)                                                         (Prof. C. Thangamuthu)
Regional Director, SRC, NCTE                                                  Chairman, SRC, NCTE
                                                 170
                                                                                                       st
                                                                                        Minutes-201 Meeting of SRC
                                                                                                 22-23 February 2011

129. Status of application returned/closed/rejected in SRC for the session 2011-2012 due to Ban and
     other reasons

STATE- ANDHARA PRADESH
  Sl     File No             Name of the Society                       Name of the College                   Course
 No
1.     SRCAPP395    Dr S A Rawoof Educational Society        Ameena Rawoof College of Education             B.Ed
                    4/130, Chandbada, Nandyal, Kurnool-      147/3, Chabolu Road, Rythunagar,
                    518501, AndhraPradesh                    Nandyal, Kurnool-518502,
                                                             AndhraPradesh.
2.     SRCAPP424    CVS Krishna Murthy Theja Charities       CVS Krishna Theja College of Education         M.Ed
                    131, Chadalawada Nagar, Daminedu,        131, #1, Daminedu, Settipalli,Tirupati,
                    Settipalli, Tirupati, Chittoor-517506,   Chittoor-517506, AndhraPradesh
                    AndhraPradesh
3.     SRCAPP351    St Marys educational Society             JMJ College of Education,                      B.Ed
                    P No-1-40/1, Thimmaraopet, VPO-          P No-71, VPO- Thimmaraopet,Taluka-
                    Thimmaraopet, Taluka-Chennaraopet,       Chennaraopet,Dist Warangal-506332,
                    City-Narsampet, Dist-Warangal-506332,    Andhra Pradesh
                    Andhra Pradesh
4.     SRCAPP280    Sri Bhadravathi Bhavana Rushi            Sumourya HPT College                           HPT
                    Charitable Trust                         P.No-180/1 180/2, Nh-18, B, Tandrapadu
                    P.No-180/1 ,180/2, Nandyal Road,         Vill, P.O- Nanur, Dist-Kurnool-518007,
                    VPO- B. Tandrapadu, Kallur Taluka,       Andhra Pradesh
                    Dist Kurnool-518007, Andhra Pradesh
5.     SRCAPP324    Azeezia Educational and Welfare          Azeezia College of Education for Women         B.Ed
                    Socirty                                  S.No 337, Manyamchal, Nalgonda-
                    5-8-75, Manyam Chalka, Nalgonda-         508001, AndhraPradesh.
                    508001, AndhraPradesh.
6.     SRCAPP384    Benaiah Christian Educational Society    Jeremiah College of Education                  DLEd
                    II Floor, Sathya Surya Complex,          673,673, Street No.1, Burugupudi,
                    Dwarakanagar, Vishakhapatnam-            Korukonda Mandal, East Godavari-
                    530016, AndhraPradesh.                   533292, AndhraPradesh
7.     SRCAPP298    Christian Educational Academy, P-No-     Dr.Samson College of Education, P-No-          B.Ed
                    778/A, Alice Nagar, Tarkupadu-VPO,       778/A, Alice Nagar, Tarkupadu-VPO,
                    Tarlupadu Mandal, Dist-Prakasam-         Tarlupadu Mandal, Dist-Prakasam-
                    523332, Andhra Pradesh.                  523332, Andhra Pradesh.
8.     SRCAPP432     Smt Lakshmamma and Srinivasula          V. C .R College of Education                   M.Ed
                    Reddy Educational Society                P.No-220/5, Mapakshi Vill, P.O
                    P.No-19-277, Reddy‟s Colony, VPO-        Reddigunta, Chittoor Taluka, Dist
                    Chittoor, Dist-Chittoor-517001, Andhra   Chittoor-517002, Andhra Pradesh
                    Pradesh
9.     SRCAPP311    Mohammadens Educational And              Mohammdens College of Elementary               DLEd
                    Welfare Society                          Education
                    S.No 369, Vuppuvagu, Gazinagar,          S.No 369, Vuppuvagu, Gazinagar,
                    Devarakonda, Nalgonda-508248,            Devarakonda, Nalgonda-508248,
                    AndhraPradesh                            AndhraPradesh
10.    SRCAPP383    Sri Sai Venkata Computer Educational     Sri Sai Venkata Hindi Maha Vidyalayam          HPT
                    Society                                  86/5, 898, Cherkupalli, Pundi, Nandigam,
                    898, Cherkupalli, Pundi, Nandigam,       Srikakulam-532218, AndhraPradesh
                    Srikakulam-532218, AndhraPradesh
11.    SRCAPP376    Malla Reddy Educational Society          CMR Institute of Elementary Teacher            DLED
                    294, Comssary Bazar, New                 Education
                    Bowenpally, Secunderabad,                S.No-563, Gundla Pochampally, Dundigal,
                    Hyderabad, RangaReddy-500011,            Secunderabad, RangaReddy-500055,
                    AndhraPradesh                            AndhraPradesh
12.    SRCAPP330    Neo Rayal Educational Society            RoyalCollege of Education                      B.Ed




     (Gangadharaiah)                                                                  (Prof. C. Thangamuthu)
Regional Director, SRC, NCTE                                                           Chairman, SRC, NCTE
                                                      171
                                                                                                    st
                                                                                      Minutes-201 Meeting of SRC
                                                                                               22-23 February 2011
                  Chevella,                                Dammergidda, Chavella,
                  Rangareddy-501503,                       Rangareddi-501503,
                  Andhra Pradesh                           Andhra Pradesh
13.   SRCAPP306   Mohammadens Educational & Welfare        Mohammadens College of Education for          B.Ed
                  Society, No.369,                         Women, No.369, Vuppu Vagu, Gazinagar,
                  Gazinagar,Devarakonda,Nalgonda-          Devarakonda, Nalgonda-508248, Andhra
                  508248, Andhra Pradesh                   Pradesh
14.   SRCAPP283   Ameeruddin Academy of general            Hazarath Ameeruddin College of                B.Ed
                  Technical & Professional Educational     Education
                  Society                                  903/1A, Yedavalli Village, Giddalur,
                  903/1A, Yedavalli Village, Giddalur,     Prakasam-523357, AndhraPradesh
                  Prakasam-523357, AndhraPradesh
15.   SRCAPP287   Ameeruddin Academy of General            Hazarath Ameerudin M.Ed College               M.Ed
                  Technical And Professional Educational   903/1A, Yedavalli, Giddalur, Prakasam-
                  Society                                  523357, AndhraPradesh.
                  903/1A, Yedavalli, Giddalur, Prakasam-
                  523357, AndhraPradesh.
16.   SRCAPP320   St Xaviers Educational Society           St. Xaviers College of Education              B.Ed
                  14-163, Lakshmi Nagar,                   14-163, Lakshminagar,
                  Chinamusidivada, Pendurthy,              Chinamusidivada,
                  Visakhapatnam-530051,                    Pendurthy,
                  Andhra Pradesh                           Visakhapatnam-530051,
                                                           Andhra Pradesh
17.   SRCAPP406   Islamia Educational Society              Asha College of Education                     DLEd
                  5-155C, Pattabhi Street,                 52/2, Yellapuram,
                  Markapuram,                              Markapuram,
                  Prakasam - 523316,                       Prakasam-523316,
                  Andhra Pradesh                           Andhra Pradesh
18.   SRCAPP243   Jeevana Prasannata Educational           Jeevana Manohar College of Education          B.Ed.
                  Society                                  R S No-35/4, Dantaguntla, Bapulapadu,
                  25-3-10, Siripurapuvari Street,          Krishna-520003, AndhraPradesh
                  Seethanna Pet, Vijayawada, Krishna-
                  520003, AndhraPradesh
19.   SRCAPP464   Vyjayanthi Educational Society           Sree Dattha Brindavan Institute of            M.Ed
                  54, Kavarampally Shivasingaram,          Teacher Education
                  Singaram, Narayanpet, Mahbubnagar-       54, Kavarampally Shivasingaram,
                  509210, AndhraPradesh                    Singaram, Narayanpet, Mahbubnagar-
                                                           509210, AndhraPradesh
20.   SRCAPP295   Residency Educational Society            Residency College of Elementary Teacher       DLEd
                  P.No-53/1, Thallapaka Cross Roads,       Education
                  VPO-Rajampet, Rajampet Taluka,           P.No-53/1, Thallapaka Cross Roads,
                  Kadapa Dist-516126, Andhra Pradesh       Village-New Boyanapalli, PO-Rajampet,
                                                           Rajampet Taluka, Kadapa Dist-516126,
                                                           Andhra Pradesh
21.   SRCAPP444   CVS Krishna Murthy Theja Charities       CVS Krishna Theja College of Education        DLEd
                  131, Chadalawada Nagar, Daminedu,        131, 3219/2000, #2, Daminedu, Settipalli,
                  Settipalli, Tirupati, Chittoor-517506,   Tirupati, Chittoor-517506, AndhraPradesh
                  AndhraPradesh
22.   SRCAPP367   Motati Nagi Reddy Memorial               Lakshmi Nagi Reddy H.P.T College,             HPT
                  Educational Society,                     P.No-181/A, Shanthinagar, Waddepally,
                  P.No-181/A, Kovildinne Road,             Alampur-Taluk, Dist-Mahabubnagar-
                  Shanthinagar, Waddepally, Alampur-       509144, Andhra Pradesh.
                  Taluk, Dist-Mahabubnagar-509144,
                  Andhra Pradesh.
23.   SRCAPP412   Pasha Educational Trust,                 Pasha College of Education,                   DLEd.
                  No.8-2-672, Banjara Hills, Shaikpet,     No. 8-2-672, Banjara Hills, Shaikpet,
                  Hyderabad-500003, Andhra Pradesh         Hyderabad-500003, Andhra Pradesh
24.   SRCAPP459   Vyjayanthi Educational Society           Brindavan Institute for Teacher Education     M.Ed
                  Seriguda, Ibrahimpatnam,                 1242, 373, 374, Seriguda, Ibrahimpatnam,
                  RangaReddy-501510, AndhraPradesh         RangaReddy-501510,




     (Gangadharaiah)                                                                (Prof. C. Thangamuthu)
Regional Director, SRC, NCTE                                                         Chairman, SRC, NCTE
                                                     172
                                                                                                     st
                                                                                      Minutes-201 Meeting of SRC
                                                                                               22-23 February 2011
                                                           AndhraPradesh
25.   SRCAPP353   MJR Educational Society, No.2-8,         MJR College of Elementary Education,           D.E.C.Ed.
                  M.D.O office Road, Marriguda,            Marriguda, Nalgonda, Andhra Pradesh
                  Nalgonda-508245, Andhra Pradesh

26.   SRCAPP203   Konaseema Women Integrated               Raghava TPT                                    DLED
                  Development Society                      K.No 503-11, P.No-9-122, Road-
                  P.No-9-122, Road-Gowtaminagar,           Gowtaminagar, VPO-Kothapeta, Taluka
                  VPO-Kothapeta, Taluka Kothapeta,         Kothapeta, Dist- E.G-533223, Andhra
                  Dist- E.G-533223, Andhra Pradesh         Pradesh
27.   SRCAPP387   Little Flower Educational Society        Little Flower College of Education             B.Ed
                  Suncity, Hydershakote,                   Suncity, Hydershakote,
                  Rajendra Nagar,                          Rajendra Nagar,
                  Hyderabad-500008,                        Hyderabad-500008,
                  Andhra Pradesh                           Andhra Pradesh
28.   SRCAPP272   Hazarat Syed Gousalazam Dastageer        Loyala College of Education                    B.ED.
                  Peeran-E-Peer Educational Society        8&9, 1, Yapral, JJ Nagar, Malkajgiri,
                  8&9, Patel Enclave, Yapral, JJ Nagar,    Secunderabad, RangaReddy-500087,
                  Malkajgiri, Secunderabad,                AndhraPradesh
                  RangaReddy-500087, AndhraPradesh
29.   SRCAPP375   St Martins Educational Society           MR Institute of Elementary Teacher             DLEd
                  294, Comssary Bazar, New                 Education
                  Bowenpally, Balanagar, Secunderabad,     563, Gundla Pochampally, Dundigal,
                  RangaReddy-500011,                       Secunderabad, RangaReddy-500055,
                  AndhraPradesh                            AndhraPradesh
30.   SRCAPP402   Deccan Educational Society               Abdul Kalam College of Education Muslim        B.Ed
                  7-76, Near Bus stand, Kotagiri,          Minority Institution
                  Nizamabad-503207, AndhraPradesh.         N S Road, Lingapur, Kamareddy,
                                                           Nizamabad-503207, AndhraPradesh
31.   SRCAPP217   Churches of Christ in Social Action      Smt BSR PG college of Education                M.Ed
                  P.No-9-39, Christian Street, Kattamuru   P.No-1-118, Gokavaram VPO,
                  VPO, Peddapuram Taluka, East             Gokavaram Taluka, East Godavari Dist-
                  Godavari Dist-533, Andhra Pradesh        533286, Andhra Pradesh
32.   SRCAPP372   St Martins Educational Society           MR Institute of Teacher Education              B.Ed
                  294, Comssary Bazar, New                 S.No-563, Gundla Pochampally, Dundigal,
                  Bowenpally, Secunderabad,                Secunderabad, RangaReddy-500055,
                  Hyderabad, RangaReddy-500011,            AndhraPradesh
                  AndhraPradesh
33.   SRCAPP169   Ameenpeer Muslim Minority                Ameenpeer College of Education,                B.Ed.
                  Educational Society,                     P.NO-15/1452, VPO-Tadiparti, Taluka-
                  P.NO-15/1452, VPO-Tadiparti, Taluka-     Tadipatri, Dist-Anantpur-515411, Andhra
                  Tadipatri, Dist-Anantpur-515411,         Pradesh.
                  Andhra Pradesh.
34.   SRCAPP389   Gods Foundation Nursing Educational      Sri Balaji College of Education                M.Ed
                  Society                                  S.No-440-3A&B, Ponnutipalyam,
                  42, Doctors Colony, B Camp Post          Madanapalle, Chittoor-517325,
                  Office, Kurnool-518002, AndhraPradesh    AndhraPradesh
35.   SRCAPP380   Sir C V Raman Educational Society        Sir C V Raman M.Ed College                     M.Ed.
                                                                          rd
                  Gandhi Road, Tadpatri ,                  D.No.3/148, 3 Ward,
                  Anantpur-515411,                         Tadpatri,
                  Andhra Pradesh                           Anantapur-515411,
                                                           Andhra Pradesh
36.   SRCAPP238   Annapurna Educational Society            Chaitanya M.Ed College                         M.Ed
                  P.No-1A, Chaitanya Nagar, P S            P.No-1A, P S Bonangi VPO, Parwada
                  Bonangi Villade, Parwada P.O,            Mandal Taluka, Vishakhapatnam Dist-
                  Parwada Mandal Taluka,                   531021, Andhra Pradesh
                  Vishakhapatnam Dist-531026, Andhra
                  Pradesh
37.   SRCAPP228   Sampathi Educational Society,            Seshachala Venkata Subbaiah D.P.Ed             DPED
                  Puttur, Chittoor, Andhra Pradesh         College,




     (Gangadharaiah)                                                                (Prof. C. Thangamuthu)
Regional Director, SRC, NCTE                                                         Chairman, SRC, NCTE
                                                     173
                                                                                                     st
                                                                                      Minutes-201 Meeting of SRC
                                                                                               22-23 February 2011
                                                          Ippathangale, Narayanavanam, Puttur,
                                                          Chittoor, Andhra Pradesh.
38.   SRCAPP428   Nova Educational Society                Nova College of Elementary Education        DECED
                  315, Engineering College Road,          315, Jafferguda, Bata Singaram, Hayath
                  Jafferguda, Bata Singaram, Hayath       Nagar, Hyderabad, Rangareddy-501512,
                  Nagar, Hyderabad, Rangareddy-           AndhraPradesh
                  501512, AndhraPradesh
39.   SRCAPP266   St. Xaviers Educational Society         St. Xaviers College of Education                DLED
                  92/1, LakshmiNagar,                     92/1, 14-163, Lakshmi Nagar,
                  Chinamushidavada, Pendurthy,            Chinamushidavada, Pendurthy,
                  Visakhapatnam-530051,                   Visakhapatnam-530051, Andhrapradesh
                  Andhrapradesh
40.   SRCAPP460   Nagarjuna Educational Society           Vellanki Telugu Pandit Training College         TPT
                  11-6-7/1,2, Raghuram Nagar,             S.No.12, 11-6-7/1,2, Street No 6,
                  Vaddavalli, Sattenapalli, Guntur-       Vaddavalli, Sattenapalli, Guntur-522403,
                  522403, AndhraPradesh.                  AndhraPradesh.
41.   SRCAPP465   Nagarjuna Educational Society           Vellanki Hindi Pandit Training College          HPT.
                  11-6-7/1,2, Raghuram Nagar,             S.No.12, 11-6-7/1,2, Street No 6,
                  Sattenapalli, Guntur-522403,            Vaddavalli, Sattenapalli, Guntur-522403,
                  AndhraPradesh.                          AndhraPradesh.
42.   SRCAPP447   Nagarjuna Educational Society           Vellanki College of Education,                  M.ED
                  No-11-6-7/1,2                           No-11-6-7/1,2
                  Raghuram Nagar, Vaddavalli,             Vaddavalli, Sattenapalli, Guntur-522403,
                  Sattenapalli, Guntur-522403, Andhra     Andhra Pradesh.
                  Pradesh.
43.   SRCAPP430   Nova Educational Society                Mutthamsetty Venkata Narayana                   M.Ed
                  54-2, Engineering College Road,         Memorial College of Education
                  Vegavaram,                              54-2, Engineering College Road,
                  Jangareddygudem,                        Vegavaram,
                  West Godavari-534447,                   Jangareddygudem,
                  Andhra Pradesh                          West Godavari-534447,
                                                          Andhra Pradesh
44.   SRCAPP390   Islamia Educational Society             Kalam D.Ed College                              DED
                  10/101, Nadendlavari Street,            823, Kasipuram, Kanigiri,
                  Kanigiri, Prakasam-523230,              Prakasam-523230,
                  Andhra Pradesh                          Andhra Pradesh
45.   SRCAPP415   Muneeriqbal Educational Society         Madani College of Education                     B.Ed.
                  7-2-1075, Mankamma Thota,               7-3-43/1, Kashmir gadda, Karimnagar-
                  Karimnagar-505002, AndhraPradesh.       505002, AndhraPradesh
46.               Maharishi Educational Society,          Srinivasa College of Education, Puttur          MEd
                  SBI Colony, Puttur, Chittoor, Andhra    Village, Puttur Taluka, Dist Chittoor-
                  Pradesh                                 517583, Andhra Pradesh
47.               K.P Educational Society,                Ahmed institution of Elementary Teacher         DLEd
                  Pegadpally, Achanpally, Bodhan,         Education, achanpally, Shakarnagar,
                  Nizamabad, Andhra Pradesh.              Bodhan, Nizamabad, Andhra Pradesh.
48.               CSI Medak Diocesan Education            CSI College of Education,                       B.Ed
                  Society,                                1-14-42, Red Ridge Cathedral Compound,
                  Secunderabad, Andhra Pradesh.           Posy-Medak, Taluka-Medak, Dist-Medak-
                                                          502110, Andhra Pradesh.



49.               Christian Outreach Centre,                                                              DLEd
                  P.No-1-379, Village-Rayudupalem,
                  APSP Post, Taluka-Kakinada, Dist-East
                  Godavari, Andhra Pradesh.
50.               Navodaya Educational Society,                                                           B.Ed
                  P.No-24,25,26, Village-Uyyalawada,
                  Post-Nagarkurnool, Taluka-
                  Nagarkurnool, Dist-Mahabubnagar-




     (Gangadharaiah)                                                                (Prof. C. Thangamuthu)
Regional Director, SRC, NCTE                                                         Chairman, SRC, NCTE
                                                    174
                                                                                                       st
                                                                                        Minutes-201 Meeting of SRC
                                                                                                 22-23 February 2011
                    509209, Andhra Pradesh.
51.   SRCAPP355     Sri Sai Educational Society,                                                            DELED.
                    No.9/542/C, Sri As Nagar, RLY.Kodur,
                    Kadapa-516101, Andhra Pradesh.
52.   SRCAPP256     Rajavaram Educational Society,                                                          B.Ed
                    H.No,1-10-85/6/B/2, New Town,
                    Mahabubnagar, Andhra Pradesh.
53.   SRCAPP316     Srinivasa Educational and Rural                                                         M.Ed
                    Development Society,
                    6/601-11-B.Ed, Sankarapuram,
                    Kadapa-516001, Andhra Pradesh.
54.   SRCAPP314     Sankar Educational Society,                                                             DELEd
                    14/811, Sangampet Street, Kadapa-
                    515001, Andhra Pradesh.
55.   SRCAPP318     Kadiri Subbarayudu KSR Educational                                                      DELED
                    Society,
                    11/322, D.C.Road, Kadapa-516001,
                    Andhra Pradesh.
56.   SRCAPP253     YBR Educational Society,                                                                DELED
                    No.14-222, Haveli Ghanpur, Mirjalguda,
                    Medak-500047, Andhra Pradesh.
57.   SRCAPP310     Siddhartha Educational Academy,                                                         DED
                    No.19-8-150, Rayalaseema Nagar,
                    Bairagipatteda, Tirupati-517501, Andhra
                    Pradesh.
58.                 Krishnaveni Educational Society, 402,                                                   MED
                    Tirumala Towers, Tanuka Vari Street,
                    Tanuka, West Godavari-534211,
                    Andhra Pradesh.
59.   SRCAPP242     Gowthami Educational Society,                                                           BED
                    No.7-25-21, Tadepalligudem, West
                    Godavari-534101, Andhra Pradesh.
60.   SRCAPP204     Rayalaseema University, Kurnool,                                                        BED
                    Andhra Pradesh.                                                                         (Distance)
61.   SRCAPP252     YBR Educational Society,                                                                BED
                    No.14-222, Haveli Ghanpur, Mirjalguda,
                    Medak-500047, Andhra Pradesh.
62                  Institute of Advance Studies, Post-                                                     M.Ed
                    Kurnool, Distt- Kurnool Andhra Pradesh

 STATE OF KERALA


 Sl       File No              Name of the Society                      Name of the College                 Remarks
 No

1.                                                            Viswabharathi Pre-Primary Teacher             TTC
                                                              Training Institute,
                                                              Choorakode, Adoor, Kerala Dist-691551.
2.                     Kerala Educational and Charitable                                                    TTC
                       Society,
                       For Unemployed Ladies, 1932,
                       Erathu, Choorakode, Adoor, Kerala
                       Dist-691551.

The committee considered the matter and decided to ratify the same for the above institutions
of Andhra Pradesh and Kerala.




     (Gangadharaiah)                                                                  (Prof. C. Thangamuthu)
Regional Director, SRC, NCTE                                                           Chairman, SRC, NCTE
                                                      175
                                                                                                           st
                                                                                             Minutes-201 Meeting of SRC
                                                                                                      22-23 February 2011

130.               ---              List of the institution not submitted reply of deficiency letter
                   ---              after 60 days for the session 2011-12.
         List of institution not
          submitted reply to        The deficiency letter was issued to the applicant institution with
       deficiency letter after 60   direction as per sub-clause (1) of clause 7 of NCTE Regulation 2009,
         days for the session       the applicant institution is required to remove the mentioned
              2011-2012             deficiencies in the letter and submit the same to the SRC office
                   AP               along with all required documents within 60 days from the date of
                                    receipt of communication of deficiencies, failing which your
                                    application will be treated as rejected and closed.

                                    In case any of the deficiencies stated above still remain and are not
                                    removed within 60 days time, no extension to time will be granted
                                    and any submissions received after 60 days will be treated as invalid
                                    and not entertained.

                                    List of the institution who did not submit reply within expiry 60 days is
                                    enclosed.

                                    S.N    File     Name of Society            Name of the          Cour          Date of
                                     O    code                                   College             se          issue of
                                           No.                                                                  deficiency
                                          SRC                                                                      letter
                                          APP
                                     1    SRCA    Nova Educational          Nova College of         B.Ed        16.12.2010.
                                          PP429   Society                   Education
                                                  315, Engineering          315, Jafferguda, Bata
                                                  College Road,             Singaram, Hayath
                                                  Jafferguda, Bata          Nagar, Hyderabad,
                                                  Singaram, Hayath          Rangareddy-501512
                                                  Nagar, Hyderabad,         AndhraPradesh
                                                  Rangareddy-501512
                                                  AndhraPradesh
                                     2    SRCA    Ghouseperr Minorities     Sri Sai College of      B.Ed        16.12.2010
                                     *    PP328   Educational Society,      Education
                                                  521, Sai Nagar,           521, S. No, 38/160-6-
                                                  Buddayapalli, Kadapa-     5, Buddayapalli,
                                                  516002,                   Chinnachowk,
                                                  AndhraPradesh             Kadapa-516002,
                                                                            AndhraPradesh
                                     3    SRCA    Holy Cross Educational    Global Institute of     M.Ed        09.12.2010
                                          PP352   Society,                  Advanced Study in
                                                  P.No. 420/2,              Education,
                                                  Madanapalli Road,         P.No. 420/3&5A,
                                                  Melumoi, Palamaner,       420/5, Melumoi,
                                                  Gangavaram, Chittoor-     Palamaner,
                                                  517408, Andhra            Gangavaram,
                                                  Pradesh.                  Chittoor-517408,
                                                                            Andhra Pradesh.
                                     4    SRCA    Gajwel Minorities         Gajwel College of       D.Ed        09.12.2010
                                          PP411   Educational Society       Education
                                                  743/AA, 743/E, 743/E-2,   743/AA, 743/E,
                                                  Pamulaparthi Road,        743/E-2,
                                                  Pamulaparthi, Wargal,     Pamulaparthi Road,
                                                  Medak-502279,             Pamulaparthi, Wargal,
                                                  AndhraPradesh             Medak-502279,
                                                                            AndhraPradesh




     (Gangadharaiah)                                                                       (Prof. C. Thangamuthu)
Regional Director, SRC, NCTE                                                                Chairman, SRC, NCTE
                                                       176
                                                                                                       st
                                                                                         Minutes-201 Meeting of SRC
                                                                                                  22-23 February 2011
                               5    SRCA    SV Educational              Jesus College of        B.Ed        16.12.2010
                                    PP302   Development Society         Education
                                            5-58, Mittamedi Colony,     22, 5-58, 1, C S
                                            C S Puram, Prakasam-        Puram, Prakasam-
                                            523112, AndhraPradesh       523112,
                                                                        AndhraPradesh
                               6    SRCA    Besant Centenary Trust,     Rukmini Devi            M.Ed        09.12.2010
                                    PP304   Madanapalle, Chittoor-      Arundale College of
                                            517325, Andhra              Education, P.No.442-
                                            Pradesh                     1, Ponnutipalyam
                                                                        Village, Madanapalle,
                                                                        Chittoor-517325,
                                                                        Andhra Pradesh
                               7    SRCA    Johnson Educational         St John College of      B.Ed        07.12.2010
                                    PP296   Society                     education
                                            1-123, Baopet X Road,       69/A1, 70/A1 &
                                            Yellapur, Hasanparthy,      69/B/2, #1, Yellapur,
                                            Hanamkonda,                 Hasanparthy,
                                            Warangal-506371,            Hanamkonda,
                                            AndhraPradesh               Warangal-506371
                               8    SRCA    Berith          Christian   Hezekiah College of     B.Ed        09.12.2010
                                    PP341   Educational Society         Education
                                            II Floor, Dwarakanagar,     Ziroithi, Rajapulova,
                                            Visakhapatnam-530016,       Bhogapuram Mandal,
                                            Andhra Pradesh              Vizianagaram-
                                                                        531162,
                               9    SRCA    Gayatri Educational &       Lalitha College of      M.Ed        10.12.2010
                                    PP452   Cultural Trust,             education
                                            S.No 795, CVSR              S.No 795,
                                            College of Engineering,     Venkatapur,
                                            Venkatapur, sanskruthi      Ghatkesar,
                                            Township, Ghatkesar,        Hyderabad,
                                            RangaReddy-501301,          Rangareddy-501301,
                                            AndhraPradesh               AndhraPradesh
                               10   SRCA    Nova Educational            Nova College of         B.P.Ed      16.12.2010
                                    PP433   Society                     Physical Education
                                            54-2, Engineering           54-2, Vegavaram,
                                            College Road,               Jangareddygudem,
                                            Vegavaram,                  W.G-534447,
                                            Jangareddygudem,            AndhraPradesh
                                            W.G-534447,
                                            AndhraPradesh
                               11   SRCA    Sri Nidamanuri              QIS College of          M.Ed        09.12.2010
                                    PP313   Educational Society         education
                                            1, Pondur Road,             159, 100,
                                            Vengamukkapale,             Vengamukkapale,
                                            Ongole, Prakasam-           Ongole, Prakasam-
                                            523272, AndhraPradesh       523272,
                                                                        AndhraPradesh
                               12   SRCA    St. Mark Educational        Susheela College of     M.Ed        09.12.2010
                                    PP401   Institution Society         Education
                                            No.5, Bellary Road,         No.5, Rachanapalli,
                                            Rachanapalli,               Anantapur-515001,
                                            Anantapur-515001,           AndhraPradesh.
                                            AndhraPradesh.
                               13   SRCA    St Stephen Educational      Trinity College of      B.Ed        10.12.2010
                                    PP327   Society                     Education
                                            II Floor, SatyaSurya        139, P No 2, Street
                                            Complex,                    No 1,
                                            Dwarakanagar,               Singannabanda,
                                            Visakhapatnam-530016,       Tagarapuvalasa,
                                            AndhraPradesh               Bheemunipatnam,
                                                                        Vishakhapatnam-




     (Gangadharaiah)                                                                  (Prof. C. Thangamuthu)
Regional Director, SRC, NCTE                                                           Chairman, SRC, NCTE
                                                  177
                                                                                                         st
                                                                                         Minutes-201 Meeting of SRC
                                                                                                  22-23 February 2011
                               14    SRCA     Sister Niveditha           Sister Niveditha       B.Ed          06.12.2010
                                *    PP293    Educational Society        College of
                                              9-155/A, Sub Court         Education,
                                              Road, Gajwel, Medak-       No.203, Gajwel,
                                              502278,                    Medak-502278,
                                              AndhraPradesh              AndhraPradesh
                               15    SRCA     Priyanka Education         Abdul Kalam College    B.Ed          09.12.2010
                                     PP374    Society                    of Education
                                              D No 13/4/53/25,           D No 120/B, 001,
                                              Kotappakonda Road,         Jonnalagadda,
                                              Narasaraopet, Guntur-      Narasaraopet,
                                              522601, AndhraPradesh      Guntur-522601,
                               16    SRCA     Churches of Christ in      Smt BSR college of     D.El.E        07.12.2010
                                     PP216    Social Action              Elementary Education     d
                                              P.No-9-39, Christian       P.No-1-118,
                                              Street, Kattamuru VPO,     Gokavaram VPO,
                                              Peddapuram Taluka,         Gokavaram Taluka,
                                              East Godavari Dist-533,    East Godavari Dist-
                                              Andhra Pradesh             533286,
                               *The reply for Deficiency letter has been received on 21.02.2011 by hand in respect of
                               Sl.No.2 and 14 after the expiry of mandatory period.

                               The committee considerd the non-reply of the institution for DLI
                               even after lapse of stipulated time and decided to reject the
                               above applications.
                                               th                       nd   rd
131.             ----          SRC in its 199 meeting held on 22 -23 December 2010 decided to issue
                 ---           Show Cause Notice to the following institutions. In the Show Cause Notice
       Ratification cases of   Following deficiencies are added in the addition to the deficiencies
          199th meeting        mentioned in the minutes which may be ratified by SRC.
                               Sl.       Code                Name of the        Points added in the show
                 TN
                               No.      Course                institution               cause notice
                               1.    8509             Grace Teacher Training   Institution is running on
                                     D.T.Ed-AI        Institute, Kanyakumari   private leased land.
                               2.    8887             Grace         College of Institution is running on
                                     B.Ed             Education,               private leased land.
                                                      Kanyakumari
                               3.    3911             Grace Teacher Training Institution is running on
                                     D.T.Ed           Institute, Kanyakumari   private leased land.
                                As per decision of SRC in its 199 meeting, SRC rejected the
                                                                            th

                                   application of Annamalai University (SRCAPP75) for M.Ed-DE course
                                                                 th
                                   but as per minutes of 199 meeting The request of the management
                                   for extension of time to submit the lesson materials to NCTE and
                                   for DEC approval cannot be complied with. The unit may apply
                                   fresh after fulfilling the requisite requirements as per norms. SRC
                                   has not made any mention about rejection. Rejection order was issued
                                   to the university on 01.02.2011.

                                   APS06356-D.T.Ed, New Ideal, Trichy District agenda was placed
                                                         th
                                    before SRC in its 199 meeting and recognition was withdrawn as per
                                    decision of SRC on 02.02.2011. The district of the institution was
                                    mentioned as Tirunelveli instead of Trichy.

                               The committee considered the matter and decided to ratify
                               the same (additional deficiencies as indicated) for the
                               above institutions.



     (Gangadharaiah)                                                                   (Prof. C. Thangamuthu)
Regional Director, SRC, NCTE                                                            Chairman, SRC, NCTE
                                                    178
                                                                                                         st
                                                                                            Minutes-201 Meeting of SRC
                                                                                                     22-23 February 2011
132.          APS04925              Thozhilathibar Teacher Training Institute was granted recognition on
                 D.T.Ed             07.09.2006 for D.T.Ed course and for D.T.Ed-AI on 16.01.2008.
       Thozhilathibar Teacher
       Training Institute, Trichy   On the basis of Direction of MHRD to re-inspect all the institutions granted
                                                                   th
                                    recognition by SRC in its 116 meeting as per the recommendation of Sri.
                   TN
                                    Sathyam Committee reports. The inspection of the institution under section
                                    17 was carried out on 18.12.2008. Whereas, the institution has approached
                                    the Hon‟ble Court in WP.29977/2008. The matter was considered by SRC
                                               th                         th
                                    in its 170 meeting held on 16-17 February 2009 and decided to issue
                                    show cause notice, accordingly a show cause notice u/s 17. Accordingly a
                                    show cause notice was issued to the institution on 4.4.2009. The institution
                                    submitted its reply on 15.4.2009, the same was considered by SRC in its
                                         th                     th
                                    180 meeting held on 29 July 2009 and SRC decided to issue notice
                                    under section 17. Accordingly a show cause notice was issued to the
                                    institution on 01.09.2009. The institution submitted its reply on 26.10.09.

                                    SRC considered the written representation submitted by the institution and
                                    decided to continue the approval given to Thozhilathibar Teacher Training
                                    Institute (D.T.Ed, APS04925) and withdraw the recognition for of
                                    D.T.Ed.(APS08186) course for which the land/buildings/infrastructure are
                                    not available as per the norms, as inferred from the reply statements
                                    furnished by the institution.

                                    As per the decision of SRC, a letter of continued recognition in respect of
                                    Thozhilathibar TTI, Trichy District, Tamilnadu was issued to the institution
                                    for D.T.Ed course on 9.2.2010(APS04925) and withdrawal order was
                                    issued to the above mentioned institution on 9.2.2010 for D.T.Ed course.

                                    Meanwhile, a complaint dated 09.09.2010 was received from Hope
                                                                                          th                  th
                                    Foundation, which was considered by SRC in its 196 meeting held on 15
                                             th
                                    and 16 September, 2010. The committee considered the matter and
                                    decided to inform the complainant that he is free to seek legal remedy as it
                                    is a civil dispute.

                                    As per the decision of SRC, a letter vide no. F.SRO/NCTE/2010-
                                    2011/22528 dated 26.10.2010 was issued to the Chief Executive Officer,
                                    Hope Foundation, Trichy.

                                    Meantime, Legal notice received from Shri. A. Kumar, Advocate, Chennai,
                                    Tamilnadu, is as follows:

                                    “My client Mr. T. Karunanidhi states that s.no. 3 of you have started TTI, under the
                                    name and style of M/s. Thozhilathibar TTI & Thozhilathibar college of Education,
                                    sponsored by the Thozhilathibar Educational and Social Trust, having its Registered
                                    office at Door No. 13/33, Senthil Vinayagar Kovil Street, Crawford, Trichy-12,
                                    Tamilnadu.
                                    My client further states that he is the absolute owner of the land and
                                    building situated at Door No: 43, Rajiv Gandhinagar, Edamalaipudur,
                                    Trichy-12, Tamilnadu state and that he had leased a part of the same
                                    property on 30.12.2006 to no. 3 of you to establish a teacher training
                                    institute for a lease period of 30 years from 10.11.2006 to 29.11.2035 and
                                    thereafter had cancelled the same lease on 30.1.2007, since the above
                                    mentioned land and building were required to house and cater to the needs
                                    of most under privileged and orphaned children of the surrounding locality.




     (Gangadharaiah)                                                                      (Prof. C. Thangamuthu)
Regional Director, SRC, NCTE                                                               Chairman, SRC, NCTE
                                                         179
                                                                                                         st
                                                                                         Minutes-201 Meeting of SRC
                                                                                                  22-23 February 2011
                               My client further states that no. 3 of you have suppressed the above facts to 1 & 2 of
                               you wantonly with an ulterior motive and to dishonestly and illegally obtain both
                               conditional and unconditional recognition to start D.T.Ed course.

                               My specific instructions from my client is that no: 3 of you have collided with no: 2 of
                               you for the above said illegal accord of recognition, which was reflected during the
                               inspection of the visiting team for the inspection to the above institution, either in this
                               case or separately, as the case may be.

                               My client further states though the things stood thus, No.3 of you have further
                               collided with land 2 of you to further obtain another recognition order to conduct a
                               B.Ed., course, thus further illegally joined hands for both granting and running a
                               court, which is per se illegal, as the NCTE Act, Regulations and Rules do not permit
                               two TTIs in one and the same land and buildings. We are at a loss to understand as
                               to how could a Statutory body along with its Regional Office can commit such a
                               serious Criminal Offence and that too for such a large pecuniary benefits illegally
                               received from no. 3 of you.

                               Take note that you are all collectively and singularly involved and joined hands in
                               perpetuating the above mentioned criminal offence and thereby had cheated not
                               only my client, but also the General Public whose children are studying in such
                               illegal TTIs”.

                               Further, one more letter has been received on 19.1.2011 from the above
                               Advocate furnishing a copy of Lease Deed dated 29.11.2006 and
                               cancellation of Lease Deed(copy enclosed) and requested to take action
                               Under Section 17 o f NCTE Act.

                               Legal Notices dated 25.10.2010 and 18.1.2011 received from Shri. A.
                                                                                    th                     th
                               Kumar, Advocate was placed before SRC in its 200 meeting held on 20
                                       st
                               and 21 January, 2011 and the Committee decided to issue show cause
                               notice. The show cause notice will be issued after confirmation of minutes.

                               In continuation to the legal notices dated 25.10.2010 and 18.1.2011 of Shril
                               A. Kumar, Advocate, Chennai sent one more legal notice dated 12.2.2011
                               received on 15.2.2011 which states as follows;
                               “My client states that pursuant to your reply dated 31.1.2011 on the above subject,
                               Mr. V. Ingersol, the Chairman of the Thozhilathibar TTI, Trichy has replied to 2 of
                               you, wherein it is alleged that though he has admitted the Cancellation Deed
                               entered between my client and Mr. Ingersol, dated 8.1.2007, he has now come
                               out with a new fabricated and forged document, wherein the title of my
                               client‟s property are purportedly in his name and that it is alleged that Mr.
                               Ingersol and the Management of Thozhilathibar TTI, Trichy had heavily
                               bribed Prof. Dr. C. Thangamuthu, the Chairman of the Southern Regional
                               Committee of NCTE at Bangalore and other officials to show him undue
                               favour, by accepting his forged documents and that not to proceed further
                               for any verification by the inspection Committee consisting of Experts.
                               My client further states and reiterate that unless and until the SRC/NCTE
                               and NCTE Head Quarters at New Delhi, constitute an appropriate
                               inspection Committee with Members of Integrity and knowledge to visit the
                               Thozhilathibar TTI at Trichy, for on the spot verification of the original
                               documents pertaining to the title of the property, the real truth cannot be
                               ascertained, just by the oral submissions and reply of the Management of
                               the Thozhilathibar TTI at Trichy and that the reply of the Management that
                               even the original document of the fabricated Title Deed are in the court
                               custody, are all false and imaginary to hoodwink the NCTE.




     (Gangadharaiah)                                                                      (Prof. C. Thangamuthu)
Regional Director, SRC, NCTE                                                               Chairman, SRC, NCTE
                                                      180
                                                                                                 st
                                                                                     Minutes-201 Meeting of SRC
                                                                                              22-23 February 2011
                               My client further states that he had already preferred a Criminal complaint
                               against Mr. Ingersol to the Superintendent of Police Vigilance and Anti-
                               Corruption, Trichy vide dated 8.2.2011, explaining in detail about the
                               Criminal Acts of Mr. Ingersol and his Associates and that the
                               S.P/DVAC/Trichy had taken the above complaint on record and are now
                               proceeding with necessary actions in accordance with law.

                               Take note that Prof. Dr. C. Thangamuthu, the Officials of NCTE both at
                               Head Quarters and Bangalore and Mr. Ingersol, Chairman of the TTI at
                               Trichy and other Members of the Trust running the TTI would be held
                               responsible for the Criminal Acts and derelictions of duty statutorily vested
                               with the Chairman and Members of SRC and Officials of SRC at Bangalore,
                               both singularly and collectively, if the NCTE, on receipt of this letter within 7
                               days do not take any action against the Tholizhathibar TTI at Trichy for
                               which you are all liable for the costs and consequences thereof.”

                               As per the direction, the above said Legal notice dated 12.2.2011
                               was forwarded to our Counsel Shri. B. Ramakrishna Reddy, Chennai
                               for taking necessary action on 22.2.2011.
                               To take appropriate legal action against Tamilnaduhe complainant
                               for indulgence in sinister campaign and casting aspersions on the
                               NCTE, by making false and malicious allegations.

                               To call for remarks of the institution on the specific allegation that the
                               institution had submitted some forged documents to the SRC.

                               To cause a composite inspection of the Teacher Education
                               institutions of the above management, on receipt of the remarks and
                               all the related documents and filled-in questionnaire and the
                               requisite inspection fee from the institution.

                               The committee considered the matter and decided the
                               following:

                               To take appropriate legal action against the complainant for
                               indulgence in sinister campaign and casting aspersions on the
                               NCTE, by making false and malicious allegations.

                               To call for remarks of the institution on the specific allegation
                               that the institution had submitted some forged documents to
                               the SRC.

                               To cause a composite inspection of the Teacher Education
                               institutions of the above management, on receipt of the remarks
                               and all the related documents and filled-in questionnaire and
                               the requisite inspection fee from the institution.




     (Gangadharaiah)                                                               (Prof. C. Thangamuthu)
Regional Director, SRC, NCTE                                                        Chairman, SRC, NCTE
                                                   181
                                                                                                    st
                                                                                         Minutes-201 Meeting of SRC
                                                                                                  22-23 February 2011
133.               ---                 Shifting of premises as per Regulation 2002 to permanent
                   ----                structure within three year from the date of issue of recognition
       Shifting of premises as         in Andhra Pradesh
       per Regulation 2002 to
       permanent           structure   The matter was placed in 178th meeting of SRC held on 13th -14th
       within 3 years from the         July, 2010 wherein the Committee observed from records of the
       date     of      issue     of   institution that the institutions were accorded recognition in the
       recognition                     rented premises and they had not yet shifted to the permanent
                   AP                  premises/building. In view of non-shifting of colleges to permanent
                                       building the committee decided to issue show cause notice under
                                       section 17 of NCTE Act and obtain shifting fees and other
                                       documents for causing inspection for shifting.

                                       As per direction of Regional Committee Show Cause Notice was
                                       issued with request to submit following documents within 21 days of
                                       receipt of letter.

                                       1.     Demand Draft of Rs.40000/- towards inspection fee in favour of “
                                              The Member Secretary, NCTE” payable at Bangalore should be
                                              submitted.
                                       2.     Land documents of the new building/location for having own land in
                                              the name of the institution /Society/Trust.
                                       3.     Building plan of the new building duly approved by the Government
                                              authority.
                                       4.     Building Completion Certificate from the Government authorities in
                                              the prescribed format ( Format enclosed).
                                       5.     Land Usage Certificate from the concerned Government authorities
                                              stating that the land is exclusively permitted / sanctioned for
                                              Educational Purposes only should be submitted.
                                       6.     Encumbrance certificate from the competent Government should
                                              be submitted
                                       7.     Fixed Deposit Receipt of Rs.5 lakhs kept in JOINT ACCOUNT with
                                              SRC in Nationalised Bank for a period of 5 years towards
                                              Endowment fund in ORIGINAL should be submitted.
                                       8.     Fixed Deposit Receipt of Rs.3 lakhs kept in JOINT ACCOUNT with
                                              SRC in Nationalised Bank for a period of 5 years towards Reserve
                                              fund in ORIGINAL should be submitted.
                                       9.     Certificate of Registration / Bye-law of the Society/Trust should be
                                              submitted.
                                       10.    The affidavit in Rs. 100/- stamp paper in the prescribed format with
                                              Notary attestation should be submitted regarding land and building.

                                       As per perusal of the files the institutions as per statement enclosed
                                       institutions have not submitted reply even after lapse of more than
                                       one year. In first instant the List of the institution who have not
                                       submitted reply, are:-




     (Gangadharaiah)                                                                   (Prof. C. Thangamuthu)
Regional Director, SRC, NCTE                                                            Chairman, SRC, NCTE
                                                         182
                                                                                                 st
                                                                                    Minutes-201 Meeting of SRC
                                                                                             22-23 February 2011

                                 Sl      Code       Course               Institution                  Our Letter
                                                                                                       Dated
                                                             Sri Venkateshwara College of
                                 1.    APSO 0006   B.Ed                                               01.06.2009
                                                             Education
                                 2.    APSO 0021   B.Ed      Sri Sai Sirisha College of Education     29.05.2009
                                                             Dada Akhalandraia College of
                                 3.    APSO 0064   B.Ed                                               01.09.2009
                                                             Education
                                 4.    APSO 0206   B.Ed      Priyanka College of Education            28.08.2009
                                 5.    APSO 0211   B.Ed      Vailankanni College of Education         28.08.2009
                                 6.    APSO 0212   B.Ed      Bharat College of Education              03.09.2009
                                 7.    APSO 0227   B.Ed      Little Rose College of Education         07.10.2009
                                                             Rabindranath Tagore College of
                                 8.    APSO 0248   B.Ed                                               02.09.2009
                                                             Education
                                                             Holy Faith Minority College of
                                 9.    APSO 0268   B.Ed                                               02.09.2009
                                                             Education
                                                             Alimineti Madhava Reddy Memorial
                                 10.   APSO 0296   B.Ed                                               28.08.2009
                                                             College of Education
                                 11.   APSO 0308   D.P.Ed    KPES D.P.Ed College                      01.09.2009
                                 12.   APSO 0315   B.Ed      J.E.S College of Educaiton               01.09.2009
                                 13.   APSO 0327   B.Ed      St. Joseph College of Education          29.05.2009
                                 14.   APSO 0337   B.Ed      Karunodaya College of Education          03.09.2009
                                 15.   APSO 0354   B.Ed      Intel Institution of Teacher Training    27.08.2009
                                                             SLNS College of Education for
                                 16.   APSO 0356   B.Ed                                               03.09.2009
                                                             Women
                                 17.   APSO 0363   B.Ed      Best College of Education                28.08.2009

                                 The committee considered the matter and decided to Withdraw
                                 recognition for the above 17 institutions in Andhra Pradesh as
                                 all the above 17 institutions which were given conditional
                                 recognition in temporary premises failed to shift to permanent
                                 premises within the prescribed time limit of three years as per
                                 the norms, and also they had failed to respond to Showcause
                                 Notices issued by SRC, NCTE long back during 2008-2009.

134.        SRCAPP233          Andhra University, Tadepalligudem, West Godavari, Andhra Pradesh
                M.Ed           has made an application for M.Ed course for the session 2011-2012
       Andhra University, West to Southern Regional Committee, NCTE, Bangalore on 01.10.2010.
       Godavari
                 AP            The application was processed and deficiency letter was issued to
                               the University on 11.01.2011. The university has submitted its reply
                               on 25.01.2011.

                                 The committee considered the matter and decided to Cause
                                 inspection on completion of 75 days time to be given for the
                                 response of the State Government and also follow up the
                                 deficiencies.




     (Gangadharaiah)                                                              (Prof. C. Thangamuthu)
Regional Director, SRC, NCTE                                                       Chairman, SRC, NCTE
                                                   183
                                                                                        st
                                                                             Minutes-201 Meeting of SRC
                                                                                      22-23 February 2011
135.         SRCAPP231          Andhra University, Kondakarakam, Vizianagram District, Andhra
                M.Ed
                                Pradesh has made an application for M.Ed course for the session
       Andhra       University,
       Vizianagaram             2011-2012 to Southern Regional Committee, NCTE, Bangalore on
                 AP
                                01.10.2010.


                                The application was processed and deficiency letter was issued to
                                the University on 11.01.2011. The university has submitted its reply
                                on 25.01.2011.


                                The committee considered the matter and decided to Cause
                                inspection on completion of the stipulated 75 days time to be
                                given for the response of the State Government and also
                                meanwhile follow up the deficiencies.

136.         SRCAPP229          Andhra University, Visakhapatnam District, Andhra Pradesh has
                M.Ed
                                made an application for M.Ed course for the session 2011-2012 to
       Andhra       University,
       Visakhapatnam            Southern Regional Committee, NCTE, Bangalore on 01.10.2010.
                 AP

                                The application was processed and deficiency letter was issued to
                                the University on 11.01.2011. The university has submitted its reply
                                on 25.01.2011.


                                The committee considered the matter and decided to Cause
                                inspection on completion of the stipulated 75 days time to be
                                given for the response of the State Government and also
                                meanwhile follow up the deficiencies.




     (Gangadharaiah)                                                        (Prof. C. Thangamuthu)
Regional Director, SRC, NCTE                                                 Chairman, SRC, NCTE
                                                 184
                                                                                                st
                                                                                    Minutes-201 Meeting of SRC
                                                                                             22-23 February 2011
137.         SRCAPP331            The English and Foreign Language University, No.33.33, Osmania
               M.Ed
                                  University Campus, Post-Jamai-e-Osmania, Hyderabad – 500 605,
       English and Foreign
       Languages    University,   Andhra Pradesh submitted an application for grant of recognition on
       Hyderabad
                                  01.10.2010. Deficiency letter was issued to the institution on
                 AP
                                  22.12.2010. In response to this office deficiency letter, the institution
                                  has submitted its reply on 20.01.2011.           A letter to the State
                                  Government seeking for recommendations has also been written on
                                  22.12.2010. However, the recommendation of the State Government
                                  has not been received for the same.


                                  The SRC in its 200th meeting held on 20-21 January 2011
                                  considered the matter and all relevant documents and decided to
                                  cause inspection after the response of the State Government on the
                                  issue of No Objection Certificate, to examine whether the university
                                  fulfils all the requirements as per the norms, for the proposed
                                  programme.


                                  Further, the committee observed that on the requirement of NAAC
                                  accreditation, the institution had already been accredited with „A‟
                                  grade, while it was a Deemed Unviersity. After it became a Central
                                  University recently,    it will be due for re-accreditation after the
                                  completion of minimum tenure in the new institutional status. Hence,
                                  the application of the institution be processed for consideration, in
                                  view of the transitional status of this Central University.


                                  The committee considered the matter and decided to Cause
                                  inspection on completion of the stipulated 75 days time to be
                                  given for the response of the State Government and also
                                  meanwhile follow up the deficiencies.




     (Gangadharaiah)                                                              (Prof. C. Thangamuthu)
Regional Director, SRC, NCTE                                                       Chairman, SRC, NCTE
                                                    185
                                                                                                   st
                                                                                       Minutes-201 Meeting of SRC
                                                                                                22-23 February 2011
CR to UCR
138.           APS09586           Ballary Rudrappa Education Society, Ballary Rudrappa Education Society‟s
                 B.Ed             B.Ed College, Motebennur P.O, Byadgi Taluk, 84-2 & 82/b/2, Byadgi Road,
       Ballary Rudrappa           Haveri District-581136, Karnataka has submitted application for offering
       Education Society‟s B.Ed   B.Ed course on 27.08.2008. The recognition has been refused to the
                                  institution vide order dated 29.05.2009.
       College, Haveri
                  KA              The institution preferred an appeal and the Appellate Authority, NCTE, New
                                  Delhi has confirmed the rejection order of SRC vide order dated
                                  11.09.2009.

                                  Aggrieved by the rejection order of the Appellate Authority, NCTE, New
                                  Delhi, the institution has filed W.P.No.66762 / 2002 in the Hon'ble High
                                  Court of Karnataka, Circuit Bench at Dharwad. The writ petition has been
                                  disposed of directing the petitioners to make an application for inspection to
                                  the NCTE within one week with requisite fees and was further pleased to
                                  direct the NCTE to inspect the institution within 6 weeks from today in
                                  accordance with law, without waiting for the certified copy.

                                  In obedience to the court directions, the institution has submitted
                                  application along with requisite fee on 13.07.2010.
                                                        th
                                  The SRC in its 194 meeting held on 30-22 July 2010 considered the
                                  matter and decided to call for documents/clarification. Accordingly, a notice
                                  was issued to the institution on 30.08.2010. The institution submitted the
                                  written representation on 13.09.2010 along with duly filed in Questionnaire.
                                                       th
                                  The SRC in its 196 meeting held on 15-16 September 2010 considered
                                  the written representation and decided to cause inspection. Accordingly,
                                  inspection was carried out on 20th October 2010. SRC in its 198th meeting
                                  held on 24-26 November 2010 considered the VT Report and decided to
                                  issue showcause notice. Accordingly, showcause notice was issued to the
                                  institution on 03.01.2011.       The institution has submitted its written
                                  representation on 13.01.2011. SRC in its 200th meeting held on 20-21
                                  January 2011 considered the written representation and decided to issue
                                  letter of Intent. Accordingly, Letter of Intent was issued to the institution on
                                  27.01.2011.

                                  The institution has submitted reply to Letter of Intent on 03.02.2011 and
                                  11.02.2011

                                  On Careful perusal of the original file of the institution and staff
                                  profiles submitted by the institution in response to the letter of
                                  Intent, the Regional Committee decided that Formal
                                  Recognition be granted to B.Ed., course of one year duration
                                  with an annual intake of 100 (One hundred only) students from
                                  the academic year 2011-12.




     (Gangadharaiah)                                                                 (Prof. C. Thangamuthu)
Regional Director, SRC, NCTE                                                          Chairman, SRC, NCTE
                                                      186
                                                                                          st
                                                                               Minutes-201 Meeting of SRC
                                                                                        22-23 February 2011
139.          APS09817           Shanthi Niketan College of Education, Theni District, Tamilnadu has
                 B.Ed            submitted an application for seeking grant of recognition for B.Ed
       Shanthi Niketan College   course on 29.10.2008.
       of Education, Theni
                  TN             Since the society/institution was not in possession of the required
                                 land on ownership basis as on the date of application, the
                                 application of the institution was returned back on 18.3.2009. The
                                 institution got the land registered in the name of society only on
                                 29.12.2008.

                                 The society again made a representation to the SRC-NCTE on 2nd
                                 April, 2009 with the request that their application be considered for
                                 the academic session 2009-2010, which was rejected by SRC vide
                                 letter dated 17th April, 2009. The institution preferred a W.P. No.
                                 3641 of 2009 in the Hon‟ble High Court of Madras at Madurai,
                                 whereby the Hon‟ble High court has quashed the order of SRC
                                 returning the application of the institution.

                                 The SRC in its 178th meeting held on 13-14 July, 2009 considered
                                 the matter and noted that the Hon‟ble Court has quashed the order
                                 of the SRC returning the application of the institution. The SRC also
                                 noted that as on date of submission of application for the session
                                 2008-09, the institution was not having the land in the name of the
                                 Society/Trust as per para 8(7) of regulations of NCTE, 2007.
                                 Further, the institution had submitted the registered land documents
                                 in the name of Society/Trust only in December, 2008 i.e., after the
                                 last date for submission of complete application for the academic
                                 session 2008-09.

                                 The Committee viewed that the consideration of the application for
                                 the session 2008-09 will go against the regulations of NCTE, 2007
                                 and also viewed that the application liable for rejection. In view of
                                 the Hon‟ble High Court order the Committee decided to refer the
                                 matter to the Legal Counsel to file an appeal against the said
                                 judgemenet as this will affect the Regulations of NCTE, 2007.

                                 Further, the Committee also decided to ask for clarification from
                                 NCTE-HQ on the above point as to whether the application
                                 submitted on 31st October, 2008 which was incomplete with regard
                                 to land documents and further land documents has been got
                                 registered in the name of Trust/ Society at a later date beyond the
                                 last date of application for the concerned session can be considered
                                 for the academic session 2008-09.Accordingly, as per the decision of
                                 SRC, letters to advocate and the Member Secretary, NCTE-Hqrs.
                                 were issued.




     (Gangadharaiah)                                                         (Prof. C. Thangamuthu)
Regional Director, SRC, NCTE                                                  Chairman, SRC, NCTE
                                                  187
                                                                                                    st
                                                                                       Minutes-201 Meeting of SRC
                                                                                                22-23 February 2011
                               NCTE-Hqrs. vide letter dated 21st August, 2009 had endorsed the
                               view of SRC for preferring an appeal against the said order. In the
                               W.A No. 483 of 2009 filed by NCTE before the Hon‟ble Division
                               Bench of the High Court of Madras the Hon‟ble Court vide order
                               dated 15th October, 2009 has directed as under:-

                               “We agree with the reasoning of the learned single judge in directing the writ
                               petitioner/respondent herein to re-submit the application and the appellant to
                               consider the same within six weeks. It is stated by the learned counsel for the writ
                               petitioner/respondent herein that counseling has started for the B.Ed degree course.

                               In the circumstances, we confirm the order of the single judge dated 3.7.2009 in
                               W.P(MD) No.3641 of 2009. As the application already submitted is still pending with
                               the appellant herein and having regard to the direction granted by this court in the
                               writ proceedings and in the light of the pendency of the Writ Appeal before this
                               court, the appellant herein is hereby directed to consider the same and pass orders
                               within a period of four weeks from the date of receipt of a copy of this order. With
                               this direction, the Writ Appeal is dismissed. Connected Miscellaneous Petition is
                               closed. No Costs”.

                               The matter was placed before SRC in its 185th meeting held on 26th
                               and 27th November, 2009 and the Committee decided that as per
                               court direction, the application taken up for consideration and decide
                               to cause inspection, accordingly, the inspection date was fixed on
                               14.12.009. The inspection report was received in the SRC office on
                               17.12.2009. Further it is stated that NCTE-Hqrs. vide letter dated
                               21.12.2009 conveyed the approval of the Chairperson, NCTE to file
                               an SLP against the order dated 15.10.2009 before the Hon‟ble
                               Supreme Court of India. The NCTE-Hqrs. has sought the legal
                               opinion of Shri. Prakash Kumar Singh in this regard. Since, the Hqrs.
                               conveyed its approval for filing an SLP just after a week‟s time of
                               conducting inspection on 14.12.009, the decision of the High Court
                               has partly been complied with.

                               The inspection report along with the direction of NCTE-Hqrs. for filing
                               SLP was placed before the SRC in its 187th meeting held on 29th and
                               30th December, 2009 and the Committee decided that “While
                               complying with the court directions, steps be taken to file SLP
                               advised by NCTE-Hqrs. as the matter involves violation of very
                               basic regulation of NCTE act, rules and regulations”

                               NCTE-Hqrs. vide their letter dated 16.7.2010 has directed that in
                               view of a lapse of considerable period in filing the SLP, a decision
                               has been taken not to file SLP in the matter at present and orders of
                               Division Bench may be implemented any further delay.

                               The institution has also submitted written representation on 2.8.2010
                               seeking further information regarding the status of the application for
                               recognition for B.Ed college for the academic year 2009-2010. The
                               Visiting team report was placed before SRC in its 195th meeting held
                               on 17-18th August 2010 for direction/decision in the matter.




     (Gangadharaiah)                                                                 (Prof. C. Thangamuthu)
Regional Director, SRC, NCTE                                                          Chairman, SRC, NCTE
                                                    188
                                                                                                 st
                                                                                     Minutes-201 Meeting of SRC
                                                                                              22-23 February 2011
                                 SRC decided to issue notice to the institution. Accordingly notice
                                 was issued to the institution on 17.09.2010. The institution submitted
                                 its reply on 08.10.2010.

                                 The Committee considered the matter and it was decided to
                                 serve Notice for the following deficiencies:-

                                  The Principal designate is not qualified as per NCTE norms.

                                 In view of the above, the Committee decided to issue Notice to
                                 the institution and thereby providing an opportunity to the
                                 institution to make a written representation within 30days from
                                 the date of issue of the Notice along with necessary
                                 certificates/documents in order to take a final decision in the
                                 matter, failing which action will be taken including the
                                 withdrawal of LOI, based on the records available, with no
                                 further notice.

140.         SRCAPP141           Sri Ramanas College of Education, Virudhunagar District-
                B.Ed             626134, Tamilnadu
       Sri Ramanas College of
       Education, Virudhunagar   Sri Ramanas College of Education, No.2/654, Chidambarapuram,
                  TN             Aruppukottai Taluk, Virudhunagar District-626134, Tamilnadu
                                 submitted its application for B.Ed course through on-line on
                                 30.10.2009. Application of the above institution was received by
                                 SRC on 30.10.2009. The application was processed and deficiency
                                 letter was issued to the institution on 22.12.2009. The institution
                                 submitted its written representation on 25.01.2010.

                                         The SRC considered the matter in its 189th meeting held on
                                   th   th
                                 25 -26 February 2010 and on careful perusal of the original file of
                                 the institution and other related documents, Committee decided to
                                 cause inspection to the institution.

                                 The inspection of the institution was conducted on 07.05.2010. The
                                 SRC in its 192nd meeting held on 10th-11th May 2010 after
                                 considering the report of the visiting team as well as other relevant
                                 materials furnished by the applicant institution, the Regional
                                 Committee decided to refuse recognition to B.Ed course for the
                                 following grounds:-

                                  The institution has not produced valid Minority Certificate issued by the
                                   competent authority.
                                  The visit was conducted inadvertently, before getting the proper
                                   clarification from the State Government on the requirements of a legally
                                   valid Minority Certificate from a competent authority.
                                  The institution without valid Minority Certificate, as such, is not eligible
                                   to apply under Minority category.




     (Gangadharaiah)                                                               (Prof. C. Thangamuthu)
Regional Director, SRC, NCTE                                                        Chairman, SRC, NCTE
                                                    189
                                                                                         st
                                                                              Minutes-201 Meeting of SRC
                                                                                       22-23 February 2011
                               Accordingly, the  application  was     rejected          vide     order
                               F.SRC/NCTE/B.Ed/2010/19161 dated. 28.05.2010.

                               Aggrieved by the rejection order, the institution preferred appeal u/s
                               18 of NCTE Act.

                               The Appellate Authority vide its order No.F.No.89-720/2010-Appeal
                               dated 24.09.2010 reversed the order of the SRC dated 28.05.2010
                               with a direction to SRC to process the application on merits. This
                               would however subject to the condition that a valid minority
                               certificate would be obtained by the society for the institution in due
                               course and that the institution shall abide by their obligation as a
                               minority institution in order to enjoy continuos recognition.

                               SRC considered the appeal order in its 197th meeting held on 13th-
                               14th October 2010 and decided to process the application.

                               SRC considered the matter in its 198th meeting held on 24-26th
                               November 2010 and decided to process the VT.

                               The SRC considered, VT report, VCD, reply to the show cause
                               notice and all relevant documents, the Appellate Authority order dt.
                               24.09.2010 and decided to issue Letter Of Intent for grant of Formal
                               Recognition to B.Ed course of one year duration with an annual
                               intake of 100(One hundred only)(one unit) for the academic year
                               2011-12 subject to the production of valid minority certificate issued
                               by the competent authority and appointment of qualified staff through
                               duly constituted selection committee as per the Norms of
                               NCTE/State Government/Affiliating University and be given effect
                               before the commencement of the academic session.

                               The Committee considered the matter and it was decided to
                               serve Notice for providing Minority Certificate in the name of
                               the institution to take a final decision on the issue of formal
                               recognition order to the institution

                               In view of the above, the Committee decided to issue Notice to
                               the institution and thereby providing an opportunity to the
                               institution to make a written representation within 60 days from
                               the date of issue of the Notice along with necessary
                               certificates/documents in order to take a final decision in the
                               matter, failing which action will be taken including the
                               withdrawal of LOI, based on the records available, with no
                               further notice.




     (Gangadharaiah)                                                         (Prof. C. Thangamuthu)
Regional Director, SRC, NCTE                                                  Chairman, SRC, NCTE
                                                 190

								
To top