Minutes of 204th Meeting of SRC by nuhman10

VIEWS: 173 PAGES: 220

									                                                                              th
                                                                Minutes of 204 Meeting of SRC
                                                                               th  th
                                                                             27 -28 April 2011



                     SOUTHERN REGIONAL COMMITTEE
                              BANGALORE

                     Minutes of the 204th Meeting of SRC held at the
           Conference Hall of NCTE, Bangalore on 27TH & 28TH April, 2011



                             The following members attended the Meeting:-

             1.       Prof. C. Thangamuthu             -      Chairman

             2        Prof. C.L. Anand                 -      Member

             3        Prof. C. Seshadri                -      Member

             4        Prof. P.J. Poulose               -      Member

             5.       Prof. C.H. Vijayalaxmi           -      Member

             6        Prof. V. Sudhakar                -      Member

             7        Anil Kumar. K.S (Kerala)         -      Joint Secretary Higher Education

              8       Fahmida Rahim (Karnataka)        -      Representative
                      Deputy Director                         (Attended on 28.04.2011)

                 9   G. Sankara Subramaniam
                       Director DTERT (Tamil Nadu)     -      Representative Tamil Nadu
                                                                    (Attended on 28.04.2011)

              10      Sri. Gangadharaiah               -      Convenor



                      The following members could not attend the Meeting :-


      Prof. Syeda Akthar, Member, & Representatives of the Andhra Pradesh, and U.T‟s of
      Lakshadweep, Pondicherry & Andaman & Nicobar Islands




                                                 1


(Gangadharaiah)                                                   (Prof. C. Thangamuthu)
Regional Director, SRC, NCTE                                        Chairman, SRC, NCTE
                                                                                               th
                                                                               Minutes of 204 Meeting of SRC
                                                                                              th  th
                                                                                            27 -28 April 2011

                                MINUTES OF 204th MEETING OF SRC-NCTE

     Sl.              Brief Description                          Remarks of SRC
  No.

  1.           Confirmation of Minutes of 203rd                     Cinfirmed
               Meeting held on 31st March & 1st
                          April 2011
  2.            Action Taken Report (ATR) on                           Noted
               the Minutes of 202nd Meeting of
                 SRC held on 14th-15th March
                            2011

      Inspection Report – New Application:

Sl.        Code Course                                           Remarks of SRC
No           Name of the
              Institution
                 State
3.           SRCAPP114              Mohammadia College of Education, Kurnool District, Andhara
                 B.Ed                                      Pradesh
             Mohammadia
               College of        Mohammadia Educational Society, Plot no- 76/97-4, Sampath Nagar, Village-
           Education, Kurnool    Kurnool, Tehsil- Karnool, Distt- Kurnool, Andhara Pradesh -518003, had
                  AP             applied for grant of recognition to Mohammadia College of Education, Village-
                                 Peddapadu, Post- Peddapadu, Taluka – Kurnool, Distt- Kurnool, Andhara
                                 Pradesh-518003 for B.Ed Course of One year duration under Section 14(1) of
                                 the NCTE Act, 1993 to the Southern Regional Committee, NCTE on
                                 29.10.2009.

                                 The application was processed and the deficiency letter was issued to the
                                 institution on 22.12.2009. The institution not submitted reply of deficiency
                                 letter.

                                 The SRC considered the matter in its 190th meeting held on 29th-30th March
                                 2010 and on careful perusal of the original file of the institution and other
                                 related documents, NCTE Act 1993, Regulations and guidelines from time to
                                 time laid on the table, written representation from the institution, the Regional
                                 Committee decided to reject the application on the following grounds:-

                                 The institution has not replied to the deficiency letter even after a lapse of three
                                 months and hence it is decided that no further action is necessary and that the
                                 applications is to be rejected.
                                 Accordingly, rejection order was issued to the applicant institution on
                                 03.05.2010 as per direction of Regional Committee.

                                 Institution preferred an appeal dated 18.05.2010 to the NCTE, Hq Under
                                                           2


      (Gangadharaiah)                                                            (Prof. C. Thangamuthu)
      Regional Director, SRC, NCTE                                                 Chairman, SRC, NCTE
                                                                                       th
                                                                        Minutes of 204 Meeting of SRC
                                                                                       th  th
                                                                                     27 -28 April 2011
                            Section-18 of the NCTE Act, 1993 against the rejection order dated
                            03.05.2010.

                            Appeal authority remands back the case to the SRC with direction to issue
                            fresh deficiency letter to the institution at the correct address. As per the
                            decision of Appellate authority a fresh deficiency letter to the correct address
                            was issued on 25.10.2010. Institution submitted its reply on 21.12.2010.

                            The SRC in its 200th meeting held on 20-21 January 2011 considered the
                            matter and all relevant documents and decided to cause inspection to examine
                            whether the institution fulfils all the requirements as per the norms, for the
                            proposed programme.

                            As per the decision of SRC inspection of the institution was scheduled
                            between 22nd –25th March 2011. Institution was unwilling for facing the
                            inspection as per statement of VT members and has requested for
                            postponement.

                            The committee considered the VT report and the letter of the institution
                            and decided to cause inspection of the institution on a revised date on
                            submission of Rs. 40000/- towards inspection.

4.        SRCAPP229         Andhra University, Visakhapatnam District, Andhra Pradesh has made an
              M.Ed          application for M.Ed course for the session 2011-2012 to Southern Regional
          Department of     Committee, NCTE, Bangalore on 01.10.2010.
        Education, Andhra
           University,      The application was processed and deficiency letter was issued to the
         Visakhapatnam      University on 11.01.2011. The university has submitted its reply on
               AP           25.01.2011.

                            The committee considered the matter and decided to Cause inspection. The
                            inspection of the institution was carried out on 28.03.2011 under section 15.

                            On careful perusal of the original file of the institution, VT Reports and
                            other related documents, Act of NCTE, 1993, Regulations and guidelines
                            of NCTE published from time to time laid on the table, the Regional
                            Committee decided to issue Letter of Intent for grant of recognition to
                            M.Ed course of One year duration with an annual intake of 35(Thirty Five
                            only)(one unit) from the academic year 2011-12 subject to the
                            appointment of qualified staff through duly constituted selection
                            committee as per the Norms of NCTE/State Government/Affiliating
                            University and be given effect before the commencement of the
                            academic session.

5.        SRCAPP365         Mahamood B.Ed College, Kadapa, Andhra Pradesh submitted an
               B.Ed         application to SRC-NCTE for grant of recognition for B.Ed course on
         Mahamood B.Ed      online 29.09.10
         College, Kadapa
                AP          The Application was scrutinized and a copy of application was sent to State

                                                    3


     (Gangadharaiah)                                                      (Prof. C. Thangamuthu)
     Regional Director, SRC, NCTE                                           Chairman, SRC, NCTE
                                                                                       th
                                                                      Minutes of 204 Meeting of SRC
                                                                                     th  th
                                                                                   27 -28 April 2011
                      Government for recommendation on 09.11.2010 / 02.02.2011. A deficiency
                      letter was issued to the institution on 10.12.2010 for the following Points:

                              Certified copy of the registered land documents issued by the
                               competent authority: the institution has submitted the copy of the
                               registered land documents in Telugu version and it is not certified.
                               Hence the institution should submit the certified copy of registered land
                               documents issued by the Office of the Sub-Registrar of competent
                               authority in English version.
                              Notarized copy of Change of land use Certificate issued by the
                               competent authority - the university has not submitted notarized copy of
                               change of land use certificate issued by the competent authority. Hence
                               the university is required to submit notarized copy of (conversion of land
                               utilization) LUC (Agriculture lands –conversion to Non – Agricultural
                               purpose) issued by competent authority
                              Building completion certificate: the institution has submitted
                               photocopy of building completion certificate issued by local civil
                               authority but not in prescribed format. Hence the institution is required
                               to submit Building completion certificate issued by local civil
                               authority/Govt. Engineer in prescribed format.
                              Affidavit in the prescribed form on Rs 100/ stamp paper duly
                               attested by oath commissioner or notary public, stating the
                               precise location of the land (village, district, state etc) the total
                               area in possession, the permission of the competent authority to
                               use the land for educational purpose and mode of possession i.e.
                               ownership or lease: the institution has not submitted the original
                               affidavit of Rs.100/- stamp paper attested by oath commissioner or
                               Notary public. Hence the institution is required to submit the original
                               affidavit of Rs.100/- stamp paper duly attested by oath commissioner of
                               notary public.
                              Building Plan gives proposed building at Sy.no.200 which does not tally
                               with Khasra no. & plot no. given in affidavit. The discrepancy may be
                               clarified. The authority which has approved the builing plan may be
                               specified whether corporation/municipal /panchayat as the case may
                               be.

                              Minority certificate: the institution is minority institution as per
                               application form, however the institution has submitted the minority
                               certificate in this regard but it this it has been mentioned that it is for the
                               period of one academic year i.e.2010-11. Hence the institution is
                               required to submit minority certificate issued by competent authority for
                               the academic year 2011-12.

                              Survey no. 200 in the affidavit and building plan, Building completion
                               certificate is not matching with application form where Plot no. 5337,
                               Akkayapalli is given as land identification and sale deed is referred to.

                      The inspection of the institution was conducted on 29.03.2011. The following
                      deficiencies still persists:


                                                 4


(Gangadharaiah)                                                          (Prof. C. Thangamuthu)
Regional Director, SRC, NCTE                                               Chairman, SRC, NCTE
                                                                                    th
                                                                     Minutes of 204 Meeting of SRC
                                                                                    th  th
                                                                                  27 -28 April 2011
                            The Committee considered the VT Report, VCD and all the relevant
                            documentary evidences and it was decided to serve the Show cause
                            Notice for the following:

                                The total built up area as per VT report is 21814 sq.ft, where as in
                                 Building Completion Certificate it is 22753 sq.ft. This discrepancy
                                 may be explained.

                                Approved building plan from competent authority is to be
                                 submitted.

                                Building completion certified from competent Govt. Engineer is to
                                 be submitted.

                                Land documents, building plan and building completion certificate
                                 shows Sy.No. as 200, where as inspection was conducted at No.
                                 5337.

                                Certified copy of registered land document issued by competent
                                 authority is to be submitted.

                                Notarised copy of Land usage certificate issued by competent
                                 authority is to be submitted.

                                The Affidavit in Rs. 100/- stamp paper in the prescribed format with
                                 Notary attestation to be submitted.

                            In view of the above, the Committee decided to issue a Show cause
                            Notice to the institution as to why the recognition be not refused and
                            thereby providing an opportunity to the institution to make a written
                            representation within 30 days from the date of issue of the Notice along
                            with necessary certificates/documents in order to take a final decision in
                            the matter; failing which action will be taken including the refusal of
                            recognition, based on the records available, with no further notice.

6.         SRCAPP254        Alexander   College,  Plot no.  40/A,40/B,41/A, 578/B,   Village-
               B.Ed         Moqdumpur,Post- Moqdupur, Taluka- Karimnagar, Distt- Karimnagar-
        Alexander College   505186,Andhra Pradesh
           of Education,
            Karimnagar      The Application was scrutinized and a copy of application was sent to State
                AP          Government for recommendation on 09.11.2010/02.02.2011. A deficiency
                            letter was issued to the institution on 09.12.2010 for the following Points:


                            1. Fixed Deposit Receipt for Rs 5.00 lakhs of Nationalized bank towards
                            Endowment funds- the institution has submitted photo copy of FDR of Rs
                            5.00 lakhs towards Endowment funds vide no 688636 dated 24.09.10 for five
                            years issued by Union Bank, Hence the institution is required to submit
                            original fresh FDR issued for proposed course as per regulation.
                                                   5


     (Gangadharaiah)                                                   (Prof. C. Thangamuthu)
     Regional Director, SRC, NCTE                                        Chairman, SRC, NCTE
                                                                                    th
                                                                    Minutes of 204 Meeting of SRC
                                                                                   th  th
                                                                                 27 -28 April 2011

                      2. Fixed Deposit Receipt for Rs 3.00 lakhs of Nationalized bank towards
                      Reserved fund - the institution has submitted photo copy of FDR of Rs 3.00
                      lakhs towards Reserved fund vide no 688635 dated 24.09.10 for five years
                      issued by Union Bank. Hence the institution is required to submit original
                      fresh FDR issued for proposed course as per regulation

                      3. Notarized copy of Change of land use Certificate issued by the
                      competent authority - the institution has not submitted land use certificate .
                      Hence the institution is required to submit notarized copy of LUC (Agriculture
                      lands -conversion of Non - Agricultural purpose) issued by Revenue
                      Department

                      4. Approved building plan by the competent civil authority :- Institution
                      has not submitted building plan approved by competent civil authority/
                      municipal/ panchayat/ corporation. Hence the institution is required to submit
                      fresh blue print wherein it should be clearly mentioning i.e Khashara no, plot
                      no, proposed course, total area, built up area duly approved by competent
                      authority with resolution in all respect either or English or Hindi language. If
                      the institution has running other teacher education courses/ other technical
                      courses in the same premises then, the institution shall submit earmarked area
                      for proposed course with total area and built up area.

                      5.Certified copy of the registered land documents issued by the
                      competent authority :- the institution has submitted land documents in local
                      regional language. Hence the institution is required to submit Certified copy/
                      notarized copy of the registered land documents in english version.

                      6. Minority Certificate:- the institution is minority institution as per application
                      form, however the institution has not submitted minority certificate in the name
                      of college. Hence the institution is required to submit minority certificate issued
                      by competent authority

                      7. Copy of Bye laws:- The institution has not submitted the Bye-laws. Hence
                      the institution is required to submit bye- laws of the society.


                      The inspection of the institution was conducted on 29.03.2011. The following
                      deficiencies still persists:

                      The Committee considered the VT Report, VCD and all the relevant
                      documentary evidences and it was decided to serve the Show cause
                      Notice for the following:

                           As per VCD observation the building (2nd floor and top floor) is still
                            under construction and is incomplete.

                           Sale deed certified copy of registered document by competent
                            authority is to be submitted.

                                                6


(Gangadharaiah)                                                       (Prof. C. Thangamuthu)
Regional Director, SRC, NCTE                                            Chairman, SRC, NCTE
                                                                                          th
                                                                          Minutes of 204 Meeting of SRC
                                                                                         th  th
                                                                                       27 -28 April 2011
                                  The institution has not submitted valid Minority Status Certificate
                                   from the Competent Authority.

                                  Multipurpose Hall size is less than Regulation-2009.

                                  Language learning is lab is not available.

                                  Science lab & Psychology lab needs to be strengthened.

                             In view of the above, the Committee decided to issue a Show cause
                             Notice to the institution as to why the recognition be not refused and
                             thereby providing an opportunity to the institution to make a written
                             representation within 30 days from the date of issue of the Notice along
                             with necessary certificates/documents in order to take a final decision in
                             the matter; failing which action will be taken including the refusal of
                             recognition, based on the records available, with no further notice.

7.        SRCAPP233          Andhra University, West Godavari district, Andhra Pradesh.
             M.Ed
        Andhra University,   Sub:- Application seeking grant of recognition for starting M.Ed course to
         West Godavari       Andhra University, No.4058, Tadepalligudem, West Godavari-534101,
               AP            Andhra Pradesh.
                             The Application was scrutinized and a copy of application was sent to State
                             Government for recommendation on 09.11.2010/02.02.2011. A deficiency
                             letter was issued to the institution on 11.01.2011 for the following Points:

                             1.Certified copy of the registered land documents issued by the
                             competent authority :- The university has not submitted the registered land
                             documents. Hence the university should submit the certified copy of registered
                             land documents issued by the competent authority in English version in the
                             favour of society/University.

                             3. Notarized copy of Change of land use Certificate issued by the
                             competent authority - the university has not submitted notarized copy of
                             change of land use certificate issued by the competent authority. Hence the
                             university is required to submit notarized copy of (conversion of land utilization)
                             LUC (Agriculture lands –conversion to Non – Agricultural purpose) issued by
                             competent authority.

                             4. Building completion certificate:- The university has not submitted building
                             completion certificate issued by local civil authority in prescribed format. Hence
                             the university is required to submit Building completion certificate issued by
                             local civil authority in prescribed format. (copy enclosed)

                                5. NAAC Certificate :- In institution has submitted NAAC certificate with
                                   B. Grade for proposed course but it is valid only for five years. Hence
                                   the University is required to renewal the NAAC certificate and submit
                                   same to this office.

                                                      7


     (Gangadharaiah)                                                        (Prof. C. Thangamuthu)
     Regional Director, SRC, NCTE                                             Chairman, SRC, NCTE
                                                                                        th
                                                                         Minutes of 204 Meeting of SRC
                                                                                        th  th
                                                                                      27 -28 April 2011
                            The inspection of the institution was conducted on 29.03.2011. The following
                            deficiencies still persists:

                            The Committee considered the VT Report, VCD and all the relevant
                            documentary evidences and it was decided to serve the Show cause
                            Notice for the following:

                                 The built up area for the M.Ed course with both exclusive & shared
                                  facilities comes to about 6000 sq,ft. which is inadequate as per
                                  NCTE norms.

                                 No. of Journals for M.Ed provided in the library is only two & library
                                  has 1060 books which are inadequate. Library needs to be
                                  strengthened.

                                 Furniture needs to be strengthened.

                            In view of the above, the Committee decided to issue a Show cause
                            Notice to the institution as to why the recognition be not refused and
                            thereby providing an opportunity to the institution to make a written
                            representation within 30 days from the date of issue of the Notice along
                            with necessary certificates/documents in order to take a final decision in
                            the matter; failing which action will be taken including the refusal of
                            recognition, based on the records available, with no further notice.

8.        SRCAPP259         Application seeking grant of recognition for starting D.El.Ed course to AK
            D.El.Ed         College of Teacher Education Muslim Minority Institution, 121/A,
         A.K. College of    Sarlapalli, Thimmareddypalli, Medak-502372, Andhra Pradesh.
       Teacher Education,
             Medak          The Application was scrutinized and a copy of application was sent to State
               AP           Government for recommendation on 09.11.2010/02.02.2011. A deficiency
                            letter was issued to the institution on 10.12.2010 for the following Points:

                            1. Fixed Deposit Receipt for Rs 5.00 lakhs of Nationalized bank towards
                            Endowment funds- the institution has submitted photo copy of FDR of Rs
                            5.00 lakhs towards Endowment funds vide no 946910 dated 27.08.2010 for
                            one year issued by Andhra Bank. Hence the institution is required to submit
                            FDR in original for proposed course as per regulation.

                            2. Fixed Deposit Receipt for Rs 3.00 lakhs of Nationalized bank towards
                            Reserved fund - the institution has submitted photo copy of FDR of Rs 3.00
                            lakhs towards Reserved fund vide no 946909 dated 27.08.2010 for one year
                            issued by Andhara Bank. Hence the institution is required to submit FDR in
                            original for proposed course as per regulation.

                            3. Building completion certificate:- The institution has not submitted building
                            completion certificate issued by local civil authority in prescribed format. Hence
                            the institution is required to submit Building completion certificate issued by
                            local civil authority in prescribed format. (copy enclosed)
                                                     8


     (Gangadharaiah)                                                       (Prof. C. Thangamuthu)
     Regional Director, SRC, NCTE                                            Chairman, SRC, NCTE
                                                                                          th
                                                                          Minutes of 204 Meeting of SRC
                                                                                         th  th
                                                                                       27 -28 April 2011
                            4. Notarized copy of Change of land use Certificate issued by the
                            competent authority - the institution has not submitted notarized copy of
                            change of land use certificate issued by the competent authority. Hence the
                            institution is required to submit notarized copy of (conversion of land utilization)
                            LUC (Agriculture lands –conversion to Non – Agricultural purpose) issued by
                            competent/revenue authority.

                            5. Minority Certificate:- the institution is minority institution as per application
                            form, however the institution has not submitted minority certificate in this
                            regard. Hence the institution is required to submit minority certificate issued by
                            competent authority.

                            6. Duly notarized copy of registered land documents to be submitted by the
                            institution

                            The inspection of the institution was conducted on 30.03.2011. The following
                            deficiencies still persists:

                            The Committee considered the VT Report, VCD and all the relevant
                            documentary evidences and it was decided to serve the Show cause
                            Notice for the following:

                                 In the approved building plan by the competent civil authority
                                  submitted, plot no. /survey no./Khashra no. are not mentioned.
                                 The survey number in the Building completion certificate and Land
                                  documents (121/A) is not matching with Land usage certificate
                                  (120/A).
                                 Multiple purpose hall size is less than the requirement of
                                  Regulation 2009.
                                 Website is not available.

                            In view of the above, the Committee decided to issue a Show cause
                            Notice to the institution as to why the recognition be not refused and
                            thereby providing an opportunity to the institution to make a written
                            representation within 30 days from the date of issue of the Notice along
                            with necessary certificates/documents in order to take a final decision in
                            the matter; failing which action will be taken including the refusal of
                            recognition, based on the records available, with no further notice.
9.        SRCAPP276          Application seeking grant of recognition for starting B.Ed course to Pavlov
              B.Ed          College of Teacher Education, No.90, 91, 316, Vedira, Ramdugu,
        Pavlov College of   Karimnagar-505451, Andhra Pradesh.
       Teacher Education,
                            The Application was scrutinized and a copy of application was sent to State
          Karimnagar
                            Government for recommendation on 09.11.2010/02.02.2011. A deficiency
               AP
                            letter was issued to the institution on 09.12.2010 for the following Points:

                            1. Notarized copy of Change of land use Certificate issued by the
                            competent authority - the institution has submitted the copy of change of land
                            use certificate issued by the competent authority but it is not Notarized. Hence
                                                      9


     (Gangadharaiah)                                                        (Prof. C. Thangamuthu)
     Regional Director, SRC, NCTE                                             Chairman, SRC, NCTE
                                                                                            th
                                                                            Minutes of 204 Meeting of SRC
                                                                                           th  th
                                                                                         27 -28 April 2011
                              the institution is required to submit notarized copy of (conversion of land
                              utilization) LUC (Agriculture lands – conversion to Non – Agricultural purpose)
                              issued by competent authority.

                              2. Affidavit in the prescribed form on Rs 100/ stamp paper duly attested
                              by oath commissioner or Notary public, stating the precise location of
                              the land (village, district, state etc) the total area in possession, the
                              permission of the competent authority to use the land for educational
                              purpose and mode of possession i.e. ownership or lease :- the institution
                              has submitted the original affidavit of Rs 100/- stamp paper but it is not
                              attested by oath commissioner or Notary public. Hence the institution is
                              required to submit the original affidavit of Rs 100/- stamp paper duly attested
                              by oath commissioner of notary public.

                              3. Minority Certificate:- the institution is minority institution as per application
                              form, however the institution has submitted the minority certificate in this
                              regard but in this it has been mentioned that it is for the period of one
                              academic year i.e. 2010-2011. Hence the institution is required to submit
                              minority certificate issued by competent authority for the academic year 2011-
                              2012.

                              4. Notarized copy of translated land document to be submitted.

                              The inspection of the institution was conducted on 30.03.2011. The following
                              deficiencies still persists:

                              The Committee considered the VT Report, VCD and all the relevant
                              documentary evidences and it was decided to serve the Show cause
                              Notice for the following:
                                  As per VCD, the building is incomplete and 2nd floor of the building
                                   is not shown in the VCD.

                                   The earmarked area for each course i.e., B.Ed & D.Ed is to be given.

                                   The purpose/utilization of the 2nd floor should be given with details.


                              In view of the above, the Committee decided to issue a Show cause
                              Notice to the institution as to why the recognition be not refused and
                              thereby providing an opportunity to the institution to make a written
                              representation within 30 days from the date of issue of the Notice along
                              with necessary certificates/documents in order to take a final decision in
                              the matter; failing which action will be taken including the refusal of
                              recognition, based on the records available, with no further notice.
10.        SRCAPP231           Application seeking grant of recognition for starting M.Ed course to Andhra
                M.Ed          University, No.4059, Kondakarakam, Vizianagaram-535003, Andhra
         Andhra University,   Pradesh.
           Vizianagaram
                              The Application was scrutinized and a copy of application was sent to State
                 AP
                              Government for recommendation on 09.11.2010/02.02.2011. A deficiency
                                                       10


      (Gangadharaiah)                                                         (Prof. C. Thangamuthu)
      Regional Director, SRC, NCTE                                              Chairman, SRC, NCTE
                                                                                         th
                                                                         Minutes of 204 Meeting of SRC
                                                                                        th  th
                                                                                      27 -28 April 2011
                            letter was issued to the institution on 11.01.2011 for the following Points:

                            1.Certified copy of the registered land documents issued by the
                            competent authority :- The university has not submitted the registered land
                            documents. Hence the university should submit the certified copy of registered
                            land documents issued by the competent authority in English version in the
                            favour of society/University.

                            3. Notarized copy of Change of land use Certificate issued by the
                            competent authority - the university has not submitted notarized copy of
                            change of land use certificate issued by the competent authority. Hence the
                            university is required to submit notarized copy of (conversion of land utilization)
                            LUC (Agriculture lands –conversion to Non – Agricultural purpose) issued by
                            competent authority.

                            4. Building completion certificate:- The university has not submitted building
                            completion certificate issued by local civil authority in prescribed format. Hence
                            the university is required to submit Building completion certificate issued by
                            local civil authority in prescribed format. (copy enclosed)

                            5. NAAC Certificate :- In institution has submitted NAAC certificate with B.
                            Grade for proposed course but it is valid only for five years. Hence the
                            University is required to renewal the NAAC certificate and submit same to this
                            office.

                            The inspection of the institution was conducted on 30.03.2011. The following
                            deficiencies still persists:

                            The Committee considered the VT Report, VCD and all the relevant
                            documentary evidences and it was decided to serve the Show cause
                            Notice under Section 17 of NCTE Act for the following:

                                 As per VCD observation the building is still under construction and
                                  incomplete.

                                 Games & Sports Facilities are not well organized.

                                 Books available in the library are inadequate, which needs to be
                                  augmented/strengthened.

                             In view of the above, the Committee decided to issue a Show cause
                            Notice to the institution as to why the recognition be not refused and
                            thereby providing an opportunity to the institution to make a written
                            representation within 30 days from the date of issue of the Notice along
                            with necessary certificates/documents in order to take a final decision in
                            the matter; failing which action will be taken including the refusal of
                            recognition, based on the records available, with no further notice.
11.        SRCAPP255        Application seeking grant of recognition for starting D.El.Ed course to SR
             D.El.Ed        College of Education Muslim Minority Institution, No.1, Habsipur,
           SR College of    Dubbak, Medak-502108, Andhra Pradesh.
                                                     11


      (Gangadharaiah)                                                      (Prof. C. Thangamuthu)
      Regional Director, SRC, NCTE                                           Chairman, SRC, NCTE
                                                                                    th
                                                                    Minutes of 204 Meeting of SRC
                                                                                   th  th
                                                                                 27 -28 April 2011
   Education, Medak
                      The Application was scrutinized and a copy of application was sent to State
          AP
                      Government for recommendation on 09.11.2010/02.02.2011. A deficiency
                      letter was issued to the institution on 09.12.2010 for the following Points:

                      1. Fixed Deposit Receipt for Rs 5.00 lakhs of Nationalized bank towards
                      Endowment funds- the institution has submitted the FDR of Rs 5.00 lakhs
                      towards Endowment fund vide no 557272 dated 25.09.2010 for one year
                      issued by Andhra Pradesh Grameena Vikas Bank. Hence the institution is
                      required to submit FDR in original for proposed course from a Nationalised
                      bank as per regulation.

                      2. Fixed Deposit Receipt for Rs 3.00 lakhs of Nationalized bank towards
                      Reserved fund - the institution has submitted the FDR of Rs 3.00 lakhs
                      towards Reserved fund vide no 557273 dated 25.09.2010 for one year issued
                      by Andhara Pradesh Grameena Vikas Bank. Hence the institution is required
                      to submit FDR in original for proposed course from a Nationalised bank as per
                      regulation.

                      4. Notarized copy of Change of land use Certificate issued by the
                      competent authority - the institution has not submitted notarized copy of
                      change of land use certificate issued by the competent authority. Hence the
                      institution is required to submit notarized copy of (conversion of land utilization)
                      CLU (Agriculture lands –conversion to Non – Agricultural purpose) issued by
                      competent authority.

                      5. Building completion certificate:- The institution has not submitted building
                      completion certificate issued by local civil authority in prescribed format. Hence
                      the institution is required to submit Building completion certificate issued by
                      local civil authority in prescribed format. (copy enclosed)

                          6. Minority Certificate:- the institution is minority institution as per
                             application form, however the institution has not submitted minority
                             certificate in this regard. Hence the institution is required to submit
                             minority certificate issued by competent authority .

                      The inspection of the institution was conducted on 31.03.2011

                      The SRC considered, VT report, VCD, reply of the institution and all
                      relevant documents and decided to issue Letter Of Intent for grant of
                      Formal Recognition to D.El.Ed. course of two years duration with an
                      annual intake of 50(Fifty only) (one unit) from the academic year 2011-12
                      subject to the production of valid minority certificate issued by the
                      competent authority in the name of the institution and appointment of
                      qualified staff through duly constituted selection committee as per the
                      Norms of NCTE/State Government/Affiliating University and be given
                      effect before the commencement of the academic session.




                                               12


(Gangadharaiah)                                                       (Prof. C. Thangamuthu)
Regional Director, SRC, NCTE                                            Chairman, SRC, NCTE
                                                                                       th
                                                                        Minutes of 204 Meeting of SRC
                                                                                       th  th
                                                                                     27 -28 April 2011
12.        SRCAPP469        Dr. YSR Elemntary Teacher Training Institute, Rangareddy, AP submitted
              D.El.Ed       an application to SRC-NCTE for grant of recognition for D.El.Ed course on
         YSR Elementary     online 01.10.10.
         Teacher Training
         Institute, Ranga    The Application was scrutinized and a copy of application was sent to State
               Reddy         Government for recommendation on 0911.2010/02.02.2011. A deficiency
                 AP          letter was issued to the institution on 09.12.2010 for the following Points


                                    Certified copy of the registered land documents issued by the
                                     competent authority: the institution has submitted the photocopy
                                     of registered land documents but not certified by competent
                                     authority. Hence the institution should submit certified copy of the
                                     registered land documents issued by the Office of the Sub- Registrar
                                     or competent issuing authority in English version.
                                    Affidavit in the prescribed form on Rs 100/ stamp paper duly
                                     attested ny oath commissioner or notary public, stating the
                                     precise location of the land (village, district, state etc) the
                                     total area in possession, the permission of the competent
                                     authority to use the land for educational purpose and mode
                                     of possession i.e. ownership or lease: the institution has not
                                     submitted the original affidavit of Rs.100/- stamp paper attested by
                                     oath commissioner or Notary public. Hence the institution is required
                                     to submit the original affidavit of Rs.100/- stamp paper duly attested
                                     by oath commissioner of notary public.
                                    Approved building plan by the competent civil authority:
                                     institution has submitted the copy of approved building paln but not
                                     clear. Hence the institution is required to submit fresh blue print
                                     wherein it should be clearly mentioning i.e. Khasra no, plot no,
                                     proposed course, total area, built up area duly approved by
                                     competent authority with resolution in all respect in English. If the
                                     institution has running other teacher education courses/ other
                                     technical courses in the same premises then, the institution shall
                                     submit earmarked area for proposed course with total area and built
                                     up area
                                    Building completion certificate: the institution has not submitted
                                     the building completion certificate. Hence the institution is required
                                     to submit Building completion certificate issued by local civil
                                     authority in prescribed format.(copy enclosed)
                                    Notarized copy of Change of land use certificate issued by the
                                     competent authority: the institution has not submitted the
                                     notarized copy of change of land use certificate issued by the
                                     competent authority. Hence the institution is required to submit
                                     notarized copy of (conversion of land utilization) LUC (Agriculture
                                     lands-conversion to Non-Agricultural purpose) issued by competent
                                     authority.
                                    Minority certificate: the institution is minority institution as per
                                     application form, however the institution has not submitted minority
                                     certificate in this regard. Hence the institution is required to submit
                                     minority certificate issued by competent authority.


                                                     13


      (Gangadharaiah)                                                     (Prof. C. Thangamuthu)
      Regional Director, SRC, NCTE                                          Chairman, SRC, NCTE
                                                                                           th
                                                                            Minutes of 204 Meeting of SRC
                                                                                           th  th
                                                                                         27 -28 April 2011
                               The inspection of the institution was conducted on 30.03.2011. The following
                               deficiencies still persists:

                               The Committee considered the VT Report, VCD and all the relevant
                               documentary evidences and it was decided to serve the Show cause
                               Notice for the following:

                                    As per VCD observation the building is still under construction and
                                     incomplete.

                                    The institution has not submitted valid minority certificate issued by
                                     the competent authority in the name of the institution.

                                In view of the above, the Committee decided to issue a Show cause
                               Notice to the institution as to why the recognition be not refused and
                               thereby providing an opportunity to the institution to make a written
                               representation within 30 days from the date of issue of the Notice along
                               with necessary certificates/documents in order to take a final decision in
                               the matter; failing which action will be taken including the refusal of
                               recognition, based on the records available, with no further notice.
13.         SRCAPP378          Application seeking grant of recognition for starting B.Ed course to Pragathi
               B.Ed            College of Education, No.310, Achampet, Mahbubnagar-509207, Andhra
         Pragathi College of   Pradesh.
             Education,
                               The Application was scrutinized and a copy of application was sent to State
           Mahabubnagar
                               Government for recommendation on 09.11.2010/02.02.2011. A deficiency
                AP
                               letter was issued to the institution on 09.12.2010 for the following Points:

                               1. Notarized copy of Change of land use Certificate issued by the
                               competent authority - the institution has submitted the copy of change of land
                               use certificate issued by the competent authority but it is not Notarized.
                               Hence the institution is required to submit notarized copy of (conversion of land
                               utilization) LUC (Agriculture lands – conversion to Non – Agricultural purpose)
                               issued by competent authority.

                               2. Certified copy of the registered land documents issued by the
                               competent authority:- The institution has submitted the copy of registered
                               land documents in English version but it is not certified. Hence the institution
                               should submit the certified copy of registered land documents issued by the
                               competent authority in English version.

                               3. Approved building plan by the competent civil authority :- Institution has
                               not submitted the building plan. Hence the institution is required to submit fresh
                               blue print of approved building plan wherein it should be clearly mentioning i.e
                               Khasra no, plot no, proposed course, total area, built up area duly approved by
                               competent authority with resolution in all respect in English. If the institution
                               has running other teacher education courses/ other technical courses in the
                               same premises then, the institution shall submit earmarked area for proposed
                               course with total area and built up area.

                                                       14


      (Gangadharaiah)                                                         (Prof. C. Thangamuthu)
      Regional Director, SRC, NCTE                                              Chairman, SRC, NCTE
                                                                                           th
                                                                           Minutes of 204 Meeting of SRC
                                                                                          th  th
                                                                                        27 -28 April 2011

                             4. Building completion certificate:- The institution has not submitted building
                             completion certificate issued by local civil authority in prescribed format. Hence
                             the institution is required to submit Building completion certificate issued by
                             local civil authority in prescribed format. (copy enclosed)

                             5. Minority Certificate:- The institution is minority institution as per application
                             form, however the institution has not submitted minority certificate in this
                             regard. Hence the institution is required to submit minority certificate issued by
                             competent authority.

                             The inspection of the institution was conducted on 31.03.2011. The following
                             deficiencies still persists:

                             The Committee considered the VT Report, VCD and all the relevant
                             documentary evidences and it was decided to serve the Show cause
                             Notice under Section 17 of NCTE Act for the following:

                                  As per VCD observation the building is still under construction and
                                   incomplete.

                                  Building plan from competent authority is to be submitted.

                                The latest Building Completion Certificate from the competent
                                 Government Engineer is not submitted.

                                Certified copy of the registered land documents issued by the
                                 competent authority is to be submitted.

                                  Psychology lab needs to be strengthened.

                                  The number of books available is adequate for B.Ed students.

                             In view of the above, the Committee decided to issue a Show cause
                             Notice to the institution as to why the recognition be not refused and
                             thereby providing an opportunity to the institution to make a written
                             representation within 30 days from the date of issue of the Notice along
                             with necessary certificates/documents in order to take a final decision in
                             the matter; failing which action will be taken including the refusal of
                             recognition, based on the records available, with no further notice.
14.        SRCAPP386         Chaitanya College of Education, No.121/1, Nehrunagar, Kandulapuram,
              D.El.Ed        Cumbum, Prakasam-523333, Andhra Pradesh.
         Chaitanya College
                             The Application was scrutinized and a copy of application was sent to State
           of Education,
                             Government for recommendation on 09.11.2010/02.02.2011. A deficiency
            Prakasam
                             letter was issued to the institution on 09.12.2010 for the following Points:
                AP
                             1. Fixed Deposit Receipt for Rs 5.00 lakhs of Nationalized bank towards
                             Endowment funds- the institution has submitted photo copy of FDR of Rs
                             5.00 lakhs towards Endowment funds vide no 061554 dated 27.09.2010 for
                                                      15


      (Gangadharaiah)                                                        (Prof. C. Thangamuthu)
      Regional Director, SRC, NCTE                                             Chairman, SRC, NCTE
                                                                                    th
                                                                    Minutes of 204 Meeting of SRC
                                                                                   th  th
                                                                                 27 -28 April 2011
                      five years issued by State Bank of Hyderabad. Hence the institution is required
                      to submit original fresh FDR issued for proposed course as per regulation.

                      2. Fixed Deposit Receipt for Rs 3.00 lakhs of Nationalized bank towards
                      Reserved fund - the institution has submitted photo copy of FDR of Rs 3.00
                      lakhs towards Reserved fund vide no 061555 dated 28.09.2010 for five years
                      issued by State Bank of Hyderabad. Hence the institution is required to submit
                      fresh original FDR issued for proposed course as per regulation.

                      3. Notarized copy of Change of land use Certificate issued by the
                      competent authority - the institution has submitted the copy of change of land
                      use certificate issued by the competent authority but it is not notarized. Hence
                      the institution is required to submit notarized copy of (conversion of land
                      utilization) LUC (Agriculture lands –conversion to Non – Agricultural purpose)
                      issued by competent authority.

                      4. Building completion certificate:- The institution has submitted the building
                      completion certificate but it is not in prescribed format and not issued by local
                      civil authority. Hence the institution is required to submit Building completion
                      certificate issued by local civil authority in prescribed format. (copy enclosed)

                      5. Affidavit in the prescribed form on Rs 100/ stamp paper duly attested
                      by oath commissioner or Notary public, stating the precise location of
                      the land (village, district, state etc) the total area in possession, the
                      permission of the competent authority to use the land for educational
                      purpose and mode of possession i.e. ownership or lease: - the institution
                      has submitted photocopy of affidavit of Rs 100/- stamp paper duly attested by
                      oath commissioner or Notary public. Hence the institution is required to submit
                      original affidavit of Rs 100/- stamp paper. LUC referred in affidavit does not
                      tally with LUC filed by institution.

                      6. Minority Certificate:- the institution is minority institution as per application
                      form, however the institution has not submitted minority certificate in this
                      regard. Hence the institution is required to submit minority certificate issued by
                      competent authority.

                      7. Survey No. mentioned in the land documents and affidavit is 121/1 but the
                      No. mentioned in the building plan is 25/A2B. Hence the institution is required
                      clarify the same.

                      The inspection of the institution was conducted on 31.03.2011. The following
                      deficiencies still persists:

                      The Committee considered the VT Report, VCD and all the relevant
                      documentary evidences and it was decided to serve the Show cause
                      Notice for the following:

                              The Sy.number25/A2B in building plan is not matching with land
                               document, Building completion certificate and Land usage
                               certificate and is not clear that where building plan in situated. The
                                               16


(Gangadharaiah)                                                       (Prof. C. Thangamuthu)
Regional Director, SRC, NCTE                                            Chairman, SRC, NCTE
                                                                                        th
                                                                         Minutes of 204 Meeting of SRC
                                                                                        th  th
                                                                                      27 -28 April 2011
                                     management has not submitted approved building plan for college
                                     in Sy.number 121/1.

                                 The built up area of the Multipurpose Hall is inadequate as per NCTE
                                  regulations.

                                 From the VCD observation, the front view of the building is not to be
                                  seen. A fresh VCD or a frontage photo of the building to be
                                  submitted.

                                Psychology lab needs to be strengthened.

                            In view of the above, the Committee decided to issue a Show cause
                            Notice to the institution as to why the recognition be not refused and
                            thereby providing an opportunity to the institution to make a written
                            representation within 30 days from the date of issue of the Notice along
                            with necessary certificates/documents in order to take a final decision in
                            the matter; failing which action will be taken including the refusal of
                            recognition, based on the records available, with no further notice.
15.       SRCAPP278         Mesco College of Education, Hyderabad, Andhra Pradesh submitted an
              B.Ed          application to SRC-NCTE for grant of recognition for B.Ed course on
         Mesco College of   online 27.09.10
           Education,
           Hyderabad        The Application was scrutinized and a copy of application was sent to State
               AP           Government for recommendation on 09.11.2010/02.02.2011 A deficiency letter
                            was issued to the institution on 10.12.2011 for the following Points:

                                    Fixed Deposit Receipt for Rs 5.00 lakhs of Nationalized bank
                                     towards Endowment funds- the institution has submitted photo copy
                                     of FDR of Rs 5.00 lakhs towards Endowment funds vide no 1244114
                                     dated 21.08.2007 for five years issued by Bank of India. Hence the
                                     institution is required to submit FDR in original as per regulation.
                                    Fixed Deposit Receipt for Rs 3.00 lakhs of Nationalized bank
                                     towards Reserved fund - the institution has submitted photo copy of
                                     FDR of Rs 3.00 lakhs towards Reserved fund vide no 0184914 dated
                                     21.08.2001 for five year issued by State Bank of Hyderabad. Hence the
                                     institution is required to submit FDR in original as per regulation
                                    Certified copy of the registered land documents issued by the
                                     competent         authority :- The institution has submitted photocopy of
                                     the Sale Deed, but not certified by the competent authority. Hence, the
                                     institution is required to submit certified copy of the Land Documents
                                     issued by the Office of the Registrar or competent issuing authority
                                    Approved building plan by the competent civil authority :-
                                     Institution has submitted building plan approved but not approved by
                                     civil authority. If the institution has running other teacher education
                                     courses/ other technical courses in the same premises then, the
                                     institution shall submit earmarked area for proposed course with total
                                     area and built up area.

                                                     17


      (Gangadharaiah)                                                      (Prof. C. Thangamuthu)
      Regional Director, SRC, NCTE                                           Chairman, SRC, NCTE
                                                                                    th
                                                                    Minutes of 204 Meeting of SRC
                                                                                   th  th
                                                                                 27 -28 April 2011
                              Notarized copy of Change of land use Certificate issued by the
                               competent authority - the institution has not submitted land use
                               certificate . Hence the institution is required to submit notarized copy of
                               CLU (Agriculture lands -conversion of Non - Agricultural purpose)
                               issued by Revenue Department
                              Affidavit in the prescribed form on Rs 100/- stamp paper duly attested
                               by Oath Commissioner or Notary Public, Stating the precise location of
                               the land (village, district, state etc) the total area in possession, the
                               permission of the competent authority to use the land for educational
                               purposes and mode of possession i.e. ownership or lease. The
                               institution has submitted the affidavit of Rs 100/- stamp paper duly
                               attested by oath commissioner or Notary public but the affidavit is
                               incomplete (Point No.5). Hence the institution is required to submit
                               original affidavit of Rs100/- stamp paper with complete details.
                              Minority Certificate:- the institution is minority institution as per
                               application form, however the institution has not submitted minority
                               certificate in the name of college. Hence the institution is required to
                               submit minority certificate issued by competent authority
                              Building completion certificate:- The institution has not submitted
                               building completion certificate in prescribed format. Hence the
                               institution is required to Building completion certificate in prescribed
                               format. ( copy enclosed).

                      The inspection of the institution was conducted on 31.03.2011. The following
                      deficiencies still persists:

                      The Committee considered the VT Report, VCD and all the relevant
                      documentary evidences and it was decided to serve the Show cause
                      Notice for the following:

                          The institute has not submitted the Land usage certificate from a
                           competent Govt. approved authority.

                              S.R. No 5 is not filled properly in Affidavit of Rs. 100/-

                           Certified copy of the registered land documents issued by the
                            competent authority is not submitted.

                           In the building plan, Khasra number is not mentioned and
                            management has to submit the building plan approved by
                            competent authority.

                          Fresh FDRs for Rs. 5 lacs and Rs, 3 lacs from the Nationalised Bank
                          is to be submitted.

                          Duly filled in questionnaire is not submitted.

                          A Certificate from the Government Affiliating body to the effect that
                           no other programme is being run by the institution in the same
                                                18


(Gangadharaiah)                                                       (Prof. C. Thangamuthu)
Regional Director, SRC, NCTE                                            Chairman, SRC, NCTE
                                                                                          th
                                                                          Minutes of 204 Meeting of SRC
                                                                                         th  th
                                                                                       27 -28 April 2011
                                building / Campus, along with the proposed Course B.Ed to be
                                submitted.

                                The institution has not submitted valid Minority Status Certificate
                                 from the Competent Authority.


                            In view of the above, the Committee decided to issue a Show cause
                            Notice to the institution as to why the recognition be not refused and
                            thereby providing an opportunity to the institution to make a written
                            representation within 30 days from the date of issue of the Notice along
                            with necessary certificates/documents in order to take a final decision in
                            the matter; failing which action will be taken including the refusal of
                            recognition, based on the records available, with no further notice.

16.        SRCAPP245        Vinayaka College of Physical Education, 120/U, Rajiv Road, Thimmareddy
              B.P.Ed        Pally, Kondapak, Medak-502372, Andhra Pradesh.
         Vinayaka College
                            Sri Venkatachalapathi Educational Society, Thimmareddipally, Kondapak,
            of Physical
                            Medak, Andhra Pradesh has submitted an application in the name and style
            Education
                            of Vinayaka College of Physical Education, 120/U, Rajiv Road, Thimmareddy
                AP
                            Pally, Kondapak, Medak-502372, Andhra Pradesh for B.P.Ed course on
                            29.09.2010.

                            The Application was scrutinized and a copy of application was sent to State
                            Government for recommendation on 09.11.2010/02.02.2011. A deficiency
                            letter was issued to the institution on 07.12.2010 for the following points.

                            1. Fixed Deposit Receipt for Rs 5.00 lakhs of Nationalized bank towards
                            Endowment funds- the institution has submitted photo copy of FDR of Rs
                            5.00 lakhs towards Endowment funds vide no 946899 dated 18.08.2010 for
                            one year issued by Andhra Bank. Hence the institution is required to submit
                            FDR in original for proposed course as per regulation.

                            2. Fixed Deposit Receipt for Rs 3.00 lakhs of Nationalized bank towards
                            Reserved fund - the institution has submitted photo copy of FDR of Rs 3.00
                            lakhs towards Reserved fund vide no 946900 dated 18.08.2010 for one year
                            issued by Andhra Bank. Hence the institution is required to submit FDR in
                            original for proposed course as per regulation.

                            3. Certified copy of the registered land documents issued by the
                            competent authority: The institution has submitted photocopy of the sale
                            deed, but not certified by the competent authority. Hence, the institution is
                            required to submit Certified copy of the Land Documents issued by the Office
                            of the Registrar or competent issuing authority.

                            4. Notarized copy of Change of land use Certificate issued by the
                            competent authority - the institution has not submitted notarized copy of
                            change of land use certificate issued by the competent authority. Hence the
                            institution is required to submit notarized copy of (conversion of land utilization)
                                                     19


      (Gangadharaiah)                                                       (Prof. C. Thangamuthu)
      Regional Director, SRC, NCTE                                            Chairman, SRC, NCTE
                                                                                       th
                                                                       Minutes of 204 Meeting of SRC
                                                                                      th  th
                                                                                    27 -28 April 2011
                      LUC (Agriculture lands –conversion to Non – Agricultural purpose) issued by
                      competent authority.

                     5. Building Completion Certificate from Government Engineer is required.
                     The BCC submitted by you is from Licensed Engineer which is not acceptable.

                      The institution has submitted written representation on 04.02.2011. The matter
                      was placed in 202nd meeting of SRC held on 14th-15th March, 2011 along with
                      original file, the committee decided to cause inspection. Hence a consent letter
                      was issued to the institution on 21.03.2011 And inspection was fixed 30th
                      March –2nd April, 2011.

                      The VT members has communicated vide its letter dated 31.03.2011 informing
                      that with reference to our NCTE letter cited they have visited vinayaka College
                      of Physical Education, Thimmareddippalli, Kondapak, Medak Dist, Andhra
                      Pradesh on 31st March, 2011. Nobody is there, building construction is going
                      on. It is upto the roof level, plastering work have not yet initiated. No
                      arrangements have been made for purchasing materials for instructional
                      facilities. Ground for Physical Education is not ready.

                      Note: Institute has not submitted notarized copy of LUC as per clause 7(I)(IV)
                      of Regulation 2009.
                      The institution has submitted a letter dated 25.04.2011 wherein the institution
                      has stated that the visiting team experts called me on 30th June, 2011 for
                      visiting my college, the phone call was received by my relatives due to I was
                      hospitalized in serious condition for colostomy operation and I was not in a
                      position to respond with the expert team at the inspection time. Now we are
                      ready with all facilities i.e., instructional facilities, sports material, library, Admin
                      Area and play ground facilities etc., as per NCTE norms. So I am requesting
                      with your good selves to consider my proposal for Re-inspectioon for the year
                      2011.12. The institution has not submitted any documentary proof in this
                      matter.

                      The Committee considered the VT Report, and all the relevant
                      documentary evidences and it was decided to serve the Show cause
                      Notice for refusal for recognition of the said institution for the following:

                           As per the VT reports dt. 31.03.02011 states that, at the time of visit
                            to the institution nobody is there, building construction is going on.
                            It is up to the roof level, plastering work have not yet initiated. No
                            arrangements have been made for purchasing materials for
                            instructional facilities. Ground for Physical education is not ready.

                           The building is substantially incomplete and is under construction.


                      In view of the above, the Committee decided to issue a Show cause
                      Notice to the institution as to why the recognition be not refused and
                      thereby providing an opportunity to the institution to make a written
                      representation within 30 days from the date of issue of the Notice along
                                                 20


(Gangadharaiah)                                                          (Prof. C. Thangamuthu)
Regional Director, SRC, NCTE                                               Chairman, SRC, NCTE
                                                                                         th
                                                                          Minutes of 204 Meeting of SRC
                                                                                         th  th
                                                                                       27 -28 April 2011
                               with necessary certificates/documents in order to take a final decision in
                               the matter; failing which action will be taken including the refusal of
                               recognition, based on the records available, with no further notice.


17.         SRCAPP99           The District Muslim Education Society D.Ed College, No.243/1,
               D.Ed            Gajbarwadi, Kukkeri Post, Hukkeri, Belgaum District-591309, Karnataka
         The District Muslim
         Education Society     The District Muslim Education Society D.Ed College, No.243/1, Gajbarwadi,
           D.Ed College,       Kukkeri Post, Hukkeri, Belgaum District-591309, Karnataka had submitted an
             Belgaum           application seeking grant of recognition for D.Ed course on 06.11.2009.
                 KA
                               Application was processed and a deficiency letter was issued to the institution
                               on 22.12.2009. The institution has replied to the deficiency letter on
                               18.02.2010.

                               The SRC in its 190th meeting held on March 29-30 2010 considered the reply
                               to the deficiency letter and decided to reject the application. Accordingly, a
                               refusal order was issued to the institution on 28.04.2010.
                               Further, the institution preferred appeal and the appellate authority has
                               reversed the rejection order of SRC vide order dated 15.09.2010. The SRC in
                               its 197th meeting held on 13-14 October 2010 considered the appellate
                               authority order and decided to process the application on merits. Accordingly,
                               application was processed and a Deficiency letter was issued to the institution
                               on 11.01.2011. The institution has submitted its reply on 11.02.2011.

                               The SRC in its 201st meeting held on 22-23 February 2011 considered a reply
                               of the institution and decided to cause inspection under Section 14 of NCTE
                               Act.

                               The inspection was carried out on 31.03.2011. The inspection report has been
                               received along with VCD.

                               The inspection of the institution was conducted on 31.03.2011. The following
                               deficiencies still persists:

                               The Committee considered the VT Report, VCD and all the relevant
                               documentary evidences and it was decided to serve Show cause Notice
                               for the following:

                                   The Land documents submitted is not in favour of the Society or
                                    Institution.

                                   From VCD observation, it is found that the Building is not fully
                                    shown.

                                   The institute has not submitted the Land usage certificate from a
                                    competent Govt. approved authority.

                                                       21


      (Gangadharaiah)                                                       (Prof. C. Thangamuthu)
      Regional Director, SRC, NCTE                                            Chairman, SRC, NCTE
                                                                                          th
                                                                           Minutes of 204 Meeting of SRC
                                                                                          th  th
                                                                                        27 -28 April 2011
                                  Furniture, Books on Methodology and journals in the library are
                                   insufficient,

                               In view of the above, the Committee decided to issue a Show cause
                               Notice to the institution as to why the recognition be not refused thereby
                               providing an opportunity to the institution to make a written
                               representation within 30 days from the date of issue of the Notice along
                               with necessary certificates/documents in order to take a final decision in
                               the matter; failing which action will be taken including the refusal of
                               recognition, based on the records available, with no further notice.


18.        SRCAPP403           Abdul Kalam D.Ed College, Nizamabad, Andhra Pradesh submitted an
                D.Ed           application to SRC-NCTE for grant of recognition for D.El.Ed course on online
         Abdul Kalam D.Ed      01.10.11.
         College of Minority
             Institution,      The Application was scrutinized and a copy of application was sent to State
             Nizamabab         Government for recommendation on 09.12.2010/02.02.2011. A deficiency
                 AP            letter was issued to the institution on 16.12.2010 for the following Points:

                                     Fixed Deposit Receipt for Rs 5.00 lakhs of Nationalized bank
                                      towards Endowment funds- the institution has submitted photo
                                      copy of FDR of Rs 5.00 lakhs towards Endowment fund vide no
                                      585075 dated 29.09.2010 for one year issued by Syndicate Bank.
                                      Hence the institution is required to submit FDR in original as per
                                      regulation.
                                     Fixed Deposit Receipt for Rs 3.00 lakhs of Nationalized bank
                                      towards Reserved fund - the institution has submitted photo copy
                                      of FDR of Rs 3.00 lakhs towards Reserved fund vide no 585074
                                      dated 29.09.2010 for one year issued by Syndicate Bank. Hence the
                                      institution is required to submit FDR in original as per regulation.
                                     Certified copy of the registered land documents issued by the
                                      competent        authority :- The institution has submitted photocopy
                                      of the Sale Deed, but not certified by the competent authority.
                                      Hence, the institution is required to submit certified copy of the
                                      Land Documents issued by the Office of the Registrar or
                                      competent issuing authority
                                     Notarized copy of Change of land use Certificate issued by the
                                      competent authority - the institution has not submitted notarized
                                      copy of change of land use certificate issued by the competent
                                      authority. Hence the institution is required to submit notarized copy
                                      of (conversion of land utilization) CLU (Agriculture lands –conversion
                                      to Non – Agricultural purpose) issued by Revenue department.
                                     Building completion certificate:- The institution has not
                                      submitted building completion certificate issued by local civil
                                      authority in prescribed format. Hence the institution is required to
                                      submit Building completion certificate issued by local civil authority
                                      in prescribed format. (copy enclosed)

                               The committee considered the reply of institution dt. 08/02/2011 for the
                               deficiencies and decided to cause inspection of the institution under Section 14
                                                       22


      (Gangadharaiah)                                                        (Prof. C. Thangamuthu)
      Regional Director, SRC, NCTE                                             Chairman, SRC, NCTE
                                                                                            th
                                                                            Minutes of 204 Meeting of SRC
                                                                                           th  th
                                                                                         27 -28 April 2011
                             of NCTE Act to verify the infrastructural and instructional facilities.

                             The inspection of the institution was conducted on 01.04.2011. The following
                             deficiencies still persists:

                             The Committee considered the VT Report, VCD and all the relevant
                             documentary evidences and it was decided to serve Show cause Notice
                             for the following:

                                 The Certified copy of Land documents is to be submitted.

                                 From VCD observation, it is found that the Building is incomplete.

                             In view of the above, the Committee decided to issue a Show cause
                             Notice to the institution as to why the recognition be not refused thereby
                             providing an opportunity to the institution to make a written
                             representation within 30 days from the date of issue of the Notice along
                             with necessary certificates/documents in order to take a final decision in
                             the matter; failing which action will be taken including the refusal of
                             recognition, based on the records available, with no further notice.
19.        SRCAPP334         Success Hindi Pandit Training College, 4-218, Nidzuru, Kurnool-518004,
                HPT          Andhra Pradesh.
           Success HPT
          College, Kurnool   The Application was scrutinized and a copy of application was sent to State
                             Government for recommendation on 09.11.2010/02.02.2011. A deficiency
                AP           letter was issued to the institution on 17.01.2011 for the following Points:

                             1. Certified copy of the registered land documents issued by the
                             competent authority:- Notarized English version of land documents on which
                             the institution is proposed to be situated may be submitted. It should either be
                             on ownership basis or Govt. lease and not a private lease. The date
                             determined to acceptance should not be after 31.10.2009.

                             2. Building completion certificate:- The institution has submitted the building
                             completion certificate issued by Mandal Assistant Engineer, Kurnool in
                             prescribed format. But the Khasra number/Plot number is not mentioned in the
                             Building Completion Certificate. Hence the institution is required to submit
                             Building completion certificate issued by local civil authority/Government
                             Engineer in prescribed format with the detailed address of the location.
                             The inspection of the institution was conducted on 01.04.2011. The following
                             deficiencies still persists:

                             The Committee considered the VT Report, VCD and all the relevant
                             documentary evidences and it was decided to serve Show cause Notice
                             for the following:

                                 Certified copy of the Registered Land documents by competent
                                  authority is to be submitted.


                                                       23


      (Gangadharaiah)                                                         (Prof. C. Thangamuthu)
      Regional Director, SRC, NCTE                                              Chairman, SRC, NCTE
                                                                                            th
                                                                            Minutes of 204 Meeting of SRC
                                                                                           th  th
                                                                                         27 -28 April 2011
                                  Language learning lab is not available.

                               In view of the above, the Committee decided to issue a Show cause
                              Notice to the institution as to why the recognition be not refused thereby
                              providing an opportunity to the institution to make a written
                              representation within 30 days from the date of issue of the Notice along
                              with necessary certificates/documents in order to take a final decision in
                              the matter; failing which action will be taken including the refusal of
                              recognition, based on the records available, with no further notice.
20.         SRCAPP281
                B.Ed          Indira College of Education, 877/2, 972, Darimadugu Village, Markapur,
          Indira College of   Prakasam-523320, Andhra Pradesh.
             Education,
                              The Application was scrutinized and a copy of application was sent to State
             Prakasam
                              Government for recommendation on 09.11.2010/02.02.2011. A deficiency
                 AP
                              letter was issued to the institution on 09.12.2010 for the following Points:

                              1.Certified copy of the registered land documents issued by the
                              competent authority:- The institution has submitted the copy of registered
                              land documents in Telugu version and it is not notarized. Hence the institution
                              should submit the notarized copy of registered land documents issued by the
                              competent authority in English version.

                              2. Notarized copy of Change of land use Certificate issued by the
                              competent authority - the institution has submitted copy of change of land
                              use certificate issued by the competent authority but it is not notarized. Hence
                              the institution is required to submit notarized copy of (conversion of land
                              utilization) LUC (Agriculture lands –conversion to Non – Agricultural purpose)
                              issued by competent authority.

                              3. Approved building plan by the competent civil authority :- Institution
                              has submitted the copy of approved building plan but not readable. Hence the
                              institution is required to submit fresh blue print wherein it should be clearly
                              mentioning i.e Khasra no, plot no, proposed course, total area, built up area
                              duly approved by competent authority/corporation/municipal/panchayat as the
                              case may be, with resolution in all respect in English. If the institution has
                              running other teacher education courses/ other technical courses in the same
                              premises then, the institution shall submit earmarked area for proposed course
                              with total area and built up area.

                              4. Building completion certificate:- The institution has not submitted building
                              completion certificate issued by local civil authority/government engineer in
                              prescribed format. Hence the institution is required to submit Building
                              completion certificate issued by local civil authority/government engineer in
                              prescribed format. (copy enclosed)

                              5. Minority Certificate:- The institution is minority institution as per application
                              form, however the institution has submitted minority certificate only for 2007-08
                              - 2009-2010 in this regard. Hence the institution is required to submit minority
                              certificate issued by competent authority for 2011-12 onwards .
                                                       24


      (Gangadharaiah)                                                         (Prof. C. Thangamuthu)
      Regional Director, SRC, NCTE                                              Chairman, SRC, NCTE
                                                                                             th
                                                                             Minutes of 204 Meeting of SRC
                                                                                            th  th
                                                                                          27 -28 April 2011
                               The inspection of the institution was conducted on 01.04.2011. The following
                               deficiencies still persists:

                               The Committee considered the VT Report, VCD and all the relevant
                               documentary evidences and it was decided to serve Show cause Notice
                               for the following:

                                   Certified copy of registered land documents from competent
                                    authority is to be submitted.

                                   Address provided in the land documents is for Idupur village,
                                    whereas in Affidavit, application, and Building plan,` it is shown as
                                    Darimadugu Village. This discrepancy is to be explained.

                               In view of the above, the Committee decided to issue a Show cause
                               Notice to the institution as to why the recognition be not refused thereby
                               providing an opportunity to the institution to make a written
                               representation within 30 days from the date of issue of the Notice along
                               with necessary certificates/documents in order to take a final decision in
                               the matter; failing which action will be taken including the refusal of
                               recognition, based on the records available, with no further notice.

21.         SRCAPP290          Siddipet College of Education, Prasanth Nagar, Siddipet, Medak-502103,
                B.Ed           Andhra Pradesh.
         Siddipet College of
                               The Application was scrutinized and a copy of application was sent to State
         Education, Medak
                 AP            Government for recommendation on 09.11.2010/02.02.2011. A
                               deficiency letter was issued to the institution on 09.12.2010 for the following
                               Points:

                               1. Fixed Deposit Receipt for Rs 5.00 lakhs of Nationalized bank towards
                               Endowment funds- the institution has submitted the FDR of Rs 5.00 lakhs
                               towards Endowment funds vide no 353540 dated 27.09.2010 for one year
                               issued by Andhra Pradesh Grameena Vikas Bank. Hence the institution is
                               required to submit FDR in original for proposed course for the period of 1 year
                               from a Nationalised bank as per regulation. Original FDR of Rs.5 lakhs is
                               returned herewith.

                               2. Fixed Deposit Receipt for Rs 3.00 lakhs of Nationalized bank towards
                               Reserved fund - the institution has submitted the FDR of Rs 3.00 lakhs
                               towards Reserved fund vide no 353541 dated 27.09.2010 for one year issued
                               by Andhara Pradesh Grameena Vikas Bank. Hence the institution is required
                               to submit FDR in original for proposed course for the period of 1 year from a
                               Nationalised bank as per regulation. Original FDR of Rs.3 lakhs is returned
                               herewith

                               3. Building completion certificate:- The institution has not submitted building
                               completion certificate issued by local civil authority in prescribed format. Hence
                               the institution is required to submit Building completion certificate issued by
                               local civil authority in prescribed format. (copy enclosed).
                                                        25


      (Gangadharaiah)                                                          (Prof. C. Thangamuthu)
      Regional Director, SRC, NCTE                                               Chairman, SRC, NCTE
                                                                                           th
                                                                           Minutes of 204 Meeting of SRC
                                                                                          th  th
                                                                                        27 -28 April 2011
                             4. Minority Certificate:- the institution is minority institution as per application
                             form, however the institution has not submitted minority certificate in this
                             regard. Hence the institution is required to submit minority certificate issued by
                             competent authority.

                             5. Notarized copy of Change of land use Certificate issued by the
                             competent authority - the institution has not submitted notarized copy of
                             change of land use certificate issued by the competent authority. Hence the
                             institution is required to submit notarized copy of (conversion of land utilization)
                             LUC (Agriculture lands –conversion to Non – Agricultural purpose) issued by
                             competent authority.

                             The inspection of the institution was conducted on 01.04.2011. The following
                             deficiencies still persists:

                             The Committee considered the VT Report, VCD and all the relevant
                             documentary evidences and it was decided to serve Show cause Notice.
                             for the following:

                                 Building Completion Certificate           from   Competent      Government
                                  Engineer is to be submitted.

                                 From VCD observation, it is observed that the building is incomplete.


                                 Language learning lab is not available.

                             In view of the above, the Committee decided to issue a Show cause
                             Notice to the institution as to why the recognition be not refused thereby
                             providing an opportunity to the institution to make a written
                             representation within 30 days from the date of issue of the Notice along
                             with necessary certificates/documents in order to take a final decision in
                             the matter; failing which action will be taken including the refusal of
                             recognition, based on the records available, with no further notice.

22.       SRCAPP409          SR College of Teacher Education Muslim Minority Institution, No.117,
              B.Ed           Dubbak, H Road, Medak-502108, Andhra Pradesh.
          SR College of
        Teacher Education,
                             The Application was scrutinized and a copy of application was sent to State
             Medak
                             Government for recommendation on 09.11.2010/02.02.2011. A deficiency
               AP
                             letter was issued to the institution on 09.12.2010 for the following Points:

                             1. Fixed Deposit Receipt for Rs 5.00 lakhs of Nationalized bank towards
                             Endowment funds- the institution has submitted the photo copy of FDR of Rs
                             5.00 lakhs towards Endowment funds vide no 557286 dated 29.09.2010 for
                             one year issued by Andhra Pradesh Grameena Vikas Bank. Hence the
                             institution is required to submit FDR in original for proposed course from a
                             Nationalised bank as per regulation.

                                                      26


      (Gangadharaiah)                                                        (Prof. C. Thangamuthu)
      Regional Director, SRC, NCTE                                             Chairman, SRC, NCTE
                                                                                          th
                                                                          Minutes of 204 Meeting of SRC
                                                                                         th  th
                                                                                       27 -28 April 2011

                            2. Fixed Deposit Receipt for Rs 3.00 lakhs of Nationalized bank towards
                            Reserved fund - the institution has submitted the photo copy of FDR of Rs
                            3.00 lakhs towards Reserved fund vide no 552787 dated 29.09.2010 for one
                            year issued by Andhra Pradesh Grameena Vikas Bank. Hence the institution is
                            required to submit FDR in original for proposed course from a Nationalised
                            bank as per regulation.

                            3. Notarized copy of Change of land use Certificate issued by the
                            competent authority - The institution has not submitted the copy of change of
                            land use certificate issued by the competent authority. Hence the institution is
                            required to submit notarized copy of (conversion of land utilization) LUC
                            (Agriculture lands – conversion to Non – Agricultural purpose) issued by
                            competent authority.

                            4. Building completion certificate:- The institution has submitted the building
                            completion certificate which is not issued by local civil authority/Government
                            Engineer and it is not in prescribed format. Hence the institution is required to
                            submit     Building    completion     certificate  issued     by     local   civil
                            authority/Government Engineer in prescribed format. (copy enclosed)

                            5. Minority Certificate:- the institution is minority institution as per application
                            form, however the institution has not submitted minority certificate in this
                            regard. Hence the institution is required to submit minority certificate issued by
                            competent authority

                           6. Duly notarized copy of registered land document to be filed.
                            The inspection of the institution was conducted on 01.04.2011. The following
                            deficiencies still persists:

                            The Committee considered the VT Report, VCD and all the relevant
                            documentary evidences and it was decided to serve Show cause Notice.
                            for the following:

                                From VCD observation, it is observed that the building is incomplete.

                                Language learning lab is not available.

                            In view of the above, the Committee decided to issue a Show cause
                            Notice to the institution as to why the recognition be not refused thereby
                            providing an opportunity to the institution to make a written
                            representation within 30 days from the date of issue of the Notice along
                            with necessary certificates/documents in order to take a final decision in
                            the matter; failing which action will be taken including the refusal of
                            recognition, based on the records available, with no further notice.


23.        SRCAPP338        Global College of Education, Prakasam, Andhra Pradesh submitted an
              B.Ed          application to SRC-NCTE for grant of recognition for B.Ed course on

                                                     27


      (Gangadharaiah)                                                       (Prof. C. Thangamuthu)
      Regional Director, SRC, NCTE                                            Chairman, SRC, NCTE
                                                                                   th
                                                                    Minutes of 204 Meeting of SRC
                                                                                   th  th
                                                                                 27 -28 April 2011
   Global College of   online 29.09.10.
      Education,
      Prakasam         The Application was scrutinized and a copy of application was sent to State
          AP           Government for recommendation on 09.11.2010/14.02.2011. A deficiency
                       letter was issued to the institution on 10.12.2010 for the following Points:

                              Fixed Deposit Receipt for Rs.500 lakhs of Nationalised Bank
                               Towards Endowment Funds: the institution has submitted photo
                               copy of FDR of Rs.5.00 lakhs towards Endowment funds vide no
                               0873423 dated 28.09.2010 for five years issued by State Bank of
                               India. Hence the institution is required to submit FDR in original for
                               proposed course as per regulation.
                              Fixed Deposit Receipt for Rs.3.00 lakhs of Natrionalised Bank
                               Towards Reserved fund: the insitution has submitted photo copy
                               of FDR of Rs.3.00 lakhs towards Reserved fund vide no. 0873422
                               dated 28.09.2010 for five years issued by State Bank of India.
                               Hence the institution is required to submit FDR in original proposed
                               course as per regulation.
                              Certified copy of the registered land documents issued by the
                               competent authority: the institution has submitted the registered
                               land documents in Telugu version. Hence the institution should
                               submit the certified copy of registered land documents issued by
                               the office of Sub-Register or competent issuing authority in English
                               version issued in the favour of Society/institution
                              Notarized copy of Change of land use Certificate issued by the
                               competent authority: the institution has not submitted the
                               notarized copy of change of land use certificate issued by the
                               competent authoirty. Hence the institution is required to submit
                               notarized copy of (conversion of land utilization) LUC (Agriculture
                               lands-conversion to Non-Agricultural purpose) issued by competent
                               authority.
                              Building completion certificate: the institution has not submitted
                               building      completion     certificate   issued    by    local     civil
                               authority/Government Engineer in prescribed format. Hence the
                               institution is required to submit Building completion certificate issued
                               by local civil authority in prescribed format.(copy enclosed)
                              Minority certificate: the institution is minority institution as per
                               application form, however the institution has not submitted minority
                               certificate in this regard. Hence the institution is required to submit
                               minority certificate issued by competent authority.
                              Building      plan    duly    approved     by   competent     authority-
                               corporation/municipal/ Panchayat, as the case may be to be
                               submitted giving total land area and built up area.

                       The committee considered the reply of institution dt. 08/02/2011 for the
                       deficiencies and decided to cause inspection of the institution under Section 14
                       of NCTE Act to verify the infrastructural and instructional facilities.

                       The inspection of the institution was conducted on 02.04.2011. The following
                       deficiencies still persists:

                                                28


(Gangadharaiah)                                                       (Prof. C. Thangamuthu)
Regional Director, SRC, NCTE                                            Chairman, SRC, NCTE
                                                                                     th
                                                                      Minutes of 204 Meeting of SRC
                                                                                     th  th
                                                                                   27 -28 April 2011
                             The Committee considered the VT Report, VCD and all the relevant
                             documentary evidences and it was decided to serve the Show cause
                             Notice for the following:

                                 The total Built up area earmarked for the B.Ed programme is only
                                  10320 Sq. ft. which is grossly inadequate for the Teacher Education
                                  Programme as per NCTE norms. The same is also corroborated by
                                  the management by affixing signature of the management
                                  representative in the essential data. As per NCTE norms, the total
                                  built up area required is 16000 sq.ft.

                                 The size of multipurpose hall is 1000 sq.ft. which is less than the
                                  NCTE norms.

                                 Education Technology lab needs to be strengthened.

                                 Furniture in the library needs to be increased/strengthened.

                                    Journals & Encyclopedias are not available in the Library.

                             In view of the above, the Committee decided to issue a Show cause
                             Notice to the institution as to why the recognition be not refused and
                             thereby providing an opportunity to the institution to make a written
                             representation within 30 days from the date of issue of the Notice along
                             with necessary certificates/documents in order to take a final decision in
                             the matter; failing which action will be taken including the refusal of
                             recognition, based on the records available, with no further notice.
24.        SRCAPP463         SPG College of Education, Kurnool, . Andhra Pradesh submitted an
               B.Ed          application
        SPG College of       to SRC-NCTE for grant of recognition for B.Ed course on online 10/10/2010.
        Education, Kurnool
                AP           The Application was scrutinized and a copy of application was sent to State
                             Government for recommendation on 09.11.2010/04.02.2011. A deficiency
                             letter was issued to the institution on 09.12.2010 for the following Points:

                              Notarized copy of change of land use certificate issued by the
                               competent authority: the institution has not submitted the copy of
                               change of land use certificate issued by the competent authority. Hence
                               the institution is required to submit notarized copy of (conversion of
                               land utilization) LUC(Agriculture lands- conversion to Non-Agricultural
                               purpose) issued by competent authority.
                              Certified copy of the registered land documents issued by the
                               competent authority: the institution the registered land documents in
                               Telugu version and it is not certified/notarized by competent authority.
                               Hence the institution should submit the certified/notarized copy of
                               registered land documents issued by the revenue authority in English
                               version.
                              Approved building plan by the competent authority: institution has
                               submitted the copy of building plan not approved by competent
                               authority. Hence the institution is required to submit fresh blue print
                                                    29


      (Gangadharaiah)                                                   (Prof. C. Thangamuthu)
      Regional Director, SRC, NCTE                                        Chairman, SRC, NCTE
                                                                                  th
                                                                   Minutes of 204 Meeting of SRC
                                                                                   th  th
                                                                                27 -28 April 2011
                          wherein it should be clearly mentioning i.e. Khasra no, plot no,
                          proposed course, total area, built up area duly approved by competent
                          authority- corporation/municipal/panchayat as the case may e with
                          resolution in all respect in English. If the institution has running other
                          teacher education courses/other technical courses in the same premises
                          then, the institution shall submit earmarked area for proposed course
                          with total area and built up area.
                         Building completion certificate: the institution has submitted the
                          building completion certificate but it is not issued by local civil authority.
                          Hence the institution is required is required to submit Building
                          completion certificate issued by local civil authority/Government
                          Engineer in prescribed format.(copy enclosed)
                         Affidavit in the prescribed form on Rs 100/ stamp paper duly
                          attested ny oath commissioner or notary public, stating the
                          precise location of the land (village, district, state etc) the total
                          area in possession, the permission of the competent authority to
                          use the land for educational purpose and mode of possession i.e.
                          ownership or lease:the institution has submitted photocopy of
                          affidavit of Rs.100/- stamp paper duly attested by oath commissioner or
                          Notary public. Hence the institution is required to submit original
                          affidavit of Rs.100/- stamp paper. The affidavit is signed by the
                          president of the society but the person submitting the application online
                          their name is not given is not member as per the society documents.
                          Institution may clarify. The affidavit does not specify course applied for
                         Minority certificate: the institution is minority institution as per
                          application form, however the institution has not submitted minority
                          certificate in this regard. Hence the institution is required to submit
                          minority certificate issued by competent authority.
                         Institute to confirm whether FDRs are submitted.

                      The committee considered the reply of institution dt. 08/02/2011 for the
                      deficiencies and decided to cause inspection of the institution under Section 14
                      of NCTE Act to verify the infrastructural and instructional facilities.
                      The inspection of the institution was conducted on 02.04.2011. The following
                      deficiencies still persists:

                      The Committee considered the VT Report, VCD and all the relevant
                      documentary evidences and it was decided to serve the Show cause
                      Notice for the following:

                        Land documents are in individual‟s Name and not in the Name of the
                         Society/Trust/Institution as per NCTE Norms. In the translation copy of
                         sale deed dt. 03.01.1901 submitted by the institution land is in
                         individual name of Arthur Youngman representing SPG Missionary;
                         however, this name does not appear in the list of office bearers of
                         Trust. Land has to be in the name of the college/trust on the date of
                         application as per 2009 regulations.

                        A per VCD, a School is run in the same building/campus in which
                         teacher education programmes are proposed to be conducted.

                                               30


(Gangadharaiah)                                                      (Prof. C. Thangamuthu)
Regional Director, SRC, NCTE                                           Chairman, SRC, NCTE
                                                                                       th
                                                                        Minutes of 204 Meeting of SRC
                                                                                       th  th
                                                                                     27 -28 April 2011
                              Language learning lab is not available.

                              The management is also running D.Ed programme in the same building
                               and the details of separate earmarked Built up area for each of the
                               Teacher Education Programme is to be given.

                            In view of the above, the Committee decided to issue a Show cause
                            Notice to the institution as to why the recognition be not refused and
                            thereby providing an opportunity to the institution to make a written
                            representation within 30 days from the date of issue of the Notice along
                            with necessary certificates/documents in order to take a final decision in
                            the matter; failing which action will be taken including the refusal of
                            recognition, based on the records available, with no further notice.
25.       SRCAPP361         Syed Jamal Memorial College of Education, Nalgonda AP submitted an
              B.Ed          application to SRC-NCTE for grant of recognition for B.Ed course on
           Syed Jamal       online 29.09.10 .
         Memorial College
          of Education,     The Application was scrutinized and a copy of application was sent to State
            Nalgonda        Government for recommendation on 09.11.10 / 04.02.11 A deficiency letter
               AP           was issued to the institution on 09.12.2010 for the following Points:

                                    Notarized copy of Change of land use Certificate issued by the
                                     competent authority: the institution is required to submit
                                     notarized copy of (coversion of land utilization) LUC (Agriculture
                                     lands- conversion to Non- Agricultural purpose) issued by competent
                                     authority.
                                    Building completion certificate: the institution has not submitted
                                     building completion certificate issued by local civil authority in
                                     prescribed format. Hence the institution is required to submit
                                     Building    completion      certificate issued      by   local civil
                                     authoirty/Government Engineer in prescribed format. (copy
                                     enclosed)
                                    Certified copy of the registered land documents issued by the
                                     competent authority: the institution has submitted the registered
                                     land documents in English version but not certified/notarized by
                                     competent authority/Government Engineer. Hence the institution
                                     should submited the certified/notarized copy of registered land
                                     documents issued by the competent authority.
                                    Minority certificate for 2011-12 onwards is to be submitted.
                                    Survey No. 203 which is reflected in all land documents is not
                                     matching with application form.

                            The committee considered the reply of institution dt. 08/02/2011 for the
                            deficiencies and decided to cause inspection of the institution under Section 14
                            of NCTE Act to verify the infrastructural and instructional facilities.

                            The inspection of the institution was conducted on 02.04.2011. The following
                            deficiencies still persists:

                            The Committee considered the VT Report, VCD and all the relevant
                                                    31


      (Gangadharaiah)                                                     (Prof. C. Thangamuthu)
      Regional Director, SRC, NCTE                                          Chairman, SRC, NCTE
                                                                                       th
                                                                        Minutes of 204 Meeting of SRC
                                                                                       th  th
                                                                                     27 -28 April 2011
                            documentary evidences and it was decided to serve the Show cause
                            Notice for the following:

                                 As per VCD observation the building is still under construction and
                                  incomplete.

                                 Survey number 203, which is reflected in all land documents, is not
                                  matching with the application form.

                            In view of the above, the Committee decided to issue a Show cause
                            Notice to the institution as to why the recognition be not refused and
                            thereby providing an opportunity to the institution to make a written
                            representation within 30 days from the date of issue of the Notice along
                            with necessary certificates/documents in order to take a final decision in
                            the matter; failing which action will be taken including the refusal of
                            recognition, based on the records available, with no further notice.
26.        SRCAPP239        Poondi Pudhumai Madha College of Education, Trichy District,
               B.Ed         Tamilnadu
        Poondi Pudhumai
        Madha College of    Kumbakonam Diocese Society, Nagapattinam, Tamilnadu submitted an
        Education, Trichy   application in the name of Poondi Puthumai Madha College of Education,
                TN          Trichy, Tamilnadu through on-line on 24.09.2010. The hard copy of the
                            application was received in this office on 07.10.2010.

                            The application was scrutinized in accordance with clause 7 and 8 of NCTE
                            Regulation 2009 and deficiencies were pointed out. Accordingly deficiency
                            letter was issued to the institution on 06.01.2011. The institution submitted
                            required documents vide letter dt.04.03.2011:


                            The committee in its 202nd meeting held on 14th-15th March 2011 considered
                            the written representation and decided to cause inspection of the institution
                            under Section 14 of NCTE Act to verify the infrastructural and instructional
                            facilities.

                            Accordingly, inspection of the institution was conducted on 04.04.2011. The file
                            alongwith VT report is placed again before SRC is as follows:

                            The inspection of the institution was conducted on 04.04.2011. The following
                            deficiencies still persists:

                            The Committee considered the VT Report, VCD and all the relevant
                            documentary evidences and it was decided to serve the Show cause
                            Notice for the following:

                             A certificate from the affiliating body to the effect that no other
                             programme is being run/shared by the institution in the same campus
                             along with the existing course B.Ed, is to be submitted.


                                                    32


      (Gangadharaiah)                                                     (Prof. C. Thangamuthu)
      Regional Director, SRC, NCTE                                          Chairman, SRC, NCTE
                                                                                       th
                                                                        Minutes of 204 Meeting of SRC
                                                                                       th  th
                                                                                     27 -28 April 2011
                              From VCD it is observed that the full building is not shown.

                              Non-Encumbrance certificate from the competent authority is not
                               submitted.

                             In view of the above, the Committee decided to issue a Show cause
                             Notice to the institution as to why the recognition be not refused and
                             thereby providing an opportunity to the institution to make a written
                             representation within 30 days from the date of issue of the Notice along
                             with necessary certificates/documents in order to take a final decision in
                             the matter; failing which action will be taken including the refusal of
                             recognition, based on the records available, with no further notice.
27.        SRCAPP240         E.G.S. Pillay College of Education, Nagapattinam District, Tamilnadu
             B.El.Ed
           E.G.S. Pillay     G.S.Pillay & Sons Charitable & Educational Trust, Nagapattinam, Tamilnadu
            College of       submitted an application in the name of E.G.S. Pillay College of Education,
            Education,       Nagapattinam, Tamilnadu through on-line on 24.09.2010. The hard copy of the
           Nagapattinam      application was received in this office on 29.09.2010.
               TN
                             The application was scrutinized in accordance with clause 7 and 8 of NCTE
                             Regulation 2009 and deficiencies were pointed out. Accordingly deficiency
                             letter was issued to the institution on 07.01.2011. The institution submitted
                             required documents vide letter dt.24.01.2011:

                             The committee in its 202nd meeting held on 14th-15th March 2011 considered
                             the written representation and decided to cause inspection of the institution
                             under Section 14 of NCTE Act to verify the infrastructural and instructional
                             facilities.

                             Accordingly, inspection of the institution was conducted on 08.04.2011. The
                             committee has noted that the following deficiencies still persist:
                              In the Affidavit the built up area is not mentioned.
                              Non-Encumbrance certificate from the competent authorities is not submitted.
                              Language learning lab is not available.
                              Certified copy of registered land document from the competent authority is
                               not submitted and further,

                              The committee has decided to defer the decision on this case and await
                             for guidelines for Infrastructural norms from NCTE Hqr, for colleges
                             seeking to start B.El.Ed courses,
28.        SRCAPP289         Ali College of Education, Guntur, . Andhra Pradesh submitted an
                B.Ed         application to SRC-NCTE for grant of recognition for B.Ed course on
           Ali College of    28/09/2010.
         Education, Guntur   The Application was scrutinized and a copy of application was sent to State
                 AP          Government for recommendation on 09.11.2010/02.02.2011 A deficiency letter
                             was issued to the institution on 03.02.2011 for the following Points:

                              Certified copy of the registered land documents issued by the Office of the
                               Sub-Registrar/issuing authority: the institution has submitted the registered
                                                     33


      (Gangadharaiah)                                                     (Prof. C. Thangamuthu)
      Regional Director, SRC, NCTE                                          Chairman, SRC, NCTE
                                                                                        th
                                                                         Minutes of 204 Meeting of SRC
                                                                                        th  th
                                                                                      27 -28 April 2011
                              land documents in English version but it is not certified by competent
                              authority. Hence the institution should submit the certified copy of
                              registered land documents issued by the Office of the Sub-Registrar or
                              competent issuing authority in English version.
                             Notarized copy Change of land use certificate issued by the competent
                              authority: the institution has not submitted the notarized copy of change of
                              land use certificate issued by the competent authoirty. Hence the institution
                              is required to submit notarized copy of (conversion of land utilization) LUC
                              (Agriculture lands-conversion to Non-Agricultural purpose) issued by
                              competent authority.

                             Building completion certificate:   the institution has submitted photocopy of
                              building completion certificate    issued by local civil authority but not in
                              prescribed format. Hence the        institution is required to submit Building
                              completion certificate issued      by local civil authority/Govt.Engineer in
                              prescribed format.

                             Minority certificate: the institution is minority institution as per application
                              form, however the institution has not submitted minority certificate in this
                              regard. Hence the institution is required to submit minority certificate issued
                              by competent authority.

                            The committee considered the reply of institution dt. 03/02/2011 for the
                            deficiencies and decided to cause inspection of the institution under Section 14
                            of NCTE Act to verify the infrastructural and instructional facilities.

                            The inspection under section 14 of the institution was conducted on
                            05.04.2011.

                            On careful perusal of the original file of the institution, VT Reports and
                            other related documents, Act of NCTE, 1993, Regulations and guidelines
                            of NCTE published from time to time laid on the table, the Regional
                            Committee decided to issue Letter of Intent for grant of recognition to
                            B.Ed course of One year duration with an annual intake of 100(One
                            Hundred only)(one unit) from the academic year 2011-12 subject to the
                            production of valid minority certificate issued by the competent authority
                            in the name of the institution & appointment of qualified staff through
                            duly constituted selection committee as per the Norms of NCTE/State
                            Government/Affiliating University and be given           effect before the
                            commencement of the academic session.

29.        SRCAPP405        Vamsadhara TPT College, Srikakulam, Andhra Pradesh submitted an
                TPT         application to SRC-NCTE for grant of recognition for TPT  course
         Vamsadhara TPT,    on01/10/2010.
            Srikakulam
                AP          The Application was scrutinized and a copy of application was sent to State
                            Government for recommendation on 02.12.2010/14.02.2011. A deficiency
                            letter was issued to the institution on 15.02.2011 for the following Points:

                                    Fixed Deposit Receipt for Rs 5.00 lakhs of Nationalized bank
                                                   34


      (Gangadharaiah)                                                      (Prof. C. Thangamuthu)
      Regional Director, SRC, NCTE                                           Chairman, SRC, NCTE
                                                                                 th
                                                                   Minutes of 204 Meeting of SRC
                                                                                    th  th
                                                                                 27 -28 April 2011
                               towards Endowment funds- the institution has submitted photo
                               copy of FDR of Rs 5.00 lakhs towards Endowment funds vide no
                               388264 dated 28.09.2010 for five years issued by Andhra Bank,
                               Hence the institution is required to submit original fresh FDR issued
                               for proposed course as per regulation.
                              Fixed Deposit Receipt for Rs 3.00 lakhs of Nationalized bank
                               towards Reserved fund - the institution has submitted photo copy
                               of FDR of Rs 3.00 lakhs towards Reserved fund vide no 388265
                               dated 28.09.2010 for five years issued by Andhra Bank. Hence the
                               institution is required to submit fresh original FDR issued for
                               proposed course as per regulation.
                              Certified copy of the registered land documents issued by the
                               competent        authority :- The institution has submitted photocopy
                               of the Sale Deed, but not certified by the competent authority.
                               Hence, the institution is required to submit certified copy of the
                               Land Documents issued by the Office of the Sub- Registrar or
                               competent issuing authority
                              Building completion certificate:- The institution has not
                               submitted building completion certificate issued by local civil
                               authority in prescribed format. Hence the institution is required to
                               submit Building completion certificate issued by local civil authority
                               in prescribed format. (copy enclosed)
                              Notarized copy of Change of land use Certificate issued by the
                               competent authority - the institution has submitted the copy of
                               change of land use certificate issued by the competent authority
                               but it is not Notarized. Hence the institution is required to submit
                               notarized copy of (conversion of land utilization) LUC (Agriculture
                               lands – conversion to Non – Agricultural purpose) issued by
                               competent authority.
                              Affidavit in the prescribed form on Rs 100/ stamp paper duly
                               attested by oath commissioner or Notary public, stating the
                               precise location of the land (village, district, state etc) the
                               total area in possession, the permission of the competent
                               authority to use the land for educational purpose and mode
                               of possession i.e. ownership or lease: - the institution has
                               submitted photocopy of affidavit of Rs 100/- stamp paper duly
                               attested by oath commissioner or Notary public. Hence the
                               institution is required to submit original affidavit of Rs 100/- stamp
                               paper.
                              The survey No. 264/7 not reflected in Building plan.                The
                               S.No.265/3 in building plan is not supported by land document.
                      The committee considered the reply of institution dt. 08/02/2011 for the
                      deficiencies and decided to cause inspection of the institution under Section 14
                      of NCTE Act to verify the infrastructural and instructional facilities.

                      The inspection of the institution under section 14 was conducted on
                      06.04.2011. The following deficiencies still persists:

                      The Committee considered the VT Report, VCD and all the relevant
                      documentary evidences and it was decided to serve the Show cause
                      Notice for the following:
                                               35


(Gangadharaiah)                                                     (Prof. C. Thangamuthu)
Regional Director, SRC, NCTE                                          Chairman, SRC, NCTE
                                                                                          th
                                                                          Minutes of 204 Meeting of SRC
                                                                                         th  th
                                                                                       27 -28 April 2011

                              The total Built up area earmarked for TPT programme is only 4600 Sq.
                               ft. which is grossly inadequate for the TPT as per NCTE norms. The
                               same is also corroborated by the management by affixing signature of
                               the management representative in the essential data.

                              Certified copy of the registered land documents issued by the
                               competent authority is to be submitted.

                              Notarised copy of Land usage certificate issued by competent authority
                               is to be submitted.

                              The survey numbers 263/2 & 264/7 mentioned in Building Completion
                               Certificate is not matching with Building plan.

                              As per approval of Gram Panchayat of the Building plan, the survey
                               numbers are 265/3 & 263/2. The survey number 265/3 is not given in
                               land document.

                              The seating capacity in the library is only for 25 (for both B.Ed & TPT)
                               which is not sufficient.

                              The Lab facilities are to be shared along with B.Ed programme.

                             In view of the above, the Committee decided to issue a Show cause
                             Notice to the institution as to why the recognition be not refused and
                             thereby providing an opportunity to the institution to make a written
                             representation within 30 days from the date of issue of the Notice along
                             with necessary certificates/documents in order to take a final decision in
                             the matter; failing which action will be taken including the refusal of
                             recognition, based on the records available, with no further notice.
30.         SRCAPP200        Dr.B.R.Ambedkar University, Srikakulam College of Education Andhra Pradesh
                M.Ed         submitted an application to SRC-NCTE for grant of recognition for M.Ed course
         Dr. B.R. Ambedkar   on 06/08/2010
             University,
             Srikakulam      The Application was scrutinized and a copy of application was sent to State
                 AP          Government for recommendation on 02/11/2010/ & 02/02/2011. A deficiency
                             letter was issued to the institution on 09/12/2010 for the following Points:

                              Notarized copy of change of land use certificate issued by the competent
                               authority: The institution has submitted land use certificate but not notarized.
                               Hence the institution is required to submit notarized copy of LUC(Agriculture
                               lands- conversion of Non-Agricultural purpose) issued by Revenue
                               Department.
                              Affidavit in the prescribed form on Rs 100/ stamp paper duly attested ny oath
                               commissioner or notary public, stating the precise location of the land (village,
                               district, state etc) the total area in possession, the permission of the
                               competent authority to use the land for educational purpose and mode of
                               possession i.e. ownership or lease: the institution has submitted an affidavit
                                                      36


      (Gangadharaiah)                                                       (Prof. C. Thangamuthu)
      Regional Director, SRC, NCTE                                            Chairman, SRC, NCTE
                                                                                   th
                                                                   Minutes of 204 Meeting of SRC
                                                                                  th  th
                                                                                27 -28 April 2011
                        of Rs 100/- but the same does not mention the Sy.No. where the proposed
                        course is to be run. Hence the institution is required to submit fresh affidavit
                        of Rs 100/- stamp paper, containing survey No, plot No. duly notarized
                        complete in all respects.
                       Approved building plan by the competent civil authority: institution has not
                        submitted building plan. Hence the institution is required to submit approved
                        building plan approved by civil competent authority. Wherein it should be
                        clearly mentioning i.e.Khashara no, plot no, proposed course, total area, built
                        up           area         duly         approved             by        competent
                        authority/corporation/municipal/panchayat as the case may be, with
                        resolution in all respect either or Engilsh or Hindi language. If the institution
                        hs running other teacher education courses/other technical courses in the
                        same premises then, the institution shall submit earmarked area for proposed
                        course with total area and built up area.
                       Building completion certificate: the institution has not submitted building
                        completion certificate. Hence the institution is required to submit Building
                        completion certificate issued by local civil authority. (copy enclosed).
                       NAAC Certificate: in institution has not submitted NAAC certificate with B
                        Grade for proposed course. Hence the institution is required to submit NAAC
                        certificate with B Gradde.
                       Duly certified copy of land documents to be filed.

                      The committee considered the reply of institution dt. 25/01/2011 for the
                      deficiencies and decided to cause inspection of the institution under Section 15
                      of NCTE Act to verify the infrastructural and instructional facilities.

                      The inspection of the institution under section 14 was conducted on
                      06.04.2011. The following deficiencies still persists:

                      The Committee considered the VT Report, VCD and all the relevant
                      documentary evidences and it was decided to serve the Show cause
                      Notice for the following:

                       The total Built up area earmarked for the M.Ed is 2029 sq.ft. which is
                        grossly inadequate for the M.Ed as per NCTE norms. The same is also
                        corroborated by the management by affixing signature of the
                        management representative in the essential data.

                       The committee also decided to issue notice immediately for stopping of
                        M.Ed course if they are already running the course without NCTE
                        recognition.

                       The Library has 1667 books related to the education which is less than
                        required as per NCTE norms.

                      In view of the above, the Committee decided to issue a Show cause
                      Notice to the institution as to why the recognition be not refused and
                      thereby providing an opportunity to the institution to make a written
                      representation within 30 days from the date of issue of the Notice along
                                               37


(Gangadharaiah)                                                      (Prof. C. Thangamuthu)
Regional Director, SRC, NCTE                                           Chairman, SRC, NCTE
                                                                                             th
                                                                             Minutes of 204 Meeting of SRC
                                                                                            th  th
                                                                                          27 -28 April 2011
                               with necessary certificates/documents in order to take a final decision in
                               the matter; failing which action will be taken including the refusal of
                               recognition, based on the records available, with no further notice.
31.        SRCAPP425           Venkata Surya College of Physical Education, Vizianagaram ,Andhra Pradesh
               B.P.Ed          submitted an application to SRC-NCTE for grant of recognition for B.P.Ed.
          Venkata Surya        course on online 01.10.10.
         College of Physical
             Education,        The Application was scrutinized and a copy of application was sent to State
           Vizianagaram        Government for recommendation on 09.11.2010/04.02.2011 A deficiency
                 AP            letter was issued to the institution on 09.12.2010 for the following Points:

                                     Approved building plan by the competent civil authority :-
                                      Institution has submitted building plan but not earmarked area for
                                      existing course and proposed course. Hence the institution is
                                      required to submit fresh approved building plan. wherein it should
                                      be clearly mentioning i.e Khashara no, plot no, proposed course,
                                      total area, built up area duly approved by competent authority with
                                      resolution in all respect either or English or Hindi language. If the
                                      institution has running other teacher education courses/ other
                                      technical courses in the same premises then, the institution shall
                                      submit earmarked area for proposed course with total area and built
                                      up area.
                                     Notarized copy of Change of land use Certificate issued by the competent
                                      authority - the institution has not submitted land use certificate . Hence the
                                      institution is required to submit notarized copy of LUC (Agriculture lands -
                                      conversion of Non - Agricultural purpose) issued by Revenue Department
                                     Building completion certificate:- The institution has not submitted
                                      building completion certificate. Hence the institution is required to
                                      submit Building completion certificate issued by local civil
                                      authority/in prescribe format. (copy enclosed)
                                     The institution is required to submit a copy of bye-
                                      laws/Registration of society/Trust in case of private institution.
                                     Duly certified/notarized copy of registered sale deed to be
                                      filed.

                               The committee considered the reply of institution dt. 08/02/2011 for the
                               deficiencies and decided to cause inspection of the institution under Section 14
                               of NCTE Act to verify the infrastructural and instructional facilities.


                               The inspection of the institution under section 14 was conducted on
                               07.04.2011. The following deficiencies still persists:

                               The Committee considered the VT Report, VCD and all the relevant
                               documentary evidences and it was decided to serve the Show cause
                               Notice for the following:

                                The management is running other programames in the same building
                                 /campus. A certificate from Government/affiliating body to the effect
                                 that no other programme is being run/shared by the institution in the
                                                        38


      (Gangadharaiah)                                                          (Prof. C. Thangamuthu)
      Regional Director, SRC, NCTE                                               Chairman, SRC, NCTE
                                                                                    th
                                                                      Minutes of 204 Meeting of SRC
                                                                                     th  th
                                                                                   27 -28 April 2011
                              same building/campus along with the B.P.Ed course is to be submitted.


                            In view of the above, the Committee decided to issue a Show cause
                            Notice to the institution as to why the recognition be not refused and
                            thereby providing an opportunity to the institution to make a written
                            representation within 30 days from the date of issue of the Notice along
                            with necessary certificates/documents in order to take a final decision in
                            the matter; failing which action will be taken including the refusal of
                            recognition, based on the records available, with no further notice.

32.        SRCAPP323        Mohammed Sathak Trust, Chennai, Tamilnadu submitted an application
               B.Ed         in the name of Mohammed Sathak Dastagir Teacher Training College,
        Mohammed Sathak     Ramanathapuram, Tirunelveli, Tamilnadu through on-line on 29.09.2010.
        Dastagir Teacher    The hard copy of the application was received in this office on
        Training College,   01.10.2010.
        Ramanathapuram
                TN          The application was scrutinized in accordance with clause 7 and 8 of
                            NCTE Regulation 2009 and deficiencies were pointed out. Accordingly
                            deficiency letter was issued to the institution on 06.01.2011. The
                            institution submitted required documents vide letter dt.05.03.2011:
                            The committee in its 202nd meeting held on 14th-15th March 2011 considered
                            the written representation and decided to cause inspection of the institution
                            under Section 14 of NCTE Act to verify the infrastructural and instructional
                            facilities.

                            Accordingly, inspection of the institution was conducted on 08.04.2011. The
                            following deficiencies still persists:

                            The Committee considered the VT Report, VCD and all the relevant
                            documentary evidences and it was decided to serve the Show cause
                            Notice for the following:

                             From VCD observation, the full view of the building is not to be seen.

                             Original Affidavit in the prescribed form on Rs 100/ stamp paper duly
                              attested by oath commissioner or notary public is to be submitted.

                             Notarized copy of Change of land use Certificate issued by the
                              competent authority is to be submitted.

                             Lease Deed from the Govt certified by the competent authority is to be
                              submitted.

                             The institution has not submitted valid Minority Status Certificate from
                              the Competent Authority in the name of the institution.

                             The management is running other programames in the same building
                              /campus. A certificate from Government/affiliating body to the effect

                                                   39


      (Gangadharaiah)                                                   (Prof. C. Thangamuthu)
      Regional Director, SRC, NCTE                                        Chairman, SRC, NCTE
                                                                                      th
                                                                         Minutes of 204 Meeting of SRC
                                                                                        th  th
                                                                                      27 -28 April 2011
                              that no other programme is being run/shared by the institution in the
                              same building/campus along with the B.Ed course is to be submitted.

                             In the affidavit, the built up area is not mentioned.

                             In the approved building plan, total area is not mentioned.

                             Non-encumbrance       certificate   from    competent    authority   is     not
                              submitted.

                             Website address is not mentioned.

                             Language learning lab is not available.

                            In view of the above, the Committee decided to issue a Show cause
                            Notice to the institution as to why the recognition be not refused and
                            thereby providing an opportunity to the institution to make a written
                            representation within 30 days from the date of issue of the Notice along
                            with necessary certificates/documents in order to take a final decision in
                            the matter; failing which action will be taken including the refusal of
                            recognition, based on the records available, with no further notice.
33.        SRCAPP294        SRM College of Education, Saroornagar. Andra Pradesh submitted an
              B.Ed          application to SRC-NCTE for grant of recognition for B.Ed course on
          SRM College of    27/09/2010.
            Education,
           Rangareddy       The Application was scrutinized and a copy of application was sent to State
               AP           Government for recommendation on 09.11.2010/04.02.2011. A deficiency
                            letter was issued to the institution on 09.12.2010 for the following Points:

                             Certified copy of the registered land documents issued by the
                              competent authority: the institution has submitted gift Settlement
                              Deed but not certified by competent authority. Hence the institution is
                              required to submit notarized copy of the same issued by the competent
                              authority in english version.
                             Building completion certificate: the institution has submitted
                              building completion certificate from private engineer. Hence the
                              institution is required to submit building completion certified issued by
                              local civil authority/Government Engineer. (copy enclosed)
                             Notarized copy of change of land use certificate issued by the
                              competent authority: the institution has not submitted land use
                              certificate. Hence the institution is required to submit notarized copy of
                              LUC(Agriculture lands- conversion of Non-Agriculture purpose) issued by
                              Revenue Department.
                             Minority certificate: the institution is minority institution as per
                              application form, however the institution has not submitted minority
                              certificate in the name of college. Hence the institution is required to
                              submit minority certificate issued by competent authority.
                             The authority approving building Plan is in local language it may
                              be specified in English.


                                                    40


      (Gangadharaiah)                                                     (Prof. C. Thangamuthu)
      Regional Director, SRC, NCTE                                          Chairman, SRC, NCTE
                                                                                       th
                                                                        Minutes of 204 Meeting of SRC
                                                                                       th  th
                                                                                     27 -28 April 2011
                            The committee considered the reply of institution dt. 07/02/2011 for the
                            deficiencies and decided to cause inspection of the institution under Section 14
                            of NCTE Act to verify the infrastructural and instructional facilities.

                            Accordingly, inspection of the institution was conducted on 09.04.2011.


                            The SRC considered, VT report, VCD and all relevant documents and
                            decided to issue Letter Of Intent for grant of Recognition to B.Ed course
                            of one year duration with an annual intake of 100(One hundred only)(one
                            unit) from the academic year 2012-13 subject to the production of valid
                            minority certificate issued by the competent authority in the name of the
                            institution and appointment of qualified staff through duly constituted
                            selection    committee      as    per    the   Norms     of    NCTE/State
                            Government/Affiliating University and be given effect before the
                            commencement of the academic session.

34.        SRCAPP333        District institution of Education and Training R.P.No. 1977, Kavaratti Village
              D.El.Ed       Union Territory of Lakshdweep, Kavaratti - 682555 submitted an application to
         DIET, Lakshadeep   SRC-NCTE for grant of recognition for B.Ed course on 29/09/2010.

                LK          The Application was scrutinized and a copy of application was sent to State
                            Government for recommendation on 02.11.2011. A deficiency letter was
                            issued to the institution on 06.12.2010 for the following Points:

                             Approved Building plan by the Competent civil authority. The
                              Institution has submitted building plan, but not ear marked or indicated
                              total area and built up area. Hence if the institution is running other
                              teacher education courses/ other technical courses in the same premises
                              then, the institution shall earmarked area for proposed course with total
                              built up area. As per the affidavit submitted the total area is 3077 Sq.Mtrs
                              whereas the handing over statement shows 2260 Sq mtrs Institution
                              requires to clarify.

                             further As per affidavit plot No. is different from that mentioned in
                              F.No.34/4/2009-LR dt 02.02.201 issued by administration of UT of
                              Lakshdweep.

                            Accordingly, inspection of the institution was conducted on 09.04.2011. The
                            following deficiencies still persists:

                            The Committee considered the VT Report, VCD and all the relevant
                            documentary evidences and it was decided to serve the Show cause
                            Notice for the following:

                             The total Built up area earmarked for the D.El.Ed is only 7924 sq.ft.
                              which is grossly inadequate for the D.El.Ed as per NCTE norms. The
                              same is also corroborated by the management by affixing signature of
                              the management representative in the essential data. As per NCTE
                              norms total built up area required for D.El.Ed is 16000 sq.ft.
                                                    41


      (Gangadharaiah)                                                     (Prof. C. Thangamuthu)
      Regional Director, SRC, NCTE                                          Chairman, SRC, NCTE
                                                                                         th
                                                                            Minutes of 204 Meeting of SRC
                                                                                           th  th
                                                                                         27 -28 April 2011

                               The survey numbers 938/2B, 4B, 5B, 6A2, 6A1B & 6A2 available in all
                                the land documents is not matching with the application form
                                submitted.

                               Duly filled in Questionnaire is to be submitted.

                               Language learning lab is not available.

                               Games & sports facilities are not provided by the management.

                               Furniture in the library is not adequate.

                               Science lab needs to be strengthened.

                               Education Technology lab needs to be strengthened.

                               In Psychology, lab materials are not available.


                              In view of the above, the Committee decided to issue a Show cause
                              Notice to the institution as to why the recognition be not refused and
                              thereby providing an opportunity to the institution to make a written
                              representation within 30 days from the date of issue of the Notice along
                              with necessary certificates/documents in order to take a final decision in
                              the matter; failing which action will be taken including the refusal of
                              recognition, based on the records available, with no further notice.

35.        SRCAPP357          Meera Arumugam Educational Trust, Vellore District, Tamilnadu submitted an
              M.Ed            application through on-line on 30.09.2010, the same was received in this office
         Meera College of     on 01.10.2010.
         Education, Vellore   The application was checked in the NCTE on-line website, the trust has
                TN            submitted twice application vide SRCAPP356 and SRCAPP357. Whereas,
                              SRCAPP357 shows detail of Good Samaritan Trust, Pudukottai for B.Ed
                              course. Further, online status cannot be changed by this office.

                              In the NCTE on-line website list SRCAPP356 reflects Meera Arumugam
                              Educational Trust, dated 30.09.2010 for M.Ed course.

                              While scrutinizing the application of the institution it was noted that the
                              institution has mentioned in the letter head as M.Ed whereas in application it is
                              mentioned as D.E.C.Ed course. Hence the application was processed for
                              D.E.C.Ed course.

                              On further scrutiny of the application it was observed that the English Version
                              land documents submitted by the institution is in infavour of the individual
                              capacity namely Shri. V. Arumugam. This documents shows that the land is
                              not in the favour of society/institution.

                                                      42


      (Gangadharaiah)                                                        (Prof. C. Thangamuthu)
      Regional Director, SRC, NCTE                                             Chairman, SRC, NCTE
                                                                                         th
                                                                         Minutes of 204 Meeting of SRC
                                                                                        th  th
                                                                                      27 -28 April 2011
                            Hence the application is rejected/returned under the following circumstances
                            as per Clause 7 (1-A) (I) (c) of regulations 2009 notified on 25.11.2010:-

                            “Copy of the registered land documents issued by the Competent Authority
                            indicating that the society/institution applying for the course possessed land on
                            the date of application is not dispatched within 7 days of the submission of the
                            on-line application”.

                            The same was informed to the institution vide letter No.F.SRO/NCTE/2010-
                            2011/25899 dated 03.01.2010.

                            The institution has resubmitted the application with the same set of land
                            documents alongwith revised English version which shows that land is in
                            favour of society.

                            The institution has also requested to correct the application code no from
                            “SRCAPP357” to “SRCAPP356” by producing a copy of list generated in NCTE
                            website where the course name is mentioned as “M.Ed” but the code no
                            “SRCAPP356” has already been allotted to “Good Samaritan Trust” for their
                            B.Ed course.

                            SRC in its 200th meeting held on 20th-21st January 2011 considered the matter
                            and decided to process the application for D.E.C.Ed course. Accordingly the
                            application was processed for D.E.C.Ed and deficiency letter was issued to the
                            institution for D.E.C.ED course on 15.02.2011.

                            But the institution in its reply to deficiency letter stated that they have applied
                            for M.Ed course for the academic year 2011-12. SRC also mentioned (letter
                            returning the application) M.Ed course only. Also our ID SRCAPP356 is
                            mentioning M.Ed in the on-line recognition process. Hence theapplication is for
                            M.Ed course only. Tamilnadu State Govt also inspected theircollege only for
                            M.Ed course and sent inspection report to Govt and SRC.

                            Note: Reference to State Government was sent for D.E.C.ED course only and
                            not for M.Ed course. Inspection report of State Govt is not received in SRC as
                            stated by institution. SRC has no information about inspection conducted for
                            M.Ed course by State Government as stated by institution as no
                            recommendation has been received from State Government.

                            On careful perusal of the original file of the institution and other related
                            documents, Act of NCTE, 1993, regulations and guidelines from time to time
                            laid on the table, written representation from the institution, the Regional
                            Committee considered for M.Ed course as requested by the management
                            and decided to reject the application on the following grounds.

                             National Assessment and Accreditation Council (NAAC) accreditation
                              with „B‟ Grade is not submitted.
36.         SRCAPP54        Don Bosco College of Education and Research Institute, Dharmapuri
              B.Ed          District-636809, Tamilnadu

                                                     43


      (Gangadharaiah)                                                      (Prof. C. Thangamuthu)
      Regional Director, SRC, NCTE                                           Chairman, SRC, NCTE
                                                                                   th
                                                                    Minutes of 204 Meeting of SRC
                                                                                   th  th
                                                                                 27 -28 April 2011
  Don Bosco College
    of Education,       Don Bosco College of Education and Research Institute, Adhiyaman By Pass
     Dharmapuri         Road, Sogathur, Dharmapuri District-636809, Tamilnadu submitted its
         TN             application for B.Ed course through on-line on 20.10.2009. Application of the
                        above institution was received by SRC on 27.10.2009. The application was
                        processed and deficiency letter was issued to the institution on 22.12.2009.
                        The institution submitted its written representation on 19.02.2010.

                        The SRC considered the matter in its 189th meeting held on 25th-26th February
                        2010 and on careful perusal of the original file of the institution and other
                        related documents, Committee decided to cause inspection to the institution.

                        The inspection of the institution was conducted on 24.04.2010. The SRC in its
                        192nd meeting held on 10th-11th May 2010 after considering the report of the
                        visiting team as well as other relevant materials furnished by the applicant
                        institution, the Regional Committee decided to refuse recognition to B.Ed
                        course for the following grounds:-

                        The institution has not produced valid Minority Certificate issued by the
                     competent authority.
                        The visit was conducted inadvertently, before getting the proper
                     clarification from the State Government on the requirements of a legally valid
                     Minority Certificate from a competent authority.
                        The institution without valid Minority Certificate, as such, is not eligible to
                     apply under Minority category.
                        The institution has not produced valid Minority Certificate issued by the
                     competent authority.

                        Accordingly,      the      application     was      rejected     vide     order
                        F.SRC/NCTE/B.Ed/2010/19160 dated. 28.05.2010. Aggrieved by the rejection
                        order, the institution preferred appeal u/s 18 of NCTE Act. The Appellate
                        Authority vide its order No.F.No.89-746/2010-Appeal dated 15.09.2010
                        reversed with the direction to the SRC for processing the case further on merit.

                        SRC considered the appeal order in its 197th meeting held on 13th-14th October
                        2010 and decided to process the application.

                        SRC considered the matter in its 198th meeting held on 24-26th November
                        2010 and decided to process the VT.

                        The Inspection was carried out on 24.04.2010. The committee in its 200th
                        meeting held on 20th-21st January 2011 decided to call remarks from the VT
                        members immediately, without waiting for the confirmation of minutes, for the
                        following:

                       The tampering/overwriting (after applying white fluid) of essential data on page
                        – 5 of the VT report
                       Contradiction between the observations of the VT in page No. 16 and in Page
                        no. 21.

                                                44


(Gangadharaiah)                                                       (Prof. C. Thangamuthu)
Regional Director, SRC, NCTE                                            Chairman, SRC, NCTE
                                                                                       th
                                                                        Minutes of 204 Meeting of SRC
                                                                                       th  th
                                                                                     27 -28 April 2011

                            As per the decision of 200th meeting held on 20th and 21st January, 2011 to call
                            for the remarks from the VT members immediately, without waiting for the
                            confirmation of minutes, was sent to Prof. V.J. Komalavalli, SCERT, Hyd and
                            Dr. T.V. Tulsidharan, Kottayam, Kerala on 22.2.2011.

                            In reply, Dr. V.J. Komalavalli, SCERT, Hyd. was received on 7.3.2011 stated
                            that (1)“I have not made any corrections in the essential data furnished on
                            page 5 of VT report”. (2) “The observations made by us in page no. 1 and in
                            page no. 21 are consistent and there are no contradictions”.

                            Again as stated as follows; “On completion of the inspection the VT report,
                            along with the C.D was sealed in front of me. On the way to the railway station
                            we stopped the vehicle at the post office and Dr. V.T. Tulsidharan and a
                            member of the Management of the college went inside the post office and
                            posted the report to NCTE. The postal receipt was retained by Dr. T.V.
                            Tulsidharan”

                            SRC considered the matter in its 202nd meeting held on 14th-15th March 2011
                            and decided to await for the remarks from the VT member Dr. V.T. Tulsidharan
                            and to send reminder to him for expediting to send his specific remarks at the
                            earliest.

                            Meanwhile, reply from Dr. V.T. Tulsidharan was received on 14.03.2011, the
                            VT member has stated as follows: “ while preparing the report we did not apply
                            white fluid or tampering in any place of the report especially in the essential
                            date pagae no.5”.

                            The committee has decided to issue Show Cause notice to the institution
                            for the following reason.

                            After careful consideration of the replies of the VT members denying
                            their hand in tampering of the data given in VT Report and as the
                            management member had accompanied one of the VT members to the
                            Post Office to dispatch this VT Report, the management be directed to
                            offer its remarks on the tampering done on the VT Report.

                            In view of the above, the Committee decided to issue a Show cause
                            Notice to the institution as to why the recognition be not refused
                            and thereby providing an opportunity to the institution to make a
                            written representation within 30 days from the date of issue of the
                            Notice along with necessary certificates/documents in order to
                            take a final decision in the matter; failing which action will be taken
                            including the refusal of recognition, based on the records
                            available, with no further notice.
37.        SRCAPP188        V.V.Sangha B.P.Ed College, No.267, D.Hipparagi Road, Muddebihal,
              B.P.Ed        Talikoti, Bijapur, Karnataka
           V.V. Sangha
          B.P.Ed College,
                                                    45


      (Gangadharaiah)                                                     (Prof. C. Thangamuthu)
      Regional Director, SRC, NCTE                                          Chairman, SRC, NCTE
                                                                                        th
                                                                         Minutes of 204 Meeting of SRC
                                                                                        th  th
                                                                                      27 -28 April 2011
              Bijapur       V.V.Sangha B.P.Ed College, No.267, D. Hipparagi Road, Muddebihal, Talikoti,
                KA          Bijapur, Karnataka has submitted application on 09.11.2009. The institution
                            was refused grant for recognition vide order dt.31.05.2010.
                            The institution preferred to NCTE, New Delhi under section 18 of the NCTE Act
                            1993 and the Appellate Authority vide order dt.21.06.2010 reversed the SRC‟s
                            refusal order with a direction to the SRC to issue a show cause noitce to the
                            institution and to take further action.

                            The SRC in its 199th meeting held on 22-23 December 2010 considered the
                            Appellate Authority order dt.21.06.2010 and decided to issue show cause
                            notice. Accordingly, Show cause notice was issued to the institution on
                            01.02.2011.
                            The institution did not care to respond to the show cause notice issued on the
                            institution even after lapse of two months as per our records.

                            The committee after going through the non-reply of the institution for the
                            show cause notice issued dt. 01.02.2011, refused to grant recognition of
                            the institution for the B.P.Ed course for the following:

                                    After considering the Appellate authority order dt. 21.06.2010 in its
                                     199th meeting held on 22-23 December 2010, the committee
                                     decided to issue show cause notice to institution and accordingly
                                     show cause notice issued to the institution on 01.02.2011.

                                    The institution did not care to respond to the show cause notice
                                     issued to the institution even after lapse of two months.

                            Hence, the Committee decided to refuse the grant of recognition to the
                            Institution.
38.        SRCAPP141        Sri Ramanas College of Education, Virudhunagar District, Tamilnadu
               B.Ed
           Sri Ramanas      Sri Ramanas College of Education, No.2/654, Chidambarapuram, Aruppukottai
            College of      Taluk, Virudhunagar District-626134, Tamilnadu submitted its application for
            Education,      B.Ed course through on-line on 30.10.2009. Hard copy of the application of the
           Virudhunagar     above institution was received by SRC on 30.10.2009.
                TN
                            The application was processed and deficiency letter was issued to the
                            institution on 22.12.2009. The institution submitted its written representation on
                            25.01.2010.

                            The SRC considered the matter in its 189th meeting held on 25th-26th February
                            2010 and on careful perusal of the original file of the institution and other
                            related documents, Committee decided to cause inspection to the institution.

                            The inspection of the institution was carried out on 07.05.2010. The SRC in its
                            192nd meeting held on 10th-11th May 2010 after considering the report of the
                            visiting team as well as other relevant materials furnished by the applicant
                            institution, the Regional Committee decided to refuse recognition to B.Ed
                                                     46


      (Gangadharaiah)                                                      (Prof. C. Thangamuthu)
      Regional Director, SRC, NCTE                                           Chairman, SRC, NCTE
                                                                                    th
                                                                     Minutes of 204 Meeting of SRC
                                                                                    th  th
                                                                                  27 -28 April 2011
                        course for the following grounds:-

                   1.      The institution has not produced valid Minority Certificate issued by the
                        competent authority.

                   2.       The visit was conducted inadvertently, before getting the proper
                        clarification from the State Government on the requirements of a legally valid
                        Minority Certificate from a competent authority.

                   3.      The institution without valid Minority Certificate, as such, is not eligible to
                        apply under Minority category.

                        Accordingly, the   application  was      rejected           vide    order     No.
                        F.SRC/NCTE/B.Ed/2010/19161 dated. 28.05.2010.

                        Aggrieved by the rejection order of SRC, the institution preferred an appeal u/s
                        18 of NCTE Act.

                        The Appellate Authority vide its order No.F.No.89-720/2010-Appeal dated
                        24.09.2010 reversed the order of the SRC dated 28.05.2010 with a direction to
                        SRC to process the application on merits. This would however subject to the
                        condition that a valid minority certificate would be obtained by the society for
                        the institution in due course and that the institution shall abide by their
                        obligation as a minority institution in order to enjoy continuos recognition.

                        SRC considered the appeal order in its 197th meeting held on 13th-14th
                        October, 2010 and decided to process the application.
                        SRC considered the matter in its 198th meeting held on 24-26th November,
                        2010 and decided to process the VT.

                        The SRC considered, VT report, VCD, reply to the show cause notice and all
                        relevant documents, the Appellate Authority order dt. 24.09.2010 and decided
                        to issue Letter Of Intent for grant of Formal Recognition to B.Ed course of one
                        year duration with an annual intake of 100(One hundred only)(one unit) for the
                        academic year 2011-12 subject to the production of valid minority certificate
                        issued by the competent authority and appointment of qualified staff through
                        duly constituted selection committee as per the Norms of NCTE/State
                        Government/Affiliating University and be given effect before the
                        commencement of the academic session.

                        Accordingly, Letter of Intent was issued to the institution vide order no.
                        F.SRO/NCTE/2011/26461 dated 25.1.2011.

                        The institution submitted written representation on 14.2.2011, which was
                        placed before SRC in its 201st meeting held on 22nd and 23rd February, 2011.
                        The Committee considered the matter and it was decided to serve notice for
                        providing minority certificate in the name of the institution to take a final
                        decision on the issue of formal recognition order to the institution.

                        Accordingly, notice was issued to the institution on 1.3.2011. The institution
                                                 47


(Gangadharaiah)                                                        (Prof. C. Thangamuthu)
Regional Director, SRC, NCTE                                             Chairman, SRC, NCTE
                                                                                        th
                                                                         Minutes of 204 Meeting of SRC
                                                                                        th  th
                                                                                      27 -28 April 2011
                             has submitted reply on 14.3.2011 was placed before SRC in its 203rd meeting
                             held on 14th and 15th March, 2011 and the committee decided to await for the
                             minority certificate.

                             Meantime, a court notice in W.P. No. 4241 of 2011 field by Sri Ramanas
                             Institute of Educational Trust, Virudhunagar Dt., Tamilnadu has been received
                             from the Petitioner‟s advocates on 15.4.2011 stated that the case will be listed
                             for hearing on 28.4.2011. The same was informed to SRC‟s Counsel on
                             20.4.2011 along with brief of the case and also requested to forward the writ
                             petition of the institution.

                             A court notice along with writ petition has been received from the Hon‟ble
                             Madurai Bench of Madras High Court in W.P.(MD) No. 1 of 2011 in WP(MD)
                             No. 4241 of 2011 filed by the institution and the court has intimated that the
                             petition will come up for hearing on 6.6.2011.

                             The institution in its letter dated 21.4.2011 requesting for formal recognition
                             order and also stated the following;

                             “Our college preferred appeal to appellate authority of NCTE-Hqrs. New Delhi
                             on 15.6.2010. We presented case before NCTE-Hqrs, New Delhi on
                             19.8.2010. After hearing, the appellate authority

                             Has revered the order passed by SRC followed by the direction to college to
                             produce minority certificate in due course.

                             I would like to bring to your kind reference that the appellate authority did not
                             insist to produce minority certificate immediately but in due course i.e during
                             running the college. This will enable us to get minority certificate quickly from
                             the secretary to Higher Education of Tamilnadu Government”.

                             The committee has decided to await for Court decision/Order in the
                             matter.

      Inspection Report – Shifting Cases:

39.        APS00250          Holy faith College of Education, Khammam District, Andhra Pradesh has
              B.Ed           made an application for B.Ed course to Southern Regional Committee,
        Holy Faith College   NCTE, Bangalore on 31.12.2001.
          of Education,
           Khammam           The application was processed and after considering the report of the
               AP            Visiting Team as well as other relevant materials granted recognition to
                             the institution for offering B.Ed course with an intake of 120 students vide
                             order No.7967 dated 03.07.2003.

                             The institution in its letter dated 29.08.2007 has submitted proposal for
                             shifting the B.Ed course to the new location.



                                                     48


      (Gangadharaiah)                                                      (Prof. C. Thangamuthu)
      Regional Director, SRC, NCTE                                           Chairman, SRC, NCTE
                                                                                          th
                                                                           Minutes of 204 Meeting of SRC
                                                                                          th  th
                                                                                        27 -28 April 2011
                               The management is running D.Ed programme also.

                               The Committee considered the VT Report, VCD and all the relevant
                               documentary evidences and it was decided to serve the Show cause
                               Notice under section 17 of NCTE Act for the following:

                                   The total built up area as per VT report in page no.1 is 32570.52
                                    sq.ft, whereas in essential data sheet it is shown as 25100 sq.ft.
                                    This discrepancy may be explained

                                   As per VCD observation the building is still under construction
                                    and is incomplete.

                                   The earmarked builtup areas for D.Ed and the proposed B.Ed
                                    courses be clearly mentioned.

                                   The Affidavit in Rs. 100/- stamp paper in the prescribed format with
                                    Notary attestation should be submitted.

                                   Non-encumbrance certificate from the competent authority is to
                                    be submitted.

                                   Science lab & Psychology lab needs to be strengthened.

                                   The questionnaire is not duly filled up and not submitted.

                                   Seating arrangements in the library is to be improved.


                                   In the absence of English version of land document, it cannot
                                    be ascertained whether the institute has shifted to own
                                    premises or not. English version of the land documents is to be
                                    submitted.

                               In view of the above, the Committee decided to issue a Show cause
                               Notice to the institution as to why the recognition be not withdrawn
                               and thereby providing an opportunity to the institution to make a
                               written representation within 30 days from the date of issue of the
                               Notice along with necessary certificates/documents in order to take a
                               final decision in the matter; failing which action will be taken
                               including the refusal of recognition, based on the records available,
                               with no further notice.

40.         APS00203           St.Peter‟s College of Education, Kurnool, Andhra Pradesh has made an
               B.Ed            application for B.Ed course to Southern Regional Committee, NCTE,
       St. Peters College of   Bangalore on 31.12.2001.
        Education, Kurnool
                AP             The application was processed and after considering the report of the
                               Visiting Team as well as other relevant materials granted recognition to
                               the institution for offering B.Ed course with an intake of 120 students vide
                                                       49


      (Gangadharaiah)                                                        (Prof. C. Thangamuthu)
      Regional Director, SRC, NCTE                                             Chairman, SRC, NCTE
                                                                                      th
                                                                       Minutes of 204 Meeting of SRC
                                                                                      th  th
                                                                                    27 -28 April 2011
                             order No.6111 dated 03.03.2003.

                             The institution in its letter dated 16.06.2009 has submitted proposal for
                             shifting the B.Ed course to the new location. Shifting inspection was
                             conducted on 08.02.2011.

                             The Committee considered the VT Report, VCD and all the relevant
                             documentary evidences and it was decided to serve the Show cause
                             Notice under section 17 of NCTE Act for the following:

                                 As per the VCD photos, it is clear that the top floor of the
                                  building is covered with asbestos sheets. This is is against the
                                  NCTE Norms.

                                 Latest building completion certificate from competent Govt.
                                  engineer is to be submitted.

                                 Non-encumbrance certificate from competent authority in
                                  English version s to be submitted.

                                 Science lab & other labs/Physcial Education lab needs to be
                                  strengthened.

                                 Furniture in the library & classrooms needs to be augmented.

                                 In the absence of English version of land document, it cannot
                                  be ascertained whether the institute has shifted to own
                                  premises or not.

                                 Details of payment of salary to staff through account payee
                                  Cheque is not submitted.

                                 As per VT report, the Instructional facilities are bare minimum,
                                  needs to be augmented.

                             In view of the above, the Committee decided to issue a Show cause
                             Notice to the institution as to why the recognition be not withdrawn
                             and thereby providing an opportunity to the institution to make a
                             written representation within 30 days from the date of issue of the
                             Notice along with necessary certificates/documents in order to take a
                             final decision in the matter; failing which action will be taken
                             including the refusal of recognition, based on the records available,
                             with no further notice.

41.         APS00318         Azizia College of Education, Kurnool District, Andhra Pradesh has made
               B.Ed          an application for B.Ed course to Southern Regional Committee, NCTE,
         Azizia College of   Bangalore on 31.12.2001.
        Education, Kurnool
                AP           The application was processed and after considering the report of the
                                                    50


      (Gangadharaiah)                                                    (Prof. C. Thangamuthu)
      Regional Director, SRC, NCTE                                         Chairman, SRC, NCTE
                                                                                        th
                                                                         Minutes of 204 Meeting of SRC
                                                                                        th  th
                                                                                      27 -28 April 2011
                             Visiting Team as well as other relevant materials granted recognition to
                             the institution for offering B.Ed course with an intake of 120 students vide
                             order No.6652 dated 08.04.2003.

                             The institution in its letter dated 25.06.2009 has submitted proposal for
                             shifting the B.Ed course to the new location.

                             The Committee considered the VT Report, VCD and all the relevant
                             documentary evidences and it was decided to serve the Show cause
                             Notice under section 17 of NCTE Act for the following:

                              The building plan submitted is not approved by competent Govt.
                               authority. Plot no. and Khasara no. are not mentioned in the
                               Building Plan. Approved building plan from Govt.authority is to be
                               submitted.

                              FDRs for Rs. 5 lacs & 3 lacs towards endowment and reserve fund
                               respectively from Nationalised Bank in the Joint account is to be
                               submitted.

                              Non-encumbrance certificate from competent Govt, authority in
                               English Version is to be submitted.

                              Furniture in the library needs to be strengthened.

                              Science lab & other labs/Physical Education lab need to be
                               strengthened.

                             In view of the above, the Committee decided to issue a Show cause
                             Notice to the institution as to why the recognition be not withdrawn
                             and thereby providing an opportunity to the institution to make a
                             written representation within 30 days from the date of issue of the
                             Notice along with necessary certificates/documents in order to take a
                             final decision in the matter; failing which action will be taken
                             including the refusal of recognition, based on the records available,
                             with no further notice.

42.         APS00726         Gnanodaya HPT College, Karimnagar District, Andhra Pradesh has made
               HPT           an application for H.P.T course to Southern Regional Committee, NCTE,
        Gnanodaya HPT        Bangalore on 27.12.2001.
       College, Karimnagar
                AP           The application was processed and after considering the report of the
                             Visiting Team as well as other relevant materials granted recognition to
                             the institution for offering HPT course with an intake of 50 students vide
                             order No.2557 dated 22.08.2002.

                             The institution in its letter dated 28.12.2008 has submitted proposal for
                             shifting the HPT course to the new location.


                                                     51


      (Gangadharaiah)                                                      (Prof. C. Thangamuthu)
      Regional Director, SRC, NCTE                                           Chairman, SRC, NCTE
                                                                                                 th
                                                                                Minutes of 204 Meeting of SRC
                                                                                               th  th
                                                                                             27 -28 April 2011
                               The Committee considered the VT Report, VCD and all the relevant
                               documentary evidences and it was decided to serve the Show cause
                               Notice under section 17 of NCTE Act for the following:

                                    As per VCD observation, the building is still under construction
                                     and is incomplete.

                                    Bye-Laws of the Society are to be submitted by the
                                     management.

                                    Approved building plan (Blue print) is to be submitted.

                                    BCC and VT reports indicated three Sy.nos, vide; sale deeds dt.
                                     03.12.2004, 18.07.2005 & 09.11.2005. But sale deed submitted is
                                     for sy.no.1334 with 1239.30 sq.mtrs dt. 07.10.2005 are not
                                     matching.

                                    Notarised Affidavit in prescribed format is to be submitted.

                                    FDR for Rs. 3 lacs towards reserve fund in joint account from a
                                     Nationalised Bank is tobe submitted.

                                    Non-encumbrance certificate from competent Govt.authority is
                                     tobe submitted.

                                    Whitewashing & painting of the building is not done and
                                     Building appears to be old and not maintained properly.

                               In view of the above, the Committee decided to issue a Show cause
                               Notice to the institution as to why the recognition be not withdrawn
                               and thereby providing an opportunity to the institution to make a
                               written representation within 30 days from the date of issue of the
                               Notice along with necessary certificates/documents in order to take a
                               final decision in the matter; failing which action will be taken
                               including the refusal of recognition, based on the records available,
                               with no further notice.

43.         APS03260           Dr. Sivanthi Aditanar Teacher Training Institute, Thiruchendur,
              D.T.Ed           Thoothukudi District, Tamilnadu
       Dr. Sivanthi Aditanar
        Teacher Training       Dr. Sivanthi Aditanar Teacher Training Institute, Thoothukudi District, Tamilnadu
             Institute,        was granted recognition for offering D.T.Ed course with an intake of 50 students
           Thoothukudi         from the session 2004-05 on 17.09.2004 at Tirunelveli Road, Tiruchendur-
                TN             628215, Thoothukudi District, Tamilnadu with the condition to shift to own
                               premises within 3 years.

                               The institution vide its letter dated 27.12.2007 submitted Rs.40000/- for shifting of
                               premises. The institution has submitted its written representation on 12.1.2009,
                               5.1.2011, 7.1.2011 & 20.1.2011 stating as follows:

                                                          52


      (Gangadharaiah)                                                              (Prof. C. Thangamuthu)
      Regional Director, SRC, NCTE                                                   Chairman, SRC, NCTE
                                                                                      th
                                                                      Minutes of 204 Meeting of SRC
                                                                                       th  th
                                                                                     27 -28 April 2011
                      “we have already sent a draft for Rs. 40000/- dated 17.12.2007 and all necessary
                      supporting documents for granting approval of shifting Dr.Sivanthi Aditanar
                      Teacher Training Institute from a temporary building to a permanent own building.

                      I request you to be kind enough to consider our request and grant approval for the
                      shifting of Dr.Sivanthi Aditanar Teacher Training Institute, Tiruchendur from a
                      temporary building to a permanent own building at your earliest convenience”.


                      The SRC considered the matter in its 200th meeting held on 20th-21st
                      January 2011 and all relevant documents and decided to cause composite
                      inspection for all the courses to examine whether the institution fulfils all
                      the requirements as per the norms, for the proposed programme.

                      The management is running D.T.Ed, B.Ed, M,.Ed and B.P.Ed courses in
                      the same building/campus.

                      Accordingly the inspection of the institution was fixed between 23 rd March-
                      2nd April 2011. The same was intimated to the institution on 04.03.2011.
                      Accordingly inspection of the institution was conducted on 28.03.2011.
                      The following deficiencies still persists:
                      The Committee considered the VT Report, VCD and all the relevant
                      documentary evidences and it was decided to serve the Show cause
                      Notice Under Section 17 of NCTE Act for the following :

                        The total Built up area earmarked for B.Ed & M.Ed is 19268 Sq.ft.
                         B.Ed is 9637 Sq.ft and for M.Ed is 9631 Sq.ft. The earmarked built
                         up area both B.Ed & M.Ed is inadequate as per NCTE norms. The
                         same is also corroborated by the management in the essential
                         data.

                        The earmarked Built up area for each of the programme is to be
                         given.

                        Building completion certificate from the Competent Govt Engineer
                         is to be submitted.

                        Land usage certificate from the competent authority is to be
                         submitted.

                        Bye-Laws of the Society are to be submitted by the management.

                        In the Affidavit, the survey number is not mentioned.

                        In the Building plan submitted, the survey number and total area
                         not mentioned.

                        Science lab needs to be strengthened.

                                                53


(Gangadharaiah)                                                         (Prof. C. Thangamuthu)
Regional Director, SRC, NCTE                                              Chairman, SRC, NCTE
                                                                                          th
                                                                           Minutes of 204 Meeting of SRC
                                                                                          th  th
                                                                                        27 -28 April 2011
                               Education Technology lab is to be established.

                               Language learning lab is not available.

                               Land documents related to sy.number 336/2 not submitted.

                              In view of the above, the Committee decided to issue a Show cause
                              Notice to the institution as to why the recognition be not withdrawn
                              and thereby providing an opportunity to the institution to make a
                              written representation within 30 days from the date of issue of the
                              Notice along with necessary certificates/documents in order to take a
                              final decision in the matter; failing which action will be taken
                              including the withdrawal of recognition, based on the records
                              available, with no further notice.

44.         APS02094          Bharatiya Adim Jati Seva Sangh D.Ed College, Halagiri Road,
               D.Ed           Ranebennur, Haveri District-581115, Karnataka
        Bharatiya Adim Jati
         Seva Sangh D.Ed      Bharatiya Adim Jati Seva Sangh D.Ed College, Halagiri Road,
          College, Haveri     Ranebennur, Haveri District-581115, Karnataka has submitted application
                KA            on 31.12.2003. The institution was granted recognition for offering D.Ed
                              course with an intake of 50 students vide order dated 10.12.2004.

                              The institution was granted recognition with a condition that the institution
                              shall shift to its own premises/building within three years from the date of
                              recogniiton. (In case the course started in rented premises)

                              The institution submitted proposal for shifting of premises on 03.10.2007
                              along with Rs.40,000/- vide Receipt No.13333 dated 25.10.2007 towards
                              inspection fee for shifiting of premises.

                              Land documents of college is one and the same. They are running in its
                              own building since beginning. From the examination of file it is
                              ascertained that it is not a shifting case.

                              The inspection was carried out on 29th March 2011.

                              The Committee considered the VT Report, VCD and all the relevant
                              documentary evidences and it was decided to serve the Show cause
                              Notice Under Section 17 of NCTE Act for the following :

                               The management is running the institution in Ist floor and II floor.
                                II floor is meant for D.Ed course. The management is also running
                                Women Degree College and P.U.Science College in Ist floor and II
                                floor along with the existing D.Ed course, which is against the
                                NCTE norms.

                               The total Built up area earmarked for the D.Ed is only 7767 sq.ft.
                                which is grossly inadequate for the D.Ed as per NCTE norms. The

                                                      54


      (Gangadharaiah)                                                        (Prof. C. Thangamuthu)
      Regional Director, SRC, NCTE                                             Chairman, SRC, NCTE
                                                                                          th
                                                                           Minutes of 204 Meeting of SRC
                                                                                          th  th
                                                                                        27 -28 April 2011
                                 same is also corroborated by the management by affixing
                                 signature of the management representative in the essential data.
                                 As per NCTE norms total built up area required for D.Ed is 16000
                                 sq.ft.

                                Approved Building plan from competent authority is to be
                                 submitted.

                                Building completion certificate from the Competent Govt Engineer
                                 is to be submitted.

                                Land usage certificate from the competent authority is to be
                                 submitted.

                                Bye-Laws of the Society are to be submitted by the management.

                                In the Affidavit, the Built up area is not mentioned.

                                In the Building plan submitted, the survey number and total area
                                 not mentioned.

                               In view of the above, the Committee decided to issue a Show cause
                               Notice to the institution as to why the recognition be not withdrawn
                               and thereby providing an opportunity to the institution to make a
                               written representation within 30 days from the date of issue of the
                               Notice along with necessary certificates/documents in order to take a
                               final decision in the matter; failing which action will be taken
                               including the withdrawal of recognition, based on the records
                               available, with no further notice.

45.         APS01569           St. Mary‟s College of Education, Thoothukudi District, Tamilnadu
               B.Ed
       St. Mary‟s College of   St. Mary‟s College of Education, Thoothukudi District, Tamilnadu
            Education,         submitted application for seeking grant of recognition for B.Ed course on
           Thoothukudi         15.12.2003.
                TN
                               The application was processed and recognition order was issued to the
                               institution on 01.10.2004 at Edmund Nagar, Seydunganallur-628809,
                               Thoothukudi with the condition to shift to own premises within 3 years.

                               The institution vide its letter dated 24.09.2007 submitted Rs.40000/- for
                               shifting of premises at Opp to Railway Station, Seydunganallur,
                               Srivaikundam Taluk. Thoothukudi-628809. Tamilnadu.

                               Accordingly the inspection of the institution was fixed between 23 rd March-
                               2nd April 2011. The same was intimated to the institution on 04.03.2011.
                               Accordingly inspection of the institution was conducted on 29.03.2011.The
                               following deficiencies are stil persists:

                                                       55


      (Gangadharaiah)                                                        (Prof. C. Thangamuthu)
      Regional Director, SRC, NCTE                                             Chairman, SRC, NCTE
                                                                                           th
                                                                            Minutes of 204 Meeting of SRC
                                                                                           th  th
                                                                                         27 -28 April 2011
                               The Committee considered the VT Report, VCD and all the relevant
                               documentary evidences and it was decided to serve the Show cause
                               Notice Under Section 17 of NCTE Act for the following :

                                In the Building plan, submitted, total area is not mentioned.

                                Building completion certificate from the Competent Govt Engineer
                                 is to be submitted.

                                In the Affidavit, the Built up area is not mentioned.

                                FDR for Rs. 3 lacs towards reserve fund from Nationalised Bank is
                                 to be submitted.

                               In view of the above, the Committee decided to issue a Show cause
                               Notice to the institution as to why the recognition be not withdrawn
                               and thereby providing an opportunity to the institution to make a
                               written representation within 30 days from the date of issue of the
                               Notice along with necessary certificates/documents in order to take a
                               final decision in the matter; failing which action will be taken
                               including the withdrawal of recognition, based on the records
                               available, with no further notice.

46.         APS03745           Siddartha College of Education, Kale Complex, Bus Stand Road,
               B.Ed            Jamkhandi, Bagalkot District, Karnataka
        Siddartha College of
        Education, Bagalkot    Siddartha College of Education, Kale Complex, Bus Stand Road,
                KA             Jamkhandi, Bagalkot District, Karnataka has submitted application for
                               offering B.Ed course on 30.12.2004. The institution has been granted
                               recognition by SRC for offering B.Ed course with an intake of 100 students
                               vide order dated 26.12.2005.

                               The institution in its letter dated 06.10.2009 has submitted a proposal for
                               shifting of premises along with Rs.40,000/- towards shifting fee. The
                               inspection was carried out on 17th October 2010. The inspection report
                               has been received along with VCD.

                               The SRC in its 198th meeting held on 24-26 November 2010 considered
                               the VT report and all the relevant documentary evidences and decided to
                               issue Show cause notice. Accordingly, Show cause notice was issued to
                               the institution on 11.01.2011. The institution has submitted its written
                               representation on 10.02.2011.

                               The SRC in its 201st meeting held on 22-23 February 2011 considered the
                               written representation and other relevant documentary and decided to
                               cause re-inspection along with Rs.40,000/-. Till date the institution has not
                               submitted re- inspection fee of Rs.40,000/-.

                               The inspection was carried out on 30th March 2011. The inspection report

                                                       56


      (Gangadharaiah)                                                         (Prof. C. Thangamuthu)
      Regional Director, SRC, NCTE                                              Chairman, SRC, NCTE
                                                                               th
                                                                 Minutes of 204 Meeting of SRC
                                                                                th  th
                                                                              27 -28 April 2011
                      has been received along with VCD.

                      The Committee considered the reply to Show Cause Notice, VT
                      Report, VCD and all the relevant documentary evidences and it was
                      decided to serve the Final Show cause Notice Under Section 17 of
                      NCTE Act for the following :

                        As per VT/VCD the new building is still under construction and
                        incomplete & it is still run in a rented premises.

                        The management has not submitted the land documents, Building
                         plan, BCC, land usage certificate to verify actual location of new
                         premises and to ascertain whether the land is in the name of
                         Society/institution as per regulation.

                        The Ground floor of the new building is incomplete.

                        The management has not submitted the Re-inspection fee of Rest.
                         40000/-.
                        Land documents with survey Nos of the land where the institution
                         is to be shifted are not submitted.

                        Bye-Laws of the Society are to be submitted by the management.

                        The Affidavit on Rs. 100/- stamp paper in the prescribed format
                         with notary attestation to be submitted.

                        The institute has not submitted the approved Building plan from a
                         competent Govt. authority.

                        The latest Building Completion Certificate from the competent
                         Government Engineer is not submitted.

                        Notarised copy of Land usage certificate issued by competent
                         authority is to be submitted.

                        Original Fixed deposits in joint name towards Endowment fund &
                         Reserve fund from a Nationalised Bank is to be produced.

                        Non- Encumbrance Certificate from the competent Government
                         Authorised person / Authorities to be submitted.

                        The Toilets in the new building is not in a position to use.

                        As per VT report, the institution is still functioning in the old
                         building and the infrastructural facilities are inadequate.

                        The books available in the library is only 2254, which is inadequate
                         for B.Ed course.
                                              57


(Gangadharaiah)                                                    (Prof. C. Thangamuthu)
Regional Director, SRC, NCTE                                         Chairman, SRC, NCTE
                                                                                             th
                                                                             Minutes of 204 Meeting of SRC
                                                                                            th  th
                                                                                          27 -28 April 2011

                              Furniture for the new building is inadequate.

                             In view of the above, the Committee decided to issue a Final Show
                             cause Notice to the institution as to why the recognition be not
                             withdrawn and thereby providing an opportunity to the institution to
                             make a written representation within 30 days from the date of issue
                             of the Notice along with necessary certificates/documents in order to
                             take a final decision in the matter; failing which action will be taken
                             including the withdrawal of recognition, based on the records
                             available, with no further notice.

47.         APS09248         Rajalakshmi College of Education for Women, Tuticorin
              B.Ed           District, Tamilnadu
       Rajalakshmi College
         of Education for    Rajalakshmi College of Education for Women, Tuticorin District, Tamilnadu
             Women           submitted application for seeking grant of recognition for B.Ed course on
               TN            19.12.2007.

                             The application was processed and recognition order was issued to the institution
                                                                               rd
                             on 22.09.2008 at No.77,77a & 77b, Toovipuram, 3 Street, New Colony Post
                             Office, Thoothukudi-628003, Tamilnadu.

                             The institution vide its letter dated 07.06.2010 on their own submitted Rs.40000/-
                             for shifting of premises at No.1/261A, Thiruvalluvar Nagar, Vagaikulam,
                             Mudivaithanendal Panchayat, Thoothukudi, Tamilnadu.

                                                                                              rd        nd
                             Accordingly the inspection of the institution was fixed between 23 March-2 April
                             2011. The same was intimated to the institution on 04.03.2011. Accordingly
                             inspection of the institution was conducted on 30.03.2011. The following
                             deficiencies are still persists:

                             The Committee considered the VT Report, VCD and all the relevant
                             documentary evidences and it was decided to serve the Show cause
                             Notice Under Section 17 of NCTE Act for the following :

                              In the Affidavit, the Built up area is not mentioned.

                              Land usage certificate of Tamil version is submitted, English
                               version is to be submitted.

                              Original Building completion certificate from the Competent Govt
                               Engineer is to be submitted.

                              Original FDRs for Rs. 5 lacs & Rs. 3 lacs in joint account from the
                               Nationalised Bank is to be submitted.

                              On observation from VCD, the front view of the building is not
                               clear.


                                                       58


      (Gangadharaiah)                                                          (Prof. C. Thangamuthu)
      Regional Director, SRC, NCTE                                               Chairman, SRC, NCTE
                                                                                       th
                                                                        Minutes of 204 Meeting of SRC
                                                                                       th  th
                                                                                     27 -28 April 2011
                              Non-encumbrance certificate from competent authority is not
                               submitted.

                            In view of the above, the Committee decided to issue a Show cause
                            Notice to the institution as to why the recognition be not withdrawn
                            and thereby providing an opportunity to the institution to make a
                            written representation within 30 days from the date of issue of the
                            Notice along with necessary certificates/documents in order to take a
                            final decision in the matter; failing which action will be taken
                            including the withdrawal of recognition, based on the records
                            available, with no further notice.


48.         APS00025        VPR College of Education, Rayavaram, Mydukur Road, Proddattur,
              B.Ed          Khadarabad, Kadapa-516362, Andhra Pradesh
          VPR College of
            Education,      VPR College of Education, Rayavaram, Mydukur Road, Proddattur,
            Cuddapah        Khadarabad, Kadapa-516362, Andhra Pradesh has submitted application
               AP           for offering B.Ed course on 29.12.2000. The institution has been granted
                            recognition by SRC for offering B.Ed course with an intake of 120 students
                            vide order dated14.05.2003 .

                            The SRC in its 178th meeting held on 13-14 July 2009 considered the
                            reply of the institution and decided to issue Show cause notice and obtain
                            shifting fees and other documents for causing inspection for shifting. As
                            per VTR dated 03.05.2003 and recognition order dated 14.05.2003 it is
                            having own land/building Notice was not issued to the institution.

                            Now, the institution in its letter dated 11.03.2011 has submitted a proposal
                            for shifting of premises along with Rs.40,000/- towards shifting fee along
                            with necessary documents.

                            The committee considered the matter and decided to cause inspection for
                            shifting to own premises of the institution.

                            The inspection of the new premises was conducted ion 30.03.2011. The
                            following deficiencies are still persists:

                            The Committee considered the VT Report, VCD and all the relevant
                            documentary evidences and it was decided to serve the Show cause
                            Notice Under Section 17 of NCTE Act for the following :

                              As per VT/VCD observation the building is still under construction
                               and incomplete.

                              Building completion certificate from the Competent Govt Engineer
                               is to be submitted.

                              Consolidated salaries being paid to the staff.

                                                    59


      (Gangadharaiah)                                                     (Prof. C. Thangamuthu)
      Regional Director, SRC, NCTE                                          Chairman, SRC, NCTE
                                                                                               th
                                                                               Minutes of 204 Meeting of SRC
                                                                                              th  th
                                                                                            27 -28 April 2011
                                In view of the above, the Committee decided to issue a Show cause
                               Notice to the institution as to why the recognition be not withdrawn
                               and thereby providing an opportunity to the institution to make a
                               written representation within 30 days from the date of issue of the
                               Notice along with necessary certificates/documents in order to take a
                               final decision in the matter; failing which action will be taken
                               including the withdrawal of recognition, based on the records
                               available, with no further notice.

49.         APS01028           Baba Teacher Training Institute, Thoothukudi District,
              D.T.Ed           Tamilnadu
          Baba Teacher
         Training Institute,   Baba Teacher Training Institute, Thoothukudi District, Tamilnadu was granted
           Thoothukudi         recognition on 12.01.2005 at Nellai-Madurai Main Road, Kayathur-628952,
                TN             Thoothukudi District, Tamilnadu with the condition to shift to own premises within
                               3 years.

                               The institution vide letter dated 26.02.2010 submitted Rs.40000/- for shifting of
                               premises at Nellai-Madurai Main Road, Kayathur-628952, Thoothukudi
                               District, Tamilnadu

                               Accordingly the inspection of the institution was fixed between 23 rd March-
                               2nd April 2011. The same was intimated to the institution on 04.03.2011.
                               Accordingly inspection of the institution was conducted on 31.03.2011.
                               The following deficiencies are still persists:

                               The Committee considered the VT Report, VCD and all the relevant
                               documentary evidences and it was decided to serve the Show cause
                               Notice Under Section 17 of NCTE Act for the following :

                                The total Built up area earmarked for the D.T.Ed is only 12991.72
                                 sq.ft. which is grossly inadequate for the D.T.Ed as per NCTE
                                 norms. The same is also corroborated by the management by
                                 affixing signature of the management representative in the
                                 essential data. As per NCTE norms total built up area required for
                                 D.El.Ed is 16000 sq.ft.

                                Original Affidavit on Rs. 100/- stamp paper in the prescribed format
                                 with notary attestation is to be submitted.

                                Building completion certificate from the Competent Govt Engineer
                                 is to be submitted.

                                Non- Encumbrance Certificate from the competent Government
                                 Authorised person / Authorities to be submitted.

                                Original FDRs for Rs. 5 lacs & Rs. 3 lacs in joint account from the
                                 Nationalised Bank is to be submitted.

                                Notarised Land documents to be submitted.
                                                         60


      (Gangadharaiah)                                                            (Prof. C. Thangamuthu)
      Regional Director, SRC, NCTE                                                 Chairman, SRC, NCTE
                                                                                                 th
                                                                                Minutes of 204 Meeting of SRC
                                                                                               th  th
                                                                                             27 -28 April 2011

                                In view of the above, the Committee decided to issue a Show cause
                               Notice to the institution as to why the recognition be not withdrawn
                               and thereby providing an opportunity to the institution to make a
                               written representation within 30 days from the date of issue of the
                               Notice along with necessary certificates/documents in order to take a
                               final decision in the matter; failing which action will be taken
                               including the withdrawal of recognition, based on the records
                               available, with no further notice.
50.         APS01173           K.N.  Subbaraj     Memorial    Teacher                   Training        Institute,
              D.T.Ed           Thoothukudi District, Tamilnadu
          K.N. Subbaraj
         Memorial Teacher      K.N. Subbaraj Memorial Educational Trust, Thoothukudi District submitted an
         Training Institute,   application in the name and style of K.N. Subbaraj Memorial Teacher Training
           Thoothukudi         Institute, Thoothukudi District, Tamilnadu for seeking grant of recognition for
                TN             D.T.Ed course on 31.12.2002.

                               The application was processed and the inspection of the institution was carried
                               out on 19.06.2004. Recognition order was issued to the institution on 13.09.2004
                               & additional intake of 50 on 03.09.2005 at K.N. Subbaraj Memorial Teacher
                               Training Institute, Manthitoppu Road, Kamarajar Nagar, Lakshmipuram Post,
                               Kovilpatti-628502, Thoothukudi District, Tamilnadu with the condition to shift to
                               own premises within 3 years.

                               The institution vide its letter dated 09.04.2010 submitted Rs.40000/- for shifting of
                               premises at No.1, Kadalaiyur Road, Ettayauram-628902, Thoothukudi,
                               Tamilnadu.

                               The management is also running B.Ed programme in the same building.
                                                                                                  rd        nd
                               Accordingly the inspection of the institution was fixed between 23 March-2 April
                               2011. The same was intimated to the institution on 04.03.2011. Accordingly
                               inspection of the institution was conducted on 01.04.2011.The following
                               deficiencies are still persists:
                               The Committee considered the VT Report, VCD and all the relevant
                               documentary evidences and it was decided to serve the Show cause
                               Notice Under Section 17 of NCTE Act for the following :

                                From the VCD observation, full view of the building in which
                                 Teacher Education programme run is not shown/seen.

                                The earmarked built up area for each B.Ed and D.T.Ed course is to
                                 be given.

                                In the Affidavit, the total built up area is not mentioned.

                                Land usage certificate of English version is to be submitted.

                               In view of the above, the Committee decided to issue a Show cause
                               Notice to the institution as to why the recognition be not withdrawn
                               and thereby providing an opportunity to the institution to make a
                                                          61


      (Gangadharaiah)                                                              (Prof. C. Thangamuthu)
      Regional Director, SRC, NCTE                                                   Chairman, SRC, NCTE
                                                                                        th
                                                                         Minutes of 204 Meeting of SRC
                                                                                        th  th
                                                                                      27 -28 April 2011
                            written representation within 30 days from the date of issue of the
                            Notice along with necessary certificates/documents in order to take a
                            final decision in the matter; failing which action will be taken
                            including the withdrawal of recognition, based on the records
                            available, with no further notice.

51.        APS01690         Anantha Sadvaidya College of Education, B.H.Road, Arasikere-
              B.Ed          573103, Hassan District, Karnataka
        Anantha Sadvaidya
            College of
                            Anantha Sadvaidya College of Education, B.H.Road, Arasikere-573103,
        Education, Hassan
                            Hassan District Karnataka has submitted application on 30.12.2003. The
               KA
                            institution was granted recognition for offering B.Ed course with an intake
                            of 100 students vide order dated 29.11.2004.

                            The institution was granted recognition with a condition that the institution
                            shall shift to its own premises/building within three years from the date of
                            recogniiton. (In case the course started in rented premises)

                            The institution submitted proposal for shifting of premises on 26.12.2007
                            along with Rs.40,000/- vide Receipt No.13738 dated 21.01.2008 towards
                            inspection fee for shifiting of premises.

                            The institution is also running D.Ed course.
                            The inspection was carried out on 04th April, 2011. The following
                            deficiencies are still persists:

                            The Committee considered the VT Report, VCD and all the relevant
                            documentary evidences and it was decided to serve the Show cause
                            Notice Under Section 17 of NCTE Act for the following :

                              The total Built up area earmarked for the B.Ed is only 13750 sq.ft.
                               which is grossly inadequate as per NCTE norms. The same is also
                               corroborated by the management by affixing signature of the
                               management representative in the essential data. As per NCTE
                               norms total built up area required for B.Ed. is 16000 sq.ft.

                             The management is running the institution in a two storied building
                              accommodating B.Ed, D.Ed & also a nursing school in the same
                              building, which is against the NCTE norms.

                             From the VCD observation, the full view of the building is not
                              seen/shown.

                              Original Affidavit on Rs. 100/- stamp paper in the prescribed format
                               with notary attestation is to be submitted.

                              In the building plan submitted, the total area and built up area is
                               not clear.

                                                    62


      (Gangadharaiah)                                                      (Prof. C. Thangamuthu)
      Regional Director, SRC, NCTE                                           Chairman, SRC, NCTE
                                                                                        th
                                                                         Minutes of 204 Meeting of SRC
                                                                                        th  th
                                                                                      27 -28 April 2011
                              Land documents for own land Khata number 1615 with 10000 sq.ft.
                               is to be submitted.

                              The land documents submitted is Lease Deed for a period of 15
                               years, which is against the NCTE regulations. As per norms, the
                               institution is required to shift to own permanent building or 30
                               years leased land from Government.

                              Only 930 sq,mtrs. land is in the name of the trust.

                              The management is running „Anantha‟ International School in the
                               same building. This is against the NCTE regulations.

                              The survey numbers given in Building completion certificate and
                               Building plan is not matching.

                              Non-Encumbrance certificate is showing different survey numbers.

                              Psychology lab, Education Technology lab and other labs/Physical
                               Education lab needs to be strengthened.

                             In view of the above, the Committee decided to issue a Show cause
                             Notice to the institution as to why the recognition be not withdrawn
                             and thereby providing an opportunity to the institution to make a
                             written representation within 30 days from the date of issue of the
                             Notice along with necessary certificates/documents in order to take a
                             final decision in the matter; failing which action will be taken
                             including the withdrawal of recognition, based on the records
                             available, with no further notice.
52.         APS02046         Impact College of Education & Applied Science, Kodigehalli,
              B.Ed           Sahakarnagar South, Bangalore-560092, Karnataka
         Impact College of
            Education,
            Bangalore        Impact College of Education & Applied Science, Kodigehalli,
                KA           Sahakarnagar South, Bangalore-560092, Karnataka has submitted
                             application for B.Ed course on 31.12.2003. The institution has been
                             granted recognition for B.Ed course with an intake of 100 students on
                             03.02.2006.
                             As per the directions given in SRC in its 175th meeting held on 13-14 May
                             2009, the office of SRC has reviewed the files of the institution who have
                             been granted recognition either in a rented premises pending construction
                             of own building or in lease premises pertaining to the B.Ed., course in the
                             State of Karnataka.
                             A list of such institution has been prepared and placed before SRC in its
                             176th meeting held on 27-28 May, 2009 wherein, it was decided that the
                             institution which have not shifted to the permanent premises even after the
                             expiry of three years time limit be issued notice under Section 17 of NCTE
                             Act for further action. Accordingly, notice was issued to the institution on
                             dated 08.09.2009.

                                                     63


      (Gangadharaiah)                                                      (Prof. C. Thangamuthu)
      Regional Director, SRC, NCTE                                           Chairman, SRC, NCTE
                                                                                  th
                                                                   Minutes of 204 Meeting of SRC
                                                                                  th  th
                                                                                27 -28 April 2011
                      The SRC in its 196th meeting held on 15-16 September 2010 observed
                      that the institution did not care to respond to the Notice served on the
                      institution, for their failure to shift to permanent premises, even after the
                      lapse of three years stipulated period permitted in their conditional orders
                      of recognition. Hence SRC decided to issue Show cause Notice to the
                      institution. Accordingly, notice was issued to the institution on 27.10.2010.
                      The institution submitted its written representation on 12.11.2010. The
                      SRC in its 198th meeting held on 24-26 November 2010 considered the
                      written representation of the institution and decided to cause inspection
                      under section 17 of NCTE Act.

                      The inspection was carried out on 06.04.2011. The following deficiencies
                      are still persists:

                      The Committee considered the VT Report, VCD and all the relevant
                      documentary evidences and it was decided to serve the Show cause
                      Notice Under Section 17 of NCTE Act for the following :

                       The Institution was granted recognition in temporary premises to
                        run B.Ed course on 03.02.2006 with a condition that it should shift
                        to its own permanent premises in 3 years. i.e., on or before
                        02.02.2009. The Institution is still running in temporary premises
                        and has not shifted to new premises even after a lapse of more than
                        5 years and 02 months.

                       The institution is functioning still in the old building, which is being
                        shared with Engineering College. This is a gross violation on the
                        part of the management to share with other colleges/courses and is
                        against the norms of NCTE.

                       The total Built up area earmarked for the B.Ed is only 3490 sq.ft.
                        which is grossly inadequate for the B.Ed as per NCTE norms. The
                        same is also corroborated by the management by affixing signature
                        of the management representative in the essential data. As per
                        NCTE norms total built up area required for B.Ed is 16000 sq.ft.

                       At the time of getting recognition the management has submitted
                        Exchange deed number 51031/12000 for survey number 28/1 & 28/2
                        of Kodigehalli village. Another sale deed submitted dt. 10.12.1998
                        for sy. nos. 10-3-F-1 of Hebbal village. At the time of the first
                        inspection the management has submitted another sale deed dt.
                        12.12.2005 for 35 years for sy,no. 57/3 of Bayyanapalli village. This
                        is against the NCTE norms.

                       As per VT report, the size of the rooms in the building are not
                        matching with Building Plan.

                       In the building plan submitted, built up area and sy,nos are not
                        mentioned.

                                              64


(Gangadharaiah)                                                      (Prof. C. Thangamuthu)
Regional Director, SRC, NCTE                                           Chairman, SRC, NCTE
                                                                                            th
                                                                           Minutes of 204 Meeting of SRC
                                                                                          th  th
                                                                                        27 -28 April 2011
                                Building completion certificate from the competent Govt. Engineer
                                 is to be submitted.

                                Non- Encumbrance Certificate from the competent Government
                                 Authorised person / Authorities to be submitted.

                                Psychology lab and Education Technology lab needs to be
                                 strengthened.

                                Other labs/Physical        Education    facilities   are    shared   with
                                 Engineering College.

                                Language learning lab is not available.

                                Seating capacity in the library is to be increased.

                                Number of books in the library is only 1895, less than required
                                 books as per NCTE norms and Journals are not provided in the
                                 library.

                                Web site is not functioning.

                               In view of the above, the Committee decided to issue a Show cause
                               Notice to the institution as to why the recognition be not withdrawn
                               and thereby providing an opportunity to the institution to make a
                               written representation within 30 days from the date of issue of the
                               Notice along with necessary certificates/documents in order to take a
                               final decision in the matter; failing which action will be taken
                               including the withdrawal of recognition, based on the records
                               available, with no further notice.

53.          APS01300          Sri Thiyagaraja Institute of Teacher Education, Tiruvarur District,
               D.T.Ed          Tamilnadu
          Sri Thiyagaraja
        Institute of Teacher   Sri Thiyagaraja Institute of Teacher Education, Tiruvarur District,
        Education, Tiruvarur   Tamilnadu submitted application for seeking grant of recognition for
                 TN            D.T.Ed course on 06.01.2003.

                               The application was processed and recognition order was issued to the
                               institution on 23.03.2006 at Sri Thiyagaraja Institute of Teacher Education,
                               15-B, Bigmill Street, Vijayapuram, Tiruvarur District-610001, Tamilnadu
                               with the condition to shift to own premises within 3 years.

                               The institution vide its letter dated 30.01.2010 submitted Rs.40000/- for
                               shifting of premises at: Navli Road, Kattur, Thiruvarur-610104, Tamilnadu

                               Accordingly the inspection of the institution was fixed between 23 rd March-
                               2nd April 2011. The same was intimated to the institution on 04.03.2011.
                               Accordingly inspection of the institution was conducted on 06.04.2011.
                                                       65


      (Gangadharaiah)                                                        (Prof. C. Thangamuthu)
      Regional Director, SRC, NCTE                                             Chairman, SRC, NCTE
                                                                                           th
                                                                              Minutes of 204 Meeting of SRC
                                                                                             th  th
                                                                                           27 -28 April 2011
                             The following deficiencies are still persists:

                             The Committee considered the VT Report, VCD and all the relevant
                             documentary evidences and it was decided to serve the Show cause
                             Notice Under Section 17 of NCTE Act for the following :

                              The total Built up area earmarked for the D.T.Ed programme is only
                               13750 Sq.ft. which is grossly inadequate for the Teacher Education
                               Programme as per NCTE norms. The same is also corroborated by
                               the management by affixing signature of the management
                               representative in the essential data.

                              Address of the land as per Questionnaire is to be submitted.

                              In the Affidavit the built up area and survey numbers are not
                               mentioned.

                              Building completion certificate from the approved competent Govt
                               Engineer is to be submitted.

                              Land usage certificate of English version is to be submitted.

                              Non- Encumbrance Certificate from the competent Government
                               Authorised person / Authorities to be submitted.

                              Approved building plan (Blue print) is to be submitted.

                             In view of the above, the Committee decided to issue a Show cause
                             Notice to the institution as to why the recognition be not withdrawn
                             and thereby providing an opportunity to the institution to make a
                             written representation within 30 days from the date of issue of the
                             Notice along with necessary certificates/documents in order to take a
                             final decision in the matter; failing which action will be taken
                             including the withdrawal of recognition, based on the records
                             available, with no further notice.
54.         APS01936         Sarvodaya B.Ed College, No.12, 10th Main, Binny Layout,
               B.Ed          Nagarabhavi Road, Vijayanagar, Bangalore – 560040, Karnataka
         Sarvodaya B.Ed
        College, Bangalore   Sarvodaya B.Ed College, No.12, 10th Main, Binny Layout, Nagarabhavi
                KA
                             Road, Vijayanagar, Bangalore – 560040, Karnataka has submitted
                             application on 31.12.2003. The institution was granted recognition for
                             offering B.Ed course with an intake of 100 students vide order dated
                             04.04.2006.

                             As per the directions given in SRC in its 175th meeting held on 13-14 May
                             2009, the office of SRC has reviewed the files of the institution who have
                             been granted recognition either in a rented premises pending construction
                             of own building or in lease premises pertaining to the B.Ed course in the
                             State of Karnataka.
                                                       66


      (Gangadharaiah)                                                          (Prof. C. Thangamuthu)
      Regional Director, SRC, NCTE                                               Chairman, SRC, NCTE
                                                                                  th
                                                                   Minutes of 204 Meeting of SRC
                                                                                  th  th
                                                                                27 -28 April 2011

                      A list of such institution has been prepared and placed before SRC in its
                      176th meeting held on 27-28 May, 2009 wherein, it was decided that the
                      institution which have not shifted to the permanent premises even after the
                      expiry of three years time limit be issued notice under Section 17 of NCTE
                      Act for further action.

                      As per the decision of SRC, it was decided to issue notice and notice was
                      issued on 02.09.2009.

                      The institution did not care to respond to the Notice served on the
                      institution, for their failure to shift to permanent premises, even after the
                      lapse of three years stipulated period permitted in their conditional orders
                      of recognition and the matter was placed before SRC in its 196th meeting
                      held on 15-16 September 2010. SRC decided to issue Show cause
                      Notice and accordingly show cause notice was issued to the institution on
                      27.10.2010.

                      The institution submitted its written representation on 26.11.2010 and has
                      stated that the Sarvodaya B.Ed College is housed in its own building and
                      the land of the Trust is Civic Amenity site allotted by the Government of
                      Karnataka measuring 0.75 acres and the address of the site is as same as
                      the recognition given by the NCTE. The institution has also stated that the
                      institution is running in its own building and hence the shifting of premises
                      of the B.Ed college does not arise. The institution has further stated that
                      the land is allotted by Government of Karnataka and the institution is
                      having its own building. In view of the above, the institution has requested
                      to drop the show cause notice issued by NCTE, Bangalore. The SRC in
                      199th meeting held on 22-23 December 2010 considered the written
                      representation of the institution and decided to cause inspection under
                      section 17 of NCTE Act.

                      The inspection was carried out on 07th April, 2011.The following
                      deficiencies are still persists:

                      The Committee considered the VT Report, VCD and all the relevant
                      documentary evidences and it was decided to serve the Show cause
                      Notice Under Section 17 of NCTE Act for the following :

                       The total Built up area earmarked for the B.Ed programme is only
                        9035.71 Sq.ft. which is grossly inadequate       for the Teacher
                        Education Programme as per NCTE norms. The same is also
                        corroborated by the management by affixing signature of the
                        management representative in the essential data.

                       The institution is running B.Ed programme which is being shared
                        with a school in the same building, which is against the norms of
                        NCTE norms.

                       Approved building plan from competent civil authority is to be
                                              67


(Gangadharaiah)                                                      (Prof. C. Thangamuthu)
Regional Director, SRC, NCTE                                           Chairman, SRC, NCTE
                                                                                      th
                                                                        Minutes of 204 Meeting of SRC
                                                                                       th  th
                                                                                     27 -28 April 2011
                              submitted.

                             Building completion certificate from the approved competent Govt
                              Engineer is to be submitted.

                             Notarised copy of Land usage certificate issued by competent
                              authority is to be submitted.

                             Psychology lab is to be strengthened.

                             Education Technology lab and other labs/Physical Education is
                              shared with another school, which is against the norms of NCTE.

                             Language learning lab is not available.

                             Out of eight Faculty members, only one faculty member is qualified
                              as per NCTE norms and others are not qualified. The management
                              has to produce a certificate from the affiliating university that the
                              faculty members are qualified as per NCTE norms.

                            In view of the above, the Committee decided to issue a Show cause
                            Notice to the institution as to why the recognition be not withdrawn
                            and thereby providing an opportunity to the institution to make a
                            written representation within 30 days from the date of issue of the
                            Notice along with necessary certificates/documents in order to take a
                            final decision in the matter; failing which action will be taken
                            including the withdrawal of recognition, based on the records
                            available, with no further notice.
55.        APS09328         Chaitanya College of Education, D. No.22-108-8, B.C. Road,
              B.Ed          Pedagantyada, Visakhapatnam Dist-530044, Andhra Pradesh .
        Chaitanya College
          of Education,     An application was submitted by Annapurna Educational and Charitable
         Visakhapatnam      Society, Visakhapatnam District, Andhra Pradesh to the Southern
               AP           Regional Committee of NCTE for grant of permission for conducting B.Ed
                            course with an annual intake of 100 students on 01.01.2008.

                            On scrutiny of the application submitted by the institution, the documents
                            attached therewith the affidavit and the input received from the visiting
                            team in the form of report and videography, the committee was satisfied
                            that the institution fulfills the requirements under the provisions of NCTE
                            Act, Rules and relevant Regulations including the Norms and Standards
                            for the Secondary teacher education programme such as instructional
                            facilities, infrastructural facilities, library, accommodation, financial
                            resources, laboratories etc for running the programme and has appointed
                            duly qualified teaching staff as per NCTE norms.

                            Therefore, in exercise of the powers vested under section 14(3)(a)
                            15(3)(a) of the NCTE Act, 1993, the SRC decided to grant recognition to
                            Chaitanya College of Education, D.No.22-108-8, B.C. Road,
                                                    68


      (Gangadharaiah)                                                    (Prof. C. Thangamuthu)
      Regional Director, SRC, NCTE                                         Chairman, SRC, NCTE
                                                                                        th
                                                                         Minutes of 204 Meeting of SRC
                                                                                        th  th
                                                                                      27 -28 April 2011
                            Pedagantyada, Visakhapatnam         Dist-530044, Andhra Pradesh for
                            conducting B.Ed course of one year duration with an annual intake of 100
                            students from the academic session 2008-2009 under clause 7(11) of
                            NCTE (Recognition Norms & Procedure) Regulations, 2007 and order
                            dated recognition was issued on 22.08.2008

                            Now the institution in its letter dated 08.02.2011 submitted an application
                            for change of Venue of B.Ed College from B.C Road to P.S. Bonangi, in
                            the same revenue division. Hence the institution has submitted Building
                            Completion Certificate and D.D of worth Rs 40,000/- towards processing
                            fees.

                            A complaint has also been received from Dr. K.B.M. Raju, Principal of
                            Chaitanya College of Education, regarding Non payment of Salary even
                            remainders to the Chaitanya College of Education authorities. Hence a
                            complainant has submitted affidavit of Rs 100/- stamp paper indicating the
                            compliant made against institution for non payment of Salary, and
                            submitted the details along with documentary proof.

                            SRC in its 202nd meeting held on 14th-15th March, 2011 considered the
                            written reply and other documents submitted by the institution and decided
                            to cause composite inspection at the new premises Under Section 17 of
                            NCTE Act. The institution is directed to submit the following within 30 days
                            of the receipt of the notice, duly filled in Questionnaire along with all the
                            necessary documents for land, building approval etc.

                            In the meanwhile remarks from the institution to be called for against the
                            complaint received from the Dr. K.B.M Raju, Principal of Chaitanya
                            College of Education, regarding non payment of salary to him even after
                            so many reminders to the institutions authorities.

                            The Committee considered the VT report of the institution, VCD and
                            other related documents along with the original file of the institution
                            and shifting to new/permanent premises is permitted.
56.         APS01884        Sri.Rudramuni Swamiji D.Ed College, Tiptur, Pin – 572201, Tumkur
               D.Ed         District, Karnataka
          Sri Rudramani
           Swamji D.Ed
                            Sri.Rudramuni Swamiji D.Ed College, Tiptur, Pin – 572201, Tumkur
         College, Tumkur
                            District, Karnataka was granted recognition for offering D.Ed. course with
                KA
                            an intake of 50 students vide order dated 01.12.2004. In a temporary
                            premises with a condition that it should shift to its own building within 3
                            years, i.e., on or before 30.11.2007. The Institution is still running in
                            temporary premises and not shifted to new premises even after a lapse of
                            stipulated 3 years and after lapse of time period of more than 6 years.
                            The institution in its letter dated 14.06.2010 has submitted a proposal for
                            shifting of premises along with Rs.40,000/- towards shifting fee.
                            Further, a letter dated 25.11.2010 has been received from NCTE, Hqrs
                            forwarding a copy of the letter dated 29.10.2010 received from Sri

                                                    69


      (Gangadharaiah)                                                      (Prof. C. Thangamuthu)
      Regional Director, SRC, NCTE                                           Chairman, SRC, NCTE
                                                                                th
                                                                 Minutes of 204 Meeting of SRC
                                                                                th  th
                                                                              27 -28 April 2011
                      Nandakumar Complainant against Sri.Rudramuni Swamiji D.Ed College,
                      Tumkur District, Karnataka. NCTE, Hqrs had requested SRC to look into
                      the facts of the complaint by placing before the Regional Committee in the
                      ensuing meeting and take action under the provision of the NCTE Act and
                      to furnish action taken report to the Hqrs.
                      The SRC in its 199th meeting held on 22-23 December 2010 considered
                      the Headquarters communication regarding the complaint against Sri.
                      Rudramuni Swamiji D.Ed College, Tumkur district, Karnataka, and
                      decided to cause inspection for shifting as well as complaint Under
                      Section 17 of NCTE Act.

                      The inspection was carried out on 14.04.2011.The following deficiencies
                      are still persists:

                      The Committee considered the VT Report, VCD and all the relevant
                      documentary evidences and it was decided to serve the Show cause
                      Notice Under Section 17 of NCTE Act for the following :

                       The total Built up area earmarked for the D.Ed programme is only
                        9875 Sq.ft. which is grossly inadequate for the Teacher Education
                        Programme as per NCTE norms. The same is also corroborated by
                        the management by affixing signature of the management
                        representative in the essential data.

                       In the Affidavit Built up Area is not mentioned.

                       The survey numbers of land documents is not matching with that of
                        affidavit.

                       Land usage certificate does not mentioned total land area and built
                        up area.

                        Bye-Laws of the Society are to be submitted by the management.

                        In the Affidavit built up area is not mentioned.

                        Original FDRs for Rs. 5 lacs and Rs. 3 lacs in joint account from
                         the Nationalised Bank is to be submitted.

                        Science lab, Psychology lab and Education Technology lab needs
                         to be strengthened.

                        Language learning lab is not available.

                      In view of the above, the Committee decided to issue a Show cause
                      Notice to the institution as to why the recognition be not withdrawn
                      and thereby providing an opportunity to the institution to make a
                      written representation within 30 days from the date of issue of the
                      Notice along with necessary certificates/documents in order to take a
                                              70


(Gangadharaiah)                                                    (Prof. C. Thangamuthu)
Regional Director, SRC, NCTE                                         Chairman, SRC, NCTE
                                                                                      th
                                                                         Minutes of 204 Meeting of SRC
                                                                                        th  th
                                                                                      27 -28 April 2011
                               final decision in the matter; failing which action will be taken
                               including the withdrawal of recognition, based on the records
                               available, with no further notice.




      Inspection Report – Section 13 & 17:

57.         APS05867           Sri Bhavani Vidyalaya Teacher Training Institute for Women &
            APS08700           Bhavani College of Education, Cuddalore District, Tamilnadu
            APS09797
             D.T.Ed            Sri Bhavani Vidyalaya Teacher Training Institute for Women & Bhavani
                               College of Education, Cuddalore District was granted recognition for
              D.T.Ed-AI        offering D.T.Ed course on 26.10.2006, D.T.Ed-AI on 12.05.2008 and
                 B.Ed          B.Ed course on 24.04.2009.
        Sri Bhavani Vidyalay
          Teacher Training     In the mean time NCTE, Hqrs vide its letter dated 30.03.2011 has
       Institute for Women &   forwarded a copy of the inspection report of Sri Bhavani Vidyalaya
         Bhavani College of    Teacher Training Institute for Women & Bhavani College of Education,
       Education, Cuddalore    Cuddalore District dated 22.09.2010 conducted Under Section 13 of
                  TN           NCTE Act along with documents submitted therewith to SRC for
                               consideration and necessary action as per laid down procedure.

                               The deficiencies communicated on 12.01.2011 by NCTE Hqrs and reply
                               submitted ny institution on 09.02.2011 also enclosed.

                               The SRC, NCTE may look into the matter and take appropriate action as
                               per laid down procedure in NCTE Act, Rules & Regulations under
                               intimation to this office.


                               The Committee considered the VT Report, VCD and all the relevant
                               documentary evidences and it was decided to serve the Show cause
                               Notice for the following:

                                    As per VT report, the earmarked built up area for D.T.Ed &
                                     D.T.Ed-Al is 16008.6 sq.ft and for B.Ed is 16008.6 sq.ft. The
                                     total Built up area for both the courses is 38000 sq.ft. which is
                                     inadequate, against      the NCTE requirement for both the
                                     courses.

                                    Inspection report CD is not available.

                                    Consolidated Salary is paid to the staff.

                                    Staff salary is paid in cash instead of Bank payment.


                                                     71


      (Gangadharaiah)                                                      (Prof. C. Thangamuthu)
      Regional Director, SRC, NCTE                                           Chairman, SRC, NCTE
                                                                                        th
                                                                         Minutes of 204 Meeting of SRC
                                                                                        th  th
                                                                                      27 -28 April 2011
                                  Payment of CPF/EPF of staff members is not maintained.

                             In view of the above, the Committee decided to issue a Show cause
                             Notice to the institution as to why the recognition be not withdrawn
                             and thereby providing an opportunity to the institution to make a
                             written representation within 30 days from the date of issue of the
                             Notice along with necessary certificates/documents in order to take
                             a final decision in the matter; failing which action will be taken
                             including the withdrawal of recognition, based on the records
                             available, with no further notice.


58.         APS02800
               D.Ed          Ankala Reddy Memorial Teacher Training Course, Kurnool-518543,
          Ankala Reddy       Andhra Pradesh has submitted application for D.Ed course on
         Memorial Teacher    30.01.2004.
         Training College,
              Kurnool        Inspection was done on 30.05.2005 (file – page no.90).
                AP
                             Application was under process and meanwhile, the Government of
                             Andhra Pradesh of Hyderabad filed a Writ Petition No.22866 of 2005 in
                             the Hon‟ble High Court of Andhra Pradesh of Hyderabad challenging the
                             Notification of NCTE with regard to the dispensing with the requirement
                             of NOC from the State Government. The writ petition was allowed by the
                             learned single judge with the directions that the rule excluding the State
                             Government is bad. Against said judgment a Writ Appeal No.692 of 2006
                             was filed in the Division Bench of Hon‟ble High Court of Hyderabad.
                             Many discussions took place between the State Government of Andhra
                             Pradesh and SRC-NCTE. However, neither State Government withdrew
                             the case filed by them nor the stay has been vacated.

                             Some institutions went to the court and filed writ petitions individually
                             seeking directions for processing of their applications, in one of such Writ
                             Petition No.8278 of 2008. The Hon‟ble High Court decided that the
                             applications of the institutions shall be processed as per the NCTE rules
                             and regulations norms and standards existing as on date.

                             As per the direction of Hon‟ble High Court and decision of SRC for
                             processing of pending D.Ed application as per new regulation of NCTE in
                             its 164th meeting held on 20th September 2008, the SRC started to
                             process the applications.

                             In view of the above decision, a reminder letter was issued to the
                             institution vide dated 02.01.2009. the institution submitted its reply on
                             10.01.2009 and file was under process and in the meanwhile, in view of
                             the recommendations of the State Government of Andhra Pradesh vide
                             letter dated 07.01.2009 not to further recognize/permit the institutions for
                             conducting B.Ed, D.Ed, Physical Education, Language Pandit Course.
                             SRC in its 169th meeting held on 12-13th January, 2009 having
                                                    72


      (Gangadharaiah)                                                      (Prof. C. Thangamuthu)
      Regional Director, SRC, NCTE                                           Chairman, SRC, NCTE
                                                                                        th
                                                                        Minutes of 204 Meeting of SRC
                                                                                       th  th
                                                                                     27 -28 April 2011
                       considered the letter dated 07.01.2009 of State Government of Andhra
                       Pradesh as such, with immediate effect.

                       A letter dated 07.02.2009 forwarded by Principal Secretary of Education
                       requesting not to accord further recognition/permission to the new
                       colleges/private B.Ed, D.Ed, Physical Education, Language Pandit in the
                       state of Andhra Pradesh as the above colleges are exceeding in numbers
                       than required.

                       A letter dated 17th March, 2009 has been received from NCTE Hqrs.
                       informing that the “the recommendations of the Govt. of Andhra Pradesh
                       not to grant recognition/permission in respect of other courses like B.Ed,
                       D.Ed and Physical Education courses have further been considered in
                       NCTE and it has been decided that no further recognition/Permission to
                       any institution in the State of Andhra Pradesh be considered by SRC for
                       the academic session 2009-10 for B.Ed, D.Ed and Physical Education
                       Courses also.

                       The State Government vide its letter dated 20.03.2009 informed that it
                       has been decided not to recommend the name of your institution.

                       The letters dated 07.01.2009, 07.02.2009, 17.03.2009 and 20.03.2009
                       were considered by SRC in its 172nd meeting held on 25th – 26th March,
                       2009 and SRC decided to accept the recommendation of the State
                       Government of Andhra Pradesh, not to grant recognition to any of the
                       Teacher Training Institutions in the State of Andhra Pradesh for the year
                       2009-2010 and decided to close the applications.

                       Accordingly, a closing letter was issued to the institution on 29.04.2009.

                       Further, the institution has approached Hon‟ble High Court of Andhra
                       Pradesh in W.P.No.17026 of 2010. The court has passed order dated
                       16.07.2010:
                       “in the light of the orders passed by this Court in the similar writ petitions
                       W.P. No. 6712 of 2009, W.P. No.9360 of 2010 and W.P. No.11078 o
                       2010, there shall be a direction to the first respondent to consider the
                       petitioner‟s application for starting D.Ed, course in accordance with law
                       without reference to the State Government‟s policy dated 07.01.2009.

                      The committee considered the matter and decided to process the
                      application, on receipt of Application fee and other relevant documents as
                      per the court orders under intimation to the institution. As per decision of
                      Regional Committee a letter was sent to the institution on 27.09.10 with
                      request to submit documents. As per perusal of file the institution has
                      submitted following documents.
                          Affidavit of Rs. 100/- regarding land - submitted Dt. 22.10.2010.
                          FDR of Rs. 5 lakhs towards endowment fund – submitted.
                          FDR of Rs. 3 lakhs towards reserved fund – submitted.
                          Application fee of Rs. 40.000/- Not submitted.

                                                  73


(Gangadharaiah)                                                           (Prof. C. Thangamuthu)
Regional Director, SRC, NCTE                                                Chairman, SRC, NCTE
                                                                                      th
                                                                         Minutes of 204 Meeting of SRC
                                                                                          th  th
                                                                                        27 -28 April 2011
                        Land documents, sale deed and building plan, BCC & LUC – Submitted, the
                         total extent of land is 3.33 + 3.33 = 6.66 (total 5.00 Acres).
                       Institution has submitted a letter dt. 17.11.2010, in this letter the
                       institution has stated that the application submitted on 30.01.2004 to
                       NCTE and still to make decision in SRC meeting after considering
                       inspection report and hence the question of payment of Rs. 40.000/-
                       .towards application form fees does not arise and there is no need of any
                       inspection since it is a old application.

                       The Committee in its 198th meeting held on 24-26 November 2010
                       considered the matter and decided to cause inspection subject to the
                       condition that the institution has submitted all the necessary documents
                       and the inspection fee and also has rectified the deficiencies, if any as
                       per the norms.

                       As per the decision of SRC inspection team reached the college on
                       24.01.2011.

                       Institution requested for cancellation of inspection and submitted a letter
                       on 03.01.2011 (copy enclosed)

                       The institution has informed that “the Hon‟ble High Court clearly given its
                       judgment stating that to consider petitioner‟s application for starting D.Ed
                       course. Even the NCTE letter vide reference at one above asking the
                       management to comply with fulfillment of deficiencies under section 14 of
                       the NCTE act.

                       The management has also requested to consider previous inspection
                       report and subsequent compliance reports regarding fulfillment of all
                       deficiencies and grant recognition to Ankala Reddy D.Ed College
                       Allagadda, Kurnool District, Andhra Pradesh without any second
                       inspection even though it is already very high time and oblige.

                       SRC in its 201st meeting held on 22nd-23rd February, 2011 considered the
                       VT Report, VCD and all the relevant documentary evidences and it was
                       decided to cause re-inspection as the request can be considered only
                       after a fresh visit, as the earlier visit was done more than six years
                       before.    The visit is needed to know the present status of the
                       infrastructural & instructional facilities of the institution .

                        The institution is not within its right to seek exemption from inspection
                         as the application is more than seven year old and that there is no
                         guarantee that the same land/infra-structure would remain in the
                         same condition during the last seven year period.
                        It is far-fetched for the institution to misinterpret the court orders as if
                         the court was against the inspection of the seven-year old applicant-
                         institution. The court only directed to consider the application “in
                         accordance with law”.
                        It is impertiment on the part of the institution to have disallowed the
                         VT (which had reached the institution), from discharging its official
                                                74


(Gangadharaiah)                                                         (Prof. C. Thangamuthu)
Regional Director, SRC, NCTE                                              Chairman, SRC, NCTE
                                                                                   th
                                                                      Minutes of 204 Meeting of SRC
                                                                                     th  th
                                                                                   27 -28 April 2011
                                 responsibilities of inspection.
                              The institution be required to remit another inspection fee of
                                 Rs.40,000/- to enable the SRC to consider the case, under the
                                 conditions explained above.
                             The institution also running B.Ed course Vide order dt. 21.07.2000.
                             Inspection of the institution was carried out on 25.03.2011 as per SRC
                             direction.

                             The Committee considered the VT Report, VCD and all the relevant
                             documentary evidences and it was decided to serve Show cause
                             Notice for the following:

                                  As per VT report, the land documents are in the name of Shri K.
                                   Ramalinga Reddy correspondent of the institution instead of in
                                   the name of the Society/Trust/Institution.

                                  Psychology Lab & Physical Education lab needs to be
                                  strengthened.

                                  Language learning lab is not available.

                                  The management has not appointed any teaching staff for D.Ed
                                   course.

                                  As per VT report, the construction of the new building for D.Ed
                                   course is of very much poor quality.

                                  Out dated furniture and steel desks are in broken condition,
                                   which are unfit for classrooms where D.Ed programme is going
                                   to be conducted.

                                  From VCD observation, the roof of the building is covered with
                                   Asbestos sheet like roof.

                                  The institution has to make payment of Rs. 40000/-towards Re-
                                   inspection fee.

                                  As per VT report, meager materials were available.

                             In view of the above, the Committee decided to issue a Show cause
                             Notice to the institution as to why the recognition be not refused
                             and thereby providing an opportunity to the institution to make a
                             written representation within 30 days from the date of issue of the
                             Notice along with necessary certificates/documents in order to take
                             a final decision in the matter; failing which action will be taken
                             including the refusal of recognition, based on the records available,
                             with no further notice.

59.         APS07460          Mother Theresa D.Ed College, Suryapet, Nalgonda, Andhra Pradesh
                                                   75


      (Gangadharaiah)                                                  (Prof. C. Thangamuthu)
      Regional Director, SRC, NCTE                                       Chairman, SRC, NCTE
                                                                                          th
                                                                       Minutes of 204 Meeting of SRC
                                                                                      th  th
                                                                                    27 -28 April 2011
        D.Ed
 Mother Theresa D.Ed   An application was submitted by Solmanraj Educational Society, Suryapet,
  College, Nalgonda    Nalgonda for grant of recognition to D.Ed course in the office of SRC-NCTE,
         AP            vide dated 27.09.2006

                       The file was processed and this office letter dated 21.11.20006 communicating
                       therewith the deficiencies and directing therewith for removal of the same within
                       90 days from the date of issue of the deficiency letter as per the provisions
                       contained in the NCTE Regulation dated 13.01.2006.

                       On perusal of the application it was noted that the stipulated period of 90 days
                       has been expired and the institution has not complied to the letters dated
                       21.05.2007, 31.07.2007 & 17.09.2007.

                       Consequent upon the direction of the SRC the application submitted for grant of
                       teacher education course has been treated incomplete.

                       As per the decision of SRC the application was closed on 01.02.2008.

                       The Institute has approached to Hon‟ble High Court in W.P.No.20439/2010
                       without exhausting remedy of appeal to appellate authority under section 18 of
                       NCTE Act.

                       Now, the Hon‟ble High Court has passed an order as hereunder:

                       “The petitioner intended to established a College of Education at Suryapet,
                       Nalgonda District. The National Council for Teacher Edication, first respondent
                       herein, had to accord approval for this purpose. Application dated 27.09.2006
                       was made to it by the petitioner enclosing the required documents and remitting
                       an amount of Rs.40000/- for the purpose of inspection of the proposed college.
                       This writ petition is filed by the petitioner complaining that the first respondent
                       had not taken any steps to inspect the proposed college.

                       Heard the learned counsel for the petitioner and the learned counsel for the first
                       respondent.

                       The State Government is said to have reviewed the situation as to the necessity
                       of according permission to establish new colleges of education in the State in
                       future and by its letter dated 07.01.2009 communicated its policy decision to the
                       first respondent that the existing institutions were adequate. However, the right
                       that is accrued to the petitioner on the basis of its application and the
                       consideration thereof by the first respondent cannot be taken away on account of
                       the change of policy. It is settled principle of law that whenever an application is
                       made, it must be considered and processed in accordance with the provisions of
                       law or the policy that existed as on the date of its presentation. Subsequent
                       changes may apply to the applications that are made thereafter.

                       Hence, the writ petition is disposed of directing the first respondent(SRC) to take
                       necessary steps in the matter and pass appropriate orders. No order as to
                       costs.”
                                                               th            th      th
                       SRC considered the matter in its 197 meeting 13 – 14 October 2010 and
                       directed the Management/institution to resubmit the old application returned by
                       SRC along with necessary documents as originally submitted relating to land,

                                                 76


(Gangadharaiah)                                                           (Prof. C. Thangamuthu)
Regional Director, SRC, NCTE                                                Chairman, SRC, NCTE
                                                                                     th
                                                                    Minutes of 204 Meeting of SRC
                                                                                       th  th
                                                                                    27 -28 April 2011
                       building, FDR, Application fee, Building Completion Certificate from competent
                       Government Engineer/authority and other relevant aspects for processing and
                       for necessary action.

                       As per the decision of SRC a letter was issued to the institution on 19.10.2010
                       and a deficiency letter was issued on 18.11.2010. In reply to our letter dated
                       18.11.2010 institution has submitted its reply on 22.11.2010 & 27.12.2010. From
                       the reply it is found that the institution purchased land only on 14/05/2008 and
                       20/05/2008 after submission of the initial application on 27.9.2006.
                                                th
                       The committee in its 200 meeting held on 20-21 January 2011 considered the
                       written explanation to the notice and other documents submitted by the
                       institution and decided to cause inspection

                       The land and building is on lease for 30 years as per Regulation 2006.
                       How ever lease deed is of November 2010.

                       Note:

                           1. The institution has submitted two sale deed dated 20.05.2008 and
                              14.05.2008 now in favor of Maram Venkata Reddy and Damidi
                              Prabhakar Reddy for S.No. 316 & 316/E, Bechirag village,
                              Suryapet, Nalgonda S.No. 316 & 65 in the same village
                              respectively. The sales deeds are not in the name of society or
                              institution and they are of a date subsequent to the application
                              date. In the initial application which was processed and closed the
                              land document was a sale deed for sy. No. 215/A3,
                              215/A1,215/B2 and building plan was for S.No. 9 at Suryapet. The
                              application was closed for non reply to Dl.
                           2. Along with resubmitted application a private lease deed of
                              10/11/2010 has been submitted for S.No. 316 & 316E, leased out
                              by private party Maram Veakat Reddy to Solman Raju
                              Educational Society which is not in accordance with regulation
                              2009. Even if the application is taken to be of 2006. The lease
                              deed is a subsequent one of 4 years late. The institution‟s
                              application is not closed due to any change in policy but for not
                              replying to DL in time as per notes in the main files letter dt.
                              01.2.2008 refers.

                       The inspection of the institution was done on 28.03.2011.

                       The Committee considered the VT Report, VCD and all the relevant
                       documentary evidences and it was decided to serve Show cause
                       Notice for the following:

                            The VCD received is not functioning.

                            A Certificate from the Government Affiliating body to the effect
                             that no other programme is being run by the institution in the
                             same building / Campus, along with the existing Course B.Ed
                             to be submitted.
                                                77


(Gangadharaiah)                                                        (Prof. C. Thangamuthu)
Regional Director, SRC, NCTE                                             Chairman, SRC, NCTE
                                                                                         th
                                                                          Minutes of 204 Meeting of SRC
                                                                                         th  th
                                                                                       27 -28 April 2011

                               In view of the above, the Committee decided to issue a Show cause
                               Notice to the institution as to why the recognition be not refused
                               and thereby providing an opportunity to the institution to make a
                               written representation within 30 days from the date of issue of the
                               Notice along with necessary certificates/documents in order to take
                               a final decision in the matter; failing which action will be taken
                               including the refusal of recognition, based on the records available,
                               with no further notice.

60.         APS09304           An application was submitted by Sri Raghavendra Educational
               D.Ed            Society, West Godavari, Andhra Pradesh for grant of recognition to Sri
         Sri Raghavendra       Raghavendra College of Education, Bhimavaram Taluk, West Godavari
       College of Education,   District Andhra Pradesh for D.Ed course of Two year duration under
          West Godavari        section 15(1) of the NCTE Act, 1993 to the Southern Regional
                AP             Committee, NCTE on 19.02.2008.

                               The application was processed and a deficiency letter was issued on
                               06.03.2008. The application submitted its reply vide dated 05.04.2008
                               which was received on 09.04.2008.The reply was scrutinized and a
                               reminder letter was issued on 29.04.2008. The institution submitted its
                               reply on 08.05.2008. The reply was further scrutinized and 2nd reminder
                               was issued on 18.07.2008, and also a copy of the application was
                               forwarded to the State Government for its recommendation on
                               07.08.2008.

                               The institution submitted its written representation for 2nd reminder on
                               28.08.2008. All the documents were verified and it was found complete.
                               Accordingly letter of consent was issued to the institution on 09.09.2008.
                               The institution submitted its consent for inspection on 30.09.2008.

                               In the meanwhile, in view of the recommendations of the State
                               Government of Andhra Pradesh vide letter dated 07.01.2009 requested
                               not to further recognize/permit the institutions for conducting B.Ed, D.Ed,
                               Physical Education, Language Pandit Courses. SRC in its 169th Meeting
                               held on 12-13 January, 2009 having considered the letter dated
                               07.01.2009 of State Government of Andhra Pradesh and decided to give
                               effect to the above decision of State Government of Andhra Pradesh as
                               such, with immediate effect.

                               A letter dated 07.02.2009 forwarded by Principal Secretary of education
                               requesting not to accord further recognition/permission to the new
                               colleges/private B.Ed, D.Ed, Physical Education, Language Pandit in the
                               State of Andhra Pradesh as the above colleges are exceeding in
                               numbers than required, was also received.

                               A letter dated 17th March 2009 was also received from NCTE Hqrs
                               informing that the “The recommendations of the Government of Andhra
                               Pradesh not to grant recognition/permission in respect of other courses

                                                      78


      (Gangadharaiah)                                                       (Prof. C. Thangamuthu)
      Regional Director, SRC, NCTE                                            Chairman, SRC, NCTE
                                                                                   th
                                                                    Minutes of 204 Meeting of SRC
                                                                                   th  th
                                                                                 27 -28 April 2011
                       like B.Ed, D.Ed and Physical Education courses have further been
                       considered in NCTE and it has been decided that no further
                       recognition/permission to any institution in the state of Andhra Pradesh
                       be considered by SRC for the academic session 2009-10 for B.Ed, D.Ed
                       and physical Education courses also. The State Government vide its
                       letter dated 20.03.2009 informed that it has been decided not to
                       recommend the name of the institution. The letters dated 07.01.2009,
                       07.02.2009, 17.03.2009 and 20.03.2009 were considered by SRC in its
                       172nd meeting held on 25-26 March 2009 and SRC decided to accept
                       the recommendation of the State Government of Andhra Pradesh, not to
                       grant recognition to any of the Teacher Training Institutions in the state of
                       Andhra Pradesh for the year 2009-10 and decided to close the
                       applications.

                       As per direction of SRC an order was issued to the applicant institution
                       on 22.04.2009 with direction to no further correspondence will be
                       entertained in this regard.

                       The institution has approached to Hon‟ble High Court of Andhra Pradesh
                       W.P.No 11587/09 without exhausting remedy of appeal to appellate
                       authority under section 18 of NCTE Act.

                      Hon‟ble High court has passed order dated first day of June, two thousand
                      and ten. The operative part of order as under:-
                       “These Writ Petitions raise common issues. Therefore with the consent of
                       the learned counsel for the parties, they are taken up for hearing and
                       disposal together.

                       In all these Writ petitions, the petitioners, which are educational
                       Institutions, felt aggrieved by non-consideration of their applications for
                       grant of recognition to D.Ed/B.Ed courses purportedly on the ground of
                       the policy decision taken by the Government not to permit establishment
                       of new D.Ed/B.Ed Colleges.

                       At the hearing, Sri Andapalli Sanjeev Kumar, learned counsel appearing
                       for the petitioners in Writ Petition Nos.11038, 11040, 11587 and 10965 of
                       2009, and Sri S. Girimoji Rao, learned counsel for the petitioner in Writ
                       petition No.11241 of 2009, submitted that the petitioners filed their
                       applications for recognition prior to the policy decision taken by the State
                       Government; and that in an identical Writ petition, this Court, vide: order
                       dated 16-12-2009 in writ petition No.6712 of 2009, held as under:-

                       “It may be true the State Government as well the first respondent have
                       reviewed the situation as to the necessity or otherwise of according
                       permission to establish new colleges of education in the State any further
                       and that the existing institutions are found to be adequate. However, the
                       right that is accrued to the petitioners on the basis of their application and
                       the consideration there of by the first respondent cannot be taken away
                       on account of the change of policy. It is settled principle of law that
                       whenever an application is made, it must be considered and processed in
                                               79


(Gangadharaiah)                                                       (Prof. C. Thangamuthu)
Regional Director, SRC, NCTE                                            Chairman, SRC, NCTE
                                                                                   th
                                                                    Minutes of 204 Meeting of SRC
                                                                                   th  th
                                                                                 27 -28 April 2011
                       accordance with the provisions of law or the policy that existed as on the
                       date of presentation. Subsequent changes may apply to the applications
                       that are made thereafter.

                       Hence, the writ petition is disposed of directing the first respondent to
                       take necessary steps as contemplated in its communication dated 24-11-
                       2009 and pass appropriate orders.
                       There shall be no order as to coasts”.

                       The learned Standing Counsel representing respondents 2 and 3 has not
                       disputed the above position.

                       Since the issue raised in these Writ Petitions are squarely covered by the
                       above mentioned orders, these Writ petitions are disposed of in terms of
                       the above mentioned orders in writ petition No.6712 of 2009 with the
                       direction that the directions given in the said orders shall form part of this
                       orders.”

                       SRC in its 194th meeting held on 21-22 July 2010 considered the matter
                       and directed the Management/institution to resubmit the old application
                       returned by SRC along with necessary documents as originally submitted
                       relating to land, building, FDR, Application fee, Building Completion
                       Certificate from competent Government Engineer/ authority and other
                       relevant aspects for processing and for necessary action.

                       As per the decision of SRC a letter was issued to the institution on
                       07.09.2010.

                       In reply to the letter dated 07.09.2010 institution has submitted a copy of
                       Building completion certificate approved by Mandal Engineering Officer
                       and FDRs of Rs.5 lakhs and Rs.3 lakhs from Karur Vysya Bank ltd.,

                       The SRC in its 198th meeting held on 24-26 November 2010 considered
                       the matter and all relevant documents and decided to cause inspection to
                       examine whether the institution fulfils all the requirements as per the
                       norms, for the proposed programme, subject to the condition that the
                       deficiencies, if any, were duly rectified by the institution, as per the
                       norms.

                       The institution is running B.Ed course of 100 students from the session
                       2007-2008 and order was issued on 26.10.2007

                       FDR submitted by the institution is not from nationalized bank

                       The Committee considered the VT Report, VCD and all the relevant
                       documentary evidences and it was decided to serve Show cause
                       Notice for the following:

                           As per VCD it is clear that the building where the D.Ed

                                               80


(Gangadharaiah)                                                       (Prof. C. Thangamuthu)
Regional Director, SRC, NCTE                                            Chairman, SRC, NCTE
                                                                                             th
                                                                             Minutes of 204 Meeting of SRC
                                                                                            th  th
                                                                                          27 -28 April 2011
                                    programme supposed to run is a residential complex having
                                    multi-storied flats, which is unsuited for education programme.
                                    The building is partly roofed with asbestos sheets, which is
                                    against the NCTE Norms.
                                   The FDRs are not from Nationalised Banks.

                               In view of the above, the Committee decided to issue a Show cause
                               Notice to the institution as to why the recognition be not refused
                               and thereby providing an opportunity to the institution to make a
                               written representation within 30 days from the date of issue of the
                               Notice along with necessary certificates/documents in order to take
                               a final decision in the matter; failing which action will be taken
                               including the refusal of recognition, based on the records available,
                               with no further notice.

61.          APS07104          A.M Reddy College of Education, Petluvari Palem, Narasaraopet
               B.Ed            Mandal, Guntur District-522601, Andhra Pradesh. .Course- B.Ed.
        A.M. Reddy College     (Code no. APS07104)
        of Education, Guntur
                AP             A.M Reddy College of Education, Petluvari Palem, Narasaraopet Mandal,
                               Guntur District-522601, Andhra Pradesh has made an application on
                               31.03.2006 for B.Ed course to SRC, NCTE, Bangalore.
                               The SRC after considering the report of the visiting team as well as other
                               relevant materials, granted recognition to the institution for offering B.Ed
                               course with an intake of 100 students from the session 2007-2008 vide
                               order no. F.SRO/NCTE/B.Ed/2006-2007/3330 dated 26.05.2007.
                               The Government of Andhra Pradesh vide letter dated 06.03.2007
                               forwarded a list of institutions not recommending the name of colleges
                               with the specific reasons with a request to NCTE-SRC to take necessary
                               action against the institutions, this institution is one of the institutions not
                               recommended.
                               The matter was placed before the SRC in its 150th meeting held on 28th –
                               29th December, 2007. The SRC after careful consideration of all aspects
                               decided to conduct the inspection of the institution under section 17. The
                               inspection of the institution was conducted on 22.04.2008 and the report
                               was received. The report was considered by SRC in its 161st meeting
                               held on 6th –7th August, 2008 and upon consideration of all aspects it was
                               decided to serve a show cause notice to the institution under section 17
                               of NCTE Act 1993.
                               Accordingly, a show cause notice was served to the institution vide dated
                               25.08.2008. the reply received vide dated 03.10.2008 was placed before
                               SRC in its 166th meeting held on 18th – 19th October, 2008. The SRC
                               considered the points raised in the show cause notice, the deficiencies
                               pointed out in the report forwarded by State Government, VCD, two
                               visiting team reports under section 14 and under section 17 of NCTE Act,
                               1993, and decided to withdraw the recognition from the academic
                               session 2008-2009.

                                                        81


      (Gangadharaiah)                                                          (Prof. C. Thangamuthu)
      Regional Director, SRC, NCTE                                               Chairman, SRC, NCTE
                                                                                   th
                                                                   Minutes of 204 Meeting of SRC
                                                                                  th  th
                                                                                27 -28 April 2011
                       Accordingly, a withdrawal of recognition order was issued to the
                       institution on 22.10.2008 for the proposed B.Ed course as per section
                       15(3)(b) of NCTE Act.
                       The applicant institution preferred an appeal under Section 18 of NCTE
                       Act, before NCTE, New Delhi. The Appellate Authority considering the
                       appeal passed an order vide.F.No.89-360/2008 dated 09.02.2009
                       confirming the decision of SRC.
                       Further the institution has approached Hon‟ble High Court of Andhra
                       Pradesh in Writ Petition No.3609 of 2009. The court has passed an order
                       dated 02.08.2010 as under:
                               1. The impugned orders dated 09.02.2009 22.10.2008 if
                                   respondent Nos.1 and 2 respectively are set aside.
                               2. The petitioner shall complete the new building with all facilities
                                   necessary for running the college by the first week of October,
                                   2010. It shall pay the inspection and shifting fees to
                                   respondent No.2 within a period of four weeks from today.
                                   Respondent No.2 is entitled to depute an inspection team in
                                   the first week of October, 2010, by which time, the petitioner
                                   shall make the building ready for inspection.
                               3. On the basis of the repot to be submitted by the inspection
                                   team respondent No.2 shall take a fresh decision and pending
                                   the decision the petitioner college shall be included in the list
                                   of the colleges eligible for admission of the students for the
                                   academic year 2010-2011. If an adverse report is submitted
                                   by the inspection team, respondent No.2 shall be free to pass
                                   appropriate orders in accordance with the provisions of the
                                   Act and the regulations made thereunder.
                       The institution has not submitted any fees and other relevant documents
                       as yet.
                       SRC in its 197th meeting held on 13th –14th October, 2010considered the
                       matter and all the relevant documents and it was decided to issue Show
                       cause Notice Under Section 17 of NCTE Act. Accordingly, a show cause
                       notice was issued to the institution for seeking clarification on
                       01.12.2010. The institution has submitted its written representation on
                       03.01.2011

                       SRC in its 201st meeting held on 22nd-23rd February, 2011 considered the
                       matter and decided to cause inspection.

                       The Committee considered the VT Report, VCD and all the relevant
                       documentary evidences and it was decided to serve Show cause
                       Notice under Section 17 of NCTE Act for the following:

                           As per VT report, the institution is running Engineering &
                            Pharmacy programme in the same building along with B.Ed
                            programme, which is a serious violation of norms.

                           Latest building completion certificate from the authorized
                                               82


(Gangadharaiah)                                                      (Prof. C. Thangamuthu)
Regional Director, SRC, NCTE                                           Chairman, SRC, NCTE
                                                                                      th
                                                                       Minutes of 204 Meeting of SRC
                                                                                      th  th
                                                                                    27 -28 April 2011
                                 Competent Govt. Engineer is to be submitted.

                                 The survey number 45/1 in Building Completion Certificate and
                                  Building Plan is not matching with Sy.Nos 176/3, 177/3, 178,
                                  54/1, 54/2 in Petlurivaripalem village as shown in Land usage
                                  certificate dt. 29.05.2007 and sale deed 8.9.2003, in favour of
                                  society.


                             In view of the above, the Committee decided to issue a Show cause
                             Notice to the institution as to why the recognition be not withdrawn
                             and thereby providing an opportunity to the institution to make a
                             written representation within 30 days from the date of issue of the
                             Notice along with necessary certificates/documents in order to take
                             a final decision in the matter; failing which action will be taken
                             including the withdrawal of recognition, based on the records
                             available, with no further notice.

62.         APS05578         St. Mark NTR Institute of Elementary Teacher Education, St.
               D.Ed          Anthony‟s Educational Society, Krishnaveni Campus, Pedda Cheru,
           St. Mark NTR      Narasaraopet, Guntur Dist-522601, Andhra Pradesh. .Course- D.Ed.
            Institute of     (Code no. APS05578)
        Elementary Teacher
         Education, Guntur   An application was submitted by St.Mark NTR Institute of Elementary
                AP           Teacher Education, Guntur, A.P for grant of recognition to D.Ed course in
                             the office of SRC-NCTE, Bangalore vide dated 30.12.2005
                             The file was under process and in the meanwhile, in view of the
                             recommendations of the State Government of Andhra Pradesh vide letter
                             dated 07.01.2009 not to further recognize/permit the institutions for
                             conducting B.Ed, D.Ed, Physical Education, Language Pandit course(s),
                             to this effect that application for B.Ed, D.Ed, Physical Education,
                             Language Pandit courses from the States of Andhra Pradesh will not be
                             considered for the academic session 2009-2010 and all such applications
                             shall be returned along with processing fees and documents.
                             The SRC in its 169th meeting held on 12-13th January, 2009 having
                             considered the letter dated 7.1.2009 of State Government of Andhra
                             Pradesh and decided to give effect to the decision of above decision of
                             State Government of Andhra Pradesh as such, with immediate effect.
                             Further, a letter dated 07.02.2009 forwarded by Principal Secretary of
                             Education requesting not to accord further recognition/permission to the
                             new colleges/private B.Ed , D.Ed, Physical Education, Language Pandit
                             in the state of Andhra Pradesh as the above colleges are exceeding in
                             numbers than required.
                             Meanwhile, a letter dated 17.03.2009 has been received from NCTE
                             Hqrs informing that the “ The recommendations of the Govt. of Andhra
                             Pradesh not to grant recognition/ permission in respect of other courses
                             like B.Ed , D.Ed and Physical Education courses have further been
                             considered in NCTE and it has been decided that no further
                                                    83


      (Gangadharaiah)                                                    (Prof. C. Thangamuthu)
      Regional Director, SRC, NCTE                                         Chairman, SRC, NCTE
                                                                                 th
                                                                  Minutes of 204 Meeting of SRC
                                                                                 th  th
                                                                               27 -28 April 2011
                       recognition/Permission to any institution in the state of Andhra Pradesh
                       be considered by SRC for the academic session 2009-10 for B.Ed , D.Ed
                       and physical Education Courses also”.
                       Further, the state Government vide its letter dated 20.03.2009 informed
                       that it has been decided not to recommend the name of this institution.
                       The letters dated 07.01.2009, 07.02.2009, 17.03.2009 and 20.03.2009
                       were considered by SRC in its 172nd meeting held on 25th-26th March
                       2009 and SRC decided to accept the recommendation of the State
                       Government of Andhra Pradesh, not to grant recognition to any of the
                       Teacher Training Institutions in the state of Andhra Pradesh for the year
                       2009-10 and decided to close the applications.
                       As per the decision of SRC the application was closed on 29.04.2009.
                       The Hon‟ble High Court has passed an order on 23.04.2010 vide
                       W.P.No.9360 of 2010 to consider the application of the petitioner without
                       making reference to the recommendation of State Government policy
                       dated 07.01.2009.
                       Further, a letter has been received from NCTE, Hqrs vide letter No.64-
                       138/2010/NCTE/legal dated 02.06.2010 with the direction to file Counter
                       Affidavit in the matter incorporating the provision of filing appeal under
                       section 18 of NCTE Act and to defend the case including on behalf of
                       NCTE (HQ) under intimation to this office.
                       The Committee considered the matter and decided to process the
                       application.
                        As per decision of Regional Committee the file has been processed and
                        deficiency letter was issued on 17.08.2010. The institution is having land
                        and building on a lease of 30 years as per regulation 2006. As per
                        questionnaire submitted by institution on 28.09.2010 it is having land on
                        ownership in Sr. NO. 522/2- total 1 Acres and the building is constructed
                        over it.
                       The institution is already running B.Ed course with 100 intake.
                       As per affidavit dated 03.04.07 it is showing that it has permanent land in
                       Sr. No. 48,60,61 of Kesanupalli, Village, Narasaraopet Mandal, Guntur
                       District to extent of 2.23 hectares. The sale Deed dated 24.12.2005
                       states that the institution is having land of one acre in Southern Regional
                       Committee. NO. 48,60,61 in Kesanupalli Village, Narasaraopet Mandal,
                       Guntur, Andhra Pradesh.
                       SRC in its 201st meeting held on 22nd-23rd February, 2011 considered the
                       matter and decided to cause inspection.

                       The Committee considered the VT Report, VCD and all the relevant
                       documentary evidences and it was decided to serve Show cause
                       Notice for the following:

                           The application submitted for grant of recognition to D.Ed
                            course by the institution on 30.12.2005, whereas the land
                                              84


(Gangadharaiah)                                                     (Prof. C. Thangamuthu)
Regional Director, SRC, NCTE                                          Chairman, SRC, NCTE
                                                                                      th
                                                                       Minutes of 204 Meeting of SRC
                                                                                      th  th
                                                                                    27 -28 April 2011
                                 document submitted by the institution on lease basis registered
                                 on 30.09.2008. This is not permissible as per NCTE norms. As
                                 per the norms, the management should have owned the land
                                 even at the time of application.

                                 Non- Encumbrance Certificate from the competent Government
                                  Authorised person / Authority is to be submitted.
                             In view of the above, the Committee decided to issue a Show cause
                             Notice to the institution as to why the recognition be not refused
                             and thereby providing an opportunity to the institution to make a
                             written representation within 30 days from the date of issue of the
                             Notice along with necessary certificates/documents in order to take
                             a final decision in the matter; failing which action will be taken
                             including the refusal of recognition, based on the records available,
                             with no further notice.

63.         APS03826         KSS College of Education, #1949/3, D.M.S. “Sadhana”, Last Bus
              B.Ed           Stop, Vidyanagar, Davangere District-577005, Karnataka
          KSS College of
            Education,
           Davangere         KSS College of Education, #1949/3, D.M.S. “Sadhana”, Last Bus Stop,
               KA            Vidyanagar, Davangere District-577005, Karnataka has submitted
                             application to SRC, NCTE on 29.12.2001. The institution been granted
                             recognition for B.Ed course on 04.01.2006.
                             As per the decision of 175th meeting held on 13-14 May 2009 the
                             institutions where recognition were granted in temporary premises with a
                             condition to shift to permanent premises within period of three years time
                             limit of grant of recognition as per NCTE regulations 2002 notified in
                             18.11.2002 were considered. It was decided that institutions which have
                             not shifted to the permanent premises even after the expiry of three years
                             time limit be issued notice under section 17 of NCTE Act. Accordingly
                             section 17 notice was issued to the institution on 02.09.2009. The
                             institution has submitted its reply on 26.10.2009.

                             SRC in its 187th meeting held on 28-29 December 2009 considered the
                             written representation and decided to withdraw recognition for B.Ed
                             course with noted reasons.

                             In the meantime, the institution has approached the Hon‟ble High Court
                             of Karnataka in W.P.3176 of 2010 and hence the withdrawal order could
                             not be issued to the institution.

                             A letter has been received from Sri.Ashok Haranahalli, Advocate by
                             enclosing a copy of the order available on the High Court Website for
                             immediate compliance. The order dated 02.02.2011 reads as under:

                             Learned counsel for respondent submits that pursuant to the resolution
                             No.3826 dated 29-30/12/2009 in withdrawing the recognition to the
                             petitioner‟s educational institute, the same has not been communicated
                                                    85


      (Gangadharaiah)                                                    (Prof. C. Thangamuthu)
      Regional Director, SRC, NCTE                                         Chairman, SRC, NCTE
                                                                                   th
                                                                    Minutes of 204 Meeting of SRC
                                                                                   th  th
                                                                                 27 -28 April 2011
                       to the petitioner and therefore the respondent seeks leave of the court to
                       communicate that order. Permission is granted. Letter to be furnished to
                       the learned counsel for petitioner within 10 days.
                       Accordingly, order withdrawing recognition was issued to the institution
                       on 03.03.2011 for B.Ed course.

                       The Hon'ble High Court of Karnataka in W.P.3176 of 2010 dated
                       11.03.2011 has passed the order which reads as under:

                        … the 2nd respondent (NCTE) has to make an inspection of the new
                        premises of the college in question. It should also accept the shifting fee
                        from the petitioner. Therefore, the petitioner is directed to deposit a sum
                        of Rs.40,000/- with the 2nd respondent towards shifting fee within one
                        weeks. The petitioner is further directed to deposit an additional sum of
                        Rs.40,000/- with the 2nd respondent towards inspection fee within one
                        week.
                    (4)               The 2nd respondent is directed to inspect the new premises of
                        the college in question within a period of four weeks from today and
                        submit the report to this Court.
                        Accordingly, as per the directions of the Hon'ble High Court of Karnataka
                        the institution in its letter dated 16.03.2011 has submitted Rs.40,000/-
                        vide DD.No.249036 dated 15.03.2011 towards shifting fee.                The
                        institution has also submitted another letter dt.18.03.2011 by submitting
                        another Demand Draft of Rs.40,000/- bearing No.121074 dated
                        18.03.2011 towards inspection fee. In this regard, it has been pointed
                        out that the institution has submitted two Demand Drafts of Rs.40,000/-
                        each. Inspection for shifting is to be conducted for three courses i.e
                        D.Ed, B.Ed and M.Ed and the institution was requested to submit the
                        Demand Draft of Rs.40,000/- more. Accordingly, a letter intimating the
                        date of inspection and seeking for DD of Rs.40,000/- was issued to the
                        institution on 23.03.2011. Till date the institution has not submitted DD of
                        Rs.40,000/-.

                       The institution is also running M.Ed and D.Ed courses.

                       Further, composite inspection has been carried out for D.Ed, B.Ed and
                       M.Ed institutions on 29-30 March 2011. The inspection was carried out
                       as per the court directions for B.Ed course on 29th March 2011. The
                       inspection report has been received along with VCD and the same was
                       forwarded to the Advocate for placing before the Hon'ble High Court of
                       Karnataka along with detailed analysis


                       The Committee considered the VT Report, VCD and all the relevant
                       documentary evidences and it was decided to serve Show cause
                       Notice under Section 17 of NCTE Act for the following:

                            Through  amendment dt. 24.08.2007, the name of the
                            Association has been changed from “Dalitha Maha Sabha,
                            Davanagere K.Shivaramu Educational & Cultural Centre, # 1382,
                                               86


(Gangadharaiah)                                                       (Prof. C. Thangamuthu)
Regional Director, SRC, NCTE                                            Chairman, SRC, NCTE
                                                                                      th
                                                                       Minutes of 204 Meeting of SRC
                                                                                      th  th
                                                                                    27 -28 April 2011
                                 2nd cross, Saraswathi Nagar, Davanagere-5” TO “KSS
                                 Foundation, # 1382, 2nd cross, Saraswathi Nagar, Davanagere-
                                 5.” The management has not taken approval for change of
                                 name of the Trust.

                                 As per VCD report, the institution is functioning in a residential,
                                  area, which is not as per NCTE norms.

                                 In the affidavit, the total built up area is not mentioned.

                                  Notarised copy of Land usage certificate issued by competent
                                   authority in English is to be submitted.

                                 Salaries are not paid through Cheque to the staff.

                                 Encumbrance certificate dt. 24.03.2011 for the period 01.04.2007
                                  to 22.03.2011 shows encumbrance in favour of Manager,
                                  Karnataka Bank Ltd., K.B. Layout Branch, which is not
                                  permissible as per NCTE norms.


                             In view of the above, the Committee decided to issue a Show cause
                             Notice to the institution as to why the recognition be not withdrawn
                             and thereby providing an opportunity to the institution to make a
                             written representation within 30 days from the date of issue of the
                             Notice along with necessary certificates/documents in order to take
                             a final decision in the matter; failing which action will be taken
                             including the withdrawal of recognition, based on the records
                             available, with no further notice.

64.          APS08208        Dalitha Mahasabha Davanagere (R), Karnataka Social Educational &
               M.Ed          Cultural Centre, #1949/3, D.M.S. “Sadhana”, Last Bus Stop,
        Dalitha Mahasabha    Vidyanagar, Davangere District-577005, Karnataka
         Davanagere (R),
         Karnataka Social    Dalitha Mahasabha Davanagere (R), Karnataka Social Educational &
          Educational &      Cultural Centre, #1949/3, D.M.S. “Sadhana”, Last Bus Stop, Vidyanagar,
         Cultural Centre,    Davangere District-577005, Karnataka has submitted application to SRC,
             Davangere       NCTE on 05.01.2007. The institution been granted recognition for M.Ed
                KA           course on 08.12.2007.

                             Further, NCTE-Hqrs. vide their letter dated 30th July, 2010 has informed
                             that the enhancement in the intake of one unit of M.Ed course
                             programme from 25 to 35 has been notified vide National Council for
                             Teacher Education Amendment Regulation, 2010 in the Gazette of India
                             on 26th July, 2010. The amendment stipulates that the intake be
                             increased from existing 25 to 35 students from the current session 2010-
                             11, without creation of any additional infrastructure and instructional
                             facilities.

                                                    87


      (Gangadharaiah)                                                    (Prof. C. Thangamuthu)
      Regional Director, SRC, NCTE                                         Chairman, SRC, NCTE
                                                                                 th
                                                                  Minutes of 204 Meeting of SRC
                                                                                 th  th
                                                                               27 -28 April 2011
                       NCTE-Hqrs. has directed to inform all the institutions of each region
                       having approved M.Ed programme of 25 students by issuing a letter that
                       they may enhance it upto 35 students, accordingly.

                       Accordingly, order enhancing the intake from 25 to 35 is being issued to
                       the eligible institutions from the session 2010-11 institutions who have
                       been granted recognition for M.Ed course with an intake of 25 students.
                       Hence, a letter to this effect was issued to the institution on 20.08.2010.

                       As per the decision of 175th meeting held on 13-14 May 2009 the
                       institutions where recognition were granted in temporary premises with a
                       condition to shift to permanent premises within period of three years time
                       limit of grant of recognition as per NCTE regulations 2002 notified in
                       18.11.2002 were considered. It was decided that institutions which have
                       not shifted to the permanent premises even after the expiry of three years
                       time limit be issued notice under section 17 of NCTE Act. Accordingly
                       section 17 notice was issued to the institution on 02.09.2009. The
                       institution has submitted its reply on 26.10.2009.

                       SRC in its 187th meeting held on 28-29 December 2009 considered the
                       written representation and decided to withdraw recognition for B.Ed
                       course with noted reasons.

                       In the meantime, the institution has approached the Hon‟ble High Court
                       of Karnataka in W.P.3176 of 2010 and hence the withdrawal order could
                       not be issued to the institution.

                       A letter has been received from Sri.Ashok Haranahalli, Advocate by
                       enclosing a copy of the order available on the High Court Website for
                       immediate compliance. The order dated 02.02.2011 reads as under:
                       Learned counsel for respondent submits that pursuant to the resolution
                       No.3826 dated 29-30/12/2009 in withdrawing the recognition to the
                       petitioner‟s educational institute, the same has not been communicated
                       to the petitioner and therefore the respondent seeks leave of the court to
                       communicate that order. Permission is granted. Letter to be furnished to
                       the learned counsel for petitioner within 10 days.

                       Accordingly, order withdrawing recognition was issued to the institution
                       on 03.03.2011 for B.Ed course. Order withdrawing recognition was not
                       issued to D.Ed and M.Ed courses.

                       The Hon'ble High Court of Karnataka in W.P.3176 of 2010 dated
                       11.03.2011 has passed the order which reads as under:
                       … the 2nd respondent (NCTE) has to make an inspection of the new
                       premises of the college in question. It should also accept the shifting fee
                       from the petitioner. Therefore, the petitioner is directed to deposit a sum
                       of Rs.40,000/- with the 2nd respondent towards shifting fee within one
                       weeks. The petitioner is further directed to deposit an additional sum of
                       Rs.40,000/- with the 2nd respondent towards inspection fee within one
                       week.
                                              88


(Gangadharaiah)                                                     (Prof. C. Thangamuthu)
Regional Director, SRC, NCTE                                          Chairman, SRC, NCTE
                                                                                     th
                                                                      Minutes of 204 Meeting of SRC
                                                                                     th  th
                                                                                   27 -28 April 2011

                    (4)                 The 2nd respondent is directed to inspect the new premises of
                          the college in question within a period of four weeks from today and
                          submit the report to this Court.
                          Accordingly, as per the directions of the Hon'ble High Court of Karnataka
                          the institution in its letter dated 16.03.2011 has submitted Rs.40,000/-
                          vide DD.No.249036 dated 15.03.2011 towards shifting fee. The
                          institution has also submitted another letter dt.18.03.2011 by submitting
                          another Demand Draft of Rs.40,000/- bearing No.121074 dated
                          18.03.2011 towards inspection fee. In this regard, it has been pointed
                          out that the institution has submitted two Demand Drafts of Rs.40,000/-
                          each. Inspection for shifting is to be conducted for three courses i.e
                          D.Ed, B.Ed and M.Ed and the institution was requested to submit the
                          Demand Draft of Rs.40,000/- more. Accordingly, a letter intimating the
                          date of inspection and seeking for DD of Rs.40,000/- was issued to the
                          institution on 23.03.2011. Till date the institution has not submitted DD of
                          Rs.40,000/-.

                          The institution is also running D.Ed and B.Ed courses.

                          Further, composite inspection has been carried out for D.Ed, B.Ed and
                          M.Ed institutions on 29-30 March 2011. The inspection was carried out
                          as per the court directions for B.Ed course on 29th March 2011. The
                          inspection report has been received along with VCD and the same was
                          forwarded to the Advocate for placing before the Hon'ble High Court of
                          Karnataka along with detailed analysis.


                          The Committee considered the VT Report, VCD and all the relevant
                          documentary evidences and it was decided to serve Show cause
                          Notice under Section 17 of NCTE Act for the following:


                              Through  amendment dt. 24.08.2007, the name of the
                              Association has been changed from “Dalitha Maha Sabha,
                              Davanagere K.Shivaramu Educational & Cultural Centre, # 1382,
                              2nd cross, Saraswathi Nagar, Davanagere-5” TO “KSS
                              Foundation, # 1382, 2nd cross, Saraswathi Nagar, Davanagere-
                              5.” The management has not taken approval for change of
                              name of the Trust.

                              As per VCD report, the institution is functioning in a residential,
                               area, which is not as per NCTE norms.

                              In the affidavit the total built up area is not mentioned.


                               Notarised copy of Land usage certificate issued by competent
                                authority in English is to be submitted.

                                                 89


(Gangadharaiah)                                                         (Prof. C. Thangamuthu)
Regional Director, SRC, NCTE                                              Chairman, SRC, NCTE
                                                                                      th
                                                                       Minutes of 204 Meeting of SRC
                                                                                      th  th
                                                                                    27 -28 April 2011

                                 Salaries are not paid through Cheque to the staff.

                                 Encumbrance certificate dt. 24.03.2011 for the period 01.04.2007
                                  to 22.03.2011 shows encumbrance in favour of Manager,
                                  Karnataka Bank Ltd., K.B. Layout Branch, which is not
                                  permissible as per NCTE norms.


                             In view of the above, the Committee decided to issue a Show cause
                             Notice to the institution as to why the recognition be not withdrawn
                             and thereby providing an opportunity to the institution to make a
                             written representation within 30 days from the date of issue of the
                             Notice along with necessary certificates/documents in order to take
                             a final decision in the matter; failing which action will be taken
                             including the withdrawal of recognition, based on the records
                             available, with no further notice.

65.         APS05474         KSS College of Education, #1949/3, D.M.S. “Sadhana”, Last Bus Stop,
              D.Ed           Vidyanagar, Davangere District-577005, Karnataka.
          KSS College of
            Education,
           Davangere         KSS College of Education, #1949/3, D.M.S. “Sadhana”, Last Bus Stop,
               KA            Vidyanagar, Davangere District-577005, Karnataka has submitted
                             application to SRC, NCTE on 02.01.2006. The institution been granted
                             recognition for D.Ed course on 12.04.2007.

                             As per the decision of 175th meeting held on 13-14 May 2009 the
                             institutions where recognition were granted in temporary premises with a
                             condition to shift to permanent premises within period of three years time
                             limit of grant of recognition as per NCTE regulations 2002 notified in
                             18.11.2002 were considered. It was decided that institutions which have
                             not shifted to the permanent premises even after the expiry of three years
                             time limit be issued notice under section 17 of NCTE Act. Accordingly
                             section 17 notice was issued to the institution on 02.09.2009. The
                             institution has submitted its reply on 26.10.2009.

                             SRC in its 187th meeting held on 28-29 December 2009 considered the
                             written representation and decided to withdraw recognition for B.Ed
                             course with noted reasons.

                             In the meantime, the institution has approached the Hon‟ble High Court
                             of Karnataka in W.P.3176 of 2010 and hence the withdrawal order could
                             not be issued to the institution.

                             A letter has been received from Sri.Ashok Haranahalli, Advocate by
                             enclosing a copy of the order available on the High Court Website for
                             immediate compliance. The order dated 02.02.2011 reads as under:

                                                    90


      (Gangadharaiah)                                                    (Prof. C. Thangamuthu)
      Regional Director, SRC, NCTE                                         Chairman, SRC, NCTE
                                                                                  th
                                                                   Minutes of 204 Meeting of SRC
                                                                                  th  th
                                                                                27 -28 April 2011
                       Learned counsel for respondent submits that pursuant to the resolution
                       No.3826 dated 29-30/12/2009 in withdrawing the recognition to the
                       petitioner‟s educational institute, the same has not been communicated
                       to the petitioner and therefore the respondent seeks leave of the court to
                       communicate that order. Permission is granted. Letter to be furnished to
                       the learned counsel for petitioner within 10 days.

                       Accordingly, order withdrawing recognition was issued to the institution
                       on 03.03.2011 for B.Ed course. Order withdrawing recognition was not
                       issued to D.Ed and M.Ed courses.

                       The Hon'ble High Court of Karnataka in W.P.3176 of 2010 dated
                       11.03.2011 has passed the order which reads as under:

                       … the 2nd respondent (NCTE) has to make an inspection of the new
                       premises of the college in question. It should also accept the shifting fee
                       from the petitioner. Therefore, the petitioner is directed to deposit a sum
                       of Rs.40,000/- with the 2nd respondent towards shifting fee within one
                       weeks. The petitioner is further directed to deposit an additional sum of
                       Rs.40,000/- with the 2nd respondent towards inspection fee within one
                       week.

                       (4).The 2nd respondent is directed to inspect the new premises of the
                       college in question within a period of four weeks from today and submit
                       the report to this Court.

                       Accordingly, as per the directions of the Hon'ble High Court of Karnataka
                       the institution in its letter dated 16.03.2011 has submitted Rs.40,000/-
                       vide DD.No.249036 dated 15.03.2011 towards shifting fee.                The
                       institution has also submitted another letter dt.18.03.2011 by submitting
                       another Demand Draft of Rs.40,000/- bearing No.121074 dated
                       18.03.2011 towards inspection fee. In this regard, it has been pointed
                       out that the institution has submitted two Demand Drafts of Rs.40,000/-
                       each. Inspection for shifting is to be conducted for three courses i.e
                       D.Ed, B.Ed and M.Ed and the institution was requested to submit the
                       Demand Draft of Rs.40,000/- more. Accordingly, a letter intimating the
                       date of inspection and seeking for DD of Rs.40,000/- was issued to the
                       institution on 23.03.2011. Till date the institution has not submitted DD of
                       Rs.40,000/-.

                       The institution is also running M.Ed and B.Ed courses.

                       Further, composite inspection has been carried out for D.Ed, B.Ed and
                       M.Ed institutions on 29-30 March 2011. The inspection was carried out
                       as per the court directions for B.Ed course on 29th March 2011.

                       The Committee considered the VT Report, VCD and all the relevant
                       documentary evidences and it was decided to serve Show cause
                       Notice under Section 17 of NCTE Act for the following:

                                              91


(Gangadharaiah)                                                      (Prof. C. Thangamuthu)
Regional Director, SRC, NCTE                                           Chairman, SRC, NCTE
                                                                                      th
                                                                       Minutes of 204 Meeting of SRC
                                                                                      th  th
                                                                                    27 -28 April 2011

                                 Through  amendment dt. 24.08.2007, the name of the
                                 Association has been changed from “Dalitha Maha Sabha,
                                 Davanagere K.Shivaramu Educational & Cultural Centre, # 1382,
                                 2nd cross, Saraswathi Nagar, Davanagere-5” TO “KSS
                                 Foundation, # 1382, 2nd cross, Saraswathi Nagar, Davanagere-
                                 5.” The management has not taken approval for change of
                                 name of the Trust.

                                 As per VCD report, the institution is functioning in a residential,
                                  area, which is not as per NCTE norms.

                                 In the affidavit, the total built up area is not mentioned.


                                  Notarised copy of Land usage certificate issued by competent
                                   authority in English is to be submitted.


                                 Salaries are not paid through Cheque to the staff.

                                 Encumbrance certificate dt. 24.03.2011 for the period 01.04.2007
                                  to 22.03.2011 shows encumbrance in favour of Manager,
                                  Karnataka Bank Ltd., K.B. Layout Branch, which is not
                                  permissible as per NCTE norms.
                             In view of the above, the Committee decided to issue a Show cause
                             Notice to the institution as to why the recognition be not withdrawn
                             and thereby providing an opportunity to the institution to make a
                             written representation within 30 days from the date of issue of the
                             Notice along with necessary certificates/documents in order to take
                             a final decision in the matter; failing which action will be taken
                             including the withdrawal of recognition, based on the records
                             available, with no further notice.

66.          APS09350        National P.G. Centre for M.Ed Course, Hafth Gumbad, Gulbarga-
               M.Ed          585104, Karnataka
        National PG Centre
         for M.Ed Course,
              Gulbarga       National P.G. Centre for M.Ed Course, Hafth Gumbad, Gulbarga-585104,
                KA           Karnataka has submitted application for M.Ed course on 09.12.2003. The
                             institution has been granted recognition for M.Ed course with an intake of
                             40 students on 22.09.2008.

                             A letter No.ED 122 PTI 2008 (BO dated 18.06.2009 was received from
                             the Principal Secretary, Primary and Higher Education, Education
                             Department, Government of Karnataka and has recommended SRC to
                             withdraw the recognition granted to D.Ed course, as the institution is not
                             mentioned Norms and Standards as prescribed by NCTE.

                             The matter was placed before SRC in its 178th meeting held on 13-14
                                                    92


      (Gangadharaiah)                                                    (Prof. C. Thangamuthu)
      Regional Director, SRC, NCTE                                         Chairman, SRC, NCTE
                                                                               th
                                                                  Minutes of 204 Meeting of SRC
                                                                                 th  th
                                                                               27 -28 April 2011
                       July 2009. The committee decided to issue notice and notice was issued
                       to the institution on 12.08.2009. The institution submitted its written
                       representation on 09.09.2009 & 14.09.2009. The SRC in its 183rd
                       meeting held on 22nd September 2009 considered the written
                       representation and decided to conduct inspection.

                       A notice was issued to the institution on 31.10.2009. The institution hs
                       submitted its written representation on 24.11.2009 & 07.01.2010. The
                       SRC in its 189th meeting held on 25-26 February 2010 considered the
                       written representation and decided to cause inspection. Accordingly,
                       inspection was carried out on 04.06.2010. Then SRC in 193rd meeting
                       held on 21-22 June 2010 considered the VT report and decided to
                       withdraw recognition for D.Ed course. Accordingly, withdrawal order was
                       issued to the institution on 04.08.2010.

                       Further, institution preferred appeal to NCTE, Hqrs and the appellate
                       authority vide order dated 27.09.2010 has reversed the withdrawal order
                       of SRC with direction to SRC to issue showcasuse notice to the
                       institution.

                       The SRC in its 197th meeting held on 13-14 October 2010 considered the
                       Appellate Authority order and decided to issue show cause notice.
                       Accordingly, show cause notice was issued to the institution on
                       07.12.2010.

                       Further, the institution has submitted written representation on
                       04.01.2011. The SRC in its 200th meeting held on 20-21 January 2011
                       considered the written representation of the institution and decided to
                       cause Composite inspection.

                       The institution is running D.Ed and B.Ed courses.

                       The inspection was carried out on 01st April, 2011.

                       The Committee considered the VT Report, VCD and all the relevant
                       documentary evidences and it was decided to serve Show cause
                       Notice under Section 17 of NCTE Act for the following:

                           In the building plan submitted, the Sy.number and total land
                            area and built up area not mentioned.
                           Original Building plan from Govt authority is to be submitted.

                           Building completion certificate from competent Govt. Engineer
                            is to be submitted.

                           The land documents dt. 11.08.1955 states that the land is in the
                            name of National School. But it should be in the name of
                            Teacher Training Institute or the Society running the college as
                            per NCTE norms, as the LUC and Encumbrance certificate
                                              93


(Gangadharaiah)                                                     (Prof. C. Thangamuthu)
Regional Director, SRC, NCTE                                          Chairman, SRC, NCTE
                                                                                        th
                                                                         Minutes of 204 Meeting of SRC
                                                                                        th  th
                                                                                      27 -28 April 2011
                                   indicates the name as National Education Society. This
                                   discrepancy may be explained with documentary proof.

                                   The Library and Science lab of this institute is being shared by
                                    a Primary school, a High School and a degree college in the
                                    adjacent building run by the management.            This is not
                                    permissible as per NCTE norms.

                                   The details of the earmarked land area, built up area for Primary
                                    School, High School, Degree College and for each Teacher
                                    Education Programme is to be given; as the management is
                                    running all the courses in the same campus.

                               In view of the above, the Committee decided to issue a Show cause
                               Notice to the institution as to why the recognition be not withdrawn
                               and thereby providing an opportunity to the institution to make a
                               written representation within 30 days from the date of issue of the
                               Notice along with necessary certificates/documents in order to take
                               a final decision in the matter; failing which action will be taken
                               including the withdrawal of recognition, based on the records
                               available, with no further notice.

67.          APS01830
               B.Ed            National College of Education, Hafth Gumbad, Darga Road,
         National College of   Gulbarga-585104, Karnataka
        Education, Gulbarga
                KA             National College of Education, Hafth Gumbad, Gulbarga-585104,
                               Karnataka has submitted application for B.Ed course on 30.12.2003. The
                               institution has been granted recognition for B.Ed course with an intake of
                               100 students on 29.11.2004.

                               A letter No.ED 122 PTI 2008 (BO dated 18.06.2009 was received from
                               the Principal Secretary, Primary and Higher Education, Education
                               Department, Government of Karnataka and has recommended SRC to
                               withdraw the recognition granted to D.Ed course, as the institution is not
                               mentioned Norms and Standards as prescribed by NCTE.

                               The matter was placed before SRC in its 178th meeting held on 13-14
                               July 2009. The committee decided to issue notice and notice was issued
                               to the institution on 12.08.2009. The institution submitted its written
                               representation on 09.09.2009 & 14.09.2009. The SRC in its 183rd
                               meeting held on 22nd September 2009 considered the written
                               representation and decided to conduct inspection.

                               A notice was issued to the institution on 31.10.2009. The institution hs
                               submitted its written representation on 24.11.2009 & 07.01.2010. The
                               SRC in its 189th meeting held on 25-26 February 2010 considered the
                               written representation and decided to cause inspection. Accordingly,
                               inspection was carried out on 04.06.2010. Then SRC in 193rd meeting
                                                      94


      (Gangadharaiah)                                                      (Prof. C. Thangamuthu)
      Regional Director, SRC, NCTE                                           Chairman, SRC, NCTE
                                                                                 th
                                                                 Minutes of 204 Meeting of SRC
                                                                                th  th
                                                                              27 -28 April 2011
                       held on 21-22 June 2010 considered the VT report and decided to
                       withdraw recognition for D.Ed course. Accordingly, withdrawal order was
                       issued to the institution on 02.08.2010.

                       Further, institution preferred appeal to NCTE, Hqrs and the appellate
                       authority vide order dated 27.09.2010 has reversed the withdrawal order
                       of SRC with direction to SRC to issue showcasuse notice to the
                       institution.

                       The SRC in its 197th meeting held on 13-14 October 2010 considered the
                       Appellate Authority order and decided to issue show cause notice.
                       Accordingly, show cause notice was issued to the institution on
                       06.12.2010.

                       Further, the institution has submitted written representation on
                       04.01.2011. The SRC in its 200th meeting held on 20-21 January 2011
                       considered the written representation of the institution and decided to
                       cause Composite inspection.

                       The institution is running D.Ed and M.Ed courses.
                       The inspection is carried out on 01.04.2011.

                       The Committee considered the VT Report, VCD and all the relevant
                       documentary evidences and it was decided to serve Show cause
                       Notice under Section 17 of NCTE Act for the following:

                           In the building plan submitted, the Sy.number and total area
                            and built up area not mentioned.
                           Original Building plan from Govt authority is to be submitted.

                           Building completion certificate from competent Govt. Engineer
                            is to be submitted.

                           The land documents dt. 11.08.1955 states that the land is in the
                            name of National School. But it should be in the name of
                            Teacher Training Institute or the Society running the college as
                            per NCTE norms, as the LUC and Encumbrance certificate
                            indicates the name as National Education Society. This
                            discrepancy may be explained with documentary proof.

                           The Library and Science lab of this institute is being shared by
                            one Primary school, a High School and a degree college in the
                            adjacent building run by the management. This is not
                            permissible as per NCTE norms.

                           The details of the earmarked land area, built up area for Primary
                            School, High School, Degree College and for each Teacher
                            Education Programme is to be given; as the management is
                                              95


(Gangadharaiah)                                                       (Prof. C. Thangamuthu)
Regional Director, SRC, NCTE                                            Chairman, SRC, NCTE
                                                                                        th
                                                                         Minutes of 204 Meeting of SRC
                                                                                        th  th
                                                                                      27 -28 April 2011
                                   running all the e courses in the same campus.

                               In view of the above, the Committee decided to issue a Show cause
                               Notice to the institution as to why the recognition be not withdrawn
                               and thereby providing an opportunity to the institution to make a
                               written representation within 30 days from the date of issue of the
                               Notice along with necessary certificates/documents in order to take
                               a final decision in the matter; failing which action will be taken
                               including the withdrawal of recognition, based on the records
                               available, with no further notice.

68.          APS01490          National D.Ed      Institute,   Hafth    Gumbad,     Gulbarga-585104,
                 D.Ed          Karnataka
           National D.Ed
         Institute, Gulbarga
                  KA           National D.Ed Institute, Hafth Gumbad, Gulbarga-585104, Karnataka has
                               submitted application for D.Ed course on 09.12.2003. The institution has
                               been granted recognition for D.Ed course with an intake of 50 students
                               on 17.06.2005.

                               A letter No.ED 122 PTI 2008 (BO dated 18.06.2009 was received from
                               the Principal Secretary, Primary and Higher Education, Education
                               Department, Government of Karnataka and has recommended SRC to
                               withdraw the recognition granted to D.Ed course, as the institution is not
                               mentioned Norms and Standards as prescribed by NCTE.

                               The matter was placed before SRC in its 178th meeting held on 13-14
                               July 2009. The committee decided to issue notice and notice was issued
                               to the institution on 12.08.2009. The institution submitted its written
                               representation on 09.09.2009 & 14.09.2009. The SRC in its 183rd
                               meeting held on 22nd September 2009 considered the written
                               representation and decided to conduct inspection.

                               A notice was issued to the institution on 31.10.2009. The institution has
                               submitted its written representation on 24.11.2009 & 07.01.2010. The
                               SRC in its 189th meeting held on 25-26 February 2010 considered the
                               written representation and decided to cause inspection. Accordingly,
                               inspection was carried out on 04.06.2010. Then SRC in 193rd meeting
                               held on 21-22 June 2010 considered the VT report and decided to
                               withdraw recognition for D.Ed course. Accordingly, withdrawal order was
                               issued to the institution on 02.08.2010.

                               Further, institution preferred appeal to NCTE, Hqrs and the appellate
                               authority vide order dated 27.09.2010 has reversed the withdrawal order
                               of SRC with direction to SRC to issue showcasuse notice to the
                               institution.

                               The SRC in its 197th meeting held on 13-14 October 2010 considered the
                               Appellate Authority order and decided to issue show cause notice.
                               Accordingly, show cause notice was issued to the institution on
                                                      96


      (Gangadharaiah)                                                      (Prof. C. Thangamuthu)
      Regional Director, SRC, NCTE                                           Chairman, SRC, NCTE
                                                                                   th
                                                                     Minutes of 204 Meeting of SRC
                                                                                    th  th
                                                                                  27 -28 April 2011
                       07.12.2010.

                       Further, the institution has submitted written representation on
                       04.01.2011. The SRC in its 200th meeting held on 20-21 January 2011
                       considered the written representation of the institution and decided to
                       cause Composite inspection.

                       The institution is also running B.Ed and M.Ed courses.

                       The inspection was carried out on 02nd April, 2011.

                       The Committee considered the VT Report, VCD and all the relevant
                       documentary evidences and it was decided to serve Show cause
                       Notice under Section 17 of NCTE Act for the following:

                           In the building plan submitted the Sy.number and total area and
                            built up area not mentioned.
                           Original Building plan from Govt authority is to be submitted.

                           Building completion certificate from competent Govt. Engineer
                            is to be submitted.

                           The land documents dt. 11.08.1955 states that the land is in the
                            name of National School. But it should be in the name of
                            Teacher Training Institute or the Society running the college as
                            per NCTE norms, as the LUC and Encumbrance certificate
                            indicates the name as National Education Society.           This
                            discrepancy may be explained with documentary proof.

                           The Library and Science lab of this institute is being shared by
                            one Primary school, a High School and a degree college in the
                            adjacent building run by the management. This is not
                            permissible as per NCTE norms.

                           The details of the earmarked land area, built up area for Primary
                            School, High School, Degree College and for each Teacher
                            Education Programme is to be given; as the management is
                            running all the courses in the same campus.

                       In view of the above, the Committee decided to issue a Show cause
                       Notice to the institution as to why the recognition be not withdrawn
                       and thereby providing an opportunity to the institution to make a
                       written representation within 30 days from the date of issue of the
                       Notice along with necessary certificates/documents in order to take
                       a final decision in the matter; failing which action will be taken
                       including the withdrawal of recognition, based on the records
                       available, with no further notice.


                                                97


(Gangadharaiah)                                                         (Prof. C. Thangamuthu)
Regional Director, SRC, NCTE                                              Chairman, SRC, NCTE
                                                                                     th
                                                                        Minutes of 204 Meeting of SRC
                                                                                       th  th
                                                                                     27 -28 April 2011
69.         AOS00027         Annai Fathima Teacher Training Institute, Hirebidanur,
            APS03115
                             Gauribidanur Taluk, Kolar District-561208, Karrnataka
                D.Ed
             D.Ed-AI
                             Annai Fathima Teacher Training Institute, Hirebidanur, Gauribidanur
          Annai Fathima
                             Taluk, Kolar District-561208, Karnataka has submitted application for
         Teacher Training
                             D.Ed course on 27.01.2004. The institution has been granted recognition
          Institute, Kolar
                             for D.Ed-AI on 13.12.2004. with an intake of 50 students which includes
                 KA
                             existing intake of 30 students and additional intake of 20 students.

                             NCTE, Hqrs vide its letter dated 10.08.2010 has forwarded a copy of
                             the inspection report dated 16.06.2010 conducted under section 13
                             of NCTE Act. As there are deficiencies pointed out in the inspection
                             report, NCTE, Hqrs has requested SRC to initiate action against the
                             institution under section 17 of the NCTE Act immediately.

                             The SRC in its 195th meeting held on 17-18 August 2010, considered the
                             report of the institution and decided to issue Show cause Notice.
                             Accordingly, show cause notice was issued to the institution on
                             27.09.2010. The institution submitted its written representation on
                             25.10.2010. The SRC in its 198th meeting held on 24-26 November 2010
                             considered the written representation of the institution and decided to
                             cause inspection under section 17 of NCTE Act.

                             The inspection was carried out on 06th April, 2011


                             The Committee considered the VT Report, VCD and all the relevant
                             documentary evidences and it was decided to serve Show cause
                             Notice Under Section 17 of NCTE Act for the following :

                              The total Built up area earmarked for the D.Ed (APS00027) & D.Ed
                               –Al (APS03115) is only 4512.6 Sq.ft. which is grossly inadequate
                               for the Teacher Education Programme being run as per NCTE
                               norms. The same is also corroborated by the management by
                               affixing signature of the management representative in the
                               essential data.

                              The instructional facilities provided are grossly inadequate & not
                               sufficient to run D.Ed programme.

                              In the Building plan the built up area and Sy,nos are not
                               mentioned.

                              Notarised copy of Land usage certificate issued by competent
                               authority is to be submitted.

                              Non- Encumbrance Certificate from the competent Government
                               Authorised person / Authorities to be submitted.

                                                    98


      (Gangadharaiah)                                                     (Prof. C. Thangamuthu)
      Regional Director, SRC, NCTE                                          Chairman, SRC, NCTE
                                                                                            th
                                                                            Minutes of 204 Meeting of SRC
                                                                                           th  th
                                                                                         27 -28 April 2011
                                Science lab, Psychology lab & Educational Technology lab needs
                                 to be strengthened.

                                Physical Education lab & Language learning lab not available.

                               In view of the above, the Committee decided to issue a Show cause
                               Notice to the institution as to why the recognition be not withdrawn
                               and thereby providing an opportunity to the institution to make a
                               written representation within 30 days from the date of issue of the
                               Notice along with necessary certificates/documents in order to take
                               a final decision in the matter; failing which action will be taken
                               including the withdrawal of recognition, based on the records
                               available, with no further notice.


      Court Cases/Appeal/Notice/Complaint/Shifting/Miscellaneous Cases:

70.          APS06003          Sri Vidya College of Education, Bowrampet, Ranga Reddy district,
                B.Ed           AndhraPradesh
        Sri Vidya College of
         Education, Ranga      A Court order has been received in the office of SRC on 25.04.2011 in
               Reddy           writ petition no. 10438/2011 in the matter of Sri Saraswathi Vidya
                 AP            Nilayama Educational Society Vs National Council for Teacher Education
                               through Regional Director. The Hon‟ble High Court has passed an order
                               dt. 18.04.2011 as under::
                               The petitioner has prayed that a direction be issued to the first
                               respondent to permit the petitioner Educational Society to set up a B.Ed
                               Colege. It is the grievance of the petitioner that though it has made an
                               application on 02.01.2006 to conduct inspection of the petitioner‟s
                               proposed B.Ed college, but no orders have been passed till date.

                               It is settled principle of law that when ever an application is made, it must
                               be considered and processed in accordance with the provisions of law or
                               the policy that existed as on the date of presentation. Subseqent
                               changes may apply to the applications that are made thereafter.

                               A perusal of the case file discloses that more than six years have elapsed
                               since the date of filing of the application by the petitioner to set up B.Ed
                               college. It seems that the petitioner has not pursued the said application
                               in the proper manner.

                               The learnt Council for the petitioner submits that the petitioner may be
                               permitted to withdraw the wirt petition giving liberaty to file fresh
                               application and on such filing of the fresh application, the first respondent
                               may be directed to consider the same in accordance with law
                               expeditiously.

                               After hearing the learnt Council for the partys, the writ petition is disposed
                               off as withdrawn with liberty to the petitioner to file fresh application to

                                                       99


      (Gangadharaiah)                                                         (Prof. C. Thangamuthu)
      Regional Director, SRC, NCTE                                              Chairman, SRC, NCTE
                                                                                         th
                                                                          Minutes of 204 Meeting of SRC
                                                                                         th  th
                                                                                       27 -28 April 2011
                             start B.Ed college. In case any such application is filed the first
                             respondent shall consider and disposed of the same and to conduct
                             inspection of the petitioner‟s proposed B.Ed college, in accordance with
                             law within a period of 6 weeks from the date of the receipt of the
                             representation.

                             There shall be no order as to costs.

                             The committee has noted the Court directions in this matter.

71.         APS07890         Pragathi Convent Society, Ananthapur District, Andhra Pradesh has
               D.Ed          made application in the name and style of Sri Sreenivasa Teacher
          Sri Sreenivasa     Training College, GIC Colony, Penukonda Mandal, Divisional Head
         Teacher Training    Quarters, Ananthpur District-515110, Andhra Pradesh to SRC NCTE for
        College, Anathapur   establishment of B.Ed course on 26.12.2006.
                AP
                             The application was processed and the deficiency letter was issued and
                             on fulfillment of all required documents the inspection of the institution
                             was conducted on 31.08.2007.

                             The SRC in its 145th meeting held on 16-18 October 2007 the Southern
                             Regional Committee after considering the report of the visiting team as
                             well as other relevant materials furnished by applicant institution, is
                             satisfied that the applicant institution does not fulfill the requirements and
                             issued a notice on 31.10.2007 under provision to section 14(3)(b) of the
                             NCTE Act, 1993, thereby giving an opportunity to the said applicant
                             institution to make a written for the following:

                                    The details of built-up space be submitted
                                    The room wise space available for D.T.Ed course apart from
                                     existing course be furnished

                             The institution submitted its representation for notice on 06.11.2007. The
                             same was placed before SRC in its 149th meeting of SRC held on 13-14
                             December 2007 which came to conclusion that recognition/permission to
                             the said institution be refused for the following reasons:

                                    The built-up space is not adequate.
                                    The room wise space available for D.Ed course is not adequate to
                                     run D.Ed course.

                             Accordingly a refusal order was issued to the institution on 04.01.2008

                             Aggrieved by the refusal order of SRC, the institution preferred an appeal
                             to NCTE–Hqrs. The appellate authority in its order dated 10.07.2008
                             confirms the order of SRC appealed against.

                             Further the institution filed a W.P.No.20129 of 2008 in the Hon‟ble High
                             Court of Judicature, Andhra Pradesh. A judgment copy was received

                                                     100


      (Gangadharaiah)                                                       (Prof. C. Thangamuthu)
      Regional Director, SRC, NCTE                                            Chairman, SRC, NCTE
                                                                                        th
                                                                         Minutes of 204 Meeting of SRC
                                                                                        th  th
                                                                                      27 -28 April 2011
                              from the Hon,ble High Court of Judicature, Andhra Pradesh on
                              25.06.2009. The same was forwarded on 30.06.2009 to the Member
                              Secretary seeking necessary advice in the matter. It appeases that a
                              appellate authority has passed order dt. 07.8.2009 rejection the appeal.

                              Now, the Hon‟ble High Court has passed an order on 23.03.2011 vide
                              W.P.No. 24870 of 2010 reads as hereunder:

                              “Pending further orders, respondents are directed to conduct fresh
                              inspection of the second petitioner college and consider for grant of
                              recognition to the college to impart the education in D.Ed programme”.

                              Note:- However, this office has not received either w.p.24870/10 or the
                              WP MP filed therein. Therefore counsel at Hyderabad has been
                              addressed in order to obtain copies of the same and has also been
                              requested to examine whether the interim order can be challenged using
                              judgment by Hon‟ble high court at Delhi in W.P.(c) No.
                              128/11dt.11.1.2011 in Shree Sitheshwar Education Trust Vs. NCTE
                              (copy is attached for perusal).


                              The committee considered the Hon‟ble High Court order dated
                              23.03.2011 for considering the recognition of the institution after re-
                              inspecting the institution on payment of Rs. 40000/- towards
                              Reinspection fee.
72.             ---           Praveen Educational Society (Code: APS07307) B.Ed, Gandhi Street,
                ---           Bestavarapeta, prakasam District, Andhra Pradesh & Venna Chinna,
        Praveen Educational   Venkata Reddy Education society, Jawahar Nagar Coloney, Markapur
           Society & V.C      Prakashan District AP.
          Venkata Reddy
        Educational Society   Complaint about the forged FDR‟s in respect of Praveen Educational
                AP            Society, Guntur District, Andhra Pradesh & V.C.Venkata Reddy
                              Educational Society, Andhra Pradesh has been received in this office.

                              The office of SRC has received a complaint on 10.7.2009 in Telugu
                              wherein it was stated that the following institutions have submitted forged
                              fixed deposits of Rs. 5 lakhs and Rs. 3 lakhs and other documents along
                              with the proforma:
                              1. Coramandal B.Ed. College, Guntur District
                              2. Praveen B.Ed College, Prakasam District
                              3. Praveen HPT College, Prakasam District
                              4. Ravi Teja college of Education, Prakasam District

                              The complaint was placed before SRC in its 178th meeting held on 13th
                              and 14th July, 2009. Wherein Committee decided to call for remarks from
                              the concerned Bank for genuineness of Rs. 5 lakhs and Rs. 3 lakhs
                              FDRs issued by the Bank. Further, the Committee decided to call all
                              original essential documents from the institutions under section 17 of
                              NCTE Act for verification of genuineness and further action.

                                                     101


      (Gangadharaiah)                                                      (Prof. C. Thangamuthu)
      Regional Director, SRC, NCTE                                           Chairman, SRC, NCTE
                                                                                    th
                                                                    Minutes of 204 Meeting of SRC
                                                                                   th  th
                                                                                 27 -28 April 2011

                       As per the decision of SRC a letter was issued to the Bank on 31.7.2009
                       for authencity and veracity of the complaint and also show cause notice
                       was issued to the institution on 31.7.2009 for the following documents for
                       verification.
                        Original FDR for Rs. 5 lakhs
                        Original FDR for Rs. 3 lakhs
                        Copy of land documents (attested by Notary)
                        Approved building Plan
                        Building Completion Certificate
                        Land Usage Certificate
                        Encumbrance Certificate
                        Affidavit in the prescribed format
                        Staff details in prescribed format.

                       The institution did not submit the reply after the expiry of stipulated time.

                       A reply regarding authenticity of FDRs was received from Senior
                       Manager, IOB vide their letter dated 04.08.2009. As the information
                       provided by bank was vague and incomplete, another letter has been
                       issued to the Bank Manager on 25.8.2009. In response, a reply
                       dt.28.08.2009 has been received from the Senior Manager, Indian
                       Overseas Bank, Guntur District, A.P. on 4.9.2009 stating that the said
                       FDR‟s were not issued by their branch and those FDRs appear to be
                       fabricated.

                       The matter was placed before SRC in its 183rd meeting held on 22nd
                       September 2009, wherein Regional Committee has considered the letter
                       from the Senior Manager, I.O.B., Brodiepet Branch, Guntur and decided
                       to ask the institution to explain as to why action including withdrawal of
                       recognition shall not be taken since the FDRs submitted by the
                       institutions are fabricated, according to the bank.

                       Accordingly, a letter was issued to the institution on 03.11.2009. In reply
                       institution has submitted its written representation on 10.12.2009.
                       Wherein the institution has submitted and stated as under:-

                       “We have engaged J.Wesley from Kerala and appointed him as
                       administrative officer to look after the entire administration of the
                       institution, including financial affairs of the institution. In the process of
                       administration we have handed over cash of Rupees eight lakhs
                       instructing him to deposit said amount in fixed deposit towards
                       endowment fund Rs.500000/- and reserve fund Rs.300000/- separately
                       and bring the original FDR receipts. Later he handed over the FDR
                       receipts, which were found to be fabricated. Later on we are made to
                       believe that the said receipts are original. He assured that they are the
                       original FDRs. Therefore we have sent them to your office. The said
                       employee stopped coming to our institution. Our enquiries revealed that
                       the address particulars given to us are false. As such we could not trace
                       him so far. Some time thereafter we received show cause notice and
                                               102


(Gangadharaiah)                                                       (Prof. C. Thangamuthu)
Regional Director, SRC, NCTE                                            Chairman, SRC, NCTE
                                                                                   th
                                                                    Minutes of 204 Meeting of SRC
                                                                                   th  th
                                                                                 27 -28 April 2011
                       other notices. Alleging that the said FDR‟s are forged receipt.
                       Immediately thereafter we have taken separate FDR‟s from Union Bank
                       of India, Guntur District and submitted original FDRs to your office on
                       21.08.2009.

                       Meanwhile a letter has been recived from Mr.B.Srinivasa Reddy,
                       Koritepadu Main Road, Guntur, Andhra Pradesh on 10.12.2009 which
                       was forwarded by NCTE Hqs vide dairy No.81297 dated 27.11.2009. In
                       this letter the complainant has stated that “the correspondent, Ravi Teja
                       College of Education, Prakasam District, Andhra Pradesh and three other
                       colleges have submitted forged FDR‟s worth of Rs.32 lakhs to the SRC
                       NCTE stating that they were drawn from the Indian Overseas Bank,
                       Brodipet Branch, Guntur. The NCTE by a complaint caught hold of the
                       fact that those FDRs were forged and it asked the Branch Manager of the
                       IOB, Brodipet Branch, Guntur for clarification and the Branch Manager
                       informed the NCTE that the FDRs were not issued by the branch and
                       those FDRs appear to be fabricated. But the NCTE, Bangalore did not file
                       a criminal case against him and also did not lodge a complaint against
                       him in the police station for such a fraud”.

                       The matter was placed in 188th meeting of SRC held on 28-29 January
                       2010 committee considered the matter and decided to Withdrawal of
                       recognition of all the four institutions as the case involves a criminal
                       misconduct and forgery/cheating by the Management. To lodge the
                       complaint with the Police instantly.

                       As per direction of Regional Committee withdrawal orders were issued on
                       04.03.2010 to the institutions concerned.

                               Apart from this the competent authority decided to seek legal
                       opinion and in this regard the facts alongwith brief history of case
                       forwarded to Shri K. Ramakrishana Reddy, Advocate, Legal counsel,
                       “Srinivas” U-89/A, (New No. 7) 3rd Main Road, Anna Nagar, Chennai-
                       600040,Tamilnadu for legal opinion 0n 17.02.2010 with request to
                       provide legal opinion and implications of filing FIR.

                       Shri K. Ramakrishana Reddy, Advocate, Legal counsel has given legal
                       opinion that NCTE can initiate criminal proceeding by lodging a
                       complaint against the erring institutions in the Jurisdictional Police Station
                       of Bangalore City if the NCTE feels that the little –bit inconvenience that
                       may be caused because of the investigation may not interfere in the day-
                       to –day work of the NCTE. (copy enclosed).

                       The committee decided to arrange to file an Appeal immediately and
                       also to arrange for getting the judgement stayed with immediate
                       effect and /or for issueing fresh orders of withdrawal. As the case
                       involves a very serious grounds of criminal misconduct of forgery
                       and cheating. Immediate action be taken on the above decision,
                       without waiting for confirmation of minutes.

                                               103


(Gangadharaiah)                                                       (Prof. C. Thangamuthu)
Regional Director, SRC, NCTE                                            Chairman, SRC, NCTE
                                                                                           th
                                                                           Minutes of 204 Meeting of SRC
                                                                                          th  th
                                                                                        27 -28 April 2011
73.        APS09050            Rosammal Memorial Minority College of Education for
               B.Ed            Women, Tuticorin, Tamilnadu
       Rosammal Memorial
        Minority College of    The committee in its 200th meeting held on 20th-21st January 2011 after
       Education for Women     going through the written reply of the institution vide letter dt. 10.01.2011
                TN             for the show cause notice issued dt. 06.01.2011, refused to grant
                               recognition of the institution for the B.Ed course for the following
                               deficiencies still persisting:

                               As per the affidavit submitted the land area is only 13680.774 sq.ft, which
                                is inadequate for the B.Ed course as per the NCTE norms. The minimum
                                required land is 2500 sq.meters.
                               The institution has submitted two private lease deeds, which is not in
                                accordance with the NCTE regulations. As per the regulations, the land
                                must be on ownership basis or leased govt. land; no private lease is
                                permissible.

                               As per the decision of SRC in its 200th meeting held on 20th and 21st
                               January, 2011 a refusal order was issued to the Rosammal Memorial
                               Minority College of Education, Tuticorin, Tamilnadu on 3.3.2011 for B.Ed
                               course.

                               Meantime, the institution in its letter 15.4.2011 submitted an application
                               for B.Ed course with processing of Rs. 41,000/-, original FDR‟s of Rs. 5
                               lakhs and Rs. 3 lakhs along with original court order in W.P. No. 6188 of
                               2011. The institution filed court case for quashing the refusal order of
                               SRC F.SRO/NCTE/B.Ed/2010-2011/27349 dated 3.3.2011 and to direct
                               the second respondent (SRC-NCTE) to conduct necessary inspection on
                               the petitioner institution and pass orders for grant of recognition to the
                               petitioner institution to start a one year B.Ed course from the academic
                               year 2011-2012.

                               The court has ordered as follows “the learned counsel for the petitioner
                               would submit that since the correspondent as well as the institution are
                               one and the same, necessary steps will be taken for the purpose of
                               transferring the property in the name of the institution so as to enable the
                               institution to file a fresh application for recognition.

                                       The petitioner/institution being a recognized minority institution as
                               held by the Appellate Authority, there is no bar for the filing of such
                               application at any point of time on complying with the various other
                               statutory requirements.

                                        In such view of the matter, I do not see any reason to interfere
                               with the impugned order passed by the second respondent. Hence, this
                               writ petition stands dismissed, however liberty is granted to the petitioner
                               to take appropriate steps for transferring the lands in the name of the
                               institution and thereafter make necessary application to the authorities
                               concerned under the Act by complying with the various requirements and
                                                      104


      (Gangadharaiah)                                                        (Prof. C. Thangamuthu)
      Regional Director, SRC, NCTE                                             Chairman, SRC, NCTE
                                                                                               th
                                                                               Minutes of 204 Meeting of SRC
                                                                                              th  th
                                                                                            27 -28 April 2011
                                    if such application is made, it is for the second respondent to pass orders
                                    on merits and in accordance with law. At this stage, the learned counsel
                                    for the petitioners would submit that after taking necessary steps,
                                    application will be made within four weeks. It is made clear that on such
                                    application being made, the second respondent shall take decision
                                    expeditiously, in the manner known to law. No costs. Consequently M.P.
                                    No. 1 of 2011 is closed”.

                                    Note: However the application is eligible for summarily rejection for the
                                    following points:

                                    The application is not submitted online as per Regulations 2009.
                               1.       There is a ban for B.Ed course in Tamilnadu (minority certificate not
                                    submitted).
                                    Individual minority cerftificate is not treated as minority institution.

                                    The Committee considered the matter and decided to process the
                                    application    on submission of original application and related
                                    supporting documents as per the regulations within Four weeks
                                    from the date of confirmation of the Minutes.
74.          APS02570               Sri   Balaji   Teachers    Training     Institute  Myelepalli,
                D.Ed                Kothacheruvu(M.Ed), Anantapur-515133, Andhra Pradesh
         Sri Balaji Teacher
         Training Institute,        An application was submitted by Sri Balaji Teachers Training Institute
             Anantapur              Myelepalli, Kothacheruvu(M.Ed), Anantapur-515133, Andhra
                 AP                 Pradesh, for grant of recognition to D.Ed course in the office of SRC-
                                    NCTE, Banglore vide dated 03.2.2004 under NCTE notification dated
                                    05.1.2004 dispensed with the requirement of NOC of the State
                                    Government from the institutions running B.Ed college and invited
                                    applications for D.Ed course from different institutions for grant of
                                    recognition to Elementary Teacher Education courses under Sarva
                                    Shikshana Ahiyan (SSA).
                                            The application was under process and in the meanwhile, the
                                    Government of Andhra Pradesh of Hyderabad filed a Writ Petition no.
                                    22866 of 2005 in Hon’ble High court of Andhra Pradesh of Hyderabad
                                    challenging the Notification of NCTE with regard to the dispensing with
                                    the requirement of NOC from the State Government. The writ petition
                                    was allowed by the dispensing with the requirement of NOC from the
                                    State Government. The writ petition was allowed by the learned single
                                    judge with the directions that the rule excluding the State Government is
                                    bad. Against said judgement a Writ Appeal no. 692 of 2006 was filed in
                                    the Division Bench of Hon’ble High court of Hyderabad. Many
                                    discussions took place between the state Government of Andhra Pradesh
                                    and SRC-NCTE. However, neither state Government withdraw the case
                                    filed by them nor the stay has been vacated.
                                           Some institutions went to the court and filed writ petitions
                                                           105


      (Gangadharaiah)                                                            (Prof. C. Thangamuthu)
      Regional Director, SRC, NCTE                                                 Chairman, SRC, NCTE
                                                                                  th
                                                                   Minutes of 204 Meeting of SRC
                                                                                  th  th
                                                                                27 -28 April 2011
                       individually seeking directions for processing of their applications, in one
                       of such Writ Petition no. 8278 of 2008. The Hon’ble High court decided
                       that the applications of the institutions shall be processed as per the NCTE
                       rules and regulations norms and standards existing as on date.
                               As per the direction of Hon’ble High court and decision of SRC
                       for processing of pending D.Ed application as per new regulation of
                       NCTE in its 164th Meeting held on 20th September, 2008 meeting held
                       on 20th September 2008, the SRC started to process the applications.
                                As per above decision, a deficiency letter was issued to the
                       institution vide dated 01.10.2008 directing to submit following documents
                       within a period of 90 days as per Section 7(1) of the NCTE Regulations
                       2007:
                       1.      Land document on Ownership basis having minimum 2500
                               sq.Mts. area with its English Translation attested to be true copy.
                       2.      Building plan in original duly approved by the competent
                               authority mentioning sy.No./Plot no. on the land mentioned in
                               point No. 1 above.
                       3.      Building Completion Certificate approved by competent authority
                               stating the location of building, Sy. No. total built-up area.
                       4.      Land Use Certificate from the Government Authority along with
                               encumbrance certificate.
                       5.      Original Affidavit relating to details of land possessed on Rs. 100
                               stamp paper attested by Notary public in the enclosed format.
                       6.      Fixed deposit receipt (FDR) for Five Lakhs from Nationalized
                               Bank submitted should be for current year.
                               As per para 9 (1) of Regulations “there shall be a Endowment fund
                               of Rs. 5.00 Lakhs per course per unit in the form of fixed Deposit
                               of a duration of and above 5 years of a nationalized bank.
                       7.      Fixed deposit receipt (FDR) for Three lakhs from Nationalized
                               Bank submitted should be for current year.
                               As per para 9(1) of Regulations “there shall be a Endowment fund
                               of Rs. 3.00 lakhs per course per unit in the form of a Fixed Deposit
                               of a duration of and above 5 years of a nationalized bank.
                               SRC in its 135th meeting held on 7th –8th June 2007 decided to
                       treat the applications which have not submitted compliance as closed after
                       the expiry of 90 days of time as per the regulations of NCTE, 2005. A
                       letter dated 31.10.2008 has been received from NCTE Hqrs clarifying that
                       all such cases where letter of deficiency has been issued but no. reply has
                       been received form the concerned institution within 90 days may also be
                       closed, in terms of Section 7(1) of the NCTE Regulations.
                               The institution has failed to submit the reply within 90 days. After
                       consideration of facts and also non-submission of reply to the deficiency
                       letter within the stipulated time, it as decided to close the application.
                                              106


(Gangadharaiah)                                                      (Prof. C. Thangamuthu)
Regional Director, SRC, NCTE                                           Chairman, SRC, NCTE
                                                                                           th
                                                                           Minutes of 204 Meeting of SRC
                                                                                          th  th
                                                                                        27 -28 April 2011
                               The institution has approached to Hon’ble High court in W.P. No.
                               3846/11 in the matter of Sri Balaji Educational Society Vs NCTE without
                               approaching the appellate Authority, NCTE, New Delhi U/S 18 of NCTE
                               Act.
                               The Hon‟ble High court has passed on order dated 28.2.2011 as
                               under:

                                       Learned counsel for the petitioner relied on a judgment of this
                               Court in the case of A.P. GIRIJANA SEVAKA SANGH vs. NATIONAL
                               COUNCIL FOR TEACHER EDUCATION & OTHER, rendered in W.P.
                               No. 6712 of 2009, wherein a learned single judge of this Court has held
                               that once an application is filed, it has to be considered with reference to
                               the policy which was in force at the time when the application was made.
                               He further contended that the respondents are not acceding to the
                               request of the petitioner mainly on the ground of change in the policy,
                               which is contrary to the aforesaid judgement of this court.

                                       As it is stated that the petitioner is yet to comply with the
                               deficiencies pointed out in the letter dated 01.10.2008 issued vide
                               proceedings bearing No. F.SRO/NCTE/2008/DL, I deem it appropriate to
                               dispose of the writ petition with a direction to the respondents to consider
                               the request of the petitioner to start D.Ed course, as per the policy, which
                               was in force at the time when the petitioner has applied for grant of
                               permission to run the said course, subject to the petitioner complying with
                               the objections/deficiencies pointed out by the respondents in the letter
                               dated 01.10.2008.
                               Subject to the above directions, the writ petition is disposed of. No. costs.


                               The Committee considered the matter and decided to process the
                               application on submission of original application along with the
                               related supporting documents within Four weeks from the date of
                               confirmation of the Minutes.
75.         AOS00598           DBHPS Rajiv Gandhi College of Education, D.C. Compound, Dharwad –
               B.Ed            580001, Karnataka
       DBHPS Rajiv Gandhi
       College of Education,
             Dharwad                   DBHPS Rajiv Gandhi College of Education, D.C. Compound,
                KA             Dharwad – 580001, Karnataka was granted recognition by SRC for
                               offering B.Ed. course with an intake of 60 students from the session
                               2000-2001 vide order dated 10.07.2000.

                               A Complaint was received on 18.11.2009 from the Secretary, Hindi
                               Prachar Mandali, Bijapur, Karnataka addressed to the Chairperson,
                               NCTE, New Delhi regarding misappropriation of funds and Mal-
                               administration of DBHPS institutions in Karnataka. The Complaint was
                               forwarded to SRC from NCTE, Delhi on 10.12.2009. The complainant
                               has requested NCTE to make investigation and to punish the real culprits
                               and the officials concerned.
                                                      107


      (Gangadharaiah)                                                        (Prof. C. Thangamuthu)
      Regional Director, SRC, NCTE                                             Chairman, SRC, NCTE
                                                                                 th
                                                                  Minutes of 204 Meeting of SRC
                                                                                 th  th
                                                                               27 -28 April 2011

                        SRC in its 188th meeting held on 28-29 January 2010 considered the
                        complaint and decided to call for the remarks from the institution on the
                        allegations made against DBHPS in Karnataka. Accordingly, letter was
                        issued to the institution on 08.03.2010. The institution submitted its
                        written representation on 30.03.2010. SRC in its 191st meeting held on
                        20-21 April 2010 considered the written representation submitted on
                        30.03.2010 and decided to cause inspection under section 17.
                        Accordingly, inspection was carried out on 02.06.2010. Accordingly,
                        inspection was carried out on 01.06.2010 and the SRC in its 193rd
                        meeting held on 2122 June, 2010 considered the report and decided to
                        withdraw recognition for B.Ed. course. Withdrawal order was issued to
                        the institution on 02.08.2010.

                        This office is in receipt of a copy of the complaint dated 23.11.2010 from
                        aggrieved students which has been addressed to Sri.Kapil Sibbal,
                        Ministry of HRD, New Delhi regarding trade of marks cards and certificate
                        in respect of Hindi Distance Education.

                        In the complaint it has been stated that the Centers of DBHP in remote
                        villages are collecting 40 to 50 thousand rupees and granting certificates
                        to various degrees like MA, M.Phil and Ph.D and also they are
                        conducting exams twice in a year. The eligibility for taking such exams
                        are as follows:

                         10+2+ Hindi Praveen of Equivalent Exam are eligible to take
                      M.A.Exam
                         10+2+ Hindi Praveen /Equivalent +Shikshak Training are eligible to
                      take even M.Ed Exam.

                        Further, only Karnataka Government has given its recognition to these
                        degrees for admissions only they are collecting very huge amounts
                        around 50 to 60 thousands rupees from the students to the student and
                        swindling the collected amount without any benefit to students. No
                        classes, no lecturers and no practical classes are being held at any of
                        the centres.

                        The Secretary of the DBHP, Chennai has issued a pamphlet stating that
                        a sum of Rs.500/- per students will be paid to the pracharak who
                        encourages the students to get admission to these courses and has
                        requested to take action immediately to stop this fraud.

                        The complainant has stated that last year the NCTE conducted
                        investigation in Karnataka about the genuineness of marks cards and
                        certificates issued by DBHPS and found so many loop holes. Such as
                        the exams conducted else where and where as the name of the centres
                        mentioned in the marks cards and certificate are quite different.

                        Further, SRC, NCTE has not given any recognition to Hindi course run
                        through Distance Education mode. The recognition accorded to 5
                                              108


(Gangadharaiah)                                                     (Prof. C. Thangamuthu)
Regional Director, SRC, NCTE                                          Chairman, SRC, NCTE
                                                                                          th
                                                                           Minutes of 204 Meeting of SRC
                                                                                          th  th
                                                                                        27 -28 April 2011
                               DBHPS institutions run in Karnataka has been withdrawn during
                               02.08.2010 for B.Ed course based on the complaint.

                               Accordingly, a letter was issued to the institution on 10.02.2011.

                               The institution preferred an appeal to NCTE, Hqrs and the appellant
                               authority has reversed the withdrawal order of SRC vide order dated
                               23.12.2010 with a direction to the SRC for issuance of show cause
                               notice.

                               The SRC in its 200th meeting held on 20-21 January 2011 considered the
                               Appellate authority order dated 23.12.2010 VT report, VCD and all the
                               relevant documentary evidences and it was decided to issue Show cause
                               notice. Accordingly, Show cause notice was issued to the institution on
                               11.03.2011 for the foolowing reasons:

                          1)     As per VT Report and as countersigned and admitted by the
                             institution, the total built-up-area of the building comes to 7963 sq.ft. It is
                             far short of the NCTE norm of 16,000 sq.ft.
                          2)     As per VT Report and as admitted by the institution, one Lecturer
                             and Principal do not possess requisite qualification and are not qualified
                             as per NCTE norms.
                          3)     Records were not produced to verify the quantum of admissions done
                             by the College giving room for suspecting the credentials.

                               Now, with the references to the above notice issued by SRC, NCTE
                               dated 11.03.2011 the same was challenged before the Hon‟ble High
                               Court of Karnataka in W.P.No. 13832-13837/2011 (EDN- RES). The
                               Hon‟ble High Court of Karnataka after considering the matter has ordered
                               the Stay on all furhter proceedings by SRC. They have also submitted a
                               copy of the order in W.P.No. 13832-13837/2011 dated 07.04.2011 of
                               Hon‟ble High Court of Karnataka.

                               Further, the institution has submitted its written representation on
                               07.03.2011 for the letter dated 10.02.2011, wherein the institution has
                               stated that they have no remarks/comments to offer in this behalf as the
                               letter does not have anything to complain against the college, it
                               specifically mentions Hindi Distance Education, which is not at all
                               concerned with this college.


                               The committee decided to get the stay vacated.


76.        AOS00156            DBHPS Lal Bahadur Shastri College of Education, 113/114,
               B.Ed            S.C.Road Sheshadripuram, Bangalore – 560 020, Karnataka
       DBHPS Lal Bahadur
        Shastri College of     DBHPS Lal Bahadur Shastri College of Education, 113/114, S.C.Road,
       Education, Bangalore    Sheshadripuram, Bangalore – 560 020, Karnataka was granted
                                                      109


      (Gangadharaiah)                                                        (Prof. C. Thangamuthu)
      Regional Director, SRC, NCTE                                             Chairman, SRC, NCTE
                                                                                 th
                                                                  Minutes of 204 Meeting of SRC
                                                                                 th  th
                                                                               27 -28 April 2011
          KA            recognition by SRC for offering B.Ed. course with an intake of 60
                        students from the session 2000-2001 vide order dated 10.07.2000.

                        A Complaint was received on 18.11.2009 from the Secretary, Hindi
                        Prachar Mandali, Bijapur, Karnataka addressed to the Chairperson,
                        NCTE, New Delhi regarding misappropriation of funds and Mal-
                        administration of DBHPS institutions in Karnataka. The Complaint was
                        forwarded to SRC from NCTE, Delhi on 10.12.2009. The complainant
                        has requested NCTE to make investigation and to punish the real culprits
                        and the officials concerned.

                        SRC in its 188th meeting held on 28-29 January 2010 considered the
                        complaint and decided to call for the remarks from the institution on the
                        allegations made against DBHPS in Karnataka. Accordingly, letter was
                        issued to the institution on 08.03.2010. SRC in its 191st meeting held on
                        20-21 April 2010 considered the written representation submitted on
                        30.03.2010 and decided to cause inspection under section 17.

                        Accordingly, inspection was carried out on 3.6.2010 and SRC in its 193rd
                        meeting held on 21-22 June, 2010 considered the report and decided to
                        withdraw recognition for B.Ed. course. Accordingly withdrawal order was
                        issued to the institution on 02.08.10.

                        This office is in receipt of a copy of the complaint dated 23.11.2010 from
                        aggrieved students which has been addressed to Sri.Kapil Sibbal,
                        Ministry of HRD, New Delhi regarding trade of marks cards and certificate
                        in respect of Hindi Distance Education.

                        In the complaint it has been stated that the Centers of DBHP in remote
                        villages are collecting 40 to 50 thousand rupees and granting certificates
                        to various degrees like MA, M.Phil and Ph.D and also they are
                        conducting exams twice in a year. The eligibility for taking such exams
                        are as follows:

                         10+2+ Hindi Praveen of Equivalent Exam are eligible to take
                      M.A.Exam
                         10+2+ Hindi Praveen /Equivalent +Shikshak Training are eligible to
                      take even M.Ed Exam.

                        Further, only Karnataka Government has given its recognition to these
                        degrees for admissions only they are collecting very huge amounts
                        around 50 to 60 thousands rupees from the students to the student and
                        swindling the collected amount without any benefit to students. No
                        classes, no lecturers and no practical classes are being held at any of
                        the centres.

                        The Secretary of the DBHP, Chennai has issued a pamphlet stating that
                        a sum of Rs.500/- per students will be paid to the pracharak who
                        encourages the students to get admission to these courses and has
                        requested to take action immediately to stop this fraud.
                                              110


(Gangadharaiah)                                                     (Prof. C. Thangamuthu)
Regional Director, SRC, NCTE                                          Chairman, SRC, NCTE
                                                                                    th
                                                                     Minutes of 204 Meeting of SRC
                                                                                    th  th
                                                                                  27 -28 April 2011

                         The complainant has stated that last year the NCTE conducted
                         investigation in Karnataka about the genuineness of marks cards and
                         certificates issued by DBHPS and found so many loop holes. Such as
                         the exams conducted else where and where as the name of the centres
                         mentioned in the marks cards and certificate are quite different.

                         Further, SRC, NCTE has not given any recognition to Hindi course run
                         through Distance Education mode. The recognition accorded to 5
                         DBHPS institutions run in Karnataka has been withdrawn during
                         02.08.2010 for B.Ed course based on the complaint.

                         Accordingly, a letter was issued to the institution on 10.02.2011.

                         The institution preferred an appeal to NCTE, Hqrs and the appellant
                         authority has reversed the withdrawal order of SRC vide order dated
                         23.12.2010 with a direction to the SRC for issuance of show cause
                         notice.

                         The SRC in its 200th meeting held on 20-21 January 2011 considered the
                         Appellate authority order dated 23.12.2010 VT report, VCD and all the
                         relevant documentary evidences and it was decided to issue Show cause
                         notice. Accordingly, Show cause notice was issued to the institution on
                         11.03.2011 for the folowing reasons:

                    1.         As per VT Report and as countersigned by the Management, the
                       total built-up-area of the building comes to 6736 sq.ft. which is far short
                       of the NCTE norms of 16,000 sq.ft.
                    2.         Language lab. is not available.
                    3.         Games and Sports facilities is not available. Corporation Ground
                       is being used.
                    4.         As per VT Report and as countersigned by the Management, 2
                       staff members do not possess requisite qualification as per NCTE norms.

                         Now, with the references to the above notice issued by SRC, NCTE
                         dated 11.03.2011 the same was challenged before the Hon‟ble High
                         Court of Karnataka in W.P.No. 13832-13837/2011 (EDN- RES). The
                         Hon‟ble High Court of Karnataka after considering the matter has ordered
                         the Stay on all furhter proceedings by SRC. They have also submitted a
                         copy of the order in W.P.No. 13832-13837/2011 dated 07.04.2011 of
                         Hon‟ble High Court of Karnataka.

                         Further, the institution has submitted its written representation on
                         07.03.2011 for the letter dated 10.02.2011, wherein the institution has
                         stated that they have no remarks/comments to offer in this behalf as the
                         letter does not have anything to complain against the college, it
                         specifically mentions Hindi Distance Education, which is not at all
                         concerned with this college.

                         The committee decided to get the stay vacated.
                                                111


(Gangadharaiah)                                                        (Prof. C. Thangamuthu)
Regional Director, SRC, NCTE                                             Chairman, SRC, NCTE
                                                                                         th
                                                                          Minutes of 204 Meeting of SRC
                                                                                         th  th
                                                                                       27 -28 April 2011



77.          APS02422          Sri Kotturswamy Instiute of Teacher Education, Sree Jagadguru
                D.Ed           Kotturswamy Math, Main Bazaar, Hospet-583201, Bellary District,
          Sri Kotturswamy      Karnataka
        Institute of Teacher
                               Sri Kotturswamy Institute of Teacher Education, Sree Jagadguru
         Education, Bellary
                               Kotturswamy Math, Main Bazaar, Hospet-583201, Bellary Distirct,
                 KA
                               Karnataka has submitted application for offering D.Ed course on
                               31.12.2003. The institution has been granted recognition by SRC for
                               offering D.Ed course with an intake of 50 students vide order dated
                               30.11.2004.

                               The institution in its letter dated 28.09.2007 has submitted a proposal for
                               shifting of premises along with Rs.40,000/- towards shifting fee.
                               Inspection was carried out on 27th October 2010.

                               The SRC in its 198th meeting held on 24-26 November 2010 considered
                               the VT report and all relevant documentary evidences and decided to
                               issue show cause notice. Accordingly, Show cause Notice was issued to
                               the institution on 11.01.2011. The institution has submitted its written
                               representation on 03.02.2011.

                               The SRC in its 201st meeting held on 22-23 February 2011 considered
                               the written representation of the institution and it was decided to issue
                               Final show cause notice. Accordingly, Final show cause notice was
                               issued to the institution on 18.03.2011. The institution has submitted its
                               written representation on 18.04.2011
                               The deficiencies pointed are as follows:
                                The earmarked built up area provided for D.Ed course in only 8550
                                 sq.ft.which is inadequate as per NCTE norms. A 16000 sq.ft. built up
                                 area is required as per NCTE norms.

                               The reply of the management to the show cause notice was duly
                               considered. The reply of the institution is not convincing and hence
                               unsatisfactory.

                               Under the above grounds, the Committee decides to withdraw the
                               recognition for D.Ed. course run by Sri Kotturswamy Institute of
                               Teacher Education, Sree Jagadguru Kotturswamy Math, Main
                               Bazaar, Hospet-583201, Bellary district, Karnataka, with effect from
                               2012-13 to enable the present batch of student to complete the
                               course.

                               But, it is made clear that the institution is debarred from making
                               any further admission subsequent to the date of issue of this order.

                               The Affiliating body / Examining board / body be informed
                               accordingly.
                               Further decided to return Endowment funds and Reserve fund
                                                      112


      (Gangadharaiah)                                                       (Prof. C. Thangamuthu)
      Regional Director, SRC, NCTE                                            Chairman, SRC, NCTE
                                                                                          th
                                                                           Minutes of 204 Meeting of SRC
                                                                                          th  th
                                                                                        27 -28 April 2011
                              deposited with SRC NCTE, Bangalore.


                                                                                 th
78.         APS09335          K.B.R College of Education, Santhi Vanam, 7 Ward, Narasa Reddy
               B.Ed                                               Kandriga,  Naidupet, Nellore,
          KBR College of                                          Andhra Pradesh
         Education, Nellore
                AP            K.S.R Memorial Charitable Trust for Rural Development, Hyderabad,
                              Andhra Pradesh has submitted an application in the name and style of
                              K.B.R College of Education, H.No.2-1-68/A, Bazaar Street, Naidupeta,
                              Nellore, Andhra Pradesh for B.Ed course on 31.01.2008.

                              The application was processed and the deficiency letter was issued to
                              the institution on 18.02.2008. The institution has submitted written
                              representation on 21.04.2008. the reply submitted by the institution was
                              scrutinized and a clarification letter was issued to the institution on
                              27.06.2008. The institution has submitted its reply on 14.08.2008 which
                              was examined and found that the institution is fulfilled all the deficiencies.
                              Hence a consent letter was issued to the institution on 12.09.2008.

                              The institution in its reply dated 18.09.2008 expressed their opinion of
                              consent for inspection. Again one more letter was received from the
                              institution on 22.10.2008.

                              Meantime, letters dated 07.01.2009, 07.02.2009 from the State
                              Government of Andhra Pradesh requesting not to accord further
                              recognition/permission to the new colleges/private B.Ed, D.Ed/Physical
                              Education/Language Pandit in the State of Andhra Pradesh.

                              Further a letter dated 17.03.2009 has been received from NCTE-Hqrs.
                              informing that the recommendations of the Government of Andhra
                              Pradesh not to grant recognition/permission in respect of other courses
                              like B.Ed, D.Ed and Physical Education courses have been considered in
                              NCTE and it has been decided that no further recognition/permission to
                              any institution in the State of Andhra Pradesh be considered by SRC for
                              the academic session 2009-2010 for B.Ed, D.Ed and Physical Education
                              courses also.

                              The letters dated 07.01.2009, 07.02.2009 and 17.03.2009 were
                              considered by SRC in its 172nd Meeting held on 25th and 26th March,
                              2009 and the Committee decided to accept the recommendation of the
                              State Government of Andhra Pradesh, not to grant recognition to any of
                              the teacher training institutions in the State of Andhra Pradesh for the
                              year 2009-10 and decided to return the applications.

                              As per the decision of SRC the application for B.Ed course in the respect
                              of K.B.R College was returned along with documents and processing fee
                              of Rs.40000/- on 28.04.2009.

                              Further the institution has approached Hon‟ble High Court of Andhra
                                                      113


      (Gangadharaiah)                                                        (Prof. C. Thangamuthu)
      Regional Director, SRC, NCTE                                             Chairman, SRC, NCTE
                                                                                         th
                                                                          Minutes of 204 Meeting of SRC
                                                                                         th  th
                                                                                       27 -28 April 2011
                               Pradesh in W.P.No.10067 of 2009. The court has passed order dated
                               13.07.2010:

                               “With a direction to the first respondent to take necessary steps for
                               granting recognition to the petitioners College of Education at Narsireddy
                               Kandriga, Naidupeta, Nellore District in accordance with the relevant
                               rules. This recognition shall ensure to the benefit of the present academic
                               year has already commenced with the schedule of counseling which is to
                               begin from 02.08.2010. in the circumstances of the case, there shall be
                               no order as to costs”.

                               SRC in its 195th meeting held on 17-18 August 2010 considered the
                               matter and decided to direct the Management/institution to resubmit the
                               old application returned by SRC along with the documents as originally
                               submitted relating to land, building, FDR, Application fee, BCC from
                               competent Government Engineer and other relevant aspects for
                               processing and for necessary action.

                               As per the decision of SRC a letter was issued on 23.09.2010 and a letter
                               to revalidate the DD was issued on 07.10.2010. Till date institution not
                               submitted its written representation and revalidated D.D.

                               SRC in its 201st meeting held on 22nd –23rd February, 2011 considered
                               the non-reply of the institution to the SRC‟s letters dated 23.09.2010 and
                               07.10.2010 and decided to send a Show cause Notice

                               Accordingly a final show cause notice was issued to the institution on
                               18.03.2011. The institution has replied vide letter dated 08.03.2011.

                               The committee considered the written explanation to the notice and
                               other documents submitted by the institution and decided to cause
                               inspection.


79.         AOS00596           DBHPS Dr.B.D. Jatti College of Education, Afzalpur Takke, Bijapur -
               B.Ed            506102, Karnataka
       DBHPS Dr B.D. Jatti
       College of Education,           DBHPS Dr.B.D. Jatti College of Education, Afzalpur Takke,
              Bijapur          Bijapur - 506102, Karnataka was granted recognition by SRC for offering
                KA             B.Ed. course with an intake of 60 students from the session 2000-2001
                               vide order dated 10.07.2000.

                               A Complaint was received on 18.11.2009 from the Secretary, Hindi
                               Prachar Mandali, Bijapur, Karnataka addressed to the Chairperson,
                               NCTE, New Delhi regarding misappropriation of funds and Mal-
                               administration of DBHPS institutions in Karnataka. The Complaint was
                               forwarded to SRC from NCTE, Delhi on 10.12.2009. The complainant
                               has requested NCTE to make investigation and to punish the real culprits
                               and the officials concerned.
                                                      114


      (Gangadharaiah)                                                       (Prof. C. Thangamuthu)
      Regional Director, SRC, NCTE                                            Chairman, SRC, NCTE
                                                                                 th
                                                                  Minutes of 204 Meeting of SRC
                                                                                 th  th
                                                                               27 -28 April 2011

                        Further, this office is in receipt of another letter dated 19.08.2009 from
                        Sri.Om Narain, Lecturer of Hari Bawa Inter College Gawan, Badaun
                        District, Uttar Pradesh regarding malpractices in B.Ed College of Dakshin
                        Bharath Hindi Prachar Sabha, Karnataka.             The above letter was
                        forwarded by NCTE, Hqrs on 16.11.2009.

                        The complainant states that the annual intake in B.Ed classes was fixed
                        at 100 students and the following colleges are admitting more than 100
                        students and adjusting these excess students against the leftover vacant
                        seats for the preceding years i.e.2007-2008 & 2008-2009:
                     1. DBHPS Dr.B.D.Jatti Siksha College, Afzalpur, Takke Athani Road,
                        Bijapur – 586101, Karnataka
                     2. DBHPS Dr.B.D. Jatti Siksha College, Jila Hasptal Rasta (District Hospital
                        Road), Belgaum – 590001.
                     3. Vishveshwara Siksha College, K.R. Mohalla, Bani Vilas Road, Mysore –
                        570 004.

                                Further, the complainant has stated that these students neither
                        attend the classes nor go to teaching schools, even then they get more
                        than 80% marks and has requested to investigate into the matter and
                        punish the defaulters.

                        SRC in its 188th meeting held on 28-29 January 2010 considered the
                        above two complaints and decided to call for the following remarks from
                        the institution on the allegations made against DBHPS in Karnataka.
                        Accordingly, letter was issued to the institution on 08.03.2010. The
                        institution submitted its written representation on 30.03.2010. SRC in its
                        191st meeting held on 20-21 April 2010 considered the written
                        representation submitted on 30.03.2010 and decided to cause inspection
                        under section 17. Accordingly, inspection was carried out on 03.06.2010
                        and the SRC in its 193rd meeting held on 21-22 June, 2010 considered
                        the report and decided to withdraw recognition. Withdrawal order was
                        issued to the institution on 02.08.2010.

                        This office is in receipt of a copy of the complaint dated 23.11.2010 from
                        aggrieved students which has been addressed to Sri.Kapil Sibbal,
                        Ministry of HRD, New Delhi regarding trade of marks cards and certificate
                        in respect of Hindi Distance Education.

                        In the complaint it has been stated that the Centers of DBHP in remote
                        villages are collecting 40 to 50 thousand rupees and granting certificates
                        to various degrees like MA, M.Phil and Ph.D and also they are
                        conducting exams twice in a year. The eligibility for taking such exams
                        are as follows:

                         10+2+ Hindi Praveen of Equivalent Exam are eligible to take
                      M.A.Exam
                         10+2+ Hindi Praveen /Equivalent +Shikshak Training are eligible to
                      take even M.Ed Exam.
                                              115


(Gangadharaiah)                                                     (Prof. C. Thangamuthu)
Regional Director, SRC, NCTE                                          Chairman, SRC, NCTE
                                                                                    th
                                                                     Minutes of 204 Meeting of SRC
                                                                                    th  th
                                                                                  27 -28 April 2011

                         Further, only Karnataka Government has given its recognition to these
                         degrees for admissions only they are collecting very huge amounts
                         around 50 to 60 thousands rupees from the students to the student and
                         swindling the collected amount without any benefit to students. No
                         classes, no lecturers and no practical classes are being held at any of
                         the centres.

                         The Secretary of the DBHP, Chennai has issued a pamphlet stating that
                         a sum of Rs.500/- per students will be paid to the pracharak who
                         encourages the students to get admission to these courses and has
                         requested to take action immediately to stop this fraud.

                         The complainant has stated that last year the NCTE conducted
                         investigation in Karnataka about the genuineness of marks cards and
                         certificates issued by DBHPS and found so many loop holes. Such as
                         the exams conducted else where and where as the name of the centres
                         mentioned in the marks cards and certificate are quite different.

                         Further, SRC, NCTE has not given any recognition to Hindi course run
                         through Distance Education mode. The recognition accorded to 5
                         DBHPS institutions run in Karnataka has been withdrawn during
                         02.08.2010 for B.Ed course based on the complaint.

                         Accordingly, a letter was issued to the institution on 10.02.2011.

                         The institution preferred an appeal to NCTE, Hqrs and the appellant
                         authority has reversed the withdrawal order of SRC vide order dated
                         23.12.2010 with a direction to the SRC for issuance of show cause
                         notice.

                         The SRC in its 200th meeting held on 20-21 January 2011 considered the
                         Appellate authority order dated 23.12.2010 VT report, VCD and all the
                         relevant documentary evidences and it was decided to issue show cause
                         notice. Accordingly, Show cause notice was issued to the institution on
                         11.03.2011 for the following reasons:
                    1.            As per VT Report and as admitted/countersigned by the
                         institution, the total built-up-area of the building comes to 6208 sq.ft.
                         which is far short of the NCTE norms of 16,000 sq.ft.
                    2.            Shiksha Snatak course is also being run in the same building.
                    3.            Psychology lab. materials needs to be strengthened. There is no
                         Language learning lab.
                    4.            In 2008-09 and 2009-10 academic year , institutions have made
                         admissions of 120 and 121 respectively which is more than the intake
                         sanctioned and thus violated NCTE norms.

                         Now, with the references to the above notice issued by SRC, NCTE
                         dated 11.03.2011 the same was challenged before the Hon‟ble High
                         Court of Karnataka in W.P.No. 13832-13837/2011 (EDN- RES). The
                         Hon‟ble High Court of Karnataka after considering the matter has ordered
                                                116


(Gangadharaiah)                                                        (Prof. C. Thangamuthu)
Regional Director, SRC, NCTE                                             Chairman, SRC, NCTE
                                                                                        th
                                                                         Minutes of 204 Meeting of SRC
                                                                                        th  th
                                                                                      27 -28 April 2011
                               the Stay on all further proceedings by SRC. They have also submitted a
                               copy of the order in W.P.No. 13832-13837/2011 dated 07.04.2011 of
                               Hon‟ble High Court of Karnataka.

                               Further, the institution has submitted its written representation on
                               21.02.2011 for the letter dated 10.02.2011, wherein the institution has
                               stated that they have no remarks/comments to offer in this behalf as the
                               letter does not have anything to complain against the college, it
                               specifically mentions Hindi Distance Education, which is not at all
                               concerned with this college.

                               The committee decided to get the stay vacated.
80.         AOS00602           DBHPS Dr.B.D. Jatti College of Education, Civil Hospital Road, Ayodhya
               B.Ed            Nagar, Belgaum – 590 001, Karnataka
       DBHPS Dr. B.D. Jatti
       College of Education,          DBHPS Dr.B.D. Jatti College of Education, Civil Hospital Road,
             Belgaum           Ayodhya Nagar, Belgaum – 590 001, Karnataka was granted recognition
                KA             by SRC for offering B.Ed. course with an intake of 60 students from the
                               session 2000-2001 vide order dated 10.07.2000.

                               A Complaint was received on 18.11.2009 from the Secretary, Hindi
                               Prachar Mandali, Bijapur, Karnataka addressed to the Chairperson,
                               NCTE, New Delhi regarding misappropriation of funds and Mal-
                               administration of DBHPS institutions in Karnataka. The Complaint was
                               forwarded to SRC from NCTE, Delhi on 10.12.2009. The complainant
                               has requested NCTE to make investigation and to punish the real culprits
                               and the officials concerned.

                               Further, this office is in receipt of another letter dated 19.08.2009 from
                               Sri.Om Narain, Lecturer of Hari Bawa Inter College Gawan, Badaun
                               District, Uttar Pradesh regarding malpractices in B.Ed College of Dakshin
                               Bharath Hindi Prachar Sabha, Karnataka.             The above letter was
                               forwarded by NCTE, Hqrs on 16.11.2009.

                             The complainant states that the annual intake in B.Ed classes was fixed
                             at 100 students and the following colleges are admitting more than 100
                             students and adjusting these excess students against the leftover vacant
                             seats for the preceding years i.e.2007-2008 & 2008-2009:
                          1.     DBHPS Dr.B.D.Jatti Siksha College, Afzalpur, Takke Athani Road,
                             Bijapur – 586101, Karnataka
                          2.     DBHPS Dr.B.D. Jatti Siksha College, Jila Hasptal Rasta (District
                             Hospital Road), Belgaum – 590001.
                          3.     Vishveshwara Siksha College, K.R. Mohalla, Bani Vilas Road,
                             Mysore – 570 004.

                                       Further, the complainant has stated that these students neither
                               attend the classes nor go to teaching schools, even then they get more
                               than 80% marks and has requested to investigate into the matter and
                               punish the defaulters.

                                                     117


      (Gangadharaiah)                                                      (Prof. C. Thangamuthu)
      Regional Director, SRC, NCTE                                           Chairman, SRC, NCTE
                                                                                  th
                                                                   Minutes of 204 Meeting of SRC
                                                                                  th  th
                                                                                27 -28 April 2011
                                 SRC in its 188th meeting held on 28-29 January 2010 considered
                        the above two complaints and decided to call for the following remarks
                        from the institution on the allegations made against DBHPS in Karnataka.
                        Accordingly, letter was issued to the institution on 08.03.2010. The
                        institution submitted its written representation on 30.03.2010. SRC in its
                        191st meeting held on 20-21 April 2010 considered the written
                        representation submitted on 30.03.2010 and decided to cause inspection
                        under section 17. Accordingly, inspection was carried out on
                        01.06.2010 and the SRC in its 193rd meeting held on 21-22 June, 2010
                        considered the Report and decided to withdraw recognition for B.Ed.
                        course. Withdrawal order was issued the institution on 02.08.2010.

                               This office is in receipt of a copy of the complaint dated
                        23.11.2010 from aggrieved students which has been addressed to
                        Sri.Kapil Sibbal, Ministry of HRD, New Delhi regarding trade of marks
                        cards and certificate in respect of Hindi Distance Education.

                                 In the complaint it has been stated that the Centers of DBHP in
                        remote villages are collecting 40 to 50 thousand rupees and granting
                        certificates to various degrees like MA, M.Phil and Ph.D and also they
                        are conducting exams twice in a year. The eligibility for taking such
                        exams are as follows:

                         10+2+ Hindi Praveen of Equivalent Exam are eligible to take
                      M.A.Exam
                         10+2+ Hindi Praveen /Equivalent +Shikshak Training are eligible to
                      take even M.Ed Exam.
                      Further, only Karnataka Government has given its recognition to these
                      degrees for admissions only they are collecting very huge amounts
                      around 50 to 60 thousands rupees from the students to the student and
                      swindling the collected amount without any benefit to students. No
                      classes, no lecturers and no practical classes are being held at any of
                      the centres.

                        The Secretary of the DBHP, Chennai has issued a pamphlet stating that
                        a sum of Rs.500/- per students will be paid to the pracharak who
                        encourages the students to get admission to these courses and has
                        requested to take action immediately to stop this fraud.

                        The complainant has stated that last year the NCTE conducted
                        investigation in Karnataka about the genuineness of marks cards and
                        certificates issued by DBHPS and found so many loop holes. Such as
                        the exams conducted else where and where as the name of the centres
                        mentioned in the marks cards and certificate are quite different.

                        Further, SRC, NCTE has not given any recognition to Hindi course run
                        through Distance Education mode. The recognition accorded to 5
                        DBHPS institutions run in Karnataka has been withdrawn during
                        02.08.2010 for B.Ed course based on the complaint.

                                               118


(Gangadharaiah)                                                      (Prof. C. Thangamuthu)
Regional Director, SRC, NCTE                                           Chairman, SRC, NCTE
                                                                                          th
                                                                           Minutes of 204 Meeting of SRC
                                                                                          th  th
                                                                                        27 -28 April 2011
                               Accordingly, a letter was issued to the institution on 10.02.2011.

                               The institution preferred an appeal to NCTE, Hqrs and the appellant
                               authority has reversed the withdrawal order of SRC vide order dated
                               23.12.2010 with a direction to the SRC for issuance of show cause
                               notice.

                             The SRC in its 200th meeting held on 20-21 January 2011 considered the
                             Appellate authority order dated 23.12.2010 VT report, VCD and all the
                             relevant documentary evidences and it was decided to issue Show cause
                             notice. Accordingly, Show cause notice was issued to the institution on
                             11.03.2011 for the following reasons:
                          1.          As per VT Report and as countersigned by the institution, the
                             total built-up-area earmarked for the course is 8,109 sq.ft.; but on
                             calculation, the total built–up–area comes to only 4976.43 sq.ft. Both are
                             far less than NCTE norms of 16,000 sq.ft. of built-up-area.
                          2.          As per VT report and as countersigned by the institution, three
                             teachers are not qualified as per NCTE norms.
                          3.          As per VT report and as countersigned by the institution, the
                             institution is in the habit of carrying forward the shortage of
                             admissions(unfilled seats of previous years) to the next year and is
                             admitting more than the stipulated intake of 100 in subsequent years as
                             and when demand increases/comes. This un-academic/commercial
                             practice is not acceptable as per the norms.

                               Now, with the references to the above notice issued by SRC, NCTE
                               dated 11.03.2011 the same was challenged before the Hon‟ble High
                               Court of Karnataka in W.P.No. 13832-13837/2011 (EDN- RES). The
                               Hon‟ble High Court of Karnataka after considering the matter has ordered
                               the Stay on all furhter proceedings by SRC. They have also submitted a
                               copy of the order in W.P.No. 13832-13837/2011 dated 07.04.2011 of
                               Hon‟ble High Court of Karnataka.

                               Further, the institution has submitted its written representation on
                               04.03.2011 for the letter dated 10.02.2011, wherein the institution has
                               stated that they have no remarks/comments to offer in this behalf as the
                               letter does not have anything to complain against the college, it
                               specifically mentions Hindi Distance Education, which is not at all
                               concerned with this college.

                               The committee decided to get the stay vacated.


81.         AOS00600           DBHPS Basaveswara College of Education, „Hindi Bhavan‟ V.V. Road,
               B.Ed            K.R.Mohalla, Mysore – 570 004, Karnataka
             DBHPS
           Basaveswara
       College of Education,         DBHPS Basaveswara College of Education, „Hindi Bhavan‟ V.V.
              Mysore           Road, K.R.Mohalla, Mysore – 570 004, Karnataka was granted

                                                      119


      (Gangadharaiah)                                                        (Prof. C. Thangamuthu)
      Regional Director, SRC, NCTE                                             Chairman, SRC, NCTE
                                                                                th
                                                                  Minutes of 204 Meeting of SRC
                                                                                 th  th
                                                                               27 -28 April 2011
          KA           recognition by SRC for offering B.Ed. course with an intake of 60
                       students from the session 2000-2001 vide order dated 10.07.2000.

                       A Complaint was received on 18.11.2009 from the Secretary, Hindi
                       Prachar Mandali, Bijapur, Karnataka addressed to the Chairperson,
                       NCTE, New Delhi regarding misappropriation of funds and Mal-
                       administration of DBHPS institutions in Karnataka. The Complaint was
                       forwarded to SRC from NCTE, Delhi on 10.12.2009. The complainant
                       has requested NCTE to make investigation and to punish the real culprits
                       and the officials concerned.

                       Further, this office is in receipt of another letter dated 19.08.2009 from
                       Sri.Om Narain, Lecturer of Hari Bawa Inter College Gawan, Badaun
                       District, Uttar Pradesh regarding malpractices in B.Ed College of Dakshin
                       Bharath Hindi Prachar Sabha, Karnataka.             The above letter was
                       forwarded by NCTE, Hqrs on 16.11.2009.

                       The complainant states that the annual intake in B.Ed classes was fixed
                       at 100 students and the following colleges are admitting more than 100
                       students and adjusting these excess students against the leftover vacant
                       seats for the preceding years i.e.2007-2008 & 2008-2009:
                1.                     DBHPS Dr.B.D.Jatti Siksha College, Afzalpur, Takke
                       Athani Road, Bijapur – 586101, Karnataka
                2.                     DBHPS Dr.B.D. Jatti Siksha College, Jila Hasptal Rasta
                       (District Hospital Road), Belgaum – 590001.
                3.                     Vishveshwara Siksha College, K.R. Mohalla, Bani Vilas
                       Road, Mysore – 570 004.

                               Further, the complainant has stated that these students neither
                       attend the classes nor go to teaching schools, even then they get more
                       than 80% marks and has requested to investigate into the matter and
                       punish the defaulters.

                                SRC in its 188th meeting held on 28-29 January 2010 considered
                       the above two complaints and decided to call for the following remarks
                       from the institution on the allegations made against DBHPS in Karnataka.
                       Accordingly, letter was issued to the institution on 08.03.2010. The
                       institution submitted its written representation on 30.03.2010. SRC in its
                       191st meeting held on 20-21 April 2010 considered the written
                       representation submitted on 30.03.2010 and decided to cause inspection
                       under section 17. Accordingly, inspection was carried out on
                       04.06.2010. The SRC in its 193rd meeting held on 21-22 June, 2010
                       considered the VT report and decided to withdraw the recognition.
                       Accordingly, withdrawal order was issued to the institution on 27.09.2010.

                       Further, this office is in receipt of a copy of the complaint dated
                       23.11.2010 from aggrieved students which has been addressed to
                       Sri.Kapil Sibbal, Ministry of HRD, New Delhi regarding trade of marks
                       cards and certificate in respect of Hindi Distance Education.

                                             120


(Gangadharaiah)                                                    (Prof. C. Thangamuthu)
Regional Director, SRC, NCTE                                         Chairman, SRC, NCTE
                                                                                    th
                                                                     Minutes of 204 Meeting of SRC
                                                                                    th  th
                                                                                  27 -28 April 2011
                                  In the complaint it has been stated that the Centers of DBHP in
                         remote villages are collecting 40 to 50 thousand rupees and granting
                         certificates to various degrees like MA, M.Phil and Ph.D and also they
                         are conducting exams twice in a year. The eligibility for taking such
                         exams are as follows:

                                   10+2+ Hindi Praveen of Equivalent Exam are eligible to take
                         M.A.Exam
                                     10+2+ Hindi Praveen /Equivalent +Shikshak Training are
                         eligible to take even M.Ed Exam.

                         Further, only Karnataka Government has given its recognition to these
                         degrees for admissions only they are collecting very huge amounts
                         around 50 to 60 thousands rupees from the students to the student and
                         swindling the collected amount without any benefit to students. No
                         classes, no lecturers and no practical classes are being held at any of
                         the centres.

                         The Secretary of the DBHP, Chennai has issued a pamphlet stating that
                         a sum of Rs.500/- per students will be paid to the pracharak who
                         encourages the students to get admission to these courses and has
                         requested to take action immediately to stop this fraud.

                         The complainant has stated that last year the NCTE conducted
                         investigation in Karnataka about the genuineness of marks cards and
                         certificates issued by DBHPS and found so many loop holes. Such as
                         the exams conducted else where and where as the name of the centres
                         mentioned in the marks cards and certificate are quite different.

                         Further, SRC, NCTE has not given any recognition to Hindi course run
                         through Distance Education mode. The recognition accorded to 5
                         DBHPS institutions run in Karnataka has been withdrawn during
                         02.08.2010 for B.Ed course based on the complaint.

                         Accordingly, a letter was issued to the institution on 10.02.2011.

                         The institution preferred an appeal to NCTE, Hqrs and the appellant
                         authority has reversed the withdrawal order of SRC vide order dated
                         23.12.2010 with a direction to the SRC for issuance of show cause
                         notice.

                         The SRC in its 200th meeting held on 20-21 January 2011 considered the
                         appellate authority order dated 23.12.2010. VT report, VCD and all the
                         relevant documentary evidences and it was decided to issue show cause
                         notice. Accordingly, Show cause notice was issued to the institution on
                         11.03.2011 for the following reasons:

                    1)      The built-up-area is only 4368.2 sq.ft., which is far short of the
                       NCTE norms of 16,000 sq.ft.
                    2)      Sports facilities, Games facilities are not available.
                                                121


(Gangadharaiah)                                                        (Prof. C. Thangamuthu)
Regional Director, SRC, NCTE                                             Chairman, SRC, NCTE
                                                                                          th
                                                                           Minutes of 204 Meeting of SRC
                                                                                          th  th
                                                                                        27 -28 April 2011
                            3)          Library is having only 800 books related to Education, which are
                                 grossly inadequate.

                                 Now, with the reference to the above notice issued by SRC, NCTE dated
                                 11.03.2011 the same was challenged before the Hon‟ble High Court of
                                 Karnataka in W.P.No. 13832-13837/2011 (EDN- RES). The Hon‟ble High
                                 Court of Karnataka after considering the matter has ordered the Stay on
                                 all furhter proceedings by SRC. They have also submitted a copy of the
                                 order in W.P.No. 13832-13837/2011 dated 07.04.2011 of Hon‟ble High
                                 Court of Karnataka.

                                 Further, the institution has submitted its written representation on
                                 07.03.2011 for the letter dated 10.02.2011, wherein the institution has
                                 stated that they have no remarks/comments to offer in this behalf as the
                                 letter does not have anything to complain against the college, it
                                 specifically mentions Hindi Distance Education, which is not at all
                                 concerned with this college.

                                 The committee decided to get the stay vacated.


82.         APS01580             Annapurneshwari Hukkeri D.Ed College, Borgaon Post, Chikodi Taluk,
            APS04778             Belgaum District, Karnataka
               D.Ed
                                 Annapurneshwari Hukkeri D.Ed College, Borgaon Post, Chikodi Taluk,
          D.Ed (marathi)
                                 Belgaum District, Karnataka (APS04778) submitted an application for
         Annapurneshwari
                                 grant of recognition on 02.01.2006. The institution was granted
           Hukkeri D.Ed
                                 recognition for offering D.Ed course with an intake of 50 students vide
         College, Belgaum
                                 order dated 31.10.2007.
                KA
                                 Another file by name Annapurneshwari Hukeri D.Ed College, Borgaon-
                                 591216, Chikodi, Belgaum District, Karnataka bearing code No.
                                 APS01580 was granted recognition vide order dated 01.12.2004 with an
                                 intake of 50 students from the session 2004-2005.

                                 NCTE, Hqrs vide its letter dated 27.10.2010 has forwarded a copy of the
                                 inspection report dated 21.05.2010. As there are deficiencies pointed out
                                 in the inspection report NCTE, Hqrs has requested SRC to initate action
                                 against institution.

                                 The SRC in its 198th meeting held on 24-26 November 2010 considered
                                 the VT report and all relevant documentary evidences and decided to
                                 issue show cause notice. Accordingly, Show cause notice was issued to
                                 the institution on 03.01.2011. The institution has submitted its written
                                 representation on 03.02.2011.


                                 The Committee considered the VT report of the institution, other
                                 related documents and clarification from the institution vide letter
                                 dt. 03.02.2011, along with the original file of the institution and
                                                       122


      (Gangadharaiah)                                                        (Prof. C. Thangamuthu)
      Regional Director, SRC, NCTE                                             Chairman, SRC, NCTE
                                                                                       th
                                                                        Minutes of 204 Meeting of SRC
                                                                                       th  th
                                                                                     27 -28 April 2011
                             decided to continue recognition accorded to the institution.

83.          APS09549        Sri.Kanakadas D.Ed College, C/o Beereshwar High School, No.289 &
               D.Ed          290, Bilagi, Bagalkot-587116,Karnataka
        Sri Kanakadas D.Ed
         College, Bagalkot   Sri.Kanakadas D.Ed College, C/o Beereshwar High School, No.289 &
                KA           290, Bilagi, Bagalkot-587116, Karnataka submitted application for grant
                             of recognition for D.Ed course on 30.06.2008.

                             The VT report along with all necessary documents were placed before
                             172nd meeting of SRC held on 25-26 March, 2009 and SRC decided to
                             issue Notice. Accordingly, Notice was issued to the institution on
                             16.04.2009.

                             The institution has submitted its written representation on 25.04.2009 &
                             29.04.2009. SRC in its 175th meeting held on 13-14 May, 2009
                             considered the written representation and decided to cause re-inspection.
                             The SRC was communicated to the institution vide letter dated
                             02.06.2009. The institution vide letter dated 29.06.2009 has requested for
                             postponement of the inspection.

                             The SRC in its 178th meeting held on 13-14 July 2009 considered the
                             letter received on 03.07.2009 and decided to refuse recognition.
                             Accordingly, Refusal order was issued to the institution on 30.07.2009.
                             The institution preferred appeal under section 18 of NCTE Act. The
                             appellate authority considered the appeal and confirmed the refusal order
                             of SRC vide order dated 12.04.2010.

                             The institution filed W.P.16446 of 2010 in the Hon‟ble High Court of
                             Karnataka, Circuit Bench at Dharwad and the case has been disposed of
                             on 16.09.2010. The judgement reads as follows:

                             The writ petition is allowed. Impugned orders are set aside. The 1st
                             respondent (SRC, NCTE) is directed to re-inspect the petitioner institution
                             after fixing a date and after communicating the same to the institution.
                             The decision regarding recognition can be taken in accordance with law
                             thereafter. “Accordingly re-inspection was carried out on 10.11.2010 as
                             per the court directions”.

                             The SRC in its 199th meeting held on 22-23 December 2010 considered
                             the VT report, VCD and all relevant documentary evidences and decided
                             to issue Show cause notice. Accordingly, Show cause notice was issued
                             to the institution on 04.02.2011. The institution has submitted its written
                             representation on 22.02.2011.

                             The SRC in its 203rd meeting held on 31st March and 1st April, 2011
                             considered the written representation of the institution and decided to
                             issue notice for CD and Photos.

                             The institution in its letter dated 19.04.2011 has stated that they have
                                                    123


      (Gangadharaiah)                                                     (Prof. C. Thangamuthu)
      Regional Director, SRC, NCTE                                          Chairman, SRC, NCTE
                                                                                         th
                                                                          Minutes of 204 Meeting of SRC
                                                                                         th  th
                                                                                       27 -28 April 2011
                               noticed the decision in the website and Notice Board wherein SRC has
                               decided to seek for latest VCD and photographs. Hence, in compliance
                               to the decision of SRC, now the institution has submitted latest VCD/DVD
                               and latest Photographs.

                               On careful perusal of the original file of the institution, VT Reports
                               and other related documents, Act of NCTE, 1993, Regulations and
                               guidelines of NCTE published from time to time laid on the table, the
                               Regional Committee decided to issue Letter of Intent for grant of
                               recognition to D.Ed course of Two year duration with an annual
                               intake of 50(Firty only)(one unit) from the academic year 2011-12
                               subject to the appointment of qualified staff through duly
                               constituted selection committee as per the Norms of NCTE/State
                               Government/Affiliating University and be given effect before the
                               commencement of the academic session.

84.          APS01428          Vanitha Vidyalaya Teacher Training Institute, Vinoba Nagar
                 D.Ed          (Keerthi Nagar), Shimoga-577204, Karnataka
         Vanitha Vidyalaya
          Teacher Training     Vanitha Vidyalaya Teacher Training Institute, Vinoba Nagar (Keerthi
         Institute, Shimoga    Nagar), Shimoga-577204, Karnataka has submitted application for
                  KA           offering D.Ed course on 16.10.2003. The institution has been granted
                               recognition by SRC for offering D.Ed course with an intake of 50 students
                               vide order dated 25.11.2004.
                              The institution in its letter dated 27.09.2007 has submitted a proposal for
                              shifting of premises along with Rs.40,000/- towards shifting fee. The
                              inspection was carried out on 29th December 2010. The inspection report
                              has been received along with VCD. The details of the visiting team report
                              is attached:

                              The institution vide letter dated 22.12.2010 has stated that the D.Ed
                              course is being run in the own building of the institution since inspection
                              and the original documents of the owned building has also been submitted
                              on 07.07.2009. Therefore, the institution has stated that shifting of the
                              premises, do not arise and this office without proper application of mind to
                              the contents of the letter negligently, misled the management and made to
                              remit Rs.40,000/- towards the inspection fee through DD No. 882992
                              dated 25.09.2007.       Now, the institution has requested to refund the
                              amount of Rs.40,000/- and as shifting of premises does not arise.

                               The SRC in its 200th meeting held on 20-21 January 2011 conisdered the
                               VT report, VCD and all the relevant documentary evidences amd it was
                               decided to issue show cause notice. Accordingly, Show cause notice
                               was issued to the institution on 11.03.2011. for the following:

                               The total Built up area earmarked for the D.Ed programme is only
                               4968.73 sq,ft. which is grossly inadequate for the Teacher Education
                               Programme as per NCTE norms. The same is also corroborated by the
                                                      124


      (Gangadharaiah)                                                       (Prof. C. Thangamuthu)
      Regional Director, SRC, NCTE                                            Chairman, SRC, NCTE
                                                                                       th
                                                                        Minutes of 204 Meeting of SRC
                                                                                       th  th
                                                                                     27 -28 April 2011
                             management by affixing signature of the management representative in
                             the essential data given in the VT report.
                             The built up area as per Building Completion Certificate is only 4000
                             sq.ft and the built up area as given in essential data is 4968.73 sq.ft.
                             Both are inadequate even if the discrepancy is explained.
                             Language learning lab is not available.


                            The institution has submitted its written representation on 11.04.2011.

                             The reply of the management to the show cause notice was duly
                             considered. The reply of the institution is not convincing and hence
                             unsatisfactory.

                             Under the above grounds, the Committee decides to withdraw the
                             recognition for D.Ed. course run by Vanitha Vidyalaya Teacher
                             Training Institute, Vinoba Nagar (Keerthi Nagar) Shimoga-577204,
                             Karnataka with effect from 2012-13 to enable the present batch of
                             student to complete the course.

                             But, it is made clear that the institution is debarred from making
                             any further admission subsequent to the date of issue of this order.

                             The Affiliating body / Examining board / body be informed
                             accordingly.
                             Further decided to return Endowment funds and Reserve fund
                             deposited with SRC NCTE, Bangalore.


85.         APS03659         Basaveshwara D.Ed College, No.19C, Sattur, Dharwad District-
               D.Ed          580007, Karnataka
        Basaveshwara D.Ed
         College, Dharwad
                KA           Basaveshwara D.Ed College, No.19C, Sattur, Dharwad District-580007,
                             Karnataka has submitted application for starting D.Ed course on
                             30.12.2004. The institution was granted recognition for offering D.Ed
                             with an intake of 50 students from the session 2005-2006 vide order dt.
                             21.12.2005.

                             A complaint was received on 11.06.2009 from Sri.A.H.Peerzada and has
                             requested to conduct enquiry against Shri.Karidurgannavar, Principal of
                             Basaveshwara D.Ed College Dharwad with noted points. The matter was
                             considered by SRC in its 177th meeting held on 22-23 June 2009 and
                             decided to issue show cause notice under section 17 of NCTE Act in
                             order to call for remarks on the complaint. Accordingly, notice was
                             issued to the institution on 05.08.2009. The institution submitted its
                             written representation on 31.08.2009. The committee in its 183rd meeting
                             held on 22nd September 2009 considered the written representation and
                             decided to issue Show cause Notice for shifting of premises.
                                                    125


      (Gangadharaiah)                                                     (Prof. C. Thangamuthu)
      Regional Director, SRC, NCTE                                          Chairman, SRC, NCTE
                                                                                            th
                                                                           Minutes of 204 Meeting of SRC
                                                                                          th  th
                                                                                        27 -28 April 2011
                              Accordingly, Show cause Notice was issued to the institution on
                              04.11.2009.

                              As the institution has not submitted any written representation to the
                              notice the matter was placed before SRC in its 198th meeting held on 25-
                              26 February 2010. SRC considered the matter and decided to issue
                              notice. Accordingly, Notice was issued to the institution on 06.04.2010
                              for the following reasons:
                                 1. Demand Draft of Rs. 40,000/- towards inspection fee in favour of “The
                                    Member Secretary NCTE” Payable at Bangalore should be submitted.
                                 2. Land documents of the new building/location for having own land in the
                                    name of the institution/Society/Trust.
                                 3. Building Plan of the new building duly approved by th Government
                                    authority.
                                 4. Building Completion Certificate from the Government authorities in the
                                    prescribed format.
                                 5. Land Usage Certificates from the concerned Government authorities
                                    stating that the land is exclusively permitted/ sanctioned for Educational
                                    Purposes only should be submitted.
                                 6. Encumbrance certificate from the competent Government authority
                                    should submitted.
                                 7. Certificate of Registration/Bye-law of the Society/Trust should be
                                    submitted.
                                 8. The Affidavit in Rs. 100/- stamp paper in the prescribed format with
                                    Notary attestation should be submitted.

                              The institution did not care to respond to the notice issued on the
                              institution even after issuance of two show cause notices dated
                              04.11.2009 and 06.04.2010 and lapse of ten months.

                              Under the above grounds, the Committee decides to withdraw the
                              recognition for D.Ed. course run by Basaveshwara D.Ed College No.
                              19C, Sattur, Dharwad District-580007, Karnataka, with effect from
                              2012-13 to enable the present batch of student to complete the
                              course.

                              But, it is made clear that the institution is debarred from making
                              any further admission subsequent to the date of issue of this order.

                              The Affiliating body / Examining board / body be informed
                              accordingly.
                              Further decided to return Endowment funds and Reserve fund
                              deposited with SRC NCTE, Bangalore.


86.          APS02069         Sri.Krishna College of Education, Karnataka Yadava Educational
                B.Ed          Society, No.12/2, Yamuna Bai Road, Madhava Nagar, Bangalore-
        Sri Krishna College
                              560001,Karnataka
           of Education,
             Bangalore        Sri. Krishna College of Education, Karnataka Yadava Educational
                 KA
                                                     126


      (Gangadharaiah)                                                         (Prof. C. Thangamuthu)
      Regional Director, SRC, NCTE                                              Chairman, SRC, NCTE
                                                                                th
                                                                 Minutes of 204 Meeting of SRC
                                                                                th  th
                                                                              27 -28 April 2011
                       Society, No.12/2, Yamuna Bai Road, Madhava Nagar, Bangalore-
                       560001, Karnataka has submitted application for starting B.Ed course on
                       31.12.2003. The institution was granted recognition on 25.11.2004 with
                       an intake of 100 students.

                       As per the decision of 175th meeting of SRC held on 13-14 May 2009, the
                       institutions where recognition‟s were granted in temporary premises with
                       a condition shift to permanent premises within period of three years time
                       limit of grant recognition as per NCTE Regulations, 2002 notified in
                       18.11.2002, were considered. It was decided that institutions which have
                       not shifted to the permanent premises even after the expiry of three years
                       time limit be issued notice under section 17 of NCTE Act for further
                       action.

                       Accordingly, Notice was issued to the institution on 01.09.2009. The
                       institution has submitted its written representation on 30.09.2009. SRC in
                       its 187th meeting held on 29-30 December 2009 considered the written
                       representation and decided to cause inspection. Accordingly inspection
                       was carried out on 04.06.2010.

                       The SRC in its 193rd meeting held on 21-22 June 2010 considered the VT
                       report and other documents and decided to withdraw the recognition.
                       Accordingly withdrawal order was issued to the on 28.07.2010.

                       The institution preferred an appeal to NCTE, Hqrs and the appellate

                       authority has reversed the Withdrawal Order of SRC vide order dated
                       21.01.2011 has reversed the Withdrawal order of with the direction to the
                       SRC for issuance of Show cause notice and for taking furhter action
                       therafter.

                       The SRC in its 201st meeting held on 22-23 February 2011 considered
                       the Appellate authority order dt. 21.01.2011, VT report, VCD and all the
                       relevant documentary evidences and it was decided to issue Show cause
                       notice. Accordingly, Show cause notice was issued to the insitution on
                       25.03.2011. The institution has submitted written representation on
                       13.04.2011. The institution is also running D.Ed (APS05894) course.
                       As per the request of the management vide letter Dt. 12/04/2011, the
                       committee decided to withdraw the recongnition of D.Ed course.

                       Under the above grounds, the Committee decides to withdraw the
                       recognition for D.Ed. course run by Sri Krishna College of Education,
                       Karnataka, with effect from 2012-13 to enable the present batch of student
                       to complete the course.
                                             127


(Gangadharaiah)                                                    (Prof. C. Thangamuthu)
Regional Director, SRC, NCTE                                         Chairman, SRC, NCTE
                                                                                            th
                                                                           Minutes of 204 Meeting of SRC
                                                                                          th  th
                                                                                        27 -28 April 2011

                              But, it is made clear that the institution is debarred from making any
                             further admissions subsequent to the date of issue of this order.

                             The Affiliating body / Examining board / body be informed accordingly.

                             Further decided to return Endowment              funds   and        Reserve   fund
                             corresponding to D.Ed course, if any.

                             B.Ed Programme:
                             The committee further decided to issue notice to the of B.Ed course and
                             directed the management for the following certificate:

                              A Certificate from the Government Affiliating body to the effect that no
                               other programme is being run by the institution in the same building /
                               Campus including I.T.I is being run along with the existing B.Ed course is
                               to be submitted.

                             In view of the above, the Committee decided to issue a Show cause Notice
                             to the institution as to why the recognition be not withdrawn and thereby
                             providing an opportunity to the institution to make a written representation
                             within 30 days from the date of issue of the Notice along with necessary
                             certificates/documents in order to take a final decision in the matter; failing
                             which action will be taken including the withdrawal of recognition, based
                             on the records available, with no further notice.
87.         APS01437         Srinivasa Vidya Nikethan D.Ed College, Arasina Kunte, Nelamangala
            APS06119         Taluk, Bangalore Rural District-562123, Karnataka
               D.Ed
             D.Ed-AI         Srinivasa Vidya Nikethan D.Ed College, Arasina Kunte, Nelamangala
         Srinivasa Vidya     Taluk, Bangalore Rural District-562123, Karnataka has submitted
          Nikethan D.Ed      application for D.Ed course on 27.11.2003 and for D.Ed-AI course on
        College, Bangalore   30.12.2005. The institution has been granted recognition for D.Ed course
                KA           on 23.12.2004 with an intake of 50 students. Further, the institution was
                             granted recognition for D.Ed–AI course on 16.05.2007 with an existing
                             intake of 50 students and additional intake of 50

                             students thus with an annual intake of 100 students with the condition to
                             shift into own premises within 3 years of eficiencie order.

                             NCTE, Hqrs vide its letter dated 22.09.2010 has forwarded a copy of the
                             inspection report dated 21.04.2010 conducted Under Section 13 of NCTE Act.
                             As there are eficiencies pointed out in the inspection report, NCTE, Hqrs has
                             requested SRC to initiate action against the institution Under Section 17 of the
                             NCTE Act immediately
                                               th
                             The SRC in its 197 meeting held on 13-14 October, 2010 considered the matter
                             and decided to issue Show cause Notice. Accordingly, show cause notice was
                             issued to the institution on 06.12.2010. The institution has submitted written
                             representation on 09.12.2010.

                                                    th
                             The SRC in its 200 meeting held on 20-21 January 2011 considered written
                                                         128


      (Gangadharaiah)                                                        (Prof. C. Thangamuthu)
      Regional Director, SRC, NCTE                                             Chairman, SRC, NCTE
                                                                                            th
                                                                                Minutes of 204 Meeting of SRC
                                                                                                th  th
                                                                                              27 -28 April 2011
                               representation of the institution and decided to issue show cause notice.
                               Accordingly, Show cause notice was issued to the institution on 11.03.2011. The
                               institution has submitted written representation on 31.03.2011.

                               The Committee considered the VT Report, VCD and all the relevant
                               documentary evidences and it was decided to serve Final Show
                               cause Notice under Section 17 of NCTE Act for the following:

                                   Complete Land documents in institution/Society‟s name for the
                                    premises where institution is located is to be submitted.

                                   Building completion certificate from competent Govt. engineer
                                    is to be submitted in the prescribed format.

                                   The building plan is entirely different from the plan submitted
                                    earlier dt. 27.7.04 and building plan submitted along with the
                                    Building completion certificate dt. 9.12.2008. This discrepancy
                                    may be explained.

                                In view of the above, the Committee decided to issue a Final Show
                               cause Notice to the institution as to why the recognition be not
                               withdrawn and thereby providing an opportunity to the institution to
                               make a written representation within 30 days from the date of issue
                               of the Notice along with necessary certificates/documents in order
                               to take a final decision in the matter; failing which action will be
                               taken including the withdrawal of recognition, based on the records
                               available, with no further notice.
88.          APS01538
                 D.Ed          Vidya Rashmi Teacher Training Institute, S.N.R. Rural Education
           Vidya Rashmi
          Teacher Training     Trust, Vidya Gangotri, Puttur Taluk, Dakshina Kannada District-
         Institute, Dakshina   574202, Karnataka
               Kannada
                  KA           Vidya Rashmi Teacher Training Institute, S.N.R. Rural Educational Trust,
                               Vidya Gangotri, Puttur Taluk, Dakshina Kannada District-574202,
                               Karnataka has submitted application for offering D.Ed course on
                               19.12.2003. The institution has been granted recognition by SRC for
                               offering D.Ed course with an intake of 50 students vide order dated
                               24.12.2004.

                               The institution in its letter dated 06.11.2007 has submitted a proposal for
                               shifting of premises along with Rs.40,000/- towards shifting fee. The
                               inspection was carried out on 28th December 2010. The inspection report
                               has been received along with VCD.

                               The SRC in its 200th meeting held on 20-21 January 2011 considered the
                               VT report, VCD and all the relevant documentary evidences and it was
                               decided to issue Show cause notice. Accordingly, Show cause notice
                               was issued to the institution on 11.03.2011 for the following points:

                                                       129


      (Gangadharaiah)                                                         (Prof. C. Thangamuthu)
      Regional Director, SRC, NCTE                                              Chairman, SRC, NCTE
                                                                                          th
                                                                           Minutes of 204 Meeting of SRC
                                                                                             th th
                                                                                          27 -28 April 2011
                               As per VT report, the management is running D.Ed programme along with
                               general Nursing course in the same educational complex/building. Which is not
                               permissible as per NCTE norms.
                               The Built Area allotted for Nursing college is 7200 sq,ft (in ground floor)
                               along with Teacher Education Programme in a two storied building, which
                               is against NCTE norms.
                               Land documents are not submitted

                               The institution has submitted its written representation on 12.04.2011.

                               The reply of the management to the show cause notice was duly
                               considered. The reply of the institution is not convincing and hence
                               unsatisfactory.

                               Under the above grounds, the Committee decides to withdraw the
                               recognition for D.Ed. course run by Vidya Rashmi Teacher Training
                               Institute, S.N.r. Rural Education Trust, Vidya Gangotri, Puttur Taluk,
                               Dakshina Kannada District-574202, Karnataka, with effect from
                               2012-13 to enable the present batch of student to complete the
                               course.

                               But, it is made clear that the institution is debarred from making
                               any further admission subsequent to the date of issue of this order.

                               The Affiliating body / Examining board / body be informed
                               accordingly.
                               Further decided to return Endowment funds and Reserve fund
                               deposited with SRC NCTE, Bangalore.


89.         APS01928           JSS Institute of Education, Huvina Hadagali, Holagundi Road,
               B.Ed            Bellary District-583219, Karnataka
          JSS Institute of
         Education, Bellary    JSS Institute of Education, Huvina Hadagali, Holagundi Road, Bellary
                KA             District-583219, Karnataka has submitted application for offering B.Ed
                               course on 31.12.2003.The institution has been granted recognition by
                               SRC for offering B.Ed course with an intake of 100 students vide order
                               dated 01.12.2004.

                               The institution in its letter dated 01.10.2009 has submitted a proposal for
                               shifting of premises along with Rs.40,000/- towards shifting fee.
                               Accordingly, inspection was carried out on 21st October 2010.

                               The SRC in its 198th meeting held on 24-26 November, 2010 considered
                               the VT report and decided to issue Show cause Notice. Accordingly,
                               show cause notice was issued on 03.01.2011. The institution has
                               submitted written representation on 27.01.2011.

                               The SRC in its 201st meeting held on 22-23 February 2011 considered
                                                      130


      (Gangadharaiah)                                                        (Prof. C. Thangamuthu)
      Regional Director, SRC, NCTE                                             Chairman, SRC, NCTE
                                                                                      th
                                                                       Minutes of 204 Meeting of SRC
                                                                                      th  th
                                                                                    27 -28 April 2011
                             the written representation, VT report, VCD and all the relevant
                             documentary evidences and it was decided to issue final Show cause
                             notice. Accordingly, Final Show cause notice was issued to the
                             institution on 23.03.2011. The institution has submitted written
                             representation on 12.04.2011.

                             The Committee considered the VT Report, VCD and all the relevant
                             documentary evidences and it was decided to serve Final Show
                             cause Notice under Section 17 of NCTE Act for the following:

                               Building completion certificate from the Competent Govt Engineer
                                is to be submitted.

                              In view of the above, the Committee decided to issue a Final Show
                             cause Notice to the institution as to why the recognition be not
                             withdrawn and thereby providing an opportunity to the institution to
                             make a written representation within 30 days from the date of issue
                             of the Notice along with necessary certificates/documents in order
                             to take a final decision in the matter; failing which action will be
                             taken including the withdrawal of recognition, based on the records
                             available, with no further notice.



90.         APS02336         Shri.Nagappana Karajagi D.Ed College, Sree Beereshwara
            APS07035         Shikshana   Samsthe,  Behind Syrian  Hospital, P.B.Road,
          D.Ed (Kannada)
          D.Ed (Marathi)     Sankeshwar – 591313, Hukkeri Taluk, Belgaum District,
         Shri. Nagappana     Karnataka
           Karajagi D.Ed
         College, Belgaum    Sree Beereshwara Shikshana Samsthe, Sankeshwara – 501313. Hukkeri
                KA           Taluk, Belgaum District, Karnataka was granted recognition for offering
                             D.Ed course (Kannada Medium) with an intake of 50 students from the
                             session 2004-2005 vide order dated 02.12.2004 bearing code No.
                             APS02336. Further, Shri.Nagappana Karajagi D.Ed College, Sree
                             Beereshwara Shikshana Samsthe, Behind Syrian Hospital, P.B.Road,
                             Sankeshwar – 591313, Hukkeri Taluk, Belgaum District, Karnataka was
                             also granted recognition for offering D.Ed course (Marathi Medium) with
                             an intake of 50 students vide order dated 26.04.2007 bearing code
                             No.APS07035 with the condition to shift to own premises within 3 years
                             of recognition.
                             NCTE, Hqrs vide its letter dated 11.10.2010 has forwarded a copy of the
                             inspection report dated 21.05.2010 conducted Under Section 13 of NCTE
                             Act. As there are deficiencies pointed out in the inspection report, NCTE,
                             Hqrs has requested SRC to initiate action against the institution Under
                             Section 17 of the NCTE Act immediately.
                             The SRC in its 197th meeting held on 13-14 October 2010 considered the
                             VT report and decided to issue Showcasue notice for both courses.
                             Accordingly, Show cause notice was issued to the institution on
                             13.12.2010. The institution has submitted its written representation on
                                                   131


      (Gangadharaiah)                                                    (Prof. C. Thangamuthu)
      Regional Director, SRC, NCTE                                         Chairman, SRC, NCTE
                                                                                         th
                                                                          Minutes of 204 Meeting of SRC
                                                                                         th  th
                                                                                       27 -28 April 2011
                               10.01.2011 and 17.01.2011.

                               Since the main file were not available, a part file was opened in which
                               reply to our notice dated 13.12.2010 was processed and placed before
                               SRC in its 200th meeting held on 20-21 January 2011. SRC decided to
                               issue Final Show cause notice on 11.03.2011 for which the institution has
                               submitted its written representation on 11.04.2011.

                               But in 201st meeting held on 22-23 February 2011 both the original files
                               were traced and the part file got misplaced and accordingly, agenda not
                               highlighting the contents of Final Show cause Notice dated 11.03.2011
                               were placed before SRC and SRC decided to withdraw recognition.
                               As such no provision for reviewing/revising its own decision by the
                               regional committee.

                               The committee has decided to re-confirm the decision which was
                               taken earlier in the 201st meeting held on 22-23 Feb 2011, for
                               withdrawal of recognition of the institution.


91.         APS01719           Sahyadri Teacher Training Institute, Thirthahalli Taluk, Shimoga
               D.Ed            District-577432, Karnataka
         Sahyadri Teacher
         Training Institute,
                               Sahyadri Teacher Training Institute, Thirthahalli Taluk, Shimoga District-
             Shimoga
                               577432, Karnataka has submitted application for offering D.Ed course on
                KA
                               30.12.2003. The institution has been granted recognition by SRC for
                               offering D.Ed course with an intake of 50 students vide order dated
                               24.12.2004.

                               The institution in its letter dated 25.09.2007 has submitted a proposal for
                               shifting of premises along with Rs.40,000/- towards shifting fee. The
                               inspection was carried out on 30th December 2010. The inspection report
                               has been received along with VCD.

                               The SRC in its 200th meeting held on 20-21 January 2011 considered the
                               VT report, VCD and all the relevant documentary evidences and it was
                               decided to issue Showcasue notice. Accordingly, Show cause notice was
                               issued to the institution on 11.03.2011. The institution has submitted its
                               written representation on 11.04.2011.

                               The Committee considered the VT Report, VCD and all the relevant
                               documentary evidences and it was decided to serve Final Show
                               cause Notice under Section 17 of NCTE Act for the following:

                                Building plan approved from a competent Govt. authority is to be
                                 submitted.

                                Land documents with survey nos of the land where the institution
                                 is to be shifted in English version is to be submitted.
                                                      132


      (Gangadharaiah)                                                       (Prof. C. Thangamuthu)
      Regional Director, SRC, NCTE                                            Chairman, SRC, NCTE
                                                                                           th
                                                                           Minutes of 204 Meeting of SRC
                                                                                          th  th
                                                                                        27 -28 April 2011

                              In the Affidavit submitted the survey nos and plot nos are not
                               mentioned.


                              Non- Encumbrance Certificate from the competent Government
                               Authorised person / Authorities to be submitted.

                              Psychology lab needs to be strengthened.

                              FDRs for Rs. 5 lacs & 3 lacs towards endowment and reserve fund
                               in joint account from a Nationalised Bank is to be submitted.

                              In view of the above, the Committee decided to issue a Final Show
                             cause Notice to the institution as to why the recognition be not
                             withdrawn and thereby providing an opportunity to the institution to
                             make a written representation within 30 days from the date of issue
                             of the Notice along with necessary certificates/documents in order
                             to take a final decision in the matter; failing which action will be
                             taken including the withdrawal of recognition, based on the records
                             available, with no further notice.

92.         AOS00508         Sanjay D.P.Ed College, Gunahalli Road, Shahapur Village, Pin-585401,
              D.P.Ed         Bidar District, Karnataka
           Sanjay D.P.Ed
           College, Bidar    Sanjay D.P.Ed College, Gunahalli Road, Shahapur Village, Pin-585401,
                KA           Bidar District, Karnataka was granted recognition for offering D.P.Ed
                             course on 23.12.1996. The institution was granted recognition on
                             21.08.2000.

                             The State Government of Karnataka in its letter addressed to Ministry of
                             HRD, Government of India, New Delhi and NCTE has recommended
                             withdrawal of some institutions in the state of Karnataka as the
                             institutions are lacking infrastructural, instructional facilities and staff.

                             The matter was placed before SRC in its 134th meeting of SRC held
                             during 29-31 May & 1st June, 2007 has decided to cause inspection of
                             the institutions recommended for withdrawal of recognition by State
                             Government of Karnataka under Section 17 of NCTE Act. Accordingly,
                             inspection was carried out on 18.10.2007. The inspection report has
                             received and placed before SRC.

                             The SRC in its 161st meeting held on 06-07 August 2007 considered the
                             report and decided that the institution prima facie, does not fulfill the
                             requirements, the norms and standards laid down by the NCTE in
                             accordance with the provisions of the NCTE Act 1993 detailed as below:
                             1. The management has not responded to inspection team.
                             2. The building in which the D.P.Ed course was functioning is closed.
                             3. The D.P.Ed college is not functioning in the same address.

                                                     133


      (Gangadharaiah)                                                        (Prof. C. Thangamuthu)
      Regional Director, SRC, NCTE                                             Chairman, SRC, NCTE
                                                                                       th
                                                                         Minutes of 204 Meeting of SRC
                                                                                           th th
                                                                                        27 -28 April 2011
                              4. The management running nightingale nursing school in the same building.

                              As the institution did not care to respond to the notice dated 26.08.2008
                              issued to the institution even after lapse of two and half years.

                              The SRC in its 201st meeting held on 22-23 February 2011 considered
                              the non- reply to the notice, VT report, VCD and all the relevant
                              documentary evidences and it was decided to issue Final Show cause
                              notice. Accordingly, Final Show cause notice was issued to the
                              institution on 23.02.2011. The institution has submitted its written
                              representation on 11.04.2011.

                              Note: The institution was granted recognition at the following address.
                              The institution is governed by Sri Sanjay Educational Society. As per
                              records the land documents submitted at the time of application ( Building
                              plan for S.No.107, Shahpur village, Gonalli Road, Bidar; sale deed dated
                              07.02.1997 in favour of individual at S.No.107, Shahpur village, Gonalli
                              Road, Bidar).

                                      Though institution states that concerned authorities have been
                              informed, no intimation is seen as per record of NCTE, the apex body for
                              granting recognition is given for present address where college is stated
                              to be running. No permission taken for shifting of premises.

                              The matter was considered by the Committee and it was decided to
                              cause Shifting inspection of the institution for D.P.Ed. Course, in
                              anticipation of inspection fee of Rs. 40000/-, under Section 17 of
                              NCTE Act.


93.         APS09669          An application was submitted by Ushodaya Residential School
               B.Ed           Committee, Guntur District, Andhra Pradesh for grant of recognition
            Ushodaya          to B.Ed course in the office of SRC-NCTE, vide dated 30.10.2008
         Residential School
         Committee, Guntur    The file was under process and in the meanwhile, in view of the
                AP
                              recommendations of the State Government of Andhra Pradesh
                              vide letter dated 07.01.2009 not to further recognised/permit the
                              institutions for conducting B.Ed, D.Ed, Physical Education,
                              Language Pandit course(s).

                              The SRC in its 169th Meeting held on 12-13 January, 2009 having
                              considered the letter dated 07.01.2009 of State Government of
                              Andhra Pradesh and decided to give effect to the above decision of
                              State Government of Andhra Pradesh as such, with immediate
                              effect.

                              A letter dated 07.02.2009 forwarded by Principal Secretary of Education
                              requesting not to accord further recognition/permission to the new

                                                    134


      (Gangadharaiah)                                                     (Prof. C. Thangamuthu)
      Regional Director, SRC, NCTE                                          Chairman, SRC, NCTE
                                                                                       th
                                                                        Minutes of 204 Meeting of SRC
                                                                                       th  th
                                                                                     27 -28 April 2011
                       colleges/private B.Ed, D.Ed, Physical Education, Language Pandit in the
                       State of Andhra Pradesh as the above colleges are exceeding in
                       numbers than required.

                       A letter dated 17.03.2009 has been received from NCTE, Hqrs
                       informing that

                       “The recommendations of the Govt. of Andhra Pradesh not to grant
                       recognition/permission in respect of other courses like B.Ed, D.Ed and
                       Physical Education courses have further been decided that no further
                       Recognition/ Permission to any institution in the State of Andhra Pradesh
                       be considered by SRC for the academic session 2009-2010 for B.Ed,
                       D.Ed, and Physical Education courses also”.

                       The State Government vide its letter dated 20.03.2009 informed
                       that it has been decided not to recommend the name of this
                       institution. The letters dated 07.01.2009, 07.02.2009, 17.03.2009
                       and 20.03.2009 was considered by SRC in its 172nd Meeting held
                       on 25-26 March, 2009 and SRC decided to accept the
                       recommendation of the State Government of Andhra Pradesh, not
                       to grant recognition to any of the Teacher Training Institutions in
                       the State of Andhra Pradesh for the year 2009-2010 and decided
                       to close the applications.

                       As per the decision of SRC the application was closed on 27.04.2009
                       and original application and DD for Rs.40000/- to the institution is
                       returned.

                       The Institute has          approached       to    Hon‟ble    High     Court     in
                       W.P.No.21400/2010.

                       Now, the Hon‟ble High Court has passed an order on 27.08.2010 as
                       hereunder:
                       “In the light of he orders passed by this court in similar W.P.Nos.6714 of 2009,
                                                                             st
                       9360 of 2010, there shall be a direction to the 1 respondent to consider the
                       petitioner‟s application for starting B.Ed., course in accordance with law without
                       reference to the State Government‟s policy dated 17.01.2009. Post along with
                       W.P. Nos 6714 of 2009, 9360of 2010 and 11078 of 2010”.

                       SRC considered the matter in its 196th Meeting held on 15-16
                       September, 2010 Meeting held on 15-16 September, 2010 meeting and
                       directed the Management/institution to resubmit the old application
                       returned by SRC along with necessary documents as originally submitted
                       relating to land, building, FDR, Application fee, Building Completion
                       Certificate from competent Government Engineer/authority and other
                       relevant aspects for processing and for necessary action.

                       As per direction of Regional Committee a letter was issued on
                       25.10.2010. In response to this office letter dated 25.10.2010 the
                                                135


(Gangadharaiah)                                                          (Prof. C. Thangamuthu)
Regional Director, SRC, NCTE                                               Chairman, SRC, NCTE
                                                                                       th
                                                                       Minutes of 204 Meeting of SRC
                                                                                      th  th
                                                                                    27 -28 April 2011
                         institution has submitted reply vide letter dated 27.11.2010.

                              As per perusal of the file the institution has submitted following
                         documents vide letters dated 29.11.2010 :-

                    1.         Processing fee and application fee (40,000+1,000= 41,000/-)
                    2.         Land documents-The Deed of Sale is Executed on 25th of
                        November 2006 for Sy No 158/9A, 158/10B1, 158/11A, 158/12B. in
                        favour of Ushodaya Residential School Committee, Dachepalli.
                    3.         BCC Certificate from Assistant Engineer. dated 10-11-2008, for
                        Sy No 158/9A, 158/10B1, 158/11A, 158/12B.Ed, Narayanapuram, Built
                        up area-17553.5 Sq.ft.
                    4.         Land use Certificate by Tahsildar.
                    5.         Approved Building Plan by Assistant Engineer, for Sy No-158/9A,
                        158/10B1, 158/11A, 158/12B.Ed, Land area-Ac.1-10guntas, Built up
                        area-1632.5 Sq.mts.
                    6.         FDR submitted in photo copy original verified.
                    7.         Encumbrance Certificate
                    8.         Bye laws of Society Registration
                    9.         Copy of Affidavit of Rs 100/- Sy No-158/9A, 158/10B1, 158/11A,
                        158/12B.Ed, Land area-Ac.1-10guntas, Built up area-1632.5 Sq.mts.
                    10.        Copy of Original Application
                        The committee in its 199th meeting held on 23-24 December 2010
                        considered the written explanation to the notice and other documents
                        submitted by the institution and decided to cause inspection. Inspection
                        was conducted on 07.02.2011.

                         The Committee considered the VT Report, VCD and all the relevant
                         documentary evidences and it was decided to serve Show cause Notice
                         Under Section 17 of NCTE Act for the following :

                                As per VCD, it is clear that the part of the building is Asbestos
                         roofed in the 1st floor, which is against NCTE norms.

                               As per VCD, ladies toilets, Art & Music rooms are covered with
                         asbestos roof which is not permitted as per NCTE norms.

                              As per VCD, plastering walls, internal rooms, front portion is
                         incomplete.

                                As per VCD, all materials are dumped in the rooms.

                                 As per VCD, entrance of each rooms carry pasted papers which
                         reads the purpose for which each room is assigned as temporary
                         arrangement. This should be explained.
                         As per direction of SRC SCN was issued on 17.3.2011. In response to
                         this office letter dt. 17.3.2011. The Institution has submitted reply dated
                         13.4.2011

                         The institution has produced self declaration affidavit to the effect that above
                                                 136


(Gangadharaiah)                                                          (Prof. C. Thangamuthu)
Regional Director, SRC, NCTE                                               Chairman, SRC, NCTE
                                                                                        th
                                                                         Minutes of 204 Meeting of SRC
                                                                                        th  th
                                                                                      27 -28 April 2011
                               statements are true.
                               VCD showing completion of building submitted as proof Building Completion
                               Certificate dated 10.11.2008 for Servey no. 158/9A,158/10B1,158/11A,
                               158/12B issued by Assistant Engineer M.P. DACHEPALLY for total built up
                               area of G.F.13,433sq.ft., F.F.4120.50 sq. ft. submitted.

                               The SRC considered, VT report, VCD, reply to the show cause notice
                               and all relevant documents and decided to issue Letter Of Intent for
                               grant of Formal Recognition to B.Ed course of one year duration
                               with an annual intake of 100(One hundred only)(one unit) for the
                               academic year 2011-12 subject to the appointment of qualified staff
                               through duly constituted selection committee as per the Norms of
                               NCTE/State Government/Affiliating University and be given effect
                               before the commencement of the academic session.


94.         APS09574           Siva Ranga College of Education, Siva Sankara Educational &
               B.Ed            Development Society, No.926, Koilkuntla, Kurnool-518134, Andhra
        Siva Ranga College     Pradesh.
       of Education, Kurnool
                AP             An application was submitted by Siva Sankara Educational &
                               Development Society, Kurnool, Andhra Pradesh for grant of recognition
                               to B.Ed course in the office of SRC-NCTE, vide dated 13.08.2008.
                               The file was under process and in the meanwhile, in view of the
                               recommendations of the State Government of Andhra Pradesh vide letter
                               dated 07.01.2009 not to further recognise/permit the institutions for
                               conducting B.Ed, D.Ed, Physical Education, Language Pandit course(s).
                               The SRC in its 169th Meeting held on 12-13 January, 2009 having
                               considered the letter dated 07.01.2009 of State Government of Andhra
                               Pradesh and decided to give effect to the above decision of State
                               Government of Andhra Pradesh as such, with immediate effect.
                               A letter dated 07.02.2009 forwarded by Principal Secretary of Education
                               requesting not to accord further recognition/permission to the new
                               colleges/private B.Ed, D.Ed, Physical Education, Language Pandit in the
                               State of Andhra Pradesh as the above colleges are exceeding in
                               numbers than required.
                               A letter dated 17.03.2009 has been received from NCTE, Hqrs informing
                               that the “The recommendations of the Govt. of Andhra Pradesh not to
                               grant recognition/permission in respect of other courses like B.Ed, D.Ed
                               and Physical Education courses have further been decided that no
                               further Recognition/ Permission to any institution in the State of Andhra
                               Pradesh be considered by SRC for the academic session 2009-2010 for
                               B.Ed, D.Ed, and Physical Education courses also”.
                               The letters dated 07.01.2009, 07.02.2009, 17.03.2009 and 20.03.2009
                               was considered by SRC in its 172nd Meeting held on 25-26 March, 2009
                               and SRC decided to accept the recommendation of the State
                               Government of Andhra Pradesh, not to grant recognition to any of the
                                                     137


      (Gangadharaiah)                                                      (Prof. C. Thangamuthu)
      Regional Director, SRC, NCTE                                           Chairman, SRC, NCTE
                                                                                   th
                                                                    Minutes of 204 Meeting of SRC
                                                                                   th  th
                                                                                 27 -28 April 2011
                       Teacher Training Institutions in the State of Andhra Pradesh for the year
                       2009-2010 and decided to return the applications.
                       As per the direction of SRC the documents along with processing fee
                       returned to the institution on 27.04.2009. The institution has approached
                       to Hon‟ble High court of Andhra pradesh without making appeal to
                       appellate authority under section 18 of NCTE Act.
                       Hon‟ble High court has passed order dated first day of June, two
                       thousand and ten. The operative part of order as under:-
                       These Writ Petitions raise common issues. Therefore with the consent of
                       the learned counsel for the parties, they are taken up for hearing and
                       disposal together.
                       In all these Writ petitions, the petitioners, which are educational
                       Institutions, felt aggrieved by non-consideration of their applications for
                       grant of recognition to D.Ed/B.Ed courses purportedly on the ground of
                       the policy decision taken by the Government not to permit establishment
                       of new D.Ed/B.Ed Colleges.

                       At the hearing, Sri Andapalli Sanjeev Kumar, learned counsel appearing
                       for the petitioners in Writ petition Nos.11038, 11040, 11587 and 10965 of
                       2009, and Sri S. Girimoji Rao, learned counsel for the petitioner in Writ
                       petition No.11241 of 2009, submitted that the petitioners filed their
                       applications for recognition prior to the policy decision taken by the State
                       Government; and that in an identical Writ petition, this Court, vide: order
                       dated 16-12-2009 in writ petition No.6712 of 2009, held as under:
                       “It may be true the State Government as well the first respondent have
                       reviewed the situation as to the necessity or otherwise of according
                       permission to establish new colleges of education in the State in further
                       and that the existing institutions are fond to be adequate. However, the
                       right that is accrued to the petitioners on the basis of their application and
                       the consideration there of by the first respondent cannot be taken away
                       on account of the change of policy. It is settled principle of law that
                       whenever an application is made, it must be considered and processed in
                       accordance with the provisions of law or the policy that existed as on the
                       date of presentation. Subsequent changes may apply to the applications
                       that are made thereafter.
                       Hence, the writ petition is disposed of directing the first respondent to
                       take necessary steps as contemplated in its communication dated 24-11-
                       2009 and pass appropriate orders.
                       There shall be no order as to coasts”.
                       The learned Standing Counsel representing respondents 2 and 3 has not
                       disputed the above position.
                       Since the issue raised in these Writ Petitions are squarely covered by the
                       above mentioned orders, these Writ petitions are disposed of in terms of
                       the above mentioned orders in writ petition No.6712 of 2009 with the
                       direction that the directions given in the said orders shall form part of this
                       orders.
                       The institution has now submitted D.Ed of 40000/- for processing fee on
                                               138


(Gangadharaiah)                                                       (Prof. C. Thangamuthu)
Regional Director, SRC, NCTE                                            Chairman, SRC, NCTE
                                                                                         th
                                                                          Minutes of 204 Meeting of SRC
                                                                                         th  th
                                                                                       27 -28 April 2011
                             30.06.2010. All documents submitted as well as application appears to
                             have been returned on 27.04.2009
                             SRC in its 194th meeting held on 21-22 July 2010 considered the matter
                             and directed the Management/institution to resubmit the old application
                             returned by SRC along with necessary documents as originally submitted
                             relating to land, building, FDR, Application fee, Building Completion
                             Certificate from competent Government Engineer/ authority and other
                             relevant aspects for processing and for necessary action.
                             As per direction of Regional Committee a letter was issued on
                             19.08.2010. In response to this office letter dated 30.08.2010 the
                             institution has submitted reply vide letter dated 03.09.2010.
                             As per perusal of the file the institution has submitted following
                             documents vide letters dated 03.09.10 :-
                             1. Processing fee and application fee (40,000+1,000= 41,000/-) Application fee
                                of Rs. 1,000/- submitted earlier too)
                             2. Land documents
                             3. BCC Certificate not in prescribed format from Panchyat Secretary
                             4. Land use Certificate by Tahsildar.
                             5. Approved Building Plan by panchyat Secretary
                             6. Original FDR of 5 lakhs and 3 lakhs not submitted.
                             7. Affidavit of Rs 100/- regarding land and building submitted in photocopy..
                             SRC in its 198th meeting held on 24th –26th November, 2010 considered
                             the written explanation to the notice and other documents submitted by
                             the institution and decided to cause inspection of the institution Under
                             Section 14/15 of NCTE Act.
                             Accordingly inspection of the institution was carried out on 22.01.2011

                             SRC in its 201st meeting held on 22nd-23rd February, 2011 considered the
                             VT Report, VCD and all the relevant documentary evidences and it was
                             decided to issue Show cause Notice Under Section 17 of NCTE Act.
                             Accordingly, Show cause notice was issued to the institution for seeking
                             clarification on 23.03.2011. The institution has submitted its written
                             representation on 18.04.2011.
                             Note: Essential data has been filled & submitted by the management
                             instead of by V.T Members.

                             The SRC considered, VT report, VCD, reply to the show cause notice
                             and all relevant documents and decided to issue Letter Of Intent for
                             grant of Formal Recognition to B.Ed course of one year duration
                             with an annual intake of 100(One hundred only)(one unit) for the
                             academic year 2011-12 subject to the appointment of qualified staff
                             through duly constituted selection committee as per the Norms of
                             NCTE/State Government/Affiliating University and be given effect
                             before the commencement of the academic session.


95.         APS09117         An application was submitted by Bhargavi Educational Society,
              D.Ed           Khammam, A.P for grant of recognition to D.Ed course in the office of

                                                     139


      (Gangadharaiah)                                                       (Prof. C. Thangamuthu)
      Regional Director, SRC, NCTE                                            Chairman, SRC, NCTE
                                                                                    th
                                                                     Minutes of 204 Meeting of SRC
                                                                                    th  th
                                                                                  27 -28 April 2011
  Bhargavi Educational   SRC-NCTE, Bangalore vide dated 19.11.2007. The consent letter was
   Society, Khammam      issued to the institution as per NCTE Regulation 2007 vide dated
           AP            26.09.2008 directing to give consent for inspection alongwith as self
                         attested copy of the completion certificate of building for which affidavit,
                         building plan and land documents were submitted. The Institution
                         submitted its reply consent letter dated 06.10.2008.

                         The file was under process and in the meanwhile, in view of the
                         recommendations of the State Government of Andhra Pradesh vide letter
                         dated 07.01.2009 not to further recognize/permit the institutions for
                         conducting B.Ed, D.Ed, Physical Education, Language Pandit course(s),
                         to this effect that application for B.Ed, D.Ed, Physical Education,
                         Language Pandit courses from the States of Andhra Pradesh will not be
                         considered for the academic session 2009-2010 and all such applications
                         shall be returned along with processing fees and documents.

                         The SRC in its 169th meeting held on 12-13th January, 2009 having
                         considered the letter dated 7.1.2009 of State Government of Andhra
                         Pradesh and decided to give effect to the decision of above decision of
                         State Government of Andhra Pradesh as such, with immediate effect.

                         Further, a letter dated 07.02.2009 forwarded by Principal Secretary of
                         Education requesting not to accord further recognition/permission to the
                         new colleges/private B.Ed , D.Ed, Physical Education, Language Pandit
                         in the state of Andhra Pradesh as the above colleges are exceeding in
                         numbers than required.

                         Meanwhile, a letter dated 17.03.2009 has been received from NCTE
                         Hqrs informing that the “ The recommendations of the Govt. of Andhra
                         Pradesh not to grant recognition/ permission in respect of other courses
                         like B.Ed , D.Ed and Physical Education courses have further been
                         considered in NCTE and it has been decided that no further
                         recognition/Permission to any institution in the state of Andhra Pradesh
                         be considered by SRC for the academic session 2009-10 for B.Ed , D.Ed
                         and physical Education Courses also”.

                         Further, the state Government vide its letter dated 20.03.2009 informed
                         that it has been decided not to recommend the name of this institution.

                         The letters dated 07.01.2009, 07.02.2009, 17.03.2009 and 20.03.2009
                         were considered by SRC in its 172nd meeting held on 25th-26th March
                         2009 and SRC decided to accept the recommendation of the State
                         Government of Andhra Pradesh, not to grant recognition to any of the
                         Teacher Training Institutions in the state of Andhra Pradesh for the year
                         2009-10 and decided to close the applications.

                         As per the decision of SRC the application was closed on 17.05.2009

                         The institution has approached to Hon‟ble High court of Andhra Pradesh
                         W.P.31046/2010 in W.P. No. 24265/2010 without making appeal to
                                                140


(Gangadharaiah)                                                        (Prof. C. Thangamuthu)
Regional Director, SRC, NCTE                                             Chairman, SRC, NCTE
                                                                                   th
                                                                    Minutes of 204 Meeting of SRC
                                                                                   th  th
                                                                                 27 -28 April 2011
                       appellate authority under section 18 of NCTE Act
                       The Hon‟ble High Court has passed an order on 29.09.2010 vide
                       W.P.M.P.No.31046 of 2010 in W.P. No. 24265/2010 as under:-

                         “In the light to consider the order passed by this court in the similar writ
                       petitions W.P.No. 6712/2009, W.P.no. 9360/2010 and W.P. no.
                       11078/2010 there shall be a direction to the first respondent to consider
                       the petitioner‟s application for starting D.Ed course in accordance with
                       law without reference to the state Govt‟s Policy dated 07.01.2009.”

                       The matter was placed in 197th meeting of SRC held on 13th – 14th ocy,
                       2010, wherein the SRC decided to Re-submit the application for
                       continuation. As per direction of SRC a letter was sent to the institution
                       on 19.10.10 with request to submit original form alongwith land use
                       certificate, BCC, Application fee, land documents and other relevant
                       documents.

                       The SRC considered the Hon‟ble court orders and all the relevant
                       documents and decided to take further action in the matter, subject to the
                       fulfillment of all the requirements by the institution as per the norms and
                       regulations.

                       The following deficiencies has been submitted by the institution on letter
                       dated 01.12.2010.
                       1. FDR of Rs 5.00 lakh submitted in original
                       2. FDR of Rs 3.00 lakh submitted in original
                       3. BCC in the prescribed proforma duly signed by the local civil
                          authority.
                       4. Further, the land use certificate Dt. 18.2.2009 is to be notarized.
                       5. Notarized English version copy of registered land document is to be
                          submitted.

                       SRC in its 199th meeting held on 22nd –23rd December, 2010 considered
                       the matter and all relevant documents and decided to cause inspection to
                       examine whether the institution fulfils all the requirements as per the
                       norms, for the proposed programme, subject to the condition that the
                       deficiencies, if any, were duly rectified by the institution, as per the
                       norms.

                       FDRs returned after the verification and attested English version of land
                       documents submitted with original Building Completion Certificate.

                       Accordingly inspection of the institution was carried out on VTR dated
                       10.02.2011
                       And Whereas SRC in its 201st meeting held on 22nd –23rd February, 2011
                       considered the VT Report, VCD and all the relevant documentary
                       evidences and it was decided to serve show cause Notice under
                       Section13 of NCTE Act Show Cause Notice was issued to the institution
                       for seeking clarification on 18.3.2011. The Institution has submitted reply
                       dated 19.4.2011 The brief summary of SCN is as under:-
                                               141


(Gangadharaiah)                                                       (Prof. C. Thangamuthu)
Regional Director, SRC, NCTE                                            Chairman, SRC, NCTE
                                                                                       th
                                                                        Minutes of 204 Meeting of SRC
                                                                                       th  th
                                                                                     27 -28 April 2011

                              The SRC considered, VT report, VCD, reply to the show cause notice
                              and all relevant documents and decided to issue Letter Of Intent for
                              grant of Formal Recognition to D.Ed course of one year duration
                              with an annual intake of 50(Fifty only)(one unit) for the academic
                              year 2011-12 subject to the appointment of qualified staff through
                              duly constituted selection committee as per the Norms of
                              NCTE/State Government/Affiliating University and be given effect
                              before the commencement of the academic session.


96.         APS04925          Thozhilathibar Teacher Training Institute, Edamalaipattipudur,
               D.T.Ed         Trichy Dt. TN.
           Thozhilathibar
         Teacher Training     Thozhilathibar Teacher Training Institute was granted recognition on
          Institute, Trichy   07.09.2006 for D.T.Ed course and for D.T.Ed-AI on 16.01.2008.
                 TN
                              On the basis of Direction of MHRD to re-inspect all the institutions
                              granted recognition by SRC in its 116th meeting as per the
                              recommendation of Sri. Sathyam Committee reports. The inspection of
                              the institution under section 17 was carried out on 18.12.2008. Whereas,
                              the institution has approached the Hon‟ble Court in WP.29977/2008. The
                              matter was considered by SRC in its 170th meeting held on 16-17th
                              February 2009 and decided to issue show cause notice, accordingly a
                              show cause notice u/s 17. Accordingly a show cause notice was issued
                              to the institution on 4.4.2009. The institution submitted its reply on
                              15.4.2009, the same was considered by SRC in its 180th meeting held on
                              29th July 2009 and SRC decided to issue notice under section 17.
                              Accordingly a show cause notice was issued to the institution on
                              01.09.2009. The institution submitted its reply on 26.10.09.

                              SRC considered the written representation submitted by the institution
                              and decided to continue the approval given to Thozhilathibar Teacher
                              Training Institute (D.T.Ed, APS04925) and withdraw the recognition for of
                              D.T.Ed.(APS08186) course for which the land/buildings/infrastructure are
                              not available as per the norms, as inferred from the reply statements
                              furnished by the institution.

                              As per the decision of SRC, a letter of continued recognition in
                              respect of Thozhilathibar TTI, Trichy District, Tamilnadu was issued
                              to the institution for D.T.Ed course on 9.2.2010(APS04925) and
                              withdrawal order was issued to the above mentioned institution on
                              9.2.2010 for D.T.Ed course.

                              Meanwhile, a complaint dated 09.09.2010 was received from Hope
                              Foundation, which was considered by SRC in its 196th meeting held on
                              15th and 16th September, 2010. The committee considered the matter and
                              decided to inform the complainant that he is free to seek legal remedy as

                                                    142


      (Gangadharaiah)                                                     (Prof. C. Thangamuthu)
      Regional Director, SRC, NCTE                                          Chairman, SRC, NCTE
                                                                                 th
                                                                  Minutes of 204 Meeting of SRC
                                                                                 th  th
                                                                               27 -28 April 2011
                       it is a civil dispute.

                       Meantime, the legal notices dated 25.10.2010 and 18.1.2011 was
                       considered by SRC in its 200th meeting held on 20th and 21st January,
                       2011. The Committee considered the legal notices and all the relevant
                       documentary evidences and it was decided to serve Show cause Notice
                       Under Section 17 of NCTE Act for the following :

                        The management has to submit all the original documents and land
                         lease Deed agreement documents of the institution, along with the
                         remarks on the contents of legal notice issued on behalf of the one
                         M.T.Karunanidhi who claims to be the lessor, that the present land
                         where the building is situated at Door No. 43, Rajiv Gandhinagar,
                         Ekamalaipudur, Trichy-12, Tamilnadu, was partly leased to the above
                         institution. The lease agreement was allegedly cancelled on 30.1.2007.
                         Now the management has to file an affidavit on the authenticity of the
                         above facts and submit the original records for verification.

                        Specific remarks on the allegation that the management/trust had
                         concealed and suppressed the fact of cancellation of lease deed and
                         thereby misled and violated NCTE norms and Regulations, to be
                         submitted in the affidavit.

                        The SRC denies and takes strong exception to the mischievous,
                         unfounded and false allegations against NCTE SRC, made out in the
                         legal notice issued on behalf of one M.T. Karunanidhi said to be the
                         lessor of the said land; that the information on the said cancellation of
                         the lease deed said to have taken place as early as 30-01.2007, took
                         more than four years to reach the SRC NCTE is ununderstandable.

                        Any Civil/Criminal dispute arising out of lessor and lessee deal may
                         have to be resolved by a Court of Law and the litigant is free to
                         proceed legally in the matter; and any attempt to involve the regulatory
                         authority in the issue and discredit the same is unwarranted.

                       In the meantime, one more legal notice dated 12.2.2011 was received on
                       15.2.2011 from Shri. A. Kumar, Advocate which was placed before SRC
                       in its 201st meeting held on 22nd and 23rd February, 2011 and the
                       Committee decided as follows;-

                       “To take appropriate legal action against the complainant for indulgence
                       in sinister campaign and casting aspersions on the NCTE, by making
                       false and malicious allegations.

                       To call for remarks of the institution on the specific allegation that the
                       institution had submitted some forged documents to the SRC.

                       To cause a composite inspection of the teacher education institutions of
                       the above management , on receipt of the remarks and all the related
                                                143


(Gangadharaiah)                                                     (Prof. C. Thangamuthu)
Regional Director, SRC, NCTE                                          Chairman, SRC, NCTE
                                                                                              th
                                                                             Minutes of 204 Meeting of SRC
                                                                                            th  th
                                                                                          27 -28 April 2011
                             documents and filled in questionnaire and the requisite inspection fee
                             from the institution”.

                             As per the decision of SRC, letter was issued to the institution on
                             7.3.2011 and a letter was issued to Advocate Counsel on 07.03.2011 to
                             take legal action.

                             In response to this office letter dated 7.3.2011 and a letter to the
                             institution as per the SRC‟s decision of 201st meeting, the institution has
                             submitted reply on 18.4.2011 stated that a case is pending in the court of
                             the District Municif Trichirapalli in O.S. No. 1359 of 2010 and I.A. No. 567
                             of 2010 regarding the right of possession of the building and land by the
                             Management and other party.

                             The institution has not submitted D.D. of Rs. 40,000/- as an inspection
                             along with essential documents as per the letter dated 7.3.2011. Instead
                             the institution has submitted a copy of court of the District Munisif of
                             Trichirapally is as follows;

                             The prayed that “this Hon‟ble court may be pleased to grant temporary
                             injunction retraining the defendant, his men, agents, servants, and any
                             persons claiming under him from in any way interfering with the
                             petitioner‟s peaceful possession and enjoyment of the suit property either
                             by dispossess upon or otherwise in any manner whatsoever except
                             under due process of law till the disposal of the suit and also pass an
                             interim exparte injunction till the disposal of application and thus render
                             justice”.

                             It appears that the place where institution is being run is the property
                             right/dispute to which is under dispute. It also appears that interim
                             injunction is given to the institution to run the institution. If the institution is
                             running there inspection as directed by SRC can be carried out.

                             The committee considered the written reply and other relevant
                             documents and decided to cause composite inspection at the
                             premises in anticipation of inspection fee of Rs. 40000/- per course,
                             as originally decided and as the Court Order is not against the NCTE
                             inspection Under Section 17 of NCTE Act.
97.         APS04653         Pachamuthu College of Education, Dharmapuri District,
               B.Ed          Tamilnadu
        Pachamuthu College
           of Education,     Pachamuthu College of Education, Dharmapuri submitted an
            Dharmapuri
                             application for seeking grant of recognition for B.Ed course on
                TN
                             21.12.2005.

                             The application was processed and finally recognition order to was
                             issued to the institution on 06.10.2006 at Pachumuthu College of
                             Education, No.26-C, Salem Main Road, Virupatchipuram Village,
                                                      144


      (Gangadharaiah)                                                           (Prof. C. Thangamuthu)
      Regional Director, SRC, NCTE                                                Chairman, SRC, NCTE
                                                                                          th
                                                                          Minutes of 204 Meeting of SRC
                                                                                         th  th
                                                                                       27 -28 April 2011
                              Dharmapuri-636705, Tamilnadu with the condition to shift to own
                              premises within 3 years.

                              SRC in its 181st meeting held on 20th-21st August 2009 wherein, it was
                              decided that the institution which have not shifted to the permanent
                              premises even after the expiry of three years time limit be issued notice
                              under Section 17 of NCTE Act for further action. Accordingly a notice has
                              been issued to the institution on 03.09.2009. The institution vide its letter
                              dated 28.10.2009 submitted Rs.40000, for shifting to new premises.

                              The inspection was carried out on 21.10.2010. The Committee in its 198th
                              meeting held on 24th-26th November 2010 considered the VT Report,
                              VCD and all the relevant documentary evidences and it was decided to
                              serve Show cause Notice Under Section 17 of NCTE Act. Accordingly,
                              notice was issued to the institution on 04.01.2011. The institution
                              submitted its reply on 25.01.2011.

                              The Committee in its 201st meeting held on 22nd-23rd February 2011
                              considered the reply to Show Cause Notice, VT Report, VCD and all the
                              relevant documentary evidences and it was decided to serve Final Show
                              cause Notice Under Section 17 of NCTE Act. Accordingly final show
                              cause notice was issued to the institution on 22.03.2011. The institution
                              submitted its reply on 18.04.2011.

                              The committee has taken note of the request for extension of time of
                              the management vide letter dt. 18.04.2011, for submission of fresh
                              VCD & approval staff list which was sent to the Registrar, Tamilnadu
                              Teachers Education University, Chennai, and decided to grant four
                              weeks time for submission.


98.        APS04658           Pachamuthu      Teacher      Training   Institute,   Dharmapuri     District,
             D.T.Ed           Tamilnadu
       Pachamuthu Teacher
        Training Institute,   Pachamuthu Teacher Training Institute, Dharmapuri submitted an
           Dharmapuri         application for seeking grant of recognition for D.T.Ed course on
               TN             15.02.2005.

                              The application was processed and finally recognition order was
                              issued to the institution on 24.10.2006 at Pachumuthu Teacher
                              Training Institute, Salem Main Road, Virupatchipuram Village,
                              Dharmapuri-636705, Tamilnadu with the condition to shift to own
                              premises within 3 years.

                              SRC in its 181st meeting held on 20th-21st August 2009 wherein, it was
                              decided that the institution which have not shifted to the permanent
                              premises even after the expiry of three years time limit be issued notice
                              under Section 17 of NCTE Act for further action. Accordingly a notice has
                              been issued to the institution on 11.09.2009. The institution vide letter
                                                     145


      (Gangadharaiah)                                                       (Prof. C. Thangamuthu)
      Regional Director, SRC, NCTE                                            Chairman, SRC, NCTE
                                                                                                th
                                                                               Minutes of 204 Meeting of SRC
                                                                                              th  th
                                                                                            27 -28 April 2011
                                dated 01.10.2009 submitted Rs.40000/- towards shifting fee.

                                The inspection of the institution for shifting of premises was carried out
                                on 20.10.2010. The Committee in its 198th meeting held on 24th-26th
                                November 2010 considered the VT Report, VCD and all the relevant
                                documentary evidences and it was decided to serve Show cause Notice
                                Under Section 17 of NCTE Act Accordingly, notice was issued to the
                                institution on 05.01.2011. The institution submitted its reply on
                                25.01.2011.

                                The Committee in its 201st meeting held on 22nd-23rd February 2011
                                considered the reply to Show Cause Notice, VT Report, VCD and all the
                                relevant documentary evidences and it was decided to serve Final Show
                                cause Notice Under Section 17 of NCTE Act. Accordingly final show
                                cause notice was issued to the institution on 21.03.2011. The institution
                                submitted its reply on 18.04.201.


                                The committee has taken note of the request for extension of time of
                                the management vide letter dt. 18.04.2011, for submission of fresh
                                VCD & approval staff list which was sent to the Registrar, Tamilnadu
                                Teachers Education University, Chennai, and decided to grant four
                                weeks time for submission.

99.          APS04710           All Saints College of Education, Kanyakumari, Tamilnadu
                B.Ed
        All Saints College of   All Saints College of Education, Kanyakumari, Tamilnadu was granted
             Education,         recognition for offering B.Ed course with an intake of 100 students on
            Kanyakumari         05.09.2006 with the condition to shift to own premises within 3 years.
                 TN
                                The Ministry of Human Resource Development (MHRD), Government of India,
                                based on the inquiry report submitted by Sri. Sathyam, IAS (Retd) has directed
                                NCTE for taking action. In this regard, it has been envisaged that all the cases
                                                          th
                                cleared by SRC in its 116 meeting held on 22-23 August 2006 should be re-
                                inspected and the maintenance of Norms and Standards should be verified.

                                The above institution was one amongst 71 institutions which was granted
                                                       th                         rd
                                recognition in the 116 meeting held on 22-23 August 2006. Based on the
                                directions of MHRD, inspection under section 17 of the above institution was
                                carried out on 18.12.2008. The VT report, VCD, original application file along
                                                                                          th
                                with other documents were placed before SRC in its 170 meeting held on 16-17
                                February 2009. SRC decided to issue notice under section 17 of NCTE Act, for
                                the deficiencies noted. Accordingly, notice was issued to the institution on
                                02.04.2009. The institution submitted its reply on 15.04.2009.
                                               th
                                SRC in its 178 meeting held on 13-14 July 2009 considered the reply wherein
                                SRC noted that the second floor of the building is completed after inspection.
                                The Committee decided to cause inspection to verify the built up space available
                                after completion of building after payment of Rs.40000/- for inspection fees.
                                Accordingly, a letter was issued to the institution on 25.08.2009. The institution
                                has not submitted the required fee and documents.

                                                         146


      (Gangadharaiah)                                                            (Prof. C. Thangamuthu)
      Regional Director, SRC, NCTE                                                 Chairman, SRC, NCTE
                                                                                            th
                                                                              Minutes of 204 Meeting of SRC
                                                                                              th  th
                                                                                           27 -28 April 2011
                                              st                       st
                             SRC in its 181 meeting held on 20-21 August 2009 where in it was decided
                             that the institution which have not shifted to the permanent premises even after
                             the expiry of three years time limit be issued notice under section 17 of NCTE
                             Act for further action. But the notice was not issued then. Hence the matter was
                                                                                                            st
                             brought to the notice. As directed on 15.07.2010, a notice as decided in 181
                             SRC meeting was issued on 23.7.2010. The institution has submitted its reply on
                             12.08.2010.
                                                                                      th                    th
                             The matter was considered by the Committee in its 195 meeting held on 17 -
                                th
                             18 August 2010 and it was decided to cause inspection of the institution for
                             B.Ed. Course, under Section 17 of NCTE Act, after payment of Rs.40,000/-
                             inspection fee and on submission of filled in Questionnaire, along with relevant
                             supporting documents relating to building, land, including Building Completion
                             Certificate from the competent Government Engineer and Land Use Certificate,
                             within four weeks from the date of confirmation of the Minutes.

                             A letter has been issued to the institution to submit the above documents on
                             22.09.2010. The institution submitted the documents with the VT members but
                             not submitted Rs.40000/-.The inspection of the institution was conducted on
                                                                        th                      th  th
                             23.10.2010. The Committee in its 198 meeting held on 24 -26 November
                             2010 considered the VT Report, VCD and all the relevant documentary
                             evidences and it was decided to serve Show cause Notice Under Section 17 of
                             NCTE Act for the following deficiencies. Accordingly a notice was issued to the
                             institution on 11.01.2011. The institution submitted its reply on 10.02.2011.

                             The Committee in its 201st meeting held on 22nd-23rd February 2011
                             considered the reply to Show Cause Notice, VT Report, VCD and all the
                             relevant documentary evidences and it was decided to serve Final Show
                             cause Notice Under Section 17 of NCTE Act. Accordingly final show
                             cause notice was issued to the institution on 22.03.2011. The institution
                             submitted its reply on 18.04.2011.


                             The committee has taken note of the request for extension of time of
                             the management vide letter dt. 18.04.2011, for submission of fresh
                             VCD & approval staff list which was sent to the Registrar, Tamilnadu
                             Teachers Education University, Chennai, and decided to grant four
                             weeks time for submission.

100.      APS01360           Crescent Teacher Training Institute, Madurai District,
            D.T.Ed           Tamilnadu
       Crescent Teacher
       Training Institute,   All India Islamic Foundation Trust, Madurai submitted an application in the name
                             and style of Crescent Teacher Training Institute, Madurai District, Tamilnadu for
            Madurai
                             seeking grant of recognition for D.T.Ed course on 28.08.2002.
              TN
                             The application was processed and the inspection of the institution was carried
                             out on 21.08.2004. Recognition order was issued to the institution on 12.01.2005
                             at Crescent Teacher Training Institute, Seethakathi Nagar, Kallampatti, Natham-
                             Alagar Koil Link Road, Chathrapatti Post, Madurai-625014, Tamilnadu with the
                             condition to shift to own premises within 3 years.

                             The institution vide its letter dated 24.09.2007 submitted Rs.40000/- for change
                                                     147


   (Gangadharaiah)                                                            (Prof. C. Thangamuthu)
   Regional Director, SRC, NCTE                                                 Chairman, SRC, NCTE
                                                                                          th
                                                                           Minutes of 204 Meeting of SRC
                                                                                             th  th
                                                                                          27 -28 April 2011
                               of address at Crescent Teacher Training Institute, Seethakathi Nagar,
                               Kallampatti, Natham-Alagar Koil Link Road, Chathrapatti Post, Madurai-625014,
                               Tamilnadu.
                                                                                th   th
                               Inspection of the institution was fixed between 8 -12 February 2011 and
                               the same was intimated to the institution on 31.01.2011. Accordingly
                               inspection of the institution for shifting of premises was conducted on
                               08.02.2011. The Committee in its 201st meeting held on 22nd-23rd
                               February 2011 considered the VT Report, VCD and all the relevant
                               documentary evidences and it was decided to serve Show cause Notice
                               Under Section 17 of NCTE Act. Accordingly final show cause notice was
                               issued to the institution on 22.03.2011. The institution submitted its reply
                               on 18.04.2011.

                               The Committee considered the VT Report, VCD and all the relevant
                               documentary evidences and it was decided to serve Final Show
                               cause Notice under Section 17 of NCTE Act for the following:

                                Building completion certificate from the Competent Govt Engineer
                                 is to be submitted.


                                In view of the above, the Committee decided to issue a Final Show
                               cause Notice to the institution as to why the recognition be not
                               withdrawn and thereby providing an opportunity to the institution to
                               make a written representation within 30 days from the date of issue
                               of the Notice along with necessary certificates/documents in order
                               to take a final decision in the matter; failing which action will be
                               taken including the withdrawal of recognition, based on the records
                               available, with no further notice.


101.         APS05688          Sri Mahalakshmi Teacher Training Institute, Coimbatore
               D.T.Ed          District, Tamilnadu
         Sri Mahalakshmi
         Teacher Training
       Institute, Coimbatore   Sri Mahalakshmi Educational Trust, Coimbatore submitted an application
                  TN           in the name and style of Sri Mahalakshmi Teacher Training Institute for
                               seeking grant of recognition for D.T.Ed course on 02.01.2006.

                               The application was processed and recognition order was issued to the
                               institution on 13.11.2006 at Sri Mahalakshmi Teacher Training Institute
                               for Women, No.3/302, Mangalam, Palladam, Tirupur Taluk, Coimbatore,
                               Tamilnadu with the condition to shift to own premises within 3 years.

                               The institution vide letter dated 15.07.2008 submitted for a proposal for
                               shifting to new premises alongwith Rs.40000/-. A letter was issued to the
                               institution on 12.06.2009 calling for documents to examine the proposal
                               for shifting of premises. The inspection of the institution was carried out

                                                      148


   (Gangadharaiah)                                                           (Prof. C. Thangamuthu)
   Regional Director, SRC, NCTE                                                Chairman, SRC, NCTE
                                                                                            th
                                                                           Minutes of 204 Meeting of SRC
                                                                                          th  th
                                                                                        27 -28 April 2011
                         on 14.11.2010. The Committee in its 198th meeting held on 24th-26th
                         November 2010 considered the VT Report and all the relevant
                         documentary evidences and it was decided to serve Show cause Notice
                         Under Section 17 of NCTE Act. Accordingly, notice was issued to the
                         institution on 05.01.2011. The institution submitted its reply on
                         04.02.2011.
                         The Committee considered in its 201st meeting held on 22nd-23rd February
                         2011 the reply to Show Cause Notice, VT Report, VCD and all the
                         relevant documentary evidences and it was decided to serve Final Show
                         cause Notice Under Section 17 of NCTE Act. Accordingly final show
                         cause notice was issued to the institution on 22.03.2011.

                         The deficienciy was as under:
                         The management in their application dt. 02.01.2006 has mentioned the address
                         as “Sri. Mahalakshmi Educational Trust” for grant of recognition. But in the land
                         documents, it has changed the trust name as Sri. Alagammal charitable Aid
                         Mission, without the approval of NCTE, Bangalore.

                         The institution submitted its reply on 18.04.2011.

                         The institution in its reply requested for permission for the change of Trust name
                         “Sri Mahalakshmi Educational Trust” into Sri Azhagammai Charitable Aid
                         Mission” in the new premises.

                         The following reasons may be considered for giving permission for the change of
                         Trust name:
                          First we applied for recognition to run D.T.Ed course in the name & style of
                             “Sri Mahalakshmi Educational Trust” on 02.01.2006.. The recognition was
                             issued on 13.11.2006 by NCTE. At that the institute was a run in a rented
                             building at 3/302. Mangalam, Palladam, Tirupur (Taluk), Coimbatore Dist. On
                             15.07.2008 a proposal for shifting the institute to the new premises along
                             with a D.D for Rs.40000 was submitted. Sri Azhagammai is the name of our
                             family deity. Very often we used to pray her. Usually our fore fathers named
                             their children as “Azhagammai”. My mother in law‟s name is also
                             “Azhagammai”. She is my family member. We love respect and adore her so
                             we named the new trust as “Sri Azhagammai charitable aid mission trust” in
                             memory of Sri Azhagammai Charitable Aid Mission. Due to our
                             psychological and sentimental feeling we named the new trust as “Sri
                             Azhagammai Charitable Aid Mission”. Before the visit the visiting team we
                             registered the new trust “Sri Azhagammai Charitable Aid Mission” on
                             26.02.2010 and created a settlement gift deed in the name of the trust on
                             28.4.2010. The land documents, Building Plan, encumbrance certificate,
                             certificate registration of trust, bye-laws of the trust, building license copy are
                             in the name of “Sri Azhagammai charitable aid mission”.

                         The institution also stated as follows:

                    1.     There is no change in the name and address of the managing
                       trustee/chairman/the author of the trust. In both the trusts the address of
                       the managing trustee has been mentioned as 4/659, Karupparayar Kovil
                       layout, Pollikalipalayam, Dharapuram road, Tirupur.
                    2.     There is no change in the name and addresses of the Trustees and
                       except Mr.B.S. Lakshmanappa, S/O H. Sanjeevappa, Saujivi Nilayam,
                                                   149


(Gangadharaiah)                                                               (Prof. C. Thangamuthu)
Regional Director, SRC, NCTE                                                    Chairman, SRC, NCTE
                                                                                       th
                                                                        Minutes of 204 Meeting of SRC
                                                                                       th  th
                                                                                     27 -28 April 2011
                             B.S2 Nagar, Bangalore-560094 joint managing trustee of “Sri
                             Mahalakshmi            Educational         Trust”.        Died          on
                             06.04.2006, after Mr. B.S. Lakshmanappa‟s death Mrs. C. Jenova
                             Suganthi, Chandra appalous, 4/659, Karupparayar Kovil Layout,
                             Pollikalipalayam, Dharapuram Road, Tirupur has been included in the
                             “Sri Azhagammai Charitable Aid Mission” as a trustee except this no
                             other change has been made in the Trustees name list in both the trusts.
                             Death certificate of B.S. Lakshmanappa has been enclosed for your
                             perusal. Trustees from 1 to 6 belongs to the same family. Hence I
                             request you to consider and grant permission for change of ”Sri
                             Mahalakshmi Educational Trust” into “Sri Azhagammai Charitable Aid
                             Mission Trust
                          3.      We have not changed the name and style of the institute. Still we are
                             maintaining the same name “Sri Mahalakshmi Teacher Training Institute”
                             for our institute. Hence I request you to consider the above reasons and
                             grant permission for change of name as “Sri Azhagammai Charitable Aid
                             Mission” to run “Sri Mahalakshmi Teacher Training Institute.

                             The committee considered the matter and decided that change of
                             name of the Trust from “Sri Mahalakshmi Educational Trust”
                             Coimbatore to “Sri Azhagammai Charitable Aid Mission”
                             Coimbatore is permitted subject to payment of Rs. 40000 fee and
                             subject to no change in the location of the institution and
                             Nature/Structure of the management and other usual conditions.

102.     APS03280            Ruben College of Education, Kanyakumari District, Tamilnadu
            B.Ed
       Ruben College of      SRC-NCTE granted recognition to Ruben College of Education,
         Education,          Kanyakumari District, Tamilnadu for B.Ed course vide order no.
        Kanyakumari          F.TN.SEC/SRO/NCTE/2005-2006/1591 dated 7.7.2005 with an intake of
             TN              100 students from the academic session 2005-06.

                             NCTE-Hqrs. has forwarded W.P. No. 910 of 2006 filed by Shri. R. Jenson
                             Muthraj against Ruben College of Education, Kanyakumari District,
                             Tamilnadu. In the writ petition the petitioner alleged that the institution
                             claims to own 4 acres 95 cents of land in the same location, a school
                             having class 1 to XII is running. In response to the above letter, it has
                             been informed to NCTE-Hqrs. vide our letter dated 3.1.2007 that surprise
                             inspection will be conducted and the report will be placed. But, no such
                             inspection has been conducted and no further action has been taken.

                             A requisition letter has been received from the institution on 26.7.2010,
                             stated that they have started running the institution during the academic
                             year 2005-2006 in accordance to the reference. As per the prevailing
                             norms that in that period an extent of 5 acres of land was desirable for
                             4000 sq.mt of land, and requested to issue the permission, that the
                             excess land may be utilized for starting an other institution.

                             The matter was considered by the Committee in its 195th meeting held on
                             17th-18th August 2010 and it was decided to cause inspection of the
                                                    150


   (Gangadharaiah)                                                        (Prof. C. Thangamuthu)
   Regional Director, SRC, NCTE                                             Chairman, SRC, NCTE
                                                                                    th
                                                                     Minutes of 204 Meeting of SRC
                                                                                    th  th
                                                                                  27 -28 April 2011
                           institution for B.Ed. Course, under Section 17 of NCTE Act, after payment
                           of Rs. 40,000/- inspection fee and on submission of filled in
                           Questionnaire, along with relevant supporting documents relating to
                           building, land, including Building Completion Certificate from the
                           competent Government Engineer and Land Use Certificate, within four
                           weeks from the date of confirmation of the Minutes.

                           A letter has been issued to the institution on 22.09.2010 to submit the
                           D.D. of Rs.40000/- alongwith essential documents. The institution
                           submitted its reply on 18.10.2010 alongwith Rs.40000/-. The inspection
                           of the institution was carried out on 22.10.2010. The Committee in its
                           198th meeting held on 24th-26th November 2010 considered the VT
                           Report, VCD and all the relevant documentary evidences and it was
                           decided to serve Show cause Notice Under Section 17

                           Accordingly a notice was issued to the institution on 11.01.2011.
                           Meanwhile, a complaint has been received from DTERT, Chennai on
                           13.01.2011 regarding faculty members working in the Ruben Teacher
                           Training Institute who were also working in the Ruben B.Ed College.
                           SRC in its 200th meeting held on 20-21 January 2011 considered the
                           DTERT report and decided to issue notice. Notice could not be issued
                           and the same was placed before SRC along with the written
                           representation for notice submitted by the institution on 08.02.2011.

                           The Committee considered the reply to Show Cause Notice, Complaint of
                           DTERT, Chennai, VT Report, VCD and all the rlevant documentary
                           evidences and it was decided to serve Final Show cause Notice Under
                           Section 17 of NCTE Act. Accordingly final show cause notice was issued
                           to the institution on 21.03.2011. The institution submitted its reply on
                           19.04.2011.

                           The committee has taken note of the request for extension of time of
                           the management vide letter dt. 19.04.2011, for submission of
                           certificate from the Govt. affiliating body to the effect that no other
                           programme is being conducted by the institution in the same
                           building alongwith the existing course and decided to grant four
                           weeks time for submission.


103.      APS04399         Nandha College of Education, Erode District, Tamilnadu
            B.Ed
       Nandha College of   Nandha College of Education, 29/4, Koorapalayam, Pirivu,
       Education, Erode    Pituchandampalayam Post, Erode-638052, Tamilnadu has been granted
             TN            recognition for B.Ed Course of one year duration with an annual intake of
                           100 students on 31.08.2006.

                           As per the direction of Ministry of Human Resource Development
                           (MHRD), as per recommendation of Sri. Sathyam Committee reports on
                           all the institution, which were granted recognition by SRC in its 116th

                                                 151


   (Gangadharaiah)                                                     (Prof. C. Thangamuthu)
   Regional Director, SRC, NCTE                                          Chairman, SRC, NCTE
                                                                                   th
                                                                    Minutes of 204 Meeting of SRC
                                                                                   th  th
                                                                                 27 -28 April 2011
                       meeting. The re-inspection for B.Ed course of the institution was carried
                       out on 18.12.2008.

                       The visiting team report was placed before SRC in its 170th meeting held
                       on 16-17th February 2009 and SRC decided to issue show cause notice
                       under section 17 of NCTE Act, accordingly a show cause notice was
                       issued to the institution on 02.04.2009.

                       The institution did not submit its reply even after completion of stipulated
                       period. The matter was considered by SRC in its 191st meeting held 20-
                       21st April 2010 and it was decided to issue final notice to the institution to
                       submit the reply within 21 days. Accordingly, final Notice was issued on
                       1.6.2010. The office did not receive any reply from the institution thus far.
                       Hence, the Committee considered the matter in its 194th meeting held on
                       21st-22nd July 2010 and decided to withdraw recognition

                       Accordingly withdrawal of recognition order was issued to the institution
                       on 20.8.2010. Aggrieved by the withdrawal of SRC, the institution filed
                       court case in W.P. no. 18549 of 2010. The court has orders as follows:

                       “The Learned Counsel appearing for the respondent has produced an
                       order dated 20.8.2010 withdrawing recognition granted to the petitioner to
                       conduct B.Ed course. While the decision of the 194th meeting of the
                       respondent was relating to other institutions also, the order dated
                       20.8.2010 is relating to the petitioner alone. The order nowhere considers
                       the representation given by the petitioner in reply to the show cause
                       notice dated 1.6.2010. Hence, the impugned order was passed in
                       violation of principles of natural justice. Hence, the impugned order is
                       quashed and the respondent is directed to consider and pass a fresh
                       order after considering the explanation given by the petitioner referred to
                       above within a period of eight weeks from the date of receipt of copy of
                       this order”.

                       The court order was placed before SRC in its 196th meeting held on 15th
                       and 16th September, 2010. SRC considered the matter and decided to
                       await for the documentary evidence and clarifications from the institution.
                       Further, SRC has decided that on receipt of the necessary documents
                       the application be processed as per the usual procedure.

                       In response to the decision of SRC, the reply for final notice submitted by
                       the institution vide their letter dated 18.6.2010 was scrutinized. The
                       Committee in its 198th meeting held on 24th-26th November 2010
                       considered the written reply of the institution dt. 18.6.2010 and all the
                       relevant documentary evidences and it was decided to serve Show cause
                       Notice under Section 17 of NCTE Act for the following. Accordingly,
                       notice was issued to the institution on 05.01.2011. The institution
                       submitted its reply on 27.01.2011 and 01.02.2011.

                       The Committee in its 201st meeting held on 22nd-23rd February 2011
                       considered the reply to Show Cause Notice, VT Report, VCD and all the
                                               152


(Gangadharaiah)                                                       (Prof. C. Thangamuthu)
Regional Director, SRC, NCTE                                            Chairman, SRC, NCTE
                                                                                     th
                                                                      Minutes of 204 Meeting of SRC
                                                                                     th  th
                                                                                   27 -28 April 2011
                           relevant documentary evidences and it was decided to serve Final Show
                           cause Notice Under Section 17 of NCTE Act for the following.
                           Accordingly, a notice was issued to the institution on 21.03.2011. The
                           institution submitted its reply on 11.04.2011.

                           The Committee considered the VT report of the institution, other
                           related documents and clarification received from the institution
                           vide letter dt. 11.04.2011, along with the original file of the institution
                           and decided to continue recognition accorded to the institution.
                           The University be informed of the decision taken in this regard.


104.     APS00929          The Gandhigram Rural Institution- Deemed University, Gandhigram-
             B.Ed          624302, Dindigul District, Tamilnadu.
       The Gandhigram
       Rural University,   The Gandhigram Rural Institution- Deemed University, Gandhigram-
           Dindigul        624302, Dindigul District, Tamilnadu was granted recognition for B.Ed-
              TN           Integrated course on 11.11.2003.

                           The university submitted an application for seeking grant of recognition
                           for B.Ed-AI(Integrated Course) on 26.6.2008. Accordingly inspection of
                           the university for B.Ed-AI(Integrated Course) was conducted on
                           09.10.2010. The Committee in its 197th meeting held on 13th-14th October
                           2010 considered the VT Report, VCD and all the relevant documentary
                           evidences and it was decided to serve Show cause Notice Under Section
                           17 of NCTE Act. Accordingly show cause notice was issued to the
                           university on 10.12.2010. The university submitted its reply on
                           07.01.2011

                           The committee in its 200th meeting held on 20th-21st January, 2011, after
                           perusal of the original file of the institution and request of the
                           management for grant of recognition to B.Ed–Al (additional intake -50
                           intake), and all the relevant data including the reply to the show cause
                           notice, has decided to refuse additional intake of students to B.Ed-Al.
                           Further, the committee decided to issue Show Cause Notice for the
                           existing course based on the written reply submitted by the institution
                           vide its letter dt. 07.01.2011. Accordingly, a notice was issued to the
                           institution on 03.03.2011. the institution submitted its reply on
                           05.04.2011.

                           The Committee considered the reply of the institution to the earlier
                           show cause notice, VT Report, VCD and all the relevant
                           documentary evidences and it was decided to serve Final Show
                           cause Notice under Section 17 of NCTE Act for the following:

                            The institution is running the B.Ed-Intergrated course in a building
                             which is partly roofed with asbestos sheets, which is against the
                             NCTE norms.

                                                  153


   (Gangadharaiah)                                                      (Prof. C. Thangamuthu)
   Regional Director, SRC, NCTE                                           Chairman, SRC, NCTE
                                                                                            th
                                                                            Minutes of 204 Meeting of SRC
                                                                                           th  th
                                                                                         27 -28 April 2011
                              The University has not submitted the Marks sheets of lecturers to
                               ascertain the qualification, and the specific documents including
                               appointment orders in support of the regular appointment of
                               permanent faculty, as per the norms of NCTE.

                              In the Affidavit submitted the survey nos of the land and plot nos
                              of the building/land are not mentioned.

                              The infrastructural and institutional facilities are not adequate to
                               run B.Ed integrated course.

                              From the reply, it is found that the institution has not taken steps
                               for appointment of regular faculty and for provision of buildings
                               with RCC roof and other requisite infrastructure as per the norms
                               of NCTE.

                              In view of the above, the Committee decided to issue a Final Show
                             cause Notice to the institution as to why the recognition be not
                             withdrawn and thereby providing an opportunity to the institution to
                             make a written representation within 30 days from the date of issue
                             of the Notice along with necessary certificates/documents in order
                             to take a final decision in the matter; failing which action will be
                             taken including the withdrawal of recognition, based on the records
                             available, with no further notice.

105.      APS01106           AVMR Teacher Training Institute, Coimbatore District, Tamilnadu
            D.T.Ed
        AVMR Teacher         AVM Foundation, Coimbatore submitted an application in the name and style of
       Training Institute,   AVMR Teacher Training Institute for seeking grant of recognition for D.T.Ed
          Coimbatore         course on 31.12.2002.
              TN
                             The application was processed and recognition order was issued to the
                             institution on 20.01.2005 at AVMR Teacher Training Institute, S.F.No.383/1,
                             Near Codissa Fair Grounds, Peelamedu, Coimbatore-641004, Tamilnadu with
                             the condition to shift to own premises within 3 years.


                             The State Govt. has informed that same institutions are not maintaining norms
                             and standards as prescribed by NCTE and deficiencies of individual institutions
                                                                                   th
                             were also submitted to this office. The SRC in its 157 meeting held on 23-24
                             April, 2008 considered the complaint and decided to issue Notice to these
                             institutions under Section 17 of NCTE Act, 1993. Accordingly, Notice was issued
                             on 17.6.2008. In reply the institution submitted written representation on
                             14.07.2008.
                                                                              th                            th
                             The written representation was placed before 166 meeting of SRC held on 18 -
                                th
                             19 October, 2008 and SRC decided to cause inspection under Section 17 of
                             NCTE Act, to verify the veracity of the compliance as claimed by the institution
                             and also the structural modifications / improvement / shifting to new building as
                             claimed, on payment of re-inspection fee of Rs.40000/- by the institution.

                             A letter was issued to the institution on 27.10.2008. The institution vide letter
                                                     154


   (Gangadharaiah)                                                            (Prof. C. Thangamuthu)
   Regional Director, SRC, NCTE                                                 Chairman, SRC, NCTE
                                                                                            th
                                                                           Minutes of 204 Meeting of SRC
                                                                                              th  th
                                                                                           27 -28 April 2011
                             dated 01.03.2010 submitted for a proposal for shifting to new premises alongwith
                             Rs.40000/-

                             The inspection of the institution for shifting was carried out on 16.11.2010. The
                             Committee considered the VT Report, VCD and all the relevant documentary
                             evidences and it was decided to serve Show cause Notice Under Section 17 of
                             NCTE Act for the following.

                              On verification from the VCD the construction of the building is incomplete in
                               spite of the Building Completion Certificate issued by the competent
                               Government Engineer.
                              A Certificate from the Government Affiliating body to the effect that no other
                               programme is being conducted by the institution in the same building /
                               Campus, along with the existing Course D.T.Ed is to be submitted.
                              Land documents & details of its location etc in English version is to be
                               submitted.
                              As per the address given in the questionnaire, the land documents are being
                               submitted.

                              Accordingly, notice was issued to the institution on 06.01.2011. The institution
                             submitted its reply on 07.02.2011.

                             The reply of the management to the show cause notice was duly
                             considered. The reply of the institution is not convincing and hence
                             unsatisfactory.

                             Under the above grounds, the Committee decides to withdraw the
                             recognition for D.T.Ed. course run by AVMR Teacher Training
                             Institute, Coimbatore District, Tamilnadu, with effect from 2012-13 to
                             enable the present batch of student to complete the course.

                             But, it is made clear that the institution is debarred from making
                             any further admission subsequent to the date of issue of this order.

                             The Affiliating body / Examining board / body be informed
                             accordingly.
                             Further decided to return Endowment funds and Reserve fund
                             deposited with SRC NCTE, Bangalore.


106.       APS04106          Vinayaga College of Education, Chennai, Tamilnadu
           APS08455
              B.Ed           Vinayaga College of Education, Malliga Nagar, Pallavaram, Chennai-600117,
             M.Ed            Tamilnadu submitted an application for grant of recognition for B.Ed and M.Ed
       Vinayaga College of   courses. The institution was granted recognition for offering B.Ed course with an
       Education, Chennai    intake of 100 students vide order dated 24.11.2005 and M.Ed course with an
               TN            intake of 25 on 17.03.2008 and as per NCTE notification dated 26.7.2010
                             enhancement of 10 intake was given on 23.08.2010. (Existing 25 to 35 intake)

                             Mean time NCTE, Hqrs vide its letter dated 28.12.2010 has forwarded a copy of
                             the inspection report dated 18.09.2010 conducted Under Section 13 of NCTE
                             Act. As there are deficiencies pointed out in the inspection report, NCTE, Hqrs
                                                      155


   (Gangadharaiah)                                                            (Prof. C. Thangamuthu)
   Regional Director, SRC, NCTE                                                 Chairman, SRC, NCTE
                                                                                       th
                                                                        Minutes of 204 Meeting of SRC
                                                                                        th     th
                                                                                      27 -28 April 2011
                       has    communicated       to   the   institution   vide   office    letter no.13-
                       8/2010/NCTE/SEC13/Insp/T.N-1/A27396 dated 02.11.2010, which was replied
                       by the institution vide its two letters dated 06.12.2010. The latest status of
                       deficiencies is also enclosed.

                       Keeping all the facts in view NCTE, Hqrs has requested SRC, may look into the
                       matter to ascertain the adherence of relevant NCTE norms & standards by the
                       institution and to take appropriate action in the matter under intimation to NCTE-
                       Hqrs.
                                                   th                     th  st
                       The Committee in its 200 meeting held on 20 -21 January 2011 considered
                       the VT Report and all the relevant documentary evidences and it was decided to
                       serve Show cause Notice Under Section 17 of NCTE Act. Accordingly notice
                       was issued to the institution for the following on 03.03.2011. The institution
                       submitted its reply on 01.04.2011.

                       The Committee considered the VT Report, VCD and all the relevant
                       documentary evidences and it was decided to serve Final Show
                       cause Notice under Section 17 of NCTE Act for all the courses Viz:-
                       T.T.I, B.Ed & M.Ed for the following:

                           As per VT report, the area earmarked for B.Ed is 1500 sq.mts
                            and for M.Ed is 500 sq.mts; the total built up area earmarked for
                            B.Ed, M.Ed & the TTI is 2307 sq.mts, which is grossly
                            inadequate for running all the three courses; as per the NCTE
                            norms, the total built-up area requirement is a minimum of 3500
                            sq.meters.

                           The institute has not submitted the approved Building
                            Completion     Certificate from a   competent   Govt.
                            authority/Engineer.

                           English version of Land usage certificate from a competent
                            Govt. approved authority is to be submittede.

                           The institution has not produced the required documents to
                            ascertain whether the salary to the staff is paid as per
                            State/UGC of the Teacher Training Institute. Salary is not being
                            paid to the staff through Nationalised Bank.

                           The institution is not maintaining CPF/PF contributions made to
                            the staff members as per rules. The procedure is not followed in
                            the present academic year.

                           The Teacher Education Institution is located as part of the Arts
                            & Science College and Higher Secondary School. This is gross
                            violation of NCTE norms.

                       In view of the above, the Committee decided to issue a Final Show
                       cause Notice to the institution as to why the recognition be not
                       withdrawn and thereby providing an opportunity to the institution to

                                                156


(Gangadharaiah)                                                         (Prof. C. Thangamuthu)
Regional Director, SRC, NCTE                                              Chairman, SRC, NCTE
                                                                                         th
                                                                          Minutes of 204 Meeting of SRC
                                                                                         th  th
                                                                                       27 -28 April 2011
                               make a written representation within 30 days from the date of issue
                               of the Notice along with necessary certificates/documents in order
                               to take a final decision in the matter; failing which action will be
                               taken including the withdrawal of recognition, based on the records
                               available, with no further notice.


107.      APS01289             Annai Theresa Teacher Training Institute & Annai Terasa
          APS05090             College of Education, Thammampatty, Salem District,
          APS05948             Tamilnadu
             D.T.Ed
           D.T.Ed-AI           Christian Mission Educational Trust, Salem, Tamilnadu submitted
              B.Ed             application in the name of Annai Theresa Teacher Training Institute &
         Annai Theresa         Annai Terasa College of Education, Thammampatty, Salem District,
       Teacher Training        Tamilnadu for conducting B.Ed course (APS05948), D.T.Ed (APS01289)
        Institute, Salem       & D.T.Ed-AI (APS05909). Recognition was granted to B.Ed course on
               TN              09.01.2007, D.T.Ed course on 20.01.2005 and D.T.Ed-AI course on
                               24.10.2006.

                               A complaint was received against Chirstian Mission Educational Trust,
                               Salem, Tamilnadu for offering Annai Theresa Teacher Training Institute,
                               Thammampatty, Salem District, Tamilnadu for conducting D.T.Ed,
                               D.T.Ed-AI & B.Ed course stating that the institution is lacking with regard
                               to infrastructure and instructional facilities

                               The complaint was considered by SRC in its 182nd meeting held on 31st
                               August 2009 and decided to issue show cause notice Under Section 17
                               of NCTE Act to all the courses in order to call for remarks on the
                               complaint along with questionnaire. Accordingly, show cause notice were
                               issued to all the three courses on 1.10.2009 for the following:

                                 B.Ed. College was granted recognition ignoring the existing of D.T.Ed
                               Course.
                                 The College having only 15,000 sq.ft. RCC building for all courses.
                                 1,000 students residing in the class rooms as hostel.
                                 Leased land and building.
                                 forgery building documents and CD produced

                               The institution has submitted its reply on 22.10.2009, which was placed
                               in 187th meeting of SRC held on 29th and 30th December 2009. SRC
                               considered the written representation of the institution and decided to
                               cause Inspection Under Section 17 of NCTE Act.

                               Again the matter was placed in SRC in its 192nd meeting held on 10th-11th
                               May 2010 and decided that “copy of the complaint “excerpts” pertaining
                               to the concerned institutions had already been given to the concerned
                               institutions and the remarks of the institutions were also obtained and
                               considered by the SRC; and hence the visit to the institution be
                               proceeded, without any further delay, in anticipation of the inspection fee
                                                      157


   (Gangadharaiah)                                                          (Prof. C. Thangamuthu)
   Regional Director, SRC, NCTE                                               Chairman, SRC, NCTE
                                                                                  th
                                                                   Minutes of 204 Meeting of SRC
                                                                                  th  th
                                                                                27 -28 April 2011
                       of Rs.40000/- payable on this account as upheld by the Hon‟ble High
                       Court of Madras.

                       As per the decision of SRC, inspection of the institution was conducted
                       on 8th June 2010. The VT report alongwith original file was considered by
                       SRC in its 193rd meeting held on 21st-22nd June 2010. The Committee
                       decided to issue notice to the institution for all the courses on
                       29.07.2010. The institution submitted its reply on 18.08.2010.

                       SRC considered the reply in its 196th meeting held on 15th-16th
                       September 2010 and the committee decided to cause re-inspection for all
                       the courses on receipt of the filed in Questionnaire, including all the
                       relevant documents. The committee decided that the Arul Teacher
                       Training Institute bearing code No. 8066 in the same campus be also be
                       inspected to verify whether it has exclusive and separate infrastructure
                       facilities.

                       A letter calling for documents alongwith Questionnaire was issued on
                       26.10.2010. The institution did not submit its reply. Inspection of the
                       institution was fixed between 18th-25th November 2010 and the same was
                       intimated to the institution on 08.11.2010. But inspection could not be
                       conducted by VT members because institution has not allowed VT
                       members to inspect.

                       The institution submitted a letter dated 23.11.2010 to the VT members
                       stating NCTE inspecting authority members visited our institution to
                       inspect the institution on 23.11.2010. Already we filed a pending case to
                       the high court, Chennai W.P.No. 25842/2010. We are expecting the stay
                       order from the court. In this movement we are not able to face the
                       inspection after getting the court order, if the court may be order to face
                       the inspection., we will ready to cooperate the inspection.

                       A court order dated 19.11.2010 has been received from the Hon‟ble High
                       Court of Madras stating as follows:

                       “The learned counsel for the respondent has brought to the notice of this
                       court that by proceedings dated 26.10.2010, the petitioner was served
                       with a notice calling upon to produce certain documents, besides giving
                       15 days time for submission of the reply also. However, on receipt of the
                       reply, the respondent can inspect and verify the stand taken in the reply
                       given by the petitioner institution. Besides, the power of inspection of the
                       respondent with the petitioner institution cannot be curtailed basing on
                       the last inspection done. According to the learned counsel, as far as the
                       impugned notice dated 8.11.2010 is concerned, it is by mistake, the
                       same has been issued and no further steps will be taken basing on the
                       notice dated 8.11.2010, which is under challenge in this writ petition.
                       However, depending on the reply to be furnished by the petitioner
                       institution for the notice dated 26.10.2010, further steps, including
                       inspection, will be done by the respondent institution.

                                              158


(Gangadharaiah)                                                      (Prof. C. Thangamuthu)
Regional Director, SRC, NCTE                                           Chairman, SRC, NCTE
                                                                                   th
                                                                    Minutes of 204 Meeting of SRC
                                                                                   th  th
                                                                                 27 -28 April 2011
                        Recording the above submission made by the learned counsel appearing
                        for the respondent, this writ petition is closed, setting aside the impugned
                        notice dated 8.11.2010. No costs. M.P. Nos.1 and 2 of 2010 are closed”.

                        No reply was received from the institution to the notice dt. 26.10.2010.
                        The committee in its 200th meeting held on 20th-21st January 2011
                        considered the matter and decided to issue Notice under Sec 17 of
                        NCTE Act to the institution giving 30 days time for reply to the earlier
                        notice issued to the institution dt. 26.10.2010 calling for documents along
                        with Questionnaire and then process the reply for inspection after
                        submission of Rs. 40000/- towards inspection fee for each of the courses
                        being run by the institution.

                        Accordingly, a notice was again issued to the institution on 03.03.2011 to
                        submit the following as called for in letter dated 26.10.2010

                           Land documents of the new building/location for having own land in
                        the name of the institution/Society/trust.
                           Building plan of the new building duly approved by the Government
                        authority.
                           Building completion certificate from the Government authorities in the
                        prescribed format
                           Land usage certificate from the concerned Government authorities
                        stating that the land is exclusively permitted/sanctioned for Educational
                        purposes only should be submitted.
                           Encumbrance certificate from the competent Government should be
                        submitted.
                           Fixed Deposit Receipt of Rs. 5 lakhs kept in Joint account with SRC
                        in Nationalised Bank for a period of 5 years towards endowment fund in
                        Original should be submitted.
                           Fixed Deposit receipt of Rs. 3 lakhs kept in joint account with SRC in
                        Nationalised Bank for a period of 5 years towards Reserve fund in
                        original should be submitted.
                           Certificate of registration/Bye-law of the society/trust should be
                        submitted.
                           The affidavit in Rs. 100/- stamp paper in the prescribed format with
                        notary attestation should be submitted.

                        The institution vide its letter dated 01.04.2011 instead of submitting
                        above documents alongwith filled in questionnaire and D.D of Rs.40000/-
                        requested to visit the college directly and consider the application and do
                        the need full action as early as your favour.

                        The Committee considered the VT Report, VCD and all the relevant
                        documentary evidences and it was decided to serve Final Show
                        cause Notice under Section 17 of NCTE Act for the following:

                         Land documents of the new building/location for having own land
                          in the name of the institution/Society/trust.

                                               159


(Gangadharaiah)                                                       (Prof. C. Thangamuthu)
Regional Director, SRC, NCTE                                            Chairman, SRC, NCTE
                                                                                     th
                                                                      Minutes of 204 Meeting of SRC
                                                                                     th  th
                                                                                   27 -28 April 2011
                              Building plan of the new building duly approved by the
                               Government authority.
                              Building completion certificate from the Government authorities in
                               the prescribed format
                              Land usage certificate from the concerned Government authorities
                               stating that the land is exclusively permitted/sanctioned for
                               Educational purposes only should be submitted.
                              Encumbrance certificate from the competent Government should
                               be submitted.
                              Fixed Deposit Receipt of Rs. 5 lakhs kept in Joint account with
                               SRC in Nationalised Bank for a period of 5 years towards
                               endowment fund in Original should be submitted.
                              Fixed Deposit receipt of Rs. 3 lakhs kept in joint account with SRC
                               in Nationalised Bank for a period of 5 years towards Reserve fund
                               in original should be submitted.
                              Certificate of registration/Bye-law of the society/trust should be
                               submitted.
                              The affidavit in Rs. 100/- stamp paper in the prescribed format with
                               notary attestation should be submitted.

                              In view of the above, the Committee decided to issue a Final Show
                             cause Notice to the institution as to why the recognition be not
                             withdrawn and thereby providing an opportunity to the institution to
                             make a written representation within 30 days from the date of issue
                             of the Notice along with necessary certificates/documents in order
                             to take a final decision in the matter; failing which action will be
                             taken including the withdrawal of recognition, based on the records
                             available, with no further notice.


108.      APS05091           KVK College of Education, Dindigul District, Tamilnadu
              B.Ed
        KVK College of       KVK College of Education, Kallipatty Village, Chettynaiackanpatty Post,
       Education, Dindigul   Thandikombu Road, Dindigul-624709, Tamilnadu has submitted an
               TN            application for seeking grant of recognition for B.Ed course on
                             30.12.2005. The application was processed and recognition to the
                             institution for B.Ed course was granted on 10.09.2007 for annual intake
                             of 100 students.

                                    Meanwhile a judgement dated 10.06.2009 in W.P.No.4545 of
                             2009 has been received from the Hon‟ble High Court of Madras at
                             Madurai Bench regarding management dispute and the court has passed
                             orders as under:-

                             “…the first respondent (NCTE) is directed to dispose of the
                             representation dated 28.04.2008 submitted by the petitioner, on merits
                             and in accordance with law, within a period of three weeks from the date
                             of receipt of a copy of this order and also providew reasonable
                             opportunity of hearing to the petitioner as well as to the second
                                                   160


   (Gangadharaiah)                                                      (Prof. C. Thangamuthu)
   Regional Director, SRC, NCTE                                           Chairman, SRC, NCTE
                                                                                  th
                                                                   Minutes of 204 Meeting of SRC
                                                                                  th  th
                                                                                27 -28 April 2011
                       respondent (KVK College of Education)….”

                       The matter was considered by SRC in its 177th meeting held on 22nd-23rd
                       June 2009 and decided to call representation from both the factions and
                       also personal hearing of both the sides. Accordingly, a letter was issued
                       on 02.07.2006. The SRC in its 178th meeting held on 13th-14th July 2009
                       decided to issue show cause notice u/s 17. Accordingly, notice was
                       issued on 25.08.2009.

                       The institution submitted reply on 16.09.2009 wherein it is stated that the
                       Court order W.P.No. 4545/2009 dated 10.6.2009 was issued without the
                       knowledge of the Management. The Management has stated that it has
                       filed a review petition in the Hon‟ble High Court of Madras, Madurai
                       Bench and has stated that it will submit the reply after getting the order
                       from the Hon‟ble Court. The reply was considered by SRC in its 185th
                       meeting held on 26-27th November 2009 and SRC decided to await for
                       the Court Orders. Accordingly, a letter was sent to advocate on
                       04.01.2010.

                       Meanwhile a complaint has been received against the institution. The
                       Committee considered the complaint in its 195th meeting held on 17th-18th
                       August 2010 and decided to serve Notice Under Section 17 of NCTE Act.
                       Accordingly notice was issued to the institution on 23.9.2010. The
                       institution submitted its reply on 11.10.2010.

                       The Committee in its 197th meeting held on 13th-14th October 2010 on the
                       basis of all the relevant documentary evidences it is decided to serve
                       Show cause Notice Under Section 17 of NCTE Act show cause notice
                       was issued to the institution on 07.12.2010 to submit reply within 30
                       days. The institution in its letter dt. 2.2.2011 has requested for a further
                       40 days time. The committee in its 200th meeting held on 20th-21st
                       January 2011 has decided to issue Final Show Cause notice to the
                       institution for the following reason under section 17 of the NCTE Act.
                       Accordingly, a notice was issued to the institution on 03.03.2011. The
                       institution submitted its reply on 05.04.2011.

                       The institution has submitted minutes of BTK Educational Development
                       Trust and copy of civil suit O.S.428/2007 which is seen to be pending of
                       Municipal Court of Dindigul. No documentary proof submitted for
                       purchase of own land, Building Plan, Building Completion Certificate etc.

                       The management has not submitted the present status of the review
                       petition filed by them before the Madurai Bench of High Court.

                       The reply of the management to the show cause notice was duly
                       considered. The reply of the institution is not convincing and hence
                       unsatisfactory.

                       Under the above grounds, the Committee decides to withdraw the
                       recognition for B.Ed. course run by KVK College of Education,
                                              161


(Gangadharaiah)                                                      (Prof. C. Thangamuthu)
Regional Director, SRC, NCTE                                           Chairman, SRC, NCTE
                                                                                           th
                                                                            Minutes of 204 Meeting of SRC
                                                                                           th  th
                                                                                         27 -28 April 2011
                               Dingigul District, Tamilnadu, with effect from 2011-12 to enable the
                               present batch of student to complete the course.

                               But, it is made clear that the institution is debarred from making
                               any further admission subsequent to the date of issue of this order.

                               The Affiliating body / Examining board / body be informed
                               accordingly.
                               Further decided to return Endowment funds and Reserve fund
                               deposited with SRC NCTE, Bangalore, if any.


109.         APS03760
             APS04875          PDR Vellachiammal Teacher Training Institute, Dharmapuri,
               D.T.Ed          Tamilnadu
              D.T.Ed-AI
        PDR Vellachiammal      PDR Vellachiammal Teacher Training Institute, Dharmaprui, Tamilnadu
         Teacher Training      submitted application for granted of recognition to D.T.Ed course.
       Institute, Dharmapuri
                  TN           The application was processed and recognition was granted for offering
                               D.T.Ed course with an intake of 50 students on 23.11.2005 and D.T.Ed-
                               AI with an intake of 50 students on 08.11.2006 with the condition to shift
                               to own premises within 3 years.

                               The institution vide its letter dated 25.03.2011 stated as follows :

                               “NCTE-SRC accorded recognition to PDR Vellachiammal Teacher
                               Training Institute, Sekkampatti, Dharmapuri District initially for an intake
                               of 50 students and then an additional intake of 50 students.

                                       From 2010-11, we have not made any admission to D.El.Ed
                               course and the same was intimated to DTERT, Chennai. We want to
                               suspend the D.El.Ed course for a further period of 5 years from 2011-12
                               onwards. Before the commencement of the counseling for 2011-12,
                               DTERT has been duly informed through the DIET, Dharmapuri that we
                               are not admitting students in D.El.Ed course during 2011-12.

                                       We request that the NCTE (SRC) Bangalore may be pleased to
                               record the suspension of D.El.Ed course for 5 years from 2011-12 by
                               PDR Vellachiammal Teacher Training Institute, Dharmapuri District and
                               the same may be intimated to DTERT. The recording of the suspension
                               of D.El.Ed course by our institute for 5 years from 2011-12 may kindly be
                               intimated to us”.

                               Note : Inspection for shifting of premises of B.Ed course already
                               conducted and final show cause has been issued, reply from the
                               institution is yet to be received. The institution is also granted recognition
                               to M.Ed course on 22.04.2008.


                                                       162


   (Gangadharaiah)                                                            (Prof. C. Thangamuthu)
   Regional Director, SRC, NCTE                                                 Chairman, SRC, NCTE
                                                                                          th
                                                                           Minutes of 204 Meeting of SRC
                                                                                          th  th
                                                                                        27 -28 April 2011
                               As per NCTE Regulations no provisions of suspension of recognition of
                               courses already granted recognition.

                               The Committee considered the VT Report, VCD and all the relevant
                               documentary evidences and it was decided to serve Show cause
                               Notice under Section 17 of NCTE Act for the following:

                                The Institution was granted recognition in temporary premises to
                                run D.T.Ed course on 23.11.2005 & D.T.Ed-Al on 08.11.2006 with a
                                condition that it should shift to its own permanent premises in 3
                                years. i.e., on or before 22.11.2008. The Institution is still running
                                in temporary premises and not shifted to new premises even after
                                lapse of time period of more than 5 years and 05 months.


                                In view of the above, the Committee decided to issue a Show cause
                               Notice to the institution for both D.T.Ed & D.T.Ed-Al, as to why the
                               recognition be not withdrawn and thereby providing an opportunity
                               to the institution to make a written representation within 30 days
                               from the date of issue of the Notice along with necessary
                               certificates/documents in order to take a final decision in the matter;
                               failing which action will be taken including the withdrawal of
                               recognition, based on the records available, with no further notice.


110.         APS03798          Palaniammal Teacher Training Institute, Coimbatore District,
               D.T.Ed          Tamilnadu
           Palaniammal
         Teacher Training      Palaniammal Teacher Training Institute was granted recognition for offering
       Institute, Coimbatore   D.T.Ed course on 08.12.2005.
                  TN
                               The institution vide its letter dated 01.06.2010 submitted proposal for
                               shifting to new premises alongwith Rs. 40000/-. The inspection of the
                               institution for shifting of premises was carried out on 13.11.2010. The
                               Committee in its 198th meeting held on 24th-26th November 2010
                               considered the VT Report,VCD and all the relevant documentary
                               evidences and it was decided to serve Show cause Notice Under
                               Section 17 of NCTE Act. Accordingly, notice was issued to the institution
                               on 06.01.2011. The institution submitted its reply on 07.02.2011.

                               The Committee in its 201st meeting held on 22nd-23rd February 2011
                               considered the reply to Show Cause Notice, VT Report, VCD and all the
                               relevant documentary evidences and it was decided to serve Final Show
                               cause Notice Under Section 17 of NCTE Act. Accordingly final show
                               cause notice was issued on 22.03.2011. The institution submitted its
                               reply on 21.04.2011 for the following:
                               In the mean time NCTE, Hqrs vide its letter dated 11.04.2011 has forwarded a
                               copy of the inspection report dated 24.09.2010 conducted Under Section 13 of
                               NCTE Act and stated that.

                                                      163


   (Gangadharaiah)                                                           (Prof. C. Thangamuthu)
   Regional Director, SRC, NCTE                                                Chairman, SRC, NCTE
                                                                                    th
                                                                         Minutes of 204 Meeting of SRC
                                                                                        th   th
                                                                                      27 -28 April 2011
                       “The deficiencies observed from the inspection team were communicated to the
                       institution vide this office letter No.13-8/2010/NCTE/Sec.13/Insp/T.N.-17/A30809
                       dated 04.02.2011, which was replied by the institution vide its letter dated
                       03.03.2011. The latest status of deficiencies as enclosed is as follows:
                       1. The lease deed dated 22.12.2006 mentioned that the KMG Charitable
                          Trust had taken on lease 5.00 acres of land on 55 years lease for
                          running two educational institutions namely (a) Palaniammal Teacher
                          Training Institute (b) KMG College of Education. The inspection team
                          has reported the details of only one institution i.e Palaniammal
                          Teacher Training Institute, Coimbatore, Tamilnadu but not of the
                          other college (K.M.G. College of Education). The trust is therefore
                          asked to submit the instructional and infrastructural details as well as
                          no of teacher education courses run by KMG College of Education.
                       2. In adequate with regard to Palaniammal Teacher Training Institute,
                          Coimbatore, Tamilnadu
                           The inspection team has reported the built up area 1399 sq.mtrs
                              for two units of D.T.Ed & 1399 sq.mtrs for one unit of B.Ed
                              course. The built up area reported/available is inadequate for
                              conducting one unit of B.Ed and two units of D.T.Ed course as per
                              NCTE norms. The institution shall submit an approved building
                              plan as well as building completion certificate issued by the
                              competent civil authority clearly indicating the total land area, built
                              up area Khasra/Survey No etc.
                           The multipurpose hall measuring 1822 sq.ft is inadequate for one
                              unit of B.Ed course and two units of D.T.Ed course as per NCTE
                              norms.
                           There are only two classrooms for two units of D.T.Ed course and
                              one unit of B.Ed courses which is not adequate as per NCTE
                              norms.
                           The size of computer lab & library is not adequate for two units of
                              D.T.Ed course and one unit of B.Ed courses as per NCTE norms.
                           The institution has submitted list of teaching staff for D.T.Ed
                              course. It has one principal and 7 lecturers. The institution has not
                              mentioned the percentage of marks in r/o its Principal (Sl.No.1)
                              and three lecturers (Sl.No.2,4 & 7). The teaching experience of
                              Principal has not been specified. Hence, the eligibility of the
                              Principal and three lecturers cannot be ascertained. The
                              institution has not submitted in documentary evidence of approval
                              of the affiliating body on r/o of its teaching staff.
                           The institution has not submitted list of teaching staff for B.Ed
                              course. The institution may be asked to submit the list of teaching
                              staff for B.Ed course alongwith the approval of affiliating body.
                           The institution is paying a consolidated salary in cash to its
                              teaching and non-teaching staff which is not in accordance with
                              the NCTE Regulations/norms & standards.
                           The        institution   may      submit     the    list  of   available
                              equipment/apparatus in the Science, Psychology and Education
                              Technology laboratories.
                           The institution has only 10 computers for D.T.Ed two units 50+50-
                              two years 100 + 100=200 B.Ed 100 (Total 300 students) which is
                                               164


(Gangadharaiah)                                                       (Prof. C. Thangamuthu)
Regional Director, SRC, NCTE                                            Chairman, SRC, NCTE
                                                                                  th
                                                                   Minutes of 204 Meeting of SRC
                                                                                  th  th
                                                                                27 -28 April 2011
                            not sufficient as per NCTE norms.
                           The library of the institution has 3828 books, 11 journals and 43
                            encyclopedias. The seating capacity of library s 25. There are 251
                            books in the reference section. The library of the institution is ill
                            equipped for two units of D.T.Ed course and one unit of B.Ed
                            course. The institution may be asked to submit the list of available
                            books, journals and encyclopedias in the library course wise.
                           The institution may be asked to submit the documentary evidence
                            regarding the joint operation of the FDR‟s (endowment and
                            Reserve fund) of all the courses.
                           The institution has not shown the details of CPF/PPF of the staff
                            members to inspection team.

                       It is pertinent to mention that the inspection team has recorded in its
                       aforesaid inspection report at Page 2 that the institution has not
                       implemented the SRC‟s recognition order of D.Ed (Additional Intake) and
                       it is conducting the D.T.Ed course with the basic unit of 50 intake only. It
                       is a matter of concern that the institution is not able to start conducting
                       the D.T.Ed (Addl) course even after a period of three years from the date
                       of grant of recognition. It has been decided that the SRC, NCTE,
                       Bangalore may look into the matter and further a status report be
                       submitted in this regard.

                       Keeping all the facts in view it has been decided that SRC, NCTE may
                       look into the matter to ascertain the adherence of relevant NCTE norms
                       & standards by the institution and take appropriate action in the matter
                       under intimation to this office”.

                       The matter is placed before SRC along with letter from NCTE, Hqrs, VT
                       report U/S 13 of NCTE Act, reply to notice and original file for decision
                       and direction.

                       The Committee considered the VT Report, VCD and all the relevant
                       documentary evidences and it was decided to serve Final Show
                       cause Notice under Section 17 of NCTE Act for the following:

                        As per VT report the built up area 1399 sq.mtrs for two units of
                         D.T.Ed & 1399 sq.mtrs for one unit of B.Ed course. Which is
                         inadequate for conducting two units of D.T.Ed course and one unit
                         of B.Ed course as sper NCTE norms.

                        A certificate from the Government affiliating body to the effect that
                         no other programme is being conducted by the institution in the
                         same building campus, along with existing course D.T.Ed is to be
                         submitted.

                        The management is also running a B.Ed programme in the name of
                         KMG Teacher Training Institute at the same address/survey nos.
                         and is trying to mislead NCTE.

                                              165


(Gangadharaiah)                                                      (Prof. C. Thangamuthu)
Regional Director, SRC, NCTE                                           Chairman, SRC, NCTE
                                                                            th
                                                              Minutes of 204 Meeting of SRC
                                                                             th  th
                                                                           27 -28 April 2011
                        The latest building completion certificate from the competent
                         Government Engineer is to be submitted.

                       In the meanwhile NCTE Head Quarters has forwarded a letter to this
                       office stating that Under Section 13 of NCTE Act conducted
                       inspection of the said institution on 24.09.2010. The deficiencies
                       identified by the Sec.13 VT are as follows:

                        The lease deed dated 22.12.2006 mentioned that the KMG
                         Charitable Trust had taken on lease 5.00 acres of land on 55
                         years lease for running two educational institutions namely (a)
                         Palaniammal Teacher Training Institute (b) KMG College of
                         Education. The inspection team has reported the details of only
                         one institution i.e Palaniammal Teacher Training Institute,
                         Coimbatore, Tamilnadu but not of the other college (K.M.G.
                         College of Education). The trust is therefore asked to submit the
                         instructional and infrastructural details as well as no of teacher
                         education courses run by KMG College of Education.
                        In adequate with regard to Palaniammal Teacher Training
                         Institute, Coimbatore, Tamilnadu
                          The inspection team has reported the built up area 1399
                             sq.mtrs for two units of D.T.Ed & 1399 sq.mtrs for one unit of
                             B.Ed course. The built up area reported/available is
                             inadequate for conducting one unit of B.Ed and two units of
                             D.T.Ed course as per NCTE norms. The institution shall
                             submit an approved building plan as well as building
                             completion certificate issued by the competent civil authority
                             clearly indicating the total land area, built up area
                             Khasra/Survey No etc.
                          The multipurpose hall measuring 1822 sq.ft is inadequate for
                             one unit of B.Ed course and two units of D.T.Ed course as
                             per NCTE norms.
                          There are only two classrooms for two units of D.T.Ed course
                             and one unit of B.Ed courses which is not adequate as per
                             NCTE norms.
                          The size of computer lab & library is not adequate for two
                             units of D.T.Ed course and one unit of B.Ed courses as per
                             NCTE norms.
                          The institution has submitted list of teaching staff for D.T.Ed
                             course. It has one principal and 7 lecturers. The institution
                             has not mentioned the percentage of marks in r/o its
                             Principal (Sl.No.1) and three lecturers (Sl.No.2,4 & 7). The
                             teaching experience of Principal has not been specified.
                             Hence, the eligibility of the Principal and three lecturers
                             cannot be ascertained. The institution has not submitted in
                             documentary evidence of approval of the affiliating body on
                             r/o of its teaching staff.
                          The institution has not submitted list of teaching staff for
                             B.Ed course. The institution may be asked to submit the list

                                           166


(Gangadharaiah)                                                 (Prof. C. Thangamuthu)
Regional Director, SRC, NCTE                                      Chairman, SRC, NCTE
                                                                                           th
                                                                          Minutes of 204 Meeting of SRC
                                                                                         th  th
                                                                                       27 -28 April 2011
                                  of teaching staff for B.Ed course alongwith the approval of
                                  affiliating body.
                                 The institution is paying a consolidated salary in cash to its
                                  teaching and non-teaching staff which is not in accordance
                                  with the NCTE Regulations/norms & standards.
                                 The institution may submit the list of available
                                  equipment/apparatus in the Science, Psychology and
                                  Education Technology laboratories.
                                 The institution has only 10 computers for D.T.Ed two units
                                  50+50- two years 100 + 100=200 B.Ed 100 (Total 300
                                  students) which is not sufficient as per NCTE norms.
                                 The library of the institution has 3828 books, 11 journals and
                                  43 encyclopedias. The seating capacity of library s 25. There
                                  are 251 books in the reference section. The library of the
                                  institution is ill equipped for two units of D.T.Ed course and
                                  one unit of B.Ed course. The institution may be asked to
                                  submit the list of available books, journals and
                                  encyclopedias in the library course wise.
                                 The institution may be asked to submit the documentary
                                  evidence regarding the joint operation of the FDR‟s
                                  (endowment and Reserve fund) of all the courses.
                                 The institution has not shown the details of CPF/PPF of the
                                  staff members to inspection team.


                           In view of the above, the Committee decided to issue a Final Show
                          cause Notice to the institution as to why the recognition be not
                          withdrawn and thereby providing an opportunity to the institution to
                          make a written representation within 30 days from the date of issue
                          of the Notice along with necessary certificates/documents in order
                          to take a final decision in the matter; failing which action will be
                          taken including the withdrawal of recognition, based on the records
                          available, with no further notice.




111.     APS03680         KMG College of Education, Coimbatore District, Tamilnadu
           B.Ed
       KMG College of     KMG Charitable Trust, Coimbatore submitted an application in the name and
         Education,       style of KMG College of Education for seeking grant of recognition for B.Ed
        Coimbatore        course on 27.12.2004.
            TN            The application was processed and the recognition order was issued to the
                          institution on 01.08.2006 at KMG College of Education, V. Kaliapuram Post,
                          Vettaikkaran, Pudur (Via), Pollachi Taluk, Coimbatore-642129, Tamilnadu with
                          the condition to shift to own premises within 3 years.

                          Notice was issued to the institution on 08.10.2009 calling for documents to
                          examine the proposal for shifting of premises. The institution vide its letter dated
                          28.10.2009 submitted a proposal for shifting to new premises alongwith
                          Rs.40000/-.
                                                  167


   (Gangadharaiah)                                                           (Prof. C. Thangamuthu)
   Regional Director, SRC, NCTE                                                Chairman, SRC, NCTE
                                                                                       th
                                                                      Minutes of 204 Meeting of SRC
                                                                                     th  th
                                                                                   27 -28 April 2011

                          The inspection of the institution for shifting of premises was carried out on
                                                                     th                th   th
                          13.11.2010. The Committee in its 198 meeting held on 24 -26 November
                          2010 considered the VT Report, VCD and all the relevant documentary
                          evidences and it was decided to serve Show cause Notice Under Section 17 of
                          NCTE Act Accordingly, notice was issued to the institution on 05.01.2011. The
                          institution submitted its reply on 07.02.2011.
                                                  st                   nd     rd
                          The Committee in its 201 meeting held on 22 -23 February 2011 considered
                          the reply to Show Cause Notice, VT Report, VCD and all the relevant
                          documentary evidences and it was decided to serve Final Show cause Notice
                          Under Section 17 of NCTE Act. Accordingly show cause notice was issued to the
                          institution on 21.03.2011. The institution submitted its reply on 21.04.2011.

                          The Committee considered the VT Report, VCD and all the relevant
                          documentary evidences and it was decided to serve Final Show
                          cause Notice under Section 17 of NCTE Act for the following:

                           As per VT report the built up area 1399 sq.mtrs for two units of
                            D.T.Ed & 1399 sq.mtrs for one unit of B.Ed course. Which is
                            inadequate for conducting two units of D.T.Ed course and one unit
                            of B.Ed course as sper NCTE norms.

                           A certificate from the Government affiliating body to the effect that
                            no other programme is being conducted by the institution in the
                            same building campus, along with existing course D.T.Ed is to be
                            submitted.

                           The management is also running a D.T.Ed programme in the name
                            of building/premises & Sy.nos. in the name of Palaniammai
                            Teacher Training Institute, Cointatore, and is misleading NCTE.

                           The latest building completion certificate from the competent
                            Government Engineer is to be submitted.




                           In view of the above, the Committee decided to issue a Final Show
                          cause Notice to the institution as to why the recognition be not
                          withdrawn and thereby providing an opportunity to the institution to
                          make a written representation within 30 days from the date of issue
                          of the Notice along with necessary certificates/documents in order
                          to take a final decision in the matter; failing which action will be
                          taken including the withdrawal of recognition, based on the records
                          available, with no further notice.



112.     APS06130         Kapi Teacher Training Institute, Madurai District, Tamilnadu
          D.T.Ed
                                                 168


   (Gangadharaiah)                                                          (Prof. C. Thangamuthu)
   Regional Director, SRC, NCTE                                               Chairman, SRC, NCTE
                                                                                               th
                                                                           Minutes of 204 Meeting of SRC
                                                                                           th  th
                                                                                        27 -28 April 2011
         Kapi Teacher        Crescent Trust, Madurai submitted an application in the name and style of Kapi
       Training Institute,   Teacher Training Institute, Madurai District, Tamilnadu for seeking grant of
            Madurai          recognition for D.T.Ed course on 30.12.2006.
              TN
                             The application was processed and the inspection of the institution was carried
                             out on 12.10.2006. Recognition order was issued to the institution on 24.10.2006
                             at Kapi Teacher Training Institute, Plot No.408, No.7/14A, Willington Road,
                             NGGO Colony, Nagamalai, Madurai-625019, Tamilnadu with the condition to
                             shift to own premises within 3 years.

                             The institution vide letter dated 15.10.2009 & 26.02.2010 submitted Rs.40000/-
                             for change of address at Kapi Teacher Training Institute, No.7/14A, Willington
                             Road, NGGO Colony, Nagamalai, Madurai-625019, Tamilnadu
                                                                                 th   th
                             Inspection of the institution was fixed between 8 -12 February 2011 and was
                             intimated to the institution on 31.01.2011. Accordingly inspection of the institution
                             for shifting of premises was conducted on 08.02.2011.
                                                         st                   nd   rd
                             The Committee in its 201 meeting held on 22 -23 February 2011 considered
                             the VT Report, VCD and all the relevant documentary evidences and it was
                             decided to serve Show cause Notice Under Section 17 of NCTE Act for the
                             following. Accordingly show cause notice was issued to the institution on
                             22.03.2011. The institution submitted its reply on 21.04.2011 for the following:

                             The Committee considered the VT report of the institution, VCD,
                             reply of the institution dt. 21.04.2011 and other related documents
                             along with the original file of the institution, and decided that
                             shifting to new/permanent premises is permitted.




113.      APS06128
              B.Ed           Kapi College of Education, Madurai District, Tamilnadu
        Kapi College of
       Education, Madurai    Crescent Trust, Madurai submitted an application in the name and style
               TN            of Kapi College of Education, Madurai District, Tamilnadu for seeking
                             grant of recognition for B.Ed course on 30.12.2005.

                             The application was processed and the inspection of the institution was
                             carried out on 30.10.2006. Recognition order was issued to the institution
                             on 23.12.2006 at Kapi College of Education, No.4/59, V.P. Sindan Nagar,
                             Theni Main Road, Nagamalai West, Madurai-625019, Tamilnadu with the
                             condition to shift to own premises within 3 years.

                             The institution vide its letter dated 15.10.2009 submitted Rs.40000/- for
                             change of address at Kapi College of Education, No.7/14A, Willington
                             Road, NGGO Colony, Nagamalai, Madurai-625019, Tamilnadu.

                             Accordingly inspection of the institution was fixed between 8th-12th
                             February 2011 and was intimated to the institution on 31.01.2011.
                             Accordingly inspection of the institution for shifting of premises was
                                                       169


   (Gangadharaiah)                                                              (Prof. C. Thangamuthu)
   Regional Director, SRC, NCTE                                                   Chairman, SRC, NCTE
                                                                                            th
                                                                           Minutes of 204 Meeting of SRC
                                                                                          th  th
                                                                                        27 -28 April 2011
                             conducted on 09.02.2011.

                             The Committee in its 201st meeting held on 22nd-23rd February 2011
                             considered the VT Report, VCD and all the relevant documentary
                             evidences and it was decided to serve Show cause Notice Under Section
                             17 of NCTE Act. Accordingly show cause notice was issued to the
                             institution on 22.03.2011. The institution submitted its reply on
                             21.04.2011

                             The Committee considered the VT report of the institution, VCD,
                             reply of the institution dt. 21.04.2011 and other related documents
                             along with the original file of the institution, and decided that
                             shifting to new/permanent premises is permitted.

114.      APS05017           Krishna Teacher          Training      Institute,       Krishnagiri   District,
            D.T.Ed           Tamilnadu
       Krishna Teacher
       Training Institute,   Bharat Educational Trust, Krishnagiri submitted an application in the
          Krishnagiri        name and style of Krishna Teacher Training Institute, Krishnagiri District,
              TN             Tamilnadu for seeking grant of recognition for D.T.Ed course on
                             30.12.2005.


                             The application was processed and the inspection of the institution was
                             carried out on 25.11.2006. Recognition order was issued to the institution
                             on 17.11.2005 at Krishna Teacher Training Institute, Kattinayanapalli
                             Post, Krishnagiri-635001, Tamilnadu with the condition to shift to own
                             premises within 3 years.

                             \The institution vide letter dated 28.04.2010 submitted Rs.40000/- for
                             change of address at Krishna Teacher Training Institute, Kattinayanapalli
                             Post, Krishnagiri-635001, Tamilnadu.

                             Inspection of the institution was carried out on 9th February 2011 and the
                             VT report was received on 10.2.2011. The Committee in its 201st meeting
                             held on 22nd-23rd February 2011 considered the VT Report, VCD and all
                             the relevant documentary evidences and it was decided to serve Show
                             cause Notice Under Section 17 of NCTE Act. Accordingly show cause
                             notice was issued to the institution on 22.03.2011. The institution
                             submitted its reply on 21.04.2011

                             Note: The institution in its reply stated as follows:

                             “Krishna Teacher Training Institute (additional intake) order was given by
                             NCTE. There is no any intake order got from State Government. Hence I
                             kindly inform that the running intake is only 50 students”.

                             The Committee considered the VT Report, VCD and all the relevant
                             documentary evidences and it was decided to serve Final Show
                                                     170


   (Gangadharaiah)                                                           (Prof. C. Thangamuthu)
   Regional Director, SRC, NCTE                                                Chairman, SRC, NCTE
                                                                                             th
                                                                            Minutes of 204 Meeting of SRC
                                                                                           th  th
                                                                                         27 -28 April 2011
                             cause Notice under Section 17 of NCTE Act for the following:

                              The latest building completion certificate from the competent
                               Government Engineer is to be submitted.

                              The earmarked built up area for each course i.e., B.Ed, D.T.Ed and
                               D.T.Ed Additional should be given.

                              Affidavit submitted is incomplete.


                              In view of the above, the Committee decided to issue a Final Show
                             cause Notice to the institution as to why the recognition be not
                             withdrawn and thereby providing an opportunity to the institution to
                             make a written representation within 30 days from the date of issue
                             of the Notice along with necessary certificates/documents in order
                             to take a final decision in the matter; failing which action will be
                             taken including the withdrawal of recognition, based on the records
                             available, with no further notice.

115.      APS05980           J.S.J.V Teacher Training Institute, Cuddalore, Tamilnadu
          APS08538
            D.T.Ed           J.S.J.V Teacher Training Institute, Cuddalore, Tamilnadu had submitted an
           D.T.Ed-AI         application for grant of recognition to D.T.Ed course. Recognition to the
        JSJV Teacher         institution was granted to the institution on 23.12.2006 for D.T.Ed course with an
       Training Institute,   intake of 50 students.
          Cuddalore                                             th                                th
                             As per decision of SRC in its 175 meeting of SRC held on 13-14 May 2009,
              TN
                             the office of SRC has reviewed the files of the institution who have been granted
                             recognition either in a rented premises pending construction of own building or in
                             lease premises. A list of such institutions has been prepared and placed before
                                              st                   th   st
                             SRC in its 181 meeting held on 20 -21 August 2009 wherein, it was decided
                             that the institution which have not shifted to the permanent premises even after
                             the expiry of three years time limit be issued notice under Section 17 of NCTE
                             Act for further action. Accordingly a notice was issued to the institution on
                             16.09.2009.

                             The institution has not submitted reply to the above notice so far. Instead the
                             institution has submitted letter dated 12.04.2010 requesting for change of name
                             from J.S.J.V. Teacher Training Institute to C.K. Teacher Training Institute.
                                                                               st                    th  st
                             The matter was considered by SRC in its 191 meeting held on 20 -21 April
                             2010. The Committee considered the brief note about the College and also the
                             complaints received against the institution and has decided to issue Final Notice
                             to the institution As per the decision of SRC, final show notice was issued to the
                             institution on 18.05.2010. The institution has submitted its reply on 01.06.2010.
                                                       rd                    st     nd
                             The Committee in its 193 meeting held on 21 -22 June 2010 considered the
                             reply to the Notice and decided to withdraw recognition. Accordingly, withdrawal
                             order was issued vide order No. F.SRO/NCTE/2010/20030, Dt. 27.07.2010.
                             Recognition to D.T.Ed-Al was also withdrawn vide order No.
                             F.SRO/NCTE2010/21089. Dt. 14.09.2010.


                                                      171


   (Gangadharaiah)                                                                (Prof. C. Thangamuthu)
   Regional Director, SRC, NCTE                                                     Chairman, SRC, NCTE
                                                                                             th
                                                                              Minutes of 204 Meeting of SRC
                                                                                               th   th
                                                                                             27 -28 April 2011
                              Aggrieved by the withdrawal order, the institution preferred appeal under Section
                              18. The Appellate Authority vide order dated 18.11.2010 reversed the SRC order
                              dated 27.07.2010 with direction to SRC to examine the reply furnished by the
                                                                                                              th
                              institution and take appropriate decision thereafter. The committee in its 199
                                                  nd   rd
                              meeting held on 22 -23 December 2010 noted the Appellate authority order dt.
                              18/11/2010 and decided to issue a show cause notice. Accordingly notice was
                              issued to the institution on 11.02.2011. The institution submitted its reply on
                              01.03.2011.
                                                         nd                   th   th
                              The Committee in its 202 meeting held on 14 -15 March 2011 considered the
                              Reply of the institution Dt. 01.03.2011 and all the relevant documentary
                              evidences and it was decided to serve Show cause Notice under Section 17 of
                              NCTE Act. Accordingly show cause notice was issued to the institution on
                              11.04.2011. The institution submitted its reply on 24.03.2011 which was prior to
                              issue of notice dt.11.04.2011 after seeing the decision of SRC in SRC Website.

                              The Committee considered the VT report of the institution, VCD,
                              reply of the institution dt. 27.04.2011 and other related documents
                              along with the original file of the institution, and decided that
                              shifting to new/permanent premises is permitted.

116.        APS02176          Sri Jagadguru Guru Basaveshwara Teacher Training Institute,
                D.Ed          Murughamutt, Achapura, Anandapura, Sagar Taluk, Shimoga
       Sri Jagadguru Guru
          Basaveshwara        District-577412, Karnataka
         Teacher Training
                              Sri Jagadguru Guru Basaveshwara Teacher Training Institute,
        Institute, Shimoga
                              Murughamutt, Achapura, Anandapura, Sagar Taluk, Shimoga District-
                 KA
                              577412, Karnataka has submitted application for offering D.Ed course on
                              31.12.2003. The institution has been granted recognition by SRC for
                              offering D.Ed course with an intake of 50 students vide order dated
                              29.11.2004.

                             The institution in its letter dated 18.09.2007 has submitted a proposal for
                             shifting of premises along with Rs.40,000/- towards shifting fee. The
                             inspection was carried out on 31st December 2010. The inspection report
                             has been received along with VCD.

                             The SRC in its 200th meeting held on 20-21 January 2011 considered the
                             VT report, VCD and all the relevant documentary evidences and it was
                             decided to issue show cause notice. Accordingly, Show cause notice was
                             issued to the institution on 11.03.2011.for the following:

                              As per VT report and from the building completion certificate submitted,
                               the built up area shown is only 2678 sq.ft,ground floor; whereas in the
                               essential data sheet, it is mentioned for B.Ed as 14368 sq.ft (sharing with
                               D.Ed) and for D.Ed as 13615 sq.ft (sharing basis) and is countersigned
                               by the correspondent of the institution. This discrepancy should be
                               explained.
                              Non- Encumbrance Certificate from the competent Government
                               Authorised person / Authorities to be submitted.


                                                      172


   (Gangadharaiah)                                                             (Prof. C. Thangamuthu)
   Regional Director, SRC, NCTE                                                  Chairman, SRC, NCTE
                                                                                         th
                                                                          Minutes of 204 Meeting of SRC
                                                                                         th  th
                                                                                       27 -28 April 2011
                                As per NCTE Regulation, private lease is not permitted. The institution
                                was permitted to start in leased land at Assessment No.71 for a period of
                                30 years. It was given recognition to start at Murughamutt, Achapura,
                                Anandapura, Sagar Taluk, Shimoga District-577412 with the condition to
                                shift into own premises with 3 years.
                                No land documents are submitted for new premises proposed to be built
                                at S.No. 57/x1 at Achapura Village, Shimoga.

                               The institution has submitted its written representation on 12.04.2011.

                               The reply of the management to the show cause notice was duly
                               considered. The reply of the institution is not convincing and hence
                               unsatisfactory.

                               Under the above grounds, the Committee decides to withdraw the
                               recognition for D.Ed. course run by Sri Jagadguru Guru
                               Basaveshwara Teacher Training Institute, Murughamutt, Achapura,
                               Anandaapura, Sagar Taluk, Shimoga District-577412, Karnataka,
                               with effect from 2012-13 to enable the present batch of student to
                               complete the course.

                               But, it is made clear that the institution is debarred from making
                               any further admission subsequent to the date of issue of this order.

                               The Affiliating body / Examining board / body be informed
                               accordingly.
                               Further decided to return Endowment funds and Reserve fund
                               deposited with SRC NCTE, Bangalore.

117.        APS09641           Haji Kareem College of Education,Saleem Minority Educational
               B.Ed            service society, Near Govt. Hospital, Brahmanakotur, Nandikottur
       Haji Kareem College     Mandal, Kurnool Dist-518432, Andhra Pradesh Course- B.Ed. (Code
       of Education, Kurnool   no. APS09641)
                AP
                               An application was submitted by Saleem Minority Educational Service
                               Society, Kurnool District, Andhra Pradesh in the name of Hazi Kareem
                               College of Education, Kurnool District, A.P for grant of recognition to
                               B.Ed course in the office of SRC-NCTE, Bangalore vide dated
                               24.10.2008.

                               The file was under process and in the meanwhile, in view of the
                               recommendations of the State Government of Andhra Pradesh vide letter
                               dated 07.01.2009 not to further recognize/permit the institutions for
                               conducting B.Ed, D.Ed, Physical Education, Language Pandit course(s),
                               to this effect that application for B.Ed, D.Ed, Physical Education,
                               Language Pandit courses from the States of Andhra Pradesh will not be
                               considered for the academic session 2009-2010 and all such applications
                               shall be returned along with processing fees and documents.


                                                      173


   (Gangadharaiah)                                                          (Prof. C. Thangamuthu)
   Regional Director, SRC, NCTE                                               Chairman, SRC, NCTE
                                                                                th
                                                                 Minutes of 204 Meeting of SRC
                                                                                th  th
                                                                              27 -28 April 2011
                       The SRC in its 169th meeting held on 12-13th January, 2009 having
                       considered the letter dated 7.1.2009 of State Government of Andhra
                       Pradesh and decided to give effect to the decision of above decision of
                       State Government of Andhra Pradesh as such, with immediate effect.

                       Further, a letter dated 07.02.2009 forwarded by Principal Secretary of
                       Education requesting not to accord further recognition/permission to the
                       new colleges/private B.Ed , D.Ed, Physical Education, Language Pandit
                       in the state of Andhra Pradesh as the above colleges are exceeding in
                       numbers than required.

                       Meanwhile, a letter dated 17.03.2009 has been received from NCTE
                       Hqrs informing that the “ The recommendations of the Govt. of Andhra
                       Pradesh not to grant recognition/ permission in respect of other courses
                       like B.Ed , D.Ed and Physical Education courses have further been
                       considered in NCTE and it has been decided that no further
                       recognition/Permission to any institution in the state of Andhra Pradesh
                       be considered by SRC for the academic session 2009-10 for B.Ed , D.Ed
                       and physical Education Courses also”.

                       Further the state Government vide its letter dated 20.03.2009 informed
                       that it has been decided not to recommend the name of this institution.

                       The letters dated 07.01.2009, 07.02.2009, 17.03.2009 and 20.03.2009
                       were considered by SRC in its 172nd meeting held on 25th-26th March
                       2009 and SRC decided to accept the recommendation of the State
                       Government of Andhra Pradesh, not to grant recognition to any of the
                       Teacher Training Institutions in the state of Andhra Pradesh for the year
                       2009-10 and decided to close the applications.

                       As per the decision of SRC the application was closed on 28.04.2009
                       and processing fee of Rs.40000/- was returned.

                       The institution has approached to Hon‟ble High court of Andhra pradesh
                       without making appeal to appellate authority under section 18 of NCTE
                       Act

                       The Hon‟ble High Court has passed an order on 06.05.2010 vide
                       W.P.No.11078 of 2010 to consider the application of the petitioner
                       without making reference to the recommendation of State Government
                       policy dated 07.01.2009.

                       The Committee considered the matter in its 193rd Meeting held on 21-22
                       June 2010 and decided to process the application.

                       The Committee considered the matter in its 195th Meeting held on 17-18
                       August, 2010 and decided to call for clarification from the institution.

                       SRC in its 199th meeting held on 22nd –23rd December, 2010 considered
                       the matter and all relevant documents and decided to cause inspection to
                                             174


(Gangadharaiah)                                                    (Prof. C. Thangamuthu)
Regional Director, SRC, NCTE                                         Chairman, SRC, NCTE
                                                                                       th
                                                                        Minutes of 204 Meeting of SRC
                                                                                       th  th
                                                                                     27 -28 April 2011
                               examine whether the institution fulfils all the requirements as per the
                               norms, for the proposed programme, subject to the condition that the
                               deficiencies, if any, were duly rectified by the institution, as per the
                               norms.

                               Accordingly inspection of the institution was carried out on VTR dated
                               07.02.2011.

                               SRC in its 202nd meeting held on 14th-15th, 2011considered the VT
                               Report, VCD and all the relevant documentary evidences and it was
                               decided to issue Show cause Notice Under Section 17 of NCTE Act.
                               Accordingly Show cause notice was issued to the institution for seeking
                               clarification on 06.04.2011. The institution has submitted its written
                               representation on 21.04.2011.

                               The Committee considered the VT Report, VCD and all the relevant
                               documentary evidences and it was decided to serve Final Show
                               cause Notice under Section 17 of NCTE Act for the following:

                                As per VCD, the present course is being conducted in a
                                 Residential Building.

                                The existing laboratory rooms and class rooms are not spacious
                                 to accommodate the students.


                                In view of the above, the Committee decided to issue a Final Show
                               cause Notice to the institution as to why the recognition be not
                               withdrawn and thereby providing an opportunity to the institution to
                               make a written representation within 30 days from the date of issue
                               of the Notice along with necessary certificates/documents in order
                               to take a final decision in the matter; failing which action will be
                               taken including the withdrawal of recognition, based on the records
                               available, with no further notice.


118.        APS09674           Sri     Vivekananda        College     of     Education,Prabhu
               D.Ed            EducationalSociety,No.590/1,       59/1/2,       Mahabubabad,
         Sri Vivekananda       Edulapussapally Road, Warangal-506101, Andhra Pradesh.
       College of Education,
             Warangal          An application was submitted by Prabhu Educational Society, Warangal,
                AP             Andhra Pradesh for grant of recognition to D.Ed course in the office of
                               SRC-NCTE, Bangalore vide dated 30.10.2008.

                                The file was under process and in the meanwhile, in view of the
                               recommendation of the state Government of Andhra pradesh vide letter
                               dated 07.01.2009 not to further recognize/permit the institutions for
                               conducting B.Ed, D.Ed, Physical Education, Language Pandit Course(s).


                                                     175


   (Gangadharaiah)                                                        (Prof. C. Thangamuthu)
   Regional Director, SRC, NCTE                                             Chairman, SRC, NCTE
                                                                                   th
                                                                    Minutes of 204 Meeting of SRC
                                                                                   th  th
                                                                                 27 -28 April 2011



                       SRC in its 169th Meeting held on 12-13th January, 2009 meeting held on
                       12-13th January, 2009 having considered the letter dated 07.01.2009 of
                       state Government of Andhra Pradesh and decided to give effect to the
                       decision of above decision of state Government of Andhra Pradesh as
                       such, with immediate effect. A letter dated 07.02.2009 forwarded by
                       Principal Secretary of Education requesting not to accord further
                       recognition/permission to the new colleges/private B.Ed, D.Ed, Physical
                       Education, Language Pandit in the state of Andhra Pradesh as the above
                       colleges are exceeding in numbers than required letter dated 17th March,
                       2009 has been received from NCTE Hqrs informing that the “The
                       recommendations of the Govt. of Andhra Pradesh not to grant
                       recognition/permission in respect of other courses like B.Ed, D.Ed and
                       Physical Education courses have further been considered in the NCTE
                       and it has been decided that no further recognition/permission to any
                       institution in the state of Andhra Pradesh be considered by SRC for the
                       academic session 2009-10 for B.Ed, D.Ed and Physical Education
                       courses also”. The state Government vide letter dated 20.03.2009
                       informed that it has been decided not to recommend the name of your
                       institution. The letters dated 07.01.2009, 07.02.2009, 17.03.2009 and
                       20.03.2009 was considered by SRC in its 172nd meeting held on 25th –
                       26th March 2009 and SRC decided to accept the recommendation of the
                       state Government of Andhra Pradesh, not to grant recognition to any of
                       the Teacher Training Institutions in the state of Andhra Pradesh for the
                       year 2009-10 and decided to close the applications. As per decision of
                       SRC the withdrawal order issued on 18.04.2009.

                       The Institution has approached to Honorable High Court in W.P 26814 of
                       2010. The Honorable High Court has directed vide dared 29-10-2010.
                       The Honorable High Court has passed an order

                       “It may be true that the state Government as well as the first respondent
                       have reviewed the situation as to the necessity or otherwise of according
                       permission to establish new colleges of education in the state in future
                       and that the existing institutions are found to be adequate. However , the
                       right that is accrued to the petitioners on the basis of their application and
                       the consideration thereof by the first respondent cannot be taken away
                       on account of the change of policy. It is settled principle of law that
                       whenever an application is made, it must be considered and processed in
                       accordance with the provisions of law or the policy that existed as on the
                       date of presentation. Subsequent changes may apply to the applications
                       that are made there after‟.

                       Hence, this writ Petition is also disposed of reiterating the same
                       directions as noticed supra. No costs.”

                       SRC had issued a deficiency letter dated 30.10.2008. The institution had
                       submitted its reply dated 05.10.09.

                                               176


(Gangadharaiah)                                                       (Prof. C. Thangamuthu)
Regional Director, SRC, NCTE                                            Chairman, SRC, NCTE
                                                                                           th
                                                                           Minutes of 204 Meeting of SRC
                                                                                          th  th
                                                                                        27 -28 April 2011
                               SRC in its 198th meeting held on 24th –26th November, 2010 considered
                               the matter and all relevant documents and decided to cause inspection to
                               examine whether the institution fulfils all the requirements as per the
                               norms, for the proposed programme, subject to the condition that the
                               institution had rectified the deficiencies, if any, as per the norms.
                               Accordingly inspection of the institution was carried out on 19.01.2011.

                               SRC in its 201st meeting held on 22nd-23rd February, 2011 considered the
                               VT Report, VCD and all the relevant documentary evidences and it was
                               decided to issue Show cause Notice Under Section 17 of NCTE Act .
                               Accordingly, a notice was issued to the institution for seeking clarification
                               on 18.03.2011. The institution has submitted its written representation on
                               15.04.2011.

                               The committee decided to call remarks from the VT members
                               immediately for the following:

                               The tampering/overwriting ( applying white fluid) of essential data of
                               the VT report on page – 5,6,16,19 & 21 of the VT report. The VT
                               members be requested to submit the reply within 15 days from date
                               of this letter, without fail.
119.         APS04363          Annai Sonia Gandhi Teacher Training Institute, Palayam Road, Nallur,
                B.Ed           Puducherry
       Annai Sonia Gandhi
         Teacher Training      Annai Sonia Gandhi Teacher Training Institute had submitted an
       Institute, Puducherry   application to SRC-NCTE for B.Ed course during 2005. The application
                 PO            was processed and the inspection was conducted on 19.8.2005. The
                               visiting team report was placed before SRC in its 100th meeting held on
                               23rd and 24th September, 2005. The Committee decided to accord
                               recognition to the institution from the academic session 2005-06 with an
                               intake of 50 students with some stipulated conditions. One of the
                               condition is the institution will ensure that the permanent building is
                               constructed within a period of 3 years on the acquired land.

                               The institution on their own submitted written representation dated
                               21.4.2009 with regard to shifting of college premises from temporary to
                               permanent building along with D.D. of Rs. 40,000/-.

                               Meantime, NCTE-Hqrs. has forwarded inspection report which was
                               conducted on 21.4.2009 in respect of Annai Sonia Gandhi Teacher
                               Training Institute, Palayam Road, Nallur, Pondicherry.

                               The Council has noticed from the inspection report submitted by the
                               inspection team that the institution is not running the course in
                               accordance with the existing norms and standards of the NCTE. The
                               Council, has, therefore, decided that the inspection report may be
                               forwarded to SRC, NCTE, Bangalore to initiate action against the
                               institution under Section 17 of the NCTE Act. The matter in the inspection
                               report is produced as follows;
                                                      177


   (Gangadharaiah)                                                           (Prof. C. Thangamuthu)
   Regional Director, SRC, NCTE                                                Chairman, SRC, NCTE
                                                                                     th
                                                                     Minutes of 204 Meeting of SRC
                                                                                    th  th
                                                                                  27 -28 April 2011

                       “The institution run by Sri Venkateswara Education and Charitable Trust
                       has been shifted to the present address… Palayam Road, Nallur(via),
                       Puducherry-605107 from the previous address no. 5 Madukarai Main
                       Road, Kakikalampakkam, Puducherry-605007. The trust has not
                       informed about the shifting of the institute to the SRC duly and has not
                       followed the regulatory formalities of change of premises as stipulated by
                       NCTE without getting the completion certificate from the Puducherry
                       Planning Authority, the trust has occupied the present premises and the
                       admissions for the current academic year 2009-2010 have been made
                       and the classes started. About 10 percent of the civil works have not
                       been completed as on date of visit. The following incomplete of works
                       have been observed:-

                              Compound walls/fence have not been erected,
                              The land is not leveled for playground and
                              Laboratory facilities are insufficient and ill-equipped”.

                       Southern Regional Committee in its 184th meeting held on 26th 27th
                       October 2009 considered the above matter and it has been decided to
                       cause inspection under Section 17 based on the report of inspection
                       conducted under Section 13 by the NCTE, HQ. Accordingly inspection
                       was carried out on 20.10.2010.

                       The SRC in its 198th meeting held on 24th –26th November, 2010
                       considered the VT Report, VCD and all the relevant documentary
                       evidences and it was decided to serve Show cause Notice Under
                       Section 17 of NCTE Act for the following.

                       1. The total Built up area earmarked for both D.T.Ed and D.T.Ed-Al
                          course is only 655 Sq. mts. which is grossly inadequate. As per
                          NCTE norms, a built up area of 16,000 Sq.ft is required for both
                          D.T.Ed and D.T.Ed Additional Units.
                       2. Building plan is not submitted.
                       3. Building completion certificate from the authorized Government
                          engineer is not clear.
                       4. Educational Technology Lab, Library facilities and other Labs,
                          Physical education, facilities needs to be strengthened.
                       5. The institution has not got the prior permission for shifting to the
                       permanent premises

                       Accordingly show cause notice dtd 17.03.2011 was issued to the
                       institution. The Institution has submitted reply to Show cause notice on
                       25.04.2011. Details of show cause notice issued and reply received are
                       mentioned below :

                       The reply of the management to the show cause notice was duly
                       considered. The reply of the institution is not convincing and hence
                       unsatisfactory.

                                               178


(Gangadharaiah)                                                        (Prof. C. Thangamuthu)
Regional Director, SRC, NCTE                                             Chairman, SRC, NCTE
                                                                                       th
                                                                        Minutes of 204 Meeting of SRC
                                                                                       th  th
                                                                                     27 -28 April 2011

                               Under the above grounds, the Committee decides to withdraw the
                               recognition for B.Ed. course run by Annai Sonia Gandhi Teacher
                               Training Institute, Palayam Road, Nallur, Pudducherry effect from
                               2011-12 to enable the present batch of student to complete the
                               course.

                               But, it is made clear that the institution is debarred from making
                               any further admission subsequent to the date of issue of this order.

                               The Affiliating body / Examining board / body be informed
                               accordingly.
                               Further decided to return Endowment funds and Reserve fund
                               deposited with SRC NCTE, Bangalore.


120.        APS09473           Shanthinikethan College of Education, Miryalguda,            Nalgonda
               D.Ed            District-508207 Andhra Pradesh
         Shanthinikethan
       College of Education,   An application was submitted by Shantinikethan Education Society for
             Nalgonda          Women, Nalgonda, A.P for grant of recognition to D.Ed course in the
                AP             office of SRC-NCTE, Bangalore vide dated 17.04.2008.

                               The file was under process and in the meanwhile, in view of the
                               recommendations of the State Government of Andhra Pradesh vide letter
                               dated 07.01.2009 not to further recognize/permit the institutions for
                               conducting B.Ed, D.Ed, Physical Education, Language Pandit course(s),
                               to this effect that application for B.Ed, D.Ed, Physical Education,
                               Language Pandit courses from the States of Andhra Pradesh will not be
                               considered for the academic session 2009-2010 and all such applications
                               shall be returned along with processing fees and documents.
                               The SRC in its 169th meeting held on 12-13th January, 2009 having
                               considered the letter dated 7.1.2009 of State Government of Andhra
                               Pradesh and decided to give effect to the decision of above decision of
                               State Government of Andhra Pradesh as such, with immediate effect.

                               Further, a letter dated 07.02.2009 forwarded by Principal Secretary of
                               Education requesting not to accord further recognition/permission to the
                               new colleges/private B.Ed , D.Ed, Physical Education, Language Pandit
                               in the state of Andhra Pradesh as the above colleges are exceeding in
                               numbers than required.

                               Meanwhile, a letter dated 17.03.2009 has been received from NCTE
                               Hqrs informing that the “ The recommendations of the Govt. of Andhra
                               Pradesh not to grant recognition/ permission in respect of other courses
                               like B.Ed , D.Ed and Physical Education courses have further been
                               considered in NCTE and it has been decided that no further
                               recognition/Permission to any institution in the state of Andhra Pradesh
                               be considered by SRC for the academic session 2009-10 for B.Ed , D.Ed
                                                     179


   (Gangadharaiah)                                                        (Prof. C. Thangamuthu)
   Regional Director, SRC, NCTE                                             Chairman, SRC, NCTE
                                                                                 th
                                                                  Minutes of 204 Meeting of SRC
                                                                                 th  th
                                                                               27 -28 April 2011
                       and physical Education Courses also”.

                       Further, the state Government vide its letter dated 20.03.2009 informed
                       that it has been decided not to recommend the name of this institution.

                       The letters dated 07.01.2009, 07.02.2009, 17.03.2009 and 20.03.2009
                       were considered by SRC in its 172nd meeting held on 25th-26th March
                       2009 and SRC decided to accept the recommendation of the State
                       Government of Andhra Pradesh, not to grant recognition to any of the
                       Teacher Training Institutions in the state of Andhra Pradesh for the year
                       2009-10 and decided to close the applications.

                       As per the decision of SRC the application was closed on 22.04.2009

                       The institution has approached the Hon‟ble High court of Andhra Pradesh
                       W.P.11038/2009 without making appeal to appellate authority under
                       section 18 of NCTE Act

                       The Hon‟ble High Court has passed an order on 23.09.2010 vide
                       W.P.M.P.No.30904 of 2010 in W.P. No. 24142/2010 as under:-

                         “In the light of the orders passed by this court in the similar writ
                       petitions W.P.No. 6712/2009, W.P.no. 9360/2010 and W.P. no.
                       11078/2010 there shall be a direction to the first respondent to consider
                       the petitioner‟s application for starting D.Ed course in accordance with
                       law without reference to the state Govt‟s Policy dated 07.01.2009.”

                       The SRC considered the Hon‟ble court orders and all the relevant
                       documents and decided to take further action in the matter, subject to the
                       fulfillment of all the requirements by the institution as per the norms and
                       regulations.

                       As per the decision of SRC a deficiency letter was issued to the
                       institution on 16.11.2010.

                       In reply to the letter dated 16.11.2010 institution submitted its written
                       representation on 30.11.2010.

                       The SRC in its 199th meeting held on 22-23 December 2010 considered
                       the matter and all relevant documents and decided to cause inspection to
                       examine whether the institution fulfils all the requirements as per the
                       norms, for the proposed programme, subject to the condition that the
                       deficiencies, if any, were duly rectified by the institution, as per the
                       norms. The inspection was conducted on 07.02.2011.

                       SRC in its 201st meeting held on 22nd-23rd February, 2011considered the
                       VT Report, VCD and all the relevant documentary evidences and it was
                       decided to issue Show cause Notice Under Section 17 of NCTE Act
                       Accordingly, Show cause notice was issued to the institution for seeking
                       clarification on 18.03.2011. The institution has submitted its written
                                              180


(Gangadharaiah)                                                     (Prof. C. Thangamuthu)
Regional Director, SRC, NCTE                                          Chairman, SRC, NCTE
                                                                                        th
                                                                         Minutes of 204 Meeting of SRC
                                                                                        th  th
                                                                                      27 -28 April 2011
                             representation on 16.04.2011.

                             On careful perusal of the original file of the institution, court order,
                             written representation of the institution to the show cause notice
                             and other related documents, Act of NCTE, 1993, Regulations and
                             guidelines of NCTE published from time to time laid on the table, the
                             Regional Committee decided to issue Letter of Intent for grant of
                             recognition to D.Ed course of two years duration with an annual
                             intake of 50(Fifty only)(one unit) for the academic year 2011-12
                             subject to the appointment of qualified staff through duly
                             constituted selection committee as per the Norms of NCTE/State
                             Government/Affiliating University and be given effect before the
                             commencement of the academic session.


121.       APS06034          Thorrur College of Education, Khammam District, Andhra Pradesh has
              B.Ed           made an application for B.Ed course to Southern Regional Committee,
        Thorrur College of   NCTE, Bangalore.
       Education, Warangal
               AP            The application was processed and after considering the report of the
                             Visiting Team as well as other relevant materials granted recognition to
                             the institution for offering B.Ed course with an intake of 100 students from
                             the session 2002 -2003 vide order No.678 dated 12.04.2007.
                             The Registrar, Kakatiya University, Warangal vide letter dt.14.03.2008
                             drawn the attention of Regional Director, SRC and informed that in the
                             process of granting temporary affiliation to the institutions the university
                             conducted inspection and observed that the institution is located in a
                             Commercial Complex. The ground floor is full of shops, first floor is
                             residential complex and second floor is accommodated for temporary
                             B.Ed. course.
                             The letter was placed before the SRC in its 157th meeting held on 23rd-
                             24th April 2008. The SRC after careful consideration of all aspects
                             decided to issue show cause notice. Accordingly, a show cause notice
                             was issued on 28.05.2008 to the institution. In response to the notice the
                             applicant institution replied on 25.08.2008 as under” the construction of
                             the building for permanent accommodation to the Thorrur College of
                             Education was completed recently. Due to heavy rain it was delayed for
                             few days. This college will be shifted to the newly constructed premises
                             on 10.09.2008 from the existing temporary accommodation premise”.
                             The reply was placed before SRC in its 161st meeting held on 6th-7th
                             August 2008. The SRC has decided and resolved to cause inspection
                             under Section 17 to verify the infrastructural and instructional facilities.


                             The SRC-NCTE conducted an inspection of the institution under section
                             17 of NCTE Act 1993 on 16.09.2008. The report received from the
                             visiting team informs as follows: That management is not ready to face
                             the inspection now on 16.09.2008 because of various factors and asked
                                                    181


   (Gangadharaiah)                                                         (Prof. C. Thangamuthu)
   Regional Director, SRC, NCTE                                              Chairman, SRC, NCTE
                                                                                   th
                                                                   Minutes of 204 Meeting of SRC
                                                                                  th  th
                                                                                27 -28 April 2011
                       for postponement of the inspection by three more months. The institution
                       not cooperated in carrying out inspection of institution as per the
                       Provisions of NCTE Act.
                       Therefore, the SRC-NCTE in its 165th meeting held on 27th-28th
                       September, 2008 on careful perusal of the original file of the institution,
                       two visiting team report under section 14 & 17, the letter dated
                       14.03.2008 from the Registrar, Kakatiya University, Warangal to the
                       Regional Director, SRC and the reply dated.21.06.2008 to the show
                       cause notice issued to the institution and other related documents, Act of
                       NCTE 1993, Regulations and Guidelines issued from time to time laid on
                       the table, the Regional Committee noted the following:-

                       The institution is Located in a Commercial Complex which is not in
                          consonance with the NCTE Norms and Standards.
                       The ground floor is full of shops, first floor is residential complex and
                          second floor is accommodating temporary B.Ed. course.
                       The institution in its application dated.29.12.2005 submitted SRC- NCTE
                          informed in writing that the construction of own building shall be
                          completed by December 2006. It failed to comply its on statement.
                       The institution did not cooperate with the visiting team in carrying out
                          inspection under section 17 on 16.09.2008. This is considered as an
                          act of defiance and unbecoming of an educational institution.
                       The institution violated the provisions contained under various sections of
                          NCTE Act and regulations there under.
                          Accordingly a withdrawal order was issued to the institution on
                       06.10.2008.

                      After that the institution has approached the Appellate Authority, New
                      Delhi wherein the appellate authority has directed as under:-
                               “ After perusal of documents, memorandum of appeal, affidavit, VT
                               report and after hearing oral arguments advanced during hearing, the
                               Council reached the conclusion that there was no ground to accept the
                               appeal and that it should be rejected. Accordingly, the appeal was
                               rejected and SRC‟s order dated 06.10.2008 was confirmed
                       In this regard, institution has approached the Hon‟ble High Court of
                       Andhra Pradesh at Hyderabad in W.P.No.29224 of 2009
                       An order dated 31.12.2009 in W.P.No.29224 of 2009 has been received
                       in the office of SRC on 25.01.2010, wherein the Hon‟ble High court has
                       directed as under:-
                       “There shall interim suspension of the impugned order dated 06.11.2009
                       passed 1st respondent in rejecting the appeal file by the petitioner
                       confirming the orders passed by the 2nd respondent vide proceedings
                       F.SRO/NCTE/Ref/2008-09/5464 dated 06.10.2008. However, it is
                       directed that the petitioner shall be entitled to run the B.Ed college in the
                       next academic year, only after the premises in which the college is to be
                       located is approved by the competent authority.
                       Also an court order dated 18.01.2010 has been received in the office of
                                              182


(Gangadharaiah)                                                      (Prof. C. Thangamuthu)
Regional Director, SRC, NCTE                                           Chairman, SRC, NCTE
                                                                                 th
                                                                  Minutes of 204 Meeting of SRC
                                                                                 th  th
                                                                               27 -28 April 2011
                       SRC as under:-
                       Interim order granted earlier is extended by four (4) weeks. Post after two
                       weeks.
                       The Judgment copy was placed along with original file before SRC in its
                       189th held on 25th – 26th Feb, 2010, the Southern Regional Committee
                       decided to await for the court orders.

                       Further SRC has received another court order dated 19.07.2010 as
                       under :-

                          “It is the case of the petitioner-college that it has rectified the
                          deficiencies pointed out during the earlier inspection in the year 2008
                          and submitted an application with the requisite fee on 29.03.2010
                          seeking inspection. As the order of this Court Dt:31-12-2009 required
                          the petitioner-college to be inspected and approved by the competent
                          authority prior to its operation in the next academic year 2010-2011,
                          there shall be an interim direction as prayed for”.
                       The matter was considered by the Committee and it was decided to
                       cause inspection of the institution for B.Ed. Course, under Section 17 of
                       NCTE Act, on payment of Rs.40,000/- inspection fee and on submission
                       of filled in Questionnaire, along with relevant supporting documents
                       relating to building, land, including Building Completion Certificate from
                       the competent Government Engineer and Land Use Certificate, within
                       four weeks from the date of confirmation of the Minutes.

                       Institution has submitted D.D of Rs. 40,000/- vide letter dated
                       21.07.2010, along with the data. The inspection was conducted on
                       15.09.2010.

                       The Committee in its 197th Meeting held on 13-14 October 2010
                       considered the VT Report Dt. 15.09.2010 and decided to issue Show
                       cause Notice. Accordingly, Show cause Notice was issued to the
                       institution on 01.12.2010. the institution has submitted its written
                       representation by fax on 18.12.2010

                       The Committee in its 201st meeting held on 22-23 February 2011
                       considered the reply to Show Cause Notice, VT Report, VCD and all the
                       relevant documentary evidences and it was decided to serve Final Show
                       cause Notice Under Section 17 of NCTE Act.

                       As per the decision of SRC notice was issued on 18.03.2011. Institution
                       submitted its reply on 13.04.2011

                       After going through the reply of the institution , Photos and VCD,
                       the committee decided to cause re-inspection of the institution on
                       submission of Rs. 40000/- towards inspection fee, as the building
                       was not visited after completion of its construction.


                                              183


(Gangadharaiah)                                                     (Prof. C. Thangamuthu)
Regional Director, SRC, NCTE                                          Chairman, SRC, NCTE
                                                                                        th
                                                                         Minutes of 204 Meeting of SRC
                                                                                        th  th
                                                                                      27 -28 April 2011



122.       APS00845          St. Pauls Teacher Training Institute, Chennai, Tamilnadu
            D.T.Ed
       St. Pauls Teacher     St. Pauls Teacher Training Institute, Chennai, Tamilnadu was granted
       Training Institute,   recognition for offering D.T.Ed course with an intake of 50 from the
            Chennai          session 2004-05 on 12.01.2005 at No.50, 70 ft Road, Periyar Nagar,
              TN             Chennai-600082, Tamilnadu with the condition to shift to own premises
                             within 3 years.

                             The institution was issued letter dt. 21.05.2009 to submit the following:

                             1. Demand Draft of Rs.40,000/- towards inspection fee in favour of “The
                                 Member Secretary, NCTE” payable at Bangalore should be
                                 submitted.
                             2. Land documents of the new building/ location for having own land in
                                 the name of the institution/ Society/ Trust.
                             3. Building Plan of the new building duly approved by the Government
                                 authority.
                             4. Building Completion Certificate from the Government authorities in
                                 the prescribed format(Format enclosed)
                             5. Land Usage Certificate from the concerned Government authorities
                                 stating that the land is exclusively permitted/ sanctioned for
                                 Educational Purposes only should be submitted.
                             6. Encumbrance certificate from the competent Government authority
                                 authority should be submitted.
                             7. Fixed Deposit Receipt of Rs.5 lakhs kept in JOINT ACCOUNT with
                                 SRC in Nationalised Bank for a period of 5 years towards Endowment
                                 Fund in ORGINAL should be submitted.
                             8. Fixed Deposit Receipt of Rs.3 lakhs kept in JOINT ACCOUNT with
                                 SRC in Nationalised Bank for a period of 5 years towards Reserve
                                 Fund in ORIGINAL should be submitted.
                             9. Certificate of Registration/ Bye-law of the Society/ Trust should be
                                 submitted.
                             10. The Affidavit in Rs.100/- stamp paper in the prescribed format with
                                 Notary attestation should be submitted.(FORMAT ENCLOSED)

                             The reply from the institution was not received. The institution has
                             submitted its written representation on 03.02.2011 for shifting of
                             premises alongwith Rs. 40000/- inspection fee.

                             Meanwhile a letter has been received from DTERT, Chennai on
                             17.2.2011. SRC in its 201st meeting held on 22nd-23rd February 2011
                             considered the matter and it was decided to issue a Final Show cause
                             Notice. Accordingly final show cause notice was issued to the institution
                             on 22.03.2011 for the following:
                              Specific Remarks on the DTERT Report to be submitted. The DTERT
                               report has stated that:

                                                    184


   (Gangadharaiah)                                                         (Prof. C. Thangamuthu)
   Regional Director, SRC, NCTE                                              Chairman, SRC, NCTE
                                                                                        th
                                                                       Minutes of 204 Meeting of SRC
                                                                                      th  th
                                                                                    27 -28 April 2011
                       “It is stated in the SRC-NCTE recognition order that the institution shall
                       shift to its own premises within three years from the date of recognition.
                       The Principal, DIET, Triplicane has visited the above said Teacher
                       Training Institute and submitted a visit report to the Director of Teacher
                       Education Research and Training, Chennai-600006.

                       On perusal of the report, a challan Rs.40000/- was remitted to SRC-
                       NCTE drawn in favour of the NCTE, Bangalore. The management of the
                       institute has not produced the copy of the proposal sent to the SRC-
                       NCTE to DTERT for shifting the Teacher Training Institute. As per the
                       Principals report, constructed area of the building in the new site is only
                       5541 sq.ft. it is stated that 1000 sq.mtrs RCC building is mandatory for
                       running a Teacher Training Institute as per Regulations, Norms and
                       Standards of NCTE. Hence, it is stated that the management of the
                       institute has not shifted the Teacher Training Institute in the fully
                       equipped own RCC building within three years and thus violated the
                       order.

                       In these circumstances, for the foregoing reasons, necessary steps may
                       be to taken to withdraw the recognition granted to the St. Pauls Teacher
                       Training Institute located at 6D, Narayana Street, Ayanavaram, Chennai-
                       600082”.

                        Non-response to SRC notice; the institution had not   cared to send the
                        specific documents as called for by SRC in its ref. Date 21.05.2009.
                        Non-shifting of the institution to a permanent premise even after a period of
                         seven years is a serious violation of NCTE norms and the conditional
                         recognition.

                       The institution submitted its reply on 01.04.2011 & 13.04.2011

                       The reply of the management to the show cause notice was duly
                       considered. The reply of the institution is not convincing and hence
                       unsatisfactory.

                       Under the above grounds, the Committee decides to withdraw the
                       recognition for D.T.Ed. course run by St. Pauls Teacher Training
                       Institute, Chennai, with effect from 2011-12 to enable the present
                       batch of student to complete the course.

                       But, it is made clear that the institution is debarred from making
                       any further admission subsequent to the date of issue of this order.

                       The Affiliating body / Examining board / body be informed
                       accordingly.
                       Further decided to return Endowment funds and Reserve fund
                       deposited with SRC NCTE, Bangalore.

                                                185


(Gangadharaiah)                                                          (Prof. C. Thangamuthu)
Regional Director, SRC, NCTE                                               Chairman, SRC, NCTE
                                                                                        th
                                                                         Minutes of 204 Meeting of SRC
                                                                                        th  th
                                                                                      27 -28 April 2011

123.        APS03593          Bethlahem College of Education, Karungal, Kanyakumari
            APS08625
            APS09080          Nesamony Memorial Trust, Kanyakumari, Tamilnadu submitted an
               B.Ed           application for grant of recognition in the name of Bethlahem College of
             B.Ed-AI          Education, Karungal, Kanyakumari District-629157, Tamilnadu for B.Ed
              M.Ed            course & B.Ed-AI.
       Bethlahem College of
            Education,        The application was processed as per the provisions contained in Rules
           Kanyakumari        and Regulation, Norms and Standards prevalent at that point of time and
                TN            the recognition was granted to the institution vide order dated 22.11.2005
                              for B.Ed course and B.Ed-AI on 28.04.2009 with certain stipulated
                              conditions.

                              As per decision of SRC in its 175th meeting held on 13th-14th May 2009,
                              the office of SRC has reviewed the files of the institution who have been
                              granted recognition either in a rented premises pending construction of
                              own building or in lease premises. A list of such institutions has been
                              prepared and placed before SRC in its 181st meeting held on 20th-21st
                              August 2009 wherein, it was decided that the institution which have not
                              shifted to the permanent premises even after the expiry of three years
                              time limit be issued notice under Section 17 of NCTE Act for further
                              action.

                              Accordingly a notice was issued to the institution on 23.07.2010 to submit
                              following documents. The institution submitted its reply on 25.08.2010
                              stating that the management decided to shift the institution to the
                              permanent premises and started the construction works. It is in the
                              finishing stage of white washing and coloring, but due to heavy rain in our
                              district for the last six months, they are unable to finish the building as
                              planned. It will take some more time to complete the building. Hence the
                              institution requested to depute the inspection team after the completion of
                              the building.

                              The committee considered the matter in its 196th meeting held on 15th-
                              16th September 2010 and decided to cause inspection for shifting of
                              premises. A letter was issued to the institution intimating date of
                              inspection on 09.11.2010. Inspection of the institution for shifting of
                              premises was conducted on 15.11.2010, the Committee in its 199th
                              meeting held on 22nd-23rd December 2010 considered the VT Report,
                              VCD and all the relevant documentary evidences and it was decided to
                              serve Show cause Notice Under Section 17 of NCTE Act. Accordingly,
                              show cause notice was issued to the institution on 01.02.2011. The
                              institution submitted its reply on 28.02.2011.

                              The Committee considered the reply in its 202nd meeting held on 14th-15th
                              March 2011. The Committee decided to wait for the letter from Tamilnadu
                              Teachers Education University regarding certificate from Government
                              affiliating body to the effect that no other programme is being run/shared

                                                     186


   (Gangadharaiah)                                                         (Prof. C. Thangamuthu)
   Regional Director, SRC, NCTE                                              Chairman, SRC, NCTE
                                                                                        th
                                                                        Minutes of 204 Meeting of SRC
                                                                                       th  th
                                                                                     27 -28 April 2011
                            by the institution in the same campus along with the existing course B.Ed
                            and B.Ed-AI in the institution.

                            Accordingly, a letter is issued to the institution on 15.04.2011. The
                            institution vide its letter dated 19.04.2011 submitted a certificate
                            No.TNTEU/R/Recog.NCTE-B.Ed/2011/194 dated 06.04.2011 from
                            Tamilnadu Teachers Education University regarding certificate from
                            Government affiliating body to the effect that no other programme is
                            being run/shared by the institution in the same campus along with the
                            existing course B.Ed and B.Ed-AI and M.Ed.

                            The Committee considered the VT report of the institution, VCD and
                            other related documents along with the original file of the institution
                            and decided that shifting to new/permanent premises is permitted.
124.      APS05395          Kamaraj College of Education for Women, Cuddalore District,
            B.Ed            Tamilnadu
       Kamaraj College of
         Education for      Kamaraj College of Education for Women, Cuddalore District, Tamilnadu
       Women, Cuddalore     submitted application for granted of recognition to B.Ed course on
             TN             30.12.2005.

                            The application was processed and recognition was granted for offering
                            B.Ed course with an intake of 100 students on 23.12.2006 with the
                            condition to shift to own premises within 3 years.

                            SRC in its 181st meeting held on 20-21st August 2009 where in it was
                            decided that the institution which have not shifted to the permanent
                            premises even after the expiry of three years time limit be issued notice
                            under section 17 of NCTE Act for further action.

                            Accordingly, notice was issued to the institution on 11.09.2009. The
                            institution vide its letter dated 28.09.2009 stated that the college owns its
                            building from the commencement of college and we declare that it is not
                            rental. The building is our own and permanent.

                            A complaint has been received from Thiru K. Devarajan, M.A, M.Ed,
                            Director of Matriculation Schools, Chennai-600006, Tamilnadu stating as
                            follows:

                            “I would like to bring to your kind attention, that one B.Ed college in the
                            name of Kamaraj College of Education (Women) is functioning in the first
                            floor of Kamaraj Matriculation Higher Secondary School in 70 Vengan
                            Street, Chidamabaram, Cuddalore District of Tamilnadu. When this
                            matter was first reported by the inspector of Matriculation Schools,
                            Cuddalore, Director of Matriculation Schools has sent a notice t the
                            management about the functioning of college of education in the building
                            of matriculation school. The correspondent wrote a letter dated 14.2.2001
                            to this Directorate stating that no such college of education is functioning
                            within the campus of Kamaraj Matriculation Higher Secondary School.

                                                   187


   (Gangadharaiah)                                                        (Prof. C. Thangamuthu)
   Regional Director, SRC, NCTE                                             Chairman, SRC, NCTE
                                                                                         th
                                                                          Minutes of 204 Meeting of SRC
                                                                                         th  th
                                                                                       27 -28 April 2011

                               Hence another inspector of Matriculation Schools, Thanjavur District was
                               asked to verify the facts and sent a report. In his letter
                               Rc.No.192/A1/2011 dated 10.03.2011 sent a detailed report along with
                               photographs stating that a college of education is functioning in the first
                               floor of the matriculation school and confirmed the report of the inspector
                               of matriculation school, cuddalore.

                               I hope NCTE rules do not permit the functioning of either Teacher
                               Training Institute or B.Ed College of Education in the premises of other
                               institutions. Hence I request you to take necessary action in this regard.

                               Photographs and copy of the reports of inspector of Matriculation
                               Schools, Cuddalore and Thanjavur are enclosed”.

                               The Committee considered the complaint from Thiru K. Devarajan,
                               Director of Matriculation Schools, Chennai-600006, Tamilnadu and it
                               was decided to serve Show cause Notice under Section 17 of NCTE
                               Act for the following:

                                The management is running B.Ed course in the first floor of
                                 Kamaraj Matriculation Higher Secondary School in 70, Vengan
                                 Street, Chidamabaram, Cuddalore District of Tamilnadu. This is a
                                 gross violation of NCTE norms on the part of the management.

                               (A copy of this show cause notice is to be sent The Director of
                               Matriculation schools, Chennai 600006, Tamilnadu for insormation.

                                In view of the above, the Committee decided to issue a Show cause
                               Notice to the institution as to why the recognition be not withdrawn
                               and thereby providing an opportunity to the institution to make a
                               written representation within 30 days from the date of issue of the
                               Notice along with necessary certificates/documents in order to take
                               a final decision in the matter; failing which action will be taken
                               including the withdrawal of recognition, based on the records
                               available, with no further notice.


125.        APS04882           Dr. Nagarathinam‟s College of Education, Salem District,
               B.Ed            Tamilnadu
        Dr. Nagarathinam‟s
       College of Education,   Chandramohan Nagarathinam Educational Trust, Salem submitted
              Salem
                               an application in the name and style of Dr. Nagarathinam‟s College
                TN
                               of Education, Kosavampalli Kadu, Ananthagoundampalayam
                               Village, Via Vennandur, Minnakkal Post, Rasipuram Taluk,
                               Namakal-637505, Tamilnadu for seeking grant of recognition for
                               B.Ed course on 28.12.2005.


                                                      188


   (Gangadharaiah)                                                          (Prof. C. Thangamuthu)
   Regional Director, SRC, NCTE                                               Chairman, SRC, NCTE
                                                                                     th
                                                                     Minutes of 204 Meeting of SRC
                                                                                    th  th
                                                                                  27 -28 April 2011
                       Whereas the inspection of the institution was carried out on
                       10.10.2006 in Salem. Recognition order was issued to the
                       institution on 08.11.2006 at No.52/7, Seelanaickanpatti, Salem-
                       636201,Tamilnadu with the condition to shift to own premises
                       within 3 years.

                       The institution vide letter dated 09.11.2009 and 15.02.2010
                       submitted Rs.40000/- for change of address:

                       Dr. Nagarathinam‟s College of Education
                       Ananthagoundam Palayam
                       Namakkal District
                       Tamilnadu

                       Following are observed in the file:

                       1. The institution submitted application for recognition of the institution in
                          Namakkal District only.
                       2. Whereas inspection was carried out at Salem District and
                          recognition order also was issued to institution in Salem address.

                       The above discrepancy found while processing the file for inspection of
                       shifting of premises. Institution has also requested that they plan to shift
                       to new building at Namakkal district and submitted fee of Rs.40000/- vide
                       their letter dated 10.2.2010 but no inspection has been conducted for
                       shifting of premises.

                       This is a case of shifting from one district to another district. NCTE
                       regulations are silent about the permissibility of shifting to another district.

                       The Committee considered the matter along with other relevant
                       documents and decided to process the application as there is no change
                       in the District and College is located at Nammakal whereas only the
                       administrative office is located at Salem.

                       The matter is once again placed before SRC as no inspection has been
                       conducted at Namakkal District at the time of granting initial recognition.

                       The committee considered the VT report and letter of the institution
                       and decided to cause inspection of the institution in the permanent
                       premises in Namakkal District (carved out of erstwhile Salem
                       District), and as the institution had indicated that the above
                       land/location for establishing its permanent premises, even at the
                       time of original application.




                                               189


(Gangadharaiah)                                                        (Prof. C. Thangamuthu)
Regional Director, SRC, NCTE                                             Chairman, SRC, NCTE
                                                                                         th
                                                                          Minutes of 204 Meeting of SRC
                                                                                         th  th
                                                                                       27 -28 April 2011
126.         APS00863
             APS04501         Joseph Chellamuthu Teacher Training Institute, Namakkal,
               D.T.Ed         Tamilnadu
              D.T.Ed-AI       Joseph Chellamuthu Educational Trust, Joseph Teacher Training
       Jospeh Chellamuthu     Institute, No.4, Arputha Nagar, Keerambur, Namakkal-637207,
         Teacher Training     Tamilnadu was granted recognition for offering D.T.Ed course vide order
        Institute, Namakkal   dated 12.01.2005 and D.T.Ed-AI vide order dated 20.09.2006 with an
                 TN           annual intake of 100 students.

                              Meanwhile the Ministry of Human Resource Development (MHRD),
                              Government of India, based on the inquiry report submitted by
                              Sri.Sathyam, IAS (Retd) has directed NCTE for taking action. In this
                              regard, it has been envisaged that all the cases cleared by SRC in its
                              116th meeting held 22-23 August 2006 should be re-inspected and the
                              maintenance of Norms and Standards should be verified.

                              The above institution was one amongst 71 institutions, which was
                              granted recognition in the 116th meeting. Based on the directions of
                              MHRD, inspection under section 17 of the above institution for D.T.Ed-AI
                              was carried out on 16.12.2008. The VT report, VCD, original application
                              file along with other documents were placed before SRC in its 170th
                              meeting held on 16-17 February 2009. SRC decided to issue notice
                              under section 17 of NCTE Act. Accordingly, a notice was issued to the
                              institution on 04.04.2009. The institution submitted its reply on 27.4.2009.
                              The SRC considered the reply in its 178th meeting held on 13-14 July
                              2009 and decided to issue notice.

                              Notice was issued to the institution on 31.07.2009. The institution has not
                              submitted its reply even after completion of stipulated period again, the
                              matter was considered by SRC in its 191st meeting held on 20-21 April
                              2010 and the Committee considered the above matter and decided to
                              serve Final Notice. Accordingly final show cause notice was issued on
                              01.06.2010. The institution submitted its reply on 29.06.2010.

                              The Committee decided to cause inspection of the institution for D.T.Ed &
                              D.T.Ed-AI courses, under Section 17 of NCTE Act, after payment of
                              Rs.40,000/- inspection fee for each course and on submission of filled in
                              Questionnaire, along with relevant supporting documents relating to
                              building, land, including Building Completion Certificate from the
                              competent Government Engineer and Land Use Certificate separately for
                              each course, within four weeks from the date of confirmation of the
                              Minutes.

                              A letter was issued to the institution to submit Rs.40000/- on 03.08.2010
                              & 27.08.2010 for D.T.Ed & D.T.Ed-AI. The institution did not submit its
                              reply. SRC considered the matter in its 196th meeting held on 15th-16th
                              September 2010 and decided to cause inspection in anticipation of
                              inspection fee. The institution submitted Rs. 40000/- towards inspection
                              fee on 08.12.2010 for D.T.Ed course only.
                                                     190


   (Gangadharaiah)                                                          (Prof. C. Thangamuthu)
   Regional Director, SRC, NCTE                                               Chairman, SRC, NCTE
                                                                                          th
                                                                           Minutes of 204 Meeting of SRC
                                                                                          th  th
                                                                                        27 -28 April 2011

                                The inspection of the institution for shifting of premises was conducted on
                                02.12.2010. The Committee in its 199th meeting held on 22nd –23rd
                                December 2010 considered the VT Report, VCD and all the relevant
                                documentary evidences and it was decided to serve Show cause Notice
                                Under Section 17 of NCTE Act for the following :

                                An Arts & Science college and a school are also being run in the same
                                building/complex. This is against the regulations of NCTE.
                                The institute has not submitted the approved Building plan from a
                                competent Govt. authority.
                                The latest Building Completion Certificate from the competent
                                Government Engineer is not submitted.
                                Duly filled in Questionnaire is to be submitted.
                                Non-encumbrance Certificate from the competent Government Authority
                                is to be submitted.
                                Along with the existing courses D.T.Ed & D.T.Ed-Al the institution is
                                running B.Ed courses also in the name of Arputha Jothi College of
                                Education in the same complex.

                                Accordingly show cause notice was issued to the institution on
                                02.02.2011 to submit the written representation within 30 days.

                                The stipulated period of 30 days has been expired, the institution instead
                                of reply stated vide its letter dated 02.03.2011 requested to extend time
                                for submitting the required documents for the show cause notice issued,
                                as the institution has applied to Competent Authority and so far it is
                                delaying to receive the same. The institution has requested for 20 days
                                time for submitting the necessary documents.

                                The committee has taken note of the request for extension of time
                                of the management vide letter dt. 02.03.2011, for submission
                                necessary documents, and decided to grant four weeks time for
                                submission.



127.        APS08772            Arputha Jothi College of Education, Namakal, Tamilnadu
               B.Ed
       Arputha Jothi College    Arputha Jothi College of Education, No.4, Arputha Nagar, Keerambur,
           of Education,        Namakal, Tamilnadu submitted an application for grant of recognition to
             Namakkal           B.Ed course in the office of SRC-NCTE, Bangalore on 31.05.2007.
                TN
                                The application was processed as per the provisions contained in Rules
                                and Regulation, Norms and Standards vogue at that point of time and the
                                recognition was granted to the institution vide order dt 28.11.2007 with
                                stipulated conditions.

                                The inspection of the institution was conducted on 2.12.2010 for D.T.Ed
                                                       191


   (Gangadharaiah)                                                           (Prof. C. Thangamuthu)
   Regional Director, SRC, NCTE                                                Chairman, SRC, NCTE
                                                                                               th
                                                                               Minutes of 204 Meeting of SRC
                                                                                              th  th
                                                                                            27 -28 April 2011
                               & D.T.Ed-AI course of Joseph Chellamuthu Educational Trust, Joseph
                               Teacher Training Institute, No.4, Arputha Nagar, Keerambur, Namakkal-
                               637207, Tamilnadu. Since the Arputha Jothi B.Ed college Namakkal is
                               also situated in the same complex and run by the above trust (Joseph
                               Chellamuthu Educational Trust).

                               The Committee in its 199th meeting held on 22nd-23rd December 2010
                               considered the VT Report, VCD and all the relevant documentary
                               evidences and it was decided to serve Show cause Notice Under Section
                               17 of NCTE Act for the following:

                                The institute has not submitted the approved Building plan from a competent
                                 Govt. authority.
                                The latest Building Completion Certificate from the competent Government
                                 Engineer is not submitted.
                                Affidavit on Rs. 100/- is to be submitted on the prescribed format.
                                Non- encumbrance Certificate from the competent Government Authorised
                                 person / Authorities to be submitted.

                               Accordingly show cause notice was issued to the institution on 02.02.2011 to
                               submit the written representation within 30 days.

                               The stipulated period of 30 days has been expired, the institution instead of reply
                               stated vide its letter dated 02.03.2011 as follows:

                               “We have applied for required certificates from the Competent Authority,
                               we are not yet received the certificates so far. Hence I humbly request
                               you to be kind enough to extend time for 15 days more for submitting the
                               required documents”.
                               The committee has taken note of the request for extension of time of
                               the management vide letter dt. 02.03.2011, for submission of
                               certificates from the competent authority and decided to grant four
                               weeks time for submission.


128.        APS02238           Smt.Sarvamangalamma Maganur Basappa College of Education for
               B.Ed            Women, Basavamandapa, Taralabalu Badavane, Davangere-577005,
               Smt.            Karnataka
        Sarvamangalamma
        Maganur Basappa        Smt.Sarvamangalamma Maganur Basappa College of Education for
       College of Education,   Women, Basavamandapa, Taralabalu Badavane, Davangere-577005,
            Davangere          Karnataka has submitted application on 31.12.2003. The institution was
                KA             granted recognition for offering B.Ed course with an intake of 100
                               students vide order dated 30.11.2004.

                               Now, the institution has submitted a letter dt.31.03.2011 for conversion of
                               Women college into Co-Education Institution. In this regard, the institution
                               has submitted No Objection Certificate from the Principal Secretary,
                               Government Karnataka vide letter dated 22.12.2010 and a resolution
                               passed on 06.06.2008 for the session 2009-2010 in Kannada. The gist
                                                        192


   (Gangadharaiah)                                                               (Prof. C. Thangamuthu)
   Regional Director, SRC, NCTE                                                    Chairman, SRC, NCTE
                                                                                        th
                                                                         Minutes of 204 Meeting of SRC
                                                                                        th  th
                                                                                      27 -28 April 2011
                              of the letter is as follows:

                              Smt.Sarvamangalamma Maganur Basappa Womens College of
                              Education is ruuning the institution for Womens only. As there are so
                              many requests coming from the public to provide an opportunity for boys
                              during the session 2009-2010, the management has decided to opt for
                              co-education. In view of the above, the management has considered the
                              matter in detail and decided to pass a resolution that from the session
                              2009-2010 Smt.Sarvamangalamma Maganur Basappa Womens college
                              will function as co-education and to write a letter to Kuvempu University
                              in this regard.

                              The committee considered the request of the management and
                              decided to permit the management for converting the existing
                              institution (APS02238) B.Ed course for Women students into a co-
                              educational institution from the academic year 2011-12, subject to
                              payment of Rs. 40000/-fee and subject to providing facilities for Boy
                              students and submission of documentary evidence for the same.


129.       APS01145            T.V.R Teacher Training Institute, Mathikrishnapuram, Manapet P.O,
             D.T.Ed                             Bahour, Commune, Puducherry
          TVR Teacher
        Training Institute,   T.V.R Teacher Training Institute, Mathikrishnapuram, Manapet P.O,
       Bahour, Pondicherry    Bahour, Commune, Puducherry has submitted application for offering
               PO             D.T.Ed course on 31.12.2002. The institution has been granted
                              recognition by SRC for offering D.T.Ed course with an intake of 100
                              students vide order dated 29.10.2004.

                              The institution in its letter dated 09.10.2009 has submitted a proposal for
                              shifting of premises along with Rs.40,000/- towards shifting fee. The
                              institution is also running B.Ed programme in the same building/premises.
                              Accordingly, inspection was carried out on 21st October 2010. The
                              inspection report has been received along with VCD.

                              The Committee in 198h Meeting of SRC held on 24th - 26th November, 2010
                              considered the VT Report VCD and all the relevant documentary
                              evidences and it was decided to serve Show cause Notice Under
                              Section 17 of NCTE Act. Accordingly show cause notice dt was issued on
                              17.01.2011. The institution submitted its reply on 10.02.2011

                               The Southern Regional Committee in its 201st Meeting held on 22nd and
                              23rd February 2011 considered the reply to Show Cause Notice, VT
                              Report, VCD and all the relevant documentary evidences and it was
                              decided to serve Final Show cause Notice Under Section 17 of NCTE Act
                              for the following :

                                      Building completion certificate from the competent Government
                                       Engineer/authority in the prescribed format is to be submitted.

                                                       193


   (Gangadharaiah)                                                         (Prof. C. Thangamuthu)
   Regional Director, SRC, NCTE                                              Chairman, SRC, NCTE
                                                                                         th
                                                                         Minutes of 204 Meeting of SRC
                                                                                        th  th
                                                                                      27 -28 April 2011

                             Accordingly Final Show cause Notice dt. 25.03.2011 was sent to the
                             institution as to why the recognition be not withdrawn and thereby
                             providing an opportunity to the institution to make a written representation
                             within 30 days from the date of issue of the Notice along with necessary
                             certificates/documents in order to take a final decision in the matter;
                             failing which action will be taken including the withdrawal of Recognition,
                             based on the records available, with no further notice.

                             The duration of 30 days given to the institution from 25.02.2011 is over
                             as on 25.04.2011. Reply received from the institution on 26.04.2011 at
                             5.25 pm along with building completion certificate

                             The Committee considered the VT report of the institution, VCD,
                             reply of the institution dt. 26.04.2011 and other related documents
                             along with the original file of the institution and decided that shifting
                             to new/permanent premises is permitted.


130.       APS04388          B.T.K. C.P.Ed College, Pudukottai District, Tamilnadu
             C.P.Ed
       BTK C.P.Ed College,   B.T.K. C.P.Ed College, Manapparai Road, Opp. E.B. Power Station, Viralimalai,
           Pudukottai        Pudukottai District, Tamilnadu submitted application on 07.04.2005
               TN            seeking grant of recognition to C.P.Ed course.

                             After considering the report of the visiting team as well as other relevant
                             materials furnished by the applicant institution in its 105th Meeting held on
                             2-3 December, 2005, SRC noted that the applicant institution does not
                             fulfill the requirements and issued a notice on 19.12.2005 to the applicant
                             institution under provision to Section 14(3)(b) of the NCTE Act, 1993,
                             thereby giving an opportunity to the said applicant institution to make a
                             written representation in this behalf.

                             Further, applicant institution had submitted the written representation on
                             24.04.2006 which was considered by the Regional Committee on 107th
                             Meeting held on 27th December, 2005 and the Committee decided to
                             seek clarification from DTERT, Chennai. Accordingly a letter was issued
                             to DTERT, Chennai on 14.02.2006. As reply from DTERT was not
                             received, the matter was placed before SRC in its 117th meeting held in
                             its 13-14th September and SRC decided to await reply from DTERT,
                             Chennai and also to send one more reminder in this regard. Accordingly,
                             a second reminder was sent to DTERT requesting for clarification on the
                             application on 11.12.2006.

                             The SRC in its 167th meeting held on 17-18th November, 2008 considered
                             the matter that even after two reminder there has been no reply from
                             DTERT. As the matter of recognition of the institution is pending, the
                             SRC decided to conduct re-inspection of the institution to verify the
                             infrastructural and instructional facilities, as the earlier inspection was

                                                    194


   (Gangadharaiah)                                                         (Prof. C. Thangamuthu)
   Regional Director, SRC, NCTE                                              Chairman, SRC, NCTE
                                                                                     th
                                                                     Minutes of 204 Meeting of SRC
                                                                                    th  th
                                                                                  27 -28 April 2011
                       three year old.

                       Accordingly, inspection of the institution was held on 09.05.2009 and the
                       VT report was considered by SRC in its 175th meeting held on 13-14th
                       May 2009 and decided to issue notice to the institution. Accordingly, a
                       notice was issued to the institution on 01.06.2009. The institution
                       submitted its reply on 30.06.2009, which was considered by SRC in its
                       178th meeting held on 13-14th July 2009 and SRC decided to issue
                       conditional recognition/letter of intent to the institution. Accordingly, letter
                       of intent for grant of recognition under clause 7(9) of NCTE Regulation
                       2007 was issued to the institution on 20.07.2009.

                       The institution did not submit its reply, the matter was considered by SRC
                       in its 181st meeting held on 20th-21st August 2009 and permitted to submit
                       the reply on or before 28th August 2009. Accordingly, a letter was issued
                       to the institution to submit reply within 28th August 2009.

                       The institution submitted its reply on 28.08.2009, which was considered
                       by SRC in its 182nd meeting held on 31st August 2009 and decided to
                       withdraw the letter of intent accorded to the institution for the proposed
                       course as per section 14(3)(b) of NCTE Act on the following reason:

                          The Management has submitted documents for appointment of
                           Principal and 5 Lecturers (One Lecturer is shortage) as against the
                           requirement of Principal and 6 Lecturers as per Norms and Standards
                           of C.P.Ed. course. One Lecturer was found not appointed and
                           documents were not submitted as per NCTE Norms and regulations
                           for C.P.Ed. course.

                       Accordingly, withdrawal order u/s 15(3)(b) was issued to the institution
                       vide order No.16923 dated. 02.12.2009.
                       The institution preferred appeal u/s 18 of NCTE Act. The Appellate
                       Authority vide its order dated 19.07.2010 reversed the order of SRC. The
                       committee considered the matter in its 195th meeting held on 17th-18th
                       August 2010 and decided to issue letter of intent to the institution.

                       Accordingly letter of intent was issued to the institution on 23.08.2010.
                       The institution submitted its reply on 27.09.2010. SRC considered the
                       reply in its 197th meeting held on 13th-14th October 2010 and decided to
                       issue notice to the institution for the following:

                        Service certificate of Principal is not submitted to ascertain the
                         eligibility.
                        Marks sheets of lecturers not submitted to ascertain the qualification.
                        Original FDR‟s of Rs. 5 lakhs and Rs.3 lakhs not submitted.
                        Website not created.

                       Accordingly notice was issued to the institution on 09.11.2010. Reply
                       from the institution is not received till date.

                                               195


(Gangadharaiah)                                                        (Prof. C. Thangamuthu)
Regional Director, SRC, NCTE                                             Chairman, SRC, NCTE
                                                                                         th
                                                                          Minutes of 204 Meeting of SRC
                                                                                         th  th
                                                                                       27 -28 April 2011

                             The committee has decided to withdraw the LOI issued to the
                             institution on 23.08.2010, as the institution has failed to submit the
                             required faculty list and other essential documents.
131.      APS02987           A.R.R. Teacher Training Institute, Thanjavur District, Tamilnadu.
          Pre-School
         ARR Teacher         A.R.R Teacher Training Institute, Kumbakonam submitted application for
       Training Institute,   Pre-School course on 11.08.2004.
          Thanjavur          The application was processed and inspection of the institution was
              TN             carried out on 04.07.2006. The VT report was placed before SRC in its
                             113th meeting held on 6-7th July 2006 and the Committee decided to
                             issue notice to the institution asking for rectification of deficiencies
                             pertaining to land, building, equipment etc.
                             Accordingly, a notice was issued to the institution on 04.08.2006. The
                             institution submitted its reply on 11.08.2006. The reply was considered by
                             SRC in its 117th meeting held on 13-19 September 2006 and committee
                             decided to reject the proposal as the deficiencies still exists. Accordingly
                             refusal order to the institution was issued on 06.10.2006.
                             The institution preferred an appeal under section 18 of NCTE Act. The
                             Appellate Authority vide order dated 26.02.2007 reversed the order
                             appealed against.
                             A letter was issued to the institution on 08.04.2009 to submit documents
                             along with details of infrastructural and instructional facilities. The
                             institution submitted its reply on 06.05.2009. SRC considered the reply in
                             its 177th meeting held on 22nd-23rd June 2009 and decided to close the
                             application. Accordingly, application of the institution was closed vide
                             letter dated 29.06.2009.
                             The institution preferred an appeal under section 18 of NCTE Act. The
                             Appellate Authority vide order dated 22.02.2010 remanded back the case
                             to SRC for necessary action. SRC considered the appeal order in its
                             189th meeting held on 25-26th February 2010 and decided to cause
                             inspection to the institution after its payment of Rs.40000/- fee.
                             A letter was issued to the institution on 13.04.2010 to submit Rs. 40000/-.
                             The institution its vide letter dated 21.04.2010 submitted Rs. 40000/-
                             inspection fee. Inspection was conducted on 29.05.2010.
                             The Committee considered the VT report in its 193rd meeting held on
                             21st-22nd June 2010 and decided to call for clarification from the institution
                             and also from the affiliating body. Accordingly clarification letter was
                             issued on 27.07.2010. The institution submitted its reply on 20.08.2010.
                             The committee considered the matter in its 196th meeting held on 15th-
                             16th September 2010 and decided to issue Letter of intent.

                             Accordingly letter of intent was issued to the institution on 24.09.2010.
                             The institution submitted its reply on 22.12.2010. SRC considered the
                             reply in its 200th meeting held on 20th-21st January 2011 and decided to
                                                     196


   (Gangadharaiah)                                                          (Prof. C. Thangamuthu)
   Regional Director, SRC, NCTE                                               Chairman, SRC, NCTE
                                                                                               th
                                                                              Minutes of 204 Meeting of SRC
                                                                                             th  th
                                                                                           27 -28 April 2011
                              issue notice to the institution for the following:

                               Mark sheets and Service certificate of Principal is not submitted to ascertain
                                qualification & experience.
                               Marks sheets of lecturers are not submitted to ascertain the qualification.
                               Staff list of institution submitted but which are not approved by the DTERT,
                                Chennai.
                               Original FDR‟s of Rs. 5 lakhs and Rs. 3 lakhs re not submitted.
                               The constitution of Selection committee of the institution for appointing of staff
                                not submitted.
                               Website details are not submitted.

                              Accordingly notice was issued to the institution on 02.03.2011. Reply from the
                              institution is not received till date.

                              The Committee considered the VT Report, VCD and all the relevant
                              documentary evidences and it was decided to serve Final Show
                              cause Notice under Section 17 of NCTE Act for the following:

                               Mark sheets and Service certificate of Principal is not submitted to
                                ascertain qualification & experience.
                               Marks sheets of lecturers are not submitted to ascertain the
                                qualification.
                               Staff list of institution submitted but which are not approved by the
                                DTERT, Chennai.
                               Original FDR‟s of Rs. 5 lakhs and Rs. 3 lakhs re not submitted.
                               The constitution of Selection committee of the institution for appointing
                                of staff not submitted.
                                Website details are not submitted.

                               In view of the above, the Committee decided to issue a Final Show
                              cause Notice to the institution as to why the recognition given for
                              pre-School Teacher Training Course be not withdrawn and thereby
                              providing an opportunity to the institution to make a written
                              representation within 30 days from the date of issue of the Notice
                              along with necessary certificates/documents in order to take a final
                              decision in the matter; failing which action will be taken including
                              the withdrawal of recognition, based on the records available, with
                              no further notice.


132.           ---            Issuance of Show Cause Notice by Tamilnadu Teachers
               ---            Education University-Dissatisfactory Compliance Report-
        Issuance of show      orders issued.
         cause notice by
       Tamilnadu Teachers
       Education University   The Tamilnadu Teachers Education University forwarded a copy of show
               TN             cause notice issued to the following institution for not functioning in
                              accordance with the conditions stipulated by the NCTE, SRC, Bangalore

                                                       197


   (Gangadharaiah)                                                               (Prof. C. Thangamuthu)
   Regional Director, SRC, NCTE                                                    Chairman, SRC, NCTE
                                                                                th
                                                                 Minutes of 204 Meeting of SRC
                                                                                th  th
                                                                              27 -28 April 2011
                       and Tamilnadu Teachers Education University as could be apprehended
                       from the report of Inspection commission which caused a surprise visit
                       to the colleges.
                       The following institution were inspected by the university and show cause
                       notice were issued on 29.03.2011 by the university:

                             Sl.   Code/course     Name of the institution
                             No
                        1.          APS04375       St. Joseph College of Education,
                                      B.Ed         Appicode, Tholayavattam Post,
                        2.          APS07370       Kanyakumari District,
                                     B.Ed-AI       Tamilnadu
                        3.          APS08865
                                      M.Ed

                       Copy of the show cause notice of the above institutions issued by
                       the university is enclosed.

                       The Committee considered the show cause notice issued by Tamil
                       Nadu Teacher Education University and it was decided to serve
                       Show cause Notice for all the courses under Section 17 of NCTE Act
                       for the following deficiencies, for further action:

                        While enclosing the staff profiles of the college along with the
                         letter dt. 28.03.2009 for continuation of affiliation, the name of the
                         Principal has been indicated as Dr. (Mrs) Lily Thiyanamani Stuart
                         when she was working at St. Christopher;s College as Lecturer at
                         that time as per her statement as stated in the foregoing paras.
                        The college has not enclosed structural soundness certificate
                         issued by the Government Engineer beyond 31.05.2009.
                        The fire prevention certificate for the current period is not
                         enclosed.
                        Attested certificates of the qualifications of the Principal and the
                         teachers appointed by the college have not been enclosed.
                        The Principal and the teaching staff do not possess the
                         qualifications as prescribed by the University and circulated to the
                         colleges in the letter dt. 13.05.2010.
                        The land area and the built up area are not in accordance with the
                         NCTE norms as observed from the building plan submitted by the
                         college. As per NCTE norms a college of Education to offer B.Ed
                         and M.Ed should have 3000 sq.mtrs of land area and 2000 sq.mtrs
                         of built up area.
                        The explanation with all the document in original regarding
                         qualifications of the Principal and teaching staff, members,
                         selection committee proceedings, as per norms, land, building
                         plan, infrastructural facilities, etc. should be submitted.

                                             198


(Gangadharaiah)                                                    (Prof. C. Thangamuthu)
Regional Director, SRC, NCTE                                         Chairman, SRC, NCTE
                                                                                         th
                                                                          Minutes of 204 Meeting of SRC
                                                                                         th  th
                                                                                       27 -28 April 2011

                               In view of the above, the Committee decided to issue a Show cause
                               Notice to the institution for all the three courses (B.Ed, B.Ed-Al &
                               M.Ed), as to why the recognition be not withdrawn and thereby
                               providing an opportunity to the institution to make a written
                               representation within 30 days from the date of issue of the Notice
                               along with necessary certificates/documents in order to take a final
                               decision in the matter; failing which action will be taken including
                               the withdrawal of recognition, based on the records available, with
                               no further notice.


133.             ---           Non-Compliance to Notice, List of institutions show cause notice
                 ---           issued as per decision of SRC and reply not received even after
        Non-compliance to      completion of stipulated period.
       notice and final show
       cause notice cases in   The following institutions have been issued notice u/s 17 and final
            the State of       show cause notices issued but replies not received so far.
             Tamilnadu
                TN             I.     Show cause notice issued cases:

                                Sl.   APS0          Name       of     The Date        of Remarks
                                No    Course        Institution           Issue       of
                                                                          notice

                                1.    APS04661      J.K.   College      of 06.01.2011         Reply      not
                                      B.Ed          Education, Dindigul                       received    to
                                                                                              notice
                                2.    APS01124      J.K. Teacher Training 06.01.2011          Reply      not
                                      D.T.Ed        Institute, Dindigul                       received    to
                                                                                              notice
                                3.    APS05144      J.K. Teacher Training 06.01.2011          Reply      not
                                      D.T.Ed-AI     Institute, Dindigul                       received    to
                                                                                              notice
                                4     APS08096      Sri     Sundareshwari 01.02.2011          Reply      not
                                      D.T.Ed        Teacher       Training                    received    to
                                                    Institute,                                notice
                                                    Virudhunagar

                               1. APS04661. B.Ed. J.K. College of Education,
                               Dindigul
                               Vedasandur Rajathiammal & Rengaswamy Chettiar Trust, Dindigul,
                               Tamilnadu submitted application for grant of recognition to J.K. College of
                               Education, J.K. Nagar, Dindigul, Tamilnadu for B.Ed course on
                               21.12.2005.

                               The application was processed as per the provisions contained in Rules

                                                      199


   (Gangadharaiah)                                                          (Prof. C. Thangamuthu)
   Regional Director, SRC, NCTE                                               Chairman, SRC, NCTE
                                                                                  th
                                                                     Minutes of 204 Meeting of SRC
                                                                                    th  th
                                                                                  27 -28 April 2011
                       and Regulation, Norms and Standards prevalent at that point of time and
                       the recognition was granted to the institution vide order dated 27.07.2007
                       with certain stipulated conditions.

                       As per decision of SRC in its 175th meeting held on 13th-14th May 2009,
                       the office of SRC has reviewed the files of the institution who have been
                       granted recognition either in a rented premises pending construction of
                       own building or in lease premises. A list of such institutions has been
                       prepared and placed before SRC in its 181st meeting held on 20th-21st
                       August 2009 wherein, it was decided that the institution which have not
                       shifted to the permanent premises even after the expiry of three years
                       time limit be issued notice under Section 17 of NCTE Act for further
                       action.

                       Accordingly a notice was issued to the institution on 23.07.2010 to submit
                       following documents. The institution submitted its reply on 01.09.2010
                       alongwith photocopies of certain documents. SRC considered the reply in
                       its 196th meeting and decided to cause inspection.

                       The inspection of the institution was conducted on 23.10.2010.
                       Accordingly Show cause notice was issued to the institution for the
                       following.
                            The total Built up area earmarked for D.T.Ed & D.T.Ed-Al is
                             23621.295 Sq.ft, B.Ed is 23621.295 Sq.ft and for M.Ed is 1082.41
                             Sq.ft. The earmarked area for M.Ed programme is only 1082.41 Sq.
                             ft. which is grossly inadequate for M.Ed programme as sper NCTE
                             norms. The same is also corroborated by the management in the
                             essential data.
                           The building proposed for shifting is incomplete even after the
                            stipulated time period of 3 years and after lapse of time period of
                            more than 4 years.
                            Building completion certificate from the authorized Government
                             engineer is not submitted.
                            Language learning lab is not available.
                            FDRs of Rs. 5.00 Lakhs & 3.00 Lakhs in joint names for each course
                             from a Nationalized Bank is to be submitted.
                            Built up area is not mentioned in the affidavit.
                            The management has not paid Rs. 40000/- towards shifting fee for
                             each course being run.

                       The institution has not replied as on date.

                       The Committee considered the VT Report, VCD and all the relevant
                       documentary evidences and it was decided to serve Final Show
                       cause Notice under Section 17 of NCTE Act for the following:
                       .
                          The total Built up area earmarked for D.T.Ed & D.T.Ed-Al is
                           23621.295 Sq.ft, B.Ed is 23621.295 Sq.ft and for M.Ed is 1082.41
                           Sq.ft. The earmarked area for M.Ed programme is only 1082.41
                                              200


(Gangadharaiah)                                                       (Prof. C. Thangamuthu)
Regional Director, SRC, NCTE                                            Chairman, SRC, NCTE
                                                                                                th
                                                                             Minutes of 204 Meeting of SRC
                                                                                            th  th
                                                                                          27 -28 April 2011
                            Sq. ft. which is grossly inadequate for M.Ed programme as sper
                            NCTE norms.         The same is also corroborated by the
                            management in the essential data.
                           The building proposed for shifting is incomplete even after the
                            stipulated time period of 3 years and after lapse of time period of
                            more than 4 years.
                           Building completion certificate from the authorized Government
                            engineer is not submitted.
                           Language learning lab is not available.
                           FDRs of Rs. 5.00 Lakhs & 3.00 Lakhs in joint names for each
                            course from a Nationalized Bank is to be submitted.
                           Built up area is not mentioned in the affidavit.
                           The management has not paid Rs. 40000/- towards shifting fee
                            for each course being run.

                       The In view of the above, the Committee decided to issue a Final
                       Show cause Notice to the institution as to why the recognition be
                       not withdrawn and thereby providing an opportunity to the
                       institution to make a written representation within 30 days from the
                       date of issue of the Notice along with necessary
                       certificates/documents in order to take a final decision in the matter;
                       failing which action will be taken including the withdrawal of
                       recognition, based on the records available, with no further notice.

                       --------------------------------------------xxxxxxx-------------------------------------------
                       2. APS01124 D.T.Ed. J.K. Teacher Training Institute, Dindigul


                       Vedasandur Rajathiammal & Rengaswamy Chettiar Trust, J.K. Teacher
                       Training Institute Dindigul, Tamilnadu was granted recognition for offering
                       D.T.Ed course with an intake of 50 students on 24.10.2006 with the
                       condition to shift to own premises within 3 years and D.T.Ed-AI with an
                       intake of 50 students on 22.06.2007.

                       Recognition order to was issued to the institution at 4/360, J.K. Nagar,
                       Dindigul-624001, Tamilnadu.

                       The institution vide letter dated 20.10.2008 submitted Rs. 40000/-
                       towards shifting fee.

                       As per decision of SRC in its 175th meeting held on 13th-14th May 2009,
                       the office of SRC has reviewed the files of the institution who have been
                       granted recognition either in a rented premises pending construction of
                       own building or in lease premises. A list of such institutions has been
                       prepared and placed before SRC in its 181st meeting held on 20th-21st
                       August 2009 wherein, it was decided that the institution which have not
                       shifted to the permanent premises even after the expiry of three years
                       time limit be issued notice under Section 17 of NCTE Act for further
                       action.
                                                    201


(Gangadharaiah)                                                                 (Prof. C. Thangamuthu)
Regional Director, SRC, NCTE                                                      Chairman, SRC, NCTE
                                                                                  th
                                                                   Minutes of 204 Meeting of SRC
                                                                                  th  th
                                                                                27 -28 April 2011

                       Accordingly a notice was issued to the institution on 23.07.2010. The
                       institution submitted its reply on 31.08.2010 alongwith photocopies of
                       certain documents. Details regarding infrastructure and instructional
                       facilities submitted in proforma.

                       The SRC considered the reply in its 196th meeting held on 15th-16th
                       September 2010 and decided to cause inspection for shifting.

                       The SRC also considered the reply dated 01.09.2010 to notice for B.Ed
                       course of the institution and decided to cause inspection of the institution
                       for shifting. Recognition was granted to the institution for B.Ed course
                       vide order dated 27.07.2007.

                       The inspection was carried out on 20.10.2010. Show cause notice was
                       issued to the institution for the following on 06.012011.

                          The total Built up area available and earmarked for D.T.Ed & D.T.Ed-
                           Al is 23621.295 Sq.ft, B.Ed is 23621.295 Sq.ft and for M.Ed is
                           1082.41 Sq.ft. The earmarked area for M.Ed programme is only
                           1082.41 Sq. ft. which is grossly inadequate for M.Ed programme as
                           sper NCTE norms.           The same is also corroborated by the
                           management in the essential data. As per the norms 6000 Sq,ft of
                           built up area is required for M.Ed programme.
                          The building proposed for shifting is incomplete even after the
                           stipulated time period of 3 years and after lapse of time period of
                           more than 5 years.
                          Building completion certificate from the authorized Government
                           engineer is not submitted.
                          Language learning lab is not available.
                          FDRs of Rs. 5.00 Lakhs & 3.00 Lakhs in joint names for each course
                           from a Nationalized Bank is to be submitted.
                          Built up area is not mentioned in the affidavit.
                          The management has not paid Rs. 40000/- towards shifting fee for
                           each course being run.

                       The institution has not replyed as on to-day.

                       The Committee considered the VT Report, VCD and all the relevant
                       documentary evidences and it was decided to serve Final Show
                       cause Notice under Section 17 of NCTE Act for the following:
                       .
                          The total Built up area available and earmarked for D.T.Ed &
                           D.T.Ed-Al is 23621.295 Sq.ft, B.Ed is 23621.295 Sq.ft and for
                           M.Ed is 1082.41 Sq.ft. The earmarked area for M.Ed programme
                           is only 1082.41 Sq. ft. which is grossly inadequate for M.Ed
                           programme as sper NCTE norms.             The same is also
                           corroborated by the management in the essential data. As per
                           the norms 6000 Sq,ft of built up area is required for M.Ed
                                              202


(Gangadharaiah)                                                        (Prof. C. Thangamuthu)
Regional Director, SRC, NCTE                                             Chairman, SRC, NCTE
                                                                                                th
                                                                             Minutes of 204 Meeting of SRC
                                                                                            th  th
                                                                                          27 -28 April 2011
                            programme.
                           The building proposed for shifting is incomplete even after the
                            stipulated time period of 3 years and after lapse of time period of
                            more than 5 years.
                           Building completion certificate from the authorized Government
                            engineer is not submitted.
                           Language learning lab is not available.
                           FDRs of Rs. 5.00 Lakhs & 3.00 Lakhs in joint names for each
                            course from a Nationalized Bank is to be submitted.
                           Built up area is not mentioned in the affidavit.
                           The management has not paid Rs. 40000/- towards shifting fee
                            for each course being run.

                        In view of the above, the Committee decided to issue a Final Show
                       cause Notice to the institution as to why the recognition be not
                       withdrawn and thereby providing an opportunity to the institution to
                       make a written representation within 30 days from the date of issue
                       of the Notice along with necessary certificates/documents in order
                       to take a final decision in the matter; failing which action will be
                       taken including the withdrawal of recognition, based on the records
                       available, with no further notice.


                       --------------------------------------------xxxxxxx-------------------------------------------

                       3. APS05144. D.T.Ed-AI. J.K. Teacher Training Institute,
                       Dindigul
                       Vedasandur Rajathiammal & Rengaswamy Chettiar Trust, J.K. Teacher
                       Training Institute Dindigul, Tamilnadu was granted recognition for offering
                       D.T.Ed course with an intake of 50 students on 20.01.2005 with the
                       condition to shift to own premises within 3 years and D.T.Ed-AI with an
                       intake of 50 students on 22.06.2007.

                       Recognition order to was issued to the institution at 4/360, J.K. Nagar,
                       Dindigul-624001, Tamilnadu.

                       The institution vide letter dated 20.10.2008 submitted Rs. 40000/- for a
                       proposal for change of premises

                       As per decision of SRC in its 175th meeting held on 13th-14th May 2009,
                       the office of SRC has reviewed the files of the institution who have been
                       granted recognition either in a rented premises pending construction of
                       own building or in lease premises. A list of such institutions has been
                       prepared and placed before SRC in its 181st meeting held on 20th-21st
                       August 2009 wherein, it was decided that the institution which have not
                       shifted to the permanent premises even after the expiry of three years
                       time limit be issued notice under Section 17 of NCTE Act for further
                       action.

                                                    203


(Gangadharaiah)                                                                 (Prof. C. Thangamuthu)
Regional Director, SRC, NCTE                                                      Chairman, SRC, NCTE
                                                                                  th
                                                                     Minutes of 204 Meeting of SRC
                                                                                    th  th
                                                                                  27 -28 April 2011
                       Accordingly a notice was issued to the institution on 23.07.2010. The
                       institution submitted its reply on 31.08.2010 alongwith photocopies of
                       certain documents. Details regarding infrastructure and instructional
                       facilities submitted in proforma.

                       The SRC considered the reply in its 196th meeting held on 15th-16th
                       September 2010 and decided to cause inspection for shifting.

                       The SRC also considered the reply dated 01.09.2010 to notice for B.Ed
                       course of the institution and decided to cause inspection of the institution
                       for shifting. Recognition was granted to the institution for B.Ed course
                       vide order dated 27.07.2007.

                       The inspection was carried on 20.10. 2010. . Show cause notice was
                       issued to the institution for the following on 06.012011.

                          The total Built up area earmarked for D.T.Ed & D.T.Ed-Al is
                           23621.295 Sq.ft, B.Ed is 23621.295 Sq.ft and for M.Ed is 1082.41
                           Sq.ft. The earmarked area for M.Ed programme is only 1082.41 Sq.
                           ft. which is grossly inadequate for M.Ed programme as sper NCTE
                           norms. The same is also corroborated by the management in the
                           essential data.
                          The building proposed for shifting is incomplete even after the
                           stipulated time period of 3 years and after lapse of time period of
                           more than 5 years and 01 month,
                          Building completion certificate from the authorized Government
                           engineer is not submitted.
                          Language learning lab is not available.
                          FDRs of Rs. 5.00 Lakhs & 3.00 Lakhs in joint names for each course
                           from a Nationalized Bank is to be submitted.
                          Built up area is not mentioned in the affidavit.
                          The management has not paid Rs. 40000/- towards shifting fee for
                           each course being run.

                       The institution has not replied as on date:

                       The Committee considered the VT Report, VCD and all the relevant
                       documentary evidences and it was decided to serve Final Show
                       cause Notice under Section 17 of NCTE Act for the following:
                       .
                          The total Built up area earmarked for D.T.Ed & D.T.Ed-Al is
                           23621.295 Sq.ft, B.Ed is 23621.295 Sq.ft and for M.Ed is 1082.41
                           Sq.ft. The earmarked area for M.Ed programme is only 1082.41
                           Sq. ft. which is grossly inadequate for M.Ed programme as sper
                           NCTE norms.         The same is also corroborated by the
                           management in the essential data.
                          The building proposed for shifting is incomplete even after the
                           stipulated time period of 3 years and after lapse of time period of
                           more than 5 years and 01 month,
                                              204


(Gangadharaiah)                                                       (Prof. C. Thangamuthu)
Regional Director, SRC, NCTE                                            Chairman, SRC, NCTE
                                                                                                th
                                                                             Minutes of 204 Meeting of SRC
                                                                                            th  th
                                                                                          27 -28 April 2011
                           Building completion certificate from the authorized Government
                            engineer is not submitted.
                           Language learning lab is not available.
                           FDRs of Rs. 5.00 Lakhs & 3.00 Lakhs in joint names for each
                            course from a Nationalized Bank is to be submitted.
                           Built up area is not mentioned in the affidavit.
                           The management has not paid Rs. 40000/- towards shifting fee
                            for each course being run.

                       In view of the above, the Committee decided to issue a Final Show
                       cause Notice to the institution as to why the recognition be not
                       withdrawn and thereby providing an opportunity to the institution to
                       make a written representation within 30 days from the date of issue
                       of the Notice along with necessary certificates/documents in order
                       to take a final decision in the matter; failing which action will be
                       taken including the withdrawal of recognition, based on the records
                       available, with no further notice.

                       --------------------------------------------xxxxxxx-------------------------------------------

                       4. APS08096, D.T.Ed, Sri Sundareshwari Teacher Training
                       Institute, Virudhunagar. TamilNadu
                       Sundareswari Medical Educational Research and Social Welfare
                       Charitable Trust, Sri Sundareswari Teacher Training Institute, No.12,
                       Madavarvalakam Street, Srivilliputtur, Virudhunagar-626125, Tamilnadu
                       had been granted recognition by SRC-NCTE for running the D.T.Ed
                       course with an annual intake of 50 by SRC vide Order No.18559 dated
                       04.03.2008.

                       As per G.O. No. 94 dated 03.05.2008 issued by the Govt of Tamilnadu,
                       the DTERT, Tamilnadu had envisaged inspection of the institution for
                       affiliation for D.T.Ed course. The Director, DTERT vide letter No.
                       Rc.No.6796/C5/2008 dated 20.06.2008 had stated that the Inspection
                       Committee had inspected the institution and noted the deficiencies in the
                       institution: -

                       The said letter of DTERT was considered by SRC in its 161st meeting
                       held on 6th-7th Aug 08 whereby SRC decided to issue Show Cause Notice
                       u/s 17 and to call for remarks with documentary proof/s on deficiencies
                       pointed out by the DTERT, Chennai to take necessary action.
                       Accordingly, a notice was issued on 24.10.2008.
                       The institution has not submitted its reply even after completion of
                       stipulated period, the matter was considered by SRC in its 191st meeting
                       held on 20-21 April 2010 and the Committee considered the above
                       matter and decided to serve Final Notice. Accordingly final notice was
                       issued on 20.05.2010. The institution submitted its reply on 18.06.2010.

                       The Committee decided to cause inspection of the institution for D.T.Ed
                                                    205


(Gangadharaiah)                                                                 (Prof. C. Thangamuthu)
Regional Director, SRC, NCTE                                                      Chairman, SRC, NCTE
                                                                                  th
                                                                   Minutes of 204 Meeting of SRC
                                                                                  th  th
                                                                                27 -28 April 2011
                       courses, under Section 17 of NCTE Act, after payment of Rs. 40,000/-
                       inspection fee for each course and on submission of filled in
                       Questionnaire, along with relevant supporting documents relating to
                       building, land, including Building Completion Certificate from the
                       competent Government Engineer and Land Use Certificate separately for
                       each course, within four weeks from the date of confirmation of the
                       Minutes.

                       Accordingly a letter was issued to the institution to submit Rs. 40000/- on
                       02.08.2010 & 02.09.2010. The institution did not submit its reply. SRC
                       considered the matter in its 196th meeting held on 15th-16th September
                       2010 and decided to cause inspection.

                       Accordingly, a letter was issued to the institution to submit Rs. 40000/-
                       towards inspection fee on 09.11.2010. The institution submitted Rs.
                       40000/- on 09.12.2010.

                       The management is also running B.Ed course.

                       The inspection of the institution was conducted on 02.12.2010. The
                       following deficiencies were noticed as per the VT report.

                        Affidavit on Rs. 100/- is to be submitted on the prescribed format.

                        The institute has not submitted the approved Building plan from a
                         competent Govt. authority.

                        The total area of the space (Site) as per building plan and earmarked
                         built up area for the course is not mentioned in the building plan.

                        From the observation of VCD, it appears that there is a School
                         functioning in the same campus/building.

                        Non- encumbrance Certificate from the competent Government
                         Authorised person / Authorities to be submitted.

                       Show cause notice was issued to the institution for the above points on
                       1.02.2011. The institution has not cared to reply for the notice.

                       The Committee considered the VT Report, VCD and all the relevant
                       documentary evidences and it was decided to serve Final Show
                       cause Notice under Section 17 of NCTE Act for the following:

                        Affidavit on Rs. 100/- is to be submitted on the prescribed format.

                        The institute has not submitted the approved Building plan from a
                         competent Govt. authority.

                        The total area of the space (Site) as per building plan and
                                              206


(Gangadharaiah)                                                      (Prof. C. Thangamuthu)
Regional Director, SRC, NCTE                                           Chairman, SRC, NCTE
                                                                                              th
                                                                            Minutes of 204 Meeting of SRC
                                                                                           th  th
                                                                                         27 -28 April 2011
                             earmarked built up area for the course is not mentioned in the
                             building plan.

                        From the observation of VCD, it appears that there is a School
                         functioning in the same campus/building.

                        Non- encumbrance Certificate from the competent Government
                         Authorised person / Authorities to be submitted.