Hope to Heal Lyme
Shared by: wuxiangyu
-
Stats
- views:
- 13
- posted:
- 5/31/2011
- language:
- English
- pages:
- 43
Document Sample


Hope to Heal Lyme 2007
Hope to Heal Lyme
June 23-24, 2007
Conference Summary and Notes
By Scott (www.BetterHealthGuy.com)
version 1.3
Disclaimer: The information shared in this document is my own perspective of the information
provided at the conference. The information may or not be entirely accurate and should be
verified by the reader. As much as I have attempted to provide an accurate account of the events
of this enlightening conference, errors may exist throughout this document. As always, you
should consult your medical professional prior to any changes in your treatment program. In
conjunction with your medical professional, I encourage you to do your own research and create
your own path to wellness. Information in this document is based solely on personal notes,
conference materials, and recollection of conference presenters.
The content is provided for informational purposes only. Errors may exist and thus this
information should not be used as a single source of information.
To report any errors in this document, the author may be reached at Scott@BetterHealthGuy.com
www.BetterHealthGuy.com 1
Hope to Heal Lyme 2007
Hope to Heal Lyme ...................................................................... 1
Observations .............................................................................. 4
Dr. Joseph J. Burrascano - Lyme Disease Diagnosis and Treatment .... 5
Stages of Illness ...................................................................... 5
Testing ................................................................................... 6
Diagnosis ................................................................................ 7
Treatment ............................................................................... 7
Approach to Treatment........................................................... 8
Types of Antibiotics ................................................................ 8
Forms of Borrelia ................................................................... 9
Designing Effective Treatment ................................................. 9
Mechanism of Administration................................................... 9
Typical Regimens .................................................................. 9
Treatment Issues ..................................................................... 9
Co-infections ......................................................................... 10
Bartonella........................................................................... 10
Babesia .............................................................................. 11
Ehrlichia ............................................................................. 12
Rocky Mountain Spotted Fever .............................................. 13
Mycoplasma ........................................................................ 13
Cast of Characters Summary ................................................... 13
Treatment With Co-infections ................................................... 14
Beyond Antibiotics .................................................................. 14
Living with Lyme .................................................................... 14
Other Notes ........................................................................... 15
Dr. Kenneth Singleton – Lyme Disease Testing Principles ............. 17
Dr. Steven Bock: Road Map for Chronic Lyme Disease .................... 22
Manifestations and Symptoms .................................................. 22
Coinfections .......................................................................... 23
Lab Assessments .................................................................... 24
Nutritional Considerations........................................................ 25
Immune Dysregulation ............................................................ 25
Neurotoxin Inflammation ......................................................... 25
Integrative Therapy ................................................................ 26
Factors in Illness .................................................................... 26
Medical Detoxification ............................................................. 26
Immune Dysregulation ............................................................ 26
Anti-inflammatory .................................................................. 26
Fatigue ................................................................................. 26
Fibromyalgia.......................................................................... 26
Sleep .................................................................................... 27
GI Prevention ........................................................................ 27
Fungal .................................................................................. 27
www.BetterHealthGuy.com 2
Hope to Heal Lyme 2007
Liver..................................................................................... 27
Cognitive Issues ..................................................................... 27
HPA Axis ............................................................................... 27
Hypothyroidism Symptoms ...................................................... 27
Functional Hypothyroid ........................................................... 27
Treatment of Hypothyroidism ................................................... 27
Low Adrenal Signs .................................................................. 28
Adrenal Testing ...................................................................... 28
Low Adrenal Treatments.......................................................... 28
Estrogen Deficiency ................................................................ 28
Estrogen Excess ..................................................................... 28
Progesterone Deficiency .......................................................... 28
Testosterone Deficiency .......................................................... 28
Treatment Focus .................................................................... 29
Diane Wilcox: Chronic Lyme Disease – What It Does to our Work Lives
.............................................................................................. 29
Dr. Joseph Jemsek: Lyme Borreliosis Complex – A Polymicrobial
Mediated Immunosuppressive Chronic Illness ............................... 30
Babesia................................................................................. 31
Bartonella ............................................................................. 31
Ehrlichia................................................................................ 31
Borrelia................................................................................. 32
Life Forms of Borrelia .............................................................. 32
Other Microbes ...................................................................... 33
Treatment ............................................................................. 34
Summary .............................................................................. 35
Other Notes ........................................................................... 36
Mark Garzon: Heavy Metal Toxicity and Lyme Disease ................. 37
Mark Garzon: Bio-Identical Hormone Replacement for Lyme Disease
........................................................................................... 38
Amy Derksen, ND: Using Alternative Methods to Help Guide Lyme
Treatment ............................................................................. 41
Carol Fisch: Introducing a New Antigen Test by Flow Cytometry to
Detect Borrelia Burgdoferi, the Bacteria that Causes Lyme Disease 41
Rita Losee, RN: When Life Gives You Lyme, Make Lymeonade ...... 42
Sarah Fletcher, MD: Our Journey .............................................. 42
www.BetterHealthGuy.com 3
Hope to Heal Lyme 2007
Observations
My general observations from this year’s event:
• As always, Char Healy put on a great event. It was well-
organized, the content was relevant, and the food was great.
Even better, seeing old friends and fellow journeymen and
journeywomen has become almost like going to a family reunion.
• Much of the content discussed was similar to previous years. I
have seen little change in the past almost two years since I was
diagnosed (July 2005). That said, I do think the next 12-18
months will be more significant in terms of the changes in how
we diagnose and hopefully treat Lyme disease.
• The most notable take-away message from the conference for
me was this: Babesia and Bartonella are KEY components
of chronic Lyme disease. They are no longer just “co-
infections”. They may in fact both be much more significant in
affecting our state of health than Borrelia has been.
• Dr. Burrascano and Dr. Jemsek both presented useful content
and have both clearly done so much for all of us with Lyme. I
also enjoyed having a few moments at breakfast to talk with Dr.
Burrascano about some of his current projects.
• Dr. Mark Garzon did a fantastic job on the topics of heavy
metals and hormones and their impact on those of us recovering
from chronic illnesses. In fact, I was so impressed by the group
of practitioners that Mark has assembled in the DC area, that I
would personally be working with their practice if I were in the
area. They have much to offer.
• One of the highlights for me of the event was a presentation by
Amy Derksen ND. Amy has been one of my practitioners for
about 18 months and has brought so much to my recovery.
Often, conferences focus on antibiotic treatment of Lyme disease
and I was concerned that a presentation on alternative and
supportive options may not be well-received. Well, fortunately, I
was wrong. People were incredibly open to the information that
Dr. Derksen presented. Seeing this gave me hope that people
will find their path and that there is a realization that antibiotics
are not the entire solution.
www.BetterHealthGuy.com 4
Hope to Heal Lyme 2007
Dr. Joseph J. Burrascano - Lyme Disease
Diagnosis and Treatment
Dr. Burrascano started with a broad definition of Lyme disease. He
described it as “the illness that results from the bite of an infected
deer tick”. Personally, I felt this definition was both broad and
restrictive. I see it as broad given that it clearly suggests that there is
much more than Borrelia burgdorferi that impacts us when we have
chronic Lyme disease. It is restrictive however in that it is my opinion
that means of transmission are much more broad that the bite of a
deer tick.
Stages of Illness
Three stages of illness were discussed. Dr. B. noted that something
happens to the body after about one year of illness and the immune
system breaks down. He suggested the following three categories:
• Stage I – Early Lyme – the time before or when symptoms
appear. At this stage, the disease can be entirely cured in many
cases with appropriate early intervention. It is a mistake to wait
for positive blood tests to start treating. By the time the tests
turn positive several weeks after being infected, the disease is
much more difficult to treat. On top of that, many people will
never get a “positive” test result. It is important to be the most
aggressive at this stage since this is the stage that may actually
be curable. 4-6 weeks of antibiotics generally recommended.
Shorter courses result in higher number of failures. Even at this
stage, Lyme has spread to many areas of the body including the
CNS.
• Stage II - Disseminated – many body systems are involved and
the disease becomes more difficult to treat. May be present
even if tests are negative. Dr. B. suggested looking for
symptoms that move from place to place and vary over time.
Treatment at this stage is generally several months or longer.
• Stage III – Chronic Lyme disease – this is defined as one or
more years of infection resulting in the breakdown of the
immune system. Dr. B. pointed out that this is the stage where
serologic (blood) tests are the LEAST reliable given that most of
them are looking for immune response to the antigen
(infections) and most people in this stage do not have what it
takes to mount any such response. At this stage, the treatment
has to be aggressive and of long duration.
www.BetterHealthGuy.com 5
Hope to Heal Lyme 2007
Testing
Only 17% of people recall a tick bite and only 36% of people develop a
characteristic rash. Just over half (50-70%) of people will have a
positive ELISA or Western Blot. Dr. B. does not even use the ELISA
test. (Personal note: If a doctor suggested running the ELISA as a
screening test for Lyme, I would turn and run for the door.)
Lyme has a 4 week regeneration cycle. If you have symptoms, you
must be treated at least one month, if not longer, beyond the end of
symptoms.
Tests miss 30-50% of cases of Lyme. The ELISA is false positive 5-
10% of the time. CSF (spinal tap) is positive only 9% of the time and
PCR generally positive 30% of the time or less and this requires being
done many times. The Lyme urine antigen capture test has similar
positivity rates to the PCR. None of these are good tests.
In terms of symptoms, onset is often gradual starting with fatigue, stiff
neck, aches and pains, and headaches. May observe joint pain or
arthritic symptoms. The nerves and brain later become involved.
CD57 – lower counts are often observed in people that have been ill
longer than one year. The test can reflect the severity of illness. It
may be a helpful screening test. It is a good predictor of relapse at
cessation of treatment. The following ranges are suggested:
<20 severe
20-60 most common in chronic Lyme disease
> 60 Lyme activity minimal
> 120 Relapse not likely when treatment ends
Dr. B. suggested that testing CD57 about every 3-6 months is
appropriate. He noted that if often jumps towards the end of
treatment and that it is not a linear improvement in all cases.
(Personal Note: I have found this test to be very useful and it has
tracked well with my recovery. I did not do the test at my sickest as I
was unaware of it at that time. However, after several months of
treatment, my CD57 was 65. It later went to 84. Later to about 130
and most recently to ~160. My personal desire is to see it over 200
before stopping treatment but based on Dr. B’s comments, ~160
suggests that stopping antibiotics may soon become a reality!).
www.BetterHealthGuy.com 6
Hope to Heal Lyme 2007
Diagnosis
Dr. B. discussed a point system that he devised that can be helpful in
determining whether or not someone has Lyme disease. The point
system is discussed in his published protocol which is available here.
He pointed out what should be common knowledge by now but sadly is
not in the minds of many doctors – that is that Lyme is a CLINICAL
diagnosis. The best tests available only help to support a diagnosis.
All tests can be negative and Lyme may still be present.
Treatment
For disseminated Lyme, treatment should be continued for at least six
weeks beyond resolution of symptoms. Combination therapy is often
required. Sicker patients often require 6-12 weeks of IV followed by
oral or injectable antibiotics.
Chronic Lyme is much more complex. It is often the stage that is the
most difficult to diagnose. The range of presentation of illness is
large; from subclinical to debilitating. The infection is very difficult to
treat at this stage and may not be curable.
Why are chronic Lyme patients more ill? There are often higher
spirochete loads observed as either a result of having been infected
longer or as a result of multiple exposures. Borrelia finds
compartments in the body where immune surveillance is limited and
essentially evades our immune system. Our immune systems become
suppressed and numerous other co-infections take up residence.
Many other conditions are often observed in people with chronic Lyme
disease. These include:
• Encephalitis – can be observed on scans such as PET and SPECT.
Areas of decreased blood flow are present. The scans are not
diagnostic but can support that disease is not psychosomatic.
Scans can be done over time to show progress.
• Neurotoxins – Borrelia produces neurotoxins. These cause
further dysfunction in our nervous systems and increase
cytokines which increase inflammation. Neurotoxins can impact
hormone receptors. Testing for neurotoxins is done using the
VCS (Personal note: I wrote about this test in the Public Health
Alert. A link is available on the “My Articles” page on my site.)
Cytokine levels can be measured. Tests for insulin resistance
are useful. Treatment is with “bile acid sequestrants” such as
www.BetterHealthGuy.com 7
Hope to Heal Lyme 2007
cholestyramine. (Personal note: I wrote about the Biotoxin
Pathway in a recent edition of the Public Health Alert. That
article is also available here). Hormones find binding sites.
These binding sites / receptors are often blocked by toxins.
Hormone levels in the blood may look adequate but if the
receptors are blocked by neurotoxins, problems result.
• Heavy metals – presence increases symptoms especially
neurological. Weakens immune system and results in more
severe illness. Metals prevent recovery. Should always be
suspected in patients with increased neurological symptoms are
patients that are slow to respond to treatments. (Personal note:
I think heavy metals are a much more significant issue than
most people recognize. Treatment protocols that do not address
the presence of metals are often ineffective.) Heavy metals
poison our immune system and damage our nervous systems.
Over 90% of people that do not respond to treatment have a
heavy metal issue.
• Hormonal issues – lack of energy and stamina, loss of libido,
exercise intolerance, weight gain, hypersensitive to
surroundings/environment
• Neurally mediated hypotension – dehydration, adrenal/pituitary
insufficiency. Profound fatigue and often need to lie down.
Diagnosed with tilt table test and hormone evaluation.
Approach to Treatment
Must achieve therapeutic levels in the blood. It is critical to measure
peak and trough levels. Peak levels should be measured about 1 hour
after having taken antibiotics and trough levels 1 hour before next
dose.
It is important for the antibiotics chosen to be effective for both
extracellular and intraceullar infection. This is why it is important to
consider combination therapies. Borrelia can survive in both inside
and outside of the cells. They must further work on both bodily fluids
and in tissues as Borrelia lives in both.
Types of Antibiotics
• Cell-wall agents – must sustain high levels for 72 hours to be
effective.
• Doxycycline and macrolides such as Biaxin and Zithromax –
Need a spike in blood levels. Taking at one time during the day
is better than taking throughout the day. IV is better here to
obtain a spike.
• Metronidazole requires sustained level for at least 2 weeks.
www.BetterHealthGuy.com 8
Hope to Heal Lyme 2007
Forms of Borrelia
• Spirochete – has a cell wall. Penicillins, cephalosporins,
Primaxin, Vancomycin
• L-Forms – has no cell wall. Tetracyclines and Erythromycins.
• Cyst – protected form. Difficult to kill. Use Flagyl, Tinidazole,
and possibly Rifampin,
Designing Effective Treatment
Combine antibiotics to target intracellular and extraceullar, body fluids
and tissues, all three known forms (spirochete, L-form, cyst).
Mechanism of Administration
Oral antibiotics provide slight benefit. IM antibiotics such as Bicillin-LA
are more effective than orals. IV is the most effective.
IV is appropriate when: abnormal spinal fluid, synovitis, illness longer
than one year, over 60, acute illness in first trimester, acute carditis,
other immune deficiency, prior use of steroids, or when other
treatments fail.
Typical Regimens
• Oral – Cefuroxime + Biaxin OR Augmentin XR + Ketek
• IM – Bicillin LA + Biaxin
• IV – Rocephin + Ketek OR Vancomycin + Biaxin
• Flagyl can be added to any of the above and is often pulsed.
Treatment Issues
Infection often persists despite treatment. Relapses do occur.
Additional treatment is sometimes required. Prolonged treatment is
usually required.
Supportive therapies are important. One must look at heavy metals,
neurotoxins, hormonal issues.
Blood levels of antibiotics should be confirmed.
May need to rotate regimens though generally suggests to stick with
one treatment approach for at least 3 months.
The speed of recovery is tied to the cycle of Borrelia. Stronger drugs
do not shorten the treatment time required. Find a program that
works and stick to it. Change only when a plateau is reached and
symptoms are still present.
www.BetterHealthGuy.com 9
Hope to Heal Lyme 2007
Do not cut down doses. When it is time to stop, stop. Cutting down
doses may lead to treatment resistance.
Exercise is a MUST. We will not get well without exercise. A light
weight or stretch program is suggested. As tolerated, increase. Not
exercising reduces chances of recovery and increases changes of
relapse. Aerobic exercise may reduce T-cell count more than weight
training.
If CD57 not in a reasonable range, cessation of treatment likely will
lead to relapse.
Maintenance therapy may be required as the infection is often not
cured entirely.
Some signs of continued infection include fevers, synovitis, four-week
cycle of symptoms, migrating symptoms, PCR positive results, low
CD57.
Co-infections
Bartonella
If there was one message that I took away from this conference it was
that Bartonella and Babesia are a MUCH larger part of the problem
than we likely ever suspected in the past. I think this will be the big
news of the next 12-18 months. (Personal note: Dr. James Schaller
has already released a book on Babesia and his upcoming book on
Bartonella is likely to change how we think about Lyme disease. It is
my current opinion that the co-infection testing from Fry Labs is likely
the best available and is appropriate to have performed.)
Co-infections are nearly universal. Symptoms become more vague
and overlapping. Tests become less reliable. Patients with co-
infections are more ill and more difficult to treat. Standard Lyme
treatments does not begin to treat Bartonella, Babesia, viruses, etc.
Specific treatments much be used for each of these. Co-infections
may be the cause of what is often perceived as treatment-resistant
Lyme.
The primary co-infections observed are Bartonella, Babesia, Ehrlichia,
Mycoplasma, viruses, and a host of yet to be identified microbes.
viruses, and a host of yet to be identified microbes. (Personal note:
www.BetterHealthGuy.com 10
Hope to Heal Lyme 2007
Nematodes have even been found it ticks. What are nematodes?
WORMS!).
Dr. B. refers to Bartonella as BLO or Bartonella-like organisms. He
was clear in that BARTONELLA IS MORE PREVALENT IN TICKS
THAN BORRELIA. He noted that clinically, these appear to be
different than the Bartonella that causes Cat Scratch Disease and
suggested that they may be Tularemia.
Sadly, testing for Bartonella is also quite poor. Up to 80% of clinically
defined cases are missed with blood and PCR tests.
When nervous system / CNS symptoms are out of proportion with the
rest of the symptoms, consider Bartonella.
Encephalitis, irritability, anxiety. Insomnia, seizures, gastritis, rashes,
tender skin nodules, sore soles of feet, AM fevers, and light night
sweats are observed with Bartonella. Nodules on the outside of the
thigh or under the arms are often observed,
Treatment of BLO is:
• Levaquin is the drug of choice. 500mg daily with proton pump
inhibitor. Tendon damage primary side effect.
• Cell-wall drugs used for Lyme are ineffective though may be
synergistic with Levaquin. Remember bartonella is usually
intracellular and cell-wall drugs do not reach the intracellular
spaces.
• Erythromycins are totally ineffective. These may even inhibit the
Levaquin therapy. Biaxin and Zithromax also ineffective.
• Rifampin and Flagyl may be alternative treatments.
• Response to doxycyclines are varied but generally poor.
• Combination therapies may be required.
• Treatment should last 1-3 (or more) months
Babesia
Babesia species are incredibly common and not to be overlooked.
Many different species exist – at least 27. There are only tests
available for two (Babesia microti and Babesia WA-1 which was
recently renamed to Babesia duncani).
The WA-1 strain is more difficult to treat than the microti strain.
www.BetterHealthGuy.com 11
Hope to Heal Lyme 2007
Tests are again insensitive and often miss the presence of these
organisms.
Babesia, like Borrelia, is immunosuppressive. It renders Lyme more
damaging and more difficult to treat.
Blood smears looking for Babesia are generally useful only for acute
Babesia infection. In acute infection, 30% of cells may be infected. In
chronic, it may be ½ to 1 percent.
Acute infection – abrupt onset, mild to severe, can be fatal.
Chronic infection – symptoms blend with Lyme and are often missed.
Symptoms of acute infection – sweats, high fever, chills, headaches,
dark urine, anemia, severe illness.
Serologic tests generally convert within one week but are not always
reliable.
Symptoms of chronic infection – marked night sweats which cycle
every few days, air hunger, cough, persistent headaches, fatigue, off-
balance.
Treatment of Babesia is:
• Babesia is a parasite and thus not treated with antibiotics.
• Babesia can be treated while on antibiotics and other Lyme
treatments.
• Clindamycin and quinine are rarely used.
• Mepron 5cc twice daily plus Zithromax 600mg daily for 4-6
months.
• Do not take doxycycline while on Mepron as it lowers
effectiveness.
• Malarone – six tablets daily
• Can add Bactrim DS – 2-4 daily.
• Can add metronidazole (Flagyl) 750-1500 mg daily.
• Artemisinin may be helpful but do not take with CoQ-10.
Ehrlichia
Ehrlichia is less common than the other tick-borne infections (Personal
note: Aren’t I lucky? I got this one too! ☺). As with the others, there
are chronic and acute forms of the illness.
www.BetterHealthGuy.com 12
Hope to Heal Lyme 2007
Acute generally starts with high fever, muscle pain, headache, low
white blood cell (WBC) counts, and elevated liver enzymes.
The chronic form most commonly presents with headaches, muscle
soreness.
Can be tested with serological tests, PCR, or smear.
Is generally treated with doxycycline or fluoroquinolones such as
Levaquin, or Rifampin for 2-4 weeks.
Rocky Mountain Spotted Fever
From dog tick. Quick onset. Generally has a rash with large spots
including the hands and feet. Headache, fever, and body pains. Low
WBC, elevated liver enzymes. Can result in death. Responds to
doxycycline. (Personal note: I have seen people with RMSF positive
tests with no rash presentation.)
Mycoplasma
Mycoplasma becomes a significant issue when the immune system is
down from other infections such as Lyme.
Dr. B. suggested that as he looked back through old patient charts,
those people that never really got well all had mycoplasma infections.
Antibody tests will often be positive as most people have been
exposed at some point in life. PCR is generally the preferred testing
approach.
Known as the “Chronic Fatigue” germ or as the causative agent in Gulf
War Syndrome.
Generally treated with Doxycycline and fluoroquinolone often with
Plaquenil. May need to be treated for months to years.
Cast of Characters Summary
Lyme is a multi-system infection that generally has 4 week cycles.
Afternoon fevers are sometimes observed. Illness onset is gradual.
Bartonella is likely when CNS symptoms are out of proportion with
remainder of the body. Gastrointestinal issues. Sore soles. Nodules
under the skin. Morning fevers. Gradual onset.
www.BetterHealthGuy.com 13
Hope to Heal Lyme 2007
Babesia – sweats, fatigue, headaches, air hunger, cough,
hypercoagulation, rapid onset, cycles every few days, leads to very
severe Lyme symptoms.
Ehrlichia – knife-like headaches, muscle pain, low WBC, elevated liver
enzymes, rapid onset.
Treatment With Co-infections
Lyme Bartonella Ehrlichia Babesia
Amoxicillin Fluoroquinolone Fluoroquinolone
Doxycycline Doxycycline
Cephalosporin Cephalosporin
Macrolide Macrolide /
Mepron
Rifampin Rifampin
Beyond Antibiotics
• Rest must be enforced
• No caffeine
• No alcohol
• No smoking
• High protein, low carb diet
• Vitamins and nutritional support
• Drink plenty of water
• Exercise a MUST
• Never use steroids
Living with Lyme
People DO get better. Do not get discouraged. The first step is to
investigate co-infections and associated conditions. It is important not
to have “Lyme blinders”.
Network with others in the community to find and see good Lyme
doctors.
Keep copies of all test results.
Keep daily diaries and lists of symptoms. Important clues might be
later uncovered. (Personal note: Of all the things I did NOT do well, it
was keeping a diary and list of symptoms on a regular basis. There
have been times that I asked myself “What was I doing 7 months ago
www.BetterHealthGuy.com 14
Hope to Heal Lyme 2007
when I felt better or worse than I do now?” and wished I had done
this. I suggest doing it.)
For your doctor visit: bring a summary of your condition and any
changes, a COMPLETE list of medications and ANY supplements, a list
of important questions.
Maximize your chances of recovery: The 1st, 2nd, and 3rd items on this
list was COMPLIANCE. Others included medications even if you need
to set a clock, vitamins and supplements, exercise, rest, diet and NO
alcohol.
Lose the “poor me” attitude. Dr. B. suggested that he can predict
those that will recover from their first visit based solely on their
attitude. Lose anger towards others. Pursue other interests. Don’t
become Lyme-obsessed. Enjoy friends and family. Laugh.
Other Notes
The sicker the patient, the less reliable the blood tests.
Main cause of death from Lyme is suicide. (Personal Note: A later
presenter pointed out though that suicide also prevents us from
recovering from Lyme!).
Steroids should NOT be used. The one exception is if adrenal
insufficiency exists, Cortef or other LOW dose steroids may be
appropriate to stimulate the adrenals. At these LOW doses, these may
support, not diminish, immune function.
For Bicillin-LA, 1.2 million units is about 1000mg. 3-4 shots a week
are needed + Probenecid to boost the effect of treatment.
There was a study done in Switzerland of 112 patients. The general
conclusion was that to get better, at least 1-2 courses of IV were
required.
Willy Burgdorfer found nematodes (worms) in ticks.
There is more to the treatment of Lyme than just antibiotics.
Hypercoagulation is not uncommon and is suggested to be related to
Babesia.
Alcohol makes Lyme germs more aggressive. Lyme cannot live in an
oxygen environment. Smoking reduces oxygen by 10-15%.
www.BetterHealthGuy.com 15
Hope to Heal Lyme 2007
Interstitial cystitis – often sees Borrelia and Babesia in bladder. Ketek
often gets there.
Cervical secretions, breast milk, semen etc. – why not looking at these
as a diagnostic test? Can do with PCR.
Question from audience - Can you get Lyme from breast feeding since
deer hunters eat raw meat and don’t seem to get it? Adult digestive
tracts may be better able to defend against oral introduction than
infants. We believe that transmission via breast milk occurs.
2 doses of Rocephin 4 days a week results in a better outcome than 1
dose 7 days a week.
Lyme suppresses B, T, and NK cells. B suppression results in low
Gamma-globulin. If you have low GG, IV GG often helps. GG is a
good anti-inflammatory and also heals nervous system damage.
There was some brief discussion about Vitamin D levels being low in
people with Lyme. Dr. B. responded that it is the chicken and egg
problem. Does one have Vitamin D deficiency which resulted in
immune suppression and made it easier to get Lyme or does Lyme
itself cause vitamin D levels to decline?
Question from audience – Is there any proven treatment other than
antibiotics for those that cannot tolerate them? Dr. B. explained that
illness is a balance. We either have to lower germ load or raise our
immune system. If you cannot tolerate antibiotics, then you must
focus on building the immune system.
Hyperbaric Oxygen (HBOT) + antibiotics results in a better outcome
than either alone, BUT it does not address the co-infections well.
Dr. B. talked about his latest project which is the “Lyme and
Associated Diseases Registry™”. This is a multi-page form that the
doctor and patient fill out and then send in. The form asks about
symptoms, test results, medications, etc. and then uses a complex
computer program to look for trends. Over time, it should help to
standardize and optimize treatment for the benefit of patients.
www.BetterHealthGuy.com 16
Hope to Heal Lyme 2007
Dr. Kenneth Singleton – Lyme Disease Testing Principles
Dr. Ken Singleton is coming out with a new book on Lyme in October.
His web site is www.LymeDoctor.com.
The presentation given by Dr. Singleton was on Lyme Disease testing
and focused on defining false negatives and false positives. It
discussed the various types of testing available though provided little
new information. I am anxious and hopeful that new information will
be available in the to-be-released book.
He started with a parable. Essentially it was:
• People in a land were happy
• People got a mysterious illness
• Nothing worked
• Experts tried to study the problem
• Result was the finding that all areas with sickness had cats
• It was believed that cats caused the illness
• All the cats were killed
• People were happy
• The problem got worse
• The cats were not the problem, they were part of the solution
• Cats were the natural enemy of the real problem
• The real problem was rats and fleas
This parable was the true story of the Bubonic Plague. The moral of
the story was that bad assumptions lead to bad conclusions which lead
to bad actions and policies which lead to human suffering.
After this introduction, the connection was that after 25 years, we still
rely on inaccurate blood tests for Lyme. Conventional medical
understanding of Lyme is truly medieval.
Doctors generally order an ELISA as a screening test. ELISA stands
for Enzyme-Linked Immunosorbent Assay. Blood is placed in a test
tube that contains Lyme antigens. If Lyme antibodies are present in
the blood, they will stick to the bottom and can be detected via a color
test. The test is cheap and has many false positives and negatives.
If the ELISA is positive, a Western Blot is performed. If not, the
patient is assumed to be uninfected.
www.BetterHealthGuy.com 17
Hope to Heal Lyme 2007
Western Blot is a much more accurate test. It is the most reliable
indicator. It looks for specific antibodies (IgG and IgM) to Lyme. It
uses a process where the test is evaluated on a specific strip which
allows for identification of specific positive or negative bands.
Dr. Singleton suggested that IgM is an early and powerful antibody
made by the body against Lyme. He also suggested that it persists in
the body until Lyme is under control and generally indicates Lyme
activity.
He stated that band 41 + at least one of: 31, 34, 23-25, 39, 83, or 93
are required. The Lymerix vaccine elevates 31 and 34 and thus one
may need to know whether or not the patient had the vaccine in order
to correctly evaluate the test. Sadly, many WB tests ignore these
important bands entirely.
IgG is a later antibody manufactured for future protection against
Lyme. May or may not be present with active Lyme. It is a reliable
indictor of exposure. Important bands are 18, 23-25, 28, 30, 31, 34,
37, 39, 41, 45, 58, 66, 83, and 93. Lymerix elevates 31 and 34 here
also.
Around the discussion of IgM vs. IgG, Dr. Singleton later sent me
additional information to further help explain his views and to clarify
the general principles of IgM and IgG as compared to the patterns
observed around Lyme specifically.
First of all, the comments about immunoglobulins were in the context
of my discussion of test accuracy - that is, false positive and false
negative test results. I often spend a lot of time in the office
explaining why a person tested "negative" in their doctor's office and
positive with me. Therefore, I felt it important to help the average
patient (many of which don't have much knowledge of the basics)
understand the general principles behind testing.
With that as a goal, the discussion of IgM and IgG were broad and
general principles, not Lyme-specific principles. As you are well
aware, Lyme patients can have any (or no) combination of IgM or IgG
at virtually any stage of their disease for a number of reasons,
primarily related to the fact that Lyme is such as stealth organism and
the individual's immune response may or may not be typical for many
reasons.
www.BetterHealthGuy.com 18
Hope to Heal Lyme 2007
In the book I go into a lot more detail in terms of application directly
to Lyme. But for the record and related to your commentary, here is
what I know after over 1200 Lyme patients, numerous ILADS
conferences, numerous discussions with Dr. Nick Harris and other
ILADS colleagues (including Dr. B and Dr. Ken Liegner), and numerous
articles in preparation to write the book:
IgM - is large and powerful (particularly as a participant in, and
probably inducer of, the inflammatory process), but is not as specific
(not as "tailor-made" as the IgG) and much too big to penetrate into
many body tissues. According to Dr. Harris, while we all know that it
may or may not be positive at any time in Lyme infection, it generally
is a marker for Lyme activity. (And, according to Harris, when positive
on initial evaluation and combined with the LDA, is nearly 95%
sensitive for detecting active Lyme.) Everyone (even the IDSA group)
would agree that some bands (such as 34 and possibly 31) tend to be
positive in later untreated Lyme. With treatment, the IgM levels may
go up, down, or stay the same. Therefore it is not a good "staging
marker" in Lyme (which is the reason that many of us use it for initial
diagnosis but don't find it useful to follow serially in chronic LD). But
again, in terms of general immunology principles, I think it was
important that the average listener know, in the context of my
discussion, that generally IgM is the "early antibody" that is involved in
acute inflammation.
IgG - is smaller and much more specific for the particular strain
involved. It may be positive early or late, and does in fact indicate
exposure and not necessarily activity. (Activity is based on clinical
findings and not laboratory findings, although CD57 may be somewhat
useful in many, but not all, cases.) While the goal of "immunity from
future infection" is to have specific IgG antibodies against the invading
organism, the variety of strains (combined with Lyme's sneakiness in
hiding from the immune system) makes immunity very unlikely.
However, everyone agrees (as you well stated) that IgG is an accurate
marker for Lyme exposure but not necessarily Lyme immunity.
What are the problems with the Western Blot?
1. The test is often done too early before antibodies are present. It
may take six weeks for antibodies to be produced after infection.
2. The patient may have a strain not being tested for by the lab.
3. The lab may have made an error
4. Antibodies are not available because they are all bound up with
Lyme organisms as immune complexes.
www.BetterHealthGuy.com 19
Hope to Heal Lyme 2007
5. Immune system is too weak to produce antibodies.
6. Antibiotic therapy reduced the number of antibodies.
7. Lyme has changed forms making it less detectable.
8. Lyme finds a way to hide out from the immune system.
9. The test was not designed for diagnosis, but for surveillance. The
test is not being used for its original purpose.
Defining terms relevant to testing:
Sensitivity – ability of a test to correctly identify a person with a
disease (a 100% sensitive test means no one is missed by the test or
there are no false negatives).
Specificity – ability to correctly identify a person not having a disease
as not having the disease (a 100% specific test means no one is
falsely labeled as having the disease or there are no false positives).
He then went on to explain true positives, true negatives, false
positives, false negatives.
He suggests that if you apply the two-tiered (ELISA + WB) approach
to testing in a group of people unlikely to have the disease, it grades
out well. If you apply to a group that is a higher risk, the performance
of this system is “utterly abysmal”. He suggests that this two-tiered
approach will miss Lyme in about 40% of cases.
Screen high risk groups with a sensitive Western Blot which includes
bands 31, 34, and 83. IGeneX or MDL were the two labs that Dr.
Singleton suggested. He noted that Stonybrook Lab will report band
31 and 34 IF the doctor specifically requests. He noted that MDL
testing is generally covered better by insurance and also stated that
MDL returns an image of the test strip with the bands for review.
Lyme PCR is specific but not sensitive. If positive, it is unlikely to be a
false positive.
Immunosciences Multi-peptide ELISA is another option. This also picks
up the European strains of Lyme.
When asked about the Bowen test, he stated that it was not specific
and that it likely picked up dental spirochetes which many people
routinely carry.
www.BetterHealthGuy.com 20
Hope to Heal Lyme 2007
Dr. Singleton and his wife Ursuline then gave a presentation on the
Lyme diet that they support. I have not attempted to discuss the
specifics of the proposed diet here.
www.BetterHealthGuy.com 21
Hope to Heal Lyme 2007
Dr. Steven Bock: Road Map for Chronic Lyme Disease
Chronic Lyme Disease Complex is a multi-faceted disease caused by
one or more infections that effect immune, endocrine, vascular, and
neurological systems. Causes multiple dysfunctions of various organs
and results in chronic symptoms including chronic fatigue,
fibromyalgia, autoimmune disease, and psychoneuroendocrine immune
and energetic dysfunction.
Health is a process. Roadblocks are opportunities for discoveries.
Patients lead the way. Trust the process.
Dr. Bock talked about Preconceptions as roadblocks such as personal
beliefs, physician education and willingness to work on a team.
Specialists can be too narrow.
He reviewed a handful of case studies.
In talking about Lyme, he stated that each case is different. < 30-
50% have a rash. <30-50% ever see a bite. Can impact cardiac
system, GI, lungs, sinus, skin, eyes, joints.
Chronic Lyme may be undertreated. Diagnosis is often delayed. Often
see false negative blood tests. Clinical diagnosis. My personal
favorite: Absence of proof is not proof of absence.
Manifestations and Symptoms
Chronic manifestations of Lyme include: nervous system, cardiac, eye,
fatigue, cognitive issues, autoimmune disease, sleep issues,
depression, headaches, pain and arthritis, sinus issues, fibromyalgia,
immune manifestations, neck stiffness, numbness, tingling, dizziness.
Pediatric Lyme - < 30% saw a tick. 20-30% have a rash. Trust
mom’s intuition. Increase fatigue, decreased energy, sleep
disturbance, joint pain, headaches, cognitive issues, memory loss,
lower performance at school, outbursts, problems reading and writing,
overwhelmed feeling.
Neurological Lyme in children – headaches, visual issues, confused,
irritable, stiff neck, fevers, depression, brain fog, fatigue, word finding
issues, ADHD, facial weakness, numb extremities, bell’s palsy, school
phobia.
www.BetterHealthGuy.com 22
Hope to Heal Lyme 2007
Psychological symptoms – irritable, depression, anxiety, tics, visual or
hearing issues, ADD, OCD, decreased school performance, outbursts.
GI symptoms – nausea, pain, reflux, vomiting.
Presentation in infants – poor muscle tone, irritability, fever, ear and
throat problems, joint pains and body aches, developmental issues,
cataracts, narrowing of trachea, delayed development, learning
disability, psychological issues.
Babesia – intermittent fever, chills in day and sweats at night, causes
increase in duration and severity of Lyme symptoms.
Treatment options include:
• Comprehensive diagnosis
• Coinfections
• Treat clinically
• Antibiotics
• Nutritional therapy
• Neurotransmitter precursors
• Probiotics
• Sleep: 5HTP, Melatonin, Herbs
• Physical therapy
• Tutoring
• HBOT
• Ondamed
Dr. Bock talked about diagnosis as those items that show sero-
positivity (ELISA, 2 tier ELISA/Western Blot, Urine Antigen Capture, C6
Lyme Peptide, Lyme PCR) and those that are considered sero-negative
(coinfection tests, ECM rash, clinical impression).
He showed the differences in test results of the Western Blot between
various labs.
Coinfections
Coinfections discussed were HME/HGE, Babesia, Mycoplasma,
Bartonella, and viruses.
HME/HGE (Ehrlichia) – headaches, joint and muscle pain, decreased
white blood cells and platelets, increased liver function tests.
www.BetterHealthGuy.com 23
Hope to Heal Lyme 2007
Bartonella – Cat scratch disease. Intracellular. Lymphadenopathy.
Rash. Diagnosed by antibody tests or PCR. Symptoms include:
encephalopathy, ataxia, peripheral neuropathy, myelopathy,
radiculopathy. Gastrointestinal, ocular, and cardiac symptoms.
In the GI tract can cause bloody stool, abdominal pain, heartburn,
gastritis, duodenitis, inflammation, vomiting. Treated with quinolones,
Zithromax + Rifampin or Doxycycline + Rifampin.
Babesia cause fever and flu-like symptoms, fatigue, enlarged liver,
enlarged spleen, jaundice, petechia (small purplish spots on the skin).
Mycoplasma responsible for chronic fatigue syndrome and
fibromyalgia. Intracellular. Immune system impacts. Vascular
problems. Autoimmune problems. Neurological and rheumatic
diseases. Difficult to treat.
Lab Assessments
• CBC
• Blood chemistry
• ESR
• ANA
• Rheumatoid Factor
• Anticardiolipin antibodies
• Serum Angiotensin Converting Enyzme
• C4 and C4 (complements)
• Lyme ELISA
• Lyme C6 Peptide
• CD57
• Thyroid antibody (TPO)
• VDRL (I think this was STDs)
• Thyroid function
• 25 D and 1,25 D levels
• B&T Cells
• Cytokines
• Immunoglobulins
• Food allergies
• B12 and folic acid levels
• Adrenal tests
• Hormone tests
• Ehrlichia (HME and HGE)
• Babesia antibodies, FISH, PCR
• Bartonella antibodies, PCR
www.BetterHealthGuy.com 24
Hope to Heal Lyme 2007
• Mycoplasma antibodies, PCR
• HHV6, EBV, CMV levels
• SPECT scan
• MRI
• ECHO/EKG
• Psychological testing
• Coagulation testing
• RBC minerals
• Heavy metal provocation with EDTA or DMSA
Hypercoagulation is an issue in Lyme. HEMEX ISAC panel as well as
other markers considered. Treatment often with heparin, nattokinase.
Nutritional Considerations
Basic: Multivitamins, CoQ10, Rhodiola, Cordyceps, Omega 3, Vitamin
C, antioxidants
Minerals and Heavy Metals – EDTA, DMSA, Cilantro, Chlorella, Garlic,
NAC, Lipoic Acid.
Immune support – Lyme transfer factors
Injectable or IV – Vitamin C, Glutathione, B12
Immune Dysregulation
Elevated 1,25 D is an inflammatory marker. Treatment may be
Marshall protocol.
Mercury pushes towards Th2 dominance. Viruses toward Th2
dominance. 80% of chronic Lyme is high Th2 which would not be
good for Transfer Factor use. 20% of chronic Lyme is high Th1.
Researched Nutritionals is the transfer factor product used.
Neurotoxin Inflammation
Toxin reaction creates inflammatory cascade. Elevates TNF-Alpha.
Elevates anti-cardiolipin antibodies. Changes seen in ACTH, Adrenals,
ADH, MSH, Leptin, Cytokine balance, IL-6, IL-10. Elevated C3a, C4a,
MMP-9. Abnormal VEGF. Abnormal VCS. Mold may be an issue.
Treatment with Actos (inhibits TNF-Alpha) and Cholestyramine.
(Personal Note: See my article on Dr. Shoemaker in a recent Public
Health Alert that discusses this in more detail.)
www.BetterHealthGuy.com 25
Hope to Heal Lyme 2007
Integrative Therapy
Detoxification, herbs, antibiotics, alternative treatments for
sleep/fatigue, immune support, fungal sensitivity.
Antibiotic treatment – multiple courses, combinations, longer
treatment, rotations, pulsing, treat cyst forms, treat coinfections.
Factors in Illness
Genetics – DR4s, SNPs
Antecedents – trauma, surgery, poor nutrition, stress, disease,
viruses, antibiotic use, toxic exposures, allergies. CMV, Mycoplasma,
Allergies, Eczema, Dysbiosis, Heavy metals.
Hormone mediators / brain chemicals – changes in cortisol, lower
DHEA, lower serotonin/epinephrine, lower melatonin, lower thyroid
hormone, low adrenal function, Th1/Th2 imbalances.
Neurotransmitter imbalances.
Signs and Symptoms – fatigue, headache, fibromyalgia, joint pain,
palpitation, inflammation, sleep problems, hormone problems, GI
problems. Autoimmune, palpitations, paresthesias, cognitive issues.
Medical Detoxification
Gastrointestinal, liver, herbal, heavy metals, homeopathic,
cholestyramine, phosphatidylcholine
Immune Dysregulation
Transfer factors, Chinese medicine, mushrooms, Qi tonics, vitamins,
CoQ10, EFAs, IV C, IV Glutathione.
Anti-inflammatory
EFA, Curcumin, Bosweillin, Olive leaf, Samento
Fatigue
Mitochondrial support – CoQ10, Enada, Provigil, Carnitine, Lipoic Acid
Adrenal stress – Pantothenic acid, B6, C, Licorice, Rhodiola
Qi deficiency / kidney deficiency – Chinese medicine
Fibromyalgia
Trigger point therapy, physical therapy, massage, acupuncture,
Chinese medicine, malic acid, magnesium, Elavil, Ondamed
www.BetterHealthGuy.com 26
Hope to Heal Lyme 2007
Sleep
Melatonin, 5HTP, Valerian, Comfort Shen, Acupuncture, Ondamed, RX
meds
GI Prevention
Probiotics, Saccharomyces boulardii, Flagyl, Vancomycin.
Fungal
Probiotics, Citricidal, Nystatin, Diflucan
Liver
Milk Thistle, NAC, Homeopathics
Cognitive Issues
Ginko, ALC, Vitamin E, Vinpocetine
HPA Axis
Hypothalamus – releasing factors
Pituitary – growth hormone, FSH, LH, ACTH, TSH
Thyroid – T3, T4
Adrenals – catecholamines, cortisol, DHEA, norepinepherine,
epinephrine
Hormonal – estrogens, DHEA, testosterone, pregnenelone
Hypothyroidism Symptoms
Low body temperature, cold sensitivity, cannot lose weight, fatigue,
dry skin and hair, constipation, mental sluggishness, slow heart rate,
depressed immune function, decreased reflexes, hair loss, inability to
conceive, menstruation abnormalities
Functional Hypothyroid
Measure basal body temperature, normal thyroid tests, symptoms of
low thyroid, TSH can be normal or borderline elevated (0-5.5) - > 2.5
can be functional hypothyroidism, decreased conversion of T4 to T3,
mercury toxicity, check TPO (antibodies) for Hashimoto’s, check 24
hour urine for iodine after iodine challenge.
Treatment of Hypothyroidism
Synthroid (synthetic T4), Armour (T3 and T4), Thyrolar (synthetic T3
and T4), Cytomel (T3), Nature Thyroid, Thyrotopin, Thyro Forte,
Iodine
www.BetterHealthGuy.com 27
Hope to Heal Lyme 2007
Low Adrenal Signs
Fatigue, mental sluggishness, weakness, hypotension,
lightheadedness, nausea, weight loss, depression, afternoon lull, salt
cravings.
Adrenal Testing
Cortisol, Salivary cortisol and DHEA, DHEA-S, Pregnenelone, ACTH, 24
hour urine for corticosteroids
Low Adrenal Treatments
Vitamin C, Pantothenic Acid, B6, Zinc, Tyrosine, Phosphatidyl serine,
glandulars, ginseng, eleuthero, licorice, rhodiola, rehmania,
ashwaganda, DHEA, pregnenelone, Cortef, AdrenaCalm.
Estrogen Deficiency
Hot flash, night sweats, vaginal dryness, foggy thinking, memory
lapse, incontinence, tearful, depressed, sleep problems, palpitations,
bone loss, dry skin and hair, headache
Estrogen Excess
Mood swing, tender breasts, water retention, nervous, irritable,
anxious, sleep problems, cold body temperature, elevated
triglycerides, fibrocystic breasts, uterine fibroids, weight gain in hips,
bleeding changes, headaches, heavy periods, breast cancer, low libido,
weight gain in waist
Progesterone Deficiency
Candida, fibrocystic breast, hair loss, anxiety, headache, fluid
retention, arthritis, endometriosis, stressed easily, sleep problems,
weight gain, heavy periods, irritable, cramps, break-thru bleeding,
fibroids, PMS, irregular periods, hypothyroid
Testosterone Deficiency
Low libido, vaginal dryness, fatigue, aches and pains, memory lapse,
incontinence, palpitations, depressed, sleep disturbance, thin pubic
hair, bone loss, decreased muscle mass, thin skin, fibromyalgia
Dysregulation accompanies infection or immune insult when he body
attempts to compensate with a struggling immune, hormone,
inflammatory, or energetic response. This combined with nutritional
deficiencies and detoxification problems leave the body imbalanced
and with a myriad of symptoms.
www.BetterHealthGuy.com 28
Hope to Heal Lyme 2007
Dr. Bock discussed acupuncture and Chinese medicine. He further
discussed energy flow within the body and meridians.
In electromagnetic medicine, human organisms respond to weak
signals in specific frequency ranges. Effects can be noted with dilute
allergy potencies, homeopathics, electromagnetic waves, acupuncture.
Dr. Bock discussed electromagnetic pulse biofeedback using a device
called Ondamed. Uses balancing frequencies to correct blockages,
micro-organism frequencies, nutritional frequencies. Can be helpful
for sleep, fatigue, well-being, joint pain, fibromyalgia, inflammation,
neuropathy, Lyme disease.
Treatment Focus
Evaluation of symptoms, testing, RX, antifungals, probiotics,
detoxification, diet, immune and nutritional treatment, hormonal
therapy, natural anti-inflammatory, nutrients, acupuncture, Chinese
medicine, energetic medicine, Ondamed, homeopathic injections
Diane Wilcox: Chronic Lyme Disease – What It
Does to our Work Lives
Diane Wilcox presented on a study she is doing on how chronic Lyme
impacts our work lives. More information is available at
http://www.lyme-and-work.blogspot.com/
Some notables:
• 37% lost more than 100,000 due to Lyme disease
• 71% take 4 or more medications per day
• 84% use nutritional supplements
• 71% use herbal remedies
• 48% had depression
• 45% had Babesia
• 29% had Bartonella
• 15% had Ehrlichia
• 38% took less than 3 month leave from work
• 29% employed full time
• 19% employed part time
• 13% were fired
• 25% permanently disabled
• 28% spent 100K-500K
• 10% spent more than 500K
www.BetterHealthGuy.com 29
Hope to Heal Lyme 2007
Chronic Lyme seriously affects the way we learn, think, plan, and
make decisions. Executive function in the brain has been impaired
Dr. Joseph Jemsek: Lyme Borreliosis Complex –
A Polymicrobial Mediated Immunosuppressive
Chronic Illness
Dr. Jemsek started out with references to his current legal situation.
He said “I have a gift and I am gonna share it, damnit!”. The audience
cheered. He even suggested that he was speaking as if Blue Cross
was in the room.
First two cases of Lyme were at his clinic in 2001. He has since
treated over 2000 people.
Polymicrobial players include:
• Babesia – AMERICA’S MALARIA
• Bartonella
• Ehrlichia/Anaplasma
• Borrelia
• Others
Polymicrobial nature of syndrome fits concept of “disease process”.
There is an alphabet soup of pathogens involved in Lyme.
Lyme Borreliosis Complex (LBC) represents an acquired
immunodeficiency. Associated with wide range of co-morbidities.
Multiple clinical patterns. Life altering without spontaneous remission.
Eventually, we will discard the term “Lyme disease” as it is poorly
descriptive, politically inflammatory. The name Acquired Immune
Deficiency Syndrome is already taken!
Success is about gaining and maintaining immunologic control.
Multiple infections require sophisticated antimicrobials. The
“pathenogenic hierarchy” or “ringleaders” not fully identified. Borrelia,
Babesia, and Bartonella clearly ringleaders. Life stressors or other
physical illnesses trigger relapse.
The controversy over Lyme is insanity. Sad reflection of society’s
disregard for a devastating health issue. Whether there is a
conspiracy remains to be seen. Power, Ego, Money. We are in the
midst of a pandemic. The storm has arrived.
www.BetterHealthGuy.com 30
Hope to Heal Lyme 2007
Babesia
Fever and chills. Sweats with exertion or night sweats. Random
sweats. Refractory headache. Refractory inflammatory joint disease.
Enlargement of spleen and liver.
Protozoa. Human pathogen. More than 100 species. B. microti,
divergens, WA-1, CA-1, MO-1, and duncani all infect humans.
Intracellular. Found in blood. > 30 cases from blood transfusion since
2001. High replication rate in humans.
Broad range of presentation from asymptomatic to severe. Fever,
malaise, fatigue, chills, sweats, headaches, myalgias, enlarged spleen,
arthralgias.
Severity related to age and host immunocompetency. Most severe
infection when spleen previously removed or host is
immunocompromised.
If you treat Babesia and you are still sick, it is probably still Babesia.
Joint pains get better when treating Babesia.
Bartonella
Endothelial disease, multiple skin manifestations, enlarged lymph
nodes, esophageal and gastric ulcers, bony exostosis, refractory
cognitive issues, history of abnormal SPECT scan. More ubiquitous.
Bumps on fingers which look like bone are Bartonella.
Bartonella – 9 species infect humans. 50-70% prevalence in European
study. 4 species found in dust mites. Found in flea feces. Bartonella
likely affects the brain. It is “silent corrosion”. Vasculitis and
Neuropathy.
Ehrlichia
HME – Monocytic. HGE – Granulocytic - now called Anaplasma.
Infects leukocytes.
www.BetterHealthGuy.com 31
Hope to Heal Lyme 2007
Borrelia
Lyme is a superbug. Syphilis is the dumb cousin. Patents in 1988.
132 lipoprotein genes in Borrelia vs. 22 in syphilis. Perhaps the most
complex bacteria known.
Persistence via:
Immune suppression
Innate – complement inhibition, induction of anti-
inflammatory cytokines, tolerization of monocytes
Adaptive – induction of anti-inflammatory cytokines,
tolerization of lymphocytes, complement inhibition, immune complex
sequesterization
Immune evasion
Phase and antigenic variation – gene conversion, variable
expression of antigens
Physical seclusion – intracellular, extracellular, cysts,
immunologically privileged sites
Borrelia wins! Borrelia destroys WBC – not the other way around.
Lyme bacteria love brain tissue. Causes memory loss, mood
disorders, lack of concentration, sleep issues, anxiety, word retrieval
difficulties, headaches
Symptoms of LBC – fever, tick bite, flu-like symptoms, severe fatigue,
rash, headache, muscle and joint pain, Bell’s palsy, meningitis,
encephalitis, cognitive deficits, mood, sleep issues.
An internal medicine doctor averages 7 minutes with a patient – not
enough time for a complex issue such as LBC.
Life Forms of Borrelia
Life forms of Borrelia – blebs and vesicles, L-forms, membrane derived
cysts, motile helical spirochetes. Spirochetes found intracellular and
extracellular. Found in tissues and fluids. Skin, heart, brain, CSF,
www.BetterHealthGuy.com 32
Hope to Heal Lyme 2007
lymphatic tissues, spleen, kidney, muscle, blood, synovial fluids. Blebs
are antigenic decoys shed by spirochetes intended to spend “immune
capital”. L-forms can form under antibiotic pressure. Lack a cell wall.
Osmotically fragile. Survive beta-lactam treatments. Reform a cell
wall when turning back into spirochete. Might be a transitional form to
cyst. Cyst – reduced metabolic activity. Formed under environmental
stress including antibiotics, pH, oxidation, heat. Found intraceullar and
extraceullar spaces. Reproduce inside the cyst. Survive longer than a
spirochete.
Other Microbes
Mycoplasma – Dr. Garth Nicholson
Chlamydia – Dr. Charles Stratton
EBV – Dr. Dagmar Hulinska
HHV6 – Dr. Joseph Brewer
Mycoplasma – lack a cell wall. Over 100 species. Lack metabolic
pathways such as energy production and synthesis of cell components.
Depend on host for nutrients. Chronic fatigue and Gulf war germ.
Associated with Bell’s Palsy and Fibromyalgia. Treat with doxycycline,
fluoroquinonine, and add Plaquenil. Not clear if it is opportunistic,
commensal, or primary player.
Chlamydia – implicated in heart disease. Role more fundamental in
chronic illness. Not culturable generally. Chlamydia trachomatis and
Borrelia found in synovial fluids of people with arthritis.
EBV – herpes virus. 90% of world is infected. Causes mononucleosis.
Can be reactivated with stressor. Borrelia and EBV shown to cause
severe neurological disease in one study.
HHV6 – herpes virus. 90% of world is infected. Most neuroinvasive of
herpes viruses. Reactivation associated with epilepsy and neurological
problems. Often found in MS.
Trigger mechanism for LBC is something that causes “tipping point”.
Could be biologic, environmental, hormonal, physical or psychological.
Once the tipping point is reached, the patient is an immunological
prisoner of LBC for life. Without intervention, matters only get worse.
Babesia and Borrelia together cause IL-10 and IL-13 to decrease –
these are anti-inflammatory. Arthritic symptoms increase. Severity of
myocarditis increased.
www.BetterHealthGuy.com 33
Hope to Heal Lyme 2007
Ehrlichia and Borrelia together cause increased load of both organisms.
Decrease in IL-12, IFN-γ, TNF-alpha, IL-2 and increase in IL-4 and IL-
6.
Study done with Borrelia and HGE infection showed that patient is less
able to fight Borrelia when HGE is present. Increases ability of Borrelia
to penetrate CNS. Increases endothelial cell barrier exposure to
Borrelia.
Immunosuppressive pathogens – Borrelia, Bartonella, Ehrlichia (HGE)
Additive or Promoting – Borrelia, Bartonella, Ehrlichia (HME and HGE),
Babesia.
Treatment
Know the ELF – Essential Life Functions
Learn your Poems:
Pain
Other – family support, access to treatment
Endocrine/metabolic
Mood/psychiatric
Sleep
Comforting POEMS make the ELF happy.
We don’t treat many chronic illnesses with one drug.
Therapy must address:
Bb multiple forms and locations
Major co-infections
Sequence and combinations that make sense
Immunological blockade by Babesia:
Babesia upregulates Borrelia
Address Babesia early
Clinical responses varied
Adequate duration is key. Serious Babesia infections may require 12-
16 weeks of treatment.
Assume herxheimer effect only with Borrelia. Bactericidal lysis and
release of lipoproteins or through cyst lysis.
www.BetterHealthGuy.com 34
Hope to Heal Lyme 2007
Continued effects with new RX combinations implies purging of Bb
strains not previously eradicated.
Chances for “immunologic control” increased when purging with focus
on blocking co-infections like Babesia.
Clinical Babesia co-infections not reliably detected by labs. Extreme
diversity. Follow the sweats.
Bartonella is a major player in endothelial disease. Major contributor
to CNS disease. More pervasive and insidious than Babesia.
Babesia Treatment:
Oral – combination of macrolide, doxycycline, Mepron or
Malarone and/or Artemisinin.
IV – Clindamycin and Zithromax plus oral Mepron/Malarone and
Artemisninin.
Ehrlichia/Anaplasma/Chlamydia/Mycoplasma – in theory covered with
other therapies
Bartonella Treatment:
Oral – Sulfa, TMP-Sulfa, Levaquin, Rifabutin
IV – Levaquin, TMP-Sulfa pulsed – alternative Rifabutin
Maintenance program consists of core combination RX, periodic
imidazole, progressive extension of holiday periods until goal of 1
week per month reached. Every other day dosing for core is
acceptable.
Maintenance – Every 4 week pulsing with three days of combination
RX. Prominent herxheimer on maintenance is a bad sign. Once past
“induction”, 18-24 month maintenance program. Best measure is
response to intense life stressors.
Summary
Immunologic control is the goal with therapy.
Babesia is America’s malaria. Must be accounted for in all cases of
advanced LBC.
Advanced disease will require extended therapy.
www.BetterHealthGuy.com 35
Hope to Heal Lyme 2007
Combination, pulsed, sequential antimicrobial therapy protocols are
effective.
Assumption – three key pathogen groups – Borrelia, Babesia,
Bartonella.
Creating an RX approach based on these three pathogens has resulted
in strong results.
Be thankful – what if there was no effective therapy? What if
antibiotics were not useful? What if there was no active research?
The time for change is near – LBC is too big, too hurtful, and too
obvious.
Other Notes
May start using Valtrex for HHV6.
He believes that much of the herx reaction is a cytokine response
moreso than a neurotoxin.
Follow the sweats when following Babesia treatment. Artemisinin or
Mepron that cause sweating is a sign of Babesia.
Resistance to Artemisinin develops if used as a monotherapy.
Does not generally use beta-lactam drugs.
750mg Mepron twice daily or 2 teaspoons twice a day in some cases.
3 days a week. Malarone + Zithromax or Ketek 3 days a week for 3
weeks with 1 week off. Amoxicillin plus Zithromax for pregnant
mother from second trimester.
Good balance takes 18 months AFTER getting well.
Biaxin, mino, Rocehpin may be neuroprotective.
Jemsek did not believe that there is a concern with doing HBOT if the
patient has Babesia as some have suggested.
www.BetterHealthGuy.com 36
Hope to Heal Lyme 2007
Mark Garzon: Heavy Metal Toxicity and Lyme Disease
Classification of Lyme patients:
• Exposure to Bb and co-infections with no symptoms
• Exposure to Bb and co-infections with symptoms caused by
Lyme and co-infections
• Exposure to Bb and co-infections whose symptoms are caused
by something else
• Exposure to Bb and co-infections whose symptoms are caused
by Lyme, co-infections, AND something else.
What is something else?
• Hypothyroidism
• Adrenal dysfunction
• Viral infection
• Gastrointestinal dysbiosis (yeast, fungus, mold, parasites)
• Mold allergy/toxicity
• Autoimmune diseases
• Depression/emotional disturbances
• Toxicity (especially neurotoxins)
Fat soluble toxins – neurotoxins are fat soluble, Dr. Shoemaker, every
cell in the body including nerve cells have a cell membrane containing
fat. Most common neurotoxins are: Bb toxins, yeast/fungal toxins,
mold, heavy metals (mercury, lead, arsenic).
Neurotoxins pass right through myelin sheath as well. Mercury
destroys myelin sheath.
If you have had mercury/silver fillings, you probably have mercury
neurotoxicity.
Symptoms of heavy metals and Lyme are nearly identical. If you are
not getting better with Lyme treatment, think about heavy metals.
Like Lyme, heavy metals is a controversial topic – ignorance and lack
of adequate diagnostic tests. Medical texts all use blood (serum) as
diagnostic criteria for heavy metals. Heavy metals are fat soluble and
therefore pass into and through cells – they are NOT in the blood.
Blood tests are only good for acute ingestion.
www.BetterHealthGuy.com 37
Hope to Heal Lyme 2007
Dr. Garzon reviewed some tests from Doctor’s Data and also talked
about the Urinary Porphyrin profile. Heme synthesis is disrupted by
heavy metals and can be evaluated with the Porphyrin test.
The gold standard is a provocation test where the patient is given a
chelating agent or a binding agent and then the urine or stool are
checked for metals. Chelating agents: EDTA, DMPS, DMSA,
Penicillamine.
Remove the sources of heavy metals if possible. Replace amalgams
with porcelain or gold using a dentist experienced in heavy metal
removal.
Avoid thimerisol in adult vaccinations. Test well water. Reduce fish.
Heavy metal toxicity – EDTA, DMPS, DMSA, Penicillamine. IV
Glutathione and Vitamin C can be helpful. Skin IR sauna, clay baths,
detox foot pads. Oral detoxification agents include: Metal Free, NDF,
chlorella, oral EDTA, Lipoic Acid, Detox-Max, NCD.
If the dentist is not wearing a gas mask to remove your mercury, they
are likely not protecting themselves or you.
DMPS is a good option for mercury and arsenic. EDTA is better for
lead.
Mark Garzon: Bio-Identical Hormone Replacement for
Lyme Disease
Hormones are messengers sent from one part of the body that have
an effect on another part of the body. They have influence over
physical, emotional, and mental health.
Hormones decrease with age. Bio-identical hormone replacement has
become a popular anti-aging treatment. Can be used to treat
symptoms of Lyme disease. Dr. Shoemaker believes that neurotoxins
impact the hypothalamus and pituitary glands which are the master
hormone organs in the brain.
Fatigue, insomnia, brain fog, digestive problems can all be helped with
hormone replacement. First step is to test levels. Checking thyroid
and steroid hormones is a minimum. Steroid hormones are cortisol,
DHEA, progesterone, estrogen, and testosterone.
www.BetterHealthGuy.com 38
Hope to Heal Lyme 2007
Cortisol is the most important and is an adrenal hormone. Has many
functions including anti-inflammatory. Lyme disease is an
inflammatory process so a person with Lyme needs to make more
cortisol to deal with inflammation.
These increase need for cortisol:
• Emotional stress
• Infections
• Autoimmune illness
• Allergies
• Acute and chronic pain
• Toxicity (chemical, heavy metals)
At first, adrenals will produce high levels of cortisol. With chronic
stress, the adrenals cannot maintain a high level of cortisol production
and leads to adrenal stress/fatigue and cortisol levels begin to drop.
Symptoms of adrenal fatigue:
• Chronic fatigue
• Digestive problems
• Constipation
• Brittle hair or nails
• Insomnia
• Inability to handle stress
• Depression
• Memory loss
• Brain fog
• Mood swings
• Irritability
• Poor immune function
• Bloating / fluid retention
• Hypoglycemia
• Dizziness when standing
• Impotence
• Low libido
• Menstrual problems
Adrenal fatigue has downstream effects on sex hormones. When
under inflammation or stress, progesterone is moved to the cortisol
pathway. This leads to imbalance of progesterone and estrogen and
results in estrogen dominance. Estrogen dominance causes uterine
www.BetterHealthGuy.com 39
Hope to Heal Lyme 2007
fibroids, fibrocystic breasts, and can lead to breast cancer.
Progesterone should be about 100 times estradiol or you are estrogen
dominant. If progesterone is higher than testosterone, you can have
erectile dysfunction.
Testosterone can be shunted to the cortisol pathway as well.
Different cortisol patterns can suggest different disease states such as
parasites, hypoglycemia, and insomnia.
High AM cortisol levels consistent with parasitic infection. Then drop
after first morning test. Drop of more than ½ from 8am to noon,
suggests parasites.
4am cortisol can be higher due to hypoglycemia.
Dr. Garzon uses a bio-identical hormone cream that is created for each
person uniquely. It has a liposomal delivery system.
Yam based progesterone or soy based estrogen is used in hormone
creams.
Tribulus used in the cream, not testosterone. Do not use cortisol or
testosterone in the cream.
Mercury is fat soluble. Lyme patients that diet can expose themselves
to more mercury. Mercury and lead together have a much more
dangerous impact than either alone.
Sun Chlorella – high doses – 550 mg caps – 4 caps 3 times a day
BEFORE meals.
Often uses a drainage remedy – German homeopathics
Clifford Research tests for compatibility of dental materials.
DMPS best provocation test but DMSA may be better for long-term
therapy. Single dose vials of vaccines may be less likely to have
mercury than larger vials.
www.BetterHealthGuy.com 40
Hope to Heal Lyme 2007
Amy Derksen, ND: Using Alternative Methods to Help
Guide Lyme Treatment
Presentation from Amy Derksen, ND can be found here.
This presentation is one that I was most excited about. Amy Derksen
is one of my personal doctors and I resonate very strongly with her
work. I was so pleased to see the strong positive response that the
audience gave to her discussion.
I am not summarizing it in detail here as the presentation is available
above and provides all the details.
Some notes:
Brown spots in iris can be heavy metals.
Weight in the mid-section can be high cortisol.
Very important to support the kidneys while using DMPS.
Carol Fisch: Introducing a New Antigen Test by Flow
Cytometry to Detect Borrelia Burgdoferi, the Bacteria
that Causes Lyme Disease
Key points:
• Passed state inspection on first attempt with no
recommendations or corrections
• One of a kind test
• Immune Fluorescence testing using Flow Cytometer
• Identifies Bb including cysts
• Can count the number of Bb in 50,000 cells in one minutes
• Test result reported as a percentage of counted cells
• Results of 0.02 – negative, 0.03 – borderline and 0.04 – positive
• Results in 72 hours
• Covered by insurance and Medicare
• Can be ordered from Europe
• www.CentralFloridaResearch.com
www.BetterHealthGuy.com 41
Hope to Heal Lyme 2007
Rita Losee, RN: When Life Gives You Lyme, Make
Lymeonade
Rita is a motivational speaker that herself has Lyme. She was a very
uplifting speaker.
The “Secret”: 1) Ask for what you want 2) You believe that you will get
it 3) You allow it to happen.
Ask from a place that is already mine – thank you for whatever you
want rather than I would like ….
What you think about and talk about comes about.
Invest energy and time into what it would be to be completely and
totally healthy again.
Institute of Heartmath – evidence of immune-suppression for six hours
after 5 minutes of angry thought.
Happy thought – immune function went up for six hours. Everyday –
do everything you can to make yourself feel good. Use imagination.
Visualization.
Don’t use “I am a Lymie” – be something positive.
Sarah Fletcher, MD: Our Journey
Dr. Fletcher shared her own personal story with Lyme.
Before Lyme – she had dental amalgams, IBS, 3 pneumonias, yeast
infections, depression, fibromyalgia, fish allergy, rheumatoid arthritis
Holmes is hired – Dr. Leila Zackrison. Removed wheat from diet.
Treated trichinella. High ELISA, + WB, + urine antigen. Milk,
chocolate, soy allergies.
Treated with orals and IM Bicillin which stabilized but neurological
symptoms followed. Urinary and fecal incontinence, bad imbalance,
brain fog, choking on saliva and food, night sweats, ulnar neuritis.
www.BetterHealthGuy.com 42
Hope to Heal Lyme 2007
Did 9 months of Rocephin and relapsed after 2 weeks.
Had gallbladder removed to see if she improved. PCR + in gallbladder
after 9 months of Rocephin. Organs like gallbladder cannot be cleared
of infection in many cases.
Identified Babesia and ureaplasma.
Started working less, amalgams removed, chelation started, weight
training. Tapeworm, C. Difficile.
Still working on her recovery from Lyme.
www.BetterHealthGuy.com 43
Get documents about "