Latin American Research. Part 2. Most-cited articles_ discipline by gyvwpsjkko


									 Essays of an Information Scientist, Vol:7, p.144-151, 1984
  Current Contents, #20, p.3-10, May 14, 1984

                                        Latin American     Research.  Part 2.
                                   Most-Cited  Articies,   Discipline Orientation,
                                        and Research     Front Concentration

Number       20                                                                  Maq    14,   1984

    In Part 1 data were provided on 3,100               ences@ (CBD@ ) to determine what ad-
Latin American        articles found in the             dresses were listed for the first authors of
1978 Science Citation Index” (SLY),                     the high-impact       1978 Latin American
The average Latin American                 article      papers in later years. Six authors were
received about three citations from 1978                found to have listed addresses at other
through 1982. In comparison,            the five-       institutions    outside   of Latin Amer-
year impact of the average SC1 article                  ica—E. R. Abney, F. Bolivar, R. Bravo,
was five. Brazil, Argentina,            Mexico,         D.E. Richards, J.L. Ochoa, and L.C.
Chile, and Venezuela accounted for 92                   Vaz. In addition, five of the 24 highly
percent of the Latin American articles                  cited articles were coauthored          with
indexed in the 1978 SC1. The same five                  researchers from the US and UK.
countries     dominated       Latin American               We’ve also provided details on the
scientific output in the 1973 and 1982                  “nationality”    of the citations to these
SCI.                                                    high-impact Latin American articles in
    Our discussion of Latin American sci-               Table 1. That is, we show the number of
ence continues with a iist of most-cited                citations given by authors based in the
articles and a discipline analysis—liie                 same Latin American nation as the cited
sciences, physics, chemistry,            etc. An        first author, those based in other Latin
analysis of the specflc            clusters      of     American nations, and those from non-
research cited by Latin American scien-                 Latin American countries. These 24 arti-
 tists in 1981 helps us identify the par-               cles received about 1,200 citations from
ticular research fronts in which they are                1978 through 1982. Eighty-nine percent
active.                                                 were from non-Latin American papers.
    Table 1 lists 24 1978 articles that re-             Ten percent were “self-citations”       from
ceived at least 30 citations from 1978                  the cited author’s own country. Only
 through 1982. Ten papers list frost au-                one percent       were from other Latin
 thors based in Mexico, five in Brazil,                 American countries. Apparently, there
 four in Chile, three in Argentina,            and      is little inter-citation     between   Latin
 two in Venezuela. Of course, it’s possi-               American      scientists,  at least as it is
 ble that some of the first authors on                  reflected in the international journals in-
 these high-impact papers listed different              dexed in SC1. Thus, whether or not a
 institutional affiliations outside of Latin            Latin American article is highly cited de-
 America on other articles. That is, some               pends on the recognition it gets from sci-
 may have been visiting researchers at in-              entists outside of Central and South
 stitutions in Europe or North America.                 America.
 Or they may have been researchers from                     This point is better illustrated when
 Europe or North America who worked                      we identify the countries that most fre-
 at Latin American         laboratories      for a       quently cited the 1978 SC1 Latin Ameri-
 while. We checked ISP’s Current Bib-                    can articles.     These articles received
 liographic Directory of the Arts & Sci-                 about 9,000 citations from 1978 to 1982.

Treble II 1978 Latin American articles cited at least 20 times from 1978 to 1982. A= bibliographic data. B= total citations,
  C= citations from first author’s own country. D= citatiom from other coumries in Latin America. E= citations from all
  other countries,

                                                  A                                                   B          c    DE

Bofivnr F. Construction and characterization    of new clonin~ vehicles, 111. Derivatives of          162    5       2     155
  plasmid PBR322 carrying unique Eco RI sites for selection of Em RI generated recombinant
  DNA molecules.     Gene 4:12 I-36, 1978. Natl. Autonomous    Univ. Mexico [UNAM), Inst.
  Biomed. Res., Mexico City, Mexico.
Abney E R, Cooper M D, Kemney J F, Lawton A R & Parkbouse SS M E. Sequential expres-                  120    0       0     120
  sion of immunoglobtdin   on developing mouse B lymphocytes:     a systematic survey that sug-
  gests a model for the generation of immunoelobulin    isoty~ diversity. J. Immunol.  120:2041-9,
  7978. Natl. Autonom&s     Univ. Mexico (UN~M),     Facul{ “Med.: Natj. Pcdytech.
  Inst. (lPN) Res. Ctr., Mexico City, Mexico; Univ. Alabama, Dept. Pcdim.. MicrobioL &
  Compr. Cancer C1r,, Bkmingham,      AL.
Borgomo J M, Mcf,emI A A, Veffn P P, Woodhour A F, Cmepa L DavldMJs W L &                             67     0       0     67
  Jfffleman M R. Vaccination     and revaccination  with polyvalent pneumococcal     polysaccharide
  vaccines in adults and infrmts (40310), Proc, 5x. .@       Jfio[, Med. 157: 14S-54, 1978, Natl.
  Hlth. SCrv,, Sect. Epidemiol.,   Santiago, Chile; Merck Inst. Ther. Res., Div. Virus Cell Biol.
  Rcs. & Corp. Med. Dept. -Occup. Hlth., West Point, PA,
Pefmbert M, Tormt-Pefmbert     S & Rayo I F. Abundance gradients in the galaxy derived                62     3       1     58
  from HI, regions. Astrophys.   1.220:5 l&24, 1978. Natl, Autonomous  Umiv, Mexico (UNAM)
  Inst. Astro”,,   Mexico   City, Mexico.
DfFolo R. Ca pump driven by ATP in squid axons. Nature         274:393.2,   1978. Sci. Res, Inst.     52     5       146
  (lVIC). Ctr. Biophys. Bic=h em., Caracas, Venezuela.
Afarcon-Segov&    D & Ruiz.Arguelies  A. Decreawd     circuiting  thymus-derived cells with           w     13       0     37
  receptors for the Fc portion of immunoglobulin     G in systemic lupus erythematosus.
  J, Cl;.. Invest 62:1390-4, 1978, Natl. lust. N“tr., Dept. Irnmunoi. Rhmmmdol.,
  Mexico City, Mexico.
Afnrcon.Segovfa   D, Ruiz-Argueiies A & Fbhbefn E. Antibody to nuclear         ribonucleoprotein      w     t8       0     32
  penetrates live human mononuclear   cells through Fc receptors. Nature       27 I :67-9, 1978.
  Nail. fnst. Nutr., Dept, Immunol. Rheumatol.,   Mexico City, Mexico.
Dfdyk B M, Sfmoneft B R T, Bmsseff S C & E@ntoa G. Organic geochemical         indicators of          45    o        0     45
  pale.eocnvironmeritai conditions of sedimentation. Nature 272:216-22, 1978. Natl. Petroleum
  Enterprise, Con con, Chile; Univ. Caiifomia, lnst. Geophys. Planet, Phys, Los Angeies, CA;
  Univ. Bristol, Sch. Chem., Bristol, UK.
Hopp H E, Romero P A, Daleo G R & Poni Lezka R. Synthesis of celiulose precursors,                    43     3       040
  Eur. f. Biochem 84:561-71, 1978. Bariloche Fdn., Dcpt. Bioi., San Caries de Bariic.the,
Padhl N, Cwnak G, McKoy B V & Lmgbott P W. Photoabsorption               in carbon monoxide:          43     3       040
  Stieltjes-Tchebycheif  calculations in the separated-channel static-exchange    approximation.
  J Chem. Phyf. 69:2992 -3CQ4, 197f$. Slate Univ. Campin as, Inst. Phys.. Campinas. Brazil;
  Calif. Inst. Technol., Arthur Amos Noyes Lab. Chem. Phys,. Pasadena, CA: Indiana Univ..
  Dept. Chem., Bloomington,       IN.
Bravo R, Otero C, Affende C C & Aliende I E. Amphibian wcytc maturation and protein                   40    8        0     32
  synthesis: related inhibition by cyclic AMP, theophylline, and papaverinc. Proc. Nat Acad.
  S.,. US 75:1242-6, 1978. Univ. Chife, Facuit. Med., Santiago, Chile.
Cuccovfs J M, Schroter E H, Mcmefro P M & ChaImovkh H. Effect of hexadecyltrimethyl-                  38    4        034
  ammonium bromide on the thiolysis of p-nitrophenyi  aceiaie. J. Org Chem.
  43:2248-52, 1978. Univ. Sao Paulo, Inst. Chem., Sao Paulo, Brazil.
Lfado$ F & Ztpata P. Effects of dopamine anaiogues and antagoni$fs on carotid body                    3s    6        0     32
  chemosensors    in situ. J. Physiol. 274:487-99, 1978. Catholic Univ. Chile, Dept. Neurobioi.,
  Santiago, Chile.

Sanchez I A & Stefanf E. Inward caicium current in twitch muscie fibres of the frog.                  38     6       I     31
  J. Physio/. 283: 197-2C0. 1978. Natl. Polytech. Inst. (IPN) Res. Ctr., Mexico City, Mexico.
Sfmeiouf R J & l,elok L F. Oligosaccharides   containing glucose and mannose in glycopro-             %     11       0     27
  teins of the Ihymid giand. Pro.. Naf. A cad. Sci. US 75:1162-6, 1978. Inst. Biochem. Res.
  “Fundacion Cnmpomar’<; COIL Exact Natur. Sci.. Buenos Aires, Argentina.
Mortata R A, Q!dm F H 6 Cbafmovkh H. Formation of closed vesicies from a simple phos-                 36     3       0     33
 phate diester, Preparation and some properties of vesicles of dihexadecyi phosphate.
 Btochem. Wiophy$. Res. Ckmmun. 81:1080-6, 1978. Univ. Sao Paulo, Inst. Chem.,
 Sao Paulo, Brazil,
Femefn S H, Nakamum M & Castro M S A. The hweralgcsic          effects of prostacyclin and            35    10       0     25
  prostaglandin E2. Pros6zglandins 16:31-7. 1978. Ribeirao Preto Facult. Med., Dept.
  Pharmacol.,  Sao PaukJ, Brazil.
Zepe&   A. Mass of the up quark. Phys. Rev. Left.     41:139-41,   1978. Nat]. Polytech.   Inst.      35     i       034
  (IPN) Res. Ctr., Mexico    City. Mexico.
(kmsco     H A, Fuenmayor A, Batiwm J S & Gonzalez G. Efiect of verapamif on normal                   34    o        034
  sinoatriai node function and on sick sinus syndrome. Am.,. Heart J. %:760-71, 1978.
  Los Andes Univ. Hosp., Cardiovasc, Cm., Merida, Venezuela.

Vmz L C & Alexander J M. Systematic     of fusion barriers obtained with a modified pmxim-                      34          0   034
  ity potential. Phys ReL. C—N..{    Phys. 18:2152-61, 1978, IFUFRJ C,dade Uni,., Dept. Nucl
  Phys,, Rio de Janeiro, Brazil: SLJNY, Dep[. Chem., Stony Brook, NY.
Perez-Tamayo      R. Pathology of collagen degradation.   A mer   J Path./     92:509-66,   1978   Nat].        32          6   I        25
  Jnst. Nutr.,   Dept. Palhol., Mexico C)ty, Mexico,
Ochoa J.L. Hydrophobic (interaction) chromatography. Biochimie 60:1-15,             1978. Natl.                 31          2   0        29
  Autonomous   Univ. Mexico (UNAM), Inst. Chem., Mexico City, Mexico.
Ramos C, Lmnoyi E. Feoll M, Rodrfguet M, Perez M & Ortk.Ortk        L. TrypanosomII <rum                        31          2   9        20
  immunosuppressed   response to different antigens in the miecled mouse. Exp. Parrm!foi
  45:190-9, 1978. NaO. Autonomous    Uni\. Mexico (UNAM), Inst. Biomed. Res., Mexico Oty,
Rkhmds D E, Regs A F & Gsrrdmn P 1. Two classes of site for ATP in the Ca2+-ATPase                              .W          ~   0        23
  from human red cell mcmhra. es. Bmch(m  Btophys  Aria 51 I 194-201, 1978, (l”iv
  Ames, Pharmacol. Biochem., Buenm Aires, Argentina.
                                                                                               1I84       !16   15    !053

Source   of da!a on artw+s    19”8 SCF”
source   cd data cm c,tatmm    IYT.JY82   .SCI

Table 2 shows21 countries that account                                  Table 2: Countries that most frequently cited 1978 SCI’
                                                                          Latin American   arllcles. Asterisks  (- 1 indicate    Lat,”
for at least one percent of citations to                                  American countries, A=citing    country    B=citations     to
Latin American research. Twenty-nine                                      Latin American articles. C=percent      of all c]talmns to
                                                                          Latin America” articles, D=c,mtKM~     m all amcks,
percent were from US citing papers.
West European articles account for 14
percent. The UK accounts for eight per-                                        A                           B          c                 n
cent. All Latin American countries com-                                  us                          2h05             29              833,933
bined account for 32 percent.                                           “Brazil                       97 I            11                 3960
                                                                        “Argentina                    787              9                 3302
    Table 3 provides details on these Latin
                                                                         UK                           -ma              8              188,323
American citations to Latin American                                    “Mexico                       436              5                 2289
research.     A pattern of high national                                 FRG                          374              4              117,817
                                                                         France                       334              4               94,919
“seff-citation” is obvious. For example,                                “Chile                        290              3                  16%
971 of the citations to Latin American                                  “Ven.exwda                    259              3                 1120
                                                                         Canada                       243              3               80.894
research came from Brazilian papers.                                     Japm                         219              3               94,149
Yet 917 of these were “self-citations” to                                Awtral]a                     I“7              2               38,099
                                                                         Jtaly                         153             2
Brazilian research. In this study, “self-ci-                                                                                           36, WI
                                                                         OSSR                         I45              2               48,459
tation” refers to citations by any author                                Swilz.srJmd                  Ill              1               30, f173
from one country to the work of any au-                                  Netherlzmds                  I(YJ             1               35,180
                                                                         Sweden                         85              I              34,33fl
thors in that same nation. It should not                                 India                          80              1              20,312
be confused with the usual meaning of                                    Belgium                        ’78             I              18,102
                                                                         Israel                         69              I              18,040
self-citation as an author citing his or her                             Denmark                        M               I              17,139
own work. Thus, national self-citations                                  All Others                   653              7              137,385
indicate a form of “provinciality” or “in-
                                                                         ToM                         8935
 sularity, ” even though the authors in
 question may not be known to each
 other.                                                                 national journals covered in SC]. A cita-
    This high level of “insularity”         is                          tion analysis of regional journals might
 observed in other Latin American na-                                   reveal a different pattern.
 tions. Ninety-one percent of Argentina’s                                  The finding that there is little inter-ci-
 citations to Latin American       research                             tation between Latin American scien-
 cited Argentinean     papers; Mexico, 98                               tists raises important      science policy
 percent; Chile, 93 percent; Venezuela,                                 questions. Much has been done to in-
 91 percent, and so on. These data indi-                                crease contacts between Latin American
 cate that Latin American researchers are                               scientists and those in the US and Eu-
 not aware of, or choose not to cite, pa-                               rope. As a result, scientific information
 pers from neighboring countries in Cen-                                from the US and Europe is more accessi-
 tral and South America. Keep in mind                                   ble to Latin American scientists, and
 that this statement is based on the inter-                             vice versa. Similar programs should be

Table 3: Inter-Latin American self-citations.  Self-citation is                           J. Davidson Frame, Department          of
  defined    M the number      of references   in a nation’s
  literature that cited that same nation’s papers divided by                          Management Science, George Washing-
  the number of references     to all Latin American papers.                          ton University, Washington,         DC, com-
  A= citing country. B = Latin American citations. C =self-
  citations  D = percent of self-citations.
                                                                                      bined 1973-1975 SCI data for a study of
                                                                                      Latin American and world science. lb He
        A                           B                  c                   D          found that 60 percent of the world
Brazil                             971                 917                  94        literature was in the life sciences, com-
Argentina                          787                 716                  91        pared to 73 percent for Latin American
Mexico                             436                 425                  98
Chile                              290                 269                  93
                                                                                     publications.      Nineteen percent was in
Venezuela                          259                 235                  91        chemistry-for        Latin    America,   this
Colombia                            46                  40                  87
Costa Rtca                          22                  15                  68
                                                                                      figure was 11 percent. Physics, including
Guatemala                           13                   7                  54        geophysics and astrophysics, accounted
Cuba                                11                  II                 103        for 21 percent of the world literature but
Uruguay                              9                   9                 lW
Peru                                 8                   6                  75       only 16 percent of Latin American ar-
Ecuador                              3                   3                 100       ticles.    Frame     concluded     that Latin
Bolivia                              1                     0                   0
El Salvador                           1                     1              Iw        American       research is “peripheral”     to
Honduras                              1                     I              IIXl      world or “mainstream” scientific output.
Panama                                I                    o                   0         But when we examine individual Latin
Total                             2859                2655                  93       American nations, we see that some are
                                                                                     more “mainstream” than others. Table 4
Table 4: Distribution of 1973 SCP articles from Brazil and
                                                                                     shows the dktribution        of 1973 SC1 arti-
  Mexico by field. A= Brazifia” articles. B=perctm[     of all                       cles from Brazil and Mexico by broad
  Brazilian   articles. C= impact   of Brazilian    articles.
  D= Mexican articles. E=percent    of all Mcmcan articles.
                                                                                     discipline, and their five-year impacts.
  F= impact of Mexican articles.                                                     About 52 percent of the world literature
                                                                                     covered in SCZ that year was in the lie
            Field             A           BCDEF
                                                                                     sciences. For Brazil, this figure is 55 per-
Life Sciences                449          55   25          390     73      2.6       cent, very close to the world average. A
Physics-                     137          17   3.2          58     II      Z.f
Chemistry                     5a           7   4,4          41      8      2.f
                                                                                     much larger proportion of Mexican pub-
Engineering/Technology        55           7     .9         12      2      1.5       lications—73       percent—is     in the life
Mathematics                   314.98
All Others””
                              82          10    ,8           26        :   ::;
                                                                                         Brazilian publications     in physics are
“    Includes   Geophysics   and Astrophysics.                                       also roughly proportional        to the world
-.   Includes   articles from m“ltidisciplimmy             journals.
                                                                                     output— 18 percent in 1973. Four per-
                                                                                     cent of Brazil’s articles were in mathe-
designed to intensify contacts between                                               matics, compared to three percent for
scientists in Central and South Amer-                                                the world literature.       Mexico is under-
ica—travel grants, exchange programs,                                                represented in both physics and mathe-
cooperative research projects, regional                                              matics—l 1 and one percent, respective-
laboratories    and journals,    etc. This                                           ly. (Both Brazil and Mexico published
could lead to a greater awareness among                                              much smaller proportions of articles in
Latin American nations of each other’s                                               chemistry      and engineering       than the
useful scientific contributions.                                                     world as a whole. In 1973, 17 percent of
   By examining the journals that pub-                                               the world’s literature was in chemistry,
lished Latin American research, we can                                               and 11 percent in engineering.)
get a rough idea of the fields of science                                                Table 5 shows how Brazilian and Mex-
they concentrate       in. Several studies                                           ican articles in the 1978 SCZ are distrib-
have indicated      that Latin American                                              uted by discipline. The Brazilian propor-
science in general is concentrated    in the                                         tion of articles in the life sciences de-
life In comparison to the dis-                                           clined to 46 percent in 1978, lower than
tribution of the world’s literature, Latin                                           the world average of 55 percent that
American science is underrepresented                                                 year. But the impact of Brazilian life
in physics and chemistry.                                                            sciences articles increased from 2.5 in

Table 5? Distribution of 1978 SCP articles from Brazil and
  Mexico by field. A = Brazilian articles. B= percent of all
                                                                         to know how much of a nation’s litera-
  Brazilian   articles, C = impact   of Brazilian   articles.            ture is devoted to life sciences, but it is
  D= Mexican articles. E= percent of all Mexican articles.               more relevant to know what disciplines
  F = impact of Mexican articles.
                                                                         within this field are stressed—biomedi-
            Ffefd             ABCDEF                                     cine, biochemistry,     clinical medicine,
Life Sciences                483     46    2.9    410     67    3,1      botany, etc. It is even more interesting
Physics.                     229     22    3.0     87     i4    4.8      to know what specific research problems
Chemistry                     96      9    3.6     30       5   1,3
                                      7    1.3     51      8      .7
                                                                         are addressed within these disciplines—
Engineering/Technology        76
Mathematics                   38      4    1.4      9       1   2.9      erythrocyte     membrane     proteins,   cell-
                             138     13      .9    24      4    3,6
All Others””                                                             mediated cytotoxicity,     T-cell responses
‘    Includes   Geophysics   and Astrophysics.                           to tuberculosis, etc.
‘-   I“cl.des   art,cles from multidisciplimry    journals.                  1S1 has developed a method to auto-
                                                                         matically classify the scientific literature
1973 to 2.9 in 1978. The percentage of                                   into thousands of discrete, highly specif-
Brazil’s output in physics increased from                                ic “clusters” of research. The method
17 percent in 1973 to 22 percent in 1978,                                relies on co-citation analysis to identify
which is higher than the world average of                                “core” documents in these clusters, and
17 percent.      The impact of Brazilian                                 the current “research front” papers that
physics articles was stable at about three                               cite them. This method has been de-
in 1973 and 1978. The proportion of Bra-                                 scribed previously. 1?
zilian articles in chemistry also grew,                                      For this study, we used the 1981 SCI
from seven percent in 1973 to nine per-                                  file to see what clusters of research were
cent in 1978. This is still lower than                                   cited by Latin American articles. Thk
the world average-16          percent of the                             helps us identify the current areas of
world’s literature was in chemistry in                                   Latin American research. In brief, we
 1978. Brazil’s proportionate    productivity                             examined     more than 2,300 research
in chemistry increased, but its average                                   fronts that included at least one Latin
impact declined from 4.4 in 1973 to 3.6                                   American paper. Obviously, we can’t
in 1978.                                                                  discuss all of them here. So we set a
    Mexico’s emphasis on the life sciences                                threshold to obtain a manageable num-
in 1978 is still strong, accounting for 67                                ber for analysis.
percent of Mexico’s publications—down                                        Figure 1 shows a map of 37 clusters of
from 73 percent in 1973. The impact of                                    research cited by at least eight Latin
Mexico’s life sciences publications          in-                          American articles in the 1981 SCI. Each
creased from 2.6 in 1973 to 3.1 in 1978.                                  circle represents a single cluster of re-
The percentage       of Mexico’s output in                                search. The connecting        lines indicate
 physics grew from 11 percent in 1973 to                                  co-citation links between research spe-
 14 percent in 1978, closer to the world                                  cialties. Each cluster is identified by a
average of 17 percent, Signtilcantly, the                                 number. The full name for each research
impact of Mexican physics articles more                                   front is provided in the table and cor-
 than doubled, from 2.1 in 1973 to 4.8 in                                 responds to the number on the map. We
 1978. Only five percent of 1978 Mexican                                  have explained previously how the re-
 articles were in chemistry, lower than its                               search fronts are named. 17 After each
  1973 proportion of eight percent and far                                research front name, the number of 1981
 lower than the 1978 world average of 16                                  citing papers is shown, as well as the per-
 percent. The impact of Mexico’s chem-                                    centage from Latin America.
 istry articles also declined, from 2.1 in                                   Before we discuss Latin American re-
  1973to 1.3 in 1978.                                                     search specialization,    a few comments
     Of course, analyses of field distribu-                               about the map itself are needed. The
 tions are too broad to give us an idea of                                map does not show the relative “sizes” of
 the specific subjects of research a na-                                  the specialty areas it depicts. The num-
 tion’s scientists specialize in. It is useful                            ber of citing articles in these research

Ffgure 1: M.ltidimensicmally scaled map of reseach clmters tiled by at least eight 1981 SCI’                Latin American        articles.    Num-
  bers correspond to accompanying    index of re%arch front names.


Names of research fronts that included at least eight 1981 SCP articles from Latin America.         A= number                            on map,
B = research front name. C= total number of citins articles. D = percentage of Latin American citing articles

                                                        Phydm       & Astropbyskm

A                                                               B                                                                          CD
 1   Spectroscopic   studies of WofFRayet stars                                                                                            75      17
 2   Interacting boson mcdel                                                                                                              133       7
3    Neutrino masses, neutral currents, and other factors involved in unified field theories                                              288      t5
4    Chemical composition     and structure of globular clusters                                                                          205       5
5    Mass, photometric     abundances,  and colors of cepheids, carbon stars, and super giants: stellar evolution                         108       8
6    Monte Carlo and other studies of renormalization,     roughening transitions, and expansions in lattice-                             225       4
        ga”ge theories
 7   Renormafiition     group studies 0[ percolation behavior in Eattice models                                                               77   16

                                                          Pbyskal     Chembtry
 8   Intermediate    valence states                                                                                                       118      9
 9   Auger spectron and self-consistent        band structure theory of metals                                                            276      3
10   Electronic stmcture,     magmetism, conductivity,      and related properties   of did      surfaces   described    by the           105      8
        Hubbard, Anderson, and other models
11   Self-consistent   field X-alpha-scattered    wave calculations of electronic    structure    and magnetic      properties            134      7
       of molecules
                                                              LU. Sciences

12   Microphage    activation and intcrcehdar     infection                                                                               63  19
13   Development     and stmcture of trypanosoma                                                                                          38 24
14   Enzymes which control DNA conformation           and [he effect of interactions     with intercalating      drugs                   988   1
Is   Analysis of tight junctions in various tissue                                                                                       244   3
[6   Transmembrane       electrical potentials and membrane permeability                                                                 3833
17   Ecological and adaptation strategies in community stabUity                                                                          315   3
18   Kallikrein and hypertension                                                                                                         126   9
19   Serodiagnosis and subtyping of arbovir”s discaw.s                                                                                    8a  10
20   Mechanisms of ion exchange and transport ATP                                                                                        337   3
21   Sarcopfasmic reticulum ATPase                                                                                                       263   4
22   Renat physiology and ion transport                                                                                                  419   2
23   Methcds for the analysis and characterization        of proteins                                                                   1034   3
24   Effecls of anti-arrythmic drugs cm cardiovascular dk.ease                                                                           314   3
25   Adrenorecepbms       and physiology of neurotransmission                                                                            567   3
26   Etiology and pathotogy of viral gastroentcritis                                                                                     495   4
27   Glycoprotein    biosynthesis                                                                                                        [80   6

28   Biochemistry   and metabolism of zinc, copper, and other trace elements                           669    3
29   Effects of dietary cholesterol on the plasma and arm’iaf wall of undernourished    rats            21   38
xl   Nutrition and the immune response                                                                 !12   10
31   Immune aspects of systemic lupus erythematosus        and other related diseases                  136    7
32   Phosphdigids    in the fetaf lung                                                                 234    3
33   Clinical treatment of pituitary prolactinoma     and adenuma                                      336    5
34   Hormone interactions M the pi!uitary level                                                         74   II
35   Neuropharmacological      regufaticm of pituitary hormones                                        402    5
24   Prolac!in and male reproductive organs                                                            102    8
37   Hormone receptor function and sexual abnormafbles                                                 161    5

fronts range from 20 to more than 1,000                          chemistry. They are numbered eight to
but they are all shown on the map as sin-                        11 on the map. These research fronts
gle points. However, the map i.r multidi-                        concentrate      cm valence states, band
mensionally scaled ls—the distances be-                          structure theory of metals, properties of
tween clusters reflect how close or far                          solid surfaces, and properties of mole-
apart they are in subject matter. In ef-                         cules. However, of the 633 1981 citing
fect, the map depicts the cognitive struc-                       papers in these research fronts, only 36,
ture of the research areas shown. Keep                           or six percent,      were from Central or
in mind that the scaling is multidimen-                          South America,
sional—when it is reproduced on a flat                               The research fronts numbered 12-37
page,     the distances     between     some                     are in the life sciences. About 8,100 cit-
clusters are altered to prevent overlap-                         ing papers published in 1981 are inchrd-
ping. Ideally, a three-dimensional     model                     ed in these 26 research fronts. Only 315,
could be built for these maps, like the                          or four percent, are from Latin America.
ball and stick models used by chemists.                          However,       several individual   research
    The research fronts numbered          one                    fronts show a high concentration       of pa-
through seven on the map in Figure 1                             pers from Latin America. For example,
deal with physics and astrophysics. They                         research front number 29, “Effects of
discuss the interacting boson model, lat-                        dietary cholesterol on the plasma and ar-
 tice-gauge theories,    untiled field the-                      terial wall of undernourished      rats,” in-
 ories, stellar evolution, and studies of                        CIudes 21 papers—38 percent of these
 various types of stars. More than 1,100                         were from Central or South America.
 1981 citing papers are included in these                        Latin America accounts for 24 percent
 seven research fronts, and 104, or nine                         of the 38 published papers in research
 percent, are from Latin America.                                front number        13, “Development      and
    The concentration    of Latin American                       structure     of trypanosoma. ” Of the 63
 citing papers was particularly       high in                    papers in research front number 12,
 three of these research fronts in physics                       “Microphage       activation and intercellu-
 and astrophysics. Of the 75 papers pub-                         lar infection,”      19 percent were from
 lished in 1981 that cited research front                        Latin America.
 number one, “Spectroscopic        studies of                        This map shows, at a glance, that
 Wolf-Rayet stars,” 17 percent were from                         Latin American science in 198f con-
 Central or South America. Sixteen per-                           tinued to place a heavy emphasis on the
 cent of the 77 papers in research front                          life sciences. Physics, astrophysics, and
 number seven, “Renormalization         group                     physical chemistry are other areas of
 studies of percolation behavior in lattice                       specialization.   Of course, Latin Ameri-
 models, ” were from Latin America. In                            can scientists do work in areas that do
 research front number three, “Neutrino                           not appear on the map—mathematics
  masses, neutral currents, and other fac-                        and engineering, for example. But they
 tors involved in unified field theories, ”                       are most active in the research areas
 Latin America accounts for 15 percent                            shown here. Also, the research fronts
 of the 288 papers published.                                     we’ve discussed were identified quan-
     Latin American scientists were also                          titatively by determining the number of
  active in four research fronts in physical                       1981 papers and the percentage         from

Latin America. The map shows those re-                        compile science indicators reports for
search areas in which Latin American                          any country or region desired. Indeed, a
scientists    published    most frequently.                   proposal to compile such data may be
They are not necessarily the “best” or                        discussed at a conference sponsored by
highest-impact      areas of Latin American                   the United Nations, to be held this May
science.                                                      in Graz, Austria, For more information,
   This concludes our analysis of Latin                       contact     M. Anandakrishnan,        Room
American science. As you can see, ISI’s                       1040, 1 United Nations Plaza, New
data bases can provide unique insights                        York, New York, 10017.
into the scienttlc output of any nation or                       In the coming weeks, we plan to pub-
group of nations—its productivity,           im-              lish more studies of the scientific litera-
pact,    internationality,    interlinguality,                ture from various other geographic re-
and areas of specialization.         The data                 gions. Interested readers should also re-
we’ve presented are relevant and impor-                       fer to earlier studies of highly cited arti-
tant measures of a nation’s scientific                        cles and journals from France, 19 Scan-
“economy.” In fact, the US National Sci-                      dkavia,zo and Italy .21
ence Board has used ISI’S data in its Sci-
ence Indicators reports since the early                                         *****
1970s. While these reports provide sev-
eral international comparisons, they pri-                       My thanks to Abigail W. Grimom and
marily fecus on the US. This study dem-                      Alfred Welljams-Dorof for their help in
onstrates that ISI’S data can be used to                     the preparation of this essay,   c,1984 [S1


16. Frame J D, Mainstream     research    in Latin America      and the Caribbean.    /n/erc-iencia 2:143-8, 1977.
17,   GarfieldE. ABCS of cluster mapping.       Paris I & 2. Most active     fields in the life and physical
       sciences in 1978. Essays of an information       scientist.
       Philadelphia:  1S1 Press, 1981. Vol. 4. p. 634-49.
18. Kruskal J B. Multidimensional      scaling by optimizing goodness of fit to a nonme(ric hypothesis.
          Psychometrika   29:1-27,   1964.
19.   Garfield   E. Le nouveau d~fi Am&’icain. I & II. Es.rays of an information       scientist.
         Philadelphia: 1S1 Press, 1980. Vol. 3. p. 88-102.
20. --------------- Journal citation studies, 28. Scandinavian joumafs. ,Jkay$ o~an information      sciert(is[.
         Philadelphia: ISI Press, 1977. Vol. 2. p. 599-W5.
21. --------------- Higfdy cited articles. 34. Articles from Italian journals and from Italian laboratories.
         Essays of an information      .Kienti.s(. Philadelphia: 1S1 Press, 19S0. Vol. 3. p, 34-41.

   In the Current Comments@ essay, “IS your journal ‘up front’ with your address?
Or, the saga of the incomplete address. Part 1,“ Current Contents” (42):5-13, 17 Oc-
tober 1983, I stated, “The signers of the now famous Vancouver Declaration did not
consider the issue of author addresses. ” This statement is indeed true of the original
   However, Edward Huth, North American correspondent,          International Commit-
tee of Medical Journal Editors, points out that the declaration was intended to
define manuscript requirements,     not to specify publication format. The latest ver-
sion of the declaration  does specify that the manuscript carry the address of the au-
thor responsible for correspondence     about the manuscript and the address of the
author to whom reprint requests should be addressed.
   My thanks to Dr. Huth, who is also editor of Anna[s of Interns/ Medicine, for his
1. [ntematJonal Committee   of Medical Jounral EdJtora, IJniform requirements for manuscripts
        submitted to biomedical journals. Ann. fnrerrz. Med. 96:766-71, 1982.


To top