FY 2005 Superfund Five-Year Review Report to Congress (October 2006) (PDF)

J~~1ED STq p~ ~~lqt PROSEG~O . z UNITED STATES ENVIRONMENTAL PROTECTION AGENCY WASHINGTON, D .C. 20460 OCT - 5 2006 THE ADMINISTRATOR The Honorable Dennis Hastert Speaker of the House of Representatives Washington, DC 20515 Dear Mr. Speaker : I am pleased to submit the FY 2005 Superfund Five-Year Review Report to Congress, in accordance with the requirements in Section 121(c) of the Comprehensive Environmental Response, Compensation, and Liability Act, as amended. If you have any questions or comments regarding the report, please contact Assistant Administrator Susan Bodine, Office of Solid Waste and Emergency Response, or your staff may contact Carolyn Levine in the Office of Congressional and Intergovernmental Relations at 202-564-1859 . Enclosure Recycled/Recyclable -Printed with Vegetable Oil Based Inks on Recycled Paper (Minimum 50% Postconsumer content) Intemet Address (URL) " http ://www .epa .gov '' n ~~SED STql~ J S, o 3 Fti A ~~r y~2 W UNITED STATES ENVIRONMENTAL PROTECTION AGENCY lq~ PROS~~ ,o WASHINGTON, D.C . 20460 OCT - 5 2006 THE ADMINISTRATOR The Honorable Richard B. Cheney President of the Senate Washington, DC 20510 Dear Mr. President: I am pleased to submit the FY2005 Superfund Five-Year Review Report to Congress, in accordance with the requirements in Section 121(c) of the Comprehensive Environmental Response, Compensation, and Liability Act, as amended. If you have any questions or comments regarding the report, please contact Assistant Administrator Susan Bodine, Office of Solid Waste and Emergency Response, or your staff may contact Carolyn Levine in the Office of Congressional and Intergovernmental Relations at 202-564-1859. Enclosure Recycled/Recyclable " Printed with Vegetable Oil Based Inks on Recycled Paper (Minimum 50% Postconsumer content) Internet Address (URL) . http://www.epa .gov OSWER # 9200.2-51 FY 2005 REPORT TO CONGRESS SUPERFUND FIVE-YEAR REVIEWS PURPOSE : The U.S. Environmental Protection Agency (EPA) is responsible for reviewing Superfund remedial actions at least every five years where hazardous substances, pollutants, or contaminants will remain on site above levels that allow for unlimited use and unrestricted exposure . EPA is also responsible for preparing a report to Congress on these reviews . BACKGROUND : Section 121(c) of the Comprehensive Environmental Response, Compensation, and Liability Act (CERCLA), as amended, states : "If the President selects a remedial action that results in any hazardous substances, pollutants, or contaminants remaining at the site, the President shall review such remedial action no less often than each S years after the initiation of such remedial action to assure that human health and the environment are being protected by the remedial action being implemented. In addition, ifupon such review it is the judgment of the President that action is appropriate at such site in accordance with section 9604 or 9606 ofthe Title, the President shall take or require such action. " CERCLA also requires that EPA report to Congress information regarding these sites for which the reviews are required . This report provides a list of sites, information about sites where additional work is required, and contacts for additional information. FINDINGS : The attached table presents a list of statutory five-year reviews for non-Federal sites and NPL Federal facility sites, including the following: . Reviews Reviews Reviews Reviews due in FY 2005, currently completed ; due in prior or later fiscal years, but completed in FY 2005 ; due in FY 2005, still pending ; and due in prior fiscal years, still pending. For non-Federal sites, a total of 163 sites required five-year reviews in FY 2005 . 162 reviews were completed for 161 of the 163 sites requiring reviews . Another 13 reviews, due in other fiscal years, also were completed, bringing the total number of nonFederal site five-year reviews completed to 175 . For Federal facility sites, a total of 24 sites required five-year reviews in FY 2005 . Reviews for 22 of the 24 sites requiring reviews were completed . Another ten reviews that were due at nine sites in other fiscal years also were completed, bringing the total number of Federal facility five-year reviews completed to 32 . In all, the total number of five-year reviews completed for both non-Federal and Federal facility sites was 207. The remedies at 15 of these sites (or portions of the sites) required additional work or additional study. For these sites, implementation ofthe recommendations in the five-year review reports are underway . For FY 2005, two Federal facility five-year reviews remain pending. The Federal Agencies responsible for producing the five-year review report are aware that these reports are due and are working to complete them. Five-year reviews at two non-Federal facility sites also are pending. In addition, two five-year reviews (one Federal facility site and one non-Federal facility) that were due in fiscal years prior to FY 2005 remain pending. EPA expects that these six reviews will be completed in the near future . The five-year reviews contained in this report are publicly available . Additional information for any five-year reviews identified in this report can be obtained by contacting the Office of Superfund Remediation and Technology Innovation at (703) 603-8960, or the Superfund Call Center at (703) 412-9810 or (800) 424-9346 . Copies of all five-year review reports also are available on the national Superfund web page (http ://cfpub .epa.gov/fiveyear/) . FY 2005 Superfund Five-Year Review Report to Congress reaera Regio n Site Name 01 BRUNSWICK NAVAL AIR STATION 01 BURGESS BROTHERS LANDFILL 01 CANNON ENGINEERING CORP. CEC CHARLES-GEORGE RECLAMATION TRUST 01 LANDFILL 01 FORT DEVENS 01 LORING AIR FORCE BASE Facility (*) * * Year Date Protectiveness Due Completed Statement' 2005 9/29/05 Short-Term Protective 2005 --N21 /05 Short-Term Protective 2005 9/23/05 Will Be Protective 2005 6/28/05 Short-Term Protective isca 01 01 f 01 01 OLD SOUTHINGTON LANDFILL 01 PINETTE'S SALVAGE YARD 01 PSC RESOURCES 01 RAYMARK INDUSTRIES INC. OU 1 01 SACO MUNICIPAL LANDFILL NNEW BEDFORD EI NEEWPORT NAVAL EDUCATION & TRAINING CENTER LO 0 CE NORWOOD PCBS 02 02 02 02 02 02 02 02 02 01 SOMERSWORTH SANITARY LANDFILL ASBESTOS DUMP ASBESTOS DUMP BARCELONETA LANDFILL BATAVIA LANDFILL BROOKHAVEN NATIONAL LABORATORY CHEMSOL INC . COLESVILLE MUNICIPAL LANDFILL FMC CORP. DUBLIN ROAD LANDFILL FORT DIX LANDFILL SITE 2005 12/29/04 Protective 2005 9/13/05 Will Be Protective 2005 9/27/ 05 Protective 2005 9/ 29/05 Will Be Protective 2005 9/30/05 Protective 2005 9/15/05 Protective 2005 2005 2005 2005 2005 2005 2005 2005 2004 2005 9/1/05 Protective 2004 _2a0J05 Will Be Prote~Five 2005 12/22/04 Will Be Protective 2005 9/29/05 Protectiveness Deferred 2005 * 9/30/ 05 9119/05 9/20/05 8/ 11/05 91 16/05 Pending Protective Protective Short-Term Protective Protective Short-Term Protective DIVISION 02 GRIFFISS AIR FORCE BASE 11 AREAS 02 HERTEL LANDFILL IMPERIAL OIL CO., INC./CHAMPION 02 GENERAL MOTORS (CENTRAL FOUNDRY 02 02 JACKSON TOWNSHIP LANDFILL 02 JIS LANDFILL 02 LI TUNGSTEN CORP. 02 MONROE TOWNSHIP LANDFILL 02 PLATTSBURGH AIR FORCE BASE 02 PULVERIZING SERVICES 02 RAMAPO LANDFILL 02 ROEBLING STEEL CO. 02 VOLNEY MUNICIPAL LANDFILL 02 YORK OIL CO. ARROWHEAD ASSOCIATES, INC ./SCOVILL 03 03 BALLY GROUND WATER CONTAMINATION 03 BERKLEY PRODUCTS C0. DUMP 03 BERKS LANDFILL CORP. CHEMICALS * * 2005 2007 2006 2005 2004 2005 2005 2005 2004 2005 2005 2005 2005 2005 2007 2005 2005 2005 7/14/05 Will Be Protective 9/15/05 Will Be Protective 6/13/05 Protective 9/30/05 Will Be Protective Short-Term Protective Will Be Protective Will Be Protective Protective 11 8/04 Protective 5/16/ 05 Will Be Protective 12/23/04 Protective 1/21/04 Will Be Protective 8/ 5/05 Short-Term Protective 11/4/ 04 Protective 9/21/05 6 9 05 8 17 05 8 2 05 Short-Term Protective Not Protective Short-Term Protective Short-Term Protective 9/29/05 4/19/05 9/28/ 05 9/29/ 05 Short-Term Protective Short-Term Protective Short-Term Protective Protectiveness Deferred * 9/26/05 6/28/05 9/2/05 4/29/05 Page 1 of 6 FY 2005 Superfund Five-Year Review Report to Congress reaera Region 03 03 03 03 03 03 03 03 03 03 03 03 03 03 03 03 03 03 03 03 03 03 03 03 04 04 04 04 04 04 04 04 04 04 04 04 04 04 04 04 Site Nam e LBUSH VALLEY LANDFILL DELAWARE SAND & GRAVEL LANDFILL E.I . DU PONT DE NEMOURS & CO., INC. NEWPORT PIGMENT PLANT LANDFILL FIRST PIEDMONT CORP . ROCK QUARRY ROUTE 719 HAVERTOWN PCP HELLERTOWN MANUFACTURING C0. HUNTERSTOWN ROAD KANE & LOMBARD STREET DRUMS KEYSTONE SANITATION LANDFILL LANGLEY AIR FORCE BASE NASA LANGLEY RESEARCH CENTER L.A. CLARKE & SON MALVERN TCE MODERN SANITATION LANDFILL MW MANUFACTURING NCR CORP. MILLSBORO PLANT) NOVAK SANITARY LANDFILL OSBORNE LANDFILL PUB LICKER IN DUSTRIES INC . RESIN DISPOSAL STRASBURG LANDFILL Facility Year Date Protectiveness (*) I Due I Completed I Statement' 2005 qL22105 Short-Te rm Protective 2004 9/21/05 Short-Term Protective isca 2005 2004 3/31/05 2/3/05 Short-Term Protective Short-Term Protective Short-Term Protective Will Be Protective Will Be Protective Short-Term Protective * 2005 2005 2005 2005 2005 ~9/05 4/29/05 9/05 3/OS 4 29 05 %21/05 Short-Term Protective 2004 Pending 03 U.S. TITANIUM WEST VIRGINIA ORDNANCE USARMY) WHITMOYER LABORATORIES WOODLAWN COUNTY LANDFILL AGRICO CHEMICAL CO. AMERICAN CREOSOTE WORKS, INC . JACKSON PLAN ANNISTON ARMY DEPOT (SOUTHEAST INDUSTRIAL AREA CAMP LEJEUNE MILITARY RES . USNAVY DAVIS PARK ROAD TCE I HELENA CHEMICAL C0. (TAMPA PLANT) 1 HOMESTEAD AIR FO RCE BASE HOMESTEAD AIR FORCE BASE INTERSTATE LEAD CO. ILCO MADISON COUNTY SANITARY LAN DFILL MILAN ARMY AMMUNITION PLANT NORTH HOLLYWOOD DUMP NORTHWEST 58TH STREET LAN DFILL IOLIN CORP. (MCINTOSH PLANT) PARRIS ISLAND MARINE CORPS RECRUIT DEPOT PEAK OIL CO. BAY DRUM CO. SUSSEX COUNTY LA NDFILL N0. 5 i * 2004 9/ 29/05 Short-Term Protective 2005 9/21/05 Short-Term Protective 2005 3/4/05 Protective 2005 8/23/05 Short-Term Protective 2005 6/28/05 Short-Term Protective 2005 ~ 3/23/06 1 Short-Term Protective 2005 91 8/05 1 Protective 2005 1/18/ 05 Protective 2005 9/21/05 Protective 2005 2/2/05 Protective * 2005 2005 2005 2005 2005 2005 * * * * 2004 20051 2005 1 2002 1 2003 1 2005 2005 2006 2005 2006 2005 2005 2005 2005 3 24/05 7/ 1R/05 JL15105 128/05 7L11105 7/21/04 11/4/04 21105 Short-Term Prote ctive Will Be Protective Short-Term Protective Protectiv e Short-Term Protective Protective Protective Not Protective 2005 * 6/1/05 Protective 1/31/06 Short-Ter m Protective 8/2 5/05 ~ Protective 8/25105 ~ Protective Pending 9/23/05 Protective 9/ 27/05 Will Be Protective 9/23/05 Short-Term PrntPrtiva 9/30/05 Protective 4/ 25/06 Protective 9/19/05 9 23 05 Short-Term Protective Short-Term Protective 3/24/ 05 Protective Page 2 of 6 FY 2005 Superfund Five-Year Review Report to Congress Region 04 04 Facility (*) e era PETROLEUM PRODUCTS CORP. PIONEER SAND C0. SANGAMO ESTON, INC ./TWELVE-MILE 04 CREEK/LAKE HARTWELL PCB ICONTAMINATION 04 SHERWOOD MEDICAL INDUSTRIES 04 STANDARD AUTO BUMPER CORP. 04 STAUFFER CHEMICAL CO TAMPA STAUFFER CHEMICAL C0. (COLD CREEK 04 PLANT STAUFFER CHEMICAL CO. (LEMOYNE 04 PLAN T.H. AGRICULTURE & NUTRITION CO. 04 ALBANY PLANT 04 TRIANA ENNESSEE RIVER 04 USN AIR STATION CECIL FIELD 04 IWHITING FIELD NAVAL AIR STATION ROAD MUNICIPAL INCINERATOR - 04 I DUMP 04 YELLOW WATER ROAD DUMP 05 ADAM'S PLATING 05 AMOCO CHEMICALS JOLIET LANDFILL) 05 BELVIDERE MUNICIPAL LANDFILL BETTER BFUTE PLATING C0. CHROME AND 05 -IZINC SHOPS 05 CHEM CENTRAL 05 ICIIY DISPOSAL CORP. LANDFILL 05 I COLUMBUS OLD MUNICIPAL LANDFI LL #1 CROSS BROTHERS PAIL RECYCLING 05 ( PEMBROKE) 05 DUELL & GARDNER LANDFILL 05 GALEN MYERS DUMP/ DRUM SALVAGE 05 GALESBURG/KOPPERS C0. 05 H .O.D . LANDFILL _05 114I-"MILL MANUFACTURING CO 05 IONIA CITY LANDFILL 05 IKENTWOOD LANDFILL 05 KYSOR INDUSTRIAL CORP 05 LAKELAND DISPOSAL SERVICE INC. 05 LEMBERGER LANDFILL INC . 05 LEMBERGER TRANSPORT & RECYCLING 05 LEMON LANE LANDFILL 05 MARION BRAGG DUMP 05 MASTER DISPOSAL SERVICE L ANDFILL 05 MIAMI COUNTY INCIN ERATOR MICHIGAN DISPOSAL SERVICE (CORK 05 STREET LANDFILL Site Name Year Due 2005 2005 isca Date Completed Protectiveness Statement' 12 20 05 Protective 12/ 13/04 Protective 20041 9/29/05 IShort-Term Protective 2005 12 13 04 Protective 2005 1 8/25/05 Protective 2004 qL30/05 Not Protective 2005 2005 2005 * * 2004 2006 2005 2005 12/21/05 Will Be Protective 12/21/05 Will Be Protective 1/31/06 2L25105 92205 §t14/06 Short-Term Protective Protective Protective Protective Protective 12/21/05 Protective 2005 E: 3/05 9T22005 §/27/05 2005 9/29/05 2005 qL19/05 Short-Term Protective Will Be Protective Protective 2005 2005 2005 2005 2005 11/23/04 Protective 11 16/04 Short-Term Protective 123/05 Short-Term Protective 92305 9/15/05 Short-Term Protective Protective 2005 I 2005 2005 2005 2005 2005 9/26/05 2005 1 9/30/05 9/21/05 9/2/05 Short-Term Protective Protective Short-Term Protective Protectiveness Deferred 2005 2005 2005 2005 2005 2005 2005 2005 2005 ~ 12/10/04 IShort-Term Protective 9/29/05 Not Protective 129/05 Protectiveness Deferred V0/26/04 Protective 130/05 Short-Term Protective 8 12 05 Short-Term Protective 9/21/05 Short-Term Protective 9/21/05 Short-Term Protective 6/23/05 Will Be Protective 9 27 05 Short-Term Protective 9/23/05 Prote ctiveness Deferred ~ 9/14/05 lProtectiveness Deferred Page 3 of 6 FY 2005 Superfund Five-Year Review Report to Congress Region ~ 05 05 05 05 05 05 05 05 05 05 05 05 05 05 05 05 05 05 05 06 06 06 06 06 06 06 06 06 06 06 06 06 06 06 06 07 07 07 07 07 07 AMERICAN CREOSOTE WORKS, INC . I(WINNFIELD PLAN BAILEY WASTE DISPOSAL CAL WEST METALS (USSBA) CRYSTAL CHEMICAL C0. JACKSONVILLE MUNICIPAL LANDFILL MOSLEY ROAD SANITARY LANDFILL 1PESSES CHEMICAL C0. 1 PREWITTABANDONED REFINERY IROGERS ROAD MUNICIPAL LANDFILL I RSR CORPORATION 1WRIGHT-PATTERSON AIR FORCE BASE NINTH AVENUE DUMP NORTHERN ENGRAVING C0. NORTHERNAIRE PLATING 1 PENTA WOOD PRODUCTS PETOSKEY MUNICIPAL WELL FIELD RASMUSSEN'S DUMP REILLY TAR & CHEMICAL CORP. (DOVER PLANT REILLY TAR & CHEMICAL CORP. INDIANAPOLIS PLANT SAUK COUNTY LANDFILL SCA INDEPENDENT LANDFILL SOUTHSIDE SANITARY LANDFILL SPICKLER LANDFILL THERMO-CHEM INC . TIPPECANOE SANITARY LANDFILL INC . TOMAH MUNICIPAL SANITARY LANDFILL U.S. AVIEX WAITE PARK WELLS WINDOM DUMP Site Name i Federal Facility (*) 2005 9/2/05 2005 9/30/05 2005 __ 2Z4 05 2005 3/ 16/05 2005 8/25/0 5 2005 2005 2005 2005 2005 2005 2005 2005 2005 2005 2005 2005 2005 2005 ~ * 2005 2005 2005 2005 2005 2005 2005 2005 2005 ~ 2005 2005 2008 2005 2005 2005 2005 2005 2005 2005 6/7/05 6/5/05 2005 Year Due is Date Completed 9/29/05 Short-Term Protective Short-Term Protective Will Be Protective Short-Term Protective Short-Ter m Protective Short-Term Protective Protective Sh ort-Term Protective Protectiveness Statement' * 8/19/ 05 Protective 5/13/05 Will Be Protective 9/20/05 Protective 9/27/05 Short-Term Protective 5/ 10/05 Short-Term Protective W30/05 Short-Term Protective 42005 Short-Term Protective 12304 Short-Term Protective 6105 Short-Term Protective 22305 Protective 12 _9/05 Protective 9/18/05 Short-Term Protective Protective Protective Protective Protective Short-Term Protective 9/28/05 _205 9/ 19/05 9129/05 9/30/05 9/ 15/05 7/21/05 9/20/05 9[30/05 9129/05 9/8/05 9 28 05 9 28 05 9 29/05 9/23/05 9/23/05 9/29/05 9/30/05 Pending 9/27/05 9/29/05 ' Short-Term Protective Short-Term Protective Protective ISAND SPRINGS PETROCHEMICAL COMPLEX SOUTH VALLEY SOUTHERN SHIPBUILDING TEX-TIN CORP. TINKER AIR FORCE BASE (SOLDIER 1CREEK/BUILDING 3001) UNITED CREOSOTING C0. 10TH STREET SITE 29TH & MEAD GROUND WATER CONTAMINATIO N CHEROKEE COU NTY CONSERVATION CHEMICAL C0. DOEPKE DISPOSAL HOLLIDAY FINDETT CORP. Short-Term Protective Protective Will Be Protective Will Be Protective * 2007 ~ 1/25/05 Short-Term Protective Protective Short-Term Protective Protective Protective Protective Protective Protectiveness Deferred Page 4 of 6 FY 2005 Superfund Five-Year Review Report to Congress reaera Regio n 07 FULBPTrWT § ANDF §FULBPTrWT M L R W T GH U L 07 IOWAACITY ITE ARMY AMML AMMUNITION PLANT 7 Site Name Facility M Year Due 2005 ' 2005 2005 2005 isca Date Completed 32306 92205 9/7/05 Protectiveness Statement' tive Protective Will Ri- Prnhor+iVe entl 7 07 07 07 07 07 07 08 08 08 08 08 08 08 08 08 08 08 09 09 09 09 09 09 09 09 09 09 09 09 09 09 09 10 10 08 LAWRENCE TODTZ FARM OBEE ROAD PEOPLES NATURAL GAS CO. SHAW AVENUE DUMP SHELLER-GLOBE CORP. DISPOSAL WELDON SPRING FORMER ARMY ORDNANCE WORKS LABOUNTY SITE W UL0 LAKKEE CITY ARMY AMMUNITION PLANT 0 ST SLj L NORTHWEST .~ LAGOON) I My Y fi E T AG, Protective * 2005 2005 2005 2005 2005 2003 2005 2005 2005 2005 2005 2005 2005 2005 2005 2005 2005 2005 2004 2005 2005 2005 2005 2005 2005 2005 2005 2005 2005 1998 2005 2005 Short-Term Protective 9 2 05 9/2205 9 1 05 3/21/05 9/27/ 05 9/ 30105 2/3/05 9/29/05 9/ 30/05 3/31/05 9/28/05 9/30/ 05 9/28/05 91 27/05 9/28/05 9/21/05 Short-Term Protective Protective Short-Term Protective Protective Protective Protective Protective Protective Protective Protective Protective Protective Protective Protective Protective Protective Protective Protective Will Be Protective Short-Term Protective Protectiveness Deferred Short-Term Protective Short-Term Protective Short-Term Protective Protective Short-Term Protective Short-Term Protective Protective ANACONDA CO. SMELTER EAGLE MINE ELLSWORTH AIR FORCE BASE F .E. WARREN AIR FORCE BASE IDAHO POLE C0. JACOBS SMELTER LIBBY GROUND WATER CONTAMINATION SAND CREEK INDUSTRIAL SILVER BOW CREEK/BUTTE AREA SMELTERTOWN SITE SUMMITVILLE MINE URAVAN URANIUM PROJECT (UNION CARBIDE CORP. DEL AMO DEL NORTE PESTICIDE STORAGE FRESNO MUNICIPAL SANITARY LANDFILL J.H. BAXTER & C0. LIQUID GOLD OIL CORP. LORENTZ BARREL & DRUM C0. SIATHER AIR FORCE BASE (AC&W DISPOSAL ~ MOUNTAIN VIEW MOBILE HOME ESTATES NINETEENTH AVENUE LANDFILL OPERATING INDUSTRIES INC . LANDFILL PHOENIX-GOODYEAR AIRPORT AREA NORTH ZON SOUTH BAY ASBESTOS AREA SOUTHERN CALIFORNIA EDISON CO. PHOENIX ODYEAR AIRPORT AREA 9 905 * * TRACY DEFENSE DEPOT USARMY AMERICAN LAKE GARDENS MCCHORD AFB BANGOR NAVAL SUBMARINE BASE VISAL POLEYARD SOUTH ZONE 9/28/05 9/22/05 9/8/05 9/27/05 9/28/ 05 * 9 28 05 9 28 05 9/28 /05 9/30105 9/28/ 05 11/24/04 Short-Term Protective 9/30/05 Pending 9/27/05 Protectiveness Deferred Short-Term Protective 9/29/05 * * * 2005 2005 2005 9 23 05 fProtective 4 7 OS Protective 12 30 05 Short-Term Protective Page 5 of 6 FY 2005 Superfund Five-Year Review Report to Congress Region 10 Facility (*) era 10 COMMENCEMENT BAY, NEAR SHORE/TIDE F LATS 10 HAR-BORISLAND (LEAD) 15A`HO NATIONAL EiiG-INEERING 10 LABORATOELLIULSDOE) JACKSON PARK HOUSING COMPLEX 10 USNAVY 10 KETCHIKAN PULP COMPANY 10 MARTIN-MARIETTA ALUMINUM E0_ 10 MIDWAY LANDFILL 10 I NAVAL UNDERSEA WARFARE ENGINEERING STATION (4 WASTE AREAS) 10 Site Name 13UNKER HILL MINI COMPLEX LURGICAL Year FD te Due leted ~ is Protectiveness Statementl COAL CREEK AKA ROSS ELECTRIC [2005 2005 2005 * * 2005 2005 10/24/05 lWill Be Protective 3/23/05 Protective 12/29/04 [Will Be Protective ,9L29/05 Will Be Protective Pending 8/2/05 Protective 6,130/05 17Protectiveness Deferred Protective 2005 005 2005 2005 5/11/06 Not Protective 9 28 05 10 PORT HADLOCK DETACHMENT (USNAVY) 10 UMATILLA ARMY DEPOT (LAGOONS) * F- , ~ . . . . ---- . . . . . ~ :- . . . P-rotective 11129111 ive 2005 P 12/14/05 lWill Be Protective 2005 1904 Short-Term 4 Short-Term 1 For all sites that require a five-year review, a separate protectiveness determination is generally made for each portion (operable unit) of the site. The statement that is considered "least protective" is used as the general determination for the review in this report. For example, if one operable unit is protective but another operable unit has protectiveness deferred, the determination for the entire review will be protectiveness deferred. Protective - The remedy is protective of human health and the environment. Short-Term Protective - The remedy is protective of human health and the environment in the short-term . This statement is generally used when the remedy is protective but requires further actions or institutional controls to remain protective in the long-term. Will Be Protective - The remedy is expected to be protective of human health and the environment completion, and in the interim, exposure upon pathways that could result in unacceptable risks are being controlled . This statement is generally used for remedies that are under construction . Protectiveness Deferred - A Protectiveness determination of the remedy cannot be made until further information is obtained . Generally, reviews that include this determination identify both the timeframe necessary to obtain the information actions and so a Protectiveness determination can be made through an addendum to the five-year review report . Not Protective - The remedy is not protective of human health and/or the environment . For example, a new exposure pathway may be identified or a remedy may not be able to meet a new cleanup reviews that include this determination level. Generally, identify actions that need to be taken to ensure protectiveness .