# Ngt Template

Document Sample

```					Nominal Group Technique - Multivoting Tool
This template guides you through a simple elimination technique that can be used to determine the final,
and vital few, root causes to a problem.

Basic Steps:
1. Conduct a brainstorming session using the Nominal Group Technique to capture Potential Root
Causes (PRCs)
2. List your 12-15 PRCs in the first column.
Have each team member assign a PRC and each is the on a scale of 1 to 8*.
3. *8 = Highest degree of correlation between score toCTQ; 7 PRC second; 6 is the third and so on to 1, or the lowest
correlation.
4. Add all the scores from the team members for each particular PRC.
5. Use the resulting Pareto to analyze your results
The PRC with the highest score is ranked 1st, the one with the second highest score 2nd, and so on.
NOMINAL GROUP TECHNIQUE MULT
VOTING CRITERIA - 8 POINTS FOR TOP MOST PRIORITY OR 1S
FOR 2ND CHOICE; 6 POINTS FOR 3RD CHOICE; 5 POINTS F
THE POTENTIAL ROOT          ETC.(SO ON TILL 1 POINTS FOR LAST PRIORITY OR C
CAUSES(PRC'S)
TEAM        TEAM        TEAM         TEAM
MEMBER 1    MEMBER 2    MEMBER 3     MEMBER 4

PRC1

PRC2

PRC3

PRC4

PRC5

PRC6

PRC7

PRC8

PRC9

PRC10

PRC11

PRC12
PRC12

TEAM MEMBERS ENTER
THEIR CHOICES IN THESE
CELLS
IQUE MULTIVOTING
OST PRIORITY OR 1ST CHOICE; 7 POINTS
CHOICE; 5 POINTS FOR 4TH CHOICE      GRAND TOTAL OF
AST PRIORITY OR CHOICE……/)          WEIGHTED RATINGS
OF PRC FOR EACH
TEAM         TEAM        TEAM       TEAM MEMBER
MEMBER 4    MEMBER 5   MEMBER 6

0

0

0

0

0

0

0

0

0

0

0

0
0
NOMINAL GROUP TECHNIQUE MUL
VOTING CRITERIA - 8 POINTS FOR TOP MOST OR 1ST CHOICE; 7
CHOICE; 6 POINTS FOR 3RD CHOICE; 5 POINTS FOR 4TH CHOICE
THE POTENTIAL ROOT                         1 POINTS FOR LAST PRIORITY OR CHOICE……/
CAUSES(PRC'S)
TEAM        TEAM        TEAM        TEAM
MEMBER 1    MEMBER 2    MEMBER 3    MEMBER 4

Dryer Surface Temperature        8           5            7           8

Air Temperature Surrounding
8           5            7           7
Dryers

Machine Speed               8           8            6           8

Steam Temperature in Main
5           8            8           8
Haeder

Moisture After 1st Press        3           5            7           7

Moisture After 2nd Press        3           5            7           7

Moisture After 3rd Press        7           7            8           8

Steam Pressure Pre - Dryer
3           4            5           5
Top

Head Box Degree SR             1           2            1           2

Moisture After Wire           5           8            7           5

Ineffective Condensate
8           8            8           8
Removal

Variable Machine Draw           8           8            5           7
Variable Machine Draw   8   8   5   7
HNIQUE MULTIVOTING
OST OR 1ST CHOICE; 7 POINTS FOR 2ND
INTS FOR 4TH CHOICE ETC.(SO ON TILL    GRAND TOTAL OF
ORITY OR CHOICE……/)                  WEIGHTED RANKINGS OF
PRC FOR EACH TEAM
TEAM        TEAM        TEAM           MEMBER
MEMBER 4    MEMBER 5    MEMBER 6

8          6           7               41

7          7           6               40

RD
8          7           8               45              3
8          8           5               42

7          5           6               33

7          6           7               35

8          8           8               46              2 ND
5          4           5               26

2          3           2               11

5          8           8               41

8          8           8               48              1 ST
7          5           8               41
7   5   8   41
PRC               RATING

Dryer Surface
Temperature
41
Air Temperature
Surrounding Dryers
40
Machine Speed           45
Steam Temperature in
Main Haeder
42
Moisture After 1st Press    33
Moisture After 2nd Press    35
Moisture After 3rd Press    46
Steam Pressure Pre -
Dryer Top
26
Moisture After Wire       41
Ineffective Condensate
Removal
48
Variable Machine Draw       41
Variable Machine Draw   41
RATING   RANKING

41        5
40        6
45        3
42        4
33        8
35        7
46        2
26        9
11        10
41        5
48        1
41        5
41   5
POTENTIAL ROOT CAUSE
Ineffective Condensate Removal
Moisture After 3rd Press
Machine Speed
Dryer Surface Temperature
Moisture After Wire
Variable Machine Draw
Air Temperature Surrounding Dryers
Moisture After 2nd Press
Moisture After 1st Press
Steam Pressure Pre Dryer Top
RANKING
48
46
45
42
41
41
41
40
35
33
26
11
60                                                                                                                                     100%100%
98%
92%
90%

50      48                                                                                           84%
46                                                                                                                     80%
45                                                          77%
42
41         41         41                                                              70%
40
40                                                                             68%

35                                        60%
59%                                    33
RANKING

30                                                       49%                                                                              50%
26

40%                                                                                         40%

20
31%                                                                                                    30%

21%                                                                                                       11      20%
10

11%                                                                                                                          10%

0                                                                                                                                        0%
Air
Ineffectiv                   Steam                                                         Steam
e      Moisture         Tempera          Moisture Variable         Moisture Moisture Pressure
Machine          Surface                     ture                              Box
Condens After 3rd            ture In          After Machine            After 2nd After 1st  Pre
Speed           Tempera                   Surroun                            Degree
ate      Press             Main            Wire     Draw             Press     Press    Dryer
ture                      ding                               SR