Flowchart Disciplinary Procedures Stages - PDF by gyf19478


More Info

     January 2005

                                                  Page No.

1.0      Purpose                                     3

2.0      Principles                                  4

3.0      Procedure                                   5

         Fact Finding                                5

         Suspension                                  6

         Hearings                                    6-7

         Penalties                                   7

         Appeals                                     7-8

4.0      Principal Officers                          8-9

Appendix 1 – Details of the Disciplinary Stages

Appendix 2 – Discipline process flowchart

Appendix 3 – Discipline support structure

Appendix 4 – Gross Misconduct

Appendix 5 – Procedure for dealing with suspension

Appendix 6 – Representation

Appendix 7 – Penalties

Appendix 8 – Appeals procedure

Disciplinary Procedures – January 2005   2
                                         DISCIPLINARY PROCEDURE

1.0      PURPOSE

1.1      The procedures are written to help and encourage all employees to achieve
         and maintain their standards of conduct and to ensure consistent and fair
         treatment for all employees in the organisation.

1.2      The aim is to ensure that appropriate action can be taken without
         unnecessary delay, but in a framework, which also ensures fairness for both
         employees and managers.

1.3      The guiding principle of the procedures is that, in every case except
         dismissal, the aim is to obtain improvement and remedy problems. Each
         case shall be treated on its merits in the light of the particular circumstances
         involved. The basis of this procedure is that the principle of natural justice
         both applies, and is clearly seen to apply, at every stage. Natural Justice is

                   •     A person knows the nature of the allegation against them;
                   •     They are given the opportunity to state their case;
                   •     And that the disciplinary body acts in good faith.

1.4      In the workplace, expected standards of conduct are usually maintained
         through the normal day-to-day relationships between supervisors and
         employees. Good management practice should ensure that all employees are
         aware of acceptable standards of behaviour and conduct and that they
         receive appropriate support to ensure that these are maintained.

1.5      Minor breaches of conduct can be dealt with successfully in an informal way
         and will remind the employee of the standards of conduct and behaviour that
         are expected. Early intervention and action are essential to avoid matters

1.6      If an employee does not respond to informal action, or there is a more serious
         allegation of misconduct, then it may be necessary to use the formal
         disciplinary procedure. This procedure is a framework to ensure that
         managers deal with disciplinary matters in a fair and consistent way.

Disciplinary Procedures – January 2005            3

2.1      This is a harmonised disciplinary procedure that applies to all staff.

2.2      In the event of disciplinary action, the emphasis should be to encourage an
         improvement in behaviour rather than merely punish the employee. A full
         investigation of facts and an opportunity for the individual to explain their
         action and state their case should be undertaken.

2.3      Privacy and confidentiality shall be observed in all actions taken under this

2.4      At all stages the employee shall be kept fully informed of the allegations
         made against him/her and will have adequate opportunity to provide an
         explanation or rebuttal.

2.5      In accordance with the Employment Relations Act 1999 the employee has the
         right to be accompanied by a trade union representative or fellow worker. It is
         the responsibility of the employee to arrange his/her own representation.
         (Appendix 6 gives more detail on representation).

2.6      Staff who are interviewed or appear at a hearing as a witness do not need to
         be represented as they are merely providing facts and information and are
         NOT being investigated themselves. However, they may be accompanied at
         a hearing by a fellow worker or trade union representative if they feel the
         need for support. Additional support may also be available in exceptional
         cases, for example, where a witness is concerned about their personal safety
         or the consequences of giving evidence. Witnesses must answer questions
         for themselves; it is neither appropriate nor permitted for anyone to speak on
         their behalf.

2.7      At all stages managers must take professional advice from either the Head of
         HR, Senior HR Manager or HR Manager prior to making any decisions on
         conclusion of investigations.

2.8      Allegations of misconduct, rather then poor performance, made during an
         employee’s probationary period shall be dealt with in accordance with the
         disciplinary procedure.

2.9      Disciplinary action against a trade union representative can lead to a serious
         dispute if it is seen as an attack on the union’s functions. Normal standards
         apply but, if disciplinary action is considered, the case should be discussed,
         after obtaining the employee’s agreement, with a senior trade union
         representative or permanent union official.

Disciplinary Procedures – January 2005       4
3.0      PROCEDURE

There are formal steps to be taken when implementing the disciplinary procedure.
These include the fact-finding process; suspension, if applicable; the hearing; the
penalties that can be applied; and the appeal procedure.

Appendix 1 outlines the detail at each stage of discipline process, including

Appendix 2 is a discipline process flowchart.

Appendix 3 outlines the managerial level that has authority to deal with the
disciplinary stages and the level at which advice and support is given.

These are formal procedures that must be strictly observed by all parties. Failure to
do so may invalidate the proceedings.

3.1      Fact Finding

3.1.1 Where appropriate, the Line Manager should undertake an investigation, with
      the support of the Human Resource Department. It should involve all parties
      and quickly establish the facts.

3.1.2 This will be concluded within a two week period. If there are exceptional
      circumstances which mean that the investigation will take longer to complete
      the Line Manager should consult with the Human Resource Department.

3.1.3 The decision whether to proceed with formal disciplinary action will be taken
      by the appropriate level of manager.

3.1.4 The employee must be kept informed of progress and likely timescales.

3.1.5 If appropriate, evidence will then be prepared and information exchanged
      with the employee, their representative, and relevant managers.

3.1.6 The disciplinary hearing should be arranged as soon as practicable giving
      notice of not less than 7 days for the first formal stage, 10 days for the
      second formal stage and 21 days for the third formal stage.

3.1.7 Where an employee is the subject of a criminal investigation this will not
      always prevent a disciplinary hearing taking place, provided that this does not
      prejudice any police enquiry or possible prosecution. Cases involving
      criminal matters should be discussed with Head of HR or Senior HR Manager
      to determine the most appropriate course of action.

3.1.8 If no formal disciplinary action is to be taken then no correspondence
      connected with the investigation should be kept on the employee’s personal
      record file, unless this is relevant to support an informal resolution.

Disciplinary Procedures – January 2005   5
3.2      Suspension

3.2.1 If the allegations involve gross misconduct, or where a continued presence in
      the workplace may prejudice an investigation or harm the interests of the
      employee or others, suspension from work or transfer to another location of
      the employee against whom the allegations are made may be considered and
      imposed. (See Appendix 4 for offences constituting gross misconduct
      and Appendix 5 for the policy on the suspension of staff).

3.2.2 Such a suspension is precautionary and is not a disciplinary penalty in itself.

3.2.3 During suspension the employee shall receive their normal pay. Normal pay
      includes all the guaranteed earnings that would be paid during a period of
      normal working, including allowances, but excludes any payments not paid
      on a regular basis. Full pay for those employees on the retained duty system
      and the retained element of employees conditioned to the day crewing
      system will be calculated on the basis of their retained payments averaged
      over a twelve-week period.

3.2.4 Where an employee is suspended and they commence sick leave, their pay
      will be in accordance with the rules of the sick pay scheme

3.2.5 A formal notice will be issued following the decision to suspend and the
      employee will receive advice on their entitlements and conditions of
      suspension. They will be asked to return to work for a disciplinary hearing as
      soon as possible. It is also appropriate at this stage to discuss any conditions
      which will apply during the period of suspension, for example,
      communications channels, availability to attend meetings, facilities to meet
      with their representative.

3.2.6 Leave which has already been arranged during a period of suspension will be
      taken and permission to take additional leave may be sought.

3.3      Hearings

3.3.1 All parties should receive notice of the time, date and location of the hearing
      in accordance with the requirements set out in Appendix 1, although it is
      acknowledged that in complex cases more time may be required. This should
      include details of the allegations and all supporting documents.

3.3.2 Where the employee indicates that they cannot attend at the specified time
      then, provided that the explanation is reasonable, alternative arrangements
      may be made. In accordance with the Employment Relations Act 1999, an
      alternative date must be offered by the employee and be within 7 days of the
      original hearing date. If the employee fails to attend, or does not give a
      reasonable explanation, the hearing may proceed in their absence.

Disciplinary Procedures – January 2005    6
3.3.3 Evidence shall be presented to a manager who will be advised and supported
      by a member of the Human Resource Department. The manager hearing the
      evidence will not be junior to the person presenting the allegations or the
      person facing them and will have had no prior involvement in the
      investigation. The Human Resource team member’s role is to advise on
      procedure and ensure fairness and consistency. A note-taker will also be

         The employee and the person making the allegation shall be given an
         opportunity to make statements, call witnesses, and question as appropriate.
         The manager will then adjourn the hearing to consider the evidence
         presented and make a decision as to misconduct

3.3.4 The outcome of the hearing will be confirmed in writing to the employee as
      soon as possible, but in any case within seven days.

3.3.5 In exceptional circumstances, or where senior managers are being
      investigated, fact finding and hearings may be conducted by people external
      to the organisation.

3.4      Penalties

3.4.1 If there is misconduct warranting disciplinary penalties the employee should
      be given an opportunity to make a statement in mitigation. The HR Manager
      will give details of their record of service. The manager conducting the
      hearing may adjourn to consider any additional information and to decide the
      appropriate level of penalty.
      (Details of penalties available are attached at Appendix 7).

3.4.2 A letter confirming the outcome of the hearing and any penalties should be
      placed on the employee’s personal record file for the appropriate period.
      Once this period has expired all correspondence relating to the discipline will
      be removed from the personal record file.

3.4.3 If no misconduct is evidenced, a letter confirming the findings and a copy of
      the notes of the hearing will be sent to the employee. No correspondence
      relating to the disciplinary matter shall be placed on the employee’s personal
      record file.

3.5      Appeals

3.5.1 Natural justice requires that employees have a right of appeal against any
      penalties imposed under this procedure, but it does not give the right for the
      whole case to be re-heard. The principle is that the evidence is presented at
      the original hearing and the appeal is confined to the outcomes from that

3.5.2 In the case of penalties other than dismissal, the penalties will not be
      implemented until any appeal process has concluded.

Disciplinary Procedures – January 2005     7
3.5.3 Notification of the intention to appeal against any penalty, including dismissal,
      must be submitted in writing to the Director of HR within 7 working days of
      receipt of the written confirmation of the penalty.

3.5.4 The employee must submit a written statement outlining the grounds of the
      appeal. These would normally be one or more of the following:

                   •       There was a defect in the procedure
                   •       The issue was not proven on the balance of probabilities
                   •       The penalty was too severe, giving reasons
                   •       New evidence has come to light which has an impact on the

3.5.5 The appeal only covers those elements raised by the employee in their
      grounds of appeal. Normally a rehearing in full will only be appropriate in the
      following circumstances (this is not an exhaustive list):

                   •       There was a procedural defect in the hearing
                   •       New evidence has come to light that needs to be heard in full

3.5.6. Reviews or part/full rehearings will be conducted at a level of management
       higher than the first hearing. (See Appendix 3).

3.5.7 Where an appeal is conducted as a review, the Appeal Manager will have
      available all the documents presented to the original hearing, as well as a
      copy of the record of the hearing, the letter confirming the outcome, the letter
      of appeal and the written statement of the grounds for the appeal. The
      Appeal Manager will reach findings based on the documentation and
      submissions from the parties. There is no requirement for attendance by the
      parties involved; however, they will be informed of the date of the review.

3.5.8 Where an appeal involves a part/full rehearing, the case will be presented by
      the manager who conducted the original disciplinary hearing, advised by the
      HR Manager also involved in the hearing. The employee has the right to
      attend the appeal hearing, accompanied by a trade union representative or
      fellow worker.

         Appendix 8 details the procedure and conduct of appeal hearings.

3.5.9 Appeals against dismissal will be heard by a Principal Officer.

4.0      Principal Officers

4.1      If disciplinary action is necessary in respect of a principal officer, this
         procedure will be applied, varied as necessary by the Secretary to the

Disciplinary Procedures – January 2005           8
4.2      Hearing will be heard as follows:

Employee                                 Formal Discipline     Appeal

Director                                 CFO/CE                FRA Appeals Committee

CFO/CE                                   FRA Appeals Committee FRA Appeals Committee
                                         3 Members             (3 different Members)

Disciplinary Procedures – January 2005                9
                                                                              Appendix 1

                            DETAILS OF THE DISCIPLINARY STAGES

1.       Informal stage

1.1      Cases involving minor misconduct are usually best dealt with informally by
         the line manager (which includes a Watch Manager or equivalent level or
         above). A quiet word is often all that is required and the informal approach
         means that minor problems can be dealt with quickly and confidentially. At
         this informal stage the manager should ensure that employees understand
         the position, and issue them a written note.

1.2      This notification would not form any part of their disciplinary record but it
         would be filed on their Personal Record File for 6 months.

1.3      There will, however, be situations where matters are more serious or where
         an informal approach has been tried but isn’t working. At this point it may be
         appropriate to enter the formal stages of the procedure.

2.       First formal stage

2.1      At this stage the employee’s line manager (Watch Manager level or
         equivalent or higher), or the equivalent support staff level of Supervisor or
         above, will instigate an investigation into the matter, after consultation and
         guidance from the Head of HR, Senior HR Manager or HR Manager.

2.2      Following investigation a decision will be taken by the line manager (Station
         Manager or equivalent or higher) to either:

                   •    Take no further action
                   •    Deal with informally
                   •    Proceed to a Stage 1 hearing
                   •    Refer to Stage 2 or 3

2.3      The decision to take no further action or deal with informally must first be
         discussed with the HR Manager.

2.4      The employee will be given a minimum of 7 days notice of the hearing. The
         letter should contain enough information for the employee to fully understand
         the case against them, including relevant documents; and the reasons why
         this is unacceptable. If the employee has difficulty reading, or if English is not
         their first language, the manager should explain the contents of the letter to
         them orally.

2.5      The employee has the right to be represented or accompanied and present
         their case in response to management.

Disciplinary Procedures – January 2005         10
2.6      Where, following a disciplinary hearing, an employee is found guilty of
         misconduct, the usual first step would be to give them a written warning
         setting out the nature of the misconduct and the change in behaviour
         required. This will take the form of a Personal Performance Improvement
         Plan produced by the manager in conjunction with HR.

2.7      A verbal decision will normally be given at the end of the hearing and this will
         be confirmed in writing and issued to those concerned within 7 days. The
         employee should be informed that the warning is part of the formal
         disciplinary process and what the consequences will be of the failure to
         change behaviour. The consequences could be a final written warning and
         ultimately, dismissal.

2.8      A record of the warning will be kept, but it will be disregarded for disciplinary
         purposes after 6 months and will be removed from the personal record file
         after that time.

2.9      Employees should be informed of their right of appeal against the written

3.0      Second Formal Stage

3.1      At this stage a Station Manager (or higher), or the equivalent support staff
         level of Supervisor or above, will instigate an investigation into the matter,
         after consultation and guidance from the Head of HR, Senior HR Manager or
         HR Manager.

3.2      Following investigation a decision will be taken by the Group Manager (or
         equivalent or higher).

3.3      Where there is a failure to improve or change behaviour in the timescale set
         at the first formal stage, the employee may be issued with a final written
         warning – but only after a further investigation and hearing.

3.4      Alternatively where misconduct is sufficiently serious, action may be initiated
         at this stage.

3.5      The procedure is the same as for stage 1 above except the notice of the
         hearing should be a minimum of 10 days and penalty that may be applied is

3.6      The final written warning will give details and an explanation of the decision.
         It will warn the employee that failure to improve or modify behaviour may lead
         to dismissal or some other penalty.

3.7      Final Written warnings will be disregarded for disciplinary purposes after 18

Disciplinary Procedures – January 2005      11
3.8      Employees should be informed of their right of appeal against the final written
         warning, or a lesser penalty, where this is issued.

4.0      Third formal stage

4.1      This stage should be conducted at Area Manager level or higher, or the
         equivalent support staff level of Section Head or above.

4.2      The procedure is the same as for stages 1 and 2 above except the notice of
         the hearing should be a minimum of 21 days and the penalty that may be
         applied is greater.

4.3      Where employees fail to improve or where misconduct is sufficiently serious,
         following an investigation and hearing, employees may be dismissed if the
         case against them is proven.

4.4      Alternatively, a decision may be made to award a penalty less than dismissal,
         or in serious cases, as an alternative to dismissal. These penalties are:

                   •     a warning
                   •     demotion, (either within role or no more than one grade/role; a
                         demotion of more than one role/grade can only be done with the
                         agreement of the employee)
                   •     disciplinary transfer (which should involve no loss of remuneration
                         and unless the employee agrees otherwise should be within the
                         same duty system)
                   •     Loss of pay up to a maximum of 13 days (this could be in addition
                         to one of the penalties listed above)

4.5      Employees should be informed of their right of appeal against the penalty

5.0      Gross misconduct

5.1      Where there are allegations of gross misconduct, that make an employee
         potentially liable for dismissal, it is important to establish the facts before
         taking any action. This must only be done following consultation and
         guidance from the Head of HR or Senior HR Manager. Examples of offences
         constituting gross misconduct are outlined in Appendix 4.

5.2      A period of suspension with full pay may be considered helpful or necessary
         while the investigation is taking place, although it should only be imposed
         after careful consideration and should be kept under review.

5.3      It should be made clear to the employee that the suspension is a
         precautionary matter, not disciplinary action in itself, and does not involve any
         prejudgement of the case.

Disciplinary Procedures – January 2005          12
5.4      Employees will have the opportunity to put their case at a disciplinary hearing
         before a decision is taken regarding any action.

5.5      Employees should be informed of their right of appeal against the dismissal,
         or a lesser penalty where this is issued.

6.0      General

6.1      At any stage in the disciplinary process the line manager in conjunction with
         HR may consider it appropriate to refer the employee to occupational health
         as a possible alternative to disciplinary action e.g. in cases of misuse of

Disciplinary Procedures – January 2005     13
                                                                                                                                                       Appendix 2
                                                                              DISCIPLINE PROCESS
                                                                                  FLOW CHART
      Describes the formal
       stages to be used
         where informal
       action has proved                                                  Line manager initiates process
        ineffective or the
       nature of alleged
         offence is more
                                                                       Seek advice from HR Management
                                                       Investigation                                                    Notify employee in writing
                                                       conducted by                                                     of investigation to include
                                                        appropriate                      Initial                           nature and details of
                                                         manager                     Investigation                                 case.

                                                        Manager                                                      Notify employee of
                                                      determination                     Decision                        outcome of

                                                    No Case to                    Informal resolution                            Refer case to a
                                                     Answer                                                                    disciplinary hearing

                                                                           Hearing chaired
                                                                          by an appropriate                          Employee given the appropriate notice
                                                                              manager                                for the hearing, dependent upon

                        Appeal must be lodged within 7 days of         Employee shall receive decision in writing     Outcome, one of the following:
                      receiving the warning and must specify the        within 7 days including notice of right of    No further action
                           grounds for the appeal in writing.           appeal where a warning is issued as an        Deal with informally
                                                                                        outcome.                      Issue appropriate warning

Disciplinary Procedure – January 2005
                                                                   Appendix 3


1.0      The table below shows the appropriate levels at which each stage of
         the discipline procedure will be conducted.

   Stage             Investigation      Advice   Hearing and/or     Appeal

Informal           Crew/Watch/Line       HR      Crew/Watch/Line      N/A
                      Manager                       Manager*

Formal                 Watch/Line        HR      Station Manager     Group
Stage 1                 Manager                   or Equivalent    Manager or

Formal             Station Manager       HR      Group Manager       Area
Stage 2             or Equivalent                 or Equivalent    Manager or

Formal              Group Manager        HR       Area Manager      Principal
Stage 3              or Equivalent                or Equivalent      Officer

* In cases of unsatisfactory performance and absence it is appropriate for a
Watch/Line Manager to inform the employee that a failure to improve could
lead to disciplinary action being taken.

Disciplinary Procedure – January 2005
                                                                          Appendix 4


1.0      The following are examples of gross misconduct that may lead to
         summary dismissal, i.e. dismissal without notice. This list is not
         exhaustive and there may be other offences of a similar gravity
         resulting in a serious breach of contractual terms that could constitute
         gross misconduct.

                •    theft or fraud

                •    physical violence or bullying

                •    deliberate and serious damage to property

                •    serious misuse of the Authority’s property or name

                •    deliberately accessing pornographic, offensive or obscene

                •    unlawful discrimination or harassment

                •    bringing the Authority into serious disrepute

                •    serious incapacity at work brought on by misuse of alcohol or
                     illegal drugs

                •    causing loss, damage or injury through serious negligence

                •    a serious breach of company rules/procedures, including health
                     and safety rules

                •    a serious breach of confidence/trust

Disciplinary Procedure – January 2005
                                                                   Appendix 5


1.0      Principles of treatment

1.1      On occasions it is necessary to suspend staff on a precautionary basis
         where allegations of misconduct/gross misconduct have been made.

1.2      Such decisions are not taken without full consideration of the
         circumstances and facts known at the time and with proper regard for
         the welfare of the staff member concerned. This policy sets out the
         welfare and other facilities available to individuals in such

1.3      A suspension may only be invoked where the allegations made are of a
         serious nature or amount to gross misconduct, (an illustrative list of
         offences are set out at Appendix 4 of the Disciplinary Procedure). The
         decision may be made either at the start of an investigation or at any
         time thereafter should it become apparent that the overall
         circumstances make this course of action necessary in the best interest
         of the Fire and Rescue Authority and/or individuals involved.

1.4      Consideration will always be given as to whether an alternative action
         to suspension is appropriate and available.

1.5      Decisions to suspend staff will be made by the Head of HR; or in their
         absence, the duty Principal Officer.

1.6      Welfare support will be offered to the individual at the time of
         suspension and beyond.

1.7      Whilst suspended the employee will be excluded from Fire Service
         premises for work purposes. They may attend for meetings with their
         representatives and have access for welfare, social/sporting purposes,
         subject to management approval.

1.8      Individuals have a right to be represented at any meeting by a
         representative of the recognised unions, or a fellow worker.

Disciplinary Procedure – January 2005
1.9      The employee will be kept appraised of progress of the investigation
         and the likely timescales involved at regular intervals.

1.10     During investigation the decision to suspend will be reviewed by the
         Head of HR.

2.0      Entitlements/Conditions of employees subject to suspension

2.1      Attendance at Fire Service premises

         You should not attend fire service premises whilst suspended, unless
         asked to do so by the manager investigating the allegations or your line
         manager, or for purposes of representation. Depending on the
         circumstances you may be allowed access for welfare or
         social/sporting purposes, subject to managerial approval.

2.2      Support facilities

         You will have unrestricted access to your representative. Welfare
         support will be available through your line manager.

         In addition, depending on the circumstances, regular contact may be
         maintained through visits from managers and/or your work colleagues.
         These visits are to ensure your well being and to update you on work

2.3      Investigation updates

         The manager investigating the allegations will provide these to you and
         your representative (if requested) at regular intervals.

2.4      Identity card, alerter, keys (where appropriate)

         You must surrender these at the time of suspension. They will be
         returned to you if the suspension is lifted.

2.5      Pay and allowances

         You will receive your normal pay and any incremental entitlement
         (subject to normal conditions) and allowances, that you would have
         been entitled to had you been at work, in accordance with section 5.3
         of the procedure.

2.6      Annual Leave

         You may book annual leave whilst suspended subject to management
         approval. If your suspension is lifted then normal carry over
         arrangements at the end of the leave year will apply.

Disciplinary Procedure – January 2005
2.7      Sickness Reporting

         If you are ill you should report this, following the normal sickness
         reporting procedures. Normal sick pay rules and entitlements will apply
         from the date you report sick. It does not, however, override the
         conditions of your suspension.

         Sickness absence does not excuse you from attending a disciplinary
         hearing and advice will be sought from the Occupational Health to
         determine if you are fit to attend. If this view differs from your own GP
         or Consultant, independent advice will be sought.

2.8      Details of allegations

         Initial details of the allegations, as known at this stage, will be
         forwarded to you as soon as possible, together with written
         confirmation of the precautionary suspension.

2.9      Further information

         If you need further information or have any queries about this guidance
         contact your line manager or HR Management team in the first instance
         who will be pleased to assist.

Disciplinary Procedure – January 2005
                                                                 Appendix 6


1.0 Employees have a statutory right to be accompanied by a fellow worker
    or trade union official of their choice at all formal stages of the

2.0 In addition, it is good practice for employees to be provided with the
    opportunity to be accompanied at the investigation stage, although this
    should not frustrate the process.

3.0 Fellow workers or trade union officials do not have to accept a request to
    accompany an employee, and they should not be pressurised to do so.

4.0 An employee or lay trade union official who has agreed to accompany a
    colleague employed by the same employer is entitled to take a
    reasonable amount of paid time off to fulfill that responsibility. This
    should cover the hearing and allow time for the representative to
    familiarise themselves with the case and confer with the employee
    before and after the hearing. A request for reasonable paid time off by a
    trade union official to accompany an employee employed by another fire
    authority in the same region shall be given due consideration by the
    respective employers.

5.0 Employers should cater for an employee’s disability at a
    meeting/hearing; they should also cater for a representative’s disability,
    for example providing for wheelchair access if necessary.

6.0 Before the meeting/hearing takes place, the employee will tell the
    manager who they have chosen as a representative.

7.0 The representative should be allowed to address the meeting/hearing in
    order to:
          • put the employee’s case
          • sum up the employee’s case
          • respond on the employee’s behalf to any view expressed at the

8.0 The representative can also confer with the employee during the
    meeting/hearing and participate as fully as possible in the
    meeting/hearing, including asking witnesses questions. The
    representative has no right to answer questions on the employee’s
    behalf, or to address the hearing if the employee does not wish it, or to
    prevent the employer from explaining their case.

Disciplinary Procedure – January 2005
                                                                          Appendix 7

                                  DISCIPLINARY PENALTIES

1.0     Counselling / Verbal warning

        It may be appropriate, in cases of minor misconduct, to take no further
        action beyond counselling the individual. This shall be recorded and kept on
        the personal record file for a period of no more than 6 months.

2.0     Written warning

        There are two levels of written warning. These remain on file for a specified
        period and will be disclosed at a future disciplinary hearing if they are still
        ‘live’ at the time of the misconduct. Once the period has expired they are
        removed from the personal record file and no further reference is made to

2.1     Written warning – to be kept on the personal file for a maximum 6 months

2.2     Final Written warning – to be kept on the personal file for a maximum 18

3.0     Payback of time/recoup of loss

        This may be appropriate, for example, where an employee has not been
        attending a college course that is funded (or part-funded) by Staffordshire
        Fire and Rescue Service. They may be required to refund the cost of the
        course and/or to make up the time given to them to attend.

        It might also be appropriate where damage has been caused to property to
        pay for the cost of repair/replacement.

        If an individual has been abusing the flexible working hours scheme they will
        be removed from the scheme and may be required to make up time owing
        or to refund the equivalent in salary.

4.0     Loss of pay

        A stoppage of pay must not exceed 13 days pay.

5.0     Disciplinary Transfer to another post

        On occasion, it may be appropriate to transfer an individual to another post.
        Disciplinary transfers should involve no loss of remuneration and unless the
        employee agrees otherwise should be within the same duty system.
        Discussions should take place with the HR Management team and it will be
        their responsibility to identify and make arrangements for the transfer.

Disciplinary Procedure January 2005
6.0     Demotion

        This can be either within role/grade or no more than one role/grade. A
        demotion of more than one role/grade can only be done with the agreement
        of the employee.

7.0     Dismissal

        This can be either with or without notice. Summary dismissal (ie dismissal
        without notice) will normally only arise from allegations of gross misconduct
        that is of such gravity that the employee’s continued employment would be
        wholly inappropriate.

Discplinary Procedure – January 2005
                                                                       Appendix 8

                               APPEAL REVIEWS/HEARINGS
                               PROCEDURE AND CONDUCT

1.0     Appeal Reviews

1.1    Appeal Reviews will be conducted as a review of paper documents and
       submissions only. The Appeal Manager will reach findings based on the
       documentation and submissions from the parties. There is no requirement
       for the parties involved in the original hearing to attend.

1.2 The Appeal Manager will have available all the documents presented to the
    original hearing, as well as a copy of the record of the hearing, the letter
    confirming the outcome, the letter of appeal and the written statement of the
    grounds for the appeal.

1.3 Reviews will be conducted at a level of management higher than the first

1.4 The Appeal Manager will be supported and advised by a different HR
    Manager than was involved in the original hearing.

1.5     The outcome of the appeal will be either:

           •   The case against the employee is not upheld.
           •   The case against the employee is upheld (in whole or part).     The
               sanction will then be the same or a lesser penalty.

1.6     The outcome of the appeal will be confirmed in writing as soon as possible,
        but in any case within 7 days of the decision.

2.0    Appeal Hearings

2.1     Notice of appeal hearings will be in accordance with whatever stage of
        discipline is being appealed, i.e., 7 days notice will be given for appeals
        against findings at stage 1, 10 days for stage 2 and 21 days for stage 3.

2.2    Part/full rehearings will be conducted at a level of management higher than
       the first hearing.

2.3    Appeal Manager will be supported and advised by a different HR Manager
       than was involved in the original hearing.

2.4    The employee will put their case by explaining the grounds of the appeal and
       presenting any relevant evidence. The management case will then be put,
       responding to the grounds of appeal, normally by the manager who
       conducted the original hearing. Relevant witnesses may be brought by either
       side, and be questioned by all parties.

Discplinary Procedure – January 2005
2.5    The outcome of the appeal and confirmation in writing will be as outlined in
       paragraphs 1.4 and 1.5 above.

2.6    In cases of gross misconduct dismissal will be summary following the
       hearing. If dismissal is not upheld on appeal, the employee will be reinstated
       and pay will be backdated.

Discplinary Procedure – January 2005

To top