Docstoc

EMINENT DOMAIN

Document Sample
EMINENT DOMAIN Powered By Docstoc
					                       Relocate a Radio Station Tower

                                    Requested by: Iowa
                              Survey Deadline: March 26, 2007

   I would love to hear from any other states that have had to relocate a radio station tower.
   In discussing with folks I know from IRWA Relocation Committee, the best and most
   consistent advice was “DON’T”! However, I don’t have that option to avoid it. We
   started working with them well ahead of our project, because we knew it would be
   difficult, but I had no idea.

   Some of the issues we’ve encountered and are having difficulty with are:

   They must be on a similar site (a high spot) in order to main the height requirements for
   operation

   The station is a long time “tenant” at the current site and will probably have to buy land
   for replacement so this is putting him in a significant financial bind

   Everything at new site, when he finds one, must be up and running before he can shut
   down the old one – this is apparently an FCC Rule that says they maintain near
   continuous on air time otherwise their permits become void

   I understand most of these things can’t be resolved to the station owner’s satisfaction,
   but I would like to hear if anyone has moved one successfully and if there’s anything I
   can gain from their experiences in doing so.

   Thanks for your help. If there’s any further information you need from my end, please let
   me know.

Nancy Halvorson, SR/WA, R/W-RAC
Iowa DOT Relocation Assistance Supervisor
800 Lincoln Way, North Annex
Ames, IA 50010-6993

Office Phone: (515) 239-1359
Toll Free: 1 (866) 282-5809
FAX: (515) 239-1247
nancy.halvorson@dot.iowa.gov

                                          ALABAMA

                                           ALASKA
                                        ARIZONA

No, Arizona has not dealt with this issue. However, we would be very interested in
hearing about the outcome. If there are other radio towers or even larger cell towers in
the area, would it be possible for the radio stations equipment to share space while the
tower is relocated?

                                       ARKANSAS

Following is information provided by the AHTD's Relocation Section on moving of towers.
If you would like more information or have questions, you may contact Danny Arendt,
Relocation Section Head, at 501-569-2308 or danny.arendt@arkansashighways.com.

In the relocation of a cell/radio tower we first determine through our appraisal section
whether the tower is realty or personalty. If it is personalty then it is considered a
business displacee, thus making them eligible for moving and reestablishment costs.

A new site must be chosen and then the tower displacee will go through the FCC
application and approval process. This may take a considerable amount of time. We
have contacted the FCC in the past in order to obtain a contact person to attempt to get
the application on the fast track. Once the site and application have been approved then
the moving process may begin.

We obtain two to three bids to have the tower dismantled and moved and reassembled
at a new location. We are sure to use qualified movers as this is a very specialized field.
The bids can include the dismantling and re-erecting of the structure, the construction of
the foundation which depending on the type of tower could be 4’ thick, 40’ square, 10’
deep in the ground, with 3 to 4 concrete piers, and a small temporary tower to prevent
interruption of service (if needed) during the move called a “cow”. Other things that can
be included in the bid are site prep, coax & connectors intallation, equipment installation,
grounding, electric power, access road, fencing and gates, permits and peformance
bonds, and generator installation. The low bidder is awarded the contract. Movers that
we have used in the past are as follows:

           WesTower
           Phillip Sarullo, Operations Manager
           300 Walker Circle
           Richland, MS 39218
           601-932-4081

           CMS Wireless
           Stephen Acuff, Director of Construction
           4700 South Bowman Rd., Suite 700
           Little Rock, AR 72210
           501-228-8188
           Verticom
           Jeff Lewis, President
           1829 E. Levee St., Suite 100
           Dallas, TX 75207
           214-741-6898


About the only thing that reestablishment expenses were used for in our experience was
for increased rent at the replacement site

                                     CALIFORNIA

                                      COLORADO

                                    CONNECTICUT

                                      DELAWARE

                               DISTRICT OF COLUMBIA

                                       FLORIDA

                                       GEORGIA

                                          HAWAII

                                          IDAHO

                                        ILLINOIS

The Illinois Department of Transportation has a parcel that is needed for the purpose of a
highway project which is commonly called the New Mississippi River Bridge Crossing
between Illinois and Missouri in the St. Louis Metropolitan area. This project calls for a
new bridge(s) to be constructed over the Mississippi River, the improvement and/or re-
alignment of several highways such as FAI-55, FAI-70, FAI-64, IL Route 3 and numerous
abutting roadways. The project also impacts 12 different railroad lines in the metro area.

As part of this project, IDOT needs to acquire a piece of property from an operating radio
tower site owned by Nobel Broadcast of St. Louis (also known as Clear Channel). Due
to how much of this property we need, we are electing to do a whole take. Currently,
eight towers are used for an A.M. station out of St. Louis. Concerns on how to treat
various items located on the premises prompted the district office to contact the Central
Bureau of Land Acquisition on how to proceed with the appraisal, acquisition and
relocation of this parcel. Information found on the Internet by the appraiser provided
instructions to consider such items as the towers as personal property and hinted these
properties and businesses were sold in this manner. Yet, the local tax assessor in
Madison County considers the towers permanently affixed to and part of the real estate.
The district had been in discussions with the Clear Channel representatives on how to
proceed. The district wanted to clarify appraisal, acquisition and relocation issues prior
to making an appraisal assignment (back in 2004). Clear Channel only wanted to know
what IDOT would pay for their new site, new realty items and new equipment. One item
in particular, the tuning of the new towers, was of extreme importance to Clear Channel.
If the towers were to be considered realty as the county considered them, IDOT could
not pay to tune them. If they were to be personalty, the relocation assistance program
could reimburse Clear Channel for the tuning.

An on-site meeting was held in August 2004. The purpose of the meeting was to clarify
and put into writing exactly what items were to be considered realty and what items were
to be considered personalty. Those in attendance at the meeting Clear Channel
representatives, various District 8 Land Acquisition personnel involved in the project, the
appraiser and review appraiser assigned to the parcel, a relocation assistance consultant
who was to be hired to perform all relocation functions, and the State Relocation
Manager and State Appraisal Manager from the Central Bureau of Land Acquisition. We
walked the property and inspected the building and equipment boxes. Each item was
discussed and determinations were made on site as to whether an item was to be realty
or personalty. The district then prepared a memo to the files depicting the two lists of
items that everyone had agreed to. Below are the lists:

              Realty                                        Personalty

    Towers                                       1- Harris Intertype MW-5 transmitter
    Fencing                                      1-Broadcast Electrical AM64 transmitter
    Underground radials                          3-transmitter remote control panels
    "Dog house                                   2-Monitors
    Electrical equipment                         Misc. stored hardware
    Transmission lines
    ATUs
    Electrical lines
    Transmitter building
    Heat/AC units (2)
    Harris Intertype Corp. phasors
    Onam Electrical Plant generator

Other topics of discussion included:
   Clear Channel would provide technical assistance during relocation
   Clear Channel would not provide estimates of services and fees already prepared to
       comply with the FCC
   Clear Channel would provide department with construction estimates for new station
   Clear Channel would provide department with maintenance records (more
      specifically annual inspection reports)*
   Department would provide appraiser with a site plan of the existing property
   District Property Manager will prepare retention values for realty items in case Clear
     Channel might want to retain any of the items.
(*The department particularly wanted access to the information because we were
knowledgeable that the site was not in compliance with the FCC guidelines. We needed
to determine if the on-compliance was "project induced" or simply neglect of
maintenance on their part.)


A big concern to Clear Channel is how much it is going to cost them to acquire or lease a
new site and construct a new radio tower site with newly acquired realty and personalty
items. They are of the opinion that IDOT is responsible for paying for all of the realty and
personalty. While Clear Channel thinks the department should consider them eligible for
a total "functional replacement", they are not a government entity and, thus, do not meet
the provisions for "functional replacement" consideration.

Clear Channel, similar to the entity your state is dealing with, told the department that the
FCC requires their new site to be up and operational before they can go off the air at the
old site. This could take 12-18 months in their estimation. It is a sensitive and time
consuming process that must be monitored by the FCC.

The department had completed an original appraisal on the property in the fall of 2004
and updated the appraisal in early 2006. No offer has been made to the owners due to
the funding for the project being pushed back in the program. The separation of realty
and personalty remains the same and will continue to be treated accordingly unless new
information supports the shifts of items from one category to another. All parties will
meet again and will have to concur to any changes before a new appraisal is prepared
and the acquisition and relocation assistance eligibility commences.

Should you have any additional questions, please do not hesitate to contact this office.

Teresa S. "Teri" Pointer
Appraisal Unit Manager/Acting Relocation Unit Manager
Illinois Department of Transportation
2300 South Dirksen Parkway
Springfield, IL 62764
(217) 782-3982
(217) 782-3813 fax
Teresa.Pointer@illinois.gov

                                         INDIANA

                                           IOWA

                                         KANSAS

                                       KENTUCKY

                                        LOUISIANA
                                          MAINE

                                       MARYLAND

                                   MASSACHUSETTS

                                        MICHIGAN

                                       MINNESOTA

                                       MISSISSIPPI

                                        MISSOURI

                                        MONTANA

                                       NEBRASKA

Nancy, as we just discussed, I'll bring our file on the radio station and tower we recently
acquired and relocated to our meeting in a couple of weeks. It went well because we had
a reasonable owner willing to make a sizable capital investment in an all new facility. If
you don't have that, your job will be much harder. At least we can show you what
worked for us.

                                         NEVADA

                                   NEW HAMPSHIRE

                                      NEW JERSEY

                                      NEW MEXICO

                                       NEW YORK

This survey topic has been discussed with our Chief Appraisal Reviewer, John Dessena.
Mr. Dessena noted that if we were to acquire real property which included a radio station
tower, that the radio station tower would be valued as part of the site improvements and
included in the real property appraised value since the radio station tower would
contribute to the highest and best use of the property. As a part of the appraisal, the
cost to relocate the radio station tower would be analyzed to determine a salvage value
of the radio station tower. It is expected that the cost to relocate the radio station tower
would be quite expensive, so the salvage value of the radio station tower might be
minimal.
Since the radio station tower would be included in the appraised value, the radio station
tower would not be considered as personal property and therefore no relocation benefits
would be available to relocate the radio station tower. Any personal property within the
acquired area would qualify for relocation benefits.

We are not aware of any acquisitions of radio station towers by NYSDOT.

It would be interesting to see other state's perspectives on this topic. Please share the
survey results with us. Thank you.

                                  NORTH CAROLINA

                                   NORTH DAKOTA

                                         OHIO

Best of luck to you. Ohio has not actually bought or relocated any radio station towers,
but we made an advance acquisition offer on one late last year to try and get a jump on
an upcoming project. The owner refused our offer, so we had to back away from the
acquisition until we get our plans and environmental clearance (a few years away). I'd
very much like to hear how your transaction ultimately works out. Please send me a
copy of your research and keep me posted as you move through your issues

                                     OKLAHOMA

Oklahoma doesn't have anything new to add on this type of issue, it sounds as if you're
on the right track based on your comments. Good luck with your project.

                                       OREGON

                                   PENNSYLVANIA

                                    PUERTO RICO

                                   RHODE ISLAND

                                  SOUTH CAROLINA

Several years ago, SCDOT displaced a radio tower and had to be very creative in the
relocation of the tower. It was owned by a minority business and near the flight path of
the airport. We would be happy to discuss the case with you. You can contact either
Don Liester, Relocation Coordinator or me (RuckerOK@dot.state.sc.us) with your
specific questions. Oscar
                                  SOUTH DAKOTA

Fortunately, South Dakota has not been involved with the entire removal of a radio
station tower. We did have one case where the guy wire anchor was moved and placed
on a guy pole. This did not affect the operation of the tower so it worked out for both
parties. It is too bad the project alignment cannot be adjusted to avoid the impact you
describe below

                                     TENNESEE

                                        TEXAS

                                        UTAH

                                      VERMONT

                                      VIRGINIA

                                    WASHINGTON

We have not completed a move yet -- but we have a radio station tenant on an old pit
site that we would like to relocate. Several years ago the department allowed the lease
on our land, and we are learning that it is much more challenging process to remove
them than we had expected. We are finding all of the issues that you point out in your
message. When you are able to complete the relocation we would be interested in
knowing how you handled everything. Good luck.

Gerry Gallinger
Director, Real Estate Services
Washington State Department of Transportation
Voice - (360) 705-7305
Fax - (360) 705-6811
Mobile - (360) 951-9656

                                   WEST VIRGINIA

                                     WISCONSIN

                                      WYOMING

				
DOCUMENT INFO