Docstoc

102406

Document Sample
102406 Powered By Docstoc
					                                                     Proposed Minutes for 10/24/06
                                               HISTORIC DISTRICT COMMISSION
                                                              37 Washington Street
                                                         Nantucket, Massachusetts 02554
                                             Telephone: 508.228.7231               Fax: 508.325.7572
                     Commissioners: Dirk Roggeveen, Chair, Dawn Hill, Secretary, John McLaughlin, Valerie Norton, Linda Williams
         Associate Commissioners: Brian Conroy, Diane Coombs, John Wagley        Staff: Mark Voigt, Aaron Marcavitch, Erin Kerwin, Ann Medina

                                                          ~~ MINUTES ~~
                                              OCTOBER 24, 2006 – NEW BUSINESS
                                            Cyrus Pierce Middle School Cafeteria – 5:00 pm

         Reminder: The deadline for submissions is October 27th at Noon (Previously this had been listed as November 3 rd.)
I. CONSENT
1. Erichsen, Jennifer #49353                   34 Rhode Island Avenue – MAB              Move off                             60.3.1/146
2. Ticcoma Way NT #49354                       28 Ticcoma Road                           Move on                              68/236
3. Erichsen, Jennifer #49355                   34 Rhode Island Avenue – MAB              Move on site                         60.3.1/146
4. Goode, Michael #49356                       6 Back Street                             Roof change, red cedar               55/356
5. Schuring, Linda #49357                      9 Flintlock Road                          Shed, 10 x 12                        75/92
6. Anderson, Duncan #49358                     31 Okorwaw Avenue                         Basement Areaway                     79/153
7. Ryan, Charlie #49359                        343 Madaket Road – MAB                    Deck Revision                        60.2.4/63.1
8. Ray, Eric #49360                            60 Miacomet Avenue                        Remove roofwalk                      67/352
9. Burke, Joe #49361                           89 Orange Street                          Porch revision                       55.4.1/49

Sitting           Mr. McLaughlin, (abstain)Mr. Roggeveen, Ms. Norton, Ms. Coombs
Alternates
Representing
Concerns
Motion            Ms. Norton approve                                                             2nd
Vote              3-0                                                                            Certificate #     49353-49361


II. OLD BUSINESS
1. Perelman, Steven                       25 Lily Street                                 Addition                             42.4.3/107
Sitting         Mr. McLaughlin, Ms. Norton , Ms. Coombs
Alternates
Representing    None- letter from Andrew Kotchen
Concerns        Would like to view again due to extent of changes
Motion          Ms. Coombs view again with new information                                       2nd
Vote            3-0                                                                              Certificate #

2. Kloppenberg                             1 Tennis Court Road                           Gate/Paving                          29/158
Sitting            Ms. Norton , Ms. Coombs, Ms. Williams (arrives at 5:30)
Alternates
Representing      Elizabeth O’Rourke – wait for another member to arrive
Concerns
Motion            Ms. Coombs approve                                                             2nd
Vote              3-0                                                                            Certificate #     49362

3. Centre Street Acquisitions            4 Chestnut Street                               Commercial                           42.3.1/68.1
Sitting          Mr. Roggeveen, Ms. Norton , Ms. Coombs
Alternates
Representing     Matt McEachern, Ted Burnham – applicant withdraws
Concerns
Motion                                                                                           2nd
Vote                                                                                             Certificate #
                                                   Proposed Minutes for 10/24/06

4. Centre Street Acquisitions             4 Chestnut Street                          Demolition                        42.3.1/68.1
Sitting          Mr. Roggeveen, Ms. Williams, Ms. Norton ,
Alternates
Representing     Matt McEachern, Ted Burnham – applicant withdraws
Concerns
Motion                                                                                      2nd
Vote                                                                                        Certificate #

5. NHM Realty Trust                        77 Easton Street                        Window Revisions                  42.4.1/35
Sitting        Mr. McLaughlin, Mr. Roggeveen, Ms. Norton , Ms. Coombs
Alternates
Representing   Jack Whelen ; waives board. Explains that TDL will be in both aspects, old photos
Concerns       Were original windows 2/2 ? Ms. Norton: need to use wooden inserts on windows, discussion of what would have
               been originally, given the style of building, it is appropriate to have all 2/2 in existing structure, new proposed
               structure, and 6/6 in house part. Repair half round and diamond. Ballroom windows to be 15
Motion         Mr. McLaughlin approve with 2/2 in existing structure, new proposed 2nd
               structure, and 6/6 in house part. Repair half round and diamond pane
               windows. Ballroom windows to be 15 light (TME)
Vote           4-0                                                                        Certificate # 49363

6. Hedgebury Lane LLC                   8 Madaket Road                               Addition                          41/595
Sitting         Ms. Norton , Ms. Coombs
Alternates
Representing   Mark Cutone , no quorum- hold until beginning of next meeting
Concerns
Motion                                                                                      2nd
Vote                                                                                        Certificate #

7. Salvatore/Piles                          27 Old Westmoor Farm Road                Window/Door Revisions              41/811
Sitting          Ms. Williams, Ms. Norton , Ms. Coombs
Alternates
Representing     Luke Thornewill
Concerns         Chimney inappropriate, outdoor fireplace, shutters in this rural area inappropriate, should not be hipped porch roof,
                 side doors should not have sidelights,
Motion           Ms. Norton hold for revisions                                               2nd
Vote             3-0                                                                         Certificate #

8. Farrell, Thomas                       19 High Brush Path                          Pool/Fence                        56/376
Sitting          Mr. McLaughlin, Mr. Roggeveen, Ms. Norton , Ms. Coombs
Alternates
Representing     Mark Poor
Concerns
Motion           Mr. McLaughlin approve                                                     2nd
Vote             4-0                                                                        Certificate #    49364

9. West, John                             1 Cambridge Street                         Addition                          42.3.1/130
Sitting           Mr. McLaughlin, Mr. Roggeveen, Ms. Norton , Ms. Coombs
Alternates
Representing      None- letter from Dave Wiley explaining changes.
Concerns          2 story bay unit (Mr. McLaughlin)
Motion            Ms. Norton approve                                                        2nd
Vote              4-0                                                                       Certificate #    49365
                                                     Proposed Minutes for 10/24/06

10. North View Realty LLC                    7A Hedgebury Lane                     Addition                         41/186
Sitting         Mr. McLaughlin, Mr. Roggeveen, Ms. Norton , Ms. Coombs
Alternates
Representing    Ray Pohl
Concerns        Shingled columns inappropriate, and need to be appropriately sized. Should have corner boards shingle style
Motion          Ms. Norton approve with corner boards, wood deck, standard square 6 2nd
                inch posts, white or natural trim
Vote            4-0                                                                       Certificate # 49366

Ms. Williams arrives at 5:30 pm
11. Fischer, Josef                           5 Fulling Mill Road                       New Dwelling                        27/26
Sitting            Mr. Roggeveen, Ms. Williams, Ms. Norton, Ms. Coombs
Alternates
Representing       Ray Pohl
Concerns           Should be only one skylight (max 2X3 vertical), east elevation has too many ganged windows
Motion             Ms. Williams approve with one skylight on east elevation (max 2X3 2nd
                   vertical)
Vote               4-0                                                                       Certificate # 49367

12. 45 Baxter Road Nominee Trust               45 Baxter Road                             Window Revisions                 49/13
Sitting          Ms. Williams, Ms. Norton , Ms. Coombs
Alternates
Representing     Ray Pohl; explains reason for bay window
Concerns         Still believes is too small, should be left the way it is; having 3 6/6. Want to see previous approvals
Motion           Ms. Norton view with previous approvals                                         2nd
Vote             3-0                                                                             Certificate #

13. MacTaggart, Barry                      48 Starbuck Road – MAB                       Window/Stair Revisions             60/30
Sitting          Ms. Williams, Ms. Norton, Ms. Coombs
Alternates
Representing     Ray Pohl; wrong plans
Concerns         MAB read
Motion           Ms. Norton hold for proper plans                                              2nd
Vote             3-0                                                                           Certificate #

14. North Bluff Holdings LLC               25 Baxter Road – Sconset Ext.                Window/Door Revisions              49.2.3/11
Sitting          Ms. Williams, Ms. Norton, Ms. Coombs
Alternates
Representing     Ray Pohl
Concerns
Motion           Ms. Norton approve                                                            2nd
Vote             3-0                                                                           Certificate #    49368

15. Landt, Eric                              42 Essex Street                            Shed, 12 x 8                       67/623
Sitting            Ms. Williams, Ms. Norton, Ms. Coombs
Alternates
Representing       None – letter from applicant
Concerns           Inappropriate location, use does not fall under our guidelines
Motion             Ms. Norton hold for revisions to location                                   2nd
Vote               3-0                                                                         Certificate #

16. Glowacki, Kim                           28 Cliff Road                           Pool/Fence                             42.4.4/48
Sitting         Ms. Williams, Ms. Norton, Ms. Coombs
Alternates
Representing    None
Concerns        Need an accurate site plan, house moved on site, existing decorative fence location?
Motion          Ms. Norton hold for accurate site plan                                      2nd
Vote            3-0                                                                         Certificate #
                                                     Proposed Minutes for 10/24/06


III. NEW BUSINESS
1. Town of Nantucket (WWTF)                   South Shore Road                   WWTF Revisions (Demo/New                     80/135
                                                                                 Building/Renovations)
Sitting            Mr. McLaughlin, Mr. Roggeveen, Ms. Williams, Ms. Norton , Ms. Coombs
Alternates
Representing       Eric Shultz, Thomas Parece (Earth Tech)
Concerns
Motion             Ms. Williams approve all 7 applications with Chairman to sign               2nd
Vote               5-0                                                                         Certificate #    49369 A-F

2. Cross, Thodore                         41 Hulbert Avenue                   Skylight                                        29/18
Sitting         Mr. McLaughlin, Mr. Roggeveen, Ms. Williams, Ms. Norton , Ms. Coombs
Alternates
Representing    None
Concerns        Location in shed dormer inappropriate
Motion          Ms. Norton view                                                      2nd
Vote            5-0                                                                  Certificate #

3. Duncan, Richard                      23 New Street – SOHD                  Addition/Door Revision                          73.4.2/77
Sitting         Mr. McLaughlin, Mr. Roggeveen, Ms. Williams, Ms. Norton , Ms. Coombs
Alternates
Representing    Chris Holland
Concerns
Motion          Ms. Williams approve                                                 2nd
Vote            5-0                                                                  Certificate # 49370

4. Burritt, John                           25 York Street                        Fence revisions                              55.4.1/176
Sitting            Mr. McLaughlin, Mr. Roggeveen, Ms. Williams, Ms. Norton , Ms. Coombs
Alternates
Representing       None
Concerns           Fence design is too formal, white is okay, posts are too formal, could keep it the same and paint white,
Motion             Ms. Norton approve capped picket fence, white                                2nd
Vote               5-0                                                                          Certificate # 49371

5. Burritt, John                           25 York Street                        Paving                                       55.4.1/176
Sitting            Mr. McLaughlin, Mr. Roggeveen, Ms. Williams, Ms. Norton , Ms. Coombs
Alternates
Representing       None
Concerns           Too deep for brick, would only want one car length,
Motion             Ms. Norton approve at current depth, double width                           2nd
Vote               5-0                                                                         Certificate #    49372

6. Newell, Sherley                           21 Willard Street                 Door Revisions                                 29/34
Sitting          Mr. McLaughlin, Mr. Roggeveen, Ms. Williams, Ms. Norton , Ms. Coombs
Alternates
Representing     None
Concerns         Fiberglass inappropriate, proximity of OHD,
Motion           Ms. Norton deny due architecturally inappropriate material          2nd
Vote             5-0                                                                 Certificate #              49373 (D)

7. Gledhill, Beth                            89 Tom Never’s Road                    Window Revisions                          91/16
Sitting           Mr. McLaughlin, Mr. Roggeveen, Ms. Williams, Ms. Norton , Ms. Coombs
Alternates
Representing      None
Concerns          Window inappropriate, would rather see 1/1, could look for other manufacturer
Motion            Ms. Williams hold for revisions                                          2nd
Vote              5-0                                                                      Certificate #
                                                  Proposed Minutes for 10/24/06

8. Mazotas, Tony                           29 Essex Road                           New Dwelling                      67/614
Sitting         Mr. McLaughlin, Mr. Roggeveen, Ms. Williams, Ms. Norton , Ms. Coombs
Alternates
Representing    Tony Mazotas; everything to match main house
Concerns        Dormer needs to be set back one foot, needs to be only 22 ft (no garage). Rear elevation needs to see porch, need to
                show trim around door. Add trim.
Motion          Ms. Norton hold for revisions                                             2nd
Vote            5-0                                                                       Certificate #

9. Knapp, Lindsey                          7 Otokomi Road                     Window Revisions                       67/195.7
Sitting         Mr. McLaughlin, Mr. Roggeveen, Ms. Williams, Ms. Norton , Ms. Coombs
Alternates
Representing    Lindsey Knapp
Concerns        No snap ins, 6/1 inappropriate on this house, should be 6/6.
Motion          Ms. Norton approve with 6/6 or 8/8 to fit rough openings            2nd
Vote            5-0                                                                 Certificate #          49374

10. Autumn Lane Association             8 South Valley Road                   Box Bay Revisions                      43/167
Sitting         Mr. McLaughlin, Mr. Roggeveen, Ms. Williams, Ms. Norton , Ms. Coombs
Alternates
Representing    John Lampe
Concerns
Motion          Ms. Williams approve                                                2nd
Vote            5-0                                                                 Certificate #          49375

11. Linehan, Paul                         28 Berkely Street                     Roof change/Chimney Rev.             76.1.3/201
Sitting           Mr. McLaughlin, Mr. Roggeveen, Ms. Williams, Ms. Norton , Ms. Coombs
Alternates
Representing      None- photos and letter
Concerns
Motion            Ms. Williams approve                                                 2nd
Vote              5-0                                                                  Certificate # 49376

12. Linehan, Paul                             28 Berkely Street                 Shed, 10 x 12                        76.1.3/201
Sitting           Mr. McLaughlin, Mr. Roggeveen, Ms. Williams, Ms. Norton , Ms. Coombs
Alternates
Representing      None- photos and letter
Concerns          Location on site is inappropriate.
Motion            Ms. Williams approve due to circumstances of lot.                    2nd
Vote              5-0                                                                  Certificate #       49377

13. Bennett, Douglas                       8 Pine Grove Road                   New Dwelling                          67/241
Sitting          Mr. McLaughlin, Mr. Roggeveen, Ms. Williams, Ms. Norton , Ms. Coombs
Alternates
Representing     Stacey Gibbons, Douglas Bennett
Concerns         Dormers should be both flush, need to show stair wells
Motion           Ms. Williams approve with flush dormers on both sides and drawn in 2nd
                 basement stair well
Vote             5-0                                                                 Certificate #         49378

14. Guill, Ben                            288 Polpis Road                       Pool/Fence                           25/34
Sitting           Mr. McLaughlin, Mr. Roggeveen, Ms. Williams, Ms. Norton , Ms. Coombs
Alternates
Representing      Grant Smith
Concerns
Motion            Ms. Williams approve                                                     2nd
Vote              5-0                                                                      Certificate #   49379
                                                    Proposed Minutes for 10/24/06

15. Guill, Ben                            288 Polpis Road                       Gazebo                                   25/34
Sitting           Mr. McLaughlin, Mr. Roggeveen, Ms. Williams, Ms. Norton , Ms. Coombs
Alternates
Representing      Grant Smith
Concerns          Need to see visibility , needs to be more simple
Motion            Ms. Williams hold for revisions                                             2nd
Vote              5-0                                                                         Certificate #

16. Ryan, Charlie                            343 Madaket Road – MAB                Window Revisions                      60.2.4/63.1
Sitting           Mr. McLaughlin, Mr. Roggeveen, Ms. Williams, Ms. Norton , Ms. Coombs
Alternates
Representing      None
Concerns          SDL inappropriate, need representation to discuss extent of work
Motion            Ms. Williams hold for representation/ clarification                   2nd
Vote              5-0                                                                   Certificate #

17. Ryan, Charlie                            343 Madaket Road – MAB             Window Revisions                         60.2.4/63.1
Sitting           Mr. McLaughlin, Mr. Roggeveen, Ms. Williams, Ms. Norton , Ms. Coombs
Alternates
Representing      None
Concerns          Need to discuss with applicant
Motion            Ms. Williams hold for representation and clarification              2nd
Vote              5-0                                                                 Certificate #

18. Moore, Norman                          38 Sparks Avenue                        Dormers                          55/240.1
Sitting         Mr. McLaughlin, Mr. Roggeveen, Ms. Williams, Ms. Norton , Ms. Coombs
Alternates
Representing    None
Concerns        Dormer inappropriate on that building and skylight inappropriate, extremely visible, shed dormer might be okay. No
                skylight even if shed dormer
Motion          Ms. Norton hold for revisions                                             2nd
Vote            5-0                                                                       Certificate #

19. Moore, Norman                           38 Sparks Avenue                         Auto Lift                           55/240.1
Sitting         Mr. McLaughlin, Mr. Roggeveen, Ms. Williams, Ms. Norton , Ms. Coombs
Alternates
Representing    None
Concerns        In front yard inappropriate, in rear might be okay, not appropriate as structure in front of building, should try in rear
                and could view
Motion          Ms. Norton hold for revisions to siting or design                            2nd
Vote            4-1 Ms. Williams                                                             Certificate #

20. Bunting, Joan                            2 Pine Tree Road                      Fence, 6’                       68/956
Sitting           Mr. McLaughlin, Mr. Roggeveen, Ms. Williams, Ms. Norton , Ms. Coombs
Alternates
Representing      Joan Bunting ; explains fence that she wants,
Concerns          5 and 1 would be better, proposed fence is inappropriate (GHYC), no stepping down and end where applicant wants
                  it to end. Mr. Roggeveen believes 6 ft board would be okay
Motion            Ms. Williams approve 6 ft board with no stepping down, no stain         2nd
Vote              5-0                                                                     Certificate # 49380

21. Nylee Trust                           1 North Beach Street                  Clapboard/Door Revision                  42.4.1/89
Sitting           Mr. McLaughlin, Mr. Roggeveen, Ms. Williams, Ms. Norton , Ms. Coombs
Alternates
Representing      None
Concerns          Clapboard inappropriate and fiberglass doors inappropriate , need to be wood doors
Motion            Ms. Williams hold for representation                                      2nd
Vote              5-0                                                                       Certificate #
                                                     Proposed Minutes for 10/24/06

22. Hale, Charles                           117 Madaket Road                      Window Revisions                         40/60.3
Sitting             Mr. McLaughlin, Mr. Roggeveen, Ms. Williams, Ms. Norton , Ms. Coombs
Alternates
Representing        None
Concerns            Wood shakes are okay but don’t match the other house, and cannot be installed as staggered,
Motion              Ms. Williams approve north elevation windows, deny round window 2nd
                    and deny shakes roofing unless roofing entire property as shakes
Vote                5-0                                                                      Certificate # 49381

23. Nantucket Land Bank                  125 Somerset Road                     Move on site                                66/69
Sitting          Mr. McLaughlin, Mr. Roggeveen, Ms. Williams, Ms. Norton , Ms. Coombs
Alternates
Representing     None
Concerns         Doors are okay
Motion           Mr. McLaughlin approve                                              2nd
Vote             5-0                                                                 Certificate #             49382

24. Merriman, Pamela                     1 Lily Street – SOHD                 Foundation/Addition                          73.3.1/116
Sitting         Mr. McLaughlin, Mr. Roggeveen, Ms. Williams, Ms. Norton , Ms. Coombs
Alternates
Representing    Chris Dallmus
Concerns
Motion          Ms. Williams view and send to SAB                                   2nd
Vote            5-0                                                                 Certificate #

25. Teckutnan NT                           11 Fulling Mill Road                     Reduce structure               27/24
Sitting         Mr. McLaughlin, Mr. Roggeveen, Ms. Williams, Ms. Norton , Ms. Coombs
Alternates
Representing    Phil Eagleburger, David, Steven Cohen
Concerns        Cupola discussion, reduce size is appropriate, cupola needs to have divided lights (match windows) stair way from
                second floor deck needs to be turned 90 degrees, deck cant be cantilevered,
Motion          Ms. Williams approve with muttons in glass in cupola, stairs to be 2nd
                turned
Vote            5-0                                                                         Certificate # 49383

26. Holdgate, Michael                          23 Madaket Road                 Pool/Fence                                  41/302
Sitting          Mr. McLaughlin, Mr. Roggeveen, Ms. Williams, Ms. Norton , Ms. Coombs
Alternates
Representing     Ethan McMorrown
Concerns         Visibility is an issue, fence should be 48 “stake
Motion           Ms. Williams view with stakes                                        2nd
Vote             5-0                                                                  Certificate #

27. Davidson, Jason                       21 Clifton Street – Sconset Ext.     Garage                                      49.3.2/34
Sitting          Mr. McLaughlin, Mr. Roggeveen, Ms. Williams, Ms. Norton , Ms. Coombs
Alternates
Representing     Stacey Gibbons
Concerns         SAB read,
Motion           Ms. Williams view with one pole                                      2nd
Vote             5-0                                                                  Certificate #

28. Hollo, Erno                             48 Main Street – SOHD                 Addition                                 73/12.1
Sitting             Mr. McLaughlin, Mr. Roggeveen, Ms. Williams, Ms. Norton , Ms. Coombs
Alternates
Representing        None
Concerns            North elevation inappropriate, drawings not clouded and hard to read, before and after on same sheet
Motion              Ms. Williams hold for revisions/clarifications/ representation             2nd
Vote                5-0                                                                        Certificate #
                                                    Proposed Minutes for 10/24/06

29. McGrath, Bill                            Tuckernuck                         As built Window Revisions         94/15
Sitting           Mr. McLaughlin, Mr. Roggeveen, Ms. Williams, Ms. Norton , Ms. Coombs
Alternates
Representing      Bill McGrath
Concerns          Need to see pictures of house,
Motion            Ms. Williams hold for pictures of house                              2nd
Vote              5-0                                                                  Certificate #

30. Stroup, Mary Jane                        10 Candlehouse Lane                       Move off                   55.4.4/51
Sitting           Mr. McLaughlin, Mr. Roggeveen, Ms. Williams, Ms. Norton , Ms. Coombs
Alternates
Representing      Val Oliver
Concerns          Want to view with all information including additional historic info.
Motion            Ms. Williams view                                                          2nd
Vote              5-0                                                                        Certificate #

31. Larson, Nancy                             15 Greglen Avenue                       Move on                     68/187
Sitting          Mr. McLaughlin, Mr. Roggeveen, Ms. Williams, Ms. Norton , Ms. Coombs
Alternates
Representing     Val Oliver
Concerns         Is going to a different place and needs to be applied for separately
Motion           Ms. Williams hold for more info                                            2nd
Vote             5-0                                                                        Certificate #

32. Stroup, Mary Jane                     10 Candlehouse Lane                   Demolition                        55.4.4/51
Sitting           Mr. McLaughlin, Mr. Roggeveen, Ms. Williams, Ms. Norton , Ms. Coombs
Alternates
Representing      Val Oliver
Concerns
Motion            Ms. Williams view                                                   2nd
Vote              5-0                                                                 Certificate #

33. Stroup, Mary Jane                     10 Candlehouse Lane                   Demolition                        55.4.4/51
Sitting           Mr. McLaughlin, Mr. Roggeveen, Ms. Williams, Ms. Norton , Ms. Coombs
Alternates
Representing      Val Oliver
Concerns
Motion            Ms. Williams view                                                   2nd
Vote              5-0                                                                 Certificate #

34. Foster, Mike                           70 Milestone Road                     Window/Door Revisions            54/35.1
Sitting            Mr. McLaughlin, Mr. Roggeveen, Ms. Williams, Ms. Norton , Ms. Coombs
Alternates
Representing       Val Oliver
Concerns           Cupola oversized, need to know material of retaining wall,
Motion             Ms. Williams view with ridge pole and material type                      2nd
Vote               5-0                                                                      Certificate #

35. Ammodt, Gary                          10 ½ Sherburne Turnpike                  As built Roofwalk Revisions      30/175.1
Sitting        Mr. McLaughlin, Mr. Roggeveen, Ms. Williams, Ms. Norton , Ms. Coombs
Alternates
Representing   Val Oliver, John Trudell; explains existing conditions: Applicant will withdraw
Concerns       Roofwalk needs to be built correctly, photos of other roofwalk were not approved that way, other things wrong such
               as windows and pitch, need a drawing showing how dormers are built to approve
Motion         Ms. Williams hold for revisions and clarification, as built drawings of 2nd
               dormers but need to correct roofwalk.
Vote           5-0                                                                         Certificate #
                                                  Proposed Minutes for 10/24/06

36. Lewis, Durvan                        1 Little Isle                         As Built Revisions                    68/758
Sitting          Mr. McLaughlin, Mr. Roggeveen, Ms. Williams, Ms. Norton , Ms. Coombs
Alternates
Representing     Brook Meerbergen
Concerns
Motion           Mr. McLaughlin approve                                               2nd
Vote             5-0                                                                  Certificate #        49384

37. Archer/Presser                       191 Polpis Road                       Deck/Window Revisions                 45/57
Sitting          Mr. McLaughlin, Mr. Roggeveen, Ms. Williams, Ms. Norton , Ms. Coombs
Alternates
Representing     Applicant withdraws
Concerns
Motion                                                                               2nd
Vote                                                                                 Certificate #

38. Model Home Trust                       8 Fourth Way                            New Dwelling                      67/123
Sitting        Mr. McLaughlin, Mr. Roggeveen, Ms. Williams, Ms. Norton , Ms. Coombs
Alternates
Representing   Gretchen Buchanan, Jason Hulun
Concerns       Cardinal points need be on drawings, need to fill in missing spots on drawings (garage), no decking over void, garage
               structure coming in front of house will be a problem. Need to ask building department
Motion         Ms. Williams view with submitted plans and height pole                     2nd
Vote           5-0                                                                        Certificate #

39. Model Home Trust                     8 Fourth Way                        New Dwelling                            67/123
Sitting        Mr. McLaughlin, Mr. Roggeveen, Ms. Williams, Ms. Norton , Ms. Coombs
Alternates
Representing   Gretchen Buchanan, Jason Hulun
Concerns       Needs to have a secondary and primary dwelling (22’)
Motion         Ms. Williams view with submitted plans and height pole              2nd
Vote           5-0                                                                 Certificate #

40. Shimmo Pond Holdings                  25 Shimmo Pond Road                Move on site                            43/144
Sitting        Mr. McLaughlin, Mr. Roggeveen, Ms. Williams, Ms. Norton , Ms. Coombs
Alternates
Representing   Dixon Shay, Steve Anderson
Concerns       Chimney inappropriate needs to be smaller
Motion         Ms. Williams hold for revisions to the chimney                      2nd
Vote           5-0                                                                 Certificate #

41. Shimmo Pond Holdings                  21 Shimmo Pond Road                  New Dwelling                      43/97
Sitting        Mr. McLaughlin, Mr. Roggeveen, Ms. Williams, Ms. Norton, Ms. Coombs
Alternates
Representing   Dixon Shay; explains legitimacy of grade changes, Steve Anderson; grade changes concerns, photos and letters from
               19 shimmo,
Concerns       Due to grade changes, should view again
Motion         Ms. Williams view with 4 poles                                          2nd
Vote           5-0                                                                     Certificate #

42. Shimmo Pond Holdings                21 Shimmo Pond Road                  Garage/Apartment                        43/97
Sitting        Mr. McLaughlin, Mr. Roggeveen, Ms. Williams, Ms. Norton , Ms. Coombs
Alternates
Representing   Dixon Shay, Steve Anderson
Concerns
Motion         Ms. Williams view with one pole                                     2nd
Vote           5-0                                                                 Certificate #
                                                Proposed Minutes for 10/24/06

43. Shimmo Pond Holdings                21 Shimmo Pond Road                  Move off                      43/97
Sitting        Mr. McLaughlin, Mr. Roggeveen, Ms. Williams, Ms. Norton , Ms. Coombs
Alternates
Representing   Dixon Shay, Steve Anderson
Concerns
Motion         Ms. Williams view                                                   2nd
Vote           5-0                                                                 Certificate #

44. Ottani, Jeffery                          4 Jonathan Way                      Foundation Revision       75/47
Sitting            Mr. McLaughlin, Mr. Roggeveen, Ms. Williams, Ms. Norton , Ms. Coombs
Alternates
Representing       Ethan McMorrow
Concerns           Concerns with design, does not look traditional, visibility
Motion             Ms. Williams view with photos and aerial maps                       2nd
Vote               5-0                                                                 Certificate #

45. Hourihan, William                    16 Hawthorne Lane                     Window/Door Revisions       56/226
Sitting          Mr. McLaughlin, Mr. Roggeveen, Ms. Williams, Ms. Norton , Ms. Coombs
Alternates
Representing     Ethan McMorrow
Concerns
Motion           Ms. Williams approve                                                2nd
Vote             5-0                                                                 Certificate # 49385

46. McManus, Matthew                       5 Mattapoisett Road               Foundation Revision           82/371
Sitting        Mr. McLaughlin, Mr. Roggeveen, Ms. Williams, Ms. Norton , Ms. Coombs
Alternates
Representing   Mark Poor
Concerns       Questions reason for this proposal,
Motion         Ms. Williams view with markings on foundation changes               2nd
Vote           5-0                                                                 Certificate #

47. McManus, Matthew                   5 Mattapoisett Road                   Hardscaping (Old Business)    82/371
Sitting        Mr. McLaughlin, Mr. Roggeveen, Ms. Williams, Ms. Norton , Ms. Coombs
Alternates
Representing   Mark Poor
Concerns
Motion         Ms. Williams view                                                   2nd
Vote           5-0                                                                 Certificate #

48. Zibelli, Ronald                           8 Long Pond Drive – MAB           Addition                   59/25
Sitting           Mr. McLaughlin, Mr. Roggeveen, Ms. Williams, Ms. Norton , Ms. Coombs
Alternates
Representing      Mark Poor
Concerns          Need picture of affected side, clarifications,
Motion            Ms. Williams view with MAB comments                                  2nd
Vote              5-0                                                                  Certificate #

49. Mleczko, Priscilla                     29 Kimball Avenue                   New Dwelling                30/24.2
Sitting          Mr. McLaughlin, Mr. Roggeveen, Ms. Williams, Ms. Norton , Ms. Coombs
Alternates
Representing     Mark Poor, Tom and Priscilla Mleckzko
Concerns         Questions of where lot is
Motion           Ms. Williams view                                                   2nd
Vote             5-0                                                                 Certificate #
                                                      Proposed Minutes for 10/24/06

50. Pino, Donna                            12 Washington Avenue – MAB                Dormer Revisions              60.2.1/24
Sitting         Mr. McLaughlin, Mr. Roggeveen, Ms. Williams, Ms. Norton , Ms. Coombs
Alternates
Representing    Mark Poor, Pete Dooley (contractor): explains why foundation was poured that way, explains what application was
                when he came on to job,
Concerns        Foundation issues, should issue a stop work order, if still enough untouched grade , need to view.
Motion          Ms. Williams view (for dormer and foundation)                               2nd
Vote            5-0                                                                         Certificate #

51. Greenberg, Frank                     3 Packet Drive                        Door/Window Revisions                      74/20
Sitting          Mr. McLaughlin, Mr. Roggeveen, Ms. Williams, Ms. Norton , Ms. Coombs
Alternates
Representing     Ethan Griffin
Concerns
Motion           Ms. Williams approve                                                2nd
Vote             5-0                                                                 Certificate # 49386

52. Webster, Chip                           12 South Pasture Lane                    Window Revisions                 80/297.1
Sitting          Mr. McLaughlin, Mr. Roggeveen, Ms. Williams, Ms. Norton , Ms. Coombs
Alternates
Representing     Ethan Griffin
Concerns         West elevation rotation of window inappropriate, architecturally inappropriate, some concerns with porthole,
Motion           Ms. Coombs approve all changes except for west elevation change 2nd
                 rotation
Vote             5-0                                                                        Certificate # 49387

53. Nineteen Monomoy Road                 19 Monomoy Road                        Gazebo Revisions                         54/260
Sitting         Mr. McLaughlin, Mr. Roggeveen, Ms. Williams, Ms. Norton , Ms. Coombs
Alternates
Representing    Matt McEachern
Concerns        Connecting piece inappropriate, chimney ever approved? Need to see original approval
Motion          Ms. Williams view with original approval                                 2nd
Vote            5-0                                                                      Certificate #

54. Kozak, Mark                            31 Orange Street                      Ridge Revision                           42.3.2/131
Sitting            Mr. McLaughlin, Mr. Roggeveen, Ms. Williams, Ms. Norton , Ms. Coombs
Alternates
Representing       Matt McEachern
Concerns           HSAB read,
Motion             Ms. Williams approve                                                           2nd
Vote               5-0                                                                            Certificate #   49388

55. Colton, John                           308 Polpis Road                       Pool/Spa                                 20/74
Sitting            Mr. McLaughlin, Mr. Roggeveen, Ms. Williams, Ms. Norton , Ms. Coombs
Alternates
Representing       David Troast
Concerns           Type of retaining wall, style of stone, length, visibility, changes in grade
Motion             Mr. McLaughlin approve due to lack of visibility                               2nd
Vote               5-0                                                                            Certificate #   49389

56. Simanson, Gary                         57 Union Street                    Addition                                    55.1.4/90
Sitting         Mr. McLaughlin, Mr. Roggeveen, Ms. Williams, Ms. Norton , Ms. Coombs
Alternates
Representing    None
Concerns        HSAB read, HDC agrees with all HSAB comments, massing is not an issue
Motion          Ms. Williams hold for revisions                                      2nd
Vote            5-0                                                                  Certificate #
                                                   Proposed Minutes for 10/24/06

57. Zimicki, Jacques                         13 Whereowhereo Lane                     Addition                       67/470
Sitting           Mr. McLaughlin, Mr. Roggeveen, Ms. Williams, Ms. Norton , Ms. Coombs
Alternates
Representing      None
Concerns          Size inappropriate due to not being a secondary dwelling, too large
Motion            Ms. Williams view                                                          2nd
Vote              5-0                                                                        Certificate #

58. Brinkley, Alan                        83 Polpis Road                        Dormer/Porch Revision                44/23.5
Sitting           Mr. McLaughlin, Mr. Roggeveen, Ms. Williams, Ms. Norton , Ms. Coombs
Alternates
Representing      None- letter to view
Concerns
Motion            Ms. Williams view                                                   2nd
Vote              5-0                                                                 Certificate #

59. Meant to Be LLC                        41 Pleasant Street                      Hardscaping                        55.4.1/153
Sitting          Mr. McLaughlin, Mr. Roggeveen, Ms. Williams, Ms. Norton , Ms. Coombs
Alternates
Representing     Larry Goode
Concerns         Need to know height and length (discussion of roofwalk shaft being inappropriate- need to change to hatch)
Motion           Ms. Williams view with marked drawings                                   2nd
Vote             5-0                                                                      Certificate #

60. Outlaw Two LLC                         13R Burnell Street – Sconset Ext.  Retaining Walls                        73.4.2/89
Sitting         Mr. McLaughlin, Mr. Roggeveen, Ms. Williams, Ms. Norton , Ms. Coombs
Alternates
Representing    Owner
Concerns        SAB read, want to see a field stone rather than a flat stone
Motion          Ms. Williams approve with field stone                                2nd
Vote            5-0                                                                  Certificate #           49390

61. Collella/Dunphy                      4 Quaker Road                         Pool Revision                         41/524
Sitting          Mr. McLaughlin, Mr. Roggeveen, Ms. Williams, Ms. Norton , Ms. Coombs
Alternates
Representing     Luke Thornewill
Concerns
Motion           Ms. Williams approve                                                2nd
Vote             5-0                                                                 Certificate #           49391

62. Shimmo Pond LLC                        14 Shimmo Pond Road                   Move on site                        43/17
Sitting        Mr. McLaughlin, Mr. Roggeveen, Ms. Williams, Ms. Norton , Ms. Coombs
Alternates
Representing   Lisa Botticelli
Concerns       8 ft doors inappropriate- need to check approval.
Motion         Ms. Williams hold for additional information, should not be 8 ft.       2nd
Vote           5-0                                                                     Certificate #

63. Cassity, Doug                           18 Cliff Road                       Window/Door Revisions                42.4.4/33
Sitting           Mr. McLaughlin, Mr. Roggeveen, Ms. Williams, Ms. Norton , Ms. Coombs
Alternates
Representing      Lisa Botticelli
Concerns          HSAB read, arched windows inappropriate,
Motion            Ms. Williams approve all except revisions to garage door            2nd
Vote              5-0                                                                 Certificate # 49392
                                                   Proposed Minutes for 10/24/06

64. Dunlap, James                          13 Eel Point Road                   Balustrade Revision                    40/51
Sitting          Mr. McLaughlin, Mr. Roggeveen, Ms. Williams, Ms. Norton , Ms. Coombs
Alternates
Representing     Lisa Botticelli
Concerns
Motion           Ms. Williams hold until next meeting due to error in drawings        2nd
Vote             5-0                                                                  Certificate #

65. Weiss, Andrea                         11 Long Pond Drive – MAB               Shed, 10 x 12                        59/34
Sitting          Mr. McLaughlin, Mr. Roggeveen, Ms. Williams, Ms. Norton , Ms. Coombs
Alternates
Representing     None
Concerns         MAB read, don’t want swing doors (west elevation) facing madaket road,
Motion           Ms. Norton approve without out-swing doors facing Madaket road         2nd
Vote             5-0                                                                    Certificate #       49393

66. Dessault, David                           42A South Shore Road                   Shed, 10 x 12                    80/117
Sitting           Mr. McLaughlin, Mr. Roggeveen, Ms. Williams, Ms. Norton , Ms. Coombs
Alternates
Representing      None
Concerns          Should not be in front of lot, fences not there so will be visible
Motion            Ms. Williams hold for revisions to siting                                 2nd
Vote              5-0                                                                       Certificate #

67. Kenny, Mike                            13 New Lane                             Major Revisions                     41/576
Sitting         Mr. McLaughlin, Mr. Roggeveen, Ms. Williams, Ms. Norton , Ms. Coombs
Alternates
Representing    David Holcomb
Concerns        Eave heights the same, roof needs to drop, center gable facing front inappropriate, chaotic fenestration. Needs to be
                more rural, shed dormers on front would be better, too many flush dormers (Ms. Williams)
Motion          Ms. Williams hold for revisions                                           2nd
Vote            5-0                                                                       Certificate #

68. Johnsen, Susan                          4 Williams Lane                    Fence, 6’                              55/418
Sitting          Mr. McLaughlin, Mr. Roggeveen, Ms. Williams, Ms. Norton , Ms. Coombs
Alternates
Representing     None
Concerns         Fence inappropriate and visible
Motion           Ms. Williams view                                                    2nd
Vote             5-0                                                                  Certificate #

IV.        HDC BUSINESS
Review Minutes -    October 17
Approve Minutes -   October 10; adopted by unanimous consent
60 Day Denials -    none
Other Business -    Discussion: 106 Main Street Façade; put in memory garden or figure out other things to do with it? Would
                    like to view it. 132 Main Street: gives example of stone, thinks it is too parged. Discussion: ATM article;
                    gives handout. Will look over it and discuss it next meeting, want to include ac units.
17 – OHD                   3 – SOHD, 3 – Sconset Ext.                  7 – MAB

				
DOCUMENT INFO