Cost of Capital Questions by zee15908

VIEWS: 11 PAGES: 6

More Info
									Chapter 10: Cost of Capital.

=================================================================
INTRODUCTION
==================

 One view of the influence of leverage on the cost of capital is that presented by
 Modigliani and Miller. In their view, the cost of debt does not rise with leverage,
 and the cost of equity rises linearly as depicted by their Proposition II. Under this
 formulation (which assumes no bankruptcy costs), the cost of capital declines
 with leverage (and the value of the firm rises). An alternative view holds that with
 increased leverage, both debt and equity take on increasing risk (positive
 bankruptcy costs are assumed). Under this theory, the cost of capital falls up to
 some critical degree of leverage, then begins to rise. Under this view, there is an
 optimal capital structure which minimizes the firm's cost of capital (and
 maximizes value).

=================================================================




                                                       298d970f-5006-43fb-bccf-99be8e9b8d7d.xls
========================================================================
 QUESTIONS
==================
 1) Assume a world of Modigliani and Miller where the after-tax debt cost does not change with
    leverage because there are no bankruptcy costs, and the equity cost function is a straight line
    reflecting the equation of Modigliani and Miller's Proposition II, which is
    ks = ku +(ku – kb)(B/S)(1-T).

      a) What happens to the cost of equity as the debt-to-firm-value ratio at market value, B/V,
         rises from 0 to 60 percent in increments of 10 percent? (The before-tax cost of debt is
         10 percent, the unlevered cost of equity is 12 percent, and the tax rate is 40 percent.)
         HINT: Translate debt-to-value ratios into debt to equity ratios for use in MM Proposition
         II. Also view this graphically.

      b) What happens to the weighted cost of capital (WCC) as B/V rises? Is there a minimum
         weighted cost of capital? (See graph.) What does this imply for the value of the firm?
         For optimum leverage?

 2) An alternative to the MM world postulates that the cost of debt rises with leverage, and that
    the cost of equity rises with leverage curvilinearly, not as a straight line as implied by MM
    Proposition II. The following figures reflect this alternative:

                                            Before-Tax
                           Leverage         Cost of Debt      Cost of Equity
                            0-10%             10.00%            12.00%
                            10-20%            10.20%            12.30%
                            20-30%            10.80%            12.75%
                            30-40%            11.00%            13.29%
                            40-50%            12.00%            15.00%
                            50-60%            16.00%            20.00%
                           Over 60%           27.00%            30.00%

      a) Compare the weighted cost of capital for each alternative capital structure under the
         Modigliani-Miller assumptions to the weighted cost of capital with bankruptcy costs.

      b) Is there a minimum cost of capital in the non-MM world? What is the optimum capital
         structure?

 3) Now you are free to change any of the decision variables: Leverage ratio, initial cost of debt,
    unlevered cost of equity, tax rate. Note, however, that the costs of debt and equity in the
    world with bankruptcy costs are dependent upon the leverage ratio and cannot be changed
    independently.



========================================================================




                                                                298d970f-5006-43fb-bccf-99be8e9b8d7d.xls
============================================================================
COSTS OF CAPITAL UNDER MODIGLIANI-MILLER ASSUMPTIONS
=========================================================

INPUTS
 Leverage (Debt/Assets = B/V)                         80.0%      (Debt/Equity = B/S = 400.0% )
 Tax rate                                             40.0%
 Unlevered cost of debt (kb )                         10.0%
 Unlevered cost of equity (ku )                       12.0%

CALCULATIONS

            ks = ku + ( ku – kb ) ( B/S ) ( 1 – T )


              = 0.120 + ( 0.120 – 0.100 ) ( 4.000 ) ( 1 – 0.40 ) =     16.80%

  WCC = k = kb ( 1 – T ) ( B/V ) + (S/V) ( k s )

              = 0.100 ( 1 – 0.40 ) ( 0.800 ) + ( 0.200 ) ( 0.168 ) =   8.16%

============================================================================




                                                               298d970f-5006-43fb-bccf-99be8e9b8d7d.xls
====================================================================
 COMPARISON OF MODIGLIANI-MILLER (MM) & WORLD WITH BANKRUPTCY
=========================================================

        Leverage (Debt/Assets = B/V)                    80%
        Tax rate                                        40%

MODIGLIANI-MILLER WORLD:
                kb =                                  10.0%
                 ks =                                 16.8%

                 Weighted cost of capital = k =       8.16%

WORLD WITH BANKRUPTCY COSTS:
              kb =                                    27.0%
                 ks =                                 30.0%

                 WCC = k = kb ( 1 – T ) ( B/V ) + (S/V) ( ks )
                        = 0.270 ( 1 – 0.40 ) ( 0.800 ) + ( 0.200 ) ( 0.300 ) = 18.96%

====================================================================




                                                      298d970f-5006-43fb-bccf-99be8e9b8d7d.xls
                                            GRAPH A: M-M COSTS OF CAPITAL

                   25%




                   20%




                   15%
Costs of Capital




                   10%




                   5%




                   0%
                         0%   10%   20%   30%         40%           50%     60%        70%          80%           90%
                                                         Leverage (B/V)


                                                After-Tax Debt     Equity   WCC



                                                                                  298d970f-5006-43fb-bccf-99be8e9b8d7d.xls
                                    GRAPH B: COSTS OF CAPITAL--BANKRUPTCY
                   35%




                   30%




                   25%
Costs of Capital




                   20%




                   15%




                   10%




                   5%




                   0%
                         0%   10%     20%                    30%            40%               50%                 60%

                                                         Leverage
                                            After-Tax Debt         Equity   WCC




                                                                                  298d970f-5006-43fb-bccf-99be8e9b8d7d.xls

								
To top