Documents
Resources
Learning Center
Upload
Plans & pricing Sign in
Sign Out

Basic Assessment Report - 1. FILLING STATION DAEA_RD_2010 BA

VIEWS: 42 PAGES: 46

									                                             Basic Assessment Report


                                   KZN Agriculture, Environmental Affairs & Rural
                                   Development
                                   umNyango: ezoLimo ezeMvelo nokuThuthukiswa
                                   kweMiphakathi yaseMakhaya
                                   ISIFUNDAZWE SAKWAZULU-NATALI

                                                      (For official use only)
File Reference Number:                                DC/
NEAS Reference Number:                                KZN/EIA/
Date Received:

                                   Basic Assessment Report
                                              in terms of the
                            Environmental Impact Assessment Regulations, 2010
                                       promulgated in terms of the
                     National Environmental Management Act, 1998 (Act No. 107 of 1998)


Kindly note that:

1.  This basic assessment report meets the requirements of the EIA Regulations, 2010 and is meant to
    streamline applications. This report is the format prescribed by the KZN Department of Agriculture,
    Environmental Affairs and Rural Development. Please make sure that this is the latest version.
2. The report must be typed within the spaces provided in the form. The size of the spaces provided is not
    indicative of the amount of information to be provided. The report is in the form of a table that can extend
    itself as each space is filled with text.
3. Where required, place a cross in the box you select.
4. An incomplete report will be returned to the applicant for revision.
5. The use of “not applicable” in the report must be done with circumspection because if it is used in respect of
    material information that is required by the competent authority for assessing the application, it will result in
    the rejection of the application as provided for in the regulations.
6. No faxed or e-mailed reports will be accepted.
7. The report must be compiled by an independent environmental assessment practitioner (“EAP”).
8. Unless protected by law, all information in the report will become public information on receipt by the
    competent authority. Any interested and affected party should be provided with the information contained in
    this report on request, during any stage of the application process.
9. The KZN Department of Agriculture, Environmental Affairs and Rural Development may require that for
    specified types of activities in defined situations only parts of this report need to be completed.
10. The EAP must submit this basic assessment report for comment to all relevant State departments that
    administer a law relating to a matter affecting the environment. This provision is in accordance with Section
    24 O (2) of the National Environmental Management Act 1998 (Act 107 of 1998) and such comments must be
    submitted within 40 days of such a request.
11. Please note that this report must be handed in or posted to the District Office of the KZN Department
    of Agriculture, Environmental Affairs and Rural Development to which the application has been
    allocated (please refer to the details provided in the letter of acknowledgement for this application).




  Department of Agriculture,                Basic Assessment Report 2010                     Page 1 of 46
 Environmental Affairs & Rural                 Version 2: August 2010
 Development, KwaZulu-Natal
                                          Basic Assessment Report



SECTION A: DETAILS OF THE ENVIRONMENTAL ASSESSMENT
PRACTITIONER AND SPECIALISTS
1. NAME AND CONTACT DETAILS OF ENVIRONMENTAL ASSESSMENT PRACTITIONER (EAP)

Name and contact details of the EAP who prepared this report:

 Business name        GBS Environmental Consulting
 of EAP:
 Physical             95 McKenzie Street, Dundee
 address:
 Postal address:      P.O. Box 743, Dundee
 Postal code:         3000                                            Cell:   083 604-0723
 Telephone:           034 212-3660                                    Fax:    086 575-7605
 E-mail:              gbsenviro@lantic.net

2. NAMES AND EXPERTISE OF REPRESENTATIVES OF THE EAP

Names and details of the expertise of each representative of the EAP involved in the preparation of this
report:

      Name of                    Education qualifications           Professional       Experience at
  representative of                                                  affiliations      environmental
      the EAP                                                                        assessments (yrs)
 Tamara Hiltunen        Bachelor of Science Degree,                 IAIASA          1.5 yrs
                        University of Natal,
                        Pietermaritzburg (Feb 1996 – Nov
                        1999). Awarded in Apr 2000 with
                        majors in Biochemistry,
                        Psychology and Zoology.
                        Bachelor of Science Honours
                        (Cum Laude) (University of Natal -
                        Apr 2001)
                        Masters (MSc) degree in
                        Biochemistry (University of Natal -
                        Dec 2003)
                        Masters of Philosophy (MPhil) in
                        Wildlife Management with a
                        Distinction (University of Pretoria -
                        Apr 2010).

 Peter Ruddle           Dip. Nature Conservation and                IAIASA          5 yrs
                        Management




  Department of Agriculture,             Basic Assessment Report 2010                Page 2 of 46
 Environmental Affairs & Rural              Version 2: August 2010
 Development, KwaZulu-Natal
                                         Basic Assessment Report


3. NAMES AND EXPERTISE OF SPECIALISTS

Names and details of the expertise of each specialist that has contributed to this report:

    Name of            Education               Field of            Section/ s            Title of
   specialist         qualifications          expertise         contributed to          specialist
                                                                 in this basic         report/ s as
                                                                 assessment            attached in
                                                                     report            Appendix D
   Eugene de          BSc (Town and         Development           Section B11           Heatonville
     Beer               Regional             Economists          Appendix D3           Petrol Filling
                        Planning);          Social Impact                              Station: The
 Urban-Econ                                 Assessment                                    Needs,
 Development             Master of                                                    Desirability and
 Economists              Business                                                         Socio-
                        Leadership                                                      Economic
                                                                                          Impact
                                                                                       Assessment

   Derek J.          PrEng, C Eng,          Traffic Impact          Section B7         Traffic Impact
   McGuigan          MSAICE, MICE            Assessment            Section B11          Assessment
                                                                   Appendix D2        Old Empangeni
 SSI Engineers                                                                            Drive-In
      And                                                                                Proposed
 Environmental                                                                         Petrol Filling
  Consultants                                                                             Station
   (Pty) Ltd                                                                                And
                                                                                        Truck Stop

 M. J. Hadlow           BSc (Hons)         Geohydrologist           Section C3        Geotechnical
                         MSAIEG             Engineering            Appendix D1        Founding and
Drennan, Maud           Pr. Sci.Nat         Geologists                               Hydrogeological
  & Partners                                                                           Assessment
                                                                                     Proposed New
                                                                                      Filling Station,
                                                                                       Empangeni




  Department of Agriculture,             Basic Assessment Report 2010                Page 3 of 46
 Environmental Affairs & Rural              Version 2: August 2010
 Development, KwaZulu-Natal
                                      Basic Assessment Report



Section B: Activity information
1.   PROJECT TITLE

Describe the project title as provided on the application form for environmental authorization:
The proposed development of a New Filling Station at Empangeni.


2.   PROJECT DESCRIPTION

Provide a detailed description of the project:
The proposed development of a new Filling Station on the R34 between Empangeni and
Heatonville.

The proposed development entails the construction of a modern, corporate standard Filling
Station (with Underground Storage Tank’s (UST’s), petrol and diesel pumps, a canopy,
parking bays, truck stop facility, driver accommodation, ablution facilities, spares shop, offices
and a fast food outlet on the R34 at the Heatonville / Ntambana junction at the old Empangeni
drive-in site.

The development includes the following components (Appendix C):
                                                                       2
       A hard-surfaced fuel dispensing forecourt with canopy (315 m ) and 5 pump islands
       that will dispense lead replacement fuel, unleaded fuel and diesel.
       Surfaced parking bays (30 parking bays of which 2 are for disabled) and a service
       bay for delivery and refuse purposes.
       Surfaced roadways for access to and servicing of this infrastructure – all contained on
       the property.
       Petrol and Diesel pumps.
       Underground Storage Tank’s (Five petroleum and diesel storage tanks that can hold
                          3                                  3
       23,000 l (23 m ) each. Total volume is 115 m . The tanks specifications and
       installation will be in accordance with industry standards).
                                                                                     2
       A hard-surfaced fuel dispensing forecourt for trucks with canopy (240 m ) with 1
       pump island.
       Truck Stop Facility.
                                                                     2
       Wash up areas and ablution facilities/change rooms (180 m ).
                                       2                  2
       Driver accommodation (240 m ) and yard (80 m ).
                                 2                  2
       Fast food outlet (200 m ) and yard (138.2m ).
       ATM.
                      2
       Offices (30 m )
       Security cameras will be in accordance with industry standards.
       The proposed site will have one entry/exit point off the R34.
       Stormwater infrastructure and sand, oil and grease separators for potentially polluted
       run-off from the entire site; and water, electricity, stormwater and sewerage
       reticulation (sewerage is proposed to be connected to a septic tank, soak pit system).




  Department of Agriculture,          Basic Assessment Report 2010            Page 4 of 46
 Environmental Affairs & Rural           Version 2: August 2010
 Development, KwaZulu-Natal
                                              Basic Assessment Report


3.   ACTIVITY DESCRIPTION

     Describe each listed activity in Listing Notice 1 (GNR 544, 18 June 2010) or Listing Notice
     3 (GNR 546, 18 June 2010) which is being applied for as per the project description:

     With respect to the Environmental Impact Assessment Regulations published in
     Government Notice No. R 543 of 18 June 2010 the following activity triggers Activity 13 in
     Listing Notice 1 Government Notice No. R 544 of 18 June 2010 thus there is a need to
     undertake a basic assessment.

     Activity 13         The construction of facilities or infrastructure for the storage, or storage
                         and handling of dangerous good, where such storage occurs in
                         containers with a combined capacity of 80 but not exceeding 500 cubic
                         meters.

     Previously an application was submitted under the Environmental Impact Assessment
     Regulations published in Government Notice No. R 385 of 21 April 2006 and Listing
     Notice 1 Government Notice No. R 387 of 21 April 2006 for the following activity which
     required a Scoping and Environmental Impact Assessment to be undertaken

     Activity 3          The construction of fillings stations, including associated structures and
                         infrastructure, or any other facility for the underground storage of
                         dangerous goods, including petrol, diesel, liquid petroleum gas or
                         paraffin.


     KZN Agriculture, Environmental Affairs & Rural Development have granted permission for
     the application to be downgraded from a Scoping & Environmental Impact Assessment to
                                                                                 nd
     a Basic Assessment as per the Legislation which came into effect on the 2 August
     2010. Correspondence with respect to the downgrading can be found in Appendix G3.




4.   FEASIBLE AND REASONABLE ALTERNATIVES

 “alternatives”, in relation to a proposed activity, means different means of meeting the
general purpose and requirements of the activity, which may include alternatives to—
(a)     the property on which or location where it is proposed to undertake the activity;
(b)     the type of activity to be undertaken;
(c)     the design or layout of the activity;
(d)     the technology to be used in the activity;
(e)     the operational aspects of the activity; and
(f)     the option of not implementing the activity.
Describe alternatives that are considered in this report. Alternatives should include a consideration of all possible
means by which the purpose and need of the proposed activity could be accomplished in the specific instance
taking account of the interest of the applicant in the activity. The no-go alternative must in all cases be included in
the assessment phase as the baseline against which the impacts of the other alternatives are assessed. The
determination of whether site or activity (including different processes etc.) or both is appropriate needs to be
informed by the specific circumstances of the activity and its environment. After receipt of this report the
competent authority may also request the applicant to assess additional alternatives that could possibly
accomplish the purpose and need of the proposed activity if it is clear that realistic alternatives have not been
considered to a reasonable extent.




  Department of Agriculture,                 Basic Assessment Report 2010                     Page 5 of 46
 Environmental Affairs & Rural                  Version 2: August 2010
 Development, KwaZulu-Natal
                                       Basic Assessment Report


4.1      LOCATION ALTERNATIVES
The applicant plans to use its own site, which is suitably located adjacent to the R34 for the
proposed purpose of a filling station. Alternative locations are currently not available, and
would thus involve the lease or purchase of land / other sites. The suitability of the location
will be assessed in further detail during the detailed EIA, but based on the initial scoping the
proposed site is deemed suitable as a result of the following factors:
*     Existing footprint of use (tarred surface, sheds, fencing).
*     Disturbed area, difficult to rehabilitate to agricultural use.
*     Good location adjacent to the R34.

4.2     LAND USE / ACTIVITY ALTERNATIVES
The site is currently zoned as agricultural but will be rezoned as a “Service Station”. The site
was the Empangeni drive in, since the drive in closed the land has remained vacant and
undeveloped. No alternative land uses such as other types of commercial developments,
residential or agriculture were considered by the applicant and the registered landowner. The
development of a Filling Station on Portions 11 (of 4) of Erf 225 Empangeni 12052 is
considered by the applicant as the preferred development of the site.

4.3     SCHEDULING ALTERNATIVES
Construction will commence once all relevant approvals and authorisations have been
obtained.

4.4        LAYOUT ALTERNATIVES
A draft conceptual layout has been provided (Appendix C), and includes allowance for some
flexibility in terms of the final layout, with respect to location of bouwsers, fast food restaurant.
The final layout will be negotiated with the fuel company who contracts with the applicant to
operate the facility. The layout is not deemed to be a high impact issue, as long as it complies
with criteria listed in this report, the specialist reports (Appendix D) and EMPr (Appendix F) for
waste management, underground tank construction, general safety and water conservation.

4.5    PROCESS ALTERNATIVES
Process alternatives are related to design configuration of industrial and service facilities:

4.5.1 Water sources / supply
The following alternatives here include:
*    Possible future Municipal supply connection.
*    Development of a new borehole (location to be determined by a geohydrologist).
*    Rainwater and storm water run-off harvesting. This will augment the water supply.
*    Water conservation measures. This will augment the water supply, reduce consumption
     and recycle where possible

4.5.2 Underground storage tank (UST) location and design
The location, design and construction of the UST’s are an important issue, as this is where
the greatest potential for contamination (fuel leakage) or hazardous outcomes (fire,
explosions, accidents). The following aspects that must be considered:
*    UST location options based on the results obtained from the geohydrological study.
*    UST construction options.
*    Materials and methods for dealing with leaks such as Drizit, Zorbit.

4.5.3 Waste management and disposal
Alternatives for waste management and disposal are numerous. Various types of waste will
be generated by the filling station of which the oil based waste is of the greatest concern. The
disposal methods that will be considered during include:
*    Domestic type waste - collection on site in appropriate waste receptacle and removal to a
     registered land fill site.
*    On-site filtration (Zorbit Grease Trap) and recycling mini-plant for forecourt run-off.
*    Sealed used engine oil containers for collection / delivery to approved recycling depot.
*    Collection of used cooking oil in sealed containers for recycling.


  Department of Agriculture,          Basic Assessment Report 2010              Page 6 of 46
 Environmental Affairs & Rural           Version 2: August 2010
 Development, KwaZulu-Natal
                                                    Basic Assessment Report


*        On site grey water and sewage recycling system using BiolytixR or LilliputR
         technologies, based on a septic tank system, whereby water can be recycled for use in
         washing, flushing and landscaping.

4.6      INPUT ALTERNATIVES
The construction of filling stations is governed by approved procedures and SANS standards,
thus there is limited scope for introducing alternatives to this aspect. However, the
construction materials that are utilised can be varied. These variations include: bricks, roof,
finishes and surfacing of the road and forecourt area. Ultimately, the finished product should
be aesthetically pleasing.

4.7    THE ‘NO GO’ ALTERNATIVE
The “no-go” alternative is a possible alternative, and must be considered. This option will be
considered should the proposed development have a significant negative impact that cannot
be adequately mitigated against. Issues further affecting this option may also emanate from:
*   Opposition from I&AP’s with due justification
*   Non compliance with certain legislative requirements of an organ of state.



Sections B 5 – 15 below should be completed for each alternative.
5.      ACTIVITY POSITION

Indicate the position of the activity using the latitude and longitude of the centre point of the site
for each alternative site. The co-ordinates should be in degrees, minutes and seconds. List
alternative sites were applicable.

Alternative:                       Latitude (S):                                       Longitude (E):
Alternative S11 (preferred or only       28 o    43‘                          47“            31o      49‘     47“
site alternative)
                                            o                                      “            o               “
Alternative S2 (if any)                            ‘                                                      ‘
                                            o                                      “            o               “
Alternative S3 (if any)                            ‘                                                      ‘
In the case of linear activities:
Alternative:                      Latitude (S):                                        Longitude (E):
Alternative S1 (preferred or only
route alternative)
• Starting point of the activity          o                           ‘            “            o         ‘     “


• Middle point of the activity            o                           ‘            “            o         ‘     “


• End point of the activity               o                           ‘            “            o         ‘     “

                                                                                   “                            “
Alternative S2 (if any)
• Starting point of the activity          o                           ‘            “            o         ‘     “


• Middle point of the activity            o                           ‘            “            o         ‘     “


• End point of the activity               o                           ‘            “            o         ‘     “

                                                                                   “                            “
Alternative S3 (if any)
• Starting point of the activity          o                           ‘            “            o         ‘     “


• Middle point of the activity            o                           ‘            “            o         ‘     “


• End point of the activity               o                           ‘            “            o         ‘     “



For route alternatives that are longer than 500m, please provide an addendum with co-ordinates taken every
500m along the route for each alternative alignment.


1
    “Alternative S..” refer to site alternatives.
     Department of Agriculture,                     Basic Assessment Report 2010               Page 7 of 46
    Environmental Affairs & Rural                      Version 2: August 2010
    Development, KwaZulu-Natal
                                                   Basic Assessment Report


6.     PHYSICAL SIZE OF THE ACTIVITY

Indicate the physical size of the preferred activity/technology as well as alternative
activities/technologies (footprints):

Alternative:                                                                          Size of the activity:
Alternative A12 (preferred activity alternative)                                                   10923 m2

Indicate the size of the alternative sites or servitudes (within which the above footprints will
occur):
Alternative:                                                             Size       of      the
                                                                         site/servitude:
Alternative A1 (preferred activity alternative)                                        57580 m2


7.     SITE ACCESS

Does ready access to the site exist?                                                           YES
If NO, what is the distance over which a new access road will be built                                   M
Describe the type of access road planned:

SSI Engineers And Environmental Consultants (Pty) Ltd conducted a Traffic Impact
Assessment (Appendix D2) and the following requirements for the access road have been
identified:

“As any access requires being both efficient and safe, a number of important criteria need to
be considered.
       The first of these is the geometry, or layout, of the intersection.
       The access, being on an important provincial route will need to meet certain criteria: It
       is recommended that a high standard of intersection be constructed with dedicated
       right turn lanes and edge tapers to a standard of at least that of a KZN DoT ‘Type B2’.

             The second item for assessment is that of adequate shoulder sight distance
             The existing shoulder sight distances to both left and right are as follows: Left > 600m
             and Right > 450m. The available shoulder sight distance generously exceeds the
             minimum requirements for shoulder sight distance.

             Entry Control
             Should the entrance to the site be security controlled this is to be positioned a
             minimum distance of 80m from the edge of the provincial road.

             Road Safety
             On both R34 approaches to the proposed site intersection a high visibility W102
             (priority crossroad sign) with information plate “heavy vehicles turning” is required. All
             signage and road markings for the proposed site intersection should be in accordance
             with the South African Road Traffic Signs Manual”.

The surface of the access road will either be tarred or be the same as the surface type and
specifications of the forecourt.


Include the position of the access road on the site plan and required map, as well as an
indication of the road in relation to the site.
2
    “Alternative A..” refer to activity, process, technology or other alternatives.
     Department of Agriculture,                   Basic Assessment Report 2010           Page 8 of 46
    Environmental Affairs & Rural                    Version 2: August 2010
    Development, KwaZulu-Natal
                                      Basic Assessment Report


8. SITE OR ROUTE PLAN

A detailed site or route plan(s) must be prepared for each alternative site or alternative activity.
It must be attached as Appendix A to this report.

The site or route plans must indicate the following:
   8.1. the scale of the plan which must be at least a scale of 1:500;
   8.2. the property boundaries and numbers/ erf/ farm numbers of all adjoining properties of
         the site;
   8.3. the current land use as well as the land use zoning of each of the properties adjoining
         the site or sites;
   8.4. the exact position of each element of the application as well as any other structures
         on the site;
   8.5. the position of services, including electricity supply cables (indicate above or
         underground), water supply pipelines, boreholes, street lights, sewage pipelines,
         storm water infrastructure and telecommunication infrastructure;
   8.6. walls and fencing including details of the height and construction material;
   8.7. servitudes indicating the purpose of the servitude;
   8.8. sensitive environmental elements within 100 metres of the site or sites including (but
         not limited thereto):
             rivers, streams, drainage lines or wetlands;
             the 1:100 year flood line (where available or where it is required by DWA);
             ridges;
             cultural and historical features;
             areas with indigenous vegetation including protected plant species (even if it is
             degraded or infested with alien species);
   8.9. for gentle slopes the 1 metre contour intervals must be indicated on the plan and
         whenever the slope of the site exceeds 1:10, the 500mm contours must be indicated
         on the plan; and
   8.10.          the positions from where photographs of the site were taken.


9. SITE PHOTOGRAPHS

Colour photographs from the centre of the site must be taken in at least the eight major
compass directions with a description of each photograph. Photographs must be attached
under Appendix B to this report. It must be supplemented with additional photographs of
relevant features on the site, if applicable.


10. FACILITY ILLUSTRATION

A detailed illustration of the facility must be provided at a scale of 1:200 and attached to this
report as Appendix C. The illustrations must be to scale and must represent a realistic image
of the planned activity/ies.




  Department of Agriculture,          Basic Assessment Report 2010             Page 9 of 46
 Environmental Affairs & Rural           Version 2: August 2010
 Development, KwaZulu-Natal
                                           Basic Assessment Report


11. ACTIVITY MOTIVATION

Has a specialist been consulted for the completion of this section?         YES
If YES, please complete the following:
Name of the specialist:               Eugene de Beer
Qualification(s) of the specialist: BSc (Town and Regional Planning)
Postal address:                       P.O. Box 50834, Musgrave
Postal code:                          4062
Telephone:                            031 202 9673                  Cell: 082 779 3821
E-mail:                               eugene@urban-econ.com         Fax: 031 202 9675
Are any further specialist studies recommended by the specialist?                     NO
If YES, specify:
If YES, is such a report(s) attached in Appendix D?                         YES

Signature of specialist:                                    Date:


     11.1. Socio-economic value of the activity
What is the expected capital value of the activity on completion?                               R 7 000 000
What is the expected yearly income that will be generated by or as a result of the activity?    R 3 500 000
Will the activity contribute to service infrastructure?                                         YES
Is the activity a public amenity?                                                                       NO
How many new employment opportunities will be created in the development phase of the           50
activity?
What is the expected value of the employment opportunities during the development phase?        R 2 000 000
What percentage of this will accrue to previously disadvantaged individuals?                           60 %
How many permanent new employment opportunities will be created during the operational          25
phase of the activity?
What is the expected current value of the employment opportunities during the first 10 years?   R 4 000 000
What percentage of this will accrue to previously disadvantaged individuals?                            80 %

     11.2. Need and desirability of the activity

Motivate and explain the need and desirability of the activity (including demand for the activity):
The site is currently zoned as agricultural but is in the process of being rezoned as a “Service
Station”. The site was chosen by Buzza Props Pty (Ltd) as the optimal site for a number of
reasons. The road on which the site is located is safe in that it is on a long straight stretch. A
detailed Traffic Impact Study has been completed and the report is presented in Appendix
D2. The site is in a good location in terms of traffic on the R34 and the P253 from Heatonville,
is a suitable size and is owned by the developer. The nearest service station is in
Empangeni, 6 km away.

A detailed Needs, Desirability and Socio-Economic Impact Assessment has been completed
and the report is presented in Appendix D3. Visibility to and from the access point is good
during the day and at night will be improved with the addition of lights. The site is relatively
level and slopes gently in a northerly direction, thus the site is suitable from a topographic
point of view for the development of a filling station. The site is currently not used and is
therefore a security risk. Furthermore the developer has considered alternative land uses but
in terms of other business owned by the developer the filling station is the most feasible.
Furthermore the filling station will be utilised by the developer’s trucks from Empangeni
Milling Pty (Ltd) as well as the traffic on the R34. Based on the above this site is the most
suitable for the proposed development.

The volume of traffic determines if there is a need for a filling station. A detailed Traffic Impact
study has been commissioned to assess the likely traffic impact of the proposed Petrol Filling
Station, truck stop and ancillary facilities. The completed report is presented in Appendix D2.



  Department of Agriculture,               Basic Assessment Report 2010              Page 10 of 46
 Environmental Affairs & Rural                Version 2: August 2010
 Development, KwaZulu-Natal
                                       Basic Assessment Report


The following conclusions can be drawn from this investigation:
         Traffic conditions at the existing intersection of the R34 and the P253 are
         satisfactory.
         Traffic on the R34 is significant in volume terms.
         The proposed development has the potential to attract small volumes of traffic which
         are well within the carrying capacity of the existing road system.

Urban-Econ Development Economists conducted a Heatonville Petrol Filling Station: The
Needs, Desirability and Socio-Economic Impact Assessment presented in Appendix G3.
They following aspects were identified:

         “The service offering will improve the levels of convenience to residents of areas that
         are in close proximity to the site.
         The proposed development site is situated within Ward 24 of the uMhlathuze Local
         Municipality. It is situated in an area consisting mainly of rural settlements and
         commercial farms. These areas make up the primary market in this study. The
         specific areas that are considered in this study as the primary market for the
         development in this study are Wards 24 to 28 of uMhlathuze, Wards 7 and 8 of
         Ntambanana, and Ward 13 of uMlalazi. The Empangeni town, which is situated
         about 6.2 kilometres south-east of the site, forms the secondary market area. Due to
         a variety of services available in this, it attracts many people from various parts of the
         district and from other districts. In view of the significant number of vehicles travelling
         to, within, and from the centre on a daily basis, there is a variety of filling stations in
         the area. Many of them are located along the R34 or nearby access roads. The
         proposed filling station is likely to have a small impact on these filling stations since
         all of them are located more than 7 kilometres away from the proposed development
         site. There are other filling stations in the town of Empangeni. However, since they
         are located more than 10 kilometres from the proposed development site, they are
         not likely to be affected by the proposed development. The residents of the eight
         wards mentioned above use various means of transport to travel to work or to school.
         They range from private vehicles to taxis and busses. The existence of a large
         number of vehicles passing the proposed development site is likely to have
         implications for the proposed development since some of them might start filling up at
         the proposed filling station.”
         There are currently seven filling stations within the secondary market area that are
         more than 7 km from the site. Other stations are situated more than 10 kilometres
         from the site and are not included in this assessment. As a result, none of them are
         likely to have significant implications for the proposed development. The
         development is also not likely to have significant implications for them.
         The conclusion drawn from these findings is that the proposed development will be
         sustainable and therefore feasible. It is worth pointing out, however, that it may take
         some time before the project yields the desired business results”.


Indicate any benefits that the activity will have for society in general:
Urban-Econ Development Economists identified the following (Appendix G3):

        “Constructing the proposed development will result in direct jobs being created for the
        construction of the various facilities. Indirectly, jobs are also created in industries that
        provide goods, materials and services. For example, an additional amount of goods
        used in construction will be required from business and industries related to the
        construction sector.
        The proposed development will lead to an increase in the local level of employment in
        the areas surrounding the development site. Both short-term and long-term
        employment will be created in this case.
        The development will lead to the increase in the number of convenience facilities in
        the primary market area.”

  Department of Agriculture,           Basic Assessment Report 2010            Page 11 of 46
 Environmental Affairs & Rural            Version 2: August 2010
 Development, KwaZulu-Natal
                                            Basic Assessment Report


Indicate any benefits that the activity will have for the local communities where the activity will
be located:
Urban-Econ Development Economists identified the following (Appendix G3):

          The proposed development will lead to the increase in the level of local employment
          in the areas surrounding the development site. Both short-term and long-term
          employment will be created in this case.
          There will be a limited impact on surrounding land uses as a result of the proposed
          development thus the local communities will not be negatively impacted by the
          development.



12. APPLICABLE LEGISLATION, POLICIES AND/OR GUIDELINES
List all legislation, policies and/or guidelines of any sphere of government that are relevant to the application as
contemplated in the EIA regulations, if applicable:
Title of legislation, policy or guideline:                                          Administering          Date:
                                                                                    authority:
National Environmental Management Act (NEMA) (Act No. 107 of 1998)                  DAEA                   1998

Environmental Impact Assessment Regulations Government Notice No. R 543             DAEA                   2010
Listing Notice 1 Government Notice No. R 544                                        DAEA                   2010
Integrated Environmental Management (IEM) Guidelines of the National                DAEA                   2002
Department of Environmental Affairs and Tourism
Conservation of Agricultural Resources (Act No. 43 of 1983).                        DAEA                   1983
Guidelines Compiled by the National Department of Environmental Affairs and         DAEA                   2006
Tourism in regard to the implementation of the regulations 385, 386 and 387,
these being :
      o Guideline 3: General Guide to Environmental Impact Assessment
          Regulations, 2006.
      o Guideline 4: The public participation process.
      o Guideline 5: Assessment of Alternative and Impacts
      o Guideline 6: Environmental Management Frameworks

National Water Act (Act No. 36 of 1998).                                            DWAF                   1998
National Heritage Resources Act (Act 25 No. of 1999).                               AMAFA                  1999
Hazardous Substance Act (Act No. 15 of 1973).                                                              1973
Health Act (Act No. 63 of 1977).                                                    DoH                    1977
National Environmental Management: Air Quality Act (Act No. 39 of 2004).            DAEA                   2004
National Environmental Management: Waste Act (Act No. 59 of 2008)                   DAEA                   2008
South African National Standard SANS 1929 : 2005                                    SABS                   2005
KwaZulu-Natal Nature Conservation Act (Act No. 9 of 1997).                          EKZNW / DAEA           1997
KwaZulu-Natal Planning and Development Act (Act No. 5 of 1998).                     Municipality           1998
KwaZulu-Natal Heritage Act (Act No. 10 of 1997)                                     AMAFA                  1997
Minimum requirements for handling, classification and disposal of hazardous         DWAF                   1998
waste (DWAF, second edition, 1998) based on the Environment Conservation
Act 73 of 1989.
DWAF Groundwater Protocol (March 2003).                                             DWAF                   2003
Mineral and Petroleum Resources Development Act (Act No. 28 of 2002).               DMR                    2002
South African National Standard (SANS) 10 089 The Petroleum Industry                SABS
Part 1: Storage and distribution of petroleum products                                                     2008
Part 2: Electrical Code                                                                                    2007
Part 3: The Installation of Underground Storage Tanks etc                                                  1999
National Building Regulations and Standards Act (Act No. 103 of 1977) (as           Economic Affairs       1996
amended)                                                                            and Technology
South African National Standard (SANS) 10 108 The classification of hazardous       SABS                   2005
locations and the selection of apparatus for use in such locations.
South African National Standard (SANS) 10 131 Section 5                             SABS                   2004
  Department of Agriculture,                Basic Assessment Report 2010                   Page 12 of 46
 Environmental Affairs & Rural                 Version 2: August 2010
 Development, KwaZulu-Natal
                                              Basic Assessment Report


          WASTE, EFFLUENT, EMISSION AND NOISE MANAGEMENT

      12.1. Solid waste management
Will the activity produce solid construction waste during the construction/initiation phase?           YES
If yes, what estimated quantity will be produced per month?                                            Difficult to
                                                                                                       estimate m3
How will the construction solid waste be disposed of? (describe)
All solid waste generated during the construction process (including packets, plastic, rubble,
cut plant material, waste metals etc) will be placed in bulk waste collection area in the
Contractors camp. The waste will be cleared regularly by a recognised waste Contractor.
Litter collection bins will be provided within the Contractors camp at convenient intervals and
will be regularly cleared. Separation of waste and recycling of paper, glass etc must be
encouraged. Burning or burying of waste will NOT be allowed. Unutilised, construction
materials will be removed once construction has ended, e.g. crushed stone may not be left or
randomly strewn around the site. The rocks and earth excavated from the site where the
Underground Storage Tanks will be located will be packed around the UST’s if regarded as
suitable by the Geotechnical Founding and Hydrogeological Assessment Report (Appendix
D1). Where the type of rock is unsuitable this waste will be disposed of at the Empangeni
Land Fill Site.

Hazardous materials that require disposal will be disposed of at a registered hazardous
landfill site. These materials may be removed by an appropriate hazardous waste Contractor.
Proof of appropriate disposal must be obtained by the Contractor.

Where will the construction solid waste be disposed of? (provide details of landfill site)

Will the activity produce solid waste during its operational phase?                                    YES
If yes, what estimated quantity will be produced per month?                                             Difficult to
                                                                                                       estimate m3
How will the solid waste be disposed of? (provide details of landfill site)
Solid waste will be generated by the forecourt and the fast food outlet and will be collected at
a central point. This waste will be disposed of as normal domestic waste at the municipal
waste disposal site in Empangeni. The National Environmental Management: Waste Act (Act
No. 59 of 2008) covers all aspects relating to waste management and must be adhered to at
all times. Any other relevant legislation must also be adhered to. Waste management at the
Filling Station shall be strictly controlled and monitored. Only approved waste disposal
methods shall be allowed. Management of the Filling Station shall ensure that all personnel
are instructed in the proper disposal of all waste and encouraged staff to participate in a
recycling scheme. In this instance separate receptacles for the disposal of these recyclable
materials could be positioned in the Waste Collection area. Sorting of the waste into organics,
recyclable, hazardous and domestic waste should be undertaken at this point if possible. Staff
training should be undertaken every six months to capacitate staff in terms of waste
minimisation, waste disposal, recycling and other waste issues. NO burning, on-site burying
or dumping of waste shall occur.

Where will the solid waste be disposed if it does not feed into a municipal waste stream (describe)?

If the solid waste (construction or operational phases) will not be disposed of in a registered landfill site or be taken
up in a municipal waste stream, then the applicant should consult with the competent authority to determine the
further requirements of the application.
Can any part of the solid waste be classified as hazardous in terms of the relevant legislation?                   NO
If yes, contact the KZN Department of Agriculture, Environmental Affairs and Rural Development to obtain
clarity regarding the process requirements for your application.
Is the activity that is being applied for a solid waste handling or treatment facility?                            NO
If yes, contact the KZN Department of Agriculture, Environmental Affairs and Rural Development to obtain
clarity regarding the process requirements for your application.




  Department of Agriculture,                  Basic Assessment Report 2010                     Page 13 of 46
 Environmental Affairs & Rural                   Version 2: August 2010
 Development, KwaZulu-Natal
                                             Basic Assessment Report


     12.2. Liquid effluent

Will the activity produce effluent, other than normal sewage, that will be disposed of in a        NO
municipal sewage system?
If yes, what estimated quantity will be produced per month?                                          m3
Will the activity produce any effluent that will be treated and/or disposed of on site?            NO
If yes, contact the KZN Department of Agriculture, Environmental Affairs and Rural Development to obtain
clarity regarding the process requirements for your application.
Will the activity produce effluent that will be treated and/or disposed of at another facility?    NO
If yes, provide the particulars of the facility:
Facility name:
Contact person:
Postal address:
Postal code:
Telephone:                                                                    Cell:
E-mail:                                                                       Fax:

Describe the measures that will be taken to ensure the optimal reuse or recycling of waste water, if any:

The water supply is from an existing borehole and may consist of a link to the municipal
supply if and when it becomes available. Based on the water usage by similar filling stations it
is estimated that the usage of water will be in the region of 150 kilolitres per month. This
includes the weekly washing of the forecourt, car wash, restaurants, etc. This usage could be
minimised with careful and resourceful planning and use of water. This could include recycling
wherever possible. Several innovative new technologies are available for this, including
recycling of grey water and storm water capture and use for washing and non-drinking
purposes. These include:
         On-site filtration (Zorbit Grease Trap) and recycling mini-plant for forecourt run-of and
         for the fast food outlet. The accumulated grease and oil must be removed by an
         accredited company.
         On site grey water and sewage recycling system using BiolytixR or LilliputR
         technologies, based on a septic tank system, whereby water can be recycled for use
         in washing, flushing and landscaping.
         Collection of stormwater from the building roofs in storage tanks.

The remaining liquid effluent will be disposed of in a septic tank (conservancy tank) as the site
is unsuitable soak pit system from a Geotechnical perspective (Appendix D1). The levels of
sewerage and effluent in tank must be monitored. When the tank levels are high the
municipality must be contacted and the sewerage collected for disposal at the municipal
sewerage works in Empangeni.

Stormwater runoff from the filling station will be directed by the stormwater drains and catch
pits to sand, oil and grease separators prior to reuse or release in the stormwater drains on
site.




  Department of Agriculture,                Basic Assessment Report 2010                    Page 14 of 46
 Environmental Affairs & Rural                 Version 2: August 2010
 Development, KwaZulu-Natal
                                      Basic Assessment Report


    12.3. Emissions into the atmosphere

Will the activity release emissions into the atmosphere?                               YES
If yes, is it controlled by any legislation of any sphere of government?                    NO
If yes, contact the KZN Department of Agriculture, Environmental Affairs and Rural
Development to obtain clarity regarding the process requirements for your application.
If no, describe the emissions in terms of type and concentration:
The major sources of air pollution will be the exhaust fumes from motor vehicles and trucks
and the emissions from the tank vent pipes. With respect to the Spatial Development
Framework of the City of uMhlatuze the site will not contribute to the zones of air pollution and
health concerns in the uMhlatuze area (Figure 1). Based on the above it is unlikely that a
detailed Air Quality Study will be required.




Figure 1: Map showing the buffer zone delineation based on all air pollution criteria -
permit operations (Revision of uMhlatuze Spatial Development Framework, City of
uMhlatuze, 2007). The site is indicated by an arrow.




  Department of Agriculture,          Basic Assessment Report 2010          Page 15 of 46
 Environmental Affairs & Rural           Version 2: August 2010
 Development, KwaZulu-Natal
                                              Basic Assessment Report


     12.4. Generation of noise

Will the activity generate noise?                                                                      YES
If yes, is it controlled by any legislation of any sphere of government?                                        NO
If yes, the applicant should consult with the competent authority to determine whether it is
necessary to change to an application for scoping and EIA.
If no, describe the noise in terms of type and level:
The general noise impact of the site will include:

            Noise from the construction of the filling station – plant, machinery, equipment and
            vehicles, hammering and blasting of the rock where the UST’s will be installed.
                 Construction / management activities involving use of the service vehicle,
                     machinery, hammering etc, must be limited to the hours between 7:00am and
                     5:30pm weekdays; 7:00am and 1:30pm on Saturdays; no noisy activities may
                     take place on Sundays or Public Holidays.
                 Activities that may disrupt neighbours (e.g. delivery trucks, excessively noisy
                     activities etc) must be preceded by notice being given to the affected
                     neighbours at least 24 hours in advance.
                 Equipment that is fitted with noise reduction facilities (e.g. side flaps, silencers
                     etc) must be used as per operating instructions and maintained properly
                     during site operations.
            The noise emanating from the R34 is not expected to increase significantly in terms
            of the current noise levels.
            The noise generated by the diesel trucks idling and revving, and other vehicles
            braking and accelerating may increase. Empangeni Milling Pty (Ltd) has a fleet of
            trucks so the noise levels generated by other trucks utilising the filling station will not
            cause additional disruption.
            Noise from the filling station will include:
                 o Staff of the filling station talking and shouting may be disruptive late at night
                     and on weekends.
                 o Music and radio broadcasts over the shop and forecourt speakers may be
                     potentially disruptive.
                 o Based on the above it is unlikely that a detailed Noise Impact Assessment
                     will be required.




13. WATER USE

Please indicate the source(s) of water that will be used for the activity by ticking the appropriate box(es):

municipal      water board      groundwater        river, stream, dam or     other          the activity will not use
                                                   lake                                     water

If water is to be extracted from groundwater, river, stream, dam, lake or any other natural Estimated
feature, please indicate the volume that will be extracted per month:                            150 kilolitres
Does the activity require a water use permit from the Department of Water Affairs?                           NO
If YES, please submit the necessary application to the Department of Water Affairs and attach proof thereof to this
report.




  Department of Agriculture,                 Basic Assessment Report 2010                      Page 16 of 46
 Environmental Affairs & Rural                  Version 2: August 2010
 Development, KwaZulu-Natal
                                             Basic Assessment Report


14. ENERGY EFFICIENCY

Describe the design measures, if any, that have been taken to ensure that the activity is energy efficient:

15.1      Insulation
     •    Insulating the ceiling helps make a building a comfortable electricity efficient place. As
          much as 50% of heat losses in a building can be attributed to a lack of ceilings and
          ceiling insulation. If a building’s ceiling is well insulated, heating and cooling expenses
          can be kept low.
     •    The flow of air into and out of a building occurs inadvertently as infiltration / exfiltration
          and deliberately as ventilation. Air leakage into and out of the building is one of the
          contributors to high heating and cooling costs. Air leakage can occur wherever
          different materials or parts of the building meet. Caulking and weather-stripping are
          the ideal methods that can be used in the design and construction for closing the
          loopholes through which heat escapes.

Describe how alternative energy sources have been taken into account or been built into the design of the activity,
if any:
The electricity services will require ongoing monitoring and maintenance for the duration of
occupation. Where possible energy will be saved using the following measures.

15.2      Power Supply
     •    Eskom will be the electrical suppliers for the Filling Station.
     •    Conservation of energy or the utilisation of renewable and sustainable energy
          technologies is encouraged. This includes solar panels that generate and store
          electricity in suitable battery packs, solar water heater(s), backed up with gas, as well
          as gas appliances.

15.3      Lighting
     •    All lights used for non-security purposes should be energy efficient for example
          compact fluorescent lights (CFL).
     •    Outside lights will have to be downward shining (eyelid type), low wattage and should
          not be positioned higher than 1 m above the ground surface.
     •    Fluorescent lamps give five times the light and last up to 10 times as long as ordinary
          bulbs.

15.4      Cooking and Refrigeration
     •    The fast food outlet should be encouraged to install gas appliances.
     •    The storage of gas must conform to the stipulations laid out in the OHSA.
     •    Switch on the energy saving switch, if one is fitted to the refrigerator.
     •    Convection ovens should also be installed as they use less energy than conventional
          ovens and cooking time is substantially reduced

15.5      Water Heaters / Geysers
     •    Solar water heater(s) conserve energy and can be backed up with gas or electric
          geysers.
     •    Installing a geyser blanket on geysers and hot water storage tanks will reduce the
          amount of heat lost by the geyser to cold air outside and thus conserves energy.
     •    Hot water pipes should also be insulated to prevent heat loss.

15.6      Air Conditioners
     •    Energy efficient heaters and air conditioners should be purchased.
     •    The outdoor cooling units must be protected from the sun. That is they should be
          placed on the south side of the building.



  Department of Agriculture,                Basic Assessment Report 2010                     Page 17 of 46
 Environmental Affairs & Rural                 Version 2: August 2010
 Development, KwaZulu-Natal
                                             Basic Assessment Report



SECTION C: SITE/ AREA/ PROPERTY DESCRIPTION
Important notes:
• For linear activities (pipelines, etc) as well as activities that cover very large sites, it may be necessary to
    complete this section for each part of the site that has a significantly different environment. In such cases
    please complete copies of Section C and indicate the area, which is covered by each copy No. on the Site
    Plan.

Section C Copy No. (e.g.
A):

•      Subsections 1 - 6 below must be completed for each alternative.

1.     GRADIENT OF THE SITE

Indicate the general gradient of the site.
Alternative S1:
 Flat          1:50 – 1:20     1:20 – 1:15    1:15 – 1:10       1:10 – 1:7,5     1:7,5 – 1:5       Steeper than 1:5
Alternative S2 (if any):
 Flat          1:50 – 1:20     1:20 – 1:15    1:15 – 1:10       1:10 – 1:7,5     1:7,5 – 1:5       Steeper than 1:5
Alternative S3 (if any):
 Flat          1:50 – 1:20     1:20 – 1:15    1:15 – 1:10       1:10 – 1:7,5     1:7,5 – 1:5       Steeper than 1:5


2.     LOCATION IN LANDSCAPE

Indicate the landform(s) that best describes the site (Please cross the appropriate box).
Alternative S1 (preferred site):
  Ridgeline Plateau Side slope of           Closed       Open      Plain     Undulating           Dune        Sea-
                           hill/mountain    valley       valley             plain/low hills                   front
Alternative S2 (if any):
  Ridgeline Plateau Side slope of Closed                 Open      Plain     Undulating           Dune        Sea-
                           hill/mountain    valley       valley             plain/low hills                   front
Alternative S3 (if any):
  Ridgeline Plateau Side slope of Closed                 Open      Plain     Undulating           Dune        Sea-
                           hill/mountain    valley       valley             plain/low hills                   front




     Department of Agriculture,              Basic Assessment Report 2010                     Page 18 of 46
    Environmental Affairs & Rural               Version 2: August 2010
    Development, KwaZulu-Natal
                                              Basic Assessment Report


3.   GROUNDWATER, SOIL AND GEOLOGICAL STABILITY OF THE SITE

Has a specialist been consulted for the completion of this section?                    YES
If YES, please complete the following:
Name of the specialist:             M. J. Hadlow, Drennan, Maud & Partners
Qualification(s)       of     the BSc (Hons), MSAIEG, Pr.SCi.Nat
specialist:
Postal address:                     P O Box 30464, Mayville, Durban
Postal code:                        4058
Telephone:                 031 201- 8992                                  Cell: 083 326-4085
E-mail:                    mike@dmpconsulting.co.za                       Fax: 031 201-7920
Are there any rare or endangered flora or fauna species (including red data                          NO
species) present on any of the alternative sites?
If        YES,
specify and
explain:
Are their any special or sensitive habitats or other natural features present on any                 NO
of the alternative sites?
If        YES,
specify and
explain:
Are any further specialist studies recommended by the specialist?                                    NO
If        YES,
specify:
If YES, is such a report(s) attached in Appendix D?                                     YES

Signature of specialist:                                     Date:


Is the site(s) located on any of the following (cross the appropriate boxes)?
                                        Alternative S1:          Alternative S2    (if     Alternative S3     (if
                                                                 any):                     any):
Shallow water table (less than 1.5m                 NO           YES         NO            YES         NO
deep)
Dolomite, sinkhole or doline areas                  NO           YES         NO            YES           NO

Seasonally wet soils (often close to                NO           YES         NO            YES           NO
water bodies)
Unstable rocky slopes or steep                      NO           YES         NO            YES           NO
slopes with loose soil
Dispersive soils (soils that dissolve               NO           YES         NO            YES           NO
in water)
Soils with high clay content (clay      YES                      YES         NO            YES           NO
fraction more than 40%)
Any other unstable soil or                          NO           YES         NO            YES           NO
geological feature
An area sensitive to erosion                        NO           YES         NO            YES           NO


If you are unsure about any of the above or if you are concerned that any of the above aspects
may be an issue of concern in the application, an appropriate specialist should be appointed to
assist in the completion of this section. (Information in respect of the above will often be
available as part of the project information or at the planning sections of local authorities.
Where it exists, the 1:50 000 scale Regional Geotechnical Maps prepared by the Council for
Geo Science may also be consulted).


  Department of Agriculture,                  Basic Assessment Report 2010               Page 19 of 46
 Environmental Affairs & Rural                   Version 2: August 2010
 Development, KwaZulu-Natal
                                             Basic Assessment Report


4.   GROUNDCOVER

Has a specialist been consulted for the completion of this section?                                           NO
If YES, please complete the following:
Name of the specialist:
Qualification(s) of the specialist:
Postal address:
Postal code:
Telephone:                                                                     Cell:
E-mail:                                                                        Fax:
Are there any rare or endangered flora or fauna species (including red data species)              YES         NO
present on any of the alternative sites?
If YES, specify
and explain:
Are their any special or sensitive habitats or other natural features present on any of the       YES         NO
alternative sites?
If YES, specify
and explain:
Are any further specialist studies recommended by the specialist?                                 YES         NO
If         YES,
specify:
If YES, is such a report(s) attached in Appendix D?                                               YES         NO

Signature of specialist:                                         Date:

The location of all identified rare or endangered species or other elements should be accurately
indicated on the site plan(s).

                           Natural veld with
                           scattered aliensE
                                                                           Building or other
                                                 Paved surface
                                                                           structure

If any of the boxes marked with an “E “is ticked, please consult an appropriate specialist to
assist in the completion of this section if the environmental assessment practitioner doesn’t
have the necessary expertise.




  Department of Agriculture,                Basic Assessment Report 2010                      Page 20 of 46
 Environmental Affairs & Rural                 Version 2: August 2010
 Development, KwaZulu-Natal
                                           Basic Assessment Report


5.   LAND USE CHARACTER OF SURROUNDING AREA

Cross the land uses and/or prominent features that currently occur within a 500m radius of the
site and give a description of how this influences the application or may be impacted upon by
the application:

Land use character                                      Description
Natural area                                     NO     None
Low density residential                          NO     None
Medium density residential                       NO     None
High density residential                         NO     None
Informal residential                             NO     None
Retail commercial & warehousing            YES          West of site. Empangeni Milling Pty (Ltd) and General
                                                        Store.
Light industrial                           YES          West of site. Offices in Empangeni Milling Pty (Ltd)
Medium industrial                                NO     None
Heavy industrial                                 NO     None
Power station                                    NO     None
Office/consulting room                     YES          West of site. Offices in Empangeni Milling Pty (Ltd)
Military or police base/station/compound         NO     None
Spoil heap or slimes dam                         NO     None
Quarry, sand or borrow pit                       NO     None
Dam or reservoir                           YES          Northwest of site (300m), across R34 and railway line
                                                        from site is a dam on the Okula River. West of the site
                                                        (400m) is a dam.
Hospital/medical centre                          NO     None
School/ creche                                   NO     None
Tertiary education facility                      NO     None
Church                                           NO     None
Old age home                                     NO     None
Sewage treatment plant                           NO     None
Train station or shunting yard             YES          North of site Across the R34.
Railway line                               YES          North of site. The Ngqwatayi railway line runs parallel to
                                                        the R34.
Major road (4 lanes or more)                     NO     R34 is only 2 lanes.
Airport                                          NO     None
Harbour                                          NO     None
Sport facilities                                 NO     None
Golf course                                      NO     None
Polo fields                                      NO     None
Filling station                                  NO     None
Landfill or waste treatment site                 NO     None
Plantation                                       NO     None
Agriculture                                YES          East, south and north of the site is undeveloped
                                                        commercial agricultural land – grazing and sugar cane
River, stream or wetland                   YES          Northwest of site. Across R34 and railway line is the
                                                        Okula River and a channelled valley-bottom wetland.
Nature conservation area                         NO     None
Mountain, hill or ridge                          NO     Site flat.
Museum                                           NO     None
Historical building                              NO     None
Protected Area                                   NO     None
Graveyard                                        NO     None
Archaeological site                              NO     None
Other land uses (describe)                       NO     None


  Department of Agriculture,               Basic Assessment Report 2010                 Page 21 of 46
 Environmental Affairs & Rural                Version 2: August 2010
 Development, KwaZulu-Natal
                                        Basic Assessment Report




6. CULTURAL/ HISTORICAL FEATURES

 Are there any signs of culturally or historically significant elements, as defined in section     NO
 2 of the National Heritage Resources Act, 1999, (Act No. 25 of 1999), including
 archaeological or palaeontological sites, on or within 20m of the site?
 If YES, contact a specialist recommended by AMAFA to conduct a heritage impact assessment. The heritage
 impact assessment must be attached as an appendix to this report.
 Briefly explain the recommendations of the
 specialist:
 Will any building or structure older than 60 years be affected in any way?                        NO
 Is it necessary to apply for a permit in terms of the National Heritage Resources Act,            NO
 1999 (Act 25 of 1999)?
 If YES, please submit the necessary application to AMAFA and attach proof thereof to this report.



SECTION D: PUBLIC PARTICIPATION
1. ADVERTISEMENT

The person conducting a public participation process must take into account any guidelines
applicable to public participation as contemplated in section 24J of the Act and must give notice
to all potential interested and affected parties of the application which is subjected to public
participation by—

(a)     fixing a notice board (of a size at least 60cm by 42cm; and must display the required
        information in lettering and in a format as may be determined by the competent
        authority) at a place conspicuous to the public at the boundary or on the fence of—
        (i)       the site where the activity to which the application relates is or is to be
                  undertaken; and
        (ii)     any alternative site mentioned in the application;
(b)     giving written notice to—
        (i)      the owner or person in control of that land if the applicant is not the owner or
                 person in control of the land;
        (ii)     the occupiers of the site where the activity is or is to be undertaken or to any
                 alternative site where the activity is to be undertaken;
        (iii)    owners and occupiers of land adjacent to the site where the activity is or is to
                 be undertaken or to any alternative site where the activity is to be undertaken;
        (iv)     the municipal councillor of the ward in which the site or alternative site is
                  situated and any organisation of ratepayers that represent the community in
                  the area;
        (v)       the local and district municipality which has jurisdiction in the area;
        (vi)     any organ of state having jurisdiction in respect of any aspect of the activity (as
                 identified in the application form for the environmental authorization of this
                 project); and
        (vii)    any other party as required by the competent authority;
(c)     placing an advertisement in—
        (i)      one local newspaper; or
        (ii)     any official Gazette that is published specifically for the purpose of providing
                 public notice of applications or other submissions made in terms of these
                 Regulations;
  Department of Agriculture,           Basic Assessment Report 2010               Page 22 of 46
 Environmental Affairs & Rural            Version 2: August 2010
 Development, KwaZulu-Natal
                                          Basic Assessment Report


(d)      placing an advertisement in at least one provincial newspaper or national newspaper, if
         the activity has or may have an impact that extends beyond the boundaries of the
         metropolitan or district municipality in which it is or will be undertaken: Provided that
         this paragraph need not be complied with if an advertisement has been placed in an
         official Gazette referred to in subregulation 54(c)(ii); and
(e)      using reasonable alternative methods, as agreed to by the competent authority, in
         those instances where a person is desiring of but unable to participate in the process
         due to—
         (i)       illiteracy;
         (ii)      disability; or
         (iii)     any other disadvantage.


2. CONTENT OF ADVERTISEMENTS AND NOTICES

A notice board, advertisement or notices must:
(a)     indicate the details of the application which is subjected to public participation; and
(b)     state—
        (i)      that an application for environmental authorization has been submitted to the
                 KZN Department of Agriculture, Environmental Affairs and Rural Development
                 in terms of the EIA Regulations, 2010;(ii)
        (iii)    a brief project description that includes the nature and location of the activity to
                 which the application relates;
        (iv)     where further information on the application can be obtained; and
        (iv)      the manner in which and the person to whom representations in respect of the
                  application may be made.


3. PLACEMENT OF ADVERTISEMENTS AND NOTICES

Where the proposed activity may have impacts that extend beyond the municipal area where it
is located, a notice must be placed in at least one provincial newspaper or national newspaper,
indicating that an application will be submitted to the competent authority in terms of these
regulations, the nature and location of the activity, where further information on the proposed
activity can be obtained and the manner in which representations in respect of the application
can be made, unless a notice has been placed in any Gazette that is published specifically for
the purpose of providing notice to the public of applications made in terms of the EIA
regulations.

Advertisements and notices must make provision for all alternatives.

The following documents pertaining to the Public Participation Process are attached to the
report as:
      Appendix G1:          Public Media Advertisements and Copy of the Site Notices
      Appendix G2:          Background Information Document (BID)
      Appendix G4:          Letters of Notification to I&AP’s, with Relevant Correspondence



4. DETERMINATION OF APPROPRIATE PROCESS

  Department of Agriculture,             Basic Assessment Report 2010                   Page 23 of 46
 Environmental Affairs & Rural              Version 2: August 2010
 Development, KwaZulu-Natal
                                           Basic Assessment Report


The EAP must ensure that the public participation process is according to that prescribed in
regulation 54 of the EIA Regulations, 2010, but may deviate from the requirements of
subregulation 54(2) in the manner agreed by the KZN Department of Agriculture,
Environmental Affairs and Rural Development as appropriate for this application. Special
attention should be given to the involvement of local community structures such as Ward
Committees, ratepayers associations and traditional authorities where appropriate.

Please note that public concerns that emerge at a later stage that should have been addressed
may cause the competent authority to withdraw any authorisation it may have issued if it
becomes apparent that the public participation process was inadequate.


5. COMMENTS AND RESPONSE REPORT

The practitioner must record all comments and respond to each comment of the public before
this application is submitted. The comments and responses must be captured in a comments
and response report as prescribed in the EIA regulations (regulation 57 in the EIA Regulations,
2010) and be attached as Appendix E to this report.


6. PARTICIPATION BY DISTRICT, LOCAL AND TRADITIONAL AUTHORITIES

District, local and traditional authorities (where applicable) are all key interested and affected
parties in each application and no decision on any application will be made before the relevant
local authority is provided with the opportunity to give input. The planning and the
environmental sections of the local authority must be informed of this application and provided
with an opportunity to comment.

Has any comment been received from the district municipality?                                          NO
If “YES”, briefly describe the feedback below (also attach any correspondence to and from this authority with
regard to this application):


Has any comment been received from the local municipality?                                        YES
If “YES”, briefly describe the feedback below (also attach any correspondence to and from this authority with
regard to this application):
     • Please note that unless the proponent is able to prove that the development is aligned to the
          Municipality’s Strategic Development Framework (SDF), this Department would not be able to support
          the project. Given this should the proposal be incompatible with Council’s development planning vision,
          the applicant would be required to go through the process of amending the current SDF to
          accommodate the proposed Filling Station and associated facilities on Ptn 11 (of 44) Farm 225
          Empangeni.


Has any comment been received from a traditional authority?                                            NO
If “YES”, briefly describe the feedback below (also attach any correspondence to and from this authority with
regard to this application):




  Department of Agriculture,              Basic Assessment Report 2010                   Page 24 of 46
 Environmental Affairs & Rural               Version 2: August 2010
 Development, KwaZulu-Natal
                                            Basic Assessment Report


7.   CONSULTATION WITH OTHER STAKEHOLDERS

Any stakeholder that has a direct interest in the site or property, such as servitude holders and
service providers, should be informed of the application and be provided with the opportunity to
comment.

Has any comment been received from stakeholders?                                                             NO

If “YES”, briefly describe the feedback below (also attach copies of any correspondence to and from the
stakeholders to this application):



SECTION E: IMPACT ASSESSMENT
The assessment of impacts must adhere to the requirements in the EIA Regulations, 2010, and should take
applicable official guidelines into account. The issues raised by interested and affected parties should also be
addressed in the assessment of impacts.


1.   ISSUES RAISED BY INTERESTED AND AFFECTED PARTIES

List the main issues raised by interested and affected parties.
      • I am concerned about the development and the facilities proposed, and do believe that there would be
          objection from other stakeholders to the location of the development, as well as the fact that a Truck
          Stop facility is included – something which is currently part of a study by uMhlathuze and uThungulu
          Municipalities which are delaying other similar types of developments. I find it of concern that the
          developer in this instance have not been informed of these studies and are very much concerned that
          they may be in a situation where, once the site for the planned “regional” Truck Stop facilities are
          decided, may find themselves in a compromised situation when it comes to other sites which would be
          better located for that purpose, and the other facilities which would logically be included with those
          developments – most of which would directly compete with the facilities offered in this development, and
          being better located strategically. (FRANS VAN DER WALT)
      • Thank you for the information. The BID has identified the issues of interest to WESSA and we would like
          to receive further information on the project. Our interest lies in potential water resource contamination
          with respect to storm water and sewage. Throughout the project there needs to be an underlying ethos
          of resource conservation – water and energy – as well as additional sustainable development options
          being considered. (CAROL SCHWEGMAN).


Response from the practitioner to the issues raised by the interested and affected parties (A full response must be
given in the Comments and Response Report that must be attached as Appendix E to this report):
     • Thanks for that information. Ultimately, my client must decide whether he wants to continue or not after
           the BID presentation. I have forwarded a copy of the minutes from one of your meetings to my client for
           him to read with regards to the proposed truck stops in the region.
     • These options have been considered during the Basic Assessment.



2.   IMPACTS THAT MAY RESULT FROM THE PLANNING AND DESIGN, CONSTRUCTION,
     OPERATIONAL, DECOMMISSIONING AND CLOSURE PHASES AS WELL AS PROPOSED
     MANAGEMENT OF IDENTIFIED IMPACTS AND PROPOSED MITIGATION MEASURES




  Department of Agriculture,                Basic Assessment Report 2010                   Page 25 of 46
 Environmental Affairs & Rural                 Version 2: August 2010
 Development, KwaZulu-Natal
                                              Basic Assessment Report


     2.1. IMPACTS THAT MAY RESULT FROM THE PLANNING AND DESIGN PHASE

     a. Site alternatives
List the potential impacts associated with site alternatives that are likely to occur during the planning and design
phase:

Alternative S1 (preferred alternative)
Direct impacts:
The planning and design phase will not result in any direct impacts. The selection of this site is as a result of the
applicant owning the site, which is suitably located adjacent to the R34 for the proposed purpose of a filling station.
Alternative locations are currently not available, and would thus involve lease or purchase of land / other sites.
The proposed site is deemed suitable as it will have a minimal impact on the environment as a result of the following
factors:
     •     Existing footprint of use (tarred surface, sheds, fencing).
     •     Disturbed area, difficult to rehabilitate to agricultural use.

Indirect impacts:
     •    The location of the site will be suitable in terms of supplying the traffic using the R34 and the P253 with
          fuel. These roads have significant traffic volumes. The resultant sales of fuel will contribute to the local
          economy as well as creating additional employment in the local area. Furthermore the filling station will
          improve the levels of convenience to residents of areas that are in close proximity to the site.

Cumulative impacts:
   •    No impacts are expected with the exception of an increase in the business potential of the area.


Alternative S2 (if any)
Direct impacts:
Indirect impacts:
Cumulative impacts:

No-go alternative (compulsory)
Direct impacts:
     •   No new impacts would result.
     •   The company will not be able to increase profitability.
     •   Alien plants will infest the site.

Indirect impacts:
     •    No additional employment will be created.

Cumulative impacts:
   •    None


Indicate mitigation measures to manage the potential impacts listed above:
Alternative S1
Although there are few impacts associated with the planning and design phase the importance of the Basic
Assessment as part of this must be incorporated. Thus the following are considered mitigation measures prior to
construction.
     •    The compilations of an Environmental Management Programme (EMPr).
     •    The EMPr must be signed by the developer and the contractor stating that they understand the conditions
          and requirements of the EMPr.
     •    The conditions in the Environmental Authorisation must be complied with by the developer and the
          Contractor.
     •    A photographic record of the site must be taken prior to construction and regularly updated during the
          construction phase.
     •    All records with respect to the construction (materials, suppliers) must be kept as well as compliance and
          non-compliance with the Environmental Authorisation conditions, environmental incidents and complaints.
          These documents must be available to the Department of Environment on request.
     •    An Environmental Control Officer (ECO) must be appointed.
     •    Where possible skilled and unskilled labour should be sourced from the local community.
     •    Training of staff working on the construction site with respect to environmental awareness and the EMPr is
          essential and the responsibility of the developer and the contractor.
     •    Only trained staff may operate plant, machinery and explosives on site. All personnel must be aware of the
          impacts and hazards associated with the tasks they perform and how best to mitigate against these.
     •    Should the developer decide to sink a borehole, an appropriate specialist must be consulted on the best
          location on site. Furthermore any authorisations required for the borehole must be obtained.
     •    The site must be rezoned from agriculture to service station.




  Department of Agriculture,                 Basic Assessment Report 2010                     Page 26 of 46
 Environmental Affairs & Rural                  Version 2: August 2010
 Development, KwaZulu-Natal
                                              Basic Assessment Report



     b. Process, technology, layout or other alternatives
List the impacts associated with any process, technology, layout or other alternatives that are likely to occur during
the planning and design phase (please list impacts associated with each alternative separately):

Alternative A1 (preferred alternative)
Direct impacts:
     •    The planning and design phase will not result in any direct impacts. The selection of alternative positions
          for the UST’s to be buried will not have an impact at this stage in the process. The proposed site is deemed
          suitable as and will have a minimal impact on the environment as a result of the following factors:
     •    Existing footprint of use (tarred surface, sheds, fencing).
     •    Disturbed area, difficult to rehabilitate to agricultural use.
     •    The site is suitable from a geotechnical point of view for building a filling station as no limitations on the
          position of the UST’s have been identified (Appendix D1).
     •    A draft conceptual layout has been provided (Appendix C), and includes allowance for some flexibility in
          terms of the final layout, with respect to location of bouwsers, fast food restaurant. The final layout will be
          negotiated with the fuel company which contracts with the applicant to operate the facility. The location of
          the UST’s is not expected to have different impacts to those already discussed.
     •    Should the developer decide to sink a borehole, an appropriate specialist must be consulted on the best
          location on site. Furthermore any authorisations required for the borehole must be obtained.


Indirect impacts:
     •    The location of the site is suitable in terms of supplying the traffic using the R34 and the P253 with fuel.
          These roads have significant traffic volumes. The resultant sales of fuel will contribute to the local economy
          as well as creating additional employment in the local area. Furthermore the filling station will improve the
          levels of convenience to residents of areas that are in close proximity to the site.
     •    The requirements for a more detailed diagram as well as the possible sinking of a borehole will result in the
          employment of skilled personnel.

Cumulative impacts:
   •    No impacts are expected with the exception of an increase in the business potential of the area.



Alternative A2 (if any)
Direct impacts:
Indirect impacts:
Cumulative impacts:


No-go alternative (compulsory)
Direct impacts:
     •   No new impacts would result.
     •   The company will not be able to increase profitability.
     •   Alien plants will infest the site.

Indirect impacts:
     •    No additional employment will be created.

Cumulative impacts:
   •    None



Indicate mitigation measures to manage the potential impacts listed above:
Alternative A1:
     •    The layout is not deemed to be a high impact issue, as long as it complies with criteria listed in the final
          report, the Geotechnical report (Appendix D1) and EMPr (Appendix F) for waste management, underground
          tank construction, general safety and water conservation.
     •    The compilations of an Environmental Management Programme (EMPr).
     •    The EMPr must be signed by the developer and the contractor stating that they understand the conditions
          and requirements of the EMPr.
     •    The conditions in the Environmental Authorisation must be complied with by the developer and the
          Contractor.
     •    A photographic record of the site must be taken prior to construction and regularly updated during the
          construction phase.
     •    All records with respect to the construction (materials, suppliers) must be kept as well as compliance and
          non-compliance with the Environmental Authorisation conditions, environmental incidents and complaints.
          These documents must be available to the Department of Environment on request.
     •    An Environmental Control Officer (ECO) must be appointed.

  Department of Agriculture,                  Basic Assessment Report 2010                     Page 27 of 46
 Environmental Affairs & Rural                   Version 2: August 2010
 Development, KwaZulu-Natal
                                               Basic Assessment Report


     •    Where possible skilled and unskilled labour should be sourced from the local community.
     •    Training of staff working on the construction site with respect to environmental awareness and the EMPr is
          essential and the responsibility of the developer and the contractor.
     •    Only trained staff may operate plant, machinery and explosives on site. All personnel must be aware of the
          impacts and hazards associated with the tasks they perform and how best to mitigate against these.
     •    The site must be rezoned from agriculture to service station.




     2.2. IMPACTS THAT MAY RESULT FROM THE CONSTRUCTION PHASE

               a. Site alternatives

List the potential impacts associated with site alternatives that are likely to occur during the construction phase:

Alternative S1 (preferred site)
Direct impacts:
The construction phase of the development will result in the greatest impact on the environment. These impacts will
occur on any potential site. The severity of these impacts can be reduced by effectively implemented mitigation
measures.

Soil and Ground Water Pollution
     •   The construction phase will result in increased infiltration of contaminants into the ground water and soil.
     •   The clearing of the site will result in exposed soil surfaces which may be prone to erosion, creation of dust
         and sedimentation of streams.
     •   Spillages of oil, lubricants and fuel from construction vehicles, plant and machinery has the potential to
         contaminate the soil and groundwater. Flora in these areas where contamination occurs will die.
     •   Cement mixing and the storage of fuel must be conducted so as to prevent contamination of the soil and
         groundwater.
     •   Stormwater run off has the potential to erode the topsoil and result in sedimentation on streams if not
         controlled.

Visual Intrusion & Light Pollution
    •     Littering and illegal dumping on the site may result in an alteration of the visual character of the site.
    •     The development will result in the removal of vegetation and the construction of buildings which may be
          visually intrusive.
    •     Lights from the contractor’s camp and the construction site will be visually intrusive.

Destruction of Flora & Fauna
    •    Construction activities will disturb the fauna in the area.
    •    The clearing of vegetation will result in the loss of habitat, habitat fragmentation and possibly a loss of
         species on the site.
    •    The noises and vibrations resulting from machinery and blasting could impact on faunal species outside the
         site.
    •    Pollution resulting from the construction site such as litter, solid waste, sewerage and spills of oil, lubricants
         and fuel could reduce the quality of the habitats in the surrounding area and directly impact on the health
         and welfare of the fauna and flora surrounding the site.
    •    Due to the disturbance of the site alien plants will be able to establish and could become a problem by
         infesting neighbouring land.

Traffic & Access
     •    Increased traffic congestion could possibly occur as a result of construction vehicles moving onto and off
          the site during construction.

Noise Pollution
    •    There will be an increase in noise during the construction of the filling station – plant, machinery,
         equipment and vehicles, hammering and blasting of the rock where the UST’s will be installed.

Atmosphere Pollution and Odours
    •  The increased dust, smoke and emissions resulting from construction activities (vegetation clearing, site
       preparation, earthworks, blasting, uncovered topsoil stockpiles and sand piles, loads on vehicles and the
       burning of waste); vehicles, plant and machinery poses a health hazard to construction staff and people
       living and working in the vicinity of the site.

Safety & Security
    •    A construction site can be a dangerous place and thus could result in harm to people and property.
    •    Construction sites by their nature act as a magnet to the unemployed, so large numbers of people may
         gather on or around the site.

Hygiene
    •   The health of workers may be adversely affected by unhygienic working conditions on the construction site.
    •   Workers may be exposed to diseases such as tick bite fever, malaria, HIV-AIDS.
  Department of Agriculture,                  Basic Assessment Report 2010                       Page 28 of 46
 Environmental Affairs & Rural                   Version 2: August 2010
 Development, KwaZulu-Natal
                                              Basic Assessment Report



Indirect impacts:
Construction Traffic
     •    Construction traffic may result in increased traffic congestion on the R34 as well as Empangeni where
          construction supplies will be collected.

Security
    •    Construction sites by their nature act as a magnet to the unemployed, so large numbers of people may
         gather on or around the site. These people must be kept of the site for safety reasons. Furthermore
         criminals may also utilise the opportunity to steal items from the site.

Spread of Alien Vegetation
    •    Due to the disturbance of the site alien plants will be able to establish and could become a problem by
         infesting neighbouring land.

Socio Economic
    •   Constructing the proposed development will result in direct jobs being created for the construction of the
        various facilities. Indirectly, jobs are also created in industries that provide goods, materials and services.
        For example, an additional amount of goods used in construction will be required from business and
        industries related to the construction sector.
    •   The proposed development will lead to an increase in the level local employment in the areas surrounding
        the development site. Both short-term and long-term employment will be created in this case.
    •   The development will lead to the increase in the number of convenience facilities in the primary market
        area.

Cumulative impacts:
Surface Water Pollution
    •    Spillages of oil, lubricants and fuel from construction vehicles, plant and machinery has the potential to
         contaminate surface water. This surface water will flow into the drainage lines and the river to the north of
         the site. The wetland located along this river would become polluted. Flora and fauna in these areas where
         contamination occurs will die.

Increased run off of Water
     •   The increase in paved areas such as the construction camp, roads and driveways and forecourt will
         increase the amount of stormwater runoff and thus reduce the infiltration of water into the groundwater.
         This may result in erosion of areas that are not paved.
     •   Stormwater run off has the potential to erode the topsoil and result in sedimentation of streams if not
         controlled.

Ground Water Pollution
    •   The construction phase will result in increased infiltration of contaminants into the ground water and soil.
    •   The clearing of the site will result in exposed soil surfaces which may be prone to erosion, creation of dust
        and sedimentation of streams.
    •   Spillages of oil, lubricants and fuel from construction vehicles, plant and machinery has the potential to
        contaminate the soil and groundwater. Flora in these areas where contamination occurs will die.
    •   Cement mixing and the storage of fuel must be conducted so as to prevent contamination of the soil and
        groundwater.

Socio Economic
    •   Constructing the proposed development will result in direct jobs being created for the construction of the
        various facilities. Indirectly, jobs are also created in industries that provide goods, materials and services.
        For example, an additional amount of goods used in construction will be required from business and
        industries related to the construction sector.
    •   The proposed development will lead to the increase the level local employment in the areas surrounding
        the development site. Both short-term and long-term employment will be created in this case.
    •   The development will lead to the increase in the number of convenience facilities in the primary market
        area.

Faunal Displacement
    •    The displacement of fauna as a result of an increase in ambient noises, vibrations is likely to remain even
         with mitigation.


Alternative S2 (if any)
Direct impacts:
Indirect impacts:
Cumulative impacts:

No-go alternative (compulsory)
Direct impacts:
Should the site not be developed the following direct impacts associated with the construction phase will not occur:
     •   Soil and Ground Water pollution
     •   Visual Intrusion & Light Pollution

  Department of Agriculture,                 Basic Assessment Report 2010                     Page 29 of 46
 Environmental Affairs & Rural                  Version 2: August 2010
 Development, KwaZulu-Natal
                                               Basic Assessment Report


     •    Increase in construction traffic volumes
     •    Noise Pollution
     •    Atmosphere pollution and odours
     •    Destruction of Flora & Fauna
     •    Construction site hygiene will not be a factor as there will be no staff on the site
     •    The safety and security of the staff and the site will not be a problem.

The direct impacts associated with the filling station not being constructed include:
    •     An increase in the number of aliens plants on the site as well as the possible infestation of neighbouring
          properties.
    •     The security of the adjacent site [Empangeni Milling Pty (Ltd)] may be compromised by the vacant land
          adjacent. The grass cover becomes dense and high which is ideal cover for criminals.
    •     The decreased infiltration of stormwater as well as the increased run off of stormwater will still be a
          problem as the site is partially paved although there is extensive grass cover which has broken through the
          existing paving.
    •     No jobs will be created. Thus there will be a loss of income in the local economy.
    •     The company will not be able to increase profitability.

Indirect impacts:
Should the site not be developed the following indirect impacts associated with the construction phase will not occur:
     •    Increase in construction traffic volumes on the R34 and in Empangeni.
     •    The safety and security of the staff and the site will not be a problem.

The indirect impacts associated with the filling station not being constructed include:
     •    The alien vegetation on site will increase which will reduce the amount of surface water reaching the rivers
          and the ground water will be reduced by the large numbers of thirsty alien plants.
     •    The alien plants may also expand onto neighbouring land.
     •    Industries that provide goods, materials and services will not benefit from the construction. Resulting in
          further loss of income in the local economy.
     •    Local communities will need to drive into Empangeni for fuel.

Cumulative impacts:
   •    The cumulative impacts associated with not developing the site are a loss of revenue in the local economy
        and the loss of potential jobs.



Indicate mitigation measures to manage the potential impacts listed above:
Alternative S1
Discussed more fully in EMPr attached in Appendix F

Soil and Ground Water Pollution
     •   Appropriate erosion and stormwater management structures must be installed around the construction site.
     •   All construction vehicles, plant, machinery and equipment must be properly maintained to prevent leaks.
     •   Plant and vehicles are to be repaired immediately upon developing leaks. Drip trays shall be supplied for all
         repair work undertaken on machinery on site or campsite area.
     •   Drip trays are to be utilised during daily greasing and re-fuelling of machinery and to catch incidental spills
         and pollutants.
     •   Drip trays are to be inspected daily for leaks and effectiveness, and emptied when necessary. This is to be
         closely monitored during rain events to prevent overflow.
     •   Vehicles to be used during the construction phase are to be kept in good working condition and should not
         be the source of excessive fumes.
     •   Fuels and chemicals must be stored in adequate storage facilities that are secure, enclosed and bunded.
     •   The installation of the Underground Storage Tanks must follow the SANS 10089, SANS 11535 and SANS
         10731 guidelines.
     •   All advice given in the Geotechnical Report (Appendix D1) must be followed.
     •   The underground cavity that will contain the Underground Storage Tanks must be lined with plastic or an
         impermeable resistant coating.
     •   Pipes from the UST’s to the pumps must be adequately sealed from the soil.
     •   Hydrocarbon counts in the groundwater and surface water must be determined prior to construction and
         filling of the tanks. The results must be forwarded on to the Department of Water Affairs (DWA).
     •   All excavations and foundations must be inspected regularly.
     •   Mulch bags or silt fences are to be placed along the base of this fence to trap any sediment, which may
         move following rain. These are to be kept clean during construction to prevent any movement of silt out of
         the demarcated zone.
     •   Once earthworks are complete, disturbed areas are to be stabilised with mulch, straw or other approved
         method.
     •   On-site filtration (Zorbit Grease Trap) and recycling mini-plant for forecourt run-of and for the fast food
         outlet. The accumulated grease and oil must be removed by an accredited company.
     •   On site grey water and sewage recycling system using BiolytixR or LilliputR technologies, based on a septic
         tank system, whereby water can be recycled for use in washing, flushing and landscaping.
     •   Collection of stormwater from the building roofs in storage tanks. Where the stormwater is discharged it

  Department of Agriculture,                  Basic Assessment Report 2010                       Page 30 of 46
 Environmental Affairs & Rural                   Version 2: August 2010
 Development, KwaZulu-Natal
                                               Basic Assessment Report


          must be discharged off site into the municipal stormwater system due to the thickness of the soil on site
          (Appendix D1).

Visual Intrusion & Light Pollution
    •     The building area is to be physically screened off with a shade cloth fence at least 1.8m in height.
    •     The site must be managed appropriately and all rubbish and rubble removed to a recognised waste facility.
    •     Excess soil and bedrock should be disposed of at an appropriate facility.
    •     A certificate of disposal must be obtained for any waste that is disposed of.
    •     Waste must not remain on site for more than 2 weeks.
    •     Refuse bins must be provided by the Contractor for rubbish to be place in by staff.
    •     Excess concrete must be disposed of correctly and at an appropriate facility.
    •     No waste may be placed in any excavations on site.
    •     The construction camp must be located as far from other properties as possible.
    •     Indigenous plants or trees should be planted next to buildings to break the lines of the buildings making
          them less visually intrusive.
    •     Advertising signs should blend in with the environment.
    •     Light pollutions should be minimised.
    •     The construction foot print must be minimised.
    •     Construction / management activities must be limited to the daylight hours between 7:00am and 5:30pm
          weekdays; 7:00am and 1:30pm on Saturdays.
    •     Lighting on site is to be sufficient for safety and security purposes, but shall not be intrusive to neighbouring
          residents, disturb wildlife, or interfere with road traffic.
    •     Should overtime/night work be authorised, the Contractor shall be responsible to ensure that lighting does
          not cause undue disturbance to neighbouring residents. In this situation low flux and frequency lighting
          shall be utilised.

Destruction of Flora & Fauna
    •    Site clearing is to be limited to only the area necessary for carrying out the specified works and the
         destruction of vegetation should be minimised.
    •    No littering by construction workers is permitted. Any litter will be collected and removed off-site to a
         registered waste site.
    •    Cleared indigenous vegetation can be stockpiled for possible reuse in later rehabilitation or landscaping, or
         as a brush pack for erosion prevention.
    •    Stockpiles of vegetation are only to be located in areas approved by the ECO, and may not exceed 2 m in
         height. Methods of stacking must take cognisance of the possible creation of a fire hazard.
    •    No burning of stockpiled vegetation is permitted.
    •    Table 3 from the Conservation of Agricultural Resources Act (Act No. 43 of 1983) (CARA) Regulation 15
         lists all alien plants that occur in South Africa. None of these species may be introduced and they must all
         be controlled.
    •    The alien plants on site will be removed during construction.
    •    Care must be taken to avoid the introduction of alien plant species to the site and surrounding areas.
         (Particular attention must be paid to imported material).
    •    Alien vegetation re-growth must be controlled throughout the entire site during the construction period.
    •    Disturbance to birds, animals and reptiles and their habitats should be prevented at all times.
    •    The illegal hunting or capture of wildlife will not be tolerated. Such matters will be handed over to the
         relevant authorities for prosecution.

Traffic & Access
     •    The access, being on an important provincial route will need to meet certain criteria: It is recommended that
          a high standard of intersection be constructed with dedicated right turn lanes and edge tapers to a standard
          of at least that of a KZN DoT ‘Type B2’.
     •    Should the entrance to the site be security controlled this is to be positioned a minimum distance of 80m
          from the edge of the provincial road.
     •    On both R34 approaches to the proposed site intersection a high visibility W102 (priority crossroad sign)
          with information plate “heavy vehicles turning” is required. All signage and road markings for the proposed
          site intersection should be in accordance with the South African Road Traffic Signs Manual”.

Noise Pollution
    •    Noise levels shall be kept within acceptable limits, and construction crew must abide by National Noise
         Laws and local by-laws regarding noise.
    •    If work is to be undertaken outside of normal work hours permission, must be obtained. Prior to
         commencing any such activity the Contractor is also to advise the potentially affected neighbouring
         residents. Notification could include letter-drops.
    •    No sound amplification equipment such as sirens, loud hailers or hooters are to be used on site except in
         emergencies and no amplified music is permitted on site.
    •    Construction / management activities involving use of the service vehicle, machinery, hammering etc, must
         be limited to the hours between 7:00am and 5:30pm weekdays; 7:00am and 1:30pm on Saturdays; no noisy
         activities may take place on Sundays or Public Holidays.
    •    Activities that may disrupt neighbours (e.g. delivery trucks, excessively noisy activities etc) must be
         preceded by notice being given to the affected neighbours at least 24 hours in advance.
    •    Equipment that is fitted with noise reduction facilities (e.g. side flaps, silencers etc) must be used as per
         operating instructions and maintained properly during site operations.

  Department of Agriculture,                  Basic Assessment Report 2010                      Page 31 of 46
 Environmental Affairs & Rural                   Version 2: August 2010
 Development, KwaZulu-Natal
                                             Basic Assessment Report



Atmosphere Pollution and Odours
    •  The building area is to be physically screened off with a shade cloth fence at least 1.8m in height, to prevent
       dust from being blown onto the road or neighbouring properties.
    •  Dust generation should be kept to a minimum.
    •  Dust must be suppressed on access roads and construction areas during dry periods by the regular
       application of water or a biodegradable soil stabilisation agent.
    •  Speed limits must be implemented in all areas, including public roads and private property to limit the levels
       of dust pollution.
    •  It is recommended that the clearing of vegetation from the site should be selective and done just before
       construction so as to minimise erosion and dust.
    •  Should construction in areas that have been stripped not be commencing within a short period of time the
       exposed areas shall be re-vegetated or stabilised. Soil stabilising measures could include rotovating in
       straw bales (at a rate of 1 bale/20 m²), applying mulching or brush packing, or creating windbreaks using
       brush or bales.
    •  Sand stockpiles are to be covered with Hessian, shade cloth or DPC plastic.
    •  Where possible stockpiles are to be located in sheltered areas and the usable/cut face orientated away
       from the direction of the prevailing wind for that season.
    •  Excavating, handling or transporting erodable materials in high wind or when dust plumes are visible shall
       be avoided.
    •  All materials transported to site must be transported in such a manner that they do not fly or fall off the
       vehicle. This may necessitate covering or wetting friable materials.
    •  No burning of refuse or vegetation is permitted.

Safety & Security
    •    Signs should be erected on all entrance gates indicating that no temporary jobs are available, thereby
         limiting opportunistic labourers and crime.
    •    Single and double storey structures may be founded on normal strip footings or isolated footings taken
         directly from the weathered siltstone at levels around 1m below the existing ground surface. If and where
         the minimum building regulation depth of 0.5m cannot be achieved in the medium hard rock, these footings
         must be anchored into the rock by steel dowels or equivalent methods to prevent sliding (Appendix D1).
    •    The site and crew are to be managed in strict accordance with the Occupational Health and Safety Act (Act
         No. 85 of 1993) and the National Building Regulations
    •    All structures that are vulnerable to high winds must be secured (including scaffolds and toilets).
    •    All manhole openings are to be covered and clearly demarcated with danger tape.
    •    Potentially hazardous areas such as trenches are to be cordoned off and clearly marked at all times.
    •    The Contractor is to ensure traffic safety at all times, and shall implement road safety precautions for this
         purpose when works are undertaken on or near public roads.
    •    Necessary Personal Protective Equipment (PPE) and safety gear appropriate to the task being undertaken
         is to be provided to all site personnel (e.g. hard hats, safety boots, masks etc.).
    •    All vehicles and equipment used on site must be operated by appropriately trained and / or licensed
         individuals in compliance with all safety measures as laid out in the Occupational Health and Safety Act (Act
         No. 85 of 1993) (OHSA).
    •    An environmental awareness training programme for all staff members shall be put in place by the
         Contractor. Before commencing with any work, all staff members shall be appropriately briefed about the
         EMPr and relevant occupational health and safety issues.
    •    All construction workers shall be issued with ID badges and clearly identifiable uniforms.
    •    Access to fuel and other equipment stores is to be strictly controlled.
    •    No unauthorized firearms are permitted on site.
    •    Emergency procedures must be produced and communicated to all the employees on site. This will ensure
         that accidents are responded to appropriately and the impacts thereof are minimised. This will also ensure
         that potential liabilities and damage to life and the environment are avoided.
    •    Adequate emergency facilities must be provided for the treatment of any emergency on the site.
    •    The nearest emergency service provider must be identified during all phases of the project as well as its
         capacity and the magnitude of accidents it will be able to handle. Emergency contact numbers are to be
         displayed conspicuously at prominent locations around the construction site and the construction crew
         camps at all times.
    •    The Contractor must have a basic spill control kit available at each construction crew camp and around the
         construction site. The spill control kits must include absorptive material that can handle all forms of
         hydrocarbon as well as floating blankets / pillows that can be placed on water courses.

Hygiene
    •   The Contractor shall make available safe drinking water fit for human consumption at the site offices and all
        other working areas.
    •   Washing and toilet facilities shall be provided on site and in the Contractors camp.
    •   Adequate numbers of chemical toilets must be maintained in the Contractors camp to service the staff using
        this area. At least 1 toilet must be available per 20 workers using the camp. Toilet paper must be provided.
    •   The chemical toilets servicing the camp must be maintained in a good state, and any spills or overflows
        must be attended to immediately.
    •   The chemical toilets must be emptied on a regular basis.
    •   The chemical toilets must be sited taking into account the possibility of the prevailing wind unfavourably
        dispersing unpleasant odours.

  Department of Agriculture,                Basic Assessment Report 2010                    Page 32 of 46
 Environmental Affairs & Rural                 Version 2: August 2010
 Development, KwaZulu-Natal
                                               Basic Assessment Report


     •    The Contractors site must be located on the high side of the site so any leakages or spillages will be
          contained on site.
     •    Tick repellent must also be provided (Bayticol is available from certain pharmacies and should be sprayed
          on the clothing in contact with grass, etc.).
     •    HIV AIDS awareness and education should be undertaken by all Contractor staff. Cognisance must be
          taken of the fact that the site is in close proximity to the N3 which is a major transportation route associated
          with the spreading of the disease.
     •    Care should be taken to adequately drain areas surrounding water points in order to avoid the development
          of pools of standing water, as these tend to be a breeding source of flies, mosquitoes and other vectors.

Cumulative Impacts
The cumulative impacts can be decreased significantly if the following are adhered to:
    •   On-site filtration (Zorbit Grease Trap) and recycling mini-plant for forecourt runoff and for the fast food
        outlet. The accumulated grease and oil must be removed by an accredited company.
    •   Construction takes place during the dry months of the year.
    •   Landscaping of the grounds must be done as soon as possible with indigenous vegetation so as to increase
        stormwater infiltration, decrease erosion and decrease stormwater runoff.
    •   The installation of the Underground Storage Tanks follows SABS specifications:
        o          SANS 10 089, 11 535 & 10 131 (Installation)
        o          SANS 10 108 (Hazardous locations & apparatus)
        o          SANS10 040 (Building Regulations)



                  b. Process, technology, layout or other alternatives
List the impacts associated with process, technology, layout or other alternatives that are likely to occur during the
construction phase (please list impacts associated with each alternative separately):

Alternative A1 (preferred alternative)
Direct impacts:
There will be no technological or activity related alternatives as a result of the construction phase of the project.

Indirect impacts:
There will be no technological or activity related alternatives as a result of the construction phase of the project.

Cumulative impacts:
There will be no technological or activity related alternatives as a result of the construction phase of the project.


Alternative A2
Direct impacts:

Indirect impacts:

Cumulative impacts:

No-go alternative (compulsory)
Direct impacts:
Should the site not be developed the following direct impacts associated with the construction phase will not occur:
     •   Soil and Ground Water pollution
     •   Visual Intrusion & Light Pollution
     •   Increase in construction traffic volumes
     •   Noise Pollution
     •   Atmosphere pollution and odours
     •   Destruction of Flora & Fauna
     •   Construction site hygiene will not be a factor as there will be no staff on the site
     •   The safety and security of the staff and the site will not be a problem.

The direct impacts associated with the filling station not being constructed include:
    •     An increase in the number of aliens plants on the site as well as the possible infestation of neighbouring
          properties.
    •     The security of the adjacent site [Empangeni Milling Pty (Ltd)] may be compromised by the vacant land
          adjacent. The grass cover becomes dense and high which is ideal cover for criminals.
    •     The decreased infiltration of stormwater as well as the increased run off of stormwater will still be a
          problem as the site is partially paved although there is extensive grass cover which has broken through the
          existing paving.
    •     No jobs will be created. Thus there will be a loss of income in the local economy.
    •     The company will not be able to increase profitability.

Indirect impacts:
Should the site not be developed the following indirect impacts associated with the construction phase will not occur:
     •    Increase in construction traffic volumes on the R34 and in Empangeni.
  Department of Agriculture,                   Basic Assessment Report 2010                      Page 33 of 46
 Environmental Affairs & Rural                    Version 2: August 2010
 Development, KwaZulu-Natal
                                                Basic Assessment Report


     •    The safety and security of the staff and the site will not be a problem.

The indirect impacts associated with the filling station not being constructed include:
     •    The alien vegetation on site will increase which will reduce the amount of surface water reaching the rivers
          and the ground water will be reduced by the large numbers of thirsty alien plants.
     •    The alien plants may also expand onto neighbouring land.
     •    Industries that provide goods, materials and services will not benefit from the construction. Resulting in
          further loss of income in the local economy.
     •    Local communities will need to drive into Empangeni for fuel.

Cumulative impacts:
   •    The cumulative impacts associated with not developing the site are loss of revenue in the local economy
        and the loss of jobs.



Indicate mitigation measures to manage the potential impacts listed above:

Alternative A1:
None.




     2.3. IMPACTS THAT MAY RESULT FROM THE OPERATIONAL PHASE

                a. Site alternatives

List the potential impacts associated with site alternatives that are likely to occur during the operational phase:
Alternative S1 (preferred alternative)
Direct impacts:
Soil & Groundwater Contamination
      •    Surface spillage of fuel
           Contamination of the soil, surface and ground water as a result of minor spillages during the tanker
           refuelling of the Underground Storage Tanks (UST’s) and fuel dispensing to vehicles on the fore court.
           Natural attenuation of fuel underground may remediate some of the spillages.
      •    Subsurface leaks (lines, tanks)
           Contamination of the groundwater, soil and bedrock. Due to the nature of the rock on site the excavation
           which will hold the UST’s is likely to have exceedingly low permeability. However if the tanks leak there is a
           possibility that the fuel would seep between the joints in the sandstone (Appendix D1).

Risks of Fires & Explosions
    •     Storage, handling and transport of fuel is potentially dangerous to humans and properties due to the risk of
          fire and explosions.

Visual Intrusion & Light Pollution
    •     Alteration of the site will alter the visual characteristics of the site and the surroundings.
    •     Littering, rubbish and illegal dumping on the site is visually intrusive.
    •     The buildings and advertising signs may be visually intrusive.
    •     Lights from the filling station may be visually intrusive.

Traffic
     •    Movement of vehicles to and from the filling station may increase traffic congestion.

Noise
    •     The noise emanating from the R34 is not expected to increase significantly in terms of the current noise
          levels.
     •    The noise generated by the diesel trucks idling and revving, and other vehicles braking and accelerating
          may increase. Empangeni Milling Pty (Ltd) has a fleet of trucks so the noise levels generated by other
          trucks utilising the filling station will not cause additional disruption.
     •    Noise from the filling station will include:
          o    Staff of the filling station talking and shouting may be disruptive late at night and on weekends.
          o    Music and radio broadcasts over the shop and forecourt speakers may be potentially disruptive.

Atmospheric Pollution & Odours
    •  Vapours produced by fuel (benzene) are potentially hazardous to human health. These emissions occur
       during the filling of UST’s, from the breather pipes, minor spillages and the dispensing of fuel.

Safety & Security
    •    Safety of staff, customers and property may be compromised as a result of the fire risk associated with a
         filling station as well by crime.

Hygiene
  Department of Agriculture,                    Basic Assessment Report 2010                       Page 34 of 46
 Environmental Affairs & Rural                     Version 2: August 2010
 Development, KwaZulu-Natal
                                              Basic Assessment Report


     •    Unhygienic conditions result in the transmission of diseases. Areas of potential concern include the
          ablutions, cooking areas, selling of food and standing water on the site.

Waste Generation & Disposal
    •   Waste has the potential to make the filling station look untidy, be unhygienic and polluted.

Socio-Economic
    •   The proposed development will lead to the increase and the level of local employment in the areas
        surrounding the development site. Both short-term and long-term employment will be created in this case.

Indirect impacts:
Traffic
     •    Traffic may result in increased traffic congestion on the R34.

Spread of Alien Vegetation
    •    Due to the disturbance of the site alien plants will be able to establish and could become a problem by
         infesting neighbouring land.

Socio Economic
    •   The proposed development will lead to the increase in the level of local employment in the areas
        surrounding the development site. Both short-term and long-term employment will be created in this case.
    •   The development will lead to the increase in the number of convenience facilities in the primary market
        area.

Safety & Security
    •    Safety of staff, customers, property and neighbouring properties may be compromised as a result of the fire
         risk associated with a filling station as well by crime.

Cumulative impacts:
Surface Water Pollution
    •    Spillages of oil, lubricants and fuel from vehicles as well as spillages resulting from the filling of UST’s and
         fuel dispensing has the potential to contaminate surface water. This surface water will flow into the
         drainage lines and the river to the north of the site. The wetland located along this river would become
         polluted. Flora and fauna in these areas where contamination occurs will die.

Increased run off of Water
     •   The increase in paved areas such as the roads and driveways and forecourt will increase the amount of
         stormwater runoff and thus reduce the infiltration of water into the groundwater. This may result in erosion
         of areas that are not paved.
     •   Stormwater run off has the potential to erode the topsoil and result in sedimentation on streams if not
         controlled.

Ground Water Pollution
    •   The construction phase will result in increased infiltration of contaminants into the ground water and soil.
    •   Spillages of oil, lubricants and fuel from vehicles as well as spillages resulting from the filling of UST’s and
        fuel dispensing has the potential to contaminate the soil and groundwater. Flora in these areas where
        contamination occurs will die.

Socio Economic
    •   The proposed development will lead to the increase the level local employment in the areas surrounding
        the development site. Both short-term and long-term employment will be created in this case.
    •   The development will lead to the increase in the number of convenience facilities in the primary market
        area.

Faunal Displacement
    •    The displacement of fauna as a result of an increase in ambient noises, vibrations is likely to remain even
         with mitigation.


Alternative S2 (if any)
Direct impacts:
Indirect impacts:
Cumulative impacts:

No-go alternative (compulsory)
Direct impacts:
The direct impacts associated with the filling station not being constructed include:
     •    An increase in the number of aliens plants on the site as well as the possible infestation of neighbouring
          properties.
     •    The security of the adjacent site [Empangeni Milling Pty (Ltd)] may be compromised by the vacant land
          adjacent. The grass cover becomes dense and high which is ideal cover for criminals.
     •    The decreased infiltration of stormwater as well as the increased run off of stormwater will still be a
          problem as the site is partially paved although there is extensive grass cover which has broken through the

  Department of Agriculture,                  Basic Assessment Report 2010                     Page 35 of 46
 Environmental Affairs & Rural                   Version 2: August 2010
 Development, KwaZulu-Natal
                                              Basic Assessment Report


          existing paving.
     •    No jobs will be created. Thus there will be a loss of income in the local economy.
     •    The company will not be able to increase profitability.

Indirect impacts:
Should the site not be developed the following indirect impacts associated with the construction phase will not occur:
     •    Increase in construction traffic volumes on the R34 and in Empangeni.
     •    The safety and security of the staff and the site will not be a problem.

The indirect impacts associated with the filling station not being constructed include:
     •    The alien vegetation on site will increase which will reduce the amount of surface water reaching the rivers
          and the ground water will be reduced by the large numbers of thirsty alien plants.
     •    The alien plants may also expand onto neighbouring land.
     •    Industries that provide goods, materials and services will not benefit from the construction. Resulting in
          further loss of income in the local economy.
     •    Local communities will need to drive into Empangeni for fuel.

Cumulative impacts:
The cumulative impacts associated with not developing the site are loss of revenue in the local economy and the loss
of jobs.



Indicate mitigation measures to manage the potential impacts listed above:
Alternative S1
Soil & Groundwater Contamination
Surface spillage of fuel
     •    Fuel dispenser pumps must be located on a hardened surface to contain spillages.
     •    The pump, refuelling and forecourt areas should all be located on a hardened surface which drains into a
          common drain. This drain must feed an onsite oil and water separator such as a Zorbit Grease Trap The
          accumulated grease and oil must be removed by an accredited company.
     •    Overfill and spillages during tanker refuelling and fuel dispensing should be prevented by the installation of
          automatic cut off devices.
     •    Tanker delivery driver must be present during delivery of fuel with the emergency cut off switch.
     •    In the event of the pump dispenser or the hoses being knocked over or ripped off the fuel supply must be
          cut off by shear off valves.
     •    Strict procedures for the management of the site must be developed and adhered to.
     •    Staff must be trained to prevent spillages during fuel dispensing.

Subsurface leaks (lines, tanks)
    •   Staff must be trained adequately so as to identify and minimise the impacts of leaks.
    •   Fuel stock must be monitored on a daily basis.
    •   The UST’s must comply with the relevant SANS standards with respect to tank manufacture and
        installation.
    •   UST’s must have corrosion protection.
    •   Cathodic protection will prevent corrosion in pipelines.
    •   Leak detectors with automatic cut off valves will be installed.
    •   UST’s must be insulated from the soil.
    •   A subsoil cut off drain should be installed in the lower boundary of the site to catch any shallow seepage of
        fuel through the sandy colluvium. The drain should be deep enough to bed 100 mm into the bedrock and
        linked to a sump that can pump out in the event of a spill. This drain must NOT be connected to the
        stormwater system. The sown slope side of the drain must be plastic lined (Appendix D1).
    •   Permanent groundwater monitoring wells will be installed at the base of the excavation on all four corners of
        the tank farm. These wells must be regularly monitored so that leakages can be picked up early. Any
        leakages are more than likely to migrate towards the north west of the site.
    •   The groundwater quality should be monitored monthly and the records kept on site.
    •   The quality of the water in the dam to the north west of the site should be monitored at the two sites
        measured by the Geotechnical and Hydrological study (Appendix D1). These records must be kept on site.
    •   Dipstick readings of all the fuel tanks must be taken daily. These records must be kept on site.
    •   If contamination or leakage is detected a rehabilitation plan must be compiled and executed.
    •   Fuel stocks must be reconciled on a monthly basis.
    •   The UST’s, underground pipes and dispensing pumps should be monitored regularly for leaks.
    •   Inform authorities of any leaks or spillages.

Risks of Fires & Explosions
    •     The design and construction of the filling station must conform to the following fire safety standards and
          legislation.
          SANS 10089 (Building Code)
          Hazardous Substances Act (Act No. 15 of 1973)
          Occupational Health and Safety Act (Act No 85 of 1956)
          Fire Services Act (Act 99 of 1956)
          National Building Regulations (Act 103 of 1977)

  Department of Agriculture,                 Basic Assessment Report 2010                      Page 36 of 46
 Environmental Affairs & Rural                  Version 2: August 2010
 Development, KwaZulu-Natal
                                               Basic Assessment Report


     •   Fire extinguishers must be easily accessible.
     •   The following signs must be installed in accordance with City of Umhlatuze’s Fire Department
         o           “NO SMOKING”
         o           “NO NAKED FLAME”
         o           “NO CELLPHONES”
     The UST’s, underground pipes and dispensing pumps should be monitored regularly for leaks.
     •   Staff must be trained adequately so as to identify and minimise the impacts of leaks and to deal with fires.
     •   Overfill and spillages during tanker refuelling and fuel dispensing should be prevented by the installation of
         automatic cut off devices.
     •   In the event of the pump dispenser or the hoses being knocked over or ripped off the fuel supply must be
         cut off by shear off valves.
     •   Tanker delivery driver must be present during delivery of fuel with the emergency cut off switch and a fire
         extinguisher.
     •   Fire fighting facilities must conform to the oil industry standard and be regularly inspected.
     •   The filling station management must develop an EMERGENCY PLAN. All staff must be adequately trained
         in the implementation of this plan.

Visual Intrusion & Light Pollution
    •     Light pollution should be minimised.
    •     Lighting on site is to be sufficient for safety and security purposes, but shall not be intrusive to neighbouring
          residents, disturb wildlife, or interfere with road traffic.
    •     Littering, rubbish and illegal dumping on the site is NOT allowed.
    •     Refuse must be contained and disposed of at the Municipal land fill site.
    •     Refuse bins must be provided. These must be sufficient in number (at the pumps, shop, fast food outlets
          and kitchen).
    •     The buildings may not be visually intrusive.
    •     The buildings must be regularly painted.
    •     All lights used for non-security purposes should be energy efficient for example compact fluorescent lights
          (CFL).
    •     Outside lights will have to be downward shining (eyelid type), low wattage and should not be positioned
          higher than 1 m above the ground surface.
    •     Fluorescent lamps give five times the light and last up to 10 times as long as ordinary bulbs.
    •     Signs must conform to the standards of South African Manual for Outdoor Advertising Control (SAMOAC).
    •     Areas that have been landscaped must be maintained.

Traffic
     •    The access, being on an important provincial route will need to meet certain criteria: It is recommended that
          a high standard of intersection be constructed with dedicated right turn lanes and edge tapers to a standard
          of at least that of a KZN DoT ‘Type B2’.
     •    Should the entrance to the site be security controlled this is to be positioned a minimum distance of 80m
          from the edge of the provincial road.
     •    On both R34 approaches to the proposed site intersection a high visibility W102 (priority crossroad sign)
          with information plate “heavy vehicles turning” is required. All signage and road markings for the proposed
          site intersection should be in accordance with the South African Road Traffic Signs Manual”.
     •    Road surfaces in the immediate vicinity of the site should be monitored. If the road is damaged the relevant
          authority must be notified.
     •    Advertising boards must not block the visibility of the R34 from the filling station access road.
     •    Access to and from the site must not impact on the traffic on the R34.
     •    Traffic must travel around the filling station in a one way circulation system.
     •    The speed limit on the forecourt should be limited to 5km/h.

Noise
    •     Noise levels shall be kept within acceptable limits, and forecourt staff must abide by National Noise Laws
          and local by-laws regarding noise.
     •    Equipment such as mechanical equipment, extraction fans, refrigerators that are fitted with noise reduction
          facilities (e.g. side flaps, silencers etc) must be used as per operating instructions and maintained properly.
     •    Noise levels should comply with the SANS Code of Practice 100103 – 0994 (recommended noise levels).

Atmospheric Pollution & Odours
    •  Research has shown that petrol attendants exposed to the emissions from a filling station have no
       additional health risks.
    •  Standard vents fitted to the breather pipes minimise the loss of vapours.
    •  Emissions from the filling station will be low level and thus disperse into the atmosphere.
    •  The emissions from the filling station would be dispersed according to the prevailing wind direction, with
       increased distance the concentration of the emitted particles will decrease.

Safety & Security
    •    Appropriate measures should be in place for the correct storage and handling of fuel as well as the
         procedures for dealing with dangerous situations.
    •    Staff should be adequately trained with respect to dealing with crime.
    •    Equipment and materials must be handled by staff that have been supervised and adequately trained.
    •    Staff must be regularly updated about the safety procedures.

  Department of Agriculture,                  Basic Assessment Report 2010                      Page 37 of 46
 Environmental Affairs & Rural                   Version 2: August 2010
 Development, KwaZulu-Natal
                                             Basic Assessment Report


     •    Emergency facilities must be available and adequately supplied for use by staff and customers.
     •    Emergency contact details for the police, security company and fire department must be readily available.

Hygiene
    •   Management policies and strategies must be in place to prevent unhygienic conditions developing.
    •   Kitchen and ablution facilities must be cleaned regularly.
    •   Food prepared in the kitchens must meet food hygiene standards, standard food handling by laws and
        municipal requirements.
    •   Care should be taken to adequately drain areas surrounding water points in order to avoid the development
        of pools of standing water, as tend to be a breeding source of flies, mosquitoes and other vectors.
    •   Paved areas, back yards, passages and service areas must be adequately graded, drained and paved to
        prevent water standing.

Waste Generation & Disposal
    •   Solid waste will be generated by the forecourt and the fast food outlet and will need to be collected at a
        central point. This waste will be disposed of as normal domestic waste at the municipal waste disposal site
        in Empangeni.
    •   The National Environmental Management: Waste Act (Act No. 59 of 2008) covers all aspects relating to
        waste management and must be adhered to at all times. Any other relevant legislation must also be
        adhered to.
    •   Waste management at the Filling Station shall be strictly controlled and monitored. Only approved waste
        disposal methods shall be allowed. Management of the Filling Station shall ensure that all personnel are
        instructed in the proper disposal of all waste.
    •   The management of the Filling Station is encouraged to participate in a recycling scheme. In this instance
        separate receptacles for the disposal of these recyclable materials could be positioned in the waste
        collection area. Sorting of the waste into organics, recyclable, hazardous and domestic waste should be
        undertaken at this point if possible. Staff training should be undertaken every six months to capacitate staff
        in terms of waste minimisation, waste disposal, recycling and other waste issues.
    •   NO burning, on-site burying or dumping of waste shall occur.
    •   Hazardous waste will only be produced during emergency situations such as a spill that has been cleaned
        up with an absorbent material. This will be disposed of at a registered hazardous landfill site. These
        materials may be removed by an appropriate hazardous waste Contractor. Proof of appropriate disposal
        must be obtained by the Contractor


               b. Process, technology, layout or other alternatives
List the impacts associated with process, technology, layout or other alternatives that are likely to occur during the
operational phase (please list impacts associated with each alternative separately):

Alternative A1 (preferred alternative)
Direct impacts:
     •    The development of a new borehole (location to be determined by a Geohydrologist) may result in over
          extraction of ground water.
     •    Rainwater and storm water runoff harvesting will augment the water supply but reduce the water available
          for infiltration into the ground water.
     •    Water conservation measures will augment the water supply and reduce consumption of future municipal
          water and/or borehole water.
     •    The use of materials and methods for dealing with leaks such as Drizit, Zorbit is dependant on the fuel
          supplier’s conditions and the filling station management.
     •    The alternatives for waste management and disposal will not impact on the site as all types of waste will be
          collected by a recognised waste contractor and disposed of at an appropriate facility.

Indirect impacts:
     •    None identified.

Cumulative impacts:
   •    The reduction in the utilisation of water on site will reduce the strain on the water resources in the
        Umhlatuze catchment.
   •    The reduction of waste on site will increase the waste entering the municipal and hazardous waste disposal
        system.

Alternative A2
Direct impacts:
Indirect impacts:
Cumulative impacts:

No-go alternative (compulsory)
Direct impacts:
The direct impacts associated with the filling station not being constructed include:
     •    An increase in the number of aliens plants on the site as well as the possible infestation of neighbouring
          properties.
     •    The security of the adjacent site [Empangeni Milling Pty (Ltd)] may be compromised by the vacant land
  Department of Agriculture,                 Basic Assessment Report 2010                    Page 38 of 46
 Environmental Affairs & Rural                  Version 2: August 2010
 Development, KwaZulu-Natal
                                               Basic Assessment Report


          adjacent. The grass cover becomes dense and high which is ideal cover for criminals.
     •    The decreased infiltration of stormwater as well as the increased run off of stormwater will still be a
          problem as the site is partially paved although there is extensive grass cover which has broken through the
          existing paving.
     •    No jobs will be created. Thus there will be a loss of income in the local economy.
     •    The company will not be able to increase profitability.

Indirect impacts:
Should the site not be developed the following indirect impacts associated with the construction phase will not occur:
     •    Increase in construction traffic volumes on the R34 and in Empangeni.
     •    The safety and security of the staff and the site will not be a problem.

The indirect impacts associated with the filling station not being constructed include:
     •    The alien vegetation on site will increase which will reduce the amount of surface water reaching the rivers
          and the ground water will be reduced by the large numbers of thirsty alien plants.
     •    The alien plants may also expand onto neighbouring land.
     •    Industries that provide goods, materials and services will not benefit from the construction. Resulting in
          further loss of income in the local economy.
     •    Local communities will need to drive into Empangeni for fuel.

Cumulative impacts:
   •    The cumulative impacts associated with not developing the site are loss of revenue in the local economy
        and the loss of jobs.

Indicate mitigation measures to manage the potential impacts listed above:
Alternative A1
     •    The water recycling system must be monitored and maintained on a regular basis
     •    Whichever method is used to clean up spills the sludge created must be disposed of by a registered waste
          contractor at a registered hazardous waste disposal facility.
     •    Waste must be reduced as much as possible. The management of the Filling Station is encouraged to
          participate in a recycling scheme. In this instance separate receptacles for the disposal of these recyclable
          materials could be positioned in the waste collection area. Sorting of the waste into organics, recyclable,
          hazardous and domestic waste should be undertaken at this point if possible. Staff training should be
          undertaken every six months to capacitate staff in terms of waste minimisation, waste disposal, recycling
          and other waste issues.
     •    NO burning, on-site burying or dumping of waste shall occur.




     2.4. IMPACTS THAT MAY RESULT FROM THE DECOMISSIONING OR CLOSURE
          PHASE

                a. Site alternatives

List the potential impacts associated with site alternatives that are likely to occur during the decommissioning or
closure phase:

Alternative S1 (preferred alternative)
Direct impacts:
The direct impacts associated with the decommissioning of the site are likely to be similar to the construction phase.
     •    Surface water pollution
     •    Soil & groundwater pollution during UST removal.
     •    Dust pollution
     •    Noise pollution
     •    Visual impact
     •    Fires and explosions may occur.
     •    Deep excavations to remove the UST’s are dangerous.

The demolition of buildings and the removal of all the fittings will result in waste that needs to be disposed of.

Indirect impacts:
The indirect impacts associated with the decommissioning of the site are likely to be similar to the construction
phase.
     •    Construction traffic
     •    Security
     •    Spread of alien vegetation

Socio Economic
    •   The decommissioning of the site will result in a loss of revenue for the local economy and the loss of jobs
        at the filling station. In the short term the decommissioning phase will create jobs for many sectors and
        people.
  Department of Agriculture,                   Basic Assessment Report 2010                      Page 39 of 46
 Environmental Affairs & Rural                    Version 2: August 2010
 Development, KwaZulu-Natal
                                              Basic Assessment Report



Cumulative impacts:
The cumulative impacts associated with the decommissioning of the site are likely to be similar to the construction
phase.
    •   Surface water pollution
    •   Increased run off of water
    •   Ground water pollution
    •   Socio Economic losses

Faunal Displacement
    •    The displacement of fauna as a result of an increase in ambient noises, vibrations is likely to remain even
         with mitigation. However if the site is returned to a state as close to the natural vegetation type of the area
         there is a possibility that fauna may migrate back over time.


Alternative S2
Direct impacts:
Indirect impacts:
Cumulative impacts:



No-go alternative (compulsory)
Direct impacts:
If decommissioning does not take place the UST’s may start to leak as they age as they have a limited life span this
would result in soil and ground water contamination.

Soil & Groundwater Contamination
     •   Surface spillage of fuel
         Contamination of the soil, surface and ground water as a result of minor spillages during the siphoning of
         the Underground Storage Tanks (UST’s) and fuel dispensing pumps on the forecourt.
     •   Natural attenuation of fuel underground may remediate some of the spillages.
     •   Subsurface leaks (lines, tanks)
         Contamination of the groundwater, soil and bedrock. Due to the nature of the rock on site the excavation
         which will hold the UST’s is likely to have exceedingly low permeability. However if the tanks leak there is a
         possibility that the fuel would seep between the joints in the sandstone (Appendix D1).

Risks of Fires & Explosions
    •     Storage, handling and transport of fuel is potentially dangerous to humans and properties due to the risk of
          fire and explosions.

Indirect impacts:
Spread of Alien Vegetation
     •    Due to the disturbance of the site alien plants will be able to establish and could become a problem and
          infest neighbouring land.

Safety & Security
    •    Safety of property and neighbouring properties may be compromised as a result of the fire risk associated
         with a filling station as well by crime.

Cumulative impacts:
Surface Water Pollution
    •    Spillages of oil, lubricants and fuel from construction vehicles, plant and machinery has the potential to
         contaminate surface water. This surface water will flow into the drainage lines and the river to the north of
         the site. The wetland located along this river would become polluted. Flora and fauna in these areas where
         contamination occurs will die.

Increased run off of Water
     •   The increase in paved areas such as the roads and driveways and forecourt will increase the amount of
         stormwater runoff and thus reduce the infiltration of water into the groundwater. This may result in erosion
         of areas that are not paved.
     •   Stormwater runoff has the potential to erode the topsoil and result in sedimentation on streams if not
         controlled.

Ground Water Pollution
    •   The decommissioning phase will result in increased infiltration of contaminants into the ground water and
        soil.
    •   The clearing of the site will result in exposed soil surfaces which may be prone to erosion, creation of dust
        and sedimentation of streams.
    •   Spillages of oil, lubricants and fuel from construction vehicles, plant and machinery has the potential to
        contaminate the soil and groundwater. Flora in these areas where contamination occurs will die.
    •   The storage of fuel and refuelling of construction vehicles during the decommissioning phase must be
        conducted so as to prevent contamination of the soil and groundwater.

  Department of Agriculture,                 Basic Assessment Report 2010                     Page 40 of 46
 Environmental Affairs & Rural                  Version 2: August 2010
 Development, KwaZulu-Natal
                                             Basic Assessment Report



Socio Economic
    •   The decommissioning will lead to the decrease in the level of local employment in the areas surrounding
        the site. Both short-term and long-term employment will be lost in this case.



Indicate mitigation measures to manage the potential impacts listed above:

Alternative S1
The site will only be decommissioned if it is no longer needed.
     •    Decommissioning should take place during the dry winter months.
     •    All the fuel must be removed from the UST’s and the site in sealed containers.
     •    Drained fuel must be transported back to the depot by an accredited transporter.
     •    Dismantling of equipment must be conducted by an accredited contractor.
     •    The sludge remaining in the UST’s must be disposed of at an accredited hazardous waste facility.
     •    Once the tanks and pipes have been degassed they can be cut up.
     •    The excavations where the UST’s and pipes were present must be surveyed for contamination. If
          contaminated they must be decontaminated.
     •    Deep excavations must be cordoned off prior to being back filled.
     •    Certificates must be obtained for all actions performed.
     •    Once the site has been filled it must be rehabilitated.



               b. Process, technology, layout or other alternatives
List the impacts associated with process, technology, layout or other alternatives that are likely to occur during the
decommissioning or closure phase (please list impacts associated with each alternative separately):
Alternative A1 (preferred alternative)
Direct impacts:
None

Indirect impacts:
None

Cumulative impacts:
None


Alternative A2
Direct impacts:
Indirect impacts:
Cumulative impacts:

No-go alternative (compulsory)
Direct impacts:
None

Indirect impacts:
None

Cumulative impacts:
None


Indicate mitigation measures to manage the potential impacts listed above:
Alternative A1
None


     2.5. PROPOSED MONITORING AND AUDITING
For each phase of the project and for each alternative, please indicate how identified impacts and mitigation will be
monitored and/or audited.
Alternative S1 (preferred site)
Environmental Management Programme (EMPr)
     •    The developer and the Contractors must sign that they have read and understand the EMPr.

Environmental Control Officer (ECO)
    •   An Independent Environmental Control Officer (ECO) must be appointed.
    •   The ECO is responsible for the implementation of the EMPr during the construction phase. The ECO’s
        responsibilities include the following:

  Department of Agriculture,                 Basic Assessment Report 2010                    Page 41 of 46
 Environmental Affairs & Rural                  Version 2: August 2010
 Development, KwaZulu-Natal
                                             Basic Assessment Report



1. Compliance Monitoring
Environmental monitoring of the construction of the proposed development will be undertaken by the ECO on a
weekly basis during the first month where after monthly audits will be conducted by the ECO. These audits can be
conducted randomly and do not require prior arrangement with the project manager. The ECO is responsible for the
compliance monitoring on the site, specifically:
     •   Undertaking routine monitoring and appointing a competent person/institution to be responsible for
         specialist monitoring, if necessary.
     •   Ensuring compliance with the EMPr, Environmental Authorisation and any other conditions which may be
         imposed from time to time.
     •   Compilation of an audit report with a rating of compliance with the EMP. This report will be submitted to the
         relevant authorities, the KZN Department of Agriculture and Environmental Affairs (DAEA).
     •   Reporting on any transgressions by the Contractor.
     •   Completing start-up, weekly, monthly and site closure checklists.
     •   Monitoring and verifying that environmental impacts are kept to a minimum.
     •   Monitoring the undertaking by the Contractor of environmental awareness training for all new personnel
         coming onto site.
     •   Monitoring the removal of person(s) and/or equipment not complying with the specifications.
     •   Ensuring that activities on site comply with legislation of relevance to the environment.
     •   Check that the Environmental Daily Checklists are filled out on a daily basis.
     •   Ensure that the Incident and Environmental Log are up to date and all incidences have been dealt with
         correctly and timeously.
     •   Ensure that the Environmental Complaints Register is up to date and all complaints have been dealt with
         correctly and timeously.
     •   Undertaking a continual internal review of the EMPr and submitting a report to the developer and the
         responsible KZN DAEA&RD Environmental Official at the end of the project.

2. EMPr Monitoring
The main objective of the EMPr is to ensure that the activities carried out during the various phases of the
development have a minimal NEGATIVE effect on the natural environment. It is therefore important to ensure that the
EMPr is reaching that objective. This can be done through various monitoring programs designed for such a purpose.
The ECO is responsible for these monitoring programmes.
     •    The EMPr must be continually monitored to determine its effectiveness and efficiency.
     •    Records of all activities discussed in the EMPr should be kept. These records should include any
          exceptions that may have been made (under permission of the ECO and appropriate authorities), problems
          that were experienced, methods used to rectify problems as well as the final outcome. This information can
          then be used to determine flaws in the EMPr. These flaws would be guidelines or recommendations that are
          ineffective and inefficient. They would then need to be removed or changed/adapted until they are effective
          and efficient.
     •    Records of non-compliance must be kept. These records must include details of the offence, offender and
          penalty.
     •    All aspects of the EMPr need to be monitored / audited to ensure compliance and in order to remedy any
          problems with either the implementation or interpretation of the EMPr. These audits will assist in
          streamlining methods to avoid future conflict situations.

3. Construction Planning
The ECO will be responsible for:
     •   Ensuring that Method Statement’s are submitted for the activities occurring on the site.
     •   Informing the Contractors of any decisions that are taken concerning the natural and social environment
         during the construction phase of the development.
     •   Informing the Contractors of the necessary corrective actions to be taken against employees transgressing
         the management activities stipulated in this EMPr.
     •   Liaison with Contractors regarding environmental management.
     •   Assisting the Contractor in finding environmentally responsible solutions to problems.

4. Method Statement (MS)
MS’s are to be completed by the person undertaking the work, the Contractor. The ECO will use the MS to audit
compliance by the Contractor with the requirements of the approved MS.

5. Site Handover
The ECO will attend the site handover meeting, where the EMPr will form part of the agenda. Key environmental
matters discussed at this meeting will be minuted and submitted as part of the environmental reporting. The
construction site layout plan is a key component of site handover and must be finalised before site handover can be
completed. The approved plan must be attached to the site handover meeting minutes. Amendments to this plan must
be discussed and approved at subsequent site meetings.

6. Site Inspections and Meetings
The ECO will conduct regular compliance inspections and must attend key site meetings. The EMPr will be an agenda
item of the monthly site meetings, and the responsible KZN DAEA&RD Environmental Official may attend these
meetings in order to provide input with respect to compliance with the EMPr. The ECO is responsible for:
      •    Giving a report back on the environmental issues at the monthly site meetings and other meetings that may
           be called regarding environmental matters.
      •    Visiting the site on a regular basis to determine whether compliance with the terms and conditions of the
  Department of Agriculture,                Basic Assessment Report 2010                    Page 42 of 46
 Environmental Affairs & Rural                 Version 2: August 2010
 Development, KwaZulu-Natal
                                             Basic Assessment Report


          Environmental Authorisation and the EMPr are being maintained.
     •    Inspecting the site and surrounding areas regularly with regard to compliance with the EMPr and will record
          the findings of the site inspection in a site inspection checklist, which will serve as the environmental
          compliance report.
     •    If any environmental matters occur at or in between the site meetings they must be reflected in written
          correspondence (email/fax/letter) directed or copied to the ECO. A copy of this correspondence must be
          placed in the environmental management files. Should it be deemed necessary the ECO must conduct a
          site visit and the matter must be recorded in the next inspection checklist.

7. Substantial Completion
The ECO will attend the substantial completion inspections.

8. Final Completion and Environmental Performance Certificate
Once the environmental items on the problem list have been addressed to the satisfaction of the ECO, the ECO will
provide written signoff confirming that the environmental specifications applicable to the Contractor(s) have been met.
This will be submitted to the Project Manager prior to the final Certificate of Completion being issued.




Alternative A1 (preferred alternative)
Same as Alternative S1



3.   ENVIRONMENTAL IMPACT STATEMENT

Taking the assessment of potential impacts into account, please provide an environmental
impact statement that summarises the impact that the proposed activity and its alternatives
may have on the environment after the management and mitigation of impacts have been
taken into account, with specific reference to types of impact, duration of impacts, likelihood of
potential impacts actually occurring and the significance of impacts.
Alternative S1 (preferred site)
The current site determination was made by the following facts:

Location
The applicant plans to use its own site, which is suitably located adjacent to the R34 for the
proposed purpose of a filling station. Alternative locations are currently not available, and
would thus involve lease or purchase of land / other sites. The suitability of the location has
been assessed in detail during the detailed BA Report, but based on the initial scoping the
proposed site is deemed suitable as a result of the following factors:
    • Existing footprint of use (tarred surface, sheds, fencing).
    • Disturbed area, difficult to rehabilitate to agricultural use.
    • Good location adjacent to the R34.
    • The site is adjacent to the developers other business Empangeni Milling Pty (Ltd).
    • The land is owned by the developer.

Infrastructure
    • There are no subterranean sewer lines, power cables, gas lines or other buried
        services located within the proposed site.

Road Access
   • The main entrance to the proposed site is from the R34 which is the main road
      between Eshowe and Empangeni. This access road will meet the Department of
      Transport safety standards and traffic requirements.

Engineering Requirements
   • The site is ideal for a filling station in that it is flat and thus requires little or no infill.
   • The only restrictions exist in the installation of the UST’s as the bedrock will need to
      be blasted to create a large enough excavation to bury the UST’s.

  Department of Agriculture,                 Basic Assessment Report 2010                    Page 43 of 46
 Environmental Affairs & Rural                  Version 2: August 2010
 Development, KwaZulu-Natal
                                     Basic Assessment Report


Socio-Economic
   • Many of the direct, indirect and accumulative impacts already discussed in this report
       will have a positive impact of significance on the local community.

ENVIRONMENTAL IMPACT STATEMENT

The construction phase has the greatest impact on the environment even with mitigation. The
negative impacts associated with the construction phase include:
   • Soil and Ground Water pollution
   • Surface Water Pollution
   • Increased run off of water
   • Visual Intrusion & Light Pollution
   • Destruction of Flora & Fauna
   • Construction traffic & access
   • Noise Pollution
   • Atmosphere pollution and odours resulting from dust and construction equipment
   • Safety & Security on the site
   • Hygiene
   • Spread of Alien Vegetation

The construction phase will be associated with positive socio-economic impacts in terms of
job creation. A number of mitigation measures to reduce or improve these impacts have been
identified and are presented in the tables above. A key environmental imperative of the
construction phase would be to prevent soil, air, water and noise pollution and erosion on the
site.

The negative impacts relating to the operational phase include the following:
   • Soil & Groundwater Contamination as a result of surface spillage of fuel and
       subsurface leaks (lines, tanks)
   • Risks of Fires & Explosions due to the storage and handling of fuel which is
       flammable and hazardous.
   • Visual Intrusion & Light Pollution
   • Movement of vehicles to and from the filling station my increase traffic congestion.
   • Noise pollution
   • Atmospheric pollution & odours as a result of emissions from the breather pipes,
       minor spillages and the dispensing of fuel. Safety of staff, customers and property
       may be compromised as a result of the fire risk associated with a filling station as well
       by crime.
   • Unhygienic conditions result in the transmission of diseases. Areas of potential
       concern include the ablutions, cooking areas, selling of food and standing water on
       the site.
   • Waste has the potential to make the filling station look untidy, be unhygienic and
       result in pollution.
   • Due to the disturbance of the site alien plants will be able to establish and could
       become a problem by infesting neighbouring land.

The primary positive impacts relate to the generation of a number of jobs. A number of
mitigation measure have been identified to reduce the potential negative impacts of spillages
of fuel, subsurface leaks of fuel, the fire and explosion risks

A number of cumulative negative impacts have been identified in the operational phase of the
proposed development, for example Surface Water Pollution; Increased run off of water,
Ground water pollution and Faunal Displacement. If the mitigation measures outlined in the
report are implemented the cumulative impacts should be nullified with the only exception
being the faunal displacement.

The construction phase will be of short duration and operational phase will have limited
environmental impacts if constructed according to the conditions outlined in this report and if
  Department of Agriculture,        Basic Assessment Report 2010           Page 44 of 46
 Environmental Affairs & Rural         Version 2: August 2010
 Development, KwaZulu-Natal
                                            Basic Assessment Report


managed according to the EMPr. Thus the proposed development is supported from an
environmental perspective.

Alternative S2



Alternative A1 (preferred alternative)
Same as Alternative S1
Alternative A2



No-go alternative (compulsory)
The positive socio-economic activities in terms of job creation would not occur.




SECTION F.                   RECOMMENDATION OF EAP
Is the information contained in this report and the documentation attached hereto in the view of   YES
the EAPr sufficient to make a decision in respect of this report?
If “NO”, please contact the KZN Department of Agriculture, Environmental Affairs and Rural
Development regarding the further requirements for your report.

If “YES”, please attach the draft EMPr as Appendix F to this report and list any recommended conditions, including
mitigation measures that should be considered for inclusion in any authorisation that may be granted by the
competent authority in respect of the application:
No specific conditions are recommended to be included in the authorization that may be
granted by the competent authority, other than specifying that all stipulations and
recommendations contained in the Environmental Management Programme (EMPr) be strictly
adhered to. See Appendix F.




  Department of Agriculture,                Basic Assessment Report 2010                   Page 45 of 46
 Environmental Affairs & Rural                 Version 2: August 2010
 Development, KwaZulu-Natal
                                              Basic Assessment Report




SECTION G: APPENDIXES
The following appendixes must be attached as appropriate:

Appendix A:        Site Plan and Locality Maps(s)

Appendix B:        Site Photographs

Appendix C:        Facility Illustration(s)

Appendix D:        Specialist Reports

                   Appendix D1:           Geotechnical Founding and Hydrogeological
                                          Assessment Report

                   Appendix D2:           Traffic Impact Study Report

                   Appendix D3:           Market Assessment and Socio-Economic
                                          Need and Desirability Assessment Report




  Department of Agriculture,                  Basic Assessment Report 2010            Page 46 of 46
 Environmental Affairs & Rural                   Version 2: August 2010
 Development, KwaZulu-Natal

								
To top