Docstoc

COMPARISON OF THE XENOPUS LAEVIS PREGNANCY TEST WITH AN

Document Sample
COMPARISON OF THE XENOPUS LAEVIS PREGNANCY TEST WITH AN Powered By Docstoc
					7 September 1963                   S.A.     TYDSKRIF           VIR   GENEESKUNDE                                         931

     COMPARISON OF THE XENOPUS LAEVIS PREGNANCY TEST WITH AN
        HAEMAGGLUTINATION INHIBITION (pREGNOSTICON) TEST *
       W. M. POLITZER, MD. and F. E. SIMPSON, South African Institute for Medical Research, Johannesburg

The present work deals with a study of the Xenopu5              TABLE   J. COMPARISON OF RESULTS OF Xenopus laevis TEST
laevis pregnancy test' carried out in parallel with a test                WITH HAEMAGGLUTINATION INHIBITION TEST
based on haemagglutination inhibition (HI). In this test
                                                                                  Xenopus laevis               HI test
the antigen is human chorionic gonadotrophin (HCG),
                                                                Number of            test results               results
and erythrocytes sensitized to HCG serve as antigen car-
riers. Addition of antiserum causes a variation in the sedi-    specimens      Positive    Negative    Positive      Negative
mentation pattern of the erythrocytes. In the presence of            43          43                       43
pregnancy urine containing HCG (1,000 IV/I. or more)
                                                                     57                      57                        57
sedimentation is prevented and a brown ring is formed
                                                                     12                      12           12
(positive result). In the absence of HCG, or when less than
1,000 IV / 1. are present, a homogeneous yellow-brown                 3            3                                    3
sediment remains (negative result).                                In 15 cases discrepancies in the results occurred. Follow-
                 MATERIAL   AND   METHODS                       up studies revealed the following data: in 12 cases giving
                                                                negative Xenopus laevis and positive HI test results, 7
One hundred and fifteen specimens of urine received by          were found to have normal pregnancies and one was a
this Institute for routine pregnancy tests were subjected       patient who died 2 weeks later of uraemia and hyperten-
to the Xenopus laevis test and to the HI test. The precipi-     sion; in this case examination per vaginam excluded preg-
tation method used for the Xenopus laevis test was that         nancy. In the remaining 4 cases (3 abortions and 1 ectopic
described by Scott,' each of 4 frogs being injected with 2·5    pregnancy) the negative Xenopus laevis and positive HI
m!. of extract corresponding to 50 rnI. of urine.               tests were both regarded as correct.
   The HI (pregnosticon) system is composed of:                    Of the 3 patients with positive Xenopus laevis and nega-
   (a) Antiserum from rabbits immunized with HCG. (In           tive HI test results, 2 were subsequently found to be preg-
the freeze-dried state this is stable for 12 months when        nant. The urine of the third patient gave a weak-positive
stored in the refrigerator.)                                    Xenopus laevis test result, i.e. lout of 4 frogs ovulated,
   (b) Erythrocytes sensitized to HCG.                          and this patient was found to be non-pregnant.
   (c) Suspension fluid for (b) which, when prepared, is           The accuracy of the results was as follows:
stable at 0 - 4°C. for 1 week.
   (d) Positive and negative control urine specimens sup-                                Xenopus laevis test        HI test
plied freeze-dried in vials.                                    Correct positive               87/,0                 96%
   All glassware used must be scrupulously clean, without       Correct negative               98%                   98/,0
the use of soaps and detergents.
   The method employed was as follows:                                                   DISCUSSION
4 m!. of suspension fluid was placed into the vial con-         To our knowledge, there have been no studies comparing
taining the erythrocytes sensitized to HCG, and shaken          the Xenopus laevis test with the HI (pregnosticon) test.
until a homogeneous suspension was obtained. After cen-            The only information available is that of Wide' who
trifugation 0'1 rnI. of urine was placed into the ampoule       carried out the HI in various dilutions on 2,701 urine
containing the freeze-dried antiserum, 1 rnI. of distilled      specimens from 1,012 women and obtained the following
water was placed into the vials containing the freeze-dried     accuracy: correct positive 99,8%, correct negative 99'8/'0'
positive and negative urine controls, and aliquots of 0·1       An interesting finding was that the urine of 15 women
mt. were treated in the same way as the test urine.             with early pregnancy, i.e. 31 - 37 days after the last men-
Finally, 0·4 m!. of homogeneous erythrocyte suspension          strual period, 8 gave positive results, I gave a negative
was added to the antiserum/urine solution in the original       and 6 gave doubtful results. In our study, 7 gave a posi-
ampoule.                                                        tive HI test result at a time when the Xenopus laevis test
   The ampoule was placed in a specially designed rack          was still negative, which indicates that the HI test is the
which was shaken for approximately I minute. The rack           more sensitive test. A further advantage of this test is its
was then left standing undisturbed at room temperature          simplicity, i.e. 40 tests can be set up and read in just over
in a position away from heaters, sunlight, and vibration.       1 hour.
Exactly 3 hours later the results were read and the pat-           All pregnancy tests depend on the detection of HCG
terns were interpreted as follows: positive result, a brown     in the urine, and besides diagnosing normal pregnancy,
ring at the bottom of the tube; negative result, the homo-      are of great value in.detecting conditions such as hydatidi-
geneous yellow-brown suspension remains.                        form mole, choriocarcinoma and malignant tumours of
                                                                the testis. Pituitary gonadotrophin may also give a posi-
                         RESULTS                                tive Xenopus laevis test result. In fact, in the Xenopus
The results are shown in Table I.                               laevis test on a non-pregnant patient who was 28 years
                                                                of age, lout of 4 frogs ovulated. Both pituitary and
  * This article was received too late for inclusion in the     chorionic gonadotrophin are glycoproteins, and although
supplement: South African Journal of Obstetrics and Gynae-
cology-hence its publication here-Editor.                       pituitary gonadotrophin differs chemically from the
932                                         S . A..   MED I C A L    J   0 URN A L                             7 September 1963

chorionic hormone, the two substances cannot be differ-                                      SUMMARY
entiated by means of immunological and biological pro-           The Xenopus laevis and the HI (pregnosticon) tests were
cedures. During menopause there is a higher excretion of         carried out on 115 specimens of urine submitted for preg-
pituitary gonadotrophin. In the HI test concentrated urine       nancy testing. The accuracy obtained was as follows:
is used, and a false positive result may be obtained. In
order to differentiate between amenorrhoea owing to                                       Xenopus laevis test        HI test
pregnancy and menopause, the manufacturers suggest               Correct positive                87%                   96%
diluting the urine with an equal amount of water which           Correct negative                98/"0                 98%
will lower the concentration of urinary pituitary gonado-          The HI test described is simple and rapid and the accu-
trophins sufficiently to render a negative result. The speci-    racy obtained compared favourably with the Xenopus
mens submitted to this Institute are not always accom-           laevis test.
panied by detailed information, and difficulty may be              We wish to thank the Director of the South African Insti-
encountered in establishing the age of the patient.              tute for Medical Research for permission to publish and the
                                                                 many gynaecologists and general practitioners for their assis-
  In 2 pregnant patients positive Xenopus laevis test re-        tance in follow-up studies. We also wish to thank Organon
sults were obtained with negative HI test results. As the        Laboratories Ltd., London, and their local agents, Keatings
                                                                 Pharmaceuticals Ltd., for the material supplied.
HI test is carried out in concentration only, sedimentation
                                                                                               REFERENCES
may have taken place owing to non-specific agglutinins,          I. Scat!, L. D. (1940): Brit. J. Exp. Path.. 21. 320.
but if dilutions had been carried out, sedimentation             2. Wide. L. (1962): Acta Endocr. (Kbh.), 41. suppl. 70.
                                                                 3. Shapiro, H. A. and Zwarenstein, H. (1933): Proc. Ray. Soc. S.A.,
might have been prevented and a positive result obtained.           October 1933 (see Trans. Ray. Soc. S.A., 1934, 22, LXXV).


                                   PASSING EVENTS: IN DIE VERBYGAAN
Dr. Kalman Ezekowitz, specialist anaesthetist, has commenced     Dr. Gerald M. Lurie, paediatrician, of Cape Town, has
practice at 1004 S.A. Mutual Buildings, Gardiner Street, Dur-    changed his residential address to 'Albatross', Blair Road,
ban. Telephones: Rooms 31-2660, residence 8-5272.                Camps Bay. Telephone 39-7348.
  Dr. Kalman Ezekowitz, narkotiseur, het begin praktiseer te                             *        *       '"
S.A. Mutual-gebou 1004, Gardinerstraat, Durban. Telefoon:        College of General Practitioners, Cape of Good Hope Faculty.
Spreekkamers 31-2660, woning 8-5272.                             A symposium on Asthma will be held at the Vineyard Hotel,
                                                                 Newlands, Cape, on Tuesday 1 October 1963, at 8.15 p.m. The
                       '"     *       *
Dr. B. Gentin, intemis, het begin praktiseer in vennootskap
                                                                 speakers will be Dr. Hendrik Muller, physician, Dr. S. C.
                                                                 Shore, paediatrician, Dr. A. W. Spratt, general practitioner,
met dr. T. G. Armstrong te Norwich Union House 403,              and Dr. N. V. Storr, allergist. The talks will be followed by
Smithstraat, Durban. Telefoon: Spreekkamer 2-8328, woning        an open discussion and refreshments will be served. The
2-6912.                                                          meeting is being sponsored by Warner Pharmaceuticals and
  Dr. B. Gentin, specialist physician, has commenced practice    all doctors are cordially invited to attend.
in partnership with Dr. T. G. Armstrong at 403 Norwich
Union House, Smith Street, Durban. Telephones: Rooms                                     *        *       *
                                                                 Society for the Promotion of Undergraduate Research. A
2-8328, residence 2-6912.                                        meeting of the ucr Medical School Society for the Promo-
                       *      *       *                          tion of Undergraduate Research (SPUR) will be held on Mon-
South African Paediatric Association (M.A.S.A.), Natal Sub-      day 9 September at 8 p.m. in the Pharmacology Lecture
group. The next meeting of this Subgroup will be held on         Theatre, Medical School, Observatory, Cape. The following
Tuesday 10 September 1963 at 8 p.m. in the Medical School,       student papers will be read: 'Myasthenia gravis and the
Durban. Dr. N. M. Mann will speak: on his recent travels in      thymus', by E. J. Coetzee; and 'Art in psychiatry', by I. N.
the USA and some problems of the newborn.                        Bernadt. All interested persons will be welcome at the meeting.

                            INTERNATIONAL CONFERENCE ON THE PORPHYRIAS
An International Conference on the Porphyrias will take             Dr. Allan G. Redeker, School of Medicine, University of
place in Cape Town at the Department of Medicine, Medical        Southern California, Los Angeles.
School, University of Cape Town, from 18 - 20 September             Dr. A. Magnus, Institute of Dermatology, St. John's Hos-
1963. A visit will also be paid to the Karl Bremer Hospital      pital for Diseases of the Skin, London.
on 21 September. The Conference is sponsored by the Coun-           Dr. Birgitta Haeger-Aronson, Department of Clinical
cil for Scientific and Industrial Research, and the Conference   Chemistry, Malmo General Hospital, University of Lund,
proceedings will be opened by Prof. D. Craib, Associate Ad-      Malmo, Sweden.
viser in Medical Research to the CSIR.
   In addition to a number of South African workers on the          Attendance at this Conference is by invitation.
porphyrias, the following overseas visitors, all of whom are        After the Conference in Cape Town the overseas visitors
experts in this field, will be attending:                        will leave on 21 September for visits to the medical schools at
   Prof. C. Rimington, Professor of Chemical Pathology, Uni-     Durban, and later Johannesburg and Pretoria, and also to
versity of London, University College Hospital Medical           the Onderstepoort Veterinary Institute.
School, London.                                                    The purpose of this Conference is:
   Dr. A. Goldberg, Senior Lecturer in Medicine, University         1. To study the porphyrias as seen in South Africa, which
Department of Medicine, Gardiner Institute, Western Infir-       has the unenviable distinction of having the highest incidence
mary, Glasgow.                                                   of porphyrias in the world;
   Dr. H. D. Barnes, Department of Chemical Pathology, St.
Mary's Hospital, London.                                            2. To discuss the research work done in this field at the
   Dr. A. M. Gajdos and Madame Gajdos-Torok, Department          various medical schools; and
of Medicine, Hotel-Dieu, Paris.                                     3. To come to some agreement if possible on the classifi-
   Prof. R. Schmid, Department of Medicine, University of        cation and nomenclature of the porphyrias. Other controver-
Chicago.                                                         sial matters will also be discussed.

				
DOCUMENT INFO
Shared By:
Categories:
Tags:
Stats:
views:36
posted:2/16/2011
language:Afrikaans
pages:2