NORTH SHORE CITY DISTRICT PLAN PROPOSED PLAN CHANGE 15 This is a Private Plan Change Re zone sites close to the intersection of Greville Road Hugh Green Drive Albany SUMMARY OF SUBMISSIONS by skatzz

VIEWS: 0 PAGES: 26

									 NORTH SHORE CITY DISTRICT PLAN




            PROPOSED PLAN CHANGE 15
             This is a Private Plan Change

Re-zone sites close to the intersection of Greville Road
             & Hugh Green Drive, Albany




     SUMMARY OF SUBMISSIONS




Enclosed:

  • Explanation
  • Public Notice
  • Summary of Submissions
Explanation


• You may make a “further submission” to support or
  oppose any submission already received (see
  summaries that follow).
• You should use Form 6.
• Your further submission must be received by Friday 13
  July 2007
• Send a copy of your further submission to the original
  submitter as soon as possible after submitting it to the
  Council.
The Resource Management Act 1991
North Shore City District Plan

Public Notice of:

Summary of Submissions received by North Shore City Council to
Proposed Private Plan Change 15 - Re-zone sites close to the
intersection of Greville Road & Hugh Green Drive, Albany

Proposed Private Plan Change 15 was publicly notified on 16 February 2006,
and the submission period closed on 17 March 2006.

Under Clause 8(d) of the First Schedule of the Resource Management Act
1991 the applicant has resolved to withdraw the part known as Area C from
the Plan Change. The reason for the withdrawal is that the applicant has sold
the part of Area C that it owned at the time the plan change was publicly
notified.

Summaries of the submissions received on Private Plan Change 15 are now
available. The summaries, and a copy of the original submissions, may be
inspected at North Shore libraries and the Council’s offices located at the
following locations:

Head Office, Takapuna                 1 The Strand, Takapuna, Level 2
(Strategy & Policy)
Area Office, Takapuna                 1 The Strand, Takapuna
Environmental Services, Takapuna      521 Lake Road, Takapuna, Level 1
Birkenhead                     33 Rawene Road, Birkenhead
Glenfield                      90 Bentley Avenue, Glenfield
Devonport                      3 Victoria Road, Devonport
East Coast Bays                Corner of Bute & Glen Roads, Browns Bay
Albany                                30 Kell Drive, Albany

Any organisation or person may make a further written submission opposing or
supporting all, or any part of, the submissions already received, and must
follow the format set out in the Resource Management Act 1991 (Form 6).
These forms are available at the Council offices listed above and on the
website at www.northshorecity.govt.nz. They must be lodged with North Shore
City Council, The Strand, Private Bag 93-500, Takapuna, North Shore City,
from Thursday 14 June 2007, and no later than 5.00 pm on Friday 13 July
2007.

Following the close of further submissions, reports will be prepared on the plan
change and a hearing date will be set and notified to all submitters.

Dated at Takapuna 14 June 2007.


John Brockies
CHIEF EXECUTIVE
Summary of Submissions
                                                APPENDIX 1                                                    Plan Change: 15
Re-zone sites close to the intersection of Greville Road & Hugh Green Drive, Albany (Private)
Submitters Numbers, Names and Addresses, Summary of Relief Sought and Key Issues
Submitter     Robert Andrews North Shore City Council
              Private Bag 93500, Takapuna North Shore City
83-1          Area A Support the change of the Business 2 zone to Business 9 subject to additional restrictions and oppose the rezoning of
              4a to Business 9 and as an alternative seek rezoning of this land to Business 7B.
Key Issues: § Adverse effect - residential amenity    § Inappropriate proposed zoning    § Adverse effects – topography        § Section 32
            analysis insufficient / inaccurate

83-2          Area B Change the 4A zone to Residential 7 subject to more detailed development rules.

Key Issues:

Submitter     Ross James Angus
              PO Box 65-138, Mairangi Bay North Shore City
84-1          Area A, B To refuse the application. Retain status quo.

Key Issues: § Adverse effect - residential amenity

Submitter     Fergus Gammie Auckland Regional Transport Authority
              Private Bag 92 236, North Shore City
85-1          Area A, B Support change of zoning subject to undertaking of structure plan and comprehensive transport audit.

Key Issues: § Adverse traffic effects

Submitter     Raymond Bagley
              12 Bundoran Way, Pinehill North Shore City
86-1          Area A, B To refuse the application. Retain status quo.

Key Issues: § Adverse effect - residential amenity § Adverse effect – visual amenity and urban design      § Insufficient and/or inaccurate
            information § Inappropriate proposed zoning § Adverse traffic effects

Submitter     Shane Donald Bagnall
              20 Glen Bay Close, Pinehill Albany North Shore City
87-1          Area A, B To refuse the application. Retain status quo.

Key Issues: § Insufficient and/or inaccurate information § Section 32 analysis insufficient / inaccurate § Adverse effect - residential
            amenity § Inappropriate proposed zoning § Adverse traffic effects § Decrease in property values

Submitter     Irina Blay
              20 Rosses Place, Albany North Shore City
90-1          Area A, B To refuse the application. Retain status quo.

Key Issues: § Adverse traffic effects   § Inappropriate proposed zoning

Submitter     Barbara and Gordon Bold
              18A Spencer Road, Browns Bay North Shore City
91-1          Area A, B To refuse the application. Retain status quo.

Key Issues: § Insufficient and/or inaccurate information § Section 32 analysis insufficient / inaccurate § Inappropriate proposed
            zoning § Adverse traffic effects § Adverse effect – visual amenity and urban design § Adverse effect - residential
            amenity § Decrease in property values

Submitter     Chris Booth
              10 Bundoran Way, Pinehill North Shore City
92-1          Area A, B To refuse the application. Retain status quo.

Key Issues: § Adverse effect - residential amenity § Insufficient and/or inaccurate information    § Adverse traffic effects     § Adverse
            effects on schools § Decrease in property values




                                                                                                                                  Page 1
Submitters Numbers, Names and Addresses, Summary of Relief Sought and Key Issues
Submitter     Mitchel Booth
              23 Malin Place, Pinehill North Shore City
93-1          Area A, B To refuse the application. Retain status quo.

Key Issues: § Adverse traffic effects    § Adverse effect - residential amenity   § Decrease in property values

Submitter     Joanna Bosman
              28 Ballymore Drive, Pinehill North Shore City
94-1          Area A, B Change the zones to recreational reserves.

Key Issues: § Inappropriate proposed zoning § Adverse traffic effects § Adverse effect – visual amenity and urban design            §
            Adverse effect - residential amenity § Insufficient and/or inaccurate information

Submitter     Paul Brown
              26 Bundoran Way, Pinehill North Shore City
95-1          Area A, B To refuse the application. Retain status quo.

Key Issues: § Adverse effect - residential amenity    § Adverse traffic effects   § Adverse effects on schools

Submitter     Neil and Maria Buckner
              36 Hugh Green Drive, Pinehill North Shore City
96-1          Area A, B To refuse the application. Retain status quo.

Key Issues: § Adverse effect - residential amenity    § Insufficient and/or inaccurate information,   § Adverse traffic effects   § Decrease
            in property values

Submitter     S M Buckner
              36A Hugh Green Drive, Albany North Shore City
97-1          Area A, B Low density and low height development.

Key Issues: § Adverse effect - residential amenity

Submitter     Stephen Burnett
              10 Ballintra Close, Pinehill North Shore City
98-1          Area A, B Due Diligence and provide more information, and council decide what is best.

Key Issues: § Insufficient and/or inaccurate information § Decrease in property values § Adverse effect - residential amenity §
            Adverse traffic effects § Adverse effects on schools § Safety and wellbeing of people § Adverse effect – visual amenity
            and urban design

Submitter     Paula and Nigel Carroll
              30 Ballymore Drive, Albany North Shore City
99-1          Area A, B To refuse the application. Retain status quo.

Key Issues: § Adverse effect - residential amenity    § Adverse effects on schools     § Safety and wellbeing of people     § Adverse traffic
            effects

Submitter     John Carter CDL Land NZ Ltd C/- CKL Surveys Ltd
              PO Box 99463, Newmarket AUCKLAND
100-1         Area A, B Conditional support. Storm water attended to.

Key Issues:

Submitter     Y M Cheah Décor Concept Ltd
              32 Ballymore Drive, Albany North Shore City
101-1         Area A, B To refuse the application. Retain status quo.

Key Issues: § Adverse effect - residential amenity § Adverse traffic effects § Insufficient and/or inaccurate information § Section 32
            analysis insufficient / inaccurate § Inappropriate proposed zoning § Adverse effect – visual amenity and urban design §
            Decrease in property values




Page 2
Submitters Numbers, Names and Addresses, Summary of Relief Sought and Key Issues
Submitter    Ching Yau Chua
             29 Ballymore Drive, Albany North Shore City
103-1        Area A, B To refuse the application. Retain status quo.

Key Issues: § Adverse traffic effects   § Adverse effects on schools    § Adverse effect – visual amenity and urban design

Submitter    Gary and Heather Clark
             11 Te Hoe Grove, Browns Bay North Shore City
105-1        Area A, B To refuse the application. Retain status quo.

Key Issues: § Adverse effect - residential amenity   § Insufficient and/or inaccurate information    § Adverse traffic effects   §
            Inappropriate proposed zoning

Submitter    Brian Coburn
             c/- Hesketh Henry, Private Bag 92093 AUCKLAND
104-1        Area A, B To refuse the application. Retain status quo.

Key Issues: § Adverse effect - residential amenity   § Adverse traffic effects   § Noise pollution

Submitter    Myma Copplestone
             15 Rosses Place, Pinehill North Shore City
106-1        Area A, B To refuse the application. Retain status quo.

Key Issues: § Adverse traffic effects   § Adverse effect - residential amenity

Submitter    Zuo Qun Cui
             126 Killybegs Drive, Pinehill North Shore City
107-1        Area A, B To refuse the application. Retain status quo.

Key Issues: § Adverse effect - residential amenity § Adverse traffic effects § Insufficient and/or inaccurate information § Section 32
            analysis insufficient / inaccurate § Inappropriate proposed zoning § Adverse effect – visual amenity and urban design §
            Decrease in property values

Submitter    Garry Dean
             3 Manu Place, Pinehill North Shore City
108-1        Area A, B To refuse the application. Retain status quo.

Key Issues: § Insufficient and/or inaccurate information § Adverse effect - residential amenity § Inappropriate proposed zoning               §
            Adverse effects on schools § Adverse traffic effects § Decrease in property values

Submitter    Bruce Devonport
             16 Te Hoe Grove, Pinehill North Shore City
109-1        Area A, B To refuse the application. Retain status quo.

Key Issues: § Adverse traffic effects

Submitter    Glendon Keith Edwards
             31 Hugh Green Drive, Pinehill North Shore City
122-1        Area A, B To refuse the application. Retain status quo.

Key Issues: § Inappropriate proposed zoning § Decrease in property values         § Adverse effect - residential amenity    § Insufficient
            and/or inaccurate information § Adverse traffic effects

Submitter    Hala El Attar
             86 Hugh Green Drive, Pine Hill Albany North Shore City
110-1        Area A, B To refuse the application. Retain status quo.

Key Issues: § Adverse traffic effects § Adverse effect - residential amenity     § Inappropriate proposed zoning      § Adverse effect –
            visual amenity and urban design

Submitter    Osama Elbettagi
             86 Hugh Green Drive, Pinehill Albany North Shore City
112-1        Area A, B To refuse the application. Retain status quo.

Key Issues: § Adverse traffic effects § Adverse effect - residential amenity     § Inappropriate proposed zoning      § Adverse effect –
            visual amenity and urban design

                                                                                                                                     Page 3
Submitters Numbers, Names and Addresses, Summary of Relief Sought and Key Issues
Submitter     Charles T Elliott and Sheila Elliott
              23 Hauraki Crescent, Browns Bay North Shore City
111-1         Area A, B The council to take the matter seriously.

Key Issues: § Adverse traffic effects

Submitter     David Evans
              4 Northcross Drive, Albany North Shore City
113-1         Area A, B To refuse the application. Retain status quo.

Key Issues: § Adverse effect - residential amenity     § Adverse traffic effects   § Inappropriate proposed zoning

Submitter     Ngaire Evans
              4 Northcross Drive, Albany North Shore City
114-1         Area A, B To refuse the application. Retain status quo.

Key Issues: § Adverse effect - residential amenity     § Adverse traffic effects   § Inappropriate proposed zoning

Submitter     G C and B E Ganley
              13 Manu Place, Pinehill North Shore City
115-1         Area A, B To refuse the application. Retain status quo.

Key Issues: § Adverse effect - residential amenity § Adverse traffic effects § Insufficient and/or inaccurate information § Section 32
            analysis insufficient / inaccurate § Inappropriate proposed zoning § Adverse effect – visual amenity and urban design §
            Decrease in property values

Submitter     Shane Gerraty
              18 Te Hoe Grove, Pinehill North Shore City
116-1         Area A, B To refuse the application. Retain status quo.

Key Issues: § Adverse traffic effects     § Adverse effect - residential amenity   § Inappropriate proposed zoning

Submitter     Hendrika Giljam
              26 Bundoran Way, Pinehill North Shore City
121-1         Area A, B To refuse the application. Retain status quo.

Key Issues: § Adverse traffic effects     § Adverse effect - residential amenity   § Adverse effect – visual amenity and urban design

Submitter     Jennie Giljam
              26 Bundoran Way, Pinehill North Shore City
117-1         Area A, B To refuse the application. Retain status quo.

Key Issues: § Adverse effect - residential amenity     § Adverse traffic effects   § Adverse effect – visual amenity and urban design

Submitter     Bruce Gregory
              2/6 Arirang Rise, Pinehill North Shore City
118-1         Area A, B To refuse the application. Retain status quo.

Key Issues: § Insufficient and/or inaccurate information § Section 32 analysis insufficient / inaccurate § Inappropriate proposed
            zoning § Adverse effect - residential amenity § Adverse effect – visual amenity and urban design

Submitter     Shirley (Shuhua) Zhou and Wayne (Weihei) Hao
              28 Glen Bay Close, Pinehill North Shore City
29-1          Area A, B To refuse the application. Retain status quo.

Key Issues: § Insufficient and/or inaccurate information § Adverse traffic effects § Inappropriate proposed zoning § Section 32
            analysis insufficient / inaccurate § Adverse effect - residential amenity § Decrease in property values § Adverse effect –
            visual amenity and urban design

Submitter     Colin Harrison
              5 Buncrana Place, Browns Bay North Shore City
119-1         Area A, B To refuse the application. Retain status quo.

Key Issues: § Adverse traffic effects § Insufficient and/or inaccurate information      § Adverse effect - residential amenity   § Decrease
            in property values § Inappropriate proposed zoning

Page 4
Submitters Numbers, Names and Addresses, Summary of Relief Sought and Key Issues
Submitter     Lavinia Margaret Haverfield
              2/6 Arirang Rise, Pinehill North Shore City
120-1         Area A, B To refuse the application. Retain status quo.

Key Issues: § Insufficient and/or inaccurate information § Section 32 analysis insufficient / inaccurate § Adverse effect - residential
            amenity § Inappropriate proposed zoning § Adverse traffic effects § Adverse effect – visual amenity and urban design

Submitter     Gabrielle Hessell
              29 Manu Place, Pinehill North Shore City
20-1          Area A, B To refuse the application. Retain status quo.

Key Issues: § Adverse traffic effects § Insufficient and/or inaccurate information § Adverse effect – visual amenity and urban design
            § Adverse effects on schools § Section 32 analysis insufficient / inaccurate § Decrease in property values §
            Inappropriate proposed zoning

Submitter     Maika Hohua
              25 Ballymore Drive, Pinehill North Shore City
31-1          Area A To refuse the application. Retain status quo.

Key Issues: § Adverse traffic effects    § Safety and wellbeing of people    § Inappropriate proposed zoning        § Noise pollution

32-1          Area B To refuse the application. Retain status quo.

Key Issues: § Adverse traffic effects    § Safety and wellbeing of people    § Decrease in property values

Submitter     Marcel Q Hohua
              25 Ballymore Drive, Pinehill North Shore City
33-1          Area A To refuse the application. Retain status quo.

Key Issues: § Adverse traffic effects    § Safety and wellbeing of people    § Inappropriate proposed zoning        § Noise pollution

34-1          Area B To refuse the application. Retain status quo.

Key Issues: § Adverse traffic effects    § Safety and wellbeing of people    § Decrease in property values

Submitter     C Bailey and T Jennett
              8 Buncrana Place, Pinehill Albany North Shore City
88-1          Area A To refuse the application. Retain status quo.

Key Issues: § Adverse effect - residential amenity     § Adverse traffic effects

89-1          Area B To refuse the application. Retain status quo.

Key Issues: § Adverse traffic effects    § Decrease in property values     § Adverse effect - residential amenity

Submitter     Susan Jeram
              7 Ballintra Close, Pinehill North Shore City
35-1          Area A, B To refuse the application.

Key Issues: § Adverse traffic effects § Inappropriate proposed zoning § Insufficient and/or inaccurate information           § Decrease in
            property values § Adverse effect - residential amenity § Adverse effects on schools

Submitter     Paul and Carolyn Johnson
              6 Bundoran Way, Pinehill North Shore City
36-1          Area A, B To refuse the application.

Key Issues: § Adverse traffic effects § Adverse effects on schools § Adverse effect - residential amenity § Section 32 analysis
            insufficient / inaccurate § Inappropriate proposed zoning § Insufficient and/or inaccurate information

Submitter     R Kenyon
              4A Arirang Drive, Albany North Shore City
37-1          Area A, B To refuse the application. Retain status quo.

Key Issues: § Adverse traffic effects    § Decrease in property values     § Adverse effect - residential amenity




                                                                                                                                   Page 5
Submitters Numbers, Names and Addresses, Summary of Relief Sought and Key Issues
Submitter     Brian Kerr
              40 Hugh Green Drive, Albany North Shore City
38-1          Area A, B To refuse the application. Retain status quo.

Key Issues: § Insufficient and/or inaccurate information § Noise pollution § Adverse traffic effects § Adverse effects on schools                 §
            Safety and wellbeing of people § Decrease in property values § Adverse effect - residential amenity

Submitter     Melissa Kerr
              40 Hugh Green Drive, Albany North Shore City
39-1          Area A, B To refuse the application. Retain status quo.

Key Issues: § Adverse traffic effects   § Adverse effect - residential amenity

Submitter     Steve Kerr
              40 Hugh Green Drive, Albany North Shore City
40-1          Area A, B To refuse the application. Retain status quo.

Key Issues: § Adverse effect - residential amenity    § Adverse traffic effects   § Adverse pollution effects     § Decrease in property values

Submitter     Tui Kerr
              40 Hugh Green Drive, Pinehill North Shore City
41-1          Area A, B To refuse the application. Retain status quo.

Key Issues: § Insufficient and/or inaccurate information     § Adverse effect - residential amenity   § Inappropriate proposed zoning         §
            Adverse traffic effects,

Submitter     Kelly Wendelborn Kindercare Learning Centres Ltd C/- Steven Havill, SFH Consultants Ltd
              PO Box 31 280, Milford North Shore City
42-1          That no decisions are made as regards Areas A and B which will impact on Kindercare's operation.

Key Issues: § Inappropriate proposed zoning § Adverse effect - residential amenity § Adverse traffic effects            § Adverse effect –
            visual amenity and urban design § Insufficient and/or inaccurate information

Submitter     Alan King
              10 Hugh Green Drive, Albany North Shore City
77-1          Area A, B To refuse the application. Retain status quo.

Key Issues: § Inappropriate proposed zoning      § Adverse effect - residential amenity

Submitter     Sandra Louw and Julian Koelewijn
              PO Box 35711, Browns Bay North Shore City
50-1          Area A, B To refuse the application. Retain status quo.

Key Issues: § Inappropriate proposed zoning § Adverse traffic effects        § Adverse pollution effects     § Insufficient and/or inaccurate
            information § Adverse effect - residential amenity

Submitter     Nick Krajancic
              14A Bundoran Way, Browns Bay North Shore City
81-1          Area A, B To refuse the application. Retain status quo.

Key Issues: § Adverse traffic effects   § Adverse effects on schools      § Safety and wellbeing of people      § Adverse effect - residential
            amenity

Submitter     Jonathan J W Kwak
              3 Carrigans Close, Pinehill North Shore City
78-1          Area A, B To refuse the application. Retain status quo.

Key Issues: § Adverse traffic effects § Adverse pollution effects       § Inappropriate proposed zoning      § Adverse effect - residential
            amenity § Insufficient and/or inaccurate information

Submitter     Ashvin Ladwa
              8A Hugh Green Drive, Pinehill North Shore City
79-1          Area A, B To refuse the application. Retain status quo.

Key Issues: § Adverse traffic effects   § Adverse effect - residential amenity    § Inappropriate proposed zoning


Page 6
Submitters Numbers, Names and Addresses, Summary of Relief Sought and Key Issues
Submitter     Lynda Lamb
              8b Bundoran Way, Pinehill North Shore City
80-1          Area A, B To refuse the application. Retain status quo.

Key Issues: § Adverse traffic effects § Adverse effects on schools § Insufficient and/or inaccurate information § Adverse effect –
            visual amenity and urban design § Section 32 analysis insufficient / inaccurate § Inappropriate proposed zoning §
            Adverse effect - residential amenity

Submitter     Simon Lamb
              8b Bundoran Way, Pinehill North Shore City
43-1          Area A, B To refuse the application. Retain status quo.

Key Issues: § Adverse traffic effects § Adverse effects on schools § Insufficient and/or inaccurate information § Adverse effect –
            visual amenity and urban design § Section 32 analysis insufficient / inaccurate § Inappropriate proposed zoning §
            Adverse effect - residential amenity

Submitter     Darryn Laskey
              103 Hugh Green Drive, Albany North Shore City
123-1         Area A, B To refuse the application. Retain status quo.

Key Issues: § Adverse traffic effects § Insufficient and/or inaccurate information   § Adverse effect - residential amenity   § Decrease
            in property values § Inappropriate proposed zoning

Submitter     Joshua Laskey
              103 Hugh Green Drive, Albany North Shore City
30-1          Area A, B To refuse the application. Retain status quo.

Key Issues: § Adverse traffic effects § Insufficient and/or inaccurate information   § Adverse effect - residential amenity   § Decrease
            in property values § Inappropriate proposed zoning

Submitter     Natasha Laskey
              103 Hugh Green Drive, Albany North Shore City
44-1          Area A, B To refuse the application. Retain status quo.

Key Issues: § Insufficient and/or inaccurate information § Section 32 analysis insufficient / inaccurate   § Adverse effect - residential
            amenity § Inappropriate proposed zoning § Adverse traffic effects

Submitter     Mr Man Bo Lau
              72 Crestview Place, Browns Bay North Shore City
45-1          Area A, B To refuse the application. Retain status quo.

Key Issues: § Adverse effect - residential amenity    § Adverse traffic effects

Submitter     Hayley Law
              6 Buncrana Place, Pinehill North Shore City
46-1          Area A, B To refuse the application. Retain status quo.

Key Issues: § Insufficient and/or inaccurate information § Section 32 analysis insufficient / inaccurate § Inappropriate proposed
            zoning § Adverse traffic effects § Adverse effect - residential amenity § Adverse effect – visual amenity and urban
            design

Submitter     Robert Law
              6 Buncrana Place, Pinehill North Shore City
47-1          Area A, B To refuse the application. Retain status quo.

Key Issues: § Insufficient and/or inaccurate information § Section 32 analysis insufficient / inaccurate § Inappropriate proposed
            zoning § Adverse traffic effects § Adverse effect - residential amenity § Adverse effect – visual amenity and urban
            design

Submitter     Li Hwan Cho and Hyang Ae Lee
              33 Killybegs Drive, Albany North Shore City
102-1         Area A, B To refuse the application. Retain status quo.

Key Issues: § Adverse effect - residential amenity    § Adverse effects on schools   § Inappropriate proposed zoning




                                                                                                                               Page 7
Submitters Numbers, Names and Addresses, Summary of Relief Sought and Key Issues
Submitter     Sung Je Lee
              2 Buncrana Place, Pinehill North Shore City
48-1          Area A, B To refuse the application. Retain status quo.

Key Issues: § Adverse traffic effects    § Adverse effects on schools

Submitter     Peter and Serena Leong
              19 Maidstone Place, Browns Bay North Shore City
82-1          Area A, B To refuse the application. Retain status quo.

Key Issues: § Adverse effect - residential amenity       § Insufficient and/or inaccurate information

Submitter     Yan Sheng Lou
              3 Malin Place, Pinehill North Shore City
49-1          Area A, B To refuse the application. Retain status quo.

Key Issues: § Adverse traffic effects    § Adverse effects on schools      § Safety and wellbeing of people

Submitter     Jia Jian Luo
              8 Errigal Close, Pinehill North Shore City
51-1          Area B To refuse the application. Retain status quo.

Key Issues: § Adverse traffic effects    § Adverse effect - residential amenity

52-1          Area A To refuse the application. Retain status quo.

Key Issues: § Inappropriate proposed zoning       § Adverse traffic effects    § Adverse effect - residential amenity

Submitter     K & E Lupton
              6 Ballymore Drive, Albany North Shore City
53-1          Area A, B To refuse the application. Retain status quo.

Key Issues: § Adverse traffic effects    § Adverse effect - residential amenity     § Safety and wellbeing of people    § Adverse pollution
            effects

Submitter     Morna MacFarlane
              13 Hugh Green Drive, Pinehill North Shore City
54-1          Area A, B To refuse the application. Retain status quo.

Key Issues: § Adverse traffic effects    § Insufficient and/or inaccurate information    § Inappropriate proposed zoning     § Decrease in
            property values,

Submitter     Ngaire and Gerard Mackle
              105 Hugh Green Drive, Pinehill North Shore City
55-1          Area A, B To refuse the application. Retain status quo.

Key Issues: § Insufficient and/or inaccurate information § Adverse traffic effects § Existing District Plan lack of understanding of
            expectations in the area § Adverse effect - residential amenity § Inappropriate proposed zoning § Adverse effect –
            visual amenity and urban design

Submitter     S L Mak Décor Concept Ltd
              32 Ballymore Drive, Albany North Shore City
58-1          Area A, B To refuse the application. Retain status quo.

Key Issues: § Insufficient and/or inaccurate information § Section 32 analysis insufficient / inaccurate § Inappropriate proposed
            zoning, § Adverse traffic effects § Adverse effect - residential amenity § Adverse effect – visual amenity and urban
            design

Submitter     Yoke Chun Mak
              42 Ballymore Drive, Albany North Shore City
59-1          Area A, B To refuse the application. Retain status quo.

Key Issues: § Adverse traffic effects    § Noise pollution     § Adverse pollution effects   § Inappropriate proposed zoning




Page 8
Submitters Numbers, Names and Addresses, Summary of Relief Sought and Key Issues
Submitter     John Collins Mansfield
              10 Taroka Close, Albany North Shore City
60-1          Area A To change Area A to 4A.

Key Issues: § Adverse traffic effects   § Noise pollution    § Adverse pollution effects    § Adverse effects on schools

61-1          Area B To refuse the application. Retain status quo.

Key Issues: § Adverse traffic effects   § Noise pollution    § Adverse pollution effects    § Adverse effects on schools

Submitter     Margaret Mansfield
              10 Taroka Close, Albany North Shore City
62-1          Area A Change to 4A.

Key Issues: § Adverse traffic effects    § Noise pollution    § Adverse pollution effects   § Adverse effects on schools

63-1          Area B To refuse the application. Retain status quo.

Key Issues: § Adverse traffic effects   § Noise pollution    § Adverse pollution effects    § Adverse effects on schools

Submitter     Ruby Mardiono
              25 Ballintra Close, Albany North Shore City
64-1          Area A, B To refuse the application. Retain status quo.

Key Issues: § Insufficient and/or inaccurate information     § Adverse traffic effects

Submitter     Dean McGowan C/- Peter Sinton
              c/- Northland Town Planners, PO Box 81-075 Whenuapai
125-1 LATE Area A, B To refuse the application. Retain status quo.

Key Issues: § Adverse traffic effects §   Insufficient and/or inaccurate information §   Section 32 analysis insufficient /
            inaccurate § Inappropriate proposed zoning § Adverse effect - residential amenity § Adverse effect – visual amenity
            and urban design § Decrease in property values

Submitter     Joanne McGowan C/- Peter Sinton
              c/- Northland Town Planners, PO Box 81-075 Whenuapai
126-1 LATE Area A, B To refuse the application. Retain status quo.

Key Issues: § Adverse traffic effects §   Insufficient and/or inaccurate information §   Section 32 analysis insufficient /
            inaccurate § Inappropriate proposed zoning § Adverse effect - residential amenity § Adverse effect – visual amenity
            and urban design § Decrease in property values

Submitter     Kerry McGowan C/- Peter Sinton
              c/- Northland Town Planners, PO Box 81-075 Whenuapai
127-1 LATE Area A, B To refuse the application. Retain status quo.

Key Issues: § Adverse traffic effects §   Insufficient and/or inaccurate information §   Section 32 analysis insufficient /
            inaccurate § Inappropriate proposed zoning § Adverse effect - residential amenity § Adverse effect – visual amenity
            and urban design § Decrease in property values

Submitter     Nancy McGowan
              20 Colin Wild Place, Glenfield North Shore City
128-1 LATE Area A, B To refuse the application. Retain status quo.

Key Issues: § Adverse effect - residential amenity § Adverse effect – visual amenity and urban design § Adverse pollution effects   §
            Noise pollution § Safety and wellbeing of people § Insufficient and/or inaccurate information § Adverse effects on
            schools

Submitter     Shaun McGowan
              20 Colin Wild Place, Glenfield North Shore City
129-1 LATE Area A, B To refuse the application. Retain status quo.

Key Issues: § Adverse effect - residential amenity § Adverse effect – visual amenity and urban design § Adverse pollution effects   §
            Noise pollution § Safety and wellbeing of people § Insufficient and/or inaccurate information § Adverse effects on
            schools




                                                                                                                           Page 9
Submitters Numbers, Names and Addresses, Summary of Relief Sought and Key Issues
Submitter     Steve McGowan
              3 Buncrana Place, Pinehill North Shore City
65-1          Area A, B To refuse the application. Retain status quo.

Key Issues: § Adverse effect - residential amenity § Adverse effect – visual amenity and urban design § Adverse pollution effects       §
            Noise pollution § Adverse traffic effects § Adverse effects on schools § Safety and wellbeing of people

130-1 LATE Area A, B To refuse the application. Retain status quo.

Key Issues: § Adverse effect - residential amenity § Adverse effect – visual amenity and urban design § Adverse pollution effects       §
            Noise pollution § Safety and wellbeing of people § Insufficient and/or inaccurate information § Adverse effects on
            schools

Submitter     Colin Meikle
              12 Taroka Close, Albany North Shore City
66-1          Area A To refuse the application. Retain status quo.

Key Issues: § Adverse traffic effects    § Noise pollution     § Adverse pollution effects    § Adverse effects on schools

67-1          Area B To refuse the application. Retain status quo.

Key Issues: § Adverse traffic effects    § Noise pollution     § Adverse pollution effects    § Adverse effects on schools

Submitter     Diane Joy Meikle
              12 Taroka Close, Albany North Shore City
68-1          Area A To refuse the application. Retain status quo.

Key Issues: § Adverse traffic effects,     § Noise pollution    § Adverse pollution effects   § Adverse effects on schools

69-1          Area B To refuse the application. Retain status quo.

Key Issues: § Adverse traffic effects    § Noise pollution     § Adverse pollution effects    § Adverse effects on schools

Submitter     Anthony Ian Milne
              7 Arirang Rise, Pinehill North Shore City
70-1          Area A, B To refuse the application. Retain status quo.

Key Issues: § Insufficient and/or inaccurate information       § Adverse effect - residential amenity   § Adverse traffic effects   §
            Inappropriate proposed zoning,

Submitter     Jeanette Milne
              7 Arirang Rise, Pinehill North Shore City
71-1          Area A, B To refuse the application. Retain status quo.

Key Issues: § Decrease in property values       § Adverse traffic effects    § Inappropriate proposed zoning

Submitter     Darrin and Denise Mirabito
              130 Hugh Green Drive, Pinehill North Shore City
72-1          Area A, B To refuse the application. Retain status quo.

Key Issues: § Adverse effect - residential amenity     § Inappropriate proposed zoning        § Adverse traffic effects

Submitter     Multiple Petition Signatories - see attached list C/- Peter Sinton
              c/- Northland Town Planners, PO Box 81-075 Whenuapai
124-1         Area A, B To refuse the application. Retain status quo and be provided with better plans.

Key Issues: § Insufficient and/or inaccurate information § Section 32 analysis insufficient / inaccurate § Inappropriate proposed
            zoning § Adverse traffic effects § Adverse effect - residential amenity § Adverse effect – visual amenity and urban
            design § Decrease in property values § Adverse effects on infrastructure

Submitter     Theingi Myint
              20 Hugh Green Drive, Pinehill North Shore City
73-1          Area A, B Not Stated.

Key Issues: § Noise pollution     § Adverse traffic effects




Page 10
Submitters Numbers, Names and Addresses, Summary of Relief Sought and Key Issues
Submitter    Judy E and Robert B Oborn
             20 Manu Place, Albany North Shore City
75-1         Area A, B To refuse the application. Retain status quo.

Key Issues: § Adverse traffic effects    § Adverse effects on schools      § Inappropriate proposed zoning     § Insufficient and/or inaccurate
            information

Submitter    Brian and Sue Pearce
             5 Te Hoe Grove, Pinehill North Shore City
76-1         Area A, B To refuse the application. Retain status quo.

Key Issues: § Inappropriate proposed zoning       § Adverse effect - residential amenity   § Adverse traffic effects,

Submitter    Raymond Peng and Irene Peng
             PO Box 100854, NSMC North Shore City
1-1          Area A, B To refuse the application.

Key Issues: § Adverse traffic effects    § Inappropriate proposed zoning      § Adverse effect - residential amenity

Submitter    James Garner Hopkins/Kristen Gunnell Progressive Enterprises Ltd C/- Russell McVeagh
             PO Box 8, AUCKLAND
134-1 LATE Mainly Area A To refuse the application. Retain status quo.

Key Issues: § Inappropriate proposed zoning,        § Insufficient and/or inaccurate information   § Section 32 analysis insufficient /
            inaccurate

Submitter    Madeliene V Quezon
             25 Ballymore Drive, Pinehill North Shore City
7-1          Area A To refuse the application. Retain status quo.

Key Issues: § Adverse traffic effects    § Safety and wellbeing of people     § Inappropriate proposed zoning      § Noise pollution

8-1          Area B To refuse the application. Retain status quo.

Key Issues: § Adverse traffic effects    § Safety and wellbeing of people     § Decrease in property values

Submitter    Mario J Quezon
             25 Ballymore Drive, Pinehill North Shore City
4-1          Area A To refuse the application. Retain status quo.

Key Issues: § Adverse traffic effect    § Adverse effect - residential amenity

5-1          Area B To refuse the application. Retain status quo.

Key Issues: § Decrease in property values      § Adverse traffic effects

Submitter    Michael V Quezon
             25 Ballymore Drive, Pinehill North Shore City
2-1          Area A To refuse the application. Retain status quo.

Key Issues: § Adverse traffic effects    § Safety and wellbeing of people     § Inappropriate proposed zoning      § Noise pollution

3-1          Area B To refuse the application. Retain status quo.

Key Issues: § Adverse traffic effects    § Safety and wellbeing of people     § Decrease in property values

Submitter    Quezon and Hohua Family
             25 Ballymore Drive, Albany North Shore City
6-1          Area A, B To refuse the application. Retain status quo.

Key Issues: § Adverse traffic effects § Safety and wellbeing of people        § Adverse pollution effects    § Adverse effect - residential
            amenity § Insufficient and/or inaccurate information




                                                                                                                                  Page 11
Submitters Numbers, Names and Addresses, Summary of Relief Sought and Key Issues
Submitter     Alison S. Renshaw
              9 Ballintra Close, Pinehill North Shore City
132-1 LATE Area A, B To refuse the application. Retain status quo.

Key Issues: § Adverse effect - residential amenity      § Safety and wellbeing of people      § Noise pollution

Submitter     Ian Renshaw
              9 Ballintra Close, Pinehill North Shore City
133-1 LATE Area A, B To refuse the application. Retain status quo.

Key Issues: § Insufficient and/or inaccurate information     § Noise pollution    § Adverse traffic effects   § Adverse pollution effects

Submitter     Pauline Renwick
              13 Te Hoe Grove, Pinehill North Shore City
10-1          Area A, B To refuse the application, status quo for A and need more info on B.

Key Issues: § Adverse effect - residential amenity § Decrease in property values § Adverse traffic effects § Adverse effect – visual
            amenity and urban design § Inappropriate proposed zoning § Limit on future potential § Insufficient and/or inaccurate
            information

Submitter     Andrew Roberts
              3 Carrowmore, Pinehill North Shore City
11-1          Area A, B Reject the application. Appropriate developments that reflect the district plan.

Key Issues: § Inappropriate proposed zoning        § Adverse effect - residential amenity

Submitter     Clive Robinson and Helene Robinson
              8 Ballymore Drive, Albany North Shore City
12-1          Area A, B To refuse the application. Retain status quo.

Key Issues: § Adverse traffic effects      § Adverse pollution effects    § Noise pollution   § Insufficient and/or inaccurate information

Submitter     Charles Roos
              4 Ballintra Close, Pinehill North Shore City
13-1          Area A, B To refuse the application. Retain status quo.

Key Issues: § Insufficient and/or inaccurate information § Adverse traffic effects § Noise pollution          § Adverse effect - residential
            amenity § Inappropriate proposed zoning § Decrease in property values

Submitter     Fiona Shilton
              8A Bundoran Way, Pinehill North Shore City
14-1          Area A, B To refuse the application. Retain status quo.

Key Issues: § Adverse traffic effects § Insufficient and/or inaccurate information § Adverse effect – visual amenity and urban design
            § Adverse effects on schools § Section 32 analysis insufficient / inaccurate § Decrease in property values §
            Inappropriate proposed zoning

Submitter     Lloyd and Debbie Sinton
              12 Hugh Green Drive, Pinehill Albany North Shore City
15-1          Area A, B To refuse the application.

Key Issues: § Adverse traffic effects      § Adverse effects on schools     § Insufficient and/or inaccurate information

Submitter     Graham Solomon
              17 Glen Bay Close, Pinehill North Shore City
16-1          Area A, B To refuse the application.

Key Issues: § Adverse effects on schools § Adverse traffic effects § Inappropriate proposed zoning                § Decrease in property values
            § Adverse effect - residential amenity § New zone may not be sustainable

Submitter     Ken and Allison Stansfield
              128 Hugh Green Drive, Pinehill North Shore City
17-1          Area A, B To refuse the application. Retain status quo.

Key Issues: § Adverse effect - residential amenity      § Inappropriate proposed zoning       § Adverse traffic effects

Page 12
Submitters Numbers, Names and Addresses, Summary of Relief Sought and Key Issues
Submitter     Andre Tedjapoernama
              4 Carrigans Close, Albany North Shore City
18-1          Area A, B To refuse the application. Retain status quo.

Key Issues: § Adverse effect - residential amenity

Submitter     Y C Mak and C T Teh
              42 Ballymore Drive, Albany North Shore City
56-1          Area A, B To refuse the application. Retain status quo.

Key Issues: § Adverse traffic effects    § Noise pollution   § Adverse pollution effects   § Inappropriate proposed zoning

57-1          Area A, B To refuse the application. Retain status quo.

Key Issues: § Adverse traffic effects    § Noise pollution   § Adverse pollution effects   § Inappropriate proposed zoning

Submitter     Maung Thanitsin
              20 Hugh Green Drive, Pinehill North Shore City
74-1          Area A, B Not Stated.

Key Issues: § Adverse effects on schools      § Adverse effect - residential amenity   § Adverse traffic effects    § Adverse pollution effects

Submitter     Andrew Thomson
              25 Hugh Green Drive, Pinehill North Shore City
19-1          Area A, B To refuse the application. Retain status quo.

Key Issues: § Adverse traffic effects § Safety and wellbeing of people § Inappropriate proposed zoning              § Limit on future potential
            § Decrease in property values § Adverse effect - residential amenity

Submitter     Regional Manager Transit New Zealand C/- Debora Field
              PO Box 1459, auckland
135-1 LATE Area A, B To refuse the application.

Key Issues: § Insufficient and/or inaccurate information

Submitter     Kevin and Marie Vitali
              12 Te Hoe Grove, Pinehill North Shore City
21-1          Area A, B To refuse the application. Retain status quo.

Key Issues: § Insufficient and/or inaccurate information     § Adverse effect - residential amenity   § Adverse traffic effects    § Adverse
            effects on schools

Submitter     Arthur and Aileen Wilson
              42 Hugh Green Drive, Pinehill North Shore City
22-1          Area A, B Retain status quo.

Key Issues: § Adverse effect - residential amenity § Decrease in property values        § Adverse pollution effects      § Adverse traffic
            effects § Insufficient and/or inaccurate information

Submitter     Brian N Winslade
              34 Hugh Green Drive, Albany North Shore City
23-1          Area A, B To refuse the application. Retain status quo.

Key Issues: § Adverse traffic effects § Adverse effects on schools        § Adverse effect - residential amenity    § Decrease in property
            values § Inappropriate proposed zoning

Submitter     Bernie and Elaine Woods
              15 Manu Place, Browns Bay North Shore City
24-1          Area A, B To refuse the application. Retain status quo.

Key Issues: § Decrease in property values § Adverse traffic effects        § Adverse effect - residential amenity     § Safety and wellbeing of
            people § Adverse effects on schools




                                                                                                                                   Page 13
Submitters Numbers, Names and Addresses, Summary of Relief Sought and Key Issues
Submitter     Chen Yan Yan
              108 Hugh Green Drive, Albany North Shore City
26-1          Area A, B Not Stated.

Key Issues: § Adverse traffic effects    § Safety and wellbeing of people     § Adverse effects on schools

Submitter     Liping Yang
              PO Box 301096, Albany North Shore City
25-1          Area A, B To refuse the application. Retain status quo.

Key Issues: § Insufficient and/or inaccurate information     § Adverse traffic effects   § Inappropriate proposed zoning     § Adverse effect -
            residential amenity

Submitter     Ying Jun Yu
              82 Hugh Green Drive, Pinehill North Shore City
27-1          Area A, B To refuse the application. Retain status quo.

Key Issues: § Adverse traffic effects    § Adverse effect - residential amenity   § Adverse effects on schools

28-1          Area A, B To refuse the application. Retain status quo.

Key Issues: § Adverse traffic effects    § Adverse effect - residential amenity    § Decrease in property values

Submitter     Haobing Qiao and Meiling Zhou
              8 Lough Derg Place, Albany North Shore City
9-1           Area A, B To refuse the application. Retain status quo.

Key Issues: § Adverse traffic effects § Safety and wellbeing of people        § Adverse pollution effects    § Adverse effect - residential
            amenity § Insufficient and/or inaccurate information

Submitter     Meisheng Zhu
              2 Ballintra Close, Pinehill North Shore City
131-1 LATE Area A, B To refuse the application. Retain status quo.

Key Issues: § Insufficient and/or inaccurate information




Page 14
Petition Signatories
Address for Service: Peter Sinton, C/- Northland Town Planners Ltd, PO Box 81-075, Whenuapai
Young Nym Ahn                                               Hyun Ju An
John An                                                     Bo Mi An
In Hye An                                                   Dul Nam An
Vadim and Elena Andros                                      Ross Angus
Ray Bagley                                                  Pania Bagnall
Shane Bagnall                                               Adam Bagnall
Young Sook Baik                                             Craig Bailey
Jung-Guin Bang                                              Muaijada Barron
Irina Blaj                                                  Chris Booth
J Bosman                                                    Paul Brown
Alan Bucker                                                 Neil Buckner
Maria Buckner                                               Stephen Burnett
Rodel Camungol                                              Nigel Carroll
John Cha                                                    Jun Ho Cha
Kyung Don Cha                                               Young Jun Cha
Hyung Ryung Cha                                             JungKi Cha
Kyung Don Cha                                               Hyong Won Cha
Suk Min Cha                                                 Yoo Don Cha
Lau Sau Chai                                                Jian Nan Chan
Lindy Chang                                                 Y M Cheah
You Chen                                                    Yan Yan Chen
Meiyu Chen                                                  Vasya Chernomorets
C K Cheung                                                  Annie Chin
Yun Sung Chiou                                              Hyun Woo Cho
Seong Kyuu Cho                                              Ji Wan Choi
Soon Hae Choi                                               Kung Ja Choi
Hye Kyumen Choi                                             Nam Choi
Ji Young Choi                                               Ching Yau Chua
Eun He Chun                                                 Yong Ook Chun
Tony Chung                                                  Joon Sup Chung
Daniel Chung                                                Jae Min Chung
Jae Yong Chung                                              Gary Clarke
Heather Clarke                                              Trevor Coles
Lilienne Coles                                              M Copplestone
Debbie Coustas                                              Warren Coustas
Xiao Ling Cui                                               Zuoqun Cui
Liping Dai                                                  Garry Dean
DeLinYang                                                   Bruce Devonport
H Easey                                                     Glen Edwards
David Edwards                                               Hala El Attar
Ngaire Evans                                                G C Ganley
Henny Giljam                                                Jennie Giljam
Bruce Gregory                                               Guixia
Mi Kyung Gye                                                Park Hang Gyu
Saad Hanabadi                                               Wei Hai Hao
Sandy Harrison                                              Lavinia Haverfield
Jung Soon Hong                                              Yoon Keun Hong
Clare Hsiao                                                 Frank Hua


                                                                                               Page 15
Petition Signatories
Address for Service: Peter Sinton, C/- Northland Town Planners Ltd, PO Box 81-075, Whenuapai
Kim Keum Hwa                                                Yong Sun Hwang
Rocky Hwang                                                 Lee Seung Il
Sun JaCho                                                   Maureen Jackson
Ian Jackson                                                 Hyn-Hwa Jang
Hong Hee Jang                                               Charlotte Jang
Moo-Woong Jang                                              Semoon Jang
Lisa Jennett                                                Martin Jennett
Sae Hee Jeong                                               Soon Pyn Jeong
Xiao Feng Jiang                                             Min Jiang
Kim Hee Jin                                                 Carolyn and Paul Johnson
Hyn Joo-Lim                                                 Joug Eun Ju
Elena Jukes                                                 Sun Il Jun
Wonsuk Jun                                                  Yung-Soon Jun
Gyu Taek Jung                                               Tae Sung Jung
Eun-Ae Kang                                                 Myung-Soo Kang
Duck Bae Kim                                                Mi-Yeong Kim
Sook Kyung Kim                                              Seung Hee Kim
Sun Mi Kim                                                  Jin Hwa Kim
Young Sun Kim                                               Chang One Kim
Jung Heo Kim                                                Song-Yeon Kim
Yeon Sang Kim                                               Youn-Ja Kim
Mi Sung Kim                                                 J H Kim
Jung Suk Kim                                                Sang Hyun Kim
Dong Min Kim                                                Esther Kim
S H Kim                                                     Sang Joon Kim
Young Seoh Kim                                              Clement Lau Kim
Hyun Seung Kim                                              Seung Hyub Kim
Jeong-Eun Kim                                               Joong-Yon Kim
Jeong-Eun Kim                                               S H Kim
Young Oh Kim                                                Kyeong Tae Kim
Ji Hun Kim                                                  Young Hae Kim
Chang Youl Kim                                              Young Sook Kim
Sungok Kim                                                  No Hyang Kim
Michael Kim                                                 Young Sook Kim
Tea Un Kim                                                  Kyeong Tae Kim
Nicky Kim                                                   Sang Hyeok Matthew Kim
Myung Rye Kim                                               Alan King
J Koelewijn                                                 Sang Ok Koh
Tristen Krajancic                                           Nick Krajancic
Lee Seung Kum                                               Kim Su Kum
Jonathan J W Kwak                                           Jung Woo Kwak
Young Hae Kwak                                              Jung-Hui Kyoo
Sangita Ladwa                                               Ashvin Ladwa
Alfred Lai                                                  T K Lam
Darran Laskey                                               Andrew Lau
Qee Toll Lau                                                Gavin Lau
James Lau                                                   Man Bo Lau
Miegan Lau                                                  Robert Law


Page 16
Petition Signatories
Address for Service: Peter Sinton, C/- Northland Town Planners Ltd, PO Box 81-075, Whenuapai
Hayley Law                                                  Hwa Sil Le
Wee-Kheng Lee                                               Hymja Lee
Anne Lee                                                    Jong Soon Lee
A Reum Lee                                                  Jung Lee
Eun Jeaing Lee                                              Xiu-Qiao Lei
Peter Leong                                                 Soo Kyung Lim
Jong A Lim                                                  Jenny Lin
Jun Young Lin                                               Mi Sun Liu
Yan Sheng Lou                                               S M Louw
Linda Ma                                                    Ngaire Mackle
Mitchell Mak                                                S C Mak
Kareen Mak                                                  Ruby Mardiono
Robert McClue                                               Morna McFarlane
Bernie McGinley                                             Colin McGinley
Shaun McGowan                                               Steve McGowan
Wendy McNeely                                               Kirk McNeely
Guoqing Mei                                                 Anthony Milne
Jeanette Milne                                              Taesik Moon
Mi Ri Moon                                                  Kyun Jun Moon
Ji Sun Moon                                                 Juhyun Moon
Greg and Gabrielle Nisbet                                   Carol Noone
Mike Noone                                                  Robert Oborn
Judy Oborn                                                  Ahn Kung Ock
Young Shin Oh                                               Tony Osment
Pam Osment                                                  Heon Sook Park
Cheon In Park                                               Brian Pearce
Sue Pearce                                                  Grahame Probert
Kenneth Quadros                                             Madeleine V Quezon
Marie J Quezon                                              Peter Randall
Ian Renshaw                                                 Alison Renshaw
Mike Renwick                                                Pauline Renwick
In Ho Rho                                                   Clive Robinson
Helene Robinson                                             P Robinson
F Robinson                                                  Charles Roos
Jae Yul Ryu                                                 Jee Eun Ryu
Mary Sarten                                                 Eun Hee Seal
Cho Yong See                                                Youngrok Seo
Hui Shang                                                   Yiming Shi
Gary Chuo Shil                                              Fiona Shilton
Allen Shu                                                   Jon Shu
Liang Shu                                                   Grace Shu
Elena Shumilo                                               Lloyd Sinton
Debbie Sinton                                               D S Sohn
H S Sohn                                                    Kang Eun Sok
Graham Solomon                                              Kyung A Son
Po Goung Song                                               K Stansfield
Ii Ae Suh                                                   Kwang Nam Suh
Joo Hyun Sung                                               Jung Yeon Sung


                                                                                               Page 17
Petition Signatories
Address for Service: Peter Sinton, C/- Northland Town Planners Ltd, PO Box 81-075, Whenuapai
Kim SungBong                                                Andre Tedjapoernama
Tony Teh                                                    Edith Teoh
Hoe Hin Teoh                                                Bryan Theunisen
Andrew Thomson                                              Selina Y M Tsang
Ping Kau Tsang                                              P S Tsui
Lesley Veale                                                M Vitali
K Vitali                                                    Wenqjang Wang
A Wilson                                                    A D Wilson
Brian Winslade                                              Elizabeth Winslade
David Won                                                   Gan Won
Kim Young Woo                                               Jeung Hee Woo
Dong Seop Woo                                               Elaine Woods
Bennie Woods                                                Hong Hua Xie
Liping Yang                                                 Judie Ye
Jianzho Ye                                                  Jin Yao Ye
Park So Yeoun                                               Bo A Yi
Keith Yip                                                   Dong Hag Yoo
Kan In Young                                                Kim Jee Young
Ying Jun Yu                                                 Sook Yu
Yip Chuen Yuen                                              Sok Houng Yuen
Shi Ing Zhou                                                Shirley Zhou
Yun Zhou                                                    Jack Zhu




Page 18

								
To top