Cease Desist Contractor Slander by ute13758

VIEWS: 158 PAGES: 8

More Info
									/   r, o r r . r r r o              MUTIJNOC
                             SHEPFARD                                                      03:50:40p.m. lo-t3-2009                r /28




                                                                 650 Tofln Ccntrr Driw | {th Ftoor I Corla ir€:a, CA 92525.1993
                                                              714-513-il0o otrre I Zt+5tl-st rc rux I wvw.tttcppaanuiltn,anr
                         o

                                                                                Wrir/s Dircct
                                                                                            Linc:?14-42&2E30
                                                                                rmccotucy@sheppardmull in.com
                         13,2009
                   October
                                                                                             0XWE-{1I3784
                                                                                OurFileNumber:



                               &
                   VU FACSIMIL.E A.S.TAIL
                   (310)
                       E2MlIl

                   Sandor Boxer,
                        T.      Esq.
                                    T.
                            ofSandor Boxer
                   LawOffices
                       Wilshire
                   12400      Boulevar4Suite1300
                             CA
                   LosAngeles, 90025-1030


                                  Re:    Cease Desist
                                             and


                   DearMr. Boxer

                               We represent
                                          Trilogy Financial  Serviscs, andJeffreyR. Motske. Although
                                                                     Inc.
                                PaulaLynch in a prior related
                  you represented                            matter,we arenot certainwhelheryou will bc
                  rcpr€senting Lynch in the puent matterwhich is w{ty we arecopyingMs. Lynchon this
                             Ms.
                  lener.

                                 As you mayrecall,on October 2003,
                                                            31,       yourclient,Ms. Lynch,entered a
                                                                                                  into
                             for                  with
                  Stipulation Entryof Judgment our clients,      TrilogyFinancial         Inc.
                                                                                 Services, andJeffreyR,
                  Mogkc. (A copyof lhe Stipulationis attachedherctoasExhibit l.) Pursuant the Stipulation,
                                                                                         to
                  the Superior              a
                              Courtentered Permanent   lnjunctionandJudgment  Thereon.(A copy of the
                  foregoinginjunctionis attached                             na"
                                               heretoasExhibit 2.) Paragraph of the injunction
                  permanently restrains Lynch from,inter alia:
                                       Ms.

                                                 unlawfulactions
                                  "(i) undertaking                towardTrilogy, its lmown
                                  employees,        associates, Moske; (ii) makinguntruthftl
                                              agents,          and
                                  slatements aboutTrilogy,its knowncmployees,  agents, associates
                                  andMotske;and(iii) plaoing  Trilogy,its knownemployees,  dlenrs,
                                  associates Motskein a falsclight before publiceye."
                                            and                             the

                                 Paragraph of lhe injunction
                                          "d"                     rcquires Lynch"[tfo cooperate
                                                            further      Ms.                  in
                  removing material
                           any                in         on
                                       already existence theinternet, elsewhere,
                                                                      or       whichwouldviolatethe
                  termsof this Judgment."

                            It hascomeour attenlionthal Ms. Lynchhasonceagainbeenpostingunuuthful
                         about
                 statements    Trilogy on thelnternet directviolationof theinjunction.
                                                    in
     5130
7r4513                        MUTIJN
                       SHEPPARD     OC                                             03:50;52p.m. t0-13-2009        2 t28




                 ilUITIIIRICMER$&II}N
            SEEFPAru}        E      LT,P
                 T.
            Sandor Boxer,
                        Esq.
                  13,2oo9
            October
               2
            Page


                       Ms Lynch'swebsite,http://wnnv.armydiller.com/financial.scam/index.hlm,
        describes greatlengthan allcgedly
                  at                      illegalmulti-level
                                                           marketing      in
                                                                     scam thc financial
                                                                                      services
                           the
        indutry, detailing practices "scammer"
                                     of            companies 'wto deliberately     theirwork
                                                                             deceive
        forceforprofit." (SeenHowTheScam     [/orks" paggattached       as
                                                                  hereto Exhibit4.) Ms. Lynch
        identifiesTrilogy Financial
                                  Services onesuch"scammer
                                          as                   fum." (See"lnboductionn
                                                                                     page,
        attached       as
                 hereto Exhibit 3.) All suchstatementsaboutTrilogyarcfalse, moreimportantlS
                                                                            and
        specificallypmhibited the injunction.
                               by

                    The following examples           jrst
                                           illustrate a few of the falseandinjuriousstatemcnts
        madeby Ms. Lynch againstTrilogy on her website;

                 r    \feedlessto say,all thescammen 100%
                                                      are    commission. theyadvertise
                                                                         lf             a,salary,
                                                                                                or
                      paidtaining it's tdrmt againstfuture         (o
                                                          commissions loan)." (SceExhibit4.)

                 e "Evenif thefirm advertises trade
                                            at                   pay
                                                   shows, recruits hr it." (See
                                                        the                    Exhibit4.)
                 r                     rep
                      "The inexperienced is instead up to fail while the firm profits andhidesits backs.n
                                                    set
                      (See"StartingOut:'lf I workhar4I'llmakeit!"'page,attached hereto Exhibit5.)
                                                                                       as
              o "lt should   alsobenotedthatscammer    firmsused deliberately
                                                                  to          advertise job asa
                                                                                       the
                'firll-timeemployee'position a salary commission,
                                                with       (+            usualty)with benehrcwhenin
                fact a) it is a full-comrnission,non-salaried
                                                            independent         position,rsually
                                                                       contractor
                misclassifying employee his detriment; any'salary'is
                                  the          to             b)            actually draw,or lour
                                                                                    a
                that mustbe repaidto the firrr out of tbercp'sfutureearnings; c) all benefits(andall
                                                                            and
                othertusiness' expcnscs!) to bebomeby therep,not the firm. Thereareoffencriteria
                                             are
                for gettingbenefitsthat few repscv€rmeelandmaintain,suchasa certainlevel of
                earnings;   benefitsarc not earned undertheusualmeaning 'employee'
                                                                        of           whcreinyou
                obtainthemautomatically a certain
                                             after        period employment."
                                                                of             (SeeExhibit5i
             .       "Theymay verballydiscourage repfrom obtainingan iruurancelicense
                                                    the                                            oncehe
                     starts,insteadtelling him to mastersecurities
                                                                 salesfirst . . . thesefirms may verbally
                     encouagerepswithout insurance    licenses takealonga manager
                                                              to                         who is tlcensed sell
                                                                                                        to
                     insurance produclswhena client shows needfor it. Sinceth.-,rp cannotlegally eam
                                                            a
                     anycommissions     lhomaninsurancc  transaction
                                                                   withoutan insurance     license,-thefullsale
                     mustin reality      tqtlg manag€r,evenif themanager verballyagreed split rhe
                                                                           has                    to
                                    l{l
                     commission."   (SeeExhibit5.)

       These jusr some manysratements Ms. Lynch's
           are        of           on           website arefalseasto Trilogy.
                                                      rhat
                     tn tight of the foregoing, hereby
                                              we      demand Ms. Lynchcease desist
                                                           that               and     her
       blatant
             violations the injunction.Consistent patagaph"d" of theinjunction, furrher
                        of                         with                         wc
       demand Ms. Lynchimmediately
               that                        remov€ andalt references Trilogyfrom herwebsite.
                                                 any              to
4 s135130                 MUI,IJN
                   SHEPPARD      OC                                    03:51:08p.m.10-13-2009        3 !28




                  uljluil HcmEnill\[Prcsr
            $us?rnD           &        uI
                 T.    Esq.
            Sandor Boxer,
                  13,2U)9
            Octobcr
               3
            Page

                               complywill resultin us filing anex parteapplication an orderto show
            Failure irnmediately
                    to                                                           for
            cause to why Ms. Lynchshould bc heldin contempt theCourtfor violationof the
                  as                     not                     of
            injuction,

                         Please         to
                               respond me by no laterthanFriday,October16,with a clearstatement
            asto whether                         complywith thedemands this leuer. If you will
                        yourclientwill immediately                    in
            not bercpresenting Lynchin this matter,
                             Ms.                   please
                                                        noti$ me immediately.




                                                          ;DUk
                                                            D. McCortrey

                                                       MULLIN,RICHTER HAMPTON
                                            for SHEPPARD,           &       ud
                       | \402258909.2
            W02-WEST:lTAf,,
            Attachments

        cc:        PaulaLynch(w/ anachmenu)

                                               2
                         R.    (w/
                  Jeffrcy Motske attachments)
714 135 13 0
   5                                  MULLINOC                                03:51:24p.m. 10-13-2009


                                           o                                 @/*n*
                                                                                               r
                                                                                            Mote,
                                                                                dqttLcl tb (zts Xtot
                I SHEPPARD.
                         MULLII.. ^rLH I ER & FIAMP'ION
                                                      r-lp                      blcasn-      u'azt
                                                                                '-eiZfet ^t/ue{ f
                2
                         A LimitedLiabilitvPartnershio
                                 Professi6nal
                         Includins            Comoritions                                          '           +/
                       PAUL F. {AFFERTY.CaI.BarNo. 132266
                3                              Cal.
                       JOHNE. BOWERBANK, BarNo.211565
                       650TownCentcr   Drive.4th Floor
                4      CoslaMesa, California 92626-1925
                       Telephone:  714-513-5100                                             U0 r
                5      Facsimile: 714-513-5130
                                                                                       {lilj SLATEF. r.
                                                                                                   I      |.
                6 Attorneys PlaintiffsTRILOGYFINANCIAL
                           for
                      SERVICES,
                              INC.;JEFFREY MOTSKE
                                         R.                                                (&,'
                7
                E                                     SUPERIOR     OF
                                                             COI.JRT CALIFORNIA
               9                                COI'NTY OF ORANCE,CENTRALJUSTICECENTER
               t0
           il TRILOGY FINANCIAL SERVICES,                           cAsENO.
                                                                          03CC095e8
              INC., a Californiacorporation;
                                           JEFFREY
           t2 R. MOTSKE,an individual,                              Assiened All Pumoses
                                                                           for          to:
                                                                    JudsEAndrewP. Banks
           t3                                                       Dep-artment
                                                                             C6
                                                  Plaintiffg
           t4                                                       STIPULATION FOR
                                                                    ENTRY OF JUDGMENT
           ls                   v.
           l6                                                       DATE:      October31, 2003
              PAULA K. LYNCH, an individuah
                                          and                       TIME:      10:00c.m.
           t7 DOESI through inclusive,
                           100,                                     PLACE:     Dept C6

           t8                                                      Filine Dete: July 28,2003
                                                  Defendants.      Trlrl-Date: NoneSet
           l9
          20
          2l
          22                             On July28, 2003,TrilogyFinancial
                                                                        Services, andJeffreyR. Motske
                                                                               Inc.
          23 ("Plaintifls')liled theirlawsuit      causes action libel,slander,
                                            bringing    of      for           negligent
          24 interference prospective
                        with        economic        intentional
                                           rclations,                   rvith
                                                             interference prospective
          25 economic       intentional
                    relations,       inflictionof emotional
                                                         distresq
                                                                invasion privacy false
                                                                       of      -
          26 light.violation California
                           of         Business Professions g 17200; injunctive
                                             &          Code      and        relief
         27 ("Action")against
                            Paula Lynch("Lynch").Theparties desire settle Action
                                K.                        norv   to      the
         2 8 in thelbrmof thisStipulation.

                    tvrt:.((.,{t,R..r
                                    t.l.l:612
                                            I
?1451 35 13 0                SHEPPARD
                                    MULLINOC                                                03r5lr52p.m. 10-13-2009    7 t28


                                             o                                       oo
                     I                         Wherefore, panies
                                                       the              and       to
                                                                    agree stipulate thefollowing:
                                                               hereby
                     2
                     3                         I.                                    judgment theform setforttr
                                                          ThattlreCourtmaysignandenter      in
                         as
                 4 hereia ExhibitA;
                 5
                 6                            2.                                  their.{ctionwithoutprcjudice;
                                                                       shalldismiss
                                                          ThatPlaintiffs                                      and
                 7
                 8                            3.          That eachof the particsshall beartheir own qttomqVs.{ecs costs..
                                                                                                                 and

                 9                                                                   f,tofrac?/au /4k.
                l0                            It is to stipulated:
                ll
                t2 Datcd:
                l3
                l4
                t5
                r6                                                         By
                17                                                                              R.
                                                                                          JEFFREY MOTSKE
                l8
                l9
                                                                                 TRILOGYFINANCIALSERVICES,      I}fC.;
            20                                                                      By its Prcsi&ntJoffreyRMotske
            2l
            22
                         Datcd:
            23
                                  /c? '- 2          3 -   '.r 3
            24
            25
            26
            27
            28

                         v903.()c NF!I4|3]l6J2.l
7 1 4 35130
    5t                                                  OC
                                                  MUI.IJN                                                        03:53:06p.m, l0-13-2009                        t3 tz'
 A.
                                                    s
               t llSHEppnRD.MULLIN, rur-rrI ur\ rx,rrA'rr r \^t LLr
                Il e rimitedLiability
                    A Limited          Partnership
                                       Partnenhip                                                                        Fii .-.*
              2ll lncluding
                    lncluding             Corporations
                                          Corporations
                               Professional
                               Professional                                                                              i. 1l . . U
                   PAULF. {AFFERTY, BarNo. 132266
                                        Cal.
                  llt t r v Ll. .v D . r E
                                                                  .t   v-.r
                                                                                                                 Ssg1,i'::'
                                                                                                                      F/r r :r
                                                                                                                                    .r1.;51:,.i.1
                                                                                                                                 i ,n                . _ Il B

              3 ll JOHNE, BOWERBANK BarNo.211566
                   JOHN BOWERBANK BarNo.211566
                         E.                Cal.
                                           Cal.                                                                               : ' ji',fr e
                                                                                                                    cEifii"ii'''
                Il65o  To*mCenter
                   650Town                  Floor
                                    Drive.4th
                                    Drive,4th                                                                           rrr r .
                                                                                                                        Yv.

              4 ffCosta
                        A
                        Mesa,
                        Mesa.  California
                                       ,
                                         92626-1925
                               California_92826-1925
                                             r,     A-f!F---?-         A      2q2   l a \^ e                                            J   I   l .u J



                fl Telephone 714-513-5
                            :-           100                                                                                      ,
                                                                                                                  flirf srAr€R. r,*
                                                                                                                               6... r;r{l
              Slffacsimite: 714-513-5130                                                                                >4.d.,--. ,
                                                                                                                            BY P r-;/,::,
                                         FINANCIAL
              6llAnorneys PlaintifhTRJLOGY
                         for
                                   R.MorsKE
                  llsgnvrCes, JEFFREY
                           INC.;
              7
              8 II                                                                COURT CALIFORMA
                                                                           SUPEzuOR   OF
              9II                                                              JUSTICE
                                                                         CENTRAL
                                                          COI.JNTY ORANGE,
                                                                 OF                  CENTER
          l0
          I I IITRILOGY FINANCIAL  SERVICES, I                                                               NO.
                                                                                                         CASE 03CC0959E
                                        JEFFREY I
                             corporation;
              lllNC,,_Lqqlt&mie                                                                          .
          t2llR.
            -     MOTSKE, indi'iidual,
                       KE,anindiiidual,         |                                                                          to:
                                                                                                         4s$en$fptA!!Purposes
              ll                                I                                                            Andrcw Banks
                                                                                                         JudgE     P.
          ' , ll                                I                                                                C6
                                                                                                         Dep-artment
                                                                 Plaintiffs,
              4
              '
                ll                                                                                               TNJUNCTTON
                                                                                                     I PERIT,TANENT
              5 ll                           v.                                                      I ANDJTJDGMENTTHEREON
              6
              "                               r'i
                                           -" and
                  llpn6e K. LyNCH,anindividuat;                                                      I DAT_E: O;tg^ber3l,2003
                         toii,fi;il;iv;
                  ir,l""Aii'
          ,7ilbaETi                                                                                    PLACE: l0-'.0P
                                                                                                     I TlYFt. Dept.*F'
                                                                                                                   C6
          !t ll                                                  Defendants.                          I-lllt|g lrete: Juli?1,
                                                                                                    I girylg*nl!:: ZU,Z
                                                                                                                      J[Iy    ?003
                                                                                                      TrirfDate:      Noire Sct
          l9
         20
         2l
         22
                                                   OnJuly28,2003,
                                                                Trilogy                 and
                                                                             Services,lnc. Jeffrey Moske
                                                                      Financial                  R.
         23                                                of
                                                       ca$es action libcl,slander,
                         "Plaintiffs") their
           ll(rott".tively          Iiled       bringing
                                           lawsuit                for
         2a
                             interference prospective
                  ll n"gtigent         with               relations,
                                                   cconomic                interference
                                                                  intentional        with
         2sll
         --                               intenlional
                                  relations,
                           economic                infliction emotional
                                                             of      distress;
                                                                            invasion
                                                                                   of
               flprospective
         26 priuory       tight,       of        BusinessProfessions g 17200;
                               violation Califomia      &         Code
           ll      - falsc                                                  and
         27llin;un.,ive ("Action")  against K. t.ynch
                                          Paula       ("Lynch"). setttement
                                                              This       isbeing
                      rclief
         28
                                                                                               "   -l'
                  **trl-{                                                                                          ffi ANI}.'UDGMENTTHEREON
,/ 7145135130                      MUI,IIN OC
                            SHEPPARD                                                   03:53:21p.m.l 0-t3-2009
  ,-.4   ,

                                            oo                                  Oc
                     I reachedpriortothefi|ingofaresponsivcp|eadingbyLynch-L@j]9
                 2 substantive                                                               the   for
                                                    ionsof thecomplaint, general, specilically need a
                                                                      in       and

                 l     permancnt        Nevertheless,orderto aniveat a stipulatediudgment without
                              injunction.          in                                  and

                 4                    of
                              admission
                                                 Injunction Judgment
                 5 stipulated entryof thisPermanent
                                                         , theparties theActiondesire settletheAction andhave
                                                          and
                                                                    to              to
                                                                        ("Judgment").
                                                                  Thereon
                                                                                                                      'ffi,u
                                                                                                                      w#
                            to
                 6
                 7                                   judgmenr
                                             WHEREFORE,     shallbeentered favofbf Plaintiffs,andagainst
                                                                         in

                 8 Lynch,in the formof thispermanent
                                                  injunctionpermanently        Lynchfrom:
                                                                     restraining

                 9
                l0                                                                                           or
                                                                       printing,witing, statingor coresponding
                                                               creating,
                                                     Publishing,
                lt    responding in anymanner in anyforumwhatsoever,
                               ro,          and                   anything           referring
                                                                          specifically
                                                                                      and
                                                                             associates Motske
                                                                       agents,
                                              Trilogy,its knownemployees,
                1 2 to, identifying, discussing
                                   or
                                               no         ofdme shatlapplyto this subparagraph
                t3 until October1,2005. However, expiration
                t4 with respect a pennanent
                              to          injunction          Lynchfrom: (i) undertaking
                                                    restraining                        unlawful

                l 5 actions                                                      (ii)
                                                               assosiates, Motske; making
                                                         agents,
                          towardTrilogy,its knownemployees,             and

                l6 untruthful                                                   and
                                                                        associatBs Motske;
                                                                  agents,
                                    aboutTrilogy,its knownemployees,
                            statements
                t7 and(iii) placingTrilogy, its knownemployees,    associates Motskein a false
                                                             agents,        and

                l8 light beforethepubliceye. In theeventthata potential               legislative
                                                                              employer,
                                                                      cmployer,
                      judicial agency, legislative
             t9 agency,              or                                               of
                                                                             disclosure
                                                                 and/orcompels
                                                      everinquires
                                                 agency
                                                                                 this
                                                                   from disclosing lawsuitto
             2A theexistence this lawsuit,Lynchshallnot beprohibited
                           of
             2 l anysuchpotential              or
                                        employer agency.
                                employer,
             22
             23                             b.                           rvith othento: (i) undertake
                                                     Invitingor conspiring                          unlawfulactions

             24 towardTrilogy,its knownemployees,                      (ii)
                                                     associates, Motske; make
                                               agents,        and            untruthful

             25 slatements Trilogy,its knownemployees,
                        about                            associates Motske; (iii)
                                                    agents,      and      and

             26 placeTrilogy,its knownemployees,    associates Motske a false
                                              agcnts,       and      in      lightbefore

             21 thepubliceyc.
             28

                      \to:.( [' NPRIIl.l-r:6.1{ |                                             PERMANENTTNJUNCTION
                                                                                             AND JUDGMENTTHF.REON
714 5130
  513                               MUI.IJN
                              SHEPPARD    OC                                03:53:38p,m. 10-13-2009    l5/28


 a        't   '                       oo                             lo
                        I              c.                with                              that
                                                                     relationships goodrvill may
                                               Inrerfering anybusincss          and

     i2                                Trilogyandits custotners;
                            existbetween
     .3
     t4                                                                                        or
                                                                                         oflice,
                                       d.      From        entering trespassing anyTrilogy
                                                   visiting,      or         upon
     ')                              harassing bothering employees lawycrs.
                      frornconfronting,      or        im       or                 no
                                                                            However, evidence

                    6 exists thistimethatLynch commined of theacts
                            at                has        any        stated thissubparagran\
                                                                         in               ns

                    7 such, inclusion thissubparagraph in nowaybedeemed admissio"UV
                           the        of             should                 an
                                                                                        )
                            that acls commined.
                    I Lynch such were                                        6ie*fl #ffi                       rtF
                    9
                                                                                                  t
                                                                                    oufg{,flrllft.,;i
                   IO                  d.                                                     on
                                                                            alreadyin existence the
                                               To cooperate removing material
                                                          in       any

                   il               or        whichwoutdviolatethetermsof thisJudgment.
                            internet, elsewhere.
                   12
                   l3                  TheCourtshallretainjurisdictionto enforce termsof theJudgment
                                                                               the
                                                                 above'
                                                        prohibited
                   l 4 shouldLynchviolateanyof theactions
                   t5
                   l5                  IT IS SOORDERED:
                   t7                                                  AND|,[!'V tjANKS
                                                                              r.,.
                   l8
                   t9
                   20
                   2l
                            Dated:      / o ' 3 t -Q)-
                   22
                   23
                   24
                   25
                   26
                   27
                   2E
                                                                                   PERMANNNT INJUNCTION
                                                                                  AND JUD(;MENTTHEREON

								
To top