The Science of Organizational Skills in Children “Organizational Skills Study Program”

Document Sample
The Science of Organizational Skills in Children “Organizational Skills Study Program” Powered By Docstoc
					  The Science of Organizational
       Skills in Children?                          “Organizational Skills Study

                                                          Rosenberg Lecture March 5, 2008

                                                                         PI: Howard Abikoff, Ph.D.
                                                                    Co-I: Richard Gallagher, Ph.D.
                                                                          NYU Child Study Center
                                                                                Renee David, M.S.
                                                                   Louis Armstrong Middle School

    Background and Rationale                     Background & Rationale (cont.)
• Many children do not develop routines for      • No comprehensive, “real-life” assessment
  meeting the demands of home and school           measures of OTMP skills in children
• Deficits in organizational, time management,   • No systematic efforts to develop and test
  and planning (OTMP) skills are associated        interventions that specifically target OTMP
  features of limited school success               deficits
• Ineffective OTMP skills compromise school      • For those with the greatest problems, lack
  success, result in family conflict, and          of measures and interventions leave
  decreased work performance                       problems unresolved
• May worsen over time

            Impact on Real-Life                   Initial Measurement Research
• A teacher’s perspective on problems             • We developed “real-life” OTMP skills
• An administrator’s perspective
                                                    – Developed the Children’s Organizational Skills
                                                      Scale (COSS)
• The effect of school demands
                                                    – Used to identify specific areas of impairment
   –   Elementary school circumstances
   –   Middle school demands                           • Lapses in Memory and Materials Management
   –   High school demands                             • Time Management Problems
   –   College demands                                 • Task Planning Problems
                                                    – Used to child status & assess treatment outcome

  Initial Measurement Studies                             Initial Measurement Results I
• Administered the COSS to over 900 children in 3rd to   • Three factors were revealed –Teacher Form
  8th regular education settings                            – Use of Organized Actions
• The New York Metropolitan Region was sampled in              • …uses a calendar to remember dues dates
                                                               • …uses folders to separate papers
  public, parochial, and private schools including NYC
                                                            – Lapses in Memory and Materials Management
  and suburban districts
                                                               • …completes homework but can’t find it
• Teachers provided data on 5 randomly selected                • …comes home without needed books
  students                                                  – Task Planning Problems
• Analyzed through factor analysis                             • …does not know how to begin assignments
                                                               • …runs out of time before completing tasks
• Important comparisons were conducted
                                                               • …is able to manage schedule in order to complete several

                                                           Simple & Probably Effective
Initial Measurement Results II
                                                                    Steps - I
• There were variations on these factors                 • Provide Overt Instruction in OTMP Skills
• Girls were more organized than boys
                                                         • Provide Physical Tools for Organization
• Those who had special educational support were less
  organized than those without                              – Planners
• Children with ADHD were less organized than               – Review the classroom environment for
  typically-developing children                               storage and placement of assignments
• Children with ADHD were less organized than            • Schedule Time to Complete Needed
  children with other emotional and behavioral
  problems                                                 Routines
• Parent observed variations as well as teachers         • Teach Kids How to Plan

Efforts to Assist Special Populations: The                                               Oh
           Story (so far) of ADHD                                                        No!!!!
• Deficits in organizational, time
  management, and planning (OTMP)
  skills are associated features of ADHD
   – DSM-IV: problems in organizing tasks &
     activities; disorganized work habits;
     tendency to scatter, lose, or carelessly
     mishandle task materials
• Ineffective OTMP skills compromise
  school success, result in family conflict,
  and decreased work performance

                                                              Initial Research: NIMH
                                                           Treatment Development Grant
                                                           • We developed “real-life” OTMP skills
 “MY WHAT? IS DUE WHEN?”                                      – Developed Children’s Organizational Skills Scale (COSS)
                     (AND, Where Is It?)
                                                           • We developed an Organizational Skills
                                                             Training (OST) intervention to improve
                                                             OTMP skills

                                                           • We conducted pilot study to determine
                                                             program’s utility and to guide design of
                                                             current randomized controlled trial

                OST Intervention                               OST Intervention (cont’d)
 • For 3rd-5th graders with ADHD and                      • 20-session manualized program
                                                            – Clinic-based, after school
   OTMP impairments
                                                            – 3 Major Domain Modules
 • Remedial intervention, not 1st line Tx for                  • Materials management
   ADHD                                                        • Time management
 • Informed by several assumptions                             • Planning for short and long-term projects

     – Children with ADHD:                                • Treatment focuses on child but also involves
         • have organizational skills deficits              – Parents
         • can learn skills but do not access them          – Teachers

         Findings from Pilot Study:
                                                                    Current NIMH Study
• Significant improvement in Parent and Teacher ratings    • Primary aims
  on the COSS
• Significant improvement on Homework Problems                – Compare two OTMP treatment approaches
  Checklist and Academic Planning Task                           • “OST” --- Organizational Skills Training
• Improvements occurred regardless of children’s                 • "PATHKO"---Parents and Teachers Helping
  medication status or ADHD subtype                                Kids Get Organized"
• No drop-outs
                                                                 • Wait-list control – choice of Tx after wait period
• High level of attendance
   – All children had at least 17 sessions                    – Assess short and “long-term” effects
• Treatment satisfaction                                         • Evaluate children’s functioning in the next
   – Parents “very satisfied”                                      school grade, to determine if treatment effects
   – Teachers “satisfied”                                          have been maintained

                Secondary Aims                                          Study Outcome Measures
• Examine impact of level of parental ADHD                       • Academic measures
  symptoms on treatment implementation                               – report card grades
  and outcome                                                        – teacher ratings of academic performance
                                                                     – parent ratings of homework problems
• Examine maintenance of treatment                               •   Ratings of organizational skills
  strategies over time and relationship to                       •   Planning tasks
  child’s functioning at follow-up                               •   Family relations
                                                                 •   Children’s attitudes toward school and

               Study Inclusion Criteria
• 8-11 year old boys and girls in 3rd-5th grade (medicated
                                                                          Potential Study Benefits
   or unmedicated)
                                                                 • Improvement in children’s organizational, time
● In mainstream education setting (resource room services          management and planning skills could:
   OK)                                                               – facilitate children’s academic functioning
         -- Not appropriate for children in an all-day special       – enable them to handle increasing task demands as they enter
            education classroom (or if child has a Para)               higher grades
                                                                     – result in less conflict with adults
• Meets diagnostic criteria for ADHD                                 – improve children’s attitudes toward school and teachers
       -- Questionnaires completed by parents and teachers       • Findings will yield essential information about the relative
                                                                   effectiveness of two different treatment approaches for
       -- Formal clinical evaluation done by study staff
                                                                   children with ADHD
• Has OTMP impairments at school or home                             – Influence clinical interventions for children with OTMP deficits
                                                                 • Teachers have the opportunity to learn new skills to help
• Estimated IQ > 85                                                students with organizational difficulties
• Teacher willing to participate

                 Practical Issues                                                Study Extensions
• Current status of the project                                  • Completing a Treatment Development
   – Study approved by NYU IRB and NYC DOE                         Project for Middle School
     Research Protocol Review Committee                            /Departmentalized Settings
• Cost                                                           • Louis Armstrong Middle School is the
   – Treatment is free of charge                                   Laboratory
                                                                 • Changes in program
• Availability of treatment                                          – Small group setting
   – Provided at Child Study Center Manhattan and Lake               – Change in characteristics of the students
     Success offices (located at Queens/Nassau border)               – Aiming to have school personnel deliver the program
      • Facilitates travel
      • Parents reimbursed for travel expenses
      • Children seen after school


Description: Time Management Skills for Children document sample