NFRC 100-2004 Language 07

NFRC 100-2004 Language Ballot - July 2007 NFRC Ballot Comments through July 10, 2007 Technical Committee and U-Factor Subcommittee Section Company Name, Rep Initials and/or AC/NG Page # Pella, JH NG H.ii. & H.v.& L. Andersen Corp, SJ AZS Consulting, AS AZS Consulting, AS Birchpoint, TC AC AC AC AC J.ii 4.2.1 & 4.2.3.1 Document 4.2.1.J.iv & 4.2.1.J.o ALI, BS NG General Marvin Windows, JK AC 4.2.1 Marvin Windows, JK AC 4.2.3.1 PGT, LT NG 4.2.1.J.iii PGT, LT NG 4.2.3.1.B QTI, MM NG 4.2.1.H.iv QTI, MM NG 4.2.1.H.v QTI, MM NG 4.2.1.J.ii QTI, MM NG 4.2.1.J.iv QTI, MM Technoform, MJ NG AC 4.2.3.1.B Document allot - July 2007 y 10, 2007 ubcommittee Comment/Alternate Language What is a “web wall” ??? I will be willing to withdraw my negative if a suitable definition of “web wall” is developed and added to the Glossary. Normally I would offer a recommended definition, but in this case I’m not sure I understand the intent well enough to do so. Section J; ii Allows decorative elements such as brickmolds to be applied to the frame or sash. If this is a valid exception for brickmold, I suggest broadening it to include the words “exterior trim components and/or casings; since brickmolds are one type of exterior trim component. Cross-check and verify "Error! Reference" Editorial changes - remove spaces, adjust "AutoFormat", etc. In 4.2.1, remove the word “vinyl” in items J.iv. and O. (Other materials may be used.) I approve of all the changes proposed in this amendment to the 100 – my objection is with the changing of certification program rules in the latter part of a document cycle. Technical documents should be left intact for their duration. These changes should be part of a larger re-write of the 1002009 document. A product line is a series of fenestration products of the same product type, as listed in Error! Reference source not found.Table 4 3, manufactured from the same profiles and components. The following changes are the only allowable exceptions within a product line: When the changes listed below are made, two or more product lines of the same product type, as listed in Error! Reference source not found.Table 4 3, shall be permitted to be included within the same Validation Test Matrix if the overall U-factor difference between the product lines is ± 0.06 W/m2K (0.01 Btu/h•ft2•ºF) or less when simulated with the lowest center-of-glazing option. Modifying lift or pull handles was moved from 4.2.3.1.B to 4.2.1.J.iii, which I am in favor of. However, in 4.2.1.J.iii "Addition or removal of" is more restrictive than the original langauage 4.2.3.1. Replace with "Changes to geometry or location, or addition or removal of". In 4.2.3.1.B, "Changes to sash profiles only" causes confusion with 4.2.3.1.A, which generally allows "Changes" to switch from outside to inside glazing. Since 4.2.3.1.B is more restrictive, it may be interpreted as the rule. Products with both sash and fixed lites (a typical Single Hung or Horizontal Roller for example) require changes to the sash and framing to change between inside or outside glazing. Suggest striking 4.2.3.1.B entirely, or in 4.2.3.1.B change "Changes to sash profiles only" to "Changes to sasah or frame profiles". Revise as shown in the text: Any changes to the exterior beyond the plane of the nailing fin, the exterior plain of the wall or interior most point of exterior accessory groove, i.e. screen tracks, varying shapes of brickmold, j channels, or stucco bars formed in (integral) or applied to the frame and that do not change the sightline. Revise as shown in the text Any changes or additions to accessory grooves or decorative flanges that do not change the sightline, i.e., lengthening, shortening, and the addition of reinforcing web wall(s). Delete the word Brickmold. This issue is addressed in section H paragraph iv Decorative elements such as grooves, or beads, or brickmomlds formed in or applied to the frame or sash are also allowed. Remove paragraph too materials specific also too ambiguous. Could allow two radically different products to be included in the same product line. Delete the word sash Changes to sash profiles only to accommodate interior and exterior glazed products. Formatting issue…Section letters jump from H to J, J to L. Resolution NG Negative Key: AC Approved w/Comment NFRC 100-2004 Language Ballot - July 2007 NFRC Ballot Results - as of 07/10/2007 Technical Committee and U-Factor Subcommittee Last Name Koustas Rancourt King Wilson Vollmer LaBerge Tinonga Mewbourne Winckler Shillingford Riopel Raske Thompson Petermann Patzer Hunter Lewis Culver Kent Jonely Johnson Fisher Tofflemire Thoman Hill Schultz Harp Gerhardt Carlsen Gramlick Muessig Stewart Egle Black Jayson Ruggles Ritko Culp Smith Stone Pei Adirim Rygg Legros Larsen Bhandari First Name Alex Stephen Scott Paul Ronald Paul Jason Thomas J. Lisa Earlene Gilbert Dennis Chuck Nils Greg Stephen John W. Mike John G. Joe Steven M. Frank Mark Michael Rick Brad Steve David C. Daniel Tracey Patrick M. Arlene Kevin Jim Robert Ken Barry Thomas Ron Garrett A. Ming Ming Aaron Tony Pierre James Mahabir Company Name Approve ABC Window Contractors, Inc. Abritek Windows & Doors, Inc. Accent Windows, Inc. Accurate Dorwin Ltd. ADCO Products, Inc. Advanced Glazings Limited Aegis Window & Door LLC AFG Industries, Inc. 1 AIMCAL - Window Film Committee 1 Airgas, Inc. Air-Ins, Inc. 1 All Metal, Inc. All New Glass, Inc. Alliance to Save Energy Aluminum Extruders Council (AEC) Aluminum Products of Cape Cod, Inc. American Architectural Manufacturers Association (AAMA) Amerimax Building Products, Inc. AMS, Inc. (Administrative Management Systems, Inc.) Amsco Windows 1 Andersen Corporation Arcadia, Inc. Architectural Glass and Aluminum Co. Architectural Testing, Inc. - PA 1 Arkema, Inc. Associated Laboratories, Inc. Associated Materials, Inc. 1 Atria Building Products, Inc. Atrium Companies Inc. Australian Fenestration Rating Council (AFRC) Azon USA, Inc. AZS Consulting, Inc. B&B Engineering Corp. Bekaert Specialty Films, LLC 1 Bendheim Wall Systems, Inc. Berdick Mfg. (Pacific) Ltd. Best Window & Door Co., Inc. Birch Point Consulting LLC BMC West Brickfield, Burchette, Ritts, & Stone, P.C. C.R. Windows Inc. California Deluxe Windows California Energy Commission 1 CANADA WINDOWS & DOORS Cardinal Glass Industries, Inc. CARLI, Inc. Haglund Kerry Huston Ed Arcati John L. Jones Don Cunningham B.J. Hite Allan Richter Stephen T. La Fevre Michael Pennell Bill Kostelecky Jason Deupree Carlos Hetzel Joseph R. Vanderbrugghen Hank Ives John Stuart Charlie Evans Rob Baylon David Rogers Tracy Rosenstock Steve Estrada Lou Noziska Howard Beach Bob Hanam Morgan Funk Isbrand Domocos Ovidiu Maher Bill Jan Anis Williams Ed Flyen Garrett Politi Dan McCluney Dr. W. Ross Wilhelm Dick Freedman Robert Paredes Ivan Trapp Bill Gibson Dolores Andrade Michael Cochran Rollie Carney Greg Croak Bruce Huebner Louis "Buddy" Gorry Henry A. Elias Brian Ricke Larry Kim Jongil Fry Nick Adams Nancy Colon Jose O'Rourke Beth Dube Sylvain Webb Margaret Smith Darrell Center for Sustainable Building Research CertainTeed Corporation Champion Window & Door Champion Window and Patio Room Company Coastal Industries, Inc. Comfort Line, Inc. CrystaLite, Inc. Custom Window Systems, Inc. CW Ohio, Inc. Dak-Cal Glass, Inc. DBA Mid West Glass & Aluminum Dallas Millwork Inc. DASMA (Door & Access Systems Manufacturers Assoc. International) Dayside Industries Ltd Del Storm Products, Inc. Draco Windows Dynamic Windows & Doors, Inc. Ecotope, Inc. Edgetech I.G. Inc. Edison Electric Institute Elite Solar Systems, Inc. Encompass, Inc. Energy Saving Products of Florida Enermodal Engineering Limited Euroline Windows Inc. EuroWind LLC FarNorth Windows & Doors Fenestration Simulation Engineering Fenetherm Fen-Tech Five Star Building Products Florida Solar Energy Center FMA (Fenestration Manufacturers Association) Focus Point Windows and Doors General Aluminum Corporation George W. Trapp Company Gibson Millworks Gienow Windows & Doors Gilwin Company Glass Association of North America (GANA) 1 Graham Architectural Products 1 Great Lakes Window, Inc. Guardian Industries Corp. Hansons Window & Siding Company Inc. Heartland Windows Manufacturing Co. Home-Guard Windows, Inc. Hometime WIndow Inc. Hunter Douglas, Inc. Hurricane Test Laboratory, LLC Ideal Window Manufacturing, Inc. INEX Spacer Inc. Insulating Glass Manufacturers Alliance (IGMA) 1 International Window Film Association 1 DiMarco Gates Maly Strawn Davidson Lybbert Klaus Bartlett Wetmore Falke Kudva Wilcox Selkowitz Emerson Niggli McNiven Roise Linford Kosiver Panarisi Shaner, Jr. Krahn Leslie Mathis Mercer Morris Cochran Bezubic Ward Franson Vilhauer Odegard Abubeker Gunara Murray Durand Yudenfriend Pitts Channell Carter Curran Reid Pecorella Allaire De Block Wright Eilert Flanigan Burks Hayden Lyons Temple Mike Martin Lance Steve Scott Scott Jeff Jeff Chuck Marcia Krish Kenneth G. Steve Randal Larry Scott Geoff Duane "Mac" Michael Paul David C. James C. Roger R. Christopher David W. Dee Gerald Bill Alecia Jeff Kevin Brad Elias Edward Robbie Sharon Herb Roland Scott Tim Dave Phil Robert M. Benoit David A. Richard Patrick Sean David Joe Peter Roland Interstate Building Materials J&M Glass Company, Inc. J.J.J. Specialty Company Jeld-Wen, Inc. Johnson Laminating & Coating, Inc. Jones Paint & Glass, Inc. K&C Industries, Inc. KDL Enterprises, Inc. (Western Skylights) Kensington Windows Inc. Keystone Certifications, Inc. Kinro, Inc. Kolbe & Kolbe Millwork Company, Inc. Lawrence Berkeley National Laboratory LbL Windows and Doors, Inc. Leslie Skylights Lindal Building Products Lindsay Window & Door Linford Glass Co. Lockheed Window Corp. Madico, Inc. Malta Wood Windows, Inc. Marvin Windows & Doors Matthews Millwork, Inc. DBA ThermaBuilt MC SQUARED Mercer Industries, Inc. Metal Window Corporation Metals USA Building Products L.P. MI Windows and Doors Midwest Energy Efficiency Alliance Mikron Industries, Inc. Milgard Manufacturing, Inc. Minnkota Windows Monda Window & Door Corp. Mulia, Inc. Murray Millwork, Inc. National Accreditation & Management Institute (NAMI) National Institute of Building Sciences National Renewable Energy Laboratory (NREL) National Vinyl Products, Inc. New Morning Windows Newpro Manufacturing North East Windows Northern Building Products, Inc. Novatech Glass, Inc. ODL Incorporated Oldcastle Glass, Inc. Pacific Gas & Electric Company (PG&E) Paradigm Window Solutions Paragon Door Designs, Inc. Pella Corporation Peter Lyons & Associates PGT Industries 1 1 1 1 1 Duly David Loomis Nicholas Blyveis Jason Kaliner Adam Adams Danny Jacobsen Cheryl Ward Mike Van Voorst Randal Fugitt Richard Foster David Surace Kevin Miller Robert Kairetz Jerry Sottile Ph.D. Gregory Rogers Christopher Zaremba Thomas S. King Noel E. Efthymiou George Waits Greg Hayes Chuck Hogan John Emmerich Dan Vresilovic Peter Carmichael Sam Shipp Craig Audsley Rick Anderson Chuck Ruel Jean-Francois Jaster Paul Schimmelpenningh Julia Wines Richard Meade John Maki Glenn Gallagher Tom Sprouse Jeff Fabian Art Bochiaro Vincent duPont William Feudner Jim Richter Karl Crouley Richard Huston Edward Tait David B. Jhaveri Milind Curtis Gary Dean Dan Chun Peter Leeds Randy Bean Michael Farley Gene Manteghi Mike Kypreos John Pilkington North America, Inc. Pittsburgh Corning Corporation Polar Seal Window Corp. Power Windows & Siding Premiere Millworks Inc. Prima Products, Inc. - Polybau Windows & Doors Public Supply Company Quality Testing, Inc. Quality Window Manufacturing, Incorporated Quantum Windows & Doors, Inc. Quiet Solution LLC/QuietHome Windows RAM Industries, Inc. Reliance Windows Limited Research Frontiers Incorporated Robert Bowden, Inc. Roetzel & Andress Royal Mouldings Limited Royal Windows Manufacturing Corp. Russell Millworks, Inc. Sage Electrochromics, Inc. Seattle Dept. of Planning and Development Semling-Menke Company, Inc. DBA Semco Windows and Doors Seven D Industries, Inc. Shelter Superstore Corp. Shwinco Industries, Inc. Sierra Pacific Windows Simonton Windows Solaris International Inc. Solatube International, Inc. Solutia, Inc. Southland Windows, Inc. Southwall Technologies Specialty Wholesale Supply Spectra Gases Sprouse Building Products Starline Windows (2001) Ltd. Suburban Building Products Sunergy Consulting Sun-Tek Manufacturing Inc. Superior Seal Corporation SureGuard Vinyl Windows Sycamore Creek Consulting Tait Solar Company, Inc. Technoform The West Wall Group, LLC The Window Factory Thermo Industries, Inc. Thermo-Tite Windows Torrance Aluminum Torrington Lumber Co., Inc. TRACO Tri-State Window Factory Corp. Grech Martin Rose Howard Maniaci John C. Naylor Marcus LeBrun Roger Seba John McGill Marion Shoots R. Joseph Brown Ronnie Strickland Gordy Doerger-Roberts Laura Garceau Timothy White Orlando Wacek Daniel McFalls Roxanne Waldenmeyer U. Jay Valentz Art Sylvester Randy Higgins Fred King William Atkinson Scott Baker Jeff Edgemon Tracy Doegg Keith Shah Bipin Jasewic Bruce Wirthgen Wolfgang Lowinski Jeff Simpkins Steven Madha Jay Turner Mike Turkstra Industries Ltd. United Window & Door Manufacturing, Inc. Unlimited, Inc. Valley Glass Corporation VELUX-America Inc. Ventana USA Viceroy Homes Ltd. Vinyl Design Corporation Vinyl Window Technologies, Inc. VinyLite Windows LLC Vinylmax, LLC Vinyl-Pro, Inc. Vinylume Products, Inc. Viracon, Inc. Viwinco, Inc. VOS Window & Door, Inc. VTech Industries Walsh Building Products Wayne Dalton Corporation Weather King Windows & Doors, Inc. Western Window WESTLab Westwood Millwork, Inc. Wheeler's WinBuild, Inc. WinDoor Incorporated Win-Dor, Inc. Window and Door Manufacturer's Association Window Craft, Inc. Windoworld Industries Inc. YKK AP America, Inc. 1 1 19 Approve w/Comment Do not Approve Abstain Mark Cody 1 1 1 1 1 Nelson Pena Jennifer Heitzenrater Jim Zimick 1 Ray Dill 1 1 Lucas Turner 1 Marles McDonald 1 1 1 John Eisele 1 1 5 4 5