UNITED STATES OF AMERICA FEDERA TRAE COMMISSION In the

Document Sample
UNITED STATES OF AMERICA FEDERA TRAE COMMISSION In the Powered By Docstoc
					                             UNITED STATES OF AMERICA
                            FEDERA TRAE COMMISSION

In the Matter of

EVANSTON NORTHWESTERN HEAL THCARE )
CORPORATION                       ) Docket No. 9315


and                                                ) Honorable Stephen   J. McGuire

EHN MEDICAL GROUP , INC.
     Respondents.


                    MOTION FOR EXTENSION OF TIME TO FILE
                   MOTION TO LIMIT SUBPOENA DUCES TECUM

       UNICARE . HEALTH PLANS OF             TH MIDWEST ,       INC. ("UNICAR"         ), by its
attorneys , Donald A. Murday, Elizabeth G. Doolin and Chittenden , Murday & Novotny LLC , in

accordance with the provisions of the Federal Trade Commission Act, and pursuant to Section

  22 of the Federal Trade Commission Rules of Practice , moves for an extension of time to fie

its motion to limit or quash Subpoena Duces Tecum and to comply with Section 3. 38A. In

support of its motion, UNICAR states as follows:

               Respondents served UNICAR with a Subpoena Duces Tecum issued April 19

2004 , which was received by UNICAR' s         Law Deparent on April         28 , 2004 , with a


compliance date of May 17 2004 (" Subpoena    ). The Subpoena has fort-three   (43) reque sts , six

of which contain subparagraphs   totaling twenty-six subparagraphs and seeks a vast number

documents and a vast amount of information from Janua 1 , 1992 to the present. A true and

correct copy of the Subpoena is attched hereto as Exhibit A.
               Counsel for UNICARE is presently engaged in reviewing the subpoena              and


forming an opinion as to UNICAR' s response thereto. In light ofthe documents sought and the

complexity of the issues presented, UNICAR and its counsel require a reasonable amount of

time to make this evaluation.

               In light of the voluminous   natue of the subpoena ,    UNIC      needs additional

time to evaluate the requests to determine whether and to what extent a motion to quash or limit

the Subpoena may be required and to confer with counsel for Respondents pursuant to Section

 22(f), in order to attempt to resolve objections that may arise.

               Counsel for UNICAR has         exchanged voicemail messages with         counsel for

Respondents , David Dahlquist, to seek an agreed thirt   (30)   day extension oftime for UNICARE

to fie   its motion to quash or limit the Subpoena     and to comply with     Section 3.38A. Mr.

Dahlquist indicated , via voicemail , that he had no objection to UNICARE' s request.

               UNICAR , after receiving and reviewing the Subpoena promptly began its efforts
to retain Chittenden, Murday & Novotny LLC and is filing this motion as soon as reasonably

possible under the circumstaces.        Ths motion     is   brought in good faith and     will not


unecessarly delay these proceedings or prejudice any of the paries to ths Litigation.

                 FORE, UNCAR seeks a th- day (30) extension of time to file its motion to

quash or limit the Subpoena and to comply with Section 3. 38A to and including June 9, 2004.

                                              Respectfully submitted

                                              CHITTENDEN         MUA Y & NOVOTNY LLC
Donald A. Murday
Elizabeth G. Doolin
CHITTENDEN MUA Y & NOVOTNY LLC
303 West Madison Street , Suite 1400
Chicago , Ilinoi 60606
(312) 281- 3600
(312) 281- 3678 (fax)
O:\UN2143\4306FfC\LDGSIMOTIONFOREXTNSION. DOC
EXHIBIT
                                                                                                                           #3770 P. 003
APR:30' 2004 10:46 5

                                         SUBPOENA DUCES TECUM
1. TO   UNCAR HEALTH PLANS OF TH MIWES t
        INC.
                     Issued PurSuant to Rule 3.34b),        34(b)(1$97)
                                                                                   2.
                                                                                         16 C.


                                                                                           UNED. STATES.
                                                                                                           R. S 3.


                                                                                                                           OF    AMRICA
        clo Jay R. Nafge                                                                  FEER TRE COMMSSION
        233 S. W ker Drve, Suite 3900
        This su          reuire you
                             or ta1e ths
        defi at th 3.34(b)). Col1l
                                          to.                Uc and pet
                                                                      or to.
                                                                             ir.s en co
                                                                            peit tnpe of
                                                                                                           of desnated bo docme
                                                                                                                at th dete. an time.
                                                                             th ptno
                                                                                                  prets
             In Rule
                       rest
                         of
                                         1NPEN                  in Item 9,. In               debe'n lte
        lte 6.

                  PRDUTION OR                                                        4. MATEAL WILL BE PRODU               10
3. PL
                                                                                          David Dahquist, Esq.
        Winon & Strwn LLP                                                            5., DATE AND. TIME OF       PRDUcm OR INSPE
        1400 L    Str N.
        Washington D.C. 20005                                                             May 17, 200

$. SUBJCT Of faEEING


         tb Ma      ofEVi Nort                               Rea          CotatiOD" et od. Doket No. 9315
    ID

        See Attached Scede A                                                                                           RECEIVED
7. MAlSL TO BE                                                                                                                   APR 2 8


                                                                                                                       UNICARE- LEGAl DEPARENT

8. ADMINISl1 LAW.JUDE                                                                9. CONSEL            RENG SUBPOEN
                                                                                           Michael L. Sibarum
    Th Hoiae sU:pb: J. McGl,\t                                                             Charles B. Klein
                         . 0                                                               Winon & Strwn LLP
        Fed ra 'tp-Qm                                                                       1400 L Stret, N.
              mngtn. .D            ' 2058                                                   Wasbingon                 C. 2005
 DA11                                                                   SIGTU

                                                       0..
                                                                        GENERAL INSUCTlON$
                                                                                                                TRYS     exes
        lel se' fcfc
                                           19"'
                                                I ..

                                                  yOl.byanmet
                                                s Rues of Pmcce is
                                                                                        Th Coison's Rutes Of Prace reuire ha
                                                                                        mi,  be pe bY. th
                                                                                        apranc..
                                                                                                             that
                                                                                                           YOIJ sho
                                                                                                                      pa        re          f
                                                                                                                                yo daim to COnse
                                                                                                                                                end


        impo byla'
                           i'                   yo to a Penalty
                                         to compty.                                     fIS In Item 9. for. pGent. , IfQther thnpermney
                                                                                        \epoli sorn
                                                                                        this subponQ end It wold reir e
                                                                                                                           yo
                                                                                                                                 th        ad
                                                                                                                                  iY trvel for
                      MOTI TO LIMIT OR. QUASH                                           yo to  appear. yo must get prior apprl fr coel
        Th Cois"s        Rues of Prctce reit that any                                   fite In    tte 9.
        moon to liit
                                         se
                   or quh this supoena be fied within
        th earf of 10 day after      0( th time
        c:mpRao. Th orna1 and ten CO of the petitin
                                th Secta
        mut be tied \'th
        COrnssn. accpaned by an
        th docmet up
                                  of th Feeql Trede
                                                       aff      of sece of
                                                        In Item 9, en upo               Th subpna doe not rere 198.             apl   by OMS .mer
        aU   oth paries p
                                 couns

                                          by the        Ru         of       ce.         th PapeMO Redon Ad   of


 FT 'For            (re. 11!7)
                                                                                                            #3770 P. 004
APR. 30' 2004 10:47 5




                                                             SCHULE A


                           Unless otherise specified the tie              perod addressed by ths Schedule is


       Jan 1, 19971hug the preent day. Al referces to year refer to a calenda ye.
                           If yo nave prouce documts                   rensve to this Schedufe in the coure of the              wO .
                 plait inves gation of           s matter.              ile No . 0110234, those documen need not be

       prouced aga so lon           as such   documents ar            identied by Bates        ra or comarble mea in
       your respnse to ths snbpoe

                 c. If                                                                   t .          Q.f riy.U       Uy'


                 clai tbe                                                      the                oft1s Su          In .
       s!miar
        addition yo        tr   submit, togeter with the clai             ofprvitege, a        og statg   the followig


        informion for eah data item withld:                     (a) the spifcatons and sub-         spification for which
        the   daa is reonsive; (b) the       ty or      spific subject maer,             and   date of the data (c) the names

        addres. postions.          and   orgnizaons of aU authrs and reipients of the data; and (d) the

        specific grunds for claing           that the data is         rivile         with suffcient parculaty an     det
                                                                                              o.nJy some
        pert th Admstrtive               Law 1udge to adjudicae the valdity of such claim. If

        pqon of      any    re!N         innnaton or da is preged all non-prvieg poon of the

         inormation or data mu           be submtt
                            With taect to specfic docents              pruce in respnse to 111s Schedule, each
         docent prvide shal              be coplete an           uness prvilege, undacted and submitted as foud

         in your fies (e.g.     docen that in their orgina codition were stpled. clipped or otherse
                                                                                                  photocopies (with color
         fastened together shan be pruced              in suh for). You              may subit


          photocopies whe neeSSar to interet                    the   document) in lieu of orginal documents prvided
                                                                                                            #3770 P.
APR. 30' 2004 10:47 5




                         ar acompaned by an affdavit ofan offce                         of Your   Company stating tht        the
       tht sucb copies


       copies ar   tre, corrct and   colete o(1 es oft be          0.a1 documents
                        Eah docuent pruced by you in rense to th                                Sche        .ould. mat:


                              cat an eem;            iveeo                   CQDtm         number . To the exten you
                                                                                                                                    LJ   t6




       prced docen in the co                      e pr6J           )?i     t u,.......;   wtin ofthis mattea, FT File No.
                         us a diernt "rejjx on docents J'ro                                in          se to ths Schede. In
       011 023,    pl

       additio all documen prouced in reponse                to the Schedule shal be              orgzed an      labeled




                    with each reuest or any     pa therf.
               F.       In the evet that any docwnent         refer to or identified ha been destrye                        or


        other dispsed pf, that doct is to be                 identied by          (i)     the autor (n)    th addrs

        includi persons to whom b1in         coies   we addrssed; (iii) the date; (iv) the subjec matter (v)
        the numbe of pages , atchments or apendices; (vi) al                   peon to wpom the docent                     was

                                                                                                                   the
        distbuted shown or    exlained, (vii) a descrption of the circumstaces under which

        document was     deye        or disposed of; (vii)     th dae of deston                   or oter dispsition; (ix) the

                                                                                                       who dited or
        pen who desyed or dispsed of the document; and (x) th person
        auori such destrcton or dispsition.
                         Ths Schedule is contnui an any doument obted                                  su.bson to pructon
                                                                                at the tie of
        tht would have    bee prduced ha it been avable or its exstence be know

         pruction shalt be pruced fortwith.
                   H. Th       chedule is intended to include all requested documents in the possession.
                                                                                                                           wherer
         cutody or contrl otfour Compa and all invidu purortng to ac on
                                                                        its beha1


         loced and by    whomever     prar
                                                                                                               #3770 P. 006
APR. 30' 2004 10:47 5




                            Refece to an          individual   sba also refer to tht       individuaPs precessors and


       succesor in         iner dit or indit, and his or her he employees, asign                                tt           qtates,

       attorneys and agen.

                             Referce to an entity shall also refer to that entity' coanes corptions

       divisions. deparents assocations                   par,         joint    ven, tr,                subsidiares, a.ffates,


       and any other fOts of busiess or commecial orgiztion                           Ot   atngement,        presrs and
       succsors in         inte, di             or indirect, an its past   prt and futu parer assoiates,
       offcm, dirors, sharolder. prcipals, employees, reresentatives,                                   asgns, advisors,

       attrney and          agents.

                             The wo           Uand"   and "   " shaU be consted conjunctively or disunctively as

       neces to make th reuest inclusive rather than exclusive. The word ' 'icludg " shan be
       coned to mea 'Wthout liitation. Th ters "each" and Hall" ar to be constcted as a
       reues tht ever document
                                                      piece of inforaton   be   identifed separely.

                             The use of the past tene shn inlude 1he presen tene. an the use of the present

        tene sh include the pa tense, so as to mae the reue inclusive rather than exclusive
                                 The   sigu includes the plur aud vice vers
                  N. Th pruetion of doen pur to                                  th                          . t tQ_ tbe             and

        COnd                                                   er.

                        , MY           question you have      relat to th scope or mean of anytng in ths
        Schedule or any suggestions for possible modfications thero should be dirted                                 to    David E.

        Dalouist at (312) 558-5660 or ddaquist                         ton.com. A reonse to th Subpen shan be

                                                 David E. DahlQuist. Esq., Win        ton & Stmwn LLP           3S        West W:;
        addTCssed to the          attion of




        Drve, Chcago, IL 60601-9703.
                                                                                             #3770 p. 007
APR.   2004 10:46 5




                                               DEt"lNl'

                      The ter uoonstute        cotain" "              analyze " or "relate to

       CQnsttong   reec. reectig, regag,            conceg,        perg to refer               to   relatg to,

       stti descrbing, rerd noti, emboyig, memoralizi contag. menonig,
       stdyig, assesin analyzg or discssing.
                       The ten udocument" is used   he in the broadest sense permissible unde
       Federa Trae    Coion R1,e of Prctice 3.       34(b) and includes without           limitaon,   wrti,
       drwing, grphs      cha hawrtten note, fi            pbotopphs, audio an video rerdgs and
                                                                                           magetic or
       any such reretations stored on a compute, a computer disk CD.

       electrnic tae, or auy oter meas of electrnic storage,
                                                                   an other compilations frm which
       information ca   be obtaed in machine-reable form
                                                                 (trlated, if neessa, into tewnably

       usable form by the peron subjec to the Subpoen). Th          ter "docuen" includes electrnic

       mail an    dr    of documents copies of docents that ar       not   identical duplicates of the


       orlgiuals, an copies of documents the   orils of which are not in your possession custy or
        contrl.
                        The ter   "EN" mean Evan Norwester Heathar Cororon
                                     GjenbIOkH               anHi_). di,
                                                                      itspaW.
                                                                 ventu      joint
        precesrs diviions, sdbsdiares afliates paerps an
                                                                                               and al


                                                                                              subsidiar,
        offcer, employees, agents, and   reresentatives of the foregoin. The        ter



                                                                                           mor) or
         afiate" and '   oint ventu" refer to any pern in whi h ther is paral (25 peren or

        tota ownp or contr1 beeen EN and any other pern.
                                   and Par trsacion" mea the merge                                      ENH and
                 The ten
                                                                                              be




        J:ghan Park Hos.h which wa conated
                                                            in   1anua 2000.
                                                                                             #3770 P. 008
APR. 30'2004 10:48 5




                                                                        Grup, Inc.,              its
                       The   ter           Medical Grup" meas ENH Medca

       preecessors an    aflites.
                       The teI "Gegrphic                  ' mea    La, Cook, Kae Kena1l, and McHen
       counties in Dlinois

                       The ter     "heath car facilit         mea a hospital, health matenance oraniztion
                                              fi     aid or other cUnc, urent car center,
                                                                                          fre-stding
        failty, ambuto car ceter,
        emercy ca cete, imag                  center, ambula        su     cener and al   oter entities tht

        provide heath cat     serces.
                        The ter       eath ca        servce"   mean a mecal or suca       sece or prceur
        peoI1 at a heath car faclity.                                                            among other
                        The   te -'hospital" is a type of heath car       facty tht provides


         seice   inatient health
                                     ca serices.
                                                           HospitaJ, its par,
                         Th te Highand Par mea Highlad par
                                                                  parerhips an joint ventu,     and aU   ditors,
         presor         division subsidiares,         efliates,


         offce:, employees agents and reentatives
                                                                  oftb foreoing.

                                                                                 physcian
                      Th tcn '             IPA" mea the Highand Park Independent
                                           gbd Par




         Asaton.
                          The ten ' "licened be" mea               be reogn author or aped by the
          State ofIDinois.
                                                               mea a pern other than a natu      peron that pays
                          The tenn -'t pa payor"

          any heath care     ex       of my other peron, and all of its     dito. offcer emp1oye, agen
                                                        lited to: Blue Cro and Blue Sheld
          an reestaves Th par payor inludes, but is not
          plan commerial ince companes, heath
                                              maitence orzations, preerr provider
APR. 30'   2004 10:485                                                                                          #3770 P. 009




           oranzations, comtie medcal plans, unon                         tr       fuds, multiple    employer   tr. corprae
           or goemeota1 self-insurd heath beefit pla.                      Metca, Medicaid, OJ; CHAMS.
                             The ter 'Cyou" or "Your Company" mea UniCar Health Plan oftbe

           Midwest, In. and any of its subsidiares, afliates or predeec;rs tht                        ar licensed     as heath

           maintence organ              ons or that offer any form ofhea                ince product of the varety
           knwn as poin of sece products.


                             Fro Janua It 1992 to the pre                   day,     aU contr betwee any             th pa
                    (inudi      but not limited to,          ur Conmaq) and           any heath     ca   facilty in th


           Gegrhic Ar1\ inluding aU                   amendments, apendices. and           related documents reflecting any

           contr tens.
                             AU documents referr or relatig in any                    maer to the crter         or   fators us by

           Your Company       in selectinp: which hea                acilitv to         ntr with an all documents tbat
           aply those crtera      to such health        car facilities.
                             Docuents (in electronic fo            if th exst) sufcient to
                          inludig monthy enUment number). subscrber or patients and the number of
                          -ssc"b       for aU    maged heath ca -pJa spnso                      or   admst by yOU
       Som
                             All d ocen J'la                to compettion amon th par pavo rclati2 to heath

           car facilties in the Gegrhic Area, inclu               di      but Dot    limted to the de.irbiUty        or n   sity of

           enter into contr with parcuar health ca falities in the Googmhic                                           includin
           ENH.
                                                                                                               #3770 P. 010
APR. 30' 2004 10:49 5




                    Al docuents relatig to cotion in the prvision of any heath car
                                                                                   serce

       in the Gegrphic Area includi, but not limted to, market stue
                                                                    ror an- suey and           s,
                                                                                                          s,




       all other documts             reg to:
                     (a)                the maket shar or co                 tive WIi01 of anv' heath care faci lity

                     (b)                the    quality of            prvided by any he1tb care faility

                     (c)                the relatve       stgt or w              s ofbeath care facties providi          any


               heath care sece;
                         (d)             suly and         demd contioni
                         (e)                   alth   ca facilty             ce ot' pem tions of employe, conswner,

               broker, unon, associations, patien or cutomer wh reide, or physcian who

               wactice; in any porton of the Gegraphic
                                                preferce nfthird patyp                (includi but      not limited to, Your
                         (f)             the




               Compay)              fo heath          ca facilties that include        tb   ca facilties locted in any
               portion of the           Gegrc Ar
                                             any anyss of aUernative medcal          or sugical rocedurs wbich


                af the tie sp                         by any   inaten-U a hnwita for the time perod            frm Januar 2000


                to th prent.

                6.             Al douments
                                                                      comparg or evaluag the serce, the

                       ofser                                           e Ge hic
         sees,     the cost
                                              e faclities ofho
                                                         e stff or




         inludi but not liited to, Evanton Hospita, Glenbrk Hospital an Highand Park.
                               Al qocuments             rela to any study, anysis, reort. summar or talatWD
                                                                                                    fr 31 hospital in the
         rearng tmy chatcterstic of any patients admed or discba~ed
         Gegthi Ar includ such chaacterstics as: age; plac of reidence; tye of admission;
                                                                                                                    #3770 p. Oll
APR. 30' 2004 10:49 5




       pricipal diagnosi;                 prur performed;             chaes; payments;      admittg physcian, physician

       grup or physcian organtion; category ofth                              pa payor afiaton.
                                                                    Your Copany s negotiation of contrts               with   any
                                        l docents relati       to


       hospita in the              Gegrc Ar including but not lited to all docuents relatig to any
        deternaon of                    whet or not to negtiate with any                 ar hosmtal, any actual or potential

        teron of such                     contrct, any decision       to later reen negotiations afer           temion, and any
                         EN or any other hospita to negotiate or agre                 upon tens wi
        refu1 by

                                   Al documents              yzin suarg,           desn'bing,      refe        or relatilU in any

                                                                                                                    any hOSita in the
        maner to You Comprs contr , contrct                                     osa1s or negotiations with



        Geogrphic
                       10.         Al    docen referg or relati                in any maer to any thTr p             rr P


         (inc:luding but not limted to Your Compy                        s)      erficati     an    medca managemen


        policies,       pro                  or protocls (includi      but    not limited to. concUlt        reews. re.fs,

         etc.)   aplicable to any hospital
                                                           il1 the Geophic

                       11.          Al docen sucient to show for any                 th part payo           (includi Your


         Compay) an if available, for each prduct sold by such th par payor:
                             (a)




                             (b) th to
                                                  the tota numbe ofmembe subsc'b enUee,

                                                  10 ;,                 ea hota in th Gehic
                                                           number ofmembc        enllees,
                                                                                                                Ar
                                                                                                              orpaen who have

                                                                                            subscbers or patients




                       in the Gegrphi.c Ara and. who have been                  adtted to or discharedjim eab bo. ita

                       in the                     hic AT
APR. 30' 2004 10:49 5
                                                                                                            #3770 P. 012




                         (c)            the    tota dollar am01Dt biUed by an              d to eah hospi    in the

                 Gegrphic Ar on behal of member, subscriber. enollees or patients redi in the
                 Gegrhic Ar; and
                         (d)                  e hospitaJ days pertbousd of your enll

                 12.           AU doouments (in machine reable                 data if available) sufficient to estblish
       separly for each                enllee,    subscriber or patient of Your Company who reides in the

       Gegrphc Ara and who wa adtted to a hospta:
                         (a)            the zi    code of    the patient' s redence;

                         (b)            the date of   adssion;
                         (c)            the prcipal        diagnosi;

                         (d)             the numbe of hospita days for that admission;

                         (e)             the amounts bited          and paid   by Your Company for that admsson; and

                         (f)             the jdentity of the        adtt physician for that admssion.
                  13.Doents sucient to estblish for each year the tota numbe of trtments by
       Interational Clasc;caton of Diseases (lCD) codes (whether or not restig in an adssion)

        an   th tota amount biled to                       aid by Your Compan to each hea cae facility in the

                   11c                                      inent
                                                                                         for       encY       orotb
                         orcl
                  14. AD documents descrbing, discuin,                            suzing
        hositas in the Gegrph Ara by enollees in any maaged health car                                 plan you sponsor


        admster.
                  15.          Documents (in machine redable fonn ifavailable)                  suffcil"t tn iJifyth

       -physician 1)a: ipA                          ft!l            health       plan that Your Company sponsrs or
APR. 30' 2004 10:49 5                                                                         #3770 P. 013




       ad           who have   admtt privieges at any hospital in the Geogrhic          Ara and, as to each

       such physci                                         s:

                               the location of the physician s om e or offces;

                    (b)        the physicia' s medical spalty

                    (c)        the physician s Univeral Prvider Identification Number;

                    (d)        the physician s Dlnois licee number,

                    (e)        any other identication number your plan assign to the physichm;

                               the aggate number of adssions of enllees in the manag                 heath

                               you spons or    adm             that the physcian mae eah year at each

              hospital;

                               tbe total amount biled    or pad to each hospita each   ye as a reult of tht
              physician adssions to the        retive hoitas;
                    (h)        the aggrate numbe of outpatient procedures peonned on enllee                  in
              the   man heath car plans tht you spnsor or adster that the physcian mae
              each year at each heath     car facilty and


                     (i)       the   to amount biled or paid to ea heath ca facilty ea year as a
              xe of that physcian s ouatent           ps                penned to th reecve heth cae


                                     cn refer    or relatig in any maner to the     shft 9r   diver~
       iments to dive                of patients or any categor of patents to or frm any hospita Qf any

        heath ca faclity in th Gegrhic Ara by any th par payor, inc1u                     , but not limited to,

        YOW' Company.
                                                                                                                   #3770 P.
APR. 30' 2004 10:50 5




               17. All sp        eehes. arclcs   press relees publications COtTspondcmce with public

       agecies or authorities, or tetiony        of mangeen of Your Compay                          regarg                     mer
       consJidation or combination of hospita generly, (ii) th merer
                                                                                                nsolid            t1nn tn



         ombinon Qiart'1121 \w9pi              IIl1bQ    CfgI              brel or   (Hi)   the' role        of   acemia or

        teachig hospitS.
               18.        Al docents referg or relati               in any    maner to any off                    to or by any thtd
                                                                                     designte any hospita in the
        par payor (includi        but   not lited   to   Your Compan) to




        Gegrphic Area as its sole prefet provider with                     a netork for any category of serce or
        for any grup of enllees or physcian or for any gegr                      i.c ara tht inludes any                    porton of

        the Gegrhic        Ar.
                19.       A1 doents        referg or relatig to an            coplait by Your Compay tht any

        heth ca failty i! the Gegrhic Ara (includ, but not lite                                 to,                ) is not   acti
        compettively, is violati        the antitrd lft-    01 is com"           unaily

                2Q.       All   docen refer           or relatig to any       complait by Your                    Company that any

        heatb ca       facilty in the   Gepphic Ara (includ but not limted to

                                mas without Dotice.
        rates on it

                                c\ te
                        chare

                  1. AJ                               or.. m               aDlI             10 Ih




                22.        AD prit adverseents and           the tcxts of any radio or televion adverseents

         tht refer or   relate to any heath ca      fail\ty an a reentaive sample of aU sales and
         promotion Jitertu of Your Company

                 23.       Al prosas to emloy,              SpDSOIS. employer groups, unions, agencies. counties

         or muncipalties tht       disc hospitals located in tbe Gegrpbic Ar.
APR. 30' 2004 10:50 5
                                                                                                                                    #3770 P. 015




               24.          Documents sucient              to show a11         mage heath care plan or prduct                                 offer

       by Your Company inclu                      documents reatig to development of'thse                           plans.           and the term

       an condions and             tO seces provided                by such plan.


               25.          All docents            reer or           relati in any           IIer to the bass upon which (i)
       emJ9 select or are peeied to se1ect amon2 thrd par                                          p          or (ii)    enllee se1ect or
       ar
            peved to selec among thrd Par payors.
                26. AU docwncnts constitutig,                        refer            or relatig to any                      aits           bvsci

       subscn"b enl1ees or patients reedin any decsion of any thrd par                                                  "awr (includin You,

        Company) to dict           a patient, enllee or subscber to a hospita for adssion or to a physcian
        for dignosis oX' tratment other than the hospita or physkian to which such enrllee,                                                 patient or


        subscn"ber (or .a     physician on his or her behal origily sought adission                                      ot'        trtment.



                                r-               refer or relat to any tl
                27.         Documents                                                           p ary     payor   s (includin Your

        Comy          s) policies, gudelmes or                 ctces relatig to utilition                  ofbosoita in the                         phic

                 lud but not lied to, provider mauas; member handbooks; docuents relatig to
        utilzation    re crtera and usge                    ofhospita; and                    other docents tht defie

        digu beee pri. senda                                        or terar ho            itals for      any pur ose.

                28.         All    docts relat to ac                                     car out" or tier sece
                                                                              or prposed "

        rontrcts     purt to which Your Coroany ha                              agf to diver patients for sece to any
        provide other than EN.

                29.          All   docen           re)atig to the        Nortwe em Healthcm: Net                                    k since its .

        incepon.
                30.          All docents tht discuss th                      use or    potential us of alternatie                     coctg
        metod010gies, inludig but not limte to discount off1ist pricing or per diem prcin.
APR. 30' 2004 10:50 5                                                                                           #3770 P.




                                                                      crtion of any               icia: networks in the
               31.        AU documents tht            discuss the



                                                                          the cost of creati       such   networks.
      Gegrhic Area inluding, but not limite                         tOt


               32.        Al doents relati                  to   cotm with physcian grups in th Geogrhio
      Ar      includig, but not        Hmted to, the EN Medcal Grup                          the Highand Park IPA.

               33.        Atl docuents tht             discss the      reJative benefits o  fh usc ofMedca s Resurce
                                                 to deterin the amount of 1)y for f)hYScian                 s     es.
      Ba.qe Relatve Value S

               34.        AD docuents relatig to the relatve c:osts burens, and/or benefits of

       negotiatng contrac usin the messenger                        models.


               35.        AU documents relating to the way in which Your Cetany preses
                                                                                                                        paynts
        bys       s with contrct         with     multiple entities, such as multiple independent physician

       asocations.
                36.       4\1 subpoenas received frm U, S. Feder Trade
                                                                       Comssion in connection with

       the ENHighand Pak trqaction.

                37.       Al coxrndence with                          docents that constitue any indice of docuents
       proced to, the U. S. Fed                  Trae Commsson in connecon with tbe ENghand Park

       ttacon.
                38'. Al               mnen        rela to any incr in ince prum that Your Coan
       asser wa caused           by th                           d Par

                39. An                          councations with your customer (includiug but
                                 documents reflecting any




        not limted to broker, emloye, associations or unons) about the raes cham
                                                                                 bv

                                         1..;c
        hositas in the
                 40.       All   docent whic1\ constitute any                  tr      manuals,        maua1          guides (o

        siilar documts) whih demonstre common technques used by your couttt negotiations.
                                                                                      #3770 p. 0:17
APR. 30' 2004 10:51 5




              41.       Al documents which   oontute press f10w diagrams related to contrctng         witb


       or reimburemt of prviders or heathca faci1ties and orgational             chas.
              42.       Al docents referng or relati    to any policies,   theores or practces of payig

       difft prices to hea car failties ba.a on the qualty of ca prVided at the failty.
               43.      Al docents rermi or relati      in any   maer to hositals identified by Your
                                                                                         highest
       Compay as ..center of excenence ' or any equiva1ent aplications mea to connte the

       quality ofbospita   ca for any serce.




              71.
APR. 30' 2004 10:51 5                                                                    #3770 P. Q18
 n/:   /O.    1Jtl1 n:     ZOUZ8Z4Z7                .AIIN LAW                     'I            tafol0/0n
                                                                                                        'I -




                                       tJSTATE OF AMCA
                                            TRE COON
                                        OJ.                TS1A\VJtQ1



       Jntb         of '
       BVANNORtaTBHP".E
       CORPRATtON.
       aDd                                                               DokcNo. 9315
                   CAGR           IN:


                                                                QR1ER
                                                                 YM.TE
               .For1h                   og.                                             eab!M

                                                    d!o-of

               rrlS!                                     P:1
                                                                 ofilj




                                                     Coom
       HeC3                                               aD~             .~:tnwaorihStof

                                                                                                               . L
                                                                                                               . 1:


                                              . 0
                                                                                                                                                            #3770 P. 019
APR. 30' 2004 10:51 5
 o"2ilO(                     15:       II    ZO%     Z8Z42f                     ,mDH IAW                                S.                                                 Oll/0n
                                                                                                   It




                                                                                                                                                       60i,, N\d
           D.,                 wiits
                                                                                 at   1301         Cc
                                                                                                                                          Dl




           its
                                                               wbsdics
                                                                               .Fnp..                                    :8Ijc
                                             aN                          Med    Om" XD88                                                                C8




                                                                                      1h     \a         of1he.st
                                                                                                                                          wiitprpa1
                      eoti



            p1s                                                                               I! IJ                      201. N1    its                par
                                                                                                                                    ve.
                                              81: 1301


                                                                                                                              omt
                                            !Bkm,,                              8t                                 s.




                                                                                      Fed Th C                                       OI 8n     of it

                                                                                       oniUbe                                                  tetdM
                 C0                                      fo               of1b

                 4-



                 pret                                                                   . TN8r                                                         to




                                                ou            Oor                                                                         i46(f)
                                       1!


                        10(oX oie;                                              i6 c:.I!                4.10(                        26(.)( oflh
                 Ru1csofCi                                     28UiS.            Q)(;m                                                             cI;
                                                                                                                                                                  ob .


                               til1,                                                                                                .isa                            Ve:


                  llof                        oi4-                                                                            d:dev
                                                               (in
                                                                                                                                                   b&-
                  Maa1:



                  a1an                                                                 avnobc
                                                                                                        Wh1                                                  C3    d:. :




                                                                                                  it.ornou                                         ptq
                                                                                                                           #3770 P. 020

                   O'
APR:30' 2004 10:51 5
   /!4104               31'AX '02S2824f                      A,JD)l tAW

                                                                                                                     ..1
                                                                                                                                  IZ 0 12/0:1 1

                                                                                                                                          .0:




            t\dal dat          Clrprea                     coer. cu.orDr                                       or


            apJice1      tQ                   ibD3ke                      1hdil                chCOul




                                                          ooDOt                                         dono

                                                        PistMMa,4
                                                                                               mdd

                   5tobe                                              F'ftJl                             cw.




            ma81 Wi                                                 ifit is ittb"          dQr
                                                               l w1ioha                                         'itbma.
            6.                                  m.' a Parfb i9 tUsiq                 Qf;                dioBi
            mstO                      aI pm


            7.
                                                                                                               hrga
                                                dtt-.
            plor                              =He
            giv=wonc
                                                                          Parln                _!B
                                                                                                         abIa1b1
                       .ed
             s.                                                            or&                                      COJl

                                                 .Or                   maDO
                                                    .i8!8n..vf
                              ccI;"                                                        Oi,.tb

                                  natli:                                            O"'
                                                                                               :so                  hEd
                                                                                                                    #3770 P. 021
APR. 30' 2004 10:52 5
                                                                     DUN .                                                   IaOU/O
 O'/   1/0C         1': 32   PAX 20Z'282CI'

                                          ...i'"




                                                   ln tabu gnb.               drwb




                                                    .da               4aprcs
                                 'amecr             ot
                                                                                                     bOk.




         tQ" caCldF                                                                                     . o
         eOJ",-                      or   QUw, .
                                            - da
                                                                 mw   _. ,uVIo . "
                                                                            w1J               on Ci    be    o'ed
         '9.                                                   fJ      or                     1I            uss: VJ I!
         1'            to                            Co1otRc.sPO                                            fhth         Dr.to


                            on atW




          10.                         JCcath                           InP;MfJrtrl
                                                                                                      d)31  .0
          tbF ct Tna

                                                   ttm   (1)th          5mcr.
              11.                                                                    i: . '



              Itdein
              8Uwboi9
                    loy byauch1&
              stdmfa1Ol
                                          . 1                (s);'
                                                                            O ofei

                                                                            ;lIa)
                                                                                              . 1 0

                                                                                                            O'de.


              1O..-'c8
               :eW1
                                                     whU;6
                                                      ...
                                                                 itopcdjm
                                                                 tO:a .
                                                                   .1
                                                                     S:.I"
                                                                            U- 11
                                                                             'I      : : A-!.:..       n:-- -'_
                                                                                                            \I!o     J1. .

                                                                              1b_




                                                                                              .. I
                                                                                                                                      #3770 P. 022
        30' 2004 10:52 5
APR
 0:/21/0,f                 1StU       A% 2023282 2'1                                J.!1                                                     !iOU/OU
             II




                                                   t:(b'trr.       B'V          Not                                CmOD.
              HvaN                                        Gr.
                                                                                                                    so1e
                  1).                               wm)p.



                                                   ontg                mt. Ottt
                                                             aPa or Tb:Pm1D                                                topr
                  14.                             Pa
                                                             to          ortb     es W"1'                iQ
                                                                                                                    c1a1Di

                  Ma of.. Th Pm                             in                   CUY.                    1 of       FT Of        ha




                                             FT bJ th Ma.         lh              P' s);
                                                                                                         1b& Th               1h
                                   'b mr
                                                                                        81 to    tb.          'J           T4g    Pat sbpU
                                           det\
                  on

                                                                                                                            by.

                                    tiPT '                   ofan


                                                                                        1're;                       QD.m.
                   15.



                   N---. Mt n.-
                   v.-"'

                                                                                                  i ..


                    16.


                                                                                )bar1h                   !;nOq      1).
                                  at=:tt.t
                                                                                                                            :ot
                    co=d                                                                                                                  lC$ of



                    ia&                                                                                             piCC
                    ms                            :piQDpl                 inf              1rc




                    phdA
                                                                                        1O
                                                                                                                        #3770 P. 023
APR30' 2004 10: 52 5
 D3/21/    1S:       20Z'2$Z4ZT                                    L\'!   Jts:                                                 W01S/031
                                                                                                                                   .. C




           'b G1           of'Wh wou1 h1:tly t1
                                                                                         COoill:h                It iB



                                                                                                                         tb
                oftb pan   fh ibs                                                                        use
                                                                                              VIiJJ b=
           OD                       pecuad




      17.    Pa"                                                                                                on 01




                                                                                   plO                         ffOc.
      1c cn aotati IS aPa. w                 tf

                m4   ag.
                                  ANC                         9N.
                        Mia1 Ot2n                                                                        soe)
       fopm. QfWau.. and                                      :f          oth                                    QU;'


                               a1pu                                                                        rm,-
                                  La 1                                                  oI.              orany:.
       8p101b;                                    f'ap.,of&




       Ma0I:                   aeVcd                                                                                       thm
        ev_the!Pa                             Dj Ma
       1eavoto40:f bY                                               i'W1be         I'            tae                    e.tO
                           . II Ma.
                              o$$1                             MdhlJ.                   .. a
                                                                                   i'. . II . " .
                                                                                                                          .I
       onyusor
                                                                    :I
                                                                                                          ce




       21 oftbF         T.ae                           _diaca:so
                                                                                                         ;ai(2)
       iegaobIimi                                                                   :in'                    '
                                                                                                         dir.wi I
                                                                                affb.
                           11i;"U'.;..
                                                                                                                                                  #3770 P. Q24
APR . 30' 2004 10: 53 5                                                                                                                                         W01810'1
                                   202 2e242J                                   .IN
 02/2   /O(
        ""11




                                                                                                                                md
                                                                                                       as
                                        c.cc               ihc 4                      ofmQ

        2. 11



                         at   Auoq Ey 0n.


                      (n)
                                               ono1                        IS                       ;s" FlDoc                        NP.        931S,




                                                                                  u CO                                                     a1   'b P'
                      Dha)                          aabe

                                                                                                                         Wi 1h 1ebiliCth
                                                             in6                               -w    DOt

              Paes by plango.                                                                                                                              ";W'r.

              th   pltal:lO                "E"                Ft      DocNo.                  931      (01


                                                                                                                             Code Di5C
                                                                                                                    au

                            1OtbMat) 't (h;f pg at a docmem
                                   Par1.                             _ca                        rl1o                        plge.of"
                                                                                                                                 Rpmo12
                                           dei
                                                                                                                JtsU
                                                                                             :m:


                   "'wi                                             iIpr.                                                mico
                                                                                                                                           do'"
                                   by               b..Par


                         !I) . .
                                                           ..D
                                                                                                                                                 Ano
                                                                   9:US.
                   EY9NL

                                                                                                                                       tb.
                            !a.
                                                                                               c:i.                           .a..


                                                                                                                                                                    b1 .
                   de'                         aB
                                                                                                             :BY.   03)FT
                                                                                                                                                    "fQ;




                                                                     OD""_oflh
                                                                                        . 7
                                                                                                                                 #3770 p. 025
                                                                                                                                           D1T/tlU
      30' 2004 10:53 5                                       AnJl!
O'/    ./04 11:"        PAl ZOZ'Z'




                                                                                                                            oucc
                           todt
                                                                                                          setive
                                            h pageof'e.


                                                                                         .' S\dl     desat sb bcmad
                                            Cdckal. A                   By

         WfonUD as
                                                                                          ud
                                                                                                                    a 8od-
         witb fulMtt                    &a the uuti       p1d"O
                                                                                                                   on t1: 8J:th
                     'IIa! m1.bj   cc fo1b hx (I 1h'h ma.                                 tb




                        sC*              matat ib         sb4
                                                                  bettasR                                                   AUBy
          2yO..                         RiOD

          cmy 1Dti
                                           ofih               dAaf1b pu1;QWm                       ofth



                                                                  bedegn                             CcClem.1,
                      !tis .,cipa         1b                 to

           amy mayisclnd                    1\M

                                               prci&n                                                              piau
                                                                                                  1bt1 pacuy
                                                                                    OD
                         on&o      1i       pipd.T)



                                                  Jia
                                                                                                                                     p1;t
                                                          EyO:1.mn dite
                                                                                                                    Couo

            .Rd:
                                                                    apb e))
                                                                                                                           _l1tb.
                                                           1i1rl1.0r                     .. t '             (d)

                                               cm(G)-                         )naI.                                R8ct
                                                                                                                             a48:
                                   O%m
                                                                  D1h        bith              CoJ!                          vo Ms:
                              iI

                                                                                                                           0a.
              s1:i
                                                                                                                                              #3770 1'. 026
      30' 2004 10:53 5
                       202S181.27                                                                                                                           qjoll
031f4/04      1S:3
                                                                                                                                                                , 8




                              Dil           ofRatcm,                 CoDf-                         ByDOD Mate1'                              vt

     Of                       arTr crDesi

                  If arPm des                to di                           t()                   A#J:                   Eye amy            .u




                                        at1r ordCsiQD thdic:g:Pat                                      sb1             aa1h
                                                                                                                                                       Par
      wi1.              at



      of it      do1O         dio.      su     mP                   S'eh !\tioe      ih                        rp& iodua
                                                                                                                                                  to


      th R.                                    AUo                            0n                 :f be ob                       Suideofion
                       1Ud   J'ut-n                                  fu:t           anpI                                             or



                                                                                                                                            Res
      8ba1


                                                                        P8I        mq objto                                        'tc




                                     mI'B       0P           n1.,                    Jive              da                        vi:nlice          orm

                                                            Corf                            By
                                                                                                       lY                           an             t1 by'
      iato


                                                      Wllh.wr                               of1h                               b.doJf
                                        ,obj                  dioaPat Jb
                                                OaJn
       agrtn                          Pm'                                     attbA                         La:1i1Ac



                                                                                   thdih                                             "!l
          fam                                                                 oIdi::O
          of5v                                                 .8              "'h1tn!1V                                                    Oiif.OOl
                 1I.                 a:fU                                    lw'            th &0'               , -v:
                        A"'tot1.                             LawJ";.I_ -J:""                 JI\-I '                          i:\ :U1
                                                                                                                              :Io O r


          Ott:         ffth                 'ht                        o'btoth
                                                     totb                     ed   bJvidDwifige                                     O:: th         di
    30' 2004 10:53 5                                                                                                 #3770 1'. 027
APR
                                                         AnKDJ JA.                                                           Ii018It:3
 oa/2 104 lS ac FA%           202S2
                                                                                               po .



                                                                   A11            Ony                 al to1hi4
      Par m1 aiOStbo




             (d)         Di
                                                lDc                                ofRe                     Coldc:
      At       By




                              ,Cce                  mouOt
                                                                                                  CoeDal"

       BY           ma
                                               lvlUac

             (e)                             ODQJ




             No                        wot                    sl1 b.dx'
                                                                     1he



                                                                                        . I-
              (i)


              No
                                      sb ,             .-1b                Pm.             101-d. ihe 1r           at or Qt,
                                                                                                              as
                                                      inBDWa'b1h




                                      .0D:                                                     . II . . .

        3.
                                      PaOJ                                  ofW
                                                                                                                                    #3770 1'. 028
APR;30' 2004 10:54 5
. 0'/11/04       is: 3( F          2a2 282t27                                .TW UW     J1S                                                    131"020/031
                                                                                                                                             .. w   c.
                                                                                                                                        l'




                                                                                                        $$ in               an desi
      :P Th Par in
                 or                       trft                 fIY.

                                                                                                        ab be      tr
      th -w obt                                                              st of1b

        Coniiuda,'"
                                                  Vlfb
                                                               ag 2(a) of1l                            . jr

                                                                                                ofth
                                                                                                                         W (hCI.
       Ccscl                      wi:f bues                          oftb




       co
         ofti 01 10 a1Pscs Ot Pries                       't                     fr wh 'C
                                                                                                                   \son O


       domm du         COt          OJam sb 110
                                    (be
                                                                                                              1h PW'e& and
       f'             tbat't sb
                                                         df1 tt             th   cd          datC:o.1h'                   o ONer't

               r1h                                  ..c   qu                fo th hIgb                         f.et CoeD1
       .A Ey 0p81d 't                            so d                                  eD.



       . 4. Cotkti
                                                 1n:                   abl1.no'      di,.                           be             0%




                                                                                                                                   ssox
                       (a) ,                                   cl,


            ofPr
                                                                                               ..r'
                        (b)

                                                                                                              'O
                        (c)
                                                                                                               $hc:);


                        (0)
                                                                                                                #3770 1'. 029
APR. 30' 2004 10:54 5
  oa/j.'04   1S: 3'   PI 202382427                        .fIH .lW
                                                                             JU                                           Iifozuou
                                                          a:.




              (e)       th                  'V   Le J           an             Mcbi
               (f)                          md   depuU8=pt                           S;' ,



                                                                                                              Ct 11   apt:
                                  amot                               ofmyco\1                ju




                      !ov.1h Ma




               00 '                                     Of.th                                            (uin         .onth

                                  reor                                        w:h,           jn-
                                    CI st          th     COnft1Mt                                 wa




                                                   t1mu                                                                n" .
        8rcm'l
                                                                                                        and
        :rp1(;m                     Ot   ICCD


                ro ' '


        5.
                                                         "0I                                            1. be          dar .



                                                                                  I' 0'
                                                                               . .. '0' .,




                (a) , 1o                         ' I                           : .. i :
                                                                                                        10dxoOt
         )(cn                3)whSUCon


                                                                     , 12.
                                                                                                                                  #3770 1'. 030
APR. 30' 2004 10:54 5
. O   124/04 11:'.                    202'IIZ42?                 jD.IN lA"          ..S                                                   Ii02Z/O:l

                                e..                                                       I'"




                     (b)                                                       MsU)                         kWCoumlor

           R.Ct. OUde Ca u                                           1I 1b                       ou of



           89pn                               or         co_n offh Ma\

                                 to,nodi sm Codc                                                  .: to              exce
                     (C)

           JI"""b
              0f            th                      Ot an


                                         sc               fi&:D2erMattthn                                       OD                 e(11ber
                     (d) , to


                                                            gec,
            so1ef(
            pr-             I:                                       \fpr
                                                                             ceto                           Ma, 3nclndi
                                                                                                             oft1

                                                                                                            eddiseo
                     Tbs.                                            1ofhe




                           1C.d:                    OrOQ                                   : .0


                                                                                           i :




                      (8) ,                         10   Cod--
                                                                                      'i'
                      if8D                               ftM"   l'rol1        Pa' I . :. I                                  1 Q



                                                                                                               OtI th
                                                                                          :J"'
                                               notrthe          duPa         md.D                     it;            ofth




             fD                                    ncce Bbld=t 1Y                                                    QOI               be.
                                                                     orOt
                        ).1!
                                 .I                                                              I.,
                                                                                          . . '0 ..




                                                                                                  I.
                                                                                                                                                          '3770 1'. 031
APK.    30' 2004 10:54 5
                                                                                                                                                                     QlOZ:SIOU
 0'/2(/04              15:"            202'21242'                               ,w.   IM   ..1I




                                                                                                                                      bypm                     the
            -w 5w



            OOJl'U""" 'idd.m.p Paes
                                                        of-rviOS
                                                                   't!
                                                                                ceoflh!)

                                                                                 QD   'W.         wr
                                                                                                                                 ge

                                                                                                                              ofth      tf           fi




                                                                                PJ !'-                                        Ct5   $b eon to1r
            d&atioa .I'.
                                                                                                  it




     . 1b                                          as             ct     D1sc                 M1:                                                         wi




             Prci pm: or Cn                             oft18            8t J.                    Jod                hong Pu
             ri en              the c1eb                          sba me. 8D               oO in                 fa iq ao a1                    to   ne$
                              to mr   chen                      ptoD.    lf.b                     ot1ho
                                                                                                                     C:8S           af n


             pe                       ot%U              tb:                      or 1fcoUD 4                           h1:   go Bdth
                                       Chcn                       =1m.wr                                     ti to
                                                                                                                                                 veLa'W             Jqe
              ha faed



              as pndedbr                                  6():o        0:1f                                                  iqPm doncpr$t
                                                                                                                                                     11
              mdgJds



              mtb                                                                                                Pa1n th at'PM.                                t(




              8ConQr


                                              ofcode                              00 ",J:.                af-_   :"L                  7Joor




                                            fmpu                                                                              y,b1docs1U'
                                                                         .0
                                                                     1a"

                                 ece&
                              ' 4l . " ,
                                                                  i. :.
                                                                                 ""nf             Ot                                 f1D1bcu:,bJQ'
               Pawl
                                                                                                                        . .0 :




                              (b) '


                                           $i u:
                                                                                  '6(a)ottb$ P'&                        Or'h                  !ecd 1Dl$lv
APR. 30' 2004 10:55 5
                                                                                                                           #3770 1'. 032

 03/2(104 11:         ' FAI 20232 82(27                                  iAw    .J1D                                                IZ 02('031




      !sIm a                            tO dl10C
                                                                                                    or,   d;1e
                          deonU qct                                 on               'Otd   Witl'                eCOtmay
                                                                    LahQ,                             $neb     1:1k        sb 1,
                                           'tthA
       ti        em                        1'Vi _4    th
                                                               Ii
                                                                          -be



                                                                                     I!et
                                                                                                          d by t cmon

                                                                                                          goodfaiih:ngecmCl
                                                                                                                                  tbe

               81(1



               fa1O                                   tsm.                                    :ad          othPares Bh

       fi      'b        dq10
                                               10                                                           peln tbPar $1.
                                                                                                                 Not iJ
                        PiH         1ic;"of                  aCo

       Prve                     sba                                                           :of                 1h     Ad.ui
       IiJud .rth                          stof'                                            dJe                    tm"




       1. Co                                                                                  io,                  de"ed
       m1bp                 4(C) .n:4(d)            'Q'        ve               un            in':r




        c10n               .sUI   p1I       e.m:      (ot'
                                                                                                                         #.meofa1

                                        tb~,               'tbfN~~                                                            s.bc,

        coOt
                                  artOth c:t l1cf9f:                       , amI! 81:                                        II bt

        mbec                                                        If.                                                    esar

                            ofO:d                             MGf ur                                                    tbco=
                              ' ou t1:                                                                                     _bO

                                                                                             I..
                                                                                                                            #3770 1'. 033
APR. 30' 2004 10:55 5
                                                                                                                                             f02S/0:l
   ft"04 1':                202S28142?                       ADKIR tAW


                                                                                                                                 ...i.'"




                             BN               P1 J)'No. 9315.



      8. 'I p,s              sb'DObe Q                      to                    tO



                                                                                                                 11'
                                                                                                                         OD or

                                                                                                                            1u my
                     ofi                    oode01, m;                                 to dO sO




      su'b                   on      sacb                                    eu or an +O                   sepe8$
       Oisuch                     1opetJt                            to
                                                                                                             d.d
                                                                            :su                                         89Omcma1
                 isPX

       11 the    ti                          Pa
                                                                 CoIdn
                                                                                                                        cwl
               tbt
                                                    be .o                                                  thPaeswi
                                                                          wn-                     I.
                                                                                                           ordo1b--

       9.. tftb                                                                                            1be            byjt

       1h?aS                                                                                  i . i :.
                       Or                   " 11
                                                                                                                       (Whcr wl1

                                                         .i
       vM
                                                                                                  .. i
                                                                                                                                     l.aV:
                                        1oa                                       F:'.
                                                                                  0

        in   wr-                                                              ptby1h;
                                                                                                  rr'            l11eiivebG'
                                                                                                                                    51be

                                                         ..iI
                                        and                                                                                 1et!
        Wiap!!                                                                              , ;' Y ,
                                                                                                   'I, '

                                                   .di                                                                                :tb
        10. Jfsu

                                                                          . 1(;
                                                                                                                                                                               #3770 1'. 034
APR. 30' 2004 10:55 5
                                                                                                                                                                                      li 028/0:11
   /i(t04                    IS:                2'2'282427                             ADIH tAW

                                                                      "I . \


            die                    Of'8,   Prdue                       !I,                   Di
                                                                                                                                  tb               bpo              =P-
                                   sh notihe                PIvl                 Par   ofteofsach                            ci Sua1D                             caol




            wren
                                                                                8I      :rb)1h                                         fB d Je!5W11N
                                                                                                  1h                                         r aD a                         let1h
             das                                                             iuead      eo


                                                                                                       er-                                   pDrrrba bi1te1
             'M                                                          ofm



                                                            tJ Dbj                     ihl'equcS1       rpJdbcm                    Not                      he




             co
             reDSble fo


                                                       th     sobpoeo.:seciem
                                                                                                             eJ                             ith.
                                                                                                                                                                     fi1O    cbli.
                                                      onlO-'                                                        '. I
                             fQ my                     fono                                       su                    or                         a;tdbD




              11. Th                                  gov'1di                                                                                                                      ard
              1It       co                 an ih
                                                                                             in-Secon 3.45 :oft                                                  lon S      i4J


                                   16 CfP.1                 45.
                                                                                                                   .. i




                                                                                                                                                       tbe                          of'
                  12.              NGin                                yeoid:et                                   tO,


                                   (1,   t()   ep21          thP                                  isa                        7.
                                                                                                                                                        :46,                1b2,
                                                                                                                                                                                      wi,
                  R\1cs3.2               3.4SOT4.11(b)-C) 16ci                          Ji3                                       (bX




                                                 11**                                                        to_,                                                           dioslX
                  4bU                                                                                  16c:       .Ji             :,,lIfo




                                                                                                                                            :i
                                                                                                                                                                  #3770 1'. 035
A1'R,'30' 2004 10:56 5
                        is: 3'            202    282.2r                                  ADIDt LAW              .nm-                                                       IiOZ7IQU
 03/24/04
                                                                                                                                                              -".r




                                                                                                                                                                  :m'
                                                                                                                     ti fo 1n co t:Cl
                          Ar       Pa or                          pSr =1 JJaY                     at    d!




                                   a1Di               M.               n,   mi          poon oflb                            aiqS in tb Maer totJ


            ncfb:Jldi                                                              MAtt. AD

                                                                                                        A;ne
                                                                                                                        Di          i1J



                                                                                                                                           Lwhll Co               !1

            't stad5'                     fonh iD 16 c..'          f                4S



                                                                                                MtJt
                                                                                                                               k,         :z0D FTL                157
                                                          audli             rw
                                    (pac 23.     19m
            LES            :IS='
                                                                                                                                                                        gp Of
                        2. an 200 FT                   tE1                       (Sep 19, 2000)
                                                                                                                                    beBU            by a




            am bt ..                             qu;fi            to             la11
                                                                                                              o!'t




                                                                                                                              l.sh
                               Attb cmalo of1hMa,
                                                                                                                                                  to tho



                                                                                                                                                            a01h
             :Pct, or                          eU o                                     ecofdo8Xd
                                                                                                                     veJ1                    lJof1hpibic


                                      4.12.
                                          Coai eo.. \h.Dp.
                                                                                                                                                                        4.12
                                                                                                       afaD




              16C.F.R




                  14.                            J;of-d;                    teVe.                      boas                                 :1b




                         ofCcm                 aJD:CO                                                                           1'em              of-
                                                                                                                                                           1Db'
                                               afth
                                                ti Ms                                    '0 '
                  th      CO'              of


                                                                                                                                                           PBr         iti;ol
                   IS              iI :P-" Or                          m.                         to1h.uoO                          J:.
                                               ioPad
                                                                                                                                                  dngp
                   c!wc
                   eg. fb'                                   'bcnini:                    be,
                                                                                                                                        #3770 1'. 036
APR:30' 2004 10:56 5                                                                                                                             IibZB/031
     4/04         15      8 FAX 2023282.21
                            ' L-
                                                                   AD.,H lA'l




        16. 11 p!ctOD 9:                       dios Of8.y D'                                                            CD ofth

                                                                                W8                              s'd1\hm be
                       tivc 0I    wb          I'ncmgPm



                                           bccofaprvU wi
                                                                                         aum         cey be d                 't be..

            prct CI&Cos
                                                                                                                h&d $e
            my pdeg to whi1b                      Pruc                              ha




            Di)4                      no



                                            O%di1
                                                                'b=n

                                                                the!o
                                                                                         or      os
                                                                                                     :sh
                                                                                                           In



                                                                                                                  follOw:
                                                                                                                              ofsu




                        (a) The Prc1g par mb'                                                                     DiB
                                                                                                                              iny
                                                                                                                                           tU,


                                                                                                                        (or
            tw &y              ofd;   aw1lit Ms


                                                                                                                        fo,tb        reofan
            pt Ot. di5cio                                                PIcp


                                                                                                            - th "PS f&'
                                       $1w                                                           , I


                                                              (orpO(m:                           I.
                                                                                                                              -dcmpdvn       F""
            the



            th wwpr                             c and th
                                                                                                                        iuprd

                         1,)
                                                         Pa,    .st\1                                                     PPh&

             Dkte                                                                                                                    Sbdm
                                                                         ' 4
                                19tJ          dug                                                                       wjil
                                                         .u
                                                                                                                                     oro
                                                                                                                              tbOO
              gofa-beiesh' De
                                             tely
                                                  bLcn                 (i).:.t:fa             xecW
                                                                                                      :i .       '-i$
                                                                                                                                           or (U)tM
                                                                                                                                       #3770 1'. 037
APR. 30' 2004 10:56 5
                                                                                                                                                   ii Q211t11
   l1t/04        1lt;7 PAX 2023212127
                                                                                                                                                                ..':8




                       cy Ofus
                                                      01;S   prvi          by     P:               Par"          Bbl no be t$           on




            srtb                               CIor4tsclos,
                                                ofth Disc Ma1at cont
                                                                                                                Wa
                                                                                                                 sueeme. th
                                                                                                                                       In the




            ev=t that 0I por
                         'P        sbdl                                         veoftbe~Ma                           attb
            'Iftki"8                      1b. mu             ofth                   Di Moft
                                                             Cu/J   tffi                      If                DiSc                               t.. '



            to                      d. te        to                  D.i           Matc                              Ped                tBof
            't 1.is              Mdm mz
                                                                                :f rm   mdcapcin tb                           of1be   pj$W
            Ma. In J0                                                                   gba               th'        of&bw:                  tb"


            ;DM&                          is                  ab .: thc pron



             17. &J ofth Wr                                          'Y           j$;wi~~to tu~n, btot
                                 to apr f'                                      cr orfmz;                        onoCany           OD Qftl


                            Of.

             ORDER


                                                                                                                           ta:r'\dge
                       24
                                                                                                                        #3770 1'. 038
APR:30' 2004 10:57 5                                                                                                           ljo;P/a
 0"241O(     lS:    f Pi 202       28.21           ft"
                                                                KIN   U"




                                               'V         ,STATE ()
                                                                              AMCA
                                        om;a:o..           l\m''m              LAW




           1nwm
           EVANTON      NOJnHBTHCA
           COlU'I0N
                                                                                            1;oc    No.         931S


           ENMBCAGlOU. lN



                                , D                      ONCONCEGmt
                                  gRRR:

                                                          (bfo                1Qbd

                   1.
                                                         loym),
                   t.                                                 bpJ'.
              .t1
           Osef
           eodt                                                               ipth
                                                                                                    onmyU$orll ,
                                                                                                          )h\                A.I
            .gmlO
                    3. ,   :l                      d21ht'              onlD




                                a.. '      lwiUt8mc,                                                      o:iV1b
                                                                                 endh            a).a
                                        ;pC).1:                       cipu
                           .. 'b           atIwiDC                    eueo                 :Di
                                                                                           Dt'
                                                                                                                       10    on.
                                                                  b11b               VCI
                                                                                                                                                                             #3770 1'. 039
. A1'R.      30' 2004 10:57 5                                                                                                                                                      raO U/DU
                                                                                          AD.IN
  0,/24/04            1St"    AX 202 Ze2.27

                        .I



                                                                                                                                        OD in 1b
                                                                                                                                                                         1,w
                                                                                                   O' ofmt
                                               th 'Qpo
                                                                    te
                                                                    the


                                                                                  nta c(deal Disoc Ma
                                                                                   aU Coal
                                                                               or Ofpe
                                                                                                                                                           tndaU

                                                                     iJt ColOt

                             4.                               th if am
                                                                             tb$
                                                                                 Coti
                                                                                   t;t1
                                                                                                                                       J)cOer:tecalDS an
                                                                                                                                           tbreC1on tmDJ
                                                                    is 4                   3D
                                        a9th
                                                                                                                                        1iQn
               Coti
                                        Ve               M.



                                  a.            to D:
                                                    1'(s) of
                                                                                        eodc
                                                                                                                'W sp
                                                                                                                                                   a1 ju   se'8Ul1od
                                                                                                                                                           DiCO Maal
                                                    1Jotbe



                                   Co ' to
                                                    t:




                                                               su
                                                                    mt or
                                                                                  cti
                                                                                  O\e

                                                                                                   on
                                                                                                    a,
                                                                                                         at   Dift




                                                                                                               scof-- .ici
                                                                                                                          es
                                                                                                                                                   tp compJt



                                                                                                                                          aJ au thc.mr'OtI
                                                                                                                                                                         ;uon()fmy


                                                                                                                                                                             to3PW't
                                                                           elYfar                                                                              or

                                                     1h                                   c1prdi
                                                                                                   OYof
                                                                                                                                              th
                                                                                                                                                                    1d()l1   .2.e&ot
                             !S   : I

                                        R. i 3.
                                               fo                         th
                                                                                    ttw
                                                                                                         tV

                                                                                                                     wi
                                                                                                                               3AZ(h




                                                                                                                      je:r                                             by1h '
                                               oftbc                                on.             ma




                                         . J
                                                                                                                                       DI
                      Fu)1p
                                                                        (PUBLIC)

                                     UNTED STATES OF AMERICA
                                    FEDERA TRAE COMMISSION

In the Matter of

EVANSTON NORTHWESTERN HEAL THCARE )
CORPORATION                       ) Docket No. 9315


and                                               ) Honorable Stephen   J. McGuire

ERN MEDICAL GROUP , INC.,
     Respondents.


         ORDER GRANTING UNICAR HEALTH PLANS OF THE MIDWEST'
               EXTENSION OF TIME TO FILE MOTION TO LIMIT
                        SUBPOENA DUCES TECUM

         The Federal Trade Commission hereby grants UNICAR' s motion for extension of time

to fie its motion to quash or limit the Subpoena Duces Tecum and to comply with Section 3.38A

to and including June 9 , 2004.



DATED:                                       ENTER:




Donald A. Murday
Elizabeth G. Doolin
CHITTENDEN MUA Y & NOV01NY LLC
303 West Madison Street, Suite 1400
Chicago , Ilinois 60606
(312) 281- 3600
(312) 281- 3678 (fax)
O:\UN2143\40306FrC\LDGS\ORDERGRAGEXT. DOC
                                 CERTIFICATE OF SERVICE

        , Elizabeth G. Doolin , hereby certifies that on May 6 , 2004 , I caused copi s of:

                      Notice of Appearance;

                      Non-Pary UNICARE HEALTH PLANS OF THE MIDWEST
                      INC. s Motion for Extension of Time to File Motion to Limit
                      Subpoena Duces Tecum; and

                       Proposed Order Granting Non- Party UNICARE HEALTH PLANS
                       OF THE MIDWEST , INC.' s Extension of Time to File Motion to
                       Limit Subpoena Duces Tecum

to be served upon the following persons:

               Office of the Secretary
               Federal Trade Commission
               Room H- 159
               600 Pennsylvania Avenue , NW
               Washington , DC 20580
               (Original and 12  copies served via FedEx overnight delivery, and electronic
               copies served via e-mail)

               The Honorable Stephen J. McGuire
               Chief Administrative Law Judge
               Federal Trade Commission
               Room H- I06
               600 Pennsylvania Avenue , NW
               Washington , DC 20580
               (Two courtesy copies served via FedEx overnight delivery)

               Thomas H. Brock , Esquire
               Federal Trade Commission
               Room H- 374
               600 Pennsylvania Avenue , NW
               Washington , DC 20580
               (Served via FedEx overnight delivery)

               Philip M. Eisenstat , Esquire
               Federal Trade Commission
               Room NJ- 5235
               601 New Jersey Avenue , NW
               Washington , DC 20580
               (Served via FedEx overnight delivery)
Chul Pak , Esquire
Assistant Director Mergers IV
Federal Trade Commission
Room NJ- 5328
601 New Jersey Avenue , NW
Washington , DC 20580
(Served via FedEx overnight delivery)

Counsel for Evanston Northwestern Healthcare Corporation and
  ENH Medical Group, Inc.
David E. Dahlquist
Christopher B. Essig
Duane M. Kelly
Winston & Strawn
35 West Wacker Drive
Chicago , Ilinois 60601- 9703
(Served via messenger delivery)

Michael L. Sibarium
Charles B. Klein
Rebecca C. Morrison
Winston & Strawn
1400 L Street , NW
Washington , DC 20005- 3502
(Served via FedEx overnight delivery)