Models, Screen Prototyping Diagrams and Examples
RDN Annotation Service : Domain Model
RDN Results Set
Record Summary
Annotation Service Delete Annotation
User
Create Annotation View Annotation Edit Annotation
Edit Annotation Moderate Annotation Auto-reject Annotation
Set Moderation Values
Accept Annotation
Reject Annotation
Moderator
RDN Annotation Use Case Main Model
uses
Accept
uses
Auto-reject
uses
Reject
uses
View
uses
Edit Annotation
Set Moderation Moderat
uses
Run Moderation
uses
Create
uses
User
Edit Annotation View
extends
Delete Annotation
List of Screens Identified in Annotation Demo Design
Screen 01 RDN Resource Results: Summaries of resources found: The Police and Criminal Evidence Act http://www.hmso.gov.uk/si/ read or write comments Screen 02 Annotation Service for RDN Resource Descriptions Main Menu View comments on this resource Write comments on this resource Return to your RDN results
Screen 03 Create Annotation Form [Text fields for comment and starrating] Submit Return to your RDN results
Screen 04 Annotation Successfully Created [Text fields showing comment and starrating] Return to Annotation Main Menu Return to your RDN results
Screen 05 Create Annotation Form Warning:your form was incomplete [Text fields for comment and starrating] Please complete and resubmit Re-submit Return to your RDN results
Screen 06 Annotation Service Results Page No. Author Date Rating Comment 01 J.Smith 10/15 *** "This Act .." 02 P.Jones 10/17 ** "PACE is .." Click id no. to view Return to Annotation Main Menu
Screen 07 Single Annotation Result showing in full Author Date Time Rating Comment
Screen 08 Single Annotation Result showing in full Author Date Time Rating Comment Edit Delete
Return to Annotation Service Results Page Screen 09 Edit Annotation Form [Text fields for comment and starrating] Submit Return to Annotation Service Results Page Screen 11 Edit Annotation Form Warning:your form was incomplete [Text fields for comment and starrating] Please complete and resubmit Re-submit Return to Annotation Service Results Page
Return to Annotation Service Results Page Screen 10 Annotation Successfully Edited [Text fields showing comment and starrating] Return to Annotation Service Results Page
Screen 12 Delete Annotation No. 02 Please Confirm you wish to delete: [Text fields for comment and starrating] Delete Return to Annotation Service Results Page
Screen 13 Annotation Successfully Deleted
Return to Annotation Service Result Page
Map of Navigation between Screens in Annotation Demo
Screen 01 RDN Resource Results: Summaries of resources found: The Police and Criminal Evidence Act http://www.hmsso.gov.uk/si/ read or write comments
Screen 02 Annotation Service for RDN Resource Descriptions Main Menu View comments on this resource Write comments on this resource Return to your RDN results [..user ! = author ] Screen 07 Single Annotation Result showing in full Author Date Time Rating Comment Screen 06 Annotation Service Results Page No. Author Date Rating Comment 01 J.Smith 10/15 *** "This Act .." 02 P.Jones 10/17 ** "PACE is .." Click id no. to view Return to Annotation Main Menu
Screen 03 Create Annotation Form [Text fields for comment and starrating] Submit Return to your RDN results
Return to Annotation Service Results Page Screen 04 Annotation Successfully Created [Text fields showing comment and starrating] Return to Annotation Main Menu Return to your RDN results Screen 09 Edit Annotation Form [Text fields for comment and starrating] Submit Return to Annotation Service Results Page
[..user= = author ]
Screen 08 Single Annotation Result showing in full Author Date Time Rating Comment Edit Delete
[..form is incomplete] Screen 05 Create Annotation Form Warning:your form was incomplete [Text fields for comment and starrating] Please complete and resubmit Re-submit Return to your RDN results
Return to Annotation Service Results Page
Screen 10 Annotation Successfully Edited [Text fields showing comment and starrating]
Screen 12 Delete Annotation No. 02 Please Confirm you wish to delete: [Text fields for comment and starrating] Delete Return to Annotation Service Results Page
Return to Annotation Service Result Page [..form is incomplete] Screen 11 Edit Annotation Form Warning:your form was incomplete [Text fields for comment and starrating] Please complete and resubmit Re-submit Return to Annotation Service Results Page
Screen 13 Annotation Successfully Deleted
Return to Annotation Service Result Page
A more detailed view of the Create Annotation Form Screen (Screen 03). Security
Write Your Own Commentan issue with security and cookies carrying a There is on this resource with this form
Resource title Resource URL user id and password are far from secure. Therefore one option would be to have the system check the login user name and Police and Criminal Evidence Act then offer a password box for completion. This will be tedious if the user intends to make a lot of annotations but in all http://www.hmso.gov.uk/si?id_234212. likelihood (s)he will not do so serially. This is a subject for further discussion if the general idea holds water.
Annotation Rating The Annotation Creation Form The form requests that data which cannot be ascertained from the login process, e.g. the type of annotation access and the kind of text entry, together with the nature of comments e.g. adverse, favourable,* neutral. The latter would be searchable across the annotation database so that RDN could ascertain which resources were attracting favour and which might be thought expendable. Nothing is as valuable as the ** comments themselves but if the numbers of annotations grow very large then this would be a rapid method of ascertaining the most successful resources. *** The submitted form would also provide the date created, a reference to the description number n and an autonumbering of itself as an annotation within that set of **** annotations of description n and / or a unique number for itself. A url containing the unique number would also prove useful. ***** The Origin of the Annotation When the form is submitted, if an RDN Login process has already taken place, then Text of Your Comment the form will submit with user id as gleaned from the login process. However there is a question of how to handle the access aspect of the annotations. Users of the resources will divide into different classes. For example, even lecturers may be differentiated, course designers from course teachers. Students will differ also, undergraduates from postgraduates for example. So there is a question as to how we ascertain the status of the annotator as this has a significant impact upon the credibility of the annotation in certain circumstances.
Submit or: Return to your RDN
Screen 03: A Create Annotation Form
Annotation Service: Annotation no. 01
Resource title Resource URL Police and Criminal Evidence Act http://www.hmso.gov.uk/si?id_234212.
Annotation no. 001 Author: J.Smith Date :10/15/01 Time 12.45 PM Star-Rating : 4 Comment : This Act had a profound effect on the manner in which evidence was sought and validated by the Police Services of the United Kingdom and was seen by many as a long overdue overhaul of police practice in the areas of criminal investigation as well as preparation of a prosecution.
Return to Annotation Service Results Page
Screen 07 : detailed view of a single annotation where user is not the annotation author
Annotation Service: Annotation no. 01
Resource title Resource URL Police and Criminal Evidence Act http://www.hmso.gov.uk/si?id_234212.
Annotation no. 001 Author: J.Smith Date :10/15/01 Time 12.45 PM Star-Rating : 4 Comment : This Act had a profound effect on the manner in which evidence was sought and validated by the Police Services of the United Kingdom and was seen by many as a long overdue overhaul of police practice in the areas of criminal investigation as well as preparation of a prosecution.
Edit
Delete
Return to Annotation Service Results Page
Screen 08 : detailed view of a single annotation where the annotation author is viewing
List of Moderator's Screens
Screen 01 RDN Resource Results: Summaries of resources found: The Police and Criminal Evidence Act http://www.hmso.gov.uk/si/ read or write comments
Screen 02 Annotation Service for RDN Resource Descriptions Main Menu View comments on this resource Write comments on this resource Return to your RDN results
Screen 06.1 Annotation Service Results Page No. Author Date Rating Comment ! 01 J.Smith 10/15 *** "This Act " 3 02 P.Jones 10/17 ** "PACE is " Click id no. to view Return to Annotation Main Menu
Screen 06.01 Annotation Service Results Page No annotations were identified for this resource Return to Annotation Main Menu
Screen 08.1 Single Annotation Result showing in full Author Date Time Rating Comment Accept Edit Reject Auto-reject Return to Annotation Service Results Page
Screen 14 Editing Annotation no. 01 Star-rating read-only *** Comment box over-writable:
Screen 15 Reject Annotation 01 [Text fields showing comment and starrating] Reason for rejection
Cancel
Submit
Cancel
Submit
Screen 04.1 Annotation Successfully Accepted [Text fields showing comment and starrating] Return to Annotation Results Page Return to your RDN results
Screen 04.2 Annotation Successfully Rejected [Text fields showing comment and starrating] Return to Annotation Results Page Return to your RDN results
Screen 16 Annotation Administration Webpage
Screen 17 Set Moderation Values Form [ Form with fields for various values to calibrate risk threshold for moderation] Submit Return to Annotation Administration Page
Set Moderation Values Return to RDN site
Map of Navigation between Moderator's Screens for Action on Annotations
Screen 01 RDN Resource Results: Summaries of resources found: The Police and Criminal Evidence Act http://www.hmso.gov.uk/si/ read or write comments Screen 06.01 Annotation Service Results Page No annotations were identified for this resource Return to Annotation Main Menu Screen 03
Screen 02 Annotation Service for RDN Resource Descriptions Main Menu View comments on this resource Write comments on this resource Return to your RDN results
Screen 06.1 Annotation Service Results Page No. Author Date Rating Comment ! 01 J.Smith 10/15 *** "This Act " 3 02 P.Jones 10/17 ** "PACE is " Click id no. to view Return to Annotation Main Menu
Screen 08.1 Single Annotation Result showing in full Author Date Time Rating Comment Accept Edit Reject Auto-reject Cancel & Return to Annotation Service Results Page
Screen 14 Editing Annotation no. 01 Star-rating read-only *** Comment box over-writable:
Screen 15 Reject Annotation 01 [Text fields showing comment and starrating] Reason for rejection
Cancel
Submit
Cancel
Submit
Screen 04.1 Annotation Successfully Accepted [Text fields showing comment and starrating] Return to Annotation Results Page Return to your RDN results
Screen 04.2 Annotation Successfully Rejected [Text fields showing comment and starrating] Return to Annotation Results Page Return to your RDN results
Navigation between Moderator's Screens for Set Moderation Values
Via confidential url RDN Homepage:
Screen 16 Annotation Administration Webpage
Set Moderation Values Return to RDN site
Screen 17 Set Moderation Values Form [ Form with fields for various values to calibrate risk threshold for moderation] Return to Annotation Administration Page
A more detailed view of the Moderator's Editing Annotation Screen (Screen 14)
Editing Annotation no. 01
Author : J.Smith Star-rating *** Comment box:
This Act was undoubtedly instrumental in the demoralisation of the Metropolitan Police Force as has been recoggnised [recognised] by many leading authorities Dear J.Smith, Whilst picking up a typo in the text of your comment above I note that you do not appear to have added the names of the authorities of which you speak which would be an invaluable addition to your annotation. Would you be able to do this for our benefit and resubmit your annotation? System Moderator Cancel Submit
A more detailed view of the Moderator's Editing Annotation Screen (Screen 15)
Rejecting Annotation no. 01
Author : J.Smith Star-rating *** Comment box:
This Act was undoubtedly instrumental in the demoralisation of the Metropolitan Police Force as has been recoggnised by many leading authorities and represents a triumph of the secret anti-white lobby.
Dear J.Smith, I regret that it is not possible to accept your annotation's comment given the racist undertones that might be identified within your text. System Moderator
Cancel
Submit
A more detailed view of the Moderator's Set Moderation Values Form Screen (Screen 17)
Set Moderation Values Form
System Setting Star Rating Threshold Email Domain Filter Email Domain List; *.ac.uk; *.org.uk; *.org; *.edu; Email Prefix Filter On Off On On Off of 5 Off
0
Email Prefix List; charstring@; charstring.Charstring@; Initial Priority Threat Threshold Watch List On Watch List Words; stupid:5; moronic:10; dishonest:15; sententious:10; h pocritical:15; Contributors List On Off Moderators List; p.james@ukoln.ac.uk; a.nother@kcl.ac.uk; a.person@umist.ac.uk;
0 20
Off
Contributors List; j.brown@glas.ac.uk; p.belton@bristol.ac.uk; a.t.lemkov@bath.ac.uk;
Submit Return to Annotation Administration Page