Cellular Systems Biology Profiling in Drug Discovery and Development
Kenneth A. Giuliano, Ph.D. Principal Scientist Cellumen, Inc.
“Optimizing Drug Discovery, Development and Clinical Trials Through Cellular Systems Biology”
FDA/NIST Sponsored Workshop In Vitro Analyses of Cell/Scaffold Products
December 2007
© 2007 Cellumen, Inc. | CONFIDENTIAL
11
Agenda
Introduction to Cellumen and Cellular Systems Biology Cytotoxicity profiling as an example application of cellular systems biology
© 2007 Cellumen, Inc.
|
CONFIDENTIAL
21
Exploring Cells and Tissues as Systems
“From Molecules to Man”
© 2007 Cellumen, Inc.
|
CONFIDENTIAL
31
The Challenge: Cell is An Integrated, Interacting Network
Gene Expression Cell Surface Attachments Cytoskeletal Assembly-Disassembly
Membrane Receptors Membrane Pumps
Cell Movements
Signaling Pathways Post-translational Modifications
Molecular Synthesis/ Degradation Energy Metabolism
© 2007 Cellumen, Inc.
|
CONFIDENTIAL
41
Evolution of Cell-based Discovery
Emergence of Cellular Systems Biology
Cell population responses HTS methods Whole plate readers “Simple” HCS Automated cellular imaging 1st generation HCS readers/1-2 features measured Multiplexed HCS Automated cellular imaging 3-4 features with data management
Cellular Systems Biology Optimally multiplexed cell and tissue imaging advanced reagents, >10 features & classifier informatics
© 2007 Cellumen, Inc. | CONFIDENTIAL
51
Cellular Systems Biology (CSB)™ Approach
The cell is an integrated and interacting network of genes, proteins & metabolic processes that gives rise to function
Functional Biomarkers Cell Arrays
“omics” Information
Tissue MicroArrays
© 2007 Cellumen, Inc. | CONFIDENTIAL
61
The Solution: Cellular Systems Biology Profiling
Proprietary Cellular Biomarker Panels
75 95 46 18 88 31 83 68 86 71
© 2007 Cellumen, Inc. | CONFIDENTIAL
71
Proprietary Profile Database
The Solution: Cellular Systems Biology Profiling
Proprietary Cellular Biomarker Panels
75 95 46 18 88 31 83 68 86 71
Proprietary Profile Database
90 98 75 2 80 42 95 3 6 98 17 67 46 3 47 11 18 8 6 79 89 88 5 76 21 95 47 91 31 3 94 97 83 5 45 87 97 13 68 13 91 88 86 4 99 79 71 55 6
© 2007 Cellumen, Inc. |
Classifiers
CONFIDENTIAL
81
Tools of Cellular Systems Biology
Existing Imagers
• Cell “Models” • Patient Cells/ Tissues
Reagents/Profiles
Informatics/Classifiers
© 2007 Cellumen, Inc. |
Systems Knowledge & Decisions
CONFIDENTIAL
91
Implementing Cellular Systems Biology (CSB)™
Improve efficacy and decrease toxicity of leads, clinical candidates & drugs
Drug Discovery
Drug Development
Clinical Trials
Cellular Models of Disease Cytotoxicity Profiling Patient Sample Profiling
© 2007 Cellumen, Inc.
|
CONFIDENTIAL
101
Cellumen Solution
Drug Discovery Drug Development Clinical Trials
CellCiphr™ Cellular Models of Disease
• Disease-relevant cellular models, biosensors, assays & profiles to improve quality and quantity of lead compounds • Profiles & tools for important, previously intractable targets • Flags off-target effects at the earliest stage
© 2007 Cellumen, Inc.
|
CONFIDENTIAL
111
Cellumen Solution
Drug Discovery Drug Development Clinical Trials
CellCiphr™ Cytotoxicity Profiles •Identifies potential toxicity before entering expensive pre-clinical testing •Enables prioritization of lead compounds Partners CHA
US EPA
| CONFIDENTIAL
121
© 2007 Cellumen, Inc.
Cellumen Solution
Drug Discovery Drug Development Clinical Trials
CellCiphr™ Patient Sample Profile R&D
• Improves trial enrollment and therefore new drug candidate efficacy by stratifying patients with profiles of the patient’s own samples • Proprietary panels of cellular biomarkers can also serve as diagnostic tools to improve treatment selection
Collaborative Partner
© 2007 Cellumen, Inc.
|
CONFIDENTIAL
131
Cytotoxicity Profiling
CellCiphr™ Cytotoxicity Profile
CellCiphr™ Advantages: Systems Biology approach monitors multiple functions, time points and doses Fully leverages the sensitivity and throughput of HCS Validated to HTS standards with 384-well capacity & extensive QC Classifier software for simplification and predictivity Delivers insights on mechanism of action
© 2007 Cellumen, Inc.
|
CONFIDENTIAL
141
Cytotoxicity Profiling
CellCiphr™ Cytotoxicity Panel #1
Stress Pathway Activation Organelle Functions
Panel 1 design* (Collaboration with Millipore) • Multiple mechanisms of toxicity • Acute, early & chronic exposure • 384-well capacity • HepG2
Oxidative Stress
DNA Damage
Cell Cycle
CSK Integrity
*Cellumen patents pending
© 2007 Cellumen, Inc. | CONFIDENTIAL
151
Cytotoxicity Profiling
CellCiphr™ Cytotox Panel #1 Features HepG2 Cells
Measurement
Cell Number DNA Content DNA Structure Nuclear Area Histone H2A.X Phosphorylation c-Jun Phosphorylati on Phosphorylatio p53 activation Mitochondrial memb. po tential memb. potential Mitochondrial mass Histone H3 Phosphorylation Microtubule stability
Cell Features
Cell Loss Cell Cycle Arrest DNA Degradation Nucl ear Size Nuclear Oxidative S tress St Stress Kina se Activation Kinase DNA Dama ge Response Damage Mitochondrial Function I Mitochondrial Function II Mitosis marker Microtubule CSK
Reagents
Hoech st 33342 Hoechst
anti-phospho-histone H2A.X Antibo dy anti- phosphoAntibody anti-phospho-c-jun Antibo dy anti- phosphoAntibody anti-p53 Antibody antiMitoTracker Red MitoTracker Red anti-phospho-histone H3 Antibo dy anti- phosphoAntibod anti-α-tubulin Antibody anti-
© 2007 Cellumen, Inc.
|
CONFIDENTIAL
161
Cytotoxicity Profiling
CellCiphr Cytotoxicity Panel #2
Apoptosis Peroxisome Proliferation
™
Panel 2 design*: • Primary Rat Hepatocytes • Multiple mechanisms of toxicity • 11 parameters • Acute, Early, 48h exposure • Fixed endpoint, 384-well capacity
Phospholipidosis
Mitochondrial Functions Stress Pathway Activation CSK Integrity
* Cellumen patents pending
© 2007 Cellumen, Inc. | CONFIDENTIAL
171
Cytotoxicity Profiling
CellCiphr™ Analysis
Acute Profile Early Profile Chronic Profile
Analysis of identifies Clusters of Additional measurements after 24 & 72 with a set of CellCiphr™ Cytotoxicity Profiling starts hours of Image analysis for a panel of Clustering a seriesPot. cellular functions compounds profiles that enhancing compounds characterize early & response capturecorrelate with cellular biomarkers selected to profile… the cellular produces a systems chronic responses,populates a based on cellular CellCiphr Profile CellCiphr sensitivityof cellular activity. CellCiphr Profile. the systemic response to toxic challenge.functions… a ‘fingerprint’ & specificity of the KinaseC-124 Oxidative Stress Profiles allowing classification. Database. Stress Induction
0.4 TERF CMPT PTXL 0.2 Comp.2 ETPS MNDN CHLQ T IN PROP SUCL VALP QUACR DI LN IMIP BU ICHPZSP NDO PARX ASTM BUPV CCCP FURA MEVA 0.0 MTRX -0.2 KTZL VBLN NOCD ANIS -0.4 AMIO MEVN -0.4 -0.2 0.0 0.2 0.4 Comp.1
Apoptosis Induction
-10
-5
0
5
10
Mito
5 -10 -5 0 10
STSP
Library of CellCiphr Profiles
Principle Components Compound Classification Analysis to build classifier
© 2007 Cellumen, Inc. | CONFIDENTIAL
181
Cytotoxicity Profiling
CSB Imaging and Data Analysis
W11 400 300 200 100
1x10
-8
A.
Ox. Stress
1x10 M
-5
11 features measured in EACH cell; 3 time points; 10 pt dose-response, curve fit the data Tabulate AC50 values
B.
Cmpd Plate
Cell Loss Acute
CC Arrest Acute
DNA Degrad Acute
Nuclear Size Acute
Ox. Stress Acute
Stress Kinase Acute
DNA Damage Acute
Mito Potential Acute
Mito Mass Acute
Mitotic Arrest Acute
Microtube Stability Cell Loss CC Arrest Acute Early Early
DNA Degrad Early
Nuclear Size Early
Ox. Stress Early
Stress Kinase Early
DNA Damage Early
Mito Potential Early
Mito Mass Early
Mitotic Arrest Early
Microtube Stability Cell Loss CC Arrest Early Chronic Chronic
DNA Degrad Chronic
Nuclear Size Chronic
Ox. Stress Chronic
Stress Kinase Chronic
DNA Damage Chronic
Mito Potential Chronic
Mito Mass Chronic
Mitotic Arrest Chronic
Microtube Stability Chronic
T42 R50 P10 S23 W11 O13
5.18 3.40 4.92 4.80 5.66 4.18 4.75 5.45 3.80 4.52 3.89 6.15 5.04 4.41 4.57 4.57 4.28 5.77 4.38
4.85
4.00
4.80 3.44
5.45
5.00 3.61 5.63
4.40 3.67 5.69
5.26 5.01 4.32 5.94 4.78 5.97 4.56 5.09 4.45 6.41
4.86
4.29 5.90 3.87 5.25
4.96
5.71 4.89 4.07 5.72
4.80
5.08
5.72
3.63 5.71
6.00
3.82
3.34 4.43 4.46
3.21 6.01 3.99
6.45
4.25 5.59
5.04
C.
10 9 Activity (-log(M)) 8 7 6 5 4 3 2
1 2 3 4 5 6 7 8 9 10
CellCiphr Profile Plot
11
12
13
14
15
16
17
18
19
20
21
22
23
24
25
26
27
28
29
30
31
32 33
34
Max
w11
Quantitative and Visual Tools for Compound Profiling
© 2007 Cellumen, Inc.
|
CONFIDENTIAL
191
Cytotoxicity Profiling
CellCiphr™ Profiling Case Study
Drug Safety Data for 137 compounds* Each compound scored on a scale of 0, 1, 2, 3, 4 for in vivo toxicity Compounds tested in CellCiphr HepG2 Panel 1 and CellCiphr Rat Hepatocyte Panel 2 CellCiphr 1 automated analysis provided similarity to known controls, the group toxicity rank order and a safety index
* Includes 101 unknown (blinded) and 36 control compounds
© 2007 Cellumen, Inc.
|
CONFIDENTIAL
201
Cytotoxicity Profiling
Combining CellCiphr™ Features from HepG2 and Rat Hepatocytes Optimizes Toxin Detection
P70 W81 D11 Total Activity X49 X39
nM μM mM
Min Toxicity
Significant Toxicity
No Safety Data
In Vivo Tox
© 2007 Cellumen, Inc.
|
CONFIDENTIAL
211
Cytotoxicity Profiling
CellCiphr™ Similarity Profile
nM
μM
mM
Compound H25 (blue) H25 (blue)
Differences from Etoposide (red) - CC Arrest Acute - Stress Kinase Chronic
© 2007 Cellumen, Inc.
|
CONFIDENTIAL
221
Cytotoxicity Profiling
Classifier Design
137 compounds produced over 4500 doseresponse curves Difficult to apply manual scoring methodology to handle analysis Assay data from compounds was used with in vivo scorings to construct a classifier to rank compound toxicity First generation classifier had improved performance over simple cytotoxicity assay
© 2007 Cellumen, Inc.
|
CONFIDENTIAL
231
Cytotoxicity Profiling
Accuracy of CellCiphr Classifier 1
Toxicity
Significant Moderate Minimal Overall accuracy
In vivo
n
47 66 24 137
24 hr cell loss 84% 65% 25% 61%
CellCiphr Classifier 100% 80% 46% 82%
© 2007 Cellumen, Inc.
|
CONFIDENTIAL
241
Cytotoxicity Profiling
CellCiphr™ Report
Compound: W11 Source: CHA Project
Maximum Tolerate Dose Earliest Toxic Indicator Most Sensitive Toxic Indicator General Indicator of Toxicity
Measurable Effects
Mitochondrial Potential Nuclear Size Cell Loss Nuclear Size Oxidative Stress Stress Kinase DNA Damage Mitosis Arrest Microtube Stability Cell Cycle Arrest Mitochondrial Potential Mitochondrial Mass
AC50 (M)
n/a, 1.2E-5 7.07E-07 3.90E-07 1.5E-6, 1.3E-6 8.4E-6, 3.4E-7 1.9E-6, 2.2E-6, 36.8E-6 1.9E-6, 3.6E-6, 5.7E-6 993.0E-9, 982.4E-9 2.3E-6, 9.1E-6 2.0E-6, 16.0E-6, 1.9E-6 8.4E-6, 8.0E-6 7.07E-7 27.2E-6, 2.5E-6
Time (hrs)
1, 72 24 72 1, 72 1, 72 1, 24, 72 1, 24, 72 1, 72 1, 72 1, 24, 72 1, 72 24 24, 72
Mechanistic Indicators
Correlation with Other Compounds
Similarity with Compounds in set
Compound
C9 Vinblastine Nocodazole Colcemid 0.70 0.69 0.60
Correlation Coefficient
0.59
Similarity with Toxin Cassette Compounds
CellCiphr™ Profile W11 (red), Vinblastine (blue) Rank Order 1/ Safety H I d
© 2007 Cellumen, Inc.
|
CONFIDENTIAL
251
Cytotoxicity Profiling
CellCiphr™ Panel 3: Rat Hepatobiliary
• Highly differentiated rat hepatocytes (sandwich culture) • Chronic exposure (3 day +) • 384 well capacity • Functional assays for: • Cholestasis • Steatosis • Mitochondrial potential
Monolayer culture overlay culture
© 2007 Cellumen, Inc.
|
CONFIDENTIAL
261
Cytotoxicity Profiling
CellCiphr™ Panels in Development
Human and Rat 1° and Cell Lines • Tissue selectivity panels • Neuronal cells • Cardiomyocytes • Stem-cell derived cultures • Co-culture/tissue engineered array models • Kinetic, Live Cell Panels
© 2007 Cellumen, Inc. | CONFIDENTIAL
271
Summary
The CSB approach to cell based discovery is being implemented to improve efficacy and decrease toxicity of leads, clinical candidates & drugs
Cellular models of disease Cytotoxicity profiling Patient sample profiling
CSB based cytotoxicity profiling assays and classifiers are evolving to improve early decision making
© 2007 Cellumen, Inc.
|
CONFIDENTIAL
281
GovernmentDocs 5/4/2008 |
404 |
4 |
0 |
legal
FDADocs 5/9/2008 |
15 |
0 |
0 |
legal
FDADocs 5/5/2008 |
182 |
1 |
0 |
legal
FDADocs 5/9/2008 |
199 |
3 |
0 |
legal
FDADocs 5/9/2008 |
178 |
2 |
0 |
legal
GovernmentDocs 5/4/2008 |
169 |
2 |
0 |
legal
GovernmentDocs 5/4/2008 |
137 |
2 |
0 |
legal
FDADocs 5/8/2008 |
120 |
1 |
0 |
legal
FDADocs 5/5/2008 |
113 |
0 |
0 |
legal
FDADocs 5/8/2008 |
316 |
3 |
0 |
legal
FDADocs 5/9/2008 |
78 |
0 |
0 |
legal
FDADocs 5/9/2008 |
140 |
1 |
0 |
legal
FDADocs 5/9/2008 |
112 |
0 |
0 |
legal
FDADocs 5/9/2008 |
93 |
0 |
0 |
legal
FDADocs 5/9/2008 |
142 |
1 |
0 |
legal
FDADocs 5/12/2008 |
142 |
1 |
0 |
legal
FDADocs 5/12/2008 |
279 |
1 |
0 |
legal
FDADocs 5/12/2008 |
157 |
1 |
0 |
legal
FDADocs 5/12/2008 |
159 |
1 |
0 |
legal
FDADocs 5/12/2008 |
109 |
2 |
0 |
legal
FDADocs 5/12/2008 |
122 |
0 |
0 |
legal
FDADocs 5/12/2008 |
228 |
0 |
0 |
legal
FDADocs 5/12/2008 |
181 |
0 |
0 |
legal
FDADocs 5/12/2008 |
265 |
0 |
0 |
legal
FDADocs 5/12/2008 |
113 |
0 |
0 |
legal