Analysis - English

Document Sample
scope of work template
							Aircraft Name:                                    USAGE
Version No:   v 1.0                                                Yellow is for user input
Date Modified:                                                     Blue is for output (formulae)
Designed by:
Contact:




              Aircraft Parameters:

              A/C Gross Weight:               5   lbs              Flaps up Clmax:                    1.4
              Desired stall speed:           20   knots, flaps up Flaps down Clmax:                   1.8
              Desired stall speed:           15   knots, flaps down
              Min Wing Area =               2.6   sq ft, flaps up Min Wing Area =                     3.6
              Flat plate area:             0.50   sq ft            Max horsepower:                    0.1
              Total wing area:              6.0   sq ft            Max prop RPM:                  20700
              Wingspan:                     6.0   ft (upper wingspan for a biplane or wingspan for a monoplane)
              Lower wingspan:                 0   ft (lower wingspan for a biplane. Enter 0 for a monoplane)
              Wing gap:                       0   ft (distance between upper and lower wing if the a/c is a biplane. Enter 0
              estimated k1 =               1.00                    engine bsfc:
                                                  biplane span factor                                 0.5
              Rectangular wing:               1   1, yes, 0 no     Max fuel (gal):                  0.01
              max fus width:                0.4   feet             Reserve fuel:                        2
              fus max height:               0.4   feet             Prop W.R.:                      0.066
              est airplane 'e'=            0.83                    mu =                               0.1
              Propeller Diameter:             9   inches           Vto/Vstall                       1.15
              Est Prop efficiency=         0.45
              Prop efficiency:             0.78   ** iterate until equals estimated prop efficiency (then subtract .03 if

              Estimated Sea Level Standard Day Performance:

              Vmax =                         27   mph =                               24   knots
              V best ROC =                   17   mph =                               15   knots
              Vmax L/D =                     17   mph =                               15   knots
              V min pwr =                    13   mph =                               11   knots
              Vstall, clean =                15   mph =                               13   knots
              Vstall, flaps =                13   mph =                               12   knots
              Max range =                    47   statute miles=                      41   nautical miles
              Wing loading=                0.83   lbs/sq ft
              Power loading =             50.00   lbs/horsepower

              Suggested Peak Efficiency 2 Blade Propeller Diameter =                   8 inches

              Estimated Takeoff and Landing Performance:

              T.O. distance =                55 ft, fixed pitch prop
T.O. over 50' =                 326    ft, fixed pitch prop                    Landing dist. =
T.O. distance =                  39    ft, constant speed prop                 Land over 50'=
T.O. over 50' =                 268    ft, constant speed prop
T.O. Speed=                      18    mph =                               15 kts

Weight and Balance Estimate:

Ultimate Load Factor:              6   g's               start of flap/semispan:          0.08
Horizontal Tail Area:           1.50   sq ft             end of flap/semispan:            0.49
Vertical Tail Area:             0.75   sq ft             airfoil alphaCL0:                -2.0
Max fuel capacity:                 1   gallons           Sug. wing incidence =             3.7
Wing root t/c:                    18                     Wing incidence:
                                       % chord (for cantilever wing)                       1.0
Fuselage Length:                   2                     Wing
                                       ft (from firewall aft) taper ratio:                   1
# front passengers:                0
# rear passengers:                 0
Fuselage construction:             1   1 - tube & fabric, 2 - metal, 3 - composite
Wing construction:                 1   1 - fabric external brace, 2 - metal external brace, 3 - metal cantilever, 4
Tail construction:                 1   1 - fabric external brace, 2 - metal cantilever, 3 - composite cantilever
Propeller type:                    1   1 - wooden fixed pitch, 2 - metal fixed pitch
Landing gear type:                 1   1 - taildragger, 2 - tricycle gear

Fuselage structure                  Weight Estimate (lbs)                      Wing structure
Welded steel tube & fabric covered fuselage   0.4                              Fabric covered external braced wi
Metal fuselage                                0.4                              Metal covered external braced win
Composite fuselage                            0.4                              Metal cantilever wing
Cockpit controls                              0.0                              Composite cantilever wing
Control system                                0.0
Seat (per passenger)                          0.0                              Propulsion group
Interior                                      0.0                              Cowling
Paint (complete airplane)                     0.0                              Engine mount
                                                                               Fuel system components
Tail structure                                                                 Fuel tanks
Fabric covered external braced hor. tail           1.2                         Wooden fixed pitch propeller
Metal horizontal tail                              1.3                         Metal fixed pitch propeller
Composite horizontal tail                          1.5
Fabric covered external braced vert. tail          0.6                         Landing gear
Metal vertical tail                                0.7                         Main wheels
Composite vertical tail                            0.8                         Nose wheel
                                                                               Tail wheel
Electrical and instrumentation group                                           Main gear legs
Instruments/Avionics                               0.5                         Nose gear leg
Battery                                            0.0                         Tail wheel leg
Electrical system                                  0.1


Mean aerodynamic chord (MAC) =                   12.00 inches (for a monoplane wing)
Fuselage station of MAC 1/4 chord:               12.00 inches

Empty Aircraft Weight and Balance
      Item                    Estimated Weight (lbs)Weight (lbs)             F.S.
         1        Wing                       5.9                 5.9             15.00
         2        Fuselage                   0.4                 0.4             15.00
         3        Hor. tail                  1.2                 1.2             28.00
         4        Vert. tail                 0.6                 0.6             28.00
         5        Main gear wheels           0.0                 0.0             13.00
         6        Main gear wheel pants                          8.0             13.00
         7        Main gear legs             0.1                 0.1             13.00
         8        Nose gear wheel            0.0                 0.0              0.00
         9        Nose gear wheel pants                          0.0              0.00
        10        Nose gear leg              0.0                 0.0              0.00
        11        Tail wheel                 0.0                 0.0             28.00
        12        Tail wheel leg             0.0                 0.0             28.00
        13        Cockpit controls           0.0                 0.0             15.00
        14        Control system             0.0                 0.0             18.00
        15        Engine (including accessories)                 0.5              8.00
        16        Spinner                                        3.0              0.00
        17        Propeller                  1.5                 1.5              0.00
        18        Engine mount               0.0                 0.0              9.00
        19        Cowling                    0.0                 0.0              8.00
        20        Battery                    0.0                 0.0             95.00
        21        Fuel tanks                 0.7                 0.7             10.00
        22        Fuel system                0.0                 0.0             10.00
        23        Inst/Avionics              0.5                 0.5             10.00
        24        Electrical system          0.1                 0.1             10.00
        25        Interior                   0.0                 0.0              0.00
        26        Front seats                0.0                 0.0              0.00
        27        Back seats                 0.0                 0.0              0.00
        28        Paint                      0.0                 0.0              0.00
                  Totals                                       22.4               12.0

                  Payload
                  Empty weight                                    22   lbs
                  Front passenger                                  0   lbs
                  Rear passenger                                   0   lbs
                  Baggage                                          0   lbs
                  Fuel           (6 lbs/gallon for gasoline)       1   lbs
                  Oil            (7.5 lbs/gallon)                0.1   lbs
                  Payload                                          1   lbs
                  Gross Weight =                                  24   lbs
                  Gross Weight from cell C15 =                     5   lbs

Forward CG Condition
      Item                                          Weight (lbs)             F.S.
        1        Empty weight                                    22                 12.0
        2        Front passenger                                  0                    0
        3        Rear passenger                                   0                    0
        4        Baggage                                          0                    0
        5        Fuel          (6 lbs/gallon for gasoline)        1                   12
                           6          Oil           (7.5 lbs/gallon)                  0.1             12
                                                    Total                              24           12.0
                 Total payload =                  1 lbs
                 Gross weight =                  24 lbs (for the given payload)
                 Hor C.G. position =          12.0 in =                            25.0% MAC
                 Ver C.G. position =            5.9 in =                          -67.8% MAC (negative below wing)
                 Horizontal angle between wheel and aft fuselage (or tailwheel) =    14.1 degrees (min. angle req'd to keep
                 Vertical angle between CG and main gear axle (taildragger) =        25.0 degrees ( 13 deg minimum at forw

                 Aft CG Condition
                        Item                                              Weight (lbs)            F.S.
                          1           Empty weight                                      22               12.0
                          2           Front passenger                                    0                  0
                          3           Rear passenger                                     0                  0
                          4           Baggage                                            0                  0
                          5           Fuel           (6 lbs/gallon for gasoline)         1                 12
                          6           Oil            (7.5 lbs/gallon)                  0.1                 12
                                                     Total                              24               12.0
                 Total payload =                   1 lbs
                 Gross weight =                   24 lbs (for the given payload)
                 Hor C.G. position =            12.0 in =                           25.0%    MAC
                 Ver C.G. position =             5.9 in =                          -67.8%    MAC (negative below wing)
                 Horizontal angle between wheel and aft fuselage (or tailwheel) =     14.1   degrees (min. angle req'd to keep
                 Vertical angle between CG and main gear axle (taildragger) =         25.0   degrees ( 13 deg minimum at forw
                 Vertical angle between CG and main gear axle (tricycle gear) =        N/A   degrees (must be greater than the
                 Min. vertical angle between CG and main gear axle (tricycle gear) = N/A     degrees (minimum req'd angle to k




Aircraft Preliminary Performance Estimate and Sizing Spreadsheet
Modified for use on R/C aircraft.
Based on methods and information presented in:
Sport Aviation Magazine, May, 2000, by Neal Willford
"Technical Aerodynamics" by K.D. Wood
"Aircraft Design" by K.D. Wood
"Engineering Aerodynamics" by W.S. Diehl
 "Airplane Performance, Stability and Control" by Perkins and Hage
"Preliminary Design Processes" by Herb Rawdon
                                                                      Background calculations
               approximately 1.3 to 1.4                               Cdo =                     0.083
                if no flaps enter same value as flaps up              Lp =                      10.00
               approximately 1.8 for plain flaps, 2.0 for slotted     Lt =                      64.10
               sq ft, flaps down                                      Ls =                       0.17
               bhp                         74.6 Watts                 lambda =                  20.02
                                                                      Wing AR =                  6.00
 pan for a monoplane)                                                 Lt cnsspd =               56.19
 for a monoplane)                                                     lamda cnsspd=             16.79
ng if the a/c is a biplane. Enter 0 for a monoplane)                  Cs 3bl =                   0.52
                get from engine manufacturer's information            L/Dmax =                   6.83
                gallons                                               Prop/body int=             0.96
                minutes
                chord/Diameter @ 75% prop radius
                .03 concrete, .05 short grass, 0.1 long grass
                ratio of takeoff speed to stall speed (1.15 to 1.2)

efficiency (then subtract .03 if using a wooden propeller)




               Fixed Pitch Propeller Performance                      Propeller advance ratio, J =      0.15
               max ROC =                   222 fpm                    T (fixed pitch)=                     2
               Abs. Ceiling =           12906 feet                    Tc (fixed pitch)=                    1
               Service Ceiling=          7092 feet                    T (constant speed)=                  2
               Constant Speed Propeller Performance                   Tc (constant speed)=                 2
               max ROC =                   284 fpm
               Abs. Ceiling =           14828 feet                    R =                                 1
               Service Ceiling=          9607 feet                    Dc =                                0
               Cl at Vmax =               0.44                        Xt fixed pitch=                     9
               Estimated Propeller                                    Ht fixed pitch=                     1
               Pitch =                      0.4 inches                Xt constant speed=                 10
                                                                      Ht constant speed=                  1
                           37 feet, flaps down (1.15xVstall)
                          455 feet, flaps down (1.15xVstall)




              0 if no flaps
              0 if no flaps                                      Wing root chord=           12.00
              airfoil zero lift angle (typically -2 to -4 deg)   Wing tip chord=            12.00
              degrees (suggested wing incidence at the MAC)      aw =                       0.077
              degrees (wing incidence at the MAC)                delta alfa0 =              -4.00
              (tip chord/root chord)                             approx delta Clflap=        0.78
                                                                 flaps up stall angle =      13.4
                                                                 flaps down stall angle =    14.1

 al brace, 3 - metal cantilever, 4 - composite cantilever
ever, 3 - composite cantilever




 ng structure                 Weight Estimate (lbs)
 bric covered external braced wing      5.9
etal covered external braced wing       6.5
etal cantilever wing                    1.1
 mposite cantilever wing                1.3

opulsion group
                                           0.0
                                           0.0
el system components                       0.0
                                           0.7
ooden fixed pitch propeller                1.5
etal fixed pitch propeller                 4.6


                                           0.0
                                           0.0
                                           0.0
                                           0.1
                                           0.0
                                           0.0
W.L.         HZ mom.      VT mom.
   14.00            88           83
   12.00             5            4
   12.00            33           14
   14.00            16            8
     8.00            0            0
     8.00          104           64
     9.00            1            1
     0.00            0            0
     0.00            0            0
     0.00            0            0
   10.00             0            0
   10.00             0            0
   10.00             0            0
   13.00             0            0
   11.00             4            6
   11.00             0           33
   11.00             0           16
   11.00             0            0
   11.00             0            0
   10.00             4            0
   11.00             7            7
   11.00             0            0
   11.00             5            6
   11.00             1            1
   12.00             0            0
   11.00             0            0
   11.00             0            0
   13.00             0            0
     10.8          270          244




W.L.         HZ mom.      VT mom.
       6.0         269          135
         0            0           0
         0            0           0
         0            0           0
         3           12           3
                           3              1               0
                         5.9            283             138




AC (negative below wing)
grees (min. angle req'd to keep tail from hitting ground on landing)
grees ( 13 deg minimum at forward CG location, about 25 deg at aft)


                  W.L.          HZ mom.        VT mom.
                         6.0          269            135
                           0             0             0
                           0             0             0
                           0             0             0
                           3            12             3
                           3             1             0
                         5.9          283            138




AC (negative below wing)
grees (min. angle req'd to keep tail from hitting ground on landing)
grees ( 13 deg minimum at forward CG location, about 25 deg at aft)
grees (must be greater than the angle below for a tricycle gear)
grees (minimum req'd angle to keep from tipping on tail at landing)
lbs at .7Vto
lbs at Vto
lbs at .7Vto
lbs at Vto

lbs at .7Vto
lbs at Vto
ft
ft
ft
ft
inches
inches
(CL/deg) wing lift slope
degrees, delta for zero alpha due to flaps
approx increase in Cl of 2-d wing section due to flap deflection
degrees
degrees
SD7062                 GOE 386 AIRFOIL        EPPLER E1212           AIRFOIL

       1           0           1    -0.0016           1          0
 0.99646    0.00027     0.95034    -0.00497    0.99621     0.00008
 0.98593    0.00092     0.90057    -0.00834    0.98512     0.00006
 0.96864    0.00163     0.80102    -0.01509    0.96735    -0.00038
 0.94491    0.00216     0.70148    -0.02184     0.9434    -0.00118
 0.91518     0.0023     0.60194    -0.02859    0.91355    -0.00231
 0.87998    0.00189      0.5024    -0.03534     0.8782    -0.00392
  0.8399    0.00087     0.40286    -0.04209    0.83789    -0.00611
 0.79557   -0.00079     0.30331    -0.04884    0.79324    -0.00892
 0.74768   -0.00307     0.20369    -0.05429    0.74489    -0.01234
 0.69692   -0.00593     0.15379    -0.05577    0.69355    -0.01635
 0.64403   -0.00927     0.10366    -0.05387    0.63994    -0.02089
 0.58975   -0.01295     0.07841    -0.05018     0.5848    -0.02587
 0.53477    -0.0168     0.05316     -0.0466    0.52889     -0.0312
 0.47979   -0.02064      0.0276    -0.03823    0.47299    -0.03672
 0.42547   -0.02426     0.01447    -0.02892    0.41785    -0.04229
 0.37238   -0.02747     0.00001           0    0.36422     -0.0477
 0.32105    -0.0301     0.01007     0.03588    0.31285    -0.05273
 0.27199   -0.03206      0.0214     0.05315    0.26443    -0.05712
  0.2257   -0.03327     0.04479     0.07694    0.21963    -0.06055
 0.18265   -0.03367     0.06855     0.09525     0.1791    -0.06247
 0.14328   -0.03319     0.09262     0.10888    0.14296    -0.06215
 0.10798   -0.03179     0.14122     0.12957    0.11083    -0.05933
  0.0771   -0.02948     0.19032      0.1428     0.0825    -0.05429
 0.05099   -0.02623     0.28963     0.15304       0.058   -0.04733
 0.02991   -0.02205     0.38971     0.15182    0.03738    -0.03884
 0.01414   -0.01701     0.49062     0.13836    0.02081    -0.02927
 0.00425   -0.01115        0.592    0.11804    0.00858    -0.01911
 0.00027   -0.00327     0.69356     0.09502    0.00152    -0.00892
 0.00103    0.00711     0.79543     0.06743           0          0
 0.00562    0.01871      0.8976     0.03546     0.0001     0.00239
  0.0141    0.03081     0.94872     0.01892    0.00342     0.01552
  0.0265       0.043           1     0.0016    0.01072     0.02949
 0.04272    0.05491                            0.02185     0.04371
 0.06269    0.06616                            0.03668     0.05773
 0.08637    0.07647                            0.05506     0.07116
 0.11363    0.08562                            0.07682      0.0836
 0.14432     0.0934                            0.10175     0.09455
 0.17825    0.09965                            0.12989     0.10351
 0.21521    0.10428                            0.16137     0.11031
 0.25496    0.10722                            0.19609     0.11495
  0.2972    0.10846                            0.23389     0.11735
 0.34159    0.10801                            0.27463     0.11756
 0.38779    0.10592                            0.31804      0.1157
  0.4354    0.10229                            0.36383     0.11193
 0.48402    0.09723                            0.41164     0.10643
 0.53322    0.09089                            0.46109     0.09947
 0.58254            0.08347                               0.51172    0.09133
 0.63154            0.07517                                  0.563   0.08233
 0.67973            0.06626                               0.61437    0.07282
 0.72662            0.05702                                0.6652    0.06312
 0.77166            0.04778                                0.7148    0.05357
 0.81427            0.03885                               0.76246    0.04443
 0.85381            0.03049                               0.80747    0.03595
 0.88967            0.02289                                0.8491    0.02829
 0.92127            0.01615                               0.88664    0.02155
 0.94818            0.01036                               0.91947    0.01575
 0.97004            0.00571                               0.94698    0.01076
 0.98634            0.00242                               0.96898    0.00634
 0.99652            0.00057                               0.98556    0.00275
       1                  0                               0.99625    0.00062
                                                                 1         0

                                          SD7062 Airfoil
         0.15

          0.1
Y-Axis




         0.05

           0
                0             0.2   0.4           0.6                0.8       1
   -0.05
                                                 X-Axis

                                          GOE 386 Airfoil
          0.2

          0.1
Y-Axis




            0
                0             0.2   0.4           0.6                0.8       1
         -0.1                                   X-Axis


                                      Eppler E1212 Airfoil
         0.15
          0.1
Y-Axis




         0.05
            0
     -0.05 0                  0.2   0.4            0.6               0.8       1
-0.05 0       0.2   0.4       0.6     0.8   1
    -0.1                     X-Axis

                          SD 7032

      0.1
     0.08
     0.06
     0.04
Y




     0.02
        0
    -0.02 0   0.2   0.4        0.6    0.8   1
    -0.04
                                X
SD7032

       1           0
  0.9967     0.0003
 0.98684    0.00113
 0.97054    0.00226
 0.94797     0.0035
 0.91942    0.00458
 0.88534    0.00526
 0.84635    0.00535
 0.80313    0.00485
 0.75634    0.00379
 0.70664    0.00224
 0.65469     0.0003
 0.60112    -0.0019
 0.54659    -0.0043
 0.49176   -0.00678
 0.43724   -0.00922
 0.38364   -0.01152
 0.33154   -0.01363
 0.28153   -0.01547
  0.2342   -0.01699
  0.1901    -0.0181
 0.14974   -0.01867
 0.11351   -0.01862
  0.0818   -0.01787
 0.05491   -0.01635
 0.03308   -0.01403
 0.01649   -0.01088
 0.00532   -0.00701
 0.00038   -0.00223
 0.00115    0.00448
 0.00606    0.01293
 0.01502    0.02206
 0.02812    0.03145
 0.04524    0.04078
 0.06627    0.04976
 0.09105    0.05809
 0.11948    0.06548
 0.15146    0.07182
 0.18671    0.07703
 0.22499    0.08096
 0.26604    0.08359
 0.30953    0.08493
 0.35506       0.085
 0.40222    0.08385
 0.45058    0.08154
 0.49967    0.07816
 0.54902    0.07381
      0.59812   0.06861
      0.64646    0.0627
      0.69356    0.0562
      0.73892   0.04925
      0.78208   0.04199
      0.82264    0.0346
      0.86021   0.02731
      0.89436   0.02041
      0.92464    0.0142
      0.95054   0.00894
      0.97155   0.00485
      0.98712   0.00204
      0.99674   0.00048
            1         0




1.2




1.2




1.2
1.2




1.2
GOE 386                                             Eppler
Alpha    CL        CM        CD                     Alpha           CL              CM               CD
      -4    0.1261    -0.106 0.01679                           -4        -0.1071           -0.063     0.01567
      -2    0.3416    -0.104    0.0158                         -2         0.1133            -0.06     0.01548
       0    0.5625    -0.103     0.016                          0         0.3331           -0.056       0.0143
       2    0.7709    -0.098 0.01471                            2         0.5504           -0.055     0.01416
       4    1.0046    -0.101 0.01528                            4         0.7794           -0.054     0.01406
       6    1.1362    -0.064 0.01688                            6         0.9797            -0.05     0.01651
       8    1.2801    -0.073 0.02051                            8         1.1709           -0.045     0.01996
      10    1.4267    -0.066 0.02524                           10         1.3431           -0.038     0.02316
      12    1.5611    -0.059 0.03114                           12         0.6936           -0.025     0.03033

                    CL vs. Alpfa GOE386                              Cl vs. Alpfa Eppler1212
                1.8                                            1.6
                1.6                                            1.4
                1.4                                            1.2
                1.2                                              1
                  1                                            0.8
                                                     CL
  CL




                0.8
                                                               0.6
                0.6
                                                               0.4
                0.4
                                                               0.2
                0.2
                  0                                              0
               -0.2 0                                 -5       -0.2 0               5          10          15
   -5                         5
                            Alpfa     10       15                                 Alpha


                           Cl vs CD                                             CL vs. CD
  1.8                                                 1.6
  1.6                                                 1.4
  1.4                                                 1.2
  1.2                                                      1
       1                                              0.8
  CL




                                                     CL




  0.8                                                 0.6
  0.6                                                 0.4
  0.4
                                                      0.2
  0.2
                                                           0
       0
                                                      -0.2 0             0.01       0.02      0.03      0.04
           0        0.01     0.02     0.03   0.04                                    CD
                              CD
SD7062                                          SD7032
Alpha    CL        CM       CD                  Alpha    CL        CM        CD
      -4    0.0192    -0.091 0.01735                  -4    0.0128    -0.102    0.0193
      -2    0.2331    -0.087 0.01115                  -2    0.2376       -0.1 0.01026
       0    0.4405    -0.082 0.01029                   0    0.4478    -0.093 0.00815
       2    0.6703    -0.081 0.01069                   2    0.6652    -0.091 0.00877
       4     0.884    -0.079 0.01198                   4    0.8749    -0.088 0.01035
       6     1.089    -0.076 0.01402                   6     1.076    -0.085 0.01268
       8    1.2754    -0.071 0.01703                   8    1.2475    -0.079 0.01669
      10    1.4319    -0.063 0.02059                  10     1.388    -0.069 0.02232
      12    1.5274    -0.049 0.02681                  12     1.418    -0.051 0.03535

                Cl vs. Alpha SD7062                                   Cl vs. Alpha SD7062
            1.8                                                 1.6
            1.6                                                 1.4
            1.4                                                 1.2
            1.2                                                  1
              1                                                 0.8
                                                 CL
CL




            0.8
                                                                0.6
            0.6
                                                                0.4
            0.4
            0.2                                                 0.2
              0                                                  0
  -5       -0.2 0          5        10     15     -5        -0.2 0                5         10     15
                         Alpha                                                  Alpha


                     CL vs. CD                                                CL vs. CD
     1.8                                              1.6
     1.6                                              1.4
     1.4                                              1.2
     1.2                                               1
       1
                                                 CL




                                                      0.8
 CL




     0.8
                                                      0.6
     0.6
                                                      0.4
     0.4
     0.2                                              0.2
       0                                               0
           0        0.01                                    0          0.01       0.02    0.03   0.04
                           CD 0.02       0.03                                      CD
GOE 386                                           Eppler
Alpha    CL        CM       CD                    Alpha            CL              CM                CD
      -4     0.122    -0.104 0.01414                         -4         -0.1118          -0.062       0.01164
      -2    0.3369    -0.102 0.01263                         -2          0.1117           -0.06       0.01103
       0    0.5609    -0.101 0.01212                          0          0.3381          -0.056       0.01106
       2    0.7738    -0.099 0.01147                          2          0.5602          -0.056       0.01101
       4    0.8595    -0.093 0.01075                          4          0.7718          -0.053       0.01099
       6    1.1291    -0.063 0.01396                          6          0.9969          -0.052       0.01216
       8    1.2816    -0.074 0.01745                          8          1.1994          -0.048       0.01384
      10    1.4226    -0.066 0.02222                         10          1.3838          -0.043       0.01647
      12    1.5441    -0.059 0.02879                         12          1.5151          -0.031       0.02039


                  CL vs. Alpfa GOE386                              Cl vs. Alpfa Eppler1212
              1.8                                            1.6
              1.6                                            1.4
              1.4                                            1.2
              1.2                                              1
                1                                            0.8
                                                   CL
CL




              0.8
                                                             0.6
              0.6
                                                             0.4
              0.4
                                                             0.2
              0.2
                                                               0
                0
             -0.2 0                                 -5       -0.2 0                5            10        15
 -5                         5
                          Alpfa     10       15                                  Alpha




                         Cl vs CD                                          CL vs. CD
 1.8                                                1.6
 1.6                                                1.4
 1.4                                                1.2
 1.2                                                     1
     1                                              0.8
CL




                                                   CL




 0.8                                                0.6
 0.6
                                                    0.4
 0.4
                                                    0.2
 0.2
                                                         0
     0
                                                    -0.2 0                0.01           0.02           0.03
         0        0.01      0.02    0.03   0.04                                    CD
                             CD
SD7062                                            SD7032
Alpha    CL        CM        CD                   Alpha    CL        CM        CD
      -4    0.1747    -0.062 0.14676                    -4    0.0201    -0.099    0.0125
      -2    0.1217    -0.003 0.08059                    -2    0.2379    -0.096 0.00641
       0     0.458    -0.085 0.00622                     0    0.4433    -0.091 0.00604
       2     0.663    -0.079 0.00605                     2    0.6676    -0.091 0.00674
       4    0.8938    -0.081 0.00924                     4    0.8812     -0.09 0.00827
       6    1.1049    -0.079 0.01089                     6    1.0858    -0.088 0.01045
       8    1.2986    -0.075 0.01328                     8    1.2549    -0.082 0.01565
      10    1.4668    -0.068 0.01621                    10     1.398    -0.072 0.02109
      12    1.5805    -0.055    0.0212                  12     1.479    -0.056 0.02936
                                                                       Cl vs. Alpha SD7062
             Cl vs. Alpha SD7062                                 1.6
         1.8                                                     1.4
         1.6                                                     1.2
         1.4                                                       1
         1.2
                                                                 0.8
                                                   CL
           1
                                                                 0.6
CL




         0.8
         0.6                                                     0.4
         0.4                                                     0.2
         0.2                                                       0
           0                                        -5           -0.2 0              5        10       15
                                                                                   Alpha
  -5    -0.2 0              5        10      15
                          Alpha

                                                                                 CL vs. CD
                                                    1.6
                        CL vs. CD                   1.4
  1.8                                               1.2
  1.6                                                    1
  1.4
                                                   CL




                                                    0.8
  1.2
                                                    0.6
    1
CL




  0.8                                               0.4
  0.6                                               0.2
  0.4                                                    0
  0.2                                                        0            0.01       0.02    0.03   0.04
                                                                                      CD
    0
        0        0.05       0.1
                            CD      0.15   0.2

						
Related docs