Fulbright & Jaworski L.L.P. v. Earthlink Legal Department - 1

Case 1:07-mi-00097 Document 1 Filed 04/12/2007 Page 1 of 29 osemesees aasms a.maa .ss sszm a amss x .m . eem a .ms. asea m pms ssam s a....ema .m. Issued bly, the GE C9113 1A NORTHERN DISTRIC"T OF ------------------------ --------------------------------------- 5~1JBlj '/)j :1 qAL IN .A. :MIL IJO&E, 'V. C 'r(} ; IEarthfinik Legal CtimlAiance, . 1375 PE ;'actitreie Street, N .vV,,, Level .A ,Aiianta, GA'3Ci3OMg1 "Number' C] YO'U ' a4RM, COMMANDED to ap,pe,ul in the United Sita te ;;1Di:;trict cowl ax tl u, lp'Ia,co, id31e, mnd t i nne specified b e1oN to testify in the above case . PLACE, 011-105111401,11 Y C OURTEt ODM ', DATE A MO'ITME C3 ~t~~tf ,A.P;1 : C;O11IlIrrSA~10~EiI) G~ a p~p~~~u Pit t1h~~ p (ace, ~d~3te, ~~~d tin~c ; s~~ec iifi{ed be'Ic~vv tc> ~te ;stiFy at ~tt~e 4akii~, a~P~~ de~p~~ ;aition in the above cast .. iE AND YDt1 , ARE, CON[Pv1AN DF:D t o Produce and permit inspection am d e;apy 'u ig of the ft l lowing, documents at obj cas at the f1l,aCt;, claIC, Mid 6Me specified below (list; dcx:urni e»is or objects) : Rair rie an d contact inl'onnation in your cus itid' ylcxiritirod rell ati3cf t oftm IP address, ;t4,1 48. 11 W; :45„ which Was used lit 9G:45:(f(f P01 "'On July 31,200i3, 1o, ims t mlal,e~n l al on vwrvw.laband br arxly.lbl'ogs pat.,aorn that irifirnngeNJ fl io Natilonal Coloi n1feren+C3 o af Ba r E:xannil ner,>' cripy rights to Multistate 13,3r IEXa 1M1na tiori iq , u vatk>ns lfnai Ti the July 2' 006 oxMSrIalI cl csiignare one car more off] iixxs, clirectcros, or nn;uLagir ig , <F P3 ' E ', Di Ef7 ' I ;PRIA5 ' Wiv v1 E ;I . MULE L)EDC L,AL1LA,7'ICEr1 C}]17 SERVER I iCe cl~~re an der pe~~stnr {~'F~a~.•i j~ ~.y~iu:dc; r tlh~~ k~vv:> i~~E l~e [1nit~;d ~5i~at~„~ i~i'~~tr~e ric~a tl~ac the fio, re :g;ciual ; itsiorrmation c on tunc ~d in the lP;mc i f'of' .Sinv ic . a: is Inv: and correct i .Krc;ui o n ----------------------- .~.. . D A:1131 ---------------------------------icri ci FSE xvER : ----------------------------II, Ci C iRES ;7 DF 91n Ztlji P 11.00 15, F xlend Rules of i,:iivil F "nxe diue, . 'P u ,adivisia~ns (c . )„ (d.), macl (e), as eundri da9 o n Da xcib e r 1, 2 OOiS : (/:) PI lOlF:CdON Of 1PE R'iOV.'i S 'V ilECT 'I'I/ SU '8101'11A !i. , . 1 ;1 ;1 A p+ i tr ar ae ti loiui:y Rsi pauibls 1 b e QK isru.ci a r tnd4ier+w : e ol'a abliae a iaA+iii nranas.ble pu :p s 'lo wii im)oi , uiabe bwn.' kn * r e xp ecw~ on . pu . o o aaLj ac l t o Uw l m mibpc Kn a, '[! .s o aurt oo behalf of W lit : h the ubl wepa wits itaell ti h+Jl . tsort IL is Airy and p hirgo K u lwo Ao e >> n y e i r ur oi misy fai b n aa6 0 l' UJiiv d'u1y aa i app Ri a i n ctiA i4 ' w liti4 way hwliw le , hPA Iii not limited to, lost 4 ai acid a m+ ui attame;/'o Its . i(2 ,I (A) A pi wmm iia d rA to 1m)i aid permit Irr"P eeAHIa . og 7ying, p 41iug. o r WIMP lie i g ol'd :=i ;ga.da1 a lee1 ro n k Ylly aOl a1 anfoenu aiai .l wois, pn pe nti ii oauniiin oiruLngilyle qunpp, o r inspection, o1' pre m i si aced wit .Fp :a r In pi au th e p lmis air Ir Rdiuctio o Or Lui tin lam w m muA:d to, sp%e4Lr f r clq)o dlra o, bwi or ariiL o (B) S ut g eato pmign;P h (dYZ ) oflhb nuk,ujw ixq aimmte A:d to produce Jd pmrit insIN etii ea P7Rn g, u s ani a& or s airg liiso ar y.'.di th i . 14 1 allla r 4 e iv i d , a f iLn aur P*o4 or baton ltbe tins spa:i l ied ifon aa n;aGLow (l' such dint iii Some Ihrja 141 d.i .I Ssr iK i ri a~, iK irve upcm the ip.R;/ eK saci daagt wail ui the wibp c Ki u wrilteo i)bje ctiali to pn mur ing any or all aiflba duigm ied ingeriii,Gi or Gsn,pecLioie nfllwi prem ipn -a rG~p R~ uing cleelroai~a p)r ~larra ! Gn ibrm u iai ii3 tAe kmn~ x bmp ~oqu~atad. G'dbjipi 6 medic, the parry . eri this IRLbipioi iiIIIAI tore Ib 0 pi to ~GJCK/:~ CC~;~~ 11NR.01 ' ilgl~k the sn te rials a r ineepea the pn:nua uuJepi pwnun l l aa n o rdero fhl ivaui 7l iywh icbUkrubf ot a. w+a i a.wd if abja ii,oa kub vnrude, he parry scn i og the m kpa ou nry ulpa o aalax ton slh a p en tau aom rtywded W piadu a , ireirN e i 1o or i,lreclad by the wblweo a, g+mb or incid i ~, the r ib',paa iu or, if rlm : ;wry Ui .rhae 'M hWl' We au'bpa injg Is ir aa A dw Wj u .uldc aotud IMM! Ibc the qMimo oy Of 1rtrq11rid that emote Iba Ofse lrruy red Ni u U W pa i 4vdithi p and .,wunn list die p : nb iv Ib whcrai tl x aibpi is .lldi-aaed will her ra .o mllY aapvd Lsi,a C*01h air. cWrbir a pFwuaa x a' p rodiicfio a in ly i ur iap npx,i/i edl o0iodiiiiwti (e)1purrms n+'WsirormuaciTn'Strercieaiuw (1) ( \) /lA person Iu Q oo idi ell to +& iu bpa m i to pmdui d na i nkioUi shill praluu UK l m .n the), am fuVl WUaa% r nmd oau3 se ofbimicias ~o rstulle~ putiwa dad Mcitherntocownipnd with the iosiciaori+m is the dic.miu d, (1!) I f& iulspoam da a jsal i pi die fomiar loytns la piraiucir4 ; e lln:u a ikalty .tored' in , fairrntki o s a poises n.p i ai l4o a smb1po aaa more Ipm-duos t!e iu fo rnW,ia e is a fi>n n a' fcirs n 4i iii th s penx ordi oaay it wupi u iqe !A gar ie i a Form or lame II6 iu ar e im,tosnatily aul) la (l) A pM; n rni rispchuliag to a .utpra4 acid a x produce th e iw= ala:Uaika!!y s tored ieTaan1i iai More IbA .1i a-as loam . (1)) A person 11C1pOl daJS to a INlbpcem& iwd sent p ivrw l a diLu orory o irdocriroioii A MaedLuifomrifin fi aniw urxt Nit Ibi per.ca Ideolil le s Jig K R t awi e ibtr .oa x+aZ4a b ccw.e On from Whicari o'f uinlue lwrclea m oaq. dIko+R'.fr is s Citl lght muse sloe lbullhm faform uiAn .miglit {s x ot i e iwmi61y r;am61e becwrr o f uwdue Iburtleei orirau. 1 Cl ~u i~6 o~riio 0 i~~ ar da, lp ~~ aowet ar;~ ro x t h elas ~~ a~~dfer di~ xv . ry, ban iw:h .c w iaea if the ix ~u ~ al ie$ p~ rt;~n b in y, raal e u~~, o a n~ ibeni~ys the l im iu t w~ae o f R ules 2~6Qh}C1',K~%J• 'i~a oauil i~ ~y eF~a:ily ~oo acGtiao~ kK the ~ Wiarrer;~. 1711(~ ~) a7bea~ infi~nr~f~oa aabj a ~ to w r ub~iaen. l s ~ with'held as a el si,m~ tlu1 it i~ pmnl~e gcdL a r ~ ulije~a w ~ ~~rtKa a ioa ~~s tei ~lk• ~~ npiu~dioa~ fe v la~k , L'he cli~l m tlha[1 be utird. e~~ns~ ~y ao dL ~Isa'll lea w ~p,pe~t~ed 6 ~ ~~ dl a w~iptitro a lf tlhe d~n~ni a~f I~~ dlau meon„oonmtiuruca iic~n~,~or IE iogi~ Jiom pialuxd libel is skRisiiei M to si u'blm the dei nncGoig poly loo arol' a K diii cla im Q9)11'uLk)ne.Aioe 61 praduae d Ui ra powK So a .kpo s nu that is sib jax to . cl aim off privilege IN o1' pmiaxion a s I6d•P1eLwWio. Isueltrid„ die Pt moil nrrkioo , time cl uir may a aU ~, t By par, that ra ;i%*t the Gifirmuooo of ati claim a nal the basis for IL A Rier beir$ entiCwd„ a party Inane pro mpely eetura , docMwari d ea ray Ph i speciliiid infasc K Uce amid soy ag i an q has aid may gal' use or dUcio.a Rho Intbi ima im4il the 1eLaia b resolved. A iraoeiviWl panty n r;y ImirtiplJy P m x ,ot the iinlfoimation loo the court uinliprs u! !'ais &ts Rriiakn ol'da dun G[tlhe hMMog panty Iii cloud this Uifonn63a before I1eia 1{ i a ititia3, it musl c ak e ie+MI)o alPle ingw to n uirve it . 'Tim p :e oi who pioclwxi iihi : in formuiau twin p +a K iwi (his uifnn n itin maid iilwt d. im as lraoi (r.) d>NTIWiT7C.lFiihaa o 1`44:f IK ixm .vitlivA .i uCwb m dxy n aulpxos penned pi tl1mi =ro ix ia nay Isn deeme dL Is ~ eoi ue mpl a? fo r nou r t I'romi . rhis 'A 9 1rs i w ibpai lsiwd , An .dki ratesa fo r IE. ilum to aba y ru irtr wh - m a a~we ou pi u~ ioM a t~ ~ mqu im I aoi pkily to ai attend or paaiuw at n 1)ur iwl within qK lima provided by clinic ii ) ol' iutpknLg ryrh (r.H 7](A) , it levy iurne fi r ant ri R la r 1+0 Ix rsep el the p ino dudaa q i nqN gio iti oa q;png , Uea ',ieg or imapl i o 8, :i ucL s o ortl c r qo ca i du l l pni aoy pcrnon l rl io is im M n p utyyr am o[ rk xu of a parry fnonn or 6as i Cui a p lan seauA l ,iwa Ci die ia ;peea4)o e q~yio g, tep i y t,i WurplL ing oa yn m.ni (3) (A)()o lidret;l o~tN~d , tl~ a aw n I ~y .rh iet ~ a n~po e a~ . wiu ini s1 u4 1 iju.s 6 ar modli ! ! y the . utpK os lilt (I) I sib to n1i n m oioab 6e f ine fcer ioompiui w e ; (ii) [eqturq a pc noi i who u wit .a 1wrt y , or an o ilk ray o f a ImMi t o it" iii ilo a pi im m t lwo 1. p] milai firam lbe puce r h e n ; ll wl person ne+nd a i, fee m p l ay a1 afi+e ipila i iy uua.ctt uk„ Picd li urin aes in p :no iy iex cept tEu , w hj cet rothe p mv tsiiau ol 'el uw~ (r.N ; ) lial„ ;iuL ) of this n u IK i uw mr), is omier l a ar e i ri trWl b. as mm. n d4d to ti sii from any w kl b 1~+0i Ii ri,Ai n the guts is i .r hic, S 1 hw tiu) I s held ; (iii) npu i ray dud tie. of p flv i k V:d cir atber p weet .d ini tt er and cia ii)uxj*on a i r (ir)i whje cvt ii person Lo a3dut Wider. IM) 1 fit 141 Mi. (i } i ocpirer4upO11 aw R of a tn id esa R t nr otl6eren n fdr atial research, di,wdopmsa l, tit caimmera . J ioforn ou liaiq or (i,i} re quira i die torture aC .n imrc W ad e xgK it•n o F inion or Izl~a Tn .tio,o e ( K 4kaecdbing specific er eiun or c c:Awrn:ar e g in d'uprta .o cl n rn ihiag ?Rirti die acpm's R ucly mad e iw~t ~ ~t t bn :og w o of jur,f I*irt)ii or (iii) nequ i ii a pano a who u e on a ',p . mr >y cif'infrin .g;im;g material, cm blogger.cOrn ;Ciux Sir or ]N I:u d~un: Pursuant to, Chit Digital 1Nfill e nniaarn Copyright Act (T7;M CA)i, 17 US.C'. § .5112' I Im writing tc) request ycur as siistmix In identiFyii rif; the individual 'or iiriclividild',s vv1113 posted cO pyrii&ted +l'uc, 5l.f iQ ; IlS from the July 2006 1Multistate Bar Examiinaficiri cc "uid b-1--2~r~cbr- am . bhmamt_q C? qtr firm re;pn,se ;rits the Naia onal C'ciF&rcu1ci, of I3m- 'Earamiirie ;rs (NC Ell-3' . NC 1BF : develops , sevea,a exarns that are used b y tit : various juriklictions ILs rXUI Of ffielr bar exam 13i-cOre ;ss„ including the 2v'E«]ti:sLat:e Bar b:flm1;]FltIS)f1 MBE;) . Ind i viicltuas Who take the 1V[13.E; w-c i mtniim:s c:f ttie, to make sure that scores i exam cm tx: meani ngifiill ;y compared to one, x wther;l. Because l que;sdO:ns are re-wskI, it is !]71FICII'G m11. t] ~3t secun: cluE:stiori s. f'roi u a given t& nini:sb a~fi0n c1 !` the 10111E riot tw disclosed Ito r p~rosjpe,cl,i vi e c:a;arni»i;c-s. See_gentafty JjC' B it.,~MIull titxait_e:_L&jal;ludlits,`LiLe_, 2,006 U.S . I?ist . ~1~, L,F-X;IS ;5 '9477, ( ;qP;Y . L,. ]dep. (C:(:; H ) 1129 ,233 Ql131„I), P' . : 0(}6;t; ],V_C1 3 E_v_ j'E~c;cazzo 110,003 `vi . a 2 ', 1 467;F:! (.5 . D . C :d. 2 003) . . Of I'1t:KE i rt;c;e;ntliy cliscav eire;c[ a'blog on v⁣k i one or mom indi'vii cIzkLIs W ho twic the bu . exam in July 2006 «ere posting copyrighted Trf1l1:, cluE:stiiciris, frci rn chat exam, IN .- Hog is 11cumidl w at v_vwvv_„Galb,a~n~~' br~~id~;t~log~~a' t~c{o n~t. I l~~a~ve~ iir irl~de+d ~~t'lf~~l~ FS t]'~,~ F~a.ges 1'r{ ~~i d~~ , bl~~~~ il~a~t sl'a ~~w~ 31 :49:160 . 1 iN ou n mw . Ncw Yo IRn n 1 HAII M IP ro ro n IDC . Au s rm . . DALLAS .- Los Am aaun 1. MINI M[A V o u s . Swm Aw irow c, o :3r. 4 Dui a D u . -i n I-143 aa- lSbmla 9 L .oNinl ei o Idlmu,n o IR I r noI w Case 1:07-mi-00097 April 9, . :t00'7 Page 2: Document 1 Filed 04/12/2007 Page 4 of 29 the infringing, questions . The p erson who set tip Ws bog has sin= removed thec questnms,, Off bci.ng lc o, ntac:tc d b,r her state: lBoari3 o1']LmAr E x, amiirie;rs . ,ihe has informed, us tliat she dpi{d n ot, p3,slt the qui GSfio~rts „ she does not knowr meho d. i d„ and she does no t have any contact iT1 folTflaltion i;cir 11t . i riclividual oir incii,ri ~d u al s; who posted the MBE questions .]ding Specifically, v rc: are &a- H IC "AJli)Il ;h-nous" WC1iti l t 3F o f the individual who FK) sID d the Ial Ia win g post : on July 3 1 , 2(K)6 at 4 :45 pan. P]DT 'I1LrnU.g;h a subpoena i;ssuc;cl to Goog,l e pursuant to the 1DA riCA, we were able to identify the TP mi(hi;ss of Chic indiviiclital wh o :pos'tc;d these un:&im;giriF; entries -- 241 .148 . 1915,4~5 . It is our understandi ng that this IF, iml3,rE;ss is owned by Esirthlirk NVc sum. requesting your as,sista uic:c; in pr-ovi,iinF; tho munc mA all contact inifornz,3tao:a in ;your custody or control related to the IF, address 24,14S ,1 '96 .4>, which w» used sit 1. 6:450D TIDT ; : ,on :filly ;31 , 20UI, to irnake the infringing post to ]~+v~n~+~la._~a~_d,b~ra~n~dy.b~a~spo_t,.c_a~nn. ]Pur:~iu~tEt 1 ,c~ . the I): hiiCA,, written notice Of the + c ojp;yrig;ht viiolaaon. is a pri-m-expus ;i te to issuing a I51,1bJPDC!n, a.. As.cxrrdin gu};, we are submitting N s wr, ttrn notice to you, imiii a subpoena will tolloww 9hori1y„ We agree to E;a.rttliirk s terms of c .onn; pe,nsation (S7S .Rillh I o ar for research, S {).25 pier page, $22 .W t oo respond by Federal Ex pres :i) . 7h e t is,e of the 1 c 1D;pYrilg~,1t a3 materials described a' ~D ve 0» 1.ht allegedly infringing b1l o p; pages was riot aui tt uizi;i ed by rd C E«:,, 'the copyright O wMc;r, or by any agent of I have it good U tlh belief that the use of 1b e, copyrighted materials described a' ~ove I wTS not otherwise authorized byffie l,a mo, . I swear, u,rnclc~r pt:t~alt;y a~ f ' ~>c,tj+wn , i 1,ia,t the infannatii cEri in tlh:i s in + a ti fi c.atiicrri ,,+ i s accurate t oy the best of my lai ir x'1 e 3ge„ mi3 that I arn authorized to act o ri behalf of rd1"MEN the ovmc r o :f uie exclusive rights that have allegedly been infringed . Thank you in advance for your pmrnpt respolise -to this request . ~~GC Caroline M. Idew Enclosures 31 :i09 :l60. 1 Case 1:07-mi-00097 Document 1 Filed 04/12/2007 Page 5 of 29 • rir IL )_Ei i & ---------------------------------------------- Case 1:07-mi-00097 Document 1 Filed 04/12/2007 Page 6 of 29 , . ~ .. ~ . • . . l M~ B M U LT1 Sl'ATE AIR ~ l7KAm i NI ikTI m .. i .' Read the idtix1~ctiajjas, .cam, the back cover., ~, Do noiu0k, the is, eid ixfibl, to are iall t~ do . .. R • ~~ . I+ fA'rII C+ Mt~i ~ ~7N/~!1 ' I: RRfH~S /fll I~ iMR IC1Wl M NtICIRiI~ .. ' t.qJP,~1& 02M ty, lv edonil Qd6raca dlBarbaiie'M , . AU rii#as n:AxxMdd. . . . r ., . . r C .. -- - -- ------ --- ^ r r w r .. - --------------------- m -- --- ----- Case 1:07-mi-00097 Document 1 Filed 04/12/2007 Page 7 of 29 ~E~C Case 1:07-mi-00097 Document 1 Filed 04/12/2007 u 111C rr I. U L KICw'nc1115 7419 V tvo~1°reLu ;~l :c [m~~v,sr] lc;yl LOGaI :~o.:u . ~E LI]s~€~! 1 ` Page 8 of 29 ---_ ., ------------------- ---------------------------------------------------------------------rl~ 1al ~ E1 N E y 13 JL` LA . N 11) Y 11 6 Si 210 SI 26, 2006 ,A 8 0 UI 1. Al I. 1n 113 {, CrN mo I s SEt1a glop io .~ -1 . f, WEDNESDAY', JULY Day 'r%.v,c)„ It Blew ]f don't like the ;Ivi33 :E, and the 101E doesn't likerrie . . r, ] rrLa. VIEW MY' COMPLETE PROFILE . i ]f'irrt mcyt fE:eling ;grE:at about i:c&y. Fumrt ofal[, I had a hotaible 1ime ;sleeping 'bewmE: of really loud :mu:;ic., ]I complained' ' to tlie front desk to no mrO„ ][ don't know Wha!t -dnie i7. :toFpe dI, kot the last -6 me I 1ook.Nl at the c1cxi, before 1, fell i ;t vww; And s;econd , of a ll, welll„ ;[ t]zi~ia~;]~1t iaiE: : N[]B :E was hand. i(]N'aybe ]'in n ffi e: mily,one .'CJberew ene so rnt: ;peo;p:[e :Vra}Rng ~~ ~~~~ m p : 1 ll a -- ,~ 3a 01 w A'V EIt] fiY'F'F]D P nui EMSM it i n as . ) The fanny thing i:,, there v+reren't that many really Kong cTaz;~ fact Wry T'abi? Why Should You Fear People 'Tak'irij ; the Bar? . ..' patterns like I had been led tea believe there would Ix, but: P1we ,;bort 4`art--F1a.ttE'ITL IT13iL:i'flgly5 were avvlkff tyitzi6gr.7Cliez^e: Ken: . r many (L[1, 3:Q;y rnan:Y) where ] y rUl'y had n.o clue as: 1) '.t1+WE'E :fl 'hND pm.mMe, choices and . just bad, to pick. me. PREVIOUS POSTS Joy to the World Day One, Not :k> ;Fun .A fti c3- RU1. 3'',A vvi:Il ,;till love IlYIE even ff ]f dian't pass, fig;bt? Idgb.t'? e Oh, w6n.'Tirne to put it out o#'iay tnuid. anidl get going oil studying for toms»rrnw.. :d3e hardest day of 0. :I. . .~ POSTED BY TAX CONNOISSEUR AT 41 :45 Phh :Fun for 'Shut-1m ; , [211:0 tie B Tei3 c-l1 Zen Accourrualls 'Suck J .._., 'Daily'Affii7na'aon 39 COMMENTS : Di:wovery Rule A1:' 41Torl+: ]Fimlicx and Detours ] ffiought tare. MBE- vrwc. ]hx r( i. l; w as pretly ' m u cb able to ivwrov+i ~6 1 0l12006 12 :03. P:1 - •' Tab and ktiand; r. lhiy ' L }wo : It Is le w Case 1:07-mi-00097 Document 1 Filed 04/12/2007 t~ le J~7iL Unc~~nne~its/a1Va~ut" ~a'l rJ; i~'itTt1~ ~!J:St7lC; yl L,OC~ 31"/o.!~I .ienu~~ ;s~ ,l 'J Page 9 of 29 - mast of the answers tlcAhn to t V T0 chokes 914 IaiE:ii gu em . 7'liC re: i~ve,r~ : some i:k~art ] had r1~~CK~DtK) clue about an dl i ~v~er~~ jzLst. - '-- '' 13 1~a ~ cl cls r R nastdOII] gCIE sS m S as well . ]. ]faa,aw i;or ii ifact I got ;> night and 2 wrong,. 1Cl»c other :193 are up in, die jO r. Good luck t'omoiToW. 7J26/21006 7 :111 PM collateral evidence said.,. If it's aif an y ma umpl,a' 6 on, p eop le I v rws; Ukirtg to here '4 r Oregon werr bemow~ng, ho 1N fe-or :N[]3 E ms-vvi.rs they felt re a lly certain e a1x)lliy 817ieL mt3 rlng how Mad it was . I was one of' tbeni., It ble+n r. ] kst, wishes for to m c»Tnv+r! 7il' Z612D +9i4 7 :'1 9 PM Tab Ckiriiicaisse ur ,s;ddL,,. , ., 'Chanks „ ,eall. 'Fhat n1,a]lc4mraw-fM som my'hat' b etter. Of course, arid l didn"t really r rwvt •to '%7ite Ftt)Oin;Uu:s ill the nn,aii ri pDst; but I thbik I ha`T' a3 touch Offood j rcris01lihg; (rQy bin li:hie,r Stopi F ~ed'd by with a fun XIe:l cake fr the l b~a]Ilpwr]c lest ru;g'ht.„ya;y vmi i1trme1 rake, 'boo feeling lilcepu" re gc&gg to die an. morning loq;,I. 15) that made the whole process riNd ly rmffky rczlfy, f n. No &-M:aills, bat,.,yeah. ][f' I wby, ;..g i mid up failing this U n,g, lr;t muse of'tb, e:, at least 11T know JAB 7171/20D15 7 :26 PM _1 ,fe s,afline WL ,. It alsa , i1oug,ht it was si 'ball cif'pnuT CA. ]3ao1111 r for flIE: C11.13T.! ...' ,EIi rn :, focd pxlsonla;g„ J[ ;hard it at 6e opera on ce, %Udz I think i:; ' passiblyiaw. m*nil worse place ,after the bar exam, so l Gm .~ ]lT[i4ine, ho%v you CTit]:K have, 1FE :1'[. Two Nv+)] chs: clear Jki& : J i 015i71a M 12 :0 3 P] --~, ji acr anc its ram a y; Iua;y 1W rO : ir. li iiewl Case 1:07-mi-00097 Document 1 Filed 04/12/2007 ;nieJ /lUiLkrcurnents "i'o.!Li ana'AUM~ dt in,~sJs~11' ry,~l.c ~ca'I~'atU ae: tltna~ ;!~Il Page 10 of 29 I 6,aaOt it was bard, as vre-11! And I was looking lorww d to, ffie, NiIBE, gm; ffi e ims-iea part 1oPtliC`t(K-t.., 7126f2006 110 :36 Phi ambiml) sai(L .. Yeah, ,the MBE b]eHr. Joii3 maybe ou had a different te-st than, me ~~ 'but the afternoon iNas like mo% :tp-rlon;g fad: paa :te,nv> dial : toolc forever to read and at the end of iuicxL one were iVV o chokes tl15l : 1k)I11CK)kF' d alb, sol u,fie] Iy ]ilci, die right mum-. I trite hate hated ii:. It kicked arid pL annieled the until l[ wis'IcE lni o lariger even s't aigl a1t, Juzd I clciri`[ even lave F nyth!~g Uz lack of sleep, NA pc~Lsoivmg;, or 2my,thinl; e: ls e 1.o , blame orn -- ii :jiust Him! . i1: I it zm1m - in e feel ;slia ;lil;l;y better toy lmYN tb2 t ciiher people d'ioq~h't it aucl :ed',, to)„ so I bore 3nm get some mrnfi»- t lairnNing you're in, such, Li xn ,' "1 go+A* corttp-my. ::) 7/ 'Z i S Ji:0 06 '10 : 54 Phti Jocellym Sm it]i sa'id... B es t of I, i& hAa,t. I aFpree , th e NUB E, was brtrG fl . I still 1liatq;ht l: ] dM rea:scn viV'y- i,41-p ro5lern is I iloii't know whether ii : was ~ enougb,.1! nd the FZi m-ida (rmeml &x on Tuesday was al bsolate bell ; the essays were better than mix:cte+ 3„ but - tliie mult iple . ~ choke was a ] mLt. I had , maybe io oif l thE; v)iD clu Ezti cirm that I 1;e11: snri S of. I thought I'd + da:am out the door When it was cioni:, bait: ]f 'm .. ~ ball .' aa;n viticx.~ L duit ]failed, and now just feeling depressed . 8le]l„ nr I EL- mss this is probably normal jxr:.t-Rair ' [#:tdoHm. 7/27,Q006 2 : 08 1111+1 } I took the 1N;E«7, in Ohio and J [ ~tlicn.y ft. it N v;Ls nUdl)i k die haxd - m.uxb, ll u*:r than , my of . Ba.rb 6 oir' PM;BR.prac;tict p roblems . ;Luc'leil;y„ everyone I SIK&C ltci felt 'tlai ! sme; mray, iso I suspect lam, ,sc Oe4l sa o;n: -wila le very gencrous -At li umct I Imp-, :3 6f2:Z 1113QW6 12 :0'3 P.1 ,la b and Brazuty: Day '11vo: It Blew Case 1:07-mi-00097 Document 1 tis ;s/sri Filed 04/12/2007 Page 11 ofig29 Ie :y,/]G ) : a,l'% 2 OSdtingsl7 .. 1 so. . . . 7 / 27 J2006, 4 1 8 INK Tab 'Con r1clisseur f 211.- Hakoml'a„ ]aair.bia~iit s,ri)t i micH ng it look any twtte r. It ne-d1l~ truly ww' ; 'tliat bac3. ~~ 7lE:'besl. i1ung? 7lere was this real properl y, question im v&i& a c[ee~~ ]~a3 the i;n mmect des al, pdc n ~ of the parcel . .[ di&A kricovv tkcnv to mvrE:r it, G ues:seci, no Oue. (UnitTact,aickxges into dee,d„ 23u1: '[ fcn % ot all f about it. iSo there 19112 t ada;y„ 0;Pelaiiig 'up my Teal pmperhr essary,. ., .»id jus1t guess what the qxm sdor[ iis. f[a ;ha, . [ tall ilo ti"t know the answer. . :-P 7'1 27 1'2 1?I)6 6 :111 P AM JcK:e 1!ni S i naiith uU.., .. ~ ~ I . I ]. kepi : i7,n'b'b'~igtlii, suz e; 41unm ;Eviiie ric :e; questions on. ]x)t1L the Florida & :A 1+ABI, r itiltiipde choi (m. Juiti. 7/27/2006 7 :59 Pm ~ l: qpvt wi th everyone tiere. 'The M EE" was, rezRy,4ii fRvdlt. .[i: iwas all . a blur to flae n.oVir. 1: daa"t re member anyihhig fi-cra it -%166 even IMA.es me more s,Nn-e4! I tb~a u&t the time before the exam was toiig~i, Now, I think the tim.e after caun, rrvaitln;g for tlzie re-stat lnay nc>1 : be t1 im: ms), mA h le ;r. 11)27/2006 9 :3 :1 PM ...~ _.! A n O nyanc w; ikud... . .J ~f13C MBE (x)mplin.ellr'bitchs:la~F iFK~cl ime:. I was doing mQr Id1 Of mp;prxiKia, sets sn, 1: figra reci I'd, p ums, rxi problem . Well on RiAt. 'T bat suc:kal lCim ;pretfiysar+~ I faiil{e+l i 1 [. It does make Erie feel so»,evilkit,bet3{ e r iflktt : sdmost. all ~ of mjr Heiads (w1[co »e i vely, smarl: »z,3 stu& e~~ lvi.Yy, 13~~~cE) Faso L'hcru6;ht it was avdbl, but 1510 . J 4 i f2. ZO /:iGt lxlEi 12 : 03 P -,'!'ab suit! Bmndy' Day Two : It Blew I Case 1:07-mi-00097 Document 1 Filed 04/12/2007 hte ,:l YlL:r 'Lk~cumen Ls~ a!~~ana i,~ Uae~tnmgu's~rt lcyil.c~caC~~dlil:u~GU~~ ri~ t i Page 12 of 29 Jesim. ._! 7/27jP2006 9 :37 NA Asi oqnn0us s a i d, . , . f C1UCH... ..t]he isi[ ;par1 : was rrmna;~iitde I thought as far as ak well ^i there, its allc31: ][ don't know here but : ][ can still try to pretend that eve,rjnUR g i:s C ocru[l:lV t 1z After••riut1: . va::it ual!y, after much stadying and pi-a .ctice, . C ao'Al ado tb,enz „ ][ ,was Even doi ag lNe;l1 . :[ d~~~~u;glht I v+ras, a set ifcir , at ]Nf i31z- 'that was arty' "e msy " &y, vibtme I ixy Wd', lax Mom! the i3;ritiv;~q; ,Wnd qtiarl :eri ng,oWm, es:u ys. FU f3.A ]3A , ]HA ;HUB Fbk ILL 712U 2 00 6 91 : 2 15 P NI _., I . 1 ,Ant niym,oUs s~icl... ~ so did, w(,- ,A take the same 'Nilg:E E:a:a mms,? did. soirrie: of iws take the ;m O triigg exam while ~ so»r Le ; took the zd fte moora and vice ve; rm.? : ii MINK thought 1I& afternoon exam imas much more d.i ffic:tat and ii wana to make sure Chat ~we; a ll took &e same half cltai n; g the , mne SeS n IC11i. Of the IMUM7Ji:E ;/ 2 0 0 6 10 :42 PMT ;yoiLtm nck ;a . nn e-e s,aiidL,,. Ok, !for m e, there was a quo--stion hi Cb,e afternoon ~ all i ieww'; ,0 about vv]ae1:kiE:r some + magmssiotud act grd ng some agency sscmt.ary sonmlli gg car another was a w-did sci: , .mad a aw, answer choices w eirC al~Ml t a sm ii»n ,-S onii l bb;g li ik:e In page lung...i arhudty 1lamg~te~L i beard that P'rRHPR itE :Ik ;,ins to dlcI the last lo, questions fimt-4hic :ki ii idbi`t. when i got to those soy +Cjue51i'D;11 S, i just kept UXaiRg, "wOH I, the bar' Ewt TIl IItE:IS are ()lid; 'to fii& ims . ..th+e;y know our seamts„ »a{3 they dbritit like it at ~a'll ." . . .,I V29/2006 1 :57 AM . . ,I ,An,oriyMIQUs saiicl.,. ,_I ~.~ 101:517a31i 110 F': _ k ,SAP In awl ,D n n uwy , I JLAkV iMF aI : ir, i"A e.+ F Case 1:07-mi-00097 Document 1 Filed 04/12/2007 ~ dier~r ~ ::~ LK~curr~ en[sio.: ~ iana r~ ~tvae~t~n~~stl UCyr l ,c~caC~ atu :~ : t r~n ~~! v t . Page 14 of 29 .[ ilhoq~ht t]ic afire moon ]N:FSI' vrgus te,r riikd{e'!' The rnonn'.i riF; session Was Similar 1:o other re1rNL4~E im uns biit die, iftern,cx»>,JiLK . ]a1]'ed, t ime . I gun depressed ricmv..., .. .~ T r 9 r 2 ooa 2 : 29 APA 'Tab Connoisseur said... a .-~ ;[ t]h', ui~c 'we: all toolk the same parts of the 7;NM]E at the same ti~nae„ ~Camel.-hair, mat, father who t eadies his scan hoHt 'to :01a), Russian to xoia]le:t'tE. and chug lbme .r., you know the, rest The vvi: d lespre id ,a )inSINISMS i[S that the EftexTLOOr.: ,s iession vom far more dUfficult, "Artiic:h leads me to believe vrE, . had the same seLlions in. the morning and afteraoan ac ross the country. n Y'a11MOck ,I %viish ][ ]had h eord that ad Mix. (h . not,. ][ d uano. I .,.. managed to fi,r,t ish c ri itim e , a;n;ymay, And : [ tlsiir.a , ]preity much the not v,rtu le gdtei 'rIcKIL i ;pumim, el o :ci me, . j iimst the Lui-t fear qu e st lD,m s. o Ugh . (1N[.) Anger over bar r ev'ie:vv courses ('pasbcu Lmly P'NrIBP.) over theb. Jt W,2Z ICIAMMS 12 :0 P; a.uwn~'~. .I , LI'V~. WLWH W /~ILVOI N{ I ~L.1 J.~{i~~~uu~~:~l :u ILC~//LV~7l17h~l :~~~C[LIYI~'~~ Case 1:07-mi-00097 .I Document 1 Filed 04/12/2007 Page 16 of 29 . ~ conduct (X 3'IUiI€; ikt1E:' tE-st simply to find out hunats, Fei:nbery; :d 2E `F;ec ~ y t~ ring, l.o , wa R : +D'LlC With I1 i Citi2:s , ete,) . Perhaps 6e E'm1Y. [llIZE',I 'S fel t : Ol)llgpit:ed . to wme up with qu.es'tions 1'2N:FSR amid ' ]3;R-Bri tuA,tievel"evi.n considered. 7130/2006 5 :49 FM Eaxxn;rtnows :kud... I took die ]MM]E inn Ra,wafl, an d[ yes, IME" M Y C?NE duit l qxAce -willi ` a"bout it so far Agrees i121 th.e fdtin710crn ,seSSaO»:s v++-ELsJuSt i»:=it:. I t'eli cc:rdideist dl3out, aia3iw 5 of ray answers out t>#' oo., t ^y What wws the,- i3eAd witbi dizLt the exch udoa of IL witness wad the xepre;;f:irtat i v,e? 11=1 no idea What dgil: iTuestiorz Vrwc, even asla Eg ! 7 1 .3 + 7 1200 5 6 : l8 P AA Chris &i1d y . . Yeah, the MBE lacked my ass. The dtE :rnoort s("-sion vrws Ai lot • ' harder flum the nzoriiin.g;. All ldio.ser torts ~questions asking about . dh•ec bul ve~nii' cLs :killeKl ;rnE:! I w jknd was it just me or &d the 'y Msk gi toll of questions cars t he pri yident"s executive xKwtiwps:s~ and Ord.y ~ . . .j question 0x1" :lE'Ve] of scrutiny 713 112 0 06 6 : 38 PM Monyanoizy sw i: dl..,. 'fJhime q uesdow were in the mornung fin' :MW ki 'Msao,asiiri. .II x ) A s eLs i a}p with J~ .a frwid3aRent scheme 'At a county f a :a lei sal tuig up a booth wid defi, Ai n. uun a:b~e~r -of,peoptF~ who ia~~~p~nkic:~t the ., .` txxnh. Another roe rro)4, C, W1ICI ]R+D't3Ge 3 this ELC'ClC1It senl3s a gated teac]5er Of ~Cs to de ]~ ao fli uz order to be clefr au&uiv .klsa,, a ' fourth ;pe:rsoi i, D„ merely sent : another cwer to the 1xx)tbi ima+3 that . .!~ 1K! r&D, n vvw; defrauded for 4tr;o. 7Chie e aM of the Su e sebri stated the four A w Ft, (:, 1) a xi cl , w hat each is li;abd e for . 2) Is I) liable -for ftud due. to his ,rwwfirig j3 person over to the d --,~ booth, evem though he iii &tknow of the scheme? a. , A ,c msscrry d ter the fact for C', becwze he E24 1a ie ffitent a nd knew about -flie, sdiei ne, ' b . 'Nt+ .a xxsso,7 sifter the fact for 1) ( was a two pu t t~i~~~tion~l . J of" .02 i 045r Z106 12 :0 3 FM a. .w. . - - YYMj n J~-rj Case 1:07-mi-00097 a " Y•. Ab Ailirr M Document 1 Filed 04/12/2007 i u u c .r,i r~- :IaNV wuI,au i ; s,Au. u aniry. z v,54KUnig!v ,517lC,YIIAcaJI%aCtl .se TamtE;sl . Page 17 of 29 ;3.1 .A . person throws a brick l1aou g;h a car v+rindshicld and four . .l i3;iffE: ren.t cfixurasi;aru:es atti.inpt to r»illiF~ the voluntary act i'Lse11: a One: was a person who was sne:e prAiz-4; and. did lids, one Mao : on mariner which was not the right answ~: r, 'tlie fizkal ru~ct~n.~,tan;ce escapes xne, Vat I pi c]zi ki the sleipvr.Ok.er as riEp .t'i rq; Ui c '-I some medication while doing it, another was ret0ating in some voluntary aclw };! :Sa.m ethiqg about the Federal Gkn: regr u.lating the'lickiz g,Q: f .a gloving toad. to get, lv:g h. Ilus vnisvt feNleral question. May a mortgage be Wen by a devisee (defesilil e;) in, vested fee :pimple then mcrtj,~q;E: the interest 1:c~ a chancli„ ii,,~ring tl~e ti~~rie: when t he church is being Liss ed "for church F itrpmes." 11ho uig;ht one out iir i.Ni as RJ E Qt1I M3D, thereby. x+o) One painter negotiates to paint far a wa amount wlikh t] :11C t nnz „ 11 valued a Mcnuil: Of $ 4o0, less than he contract fUnou nt. 'T lx: p;~xiter h; ,a'.llar w°ed , zm opparbnvity to paint 6e trini, bu1t idoe s not I[tiE :refi» re, I believe li at the owner iss jpwrinittei3 to clklu c:t the $400 from the wd ue of the contract, as it appmj -s , 11q, both intended ;f0r this t 0i lie. inclusive o f the tri:nn.,'Therefare„ I ;seZec 'tec d an tunousit o#' th.e contract which r ub-t i-a ct eci the $ 4 :0 o. ]: i:lu.nk k this as peraiis:sible because ther e, was no question as to the f ~ hIclusioll of the trim ., lo 'T'he tea&kq; c o if ervolv,ticin izi s i:3ioo]', was, ist ixty A ew invoking the s'tablLstanent clat v, e and therefore H rus applied the ^~ .-~ O;mjh :Iling , iDxCMSt test: iii order 1:o ] ;mrrnit , lite. 1:e ochi q; of such a 1 subject in a public school setting. The answers "re;re either rati,o:na1 basi s or compe Dirzg , , and, I picked co:m peIling tinder 1 ~ establis,laneat clause i inaiple >. i,2; ) 'Tbere vrw; anuride; r cavercop who J)wtlCx]P,a1te c!' in a a conspiracy to purchase stolen gtuis . The ,seIlE,r of the stolen guns got aHMy, thus the cop c ;Otdd trot: have immFletFx'l the in e :imsar;v elements for it ao:ns~piirac;y„ i1w, whatever guLtiver :[ picl;e .4 Id .not have a ixuugAra+:ycime in it. •~ t3:) Julia is st;i3ring in a'hote2 as it guest K" Ee4d{ era' police ofii,xt. detezzsn~.ixaez, Slat sbe is aIReged to lurre }p,artiipateiti ua a bwIlc robbery two weeks prior„ iN ritlz oillt a warrant and without ~ "requv i:cl p : rolxflb].e c aus e' laie O :Efimr uses the master key from the j ,rr iatuige:r Of' 1lLe; ]H Otell UP enter Ad ia',s r+aorn, where be firld.s nothing except ad isucy on tlzebed, wMclh Officer reads and lea nx% .. f "tliat: it was ;ii : fact, + aiuxwd'aan;g to the clia qr, Julia 'who wnnmaiitten't" wa+d sends the Ie'tt: er„ Swx~ gets the ]le'tter' ~ drafts a letter cce;ptin.g, the! req uEest,, but i3oe ; ;aot nvoI an(3 the ,aw-eptance uxitil Mother dim. Son gets the $jow, and. qae Nion is whether mo1lier's mute hdlablle farthe a ;j . tKx) . :~, i) A cbmpaun;y i:s aorn'tractiki to produce a large number Of lani(Ille rneta]l pk cqu ards each cvstom~ imz dle with, the wtnpany' s 1080 on llie; rn.'T he contract is breaclbiNI =dl ff ie : answers reflect AI i1 ; l:tte; l •-Il I'd 22 1015tNV; 12 :03 PDT .w. iwn g A~k aunu Y, gua r a vukr. A16 l u Lc W Case 1:07-mi-00097 Document 1 Filed 04/12/2007 ~IIC ;:/'l/l.. :/' lJ(1C;UIfICT1LS 7' O.: IrA~I1Q'Yo1VJG1:L7'SI gSI$J1 1G y/L.C ~CB ',Ii'a. CIJ :l~' U~I7 7~~yS~l . Page 19 of 29 I - darriages €xe and the only two that acre Fos,sibly~ riigh at axe, the 16H value Of ffie IN)nIIart" OK' UX Cost to the C «ITI p2Ln}r for prcKlucx:ag the ;pnr3 ulci:s, l 71111/2 006 6 : 45 P'M .., 'F,ab cziirnorss eu,r s;al' ZL... I ]Er...Arioii...hovv the- beck chid you ;rs:meml~.r A that????? (T,st, ..arey-ou a rep for Pr I BR? ]Did you sn FZl:ffiom~ otii:? ) And yes, t]aoyc. ,a:rt3 the questions I bad in C~ 1e morning. 7/' 31 1 2 QO6 6 :56 PM Anonymom> &d d.. .;;gmy- ilus may be off topic NIt i i know 0if ] nOW011ier forum where such a question, .art be uLswC:red . On the UL perform-miex. e:!uun ,15 what Were the format gxudlin.es for the opinon letter,, 11 mum wondering if i did rninE ; :ti~;ht. V/01/2006 3 :91 VM Tab Cc n rioi,5 :if !LR' silld... I :.1I1f0 -mki .An0r. IyTn,Orus You might cheek od this srte .,The person who runs it took the ~ tza-ifonaia lbmr, firid there i U-e : several Links eai die ,sidebar to other people Halo tcxyk the bar,, many in iCalifc»rua . • ' I can, tell, you r+ptuit the MIT ,sULn&tr & for any opinion. letter wou]d be (as per Barlsii) , but to the extent that Cali:fonv; a wanted something dil~e~r~:r~t, Inn afraid l.tir~: Jg~~ It ;nut]'~i~ri'„ 8 J1 y 'II' ~006 41 :03 F I A 4 sail .AnariyWOUs . i Here acre all 41 quesldo:as or,t iaie :N[13:E that I could remember. ][ , aim :not a rep, I s~~npbr q~*e at my wife for dave lic»urs, Mv~% 'to the airport ~ a'fter 6,e flair, and, she itcKd+: InCAM; iwhil',e ]f g;iblre(i. :ic), Here are the questions and my proposed answe: rs.. Anybody .. ~ J12 of' 22 10t$121M ; 12:03 FT, _ S inn nMa t I Unr : Lnsy' . 1 +vo ns Case 1:07-mi-00097 trv Document 1 xuc:;~~ Y1. ; ::/ ,UOC1;lI1]CI]t5'%aLV ~3ACii'a11J:1t :tf31f1!'>SY:i~lUC;~lLOG3i ~iu: u~~rttm~g~' i Filed 04/12/2007 Page 20 of 29 re nzeyrst+e.r more than these? or ca n, eZabaral:e? J) A sets up vdt]h 11 a f'rai a ilulF ,nt, scheme at a county fair by setting up a lxx )tbi acid defirnac b, a number c1 people who a:P:pro,10x ffic .~l lmili. Jai otltr 1wrso n , C, who n otices the, action sends a ]m1,e~l ~ teacher of Os to -flie booth in order to tie; iieiTauded. .AZso, it - ' fourth person, ]7, ,mE:rely sent another wer to the booth and! 11tat 1 Ivison was defy aucle:cl for , S 5o. 'Tbe =1l of the opestion stated the dour J~ 13,. I-„ D and Av i1: each 'h ; lG,al'SIIe for. :!)1 Is D liable fo:r fi.Mild due to, ]ti~ s,endk g a, person over 1:o ilie n; Imffi,eve,n t houg h lays di+in't Icnow of the scheme? "~ . a. Aexvssary idler the facl: for t',, lvc;aus, e hE, ;hard the intent wnd knew alciut the scheme. b . ZJ,o a.cae!Lsory after late fact for I) (vs+as a two par t question) <<) A pe:rs{xn throws 2L lb ;rick through it cw- whAsNeld and, four ilifi;ereimt 6rcam stan ms attempt to nuUi5, the w]'.uxitan( acct ft sellf. One vwu. a person who was sIeeprw2D3hg, wzii did thLs, aer ie; was airl some m+efficati.crrn while doing it, another was reUxhating in some manner vv]v : ch was not the iz g~hticn swe:r,, the final[ 6 ncmnstwoce escapes nze, but: ]f p:ick.e ~dl the sleepwalker , as neg,afing the . voluntary ud. 41) :x»netlhiE xig, about -die Federal~ i3av. xegndadn,g, 1bz licking o!'fi glowing tIaId. t1 o get lu;~h . 'Thi:a - HT,s it ifkle: ral q u esliom. 1 ~; ) May Fi ~tru~z t ~,~,e be taken 1)3r a dlevi;;e~e ~;dl e~f ~~i51E~) in vested f De simple them rrno: rl g;age the i .ntem-st to it dlurbN; the time when the churclh is being used I tlbou,ghi j one co i ]d not inrtort;g,3ge a future Interest iyhi& its not wm-ted? d Iha~~,no. 6) Evidence y ues6 ar,t aal mxu't ' tl ie sitateaierit " 't he sang of a bi1:& is it i " the witness i:; tes fif&F; ~as t o whether thLsslatelment dead »= is an excited uite;ruice- not b/ c :not for the Itruth of the matter ass erted, l bat ,a x»'!c[ : have been , a ;pr~~~~z~t s ~e~n~se iQ~p: essii c~~i. 7ilzat; is what 3[ picked. 7 ) Another evicienia,axSr question about k hot n OLO I* excluded from the cxiurbrwan during the 1 »-Me edinp, i;ncllcic[ing (or not) the presence but does -not s li2,9i ]Pri )NV1 tS IlW IM 2usii aii Of an. ernplcnrm, or assistant to~ a v~ritine s from being pxevF:i.tted from of rach witness from presence in the GDU[tIOOfl1 . 7Cl~~ was a viscous qu esti; o ri oif;lit t]e or =icy ;rE; ztI value. . .~ 1015,2006 12 :03 11,11 _, l & pana timcty :11a ry 71WX Jtlili :w Case 1:07-mi-00097 Document 1 Filed 04/12/2007 Page 21 of 29 . ._~ it) 17ouble ;jEopardy question Hears w hether after the first 1tli,d, 1;or j axnmui r+db'baq, when faan d not : Ipv1lty, ma;ybe tried ,ag,dn for ._I . 1-1 1- l essaiuCt, but the second trial h ad', not lbe3pm because the jiLtQr had r iot been sworn in yet, lb'a t it: is still i d cyubZ ( :;je:ciFia,rdy. ' Becaimsi, flae same e 'letnenLR Of'die crime have ayr~~a~clyl~.en tried in the lit, t amicA robbery t3Ul . Si) An office worker turns in another worker for possi!ssill1 Of Cocaine in dae office. 17he worker i:3 arrested and i:lkuged., but vhxts; Iite! trial for rimosse ssion charge Then, the HtcO:er that hmnied him in has her office s,ubject: ed. to evil f'orFei'hu•e under th e drug e laws On mrluclh the LmdE:rI;O. n g offense was a1)P,'U'entb'1H','1te-n on the first trial, thus this h, a hybrid double-Jecipardy question, which would have made for an, interesting essay (Viestion„ bill" :[ answered, it as being allowed due #o the. Civil nature Of the prnceev3ings, are not seemingly duplicative enou, gh to Ix.. subject to R. lffodblE;;je:cTl asdy ru srnis :k 1 . 10) In a re+piiremenls Contract, the worcls; "require.4" fine mi.tak~en~r replaced with the wnrc desired which subjects this d contract tai niatters of mu bidi n,usiak.e, t]»ereb y ;fllcn ffig for i l us w Contract ion be- subject to reFornmaiaon iv~ith i re in.ut ually reaiprncadng, terInS W; desired as lt]EQtT]f XE Di, thereby. iY:) C~i~e: ;painter negotiates to paint if or gin amowilt, wbd di u3~i]n, d~es the triirn, a valued amount OF $400 less than the contract gun ount . 7lie painter is ago %Ie~[ »z a pFicirtw;i ity to punt the t rinz„ 1)111t d oes not, the,refo.n r, I believe that the owner Ls permilteii to deduct the $41 no from the value of' the cx or itrac t, as it ,a',P; p aaar:, l1E.y both ..4 vn'tE lUdEKd for lads to k 1ie, isicliisive cif the triiI:n .'Themfore„ :[ selected any iunomt. ofthe wricraw whicli sui bauacteci the $400 . 1 think, ^L this was 1wrmis; sible becaiu:y, there w as no ipuftio n as to the . Laic]u:sion of Che trim. 12) Ili e; teaching of ev' o:li6 o 1s in s60 oPw s, in my view inwokng M the estabIi:>h ne: nt c;[atise find thereform-was applied the u ; compelling interest test in order #:o p .aznit: t he! teaching of such, a subject in S . public sc'h0a:l V:ttiing;. 7liE. ,answers -were either . ralaonal 'basii s or compelling, and, I picked eampelUng under esitAdis,lanent clause principles. 1, 3;} 'Tb,ere was an und[e: rayver cop Who 'participated' in a. co:ns]piracy to purchase stolen g,ms. The seller of the stolen guns ,got a AMy; ChUs Chl e top could n0t haves o »mplei:e:d [ the inecem r y _} J141 W':!:! 1015,S006 12 :(13, 1?1~ i au ariu uI &w AsY .1 Iwu . RL D iC I w . J. .1,/ Case 1:07-mi-00097 11tC:J!'III,. .;~ ,UVl:1,lIRC17l~'%a~V ~llpU i'aGW:lt 7 [1Wf1~~ J :i1'U~~~I LOC7il7~o~: U~JC[[lrl~~~ . Document 1 Filed 04/12/2007 Page 22 of 29 ,_ eleatents for a coruspiracy, thus whatever answer- I picked did not 1 have .a cons;piz_a.cy cxune in it.. 1.q ,) J idi a -i:; staying in a hotel as a gRi est . ,A. `fedena1" pol iix- officer determines a't she fi, ,Oejp~-ti to br ave p aitica;p,a't ecl ~ui a t0aA robt ~erytwo 'weeks prior. Without Fi wa.rr uzi: and Without ~nxp use+3 probable calaue the officer uses the master key' ftarn. the .~ ... 1 manager ofthe Hotel to enter Julia's lYK)in, vrb(i-e he -finds i oibu ; n ; g except a diary on the bed, which Officer rip= i;,a;nd learns that it ,was i n fart, Eicc oriiirq; Ito tlie ai~ uy; Ju ha who cxirn nlittEK[ the cxim.e . Chi(:sticin 6; whether Ws diary Lsadrrussible, or ixzyb e whether her arrest based on; the contents of the diary is r 2s) Mother says .S,a irn , please ;giive, m,y son $woo, amid[ "]: iNill . pay you back if he doesn't" amid sends the letter. ' iazn gets the . letter and drafts a letter aGG!pi i, o,g the request, but: does not mail the a c cep wzix., u ndl Mather 43iies. Son ge t s the a"w oo, and question ', is inrhet]»el' unother"s (state! is liable for the $ i aicio . 16,)A company is; contracted 1to ;pro 3ia,x a large .numly.i- oiF iu:ni(pif. metal plaapards each eu sl:orn made with the cxiiqpany's logo on them. The co:nti7ac:t b'br+eacliec :nd the Fukwvers reflect what iite da damages are. and the sully two t]zat ive ]pm3.witibr ,tight are,, the "full value ofthe contract" or the cost to the company fia~r ;pn~lad n j, the products. 17) Cxxigzess,gas:xts a law vv]3ich effixtiWe,ly makes a portion of ) contracts with the g;overaaient: iniv alid:, one: of the aiy-n-v e,rs mentions ex: post facto kaw violation, another artswer states that ex Ix>st facto ]lavv;; O:ri!y Pertain to cri1 nii .21. actions :not civil ones. 18) C;cirqzess passes a b w which 1i;l1 jst :aU~vdva1: lit y vi L'l rx-g2Aa'tf: ii ri eve:~r manner the l S()1I11ds E:[YLitIkltlnJ'y {]roil] mE:I'YL1 rbere, ,si:atu% the protection of hunz,an"s hearing an dl 'noI; , ;poRntibrt' beiqg the reason for iGongrevs,' entry, into this field of relpAa.tionAt also states that: 'wwiw pity or, state government ch.has ;not ;pasS4x'I sud]i regulation will tK~ ;nibjedt ' to a noise decibel Zevel of 131) clb as -the standard for all . Then, three weeks later a ci1y~ passes a. ]are which set,; the Ddb level at ;rn db. The que-stion choices ask "Arbe ther the city law i s cxins titud OnLat oru noons'titislional bemitLse,'Ungrew sought to MY IacCujY.~ US iiLfldl Of :regulation-sound", or that the city may pass laws which are more restrictive than the Congressional vvirsibrt . f .._ac 1015 r7 1aN > > 2 .0 111 _ .~ I au MuIu t>iauls:r LRIy l + wt1 : AL D fo' w Case 1:07-mi-00097 IIIC ,J I'l l ,,.; I JIJOC~liR~G1SI5'7a1~, ~f]Cli'aLIJ :lt :Cdll l~~S J :,7lIC; ~/ LOG317~ u:~~~t[Llfl$ ~ ' 1 , Document 1 Filed 04/12/2007 Page 23 of 29 _ a~g) ]nt a certain stal.er, based tqxui the new census, re-&biclting was begun . Due -to the pcli ;tica] v+aarz,liing which went on Hr lule attempting to finipIe,rriE:rit INredistric:til:4;, the Federal Courts were ;pe'titi:one; dl to come to a decision on aie correct ftpIxnti o iun. en t o f'l*ople i:n each ~vvtleh make this a'FederQr ;jim;tirmlJYe, 1 tnatl :er. ~.~ o;i A plai nl3,Ff'liles e m action to s.u i Ficticiii iii fiXii -i-a] e n it diversity court when the amount in conbrcnre,rsyLs $ 6ol , ooo, which tit the time was h a the process of being a:menulEKI to 'be Iu,g;b e:r than the ;6 :i %cfoo which is vrm; al[ 1fl i e time of his filing, the cm e. 'T 'h , en,, the . i firnount i.n controversy was changed by'CDIR&M~S to IV: $100,000, making his ~~:>E~ not valuable enough for it a1`rf:rS: tty action. I~o, ~~ this change nn,alke his case ,fo ul ,on the merits or is it :Kivkl I;y the pio,r filing if there WI2lS no I]1e »15orn of a sunset provision, etc. The E msvvexs were 'time of u ijjLLry, time of filing iauai3 tine of clax ig;e, int the mount of controversy. l 21) Mortgage pioriity qustion had to do ~wz ltt vwIie:iher in a i-ace iiotiox., :jiui ;34 ctioin , a "pt mba5e man e;y mortgage" has t d, ghe ; r Y ." 8:; ORPoRN i t O a. "commeri cia] mortgage ."' One cif' tbe mLm vers >;u a~~rr~lv~e+r~ mgs~~1 Page 24 of 29 .. 1 funny to ]her ' b o;yifriE :I] d when she f ind[s oult'dzat: lier. 1~;ft was: st ,o:le:n. The ihv0 q[ti esti;0 n Ls asked what rri:nne i s Cla ra j;Izii I~F Of, and because she had `stol[e-W her own F Kosessi o:Q, she could only be guilty of ' cxir.IS-TI i;r`a cy ' ;Ui d soiicitati.oni. DUrgzutt„ ont the ether [[tlE'S t ICIII , c= be guilty of only conspiracy a n d llaxaen;y le caus e r solicitation meiges ands cannot be c6aryy-A ~Cia u, ,l1fl :!4[) A vvoi n = hires a Ht r n,ain for $101,000 1 .0 lall, a W3d'r'ieriit spc,u se7 lLi icl pays ti,rr i ~dit, $io,oi3lo, ' ho%reN,erth e ln, t ni:ui shaot', aci d missim; , kit the txr31'nienrcli' 'Me; n fills and & es because cif' the fall, ; hit&Lg ia rac]'F„ and r[Ot 1151 is whether she is guilty of murder nor only ail:ennptEKl murder wid or soliciu .tioxr. The :n ud question had to do H Atli whether C'firnizNil i:rxip):sib i l i ty as opp).seAl to legal ianposs,ikilir~ 'Kill n e%ate the attemp t part. .•5) Then there was a . pwe rit who iiise(niE:red ont tbte breath of her song alcohol, 3rd Still &IIIe ;hun. ile. keys : to her newer car;, lbei=ii e the son convinced her- that iris car was less safe. knamiderit c+ccars vz which vio one is but the queMi on I~a,s t.rn do whether the mother {Gmi by e a ttcxes;s1v111y charged with "'atteinpt,Nl rrrurdv~ "attemptv3 uvo]Luucttary n ,=a;>laughter' attempted voluntary ananshaq;hter" or no attempt ( :ru.mt . I sb^1q; F;ID3 with thL-; I Q;ne„ because ]. ]berw t h,ere VMS no such thing as art al :tempi :e~l rie.%Iiig;en,ce based cxime, nor eSt ,alttempi:ed, reckless based, ixirn(r, thus I really have, nto idw what ffiey were ]Iwliqg far her.. . 26) May two ~a» it1wtin$; parties .;1x:csfiGally draft, "a.q)exiiic FCrf0:M,anO.- c:lz IUs,e' into a c.Dritr3ct. in, order to force a court to o rder ST' otz the construction -of a biuliiing ; to, b , coimp2e'[E'd 'wkie:ni only 606 of is was: exrrnplE:ted? Here, cone i reasan,able answer which ]ipiic:k:ed stated that a contract cannot impose at wun: to order s;pe+ci .fiic, I) :tfD ;r7nan.ce in 2r ictni lxaelt . The other al Lsi+ve; r:"wene riot souriC[, ami dl did inot address the i~S sIue offorcing at pairty to complete perl `orni.uic:e: oi a a. i:oniraclt wb. en~ ilun,ages rmwr suffice as comapetisa t iont for a kewcli„ 2,7) When an architect puT.Koselpiurid lai~dmg good f;dt]h delays t]h e issuance of' Fi qvcx:fic element of a, i.oniracl:, bere it'aw ffie ce,riifimi1ion from, the »-chste ;cx„ ffiE:r6by forcing E i lbnui& fiff which a ccmi3i .tiori ;preN:klenit -*T.2m not fixl',#aIecE dime t{v the parties failure to IG:Aify, thereby lacking good U:th cle:akg. I stiN.rkl e'le:ar from nia,y enforceability issues in answ-eriixig ; lads orte, . .1 .. . :1 _. . . . ~ .~ . ~ .. ' ... ! ._ 1 1 01:5121W 1 2 :0 3 P`r4 Case 1:07-mi-00097 i Document 1 Filed 04/12/2007 [ 11 1 1 :: l/ .l l. :t1JN1: L[L Lp ~[lV> ' 76 t 1A{ 1.070..l/: ICA](I~ S~SI7~~'.~ '/1LJ~I~II"Y/I~ ~(I~ ~C tt IL Ig;S~ ~ ', Page 25 of 29 .-I because each element of the contract was fdVilled save the architect cert . iclla,use which thereby breached the contract ; . This vam tvrnclle:ar anel unfair as a iquest3o;n . 2 S) ;kuah wanted an, :sttIMii ;Jr ,a;ppoiali:e4 linle to her indigent status,but she requested a "Jahn .ry C"Ionarui" a~jw {3eft,nlse I ._ _ 1 attorney, and. was othenrise ap1minted at public defender. 711E, juite appointed this gnblic :,deife:nder on Chie suited, basis t'ha't Sarah could not defend herself, imm,Feen'dy."' Later,,Sanol fires her public: dielfericler and aQ,ttipleh :-s hier dial on tier oWn, only to be found IpAit}, of imiu~le;r and sentenced 1:o ;p years ux prLsori . On appeal, may she Ix- successful in, ovc :ivin*ig; her ',gjxilty finding cluEe to :f. S .'D 'Mere its a ;geneirator sold in a sealed pack age fi-oxn a store . . .~ .. ji .18 of 22 l iWSrWM 1 1 2; :1)_f ;PN, . , aw MOM arA at0 u f . .r4 aJO ∎ •. .~ Case 1:07-mi-00097 ii1 cw IIIC '. J I'!1„J . UOCISI!]C71I5%tLV311(I" .~GLI'J: lt: [1C1 1~1~~J !iTl1 i C;/ILOCi II'%i1 :~~ JC~Ill~lg',S+~l Document 1 Filed 04/12/2007 Page 26 of 29 The stoi-e from wlv.chh it mu, sold, sells the :it:em se;fled, in ari "fps. . is" condil3ori . Cori the outside, states it: handles nioo watts 'but i1a .. ii-e ali:ty„ it is only 5rio'%m,tt;;. The b1MZc11 Of Imierc;hazitabiZity is ~~ something 11<,wIuch at nnost : favored the dle.fen1dant in _~ the sense i1at it 6haric ;teri2ed teasomlblEe! doubt iiriver3r specific i:ertim, liut #be l?e,fE~rul~~it, was fi~i~n~d g ;u~lty a~r~yryw~~r,a;nd ~v~a:; J 9 Of22 10/5121W 12:03 PPN Case 1:07-mi-00097 _ .~ Document 1 Filed 04/12/2007 Page 27 of 29 . .j j sentenced. to m,any',(E:aTS. The c1tiE'.stiori h; ,rvh.etl7 ei r flii's clue-sti()Il is appeal ablle! ifthe jury uLftnuCl30:ns are nnOre .favorable. to the de: fer: l uiZ: i:hart the prosecution. 40'Ma,ei;her the evidence swi&u-d ?is. was "O'Lavve: ighecr' l »"substand:a. Il;y outv veighed." I know that one iv as sdbs'taritia]],y OufiNe :ighecL «~I ~8/ 0 111 2006 6 : 11 F' M Anonymous sai& . ;yIDU left oin, iny favorite c [Uestiion - for so me reaso:n (pirob ably 'lig'htlmidimbiems ) this question totally cracked me up„ it %~rms a'bou t 4 0ci-pouLCl ells, ,and imd+ar"Az,t scienairio someone %voiild 'be g ;dlty cif'fit ti.mpt with regan i to a, statute f:orbidi3i'rr.tf;1aiE; . sh{ao'~ng o!' elks under gloo rcLrkh~ I(c>r maybe it vats elks civer 4 o1 a jp0Unds .-h o'knomm,; l. ap}ryray, ibz cypdoi as vm-re a ; gu;yvvlao 0 v shoots a Iigbnre1k thinking i1.',, a tie;a,vieIl' ilk, a guy vdi a shoots a heavier elk thizilanrg ; it's Fi 'li;g'htt:r elk, a g2ry, iodo shoots E moose tl:vixEng zt's an , elk, 'and a ;gqy who shooLs m elk thhildng it"s a mcxo: t, ar solimel:kiing idoag those Iiims. i ;jiLst remerntcr reading die question mid having ffii~ out o i`1~~3;yexperien.ce, vvoricle:ring to m;y:~e~Lf;how r i,t is that Of,a:ll the paths in my life, i , somehovv picked the One that required me to figure out how to legally shoot an elk. 8102120 06 7 : 49 F ' Ah Tab Oon :no:Lsseur sari... ~Oh, yes, the ell k: gues-6ma.. Cll uty, I vvi:lll lp.=Lt jx.,opl e tih Ls.. I s a.r+is I'17E'.I'a 2 SI .NIII A Et qL1E stlOil:i on. practice tesu, although they i a:>iud ly u voIve4 3 i:[lqgO. (L-14"s (em El thought it was illegal but it 1wasn't, El 1thnug ;lit: h+e b.a.di more than. the prohibited amount ]bruit ;he cli&'t; letc:. ). T we l] So, :[ SO WD:511' t : sure ,alborLy[ the answer to that one. B102)'2006 VA t P hl ,A.r iortym ous s~icl... .I took the ~Aansas bar and was getting around[ ~7o%,m x %ua cy on ~tlie i;~~a~ o l'IN :F~It gv ~e~dons l c~id~ ~~l fu ~s g~yotb,er ~;cio on 1-2.0 *W"22 10/5)2ONS 12:43 11111 . . ~ A a I ; wu u Cuu My : Wny 1. Iffl r. IL .bit ;vr Case 1:07-mi-00097 Document 1 Filed 04/12/2007 n xCYBIL. .riAMMIem M' a,u~~na iu :u~artr~n gsO s;nuyri.A x :arro Z v,NKan; g~.v i Page 28 of 29 ..~ 1 1]N [1 31: was spawned in . I pray for a . Hell genemm came . I ._ I do feel somewhat better after stufirq, 1aw- Internet to see t'ha't pretty, much everyone thiiAs iit was m er••the-i.ctp harci.. 8/10,512006 '111 :32 PA Tall CiDnnoLsmT Y'oLi'ren D t unagH:r.ig, l:tungs. ;[i: re:a1]Ly, was that ;hard. I min a that the ablii6m that mjo:ng aw holum c gm provide helps a great deal . m I K g;EV rccxirnaieiid iii 8 1071200 6 5 : 03 Alrl _, j belt' i nuun taker. had tesi[s; kk b ao'li[ets 15 amcl ; ha[fl u t d tmts vz booldets 26. you axe ;seated every crther penson and . :2i5 alternate : the morning and afternoon jx»tioms. so you can't look el your s e: a tm<