greenhouse plastic by Augustalbum


									Impact of ultraviolet-absorbing plastic films on insect vectors of
virus diseases infecting crisp lettuce
Alberto Fereres, Ricardo Biurrún*, Aránzazu Moreno, Beatriz Díaz, Miguel
Centro de Ciencias Medioambientales-CSIC. C/Serrano 115 dpdo. 28006 Madrid.
* Instituto Técnico de Gestión Agrícola, S.A. Ctra. El Sadar s/n. Edificio El Sario.
31006 Pamplona, Spain

Abstract: Crisp lettuce is widely grown in northeastern Spain under tunnel-type greenhouses.
Insect pests are a major threat to lettuce and insecticides are widely used to control aphids,
thrips, cutwoms and other lepidopteran pests. UV-absorbing plastic films have proved to be
useful to control insect vectors and associated virus diseases in a number of horticultural crops.
A 2-year study in the area of Sartaguda (Navarra, Spain) was conducted to evaluate the impact
of a UV-photoselective film on the population density of insect pests and the spread of virus
diseases infecting ‘Batavia type’ lettuce. Two walk-in tunnel greenhouses (40 m x 9 m) divided
in 4-6 sectors were used for the study: one was covered with a UV-absorbing film named
Ginegar AD-IR AV clear and the other with a standard plastic film (Astrolux type). Insect
population dynamics were monitored weekly by means of yellow and blue-sticky traps located
in each of the sectors. In addition, lettuce plants were sampled (15 plants/sector) to determine
the presence of insect pests at different time intervals. Plants were periodically inspected to
assess virus spread in both greenhouses. Plants showing virus symptoms were sampled to
identify the viruses present by means of ELISA and using specific antibodies. In both years, the
UV-absorbing plastic film was able to significantly (P<0.05) reduce the percentage of lettuce
plants infested with aphids and thrips as well as the spread of aphid and thrips-transmitted virus
diseases (Potyvirus and Tomato spotted wilt virus, TSWV). The number of winged aphids
caught on yellow sticky traps in both years was dramatically reduced in the greenhouse covered
with UV-absorbing films. In the autumn-sown crop of year 2002, 80% of lettuce plants grown
under the Astrolux-covered greenhouse were infested by >5 aphids (Macrosiphum euphorbiae
and Acyrthosiphon lactucae), while only 10% were infested under the UV-absorbing film. Virus
spread was also significantly reduced in both cropping seasons under the greenhouse protected
by UV-absorbing film. In 2002, the total incidence of Potyviruses and TSWV-infected lettuce
plants was reduced by 78% and by 69%, respectively, in the greenhouse protected with UV-
absorbing plastic film. These results show that UV-absorbing films are a very good alternative
to reduce the need for insecticide sprays and effectively protect lettuce crops from insect pests
and insect-borne virus diseases.

Key words: pests, virus, UV-absorbing film, photoselective barriers, aphids, thrips, TSWV,


Lettuce is often grown during spring and autumn seasons in northeastern Spain under
plastic tunnel greenhouses. Although most of the plastic films contain UV-absorbing
properties to extend the life of the material, only few are able to block the transmission
of UV light with wavelengths below 380 nm. The latter interfere with insect vision and
orientation causing a significant reduction in population density and spread of insect
pests such as aphids or thrips (Costa et al., 2002). Previous works also show a
significant reduction in population density and damage caused by whiteflies (Bemisia
tabaci Gennadius), leafminers (Liriomyza trifolii Burgess) and moths (Laphigma sp.)
under greenhouses protected by UV-absorbing films (Antignus et al., 1996, Antignus,
      Another positive effect associated to the use of UV-absorbing films is the effective
control of insect-transmitted virus diseases. A clear reduction in virus spread has been
clearly observed in Bemisia-transmitted viruses such as Tomato yellow leaf curl virus
(TYLCV) and Cucurbit yellow stunting disorder virus (CYSDV). This significant
decrease in virus spread has been attributed to the impairment of whiteflies to fly and
disperse in the absence of UV-light (Antignus, 2000; Antignus et al., 2001).
      Most of the information related to the effects of UV-light absorbing plastic films
on insect populations and virus spread have concentrated in tomato and cucurbits. To
our knowledge, there is no information on the impact of UV-absorbing plastics on
insect pests and virus diseases commonly found in lettuce crops grown under
greenhouse environments. Our objective was to study the population dynamics of insect
pests and the spread of insect-transmitted viruses in a lettuce crop grown under a
greenhouse covered by a UV-light absorbing film at the Navarra region (Spain).

Material and methods

Cropping Practices
A 2-year field experiment was conducted to evaluate the impact of UV-absorbing
plastic films on population dynamics of insect pests associated to lettuce grown under
greenhouse conditions at Sartaguda, (Navarra, Spain). A ‘Batavia’ type crisp lettuce
crop was grown in two different seasons: September 9-November 7, 2002 and March
28- May 13, 2003.
      Two different commercial greenhouses (tunnel type, 40 m x 9 m) were used for
each growing season: one was covered with a standard polyethylene plastic film used in
the area (Astrolux), and the second was covered with a UV-photoselective plastic
named Ginegar AD-IR AV clear (supplied by Ginegar Plastic Products Ltd.) that had
similar properties as the Astrolux film except for the UV-absorbing additive. Both
greenhouses had the same orientation and were separated 50 m between each other.
They were provided with openings at each side of the tunnel and on the roof to facilitate
ventilation. These openings allowed unfiltered light to enter part of the greenhouse
structure. Doors were occasionally covered with nets to avoid wind damage to lettuce
plants. Each greenhouse was divided in 4-6 sectors (replicates) for sampling purposes.
A black plastic mulch was used for weed control and to increase soil temperature.
      Spraying was necessary at the beginning of the experiment conducted on autumn,
2002 to control cutworms (Agrotis sp.) and other lepidopteran pests (e.g. Autographa
gamma). Selective baits and two Bacillus thuringiensis sprays were used to control
these pests and avoid any detrimental effects on insect vectors of plant diseases. No
pesticides were needed in the experiment conducted in spring, 2003.
Sampling Methods
Insect population dynamics were monitored in three different ways:
a. Yellow and blue sticky traps were placed in each sector of the greenhouse (4 and 6
replicates were used in the experiment of 2002 and 2003, respectively). Plates were
replaced each week after plant transplant and the number of aphids, thrips, whiteflies
and leafhoppers were counted.
b. A horizontal green tile trap was placed in the middle of each greenhouse to monitor
landing rates of virus vectors (aphids, thrips, whiteflies and leafhoppers).
c. Fifteen plants per sector were inspected every two weeks as well as at harvest time to
determine the presence/absence of insect pests.
        Virus incidence was monitored at different time intervals by inspecting all plants
within each greenhouse sector and taking leaf samples of plants showing symptoms of
virus disease. Identification of viruses were conducted by ELISA using specific
antibodies: Lettuce mosaic virus (LMV), Broad bean wilt virus (BBWV), Alfalfa
mosaic virus (AMV), Beet western yellow virus (BWYV), Cucumber mosaic virus
(CMV) and Tomato spotted wilt virus (TSWV) and a general anti-Potyvirus monoclonal
antibody. These specific antibodies were selected because the above-mentioned viruses
were the ones that were most frequently found in a 3-year survey recently conducted by
our research group in the major lettuce-producing areas of Spain (Fereres et al.,

Results and discussion

Autumn, 2002 assay
The most abundant insect pests detected on lettuce plants were aphids (Macrosiphum
euphorbiae Thomas and Acyrthosiphon lactucae Passerini) followed by thrips
(Frankliniella occidentalis Pergande). Less number of winged aphids were trapped in
the yellow plates located under the UV-absorbing film than under the Astrolux control
film (overall mean  SE = 0.7 ± 0.2 vs. 2.4 ± 0.5; F= 8.275; P= 0.006; Figure 1).

      Mean number of aphids/trap

                                   7    
                                                                                      Non-UV absorbing film
                                   2                                                 UV-absorbing film
                                                           
                                                                     
                                                                 

                                       21.09.02 03.10.02 14.10.02 26.10.02 06.11.02

Figure 1. Mean number of aphids per trap and week caught in yellow sticky plates
located in a greenhouse covered with either UV-absorbing film or non-UV absorbing film

       No significant differences were obtained between the number of whiteflies
(Trialeurodes vaporariourum Westwood) caught in yellow plates located in the
greenhouse covered with UV-absorbing film than in the one covered by Astrolux film
(overall mean  SE = 5.7 ± 0.6 vs. 5.4 ± 0.6; F= 0.648; P= 0.424). The number of
insects caught in blue sticky traps and in the horizontal green tile trap was too low to
make statistical comparisons. At harvest time, the UV-absorbing plastic film was able to
significantly (P<0.05) reduce the number of lettuce plants infested with aphids and
thrips. The percentage of plants infested with at least one aphid was 97.5% in the case
of the greenhouse covered with Astrolux film. Only 10% of the lettuce plants grown
under UV-absorbing film were infested with 1 or more aphids. Plants with 5 or more
aphids were considered unmarketable. A significantly greater percentage of marketable
plants were found under the UV-absorbing film than under the Astrolux film (80 ± 11.5
vs. 10.0 ± 7.1; F= 17.121; P= 0.006). The type of plastic film used did not affect the size
and weight of lettuce plants.
        Virus incidence was first assessed 10 days after transplant (September 19). Only
few ELISA-positive samples were detected when using all the commercial antibodies
previously mentioned. The only 2 viruses detected in this initial survey were
Potyviruses and TSWV, and no differences were obtained in virus incidence between
the two greenhouses at this first sampling date. Further sampling was conducted looking
for symptomatic plants after inspection of all the plants present in each greenhouse.
There were clear differences between the number of symptomatic plants under the UV-
absorbing film and under the Astrolux film one month after the first sampling date
(October 22) (Table 1). At harvest time, the differences in virus incidence under each
type of film were even more obvious. The UV-absorbing film was able to provide a
reduction of 78% and 69% in the total incidence of Potyviruses and TSWV,
respectively. Most of the Potyvirus-infected plants were infected with LMV. Positive
infection of symptomatic plants was confirmed by ELISA.

Table 1. Virus incidence1 in lettuce grown under UV-
absorbing and non-UV absorbing (control) films

  Date                TSWV                                   Potyviruses
               UV film Non-UV film                     UV film    Non-UV film
 9-09-02         4          1                            11              6
22-10-02         7         19                            7              25
 7-11-02         1         19                            3              64
  Total          12        39                            21             95
24-09-03      1             1            2            4
08-10-03      1             4            3            8
29-10-03      0             2            1            6
  Total       2             7            6           18
  Total number of plants showing clear symptoms of virus
disease. Some of the plants showing symptoms of virus disease
died few days later.
Spring 2003 Assay
For this assay both greenhouses were divided in 6 sectors instead of the 4 used for the
autumn assay. Results on aphid numbers trapped on yellow sticky plates were very similar
to the ones obtained for the autumn assay. The number of winged aphids trapped under
UV-absorbing film was significantly lower than under the non-UV-absorbing film (overall
mean  SE = 0.6 ± 0.1 vs. 3.8 ± 0.8; F= 13.590; P= 0.001). No significant differences
were obtained between the numbers of thrips caught under the two types of plastic
     The most abundant insect pests detected on lettuce plants were aphids (M. euphorbiae
and A. lactucae) and lepidoptera larvae identified as Autographa gammaL., which reached
damaging levels close to harvest time. There were a significantly lower percentage of
plants infested by aphids in the greenhouse covered with UV-absorbing films at harvest
time (8.9% under UV-absorbing film versus 24.4 % infested under the non-UV-absorbing
plastic film). Table 2 shows clear differences between the numbers of plants infested with
A. gamma under both types of plastic films used in the study.

Table 2. Incidence of Autographa gamma under UV-absrobing and non-UV absrobing
(control) films at harvest time

                                            Film type
                                    UV film      Non-UV film           F            P
  Percentage of plants infested    17.8  4.1      37.8  5.6        8.633        0.015
    with one or more larvaea
   Mean no. of larvae/plantb    0.19  0.04     0.42  0.06          9.496        0.002
  Data was transformed by arcsinx before analysis
  Data was transformed by log (x+1) before analysis

        Total virus incidence was much lower in the spring than in the autumn experiment
probably because insect vectors entered the greenhouse at late in the growing season due to
low temperatures and/or the absence of virus reservoirs after the winter. Nevertheless, the
results were similar to those found in the autumn, and virus symptoms appeared much less
frequently in lettuce plants grown under the UV-absorbing film.
        In conclusion, the UV-absorbing films tested can effectively reduce aphid
abundance and spread of winged forms inside the greenhouse and protect lettuce plants
from aphid infestation. Also, these films proved to be very useful in reducing the spread
of aphid and thrip-transmitted virus diseases infecting lettuce. No effects were observed
on whitefly abundance (and/or spread), although population densities were not as high
as those observed for aphids and thrips. Our results are consistent with those reported by
Costa et al. (2002) that found no reduction in the population of T. vaporariorum under
commercial greenhouses covered with UV-absorbing films.


We thank the Spanish Ministry of Science and Technology (Research Grant, no.:
AGL:2000-2006) for funding this work and to Ginegar Plastic Products Ltd. (Israel) for
providing the UV-absorbing film.

Antignus, Y., Mor, N., Joseph, R. B., Lapidot, M. & Cohen, S. 1996: Ultraviolet-
    absorbing plastic sheets protect crops from insects pests and from virus diseases
    vectored by insects. Environ. Entomol. 25: 919-924.
Antignus, Y. 2000: Manipulation of wavelength dependent behaviour of insects an IPM
    tool to impede insects and insect-borne virus. Virus Res. 71: 213-220.
Antignus et al., 2001: Ultraviolet-deficient greenhouse environment affects whitefly
    attraction and flight-behavior. Environ. Entomol. 30: 394-399.
Costa, H. S., Robb, K. L. & Wilen, C. A. 2002: Field trials measuring the effects of
    ultraviolet-absorbing greenhouse plastic films on insect populations. J. Econ.
    Entomol. 95: 113-120.

To top