The GOP's December Surprise − Cooking the Books to Avoid Declaring a Recession?
The GOP's December Surprise − Cooking the Books to Avoid Declaring a Recession?
Source: http://newsgroups.derkeiler.com/Archive/Talk/talk.politics.misc/2008−07/msg00045.html
• From: Jeffrey Turner • Date: Fri, 04 Jul 2008 00:40:21 −0400 http://www.motherjones.com/news/feature/2008/07/december−surprise.html The GOP's December Surprise NEWS: Is the GOP cooking the books to avoid recession till after Election Day? By James K. Galbraith Is the worst over? Are we on the road to recovery? Will the next president take office against a backdrop of economic improvement, as Bill Clinton did in 1993? Or has something deeper and more intractable gone wrong? Early this year, the optimists, including Citigroup chairman Bob Rubin and Treasury secretary Hank Paulson, argued that the slowdown was short−term and that a "stimulus" package should be "targeted and temporary." This with rare haste the Democratic Congress enacted. As a result, most taxpayers got one−time $600 checks in May, prefigured by bubbly messages touting "Good News!" if you filed your taxes electronically. The rebate isn't the only little Dutch boy thrown headlong at the dike this election year. Government spending, especially for defense, will be up: Military spending as a share of gdp is expected to grow by $75 billion in fiscal 2008, enough to neutralize a 0.3 percent decline in gdp. Dick Cheney was secretary of defense for Bush 41; just before the 1992 election he engineered a big run−up in outlays, as the military restocked following the first Gulf War. (It was exposed in the first Clinton "Economic Report.") Is the Pentagon up to that trick again? I'd be astonished if it were not. Under intense pressure from panicky bankers, Ben Bernanke cut interest rates relentlessly from August 2007 through the spring of 2008. I don't accuse Bernanke of playing politics. But it's worth noting that this is what usually happens. In presidential election years when Republicans are in office, the Fed regularly and predictably pursues a more expansionary policy than when Democrats ruleafter controlling for The GOP's December Surprise − Cooking the Books to Avoid Declaring a Recession? 1
The GOP's December Surprise − Cooking the Books to Avoid Declaring a Recession? differences in the rates of inflation and unemployment. (I made these calculations myself; see the chart.) Maybe they just can't help themselves. But much of the ordinary effect of interest cuts on new lendinglike a rebound in construction and automobile salesdidn't happen this time. That's because the fall in home prices (and therefore the value of collateral) overwhelmed the benefit of cheaper money to the banks. And the banks barely cut mortgage rates, so consumers saw no benefits at all. Lower interest rates did cut the value of the dollar, however, and that promotes exports and foreign investment. (These days New York Times real estate listings come with a currency converter.) It also boosts the stock market, since multinational firms can report their (unchanged) foreign income as higher dollar earnings. Possibly all this stimulus will ward off the two−quarter decline that has historically defined a recession. Don't be surprised: Republicans haven't had an election−year slump since 1960. On the other hand, the National Bureau of Economic Research, which has the official call, may describe the early spring as a recession anyway. Republicans will welcome that, too, so long as they can plausibly call the summer a "recovery." Even if they can't stop a recession, they may be able to make it short and shallow enough, this year, to put John McCain in the White House. But all this brings up an important questionwhat of next year? No matter how effective the stimulus, two enormous clouds remain for whoever becomes president: the housing slump and the banking crisis. Both are far from being finished yet. The problem with a housing slump is inventory. Unlike factories and Internet startups, shuttered houses don't go away. No one declares them obsolete. They aren't boxed up and sent to China. They remain, a drag on the market, decaying and pulling down property values for years. Here in Texas, housing values slumped with the S&L crisis and the oil bust of 1985 and did not recover until around 1993. That slump clobbered the oil patch but was barely felt anywhere else. This slump is the reverseit's driving down housing prices just about everywhere except Texas, where the scars of the last bubble helped keep the recent one under control. Nationally, the subprime debacle is blowing away the homeownership gains of the last few years. Those abusive mortgages were deliberately targeted at vulnerable, even desperate, people who could be steered into financial death traps. Lenders didn't care, because with the help of fraudulent appraisals, the loans could be off−loaded quickly in packages bought by greedy or gullible investors, including your pension fund. Poor people got hit on the front end; 1.5 million homes entered foreclosure last year. Middle−class people got it on the return volley. −− The struggle with evil by means of violence is the same as an attempt to stop a cloud, The GOP's December Surprise − Cooking the Books to Avoid Declaring a Recession? 2
The GOP's December Surprise − Cooking the Books to Avoid Declaring a Recession? in order that there may be no rain. −Leo Tolstoy .
The GOP's December Surprise − Cooking the Books to Avoid Declaring a Recession?
3