Docstoc

S Corp California - Excel

Document Sample
S Corp California - Excel Powered By Docstoc
					DATABASE FOR JANICKE-REN ARTICLE, WHO WINS PAT


                                                                         State of
  Index                                                    Ultimate      District       District                                   Patentee HQ
 Number      Case Name         Citation        Date        Winner         Court          Court         Patentee / Parent ID           State




                                                         P = patentee;
                                                         AI = accused
                                                           infringer.
                                                          "Win" for P
                                                         defined as at                                                              state where
                                                           least one                                                               the patentee
                                                         claim of one                                                                or parent
                                             date of the patent valid, state where district court name of the patentee or the      corporation's
[internal use name of the                     Fed. Cir. infringed, and district court from which   parent corporation of the       headquarters
     only]       case         case cite       decision    enforceable        is       appeal taken         patentee                 are located

                Smith
             Engineering      2002 WL
             Co., Inc. v.    70440 (Fed.
             Eisenmann       Cir. Jan. 17,
    192         Corp.           2002).       1/17/2002         P         California Central District Smith Engineering Co., Inc.       N/A

               Vulcan
             Engineering
             Co., Inc. v.
                Fata          278 F.3d
             Aluminum,       1366 (Fed.                                                            Vulcan Engineering (Wafra
    191         Inc.         Cir. 2002).     2/5/2002          P         Michigan Eastern District          Parent)                 New York
             Fiskars, Inc.    279 F.3d
             v. Hunt Mfg.    1378 (Fed.
    189          Co.         Cir. 2002).     2/15/2002         P        Wisconsin Western District          Fiskars, Inc.            Finland


              Schreiber    2002 WL
             Foods, Inc. 315187 (Fed.
              v. Beatrice Cir. Feb. 27,
    187      Cheese, Inc.    2002).          2/27/2002         P        Wisconsin Eastern District     Schreiber Foods, Inc.        Wisconsin


             Biacore, AB  2002 WL
              v. Thermo 418166 (Fed.
             Bioanalysis Cir. Mar. 15,
    267          Corp.      2002).           3/15/2002         P         Delaware       District            Biacore AB               Sweden
       Welding
       Services,        2002 WL
        Inc. v         1000071
       Thermal         (Fed. Cir.
      Engineering       May 13,
263       Int'l          2002).      5/13/2002   P   South Carolina    District            Welding Services           Georgia
      Juicy Whip,
         Inc. v.  292 F.3d 728
        Orange      (Fed. Cir.
171    Bang, Inc.     2002).         6/7/2002    P     California Central District            Juicy Whip             California


      Teleflex, Inc.    299 F.3d
      v. Ficosa N.     1313 (Fed.
170    Am., Corp.      Cir. 2002).   6/21/2002   P     Michigan Eastern District             Teleflex, Inc.         Pennsylvania


        Catalina
      Lighting, Inc.    295 F.3d
        v. Lamps       1277 (Fed.
168     Plus, Inc.     Cir. 2002).   6/28/2002   P      Florida    Southern District       Lamps Plus, Inc.          California
        Rotating
       Prod. Sys.,   2002 WL
      Inc. v. Bock    1560776
      Specialties, (Fed. Cir. Jul.
164        Inc.      16, 2002).      7/16/2002   P     Colorado        District        Rotating Production Sys.     New Mexico



      Riles v. Shell
       Exploration      298 F.3d
       & Produc.       1302 (Fed.
161        Co.         Cir. 2002).   7/31/2002   P       Texas     Southern District       William G. Riles            Texas
      Bayer AG v.       301 F.3d
        Schein         1306 (Fed.
158   Pharm., Inc.     Cir. 2002).   8/9/2002    P    New Jersey       District                 Bayer                Germany
      Bayer AG v.       298 F.3d
        Carlsbad       1377 (Fed.
159    Tech., Inc.     Cir. 2002).   8/14/2002   P     California Southern District             Bayer                Germany
                       2002 WL
         Laporte       1890749
        Pigments,      (Fed. Cir.
       Inc. v. Axel     Aug. 15,                                                      Laporte Pigments, Inc. (now
156       J., LP         2002).      8/15/2002   P      Missouri Western District        Rockwood Pigments)          New York
       3M Co. v.        303 F.3d
       Chemque,        1294 (Fed.
152      Inc.          Cir. 2002).   8/30/2002   P       Texas     Western District               3M                 Minnesota
          BBA
       Nonwovens
      Simpsonville,
         Inc. v.
        Superior       303 F.3d
      Nonwovens,      1332 (Fed.
153       LLC         Cir. 2002).   8/30/2002    P   South Carolina    District        BBA Nonwovens            Sweden
                      2002 WL
        Lawman        31497305
      Armor Corp.     (Fed. Cir.
       v. Winner       Nov. 8,
251     Int'l, Inc.     2002).      11/8/2002    P   Pennsylvania Eastern District    Lawman Armor Corp       Pennsylvania
                      2002 WL
      Nikken USA,     31664765
         Inc. v.      (Fed. Cir.
        Robison-       Nov. 20,
145    May, Inc.        2002).      11/20/2002   P     California Central District     Nikken USA, Inc.        California


       K&K Jump       2002 WL
      Start/Charge    31684820
        rs, Inc. v.   (Fed. Cir.
      Schumacker       Nov. 25,
144    Elec. Corp.      2002).      11/25/2002   P      Missouri Western District K&K Jump Start/Chargers       Kansas
                      2002 WL
       Maxwell v.     31809442
      Angel-Etts of   (Fed. Cir.
       California,     Dec. 13,
143       Inc.          2002).      12/13/2002   P     California Central District     Susan M. Maxwell        Minnesota
         Micro
       Chemical,       317 F.3d
         Inc. v.      1387 (Fed.
138   Lextron, Inc.   Cir. 2003).   1/24/2003    P       Texas    Northern District   Micro Chemical, Inc.       Texas


          Wesley     2003 WL
      Jessen Corp. 681706 (Fed.
       v. Bausch & Cir. Feb. 12,
135     Lomb Inc.     2003).        2/12/2003    P     Delaware        District       Wesley Jessen Corp
                                                                                                     Switzerland (Novartis Parent)



       Crossroads
        Systems,
      (Texas), Inc.   2003 WL
      v. Chaparral     344091
        Network     (Fed.Cir. Feb
246   Storage, Inc. 12, 2003).      2/12/2003    P       Texas    Western District        Crossroads             Texas
       Boehringer
        Ingelheim
       Vetmedica,
          Inc. v.      320 F.3d                                                         Boehringer Ingelhaim
        Schering-     1339 (Fed.                                                       Vetmedica US (Parent BI
130   Plough Corp.    Cir. 2003).     2/21/2003   P   New Jersey       District                Corp)              Germany


                   2003 WL
      Watts v. XL  932439
       Systems, (Fed.Cir. Mar
245      Inc.     06, 2003).          3/6/2003    P     Texas      Eastern District         John D. Watts          Texas

        Hodgdon
      Powder Co.,
      Inc. v. Clean 2003 WL
           Shot      1194277
      Technologie (Fed.Cir. Mar
244      s, Inc.    07, 2003).        3/7/2003    P     Florida    Southern District    Hodgdon Powder Co.         Kansas
                       2003 WL
        Applera        1795593
        Corp. v.       (Fed. Cir.
       Micromass        Mar. 11,
125     UK Ltd.          2003).       3/11/2003   P   Delaware         District             Applera Corp         Connecticut


       Hockerson-      2003 WL
       Halberstadt,    1795641
      Inc. v. Propet (Fed. Cir. Apr
119     USA, Inc.      1, 2003).      4/1/2003    P   Louisiana Eastern District Hockerson-Halberstadt, Inc         N/A
         Dekalb        2003 WL
        Genetics       1878950
        Corp. v.       (Fed. Cir.
       Pioneer Hi-      Apr. 11,
242     Bred Int'l       2003).       4/11/2003   P     Illinois   Northern District    Dekalb Genetics Corp       Illinois


        Nutting v.  2003 WL
          RAM       2008072
       Southwest,   (Fed. Cir.
113       Inc.     May 1, 2003).      5/1/2003    P    Colorado        District           Donald W. Nutting       Colorado
                      2003 WL
      Taco Metals,    21206076
         Inc. v.      (Fed. Cir.
        Tigress        May 16,
238   Trading Co.       2003).        5/16/2003   P     Florida    Southern District      Taco Metals, Inc.        Florida


         Integra
      Lifesciences 331 F.3d 860
        I. Ltd. V.   (Fed. Cir.
106   Merck KgaA       2003).         6/6/2003    P   California Southern District       Integra Lifesciences    New Jersey
      BJ Services
         Co. v.
      Halliburton      338 F.3d
        Energy        1368 (Fed.
102    Serv., Inc.    Cir. 2003).    8/6/2003    P      Texas      Southern District      BJ Services             Texas
                      2003 WL
      Libman Co.      22025068
       v. Quickie     (Fed. Cir.
      Manufacturin     Aug. 27,
98      g Corp.         2003).      8/27/2003    P      Illinois   Central District          Quickie            New Jersey


      Applied Med.
      Res. Corp. v.    2003 WL
         United       22129334
         States       (Fed. Cir.
        Surgical       Sep. 11,
229      Corp.          2003).      9/11/2003    P     California Central District Applied Medical Resources     California
                      2003 WL
      Atmel Corp.     22129398
       v. Silicon     (Fed. Cir.
        Storage        Sep. 12,
94    Tech., Inc.       2003).      9/12/2003    P     California Northern District           Atmel              California

        Akamai
       Tech. v.
       Cable &
       Wireless        344 F.3d
        Internet      1186 (Fed.
93     Sev., Inc.     Cir. 2003).   9/15/2003    P   Massachusetts     District           Akamai Tech          Massachusetts
       Arlington
       Indus. V.       345 F.3d
      Bridgeport      1318 (Fed.
88    Fittings, Inc   Cir. 2003).   9/25/2003    P   Pennsylvania Middle District      Arlington Industries    Pennsylvania

        Rhone-
        Poulenc
      Agro, S.A. v.
        Dekalb         345 F.3d
       Genetics       1366 (Fed.
86       Corp         Cir. 2003).   9/29/2003    P   North Carolina Middle District Rhone-Poulenc Agro S.A.
                                                                                                         France (Now Aventis)
                      2003 WL
                      22455416
      Harris Corp.    (Fed. Cir.
      v. Sanyo N.      Oct. 29,
82        Am.           2003).      10/29/2003   P      Texas      Northern District       Harris Corp            Florida


      Merck & Co.,     347 F.3d
      Inc. v. Teva    1367 (Fed.
81    Pharm USA       Cir. 2003).   10/30/2003   P     Delaware        District              Merck              New Jersey
       Regents of       2003 WL
        Univ. of       22671582
      Michigan v.         (Fed.
      Genesearch,      Cir.Nov. 7,
80       LLC             2003).      11/7/2003    P        Michigan Eastern District        University of Michigan   Michigan
       Utah Med.
      Prod., Inc. v.
        Graphic         350 F.3d
        Controls       1376 (Fed.
75       Corp.         Cir. 2003).   12/4/2003    P           Utah          District            Utah Medical           Utah
                        352 F.3d
      Ericsson v.      1369 (Fed.
71    Harris Corp.     Cir. 2003).   12/9/2003    P          Texas      Eastern District          Ericsson           Sweeden
                       2003 WL
         In Re         22928641
      Omeprazole       (Fed. Cir.
        Patent          Dec. 11,
70     Litigation        2003).      12/11/2003   P        New York Southern District Astra (parent AstraZeneca) Great Britain
      Golight Inc.      355 F.3d
      v. Wal-Mart      1327 (Fed.
62    Stores, Inc.     Cir. 2004).   1/20/2004    P        Colorado         District             Golight, Inc.       Nebraska
                        355 F.3d
      Toro Co. v.      1313 (Fed.
64    Deere & Co.      Cir. 2004).   1/20/2004    P        Minnesota        District              Toro Co.           Minnesota


      Pfizer Inc. v.    359 F.3d
      Dr. Reddy’s      1361 (Fed.
54      Lab., Ltd      Cir. 2004).   2/27/2004    P       New Jersey        District              Pfizer Inc.        New York

      Safari Land
      Ltd., Inc. v.
        Hellweg       2004 WL
      Intern., Pty     434167
         Ltd. of    (Fed.Cir. Mar.
223    Australia      8, 2004).       3/8/2004    P        California Southern District        Safari LandLtd.        Florida


       Glenayre      2004 WL
      Electronics,    842828
         Inc. v.   (Fed.Cir. Apr
221    Jackson      08, 2004).        4/8/2004    P          Illinois   Northern District      Phillip Jackson        Illinois
      Vanderlande
         Indus.         366 F.3d
       Nederland       1311 (Fed.
43     BV v. I.T.C     Cir. 2004).    5/3/2004     P             International Trade    Siemens/Rapistan
                                                  International Trade Commission Commission                          Germany


                   2004 WL
      Hem, Inc. v.  1153367
       Behringer (Fed.Cir. May
214   Saws, Inc.   17, 2004).        5/17/2004    P        Oklahoma Northern District             Hem, Inc.          Oklahoma
      Metabolite         370 F.3d
      Lab., Inc. v.     1354 (Fed.
35    Lab. Corp.        Cir. 2004).    6/8/2004    P   Colorado        District           Metabolite Lab., Inc.          N/A
      Hockerson-        2004 WL
      Halberstadt,      1491647
      Inc. v. JSP       (Fed. Cir.
       Footwear,         Jun. 23,
34        Inc.            2004).      6/23/2004    P   Louisiana Eastern District Hockerson-Halberstadt, Inc             N/A


      Glaxo Group        376 F.3d
         Ltd. v.        1339 (Fed.                                                     Glaxo Group Ltd. (parent
27    Apotex, Inc.,     Cir. 2004).   7/27/2004    P    Illinois   Northern District      GlaxoSmithKline)           Great Britain
                        2004 WL
                        1946482
      Fisher-Price,     (Fed. Cir.
      Inc. v. Safety     Aug. 16,                                                       Fisher-Price, Inc. (Mattel
24       1st Inc          2004).      8/16/2004    P   Delaware        District                 Parent)                  NY
          Nat’l          2004 WL
      Instruments       2030128
        Corp. v.        (Fed. Cir.
      MathWorks,         Sep. 3,
21         Inc.           2004).       9/3/2004    P    Texas      Eastern District National Instruments Corp.          Texas
        Poly-
      American v.        383 F.3d.
      GSE Lining        1303 (Fed.
16    Tech., Inc.       Cir. 2004).   9/14/2004    P    Texas      Northern District       Poly-America, L.P.           Texas
       Insituform
      Tech. Inc. v.      385 F.3d
          CAT           1360 (Fed.                                                     Insituform Technologies,
20    Contracting       Cir. 2004).   10/4/2004    P    Texas      Southern District              Inc.                 Missouri


       Universal
      Surveillance
       Systems,
         Inc. v.    2004 WL
      Sensormatic   2370590
      Electronics (Fed.Cir. Oct                                                         Sensormatic Electronics
205      Corp.     05, 2004).         10/5/2004    P    Florida    Southern District           Corp.                   Florida
       C.R. Bard,
       Inc. v. U.S.    388 F.3d 858
         Surgical        (Fed. Cir.
11        Corp.            2004).   10/29/2004     P   Delaware        District              C.R. Bard, Inc.         New Jersey
                         391 F.3d.
      Alza Corp. v.     1365 (Fed.                                                     Alza Corp (parent Johnson
2      Mylan Lab.       Cir. 2004).   12/10/2004   P   Vermont         District               & Johnson)              California
                         392 F.3d.
      Versa Corp.       1325 (Fed.
3      v. AG-Bag        Cir. 2004).   12/14/2004   P    Oregon         District               Versa Corp               Oregon
      NTP, Inc. v.      392 F.3d
      Research in      1336 (Fed.
19    Motion, Ltd.,    Cir. 2004).    12/14/2004   P       Virginia   Eastern District            NTP, Inc.              Virginia
        PACTIV         2002 WL
        Corp. v.      21944 (Fed.
       Johnson &      Cir. Jan. 4,
195     Son, Inc.       2002).         1/4/2002    AI      Illinois   Northern District        PACTIV Corp.              Illinois
      Rheox, Inc.       276 F.3d
       v. Entact,      1319 (Fed.                                                         Rheox, Inc. (Elementis US
194       Inc.         Cir. 2002).     1/8/2002    AI    New Jersey       District                 Parent)             New Jersey


       McLaren
      Performance 2002 WL
      Technologie 44212 (Fed.
       s v. Dana  Cir. Jan. 8,                                                           McLaren Performance Tech.
266      Corp.      2002).             1/8/2002    AI     Michigan Eastern District        (McLaren Engines Inc.)       Michigan
                      2002 WL
      Saeilo Inc. v. 59674 (Fed.
       Colt's Mfg. Cir. Jan. 16,
193     Co., Inc.      2002).         1/16/2002    AI     New York Southern District             Saeilo Inc.           South Korea
       Datapoint
        Corp. v.   2002 WL
       Standard 243431 (Fed.
      Microsystem Cir. Feb. 15,
190     s Corp.      2002).           2/15/2002    AI     New York Eastern District            Datapoint Corp. Texas (Cattlsale Company)


       United Sys.
      of Arkansas,    2002 WL
      Inc. v. Laser 243448 (Fed.
       Substrates, Cir. Feb. 19,
188        Inc.        2002).         2/19/2002    AI     Arkansas Eastern District           Laser Substrates           Florida


      Neutrik AG     2002 WL
           v.      315032 (Fed.
      Switchcraft, Cir. Feb. 27,
186       Inc.        2002).          2/27/2002    AI     New York Southern District             Neutrik AG           Liechtenstein


                     2002 WL
                   343415 (Fed.
      Okor v. Sega Cir. Mar. 5,
185     of Am.        2002).           3/5/2002    AI   Massachusetts     District          Joseph Kwame Okor         Massachusetts


          I/O           2002 WL
       Concepts,      424550 (Fed.
        Inc. v.       Cir. Mar. 13,
268    Johnson           2002).       3/12/2002    AI    Washington Western District          Brent R. Johnson          Oklahoma
       Johnson &
        Johnston
      Assoc., Inc.      285 F.3d
      v. R.E. Serv.    1046 (Fed.
184      Co., Inc.     Cir. 2002).   3/28/2002   AI   California Northern District     Johnson & Johnson       New Jersey


        M-3 &        2002 WL
      Assoc., Inc. 504783 (Fed.
       v. Cargo     Cir. Apr. 2,
183    Sys. Inc.      2002).         4/2/2002    AI    Indiana     Northern District M-3 & Associates, Inc.      Indiana
      Sealmaster,
       L.L.C. v     2002 WL
       Silverline 519811 (Fed.
       Building    Cir. Apr. 5,
264    Products      2002).          4/5/2002    AI   Tennessee Eastern District        SealMaster LLC         Tennessee


      Jackson v   2002 WL
        Casio   535809 (Fed.
      Phonemate Cir. Apr. 10,
259      Inc.      2002).            4/10/2002   AI     Illinois   Northern District   Phillip S. Jackson        Illinois
      TechSearch,       286 F.3d
       LLC v. Intel    1360 (Fed.
182      Corp.         Cir. 2002).   4/11/2002   AI   California Northern District     TechSearch, LLC           Illinois
        IGC-Med.
        Advances,    2002 WL
       Inc. v. USA 598339 (Fed.                                                  IGC-Medical Advances, Inc.
      Instruments, Cir. Apr. 16,                                                   (parent Intermagnetics
181        Inc.       2002).         4/16/2002   AI   Wisconsin Western District       General Corp)            New York
       Neomagic
        Corp. v.
        Trident         287 F.3d
      Microsystem      1062 (Fed.
180      s, Inc.       Cir. 2002).   4/17/2002   AI   Delaware         District         NeoMagic Corp           California
       3M, Co. v.     289 F.3d 775
       Barr Lab.,       (Fed. Cir.
179      Inc.             2002).     5/1/2002    AI   Minnesota        District                3M               Minnesota


      McKeown v.   2002 WL
       Bayshore 914339 (Fed.
       Concrete   Cir. May 7,
178   Prod. Corp.   2002).           5/7/2002    AI    Virginia    Eastern District     Kevin Mckeown         Washington DC


      Blistex Inc. v 2002 WL
          Circle    972204 (Fed.
      Laboratories, Cir. May 7,
261        Inc.        2002).        5/7/2002    AI     Illinois   Northern District     Circle Lab. Inc.        Florida
      Okor v. Sony 2002 WL
       Computer 972206 (Fed.
      Entertainme Cir. May 8,
177   nt Am., Inc.  2002).           5/8/2002    AI   Massachusetts      District         Joseph Kwame Okor         Massachusetts
                       2002 WL
      Indian Creek     1025099
        Mesquite,      (Fed. Cir.
      Inc. v Wood,      May 10,
260        Inc.          2002).      5/10/2002   AI      Texas       Northern District Indian Creek Mesquite Inc.      Texas
      Belden Wire
      & Cable Co.    2002 WL
        v. Cable   987999 (Fed.
      Design Tech. Cir. May 14,
175      Corp.        2002).         5/14/2002   AI      Illinois    Northern District    Belden Wire & Cable         Missouri

        Cooper
       Cameron
        Corp. v.
       Kvaerner         291 F.3d
        Oilfield       1317 (Fed.
176    Prod., Inc.     Cir. 2002).   5/14/2002   AI      Texas       Southern District Cooper Cameron Corp.            Texas

         Husky
        Injection
      Molding Sys.
      Ltd. V. R & D
           Tool     291 F.3d 780
      Engineering     (Fed. Cir.                                                         Husky Injection Molding
174        Co.          2002).       5/17/2002   AI     Missouri Western District                 Sys.                New York
                       2002 WL
          Home         1066665
      Diagnostics,     (Fed. Cir.
          Inc. v.       May 29,
173   Lifescan, Inc.     2002)       5/29/2002   AI     California Northern District            Lifescan Jersey (Johnson & Johnson Parent)
                                                                                                      New


        Frank's
      Casing Crew
        & Rental
      Tools, Inc. v.    292 F.3d
      PMR Tech.,       1363 (Fed.
172       Ltd.         Cir. 2002).   6/4/2002    AI     Louisiana Western District          PMR Tech. Ltd.          Massachusetts


      Ryan Marine
        Products    2002 WL
       Pty. v Hale  1218028
       Propeller,   (Fed. Cir.
262   Dist. Conn. Jun. 5, 2002).     6/5/2002    AI    Connecticut       District             Ryan Marine             Australia
        Insight
      Development 2002 WL
        Corp. v     1291853
        Hewlett-    (Fed. Cir.
258   Packard Co. Jun. 6, 2002).        6/6/2002    AI    California Northern District Insight Development Corp.    California
                        2002 WL
      Neupak, Inc.      1363568
      v. Ideal Mfg.     (Fed. Cir.
         & Sales         Jun. 24,
169       Corp.           2002).        6/24/2002   AI   Minnesota        District            Neupak, Inc.
                                                                                                       Wisconsin (Ideal Mfg & Sales Parent)
       Netscape
      Communicati       295 F.3d
      ons Corp. v.     1315 (Fed.
167     Konrad         Cir. 2002).      7/9/2002    AI    California Northern District       Allan M. Konrad        California
         Cardiac
      Pacemakers,
        Inc. v. St.     296 F.3d
       Jude Med.,      1106 (Fed.
166        Inc.        Cir. 2002).      7/11/2002   AI     Indiana Southern District Cardiac Pacemaker Inc
                                                                                                        Indiana (Guidant Parent)


       Edberg v.     2002 WL
        CPI-The       1541688
       Alternative (Fed. Cir. Jul.
165   Supplier, Inc. 15, 2002).         7/15/2002   AI   Connecticut      District          Stepehn C. Edberg      Connecticut

        Aspex
       Eyewear,
         Inc. v.        2002 WL
       Revolution        1560642
       Eyewear,       (Fed. Cir. Jul.
255       Inc.          15, 2002).      7/15/2002   AI    California Central District        Aspex Eyewear           Canada


       Pro Sports,  2002 WL
         USA v.      1560780
      Mizuno USA, (Fed. Cir. Jul.
257        Inc.     15, 2002).          7/15/2002   AI      Utah          District       Pro Sports USA (Dreams)     Florida


                    2002 WL
                     1587045
       HM Elecs., (Fed. Cir. Jul.
256    Inc. v. 3M   17, 2002).          7/17/2002   AI    California Southern District       HME Electronics       Switzerland


       Semittool,       2002 WL
        Inc. v.          1628368
       Novellus       (Fed. Cir. Jul.
163    Sys., Inc.       23, 2002).      7/23/2002   AI    California Northern District        Semitool, Inc.         Montana
         New
       Railhead
      Mfg., LLC v.     298 F.3d
       Vermeer        1290 (Fed.
162    Mfg. Co.       Cir. 2002).    7/30/2002   AI      Texas     Northern District      Railhead Mfg., LLC          Texas
                      2002 WL
       Read Corp.     1822282
           v.         (Fed. Cir.
      Powerscreen      Aug. 7,
160    of Am., Inc.     2002).       8/7/2002    AI   Massachusetts     District             Read Corp            Massachusetts
                      2002 WL
       Basic Fun,     1890782
         Inc. v.      (Fed. Cir.
       RBTACQ,         Aug. 14,
157       Inc.          2002).       8/14/2002   AI   Pennsylvania Eastern District           Basic Fun            Pennsylvania
      SmithKline      2002 WL
       Beecham        1890708
        Corp. v.      (Fed. Cir.
        Copley         Aug. 15,                                                        SmithKline Beecham Corp
155   Pharm., Inc.      2002).       8/15/2002   AI   Massachusetts     District          (GlaxoSmithKline)    Great Britain
          In re
      Cruciferous      301 F.3d
        Sprout        1343 (Fed.
154    Litigation     Cir. 2002).    8/21/2002   AI     Maryland        District       Johns Hopkins University     Maryland
      Creo Prod.,
        Inc. v.        305 F.3d
       Presstek,      1337 (Fed.
150       Inc.        Cir. 2002).    9/17/2002   AI     Delaware        District            Presstek, Inc         New Hampshire
        Eastman       2002 WL
       Chemical       31085363
          Co. v.      (Fed. Cir.
      Aktiengesells    Sep. 17,
151       chaft         2002).       9/17/2002   AI    Tennessee Eastern District               BASF                Germany
         Novo
      Nordisk A/S
       v. Becton       304 F.3d
      Dickinson &     1216 (Fed.
149       Co.         Cir. 2002).    9/19/2002   AI     New York Southern District        Novo Nordisk A/S          Denmark
                                                                                                                       Texas
       Zevo Golf     2002 WL                                                                                        (Purchased
       Co., Inc. v.  31175474                                                                                      by Golfsmith
      Karsten Mfg. (Fed. Cir.                                                                                      International
148      Corp.      Oct. 1, 2002).   10/1/2002   AI     California Southern District          Zevo Golf               in 2003)


        All Dental
       Prodx, LLC
      v. Advantage 309 F.3d 774
      Dental Prod., (Fed. Cir.
147         Inc.      2002).    10/25/2002       AI     New York Eastern District Advantage Dental Products         Michigan
                       2002 WL
      Ohio Cellular    31497320
      Prods. Corp.     (Fed. Cir.
       v. Adams         Nov. 7,                                                           Ohio Cellular Product
253    USA, Inc.         2002).      11/7/2002    AI       Ohio       Northern District     (Varsity Sports)          Ohio

                       2002 WL
                       31497314
      Vanmoor V.       (Fed. Cir.
       Sonoco           Nov. 8,
252   Prods. Co.         2002).      11/8/2002    AI      Florida     Southern District     Arthur Vanmoor           Florida

       Deltatrak,
        Inc. v.        2002 WL
        Monitor        31509875
      Temperature      (Fed. Cir.
       Recording        Nov. 12,
250       Co.            2002).      11/12/2002   AI     California Eastern District            Deltatrak           California
                       2002 WL
      Leoutsakos       31546018
       v. Coll's       (Fed. Cir.
        Hosp.           Nov. 15,
146   Pharm., Inc.       2002).      11/15/2002   AI   New Hempshire      District        Thomas Leoutsakos       Massachusetts
                       2002 WL
                       31875667
        Holtz v.       (Fed. Cir.
       Conexant         Dec. 26,
142    Sys., Inc.        2002).      12/26/2002   AI     California Northern District        Klaus E. Holtz         California
                       2003 WL
        Ziarno v.     57060 (Fed.
       Am. Nat'l      Cir. Jan. 7,
141    Red Cross        2003).        1/7/2003    AI      Illinois    Northern District      Witold Ziarno           Illinois


      Vanmoor v.   2003 WL
       Sonoco      124152
       Products (Fed.Cir. Jan
249    Co., Inc.  10, 2003).         1/10/2003    AI      Florida     Southern District     Arthur Vanmoor           Florida

         Plant
        Genetic
      Sys., N.V. v.
        DeKalb         315 F.3d
       Genetics       1335 (Fed.
140      Corp.        Cir. 2003).    1/13/2003    AI    Connecticut       District         Plant Genetic Sys.       Belgium
        Warner-
      Lambert Co.      316 F.3d
       v. Apotex      1348 (Fed.
139      Corp.        Cir. 2003).    1/16/2003    AI      Illinois    Northern District   Warner-Lambert Co.New York (Pfizer Parent)
       Bowers v.       320 F.3d
        Baystate      1317 (Fed.
137    Tech., Inc.    Cir. 2003).    1/29/2003    AI   Massachusetts      District          Harold L. Bowers         Virginia
         Kensey     2003 WL
      Nash Corp. 262343 (Fed.
      v. Perclose, Cir. Feb. 5,
136       Inc.       2003).            2/5/2003    AI   Pennsylvania Eastern District    Kensey Nash Corp.          Pennsylvania

        Aspen
      Manufacturin
       g, Inc. v.    2003 WL
      Benchmark       343310
      Manufacturin (Fed.Cir. Feb
247     g, Inc.      10, 2003).        2/10/2003   AI      Texas     Eastern District Aspen Manufacturing, Inc.        Texas
      Clear-Line         2003 WL
      Chemicals,          344106
        Inc. v.          (Fed.Cir.
       Palmero           Feb. 10,
248   Health Care         2003).       2/10/2003   AI      Texas     Southern District   Clear-Line Chemicals          Texas
      Phonometric
       s, Inc. v.        319 F.3d
      Westin Hotel      1328 (Fed.
134       Co.           Cir. 2003).    2/12/2003   AI      Florida   Southern District    Phonometrics, Inc           Florida
        Springs
        Window
      Fashions LP 323 F.3d 989
        v. Novo     (Fed. Cir.
132    Indus., LP     2003).           2/13/2003   AI                                              Fashions
                                                         Wisconsin Western District Springs WindowSouth Carolina (Springs Indus. Parent)


        Pinnacle
      Pigging Sys.,
         Inc. v.    2003 WL
       Eliminator 343300 (Fed.
      Pigging Sys. Cir. Feb. 13,
133     USA, Inc.     2003).           2/13/2003   AI      Texas     Southern District Pinnacle Pigging Sys., Inc     Canada
      Intel Corp. v.     319 F.3d
       VIA Tech.,       1357 (Fed.
131        Inc.         Cir. 2003).    2/14/2003   AI    California Northern District            Intel               California
       Dura-Last,
         Inc. v.         321 F.3d
        Custom          1098 (Fed.
129    Seal, Inc.       Cir. 2003).    2/28/2003   AI     Michigan Eastern District           Duro-Last              Michigan


                    2003 WL
      Robinson v. 858911 (Fed.
      Fakespace Cir. Mar. 5,
127    Labs, Inc.    2003).            3/5/2003    AI     Michigan Eastern District William Henry Robinson           Michigan


                         2003 WL
        Reese v.       859234 (Fed.
       U.S. West,       Cir. Mar. 5,
128       Inc.            2003).       3/5/2003    AI     Colorado       District           Morris Reese             California
       Williams v.
          Gen.       2003 WL
        Surgical   932449 (Fed.
      Innovations, Cir. Mar. 7,
126        Inc.       2003).            3/7/2003    AI      Texas      Eastern District Randy Williams (trustee)     Texas
      Abbott Lab.
          V.             323 F.3d
      Novopharm         1324 (Fed.
124      Ltd.           Cir. 2003).     3/20/2003   AI      Illinois   Northern District        Abbott Lab           Illinois
       Lockheed
      Martin Corp.
       v. Space          324 F.3d
      Sys./Loral,       1308 (Fed.
123       Inc           Cir. 2003).     3/24/2003   AI    California Northern District       Lockheed Martin        Maryland
                         2003 WL
      Am. Seating        1795638
         Co. v.          (Fed. Cir.
        Transp.           Mar. 26,
122   Seating, Inc.        2003).       3/26/2003   AI     Michigan Western District Transportation Seating Inc.   Michigan

                         2003 WL
                          1795638
                         (Fed. Cir.
      Am. Seating         Mar. 26,
         Co. v.         2003) (both
        Transp.          are patent
269   Seating, Inc.       holders).     3/26/2003   AI     Michigan Western District       American Seating Co.     Michigan
      Eaton Corp.        323 F.3d
       v. Rockwell      1332 (Fed.
121   Intern. Corp.     Cir. 2003).     3/27/2003   AI    Delaware         District               Eaton               Ohio


      Allergan, Inc.     324 F.3d
         v. Alcon       1322 (Fed.
120     Lab., Inc.      Cir. 2003).     3/28/2003   AI    California Central District            Allergan          California
      Moba, B.V.
      v. Diamond         325 F.3d
      Automation,       1306 (Fed.
118       Inc.          Cir. 2003).     4/1/2003    AI   Pennsylvania Eastern District     Diamond Automation      Michigan


                         2003 WL
       Caputo v.         1827223
       Sealed Air       (Fed. Cir.
117      Corp.         Apr. 8, 2003).   4/8/2003    AI   New Jersey        District          Garry L. Caputo       New Jersey
          First          2003 WL
       Graphics,         1875570
         Inc. v.         (Fed. Cir.
      M.E.P. CAD,         Apr. 10,
243       Inc.             2003).       4/10/2003   AI      Illinois   Northern District      First Graphics         Illinois
      Bristol-Myers
       Squibb Co.
       v. Rhone-        326 F.3d
         Poulenc       1226 (Fed.
116    Rorer, Inc.     Cir. 2003).   4/15/2003   AI   New York Southern District Rhone-Poulenc Rorer, Inc
                                                                                                        France (Now Aventis)
                       2003 WL
       Lopes v.        1949581
       Hardware        (Fed. Cir.
      Distributors,     Apr. 23,
114       Ltd.           2003).      4/23/2003   AI   Minnesota Northern District           Lopes              California


        Atlantic       2003 WL
      Construction     1949582
      Fabrics, Inc.    (Fed. Cir.
       v. Dandy         Apr. 23,
115    Prod., Inc.       2003).      4/23/2003   AI    Virginia   Eastern District     Dandy Products            Ohio


                    2003 WL
                    21058271
        Rubin v.    (Fed. Cir.
241   Henkel Corp. May 8, 2003).     5/8/2003    AI   New York Southern District       Burton S. Rubin         New York
      Mertens v.       2003 WL
      Doty (doing      21130005
       Bus. As         (Fed. Cir.
       Archers'         May 14,
240     Edge)            2003).      5/14/2003   AI   Montana         District         Greg A. Mertens          Missouri
                       2003 WL
                       21130013
      Manchak v.       (Fed. Cir.
      Atl. Richfield    May 15,
239        Co.           2003).      5/15/2003   AI   Delaware        District         Frank Manchak           California
                       2003 WL
        J.G. Peta,     21206079
       Inc. v. Club    (Fed. Cir.
        Protector,      May 20,
112        Inc.          2003).      5/20/2003   AI   New York Northern District      Club Protector, Inc.     New York
                       2003 WL
          Marlow       21212626
       Indus., Inc.    (Fed. Cir.
      v. Igloo Prod.    May 23,
111        Corp.         2003).      5/23/2003   AI     Texas     Northern District     Marlow Indus. Pennsylvania (II-IV Parent)

                       2003 WL
                       21259765
      Versa Corp.      (Fed. Cir.
       v. Ag-Bag        May 30,
109   Intern. Ltd.       2003).      5/30/2003   AI    Oregon         District              Versa               Oregon
         T.F.H.        2003 WL
      Publications,    21259768                                                                                 California
      Inc. v. Hartz    (Fed. Cir.                                                                                (Central
        Mountain        May 30,                                                                                Garden & Pet
110      Corp.           2003).      5/30/2003   AI   New Jersey         District       T.F.H. Publications    Corp. Parent)
        Pioneer
       Magnetics,       330 F.3d
      Inc. v. Micro    1352 (Fed.
108   Linear Corp.     Cir. 2003).   6/2/2003    AI    California Central District      Pioneer Magnetics        California
       Waner v.       331 F.3d 851
      Ford Motor        (Fed. Cir.
107      Co.              2003).     6/4/2003    AI   South Dakota       District             Waner               Illinois

        Tru-Fire
        Corp. v.       2003 WL
      Tomorrow's       21479730
         Res.          (Fed. Cir.
       Unlimited,       Jun. 20,
237       Inc.           2003).      6/20/2003   AI    Wisconsin Western District       Tru-Fire Corporation    Wisconsin


       Composite     2003 WL
      Rotor, Inc. v. 21659464
       Beckman (Fed. Cir. Jul.
236   Coulter, Inc. 10, 2003).       7/10/2003   AI    California Northern District      Composite Rotor         California


                   2003 WL
      Deere & Co. 21674752
       v. Kubota (Fed. Cir. Jul.
235      Corp.     17, 2003).        7/17/2003   AI      Illinois    Central District         Deere               Illinois
       Minton v
       National
       Ass'n of         336 F.3d
      Securities       1373 (Fed.
105   Dealer, Inc.     Cir. 2003).   7/29/2003   AI      Texas       Eastern District         Minton              Texas


      McNeil-PPC,       337 F.3d
       Inc. v. L.      1362 (Fed.
103   Perrigo Co.      Cir. 2003).   8/1/2003    AI   Pennsylvania Eastern District        McNeil-PPC Jersey (Johnson & Johnson Parent)
                                                                                                  New
       Schering
       Corp. v.         339 F.3d
       Geneva          1373 (Fed.
104     Pharm.         Cir. 2003).   8/1/2003    AI   New Jersey         District         Schering Corp.       New Jersey
                       2003 WL
        Glick v.       21805258
         United        (Fed. Cir.
       States Toy       Aug. 5,
233       Co.            2003).      8/5/2003    AI     Missouri Western District           Eileen Glick        New York
                       2003 WL
        Scholle        21805248
        Corp. v.       (Fed. Cir.
       Packaging        Aug. 5,
234      Sys.            2003).      8/5/2003    AI        California Central District       Scholle Corp           California
                       2003 WL
       Spectronix      21911243
         Ltd. v.       (Fed. Cir.
        Detector        Aug. 11,
232      Elecs.          2003).      8/6/2003    AI       Minnesota        District           Spectronix              Israel


        Hewlett-
      Packard Co.       340 F.3d
       v. Mustek       1314 (Fed.
101     Sys.Inc.       Cir. 2003).   8/7/2003    AI        California Southern District   Hewlett-Packard Co        California

       Submarine
        Pipeline
        Spoilers       2003 WL
      (U.S.A.), Inc.   21949843
         v. Shell      (Fed. Cir.
       Exploration      Aug. 11,
231    & Prod. Co.       2003).      8/11/2003   AI         Texas     Southern DistrictSubmarine Pipeline Spolers    Alabama
      Bayer AG v.       340 F.3d
        Housey         1367 (Fed.
100   Pharm., Inc.     Cir. 2003).   8/22/2003   AI        Delaware        District            Housey                Michigan

        Honeywell
       Intern., Inc.
            v.
      International     341 F.3d
          Trade        1332 (Fed.
99    Commission       Cir. 2003).   8/26/2003   International Trade Commission
                                                 AI                         ITC               Honeywell             New Jersey
       Jansen v.
        Rexall          342 F.3d
       Sundown,        1329 (Fed.
96       Inc.          Cir. 2003).   9/8/2003    AI         Indiana Southern District          Jansen                Indiana
      Turn-Key-        2003 WL
      Tech, LLC.       22097823
      V. National      (Fed. Cir.
      Film Lab.,        Sep. 8,
97        Inc.           2003).      9/8/2003    AI        California Central District      Turn-Key-Tech           California


      Alloc, Inc. v.
      International     342 F.3d
          Trade        1361 (Fed.
95      Comm'n         Cir. 2003).   9/10/2003   International Trade Commission
                                                 AI                         ITC                  Alloc              Wisconsin
                        2003 WL
      Phonometric       22129271
       s, Inc. v.       (Fed. Cir.
      Marriott Int'l,    Sep. 11,
230       Inc.            2003).      9/11/2003   AI      Florida   Southern District      Phonometrics, Inc           Florida
                        2003 WL
                        22203775
                        (Fed. Cir.
      Pieczenik v.       Sep. 23,
68    Dyax Corp.          2003).      9/12/2003   AI   Massachusetts     District              Pieczenik              New York
                        2003 WL
                        22148905
       Accuscan,        (Fed. Cir.
      Inc. v. Xerox      Sep. 17,
91        Corp.           2003).      9/17/2003   AI     New York Southern District            Accuscan                Georgia
                        2003 WL
         Senior         22148908
      Tech., Inc. v.    (Fed. Cir.
       R.F. Tech.,       Sep. 17,                                                   Senior Tech (Stanley Works
92        Inc.            2003).      9/17/2003   AI     Nebraska        District             Parent)          Connecticut

         Medical
      Instrumentati
           on &
       Diagnostics       344 F.3d
         Corp. v.       1205 (Fed.                                                      Medical Instrumentation &
90      Elekta AB       Cir. 2003).   9/22/2003   AI     California Southern District         Diagnostics               N/A
        AK Steel
        Corp. v.         344 F.3d
        Sollac &        1234 (Fed.
89       Ugine          Cir. 2003).   9/23/2003   AI       Ohio     Southern District        AK Steel Corp.             Ohio
                        2003 WL
                        22229094
      Okor v. Atari     (Fed. Cir.
        Games            Sep. 26,
87       Corp.            2003).      9/26/2003   AI   Massachusetts     District         Joseph Kwame Okor         Massachusetts



         ACCO
      Brand, Inc. v.     346 F.3d
       Micro Sec.       1075 (Fed.                                                        Acco Brands (Fortune
85    Devices, Inc.     Cir. 2003).   10/7/2003   AI     California Northern District        Brands Parent)            Illinois
       Genzyme
        Corp. v.
      Transkaryoti       346 F.3d
      c Therapies,      1094 (Fed.
84        Inc.          Cir. 2003).   10/9/2003   AI     Delaware        District           Genzyme Corp.           Massachusetts
        Evident    2003 WL
        Corp. v.   22332115
       Church &    (Fed. Cir.
228    Dwight Co. Oct. 9, 2003).     10/9/2003    AI    New Jersey         District           Evident Corp.       New Jersey
                       2003 WL
                       22435261
      Senior Indus.    (Fed. Cir.
      v. Thomas &       Oct. 24,
227    Betts Corp.       2003).      10/24/2003   AI       Illinois    Northern District     Senior Industries       Illinois
      Talbert Sys.
      Patents Co.       347 F.3d
       v. Unocal       1355 (Fed.
83       Corp.         Cir. 2003).   10/28/2003   AI     California Central District       Talbert Fuel Systems   Pennsylvania
      Vivid Image      2003 WL
      Tech., Inc. v.   22514518
          Jack         (Fed. Cir.
       Guttman,         Nov. 4,
226       Inc.           2003).      11/4/2003    AI     9th Circuit         N/A            Jack Guttman Inc.         Ohio
                       2003 WL
                       22701291
       Fulhorst v.     (Fed. Cir.
      Toyota Motor      Nov. 12,
225      Corp.           2003).      11/12/2003   AI       Texas       Eastern District      George Fluhorst       California
       Combined
      Sys., Inc. v.
        Defense         350 F.3d
      Tech. Corp.      1207 (Fed.
79       of Am.        Cir. 2003).   11/20/2003   AI     New York Southern District        Combined Systems        New York
        Geneva
      Pharm., Inc.
            v           349 F.3d
      Glaxosmithkl     1373 (Fed.                                                            Glaxosmithkline
78      ine PLC        Cir. 2003).   11/21/2003   AI      Virginia     Eastern District     (GlaxoSmithKline)     Great Britain
                       2003 WL
       Backyard        22839337
      Nature Prod.     (Fed. Cir.
      V. Woodlink,      Nov. 26,
76        Ltd.           2003).      11/26/2003   AI     Wisconsin Eastern District Backyard Nature Products       Wisconsin
                       2003 WL
      Soitec, S.A.     22839338
       v. Silicon      (Fed. Cir.
       Genesis          Nov. 26,
77       Corp.           2003).      11/26/2003   AI   Massachusetts       District            Soitec, S.A.         France


        Ferguson        350 F.3d
       Beauregard      1327 (Fed.
74    v. Mega Sys.     Cir. 2003).   12/4/2003    AI       Texas       Eastern District    Dover Resources, Inc    New York
      Novo Indus.       350 F.3d
       V. Micro        1348 (Fed.
73    Molds Corp.      Cir. 2003).     12/5/2003    AI    Florida   Southern District            Novo              California
                        2003 WL
          In re         22928658
       Manchak          (Fed. Cir.
        Patent           Dec. 9,
72     Litigation         2003).       12/9/2003    AI   Delaware        District           Frank Manchak          California
                        2003 WL
                        22961192
      Epic Metals       (Fed. Cir.
        Corp. v.         Dec. 9,
224   Consol. Sys.        2003).       12/9/2003    AI    Florida    Middle District          Epic Metals        Pennsylvania
                        2003 WL
                        22977470
       Specialty        (Fed. Cir.
      Rental Tools       Dec. 17,                                                     Specialty Rental Tools &
69     v. Boyds           2003).       12/17/2003   AI    Texas     Southern District          Supply                Texas
      Scimed Life       2004 WL
      Sys., Inc. v.    94096 (Fed.
      Johnson &        Cir. Jan. 14,                                                    Scimed Life Systems, Inc.
67     Johnson            2004).       1/14/2004    AI   Delaware        District          (Parent Boston Sci)    Massachusetts
                        2004 WL
      Hemphill v.      74620 (Fed.
       Proctor &       Cir. Jan. 15,
66    Gamble Co.          2004).       1/15/2004    AI   Maryland        District           Allegra Hemphill       Maryland


          Minka        2004 WL
      Lighting, Inc. 506587 (Fed.
      v. Craftmade Cir. Jan. 16,
65     Intern., Inc.    2004).         1/16/2004    AI    Texas     Northern District     Minka Lighting, Inc.     California
          PSC
       Computer
      Prod., Inc. v.    355 F.3d
        Foxconn        1353 (Fed.                                                       PSC Computer Products,
63     Inter., Inc.    Cir. 2004).     1/20/2004    AI   California Central District        Inc. (Hoovers)         California


          Glaxo
       Wellcome,        356 F.3d
      Inc. v. Impax    1348 (Fed.                                                         Glaxo Wellcome, Inc.
61      Lab., Inc.     Cir. 2004).     1/29/2004    AI   California Northern District      (GlaxoSmithKline)      Great Britain
      Epcon Gas
      Sys., Inc. v.   2004 WL
        Bauer       232089 (Fed.
      Compressor Cir. Feb. 2,
60      s, Inc         2004).           2/2/2004    AI   Michigan Eastern District        Epcon Gas Sys., Inc.     Michigan
       Microsoft
     Corp. v. Multi- 357 F.3d
      Tech. Sys.     1340 (Fed.
59       Inc.        Cir, 2004).     2/3/2004    AI       Minnesota        District         Multi-Tech Systems          Minnesota


     Nomos Corp.        357 F.3d
      v. Brainlab      1364 (Fed.                                                        Nomos Corp. (N. American
58     USA, Inc.       Cir. 2004).   2/4/2004    AI       Delaware         District             Scientific)             California


       Univ. of
     Rochester v. 358 F.3d 916
     G.D. Searle    (Fed. Cir.
57    & Co., Inc.     2004).         2/13/2004   AI       New York Western District University of Rochester             New York


       Chef Am.,        358 F.3d
     Inc. v. Lamb-     1371 (Fed.                                                        Chef Am., Inc. (Now Hand-
55   Weston, Inc.      Cir. 2004).   2/20/2004   AI        Colorado        District                Held)                Colorado


       Mycogen
         Plant       2004 WL
     Science, Inc. 363344 (Fed.
     v. Monsanto Cir. Feb. 20,                                                       Mycogen Plant Science, Inc.
56        Co.         2004).         2/20/2004   AI       California Southern District (Dow Chemical Parent)            Michigan


                     2004 WL
                   386590 (Fed.
       Colida v.    Cir. Mar. 2,
53   Ericsson, Inc    2004).         3/2/2004    AI     North CarolinaEastern District         Tony Colida               Canada
      Q-Pharm.,
        Inc. v.         360 F.3d
       Andrew          1295 (Fed.
52   Jergens Co.       Cir. 2004).   3/8/2004    AI      Washington Western District          Q-Pharma, Inc.           Switzerland
     Int’l Rectifier    361 F.3d
        Corp. v.       1363 (Fed.
51    IXYS Corp.       Cir. 2004).   3/18/2004   AI       California Central District International Rectifier Corp.     California
       Premier
      Networks,     2004 WL
        Inc. v.   578396 (Fed.
     Lucent Tech. Cir. Mar. 22,
50       Inc.        2004).          3/22/2004   AI         Illinois   Northern District Premier Networks, Inc.         New York
     Kinik Co. v.       362 F.3d
     Intl’ Trade       1359 (Fed.
49     Com’n           Cir. 2004).   3/25/2004   International Trade Commission Commission
                                                 AI             International Trade                 3M                  Minnesota
       Summit
     Tech., Inc. v.     363 F.3d
      Nidek Co.,       1219 (Fed.
48       Ltd.          Cir. 2004).   3/26/2004   AI     Massachusetts      District         Summit Tech., Inc.        Massachusetts
       Dynacore
       Holdings         363 F.3d
      Corp. v. U.S.    1263 (Fed.
46    Phillips Corp    Cir. 2004).    3/31/2004   AI     New York Southern District Dynacore Holdings Corp.           Texas
                        363 F.3d
        Gaus v.        1284 (Fed.
45    Conair Corp.     Cir. 2004).    4/1/2004    AI     New York Southern District            Harry Gaus            Germany


        Novartis
      Pharm. Corp.      363 F.3d
      v. Eon Labs      1306 (Fed.                                                        Novartis Pharmceuticals
44     Mfg., Inc.      Cir. 2004).    4/2/2004    AI     Delaware        District                 Corp.             Switzerland



      Knopik v. BP 2004 WL
       Products       842668
         North      (Fed.Cir. Apr
222   America, Inc. 07, 2004).        4/7/2004    AI     Minnesota       District                Knopik              Minnesota

      C.M.L. s.r.l.
        v. Ineco
       Industrial
      Navarra de        2004 WL
      Equipos y          842660
      Comercio,       (Fed.Cir. Apr
220       S.A.         13, 2004).     4/13/2004   AI     Maryland        District               CML s.r.l              Italy


       Databurst,       2004 WL
        LLC v.           842653
       Checkfree      (Fed.Cir. Apr
219      Corp.         15, 2004).     4/15/2004   AI      Illinois   Northern District       Databurst LLC            Illinois


      Leoutsakos   2004 WL
       v. Coll’s   1010162
        Hosp.      (Fed. Cir.
42    Pharm., Inc May 4, 2004).       5/4/2004    AI   New Hempshire     District          Thomas Leoutsakos       Massachusetts


            Ta          2004 WL
       Instruments,     1009635
      Inc. v. Perkin- (Fed.Cir. May
218    Elmer Corp.      5, 2004).     5/5/2004    AI     Delaware        District          TA Instruments, Inc.      Delaware
        Housey
      Pharm., Inc.
           v.           366 F.3d
      Astrazeneca      1348 (Fed.                                                        Housey Pharmaceuticals,
41      UK Ltd.        Cir. 2004).    5/7/2004    AI     Delaware        District                 Inc.               Michigan
       Boyd's Bit
      Service, Inc.
      v. Speciality 2004 WL
      Rental Tools   1153055
       & Supply, (Fed.Cir. May
216       Inc.      10, 2004).        5/10/2004   AI     Louisiana Western District        Boyd's Bit Services       Louisiana


                      2004 WL
      Braun Corp.      1153429
      v. Maxon Lift (Fed.Cir. May
215       Corp.       17, 2004).      5/17/2004   AI      Indiana   Northern District          Braun Corp.            Indiana


        Edwards         2004 WL
       Sys. Tech.,      1153662
      Inc. v. Digital   (Fed. Cir.
      Control Sys.,      May 18,
40         Inc.           2004).      5/18/2004   AI      Oregon          District                          Inc.
                                                                                         Edwards Sys. Tech.,North Carolina (SPX Parent)

                        2004 WL
                        1194245
      VLT, Inc. v.      (Fed. Cir.
       Artesyn           May 24,
39    Tech., Inc.         2004).      5/24/2004   AI   Massachusetts      District              VLT, Inc.         Massachusetts


                   2004 WL
      Bauer v. CD   1194249
      Repairman, (Fed.Cir. May
213      Inc.      27, 2004).         5/27/2004   AI      Arizona         District            Jason Bauer             Arizona
       Jacobs v.         370 F.3d
      Nintendo of       1097 (Fed.
38     Am., Inc.        Cir. 2004).   5/28/2004   AI      Florida      Middle District   Jordan Spencer Jacobs        Florida
       W.E. Hall
      Co., Inc. v.
        Atlanta          370 F.3d
      Corrugating,      1343 (Fed.
37        LLC           Cir. 2004).   6/7/2004    AI      Georgia Northern District         W.E. Hall Co., Inc.         N/A


       Animatics       2004 WL
        Corp. v.       1375690
       Quicksilver     (Fed. Cir.
36    Controls, Inc. Jun. 8, 2004).   6/8/2004    AI     California Northern District        Animatics Corp.         California
      Chiron Corp.
           v.            363 F.3d
      Genentech,        1247 (Fed.
47        Inc.          Cir. 2004).   6/8/2004    AI     California Eastern District          Chiron Corp.           California
       For Your
      Ease Only,
        Inc. v.
        Natural         2004 WL
       Science           1378609
      Industries,     (Fed.Cir. Jun
211      Ltd.           14, 2004).    6/14/2004   AI      Illinois   Northern District      For your ease only             N/A

      Halliburton
        Energy
       Services,    2004 WL
         Inc. v.     1378626
      Weatherford (Fed.Cir. Jun.
212   Intern., Inc. 14, 2004).        6/14/2004   AI      Texas      Northern District Halliburton Energy, Inc.          Oklahoma
      TI Group v.       375 F.3d
      VDO N. Am.       1126 (Fed.
33        LLC          Cir. 2004).    6/30/2004   AI     Delaware        District        TI Group Automotive Sys.        Michigan
       Seafoss v.
        Pioneer         374 F.3d
        Consol.        1142 (Fed.
32       Corp.         Cir. 2004).    7/6/2004    AI     Michigan Eastern District               Searfoss                Michigan


                      2004 WL
       McNulty v.     1565497
      Taser Intern, (Fed. Cir. Jul.
31        Inc.        7, 2004).       7/7/2004    AI     California Central District      James F. McNulty, Jr.            N/A
      Pellegrini v.
        Analog          375 F.3d
       Devices,        1113 (Fed.
29        Inc.,        Cir. 2004).    7/8/2004    AI   Massachusetts     District            Gerald Pellegrini         Massachusetts
        Novartis
      Pharm Corp.       375 F.3d
       v. Abbott       1328 (Fed.                                                        Novartis Pharmceuticals
30        Lab.         Cir. 2004).    7/8/2004    AI     Delaware        District                 Corp.                 Switzerland

           Dane
       Industries,
          Inc. v.       2004 WL
         Ameritek       1563391
        Industries    (Fed.Cir. Jul
209        LLC.        09, 2004).     7/9/2004    AI     Minnesota       District             Dane Industries            Minnesota


      Keytrak, Inc.   2004 WL
      v. Key Trak     1563399
        Western     (Fed.Cir. Jul
210    Div., Inc.    09, 2004).       7/9/2004    AI      Georgia Northern District            Keytrak, Inc.              Texas


        Unitherm
       Food Sys.,       375 F.3d
      Inc. v. Swift    1341 (Fed.                                                        Swift Eckrich, Inc. (parent
28    Eckrich, Inc.    Cir. 2004).    7/12/2004   AI     Oklahoma Western District               ConAgra)                Nebraska
         Pacific
      Intern. Tool      2004 WL
       & Shear v.       1637924
      Certainteed     (Fed.Cir. Jul                                                      Pacific International Tools &
208      Corp.         13, 2004).     7/13/2004   AI       Washington Western District            Shear, Ltd.          Washington
         Elster
       Electricity  2004 WL
         LLC v.      1799400
      Schlumberge (Fed. Cir. Jul.
26     rsema Inc    30, 2004).        7/30/2004   AI        Delaware        District        Elster Electricity LLC   North Carolina
       NeoMagic         2004 WL
        Corp. v.       1799404
        Trident        (Fed. Cir.
      Microsystem       Aug. 05,
25         s,            2004).       8/5/2004    AI        Delaware        District          NeoMagic Corp            California
          Sony
       Electronics 2004 WL
           v.       1878346
       Soundview (Fed.Cir. Aug
207       Tech.    11, 2004).         8/11/2004   AI       Connecticut      District          Soundview Tech           Colorado


          Power        378 F.3d
      Mosfet Tech.    1396 (Fed.
23     v. Siemens     Cir. 2004).     8/17/2004   AI         Texas       Eastern District Power Mosfet Tech. LLC         Texas
       Koito Mfg.
       Co. v. Turn     381 F.3d
       Key Tech.,     1142 (Fed.
22        LLC         Cir. 2004).     8/23/2004   AI        California Southern District       Turn-Key-Tech           California


       Toro Co. v.
         White         383 F.3d.
      Consolidated    1326 (Fed.
18    Indus., Inc.,   Cir. 2004).     9/13/2004   AI       Minnesota        District              Toro Co.             Minnesota


         Irdeto
      Access, Inc.
      v. Echostar      383 F.3d.
       Satellite,     1295 (Fed.
17        Inc.,       Cir. 2004).     9/14/2004   AI        Colorado        District         Irdeto Access, Inc.
                                                                                                              South Africa (Naspers Parent)



      Gemstar-TV
      Guide Intern,
          Inc. v.
      International    383 F.3d.
          Trade       1352 (Fed.                                                     Gemstar-TV Guide Intern.,
15    Commission,     Cir. 2004).     9/16/2004   International Trade Commission Commission
                                                  AI             International Trade          Inc.                     California
                       2004 WL
                       2245225
                       (Fed. Cir.
       Ghaly v.         Sep. 29,
14    Hasbro, Inc.       2004).       9/29/2004   AI    New York Eastern District             Nabil Ghaly           New York


      Astrazeneca      384 F.3d
      AB v. Mutual    1333 (Fed.
13    Pharm. Co.      Cir. 2004).     9/30/2004   AI   Pennsylvania Eastern District       Astrazeneca AB          Great Britain


       Budde v.       2004 WL
        Harley-        2288149
       Davidson,      (Fed. Cir.
12       Inc.        Oct. 5, 2004).   10/5/2004   AI    California Northern District       William A. Budde         California
        Spotless
      Enterprises,  2004 WL
      Inc. v. A & E  2370617
        Products (Fed.Cir. Oct
204    Group L.P.   12, 2004). 10/12/2004         AI    New York Eastern District Spotless Plastics Pty. Ltd.        Australia
        Kustom
      Signals, Inc. 2004 WL
       v. Applied    2370634
       Concepts, (Fed.Cir. Oct
201       Inc.      15, 2004). 10/15/2004         AI     Kansas         District         Kustom Signals, Inc.        Kansas


      ICON Health
       & Fitness,    2004 WL
         Inc. v.     2383192
       Sportcraft, (Fed.Cir. Oct
200       Ltd.      20, 2004). 10/20/2004         AI   New Jersey       District       ICON Health & Fitness Inc       Utah
                       2004 WL
                       2470017
                       (Fed. Cir.
       Colida v.        Nov. 3,
10    Matsushita         2004).       11/3/2004   AI   New Jersey       District             Tony Colida             Canada


                     2004 WL
                      2550421
       Ishida Co., (Fed.Cir. Nov
199   Ltd. v. Taylor 03, 2004).       11/3/2004   AI    California Northern District        Alfred A. Taylor         Australia


      Postx Corp.    2004 WL
       v. Secure     2711066
        Data in    (Fed.Cir. Nov
197   Motion, Inc. 15, 2004). 11/15/2004          AI    California Northern District      PostX Corporation         California
                       2004 WL
        Catalina       2633316
      Marketing v.     (Fed. Cir.
      Coolsavings.      Nov. 19,
9        com             2004).       11/19/2004   AI      Illinois   Northern District    Catalina Marketing        Florida

         Frank’s
       casing crew
        & rental v.
       Weatherford      389 F.3d.
      International,   1370 (Fed.                                                   Frank's Casing Crew &
7          Inc.        Cir. 2004).    11/30/2004   AI     Oklahoma Western District         Rental                  Louisiana
                       2004 WL
        Kyocrea        2712421
       Wireless v.     (Fed. Cir.
        President       Nov. 30,
8      Electronics       2004).       11/30/2004   AI     California Southern District    President Electronics      France
                       2004 WL
                       2757399
                       (Fed. Cir.
        Colida v.       Dec. 2,
6        Sanyo           2004).       12/2/2004    AI     California Southern District        Tony Colida            Canada


       Centricut,       390 F.3d.
      LLC v. ESAB      1361 (Fed.
1      Group, Inc.     Cir. 2004).    12/6/2004    AI   New Hempshire     District            Esab Group          South Carolina
       Iron Grip
      Barbell Co.       392 F.3d
        v. USA         1317 (Fed.
4     Sports, Inc.     Cir. 2004)..   12/14/2004   AI     California Central District     Iron Grip Barbell Co      California


           Orbit
        Irrigation    2004 WL
        Products,     2982917
       Inc. v. L.R. (Fed.Cir. Dec
196   Nelson Corp. 17, 2004). 12/17/2004           AI       Utah          District         L.R. Nelson Corp.          Illinois
                       2004 WL
       Anheuser-       2980491
      Busch Co. v.     (Fed. Cir.
      Crown Cork        Dec. 23,
5       & Seal          2004)..       12/23/2004   AI     Wisconsin Western District Crown Cork & Seal Tech.      Pennsylvania
HO WINS PATENT CASES?, 34 AIPLA Q.J. 1 (WINTER 2006)

                                                 Patentee
                   Patentee                     Nationality                                                   AI Rev. in
      Patentee    Rev. in 2003     Patentee     Based on     Accused                                           2003 or
       Entity      or Latest        Income       Parent if Infringer (AI)                        AI Entity     Latest         AI Income        AI
       Nature     Known Year       Category     Applicable       ID       AI HQ State             Nature     Known Year       Category     Nationality




                                                                                                                  latest
                       latest                                                                                   reported
                    reported                                                                                    accused
                   patentee or          0=                                                                    infringer or         0=
                      parent       individual; S                                                                 parent       individual; S
                   corporation    = $1 - $1MM;                                                                corporation    = $1 - $1MM;
                      annual       M = $1MM -                                  state where                       annual       M = $1MM -
                   revenue in      100MM; L =                                 the accused                     revenue in      100MM; L =
                  dollars (MM =     $100MM -                                  infringer's or                 dollars (MM =     $100MM - nationality of
                   million US     $1000MM; LL nationality of                      parent                       million US    $1000MM; LL accused
         1=        dollar; B =    = >$1000MM patentee or          name of     corporation's         1=         dollar; B =   = >$1000MM infringer or
    corporation; 0 billion US     (MM = million   parent          accused     headquarters     corporation; 0 billion US     (MM = million   parent
     = individual    dollars)       US dollars) corporation       infringer    are located      = individual     dollars)      US dollars) corporation




          1           N/A             N/A           USA     Eisenmann Corp.      Illinois            1          24MM              M           USA




          1        22 Million          M            USA Fata Aluminium, Inc. Italy                   1          342MM             L           Italy



          1          751MM             L          Finland       Hunt Mfg. Co Pennsylvania            1          160MM             L           USA




          1        1.4 Billion         LL           USA        Beatrice Cheese (ConAgra Parent)1
                                                                        Nebraska                               16.939 B           LL          USA




          1          68MM              M          Sweden
                                                      Thermo Bioanalysis Corp Mexico
                                                                         New                         1          227MM             L           USA
1      79MM                   USA                       South Carolina
                   M Thermal Engineering Int'l (dob Boiler Tube Co. of Am.) 1    100MM       L      USA




1   6.5 Million    M           USA       Orange Bang        California     1     6.9 MM      M      USA




1     2.282 B      LL          USA
                            Ficosa N. Am. (Fiscosa International SA)
                                                            Spain          1     300MM       L      Spain




1   80.2 Million   M           USA      Catalina Lighting    Florida       1    202 MM       L      USA




1      <1MM        S           USA      Bock Specialties       N/A         1       N/A       N/A     N/A

                                                             Texas
                                                            (Kinder
                                                            Morgan
                                                            Energy
                                                            Partners
0    individual    0           USA           Shell          Parent)        1    6.624 B      LL     USA



1    35.986 B      LL        Germany     Schein Pharm (Now Watson Pharm)
                                              California              1         1.457 B      LL     USA



1    35.986 B      LL        Germany Carlsbad Tech. California             1     94 MM       M      USA




1     500MM        L           USA       Axel E. Jungk      Germany        0    individual   0     Germany



1   18.2 Billion   LL          USA       Chemque, Inc.      Canada         1     50MM        M     Canada
                                                  South
                                                 Carolina
                                               (Now part of
                                                BBA Gray
1      2.2B        LL    SwedenSuperior Nonwovens Court)             1   3.1 MM     M     USA




1     <1MM         S       USA           Winner       Pennsylvania   1    13MM      M     USA




1    1500MM        LL      USA Robinsons-May, Inc.Missouri           1   13.343 B   LL    USA



    10.1 Billion
    (Purchased
      by Clore
1   Automotive)    LL      USA Schumacker Elec. Corp.llinois
                                                    I                1   85 MM      M     USA




0    individual    0         A
                           USAngel-Etts of California, California
                                                       Inc.          1   1.7 MM     M     USA




1   16.5 Million   M       USA        Lextron, Inc.    Colorado      1   340 MM     L     USA




1    24.864 B      LL   Switzerlandausch & Lomb, Inc.New York
                                  B                                  1   2.019 B    LL    USA




1     26MM         M       USA
                           Chaparral Networks Storage, Inc.
                                                    Colorado         1     N/A      N/A   USA
1   8.5 Billion,   LL          S
                         Germany chering-Plough Corp Jersey
                                                  New               1    8.334 B    LL    USA




0   individual     0      USA
                          XL Sys. Inc. (V=Grant Prideco Inc)
                                                      Texas         1    >1000MM    LL    USA




1     20MM         M      USA Clean Shot Tech., Inc. N/A            1      N/A      N/A   N/A




1    1.682 B       LL     USA        Micromass
                                         Massachusetts (Waters Parent)
                                                                    1    723 MM     L     USA




1      N/A         N/A     N/A      Propet USA       Washington     1     20 MM     M     USA




1    500MM         L      USAPioneer Hi-Bred (DuPont)
                                                  Delaware          1    >1000MM    LL    USA




0   individual     0      USA     RAM Southwest         N/A         1      N/A      N/A   N/A




1     25MM         M      USA      Tigress Trading     Florida      1     <1MM      S     USA




1    185 MM        L                   Merck         New Jersey     1    22.485 B   LL    USA
1     2.142 B      LL          USA        Halliburton      Texas           1   16.271 B   LL       USA




1   28 Million     M           USA        Libman Co.       Illinois        1    48 MM     M        USA




1     60MM                   USA
                   M United States Surgical Systems (Tyco International)
                                                       Bermuda             1   >1000MM    LL    Bermuda




1   1.33 Billion   LL          USA Silicon Storage Tech
                                                      California           1   86.5 MM    M        USA




1   161 Million    L            Cable
                               USA & Wireless Internet Serv.
                                                    Great Britain          1   6,672MM    LL   Great Britain




1    67 Million    M           USA     Bridgeport FittingsConnecticut      1    19 MM     M        USA




1    22.442 B      LL                         Missouri
                              France DeKalb Genetics (Now Monsanto) 1          4.910 B    LL       USA




1    2.0 Billion   LL          USA Sanyo North America (US Parent)
                                                California                 1   10.083 B   LL       USA




1   22.4 Billion   M           USA           Teva (Teve Pharm Indus Parent)
                                             Israel                     1      3.276 B    LL      Israel
1   3.38 Billion    LL          USA        Genesearch      Australia         1      N/A       N/A    Australia




1   27.1 Million    M           USA      Graphic Controls (Tyco Intl Parent) 1
                                                  Bermuda                         36.801 B    LL     Bermuda



1      15MM         M         Sweeden      Harris Corp      Florida          1     2.060 B    LL       USA




1    >1000MM        LL      Great Britain
                                   Andrx/Genpharm/Cheminor
                                                        Florida              1     1.046 B    LL       USA



1     .73MM         S           USA Wal-Mart Stores, Inc. rkansas
                                                        A                    1    229.616 B   LL       USA



1   1.496 Billion   LL          USA        Deere & Co.      Illinois         1    15.535 B    LL       USA




1    45 Billion     LL          USADr. Reddy's Laboratories Jersey
                                                       New                   1    122 MM      L        USA




1     200MM         L           USA        Hellweg Int'l   Australia         1      N/A       N/A    Australia




0    individual                 USA                         Goergia
                    0 Glenayre Electronics (subsidy of Glenayre Technologies) 1    58MM       M        USA




1      90 B         LL        Germany
                              Vanderlande Industries Nederland BV
                                                        Netherlands          1    335 MM      L     Netherlands




1     12.4MM        M           USA Behringer Saws, Inc. Texas               1     2.5MM      M        USA
1       N/A        N/A        USA Laboratory Corporation Carolina
                                                    North                  1   2.9 Billilon   LL     USA




1       N/A        N/A        N/A       JSP Footwear New Jersey            1      N/A         N/A    USA




1   35.7 Billion   LL     Great Britain Apotex Corp.        Florida        1     2.3 B        LL     USA




1   4.96 Billion   LL         USA
                         Safety 1st, Inc. (parent Dorel Industries Inc.)
                                                           Canada          1    1,164MM       LL    Canada




1    543.6MM       L          USA      MathWorks, Inc.
                                                     Massachusetts         1    111 MM        L      USA




1   185.4 MM       L          USA GSE Lining Tech., Inc. Texas             1     274 M        L      USA




1   487.2 MM       L          USA CAT Contracting, Inc. Illinois           1    21.048 B      LL     USA




1    1100MM        LL         USA
                               Universal Surveillance Sys., Inc.
                                                        California         1     10MM         M      USA




1      1.4 B       LL         USA         US Surgical
                                                Bermuda (Tyco Intl Parent) 1   >1000MM        LL     USA



1   47,000MM       LL         USA         Mylan Lab      Pennsylvania      1   > 1,000 MM     LL     USA



1      5MM         M          USA           Ag-Bag          Oregon         1    21.5 MM       M      USA
1       N/A       N/A       USA Research in Motion, Inc,
                                                      Canada        1   600MM     L    Canada




1    3.138 B      LL        USA S.C. Johnson & SonWisconsin         1   1.134 B   LL    USA



1   613 Million   L         USA        Entact, Inc.     Texas       1    14 MM    M     USA




1     10MM        M         USA        Dana Corp         Ohio       1   >1000MM   LL    USA




1    12.2MM       M               C
                        South Korea olt's Mfg. Co., Inc.
                                                      Connecticut   1    48 MM    M     USA




1   $113,000      S         USA
                             Standard Microsystems Corp.York
                                                   New              1    84 MM    M     USA




1   2.5 Million   M           U
                            USAnited Systems of Arkansas
                                                     Arkansas       1    3 MM     M     USA




1     79MM        M     Liechtenstein Switchcraft       Illinois    1    30 MM    M     USA




0    individual   0         USA     Sega of America     Japan       1    37 MM    M    Japan




0    individual   0         USA       I/O Concepts Washington       1    2.6MM    M     USA
1    41.862 B      LL        USA      R.E. Service Co California      1     N/A      N/A    USA




1   1.3 Million    M         USA Cargo Systems, Inc.
                                                  Connecticut         1   4.8 MM     M      USA




1     <1MM         S         USA Silverline Building Prod. Jersey
                                                       New            1   1000MM     LL     USA




0   individual     0         USA Casio Phonemate, Inc. Japan          1   >1000MM    LL    Japan



1     <1MM         S         USA           Intel       California     1   30.141 B   LL     USA




1    164MM         L         USA USA Instruments, Inc. Ohio           1     N/A      N/A    USA




1    1.8 MM        M         USA Trident Microsystems
                                                    California        1   52.7 MM    M      USA



1   18.2 Billion   LL        USA         Barr Lab.    Pennsylvania    1   2.6 MM     M      USA




0   individual     0         USA
                        Bayshore Concrete Prod. (parent Skanska AB)
                                                        Sweden        1   17.035 B   LL    Sweden




1     <1MM         S         USA        Blistex Inc      Illinois     1    59MM      M      USA
0    individual     0           USA Sony Computer Am. Japan                 1    747B     LL   Japan




1       1MM         M           USA      W.W. Wood Inc. Missouri            1   100MM     L     USA




1     826 MM        L                            Tech. Corp
                                USACable DesignIllinois (Now Belden Cdt Inc)1   484 MM    L     USA




1     1.634 B       LL          USA
                          Kvaerner Oilfield Products, Inc. (Kvaerner ASA)
                                                              Norway        1   1.937 B   LL   Norway




1   773.6 Million   L              R
                              Canada &D Tool & Engineering
                                                         Missouri           1   59MM      M     USA




1     41.862 B      LL          USA     Home Diagnostics Florida            1   40 MM     M     USA




1      .25MM        S           USA Frank's Casing CrewLouisiana            1   54 MM     M     USA




1       N/A         N/A       Australia Hale Propeller LLCConnecticut       1   2.5MM     M     USA
1     2MM        M        USA               HP         California      1      >1000MM    LL    USA




1    1.8 MM      M        USA    Ideal Mfg. & Sales Wisconsin          1      1.8 MM     M     USA




0   individual   0        USA           Netscape
                                           New York (Time Warner Parent)
                                                                      1       39.565 B   LL    USA




1   3.698 B      LL       USA St. Jude Medical, Inc.
                                                  Minnesota            1      1.499 B    LL    USA




0   individual   0        USA
                            CPI-The Alternative Supplier
                                      California (CPI International Parent)
                                                                       1      7.1 MM     M     USA




1    50MM        M      Canada Revolution EyewearCalifornia            1        N/A      N/A   USA




1    31MM        M        USA        Mizuno USA Inc.     Japan         1      >1000MM    LL    Japan




1      N/A       N/A   Switzerland          3M         Minnesota       1      >1000MM    LL    USA




1   117 MM       L        USA        Novellus Sys. Inc California      1      925 MM     L     USA
1   2.5 Million    M         USA      Vermeer Mfg.     Iowa         1   173 MM    L     USA




1      N/A         N/A       USA Powerscreen of 'Am.
                                                  Connecticut       1   3,897MM   LL    USA




1   20 Million     M         USA
                         RBTACQ, Inc. (parent Russ Berrie &Jersey
                                                     New Co Inc.)   1   266MM     L     USA




1   35.7 Billion   LL     Great Britain
                                    Copley Pharmceutical
                                                   Massachusetts    1   133 MM    L     USA




1   >1000MM        LL        USA      Sunrise Farms    Iowa         1    6 MM     M     USA




1     83 MM        M         USA      Creo Products   Canada        1   650MM     L    Canada




1    7.246 B       LL      Germany Eastman ChemicalTennessee        1   5.800 B   LL    USA




1   5.07 Billion   LL      Denmark Becton DickinsonNew Jersey       1   4.527 B   LL    USA




1    352 MM        L         USA    Karsten Mfg. Corp. Arizona      1   159MM     L     USA




1     2.5MM        M         USA All Dental Prodx, LLC Jersey
                                                     New            1    1MM      M     USA
1    156MM       L         USA     Adams USA Inc. Tennessee         1      2MM      M      USA




0   individual   0         USA     Sonoco Prod. Co.
                                                 South Carolina     1     >1000MM   LL     USA




1    500MM       L         USA
                            Monitor Temperature Recording
                                                      N/A           N/A     N/A     N/A    N/A




0   individual   0           Coll's
                           USA Hospital Pharmacy, Inc
                                             New Hampshire          1     1.4 MM    M      USA




0   individual   0         USA    Conexant Systems California       1     599 MM    L      USA




0   individual   0         USA
                            American National RedPennsylvania
                                                  Cross             1      .55MM    S      USA




0   individual   0         USA     Sonoco Prod. Co.
                                                 South Carolina     1     >1000MM   LL     USA




1      N/A       N/A                      Missouri
                         Belgium DeKalb Genetics (Now Monsanto) 1         4.910 B   LL     USA




1   45.188 B     LL        USA       Apotex Corp.     Canada        1     2.375 B   LL    Canada



0   individual   0        USA
                       Baystate Tech., Inc. (parent Kubotek Corp)
                                                        Japan       1      47MM     M     Japan
1    27.0 MM        M     USA      Perclose,Illinois (Now Abbot Labs) 1
                                              Inc.                        19.680 B   LL    USA




1      10MM         M     USA
                           BenchMark Manufacturing Texas
                                                   Inc.              1     20MM      M     USA




1      <1MM         S     USA Palmero Health Care
                                               Connecticut           1     1MM       M     USA




1      <1MM         S     USA       Westin Hotel   New York          1    45 MM      M     USA




1      3.0 B        LL    USA       Novo Indus.    California        1    .12MM      S     USA




1     1.3MM         M    Canada
                              Eliminator Pigging Sys.Texas           1      N/A      N/A   USA



1    30.141 B       LL    USA      VIA Tech., Inc. California        1    32 MM      M     USA




1   105.8 Million   L     USA      Customs Seal       Ohio           1    2.1 MM     M     USA




0    individual     0     USA Fakespace Labs, IncCalifornia          1    1.5 MM     M     USA




0    individual     0     USA      U.S. West, Colorado (Now Qwest) 1
                                              Inc.                        14.288 B   LL    USA
0    individual    0           USA
                               General Surgicial Innovations, Inc
                                                          California       1    N/A      N/A      USA




1    19.680 B      LL          USA        Novopharm        Canada          1    20B      LL     Canada




1    31.824 B      LL          USA Space Systems/Loral ew York
                                                     N                     1   533 MM    L        USA




1   82 Million     M           USA
                                American Seating Corporation
                                                       Michigan            1   119MM     L        USA




1     119MM        L           USA
                                 Transportation Seating Co.
                                                        Georgia            1   2.5MM     M        USA



1    8.061 B       LL         USA
                        Rockwell Intern (parent Rockwell Automation Inc)
                                                          Wisconsin        1   4411MM    LL       USA




1    1.755 B       LL          USA           Alcon       Switzerland       1   3.407 B   LL    Switzerland




1   13.3 Million   M           USA        Moba, B.V.     Netherlands       1    N/A      N/A   Netherlands




0    individual    0           USA         Sealed Air    New Jersey        1   3.531 B   LL       USA




1     2.5MM        M           USA     M.E.P. CAD, Inc. Colorado           1   <1MM      S        USA
1   22.442 B      LL         France Bristol-Myers SquibbNew York         1    20.894 B     LL        USA




0   individual    0           USA Hardware Distributors N/A              1       N/A       N/A       N/A




1   1.1 Million   M           USA Atlantic Construction Virginia         1    16.2 MM      M         USA




0   individual    0             H
                              USAenkel Corp (Henkel KGaA)
                                                      Germany            1    >1000MM      LL     Germany




0   individual    0           USA
                        Michael & Deborah Doty (dob as Archer's Edge)
                                                         Maine           0    individual   S         USA




0   individual    0           USAAtlantic Richfield Co. Great Britain
                                                        (BP)             1    >1000MM      LL    Great Britain




1      N/A        N/A         USA       J.G. Peta, Inc      N/A          1       N/A       N/A       N/A




1    128 MM       L           USA         Igloo Prod called I-Prodcts Corp)
                                               TX (Now                   1    123 MM       L         USA




1   5 Million     M           USA          Ag-Bag         Oregon         1    21.5 MM      M         USA
1   1.145 B      LL     USA       Hartz Mountain New Jersey        1    57.504 B    LL      USA




1    20MM        M      USA        Micro Linear     California     1    20.6 MM     M       USA



0   individual   0      USA            Ford         Michigan       1    164.196 B   LL      USA




1     5MM        M      USA
                       Tomorrow's Resources Unlimited, Inc
                                                   Iowa            1     2.5MM      M       USA




1      N/A       N/A    USA BECKMAN COULTER
                                          California               1    >1000MM     LL      USA




1   >1000MM      LL     USA        Kubota Corp       Japan         1    >1000MM     LL     Japan




0   individual   0      USA
                        National Ass'n of SecuritiesCalifornia
                                                    Dealer         1     1.027 B    LL      USA




1   41.862 B     LL     USA           Perrigo       Michigan       1    825 MM      L       USA




1   8.334 B      LL     USA      GenevaSwitzerland (Novartis Parent)1
                                       Pharm.                           24.864 B    LL   Switzerland




0   individual   0      USA          US Toys        Missouri       1     79MM       M       USA
1    121MM        L        USA
                            Packaging Sys. (DS Smith Plc)
                                                 Great Britain        1    >1000MM    LL   Great Britain




1     15MM        M       Israel Detector ElectronicsMinnesota        1     36MM      M        USA




1   73.061 B      LL       USA           Mustek       California      1    382 MM     L        USA




1     <1MM        S     Netherlands        Shell    Netherlands       1    >1000MM    LL   Netherlands



1     <1MM        S        USA          Bayer AG      Germany         1    35.986 B   LL    Germany




1   23.103 B      LL       USA           Hyosung       Korea          1    1.690 B    LL      Korea




0   individual    0        USA        Rexall Sundown
                                                New York (NBTY Parent) 1   1.192 B    LL       USA




1      N/A        N/A      USA    National Film Lab California        1     22 MM     M        USA




1   1.6 Million   M        USA          Pergo Inc     Sweden          1    367MM      L      Sweden
1      < 1MM        S     USA      Marriott    Washington DC   1   >1000MM   LL     USA




0    individual     0     USA    Dyax Corp Massachusetts       1   16.8 MM   M      USA




1    13 Million     M     USA       Xerox        Connecticut   1   3.267 B   LL     USA




1   2.678 Billion   LL    USA     RF Tech          Maine       1   1.4 MM    M      USA




1       N/A         N/A   N/A     Elekta AB       Sweden       1   381 MM    L     Sweden




1    4.0 Billion    LL    USA   Sollac & Ugine     France      1     N/A     N/A   France




0    individual     0     USA    Atari Games      New York     1   534 MM    L      USA




1    6.2 Billion    LL    USA   Micro Security California      1   5.6 MM    M      USA




1   1.56 Billion    LL    USA   Transkaryotic Massachusetts    1    58 MM    M      USA
1       N/A        N/A      USA     Church & DwrightNew Jersey           1    >1000MM    LL      USA




1     10MM         M        USA Thomas & Betts Corp.
                                                  Tennessee              1    > 1000MM   LL      USA




1    2 Million     M        USA           Unocal       California        1     6.219 B   LL      USA




1     < 1MM        S        USA Vivid Image Tech., Inc.
                                                     California          1      2MM      M       USA




0    individual    0        USA        Toyota Motor     Japan            1    > 1000MM   LL     Japan




1   11 Million     M        USA Defense Technology Holdings Parent)
                                        Florida (Armor           1            365 MM     L       USA




1   35.7 Billion   LL                        Pharm.
                         Great Britain GenevaSwitzerland (Novartis Parent)1   24.864 B   LL   Switzerland




1   1.2 Million    M        USA          Woodlink        Iowa            1     6 MM      M       USA




1   102 Million    L       France    Silicon Genesis California          1     7 MM      M       USA




1   4.4 Billion    LL       USA       Mega Systems      Canada           1      1MM      M     Canada
1     .12MM        S        USA         Micro Mods Pennsylvania    1    1MM       M     USA




0    individual    0        USAArgonomics ManagementN/A            1     N/A      N/A   N/A




1      30MM        M        USAConsolidated Systems Inc Carolina
                                                 South             1   165MM      L     USA




1   38.6 Million   M        USA     Boyd's Bit Service Louisiana   1     N/A      N/A   USA




1   3.47 Billion   LL       USA Johnson & Johnson ew Jersey
                                                N                  1   41.862 B   LL    USA




0    individual    0        USA Proctor & Gamble Co Ohio           1   43.377 B   LL    USA




1    51 Million    M      Taiwan
                              Craftmade International Inc.
                                                        Texas      1   109 MM     L     USA




1   11.9 Million   M        USAFoxconn International Inc.
                                                      California   1   11.9 MM    M     USA




1   35.7 Billion   LL   Great Britain   Impax Lab.    California   1   58 MM      M     USA




1    1 Million     M        USA Bauer Compressors Virginia         1   31 MM      M     USA
1    61 Million    M        USA      Microsofto Corp. Washington      1   32.187 B   LL     USA




1    14.6 MM       M        USA       Brainlab USA        Illinois    1    22MM      M      USA




1    1.8 Billion   LL        Searle
                        G.D.USA & Co. (parent Phamarcia Corp
                                                  Canada              1     N/A      N/A   Canada




1   62.7 Million   M        USA    Lamb-Weston, Inc. (ConAgra Parent)1
                                          Nebraska                        16.939 B   LL     USA




1    32 Billion    LL       USA       Monsanto Co.      Missouri      1   4.910 B    LL     USA




0    individual    0      Canada         Ericsson        Sweden       1    15MM      M     Swden




1      <1MM        S    Switzerland
                         Andrew Jergens Co. (parent Kao Corp)
                                                      Japan           1   5.691 B    LL    Japan



1   864 Million    L        USA        IXYS Corp.       Callifornia   1   136 MM     L      USA




1     2.5MM        M        USA       Lucent Tech. New Jersey         1   8.470 B    LL     USA



1   18.2 Billion   LL       USA         Kinik Co.         Texas       1    48MM      M     Taiwan




1   111 Million    L    Great Britain Nidek Co., Ltd.     Japan       1   243 MM     L     Japan
1   5.4 Million   L        USA     U.S. Phillips Corp.    N/A      1   >1000MM    LL        N/A



0   individual    0      Germany Conair Corporation
                                                  New Jersey       1    1.277 B   LL        USA




1   24.864 B      LL            Eon
                        Switzerland Labs Manufacturing York
                                                    New            1   430 MM     L         USA




0   individual    0        USA BP Products N. Am.
                                               Great Britain       1   > 1000MM   LL    Great Britain




1      N/A        N/A      Italy    Ineco Industrial     Spain     1     N/A      N/A      Spain




1     <1MM        S        USA         Checkfree         Goergia   1    551MM     L         USA




0   individual    0          Coll's
                           USA Hospital Pharmacy, Inc
                                             New Hampshire         1    1.4 MM    M         USA




1     36MM        M        USA     Perkin-Elmer Corp.
                                                  Massachusetts    1   > 1000MM   LL        USA




1     <1MM        S        USA      Astrazeneca UKGreat Britain    1   18.849B    LL    Great Britain
1     3.6MM        M      USA
                         Speciality Rental Tools & Supply, Inc.
                                                       Texas      1   10MM      M     USA




1     50MM         M       USA     Maxon Lift Corp. California    1   39MM      M     USA




1     5.081B       LL      USA Digital Control Sys., Inc.
                                                        Oregon    1   1.6 MM    M     USA




1    1.5 MM        M       USA     Artesyn Tech. Inc. Florida     1   356 MM    L     USA




0   individual     0       USA CD Repairman, Inc. Arizona         1   <1MM      S     USA



0   individual     0       USA      Nintendo of Am.     Japan     1    4.1 B    LL    Japan




1      N/A         N/A     N/A Atlanta Corrugating, LLC N/A       1    N/A      N/A   N/A




1      N/A         N/A     USAQuicksilver Controls, Inc.
                                                     California   1    5MM      M     USA




1   1.76 Billion   LL      USA      Genentech, Inc. California    1   3.300 B   LL    USA
1       N/A         N/A      N/A
                              Natural Science Industries, Ltd.
                                                       New York     1   15.3MM     M      USA




1    >1000MM        LL       USA
                              Weatherford International, Inc.
                                                      Oklahoma      1   > 1000MM   LL     USA



1   310.6 Million   LL       USA        VDO North Am Germany        1     N/A      N/A   Germany




0    individual     0        USA
                               Pioneer Consolidated Corp
                                                  Massachusetts     1    1.4 MM    M      USA




0    individual     0        USA Taser International Inc. rizona
                                                        A           1   24.4 MM    M      USA




0    individual     0        USA Analog Devices, Inc.
                                                  Massachusetts     1    2.047 B   LL     USA




1    24.864 B       LL    Switzerland    Abbott Lab      Illinois   1   19.680 B   LL     USA




1     2.5MM         M        USA Ameriteck Indus. LLC. N/A          1     N/A      N/A     N/A




1     8.1MM         M        Key
                             USA Track Western Division, Inc.
                                                         N/A        1     N/A      N/A     N/A




1   19.8 Billion    LL       USA Unitherm Food Sys.Oklahoma         1    4.2 MM    M      USA
1     5MM         M            USA     Certainteed Corp. ennsylvania
                                                       P                   1    2500MM    LL    USA




1   58 Billion    LL           USA Schlumbergersema Inc. York
                                                      New                  1     14 B     LL    USA




1    2.1 MM       M            USA Trident Microsystems
                                                      California           1    52.7 MM   M     USA




1    163MM        L            USA Sony Electronics Inc. Japan             1    >1000MM   LL    Japan




1      N/A        N/A          USA       Siemens AG      Germany           1     100B     LL   Germany




1      N/A        N/A          USA      Koito Mfg. Co.     Japan           1      1B      LL    Japan




1   1.4 Billion              USA                          Sweeden
                  LL White Consolidated Indus., Inc. (parent AB Electrolux) 1    15.9 B   LL   Sweeden




1    1.633 B      LL       South AfricaEchostar Satellite Colorado         1    5.399 B   LL    USA




1    8.7 MM       M            USA Scientific-Atlanta, IncGeorgia          1    >1000MM   LL    USA
0   individual   0        USA        Hasbro Inc. Rhode Island     1   3.138 B   LL     USA




1   18.849B      LL    Great Britain Mutual Pharm. Pennsylvania   1   100MM     L      USA




0   individual   0        USA Harley-Davidson, Inc.
                                                  Wisconsin       1   4.624 B   LL     USA




1      N/A       N/A          A&
                        Australia E Products Group LP
                                                    Canada        1   20MM      M     Canada




1    26MM        M        USA Applied Concepts Inc. Texas         1   8.3MM     M      USA




1    19MM        M        USA       SportCraft Ltd. New Jersey    1   115MM     L      USA




0   individual   0       Canada      Matsushita      Japan        1   36.4 B    LL    Japan




0   individual   0      Australia     Ishida Co.     Japan        1    N/A      N/A   Japan




1    11MM        M        USA Secure Data in Motion alifornia
                                                  C               1   3.9MM     M      USA
1        470.7 MM           L     USA       Coolsavings      Virginia   1   823 MM     L    USA




1         54.9 MM          M      USAWeatherford International
                                                             Texas      1    10.0 B    LL   USA




1            N/A           N/A   Canada yocera Wireless Corp.Japan
                                      K                                 1    4.1 B     LL   Japan




0         individual        0    CanadaSanyo North America Japan        1    10.0 B    LL   Japan




1         1500MM           LL     USA         Centricut New Hampshire   1   14.3 MM    M    USA




1          3.3 MM          M      USA     USA Sports Inc.     Texas     1   11 MM      M    USA




1          35MM            M      USA Orbit Irrigation Products Utah    1   115 MM     L    USA




6                           LL
1 .6 B (parent Crown Holdings)    USA     Anheuser-Busch Missouri       1   16.320 B   LL   USA
NTER 2006)


                         Jury Verdict
       Technology in     as Basis of                               Fed. Cir.      Authoring                                      Add'l Voter       Add'l Voter
          Patent          Judgment          Jury Verdict           Decision       Cir Judge      Dissent       Voter for AI        for AI            for AI




      1 = electrical; 2 =
     electro-mechanical;                     0 = summary
     3 = mechanical; 4 =                 judgment or bench
        chemical (non-                     trial result; P =
     pharmaceutical); 5                   patentee wins on
      = pharmaceutical                    at least one claim
         chemistry; 6 =                  valid, infringed and
          biotech; 7 =                    enforceable (if in
        manufacturing 0 = no verdict            issue).                                                          judge who         judge who         judge who
         methods; 8 =         (incl.         AI = accused                                                      voted for the     voted for the     voted for the
           computer        summary        infringer wins on      dispositive                      0 = no          accused           accused           accused
        implementable     judgments       non-infringement       result of the      Federal     dissenting        infringer,        infringer,        infringer,
     process (other than and bench          or invalidity or     case at         Circuit judge opinion; 1 =     whether as        whether as        whether as
         business); 9 =   trials); 1 =   unenforceability, all   Federal         who authored dissenting       author, joiner,   author, joiner,   author, joiner,
      business methods jury verdict        claims in issue       Circuit          the opinion opinion exists    or dissenter      or dissenter      or dissenter




             3                 1                  P                  affirm       Clevenger         0




             7                 0                  0                  affirm        Newman           1              Lourie



             3                 1                  P                  affirm         Plager          0




             7                 1                  P                 reverse         Rader           0




             6                 0                 N/A                 affirm       Per Curiam        0
 7     0   N/A   affirm    Per Curiam   0    Schall      Dyk   Prost




 9     1   AI    reverse      Linn      1    Mayer




 3     1   P     affirm       Linn      0




3,3*   1   P     affirm      Prost      0




 3     1   P     affirm     Newman      0




 7     1   P     affirm      Rader      1   Michel (d)



 5     0   0     affirm    Clevenger    0



 5     0   0     affirm      Rader      0




 7     1   P     affirm      Lourie     0



 4     1   AI    reverse    Gajarsa     1    Mayer
2     1   P     affirm      Linn      0   Dyk (d)




 3    0   N/A   affirm   Per Curiam   0




2,6   1   P     affirm     Lourie     0




3     1   P     affirm   Clevenger    0




3     1   P     affirm      Linn      0




8     1   P     affirm     Plager     0   Lourie    Michel




4     0   0     affirm   Per Curiam   0




 1    1   P     affirm   Per Curiam   0
6   1   P     affirm   Clevenger    0   Mayer   Rader




3   1   P     affirm   Per Curiam   0




3   1   P     affirm   Per Curiam   0




2   0   0     affirm   Per Curiam   0




3   1   P     affirm     Schall     0




6   0   N/A   affirm   Per Curiam   0




3   1   P     affirm   Clevenger    0




3   0   N/A   affirm   Per Curiam   0




5   1   P*    affirm     Rader      1
3   1   P         affirm         Mayer      0




3   0   0         affirm         Rader      0    Bryson     Gajarsa




3   0   N/A       affirm       Per Curiam   0




1   1   P         affirm         Schall     0




8   1   P*    affirm/reverse    Gajarsa     1




3   1   P         affirm          Linn      1




6   1   P         affirm       Clevenger    0    Schall      Dyk




8   1   P*    affirm/reverse    Newman      1




5   0   0         affirm        Newman      1   Mayer (d)
6   0   0     affirm      Rader      0




6   1   P     affirm      Rader      0



1   1   P     reverse     Lourie     1




5   0   0     affirm      Rader      0



2   0   0     affirm      Prost      0



3   0   0     affirm      Michel     0




5   0   0     reverse    Newman      1   Mayer




3   0   N/A   affirm    Per Curiam   0   Mayer   Bryson   Linn




1   0   N/A   affirm    Per Curiam   0




3   0   0     affirm      Michel     0




3   1   P     affirm    Per Curiam   0
6     1   P        affirm         Rader      1   Schall (d)




3     0   0       reverse         Rader      1   Michel (d)




5     0   0        affirm        Gajarsa     1




3     1   P*   affirm/reverse     Schall     0




8     1   P        affirm       Per Curiam   0




3,7   1   P        affirm         Lourie     0




3     1   P        affirm         Schall     0




2     1   P        affirm       Per Curiam   0




6     1   P*       affirm         Michel     0



5     0   0        affirm         Archer     1



3     0   0       reverse          Dyk       1                Newman (d)
8   1   P     affirm      Linn      0




3   0   0     affirm     Schall     0   Newman      Bryson



4   0   0     affirm    Gajarsa     0    Schall      Linn




3   0   N/A   affirm   Per Curiam   0    Michel     Bryson     Linn




3   0   0     affirm   Clevenger    0    Archer      Dyk




8   0   0     affirm     Michel     0    Rader      Bryson




3   0   0     affirm     Lourie     0    Rader      Gajarsa




3   0   0     affirm    Gajarsa     0   Clevenger   Schall




1   0   0     affirm   Per Curiam   0    Bryson      Dyk      Gajarsa




8   0   N/A   affirm   Per Curiam   0    Rader      Schall     Dyk
3   1   P     reverse   Per Curiam   1




3   0   0     affirm       Dyk       0   Bryson    Mayer




3   0   N/A   affirm    Per Curiam   0   Mayer    Newman     Prost




1   0   N/A   affirm    Per Curiam   0   Newman    Rader     Prost



8   0   0     affirm     Gajarsa     0   Newman     Dyk




1   0   0     affirm      Prost      0   Mayer      Linn




1   0   0     affirm    Clevenger    0   Lourie   Friedman



5   0   0     affirm       Dyk       0   Michel   Gajarsa




3   0   0     affirm    Per Curiam   0   Bryson   Gajarsa    Linn




5   0   N/A   affirm    Per Curiam   0   Bryson   Gajarsa    Linn
2   0   0     affirm   Per Curiam   0    Schall       Dyk      Prost




3   1   AI    affirm   Per Curiam   0    Michel     Friedman   Rader




4   0   0     affirm     Lourie     0    Bryson       Dyk




3   0   0     affirm     Lourie     0    Mayer       Schall




3   0   0     affirm      Dyk       0    Michel      Lourie




6   0   0     affirm   Per Curiam   0    Mayer       Michel     Dyk




2   0   0     affirm      Dyk       0   Clevenger    Archer




2   0   N/A   affirm   Per Curiam   0   Clevenger   Friedman   Schall
8   0   N/A   affirm   Per Curiam   0    Michel      Plager    Rader




3   0   0     affirm    Bryson      0   Clevenger   Friedman




8   0   0     affirm     Mayer      0   Newman       Prost




2   0   0     affirm    Gajarsa     0   Newman       Prost




6   0   0     affirm     Lourie     0    Plager       Dyk




3   0   N/A   affirm   Per Curiam   0   Newman       Plager    Gajarsa




3   0   N/A   affirm   Per Curiam   0    Mayer       Lourie     Linn




1   0   N/A   affirm   Per Curiam   0




2   0   0     affirm     Lourie     0    Michel      Rader
3,7   0   0    affirm      Michel     0    Mayer        Dyk




3     1   P    reverse    Bryson      1   Clevenger




2     0   0    affirm      Schall     0    Mayer       Michel




5     0   0    affirm    Per Curiam   0    Mayer       Michel    Gajarsa




6     0   0    affirm      Prost      0    Bryson      Prost




2     0   0    affirm     Bryson      1    Rader




4     0   0    affirm     Gajarsa     0   Friedman      Linn




3     1   AI   affirm     Newman      0    Schall      Bryson




3     0   0    affirm      Lourie     0   Friedman     Prost




3     0   0    affirm      Lourie     0   Newman      Friedman
7   0   N/A   affirm    Per Curiam   0    Lourie      Gajarsa     Linn




7   0   N/A   affirm    Per Curiam   0    Mayer       Bryson     Gajarsa




3   0   N/A   affirm    Per Curiam   0    Mayer       Rader       Linn




3   0   0     affirm      Rader      0   Clevenger     Dyk




8   0   0     affirm    Clevenger    0    Mayer        Prost




8   1   AI    affirm       Linn      0    Mayer       Schall




7   0   N/A   affirm    Per Curiam   0   Clevenger    Rader      Gajarsa




6   0   0     affirm      Michel     0     Prost     Newman




5   0   0     affirm      Lourie     0    Plager      Michel



8   1   P     reverse     Rader      1     Dyk       Clevenger
3   0   0     affirm      Rader      0   Archer    Gajarsa




3   0   N/A   affirm    Per Curiam   0   Mayer     Michel      Dyk




3   0   N/A   affirm    Per Curiam   0   Mayer     Plager     Gajarsa




1   0   0     affirm    Per Curiam   0   Lourie    Schall     Bryson




3   0   0     affirm     Bryson      0   Mayer     Gajarsa




3   0   0     affirm    Per Curiam   0   Newman    Plager     Bryson



1   0   0     affirm      Michel     0   Mayer    Clevenger




3   1   AI    reverse     Plager     0    XX




2   0   0     affirm    Per Curiam   0   Newman    Michel     Bryson




1   0   0     affirm      Lourie     0   Schall     Prost
6     0   0     affirm       Dyk       0    Bryson     Gajarsa




5     0   0     affirm      Lourie     0    Bryson      Lourie




2     0   0     affirm     Gajarsa     0    Schall     Friedman




3,3   0   0     affirm      Prost      0    Bryson     Gajarsa




3,3   0   0     affirm      Prost      0    Bryson     Gajarsa



2     1   P     reverse     Prost      0   Newman        Dyk




5     0   0     affirm    Per Curiam   1   Clevenger    Schall     Linn




7     1   AI    affirm    Per Curiam   0    Rader       Schall    Bryson




3     0   0     affirm    Per Curiam   0    Bryson     Gajarsa     Prost




 8    0   N/A   affirm    Per Curiam   0    Rader       Plager    Gajarsa
5   0   0     affirm     Prost      0   Clevenger    Schall




3   0   0     affirm      Linn      0    Lourie      Rader




3   0   0     affirm     Michel     0    Mayer      Clevenger




3   0   N/A   affirm   Per Curiam   0    Michel      Archer     Lourie




3   0   N/A   affirm   Per Curiam   0   Newman      Clevenger   Gajarsa




4   0   N/A   affirm   Per Curiam   0    Michel      Lourie     Gajarsa




3   0   0     affirm    Bryson      0    Mayer      Clevenger




2   0   0     affirm     Prost      1    Lourie       Linn




2   0   0     affirm     Prost      0    Lourie      Schall
4   0   0     affirm       Linn      0   Friedman     Prost




1   0   0     affirm    Per Curiam   0    Mayer     Newman      Lourie



3   1   P     reverse     Archer     1    Michel




3   0   N/A   affirm    Per Curiam   0   Newman      Gajarsa    Prost




3   0   N/A   affirm    Per Curiam   0    Michel     Schall     Prost




3   1   AI    affirm    Per Curiam   0   Newman      Lourie     Schall




8   0   0     affirm      Lourie     0   Gajarsa      Linn




5   0   0     affirm      Lourie     0    Archer     Michel




5   0   0     affirm      Rader      0    Plager     Bryson




3   0   N/A   affirm    Per Curiam   0    Lourie    Clevenger   Rader
 7    0   N/A   affirm   Per Curiam   0   Bryson     Dyk       Prost




 8    0   N/A   affirm   Per Curiam   0




2,8   1   P     affirm      Dyk       1   Schall




 3    0   N/A   affirm   Per Curiam   0   Michel   Clevenger   Bryson



6     0   0     affirm      Dyk       0   Mayer      Prost




7     0   0     affirm      Linn      0   Lourie    Gajarsa




5     0   0     affirm     Lourie     0   Rader     Schall




7     0   0     affirm      Linn      0   Bryson    Mayer




3     0   0     affirm     Rader      1   Michel
1   0   N/A   affirm    Per Curiam   0   Newman      Michel   Rader




6   0   0     affirm      Rader      0   Newman      Michel




1   1   P     reverse   Clevenger    0    Plager     Schall




2   0   0     affirm    Clevenger    0    Smith      Bryson




8   1   P     reverse   Clevenger    1    Schall




3   0   0     affirm      Lourie     0   Clevenger   Rader




8   0   0     affirm    Per Curiam   0   Newman      Michel   Rader




3   0   0     affirm     Newman      0    Rader       Dyk




6   0   0     affirm      Rader      1    Schall      Linn
4   0   N/A   affirm   Per Curiam   0   Lourie    Plager      Prost




3   0   N/A   affirm   Per Curiam   0   Michel    Schall     Gajarsa




4   0   0     affirm    Newman      0   Michel    Rader




2   0   N/A   affirm   Per Curiam   0   Rader     Bryson      Prost




1   0   N/A   affirm   Per Curiam   0   Mayer    Clevenger   Gajarsa




3   0   0     affirm     Michel     0   Mayer     Bryson




5   0   0     affirm     Rader      0   Mayer     Bryson




3   0   0     affirm     Prost      0   Michel     Dyk




7   1   AI    affirm   Per Curiam   0   Mayer    Clevenger   Schall




2   0   0     affirm      Linn      0   Rader      Dyk
3   1   AI    affirm      Dyk       0   Clevenger    Gajarsa




4   0   0     affirm    Newman      0    Michel      Rader




3   0   N/A   affirm   Per Curiam   0   Newman       Schall     Linn




3   1   AI    affirm   Clevenger    0   Newman       Lourie




6   1   AI    affirm   Clevenger    0    Bryson      Gajarsa




5   0   0     affirm     Rader      0    Gajarsa     Bryson




2   0   0     affirm     Rader      0    Michel       Dyk




3   0   0     affirm    Gajarsa     0    Mayer      Clevenger




5   0   0     affirm     Rader      0    Plager      Gajarsa




7   0   0     affirm      Linn      0     Prost     Clevenger
8     0   0   affirm      Lourie     1     ___         ___




6     0   0   affirm      Mayer      0    Gajarsa      Dyk




5     0   0   affirm      Lourie     0    Bryson       Dyk




7     0   0   affirm    Friedman     0    Rader       Schall




6     0   0   affirm    Per Curiam   0   Clevenger    Bryson     Linn




3*    0   0   affirm    Per Curiam   0    Michel      Bryson     Prost




5     0   0   affirm      Lourie     0    Archer     Clevenger



1     0   0   reverse      Linn      0     Prost     Newman




1     0   0   affirm     Bryson      0   Clevenger    Rader



7     0   0   reverse    Newman      0    Bryson       Linn




3,6   1   P   affirm       Linn      0    Schall      Bryson
8   0   0     affirm     Gajarsa     0    Rader      Bryson



1   1   P     reverse    Bryson      0    Rader       Dyk




5   0   0     affrim       Dyk       0     Prost




3   0   N/A   affirm    Per Curiam   0   Clevenger   Gajarsa   Prost




3   0   N/A   affirm    Per Curiam   0    Mayer      Rader     Prost




2   0   N/A   affirm    Per Curiam   0   Newman      Rader     Linn




3   0   0     affirm      Rader      0   Clevenger   Rader




3   1   P     affirm    Per Curiam   0   Clevenger   Rader     Schall




5   0   0     affirm    Clevenger    1    Mayer
N/A   0   N/A   affirm   Per Curiam   0   Mayer     Michel       Linn




N/A   0   N/A   affirm   Per Curiam   0   Newman    Plager     Clevenger




3     0   0     affirm     Archer     0   Newman     Prost




1     0   0     affirm     Lourie     0   Plager     Prost




3     0   N/A   affirm   Per Curiam   0   Lourie   Clevenger    Gajarsa



2     0   0     affirm    Bryson      0    Linn     Michel




3     0   0     affirm    Gajarsa     0    Linn      Prost




2     1   AI    affirm     Schall     0   Mayer      Linn




6     1   AI    affirm     Rader      0   Archer    Bryson
3   0   N/A   affirm   Per Curiam   0    Mayer      Bryson    Linn




3   0   N/A   affirm   Per Curiam   0   Clevenger   Rader     Schall



2   1   P     affirm      Linn      0   Newman      Bryson




2   0   0     affirm     Michel     0   Newman      Schall




2   0   0     affirm   Per Curiam   0    Lourie     Gajarsa   Prost




1   0   0     affirm     Lourie     0    Rader      Bryson




5   1   P     affirm     Prost      1    Gajarsa




3   0   N/A   affirm   Per Curiam   0    Mayer      Lourie    Linn




2   0   N/A   affirm   Per Curiam   0    Michel     Gajarsa   Linn




7   1   AI    affirm    Gajarsa     0    Schall      Linn
3   0   N/A   affirm   Per Curiam   0    Michel      Lourie    Rader




1   0   0     affirm      Linn      0    Mayer      Friedman




1   0   0     affirm     Lourie     0   Friedman     Prost




1   0   N/A   affirm   Per Curiam   0   Newman       Rader     Bryson




1   0   0     affirm    Gajarsa     0    Michel     Gajarsa




7   1   P     affirm    Gajarsa     0    Bryson       Dyk




3   0   0     affirm      Linn      0    Rader        Dyk




8   0   0     affirm     Michel     0   Newman       Bryson




8   0   0     affirm      Linn      0   Clevenger     Linn
1    0   0     affirm    Per Curiam   0    Michel      Rader       Prost




5    0   0     reverse     Michel     0    Archer      Bryson




3    0   0     affirm       Linn      0    Rader       Bryson




3    0   N/A   affirm    Per Curiam   0    Mayer       Archer     Gajarsa




1    0   N/A   affirm    Per Curiam   0    Michel     Clevenger   Bryson




3    0   N/A   affirm    Per Curiam   0   Newman        Linn       Prost




3*   0   0     affirm    Per Curiam   0   Clevenger    Gajarsa     Prost




3    0   N/A   affirm    Per Curiam   0    Mayer       Gajarsa     Linn




8    0   N/A   affirm    Per Curiam   0   Newman      Clevenger   Bryson
1    0   0     affirm      Prost      0    Michel     Rader




2    0   0     affirm      Rader      0   Friedman     Dyk




3*   0   0     affirm     Newman      0    Michel      Prost




3*   0   0     affirm     Newman      0    Michel      Prost




2    0   0     reverse      Dyk       0   Clevenger   Michel




3    0   0     affirm       Dyk       0    Archer     Newman




3    0   N/A   affirm    Per Curiam   0   Newman      Michel   Gajarsa




3    0   0     affirm      Lourie     0    Mayer       Dyk
                                                 WLA Time                                                                                        LLA
                Add'l Voter    Add'l Voter       Admitted         WLA Patent      WLA Firm        WLA Firm      WLA Firm      WLA Firm         Admitted
 Voter for P      for P          for P           Category          Attorney       Location          Size        Category        Size           Category




                                                                                                                              SS = 1-10
                                                                                                                             attorneys; S
                                                Time winning                                                                    = 11-25        Time losing
                                                 lead attorney                                                                attorneys ;     lead attorney
                                 judge who         (WLA) has                                                                 SM = 26-50         (LLA) has
                                voted for the         been                                                                   attorneys; M          been
                                  patentee,       admitted to       Whether                                                    = 51-100        admitted to
                                  whether it     practice law.       WLA is                                                 attorneys; ML     practice law.
                                 was for the        0 = < 10       registered                                                 = 101-250          0 = < 10
  judge who      judge who opinion, the         years; 1 = 10 -       patent                                      1 = IP    attorneys; L =   years; 1 = 10 -
voted for the voted for the dissenting or       15 years; 2 =     attorney. 0 = state where the                boutique; 0 = 251-500         15 years; 2 =
   patentee,      patentee,      concurring         16 to 20        not PTO      headquarter of    number of general firm; attorneys ; LL        16 to 20
 whether as whether as opinion, or              years; 3 = 21     registered; 1   the winning     attorneys in   2 = other      = 501+       years; 3 = 21
author, joiner, author, joiner, per curiam      to 30 years; 4       = PTO      leading law firm the winning (corporate,       attorneys     to 30 years; 4
 or dissenter or dissenter         opinion       = > 30 years      registered      is located    lead law firm     etc.)                      = > 30 years




    Mayer           Linn                              4                1            Illinois          27            SM             1               3




   Michel                                             4                0           Alabama         101-250          ML             0               4



   Gajarsa          Dyk                               1                0          Wisconsin          501+           LL             0               2




    Mayer           Dyk                               4                1        Washington DC         27            SM             1               3




  Newman            Linn      Dyk                     0                1            Virginia         342             L             0               4
                      3   0   Georgia       520     LL   0    4




Lourie                4   1   Michigan     26-50    SM   1    4




Gajarsa    Rader      1   0   Michigan      2-10    SS   0    3




Mayer      Bryson     3   0   California   501+     LL   0    2




Gajarsa    Plager     4   1   California    10      SS   0   None




Gajarsa               3   0    Texas        2-10    SS   0    4



Rader       Dyk       4   0    Illinois    26-50    SM   0    4



Gajarsa     Prost     4   0    Illinois    26-51    SM   0    2




Lourie    Clevenger   4   1    Illinois    51-100   M    1    4



 Linn                 4   1    Texas       501+     LL   0    3
Newman                        2   1   North Carolina    501+     LL   0   3




Mayer     Bryson    Gajarsa   3   1   Pennsylvania       2       SS   0   4




Michel    Plager              2   1     California      2-10     SS   1   4




Archer    Bryson              4   1      Missouri       501+     LL   0   4




Bryson     Linn               2   1     Minnesota      101-250   ML   1   4




                              1   0   Washington DC     501+     LL   1   3




Newman   Friedman   Prost     4   1   Washington DC     1000     LL   0   4




Newman    Schall    Dyk       3   0     California      501+     LL   0   2
                                    2     1   New York      501+     LL    0     4




Newman   Gajarsa    Linn           None   1    Texas        501+     LL    0     3




Mayer     Michel    Prost           4     1   Missouri      501+     LL    0     4




Schall   Gajarsa    Prost           3     1   New York     101-250   ML    1     2




Michel    Prost                     1     0   Louisiana      1       SS    0     3




 Linn     Plager           Prost    4     1    Texas       251-500   L     0     3




Schall     Dyk                      4     0   Colorado      11-25    S     0     4




Newman   Friedman      Schall       2     0    Florida      11-25    S     0     4




Newman    Prost                     3     0   California   merged    N/A   N/A   4
 Dyk      Prost             4   0     Texas         6       SS   1   4




                            1   0     Illinois    101-250   ML   0   2




Newman   Friedman   Rader   4   1   California    251-500   L    0   4




Archer    Prost             3   0   California     501+     LL   0   4




Newman     Dyk              3   1     Illinois    51-100    M    1   4




Archer     Dyk              2   0    Virginia     101-250   ML   0   3




                            3   0   Delaware      51-100    M    1   4




Lourie    Schall            4   1   California    251-500   L    0   4




 Prost                      4   1   Californina   251-500   L    0   3
 Bryson       Prost             None   N/A        N/A         N/A      N/A   N/A   None




 Mayer       Michel              4     0         Utah         2-10     SS    0      2



Newman       Mayer               3     0        Texas        51-100    M     0      4




 Gajarsa      Prost              2     1       New York      101-250   ML    1



 Schall      Archer              3     1       Wisconsin     251-500   L     0      3



 Lourie       Linn               4     0       Minnesota     101-250   ML    1      4




Lourie (d)                       2     0     Washington DC    501+     LL    0      2




                                 3     1       California     26-50    SM    1      2




Clevenger    Gajarsa   Prost     1     1        Illinois      26-50    SM    1      3




 Gajarsa      Linn               3     1       Michigan       2-10     SS    1      2




Newman       Michel    Schall    3     0       Oklahoma      101-250   ML    0      4
Friedmam                          3     1       Colorado       501+     LL    0      1




Newman                            1     0       Louisiana       1       SS    0      0




 Schall    Dyk (cip)              3     1       New York       501+     LL    0      2




 Prost      Michel                3     0     Washington DC   101-250   ML    0      4




Friedman     Linn      Mayer     None   N/A       N/A          N/A      N/A   N/A   None




 Rader      Michel                3     1        Texas        251-500   L     0      4




 Michel     Mayer                 4     1       New York       2-10     SS    0      2




 Lourie     Rader      Gajarsa    4     1     Massachusetts    307      L     1      4




Newman      Prost                 3     1       New York       501+     LL    0      1



Newman     Dyk (dip)              3     0       New York      101-250   ML    0      4



 Rader                            3     1        Oregan        11-25    S     1      3
Schall   Michel   4   1   Washington DC   101-250   ML   0    4




                  4   0   Washington DC    501+     LL   0    3



                  4   1   Washington DC   251-500   L    0    3




                  3   1   Washington DC   251-500   L    0   None




                  3   1     New York        8       SS   0    3




                  3   1     California    101-250   ML   1    4




                  4   0      Illinois       1       SS   0    1




                  4   1      Illinois     251-500   L    0    3




                  3   0     New York       501+     LL   0   None




                  4   0    Washington      26-50    SM   1    4
4   1   Massachusetts   251-500   L    1    4




0   1   Washington DC   251-500   L    1    3




4   1    New Jersey      26-50    SM   0    4




4   1     New York       195      ML   1    4



3   0     California     501+     LL   0    2




2   1       Ohio         2-10     SS   1    4




3   0     California     501+     LL   0    1



2   0      Illinois      501+     LL   0    4




3   0      Virginia       50      SM   0   None




4   1      Florida       2-10     SS   0   None
1   1    New Jersey       47      SM   0   None




4   0       Texas        2-10     SS   0    2




1   1   Massachusetts    26-50    SM   1    3




2   1       Texas       251-500   L    0    4




0   0      Missouri       23      S    1    3




2   1   Washington DC   251-500   L    1    3




4   1       Texas         1       SS   1




2   1    Connecticut    251-500   L    0    2
3   1   Washington DC   251-500   L    1   4




1   1     Wisconsin     51-100    M    0   3




3   1      Oregon        26-50    SM   1   2




3   0     California     501+     LL   0   3




3   1    Connecticut    101-250   ML   0   1




2   1     Californina    2-10     SS   1   1




1   0      Georgia      251-500   L    0   4




3   0     California     501+     LL   0   2




3   0     California    101-250   ML   0   4
                1   1     Colorado      101-250   ML   1   3




  Prost (d)     4   0   Massachusetts   101-250   ML   0   4




                4   1      Illinois     251-500   L    0   3




                3   1     New York      101-250   ML   1   4




                2   1     Wisconsin      2-10     SS   1   4




Clevenger (d)   4   1     California     501+     LL   0   4




                4   1       Ohio         501+     LL   0   3




                4   1     New York      101-250   ML   1   4




                4   1     New York       501+     LL   0   4




                2   1     New York      101-250   ML   1   3
3   0     Kentucky       101-250   ML   0    3




3   1   North Carolina    501+     LL   0    1




0   1     California     101-250   ML   1   None




3   0   New Hempshire      63      M    0   None




4   0      Illinois      51-100    M    1    3




4   1      Virginia       501+     LL   0   None




3   1   North Carolina    501+     LL   0    1




4   1       Texas        251-500   L    0    3




0   0      Illinois       11-25    S    0    4



3   0   Massachusetts     26-50    SM   0    4
 2     0    Illinois     501+     LL   0    4




 3     1    Texas        501+     LL   0    4




 0     0    Texas        11-25    S    0    1




 4     1   New York     251-500   L    0    4




None   1    Texas        501+     LL   0    3




 4     0    Texas        2-10     SS   0    4



 3     0   California    501+     LL   0    3




 2     1     Ohio        2-10     SS   1    2




 0     1   California    1-10     SS   0   None




 3     0   Colorado      650      LL   0   None
4   1     California      501+     LL   0    4




3   1       Illinois     51-100    M    1    2




4   1   Washington DC    101-250   ML   0    4




3   0     Michigan         2       SS   0    3




3   1   South Carolina    109      ML   0    3



4   0       Illinois     51-100    M    1    4




3   0     New York        501+     LL   0    4




4   0   Pennsylvania     251-500   L    0    4




3   0    New Jersey        47      SM   0   None




2   0       Illinois       2       SS   1    1
4   1     New York      101-250   ML   1   4




3   0     Minnesota     101-250   ML   0   4




2   0      Virginia      240      ML   0   2




3   1     New York       501+     LL   0   0




4   1     Montana         1       SS   1   2




4   1     Delaware      51-100    M    1   2




3   1   Washington DC   101-250   ML   0   3




4   1      Texas         501+     LL   0   4




3   0      Oregon       101-250   ML   0   4
             3   0    New Jersey      162      ML   0   3




             3   0     California     501+     LL   0   3



Newman (d)   4   1     Michigan       26-50    SM   1   0




             3   1      Virginia      11-25    S    0   2




             3   0     California     501+     LL   0   3




             4   1      Illinois      501+     LL   0   4




             3   0      Texas         501+     LL   0   2




             4   0     Michigan       11-25    S    1   4




             4   1   Washington DC   251-500   L    1   4




             3   1      Kansas        2-10     SS   0   2
         4   0     California    251-500   L    0   1




         3   1     Minnesota     101-250   ML   1   2




Mayer    2   1     California    101-250   ML   1   3




         4   0      Texas          6       SS   1   3



         3   0     Delaware      51-100    M    1   3




         3   1   Washington DC    195      ML   1   3




         3   1   Pennsylvania    51-100    M    1   4




         4   1      Illinois      501+     LL   0   1




Schall   2   1     New York       501+     LL   0   4
             1   0      Florida       2-10     SS   0    4




             3   1     New York      101-250   ML   1   None




             4   1   Washington DC   251-500   L    1    4




             3   0     Wisconsin      26-50    SM   0    4




Newman (d)   3   1     New York       501+     LL   0    4




             2   1      Virginia     51-100    M    1    3




             0   1      Illinois      585      LL   0   None




             3   1      Oregon        11-25    S    1    2




             2   1     New York       501+     LL   0    2
4   1   Washington DC    2-10     SS   0   4




3   1     New York        2       SS   1   3




2   0     Minnesota     101-250   ML   0   4




1   0     Minnesota     251-500   L    1   1




4   1      Virginia     51-100    M    1   2




2   1       Ohio         11-25    S    0   0




2   1     New York       501+     LL   0   4




0   1       Iowa         11-25    S    1   2




2   0     California     501+     LL   0   3




1   1      Texas          1       SS   1   4
 3     1        Florida      251-500   L     0     None




 0     1         Texas       251-500   L     0      2




 4     0     Washington DC    501+     LL    0      3




 2     1         Texas       251-500   L     0      4




 3     0       New York       181      ML    0      4




None   N/A        N/A         N/A      N/A   N/A




 1     1         Texas       51-100    M     0      1




 3     1       Californina   251-500   L     0      4




 3     1       New York      101-250   ML    1      4




 4     1       Michigan        10      SS    1      2
 3     0       Illinois      501+     LL   0    0




 2     1        Ohio         11-25    S    1    3




 4     1     New York       251-501   L    0    4




 4     1     Californina     756      LL   0    4




 4     1       Texas        251-500   L    0    3




 2     1   North Carolina    2-10     SS   1   None




 3     1   Washington DC     501+     LL   0    3



 4     1     Californina    101-250   ML   1    3




None   0     New York       101-250   ML   1    3



 3     0   Washington DC     501+     LL   0    3




 4     1   Washington DC      76      M    1    2
                2   0     California     501+     LL   0    2



                4   1   Washington DC   251-500   L    1    3




Clevenger (d)   3   1     New York       11-25    S    0    4




                3   1      Illinois     51-100    M    1    0




                1   0     Maryland       501+     LL   0    4




                3   1      Illinois     51-100    M    1    1




                3   0   New Hempshire   51-100    M    1   None




                3   1     New York      101-250   ML   1    2




Newman (d)      4   1     New York      101-250   ML   1    3
2   1      Texas         550      LL   0   4




1   1     California    251-500   L    0   4




3   1      Oregan         21      S    1   3




4   1   Massachusetts   101-250   ML   0   1




2   0      Arizona       26-50    SM   1   1



2   0     New York       501+     LL   0   4




3   1      Illinois     251-500   L    0   3




2   1    Californina     2-10     SS   1   2




2   1     New York       501+     LL   0   3
              3     1     New York        7       SS    1    2




              4     0      Texas          6       SS    1    3



              3     0     New York       3500     LL    0    4




              1     1     Michigan       11-25    S     1    4




             None   1      Arizona       N/A      N/A   1   None




              2     0   Massachusetts    2-10     SS    0   None




Bryson (d)    4     0     California    101-250   ML    0    4




              4     0    Minnesota       11-25    S     1    1




              4     0     Colorado      101-250   ML    0    2




              4     0     Oklahoma      51-100    M     0    4
3   1     New York       501+     LL   0   4




3   1   South Carolina   11-25    S    0   1




3   0     California     501+     LL   0   1




3   0   Washington DC     300     L    0   0




4   1     New York       501+     LL   0   4




2   1   Washington DC    51-100   M    1   1




3   0     New York       501+     LL   0   4




4   0   Washington DC    501+     LL   0   3




3   0     California     501+     LL   0   3
1   1     Illinois   51-100    M    1   None




1   0   New York     101-250   ML   1    3




2   0   Wisconsin    251-500   L    0    3




3   1   New York       43      SM   1    3




3   0   California     2       SS   1    4




3   0   New Jersey    155      ML   0    2




3   0   New Jersey    100      M    0   None




4   1   California    931      LL   0    3




0   0   California    121      ML   0    3
None   N/A        N/A          N/A       N/A   N/A   None




 4     1         Texas         501+      LL    0      4




 3     1       Californina   Corporate   N/A   2     None




 1     0       Californina     966       LL    0     None




 4     0     New Hempshire    51-100     M     0      3




 0     1         Texas         2-10      SS    1      1




 3     1          Utah          9        S     1      4




 1     0         Texas          11       S     1      3
LLA Patent        LLA Firm        LLA Firm      LLA Firm      LLA Firm
 Attorney         Location          Size        Category        Size




                                                              SS = 1-10
                                                             attorneys; S
                                                                = 11-25
                                                              attorneys ;
                                                             SM = 26-50
                                                             attorneys; M
                                                               = 51-100
Whether LLA                                                 attorneys; ML
is registered                                                 = 101-250
    patent                                        1 = IP    attorneys; L =
attorney. 0 =   state where the                boutique; 0 = 251-500
   not PTO       headquarter of number of general firm; attorneys ; LL
registered; 1      the losing     attorneys in   2 = other      = 501+
    = PTO       leading law firm the losing     (corporate,    attorneys
  registered       is located    lead law firm     etc.)




     1              Illinois         240            0             ML




     1             Michigan          24             1             S



     1           Pennsylvania       26-50           1            SM




     0          Washington DC       1000            0             LL




     1             Delaware          80             1             M
1     California     N/A      1     N/A




1     New York       26-50    0     SM




1       Ohio         501+     0     LL




1     Maryland       2-10     1     SS




0        N/A         N/A      N/A   N/A




1       Texas        501+     0     LL



0   Washington DC    26-50    1     SM



0   Washington DC   251-500   0     L




1      Missouri      189      0     ML



1   Washington DC   51-100    1     M
0   South Carolina   101-250   0   ML




1       Ohio          26-50    1   SM




1     Michigan         40      1   SM




1      Missouri       189      0   ML




0     California      501+     0   LL




1     New York        501+     0   LL




1     California     101-250   1   ML




1       Texas         501+     0   LL
1   Washington DC   251-500   0   L




0      Texas         501+     0   LL




0      Florida       2-10     0   SS




1      Virginia      N/A      0   N/A




1    Washington     251-500   0   L




1      Virginia     51-100    1   M




1    New Mexico      2-10     1   SS




1      Florida        1       1   SS




1     California    251-500   1   L
1   Washington DC   251-500   1   L




0      Illinois     51-100    1   M




0     New York      251-500   0   L




0     California    101-250   0   ML




0      Virginia      501+     0   LL




0     Minnesota      501+     0   LL




1      Texas        251-500   0   L




1     New York      251-500   1   L




0     New York      101-250   1   ML
N/A        N/A          N/A          N/A   N/A




1        Illinois      501+           0    LL



1       California    251-500         0    L




N/A        N/A          N/A          N/A   N/A



0     Washington DC   251-500         0    L



1        Illinois      26-50          1    SM




1      New Jersey        94           0    M




1         Utah         51-100         0    M




1      Washington      26-50          0    SM




1       New York       501+           0    LL




1        Texasmerged with Andrew Kurth 0   N/A
0     Washington DC    501+     0     LL




0       Louisiana      11-25    0     S




1        Illinois     251-500   0     L




1     Massachusetts     44      0     SM




N/A        N/A         N/A      N/A   N/A




1     Washington DC   251-500   1     L




1        Texas        251-500   0     L




1       California     151      1     ML




0     Massachusetts   101-250   0     ML



0     Washington DC    26-50    1     SM



0        Oregon       101-250   0     ML
1   California   251-500     0        L




0    Illinois     373        0        L



0    Illinois    51-100      0        M




0   Michigan      116        0       ML




0     Ohio        590        0       LL




1   New York      175        1       ML




0    Florida      2-10       0       SS




0   New York      200        0       ML




0    Pro Se      Pro Se    Pro Se   Pro Se




1    Virginia    51-100      1        M
1   Washington DC   251-500     1        L




1      Indiana       1-10       1       SS




1       Ohio          36        1       SM




1      Illinois      2-10       1       SS



1      Illinois      11-25      1        S




1     New York      251-500     0        L




1   Washington DC    1000       0       LL



1   Washington DC   251-500     1        L




0      Pro Se       Pro Se    Pro Se   Pro Se




0      Illinois      < 10       1       SS
0     Pro Se       Pro Se    Pro Se   Pro Se




1      Texas         1         0       SS




0    New York      101-250     1       ML




0    New York      51-100      0        M




1      Illinois    51-100      1        M




1   Pennsylvania     73        1        M




0      Texas        2-10       0       SS




1   Pennsylvania    501+       0       LL
0     Ohio        N/A      0   N/A




0   Minnesota     114      0   ML




1   California   101-250   1   ML




1    Illinois    51-100    1   M




1   California    501+     0   LL




0   California    1245     0   LL




0     Utah        11-25    1   S




1   Wisconsin     501+     0   LL




1    Illinois      25      1   S
1      Texas        251-500   0   L




0   Massachusetts    2-10     0   SS




1   Pennsylvania     501+     0   LL




1     New York      101-250   1   ML




0   Washington DC    26-50    1   SM




0     New York       26-50    1   SM




1     New York      101-250   1   ML




1     New York       501+     0   LL




0     Wisconsin      501+     0   LL




1     Michigan       11-25    0   S
0       Ohio          1         0       SS




0      Florida        6         0       SS




1     California     2-10       1       SS




0      Pro Se       Pro Se    Pro Se   Pro Se




0     California     2-10       0       SS




0      Pro Se       Pro Se    Pro Se   Pro Se




0      Florida        6         0       SS




1      Virginia     51-100      1        M




0     New York      101-250     1       ML



1   Washington DC   51-100      1        M
1   New York     251-500     0        L




1     Texas       2-10       1       SS




0   Louisiana      1         0       SS




1   California    1-10       1       SS




1   New Jersey    26-50      0       SM




1     Texas       1-10       1       SS



0   California    501+       0       LL




1    Michigan     2-10       1       SS




0     Pro Se     Pro Se    Pro Se   Pro Se




0     Pro Se     Pro Se    Pro Se   Pro Se
0       Texas         1-10       1       SS




1    Washington       501+       0       LL




1     New York        501+       0       LL




1   South Carolina    109        0       ML




0     Michigan         2         0       SS



1   Washington DC     1000       0       LL




1   Washington DC    251-500     1        L




1     New York       101-250     1       ML




0      Pro Se        Pro Se    Pro Se   Pro Se




1       Illinois      2-10       1       SS
1   Washington DC   251-500   1   L




0     California     2-10     1   SS




1      Virginia      600      0   LL




0     New York        1       0   SS




1      Missouri       1       1   SS




0   Washington DC   101-250   0   ML




0     New York        4       0   SS




1       Texas         1       1   SS




1     Nebraska        3       1   SS
0    California    2-10    0   SS




1    California    300     0   L



0   South Dakota   26-50   0   SM




1    Wisconsin     2-10    1   SS




1    California    630     0   LL




1      Illinois    225     0   ML




1      Texas        40     1   SM




1      Illinois    373     1   L




1    California    501+    0   LL




1    Minnesota     26-51   1   SM
1     Michigan       2      0   SS




1     Minnesota     26-50   1   SM




0     California    501+    0   LL




0      Texas        2-10    0   SS



0      Illinois     2-10    1   SS




0   Washington DC   2-10    0   SS




1      Indiana      26-50   1   SM




1     California    2-10    1   SS




0      Illinois     501+    0   LL
1    California    < 10       1       SS




0     Pro Se      Pro Se    Pro Se   Pro Se




1    New York     51-100      1        M




1     Illinois     2-10       1       SS




1   New Mexico     2-10       1       SS




1      Ohio       251-500     0        L




0     Pro Se      Pro Se    Pro Se   Pro Se




0    California   101-250     1       ML




1    New York      195        1       ML
1     Delaware        80      1   M




0     Colorado       26-50    1   SM




0   Massachusetts     1       2   SS




1       Ohio         < 10     1   SS




1      Texas         2-10     1   SS




1      Arizona        9       0   SS




1   Washington DC   251-500   1   L




0     Wisconsin      2-10     1   SS




0      Illinois      501+     0   LL




0       Ohio        101-250   0   ML
1      Illinois      501+       0       LL




0   Washington DC   101-250     0       ML




0      Florida       2-10       0       SS




1      Texas          1         1       SS




1     New York      101-250     1       ML




0      Pro Se       Pro Se    Pro Se   Pro Se




1      Texas         501+       0       LL




1    New Mexico      2-10       1       SS




1     New York       501+       0       LL




1     Michigan        5         1       SS
1      Virginia     51-100      1        M




1      Texas         501+       0       LL




1     California     501+       0       LL




1   Washington DC   251-500     1        L




0     New York       501+       0       LL




0      Pro Se       Pro Se    Pro Se   Pro Se




0    Washington     251-500     0        L



0      Texas         501+       0       LL




0      Illinois      2-10       0       SS



1   Washington DC    501+       0       LL




0   Massachusetts    2-10       0       SS
1   New York     175        0       ML



0   Minnesota    501+       0       LL




1   New York    101-250     1       ML




1   Minnesota    161        0       ML




0    Virginia    2-10       1       SS




1    Illinois    < 10       1       SS




0    Pro Se     Pro Se    Pro Se   Pro Se




1    Virginia   251-500     0        L




1   Michigan     11-25      1        S
1      Texas         < 10     1   SS




1      Illinois     251-500   0   L




0      Illinois     251-500   0   L




1   Massachusetts    501+     0   LL




1     New York       501+     0   LL



0      Florida        29      0   SM




1     California     11-25    1   S




0   Washington DC    1000     0   LL




0     California     501+     0   LL
1     Minnesota      114        1       ML




1   Washington DC   251-500     1        L



1     Michigan       11-25      0        S




0     Michigan       2-10       1       SS




0      Pro Se       Pro Se    Pro Se   Pro Se




0      Pro Se       Pro Se    Pro Se   Pro Se




1     New York      101-250     1       ML




1     Minnesota      501+       0       LL




1      Georgia      251-500     0        L




1     California     501+       0       LL
1    Washington      501+     0   LL




1   Pennsylvania    51-100    1   M




1   Washington DC    1000     0   LL




1      Illinois      11-25    1   S




1   Washington DC   251-500   1   L




1     California     2-10     1   SS




0     Minnesota     101-250   1   ML




0     California     501+     0   LL




0   Massachusetts    501+     0   LL
0    Pro Se      Pro Se   Pro Se   Pro Se




1    Illinois    51-100     1        M




0   California    2-10      0       SS




1   New York      26        1       SM




1    Kansas        7        1       SS




0     Utah        59        1        M




0    Pro Se      Pro Se   Pro Se   Pro Se




1    Illinois     390       0        L




0   California    900       0       LL
N/A        N/A          N/A       N/A      N/A




1     Washington DC    251-500     1        L




0        Pro Se        Pro Se    Pro Se   Pro Se




0        Pro Se        Pro Se    Pro Se   Pro Se




1     North Carolina    501+       0       LL




0       California     251-500     0        L




1        Illinois       501+       0       LL




1     Pennsylvania       73        1        M

				
DOCUMENT INFO
Shared By:
Categories:
Stats:
views:59
posted:7/10/2010
language:English
pages:140
Description: S Corp California document sample