Increasing Political Freedom May Be Key To Reducing Threats by ProQuest


More Info
									t e r r o r i s m

Increasing Political Freedom
May Be Key To Reducing Threats
By Craig P. Aubuchon, Subhayu Bandyopadhyay and Javed Younas

                                                                                                                                           © Robin baRtholick /coRbis

E    ach year, the U.S. State Department
     publishes Country Reports on Terror-
ism, which highlights current strategies,
                                                   demonstrates that terrorists are using more
                                                   lethal methods and weapons.
                                                                                                      of civil liberties and that economic condi-
                                                                                                      tions (as captured by GDP per capita) in
                                                                                                      these nations had no statistically significant
outcomes and casualties from U.S. counter-         Poverty and Terrorism                              relationship with terrorism.5 On the other
terrorism efforts. The 2008 report high-              A study by economists Alan Krueger              hand, they find that nations with high GDP
lights the growing trend in terrorist attacks      and Jitka Maleckova considers the influ-           per capita were more likely to be targets of
abroad, including the September attack             ence of poverty and education on terrorism.        terrorism. A 2006 paper by Harvard econo-
against the U.S. Embassy in Yemen that             Surprisingly, they find no evidence that           mist Alberto Abadie also found that the risk
killed 18 people. The continued incidence          reducing poverty or improving education            of terrorism was not significantly higher for
of terrorism prompts us to consider its root       would “meaningfully reduce international           poorer nations once one accounted for other
causes. It is popular to single out poverty or     terrorism.” 3 The authors reached their            country-specific characteristics such as the
lack of education as major factors.1 Recent        conclusion based on evidence from three            level of political freedom.6
economic literature, however, points more          sources: Hezbollah militant activities in the         The study by Bird and his co-authors
toward civil liberties, political rights and the   Gaza/West Bank region from 1998 to 2000,           comes to a different conclusion. They found
rule of law as far greater factors.                individual profiles from members of Israeli        that net exporters of terrorism were poorer
                                                   Jewish extremists in the late 1970s and from       nations, while terrorist targets (effectively,
Measuring Terrorism:                               a cross-country analysis using data from the       the importers of terrorism) were rich.
What Counts and How Much?                          U.S. State Department. Interestingly, the          Based on this observation, they suggest that
   Measuring the incidence and type of ter-        authors found that within the context of the       economic factors, among others, do have a
rorism is controversial. First, it is important    West Bank/Palestinian conflict, individu-          role in explaining both the origin and the
to distinguish between domestic and trans-         als who engaged in terrorism were better           location of terrorist acts.
national terrorism. The latter is generally        educated and economically more affluent
                                                   than the average citizen. This apparently          The Role of Political and Civil Rights
considered any event that involves citizens
or territories of more than one country,           paradoxical result may be better understood           The aforementioned study by Abadie
while the former is a local act carried out by     when one realizes that individuals’ incomes        focuses on the role that political freedom
citizens of the target country. (The attack        may correlate with their abilities. To suc-        plays in spurring terrorism.7 By studying
in New York City on 9/11 is a prominent            ceed in terrorist attacks in a heavily guarded     different nations, he finds that the incidence
example of transnational terrorism, where          environment (like Israel), one needs a             of terrorism is highest in nations with
foreign citizens carried out the attack. The       relatively high degree of skill and ability.       intermediate levels of political freedom.
bombing by Timothy McVeigh in Okla-                Therefore, it is natural for leaders of the ter-   Highly democratic and also highly auto-
homa City in April 1995 is an example of           rorist groups to choose more-able volunteers       cratic regimes both tend to experience
domestic terrorism.) It is also important to       so that a planned attack is more likely to be      less terrorism.
consider whether the number of incidents           successful.                                           A recent working paper by St. Louis
or the magnitude of events is more impor-             Another study, by Krueger and economist         Federal Reserve economist Subhayu Ban-
tant. This is brought out very clearly in the      David Laitin, analyzes the characteristics         dyopadhyay and co-author Javed Younas
accompanying graphs reproduced from the            of nations from which terrorism originates         explores the link between terrorism and
work of economists Graham Bird, S. Brock           and of target nations.4 They considered            political and civil rights in developing
Blomberg and Gregory Hess.2 While Figure 1         incidents of terrorism where the target and        nations, using a sample of 125 countries.
shows a drop-off in the number of terrorist        source nations of terrorism were distinct.         Disaggregating the data between domestic
incidents, Figure 2 shows a rise in the num-       They found that source nations of terror-          and transnational terrorism, they found that
ber of deaths per incident over time. This         ism were more likely to suffer from a lack         it was only domestic terrorism that was
10 The Regional Economist | October 2009
 figure 1                                                                                                                                                       endnotes
                                                                                                                                                                 1   For example, Chapter 5.7 of the 2008 Country
 Transnational Terrorist Incidents, 1968-2003                                                                                                                        Reports on Terrorism states the implicit
                                     700                                                                                                                             assumption that poverty can lead to terrorism:
                                                                                                                                                                     “High unemployment and underemployment,
To top