Docstoc

Rebuttal

Document Sample
Rebuttal Powered By Docstoc
					Robert A. Hall is the actor who plays the coroner on CSI if you       Comment [e1]: No. Not even close.
                                                                      Comment [e2]: From my job as MA state senator, or
watch that show.                                                      director of a number of associations after that.
                                                                      Comment [e3]: Except that he’s most likely very upper
                                                                      middle class or wealthy. But he’s sure like you to think that he’s
                                                                      a work-a-day stiff, just like you, because you’re easier to
                                                                      manipulate that way.
"I'm 63 and I'm Tired"                                                Comment [e4]: Who’s telling him this? Joe the plumber? Is
by Robert A. Hall                                                     a tax-cut for the middle class what he’s referring to? Because
                                                                      for about 90% of Americans, that’s what we got. Perhaps he’s
                                                                      referring to the expiration of the Bush tax cuts for the wealthy.
                                                                      Comment [e5]: Inflammatory crap. There’s no such thing as
                                                                      debtors’ prison since about 1770. But he does know his
                                                                      audience really well—all you folks holed up in Montana watch
                                                                      out for the gub’ment man and keep stocking that ammo and
                                                                      voting Republican.
                                                                      Comment [e6]: Quite a leap. I’d be interested to see if
                                                                      *anyone* could dig up a direct quote from somebody who’s a
                                                                      lawmaker who said that.
                                                                      Comment [e7]: Well Holy Smokes, all those days working
I'm 63. Except for one semester in college when jobs were             and not taking a break for sick leave has really fried the old
                                                                      boy’s brain.
scarce and a six-month period when I was between jobs, but job-       The Real Deal
hunting every day, I've worked, hard, since I was 18. Despite         So who is to blame? There's plenty of blame to go around, and it
some health challenges, I still put in 50-hour weeks, and haven't     doesn't fasten only on one party or even mainly on what
                                                                      Washington did or didn't do. As The Economist magazine noted
                                                                      recently, the problem is one of "layered irresponsibility ...
called in sick in seven or eight years. I make a good salary, but I   with hard-working homeowners and billionaire villains each
                                                                      playing a role." Here's a partial list of those alleged to be at
didn't inherit my job or my income, and I worked to get where I       fault:
                                                                         ·The Federal Reserve, which slashed interest rates after the
am. Given the economy, there's no retirement in sight, and I'm           dot-com bubble burst, making credit cheap.
                                                                         ·Home buyers, who took advantage of easy credit to bid up
tired. Very tired.                                                       the prices of homes excessively.
                                                                         ·Congress, which continues to support a mortgage tax
                                                                         deduction that gives consumers a tax incentive to buy more
                                                                         expensive houses.
I'm tired of being told that I have to "spread the wealth" to            ·Real estate agents, most of whom work for the sellers rather
                                                                         than the buyers and who earned higher commissions from
people who don't have my work ethic. I'm tired of being told the         selling more expensive homes.
                                                                         ·The Clinton administration, which pushed for less stringent
government will take the money I earned, by force if necessary,          credit and downpayment requirements for working- and
                                                                         middle-class families.
and give it to people too lazy to earn it.                               ·Mortgage brokers, who offered less-credit-worthy home
                                                                         buyers subprime, adjustable rate loans with low initial
                                                                         payments, but exploding interest rates.
                                                                         ·Former Federal Reserve chairman Alan Greenspan, who in
I'm tired of being told that I have to pay more taxes to "keep           2004, near the peak of the housing bubble, encouraged
                                                                         Americans to take out adjustable rate mortgages.
people in their homes." Sure, if they lost their jobs or got sick,       ·Wall Street firms, who paid too little attention to the quality
                                                                         of the risky loans that they bundled into Mortgage Backed
I'm willing to help. But if they bought McMansions at three              Securities (MBS), and issued bonds using those securities as
                                                                         collateral.
times the price of our paid-off, $250,000 condo, on one-third of         ·The Bush administration, which failed to provide needed
                                                                         government oversight of the increasingly dicey mortgage-
                                                                         backed securities market.
my salary, then let the left-wing Congress-critters who passed           ·An obscure accounting rule called mark-to-market, which
                                                                         can have the paradoxical result of making assets be worth
Fannie and Freddie and the Community Reinvestment Act that               less on paper than they are in reality during times of panic.
                                                                         ·Collective delusion, or a belief on the part of all parties that
created the bubble help them with their own money.                       home prices would keep rising forever, no matter how high
                                                                         or how fast they had already gone up.                       ... [1]
I'm tired of being told how bad America is by left-wing
millionaires like Michael Moore, George Soros and Hollywood
Entertainers who live in luxury because of the opportunities
America offers. In thirty years, if they get their way, the United   Comment [e8]: I’m tired of hearing how somehow it’s only
                                                                     “liberal millionaires” who aren’t to be trusted, and somehow
                                                                     millionaire bottom-feeders like Murdoch, Limbaugh, Hannity,
States will have the economy of Zimbabwe , the freedom of the        and Newt Gingrich are patriots and saints for the cause.
                                                                     Legends in their own minds.
press of China , the crime and violence of Mexico ,
the tolerance for Christian people of Iran , and the freedom of
speech of Venezuela .


I'm tired of being told that Islam is a "Religion of Peace," when
every day I can read dozens of stories of Muslim men killing
their sisters, wives and daughters for their family "honor"; of
Muslims rioting over some slight offense; of Muslims                 Comment [e9]: Islam is to terrorism what Christianity is to
                                                                     the KKK or the IRA.

murdering Christian and Jews because they aren't "believers"; of
Muslims burning schools for girls; of Muslims stoning teenage
rape victims to death for "adultery"; of Muslims mutilating the
genitals of little girls; all in the name of Allah, because the
Qur'an and Shari'a law tells them to.


I'm tired of being told that "race doesn't matter" in the post-      Comment [e10]: I’m pretty sure nobody of color would say
                                                                     this.

racial world of Obama, when it's all that matters in
affirmative action jobs, lower college admission and graduation
standards for minorities (harming them the most), government
contract set-asides, tolerance for the ghetto culture of violence
and fatherless children that hurts minorities more than anyone,
and in the appointment of U.S. Senators from Illinois.               Comment [e11]: I’m sure being Editor of the Harvard Law
                                                                     review and being a professor of Constitutional Law was just
                                                                     Barry eating chicken and picking his Jheri curl all day.
I think it's very cool that we have a black president and that a      Comment [e12]: Translation: “I just wish it were a darkie
black child is doing her homework at the desk where Lincoln           who agreed with me. What does an upper class white guy from
                                                                      Massachusetts have to do to get minorities to see it my way?”
 wrote the Emancipation Proclamation. I just wish the black           Should I somehow do something to make it so that they had
president was Condi Rice, or someone who believes more in             more opportunities to actually see my perspectives on things,
                                                                      what with incentives to get out of their fatherless, violent
                                                                      ghettos and come to the schools where my children are, and
freedom and the individual and less arrogantly of an all-knowing      have some assistance to go to the colleges where my children
                                                                      go?
government.
                                                                      Nah. Bootstrap-it; everything will work out because my
                                                                      ideology says that everything will work out.

                                                                      Comment [e13]: Apples vs Orchards: Comparing
                                                                      Inauguration Costs
I'm tired of a news media that thinks Bush's fundraising and          Category: bad math
                                                                      Posted on: January 20, 2009 4:16 PM, by Mark C. Chu-Carroll
inaugural expenses were obscene, but that think Obama's, at           People keep sending me links to this, so I'll make a short post
                                                                      about it.
triple the cost, were wonderful; that thinks Bush exercising daily    In the hubbub surrounding the Obama inauguration, there've
                                                                      been all sorts of incredulous press pieces discussing the

was a waste of presidential time, but Obama exercising is a great     supposed outrageousness of the costs of this inauguration
                                                                      compared to others. I've personally heard this reported on the
                                                                      BBC world service, CNN, Fox, and MSNBC. In these reports,
example for the public to control weight and stress; that picked      the cost of the Obama inauguration is generally reported as
                                                                      between 150 and 160 million dollars. When they provide a
over every line of Bush's military records, but never demanded        contrast, they talk about how Bush's second inauguration cost
                                                                      $40 million.
that Kerry release his; that slammed Palin, with two years as         The problem is, this is a metric error. They're comparing apples
                                                                      to orchards.

governor, for being too inexperienced for VP, but touted Obama        When they cite the Bush inauguration cost as $40 million,
                                                                      they're talking about the cost of the inauguration parties - that is,
                                                                      the cost of the festivities themselves. That cost does not include
with three years as senator as potentially the best president ever.   security. It does not include the cost of paying police to shut
                                                                      down the city streets. It doesn't include the cost of cleaning up
Wonder why people are dropping their subscriptions or                 after the crowds. It's just the cost of the parties.
                                                                      The Obama figure of $150-$160 million includes everything -
switching to Fox News? Get a clue. I didn't vote for Bush in          police, security, setup, and cleanup.
                                                                      A fair comparison? If you exclude the security costs, Bush's
                                                                      second inauguration cost $42 million; Obama's is expected to
2000, but the media and Kerry drove me to his camp in 2004.           cost around $45 million. If you include the security costs,
                                                                      Bush's second inauguration cost somewhere around $155
                                                                      million. (The exact figures are still not public knowledge; Bush
                                                                                                                                    ... [2]
I'm tired of being told that out of "tolerance for other cultures"    Comment [e14]: And the fact that Sarah Palin is a
                                                                      certifiable boob and her nomination (why not Olympia Snowe?)
we must let Saudi Arabia use our oil money to fund mosques            was a transparent attempt to peel Hillary voters off the Dem
                                                                      ticket. I’m not sure which is sadder; that McCain (or rather, his
and mandrassa Islamic schools to preach hate in America , while       strategists), picked an unvetted rube who fills a pantsuit and
                                                                      spouts Republican mad-lib bromides, or the fact that people
no American group is allowed to fund a church, synagogue or           actually voted for him after that.

religious school in Saudi Arabia to teach love and tolerance.         Comment [e15]: Something to think about. This is the cost
                                                                      of cheap oil. Just like the war on drugs, we fund both sides of it.
                                                                      Comment [e16]: “Lower his living standard?” Wasn’t he
I'm tired of being told I must lower my living standard to            just griping about people and their “McMansions?”

fight global warming, which no one is allowed to debate. My           And of course, we can debate global warming. I’ll bring all the
                                                                      scientific data amassed over the last 50 years, and the
wife and I live in a two-bedroom apartment and carpool together       overwhelming consensus of the community who devotes their
                                                                      lives to studying this phenomena, and expert testimony from
five miles to our jobs. We also own a three-bedroom condo             climatologists, seismologists, weather experts, and the work
                                                                      that spans all Western countries’ accepted science, and you

where our daughter and granddaughter live. Our carbon                 bring your opinion and your folksy sayings.

                                                                      At the end, we’ll have mooseburgers.
footprint is about 5% of Al Gore's, and if you're greener than        Comment [e17]: Because it’s about taking pot-shots at Al
                                                                      Gore and not being “responsible for your own actions.”

Gore, you're green enough.
I'm tired of being told that drug addicts have a disease, and I
must help support and treat them, and pay for the damage they
do. Did a giant germ rush out of a dark alley, grab them, and
stuff white powder up their noses while they tried to fight it off?
I don't think Gay people choose to be Gay, but I damn sure think      Comment [e18]: This must be an unpopular point for his
                                                                      more ardent supporters.

druggies chose to take drugs. And I'm tired of harassment from
cool people treating me like a freak when I tell them I never         Comment [e19]: ?


tried marijuana.
I'm tired of illegal aliens being called "undocumented
workers," especially the ones who aren't working, but are living
on welfare or crime. What's next? Calling drug dealers,               Comment [e20]: Citation? Or do they just live next-door to
                                                                      his imaginary welfare queen?

"Undocumented Pharmacists"? And, no, I'm not against                  They’re probably called undocumented workers because they
                                                                      come here illegally and we hire the hell out of them—else they
Hispanics. Most of them are Catholic, and it's been a few             probably wouldn’t bother making the trip.

hundred years since Catholics wanted to kill me for my religion.
 I'm willing to fast track for citizenship any Hispanic person,
who can speak English, doesn't have a criminal record and who
is self-supporting without family on welfare, or who serves
honorably for three years in our military.... Those are the           Comment [e21]: Already in place.


citizens we need.
I'm tired of latte liberals and journalists, who would never wear     Comment [e22]: Just one and the same. Nothing to see
                                                                      here, workaday folks.

the uniform of the Republic themselves, or let their entitlement-     Comment [e23]: There has been *no* military backlash
                                                                      about our current two fronts on the seemingly neverending
handicapped kids near a recruiting station, trashing our military.    “war on terror.” No Dem OR Republican would do this as it
                                                                      would be political suicide. On the other hand, keeping these
They and their kids can sit at home, never having to make split-      wars out of the spotlight has made sure that they have now
                                                                      gone on longer than Vietnam, and nobody is truly conscious of
second decisions under life and death circumstances, and bad          what military family members are going through.

mouth better people than themselves. Do bad things happen in          Nobody in the military that I know would think of themselves
                                                                      as “better than anyone else.”
war? You bet. Do our troops sometimes misbehave? Sure.                Also, the people that I know in the Marine Corps and Navy also
Does this compare with the atrocities that were the policy of our     gladly acknowledge that you can be a patriot and love your
                                                                      country without putting on a helmet and pulling a trigger. Lots
                                                                      of people do this by being good citizens.
enemies for the last fifty years and still are? Not even close.
So here's the deal. I'll let myself be subjected to all the
humiliation and abuse that was heaped on terrorists at Abu
Ghraib or Gitmo, and the critics can let themselves be subject to   Comment [e24]: Because they were all terrorists and we
                                                                    threw out Habeas Corpus because we needed to torture and
                                                                    kill sometimes those terrorists for information that would get
captivity by the Muslims, who tortured and beheaded Daniel          Osama Bin Laden and end this “War On Terror” more quickly.

Pearl in Pakistan, or the Muslims who tortured and murdered         Except that neither of those things have happened, and now
                                                                    instead of the world thinking of us as the *one* place *in the
Marine Lt. Col. William Higgins in Lebanon, or the Muslims          world* where we treat even our enemies with fairness under
                                                                    the rule of law as now being just the “Great Satan” that they
who ran the blood-spattered Al Qaeda torture rooms our troops       always knew we were, and now they can show films of Gitmo
                                                                    and other torture facilities and increase their ranks in orders of
found in Iraq, or the Muslims who cut off the heads of              magnitude they wouldn’t have dreamed of if we’d been playing
                                                                    chess all along instead of checkers.
schoolgirls in Indonesia, because the girls were Christian. Then
we'll compare notes. British and American soldiers are the only
troops in history that civilians came to for help and handouts,
instead of hiding from in fear.
I'm tired of people telling me that their party has a corner on
virtue and the other party has a corner on corruption. Read the
papers; bums are bipartisan. And I'm tired of people telling me
we need bipartisanship. I live in Illinois , where the "Illinois
Combine" of Democrats has worked to loot the public for years.
Not to mention the tax cheats in Obama's cabinet.                   Comment [e25]: Yeah, bums are bipartisan—but it’s mostly
                                                                    Democrats! Impeccable logic.


I'm tired of hearing wealthy athletes, entertainers and
politicians of both parties talking about innocent mistakes,
stupid mistakes or youthful mistakes, when we all know they
think their only mistake was getting caught. I'm tired of people
with a sense of entitlement, rich or poor.
Speaking of poor, I'm tired of hearing people with air-
                                                                    Comment [e26]: The who and the what now? I think we
conditioned homes, color TVs and two cars called poor. The          can all agree that a trailer, a cabinet TV, and two Hondas do
                                                                    not the Rockefellers make.
majority of Americans didn't have that in 1970, but we didn't       But by that same logic, is anyone who doesn’t have all of those
know we were "poor." The poverty pimps have to keep                 things *actually* poor? Is anyone who has more than that
                                                                    “rich”?
changing the definition of poor to keep the dollars flowing.        Does my third Honda come with a cummerbund and a
                                                                    monacle?
I'm real tired of people who don't take responsibility for their   Comment [e27]: If you’re a writer, you should learn to
                                                                   spell. Unless, that is, you’re adopting a folksy mask to herd
                                                                   your workaday sheep to the ballot box.
lives and actions. I'm tired of hearing them blame the
government, or discrimination or big-whatever for their
problems.                                                          Comment [e28]: I’m tired of hearing wealthy Republicans
                                                                   blame poor people for being poor.


Yes, I'm tired. But I'm also glad to be 63. Because, mostly, I'm
not going to have to see the world these people are making. I'm    Comment [e29]: You mean fellow citizens who
                                                                   overwhelmingly repudiated your ideology and your ability to
                                                                   lead the country forward in the last election, as dictated by the
just sorry for my granddaughter                                    constitution of the United States, the same one you upheld to
                                                                   serve and protect when you wore her uniform?

Robert A. Hall is a Marine Vietnam veteran who served five         You don’t like the process when it doesn’t go your way?
                                                                   Shocking.
terms in the Massachusetts State Senate.
There is no way this will be widely publicized, unless each of     Comment [e30]: Translation: “Because it doesn’t really
                                                                   bear out any facts at all, it’s just the ramblings of a guy who’s
                                                                   uber-right and likes to share his malformed opinions.”
us sends it on!
This is your chance to make a difference.
Page 1: [1] Comment [e7]                             eXPerience                                 6/22/2010 16:28:00
Well Holy Smokes, all those days working and not taking a break for sick leave has really fried the old boy’s brain.



                                                 The Real Deal

So who is to blame? There's plenty of blame to go around, and it doesn't fasten only on one party
or even mainly on what Washington did or didn't do. As The Economist magazine noted recently,
the problem is one of "layered irresponsibility ... with hard-working homeowners and billionaire
villains each playing a role." Here's a partial list of those alleged to be at fault:

    ·    The Federal Reserve, which slashed interest rates after the dot-com bubble burst, making
         credit cheap.

    ·    Home buyers, who took advantage of easy credit to bid up the prices of homes
         excessively.

    ·    Congress, which continues to support a mortgage tax deduction that gives consumers a
         tax incentive to buy more expensive houses.

    ·    Real estate agents, most of whom work for the sellers rather than the buyers and who
         earned higher commissions from selling more expensive homes.

    ·    The Clinton administration, which pushed for less stringent credit and downpayment
         requirements for working- and middle-class families.

    ·    Mortgage brokers, who offered less-credit-worthy home buyers subprime, adjustable rate
         loans with low initial payments, but exploding interest rates.

    ·    Former Federal Reserve chairman Alan Greenspan, who in 2004, near the peak of the
         housing bubble, encouraged Americans to take out adjustable rate mortgages.

    ·    Wall Street firms, who paid too little attention to the quality of the risky loans that they
         bundled into Mortgage Backed Securities (MBS), and issued bonds using those securities
         as collateral.

    ·    The Bush administration, which failed to provide needed government oversight of the
         increasingly dicey mortgage-backed securities market.

    ·    An obscure accounting rule called mark-to-market, which can have the paradoxical result
         of making assets be worth less on paper than they are in reality during times of panic.

    ·    Collective delusion, or a belief on the part of all parties that home prices would keep
         rising forever, no matter how high or how fast they had already gone up.
just political grandstanding. We have no advice to offer on how best to solve the financial crisis.
But these sorts of partisan caricatures can only make the task more difficult.

Page 3: [2] Comment [e13]                     eXPerience                          6/22/2010 16:41:00



Apples vs Orchards: Comparing Inauguration Costs
Category: bad math
Posted on: January 20, 2009 4:16 PM, by Mark C. Chu-Carroll

People keep sending me links to this, so I'll make a short post about it.

In the hubbub surrounding the Obama inauguration, there've been all sorts of incredulous press
pieces discussing the supposed outrageousness of the costs of this inauguration compared to
others. I've personally heard this reported on the BBC world service, CNN, Fox, and MSNBC. In
these reports, the cost of the Obama inauguration is generally reported as between 150 and 160
million dollars. When they provide a contrast, they talk about how Bush's second inauguration
cost $40 million.

The problem is, this is a metric error. They're comparing apples to orchards.

When they cite the Bush inauguration cost as $40 million, they're talking about the cost of the
inauguration parties - that is, the cost of the festivities themselves. That cost does not include
security. It does not include the cost of paying police to shut down the city streets. It doesn't
include the cost of cleaning up after the crowds. It's just the cost of the parties.

The Obama figure of $150-$160 million includes everything - police, security, setup, and
cleanup.

A fair comparison? If you exclude the security costs, Bush's second inauguration cost $42
million; Obama's is expected to cost around $45 million. If you include the security costs, Bush's
second inauguration cost somewhere around $155 million. (The exact figures are still not public
knowledge; Bush and company treated it as a "national security matter" which did not need to be
disclosed.)

Yet another fake controversy brought to you by the supposedly liberal-biased media.

				
DOCUMENT INFO
Shared By:
Categories:
Tags:
Stats:
views:141
posted:6/22/2010
language:English
pages:8