Conservatism and Liberalism

Document Sample
Conservatism and Liberalism Powered By Docstoc
					       Conservatism and Liberalism
   Great Britain as a test case for the conservative
    backlash against liberalism.
   Remember, everything is relative, and Britain is
    the “most liberal” of any nation Europe
   Remember also that Parliament is dominated by
    the interests of the wealthy
   How much do they really represent the “needs”
    of the people
               Do Now: 1.16.04
   AP: Set up notebook for mini-presentation on
    Conservative Reaction to Liberalism in Britain
    and France.
   Read Frankenstein or Kagan for 15 minutes.
   Homework: Frankenstein Chapters 1-10 for
    Tuesday. Take reading notes, handwritten, and
    use these for the test
   Kagan: pages 724-733 for Wednesday, 1.21.04
       Conservatism and Liberalism
   Further, there has always been a historic belief
    that the Government of Britain was the
    “paternalistic protector” of the people…a sort
    of social contract existed
   Conditions and the call for change…
       Conservatism and Liberalism
   1815 – post Napoleonic Europe
   Britain has a series of bad harvests and high
   Rather than deal with this, Lord Liverpool
    protects the interests of those who have the
    greatest influence, and he pushes the Corn
    Laws through Parliament
   This is conservatism in action
       Conservatism and Liberalism
   The Corn Laws – are emblematic of a simply
    economic plan; protect domestic corn grown by
    wealthy landholders
   These wealthy landholders are also
    parliamentarians, or have relationships with them
   By driving up prices, using import duties and
    tariffs, of foreign grain, domestic prices rise as
    do profits for the wealthy
       Conservatism and Liberalism
   Unfortunately, the urban poor, the unemployed and the
    rural poor are adversely affected by this move
   Who is looking out for their interests?
   Further, by abandoning the income tax a year later, the
    wealthy are able to keep more of the money they are
   Also, by passage of the Combination Acts in 1799,
    workers organizations are outlawed and wages are no
    longer protected
       Conservatism and Liberalism
   Hence, you have a climate where the very
    legislative body who got a king to sign the Bill of
    Rights is abandoning their mandate to represent
    the interests of the people
   Remember, this is not particular to England, but
    we, ostensibly, expect much more from them…
       Conservatism and Liberalism
   It become an inevitably that the lower classes
    would not take all of this lying down
   And, as these “masses” begin to voice
    discontent, the government can only think of
    the chaos of the French Revolution, and the
    sans-culottes running wild in the streets
   Like most governments we have seen, the
    British will not deal lightly with calls for change
    that will affect their social status and Power
       Conservatism and Liberalism
   By Passage of the Coercion Act – By repealing
    the writ of “Habeas Corpus” – guaranteed by
    the Bill of Rights – parliament reflects in a much
    less severe scale the Law of 22 Prairial during the
    Reign of Terror
   This leads us to “Peterloo, and the Six Acts”
       Conservatism and Liberalism
   The reference to Waterloo is intentional!
   Labor organizers in Britain were more active in
    the north because that is where the
    Industrialized centers were!
   Remember that as far as the government was
    concerned, you could not organize at all!
   Those gathered in St. Peter’s fields who
    demanded reform were lawbreakers, and had to
    be dealt with! ( You can recognize the duplicity)
       Conservatism and Liberalism
   Why Peterloo is significant is that it lead to the
    justification and passage of the “Six Acts”
   This is often referenced on the exam, and are a
    great example to use to exemplify the
    conservative backlash against the growing tide
    of Liberalism
       Conservatism and Liberalism
   The Six Acts:
   Large (unauthorized) Meetings are forbidden
   Fined for “seditious libel” slander against the
    Government) are raised
   Trial for agitators are expedited
   Newspaper taxes increased
   No training of armed groups
   Home could be searched if necessary
        Conservatism and Liberalism
   What happens naturally after such draconian
    measures, is that tensions will rise, the people
    will act (inappropriately) and the government
    will then have and
       “You see, I told you so” moment

   Any action after that is totally justified, but the
    subtext is that The Law enforces, but it does
    not represent!
       Conservatism and Liberalism
   France and The Bourbon Restoration
   Louis XVIII (Brother of the deposed monarch)
    will have a difficult situation to manage
   What level or degree of the gains of the
    Revolution must be maintained
   And, how much of his rule must mirror the
    conservative Monarchical “reactionism” of his
    European Contemporaries
       Conservatism and Liberalism
   France was different than it was under his
    brother, and there was no way to “un-ring” that
   France was under a Charter, which was a hybrid
    of a Monarchy and an Constitutional Monarchy
   Usually, when you try and play both sides of the
    street you end up getting run over.
       Conservatism and Liberalism
   The Upper House were Monarchical Appointees
   The Lover House (Chamber of Deputies) were
    elected, but the “franchise” (voting rights and
    specifications) skewed the Chamber toward the
    wealthy landowners
   Hence, “The People” are not exactly highly
       Conservatism and Liberalism
   The Charter:
   Guarantees the Rights in the Declaration of the Rights
    of man and the Citizen (for now)
   Religious toleration (but…Catholicism in the de-facto
    religion of France
   Property that changed hands during the Revolution
    remains in those hands
   This, obviously, will anger those who are looking for a
    return to the Ancien Regime (like the rest of Europe)
        Conservatism and Liberalism
   UltraRoyalism (This is also know as reactionism)
   Royalists take advantage of the climate of chaos after
    Napoleons downfall to rise up against former
    revolutionaries (White Terror)
   Even after the King dismisses the Chamber of
    Deputies for being too reactionary, a moderate
    Chamber will eventually turn on him as well
   Big Issue: if the monarchy is not sufficient, what is to
    be done and who will do it?
        Conservatism and Liberalism
   Here is a thematic connection between Britain
    and Europe
   Louis XVIII will eventually bow to the pressure
    of the UltraRoyalists and pass repressive
     “Electoral Reform” to benefit the wealthy
     Press Censorship

     Arrests of suspicious persons were facillitated
       Conservatism and Liberalism
   Summary statements
   If we look at Britain and France, and examine
    them though the lens of the Conservative Order
    struggling in the face of Liberalism, we can see
    some interesting parallels…
       Conservatism and Liberalism
   Britain             France
       Conservatism and Liberalism
   Britain             France
       Conservatism and Liberalism
   The Conservative Order
   Maintain the Status Quo
   Congresses and Consultations are the root of
    the Alliance Systems that would lead to WWI
   This system of Cooperation was known as the
    “Concert of Europe”
   How is this concert of Europe shown or
        Conservatism and Liberalism
   Treaty of Aix-la Chapelle
     Big Four remove their troops from France
     France re-Admitted to the Concert of Europe
           “No Blood-No Foul”
   Yet, within the Congress there were differing
    views on the extent to which they should police
    Russia believes in upholding the borders
   Britain does not
        Conservatism and Liberalism
   The beginnings of the revolutionary periods in
   By looking at these revolutions we can measure
    two things
     The degree to which they represent any margin of
      Victory for the liberal cause
     The degree to which the conservative order was able
      to withstand a challenge to their way of life.
       Conservatism and Liberalism
   Revolutionary Template
   Area
   Existing Governmental structure
   Challenges to that structure/Issues of
   The Involvement of outside forces
   The Extent to which the Congress of Europe
    was able to maintain the Balance of Power
       Conservatism and Liberalism
   Spain:
   Existing Monarchy: The Bourbon Ferdinand
   Issue: Ferdinand reneges on the promise of a
    written constitution.
   Abolishes the Cortez and chooses t rule alone
   He is threatened by army officers and backs
    down; score on for the resistance
       Conservatism and Liberalism
   This and another revolt in the Kingdom of the Two
    Sicily's makes Metternich nervous: Was the Concert of
    Europe beginning to falter?
   After appealing top the others in the Holy Alliance
    Prussian and Russia they come to an agreement at the
    Congress of Troppau.
   Here the so-called “Protocol of Troppau” is formed.
    This stated that stable governments might
    intervene/restore order where revolution was
       Conservatism and Liberalism
   Keep in mind that while these countries are all
    looking after the interest of each other, they all
    have agendas of their own.
   For instance, Metternich is interested in
    protecting the Habsburg interest in Northern
    Italy as much as he is in maintaining some
    manner of control over the force of Liberalism.
   Hence, there is a fine line between cooperation
    and self interest.
Conservatism and Liberalism
Conservatism and Liberalism
Conservatism and Liberalism
Conservatism and Liberalism
Conservatism and Liberalism
Conservatism and Liberalism
Conservatism and Liberalism
Conservatism and Liberalism
Conservatism and Liberalism
Conservatism and Liberalism
Conservatism and Liberalism
Conservatism and Liberalism
Conservatism and Liberalism
Conservatism and Liberalism
Conservatism and Liberalism
Conservatism and Liberalism
Conservatism and Liberalism
Conservatism and Liberalism
Conservatism and Liberalism
Conservatism and Liberalism
Conservatism and Liberalism