Competitive Intelligence: What is It & It’s Status
Jerry P. Miller Director Competitive Intelligence Center Simmons College Boston, MA
+1-617-521-2809 +1-671-521-3141 (fax) jmiller@simmons.edu cic.simmons.edu
Conduct Intelligence to:
Gain a Competitive Advantage
The Intelligence Function:
• The process of ethically collecting, analyzing, and disseminating accurate, relevant, specific, timely, foresighted and actionable intelligence regarding the implications of the business environment, competitors, and the organization itself.
NOM May 15, 2001 Jerry P. Miller
3
The Intelligence Function:
• Gather information from primary & secondary sources • Upgrade information to intelligence incorporating analyst’s perspective • Generate insights and suggestions • Disseminate to decision makers who take action that can gain a competitive advantage for the firm
NOM May 15, 2001 Jerry P. Miller 4
The Intelligence Process is NOT:
• • • • Industrial/Economic Espionage Corporate Spying Routing news clippings Searching the Web
NOM May 15, 2001 Jerry P. Miller
5
Why Intelligence?
• Managers need to increase the quality of: 1) products or services 2) strategic planning and 3) market knowledge • That results in higher business performance
NOM May 15, 2001 Jerry P. Miller
6
How Do I Know if I Need an Intelligence Function?
Well, how critical are the questions that keep you awake at night?
How Many Resources Are Enough?
Well, how many key managers are currently obtaining and using adequate intelligence effectively for decision making?
Strategic Intelligence:
• Emphasizes the relationship between the intelligence function and strategic decisionmaking
NOM May 15, 2001 Jerry P. Miller
9
Business Intelligence:
• Incorporates the monitoring of a wide array of developments across an organization’s external environment, which includes customers, competitors, suppliers, economic issues as well as technical and regulatory changes
NOM May 15, 2001 Jerry P. Miller
10
Technical Intelligence:
• • • • • Monitors research and development issues Reduces risky decision making Broadens awareness of competitive situation Identifies business alternatives Increases warning time from 31 to 37 months in chemical/pharmaceuticals industry and from 17 to 33 months in other industries
NOM May 15, 2001 Jerry P. Miller
11
Counterintelligence:
• Protects intelligence collection activities and protects plans, programs, and projects from adversaries • Hire security specialists • Train employees not to give away sensitive information • Computer usage heightens importance
NOM May 15, 2001 Jerry P. Miller 12
Who’s Doing Competitive Intelligence?
• • • • • • • 90% of Fortune 500 firms in the U.S. 9% of U.S. firms with formal processes Chemical and telecommunications firms Firms with high R&D expenditures Firms that own many patents 2-3% of German firms in various industries U.S. & U.K. firms: leading intelligence producers
NOM May 15, 2001 Jerry P. Miller 13
How Do Leading Firms Conduct Intelligence?
• • • • • • • Broadcast intelligence to users Increase number of intelligence users View intelligence as decision critical Intelligence is part of managers’ duties Institutionalize the intelligence function Manage corporate knowledge assets Maintain and rely on during a recession
NOM May 15, 2001 Jerry P. Miller 14
Primary Information Sources (Find Experts!):
• Interviews with internal experts, customers, and suppliers • Marketplace surveys • Industry analysts • Business editors • Associations • Observations • Unpublished documents
NOM May 15, 2001 Jerry P. Miller 15
Secondary Information Sources:
• • • • • • Internal and external databases Industry and government reports Directories Statistical sources Newspapers and magazines Trade publications
NOM May 15, 2001 Jerry P. Miller
16
Criteria Not to be Overlooked:
• • • • • • Balance strategic & operational needs Adjust the function as the market changes Determine locus of decision making Company’s structure Corporate culture Market environment
NOM May 15, 2001 Jerry P. Miller 17
Common Problems:
Managers don’t value intelligence Managers consider intelligence a luxury Inability to incorporate it into strategy Managers believe “I know my industry!” Unskilled people try to perform intelligence Managers hoard information The function doesn’t meet the real needs and concerns of decision makers • Intelligence is seldom used by decision makers (A.S. e.g.)
NOM May 15, 2001 Jerry P. Miller 18
• • • • • • •
Creating the Intelligent Firm:
• • • • • Adjust decision-making process & culture Open communication lines Sensitize firm to marketplace changes Align intelligence to decision-making Support the process with technology
NOM May 15, 2001 Jerry P. Miller
19
Excellent Intelligence Service:
• • • • • Clearly define intelligence needs Use creative sources Understand the complexity of the issues Upgrade information to intelligence Offer recommendations, suggestions, and alternatives • Obtain feedback from decision makers
NOM May 15, 2001 Jerry P. Miller 20
Motivator:
What’s in It for Me?
Motivational Issues
• What are the benefits to the firm? • What are the benefits to decision makers? • What are the benefits for intelligence professionals?
NOM May 15, 2001 Jerry P. Miller
22
Predict & Measure the Impact of the Intelligence Function
• • • • Determine where & how impacts will occur Determine your competitive advantage Assess appropriateness of costs (cf. CFO) Measure impacts in terms of:
– Time- or cost-saving – Cost avoidance – Revenue enhancement
NOM May 15, 2001 Jerry P. Miller 23
Various Roles in the Intelligence Process
• Core Roles:
– – – – primary researchers secondary researchers analysts integrators
• Supporting Roles:
– – – – – system builders data builders knowledge builders protectors decision makers
NOM May 15, 2001 Jerry P. Miller
24
Intelligence Skills Come From:
• • • • Personal traits Formal education Mentoring Work experience
NOM May 15, 2001 Jerry P. Miller
25
NOM May 15, 2001 Jerry P. Miller
26
Competitive Intelligence:
It’s Current Status
NOM May 15, 2001 Jerry P. Miller
28
NOM May 15, 2001 Jerry P. Miller
29
NOM May 15, 2001 Jerry P. Miller
30
NOM May 15, 2001 Jerry P. Miller
31
NOM May 15, 2001 Jerry P. Miller
32
NOM May 15, 2001 Jerry P. Miller
33
NOM May 15, 2001 Jerry P. Miller
34
NOM May 15, 2001 Jerry P. Miller
35
NOM May 15, 2001 Jerry P. Miller
36
NOM May 15, 2001 Jerry P. Miller
37
NOM May 15, 2001 Jerry P. Miller
38
Where is the Intelligence Profession Going?
• More firms, regardless of size, establish intelligence • Development of more sophisticated and accurate measurement techniques • Deterioration of centralized intelligence functions • The business community pressures academics to teach intelligence
NOM May 15, 2001 Jerry P. Miller 39
Where Going Continued...
• Most industrialized countries adopt standards to protect trade secrets • More extensive background checks of potential executives • More firms establish guidelines for conducting intelligence • The volume of legal cases establishes a body of legal precedent
NOM May 15, 2001 Jerry P. Miller 40
Where Going Continued...
• Corporate leaders demand a deeper analysis of critical issues • Internationalization of business leads to a varying sets of business conduct • Information technologies will enable an increase in unethical collection attempts
NOM May 15, 2001 Jerry P. Miller
41
NOM May 15, 2001 Jerry P. Miller
42
Coming up Today
• • • • • Learn how to search the Invisible Web Use the Web and alerting services to do CI Use the right application to support CI Using workflow applications to support CI Learn how to diagnosis and fix knowledge based, value-creation processes • Learn to create knowledge correctly to sustain a competitive advantage
NOM May 15, 2001 Jerry P. Miller 43