100% Money back guaranteed

Document provided by...: www.proquest.com; (Learn more...); ProQuest creates specialized information resources and technologies that propel successful research, discovery, and lifelong learning.

Are you the owner of this document? Click here for information on why it's on Docstoc.

About This Document: A common view, shared by legal theorists and ordinary people, is that there is and should be a close, positive relation between ethics and law, that law should, and commonly does, embody ethical principles. There is certainly some validity in this view. But there is at least as much error as validity, for ethics and law are also deeply opposed. I am not referring here to contingent oppositions-particular laws that are immoral, particular judges who are corrupt. I am referring to a fundamental contradiction between the principles that guide ethical adjudication and those that guide legal action. This contradiction is one of the tensions that can make human life tragic. As such, it is also bound up with the development of tragedy in art. The following essay begins by examining the irreconcilability of law and ethics. It then takes up the relation of this to tragedy in both literature and life. It concludes by considering two works- one modern (Krzysztof Kieslowski's Decalogue V), one ancient (Aeschylus' Eumenides)-that treat this tragic irreconcilability and that suggest how ethical considerations might curb the otherwise inevitable cruelties of law. [PUBLICATION ABSTRACT]

Stats: Type:
Acrobat PDF; Size:
1602 kb; Pages:
30; Views:
0; Posted:
05/28/10

Categories: DocStore > Periodicals > Humanities
Tags: College Literature, Summer 2008, TRAGIC LIVES: ON THE INCOMPATIBILITY ..., Hogan, Patrick Colm, Feature, Ethics, Legislation, Law, Human error, Ancient languages

TRAGIC LIVES: ON THE INCOMPATIBILITY OF LAW AND ETHICS

Document Sample

TRAGIC LIVES: ON THE INCOMPATIBIL

By registering with docstoc.com you agree to our
privacy policy and terms of service