Docstoc

EXTERNAL

Document Sample
EXTERNAL Powered By Docstoc
					                                                                       ANNEXURE 3
                LEGAL COSTS OF APPEALS CONDUCTED BY
                        EXTERNAL SOLICITORS

                        DEVELOPMENT APPLICATION MATTERS
                      FOR PERIOD 1 JULY 2005 TO 30 JUNE 2006
                                                    2006           2005
                                                   ACTUAL         ACTUAL
                                                     $              $

SOLICITORS                                          354,903.00     121,778.00
BARRISTERS                                           62,121.00      17,962.00
PLANNING – EXTERNAL                                  40,100.00      37,820.00
PLANNING – INTERNAL                                  51,517.00      14,952.00
LANDSCAPING AND HORTICULTURE                         72,919.00             0
TRAFFIC                                              17,505.00             0
ENGINEERING (EXTERNAL)                                 8,247.00            0
ENGINEERING (INTERNAL)                               12,950.00       4,622.00
ECOLOGY                                                4,650.00            0
VALUATION                                              4,000.00      1,500.00
INTERNAL LEGAL SUPPORT                               11,915.00       7,151.00
DISBURSEMENTS                                        17,281.00       2,967.00
SUB TOTAL                                           658,108.00     208,752.00
LESS: COSTS RECOVERED                                14,200.00
LESS SECTION 94 RECOUP                               41,000.00
TOTAL COSTS                                        $602,908.00    $208,752.00




D:\DOCSTOC\WORKING\PDF\EEE0DB28-504D-4F69-8F58-2F1622A6FF40.DOC
                                             1
                                                                                                                            ANNEXURE 3
                                                       EXTERNAL
                                        LAND AND ENVIRONMENT COURT MATTERS
                                      FOR THE PERIOD 1 JULY 2005 TO 30 JUNE, 2006
                                          DEVELOPMENT APPLICATION MATTERS

    APPELLANT                          DETAILS                                COMMENTS                                     COSTS
John Gilbert             228 Kingsway CARINGBAH NSW                Issues:                              Disbursements:                 $20.00
Court No: 03/10098       2229                                      • Impact on adjoining residents      Solicitor (Ext):              $975.00
Project No: E13091       Application No: DA02/2067                 • Scale                              Total                         $995.00
Solicitor File:          Deemed Refusal of Development             • Out of character with
03/00107                 Housing for Older Persons or              surroundings
                         Persons with a Disability, Strata         • Floor Space Ratio                  Note: Entry for cost purposes only
                         Subdivision & Boundary Adjustment         • Landscaping Issues
                         Determined by: LEC                        • Setbacks from boundaries
                         Solicitor: G Green/Pike Pike &            • Car parking
                         Fenwick                                   • Streetscape
                                                                   • Visual Impact
                                                                   • Privacy

                                                                   Outcome: Settled
                                                                   A negotiated settlement was
                                                                   reached following the submission
                                                                   of amended plans which satisfied
                                                                   the majority of Council's planning
                                                                   objectives and the Applicant
                                                                   agreed to remove an existing right
                                                                   of carriageway over 8A Oleander
                                                                   Parade, thus requiring all vehicle
                                                                   movement to be to and from
                                                                   Kingsway.


 D:\DOCSTOC\WORKING\PDF\EEE0DB28-504D-4F69-8F58-2F1622A6FF40.DOC
                                                                      2
    APPELLANT                          DETAILS                                 COMMENTS                                       COSTS
JCS Developments         64 Glaisher Parade CRONULLA               Issues:                                 Disbursements:               $530.69
Pty Ltd                  NSW 2230                                  • Building Height                       Solicitor (Ext):             $690.50
Court No: 03/10565       Application No: DA03/0310                 • Floor Space Ratio                     Total                       $1,221.19
Project No: E13110       Deemed Refusal of Development             • Landscaping Issues
Solicitor File:          New Two (2) Storey Dwelling and           • Building Bulk                         Costs recovered from
03/00343                 Swimming Pool and Demolition of an        • Size of Buildings                     2004/5 expenditure          $7,102.72
                         Existing Dwelling                         • Impact on adjoining residents
                         Determined by:
                         Solicitor: J Cole/Abbott Tout             Outcome: Appeal Dismissed               Note: Entry for cost purposes only
                                                                   The Appeal was decided in
                                                                   Council's favour as the Court found
                                                                   that the size, height and bulk of the
                                                                   proposed dwelling would impact on
                                                                   the amenity and views of adjoining
                                                                   residencies and would be out of
                                                                   character with the adjoining
                                                                   residential devleopment.
Sammut                   163 David Road BARDEN RIDGE               Outcome:                                Solicitor (Ext):            $4,636.50
Developments             NSW 2234                                  The Appeal was discontinued by          Total                       $4,636.50
Court No: 03/10839       Application No: DA03/0155                 the Applicant.
Project No: E13121       Deemed Refusal of Development                                                     Costs recovered from
Solicitor File:          Eight (8) Townhouses and Strata                                                   2004/5 expenditure          $7,000.00
03/00486                 Subdivision
                         Determined by:
                         Solicitor: J Reilly/Abbott Tout                                                   Note: Entry for cost purposes only




 D:\DOCSTOC\WORKING\PDF\EEE0DB28-504D-4F69-8F58-2F1622A6FF40.DOC
                                                                      3
    APPELLANT                          DETAILS                                COMMENTS                                    COSTS
Upperclass               152-158 Taren Point Road                  Issues:                               Disbursements:                 $19.91
Developments Pty Ltd     CARINGBAH NSW 2229                        • Building Height                     Total                          $19.91
Court No: 03/11355       Application No: DA02/1679                 • Floor Space Ratio
Project No: E13139       Deemed Refusal of Development
Solicitor File:          Three (3) Storey Building for Bulky       Outcome:                              Note: Entry for cost purposes only
03/00778                 Goods Retailing & Associated Uses &       The Application was approved by
                         Parking                                   the Council at its Meeting held on
                         Determined by: Council                    29 November 2004. The Court
                         Solicitor: G Green/Pike Pike &            stoodover the proceedings to allow
                         Fenwick                                   to Applicant and Council to discuss
                                                                   any concerns regarding the
                                                                   conditions of consent. The
                                                                   Applicant without discussion
                                                                   discontinued the Proceedings.
Australand Holdings      422-450 Captain Cook Drive                Outcome:                              Landscape/Horticulture:       $660.00
Ltd                      KURNELL NSW 2231                          Heard in conjunction with Appeal      Total                         $660.00
Court No: 04/11330       Application No: MA06/0048                 Nos 10123/00 and 10124/00.
Project No: E13180        of Development
Solicitor File:          S96(1A) Modification to DA05/1149 -                                             Note: Entry for cost purposes only
04/00847                 Modify Approved Stage 1 Subdivision
                         Works and Related Landscaping into
                         Two (2) Substages and Modify
                         Condition 53 to Remove Restrictive
                         Covenant on all Allotments Specifying
                         the 9m Maximum Height of Buildings
                         Determined by:
                         Solicitor: B Woolf/Woolf Associates
                         Barrister: T Robertson




 D:\DOCSTOC\WORKING\PDF\EEE0DB28-504D-4F69-8F58-2F1622A6FF40.DOC
                                                                      4
    APPELLANT                          DETAILS                                 COMMENTS                                      COSTS
Alan J Wild & Anne M     368 President Avenue GYMEA NSW            Outcome: Appeal Dismissed              Disbursements:                 $59.77
Wild                     2227                                      The Applicant gave undertakings to     Solicitor (Ext):            $1,776.50
Court No: 04/11468       Application No: NOT08073                  the Court that meet Council's          Total                       $1,836.27
Project No: E13184       Appeal against Order of Development       requirements.
Solicitor File:          Section 124 Orders (Local
04/11468                 Government Act)
                         Determined by:
                         Solicitor: J Reilly/Abbott Tout
Cresville Pty Ltd        356 Port Hacking Road CARINGBAH           Issues:                                Disbursements:                  $2.00
Court No: 04/11525       NSW 2229                                  • Public Interest                      Solicitor (Ext):              $583.00
Project No: E13186       Application No: DA04/0924                                                        Total                            $585
Solicitor File:          Refusal of Development                    Outcome: Appeal Upheld
04/00936                 Business Development - Use of a           The Appeal was not decided in
                         Shop as a Sex Shop for Sale of            Council's favour. The Court            Note: Entry for cost purposes only
                         Adults Publications, Clothes and          granted consent for a limited period
                         Accessories                               terminating 12 months from 7 June
                         Determined by: Council                    2005. The Court also imposed a
                         Solicitor: J Reilly/Abbott Tout           number of conditions governing the
                                                                   management of the use.
Adrienne L Ebsworth      22-30 Brighton Street BUNDEENA            Issues:                                Solicitor (Int):               $22.37
Court No: 04/11664       NSW 2230                                  • Car parking                          Solicitor (Ext):           $63,374.82
Project No: E13189       Application No: DA03/1552                 • Building Height                      Planning (Int):             $6,714.99
Solicitor File:          Refusal of Development                    • Privacy                              Disbursements:              $1,472.25
04/00965                 Ancillary Development to Business                                                Planning (Ext):             $7,963.75
                         Premises - Additions and Alterations      Outcome:                               Engineering (Int):          $3,026.74
                         to Existing Shops and Alteration to       Further amended plans have been        Traffic:                    $8,066.86
                         Three (3) Existing Residential Units to   submitted by the Applicant.            Total                      $90,641.78
                         Create a Totalof Nine (9) Residential     Appointed voluntary administrator
                         Dwellings and Strata Subdivision into     for the Applicant is reviewing the
                         17 Lots                                   current position of the proceedings.
                         Determined by: Delegated
                         Solicitor: G Green/Pike Pike &            Callover 21/07/06
                         Fenwick
 D:\DOCSTOC\WORKING\PDF\EEE0DB28-504D-4F69-8F58-2F1622A6FF40.DOC
                                                                      5
    APPELLANT                          DETAILS                                 COMMENTS                                 COSTS
Baker Kavanagh           36-40 Brighton Street, Bundeena           Issues:                              Solicitor (Int):              $49.23
Architects               Refusal of Development Application        • Building Bulk                      Solicitor (Ext):          $37,026.00
Court No: 05/10082       No. DA04/0325 for a mixed                 • Building Height                    Planning (Int):            $2,221.35
Project No: E13191       commercial/residential development        • Out of character with              Barrister:                 $4,250.00
Solicitor File:          comprising of seven units, two            surroundings                         Disbursements:             $1,326.33
05/00106                 commercial premises and eleven            • Floor Space Ratio                  Planning (Ext):            $6,765.90
                         carparking spaces                         • Privacy                            Engineering (Int):         $1,274.27
                         Determined by: Council                    • Car parking                        Traffic:                   $5,155.00
                         Solicitor: G Green/Pike Pike &                                                 Total                     $58,068.08
                         Fenwick                                   Outcome: Appeal Upheld
                                                                   The Court approved the proposal
                                                                   following the submission of a
                                                                   number of sets of amended plans
                                                                   by the applicant.
Marcia S                 35 Holt Road TAREN POINT NSW              Issues:                              Planning (Int):            $4,475.65
Christofidellis          2229                                      • Building Height                    Solicitor (Ext):           $8,689.00
Court No: 05/10100       Application No: DA04/1840                 • Floor Space Ratio                  Disbursements:             $1,185.98
Project No: E13192       Refusal of Development                    • Landscaping Issues                 Landscape/Horticulture:    $8,500.00
Solicitor File:          Demolition of Existing Dwelling,          • Structures below Foreshore         Total                     $22,850.63
05/00113                 Construction of New Dwelling,             Building Line
                         Swimming Pool and Associated
                         Landscaping                               Outcome:
                         Determined by:                            A negotiated settlement was
                         Solicitor: J Cole/Abbott Tout             achieved through design and layout
                                                                   changes that were acceptable to
                                                                   Council.




 D:\DOCSTOC\WORKING\PDF\EEE0DB28-504D-4F69-8F58-2F1622A6FF40.DOC
                                                                      6
    APPELLANT                          DETAILS                                 COMMENTS                                      COSTS
BBS Holdings Pty Ltd     143-145 Elouera Road CRONULLA             Issues:                                Solicitor (Ext):            $1,560.00
Court No: 05/20124       NSW 2230                                  • Impact on adjoining residents        Total                       $1,560.00
Project No: E13194       Application No: POPE04/0036
Solicitor File:          Deemed Refusal of Development             Outcome:
05/20124                 POPE Northies increase in numbers         The Applicant discontinued the
                         from 1210 to 1600                         Appeal following negotiated
                         Determined by:                            settlement of the issues.
                         Solicitor: M McMahon
Anglican Retirement      2-28 Alexander Avenue TAREN               Issues:                                Disbursements:                  $7.78
Villages Diocese Of      POINT NSW 2229                            • Amenity in General                   Solicitor (Ext):              $154.00
Sydney                   Application No: DA04/1249                 • Design                               Total                         $161.78
Court No: 05/10259       Deemed Refusal of Development             • Validity of s.94 contributions
Project No: E13196       Stages 3 and 4 of a 5 stage Seniors
Solicitor File:          Living Development - (Woolooware          Outcome:                               Note: Entry for cost purposes only
05/00201                 Shores) Retirement Village consisting     A negotiated settlement was
                         of Three (3) and Four (4) Storey          achieved as design changes were
                         Building containing One Hundred and       made which are acceptable to
                         Forty Three (143) Self Care Units,        Council's in house architect. The
                         One Hundred and Eighty Six (186)          Council, by resolution, withdrew the
                         Vehicular Parking Spaces and              requirement for monetary
                         Landscaping                               contribution towards the acquisition
                         Determined by:                            of open space due to the area of
                         Solicitor: J Cole/Abbott Tout             foreshore land under the proposal
                                                                   intended to be transferred to
                                                                   Council at no cost.




 D:\DOCSTOC\WORKING\PDF\EEE0DB28-504D-4F69-8F58-2F1622A6FF40.DOC
                                                                      7
    APPELLANT                          DETAILS                                COMMENTS                                      COSTS
Sammut                   18 Coast Avenue CRONULLA NSW              Issues:                               Solicitor (Int):             $266.35
Developments             2230                                      • Building Height                     Solicitor (Ext):           $27,081.50
Court No: 05/10266       Application No: DA04/1127                 • Floor Space Ratio                   Planning (Int):             $4,463.68
Project No: E13198       Deemed Refusal of Development             • Landscaping Issues                  Disbursements:               $289.94
Solicitor File:          Demolition of the Existing Buildings,     • Setbacks from boundaries            Planning (Ext):             $7,862.31
03/00486                 Construction of a Four (4) Storey         • Privacy                             Traffic:                    $2,814.75
                         Residential Flat Building Containing      • View Loss                           Total                      $42,778.53
                         Four (4) Units with Basement              • Streetscape
                         Parking for 13 Vehicles and Strata        • Solar Access
                         Title Subdivision.                        • Out of character with
                         Determined by:                            surroundings
                         Solicitor: G Green/Pike Pike &            • Vehicular access
                         Fenwick
                                                                   Outcome: Appeal Upheld
                                                                   TheCouncil did not support
                                                                   Council’s arguments in respect to
                                                                   height and general issue of
                                                                   overdevelopment of the site.
Traudel Kapanke &        27 The Crescent WORONORA NSW              Comment:                              Solicitor (Int):            $1,014.72
Manfred Kapanke          2232                                      The respective valuers and quality    Solicitor (Ext):           $17,557.29
Court No: 05/30291       Application No: Crt06/0002                surveyors are joint conferencing in   Barrister:                 $18,400.00
Project No: E13199       Deemed Refusal of Development             an attempt to reach an agreed         Disbursements:               $903.20
Solicitor File:          Appeal against Property Valuation         position.                             Engineering (Int):          $2,332.09
05/00230                 Determined by:                                                                  Total                       $40,207.3
                         Solicitor: Solicitor: L. Finn/Abbott
                         Tout
                         Barrister: J Ayling




 D:\DOCSTOC\WORKING\PDF\EEE0DB28-504D-4F69-8F58-2F1622A6FF40.DOC
                                                                      8
    APPELLANT                          DETAILS                                COMMENTS                                    COSTS
Tony C Buchanan &        35 The Crescent WORONORA NSW              Outcome:
Kerrie J Buchanan        2232                                      Being heard in conjunction with
Court No: 05/30290       Application No: Crt06/0001                Appeal No 3029/05.
Project No: E13199       Deemed Refusal of Development
Solicitor File:          Appeal against Property Valuation         Callover 21/07/06
05/00230                 Determined by:
                         Solicitor: L. Finn/Abbott Tout
                         Barrister: J Ayling
Trudy L K Moyle &        31 The Crescent WORONORA NSW              Outcome:
Gregory J Moyle          2232                                      Being heard in conjunction with
Court No: 05/30292       Application No: Crt06/0003                Appeal No 3029/05.
Project No: E13199       Deemed Refusal of Development
Solicitor File:          Appeal against Property Valuation
05/00230                 Determined by:
                         Solicitor: L. Finn/Abbott Tout
                         Barrister: J Ayling
Donna Lowe               31 Bate Bay Road CRONULLA NSW             Issues:                                Internal Planning:              $6.00
Court No: 05/10355       2230                                      • Car parking                          Disbursements:                 $82.79
Project No: E13202       Application No: DA03/1273                 • Traffic                              Total                          $88.79
Solicitor File:          Refusal of Development
05/00246                 Use of Cronulla High School for           Outcome: Appeal Upheld
                         Markets Held 21 Times a Year              The Appeal was not decided in          Note: Entry for cost purposes only
                         Determined by: Council                    Council's favour. The Court
                         Solicitor: G Green/Pike Pike &            granted consent for a limited period
                         Fenwick                                   of 12 months.




 D:\DOCSTOC\WORKING\PDF\EEE0DB28-504D-4F69-8F58-2F1622A6FF40.DOC
                                                                      9
    APPELLANT                          DETAILS                                COMMENTS                                    COSTS
Meriton Property         2 Corea Street SYLVANIA NSW               Issues:                                Solicitor (Int):               $78.61
Management Pty Ltd       2224                                      • Floor Space Ratio                    Solicitor (Ext):           $46,601.50
Court No: 05/10427       Application No: DA05/0188                 • Building Height                      Planning (Int):            $13,387.99
Project No: E13206       Deemed Refusal of Development             • Landscaping Issues                   Disbursements:              $2,590.24
Solicitor File:          Medium Density Development -              • Visual Impact                        Landscape/Horticulture:    $56,214.54
05/00296                 Construction of 90 Townhouses,            • Traffic                              Planning (Ext):             $6,056.00
                         Swimming Pool, Communal                   • Urban Design Issues                  Engineering (Int):             $80.52
                         Recreation Facilities, Basement                                                  Total                     $125,009.40
                         Carparking for 166 Vehicles & Strata      Outcome: Appeal Dismissed
                         Title Subdivision                         Further amended plans were
                         Determined by:                            submitted by the Applicant,
                         Solicitor: J Cole/Abbott Tout             however, they failed to resolve
                                                                   Council's issues.
Harbour Port             107 Kangaroo Point Road                   Issues:                                Solicitor (Int):            $1,986.36
Constructions            KANGAROO POINT NSW 2224                   • Cumulative Impact                    Solicitor (Ext):            $7,040.50
Court No: 05/10580       Application No: DA04/1903                 • Fender Piles                         Planning (Int):             $4,703.87
Project No: E13209       Refusal of Development                    Outcome:                               Disbursements:                 $89.43
Solicitor File:          Development Below the Foreshore           The Applicant is reviewing the         Engineering:                 $700.00
05/00326                 Building Line - Construction of Jetty,    current position of the Proceedings.   Engineering (Int):             $92.60
                         Ramp & Pontoon                                                                   Total                      $14,612.76
                         Determined by: Delegated Authority        Hearing 13 -14/07/06
                         Solicitor: J Cole/Abbott Tout
Katrina Sachmacinski     19 Cumbee Lane CARINGBAH NSW              Issues:                                Solicitor (Int):            $1,006.24
Court No: 05/10708       2229                                      Outcome: Appeal Upheld                 Solicitor (Ext):            $7,350.00
Project No: E13214       Application No: DA04/1313                 Amended design negotiated that, in     Planning (Int):              $420.25
Solicitor File:          Refusal of Development                    part, achieved Council's planning      Disbursements:                 $49.86
05/00358                 Construction of a New Two Storey          objectives.                            Engineering (Int):           $339.97
                         Dwelling and Demolition of the                                                   Sub Total                   $9,166.32
                         Existing Dwelling                                                                Less: costs recovered          $23.43
                         Determined by: Delegated Authority                                               Total                       $9,142.89
                         Solicitor: G Green/Pike Pike &
                         Fenwick

 D:\DOCSTOC\WORKING\PDF\EEE0DB28-504D-4F69-8F58-2F1622A6FF40.DOC
                                                                      10
    APPELLANT                          DETAILS                                COMMENTS                                     COSTS
Thornbrook Properties    72 Yathong Road CARINGBAH                 Issues:                              Solicitor (Int):               $65.64
Court No: 05/10759       NSW 2229                                  Outcome: Consent Orders              Solicitor (Ext):           $12,169.00
Project No: E13216       Application No: DA04/0793                 Amended plans submitted by the       Planning (Int):              $405.25
Solicitor File:          Deemed Refusal of Development             Applicant that reduced the impacts   Disbursements:               $457.64
05/00380                 Demolition of Existing Structures and     on the adjoining medium density      Planning (Ext):             $5,726.25
                         Construction of 22 X 3 Bedroom            housing to the south were            Engineering (Int):           $972.25
                         Townhouses with Basement                  acceptable to the Court appointed    Total                      $19,796.03
                         Carparking and Strata Subdivision         planning expert and Council's
                         Determined by:                            planning assessment officers.
                         Solicitor: J Cole/Abbott Tout             Accordingly, the Court issued
                                                                   Consent Orders.
Thornbrook Properties    252 Kingsway CARINGBAH NSW                Outcome: Consent Orders              Solicitor (Int):               $65.64
Court No: 05/10758       2229                                      Heard in conjunction with Appeal     Solicitor (Ext):            $1,431.00
Project No: E13217       Application No: DA04/0795                 No. 10759/05.                        Planning (Int):              $150.09
Solicitor File:          Deemed Refusal of Development                                                  Disbursements:                 $88.25
05/00381                 Demolition of Existing Structures and                                          Planning:                   $5,726.25
                         Construction of 18 x Three (3)                                                 Total                       $7,461.23
                         Bedroom Townhouses with
                         Basement Carparking and Strata
                         Subdivision
                         Determined by:
                         Solicitor: J Cole/Abbott Tout




 D:\DOCSTOC\WORKING\PDF\EEE0DB28-504D-4F69-8F58-2F1622A6FF40.DOC
                                                                     11
    APPELLANT                          DETAILS                                 COMMENTS                                     COSTS
Mars Capital             96-98 Loftus Street BUNDEENA              Issues:                               Solicitor (Int):               $22.65
Corporation Pty Ltd &    NSW 2230                                  • Out of character with               Solicitor (Ext):           $32,886.00
Mars Consolidated        Application No: DA04/1213                 surroundings                          Planning (Int):             $9,899.66
Pty Limited              Deemed Refusal of Development             • Building Bulk                       Disbursements:              $3,518.62
Court No: 05/10977       Construction of a Three (3) Storey        • Car parking                         Landscape/Horticulture:     $7,543.95
Project No: E13222       Building Containing Four (4) Shops        • Visual Impact                       Engineering (Int):          $3,554.36
Solicitor File:          and Eleven (11) Residential Units         • Floor Space Ratio                   Traffic:                    $1,468.75
05/00437                 with a Basement Carpark with              • Design                              Valuations:                 $4,000.00
                         Accommodation for Twenty Eight (28)       • Streetscape                         Total                      $62,893.99
                         Vehicles                                  • Scale
                         Determined by: Council                    • SEPP65 Issues
                         Solicitor: G Green/Pike Pike &
                         Fenwick                                   Comment:
                                                                   Amended plans do not satisfy
                                                                   Council's issues.
                                                                   Hearing 3-4/8/06
Rocla Pty Ltd            278 Captain Cook Drive KURNELL            Outcome:                              Planning (Int):              $390.23
Court No: 05/10447       NSW 2231                                  Expert reports being finalised.       Solicitor (Ext):           $32,781.50
Project No: E13224       Application No: Crt06/0004                Callover 27/07/06                     Barrister:                 $22,320.80
Solicitor File:          Ministerial refusal of a proposal to                                            Disbursements:              $2,849.18
05/00313                 extract sand.                             Comment:                              Engineering:                $5,447.00
                         Determined by:                            Council is party to the proceedings   Ecology                     $4,650.00
                         Solicitor: B Woolf/Woolf Associates       as objector.                          Total                      $68,438.71
                         Barrister: T. Robertson




 D:\DOCSTOC\WORKING\PDF\EEE0DB28-504D-4F69-8F58-2F1622A6FF40.DOC
                                                                      12
    APPELLANT                          DETAILS                                COMMENTS                                     COSTS
Joe Ryan Lawyer          41-45 Gymea Bay Road GYMEA                Outcome: Appeal Dismissed            Planning (Int):             $1,245.76
Court No: 05/11091       NSW 2227                                                                       Solicitor (Ext):           $10,852.00
Project No: E13226       Application No: MA05/0172                                                      Barrister:                  $6,650.00
Solicitor File:          Refusal of Development                                                         Disbursements:               $505.01
05/00457                 S96(2) Modification to DA03/0661 -                                             Total                      $19,252.77
                         Change of Hours to Allow 24 Hour
                         Trading Monday to Saturday and
                         10am to 12 Midnight Sunday
                         Determined by: Director
                         Solicitor: J Reilly/Abbott Tout
                         Barrister: A Pickles
Jefferson M E            288 Prince Charles Parade                 Comment:                             Solicitor (Int):             $155.87
Robinson                 KURNELL NSW 2231                          Negotiations undertaken to settle    Solicitor (Ext):            $5,896.50
Court No: 03/11128       Application No: MA05/0313                 the proceedings and outcomes         Total                       $6,052.37
Project No: E13228       Deemed Refusal of Development             being considered by the Applicant.
Solicitor File:          S96 Modification Application -
05/00459                 Amendment to Land and
                         Environment Court Approval
                         Determined by:
                         Solicitor: J Reilly/Abbott Tout
Harbour Port             21 Grays Point Road GRAYS POINT           Issues:                              Solicitor (Int):             $599.97
Constructions            NSW 2232                                  • Cumulative Impact                  Solicitor (Ext):            $2,023.50
Court No: 05/11081       Application No: DA04/1445                 • Fender Piles                       Planning (Int):                $60.04
Project No: E13230       Refusal of Development                                                         Disbursements:                  $7.80
Solicitor File:          Development within the Waterway -         Outcome:                             Total                       $2,691.31
05/00473                 Installation of Two (2) Pontoon Piles     The Appeal was discontinued by
                         Determined by: Delegated Authority        the Applicant.
                         Solicitor: J Cole/Abbott Tout




 D:\DOCSTOC\WORKING\PDF\EEE0DB28-504D-4F69-8F58-2F1622A6FF40.DOC
                                                                     13
    APPELLANT                          DETAILS                                COMMENTS                      COSTS
Harbour Port             5 Wareemba Place LILLI PILLI NSW          Issues:               Solicitor (Int):            $674.75
Constructions            2229                                      • Cumulative Impact   Solicitor (Ext):           $1,659.00
Court No: 05/11083       Application No: DA04/1968                 • Fender Piles        Planning (Int):               $60.04
Project No: E13232       Deemed Refusal of Development                                   Disbursements:                 $2.40
Solicitor File:          Waterway Development - Jetty Ramp         Comment:              Engineering:                $700.00
05/00472                 & Pontoon                                                       Total                      $3,096.19
                         Determined by:                            Hearing 21/07/06
                         Solicitor: J Cole/Abbott Tout
Harbour Port             43 Harrow Street SYLVANIA NSW             Issues:               Solicitor (Int):            $660.58
Constructions            2224                                      • Cumulative Impact   Solicitor (Ext):           $1,749.90
Court No: 05/11084       Application No: DA05/0364                 • Fender Piles        Planning (Int):               $60.04
Project No: E13233       Deemed Refusal of Development                                   Engineering:                $700.00
Solicitor File:          Development Below the Foreshore           Comment:              Total                      $3,170.52
05/00471                 Building Line - Jetty, Ramp and
                         Pontoon                                   Hearing 21/07/06.
                         Determined by:
                         Solicitor: J Cole/Abbott Tout
Harbour Port             86 Parthenia Street DOLANS BAY            Issues:               Solicitor (Int):            $434.42
Constructions            NSW 2229                                  • Cumulative impact   Solicitor (Ext):           $1,971.00
Court No: 05/11085       Application No: DA04/1134                 • Fender Piles        Planning (Int):               $60.04
Project No: E13234       Refusal of Development                                          Disbursements:                $28.00
Solicitor File:          Development below Mean High               Hearing 21/07/06      Engineering:                $700.00
05/00475                 Water Mark - Two (2) Fender Piles                               Total                      $3,193.46
                         Determined by: Delegated
                         Solicitor: J Cole/Abbott Tout




 D:\DOCSTOC\WORKING\PDF\EEE0DB28-504D-4F69-8F58-2F1622A6FF40.DOC
                                                                     14
    APPELLANT                          DETAILS                                COMMENTS                                  COSTS
Harbour Port             1A Yellambie Street YOWIE BAY             Outcome:                          Solicitor (Int):            $659.87
Constructions            NSW 2228                                  The Applicant discontinued the    Solicitor (Ext):           $3,314.50
Court No: 05/11155       Application No: DA04/1451                 Proceedings.                      Planning (Int):               $60.04
Project No: E13235       Refusal of Waterway Development                                             Disbursements:              $291.65
Solicitor File:          and Development below the                                                   Sub Total                  $4,326.06
05/00479                 Foreshore Building Line - Replace                                           Less: costs recovered         $74.50
                         Existing Pontoon with New Pontoon                                           Total                      $4,251.56
                         and Two (2) Fender Piles and
                         Replace Slip Rails
                         Determined by: Delegated Authority
                         Solicitor: J Cole/Abbott Tout
Dimensional Capital      31 Durbar Avenue KIRRAWEE NSW             Comment:                          Planning (Int):             $300.18
Design Pty Ltd           2232                                      Further amended plans being       Solicitor (Ext):           $7,630.00
Court No: 05/11475       Application No: DA04/1219                 notified.                         Disbursements:              $271.76
Project No: E13239       Refusal of Development                                                      Engineering (Int):         $1,277.84
Solicitor File:          Construction of a Medium Density          Callover 21/09/06                 Total                      $9,479.78
05/00550                 Development, Consisting of 15 x 3
                         Bedroom Townhouses with
                         Basement Carparking and Tree
                         Removal
                         Determined by: Delegated Authority
                         Solicitor: J Cole/Abbott Tout
H & J Standen Pty Ltd    72 Parthenia Street DOLANS BAY            Comment:                          Disbursements:                $12.00
Court No: 06/10015       NSW 2229                                  Negotiations continuing between   Solicitor (Ext):           $5,123.90
Project No: E13243       Application No: NOT08722                  the Parties.                      Total                      $5,135.90
Solicitor File:          Appeal against Order of Development
06/10015                 Prevention Notice (POEO Act)
                         Determined by:
                         Solicitor: J Cole/Abbott Tout




 D:\DOCSTOC\WORKING\PDF\EEE0DB28-504D-4F69-8F58-2F1622A6FF40.DOC
                                                                     15
    APPELLANT                          DETAILS                                 COMMENTS                                       COSTS
Stephen Fleming          84 Cronulla Street CRONULLA NSW           Comment:                                Solicitor (Int):             $231.64
Court No: 06/10157       2230                                      Section 82A application for a           Solicitor (Ext):            $1,225.00
Project No: E13246       Application No: DA05/0900                 review of the Council\rquote s          Planning (Int):              $840.51
Solicitor File:          Refusal of Business Development -         decision being assessed.                Total                       $2,297.15
06/00181                 Use of the First Floor of a Building as
                         a Nightclub with a Capacity of 450        Callover 01/08/06
                         Persons
                         Determined by: Council
                         Solicitor: J Cole/Abbott Tout
Innovative Building      30 Wilson Parade HEATHCOTE                Issues:                                 Solicitor (Int):            $3,852.71
Design                   NSW 2233                                  • Car parking                           Solicitor (Ext):            $1,956.00
Court No: 06/10290       Application No: DA05/1137                 • Traffic                               Planning (Int):              $840.49
Project No: E13248       Refusal of Development                                                            Disbursements:                 $82.18
Solicitor File:          Ancillary Development to Existing         Comment:                                Total                       $6,731.38
06/00221                 Long Day Care Centre - Alterations
                         and Additions                             Hearing 28/07/06
                         Determined by: Delegated Authority
                         Solicitor: J Cole/Abbott Tout
Burwood Area             115 Georges River Road JANNALI            Outcome:                                Solicitor (Int):               $67.94
Community Housing        NSW 2226                                  Point of Law - The Court ruled in       Solicitor (Ext):            $7,137.50
Ltd                      Application No: DA06/0186                 Council's favour in deciding that the   Planning (Int):              $750.44
Court No: 06/10325       Refusal of Development                    Applicant cannot rely on the            Barrister:                 $10,500.00
Project No: E13249       Demolition of Existing Structures and     provision of the Seniors Living         Disbursements:               $536.54
Solicitor File:          Construction of Housing for Aged or       State Environmental Policy              Total                      $18,992.42
06/00230                 Disabled People, Containing Seventy       meaning that the proposal will need
                         (70) Aged Care Bedrooms and Three         to meet the development standards
                         (3) Self-Contained Community              and planningobjectives of
                         Housing Units with Basement Car           Sutherland Shire Local
                         Parking and Associated Landscape          Environmental Plan, 2000.
                         Works
                         Determined by: Delegated Authority        Comment: Amended plans
                         Solicitor: J Cole/Abbott Tout             submitted by the Applicant.
                         Barrister: T Robertson                    Hearing 31/08/06 - 01/09/06
 D:\DOCSTOC\WORKING\PDF\EEE0DB28-504D-4F69-8F58-2F1622A6FF40.DOC
                                                                      16
    APPELLANT                          DETAILS                                 COMMENTS                      COSTS
David Crane &            119-121 Parraweena Road                   Issues:                           Total           $0
Associates Pty Ltd       MIRANDA NSW 2228                          • Flooding
Court No: 06/10521       Application No: DA06/0240                 • Public safety
Project No: E13255       Deemed Refusal of Development
Solicitor File:          Commercial Construction -                 Comment:
06/00303                 Alterations and Additions including       Amended plas being submitted by
                         Change of Use from Retail Plant           the Applicant.
                         Nursery to Fresh Food Market
                         including a New Café/Delicatessen         Callover 12/08/06
                         Determined by:
                         Solicitor: G Green/Pike Pike &
                         Fenwick
Serenity Cove            238-258 Captain Cook Drive                Comment :                         Total           $0
Business Park Pty Ltd    KURNELL NSW 2231
Court No: 06/30363       Application No: Crt06/0012                Callover 03/08/06
Project No: E13256       Class IV Action.
Solicitor File:          Claim for recovery of unapid rates
06/00288                 Determined by:
                         Solicitor: S. Griffiths/Pike Pike &
                         Fenwick




 D:\DOCSTOC\WORKING\PDF\EEE0DB28-504D-4F69-8F58-2F1622A6FF40.DOC
                                                                      17

				
DOCUMENT INFO