Documents
Resources
Learning Center
Upload
Plans & pricing Sign in
Sign Out

AEP

VIEWS: 77 PAGES: 11

									                                                                                                                       715501c8-60c0-4f4a-b037-942cb0a25430.xls




AEP
                                              Small
                                  Small     Javascript "Slow
                                Javascript             server"
                                            applicatio basic
                                applicatio n for real- Webmail           Monitoring    Power
                                n for real-   time     application       tool          manageme        Exchange        Lotus                     Basic Web
                     Note          time     monitorin , tests            (WhatsUp      nt              Outlook         Domino          Avocent   page                                     Windows         Citrix
                   applies to   monitorin       g      timing            by            application     Web             Web             KVM-over- (HTML                                    Terminal        Presentatio                                               # of    # of
 Clients/Apps       all Apps     g (HTTP) (HTTPS) issues.                Ipswitch)      (APC)          Access          Access          IP        only)              SMB server FTP server Services        n Server      Telnet          SSH           VOIP         Passes   Halfs
 Note applies
 to all Clients                                                                                                                                                                              (G)

   W2K/IE5.5                       Pass         Pass         F (F)          Pass        Half (B)        Half (C)       Half (C)(D)         F         Half (E)          Pass        F       Pass (G)         Pass+        Pass           Pass           Pass             9           4

  XP/IE6/User                      Pass         Pass         F (F)          Pass        Pass OK!        Pass (C)       Pass (C)(D)         F          Pass             Pass        F       Pass (G)         Pass+        Pass           Pass            F              12           0

XP/Firefox/User                    Pass         Pass          F             Pass          Pass            Pass          Pass (I)           F          Pass             Pass        F       Pass (G)          Pass       Pass (H)       Pass (H)         F              12           0

 XP/IE6/Admin                      Pass         Pass          F             Pass          Pass          Pass (C)       Pass (C)(D)         F          Pass             Pass        F       Pass (G)          Pass        Pass           Pass           Pass            13           0

XP/Firefox/Admin                   Pass         Pass          F             Pass          Pass            Pass          Pass (I)           F          Pass             Pass        F       Pass (G)          Pass        Pass           Pass            F              12           0

   Mac/Safari                      Pass         Pass          F             Pass          Pass          Pass (L)          F (K)            F         Pass (E)          Pass        F       Pass (J)          Pass       Pass (H)       Pass (H)         F              11           0

  Mac/Firefox                      Pass         Pass          F             Pass          Pass            Pass            F (I)            F          Pass             Pass        F          F                F           F              F             F               7           0

  Treo/Blazer          (M)        NOTEST       NOTEST       NOTEST        NOTEST        NOTEST          NOTEST          NOTEST          NOTEST          F               F          F       NOTEST          NOTEST       NOTEST         NOTEST         NOTEST            0           0

Symbian/Opera          (A)        NOTEST       NOTEST       NOTEST        NOTEST        NOTEST          NOTEST          NOTEST          NOTEST          F               F          F       NOTEST          NOTEST       NOTEST         NOTEST         NOTEST            0           0

  # of Passes                              7            7            0             7               6               6               4             0              6             7        0              6             6              6              6            2
  # of Halves                              0            0            0             0               1               1               1             0              1             0        0              0             0              0              0            0

      (A)          Sygate blocks login even if "allow to login if doesn't load" runs. If Sygate is disabled, then HTTP works with some corruption. The main page displays rendered unreadable because all the icons go off the screen.
      (B)          Some Javascript improperly rewritten, so logout is impossible
      (C)          Some HTML not rendered properly; some icons missing
      (D)          Lotus logout blew away the entire session.
      (E)          Some images did not load;needed to reload to get page properly.
      (F)          Timeout - doesn't wait long enough for transfer to complete. Also is causing some sort of breakin detection.
      (G)          Netilla also has its own terminal services client.
      (H)          HUGE (e.g., up to 1 minute or longer) delay in starting occasionally, sometimes outright failure; sometimes as fast as 20 seconds.
      (I)          Very poor performance, many features don't work. Can't send email, for example.
      (J)          Worked with native client, but not in port forwarding mode
      (K)          Did not display fallback option for unsupported browser.
      (L)          Had to re-authenticate
      (M)          Got logged in, but anything you click on goes nowhere
                                                                                                                     715501c8-60c0-4f4a-b037-942cb0a25430.xls




     Array
                                              Small
                                  Small     Javascript "Slow
                                Javascript             server"
                                            applicatio basic
                                applicatio n for real- Webmail          Monitoring      Power
                                n for real-   time     application      tool            manageme      Exchange       Lotus                   Basic Web
                     Note          time     monitorin , tests           (WhatsUp        nt            Outlook        Domino        Avocent   page                                 Windows         Citrix
                   applies to   monitorin       g      timing           by              application   Web            Web           KVM-over- (HTML                                Terminal        Presentatio                                                   # of    # of
 Clients/Apps       all Apps     g (HTTP) (HTTPS) issues.               Ipswitch)        (APC)        Access         Access        IP        only)          SMB server FTP server Services        n Server        Telnet          SSH           VOIP           Passes   Halfs
 Note applies
 to all Clients

   W2K/IE5.5                        F           F           Pass         Pass (B)          Pass          Pass          F (A)           F         Pass        Pass (G)    F (E)        Pass         Half (K)       Pass (I)       Pass (I)        Pass              10           1

  XP/IE6/User                       F           F           Pass         Pass (B)          Pass          Pass          F (A)           F         Pass        Pass (G)    F (E)        Pass         Half (K)        Pass           Pass           F (F)              9           1

XP/Firefox/User                     F           F           F (H)        Pass (B)          Pass          Pass          F (A)           F         Pass        Pass (G)    F (E)        Pass         Half (K)        Pass           Pass           F (F)              8           1

 XP/IE6/Admin                       F           F           Pass         Pass (B)          Pass          Pass          F (A)           F         Pass        Pass (G)    F (E)        Pass           Pass         Pass (I)       Pass (I)       Pass (J)           11           0

XP/Firefox/Admin                    F           F           F (H)        Pass (B)          Pass          Pass          F (A)           F         Pass        Pass (G)    F (E)        Pass         Half (K)        Pass           Pass          Pass (J)            9           1

   Mac/Safari          (C)          F           F            F              F                F            F              F             F          F             F        F (E)         F               F             F              F              F                0           0

  Mac/Firefox          (D)          F           F            F              F                F            F              F             F          F             F        F (E)         F               F             F              F              F                0           0

  Treo/Blazer          (D)       NOTEST       NOTEST       NOTEST        NOTEST          NOTEST        NOTEST         NOTEST        NOTEST        F             F        F (E)       NOTEST        NOTEST         NOTEST         NOTEST         NOTEST              0           0

Symbian/Opera          (D)       NOTEST       NOTEST       NOTEST        NOTEST          NOTEST        NOTEST         NOTEST        NOTEST        F             F        F (E)       NOTEST        NOTEST         NOTEST         NOTEST         NOTEST              0           0

  # of Passes                             0            0            3               5             5              5             0             0          5           5            0            5               1              5              5              3
  # of Halves                             0            0            0               0             0              0             0             0          0           0            0            0               4              0              0              0

       -           When using Secure Desktop, it forced the browser to be the system "default browser" (I.e., could switch browsers on you randomly). Bad behavior.
       -           Policy required Sophos, but Sygate reported wrong information, thus broke things in the XP User (non-Admin) case
      (A)          Works as long as you are moving. If you let it sit and refresh, Domino fails.
      (B)          Works - but should because ACL doesn't let it.
      (C)          Would not run with Safari. System went into an infinite loop and locked up the browser.
      (D)          Refused to run - says Java required, can't go on.
      (E)          FTP not supported
      (F)          Windows port forwarding won't run in user mode; fallback system listens on ports but does not forward connections.
      (G)          Configuration is case sensitive between portal and ACL. A good example of where the "loose coupling" management approach doesn't work. Poor design.
      (H)          Side bar does not appear.
      (I)          Port forwarder works, but Windows Redirector doesn't! It traps the connect and does some sort of a redirect, but the connection never happens.
      (J)          Doesn't work. Packets go to the PC, but nothing is ever emitted from the Array box. No, wait. This does work. Turns out to be a poor documentation/poor GUI issue instead. Fixed with help.
      (K)          Unreliable; sometimes is unable to connect
                                                                                                           715501c8-60c0-4f4a-b037-942cb0a25430.xls




Aventail

                                                        "Slow
                               Small        Small       server"
                            Javascript    Javascript    basic
                            application   application   Webmail       Monitorin   Power                                           Basic
                   Note      for real-     for real-    application   g tool      managem      Exchange    Lotus                  Web
                  applies      time          time       , tests       (WhatsUp    ent          Outlook     Domino       Avocent   page                               Windows     Citrix                                    # of
                   to all   monitoring    monitoring    timing         by         applicatio   Web         Web          KVM-      (HTML      SMB         FTP         Terminal    Presentati                                Passe   # of
 Clients/Apps      Apps       (HTTP)       (HTTPS)      issues.       Ipswitch)   n (APC)      Access      Access       over-IP   only)      server      server      Services    on Server    Telnet    SSH      VOIP        s     Halfs
Note applies to
  all Clients

  W2K/IE5.5          (J)          F             F             F            F           F           F            F         F (K)       F         Pass         F (N)       F           F          F        F       F (J)         1       0

 XP/IE6/User                  Pass (A)       Pass (A)      Half (C)      Pass        Pass       Half (B)      Pass        F (K)      Pass       Pass         F (N)     F (L)       F (L)       F (L)    Pass     F (D)         8       2
XP/Firefox/Us
      er                      Pass (A)       Pass (A)      Half (C)      Pass        Pass       Pass (B)      Pass        F (K)      Pass       Pass         F (N)     Pass         Half       Pass     Pass     F (D)        11       2

XP/IE6/Admin                  Pass (A)       Pass (A)      Half (C)      Pass        Pass       Half (B)      Pass        F (K)      Pass       Pass         F (N)     Pass         Pass       Pass     Pass    Pass (M)      12       2
XP/Firefox/Ad
     min                      Pass (A)       Pass (A)      Half (C)      Pass        Pass       Pass (B)      Pass        F (K)      Pass       Pass         F (N)     Pass         Pass       Pass     Pass    Pass (M)      13       1

  Mac/Safari                    Pass          Pass          Pass         Pass        Pass       Half (E)      Pass        F (K)      Pass       Pass         F (N)    Pass (I)    Pass (I)      F        F       F (J)        10       1

 Mac/Firefox        (G)       Pass (A)       Pass (A)       Pass         Pass        Pass       Half (E)     Half (F)     F (K)      Pass       Pass         F (N)       F           F          F        F       F (J)         7       2

 Treo/Blazer        (H)       NOTEST         NOTEST        NOTEST      NOTEST      NOTEST       NOTEST       NOTEST      NOTEST       F           F          F (N)    NOTEST      NOTEST      NOTEST   NOTEST   NOTEST         0       0

Symbian/Opera       (H)       NOTEST         NOTEST        NOTEST      NOTEST      NOTEST       NOTEST       NOTEST      NOTEST       F           F          F (N)    NOTEST      NOTEST      NOTEST   NOTEST   NOTEST         0       0

  # of Passes                     6             6             2            6          6            2            5          0          6           7           0          4           3          3        4         2
  # of Halves                     0             0             4            0          0            4            1          0          0           0           0          0           1          0        0         0

      -            Observed problems with IE5.5 because of the client load failing. When we moved to a non-tunnel client community, things got even worse.
      -           Doesn't cache user passwords; can't handle form-based passwords
     (A)          When certificate errors occur, cannot override them (e.g., mismatch between DN & expressed URL)
     (B)          OWA "logout" forces logout of entire session. Have to reauth to SSL server again. Is this intended?
     (C)          Paint of screen in squirrelmail not correct. Need to refresh to see properly.
     (D)          Client initially failed to load on our XP system. Privilege problem.
     (E)          Failed to cache password. Had to login twice to complete test. After did actually log off, ketp cookie & browser
     (F)          Locked up browser
     (G)          Java crash (fixed in 8.6 per tech support)
     (H)          FAIL - can't log in (fixed in 8.6 per tech support)
     (I)          Changed configuration to enable a cipher we didn't use, and this made it start working. Previously failed.
     (J)          Not supported on W2K/IE5.5 per tech support. Strange.
     (K)          Certificate not acceptable to Aventail and count not configure around.
     (L)          Would not start tunnel; no diagnostics
     (M)          Client initially failed to load, but later attempts worked.
     (N)          FTP not supported
                                                                                                                      715501c8-60c0-4f4a-b037-942cb0a25430.xls




Caymas


                                                                    "Slow
                                     Small             Small        server"
                                  Javascript        Javascript      basic           Monitoring    Power                                                   Basic
                                application for     application     Webmail          tool         managem       Exchange      Lotus                       Web
                     Note         real-time        for real-time    application,    (WhatsUp      ent           Outlook       Domino        Avocent       page                                      Windows       Citrix                                                 # of
                   applies to    monitoring         monitoring      tests timing    by            applicatio    Web           Web           KVM-          (HTML        SMB             FTP          Terminal      Presentat                                              Passe   # of
 Clients/Apps       all Apps        (HTTP)           (HTTPS)        issues.         Ipswitch)     n (APC)       Access        Access        over-IP       only)        server          server       Services      ion Server    Telnet        SSH           VOIP           s     Halfs
 Note applies
 to all Clients

   W2K/IE5.5         (B)(L)           Pass             Pass             F (A)          Pass          Pass         F (C)         F (A)         F (F)         Pass        Pass (G)           F            F            Pass        Pass         Pass           Pass           10       0

  XP/IE6/User          (D)            Pass             Pass              F             Pass          Pass         F (C)         F (A)         F (F)         Pass        Pass (G)           F          F (H)          Pass        Pass        Pass (E)        F (I)           9       0

XP/Firefox/User                       Pass             Pass              F             Pass          Pass         Pass          F (A)         F (F)         Pass        Pass (G)           F          F (H)           F          Pass         Pass           F (I)           9       0

 XP/IE6/Admin                         Pass             Pass              F             Pass          Pass         F (C)         F (A)         F (F)         Pass        Pass (G)           F          Pass           Pass        Pass         Pass           Pass           11       0

XP/Firefox/Admin                      Pass             Pass              F             Pass          Pass         Pass          F (A)         F (F)         Pass        Pass (G)           F          Pass            F          Pass         Pass           F (K)          10       0

   Mac/Safari                         Pass             Pass              F             Pass          Pass         Pass          F (A)         F (F)         Pass          Pass             F            F             F           F           F (J)          F (K)           7       0

  Mac/Firefox                         Pass             Pass              F             Pass          Pass         Pass          F (A)         F (F)         Pass          Pass             F            F             F           F           F (J)          F (K)           7       0

  Treo/Blazer          (B)          NOTEST            NOTEST          NOTEST         NOTEST        NOTEST        NOTEST        NOTEST        NOTEST          F             F               F         NOTEST        NOTEST       NOTEST       NOTEST         NOTEST           0       0

Symbian/Opera                       NOTEST            NOTEST          NOTEST         NOTEST        NOTEST        NOTEST        NOTEST        NOTEST          F             F               F         NOTEST        NOTEST       NOTEST       NOTEST         NOTEST           0       0

  # of Passes                                  7                7               0             7             7             4             0             0            7               7            0             2             3            5              5            3
   # of Halfs                                  0                0               0             0             0             0             0             0            0               0            0             0             0            0              0            0

      (A)          "This page contains secure and insecure items" (sure sign of a bug in the product rewrites)
      (B)          Required Java just to log in
      (C)          Inbox wouldn't load, but other functions worked
      (D)          Host checker doesn't work. Looks for SavService.exe, and even though it is there, doesn't find it. Must be a user versus administrator issue. OK in IE as Admin.
                   When Host Integrity Checker makes you FAIL, it doesn't tell you unless the network manager has set the entire login to fail.
      (E)          Must put actual application in the definition to make this work; poor compatibility across different installations
      (F)          Cannot hit back-end server error FAILURE. Turns out to be poor error message, means CN of cert did not match URL.
      (G)          Very nice looking exporer and when not IE, falls back to an ugly, but acceptable, representation
      (H)          "TSAC browser" looks good, but doesn't actually launch the application.
      (I)          Needs privileges to install.
      (J)          Java port forwarder starts on the local port, but cannot be moved so will not work for low-numbered applications on Mac
      (K)          Not supposed to work (officially not supported)
      (L)          Attempting to de-install client on W2K causes blue screen system crash; cannot be de-installed normally
                                                                                                                              715501c8-60c0-4f4a-b037-942cb0a25430.xls




Checkpoint


                                                   Small           "Slow
                                  Small          Javascript        server"
                               Javascript        application       basic           Monitoring    Power                                                     Basic
                    Note       application        for real-        Webmail          tool         managemen      Exchange      Lotus                        Web
                   applies    for real-time         time           application,    (WhatsUp      t              Outlook       Domino         Avocent       page                                         Windows       Citrix
                    to all     monitoring        monitoring        tests timing    by            application    Web           Web            KVM-          (HTML           SMB             FTP          Terminal      Presentati                                               # of     # of
 Clients/Apps       Apps         (HTTP)           (HTTPS)          issues.         Ipswitch)     (APC)          Access        Access         over-IP       only)           server          server       Services      on Server      Telnet        SSH          VOIP          Passes   Halves
Note applies to
  all Clients

  W2K/IE5.5                       Half (E)         Half (E)            F (B)          Pass          Pass          Pass           F (C)           F           Pass           Pass (D)          N/A         Pass           Pass         Pass         Pass        Pass (K)           10            2

 XP/IE6/User         (A)          Half (E)         Half (E)            F (B)          Pass          Pass          Pass           F (C)           F           Pass           Pass (D)          N/A         Pass           Pass         Pass         Pass         F (J)              9            2
XP/Firefox/Use
       r              (F)         Half (E)         Half (E)            Pass           Pass          Pass          Pass           F (C)           F           Pass            F (H)            N/A         Pass           Pass         Pass         Pass           F                9            2

XP/IE6/Admin                      Half (E)         Half (E)            F (B)          Pass          Pass          Pass           F (C)           F           Pass           Pass (D)          N/A         Pass           Pass         Pass         Pass        Pass (K)           10            2
XP/Firefox/Ad
     min                          Half (E)         Half (E)            Pass           Pass          Pass          Pass           F (C)           F           Pass            F (H)            N/A         Pass           Pass         Pass         Pass        Pass (K)           10            2

  Mac/Safari                       Pass             Pass                F             Pass          Pass          Pass           F (C)           F           Pass            F (D)            N/A         F (J)          F (J)        F (J)        F (J)        F (J)              6            0

 Mac/Firefox                      Half (E)         Half (E)             F             Pass          Pass          Pass           F (C)           F           Pass            F (D)            N/A           F             F            F            F             F                4            2

 Treo/Blazer                     NOTEST            NOTEST            NOTEST         NOTEST         NOTEST        NOTEST         NOTEST        NOTEST           F             F (D)            N/A        NOTEST        NOTEST        NOTEST       NOTEST       NOTEST              0            0

Symbian/Opera                    NOTEST            NOTEST            NOTEST         NOTEST         NOTEST        NOTEST         NOTEST        NOTEST        Pass (G)         F (D)            N/A        NOTEST        NOTEST        NOTEST       NOTEST       NOTEST              1            0

  # of Passes                                1                 1               2             7              7             7              0             0               8               3            0             5              5            5            5              3
  # of Halves                                6                 6               0             0              0             0              0             0               0               0            0             0              0            0            0              0

      (A)         Integrity would not scan computer when logged on as user. At first, IE would not run at all. Then, after the administrator logged in and the scan
                  was loaded on the PC, the user scan started but would not finish successfully
      (B)         Missing left-hand-side of window
      (C)         Continual alert for Domino Web Access
      (D)         Gorgeous file browser!
      (E)         Lost "anchor" so had to log out and back in.
      (F)         Integrity ONLY works in IE with ActiveX, so no client integrity with non-IE+ActiveX browsers
      (G)         Even the little pop-up window is there - excellent
      (H)         Will only run on IE
      (I)         Privilege problem
      (J)         Tries, but Java/Javascript fails
      (K)         Works if you don't use the application layer gateway for SIP, but not if we do. Not really part of the test plan, but funny nonetheless.
                                                                                                                                  715501c8-60c0-4f4a-b037-942cb0a25430.xls




 F5



                                   Small              Small           "Slow
                                Javascript         Javascript         server" basic   Monitoring                                                                      Basic
                     Note       application        application        Webmail         tool             Power             Exchange        Lotus                        Web
                    applies    for real-time      for real-time       application,    (WhatsUp         management         Outlook        Domino        Avocent        page                                      Windows       Citrix
                     to all     monitoring         monitoring         tests timing    by               application       Web             Web           KVM-           (HTML        SMB             FTP          Terminal      Presentation                                               # of     # of
  Clients/Apps        Apps        (HTTP)             (HTTPS)          issues.         Ipswitch)        (APC)             Access          Access        over-IP        only)        server          server       Services      Server             Telnet        SSH         VOIP         Passes   Halves
  Note applies
  to all Clients                                                                                                                                                                                                   (G)            (M)             (H)          (H)

   W2K/IE5.5           (A)         Half (B)        Half (B) (C)           F (E)           Pass           Pass (D)          Pass             F             F (L)         Pass        Pass (F)          N/A         Pass         Half (M)(E)        Pass         Pass         Pass             9            3

  XP/IE6/User          (I)         Half (B)          Half (B)              Pass           Pass           Pass (D)         Pass (K)          F             F (L)         Pass        Pass (F)          N/A         F (J)           F (M)           Pass         Pass         F (J)            8            2

XP/Firefox/User        (Q)         Half (B)          Half (B)              Pass           Pass             Pass            Pass             F               F           Pass        Pass (F)          N/A         F (J)           F (M)           F (P)        F (P)        F (J)            6            2

 XP/IE6/Admin                      Half (B)          Half (B)              Pass           Pass           Pass (D)         Pass (K)          F             F (L)         Pass        Pass (F)          N/A         Pass         Half (M)(E)        Pass         Pass         Pass            10            3

XP/Firefox/Admin       (N)         Half (B)          Half (B)              Pass           Pass             Pass            Pass             F               F           Pass        Pass (F)          N/A        Pass (O)      Half (M)(E)        F (P)        F (P)        Pass             8            3

   Mac/Safari                      Half (B)          Half (B)             F (S)           Pass             Pass            Pass             F               F           Pass        Pass (F)          N/A         F (R)           F (R)           Pass         Pass         F (T)            7            2

  Mac/Firefox                      Half (B)          Half (B)              Pass           Pass             Pass            Pass             F               F           Pass         Pass             N/A         F (R)           F (R)            F           F (R)        F (T)            6            2

  Treo/Blazer          (U)         NOTEST            NOTEST              NOTEST         NOTEST            NOTEST          NOTEST          NOTEST         NOTEST         Pass         Pass             N/A        NOTEST         NOTEST           NOTEST       NOTEST       NOTEST            2            0

 Symbian/Opera                     NOTEST            NOTEST              NOTEST         NOTEST            NOTEST          NOTEST          NOTEST         NOTEST         Pass         Pass             N/A        NOTEST         NOTEST           NOTEST       NOTEST       NOTEST            2            0

  # of Passes                                 0                   0               5                7                 7               7             0              0            9               9            0             3                  0            4            4            3
  # of Halves                                 7                   7               0                0                 0               0             0              0            0               0            0             0                  3            0            0            0

       (A)         Even with administrator account, EPS check failed with "unscannable"
       (B)         Javascript errors - unterminated string constants
       (C)         Originally FAIL, won't show at all - FIXED with system restart
       (D)         Kept cookie so stayed logged in - strange behavior
       (E)         "This page contains secure and insecure items" (sure sign of a bug in the product rewrites)
       (F)         A particularly unsatisfying GUI for the file service. Why so ugly?
       (G)         Has own TS client OR can do port forwarding. Nice client!
       (H)         Has own Telnet/SSH client OR can do port forwarding. Good!
       (I)         End point security does not detect Sophos
       (J)         Privilege problem installing
       (K)         Blocked cookie error. Very strange.
       (L)         Logs you out!
       (M)         Has own client to replace Citrix client. Great! Except won't work when logged in as User if not installed
       (N)         Required manual (controlled) download of EPS plugin to work
       (O)         Required patch from Microsoft
       (P)         "Waiting for F5" never completes
       (Q)         Originally FAIL with blocked login. FIX: Turns out to be poorly drawn HTML and there is a magic link far off the page.              Semi-pilot error. Bug reported.
       (R)         Not supported in this browser
       (S)         One side not drawn (left)
       (T)         Firepass closed connection (code 37). Broke the connection; killed /etc/resolv.conf. Bad. F5 still debugging?
       (U)         Misdetect platform as Windows.
       (V)         Used local "mobile mail client." Interface leaves a great deal to be desired.
                                                                                                                       715501c8-60c0-4f4a-b037-942cb0a25430.xls




 Fortinet




                                     Small           Small
                                  Javascript      Javascript
                                  application     application     "Slow server"        Monitoring    Power           Exchange   Lotus               Basic Web
                     Note        for real-time   for real-time    basic Webmail        tool          management      Outlook    Domino    Avocent   page                                  Windows    Citrix
                   applies to     monitoring      monitoring      application, tests   (WhatsUp by   application     Web        Web       KVM-over- (HTML                                 Terminal   Presentatio                               # of   # of
  Clients/Apps      all Apps        (HTTP)          (HTTPS)       timing issues.       Ipswitch)     (APC)           Access     Access    IP        only)         SMB server FTP server   Services   n Server      Telnet    SSH     VOIP     Passes Halves
  Note applies
  to all Clients                                                                                                                                                                                                    (A)      (A)

   W2K/IE5.5                          F (E)           F (E)              F (E)             F (E)         F (E)         F (E)      F (E)      F (E)     F (E)         F (F)      F (F)       F (G)       F (G)       Pass     F (D)    F (B)       1       0

  XP/IE6/User                         F (E)           F (E)              F (E)             F (E)         F (E)         F (E)      F (E)      F (E)     F (E)         F (F)      F (F)       F (G)       F (G)       Pass     F (D)     F          1       0

XP/Firefox/User                       F (E)           F (E)              F (E)             F (E)         F (E)         F (E)      F (E)      F (E)     F (E)         F (F)      F (F)       F (G)       F (G)       Pass     F (D)     F          1       0

 XP/IE6/Admin          (C)            F (E)           F (E)              F (E)             F (E)         F (E)         F (E)      F (E)      F (E)     F (E)         F (F)      F (F)       F (G)       F (G)       Pass     F (D)    F (B)       1       0

XP/Firefox/Admin                      F (E)           F (E)              F (E)             F (E)         F (E)         F (E)      F (E)      F (E)     F (E)         F (F)      F (F)       F (G)       F (G)       Pass     F (D)    F (B)       1       0

   Mac/Safari                         F (E)           F (E)              F (E)             F (E)         F (E)         F (E)      F (E)      F (E)     F (E)         F (F)      F (F)       F (G)       F (G)       F (G)    F (D)    F (G)       0       0

  Mac/Firefox                         F (E)           F (E)              F (E)             F (E)         F (E)         F (E)      F (E)      F (E)     F (E)         F (F)      F (F)       F (G)       F (G)       F (G)    F (D)    F (G)       0       0

  Treo/Blazer                       NOTEST           NOTEST            NOTEST            NOTEST        NOTEST         NOTEST     NOTEST    NOTEST      F (E)         F (F)      F (F)      NOTEST     NOTEST       NOTEST   NOTEST   NOTEST       0       0

 Symbian/Opera                      NOTEST           NOTEST            NOTEST            NOTEST        NOTEST         NOTEST     NOTEST    NOTEST      F (E)         F (F)      F (F)      NOTEST     NOTEST       NOTEST   NOTEST   NOTEST       0       0

   # of Passes                         0                0                  0                0              0             0          0         0          0            0           0           0           0          5        0        0
   # of Halves                         0                0                  0                0              0             0          0         0          0            0           0           0           0          0        0        0

       (A)         Uses their own applet client for Telnet. Port Forwarding not supported.
       (B)         Brings up tunnel, but doesn't work for VoIP. Other services do work, such as Telnet and Citrix.
       (C)         End Point Security does not detect Sophos AntiVirus running, even though it is.
       (D)         No port forwarding supported, and no own applet for SSH, so not supported.
       (E)         Many elements on page are not appearing --- some rewrite failure.
       (F)         Never shows any files
       (G)         Not supported
                                                                                                                          715501c8-60c0-4f4a-b037-942cb0a25430.xls




Juniper




                                 Small              Small           "Slow server"
                               Javascript        Javascript         basic           Monitoring                                                                     Basic
                   Note      application for     application        Webmail         tool             Power             Exchange      Lotus                         Web
                  applies      real-time        for real-time       application,    (WhatsUp         management        Outlook       Domino          Avocent       page                                   Windows         Citrix                                                 # of    # of
                   to all     monitoring         monitoring         tests timing    by               application       Web           Web             KVM-          (HTML        SMB          FTP          Terminal        Presentat                                              Passe   Halve
 Clients/Apps       Apps         (HTTP)            (HTTPS)          issues.         Ipswitch)        (APC)             Access        Access          over-IP       only)        server       server       Services        ion Server    Telnet        SSH           VOIP           s       s
Note applies to
  all Clients                       (C)              (C)                                                                                                                                                     (D)             (J)         (D)           (D)

  W2K/IE5.5                      Half (A)          Half (A)             Pass           Pass              Pass            Pass          Pass              F           Pass         Pass          N/A        Pass (D)          Pass        Pass        Half (E)        Pass           11       3

 XP/IE6/User         (B)         Half (A)          Half (A)             Pass           Pass              Pass            Pass          Pass              F           Pass         Pass          N/A        Pass (D)          Pass        Pass        Half (E)        F (L)          10       3
XP/Firefox/Use
       r                           Pass              Pass               Pass           Pass              Pass            Pass          F (H)             F           Pass         Pass          N/A         Pass             Pass        Pass        Half (E)        F (L)          11       1

XP/IE6/Admin                     Half (A)          Half (A)             Pass           Pass              Pass            Pass          Pass              F           Pass         Pass          N/A        Pass (D)          Pass        Pass        Half (E)        Pass           11       3
XP/Firefox/Ad
     min                           Pass              Pass               Pass           Pass              Pass            Pass          F (H)             F           Pass         Pass          N/A         Pass             Pass        Pass        Half (E)        Pass           12       1

  Mac/Safari                       Pass              Pass               Pass           Pass              Pass            Pass         Pass (F)           F           Pass         Pass          N/A        Pass (G)          Pass        Pass        Half (E)        Pass           13       1

 Mac/Firefox                       Pass              Pass               Pass           Pass              Pass            Pass          F (H)             F           Pass         Pass          N/A         F (I)             F           F          Half (E)        Pass            9       1

 Treo/Blazer         (N)         NOTEST            NOTEST              NOTEST         NOTEST            NOTEST          NOTEST        NOTEST          NOTEST          F             F            F         NOTEST          NOTEST       NOTEST       NOTEST         NOTEST           0       0

Symbian/Opera        (M)         NOTEST            NOTEST              NOTEST         NOTEST            NOTEST          NOTEST        NOTEST          NOTEST          F             F            F         NOTEST          NOTEST       NOTEST       NOTEST         NOTEST           0       0

  # of Passes                               4                   4               7                7                 7             7               4             0            7            7            0               6             6            6              0            5
  # of Halves                               3                   3               0                0                 0             0               0             0            0            0            0               0             0            0              7            0

      (A)         Javascript error
      (B)         User cannot be host checker scanned
      (C)         Get warning about invalid certificate, and ability to override
      (D)         Has own Terminal Services client for Windows; works on user. Also Telnet/SSH client!
      (E)         Client works with Telnet, but has some problem with terminal emulation with SSH. CRLF is being sent as LF
                  Tech support provided documented workaround to change Java applet
      (F)         Domino Web Access says "not certified on this browser" but works anyway. Hooray.
      (G)         Port forwarding
      (H)         Works slightly, but not really. Timeouts.
      (I)         Cannot do port forwarding.
      (J)         Really hard to configure.
      (K)         Downloads Java client & modifies client behavior on the fly. No JSAM required. Slick.
      (L)         No privilege.
      (M)         Does not paint opening page.
      (N)         Can not get logged in
                                                                                                                            715501c8-60c0-4f4a-b037-942cb0a25430.xls




Nokia


                                                      Small           "Slow
                                    Small           Javascript        server"
                                 Javascript         application       basic                              Power                                                    Basic
                                 application         for real-        Webmail                            managemen      Exchange      Lotus                       Web
                     Note       for real-time          time           application,       Monitoring      t              Outlook       Domino        Avocent       page                                            Windows         Citrix
                   applies to    monitoring         monitoring        tests timing       tool (WhatsUp   application    Web           Web           KVM-          (HTML           SMB             FTP             Terminal        Presentat                                                 # of         # of
 Clients/Apps       all Apps       (HTTP)            (HTTPS)          issues.            by Ipswitch)    (APC)          Access        Access        over-IP       only)           server          server          Services        ion Server    Telnet          SSH           VOIP         Passes       Halves
Note applies to
  all Clients                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                  (J)

   W2K/IE5.5                         Pass              Pass               F (K)               Pass          Pass          Pass          F (A)         F (B)         Pass            Pass            Pass           Pass (G)          Pass         Half         Pass (G)        Pass             12               1
                                                                                                                                                                                                                    Pass
  XP/IE6/User                        Pass              Pass               Pass                Pass          Pass          Pass          F (A)         F (B)         Pass            Pass            Pass           (C)(D)            Pass       Pass (C)       Pass (C)        F (E)            13               0
                                                                                                                                                                                                                    Pass
XP/Firefox/User                      Pass              Pass               Pass                Pass          Pass          Pass           F            F (B)         Pass            Pass            Pass           (C)(D)            Pass       Pass (C)       Pass (C)        F (E)            13               0

 XP/IE6/Admin                        Pass              Pass               Pass                Pass          Pass          Pass          F (A)         F (B)         Pass            Pass            Pass           Pass (G)          Pass        Pass          Pass (G)        Pass             14               0
                                                                                                                                                                                                                    Pass
XP/Firefox/Admin                     Pass              Pass               Pass                Pass          Pass          Pass           F            F (B)         Pass            Pass            Pass           (C)(D)            Pass        Pass          Pass (C)        Pass             14               0

   Mac/Safari                        F (F)             F (F)                F                 Pass          Pass          Pass          F (F)         F (B)         Pass            Pass            Pass           Pass (H)          Pass       Half (I)       Half (I)        Pass                 9            2

  Mac/Firefox                        Pass              Pass                 F                 Pass          Pass          Pass          F (M)         F (B)         Pass            Pass            Pass              F               F            F              F            Pass                 9            0

  Treo/Blazer                       NOTEST            NOTEST            NOTEST              NOTEST         NOTEST        NOTEST        NOTEST        NOTEST         Pass            Pass            Pass           NOTEST          NOTEST       NOTEST         NOTEST         NOTEST                3            0

 Symbian/Opera                      NOTEST            NOTEST            NOTEST              NOTEST         NOTEST        NOTEST        NOTEST        NOTEST        Pass (N)        Pass (N)        Pass (N)        NOTEST          NOTEST       NOTEST         NOTEST         NOTEST                3            0

  # of Passes                                   6                 6                  4               7              7             7             0             0               9               9               9               6             6              4              5            5
  # of Halves                                   0                 0                  0               0              0             0             0             0               0               0               0               0             0              2              1            0

        (A)        Javascript errors
        (B)        Close, but oh so far. Asked about self-signed certificate.
        (C)        Tried "application" mode, but did not work. Used port forwarder instead.
        (D)        Had to change ports.
        (E)        Privilege problem installing client.
        (F)        Blank screen.
        (G)        Auto-launched client!
        (H)        Port forwarding mode only.
        (I)        Could not run on ports less than 1024 (non-privileged).
        (J)        Secure Connector (network extension) requires a manual/semi-manual download and install of the client
                   and is not integrated with the browser. On IE5.5, had to reboot.
        (K)        "This page contains secure and insecure items" (sure sign of a bug in the product rewrites)
        (L)        Tries to connect, but then fails. FIXED: Bug in username handling.
        (M)        "Domino Web Access has encountered problems accessing your personal preferences'
        (N)        Required patch to work; will be in released v3.3 version
                                                                                                                             715501c8-60c0-4f4a-b037-942cb0a25430.xls




Nortel




                                    Small               Small
                                 Javascript          Javascript         "Slow server"       Monitorin     Power                                                       Basic
                                 application         application        basic Webmail       g tool        managem       Exchange        Lotus                         Web
                    Note        for real-time       for real-time       application,        (WhatsUp      ent           Outlook         Domino          Avocent       page                                   Windows         Citrix                                                 # of    # of
                  applies to     monitoring          monitoring         tests timing         by           applicatio    Web             Web             KVM-          (HTML        SMB          FTP          Terminal        Presentati                                             Passe   Halve
 Clients/Apps      all Apps        (HTTP)              (HTTPS)          issues.             Ipswitch)     n (APC)       Access          Access          over-IP       only)        server       server       Services        on Server     Telnet        SSH           VOIP           s       s
Note applies to
  all Clients                                                                                                                                              (J)                                                                  (Q)         (F)

  W2K/IE5.5                          Pass               Pass                 F (L)            Pass           Pass         Pass           Pass (D)         F (C)         Pass         Pass         Pass         Pass             Pass        Pass         F (E)          Pass           13       0

 XP/IE6/User                         Pass               Pass                Half (B)          Pass           Pass        Pass (A)         Pass            F (C)         Pass         Pass         Pass        Pass (H)          Pass        Pass         F (E)         F (G)           12       1
XP/Firefox/Use
       r                             Pass               Pass                Half (B)          Pass           Pass         Pass            F (I)             F           Pass         Pass         Pass        Pass (H)          Pass        Pass         F (E)          F (K)          11       1

XP/IE6/Admin                         Pass               Pass                Half (B)          Pass           Pass        Pass (A)        Pass (A)         F (C)         Pass         Pass         Pass        Pass (H)          Pass        Pass         F (E)          Pass           13       1
XP/Firefox/Ad
     min                             Pass               Pass                Half (B)          Pass           Pass         Pass            F (I)             F           Pass         Pass         Pass        Pass (H)       Pass ( R )     Pass         F (E)       Half (K)(O)       11       2

  Mac/Safari          (N)              F                  F                    F                F             F             F               F               F            F             F            F            F               F           F            F              F              0       0

 Mac/Firefox          (M)              F                  F                    F                F             F             F               F               F            F             F            F            F               F           F            F              F              0       0

 Treo/Blazer        (M)(P)         NOTEST              NOTEST               NOTEST           NOTEST        NOTEST        NOTEST          NOTEST          NOTEST          F             F            F         NOTEST          NOTEST       NOTEST       NOTEST        NOTEST            0       0

Symbian/Opera       (M)(P)         NOTEST              NOTEST               NOTEST           NOTEST        NOTEST        NOTEST          NOTEST          NOTEST          F             F            F         NOTEST          NOTEST       NOTEST       NOTEST        NOTEST            0       0

  # of Passes                                   5                   5                   0             5             5               5               4             0            5            5            5               5             4            5            0              2
  # of Halves                                   0                   0                   4             0             0               0               0             0            0            0            0               0             0            0            0              1

         (A)      Logging out of OWA causes entire session to be killed
         (B)      Left side blank; fixed with a refresh
         (C)      Javascript errors
         (D)      Needed refresh on some pages to work
         (E)      Applet does not go further than display of version string; locks up
         (F)      Has own Telnet/SSH Java applet. Doesn't work very well. Might work better with port forwarding
         (G)      Failed to start with error code 1326
         (H)      Launches application and everything!
         (I)      Operation timed out.
         (J)      No warning on self-signed certificate! Bad security, bad security.
         (K)      Requires ActiveX
         (L)      Blank - never returns
         (M)      Hangs in tunnel guard forever. Tunnel Guard needs work.
         (N)      Says need to install JRE even though it is installed already (and the "Java Adapter" is in place)
         (O)      Works if you manually download and install the client software
         (P)      Has special /PDA/ friendly PDA support - but with Tunnel Guard in place, even in "fallback" mode,
                  blocks all access. Did I say Tunnel Guard needs work?
         (Q)      Configured to use ICA Applet per Nortel Tech Support. Works great then.
         (R)      Required
                                                                                                                           715501c8-60c0-4f4a-b037-942cb0a25430.xls




SonicWALL

                                                                       "Slow
                                                                       server"
                                       Small               Small       basic
                                    Javascript          Javascript     Webmail                                                                                   Basic
                                    application         application    application    Monitoring     Power             Exchange      Lotus                       Web                                                      Citrix
                                   for real-time       for real-time   , tests        tool           management         Outlook      Domino        Avocent       page                                     Windows         Presentat
                   Note applies     monitoring          monitoring     timing         (WhatsUp by    application       Web           Web           KVM-          (HTML         SMB           FTP          Terminal        ion                                                   # of         # of
 Clients/Apps       to all Apps       (HTTP)              (HTTPS)      issues.        Ipswitch)      (APC)             Access        Access        over-IP       only)         server        server       Services        Server        Telnet        SSH         VOIP         Passes       Halves
 Note applies
 to all Clients                                                                                                                                                                                              (K)             (O)         (C)          (C)

   W2K/IE5.5                              F                F (B)          F (B)          F (B)           F (B)           F (B)         F (A)         F (I)         F (B)         F (F)         Pass       Pass (J2)          N/A          F            F           Pass                 3            0

  XP/IE6/User                           Pass               Pass           F (H)           Pass           F (B)           Pass          F (A)         F (I)         Pass          F (F)         Pass        Pass (J)          N/A          F            F           F (M)                7            0

XP/Firefox/User         (N)               F                F (D)          F (D)           Pass           F (E)           F (G)         F (A)         F (D)         Pass          F (F)         Pass        Pass (J)          N/A          F            F           F (M)                4            0

 XP/IE6/Admin                           Pass               Pass           F (H)           Pass           F (B)           Pass          F (A)         F (I)         Pass          F (F)         Pass       Pass (J2)          N/A          F            F           Pass                 8            0

XP/Firefox/Admin        (N)               F                F (D)          F (D)           Pass           F (E)           F (G)         F (A)         F (D)         Pass          F (F)         Pass        Pass (J)          N/A          F            F           F (L)                4            0

   Mac/Safari                             F                F (D)          F (D)           Pass           F (E)           F (G)         F (A)         F (I)         Pass          F (F)         Pass        Pass (J)          N/A          F            F           F (L)                4            0

  Mac/Firefox           (N)               F                F (D)          F (D)           Pass           F (E)           F (G)         F (A)         F (D)         Pass          F (F)         Pass         F (D)            N/A          F            F           F (L)                3            0

  Treo/Blazer                          NOTEST             NOTEST         NOTEST         NOTEST          NOTEST          NOTEST        NOTEST        NOTEST         Pass          F (F)         Pass        NOTEST          NOTEST       NOTEST       NOTEST       NOTEST                2            0

Symbian/Opera                          NOTEST             NOTEST         NOTEST         NOTEST          NOTEST          NOTEST        NOTEST        NOTEST         Pass          F (F)         Pass        NOTEST          NOTEST       NOTEST       NOTEST       NOTEST                2            0

  # of Passes                                      2               2              0              6                 0             2             0             0             8             0            9               6             0            0            0            2
  # of Halves                                      0               0              0              0                 0             0             0             0             0             0            0               0             0            0            0            0

      (A)          Couldn't get authenticated
      (B)          Javascript errors
      (C)          Has own Java-based Telnet and SSH clients. However, when run, show HTTP proxy errors.
      (D)          Blank screen.
      (E)          Missing data; some menu items do not work.
      (F)          Cannot log in. Support says "known bug if you have two users"
      (G)          Cannot send a new message; can only read email.
      (H)          "This page contains secure and insecure items" (sure sign of a bug in the product rewrites)
      (I)          This page cannot be displayed
      (J)                                             client
                   Used Terminal Services (RDP) "4"(J2)              Used RDP "5" client
      (K)          Has 2 Terminal Services clients, RDP4 and RDP5, running on local PC
      (L)          Not supported (requires IE5 or better)
      (M)          Requires privileges to install
      (N)          Firefox users cannot see the entire portal because the scroll bar does not show up!
      (O)          Not supported by SonicWALL

								
To top