Using biographies of outstanding women in computer engineering to
W
Shared by: qza17959
Categories
Tags
computer science, science and engineering, research interests, science and technology, the women, electrical engineering, stanford university, assistant professor, women mathematicians, computer science department, gender equity, microsoft research, contributions of 20th century women to physics, associate professor, computer scientists
-
Stats
- views:
- 8
- posted:
- 5/16/2010
- language:
- pages:
- 6
Document Sample


Using biographies of outstanding women
in computer engineering to dispel false
impressions about engineers
Yin Kiong Hoh
ABSTRACT The author has carried out an activity with 80 teachers to enable them to reconsider
their perceptions of engineers. This introduced them to 20 outstanding women in computer
engineering, and raised their awareness of their contributions to engineering and society. The
results revealed that the activity was effective in countering typical perceptions of engineers. By
providing detailed information about the personal lives and work experiences, the biographies
might be useful in countering existing cultural stereotypes of female engineers and initiating
changes in perceptions needed to narrow the gender gap in engineering.
The perception that engineers and scientists science in Austria. In Germany it was 15.1%, in
are intelligent Caucasian men who are socially France 22.1% and in the USA 27.1% (National
inept and absent-minded seems to be prevalent Science Foundation, 2006).
among students of all levels, from elementary Fortunately, research has shown that strategies
school to college (Congressional Commission such as presentation of female role models,
on the Advancement of Women and Minorities distribution of career information, examination
in Science, Engineering and Technology of gender-equitable materials, and participation
Development [CCAWMSETD], 2000; Knight in hands-on science investigations are effective
and Cunningham, 2004). While the media may, in countering the stereotypical perceptions of
by chance or choice, promote this image, it is engineers and scientists (Anderson and Gilbride,
unfortunately not far from reality. For example, 2003). Research has also pointed to the presence
while women constituted 46.1% of the general of female role models as the most important
workforce of the USA in 2000, they represented factor in sustaining girls’ interests in engineering
only 25.4% of the engineering and science and science (Advocates for Women in Science,
workforce (National Science Foundation, Engineering and Mathematics, 2000).
2006). These stereotypical images of engineers In order to reach out to students at an early
and scientists as Caucasian men have, in part, age when they are still impressionable, many
discouraged many young women from pursuing universities have recently organised outreach
any interest they may have in an engineering programmes to inform high-school teachers about
or a science career because they do not want to engineering, in the hope that this will encourage
be the people so often portrayed in the media their students to study engineering (Jeffers,
(Brownlow, Smith and Ellis, 2002). Safferman and Safferman, 2004). The feedback
Stereotypical images of engineers and from such programmes has been encouraging.
scientists have contributed, in part, to the For this work, the author wanted to inform
existing gender gap in engineering and science teachers about the applications of engineering,
(CCAWMSETD, 2000). This gender gap can be to demonstrate the problem-solving approach
traced back to the educational choices made by of engineers, to correct perceptions of engineers
young women. Statistics show that women in the generally, and to provide them with female
OECD countries earn fewer Bachelor’s degrees in role models from the various disciplines of
most engineering and scientific fields as compared engineering. To achieve these goals, the author
with men. For example, in 2003, women earned recently conducted a number of outreach
only 9.5% of all Bachelor’s degrees in computer workshop activities for 80 high-school computer
SSR September 2009, 91(334) 113
Biographies of outstanding women in computer engineering Hoh
science teachers. The teachers were then conduct their research and were encouraged to use
encouraged to integrate what they had learned Internet resources.
from the workshop into their teaching. To familiarise the participants with the
discipline of computer engineering, individuals
Method from a broad range of specialties were included
The 45 male and 35 female teachers were first in Box 1. These areas of specialisation were:
asked to complete a ‘draw-an-engineer’ test to coding, cryptography and information protection;
assess their perceptions of engineers. The test communications and wireless networks; compilers
required them to draw a picture of an engineer and operating systems; computational science
at work (Knight and Cunningham, 2004). The and engineering; computer networks, mobile
drawings were analysed as follows. Drawings computing and distributed systems; computer
showing short hair and broad shoulders were systems – architecture, parallel processing and
regarded as males and those with long hair and dependability; computer vision and robotics;
narrow shoulders as females. Engineers working embedded systems; integrated circuits, very
with one or more of the following items were large-scale integration design, testing and
considered as engaged in building or repairing: computer-aided design; and signal, image and
hard hat, workbench, heavy machinery, hammer, speech processing. The range of specialties would
wrench, car, engine, rocket, airplane, robot, bridge, enable the participants to note that the work of
road, building, train and train track. Those working computer engineers was grounded not only in
with computer, blueprint, pen, model and/or desk the hardware – from circuits to architecture – but
were regarded as engaged in planning or designing, also in operating systems and software (Sloan
while those working with test-tube and/or beaker Career Cornerstone Center, 2008). The computer
were deemed to be doing laboratory work. engineers worked on the design, planning,
The participants were then randomly divided development, testing, and even the supervision of
into groups of four, and the groups were each manufacturing of computer hardware – including
assigned someone to research from the 20 everything from chips to device controllers. They
outstanding women in computer engineering listed might also focus on computer networks for the
in Box 1. The participants were given one week to transmission of data and multimedia, and design
and develop software applications.
BOX 1 Outstanding women in computer Each group was required to produce a
engineering 20-minute oral presentation and submit a written
1. Prathima Agrawal report on the female computer engineer assigned
2. Frances E. Allen to the group. The participants were required to
3. Ruzena K. Bajcsy design and present various documents to give an
4. Alice M. Chiang overview of the computer engineer’s life, such as
5. Frederica Darema birth certificate, educational certificates, marriage
6. Susan J. Eggers certificate and summary of a hypothetical research
7. Susan L. Graham post that the female computer engineer wished to
8. Mary Jane Irwin apply for. They were also required to address the
9. Ruby B. Lee following questions during the presentation:
10. Nancy G. Leveson l Who inspired her to become a computer
11. Barbara H. Liskov engineer?
12. Jane W. S. Liu l What were her research interests?
13. Teresa H. Meng l What were her major research findings, and
14. Catherine P. Rosenberg how had they influenced current knowledge?
15. Jean E. Sammet l What were the difficulties she had encountered
16. Patricia G. Selinger in her research or work, and how had she
17. Eva Tardos overcome them?
18. Bhavani M. Thuraisingham l What were some issues in her life which were
19. Elaine J. Weyuker unusually inspiring for young women studying
20. Jeannette M. Wing engineering?
114 SSR September 2009, 91(334)
Hoh Biographies of outstanding women in computer engineering
Each oral presentation was followed by a
BOX 2 Post-activity survey questions
five-minute question-and-answer session. After
all the groups had presented, the ‘draw-an- 1 Who inspired the female computer engineers
engineer’ test was administered again to determine featured in the oral presentations to become
the effectiveness of the oral presentations. The engineers?
significance of differences in drawings before Parents
and after the intervention was assessed using Peers
McNemar’s Test for the Significance of Changes. Relatives
Teachers
A post-activity survey consisting of four forced-
Others. Please specify ...................................
choice items was also administered (Box 2),
which required the high-school teachers to 2 What appointments did the female computer
indicate what they had noted about the female engineers featured in the oral presentations hold?
computer engineers in terms of: Professor
Senior position in the civil engineering industry
l Who inspired them to become engineers?
Senior position in the government
l What appointments did they hold?
Laboratory assistant
l What difficulties did they encounter at their Others. Please specify ...................................
workplaces?
l How did they cope with both work and family 3 What difficulties did the female computer
life? engineers featured in the oral presentations
encounter at their workplaces?
Results and discussion Absence of female role models, mentors and
The author observed that the female engineers colleagues
featured during the oral presentations successfully Inadequate physical strength
captured the attention of the participants. The Male supervisors’ stereotyping of women’s
abilities
teachers became actively involved in the question-
Differences in communication style between
and-answer sessions, showing greater enthusiasm
male supervisors and female engineers
than expected. Difficulty in coping with both family and career
The participants commented that Lower pay scales and slower promotion rates
administering the ‘draw-an-engineer’ test at the for females compared with males
outset without them suspecting anything, was a Others. Please specify ...................................
powerful way to make them become aware of
their entrenched perceptions of engineers. The 4 How did the female computer engineers
featured in the oral presentations cope with both
percentage of male participants who depicted
work and family life?
engineers as men decreased from 100% before
the intervention to 62% afterwards (p < 0.01). For Quitting and resuming career some years later
Pro-family workplace policies
females, the decrease was from 91% to 31% after
Having a supportive and understanding
the intervention (p < 0.01). The male participants’ husband
perceptions of engineers as men seemed to be Having an efficient domestic help
more tenacious (38% reduction) than those of the Others. Please specify ...................................
female participants (56% reduction).
In the drawings, the participants showed
engineers engaged in building or repairing, participants who depicted engineers engaged in
planning or designing, or laboratory work. The planning or designing increased from 27% before
results showed that the activity was effective in the intervention to 91% after the intervention,
countering the participants’ perceptions of the while that of female participants increased from
nature of engineering jobs. The percentage of male 20% to 91%. Thus, prior to the intervention, a
participants who portrayed engineers engaged in majority of the participants had the misperception
building or repairing decreased from 67% before that engineering jobs involved a lot of manual
the intervention to 4% after the intervention, work and were physically demanding. The oral
while that of female participants decreased from presentations enabled the participants to note that
74% to 3%. Conversely, the percentage of male engineers were increasingly required to think,
SSR September 2009, 91(334) 115
Biographies of outstanding women in computer engineering Hoh
plan, design and communicate, and not just do revelations might deter talented young women
manual work. In order to encourage more girls from pursuing careers in engineering. This is a
to pursue engineering, teachers need to highlight significant point because research shows that
to students that in today’s knowledge-based and young women are less likely to choose careers in
innovation-driven economy, engineering requires science because of the difficulties associated with
intellectual ability and capacity for innovation and doing science (Clewell and Campbell, 2002). The
less manual work. participants felt that, while it was important to
In the post-activity test, the participants noted raise young women’s awareness of the unfriendly
that the female engineers studied cited the role environment that might exist in engineering,
of their parents or teachers in encouraging their it was even more important to highlight the
pursuit of an engineering career. Research has progress being made towards more inclusive
pointed out the importance of parental support workplaces in engineering.
in fostering young women’s interest in science- It was noted that the female engineers were
related careers (Tilleczek and Lewko, 2001). able to cope with both work and family life because
Research has also shown that teachers play a of pro-family workplace policies, and having a
critical role in young women’s decision to pursue supportive and understanding husband and efficient
careers in engineering and science (Schoon, domestic help. This is an important point because
Ross and Martin, 2007). All these might suggest concerns about how to balance work and family
that organising outreach programmes directed responsibilities appear to be a recurring issue in
specifically at parents or teachers might help to research on the factors that keep young women
narrow the gender gap in engineering. from pursuing engineering and science careers
The fact that these female engineers held (CCAWMSETD, 2000). In order to encourage
senior positions in academia, government or more young women to pursue engineering, it is
industry was also noted. Many of them were thus important to highlight how female engineers
members of the US National Academy of successfully combined work and family.
Engineering (NAE) or fellows of the American
Academy of Arts and Sciences (AAAS), the
Conclusion
Association for Computing Machinery (ACM) The results showed that the activity appeared
or the Institute of Electrical and Electronics effective in countering false perceptions of
Engineers (IEEE). They were different from the engineers among high-school teachers. By
female engineers the participants had encountered providing detailed information about the personal
and those found in many studies, where most lives and work experiences, the biographies
female characters were shown as pupils, laboratory might be useful in countering existing cultural
assistants or science reporters (Steinke, 2004). stereotypes of female engineers and initiating
These engineers could therefore be used to changes in perceptions needed to narrow the
overcome existing stereotypes of female engineers. gender gap in engineering. The activity could
The participants noted that the female also be used with elementary and middle-school
engineers acknowledged that they had teachers, and might enable them to correct
encountered difficulties at their workplaces. false impressions about engineers amongst
These included: the absence of female their students. Furthermore, the activity could
role models, mentors and colleagues; male be carried out by professors with female
supervisors’ stereotyping of women’s abilities; undergraduates or graduate students in order
differences in communication style between male to provide them with female role models. This
supervisors and female engineers; difficulty in would encourage them to pursue and excel in
coping with both family and career; and lower computer engineering as a course of study and
pay scales and slower promotion rates for females as a profession. It is hoped that more educators
as compared with males. The female engineers will use this type of activity to correct the myth
also mentioned, however, progress made towards amongst girls and young women that a career in
acceptance and equality. The participants felt that, engineering is not for them.
although these difficulties truthfully reflected Box 3 summarises some of the biographical
the experiences of the female engineers, such details collected by the 20 working groups.
116 SSR September 2009, 91(334)
Hoh Biographies of outstanding women in computer engineering
BOX 3 Summarised biographies produced by the teams on a selection of the engineers listed in Box 1
Prathima Agrawal
She was the Samuel Ginn Distinguished Professor in the Department of Electrical and Computer
Engineering at Auburn University. Internationally renowned for her research on computer networks,
wireless communication systems, computer-aided design and testing of integrated circuits, and parallel
computing architecture and algorithms. Held 48 patents. Elected a fellow of IEEE.
Ruzena K. Bajcsy
She was an Emeritus Professor in the Department of Electrical Engineering and Computer Sciences at
University of California, Berkeley. Internationally renowned for pioneering research on artificial intelligence,
machine perception and robotics. Elected a member of the US NAE and Institute of Medicine, and a
fellow of ACM and IEEE.
Ruby B. Lee
She was a Professor of Electrical Engineering and Computer Science at Princeton University.
Internationally renowned for pioneering multimedia instructions in general-purpose processor architecture,
and innovations in the design and implementation of the instruction-set architecture of RISC processors.
Held 115 patents. Elected a fellow of ACM and IEEE.
Teresa H. Meng
She was the Reid Weaver Dennis Professor in the Department of Electrical Engineering at Stanford
University. Internationally renowned for contributions to the system integration of algorithms, parallel
architectures and signal processing circuits, and for pioneering the development of distributed wireless
network technology. Held 15 patents. Elected a member of the US NAE, and a fellow of IEEE.
Catherine P. Rosenberg
She was a Professor and the Chair of the Department of Electrical and Computer Engineering at
the University of Waterloo, Canada. Internationally renowned for contributions to wireless networks,
broadband networks, multimedia applications, quality of service, traffic engineering and network security.
Held eight patents.
Readers are encouraged to use the same exercise would deliver mainly female pictures. Afterwards,
with students to find details about the other female people know what is expected and why they
computer engineers listed in Box 1. Alternatively, are being asked. Hence the results are not then
this information is available from the author. necessarily genuine reflections of their feelings.
Teachers and professors need to take every They still have other experiences. Some will
opportunity to assure girls and young women that draw females, believing that is what the presenter
females can contribute as significantly as males wants, without changing their true ideas. Others
to engineering. As the world economy becomes will deliberately not draw females because they
increasingly reliant on a technologically literate know that most engineers are male even though
workforce, the world cannot afford to overlook they have accepted that some top engineers are
the talent and potential contributions of half of the female. Using only the very narrow evidence of
population. If it does, societies, nations and our this directed research (only computer engineers
world will suffer. and only females) the inference would be that all
engineers are female, which is of course not true.
Limitations
References
Participants in this or any similar study cannot
be guaranteed to give responses that demonstrate Advocates for Women in Science, Engineering and
Mathematics (2000) In their nature: Compelling
their genuine thinking. The ‘draw-an-engineer’ reasons to engage girls in science. Available at: www.
activity (with no introduction) would certainly saturdayacademy.pdx.edu/awsem/Articles/AWSEM_In_
bring results with male-dominated figures Their_Nature.pdf (visited December 2008).
anywhere in the world, just as ‘draw-a-nurse’ Anderson, L. S. and Gilbride, K. A. (2003) Pre-university
outreach: encouraging students to consider engineering
SSR September 2009, 91(334) 117
Biographies of outstanding women in computer engineering Hoh
careers. Global Journal of Engineering Education, 7(1), students’ ideas about engineers and engineering.
87–93. Proceedings of the 2004 American Society for
Brownlow, S., Smith, T. J. and Ellis, B. R. (2002) How Engineering Education Annual Conference and
interest in science negatively influences perceptions of Exposition. Salt Lake City, UT.
women. Journal of Science Education and Technology, National Science Foundation (2006) Women, minorities
11(2), 135–144. and persons with disabilities in science and engineering.
Clewell, B. C. and Campbell, P. B. (2002) Taking stock: Available at: www.nsf.gov/statistics/wmpd/listtables.htm
where we’ve been, where we are, where we’re going. (visited December 2008).
Journal of Women and Minorities in Science and Schoon, I., Ross, A. and Martin, P. (2007) Science-related
Engineering, 8, 255–284. careers: aspirations and outcomes in two British cohort
Congressional Commission on the Advancement of Women studies. Equal Opportunities International, 26(2),
and Minorities in Science, Engineering and Technology 129–143.
Development (CCAWMSETD) (2000) Land of plenty: Sloan Career Cornerstone Center (2008) Computer
diversity as America’s competitive edge in science, engineering. Available at: www.careercornerstone.org/
engineering and technology. Available at: www.nsf.gov/ compeng/compeng.htm (visited December 2008).
pubs/2000/cawmset0409/cawmset_0409.pdf (visited Steinke, J. (2004) Science in cyberspace: Science and
December 2008). engineering World Wide Web sites for girls. Public
Jeffers, A. T., Safferman, A. G. and Safferman, S. I. (2004) Understanding of Science, 13(1), 7–30.
Understanding K-12 engineering outreach programs. Tilleczek, K. C. and Lewko, J. H. (2001) Factors
Journal of Professional Issues in Engineering Education influencing the pursuit of health and science careers for
and Practice, 130(4), 95–108. Canadian adolescents in transition from school to work.
Knight, M. and Cunningham, C. (2004) Draw an engineer Journal of Youth Studies, 4(4), 415–428.
test (DAET): development of a tool to investigate
Dr Yin Kiong Hoh is Assistant Professor, Natural Sciences and Science Education, at the National
Institute of Education, Nanyang Technological University, Singapore. Email: yinkiong.hoh@nie.edu.sg
118 SSR September 2009, 91(334)
Related docs
Get documents about "