A letter Full of Agony
Few days back, a book named "Saamajik Samrasata", based on my speeches and articles was dedicated
Today I received a letter full of agony from the Dalit author of the book and my close friend Kishor
I am trying to convey agony of a dalit to you all, through this blog medium.
The full text of Shri Kishore Makwana's letter...
I am writing this letter to acquaint you with the following facts:
I was born in a Dalit family. My life is full of oppression and deprivation the Dalits have faced for
centuries. It is therefore natural for one to express the feelings of pangs the Dalits experience. I am
lucky to have fought and overcame the circumstances and am in a profession to write and express.
I have witnessed Chief Minister Shri Narendra Modi's thoughts and deeds from close quarters for two-
and-a-half decades. He has devoted his life in the service of the oppressed and the last man in the last
mile. His task is making the Dalits economically self-reliant, free them from exploitation and establish
the rule of equanimity, 'samras-ekras', in the state. In a way, his efforts are directed at realizing the
dreams of Dr Babasaheb Ambedkar. I have not seen any bias or prejudice in Shri Modi's thoughts and
deeds. I felt it as my duty to publicize his sense of duty before the public at large through writings and
speeches. It was the manifestation of such thinking that the book, titled 'Samajik Samrasta', was
created. This is not my first book. I have published 13 books, including that on Birsa Munda, Sant
Ravidas, 'Samar-Nahi-Samrasta', Rashtrabhakta Dr Babasaheb Ambedkar and Swami Vivekanand.
It was a matter of pride for me that my fourteenth book, 'Samajik Samrasta' was dedicated to the
public at a function on April 26, 2010 at 6.30 p.m. in presence of Swami Sacchidanand, Chief Minister
Shri Narendra Modi and noted poet-writer Suresh Dalal.
The entire function was conducted in full glory and decorum. It received rave reviews in the media. It
was the most eventful day and memorable event for a Dalit creative writer like me. But the brightest
pages were blackened by the Congress party, with an intention to malign a Dalit. Shri Modi did not
speak ill about the community in his speech, but the Congress reacted by putting imaginary words into
Shri Modi's mouth which he did not utter. It exposed the Congress leaders' attempt to malign a solemn
function to mark social equality with lies.
The Congress' lies have hurt not only my feelings and that of Shri Modi but also of the entire Dalit
community. The video recording and transcripts are available on the website and DVD for anybody to
The editor of leading English daily 'The Hindu', Shri N. Ram, has also exposed the Congress leaders'
feigning concern for the Dalits.
We cannot expect anything better from the Congress party, which had insulted Dr Babasaheb Ambedkar
throughout his life, and had always used Dalits as vote-bank. Dr Ambedkar had wanted a casteless
society, but the Congress continued to sow the seeds of hatred among different castes and races ever
since its inception.
Dr Ambedkar's book on what the Congress did for the untouchables is worth reading. It chronicles and
describes a number of events that uncovers the true face of anti-Dalit Congress. The people of Kavitha
village in the Ahmedabad district had once outcast untouchables. Dr Ambedkar came to Kavitha and
intervened. Instead of asking the upper caste people to take the untouchables along, the Congress
leaders asked the untouchables to leave the village. When he had arrived from Mumbai at Kalupur
railway station, the Congressmen heaped insults on him by waving black flags.
There are a number of such occasions of political parties like the Congress inflicting mental injuries on
Dr Ambedkar, using the Dalits as vote-bank. Instead of alleviating the pains of the oppressed-deprived-
exploited-suppressed Dalits, the Congress had only spread rumours and canards against thoughtful
people like Shri Narendrabhai Modi fighting for the cause of the Dalits. It is perhaps natural for the
Congress to express vengeance against them who oppose the formers' anti-Dalit policies.
I would also like to take this opportunity to draw your attention to vested interests and the need to
recognize such divisive forces bent on maligning Shri Modi for the last eight years.
I am conveying my views through this letter and expect you to share the views in the same spirit.
Editor of book 'Samajik Samrasta'
Editor of periodical 'Namaskar'.