Docstoc

WEB SALES REPORT OVER XXXX

Document Sample
WEB SALES REPORT OVER XXXX Powered By Docstoc
					                                                            SHELBY TOWNSHIP SALE LIST
                                                                      Residential Class Improved
                                                Sales from: 01/01/2006 TO: 12/31/2008                        Sales Over: $450,000
                                                                    This List is indexed by Neighborhood / Area Name
  Neighborhood / Area Name
                                                                                                     Sale                                                                    Sale $ /
  Parcel Number              Property Address         Manatron Number             Date of Sale       Price       Struc Type       Sq Ft   Yr Blt   Bsmt   Gar Area         Bldg. sq. ft.
                             Terms of Sale             Grantor                           Grantee                                 Sale Short Comments                 Other Parcel in sale #1

 ABERDEEN
 23-07-18-452-034            51100 FORSTER LN          50-07-593-100-10           03/31/2006    734,000         COLNL/SPLT-LEV   3,927     2003     YES       841               $186.91
                             RELATED PARTY/ NAL        SHANGO RAAD T & LINA              SHANGO IHSAN

 23-07-17-306-011            4350 FORSTER LN           50-07-593-227-00           05/15/2006     690,000        COLNL/SPLT-LEV   3,870     2004     YES       696               $178.29
                             CONVENTIONAL SALE         AMA ANNE S & KENNY                MIKHAIL NOHA

 23-07-18-401-009            51515 SANDSHORES          50-07-593-070-00           02/28/2007    470,000    COLNL/SPLT-LEV        3,275     1987     YES       570               $143.51
                             CONVENTIONAL SALE         QUITMEYER PAUL R & CINDY          NATER ERNST I & MARTINA R JERANT

 23-07-17-352-014            4121 CLEAR SPRING CT 50-07-593-131-00                04/27/2007    510,000         COLNL/SPLT-LEV   3,569     2001     YES       668               $142.90
                             TO/FR FINANCIAL INST      THE BANK OF NEW YORK              MAROOF THAER

 23-07-17-352-002            51158 CLEAR SPRING LN 50-07-593-119-00               04/11/2008    550,000    COLNL/SPLT-LEV        3,785     2003     YES       661               $145.31
                             CONVENTIONAL SALE         CANYON CONSTRUCTION INC           GORGES THAIER & THEKRA

 23-07-17-306-018            51347 MERRY LN            50-07-593-234-00           10/03/2006    536,454        RANCH             2,552     2006     YES       718               $210.21
                             PARTIAL ASSMT             LAKESHORE-SHELBY INC              QASAWA JANFIAF R & NABIL                H&W      DEED $166,450
                                                     Neighborhood / Area Name
                                                                                      Totals       3,490,454                     20,978                      4,154            $1007.13
                                                         ABERDEEN                                    581,742                      3,496    2000                692             $167.86
                                                                                   Averages
 ACREAGE SEC 19-21, 28-33 (SW QUAD)
 23-07-31-226-016            3455 BROOKLAND            50-07-031-016-10           03/15/2006        650,000        RANCH         2,379     1986     YES       929               $273.22
                             CONVENTIONAL SALE         SCHMIDT ROBERT II & RUTH          KIM EUI
                                                    Neighborhood / Area Name
                                                                                      Totals        650,000                       2,379                       929               $273.22
                                             ACREAGE SEC 19-21, 28-33 (SW QUAD)                     650,000                       2,379    1986               929               $273.22
                                                                                   Averages
 ACREAGE SEC'S 1-3, 10-15 (NE QUAD)
 23-07-11-400-025            13407 24 MILE             50-07-011-054-40           07/31/2007    450,000    COLNL/SPLT-LEV        4,144     1989     YES     1,046               $108.59
                             CONVENTIONAL SALE         PIERCE MARIA                      DETOMASO PHILLIP JR & MICHELLE

 23-07-02-100-005            56526 JEWELL              50-07-002-023-00           06/08/2007     782,592         MULTI/MIXED     1,187     1950     YES       864               $659.30
                             TO/FR FINANCIAL INST      MACOMB COUNTY SHERIFF             FIRST PLACE BANK



Print Date:02/26/09   Print Time: 16:52:20        SHELBY TOWNSHIP ASSESSOR'S SALE LIST RESIDENTIAL IMPROVED OVER: $450,000                                                  Pa g e : 1
                                                Sales from: 01/01/2006 TO: 12/31/2008                      Sales Over: $450,000
                                                                   This List is indexed by Neighborhood / Area Name
  Neighborhood / Area Name
                                                                                                   Sale                                                                   Sale $ /
  Parcel Number              Property Address         Manatron Number             Date of Sale     Price       Struc Type      Sq Ft   Yr Blt   Bsmt   Gar Area         Bldg. sq. ft.
                             Terms of Sale            Grantor                            Grantee                               Sale Short Comments                Other Parcel in sale #1

 23-07-02-100-005            56526 JEWELL             50-07-002-023-00            06/12/2007      782,592     MULTI/MIXED      1,187   1950      YES       864               $659.30
                             NOT AUDITED              FIRST STATE BANK                   RIZZO VINCENT J & NANCY D             REDEMPTION CERTIFICATE

 23-07-02-100-005            56526 JEWELL             50-07-002-023-00            06/15/2007     938,723       MULTI/MIXED     1,187   1950      YES       864               $790.84
                             TO/FR FINANCIAL INST     MACOMB COUNTY SHERIFF              FRANKLIN BANK

 23-07-01-476-003            55465 HAYES              50-07-001-036-00            12/10/2007   1,915,000   MULTI/MIXED         1,057   1947      YES       754             $1811.73
                             MULTIPLE PARCEL SALE     SHELBY 25 INVESTORS LLC            OZZAD PROPERTY MANAGEMENT LLC                                            23-07-01-476-001

 23-07-02-100-005            56526 JEWELL             50-07-002-023-00            06/15/2008     938,723       MULTI/MIXED     1,187   1950      YES       864               $790.84
                             TO/FR FINANCIAL INST     MACOMB COUNTY SHERIFF              FRANKLIN BANK
                                                   Neighborhood / Area Name
                                                                                      Totals     5,807,630                     9,949                      5,256            $4820.60
                                             ACREAGE SEC'S 1-3, 10-15 (NE QUAD)                    967,938                     1,658   1956                 876             $803.43
                                                                                   Averages
 ACREAGE SEC'S 4-9, 16-18 (NW QUAD)
 23-07-06-100-014            56933 MT VERNON          50-07-006-015-10            12/08/2006   1,000,000      COLNL/SPLT-LEV   3,057   1989      YES     1,119               $327.12
                             CONVENTIONAL SALE        MARTENS DARREN & JILL              STAPLES MARK D
                                                   Neighborhood / Area Name
                                                                                      Totals     1,000,000                     3,057                      1,119              $327.12
                                             ACREAGE SEC'S 4-9, 16-18 (NW QUAD)                  1,000,000                     3,057   1989               1,119              $327.12
                                                                                   Averages
 BIRCHFIELD SUB
 23-07-14-249-003            13471 EAGLE NEST TRAIL50-07-099-047-00               01/04/2006    500,000       COLNL/SPLT-LEV   3,711   2005      YES     1,104               $134.73
                             PARTIAL ASSMT            KEYSTONE HOMES                     KHAMO EMAD                            DEED $140,000

 23-07-14-233-002            13507 MAPLE LAWN         50-07-099-002-00            01/13/2006     560,000    COLNL/SPLT-LEV     3,313   2004      YES       705               $169.03
                             PARTIAL ASSMT            L & M HOMES INC                    BOIK DAVID L & ROSALIE J

 23-07-14-249-012            13248 MAPLE LAWN         50-07-099-056-00            04/26/2006    570,000       COLNL/SPLT-LEV   3,950   2004      YES       775               $144.30
                             CONVENTIONAL SALE        RISMAN DEVELOPMENT INC             GORGES MAURICE

 23-07-14-249-021            13512 MAPLE LAWN         50-07-099-065-00            04/27/2006     465,000   COLNL/SPLT-LEV      3,555   2004      YES       770               $130.80
                             PARTIAL ASSMT            L & M HOMES INC                    GOJCAJ GJOKA & DRANA

 23-07-14-233-003            13479 MAPLE LAWN         50-07-099-003-00            06/02/2006     525,000   COLNL/SPLT-LEV  3,681       2004      YES       733               $142.62
                             CONVENTIONAL SALE        L & M HOMES INC                    ORLANDI MARINO & KIMBERLY MIDDLET

 23-07-14-249-013            13274 MAPLE LAWN         50-07-099-057-00            08/04/2006    595,000    COLNL/SPLT-LEV      3,983   2005      YES       767               $149.38
                             PARTIAL ASSMT            RISMAN DEVELOPMETN INC             HURTTGAM ERIC J & GAIL B              NO PRE W PTA

 23-07-14-249-001            13569 EAGLE NEST TRAIL50-07-099-045-00               03/12/2007     675,000      COLNL/SPLT-LEV   3,318   2004      YES       679               $203.44
                             OUT OF STATE             L & M HOMES INC                    LOSH STEVEN

Print Date:02/26/09   Print Time: 16:52:20       SHELBY TOWNSHIP ASSESSOR'S SALE LIST RESIDENTIAL IMPROVED OVER: $450,000                                                Pa g e : 2
                                                Sales from: 01/01/2006 TO: 12/31/2008                       Sales Over: $450,000
                                                                      This List is indexed by Neighborhood / Area Name
  Neighborhood / Area Name
                                                                                                    Sale                                                                   Sale $ /
  Parcel Number              Property Address           Manatron Number           Date of Sale      Price       Struc Type      Sq Ft   Yr Blt   Bsmt   Gar Area         Bldg. sq. ft.
                             Terms of Sale              Grantor                           Grantee                              Sale Short Comments                 Other Parcel in sale #1

 23-07-14-249-001            13569 EAGLE NEST TRAIL50-07-099-045-00                09/28/2007   456,000   COLNL/SPLT-LEV  3,318         2004      YES       679               $137.43
                             TO/FR FINANCIAL INST       MACOMB COUNTY SHERIFF             MORTGAGE ELECTRONIC REGISTRATIO

 23-07-14-233-001            13565 MAPLE LAWN           50-07-099-001-00           12/07/2007    640,000    COLNL/SPLT-LEV     4,027    2004      YES       843               $158.93
                             CONVENTIONAL SALE          ALDI LAWRENCE A                   MUELLER ROGINA & ROBERT PICONE

 23-07-14-249-004            13437 EAGLE NEST TRAIL50-07-099-048-00                01/31/2008     482,500    COLNL/SPLT-LEV    3,497    2006      YES     1,030               $137.98
                             CONVENTIONAL SALE          RENAISSANCE BUILDING CO INC       LAZARIS PETER & JOSEPHINE

 23-07-14-234-012            52349 FOREST GROVE         50-07-099-027-00           07/24/2008    629,000    COLNL/SPLT-LEV     4,240    2006      YES       738               $148.35
                             CONVENTIONAL SALE          RISMAN DEVELOPMENT INC            REDMAN MIKE & AMY

 23-07-14-250-009            13376 EAGLE NEST TRAIL50-07-099-040-00                10/30/2008     485,000    COLNL/SPLT-LEV    3,932    2008      YES     1,248               $123.35
                             CONVENTIONAL SALE          RENAISSANCE BUILDING CO INC       MEGIE JASON A & JENNIFER M
                                                       Neighborhood / Area Name
                                                                                       Totals    6,582,500                     44,525                     10,071            $1780.35
                                                        BIRCHFIELD SUB                             548,541                      3,710   2004                 839             $148.36
                                                                                    Averages
 BUCK FOREST/COV. WOODS (SEC 12)
 23-07-12-405-009            53153 ALYSSA CT            50-07-153-012-00           08/14/2007     485,000   COLNL/SPLT-LEV     3,397    1993      YES       739               $142.77
                             CONVENTIONAL SALE          KANAN JOSEPH                      STULZ JEFFERY & KELLIE
                                                    Neighborhood / Area Name
                                                                                       Totals       485,000                     3,397                       739               $142.77
                                             BUCK FOREST/COV. WOODS (SEC 12)                        485,000                     3,397   1993                739               $142.77
                                                                                    Averages
 BUCKINGHAM GLEN/POINTE
 23-07-36-153-021            13891 STRATHMORE           50-07-765-030-00           01/12/2006     470,960     COLNL/SPLT-LEV   3,551    2006      YES       749               $132.63
                             PARTIAL ASSMT              RANDY DEPREZ CUSTOM HOMES I       GRIFKA WILLIAM J & LISA M            DEED $150,000
                                                      Neighborhood / Area Name
                                                                                       Totals       470,960                     3,551                       749               $132.63
                                                    BUCKINGHAM GLEN/POINTE                          470,960                     3,551   2006                749               $132.63
                                                                                    Averages
 CARRINGTON MANOR
 23-07-07-202-010            54469 SALEM                50-07-166-040-00           04/24/2006    527,000     COLNL/SPLT-LEV    4,109    1997      YES       713               $128.26
                             CONVENTIONAL SALE          EL-HAGE NABIL & GILDA             PATROS EDDIE & IVLIN                 DEED $1. EXECUTED 01/31/06

 23-07-07-202-009            54501 SALEM                50-07-166-039-00           09/29/2006     510,000    COLNL/SPLT-LEV    3,787    1996      YES       718               $134.67
                             TO/FROM TRUST              KACHOREK PENNY TRUST              LOFTIN DEAN R & DIANA R

 23-07-07-202-024            54017 HUNTINGTON           50-07-166-052-10           11/08/2006    470,000  COLNL/SPLT-LEV       4,093    1997      YES       671               $114.83
                             CONVENTIONAL SALE          HENRY KIMBERLY A & MICHAEL J      ASHFORD DURRAND                      DEED ONLY LISTED DURRAND



Print Date:02/26/09   Print Time: 16:52:20       SHELBY TOWNSHIP ASSESSOR'S SALE LIST RESIDENTIAL IMPROVED OVER: $450,000                                                 Pa g e : 3
                                                Sales from: 01/01/2006 TO: 12/31/2008                     Sales Over: $450,000
                                                                    This List is indexed by Neighborhood / Area Name
  Neighborhood / Area Name
                                                                                                  Sale                                                                    Sale $ /
  Parcel Number              Property Address         Manatron Number           Date of Sale      Price       Struc Type       Sq Ft   Yr Blt   Bsmt   Gar Area         Bldg. sq. ft.
                             Terms of Sale            Grantor                           Grantee                               Sale Short Comments                 Other Parcel in sale #1

 23-07-07-252-028            54232 CARRINGTON         50-07-166-097-00           02/28/2007     555,000    COLNL/SPLT-LEV     3,588    2005      YES       804               $154.68
                             CONVENTIONAL SALE        OLIVER HOMES                      FITAL CATHERINE & DAVID

 23-07-07-201-027            54876 ALEXIS CT          50-07-166-005-00           04/06/2007     595,513   COLNL/SPLT-LEV      4,023    1995      YES       702               $148.03
                             TO/FR FINANCIAL INST     MACOMB COUNTY SHERIFF             US BANK NATIONAL ASSOCIATION

 23-07-07-252-013            54722 SALEM              50-07-166-034-00           05/29/2007    467,500    COLNL/SPLT-LEV      4,132    1993      YES       738               $113.14
                             CONVENTIONAL SALE        ARTYMOVICH WILLIAM & DEBORA       LONG PATRICK M JR

 23-07-07-251-012            54220 SALEM              50-07-166-058-00           08/28/2007     510,000    COLNL/SPLT-LEV     3,860    2001      YES       700               $132.12
                             CONVENTIONAL SALE        ADRAGNA GIUSEPPE & CRISTINA       ABDAAL FRED & IMAN

 23-07-07-251-019            54045 BIRCHFIELD         50-07-166-083-00           11/30/2007    534,323       COLNL/SPLT-LEV   3,946    2002      YES       805               $135.41
                             TO/FR FINANCIAL INST     MACOMB COUNTY SHERIFF             FLAGSTAR BANK

 23-07-07-251-024            54495 CARRINGTON         50-07-166-112-00           01/18/2008   585,000   COLNL/SPLT-LEV  5,157          1998      YES       730               $113.44
                             TO/FR FINANCIAL INST     MACOMB COUNTY SHERIFF             MORTGAGE ELECTRONIC REGISTRATIO

 23-07-07-201-025            54911 ALEXIS CT          50-07-166-007-00           03/12/2008    650,000       COLNL/SPLT-LEV   4,877    2003      YES       817               $133.28
                             CONVENTIONAL SALE        OLIVER HOMES INC                  MURAD NITA

 23-07-07-251-024            54495 CARRINGTON         50-07-166-112-00           07/18/2008     585,000      COLNL/SPLT-LEV   5,157    1998      YES       730               $113.44
                             TO/FR FINANCIAL INST     MACOMB COUNTY SHERIFF             US BANK NA

 23-07-07-252-007            54438 ROSELAWN CT        50-07-166-028-00           09/12/2008     575,000   COLNL/SPLT-LEV      4,015    1993      YES       770               $143.21
                             CONVENTIONAL SALE        OSKOIAN THOMAS M & BROOKE         RIDER EUGENE & ISABELLE
                                                     Neighborhood / Area Name
                                                                                     Totals    6,564,336                      50,744                      8,898            $1564.51
                                                    CARRINGTON MANOR                             547,028                       4,228   1998                 741             $130.38
                                                                                  Averages
 CASCADES OF STONEY CREEK (ATT)
 23-07-05-201-021            56640 LONG ISLAND        50-07-162-021-00           05/03/2007  2,638,211     STYLE "A"          1,520    2007                399             $1735.67
                             NO CONSIDERATION         STONEY CREEK HOLDINGS LLC         CASCADES OF STONEY CREEK LLC          PTA $ 6091 MULT PARCELS

 23-07-05-201-092            5112 MESA                50-07-162-092-00           05/03/2007  2,638,211     STYLE "A"          1,520    2004                399             $1735.67
                             NO CONSIDERATION         STONEY CREEK HOLDINGS LLC         CASCADES OF STONEY CREEK LLC          PTA $6091 MULT PARCELS

 23-07-05-201-020            56632 LONG ISLAND        50-07-162-020-00           05/03/2007  2,638,211     STYLE "B"          1,433    2007      YES       399             $1841.04
                             NO CONSIDERATION         STONEY CREEK HOLDINGS LLC         CASCADES OF STONEY CREEK LLC          PTA $6091 MULT PARCELS

 23-07-05-201-093            5120 MESA                50-07-162-093-00           05/03/2007  2,638,211     STYLE "B"          1,434    2004      YES       399             $1839.76
                             NO CONSIDERATION         STONEY CREEK HOLDINGS LLC         CASCADES OF STONEY CREEK LLC          PTA $6091 MULT PARCELS



Print Date:02/26/09   Print Time: 16:52:20       SHELBY TOWNSHIP ASSESSOR'S SALE LIST RESIDENTIAL IMPROVED OVER: $450,000                                                Pa g e : 4
                                                Sales from: 01/01/2006 TO: 12/31/2008                    Sales Over: $450,000
                                                                   This List is indexed by Neighborhood / Area Name
  Neighborhood / Area Name
                                                                                                 Sale                                                                    Sale $ /
  Parcel Number              Property Address        Manatron Number           Date of Sale      Price       Struc Type       Sq Ft   Yr Blt   Bsmt   Gar Area         Bldg. sq. ft.
                             Terms of Sale           Grantor                           Grantee                               Sale Short Comments                 Other Parcel in sale #1

 23-07-05-201-116            5023 PALADIN            50-07-162-116-00           05/03/2007  2,638,211     STYLE "E"          1,377    2004                672             $1915.91
                             NO CONSIDERATION        STONEY CREEK HOLDINGS LLC         CASCADES OF STONEY CREEK LLC          PTA $6091 DEED MULT PARCELS

 23-07-05-201-019            56624 LONG ISLAND       50-07-162-019-00           05/03/2007  2,638,211     STYLE "F"          1,730    2007                353             $1524.98
                             PARTIAL ASSMT           STONEY CREEK HOLDINGS LLC         CASCADES OF STONEY CREEK LLC          PTA $6091 MULT PARCELS

 23-07-05-201-104            5074 MESA               50-07-162-104-00           05/03/2007  2,638,211   STYLE-ASHTON         1,418    2004                686             $1860.52
                             NO CONSIDERATION        STONEY CREEK HOLDINGS LLC         CASCADES OF STONEY CREEK LLC          PTA $6091 DEED MULT PARCELS

 23-07-05-201-156            56764 LONGHORN          50-07-162-156-00           05/03/2007  2,638,211   STYLE-ASHTON         1,418    2007                686             $1860.52
                             NO CONSIDERATION        STONEY CREEK HOLDINGS LLC         CASCADES OF STONEY CREEK LLC          PTA $6091 DEED MULT PARCELS

 23-07-05-201-157            56756 LONGHORN          50-07-162-157-00           05/03/2007  2,638,211   STYLE-ASHTON         1,418    2007                686             $1860.52
                             NO CONSIDERATION        STONEY CREEK HOLDINGS LLC         CASCADES OF STONEY CREEK LLC          PTA $6091 DEED MULT PARCELS

 23-07-05-201-168            56751 SUNSET            50-07-162-168-00           05/03/2007  2,638,211   STYLE-ASHTON         1,418    2007                686             $1860.52
                             NO CONSIDERATION        STONEY CREEK HOLDINGS LLC         CASCADES OF STONEY CREEK LLC          PTA $6091 DEED MULT PARCELS

 23-07-05-201-169            56759 SUNSET            50-07-162-169-00           05/03/2007  2,638,211   STYLE-ASHTON         1,418    2007                686             $1860.52
                             NO CONSIDERATION        STONEY CREEK HOLDINGS LLC         CASCADES OF STONEY CREEK LLC          PTA $6091 DEED MULT PARCELS
                                                   Neighborhood / Area Name
                                                                                    Totals    29,020,325                     16,104                      6,051           $19895.60
                                             CASCADES OF STONEY CREEK (ATT)                    2,638,211                      1,464   2005                 550            $1808.69
                                                                                 Averages
 COPPERFIELD
 23-07-06-252-020            3224 MOUNTBATTEN CT 50-07-178-080-00               08/10/2007    640,000          RANCH         2,893    1999      YES       697               $221.22
                             CONVENTIONAL SALE       CASTELLANA JOHN & LISA            STAPELS MARK D
                                                    Neighborhood / Area Name
                                                                                    Totals       640,000                      2,893                       697               $221.22
                                                       COPPERFIELD                               640,000                      2,893   1999                697               $221.22
                                                                                 Averages
 CREEKSIDE VILLAGE
 23-07-06-101-014            56892 OAKWAY            50-07-191-151-00           01/21/2006    550,000   COLNL/SPLT-LEV       3,002    2005      YES       706               $183.21
                             PARTIAL ASSMT           DELTA BUILDING LLC                DAOUD AMJED & MARY E                  NO PRE W PTA

 23-07-06-106-015            56644 HARTLEY CT        50-07-191-133-00           04/10/2006    544,050    COLNL/SPLT-LEV      3,833    2005      YES       705               $141.94
                             PARTIAL ASSMT           L C & ASSOCIATES LLC              REKAR KEVIN & NANCY

 23-07-06-153-018            2276 NICKELBY           50-07-191-103-00           04/19/2006    559,700    COLNL/SPLT-LEV      4,309    2005      YES       681               $129.89
                             PARTIAL ASSMT           NINO HOMES & ASSOCIATES INC       COON DAVID A & MONICA G

 23-07-06-177-012            2715 HAWTHORNE SOUT 50-07-191-042-00               04/26/2006     585,000      COLNL/SPLT-LEV   3,665    2002      YES       692               $159.62
                             SELLER FINANCED         RUTZ DAVID                        VITTO GREGORY L

Print Date:02/26/09   Print Time: 16:52:20       SHELBY TOWNSHIP ASSESSOR'S SALE LIST RESIDENTIAL IMPROVED OVER: $450,000                                               Pa g e : 5
                                                Sales from: 01/01/2006 TO: 12/31/2008                   Sales Over: $450,000
                                                                  This List is indexed by Neighborhood / Area Name
  Neighborhood / Area Name
                                                                                                Sale                                                                   Sale $ /
  Parcel Number              Property Address        Manatron Number          Date of Sale      Price       Struc Type      Sq Ft   Yr Blt   Bsmt   Gar Area         Bldg. sq. ft.
                             Terms of Sale           Grantor                          Grantee                               Sale Short Comments                Other Parcel in sale #1

 23-07-06-177-015            2597 HAWTHORNE SOUT 50-07-191-045-00              04/28/2006    552,000   COLNL/SPLT-LEV       3,835   2003      YES       867               $143.94
                             PARTIAL ASSMT           NINO HOMES & ASSOCIATES          MOORE BRUCE D & GRETCHEN L            PTA $549,000

 23-07-06-177-008            2648 HAWTHORNE NORT 50-07-191-038-00              05/17/2006    450,000    COLNL/SPLT-LEV      3,859   2004      YES       680               $116.61
                             PARTIAL ASSMT           OLYMPIA HOMES INC                PRASHAR ABHIN & ANUSUYA

 23-07-06-106-007            56793 HARTLEY E         50-07-191-125-00          05/22/2006     463,700   COLNL/SPLT-LEV      3,764   2006      YES       705               $123.19
                             PARTIAL ASSMT           L C & ASSOCIATES LLC             GABRAIL KASSAN & ASEEL

 23-07-06-106-002            2471 NICKELBY           50-07-191-120-00          06/16/2006   559,000   COLNL/SPLT-LEV 4,066          2005      YES       837               $137.48
                             PARTIAL ASSMT           NINO HOMES & ASSOCIATES INC      LANGWORTHY CHARLES & A SKOWRON

 23-07-06-107-007            56831 HARTLEY W         50-07-191-144-00          08/17/2006     561,500    COLNL/SPLT-LEV     3,647   2005      YES       723               $153.96
                             PARTIAL ASSMT           DELTA BUILDING LLC               DAVIS JOE & TERESA

 23-07-06-106-014            56676 HARTLEY CT        50-07-191-132-00          08/30/2006    573,000    COLNL/SPLT-LEV      3,876   2006      YES       686               $147.83
                             PARTIAL ASSMT           LC & ASSOCIATES LLC              MEHR JOHN & NICHOLLE                  RERCORD DATE 18219/356

 23-07-06-106-005            56701 HARTLEY E         50-07-191-123-00          09/15/2006    524,879     COLNL/SPLT-LEV     3,653   2005      YES       702               $143.68
                             PARTIAL ASSMT           DELTA BUILDING LLC               WAHL ERIC A & SHARI M DUFFY

 23-07-06-177-007            2590 HAWTHORNE NORT 50-07-191-037-00              09/27/2006    523,000    COLNL/SPLT-LEV      4,258   2004      YES       687               $122.83
                             PARTIAL ASSMT           OLYMPIA HOMES INC                COPACIA TREVOR J & KIMBERLY A

 23-07-06-107-004            56870 HARTLEY W         50-07-191-147-00          10/10/2006    511,700    COLNL/SPLT-LEV      3,827   2006      YES       682               $133.71
                             PARTIAL ASSMT           L. C. & ASSOCIATES               KOERBER KEVIN & KATHLEE A

 23-07-06-101-018            56742 HARTLEY E         50-07-191-155-00          11/03/2006     488,950    COLNL/SPLT-LEV     3,257   2006      YES       708               $150.12
                             PARTIAL ASSMT           L C & ASSOCIATES LLC             HIOVICH JOHN P & CAPRI P

 23-07-06-153-012            55943 ASHBROOKE EAST 50-07-191-080-00             12/20/2006    595,000   COLNL/SPLT-LEV       3,840   2003      YES       662               $154.95
                             PARTIAL ASSMT           NINO HOMES & ASSOCIATES          PORTER LAWRENCE J

 23-07-06-177-012            2715 HAWTHORNE SOUT 50-07-191-042-00              04/01/2007    525,000       COLNL/SPLT-LEV   3,665   2002      YES       692               $143.25
                             TO/FR FINANCIAL INST    VITTO GREGORY L                  RUTZ DAVID

 23-07-06-106-001            56629 HARTLEY EAST      50-07-191-121-00          06/29/2007     542,890    COLNL/SPLT-LEV     4,417   2006      YES       642               $122.91
                             PARTIAL ASSMT           NINO HOMES & ASSOCIATES INC      WILKINS LEONARD J & DONNA J

 23-07-06-153-012            55943 ASHBROOKE EAST 50-07-191-080-00             01/25/2008    511,868       COLNL/SPLT-LEV   3,840   2003      YES       662               $133.30
                             TO/FR FINANCIAL INST    MACOMB COUNTY SHERIFF            HSBC BANK USA

 23-07-06-154-008            2172 NICKELBY           50-07-191-007-00          04/10/2008    500,000       COLNL/SPLT-LEV   3,918   2002      YES       865               $127.62
                             CONVENTIONAL SALE       DOUGHTY LIVING TRUST             BOYD APRIL


Print Date:02/26/09   Print Time: 16:52:20       SHELBY TOWNSHIP ASSESSOR'S SALE LIST RESIDENTIAL IMPROVED OVER: $450,000                                             Pa g e : 6
                                                Sales from: 01/01/2006 TO: 12/31/2008                     Sales Over: $450,000
                                                                   This List is indexed by Neighborhood / Area Name
  Neighborhood / Area Name
                                                                                                  Sale                                                                    Sale $ /
  Parcel Number              Property Address         Manatron Number          Date of Sale       Price       Struc Type       Sq Ft   Yr Blt   Bsmt   Gar Area         Bldg. sq. ft.
                             Terms of Sale            Grantor                           Grantee                               Sale Short Comments                 Other Parcel in sale #1

 23-07-06-153-009            56079 ASHBROOKE EAST 50-07-191-077-00              05/15/2008     510,000     COLNL/SPLT-LEV     4,164    2006      YES     1,393               $122.48
                             TO/FROM TRUST            SOCKS JOHN                        SOCKS JOHN R LIVING TRUST

 23-07-06-153-009            56079 ASHBROOKE EAST 50-07-191-077-00              05/15/2008      510,000      COLNL/SPLT-LEV   4,164    2006      YES     1,393               $122.48
                             CONVENTIONAL SALE        SOCKS JOHN R LIVING TRUST         DIPIAZZA DAVID

 23-07-06-153-012            55943 ASHBROOKE EAST 50-07-191-080-00              07/25/2008     511,868       COLNL/SPLT-LEV   3,840    2003      YES       662               $133.30
                             TO/FR FINANCIAL INST     MACOMB COUNTY SHERIFF             HSBC BANK USA

 23-07-06-101-015            56854 HARTLEY E          50-07-191-152-00          05/26/2006      470,000      RANCH            2,567    2005      YES       775               $183.09
                             PARTIAL ASSMT            DELTA BUILDING LLC                MARTIN GARY P & DEBRA K
                                                    Neighborhood / Area Name
                                                                                     Totals   12,123,105                      87,266                     17,807            $3231.39
                                                    CREEKSIDE VILLAGE                            527,091                       3,794   2004                 774             $140.50
                                                                                  Averages
 FOREST GLEN/PINECREST SITE CONDOS
 23-07-13-105-009            52896 SABLE CT           50-07-476-009-00          01/11/2006     648,750       COLNL/SPLT-LEV   4,114    2002      YES     1,366               $157.69
                             CONVENTIONAL SALE        TOBIANSKI GARY & PENNY            ORR JAMES & ERIN                      PTA $650,000

 23-07-13-105-001            52945 SABLE CT           50-07-476-001-00          01/13/2006      910,000      COLNL/SPLT-LEV   3,997    2000      YES     1,095               $227.67
                             NOT TYPICAL              NEFF SUSAN                        KING WILLIAM R JR

 23-07-11-303-013            12235 FOREST GLEN LN 50-07-261-013-00              06/30/2006     968,138  COLNL/SPLT-LEV        5,095    1998      YES       921               $190.02
                             TO/FR FINANCIAL INST     MACOMB COUNTY SHERIFF             ABN AMRO MORTGAGE GROUP INC

 23-07-11-303-020            12452 FOREST GLEN LN 50-07-261-020-00              07/26/2006      690,000   COLNL/SPLT-LEV      3,906    1996      YES     1,743               $176.65
                             TO/FROM TRUST            MOLJEWSKI PAMELA TRUST            SNIDER ANDREW & ELAIN MALLEY-

 23-07-11-303-013            12235 FOREST GLEN LN 50-07-261-013-00              08/07/2006     968,138  COLNL/SPLT-LEV        5,095    1998      YES       921               $190.02
                             TO/FR FINANCIAL INST     MACOMB COUNTY SHERIFF             ABN AMRO MORTGAGE GROUP INC           UNCAP 08 IF NOT SOLD BY

 23-07-13-105-001            52945 SABLE CT           50-07-476-001-00          12/15/2006     615,762   COLNL/SPLT-LEV       3,997    2000      YES     1,095               $154.06
                             TO/FR FINANCIAL INST     MACOMB COUNTY SHERIFF             JPMORGAN CHASE BANK

 23-07-11-303-013            12235 FOREST GLEN LN 50-07-261-013-00              02/08/2007      639,000      COLNL/SPLT-LEV   5,095    1998      YES       921               $125.42
                             TO/FR FINANCIAL INST     ABN AMRO MORTGAGE GROUP IN        KHALIFA RAFIK                         DEED C

 23-07-11-303-013            12235 FOREST GLEN LN 50-07-261-013-00              05/02/2007     889,000       COLNL/SPLT-LEV   5,095    1998      YES       921               $174.48
                             CONVENTIONAL SALE        KHALIFA RAFIK & CECILE            SCHMIDT LISA M

 23-07-13-105-001            52945 SABLE CT           50-07-476-001-00          06/15/2007     615,762   COLNL/SPLT-LEV  3,997  2000      YES            1,095               $154.06
                             TO/FR FINANCIAL INST     MACOMB COUNTY SHERIFF             JPMORGAN CHASE BANK NATIONAL ASS UNCAP 09 IF NO SALE



Print Date:02/26/09   Print Time: 16:52:20       SHELBY TOWNSHIP ASSESSOR'S SALE LIST RESIDENTIAL IMPROVED OVER: $450,000                                                Pa g e : 7
                                                Sales from: 01/01/2006 TO: 12/31/2008                      Sales Over: $450,000
                                                                     This List is indexed by Neighborhood / Area Name
  Neighborhood / Area Name
                                                                                                   Sale                                                                    Sale $ /
  Parcel Number              Property Address          Manatron Number           Date of Sale      Price       Struc Type       Sq Ft   Yr Blt   Bsmt   Gar Area         Bldg. sq. ft.
                             Terms of Sale             Grantor                           Grantee                               Sale Short Comments                 Other Parcel in sale #1

 23-07-11-303-024            12336 FOREST GLEN LN 50-07-261-024-00                10/12/2007     455,000   COLNL/SPLT-LEV      2,975    1996      YES       931               $152.94
                             CONVENTIONAL SALE         ANDREWS MARK C & DEBORAH L        KRASKI STEPHEN M & MICHELE

 23-07-13-105-001            52945 SABLE CT            50-07-476-001-00           01/31/2008     457,500     COLNL/SPLT-LEV    3,997    2000      YES     1,095               $114.46
                             CONVENTIONAL SALE         RIBAUDO MICHAEL A & MICHELLE      HARRIS BRIAN & LISA

 23-07-13-105-002            52891 SABLE CT            50-07-476-002-00           12/24/2008   510,000        COLNL/SPLT-LEV   4,723    2001      YES     1,681               $107.98
                             CONVENTIONAL SALE         JOHNS WILLIAM JR & SHANNON        MARCHEWITZ ERIC
                                                    Neighborhood / Area Name
                                                                                      Totals    8,367,052                      52,086                     13,785            $1925.45
                                             FOREST GLEN/PINECREST SITE CONDOS                    697,254                       4,340   1998               1,148             $160.45
                                                                                   Averages
 FOREST PARK ESTATES
 23-07-09-401-013            53472 AURORA PARK         50-07-262-046-00           01/13/2006    454,330    COLNL/SPLT-LEV      2,809    2005      YES       756               $161.74
                             PARTIAL ASSMT             TORRES BUILDING CO INC            DANYKO DAVID S & ROBERTA E

 23-07-09-328-019            6733 PAINT CREEK CT       50-07-262-022-00           01/25/2006    506,296  COLNL/SPLT-LEV        3,310    2005      YES       755               $152.96
                             PARTIAL ASSMT             GUY-CON BUILDIING CORP            DIRNBERGER EDWARD & E VOULTOS

 23-07-09-328-025            53813 AURORA PARK         50-07-262-016-00           08/30/2006    505,000    COLNL/SPLT-LEV      2,879    2005      YES       657               $175.41
                             PARTIAL ASSMT             POLO HOMES INC                    ROSEN MARY E & RICHARD K

 23-07-09-401-011            7020 SUGAR CREEK CT 50-07-262-044-00                 01/19/2007    525,000       COLNL/SPLT-LEV   2,742    2004      YES       657               $191.47
                             CONVENTIONAL SALE         TORRES BULDING COMPANY            ROSEN RICHARD K                       NO PRE W PTA. MLG PER PTA
                                                      Neighborhood / Area Name
                                                                                      Totals    1,990,626                      11,740                      2,825              $681.57
                                                    FOREST PARK ESTATES                           497,656                       2,935   2004                 706              $170.39
                                                                                   Averages
 GOLDEN LAKES SUB
 23-07-23-452-008            49309 GOLDEN LAKE         50-07-277-066-00           05/01/2007    500,000   COLNL/SPLT-LEV       3,360    2000      YES       946               $148.81
                             CONVENTIONAL SALE         FORGIONE LARRY & AMY              BADALAMENTI ANTONINO & RAECHEL        SPELLING PER DEED PRE LATER

 23-07-23-478-002            49442 SANDRA              50-07-277-021-00           05/18/2007    477,630   COLNL/SPLT-LEV       3,628    1999      YES       861               $131.65
                             TO/FR FINANCIAL INST      MACOMB COUNTY SHERIFF             DEUTSCHE BANK NATIONAL TRUST

 23-07-23-273-024            12790 BLUE LAKES CIR      50-07-273-024-00           08/04/2007     460,000    COLNL/SPLT-LEV     3,483    2005      YES       780               $132.07
                             CONVENTIONAL SALE         JIRGIS USAM & INTESAR             WILLIAMS RAY & APRIL

 23-07-23-401-002            49961 GOLDEN LAKE         50-07-277-083-00           07/18/2008   501,592   COLNL/SPLT-LEV  3,156          2000      YES       868               $158.93
                             TO/FR FINANCIAL INST      MACOMB COUNTY SHERIFF             MORTGAGE ELECTRONIC REG SYSTEMS
                                                     Neighborhood / Area Name
                                                                                      Totals    1,939,222                      13,627                      3,455              $571.46
                                                     GOLDEN LAKES SUB                             484,805                       3,406   2001                 863              $142.87
                                                                                   Averages

Print Date:02/26/09   Print Time: 16:52:20       SHELBY TOWNSHIP ASSESSOR'S SALE LIST RESIDENTIAL IMPROVED OVER: $450,000                                                 Pa g e : 8
                                                Sales from: 01/01/2006 TO: 12/31/2008                  Sales Over: $450,000
                                                                 This List is indexed by Neighborhood / Area Name
  Neighborhood / Area Name
                                                                                               Sale                                                                   Sale $ /
  Parcel Number              Property Address        Manatron Number         Date of Sale      Price       Struc Type      Sq Ft   Yr Blt   Bsmt   Gar Area         Bldg. sq. ft.
                             Terms of Sale           Grantor                         Grantee                               Sale Short Comments                Other Parcel in sale #1

 GOLDEN LAKES-LAKE
 23-07-23-428-018            49662 LAKEBRIDGE        50-07-277-152-00         03/23/2006     670,000      COLNL/SPLT-LEV   3,526   1999      YES       466               $190.02
                             OUT OF STATE            BORST RICHARD K & STELLA        BOS LISA & KEVIN

 23-07-23-429-020            13059 AZURE             50-07-277-032-00         04/21/2006     675,000    COLNL/SPLT-LEV     4,401   2005      YES       759               $153.37
                             PARTIAL ASSMT           CAROLLO PIETRO & ROSALBA        MILLER JACQUE L & SONIA R

 23-07-23-429-017            13157 AZURE             50-07-277-029-00         11/17/2006   511,483   COLNL/SPLT-LEV  3,734         2002      YES       681               $136.98
                             TO/FR FINANCIAL INST    MACOMB COUNTY SHERIFF           MORTGAGE ELECTRONIC REGISTRATIO

 23-07-23-429-011            49609 LAKEBRIDGE        50-07-277-108-00         12/15/2006    685,000       COLNL/SPLT-LEV   4,045   2001      YES       642               $169.34
                             OUT OF STATE            GONZALES ROGELIO & ROSE MA      BROWN DARRYL

 23-07-23-428-016            49650 LAKEBRIDGE        50-07-277-150-00         03/21/2007     540,000    COLNL/SPLT-LEV     3,523   2005      YES       757               $153.28
                             PARTIAL ASSMT           GIAMBANCO BUILDING CORP         JOSEPH JOLLY & TINO MANIMALETHU

 23-07-23-429-014            13287 AZURE             50-07-277-026-00         04/27/2007    523,403   COLNL/SPLT-LEV       3,242   2000      YES       759               $161.44
                             TO/FR FINANCIAL INST    MACOMB COUNTY SHERIFF           AURORA LOAN SERVICES LLC

 23-07-23-429-011            49609 LAKEBRIDGE        50-07-277-108-00         06/08/2007    567,452  COLNL/SPLT-LEV        4,045   2001      YES       642               $140.28
                             TO/FR FINANCIAL INST    MACOMB COUNTY SHERIFF           GREENPOINT MORTGAGE FUNDING

 23-07-23-429-015            13225 AZURE             50-07-277-027-00         06/15/2007   477,000   COLNL/SPLT-LEV  3,779         2000      YES       655               $126.22
                             TO/FR FINANCIAL INST    MACOMB COUNTY SHERIFF           MORTGAGE ELECTRONIC REGISTARION

 23-07-23-477-025            49290 GOLDEN LAKE       50-07-277-060-00         07/13/2007     678,860   COLNL/SPLT-LEV      3,927   2000      YES       658               $172.87
                             TO/FR FINANCIAL INST    MACOMB COUNTY SHERIFF           US BANK NATIONAL ASSOCIATION

 23-07-23-429-020            13059 AZURE             50-07-277-032-00         11/09/2007   593,743   COLNL/SPLT-LEV  4,401         2005      YES       759               $134.91
                             TO/FR FINANCIAL INST    MACOMB COUNTY SHERIFF           MORTGAGE ELCTRONIC REGISTRATION

 23-07-23-429-017            13157 AZURE             50-07-277-029-00         11/21/2007    480,000       COLNL/SPLT-LEV   3,734   2002      YES       681               $128.55
                             TO/FR FINANCIAL INST    COUNTRYWIDE HOME LOANS INC      SOLAKA GEORGE T                       COV DEED SENT RPS 3/17/08

 23-07-23-477-001            12950 AZURE             50-07-277-036-00         12/05/2007   650,000     COLNL/SPLT-LEV      4,240   2002      YES       751               $153.30
                             CONVENTIONAL SALE       CHIRCO MICHELE                  STEMMERICH INGRID                     NO PTA OR PRE FILED/DJK

 23-07-23-477-025            49290 GOLDEN LAKE       50-07-277-060-00         01/13/2008     678,860   COLNL/SPLT-LEV      3,927   2000      YES       658               $172.87
                             TO/FR FINANCIAL INST    MACOMB COUNTY SHERIFF           US BANK NATIONAL ASSOCIATION          UNCAP 10 IF NO SALE IN 09

 23-07-23-429-020            13059 AZURE             50-07-277-032-00         05/09/2008   593,743   COLNL/SPLT-LEV   4,401        2005      YES       759               $134.91
                             TO/FR FINANCIAL INST    MACOMB COUNTY SHERIFF           MORTGAGE ELEC REGISTRATION SYSTE



Print Date:02/26/09   Print Time: 16:52:20       SHELBY TOWNSHIP ASSESSOR'S SALE LIST RESIDENTIAL IMPROVED OVER: $450,000                                            Pa g e : 9
                                                Sales from: 01/01/2006 TO: 12/31/2008                       Sales Over: $450,000
                                                                      This List is indexed by Neighborhood / Area Name
  Neighborhood / Area Name
                                                                                                    Sale                                                                     Sale $ /
  Parcel Number              Property Address           Manatron Number           Date of Sale      Price       Struc Type       Sq Ft   Yr Blt   Bsmt   Gar Area          Bldg. sq. ft.
                             Terms of Sale              Grantor                           Grantee                               Sale Short Comments                  Other Parcel in sale #1

 23-07-23-428-018            49662 LAKEBRIDGE           50-07-277-152-00           06/06/2008    559,828       COLNL/SPLT-LEV   3,526    1999      YES       466                $158.77
                             TO/FR FINANCIAL INST       MACOMB COUNTY SHERIFF             HSBC BANK USA

 23-07-23-428-018            49662 LAKEBRIDGE           50-07-277-152-00           07/09/2008    559,828       COLNL/SPLT-LEV   3,526    1999      YES       466                $158.77
                             TO/FR FINANCIAL INST       MACOMB COUNTY SHERIFF             HSBC BANK USA

 23-07-23-429-020            13059 AZURE                50-07-277-032-00           07/31/2008     485,000      COLNL/SPLT-LEV   4,401    2005      YES       759                $110.20
                             TO/FR FINANCIAL INST       COLONIAL NATIONAL MORTGAGE        HIRMIZ FARID                          SENT RPS ON 8/5/08; COV DEED
                                                       Neighborhood / Area Name
                                                                                       Totals    9,929,201                      66,378                     11,318             $2556.10
                                                      GOLDEN LAKES-LAKE                            584,070                       3,904   2001                 665              $150.36
                                                                                    Averages
 HIDDEN RIVER WOODS
 23-07-02-302-016            55618 LORDONA LN           50-07-292-030-00           03/20/2006     620,000   COLNL/SPLT-LEV      3,815    1987      YES       852                $162.52
                             CONVENTIONAL SALE          LENANDER JEFFREY & SANDRA         LIGDA ANDREW M & SHELLY L
                                                       Neighborhood / Area Name
                                                                                       Totals       620,000                      3,815                         852              $162.52
                                                      HIDDEN RIVER WOODS                            620,000                      3,815   1987                  852              $162.52
                                                                                    Averages
 LAKE IN THE WOODS-LAKE
 23-07-10-227-009            54516 QUEENSBOROUGH50-07-347-018-00                   09/11/2007    875,000   COLNL/SPLT-LEV       5,080    1998      YES       898                $172.24
                             CONVENTIONAL SALE          CASASANTA LUCY                    PANKRATZ CHARLES E TRUST

 23-07-10-226-007            11436 HEATHERWOOD CT50-07-347-011-00                  10/26/2007     875,200      COLNL/SPLT-LEV   3,966    1997      YES       855                $220.68
                             TO/FR FINANCIAL INST       MACOMB COUNTY SHERIFF             LASALLE BANK
                                                       Neighborhood / Area Name
                                                                                       Totals    1,750,200                       9,046                      1,753               $392.92
                                                    LAKE IN THE WOODS-LAKE                         875,100                       4,523   1997                 876               $196.46
                                                                                    Averages
 LAKE POINTE WOODS
 23-07-11-252-002            54210 OAKDALE              50-07-349-016-00           05/01/2007    454,500   COLNL/SPLT-LEV       4,123    1997      YES       892                $110.24
                             CONVENTIONAL SALE          ACOVSKI JOSE & AGNES              AYAR MUHANDAD & DOLORES R
                                                       Neighborhood / Area Name
                                                                                       Totals       454,500                      4,123                         892              $110.24
                                                      LAKE POINTE WOODS                             454,500                      4,123   1997                  892              $110.24
                                                                                    Averages
 LAKE POINTE WOODS-LAKE
 23-07-11-427-027            13154 LOOKOUT POINTE 50-07-349-089-00                 08/18/2006     525,000      COLNL/SPLT-LEV   3,604    1994      YES       652                $145.67
                             TO/FROM TRUST              CISCO EDWARD D & MARGARET         FOY WILLIAM R




Print Date:02/26/09   Print Time: 16:52:20       SHELBY TOWNSHIP ASSESSOR'S SALE LIST RESIDENTIAL IMPROVED OVER: $450,000                                                   Pa g e : 10
                                                Sales from: 01/01/2006 TO: 12/31/2008                     Sales Over: $450,000
                                                                    This List is indexed by Neighborhood / Area Name
  Neighborhood / Area Name
                                                                                                  Sale                                                                     Sale $ /
  Parcel Number              Property Address         Manatron Number           Date of Sale      Price       Struc Type     Sq Ft   Yr Blt   Bsmt    Gar Area           Bldg. sq. ft.
                             Terms of Sale            Grantor                           Grantee                             Sale Short Comments                    Other Parcel in sale #1

 23-07-11-427-029            13151 LOOKOUT POINTE 50-07-349-087-00               06/20/2007     460,000   COLNL/SPLT-LEV    3,413    1995      YES           669              $134.78
                             CONVENTIONAL SALE        RAO BONITA                        ZWIEZ STEVEN & DOROTHY
                                                    Neighborhood / Area Name
                                                                                     Totals       985,000                    7,017                       1,321                $280.45
                                                 LAKE POINTE WOODS-LAKE                           492,500                    3,508   1994                  660                $140.23
                                                                                  Averages
 LOUIS LAKES ESTATES SITE CONDOS
 23-07-31-199-011            2929 ERMA                50-07-378-011-00           01/25/2006     569,000    COLNL/SPLT-LEV   3,530    2004      YES           761              $161.19
                             PARTIAL ASSMT            MERAM BUILDING LLC                HIRMIZ GHASSAN P & JEOLEIT EILIYA   NO PRE W PTA

 23-07-31-199-007            3051 ERMA                50-07-378-007-00           03/09/2006     525,000  COLNL/SPLT-LEV     3,692    2005      YES           743              $142.20
                             PARTIAL ASSMT            MERAM BUILDING LLC                JAJOU AWSAM & LENDA

 23-07-31-199-012            2895 ERMA                50-07-378-012-00           05/02/2006    504,000   COLNL/SPLT-LEV     3,484    2004      YES           599              $144.66
                             PARTIAL ASSMT            MERAM BUILDING LLC                THOMAS ROMEO & FLORENCE
                                                    Neighborhood / Area Name
                                                                                     Totals    1,598,000                    10,706                       2,103                $448.05
                                             LOUIS LAKES ESTATES SITE CONDOS                     532,666                     3,568   2004                  701                $149.35
                                                                                  Averages
 MEADOWRIDGE
 23-07-06-474-002                                50-07-401-002-00
                             55199 MEADOW RIDGE CT                               09/20/2007    460,000    COLNL/SPLT-LEV    3,657    2002      YES           665              $125.79
                             CONVENTIONAL SALE        RYDZIK KRZYSZTOF & KLAUDIA        BLEDSOE JEFFRY M & LESLIE M
                                                     Neighborhood / Area Name
                                                                                     Totals       460,000                    3,657                           665              $125.79
                                                       MEADOWRIDGE                                460,000                    3,657   2002                    665              $125.79
                                                                                  Averages
 MEADOWS @ CENTRAL PARK
 23-07-21-376-010            49101 WEST CENTRAL PA50-07-403-010-00               09/12/2006     562,299  COLNL/SPLT-LEV         0    2007                      0          $562299.55
                             VAC LAND SALE(MULTI)     GRAND SAKWA OF SHELBY LLC         VALENTI CUSTOM HOMES INC            UNITS 10,81,179,185,186

 23-07-21-376-035            49579 WEST CENTRAL PA50-07-403-035-00               08/14/2006    473,375      RANCH           1,590    2007      YES           462              $297.72
                             VAC LAND SALE (GOOD)     GRAND SAWKA OF SHELBY LLC         LOCHIRCO HOMES OF SHELBY LLC        UNIT 27,35,139,140,156,159,160
                                                    Neighborhood / Area Name
                                                                                     Totals    1,035,674                     1,590                           462          $562597.27
                                                 MEADOWS @ CENTRAL PARK                          517,837                       795   2007                    231          $281298.64
                                                                                  Averages
 PINEWOOD ESTATES
 23-07-04-203-019            56537 SUMMIT             50-07-477-019-00           01/12/2006   462,500   COLNL/SPLT-LEV      3,513    2004      YES           667              $131.65
                             PARTIAL ASSMT            D'ANNA BUILDING INC               MCCLOUD TERRENCE B & NAVIA N        17683/321




Print Date:02/26/09   Print Time: 16:52:20       SHELBY TOWNSHIP ASSESSOR'S SALE LIST RESIDENTIAL IMPROVED OVER: $450,000                                                 Pa g e : 11
                                                Sales from: 01/01/2006 TO: 12/31/2008                   Sales Over: $450,000
                                                                 This List is indexed by Neighborhood / Area Name
  Neighborhood / Area Name
                                                                                                Sale                                                                   Sale $ /
  Parcel Number              Property Address        Manatron Number          Date of Sale      Price       Struc Type      Sq Ft   Yr Blt   Bsmt   Gar Area         Bldg. sq. ft.
                             Terms of Sale           Grantor                         Grantee                                Sale Short Comments                Other Parcel in sale #1

 23-07-04-206-039            56312 SUMMIT            50-07-477-140-00         01/20/2006    537,617  COLNL/SPLT-LEV         3,687   2001      YES       762               $145.81
                             TO/FR FINANCIAL INST    MACOMB COUNTY SHERIFF           WASHINGTON MUTUAL BANK                 UNCAP 08 IF NO SALE

 23-07-04-206-001            7156 VISTA              50-07-477-102-00         02/03/2006     571,996   COLNL/SPLT-LEV       3,648   2004      YES       717               $156.80
                             TO/FR FINANCIAL INST    MACOMB COUNTY SHERIFF           US BANK NATIONAL ASSOC

 23-07-04-205-002            56916 PINECONE BLVD     50-07-477-079-00         02/17/2006    475,000    COLNL/SPLT-LEV       3,763   2000      YES       712               $126.23
                             TO/FR FINANCIAL INST    AMERICAN HOME MORTGAGE          GOUDIOTIS STELLAKIS T & LISA A         NO PRE W PTA DEED "C"

 23-07-04-252-026            55973 RED CEDAR CT      50-07-477-048-00         02/28/2006        792,000    COLNL/SPLT-LEV   4,241   2001      YES       721               $186.75
                             NOT TYPICAL             ZUTANTAS STEPHEN & KIMBERLY     BOS LISA

 23-07-04-205-008            7357 SUMAC CT           50-07-477-073-00         04/28/2006    617,300   COLNL/SPLT-LEV 3,126          2000      YES       679               $197.47
                             TO/FR FINANCIAL INST    MACOMB COUNTY SHERIFF           DEUTSCHE BANK NATIONAL TRUST CO

 23-07-04-206-042            56418 SUMMIT            50-07-477-143-00         05/19/2006    465,000        COLNL/SPLT-LEV   3,001   2000      YES       689               $154.95
                             TO/FR FINANCIAL INST    DELIA JOSEPH & AUDREY           MALCOLM KEVIN C                        PTA WEICHERT RELOCATION

 23-07-04-206-001            7156 VISTA              50-07-477-102-00         06/08/2006    461,000        COLNL/SPLT-LEV   3,648   2004      YES       717               $126.37
                             TO/FR FINANCIAL INST    U.S. BANK NATIONAL ASSOCIATIO   GOJCEVIC MRIJA                         COVENANT DEED

 23-07-04-204-009            56623 EDGEWOOD          50-07-477-089-00         07/13/2006    710,000        COLNL/SPLT-LEV   3,647   2003      YES       738               $194.68
                             NOT TYPICAL             NAHAS ANNA B & SHAWN A          GREEN LATISA

 23-07-04-206-039            56312 SUMMIT            50-07-477-140-00         07/20/2006    537,617  COLNL/SPLT-LEV         3,687   2001      YES       762               $145.81
                             TO/FR FINANCIAL INST    MACOMB COUNTY SHERIFF           WASHINGTON MUTUAL BANK

 23-07-04-206-025            56205 EDGEWOOD          50-07-477-126-00         08/11/2006     522,319   COLNL/SPLT-LEV       3,675   2004      YES       738               $142.13
                             TO/FR FINANCIAL INST    MACOMB COUNTY SHERIFF           US BANK NATIONAL ASSOC

 23-07-04-206-025            56205 EDGEWOOD          50-07-477-126-00         08/12/2006    522,319        COLNL/SPLT-LEV   3,675   2004      YES       738               $142.13
                             TO/FR FINANCIAL INST    US BANK NATIONAL ASSOCIATION    HOMESALES INC

 23-07-04-206-009            7386 VISTA              50-07-477-110-00         08/25/2006   585,511   COLNL/SPLT-LEV  3,672          2005      YES       717               $159.45
                             TO/FR FINANCIAL INST    MACOMB COUNTY SHERIFF           MORTGAGE ELECTRONIC REGISTRATIO

 23-07-04-205-021            56400 EDGEWOOD          50-07-477-060-00         11/03/2006     571,779   COLNL/SPLT-LEV       3,847   2004      YES       738               $148.63
                             TO/FR FINANCIAL INST    MACOMB COUNTY SHERIFF           US BANK NATIONAL ASSOC

 23-07-04-206-009            7386 VISTA              50-07-477-110-00         12/22/2006    585,511    COLNL/SPLT-LEV       3,672   2005      YES       717               $159.45
                             TO/FR FINANCIAL INST    MACOMB COUNTY SHERIFF           UBS REAL ESTATE SECURITIES INC         UNCAP 08 IF NO SALE

 23-07-04-205-021            56400 EDGEWOOD          50-07-477-060-00         05/03/2007      571,779    COLNL/SPLT-LEV     3,847   2004      YES       738               $148.63
                             TO/FR FINANCIAL INST    MACOMB COUNTY SHERIFF           U. S. BANK NATIONAL ASSOC              UNCAP 09 IF NO SALE


Print Date:02/26/09   Print Time: 16:52:20       SHELBY TOWNSHIP ASSESSOR'S SALE LIST RESIDENTIAL IMPROVED OVER: $450,000                                             Pa g e : 12
                                                Sales from: 01/01/2006 TO: 12/31/2008                      Sales Over: $450,000
                                                                     This List is indexed by Neighborhood / Area Name
  Neighborhood / Area Name
                                                                                                   Sale                                                                    Sale $ /
  Parcel Number              Property Address         Manatron Number            Date of Sale      Price       Struc Type       Sq Ft   Yr Blt   Bsmt   Gar Area         Bldg. sq. ft.
                             Terms of Sale            Grantor                            Grantee                               Sale Short Comments                 Other Parcel in sale #1

 23-07-04-205-028            56160 EDGEWOOD           50-07-477-053-00            07/03/2007    595,000       COLNL/SPLT-LEV   3,857    2005      YES       738               $154.26
                             CONVENTIONAL SALE        MARK CHRISTIAN HOMES               PUSTELAK JUDITH

 23-07-04-206-043            56450 SUMMIT             50-07-477-144-00            01/28/2008     459,000      COLNL/SPLT-LEV   4,501    2002      YES       787               $101.98
                             CONVENTIONAL SALE        CARADONNA JOSEPH L                 RUFFINO ANTON
                                                    Neighborhood / Area Name
                                                                                      Totals    10,043,253                     66,707                     13,075            $2723.19
                                                    PINEWOOD ESTATES                               557,958                      3,705   2002                 726             $151.29
                                                                                   Averages
 PRESCOT WOODS SITE CONDOS
 23-07-05-479-015            5673 FRANCESCA LN        50-07-484-015-00            07/20/2007     460,000    COLNL/SPLT-LEV     3,245    2007      YES       731               $141.76
                             CONVENTIONAL SALE        J.B. HOMES INC                     VICTORIA BAYANI R & JOSEFINA I
                                                    Neighborhood / Area Name
                                                                                      Totals       460,000                      3,245                       731               $141.76
                                                PRESCOT WOODS SITE CONDOS                          460,000                      3,245   2007                731               $141.76
                                                                                   Averages
 ROYAL FOREST SUBS
 23-07-13-176-013            14149 PROVIM FOREST C50-07-508-288-00                01/20/2006    493,401  COLNL/SPLT-LEV        3,786    1998      YES       774               $130.32
                             TO/FR FINANCIAL INST     MACOMB COUNTY SHERIFF              WASHINGTON MUTUAL BANK                UNCAP 08 IF NO SALE

 23-07-13-205-011            14505 BOURNEMUTH         50-07-508-117-00            01/26/2006   495,000    COLNL/SPLT-LEV       3,624    1993      YES       759               $136.59
                             CONVENTIONAL SALE        DAVIDSON THOMAS E & MARTHA         MANQUEN MARK A & DIANE L

 23-07-13-151-011            52203 HIGHBURY CT        50-07-508-310-00            04/20/2006    462,500       COLNL/SPLT-LEV   2,925    1998      YES       708               $158.12
                             CONVENTIONAL SALE        STABLEY GERALD F                   ORAHA ATHINA                          PTA 04/17/06 $468000

 23-07-13-202-001            52942 ROYAL FOREST       50-07-508-077-00            09/25/2006    630,000       COLNL/SPLT-LEV   3,749    1989      YES       736               $168.04
                             CONVENTIONAL SALE        SHKRELJA PASKO & SHARON            PINO MAMICA                           NO PRE W PTA

 23-07-13-103-015            52388 WOODSIDE CT        50-07-508-246-00            12/15/2006    488,220    COLNL/SPLT-LEV      3,435    1995      YES       814               $142.13
                             TO/FR FINANCIAL INST     MACOMB COUNTY SHERIFF              USBANK NATIONAL ASSOC

 23-07-13-102-001            13632 TIMBERWYCK         50-07-508-209-00            05/22/2007     462,500      COLNL/SPLT-LEV   3,637    1997      YES       716               $127.17
                             CONVENTIONAL SALE        REGGIO THOMAS & LAWRENCE A         PIFKO STEVEN S

 23-07-13-152-016            52185 HIGHBURY CT        50-07-508-305-00            10/03/2007    580,000    COLNL/SPLT-LEV      4,713    2000      YES       797               $123.06
                             CONVENTIONAL SALE        VIVIANO PAUL                       HENK GREGORY J & CHRISTINE J

 23-07-13-152-016            52185 HIGHBURY CT        50-07-508-305-00            10/03/2007    580,000    COLNL/SPLT-LEV      4,713    2000      YES       797               $123.06
                             CONVENTIONAL SALE        VIVIANO PAUL                       HENK GREGORY J & CHRISTINE J

 23-07-13-201-006            52525 ROYAL FOREST       50-07-508-018-00            01/09/2007    450,000       RANCH            3,435    1992      YES       698               $131.00
                             TO/FROM TRUST            HOPMAN VIVIAN TRUST                LODUCA GASPARE JR & MARY

Print Date:02/26/09   Print Time: 16:52:20       SHELBY TOWNSHIP ASSESSOR'S SALE LIST RESIDENTIAL IMPROVED OVER: $450,000                                                 Pa g e : 13
                                                Sales from: 01/01/2006 TO: 12/31/2008                     Sales Over: $450,000
                                                                    This List is indexed by Neighborhood / Area Name
  Neighborhood / Area Name
                                                                                                  Sale                                                                    Sale $ /
  Parcel Number              Property Address         Manatron Number            Date of Sale     Price       Struc Type       Sq Ft   Yr Blt   Bsmt   Gar Area         Bldg. sq. ft.
                             Terms of Sale            Grantor                           Grantee                               Sale Short Comments                 Other Parcel in sale #1
                                                     Neighborhood / Area Name
                                                                                     Totals     4,641,621                     34,017                      6,799            $1239.50
                                                    ROYAL FOREST SUBS                             515,735                      3,779   1995                 755             $137.72
                                                                                  Averages
 ROYAL FOREST-LAKE
 23-07-13-251-023            14377 KNIGHTSBRIDGE      50-07-508-184-00           12/07/2007    525,000     COLNL/SPLT-LEV     3,094    1995      YES       726               $169.68
                             CONVENTIONAL SALE        MANUEL MARK & CHARLOTTE           KOEHN WILLIAM F & CAROLYN A
                                                     Neighborhood / Area Name
                                                                                     Totals       525,000                      3,094                       726               $169.68
                                                    ROYAL FOREST-LAKE                             525,000                      3,094   1995                726               $169.68
                                                                                  Averages
 SEC 11 NEWER EXC LAKEPOINTE WOODS
 23-07-11-226-019            54473 FLAMINGO           50-07-203-032-00           06/26/2006    489,900       COLNL/SPLT-LEV   3,193    1996      YES       699               $153.43
                             CONVENTIONAL SALE        KNOX DONALD & PAULINE             MARTINEZ JOSE                         NO PRE W PTA

 23-07-11-276-021            54414 PELICAN LN         50-07-203-066-00           08/18/2006   499,000        COLNL/SPLT-LEV   3,511    2004      YES       652               $142.12
                             CONVENTIONAL SALE        LOCHIRCO DEVELOPMENT CO           ROMBERGER RON                         NO PRE W PTA

 23-07-11-277-001            13226 DIEGEL             50-07-203-010-00           10/02/2006     500,000      COLNL/SPLT-LEV   3,123    1993      YES       682               $160.10
                             SELLER FINANCED          RUFUS MARY JO                     BUTLER GREGORY

 23-07-11-276-021            54414 PELICAN LN         50-07-203-066-00           02/02/2007     500,544  COLNL/SPLT-LEV       3,511    2004      YES       652               $142.56
                             TO/FR FINANCIAL INST     MACOMB COUNTY SHERIFF             WELLS FARGO BANK

 23-07-11-276-026            13462 OWL CT             50-07-203-071-00           03/16/2007     597,812   COLNL/SPLT-LEV      3,398    2004      YES       745               $175.93
                             TO/FR FINANCIAL INST     MACOMB COUNTY SHERIFF             US BANK NATIONAL ASSOC

 23-07-11-276-021            54414 PELICAN LN         50-07-203-066-00           08/02/2007     500,545   COLNL/SPLT-LEV      3,511    2004      YES       652               $142.56
                             TO/FR FINANCIAL INST     MACOMB COUNTY SHERIFF             WELLS FARGO BANK, NA                  UNCAP 09 IF NO SALE

 23-07-11-254-004            54546 WHITE PINE LN      50-07-279-056-00           09/20/2007    557,300   COLNL/SPLT-LEV       4,073    2004      YES       761               $136.83
                             CONVENTIONAL SALE        INFINITY BUILDING CORPORATIO      BURBARY KENNETH & KATHLEEN

 23-07-11-227-010            54886 PELICAN LN         50-07-203-086-00           12/31/2007     490,000      COLNL/SPLT-LEV   4,050    2006      YES       837               $120.99
                             CONVENTIONAL SALE        LOCHIRCO DEVELOPMENT CO           MEIER ERIC S

 23-07-11-201-003            54893 GLEN OAKS          50-07-279-003-00           01/31/2008    579,900       COLNL/SPLT-LEV   3,647    2005      YES       697               $159.01
                             CONVENTIONAL SALE        ALEXANDER HOMES INC               CAVATAIO PIETRO

 23-07-11-202-002            12840 RED PINE LN        50-07-279-067-00           10/06/2008     453,500    COLNL/SPLT-LEV     3,541    2007      YES       677               $128.07
                             CONVENTIONAL SALE        INFINITY BUILDING CO INC          HILLIARD ROBERT & TAMMY MARIE
                                                      Neighborhood / Area Name
                                                                                     Totals     5,168,501                     35,558                      7,054            $1461.61
                                             SEC 11 NEWER EXC LAKEPOINTE WOODS                    516,850                      3,555   2002                 705             $146.16
                                                                                  Averages

Print Date:02/26/09   Print Time: 16:52:20        SHELBY TOWNSHIP ASSESSOR'S SALE LIST RESIDENTIAL IMPROVED OVER: $450,000                                               Pa g e : 14
                                                Sales from: 01/01/2006 TO: 12/31/2008                     Sales Over: $450,000
                                                                    This List is indexed by Neighborhood / Area Name
  Neighborhood / Area Name
                                                                                                  Sale                                                                    Sale $ /
  Parcel Number              Property Address         Manatron Number            Date of Sale     Price       Struc Type       Sq Ft   Yr Blt   Bsmt   Gar Area         Bldg. sq. ft.
                             Terms of Sale            Grantor                           Grantee                               Sale Short Comments                 Other Parcel in sale #1

 SEC 11-NEWER-LAKE
 23-07-11-229-005            54496 FLAMINGO           50-07-203-113-00           04/20/2007    585,000    COLNL/SPLT-LEV      4,135    2000      YES       651               $141.48
                             SELLER FINANCED          SOURVELIS IRENE                   BELLANCA JOSEPH & ROSE B

 23-07-11-229-005            54496 FLAMINGO           50-07-203-113-00           04/20/2007    585,000   COLNL/SPLT-LEV       4,135    2000      YES       651               $141.48
                             FULFILLMENT OF LC        SOURVELIS IRENE                   BELLANCA JOSEPH & ROSE                LC 04/20/07

 23-07-11-229-006            54468 FLAMINGO           50-07-203-114-00           07/13/2007    555,000    COLNL/SPLT-LEV      3,606    2005      YES       757               $153.91
                             CONVENTIONAL SALE        LOCHIRCO DEVELOPMETN COMP         MILEWSKI JEFFREY S & KRISTEN C

 23-07-11-229-017            13452 HAWK               50-07-203-132-00           04/25/2008    599,000     COLNL/SPLT-LEV     3,870    2006      YES       642               $154.78
                             CONVENTIONAL SALE        LOCHIRCO DEVELOPMENT COMP         PUGH ALLEN T & LAVERNE C
                                                     Neighborhood / Area Name
                                                                                     Totals     2,324,000                     15,746                      2,701              $591.64
                                                    SEC 11-NEWER-LAKE                             581,000                      3,936   2002                 675              $147.91
                                                                                  Averages
 SEC 12 SUBS
 23-07-12-425-001            14812 TOWERING OAKS 50-07-727-013-00                03/03/2006     500,000      COLNL/SPLT-LEV   3,491    1993      YES       709               $143.23
                             CONVENTIONAL SALE        NOWICKI ROBERT W & CARMEN         GOJCAJ KOLE

 23-07-12-424-009            15133 TOWERING OAKS 50-07-727-004-00                08/23/2006     479,000  COLNL/SPLT-LEV       3,363    1994      YES       682               $142.43
                             CONVENTIONAL SALE        RIBITCH FRANK J & JUDITH          WIGGINS RAYMOND JR                    NO PRE W PTA
                                                    Neighborhood / Area Name
                                                                                     Totals       979,000                      6,854                      1,391              $285.66
                                                       SEC 12 SUBS                                489,500                      3,427   1993                 695              $142.83
                                                                                  Averages
 SEC 22 AVERAGE
 23-07-22-352-022            8151 22 MILE             50-07-415-012-00           06/25/2008   1,200,000   MULTI/MIXED         1,407    1950      YES       440               $852.88
                             MULTIPLE PARCEL SALE     JOVANOVSKI DJOCE & KATA           LEONARDO MOUND LLC                                                        23-07-22-352-004

                                                    Neighborhood / Area Name
                                                                                     Totals     1,200,000                      1,407                       440               $852.88
                                                     SEC 22 AVERAGE                             1,200,000                      1,407   1950                440               $852.88
                                                                                  Averages
 SEC 22 NEWER-LAKE
 23-07-22-453-004            49133 WHITE MILL         50-07-263-066-00           02/03/2006   468,672   COLNL/SPLT-LEV  4,027          1990      YES       662               $116.38
                             TO/FR FINANCIAL INST     MACOMB COUNTY SHERIFF             MORTGAGE ELECTRONIC REGISTRATIO
                                                    Neighborhood / Area Name
                                                                                     Totals       468,672                      4,027                       662               $116.38
                                                    SEC 22 NEWER-LAKE                             468,672                      4,027   1990                662               $116.38
                                                                                  Averages
 SEC 25 WESTERN SUBS EXC PHSNT RUN

Print Date:02/26/09   Print Time: 16:52:20       SHELBY TOWNSHIP ASSESSOR'S SALE LIST RESIDENTIAL IMPROVED OVER: $450,000                                                Pa g e : 15
                                                Sales from: 01/01/2006 TO: 12/31/2008                     Sales Over: $450,000
                                                                    This List is indexed by Neighborhood / Area Name
  Neighborhood / Area Name
                                                                                                  Sale                                                                 Sale $ /
  Parcel Number              Property Address          Manatron Number           Date of Sale     Price       Struc Type    Sq Ft   Yr Blt   Bsmt   Gar Area         Bldg. sq. ft.
                             Terms of Sale             Grantor                          Grantee                            Sale Short Comments                 Other Parcel in sale #1

 23-07-25-332-072            47780 ADDARIO             50-07-497-072-00          09/08/2006    499,495   COLNL/SPLT-LEV    3,428    2002      YES       677               $145.71
                             TO/FR FINANCIAL INST      MACOMB COUNTY SHERIFF            DEUTSCHE BANK TRUST CO

 23-07-25-332-014            13800 BERRYKNOLL          50-07-497-014-00          08/21/2008    520,100    COLNL/SPLT-LEV   3,910    2003      YES       999               $133.02
                             CONVENTIONAL SALE         PIZZO JOSEPH & ROSA              WEINGARTZ DANIEL & KRISTINE
                                                     Neighborhood / Area Name
                                                                                     Totals     1,019,595                   7,338                      1,676              $278.73
                                             SEC 25 WESTERN SUBS EXC PHSNT RUN                    509,797                   3,669   2002                 838              $139.36
                                                                                  Averages
 SEC 26 NEWER EXC VILLA DI ORO
 23-07-26-101-023            48475 RED OAK             50-07-336-023-00          03/10/2006     464,436   COLNL/SPLT-LEV  3,528     2002      YES       637               $131.64
                             TO/FR FINANCIAL INST      MACOMB COUTNY SHERIFF            CHIEF PONTIAC FEDERAL CREDIT UNION

 23-07-26-128-004            12185 ANTHONY             50-07-591-039-00          10/26/2006    452,500  COLNL/SPLT-LEV     3,034    1993      YES       686               $149.14
                             CONVENTIONAL SALE         MARRA TODD & MAUREEN             MCINTOSH GREGORY A                 NO PRE W PTA
                                                      Neighborhood / Area Name
                                                                                     Totals       916,936                   6,562                      1,323              $280.79
                                                SEC 26 NEWER EXC VILLA DI ORO                     458,468                   3,281   1997                 661              $140.39
                                                                                  Averages
 SEC 6 LARGER
 23-07-06-280-006            56149 HEATHROW            50-07-605-123-00          12/27/2006    550,000  COLNL/SPLT-LEV     3,196    1999      YES       749               $172.09
                             CONVENTIONAL SALE         KELLY JOHN & CRYSTAL             ARTYMOVICH ROBERT W & ELAIN B

 23-07-06-282-001            56015 PARKVIEW            50-07-699-019-00          01/18/2008    485,000   COLNL/SPLT-LEV    3,869    2000      YES       920               $125.36
                             CONVENTIONAL SALE         FORNARI GREGORY L AND MICHE      KRAEMER JOHN T AND REGINA A
                                                     Neighborhood / Area Name
                                                                                     Totals     1,035,000                   7,065                      1,669              $297.45
                                                       SEC 6 LARGER                               517,500                   3,532   1999                 834              $148.72
                                                                                  Averages
 SEC 6 LARGER-LAKE
 23-07-06-278-003            56373 NICKELBY SOUTH 50-07-605-092-00               12/01/2006   642,089   COLNL/SPLT-LEV  3,364       1999      YES       738               $190.87
                             TO/FR FINANCIAL INST      MACOMB COUNTY SHERIFF            MORTGAGE ELECTRONIC REGISTRATIO

 23-07-06-278-003            56373 NICKELBY SOUTH 50-07-605-092-00               06/01/2007    642,089  COLNL/SPLT-LEV  3,364  1999      YES            738               $190.87
                             TO/FR FINANCIAL INST      MACOMB COUNTY SHERIFF            COUNTRYWIDE HOME LOANS SERVICIN UNCAP 09 IF NO SALE

 23-07-06-278-003            56373 NICKELBY SOUTH 50-07-605-092-00               12/06/2007    460,000  COLNL/SPLT-LEV     3,364    1999      YES       738               $136.74
                             TO/FR FINANCIAL INST      CITIZENS BANK OF RHODE ISLAN     GENTNER THOMAS M & JUDY L          COVENANT DEED
                                                     Neighborhood / Area Name
                                                                                     Totals     1,744,178                  10,092                      2,214              $518.48
                                                     SEC 6 LARGER-LAKE                            581,392                   3,364   1999                 738              $172.83
                                                                                  Averages


Print Date:02/26/09   Print Time: 16:52:20        SHELBY TOWNSHIP ASSESSOR'S SALE LIST RESIDENTIAL IMPROVED OVER: $450,000                                            Pa g e : 16
                                                Sales from: 01/01/2006 TO: 12/31/2008                     Sales Over: $450,000
                                                                   This List is indexed by Neighborhood / Area Name
  Neighborhood / Area Name
                                                                                                  Sale                                                                    Sale $ /
  Parcel Number              Property Address         Manatron Number            Date of Sale     Price       Struc Type       Sq Ft   Yr Blt   Bsmt   Gar Area         Bldg. sq. ft.
                             Terms of Sale            Grantor                           Grantee                               Sale Short Comments                 Other Parcel in sale #1

 SEC 7 LARGER EXC CARRINGTON MANOR
 23-07-07-152-022            2162 HILLSDALE           50-07-293-002-00           02/03/2006     450,000   COLNL/SPLT-LEV      3,171    2005      YES       769               $141.91
                             PARTIAL ASSMT            J W ADAMS DEV CO INC              BEATTY THOMAS J & JAMIE L             DEED $110,000

 23-07-07-128-006            53992 SUTHERLAND LN 50-07-503-128-00                04/14/2006     456,000   COLNL/SPLT-LEV      3,397    1995      YES       694               $134.24
                             CONVENTIONAL SALE        MARTIN WILLIAM & SHARON           LEE STUART & MICHELLE E

 23-07-07-129-002            53953 SUTHERLAND CT 50-07-503-137-00                04/28/2006     450,000   COLNL/SPLT-LEV      3,281    1991      YES       638               $137.15
                             RELATED PARTY/ NAL       NIKOLLBIBAJ KOLE & TUSHA          NIKOLLBIBAJ ENGJELL & LIZA

 23-07-07-153-021            2357 WESTCOTT CT         50-07-503-296-00           06/28/2006   450,000        COLNL/SPLT-LEV   3,333    1999      YES       717               $135.01
                             TO/FROM TRUST            JACOBS JENNIFER TRUST             AGARWAL KEDAR B

 23-07-07-201-032            3215 GRANDVIEW CT        50-07-298-006-10           06/28/2006    650,000       COLNL/SPLT-LEV   4,729    1993      YES     1,078               $137.45
                             SELLER FINANCED          CHIRCO MICHAEL J & MARIA M        BRAY KATRINA                          L-4054 UNRECORDED LC REC'D

 23-07-07-303-022            2101 HILLSDALE           50-07-293-009-00           08/15/2006    450,000    COLNL/SPLT-LEV  3,550        1999      YES       863               $126.76
                             TO/FR FINANCIAL INST     REDD CYNTHIA S TRUST              NATIONAL RESIDENTIAL NOMINEE SEER

 23-07-07-303-022            2101 HILLSDALE           50-07-293-009-00           08/31/2006     450,000      COLNL/SPLT-LEV   3,550    1999      YES       863               $126.76
                             TO/FR FINANCIAL INST     NATIONAL RESIDENTIAL NOMINEE      ALSOTT GARY N

 23-07-07-202-002            3180 GRANDVIEW CT        50-07-298-015-00           03/30/2007    529,900       COLNL/SPLT-LEV   3,523    1992      YES       682               $150.41
                             CONVENTIONAL SALE        KINAIA NIDHAL & NABIL             YALDO GEORGE

 23-07-07-152-023            2194 HILLSDALE           50-07-293-001-00           08/31/2007     505,000      COLNL/SPLT-LEV   3,470    2005      YES       854               $145.53
                             CONVENTIONAL SALE        J W ADAMS DEV CO INC              LESKIW JEFFREY

 23-07-07-126-009            2641 HARROW WAY          50-07-503-220-00           09/21/2007   511,844   COLNL/SPLT-LEV  2,515          1997      YES       707               $203.52
                             TO/FR FINANCIAL INST     MACOMB COUNTY SHERIFF             MORTGAGE ELECTRONIC REGISTRATIO

 23-07-07-202-001            3100 HARROW WAY          50-07-298-016-00           11/30/2007    674,654  COLNL/SPLT-LEV        4,535    1996      YES       834               $148.77
                             TO/FR FINANCIAL INST     MACOMB COUNTY SHERIFF             SAXON MORTGAGE SERVICES INC

 23-07-07-126-009            2641 HARROW WAY          50-07-503-220-00           03/21/2008   511,844   COLNL/SPLT-LEV  2,515          1997      YES       707               $203.52
                             TO/FR FINANCIAL INST     MACOMB COUNTY SHERIFF             MORTGAGE ELECTRONIC REG SYSTEMS
                                                      Neighborhood / Area Name
                                                                                     Totals     6,089,242                     41,569                      9,406            $1791.03
                                             SEC 7 LARGER EXC CARRINGTON MANOR                    507,436                      3,464   1997                 783             $149.25
                                                                                  Averages
 SEC 9 AVERAGE
 23-07-09-451-010            7265 CONNIES             50-07-009-032-10           09/29/2006    544,786   COLNL/SPLT-LEV       3,208    1979      YES       704               $169.82
                             TO/FR FINANCIAL INST     MACOMB COUNTY SHERIFF             DEUTSCHE BANK NATIONAL TRUST

Print Date:02/26/09   Print Time: 16:52:20        SHELBY TOWNSHIP ASSESSOR'S SALE LIST RESIDENTIAL IMPROVED OVER: $450,000                                               Pa g e : 17
                                                Sales from: 01/01/2006 TO: 12/31/2008                       Sales Over: $450,000
                                                                     This List is indexed by Neighborhood / Area Name
  Neighborhood / Area Name
                                                                                                    Sale                                                                    Sale $ /
  Parcel Number              Property Address          Manatron Number           Date of Sale       Price       Struc Type       Sq Ft   Yr Blt   Bsmt   Gar Area         Bldg. sq. ft.
                             Terms of Sale              Grantor                           Grantee                               Sale Short Comments                 Other Parcel in sale #1
                                                      Neighborhood / Area Name
                                                                                       Totals       544,786                      3,208                       704               $169.82
                                                       SEC 9 AVERAGE                                544,786                      3,208   1979                704               $169.82
                                                                                    Averages
 SEVEN OAKS SUB
 23-07-18-229-002            52890 SEVEN OAKS           50-07-538-002-00           01/12/2006    465,000       COLNL/SPLT-LEV   3,451    1992      YES       709               $134.74
                             OUT OF STATE               FORTUNA FRANCO D                  CUSACK TERRY

 23-07-18-229-006            52850 SEVEN OAKS           50-07-538-006-00           09/01/2006    466,435   COLNL/SPLT-LEV       2,820    1994      YES       709               $165.40
                             TO/FR FINANCIAL INST       MACOMB COUNTY SHERIFF             DLJ MORTGAGE CAPITAL INC
                                                      Neighborhood / Area Name
                                                                                       Totals       931,435                      6,271                      1,418              $300.15
                                                       SEVEN OAKS SUB                               465,717                      3,135   1993                 709              $150.07
                                                                                    Averages
 SHELBY CREEK ESTATES
 23-07-22-405-007            11150 NATURE WAY           50-07-556-007-00           01/26/2006     510,000      COLNL/SPLT-LEV   3,070    2002      YES       974               $166.12
                             CONVENTIONAL SALE          FORTUNA EDWARD                    COLLINS SCOTT

 23-07-22-404-017            49829 DECKER               50-07-556-047-00           08/08/2006    520,000   COLNL/SPLT-LEV       3,622    2004      YES       705               $143.57
                             TO/FR FINANCIAL INST       DEMBECK GREGORY T & KONSTA        AMERICAN ESCROW & CLOSING CORP

 23-07-22-405-007            11150 NATURE WAY           50-07-556-007-00           12/01/2006    487,261   COLNL/SPLT-LEV       3,070    2002      YES       974               $158.72
                             TO/FR FINANCIAL INST       MACOMB COUNTY SHERIFF             DEUTSCHE BANK NATIONAL TRUST

 23-07-22-405-008            49582 DECKER               50-07-556-008-00           03/03/2007    477,500       RANCH            3,418    2004      YES       842               $139.70
                             TO/FR FINANCIAL INST       DARLING DAVID W & DIANNA          CARTUS FINANCIAL CORP
                                                      Neighborhood / Area Name
                                                                                       Totals   1,994,761                       13,180                      3,495              $608.11
                                                    SHELBY CREEK ESTATES                          498,690                        3,295   2003                 873              $152.03
                                                                                    Averages
 SHELBY HILLS
 23-07-08-103-007            4000 WOODBINE CT           50-07-566-095-00           11/09/2007   472,290   COLNL/SPLT-LEV  4,097          1996      YES       623               $115.28
                             TO/FR FINANCIAL INST       MACOMB COUNTY SHERIFF             MORTGAGE ELECTRONIC REGISTRATIO

 23-07-07-280-010            54228 BIRCHFIELD           50-07-566-112-00           06/14/2008    450,000  COLNL/SPLT-LEV        4,165    1997      YES       639               $108.04
                             TO/FR FINANCIAL INST       MACOMB COUNTY SHERIFF             WASHINGTON MUTUAL BANK

 23-07-08-103-005            4048 WOODBINE CT           50-07-566-093-00           04/11/2006     477,500       RANCH           2,677    1994      YES       700               $178.37
                             CONVENTIONAL SALE          SCHULZ THOMAS & DIANNA            SELF JERRY B & CALUDIA A HILLER
                                                      Neighborhood / Area Name
                                                                                       Totals   1,399,790                       10,939                      1,962              $401.69
                                                        SHELBY HILLS                              466,596                        3,646   1995                 654              $133.90
                                                                                    Averages


Print Date:02/26/09   Print Time: 16:52:20       SHELBY TOWNSHIP ASSESSOR'S SALE LIST RESIDENTIAL IMPROVED OVER: $450,000                                                  Pa g e : 18
                                                Sales from: 01/01/2006 TO: 12/31/2008                      Sales Over: $450,000
                                                                     This List is indexed by Neighborhood / Area Name
  Neighborhood / Area Name
                                                                                                   Sale                                                                    Sale $ /
  Parcel Number              Property Address          Manatron Number            Date of Sale     Price       Struc Type       Sq Ft   Yr Blt   Bsmt   Gar Area         Bldg. sq. ft.
                             Terms of Sale              Grantor                          Grantee                               Sale Short Comments                 Other Parcel in sale #1

 SHELBY ORCHARDS
 23-07-04-453-014            55081 APPLE LN             50-07-568-082-00          01/25/2006    649,000       COLNL/SPLT-LEV   3,438     2000     YES       715               $188.77
                             INVESTOR SALE              CALIFORNIA MANAGMENT INC         KELLOW VINSON                         $ PER PTA, ZYAD DADOUSH

 23-07-04-453-012            7396 SPARLING              50-07-568-080-00          09/21/2006    450,000    COLNL/SPLT-LEV      3,656     2000     YES       722               $123.09
                             CONVENTIONAL SALE          JONES KIMBERLY & LELAND T/C      BROOKS JR JOE W & DARA                DIVORCE

 23-07-04-403-025            55766 APPLE LN             50-07-568-017-00          11/28/2006    875,000       COLNL/SPLT-LEV   3,541     1999     YES       839               $247.11
                             NOT TYPICAL                HAHAIM DELCIE                    FOSTER MICHAEL
                                                      Neighborhood / Area Name
                                                                                      Totals     1,974,000                     10,635                      2,276              $558.96
                                                      SHELBY ORCHARDS                              658,000                      3,545    1999                758              $186.32
                                                                                   Averages
 SHERWOOD FOREST SUB
 23-07-12-278-016            14960 SHERWOOD PARK 50-07-587-247-00                 07/07/2006    528,497   COLNL/SPLT-LEV       3,667     1993     YES       840               $144.12
                             TO/FR FINANCIAL INST       MACOMB COUNTY SHERIFF            DEUTSCHE BANK NATIONAL TRUST

 23-07-12-278-014            14880 SHERWOOD PARK 50-07-587-245-00                 02/12/2007     850,000      COLNL/SPLT-LEV   4,447     1996     YES       760               $191.14
                             CONVENTIONAL SALE          TIBERIO CHRISTINA & ANTHONY      TINDALL DANIEL                        NOT FILING PRE PER TAXPAYER

 23-07-12-278-014            14880 SHERWOOD PARK 50-07-587-245-00                 01/11/2008    711,738   COLNL/SPLT-LEV       4,447     1996     YES       760               $160.05
                             TO/FR FINANCIAL INST       MACOMB COUNTY SHERIFF            GREEN POINT MORTGAGE FUNDING

 23-07-12-278-014            14880 SHERWOOD PARK 50-07-587-245-00                 07/11/2008    711,738  COLNL/SPLT-LEV  4,447           1996     YES       760               $160.05
                             TO/FR FINANCIAL INST       MACOMB COUNTY SHERIFF            GREENPOINT MORTGAGE FUNDING INC
                                                      Neighborhood / Area Name
                                                                                      Totals     2,801,973                     17,008                      3,120              $655.36
                                                    SHERWOOD FOREST SUB                            700,493                      4,252    1995                780              $163.84
                                                                                   Averages
 SHWARK
 23-07-01-476-018            15075 25 MILE              50-07-535-001-10          12/10/2007   1,915,000                           0     0                    0         $1915000.00
                             MULTIPLE PARCEL SALE       SHELBY 25 INVESTORS LLC          OZZAD PROPERTY MANAGEMENT LLC                                             23-07-01-476-001

                                                      Neighborhood / Area Name
                                                                                      Totals     1,915,000                          0                         0         $1915000.00
                                                           SHWARK                                1,915,000                          0    0                    0         $1915000.00
                                                                                   Averages
 SILVER BIRCH VILLAGE CONDOS
 23-07-24-354-024            49329 SILVER BIRCH CIR 50-07-597-024-00              09/17/2008    880,594      STYLE "C"         1,520     2004               444               $579.34
                             TO/FR FINANCIAL INST       MACOMB COUNTY SHERIFF            JANKOWSKI THOMAS & CAROLE




Print Date:02/26/09   Print Time: 16:52:20       SHELBY TOWNSHIP ASSESSOR'S SALE LIST RESIDENTIAL IMPROVED OVER: $450,000                                                 Pa g e : 19
                                                Sales from: 01/01/2006 TO: 12/31/2008                     Sales Over: $450,000
                                                                    This List is indexed by Neighborhood / Area Name
  Neighborhood / Area Name
                                                                                                  Sale                                                                  Sale $ /
  Parcel Number              Property Address         Manatron Number           Date of Sale      Price       Struc Type     Sq Ft   Yr Blt   Bsmt   Gar Area         Bldg. sq. ft.
                             Terms of Sale            Grantor                           Grantee                              Sale Short Comments                Other Parcel in sale #1
                                                     Neighborhood / Area Name
                                                                                     Totals       880,594                    1,520                       444               $579.34
                                                SILVER BIRCH VILLAGE CONDOS                       880,594                    1,520   2004                444               $579.34
                                                                                  Averages
 SPRING ARBOR SITE CONDOS ( 596 )
 23-07-25-404-023            47877 MILONAS            50-07-596-023-00           01/12/2006    457,500   COLNL/SPLT-LEV      3,331   2005      YES       713               $137.35
                             PARTIAL ASSMT            WOODMOOR HOMES LLC                NGUYEN EDWARD & TRACY
                                                    Neighborhood / Area Name
                                                                                     Totals       457,500                    3,331                       713               $137.35
                                             SPRING ARBOR SITE CONDOS ( 596 )                     457,500                    3,331   2005                713               $137.35
                                                                                  Averages
 SPRING LAKE SUBS
 23-07-17-305-021            51376 MERRY LN           50-07-593-178-00           04/25/2006     492,000   COLNL/SPLT-LEV     3,467   2005      YES       696               $141.91
                             PARTIAL ASSMT            CANYON CONSTRUCTION INC           JIMMY VU & NGOC MA                   GRANTEES PER DEED
                                                     Neighborhood / Area Name
                                                                                     Totals       492,000                    3,467                       696               $141.91
                                                     SPRING LAKE SUBS                             492,000                    3,467   2005                696               $141.91
                                                                                  Averages
 TIMBERS EDGE
 23-07-04-454-018            55423 TIMBERS EDGE       50-07-656-005-00           07/13/2006    500,000    COLNL/SPLT-LEV     3,973   2005      YES       832               $125.85
                             PARTIAL ASSMT            ALLANTE BUILDING CO               TROTTIER MARK & CHARISSE

 23-07-04-454-015            55537 TIMBERS EDGE       50-07-656-002-00           07/31/2006     475,000     COLNL/SPLT-LEV   3,575   2005      YES       811               $132.87
                             PARTIAL ASSMT            ALLANTE BUILDING CO               PATEL DILIPBHAIV & KALAVATI
                                                     Neighborhood / Area Name
                                                                                     Totals       975,000                    7,548                      1,643              $258.72
                                                       TIMBERS EDGE                               487,500                    3,774   2005                 821              $129.36
                                                                                  Averages
 TUSCANY SITE CONDO
 23-07-14-204-014            52680 TUSCANY GROVE 50-07-668-014-00                01/20/2006    580,000   COLNL/SPLT-LEV      3,619   2002      YES       736               $160.27
                             CONVENTIONAL SALE        ROBERTS JEFFREY & DIANE           VANTUYLE JEFFREY

 23-07-14-204-004            52870 TUSCANY GROVE 50-07-668-004-00                10/20/2006    650,000   COLNL/SPLT-LEV      4,228   2001      YES       886               $153.74
                             CONVENTIONAL SALE        PALADINO HOMES INC                COUTURE A GORDON                     NO PRE W PTA

 23-07-14-204-039            52847 TUSCANY GROVE 50-07-668-039-00                08/08/2008   480,000    COLNL/SPLT-LEV      4,134   2004      YES       944               $116.11
                             CONVENTIONAL SALE        DISTINGUISHED HOMES INC           MACDONALD DAVID S & RENEE N

 23-07-14-204-028            52775 FLORENCE           50-07-668-028-00           03/09/2006    482,400       RANCH           2,853   2002      YES       710               $169.09
                             CONVENTIONAL SALE        DISTINGUISHED HOMES INC           NELSON ROBERT H & JUDITH




Print Date:02/26/09   Print Time: 16:52:20        SHELBY TOWNSHIP ASSESSOR'S SALE LIST RESIDENTIAL IMPROVED OVER: $450,000                                             Pa g e : 20
                                                Sales from: 01/01/2006 TO: 12/31/2008                     Sales Over: $450,000
                                                                    This List is indexed by Neighborhood / Area Name
  Neighborhood / Area Name
                                                                                                  Sale                                                                    Sale $ /
  Parcel Number              Property Address         Manatron Number           Date of Sale      Price       Struc Type       Sq Ft   Yr Blt   Bsmt   Gar Area         Bldg. sq. ft.
                             Terms of Sale             Grantor                          Grantee                               Sale Short Comments                 Other Parcel in sale #1
                                                     Neighborhood / Area Name
                                                                                     Totals    2,192,400                      14,834                      3,276              $599.20
                                                    TUSCANY SITE CONDO                           548,100                       3,708   2002                 819              $149.80
                                                                                  Averages
 VILLA DI ORO-LAKE
 23-07-26-227-015            13097 FLORENTINE          50-07-703-059-00          07/07/2006    545,809   COLNL/SPLT-LEV       3,338    1994      YES       720               $163.51
                             TO/FR FINANCIAL INST      MACOMB COUNTY SHERIFF            DEUTSCHE BANK NATIONAL TRUST

 23-07-26-227-015            13097 FLORENTINE          50-07-703-059-00          01/07/2007    545,809   COLNL/SPLT-LEV       3,338    1994      YES       720               $163.51
                             TO/FR FINANCIAL INST      MACOMB COUNTY SHERIFF            DEUTSCHE BANK NATIONAL TRUST
                                                     Neighborhood / Area Name
                                                                                     Totals    1,091,618                       6,676                      1,440              $327.03
                                                     VILLA DI ORO-LAKE                           545,809                       3,338   1994                 720              $163.51
                                                                                  Averages
 WESTMINSTER ESTS
 23-07-10-429-006            53892 VIAR                50-07-739-006-00          07/21/2006   585,349   COLNL/SPLT-LEV  3,769          2004      YES       738               $155.31
                             TO/FR FINANCIAL INST      MACOMB COUNTY SHERIFF            MORTGAGE ELECTRONIC REGISTRATIO

 23-07-10-429-006            53892 VIAR                50-07-739-006-00          08/24/2006   585,349   COLNL/SPLT-LEV  3,769          2004      YES       738               $155.31
                             TO/FR FINANCIAL INST      MACOMB COUNTY SHERIFF            MORTGAGE ELECTRONIC REGISTRATIO

 23-07-10-428-002            53847 VIAR                50-07-739-008-00          09/18/2006    510,000    COLNL/SPLT-LEV      3,859    2005      YES       738               $132.16
                             CONVENTIONAL SALE         MARK CHRISTIAN INC               DURAKU BAJAZIT & HATIDZE              H&W

 23-07-10-427-013            53529 DESANO              50-07-739-032-00          11/17/2006   472,920   COLNL/SPLT-LEV  3,568          2004      YES       650               $132.54
                             TO/FR FINANCIAL INST      MACOMB COUNTY SHERIFF            MORTGAGE ELECTRONIC REGISTRATIO

 23-07-10-429-006            53892 VIAR                50-07-739-006-00          11/30/2006    481,000       COLNL/SPLT-LEV   3,769    2004      YES       738               $127.62
                             TO/FR FINANCIAL INST      TERWIN ADVISORS LLC              SACO JAMIL & YAZI                     PTA 12/13/06

 23-07-10-429-002            11513 EDINBURGH           50-07-739-002-00          01/12/2007   613,758   COLNL/SPLT-LEV  3,784          2001      YES       744               $162.20
                             TO/FR FINANCIAL INST      MACOMB COUNTY SHERIFF            MORTGAGE ELECTRONIC REGISTRATIO

 23-07-10-427-020            53590 DESANO              50-07-739-039-00          05/01/2008      495,000     COLNL/SPLT-LEV   3,635    2003      YES       721               $136.18
                             CONVENTIONAL SALE         SHEHU ISMAIL & ENIDA             SINA FIDAI
                                                     Neighborhood / Area Name
                                                                                     Totals    3,743,378                      26,153                      5,067            $1001.31
                                                     WESTMINSTER ESTS                            534,768                       3,736   2003                 723             $143.04
                                                                                  Averages
 WHISPERING HILLS & #2
 23-07-04-376-007            55091 WHISPERING HILL 50-07-744-018-00              09/25/2006    534,000   COLNL/SPLT-LEV       3,481    0         YES       645               $153.40
                             PARTIAL ASSMT             LACASA LLC                       MYHALCHUK VIKTOR



Print Date:02/26/09   Print Time: 16:52:20       SHELBY TOWNSHIP ASSESSOR'S SALE LIST RESIDENTIAL IMPROVED OVER: $450,000                                                Pa g e : 21
                                                Sales from: 01/01/2006 TO: 12/31/2008                      Sales Over: $450,000
                                                                    This List is indexed by Neighborhood / Area Name
  Neighborhood / Area Name
                                                                                                   Sale                                                                    Sale $ /
  Parcel Number              Property Address          Manatron Number          Date of Sale       Price       Struc Type      Sq Ft   Yr Blt   Bsmt   Gar Area          Bldg. sq. ft.
                             Terms of Sale             Grantor                           Grantee                               Sale Short Comments                 Other Parcel in sale #1
                                                     Neighborhood / Area Name
                                                                                      Totals       534,000                     3,481                         645              $153.40
                                                    WHISPERING HILLS & #2                          534,000                     3,481   0                     645              $153.40
                                                                                   Averages
 WHITNEY ESTATES SUB
 23-07-03-402-010            55760 ST REGIS            50-07-747-122-00          04/28/2006      515,000   COLNL/SPLT-LEV      3,458    2000     YES        670               $148.93
                             TO/FR FINANCIAL INST      ALAMPI JOSEPH & MARIA             SIRVA RELOCATION LLC

 23-07-03-402-010            55760 ST REGIS            50-07-747-122-00          07/21/2006     515,000       COLNL/SPLT-LEV   3,458    2000     YES        670               $148.93
                             TO/FR FINANCIAL INST      SIRVA RELOCATION LLC              FLAGG ORVILLE                         PTA 07/28/06

 23-07-03-404-009            55510 CAESARS             50-07-747-088-00          11/29/2006     565,000       COLNL/SPLT-LEV   3,295    2005     YES        670               $171.47
                             PARTIAL ASSMT             JCM DISTINCTIVE HOMES INC         WILMORE LISA

 23-07-03-477-006            55265 WHITNEY             50-07-747-042-00          03/09/2007     546,176   COLNL/SPLT-LEV       4,182    2004     YES       1,054              $130.60
                             TO/FR FINANCIAL INST      MACOMB COUNTY SHERIFF             SACCO DOMENICO & FILLIPPA

 23-07-03-427-009            55725 WHITNEY CT          50-07-747-140-00          03/16/2007     860,000   COLNL/SPLT-LEV       4,018    2003     YES        910               $214.04
                             RATIO<20% >75%            BASILISCO VITTORIO & DOMENIC      ELKHOURY JACQUELINE

 23-07-03-477-006            55265 WHITNEY             50-07-747-042-00          09/09/2007      546,226  COLNL/SPLT-LEV       4,182    2004     YES       1,054              $130.61
                             TO/FR FINANCIAL INST      MACOMB COUNTY SHERIFF             BANK OF NEW YORK                      UNCAP 09 IF NO SALE IN 08

 23-07-03-427-009            55725 WHITNEY CT          50-07-747-140-00          10/19/2007    715,523   COLNL/SPLT-LEV  4,018          2003     YES        910               $178.08
                             TO/FR FINANCIAL INST      MACOMB COUNTY SHERIFF             MORTGAGE ELECTRONIC REGISTRATIO

 23-07-03-404-007            55582 CAESARS             50-07-747-086-00          12/28/2007    450,000    COLNL/SPLT-LEV       3,606    2004     YES        734               $124.79
                             CONVENTIONAL SALE         PONE MARK & KAREN                 TOWNSEND BRAD & KARRA

 23-07-03-404-007            55582 CAESARS             50-07-747-086-00          12/28/2007    450,000    COLNL/SPLT-LEV       3,606    2004     YES        734               $124.79
                             CONVENTIONAL SALE         PONE MARK & KAREN                 TOWNSEND BRAD & KARRA

 23-07-03-404-009            55510 CAESARS             50-07-747-088-00          01/04/2008    474,143   COLNL/SPLT-LEV  3,295          2005     YES        670               $143.90
                             TO/FR FINANCIAL INST      MACOMB COUNTY SHERIFF             MORTGAGE ELECTRONIC REGISTRATIO

 23-07-03-477-006            55265 WHITNEY             50-07-747-042-00          03/13/2008     552,000   COLNL/SPLT-LEV       4,182    2004     YES       1,054              $131.99
                             TO/FR FINANCIAL INST      BANK OF NEW YORK                  NEWELL-MCLAUGHLIN LAURA               SENT RPS ON 4/22/08

 23-07-03-477-006            55265 WHITNEY             50-07-747-042-00          03/13/2008     552,000   COLNL/SPLT-LEV       4,182    2004     YES       1,054              $131.99
                             TO/FR FINANCIAL INST      BANK OF NEW YORK                  NEWELL-MCLAUGHLIN LAURA

 23-07-03-427-001            55509 WHITNEY CT          50-07-747-132-00          07/07/2006      610,000         RANCH         3,664    2001     YES       1,112              $166.48
                             CONVENTIONAL SALE         LANDA TOMMY & TINAANNE            IBRAHIM CHADI M



Print Date:02/26/09   Print Time: 16:52:20       SHELBY TOWNSHIP ASSESSOR'S SALE LIST RESIDENTIAL IMPROVED OVER: $450,000                                                 Pa g e : 22
                                                Sales from: 01/01/2006 TO: 12/31/2008                      Sales Over: $450,000
                                                                     This List is indexed by Neighborhood / Area Name
  Neighborhood / Area Name
                                                                                                   Sale                                                                    Sale $ /
  Parcel Number              Property Address          Manatron Number           Date of Sale      Price       Struc Type       Sq Ft   Yr Blt   Bsmt   Gar Area         Bldg. sq. ft.
                             Terms of Sale              Grantor                          Grantee                               Sale Short Comments                 Other Parcel in sale #1
                                                     Neighborhood / Area Name
                                                                                      Totals    7,351,068                      49,146                     11,296            $1946.62
                                                    WHITNEY ESTATES SUB                           565,466                       3,780   2003                 868             $149.74
                                                                                   Averages
 WILDWOOD
 23-07-12-129-033            54676 WOODCREEK BLVD50-07-755-075-00                 07/31/2006    465,000   COLNL/SPLT-LEV       3,046    2003      YES       901               $152.66
                             CONVENTIONAL SALE          SAL-MAR HOMES INC                CACCHIONE CHARLES & LYNN M

 23-07-12-129-020            54483 SWEETWOOD            50-07-755-062-00          10/10/2008     486,047   COLNL/SPLT-LEV      4,021    2004      YES       728               $120.88
                             TO/FR FINANCIAL INST       MACOMB COUNTY SHERIFF            LASALLE BANK NATL ASSOCIATION

 23-07-12-129-020            54483 SWEETWOOD            50-07-755-062-00          12/12/2008     486,047   COLNL/SPLT-LEV      4,021    2004      YES       728               $120.88
                             TO/FR FINANCIAL INST       MACOMB COUNTY SHERIFF            LASALLE BANK NATL ASSOCIATION
                                                      Neighborhood / Area Name
                                                                                      Totals    1,437,094                      11,088                      2,357              $394.41
                                                          WILDWOOD                                479,031                       3,696   2003                 785              $131.47
                                                                                   Averages
 WINDMILL POND CONDOS
 23-07-24-476-142            14737 KINGS MILL           50-07-767-142-00          02/21/2006     600,000     STYLE "C"         1,336    2005      YES       391               $449.10
                             COMMON/CONTROL ENT         ADMIRAL HOMES SHELBY LLC         D'AGOSTINI LAND COMPANY LLC                                               23-07-24-476-143

 23-07-24-476-143            14745 KINGS MILL           50-07-767-143-00          02/21/2006     600,000     STYLE "D"         1,434    2005      YES       401               $418.41
                             COMMON/CONTROL ENT         ADMIRAL HOMES SHELBY LLC         D'AGOSTINI LAND COMPANY LLC                                               23-07-24-476-142

 23-07-24-476-144            14753 KINGS MILL           50-07-767-144-00          02/21/2006     600,000     STYLE "D"         1,519    2005      YES       380               $395.00
                             COMMON/CONTROL ENT         ADMIRAL HOMES SHELBY LLC         D'AGOSTINI LAND COMPANY LLC                                               23-07-24-476-143

                                                      Neighborhood / Area Name
                                                                                      Totals    1,800,000                       4,289                      1,172            $1262.51
                                                    WINDMILL POND CONDOS                          600,000                       1,429   2005                 390             $420.84
                                                                                   Averages
 WOODLANDS OF SHELBY
 23-07-14-277-010            13555 PARTRIDGE RUN        50-07-776-001-00          01/19/2006     550,000    COLNL/SPLT-LEV     3,534    2002      YES       723               $155.63
                             CONVENTIONAL SALE          VAN AMEYDE PATRICIA M            WITT GARY L & MICHELLE T

 23-07-14-277-007            13439 PARTRIDGE RUN        50-07-776-004-00          05/05/2006    650,000       COLNL/SPLT-LEV   3,398    2003      YES       718               $191.29
                             CONVENTIONAL SALE          MED MAR GROUP INC                KARPINSKY JOHN

 23-07-14-251-009            12791 PARTRIDGE RUN        50-07-776-024-00          07/19/2006    650,000       COLNL/SPLT-LEV   3,345    2004      YES       873               $194.32
                             NOT TYPICAL                MEDMAR                           TURNER MATTHEW                        NO PRE W PTA

 23-07-14-279-009            13436 PARTRIDGE RUN        50-07-776-058-00          07/21/2006    760,000    COLNL/SPLT-LEV      3,829    2004      YES       747               $198.49
                             NOT TYPICAL                MACLEOD SHANNON                  DEKUBBER DANIEL JR



Print Date:02/26/09   Print Time: 16:52:20       SHELBY TOWNSHIP ASSESSOR'S SALE LIST RESIDENTIAL IMPROVED OVER: $450,000                                                 Pa g e : 23
                                                Sales from: 01/01/2006 TO: 12/31/2008                   Sales Over: $450,000
                                                                 This List is indexed by Neighborhood / Area Name
  Neighborhood / Area Name
                                                                                                Sale                                                                   Sale $ /
  Parcel Number              Property Address        Manatron Number           Date of Sale     Price       Struc Type      Sq Ft   Yr Blt   Bsmt   Gar Area         Bldg. sq. ft.
                             Terms of Sale           Grantor                          Grantee                               Sale Short Comments                Other Parcel in sale #1

 23-07-14-276-005            52243 CHICKADEE LN      50-07-776-011-00          08/14/2006    470,000     COLNL/SPLT-LEV     3,254   2002      YES       832               $144.44
                             CONVENTIONAL SALE       JARVIS HOMES SHELBY INC          MOONEY PHILIP M & SHARON K            DEED $90000

 23-07-14-251-019            12784 PARTRIDGE RUN     50-07-776-034-00          09/15/2006   739,459   COLNL/SPLT-LEV  4,134         2004      YES       822               $178.87
                             TO/FR FINANCIAL INST    MACOMB COUNTY SHERIFF            MORTGAGE ELECTRONIC REGISTARTIO

 23-07-14-277-008            13477 PARTRIDGE RUN     50-07-776-003-00          10/06/2006    606,988   COLNL/SPLT-LEV       4,013   2002      YES       751               $151.26
                             TO/FR FINANCIAL INST    MACOMB COUNTY SHERIFF            DEUTSCHE BANK TRUST CO

 23-07-14-251-008            12827 PARTRIDGE RUN     50-07-776-023-00          10/16/2006    760,000    COLNL/SPLT-LEV   5,377      2005      YES     1,204               $141.34
                             TO/FR FINANCIAL INST    BANPAMEL MICHAEL J & KELLY J     NATIONAL RESIDENTIAL NOMINEE SERVI

 23-07-14-251-008            12827 PARTRIDGE RUN     50-07-776-023-00          03/02/2007    655,000   COLNL/SPLT-LEV       5,377   2005      YES     1,204               $121.82
                             TO/FR FINANCIAL INST    NATIONAL RESIDENTIAL NOMINEE     JACKSON GERMAIN M                     COVENANT DEED

 23-07-14-251-019            12784 PARTRIDGE RUN     50-07-776-034-00          03/15/2007    739,459  COLNL/SPLT-LEV        4,134   2004      YES       822               $178.87
                             TO/FR FINANCIAL INST    MACOMB COUNTY SHERIFF            COUNTRYWIDE HOME LOANS INC            UNCAP 09 IF NO SALE

 23-07-14-277-008            13477 PARTRIDGE RUN     50-07-776-003-00          04/06/2007     606,988   COLNL/SPLT-LEV      4,013   2002      YES       751               $151.26
                             TO/FR FINANCIAL INST    MACOMB COUNTY SHERIFF            FIRST NATIONAL BANK OF ARIZONA        UNCAP 09 IF NO SALE

 23-07-14-277-007            13439 PARTRIDGE RUN     50-07-776-004-00          04/27/2007    541,368   COLNL/SPLT-LEV 3,398         2003      YES       718               $159.32
                             TO/FR FINANCIAL INST    MACOMB COUNTY SHERIFF            DEUTSCHE BANK NATIONAL TRUST CO

 23-07-14-251-009            12791 PARTRIDGE RUN     50-07-776-024-00          06/15/2007    539,971   COLNL/SPLT-LEV       3,345   2004      YES       873               $161.43
                             TO/FR FINANCIAL INST    MACOMB COUNTY SHERIFF            AURORA LOAN SERVICES LLC

 23-07-14-277-007            13439 PARTRIDGE RUN     50-07-776-004-00          10/27/2007    541,368   COLNL/SPLT-LEV   3,398  2003    YES      718                       $159.32
                             TO/FR FINANCIAL INST    MACOMB TWP SHERIFF               DEUTSCHE BK NATIONAL TRUST CO AS TSEE LONGER GRANTOR NAME ON T

 23-07-14-251-019            12784 PARTRIDGE RUN     50-07-776-034-00          11/08/2007    537,500    COLNL/SPLT-LEV      4,134   2004      YES       822               $130.02
                             TO/FR FINANCIAL INST    COUNTRYWIDE HOME LOANS INC       ZATKOFF STANLEY & ANNETTE             SENT RPS ON 3/25/08

 23-07-14-251-011            52197 LOON CT           50-07-776-026-00          11/16/2007    562,500    COLNL/SPLT-LEV      4,285   2002      YES       734               $131.27
                             TO/FR FINANCIAL INST    MACOMB COUNTY SHERIFF            RESIDENTIAL FUNDING COMPANY

 23-07-14-251-005            12937 PARTRIDGE RUN     50-07-776-020-00          12/14/2007     795,000      COLNL/SPLT-LEV   3,868   2004      YES       954               $205.53
                             CONVENTIONAL SALE       SIGNATURE CONSTRUCTION           KHALIFA RAFIK

 23-07-14-251-021            12860 PARTRIDGE RUN     50-07-776-036-00          09/05/2008    460,000  COLNL/SPLT-LEV        3,613   2003      YES       752               $127.32
                             CONVENTIONAL SALE       GUERRERI ANTHONY & PATRICIA      SOURESHO NENOSE

 23-07-14-251-018            52022 LOON CT           50-07-776-033-00          06/15/2006    675,000          RANCH         2,902   2004      YES       861               $232.60
                             NOT TYPICAL             MED-MAR GROUP INC                PUGH SHARMONICA


Print Date:02/26/09   Print Time: 16:52:20       SHELBY TOWNSHIP ASSESSOR'S SALE LIST RESIDENTIAL IMPROVED OVER: $450,000                                             Pa g e : 24
                                                Sales from: 01/01/2006 TO: 12/31/2008                       Sales Over: $450,000
                                                                   This List is indexed by Neighborhood / Area Name
  Neighborhood / Area Name
                                                                                                    Sale                                                                     Sale $ /
  Parcel Number              Property Address         Manatron Number            Date of Sale       Price       Struc Type        Sq Ft   Yr Blt   Bsmt   Gar Area         Bldg. sq. ft.
                             Terms of Sale            Grantor                            Grantee                                 Sale Short Comments                 Other Parcel in sale #1

 23-07-14-279-003            13186 PARTRIDGE RUN      50-07-776-052-00           09/07/2006     485,000        RANCH             3,092    2005      YES       741               $156.86
                             PARTIAL ASSMT            SPLENDOR HOME INC                  LOPICCOLO SEBASTIAN J
                                                    Neighborhood / Area Name
                                                                                      Totals     12,325,603                      76,443                     16,620            $3271.24
                                                  WOODLANDS OF SHELBY                               616,280                       3,822   2003                 831             $163.56
                                                                                   Averages
 WOODSIDE VILLAGE
 23-07-04-404-002            55872 LANCEWOOD          50-07-780-079-00           08/13/2007      560,000       COLNL/SPLT-LEV    3,304    2006      YES       661               $169.49
                             CONVENTIONAL SALE        WOODSIDE BUILDING LLC              FISHER ROY G                            DEED SHOWS $100,000 SALE PRICE

 23-07-04-404-019            55733 NICHOLAS           50-07-780-071-00           08/31/2007      580,000       COLNL/SPLT-LEV    3,246    2005      YES       855               $178.68
                             CONVENTIONAL SALE        WOODSIDE BUILDING LLC              KELLY RODERICK                          DEED SHOWS $100,000

 23-07-04-402-001            55955 LANCEWOOD          50-07-780-058-00           09/06/2007      790,000       COLNL/SPLT-LEV    3,361    2005      YES       711               $235.05
                             NOT TYPICAL              RUFFINO ANTON & JANINE             RAHAIM DELICE
                                                    Neighborhood / Area Name
                                                                                      Totals      1,930,000                       9,911                      2,227              $583.22
                                                    WOODSIDE VILLAGE                                643,333                       3,303   2005                 742              $194.41
                                                                                   Averages

                                                                                                    Sale                                                                    Sale $ /
                                                                                                    Price                         Sq Ft   Yr Blt          Gar Area        Bldg. sq. ft.

                                                                                     Totals     179,350,795                     951,037                   206,339        $2,542,347.49
                                                                                  Averages         661,811                        3,509   1985                761             $9,381.36
                                                                                       Min.        450,000                            0   0                     0                 $0.00
                                                                                       Max        2,638,211                       5,377   2008              1,743        $1,915,000.00
                                                                               Record Count          36,856




Print Date:02/26/09   Print Time: 16:52:20       SHELBY TOWNSHIP ASSESSOR'S SALE LIST RESIDENTIAL IMPROVED OVER: $450,000                                                   Pa g e : 25