Docstoc

Equal Protection Analysis IIMT

Document Sample
Equal Protection Analysis IIMT Powered By Docstoc
					Equal Protection Analysis Does the statute fall under the purview of the Equal Protection Clause? o The State “cannot deny anyone it its jurisdiction the equal protection of the laws.” Distinguish between DeFacto and DeJure discrimination:

DeJure: - Facially Discriminatory? o Suspect Class (Race, Origin, Alienage) o Quasi-Suspect Class (Gender) o Non-Suspect Class (Age, Wealth, Economics, Sexual Orientation) Suspect Class (Race) o Apply Strict Scrutiny Standard:  Narrowly tailored to;  Achieve a compelling government interest.  Remedying past discrimination (Brown I).  Achieving racial diversity in schools (Brown II).  Protecting fundamental rights (Loving). Quasi-Suspect Class (Gender) o Is there discrimination against gender stereotypes? If no – The law was constructed that separated men and women for reasons other than their gender (i.e. – ability to become pregnant). o If yes – Apply Intermediate Scrutiny Standard (Craig Standard).  Substantially related  To an important governmental interest  Health, Welfare, Public Question. Non-Suspect Class (Age, Wealth, Sexual Orientation) o Apply Rational Basis Test:  Rationally Related to;  A legitimate government interest.  Sexual Orientation – Romer  Wealth – Kramer

-

-

OR DeFacto - Discrimination is neutral on its face, but law may have been administered in a discriminatory way. o Intent?  No Intent –  Rational Relation: o Rationally Related to o A legitimate state interest  Intent –  Prove by: o Disparate impact o Departure form procedure by state. o Departure from criteria applied by the state o Legislative history





If proven – Burden will jump back to the state and the Court will apply the strict scrutiny standard. o Narrowly tailored to o Achieve a compelling state interest Note: State must prove that if the intent were taken away, the same result would have been reached.


				
DOCUMENT INFO
Shared By:
Tags:
Stats:
views:984
posted:1/22/2009
language:English
pages:2
Description: Constitutional Law II- general focus economic liberties through amendments