Docstoc

SCORES

Document Sample
SCORES Powered By Docstoc
					Project Assessment Decision Matrix                      1             2             3

INSTRUCTIONS        PROJECT NAME                      Project       Project       Project


                            Descriptions
                     (See Comment Box for Levels) Score Awarded Score Awarded Score Awarded
     Relevance
                    Is the need identified in a
 1. MAC/Peak Body   WA Strategic and/or
        GAP         'Management' Plan?
2. National         Is the project relevant on a
relevance           national level?
                    Are the relevant fishery's
                    stocks currently threatened
3. Risk to stock    by fishing or environmental
(Wild Stocks)       impacts?
                    Does it address impacts on
                    fish habitat/ecosystem/
                    listed species from
                    detrimental activities (eg
4. Environmental    fishing). This is NOT impact
Impact              on a stock (see Q 3 above).
                    GVP (or Potential within 5
5. GVP              years) of commercial
(Commerical         fishing/aquaculture sector in
/Aquaculture) or    WA (or component of the
Potential Benefit   fishery if one species only.)


                    Relative priority/number for
6. Recreational     recreational fishers targeting
Significance        this stock(s).

                    Level of general social
                    concern/signifcance of issue
                    from NON PARTICIPANTS.
7. Community        (eg not a repeat of
Concern Support     recreational participation)
                    Do objectives assist
                    individuals, fishing sector or
                    agencies build skills to
8. Human capital    enhance management? (eg
building            PhD Students)

                    Are objectives consistent
                    with current Government's
9 Government        platform (eg Regional
Initiatives         Development) or agendas?
                    Subtotal (raw score)                        0             0             0
                    Subtotals - (weighted)             0.0           0.0           0.0
Attractiveness
                    What level of commitment
                    and support have the
1. Stakeholder      stakeholders made to this
support             project?
                   How likely is it that all
                   relevant
                   agencies/industries/sectors
2. Management      will adopt the planned
adoption prospects outcomes?
                   Will the planned outcomes
3. Value for money provide sound value for
(cost benefit)     money benefits?
                   How much of an impact will
4. Practical       the results (or the lack of
application/impact results) make?
5. Contribution to Will the project contribute to
new knowledge      new knowledge and
(uniqueness)       understanding?
                   Will the projects outcomes
6. State/industry  deliver kudos to the
promotion          State/industry sector?
                   Does the project
                   complement or add value to
                   existing WA projects or
7. Linkages        include other institutions?

                      SUBTOTAL
                      ATTRACTIVENESS                  0   0   0
Feasibility
                      Are the project outcomes
                      and objectives clearly set
1. Objectives clear   out?

2. Method             Are the methods appropriate
competent             and well described?
                      Does the Applicant, PI,
                      Collaborators have a
                      demonstrable good track
3. Personal track     record for delivering
record                competent outcomes?
                      Do the forecasted deadlines
                      meet the needs of the
                      industry sector and how
                      urgent are the outcomes
4. Timeliness         needed?
                      Does the
                      applicant/PI/Collaborators
                      have the capacity,
                      competency, time
                      commitment and available
                      infrastructure to achieve the
5. Capacity           outcomes?
                      Are the project outcomes
                      acheivable within the
                      proposed budget and
6. Achievability      timelines?
                 Does the proponent have the
                 capacity to provide the
                 managers/industry/stakehol
                 ders with the project
7. Extension     outcomes in a form suitable
capacity         for their use?

                 SUBTOTAL Feasibility                    0             0             0
                 No                                      1             2             3

                 NAME OF PROJECT               Project       Project       Project


WEIGHTS USED     TOTAL WEIGHTED SCORE                    0             0             0

RELEVANCE                   50%
ATTRACTIVENESS              25%
FEASIBILITY                 25%
      4             5             6             7             8            9             10

   Project       Project       Project       Project       Project       Project       Project



Score Awarded Score Awarded Score Awarded Score Awarded Score Awarded Score Awarded Score Awarded




             0             0             0             0             0             0             0
     0.0           0.0           0.0           0.0           0.0           0.0           0.0
0   0   0   0   0   0   0
          0             0             0             0             0             0              0
          4             5             6             7             8             9             10

Project       Project       Project       Project       Project       Project       Project


          0             0             0             0             0             0             0
     11            12            13            14            15            16            17

   Project       Project       Project       Project       Project       Project       Project



Score Awarded Score Awarded Score Awarded Score Awarded Score Awarded Score Awarded Score Awarded




             0             0             0             0             0             0             0
     0.0           0.0           0.0           0.0           0.0           0.0           0.0
0   0   0   0   0   0   0
           0              0              0              0              0              0              0
          11             12             13             14             15             16             17

Project        Project        Project        Project        Project        Project        Project


          0              0              0              0              0              0              0
     18            19            20            21            22            23            24

   Project       Project       Project       Project       Project       Project       Project



Score Awarded Score Awarded Score Awarded Score Awarded Score Awarded Score Awarded Score Awarded




             0             0             0             0             0             0             0
     0.0           0.0           0.0           0.0           0.0           0.0           0.0
0   0   0   0   0   0   0
           0              0              0              0              0              0              0
          18             19             20             21             22             23             24

Project        Project        Project        Project        Project        Project        Project


          0              0              0              0              0              0              0
     25            26            27            28            29            30            31

   Project       Project       Project       Project       Project       Project       Project



Score Awarded Score Awarded Score Awarded Score Awarded Score Awarded Score Awarded Score Awarded




             0             0             0             0             0             0             0
     0.0           0.0           0.0           0.0           0.0           0.0           0.0
0   0   0   0   0   0   0
           0              0              0              0              0              0              0
          25             26             27             28             29             30             31

Project        Project        Project        Project        Project        Project        Project


          0              0              0              0              0              0              0
     32            33            34            35            36            37            38

   Project       Project       Project       Project       Project       Project       Project



Score Awarded Score Awarded Score Awarded Score Awarded Score Awarded Score Awarded Score Awarded




             0             0             0             0             0             0             0
     0.0           0.0           0.0           0.0           0.0           0.0           0.0
0   0   0   0   0   0   0
           0              0              0              0              0              0              0
          32             33             34             35             36             37             38

Project        Project        Project        Project        Project        Project        Project


          0              0              0              0              0              0              0
     39            40            41            42            43            44            45

   Project       Project



Score Awarded Score Awarded Score Awarded Score Awarded Score Awarded Score Awarded Score Awarded




             0             0           0             0             0             0             0
     0.0           0.0           0.0           0.0           0.0           0.0           0.0
0   0   0   0   0   0   0
           0              0    0    0    0    0    0
          39             40   41   42   43   44   45

Project        Project         0    0    0    0    0


          0              0    0    0    0    0    0
     46            47            48            49            50




Score Awarded Score Awarded Score Awarded Score Awarded Score Awarded




           0             0             0             0             0
     0.0           0.0           0.0           0.0           0.0
0   0   0   0   0
 0    0    0    0    0
46   47   48   49   50

 0    0    0    0    0


0    0    0    0    0
SUMMARY TABLES
                                                   TOTAL
                  No.        NAME OF PROJECT       SCORE No.
                         1   Project                   0      1
                         2   Project                   0      2
                         3   Project                   0      3
CLICK ON BOX TO          4   Project                   0      4
    UPDATE               5   Project                   0      5
SUMMARY TABLES
                         6   Project                   0      6
                         7   Project                   0      7
                         8   Project                   0      8
                         9   Project                   0      9
                        10   Project                   0     10
                        11   Project                   0     11
                        12   Project                   0     12
                        13   Project                   0     13
                        14   Project                   0     14
                        15   Project                   0     15
                        16   Project                   0     16
                        17   Project                   0     17
                        18   Project                   0     18
                        19   Project                   0     19
                        20   Project                   0     20
                        21   Project                   0     21
                        22   Project                   0     22
                        23   Project                   0     23
                        24   Project                   0     24
                        25   Project                   0     25
                        26   Project                   0     26
                        27   Project                   0     27
                        28   Project                   0     28
                        29   Project                   0     29
                        30   Project                   0     30
                        31   Project                   0     31
                        32   Project                   0     32
                        33   Project                   0     33
                        34   Project                   0     34
                        35   Project                   0     35
                        36   Project                   0     36
                        37   Project                   0     37
                        38   Project                   0     38
                        39   Project                   0     39
                        40   Project                   0     40
                        41                     0       0     41
                        42                     0       0     42
                        43                     0       0     43
                        44                     0       0     44
                        45                     0       0     45
                        46                     0       0     46
47   0   0   47
48   0   0   48
49   0   0   49
50   0   0   50
                      RELEVANCE
NAME OF PROJECT       SCORE
Project                       0
Project                       0
Project                       0
Project                       0
Project                       0
Project                       0
Project                       0
Project                       0
Project                       0
Project                       0
Project                       0
Project                       0
Project                       0
Project                       0
Project                       0
Project                       0
Project                       0
Project                       0
Project                       0
Project                       0
Project                       0
Project                       0
Project                       0
Project                       0
Project                       0
Project                       0
Project                       0
Project                       0
Project                       0
Project                       0
Project                       0
Project                       0
Project                       0
Project                       0
Project                       0
Project                       0
Project                       0
Project                       0
Project                       0
Project                       0
                  0           0
                  0           0
                  0           0
                  0           0
                  0           0
                  0           0
0   0
0   0
0   0
0   0
          GET NUMBER AND
            TITLES FOR
             PROJECTS

PROJECT
NUMBER        TITLE
   1          Project
   2          Project
   3          Project
   4          Project
   5          Project
   6          Project
   7          Project
   8          Project
   9          Project
  10          Project
  11          Project
  12          Project
  13          Project
  14          Project
  15          Project
  16          Project
  17          Project
  18          Project
  19          Project
  20          Project
  21          Project
  22          Project
  23          Project
  24          Project
  25          Project
  26          Project
  27          Project
  28          Project
  29          Project
  30          Project
  31          Project
  32          Project
  33          Project
  34          Project
  35          Project
  36          Project
  37          Project
  38          Project
  39          Project
  40          Project
  41
  42
  43
  44
45
46
47
48
49
50
COMMENTS
ASSESSMENT                       1               2               3               4               5               6               7               8               9



                           Score Awarded   Score Awarded   Score Awarded   Score Awarded   Score Awarded   Score Awarded   Score Awarded   Score Awarded   Score Awarded
       Relevance
1. GAP
2. National relevance
3. Risk to stock
4. Environ. Impact
5. GVP
6. Rec Significance
7. Community Concern
Support
8. Human capital
building
9 Government or Peak
Body Initiatives
Raw
x 1.66 weighted
Attractiveness

1. Stakeholder support
2. Management adoption
prospects
3. Value for money
4. Practical
application/impact
5. Contribution to new
knowledge
6. State/industry
promotion
7. Linkages
Raw
x 0.71 weighted
Feasibility
1. Objectives clear

2. Method competent

3. Personal track record
4. Timeliness
5. Capacity
6. Achievability
7. Extension capacity
Raw
x 0.71 weighted
TOTAL
ASSESSMENT                      10              11              12              13              14              15              16              17              18



                           Score Awarded   Score Awarded   Score Awarded   Score Awarded   Score Awarded   Score Awarded   Score Awarded   Score Awarded   Score Awarded
       Relevance
1. GAP
2. National relevance
3. Risk to stock
4. Environ. Impact
5. GVP
6. Rec Significance
7. Community Concern
Support
8. Human capital
building
9 Government or Peak
Body Initiatives
Raw
x 1.66 weighted
Attractiveness

1. Stakeholder support
2. Management adoption
prospects
3. Value for money
4. Practical
application/impact
5. Contribution to new
knowledge
6. State/industry
promotion
7. Linkages
Raw
x 0.71 weighted
Feasibility
1. Objectives clear

2. Method competent

3. Personal track record
4. Timeliness
5. Capacity
6. Achievability
7. Extension capacity
Raw
x 0.71 weighted
TOTAL
ASSESSMENT                      19              20              21              22              23              24              25              26              27



                           Score Awarded   Score Awarded   Score Awarded   Score Awarded   Score Awarded   Score Awarded   Score Awarded   Score Awarded   Score Awarded
       Relevance
1. GAP
2. National relevance
3. Risk to stock
4. Environ. Impact
5. GVP
6. Rec Significance
7. Community Concern
Support
8. Human capital
building
9 Government or Peak
Body Initiatives
Raw
x 1.66 weighted
Attractiveness

1. Stakeholder support
2. Management adoption
prospects
3. Value for money
4. Practical
application/impact
5. Contribution to new
knowledge
6. State/industry
promotion
7. Linkages
Raw
x 0.71 weighted
Feasibility
1. Objectives clear

2. Method competent

3. Personal track record
4. Timeliness
5. Capacity
6. Achievability
7. Extension capacity
Raw
x 0.71 weighted
TOTAL
ASSESSMENT                      28              29              30              31              32              33              34              35              36



                           Score Awarded   Score Awarded   Score Awarded   Score Awarded   Score Awarded   Score Awarded   Score Awarded   Score Awarded   Score Awarded
       Relevance
1. GAP
2. National relevance
3. Risk to stock
4. Environ. Impact
5. GVP
6. Rec Significance
7. Community Concern
Support
8. Human capital
building
9 Government or Peak
Body Initiatives
Raw
x 1.66 weighted
Attractiveness

1. Stakeholder support
2. Management adoption
prospects
3. Value for money
4. Practical
application/impact
5. Contribution to new
knowledge
6. State/industry
promotion
7. Linkages
Raw
x 0.71 weighted
Feasibility
1. Objectives clear

2. Method competent

3. Personal track record
4. Timeliness
5. Capacity
6. Achievability
7. Extension capacity
Raw
x 0.71 weighted
TOTAL
ASSESSMENT                      37              38              39              40              41              42              43              44              45



                           Score Awarded   Score Awarded   Score Awarded   Score Awarded   Score Awarded   Score Awarded   Score Awarded   Score Awarded   Score Awarded
       Relevance
1. GAP
2. National relevance
3. Risk to stock
4. Environ. Impact
5. GVP
6. Rec Significance
7. Community Concern
Support
8. Human capital
building
9 Government or Peak
Body Initiatives
Raw
x 1.66 weighted
Attractiveness

1. Stakeholder support
2. Management adoption
prospects
3. Value for money
4. Practical
application/impact
5. Contribution to new
knowledge
6. State/industry
promotion
7. Linkages
Raw
x 0.71 weighted
Feasibility
1. Objectives clear

2. Method competent

3. Personal track record
4. Timeliness
5. Capacity
6. Achievability
7. Extension capacity
Raw
x 0.71 weighted
TOTAL
ASSESSMENT                      46              47              48              49              50



                           Score Awarded   Score Awarded   Score Awarded   Score Awarded   Score Awarded
       Relevance
1. GAP
2. National relevance
3. Risk to stock
4. Environ. Impact
5. GVP
6. Rec Significance
7. Community Concern
Support
8. Human capital
building
9 Government or Peak
Body Initiatives
Raw
x 1.66 weighted
Attractiveness

1. Stakeholder support
2. Management adoption
prospects
3. Value for money
4. Practical
application/impact
5. Contribution to new
knowledge
6. State/industry
promotion
7. Linkages
Raw
x 0.71 weighted
Feasibility
1. Objectives clear

2. Method competent

3. Personal track record
4. Timeliness
5. Capacity
6. Achievability
7. Extension capacity
Raw
x 0.71 weighted
TOTAL

				
DOCUMENT INFO