STATUS OF INDEPENDENT THIRD PARTY EVALUATION Annexure-IX If the third party system not No. of districts Item of work involved in Report submitted & Sl.No. States/UTs Name of agency Date of contract started, present status and likely Remarks involved evaluation periodicity date for finalizing Engineering Staff College of 25-03-2008 13 Foundation/Roof level, ESCI - 2203 no inspected schools 1 Andhra Pradesh India Monthly basement level finishing SGS India Pvt. Ltd. April, 2008 9 SGS - 392 inspected schools 2 Arunachal Pradesh Fresh tenders are to be invited by July, 2009 Engineering Institutes & Private 3 Assam 23 1st,2nd,3rd interim recived NA final report expected in June 09 Institute Third party evaluation agency has almost been finalised. For 4 Bihar SRG Engineers On honararium basis 37 All works Yes negotiation of rates 25.5.09 has been fixed then contract will be signed 5 Chhattisagrh Information not furnished Civil College of Engineering, Will be started soon probably in the 6 Goa 2 Farmagudi Month of July, 2009 SGS India Pvt. Ltd. WAPCOS Pace Consultants 4 visits to all sites including 7 Gujarat All districts Interim reports received final report is expected testing of material Mars Planning&Engineering Shrey Consultants Bhoomi Consultants 8 Haryana Tenders are being called for the year 2009-10 9 Himachal Pradesh Information not furnished For rest of 21 districts retendering of National Institute of Technology 10 Jammu & Kashmir 1 In progress construction TPE will be done after 1st June, (Srinagar) 2009 11 Jharkhand Information not furnished STATUS OF INDEPENDENT THIRD PARTY EVALUATION Annexure-IX If the third party system not No. of districts Item of work involved in Report submitted & Sl.No. States/UTs Name of agency Date of contract started, present status and likely Remarks involved evaluation periodicity date for finalizing Mars Engineering Consultants April, 2008 8 Monthly New school building, Agriculture Finance Corporation April, 2008 9 Monthly The civil works of 2008-09 tender is Additional classroom for the Civil Works are supervised by the third party. completed year 2007-08 They visit site at different stages 5 to 6 times Niketan Consultants April, 2008 12 Monthly to each work and give technical guidance to Somat Infrastructure India Pvt. village level committee. They also conducts 12 Karnataka 20th April, 2009 9 tests on materials brought for construction at Ltd. site and laboratory tests are also conducted JSS Consultants, Mysore 15th April, 2009 8 New school building, and they furnish the reports and suggests the Agriculture Finance Corporation Additional classroom for the Monthly - block engineers to village level committee if 20th April, 2009 7 Ltd., Bangalore year 2008-09 there is any correction. Indian Register of Shipping 16th April, 2009 5 Bangalore Payment will be permitted only after getting 13 Kerala Not implemented due to the major civil works are being carried out by the Local Self Govt. (LSGs) the evaluation certificates from the LSG engineers in each stage 14 Madhya Pradesh The Lion Consultant and Engineers case is in litigation, completion date expired, new agency's case, tenders etc. are being called. Report submitted to Jr. Workshop at CEC & District engineers and executive Govt. Polytechnic, Thane 30th July, 2008 2 level and at least 4 - 5 times engineers at district level and visit to each SPO office Rajendra Goodakari & 30th July, 2008 3 -do- -do- Association 15 Maharashtra Not applicable There are 8 education region in Maharashtra Shree Joshree Creations 30th July, 2008 4 -do- -do- Struction Project Consultant 30th July, 2008 5 -do- -do- Kirloskar Consultant 30th July, 2008 5 -do- -do- Keskar Consultants 30th July, 2008 5 -do- -do- Govt. Polytechnic, Latur 30th July, 2008 3 -do- -do- PT Mase & Association 30th July, 2008 6 -do- -do- STATUS OF INDEPENDENT THIRD PARTY EVALUATION Annexure-IX If the third party system not No. of districts Item of work involved in Report submitted & Sl.No. States/UTs Name of agency Date of contract started, present status and likely Remarks involved evaluation periodicity date for finalizing Expression of interest to be invited as per the After PAB approves for the year 16 Manipur item of works to be taken up in the year 2009- 2009-10 civil works 10 17 Meghalaya Information not furnished 18 Mizoram Information not furnished Rural Development (RD) April, 2007 11 One time GPS, GMS, ACR, BW, Toilet, 19 Nagaland State level Education Committee 2007 11 Drinking water, BRC Through out the year Civil work, accounts and Starts on February, 2009 for the year 2008-09 20 Orissa NIT, Rurkela 1/14/2009 30 Started on February, 2009 progress and it will continue 21 Punjab Fresh tenders are to be recalled 22 Rajasthan Tender cannot be received in March and now it is received on 19-5-09 23 Sikkim Information not furnished Department of Technical 24 Tamil Nadu - 30 - - - All are in progress Education Inspite of efforts no agency could be selected for engagement of third party for monitoring and evaluation of civil works upto 2008-09 due to very high rate quality by the bidders. Expression of interest has been invited for selection of 25 Tripura 3rd party for monitoring and evaluation of civil works during 2009-10 26 Uttar Pradesh Information not furnished Central Building Research Workshop/training of VECs/DPO and JE is 27 Uttarakhand November, 2008 13 All PS/UPS building and ACR Monthly, quarterly and annually Institute Roorkee, India (CBRI) completed by the agency Evaluation and quality control BASS Consultancy 5/19/2009 8 28 West Bengal measures for on going civil Started For contractual works 2007-08, 2008-09 etc. works DEATELIER 5/19/2009 10 29 A & Nicobar Islands Information not furnished 30 Chandigarh Tenders have been received. The selection of the firm is at final stage and shall be started as per the finalisation of the tender 31 Dadra Nagar Haveli Information not furnished STATUS OF INDEPENDENT THIRD PARTY EVALUATION Annexure-IX If the third party system not No. of districts Item of work involved in Report submitted & Sl.No. States/UTs Name of agency Date of contract started, present status and likely Remarks involved evaluation periodicity date for finalizing 32 Daman & Diu Information not furnished Engineering Faculty, Aligarh January, 2008 9 Material testing in Lab Site 33 Delhi Supervision at Lintel level, Quarterly NA root level and final stage Muslim University, Aligarh, UP December, 2008 9 34 Lakshadweep Information not furnished 35 Pondicherry Since the State PWD is declared as 'Nodal agency' the PWD itself being the third party evaluator Note: The details given above are based on the information furnished by the participants in the review meeting held on 21st & 22nd May, 2009. The states of Assam, Chhattisgarh, Gujarat, Himachal Pradesh, Jharkhand, Meghalaya, Mizoram, Sikkim, Uttar Pradesh, Andaman & Nicobar, Dadra & Nagar Haveli, Daman & Diu, and Lakshwadeep have not furnished the details and the remaining states have furnished the details.
Pages to are hidden for
"thirdparty"Please download to view full document