Document Sample
Index Powered By Docstoc
					Determinants of the Occupational Community: II

WE HAVE SUGGESTED that the relatively high status of printers and their positive liking for their craft
are two of the principal factors contributing to the existence of an occupational community among printers.
Yet the widening of popular education, reducing the status claim of the printer, and the increased mechanization
of printing, limiting his variety in work, indicate that the occupational community might be less significant today
than in the past. Our impressionistic judgment, based on reading printers' papers and magazines for the last fifty
years, is that there has been a decline. Yet two unique factors, apart from status and craft pride, continue to
provide the mortar to keep the occupational community together. These are the conditions under which men
secare and maintain employment in a print shop, and the fact that a large pro portion of printers work nights.

§ The Substitute System
  ONE OF THE CHARACTERISTICS of the printing industry is the fluctuating work loads on different days
of the week and at different periods of the year. Newspapers, for example, require additional printers on
days, such as Thursdays, Fridays, and Saturdays, when advertising is heavier. They also expand their labor
force considerably during the pre-Christmas season. Many book and job shops which specialize in

advertising, magazine, or election work have comparable hiring problems. Printing tends to be seasonal,
with a major slack period in the
summer and the greatest amount of work between September and January.
    These extra loads are filled by substitutes and by overtime. The substitutes are either beginners in the
industry who, having finished a six-year apprenticeship, go to the bottom of the priority (seniority) list and
must wait out an opening in the regular work force, or other printers who have lost their regular jobs.
    Substitutes are hired by the day. Every printer working in a print shop, regularly or as a substitute, has
a priority number within that shop, assigned according to the length of time he has been in the shop. New
situations are filled or regular men discharged according to one's position on the list. When a substitute
deposits his union card in a particular shop, he is assigned a number at the bottom of the list and waits his turn
for a regular situation.
    However, the daily hiring of subs is not carried out in accordance with this list. Instead, the chapel
chairman holds a lottery in which each sub draws a numbered ball. Those men with the highest numbers get
the positions for the day, while those with lower numbers are out of luck for that shift.
    The first consequence of this procedure is that every man feels constrained to show up every day.'
Those subs who do not get work find themselves downtown with nothing to do for the rest of the day. Subs
are permitted to show up on all three shifts if they like. Many men who do not get work in the morning
will often show up for the evening shift as well. If a man needs money badly, he may show up for all three
shifts, trying his luck each time.
    The men who have failed to get work have to kill six to eight hours between shifts. During the period
when printers' clubs had full-time headquarters, many subs went there to talk, play cards, or drink? Then and
now, many of them go to the union headquarters, which has rooms for cardplaying or sitting around and
talking. Others may meet at a

   1 One important function of this system for the employer is that it supplies him each day with a full "reserve army of
   unemployed," so that unanticipated work schedules may be filled. If there were another system of hiring so that one man's
   chances were less than anther's, either due to position on the priority list or the foreman's favor, those men with less chance would tend to
   stay at home.
   2 . Full-time headquarters disappeared during World War II, when there was full employment in the trade for the first time since World War I.
     Without patronage of subs, with most men working long overtime hours, and with the younger men in the military services, there
     was a sharp decline in occupational community activities. The Typographical Forum, the occupational-community newspaper, also
     ceased publishing in this period. Since the end of the war the situation has gradually returned to "normal." Club and other
     occupational-community activity has revived, but is still far from the point reached in the thirties.

 local bar and socialize. Many of the newspapers have large lounging rooms which were set up for
the benefit of subs or workers who have
come downtown early to see their friends. In all these ways the subs are thrown together throughout their
entire substitute period.
   But this is not the only consequence of the substitute hiring system for the occupational
community. A second method of hiring subs also operates as a force for association. The hiring
system we have described, in which the sub's job is dependent on chance, operates only for that extra work
which is created by the employer. But when a job-holder is ill, he decides to take a day off, or when he has
accumulated overtime and must take a day off in accordance with union rules, the job holder
himself determines who will replace him. The employer has no control over the hiring in this case,
nor does the union. The job-holder, in effect, owns his job, and determines who will replace him in
it. Naturally the man will tend to give the opening to a friend or to the friend of a friend, or in some cases
to a man who pays him a few dollars for the
day's work.
    Throughout a man's substitute career his work opportunities will
depend on his ability to make friends among other printers in the shop. Subs are under strain to
ingratiate themselves with job holders. 3 This, of course, may be done by doing favors for such men,
participating in

   3. And as would be expected, the situation-holder sometimes does manipulate the sub, in any of several ways. The pressures put upon a
   substitute are well illustrated by some comments made during the interview by a sub who was in our sample.
In a probe following a question about security:
    No, I've felt the same about that [the security of printers, which he had characterized as `only fairly good"]. It's called to
   my attention every time I draw one of those balls, or whenever somebody slips one of the old sots a pint so he'll put
   his name up on the board as a substitute.
Q. Is there anything about the ITU which could stand improving?
     Yes: the priority law. If you came into a shop and then there was a layoff, the last man still works every day, and the others who
   are laid off don't work at all. In the ILGWU if there's not enough work for everybody, they share it. Union ism should
   provide an equalization of work rather than gambling every day for a job. In hiring subs a man can pick whoever he wants, which is
   the worst form of unionism in the world. Favoritism is very prevalent. You can give a lush $z and still make $i8 a night.
Q. Do you think people like you have a lot of influence on how the union runs
 things, some influence, or not much influence?
     Not much. [Q. Why?] Because a sub is considered a step lower than the rest, and any opinions or gripes are politely turned
   down.... He's afraid to voice his opinion because he might antagonize men giving him work and become known as a
   troublemaker; men who are off once in a while will not put him up as a sub for them when they are off.
    Running through these statements is (along with a bitterness toward the priority system) awareness of the pressure to make
    oneself liked by the printer on the job and painful awareness of the substitute's dependency on the situation-holder.

printers' social affairs in which they may make friends, trying to join shop cliques, going out bowling, and other
similar devices. While the stress is on making friends in one's own shop, knowing printers in a number of shops
may help. Subs are permitted to work temporarily in a shop other than the one in which they
have their card, if there are no subs available for work in the other shop. Many small shops have
few or no subs since the opportunity to secure extra work or a steady situ ation is related to the size
of the shop. These smaller shops must therefore call upon men from the larger plants. Here
acquaintanceship pays off, since a friend may let one know in advance th at his shop will need
people. Attending club meetings or occupational -community affairs may pay real dividends for the
    It is difficult to document on the basis of our data the precise con sequences of the above two
mechanisms-the need to show up every day and the dependence on friendship for employment.
This is especially true since these factors were not considered in our initial formulation of the study
when the interview questions were developed .4 Nevertheless, it is possible to differentiate among
the members of the sample between those men who had more substitute experience in their
background than others, and to compare their social relations with that of other printers. One
indirect indicator of length of substitute experience is the resp onse to the question asking how long a
man has been without steady work . 5
   It is clear that the more unemployment a man has experienced and presumably the more time he
has spent as a sub, the more likely he is to be active in the occupational community. In addition, the men in
the sample who were substitutes when interviewed were more involved in informal and formal social
relations with other printers than the fully employed men.
   If the substitute period were short or if only a few men went through the trials of a substitute,
this system would not be too important for the social system of the union. But the substitute period
may last from

    4. It should be noted that even if we had considered these factors before beginning our field research, it would not have been
possible for us to distinguish quantitatively between the two processes. This is because both processes are postulated to operate in the
same direction for the same men. If we knew precisely who the substitutes associated with most, and under what conditions, we would
then have the information to analyze which process contributed most to socialization into the occupational community.
    5. While responses to this question are undoubtedly related to the extent of substitute experience, it is clear from the totals that many
men who were substitutes did not tell us that they were without steady employment. We would guess that the difference is a result of
the fact that men do not consider substitute periods, in which they may work an average of two or three days a week, as being without
a job.

Figure 23-Relationship between Reported Periods of Unemployment
and Activity in the Occupational Community

three to five years on the large newspapers, and except for the war years it has been virtually
impossible to get a job on a newspaper or in a large book and job shop without being a sub. This
experience, therefore, is a characteristic of the whole occupation and not simply of a few men in it. This
pressure to get involved socially with other printers ends once a man has a regular position, but the
informal and formal associations which he has formed may continue for many years.
    There are many other occupations, such as the building trades, longshore work, and the entertainment
fields, which are seasonal and irregular in character and in which job opportunities depend on social contacts.
And indeed, the workers in all these occupations tend to associate with each other. Painters, for example,
must find something to do when it rains, and one finds hangouts where painters or bricklayers are known
to cluster. These are often in restaurants, bars, the union hall, or even occupational social clubs such as
exist among printers. In these occupations the men do not own their jobs nor do they have a system of
picking substitutes like the lottery, and the power to pick workers be comes a source of power in the
hands of the union administration, or foremen and employers? 6
     While we have not studied intensively any other comparable occupation, it seems clear that irregular
 work, while contributing to the existence of an occupational community, is most often a source of strength
 for the incumbent union administration? Workers are so

   6. One interesting exception occurs among the musicians. Band leaders who are members of the union hire pickup
t.ands from men in the union hall. In this union and occupation, which resemble those of the printers in many ways,
the band leaders constitute the basis for political conflict. The New York local of the union has two regular parties,
much like those in the ITU, which are based on -the cliques around different groups of band or orchestra leaders. A
comparison of two unions in the same occupation adds further weight to these interpretations. Longshoremen, like
substitute printers, must show up daily for employment, and many work only a few days a week. Longshoremen also
have an occupational community. Many of them live near the docks in close proximity to each other. East Coast
longshoremen are hired through the shapeup system. Each man shapes up at the dock, and the hiring boss, who is
often a union official or part of the same machine that controls the union, selects the m en to work. In San
Francisco the longshoremen are hired in rotation, and neither the union nor employer can affect a man's chances to
obtain work. The East Coast union is one of the worst dictator ships in American unionism, whereas the West Coast
union, though Communistcontrolled on the international level, is very democratic. The San Francisco local has two
permanent political groups, which alternate in power much as do the parties in the ITU.
    7. On the other hand, Shepard in a study of the Amalgamated Clothing Workers considers slack periods which provide "opportunities for
 social participation in the union hall and developing interest in and knowledge of union problems" to be one of the objective factors
 that made for democratic control in the union. Cf. Shepard, American Journal of Sociology, 54:315 .
dependent on the union for employment that they do not dare to participate in opposition activities. It is only
when workers have the security of protection from discrimination by the union that such associations may form
the basis for political opposition."
   The difference between the printers and those occupations in which there is control over hiring by the
union or the employer or a combination of both, makes possible a fairly precise statement of the consequences of
variable work requirements in conjunction with different types of hiring policies. The consequences for printers, as
described in the preceding pages, are summed up in Diagram A.
Diagram A

That is, the variable work requirements in conjunction with the hiring policies of the union combine to make
the substitute associate with other subs and with regular printers in his shop; this in turn helps support the
institutions of the occupational community, which form a basis for a continuing opposition against the
incumbent administration.
   In unions in which the hiring policies are controlled by the union administration, however, the same
variable work requirements can have quite different consequences. Diagram B indicates the processes which

   8. The freedom from manipulation on the part of the employer and the union gives rise among some of the printers to real
feelings of exuberance and expressions of a sense of freedom. Several of the men in interview expressed these feelings. As on e
man happily put it: "How free is free? How free can a man be?" Although some of the practices of the printers which engender
this feeling are not workable in more highly rationalized industries, some certainly are. The resulting feelings of security and
well-being among printers indicate a partial solution to the problem of the worker's ever-increasing subjection to the
manipulative forces of big business, big unions, and big government. One of the most appealing consequences of the ITU's
democratic process, including the laws making for autonomy of the individual printer, is this feeling of freedom from
manipulation, the power of selfdetermination.
    If such grass-roots democracy with its concomitant feelings of freedom from manipulations is not possible on the nat ional
 level in civil politics because of size, it is not inherently impossible in other spheres of a man's life, especially the cru cial sphere
 of his occupation. A lessening of the manipulative power of management and of the union over a man's work would b e one
 step in the realization of a liberal society.
                                   Diagram B

we suggest are operative. Thus while potential opposition is produced by the variable work, the power to
crush this opposition is also produced by the combination of this with union leader-controlled hiring
   The hiring policies themselves are at least partially a consequence of the type of government of the union,
the printers' hiring policies having been instituted at the demand of the members and the political
opposition to the administration in order to eliminate such a union foreman combine within the ITU. Before
the priority system was introduced (and its introduction was gradual, each step eliminating some of the power of
the foreman) control over hiring was completely in the hands of foremen. And as the reader will recall from
Chapter 3, the old Wahneta organization is reputed to have built its power by recruiting foremen, who then
gave preference to fellow Wahnetas. The predecessors of the present Progs led the fight for the priority
system as a means of reducing the power of the Wahnetas and the foremen.
   This historical note, together with the processes diagramed above, provides an excellent illustration of the self-
maintaining mechanisms of a democratic system. The democratic control of the ITU led to 'The institution
of a hiring system free from union leader control, which in turn helps perpetuate the institutions which give
power to a political opposition. The other pattern is, conversely, a self-maintaining one for oligarchic control.9
Oligarchic government gives the administration power to control hiring policies, which in turn gives the
administration control over potential oppositionists.
    Another socializing agency which affects many printers is appren tice school. While most of an
apprentice's time is spent in the print shop at which he is apprenticed, there are regular classes which he
attends as well. Since the whole apprentice period is six years, this means that an apprentice will get to know his
classmates well. The apprentices in New York State take a trip to Albany together for a special training

  9. Of course other factors enter in. If they did not, the printers would never have managed to free hiring from administration control.

session in each of the last two years of their apprenticeship, which further acts to increase their cohesion.
The major difference between this and other school periods which produce the same kind of cohesion is
that these men never separate to go their various ways as do college classmates. Many of them stay in the
same city, so that their apprentice friends are fellow union members in the same local for the rest of their
career. These friendships are long-lasting, as several of the members of our sample testified. One of the union
political leaders clearly indicates the socializing function of the apprentice school as well as the political
relevance of social groups in his answer to the question, What was the first political meeting you attended in
the union?:

  Some of the boys I went to apprentice school with were associated with the Liberals and I went along to observe. This
was 1932 [while still an apprentice]. A fellow who serves as an apprentice in New York is different from one coming from
out of town. There are groups in apprentice school, and you form opinions there and get interested. By the time
you're out, you're interested and active. It's like college in a way-you make close friends and do things in and out of
school together that you have fond memories of. The thing you remember most is the fun you had in school.
When you see the same fellows now, you have sort of a spontaneous greeting. Going around campaigning now, I see
some of them every once in a while, and we go over old times.

 § Night Work
    MANY PRINTERS must work nights and week ends, thus breaking the normal pattern of family life and
leisure life. About 45 % of the membership of Big Six are night workers. Every newspaper and a large num ber
of book-and-job shops have night shifts. Most newspapers actually have two night shifts, one from about
    four in the afternoon to midnight and the other from midnight to some time in the morning. In many
    industries which require night work, workers alternate between periods of night and day work. A printer,
    however, must remain on the night shift until he has accumulated enough priority to claim a day job. Thus,
    almost every printer has spent some time on the night shift. The only exceptions are the small group of
    men who have always worked in small shops, which do not have night work. Only 8% of the members of our
    sample reported that they had never worked on a night shift.
      One of the primary consequences of night-work is the breakup of normal leisure patterns. Neighborhood
     and other organizations are built around the "normal" nine-to-five working day and meet in the evening. Mass
     entertainment is similarly organized to meet the needs of people who work days and want to relax in the
     evening. The night worker's social relationships must in large measure be limited to people who are in his same
     situation. For a printer the pool of other night workers most easily available to him is other printers. Printers
     working on the night shift will thus seek out other printers and become involved in the occupational community

          Table I I-Relationship between Work Shift and
          Involvement In the
                                         Night Workers Day
              High in social relations   30%           23
              Two or more printer 38%                  27%
              Members of printers' clubs 36%           26
                  N                      (200)         (234)

       Thus whatever the varied consequences of night work are, the data indicate that night work increases the
    likelihood of printers' associating with fellow craftsmen.
        New night workers probably attempt to continue as much of their past social life as possible after going on the
    night shift, and these men initially show even lower levels of social interaction with other printers than do day
    workers. The longer, however, that they are on the night shift, the more likely they are to evidence a high level of
    leisure-time social relations with printers. The success that a man has in adjusting to the social requirement of night
    work greatly affects his attitude to working nights. When asked whether they preferred working days or nights, 62%
    of the night workers indicated a preference for the night shift. When we compare the leisure pattern of those
    preferring nights with those who would like to be on the day shift, it is clear that these responses are, in part at
    least, a reaction to success or failure in adjusting one's social life.

     Table 12-Relationship between Preference for Night or Day Work among Night Workers, and

     involvement In Social Relations with Other Printers

          Table 12-Relationship between Work Shift and
          Involvement In Social relation with other printers
          Night workers who
                                            Prefer days    Prefer nights
              High in social relations      22%             37 %
                 N                          70              114

      Earlier we suggested that the substitute system was important in initially integrating printers into the occupational
    community, and that friendship patterns formed in this early period continue after men get regular jobs. Night work
    has a similar effect. As printers grow older they gain priority, and eventually many, though not all, claim situations

on the day shift. When printers who have been on the night shift for a decade or. more change to day work, they
have difficulty in readjusting their leisure habits. A number of men pointed out that a printer working in a
newspaper hardly gets to know his children, who are in school while he is not working. Often the children are adults
before he gets a chance to work days. He has also lost contact with many of his nonprinter friends during his long
period on the night shift. Such men will continue to associate with other printers, given the difficulty of making new
friends after forty.
To verify the long-range effects of night work, we compared the social relations of night and day workers who have
spent amounts of time working nights.

Figure 24- Relationship between Time spent on Night shift and Social Relations with printers

                      PROPORTION OF             NIGHT
                      CAREER ON                 WORK
   PERCENT                    27%              30%            43%
               15%            23%              29%
   TOTAL                      (21)             (79)           (89)
               (34)           (154)            (27)

    It is clear from the above data that past experience on the night shift continues to affect men's social behavior
after they leave it.
    There are a number of processes which underlie the propensity of night workers to associate with printers. First,
we would suggest that the day worker is subject to the structured pulls of mass entertainment, of neighborhood
organizations, and of nonprinter friends away from the printers' community, while night workers on all these counts
are subject to a push toward the printers' community. Thus while night

workers take less part in nonprinter organizations, they take more part in organizations associated with printing than
do day workers.10
   A second element in night work leading to greater social relations with fellow printers is the effect of
night work on family relations. As one printer pat it in an interview, "Night workers don't have to punch
the family time clock." Day workers, finishing work in the late after noon, are under pressure to rush home to
dinner and to conform to a time schedule set by their children or by plans for evening activities of the family.
For the day worker, the end of the day's work often means the end of relations with fellow workers unless
special arrangements are made to return or to stay over for a meeting later in the evening. Thus it requires an
added effort and inconvenience to see other printers after work-either missing a meal at home or leaving
again after supper.
    Night workers, on the other hand, finish work after their wives and families are asleep. Their schedule is
so completely in conflict with that of the children that they are not expected to conform as are day
workers. If a fellow worker suggests that a group go down to a local bar or go bowling or talk for a
while over coffee in a cafe, no one at home will object. Many night workers, in fact, have reported such a
pattern of afterwork activity. Similarly, the night worker can take his time going to work. Unlike the day
worker, who is usually rushed in rising, breakfasting, and reaching work on time, the night worker
customarily does not go to work for many hours after he has risen. He may and often does arrange to meet
his friends downtown before work. One worker who had spent most of his time on night work reported
having had a regular pattern through the summertime of meeting two printer friends in the early afternoon,
going to the baseball game together, and then coming to work together afterwards.
    Some of the data show that working nights does disrupt normal family schedules, making the printer freer to
 associate on his own. For example, we asked the men whether they visited other printers at home, and if so, how
 often. In accordance with the above pattern, we would expect that night workers, though they generally
 associate more with printers, do not visit them as often at home. That is, in this one area of association among printers,
 night workers should associate less than do day workers. Table 13 shows this to be true although the differences
 are small.10.
          Table-Recruitment of Members of Printers' and and Nonprinters' Clubs from day and night shifts

                                                            Members of
 Members of Printers'                                       Nonprinter
 Present Shift Clubs Only,                                   Groups Only,
         Days                         36                    61
         Nights                       64                    39
 Proportion of Career on Shift        55                    77
         Most on Doys
         Most on Nights               45                    23
           N                          (73)                  (155)

        Table 13-Effect of Night Work on Home
                                           Night         Day Workers
        Do you ever visit other            71%             76%
printers at their homes? Yes
N                                            (199)         (234)

   A third factor which seems to contribute to greater informal social relations among night workers is the
different pace of work on the night as compared with the day shift. In many printing plants, especially the middle-
sized book-and-job shops, the night shift is regarded by the men as an easier shift to work on. The pace of
work is more relaxed. Supervision is less strict. This easier pace of work may have two consequences. In many
shops there is no representative of management present except the night foreman, who is a fellow union member.
A number of printers indicated that absence of any management personnel on the premises serves to reduce
tension. A second factor present in the situation is the "abnormality" of night work itself. It is therefore more
difficult for a supervisor to press a night worker hard, given the fact that he is working during what are legitimately
sleeping hours.
   The greater freedom of night workers from normal industrial routines tends to facilitate socializing on the
job. In addition, the easier pace of night work may facilitate the development of interest in union affairs. Active
partisans find it easier to walk around the job discussing elections or union issues with night men than on days.

§ Conclusions
    THESE, THEN, are some of the factors within printing which seem to make for a high degree of social
relations among printers:
    I . Printers have been and are among the elite manual occupational groups in terms of social status. The
marginal (between manual and nonmanual or working-class and middle-class) status of printing seems to be one
factor which has been unique to printing all through its history and has been of major importance in
motivating printers to associate with one another.
    2. The craft aspect of printing gives printers a basic ground of com mon interest, which is probably not
the case in most other manual occupations.
    3. The union's substitute system operates to heighten interaction among printers, first through motivating printers to
show up for work every day, and second through the fact that a substitute's chances for employment are directly
related to the number of friends that he has among regular situation holders.
    4. Finally, the night work (and most printers work nights for at least part of their careers) tends to
increase printers' associations with each other. It reduces printers' opportunities to associ ate with
nonprinters or to take part in neighborhood activities and mass entertain ment; early in a man's career, it
habituates him to occupation-linked leisure activities and releases him from the pressure of regular family life.
    These four factors clearly do not exhaust the variables which could be considered possible determinants of
the printers' social community. We considered at least two others, but did not have the data necessary to test
them. We thought that the lack of status differentiation among the union's members and the possibility that
printers might be more skilled in organizational techniques than persons in other occupations might tend to
increase socialization among printers. Status differentiation within a union should operate to reduce the amount
of free interaction among all members of the union. Thus we would guess that pressmen's assistants, who
comprise a large minority of the membership of that union, do not mingle much socially with pressmen. In
the ITU, on the other hand, almost all members are of about equal status, skill, and salary,
 thus permitting the choice of friends among the entire membership. We would assume also that the higher
educational and cultural background of printers as compared with other manual workers means in part that
they will have more know-how on setting up and managing organizations. Neither of these hypotheses,
however, can be tested without comparative data from other occupations."
    A further determinant of printers' social relations is the nature of the ir work itself and the chances for
 informal relations at work. This factor will be discussed later, when we take up the impact of social
 relations within the shop on the union's political system.
    We also have not attempted to take up the factors which might make some printers more social than others
 but which are not unique to printers. For example, it is quite possible that those printers who associate with
 other printers have different personalities from those who do not.
     Gregarious printers, we find from our data, are, not surprisingly, more likely to associate with other
 printers than nongregarious ones. But there is no reason to expect that printers as a group are any different
 in their personality traits from followers of other occupations, nor that personality characteristics as such
 would help explain the high level of formal and informal social organization among printers.

   11. An indirect test of the latter is possible and was carried out: we found that, within printing, those with most
education and highest status background were disproportionately active in printers' clubs.

Shared By: