VIEWS: 958 PAGES: 293 CATEGORY: Operations POSTED ON: 2/6/2008 Public Domain
AICP EXAM REVIEW Quantitative Methods Pennsylvania Planning Association March 2004 Kurt Paulsen Temple University Kurt.Paulsen@temple.edu http://astro.temple.edu/~paulsenx Outline Sampling and Surveys Statistics Demographics and population analysis Economic analysis techniques Impact Analysis/Decision tools Cost-benefit analysis Fiscal impact analysis Sampling and Surveys Where have we come so far? In our data analysis so far this semester, we have assumed the data come from “good sources”, that is they are scientifically based, readily available, without error, etc. In reality, we need to peer behind the methods used to collect the data before we can really analyze the data. (metadata) And, often, we have to think about how to collect data ourselves Acknowledgements … Sources for this lecture: Babbie, E. 2004, The Practice of Social Research, 10th ed. Wadsworth/Thompson Learning. Chapters 7 (The Logic of Sampling) and ch. 9 (Survey Research). Lohr, S. 1999. Sampling: Design and Analysis. Duxbury Press. (more advanced mathematically) …and disclaimers… After this 3 hour lecture, you will know a lot about how surveys and samples are constructed, such that you can be an intelligent consumer of this type of research. However, you do not know enough to put together your own sample. You do not know what you do not know. Most likely, you would need further study or hire a professional polling organization. …more disclaimers Most university associated research, as well as some research funded by government and/or non-profit money requires “Institutional Review Board” and/or “Human Subjects Committee” approval of survey design and compliance with ethical research protocols before research begins. Check out the requirements before you begin conducting a survey. Sampling As we have been thinking all along in statistics and probability theory, we start with an interest in some parameter of a population. However, collecting data on the entire population is neither feasible nor necessary. Instead, we collect a sample, and calculate “sample statistics”. Recall that a sample statistic is simply an estimated population parameter. Research focuses on collecting a sample of observations to make inferences about a general population. Sampling The process in research of selecting observations is called “sampling.” The logic of probability theory can help us determine how to sample (random sampling) and how many to sample (calculate “margin of error”). Sampling Non-random sampling There are special cases where we would substitute non-random sampling for random/probability sampling. Purposive/judgemental sampling Snowball sampling Quota sampling “Surveys” and sampling A lot of what passes for “samples” or “surveys” these days is unscientific Reader/viewer/listener response Internet polling/voting “man on the street” The “non-survey” survey… Probability sampling Probability sampling is simply selecting samples based on probability theory. This is the only way that our sample results can be used to generalize to a larger population. Probability sampling is the primary method of selecting large, representative samples for social research. Conducted properly, probability sampling is the best method available for reducing potential bias in data collection. Probability sampling Roughly (according to Babbie), in order for a sample to provide a useful description of the total population, a sample of individuals must contain essentially the same variation(s) that exist in the population. Put another way, a sample should be representative. “Representativeness” No formal, scientific meaning. Should include those characteristics reasonably considered to be relevant to the interest of the study. Definitions Sampling frame: who is chosen to be surveyed/sampled. The “list” of units/elements composing a population from which a sample is selected. If a sample is to be representative, the sampling frame should include all (or nearly all) of the population. One begins with a list of elements (units of the population). Usually individuals, but could be households, etc. Probability Sampling The purpose, then, is to select a set of elements from a population in such a way that a description of those elements portray the total population. Probability theory then allows us to estimate the accuracy and representativeness of the sample. Probability theory and sample size Let‟s think back to our discussion of the Central Limit Theorem (a result which was important in our descriptive and inferential statistics). For sampling, if many independent, random samples could be selected from a population, the resulting sample statistics (technically: the “sampling distribution”) would be distributed around the “true” population parameter in some known way. Probability theory and sample size This knowledge of probability then allows us to estimate the “sampling error” – which is the degree of error which is expected….AS A FUNCTION OF SAMPLE SIZE. That crazy central limit theorem again…as sample size increases, what happens to the sampling error? Probability Sampling EPSEM (equal probability of selection method): A sample design in which each member of a population has the same chance of being selected into the sample. If EPSEM holds, then we can call the sample a “random” sample…or more technically, a probability sample Sampling Error and Sample Size Now for the moment you all have been waiting for…because you love the probability theory which keeps popping up…. Sampling error: The error expected in probability sampling…composed of three factors: Parameter Sample Size Standard error Sampling error Probability theory gives us a way to estimate how closely sample statistics will be dispersed around the “true” population parameter. s p q n S=sampling error, p and q are population parameters for the binomial, n=number of cases Sampling error The above discussion assumes, of course, that we know the population parameters…. But like everything else so far in this class, we actually don‟t know any of the population parameters. That‟s why we are conducting research!! So, we have to estimate them from samples. Confidence and significance Recall from our discussion on confidence levels that we can define a 95 percent confidence interval as p=0.95, with alpha = 0.05. Alpha=1-p, p=1-alpha. We can define either the significance level or the confidence level. They are mathematically identical. Different people use different methods, but be careful in your language. Back to…..CONFIDENCE INTERVALS! We begin by specifying a confidence level…sometimes we have called the confidence level as the opposite of the significance level. If we want to be 95 percent confident that our true population parameter falls within some interval, we construct a 95 percent confidence interval, or chose a 5 percent significance level. Significance levels Let‟s define the error which we will “tolerate” in our sample in terms of probability: P ( x e) 1 Or: P ( x e) p Where e is the “margin of error”, alpha is the significance level. Margin of error So in the “typical” 95 percent confidence level/5 percent significance level, we are looking at: P ( x e ) 0 . 95 We read this as telling us that, for a margin of error “e” we are 95 percent confident that the true population value mu is represented by the sample statistic x-bar Margin of error When you read a poll or survey in a report and are told the “margin of error”, you only know “e”. If they do not also tell you the “confidence level” you can assume it is at the 95 percent confidence level. Consider this report from the Philadelphia Inquirer about their poll on likely votes for Street/Katz in the mayor‟s race…..a good example of actually explaining to readers what the poll is! Philadelphia voters survey “This poll was conducted by Mason-Dixon Polling & Research, Inc. of Washington, D.C. from October 21 through October 23, 2003. A total of 800 registered city voters were interviewed by telephone. All stated they were likely to vote in the November general election.The margin for error, according to standards customarily used by statisticians, is no more than plus or minus 3.5 percentage points. This means that there is a 95 percent probability that the "true" figure would fall within that range if all voters were surveyed.The margin for error is higher for any subgroup, such as a racial or party grouping.” Philadelphia voters survey Lets look at those numbers more carefully…hinting toward our calculations. N=number surveyed, in this case is 800 95 percent confidence level Margin of error of +/- 3.5 points. How did they get these numbers? Philadelphia voters survey In this case, they use a well known result that, in large surveys, the margin of error is approximately equal to: 1 n This square root of n on the bottom shows up a lot in statistics!!!!! Philadelphia voters survey Since n=800, square root of n≈28.28. 1 divided by 28.28 is ≈ 0.035 But what if we wanted to be 99 percent confident??????? More on the “margin of error” The margin of error is, simply, the width of the confidence interval. For example, suppose I survey and find 50 percent indicate they will vote for a candidate. If the “margin of error is +/- 4 points, then the 95 percent confidence interval is [46,54]. That is, we are 95 percent confident that the true percentage of voters intending to vote for this candidate lies within a range from 46 to 54. Back to confidence intervals Do you remember the formula….Oh joy! P ( x z 2 n x z 2 n ) 1 Confidence intervals Lets make the formula above into a 95 percent confidence interval. (Anything here look familiar) P ( x z 2 n x z 2 n ) 0 . 95 Confidence intervals Lets substitute in what we already know P ( x 1 . 96 n x 1 . 96 n ) 0 . 95 Let’s rewrite this in terms of our “margin of error” idea (plus or minus) P ( x 1 . 96 n ) 0 . 95 Confidence intervals and margin of error Thus….by the “magic” of probability theory, the margin of error, e, is simply: e z 2 n e 1 . 96 n For 95 percent confidence Margin of error Given the formula above, you can: Figure our margin of error, given n Figure out required sample size, n, for a targeted margin of error e z 2 n z 2 n e 2 Margin of error But what about sigma??? A neat result of the central limit theorem: in large samples, the population variance (sigma squared) ≈ p(1-p) (or p x q) Now if we don‟t know p and q, we can place an upper bound on the variance….what is the highest it could be Margin of error What value of p maximizes the value p(1-p)? p=0.5!!....which leads to p(1-p)=0.25 So, putting it all together and substituting: e 1 . 96 0 . 25 n 1 n Margin of error Thus, in the most simple cases, the margin of error in a sample, with 95 percent confidence, is 1/square root of number of respondents. S A M P L E S IZ E M A R G IN O F E R R O R 10 0 .3 1 6 20 0 .2 2 4 30 0 .1 8 3 40 0 .1 5 8 50 0 .1 4 1 60 0 .1 2 9 70 0 .1 2 0 80 0 .1 1 2 90 0 .1 0 5 100 0 .1 0 0 150 0 .0 8 2 200 0 .0 7 1 250 0 .0 6 3 300 0 .0 5 8 400 0 .0 5 0 500 0 .0 4 5 600 0 .0 4 1 700 0 .0 3 8 800 0 .0 3 5 900 0 .0 3 3 1000 0 .0 3 2 1250 0 .0 2 8 1500 0 .0 2 6 1750 0 .0 2 4 2000 0 .0 2 2 3000 0 .0 1 8 4000 0 .0 1 6 5000 0 .0 1 4 D im inis hing R e turns to S a m p le S ize Inc re a s e s 0.350 0.300 0.250 M a rg in o f e rro r 0.200 0.150 0.100 0.050 0.000 0 500 1000 1500 2000 2500 S am p le S ize 3000 3500 4000 4500 5000 Sampling Once you have figured out the sample size you need to get the precision you want, you need to go about constructing your sample frame and chose your sampling method. You need to figure out Can I construct a list of all possible respondents Tradeoffs between cost, coverage, and precision Simple Random Sampling If you can make a complete list of your target population then you can use simple random sampling (SRS). SRS assigns a random number to each of the units in a population, and then uses random number generators to chose the appropriate number of respondents for analysis. Researchers until recently have avoided this procedure because it took a lot of time to look up random numbers in a book. Systematic sampling Every kth unit in a list is selected for inclusion in the sample. To be effective, there needs to be no systemic order in the list. Empirically, virtually identical to simple random sampling. Stratified Sampling “The grouping of units composing the population into homogeneous groups (strata) before sampling.” May be used in conjunction with simple random sampling, systematic, or cluster sampling. Improves representativeness, in terms of the stratification variables Stratified sampling Choice of stratification variables Depends on what is available Depends on what variables you think matter for responses, and which variables you are interested in In most socio-economic-demographic type research conducted by planners, obvious candidates are race, income, education, gender, location, etc. Stratified sampling Groups/strata need to have: within-group homogeneity between-group heterogeneity (Multistage) Cluster sampling “A multistage sampling in which natural groups (clusters) are sampled initially, with the members of each selected groups being subsampled afterwards.” Used when impractical to compile an exhaustive list A multistage process of listing and sampling, listing and sampling, listing and sampling… (Multistage) Cluster sampling Highly efficient, but tradeoff is in accuracy Subject to errors at each of the stages. For a given sample size, if the number of clusters increases, then the number of elements selected from each cluster decreases. General guidelines: maximize # of clusters while decreasing elements. Balance these guidelines with administrative and cost constraints. General guideline: Population researchers aim at selecting 5 households per census block. Probability Proportionate to Size Sampling PPS (Probability proportionate to size sampling) refers to multistage cluster samples in which clusters are selected, not with equal probabilities but with probabilities proportionate to their size. Disproportionate Sampling and Weighting You may want to sample certain subpopulations disproportionately, especially if you believe that subgroup numbers will be so small as to make statistical analysis difficult. Many national level surveys “oversample” minority households Overall analysis thus involves assigning weights to disproportionate observations. Sampling and surveys Sampling can be used for research design for almost any research question. For example, you can collect samples in various environmental and ecological fields. The use of sampling most common to planning would be selecting respondents to administer a survey. Surveys in planning “Survey before Plan” -- Geddes Survey techniques play important role in history of planning The “Booth Survey” of poverty in east London W.E.B.DuBois in Philadelphia Surveys in planning When we wish to find out something about the people/place for whom we are planning, and we don‟t have the data already available, we need to collect original data. We conduct surveys to: Understand important issues Identify public opinion Measure attitudes Justify, and cloak in the legitimacy of public participation what public officials have already decided ahead of time should occur Survey research In planning applications, much socioeconomic and demographic data is already widely available, both for analysis, and to serve as a baseline for survey research Surveys are most frequently used, then, to gauge public attitudes and public opinions around planning related issues. In the textbook world, you conduct a detailed survey before a comprehensive planning process. Surveys - process Begin with a definition of your research question – what do you want to know or find out? Operationalize your research questions with a questionnaire. Writing clear and coherent questions is crucial. Decide what type of quesitons to include. Pre-test your questionnaire Surveys - process Decide: Desirable margin of error, sample size Form of sampling Method of delivery Acceptable response rate Administer questionnaire Monitor Analyze Types of questions Open-ended. Questions for which the respondent is asked to provide his or her answers. Closed-ended. Questions in which the respondent is asked to select an answer from among a list provided by the researcher. A good survey should include both, although there are strengths and weaknesses to both. Closed-ended questions Easier to code for data analysis. Response categories must be: Exhaustive Mutually exclusive Open-ended questions Allows respondents to give their own answers May uncover relationships, and attitudes of which the researcher was unaware before the study Difficult to code and analyze Frequently, researchers will code openended questions for analysis. Writing questions Define terms e.g “We define working full time if you work more than 35 hours per week.”… Make items clear and concise as possible Use as neutral language as possible Avoid double-barreled questions Avoid negatives Keep each question to one concept More on survey design Respondents must be competent to answer. Surveys should be designed in such a way as to elicit truthful and honest answers. Make respondents comfortable to express views which may be considered socially undesirable and/or about subjects of personal matters. Assure confidentiality Avoid biased items and terms More on survey design Question order matters. When different people read your question, they should all basically understand the same meaning from the same wording. When different people respond to your question, the same answers should mean relatively the same thing. IMPORTANT PRETEST YOUR QUESTIONNAIRE!!! PRETEST YOUR QUESTIONNAIRE!!! PRETEST YOUR QUESTIONNAIRE!!! PRETEST YOUR QUESTIONNAIRE!!! PRETEST YOUR QUESTIONNAIRE!!! PRETEST YOUR QUESTIONNAIRE!!! Types of questionnaires Self-administered. Respondents themselves actually complete the questionnaire. The most common form is the mail-out, mail-back survey. Interviewer-administered. An interviewer asks questions of the respondents, and records respondent‟s answers. Face-to-face interview Telephone interview Relatively new: computer administered. Each type is subject to their own biases and response rates. Mail surveys Send letter of introduction, survey and method to mail in to researcher. Provide mechanism for reminder card, and follow up to improve response rate. 3 mailings seems most efficient. 2-3 weeks intervals between mailings. Response rate Whenever you are reporting a survey, you should ALWAYS include your response rate. The response rate is the number of people who respond to a survey divided by the number selected to be in the sample. What is adequate? Babbie‟s rules of thumb 50%= adequate, 60%= good, 70%= very good I think he‟s being a little optimistic. However, for surveys being conducted with outside funding sources, there may be standards for response rates. The federal government has some standards which require 80-85 percent response rate in surveys. Face to face interviews Higher response rates, but most costly. Some national level surveys use trained face to face interviewers. Telephone interviews Random digit dialing on computers reduces the biases of unlisted numbers. Increasing public frustration with fake surveys leads to increasing refusal rates. Safer and cheaper than face to face interviews. Strengths and weaknesses of surveys Strengths: Surveys make large samples possible Surveys can measure public attitudes and perceptions Standardization allows statistical analysis Surveys are widely used in America Weaknesses Standardized questionnaires can be superficial and complex, cater to lowest common denominator. Ignores social context of life, can be artificial Subject to a number of potential biases. While good survey design can reduce potential biases, you cannot completely eliminate all potential biases. Potential biases in surveys Selection bias: Some portion of targeted population is not in sample Non-response bias: Does the distribution of characteristics of non-respondents equal that of respondents? When the measuring instrument or survey design systematically over or under estimates. Measurement bias: Potential biases in surveys People: Misrepresent facts, overstate income, etc. Don‟t remember Understand different words to mean different things Are confused Don‟t want to give a socially undesirable answer Potential biases in samples Hypothetical choice bias: Respondents are asked for a response of what they would or would like to do, without having to actually chose. Survey respondents frequently say that they would like more services and lower taxes…. Utilizing national surveys There are a number of nationwide, well designed surveys which may be of interest and use in planning and research. The caution is: although they are representative of the nation as a whole, there may not be a sufficient sample size to generalize about your town/city/county/region. National surveys of interest to planners American Housing Survey. http://www.census.gov/hhes/www/ahs.html American Community Survey. http://www.census.gov/acs/www/ http://www.bls.census.gov/cps/cpsmain.htm http://www.bts.gov/nhts Current Population Survey. National household travel survey Statistics The foundation of statistics is probability. May be helpful to review some probability theory. The Probability of an event is the the relative likelihood or relative frequency of an event, defined over a sample space of all possible outcomes. A “random variable” is a variable whose values occur at random, that is from random draws of a probability distribution. Random doesn‟t mean that values can‟t be known or predicted. Variables are things such as age, income, etc. Random simply means they come from some underlying probability distribution. Statistics on the AICP exam Most often, it is knowing which test or which procedure to use when. Occasionally, some of the less well known statistical tests are thrown in as wrong answers to distract you. Half of the battle is just learning the terms, and recognizing the right situation to use which statistic Statistics/Probability help on the web http://davidmlane.com/hyperstat/index.html http://www.tufts.edu/%7Egdallal/LHSP.HTM http://espse.ed.psu.edu/statistics/Investigating.htm http://trochim.human.cornell.edu/ http://bmj.bmjjournals.com/statsbk/ http://www2.sjsu.edu/faculty/gerstman/StatPrimer/ http://www.businessbookmall.com/free-stuff-statistics.htm http://www.stats.gla.ac.uk/steps/glossary/presenting_data.ht ml Probability distributions Generally, is a plot of the probabilities with the values on the horizontal (x) axis and the associated probabilities on the vertical (y) axis. Probability distributions can be: Discrete: Only take on a countable number of values (examples: Binomial, Poisson) Continuous: probabilities are assigned a range of continuous values (examples: normal, Student‟s t, Chi-squared, F). Binomial Distribution, p=0.5, n=20 Normal curve, mean=0, sigma=0.5 Normal curve, mean=0, sigma=1 As you increase the standard deviation, the distribution becomes more spread out. 0.45 0.40 0.35 0.30 0.25 0.20 0.15 0.10 0.05 0.00 -5 -4 -3 -2 -1 0 1 2 3 4 4 5 5 Probability and Statistics Why waste all this time with probability? Because “statistics” are merely estimated parameters of probability distributions. Statistics, then, are ways of summarizing the information in a probability distribution or a random variable. Two main types of statistics Descriptive Inferential Descriptive Statistics A descriptive statistic is any summary of the values of a set of data (variable) or a sample. That is, they are calculated as ways to “describe” or “summarize” your data. 4 main types 1. Percentiles and quartiles 2. Measures of Central Tendency 3. Measures of Dispersion or Variability 4. Measures of distribution shape. Descriptive Statistics 1. Percentiles and quartiles. The p-th percentile is the value of a given distribution such that p-percent of the distribution is less than or equal to that value. Pr(X x) p Most commonly used are the 25th percentile (1st quartile) and the 75th percentile (3rd quartile) The 50th percentile has more common name: the MEDIAN Descriptive Statistics 2. Measures of Central Tendency (how “centered” is your distribution). Most common is the MEAN, also called the “AVERAGE.” Sometimes written as x To derive the mean, add up all values and divide by number of values. x x1 x 2 x 3 ... x n n or x x i 1 n i n Descriptive Statistics MODE is simply the most frequently occurring value. (the tallest bar on a histogram). Descriptive Statistics 3. Measures of Dispersion or Variability (how spread out your distribution is) IQR (inter-quartile range): the range between the 25th percentile and the 75th perecentile Standard Deviation and Variance Variance = Standard deviation squared Standard deviation = square root of variance Variance = σ2; standard deviation = σ Variance No, not that much abused land use phenomena from the ZHB, but a measure of how spread out the data is around the mean: s 2 (x n 1 i 1 1 n i x) 2 This is the “sample variance”. The “population variance has n instead of n-1 Calculate the standard deviation by hand? Suppose stuck on a desert island or in an AICP or a GRE exam. Although rare, a standard deviation question has come up. Remember, since its multiple choice, only approximate the standard deviation. Make 3 columns by hand. Column 1 is the numbers, column 2 is deviations and column 3 is “squareds.” 1.calculate the mean (add all together and divide by n) 2.subtract each number from the mean N u m b e rs D e v ia tio n fro m M e a n 2 6 8 4 5 <==M ean 3. Square each deviation 4. Sum up the deviations 5. Take value from Step 4 and divide by (n-1). S q u a re d -3 1 3 -1 9 1 9 1 20 Sum ==> s 20 /( n 1) 20 / 3 6 . 67 2 Coefficient of Variation Standard deviation divided by the mean (a mean-standardized standard deviation) CV Inferential Statistics These are statistics which allow us to draw conclusions about the data or to test hypotheses. Generally in the framework: Confidence intervals Hypothesis Testing Confidence Intervals Because our observations and samples are “random” variables, there is always the possibility that that value we calculate (e.g. the mean) is not actually true, but a fluke. We can use probability theory to establish how confident we are (confidence level) that the true value lies within a specified range (confidence interval). Most common is a 95 percent confidence interval. This means that if we were to take 100 samples (instead of 1) we would be confident that 95 out of those 100 times, our sample average would capture the “true” population mean. Confidence Intervals Key point: Confidence intervals are SAMPLE SIZE DEPENDENT. As the sample size increases, the interval in which we are ppercent confident (e.g. 95 percent confident) gets thinner and thinner. I can‟t imagine the AICP exam would ask you to calculate a confidence interval, so I won‟t bother with the formula. Hypothesis Testing We formulate and test hypotheses about the data. 1 sample hypothesis testing. Most common is to ask, does this variable equal some value. E.g. We hypothesize that the value of the mean I.Q. of practicing planners is 120 2 sample hypothesis testing. We want to compare two samples or two variables. (Can be that the two values are equal or that one is higher). E.g. We hypothesize that the mean I.Q. of practicing planners is not equal to the mean I.Q. of local township supervisors. Or, we hypothesize that the average income of town X is greater than the average income of town Y. Hypothesis testing 4 elements in all hypothesis testing 1. Formulate “null hypothesis” H0 2. Forumulate “alternative hypothesis” Ha 3. Identify correct test statistic This is 90 percent of the difficulty 4. Identify rejection region. 5. Calculate test statistic 6. Compare to rejection region. Either: Reject the Null and accept the Alternative Accept the Null or “fail to reject the null” Choosing the right test statistic If the null hypothesis is true, how is the test statistic distributed (from what probability distribution does the test statistic come) There are, most commonly, only 4 types of test statistics. The names of the test statistics come from the probability distribution of the test statistic. The confusion comes in that some of the test statistics have people‟s names associated with them, and different disciplines call them different names. E.g. The Pearson Chi-Squared Test. Sometimes people simply call this “The Chi-squared test.” But there are lots of “Chisquared tests.” Any test statistic which is distributed as a “chisquared” probability function is a “chi-squared test”! Test statistics 1. Z-test. When the test statistic is distributed as a STANDARD NORMAL. You only use this when you already know the population standard deviation (that is, you don‟t estimate the standard deviation from the sample). Rarely used except in statistics classes as an illustration. Test statistics 2. t-test. When the test statistic is distributed as a STUDENTS‟ t-distribution. Used for 1 sample tests of hypothesis that estimated parameter takes on certain values. Mostly used to test regarding an estimated mean or a regression coefficient. Examples: Is the mean housing price in Upper Pothole township = $167,000. Is the mean income in Lower Podunk township >$50,000 Is the estimated regression coefficient = 0. We generally test all regression coefficients with H0 that = 0. This is also called a “statistical significance” or more precisely a test that the estimated coefficient is statistically significantly different from zero. T-test continued Used in 2 sample means test. (sometimes called the “comparison of means test”). The question being asked is whether data drawn from two samples shows statistically significant differences. Examples: Ho: Mean income Bucks = Mean income Chester Ho: Mean income „burbs > mean income city. Interruption:Types of variables The t-test and z-test are used on continuous variables (variables that can take on a continuous range of values.) What about variables which are CATEGORICAL. That is, they take on values according to certain categories. Examples: marital status, region, educational attainment, what type of car do you drive, responses to most survey questions. Interruption:Types of variables Categorical data can be of two types: 1. Ordinal: the categories can be placed in an ordered relationship. E.g. Educational attainment: no college, some college, college, graduate school. Likert-scales on surveys. "strongly agree", "somewhat agree" "neither agree nor disagree”, “somewhat disagree”, “strongly disagree.” 2. Nominal (Non-ordinal). No logical ordered relationship. E.g. What region you live in (Northeast, South, etc.) What type of car you drive (Ford, Hyundai, Toyota, GM) Test statistics 3. Chi-squared tests. The most commonly used in hypothesis testing is the Pearson Chi-squared test, commonly called simply a chi-squared test. First, we summarize two categorical variables through a “cross-tabulation table,” also called a “pivot table” or a “contingency table”. You then test whether there is a relationship between these two variables. The null hypothesis is no relationship or “independence” E.g. Is there a (statistical)relationship between region and educational attainment Is there a relationship between perceptions of environmental quality and car-type ownership Test statistics F-test. (not used often, unlikely to be on the AICP exam.) When the test statistic is distributed as an F-distribution. When the test compares if the VARIANCES of two samples are equal. Used in ANOVA tests of proportion of variance.\ Used in regression as a joint test that all the coefficients are statistically significant. Testing relationships Frequently, we want to test the relationship between two variables. Most common is CORRELATION. That is, do the two variables MOVE IN THE SAME DIRECTION. Positive correlation. As one variable increases, the other increases Negative correlation. As one variable increases, the other decreases. Correlation Correlation measures the strength of the relationship between two variables. Technically: it measures the linear relationship between two variables. The most common measure of correlation is the Pearson Correlation Coefficient, usually simply called “correlation” or given by the letter “r”. It ranges from –1 (negative correlation) to 0 (no correlation) to +1 (positive correlation.) The closer the absolute value of the correlation coefficient is to 1, the stronger the correlation. The correlation coefficient does not depend on the units in which the variables are measured Correlation Most statistical packages and Excel can calculate a correlation coefficient. Usually, a “p-value” is also reported. Like hypothesis testing, a low p-value (less than 0.05) indicates statistical significance. Thus the correlation coefficient can test a) is there a linear correlation and b) the strength of that correlation Another correlation coefficient sometimes seen is called “Spearman‟s” or “Spearman‟s Rank Correlation” or simply “Rank correlation.” It is a “nonparametric” test. (Does not assume any “parametric” structure) Tests of association and measures of association A large branch of statistics, common in psychology, sociology and some biostatistics is based on testing the association between different types of variables and measuring the strength of that association. These measures are particularly used in various forms of categoric data, depending on their structure. I include them here only based on the idea that they may appear on the exam as false leads Tests of association Tests of association simply measure whether the variables are statistically related. The Pearson chi-squared test from earlier is the most common TEST of association. It does not measure the STRENGTH of association. Other tests of association: Continuityadjusted Chi-squared; Likelihood-Ratio Chisquared Measures of Association Statistics which show the direction and/or magnitude of relationships between pairs of non-continuous (discrete) variables. I doubt the AICP exam will require you to know which ones are for ordinal and which ones for nominal data, so I just list them here for purposes of acquaintance. Recall that CORRELATION is the most common MEASURE of association Measures of Association Yule‟s Q Phi Gamma (also called Goodman-Kruskal Gamma) Cramer‟s V Tau-b (also called Kendal‟s tau-b) Tau-c (also called Stuart‟s tau-c) Somer‟s d Other “obscure” tests/statistics The following are also test statistics which are either highly specialized to particular applications/fields, or are “non-parametric) and thus would only show up as false answers. Durbin-Watson test, Wald test, Likelihood ratio test, Moran‟s I, Wilcoxson signed rank test, Bonferroni correction, mean squared error (MSE), mean absolute deviation (MAD), Mann-Whitney test, Fisher‟s exact, Kaplan-Meier, Breinich-Slusser, Breslow-Gehan Regression There are a virtually limitless number of different “types” of regression such that the term itself is quite vague. Often, though, when people say “regression” they simply mean “linear regression” Linear regression is, informally, a line fitted between two (or more) variables to estimate the linear relationship between the two variables. The line is “fit” according to best criteria such that it is a “best fit.” The most common criteria is to minimize the sum of squared errors. 2 5 0 ,0 0 0 2 0 0 ,0 0 0 y = 4 7 8 1 .9 + 6 1 .3 6 7 x 1 5 0 ,0 0 0 P R IC E 1 0 0 ,0 0 0 5 0 ,0 0 0 500 1 ,0 0 0 1 ,5 0 0 2 ,0 0 0 2 ,5 0 0 3 ,0 0 0 3 ,5 0 0 4 ,0 0 0 SQUARE FEET Regression In a regression analysis, we try to “explain” the variation in a DEPENDENT variable with a number of INDEPENDENT variables. These variables are known by different names: DEPENDENT = OUTCOME = LEFT HAND SIDE variable INDEPENDENT = PREDICTOR = RIGHT HAND SIDE variable Regression A regression equation simply looks like this: y 0 1 x1 2 x 2 3 x 3 ... k x k DEPENDENT VARIABLE COEFFICIENTS INDEPENDENT/PREDICTOR VARIABLES ERROR TERM Regression Overly general approach: Is the DEPENDENT variable continuous? YES=proceed with standard regression (OLS) NO=must utilize another form of regression. If Dependent variable is a (0,1) variable use Probit or Logit If Dependent variable is count data, use Poisson regression Perform standard linear regression (OLS) Utilize diagnostic tests to see if: Regression assumptions are violated If violated, perform various corrections Regression Regression Output: 1. Measures of regression‟s “significance” 2. Measures of regression‟s “goodness of fit.” 3. Estimated coefficients and associated “standard errors” 4. Predicted values and residuals EXAMPLE REGRESSION OUTPUT FROM EXCEL DEPENDENT VARIABLE = PRICE S U M M AR Y O U T P U T R e g re s s io n S ta tis tic s M u ltip le R 0 .8 6 8 2 R S q u a re 0 .7 5 3 8 Ad ju s te d R S q u a re 0 .7 4 5 0 S ta n d a rd E rro r 1 9 2 1 2 .5 3 8 5 O b s e rv a tio n s 117 AN O V A df R e g re s s io n R e s id u a l T o ta l 4 112 116 C o e ffic ie n ts 1 5 1 0 1 .4 1 5 2 .5 4 -3 9 8 .5 2 2 0 3 4 .8 9 1 4 5 0 6 .0 0 SS MS 126547844717 31636961179 4 1 3 4 1 6 2 3 1 4 6 3 6 9 1 2 1 6 3 5 .2 167889467863 S ta n d a rd E rro r 7 6 2 5 .9 4 4 .2 2 1 5 8 .4 8 1 4 0 1 .0 0 4 9 4 8 .0 4 t S ta t 1 .9 8 1 2 .4 6 -2 .5 1 1 .4 5 2 .9 3 F S ig n ific a n c e F 8 5 .7 0 8 7 6 9 5 7 0 .0 0 MEASURES OF GOODNESS OF FIT Regression Significance In te rc e p t S q u a re F e e t Ag e F e a tu re s C o rn e rL o t P -v a lu e 0 .0 5 0 .0 0 0 .0 1 0 .1 5 0 .0 0 Low er 95% -8 .4 0 4 4 .1 9 -7 1 2 .5 4 -7 4 1 .0 2 4 7 0 2 .0 9 U pper 95% 3 0 2 1 1 .2 2 6 0 .9 0 -8 4 .5 1 4 8 1 0 .8 0 2 4 3 0 9 .9 1 Coefficients and Standard Errors Output 1. Regression Significance. An F-test is performed of the null hypothesis that all the coefficients are zero (insignificant.) Higher F-test statistics imply greater degrees of overall regression significance. The significance of F, also called its p-value should be less than 0.05. A very low F or a significance greater than 0.05 implies a very poor regression. AN O V A df R e g re s s io n R e s id u a l T o ta l 4 112 116 SS MS 126547844717 31636961179 4 1 3 4 1 6 2 3 1 4 6 3 6 9 1 2 1 6 3 5 .2 167889467863 F S ig n ific a n c e F 8 5 .7 0 8 7 6 9 5 7 0 .0 0 Output 2. “goodness of fit.” The most commonly accepted goodness of fit measure is R-squared, sometimes called the “coefficient of determination.” It measures the proportion of variation in the DEPENDENT variable explained by a linear-combination of the INDEPENDENT variables. As such, it measures how good your regression has “explained” the DEPENDENT variable. Adjusted R squared adjusts for the number of independent variables. R e g re s s io n S ta tis tic s M u ltip le R 0 .8 6 8 2 R S q u a re 0 .7 5 3 8 A d ju s te d R S q u a re 0 .7 4 5 0 S ta n d a rd E rro r 1 9 2 1 2 .5 3 8 5 O b s e rv a tio n s 117 My regression has “explained” about 75 percent of the variation of house prices in my sample. Regression output Estimated coefficients and associated standard errors. Interpretation of coefficients: How much change (on average, measured in the UNITS of the DEPENDENT variable) in the DEPENDENT variable would be associated with a 1-unit increase in THIS INDEPENDENT variable, holding all else constant. Standard errors are then used to generate t-tests of the null hypothesis that THIS coefficient is zero. If you reject the null hypothesis that this coefficient is zero, you conclude that this coefficient is “significant” or more precisely “statistically significantly” Output 3. Determine which coefficients are statistically significant. If p-value < 0.05, then the coefficient is significant. Significant coefficients are highlighted. In te rc e p t S q u a re F e e t Age F e a tu re s C o rn e rL o t C o e ffic ie n ts 1 5 1 0 1 .4 1 5 2 .5 4 -3 9 8 .5 2 2 0 3 4 .8 9 1 4 5 0 6 .0 0 S ta n d a rd E rro r 7 6 2 5 .9 4 4 .2 2 1 5 8 .4 8 1 4 0 1 .0 0 4 9 4 8 .0 4 t S ta t 1 .9 8 1 2 .4 6 -2 .5 1 1 .4 5 2 .9 3 P -v a lu e 0 .0 5 0 .0 0 0 .0 1 0 .1 5 0 .0 0 Step 2. Interpret significant coefficients. Example: Holding all else constant, a 1 unit increase in square feet (in this case, a 1-square foot increase in house size) is associated with a $52.54 increase in house price. A corner lot commands a $14506 premium. Define research, formulate hypotheses Gather data / collect sample Descriptive Statistics 1. Percentiles, Inferential Statistics Confidence Intervals Measures of Association quartiles,median 2. Central tendency (mean, mode) 3. Dispersion (variance, standard deviation, coefficient of variation) Correlation Hypothesis tests For categorical variables: Phi, Kramer’s V etc. 1 sample? 2 samples? Test about mean: t-test Test about variance: χ2 test Continuous? Categorical? Test about means: t-test Test about variances: F-test Pearson χ2 test REGRESSION Demographic methods Catching Up from Statistics How many planning methods professors does it take to screw in a light bulb? Answer: 3.26 +/- 1.43, with 95 percent confidence. Demography The scientific study of human populations, primarily with respect to their size, structure and development For planners, we would want to include location Demography and planning PA MPC Article III, Sec. 301.2 “In preparing the comprehensive plan, the planning agency shall make careful…analyses of housing, demographic, and economic characteristics and trends.” Demography To demographers, you only do a few interesting things in your life (undergo a “demographic event” Be born Give birth Move Die The rest is details, I guess… Demography This gives rise to the 3 major components of demographic analysis: Fertility Mortality Migration Demography Each of these components can be modeled as complexly or simply as needed. Simple e.g.: Calculate “crude” rates Complex: disaggregated regression model of migration decisions by age, race, sex, education, and economic structure Demography - components What influences fertility? Age Education Economic status Rates and timing of marriage/cohabitation Religion …and many others Demography - components What influences mortality? Age Gender Income/Socio-economic status Genetics Behavior Access to health care….. ….and of course many more Demography - components What influences migration/immigration? Age Economic structure/opportunities Public policies Quality of life, cost of living Climate ….and many more of course! Demography - components You probably noticed that age plays a significant role in all three components. Demography frequently employs lifecylcle/temporal models. People‟s probability of giving birth, dying, migrating, etc. exhibit clear age effects. Demography An important way demographers model “age” is to group all those with a similar age into a “cohort.” Demography Three basic types of demographic analysis used by planners Descriptive – tools, data, and methods to describe the population of an area Trends analysis – look at how demographic data has changed over time Projections – estimates of future population and population structure Descriptive Demography You can access/acquire demographic data for a place from a number of sources: PASDC http://pasdc.hbg.psu.edu http://www.census.gov Census Private vendors Descriptive Demography After acquiring data for a place, you can calculate all of the descriptive statistics we learned earlier in the course, and use the statistics to tell a story about a place Descriptive demography Demographic-specific methods Age-Sex pyramids Dependency ratio = children + seniors divided by total working age population Or: non-working population divided by working population Some researchers specify under 15 + over 65 as “dependent” Age-sex pyramids Age-sex pyramids are graphic representations of the age and sex distribution of a population. The show the percentage of a population for each sex by age category/cohort. Typically they present data in 5 year bins, although this is dependent on your data. Bin data – a note A lot of demographic data we have is not individual data, but rather counts of the number of people who fall into a certain category. Travel time (25 to 29 minutes) Age (birth to 4, 5 to 9 …) Some of our descriptive statistics have biases when used on bin data Bin data – descriptive statistics Consider calculating the mean travel time for an area based on knowing the number of people who fall into each category of time intervals. How do we do it? To perform calculations, we have to make assumptions about the distribution of data within the bin. Consider this travel time bin: 339 people in Richland Twp, Bucks Co., travel between 25 and 29 minutes to work 339 people? 25 27 29 OR? 67.8 people 25 26 27 28 29 Bin data How do our two options differ in contributions to overall average and standard deviation calculations? Recall the formula for an average: x x1 x 2 x 3 ... x n n Option 1 = 339*27 =9153 Option 2 = 67.8*25+67.8*26+…67.8*29 = 9153 Bin data So, in this example, these two options are equivalent in their effects on the overall mean…. But what about the standard deviation? Ok, but what if, instead the real data looked like this: Non-symmetric distribution within a bin 300 people 39 people 25 27 25.8*300+28.1*39=8835.9 25.8 28.1 29 Bin data What are we left with? We have to make assumptions about the distribution of data within bins, but we have no a priori way to determining which is “best”, and with the understanding that our output is dependent on our assumptions. Bin data strategy State your assumptions clearly Easiest solution is to assume all members of the bin share the mid-point value. If exact results are important enough, calculate at least 3 ways and present all 3 results (sensitivity analysis) You could chose all lower values and then all upper values for upper and lower “bounds” Don‟t believe standard deviation calculations from bin data! Back to age-sex pyramids Age-sex pyramids provide a visual representation of population structure. Consider the following three national level pyramids from the U.S., Bangladesh and Germany. Age-Sex Pyramids You can also produce pyramids for population forecasts, to show the underlying demographic structure. Constructing an Age-Sex Pyramid See Excel Spread Sheet…Population Example.xls on class server Step 1. Download age-sex data from the Census Bureau website or other data server. (factfinder.census.gov) Find variable P12 (Census 2000): Sex by age (total population) If you wanted to, you could find sex by age for different racial/ethnic groups Age-Sex Pyramids Step 2. Unzip downloaded data, and transpose data into columns. Step 3. Clean data such that it is 5-year age bins with consistent labels. Step 4. Multiply Males by –1 (so on left side of pyramid) Paste in format appropriate to Chart Wizard Make stacked Bar Chart. (second option on bar chart chart wizard) Special Excel Trick Reformat Axis to eliminate negative numbers. Double click on bottom axis, chose “number” tab, chose custom, in box type: 0;0 Click Ok. A g e -S e x P yra m id , L o w e r M a c u n g ie T o w n s h ip , L e h ig h C o u n ty, P A -- 2 0 0 0 M A LE S 85 plus 80 to 84 75 to 79 70 to 74 65 to 69 60 to 64 55 to 59 50 to 54 45 to 49 40 to 44 35 to 39 30 to 34 25 to 29 20 to 24 15 to 19 10 to 14 5 to 9 0 to 4 1000 800 600 400 200 0 200 400 600 800 1000 1200 F E M A LE S Population Example Calculate Male/Female ratio, overall and for each age category. Graph this to show general trends. Calculate overall dependency ratio. (For example = 0.532) This means there are 53 dependents for every working-aged person. M A L E /F E M A L E R A T IO B Y A G E , L O W E R M A C U N G IE T O W N S H IP , L E H IG H C O U N T Y P A , 2 0 0 0 1 .2 1 .1 1 M ale/Fem ale R atio 0 .9 0 .8 0 .7 0 .6 0 .5 0 .4 0 to 4 5 to 9 1 0 to 14 1 5 to 19 2 0 to 24 2 5 to 29 3 0 to 34 3 5 to 39 4 0 to 44 4 5 to 49 5 0 to 54 5 5 to 59 6 0 to 64 6 5 to 69 7 0 to 74 7 5 to 79 8 0 to 84 85 p lu s A g e C a te o g y 0 .4 1 0 .5 0 .6 0 .7 0 .8 0 .9 1 .1 0 to 4 9 to 5 10 to 14 17 19 ar s s ar 24 29 34 39 44 49 54 59 61 to 65 67 70 75 80 85 an to to to to to d 64 66 69 74 79 84 ov er to to ye ye to to to to to to to to to 15 18 20 21 22 25 30 35 40 45 50 55 60 62 M A L E /F E M A L E R A T IO , U N IT E D S T A T E S , 2 0 0 0 C E N S U S Demography – trend analysis Often, an analysis and visual presentations of the demographic trends in a community can tell a story and highlight significant planning issues. Recommended: Tufte, The Visual Display of Quantitative Information The Planner‟s Use of Information Trends – quantitative analysis One of the more common simple quantitative analyses of past trends is to calculate “rates of change” (works not just in demography) Rate formula: r X t 1 X t Xt Calculating Rates The population of a census tract in Montgomery County grew from: 1990 population: 2371 2000 population: 3353 r 3353 2371 2371 0 . 4142 We read this as saying the population growth rate from 1990 to 2000 was 41.42 percent Growth rates example If the growth rate from 1990 to 2000 was 41.42 percent, what was the average annual growth rate? If you said 41.42 / 10 = 4.142 percent per year, that would be….WRONG – but a common mistake Why? COMPOUNDING!!! Rates of growth (and decline) Additional information is presented in the Word document: “Growth Rates and Decline Rates.doc” So…. This is the formula Vn g V 0 1 t 1 So what is the average annual growth rate of population for this Montgomery Census Tract? 1 10 3353 g 2371 1 0 . 03526 We read this as a 3.526 percent average annual growth rate. Growth rates Calculated growth rates can be used for: Estimating population between two censuses Projecting population based on constant growth rate assumption Final word on growth rates If r is the rate of population growth, then a population will double in ln(2)/r years! Population Projections and Forecasts Clarify some definitions, keeping consistency with Census Bureau: Estimate: indirect measurement of population for the past, between Censuses, based on births, deaths and migration figures. Released for July 1st of previous year Projections: estimates of population for future years. Population Projections Two basic types Top-down Applying constant rates Curve-fitting/extrapolation techniques Bottom-up Cohort-component model Distributed housing unit method There are also regression models, not covered in this class Top down projections Constant rate projections: 1. Calculate average annual growth rate, using most recent data. (e.g. 1990-2000). 2. Apply growth rate to future years. Incidentally, this is also called a “geometric” curve Top-down projections Constant increment projections: 1. Calculate total number of people added per year. 2. Apply constant increment to future years. Also called “linear” curve Curve-fitting/extrapolation Idea is relatively straightforward: 1.Plot the data In this case, population from previous time periods 2. Fit a curve to the data Made easier in Excel with “insert trendline” 3. Derive the equation of the fitted curve 4. Use the equation to calculate future values. Curve-fitting/extrapolation Step 1. Plot the data. U S P o p u la tio n 300 250 P e rs o n s (m illio n s ) 200 150 100 50 0 1790 1810 1830 1850 1870 1890 1910 1930 1950 1970 1990 2010 Year Curve-fitting Step 2. Fit a curve. Types of Curves:The most commonly used curves in population analysis are: Linear, geometric, exponential, modified exponential, polynomial, logarithmic, logistic, and Gompertz. The number of possible curves is virtually limitless! Curves 1. Linear y a bx a=intercept, b=slope Curves 2. Geometric y ab x We can do a logarithmic transformation to get: ln y ln a x ln b Curves 3. Polynomial Called a 2nd degree polynomial because highest exponent is 2 2 y a bx cx 2 3 Can create an n-th degree polynomial: y a bx cx dx ex ... x 4 n Curves 4. Exponential y ae bx 5. Modified Exponential y c ab x Curves 6. Gompertz y ca b x Curves 7. Logistic y 1 c ab x Fitting curves to data See examples on Population Projections.xls Worksheet: “fittingcurves” with population data from US. Graph data Fit curve Get equation Extrapolate Bottom-up projections The most commonly used in planning is the “cohort-component” method Cohort=age group Component=the three components of demography (fertility, mortality, migration) The Master Demographic Equation Put all three components together: POP t 1 POP t Births Deaths Inmigratio n Outmigrati on Cohort Component Technique Step 1. Get age-sex data Step 2. Acquire “vital records” data Birth rates Death rates Step 3. Calculate survival rates. Step 4. “Age the survivors” – move to next bin for next period Step 5. Calculate births Cohort Component Technique 6. Allocate births to males/females 7. Project Population 8. Model migration as residual. Cohort Component Technique Two files for utilization, with different techniques of handling migration. Cohort_Component_Example.xls NEW AND IMPROVED COHORT COMPONENT MODEL.xls Basic techniques of regional economic analysis Topics Covered Using employment data to provide a snapshot “story” of your regional economy Economic Base Multipliers Location Quotients Shift-Share Analysis Input-Output Employment Data Most techniques of analyzing a regional economy look at employment data Main national sources County Business Patterns (Census) BEA-REIS (Commerce) Bureau of Labor Statistics (CEW-ES202) Data includes both number of jobs and average wages earned Most data is at county level. Employment data at municipal level is highly problematic. Example from Lehigh County, Pennsylvania First slide: NAICS data from County Business Patterns Second slide: Data extracted from Bureau of Economic Analysis Regional Economic Information System REIS utilizes older SIC codes Lehigh County Employment, by NAICS Industry (2000) Health care and social assistance Manufacturing Retail trade Admin, support, waste mgt, remediation services Accommodation & food services Management of companies & enterprises Wholesale trade Other services (except public administration) Finance & insurance Construction Educational services Professional, scientific & technical services Transportation & warehousing Information Auxiliaries (exc corporate, subsidiary & regional mgt) Utilities Real estate & rental & leasing Arts, entertainment & recreation 0 5 10 15 20 25 30 Thousands Lehigh County Employment, by SIC Industry (2000) Government and government enterprises Services Finance, insurance, and real estate Retail trade Wholesale trade Transportation and public utilities Manufacturing Construction 0 10 20 30 40 50 60 70 80 Thousands Comparing data sources Note the large component of “service” sector employment in the 1-digit SIC aggregations. Which method better characterizes this regional economy, NAICS or SIC data? Data Problems in analyzing economic change Looking particularly at online sources Official shift for statistics from the SIC system to the NAICS system Problem is comparability of older data “Bridge files” are provided but they are complex and tedious BEA-REIS provides historical through 2000 data at only 1-digit SIC code Data problems (cont) New Jersey State Data center provides historical employment data using SIC codes in a difficult to use text forma Pennsylvania Dept. of Labor and Industry‟s website only provides data back to 1998 BLS Covered Employment Wage data only based on NAICS from 1997 to present County Business Patterns was based on SIC (through 1997) now is based on NAICS Data problems (cont) County Business Patterns has downloadable files going back to 1988 under 2-digit SIC categories Always make sure you know the source of your data and whether it is seasonally adjusted Economic Base theory and regional economic growth Economic “base” techniques divide regional industries into two groups Basic or export sectors Non-basic or local sectors Assumes that export or base industries drive regional economic growth Relatively simple to calculate, generates straightforward impact and prediction tools Economic base theory Rationale: exports from a region represent competitive or comparative advantages in technology or cost Export industries drive regional growth through multiplier effects, backward and forward “linkages” Emphasizes the “open” quality of small regional economies Economic base theory Many criticisms and problems Non-spatial: as the size of the region studied grows relative to the national economy, the economic base declines Ignores factor mobility, migration Makes pretty strong assumptions about which industries are export oriented Misrepresents services, technology Demand-side driven model of economics Economic base approaches Many limitations, but widely used Relatively simple to use and understand Three main approaches we will study Location Quotients Shift-Share Analysis Input/Output Defining the export base Direct (survey) approaches Out-flow surveys (goods and services) In-flow surveys (income, payments received, receipts) Expensive, time consuming Data quality, disclosure issues not often used Defining the export base Indirect methods Assumption Approach Location Quotients Minimum Requirements Assumption approach Assigns industries to either “basic” or “non-basic” sectors based on assumptions of production Typically assume agricultural, extractive (mining) and manufacturing industries are exporters Typically assume remaining industries are local, or supportive industries Can be a reasonable assumption for specific industries and/or based on local knowledge Minimum requirements approach Not widely used anymore Chose reference or peer region as a “minimum requirement” region Assume a region meets all of local demand first, then exports Employment above the “minimum” needed to meet local demand represents export employment Location Quotient approach Commonly used, relatively easy to find data and calculate Can be based on various data sources Employment data Income data, by source Consumption data Most common usage is with employment data Location Quotients are used to tell us the amount of export employment in each industry Location Quotient Approach Caveats and Assumptions Analysis is most informative at more disaggregated levels of industry data For example, 2-digit SIC or 3-digit NAICS codes All economic base techniques are dependent on the size of the region being studied Ignores differences in: regional income levels; technology; productivity; economies of size, scale and scope Location Quotients For industry i: LQ i Or: %local employment %national employment i i i Local Employment LQ i Total Local Employment National Employment Total National i Employment Location Quotients LQ = 1 Regional employment proportion in industry i is same as national proportion Regional employment proportion in industry i is less than national proportion LQ < 1 LQ > 1 Regional employment proportion in industry i is greater than national proportion Location Quotients Export employment: X i, r (1 1 LQ i ) * E i, r X i, r [ E i, r E i, n E i, r E total, r E total, n ] * E i, n X i, r [ E i, n E total, n E total, r ] * E total, r Using Location Quotients to Identify Basic Sectors – Example from Lehigh County PA Utilize 3-digit NAICS codes, private employers, employment numbers, 2001 Download data from BLS, Covered Employment and Wages Calculate LQs for all industries 27 industries have LQ‟s > 1 10 highest LQ industries in Lehigh County, PA 312 Beverage and tobacco product manufacturing 325 Chemical manufacturing 314 Textile product mills 493 Warehousing and storage 221 Utilities 334 Computer and electronic product manufacturing 485 Transit and ground passenger transportation 339 Miscellaneous manufacturing 524 Insurance carriers and related activities 622 Hospitals 10 largest “export-employment” industries, Lehigh County, PA Hospitals (4192) Chemical manufacturing (3711) Insurance carriers and related activities (3345) Computer and electronic product manufacturing (3238) Nursing and residential care facilities (2537) Ambulatory health care services (1656) Utilities (1632) Warehousing and storage (1411) Miscellaneous manufacturing (1197) Beverage and tobacco product manufacturing (921) Economic Base Multipliers Base Multiplier Total Activity Basic Activity The regional economic base multiplier measures the total impact on a region’s economy caused by a change of one unit of export activity Base multipliers can be based on employment, income, or output Economic Base Multipliers Returning to our Lehigh County example, and using export employment calculated with Location Quotients Total Activity (employment) = 156,709 Basic Activity (employment) = 29,040 Base Multiplier = Total/Basic = 5.39 For each 1 job created in a basic sector, 5.39 additional jobs created Shift-share analysis Technique for analyzing sources of change in the regional economy A descriptive tool, no real causal structure, not good for use in forecasting – contra Klosterman book, where described as a “projection” technique Controversial, yet simple -- often used, often misused Shift-share analysis Disaggregate regional employment change into 3 component parts: 1.National (Growth) Share (NS) – changes in the regional economy attributable to changes in the national economy 2. Industrial Mix Share (IM) – changes in the regional economy attributable to the mix of industries 3. Regional/Local Shift (RS) -- changes in regional employment due to local factors, or regional competitiveness Shift-share analysis National (growth) share: estimates the total employment in industry i in the region if industry i in the region grows at the same rate as the nation. t1 n t0 n NS i, r E E * E t0 i, r Shift-share analysis Industry Mix Share: estimates change in employment in industry i based on the difference in growth rates between industry i nationally and the entire national economy IM i, r E E *( E t0 i, r t1 i, n t0 i, n E E t1 n t0 n ) Shift-share analysis Regional “shift”: estimates change in employment in industry i in the region based on the difference in growth rates between industry i in the region and industry i nationally. RS i, r E E *( E t0 i, r t1 i, r t0 i, r E E t1 i, n t0 i, n ) Shift-share analysis Putting it all together: Or, measuring change: E t1 i, r NS i, r IM i, r RS RS i, r ΔE t 0 ,1 i, r ΔNS i, r IM i, r i, r Shift-share analysis Interpreting results National share: simply tells you the extent to which the national economy grew or declines Industry mix: when summed over all industries, tells you if the mix of industries in your region are growing or declining (relatively) Regional shift: tells you if your region is strong or lagging in this industry relative to the nation Input-Output Analysis Acknowledgement and disclaimer: Some of the images and slides displayed in this presentation were shamelessly “borrowed” from my regional economics instructor, Dave Marcouiller at U. of Wisconsin. I saw no reason to reinvent what I thought were good slides and explanations of I/O Today’s objectives Focus on conceptual understanding of the Input-Output system Understanding the system of accounts, I/O tables Basic understanding of the mathematics of I/O Interpretation of multipliers Most I-O modeling is performed by experts and therefore we will focus on planners as “consumers” of the output of the analysis Input-Output Analysis Developed as an inter-industry accounting technique, a regional accounting system Relates “final demand” sectors to inputs from industrial sectors Demand driven: demand for final goods determined exogenously From income and product accounts to inputoutput model Recall from the study of national income and product accounts: Gross National Income=Gross National Product Or: Total factor payments in the economy =total spent on consumption, investment, government, and net exports Same principles hold at a regional economy Regional economic accounting L N C I G (E - M) Where L=labor, N=rents, C=consumption, I=investment, G=governemnt, E=Exports, M=Imports Rewrite, moving imports to left-side: L N M C I G E The left hand side is regional value added, while the right hand side represents final demand Remember that total output = total outlays In expanded form, this equation looks like: X 1 z 1,1 z 1,2 z 1,3 ... z 1, n Y1 X 2 z 2,1 z 2,2 z 2,3 ... z 2, n Y 2 X 3 z 3,1 z 3,2 z 3,3 ... z 3, n Y 3 ... X n z n,1 z n,2 z n,3 ... z n, n Y n A matrix is simply of way of organizing information, and is a way of representing a system of equations a 11 a 21 A a 31 a m1 a 12 a 22 a 32 a m1 a 13 a 23 a 33 a m1 a m1 a 1n a 2n a 3n a mn This matrix A has m rows and n columns, and is therefore an (m x n) matrix. It can be represented as: A (m x n) Matrices A one row matrix is called a row-vector A one column matrix is called a columnvector Again, a matrix has m rows and n columns A matrix can represent a series of equations For example, recall from a few slides ago our expanded equation: X 1 z 1,1 z 1,2 z 1,3 ... z 1, n Y 1 X 2 z 2,1 z 2,2 z 2,3 ... z 2, n Y 2 X 3 z 3,1 z 3,2 z 3,3 ... z 3, n Y 3 ... X n z n,1 z n,2 z n,3 ... z n, n Y n This can be written in matrix form as: X (n x 1) Z (n x n) Y (n x 1) Input-Output: The transactions table The first step is to represent all our sectors‟ relationships in a transactions table. This will include “intermediate” or “interindustry” demand sectors, as well as “final” demand sectors Transactions Table Purchasing Producing Producing Sector1 Sector2 Sector1 Purchasing Sector2 Final Demand Gross Output Z 11 Z 21 W1 X1 Z 12 Z 22 W2 X2 Y1 Y2 WY Y( Y ) i X1 X2 Y( Y ) i X( X ) i Value Added Gross Outlays Another way to represent this: These three basic quadrants define an Input-Output Table Production structure in I-O Inter-industry flows from i to j are wholly dependent on the output of j Production takes place under “fixed proportion” or “Leontieff” production functions. Prices are “represented” in the production coefficients, also called “technical coefficients” z a ij ij aij’s are called technical coefficients xj Input Output In working with your I-O table, the technical coefficients are derived by dividing the individual elements in your Z matrix by the row total, or the gross output. The row-sum of all your technical coefficients is, by definition, equal to 1. The table of technical coefficients is called a “direct requirements table” Let’s get back to the math of how this all works. Recall that previously we had this relationship: X ZY (these are matrices) But now we have created the matrix of technical coefficients, aij,the matrix of which we will call A. We can now rewrite the equation above as: X AX Y Let’s rearrange this to get the X’s on the same side, but be careful Matrix algebra is not the same as regular algebra X AX Y In order to factor out the X, we need to use a matrix algebra trick Define an “identity matrix” to be: 1 0 I 0 0 0 1 0 0 0 0 1 0 0 0 0 1 This functions like a 1 in Regular algebra The diagonal elements are all 1, the off-diagonals are all 0 We can thus factor out the X’s from this equation: X AX Y To yield: (I A)X Y We can isolate X on the left hand side by pre-multiplying by the inverse X (I A) 1 Y The expression (I A) 1 is frequently called the “Leontieff Inverse” We can use this expression for the predictive or multiplier form Of input-output analysis ΔX (I A) ΔY 1 Input-Output Model an example in Microsoft Excel inputoutputexample.xls Input-Output Multipliers Where you “close” the model refers to which elements of the (I-A) table you include in the Leontieff inverse Closure only through industry sectors are “simple” multipliers or “Type 1” multipliers and capture Direct effects Indirect effects Closure through households and/or governments leads to “total” multipliers or “Type 2” multipliers and capture Direct, indirect and induced effects Input-Output Multipliers Output multipliers: measures requirements needed from all sectors to deliver one additional dollar unit of sector I output to final demand Income multipliers: measures total change in income from a dollar unit change in sector I output resulting from a change in final demand Measures total changes in employment required from all sectors given a one unit change in employment in sector I needed to satisfy changes in final demand Input-Output Multipliers Interpretation: Multipliers are region specific Since multipliers include “direct” effects, be careful not to double count the impact Multipliers do NOT represent the “turnover” of dollars in a local economy but rather the net result of interindustry purchases and increases in income from outside Time for the impact to occur? Regional Input-Output Models Also available from the Bureau of Economic Analysis (Dept. of Commerce) is the Regional Input-Output Modeling System (RIMS II) RIMS II Handbook contains Four Case Studies Using RIMS multipliers for economic impact analysis Extending Input Output Inter-regional Input Output Social Accounting Matrices Other regional economic modeling approaches Regional Econometric (forecasting) Computable General Equilibrium Impact Analysis/Decision tools Cost-Benefit Analysis Fiscal Impact Analysis (also called CostRevenue Analysis) Cost-Benefit Analysis Good resources for further study: Circular A-94: Guidelines and Discount Rates for BenefitCost Analysis of Federal Programs, Executive Office of the President, Office of Management and Budget “A student‟s guide to cost-benefit analysis for natural resources”, http://ag.arizona.edu/classes/rnr485 Lecture notes from Prof. Allen Bellas, U. of Washington at: http://faculty.washington.edu/bellas/cba/ Cost-benefit Analysis A method of project evaluation – an “aggregative” approach A decision “tool” not a decision “rule” Conceptually straight-forward Cloaks public actions in “rationality” Required by Executive Order 12291 and others, cf. OMB Circular A-94 Cost-Benefit Analysis At its most simple level, CBA involves: 1. Calculate the costs of the project 2. Calculate the benefits of the project IF BENEFITS>COSTS, undertake project IF COSTS>BENEFITS, don‟t undertake project OR: chose project with highest benefit/cost ratio Of course, its never this simple…. Cost-benefit analysis Complications of this “simple” world Ethical complications: whose benefits? Whose costs? Interpersonal comparisons? Future generations? Practical complications: the “consumers” of a CBA have preconceived expectations of results Practical complications: Aggregate over different types of costs and benefits Aggregate over time / choice of a discount rate Assign “prices” to non-market goods Risk/Uncertainty – Sensitivity Analysis Some CBA relatives to consider Cost-Effectiveness Analysis Risk-Cost Analysis, Risk-Risk Analysis Fiscal Impact Analysis/Cost-revenue analysis Internal Rate of Return (IRR) Willingness to Pay/Willingness to Accept Methods of valuing environmental amenities Contingent Valuation Travel Cost Method Hedonic Price method Steps in a CBA 1. 2. 3. 4. 5. 6. 7. 8. 9. Define scope of project Identify alternatives Clarify issues of “standing” Explicitly specify assumptions List impacts of each alternative Assign values to impacts Discount future values to present values Account for uncertainty/risk Compare benefits to costs The normative basis of CBA Pareto-Optimality and Welfare Economics Kaldor-Hicks Criterion “The principle of maximizing net present value of benefits is based on the premise that gainers could fully compensate the losers and still be better off” --OMB Circular A-94 Cost-Benefits: The Basics Criteria depend on scope of problem: If scope is accept or reject one project: Accept if NPV > 0 This is most Reject if NPV < 0 common If scope is choosing between 2+ projects Chose project with maximum “net benefits” or Chose project with highest Benefit/Cost ratio Given a project, chose its scale Set MB = MC (marginal benefits=marginal cost) Cost-Benefits: The Basics Definitions: Present Value (PV) = the value today of a payment or a stream of payments in the future. Future Value (FV) = the value at a time in the future of an amount today Discounting: reducing a future value to present value by means of a discount rate Compounding: increasing a present value to a future value by means of an interest rate Internal Rate of Return (IRR): what discount rate sets the present value of benefits and costs equal. (NPB=NPC) Cost-Benefits: The Basics Comparison between two alternatives is “with/without” NOT “before/after” State assumptions clearly Perform sensitivity analysis, particularly concerning the choice of the discount rate What are “costs”? What are “benefits” Avoid “double-counting” With/Without vs. Before/After:What is policy “impact” c-b is with/without; c-a is before/after c b a “Value” Policy Intervention at time t Time t Steps in Cost-Benefit Analysis 1. 2. Define scope of project -define project exactly, identify likely impacts -engineering and financial cost estimates Define alternatives of the project -may be “reject” project and do nothing Steps in Cost-Benefit Analysis 3. Clarify issues of standing -whose benefits and costs are considered in the analysis -- must be consistent -often is given by the “client” 4. Explicitly specify assumptions “Analyses should be explicit about the underlying assumptions used to arrive at estimates of future benefits and costs. The analysis should include a statement of the assumptions, the rationale behind them, and a review of their strengths and weaknesses. Key data and results, such as year by year estimates of benefits and costs, should be reported to promote independent analysis and review.” -OMB Circular A94 Steps in Cost-Benefit Analysis 5. List impacts of each alternative Types of impacts: -Direct impacts -Indirect impacts Note:DO NOT USE MULTIPLIERS -Externalities and spillovers Steps in Cost-Benefit Analysis 6. Monetize (assign value to) all benefits and costs. -Costs should reflect opportunity costs -Costs should reflect market costs where possible -Costs should reflect willingness to pay (WTP) wherever possible -Variety of techniques for valuing non-market amenities Steps in Cost-Benefit Analysis 7. DISCOUNTING - Choosing the appropriate discount rate -The choice of the discount rate is quite controversial. Ideally, the discount rate should “The social discount rate” (SDR) - Mathematical mechanics of discounting in Excel More on “discounting” Discounting contains implicitly, adjustment for at least 3 factors: Time preference Opportunity cost of capital Risk and uncertainty Discounting V t V 0 (1 ) V0 Vt (1 ) t t The formula to convert today’s money into tomorrow's The formula to convert tomorrow's money into today’s THE DISCOUNT RATE Even more on discounting Most government agencies have pre-set discount rules which are to be used, so you take what is given to you. Federal guidelines: start with 7 percent as discount rate. (OMB Circular, cf. appendix C) Why 7 percent? “Approximates the marginal pretax rate of return on an average investment in the private sector in recent years.” Fiscal Impact Analysis In PA, cf. http://cax.aers.psu.edu/residentialimpact/ (even though it is Penn State…) Fiscal impact analysis is used to estimate the costs and revenues of a proposed land development. Ideally it is used not in NIMBY type opposition to development, but in accurate capital improvements planning (CIP). Fiscal Impact Analysis The most commonly used form is the “per capita multiplier” method. Quite simply, it uses average per capita revenue and cost figures, and multiplies these by the estimated number of new residents/school children in a proposed development. The difference between AVERAGE and MARGINAL Ignores actual infrastructure capacity and capital expenditures. Fiscal Impact Analysis Steps in the per-capita multiplier method 1. Estimate number of expected new residents and new school children to reside in new development. How? Use statewide averages, or locally derived averages. (From census data or local school enrollment data) 2. Estimate additional school spending as: New school children * per pupil expenditures Fiscal Impact Analysis 3. Estimate additional municipal (non-school) expenditures. Generally use “current” not capital expenditures. Estimate current spending on roads, police/safety/fire, administration, etc. and divide by current population totals to get per capita expenditures Multiply number of new residents * per capita expenditures Net revenues minus net costs. 4. Calculate net fiscal impact: 5. Answer: Keep out as many school kids as possible. Fiscal Impact Methods Other types of fiscal impact methods 1. Cast Study method. Perform detailed case studies and/or solicit expert opinion from local and school district officials to estimate costs. 2. Service Standard method. Focuses on requirements of service levels to service proposed developments. (If done properly, would look at existing service levels and capacity.) 3. Comparable City method. Rarely used. Look at comparable developments in comparable cities. Fiscal Impact Analysis For non-residential developments, two methods to assess impacts: 1. Proportional valuation method. The denominator for assessing revenues and costs is not people (i.e. per capita) but the proportion of proposed development‟s property valuation relative to community. 2. Employment Anticipation method. Estimate number of employees to be serviced. Then use similar techniques to estimate costs and revenues per employee. NOTE: Non-residential uses do not send kids to school.